001[Music] I got Christmas shopp in to do you should have put it off be beening for my my my angel now I got to talk the people belong to me they got put onbody no I'll straight I why are we talking about AC Steve Slater get to the [Laughter] [Music] Des it ain't you right see l we're going to call the December 9th board meeting for the hon County department Department of Education to order beginning with the approval of the agenda need a roll call that's right you I'm ready to go and Steve roll call chairman Smith Mrs black here Mr Connor here Mr Dy here Mr groan here Mrs Haden here Mrs Jones here Mr Keane here Mrs schaer here Mr Slater here miss Thomas here superintendent Dr Robertson here next we have the
002approval of the agenda Madam chair I need to note that there's an addendum or an amendment offered for the agenda tonight involving item 7 d as in David four that item is on the agenda but there there's an updated um exhibit to go with that based on County Commission action that took place yesterday okay so item 74 acceptance of revised federal arpa funds for Hamilton County Board of Commissioners that's correct okay need a motion and a second as amended to approve the agenda motion to approve second ready move roll off Mrs black yes Mr Connor yes Mr Dy yes Mr groan yes Mrs Haden yes Mr Keane yes Mrs schaer yes Mr Slater yes Miss Thomas yes Vice chair Jones yes okay um before we move any further with our agenda um I felt that
003spoke with superintendent Robertson and I felt that we would be in Ultimate remiss if we did not take time to acknowledge the life and the legacy of Dr Carol burs Council woman for district 6 and for the city of Chattanooga um the city of Chattanooga lost Dr burs on um Monday no last Wednesday um and uh if anybody has been around Chattanooga for any significant amount of time you are probably keenly aware of who and what type of force Dr Carol bur was and so Carol um was a colleague she was a friend I met Carol bur as a young social worker she's a social worker if y'all didn't know that I'm Mar's a young social worker fresh out of college coming back home to work and the wisdom that she imparted in my life
004and I know many others across this this um city and this County and this region and this country um from that time fourth is just um Irreplaceable Carol has left a fo footprint that we can never step into but we will never forget and I just wanted to take the time to acknowledge her Carol spent 16 years on chattano city council representing district 6 and I would have to say um by representing District 5 I have several schools that are in the city council District of six and I could always count on Carol to support those schools Tiner Academy Tiner mle bestie Shephard bargar um she was always a staunch supporter of those students and those schools the arts and culture and enrichment of the students in those schools and their families and I just
005wanted to for us to just take a moment to reflect on her life and I everybody keeps bringing this up this this is how you know Carol Carol would always in leadership in any facet be it Women's Conference be it city council social working mediation whatever all of her peers are stating this and I remember hearing her say this for countless years she would always ask people when they were advocating um to her about an issue that was concerned to them or wanting to show why something um there was something she should be advocating for she would always say what does yes look like she would always ask that question and so I just want to remind those of us that sit at this day is and those of us out there in the audience
006as you go about work your life and you're doing things for the greater good of our community always think to yourself or ask your peers what does yes look like and how can your yes be the difference in someone's life because that's what Carol B did so if you don't mind at this time we take take a moment a moment of silence for Dr bur thank you next we have the pledge to the flag oh no we have no executive session so that's we have a pledge to the flag um in meditation by District 5's own Dr Crystal sell's brard High School good evening everyone if you would please stand with me for the pledge to the flag I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for
007which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all you may be seated thank you so our board members you may have a familiar image in front of you does that look familiar up on the up on the bar up on the bar there oh looks like that oh okay look familiar the Charlie Brown Christmas tree take a moment and reflect on the humble charlyy Brown Christmas tree it's small imperfect and often overlooked yet it stands as a symbol of Hope and transformation for students families and some communities who may not feel as fortunate during this holiday season the tree reminds us that beauty and joy can come from within even in the simplest of things like that tree you have a unique value that isn't determined by material possessions or
008outward appearances the holiday season is about love kind and the connections that we share even if the world feels heavy know that your presence brings light to others take pride in your resilience and cherish the small moments that make the season special a kind word a warm hug or the piece of quiet reflection just like that little tree you have the power to bring meaning and warmth to the world around you thank you thank you thank you next we have um exemplars of Excellence recognition of csas energy Grant wi winning team Dr Shane Harwood thank you board members Dr Robertson appreciate the opportunity to be here to recognize uh what was going to be a larger group we tried to time this at the break because we had seniors that have gone off to college
009and I don't know if we gave them the wrong address or what we did uh but but they are not here uh but what we do have is Jennifer Mitchell who is currently assistant principal at East Ridge High School and then we have Dr Kristen Carlile who's assistant principal at csas upper uh Miss Mitchell is here because she was one of two teacher Representatives that actually kind of coordinated with this group of five students to pursue a TVA Energy Grant uh that Grant is a very prestigious hard to um attain Grant a lot of work goes into that and that group of kids with the help of their teacher leader and the school support were able to secure a grant of over $400,000 to go towards Energy Efficiency at csas supper um so would you
010like to share a couple of the things that they did with that Grant or are doing so we had to um each each course had to we had to actually qualify for so at the very beginning when we first started it it was okay if you um get across this level right here you get say $110,000 and so we kept progressing um he was very reluctant at first to work with us because he was like well uh cuz I told him every time we have a meeting I'm going to have the kids there and he was like well no this meeting is just for me and you to just kind of touch base I said well that's not going to work for me um I'm too busy I'm going to have my kids there they're
011going to have to answer your questions they'll update you as far as how we're working through the program and what all we're going to be doing to educate our staff and educate the students there and uh telling you what programs we're going to do and then we also had to like update our light bills and all of our energy bills to show that all of our uh bills were decreasing at the time and so after like the second meeting he was like okay so I understand what you mean now when you say work with the kids cuz they're all Hands-On deck um they helped write the grant uh all me and Miss Davis did was like proof fre the grant at the end just to make sure that everything was in there that needed to
012be in there um they're the ones that like did the trips around the building measuring different items they also um did a lot of the paperwork they coordinated a whole day K through 12 uh with energy and I mean it was from the second the kids hit the door to the second they left they had a whole full day of activities learning about energy how they can be more energy um proficient at home and taking it back to their families as well and so uh they we qualified each level I think it was like four levels in all and we had to write another Grant towards the very end to get the uh the final the 400,000 and then plus our many steps along the way we also got awarded a couple of other ones
013as well so if I may like I said these these students are not here or former students are not here but I just want to call them by name uh Karen Lynn who is currently attending University of Tennessee at Knoxville Patel and rvic sinki are both at Purdue University uh hetv Patel is at Alabama Birmingham and Sullivan Smith is at Davidson so again just speaks to the preparation that we give kids in Hamilton County and the things that they do Beyond uh our K12 system and so again just if you'll share in some appreciation for csas and what they've done for this grant uh we appreciate all that they've [Applause] done thank you Mr Kean yeah could we pass their names on to Greg Higgins he might want to jop those down oh trust me
014we met did a lot of meetings with GRE Higgins he already knows thank you no I got recognition of state champions and tsaa award winners it's one of my my favorite parts of my job is to get here again and come up and kind of brag on the accomplishments of of the kids that we have in in Hamilton County but not just the kids the adults as well uh we're here tonight uh first first order of recognition is going to be the uh repeating girls state champion cross country team uh from Signal Mountain before I introduce their team members I want to tell you this is the 10th girls state championship in Cross Country uh from Signal Mountain and and their head coach Dustin carp this is his seven state championship in trackfield between trackfield
015and cross country so uh we're going to go ahead and introduce these team members and the these also this aome coaching staff so um the principal of Signal Mountain High School is Mr Michael Carson their athletic director is Mr Brian Beasley the head coach is Dustin Carpenter and their assistant coach is Maddie Livingston who is actually a returning coach uh who ran at Signal Mountain high school and was a state champ Ion on a state championship team there so she has returned to Roose to to help uh continue the tradition uh team members are Miss Hannah lore Maxine Richards aah Boyd Naomi Malone Lily Paxton Aubrey Lynch Callaway wheeler and McKenzie Locker so guys thank you so much for representing H the county did you get a photo opportunity Mr daughter here so you guys
016will just walk up here real if you all could go take everybody all the way through Ladies sorry about that and then you'll coach you should know how to do this coach rumor has it you drop them off at the bottom of the W Road make them run back up congratulations congrat congratulations conat congratulations congratul con got L yeah you holding line awesome awesome job good job we need to get the I was give him a round of [Applause] applause uh the next set of awards uh are the AF Bridges award that are given annually by the Tennessee secondary athletic schools uh Administration uh Association this uh these Awards recognize individuals and schools that demonstrate exceptional sportsmanship and citizenships uh through their their athletic program so Hamilton County has three recipients this year uh we
017have uh one which is a a school award to csla uh the principal there is uh Miss Crystal Scarboro their athletic director is West Castle have a couple of young men present uh if you guys want to come forward with your with your trophy uh Mr Castle uh the the AF Bridges School award is very difficult to get uh you have can have no unsportsman like uh ejections throughout a school year officials have to give uh good recommendations based on your players and your coaches Behavior so we have uh Ben Hopper and uh Omar El letter that are going to just say a couple of words here real quick for you guys and uh congratulations to csla so setting the example of sportsmanship in Hamilton County school so congratulations to you guys want to say
018something real quick thank you school board members for recognizing csa's accomplishment in receiving the AF Bridges award part of our code of conduct at csla is respecting ourselves and others as students of csla we know the code and strive to live by it in all that we do this award was given to only three high schools in the entire state we were the top recipient for the East Division this award pres was presented to csla at the tsaa regional meetings in November it is given in recognition of the high ideals of ethics and integrity in the teaching and promotion of citizenship and sportsmanship we are so proud to have been honored by the state thank [Applause] you down check everybody and we'll get a quick picture with you in correction csla is in District five
019not nine only for a short time congratulations for the next 10 years congratulations con s Eagles sorry about that wrong gri M Mosley all right congratulations guys job well done uh next next award we have a female coach of the year uh from from the Eastern uh division uh she is from uh Saudi Daisy high school she was softball coach and principal is Angie Cass there the athletic director is Jared Hensley they're present here um coach Nunley is one of the finest coaches in the State uh she set the example for sportsmanship our girls played I tell you anytime you want to watch a a softball team get after it play hard but play respectfully I would suggest you go up and watch the girls at Saudi Daisy High School play it's truly pleasure watch
020how she led her team last year and uh fortunately I think she's uh she's going to go play mom for a while uh but the EF AF Bridges sportsmanship award this year goes to female coach of the year goes to miss Kelsey Nunley [Applause] more you picture M and I'll give you your box congratulations congratulations come back any time you you want me [Applause] the uh the last word is uh the athletic or excuse me the system administrator of the Year award uh I want I want I want to speak about Dr Robertson I'm going to embarrass him here for a minute um you know I I was very fortunate to take this role two and a half going on almost 3 years ago now and I have seen I've been in Hamilton County schools
021on and off for 34 years I've seen more advancement toward Athletics in the past three years than I had along the way uh I think Dr Robertson has a true commitment to uh educational based Athletics and is a proponent of all the things that it does for our student athletes so he uh he was nominated and elected as the East Regional uh uh system at administrator of the year so without further Ado Dr Jo Justin Robertson come on up and get your award have to get a picture out okay that sounds great hey I I do want to say this with Tim here this is more a reflection of Tim uh and the work that he do does under Robert sharp I'll give you a quick stat so in Fall of 2023 we had 32
022ejections across Hamilton County which think about all the athletes that's really not that bad this fall we've had eight uh and it's because of the work that Tim does to promote sportsmanship to make sure our coaches are trained to make sure that they are setting the values and ideals of this uh District so I will accept this but it's really on behalf of Tim and his team so thank you uh wait uh he needs to start do it after evaluation did they give him Awards before the evaluations came out we hope to I appreciate your time I really hope to be back here uh probably in February with a couple more state champions under a belt I know Saudi Daisy is is raring to go again in in wrestling so hopefully uh we can we
023can have a repeat there so guys thank you for your time I hope you have a blessed evening thank you hey Mr James could I ask one quick question yes sir uh women's flag football I know we're getting some press on that is there a push to have that as a Statewide sport uh it is a it's called an emerging sport it is recognized by T A and actually when I leave here I'm going to the county championship game at csla tonight T Daisy in first place right now s Daisy is y s Daisy on it just wait on it Steve they got a nice new feel up there they're going I'm going leave you guys with the Rivalry there so have a great evening thank you you know what moving right along board member
024disclaimer statements does not apply does not apply does not apply does not apply does not apply I declare that I have a family member who works for the for the school system and that the board's vote on budget policies Etc may have an effect on my relatives employment even so I hereby certify that I will cast my vote in the best interest of the school system does not apply does not apply all right appr approval of the consent agenda move to approve second roll call discussion oh discussion any discussion or anything to be pulled any discussion Mr doter thank you um Ju Just one one quick question and I apologies I wish I had opportunity to talk about this in advance um the the approved single Source software contract with IC IMS for talent applicant
025tracking software and I apologize again just for my own understanding what what's going on with that do do we need to pull that and is your intention to discuss you want to discuss yeah I'm sorry let pull back yes please thank you okay so he's pulling item d1a D1 a right any other items P for discussion okay welcome Mrs black yes Mr Connor yes Mr Dy yes Mr groan yes Mrs haton yes Mr yes Mrs schaer yes Mr Slater yes Miss Thomas yes Vice chair Jones yes okay Mr Ry I ask Dr Brown to come up uh isms is one of our HR softwares mainly used for recruiting but he's going to be much more familiar with it than I would to ask him to yes sir thank you very much so isms is our
026applicant tracking system and so if you ever just a short version if you ever go to our website that's that's the first way that uh any candidate engages with HCS right so our town acquisition team with our recruiters it's the platform where folks just uh when they inquire about jobs that we have and so that's the way they apply IIM is a robust system where it allows easy application process through mobile devices it allows us to not only track candidates in a sense to you know coordinate and communicate with them but it also houses all of our onboarding materials and so when it comes to um offer letters when we hiring um making sure we're getting our you know W2s or excuse me our bank drafts or criminal background checks it's the robust system that
027takes care of everything from point of entry uh to get the teacher in the classroom or any of our staff members um there is also another component with the icms versus some other applicant tracking systems it's really all about the employee experience and that's the main thing the candidate experience right you want to make sure you have a platform that that's easy to use that's easy on the eyes that's um the Aesthetics is great um and so we've had great success with um iims uh there's a document in your packet that um I just want to give you some benchmarks you know last three four years we've been able to maintain a 97% field rate U this past year we had a 99% fill rate for our classrooms in turn that's because of iims right
028it allows us our recruiters to make sure that we're doing a great job communicating with our candidates and so uh it's time to renew uh we've been um very pleased with icms are great Partners um but um the easy answer is that we want to maintain it 99% field so just a renewal of the contract yes sir awesome okay thank you Dr Brown Dr Brown do you know off top of your head I think it's a good number like how many transactions uh this spring you anticipate your team will do through yeah so we'll have uh approximately you know 300 320 new teachers but we'll also hire around 450 teachers all together and that's just teachers that's coming into the system but of course you know in our district we allow all of our teachers
029to have an internal transfer and so we're now starting that process where you know if I work at Red Bank I want to go to another school for whatever reason we allow our um teachers to apply and so that's another transaction and iims um allows us to move a teacher from one school to another school so uh we'll have upwards of 3,000 transactions when it's all said and done when you think about our classified staff as well as our certified staff um part-time employees School Nutri um um uses the platform as well as child care Etc put it back we need a motion to place it back on the agenda approve just motion to approve that's saying Mo motion to approve it back on the agenda motion motion to approve second Mrs black yes Mr
030Connor yes Mr Dy yes Mr groan yes Mrs haton yes Mr Keane yes Mrs schaer yes Mr Slater yes Miss Thomas yes Vice chair Jones yes okay now we're moving on to board matters that's what I thought okay board matters chief operations officer Robert sharp consideration of bond funded capital projects and FY 25 budget amendment self funded it's the first phase of that 60 million dollar in deferred M maintenance Bond um and and you should have received a call and talked through majority of this but you can see the projects there vast majority of them are projects that have been deferred for years terms of HVAC systems um roofs boilers things of that nature you're also going to see a couple of things that uh we know that we need to do from a safety
031and athletic standpoint um and so these hit all across the district uh again this is the first wave understand that um this is a robust amount of works I was talking to Dr Sharp today talking to Justin wood earlier uh we expect to get a lot of this done um internally but there are also portions of it that be contracted out and we'll give you an update uh as we go throughout this process need a motion in a second motion to approve second roll call Mrs black yes Mr Connor yes Mr Dy yes Mr groan yes Mrs Hatton yes Mr Keane yes Mrs schaer yes Mr Slater yes Miss Thomas yes Vice chair Jones yes Item B Chief um this is submitted by the chief strategy officer Shannon Moody consideration of 2025 legislative agenda you
032have copies of this in your packet as well any discussion yeah like discuss motion motion any motion I need a motion to approve the legislative agenda that's right second discussion discussion Mr D put a motion or go ahead no no they motion second discussion now go ahead go ahead okay um Ben I know you've got uh a tough situation right mean you've got a you've got a relay what's happening with the legislative with what's what's occurring here in the county and I think you do a great job of that from what I can gather um you know we've got us effectively if PR may not aware there's there's six topics of discussion that are included in this and I see this for a second Gary and I I I I agree with almost all of
033them but where I have some challenges is in two and three um primarily within two um I think it's important to note that when we switch from the previous funding model to Tissa we got around 64 million more than we had previously so exponential increase in terms of our total funding from the state state of Tennessee so where I have and this is just my personal opinion where I have a little issue is effectively what we're saying is hey we need an open checkbook um if there was a number then I can totally understand that um and if it was validated with the fact that hey we've had headcount increase of 15% we feel we need 15% more additional funding but we we all can agree that our enrollment has been relatively flat there's been
034some slight fluctuations but for the most part it's stayed where it is relatively um and then three I love the idea of the state taking on the funding of the the ssos and SRO program entirely that would free up a massive line item from us and we could happily apply that to teacher salaries um where I have a little challenge as well is the second paragraph where we talk about additional funding for mental health and I'll be the first to tell you mental health is is incredibly important but where I have issues is we've got we've got roofs with with leaks in it we've got AC units that need massive updates um if we're going to be asking for additional funding I feel we should be applying it to things that we really need from
035a maintenance perspective um the other thing too is is a lot of schools I can't speak of everybody with mind school there's not enough space to put more more staff I mean you take for example Thrasher we've got teachers and staff in hallways and closets um schools weren't built to have more and more staff so that's that's another consideration as well so I just wanted to voice it and I wanted to thank you again Ben for doing what you're doing because I know it's tough um but I just wanted to hear on that those are really the only two things that I have um just wanted to be vocal about my positions on so please is a chair would you like me to address each individually or wait and do collectively okay hold on one
036second believe okay um one of the issues I have because people might not be aware there's one real popular topic on here but there are actually six sections and six topics in this legislative agenda and so we would be voting to approve all six of them and um I'm uncomfortable with as a former teacher who took the practice test to be certified to teach uh upper well math secondary mathematics um I agree with a part as far as reciprocity between states if someone's certified in one state and has a great you know history track record you know allowing to be certified in our state without a practice but uh for secondary licensure I still think to be certified in math they need to take the practice test but they could still you know be a
037certified teacher in their uh first subject that they were certified in but um and still will be able to teach math on a provisional license or and they actually have multiple opportunities which many people take to pass the prac test so you know I just you know that's the ISS one of the main issues I have and just for clarification too we actually discussed these issues in our policy meeting last week Mr King so I guess my question is when we vote on this are we voting on all six as a yes or a no and or can we separate them out so please as a chair go yes go ahead okay so the idea Gary to answer your direct question is that it's better to have it on one page the reason for that
038is um there's there's there's a lot going on in our lives there's a lot more going on in the lives of the uh men and women that represent us and there's not a lot of time to waste when you're there so it's a lot easier to put single document in front of them and then beyond that as you all know as I did last year I go through and and make more notes and talk about the things you know specifically costs like Mr Dorney was talking about and number two there would be listing out of you know this is what it costs to educate a child in this situation and this is how much we're funded right now so let's just for instance as was mentioned earlier it costs around $40,000 to educate a child
039of of certain needs and Tisa right now has the funding at like $5,000 so what would be listed in my further notes would be details not not opinion by any means just details of what this means like here's where we're funded on on uh UNL uln n and here's where it needs to be funded in order to educate a child um I think that answerers the first part so so yes it is supposed to go as one um we've not done it before and in all of my other practice I've never seen anybody do it out unless and I want to be very clear there absolutely have been resolutions as as former board member uh lenon mentioned there's been 86 different uh counties that have just done a resolution against um against vouchers but in
040their legislative agendas they still do have it listed as one of the items and I I'd like to bring up just so the public knows when we vote on this uh item number one which involves a very popular topic uh We've receiv received 30 to 50 emails and phone calls and that uh the state voucher system this is stating that we are against the vouchers but that would be a yes vote so when we say yes we are not voting for vouchers we are voting against vouchers by saying yes we will support no vouchers I just want to make that clear to the public it's an excellent note and you're absolutely correct as it is written and and again um actually I tell you what if if so please is a chair I'd like to
041read one because that's one of the ones that has changed drastically and um and if you don't mind I'd like to read six this is a document that is available online if you're following our agenda but in our policy meeting which uh Miss schaer was so kind to allow me to do the legislative part at the end um we did read them in full so number one and number six are the ones I'll read out loud again uh number one uh Tennessee State policy on school vouchers the Hamilton County Board of Education strongly urges the general assembly not to expand the voucher program in any way and to fully evaluate its current pilot for Effectiveness as it has not demonstrated improved student outcomes the board recommends retaining current limitations of the pilot program to evaluate
042the effectiveness including 200% poverty level income eligibility and prior Public School attendance and to include holding private schools and home school programs accepting vouchers to the same accountability standards as public schools this includes teap T and ready School letter grades and Tas scores with results made publicly available to help families make informed decisions many of our speakers spoke to these exact items which is why we wanted to make sure that we retained them I know the chair Smith was very big on making sure that we said these things because last year our conversation line was a whole bunch of this was supposed to be a 5-year pilot program we're literally in the second year how can we discern whether or not we've done anything what let alone a good job um but through all of
043the numbers that we've been seen and through all of it seems like the vast majority of our constituents based off all the things you just referenced and um my counterparts poll on his on his social media is mine as well um it's not something our community wants so that's why I think that it's important that we have written it as as Gary said yes we are against it but at least keep the guard rails on that we're talking about number six advocate for fully funded Federal programs the Hamilton County Department of educa I'm sorry the Hamilton County Board of Education urges Federal legislators to fully fund Title One someone very loud outside the door I'm sorry uh to fully fund Title One and the individuals with disabilities Education Act idea enhanced Title One funding would
044provide critical resources to support students living in poverty address disparity and promote Educational Opportunity fully funding idea is an is essential to fulfill the federal commitment to students with disabilities increasing per pupil support and reducing Financial strain on local school systems additionally Ida amendments should prioritize improving collaboration between schools and parents simplifying processes making dispute resolution less adversarial and less expensive and ensuring individual plans effectively meet the needs of all students these measures will advance access to support Student Success so a lot of wording was dropped off as Miss Schaefer and a few of my colleagues had had asked for um and again to stay out loud idea currently is is is funded at 14% of what the budget is for it so the last time that we saw even close to 40% funding for
045this was during Co and it it helped a lot it really did it it made a lot of supports for children that were there and and saw a lot of great success stories because of it um which is why which is why I'm glad that we were able to change the the wording but keep this item on there so um I'm G if you don't mind I'll keep going for just a moment and finish out this so um to address uh Mr dh's conversation in the second one I I definitely agree that we you we have a multitude of things that we need for our school um we just voted on a very large facilities uh spend U but I I would continue to say that the first part is yes I hope that we
046can continue a partnership absolutely second part is I I I I just have to keep saying that when we feed and care about these kids we tend to see better outcomes and specifically through our ssos there's less interactions of negative with a child that is fed and has the mental support that they need in schools so um while while they uh can't do any of that if the roof is falling in on them um I would have to argue that we do need both and so we've got to find the line between the two uh would be my my opinion on it and again that's a great place for me to say my opinion you all are going to hear me arguing what I feel like should be on here but whatever this board passes
047is what I will take to our legislators so I have have to argue for what district 6 wants I have to argue for my personal convictions of what I think is best for our children but at the end of the day I'm going to take what you guys vote for to our legislators and I do appreciate you as well um for how diligent you are in getting this together and how passionate you are about this we motion a second you have c a question all right there was a discussion if that's closing the discussion I do want to say one quick thank you too this is not possible without Shannon and Rachel's help uh it looks pretty and it's well uh my thoughts are well written because of them so thank you I do do
048have one related comment um I do a lot of research and The anenberg Institute went into Metro Nashville and did a three-year study on their expanded tutoring program so when we talk about advocate for fully funded Federal programs this District they found evidence in this study of only a small to medium average positive effect on students reading scores but no average effects on MTH scores or course grades in either subject they say this this might be that it's a limited treatment control contrast because it's only three years a modest program duration in other words maybe four to six weeks in the summer isn't long enough uh and miscalibrated expectations of tutoring effects at scale so I'm not a big advocate of federal programs that don't work so we'll just have to wait and see how
049that's going to play out but just wanted to throw that in so Mr Connor yes ma'am so um I forgive me I said we were done and I did not answer felices so I need to come back to talking about practice but okay um to to respond to to Mr Gro the first thing that I should say is Ida has exclusively other than the years of covid been funded around 14% I would love to see that three-year study with it funded even at 70% you know I just I don't think we can accurately study something that's never been funded and but thank you because you did bring me up to another great point that one is I appreciate your help that one is definitely more of something that I would be bringing to our legisl
050legislative team on Capitol Hill in DC and so this is something that's going to be going to you our our Senators Mr fleshman uh other people that would be adding more money to idea at the federal level so that's a great great note there although it's something obviously that can be talked about with our local legislative uh body um and hopefully they could help us also to advocate for the proper funding amounts through what they've budgeted um but thank you and Dr Robertson I would love to pipe in here because this is something that obviously we've talked about it a whole bunch and um and on this DS as well um but I'd like to add a little bit more insight because I want to make sure Felicia's comment is is correct like we want
051to make sure that we are having the best we we said we said that a couple times tonight the best we want to have the best teachers that we can available that have proven their worth through whatever model we have available which right now is the practice testing so if I'm not mistaken what we're saying is we are allowing people to move into different practices and or come from different states before that testing is done but that that is still something that's necessary down the road so couple things being said here one uh I think recognizing that Tennessee has some of the highest bars for practice scores like we it's not the same across States so what we're saying is look at what other states are doing and consider especially in high needs areas of
052being more in line with industry standard on the cut score that's one okay maybe just the score itself not eliminating it right and then the the second one is saying for a currently so if you don't mind I'll use yourself right that's okay you know if a math teacher wanted to become also certified in exceptional Ed into their career that that's an experienced teacher you could you could look at alternative Pathways other than the prais right the cours workk evaluation scores performance on other types of things just to provide again when you look across what other states are doing there are many options available to teachers to get those certifications essentially like the teachers took an AP class and they had their college credits that they took with them okay can I make a comment
053and one comment I was going to make before too is um we actually started the school year 99% of certified position staffed which was 4% above our goal so we commended Dr Robertson but I want to commend you too Dr Brown for your work in that so that's a great achievement [Applause] i' like to make make a motion to approve the legislative agenda we already have a motion calls for the question roll call Mrs black wait wait I'm sorry what are are we voting on yes I'm sorry I just want to make sure so for clarity for clarity we're voting on the document as it is okay everybody hear me so for full clarity we're voting on the legislative agenda document as it is with these six key points on it okay call for the
054question Mrs black yes Mr Connor yes Mr Dy abstain Mr Gro although there are things on here that I can nitpick about I know that this is all a project in motion as you've seen by you're up there looking at committees and meetings so um I know you and maybe some other of us will be working with our local representatives and making sure we have our input so for the entire board up here I think it's important that that we speak to those representatives and and continue to be actively involved in this I'm going to vote Yes Mrs Haden I'll say I'm not a advocate of school vouchers but I'm going to say no you vote no that's okay Mr Keane and I just want to District nine the yes is for no vouchers yes
055Mrs schaer no Mr Slater I ran an unofficial poll in District one it was 85% of the people said no vouchers so I'm yes Miss Thomas yes Vice chair Jones yes seven in favor two opposed and one abstention Madam chair it's passes okay last item on the agenda close moving closer closer to the last item of the agenda is the discussion of the superintendent evaluation everyone that is a member of this board completed an evaluation on Dr Robertson we submitted that information it is public record um we have copies of it and our yeah copies of it in your folders copies of it in your email and you should have your copy um it's a packet the packet that's in our folder has it's a cumulative report of all um I I just would like
056to say um to Dr Robertson I tell you this all the time I would never want your job ever ever never ever ever I've said this to every superintendent I work with being the superintendent and the director of schools is one of the most rewarding I my opinion one of the most rewarding for one of the most grueling jobs that you can ever have because you are giving an account for four 40,000 plus children and all the adults that come along with them and everybody else who got an opinion and so I would like to tell you that I know that um your job job is is a very difficult job but I am very thankful for the work that you do the commitment that you make to trying to do your best at all
057times um and I continue I will continue to say whether we agree or disagree on anything that and I'll stand on the mountain tops about this I know Dr Justin Robertson to be a great human and so I thank you for the work that you do um here in Hamilton County schools because we know um probably other than Casey and your F your family we probably are the the only ones that know what you really go through and your team um what you really go through on a daily basis so thank you um for all that you do um and that's the only discussion that I have Madam chair can can I just say uh thank you to the board we I said this last year and we talk about it as a team kind
058of say it tongue and cheek but it's true that you know feedback is a gift and I appreciate the board putting time into this to provide me uh you know feedback on on how to get better uh I know that for many of you we just started working together and it was probably awkward and difficult to fill this out but I appreciate uh the input look forward to the work moving forward and more importantly uh to to say thank you to this team like it you see it every night when we come together in places like this where we're talking about HR talking about Athletics we're talking about learning and Leadership but um it is it's a difficult job but it's much easier when you have an incredible team around you and uh we've got
059a great team here in Hamilton County I'm really proud of the work that they're doing and again thank you for the board for the opportunity but also for the feedback that helps us uh and me more importantly get better so thank you thank you um so we have a list of people one we got the b b& d to BNC that's order okay b& D BNC police and oh I'm sorry okay so I got BN d n c Steve Slater and Jackie that's the order y'all going to remember that yes ma' I'm to to just Echo the the sentiments of my colleague um I think there the two that and I said this the two probably hardest jobs is the head coach of an SEC football program and the superintendent of a of a County
060School System um Justin I want you to know that I appreciate what you're doing and I feel like you've got the right heart you've got the right approach uh the disadvantage you had with this is is you had several new board members join without really getting to know you um so while my grade was not as high as some of the others I just want you to know manto man that I think you're doing a good job and um and I look forward to working for you the rest of my term BNC I'm glad you guys got all the glowing out of the way so I can R it over the [Laughter] coals I've referenced the one minute manager before and I think the idea is that you put the bad stuff in the middle
061so let me start by saying um the my number one like I wanted to reference a couple of fives and one lower point so I gave him a five for school leadership I I in my district I walk in and the the people that are leading those schools just want to run through brick walls for for the team for the kids and it shows and and they come uh you when we do our Red Bank Way meetings and and talk about the pathways to high school shows when they come out of a PD day and they're proud and they're happy and they're wanting to talk about things that have been discussed there good or bad but ways that we can Implement them or questions that they have so um so that's huge um we'll do
062one more B we'll do the bad one now so I comprehensive developing a comprehensive bu building plan obviously there have been a lot of struggles hiccups there have been district 6 has had a lot of moving parts that we've tried a lot of different ways to satisfy the public and still do what's right to for the children and for the school buildings and the way that we're funded um this uh I held on to mine for a little while this one was uh this number changed at the 11th Hour uh and a lot of it has to do with this document that the superintendent just put before us that's on the record of making sure that we're doing right by our schools like U making sure that you know we uh we knew that there
063were schools on here that that needed to be looked at to make sure that we're doing the right thing by them and and and obviously noral Park's one of them there's other schools in district 6 that will need things too but but that's why that was raised um why it was low to begin with um talking about the graduation rate and the increased number of students who graduate with postsecondary I think it was awesome that Miss Lind and her son came up here to talk about opportunities we're talking about a sixth grader who's thinking about postsecondary and jobs that they can do like I there's no reason that that's not like on here uh I I did make is a little bit lower on that because uh I think that we still have some opportunities
064there we need to figure out what we're doing with the Gateway building for for CTE and and things of that nature but talking just about graduation rate with CCA at 100% And Red Bank High School having the greatest graduation rate they've had since they've been a high school that's huge that's awesome it speaks to your leadership and it speaks to the leadership at the schools so thank you and I'll finish by just saying um uh my counterpart my fellow Ben uh um talking about the budget in in a transparent manner it's not just talking about the budget the reason that this is so high is that you fight for us to the County Commission to the people that need you you go out and you fight for the for the kids you fight for the
065students you fight for the facilities and you make sure that it's clear and present and and explained to each one of us and uh and I appreciate that so thank you Jackie oh I'm sorry you forgot me yes Steve Jackie U I want to Second what carit said about Dr Robertson he's he's always available and if he's busy he always calls me back or text me back and I I appreciate that and like she said I wouldn't have that job for a million dollars I just it's unbelievable people don't understand and being new on the board I I found out so uh he's uh I just appreciate what you do Miss Thomas I think I kind of said this a little bit before when when I look at my evaluation and Dr Robertson uh and
066being fair trying to look at everything from when I came which is 90 days ago but I think uh as a new board member we are asked to look at a plan that was um created before we came and to also the plan even exceeds our four years um that we may or may not be here so in doing that and discussing discussing this I do feel that Hamilton County schools are exactly where at minimum I would say we were we are where we should be however I think that In fairness to you or any superintendent a policy change need to occur in which it's just a date needs to be given 23 24 school year we were not a part of this and it is not fair for us honestly in my opinion to
067even evaluate you because we have not had the opportunity to know you or even to learn the process of the school system in my opinion so I I I would and I think I've kind of said this before the policy on evaluating the superintendence needs to occur before August the 1st of every year versus December because that gives the outgoing board the opportunity to evaluate the superintendent because they've had that school year to look at and be able to do all of that versus a newcoming board doing it and not in my opinion really being as Fair as possible so I just wanted to say that um and that's how I feel about it Mr CH got say we you and I talked about this earlier so I just kind of wanted you know affm
068what Miss Thomas said I think it is difficult time to provide an evaluation I'm not opposed to looking at you know a even a May June end of end of school year just with the understanding that many of the data points would have to be lag data points because we don't get it back until you know uh sometimes November the way the policy is written now is it's a month after we get the last data point back um so we we can definitely look at the dates I don't know Mr Bennett if you're like I said something wrong you're looking at me weird I'm smirking because of we we've talked about changing U when we do the evaluation for the superintendent now for 30 years Absolut absolutely T and I been it's always been well
069it's it's it's it hasn't always been during this time frame my my point here is there's never a good time to evaluate the superintendent because there's always something that about to happen or there's something that just happened or we've had an election and so what this board decided to do um several years ago was to try to tie his evaluation to when you were getting your hard data back so that it could inform the board's decision towards the budget as Miss schaer pointed out uh at the work session a week or so ago um one of the most important things that the board does is it develops the budget which is the way that you speak your policies into operation and so if there's if there's an issue that you have with the with his
070performance then you look and see well is it is there a problem with the system are we not appropriately Staffing this need or we not appropriately Le leveraging this department and then that informs this board as you're going into budget season um but to to Miss Thomas's point it does sometimes lead leave new board members at a some somewhat disadvantage as you're coming in but on the other side of that coin maybe you were elected to the board because your constituents had strong feelings about how the superintendent was doing so there's we we can move this around um and we and we have before but there's really never a great time where it's tied up to either um getting test scores back from the state or making budgeting decisions or doing whatever else so just
071pick your poison J and then is J and the police you touch your light for I wasn't the next to lowest this year um I just wanted to articulate and I know I've said it before um I did give you a low score on the budget but it was based on the presented on time situation and all of the hiccups we've had at least the last couple of years um that I've voted on voted on a budget um and I would like to us to get better at that exchange and feel like that we have more time to discuss that before it goes over to the County Commission and have more time to respond if they don't accept it um but when it comes to creating a budget that meets the moment I've said it
072over and over again you'all done a great job at focusing and tying how we spend our where we spend our money to what our goals are and you're always very clear about this is what we're asking for and this is what it's this is what we're goal we're trying to meet and this is why we've asked for this and this is the data that that backs it up and I always appreciate having that information and how clear you are on it so the low score on the budget had more to do with the timeline than the actual appropriateness of the budget because I've always felt like your team has put a lot of effort and time and um in trying to be clear about what we're spending our money on and why and I appreciate
073that I was going to say um I am a new board member but I really appreciate the line of communication you have and the respect you all have given all of us and I appreciate you all that much and I say overall you know I've seen so many impressive things especially I think the communication the newsletters being so organized in tying everything to our strategies and um and your own self-evaluation was very helpful too and very organized and so um I appreciate that and I just want to say overall I think it's a very good evaluation so I don't know if the public realizes that it really was so if you think about it as far as the scale it's between meeting expectations and being strong so it really was a good evaluation in my
074opinion Mr K so I can honestly say I think I'm the only one that knows you from high school and uh we have one employee and you're the right man so good job don't don't hold that against me from high school uh oh all right any other um discussion so need a motion we don't have to right discuss just a discussion good job we guess we'll keep you to 2025 I'm just one just one um um we have information only students have a half a day tomorrow so if you're a parent pick up your kids so the teachers can go home no I'm just playing no students have half a day at school tomorrow U I need to be telling myself that December the 23rd through January 3rd is winter break January 6th through January
0757th is professional development days and our next board meeting is January the 16th I'm right here in the boardroom that concludes this meeting Merry Christmas well happy holidays Merry Christmas and all those things Happy New Year we will see y'all in 2025 thank you