001and I'll let you know once we're streaming thank you Mr ad does that have to to the table push it all the way up to the table yep so we can get all of you in there all right we are streaming all right I have 550 I will call the meeting to order if everyone would stand for the moment of silence in the pledge you face the flag I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all Madame recorder if you call the role chair Laura Harrison pres Vice chair Jeremy Bernett here Keith Acton present Michelle Childs Here Deborah Thomas present I would like to welcome everyone to our February business meeting this is
002our only meeting this month just a reminder to the board and to the public um that due to the tsba I don't know their legislative legal Institute their new title or newer title um we only have one meeting this month so just reminding the public and the board of that Mr Mr superintendent will you lead us through our agenda I will uh the first item on the agenda is the opportunity for public comment would anyone from the public like to speak hearing none next item uh next item is our report section starting with our legislative liaison update Michelle Childs Miss Childs the floor is yours yes um there's not um there's not anything groundbreaking because I already um I think we all closely followed what happened but I will briefly mention that as I talked
003about in our special session last week that um the general assembly had gone into a special session and um did with a very swiftness pass the um School voucher scholarship um bill which is expected to be signed by the governor it will primarily be used by current private school students um but they've assured us it will not affect our funding um and um there were some concerns that we had about this bill but it will be law soon so we will see what that looks like um the special session ended on Thursday uh last Thursday January 30th and um they are back in regular session now any questions Miss Childs hearing none next item uh next item is the superintendent report uh I do have a few things I want to share but before we
004do that the the main and most important part of my report is recognizing some individuals uh who who have achieved distinction in uh Lakeland School System among our faculty in particular so uh let me change the The View here on the stream real quick and we'll we will get those up here okay board want to go does the board want to go down too as well you want to come on down so uh this is always an exciting recognition to give but we have uh three teachers who have achieved distinction in Lakeland School System uh by being recognized by a combination of their peers and their Administration as Lakeland School Systems representatives for uh teacher of the year for Lakeland school system and uh now that we have our high school grades we have three
005out of the four high school grades at least we give these in three different categories we have a K4 teacher of the year uh we have a 5 through eight or middle school teacher of the year and then we have a high school teacher of the year and uh we could not have better Representatives than we have this year we're so excited about all three of these individuals yeah give them a round of applause I'll tell you who they are shortly uh like I said these are folks who it starts with peer recognition um and then uh it goes on to the administration and the administration makes the decision on the folks that they believe uh for this year would best represent the school and the school system and each of these will move on
006to the state teacher of the year competition so uh in any any respect we're very excited to recognize these folks and I know the principles especially were excited to uh to make sure that they get these uh very deserved recognition so for our K through four teacher of the year we want to recognize Kristen connly so come on up Miss [Applause] connly and we're going to have you come up back up in just a second okay so if you want to sit down we'll we we'll do this then we'll get all the group pictures for our 5 through eight Teacher of the Year this is somebody that's been rocking it at uh back when it was Lakeland middle preparatory school she's been getting the job done there in the Spanish and foreign language department and
007has continued to do great things as we have grown and expanded uh one of the true foundations of our foreign language program at Lakeland prep so I'm so excited that she was recognized uh but we want to bring up Heather hawal de Rios [Applause] we'll get more pictures in just a second and then finally an individual who joined us when we opened our high school and uh is the founding director of uh the Lakeland Preparatory High School theater program and in a short time he's already become an award-winning uh director in our program and uh made sure that we have an award-winning theater Department uh it works hard loves kids and puts on great Productions and uh that is our 9 through 12 teacher of the year Jeff [Applause] White so what we'd love to
008do is uh just one by one we want to get you you can stay up here we'll go in reverse order at this point if we want to get the school board members up and uh any members of the Lakeland prep Administration that want to come up uh Miss dooso if you want to come up and be in this picture that would be great I'm going to move this again and then we'll move it back for I know I saw [Music] you thank you all right you want to come up yeah and the family you can come on up too you want to come up it takes all [Music] right up it will also not be rude of you [Music] step back it's warm tonight so starving think it's cuz I went back that smelled
009that damn Chi there you go popped up roast is going to be even better do the Mississippi rast yeah Ranch don't do a stick of the mood when you did that earlier I don't know roast has got plenty of fat in it you only a stick of there you go that work there you go [Music] all right let me switch the layout here all that happy energy and then it's just left with us I know my favorite part we have Mr idler though I know my favorite part is you can tell like um what school each is from because there's that friendly rival of like yelling for your Lees or LPS groups you know so I love it I love all the energy and the loyalty to the comrads yes all right uh just a
010few more things to report I'll keep it uh keep it brief uh but just to give an update we will open registration for new returning and kindergarten students on March 3rd so about a month from now we'll get that process up and running and that runs through March 28th um and uh so we can start getting a a better hand handle on on uh what our numbers might look like for next year although we've got already gotten our projections and they've tended to be very very accurate over the last few years so we thank Jerome McKibben for doing that uh a lot of great work going on in the instruction Department particularly with a focus on math um just wanted to note that I appreciate the work that's been done by Miss dooso and uh
011the academic leadership team there and uh particularly making sure that our new math curriculum materials are being put to good use uh we've had several new firsts it seems like every year and every month there's new first in Lakeland uh uh Lakeland prep and Lakeland School System but we want to congratulate the inaugural members of the National Technical Honor Society which is a first so we've got another another group of honor students had a lot of Award winners in the Midsouth Scholastic art Awards in our art Department um and then we had some students uh for a local technology Student Association TSA Regional event um that competed and did very very well and some of those students have earned a trip to State as well so we're excited uh for and about those students as
012well um we've got uh there's a special education parent training um that's going to be really the first of its kind that's being put on by uh our our sped director Rachel gay on February 12th uh there's two in-person options at 9:30 a.m. and 5:30 p.m. they're both in the LPS Library so just trying to make sure that folks are uh checking able to come so we've got uh morning and evening options there uh want to highlight again the Lions Den podcast which has been a great collaboration between our coordinated school health uh and St student services departments uh to making sure make sure all the good work that's being done in Lakeland school system is getting out this one features uh Tammy Wilson who is our CTE director among many other things uh so
013we appreciate that um for sure so uh lots of things going on uh we will be out for President's Day the students will be out we'll have a day of professional development on February 17th so students are out but teachers and staff for the most part are in uh parent teacher conferences are February 14th uh got any number of orchestra band and Choir concerts coming up in February so uh as always it's just a busy busy time but we're very proud of all the work that's that's happening uh so so happy to to share that as always uh in addition to that uh the monthly Financial summary is available and I'll certainly take any questions uh that the board members may have on any of those things anyone have any questions for the superintendent hearing
014none next item uh next item is the approval of the agenda can I get a motion to get this item on the floor so I moved have a motion I'll second is there anything anyone would like to remove or add to the agenda um is there anyone any changes anybody anything anyone would like to make to the agenda Madam chair I'd like to move item number two from the discussion action item to the consent agenda is there is that a motion that is a motion all right I'll second any disc discussion on the amendment hearing none all in favor of the amend Amendment say I I I any opposed the agenda has been amended is there any we're back on the amend amended agenda I'll get it right back on the amended agenda the whole
015agenda is there any discussion on any more discussion hearing none all in favor of approving the amended agenda say I I any opposed the agenda is approved next item next item is the ual consent agenda which now has three items on it I'll make a motion to get this item on the floor is there a second second you have a motion and a second any discussion on the consent agenda hearing none all in favor say I I I any opposed the consent agenda is approved next item next item we move to our discussion action items uh the first item is a benchmark 2 presentation by our director of data assessment and accountability Matt Adler Mr Adler we love when you come tons of data good evening um first of all you are very appreciated uh
016I appreciate you for allowing me to come here to discuss data um and mainly for the public this is more for the public because you already know this is The Benchmark data is a snapshot in time of how our students are progressing towards goals how they're progressing towards um success rates achievement um towards TCAP and to highlight areas that can be reinforced but also areas that need a little bit more support um tonight's presentation I'm going to give an overview of where we are uh this year where we uh stood in terms of the three-year trend for our U TCAP data and how it compares to our Benchmark data I'm not going to spend too much time on that because arrows can be read and numbers can be read as well but I also want
017to focus on goals and school plan goals in terms of are we meeting making progress towards the end goal which we may or may not be there yet but if we're progressing towards it a good sign and it's a a good indication of what what we're doing um at the school level the other thing is I'm including um a uh some slides in terms of how students are meeting or exceeding expectations and I'll explain a little bit more about that because it's based on projections it's not based on actual um success rates of those kids so if a student for example is projected to be a two and they're making twos on The Benchmark they're meeting their expectation or you ones twoos threes and fours um and those equate to below expectations approaching expectations met
018expectations or exceeding expectations so when I get to those slides I'll focus a little bit more time on that so and then at the very end some recommendations um some of the same and some additional recommendations based on this data so our second Benchmark was T taken in the first week of December um the window closed on December 11th that data came back right before we went to to Winter Break um so we had some time to process and get it into the teachers Hands by time they came back after a winter break the grades tested of course are still 2 through 11 um the achievement content areas are Ela math science and social studies not all four are tested in all Sub in all grades but all of those subjects are tested and then
019our EOC content areas are all the same except for the additional US History um which we added this year for our juniors some data resources that I haven't talked about but I want to give insight to what we provide our teachers because over the last three years it truly has become a datadriven system teachers are using these numbers they're looking at item analyses they're looking at how their students are progressing in certain standards how they're mastering some if they're retaining or not and it's all for it's all because of this master review predictive assessments um the first thing that we give the teachers are teap scores from the previous school year if they are available um the state provides those and we provide those to the teachers and if the student was tested in Tennessee
020those scores are available we give them a Tas probability of success that is a probability of whether or not a student is going to make a three or higher on the TCAP assessment we give them projected State percentiles that's provided from Tas as well from those projected state percentiles we are able to give them a projected achievement level which then kind of gives us some insight in terms of our students making progress are they potentially growing it's not end all be all for growth but it at least gives us an indicator of how well our students are performing we give them uh students or we give the teachers percent of students meeting or exceeding expectations that's done at the school level by our instructional supervisor uh Carrie Eldridge and then of course the benchmark results
021Benchmark 1 benchmark 2 Benchmark 3 and then a new um Insight that I I've given them for this second Benchmark are the standards proficiency rankings which I'll talk about in a little bit so this is an example of what data each teacher gets and they can track it and of course I went with all ranges and they how they did on the first Benchmark how they did on the second Benchmark and then how they did last year so for example that first line the first first Benchmark they made a three second Benchmark they made a three last year they made a two that's tremendous progress for that student that probability of success for this individual student is a 61.9 so it's above 50% so there's a pretty good chance that they're going to make a
022three or higher the projected State percentile which then gets converted into a projected achievement level they're projected to make a three how are they doing on their benchmarks compared to that uh projection we say that that student is meeting expectations um for example the second student and I'm not going to go through every one of these students that second student the projected achievement level was a two the first Benchmark was a one the second Benchmark was a three that third Benchmark should give us good Insight of how that student is going to perform um this helps with teachers identifying student groups identifying intervention groups identifying who doesn't who needs enrichment like especially the probability of successes that are 85% or higher there that's a pretty good chance that they're going to make a three or
023higher on the tat so you want to grow them you want to keep giving them extra information and then support the students that are not projected to do as well this is the new resource that we're providing teachers and we take their item analysis and we can transpose it into a vertical column and then rank the standards from most successful to least successful I highlighted just one standard because the teacher can go in do a control copy uh find and uh paste and it will highlight where that standard was tested so this gives good Insight because if a standard was tested multiple times on one Benchmark you can see okay if it if the uh standard success went down why did it go down teachers look at the question is it a harder question is
024the depth of knowledge higher is it at a level two or level three versus level one and if you compare benchmarks you can see our students retaining material or are the questions on Benchmark 2 a little bit more difficult than Benchmark 1 if the values went down so again another insight for teachers um I have had a lot of positive uh comments based on this new report for teachers and plc's I've met with teachers um individually to show them how they can manipulate their own classroom data so then they can identify intervention groups and enrichment groups and really start making really um a lot more progress with their kids so um again these slides I'm just going to go through relatively quickly you've seen this for the uh first presentation you'll see it for the
025third as well how Benchmark 1 and Benchmark 2 you can see that we're making progress across the board for ELA in grades 2 three and four um one me thing I want to mention about grade two that Ela last year I've talked to Mrs lockart and that's somewhat of anomaly that is extremely high achievement 92% is an extremely high number so what I want to focus on grade two is are we improving and the St and we are improving with grade two as the year goes on just like we are in three and four which is what you want to see in one of the school goals for um or for Lees is to increase grade three Ela success rate to 77.9% so on the first Benchmark and for a total of 27 students we
026were 13.6% away from that goal uh in the second Benchmark we are a few students less we're 13.5% from that goal so we still need to do some work with grade three Ela uh to make more progress towards that goal again this was back in December so there's been a lot more teaching that has happened since then in grade four the goal is to increase the ELA success rate to 78.5 and as you can see the after the first Benchmark we had we were 13.5% from the goal second Benchmark we're only 7.8% from the goal that's great progress and you can see that the momentum is going towards meeting that goal and hopefully we meet that goal after teap uh the third Benchmark should give us more insight this was the slide in terms of
027students meeting or exceeding expectations we take their projections we take their achievement levels are they projected to be at one two three or four and how are they doing on the benchmarks in both cases we see positivity happening um in grade three there's 10% more kids meeting or exceeding their expectation compared to grade four which there's 5% but they're both positive numbers so what the instructional supports are that that are in place are tend to be working PLC work that's in place tends to be working at least from these graphs in grade 5 through 8 um for ELA it's a mixture um we see a little decline in grade six but in all other grades we're improving um in The Benchmark grade eight is especially important because that's one of the focus areas that in
028years past has been a little bit lower but now it's uh becoming on par with the rest of them and again this slide reinforces that comment is that after the first Benchmark we had 11.4% from the goal of meeting a success rate for all grades that's 5 through eight Ela so that's all the kids um as you can see 917 students that are um meeting or exceeding expectations um in terms of uh Benchmark 1 we're 11.4% from that goal we decrease that to 8.8% from the goal so if that trajectory continues we should be able to meet that goal by time the uh April teap comes around and again this is a quick visual to show what grade areas just need reinforcement keep doing what you're doing so that those percentages increase and what area
029needs some support and grade six from a quick visual I would say grade six Ela needs a little extra support because they're not making any positive or negative changes and that's a good thing that they're not making negative changes but they're not making any gains either so we want to identify what we can do at the school level to make sure that those uh kids improve between now and April and then finally our eoc's and um English one they're doing what they've done they've been successful for the last few years English too there was a slight dip but I don't think it's a dip that is enough to cause heartache in terms of what's Happening we did have some teacher changes um with English to from previous year to this year um so that could
030account different pedagogical uh strategies instructional approaches that could account for that difference but look at this 43% of students in English one are meeting or exceeding their expectation that's incredible 177% for English too so with those numbers in place The Benchmark comparisons may not be something too much to worry about if one's going down or one's going up this is really the progress that students are making and the impact that teachers are having on their students so what instructional supports do we have in play for ELA I've already mentioned the pedagogical methods but new teacher resources assessment planning based on three-year TCAP analyses that's done at from by the instructional supervisor working with the plc's what standards are missed most what standards are tested most and let's create um assessments unit tests that mimic where
031the standards are taught or where the standards are assessed and the big p the big change for LPS students are now using reading and writing Companions and they're writing they're being forced to write using paper pencil instead of everything on the computer and that's making an impact in terms of possible retention so moving on to math as you can see same thing with grades 2 through four there's improvement with the benchmarks a math 3 performed at a very high level last year their school plan goal is based on where they performed last year in most cases we want to improve uh the percentage by 2% to 3 % in grade three the goal increased by 1% because they were so high already and to get even higher it it becomes a challenge so where are
032we our great three Mass success rate that 90% it seems unattainable but after the first Benchmark we are 27.2% from that goal after the second we're only 14% so that's a big change and we are making the positive uh growth in term terms of improving towards that goal in grade four math good news for the second Benchmark they've already hit their goal and they've went beyond their goal by almost 6% so they continue to do what they're doing they should do very very well when it comes to tat and again double digit gains for students meeting and exceeding expectations this is all positive news and this is the importance of benchmarking the importance of getting a snapshot midye to see how our students are doing so we can respond to that data in grade 5
033through 8 in grade five there was no change between the first and second Benchmark um and in grades uh six and8 Math there's Improvement and that's due to the instructional supports that are in place for math as Dr horal said earlier when um he mentioned Mr dooso the instructional supports and the focus is on math math has been one of our lower areas and that focus is intentional that focus is purposeful the resources that are provided for teachers the resources that are provided for administrators are to to move that bar in the math curriculum and in grades 5 through eight we see it at the elementary school and we're also seeing it uh in the middle school with math eoc's some of this can be explained I'm going to explain geometry uh very quickly discussions
034with the teacher they didn't meet all the standards they didn't teach all the standards so that's a pacing issue that's a let's review how are we doing on pacing let's make sure we are covering the standards that are going to be assessed to make sure our numbers change and that was a teacher owning the data which is something that is so remarkable that we've seen over the last few years they own it they respond to it and they they change their style of teaching they change the resources that they're using me uh method methods for teaching may change conversations with PC's um happen and it's a really truly a datadriven discussion in here this is would be a wakeup call of students of our Mass success rate goal is to increase to 56.1% after the
035first Benchmark we are 4.7 % from that goal but what happened in the second Benchmark we got a little bit further away from that goal so that is something that I would recommend at the school level to okay what's happening what supports need to be in place to change that trajectory so we move make strides towards the goal rather than getting further and further away from it and then Alber one success rate and that success rate 51% just to kind of give it um some context that's a very high goal for Algebra 1 in Tennessee um I want to say actually I don't want to say this is a public meeting but the state average is not nearly near 51% um and I know we're we're above the state average in most cases but that
036goal is very very lofty um but in just like in many of the other content areas we are making strides and steps towards that goal which is what you want to see as the year is going on and again this slide I immediately go to Geometry but based on what I know in terms of pacing I'm not going to be too worried about students declining by 10% meeting or exceeding expectations because I know what the teacher did not teach and it got caught up in pacing and therefore you did not make as many gains in the others I'm seeing gains and that's making me happy in terms of what I how I compare the benchmarks if I see a decline but I see an increase here that gives me some comfort for the efforts that
037teachers are making so what instructional supports are in mathematics we see them across the board from grade four Math teachers attended and actually it was both schools what they call the math intellectual prep day at LPS and it was vertical alignment they were able to have conversations about what instructional strategies are being used at both schools um what is needed in fourth grade to get them ready for fifth grade fifth grade to get ready for sixth and so on um K4 teachers received math binders with instructional Focus documents and in those instructional Focus documents it opened up eyes of teachers of it's more computational and more conceptual than procedural and at first teachers were teaching procedures and not um the uh what I just said uh Concepts yeah content or conceptual yeah that's sorry okay
038and then math walks are still being done with Dr Thigpen who's our state math consultant who visits the schools on a regular basis to do walkthroughs to identify what instructional practice are working what instructional practices are not and that need to be changed and then School administrators are also working with teachers to continue the transition from procedural based instruction to conceptual based understanding which is what I just said and then lastly with geometry and possibly a few other areas of focus on instructional pacing to make certain standards are covered prior to the assessment getting through the material or majority of the material is essential for success with students and in grade three through five science again it's a mixed bag um grade three slightly going down in grade four and 5 is going up in
039biology and there are no goals for grad 3 through five science in 6 through eight in biology as you can see it's a mix of results of some improvement and some decline but the declines are not um major declines it's not a drop um in terms of from a high value to a very low value and then this biology success rate goal we met it after the first Ben Mark now do we surpass by a lot no but we're surp we're at least there and we're a little bit beyond we went down a little bit for Benchmark 2 but we're still beyond that success goal for biology and then from here my eyes go directly to uh science grade six and in biology even though it's a slight decline um what supports can we put
040into place for sixth grade science students and sixth grade science teachers to improve that uh the value or that percentage of students meeting or exceeding expectations what's happening in grade five science that could potentially be replicated in grade six and that those are some recommendations that I recommended last time and I'm still recommending that we want to find instructural strategies that can be reproduced across the board because good teaching is good teaching and when you have good teaching and good instructional methods you're going to get results in the end so what supports are in place for science you have individual PLC supports um science teachers are looking at new material sampling uh textbooks using harder uh concept or harder skills to vet high quality instruction materials for adoption for next year science plc's revise their
041pacing they recognized that in certain cases students were not ready uh from us mental standpoint to handle some of the more abstract Concepts so they flipped it so from macroscopic to microscopic or vice or vice versa and in social studies um which tends to be forgotten about a lot um again we get a mixed bag we have um grade six and seven improving and grade eight is decreasing and US history is going to be kind of an anomaly this year and I got permission from uh the vice principal at LPS to say this because they're changing where students are going to take us history and they're going to be in dual enrollment if they go into dual enrollment they don't have to take the eocc so the few students that will take the EOC our
042end count will probably not be 30 going forward and therefore US History will not be considered tested for uh Lakeland school system and again there are no goals for social studies there usually aren't um I would not pay too much attention to US history but I would look at what am I doing in social studies grade eight why are we going down in terms of students meeting or exceeding expectations although it's not a major drop it is still a drop what are we doing in grade seven that can be replicated in grade six and grade 8 so social studies uh teachers are still reviewing supplemental curriculum there's a focus on PLC work peer mentoring is happening especially in areas that uh students are not performing as well and of course that item analysis is being
043used to identify what standards need reteaching what standards need reinforcement and it's not just to teach the standard and forget about it but it's constantly coming back to that standard so retention happens so the overall recommendations um some of these are the same from last time it's still to identify underperforming areas and then to work with the PLC groups to find instructional resources or instructional practices that can um address those underperforming areas it's to evaluate instructional strategies what's happening in one class compared to another one content area compared to another and replicate those strategies as I've already said making informed instructional decisions and responding to the data in real time what's happening what is the data showing and what can we do to improve it or to reinforce it and then identifying standards that have
044not been mastered to adjust instruction through differentiation through intervention through a variety of practices to help uh raise the bar with those standards to monitor instructional pacing that's important because if the standards are not being taught they're not going to be able to be assessed at a at a very good level so what's upcoming The Benchmark third Benchmark already I can't believe I'm saying that that we're already in early February the third Benchmark opens late February and I'll give that overview of how they did on that third Benchmark which should be a a little snapshot into how they're going to do on TCAP that will be presented to you in early April and then of course our TCAP which is why we do all this why we make all this all the data driven instruction
045decisions and why we offer all these supports happens beginning starting April 16th and that overview of the data will be given when the data gets unargued and I can speak of it publicly in the fall so with that said do you have any questions for me are there any questions for Mr Isler Miss Childs okay I have several thank you um the first is you mentioned um I guess going forward for next school year with us history that if you take dual enrollment you don't have to take the EOC is that for ap2 or just the dual enrollment it's uh for I would have to go back and recall it's been a minute since I've taught High School um I think it's for both I believe um because if they're if they're not enrolled in
046US history they don't take a US History EOC AP AP US History is not or AP History is not considered US history and same thing with duel right so basically um you're anticipating we will have out of um a class of 200 maybe 175 or so 175 200 class um because I know our current 10th graders are of the bigger classes that like only 30 kids will be taking standard and will not be taking like you you anticipate that many kids are going to take a college level either AP or D I do because that's the the movement that the school is making and all students um that have passed English one or English two are going to be filtered and funneled into uh dual enrollment US history now I'm not saying that all those
047students are going to be absolutely successful on dual enrollment right but they're choosing to take that class and they won't it will be taking that and it also um accounts for our College and Career Readiness because the students all students more most of them everybody that passes English one and English 2 will be able to get that College and Career Readiness check mark of taking a dual enrollment class yeah no I mean it's a fabulous opportunity um I just didn't realize it would be that amount yes percentage wise of our students that's that's awesome um and I'm saying that just based on conversation with Mr Waddell um but we also don't have a very high failure rate with English one and English two as of today um so that's why that end it's a great
048way to get college credits for um no money from the parents or very little because they may have to buy textbooks but they don't have to pay College tuition so I mean my son signed up for dual enrollment US history so I get it I was just surprised by the number um my next question is um you were showing the algebra 1 middle um School scores and those seem very low compared to last year's do you because I thought I thought English was the only one that was comprehensive so I thought it was like the math would be on pace so do you have um any idea why for Algebra 1 middle it's such a disparity between last year the pre not just last year's but the year before scores and the current Benchmark I
049can only speculate and I I can share some conversations that I've had at the school level one there's 80 students taking Algebra 1 middle which is the highest number that we've ever taken maybe all those students were not supposed to be in Algebra 1 or they can't handle algebra one middle that could be part of it and then also instructional practices um there's been some coaching going on uh with algebra 1 middle and uh alignment with curriculum resources and alignment with um what works and what doesn't work and those Co those coaching conversations are also happening but I think it's a mixture of both uh a lot more students but also um possibly misplaced students but also change in teaching style because there has been a change in teacher over the last couple years too
050okay and then um my next question is almost like the opposite of that one um where do the success rate goals come from is that us or the state for example um on the um third grade ELA that was a I mean that's a huge jump like to I mean the students are already doing pretty well at 64% and our um ambitious goal is 78% which is great I mean we want 100% right but I just mean being realistic you know there's we have a lot of variety of students I was just curious for that um percent standard increase on that one yeah can I answer that question I can or yeah you can can I answer that question yeah uh I worked with the team on those goals specifically we did set very aggressive
051goals I just want to be be clear on that there was initial that had uh more incremental goals and uh they are completely okay self set and uh we are our team made the decision to kind of go big or go home and uh we we'd rather have a high goal that we don't meet uh than less ambicious goal that we can meet easily so I mean we want all students to do well so welcome to add to that and I would like to add what Dr H said um it is done internally the school plan is reviewed internally it is it's our a benchmarking basically it's how we're doing as a system it don't I don't want it to be confused with it's the state's Amo goal that they set for us and if
052we don't meet Amo or double Amo then we're not doing our job according to the state those goals are completely different than School plan goals so what I showed you were the school plan goals that were developed internally okay no that's great and then my um last question is um so when determining the students who the individual students who need help in all of these subject areas um how exactly does that work um you know for the ELA the math um at the elementary and M elementary middle and high how's that work are the students pulled out of the class and given extra are they offered like um the tutoring are we having I think we have the camps again right this summer for the students that get invited or anybody who who feels they
053need it so could you just speak a little bit more about that because I know it can be different at different grade levels uh from my knowledge uh te it's done a variety of ways tutoring does it gets offered to students that are identified by School administration and by the instructional supervisor identifying various students for tutoring opportunities and they'll look at a variety of factors how they're doing on benchmarks how they've done in previous years are they making progress towards their goal are they making progress towards their achievement level that's projected um so those are kind of the tutoring groups um interventions and intervention groups um from my own knowledge are uh developed by teachers they look at their students they look at students that are performing at a very high level those may be
054your enrichment group uh students in the the main level standard level that are they're doing okay they're not doing great but they're not doing horrible that may be just teaching to the middle and then you have your low groups that need uh remediation and then those groups are separated out into smaller groups to get the remediation as needed to help help the student make gains and how does that work at the high school level because I mean you know they're in the class so how how does that look I cannot answer that may Dr could answer say it one more time they do have sessions before school and after school yeah I was just asking um I just I don't have a great grasp of how the intervention works so like at the high school
055level you know because they're obviously in certain classes all day long so how does it work when they need the REM and maybe mrisa wants to answer why don't you answer that question yeah she supervis area thank you so at the high school level students get credit credited courses for intervention classes so if they're identified by Benchmark screenings and maybe they've been in intervention meaning they've had remediation um uh when everybody goes somewhere for enrichment or remediation they may have gone to specialized intervention classes and if that's needed in the high school they take take a class and get credit for that so there's a pathway okay if they're not in a class like that so let's say they did okay last year so there wasn't a reason to put them in it but now
056they're really struggling how does that work at the high school level on how they get the extra help yeah so we do the screeners there like we do at elementary and middle and so we have a like a a warning system type um data source set up to where we're always looking at how our student doing on the the benchmark assessments that Mr ader's been talking about so the MVP or the case assessments where we're looking at how students are doing on standards and then um you know we're looking at uh the the assessments that teachers are giving so teachers are giving their own common formative assessments meaning um we're going to ask students all the same questions and see how they're doing and so all that we're tracking or looking at and students can
057go in and out of intervention if they need to uh you know even if they needed to um even get some extra support uh or um get even a move into that you know for they basically like pulled out a class is that how it works or when they need the high school yeah yes so in the high school they would have a class for intervention if they need that um and so would you change your schedule then if they need it and they're not already scheduled for it would there is that how they would get it uh if they needed intervention and we hadn't already put them in intervention it's it's I would say it's really planned for as well as students who have special education needs so if a student has more special
058education needs for a classes in the high school and has had that you know history of needing that then we would look at that very Clos mostly at the beginning of the school year I'm really thinking more of I was just curious because I just don't know enough about it if you know if a student's in an English or math and they they don't have an IEP they're just really struggling and making poor grades and poor benchmarks like how do they get the intervention they need yeah um so the teachers and the counselors are monitoring grades so say a student in a regular English class and they're not getting intervention um then they would you know monitor those grad and um in the class as the teacher is teaching during the instructional time could help
059remediate some of those standards we've also added some stiens for teachers to tutor students and they're specifically asked to come to tutoring um and so we try to work you know with the schedules for that so we have some we do have some before and after school tutoring that's that's really looking at students that might be an intervention or that might not be me Meeting those expectations okay and then at the elementary middle would they get it during class time um or how would they get the intervention if they're again not not under an IEP they're just all of a sudden this year they're doing really poorly and in English and math or you know something like that MH so since it's not credit bearing like the high school then then it's you're able to
060look at the The Benchmark data and the data that we've talked about you know how are students doing on the standards how are they doing in the course if all of a sudden we're seeing a pattern where a student would need help then we have um like a a student meeting kind of a a an Este team type meeting is what we call it and we look at that data and students might go into intervention so all that means that in if they're in fourth grade for example instead of maybe staying with their fourth grade teacher or the fourth grade teacher that's just doing General remediation and they need more specialized remediation then they're SK during that time that all of fourth grade has intervention then they would go to that tier 2 or tier
061three more individualized intervention okay it's more nuanced at the high school certainly I mean the elementary school there is an intervention block depending on the grade level the students we we do things at the high school too with course recovery too so if they're looking at grades and and things like that then we still have the you know similar media meting and may say you know you you need to really catch up on some of the first nine weeks typ types of things we have options to put students on that in addition to their classes you just do have to find time to do that during the day or some students come to a summer school and so and also if it's the very beginning of the school year like let's say the first nine
062weeks and it's it's clear maybe the student just placed in the wrong class like you know whether you know the student wanted it the parent wanted it the teacher wanted it and then it turns out like this is not a great fit can that schedule be changed too if you know um let's say that you know algebra one in e8th grade is not cutting it and you know they might need to change to eighth grade I don't know like did are their schedule changes possible if they're overwhelmed and it's not something they feel they can overcome quickly there are schedule changes possible especially if students go into a class and may not meet certain criteria by the end of the 9 weeks maybe they're in more of an honors course and maybe they they could
063go to a standards class standard type class those types of things are possible generally you you may not try to drop a student to a lower Year's math just because of the course credit um and and and some things we have in the high school you might have students who need intervention math or they might need um an algebra one spread out over two years so we have those types of options for students with real you know special situations and we are um looking to propose some options for you might take your algebra 1 and then following that have a math learning lab so you're doing it you're you're you're practicing those standards and getting it kind of a double dose of that so we can stack things like that and kind of add those
064supports in and out but you're you're really working with your counselors and teachers to make sure they're still getting the right credit but we would layer in the supports or spread it out over two years if we needed to okay thank you I asked so many questions and I really appreciate it because I just didn't know that much about it and obviously we hear a lot more about you know especially with the high school adding the D and the AP which is amazing and great but it's also just nice to hear about the students that are struggling on the other end of it and the services provided so thank you for answering all my questions and just to add to the it was the history with the so we have a couple types of dual
065credit with that you you have like the dual enrollment which is you're enrolling at a college like University of Memphis for example a four-year institution or there's also like a State dued Credit which might be students that might get um could could transfer that to Southwest or something like that so it's it's it's a another layer in there in addition to AP and duel there's a sort of the two-year um uh University type credit yeah and which I think clarifies the question it's it's not that uh 80% or 90% of our students are going to be in dual enrollment it's it's the local dual credit combination that would become more your question that you were asking yeah no thank you for that clarification on that too that makes sense but it's still a crit it's
066still a college credit opportunity yes it's a third it's a third type of four options it it sounds like four okay what are the four I mean apde the you could have the SDC the course where they would take the end of course test the standard in the standard okay got it and then yeah the the college credit options and the AP okay thank you there any more questions for Mr iser uh and just one more thing too Miss child too with that US History option for either uh local dual credit or dual enrollment or AP that checks the ready graduate box whether they pass the end of the exam at the end of the year or whether they don't so that really um increases our ready graduate percentage as well it's great so it's
067a it's a great approach to that course Thomas you had some questions I do you mentioned um Universal screening so is that were you talking about AMS web Plus or what we used to use was what was easy CBM were you talking about did you mention Universal screener or did I hear it wrong I did not mention Universal screener okay so do we what grades do we do um I think Mr Delo mentioned universal screen is part of intervention identification I believe k k yeah for as web so um I I was just going to ask it seems like that would be that would kind of help you get them sorted in the best starting place and then see if they could move up from there in some of the Middle School classes um and
068then I was going to ask kind of similar to Michelle about if a student is in as is in LPS and the second Benchmark has taken a dive or it really didn't improve any from the first one is it pretty easy to move that student into an intervention period from say a Maps class I I don't know about the scheduling piece um per se but it does give administrators and teachers Insight in terms of what support they need to provide for those students and what supports they may need to provide for a teacher they could say Okay teacher needs a little additional support or some peer mentoring which is happening right now to improve uh pedagogical approaches to um students that are taking these benchmark assessments so it's not a one-size fits-all uh situation but
069it's the data it's responding to the data to see where do we need to reinforce stuff that's being done really well and where do we need to remediate and strengthen and help bring the students up okay and then um one of the most helpful things I think is teacher a has pretty high scores um lots of tough standards are met you know with great success teacher B needs some of those strategies um to help her kids have the same level of understanding how much do we do to ensure that they have time to work together in these grade level subject level groups because it seem I mean it's there's so many responsibilities they have you know in the regular classroom day but it seems to me like that is one of the hugest ways for
070for for me as a former teacher to go to somebody and say hey I'm having a lot of trouble with you know teaching irony what do you do show me how you what do you do um there is an intentional approach of scheduling PLC time at both schools which um is incredible uh the hard part is the human nature part of teaching uh the vulnerability anybody that studies any PLC work vulnerability has to be shown to be able to be willing to say I need help with this standard and that's why the item analysis um ranked from most success to Le that's as a grade level and I told all the teachers at least at the element school I told the teachers that it's because these are our students we don't want to look at
071class by class but if you want to look at your class individually to see okay what standard are you struggling with or mastering that can help somebody else and I had this conversation with a couple second grade teachers the other day they were like this is amazing this is a life Cher in terms of if my kids are mastering a standard and your kids aren't what's the difference right and that's those conversations are starting to happen which again through years ago this this is my data and this is my classroom data I'm not going to share that now these conversations the barriers are being broken down because I do believe teachers at both schools are seeing the value in what the data can provide and I'm also going to be meeting with some LPS teachers
072to see what we can do to provide even more information for them or what information doesn't need to be provided that's not useful so we're having these conversations with the teachers at a granular level as well so okay any more questions anyone hearing none Mr Adler thank you as always thank you m Harrison appreciate it look forward to the next one with the I guess it's about the right time for teap right we'll get the about the time it's and I'll make the requests a year in advance can I go first next time so I Kidd I'm just kidding you guys are all appreciated thank you so much I offered to put you on the consent agenda but I got denied he tried rler all next item is discussion on new legislative agenda items is
073there any legislative items that we need to discuss then I'm I'll make a motion to get the sment on the floor I'll second it okay go ahead Mr Bernett I just want to bring it up um with the legislation that passed we all knew it was going to happen it happened it happened the way it happened um one of the things I'd like for us to consider is as a board we know it's not going to get repealed it's not going away but one of the disparities is the fact that private schools are not held of the St same standards or really effectively any standard and our students are tested and tested and tested and tested again when I guarantee you miss Lockhart's teachers and Miss Martin's teachers know through formative assessments how well their
074students are doing um and we spend an in inordinate amount of time in the state of Tennessee assessing um and that takes away from quality instruction all time or quality teacher development time um when we know what what it takes to do this what I'd like to see is is something that we advocate for reduced assessment standards and private schools to be held to the same standards we have discussed this prior but I don't know that we got that as direct and deep uh Dr hor can you go back and check our um resolutions we' P passed before to see if we've gotten that specific I know we've talked with leg legisl legislators before specifically if you're going to pass this law make it an even playing field that was very direct what we said
075um to their face repeatedly umly and that didn't happen but can you find out go back and look and see if our any of our resolutions I know we've discussed it I know we've said we all support um making sure the playing field is even um so that we can communicate during this legislative session because I know we don't have another meeting um till March since this is our only meeting so to make sure we're able to communicate the will of the board and what our voice is from now until the end of their session which is usually april-ish time frame is that right beginning of April is that about usually when they're adjourning I think that's about right yeah think so depending on the year yeah can you go back and look I know
076we've discussed it I know we've gone on record I think I think what I'm going to find is I think the challenge has been that that's been a speculative proposition like we it's been an if then kind of thing so we have not put I don't think as strongly as as we have the opportunity to do now um what our requests would be as far as assessments relative to private schools because our Our Hope has been that uh it would be irrelevant that we weren't being you know if they weren't receiving the public school dollars then we wouldn't be as forceful in that kind of uh you know advocacy um also how about this how about the executive committee can draft a resolution I think with the will of the board and the executive committee
077can send send it on so that we get it before the legislators during this session with we all know what we've discussed um and have in our legislative agenda and have documented in the past repeatedly at public meetings is that would that be fair so that we could get something to legislators within the next week or so and I'd say for my perspective for what I just said or presented it would be twofold one to have the same standards that held to public and private schools but that they should also be number two A reduced set of of assessment standards I with that if I may would this include potential elimination of TCAP I would say anything could be on the board yes sir absolutely I mean I do want to note that I did
078request that the legislators have um on this voucher scholarship bill I request I sent them an email and I asked that um they would um with public dollars that at the private school that they would have the same testing we have or that they would change our testing to be what the private school has but they had no interest in that um I mean I'm supportive of um you know it being the same standards I think it's a bit disingenuous to say that you know if a student's not doing well in a public school and then you you know are able to get in a private school which of course they can decline you um based on number of factors but um then as a parent you don't know if they did better or not
079because unlike the esa pilot where they're required to take the same test this one does not but the legislators made it very clear that this was not a bill um that was targeting poor families to have a better option this was a universal Bill and that they were um this was not to put any um um regulations on private schools with um public taxpayer dollars This was um to um have no matter um if you're a current private school student no matter what your income level is this was to be um a universal Bill and they made this very very clear um a numerous times throughout the legislation or throughout the um special session because I watched quite a number of hours of it um but I'm not opposed at all to um you know
080saying our voice again but they did hear our voice and decided that to go otherwise with it can I add something to it I will note so I just reviewed the legislative agenda that this board did pass so there are two statements under accountability just just to review LSS supports a fair transparent account accountability system that utilizes multiple measures to provide information to parents and taxpayers and supports requiring any schools or districts receiving taxpayer dollars to have the same accountability system this includes third grade promotion standards as required by state law and then the next was uh LS supports any school or parent Guardian receiving taxpayer dollars to have the same standardized testing requirements and publicly post the results of schools in a manner that allows for easy timely and informed Decisions by parents so
081certainly it sounds like one half of of your comments Mr berett are clearly included there I actually I'd like to as far as the discussion may I I I support the agenda now since the legislation is passed I think it is important that we go ahead and put a new um legislative agenda out there in order to um voice our concerns and I you know quite frankly I I think the teap is uh unfair playing ground right now with the uh with everybody and I feel like we we need to make push personally to uh amend or you know eliminate that which probably wouldn't happen but uh the teap test and um you know Miss Charles is so well put that uh there was uh a lot of that fell on death ears but hopefully
082we can U bring that up and and make people realize that it is truly an unlevel playing field can I make a recommendation yes mean I I think it would be in order uh for the board to make and pass a motion that to Miss Harrison's point would authorize the executive committee to draft a statement on behalf of the board of education advocating for the reduced number of standardized assessments up to and including the possibility of the elimination of TCAP testing and to Advocate that uh I don't know that the second part is even necessary but Advocate that any uh school or parents Guardians receiving taxpayer dollars have the same standardized testing requirements as uh Tennessee Public Schools there's one I would like to add to um related to uh teaching requirements that the private
083schools have a lot more Flex ability as to who teaches what courses where like let's say a CTE for us we still might have to have somebody that has some special you know a education degree or whatever so um it's also the the teaching side of it too as to who we can employ to teach certain courses some flexibility there for especially for our CTE World um that would be something I would like to see included as well I know we've talked on it here but that if the board is so inclined I'd like to have that included too I'd like to move that we accept Dr whl's written or or verbal comments he entered into the record a few minutes ago um to authorize the two of you the executive committee rather to um
084draft that document as the board's new legislative agenda um with those things that also included as well as what you just add it sounds like the motion that's the motion on the floor so I'm I'm assuming you're making the motion that Mo does the motion include Miss Harrison's third may I request that that be a separate agenda item is that okay does it need to be included or as far as the the legislative you correct um it doesn't have to be included but I like a separate I'm supporting it I just I wonder if it needs to be a separate item it's separate you mean like a separate bullet point oh yeah yeah separate bullet point yeah and I mean I intended for my motion to include all three to include all three yes okay
085well and I will say I mean there has to be some way to compare us to compare that this is going to play out over the next few years if the private schools take what the public schools are taking I don't see a wholesale change in teap until they figure out well how are we going to see how these people over here are going to test their kids so I mean I know I know I I would just like to say Miss lockart she she and her staff do a phenomenal job um with the kids every year and not increasing The Angst and anxiety in that building you walk in that building and it's like a Tuesday I mean it does not ites it is not a stress around the kids because of what she's
086established there and I think to say we don't want accountability when teaps all we have right now um is probably not the direction we want to go we need some way to compare ourselves to these other kids me taking public funds to a private school um the law lawmakers basically said no that's the thing so why we're well what they basically said too was we're we're going to do this so tell us how you want us want it to be framed to be better for you for operating so that's what we're that's approach yes because when we had the legislated breakfast I guess it was last year the year before I can't remember anyways that was basically the statement that they made to miss child and myself was they were they're going to do this
087and they don't want us to tell them don't do this and do they want to say what's going to be better for you operationally that's what you need to approach us with you need to stop trying to control what's going on over here well and they said in those meetings because I watched a lot of them too this bill's not perfect this bill's not perfect this and okay duh we know that but I do think that the push should be not to eliminate accountability but to create parity and accountability that's what I was getting at well and I think that's where we're going with this is parity and reduction so eliminate TCAP is 100% make it a sampling instead of 100% make sure that schools are are are required to do a an in perent
088sampling that's a random sampling um I I think that's a reduced level of assessment that's certainly one option to pursue I think the idea of a reduction in the excessive testing that occurs in all Tennessee schools is what I'd love to see us advocate for um I was just going to say that um you know they had the esa pilot and um those students scored worse on teap across the state and um that was brought up to legislatures and they were like um we're not worried about that we're just looking at parent satisfaction scores for private schools that's all they said that they cared to look at um what I would actually um propose on the wording instead of the um about the teap is that we use the exact same wording they used for
089the private schools it was a national standardized test so whatever that they are using that we would switch to use that for all schools and um unfortunately it sound I'm not 100% but it sounded like it was a variety depending on um there are levels of private schools like and it's level one two and three that can participate in the scholarship voucher and um there are standardized um tests that they can choose from it sounded like it was more than one because they didn't list a specific test but however the wording is I think we should put that wording um I'm not sure how to even address this but I will also throughout last year or maybe the year before runs together but there was the huge year of the third grade retention and the
090legislators said this was super important to them but you know with this a student student could you know we could go through the whole process at Lees and then a student would be required by law to be held back and then they could use the taxpayer voucher to go to a private school and then they would not be held back so to me that's another layer that just doesn't make a lot of sense to me but that is like another form of um unintended consequences but you know again the legislators in the session were very clear that they didn't want to put any um accountability or burdens on private schools it take taxpayer dollars well and there was also the point which we've made is that um some of the legislators who spoke against it
091said this is not a school choice bill this is the school's Choice bill which means you can pick and choose who you want to take and so it is disingenuous to say to parents here's your $7,000 go and get a better education but those schools do not have to provide special services for kids who need them and guess where those kids are going to come back to when they realize they're not getting the special needs um supports they're going to come right back to the public school and then we've got to figure out how to remediate what they've lost in the time that they were away from us so Madam chair just a clarification I'm I'm understand that there has to be some testing and I'm not the the obviously where I'm going with the
092teap if it's just us doing the teap and not everyone then that's where my struggle is I I I I agree and I think we're saying the same thing a standardized test is what I propose across the board so I I do agree with you there yeah I was just throwing out there it might be good to use um to um cease that we're asking to cease CCAP and to use the same wording that was in the um the vure scholarship Bill may I request an update on the proposal here I just want to clarify but not a second I'm sorry I'll did go ahead so I was the I'll be the second if I if there wasn't a second I'll be the second one um can you give us kind of the summary of
093I see you have a page full of notes I think Keith had something he's still well I just I'd like to clarification on where we are with if we can reread what the Yeah the list the list is I okay we're going to go I'm more sure on the first two than the third one because it was kind of the last one added um the uh the first one I was initially uh the statement I initially made was directly from the legislative agenda as it exists now which was um uh LSS supports any school or parent Guardian receiving taxpayer dollars to have the same standardized testing requirements and publicly post the results of schools in a manner that allows for easy timely and informed Decisions by parents it was a variation on that that that
094was the in the initial motion and then um from Mr Acton's uh recommendation that the uh lak Board of Education advocates for reduced uh assessments up to and including the possibility of the elimination of TCAP testing and then Miss Harrison after that added reduction of teaching requirements to be more in line with private school teaching requirements CTE and I think specifically for like CTE or those or not exploratory courses things like that because for example I know I've heard I think it was cville somebody they had maybe it was germ toown one of them had to stop like their Aviation program because they the FAA certifies somebody to teach somebody how to fly a plane but that person's not good enough to come teach somebody how to fly a plane in the classroom which is
095crazy to me sure so there are schools that have had to discontinue Aviation programs because the state of Tennessee says you have to have a teaching degree instead of saying you know so so that's why I say exploratory CTE I don't know what we call them instead of reduction could we say flexibility in CU we're thinking to lower the standards we're giv that's what concerns me about this one is I think you can get into a lot of nuance and I do think if you start talking about I mean PRI private schools don't have any teaching requirements they can hire literally anybody they want to so I don't think that's what we're talking about and I think if you start talking about that you get potentially push back from our own teachers who I think
096for the most part would argue that's not what they want and and now that that may be exactly what we're advocating from CTE perspective like I mean we've had issues in the past where the state gave us a waiver one year and then we had to do something different in the middle or the next year because it was somebody who was certified and I mean they were they knew how to teach this specific course like they maybe were nursing or whatever so I feel like I'm not I get that like our legislative agenda says LSS supports legislation allowing CTE professionals a simple Pathway to teacher license your through professional experience and that's what I feel like should be built into this that that is more similar to or like reinforcing that maybe would be the
097right well and we should figure out a way to also allude to the fact that the special the um special needs preschool classrooms have those really um um specific codes right um wasn't that one of the things that the teachers talked about when we were there that you have to have this very specific code to be able to teach kids with a certain disability um and that probably um causes a lot of problems I would imagine with these preschool programs across the state with them having uh qualified people according to the regulation so maybe flexibility with the regulations or something like that yeah we can we could certainly do whatever I mean this is sounding like a new legislative agenda perhaps that's that's rich with a lot of detail I just want to make sure
098that this is the pathway we want to do this on would we're not going to have the opportunity to come back to the board for clarification and I want to make sure that the executive committee properly represents the feelings of all the board members or that they at least have the opportunity for I mean it's one thing to take a couple of things that the board's already voted on and put that language in a new you know I think resolution I'm I'm I'm just very honestly I'm a little concerned about that we're starting to get into the the details here and if the board's comfortable with that I I will work with Laura and we will make the decisions that we think reflect the the will of the board based on the conversation we could
099also talk about it for you know I think I'm comfortable with the as we've empowered the executive committee to do it I think if after tonight there's a draft that we could see and we could give you individually our feedback on on a draft of that before you all send it out that would work for me me that good with you okay hearing and I value your opinion on this and would like to have more conversation with you Dr Hall just um offline and we can we can go through any thoughts related to this that work okay any more discussion hearing none yeah Miss mil is the motion now then that the executive committee will work to develop a new legislative agenda or is it still it was a resolution it's a resolution resolution yes
100yep so a new resolution the legislative agenda is staying the same yeah this would be a resolution based on largely based on the legislative agenda but with the a couple of other uh things that were discussed tonight everybody clear on what we're voting on all right all in favor say I I I any opposed motion passes next item you were implying that was convoluted no the next item is a review of policy manual section five are there any policy items from section five that we need to discuss um I had a couple I sent to Dr horal earlier and um I think that's it for now it's just the first half of section five oh yeah to clarify there there were a couple of uh pieces of policy that had Sunset um and actually the
101board had already acted on those and it was just a matter of updating the manual so I appreciate the policy committee bring those to our attention we've uh we've already passed those on to uh uh tsba to get them removed from the manual they were Co era um requirements that basically were were unique to that time and uh or archaic so thank you yep are there any announcements hearing none is there a motion to adjourn moved we have a motion I'll make the second all in favor say I I any opposed we are adjourned all right