CorpusRecord 75027

Bus Contract Work Session - February 18, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / RCTV
Date
2025-02-19
Location
Rutherford County, TN
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,312 words · about 47 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I think we're all back I call to order the bus contract work session first up we are going to say the Pledge of Allegiance again Mr VA Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for [Music] all as you can see this is their agenda brief that it is any questions or comments I'm so sorry I did forget the moment of silence let's have a moment of silence please bow your heads please thank you say he with the motion to approve the agenda presented we don't usually vote on we do okay okay I'll entertain a motion to approve the agenda as presented so moved thank you Miss Arby thank you Miss sharp all in favor say

002I I Mission passes next we move to bus contract discussion thank you Mr Reed or as you know we've been engaged with a number of bus contractors the last few weeks about um the new contract which comes up for renewal here at the end of this school year um we have there a number of the contractors are represented by Association group um Gabriel Ragsdale is their attorney um he is here tonight to address any questions may have some comments for the board um on behalf of the association there also there are also a number of of contractors who are not members of the association that have sent comments um to my office and me with with respect to their their ideas about the contract a lot of those comments we've gotten from the association are

003common with respect to the ones we've received from people who are not members of Association so there's been kind of a lot of commonality between the issues they've been raised I've also U talk and met with um our transfer transportation department staff uh about the comments we received from the bus contractors and to see what extent we can incorporate their ideas and thoughts into the contract so that's being discussed with the transportation department now um there are still a lot further discussions that would need to be H had between myself and the um attorneys for the association and other contractors to get some terms that are acceptable to everybody but the process is underway the big uh issue in is obviously the mileage rate and seat rate and what the board wants to do on

004that because U the association is called for Fairly significant increase um this in the first year and also some additional increases in the following each of the four years of the contract so that's something the board will have to make a determination on um certainly the school system understands there needs to be some there probably should be some sort of increase um in the rates the contractors currently operate under they have had there's been a lot of inflationary pressures with respect on the bus contractors over the last um four years so that has affected pricing from um from just maintenance servicing the purchase of buses themselves labor things like that so there's no doubt there there the increases the cost to operate a bus are higher today than they were four years ago so ultimately

005the board will have to make a decision as what an appropriate amount would be to to increase um on the bus contract um and they may have some information to share with you tonight from the association attorney as kind of some of those examples of what cost they' have incurred along those lines so so ultimately this the contract still in discussion um there'll be um a number of points still be hashed out between the school system and the contractors and ultimately you know hopefully within a few weeks we'll bring a contract back to the board for your review and consideration but I think tonight's purpose is to kind of be a fact Gathering uh mission for the board so U with that I do want to kind of open the floor for Gab ragdale to

006come before you and uh making additional comments or or points that he'd like to raise in regards to the contract thank you Mr Reed and thank you to the board for having this working session um again and uh for the time and opportunity to speak on these issues uh just want to Echo what Mr Reed mentioned that we are in process we've exchanged versions of of the most recent version uh produced by his office and we've returned a uh written up version U that incorporates um you some of our thoughts and changes within you know a new version of the document we spoke earlier today and we have uh a plan to speak again either later this week or early next week about trying to come together over our proposed changes versus you know what

007the you know what the board is looking for and and things that are more or less movable um given that you know we're trying to develop you know my understanding is a uniform contract for all the contractors and getting feedback from everybody is obviously a little bit of a process um we uh you we're I think we're optimistic that you know we've been productive so far so we expect that productivity to continue um in our kind of next iteration um we uh I sent a few examples and I know that was one of the questions is you know how are we substantiating some of these num numbers and some examples of these inflationary costs that have really undermined the contract and you know this Association uh of contractor's ability to continue operating with a 5%

008raise and i' be happy to to provide the I I have copies of them if you want to look uh and follow along and I thought that maybe the most beneficial way to kind of give some color to these examples is to have uh some of our members give a little bit of background because although the words I the numbers on the paper show significant increases for say the costs of tires oil um and labor associated with uh you know those maintenance uh issues they can give a little bit more background on how often am I buying these tires you know what what you know what is the overall maintenance picture for some of these things look so that we can show you know show your work basically behind you know how are we getting

009to a certain percentage or how are we getting to a certain number uh uh as it is tied to you know actual invoices that our our members have paid in the last you know couple of years and the examples that we have are from 2020 2021 up until like last week and so trying to show a you know the the disparity in pricing and and cost between when the last contract was uh you know became effective and you know what we're going to go into with the new contract and so I thought that that might be helpful and and to the same extent I know there were some questions about policy changes that the board may affect and issues in implementing those uh changes in practice and when they're on the road and so I

010thought having a member to speak a little bit about you know their experiences with that um and that's something that you know I understand that we'll you know we'll kind of go back and forth uh with Mr Reid's office and you know figure out how you know basically you know can we get more involved in some of those changes or at least being uh participant to meetings where certain Transportation related policies are adopted so that you know the people who are responsible with you know picking up transporting the students safely can do so in a way that you know they don't you know they're not being set up in some way to not be able to comply with their obligations and to do so safely and efficiently so that that was my thoughts and happy

011to answer any particular questions uh from from any member uh prior to kind of getting into that discussion but um that's kind of what I had in mind you know could be a little bit more Q&A as opposed to yall sitting here listening to me talking again so um would you like the examples the invoices that okay I'll I'll pass those thank you while he's getting that can I yes Mr is on he brought up a point there about policy is there any representative of the transportation industry on the policy committee I can't remember is that ever has there ever been any bu driver been on one before but there's somebody from the from the Transportation not anybody from Transportation here on our policy neither one that could be easily rectified probably we just need

012to I'm sure at some point there probably was one way or another but not and they may not want to be policy committee all right that was just a I do just want to add as well there may be other contractors here who are not part of the association who have comments to the board so we'll certainly make the floor available um for any comments from them as well absolutely y u not everybody is part of this Association how does their representation and this representation mesh are we going to get everybody to the table or how do we do that well we're taking comments from everyone so yes I'm on my you know we've been I've had a number of bus contractors who are not part of the association contact me with thoughts and ideas

013that they have with respect to the contract so we're trying to address those as well with those contractors who are not part of the association some of the issues that those folks have raised are common to the same issues that are being raised by the Association so there are some commonality between the two but there are some things that have been raised by some of the group outside the association that has not been raised by the Association but we are um hearing all those comments and trying to incorporate all those comments into the contract and I just wanted to add thank you to the board and whoever put together that spreadsheet because I think that's going to be very helpful and instructive as we're able to kind of move towards you know a workable number

014there so thank you thank you is there anyone um that would like to speak yeah okay yes please thank you if you look there are all right you have four bills of sale which are four buses that I personally bought the first one was bought it's in your packet okay I think it's in the should be back last the last four pages of your packet I think okay not sure what order they're in but there are four bills of sales just find that if you don't mind um okay here we are does it start with the mid South did they all say to Ursa Major Logistics they're Mid South invoices for Ursa Major Logistics okay there's four of them and as you can see these are four special education buses all four of these buses

015meet the minimum standard of our current contract they are 20 they're eight seats one wheelchair slot with air condition in because our contract does require that all sped buses have air conditioning as you can see the first bus was bought in February of 2022 for $76,500 the second one was bought in March of last year with an increase of 100 to 118,000 bought another bus the same month if you look those buses were bought 3 weeks apart for 129,000 and then the latest bus that I bought in all August is now 135,000 those four are identical buses there's nothing different between them except for the day they were manufactured and bought so between just those buses and a 2 and 1/2 year span that's $58,500 for the same bus for a sped bus that's 76

016a 12% cuz when we talk about our big buses because that is the majority of of our buses are our large buses but we do have them a small you know a small group of these buses which are that's a huge increase in the past we've sent you the invoices for the you know for our 90 passenger buses where those have went up anywhere from was it 46 yeah Central blue BL sales yeah the and those are we have some that we've sent you that are just our 90 passenger we've sent you the bluebird for the last four years in the Thomas the bluebird bus has went up 52.9% and the Thomas has went up 48.1 so that's where we're coming from where we're you know and you get to realize in four years we've

017gotten 14% to cover those costs which is where our ra is where where we're coming from you know we've got a lot of ground to cover up cuz 14% does not cover those increases and you can also look at we gave you some examples of labor costs and how much they have went up if you look there's a Central State invoice from March the 3rd of 2021 their labor rate was $130 an hour then there's an invoice from December of 20124 where their labor rate is now $192 an hour I have a question okay how often do you guys have to buy a new bus well how well we're allowed 15 years to run them um we can get a three-year extension but every time a new contract or new route is added that requires

018another bus a couple years ago uh I heard that it was really hard to get parts for the uh sped buses yes has that gotten any easier it's gotten better you can see I bought three buses in a very short period of time because we were running old old buses that we were limping through and till those new buses to give you an example that first bus that I bought in March of last year took Me 2 and 1/2 years to get that bus I ordered that that down payment was 2 and 1/2 years old before the bus actually made it to Murphysboro parts are getting better for the little buses I I will say but they're still you know we had a bus that needed a crossarm and we literally had to go and

019steal a bus off of a steal a crossarm off a donor bus because that contractor is still waiting on that new crossarm because they're special for the little buses okay M Maxell yes Mr TI uh how many how many suppliers do you have for buses is it just Bluebird is there in this area there's only for our 90 passenger buses there's only two manufacturers that make them in this area and that is Bluebird and Thomas International no longer makes a 90 passenger bus the largest they make is 83 do you know what the reason is behind that why they're moving away from because they no longer make a Transit bus to get larger than 83 passengers it has to be a Transit which are the flat they switched to purely conventional buses I don't know

020just that the the invoices you showed us were all Bluebird buses um the ones that we got you there are some there's some Midsouth buses in there there's Midsouth I just highlighted the central state if you look there are uh Midsouth invoices in there is that Thomas busy yeah Midsouth is the Thomas bus the one that's that's the dealership located here in Murphy's Boro and then of course Central State is our Bluebird in Lebanon didn't didn't they they sell Bluebird too here don't they I'm sorry don't they sell Bluebird here no the bluebirds are that dealer this used to be the bluebird dealership here in Murphysboro but then it's now in Lebanon when this dealership switched to Thomas they open the one in leanon for Bluebird is there a market for use bues for our

021specifications it is hard to find because with the 90 passenger bus very few districts use them so it is they're they're few and far between to find a used 90 passenger bus and most districts that run them are running them till they can't run them anymore and then by that time they're too old for us to purchase or they're not in the condition that we would want to use them Ma Mr tile where does that you said 15 years plus a three-year extension where does that come from that from the state or that is the that is this that is the TCA code we're allowed 15 years after 15 years you can go through a two inspections per year for three years or after the end of the 18 years if your bus is still

022under 200,000 Mi you can continue to run it until it hits 200,000 Mi but once they hit those extensions we as the contractor have to pay every 6 months we have to pay the state to come and look at our bus for the first 15 years we don't pay that's includ the state does it for us for free but still cheaper than yeah if you can get a three more years better buy it is it is but as as a contractor who owns some older buses sometimes it's not because the older buses especially cuz I have some that have caterpillar engines caterpillar hasn't made a school bus engine in years so finding those parts is almost impossible I'm like most time when I buy when I get a part you're ordering it from Arizona or

023Colorado and hoping that they've still got a part sit in a warehouse somewhere that nobody's bought yet so the older buses because it's just like with older cars it's they're hard to find those parts when things wear out and they do wear out oh do the get the harder it is find yeah and the maintenance cost on the older buses is astronomical any other questions yes I got one not looking at your Eno this curious question you there may be an answer there may not be an answer but on the sped buses right there the percentage increase in the last 5 years has been significantly higher on those as opposed to the big buses why what what what the chassis okay I can tell you it's the chassis because those buses run on either a

024Chevrolet for chassis typically in this most of ours are for our Chevrolets they've started they've got some Fords now the problem is we use those chassis for school buses they use them for ambulances they use them you know fire the smaller fire that we all share a chassis so they're only making so many chassis because of course they could either put a truck beted on that chassis and sell it at their dealership or sell it to a specialized to put a school bus body on it and you know when Co hit and things like that of course those chassis became few and far between so it's like everything you know that I mean list price plus $10,000 and that kind of stuff went off you know with Chevrolet and you you know now there's some

025rebates back on the half ton trucks but it it hasn't obviously it hadn't shown up yet on those CH on those chassis yet no and that that was reasing for the Curious you know it was just significantly higher percentage and I didn't know and we went almost two years without the ability to get those buses period because Chevrolet and Ford was not giving the bus manufacturers the chassis for them to put a body on any other questions thank you that was very interesting thank you so much I just wanted to make one note before we move on to another example about the new B uh you know the purchase prices of new bus and how that is you know we just went through a discussion of how you know often maybe they might need to

026replace a bus or due to you know increasing uh costs uh one of the reasons I just wanted to point out and this is something that is still part of our negotiations as to why is this so important if they're you know if we're only buying a new bus every 15 to you know 18 years part of what is in the present version of the contract is a requirement that every contractor have access to a spare bus uh in the event there is a breakdown or there's some sort of coverage issue in addition to a spare driver that that's different from what the the current contract had it's a little bit more explicit in the new version but you know if that type of requirement stays in this agreement we're talking about a lot more

027buses being purchased uh to be able to provide those coverage and um you know substitute drive you know all that type of thing to be able to have that bus uh available and so you know that's something that I think that we're still working out on what the best solution to have uh a backup bus available for you know coverage in the event that there's an issue um but I just wanted to emphasize that in you know in our discussion of the bus prices um I'm going to take a look at another example when we can and we don't have to go through each one of these line by line but I know Gary has already mentioned you know the increase uh in labor cost Associated for these my understanding is that you know the

028vast majority are diesel and require some sort of diesel Certified mechanic to work on them and so that you know it's it's a it's a more specialized type of work and so maybe he's got some some comments on those types of things yeah that's that yeah M Maxwell yes M has a question question real quick before we move on uh what's the average loan for the bus are they 10 years 15 years um typically they've in the past have been 5 to S years I know that Pinnacle we've heard is now doing 8 and 1/2 years just because they're having to add the extra time on just to make our debt to income work because they've told us you know that our contract doesn't pay enough for them to justify the payment it was 5

029to seven but now you're saying they're they're now they're going up to 8 and a half oh yes the shark you can answer this or not some maybe somebody can um I know you've been with us for a while has there ever been a time that the bus routes were not covered because of a breakdown our transportation director here so she can answer that question okay okay thank you thank you okay any other questions okay thank you anyone else want to I'm yes I was just want to make sure their attorneys is that everyone like I said we're we're still as Mr Reed uh mentioned at the top you know exchanging information and in the process of you know making revisions to the contract um what I Our intention is is you know this is

030meant to serve as as examples and we're still organizing additional examples trying to track down invoices from a couple years ago that type of thing and so we'll be happy to share additional examples of these types of increases just to help you know build a little bit more of the of the story behind you know some of the numbers um you know I think that we're going to continue working productively we'd be happy to answer any questions that you have for us uh as we move forward and you know pass along through Mr Reed um and uh in the meantime uh one one thing that we were also going to touch on real quickly if there's still time for it because we had mentioned you know policy changes having different effects in practice and I

031thought you want to say anything about Tyler yeah and so just to give an example and I think you know the idea is just to give a little you know background on that this is Tyler thank you hey um my incident just happened on my bus W knows about it already um we had a our policies right now currently from the board from transportation is that they're not allowed to call 911 for us um the driver has to do it it I had a driver that had a fight they haul Daniel mcke kids which is our alternative school had a fight on the bus Thursday last week and uh called transportation and said can you call 911 she had just left the school had nowhere to pull over um transportation said you need to call

032911 yourself and then she turned around and said I can't I'm trying to find a safe place pull over can you please call 911 for me and they again told her she need to do it herself and and she said Can someone please help and they did absolutely nothing one of my other drivers heard the incident going on and told the SRO officer after school and the SRO officer jumped in his car and went to the bus um the SR officer took the two fighters off the bus and told her to go and go to Oakland to meet with the principal and dropped the rest of the kids off on the way to Oakland she told she called transportation again told her she needed the nurse to come out to get the child that had

033been hurt like she just got in a crossfire to uh get that child off the bus to make sure she was okay and um when she got to the schools of course that she' asked for the SR officer to come out because the kids were still going crazy on the bus and the SR officer walked up the sidewalk like nothing was going on got on the bus and said we've already took the other two that was fighting what do you need me to do and then turn around and got back off the bus they took the girl off the bus carried her into the office the principal came back out and said that the parent was coming to pick up the child the child that was on the bus that my driver had asked for

034the ambulance for and 911 now has a sling and the parent is suing the system so parents already told the school that told my driver that she found charges against the kids that got in the fight and everything else when we called and talked to Wanda about it Wanda said that they've talked to Patty Patty said that they're going to talk about it this summer but we still have four months of school left that anybody can get hurt a driver my driver specifically asked for help three times and did not receive it whether she had her phone in her hand and could have called 911 she might have dropped her phone and not been able to grab it she could have forgotten her phone at home but when you asked three times for help and

035you could hear it in her voice that policy needs to change because that kid could had a gun could had a knife could have been attacking the driver anything could have been happening and the driver was trying her best to get the bus pulled over safely with the kids fighting behind so that's just one policy that got changed in our contract that that does not help us in any way it actually hinders us you know to do our job that's just an example thank you m Maxwell yes M Rosal Mr re last time that they came they brought that up that there were some policies that were impacting their operation and I had requested to bring examples of policies that were not help that were impacting their day-to-day operations and I don't know if that

036was um submitted or reviewed I think they're still looking and getting those together we don't have those yet from them but I think they're working on that when do you think we can get those policies that okay thank you madam chair yes M Darby Dr suin do you know why that's in policy it wouldn't be in policy that'd be in a procedure and I can tell you the part of the reason is you also have your Sheriff's Department who doesn't this situation of course is one that we want to make sure we handle the other side is you don't want people calling 911 privilously because then the sheriff's department is going to be calling things and this was not a frivolous one at all yeah but in practice that is what occurs when somebody calls

037911 when it doesn't need to be and then they're responding to an incident that they don't need to be responding so that is what we don't have jurisdiction over the sheriff's department and so that is the reason that that procedure is there because the sheriff's department requested us to have that in procedure procedure it has been a long-standing practice so ID have to go and check do you know and I'm just gathering information do you know if at some point in time there was an issue with bus drivers asking for that to be done frivolously cuz my concern is this we have somebody with a school bus with multiple kids on there and the high schoolers are some of the middle schoolers are big kids um and these drivers need to be focused on the

038road in front of them and what they're doing not on necessarily what's happening behind them where when there's an emerging situation the last thing I would want is somebody trying to maneuver driving a vehicle like that and trying to get on their phone to dial something while they're probably having some anxiety themselves because of what's occurring behind them so that's concerning to me that we have a policy that says when they reach out to help we're not allowed to give it agre I make um which which want W to told me this uh they they called my driver after this was over and said the GPS wasn't working to make the contractor get a hold of transportation to fix which is not our deal not our GPS um however I did tell them it wasn't

039working uh but the red button it's on our new radios we were told at first we could use those to call 911 then we were told No don't touch those at all and now we're being told that some of them work for 911 some of them does not so so as I told Wanda that needs to be implemented to find out that every single one of them does work for 911 or they do not work for 911 we need like it needs to be across the whole board that every single one of them does the same thing not hey does this bus work or does this bus not work you know that's danger for a driver because they think it works and push it and they're expecting 911 and nothing's happening then they're just in

040more danger Madam chair yes Mr Derby Dr Sullivan can we find out from Mr Lee um if the new GPS's if there's any kind of coordination for some kind of emergency button or I don't know what but if they have any kind of capability like that yep think that will be in that'll be something that'll have to be talked with with contractors as well because I don't think that's spelled out so yes thank you yes Miss sharp thank you madam chair um I think everybody that drives is under the handsfree we under handsfree okay Miss Maxwell so this situation with a 901 this is a policy that it's in the contract so we have to wait for the contract to change or can we change with procedure it's a procedure it's just a so it

041doesn't need a a policy corre okay so is that so I guess what you're saying is that this is going to be looked at and change I can work on Perfect all right thank you thank you so much thank you thank you for letting us yes thank you M 30,000 [Music] yep not quite 10 of our population 10 our population and so if I was in law enforcement I'd want to think you know there probably a pretty good way to cut off time you know whether or not you know a kid had you know medical Emery whatever so just I'm thinking out loud this sh free but they they can utilize the radios ex that within the limits of the law so to speak are y'all exempt our radios are exemp from hre from from

042hre I think the radio that is installed in the bus it is installed it is you can talk on your phone just like I can but you can you can talk on the r okay trying to process all this through my head very quickly now thank you um I spoke to someone earlier today and I said anyone that would like to speak can speak tonight so I'm giving you yes could you come up Miss crosslin and anybody else who had their hand up as soon as she's done uh you can come on up as well just you might want to identify who you are thank you all for letting me speak tonight my name is chrisy and I am here representing part the K K&M Transportation I'm not affiliated with the organization but we all

043are a Unity as we all transport for rther County um a lot of the things that I would like I have heard them speak of as well in regards to what we would like to have address I've sent you all an email uh Mr Reed and Mr rexville too in regards to some of the things with the collaborating companies that I have spoken with that is not affiliated with the organization of things that we might would like to have changed within the country and in section 1.2 uh is regarding our Insurance liability of the contract and I have asked um Mr Halton Ken he is here with Miller Lowry and Beach Insurance um if you all have any questions regarding the liability insurance um I did send within the email the uh quotes that he

044has given in regards to us purchasing liability insurance so liability and the format I just wanted to explain and go over that to in case there was any questions as well um with their company which I believe the cor Auto Owners Auto Owners um if we pay in full with work comp um and the previous uh quote that I had was 44 and two on and I believe that was in the first presentation of the contract but it has then been a change to one one and two on the million um the price if you pay it in full would be 11,891 uh I have three buses so that was for three if I'm telling correctly if you break that down it's $435 33 per bus that's if I pay a lump sum if I

045can't pay it in a lump sum because we have to have it by July then um monthly payments with the work comp would go up to $113,000 $69 and then we would break that down so um it is an increase it does cost more to pay it monthly than it does to pay it in full but if you break that down into monthly it breaks down into uh an extra $435 63 a month which to me I've done the math the 5% increase that you're offering and I know money is money but we have to come back to the black and white numbers do not lie 5% increase in numbers you're offering me a $358 79 increase which doesn't even pay for the insurance that is being mandated not by the board but by the

046hire saying that we have to carry this insurance so if you go into compensation I think 5% is a nice little discussion piece but we have to talk facts and that's just not ample enough to cover the increases that we are having to endure um anything on insurance before we move Maxwell to Mr T can I get that number again say this month and it's in the email that I sent you the copy um the 11,891 is if you pay it in full $3,694 payment um I did not break down the monthly payments you may have that it's 43 bit less than $1,000 a month it's like 990 or something oh the month is 4356 if you paid um if that was broken down so it's going to be roughly $450 $500 a month per

047if you per bus that's per bus yeah okay and then um the one thing that that I'd like to point out as part of this discussion of an increased cost of coverage or increased cost of Premium so in the past most of all these drivers just had physical damage coverage as you probably already know you may not know what they've been paying for that and that would have been you were paying what $400 a year per bus so and that was kind of an average there was eerie and a couple of different markets that were out there where at so if someone was paying $400 a year for physical damage coverage was their insurance cost in the past and now it's going to be closer to 12 or1 13,000 a year that's in total for

048three buses so you could divide that so you could say it's going from $400 to $4,000 in a year's time based upon each bus on average um based upon the new insurance requirements meaning them having to have the general liability the umbrella um and if if workers comp is required also and finding companies to write this insurance has been challenging as well like Eerie Insurance they will no longer if we have to have this I will not be able to keep Eerie they said as long as um they would write it as long as we do not have to cover the students but if we have to put the umbrella on it Erie will not Ure the buses anymore um for that so we're having to look at all new companies I've reached out their

049their company does it AO owners but I've reached out to multiple companies to get price comparisons too and when you start talking about the umbrella that has to be in place they're done talking so we're that's a challenge as well you say y'all don't you won't cover it liability on the students oh no this company we will when I say we Auto Owners [Laughter] will Auto Owners eie eie will not that's who I'm currently with now ma'am Miller Lowry and Beach is yeah Auto Owners is the name of the carrier that we would ride it through would you give if everybody went with you would you give them a discount I wish I could on but I'm not able to do that and and I will say each risk is evaluated on its own Merit

050so I mean these numbers are associated with this particular situation but but the fact of the matter is these folks are going to see that sort of increase that that part's uh a given that's a very minimum I'm sure if they have record those go yes sir and then the numbers that I've given um is on the 4 million if it's a million I believe he said it's $157 difference so you're looking but it's still at 450 I think Joanna just said that she has the 1 million 464 and she has the $1 million policy already um with me I'm just going to we but that's your numbers if you wanted the four or the one but whatever is best for your company yes I appreciate make sure you talking to the mic because we

051can all hear you but anybody at home that's listening is having a hard time if you turn your head I'm bad about that too so sorry okay any other questions for the insurance before we move on Stan I think Stan had some but you said that quote roughly 4,000 a little over $44,000 a year that included workman's comp how much much of that is workman's comp in in this situation uh $2,554 a year so uh about $200 a month yeah so roughly it's $2,000 and I'm trying to figure out identify or at least and I don't know if we've identified the number yet from the county have we Dr Sullivan what the pass through amount is for the liability insurance I know i' had a couple of discussions with what's the Department called what's the

052Ed's department called I can't remember risk management I know there's a new me a minute to go back yeah Risk Management Department uh Ed Elum is over that and and trying to identif of course the County's got the liability now obviously the county can buy has a greater purchasing power than say Christie does by herself or any one of these individuals and so I'm trying to you know there's a number that's over here somewhere right now that's got to be pass through so that reason I was trying to get to it and the liability thing you know again inflation has gone up so I hate to say it but a million dollars doesn't buy what a million dollars used to and so if you go to if you do have an accident or something medical

053bills and Jeff can correct me if I'm wrong um the way the last contract I read was a million dollars worth of general liability um but you were looking for also to get to a 3 million occurrent so you would have a $2 million umbrella on top of that which that $2 million umbrella is included in the numbers that we're talk talking about here so that is 3 million that is 3 million roughly $2500 a year that's taking away the workman's comp I'm yeah that's another animal in you got to pay it I understand that but it's a that's another animal in itself there so anyway thank you okay for that thank you thank you bring Mr Dr no you were done you were good that was oh okay sorry all right the next uh

054that I would like to in section 1.2 um that was sent out also in the email so everything will be referring to the email that I sent everyone that way we we are all on the same page of my discussion um in the contract and section 1.2 um all of this is going back to the insurance so we are having to carry our liability insurance and in regards to liability and as I say I'm speaking for my company only it is a liability for any contractor out here running that does not have a a roster population list prior to the first day of school we need to know who's on this bus anything if a child is at a bus stop in the mornings on the very first day of school and the school is

055giving her a bus stop because no one's notic no ified the contractor or they've not notified transportation and said hey this is this child's going to be riding what is their bus stop they go in and our bus stops are autop populated by a system from my uh knowledge the secretary at the school looks and they get the closest bus stop that may not be the bus stop that that child needs to be at but if I have a driver that's on this bus who has never driven does not know that last year they only picked up three kids at this stop but this year there's a fourth child out there no one speaks and then something you know we need to know who's on the bus the parent information we should not be out

056here doing Blind pickups because if something happens and it can happen day one day 10 the last day anything can happen this world is changing a lot we have no way to communicate there's children that ride this bus that don't even speak the the language I have no communication at all that tells me who this child is where she lives or a guardian so I've requested and I think it needs to be in here somewhere to where we are not out here blindly picking up and it's a huge liability on us who's going to be responsible if something happens to a child are they going to say well why didn't you know that she was on the bus how am I supposed to know if no one speaks so if we've got a roster that

057is given out 7 days which I picked the seven days cuz if you look within the email I have requested the 14 days to be changed to 7 days because 14 days if you turn in driver information there are some years that we don't know until the day before school who's going to be on that bus because with the pay that we have to offer drivers they are few and far between so whoever we can get to get on this bus is who we have but we may not know 14 days out we may not know s days out but if we could turn if we turn in our information 7 days and then the county gives us our driver routes our people that's on here then it'll be an equal change but without having

058a new child with a piece of paper from the school a roster that gives us information it just increases our liability Miss Maxwell yes M Ros um she's bringing in a really good point and Dr suvan I sat with you and talk about that I have zero idea how to make that happen um unless we are the bus stop is considered an extension of the school and so if a parent puts a student at the bus stop they're technically at school and so if that kid is there even if they are not registered it would be hard for us to leave a kid there cuz technically we are we are liable for them right um yeah got to pick them up and so for kids that do not register which happens she is exactly right

059there are hundreds of kids on that first day of school who were not and probably more than that they absolutely yeah so we have kids absolutely and so 7 Days our secretary start 10 days before parents register their kid that is why we do the 2-hour day which makes it even harder on Transportation um but that allows our schools cuz they stay full days on those 2hour days it allows us an opportunity to get parents in um figure out who is there and try to do a mass entry of as many kids as we possibly can um in a perfect world absolutely I 100% agree that is that is the way it should work if we could get an entire Community behind registering your kids and getting them there I don't know a way to

060do it yeah and I understand I know that's a horrible excuse I just I don't know a way to do that I understand but but um but in the beginning of the year excuse me if the students that are register and we know they're going to go to school regardless of where they're at will it be possible to have some kind of roster that they can get ahead we know that the numbers going to fluctuate during the week because they're new um that gives them the bus drivers the contractors who work with the bus drivers so they can at least see who's potentially going to get on the bus and where they're going to get off or picked up or whatever um it's not going to be perfect but at least they've got some knowledge

061of who they can expect to ride the bus at least on the first day and then the transportation and the bus you guys still could coordinate that and updating that list um because of the fluctuations that are happening um I'm just asking if there is we'd be willing to try anything but it's going to take weeks before it's accurate oh I'm sure it will take weeks but at least in the first week just for them to have some knowledge and maybe at the end of the week they'll get another uh another roster and maybe um you can update that and give them a new list after 3 weeks after the first day have to be it doesn't have to be exact something beats because if an accident happens that's the first thing they ask for

062who have you got on this bus and I don't know so that doesn't cut it if you're sitting on the other side and I also would like to know if this is something that can be in the contract or whatever um especially on the first day if regardless of who's even if the kid has been there before just to ask them hey are you going to cross the street or are you going to uh be needing to are you going to be are you going to get off at this bus step or are you going to cross the street especially if it's on a busy road um I just I want to know if that's something that is doable that can be done where there is a requirement that when especially on the first day

063of the first week of school when the kids are still trying to figure out where the bus routs are especially with the younger kids cuz they're not really understanding where they're going um they get off Neti H the the older ones don't well exactly Well everybody's not sure where they're going but if a kid is needing to cross the street that the bus driver will stay there and allow the kid to cross the street Street before it walks away and I just would like to know if that's something that can be done we do well we wait now to make sure and that's great and thank you so much for do for doing that I think that's awesome and we need to continue to do that um just that's great mhm no I think that's

064wonderful yeah okay yep let Crossland continue okay the next section is 2.3 and that's where I go back to um there's a 14-day and again 14 days and this is just negotiations its numbers I understand that they have a reason to but again the 14-day also puts us if you look in June when they're asking to have their meeting in July not June in July we're requesting that the meeting be changed until um August in June and July that is the time that's when we're got buses everywhere we've got a service buses we have in service that we do for our people for training and to make sure that safety and to make sure everything is like it's supposed to be for the upcoming year so we are requesting the 14 days and that would

065coincide too with the paperwork that we have to turn in at the meeting if we could get that changed we are in contract from our contract says from um August to May so June and July my drivers aren't available I know they would like drivers to come to the these meetings uh they want contractors but I just can't tell my driver no you have to come back first of all I don't pay them I mean they're not being paid when they're not working so I'm definitely not going to ask them to come and then me Fork out more money for them to come sit in a meeting um so that's that's just a small request uh to change those stes and section 2.4 uh this is a big one for me is changing the passengers

066I don't speak for every contractor I speak for myself and I sent over a quote and my company only runs Bluebird so that's why you only have a bluebird uh quote in regards to the buses and let me find it I just had it um of from Chuck of how much a bus is and the 90 passenger um buses and what they cost compared to a 78 passenger and an 84 passenger um right here it is so a 90 passenger bus which I do want to make this 90 passenger Productions it's only a 2% production so Bluebird is only manufacturing 2% of their fleets that are 90 passengers so that's another reason why it's hard for us to get 90 passengers I had to wait 2 years um a little over 2 years for the

0672025 that I have now now because uh my bus was total and that he didn't have insurance but regardless you got to get that bus back on the road I couldn't just get a bus that following year they wouldn't available so I had to wait 2 years for this 90 passenger I looked everywhere for a used bus like Gary says if you have a 90 passenger and it's running you're using it until you get your full life the life uh 15 years if the bus qualifies a lot of my buses I had one bus to qualify based on mileage my bus could not get an extension um I had one that could but again if we open the doors to the 84 passenger if there was a Ru route that had 70 kids or less

068on it I mean why am I hauling them on 90 um I could be getting a smaller bus is that less compensation yes but if that works out for my business it works out for my business it may not work for everyone in the city who is you know my Blackman route yes I had 90 plus I could not have used a small bus but on other routes we can but if there was an option it would allow us the ability to buy from other counties as well and it would help offset the price gouge too I mean we are being gouged we don't get the tax free cuz I I even tried for that too let me see if I can it's a school bus but unless the organization or such we don't have

069a tax exempt can't get one privately um so again you're paying all these taxes to where if it was a different way you know it would offset and help as well in regards to the email to the um labor cost is up 28% over the 3 years and parts have averaged a 25 to 40% increase in the past 3 years which which is a huge with income and I understand we are asking for the 34.8 35% but over the past years I've been driving for 30 years I've been in Rutherford County and the small increases don't the inflation is high for everyone any questions in regards to a bus M Maxwell on the seat requirement that's something that we talked about I think on the at the last work session afterwards but you said there

070would be more options available it's kind of a question I had for Gary um about you have Thomas and bluebird would there be more suppliers available or would it just be simply a cheaper bus and more options from counties that might be use buses like what what are you saying when you say more more options with counties and I would ask Lisa I think I've not ran an international or anybody we've had Internationals here [Music] they make a smaller so you would yes so we would I think it would open the door back up to where we would have more than Bluebird and Thomas um but it would definitely open the door up to where you could buy from Beford County I mean the surrounding counties that uh Franklin that do not have to run

07190 passenger buses it is just you cannot find a 90 passenger bus unless you're going to buy it from a contra tracker here because the they're just not readily available yes they are special order I mean we do have to order these you have to wait and put your deposit down and the numbers that that he's given on the bus prices that's for right now come May and August W well yeah they're going up just like the insurance that um Mr Alberton talked about that quote is only good for 90 days by the time I get ready to do it in July who knows what it's going to be hopefully things will go down that is what we all want but so far not seeing inflation go down yet sorry you made you made a

072statement there that surrounding counties often use a different what would you say the average size bus is for surrounding counties 78 78 yeah but there that's a more common I think bford County's running 78 um most yeah 78 yeah Franklin um the 78 if you look at the so a 90 passenger roughly is 17 172,000 376 an 84 passenger you don't noticeably see the savings that you're going to get um it's only $11,000 171 641 but it opens up the option to to be able to find used buses cuz there are counties Canon County um well the surrounding counties too have 84 it's not common but when you get into the 78 you have opened a uh Winchester Coffee County Canon County uh Franklin Nashville we've opened up a wide door with that one do

073you have the price on that one 78 passengers 134994160 no extras I mean it's conventional it's you know what we're running now I'm not running Cadillacs I am on a two-seater bicycle whatever I can get to run these kids with shiny wheels so if my banana seat bicycle out here with the wheels shined up if you see it that's going to be a K&M bus but it it looks pretty enough to keep up with the fancy ones but I just can't see forking out company-wise um for the textures I do want to say now I might if this was changed in the contract would possibly the air conditioning my drivers would probably like that kids too that would make it maybe feasible to where I might could do air but right now my company can't

074do air I don't get paid to it it's just not there for them um almost done and then my next section I'm going to go to the uh cameras and GPS and of course that was on uh um 2.6 um C well that goes back to the meeting we no longer have two meetings we used to have two meetings a year and here recently we've only had one meeting of year our um meetings for our license are now done online so we don't have to meet for that a request that uh some some is uh requested is for Google to be an option for these meetings so that when people if it's not going to be changed can we remote in to these meetings um instead of having to physically be there in person okay

075that's an option yeah I mean that would be that would help tremendous is this going to be much longer cuz I did I see one more hand and we have to hard stop at 8:00 that's fine okay thank you thank you no thank you and yes just come on up and okay while she's coming up I do want to bring up because this apparently is a state law or a state issue everywhere so there has been one bill filed for transportation and it is Senate bill 0656 by Hensley and it amends TCA 49655 to increase from 200,000 to 230,000 miles and it has a it's already been pass it failed so I'm sure they will so yeah I was good good so it's already and we have Don White as our Senate education chair so

076yes ma'am go hi I'm Lisa Adams I'm here representing my business Adams bus services and I was going to piggyback on what Miss Crosman said about the mileage but you just kind of touched based on that we do have to retire them at 200,000 miles and you know I own a semi TR and a dump truck and those things will go a million miles they have the same engine in them but you know if we could get that worked out to where we could keep them a little bit longer that would help a lot too but I know y'all hav't do that I just want to point this out real quick I know we're ready to go I'm ready to get home before the snow comes Etc but I wanted to point this out okay

077about the RFP bids all right the RFP bids I know they were approved without intent I understand that but just to give you guys an idea about this 34.8% that I I I know it seems astronomical but okay the first student bid was for $1,541 188 that was $585 66 per day gossip bus lines was 95004 per month and that was $527 78 8 cents a day the proposed 34.8% is 9,665 125 at $36.97 per day so I mean we're right in there with them you know and if they were approved at that I mean maybe that gives you guys a better idea of what it is exactly that we're asking for so just wanted to point that out I'm ready to go home it's going to snow thank you yes I've got one hand

078up come on in hi hi Kelly Hobbs U me and my husband have seven contracts between us there's a couple things that I haven't heard touched on and one is the debt to income a lot of the banks are not even loaning money on these buses because our debt to income doesn't match and the most recent one we just purchased it was a used bus and the bank only loaned 80% so you know with what little we're getting we also have to try to figure out how to save to put down on these buses um driver pay has gone up tremendously um a lot of contractors will get new buses every 5 years instead of the 15 because you have the warranty and when their warranty runs out um because a lot of repairs can

079be astonishing so instead of going through that they'll do new buses every 5 years so they're turn they're turning them every 5 years they're not doing 15 um and I think that's that's it but my main thing was the debt to income because and Midsouth you can go to Midsouth Bus Center I don't know about Bluebird Mid South Chuck will loan you a bus but what he does is he he he finances it his but he doubles the interest so you're paying Chuck 12% you can get a buck but you're paying 12% interest um the the used one we just bought was like 82 something like that which has gone up tremendously so but that's it thank you thank you thank you very much right everybody yes just speaking quickly with some of the leaders

080here I think we largely agree with some of the the thoughts presented by Miss Crossland um but in particular about the S uh seat Capac requirement I think that what our position would be is is that having some flexibility around that is the um it would be kind of where we would want to work with the board and with the transportation department as opposed from changing it from 90 as mandated to 78 because those numbers are calculated based on that's fitting three kids per seat and with they're larger you know middle school and high school students that would basically create you know less space and and more routes to take on so so I think we were just thinking you know a discussion about flexibility where it makes sense so thank you thank also thank

081you for everything tonight thank you well thank you thank you I think this was very valuable information anything Dr Sol okay motion to adj okay second second we're adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.