CorpusRecord 7533

Seattle Schools Board Meeting Dec. 18, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Seattle Public Schools Board Meetings
Date
2024-12-19
Location
King County, WA
Material
Transcript
Extent
24,295 words · about 135 min
Collected
2026-05-22

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] all right we've gotten word that we we have a couple of directors still in traffic um but we do have [Music] a call uh the board meeting will call the order in just a [Music] moment reset okay uh this is president again for the last time I am calling uh the December 18th 2024 regular board meeting to order at 4:21 p.m. this meeting is being recorded and we would like to acknowledge that we are on ancestral lands and traditional territories of the Puget Sound Coast Salish people Miss Wilson Jones the roll call please director BRS here director Clark I not quite yet um director hery here director M Rahi here vice president sarju on I can see that she um parking lot I'm here in the parking lot excellent vice president sju is uh

002remote for the next 30 seconds or so and then director top here president Ranken here and director Bragg oh here director ilas here and director Yun present all right I will now turn it over to superintendent Jones for his comments good evening uh board members and president Rankin uh and Community watching today uh this evening we'll start with progress monitoring on two of our goals third grade literacy and seventh grade math uh we'll discuss the strides we've made especially in Middle School mathematics and also address our efforts to accelerate progress in third grade literacy which appears to require special attention for this particular cohort of students I would encourage the board to situate our agenda this evening in our year zero framework year zero serves as the diagnostic period from uh some of the most

003significant areas of our work in the district while we're between while we are between strategic plans tonight represents an important milestone in our efforts as we create a smooth transition into our next strategic plan following progress monitoring we will discuss governance uh governance review conducted by our partners at Moss Adams the findings from the review suggest that we have an opportunity in front of us to build institutional awareness and ensure Clarity around our shared responsibility to implement an effective and effective governance model uh so I'm fully committed to working alongside this board to build on the uh initial implementation work that we've done together and our need to go deeper and further so at the heart of our governance work is the board's goal and guardrail setting and I want to thank each one of

004you for the clear direction that you provided during last week's goals and guardrail work session later in the meeting you will introduce a bar to operationalize the Topline measures which will then be shared with our community for ongoing engagement this process is crucial as we move forward together I see tonight's reports as the additional grounding for us to level set as a governance team especially as we prepare to transition into our new strategic plan we are excited to focus focus on moving ahead on the board's revised goals including second grade literacy and high school graduation as align with students planning efforts I look forward to building on this exciting work in the month years ahead we also have board officer selection process this evening and I want to express my deep appreciation for president Ranken

005for her leadership this year uh she's guided us through some uh challenging times with courage and determination uh president Rankin we uh senior leadership team you know we we value your partnership and we look forward to continuing to work alongside you and the rest of the board uh along this uh this journey together on a somber note um by once you I want to acknowledge the the devastating impact of recent gun violence one of our partner schools in Madison Wisconsin uh experienced this and you know we must stay v villig um to address this and we need to do what we can to continue to create safe and welcoming environments for each and every one of our students and so just wanted to acknowledge that as we go forward uh and that concludes my remarks

006back to you president Rankin thank you um we are now at board comment section um as Dr Jones noted this is our annual organizational meeting uh we'll be moving into the election of board officers immediately after the consent agenda and the officers elected tonight will then immediately take on those new roles and the newly elected president will preside over the remainder of the meeting um so we now move into if there are any other reports uh from student members reports or comments from student members or directors um are there any liaison reports that anyone wants to share okay in the um I have included two uh for legislative liaison and Council of great City Schools liaison they are are in the informational items in the packet in the interest of of time so please read

007those when you can if you haven't already um I did post the send in the legislative liaison um update prior to Governor eny's budget proposal yesterday today yesterday which includes a wealth tax so that is something definitely that we will be keeping an eye on and that um isn't included in what's uh in the packet since it was it just happened um I will say this is you know in my opinion long overdue and welcome and also uh while we will continue to advocate for increased funding and better support of students from the state um uh the expectation that this will suddenly solve all of our problems would be unrealistic just to put it to put it bluntly so but that is it is great to and also that when the uh Governor makes his

008budget Rec recommendations it is literally just a recommendation the legislature determines and then recommends a budget back to the governor so this is the governor's sort of um well it's just exactly that recommendations from the executive body the legislative body will be in this upcoming session it's a long session also known as a budget session that's where um we'll know what we actually uh will be looking at for the state budget coming out a session depending on what the um legisl nature decides to do um oh uh I had the opportunity to speak at um the Seattle Human Rights Commission had an event this last weekend um on educational Equity following Human Rights Day which was a couple days before and so they asked me to speak and um I talked about our goal and

009guardrail process and just wanted to share with you all how much of a like really positive response we got how excited our community is to see real tangible measures that we're holding ourselves accountable to and monitoring and sharing out with the public um so that was really a positive feedback and encouragement um in in the work that we're doing in this uh governance model and go and guardrail setting and I also asked uh or let the student board members know about it and they were all Ava aable to attend so also got to speak which was awesome and then they did a fantastic job um so just to share that we have a whole new group of people who are into um you know doing work in their community that are now I would say

010coming alongside and excited about what what um our school district is doing and what the board is doing on their behalf do students have any comments yes um first and foremost all three student board members attended the annual student was the annual wasda conference last month and it was a great opportunity to network and meet other students with our position in a way we gained Insight from districts who've had student Reps for much longer than our district um next we have a few social media posts in the work such as a vlog on the conference we attended last month a summary post regarding the meetings the big meetings and uh an update on when we plan to visit schools you can find all of that on our Instagram page at SPS student reps consequently I'd

011like to emphasize well I'm pretty sure I'm talking for a lot of students when I say um Librarians are a huge part of our day and schedule um I remember as a I remember as a ele School student I was very excited for the read alloud times and Library times so yeah just want to share that sorry I also just wanted to give an update on the school visits we've been PL planning and we've also previously mentioned this in our student comments last board meeting we've moved all three School visits Ballard Franklin in Lincoln High School to January and we've been planning a lot for these visits so we're very excited to start fresh in 2025 and have a voice to listen to student voices um I also wanted to kind of add on on

012what director ilos was saying um I met with 16 Library leaders at Ballard High School this week um Library leaders are students who help manage your library and host events and I've just heard so much from them and how much the libraries mean to them and their students and their communities and you know for students libraries aren't just places to check out books they're places where students go to study meet for tutoring sessions after school or just find a quiet place to focus and they're also a place where many clubs meet um friends hang out and they host a lot of events that bring schools um communities together and a lot of students talked about how libraries feel like a safe and welcoming space for them and they just expressed that it feels like they're

013they will be losing more than a physical space and they're losing a space where they could learn grow and connect so I just wanted to you know after listening to these students I just want to emphasize how much libraries matter and how much big of a part of their Community it is thank you director Bank do you have it's okay if you don't but I want to make sure you have the opportunity if you have something uh I can say that it was really exciting to go to the human rights events this weekend and I did have the opportunity recently to speak to a lot of student leaders at Lincoln and they are very they are actually informed and excited about the goals and guardrails process uh so from a student perspective awesome that is

014going quite far because it's a lot more digestible and students are having the ability to understand and feel connected to the process that's great thank you um and I forgot it seems like such a long time ago but yeah the wasda conference um I think wait let's see director Briggs director top and I and the superintendent were there as long as well as our three student members and it's probably the largest representation that Seattle has had in a lot of years which is um for the largest school district you know it's I'm I'm just really excited people were were're we're happy to see uh representation from our team there um especially as we go into a uh a budget session where we really need to work with our partners across the state um having uh

015so many of us there was was really really great um just a chance to further our our own learning and ongoing continuous improvement in our governance roles and collaborate with other uh other boards and then of course having student members having the opportunity to talk with students who have been from districts who have been doing the student board member thing longer than we have I know that they already have some ideas we've been talking about about taking now that we're in the third year taking a look again at our student board member policy and seeing how we can apply what we've learned from the last three years and what this cohort has learned um to making some updates to continue to strengthen uh that role so that's super exciting um and I don't see any

016other board board director comments okay um so we're going to move to the tables please take your microphone and we will be doing a progress monitoring and uh and then we'll just stay there for uh conversation with moss Adams before we come back here for [Music] Testimony e e all right for our monthly progress monitoring session we have uh reports on goals one and two Dr Jones [Music] thank you president ranking and board um we are going to be talking about uh progress monitoring third grade reading and seventh grade math and uh this will be our sixth formal opportunity to review outcomes in these two areas I'm joined tonight by uh colleagues from our office of academics celle toner executive director for curriculum and assessment and instruction and Dr Caleb Perkins executive director of college

017and Readiness and Dr Mike stoski assistant superintendent for academics uh tonight's uh presentation I will Begin by summarizing our theory of action for both goals before sharing the results from our fall 2024 map assessment and that's measures of academic progress I will then conclude by recapping what the data is telling us and how it's informing the strategies and actions we are taking to achieve both goals next slide please so our theory of action beginning with the impact from from on the far right is to increase the proportion of students achieving grade level proficiency on the SBA and that's the smarter balance assessment uh working backwards to the left will be able to achieve that impact as more teachers deliver high quality standards align culturally responsive instruction teachers will be able to do that when they

018are given ongoing job embedded professional learning and support grounded in student data and research uh based on instructional research-based instructional practices also uh ongoing professional learning and support is in is in turn enabled by our District's investment in the following high quality curriculum and assessments a focus on improving a limited number of instructional priorities a year instructional coaching and dedicated time each month for teachers to engage in professional learning communities and finally strong instructional leaders who create the conditions for professional growth um those Investments are in turn uh enabled by our systems leadership ability to one articulate a clear coherent and actionable vision of instructional Excellence that has maintained over many years and two to align the central office's work across departments to enable systemwide continuous Improvement one of the things I've been saying uh

019since I've been superintendent is that central office exist to to support schools uh and that's been very intentional so that the support that we provide schools for instruction is is Meaningful relevant and timely so if we go to slide four let's turn uh the focus of tonight's conversation to third grade reading and seventh grade math um given there's a positive correlation with that we've talked about between the fall map scores and predicted proficiency on the SBA this um and so that's really important that we uh we ground ourselves in the different assessments that we're doing so as we as we monitor the interim assessments excuse me interim measures for support and achieving our Top Line goals it's always a comparison to map in the spring uh excuse me map in the fall and then map

020in the spring so for tonight uh for third grade reading we'll be reporting on our first interim measure which is the percentage of black boys who based on the fall third grade map Reading assessment are projected to achieve proficiency on the third grade Smarter Balance assessment the following spring and for seventh grade math we will also SE seventh grade math we will also be reporting on our first interim measure me of the percentage of black boys and teens who based on the fall seventh grade map assessment are predicted to achieve proficiency on the seventh grade Smarter Balance assessment the following spring and so you all received memos and as a result I'm going to proceed with a brief overview of the executive summary before sharing the data and discussing what we are seeing with our

021interim measures starting with third grade reading so next slide please so so in summary uh 27 excuse me 25.7% of third grade African-American males are projected to achieve proficiency on the ELA uh English language assessment portion of the SBA in Spring 2025 this is representing a 6.5 percentage Point decline from Fall of 39.4% of third grade students of color furthest from education Justice are projected to achieve a proficiency on the ELA proportion of the smarter balance assessment in Spring 2025 representing a 4.2% uh decrease from Fall 2023 uh in the targeted schools uh year-over-year declines amongst African-American males and students of color furest from educational Justice were 4 point for four percentage points and one percentage point so if we go to slide seven as you can see on slide seven here maybe not on

022your screens but on your um in your packet uh as previously stated in my executive summary we see we're seeing seeing year-over-year declines for African-American males and students of just students of color furthest from educational Justice projected to achieve proficiency on the ELA propor portion of the SBA in Spring 20125 I will also note that 22% of our multilingual Learners are project Ed to achieve a proficiency on the ELA proportion of the SBA in Spring 2025 representing a 1.4% decline from Fall 2023 and 44.2% of students with IEPs are projected to achieve proficiency on the ELA proport portion of the SBA in Spring 2025 which represents a 5.7 Point increase from fall 23 so hopefully you all have had a chance to kind of look look through this these data um it's very telling as

023to where we are and with that I'll move move forward and have some discussion on these student outcomes so uh when we talk about the cohort analysis and fall map Reading from 2 through fifth grade on slide eight uh I'd like to take a step back from the specific data point being discussed and look at the overall trajectory for certain certain cohorts at which you will see here on the slide eight which shows an upward Trend in ela proficiency what you see here are different cohorts of students as they are tested in the spring and fall from second to third grade so for example the Orange Line are our current fourth graders you can see their map results at each point in time beginning on the far left when they are tested as second graders

024and then move Ming right through the spring of their second grade year then as third graders until their most recent map test this fall as fourth grades fourth graders The Gray Line represents fifth graders and the yellow and the yellow current sixth graders the blue line is our current third graders Now map was consistently administered across our system starting only in the 2223 school year so we don't have complete longitudinal data for all these cohorts nonetheless you can see a consistent pattern of performance emerging at each of these points in time except for this past fall where you see the current third grade students represented in the blue line starting to diverge from other cohorts that Gap is what represents the year-over-year decline in map scores for grade three what this view of the data

025shows is not only that uh not only that last spring when they were second graders there was virtually no gap between these students in the prior cohort but for some reason over the summer a gap did emerge this may indicate a need to boost enrollment in expanded learning over the summer we confirmed in our analysis that demogra Dem demographic differences between cohort was not a factor in the year-over-year change while that Gap did emerge over the summer it is critical that we help schools get students back on track and if we go to slide nine thank you uh also with the year-over-year drop as a concern we're confident that job embedded systems of instructional Improvement that we've been building over the last several years equips schools to monitor these kinds of data changes at the

026building level and develop the appropriate instructional responses these systems include multi-tiered systems of support mtss curriculum embedded assessments the early literacy principal Network Regular teacher professional learning communities we call those plc's and instructional coaching in addition at our targeted schools this year we have expanded the number of third grade teachers using ad adapted instruct adopted in instructional materials for the writing about reading project and will be training multilingual and special education support staff on those in January which will be aligned with our efforts to focus on inclusionary practices more generally we know that schools are able to achieve consistent improvement over time when their principles are strong instructional leaders when teachers engage in reg regular instructional coaching and plc's everyone is aligned around the common adopted instructional materials Improvement efforts are bite-sized and focused and

027data about student learning is put at the center of everything the school does so that concludes talking about uh third grade reading third grade literacy I'd like to now transition to our second goal of seventh grade math so like third grade reading I'm going to begin with the executive summary before reviewing the data the P the percentage of seventh grade students furthers from educational Justice projected to meet the standard levels of third third and fourth on the excuse me on the 2025 spring Smarter Balance assessment based on the 2024 fall map assessment has increased from 34.6% in fall 2023 to 40.4% in Fall 2024 so almost a 5% increase the percentage of seventh grade African-American male students projected to meet standards and that's level three and four on the 2025 spring math Smarter Balance assessment

028based on Fall 2024 map assessment has also increased from 23.5% in Fall 2023 to 33.2% in Fall 202 four that's almost a 10% increase and for our six targeted schools we have seen an increase from 12.9% to 27.5% of African-American male students projected to meet Smarter Balance assessment math uh based on based on Fall the fall map test almost a 15% increase so we go to slide 12 fall 2024 four map assessments results show a positive trend in all subgroups of students projected to meet Proficiency in Spring 2025 and we can see similar positive trends of African-American males and students of color furthest from educational Justice with an increase of 7.9% from 10.3% to 18.2% for 7th grade students receiving multilingual services and an increase of 7.7% % from 39 from 30.9% to 38.6% for

029our students receiving special education services so if we go on to slide 13 since our last progress monitoring update we've asked our instructional coaches to synthesize what have they learned about schools and Educators who have shown growth in fall in the fall map scores and their insights include the following one is strong School leadership and an instructional vision for the school that supports the seventh grade math math goal they've also used formative data consistently such as curriculum curriculum uh embedded assessments uh student work leads to in this and this student work leads to learning more about students and informing instructional planning also partnering with families through frequent Outreach and math engagement opportunities we also noted that participating in instructional coaching on mathematical discourse and belonging in the classroom was important and then the last two

030uh items that had an impact were increasing opportunities and quality of student discourse about mathematics and supporting students in the in productive struggle in learning new content and using success maker as an intervention tool next slide please and so before I transition to the board for questions and discussion I want to conclude by thanking the board for providing a framework for which we can monitor how frequently we can monitor frequently how our students are doing and by establishing a robust assessment of portfolio measures and implementing curriculum embedded assessments our system is now able to better understand student learning which in turn helps to inform our teaching and learning practices and ultimately improve student outcomes we now transition to questions and discussions and I'mma turn it over to president Ranken to to lead that so thank

031you so much thank you I'm actually oh sorry I'm still getting used to using this um I will pass it over to director Briggs to facilitate in just a moment but I just uh uh was thinking about um and this is not something that has to get answered now now but we just approved a progress monitoring report or a progress monitoring calendar that I'm guessing we may need to revisit once we have the new uh interim measures and kind of know what those might be and when it might be best to monitor them but we we really should this is a lot of information we should be aiming for one one goal a session I'm not going to fault us for overachieving here but but generally we we want to monitor one goal monthly um

032so that would be one one interim and either or but like I said we'll we'll see when the we have the new interims what what might make make the most sense in terms of the timing but I would imagine that we might want to revisit the the calendar yeah we we'd be more than happy to make that adjustment okay great and then um uh other thing I was thinking about is um I think the most useful pieces of the the we have the reports in the presentation and actually I don't know that we need much more than what's in the presentation I think the executive summary is really helpful and but then we really what we really want to focus on is what is the current reality for our students and then what strategies may

033or may not change the other information about inputs and what not are are things that if we're all doing our homework we should we should be keeping up on so um uh don't want to have you all have to produce duplicative work um especially when we need to read it ahead of time which brings me to my last point which is um we've made a commitment as a board to try to in the interest of using our time together well uh try to differentiate between Technical and tactical versus strategic Technical and tactical questions can be asked between meetings or in writing just to save time and it's the Strategic questions that we want to be focusing on here which are things that we need to be able to discuss together um in order for us

034to maintain our commitment though to to that effective time use we need these sooner than the Friday before our meeting we really need these 10 days ahead when the when the material posts for the meeting um and then also I will say that so so be because we didn't get this far enough in advance I'm not going to uh fault anyone for maybe having a tactical question come up that they didn't have a chance to think about and submit ahead of time um and then also I have unless I missed it we haven't received the responses to Technical and tactical questions that we have asked in other monitoring sessions um that there's been a commitment to we'll get we'll get that we'll answer that in writing later to the board we haven't actually seen those

035so um we need a uh a mechanism that we can all rely on to make sure that um if we don't ask or if we ask them here and don't get the answers here we are getting getting the answers so that's just a little bit of of I guess administrative housekeeping and also keeping us all you know we want to we want to use our time well and focus it on um the strategies for students so I will now pass it over to director Briggs to facilitate and um we can use this this method again okay I see director Hy's got a question okay uh statement and a couple questions if that's okay um I don't want to scirp pass the fact that the growth in projected growth that we're seeing in math is pretty

036phenomenal um I think that as one of the folks that kind of like brought the system here um it's evidence that like it takes a minute for things to take right that being said the question that I have is given that we're seeing the substantive projected growth in math um versus a substantive decline in Reading from y'all's Vantage Point what is the difference in administration of the strategies and why are we seeing opposite impacts in our math instruction as opposed to our reading instruction um so here and I have a couple of follow-ups depending on that the answer to that question so I'll take the first crack at it and team feel free to jump in um I think we have more stronger systems in Middle School in terms of uh how it's all working

037together I think we have much more Fidelity of implementation and I think there's also been a strong Foundation that our students are starting from in elementary so by the time they get to uh middle school they're they're in good position to uh take advantage of what they learned so uh but I do think it's more about the systems uh the the adopted standards based curriculum the uh multi-tiered system of support the uh using data to inform instruction I think there's more uh experience with that a little more uh yeah I think we've had two or three more years of experience with the the math pieces but if my colleagues want to add in please do maybe let's just keep it a conversation between the superintendent and the board um for now and then if we

038have if there's other things that staff want to add that would be great to get after the fact and writing um okay is it do you have a followup I do um and so Dr Jones in in concert with that and to be clear that makes perfect sense to me I guess my outlining question is given the fact that both seventh grade and second grade or rather students going into seventh grade and students going into third grade those are both significant transitions in their own way um what I'm trying to understand is have yall identified any particular occurrences or outliers about this specific cohort that falls outside of instruction that could be impacting the Gap and just framing that question as we all know there's been a lot of you know I think a fair

039word is um turmoil specifically in elementary schools given that you know we have moved around with what our plan for closures might be that is not gospel I'm just saying as an example I'm wondering ing from y'all's vantage point being the ones who are communicating with buildings on a regular basis or taking into consideration that I believe if a child is in second grade or rather in third grade this year that means that they've been with us for four years which means that they started school during the pandemic correct are we seeing any other impacts that um May po potentially be attributed to the dip that we're seeing yes and if if uh you can go back to slide eight in this this Gap um that Gap that we're seeing right there this year-over-year dip

040that we saw in Fall 2023 and grade three we think it's partly because of the impacts from the pandemic but this is also the place where we're studying right now this these data are really important for us to really dive in deeper to see okay what's really impacting that we could say the pandemic but there's pieces to the pandemic but I I think this is more around uh our recovery efforts and our our implementation of our strategies and doing it in a in a strong and coherent way and I don't think we've had as much opportunity to do that with this group given what they went through during the pandemic that tracks for me because as a teacher what's coming to my mind is that if you're looking at right those students if I'm not

041mistaken still had the foundational experience of kindergarten in class that's that's correct and if we're looking at this particular cohort the chances that they had that are are low right or they went to a different educational environment potentially came back we could pontificate and speculate about all those things but what this says to me is that the foundational pieces of literary instruction which kind of speaks to the goal that we're adopting in second grade right hopefully um are incredibly critical to the point to where as we continue to go through this process really thinking about how do the experiences in K one and two impact what our ultimate goal is for whatever the grade might be that we're measuring right because what I would imagine is that unless there's something significant that happens in between

042um and y'all have talked a little bit about like the fact that this you know we we notice this dip uh specifically during the summer um I think that like the fact that we're moving from learning to read to reading to learn is a is a big indicator right so I don't know personally and I would love to hear at some point whether it's responding in writing or talking at this moment like how much of it do you actually think is like summer slide which we there's data that says maybe it is maybe it isn't and how much of that do you think it is like the inate transition to the model that we are using to measure progress and growth like let me try to rephrase that question into something more clear I guess

043my the first part of that question is are we utilizing the same measure in second grade to measure preparedness as we are in third grade like it's the same structure of testing is that accurate or no that that is accurate okay given that I'm still trying to parse out and what I would love to see in in writing at the appropriate time is if you look at this cohort what could potentially be some outlying factors that are impacting them because this drop is statistically significant in my eyes and how are we going to catch them up yes so a couple things um one is a is a positive outlier is that 44.2% of our students with IEPs are are seeing a 5.7% % increase and so what what that suggests to us is that our

044mtss work is is effective there our inclusionary work is effective there how we're utilizing adults uh in the classroom is effective we're doing push in instead of pull out so I think we may be seeing some of the fruits of our labor from from those efforts and so I think there's a some positive outliers that we can learn from as we go through this so uh it's kind of disruptive disrupting our thinking because we were trying to look at oh is it the summer slide is it are these all these how are we seeing uh significant increase with our students with IEPs and so we're still kind of learning and walking through this to try to understand it better ourselves right so so that actually just triggered another question I swear I'm going to be

045quick it's all good I love the fact that you brought that up because what that says to me is that uh interventions and individualized instruction work s right that's that's pretty that's pretty clear how do we in the vein of targeted universalism take those aspects that we know are working and through mtss or whatever structure y'all um are are putting hanging your hat on how do we provide that type of experience to as many students as possible within the resource constraints that we have at this moment is is it possible and do you need um anything to change from the board's perspective to make that happen right because here's here's where I'm getting with this you just told me that students with IEPs and indivi individualized instruction plans are actually increasing when we have our

046general population students who are decreasing what I want to know is how am is that right okay tell me if I'm wrong wrong okay what I want to know is what changes in our funding and our budget conversations do we need to make in order to give more support to this particular cohort right that is the type of I would say intertwining of our progress monitoring and our budget conversations as we enter those in the next few weeks I want to know specific what are my options to let go of potentially to incorporate more of the strategies that you're seeing clearly are working at this level for some students to as many students as possible so uh couple couple responses to that One Singular response actually my last three School visits were to Beacon Hill

047LOL and Santa slow and what I saw that was effective at each one is they had adults with very clear roles function seamlessly with each other and so they were uh in in the those School leaders and those school teams were maximizing every adult's time talent and treasure in a way that was was powerful and so the way they were implementing mtss the way they were doing push in the way they were I had had groupings of students was powerful so if we see budget requests come through to support those type of uh interventions or practices I think that's where we're going to see uh Dynamic changes and so uh LOL in particular was a is a um an early adopter of the what's what are they priority school and but they're they along with

048Gatewood they're uh cohort they're part yeah they're part of the udl cohort and so the Universal Design learning cohorts are the are the we're starting to see a dedicated resource uh to help them to have consistency and predictability so I think that's an other piece uh for the job embedded professional development uh so request for one focused uh adult supports uh that are that are uh strategic and then the professional development for udl and in these inclusive practices I I think you would see uh you I think if I was advising a board I'd say analyze our budget for those type of things that are go along with our strategy I don't know if I fully okay great thank you um okay so I have a couple of questions um so when I look at

049the top four points of the executive summary um while I am well it's great to see an increase in uh proficiency of student with IEPs I wonder when we break that down if that's attributed mostly to White students or if that includes students of color with IEPs an increase is great but if who we're trying to focus on and who is clearly um uh experiencing decline are African American male students of color furthest from educational Justice and multilingual Learners who are more likely than not also students of color if those students also have IEPs and are not included in the increase that to me says more about white students than it does about IEPs and the way and how our system is or isn't serving students of color so I'm curious about that if we

050were to break down the IEP data if that shows a correlation along racial demographics or not um it's still positive uh but um yeah uh and then I notice that across all schools those that enroll smaller proportions of African-American males and students further from educational Justice declined faster which I'm really interested in because then later it says that nothing emerg as a major factor but if there was a more significant decline where there's a smaller population that seems to me to be a factor of some kind so I would like to know more about what what we attribute that to and what we could maybe do to address it is that a function of having many many elementary schools that are under enrolled is that a function or not of having staff spread very thinly

051and having St students um be sort of in isolated pockets instead of with a with a bit larger Community I don't know but I certainly would like to especially if you notice that um uh that data point um and then I'm wondering about uh I guess and this is all you know also as we move into talking about the Strategic plan May signal an increasing need for expand and learning during the summer months I think I I would be more I mean I think that's probably a great solution but I with out but with the next bullet point saying nothing emerged as a major factor in the decline I would be concerned with the suggestion of a solution when we haven't identified the problem so um my question after all that is the uh analysis

052of demographic changes and and test taking participation rates not indicating anything um I would ass assume that maybe there's more happening at the school base level um and I and I wonder if you all think there's more to look at there I mean for me basically saying there's a significant decline but we don't know why to me says we still need to figure out why so our what is what is the next step in this into figuring out the current reality for our students where this cohort declined um and is projected to continue upon that for the spring ASC what can be done between now and then to um change that President Rankin you you have some really astute observations here and I I believe you're talking about uh what is racial Equity 2.0 in

053Seattle public schools and I think we're talking about uh access to consistency access to the high leverage strategies uh the the consistency in that and so I think as we look at uh the differences here uh and why are they why is there deviance between these different groups I I'm thinking as we dig deeper into this we're going to see that certain students have higher access to uh the best mtss practices the best UD udl practices the best high lever teaching practices and so as we think about uh the next interation of our strategic planning I I think we're really talking about access to the best of the best that we have to offer and I don't know if if we have Clarity well I know we don't have Clarity yet as to which students

054get that at which schools how that manifests but I think that's what we're seeing is a little bit of inconsistency between school to school to school and that may that may be break broken down demographically it may be broken down based on income we're not sure yet but I think you've raised the the the ideal question around the intersectionality of all those pieces and I think that's our next our next step as we step into this strategic plan to look at again access to consistent and predictable tier tier one practices that's the I think that's the key is this on oh yeah okay um is that all for you president Ranken um yeah yeah yep okay um I don't see anybody else's uh name tag put to the side so does that mean there no

055I have a question but I'll I'll go last um oh okay do you have a question too Joe just a followup to Li oh okay okay you wanted yeah I just wanted to to to to agree that um disaggregating the racial demographic data from the IEP data would be very interesting for future reports yeah we we'll we'll get on that we have those data we'll just enter them into our next report yes okay director Clark oops turn my mic off director Clark thanks um I think I had a similar question to Joe but yeah is it possible for us to like map school by school which students are receiving access to these supports and which ones aren't or is that too granular like it's it's not too granular and that's um that's what we're doing

056internally uh we have it we have it broken down just just as you've talked about it um I don't know if it's just a limitation of the six pages that we have but uh I think we can figure out an elegant way to enter that into here if that if that's of interest to the board for sure yeah I mean I feel like that would be important information for us to have as we go into strategic planning and budget conversations thank you and and director Clark If I may follow up by asking that can you go deeper on the the question that you want to that you're trying to to tease out because we want to be responsible ultimately and if you don't have that answer now that's fine um I don't think I necessarily

057have I guess my question is more around um yeah are we equitably Distributing our resources and if not how can we um balance things out to ensure that um that our our students who are um who need more investment are getting the the the investment they need yeah I appreciate that and as we we're in year zero of kind of doing our of doing our diagnostic work th that's those are the type of things when we start to talk about programmatic service mix uh we want to be looking at so so thank you for that question president rank in this is so not a strategic question and really not allowable but I can't I so you don't have to answer it but all all of these different things that were examined that nothing emerged uh

058exploring a range of possible other factors teacher tenure teacher aism BL La I I feel like teachers and students and families would probably be able to tell you why they think they're having challenges and they're just not represented here so that's that was really an unallowable question but in terms of like I don't see how we can even talk about trying to determine the factors when the people who are the closest who are the students themselves and who are the closest to the students um like they might be able to say oh yeah this major change happened at our school and we know exactly why this led to a challenge in Reading instruction I mean they also might not know but we need to ask them ask ask your question because I you said it's

059not techn or you may be technical or strategic but I want to actually try to walk well I in in in trying to ask you know in trying to look at what the current reality is for our students and hear from you all what you're thinking about in terms of addressing it where is talking to teachers and students and families about you know it says nothing emerges as a major factor but so let why did you ask them let me let me give you an example so uh I mentioned uh had school visits and I was talking to Chelsea principal at LOL and one of the things that she Prides herself on and the staff is consistency and and when uh they have uh substitutes or they have people on on long-term leaves it it

060impacts their consistency so when we start talking about teacher absenteeism or uh ia's not being there it kind of impacts their ability to do their work we don't know in the aggregate what those are yet I mean so we need to continue to break those down so when we say nothing emerges yet we haven't really gotten to kind of the bottom line or the root cause analysis for some of these so so some schools may have different needs I know at L for example uh jelie was talking about consistency is their currency that's that is the thing that is most valuable to to her and their team as they as they deliver services and they have a very diverse population in multiple ways and so I think for that particular school it's around consistency so

061when we start naming all those different things it could be uh multiples of those or some schools may have a greater impact with just one of those factors but that's the work we're doing right now so I I appreciate the question okay seeing no other questions I'm going to ask my question oh oh sorry I'm so sorry Colin I didn't see that from down here please go ahead oh well okay I mean LI or president ranking kind of beat me to it uh cuz I didn't know if I could ask it it it is more technical but cuz when I look at these like when I read through all of these I see a lot of numbers and we love numbers and when I hear you talking it's a lot of that but like during

062your diagnos diagnostic like period here that we're going into how much time are you going to spend on those less numbery like more talking to people things talking to your students talking to your teachers talking to your parents to make sure that we are cuz a lot of the questions that are being posed of we don't know I feel like can be answered partially when you just ask someone and it will look different for school to school I understand that but like what what will that look like is that going to happen so I think this is worthy of a response um and if any of my colleagues here uh can you talk about the pln work the PLC work the those type of work th those type of efforts where we have forms where

063we're getting data from those on the front lines who are who are actually doing that work because I I think that's a missing piece that's not articulated here so if you all could just give some highlights if you don't I don't know if it's if they can give highlights but just saying that there is missing pieces here that was that might be enough just if you say there is stuff it's just not here that is that's enough of an answer to my question I I'm I would suggest just in the interest of time that I think that's a great question and and I think everybody's interested in the answer to it so if that could be included in the written responses that get sent to all of the board including the student board members that

064would be um I think the best most efficient way to get that question answered okay some some of that is already in the memo but we'll we'll get more specific okay Ranken sorry I have one more and it is a strategic question um as the various the various things that uh so what I'm hearing is that you all have identified that strong instructional leadership in the principal is one of the best like is LOL and um what was the other school that you said I just happen to have L and Gatewood that have been um some of the strongest aligned to the the um udl and mtss implementation um they the students that attend those schools do they represent the the the African-American males and students of color do th students at those schools represent

065a departure from the decline overall was there less of a decline at those schools at Gatewood and R um I I don't know those specifically we may have those data but demographically we don't I don't have that right now but yeah cuz I'm what I'm hearing is sort of a vague uh statement that that leadership is really important for the success of students so if that's the case I would expect strong instructional leadership on the part of the principal to be a pretty powerful strategy that we should be investing in so we do we do believe strong instructional leadership is one of the keys and we've we've kind of said that throughout um and regardless if you're at those udl the udl early adopter schools or some of the uh School that we're seeing uh

066really good outcomes you're you're seeing strong instructional leadership and so that's really around the consistency of the practices that's really focusing on data that's really providing the type of uh timely relevant professional development that's necessary and so I I think you'll see that common to any of these schools that are are we're seeing a positive growth I don't know if that's the answering your well no I'm I'm guess I'm wondering if you've if you've identified that that is meaningful in terms of the outcomes Would we not expect to see that that is that investing in principle support and implementation of these best practices is a strategy that is worth pursuing and investing in instead of leaving it up to what people feel like I don't know CU I can't tell if if the if you

067know correlation causation it feels like you're saying that those two schools are outliers and then that is important and so to me I wonder why there's not that would be a strategy ensuring that principles are implementing these best practices and the investment in that would be in the accountability and support from central office no you cannot um I my question sort of don't understand what yeah my question is is sort of tangentially related so I wonder if it makes sense to just pile on um I you know I it's the increase in math proficiency for seventh grade is awesome and um really um positive and and I'm wondering about these high leverage strategies um that that we know are working or that we believe are the reason behind the Improvement that we are seeing and

068what what do you see Dr Jones as the um barriers to widespread implementation of those strategies so taking um like to to Liza's point that like we do have a really decentralized system where every school is kind of doing its own thing um so how do we create a a a system where we can Implement these strategies with Fidelity across the entire District the the things that we know are working how do we do the implementation part of that is is my question yeah so um we've been talking about uh having instructional coaching we talk talking about plc's common common adopted curriculum uh doing that across the board and so we know that there's been uh we haven't adopted uh systemwide curriculum now we've now we've done that we're we're a couple of years in

069so we're starting to see that happen one of the pieces that we've talked about is curriculum and beted assessments we've we've done that uh intermittently now we're seeing that consistently we're seeing that at about 80% across the board for for all of our schools so that consistency in terms of uh using the assessment calendar making sure that you have job embedded professional development making sure you have coaching you're looking at data when we see those things happen consistently across the board then we'll start to see that's our theory of action we'll we'll start to see those results and so uh I think if we were to go back two or three years uh we'd see a lot lot of deviant in terms of our people using the same uh standards based curriculum now we're start

070now we're seeing across the board everyone is using that curriculum now they're even making some reasonable and relevant demands on C central office that how can we have those in different languages you know so some of it doesn't doesn't consider uh some of the some of the diverse needs of our Learners so now they're starting to inappropriately interrogate our curriculum saying okay this is where there's gaps in it so I I think we're we moved from some uh diversity of how we were doing it to some consistency now we're starting to see people leverage the tools and I think that's the that's the key as we as we move forward so it's always been about Fidelity of implementation and it's always been about consistent practices uh scope and sequence just making sure that the everyone

071knows we're on the same page so when I talk about all those things and we start talking about instructional strong instructional leadership from a building perspective uh those School leaders that have all those together and uh can look at all of those in the Aggregate and Implement those I think again that's where you'll see the the strong uh strong gains and when and the converse of that is if they're done kind of intermittently I think we won't see gains and in fact it could be uh we could have the equal and opposite impact president Rankin back to you thanks sorry I have two two more questions um when we as we're moving towards the Strategic plan I would like to see what you all are going to do what the strategies are from central office

072to increase the presence of learning environments where the things that Dr Jones was just talking about exist um it still feels kind of like we'll just kind of see if it happens or not but when we're talking about strategies that's the strategies that we want to see um what is happening here to make that make the the implementation and the consistency a reality for more students not based on if it just happens to be there or not but based on what actions happen here um uh and then when is the next time that this the reading goal is being monitored February February February February okay so um I'll just say that uh at in that monitoring session I hope that we're talking about what changed between now and then for those students so in response

073to your statement about the Strategic plan we should see a strategic plan that looks like uh a coordinated set of implementation plans and so that's how how all these things should be manifesting that's going to be kind of the difference between our past strategic plan and this strategic plan our past strategic plan was a set of extraordinarily brilliant ideas and Visions this strategic plan should be uh a set of strategies and how they're going to be implemented with uh with timeline s with with uh monitoring along the way in a way that we we haven't seen before but I think this is going to be the difference between the Seattle Excellence plan which was ideal and everybody saw it across the nation and thought it was fantastic and it's still is now we're moving into

074a strategic plan that should should should speak to how are we going to implement each one of these strategies over time and so that's that's what it should look like director [Music] Clark uh all right thanks um I guess kind of piggybacking off of um where president Ranken was going um and um director brag um about you know trying to identify deeper Identify some some of the gaps that we're seeing as far as whether it's uh instruction with Fidelity or teacher absences or you know trying to identify some of the causes um I'm curious if um like would it be like I'm thinking about the budget and curious if like funding for some kind of broader qualitative study where like we can actually bring people on to go into schools and have those conversations with

075students and families or surveys or whatever like the methodology might be um is something that you think would be helpful in um when we're looking at the budget or the Strategic plan so that's my first question yes so one of the things that we're doing in supported that is the re is a resource allocation study to see where where our resources going and are they having the right impact but I also was remiss in not uh affirming that the uh any time that we can we can generate get to talk to those who are closest to the work to understand what some of their challenges and barriers are and opportunities is always a good thing so we can we can uh if we have those opportunities we should take them early and often uh if

076we can be more strategic and intentional About It by uh using some third party to come in and help us uh to do some uh analysis that that's great too but I I don't want to uh run by the fact that uh talking to those who are closest to the work is is powerful in terms of us understanding it I mean there's evidence-based things that we talk about all the time there's research-based there's there's promising practices but how it manifest at the point of Service delivery educational delivery you can't get better data than that so I I didn't really touch on that but I just want to affirm that that's a really important thing talking about what president Ranken and director brag were speaking to thank you I appreciate that um and then my second

077question um there's a point here and I'm I'm looking at the third grade reading progress monitoring memo on page two um uh the point that says um this may signal an increasing need for expanded learning during the summer months and I see a note here that about a fifth of students um for this from educational Justice participated in summer school I'm wondering did did those oneth of students that participated in summer school see an increase in their scores is that I I wasn't here I'm just trying to better understand that data point yeah the answer is yes I I can't speak to the specificity of it but there are we we did see in the aggregate yes and one thing I want to say about summer school uh that's kind of recovery and catchup we

078want to really try to embed you know during our 180 days the best of practices we can have uh but for some of those students that we haven't served them well enough I I think summer school is certainly an opportunity to try to bring bring them back up to standard great thank you any last questions okay I think we're I think we're done thank you thank you thank you um uh directors and superintendent we are going to stay here at the tables for this next item before we move back to the Das for public testimony so um we have a uh fairly Hefty report thank you uh which we're not going to go through all of it right now this is just intended to provide a touch point and update from uh Moss Adams about

079this work and there's much more for us to do in the future and not right now in this in this moment um so uh from Moss Adams we are joined by Colleen rosiles here in person and Annie Rose fa uh sorry favro remotely for their um presentation of the completed governance assessment for Seattle Public Schools uh if you'll remember in June um we voted uh to contract with moss Adams to support the board's work to implement a a policy governance model um we started work in 2021 in the adoption of this model and have um faced some significant challenges to implementation so we asked for um Moss Adams to come and support us with the in-depth kind of Investigation of what's what's moving what's not moving why and then uh what can we do about

080it um so this is uh um very much aligned with this shouldn't be a dramatic surprise to anybody um but very very helpful to see it all laid out here and um give us a path forward as we continue to implement and and improve our practices as a board um and our direction to the district uh into the coming year and Beyond so um Dr Jones has a comment or two I think and then we'll go to uh Colleen and Annie Rose so uh thank you president Rank and I think this is really important that we're uh doing this work we're talking about creating effective governance so we can have clear predictable uh metrics we can have Clarity in terms of our goals Clarity in terms of our our roles um and if we recall

081the last strategic plan we kind of retrofitted the goals on top of our our goals and guard rails on top of the last strategic plan this is our opportunity through this effective governance that we can do this in advance and we can do it in the right order and so uh the last thing I want to to state is we're doing a lot of diagnostic work as I've talked about in year zero one of the areas that we're doing is is governance um my role as a superintendent is around implementation so this work that's helping us uh diagnose where we have gaps is is tremendous and is valuable to us as we move forward and so I'm I'm grateful for the opportunity to look at you know what is what's the board's role Visa the

082superintendent's role bring that Clarity forward it's going to help us as we uh again do our diagnostic work getting ready for the next strategic plan so so thank you um and just to add to that too in terms of the board role versus superintendent role with strategic plan the board is the owner of the Top Line goals and guardrails when we adopt those in January we are not part of the I mean we'll be in conversation about it and want to know about it and I'm sure want to you know be invited or be present to different Community conversations but once we set our goals the development of the Strategic plan is 100% the responsibility of the superintendent which means that for the next five or six months we have some time to dedicate to

083the recommendations that are in here about governance um that you know obviously align but uh you know the the heavy lift of the board for strategic plan is is getting the goals in guardrail set and then we kind of we don't have a role to play in governance specifically until we receive recommendations and evaluate whether or not we want to accept them for the plan um so I will turn it over to Colleen and Andy Rose oh I'm G to take both microphones I'll start with this one okay good afternoon everyone my name is Colleen roselis I'm a partner at Moss Adams and I'm our firm's government National practice leader and I provided quality assurance and oversight on this project I've worked with the district since about 2017 and my colleague Annie Rose favro who's

084joining us virtually from beautiful Bakersfield California um oversaw this project and led the analysis um if you could go to the next slide please tonight we're going to give just a quick overview of this work to allow you time to ask questions I do want to know like other Assessments in this type of work will be um coming back to the audit committee there will be regular progress reporting the district has already put together a draft implementation plan so you'll be able to continue to engage with this through the audit committee process like all the other assessment work across the district so next up I just have a quick overview of our background in um 2017 the board commissioned a study if you could go to the next slide please related to operational efficiency within

085the teaching and learning function of the district and one of the recommendations in that study was to align governance practices with a policy governance model which is a best practice in the public sector in 2021 the board adopted student outcomes focused governance which is a policy governance framework and our objective was to assess where the district is in implementing policy governance our main objective was really to look at those rules and responsibilities how far are we Along on this path within the school board those that directly support the school board the superintendent office District staff and then we also looked at kind of that big picture of what is the school board responsible for what does governance mean so it's not just the operations in these me meetings But it includes progress monitoring it includes

086risk management and compliance and so we wanted to look at that holistically as part of our work we benchmarked the district against other districts that had um adopted either student outcomes focused governance or policy governance and then we provided recommendations on how to get um closer to the district's goals on the next slide we show our methodology so we conducted interviews with folks across the district from building leaders to to um folks in the superintendent cabinet all the way through to board members we reviewed a lot of documents including board meeting minutes data tools and templates all those sorts of things as I mentioned before we did peer benchmarking and also Research into industry standards and best practices and then we put all that together to make some recommendations and we worked with staff to

087make sure that those recommendations were practical and implementable it's really important for us in a resource constrained public sector environment that we're looking for things that actually can be implemented and so that's um hopefully what you will see um in the robust report that we provided before we get into the meet of our findings I did want to give just a quick introduction to policy governance I know those of you who are on the board are quite familiar but I think it's important as we're having this discussion in the the public to be able to talk about this a little bit um so a policy governance model is a best practice in the public sector and it identifies clear roles and responsibilities between the board and staff and it's really trying to focus the board

088on policies and goals so that the essentially the what so that the how is done by staff the folks who are experts in their particular areas and performance is then assessed on quantitative measurement of progress policy governance in the public sector is also characterized by strong connections to the community and their expectations should be reflected in goals and policies student outcomes Focus governance as I mentioned before is a policy governance framework it's been designed for education and the board adopted it three years ago so next up we have some commendations we always include um some nice things in our report before we identify all the opportunities for improvement a couple of things that we want to highlight for this group across the district we had Folks at all levels really acknowledging that there was a

089need to improve governance and cultivate a culture that was focused on student outcomes really using the governing body to help move the whole District forward and we also found a very strong commitment to Student Success we talked to folks again in buildings all the way up to the board we were very impressed by uh the theme of student outcomes there I also want to acknowledge that environment that the district has operated in uh since this model was adopted in 2021 so it was adopted the height of the pandemic there have been significant budget challenges there's been board and Leadership turnover there are a lot of barriers to change and so the fact that there has been some progress is good would we like to see more progress yes but we think there's a lot of

090opportunity for additional progress and to build on the momentum that has been made so far so with that I'm going to turn it over to my colleague Annie Rose to cover our recommendations thank you so much can you hear me okay in the room yes great all right well then I'm going to quickly go through the um recommendations we had our observations and recommendations broken into three sections transition policy governance leadership engage engagement and governance processes and there were two recommendations in that first section we first looked at implementation planning as Colleen mentioned we know that the district adopted this model in early 2021 and there has been work at both the board and the management level to implement a variety of new practices processes reports Staffing structures to support support this work and the

091various um processes that come off of the governance model and a lot of that work has taken place in the past year however we noted that there has not yet been a unified planning process that really outlines the work that is yet to be done at both the board and the management level so the recommendation here focuses on collaboratively developing that type of plan to guide the next set of implementation activities and we hope that this report will also support that planning process the second area that we looked at was communication and change management and that's because when you're implementing a new uh policy governance model especially one like sofg that has very specific ways of setting goals and Reporting on data and incorporating Community impact all of which have operational implications Um this can

092impact positions really across the district and so it's particularly important within context like this that there is very clear communication and that when things are changed there's help to support folks through those changes and there's been a lot going on at the district since 2021 so while the board has been fairly well kind of brought along in this work in terms of training and coaching we did find a wide variety of levels of understanding within different areas of the organization about policy governance and its practical implications and while by no means everyone needs to be an expert in policy governance we do need to make sure that staff particularly those who support the specific related processes that support sofg and those who may be answering questions from the community have enough information to do that

093work well so the recommendation here is really related to developing that comprehensive communication and training plan that is tailored to different groups within the organization and in particular focusing on clearly documenting roles and responsibilities so that when employees have questions they have a really clear point of contact within the organization if you go to the next slide our second section focused on leadership engagement there are three recommendations here first we're looking at board engagement and the board has made positive progress toward implementing this policy governance framework and there are still some challenges to ensuring that this framework is fully understood but most importantly regularly applied in a practical manner so the recommendation here is focused on continuing to en the board's Effectiveness in implying that policy governance framework and doing that through things like um

094continuing to receive coaching regularly using the sofg tools continuing to improve communication especially in terms of responding to constituent concerns adopting tools like School visitation policies and other things like that to make sure that there are appropriate methods both to understand and respond to constituents because because this um framework really shifts some of those um more traditional kind of constituent engagement activities in terms of um central office engagement um the superintendent the cabinet other teams across the district are responsible not only for engaging with this work and and kind of championing this model especially in relation to the goals and guardrail structure and some of those related processes like data monitoring and there has been some good progress on this front but there is still varying degrees of Engagement and understanding of this work so

095the recommendation here focuses on continuing I would say those current efforts to clarify roles incorporate responsibilities into standard practices like incorporating it into job descriptions performance evaluation process those types of things and making full use of the relatively newer project management infrastructure and team that has been put into place that can really help move this work forward finally we also looked at Board office support right now this team there are several vacant roles and there's certainly a need for support because as all of you know board roles are volunteers some of the members of the board office support team currently split their time between board support and Performing other tasks um and what we learned here is that uh based on peer benchmarking data at least there is not a singular best practice in terms

096of how to set up this team so we would recommend continuing and and going in and assessing whether the current roles within the board office are fully aligned with the needs and the priorities of the board and specifically as part of that defining the responsibilities of each position and distinguishing which roles and which features of those roles support the board versus assisting superintendent cabinet members or performing other tasks to help reduce confusion and ensure the tasks um can be focused on as as um they are received in priority order and then on our last slide we have quite a few pieces here related to the governance process if you can go forward one slide so our last few recommendations are really focused on some of the processes that support this work so our first one

097strategic planning and goal setting under the sofg model it's important that the Strategic goals and guide rails are based in the needs of the community as we have been discussing tonight and for those goals to really Cascade throughout the or organization and the district is in the process of implementing this model as part of your most recent strategic planning work that is in in the works right now there were good strides to offering more comprehensive opportunities for Community input within that process so moving forward the recommendation is to continue to expand those efforts and ensure that there's that strong stakeholder input especially also incorporating input from school level staff during the goal setting process and taking steps to establish a cascading goal structure so there's strong alignment between the priorities that are established in in

098the Strategic plan and those individual for example Department operating plans number seven we looked at data and progress monitoring and again as we saw earlier this evening there are strides happening in terms of coming and presenting information and implementing new structures to support progress monitoring but there are some challenges here and Shing the data is collected reported and acting acted on in a timely manner so the recommendation focuses on ensuring that for example the accountability office has full access to the essential data that they need to um productively monitor the work exploring options to incorporate educator input into the data that is selected and used and continuing those efforts to strengthen the review process to make sure that we're not only receiving this data but actually taking action upon it and making shifts in strategy

099so that it can fully inform decision-making processes accountability was another area that we looked at as we know historically the district has struggled to cultivate a culture of healthy accountability and that can get in the way of ensuring that districtwide initiatives including the policy governance framework but certainly not limited to that and its related processes making sure that those District wide initiatives are actually implemented and the district has a lot of the pieces in place to make this work happen but there is still work to be done so the recommendation focuses on clarifying expectations empowering the accountability office and supporting consistent Equitable implementation of District initiatives like standardized curriculum and similar a big part of this and continuing to also strengthen the collaboration between central office and school level staff to address Mutual concerns and

100continue to build trust in that area compliance oversight was another area we looked at as part of the board governance role to provide oversight in this area we noted that the district has not yet established a centralized compliance function and instead individual departments and teams are responsible for various aspects of compliance monitoring and Reporting and so with that kind of limited coordination there may be risks of non-compliance and it's really challenging to see a holistic picture of compliance activities across the district so we would recommend establishing a compliance Matrix which is a tool that can help give you that holistic picture and considering creating a position to provide more of that centralized compliance oversight and coordination and finally in terms of risk management in the past the district's risk management activities have often focused on

101operational or kind of more tactical issues and right now the RIS risk management function is going through a period of transition you have a new risk manager that's that's kind of refocusing this role to provide more strategic um organization wide risk management leadership and even with limited staff we do want to note that the district has integrated many industry best practices within this space to strengthen its risk management framework things like periodic Enterprise risk assessments maintaining a comprehensive risk register providing risk updates on a quarterly BAS to the audit committee and I believe you're in the process of updating the district's risk register as well so the recommendation is to continue those efforts and continue to strengthen the Enterprise risk management function and ensuring that that risk manager can uh have appropriate resources so that

102they can operate at uh the Strategic level so with that I believe we can close out our presentation here and see what questions you may have I got questions wh sorry thank you very very much um I'm just quick notes before we go to questions the implementation planning is something we've already undertaken that is in progress um uh an implementation timeline uh a refresh of what we had previously um that will delineate between uh um board responsibilities and superintendent responsibilities and give us some some steps to track our progress and to make sure that we do the things that need to get done um and so I think we will I can't remember now but at the retreat we'll probably talk somewhat January Retreat about that about um Community engagement policies again what's board what's

103superintendent um and uh we also have for just uh tentatively for the board retreat discussing um a board code of conduct or just board operating procedure what however we want to call it um but that is again a standard practice of how we do our work together um that will help a lot with number three that we'll also be talking about in January I have a question for Liza not this if I can real fast or president Rankin um so you the implementation plan you expect it to be ready in January I think we'll have a draft in January do you remember yeah and and um yeah I think we'll have in January to look at and then we we'll adopt it too so we won't we'll we'll have a formal introduction and adoption all

104right uh director seru um my question is this is the first time that I'm hearing the term accountability office and so I'm sure I missed something but I need I need clarification like what is the accountability office and who works in it so we have an accountability office um and our accountability officer for the for our district is Ted Howard um and we have kind of three connecting pieces we have uh the the Str excuse me the Strategic piece where the academic folks come up with our strategy and then we have the Imp impementation piece where we have uh a team PL plans and programs office uh as well as our uh student support services our regional executive directors that provide the implementation support and then we have the accountability office who monitors and measures

105how well this implementation is happening how well the the strategy is being implemented and so uh that position's been on board for two years now and and uh again it's LED by Ted Howard has research and evaluation in in there as Partnerships um but that's that's that's the office okay okay so what I'm thank you so when I read empower the accountability office with access to essential data incorporate educator input into Data metrics I won't I won't cover that so the fact that this report is stating to empower the accountability office sounds to me like they're they don't have power and what you just described was that they should that this office partially exists that those that wasn't your word but to collect data and ensure implementation is happening and if they have no power

106and they're not collecting data that seems like a big disconnect for me and again I'm willing to accept that I'm missing something here um and maybe this is not the time to discuss it but it's concerning to me that an office with the title accountability office doesn't have power and they don't have access to essential data because that defeats a lot of the things that we're that we're trying to do and so I'm not saying we need to have that conversation right now in public but I do not believe this report would actually point that out if that office had power and had access to the data there's something in their research that discovered that this office does not have power and that they don't have access to data and that to me seems like

107something that really needs to be turned around very quickly because it's essential to a high functioning district and outcomes for our kids from that then this is just my opinion and my assessment so vice president SAR you uh I I'll let um our folks who did the report kind of explain that uh but I believe they do have power I believe that they do have data and I'm the one that's empowered them and so uh there may be a different way to kind of characterize it um from from uh those who did our evaluation on this but I that that was something that I kind of said emphatically that that office is powerful and office has range it has influence uh but if it's not obvious then we need to maybe do some more clarity

108and clarifying and and marketing or communication about it but that's certainly uh individ ual in there are are powerful and influential as well as uh having a great range of data uh access to data so uh folks can speak to it now or later but I just didn't want to let that lay because it's it's part of the challenge for me is that again I am willing to take responsibility and ownership that I miss something right I mean I'm I'm trying to get through 3,000 emails 2,000 of them which are about school closures and I have a full-time job this is just for the audience and so I do my best to keep up at that this is the first time that in my memory I'm hearing the actual term accountability office and F yes

109I know Ted Howard but I but I didn't know that he was in charge of the accountability office because we've had no interaction action with him related to I think the things that we need as a board um that we need to do our jobs best and so maybe there's a gap in how implementation happens and that's what we should address but for me it's I would like my board directors to weigh in did I miss something okay I'm I'm seeing people shake their heads so thank you um I see you're oh sorry Annie Rose did you go ahead yes if I could speak to that apologies because I cannot fully see the Dynamics in the room so um two two pieces that I would add to this and Colleen obviously if you have other

110elements to add here as well I do think the item that superintendent Jones brought up is very important in terms of clarifying roles and responsibilities and this this goes to some of the elements that we spoke to earlier around making sure that there is very clear documentation around what each of these groups do why they exist what the work is and that's something that we found and and not just for the accountability office but some other groups that are doing really important and critical work we don't have a centralized place where all of those roles are described within the report within the central office engagement section there is a description of roles and responsibilities specifically related to the policy governance model so might help be the beginning of some of that description but in general

111clarifying those roles and responsibilities and and fully communicating those out in a consistent way I think is a is a big piece of this conversation the other element that I wanted to add specifically when we're talking about data and progress monitoring is that a lot of um especially for data that falls outside some of those really really key elements that you will be getting through um your standardized assessments and testing a lot of the other types of data that might be useful in this situation really rely on cooperation and investment of time at the individual School level as well and making sure that there's a really clear um communication happening clear expectation setting happening there um and this goes back to how do we ensure that there's consistent implementation of district-wide initiatives and so that

112speaks to a piece of why I think the accountability office has not always been able to get get all of the data that they would be interested in getting and receiving as part of their work is because this is a very very large shift that relies on many people to um come and and help provide data and input as well so that section does get into quite a bit more detail around some of those challenges but I just wanted to highlight those pieces too um excuse me thank you uh I I just I want to um if anybody has question more questions specifically for Colleen or Annie Rose let's get those asks but if you're if we're I want to stop us from getting too far into the actual recommendations and and deliberating over what

113we should or shouldn't do next we will do that what the intention was for this tonight was for the um these two folks to to present this make sure everybody has access to the full report there's tons more in this is a great overview there's tons more there to read um but something that I wanted just to say is how important it is that um this isn't anything personal about anybody the since at least 1990 maybe before that but since at least 1990 it has been recommended by multiple outside professional entities to the Seattle School District that the number one lever for improving the system improving customer and Community engagement in service and most importantly improving outcomes is for the board to adopt a policy governance model that has been made multiple times again going

114back to 1990 and so that this is our reality didn't happen in one year didn't happen in five years it's happened over many decades and um trying to figure out whose fault it may have been is totally unimportant we're all here now we have this information now we have an opportunity to change the trajectory for our students now and hopefully this will help get us closer to making some progress that has not been made yet that is long overdue so um we'll have a lot more to talk about in terms of the recommendations and how we get there but does anybody have any more questions for Colleen or Annie Rose Michelle is that do you have another question no okay okay well then I will say thank you thank you very much some fun uh

115winter break reading going even deeper into all of these recommendations but thank you so much this is a huge value ad um for us here thank you Annie Rose um we're going to go to public testimony so we're going to go back up there um and then um do you guys want five minutes before public does okay we're going to take five [Music] I [Music] m [Music] m [Music] for those who are joining us on the phone right now um waiting public testimony the board is currently at recess and we'll be called back to order relatively shortly [Music] there and [Music] all right we're going to go ahead and move along we have uh two empty seats up here that I'm sure will be filled momentarily so I'm going to go ahead and get us

116going um we are now going to go to public testimony uh board procedure 1430 BP provides the rules for Testimony I ask that speakers are respectful of these rules in summary some important parts of this procedure feach are as follows first testimony will be taken today from those individuals called from the public testimony list and if act applicable the waiting list which are included on today's agenda posting on the Schoolboard website only those who are called by name should unmute their phones or step forward to the podium and only one person should speak at a time listed speakers May Seed their time to another person when the listed speaker's name is called but the total amount of time allowed will not exceed 2 minutes for the combined speakers uh time will not be restarted after

117the new speaker begins and the new speaker will not be called again later if excuse me if they are on the testimony list or waiting list those who do not wish to have time seated to them may Decline and if you are on the testimony or wait list you can retain your place uh the majority of the speaker time should be spent on the topic you have indicated you wish to speak about and the board expects the same standard of Civility for those participating in public comment as we expect of oursel um as board president I have the right to and will interrupt any speaker who fails to observe the standard of Civility required by board procedure BP a a speaker who refuses or fails to comply with these guidelines or otherwise substanti substantially disrupts

118the orderly operation of this meeting may be asked to leave and staff will read off the testimony speakers good evening for Ton's testimony um please do uh start your testimony by reintroducing yourselves I apologies in advance I will not be getting all of your names pronounced correctly um and if you are joining us by phone I will be uh enabling it so that you can unmute when your turn comes and you can press star six at that time to unmute on the conference line that is star six you'll also need to unmute on your device the first Speaker today is lilan STW well after lilan will be Ryan sander and then Hamza [Music] Ali hello my name is Lillian sto and I from Denny International Middle School my siblings go to West Seattle Elementary in

119Chief South in the present day there's no place more important than a school library there students can physically interact with people a rare occurrence in the days of social media when the libraries open all day people can stop by anytime for a book recommendation from our librarian a thing that's so important but often overlooked finding the right book is the key to learning to like reading and Librarians have time to pick one out for you I know that I never enjoyed reading until I found my sort of book and many others agree over 800 people have come into Denny's Library since September that's more than the entire School dur during lunch alone to find a book take a break from the noise of the cafeteria hang out with friends join a club like crocheting club

120or print something in our 3D printers or have a safe space to read a variety of things that no other place has the ability to fulfill people from Madison Middle School feel like the LA library is a safe space to read too my friend merera spends 15 minutes every day in the morning in the Madison Library just reading things are the same at Denny a tidal one school in South Seattle the library is utilized by so many people and fulfills the needs of so many students and the thing is since the library matters so much to so many people that taking full-time Librarians away is going to take a vital part of kids schooling away I'm not the only person thinking like this I and other classmates in 7eventh grade have gotten the signatures of

121a third of Denny's students 242 in all in agreement with this statement Seattle public school needs their Librarians thank you for listening the next speaker is Haley Ryan sander hello I am Haley Ryan I'm Ryan sander representing my Ballard High School library as a library ta I have come to understand that libraries are a crucial part of a school's ecosystem they provide more than just books My Librarian at Ballard has spent years cultivating her Library into a welcoming welcoming space that offers safety warmth and diversity she has done just that every day students flock to our library for academics books eating lunch and more honestly a space where we know we can feel accepted secure and happy a space that wouldn't be there if our library hours are cut in my four years at Ballard

122I have utilized Library Space daily because I know it is an area where I can be scholarly and make good use of my time and feel safe while doing so My Librarian plays an important part in all of this she is a bridge between students teachers and academics and in is an adviser to a number of Library oriented clubs in my case she is the adviser to a club I am president for comic book club we meet weekly in the library for discussion snacks and comics and good times if you are deciding to cut library and librarian hours making it a non-accessible space my Club will not only lose its advisor but also the space in which we discuss our books making libraries and their curators part-time is not a problem solver I rely on

123this space other students rely on this space and teachers rely on our Librarians as fellow Educators I implore you to consider the lives of your students and their well-being over your budget we love our libraries and we need our libraries thank you the next speaker is Hamza Ali after Hamza will be Mona Muhammad and then Nolan Jones Hamza you'll need to press star 6 to unmute on the conference call line uh good evening members of the board thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak today my name is ham Ali and do even H high school I'm uh here to strongly oppose the proposed reduction of the librarian workdays and closure of libraries during lunch U this decision would not just harm students but the entire School community at e hill our library isn't

124the room filled with books it's the lungs of our school's culture it's where ideas breathe and creativity thrives Miss West our librarian plays an Irreplaceable role in the in in in the making of this space uh cutting her presence is just two days a week would deprive students and teachers of essential support and resources that keep our school alive on a personal note the library has been My Sanctuary during the pandemic I couldn't go outside for 2 years when I started high school as a freshman I felt isolated I had friends but I never ate lunch with them instead I will take my lunch to the library grab a chair sit by the glass wall eat while reading lunch if became my refuge a place where I could feel at peace and connected in my

125own way I know that I'm not the only student who finds comfort and belonging in this space the library's impact goes beyond individual students during lunch is a safe haven for many a place to meet meet for Club activities or simply a place for Solace Miss West also collaborates with teachers to enhance classroom instructions whether it's designing lessons finding resources or teaching us valuable research skills reducing her availability would harm both students and staff I understand the need for budgetary Decisions by cutting Library resources but but but cut cutting Library resource is a false economy the library is investing in our education mental health mental health and future by limiting its re access we not not just cutting costs we're cutting opportunities please reconsider this proposal our libraries and Librarians are vital to the heart

126and soul of our schools Nathan Hill is a thriving because of spaces like ours and reducing its availab availability would restrain the very culture that makes our our school unique thank you for your time and consider considering the voices of students who are directly affected by decisions the next speaker is Nolan um sorry the next speaker is monira Muhammad manira if you're on the line you'll need to press star six to unmute hello my name is manira Muhammad and I'm a student at Nathan Hill High School today I want to address an issue that deeply affects not just me but my entire School Community the reduction of essential School resources particularly libraries and classrooms these spaces are not just physical areas they are the backbone of our education our community and our and our success

127as a running start student I spend part of my day taking online classes and the other part attending inperson classes at Nathan Hill the school library is my lifeline during this time it's where I go to focus to learn and to access resources I simply can't find anywhere else without it me and countless other students would lose a quiet productive space that is critical for our education but the library is so much more than just a study area for me is where I stay connected many students like me are not there during morning announcements to which I go to My Librarian Miss West who has become an invaluable source of in information she ensures I know about school events updates and opportunities but more importantly she ensures every student feels seen supported and empowered with

128Miss West is more than a library and she's the heart of my school her kindness dedication and resourcefulness have helped me and so many others succeed and to lose her consistent presence would be devastating to my community the library is also a h for Technology support helping resources that many students Reliance to complete assignments and access vital tools reducing Library access to just two days a week will Le countless students and staff without timely help creating unnecessary barriers to learning most importantly the library is a space where we create Community it's where ideas are shared friendships are built and collaboration drives it's a safe haven for students who don't who might not feel at home anywhere else in the school taking that away would be taking away more than just a room with books it'd

129be taking away a place where students find Bel logging cutting access to libraries and classrooms is not just about saving money it's about sacrificing the very resource that make education meaningful and impactful we need these spaces and we need our Librarians we need to protect what makes our schools a place for everyone to learn grow and succeed thank you for your time the next speaker is Nolan Jones Nolan Jones after Nolan will be Chris jackins and then U malen Landis good evening board members I'm oh it is the low okay is this better okay good I'm uh here back to um basically take have you guys just take a a look at the uh School Board Action Report which was going to deal with um your I guess acquiring Sap's cloud services and I don't

130know if you had a chance to look over that report or not but it's like about 88 pages long and I'd be surprised if any of you understood the technical pieces behind all of that because it's pretty in-depth and the thing is is that I would gather to say that maybe 1,000 people in the United States could possibly go through and understand the technology that's behind this system not to say that there's anything wrong with the system there isn't the thing is that you're basically purchaseing assistance for over $12 million and I've done you know some research here in terms of when I first came here over a year ago and I saw that you guys had invested over $8 million with the iPads and I looked at the purpose or the actual benefits Behind

131these they're supposed to be related to helping you know children the primary kids that are having issues but if you look at the history these systems they're not helping the children so I'm here to say to you that I have an application a software application that will help the children that are directly not getting helped and so I hope that you will find in your resources to give me a chance to put my application into your system and you'll see the benefits of it thank you next is Chris jackins [Applause] my name is Chris jackins Box 84063 Seattle 98124 my appreciation for the library testimony tonight also for Ted Howard who is in the room but has not yet been invited to speak on the minutes of the November 26th board meeting thank you for

132voting to stop school closures the minutes omitted the board discussion of future closures on Aki kosi the board is being asked to vote before receiving final environmental review please vote no on the perk notice two points number one the perk notice references an appeal one by the Seattle Education Association against the school district before the public employment relations Commission number two under order 2f the notice must be signed by an authorized District representative the copy of the notice provided with the board agenda is so tiny that the name of the signer is not clear on Final acceptance on Rising Star Elementary School at African-American Academy the reference to African-American Academy was left off the board report the district is thereby wrongly burying the history of its harmful closure of the African-American Academy on board oversight

133three points number one at a recent court hearing on Schoolboard recall there were claims of inadequate board oversight the district noted that the board still retained a board audit committee number two I attended the December 3rd board audit committee meeting the day after the board hearing the court hearing committ committee agenda item number 21 was a proposal to consider removing all board directors from the committee number three please don't do that thank you very much the next speaker is me Landis hi I'm Meen Landis I'm the librarian at McClure Middle School and the former librarian at Sandpoint Elementary and John Rogers Elementary as you consider our goals guard rails and budget please keep in mind the immeasurable value library programs offer to our school communities multiple independent Studies have shown positive correlation between highquality library

134programs and student achievement these students uh these studies are mindful of demographic factors showing that the benefits of well resource library programs are strongest for students farthest from educational Justice and students with disabilities additionally a 2022 Human Rights Campaign study showed that while half of all lgbtq students feel unsafe at school nine out of 10 of those students usually or always feel safe in their school libraries Beyond improving test scores literacy and being a safe place school librarians teach information and media literacy studies from Stanford indicate high schoolers are largely unable to identify misinformation online school librarians are information professional trained to prepare youth to navigate the vast amount of unverified information found in our changing media landscape funding School libraries is a preemptive move against misinformation because teacher Librarians Empower students with strategies to

135be Discerning users and creators of information statistics tell a story School libraries are vital to students staff and families and support SPSS goals and guardrails cutting all Librarians to halftime positions is not a a Band-Aid it would be a wound our schools need full-time certified Librarians thank you for your consideration the next speaker is Laura Marie Rivera after Laura Marie will be Hank Morgan and then an Annie Becker good afternoon uh my name is Laura Marie Rivera and I am the proud mom of four Seattle public school students two in elementary school and two recent graduates like I said very proud I've been involved in SPS since we moved up here in 2016 and there have been a lot of moments and changes since then and not all of them are productive steps in the

136right direction but as we look forward to this new strategic plan and implementing new goals and guardrails I encourage the board and all of the staff and the superintendent of course to consider all that public schools can and really should be we know that each student is an individual they come with their own strengths and challenges and hopes and dreams and I want to make sure that they will be welcomed and supported not only by the district but by their specific School communities I'm asking each of you to remember what works for some students will not work for all whe whether we were talking about academics or Sports option programs dual language immersion Advanced courses and the often ignored needs of special education we have at least 20% of our our students relying on special

137education ation services and yet the needs of these students are often an afterthought this doesn't work for their education for our communities as a whole or for the future of our society we live in one of the wealthiest cities in the country and we are operating in a massive deficit this isn't news to anyone in the room but we need to change the way that we're thinking about this I am a mom my children are of course the most precious things in the world to me and I think that all of you would agree yet when we look at our schools and the lack of investment that is going into them I wonder where our values truly are the next Administration is threatening to dissolve the Department of Education but I believe it is exactly

138that lack of education and investment in education that has brought us to this place I appreciate that Governor Insley has come out in support of Education needs and I hope that our governor-elect Bob Ferguson and all of our local legislators will carry that torch going forward if we would like to keep our societies governments and companies running we need to invest our children and Washington State needs to fully fund our schools the next speaker is Hank Morgan Hank Morgan Hank if you're on the phone you can press star six to unmute on the conference call line I'm not seeing Hank on the line so I'm going to move to our next speaker Annie Becker is Annie Becker in the room oh Annie it looks like you are unmuted on the conference line we should be

139able to hear you if for unmuted on your device che check can you hear me okay yes we can hear you excellent thank you my name is Annie Becker I am the parent of four current SPS student um in public health it is well known that the greatest failures are interventions that are conceived designed and implemented without consistent Community Partnership at every step the school closures debacle this past year has been a nightmare for parents students and teachers who all understand fully that this situation was either due to mismanagement of x five and its unintended consequences a governance model that is both obis skating District's finances a lack of authentic engagement with the community that SPS served perhaps a lack of comprehensive transparent long-term plan that involves the community or some combination of all of

140the above trust in the Schoolboard leadership and School District leadership is of an all-time low parents are rallying together with full understandings of the the consequences that if we built a coalition and campaign to vote no on Beck 6 we could but would we want to there is so much on the line with a new Becky since director song and Rivera resigned from the school board nearly a year ago there's been no school board representation on the capital oversight committee why is that well the public have many questions and concerns the biggest concerns swirl around the lack have a comprehensive multi-year plan around the conception design and implementation of capital B project and how they clearly lack Community input around which buildings are or are not included because if the public were included our first

141demand would be a comprehensive plan what is a comprehensive plan it's one that includes students teachers and parents at every step it's one that includes construction growth and up zoning in each of the School's attendance areas how our families actually utilize studio in one-bedroom apartment generally speaking it's pretty standard for most of the world to F multi generational families and multiple children in one bedroom apartment it's eurocentric to consider that we wouldn't and that's exactly what lands the district with gross underestimates of student involvment a comprehensive plan would also include all of the schools that have building conditions rated between a three and a four and would actively engage with communities to ensure that they get what they need it would plan for the future of all our schools all our communities and all of

142our children just throwing it out there but what if we ensured a $4 million in Design Services on the back for each of the Schools rated between in three and a four and what if any school that had been placed on a previous Levy for design and preparation for modernization or total replacement was named on the next Levy for the next stage in that process and since the district wants to earn the trust to the public keeping their word would be imperative because our student outcomes are Paramount keeping small schools that are appropriately sized for the school population would be part of that discussion not a 650 child school but rather smaller schools that are built for the pop using best practices and partnering with academic centers for excellence like those at the University of

143Washington the greatest mistakes are intervation or interventions or plans that are conceived designed and implemented without partnership with the community ask us which board and District governance model we want ask us if we want sosg if we are focused on student outcomes we shouldn't be spending million dolls on evaluation and implementation of a governance model that the board hasn't assessed if the public wants your your time is exhausted Please wrap up okay bring us in to partner with you bring the community back into the picture create Community co-design roles on community on committees and please reinstate the finance committee also please maintain our current Library up thank you for your time the next speaker is Megan Hamilton after Megan Hamilton will be Aaron Moore and then ba Bailey Millo hello my name is Megan Hamilton

144uh growing up I walked to North Beach with my mom and brother and dog shadow and now I live across from Santa slow Elementary with my 2-year-old and 5-year-old sanis slow is one of the most diverse student bodies in SBS 78% of students are bipo and 34% are multilingual Santa slow is a safe haven to students of color and immigrant families sanow has deep Community Partnerships and a stable staff roster it's extensive students supports and extracurriculars envy wealthier schools in the upcoming Administration spaces that are safe for students of color are going to be more important to protect and Foster yet sanow has routinely and systemically been neglected and its enrollment adversely affected by District choices or inaction sanislo has not received meaningful beex fund since 1998 sanow has not had earthquake safety or sesmic

145Improv mement since 1998 parents staff and students want SBS to invest in model programs like santow there is an alternative path forward that does not include building Mega schools and closing model neighborhood schools these actions will only further drive more parents away the beex 6 Levy is an opportunity to reframe how SPS spends vital dollars on more students as written one of the current project projects project plans is to rebuild one Elementary School to serve 500 students at a cost of $150 million instead consider fixing delayed main maintenance at elementaries and k8's rated poor health on the SPS Building reports in 2021 numbers so it it has changed the district could have afforded to do that with 87 million let's say construction costs have doubled if we chose those those all those schools we would

146benefit roughly 20,000 students 20,000 versus 500 students in a time of budget crisis why is the district not shifting its strategy to spend pivotal dollars on more on more students in a time of low public trust why is the beex oversight committee only composed of construction and real estate Professionals in a time when students feel powerless and like their Futures are decided for them I'm almost done why is the district not engaging students and staff in its process I ask that those who hold power in this room increase transparency and accountability and propose a 10-year strategy that centers students invest in existing buildings and attracts more families back to SBS thank you the next speaker is Aaron Moore after Aaron will be Bailey Millo and then Tuesday CH Tuesday Chambers I'm Aaron Moore I'm seeding

147my time to Yang Escalante I'm young a student at rer Beach uh rer Beach High School and officer of his Phil Filipino club and a member of anak Bay in South Seattle always speaking on behalf of our newly launched campaign save our schools campaign that seeks to achieve Pro people Mass oriented culturally relevant quality and safe education South Seattle students are done with militarization being uh prioritized over social services and our education our schools are in shambles under the def deficit and last year due to the same reason the SPs board decid to cut the defic the uh budget for liberatory classes including the Philippine X history history class students from Club wish to see genuine representation of culture and ideas we want learn more about the Philippines and our education because we don't get

148much information culture wise culture wise we want to learn the real situation of our people as a product of force M migration and safety for our people as especially migrants today is international migrants day as a youth living in South Seattle a community with migrant families especially Filipino migrants how long will we have to face and endure this I as well we came here for a better life only to face neglect in Social Services and education we are targeted by military recruiters who will send us to to to go to war against our own people as the Seattle public school board we demand you fund education not militarization normal police or military recuits on campus thank you [Applause] NE next will be Bailey Millo and then Tuesday Chambers uh good morning board members my name

149is Bailey Millo and I'm seeding my time to Annabelle Garcia Andresen hi good evening um my name is Annabelle Garcia andreon and I am an SPS parent with two children that are G ghs alumni and one in elementary school I am an educator at Dunlap Elementary School I am an officer of the Filipino American educators of Washington and a Community member that is involved in the development of the philipin X American history curriculum currently being implemented in this ncal public school's philipin X American history class at Cleveland High School in all of these roles having a culturally relevant and responsive curriculum is critical in ensuring our students receive the tools they need to rebuild a broken education system this is why I wholeheartedly support the save our schools Campaign which demands that seal Public Schools

150plays an active and authentic part in providing a proe people culturally relevant education that ensures safe and secure learning environments this means providing a learning environment where our Educators families and students are focused on learning not in the fear of violence and mass shooting Tings or whether their classrooms will be clean and pest free this means that instead of saying cops and practices that mirror the prison system that we as a solution that we fund and focus resources on counselors and mental health supports and programs this means that we fund liberatory studies and ethnic studies classes and require them as graduation requirements this means that when determined in the seal public school budget that it is informed by public participation in decision making and reflect needs of migrants and workingclass students and families we demand

151that seal Public Schools provides this Pro people culturally responsive and relevant education to ensure that every students in Seattle Public Schools can have a genuine education that centers bipo migrants and and and workingclass experiences in your role as a Schoolboard you have the means the responsibility and the positionality to create informed budgets that advocate for students rights for a quality education so to conclude that second demand that we have for save our schools is that seal Public Schools provides a proe people culturally relevant and responsive education thank you thank you so much the next speaker is Tuesday and then will be Michelle Campell and then Nika say hello my name is tuesd Chambers I'm the Ballard High School librarian and I'm here to talk about well-resourced schools and I'm seeding my time to Laura McGinty

152hello my name is Laura mgti I teach biology at Ballard High School and time where record number of students are struggling with basic literacy skills and books are being banned it is profoundly shocking to me that we are even considering cutting Library resources a school library is so much more than just a room filled with books and a library and is far more than a book manager libraries are an embodiment of our values they are the heartbeat of our schools and a reflection of the Vitality of our community in these spaces students can escape into literature finding themselves or becoming someone entirely new they offer a s sanctuary of mental respit where imagination takes flight and worlds of possibilities unfold of course libraries do more than provide an escape they are vital for intellectual growth

153and freedom through Library students explore new careers discover ideas and develop a sense of purpose the library is a place to research collaborate create and imagine where ideas can come to life it is the ultimate equalizer providing free access to knowledge and opportunity to every student regardless of background Behind These spaces are the Librarians cultivators and curators of this Treasure Trove of resources they are the ones who help students navigate the wealth of information who Foster a culture of curiosity and exploration it is impossible to list the extent of work a librarian does within the time limit here today suffice it to say that without Librarians we risk losing the key to unlocking the full potential of the library and therefore the student when we make cuts to libraries we aren't just trimming a budget

154we are sending a message that we don't value intellectual exploration we don't prioritize safe spaces for students and we don't see the importance of fostering Community the financial savings from cutting Library resources will be small but the impact on our students is immeasurable and it is a blow to the very heart of our schools in short the library is more than a place it's a vital space that shapes our future nurtures creativity and ensures that every student has access to a world of opportunities I urge you to stand with our students with our community and with the future of intellectual exploration think of the long-term effect and choose what will support future generations of students thank you the next speaker is Michelle Campbell after Michelle be nikai and then Samantha fog Michelle you'll need to

155press star six to un mute on the conference call line hello this is Michelle Campbell I'm seeding my time to Laura gramer Laura if you're on the line you can go ahead hi yeah hi can you yeah can you hear me thank you Michelle hello everyone I'm online with an interpreter my name is Laura rer I'm a parent at Topps eight Elementary um and my student I have an 8 a student in 8th grade and seventh grade at Topps tops an K8 school about a week ago the Topps Community found out that the assistant principal was arrested as part of a child trafficking during with team in targeting teens and I have a teenage child at that school so as you mentioned earlier that your role of at the central Office of Support for for

156schools- which means first of all at the right at the re relevant at the relevant time and supporting Stu those are your words to me so you have failed in all three of those roles the family at tops had no direct communication from the school until today at 3:15 we received a message saying that there would be a meeting tomorrow with the district we had to wait for a full week to hear back from the district and as a parent I'm sitting here wondering why didn't I receive any letter why did I receive this letter with these questions in it how will SPS improve communication and transparency and how and what resources are SPS providing our families on how to discuss about child sex trafficking with children uh on the developmental Spectrum at through from

157K through e grade cuz I don't know how what specific communication with the students has occurred in the classroom what are the students being told if they ask about their former vice principal being arrested can you share if there's a current system in place that will alert the district if anyone work employed or formally employed by the district is arrested for crimes involving minors and how do you plan to make sure this doesn't happen again what changes will you do to screen and prevent uh screening and prevention process to ensure that this does not happen again now for all of you the the top discussion is the budget discussion and we were told that we have to ask the district again for support for ASL teachers for next year and I hope and I and

158I ask the district continues to support this because we have a deaf and heart of hearing par program at Topps and also at tops and Roosevelt High School we have an accessible emergency system we've been we need an accessible emergency system we've been advocating for that for a long time and finally please save our Librarians thank you the next speaker is Nik Sai and then Samantha fog and Liz Barry hello my name is niika Sai uh I am a member of ANUK Bayan South Seattle and I'm here representing the save our schools campaign anakbayan South Seattle is an organization of Filipino Youth and students fighting for the rights and Welfare of Filipinos back home in the Philippines and abroad like here in Seattle we're also members of Bayern Washington and the International migrants Alliance alliances

159that are committed to protecting migrants under an economic and political climate that makes them increasingly more unsafe at Seattle Public Schools migrant custodial staff and their families aren't protected custodial hour don't just make schools unclean and unsafe they make life unsafe for migrant families who are left without sufficient livelihood at SPS migrant students aren't safe when they're subject to discrimination and bullying I want to uplift the story of Glendy a migrant mother who is fighting for justice for her daughter after months of Relentless bullying at Mercer International middle school after Glend Mar's daughter was assaulted by a group of other classmates and the video of this assault was posted on social media Glendy M and her daughter have not received any true Solutions the harassment has persisted and her daughter's experience in the education system

160has gone from one of opportunity community and curiosity to one of fear isolation and anxiety and this experience isn't isolated thousands of migrants leave their home countries each day thousands of Filipinos leave the Philippines each day in search of better jobs and better education abroad but instead what they find at SPS is exploitative jobs and an education system that doesn't meet their needs our save our schools campaign is calling for SPS to uphold its duty to protect migrants and working-class youth from State and interpersonal violence under the incoming Trump Administration SPS must protect migrant families from deportation and anti-migrant policies we call for the justice for all migrants impacted by Seattle public schools in action and lack of protection justice for all people who are suffering under a system that prioritizes putting money into war

161and militarism rather than keeping students safe thank you next is Samantha fog after Samantha will be Liz Berry Samantha you'll need to oh you have unmuted this is Sam the fog I seed my time to Sabrina Burr good evening superintendent Jones and Schoolboard directors as you know I am Sabrina Burr and I stand here as one but I come as 10,000 for 70 years I can personally count Seattle Public Schools failing black children the descendants of the stolen ones the generational educational trauma inflicted to the black community then and now the way that black and brown bodies are treated in this district is Criminal and we demand that these practices stop in all the places and spaces that our children are throughout this district and now my East African brothers and sisters their children like

162ours have been here unseen long enough and now experienc generation trauma at the hands of this District who once not only cared about but also practiced good authentic family and Community engagement who want build capacity districtwide the fact that it no longer exist is why well- race Source schools was the biggest failure and the most harmful traumatizing engagement of six superintendents I can personally speak to one we um we want pra we once practice two-way communication beyond the loudest and most privileged voices in a time when multi-tier systems and support was a focus for our district and practiced in every building when social emotional literacy was practiced in align with our cips scaffold and practiced in all areas of our schools School Board directors especially those new are on the board I have documents that

163can show you um uh that can no longer be found on the website that will tell the story of how we got to where we are now why we must focus on student outcomes if we are going to close the opportunity and belief gap for students who are dying at the hands of decisions of this leadership directors you are the leaders of this District your leadership must direct actions and outcomes accountability to operational oversight and goal attainment has not been your strength and it is our students who suffer you chose this job stop putting adult greed over student need I would be glad to meet with you and walk you through this journey the fact that we no longer focus on that we do not focus on student outcomes is exactly why we continue to

164fail not only black boys and Young young men but black children and families districtwide these practices must stop now we are no longer asking lastly sexual predators within our schools show we as a district have not learned from Decades of incident why do we not have a system in place instead of continually repeatingly cause the same harm to schools students and families and communities that make up our school community shame on us I have been advocating and partnering with this district for over two decades how many black and African students need to die because we have a system put adults first at the cost of students and their lives not only on the streets but in our schools and when our students voice tell us about their safety needs like the need to have their

165doors locked Why is the decision in the sole discretion of a building leader who is truly responsible please read all the audit reports that tell the story of what the black community has been saying far too long for far too many Direction Generations talking to I've been talking to many leaders Advocates Advocates and families you you may not physically be they may not physically be standing in here but believe me they are standing with me we will read and review the reports of the audit committee we will stand together we will say enough our children of our children not being seen being disrespected uneducate uneducated characterized by the reaction to harm trauma not belonging or even mattering in too many instance we demand that you practice what you say your commitment to our children in

166writing but not in action we demand that you take the safety and education of our children the same as white children because if they were dying in our schools like no student should ever be sadly the care and the action you take would be different why truth is you have a constitutional ethical and moral obligation to every student not some and no student should have to die to be educated next is Liz [Applause] Berry Liz you can press star six it will unmute I'm going to go to the next speaker but I will Circle back the next speaker is uh Shana sh uh shastin hello oh is that Liz Berry oh I see lizz's hand is up um Liz you'll need to press star six to unmute hi this is Liz Barry can you hear

167me we can hear you Liz and the next speaker who I called we'll we'll pause for um Liz and then we'll come to our next speaker so Liz you can go ahead okay I'm sorry about that um this is Liz Barry and I'm feeding my time [Music] too the time is running so um Liz if the person oh one two okay good evening board directors my name is best mono I am an SBS parents uh tonight I am sharing a proposal with you that comes from a joint PTA efforts from many of our dual language schools we are mainly addressing the needs of the Dual language program at Concord international elementary school however we have been Consulting with Educators experts and PTA leaders at other dual language schools the set of concrete policy changes that

168we would like to propose are the following an increase enrollment in concord's dual language program prioritizing students from Heritage spanishs speaking families strengthening the curriculum and instruction to ensure that dual language teachers have the supports they need to effectively serve multilingual Learners and expanding opportunities for dual language programs across the district more specifically we are requesting three action items one a district provided curriculum that is high quality and intended to meet the needs of multilingual Learners in dual language programs currently the burden is on teachers and ptas to fund these curriculums or translate curriculum from English this is not sustainable and leads to burnout of our staff two revised District dual enrollment policies that prioritize multilingual Learners within this superintendent procedure 3130 SP be revised to specifically allow dual language schools to prioritize native speakers

169with a 50% set aside for Heritage speakers with priorities to multilanguage Learners we also ask enrollment to update the new student registration form home language survey uh section to allow families to identify more than one home language we also ask enrollment to proactively identify and invite families whose first language and or Heritage language is Spanish to enroll in dual language schools K through 12 finally three fully staff and retain bilingual teachers at dual language schools through the following prioritizing a process to recruit and hire more bilingual staff codifying protections for bilingual staff to avoid displacements implementing a school teaching ratio that specifies funding of dual language teaching positions and proactively giving opportunities to Heritage speaking students affected by school consolidation to choose to come to dual language schools in their region we encourage SBS to

170continue to learn from its existing international school and dual language models and begin taking steps towards expanding a formalized dual language program into more neighborhood schools cited within native speaking communities while prioritizing set asides that protect Equitable dual language access I also have another guest my son who is the student Arie what would you like to say say hello hello my name is Archie it's easier writing in Spanish because the word you hear I mean the letter you hear it's it's that letter but in English it's a bunch of different languages so you may hear like light you think it's l but you want to learn both English I want to learn both English and Spanish and learning both help me Ro thank you thank you thank you for your time board members the next

171speaker is shanana um shtin is Shana here in the room not seeing shanana on the phone going to go to the next speaker Sarah Brown hi my name is Sarah Brown and I'm a math specialist at Wing luk Elementary and I'm here to speak on behalf of my community I'm here to shine a light on conf in District practices that result in class sizes of up to 33 in our very high poverty school last spring we were given a low enrollment projection of 74 students at fourth and fifth grades causing us to lose a classroom this didn't account for the expansion of a nearby long-term shelter and an underperforming Charter School in the neighborhood and today we stand at 97 fourth and fifth grade students spread among just three teachers 80% are defined by SPS

172as students of color furthest from educational Justice 42% are elll served and 18% are designated as homeless 15 have IEPs and just five of 23 new students came in ready to work at grade level Equity tier one schools are supposed to be funded at 26 four or five students per teacher so we waited eagerly for our October 1st adjustment our math showed that we should be gaining one and a half teachers schoolwide but instead we got nothing turns out that new language was snuck snuck into the budget gold book two years ago and schools no longer gain any additional teachers in October unless they qualify for at least two this shows that the district is intentionally underfunding schools is the per pupil money from the state intended for the students on whom SPS claims to

173be laser focused being diverted from schools and used to balance the budget elsewhere that's not educational Justice adjusting for half as many staff as given by the weighted Staffing standard is creating large classes over both the WSS and the CBA and we know it's happening at other schools around the district 10 new four five students have enrolled at Wing Luke since school started and none have left nobody nobody downtown will answer the simple question of how big these classes have to get before they'll do something is the only hard cap the fire code already there's no room for students to make a circle in their classroom or meet in a small group with their teacher don't punish kids for your bad enrollment projections and start fully Staffing schools to match our numbers thank you we're

174going to go now to those who um uh were not with us earlier on the call trying Hank Morgan one more time is Hank Morgan in the room or on the phone and if I call your name please press star six to unmute not seeing Hank going to try one more time for shanana shastin okay I'm going to move to the wait list an Andrea Redmond is Andrea here or online Andrea please press star six if you're unmuted I'm in the I'm on the wait list if folks want to follow along going to the next speaker Gabriel De Los Angeles is Gabriel in the room okay I'm going to go to the next speaker Virginia Tron Virginia indicated they would be remote I think you are on the line okay you can hear me right

175yes we can hear you okay thank you um okay hello everyone my name is Virginia truan and I'm the teacher librarian at Ingram high school every day I see the positive impact of having a well-resourced school library and the positive outcomes that that has on students the research shows that um the value of having full-time school librarians there's a lot of data to support that that has a beneficial that that has a benefit to that that is highly beneficial to student outcomes um and so I am here to ask to ask you to consider what the data is saying that this is helpful to hear what the parents and students are saying that this is helpful and also to consider all of the Librarians you see standing before you and their experience of seeing every

176day the impact that the library as a place and program has on their students and staff small sample of a day of a typical day at the library at Ingram is that we see 115 students during lunchtime that's on average we generally see between um 100 and 130 every day and I typically answer about 23 questions a day this number uh ends up being a lot more at the beginning of the school year and then at the end of the school year or anytime it's the end of the quarter um and all the students many students need help with their laptops each day we check out again an average 44 books um and we also serve as just a resource center for students to come and work quietly in the library when they need a

177quiet place or maybe they just can't handle being in class that day um and so each day we have about 42 students who have permission from their teachers uh to be working in the library uh so far this year let's see it is uh December 18th and so far all of the together combined all of the School libraries across the all public schools have checked out 1 million books uh which is more we've beaten our record for the last two years um and we still have two more days left before winter break which is pretty amazing thank you for your time going to the next speaker on the testimony list Grace Rooney is Grace here in the room or online okay Rebecca bins oh I see one speaker who is uh Rebecca bins you'll need

178to press star six to unmute if you're on the conference line moving on Elias Markham okay we've now called all oh I see somebody is unmuted is this Rebecca hello um can you guys hear me is this Elias yes this is Elias okay Elias will be our 20th speaker tonight okay you can go ahead elas we can hear you okay cool um my name is Elias Markham I'm a senior at Nathan Hill High School uh as the library teacher assistant I know that the library should not be cut down to 2 and a half days the library is a space for everyone in the hill Community whether that be people in clubs people during lunch or even teachers teaching their class in an alternative environment the library is inclusive and if it is cut down

179to two and a half days then this valued space won't be available as often as it should I remember being a Freshman and not having many friends to hang out with during lunch the library was a space where I met some of my closest friends that wouldn't have been possible if it wasn't open every day the library also gives class for teacher assistant such as myself going into being the fifth or sorry going into being the fifth period library teacher assistant uh I didn't know anything about how the library worked and Miss West taught me so much and now I sh books I help check in and out books to students and I also interact with the community uh if the library was cut down to 2 and a half days that means the teacher

180assistant in the library would get cut meaning Miss West would have to take over and cover what they would do if the library is cut people will lose access to books teachers and Miss West collaborate and if she is there half the time that means she would do significantly less to support our curriculum at hail this cut isn't feasible thank you for your consideration president Rankin that was our 20th speaker and concludes today's testimony all right thank you um Lots came up there but I just wanted to quickly address one thing which is that cutting Librarians is not something that has been proposed by the board it is also not something that has been brought to the board to consider so um just I'm not saying it didn't come from somewhere but as as like

181yeah and so uh for the budget next steps of the budget um uh we have a resolution on as our one action item this evening that if approved will direct the superintendent to provide us with the first round of preliminary budget recommendations in January and then uh by state law we have to pass a balance budget um before August but we typically do it in about June or July so um just thank you for coming and um we have more more to look into it and and and discuss um but I just wanted to make sure you all knew that that wasn't something that was going to suddenly happen to you um and that that we haven't had it it's that that's not how the yeah I think you got it but thank you um

182all right uh consent agenda um we have now reached the consent portion of today's agenda may I have a motion for the consent [Music] agenda I move approval of the consent agenda I second uh the approval of the consent agenda has has been moved by vice president seru and seconded by uh director Briggs are there any items for discussion removal all right uh seeing none all those in favor of the consent agenda please signify by saying I I I I I I any opposed or exensions all right uh the consent agenda has passed unanimously thank you um okay yes I'm so ready to pass this whole situation on to somebody else all right uh uh um we are now moving to election of board officers which is an annual practice that we do in December

183um uh and um as we are as the president is tasked with chairing the meeting and we are now in the process of of electing new officers I will turn the meeting over to superintendent Jones who will run the election process as the secretary of the board um and once we have officers elected the uh elected president will immediately preside over the meeting for the rest of the meeting um all right thank I was I was going to say it's been a people sometimes say it's been an honor and a pleasure to do something it's been an honor to be to be president and it's it's been a year it's been a time um it's uh yeah a a growth opportunity that I am excited to support someone else in uh participating in so all

184right thank you president Rankin uh president Rankin that's the last time okay before I uh open the floor for nominations I'd like to review the election process for each officer position president vice president and member at large I will take nominations from the board a second is not required for the nomination but can be made after all the nominations are made for a position there will be an opportunity for directors to provide comments before voting after comments have been concluded the board will vote for each position in the order the nominations were made by law and board policy the voting will be conducted by a roll call vote the voting will conclude at the point when one nomination gets four or more votes after the president has been elected we will move on to the

185vice president and then to the member at large in summary for each position there will be nominations then discussion then voting at the conclusion of the election process for all three POS positions each new officer will have an opportunity to provide remarks drum roll please nominations are now in order for the office of President I'm not sure who was first well let's just do alphabetical order by the first name [Laughter] that was a joke you don't want to do it okay okay um okay vice president Sergeant that's the last time you'll call me that amen hallelujah I would like to nominate uh four president do I have to do a formal Roberts rules kind of okay because I don't know how to do that um I would like to nominate for president director top are

186there other I second are there other nominations for president I'm a former teacher I'm comfortable with wait time if there are no more nominations I close the nominations for president would any directors like to make any comments at this time about the nominations that's correct I'd like to make vice president sergy oh man last time um so for those who are still left here and those who are online um I think it's important that you all understand the Colossal amount of work that this volunteer unpaid um not necessarily respected um job re well it's just not respected it's not even not necessarily respected um job requires and um you know I like to have fun this whole process is formal and I think it's ridiculous um but the Office of the President um is pretty

187important in terms of providing leadership and direction to the board um and for those of you who have watched me for three years I have been true to what I set out to do and that is in every decision in every comment it's about kids and so I actually had a conversation with director top if I'm if I'm being honest I told her she was running for president although she I think she was thinking about it um but I I I stated it um with the expectation that there will be a continued focus on the children that this district has failed for hundreds of years now um we can't let our foot off the gas pedal on that and while we are seeing improvements we're still failing most of those children and so for me

188it's important um and I'm stating this publicly because I want you all to know that I have shared what my expectations of our her in this role and that is to continue to Advocate and continue to move that Focus um and while I have the mic I am just going to thank my bestie and my buddy Liza we have been through it this year um and um I just I I will thank you in another ways another time but I I think it's important to publicly acknowledge what you have personally been through um it has been ridiculous it has been not easy and it has not been deserved and so what you deserve is praise for the way you stepped into the role um and led even in the midst of all of the stuff

189that was actually not necessary and not did not move things forward for kids so thank you for that but I'm excited about Gina and with that I will um are you are you like give me a look are you okay with this okay all right I will um close the mic so we can take a vote that's the next step right no are any other directors liking to would like to make a comment I think you right on uh okay Miss Wilson Jones please call the role for the vote for director top director Briggs I director Clark I director hery I director Mahi I vice president sju I'm sorry I really thought it was only going to be one more time of calling me by that title that's three now y'all counting M with I

190director top hi president rank HIIT sorry I really want to make sure that mic is on I the nomination of director top is approved unanimously President congratulations on your election as president director top nominations are now in order for the office of Vice President are there any nominations for vice president president do I do I need to be recognized I recognize director hery right on thank you Emeritus president hery um I would like to nominate uh director Briggs are there other nominations for vice president I second a second is is not necessary but it's it shows affirmation you let her yeah and that wasn't necessary either other nominations for vice president if there are no more nominations I close the nominations for vice president would any directors like to make any comments at this time

191director hery oh you don't know that it's going to be nice no I'm kidding I don't know how to be anything but nice um I think like having pretty much worn every hat that the board has to offer at this point um what I'm really excited about and this doesn't just apply to director Briggs I'm going to get to personal stuff uh in a second but like for all of our new directors I have served with three or four different boards uh over the course of the six years almost that I've been here um and I can honestly say that like the new crop of directors that we have uh director Clark director Mahi president top uh director Briggs um y'all are strong y'all are very very strong in terms of intellect in terms of

192the willingness to get in and like roll your hands up and and your engagement with community and your own different ways right so regardless of the outcomes of these personal elections I think that the leadership on the board is going to be incredibly strong for years to come and and it's no secret that we have some very tough challenges ahead of us um I think what I'm really excited about director brick specifically is that when we adopted student outcomes focused governance uh when we had new folks come and join there 's always a a sense of well a time period for folks to get their legs up under them some folks coming in uh you know don't support it immediately some folks coming in are just like you know full throat it um but what

193I what I've really appreciated about director Briggs leadership is that when Evan was running it wasn't like a full-throated support I she was super curious around it and um she has really leaned into developing an understanding of not only the governance framework as its own thing but also like how do we apply that in Seattle public schools in a way that is both accessible and representative to I think a lot of folks's curiosity and and rightfully so concerns about how do we implement this um and still be incredibly responsive to community at the same time I think what I am excited about uh really for the vice presidency is that it's an opportunity to not only support when the president is not around but it is also just an indicator for where we as a

194board are headed and I and I'm really excited about these two specifically for one reason and particularly director Briggs is are you a strong Communicator are you a person who can not only like take in information but disseminate it out amongst community in a way that is Meaningful and understanding um and provide context for folks surprisingly the board President and Vice President don't really have that much power aside from like um setting agenda having served in both of those roles for a number of years but where I think the True Value in both of these roles are is what is your ability to not only work with one another but to genuinely work with community and I don't think on the board currently and again any of our new directors would serve really strongly in

195this role but I'm really excited about the balance and relationship between the two people who we've nominated for the presidency and the vice presidency to take the next phase of whatever this is for our district as we solve these big problems and really work together to figure out how do we not only solve these problems but communicate the solutions out to community in an effective accessible way because communication as we have heard very plainly here tonight in many ways and I feel like we hear it every single board meeting and it's fair and valid it is not a strength but I think under the leadership of these two very intelligent very capable women that we have a really strong shot at improving that in meaningful ways not only for our students but for all of

196our families and all of our constituents so it is with great pride that I nominate director Briggs for the role of Vice President presid president top please Perfect uh so I've had a opportunity to spend some time with director bricks somehow we end up traveling a lot together um to either wda or to St Louis for Schoolboard work um and have uh I've really come to appreciate and respect her values um her Integrity her willingness to have open conversations and I think uh director her's right we are very aligned on where we need to go on engagement and communication in this district and I would be very grateful to have her as a partner as vice president president Emeritus rank it immediate P president soon to be invisible I don't know um I I just

197want to something that I am excited about this this pairing is um this year has been oh again I almost FCC violation this year has been quite a a roller coaster there we go quite a roller coaster um and uh which which happens when we're pushing for things to change um against a uh longstanding and very strong force um but something that has been uh really that I have really valued so much in the role of President is that I always knew that you too would be there to check in with to offer um thoughts or feedback to be part of the solution and um there's a lot that I hope you won't have to deal with that needs to be different um but I know that uh the two of you will support each

198other and I also hope you know that I will be here to support you no matter what what you need um because the the success of this board means the success of our superintendent means the success of our students and so it's really about the board as a as a body and the thoughtfulness and level-headedness that you both bring and the genuine care um is is going to help move us into the next phase and I'm grateful that you're both willing to do it would any more directors like to make comments Miss Wilson Jones please call the rooll vote for director Briggs director Clark director hery hi director mrai hi director Ranken I yes vice president saru again v i i oh I still have to vote but I don't have to vote now now

199she's vice president I sorry about that director Briggs I I president top I the nomination of director Briggs is approved unanimously congratulations on your election as vice president director Briggs nominations are now in order for the office of member at large are there any nominations for member at large director Clark um okay much better um I would like to nominate director M Rahi for member at large I will second since that was going to be my nomination as well all right second are there other nominations for member at large if there are no more nominations I close nominations for member at large would any directors like to make any comments at this time um I would like to make a comment so full transparency I'm not sure what the member at large does but yeah

200they second things um so I I think great that director Miss Rahi would be great at seconding things but all joking aside um I really appreciate and respect your leadership um both on the board and in the work that you do in community and um I think that you've always been really thoughtful and mindful of prior izing students fur this from opportunity but also ensuring that all voices are heard um I think that you ask really um probing questions and just have an attention to detail that I really respect and I think that you um will be a great leader for us next year along with our uh the rest of our leadership team president Emeritus right good um yeah I'll just want to add to that that's also why I wanted to um nominate

201director M Rahi is and we have again half of our board has been here for a year or less more the majority of our board has been here for a year or less and so um yeah and so I want to acknowledge all four of you for um not hight tailing it out of here after the the time that you've experienced so far and and the hopes that we can um you know keep keep disrupting what needs disrupting but um also focus and and move in the same direction and I think director Mahi has been um such a a level consistent voice um uh that is always focused on on students and um and primarily for me when I was the president the tried not to have individual meetings a lot of times especially with

202agenda setting try to bring either the vice president or the member at large and so I think having you know the the triumverate to to always be able to have two people when needed is really helpful in in those meetings at least I found it helpful um and I think any of those conversations uh director Mahi would just be a great asset and um yeah I've appreciated him on the board for question no please please no this has nothing to do with the current situation you still May comment um I need help figuring out how to remove board vice president from my email signature so if somebody could help me with that okay great thank you that is technical Michelle we can do that later but I am no longer Vice I'll get i'll seek

203you before you get thank you Miss Wilson Jones please call the role for the vote for director Miss Rahi director hery hi director mrai hi director Ranken I director sarju I vice president Briggs I director Clark I president top I the nomination of director M Rahi is approved unanimously congratulations on your election as member at large director Miss Rahi president I would like to report that the officers for the board of directors for 2025 are VI our president top vice president Briggs member at large Miss Rahi I would now like to invite our newly elected officers beginning with the president to offer any remarks that they would like to make I won't take a lot of time I just want to thank uh director Ranken for her leadership this past year in the challenging time

204you know our dedic your dedication to our students is is truly admired and I also want to thank the board for placing this trust in me to uh serve this really awesome responsibility it is extremely heavy um and there is a lot of opportunity in this coming year and I'm excited to serve in this role um I think this past year we we've all alluded to it has brought challenges particularly you know with the school closures process and you know I think we we did some damage in our community and we have some work to do to regain some of the trust as as Dr says um I think the school closure process also highlighted how impactful our schools are in the community how what a valued asset they are for so many and how

205important they are the resources they provide to our families in Seattle education is what provides access to opportunity and we have the burden and the responsibility to make sure that all students have access particularly those who have been left out of the system previously and have not had that same access um the year ends uh one thing I don't think we do as a board enough is just thank the Educators in the classrooms who are doing this work every single day it is a job that I think is probably the hardest job there is so thank you to all those who are listening who are doing this work um work out there I think that's that's where I'll leave it I look forward to working with my new vice president member at large but really

206the entire board on this upcoming year and all that we we need to do but also as we talk about engagement the rest of our city you know we have we live in a place with so much Innovation and knowledge and experience so let's harness that as we try to make Seattle public schools great again I know I that was a joke sorry um but with that uh vice president I really just want to acknowledge and thank Liza and Michelle um for their leadership this last year and let you both know how very much I've learned from both of you um wow I'm strangely feeling emotional um that's actually not surprising if if you know me at all but but just that you two have both taken real hits um you've taking real hits this

207year and um you don't back down and that is so much um just determination and courage so thank you director m I'll just say uh all due respect to your tenure director Briggs I'm gonna second the heck out of those Motions like you folks wouldn't believe I'm gonna revolutionize the whole seconding uh game no um in all seriousness just uh thank you for the kind words and um I I found everyone on this board to be so incredibly welcoming to myself to director Clark as well and being the two newest board members and uh jumping in at a difficult time and it's been um even through all the hard times a pleasure to work with everyone and I'm looking forward to the year ahead so I now turn the meeting over to our 2025 board

208president director top thank you thank you so much uh Dr Jones uh we have a very few items left on our agenda but we're still going to take a quick recess um we will reconvene at 7:55 [Music] okay [Music] o [Music] oh [Music] so one minute warning [Music] we're going to move to the action items on today's agenda this item [Music] is approve of approval of board resolution number 2024 259 educational program reduction per board policy number 0060 can can I have a motion for this item I move that the board adopt board resolution number 25-9 educational program reduction as attached to this board Action Report second yes Joe yeah nailed it approval has been moved by vice president Briggs and seconded by director Mahi this item is sponsored by director Ranken director Clark and

209myself so I'm going to pass it to the sponsor for their remarks and updates since introduction yeah all right thank you so yes so this um this item came to the board for introduction in uh I don't I don't in September um uh our our current policy on financial planning requires um that the board present or or that the superintendent bring us a a resolution for approval to um in the in the Years where there is a projected significant budget deficit or budget surplus to have a conversation about um you know what what that might what that might look like for the coming year so we are in a year that is facing a significant deficit um and the uh underlying resolution that we saw in September was um very similar for not identical to

210one that we've passed before but we're you know all resolution and policy and whatnot is meant to meant to change as needed um and so in in looking at it we we wanted to focus in on uh just the our Direction on on the budget is to align with the goals align with making progress on the goals stay with the guardrails um some of the challenge that we had uh this past year was not was was uh kind of concurring around different areas without the really cold hard numbers to talk about and so um the three of us have offered language for the board to consider that specifies that what we are asking for is for preliminary budgets in January uh that include a scenario with no additional revenue and that include a scenario with

211with additional Revenue so that we can really understand as a board what the options are and importantly so that we can also um have real conversations with the community about uh what the trade-offs are what the challenges are and um and also though we will of course continue to advocate for and hopefully receive additional funding from the state um the difference from between us as board members as opposed to community Advocates is we have to plan for the worst so um I don't want anybody thinking that looking at a budget without additional funding doesn't mean that we think that's a good idea or hope that's happens it's just that we're the responsible we're the responsible body so we have to hope for the best but also plan for the worst which is specifically why we

212asked for um preliminary budget recommendations in January that include um the worst case scenario basically um so if if uh other co-sponsors have anything to add director CLK thank you um one other thing I just wanted to um call out um is that um we're also asking that um any um reduction scenarios include um should contemplate the impacts to enrollment um that um basically hoping for kind of an itemized um look at the impact on enrollment so that we can make better informed choices um if that scenario um were to happen so um it was great working with you guys on this and I will just add one thing uh in the resolution includes a oh a task force to help guide uh recommendations for a multi-year budget forecast this was in one of our

213previous resolutions and there was some confusion whether it would continue on I think it's extremely important that we uh that this task force be created and I I know the language because it's this is a 2526 budget resolution is a little vague in here but I look forward to hearing from the superintendent uh further how he plans to execute that task force not tonight but in the future in the near future so with that do any directors have any questions or comments okay seeing none could staff please call for the vote director m Rahi I director Ranken I director sarju I vice president Briggs I director Clark I president top I this motion has passed unanimously we will uh now move I guess to the introduction item on today's agenda uh this item is adoption

214of board policy number 0020 goals for the district and 0025 guard rails for the district an amendment to board policy number10 oversight and progress monitoring getting to pass it to director Rankin as the sponsor of this item to update us on the board Action Report which would adopt the goals and guard rails we've developed into policy director Ranken okay um this is hopefully not not a surprise uh this is um based upon the um work session that we had last week when was it yeah to to narrow down our our uh go and guard rail drafts um the uh this reflects we heard were the top priorities of our community thank you um uh and are being introduced tonight to to give us time uh to take it back out to community we have some

215things in the works that I think you'll be getting more information from staff about um but as we said earlier the the student members and I had an opportunity to kind of do a practice run with the a presentation to um the Human Rights Commission event just about talking talking with folks about about how we arrived at the drafts and what we were looking for from the community um so yeah I look forward to that uh this basically is just um putting uh approval of it eventually would put it into policy um to better support alignment and direction from the board as opposed to the current iteration existed as a motion but it wasn't it wasn't codified um and so adopting this into policy will become would become then part of our governance manual and

216subsequent boards would would further um make changes to it to adopt new goals we also as we discussed in the work session uh may decide that there's some wording adjustment or different things that we want to consider and you know it's our policy so we can bring that back to vote on so um was there anything else Julia that we needed to add about no okay was there a wait sorry the the guard rail there was one guard rail do you want to come and talk about um there there was a we had a there was a little bit of a oh it's not in here um we had a wording question come up based on a legal concern about um we we had in guardwell 3 I think that uh we wouldn't allow opting

217out of um practices curriculum aligned with um our values and anti-racist practices and uh Legal C that we want to clarify that we mean adults um yeah and so um Julia can you tell share a little bit more about that yes um so the new guardrail language clarifies that it is um regarding adults um and and specifically District staff and their um practices within um the district setting um and and that the guardrail does not apply to students um the language has also been changed um from opting out because that has um some specific connotations and uh Greg will correct me if I am incorrect here um but making sure that we're also protecting staff's rights um and their their first amendment rights so um the new guardrail language tries to kind of um thread

218that needle as it were but still reflect the community's value as the board understands it do directors have any questions for either staff or the for sponsor director rink and director Clark I have a question for the sponsor um so thinking about I'm thinking about um the change that we're making both from this current strategic plan and the the goals and guard rails to our next one which we're now putting in policy I'm thinking about our math goal that's not in our um current strategic plan but is or future strategic plan but is in the current one and I know we've had conversations about you know that we're we're setting this Foundation we're continuing the work forward even though it's not necessarily continuing written in the in this so if if that's just motion for

219the last strategic plan or am I understanding correctly that the Strategic plan that we're in right now is not in policy how are we going to ensure that that work continues the yeah the goals and guardrails were adopted by the board through a vote of the board um but and and legal or somebody correct me if I'm wrong they're not they're they're reflected on the on the website and they're reflected as as formal board action but they weren't codified into into policy specifically that we would be measuring these goals um so I mean uh supporting math outcomes is still part of basic education in uh just District work so are you um wondering about getting uh I guess I'm just tell me a little bit more I guess I'm just wondering like I mean even

220in our progress monitoring today like you know you know we are seeing progress in math I just want to make sure that we're still that if if maybe policy isn't the vehicle but if that we're still able as a board to like monitor how that's going even though it's not formally in our strategic plan I got you I think so the basically putting it into the policy for goals and guardrails we're saying this is how we these are the measurements that we're going to use to evaluate essentially the performance of the superintendent and the district it doesn't mean that we don't have access to or monitor other things but in terms of in terms of like progress monitoring and saying uh uh how we Define yes the district is doing its job or or how

221we kind of evaluate we're saying that that those those two measures will be what we're using for evaluation so there's still regular um esack and different reports and there's also um some other me monitoring mechanisms to get information about student performance okay um does I don't know if um Dr stoski wants to evaluate a little bit more so so just our goals are just saying this is kind of how we're evaluating the success of the system we will still have access to and and and look into other things uh yes uh Mike stoski assistant superintendent of academics we will continue to to prioritize our our focus on seventh grade math and be able to report back out um how we're doing on that so we want to build on the good things that are that

222we reported out some of the promising things tonight and we were will continue to do that moving forward thank you so I I I'm not in contradiction to Dr stoski here um however if the board wants to prioritize an investment in mathematics that should be very clear and so we will have this as part of our accountability framework but in terms of progress monitoring my interpretation is we're going to do progress monitoring on the two goals and the and the five guard rails and that's that's it for the the the formal investment of time and energy into that but we just like science just like everything else we're going to still have that as a priority PRI priority for us but in terms of the reporting um and the Cascade goals from the board through

223the superintendent to staff it's going to be on those two two goals that's my interpretation so I just want to uh be clear on that and if that's not the desire to board now would be the time to kind of speak into that please and thank you I appreciate the clarity Dr Jones and we also don't have to the great thing is we're not we don't have to decide this tonight uh we have some time and as uh Dr or Dr Ranken uh director Ranken uh said we have some opportunities to go back to community with these to see have have have we got this right is this correct is this what we really uh heard in the engagement session doc director Ranken uh one other thing to add is that we will also have

224um I well I don't I guess I don't know but you know uh certain progress in mathematics is a graduation requirement so it's possible that we would see that in interim measures I don't know if you heard that yeah um uh and and yeah and we still have those other indicators in the interims that will provide us the regular monitoring on do any other directors have questions for the sponsor or for staff okay seeing none we're going to move on to announcements announcement portion of the agenda we have a uh public employment relations commission notice that will be read into the record tonight staff will offer this announcement thank you good evening um Dr Sarah PID assistant superintendent for human resources reading the notice to employees of unfair Labor practice related to case d-23 C

225decisions 13982 D- e Duc and 13983 B- PB state law gives you the right to self Oran self organized join or assist labor or or employee organizations bargain collectively through the representative of your choice refuse to pay dues to a union unless you have affirmatively agreed to make such payments the Washington state public employee relations commission perk conducted a legal proceeding issuing a ruling that Seattle School District committed an unfair Labor practice and ordered that this notice be posted to employees we unlawfully disciplined employees for including other people including their Union representatives and similarly situated co-workers on emails with the employer concerning wages hours and working conditions we unlawfully directed employees to not include other people including their Union representatives and similar similarly situated co-workers on emails with employers concerning wages hours and working conditions

226we unlawfully issued written discipline to employees for including their Union and other impacted employees on an email concerning a potential grievance we unlawfully discriminated and interfered with an employes right by considering an employees protected activity when evaluating their job performance and a we unlawfully included negative comments in an employee summi of evaluations and reprisal for their protected unit AC ity to Remedy Our unfair labor practices we will withdraw the letter of counseling issued to Laura Jensen erroneously dated November 23rd 2022 but actually issued shortly after November 28th 2022 and eliminate any reference to the letter of counseling in Jensen's evaluation personal files and employer files we will withdraw the written evaluation issued to Laura Jensen for the 222 3 for 2022 23 review period and eliminate any reference to the evaluation in Jensen's Personnel files

227and employer files and conduct of a new and conduct a new evaluation for the 2022 23 review period that is not based on Jensen's protected activity we will withdraw the written evaluations issued to Julia Diaz for the 2223 review period and eliminate any reference to the evaluation and JD's Personnel files and employer files and conduct a new evaluation for the 2223 review period that is not based on JD's protected activities and change the proposed evaluation cycle for next year from comprehensive to focused we will withdraw the written evaluation issued to Elizabeth Ward Robinson for performance evaluation covering April 2022 to April 2023 and eliminate any reference to the evaluation in Ward Robinson's Personnel files and employer files and conduct a new evaluation for the April 2022 to April 2023 review period that is not based

228on Ward Robertson's protected activity and remove that recommendation um that she is moved to a comprehensive evaluation cycle we will not include negative comments in the employees summi of evaluations in reprisal for their protected unit activity we will submit copies of the new evaluations to the compliance officer at the public employee relations commission and to the union once the new evaluations have been received and approved by the compliance officer provide the union and affected employees with the new evaluations and replace all copies of the discriminatory evaluations with the new evaluations in all Personnel files and employer files we will not in any other manner interfere with the with restraining or coercing its employees into in the exercise of their collective bargaining rights under the laws of the state of Washington Seattle Public Schools my Sarah

229pritchet dated 2024 assistant superintendent of Human Resources authorized representative for Seattle School District thank you Dr pritet um there being no further business to come before the board the regular board meeting is now adjourned at 8816 happy holidays everyone than

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.