CorpusRecord 73913

01/14/25 MNPS Board of Education

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Metro Nashville Network
Date
2025-01-15
Location
Coffee County, TN
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,298 words · about 47 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001starting announcements uh before our board meetings instead of at the end of a our board meetings so we're going to go ahead and get started with district one for announcements well good evening everyone good evening I have a couple of announcements today I'll let folks get settled a little bit no she y'all a tough crowd all right first announcement at M Medical College our School of Dentistry is hosting their annual dental clinic it's going to be free on February 7th and they're going to do free dental exams cleanings oral health education they'll do free x-rays filling sealant uh pretty much all of the basic care that you need uh for your mouth and uh and it's free to all young people um and it's on February 7th from 8: to 300 p.m. at the dental

002school at mahary Medical College my next announcement takes place on January 18th we have our North Nashville collaborative back to school supply reup so every year we provide school supplies in the middle of the school year because we know that many parents have gone through the supplies that they got at the beginning of the year and so that event is going to take place January 18th from 10:00 a.m. to 100 p.m. at Hartman Park and there's going to be a celebrity there I heard and so you want to come and meet that person all right so January 18th 10 to 1 at Hartman Park you'll be able to get free school supplies and backpacks for your kids and that's all I have District Two District three pass District Five good evening um yeah I'll just

003roll into this one um exciting news from John early and our Vanderbilt partnership we were thrilled to announce out outstanding success of our scholars in Quarter Two benchmark assessments um I met with principal rigs on yesterday and we had 50% or higher to um to out out of the scholars to score um at meet expectations or above um we had 22 Scholars total in English math 17 Scholars science 22 Scholars social studies 10 Scholars um and again all of those met or exceeded expectations um and that was a part of our Vanderbilt partnership that we just established at the beginning of this school year um we're especially proud to report that those Scholars um achieved higher scores in all subjects overall um for both categories um and that that was just awesome to to hear

004the progress um and that's a reflection again in a dedication of our educator Educators um the students and without a doubt um the vanderbel partnership um stay tuned as we continue to celebrate and Foster those academic Excellence for John early also again for John early their annual uh black history program will be February um 5th from 10 to 12 and yours truly will have a case in the museum so come out in support yeah they decided to do me this year that was a surprise I was like oh wow not me but but yeah if you're available um February the 5th from 10: to 12 come out to John early for their annual black history program um it's a really amazing display of um arts and crafts all created and created from most of the

005students but then there are some special artifacts that are contributed from like Frisk and other museums from around the city that's it District Six good afternoon everybody I'm excited to share a few announcements regarding MLK Day in Nashville um we have already kicked off our annual MLK Day events uh that kicked off on January 12th with the woman of Faith panel our next event will be this coming well tomorrow actually it will be Banner day it's going to be held at Robert Churchwell Elementary School starting at 6: pm. it'll be from 6: p.m. to 8:00 p.m. this is an opportunity for the community to come out and um create banners that will be used in our annual MLK Day March which will be held on January 20th uh again that will be tomorrow from 6

0066:00 p.m. to 8:00 p.m. at uh rubber Churchwell Elementary School and then you can join us on well you can't join us but the next event will be this Thursday January 16th the annual MLK Gaya this event will be held at the parnon but it is completely sold out I cannot stress enough that if you have not already secured ticket you will not be able to attend this event this is um there will not be tickets available at the door for this event on Friday the 17th is the annual labor and human rights breakfast which will take place at scarrett Bennett center from 7:30 a.m. to 10: a.m. again this event is completely sold out so I thank you Nashville for supporting both of these events and selling them out so quickly on Saturday January

00718th will be the youth Symposium which will be held at MLK academic Magnet School we invite all of our young people to come out for this event we will have um an intergenerational panel and workshops for our young people if you are planning to attend this event I would uh can I would ask you to please go ahead and register in advance we will provide lunch and uh breakfast for the students but you will have to register in advance so that we have an accurate headcount so you can go to our website at MLK nashville.com to register for this event on Saturday January 19th at 3M we will hold our youth worship service it will be held at First Baptist Church Capitol Hill starting at 3 p.m. you don't have to register for for this

008event we encourage you all to come out to this event as well and on Monday January 20th it is MLK day and we will hold our annual MLK Day youth rally and March at Jefferson Street Baptist Church the rally will begin at 8:00 a.m. and the March will begin at 9:00 a.m. please please note that Jefferson Street will be closed from 26th Avenue down to 33rd Avenue North for the March this month this year because we're are celebrating our 40th year anniversary we are also uh welcoming three of our high school bands to participate in the march with us those will be Antioch High School Whites Creek High School and Cane Ridge High School they will be participating in the March and we're super excited about that um the annual convocation will take place immediately

009following the March down Jefferson Street it will begin at 10:00 a.m. and will feature our keynote speaker this year uh Dr Daniel black who is the professor of African-American studies at Clark Atlanta University we're super excited about that and we hope that you will come out and join us for these MLK Day events in Nashville um thank you that's all I have for now district 7 um I have no announcements but there was a cell phone left in the ladies room so if you're missing a cell phone check the Ladies Room District 8 um wanted to just we are uh about to be in the optional School window and I know schools are having visits um for families and students so um if you're interested in a school that might have um openings you can

010find that information on the school options page and then you can go to websites for school um parent teacher organizations Etc to find out about times to go visit um schools to get familiar the best way to know um what a school is like is actually to get some experience in that school um I know that uh as part of the HERO program um and uh unicycle they are collecting still winter coats um and sweatshirts um you can drop those off at most schools so if you have um after the recent snowstorm uh ascertained that there are some available things in your house that maybe got too small between this year and last year um folks could use those um and then lastly we're going to hear in a few minutes um about an initiative

011done um at Percy Priest um to do with grief supports for students and I've said this here before but nationally something like one in um nine kids experience the death of a parent sibling or caregiver um during uh the time between when they are born and age 18 um with the population of students and families that we have here in Nashville that number probably drops to one and seven um and with uh with students that are living um either uh in poverty or in more difficult conditions that number can go as low as one and four um and so just to draw awareness to what our kids are experiencing um you may encounter students in your life that you don't know are going through the loss of a parent sibling or caregiver um and so

012grateful to the work that py priest is doing um and to the nonprofits we work here in town thanks District nine um just a plug for the application for the School of Science and Math at vanderbild ssmv if you're more familiar with the acronym it's still open the applications for it are still open and they're going to close on February 17th they opened on January 6 um and it is for current mnps 8th graders um it gives you the opportunity to go take some classes at Vanderbilt it's really exciting it'll be lasting for your whole High School career and um every single student I know who has done it just Raves about it and it is amazing it's a wonderful program if you don't know about it and you are a current eighth grader or

013you have a current eighth grader I would suggest looking into it that application is open until February 17th Junior board member um good evening everybody uh students I hope you all eny enjo the snow day um in your break happy New Year Of course um so January 20th of course we have ml day um I highly encourage you guys to come to the events um second of all uh John Overton which I attend January 7th through January 27th through 31st we have new Lunar New Year celebration week um so that should be really exciting and then lastly for Academy Schools uh Academy selection is coming up for freshmen um so be encouraged to make the right choice and educate yourselves thank you senior board member hi everyone uh just wanted to say that in two

014Saturdays the debate tournament I think will be held at MLK so looking forward to that um and also for seniors have yourself on the backat because most most if not all college applications are you know are done I I went through it too it's rough um but you know congrats from finishing that that's and for District 4 I will be resuming my community meeting so we will have our first uh community meeting of the new year on Tuesday January 21st from 6:00 to 7:30 at The Donaldson Library um so if you are available please join me at The Donaldson library on Tuesday the 21st um from 6:00 to 7:30 p.m. and happy New Year and welcome back to your second semester of school hope everyone in here has a great second semester and we finish

015off the school year [Music] strong and with no other announcements we're going to end the session thank you e e e um Chief robl will you lead us to a bedge of Allegiance I bless allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stand na indivisible Chief Perry you escaped yes um uh if you please indulge us um going take a point of personal privilege we'll do a brief moment of silence for our um fellow Americans in California who have lost everything particularly schools um we know schools are the stability of our children and of our community They don't serve as places of education but serves as a place where Community comes together um for Relief and rieve um and respit and um we send our condolences

016out to our fellow Schoolboard members in um Los Angeles County um for the long work in head that they have to do and The Grieving that they have to do of loss of their buildings so please let's have a moment of silence thank you uh now we'll move on to adoption of the adoption of the agenda I will entertain a motion to approve the agenda motion to approve there's been a motion there's been a motion by chair Mae and a second by Vice chair nabal Kenny uh oh well cherry merid uh chair Emeritus Ma and vice chair um theal and Kenny um is there any discussion seeing none all in favor say I I any oppose all right the adoption agenda stands now we'll move on to Awards and recognitions I will now turn over

017to our director of schools Dr battle uh for this section all right thank you so much chair player and good evening to all of our board members um tonight we have an outstanding student an athlete and two awardwinning schools to celebrate first up I'd like to start with Joshua Sims from Pearl cone high [Laughter] school so Joshua is the 2024 winner of the William eh Hume award which honors the mmps senior football player who best exemplifies sportsmanship academic Excellence individual performance on the field and significant contributions to his team the hum award has been given annually since 1944 Joshua is a very deserving winner of this prestigious award in the classroom he is in the top 5% of the Pearl cone class of 2025 here's May the honoral every semester and has taken multiple dual

018enrollment courses now on the field he has been a team captain for both football and track he was all state as a defensive back in 2023 when he helped lead the fire Birds to the twaa state football championship and he was the individual state champion in the boys 400 meters in 2020 24 y'all that is significant a two-time state champion um he has received more than 20 offers from division one football programs and plans to major in um premade um and other medical Fields um when he's in college so let's give him a round of applause and no matter where he does his work or how he makes his Mark Joshua is always known for his kindness leadership positive attitude commitment to teamwork humility resilience and outstanding work ethic Joshua Sims thank you for representing

019Pearl cone in Nashville Public Schools so well and congratulations on winning the hum award um Joshua we'd like to give it up for you one more time and get a quick photo after he takes some individual pictures Joshua if you can come up um towards the front and I'd like to invite our school board um member to join you and our chair and the entire Pearl com um family and team that's here and any family members who might be with you we ready all right one [Laughter] all right congratulations again to Joshua on the hum award his many outstanding accomplishments um now I'd like to recognize one of our elementary schools for blazing a new Trail this year Percy Priest Elementary School is the first school in the district and the only one in Middle

020Tennessee to win the grief sensitive School Grant in designation the grief sensitive schools initiative is part of New York life's Nationwide effort to better equip Educators and other school Personnel to care for grieving students this fits in perfectly with our commitment as a district to social emotional learning and to supporting our students in whatever we can Percy Priest is using its GR funds to create what will be known as heart's Garden when the brand new Percy Priest facility opens for the 2025 26 school year they plan to purchase smooth Stones Paint pin a plaque and a small border for a tree or shrub after a loss of a loved one any student or staff member will be able to get a stone from the counseling office and decorate it in honor of their person or

021pet which they can do either at school with counselors or at home with family once they finish decorating the S they'll place it in the garden this is a beautiful way to support our students and staff after a challenging loss I hope more of our schools can apply for and win this Grant and I appreciate principal Russell young and school counselor Kristen Kyper verman or Miss KB as the students call her for leading this effort at Percy Priest um I'd like to recognize Percy Priest Elementary School at this time um all the leaders who are here please come on up let us celebrate you and we'd love to get a quick photo one two want to get all right again congratulations and thank you to Percy Priest Elementary um and finally I'd like to recognize

022another Elementary School for a job very well done Tom Joy Elementary School recently was named a Blue Ribbon School of Excellence Beacon School based on the Blue Ribbon Schools of Excellence National validated assessment process Tom Joy has met or exceeded requirements in the n performance areas for this recognition student focus and support school organization and culture challenging standards and curriculum active teaching and learning technology and integration professional learning leadership and education Vitality School family and Community Partnerships and indicators of success as a digital literacy and Leadership Magnet School Tom Joe incorporates the purposeful use of digital tools to build student engagement empow student voice and create more meaningful learning experiences Tom Joyce students work with real world Technologies to learn and communicate the entire team there has worked hard to make sure students are getting

023the high quality instructional supports they need every day so I'm very proud of Tom Joy's principal Dr Shelley hood and everyone on the falcony and staff there for their hard work their commitment to Innovation and everything they do to increase academic outcomes and drive Student Success we're also extremely proud of all of the students and families that are part of the Tom Joy family so at this time please give me a moment to acknowledge Tom Joy um the team and representatives that are here um let's celebrate them and we'd love to get a photo Blue Ribbon one two at this time um that will conclude our Awards and recognitions um chair I will turn it back over to you thank you very much Dr battle we will now move on to public participation uh we

024will have the list on the screen um if you're here for public participation um we have 2 minutes to speak there is a timer um at the end of the day is here that will count down um where the timing of their remarks um and we will start with Jasmine hairro hello my name is Jasmine Herr I'm in district one I'm up here speaking on behalf of explore um my son has been at explore for three years now and with him being a preey he uh was diagnosed with autism and explore has actually been very exceptional in his progress uh cuz he did have a small speech impediment he gets speech therapy and occupational therapy and just in the three years that he's been there I've seen tremendous strides in his speech how he communicates

025with people um also uh and his fine motor skills he definitely had to work on tying shoes buttoning clothes um and as far as the core values they've actually they've taught my son how to be compassionate and take other people's feelings into consideration um whenever he does something uh I they have taught him to think before he acts and also having a school like that I live in Casey right across street from the school having a school like that in that neighborhood is beneficial to all the kids over there because there are several special need actually more than several special needs kids over there that need those type of um to have assess what's the word I'm looking for to be able to assess the programs that they need to achieve their goals that's what

026I was trying to say um that school caters to all the different children that live in that neighborhood and that is it I still have eight yep 17 seconds thank you thank you uh Marque Smith good evening good evening my name is marqueis Smith I'm with District 3 bellshire Terrace Drive um I'm a proud parent of two students that explore Community School my oldest daughter is in 8ighth grade and my son is in the fifth they have both been an Explorer since kindergarten during my daughter's eighth grade year she has worked with her principal and teachers to identify her areas of interest and learn more about high school programs she is an athlete but also strong student she has had opportunity to visit multiple high schools in the area to determine which is her best

027fit to meet for her future goals this has also inspired her to be a better leader at explore and for her peers each week Explorer wears their vest to morning programs and have the opportunity to earn pens and Milestones in front of their peers these can be for showing core values academic achievements and other special recog recog recognitions it's a great way for them to build confidence as they prepare for life in the real world Explorer is built on five cores curiosity Community compassion courage and craftsmanship my kids have been trained in these values since kindergarten and continue to live out these values in school and in their daily lives they are an inspiration to me and my family and as well to those who come in contact with them at Community I ask for

028your vote in renewing explore community school thank you thank you tag steel I mispronounced it please correct me Tajima steel um good evening Madam chair and members of the board my name is Tajima steel I am the director of schools for rocket ship Tennessee I am here this evening to speak to our Charter renewal application for Rocky ship United Academy I have overseen the academic programs at all three rocket ship schools in Nashville for the past two years uh prior to that I was the proud principal at rocket ship United Academy I actually began my career Journey with rocket ship as a founding teacher at United Academy 10 years ago this year I was driven to work at rocket ship because of the focus on personalized learning which benefits all students but especially our large

029population of historically under under served and disadvantaged students but one of the many reasons I've stayed at rocket ship is because rocket ship values talent development and building our teacher pipeline from within I am an example of that and so too is the school's current principal who also started as a teacher I was given opportunities to build and demonstrate my leadership and I do the same with those I coach and supervise rocket ship believes in building the strengths and capacity of everyone in our school Community our focus on Talent Development has created stability and consistency evidenced by our high levels of teacher retention this type of stability is essential to maintain academic progress and academic growth the academic track record at rocket ship United Academy demonstrates what is possible for students when we value and

030invest in the adults who are teaching them as a result we have built a school community that our families our Scholars and our staff trust and depend on we re respectfully ask that you vote in support of our Charter renewal application thank you and thank you for your time thank you Benjamin Hart uh thank you members for letting me and everybody else come and speak to you all tonight um I'm in here in support of the charter renewal application for rocket ship United Academy as well my name is Benjamin harp and as our director of schools just stated I am a part of the talent pipeline that is Rec ship United starting as a teacher serving as an assistant principal for 5 years and now I'm in my second year as principal of that campus

031as well several of you have had the opportunity to come and visit our campus so thank you it is so great to see you all again and those of you who were not able to come visit we encourage you to please come to our campus and see what our community is about but if you want to give me a little time to give you a preview if you just look out behind you at all the purple this is us this is our community we show up we show out for our school our families represent how diverse Nashville is in its entirety speaking over a dozen different languages on our campus we work in partnership with our families we build a positive School culture that is welcoming to all you'll always see our students represented through

032the photographs on the walls and you'll always see our parents in the hallway supporting their students and supporting their teachers in and out of the classroom as well our teachers work really closely with these families to make sure that every student reaches their individual learning goal on a personal level we focus on what students are able to learn what they're capable of being able to learn and what they're able to achieve regardless of where they started from or what their zip code is and that's why our school has achieved the Tas level five four out of the five years that the scores have been issued since we since we've opened and we've been recognized as reward school three separate instances in my 10e at rocket ship United in 2018 22 and in 2023 we are

033probably one of the most diverse High perform performing elementary schools in the city of Nashville and we have achieved these results based on everybody that you see here behind me in this sea of purple we ask that you please vote Yes so we can continue this impact for another 10 years thank you so much thank you Randy Flo good evening boy members my name is Brandy flenoy and I stand proudly before you today advocating first as a parent for my first my first grader Rocketeer and secondly as a rocket ship United Academy teacher um out of all the schools I could have S my child to I chose rocket ship and I chose rocket ship because I believe deeply in children being able to access a quality education that is rooted in equity for all

034daily I watch my child her peers my students flourish as their potential is Unleashed and one of the things I love here at rocket ship is that we have a all mindset providing Equitable opportunities for all of our students and their families so overall like rocket ship United Academy is an all encompassing educational environment that supports both academic and personal growth of students while providing invaluable benefits to their to the entire community and also their families so in a sense we all want the same thing a future where every child no matter where they come from has a chance to thrive so voting yes for rocket ship is voting for that future voting yes for rocket ship is voting for equity and voting yes for rocket ship is voting for opportunity and lastly voting yes

035for rocket ship is voting for a brighter future for every child regardless of their background so these future the future of these children are in our hands some of my students are in this room today so together we must join together and ensure that every child's potential is not just fully embraced but it's grown to their best of their abilities so thank you for your time today and your support support and please join us in making a lasting impact by voting yes for Rocky show United Academy thank you Ruby cers part own sorry Hi good evening members of the board my name is Ruby calron I am a very I'm very proud to stand here today not only as a parent leader with rocket ship United Academy but also as a former student of MPS

036meaningful it's very meaningful to me for to me I'm sorry to be a former student and now as a parent with two children uh fourth grader and a second grader they started with IEP at rocket ship one of them this year graduated from IEP with his autism and my second is still an IEP uh student at rocket ship uh my daughter has a CMT disease this in the future will prevent from her being able to walk but rocket ship has supported us not only academically they have been able to help us with the walker and a wheelchair mostly uh they have shown support towards her dreams and goals this year she made the cheer leading team which I am beyond uh grateful she tried out she made the team she is able to live a

037dream while God peritter Mobility difficulties Rua has shown that they believe in each student's dreams and goals to be accomplished I would also like to express our deep appreciation to the board members that took the time to meet with the parent leaders and were able to tour our school we truly enjoy getting to know to know you and sharing incredible commitment and the and understanding the needs that our families that you serve and we hope that this is just the beginning of stronger partnership and ongoing collaboration we as parent leaders regarding today's boat outcome we would like to still extend the invitation to the other board members that we emailed previously to come and meet with us as parents at rocket ship and to show you the work behind all the data you may have

038before you I would like to highlight that we recently emailed of support from all our families many of whom are here today these are letters with that show powerful Testaments to the impact of our school has had on their children and their belief in our shared mission in providing Equitable opportunities for all our students we hope you got the chance to review these stories as they reflect the heart of our school and why we are here today thank you thank you Jenny Sano good evening esteemed board members my name is Jenny salano and I am proud to stand before you as a first generation Latina college student and Alum of rocket ship United Academy on both sides of my family I am the first American Born 10 years ago I was a fourth grader walking

039through was hallways when it opened its first year first year Miss steel now our director of schools was my principal today I am a biom major on a pred Dental track Paving the way not just for my myself but for others with similar backgrounds and dreams to my own joining me here tonight are two incredible peers who graduated with me for 10 years ago Joanna and David we all ran into each other during our Premed orientation at lipsum like myself all of us attended Charter Charter Schools K through 12 and together we represent the lasting impact of the elementary Foundation rocket ship provided us with rocket ship was not just a school it was a family our teachers believed in us and helped us believe in our ourselves my peers here are my peers here

040today are multilingual Learners who remember the support teachers provided when you're learning a new language and now a decade later we stand before you as living proof of a great education we are here to ask you to approve rocket ship United's Charter for another 10 years so that families and students can continue to have the same opportunities we did have a blessed night graus uh marra Rivera Mara Rivera sorry good evening members of the board uh my oldest son was in the founding class at stem prep graduated in 2019 after stem he earned a bachelor's degree in computer science from UT at Knoxville today he works at the robotics department at Amazon my second son graduated from stem in 2022 he is at the last year at Nashville State also studying computer science my youngest

041one is seven years uh it's in seventh grade at as prep middle school he wants to attend a college as well just like his brothers did I know this school has changed the curse of my son's life and I know this because my husband son my stepson had a very different experience at our son high school before stem prep existed in his first month as a freshman he was offered drugs in the bathroom and told them he needed to sell them he came to me for help I went to the dean when they later found my son with drugs at school instead of offering him support he was sent to another school which makes the case worth worse he ended up we ended up losing our son to drugs our family is from Honduras the

042story I just shared with you is like the many other stories in our community but a lot of parents don't speak out about it as Latinos we don't feel like the education opportunities were made for us but stem makes it very clear to all students that they can have an opportunity to grow and become someone that mind mindset has stayed in my sons within my sons and everything after they graduated I wish St prep had been an option for my stepson when he was in trouble please allow stamp prep to continue serving my family in our community graus uni uh seia good evening Board of members my my name is jice Topia and I am here this evening to speak to you about my student experience at s Prep High I am one of the

043lemon I um Stam prep middle from the founding class of fifth grade and I was also part of the first inaugural graduating class of stem Prep High I am here to speak to you about how much stem has transformed my life I was able to receive an amazing education by amazing professors and also just want to give thanks to Dr mcgreer for opening the doors to this school I was able to receive a higher education in a town where I am a first graduating student for my family I have immigrant parents and coming to Nashville Tennessee they did not have many opportunities and the one thing they did want was to provide their kids an education where they could be successful and stem open their doors for them and I'm very grateful for that because

044I was able to receive a scholarship and attend a private university I was also able to take ad do enrollment classes and my freshman year I was able to be almost a sophomore year and that helped me and my family financially because we didn't have much and being able to provide that scholarship in less years of university for me was in a great abundance and until this day now I decided to take the educ a route and now I am a teacher and I am back at St prep middle teaching I am an exceptional education teacher and I am here to say that I want to be able to provide education and change the lives of students like stem did for me and please take a note that stem open doors for others that we

045didn't have education so I please ask that you vote for stem for another 10 years to provide excellent education for them thank you thank you Michael Vine good evening everyone my name is Michael Paul Vine I'm a fifth grade ELA teacher at Paragon Mills Elementary School and because I need to be brief I just want to talk about two things reading and leading my problem is is that since September I've been reading email after message about following the script as it was intended of wit and wisdom yet a cursory Google search of the site the people who created it great minds reads and I quote wit and wisdom is not a scripted program so a what are we talking about B I want to talk about leadership just as I teach my students that just

046as up is defined by down left by Right leader is defined by follower willing follower otherwise you have a dictatorship and in the words of Chief thunder rolling in the mountains there's a whole lot of talking from people who have no right to talk the answer that I ask for is please you hired me I'm fairly educated much more than most please let me do my job and if you can't please be silent now and just in case you're wondering there will be a test thank you Barry Barlo to board member player to directs the school Dr battle to the rest of the school board members and to these uh even student members members it's good to see you as well I am here tonight to Simply say thank you thank you for all the

047hard work that metro public schools has done year in and year out I've had the pleasure and the honor of serving as PTO president steam advisor council member mnp mnx next just an array of things with this organization and I'm here to say thank you because this organization has given me an opportunity to flourish to use my gifts but most importantly it has made it possible for the young people who are my children who are my neighbors who are my nieces and nephews and great nieces and nephews to be able to go to the next levels of life without weary and I am so proud to been a part of I think the greatest thing that M mnps offers is the fact that you have an opportunity to have choice choice the choice to go

048to a charter school the choice to go to a traditional and Zone School the choice to go to a magnet school a stem school and so I think all of that for me has made it worth it and I could have never imagine that one day I would sit in this very room and watch my youngest child be honored as a a a salutatorian of her High School graduating class while I was at the same time serving as the first ever PTO president and I pleased to say to you I'm in touch with hundreds of students and I'm glad to say that you all are making students classroom career and job ready and I say thank you to all of you thank you Mr Barlo we will now move on to governance issues um we

049will I will entertain a motion to accept the consent agenda motion to accept the consent agenda as uh there is a motion from board member maziz is there a second second second from Vice chair Nal and Kenny um is there a discussion all in favor say I any oppose uh the consent agenda passes unanimously we will now move on to Charter renewal applications I will now turn over to our director of schools Dr battle thank you so much um chair player at this time I'd like to invite up Dr sharik Kobi Grant um who will lead us through our Charter renewal um presentation Madam chair memb MERS of the board and superintendent battle thank you for the opportunity to share the Charter office review team reports on six Charter renewal applications this evening the charter

050school office will present the renewal application ratings and renewal recommendations for Valor Voyager stem Prep High School rocket ship United explore Community School strive Collegiate and Kip a Academy Nashville Elementary at Kirk Patrick the renewal process has four main objectives use the published evaluation criteria from the Tennessee Department of Education incorporate supporting documentation within the review rate each section using the tdoe rating standards and reach a consensus and recommendation as you can see on the flowchart the review process is similar when rating a new start and renew application one distinction within the review process for a renewal application is review members provide a recommendation of renewal or nonrenewal of the applicant sections within the renewal application include the following academic success operational stability Financial Health and future planning these sections were rated by review team

051members utilizing tdoe guidance from the rubric ratings of meets or exceeds the standard partially meets the standard or does not meet the standard as determined by the characteristics listed tonight the board court has the option to approve or deny each renewal application state law requires each Charter application be considered and voted on separately if the board votes to deny the renewal application the charter schools governing body May appeal to the public charter school state commission within 10 days of the date of the decision to deny please note if the renewal application is denied and the appeal is submitted an appeals hearing will proceed with the Tennessee Charter commission the charter commission has the option to uphold or overturn the decision of the school district in the event the decision is overturned the charter commission will

052become the Lea for the renewal applicant we will begin this evening with Valor Voyager a 58 charter school with an enrollment cap of 520 students located in the southwest quadrant of Davidson County the applicant was rated as meets or exceeds standards in each of the rated categories we will now move to rocket ship United a K5 charter school with an enrollment cap of 525 students in the Southeast quadrant of Davidson County the applicant was rated as meets or exceeds standard in each of the rated categories next we have stem Prep High School a 9912 charter school with an enrollment cap of 483 students located in the Southeast quadrant of Davidson County the applicant was rated as meets or exceed standards in three of the four categories and partially meet standards in one of the rated

053categories the next renewal application is explore Community School a K8 charter school with an enrollment cap of 900 students located in the Northeast quadrant of Davidson County the applicant was rated as meets or exceed standards in three of the four rated categories and partially meet standard in one of the rated categories utilizing the guidance from tdoe a charter school should be renewed if it did not commit a material violation of its Charter agreement met or made sufficient progress toward the performance expectations in its Charter agreement and generally met the accepted standards of fiscal management the review team determined that the academic outcomes the operational conditions the financial conditions and goals for the next Charter term Merit renewal of the charter agreements I will turn it over to the board for the discussion and vote for

054Valor Voyager rocket ship United stem Prep High School and explore Community School renewal applications please note that each Charter renewal application must be voted on separately we will start the discussion and vote for Valor Voyager I will entertain a motion uh Vice chair Nal Kenny I move to approve the charter renewal for Valor Voyager based on the recommendation of the charter renewal team second there's been a uh been motion by move by Vice chair nenny uh second by member ma discussion since there's no discussion we'll move to a vote all in favor say I I any oppose the motion passes next we'll move on to rocket ship I will entertain a motion for rocket ship Vice chair nbal McKinny I move to approve the charter renewal for rocket ship United based on the recommendation of

055the charter renewal team second um it's been moved by Vice chair nbal mckenny it's been seconded by member Mae is there a discussion seeing none we'll move to a vote all in favor say I any oppose passes unanimously we will move on we will move on to stem Prep High School um Vice chair mcken I move to approve the charter renewal of stem Prep High School based on the recommend of the charter renewal team second there's been a motion by Vice chair Nal mckenny this has been seconded by member ma discussion seeing no discussion we'll move on to a vote all in favor say I any oppose it passes unanimously motion proves motion passes move on to explore Community School Vice chair nbal Kenny I move to approve the charter renewal of explore Community School

056based on the recommendation of the charter renewal team second there's a second it was um moved by Vice chair nbal Kenny second by member maiz uh discussion I just want to say very quickly uh just a quick thank you to all of our Charter applicants for doing your due diligence and making it uh um an easy your decision for us because you have submitted all of the required documents that are needed to help us move forward in our decision making so thank you for doing your due diligence all right we we will now um move on to a vote all in favor say I any oppose say nay uh the motion passes so um we move on to uh strive collegia yes we will transition to our final two applicants strive collegate and Kip Academy

057Nashville Elementary at Kirk Patrick we will begin with strive collegate a 68 middle school with an enrollment cap of 360 students located in the Northeast quadrant of Davidson County the applicant was rated as meets or exceeds standard in one of the four rated cat categories and partially meet standard in the remaining three rated categories the review team determined that this Charter Schools academic outcomes operational condition Financial condition and goals for the next Charter term Merit renewal of the charter agreement serving only grades 6 through eight if the board appr votes to approve the renewal application the charter office will continue to leverage its meeting and observation structures aligned to the progressive intervention policy approved by the board in July of 2023 where the Charter office Sor you please to the room quietly can you please

058ex to the room quietly we're still conducting business thank you excuse me sorry for the interruption if the board votes to approve the renewal application the Char office will continue to leverage its meeting and observation structures aligned to the progressive intervention policy approved by the board in July of 2023 where the Charter office will intensify its progress monitoring procedures but not limited to the following areas academics operations and future planning I will turn it over to the board for the discussion and vote for Strife Collegiate renewals application thank you I'll accept a motion Vice chair and N Bal and Kimmy I move to approve the charter renewal of strive collegate Academy based on the recommendation of the charter renewal team is there a second a second second uh mooved by Vice chair Nal Kenny second

059by member O'Hara block is there a discussion yes member Tyler please yes um so one of the few directives for charter schools in Tennessee is to close the achievement Gap in fact the original law that was written for the creation of charter schools state that the purpose of charter schools was to and I quote improve the learning for all students and close the achievement gap between high and low students and that language continues to exist in state law today meaning that starter Charters have a directive from state law to focus on closing achievement gaps based on the last 10 years strive has varied result results with closing achievement gaps with some gaps not just staying the same but they're actually widening and becoming worse um additionally I have serious concerns with their student attrition numbers

060they've been on a steady decline in their numbers the last few years in their eighth grade class right now is currently the largest one meaning that another drop is likely next year additionally with the sharp increase in their chronic absenteeism from 8% to 26% it speaks to their struggle to keep the existing students attending frequently enough to receive continuous instruction and because of these issues even with the supports that the Charter office is willing to give I cannot vote to renew strip's application thank you member block can I ask just a quick question can you repeat for us what the plan was from July 23 that you referenced and just could you be explicit about some of the supports that you all we go yes um so the 2023 Progressive intervention policy just details um

061supports that the Charter office will provide if a if a school is struggling in academics operations or financials um so the the the beginning phase is a non-compliance memo where we highlight to the charter school any area that we're seeing of concern um if that area still continues to be um a concern for the Charter office or noted as a deficiency it will move to a notice of concern uh where we do notify the governing board members of that particular Charter School the noted deficiency if the charter school continues to not come into compliance we do issue a notice of deficiency where we outline um that particular deficiency and issue a performance Improvement plan that the charter school would have to uh develop to correct the particular deficiency um if that is not corrected we

062move uh to the level of probation uh where the charter school is put on probation and then a corrective action plan is required um by the school if there are still uh areas of deficiencies that are noted um the board could move to revoke the charter agreement or put the school on notice um as far as restitution and looking at um reassigning the governing board of that particular uh charter school so we have the ability if we vote to renew the charter um we get the notices of concern as well um and we have the ability to follow through on any sort of uh sort of rationing up of the progressive um yes thank you for the proper terminology the progressive course of action that you just laid out up to an including revocation of

063the charter correct I'm just just confirming the process from here thank you yes and we do have language that includes it doesn't have to be Progressive at any moment depending on the deficiency we could move uh for revocation at any point great thank you very much member nah naah mcken so for clarification um going through through that process um in one two 3 years if if we're not seeing any Improvement we can move it towards revocation yes if we've gone through all of those processes correctly and I'll be clear there's not a this is not about amount of time right this is about the documented deficiencies and as was stated if egregious enough or if there is such a breach in the contract the board can uh move to a higher act level of action

064um another question over the time that we've seen the deficiencies because we have a a action plan in place as of 2023 has there how has the response been for corrective action uh particularly for strive they were noted as a TSI School in 2018 2019 um oh can you clarify whether a TSI school is targeted support and Improvement school um where uh particular subgroup did fall in the bottom 5% um and so they did receive a notice of concern uh from the Charter office and then worked um and was able to get off of the list so um in 20 the last three years they've received a Tas of level of a level 5 um in 2021 22 and then 22 23 they received a level five and then last year they received a level

065four so um they did come off of the TSI list was issued a notice of concern had to add specific action steps within their school Improvement plan uh to address the bottom 5% um students that were targeted as being uh targeted support and Improvement and they worked off of that particular list and two notes um TSI is a federal designation correct um so that's a a designation that comes from the US Department of Education and the second thing is you might have noticed in the term of their agreement they're originally a 58 school and so they have transition to a 68 school which this if approved for Renewal um there will remain a 68 School moving forward correct member young thank you madam chair um I just you know I don't I guess I mean

066we don't have audited financials because they changed staff and an accounting firm um the teacher retention rate is very concerning um and you know I was able to visit the school and uh it's an office building it felt sterile like a medical office building and and what concerns me further about that is when you look at their growth plans or one of the challenges that was identified is they're considering purchasing that building and I I just and those aren't necessarily achievement related but but I think all of these just kind of compound into this this concern I have that I'm I'm hesitant to give my stamp of approval on this um and I'll have to be a no on this but thank you madam chair thank you any other discussion all right I will move

067to a vote um if you're in favor please raise your hand if you're opposed raise your hand the motion passes 62 thank you we will now move on to Kip Academy and finally Kip Academy Nashville Elementary at Kirk Patrick is a K4 Elementary School with an enrollment cap of 350 students located in the Northeast quadrant of Davidson County the applicant was rated as meets or exceed standard in one of the four rated categories and partially meets in the remaining three rated categories in collaboration with the kip Charter management organization and as part of the renewal process the kip Academy Nashville Elementary at Kirk Patrick will serve as a K4 optional school with no Zone in alignment with with all other Charter Schools currently all fifth graders residing in the zone are zoned to Warner Elementary

068School starting in the 2025 2026 school year we will begin with kindergarten and add one grade each year completing the rezoning process by the 2029 2030 school year families will also have the option to participate in mns's optional School process the review team determined that this Charter School's academic outcomes operational condition Financial condition and goals for the next Charter term Merit renewal of the charter agreement and will operate as a K4 optional school if the board votes to approve the renewal application the Charter office will continue to leverage its meeting and observation structures aligned to the progressive intervention policy that was approved by the board where our office will intensify its progress monitoring procedures but not limited to the following areas of academics operations and future planning I will turn it over to the board

069for the vote and the discussion of Kip Academy Nashville at Kirk Patrick renewal's application thank you Vice chair Nal Kenny I move to approve the charter Ren renewal of Kip kpatrick um Academy Nashville Elementary I think that's the name of it yep based on the recommendation of the charter renewal team Sarah second a second second by member of Herold block um discussion yes member Tyler thank you um as I previously mentioned charter schools are directed by state law to close achievement gaps over the course of the last decade Kip has not closed the achievement Gap between general education students and exceptional education students they have had the full weight of a national Charter chain in Kip behind them to fundraise and provide extra funding to meet the needs of their exceptional Learners and they have

070had the autonomy to choose the curriculum to best support those students for a full 10 years and they have not been able to demonstrate a decrease in the achievement Gap in that time although it has made some gains in its overall academic performance it is still being outperformed by both the cluster it resides in and the district for mmps as a whole and it has um sorry I lost my place and that has been held that has held true since the 2017 2018 school year that's seven years or the majority of its time that it's been open where it has not performed as well as both its own cluster or the district as a whole goal additionally The Chronic absenteeism in 2023 for the school increased to a whopping 48.9% of their total School population

071and 55.1% for their exceptional education subgroup these students are simply not present frequently enough to receive continuous instruction and I cannot in good conscious agree to renew a school that's being so consistently outperformed by the surrounding choices and cannot get its students to attend class to try to do better thank you member o' hero block I I want to say um this is actually a tougher one for me than I would like for it to be um and one of the other things when Charters were started in Nashville and in this state is that they are there to uh theoretically provide Innovation provide for um competition and in a lot of always and looking at that the school has done its job because the schools the uh mmps run schools in the area are outperforming

072it um and that's sort of part of what has has uh been meant to happen here um in a theory that is one based on choice and competition some of these things I'm not saying I agree with or disagree with that um except that that they are being outperformed um there are however uh I'm just looking at the number number of students that are currently enrolled 350 students and all of their families who have chosen this particular school um and uh are zoned for the school now and we will be making a change in the zoning um students in this area could actually choose other schools in the area at the moment um if they wanted to write Zone schools you can still make other choices that's sort of how I meant it um but

073I do think that the the partnership ship um and the the discussion around this of looking at how can we uh try and ensure that students within this area have as many options as they can um that they have the ability to choose the uh to choose Warner um to choose idb Wells if those are their zoned schools um and that they can still choose Kip Academy Nashville if they would like to make that choice I think we are doing uh in this um in this movement and and making making an approval here and doing it with a change to Zone um I think we are sort of attacking this in the right way which is to say to Kip Academy Nashville Elementary we will renew but with these sort of conditions on that renewal

074um and we need to see Improvement and so I you know this is hard but I think we're doing uh the right set of things together here thank you any other discussions member Tyler sorry I just have to say [Music] I in a competition there are winners and losers and in education there should never be losers I just couldn't let that one go sorry thank you thank you any discussion Mr uh member Taylor thank you uh only other thing want to add is just that um this is based on the recommendations from our Charter office and as a board member I want to trust the staff that they've done their job they've done the due diligence they provided us the information and to accept the recommendation which included the resoning and I think that uh

075as board member block mentioned I think that having those pieces is one of the ways that we can address some of the concerns that we've had with uh with the charter schools not performing and we still have the option to revoke the charter if they're not able to perform going forward and so I thank you all for the work that you've done and providing us the information that we need to make a decision and uh that's all I had to say thank you Vice chair Nal nenny I'm gonna ask the same question with um Kip kpatrick how has the charter organization been responsive to the corrective action plans if any that have been in place for them to move students and to close achievement gaps um I will say they are very responsive um they

076did receive um a bottom 10% notification immediately they got their exe uh two years ago uh immediately they got their executive team um in place um developed an academic plan to address those needs um and we're very collaborative with our office so um I will say they are um collaborative with us recognize the areas of deficiencies and always put forth um a plan to try to address those thank you and then with um the monitoring that we're going to do um we will be a lot more aggressive moving forward with how we monitor um their achievement moving forward correct yes okay any other discussion all right we will vote all in favor um of the motion to approve uh Kip kpatrick Academy raise your hand you oppose raise your hand all right the motion passes

0777 to one thank you uh and before we move on oh you can go down okay um I just want to thank um with Dr Grant for your work in the Charter office work um of reviewing the applications and making your recommendations as Mr um member Taylor said that um this a lot of work that has to go through you and your committee and we just appreciate the work that you have and then also I like to thank um our board members for having a high quality discussion um and that we have become more of evolved board about our discussions around Charters renewals and I personally just want like to thank you about that that we're having high Lev ful conversations um that shows that we are here to educate our children and make sure

078the best education is possible right thank you we'll move on to number three the Warner attendance Zone okay you just saw it in the got okay so we will entertain a motion to approve the one or attendance Zone that was presented um by Dr rby Grant as part of the application motion to approve second been approved by member maiz and uh seconded by Vice chair Nal and Kenny um is there any discussion and for clarification um the attendance change was stated in uh the charter renewal part part of katrick we are just qualifying that um into our minutes um to make sure there is Clarity and uh around the around the change in attended Zone all right all in favor say I I any oppose all right it passes unanimously we will go on to

079board reports I will turn over to Vice chair and chair of the budget Committee Member nabal McKinny uh thank you chair player um today we went over the uh capital budget uh or capital budget request uh for the 2526 school year we had a robust conversation related to the budget um board members were able to ask um very thorough questions as it relates to that um and now we will move on to the second portion um of the capital budget request uh process um but that will be it thank you very much um the tax the tax collections are stated in our agenda and be no fur be no further business we are adjourned this has been a service of the Metro Nashville network if you would like to see this presentation again or for

080more information on this and other programs visit nashville.gov [Music]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.