001to order um so before we get started we'll stand and have a moment silence and do the pl Le so everybody will all right go PL of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation God indivisible with libery and justice for all thank you very much so uh since this is a special called meeting and it's on the um opposing we're doing a resolution opposing the education Freedom car shift act or vouchers um input is limited to that specific topic tonight so on public input um so we'll get the public input here out of the way so who's our first person David seal all right thank you Mr chairman David seal 7:30 s Martin Road in v and I commend you for making a resolution opposing the falsely
002titled education Freedom scholarship act here in colge Bill globalist forces outside this state are openly threatening your legislators with expensive primary elections if they listen to the will of the people these threats are published in major newspapers which violate the spirit of our Republic first year cost to tax pairs $347 million reoccurring cost year after year $191 million and that's on page nine of the fiscal no of this bill there's nothing conservative about spending a billion tax dollars every five years that's redistribution of wealth proponents of the bill believe that featers are stupid enough to fall for that $2,000 bride the cost is $172 million to taxpayers it's anti-conservative and it's insell the bill diverts 80% of the sports betting tax from the lottery for Education fund to the school building approvement fund to the
003tune of $77 million per year and that's on page eight of the fiscal review mode this money could be appropriated for school building without the voucher bill now they think in terms of the bill sponsors they think that you're stupid enough to believe that not withstanding Jefferson County taxpayers in several counties with no private schools they'll be forced to subsidize the private education of students in communities with private schools that's a blatant unfair discriminatory anti-conservative practice wor first of all the bill empowers State bureaucrats just to make rules it makes 28 references to administrative real me these are unelected swamp rats that need less power over teachers not more that too is antier I'm providing a table of authorities to prove what I've what I've told you and finally Mr chairman if you will scan
004a copy of your signed resolution and email to me I'll make sure my readers in all 95 counties see the Tennessee conservative news before their legislators convene in Nashville tomorrow and this will magnify the effect of your resolution thank you very much kenon Bo here for the city and I'm just here to encourage you to oppose vouchers I think they weakened the public school system the public system school system need all the help you can get U I talked with a new resident of this County last Sunday afternoon Liv in a brand new subdivision around here he's been here two years and has a little toddler and he said I'm trying to get out of here as soon as I can because he doesn't want his toddler to go to school CH County once he
005once he move here and I talked to another person today who has been interviewing U some dentists about coming here as you might expect one of the first things they asked is about school system and none of them came so I'm all in favor of supporting public schools and I think the voucher system is not undermining thank you thank you next Laura my name is Laura Mallette and I live at 847 stonate Shores in dridge I'm here to support the resolution that opposes Governor Lee's misnamed education Freedom scholarship act this Universal voucher bill will not improve education opportunities for Tennessee families and it has nothing to do with freedom and it will not improve scholarship House Tennessee students it will however adversely affect our public schools and our community while spending tax money irresponsibly this
006year's Bill adds a one-time teacher bribe diverts funds intended for scholarships towards K12 infrastructure which should be funded separately and sweetens a deal with a promise that public schools won't receive less money if students move to private schools at least for now that can change at any time Lee talks about giving families choices but in the world of private education the schools that get to choose their students and reject them if they want to sending them back to public schools that are mandated to teach everyone here's a couple important points only 42% of voucher eligible schools provide state level non-discrimination protections against racial discrimination and only 24% of voucher eligible schools protect against discrimination on the basis of religion and let's talk about the families that won't be able to take advantage of the cash
007giveaway families that live in rural areas where the private schools are too far to get to families without reliable transportation or where parents work schedules preclude them from providing transportation for their children and families who cannot afford the unpaid portion of the private school tuition our public schools are struggling due to underfunding and neglect by the state that has persisted for years census data shows that Tennessee spends 30% Less on education than the national average ranking in the bottom 10 states below all our neighboring states except Mississippi this new expense paid out to those privileged enough to to choose private schools will create a two- tiered education system destroying public schools which will continue to serve the needs of most Tennessee children and costing taxpayers money at the same time if voucher funds are eventually
008taken away from the public schools local governments will have to make up the loss of funding diverting money from other budget needs and property taxes will rise and the community community will be left with deficits if outter funds do not follow the students to private schools the state's going to have to find a way to generate those funds required for this new separate but equal education path and yes I said separate but equal because Universal voucher plans will take us back to schools that look like they did before Brown versus Board of Education let's stop the voucher expansion and ask the state of Tennessee to invest in our future by fully funding public education thank you for presenting the resolution and I urge every board member who believes in the value of public education to
009vote Yes I also want to say that um a special session is definitely needed for Hurricane Relief and it should have been called months ago they do not need to be tying Hurricane Relief to unrelated things that are not good for our children thank you thank you all right so that's all for public input which then brings us to the new business portion and before we do I'm going to read our resolution just in case you haven't heard it um thank to Dr Arnold and his staff for coming up and getting this for us real quick so it says whereas the Tennessee Constitution Article 11 section 12 mandates that the general assembly shall provide for the maintenance support and eligibility standards of the system of free public schools and whereas school choice already exists via
010District transfers Charter Schools home schools virtual schools and private schools and whereas Jaron County Schools educates every eligible student in our community who wishes to enroll and whereas Jaron County Schools serves a diverse student body with programs and resources designed to meet individual student needs including students from economically disadvantaged households students with disabilities and English Learners and whereas the proposed education Freedom scholarship act would create a program that diverts public funds to private institutions thus strengthening the ability of public schools to provide high quality education and maintain local control and whereas under this proposed legislation private schools receiving these funds will not be held to the same accountability standards as public schools and public dollars would be used without assurances of Equitable access for all students including those with disabilities or limited income and whereas
011while the proposed legislation guarantees that Lea's funding will not decrease due to student disenrollment this static funding fails to account for Rising operational cost and without continued enrollment growth districts lose the opportunity for future student funding increases that would otherwise offset expense growth creating a widening disparity over time and whereas as a result of static funding amidst Rising expenses districts may be forced to reduce essential programs and opportunities for students or seek additional funding from Lo from local governing bodies placing an increased financial burden on communities and undermining the quality of public education and whereas while investments in teacher pay and the construction and maintenance of public school buildings are critically needed these initiatives should not serve as enticements tied to voucher legislation that jeopardize the long-term stability and quality of public education but instead
012should be evaluated and implemented on their own merits and now therefore be it resolved that the Jon County Board of Education expresses its opposition to the education Freedom scholarship deck of 2025 in any future efforts to implement or expand voucher or Esa programs in Tennessee and be it further resolved that the J County Board of Education uh urges the Tennessee General Assembly to prioritize investments in public schools strengthen teacher Recruitment and retention efforts and ensure that all students receive the support they need and Thrive and be it finally resolved that the Jer County Board of Education calls on stakeholders including parents community members and policy makers to support public education as a Cornerstone of democracy and an essential foundation for the future teny so that is the resolution before us so is there any motion
013on the new business for the resolution opposing the education Freedom scholarship act [Music] 2025 move to adopt the resolution we have a move to adopt the resolution second we got Mr D in the second once again the move is to adopt the resolution 2025 135 opposing the education Freedom Starship act any comment all right we'll vote all those in favor of adopting the resolution 2025 135 opposing the education Freedom scar Act of 2025 please raise your right hand and if my public school counting is correct at seven zero opposed motion to pass the resop resolution passes so that brings us to the adjournment of the special session as there move to Jour got Mr Danny Martin over here moving to journ or second got Paul over here as a second all those in favor raise
014your right hand all right 74 zero against we are Jour thank You' all very much on that um I'm going to pass around this copy that's to be signed so we'll start over here andbody whoever's last make sure we get the r i have the unfortunate duty of having to go to Atlanta so I got to leave and do a little online thing for school so I'm going to turn the work session over to Doug here and he's going to run it but thank y'all appreciate getting that resolution I know we're we're we're we're doing our best hopefully somebody listen so thank you'all all right the Viro scheduled work session of the Jefferson County School Board is n session um our first item is recognition Dr Arnold thank you Miss Walky is going to start
015off with the spelling be which we had a week or two ago so come on up come on up um our spelling be winners that are here tonight I want to tell you about our spelling be winners so every year we have a districtwide competition and to get to the districtwide competition you have to win at your school and so our spelling be is 3rd through 8th grade and this time I think our future is very bright because we have all Elementary winners that beat the middle schoolers so I'm very impressed with them um there are lots and lots of challenging words and these boys did a great job studying and I also saw some of their sponsors here tonight so I know I saw Miss forre um if there are any other sponsors here
016like to recognize you thank you for running the spelling bees at your school and organizing those events and then getting our students prepared um to comp to compete um all of our spelling be winners at the school level get to go on and compete in the regional competition and so they can go on and possibly compete um and win at that level and go on to Nationals so um we're very proud of these young men and I will say that first place if you'll raise your hand please was um from Jefferson Elementary School this is Liam and second place from Rush strong school that's Connor and third place from pedma elementary school is Chase with a c with a c Chase with the SE very good congratulations boys thank you for great [Music] job hey
017we're going to take one picture here and then we I'm sure we might have all right [Applause] than M Taylor Johnson principal at w Pine has a recognition all right so this is Megan Vasquez she is an eighth grader at w Hine and she was recognized for an Award of Excellence with the twsa and the nfh nfhs for her uh sportsmanship so she was nominated by her coach Nicole Martin and she received that award for the state so we are so proud of her [Applause] [Music] all right one more recognition um real quick is uh not going to ask you to come up and give a speech but uh just as we recognized teacher of the year we recognized principal of the year and our principal of the year for Jon County was uh Miss
018Julie Allen down in pedmont uh Julie last year went well for two years went through a renovation process down there at pedmont uh carried that through wonderfully she cons continued High academic standards handled issues on a daily basis uh so we just appreciate that going above and beyond and and extra effort that that that entailed so we recognize Julie today with u a cake uh for her St St down there and and uh went down and had pictures so uh we're we're thankful to have all our administrators and this year we recognize Julie Allen so [Music] [Applause] congratulations okay um the next will be director's information um I'd like to ask that the board members uh wait until both uh uh the L group and bership partners make the presentations and finish and then at
019the end of both of the presentations any questions that we have we propose it to so I would ask to please train from asking questions during their presentation so they it's easier to keep on your thought try when people aren't interrupting you I'm sorry uh that I'll turn it over to Dr Arnold and and if you have anything will have come on up Mr BL ship come on up did you have anything for me board or anything get my assistant up here to help and uh as I'm say we're here to answer any of your questions that you may have uh we'll certainly F anything you'd like to know all right any questions for Mr Black I thought we wait till the end I know that Mr Mr blank presented um last week and uh
020or last months and um you just want to discuss a little bit about those options that were on there before and removing those I'll be glad to yeah well when we first submitted uh a budget uh it had a group of options up at the top and let me see if I can get my hands on right here um and there were five or six options to be considered later on okay um we've since gone back and reviewed each and every one of them and uh carefully and really picked at them and looked into them and we found duplications there uh so we don't need this option anymore that sort of thing because it cost us in the big general contract and U one of them uh definitely was the U The increased number of
021classrooms which many class for uh we had included that and it was for $3.4 million but uh now hey after we uh picted at these things a lot we found nobody really interested in additional classrooms took that off the paper um real quick um renovate the gym stage uh was overpriced uh it was shown at $500,000 and that is going to be easily less than $100,000 and so that was um also covered that was a duplication it was also covered in the uh the large General uh contract cost um it was a hazardous waste contingency of $50,000 we have another contingency uh substantial contingency uh of 5% of the construction cost and that's $948,000 uh for unforeseen CES later on um so hey um you don't need contingency on top of contingency so uh that
022one was taken up and um uh that's mostly the soy but they were two or three duplications did you get copies of the revised budget I did send them copies of revised budget I don't know if they have them in front of them I did email them copies do you have copies or I I did have been emailed copies of the revised budget with the options that were removed out of the uh it show the big numbers are the hard cost total 19, 913,256 th000 for a total uh grand total project cost 23 million 330s I'm looking at the old they had the options on go back to the one I sent you okay the U hard costs are still 19 million $898,000 the soft cost came down in 2,884 th000 which leaves a grand
023total project cost of 22 mil 78,000 so I knew that grow um we something I would like to point out I think at the last meeting a few weeks ago we suggested that the abatement of the hazardous material the abatement uh project take place during this coming summer to get uh those goes out of there once and for all and as soon as possible while the kids are not there and while they're away for the summer okay uh we talked into we we've been in conversation with two very good authorities uh one a b company and one U uh professional batement engineer and uh different conversations and both of them came back and told us uh that can easily happen during the summer weeks um I believe you have a u about a a 9
024week summer vacation up for kids uh starts last day something like May 23rd somewhere around there yes and then U it last about n weeks the to give you a little detail I'm never going be around beat this much but the toughest material will be forti to get out of there is throughout the school the maximum uh the contractor said uh this is an Bap the contractor he said the maximum that would take would be 5 weeks he said comes out easier the Rees and that sort of thing uh quickly you know maybe we half or four week so can easily happen this Su there is enough time that's a big enough window uh we have uh schedule for them we have worked out a a pretty color schedule uh we'll be glad to share
025it with you uh of course this is just our thoughts and uh it need a lot of good input from the uh um when you would like to see things happen too but I'll be glad to share it with you and what you you see on this piece of paper is all up in the upper left corner is where it starts with a 30 day U architect engineer contract uh putting the contracts in place for this project and then after that uh mid mid March for about uh uh 2 and 1/2 months or 75 days there be a schematic design period at the end of the schematic design and at the end of these other design um phases those blue box are are crossing periods where contractor can spend a couple weeks uh constantly process
026this project to make sure it is on budget and um we have it run off the road or uh well run up the price added things to the scope that shouldn't be added so those blue boxes are very very important in maintaining price and cost control over this project or any project uh starting I show uh down below there's a green abatement uh period of 60 days from June through July um and up of the design development phase and then proceeding after September proceeding into construction documents some things for this project are unique can get started earlier almost as early as you want to go with them um there's some site work uh moving parking lots uh better uh sight lighting uh storm seers uh need total reconstruction uh those things can happen quickly um
027and U it'll be nice if you get those CED items out of the way before the winter month and then um sometime about December from there on uh is when uh the major work will start inside in the building um one phase at a time uh do you remember the last time we were here we showed the phasing plan uh how do this Wing in the building and that Wing in this area that area um hey they can start in the fall and continue uh probably two years worth of construction and the the blue boxes he mentioned are for us to just kind of keep an eye on the pricing but it's also an opportunity for the school board to give us feedback we to review drawings where we are at that stage and say
028hey you didn't listen to us fix this or great job you you got this exactly the way we want it so it's an owner review period as well yeah I think it'd be better if we ask each individual question you go right ahead uh just hold on a minute um I want to read the motion that was made at the September 23rd meeting uh motion was made that the board select blank and Chip and partners to provide a detailed itemized estimate for the cost and timeline to renovate Jefferson Elementary School per the approved scope of work and that's this document right here yes is everything on this document in your estimate yes sir everything best of my knowledge it is it's on this list okay are you going to be able to upgrade those classrooms
029from 700 Square ft to 800 square ft 700 ft to 800t it's on this on this list there are some classrooms that are 700 Square ft 770 70 780 something like that I know what you're talking about yeah there's some some just shy of 720 725 there's some 700 ft classrooms yes uh right see classroom space of 800 plus Square ft are you going to be able to do that for those classrooms that are not 800 square fet physically it could be done that's not what I ask you is it in your if over is it in that estimate that cost is what I'm asking that is not in the estim H in in laring the classroom like suggested is not in the okay it's on this list you just said everything on this list
030was in your es well I should should have got do I need to go down the list do I need to go down this list and ask you everyone individually if they're in your estimate or what to my knowledge they are what I was about to say uh Dr arold and I we went over all the bar classroom sizes you have there and uh I'm sorry my understanding that they're adequate as S as they are well and that's not what this board wanted what you want what we want are two different things because this document right here was a unanimous vote and so you were suppos do according to this motion follow this document and make these changes and include these things in your estimate so I'll go back and see my contractor pick that
031up but I'm sorry oh it's not there the classroom you've not in your estimate you've not included uh the increasing the size of some of those classrooms that are less than 800 square ft two 800 square ft hey everybody on the team had that list I'll go back and talk to my contractor and see if he included that or including a price for it I'll be glad to report back to you could you do you have a copy of this list oh yes I do yes great if you're going to report back then I would like I request unless I need to make a motion is to take every item that's on this list and break it down to how much each one of these items cost that makes sense you know right so the
032first one on here uh new mechanical system boiler exhaust heat hbac system gas rooftops and control hot water okay how much is that going to cost you know all these items on this list I think this board approved this uh and it was a document I think was put together by the director of schools and by our maintenance department and it was unanimous vote on this and so this existed before you were awarded or asked to give us an isue so to me personally maybe the others maybe I'm a little bit out of line here but if you could follow this down through and break it down how much each one of these items is costing in that U your estim yes sir and you also had and I don't have it in front of
033me you had a number on there of 2 like 89 something square feet is it on the document I was not here at the last meeting was it for C right you know you had you had the square footage and then you had the cost per square footage which was like $289 dollar and and that that has been reduced to 262 262 yes on the revised budget and email okay so um okay uh I'll leave it alone I I put a pretty good load on you there if you could do that and bring it back to the next meeting because I think uh Jeff elementary school is on the agenda next meeting right about a six if that's too much trouble to itemize you know the cost for each one of these items on this
034you as best you can that give me a better understanding of what's going okay thank you any other anybody else uh the last time you was here you gave us an estimate for six additional classrooms who asked you to put six on there uh the contractor put those on who asked any individual here asking uh and I asked him where did it come from and when he first put it on and uh he said most School citizens asked me for kind of a unit cost for classrooms they were interested in more and more and more so uh said okay we'll show it to it well who asked you to take take that price off for tonight uh well we took it off we we couldn't find anyone who was interested in additional classrooms so hey
035it seemed like a useless item on on than you any other question Mr joh any other questions Mr hard um talk about a list of things that uh I don't know it's actually in your price if it includes it or not um so I'm just going to kind of go down some of the things that I think about with a price and I so like I said I don't know if this is included this needs to be something we'd be thinking about after the fact things like a playground he's asking about the playground whether or not that would be included I I do believe that it's been a few days since I've worked at the the contractor's document where he gave us an estimate I believe he did include replacing the play and then the
036appr I know revised it um what about the parking lot you had something in the parking about the parking lot drop off area with a walkway yes we do have U revising some of the parking and that's and that's part of the price that's part of the new document that I forwarded to and that would include walkways I walkways um moving parking further away from the school itself um and the VIS um what about like as far as in the cafeteria so yours I think I saw an option was it an option for ovens freezers things in the in the kitchen area and new stuff I think the intent was to replace all of the equipment in the kitchen and that's that's what we asked them to includ and that's included in it also I
037understand it is yes I think it's about $600,000 for kitchen including new cooler and freezer um so as far as Tech the technology cabling electricity Communications stuff like that what how does that work out with what you're proposing is that all inclusive is is that um a certain amount and then we are responsible as a school district to finish out what we whatever it is we want does that make sense what I'm saying um generally speaking all of the cond and raceways are in large basic General the 19 mil um including cable trades running down the cor St clroom they need to go um I say yeah um come do um boxes in the wall all of that is in the general C con uh most owners have their own it people uh and call
038them in when the project year complete and they string their own pull own cabling and water I'm not I'm just talking about Communications the the soft cost on the list here does include 75,000 for the not not for the raceways and the cond but for the cable and get people would put in or whoever you come back uh you were talking about the abatement um roughly the cost to do an abatement break cost to do the abatement uh it's my understanding it will cost approximately $250,000 and I believe that's the figure that's showing in the um report done what about the actual um when it comes to like say gym equipment um you know I noticed that you had like new Hoops up I think as an auction is one of them asking about gymnasium
039equipment uh that was in the U that was a duplication that was shown in the options and we found that also listed in the large general contract so that's part of the price already then yes it was already there in uh so one thing I do worry about is the security of outside around I'm sure it's pretty well Fen pretty well the way it isan there is fencing around you know the entrances are not fenced gated I mean it's a large campus I mean you're talking about 25 acres or more cting the Middle School access so fencing would have to be replaced I mean you have and I think that's part of it it is yeah there there is fcing in the some of that fencing is 40 plus years old some of falling down
040thank you I appreciate any other questions I have a few um one of the things that you mentioned I believe in your last presentation was um the need to expand the administrative area the office space and I in your last proposal that has been revised that was a um option yeah is was that a duplication also was that that was a duplication it was the contractor that was doing our estimate overpriced it thinking it was far more there than it really was and we already had sufficient amount of money in the large general contract okay to cover so it's not that big it's not that costly and it was already covered in that's so the option to increase the administration area that would call and and SEC and add a secure entry for 1 million5
041is already in your soft cost or in your hard cost he he he was really thinking it was much larger and and more complex than that it's not okay and the re to renovate the parking and access drives and canopies which was an option of that in your first estimate um was not in your hard cost that's $900,000 so that is in your hard cost in a hard cost and it's not $900,000 okay but but whatever would cost to do that is in your hard cost in the revised estim yes sir uh um we talked about the increasing number of classrooms um hazardous waste contingency um is that in your hard cost or you that was a contingency I think you said that you don't need that contingency because you already have a contingency that
042that's correct so that could be that could be taken off also okay it's a duplication of contingencies now there um in our new build um estimate that we saw there is a cost for a owner's representative building manager which does not appear in yours if we were to want a owner's representative building manager do you have any idea what that cost would be uh yes I do uh I think the best I know are costing about 4% of uh the cost of those hard costs 4% of that $19.8 million so I they uh become cheaper than that but that's pretty much a top price well that that's the trigger I use based upon the other estimate we got so that would be an additional $617,000 for the owner rep that was not included in your
043revised you revised estimate so I guess what I'm saying is for in your estimate your site work is pretty much would would remain the same your existing building renovation cost includes those options that we just discussed those are already in there so those options if we wanted them wouldn't have to be added they're already in that cost there is a 5% contingency in there for anything that you I'm just reading off the estimate here for anything that you might find that we didn't expect so almost you know $950,000 the renovated parking is in the hard cost the increase in the administrative area and to add the secure entry is already in your hard cost um we agreed that you know the increased number of classrooms are um probably not necessary renovating the gym is that
044in your hard cost it's in a hard cost that's in your hard cost so we don't have to worry about that high electrical and low voltage in classrooms is that in your hard cost s that that is one of your options that you have in here concealing con it no uh wait yes we have new um uh Power communication lines things like that in uh the new classrooms and everywhere else okay um and we're going to try to conceal them as best we can in the large general contract okay without getting into more expensive furring out of all the wall right which costs a lot of money now and I think there's better ways or simpler ways to do it and get rid of cemented wires and all other walls um so that's going to
045be in general contract okay so that's an option that we don't have to worry about and we're pretty optimistic we can do that okay so what we're saying is with your site work staying the same with the hard cost that you quoted in here that includes a lot of options that the first one did not include because they were duplicated the contingency brings us to a total hard cost price of 19 mil 250,000 if you add the soft costs in to that that's an additional 3,476 195 and if we take 4% of the hard cost price for the owner's representative that in I calculations come to $617,000 so adding the hard costs soft costs and the uh owner's rep costs we come to a bottom line figure grand total project cost of $23,400 million million
046what's that 23 million what did I say 23,000 I'm sor sorry 23 23 I'm not using to talking Millions $23,400 th000 is that correct I think some of the numbers you were reading were from the old oh maybe it was okay uh you you you listed or you read soft cost of three million and we're at 28 28 yes okay yeah I okay on the on the sheet I added up I added hard of 19 m898 a soft of 28849 for a subtotal of 22 m783 plus the owner's rep cost of $617,000 to bring us to a grand total project cost of $23,400 yeah I didn't know initially did we know that we were to have an owner's rep included in the well I'm just I'm just comparing the renovation cost to the new cost
047and because it was in there I see so with that with that it would be about 234 if we elected to have that I now is if in fact we we did this is that if we contracted for 23,400 whatever 23, 400,000 in change is at a guaranteed price in other words is there other than the contingency that would kick in if you found things that were unexpected is there any kind of cost PR the reason I'm asking as I was a commercial lend i l on Commercial uh Office Buildings things of that I've never looked at a loan application for a school and this was at a different state at a different time way that um and I know there's something called Cost Plus where you cost something out and then you add things
048on as it goes along which drives a lender crazy um is this a pretty a guaranteed price once we uh decide and agree on a price can we be certain in in writing that that price that you give us in the beginning is going to be be the absolute most that we will pay during this project that's certainly the way we're added that's certainly what we recommend okay um hey I need contractor standing here also and uh him say the same thing agreeing that that is uh Hey the guaranteed maximum top figure okay okay um design has not taken place yet uh nobody knows how many square feet of glass or how many linear feet of boards or masas how much new roof's going to cost things like that until it's designed once it is
049designed uh one of say different when we design it it needs to fit in this budget okay and uh the contractor is going to sign a contract for a stipulated sum which means that's it that's what you call a guaranteed maximum yes yes and he's got to stick to that he's got to run very detailed hard costs get hard costs from all of his subcontractors and all of those very ious prices have to fit within this number that you're talking about okay so if if we decide to go with your option and we say okay this is what it's going to cost this is what we have once we sign that agreement we're not going to have to go back to the well during this during this project for more money just tell us don't
050come back here ask you for more money okay just tell us that's that's the way it is unless we add something from our end obviously you're the owner you can do that okay um in in your in the way you do things do you guarantee a completion date do you commit to having this done in so many months on a certain by a certain dat and if you don't perform what happens if in fact it's only five six done and it's got to take another three or four months to complete it what happens are you asking about design or about Construction Construction okay finishing of the project the owner contract agreement always has a completion date written into it at least all the ones I've done in my life um hey it could be a
051small job it can be a large job it don't matter it's got a completion date and the general contractor has to work very very hard and efficiently and be finished at that particular day if he has fallen way behind in the work is not completed then that's why we put liquidated dages into his contract um yes I've been for a few times in my practice um and it's so much per game like $1,000 per day or whatever so much per day and uh hey they really move their T when you have liquidated damages so there are pen there are penalties if things are not done on time but yes um but you can't wait till right at the end of the project and then see behind good um you need to monitor the contractor and
052the work as it is done in the field for instance we have progress meetings every two weeks on site with the contractor with the owner and the contractors is required to produce project schedule and we review that every two weeks or every month and you can see if he is really staying up on the schedule or ahead of schedule and uh don't wait till the very in and my last question is when when this is going on you and Dr Arnold have talked and are pretty assured that while this is being done the kids do not have to be moved off site is that correct you can do this in stages and and you know the kids would would still you know U be able to go to school you know as normal with maybe
053a little bit more noise than than normal but we would not have to move them on site to somewhere else is that correct that's correct okay that's all my questions thank you I've got question here second uh ask the director a question first how old is that Bild going on 67 years 67 66 going on 67 so it's younger than bad it's in better shape now my question there's remodeling what you said I can't hear out you know that nobody's want all right uh so we R all the building how much more life can we get out of that building with this renovation there's not one quick answer I could give you to that I'll one of the things on that list that you holding up is you can probably get uh probably 25 years
054there's 25 more what about new they're more than 25 Old probably 50 for the windows in the building right now you you talking about the glass in the building right now I'm talking about removing yeah I know but they've been there for six years which way um and putting in those should have been replaced putting in new windows 50 years or more out of glass aluminum aluminum not a corroding material not a coring metal um you've got masonry there a lot of masonry that will go a lot more time uh probably another 50 years or who knows um so which one you want to pick and talk about your longevity well let's start with the foundation okay are you doing anything to the foundation we're not okay what about to crack in the June it
055has been fed at one time uh Mr blank spoke about that that would need an additional study U on that with last meeting uh we said we would would just like to study that corner of the gym one more time a little bit more detail make sure it's okay so you think the foundation will last another 66 years on that build it's in huh it's in it's have you looked at it or anything I've had foundations were would give all and better than any New Foundation well understand that yeah but I'm talking about Jeff element school I don't care about any other buildings I'm talking about Jeff med school Foundation sure our structural engineer did a very thorough assessment of the things that he could observe nobody dug a hole nobody he just walked around
056the outside of the building and looked at the found he looked at everything that he could see he looked at the drawings that we sent him he went up in the ceiling where it was accessible looked at the roof structure got up on the roof and looked around but no we didn't take anything apart so what could he see it's what I'm asking now then you said so he he just walk around the building look at the he did see all of the cracks huh all of the cracks okay in make sure W so we never done any core samples or nothing like okay vast majority of those cracks are expansion and contraction cracks they don't have a one thing to do with the foundation they have a lot to do with not having I'm
057asking about the foundation because I'm concerned about it because the agge of the building and uh we don't get a good view of it because it's burping you know I understand that I'm just you know starting at the bottom you started at the top of the roof I went to the bottom say uh I know a roof will last 25 years is a good number for that's about it on the roof I know but U there's some unknowns and I know it's difficult to see that uh see that Foundation but there's nothing in the uh to do anything to the foundation itself I know houses expanding you know my house does on the amount of rain and drought and so on uh so this building's been expanded and contracted for 6 six years those expensive
058joints or you know had a lot of work out I've seen work okay thank you there's no soft point cut those U Mason walls every you know 25 to 30 ft that's what we do in standard practice today that they did not do way back when so it's all tied together brick brick brick you know how brick whole gymnasium and it need some soft joints in there okay here I'll read to you the paragraph that the structural engineer included in the report he says pre Mrs uh out of a section on his recommendations he has exterior walls and brick and a number of bullet points one of those has previously repaired cracking and settlement at the northwest corner of the gymnasium Cen the repairs in this area appear to be performing adequately to date however
059based on our review of the existing drawings there does not appear to be spec specification of vertical reinforcement in these walls and given the wall Heights opening sizes and previous cracking that fully penetrates the wall system we recommend non-destructive testing be performed to determine what reinforcement is present followed by analysis to determine if the walls are adequate to meet current code wind load requirements so he's aware he's looked at the drawings he's um you know he understands that this crack goes through the wall and it's been repaired so he's you know it's not a mystery to him he just you know like I said we weren't able to take things apart and see what's inside well he in the building 66 year old it's in perfect condition it is say you seen over that's f
060unfortunately as we as we age our bones do deteriorate but buildings their bones tend to be um speaking of the foundation um just through my knowledge of Foundations I would imagine that's a lot of concrete and over time it's not like brick M where uh starts failing from the weather but you actually have a curing of a concrete which would probably make that even better today than it was probably 30 years ago um I I imagine what they're seeing is whatever is settled in that building is probably settled after 60 almost 70 years I we need to make sure we take that in consideration instead of drill doing core samples um am I incorrect on saying that about the concrete though that it actually cures it cures after a long period of time it actually
061becomes stronger and harder in the right conditions it can concrete loves cool and damp conditions it's like fine one just get better and better U you know all walls I have spr footings under them let down in the and close to a constant temp on the bottom of the if you take the top of that wall it could be 120° so um got it easy got it P and shade uh kind of Conant cool condition but the wall is really suffering up at the time so it's quite a difference when it comes to expansive contraction and throw in weather any other questions one thing just as as far as project timeline and I'll put Joy on the spot some since Jesse's not here but I'll try to answer most of it um within a project
062um we need to have that project fully funded before we start a phase of the project so for instance within you know looking at a batement this summer um that's probably not going to be possible to get that project complete uh through um schematic design construction design development bid out people hired and then be able to fully fund that project whereas um some agencies outside of of state level would be able to phase in projects in phases and funding but we have to have that Joy they're not going to issue me a PO for a partial project so we have to have that fully uh if it's a $23 million project we have to have that $23 million security bid out the project in totality before we begin a phase of that sound about right
063like your plan for p right Pont was a very that crossed the line a little bit and that we had that money figured out um and how it's going to be funded through various 141 142 uh and how that phased in so we would just need this this timeline and project would need to match up with construction it would need to go all the way through be bid out uh be fed before we could start the project so it has to be fully funded or available of fund before we can sign a contract so yes because we are not a funding body um we could very easily fund a portion of this project started and County Commission could remove funding from us so that's why funds have to be secured 100% fun in order to
064to move the project forward yes that rais so if we had funds and we had a commitment or funds from County Commission merg and we had those funds at that point we could move forward if we so choose once it is yes once schematic design occurs design development occurs construction documents are produced in is Bid out that bid matches up with the amount of money that we have available you know if we have $24 million available and it comes in at 23, 500,000 they issue a PO and it moves forward right if we have $24 million available and that bid comes in at $24 million and $1 they will not issue a PO understood okay I'll throw a dollar in I know any other questions thank you Mr blanket appreciate next we have Lewis group
065um good evening I'm Todd brang with Lou tro Architects and with me tonight is Paul McCall he's our director of architecture and principal as well with L group thought we would uh just go over real quick I know we were here I believe it was back in September maybe and provided uh cost es updated and so we will um just look through that real quick together answer any questions that you may have um it really hasn't changed all that much a couple of things that next one uh couple things to point out um first of all uh what we were asked to do I was looking the last couple of days uh back in January or no it was sometime in 2020 later 2020 uh we were as to look at an elementary school designed
066for a 600 student capacity so that's what we're talking about here today um we went through an extensive programming process with at the time Dr Johnston Dr Arnold um and then I know that through some Administration other Administration and staff at the school as well to develop a program for this for this school the total square footage of the new school tool is uh 7790 ft um and so when asked to look at a costing exercise for this or just update the numbers what we did was is that we used a per square foot cost based on some recent construction uh back in uh about 6 months ago five months ago we bid uh a project Union County Middle School Forest mayard um that project was uh 1,000 student for capacity 800 students um to
067start U at opening and um that project base big came in around $283 a square foot uh so taking one of the most recent schools that has bid in the area and taking that per square foot cost um we took that data back in September and then we added a r bit inflation to it for this year um and used a number of $292 a square foot which you'll see at the start of where um the information becomes a little bit more itemized um we also have a demolition number in there from 100 for $100,000 uh if you remember the site for the new school is at the current County Fairgrounds there's buildings on that site and the demolition was for uh some of those buildings if I remember right Dr you may remember I
068think they were the possibility of maybe keeping a couple of those buildings out there and disassembling them at that time this has been three four years ago so hard to remember you know exactly what those conversations were um one one item I will say before I go any further um is that during that time we had owner representative as well that was hired and on board at the time scansa and so they had looked at these they had originally looked at this number back then in in 2020 2021 and um and so at that point in time they had a demolition number of about 85,000 $85,000 and so we added inflation to that number uh to bring it up to uh 20 late 2024 early 2025 and that's why we're sitting at around $100,000 for
069demolition right now uh construction contingency of 5% um leaving us with a total building including site cost of 23,7 4,794 we have soft costs as well uh 3 point basically we'll say $3.5 million leaving a total project cost of 27 m280 794 um just real quick wanted to go through kind of I have an aster as you'll see there with u with soft cost and um that will include architectural and Engineering fees uh civil engineering fee f f which is Furniture fixtures and equipment um so basically if you take the building this is all it was always explained to me if you take the building you turn it upside down shake it every falls out your f um so there's FF design fee a $445,000 technology which will sort of probably come back to that
070one uh there was an estimate in there originally and uh so it's been escalated just a little bit to $500,000 as you turn the page there's an owner's representative uh fee there which was slightly or a little bit lower than that again back in 21 so it's been escalated up um 620 uh survey somewhere in the neighborhood of $35,000 is is probably a good budget number for that uh environmentals has assessment which has actually been completed there's been a phase one environmental assessment that is actually already been completed for that site so um that $5,000 could actually be we can credit the bottom line if we need to there so uh andir um Hazmat monitoring um because uh I think it was identified that there were some maybe some ASV in one of those buildings
071a little bit and so there's some Hazmat monitoring to take care of that uh construction materials testing and special inspections which is something that is a third done by a third party during the construction process 130,000 uh building permit fees State Fire Marshall fees building permit fee somewhere around $45,000 State Fire Marshal fee $50,000 you plug that into a calculator and spits out a number for you and uh based on the building construction cost it was slightly lower than that uh when we plugged it in today so um it's like $45,000 so there's maybe 5,000 there a little bit over the top but um utility connection fees and uh reimburse expenses leaving the total soft cost of 3.5 million basically there so that's how you get to your total project cost um I'll be honest
072we have a little bit of an easier uh job to look at when you're talking about new construction over renovation so uh but we'll be happy to answer any questions that you have concerning this um I also have a copy of the FL on a jump drive if that's something you all want to look at or we can send it to you later and you can look at it you know tomorrow or whatever send it to electronically if you guys would like to look at that as well but with that I'll take some questions any questions uh go ahead right ahead um first item um what was a square footage remodeling I I don't have the do I missed last meeting was roughly 69,000 Square ft is the current 699 is 69 6999 so and
073that was at $262 a Le squ the remodeling yes huh 262 was the remodeling 262 for remodeling yes so the difference between um two numbers cost wise is $3,880 794 8,8 and you get 77,000 Square fet um which is about 8,000 more Square ft I'm trying to compare remodeling understand I'm going right square footage to news square footage and the cost difference between the two and um you know hly we're getting more squ FS with new construction another question what would be the Lipan to this new building ask them the same question be fair right go ahead well I mean typically you know you're looking at a at a you know new construction Bas where 50e building but you know even your current building is far exceeded that right even without probably uh you know
074reinfor I mean you know we always you know this isn't the first system we talk about these issues with right I mean there's a lot of Aging stock of buildings throughout the state throughout the country you know me 2006 there were new seismic codes you know the reinforcing you know fied cells and masonry I mean that stuff you know is significantly more robust than it was you know back in back in the day so uh yeah I mean that Last Stand would be sorry long winded kind answer but it's years just a hard question to answer I know wouldn't try to put anybody on the spot let's go building Cod I don't much about uh but Jon Elementary School 66 years old talking about the foundation I know there's rebar in that Foundation but would
075a standards be better require more rebar than say back in whatever 19 I guess and and I believe you concrete is is some forest and so rebar will rush over time correct I mean if you over damd they tearing no two Bridges out and basally that the reason because of rebar in the concrete Bridges so you take a building 66 years old the foundation is not going to be quite up to today's building Cod I guess is what yeah I mean so so Mr blank he's correct about you know concrete does or maybe you were the one that brought up concrete cures over time it continues to harden uh so you know that it does do that you know with a lot of older structures I mean concrete doesn't work without the reinforcing steel you
076know in it you know the concrete's great for compression the steel Works in tension so as a system it works stra together as long as you got adequate cover on that rear it you know it it can last a long time you know but your repreren Bridges and things like that when it gets exposed U there's there's degradation carbon carbon carbonation of Steel happens you know and it it basically just flakes out so that can happen so but I have no knowledge of what to cover you know on this and again what was stated earlier no nobody's really been able to see you know because a lot of that that material very right underr good Mr Mark I just got one question which we had discussed is remodeling we're going to use the old facility
077you know make it new make it better or whatever uh compared to building new school if we build a new school then we're still going to have a price of something what we going to do with this old school if it's not good enough to remodel is it good enough to sell to somebody or use for somebody what we do with that you got to pay to have a demo which is going to be how many million dollars that's just a question I'm throwing out here it's a good question and it does have a cost yes I mean have a big cost because you got that you got to handle a certain way you know I'm just kind of thinking new school we got a new school but we still have an old school that
078we got to do something with old school remodel they go in and take aspers out or they do whatever they're going to do with it I don't know just something think about back any other questions I can share oh I'm sorry do you mind if I I didn't know it was a question go ahead it really wasn't a question but I can share you go right ahead because just we had a recent building that just Oliver Springs High School in Oliver Springs um they just renovated or I'm sorry they just demoed their existing build that they had they got bids anywhere from 300 thou about $300,000 to a million dollars to to demo that now obviously they took the lowest bit at $300,000 and they had a lot ofes as well they can demo that
079school oh I'm not saying this one I'm just letting you know this is what what I'm saying I mean but it was in terrible shape I will say that it had a lot of ases and a lot of coal it had old coal in there where they used to heat it for years ago I'm not sure but it made we paid 65,000 at demo the old store build restaurant I believe it was somewhere in that neighborhood so that included demo and then some feel and putting back so so there was a lot to that just something think yeah and back back when it was very well I mean me if it's not good enough to put kids in I don't feel like it be good enough to sell somebody put an O home in the
080boards had a lot of property that um you know old New Market school is now New Market City Hall swans syania is that swans Sylvania over there is some Community stuff and uh whenever we had the flood it was Emergency Management Center U we also have uh old Dandridge Elementary up on the hill behind the post office is unbelievably got renovated and becoming uh some type of uh yeah up on the hill yeah and uh you know there there is a u i mean central office is in a building built in 18 68 or somewhere around there U some of that building so I know that the county is talking about space and and different things they that they're looking for you know the mayor's all this Finance they're all running out of space we're
081spread I mean Central offices spread all across District any any other question Mr well I'm going to go ahead and ask you guys the same thing that I asked blank and sh I'm going to ask you this with the understanding the price that we have is strictly for the building corre nothing outside that building that incl is included in this I'm kind of asking I mean because I have a drawing but that's all that this is deals with it's just the building itself your numbers no okay so this is to this is a total project okay so so yours includes playground it does not because normally when we work for Public School Systems across East Tennessee the PTA normally funds the playground okay but it can be included it's just something that you have to
082but but it's not correct not that it couldn't be an option not lie sure okay um Does it include a parking lot as well as drop off area or inclusive and all that that's correct and even the the access draw the improvements to the access drive that connects back because it's on the back side of the site the connections back to the to the main we'll come to the main Highway do that go to the like Universal I Universal road to to the highway to the high to so split somewhere between alternative school and middle school okay also include obviously walkway canopies stuff like that fencing going around the property it we have fencing on the back side of the property where um the industrial building is it's on the back very back side of
083it and if I remember correct it's fcing on the front side of the property because there's we have where it was located originally there's a detention pond in an area and I think there was fing around the detention Pond as guess I'll give you like half a credit okay okay um now as far as like cafeteria the ovens freezers walk-in coolers all that's inclusive what about like uh lunch tables that's all included so um technology I know and I noticed in yours you had a lot of exclusions explain to me what is included what isn't included sure so you can help me too this Paul but we have some exclusions in there you go back and look at under technology there's $500,000 that we're carrying in the price right and so um the reason that
084some of those things are exclusions so take security for instance the school system has a security consultant that they like to use throughout their entire system so that everything's probably key the same the card readers are the same everything else so you know if you bid that project though and I'm not sure what we do we will do here I mean we have a we have a fee in here for an owner's representative but if you bid that project and you're subject to you can't signal out that vendor you're subject to whoever the lowest bid is for security a lot of times the school systems like to pull that out and then they pay it out of their line there's a line item in their budget that they pay for that so that they can
085get the vendor that they want right for for the building so we're carrying some in here of $500,000 for technology but that number can be maybe shifted a little bit just based on what the school system ultimately which one they decide to do correct that's why it's listed in soft cost you know as opposed to being part of the bricks of um okay so I did notice two of yours that had deep end or special Foundation I imag that's just because you're going into some new ground yeah you don't know what you're getting into well right I mean that's in a way that's a little bit of weird exclusion but I mean it's kind of an obvious exclusion because it's a twostory building this was a one story building but even up two up to
086a twostory building you know there were never be an expectation where you would have micropiles or Foundation just because the varing capacity wouldn't requir so yeah and so all the side work would basically be covered pretty much cover underneath it it wouldn't be any kind of contingency or anything like that that we would need to account for you know there's always uh I know there has been some Geotech done on this uh you know rock is always an issue you know doing unit prices for rock that's I mean we're you know you mentioned the horse manger project up in mun County I mean there's a lot of rock on that side and I mean we had a very healthy contingency and it's it's taking a real hit just because there's a lot of rock you
087know you know back in back in 2020 we had a we had a site plan for the site where we would approximately site the building that so there actually we have done geal investigation there was nine Wars that was was done during that time and um and the report came back favorable now where they do that b they could go 10 ft over and get right so I mean it's happen before but you know based on the investigation that was done at that time um it said that and also the structural engineer agrees that soils are suitable for shallow foundations as well so which addresses yeah just and not to get too far in the weeds just couple of bullet points from the Geotech that catch my eye you know soils would need to be
088dried during the pring process so you know kind of similar to the project we had in West Knoxville not too long ago where we just need to make sure that uh you know time of year we all know is so important in terms of when we grade moving Earth because you know if you're doing that in the winter and you're trying to dry soil turn soils over and dry them out this particular contractor used a lime treatment that they ended up sort of eating uh at a pretty good cost just because it was the middle of winter and uh very difficult to get the soils dried so I think you know we go into this process you know the sooner and and having a good you know starting that project as soon and as soon
089as possible Right to meet an in dat schedule is is super important uh they also did note kind of along with that that some undercut would be required replace with suitable material it doesn't quantify that you know at this point what do you what do you mean by that right there say that again some undercut some just finding that there were some unsuitable soils I mean it doesn't sound like there's a lot of it some unsuitable Souls that would have to be undercut and replaced with engine F so any other questions go ahead and roughly how long would this project to do a new start to finish what are we looking at time so right now and even Point guess um we completed schematic design on this project and so you can you can probably
090take this you can take the architectural fee and reduce the amount that we've already spent with you because that would be credited towards us I just put it together as an overall project it's basically what I did so you could take a little bit of money out of the architectural Fe for what we spent to this point in time and I think Tommy you had the amount or something maybe but um so we would be starting right now in D that's called and so with design development so we're already ahead from the standpoint of having a schematic design that's approved by this board or this yeah the board I guess is what I should say a a board yeah right because I think it's changed twice since then but um but yeah and and so
091it's been approved and um so we're looking at about four to five months to finish construction documents uh and then we would go bid and look at starting construction somewhere around September late August September of this year and we we're thinking a 20 to 22 month construction schedule which should put you in in the U beginning of the school year 27 27 28 I guess what that would be so any other questions I got a question um on these exclusions what would be roughly a ballpark cost on each of these you know should you know should we get these done well so if you take this confusing take two three four and five you know and they are those are lumped in if you look under the soft cost for technology it equipment CA and
092phone security that number that's included there in the soft cost so I would say two through five it's already represented in this overall cost you know but as a soft cost it's just not part of the bricks and mortar cost because again that's work that the schools forces you know people or or vendors that the school uses would be doing you know get into little things like uh you know residential number six residential appliances such as refrigerated I mean that's just stuff that you know just it's just trying to make a point that that's not included in in the base bit of the project that's stuff that typically teachers or you know people you know in The Faculty bring in walk off mats I mean that's a pretty minor item just you know at the
093front doors so and then number eight waste handling equipment that's your dumpsters and and waste you know that's going to like dumpsters it's going whoever you contract with you know for for uh for Waste Management and things like that um the only other one I didn't talk about initially was number one again the the vandor special foundations the expectation is that that's that's not even inous it's almost more confusing to put it in there but it's basically just saying the expectation with a one or two story building is that this is just typical spread concrete spread buildings so you're not you're not talking about mic Cas on or anything like that so the answer is is really we're carrying it in there in that the majority of it in that $500,000 represent I mean a
094walkoff mat can be $2 $300 something like that right depending on how many you put throughout your school um and then the waying equipment I don't know they charge you for I'm sure they charge rent Forst but you don't buy no no we pay a fee to the county and the county provides right so it's pretty pretty minimal and and I'm sorry if uh you mentioned this already but um if if we needed to demolition the old building and evade it what would something like that cost no idea because that wasn't part of the original project it had never been decided whether or not what they were going to do with it keep it sell it demo it it just kind of like where we are probably today right the example that I gave was
095of the school that we had a little bit of minor involvement in but a civil engineer handled the the bid documents for the for the demolition of of a building um i' like to go back maybe about the same size building maybe it had maybe a little bit smaller building old building probably the same age or older um and it I think they had nine contractors that bid it and and it was a bid so they took with low bid which was around $300,000 to demo and see it um but they had some bids that were as much as a million dollar too so but they were kind of all over the place but I talked with that school system actually just the other day asked them how it was how it was going and
096said we going great so they're very very pleased they had a lot of BU best in it as well so they're ating that as they as they demo so I would say probably the best thing to do is maybe call local not local but local to East Tennessee demo contractor to to give an estimate looking for that you you probably get a couple of estim yeah questions um I have some comments um as I said being a past commercial Banker um I probably look at things in a little bit different way than a lot of people because I'm usually on the end on the beginning you know and putting putting my institution's money at risk for something that somebody brings in so I like to look at cost per square foot you know I try
097to compare apples as much as I can and so when I saw your uh square footage T $292 per square foot my antennas kind of went up so I went online and called some folks and found some similar you never find a project similar projects one is just the road L Heights Elementary it's being Mor um about the same size school a little bit bigger uh new school their square foot price was $3 foot 3 yeah I mean excuse then there's one in Anderson County in Clinton Clon middle school that is not finished yet by the way one Mor I would say withinin four or five months of being so just finishing the one in Anderson Clinton is $3 $328 per square foot I based upon that I don't know how you came in with
098$292 per square foot it seems like that's an awful awful inexpensive price um for what what we're looking for and I was just wonder how you keep to that price um as I as I talked about earlier it came from that we had just been a school about five or six months ago as well and it was $283 aare foot was was build construction as there some alternates they accepted some of the alternates but you know in the base we used the Bas B of it and because it's very similar to this also it's very hard to I'll say this it's very hard to compare because programming changes from school to school oh yeah and so you know you're going to have extra programs and um maybe extra items maybe wider hallways different things that
099may affect the design of the building this this building is a very efficient building very efficient design and sorry I don't mind saying that we were we were very pleasantly surprised at the cost of that project and in fact we had we only had three bids on the project and they were all very very reasonable I mean the 283 was the low but uh I think they were the highest one might have been right around 300 so yeah but you know I don't mind saying that we we were elated actually because we were very concerned about that budget and and you know things we all know it's a period of inflation things are really high that they're also just sort of all over the place you know I mean I think I've said this in
100front of this board before so you might stalk me but you know I've said it in front of a lot of people is that I think there were a lot of sub subcontractor costs you know especially electrical and mechanical anding that were really they were they were maxed out and I think that was driving a lot of cost up what we've been seeing and kind of represented by the wor man project that I'm not saying prices are going down but I think that kind of stabiliz a little and that helps whether it's a renovation or new construction but but stabilized a bit and I think part of that has to do with to me the subcontractors seem a little less busy and therefore they're a little more hungry I mean I honestly feel like if
101we're getting numbers on some projects that it's like we'll do it for this cost they can submit that to their general contractor and we'll we'll do it for this and you know if you'll accept that number we'll see my concern because I've been is a price comes in we as a lender would make a loan then all of a sudden that the loan we make is not enough to complete the project so we have to go back to the web or they have to come back to us and we're almost on the hook because of think 34 of the way done finish I want to make sure that what and this I asked Mr the same thing the price that we get at the time that we sign is the price that's going to be
102what we pay I don't want to see in regardless of which option we're talking about I think we're going to pay this and end up paying this because of whatever reason I know you have contingencies in there I know a lot of that's a lot of that but I do not want to have a price agreed to that is not that is not guaranteed and again I asked Mr blank do you are you willing to guarantee that whatever price is on the contract what we think that thing is going to be the price at the end of the unless unless we proactively ask you for more can you guarantee that whatever whatever the price I'm not talking about this price but whatever the price comes up be but that's going to be the price on
103the contract is what we pay yeah yeah you know sorry hope I sound like I'm not going to avoid answering your question but the way it's important to control those things in the front end so you know good thing about new construction is you take a lot of PS work out of it right the things that it all gets opened up you can so that that's a good thing usually in new construction where you get hit the hardest or the unforeseen there which is the stuff on your ground right you know it's it's running in the Rock it's you know unforeseen conditions know once you get beyond that point and the pad is is prepared then you know it should come together there's always going to be stuff I mean right we're not going to
104stand up here and say we're perfect you know we not there's going to be there's going to be glitches there's going to be some coordination issues you know and what you always hope for is those are very minor things and typically they are very minor things but once you come out of the ground and have a had prepared then then those issues become much less significant right because then it's then just construction new construction as opped to you know all the things underground that you can't see so is that a yes or a no well what I would do to help to help make that a yes is I I think we need to do more GE you know we have nine borings right now but I think within that footprint these aren't big cost
105you know you go Geotech out there for $ 354,000 and you know for 10 or 12 borings do that make sure that you know we get borings to refusal you know that bullet point that I read a minute ago being concerned about you know where said something about some of the undercut making sure we know where that is so that we know we get that put in the base B otherwise be a unit cost and then it can just you know almost seem unlimited right so I think we need to do our due diligence just us but just all of us as a team you know to make sure that we control those issues and then I would say yes then as long as we do all those things and make sure we're we're controlling
106the cost and that cost can be can be a guarantee uh again a question that I asked Mr Black do you in your contracts guaranteed date of um completion and if that completion does not take place do you uh are you are you penalized for not performing completing it on that dat or I mean weather permitting obviously if we have a flood like that Carolina is getting sure yeah and again just I'll answer the way Mr BL did because 100% SP on by that you know it's that's a construction issue as opposed to a design issue I mean as long as we meet Our obligation get documents out we we employ the same methods of liquidating damages you know typically that will be $1,000 a day it can be anywhere we want to set it
107you know uh and basically that that provides some uh some motivation you know to for the for the general contract yeah yeah the contract that's that's what I was asking okay any anybody else have any questions I just share a thought on what you were talking about being called the number 3177 and there was another one right uh and there's this 29 okay why there discreption more than likely two numbers you mentioned are over two years old two two and a half years ago things change like you said you know inflation or the government changes you know that changes oh don't I know yeah I will share this with you you trying to get a guaranteed number and I understand I try the same thing bill I have gone through a lot over since 2010
108I came on uh you don't get a guaranteed maximum price until everything goes out for being you know okay now the number is larger than what we got from the County Commission you make Cuts yeah no I'm contract well then they'll have guaranteed man well that's what I was asking they'll have with the subcontractors they'll be contracts already and everything and they'll come to us with a guaranteed Max price but it could be harder than the amount of money we bought it's a crazy situation you know you bought you bought the money beforehand open this Square P will fit around ho and so there you go here and it's frustrating 12 years you have to cut out you have to cut out something that was in design and maybe a classroom or sidewalk care or
109where the the roofing where car pick up you know those little things like that and you come back and put them in later say I'm we've done that every over time but anyway it's just a little frustrating it's a good question you know maybe to help jump in here you know to help sort of address that issue and kind of what you're saying is you no further than Pont I mean I think Pont turned out to be very successful ROV we had we had un foreseeing things it was it was existing building it had some age on it right I'm talking about t we're talking about cost and guaranteed cost and you know but I think I remember you telling me some time back and I don't I remember the exact number but U you
110know we had things be added you know as we went in the project so that was like you were saying you know proactively added project there were things that were unforeseen you know things that you know weren't where the asil growing said they would be or something you know so the connections you know so we had half a million dollar contingency on that project and we spent somewhere around $96,000 was the actual amount of change orders where you know we dug in the ground and we hit found an electrical line that we thought was 3 ft deep and it was 6 in deep and then in the front around the school there was some sort of septic tank some sort of concrete tank that had to be removed and soils added there was U some
111asasas that was not figured into the price and we found it and uh and it was an additional cost uh we had some meal work some Cabinetry that was uh as we got in there there was some water damage some rotten interior and backboard that had that we needed to replace um so then as we found a something that was an addition to cost we looked for ways to uh save money I think there was a receptionist desk that was priced at $227,000 to put new and we ended up going in and refinishing it and it was a $7,000 cost to refinish it instead of purchase new so um there was some some things that that happened and occurred so that that was that's a very good amount of money that we then returned to
112the district and then that money was put put on the talet elementary project to move that project forward in that cost and I think the byor percentage I think I read you say I'm very sympathetic to what you're saying I get it you know you don't like that mov right and just sometimes there's unforseen things that you can't really deal with you and you did bring up a good point too we were always very actively along with us B did a great job in Stans was involved in that but always looking for way if we found something we were looking for a way we do something to offset that cost you know so we try to keep that well I know and my my question is I'm not would never hold you to something like
113this but my op is once the ink is on the line on the contract and the price is there that's what we're going to end up pay and I understand that's what contingencies are for you know that's why they're in there to to you know to take care of unknowns yeah I well we understand you had a question I I do have question I did notice I to ask you this on the top of the uh pricing here it says 3% inflation for year 2025 I mean you what you gave us in September is the same thing and that's fine are we now we're in 2025 is that 3% I need to add on to because this was 2024 you actually gave us the original adding 3% to that now and so then when we
114hit 2026 it's going to add 3% 2027 the total of that's going to end up adding another 3% it we it this year increase anym just want to make sure I I'm going to be I'm going to be straight honest now okay I think Doug's concern is the same concern that I have I've seen on many projects not even around here not with you guys not with black sh I've seen many many multi-million projects $15 million and they cutting check 21 22 million uh $150 million cut the check for almost $200 million you know I see this all the time in new construction all the time me that's the biggest variable about new construction all I know what you want with that downtime price this is it and I get that there's variable contingencies but
115very rarely I ever seen a new building go up in this case I would probably at 5 to 7 million what I would I I think that when we're done that we're probably looking at no less than 5 more million being added to theost um I would hope not but even at 3 million I I've seen jobs around us done where it cost them more than two times what it was supposed to do and so when I see stuff like that ruction going up um I stay really perked up on to um prices and it's starting to easily inflate and I have the same concerns that Mr as far as going I would say one way we try to help avoid that is you know would schol right now and so at the end of
116development we waying our where it needs to be you're right zds at that point a lot of the major decisions are made you're talking about you know what kind of chical systems you're using you know you know cooking systems all that kind of stuff so you can get a pretty good price but you never know what's going to happen TimeWise not because of the drawing between DDS and CDs you know it's two [Music] months or whatever something happens but would be a really good che che where we're at right here we should be in this R right here if need some direction that we don't want a trend and we go back and we make some adjustments that's with the help of a Contractor on board it doesn't do have to be our owner rep
117it can be somebody in the community that has done these things we do this a lot yeah I was just kind of curious with the um don't the um if you did run into a bunch of rock in that soil so what would that something like that increase the cost here hypothetically iterally isard whatever you're extracting so however much I mean a unit cost per yard ofial I mean depends on what your I mean it's it's riable rock has to be blasted I mean there's a whole there's a whole range of and that's what we been handle in the unit cost that's kind of I'm saying 5,000 and and get that documented really well so that we have a really good idea of profile of crosssection that worst scen it's hard to tell because if
118you have we do we have across the entire right here we have you know so ACR the entire nine holes have been and and it falls within limits of of average amount that would be cover that's why do on on hopefully if there's some there we get it and then we can give you an idea of what that might to try to give an example I'll reference that job there's an excessive amount there no way that amount of rock on this job and I I think I think we've been somewhere between i' to go back check that somewhere probably between $500 and $600,000 just but again there's a ton of you know extracting that so that may be the kind of thing and we're we're pretty much of that's a te it's a te on
119Hill that's a very unique I mean I get that it's like a sliding scale you know like it would be really minor versus really so what is that scale i' say just really scale contract any other questions any other questions thank you I know that Mr blank and I talk about talet and there in design development headed towards when did we expect uh construction documents on Sal Elementary be complete like together with next couple weeks session and did [Music] anything else any questions we we've not we' discussed that um that's definitely U an OP still an option it's an option we've looked at that yeah we'll dig into that question thank okay um School commission it for discussion anybody have anything I have one you know based upon our policy today um a number of
120our policies were um on the agenda changes that we're making uh I School the policy committee asked AG to have we asked to suspend the rules um wave second reading and pass the agenda changes you know allowing the public comment at the work sessions Etc on the first so I will be that just let you know know we get to the policy polies talking about um so we can actually begin that those new agenda and rules of procedure in that's all I have anybody else have anything all right well then I guess this meeting is aded do I have a move second all in favor so