CorpusRecord 7530

Seattle Schools Board Meeting Feb 12, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Seattle Public Schools Board Meetings
Date
2025-02-13
Location
King County, WA
Material
Transcript
Extent
27,681 words · about 154 min
Collected
2026-05-22

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] good afternoon we will call the meeting to order momentarily and SPS TV will begin Broadcasting [Music] all right the February 12th 2025 regular board meeting is called to order at 4:23 p.m. we would like to acknowledge that we are on the ancestral lands and traditional territories of the Puget Sound Coast Sal people Miss Wilson Jones the roll call please vice president Briggs is she not yet in the room okay vice president Briggs has walked in and here director Clark present director hery here director mrai present director Ranken here director sarju present uh director Bragg here director elas director Yun presid and president top here all right I will now turn it over to superintendent Jones for his comments thank you president top and board members and everyone here tonight uh to open the evening

002I want to shout out and congratulate the Lincoln and Cleveland High School volleyball teams for their status as the 2024 academic state champions [Applause] this is a prestigious honor and a testament to their hard work and dedication on and off the court achieving the highest average GPA amongst teams in their classification this is no small feet and it speaks volumes about their discipline perseverance and the culture of academics and athletic success fostered by their coaches teachers and families congratulations to our student athletes for setting such a high standard we are extremely proud of you are you all in the house tonight stand up stand [Applause] up that's right my my daughter went to Cleveland so I'm a I'm a a little bias around what they do that's such such a good uh educational environment thank

003you Cleveland thank you uh Lincoln as well um so uh I'm also pleased to announce both levies have passed start clapping already I want to take a moment to express my sincere gratitude to the Seattle voters for renewing the educational programs and operations Levy and the building Excellence Capital Levy uh your continued investment in ensures that our students have the resources they need for a strong education funding everything from classroom learning and special education services to safety building improvements and Technology we appreciate the commitment to Seattle students and schools and extend our sincere appreciation to your support and being an essential part of Seattle Public Schools Community uh let us be reminded let me remind you that we will continue to be good stewards of taxpayers dollars uh it's particularly telling that the levies passed

004on our 100th day of school uh thank you for a 100 days of excellence and teaching and learning we have 80 more to go uh I want to note that our I want to note that our voters have given us the authority to spend above and beyond what the state's current funding ceiling is we are actively advocating to the state legislature to allow us to lift our lid on our Levy Authority so that we can fully take advantage of the spending Authority which the vote have entrusted us with the levey lid is just part of our multi-prong legislative agenda we are actively working with our legislators on securing essential funding and I believe strongly that our legislators are fighting for us and I will I will continue to make the case on specific bills and

005in conversations with the delegation with our legislative delegation as a whole uh I'd also like to acknowledge that that director rank in our legislative Le our board legislative leaone has been ready and willing to pushed forward and has and had a a big presence in Olympia already uh I want to switch to inclement weather I want to thank our school leaders Educators and staff for your flexibility and resilience and Contin continuing to deliver instruction during in Clement weather I had the opportunity to visit our virtual classrooms at the Skill Center Cleveland High School Jane Adams Middle School and Highland Park Elementary schools during remote learning and I saw lots of learning going on so hats off and congratulations to our Educators for making that happen uh today we'll have progress monitoring and we do this

006monthly and tonight we're going to report on literacy and math uh this progress monitoring keeps us accountable uh but because of no new data is available since the last time we reported out we'll be sharing some of the strategies that we're implementing as part of the teaching and learning and instructional cycle so how we continue to monitor is that we're we we monitor how we're Rel we're doing relative to the state and to our peers and it's really important to know that we are we are making progress uh are we making enough progress not yet but we're we're we put things in place to make sure that our students are getting the the full opportunities from our Educational Service model uh I want to thank the board for uh finalizing our top goals and guard

007rails and these are what's going to be guiding our work for the next 5 years and a good way to describe our goals and guard rails is having a strong start and a strong finish we're talking about second grade literacy sixth grade math and Pathways for being life ready uh my my principles and and team reviewed these yesterday during our engagement session and we're building strong organizational understanding uh we are being intentional about this work in response to some of our uh studies that we had in particularly uh one that was on on governance and so we're really trying to make sure that at the at the top of the organization the board understands then the superintendent and then the the principles and school leaders and then our Educators understand how do these goals manifest

008whether they manifest in cips or they manifest in the classroom we want to make sure that they're active and and effective so uh we want to make sure that we are uh getting ready for this next strategic plan and what we have is uh year zero work and this is the work that we're doing to analyze what are our gaps in Services right now what are our gaps in programs what are our gaps in operations so that when we lead out to this next strategic plan we know what's happening we have a clear understanding we have a clear diagnosis of what our organizational challenges are and one of those areas that we we're looking at is highly capable and so tonight we're going to give our board an update on where we are with providing

009highly capable Services tonight's intended to to mark an honest rendering uh ahead and ahead and we'll have more details coming forward but we really want to give uh some visibility to what the challenges are and what the opportunities are so uh it's important that we have access assurances and adequate support when we're providing highly capable opportunities for our students uh this is Black History Month and really want to take pride in the work that we've done to recognize the struggle and liberation of black people and and celebrate their accomplishments uh we're doing this by sharing with students uh having our students share with adults they inspiring stories passions and the legacies that we are leaving and so it's it's opportunity for us to affirm uh a really important population uh and the the legacy of

010uh African-American people in this country um as we all know there's some federal changes that are happening and we are trying to be responsive and intentional and State true to our values we want to make sure that we serve as a reminder that we're still committed to the ideal and the values of Seattle Public Schools particularly in policy 0010 and policy 0030 it's important that we really kind of affirm that we're still committed to those uh and as we look at our immigration uh our immigrants and our Refugee populations our lgbtqia plus students and particularly our transgender and B non-binary students we have to continue to reaffirm that we are trying to commit to having safe and welcoming environments for those students and so we're going to continue to monitor the impacts of the changes

011at the federal agencies and the department level including the Department of Education and how those may or may not impact Seattle Public Schools so we're going to keep watch on on those developments and we want to try to make sure that we respond accordingly so that concludes my remarks and I want to give it back to you president top thank you so much thank you Dr Jones uh quick housekeeping item we will do a quick break before progress monitoring uh just so oh never mind the students are leaving I was going to say just so board members could chat and and congratulate this the Cleveland students but uh have a good evening um thank you so much for coming this evening uh all right then we will go straight to student board member comments Dr

012or do director ilas yeah doctor hopefully um as student board me Members wanted to uh say students are aware of what is happening around them they see and experience the challenges that affect their peers their schools and their communities the best way for parents faculty teachers and the district to respond is not just by acknowledging these concerns but by actively educating students and providing them with the resources to navigate difficult and unfortunate situations Seattle public school serves a diverse student body including many from marginalized communities who often face unique struggles right now students are not just concerned they are scared they fear for their friends their safety and their future it is our responsibility as a community to Foster an environment where students feel heard protected and empowered addressing these issues requires more than just

013policies it requires open conversations mental health support and proactive measures to ensure all students feel secure in their schools thank you thank you so much director director brg I know I have to follow that uh uh my other comments to that is the fact that we as students are talking about it we do know what's happening and we are there for each other and we do know that our schools are there for us and we appreciate all the work that and all the students I've talked to appreciate all the work that SPS is putting in to ensuring that they understand that safety and legislative session uh many uh on the student uh board member side uh I've personally been keeping up with it all and making sure we get emails out on legislation that the

014uh we are supporting and that SPS is supporting and I think that's it for our comments thank you director brg all right perfect then we are going to move on to board and leaz on reports um and I'm going to start and I'm going to start uh this section of the meeting really always focusing on our board work plan and how we are holding accountable to what we say we're going to do flagging where we may be off um for whatever reason um and making sure that we all have a shared understanding also of what is coming up um so uh directors have been busy uh lifting up key priorities I I will flag director Ranken chair of the ad hoc policy manual Review Committee she may address this further but I'll note that uh

015she her committee is underway uh with its first meeting later this month with updates planned to come to the full board at the close of the year um we're also identifying the governance work needed to support student safety in the ad hoc student Safety Committee and I look forward to hearing from staff on their recommendations in areas where the board can best support this work uh we continue as a board to engage in professional development and we are able to uh click check off some boxes here our governance coaches joined director mizeri Dr Jones Board office staff and me yesterday to learn more about best practices for agenda development uh we also had a chance to uh review our work plan alongside their recommendations for improving our governance practices um looking ahead staff are receiving

016uh training on time use evaluation to support the board here on receiving on our quarterly evaluation um process and it sounds like we may have just scheduled the progress monitoring training and director hery is uh uh coordinating that um on that front from the uh quarterly self-evaluation I've asked staff to assign each board director uh a section of the quarterly evaluation for completion in advance of each evaluation session so please uh be on a lookout for that assignments are coming soon and come prepared so we can have a a fruitful conversation um sort of the next bucket on our work plan is engagement remains a huge Focus we had three uh engagement sessions last month uh which C accum accumulated sorry in the adoption of our new goals and guard rails and I'm super super

017excited for a full board engagement session on February 26th at ba Bailey Gater Elementary School on the budget and legislative session um it will start with sort of a short presentation from staff about budget information most of which was shared with us in Jan with the board in January and then we are going to move to a community discussion we'll see a Cadence of this happening um uh with a engagement session with with board on a month basis uh School visits was also one of the the things uh we did did have some changes to our school visit schedule in January flagging this as something that we did not fully uh get accomplished in in January um but working to get ahead of it and and make sure it's back on the calendar here in

018February uh a final note that today's agenda includes the annual board director and Senior staff ethics disclosure forms riveting reading um so that is the end of my sort of update on on where things are at but I want to go to board committee chairs and liaison for reports director rinken all right uh can you hear me yeah okay uh thank you president top um so I am reporting to you as the legislative liaison um I attached to the information item section of this meeting agenda is um an overview of of legislative activity at the state and federal level over the past month um I provide updates to the board and superintendent on a weekly basis and so what's attached to the meeting is a summary of those you know minus things that are no

019longer relevant as stuff happens very quickly during session um but you can find in that a um Bill comparison on some bills in the house for special education three different bills you can find um links to uh some other information including um uh some some stuff at the federal level um that we've talked about here already also there's a link to our superintendent procedure for um engagement or or boundaries around uh protecting immigrant students in our schools and some other things um something I wanted wanted to note uh as we react and respond to the the uh I don't know what to call it the the swirl the fire hose of things coming at the federal level um we will not be unaffected of course but it's important to note that executive orders don't apply

020to us we are we operate at under the authority of the state and our state Governor attorney general OSI have been really clear about um maintaining and upholding our state law and so until we hear differently we're still committed to and part of our state's government we authorized to operate a public school district by the state um so just yeah so there's more about that there um I was in Olympia yesterday for the uh Senate Ways and Means committee Ways and Means is the Senate committee that determines where the money what their recommendations on spending um goes and so the the big three um as many as uh we're all uniting around for public schools um in terms of our funding deficits across the state special education transportation and MSO which is materials and supplies

021there was a hearing yesterday in the Senate Ways and Means Committee about those issues the big bills on those issues and and um it was actually surprisingly sparse in the room and uh I plan to continue showing up even if I'm not speaking and invite my colleagues and any members of the community to join even if you don't testify it does send a message to our legislators that these high priority things that we really care about when they can see people showing up for it it is a Trek to get down there but it also shows the you know putting in the effort to get down there shows how much of a priority it is um what I was really pleased to hear in testimony on these bills was how much we learned from our

022Effectiveness and uniting around common messages two years ago for special education and and yes and Dr Jones provided testimony yesterday so but how much we've come aligned around these big three um as a priority we there's also conversation about that our our issue really is the underlying funding formula the prototypical school model and the way in which we fund schools in our state is not Equitable and is not adequate and the focus this session is to say to our legislature right now stop the bleeding Help Us close these big gaps and we need to talk about the underlying formulas or we're going to just have to keep coming back and back and back for the same um Band-Aids so uh the asks for special education there are mult multiple different things that um this Statewide

023Coalition has focused on our top priority is focusing on um increasing the tiered multiplier that's the amount of money that's allocated per student with an IEP so if you are talking with folks about this that's that's your number one um talking point is increase the multiplier increase the multiplier increase the multiplier um we also whoops uh that is also something to watch as these various bills move through their committees and into the opposite chamber is how things are adjusted in terms of the multiplier so for example um a Senate Bill 2536 started with um an Ask of or um in the in the in the policy bill was increasing the multiplier to uh 1.5 that's already been reduced to 1.32 so as these bills move bills we like are going to change um so uh

024as things get closer and closer to the finish line and the reality sets in of um what people have what flexibility there is to pay for pay for these things um so watching the multiplier is really key um in uh in in MSO or Material supplies and operating cost again there are multiple bills that do a couple of different things um our ask is increasing the per student allocations to close that gap between the actual operational costs and what the state provides um and specifically the insurance costs and utilities are some of the biggest costs but they're not the whole they're not the whole um bucket and so we really want to make sure that the per student allocations are being increased across all of those eight areas not just those big to um and

025then in transportation school districts need a funding formula that is predictable that is easy to use and that provides the reimbursement to districts based on what it costs to transport students and um and so uh in the immediate we're asking for well we're asking really for an overhaul to the it's called Stars this the trans the allocation reim reporting system that reimburses um and just to make it simpler and clearer and more predictable for districts um yes most exciting update all night so there's a lot going on we're about a third of the way through session things will continue to move quickly continue to change and evolve Advocates if you've gone once written once that's awesome do it again um and keep doing it uh because we have the attention of the legislature right now

026in public education and we want to keep it there uh as director top or president top said our first ad hoc policy committee meeting is um later this month on Monday the 24th we will be starting with an overview of the committee work from 2023 and um doing a training on policy evaluation so um if you if you have been riveted by this update you will want to tune in for that training because it's more of this so yeah but it's exciting work and um really critical and thank you everybody for for um you know staying engaged and supporting our students perfect thank you director rinken and just so flagging one more time if anyone can make just the training on the 24th I think uh it's welcome to all board members the committee meeting

027is open to everyone as well but I think it would be valuable um and thank you director Ranken for all of your hard work in the legislature it is a Sprint and we appreciate it and we appreciate you the continual updates to the board that you provide I I appreciate th those updates from you so thank you for that and I love the this this quote from you we have the attention of the legislature on education and we want to keep it there yes for sure um other board directors all right then we are going to move to the tables for Progress monitoring I will note that we have we're we will be back here at 5 to start public testimony we may we may have to jump back into progress monitoring we may split

028it up but we will start start uh public testimony at 5: all right so to make the most of the short time that we have here at the U we're going to go ahead and get started uh thank you president top when we adopted the progress monitoring calendar at the beginning of this year uh there were a couple of dates that staff notified us that would not have new interim metric data uh the board decided to keep these dates to ensure monthly monitoring and tonight is the first of those two such sessions as noted in the memos staff are bringing forward data on uh additional student assessment tools that are used within our system these tools provide information for teachers to inform uh practice and instruction they are part of the way that our goals

029metrics Cascade through the entire District while this is not our typical progress monitoring session uh it will provide us with a window into how and what happens uh in the boardroom impacts what is happening in the classroom and how we are using data at every level of our system with that I will turn it over to Dr Jones Thank you thank you and recognizing that we probably will have a break in in uh by 5:00 we'll we'll go as far as we can and U all of us were teachers before so we can adjust um so good evening and as part of our regular board meeting uh I'd like to transition to progress monitoring discussion so we can outline tonight's discussion around goals uh our third grade reading goals and our seventh grade math goals

030this is our seventh formal opportunity to review student outcomes in these two areas using this formal progress monitoring framework I'm joined tonight by uh colleagues from our office of academics Dr M Mike stoski assistant superintendent of academics and Dr Caleb Perkins executive director of college career Readiness uh so during tonight's presentation I'll begin by summarizing our theory of action for both goals before recapping the data shared in previous memos from this year's uh from this school year including fall map uh I will then conclude by discussing the curriculum embedded assessments work that our schools have been engaged in and the steps that our team is taking in response to that um so uh if we can go to slide two and we're going to start the conversation talking about thir third grade reading uh as

031a as a reminder the Topline metric for third grade reading has been based on the percentage of black boys and students of color who achieve Ela English language arts proficiency uh on or higher in the third grade uh harder balance assessment so this inter these interim measures are based on third grade map and second grade spring map um the Topline goal for the seventh grade math has been uh based on the percentage of black boys and teens and students of color who achieve proficiency or higher on the seventh grade Smarter Balance assessment the interims for our math goal include seventh grade fall map and sixth grade spring map testing uh given that no inter no new interim or Topline data are available at this time the focus of tonight's session will be spent on quickly

032summarizing the key findings from both the Topline data shared in October and the most recent interim data in December starting with third grade reading before we discussed several important uh and we'll discuss several important implementation updates and that's going to be particularly the work that we're doing to help students achieve uh the set goals through curriculum embedded assessments so you all received the memos last week and as a result I'm going to proceed with outlining our theory of action for helping students achieve grade level Proficiency in reading and math and then if we have time we'll we'll go go on to start talking about curriculum embedded assessments so uh next slide please working from uh from backwards to the left our theory of action for achiev aing our academic goals start with ensuring more teachers

033deliver high quality standards align culturally responsive instruction uh the teachers will be able to do that when they're given ongoing job embedded professional learning and support grounded in student data and research-based instructional practices ongoing professional learning and support is in turn enabled by our District's investment in a number of areas includ including high quality curriculum and assessments including curriculum embedded assessments and instructional coaching those investments in turn are en enable our student our systems leadership ability to align the central office's work across departments to enable systemwide continuous Improvement so I think that might be a good stopping point and and we can go on to we we'll start back with talking about curriculum embedded assessments is that is that okay director hery okay so we'll we'll go on back up for testimony and then we'll

034you have six more minutes is this we or we can't start we can't start public testimony till 5 all right well let's go on to the next slide then thank you so uh a key lever for achieving instructional excellence and aligning our system for continuous Improvement is the implementation of curriculum embedded assessments looking at this uh curriculum embedded uh assessment system systemwide gives us an opportunity to have common assessment Windows to ensure everyone across the district is looking at the same data at the same time and using that information to inform ongoing cycles of instructional improve Improvement as you see depicted here on the screen so next slide please so we have assessment types um curriculum embedded next slide please curriculum embedded assessments are situated within an assessment framework that includes both standardized assessments like

035Smarter Balance assessment and map which which ALS which provide highly reliable data for systemwide accountability and board reporting this also has uh shorter cycle teacher administrated administrated assessments such as Dibbles and curriculum bettered assessments that help schools and teachers monitor progress to inform their instruction so standards uh we have uh annual assessments uh quarterly assessments and then we have the shorter cycle assessments uh next slide please we'll now turn our attention to the uh third grade reading goal and we'll take this opportunity to summarize information from the last two reporting windows before we share the work that we've done to respond to the data that we shared in December for the SBA data our our Topline goal is strongly strongly suggestive that our literacy strategies are working both systemwide and for students at our targeted

036schools however our fall map data projects that our scores for African-American male students and students of color will be lower in the spring than in years past in response we're taking steps to close those gaps and help students catch catch back up and are excited to share with you how we're doing that through corre curriculum embedded assessments and other initiatives so uh slide 8 please so uh let's recall the Topline SBA data that we reviewed in October one of the key takeaways from that review was that SPS has been outperforming Washington state from the start of the pandemic until now and that Trend accelerated in the past year reading rates declined uh Less in SPS and have been improving f faster than other districts after returning from remote instruction this is true for both African-American

037male students and all students in 2019 SPS outperformed the state by 10% now we outperformed the state by 15% similarly when we look to compare our own schools to one another we saw that our targeted Target schools were achieving bigger gains for African-American males and students of color we are excited to begin applying these Lessons Learned in targeted schools in our next strategic plan uh I think this might be a good place to to break and we'll come back we will head back up to the Das I really appreciate board directors being flexible and and taking a brain break as we move to public testimony because folks are here um and excited to hear from them all right we are now going to be moving to public testimony uh board procedure 1430 BP provides our

038rules for Testimony the board expects the same standard of Civility for those participating in public comment as the board expects of itself as uh board president I have the right and will interrupt any speaker who fails to observe the standard of Civility required by our procedure a speaker who refuses or fails to comply with the these guidelines or who otherwise substantially disrupts the orderly operation of this meeting may be asked to leave um I'm now going to pass it to staff to summarize a few additional points and then read off the testimony speakers thank you president top the board will take testimony today from those on the testimony list and we'll go to the waiting list if we are missing speakers please wait until called to approach the podium or unmute and only one person

039may speak at a time the board's procedure provides that most of your time should be spent on the topic you signed up to speak to speakers may see their time to another person but this must be done when the listed speaker is called time isn't restarted and the total time remains 2 minutes the timer at the podium will indicate the time remaining for speakers here in person when the light is red and a beep sounds it means that your time has already been exhausted and the next speaker will be called for those joining by phone the beep will be the indication that the time has been exhausted moving um I also one more note we do have um a Spanish a language interpreter joining with us today if they're in the room at this point

040do we have our interpreter in the room yet I believe they will be joining us shortly um for uh moving into our list now for those joining by phone please press star 6 to unmute on the conference line and for everyone please do reintroduce yourself when called as I will Mis um pronounce some names as we move through the list the first Speaker today is Arthur nesmon who will be followed by Jessica Chong and then Brent [Music] Wares hello my name is Arthur and I'm I've been part of cascadia's HC program since 2022 I remember being so bored in my old school that I felt like I was wasting my time every day once I joined the HC cohort everything changed School became exciting and I loved learning again my little brother Dimitri worked incredibly

041hard so he could have the same experience he scored in the top 1% nationally in both math and reading but just when he qualified they started phasing out the HC program it feels really unfair that he won't get the same chance I had I know firsthand how frustrating it is to sit in a class where you're not challenged nobody should go should have to go through that I'm asking you to please pause sunsetting the HC program at Cascadia until there's a real equivalent option at our neighborhood schools Demitri and every kid who works that hard deserves the same opportunity I've been lucky enough to have thank you next is Jessica Chong hi I have a first grader at Bryant Elementary and I'm begging the board to pause closure of ACCC schools until SPS can prove

042that equivalent enrichment acceleration programs exist at every neighborhood School SPS defines High cap students as those showing knowledge two or more years above grade level in decades of research show that most highcap students need both Accel enrichment and acceleration to thrive denying them access to material above grade level is denying them the opportunity to learn and to develop academic grit a few schools like mine Bryant have enough funding or parent volunteers to provide one hour of grade level enrichment per week in other words highcap students at a few High resource schools spend 30 school hours a week covering material they already knew two years ago and one hour doing activities that may be a little more interesting but are still not challenging even then many still feel socially isolated because they learn differently than their

043peers this is inequitable and it's not a replacement for the cohort program Bryant is a great school the teachers are amazing but even they told us SPS is math curriculum lacks differentiation and they can only sprinkle in a little grade level enrichment via udl even leveled reading groups only cover grade level material when a highcap student finishes their assignments early they're given a device for screen time for grade level enrichment in a poorly designed app School Administration has told parents that SPS banned acceleration because because despite the re despite the research SPS claims that most high cap students are best taught at grade level only as a result all Accel accelerated services like walk to maath clustered classrooms and even cross classroom clusters are banned across the district because they provide acceleration above grade level

044if cohort schools stop enrolling new classes SPS has no alternative for educating highcap students this is why 42% of current SPS families are considering leaving SPS due to high cap service changes when we need to grow enrollment the thousands of SPS highcap students bring in the same amount of State funding for basic education as their peers and Washington state law defines that as acceleration and enrichment for highcap if SPS does not suspend closure it will be failing its duty to provide a basic education for this year's students and classes to come the next speaker is Brent Wes Brent Wes after Brent will be toao fan and then Lillian Adams I seed my time to Leanne Thompson good afternoon my name is is Leanne Thompson under Washington law SPS is mandated to provide access to accelerated

045learning and enhanced instruction for highly capable students by sunsetting the HCC program before implementing neighborhood School Services SPS is harming all of our students SPS claims that these services are being provided in neighborhood schools but that is false for example I have a sixth grader who's highly capable and he is not receiving any accelerated learning because the district implemented a policy that access to advanced math is restricted to students who came from a pathway Elementary School all other highly capable students are now placed in general educated education classrooms receiving no accelerated learning and no enhanced instruction after reaching out to Senator Peterson for help on this topic I did receive an email from someone at the district acknowledging SPSS legal obligation to provide these services and in that email he stated and I quote we

046are currently planning to implement these services in students home schools in other words these Services have not been implemented and these students are not receiving their basic education I followed up asking for a timeline of when these Services would be implemented and what resources will be given to our wonderful administrators and teachers who will Pro provide these Services I was faced with radio silence until SPS has a real working alternative that is both pedagogically sound and and in line with our state legislator's intentions for highly capable students SPS is failing all of our students thank you the next speaker is [Applause] tan hello members of the board my name is Talan and I'm the proud parent of a third grader at Cascadia Carter and two little ones who plan who we plan to be part

047of SPS I'm also a lifelong SPS student I grew up as an immigrant the child of parents who didn't speak English and I know firsthand what it means to rely on public schools to provide opportunities Beyond My Home Troy schools and programs like International balette changed the tra trajectory of my education giving me access to a learning environment that met me where I was I returned to Seattle with my own children believing in SPS but now I find myself standing here disheartened because the that vision of public education the one that lifts all children by meeting their diverse needs is fading I know this board has long been against a highly capable cohort and I understand the concerns but what I don't understand is why are we choosing to dismantle highly capable before we built

048the infrastructure to replace it why are we rushing to close a door without making sure another one is open what's being done in the name of equity is actually pulling the rug from under our children Carter a first generation biracial Vietnamese American struggled at his neighborhood school because his academic needs weren't met I asked how he could be challenged at three different schools and he attended and multiple teachers across those schools told me we don't have the bandwidth this is not this is a tra tragedy not just for students but who deserve to be met at their level but for teachers who are already stretched so thin and it leaves me wondering is the board truly listening to these teachers and parents or are they turning a blind eye we have seen this story unfold

049in other districts when programs like this are removed without a functioning alternative families leave the district because they feel forced to I'm here not to fight an impossible battle I understand the larger decision may have already been made um but I'm asking you to pause give SPS the time to prove that an alternative model can work thank you the next speaker is Lillian Adams after Lillian Adams will be Annie Ki and then Lily Styers good evening my name is Lillian Adams and I'm an eighth grader at Madison Middle School I'm here tonight to speak to you about the necessity of libraries and their Librarians in public schools I'll begin by asking what is a library the definition given by dictionary would be a building or room containing collections of books periodicals and sometimes films and

050recorded music for people to read borrow or refer to though that sounds quite boring doesn't it add I have found over the years libraries are so much more than simply a room that holds books for public usage they allow us to step into the world of opportunities that differ from ours they offer insight to the complexities of others lives and experiences however embedded within the definition that I shared previously libraries cannot live up to their full potential without the people who bring the space to life Librarians are the glue that holds the binds of the books together the blood that works to keep the library's heart pumping day in and day out as my time as a middle schooler comes to a close I can say one thing for certain I may not have made

051it through without the presence of my school's beloved library and librarian throughout the hardest points of my time in Middle School My Librarian and the library have always given me a place where I feel like I belong she's not only Madison Middle School's librarian she's a mentor she's a counselor My Librarian Is the one person in the building that knows everyone's name I can't begin to imagine what school would be like every day without the radiating joy that our library Ms to every passer by as Albert Einstein once said the only thing that you absolutely have to know is the location of the library it would be absolutely devastating for Seattle Public Schools to lose their library and Librarians before we go to our next speaker I'm going to invite our interpreter to uh the

052podium real quickly just to introduce themselves for anyone who may be here in person who has requested Spanish language interpretation um so our interpreter can um flag that they're here and then I know we also had somebody who was joining by phone requesting interpretation hi uh Wilson Jones can we also get the screen up here uh turned on so we can see so sorry go ahead my name is hyro Wayman I'm going to be interpreting uh t for Spanish and do you want to make the announcement in Spanish real quick too thank you the next speaker is Annie kegi good afternoon um thanks for the opportunity to leave work early today and speak with you um my name is is Annie and I have a third grader at Cascadia Elementary Alder has a creative curious

053exciting and sometimes seemingly Sleepless brain his interest in learning new things is Full Throttle from early morning until he closes his book or math activity books it lights out he was too nervous to be here today so I'm speaking on his behalf his beautiful active brain is also an anxious one and one prone to depression and sensory overload even at an early age we've started to see this he's been incred L fortunate that Cascadia the community of Cascadia has been there for the last 3 years to support him not only has the school from grade one helped him thrive in his neurodiversity the teachers and staff have celebrated who he is and his thirst for learning with academic challenge cultural learning opportunities and mental health counseling ever since um alter's Seattle preschool program teacher sent

054him home with chapter books at age four to read to himself I knew I had an important job ahead to keep him engaged and interested his kindergarten teacher superhero Miss Fuller who's now my daughter's kindergarten teacher at Olympic Hills recommended that we consider HC services for Alder at Cascadia at for first grade um in order to meet his behavioral neurological and learning needs I acknowledge the equity gaps in accessing highly capable services and I completely understand the district's goals um to provide go uh services in neighborhood schools I fully support that goal and agree with the equity goals however we have not seen this implemented in the local school um and there are other kids that as others mentioned are considering leaving the district looking at Shoreline um or possibly even moving to Cascadia for

055those who are in third to fifth so I ask that you consider keeping important Learning and Development opportunities open to Young Learners please enroll a second grade class next year at Cascadia thank you the next speaker is Lily Styers Lily sters hi I'm Lily Styers a sixth grader from Madison Middle School when I saw the Madison Middle School library for the first time my jaw dropped there were so many books and so many great reading spaces now I go to the library every day it's one of my favorite places in the whole school and for many other students as as well a full-time librarian provides a safe and open space for all students to go to whenever they need it the lunchroom and classrooms can be a very chaotic space I get over stimulated sometimes

056especially at lunch where it is too loud when this happens I know I can go to the library where it is calm and quiet this is why the library is so important to and everyone has a quiet and calm space where they can go to learn at any time if the library is closed where do we go another thing School classes give you the basic math science history but the library gives you different perspectives the books there teach you about the bigger world and not just numbers and formulas through the books I've read in our library I have learned about wars what it's like to be in someone else's situation that is very different from my own and the mistakes that people have made and that we can all learn from cutting the library to

057half time is cutting my education because the library is always open I have read more books this year than ever reading has improved my vocabulary my writing my comprehension of text and my spelling My Librarian is also a very great librarian we have book talks where we can talk about our favorite books and get other interested in books it is a place where we can share ideas make friends and grow as kids hear me out as just a student who wants a good school experience it is very important that everyone has a space to go to Anytime and that space in our school is the library thank you for your [Applause] time NE the next speaker is Leia zenab Al [Music] jaad um libraries have had a huge impact on my life during Ramadan I

058have been able to go to the library during lunch because no one wants to be around that much food when you can't eat I've made friends by talking about books and found a community in our book club but the library isn't just a place to read when we need replacement laptops we go to the library because the tech people are only at my school 4 days a week for 3 hours each we have yarn for knitting and crocheting and art and beating on certain days there are board games and Legos and so many community building activities La teachers hold classes in the library and so many people look forward to them currently we have an event called blind date with a book and I've tried books that I've never thought I would ever read personally

059I read books super fast I'm in the library as many days as I can before school if I couldn't go to the library I wouldn't have enough books to read but everyone should have access to books knowledge is power and schools are meant to help us succeed librar should stay open because they're a fundamental uh part of our education the next speaker is Chris jackins Chris jackins will be followed by Dr Elizabeth Ramirez aola and after that we will have Hans Kell my name is Chris jackins Box 84063 Seattle 98124 on the Personnel report under separations the report lists executive director of coordinated school health Pat sander I wish to thank Miss sander for her service to the district and many roles over a number of decades on the approval of the Kimble Elementary project

060settlement agreement to pay $1.5 million to Cornerstone General Contractors two points number one putting this item in the consent agenda without discussion does not give a proper public accounting of what is going on number two it seems likely that there were other District legal costs associated with producing the settlement which are not referenced in the report please vote no on the $13.4 million Phoenix contract related to sap Cloud enterprise resource planning can the contract be cancelled if breaches of employee and other data occur related to the system as has recently occurred on other District computer systems on my opposition to proposition two the be6 capital levy on the February 11th ballot Four Points number one I oppose school closures and prop two Mega siize schools mean more school closures number two the Seattle Times editorial

061board raised serious doubts about prop two number three three parents wrote an opad in the Seattle Times opposing prop to raising issues including that it would be better to spread out Capital Levy money for maintenance at many more schools number four the district should keep these concerns in mind I would suggest after the rest of public testimony it's been great stuff all of you are great uh that you take a break and sit down and chat with these people that are right here I've heard a lot of them before you need to just settle some of this stuff thank you very much next speaker is Dr Elizabeth Ramirez arella hello I am Dr Elizabeth Ramirez arola a parent of a middle schooler attending sixth grade at exin midal school I am here today to discuss

062Multicultural communities experiences engaging with our school system and the impact on Student Success communities of color have been historically underserved and disenfranchised particularly those with language barriers students of scholar graduate at lower at lower percentages compared to their white peers many college students are prepared to Su are not prepared to succeed in the more demanding college courses and I know this because I am a college professor in addition students of color are under represented in highly capable as shown in today's um highly capable update it is worth acknowledging that two of the priorities of the current Strate strategic plan are highly quality instruction and learning experiences inclusive and authentic engagement however materials of the recent enrollment study presentation show the number one motivator for families to leave the district is concerned about the quality of

063Education this is directly connected to the district's leadership leadership ability to produ towards meeting school board board goals our Pro our proposed exploration one prop proposed exploration area is why students of color live at at a higher rate this is directly connected to the schools district uh engages with community of color therefore I urge the school board as our elected officials and Community representatives to um to discuss publicly and openly the superintendent contract extens extension before your vote whether the Strategic plan goals or guard guard rails have been honored and what the path for for our district it is you owe that to the school communities and to the students thank you the next speaker is Hans Kell after Hans will be Julie SN Schneider and then stael I'm Hans kale a parent at Bryant

064and exin and a proud Alum of Washington Middle School thank you for finally launching highly capable Universal screening but while this opens an important door towards Equity the benefits of highcap are being removed shutting the door to advancement at SPS sunsets highcap cohort schools the new highcap service model for bids above grade level instruction for all future students while Universal screening will lead to more diverse representative highcap identification those identified won't receive the same educational benefits their privileged predecessors have received for years they'll finally be let in but High cap will be a label with little educational benefit or programming beyond what would be received were they not identified at all these beneficiaries of universal screening will be right to wonder what's the point of being screened we all deserve an answer to that question

065in SPSS new highcap approach even when students demonstrate clear Mastery of grade level content teachers are stopped from accelerating Beyond it because what SPS calls accelerated learning excludes and forbids above grade level instruction so even excellent teachers at well-run schools like Bryant can't challenge kids that way this isn't just happening to my child at Bryant it's districtwide only cohort schools allow above grade level instruction it's why families are so desperate to keep them this change hurts those furthest from educational Justice I'm the child of an immigrant mom and a dad who never graduated high school I entered SPS as 1980s version of highcap then udub at age 13 that wouldn't have happened Sav for access to above grade level instruction at SPS removing that access only harms kids without Alternatives my family had few Alternatives

066when I was in SPS but my kids have plenty now because of the SPs education I received your s survey shows 42% of all students are considering leaving SPS due to the changes High cap this is a preventable own goal Dr Jones I believe you also received above grade level instruction from SPS I implore you don't shut the door behind you Universal screening opens doors don't close them by sunsetting cohort schools unless neighborhood schools can provide above grade level instruction thank you the next speaker is Julie Schneider good afternoon my name is Julie Schneider and I'm an SPS parent of three kids I'm here today with the Seattle student options Coalition a growing group of parents from across the city who are concerned that the district is mismanaging student enrollment to the detriment of option

067schools and the entire system in December parents in our Coalition filed a formal complaint to the SPs on buds person about concerns with enrollment practices for this school year the district responded without any substantive action to our concern conerns our complaint and the district's responses are on our website Seattle student options.org open enrollment is meant to give an opportunity for children to attend a public school that can effectively meet their needs unfortunately the district's current processes contributes to enrollment loss worsening the budget deficit to strengthen the entire SS system the district must focus on enrolling students who want to enroll instead families have been turned away from SPS due to lack of option School enrollment for this school year the district did not assign more than 800 Elementary and K students to the school of

068their choice despite the fact that these schools had room to accommodate many more students further these schools appear to have been intentionally under enrolled when compared with the district's purple book and building capacity I personally was in touch with 27 weight Ed families this summer some had children who were not enrolled at their school their choice School even when an older sibling was already there others opted for homeschooling or private school because weeks and months of not knowing if a spot would be offered was too stressful for the family the district's current approach to enrollment is misguided shortsighted and unacceptable all children who want to attend SPS should be enrolled this is your job to work on behalf of all children who have a right to access Public Schools the next speaker is stasa Bell

069after stacea will be Alex nesmon and then Matt sesman my name is stacea Bell and I seed my time to SPS parent Michelle whan hello I took I took the time to research each of you and you're all wonderfully accomplished and well educated each of you has worked very hard to get where you are today and in your path to this place here is a unifying experience you share not just with the people in the room but also everyone outside you went to the library from childhood on the library was there for you but a library alone is like a bunch of raw ingredients sure you can do some things on your own but at it is Librarians who help you turn those ingredients into a meal a meal that can feed you for the

070rest of your life I encourage the board to not approve a budget that cuts Librarians because of the harm it will do to our students it also goes directly against your 2025 2030 proposed guard rails number one and five which relate to access to high quality educational opportunities and the allocation of resources matching student need how can we start the year knowing you've crashed through two of the five protective barriers to cut Librarians amounts to $2.7 million it may seem like a lot but that amounts to just2 one six of the budget not even a quarter of 1% yet in that point 216 part of the budget Librarians add value to every aspect of student life with educational resources teacher support Community connections life skills and giving kids a place to belong and feel safe

071which we need now more than ever choosing a budget that doesn't cut Librarians means as my child who fiercely loves her Madison Middle School librar said it best you're keeping such a big thing for such a little amount thank you next is Alex [Applause] nesmon hello I'm Alex n speaking for my sons Arthur 9 Dimitri 7 Arthur was bored in miserable at our neighborhood school until Cascadia HC reignited his passion for learning when we realized that Dimitri would have similar struggles in the neighborhood school we gave him a path to HT work hard and so he did he scored 99th percentile on both math and reading and was excited to join his brother the following year then last spring I found out that first grade of HC won't exist in Cascadia this was a shock

072I was relieved due to a promise that local neighborhood schools would fill the Gap by having their own H equivalent programs but the more talked to parents called hotlines and talked to various teachers the mor became apparent that no one really knew what AC at his school would look like the best answer received was that each class would have a dedicated corner with a table where Advanced material would be and so kids could come over and help themselves if they choose to this was very unsatisfactory and by no means Cascadia HC equivalent so I decided to put anecdotes aside and go to the source go talk to the principal from here I finally got got a reliable realistic answer HC program would be implemented in the form of a student can ask their stud their

073teacher to take extra homework home if they choose to does that sound H equivalent no of course it doesn't in an America who's not from a us one thing I deeply admire here is the principle that promises come with accountability Dimitri feels left down after all his hard work and he's not alone many kids are missing out on the challenging fulfilling education they were told that they would receive I respectfully ask you to please Sunset pause the sunset of the HC program at Cascadia until you genuinely Implement comparable Advanced learning opportunities in our neighborhood schools please don't let these children aspirations and hard work go unfulfilled thank you next is Matt sesman after Matt will be Stephanie Gro goian and then Jen Elliot Blake I'm a parent of two children my son currently thriving at

074Cascadia and my daughter a kindergartener already reading chapter books and doing second grade math she may be denied the same opportunity due to the sunsetting of the HCC program I'm not just speaking for my family I represent the majority of parents who believe in educational opportunities and appropriate academic challenges for all students we will no longer be silent the enrollment study shows 58% of current SPS families have considered leaving the district over concerns about educational quality parents want and expect that they their children will be challenged appropriately what strikes me most is the disconnect between what's working and what's being dismantled Cascadia exceeded enrollment projections this year by over 120 students the school has become increasingly diverse with the major majority of students now being children of color this is a success story of equity

075and Excellence that we should be building upon not ending I heard you Dr Jones acknowledge the major gaps in implementing HC services at neighborhood schools yet instead of addressing these gaps first we're rushing to Sunset a program that's serving our community well as I watch my daughter's hunger for learning outpace her class this feels like demolishing a bridge before building its replacement the board's mission is to serve all students right by eliminating HCC without a proven alternative in place you're not advancing Equity you're creating a system where only families who can afford private tutoring and enrichment programs will be able to access accelerated learning is that the outcome that you want I respectfully ask you to pause the suns setting of CC until there is a real functional alternative in our neighborhood schools keep Cascadia

076open for grades 2 through five this isn't about my daughter only it's about maintaining a pathway please conclude your remarks okay each of you chose to serve on this board to make a positive difference in children's lives tonight you have the chance right we going to could please do the job you elected to do the next speaker is Stephan the next speaker is Stephanie Goen I see my time to Heather huet hi I just want to start by thanking you all for being here and listening to us and a lot of us are saying kind of the same thing so I'll try to be you know I I think what most of us want is to make sure that we're heard and that so many of us were actually really excited about the neighborhood schools

077and my son story is that he started kindergarten in an SPS neighborhood school with a severe speech impediment and his speech teacher was wonderful and got him to a really functioning student level and we fell in love with our neighborhood school and tried to stay as long as we could but his um he kept acting out and getting more and more bored and frustrated and his big love is math and we said well focus on learning how to read and then you know like you have to qualify if you want to go to a different school and even though it was a difficult decision he decided to leave his friends behind um he's Nur Divergent it was difficult to do um and the first couple months were a little bit of a struggle but he

078went from crying yelling screaming every night saying that he hated school saying that it was boring saying that a waste of time that it was baby math everything I did with the principal and the teachers were trying to help but they were limited they said that there's a ceiling in place you are not allowed to learn above grade level curriculum and it broke his heart but he is at an HC School C School this year sorry I'm tearing up he's happy every day every day is Awesome every day is fantastic and his best friend won't come because his sister is a first grader and she can't go with her brother so they're all staying behind and reyer graduated from his speech therapy but there are so many kids who are highly capable but have IEP

079so they can't leave their schools and I just ask you please think of us think before sunsetting the program because it means so much thanks next is Jen Elliot Blake Jen Elliot [Applause] Blake hello my name is Jen Elliot Blake and I am a parent of two children who are enrolled in Seattle Public Schools my youngest child was granted the opportunity to attend the SP plus preschool program after I advocated for him to receive early evaluation by this school district this year as a kindergartner with an IEP he is thriving in ways that were only made possible through this early intervention and his ability to have access to Unique Education Services I'm grateful this District allowed me as his parent advocate on his behalf on the other hand and in stark contrast my eldest child's

080unique learning needs are being disregarded by this District he has qualified for advanced learning Services since his first opportunity to test into them many years ago this District chose to shutter my 's only reasonable access to an HCC School in West in South Seattle before they before they even had a plan in place to provide Advanced learning services in his neighborhood school he has received little to no Advanced learning support in the past four years at his neighborhood School even despite my attempts as his parent to advocate for these needs my third grader who once had a joy for Learning and was eager and excited to go to school is bored and unchallenged he started being bullied this year and has lost his drive for learning our family doesn't have the financial means to place

081him in private school or to move quotee move to another city as was s suggested by a member of this District's Advanced learning staff this district is currently providing no support funding or training to allow our teachers to support these unique students and is in turn failing and neglecting thousands of children around Seattle I know you will hear from a lot of parents in the north on this issue tonight but I want you to know there are parents like me who reside in west and south Seattle and are just as disappointed and frustrated that this school district is choosing to restrict our children from having access to learning opportunity to allow them to thrive and reach their greatest potential I ask this district and this board please allow me to successfully advocate for The Unique

082learning needs of my oldest child just as I have done for my youngest child allow me to advocate for all of the children in the school district who qualify for and deserve Advanced learning their unique learning needs matter too thank you for your time the next speaker is Gloria Ramirez Gloria Ramirez is she going to be is she going to be on the phone or in person um she had indicated in person do we have Gloria here in the room I believe Gloria is on the phone now gloral you'll need to press star six we do have an interpreter in the room who can provide you instructions as well and we will extend the testimony time to allow for interpretation hello hi my name is Gloria Ramirez I'm a parent of a child here in

083the school uh Sal School District I come here with a respectful petition asking for um for information that is um is available in in beforehand at the right time so it's also in Spanish or in different languages depending on so there's many times where we get this information from other sources like social media but not from the district directly and in our own language and such important matters as programs being shut down and this is institutional racism not to have this information in a timely manner and through the right channels a lot of times our Childs our children are forced to leave schools because they are forced to work uh especially with the high rises of mostly everything uh here in Seattle so therefore we need more more support for our community for this for

084these young kids to to continue in school yeah that's all she has to say thank you very much the next speaker is Jana [Music] Parker hello we can hear you hello we can hear you can go ahead good evening my name is an Parker president of the Seattle special education PTSA I am both an advocate supporting families across the district and a parent of twice exceptional children students who are highly capable and have disabilities I want to address key concerns about information that will be shared in tonight's presentation what highly capable Services exist are few and not equitably accessible the data is incomplete on math and Ela goals and lacking whether students with disabilities were also bip there is no student and family feedback on how things are going according to the slide during the

0852023 2024 school year the district provided direct programming and staff development in Universal Design for Learning and differentiation it is um if this professional development is continuing this school year families are seeing little or um little of it or and and I caness as a parent these practices are not meaningfully and consistently implemented across the district lack of consistent standards for all schools means students are significantly uh have the significantly different experiences that is inequitable it it should not depend on the school for the students to receive the high quality services they need the that includes students um no matter what their needs are special education highly capable multilingual and other one major program problem is the Reliance on each school's cep um it creates for implementation of Highly capable Services it creates District white

086inconsistency and risks non-compliance with the state law for example we don't see any highly capable services available across multiple subjects in some schools the only advanced class is math and that's only in eighth grade for a few schools the district is not meeting its legal obl ation to develop high school and Beyond plan um and align and align them with transition plans parents and students report that I'm going to ask you to conclude your remarks okay I'm just saying that um I'm going to submit the whole testimony in in in writing but I will say that reports are being um parents and students report that they are not aware of high schools and Beyond plans and or the high school andbon plan is developed after the secondary transition plan I will submit the rest of

087my testimony and writing thank you the next speaker is Helen lundell I'm Helen lundell and I seed my time to Christine hi I'm Christine Highlander I'm a psychiatric nurse practitioner and an SPS parent with children in my neighborhood Elementary and Middle School by way of decar today I would like to share with you about the importance of HCC schools as it relates to ps's policy 3420 regarding student behavior and disciplinary responses highly capable and twice exceptional kids are commonly known for their asynchronous brain development meaning their brain formation is often spent on greater cognitive connectivity with relatively delayed social or emotional connectivity these kids don't know that their brains are wired differently but it shows up in the classroom in ways like having a tangental thought to a science question and getting out of their

088seat to start messing with materials that aren't part of the experiment blurting out in class or fidgeting in their seat when they get done with a worksheet while their peers are still working when not in an environment filled with other highly capable Learners they are more likely to experience behavioral issues which you've heard about from other parents and you can see from SPSS own data across the district the proportion of HC kids subject to disciplinary disciplinary action is second only to students with disabilities in any given neighborhood Elementary School the proportion of HC kids who are disciplined is commonly 7 to 20 times higher than the general student body while at HC schools the disciplinary rates are the same as the district's average in middle schools where HC was phased out years ago and the

089district promised other opportunities to support learning the discipline disparity also exists HD kids are more frequently disciplined than their than most other demographic groups at five of the eight middle schools that were never HC pathway schools and the discipline rate of HC kids is notably lower at the middle schools that were previously HCC these numbers are not evidence of unruly students but rather of a district that does not provide enough academic rigor to HC students in neighborhood schools and a district that is not providing training to teachers on how to work with highly capable Learners at a behavioral level I urge you to consider that maintaining the HCC program is part of the foundation of the district 3420 policy regarding effective and engaging instruction and behavior management that are found to behavioral violations thank the

090next speaker is AA Natalia rivo and ARA we do have an Spanish language interpreter with us who will um provide instructions for Testimony good afternoon my name is Natalia um I'm a mother of um of children here in the C School District I I'm thankful and grateful for this opportunity to be listened and I would like you all to um to pay attention to what I'm about to tell you the district hasn't been knowledgeable of people like me that have barriers with language they have made that our participation in decision making mostly to be null especially important decisions that uh definitely affect my community and my family especially um closing down schools um like immersion schools that are risk as well very important decisions that are um taken without having our participation or taking us

091um for for these matters [Music] okay she would like to know if for the upcoming meeting with the superintendent um it will be discussed on how um it is it is dealt with these issues with the with the community that presents language barriers I would really like for them to be honest for them to recognize their mistakes and for us to be able to learn from them as well above everything I would really like for them to um find a way or a solution for us to keep uh communicated and for our community to be also involved in these sort of decisions that are really important especially in these moments that are really difficult for our families and our students as well I am grateful for your attention and have a good day thank you

092the next speaker is Michael Tarantino after Michael will be Manuel Li and then Janice White a decision to close the highly capable cohort would be counterproductive and contrary to SS's goals it's perplexing especially when one considers the positive impacts these cohorts have on our students in these settings students are not only appropriately challenged but also Thrive having previously struggled in neighborhood schools where they felt unsupported and bored the need to preserve HCC might be less acute if in fact neighborhood schools were providing meaningful differentiation and enrichment but they are not consider for example the experience of my friend's first grade child identified as HC who receives a mere 30 minutes of enrichment activities per week at loyal Heights the rest of his time has spent revisiting material he's already mastered leading to a growing dislike

093of school disengagement with his teachers and classmates and disruptive behavior affecting the entire class I do not fault the intentions of the teachers but the truth is that differentiated learning simply is not happening and turning a blind eye to this reality is the opposite of equity and inclusion were it not for HCC my own son a current third grader who started at Cascadia this year would be similarly left behind instead he is thriving he is in a school that is far more diverse than our neighborhood school and is surrounded by kids who share his capabilities and motivations he is pushed in ways that simply were not feasible before and he is learning how to enjoy being challenged when at his neighborhood school he barely had to try why dismantle a program that is working when

094the alternative is so clearly not it's not a problem of capacity quite the opposite with no school closures slated for next year dismantling HCC will leave a gorgeous new building like cascadas woefully underutilized and with a shrinking student body keeping HCC in place makes sense it's good for the students it's good for the schools and it aligns with the board's goals and priorities in the stated alternative differentiation and enrichment either isn't viable or isn't materializing but either way it isn't working our children shouldn't be forced to ride it out in the meantime when the HCC program has worked and can continue to work the next speaker is Manuel sly hello my name is manua s i see my time to student Isaak narango Lopez hello my name is Isaac narah Lopez and I am eighth

095grader at Denny International Middle School I am here to talk to you about the concerns I have for my safety and my classmat safety at school and outside of school first I have to talk about ice there are many students who are not able to focus on their studies because they are afraid of going home and their parents or Guardians won't be there because they've been taken away by Ice they're they are afraid of of this even if their family members are here legally they worry their loved ones could be targeted by ice because of the way they look I've heard stories about kids who go home and their parents aren't there then families get separated and it makes it so hard it makes me shake to think about it last week many students were

096part of the day without immigrants boycott my classmates and I made up posters to put around our schools about the importance of immigrants in our country and our schools we need more education in schools about our rights and what to do if we get in a situation with ice the second thing is keeps is gosh the second thing um I'd like to talk about uh is about Transportation I live right on the edge of the 2 mile range so I don't qualify for a school bus I wouldn't mind walking but my area is not safe because there's always something going on where I live there have been shootings people doing drugs and kids getting jumped this happens when it's dark and in broad daylight it scares me and my family for my safety there is

097a bus that goes right by my house but it won't stop for me and and the other students who live near we need more flexible Transportation so students feel safe going to school and please help us solve this problem thank you the next speaker is Janice White after Janice White will be Aaron comes and if we have both Janice and Aaron today that will be our final speaker hi I'm Janice White I'm the parent of three SPS graduates um with respect to the enrollment study uh there was an Seattle Times article on April 15th 2024 that said that SPS was planning to use its Grant from the state to conduct a survey to help understand why families have opted out or not enrolled their students in SPS I'm puzzled as to why 115 interviews out

098of 1,420 were of adults of current students and only 300 interviews were of adults of former students and only 105 interviews were of adults of students who've never attended SPS and I hope you ask about this um regarding HCC um in 2021 the plan for changing the model of Highly capable Services stated that staff um were working on how twoe or twice exceptional students would served and twoe students as you've heard are students with high cognitive abilities who also have a disability and the plan said that there might be a need for a cohort model for this group of students to be served effectively but since then the community has heard nothing and there's no mention of twoe students in the PowerPoint attached to the agenda for today's presentation I've testified before about this and

099I'm going to continue to do that because I know from painful personal experience the harm that will be done to students fitting this profile if they're not served appropriately my twoe son now a college sophomore was considered dangerous as an elementary student because of his behavior he wasn't allowed to access advanced academics because he's autistic when his academic needs weren't met his behavior resulted in him being restrained being put into isolation running away from school having the police called on him and refusing to attend school for months at a time because of my family's priv privilege we were able to Sue and get him access to the advanced academics he need started in seventh grade and once we did that he never had another behavioral incident not one please don't forget this very vulnerable group

100of students thank you the next speaker is Aaron comes Aaron [Applause] comes hi uh my name is Aaron comes and I am a parent of a second grader at Thorton Creek Elementary I am one of thousands of parents who actively oppose school closures in the fall when our families endured a grueling and prolonged Whiplash as the district moved to close dozens of elementary schools at the time you insisted that the budget deficit was largely due to under enrolled schools and declining enrollment given that it is unconscionable to me that the district was knowingly suppressing enrollment at the same time you've already heard about the impact Advanced learning has on enrollment tonight so I'm going to tell you my school Thorton Creek had about 450 kids enrolled last year in 2024 75 kids tried to enroll

101were weight listed but the district simply never enrolled them Thorton Creek has a building capacity of 650 so there's certainly space available as a result our enrollment dropped this year to 390 that's a decline of about 15% or 60 kids so we became one of those under enrolled schools quote unquote because the District caused us to be under enrolled we also had to cut two full-time staff in October as a result my school unfortunately is not alone more than 800 kids were weight listed and not enrolled in elementary option schools throughout the city despite capacity at each one I volunteer to help lead School tours and several parents this year during tours asked if they should even bother applying to Thorton Creek since so many families didn't get in this year these are families SPF

102cannot afford to lose as you in this state funding follows the student so every student not enrolled in Sp SPS makes our budget deficit worse why on Earth is the district intentionally preventing families from enrolling at the same time you want to close schools because they are under enrolled I need someone to make this make sense rather than closing or shuttering the most desirable Innovative and effective and inclusive programs and turning more students away the district must shift its focus to growing and M and bringing more families in thank you president top that was the 25th speaker for tonight and concludes testimony thank you all I appreciate folks giving their time and their feedback this evening on highly capable services on uh Library Services I know those are the two topics that my inbox right

103now uh sees the most uh emails from and I assume that's similar to other directors here at the dis um but that concludes our public testimony we're going to go back to the table to finish progress monitoring and I'm going to hand it over to Brandon for that back to the youu oh do you want to take a break before Oh okay we set a time I we should probably take five minutes yeah I've heard we need a break so we will reconvene at 6:05 [Music] Hi how are you a very long time it's good to see you how are you doing I know I'm hanging in [Music] is [Music] your way back to the table we greatly appreciate it I know these conversations are just so fun all right I got one I got

104two I got three oh now I'm back to two you were first noted and appreciated good job all right I got four just waiting on director bricks do we have Evan all right all right so uh we are going to pick up where we left off thank you so much uh everybody for the excellent public testimony we sincerely appreciate it I will now hand it over to Dr Jones thank you very much yes so I want to uh take uh an uh opportunity to get to the meat of what we're talking about had a conversation with uh uh president top at the and during the break and so if we can go to slide 11 and talk about uh how curriculum embedded assessments drive a adult Behavior Uh and really dive in right there that

105would be helpful okay so I'm going to ask uh doctors Perkins and stoski to kind of lead through this this is where we're talking about the implementation and why this is so important we've been talking about curriculum embedded assessments and I think there's a piece in here as we talk about uh the administration of this uh that would be interesting to the board so uh Dr Perkins will you uh talk about the how we Implement uh curriculum embedded assessments and why it's why it's important absolutely and I'll invite Dr stoski to enhance what I'm sharing so uh this board was very clear at the December update that they wanted to hear the steps we were taking in response to the data some of the concerns about the fall map data and one of the major

106ways uh there's a number of things in the memo I'll just highlight supporting professional learning communities working with special ed multi lingual staff but the one of the key things we're doing districtwide is this effort to have common curriculum embedded assessments that uh Drive conversations particularly within professional learning communities of teachers to say how do we plan better what do we learn from the data that we're getting um how do we respond in the moment how do we answer the question how are our students doing right now and what are we doing about it if they're not meeting particular standards and so we have settled on common curriculum embedded Assessments in K5 Ela uh as well as in other areas and other um subject areas that I can share but in k5a this has resulted

107in uh district-wide conversations that connect right back to the Strategic plan in terms of driving adult Behavior Uh just yesterday In This Very Room we were having conversations with school leaders on the K5 curriculum embedded assessment data and what steps School leaders could take to support their Educators support their professional learning communities to plan better so that the next set set of lessons and units are effective for students and I'm going to turn to Dr stoski to add to that so if we're looking at what what's the headline um for this memo is around curriculum embedded assessments that we had shared previously is that we've as an entire system did our first phase our first uh implementation of curriculum embedded assessment we're right here in uh the second phase as we're starting to uh ramp

108up into the second uh group of Assessments uh across the district and what this is doing is it's allowing us from the practitioner level and so from the practitioner level I'm talking from the the teacher level back up to central office back up to us in this room uh for our school board so how we're specifically using it right now is number one we're the year one implementation is we're just looking at right now the number the percentage that we're getting back from schools of students in schools who have actually completed the curriculum embedded uh assessments and so in year one right now we're at 80% uh when you compare that to any uh a year one implementation systemic wide that's a pretty remarkable number and you can see it in our uh memo that

109we sent to you specifically around what that compares to the first year that we did Dibbles um and then the first year um that we've done map so we're way ahead where we are in the first year implementation which we are very proud of however where we're uh uh doing this at the practitioner level as Dr Perkins spoke just yesterday we're continuing to have monthly meetings with our principles um about uh the implementation of curriculum embedded assessments just like how when and how do you do them how's it going um what what are the process improvements that we could be doing what are we learning from doing it and that we can apply to the second group that we're uh just about uh ready to start right now um so for us um ideally it's

110to drive instruction tier one instruction for our students our teachers are using this to help inform their plc's or professional learning communities our principles are using it to inform their principal learning networks and our regional executive directors are using that to help have focused conversations about how well are our students doing right now and how do we we know is where we're going where we're not yet um uh at the point of being able to say how well are our students doing right now what we're looking at at us as a system is have we got the uh curriculum embedded assessments completed and entered into our system today Dr Perkins and I uh engage in a a call behind the curtain uh things that most people wouldn't be paying attention to and by behind the

111curtain what I'm talking about is what are the structural movements that our system needs to make in the form of technology and supports um across our multiple uh platforms that we use uh to be able to uh enter in uh these curriculum embedded assessments so we're in phase one phase one is now complete phase two we're we're moving towards um uh the practitioner level of getting into the things that we're specifically focusing on plns or so principal learning networks plc's that's our professional Learning Works networks for teachers and using that to drive our professional development with our principles um on a monthly basis so I think this is a opportunity for us to transition for questions and discussions uh I think this is really around the we wanted to focus on the implementation since we

112didn't have new data I think we heard the desire of the board to just get into uh give us us some information about how we're how this is manifesting in the classroom or in schools so director hery I'm going to leave leave it to you to uh facilitate some Q&A all right um everybody knows the protocol if you have a question please turn up your name tag and I will recognize you uh director Ranken thank you um I'm wondering about the um the 80% if there is any uh any patterns emerging over where it's being implemented and where it's not and if if if you've identified any any barriers or if it's just that it takes time for things to roll out go ahead yeah great question because there's a lot we can get just

113from completion data um one in particular is that some of our schools were struggling with pacing and so they were meant to do these curriculum beded Assessments in a particular way window to show that whether students were reaching standards and getting the opportunity to meet those standards so some of the the not getting to 100% is about the fact that students need more time which begs the question of how do we can help those Educators um cover all the the key standards the second piece is that there are some smaller cases of which students we're finding out students aren't getting full access to standards based instruction which I know is very important to to this board as and as well as the community um and that's also a thing that we've been able to address

114by having this data and another thing to add to that um along with um trying to understand uh why we might not be getting uh 100% uh student absenteeism contributes uh to some of that um but if we're looking at specifically the adult behaviors one of the things that we're doing right now at the secondary level is a brand new curriculum brand new curriculum takes time to be able to uh Implement figure out your timing as a teacher as a professional educator learning the curriculum yourself and the timing at the same time uh is some of the things that we heard back from uh our High School principles about some of the things that they were uh seeing at the building level any additional questions director Rank and Yore please continue thank you um uh

115I this might be a we may not know this because this is the first year but regarding the pacing um I am wondering how we reconcile having I mean curriculum Abed assessment sounds very kind of ominous but it's it's a unit test I remember you know you get to the end of a unit you take the I remember doing that in school um uh the the I guess my concern is that the changes in adult Behavior we don't want are to go towards compliance instead of learning we don't want for classrooms to feel like they have to adhere to this same schedule when their students are going to have very very different needs and there's going to be maybe one classroom where a unit is mastered and everybody's ready to move on and one classroom

116where maybe they realize wow something something was off here and and our my class just isn't ready to to go on to the next thing yet um can you describe a little bit about how that works and that's really a difference between curriculum and instruction and how yeah so I'm going to ask uh Dr stoski and Perkins to kind of finish this but we started uh an assessment calendar that that we wanted to see how all these align with our formative assessments and our uh summative assessments uh and we're starting to see where uh there's overlaps where there's gaps but I think the the piece around kind of the behavioral supports that we're providing I'll let uh Dr stoski and uh Perkins talk about that the the first thing that comes uh to mind about

117what you're uh speaking to is that we're not expecting our Educators on Tuesday to everyone to be in the same lock step um and also recognizing that there are even within uh school buildings and grade levels there people are going to be at different places for different reasons um and that's why we're providing a window and so it's a 3-we window that we're asking uh our Educators to try to to to get into somewhere somehow and from that where that's going to help us inform next year's uh first uh assessments maybe the window needs to be smaller maybe it needs to be moved up uh earlier but listening to our Educators about what's really working in the the uh the day-to-day in maybe it's the windows fine it's just the first time everyone as an

118entire system is trying to work this together so the windows are are our primary uh way of to mitigate that that concern I'll just Chim briefly uh that a theme tonight has been the importance of differentiated instruction so this is absolutely not about lock step uh but one first step in to be able to different differentiate instruction is to understand where your students are which of them are meeting standards which of them are not just to make it a little bit more tangible just to highlight a part of the memo from our math first round of math CA we learned that the students in math 7 were having trouble commun uh Computing unit rates involving fractions and you're probably what's that mean example I ran onethird of a mile in 1 half hour what is

119my rate in miles per hour so we we highlighted in certain classrooms that students weren't getting that other classrooms they were and they were able to to move faster or move Beyond so it is a key to differentiation it is a key to find a way to challenge all students students is to have this data um but no it does not mean lock step thank you do we have any other questions at this time okay seeing none I'll hand it over back to you president top we're going to shuffle back up again to the dis and go into the uh business action items on today's agenda e we have now reached the consent portion of today's agenda may I have a motion for the consent agenda yes I move for the approval of the consent

120agenda second yep um approval of the consent agenda has been moved by director hery and seconded by director Mahi do directors have any items they would like to remove from the consent agenda all right seeing none all those in favor of the consent agenda uh signify by saying I I I I I I I those opposed the consent agenda has passed unanimously all right we will now move to our action item renewal of the superintendent's employment agreement may I have a motion for this item I move that the school board authorize the board president to execute an amendment to the superintendent employment agreement excuse me extending the terms specified in Section 1 to June 30th 2027 a one-year extension of the current term consistent with the provision of SE section one stating that the board

121shall annually vote whether to renew the agreement for a term of up to three years at the start of each year immediate action is in the best interest of the district second this item has been moved by by vice president Briggs and second by director Mahi um I will tee up this item briefly and then move to board discussion uh the superintendent employment agreement approved um October 1st provides that the board shall vote whether to renew the superintendent agreement for a term of up to three years no later than January 15th of each contract year by mutual agreement this was deferred to today's meeting um today's motion extends the the term by one year consistent with this language and Our obligation to vote on renewal if approved I will sign an amendment to the employment

122agreement that extends the term but does not include any other additions um I will now open it up for board discussion I was trying to bring up something to look at on my screen that's not coming up sorry director anen do you want to speak um sure I just I can I've gotten some questions about this and and some puzzlement um about the fact that the the contract was just approved in October and now now here we are so the um the contract that we appr approved um it took us a while to get to a final final agreement and um as the board president at the time I was the design on behalf of the board to do that um the contract used to have this automatic Ro annual rollover that the board had

123to notify the superintendent publicly in September if they intended to nonew in November for a contract that ended in June and in my time as a community member and as a board director that was always very like um confusing and it put the board in a weird place where you have to make a decision about the contract of your singular employee 9 months ahead of when it expired or else it would just renew in per perpetuity so that's that's why there's this this now is in response to that um that the board would a affirmatively vote to extend rather than have to notify non- extension if that makes sense um uh but given for for me personally given as um the current contract was just approved in October um for a time through um June

124of 2026 um I am not comfortable considering an extension at this point um I would prefer that we could consider an again in June or even a year from now and I will be voting now thank you director rinken others director Mahi I think I was one of those uh voices that had initial uh questions about why this was coming up now uh I think my first question was well wait didn't we just do this um uh just the timing seems odd uh but you know given this i' I thought a lot about uh this extension and the timing of it and because it is this is the time when we have have a vote on it um you know the question that I've been asking myself is what gives us the greatest chance of

125meeting the goals that we just passed at the last meeting and to me giving Dr Jones and his team the runway to actually execute those goals and put a plan into place and see it through I think is the is the right move and I think that that will uh give us the greatest opportunity to meet those goals um and I think any turnover or even folks looking a year ahead and seeing potential turnover I think would be very harmful for us Meeting those goals thank you director Mahi others I will just quickly Echo uh what director Mahi said I think we've set some ambitious goals um we have a lot of really difficult things ahead of us a budget deficit um um trying to figure out how best to use our our resources uh

126a strategic plan that needs to align with our newly adopted goals and guard rails and I think uh taking a term from director Mahi providing the runway in order to get those done and to show that you have progress uh and having two years to do that I think is uh will be very impactful for our students and now is not the time for disruption or chaos especially when I'm feeling a lot of disruption and Chaos from the Federal government so um I will I look forward to uh supporting the extension this evening other directors all right then we will have uh Miss Wilson Jones please call the role director hery I director Mahi I director Ranken no director sarju abstain vice president Briggs no director Clark I president top I this motion has passed

127with a vote of four yes to two no and one abstention thank you appreciate that um we are going to now move to the introduction item approval of the Seattle School Board sponsorship for proposed Washington State School Board director's Association positions uh tongue twister um as legislative liaison uh director Ranken has teed up this board action report for us to consider whether there are any positions we wish to propose to the Washington State School uh director's Association um if there are positions we wish to propose based on tonight's discussion uh then the board action report will be updated prior to action in March to include relevant positions and I'm going to hand it over to director Ranken now to introduce this item as the sponsor director Ranken thank you very much um uh so if

128you'll remember back in September this was a little bit of a funky timeline but if you think about it in terms of the calendar year we're at the beginning even though um the fall feels like the beginning for us on the school calendar so um director top and I attended the um wasda or Washington State School director Association um uh General Assembly where uh I as our legislative Le liaison I'm our designated board's voting delegate um every board sends a a voting delegate other people can attend but only one one board um one board member votes uh on behalf of each each board um and we look together at positions that have been submitted by members of the 295 school districts across the state and vote as a body what we as a Statewide organization

129want to support that then becomes the advocacy platform so you can see from our vote in September on adopting different um positions and some that already existed right now uh when I go to Olympia I'm able to um if it's a wasda position say on behalf of the membership of wasda as a wasda member the same way I'm able to say this is a position of Seattle Public Schools um and so it's it's really powerful to have that Statewide voice and to have it voted on membership representing all of our 1.1 million children in Washington state and their communities um together and having the voice of the body behind it so every year districts have the opportunity to submit the positions for consideration that then go to be voted on by membership in September and

130so the window where they accept submissions is between our our March and April board meetings so in order on our schedule of introduction and action we're introducting introducing it tonight and I want to make sure that you all know that this is our opportunity for individual directors to propose positions if you have any that you want us to take so that we can vote on them as a board in March because you can't um the submissions have to be on behalf of the whole board uh individual directors uh can't submit their own position um so we have to take a board vote before it goes into the window so that's why the introduction now doesn't have anything in it um in terms of actual positions if nobody has positions we just would not take action

131on this item I have at least one um that I'm working on in uh has to do with um board governance training um and the legislature so uh the if there are any questions anyone has now we can talk about them now or um as you if you want go and look at the current position catalog and see if there's anything you believe that the state association should have a position on and you can um I can support developing the position if you if you want there's also wasda staff can offer some support and then um uh if we when we come back in March any positions that we have written will be adopted or voted on and if adopted then I'll submit them on our behalf to wasda and they will become part of

132the catalog of positions that are considered by the voting uh delegates again this September that would set the priorities for 2026 does that make sense all right any questions or discussion all right yeah and just let me know if you come up with something that you want to address and student members too take a look let me know we can we can bring um something to together to the board to consider and uh pass along to wda thank you director Rank and I got to uh accompany director Ranken to the general assembly meeting and it was one of the best well run meetings I've been to in a very long time and appreciate all the work you you're doing there tracking all the positions um we are going to now move back to the tables

133I promise for a final time tonight and we'll work on the back and forth on the future agendas for fin time tonight to do enrollment study and highly capable services update so take your microphones we'll meet back there we're going to stay there for the rest of the evening e right directors uh we are joined by strategies 360 for a presentation finding from the recent enrollment study staff can you confirm that uh strategies 360 is [Music] online yep it looks like they are um and so I'm going to pass it over to our guests from strategies 360 for introductions and to begin the presentation good evening this is David Coran senior vice president of research with strategies 360 let me know if I being heard and if we are approved to proceed we can hear

134you and you may proceed wonderful I'm being joined here tonight by Rachel nakanishi who is our vice president of Communications uh working with our education team um and is a former Seattle Public Schools uh staffer herself we are presenting uh data uh in a limited amount of time um but data on our representative study of adults with school AED children in the Seattle public school district meaning Seattle Washington um and so uh we will proceed next slide please so I'm actually going to take a moment on the slide to explain uh what we did with this study and why we did it um starting from what the study was able to produce we very deliberately wanted to understand uh the thoughts opinions and perceptions of families across uh Seattle Washington and specifically we wanted to

135understand how to retain family of current students in addition to which ways we could uh attract back into enrolling uh into Seattle Public Schools families of former students uh that ability to understand where there is commonality of opinion or agreement and where there is Divergence or difference of opinion between those two groups in the smaller squares here led us to interview over a thousand uh adults of school AG children the reason why it is such a large number of interviews specifically 1,420 is because they are representative meaning that we tracked many metrics uh amongst the largest group that largest uh shape there on the bottom half um and then within the smaller shapes and those metrics characteristics were tracked and weighed upon so that 1,420 interviews would be representative of all adults of school aged

136children within Seattle Washington and the same goes for adults of currently enrolled children and adults of formerly enrolled children that process and the size of these smaller shapes are the way they are because 71% uh we calculate with the assistance of uh SP SPS enrollment staff and MIT graduate researchers 71% of adults with school age children in Seattle Washington had their children enrolled in Seattle Public Schools so we are able to report data that is representative of these different shapes and know that is representative even though we may have only talked to 300 interviews in one shape or 1,50 15 interviews in another shape we know that they're representative of the opinions with a margin of error uh taken of all of those individuals despite not talking to all of them the third shape is

137adults of children who have never been enrolled in Seattle public schools and that uh is a necessary byproduct of interviewing all of these groups but that group is so small um then that information is more um directional or descriptive than it is representative of that group so I know there's been some um questions uh very warranted and I hope this uh explanation of the methodology that we conducted um ensuring that these uh groups of adults or caretakers of students are in the correct proportion to each other so that they're representative of all adults of school age children in Seattle and representative within the individual groups answers all questions I will briefly just say um that this survey was uh collecting interviews between I believe October 28th 2024 and December 4th 2024 it was offered through

138uh live uh interviewers calling cell phones landlines SMS text invitations to take the survey and web hosted um and a few other methods too We additionally offer this survey to be taken in English Spanish Cantonese Vietnamese Somali and amaric languages which was then translated after the fact um so we uh took very deliberative steps to meet uh caretakers of students where they prefer and how they prefer to take interviews and discuss these topics next slide please so first um just a brief uh if if we go to the next slide um just a brief um question that we asked as a baseline attitude we asked for the level of satisfaction or dissatisfaction towards Seattle Public Schools amongst these groups um the labels should be read as due to sizing there's fewer words than we would

139like but they should be read as among caretakers of current students among caretakers of former students and among caretakers of students who have never enrolled in Seattle Public Schools the large numbers at the top of each bar represent the total or overall satisfaction or dissatisfaction the numbers within the bars represent um the Nuance of either very satisfied versus somewhat satisfied very dissatisfied would be the darker section somewhat dissatisfied and we can report um that again keeping in mind this is representative data among caretakers of current students there is 86 % overall satisfaction towards Seattle public schools and 133% dissatisfaction overall um among uh caretakers of former students there is 32% overall satisfaction towards Seattle public schools which their children no longer attend and 66% overall dissatisfaction uh and then unsurprisingly among caretakers of never students

140who have never enrolled in Seattle Public Schools the not sure rate is notably higher 25% not sure when asked about their neighborhood schools uh 22% overall satisfaction 53% overall dissatisfaction keeping in mind that the number of interviews in each of these groups is proportional so as to be representative of how much each group makes up of all adults of school AG children as of the Year 2024 in Seattle Washington um the views of uh caretakers of current students that 86 compared overall satisfaction to 133% satisfaction represents roughly 71 or 72% of adults of school aged children in Seattle Washington whereas uh the caretakers of former students um represents a smaller portion uh roughly 21% and the caretakers of students who've never enrolled uh on the furthest right right hand side represents the views of 7%

141of adults of school AED children again those percentages are purposeful so that uh they accurately represent how much each group of caretakers makes up of the overall population of adults of school AED children next slide please now uh that we have an idea of what these labels mean um I'm going to uh describe two types of questions that we asked we uh very specifically either ask questions that had a limited number of answer options such as the previous slide those we would call quantitative questions um those are questions you normally would find in a survey what is unique is in this survey we also were able to ask up to 30 qualitative or open-ended questions which in effect is almost like public comment for a open-ended qualitative question which is the data we're seeing here

142a survey respondent can say as much or as little as detailed or as vague as positive or as negative is they prefer literally anything they either type in as they're uh answering the question if they're taking it online or they say if they're talking to a live interviewer is recorded we then uh review all that data clean it make sure there's no typos uh we use a advanced sentiment analysis tool using machine learning artificial intelligence which creates these categories that you see in front of you here and then we review those categories and labels after the fact so on the front and the back end of using that uh artificial intelligence tool we are doing human review with that being said from here on out I will be notating whether this data represents um qualitative

143questions as we see here where respondents can say whatever they want and it's categorized or whether it is uh representing quantitative questions that have a limited number of answer options what this provides is when we make conclusions we're making them based on multiple types of questions from each of the qualitative and quantitative varieties I just mentioned we therefore are much more confident in our conclusions the first of which is that when asked what caretakers like especially about Seattle public schools and again comparing caretakers of current students to caretakers of former students uh a through line was found that was the most widely shared positive perception was Seattle Public Schools as a place uh in close proximity to one's own home where there was positive socio um emotional engagement with friends with teachers and high high

144quality teachers especially and that it was a positive student experience that's all to say quote unquote a sense of belonging that was the most widely shared positive perception towards Seattle Public Schools among both caretakers of current students and caretakers of former students now if we go to the next slide we see that exact same conclusion borne out by asking uh caretakers of current students to rate each of these factors and the question was for each of the following factors I read please indicate how much of a motivation that reason provides for you for your student to continue attending Seattle Public Schools again this is why it's important that we interviewed both caretakers of current students and caretakers of former students so we could compare the two groups um and what Rises to the top uh

145as the highest percentage saying that's a highly motivating reason to keep my child enrolled is sense of community and belonging close distance or proximity friends high quality teaching and support so we now see this borne out in a quantitative question as the slide before this was a completely open-ended qualitative question if we go to the next slide we will then see in a slightly different uh quantitative format we now are not asking the survey respondents to rate each individual reason but to instead pick the top two pick their two most motivating reason As a caretaker of a current student to keep your student enrolled in Seattle public schools and it is that sense of community and belonging and highly high quality teaching and support for students that rises to the top uh notably uh close

146travel distance and curriculum being taught isn't I would call it a secondary tier um but we now have an idea because these reasons have been tested in a qualitative format in a quantitative format where we were uh asking respondents to rate individually each reason and then a quantitative format where we said okay you can only pick the top two reason reasons that highquality teaching supported students and a sense of community and belonging are the most widely shared positive perceptions that caretakers have towards Seattle public schools that we can be sure of uh next slide please so now on the other side of the coin what is the reasoning or decision making behind caretakers who have chosen to disenroll their students from Seattle Public Schools it's it's a bit broader than caretakers of former students but

147that is who we will largely focus on if we could go to the next slide um I will just pause to say um that our colleagues at uh the enrollment team have conducted um a very thorough um what I would call Big Data analysis of what has been um contributing and I will just describe this in terms of what the slides are that we have provided and are going through compared to what uh this type of Big Data analysis provides um what we are doing is conducting over a thousand interviews that are representative of both adults of schoolage children but those discret groups I mentioned especially caretakers of current and caretakers of former students this study that we strategies 360 have conducted is the why the decision making the reasons the perceptions the public opinion

148what our colleagues at the enrollment uh Team have uh conducted is a very very thorough analysis of the data the what what happened where did it happen at what time did it happen and so that is how these two studies and all of our work complements each other um I will briefly uh pause if there is any um interest in the room to uh have our colleagues describe this or just let me know if I should proceed board directors we have questions but I think the question is do we want this that described in further detail or do we want to proceed and continue on let's continue on and then we'll wait we I think we do have a directors do have questions and I think there's a lot of interest for questions so we'll

149save time at the end for questions yes please uh if we could move to the next slide again um so we are looking at the other side of the coin the most widely shared um either negative p uh perceptions or um critical uh constructive feedback when we asked uh in a qualitative open-ended fashion what uh caretakers disliked about Seattle Public Schools um there was a widely shared concern over the quality of Education um funding class sizes uh overcrowding and you can see those reasons rise to the top amongst both caretakers of current students and caretakers of former students on the right hand side we have a pop out bubble um again keeping in mind this is all qualitative data that is uh categorized uh and then those categories are reviewed by us um what that

15048% bar breaks down into as you can see here this is kind of the um pros and cons effectively of qualitative data you can uh receive any amount of information detail or idea that a survey respondent may have but sometimes it makes it a little messy in terms of categorizing it so if you do have interest in what these overall categories mean this is an example we've provided for an especially large one poor education curriculum and teaching um and we can see how there is when you really start drilling down some more um mixed opinions that are uh more difficult to uh articulate um and a little bit more mixed um but the big and we'll we'll drill into this in further slides the big concern is is quality of Education when it comes to

151negatives or um gaps that uh caretakers would like to see closed uh let's go to the next slide where we ask um in a quantitative uh fashion uh among caretakers of current students what is the uh how would you rate these reasons in terms of con uh strongly considering them as a reason to disenroll all the way over to never considering them as a reason to disenroll and again we see concerns about the quality of Education rising to the top uh 58% of caretakers of current students have either strongly or moderately considered disenrolling their students due to concerns over quality of Education compared to um other factors which are at lower levels of consideration um and again like I said this is why we conducted the survey we did so we could both accurately understand

152the perceptions of caretakers of current families and how best to retain them and then also caretakers of former uh students um and any uh possibility of ATT racting those students back into the system and their families and caretakers next slide please so this is the same data um or excuse me same question but asked of caretakers of former students so we on the last slide looked at caretakers of current students now this is caretakers of students whose families have made the active decision and taken the step to disenroll again quality of Education Rises to the top we ask it a slightly different way since the action has already been made to disenroll but um the uh all of these factors are asked on a scale of did that factor motivate you a great deal motivate

153you somewhat or not motivate you at all in the decision you have taken to disenroll your student um on the right hand side we have this broken down by the actual self-reported year of disenrollment so we can look at the factors and the the self-reported levels of motivation for these factors broken down before covid uh healthare crisis during the covid health care crisis and after the covid health care crisis um with the middle column in red uh noting the exact dates for that um the reason we did this is because it is important to point out the top three High most highly reported reasons that families made the decision to disenroll are always the same quality of Education a sense that a better option was available and concerns over the curriculum being taught that is

154true whether it is before during or after the covid health care crisis the only thing that comes close is is you can see um highlighted in uh purple notations and boxes is uh there is uh concerns over changes to highly capable uh before Co preo that rises up still only to a fourth highest uh Factor um but higher than other points in time and then if we were to combine Co or school closures due to covid and online only classes due to co that would be uh basically tied for second um but quality of education is always number one um regardless of what time the act of dis rolling their student was took place excuse me if we go to the next slide we um asked uh again in a in a slightly different way

155uh among caretakers of former students rather than the previous slide which was rate each individual reason we now are saying choose the top two reasons and the top two reasons um only two selections can be made of why caretakers of former students made the decision to disenroll was concerns over quality of education and the curriculum being taught further down is perception that a better option was available at 28% in changes to highly capable services at 9ine sense of lack of safety at 92 um so we we now can have some confidence in the conclusion whether we are talking about caretakers of current students caretakers of former students whether we're asking the question allow them to say whatever they want to in response or asking the question in a quantitative form with uh predefined uh answer

156options that is more narrow the same reasons rise to the top um and are most widely shared if you go to the next slide um relatedly but slightly different we asked uh caretakers of for or excuse me current students we ask caretakers of current students what do you believe is the most important uh priority for Seattle public school in the near future um this is qualitative uh so they could say whatever they wanted and we would categorize it after the fact improving educational quality is number one within that 43% um that breaks down to 23% mentioning uh a high needing a higher quality of Education uh needing focusing on quality teaching should be priority challenging education 6% bring back highly capable 4% there's a reason I have quotations around bring back um and so on

157and so forth we see how that breaks down um increasing funding at 28% um and we have some more options further down there um so this is all to say on this slide that there are concerns over the quality of education but it is broader more broadly shared and perceived than any one specific uh service program um and that that is something that we recommend uh Seattle Public Schools focuses on um based on this data is is a more broadly shared concern over improving educational quality if we go to the next slide um this is a slide that was uh formulated in conjunction with uh the enrollment staff um basically next steps are areas for exploration um I can briefly just say uh I know they can speak to it better than I can um

158but uh their identified areas for exploration is engagement with early Learners especially focusing on making sure uh the rate of children born in Seattle corresponds as closely as possible to the rate of uh attendance in prek um engagement with the community around curriculum and instruction related to what I just mentioned about concerns about the quality and challenging uh academics needing to be challenging um finding unaccounted for students uh creating a task force um specifically to engage students of color and understand why they're leaving Seattle public schools at higher rates than white students um and then continuing to partner with City agencies to support planning for affordable housing for Seattle families again um the enrollment staff can speak to this with more details specificity um and I believe that is our last slide great we have

159questions and director Mah he's extra prepared his card is already up that yeah thank you David I appreciate the um thorough presentation I have a few questions one um is there uh statistically significant enough data to get disaggregated data based on like racial demographics geography socioeconomics and I would love to see that and also just ask you if you off the top of your head know were there any things that stood out as like areas where there were vastly different um responses or anything that uh stood out uh in those subgroups yeah yes provided more time I could go into uh those slides but I can tell you there actually were very few examples of uh subgroups that had um Divergent opinions um part of the benefit of interviewing um upwards of 1,420 is that

160the margin of error level is relatively low for a poll even within subgroups and we did make sure to um control for and make sure uh that these results were representative geographically uh racially and ethnically um by gender um and by student enrollment status like I said um but like one of the few examples I can say is uh caretakers of former students um of Seattle Public Schools reported that they would never enroll their students at a higher rate if they made over $250,000 a year so like that is one of the very few examples of uh a Divergent opinion um when we looked at the subgroups um when I was describing the um reason why uh families disenroll their students uh regardless of whether it was before during or after covid um in terms

161of their self-reported disenrollment date uh quality of Education was number one among all of those groups regardless of when they disenrolled and for many questions we see the exact same thing whether we break it down by geography race gender so on and so forth but um in the future I'd be happy to go into more detail and with current students I'd also be curious if there's any difference between Elementary age middle school and high school yeah um I I would have to uh look back at the data I know um that the actual uh reported among caretakers of former students the actual reported uh disenrollment uh grade level the time when the decision was made to disenroll um spiked at certain points when uh there was a I believe a a transfer change from uh

162Elementary School to middle school middle school to high school um but I I'd have to go back and look at that data um broken down by specific grade levels perfect thank [Music] you other directors director Briggs um thanks David for the presentation um I I just you know it strikes me that um sorry I'm looking for the slide uh the first slide with the um bars uh that says caretakers of current students have a positive view or overwhelming satisfaction of Seattle Public Schools um just that there's a pretty it feels to me like a pretty big difference between somewhat satisfied and very satisfied um like somewhat satisfied could mean you know like a whoever was was being interviewed had a really great teacher at one point and for that reason they you know felt that

163they could say that they were somewhat satisfied um what do you have any other information that you can provide about what somewhat satisfi like that that just feels like a spectrum I guess and so I'm wondering if you have any insight there yes um I can say that it is a spectrum very purposefully um we ask these questions to be able to report overall data um that 86 to 133% being overall satisfaction versus overall dissatisfaction but we also then ask uh the specific answer options to provide that nuance and I would agree with you that um 51% being somewhat satisfied is probably the biggest takeaway um of that um as it is the largest group and and a majority uh by itself um so uh I I would say with more time um I could

164go into some of the um with more time I could go into the uh qualitative questions uh broken down by that only within that somewhat satisfied group um but uh simply tonight uh I I was only um able to go over the high level uh but yes I I think it's right that you're um focusing on that Nuance director Mahi NOP uh go for it okay um so on slide I don't know the number here okay so you have the slide that shows that the shrinking kindergarten classes is one of the drivers of enrollment decline uh so I'm curious so given that that would indicate to me that the group The Never enrolled group is fairly important and I'm wondering if there is a version of the slide 10 12 and 13 uh that was

165specific to folks who unenrolled is was there a version of that question for people who never enrolled like what was their perception that led them to not enroll yeah I I can speak broadly about um the caretakers of students who've never enrolled um with those groups we did ask both uh quantitative and qualitative questions and having um looked over uh I believe it's almost 8,000 qualitative responses um I can tell you there are higher rates of um families making uh the decision based on parochial or religious reasons higher rates of families making the decision based on political reasons um and then higher rates of families making the decision to never enroll based on concerns over uh challenging um Academia or academics um so it is slightly higher um amongst uh all of those factors are

166more highly reported uh amongst caretakers of students who've never enrolled in the system um but I I I think uh my colleagues on the enrollment team can can speak to the shrinking kindergarten classes is actually likely being motivated or connected to to to different factors um I just was answering that question based on uh the quality of data especially from the caretakers of students never enrolled right okay appreciate it do we want does staff want to respond at all go ahead fce yourself hello so we added that slide is just to have um since we didn't introduce you at the top just introduce yourself hi my name is f Manu and I'm the director of enrollment so we added that slide in this uh presentation just to give you some context that um as we

167see the out migration with um our students who have left we also have continuing shrinking um kindergarten classes because of our birth rates and our birth Decay ratio that um those births don't show up and enroll in kindergarten in fact um at the peak we had 72% of those cohorts coming in um giving us 4500 to 5,000 um kindergartens in those cohorts now we're at 53% the birth rate um Decay so we're looking at 3600 um cohorts of kindergarten so that is our biggest decline um that you see year over-year because of the birth Decay ratio continuing to decline because they're opting for other options or because they're moving out of the city like what's the reason yes all the Y there's multiple choices that they have and including public school so I guess I

168would add and I'm Fred podesta chief operations officer as David noted for um the uh prospective families were going to enroll their concerns mirrored um the same in the currently enrolled and formally enrolled group about um academic rigor and but they had some externalities that don't apply to the other group that they um weren't considering public school because they were interested in a perial school there was also a fairly broad segment that just said they didn't and that we don't have details about that they never considered public school for whatever reason um so but of those that did and chose something comparable I think the dimensions of it were similar to the other two populations so I have a question and I'm struggling to differentiate um slide I'm looking at slide 13 sort of this

169idea of concerns over the quality of education and the idea of curriculum being taught and are are those how how do we differentiate those two those things and are they the same thing or yeah just kind of some understanding there would be helpful and I'm actually looking at the presentation of all of the slides tonight um what is the uh header and red of the slide that you're focusing on caretakers who disenrolled their students from SPS overwhelmingly cited concerns about the quality of education and the curriculum as top reasons okay so I'm uh I'm on the correct slide then uh so for these uh for for the top reasons you're you're asking for more detail on what they meant I I guess it seems like there two are very connected they they are and and

170I will say that um if you look at some of the other slides where there is um basically pop out bubbles or pop out shapes describing how the uh bars break down this being a qualitative or excuse me um this is actually a quantitative question uh so so the way this question was asked um we aren't necessarily able to get that Nuance uh a different slide which has one of the pop out bubbles um would be able to give more nuance and break down what it means within the bars the um advantage of a slide like this where it says top motivating reasons to leave SPS is we force uh the survey respondents to um really congregate and and choose only two options out of a pre-selected list of options so intentionally there's not the

171ability to really impart a lot of nuance or detail um I think one of the other slides uh would have more of what you're looking for um such as the why do people dislike um Seattle Public Schools um back a couple of slides uh among the former students you can see that um pop out bubble describing the uh bar of 48% sting poor education curriculum in teachers and I think that will give more of the detail that you're looking for because the question here uh the slide begins both caretakers and current students and former students um this question was asked in a way where respondents could say literally as much or as little as positive or as negative as detailed or as vague and we capture that sentiment rather than giving a predetermined selection of

172let's say 12 answer options and only allowing them to choose two any other questions from board directors staff does staff have anything to add or anything to add specifically on the uh areas for exploration on the end end slide so I think we definitely um want to focus on early Learners and the um kindergarten enrollment rate um the pattern of um families disenrolling students during the course so their career has stayed um uh very stable in the same study period so um the me mechanics of lower enrollment are we're attracting fewer students not that we're losing that students are disenrolling during their career and then um obviously the kindergarten cohort represents uh you know a bow wave through the whole system since we have a focus on early learning since we have relationships with Early

173Learning that's um we we do want to know more about that group of families that don't ever enroll and that we think that's kind of the connection Point um to see um in Elementary grades in particular uh kindergarten in particular that that would be this is a great kind of landscape analysis to say so you you can't make everything a priority um that's the next step is so um what do we do with this data these data and where do we do it you know what do we focus on all right well thank you so much to strategies 360 for being here this evening um I think we will move into our final update for this evening um staff will provide the status update on highly capable Services something we heard uh strong concern about

174in public testimony in light and in light of our changes to board policy number 2190 this fall um give staff a moment to transition here then I will turn it over to you Dr Jones yes thank you um in the board's revisions to 2190 this fall uh you directed me to bring the information that will be used to develop the highly capable Plan before we bring the final plan for your approval in this update we'll be providing a couple of things one is the information about how we're implementing 2190 and transitioning how we serve students who qualify for highly capable Services second it will be an opportunity for me to hear from you what details will be most helpful to bring you in alignment with the new requirement in 2190 uh I will then come

175back to the board with uh information inform and detail required in 2190 prior to bringing the highly capable plan for approval uh with that I'll pass it on to associate superintendent Tores Morales who uh will bring the expertise and and perspective to uh what we're trying to get done here thank you thank you superintendent Jones and Schoolboard I'm going to give us a highlevel uh progress update on the highly capable plan so next slide please all right so what we're going to do is an overview we're going to start off with a timeline review of the policy uh 2021 or 2190 from the timeline review of when it first passed in 2021 through 2028 and then touch on the update that was done in the fall of 2024 then I'm going to talk through a

176bit of the model descriptions essentially what did the servicing models look like prior to 2021 what did they look like currently and then what is the intended future State based on policy 2190 we're going to also get into a conversation around the number of students served part of the P passage of 2190 back in 2021 involved Universal screening so we're going to provide some data around what that those Trends look like and then we're going to talk a little bit about the financing and then some next steps that are currently in process for the department and the district so next slide please this timeline here just shows a timeline from when the initial policy passage was done to start thinking about doing a neighborhood model versus the cohort model and essentially what this does is

177it provides a bit of a road map of steps of things that were to take place each part of the year as we get into the roll out of the model and move into a neighborhood School model per policy next slide please so policy 2190 in the fall of 2024 there was an update to the policy and essentially it was adding pieces around what Dr Jones was just referencing on bringing a more robust plan forward before the board prior to submitting to Opi finally for the year there is a uh it's almost more like a template that OPI requires us to fill out and submit and they consider that to be the plan and that's how we get our funding from the state and we have to get that done every year through an approval

178of the board what this policy is saying is yes and can you please bring us some more detail around those things versus just the plan that OPI has put forward and so this is our first step in sharing some information with you all and then looking forward to coming back with further information as we progress so next slide please so this slide discusses the model description so the first box here on the left it says model prior to policy 2190 that was passed in 2021 so essentially if there was a child who was found to qualify for highly capable Services it was the Parents Choice to enroll and or access the highly capable services at the cohort school so they were students were essentially sent to cohort schools where curriculum was delivered two grade levels

179above for all students if the option was chosen the screening was not necessarily Universal there was uh staff recommendations that were put into this there was outside testing that people were able to access for these sort of things Etc and essentially at the at the local school there wasn't always service available there were some schools that were doing some accelerated things but it was not universally done and it was only in in certain parts of the city the current model meaning where we're at now based on that timeline involves still having a cohort model where if a child is is qualified for highly capable Services the parents choose do I want my kid to go to their neighborhood school or do I want them to go to the cohort model the cohort model still exists

180as is with ex um instruction at two years ahead it is the same curriculum that we would use in the neighborhood school but at the two years ahead in the neighborhood school what you would see is differentiation and Universal Design for Learning in depth and complexity each School needs to have a CIP to explain how they will deliver those services for those students and they are held accountable to those uh to that CIP additionally in the current model one of the big differences was a universal screening so now at this point every student gets screened regardless and then based based on that that's how you qualify for services so it wasn't necessarily in the previous model where it was based on a referral or um an assessment that was done from outside syes and those

181sort of things so it's Universal screening process so based on the way 2190 which is the the policy is currently written the future would be that all kids would attend their neighborhood school for their HC Services Universal screening continues and each school will continue to refine their CIP and determine how they're going to provide these services to kids and schools next slide please so if we look here this basically is giving us the number of students served um it's just some data to look at if you look at the bar chart on the right what you're going to see is uh right around the 2019 Point you'll see an increase in the number of students that are now qualified for highly capable services that is because I should say in 2021 that is because of

182the universal screening in particularly what you'll notice is the number of students of color that are now being identified as highly capable students has increased as well if you go to the next slide there's a little bit more data in a chart form there we go so if you look uh 2021 forward that's where you'll see some of the big differences so if we just highlight a couple data points if you look for example black African-American students back in 2019 there were about 70 students that were qualified for highly capable Services 2021 was the policy change in the switch to Universal screening we've been doing that for a few years now now fast forward I believe the number says we're at 195 now so it shows that we have 125 more black and African American

183students who are being qualified as students who are highly capable at this point and if you look across some of our other student of color category such as Hispanic and multi-racial you'll see similar Trends and for our Asian students as well so essentially one of the big pushes when the policy change came up was around are we actually identifying all of our students that are really highly capable or is it that it's getting a select group of students in so that was a big push for the district and what we're seeing is that through this process of the universal screening we are identifying more students of color as actually being students who are highly capable as well another data point to just uh talk through quickly is that approximately at this point you know in

184the previous slide we were talking about there's the three different models like what it was where we're at now where we're going and so at this point parents do get to choose to remain in the neighborhood school or attend the cohort school and what our data is showing us is about 38% of H qualified students are choosing to remain in their neighborhood School versus accessing cohort School options next slide go for it yes the director Sergeant can you ask your question in the mic sorry MH I I didn't catch what you said I heard words but I'm not sure I understood 38% can you just restate it yep okay so I'm going to say it and I'll say it in a different way as well so let's say uh I'm just going to say Gatewood

185this isn't the actual numbers for Gatewood but at Gatewood in that attendance area there'll be a certain number of kids that are qualified for highly capable services and a certain percentage of those kids decide to attend Gatewood or or access something else such as an option school or the highly capable model so what this data point is saying is currently 38% of students that are qualified for highly capable services are choosing to access those services in their neighborhood School versus another option school or a cohort school so so a different way of saying it is that the majority of kids are either doing the cohort model or this other thing I mean I'm I'm sorry I I need to I asked him a question and that was a a distractive Interruption did you understand my

186question I I I before we were interrupted 3% stay in their neighborhood school yes what I'm curious about is how many families are interested in the cohort model so if I hear you correctly director Sergeant what you were saying is that another way to say this would be that 62% are accessing either the cohort model or an option school okay so the option school okay that now that the the light bulb is going on MH so if we remove the 38% and we talk about the 62 that's right math right that's right mhm of the 62% how many are interested in the cohort model you see where I'm going with this because we've gotten a lot of testimony about this cohort model and honestly this is like Whiplash Decades of Decades of whiplash for parents

187not having a consistent and reliable model in which they can count on from year to year and so in that 62% maybe you don't have the number but is it the majority of the 62% that are interest Ed in the cohort model and a smaller number are going to option schools or is it the other around is it about 5050 that I don't know in the moment but we'll pull it for you and we'll pull it for sure Al what we'll get you is percent attending neighborhood percent attending cohort percent attending option if that's helpful yeah but the but for the record the vast majority of people are not interested in staying in their neighborhood School if you say 38% choose the neighborhood school that means the majority are not are not choosing the neighborhood

188school at this time continue any okay next slide please so budget and spending essentially when you think about highly capable servicing in the state of Washington it's actually based on student enrollment so it goes off 5% so in general what we see is in Seattle Public Schools receive around $1.7 million annually as we were just discussing in the previous presentation enrollment is fluctuating and so that number does fluctuate just depending on the number of kids that we have enrolled but it is 5% the funding is intended to use for Universal screening the program Administration professional development servicing Etc and we're currently in the process of developing the budget going into 2526 it essentially becomes like a spending plan for the 1.7 million on how we're going to do these things um one of the things

189to noce just a good chunk of the money ends up going into PR program Administration and Universal screening because we do have to screen all of those students and if you think about some of the co the cohort models in general those are not included in the 1.7 million those are done on top of the 1.7 million that we receive next slide please so next steps one more time we need to do an update to 2190 superintendent procedure we are in the process of hiring a new director of advanced learning this is going to be really important for the school district because this person will be someone who's out there engaging with Community around the next steps and what the models need to look like we are going we need to review and refine the

190neighborhood School implantation to determine future States so for example we need to look through what is the professional development implementation and how is it going I think we heard clearly today testimony from many people that what what we're saying and what is happening may not be aligning and so we have an obligation to investigate and interrogate that professional development to see what's happening um appropriate support for schools to support the CIP implementation it is in their cips and they have an obligation to implement it so the question becomes how are we making sure to support them so kids are getting what they need we need to decide on the next steps for the current and upcoming uh school year and the AL budget fully develop Seattle Public Schools multi-tiered systems of support this is related

191to an earlier presentation this evening as well around curricul embedded assessments a lot of that stuff provides the found the foundation for us to get into a multi-tiered system of support which means how do we support our kids when they need it whether it's accelerated learning whether it is intervention whether it is enrichment that Foundation comes through having a functional mtss system districtwide and then I'm going to pause now I think for additional data requests questions thoughts concerns perfect I appreciate that director miseri I know you have to leave do you have any questions before okay okay perfect uh I don't I'm sorry I don't know who did it first director to thech um did you say be oh okay okay um so I yeah um I do think it's really important that we acknowledge

192that um what we're saying is happening in neighborhood schools isn't happening um and I and I can attest to that as as a parent as well um I'm also concerned about um the second to last bullet point here fully developed um fully develop SPS multitiered systems of support which is my understanding with the board um directed SPS to implement mtss in 2011 um and it is now 2025 so 14 years later and we still don't have it um fully implemented and it and it points to a chronic issue I think in this District of um ideas and words on paper and then a failure to implement um and so I the fact that that mtss after 14 years still hasn't been implemented it it you know you can understand why people are really doubtful that

193that we will Implement a successful neighborhood model so I guess I'm just curious what um and I know that was before your time Rocky before my time too so I'm not saying like you know um you bear responsibility for that I it's it's a it's an Institutional problem that we have so I'll I'll address it then Dr Jones if you want to jump in please but there's a couple things one what we know is I would not go to a place of the neighborhood School model is not working we have plenty of evidence points of where it is working what we do know though is it universally working is every single School make it to what we what we would expect I think that's that's that's the question because we do have evidence of some

194schools that are doing it and doing it very well the students are growing very well regardless of if they have IEPs whether they're multilingual whether they're highly capable they're meeting growth goals and exceeding them and so I just want to point that part out but to your point um this is specifically talking about having a functional system districtwide because what we're seeing is very similar that some schools actually have a pretty good mtss but it can't be that some schools have a functional mtss it needs to be that as a parent as a community member you have a guarantee that no matter where your kid goes to school it's going to be a functional mtss system the other thing to consider is when you think about Mobility rates in the city of Seattle and kids

195that move through schools it needs to be that if a kid moves from one school in the city for whatever the reason is to another we're not losing any of their data any of their enrichment plans any of their and so that's what we mean by refining the system and duly noted and and one of the things that we're going to be bringing forward in the near future to the audit committee is um the mtss audit that we had around what are the next steps we need to do in a district to get this done well and so there's a whole corrective action plan that goes with that and a plan and sequence to finally get it to a place where we're not talking about it 15 years from now and it's not done it's

196actually going to be Focus through if you know what I'm saying do you have any followup um yeah I mean I just I I just think at this point the only thing that's going to have an impact or convince anybody is just action you know to see it actually happen MH making it real director Ranken thank you it might be a while and I'm going to try not to cry um so I was a four-year-old kindergartner reading chapter books in Seattle Public Schools and I have had the experience of growing up with a sibling and raising a child that have had major behavioral issues and hate school because it doesn't feel relevant to them and I know they're not alone in this it feels like a pointless waste of time and this is the reason

197that my younger son is now enrolled in the Cascade parent partnership is he literally could not tolerate 6 and a half hours of sitting there feeling like he he actually said this does not feel like a good use of my time to which I'm like you're 12 what else are you going to be doing but but he for him to just be like I can't do this and as a twice exceptional adult whatever we want to say it I feel the same like I am like crawling out of my skin right now because I cannot stand that I am here after being part of this conversation for over a decade listening to the same presentation and having to just rehash what we already know to be true and nothing's changing and it it the conversation

198started with saying you know that the board directed this extra thing in policy it is not extra it's what's in state law so I'm I've been gaset over this for 2 years and I just have to say it out loud so that we can be clear so I can stop being told the opposite of what is in law is what we're supposed to do so in September of 2023 after spending huge chunks of my personal time with my family visiting my brother in Montana on the phone with distraught parents who could not get their kid into a math class that was being offered at their school simply because they didn't attend a cohort School even though they were perfectly capable of doing so I wrote this memo I wrote a math memo and a highly

199capable memo I'm here now instead of with my kids who need me so the people who come come and go to the podium and the people who are here instead of with their families they may come and go they may just become more people but I am here every month for two and a half three more years I mean maybe because this is this is absolutely demoralizing and exhausting to feel like I'm just repeating and treading water and it's not worth the sacrifice that my family has had to make for me to be here to have it be so disregarded so RCW and wac RCW is Revised Code of Washington that is a that is law so RCW has a whole bunch of numbers that's state law whack Washington administrative code is rules associated with

200carrying out the law could kind of think of it as policy and procedure the um no matter what you think about highly capable Services whether it should or shouldn't exist it actually doesn't matter it's in state law the instructional program of basic education provided by each School District shall include implementation of programs for highly capable students under RCW 28a uh 18 5.10 through 28 oh my gosh my reading glasses are up there uh 28 A.1 185. 030 highly capable services are basic education according to our law we are agents of the state It's Our obligation and duty to hold the district account we're elected by our community not to figure out how to do this that's not our job the only qualifications that we have to be up here are being registered to vote where

201we live you know running where we're registered to vote we are not the people we are a part-time governing body the people with phds and six figure salaries should be having this conversation not us so Washington administrative code in association with the state law says uh this is wack 39217 20 District's plans for the highly capable program each district shall submit an annual plan for the district's highly capable program on forms provided by the superintendent of Public Instruction for approval that's an annual vote folks may have been aware of that last year we push it off multiple times because we didn't get actually the plan and it was the very last minute that it was approved so that we didn't lose the funding with the policy update that required we actually see the plan so

202the wack says each district shall submit an annual plan okay then there's another whack board approval the district's plan the plan I just mentioned for students who are highly capable shall be annually approved by formal action of the district's board of directors annual vote to approve the plan substance this is whack 392 17030 is the substance of the of the school district plan and this is what our updates in September were uh made to include is what state Administrative Code requires are components of the plan that the board annually approves a report of the number of K12 students who are highly capable that the district expects to serve by grade level a description of the district's plan to identify students consistent with RCW blah blah that's the one that says yes you have to do

203this um District practices for identifying the most highly capable students must prioritize Equitable identification of low-income students the third requirement of the plan a description of the highly capable program goals and it's not just do the bare minimum of fall state law a description of the services the highly capable program were will offer if we had that description of what the program was offering that would answer a whole lot of questions as to what is it and then is it happening for my kid or not and then what do I do if it's not but we don't even know what the services are we can't even evaluate because we don't have that information a description of the instructional program the highly capable program will provide a description of ongoing professional development for educators of students

204who are highly capable and general education staff a description of how the highly capable program will be evaluated that includes information on how the district's highly capable program goals and student achievement outcomes will be measured a fiscal report and assurance is signed by the district's authorized representative that the district will comply with all applicable statutes and regulations so annually our state Administrative Code says the board in a formal action is supposed to approve a plan that includes all of those things we have never seen that then the end of the year report is that the district submits to the superintendent of Public Instruction at the close of each fiscal year an end of the year report on forms provided the superintend attendant that includes some of the information in the plan we have been asked

205every year to approve the form that goes to Opi we're supposed to approve the plan and then at the end of the year the district sends the form to Opi part of which is affirming that the board has seen and approved the plan and I have been having this conversation with people in this room for two years who keep trying to tell me the op form is the plan so somebody like help me here because what's in the plan and what's now in our policy that I had to fight to get brought to the board is what is in the wasda model policy and is in compliance with state law so no we're not asking for some extra information because we're special extra Seattle before the plan we're saying we need this information annually to

206accept to ensure that our students are being served in accordance with the law and at the end of the year you affirm that to Opi we don't have to do that part we can we could vote twice I guess but our job this is this is our job as the accountability body is to annually review the substance of the annual School District plan and approve it and that is what tells us whether or not students are being served we don't need a presentation on the history of past programs we don't need to talk about how we individually think our what our opinions are of how it should be done we're not in the classroom we're the oversight and so I'm just I'm really upset cuz I I feel gaset I feel like I have been

207run around in circles and told that I'm being unnecessarily picky or whatever and and you know this is what it looks like if I was a kid I would be a chair throwing kid right now because this is what it looks like when you're not seen as your whole self and allowed to just be hey you're you're a whole person you're a whole person and I listen to you and respect you and expect the same from you this is what it looks like when someone has been dismissed and gasset especially as board president and I'm not the president anymore so I don't speak for the board I'm just speaking for myself I would like to know when we're going to get the substance of the school district plan that according to our policy we are

208supposed to get early enough in the year in the school year to know that our students are being served for that year and I do not want to hear anything else about this I want to see the plan that's required I want to give staff an opportunity to respond and then I think it was director brag director sarju and then director hery so there's compliance issues access issues quality issues service issues and consistency issues that we want to make sure that we're we're addressing uh and I hear clearly uh director Rankin's uh desire to have uh Clarity on the date time uh of when the plan will be uh submitted uh my commitment is is in April 1st as the as the date for that for that plan um and so if that's a preview

209of that at the March meeting uh that's we can provide that but the plan should be uh ready by March 1st and and Dr Tores Morales uh if you can confirm that we we're making a a declaration right now yes director BR I agree oh everything just said and my my initial comment when I was just reading this over is you talk a lot about the current model and the uh future policy model but then we've also heard a lot from the testimony that the current model is it like there is that lack of like where what is happening in schools versus what we're being told is supposed to be happening cuz I cannot imagine the transition To The Future model without the current model even working cuz like uh from the student perspective switching

210to new plans and new models when you're in school is going to be painful no matter what there's no like easy thing to do that but like the students currently in there who are experiencing what's currently happening and the transition that's trying to happen and it not working is just going to get worse and worse when you try to transition to that new model without addressing that it works first and also having more concrete of that future plan and how that's going to transition and that's just this it wasn't in this presentation and I think what Liza was getting director Ranken is getting at there uh with like seeing that plan is the most necessary there cuz you just can't ask them to approve this without knowing that and I just I do also want

211to know if there is more of a plan to make sure that the current model is actually happening yes and that's what will be brought forward prior to April 1st director sario so for the audience and for the record um what you're seeing here is frustration not necessarily the the ca the the cause is not necessarily the two people sitting at the table meaning what I mean by that is this situation predates them I don't want another presentation that is the president's perview to to approve what happens but I'm going to tell you I'm going to get up and walk out if we have another one of these presentations this is the same model year after year decade after decade what the parents want to know is how are their children who are in the

212highly capable program going to receive Services it's not complex and yet every time we we bring this issue up like I don't understand is it are we transitioning from the cohort model because of costs well well maybe um I was having I was having a conversation with a parent in the audience and I said I don't I'm not against dismantling quote unquote dismantling the cohort model but I can't support the dismantling of a cohort model without a coherent implementable plan that works for kids not you parents this is these are your children this needs to work for them not for you individually that's what we need and that's what essentially I think parents are asking for yes they're coming up as parents they care about their kids they're advocating but the reason why they're coming

213up is because there isn't a plan for by which we can understand and see how it's going to work on the other side and and so to keep having and this is not a diss on on my friend Rocky this is not a diss on you but we've got to stop these presentations it is almost 8:00 and you have presented nothing new and that's not about you but the reason why we keep coming back to the table every four or five years is because the work isn't being done we need a solution for this for this for the highly capable children in our district that is not going to change every 2 or 3 years this is literal Whiplash I am so exasperated my oldest is going to be 35 years old he entered kindergarten

214in 1995 I don't know how many conversations we've had about iy capable I could probably go back and look at some ancient record but we keep having this conversation over and over again because we can't get to an implementable plan I don't think it's unrealistic for the parents to expect consistency we expect consistency in the classroom when children show up they need consistency predictability reliability every day when they come into the classrooms and right now they feel like they're not getting it because when I asked that 38% versus whatever the number is 62 I have to question in my head and I'm and and again this is not a full analysis well if the majority of parents and the data and the data says that the kids are doing well under the cohort model why

215are we changing it I don't know what the data says cuz I haven't seen anything I haven't even seen a plan at this point we vote we you know h hon ly if we're being honest we voted on a plan we ain't never seen that's what happened we voted on a plan we actually haven't seen and so I don't want to keep coming to this table I'm asking I'm asking future presentations present us something that is coherent that is clear that is understandable and that's implementable our children deserve that and right now we can't reliably hold them accountable stop you need to go back to the Apple Store um and I won't be there um but we've this is I I'm done I I'm just I'm exasperated that's I'm being really honest and it's you're

216getting the brunt of this exasperation but let's stop this game this is a game we get presented information and yet nothing seems to change and let's come back to this table so that these families and the ones who came and testified and the ones who left can come back they may not like it y'all may not like the plan you'll get over it but there will be a plan for your children that's going to work for the collective of children not your individual child if Works mostly for everybody we do the tweaks for the kids it's not working for right so you may not like it I may not like it but what we want is a plan that can be implemented across the district if you move from your neighborhood to my neighborhood you

217can expect something similar right now you can't you don't know what to expect that's where I want to get to I I think we're we're way past this we're WP overdue we're long overdue for a solution that is longterm I'm looking for a long-term sustainable solution it's taken me all that talking to get there I want a long-term sustainable solution that works for the vast majority of kids in that program I don't have the answer to that but that's what we need that's what our kids deserve and that's where we need to go director hery thank you uh is there any information director sgud that you needed from them before I begin there isn't any information to give me okay all right I was just trying to clarify okay so the first thing that I

218think is super important here is just acknowledging the fact that like a lot of folks are going to experience change right like whatever their child is receiving right now is going to for the folks in this room for the most part for some of their children stay the same but for others they cannot guarantee that they're going to get the same level of services so regardless of where you might be at on this spectrum of like the conversation that I know that we've been having for a very long time not just in the context of tonight but like decades like acknowledging that change it is going to be different and different doesn't necessarily mean good it also doesn't necessarily mean bad but the unknown is incredibly scary for a lot of folks especially after the

219year we''ve had like I get that a lot lot of folks at this table get that and that's real so I want to make sure that folks understand that like that is not to be dismissed and there is the very real reality that we do have or rather we are at a precipice of change that needs to be decided and we need to press forward in some way so I have a few questions to that regard the first question that I have is what makes you feel confident that you are able given the conversation that we have had here tonight that we are going to be able to deliver the same quality of services and I really want to like Peg on that service for a second when we come back under the model of

220mtss and if you are not confident that we are going to be able to do that by the time you're asking us to vote on it what allocations or rather what resources need to be reallocated to better position y'all to do that so the confidence is we do have it working in some places we we have evidence of that um to take that to scale and have some uh reassurances that's going to be difficult but we do have some evidence uh I'll let Dr Dr Torres Morales talk a little bit about a couple of examples that we have this this working but we we have some something to work with in terms of understanding how to implement this how to make sure it's a a service delivery model that gets uh students what they need

221so Dr Torres if you want to talk about the two models that we've been working with that you find to be uh promising yep and then and I'll also just add that when we come forward in the next iteration we'll bringing some data because what at least initial data looks are looking like and this isn't confirmed yet but what we're seeing is that we're not seeing a huge difference and what I mean by that is kids who are choosing families who are choosing to keep their kids in the neighborhood School model versus access the cohort model in General within some small standard deviation we're seeing the same results so what is that telling us that there are a lot of kids who are in their neighborhood school who are getting what they need because they're

222growing at the same pace is those kids that are in the cohort models so there's a couple schools that have engaged in inclusion work and udl work with Fidelity for some time now when you look at those schools and you see the academic performance of the students in those schools it's actually quite remarkable and that includes multilingual students students with disabilities students with highly capable designations all being in the same neighborhood School Y and so do we have evidence that this works when we have schools and communities that are engaging in it fully absolutely is that something that we can do to scale within the district absolutely now does that also mean that we have to take some time to have a conversation over what does this look like in the future is it that

223we're going to do that at every school to director serre's point if there's a lot of people accessing the cohort already do we do we go down that down that path I think we have the data we need to bring everything forward and say this is what this would look like sure up to an including if we need to bring videos of classes so people can see them and have a little bit more clarity around what these things look like yeah but it is possible and it is happening currently in our system great thank you I think in addition to the data given everything that you know when you bring It Forward a very realistic and honest timeline from your perspective of how long it would take to implement at every school right and if

224that's a decade it's a decade you know what I'm saying then that comes back to the board to say it's not quick enough and then but let me cook what I'm saying is then we need to have hard conversations about again what we are willing to do to expedite that process this is all interconnected so when we're talking about adding in a math goal when we're talking about increasing 10% to 15% and we got a monetary allocation for what would it take for that to be possible when I was talking about this 3 weeks ago these decisions don't happen in a vacuum when we been getting all of the education from the Council of great City schools and so many other institutions that are helping us become better at our governance model I think that

225it's it's easy for us to say oh the district is not providing X Y and Z and don't get it twisted in many cases in respects they're not at the same time I don't believe that we are holding up our end of the bargain in really doing our side of the work as a board to be brave and say look we're not going to do X so that we can do why and we need to be Unapologetic about what our priorities are based on all the work that uh thanks to director Ranken um and all of the data and information we got back from the vision and values of our communities we are in a financial crisis we can't afford to do everything we just can't we can do everything but it's not going to

226be well done so we need to be really clear and pick what it is that we are going to do well and be really honest with ourselves with what we can't afford to do as well as other things I think that's a hard conversation is unpopular but like that that in and of itself is governance right I have a few more questions I really want to know what from y'all's perspective because I think that this is going to be super helpful for Community too if we if y'all bring forward this plan in a timeline and we decide that it is not fast enough we also need to know what are the options that are available to us as a board to be able to expedite this process please give us some suggestions of things that

227we can let go of and have a so that we can go out and have a real conversation with Community about like hey we have heard very clearly during public comment tonight that this is a high priority for us to be able to figure out and to figure out well this is also a microcosm of all of the students that we serve so I would be remissed and I love y'all don't get it twisted but if I made a decision for the entire District based on public testimony tonight I'm not saying y'all are wrong I'm just saying I don't know so I need to have a slate of options that I can take to all communities throughout the district so that we can do our work of understanding what are the vision and values of

228our community around this particular issue I I don't get paid to know what those options are that's why I'm asking y'all I don't expect an answer for that it is request the next piece I need to be super honest I think I am the only person at this particular table amongst the board who has led a classroom for half a decade and I need to be super clear I am not having taught in both a highly capable and a non highly capable environment I am very I want to be super careful as I say this two years of acceleration is not equal to receiving highly capable services and I need to be super clear I know that it's great and the cohort model is serving children in a really significant way especially children that were

229not thriving in a standard learning environment that is a real benefit and that does not necessarily mean mean that those are highly capable Services your child is receiving something different that is working for them but to equate that to highly capable Services is doing your child a disservice because what I know as an educator is that true differentiation goes leagues above doing two years ahead in math it's cool that our kids can do that but there's a lot of data that suggests that that is not going to help them long term in life what does provide and what is a real benefit is an alternative environment when the standard learning environment is not serving a child equitably or adequately these two issues are different I don't have a good answer because th this is why

230like again to bring It full circle to lose that when a family has found that is a significant loss it is a big deal however that loss cannot be inextricably linked to the delivery of Highly capable services so we have to be able to have two conversations at once so my question is if we change pretend I am a parent I'm very excited to be a parent and hopefully if Rainer view is open when my child is born at some point I am really excited for them to go there I'm not yet but hang with me you're working on it I'm working on it actively so here's this here's my question pretend I'm a parent and I have a child that is is not receiving their highly capable Services as outlined in the plan that

231y'all are going to bring forth what is my recourse in that instance what can I do to ensure that my child is receiving all of the things that they deserve as articulated in your plan so I want to clarify your question first please so essentially when we come forward with all the details one of the things you want to see in there is essentially let's say here's this here's this here's this and little Brandon's in school yep and then all of a sudden you're like well this is not what's happening or it is what's happening and it's still not working for my kid two different tracks what is the next step in the moment what I would say is what you're going to hear is U around how do we access uh connections with the

232principal at the building with the actual teacher there are resources that we can push in in terms of like Advanced learning Specialists which are teachers on assignment that work and go into classrooms they currently exist in our current model but they go in there to work with the teacher to specifically address little Brandon's needs but that is something that duly noted and to make sure we detail more out almost around I don't want to call it um an appeal but some sort of like what is an escalation process for families if it doesn't feel like this is working that is just very clear for them in those cases ex and in addition to that right because like as an educator and as a person who is serving on a board I hear that and I

233know for a fact that the way that y'all are articulating and designing this plan that you hear me right the on the other end of that it has been my firsthand experience that that process can take an entire year and by that time the child has moved on to a different teacher that may or may not be meeting those needs as well and then before you know it an entire child's Elementary experience has been trying to get them services that they have ultimately not received so what I am also asking for in addition to that is what parameters are in place to ensure that that is handled in a timeline that actually gets kids the services because what what we know is that like yes pushing model help the teacher get the principle involved that's

234a lot of triangulation that at a building that may or may not have like maybe they have a high turnover maybe they have a new principle people move and that's just a part of running a system that's large but being the director of the largest District per school basis here I have seen that there is in fact a lot of turnover specifically in Southend schools for lots of reasons right the stability that my kids experience is very different than the stability that some kids in other parts of the city experience so again I'm not asking you to solve that problem but what I am asking is not only what is the path of scores but what are the I would say systematic assurances and the timeline for making sure that if a child is not

235receiving Services as they are detailed in the plan that within a reasonable amount of time they are going to get to receiving those Services MH so yeah I have yeah there's about two or three points I'll hit on them app all of the pieces we're talking about are very interconnected so if we go all the way back to earlier this evening Dr Perkins and Dr stasy talking about the importance of hey look how many people are actually completing the curricular based assessments the curricular beted assessments what Eliza or director rank who has the unit test those things are actually really important because if we go back to just teaching and learning the teaching and learning cycle one of the first things is and if we use little Brandon as the example in order for us

236to determine is this an intervention issue do we need to accelerate in the classroom and all those sort of things we need that sort of data to tell us where the student is at the other piece to that is when we start getting that done districtwide that is the foundation to director Brick's question around mtss like what what is happening and so just raising that up because understanding that for decades it has not happened and want to clarify that it is in the process of happening now and all the foundational pieces are moving m to the point though is is when you're thinking about a timeline one of the things we're moving into next year now I think uh many of you are aware and if you're not we've had a consultant called Novak education

237we've working on What's called the inclusion initiative and there's been schools that have been able to opt in or opt out in those sort of things the schools that have opt in opted in and done all the PD all the work with the teachers all the things we are seeing amazing results out of those schools given that where we're moving now for example into next year is everybody's going to be doing it it's not going to be an optional I get to do it or I don't so when you get to your question around hey in Timeline once these two things merge and the system starts going it's going to be pretty solid and lock steps so for example little Brandon might be at Rainer view he might need to be accelerated that data is

238going to live somewhere that if he has to move and go to West Woodland for whatever the reason may be that information's still there and mtss functional structure is still there whatever the acceleration that student needs is still there and so all the pie P that we've been hitting on even throughout the evening is is is really directing towards what your question is I think the only other piece that um that you asked earlier and that I hadn't talked about was just allocations and so one of the things that we have done as a district is in our budget last year I've already advocated for it to stick for next year is there is a chunk of money that protects that level of professional development for that inclusion initiative and that is something that we

239do have to be aware of and hold on to to move this plan continually forward that's all super clear to me and that actually prompts one last question in what way are School leaders and Educators and directors of schools held accountable to implementation of mtss I know that since there's probably opt in it's probably not baked into an evaluation or something like that right but what I want to know is that what is the link between professional development and reasonable expectations around implementation and performance yes because and and I Want To Tread very carefully here M though I believe strongly that the pretense of mtss has an innate value not only in the context of Highly capable but also for both our math and our reading goal right all interconnected so what is your Administration

240willing to do in terms of if we are offering this as as the solution to double down as well on the accountability metrics for teaching utilizing with Fidelity the ntss strategies that we are putting in front of Educators principles in the entire system so so one way from a systemwide perspective uh every school has to have elements of tier one instruction in their cips and so that that's uh people are being accountable to that it's in it's in evaluations around sure uh how is this not only embedded in your CIP how are how is this manifesting in the classroom what's observable what what feedback are you getting on this are you doing walkthroughs to see what these critical elements are so it's it's now uh aligned and the next step is integration so it comes

241easily naturally uh it's part of part of just practice and so uh this is the first time that we've had cips aligned uh excuse me mtss goals and objectives aligned in cips and it really speaks to uh student populations who they know from their school-based data who who need the services uh and and in a a timely relevant way I'll say related to this I know I was hitting on earlier that uh with director Briggs and upcoming audit committee we're going to bring forward this mtss needs assessment and what the corrective action plan is sure what you would see what you're going to see in that plan and essentially in there is very much related to what you're saying y because through the first years of the cohorts we did a lot of reflection over

242what's working well what's not what we found was there were some schools that did all the PD all the things the results for kids have been outstanding we're going to make sure to share some of that data with y'all on the flip side there were some schools where it was I think I want to do this and I want to do that and I might do this piece or I might do that piece M guess what their data wasn't as strong as the other schools and so one of the things we've been sitting with is what is it that we need to do differently as we're moving this to all the schools to make sure that it sticks so for example uh moving it more into a coaching and a tracking model and what does

243that mean so between Regional executive directors the Novac Consulting team let's say director Rankin's our principal and here's the topic it's udl 101 it's not going to be essentially that the Novak team is going to come in and say Here's your udl 101 that's an option for you if your school wants it but we found a lot especially we are the city of Seattle so we need to own this our schools are are their own individual entity within a system and the leader often wanted to say well you know this is how we do it here and so it became a conversation of okay that's fair but here's the Baseline standards for what this means for Seattle Public Schools sure so yes and here's your PowerPoint let's vet that together go ahead do your PD

244with your teachers or who's your lead teacher that wants to come in and do that and those are around all those elements so fast forward when we get into the whole District model what this is going to look like is it's almost like a scoping of here's your school leader here's your PDS on udl multi-tiered systems of support restorative practices and you're working with your team and your BLT and your school to go through okay here's where we're at here's where we're at but on the back end there is some protections of here's the Baseline of what your RP 101 your restored practice 101 training needs to look like in Seattle Public Schools make it the West Woodland way but these need to be in there and someone working with them around those presentations and

245those professional development and that happening across the system okay so just to repeat that back because you and I know a lot of those acronyms and whatnot no I know so just to make sure that there is Clarity when we are providing instructional materials for professional development purposes to principles there is a common denominator a baseline quality of instruction that is going to be expected of every single building but because we know that Seattle is Seattle and our schools are unique entities within a system there will still be an opportunity for schools to deliver it within reason in their own way that is responsive to their Community but there will be at a bare minimum expectation of quality and methods around instruction and delivering these Services yes perfect I'm done thank you Briggs or sju

246I mean director Briggs or Ranken I um so I want to Second a lot of what Brandon said um and he is the only K12 classroom leader I've taught at the post secary level just have to get that in there but yeah K12 is a different it's a whole different thing um there are two other issues that have come up in testimony and in emails that we're getting that are 100% operational that need to be solved that I'm not asking to be solved right now because it's actually not our job um but that are going to continue to come up and it's connected to last year's conversation on school consolidations and enrollment and everything and it's actually connected to other testimony that people gave about option schools when we have fewer students and large amounts

247of empty space in our buildings capacity is not in physical space it's in Staffing so the option schools that are saying you know you're not letting kids in there's plenty of room if a new classroom is opened that takes a classroom teacher away from a neighborhood school from a neighboring school and so the the there's no I don't believe uh option schools are not being singled out in this way we have different capacity based on the number of kids and the number of Staff in the building because that is how we're funded on a per pupil basis the state does not care how many schools we have we could close all the schools and have T-Mobile be one school and we would have the number of teachers of you know T-Mobile stadium we would have

248the number of teachers corresponding to the number of students that same number of teachers and number of students exists with students in 106 buildings so we have plenty of space at my school why aren't they letting more kids in it's because it would open another classroom it's a staff issue it's not a space issue and if we were if we were more appropriately sized as we had the conversation last year that would the staff capacity and the space capacity would be closer to each other um so but the operational issue at Cascadia and dear that needs to be had with those communities not with us is one of our newest nicest largest buildings is going to be half empty next year because we didn't do any boundary changes so I need to know and the

249board will have to approve we have to approve boundary changes what is being address to do that and what it's going to look like next October when both of these schools have few students as every other school is projected to and they lose teachers and they don't have access to music anymore and they don't have access to art or whatever the case may be they maybe have split classes are you going to combine the schools so that the programming that they have is preserved and honestly I'm going to like I have nothing to lose at this point Decor never should have reopened that was a mistake 10 or so years ago we didn't actually need it Decor reop it was a where Thorton Creek used to be Thorton Creek got a new new double the

250size building because people love that school kids moved from decar to Thorton Creek they filled that building decer sat had been kind of upgraded to meet the needs of the the um I think it was used as a transition site or something I can't remember and then the board at the time decided what a great idea high demand highly capable we're going to open to cater well that in addition to 4500 other optional seats north of the ship Canal that opened between 2016 and 2018 and now we are 4,200 students down from the pandemic so that added optional seats in optional programs and that is impacting all of our kids because the option schools now are full or at capacity because we can't we can't take away from the neighborhood you know it's the balance

251of the staff so those things have real impacts but we could come up with a number of solutions it's not our job to do that it is our job to approve boundary changes if they're brought to us so in thinking about the service both the service delivery for students currently at decar and currently at Cascadia what is the impact to them on next year's enrollment projection and how are we not going to let one of our best quality buildings not have students um enjoying it and benefiting from it that's for you guys to solve and and we'll approve it if we need to you know as as needed if it if it requires boundary changes I want to be also really clear that nothing I say should be taken as don't make any changes because

252having been part of this conversation around highly capable for over a decade there are very real reasons that the board made the decision that they did to eliminate the cohort we're one of I don't know if we're the only District in the country or one of the only districts in the country where a whole separate school is required to attend in order to have the needs of gifted and highly capable students met there's lots of different models of you know different classes or walk to maath or whatever and there's even some I'm sure there's some plenty of schools that have some students that are highly capable and some that are our agenda track whatever but having a whole separate building where you have to go to one or another location or you don't have access

253is really um should not continue and so I just want to be really clear about that that that should I don't want anybody walking away thinking oh director anran wants to revert back to 2019 and we just continue on we can't do that that would be such a disservice to the parents and students and Educators and Advocates that worked for so long to demand that more students have access to highly capable services and that it doesn't require that you leave your community to access it um one other thing to Brandon's point about two years ahead for a lot of kids that's that's not gifted education that's two years ahead but I want to say on record or just out loud that what people found that they're afraid of losing is a place where their kids

254aren't the weird ones and I say that as a weird kid kid at Laurel Hurst Elementary School in the'80s everybody else sat in clusters I had a desk against the wall because I was a delight to have in class but I could be disruptive at times and I was Oho energetic that was code for there's something wrong with you we don't have time for you we don't want to deal with you and so when you have parents coming here saying please do not take that away from my kid they're responding to the fact that their kid felt weird and bad about themselves in one of our schools and that the cohort has given them a place where they don't were they're accepted by the adults because this is not just a kid bullying issue this

255is an adult issue about how children who are different are treated and this applies to much more than highly capable so I just want to be really clear that the fear that you're hearing from people about my kid has a place where they belong and that's going to go away is a real fear and that it's not just about the academics two years ahead I mean we have the internet now you can access any kind of knowledge or information you want at any time you know until the whole grid goes down and we're all in disaster mode but like what they need is what they want what they need what they have found is a place where their kid is seen as a whole person and every single one of our students deserves to have

256that space no matter what neighborhood they live in um so yeah I just wanted to clarify I'm not not saying pait but let's have real honest conversations we don't want Perfection we want honesty transparency and [Music] progress director bricks super Snappy um so we I'm I'm hearing the term accountability thrown around and I uh I just want to underline that yes that accountability is is critical and it's lacking and I also want to acknowledge that accountability starts with the board that is literally our job um we are elected to hold this District accountable and I want to acknowledge that I understand that that is our role um I also want to request that families are communicated with ASAP um having a plan on by April 1st uh doesn't answer a lot of questions for families

257who um do who need to make choices during the open enrollment period um and who have been asking questions for a long time and not getting answers um and and sometimes they will get a form letter that basically tells them like this is happening in your neighborhood school when that's that doesn't align with their reality so if meaningful communication transparent honest communication could go out to families as soon as possible um I think that is a really important step in this process because it's been um these questions have been left unanswered for so long um and families deserve to be leveled with so that is my request um and that's all I have all right just share with me um the form letter piece something a little bit of specificity around that just so I

258know yeah I will forward it to you uh um a parent inquired with the advanced learning Department about um it had a really really specific questions that have come to many of us many times at this point and got back like like a a boiler plate letter that if you could please I will to you thank you I want to wrap that up I think we at least as a board have sort of next steps on the accountability front I think a lot of this is board members needing Clarity Community families needing Clarity and I hope we can get there and what I heard of is a lot of this cyclical cycle and hopefully we can somehow figure out how to break that and be an anomal um but before we adjourn tonight I am

259going to turn it over to director sarju um she's going to do a a reading for us I'm very excited about um so thank you for the kids for coming up who knows what month it is what month is it what month is it um February February and there's something that we celebrate in February do you all know what it is black history month do we have any Librarians in the audience so I have a library book that I'm carrying around with me I did not bring it today because I knew you all were going to show up this is a very special library book um it's from Adams County School District number 12 in Colorado um a dear friend of mine um was at a library where they were selling this book and she

260picked it up for me and the book is titled Linda Brown You Are Not Alone the Brown versus Board of Education decision and so I'm going to read something to you all that I read to a college class that I lectured at yesterday and this class was aspiring teachers and for the adults in the room I gave them a serious talking to but I ended with two readings from this book so first of all February is the shortest month and that's the month this nation has decided it's going to be black history month but what you all should know is that every month is Black History Month for me does that make sense why do you think it is go ahead amen yes that's oh girl I don't know who your mama is but whoever

261that is she's done a good job okay so the first poem I'm going to read the first I'm going to read is a poem called desegregation if that isn't connected to highly capable I don't know what is and it's by Greenfield we walk the long path lined with shouting nightmare faces nightmare voices inside the school there are eyes that glare and eyes that are distant we wish for our friends we wish for our old laughing selves we hold our heads up hold our tears in in the grown-ups have said we must be brave that only the children can save the country now the adults in the room better remember the last piece of that only the children can save our country now this was written in 2002 and I just want us to think about

262where we are at in 2025 only these children right here and all the other children who were here and all the other children in our 106 school buildings can save the country now that's you all that's your job it's to work hard get smart and save our country because clearly the adults right now are not able to do it okay the next thing I'm going to read is it's just one paragraph but it's by Eloise Greenfield in her chapter called Legacy and so for the kids this may not make sense cuz I'm not reading the whole chapter um but I think the last part will make sense to you this Legacy then is a precious gift of Courage dedication and struggle an inheritance handed by each generation to the next so that's from your parents

263to you that's from your grandparents to your parents to you that's what that means it is seen in the lives of teachers who teach children who learn in spite of the odds against them but the story is bigger than that and here I'm talking to the adults it accomp encompasses people in every field doing what they do in the best way they can to make life better for generations of the children to come that's for the adults if we don't get this right we don't get a second chance we need people on every field doing what they do in the best way they can to make life better for the generations of children to come the end thank you for coming up and and pretending to be students cuz I'm not a teacher but I

264sure like that maybe I'll be a teacher one day maybe that'll be my next gig after Schoolboard I don't know I don't know I appreciate everyone being here tonight and working to make life better for generations to come um there being no further business to come before the board the regular board meeting is now adjourned at 8:34 thank you everyone w

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.