CorpusRecord 73912

01/28/25 MNPS Board of Education

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Metro Nashville Network
Date
2025-01-29
Location
Coffee County, TN
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,198 words · about 52 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001n uh no was eight members uh present um so we do have a quorum uh we will begin with the PED of Allegiance from our former colleagues uh former board member jie pooo Walker and Dr Sharon Gentry I pledge allegiance to the of the United stes of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under indivisible with libery and justice for all thank you ladies thank you for being here um next um we're going to have a moment of silence um given the the events that happened last Wednesday um we'd like to take a moment just to reflect um on our um on our district particularly the high school and um the families that were affected thank you right the nationville community has once again been touched by the effects of gun

002violence which has been deemed a public crisis in America the events of Wednesday January 22nd and the events that followed have taken emotional toll on our students staffs family the families of Antioch high school and across our district our heartfelt condolences are extended to the families of Joselyn Diana Korea Escalante and Solomon Henderson we will like to thank Chief Drake Chief Sean Chief Swan the Personnel of mmpd and the office of emergency management for their Swift response to Antioch High School prioritizing the reunification of our students with their families we are thankful and proud to be in partnership with you mayor oconnell we thank you for yours and Metro Government support throughout this entire week although mnps in Nashville has certainly seen a share of crises in the past years tornadoes pandemics and other loss

003of life a tragedy such as this causes the distinct characteristic of leaving survivors plague with a major case of the Whata ifs a condition that leaves us at best ineffective our first first priorities create a stable and supportive environment for our students and the staff at aniac high school ironically there is a common factor in all the four mentioned crises the tornado that pandemic and others and that's our current director of schools Dr Adrien battle as we as the board praise her and basking the glow of others who have also praised her leadership through those times we are fortunate to have leadership through this crisis she has been tested time and time again and she has truly inspired us and led the way when the road felt so hard we are fortunate to have her

004discipline and dedicated team who have supported her throughout this crisis and worked just as hard as she has throughout the week the decision to Pilot metal detectors at Antioch High School was not made lightly we are aware of the many concerns and limitations of using them and the the assessment of their effess their assessment excuse me and the assessment of their effectiveness will extend beyond the fysical results for the upcoming weeks we also recognize that we must do more to ensure students who feel isolated disconnect disconnected or hopelessness that students to have students and staff who can reach out in off offer support this is essential ingredient to preventing violence in our schools and our communities we will continue PRI prioritize making every student known but also loved and supported Dr battle since the incident

005Wednesday you have held meetings press events met with students staff families and Community leaders you have been going from sunup and into the we hours of the morning you have sacrificed your time with your own family to console and comfort your mmps family you have connected with other leaders and other other leaders from other cities and school districts and agencies you have walked this scene and many may hear this and think well that's her job but many of us may not know that a school would that at that school you spent a huge part of your professional career in which you still have personal ties not to mention your own personal experience with gun violence at school so we are Beyond grateful for the ways you have led putting students staffs family our district and

006our ceiling onto a path of healing We Salute your dedication to our students and remain grateful for your service now our hand over to board member Mae to make her remarks regarding her District thank you chair player and thank you Dr battle and to your entire team for your unwavering leadership not just in times of Triumph but also in the face of adversity to my fellow Board of Education members your dedication and support are deeply appreciated and I truly grateful for each of you but today my greatest gratitude is reserved for the extraordinary staff administrators and First Responders at Antioch High School when the unimaginable occurred in the Cafe last week you didn't hesitate you didn't step back you stepped forward without a second thought you ran toward danger to protect our students or our

007babies as I call them in those critical moments your training instincts and most importantly your hearts took over to me that makes you heroes in the days since you have continued to demonstrate the same unwavering commitment not just to our students but to one another you have stood shoulder-to-shoulder offering strength support and Solace wrapping the Antioch community in care and compassion but I can't say I'm surprised this is Antioch this is who we are strength resilience and unity are woven into the fabric of our community Antioch is a place where we lift each other up where we where our diversity is our strength and where in the toughest of times we come together with purpose so today I ask each of you students families faculty and staff to hold on to Hope even in the

008darkest moments there is still light to be F to be found and please know this You Are Not Alone we are here we will stand beside you support you and lift you up in every way possible we see you we love you and we've got you thank you thank you thank you um and I went to visit Glen Cliff high school yesterday to drop off some items and principal Clinton Wilson probably summed it up best it's like this not was an Antioch student this was our student so on behalf of the district this was our student and so I want to duly note that all right I will entertain a motion to adop to adopt the agenda as listed motion to adopt there is a motion by board member Mae is there a second there's

009a second by Aaron O'Hara block um all in FA discussion all in favor say I any oppose the motion passes and now uh we will move on to our director's report we'll have the students speak directly after a followed by other board members questions and comments all right thank you thank you chair player I mean good evening board members a week ago at this time our world looked very different and we were planning a very different report for today we've worked hard over the past six days to understand the tragedy at Antioch high school and make adjustments to make our students and St more safe and Ure they feel supported and I want to update you tonight on what we're doing and what we're changing in our schools but first we need to pay tribute

010to the young student who lost her life on the morning of January 22nd joselene Carrera Escalante Joseline was a lovely young woman who was taken from her family her friends and our community much too soon she was beautiful bright and athletic with a passion for soccer and dreams of becoming a doctor my heart goes out to Joseline's parents other family members and everyone else who cared for her let me tell you a bit more about Joseline from the teachers and staff at Antioch High School who knew her and loved her jeline was a good diligent student who excelled at math and science valued her education and always did her best Janie Macklin her science teacher said she never had to ask Joseline to put away her phone or redirect her and she took amazing notes

011Joseline gave me great hope Miss Macklin recalled her radiant light elevated those around her and gave me a great deal of inspiration Joseline would Amaze her classmates by always volunteering answers and being ready each time she was called on a thriving eel student she was a kid that I knew I could count on I often look to ensure that my pacing was right last Wednesday we learned DNA Bas pairing she was able to identify the components of a nucleot and build her first complimentary strand of DNA I was so proud teachers also remember Joseline for her kindness and warmth she had a big bright smile and was always ready to help others her smile was so contagious it brightened the entire room said her integrated m two teacher this year Kamisha Owens Mar a scholar

012with so much potential Gone Too Soon Joseline was an excellent student and a great friend she would be missed immensely she also was willing to try new things revealing more of her skills and talents in the process Rachel Peterson her music told she told us she would meet her where she was as a singer in her choir class over the next few weeks of being in class with her she always participated in class with a kind spirit and positive attit attitude Miss Peterson said she always supported her peers with joy once she got more confident in the choir class once she got confident I was blessed to hear her soft and Angelic voice that was the last thing I heard before she passed I will always appreciate the short time I did have with her

013this year may her soul rest in peace and today at Antioch a student leader paid tribute to Joseline by saying your memory will continue to shine bright in all of us before students release red balloons in Joseline's honor you can see and hear from these tributes that joselene was a ray of light at Antioch and in her nationville Public Schools Community her death is a tragedy but I hope Joseline's short but brilliant life can be an example and inspiration to all of us in the weeks months and years ahead as you all know our students are so smart passionate they're advocates for themselves and their Community they take their safety just as seriously as we do and they speak up about it they did it after the Covenant shooting nearly two years ago and they're

014doing it again now with strong and compassionate voices we work hard to promote and amplify find uplift student voice but sometimes we don't have to do a thing our student voices spoke loud and clear this afternoon on the football field and in the bleachers at Antioch High School School Safety and Security is not one person or one team's job it's a collaboration between various different stakeholders departments and agencies who work together to prevent incidents from happening and respond when they do our school staff from principals to teachers to support staff all work together on keeping students safe developing plans and protocols to ensure there is proper supervision during transition times that we are working to stop conflicts before they escalate into violence through restorative practices and respond quickly when incidents do occur our mmps security

015department rotates throughout the district on a daily basis and response to incidents when they occur providing guidance and support as well as conducting searches when necessary or answering questions from school or District administrators Transportation also plays an important role as communication with principles about incidents can be important in diffusing future situations the mmpd is involved in our schools through the SRO program as well as a strong Spirit of collaboration between our two Metro agencies and the support of Chief Drake for the needs of our students student Support Services provides help and guidance to our schools on how to properly prevent or address safety situations seen throughout the normal course of school operations students and families also have a key role in keeping our schools safe with parents reinforcing rules and expectations outlined in the student

016parent handbook with their students who can help by reporting suspicious behavior and helping to establish a culture and a climate that discourages bad behavior the student parent handbook includes information about the importance of gun safety and locking up weapons we've taken big steps to make our school safer both for everyday security and for worst case scenarios first we've installed security vestibules at at our schools this means when someone arrives they can't just walk in they check in at the front office first we also have AV intercom locks at entrances this allows staff to see and talk to visitors before unlocking the door for even more control badge access systems make sure only authorized people can get through exterior doors beyond the main entrance inside classrooms all doors can be locked from the inside and the

017exterior hand exterior handles can be automatically secured if needed we've also added shatter resistant film on Windows if a Windows impacted by gunfire this helps keeps the glass in play slowing down or stopping any attempt to get inside to allow for police to respond on the technology side we've implemented Omni alert's weapon detection system this uses Ai and and our security cameras to detect visible firearms and notify School ad administrators and the police as you're aware by now based on the position and location of the shooter at Antioch this system did not activate on Wednesday because it was activated when police responded to the scene to be clear even if it had been activated it likely wouldn't have made a difference as it was less than two minutes between the time of the shooter brandished

018weapon and our and our police sros responded to the cafeteria we also have audio enhancement systems that we have been installing in our schools this technology first and foremost allows teachers to project their voices across a classroom to reduce teacher fatigue and help with student learning but they also have a feature that allows staff to send an immediate alert if there's an emergency ensuring a quick response all of these efforts are about keeping students and staff safe while we want to be open about our security improvements we're also mindful not to share every detail publicly to protect the Integrity of our safety measures one of the strongest connections between mmps and mmpd is through the school resource officer program which allows experienced police officers to volunteer for assignment in one of our schools traditionally they

019have been in middle and high schools but starting this year we've expanded that to elementary schools and and are being assigned as new team members come on board to date we've had a very positive response from the school communities who have been assigned SOS it is important to note that these are not just armed security but rather they are tasked to provide mentorship and instruction while helping to create a safe learning environment they receive special training on how to do just that and are meant to build meaningful relationships with staff and students alike in any addition to providing police response when necessary as a police work to add more schools SRO to cover our needs the mmpd deploys community police officers to our elementary schools to provide visibility and greater sense of security for our

020students parents and staff mmpd also works with schools to provide security planning based on state law and provides guidance and support to school administrators in developing those plans our partnership with the m mmpd includes craze training which was offered to all of our schools this year where they were able to learn important information about how to respond in an emergency situation the MPD also conducts threat investig ation and response to school threats after a school shooting it is very common for there to be a rash of rumors threats and social media threats that come out and cause panic and fear we were grateful for the mmpd to provide additional safety measures at those schools directly impacted by working quickly to identify the individuals responsible several students have been arrested and have been negatively impacted by

021this it is very important to know this is not a joke you should never start or share a threat online and you should always report these directly to a school team or SRO school team member or SRO now while metal detectors are not Pia and they're not perfect solutions to school safety we do use them at some school events we have provided wands to schools for spot checking and specific uses and today we started piloting the evolved concealed weapons detection system at Antioch High School evolve uses advanced technology to enhance security while allowing for a faster and less intrusive entry process this system is already in use at major events like Nissan stadium and represents a promising step forward for school safety this morning we were able to observe a very fluid entry process for

022students with limited challenges in responding to and learning the protocols we will continue to monitor throughout the week to see if any process adjustments need to be taken we would not have been able to accomplish this in such a short time frame with no funding allocation without the support of our security vendor system Integrations and the manufacturer manufacturer evolve so at this time I'd like to welcome up Jill lemon um evolves Technologies head of Education um she's going to come up to provide some more information on how the system works to keep students safe while minimizing disruptions to the school environment um Gio would you come on up to the podium please thank you good evening to the board and to the community thank you for having me here tonight um as Dr battle me

023mentioned my name is Jill amand I'm our vice president of education at evolved technology and though I recognize I'm meeting you uh during perhaps the worst of circumstances uh I was really honored today to walk beside your staff and meet your students at Antioch high school and and really witnessed what we see out in the field as the most important piece of a Safety and Security plan and that's trusting adult relationships and we saw that today and it was it was a beautiful thing as a former educator I was honored so thank you for having me I just very briefly want to talk about the technology itself so we're trying to help students to have a safer experience and so it's not just that moment as they're walking in it's the entire entry process and

024then the way that they feel throughout the school day our mission at the company is really to make the world a safer and more enjoyable place to live work learn and play and I did highlight learn because that's what we're talking about this evening and that is my sole focus at evolved technology these are some of our representative customers some of our Marquee customers you might recognize we are in uh we have about 6,000 units across the world globally and I think the more important statistic to note is we're in over 12200 school buildings across the United States some of those districts are large districts like yours some of them are smaller districts we have rural urban Suburban schools and we've been able to roll this out and this technology out in a variety of

025different types of settings and it looks different honestly at every different school and in each different Community I do want to mention we're in seven other school districts in the state of Tennessee um just so you know and I know that you've chosen to meet with some of them and to learn some of their best practices already we are screening about 3 million people every day across the world um we do have over 850 different companies that partner with us but like I said that's not as important to me as the school districts that we are working beside our system is a connected system meaning it's a smart technology um you can see it in the top right corner there and I'll have some better images soon um but the system does provide data and

026Analysis of that data as students are walking through and here is what the system kind of looks like there that's what we call a dual Lane system on the left hand side and what we're hoping for is what Dr battle mentioned which is as close to free flow or natural pace of Entry as possible um and today typically day one is um maybe the most difficult day as students and staff are learning the procedures we saw really some excellent uh entry points today at the school and your staff was just absolutely phenomenal I have to mention that again but what's important about the system and when we're looking at this type of weapons technology weapons detect protection technology is the distance between those towers that you see on the left hand side our system has

027a repeatable installation process because it has a fixed width so sometimes it depends on how far apart those Towers may be to determine how uh reliable that detection is our system is a fixed width system so that's an important piece of information for you um it's ADA Compliant and it's not setting off any more uh electrical energy or anything like that for the students in terms of health and safety than a typical sense of or theft you know device anti- theft device at a department store when a student is walking through and has something on their person or in their belongings again concealed not divesting it necessarily the system is scanning them and their belongings in in real time as they walk through and if something appears threatening to the technology it's going to create

028an image that you see in the center of the screen there that image is important because it provides a red box around the Potential Threat that allows for a very pinpointed search of the student whether it's on their person themselves or in their belongings and allows for a little bit of a quicker process when we're coming in in the morning so students bring a lot of things to school and we saw that again today you know backpacks and athletic gear all those different things we want that to still come in the school but what that system the system sees that as we call clutter what we're trying to do is make it so that the Security Professionals and the staff who are searching have a very obvious place to look and don't have to look

029through all of their their students belongings we're trying to minimize the invasiveness of the process while still balancing the need for Safety and Security at the same time you can see that image there um does help to assist with that and supports the operations and we saw that today with students I think it was relatively easy for them to uh not only identify which student alerted the system but then again where on their body or in their belongings they could look for the potentially threatening item we do have the opportunity uh at a very low cost actually for printing um nearby to just customize those panels and make them a little bit more part of the culture and climate of the school whether it would be your mascot or something else school pride we've seen

030some districts have students that do contest to actually design the panels and things like that um just to make it softer and more welcoming in in the school environment and I really didn't have anything else tonight to talk to about the technology but I am available if if um you have any other questions Dr battle thank you so much Jill so now Safety and Security is not only about protecting students from active Shooters but also protecting them from the daily safety issues that could result in physical or emotional harm our student Support Services team has worked with our school counselors to put in place advocacy centers and all of our elementary schools focus on helping students to process their emotions in a healthy way that will reduce behavioral incidents in the future as well as

031restorative practice assistance and PE centers in our middle and high schools and identifying a mental health provider for all of our schools we've put protocols and teams in place to assess threats posed by students or others towards the Safety and Security of students or staff along with plans for individual student safety issues and screening tools for students exhibiting signs of su suicidal ideation we've built up our Title Nine and anti-bullying supports to provide assistance with investigations along with training and protocols to ensure that we are properly addressing threats to students and providing appropriate disciplinary responses when situations occur we provide detailed guidance and support for schools on how to apply the student handbook to behavioral incidents while we we always want to provide restorative services and support it is also important to ensure students receives

032the appropriate consequence for their actions last let me just say thank you to everyone who has stood with us over the past week from our school board members here to team members across the district to families students Community Members First Responders May Connell and other elected officials we are so thankful for your support board members I appreciate you every week but especially on a week like this you have been here with me and with our team as we've dealt with a unique crisis that required a unique response and as always your guidance has been steady and strong and helpful thank you for always having the best interest of our students and our team members across the district not only in your minds but in your hearts we simply could not do this without you so

033thank you again um in a week where we're celebrating board members leadership all across the country specifically here in National Public Schools thank you again and with that chair player I'll turn it back over to you thank you very much um first we're going to hear from our student board members and then we'll go on to our other board members so I will start with our senior board member Christina Tran um good evening everyone I wanted to first start off by extending my heart to joselyn's family may she rest in peace um next I want to talk about something that I was told just last Saturday at the MLK youth Symposium a parent came up to me after the panel and told me about how his son was scared of going to his bus stop

034because he was scared he was going to get shot um when I came home on the day of the shooting my little brother told me how he was scared of even going to school at all um he's an eighth grader last Friday 50% of students at my school stayed home those that went were also scared and paranoid how many kids have to be scared and cautious before something is done how many kids have to succumb to gun violence before something is done how many kids does mental health have to affect for something to be done I think I speak for every M&S student when I say that we are angry and frustrated we want something to change we want something done differently to ensure that this kind of tra is prevented and not glossed over

035we want our security ensured school is the one place that students should be able to go to and feel completely safe but I know that MPS students do not feel this way despite what some may say um I know every single person sitting at this table cares and the point I'm trying to make right now is that we need to learn how to make everyone else feel the same way overall time and unity is needed in order to heal after this shooting but change is necessary for us as a community to continue moving forward we cannot keep doing the same thing expecting it to work because indifference is the biggest danger right now thank you thank you School Board member Hannah win good evening board and Community two years ago student board member Elena Mitchell

036sat in this very seat giving a very similar statement to the one I'm about to give about the mass tragedy at covenant High Covenant Elementary School excuse me but today today I sit in front of you all another student board member and the sentiment still stands I would like to start by expressing my deepest condolences to the students staffs and family at an families at Antioch high school but it's hard to repeat condolences because it will never be enough it hurts me as a student knowing I'm only going to be able to feel a fraction of an ounce of those what those have been affected are feeling it doesn't get much simpler than the fact that you parents students and staff deserve to feel safe both physically and mentally at school you deserve legislation and

037policy that makes you feel as such and you deserve more than this somehow this has become the norm of Our Generation my peers and I asking ourselves how many more but this time it was our district and our community this is the danger of indifference and we are tired of the headlines to our state legislators I want you to know that Metro natural public school students are watching our communities are watching do not be desensitized by the free queny this will never be okay and just as a reminder we are the only nation with this issue and frankly it is embarrassing and unpatriotic we don't want vouchers we don't want violence protection sorry we want violence protection the events at Antioch High School will not be ammunition for any political agenda especially to discriminate against

038public schools and minorities and it is so clear to me that gun violence is not a political issue I more in action I expect more remember Joselyn Deana Carrera Escalante and do not let this tragedy pass by without change Joselyn whom I believe went by dayana deserved to see her future to become a doctor to receive her dipl diploma and her family came to this nation similar to mine to escape violence in the circumstances back at home but instead they were met with violence at the hands of the systematic failure of gun policies and the societal neglect of mental health students I beg you to stay strong during these difficult times your voice matters you are loved and you are cared for and you deserve to be heard importantly your pain and fr ation deserves

039to be heard as student board members we are here for you and we are here to work towards your interest for better safer secure schools and I urge you to let out these Grievances and let us be of service to you so we can see the change that we want but not only the change we want but the change that we so desperately need remember if you see something to say something and I stand each side along each side of you and I will continue to fight for you during these tragic times thank you thank you I know you're not babes but I think of the scripture out of the mouth of our babes so thank you for saying your words all right I will open up to school board members so if anyone like

040to make have questions or make comments please raise your hand Schoolboard member Maz yes just a quick comment um I just want to say I was uh extremely impressed with our young people today they uh stood up they spoke up and they asked us to do something and they did it in such an amazing way they advocated for themselves and I'm so thankful for Dr badle and her team and for principal Bernett and her team for making sure that our children's voices were heard and those act those requests were put into action it was an amazing day at Antioch high school and it it may sound uh little odd to say that but I'm so proud of those young people they did an amazing job today from the very beginning I was there at 6:15

041this morning were ready to greet them and it blew my mind how uh well they did they they adapted as we expected they would they knew what to expect and they adapted and I'm so proud of them and I'm so thankful for you Dr battle for your team making sure that they were ready so just wanted to say publicly how much I thank every single one of you on the leadership team for making sure that our babies were taken care of thank you very much board member Tyler um yes I want to Echo the thanks I mean there there aren't enough thank yous for what the people who have stepped up have done and I don't think people understand how smoothly we have been able to respond because of how well your team works together

042so that is a testament to um Dr battle and her team that they have been able to immediately jump into action and immediately start prepping and planning and creating space so that when people come back it is a smooth and the least amount of trauma is possible given the circumstances so that's really important and I also wanted to make a note that you had a slide about previous school security enhancements that included a a lot of information about what we've done and we have made the point in the past and you've heard it from other people as well that no one thing is 100% foolproof no one thing is going to be the golden you know snitch is what I was thinking of because I'm Harry Potter but like it's not going to be the

043one thing that's going to stop everything from happening all of these have to work together as a layered system and the thing that I saw missing from here is what I think we try our hardest to do the best which is the relationships that we Foster and create and allow our students to have with one another and then also between the staff and the students because the most often way the best way we can stop something from happening is if you see something you say something and so the most likely chance of stopping something from happening comes from people being willing to speak up and you're only willing to speak up when you trust that you will be heard and and we have worked really hard with our staff and I know our staff deeply

044cares about every single student and they want the students to feel comfortable and safe enough to approach them with a concern and so that to me is something worth pointing out that it it's not something that you can buy it's something you have to create and it is the number one way to stop something bad from happening having the ability to say when a peer sees something that they feel comfortable coming up to somebody and saying my friend is saying this and I'm really concerned I'm really worried that this is going to happen I saw something on someone's social media that was really scary I don't know who to turn to and we are then able to immediately jump into action and provide support for that student and do everything we can to stop an

045incident from happening before it can start and so the ability for our teachers to be a safe space for a student to come to to feel comfortable enough to come to them is to me one of our top priorities and that really is encompassed in your every student known mantra for our for our schools and I think um we can add every layer of hardened security protocol in the world but if we don't have the adults in the school able to form a connection with the students so that they feel feel like they can come to them with their concerns those will eventually fail we have to have the ability for our students to feel safe with the adults in the building with them and we want our students to feel safe with each other

046as well and that's why as a student if you see something it is so important to say something even if you only have one adult that you can trust go to that person if you as the parent are told by your child they said to me their friend is is they're concerned about their friend they need help then you as the parent don't need to keep that you need to also approach and let us know about that we can only help when we know that there is something happening and so instead of being reactionary and trying to stop something immediately we want to be proactive and providing a support before something goes downhill before something terrible happens again um our students are our most important resource they are our future all of the platitudes that

047we hear all the time they exist for a reason and so I I think maintaining keeping the trust and the professionalism and the ability to talk to one another is going to be our one of our absolute best defenses and so I I don't want the conversation to devolve into how can we Harden our schools enough to protect them because nobody at the legislature will do that we need to look for the best ways that we can help one another and I don't want to say I don't want it to sound try to say that caring about one another matters but it does it's the only thing that matters thank you thank you School B Rachel and El Rod my whole name um I too noticed that it um there's there's a mosaic a web

048of security that we have or pieces of security that we provide to try to mitigate against the worst of outcomes if you want to say it that way and um within that I want to say that we've there was a lot of Heroes within Antioch and so I want to make sure that we recognize them even though they're not here with us hopefully they're getting rest and respit frankly um from the week that they've had and the response that's been necessary from them but our staff are our biggest asset to our biggest value which is of course our students so it's important that we recognize the priority that we have for them within that [Music] um it has been interesting to hear the response about hardening our schools I have some mixed feelings about it

049because of historical connotations of hardening our schools therefore I know today is our first day of it and there's all types of um things that we will need to iron out particularly as the attendance increases and we figure out where students will wait and all of those kinds of things my hope is is at the end of this pilot is that there will be a larger report of some kind or a task force of some kind that will provide that information of what we need to do is there a way that you can provide us about what that pilot is going to look like it's my understand it's for 30 days at this time can you tell us kind of what the response was the biggest concern I heard from any type of constituent was

050where do the students wait while they're waiting to go through the process how long does it take to go through it that kind of more operational thing can you explain any of that to us though I think today being a singular day of experience is probably not a great intuition of what it's going to be like going forward but can you tell us what you've heard or seen so as you mentioned today is the first day of the pet um overwhelmingly we um receive positive feedback um from our students stents um both during the experience and um throughout the day at the end of the day included um so overwhelmingly a positive experience I mean the experience is very similar um to the experience you would have attending um an event at Nissan Stadium or

051Bridgestone um Arena I'm attending a concert is a very similar process uh one of the benefits of the um detection system that we are pting there is that um it does have the ability um to um scan if you will um or have large numbers of students right track through the system at one time so as an example um today um we were about right on time for the start of school on the first day of school leveraging the system and so um as you know um Ania K is a pretty large um high school and so it will give us a tremendous amount um of information um given that it really is our largest school um and so it we were able to with pretty good ease um get every student through um the

052system um today in a timely fashion we didn't have a lot of waiting we running two different um entry points and so by way of that um just significant um ability to process if you've experienced um going in a Nissan Stadium they tell you to keep walking like that's the that's a thing people just naturally want to stop and pause but as we get everyone accustomed to it just continue to walk through un less um we need to do a second screening um due to any detection um with regards to the pilot itself um our our our goal is to Pilot in some ways indefinitely um if you will to continue to um engage in the conversations Gathering feedback I'm having the conversations our students um actually recorded a video um yesterday and they shared

053it out with their friends about the ease um of the system and just their experience walking through it before the first day of school um my understanding from watching the videos from this particular company though I understand there are other companies so it may be different as we continue to Pilot between between different systems my understanding with this specific system is that it will go off if there's a laptop and the suggestion is to remove your laptop is that did that have any implications particularly now that we're a onetoone district do we notice that there's anything that I guess my biggest question and revolving to that is if a student does have an accident where they leave their backpack they leave their laptop in their backpack cuz that's frankly what I would have done as

054a student particularly because it's a new system when that is noticed what is the process by our staff to I hate to say detain but pull that student to the side and review what is setting off the system what does that look like for our students I'm concerned about of course ret traumatizing them or stigmatized and all that kind of stuff it is very much like what we've all experienced going to any event or like concert sporting event um it is a simple so the whole goal is for students to be able to keep as much as they can like we don't we we're trying to um um prepare for what we know will likely be detected but for the student to keep as much as they can in their backpacks so we have the

055student go ahead like at if you're at the airport even take out your laptop because that is something that could um be um detected in the system if a student for instance forgets to take it out then they'll be asked to just come over to the side for secondary screening of which we'll search um their belongings we'll identify the item um which the system helps us detect um by way of the visuals um we'll identify that and if the student is clear the student moves on um to class so it is a very similar um experience that we've all likely had if you've attended celebration of schools um which we hold that event down at Nissan Stadium it's the it's the almost the exact same um process in fact they are it's the exact same

056system um that we're pting at an school okay um I guess my last question is before you ask can I respond to that board chair sorry um so I was there this morning um when students were coming in and saw an example of exactly what you said um a student was coming in with their backpack on they were so excited to see principal Bernett that she was hugging them as they were coming through the system um the alarm went off and as she finished hugging them them they let her know that the backpack went off and she escorted that student over so it was not any problems or any feelings or any disruptions um from students through there it was a really smooth process most students did take out their backpacks uh take their laptops

057out but there were instances in which a few instances in which that happened and students responded smoothly to it well and I'll say we we're trying to set the students up for Success so anytime you're um implementing um something new um you will likely um Institute additional kind of parameters to help everyone prepare for it so we sent out information to families I'm in advance again our students um self-recorded a video that they sent out um to their school Community as students were arriving and buses were pulling up we just hopped on and said hey um that you're going to go through the system go ahead and pull these items out of your book bag um that'll help you just with ease move through of course just like we all do I mean I've been

058at the airport and thought I didn't have that bottle of water and then I go through and it's like oh my gosh how do I leave the bottle of water in there so that's simple process this can't go in um but what's most important something that uh board member Tyler just mentioned the most important thing is that our students have the relationship with the individuals who are leading the screening so these are their teachers and their administrators and the the the support staff that they're accustomed to interacting with on a daily basis and so that is very familiar um to a students so if there was a need for a second screen in this probably someone that the student has a positive relationship with but we'll hold them accountable for the things that can or

059cannot um come into the school building okay um so at the end of the 30 days are we going to receive some type of report of how that went if there's unintended consequences be that like tardies or interrupted classroom time or anything along those lines are we going to get that type of update at the end of the 30 days so we can make a clear decision on what we might do districtwide if anything yes okay okay okay thank you absolutely uh next uh School Board member when um I just wanted to re reiterate a point that I misspoke on previously um intended to our state legislature um that we do not want vouchers we want violence protection in our schools um and to Echo member Tyler's Point um just just to be an open

060ear and I think that those that goes for everyone um just like with responsibility both to uh parents staff students and these difficult times I think it's really important to be there for each other um for that mental aspect but again also for that physical aspect um when you see something to say something um I think that's how we mitigate both the mental and physical security um and then I also just want to say to any students out there um that are feeling any kind of way about any issue not just regarding the recent events um me and Christine are working on kind of a consistent way to get in contact with us um but we're in the process of operationalizing um at student board members on Instagram um and there's a contact form that

061we both have access to um for any questions comments and concerns so that's all I got thank you I love your Ingenuity uh board member uh O'Hara block just along those lines I want to say thank you to Hannah and Christine to sit up here after the week that we've had the week that you all have had as students and to be willing to make comments and offer thoughts is really remarkable and brave and thank you and what you just said is incredible I'm so excited to be able to get that feedback and that was actually my question for you Dr batt is if you wouldn't mind just to talk a little bit about you've met with students you were at the the rally this afternoon at anoch just what you've been hearing from students

062um yes so I've had an opportunity um a few days ago I had an opportunity to meet with a group of students from um Antioch High School specifically um actually I've met with them several times um now getting their feedback I've had an opportunity to meet with our student board members um as well um as other students and it's pretty it's been pretty consistent to what Christine and Hannah have shared um today um wanting to continue to push for uh policies and legislation regarding mental health um supports as well as um gun laws and so that has been pretty consistent across um the conversations that I've had um with students listen our students are clear they understand um that as was described earlier there's not one strategy um that's going to solve um this for

063us but there are many things we can be doing um should continue to do in our district and can be doing um external to our district to help um decrease the likelihood and to build community um in a way that's supportive um for us as individuals but also um for those that we're learning and growing with and so that's been consistent across the board um some of our um student leaders had an opportunity to speak with um some legislators um over um the weekend and on yesterday um around um their message um for pushing in those two particular areas and being clear um that just because it hasn't happened they will continue um to Advocate um in those spaces because it is clear that um there is some opportunity there and is needed um not

064only here but across the the state um and the country and so it's been a really consistent message um it's been really clear to us around ways in which we can support our students um in their um advocacy efforts in fact today's um rally at 1:00 um the students came to us and said they wanted to honor jine and they wanted to make sure um that they continue to advocate for the things that have been shared and our responsibility was to support them give them the resources that they need and step back and allow them to lead by continuing to hold their hand um and pushing for the things that um they would like to see um in our school community so pretty consistent School member ma the um I don't want to belabor this

065issue but I did want to share with uh board member Elrod that this morning I did go into the school with my backpack on intentionally because I wanted to feel the effects of being a student walking through that system and I did have my laptop with me and I I took it out but to Jill's uh you going back to Jill's presentation earlier I had an item which I forgot I had in my bag which was just a mini microphone and that set the sensors off but it pinpointed exactly where which bag it was in so I was able to take that out it was a very single process and it probably delayed me 15 seconds all right board member young thank you chair um Dr battle I had asked you this but I want

066to make sure it's explained because I've had a number of parents and students also that have reached out to explain why uh we have metal detectors already uh for athletic events and so if you can just help folks understand why that you repurposing those is not uh a viable way of kind of securing the schools at this point and and just because I've had so many people reach out say well we already have metal detect for for for athletics why why don't we you know shift those around and you can kind of explain the logistics behind why that would or would not work absolutely so we currently um do leverage um metal detectors at um our some of our athletic events um and other concerts and events um at the school level and so as

067we're talking about um the layers of support you know part of the part of the approach has been comprehensive um in the nature of trying to quite frankly build the relationships and respect our young people to be as less intrusive but safe um as possible and so um we've essentially exhausted those um strategies so that um again has led us to this discussion around the weapon detection um systems but simply we don't have the capacity or the ability to repurpose um the the systems that are in place one they are much smaller so you can um it'll it would would delay entry um the weapons detection system allows for a faster um kind of safer if you will less intrusive way um for us to U Move students in um from arrival to the the

068the school um where they're learning um so that's one example it's the same conversation when you think about school resource officers um as you're building out your comprehensive plan um you can't take something and give something and so we're looking at expansion right expanding um those strategies um that we've learned from quite frankly we've learned from those strategies being at our athletic events into our school um setting so those are just a few um reasons why we can't just do the swap nor will we have the capacity um because those are much smaller systems um that could not handle the demand um of the weapons detection system board member Tyler um yeah just one thing real quick um you mentioned that this is a pilot at anoch right now and I know that there are

069other high schools who are concerned about their student body can you just talk a little bit about our our thoughts about expanding this absolutely so um we of course one want to continue to implement with High Fidelity the strategies we have in place um including building um strong relationships see something say something we've got to continue all of those um practices across um our schools at the same time we're leveraging um our um partnership with MPD um we have um increased um our security where we needed to um where we there was a Potential Threat we've leverage our own mmps um security team as well um so they will continue to support all of our schools they will do um searches at our schools um some of them random in nature um to make sure

070we're supporting all the schools across the district in addition to that as we're thinking about this pilot while we're already piloting in Antioch High School we are exploring um pretty rapidly what it would look like um to Pilot across um all of our schools starting with our high schools and then moving um throughout our system as we um see fit and determined um again and um working closely with the board where we land with that um will be up to this board but I want to make sure that we provide you all the necessary information and feedback um so that as we look at expansion we can be um clear about our path forward um and how we might expand across um the district given the various variables um we want to solve for first

071um I know that there has been some talk about maybe getting some grants or help to pay for something of this magnitude how can our parents and the board help advocate for that at the state level to um get them to look into providing that kind of grant funding so that we can do this as quickly as possible for as many schools as to keep our kids safe yeah I mean I I'll I'll tell you when you look at um the implementation of um this type of um pretty complex system um in our schools the reason you don't see a high percentage of schools and school districts implementing them is because it is a very significant investment um and school budgets typically um are not at a level where you can at scale um invest

072in them and so I mean we're talking about as low as two to 5% of schools and school districts across the country implementing um a weapon detection system so the investment is significant um it would be it will be important um both at the state level and the local level we know we've got a um we've had some historic Investments at the um local level which has helped does make huge steps in the right direction but because of the wul underfunding that we've experienced over the years we still have a lot of need um and so advocating at both levels will um be critically important because we will have to secure the funding um in order to you know have a large scale pilot or full implementation um across our school district again if you

073and talking with other leaders across the country which I always do but I have significantly um increased um touch points over the last few days um that has been the biggest barrier um is the investment followed by the the the comprehensive layered support that they're trying to build in before they get there all right uh School Board member Chan I just wanted to ask some clarification questions so are these going to be like every entrance so that's to be determined but it is likely we will determine which we already have the the entrance points for schools so it will depend on the size of the school um it will depend on the design of the school for instance at your school you likely have um a primary entrance which opens up into your new beautiful

074Lobby um there um I would imagine that would be a um Point by which we would have entry it is likely that it will also be only one or two um entry points if we can get it down to one that would be our goal okay um and how often will these like be checked throughout like the month the system itself yeah everything is working that is a question that Jill if you don't mind I'm responding to because it's a connected system it's going to be doing a self check every time it's turning on right and it's looking at it and because it's at fixed width we are able to actually remote in and see many of the issues that you could have um and and the person who's actually using the tablet would be

075able to see if there was a critical alert or some sort of notification that the system was not operating appropriately so when you power cycle on the system it goes through a many different checks and it actually does a self check every time you're powering it on so we encourage schools to to turn off power and recycle the power at least once a week if they can many schools choose to do it every day you know but that that's really helps with the health of the system and I'll add that um through um our partnership with systems Integrations they are who we use for a lot of our other technology um so when we have things like cameras or things go offline they're actually who already do this um work for us to make sure

076um that it's up and so it sounds like a very similar we know something is wrong with the system many times before the operator does um yep to the software all right see no further comments we'll move on to public comment um if you have signed up for public comment please approach the desk you have two minutes to speak uh we will begin with Leland Evans how are you all doing this evening um this is going to be tough to get done in two minutes but I'm going to do everything I can to make sure it happens I stand here before you not as a single individual but as the voice of over 2,500 people who have signed a petition mandating that there be metal detectors placed at the schools I had a whole speech

077written out but as I sat in the back I couldn't help but listen to you all talk for over an hour and have heard nothing to make me feel safe as a parent you all told it that there's uh shatterproof glass that sounds like something that's a reactive decision you all told it having cameras that you spent lots of money on that can detect a gun and it didn't work as out of your own mouth said that it was ineffective talking about if you see something say something that sounds just like the gun system that did not work because if they see it guess what it's too late what are you all doing to make sure that preventative measures are taking place having a gun in the school it's too late the gun the the

078you told about the first responders that showed up by the time the First Responders got there the situation was already over my child doesn't go to Antioch high school so having a pilot program only at Antioch High School does nothing for me as a parent or any of the other 2000 parents students who have signed this petition saying that we want metal detectors at all of our schools we are tired of seeing school shootings happen and you all sit here and talk about the good things that happened the bad thing that happened is what we want to see you come up with the answer for we no longer need you to come up with spending our money on camera systems that are ineffective we want Solutions and we're telling you what solution we want we

079want metal detectors at our schools thank you thank you Richard hedg paath Richard hedgepath Lyn Anton Lyn Anton Tyran Hill Tyran Hill Kesha pway Kesha pway Nicole John hi there my name is Nicole Johns I am with the child safe division of American Income we are a life insurance company that is we're fully Union uh we are the only life insurance company that is fullly Union and we help protect Working Families and we help uh the safety of children uh specifically on Elementary level we provide child safe kits at completely no cost to elementaries and we want to be able to get it out to as many districts as possible we specifically work with mempis Shelby County Schools um here in Tennessee well it's probably our biggest District here in Tennessee that we work with

080um and in here is partent information that the um police need fingerprinting updated photos medical details so if the child where to go missing be abducted I know sex trafficking is a huge problem specifically in Memphis um that information can go right to the police uh there's a app as well with that information so if the child were to go missing they have that instantly you press a button it goes right to the police um we do this on a flyer basis so for every flyer um that is it goes home to a student and every flyer that is returned we donate a dollar back to the school or the school district that is completely up to you guys and with Memphis we work with about half the schools right now um and we have

081donated over $7,000 to them and we um really are just looking for permission to be able to work with you guys and we do provide gift cards as well $250 gift cards for teachers as well uh with the Flyers so just permission to work with you guys um or just approach the elementary schools thank you thank you Christian bugs [Music] hello Dr battle uh mmps board members I had a different I had a different set of words planned but I remember sitting at that day with you all after the covet elementary school shooting I remember us being berated and it being suggested that Educators needed to do more schools needed to do more I am reminded often of the words of our former colleague Dr Gentry that schools are where Community issues Bubble Up that

082we as a community have got to be more thoughtful about what it takes to educate a child because I send my son Christopher to school in mnps every single day to make sure that he is taught how to read how to write and how to do arithmetic I take on the task of making sure that I expose him to as much as I can to make sure that he is loved on but there are so many students and so many families who just don't have that capacity and so it is you all's task unfortunately to do that but I would suggest that all of the planning all of the hours that you all have invested in making sure that all 81,000 students all almost 11,000 employees understand that task understand that sometimes they are buying

083shoes and pants they are sometimes acting as the cafeteria the heroic cafeteria staff acted that day to make sure that students were supported and protected putting themselves in In Harm's Way it's not that I suggest that this is perfect that these systems we all operate in are perfect I am suggesting that I am glad that there are people that wake up every day trying to be thoughtful about what happens to our young people I know that there are Community groups such as uh Second Harvest Food Bank and mercy shifts uh the Community Foundation of Middle Tennessee uh the Nashville School violence support and healing fund a number of other groups that came together immediately to make sure that children not very different than my own were at least supported after a tragedy like this so

084it's it is human for us to feel frustrated to feel uh a sense of almost anger but I thank you for stepping in at a time such as this and pencil is here to support you thank you Harold gardet Harold gardette Aaron Turner Aaron Turner Meredith Libby I want to extend my condolences and hope for healing to the Escalante family and all the families in the Antioch High School Community who were affected by this tragedy I am a mother of two k through 12 menro Nashville Public Schools graduates and a former employee um my youngest daughter graduated just 5 years ago and I really am here to express my thanks my daughters were exceptionally well prepared for college but the benefits of metro schools for them were far more than academic and our schools students

085have the opport opportunity to make friends with or at least learn to get along with students of many backgrounds and from around the world teachers coaches administrators help students like my daughters Thrive academically Excel on the playing field and prepare for the future in fact my daughters were encouraged by their teachers to register and vote and Advocate at Metro Council the state legislature and Beyond and they have done so I'm proud my daughters are Metro school's gr grad ues so while we are grieving and searching for ways to make our school communities even safer I want to thank the faculty the staff administrators and Board of Education members who have the toughest part-time job out there in my opinion for the work you've done already and the work that you're going to do in the

086days ahead thank you Miss Libby uh we will now move on to governance issues um I will entertain a motion to approve the consent agenda is there is moved by school member Young seconded by Vice chair Nal Kenny is there a discussion see no discussion we'll move on to a vote all in favor say I I any oppose it passes unanimously thank you um will Mr Christopher come up to the Das come here Mr Christopher come here no come here come to the door oh yeah yeah I want us to end on a positive note and why we're here uh come here on the side this is Mr Christopher he is one of our board babies and I'm going to have him G gas g g W us out so say be no further business

087be no further business we are adjourned we are adjourned B it y thank you every this has been a service of the Metro Nashville network if you would like to to see this presentation again or for more information on this and other programs visit nashville.gov [Music]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.