001[Music] okay let's keep I'm going to go ahead and get started as people are getting settled in good afternoon everyone the board meeting will be called to order in just a moment and spsv will be begin broadcasting this is President Rankin I am now calling to order the December 11th 2024 board special meeting to order at 4:34 p.m. this meeting is being recorded we would like to acknowledge that we are on ancestral lands and traditional territories of the Puget Sound Coast Salish people and for the record I will call Ro director brag here director Briggs here pres yeah director Clark pres all right director hery yo director ilas present director Miss Rahi uh oh I I think we heard you enough Joe to know that you're here but um when when we get to it
002if you want to be able to contribute more we might have to think about what's happening with your sound um vice president sergeant present director top here let's see we have a spot for director Yun oh she's online awesome and this is President Ranken all right the objective for this evening's work session is to finalize language for the drafts of the 2025 2030 goals and guard rails and nothing else um coming out of tonight's discussion and proposals uh we will finalize language I will draft that and include it in a bar for introduction at our board meeting next week um then we'll take that back out to our community to confirm that um we've interpreted Community priorities on vision and values um in a way that feels right and makes sense uh before we take
003um action on January 22nd to approve the final versions that will then be our policy for the next uh strategic plan so we're going to begin with goals because we have seen and discussed these recommendations and um had a a decent amount of time with the goals I'm hoping that we can get let's let's let's aim for half an hour I'm going to give us an hour if we need it but but I feel like we've we've narrowed in pretty well um and we just need to make some decisions um and then we'll spend the rest of the time on guard rails with a little bit more discussion because we uh we haven't had as much opportunity together to talk about pros and cons and wording and stuff um but we do still want to
004end the meeting with final drafts for goals and guardrails um so we will start with a brief presentation oh well we have um Fred podesta is is acting super superintendent this evening um as superintendent Jones is out and so uh asked staff to present briefly on kind of recap on the recommendations that we've seen on the topl line goals and guard rails and then available to answer technical questions but we're at the point in the process where it's the board's responsibility to finalize this language based on what we think we heard from the community um and taking to consideration technical expertise from staff but also this is our main uh main representation of how we represent to the district the priorities of our community for the Strategic plan so that needs to come from us
005not from staff so um questions that we do have should focus on supporting us getting to a decision point on the Topline drafts and goals goals and guardrails don't worry about the interims um and it's possible that the superintendent and staff will need to change them based on what we decide finally for those Top Line um so uh yeah so we've requested that the superintendent and staff make recommendations based on their expertise doesn't mean we have to accept the recommendations if we don't agree that they reflect the priorities that we heard from our community um so these recommendations were based on community engagement available resources expertise what they interpret from what they've heard from the board our job is to now determine and decide finally which ones and what we want to move forward with
006to honor our community's vision and values in the most impactful way um we are also joined by Alisha and Carol um governance coaches to um support the conversation if we need to although their role I believe primarily is as as listening and maybe providing us feedback later but they're there if we need to phone a friend um hi everyone thanks for being here um okay so anybody have any questions about that that's so far all right so for goals we have two main things we need to answer we've got a decision to make between two goals versus three and then of the recommended language that's in here for those two versus three um what language do we want to do we want to adopt so I will pass it over to staff or to Acting
007Superintendent pesta to present those Topline recommendations a couple remarks on Dr Jones behalf he wanted me to express his appreciation and gratitude to the board for all the work you did to gather this input from the community and your leadership and making it actionable through the uh goals and guardrails um I think we've all heard um Dr Jones say many times the importance of clarity and that Clarity is kindness and he wanted to emphasize that he and the staff are crystal clear that this is the board's work at this point that we're here to answer technical questions and that you might have about recommendations from staff but um you've got a you've got the staff recommendations you've got experts here if you want to drill into any of those but that we appreciate at this
008point um this is in your hands and um whatever decisions are made uh the team will do their best um to provide the information Downstream that you need to support those so with that I will turn it over to Dr stoski uh good evening uh directors Mike stoski assistant superintendent of academics uh so uh myself and our team are here to uh do just a brief uh summary of where we are based on what we've heard from uh the school board based on what you've heard from community um so on behalf of the superintendent um he again uh as Chief podesta said uh wants to express his deep appreciation for the leadership and vision that you've provided to get us to this point uh we believe what we're presenting to you uh best represents uh
009what you've heard out in community and if we could go to the next slide please so throughout the process uh you as the board and the superintendent have grounded uh what you have heard in the community uh in the following uh areas uh a strong start and a strong finish academic preparation in core subjects so that our students are experiencing uh educ educational equity and high quality instruction and it that they're becoming independent critical thinkers and lifelong Learners in service of them being life ready so throughout this what we're being consistent with is that we want our students to be academically prepared in core subjects to succeed in education for their future careers also that they're meeting High academic standards in core subject areas specifically in Reading Writing and math and also science social studies
010foreign language technology and the Arts and uh connected to them being independent thinkers we want those our students to be lifelong learned ERS who can consider multiple perspectives in problem solving and are adaptable and great citizens in our communities so when we talk about equity in Seattle Public Schools how we're defining it uh clearly is it's high quality instruction with high expectations and effective pedagogy that has engaging curriculum and differentiation to support individual student student learning needs and it also has as equity in our system should be measured by academic performance including standardized test with an emphasis on closing gaps between groups this presentation uh and all of its associating cascading strategies are grounded in the vision that our North Star is equity and student performance and student learning so uh with that being said
011we'd like to uh move to the next slide which is are guiding principles and recommendations so the recommendation that uh superintendent uh Jones is offering to the board for discussion and consideration are based on the following guiding principles first we need to put students on a trajectory towards life ready by Pro focusing on key grade levels and on particular subjects that indicate students are on a trajectory to be life ready second positively influence adult behaviors in our system to move student outcomes across the system and so what you'll see what we've heard clearly is the focus on adults to help and support and move our students and third guide resource and strategy allocations so that we are investing in high leverage strategies that will have the greatest impact on student outcomes so as we know
012the biggest influence uh in school uh for student performance is the quality of teaching the second biggest influencer of in School academic performance is our principles uh and our school leaders so our strategies must impact our school leaders and our teachers our instructional staff who are directly supporting our students and we know that resources matter the quality of the curriculum matters and the professional development and learning of our our staff equally matters in supporting our students so the recommendations uh from Dr Jones uh is the following uh with those principles in mind he is recommending three goals using the following metrics an early learning literacy reading and at third grade as the Topline goal a K8 mathematics goal with seventh grade mathematics as the Topline metric and third and finally a life ready goal with
013diploma plus being a pathway towards completion as a Topline goal the community's vision is for our students to graduate prepared to enroll in college or university or to enter the workforce or to pursue a vocational training program diploma plus is about students en ensuring their preparedness for postsecondary opportunities so as uh president Rankin mentioned the interims will be uh discussed at a later time and not uh being proposed to uh tonight ultimately we are seeking to uh create a predictive system of accountability Milestones across grade levels that support our students and support our our staff as well so with that being said the the main measurements that we're using are going to be focusing on uh smarter balanced so SBA and then measures of academic progress so map and with that I'll hand it over
014to Dr uh Eric Anderson who will talk about the target setting uh thank you Mike uh good afternoon uh Eric Anderson director of research and evaluation uh so before we walk you through the specific recommendations I know you already have some familiar it with them so we'll try to be efficient um we wanted to just briefly outline uh our general approach to uh developing measurable goals and performance targets so consistent with what we've heard from you we're proposing Universal goals for all students in the applicable grades for example all third graders or all second graders um it's important to note that we would always disaggregate the results in our board monitor reports by rate the ethnicity or for key Target groups uh such as students from low-income families or students with IEPs for example so
015in the slides ahead what you'll see is that the proposed performance targets aim for a 10 percentage Point increase over five years or an average two point increase each year from 2025 to through 2030 and again these goals are for an entire grade level so we believe these targets are realistic but only achievable if adult behaviors change systemwide to ensure all students and all schools receed the instruction and supports they need to succeed one thing to note we are currently in our Baseline year uh next year will be year one so we've used an assumed 2025 Baseline to set these targets uh and those were extrapolated based on average gains over the last three years uh we of course plan to revisit this Baseline after the spring 2025 results are available finally and really importantly
016uh while the goals may be Universal we expect our interim goals will be targeted for specific student groups based on the comprehensive needs assessment and initial analysis that will inform the targeted strategies to improve outcomes for students who need the most growth thank you so as we move to the first goal um I want to turn our attention to early literacy so the strong start so for us the smarter balance assessment the SBA um is administered the first time in third grade and is the most reliable measurement of Student Success across the full Continuum of grade literacy skills including Reading Writing speaking and listening so our recommendation is for a Topline goal for literacy at third grade which marks the culmination of foundational skills and instruction per state standards this will help ensure students have
017a strong start so the top line uh goal on the next slide consistent with what Dr Anderson uh said you'll see that the percentage of students in third grade scoring proficient or above an Ela on the smarter balanced will increase from 64.4% in June 2025 to 74.4% in June 2030 so as we look uh forward to aligning our resources and our strategies to drive changes in adult Behavior we will be seeking to create a CO coherent and comprehensive literacy strategy across primary uh primary grades from pre kindergarten so prek through third grade that strategy will rely on increasing teacher and leader Technical and ped pedagogical knowledge of the science of reading which we have spoken uh about in multiple spaces uh with the board and the public so this will help ensure that we're engaging
018our students uh in diverse and challenging texts in front of our students that we're getting curriculum that is has in curriculum embedded assessments uh and that we're able to monitor our student progress early and often and making adjustments to our instruction based on what our students are needing so Dr Jones recommendation in this area is the following first high quality instruction reinforces high quality mathematics uh excuse me high quality literacy instruction reinforces high quality mathema ICS instruction when we look at our data we can see a percentage of students who are proficient in literacy tracks closely with the percentage of students who are proficient in mathematics but mathematics has a steeper drop off in later Elementary School and Middle School second using second grade as our Topline goal rather than third grade could be misleading
019based on what we heard Dr Hart share with us in October as students transition from learning to read to reading to learn important gaps in student learning emerge in third grade and have an impact on future learning success foundational skills taught through second grade such as fluency um are necessary but not sufficient to ensure future success as students transition again from learning to read to reading to learn uh celle hi good evening celle toner executive director curriculum assessment and instruction uh and I'll talk a little bit more about about this proposed goal we recognize that this is similar to our current goal in third grade while we have not met our current targets we believe that there is significant Merit in the goal and that uh and the assessment tools that are already in place
020we've seen some promising gains but we also recognize that we need to monitor our efforts earlier which uh the interim goals could do and shift strategy and adult behavior in some areas in order to significantly accelerate student progress um let's see if we can go to the next slide I think Yep this one so this is a representation of what you heard Dr Anderson talking about um sort of charting out the 2% gain um across the next several years so in support of the community's vision and our shared interest in starting strong and monitoring progress early we recommend that the early Le learning goal starting strong focus on early literacy to have a Topline goal of third grade ELA supported by interim metrics to be developed later in this image you can see um the
021measured realistic and ambitious 10 10 percentage Point gain set from 2025 um um in in the out years so um remember that Dr Hart talked with you um and shared a Hallmark image of um how we described the science of reading with that scar Bros rope in October um and he talked you about the importance of a P3 strategy including opportunities for children to develop background knowledge and vocabulary development um and that really drove us to thinking about the third grade Topline measure of the SBA because that's the time when students get to demonstrate and synthesize their thinking read something and write about it which are um the skills for um that developmental stage that really do predict future academic success so moving on to the next goal um is Middle School mathematics and uh
022to put uh forward for consideration so the superintendent's second recommendation is a middle school mathematics goal focusing on seventh grade math proficiency while including a broader set of interims that capture and uh Later Elementary and Middle School experience so what Dr Jones wanted to make clear was that um although the uh School Board uh did not um ask for this specific goal uh in the draft ongoing student needs and assessments continue to surface uh and create critical challenges in Middle School map uh which directly impacts our students Readiness uh for Life ready coursework and requires critical thinking in high school rates for meeting uh standard in math in the SBA uh decline in grad 6 through 12 indicating that middle school is a key uh juncture and important to focus on for math so for
023us moving forward uh Dr uh Perkins will briefly discuss the math goal thank you Dr stoski uh Caleb Perkins executive director of college Inc Readiness and as we transition to the next slide you can see as Dr saski shared it is critical that we have a strong continuation in Middle School grades that is why this is our recommendation a critical bridge between third grade literacy and the life ready goal that we want all of our students to be able to access so the specific uh targeting piece I think we're moving on to the next Slide the specific Topline measure is the percentage of students in seventh grade scoring proficient or above in math on the smarter balance assessment and we'll get into more of the percentages in just a moment but I want to underscore
024and Echo some of the comments that executive director toner mentioned this uh work at the middle school grades is critical to ensure that we're driving adult behaviors across our system from Elementry to Middle to high and as we'll talk about with the life ready goal the only way we can ensure that students are not only knowing what they want to do after they graduate but ready for it is to ensure they have a strong foundation in particular areas including math in the Middle School grades a h a big predictor of success as executive director toner also all uded to we are seeing promising signs in fact we'll be talking about more with this board on December 18th around some of the uh progress we're seeing in student achievement in math and yet another reason why
025uh we're advocating uh recommending this additional uh goal so we can move to the next slide once again echoing executive director toner for the third time um these are targets that are measured realistic and ambitious trying to learn from our past round of strategic plan and so you can see that we're aiming for also a 2% growth each year for a 10% gain overall um and as uh Dr Anderson also shared this would also be broken down in the interims uh by subgroups to ensure that we're helping support all students and with that I'll turn it back to Dr stoski so the third and final goal is the life ready goal and as Dr Jones has uh previously uh mentioned uh is and referenced is that the life uh ready goal is to push ourselves
026a little bit in our thinking about what we've traditionally done uh when it comes to life ready by proposing that we create what uh we are calling a diploma plus pathway for students as Dr Jones referenced diploma plus is about ensuring preparedness for post-secondary opportunities based on each student's individual needs uh and also their individual interests and what they are planning for uh during high school for post High School uh State legislation passed in 2019 expanded the ways in which Washington students can prepare for a meaningful First Step uh with After High School unfortunately meeting the new state requirements does not ensure students graduate ready to take courses in college or university without the need for re remediation so for us uh compounding that problem is the fact that many students have required emergency waivers
027to graduate from high school particularly in the aftermath of the pandemic so for the class of 2023 approximately 42% of African-American male and 3 35% of students of color Furs from educational Justice required one or more credit pathway waivers to graduate and so with the our diploma plus is direct ly connected to our College and Career Readiness goals uh in emphasis and so we need to do more to support our students and prepare our students so this goal sits right in the middle um uh for the life ready goal proposal we want our students to be ready for uh higher wages and professions in stem so science technology engineering and math uh fields and our growth in a city like Seattle this should be our priority and is our priority so that our students can
028be Seattle ready by 2030 Washington stem uh estimates that nearly 90% of high school and high demand uh family sustaining wage jobs in King County will require a postsecondary uh degree or credential um and so with that I I'll pass it back over to um Dr Perkins to sh more light uh to our final goal here thank you Dr stoski um so the Topline measure building off of Dr st's comments would be the percentage of students in each cohort or graduate and successfully complete a personalized life ready diploma plus pathway aligned to their high school and Beyond plan and this speaks to what we heard from our last conversation I think it was President Ranken in particular who said the community clearly said they want uh students to know where where they want to go
029what they want to do and then have the skills and the ability to do it and so we're trying to design um this goal to help meet the spirit of that that request uh we believe we can design Pathways that go beyond the basic graduation requirements as Dr shoski alluded to that uh we believe that to be truly ready we need to set a higher bar than merely on-time graduation um so one thing just to note on that as you look at the bottom of this screen you'll see the initial proposed diploma plus Pathways uh really basically there would be a pathway in stem science technology engineering and math one in Humanities arts and social science Sciences one in career in technical education and one in dual language including uh the Seal of biliteracy so
030the idea is that students would not only uh have ample time to explore and learn uh a variety of things through their core graduation requirements but they would go a Step Beyond to truly ensure that they're ready for for a variety of Pathways that said um we do understand that the board has uh weighed in on this and and has some um thoughts on exactly how to explore this we do believe that we will need additional time with you all to determine what exactly these Pathways would be and we look forward to getting that input and Community input on uh exactly what uh the pathways that we want to commit to are with that I'll go to one more slide and just share that we have done some initial analysis it's a little hard to
031see the the gray bars there on the left but uh bottom line just to kind of give an initial sense just uh thank you to Dr Anderson based on preliminary analysis of the class of 2023 59% of all students uh would have graduated without waivers and successfully completed one of these diploma plus Pathways just to give you a sense of where we'd be starting from again we have a lot more work to do on that front to really make sure that aligns well with the community input on life ready goal with that I'll turn it back to Dr stoski thank you so uh in wrapping up um here um if we are to move move forward we're proposing uh three goals for your consideration um and Dr Jones wanted uh to make uh public and
032rest assured that if we were to go to uh two goals that uh the staff uh would uh be in support of the third grade literacy goal and the life ready goal um but we're uh here to answer any and all questions that you may have um but uh Dr Jones wanted to reemphasize that if we opt for two goals we'll of course continue to do focused work on mathematics and elementary and middle and high school that's never going to go away for our our priority uh but we can share uh that the resources that we all know um that we're competing for are very limited and understand that you have uh strong considerations that you need to make and so with that I'll turn it back over to uh president Ranken for any questions
033and discussion thank you very much okay excuse me um first uh just for those of you uh directors online please use the hand raise function as you do and for those of us in the room we're going to do this if you have a question or comment um just so I can keep track of everybody and um make sure that everyone has the opportunity to speak who wants to before we move to any second round or any other other topic um so uh the um first thing is if anybody has any clarifying questions or other about the information that we saw from staff that we need answered before we get into decision making director hery go ahead all right so um I do want to just like ask to staff given that y'all are overseeing
034the day-to-day um how has it been managing three goals because I am really trying to drill down and be thoughtful about the fact that like I want to do fewer things really well as opposed to having a goal that yeah so I'm going to end my question there so it would it would be helpful to hear from y'all's perspective how has managing three goals been for the system over the past few years I can start on that um so in my role in the last year and a half um it's it's a little difficult to manage because as we're reporting back back out um we're trying to get the um the other reports back right and so there's a lot of work of managing just reporting back out um and but I can't say though
035a positive of doing that is that we're seeing the opportunities for alignment right um about the the behaviors say adult behaviors right um that we could be doing uh in aligning so I think through through through some of the struggle of reporting out continuously um it requires us to be a little bit more intentional about what it is that we can truly do but it's a it's a struggle at times okay uh the next question that I have is do you think that the system well between oh can I ask a second question okay between the math goal and the literacy goal which one do you think the system has had an easier time adjusting to and adopting like which one is closer to being implemented with Fidelity good question go ahead take your time
036no I'm I'm I'll I'll say what I I think about this one and and Others May jump in so I think uh what we've seen with the success and the challenges for doing third grade reading okay has really informed how we've created and structured the math goal right and so the Lessons Learned U about how to implement a systemwide uh Focus um and so I think the the lessons learned from third grade reading just structurally has helped us set things up for Success on the front end right um for implementation for the for the math goal right and so i' I'd say those are those things are are so connected and it also informs our College and Career Readiness goal and then also whatever is chosen uh tonight and into the future we can implement
037the lessons that we've already learned to be able to build off some of the successes but also equally the the struggles I'm good for right now okay great so thank you very much to staff they will they will stay at the tables should questions arise but we want to move now to focusing mainly on the board making decisions about the goals that we're going to set um so uh director bricks why don't you go ahead and just put put your put your thing down so I can remember as we go around to make sure I get to everybody okay um so I'm just going to like whip through all my thoughts in the interest of uh we're 20 minutes away from being at the hour deadline um I think oh was this okay um I
038feel pretty strongly that we need two goals and instead of three I just feel like let's as Brandon said let's do fewer things well um so I just want to put in a plug for that's that's my strong opinion here um regarding the the third goal or the second goal rather the College and Career Readiness I guess and maybe this maybe this is a staff question I'm I'm I'm struggling with how the this diploma plus um thing is is different from what's already been codified by the state in the future ready initiative and the updated graduation requirements and I'm wondering why instead we wouldn't put uh put more of an investment towards school counselors based on the feedback that we received from the audit um that I don't I know that wasn't presented to the
039full board but everybody had access to it and it just it feels to me like that's where we need to focus um sure yeah so we there was a um an audit done on school the basically school counselor function and how much we are underutilizing school counselors for specifically for um gradu for kids helping kids be College and Career ready um and that a lot of school counsel there's like a conflation happening between um what the actual role of a school counselor is versus like a mental health counselor or a social worker and if we if we had the appropriate supports in buildings so school counselors could perform their actual Duty which is to help kids graduate and know what's next that that would have way more of an impact on on our outcomes and
040so I would like to see us focus on on that um as opposed to dipl diploma plus which feels very redundant with future ready to me and you know there could be something I'm missing here but um that that's all I have for right now that those are my feelings um uh director ilas um from a students's perspective the life ready diploma plus pathway isn't really necessary if we were to focus on adequately supporting students and guiding them through what they want to do and ensuring their success by regular check-ins and making sure they know what they want to do Post high school and are on track for setting them up for graduation and pursuing a career they want Dr brag well Sophia proceeds to say a much clearer version of basically what I was
041going to say very similarly because also director Briggs brings up a lot of that from a student perspective diploma plus once again comes into just like adding on to stuff we already should be working on and you brought up counselers before I was actually going to a lot of it is less about like oh what more can we do for this a lot of students don't even know how they graduate they don't know what the requirements are they don't need more they should be told and they're doing it's that they need to know how they get there and they need support within their schools they need I need to be able to say that I've met with my C more than two times about my Readiness Plan a lot of like we we talk about
042pathway learning a lot um most students don't know what pathway they're on if I ask anybody at my schools hey do you know what the CTE pathway is they have no idea what I'm saying I'm talking nonsense to them um so adding on to life Readiness what it a strong finish to me does not look like diploma plus it looks like students knowing how they finish and getting the support within their schools from a lot of the other stuff you you brought up the audit before I could but yeah a lot of that so I just don't know the use of diploma plus I don't understand it fully director ilas oh no you already went sorry yeah director hery go ahead um yeah so not to pile on to the diploma plus thing I actually
043have a it sounds like there are kind of like two components here from when we were talking about this goal the first time um and I really want to dovetail with what director Bragg said the fact that it almost feels like there is the very real need for a strong finish as well as a solid start so like when we were brainstorming this idea there was a component of like or at least the essence of it was around all right when you leave Seattle Public Schools do you have a resource a document a play a personal Playbook or at least an idea or a road map for what comes next for you right so that's one piece then the other piece that I think is really poignant is the fact that like we can't even
044do that because there it seems like there are a bunch of of students um for a variety of reasons who are struggling to even figure out like I I'm not worried about what the start looks like after high school I'm trying to finish High School right so those almost feel to me separate and so what I guess I would ask back to the students is what do you feel as though and I know it's kind of like a chicken and an egg kind of situation but from y'all's Vantage Point what do you think is impacting students more because we have data that suggest that our graduation rates are good kids might not necessarily know how they're getting there but a lot are getting there objectively right that doesn't mean that like you know I I
045know that there is a whole system of pushing kids along and like just on a track but do you think from y'all's perspective it would be more helpful to have supports with finishing as opposed to supports or like from y have heard from your peers supports in determining what's next whether it be college career starting your own business potentially um I would love to hear y'all riff a little bit about that yeah go ahead so I mean to start yeah a lot of it is the fact that pushing along a lot of students are at least I know within my feeling is a lot of students tend to be told there's one pathway and it's college so a lot of times we would I think and I think Sophia would agree with this a lot
046of times you're kind of told like hey you want to go somewhere in life you got to go to college it's a Seattle culture thing and I know that um and with like Seattle ready like what our city expects out of people does tend to be those more stem focused those more that but a lot of students within our schools are kind of pushed towards one pathway and they're pushed through school and not told about other options a lot of options within schools that are meant to be presented like you're meant to be presented with all your options for postgraduation and you're supposed to make that plan you're kind of told your only way for that plan tends to be one or the other thing um and a lot of them are looked down upon
047uh I feel like it a lot of students don't know where they're going after high school so they'll pick the option that is most widely and variety like told to go to which is college but that's whole discussion but they'll pick one thing that they're just going to with no preparation so it does feel like that pathway that having something that shows you okay a counselor walked me through how all of these Pathways can get there I feel like this one is the best for me because we don't have that that's the more important part is the your you're walked through where you can go after high school because a lot of students they'll push through they'll get to they'll get through high school and they finish it but they have no idea what they're
048doing after so they'll pick an option that will maybe maybe they'll go along with it for a year maybe they'll feel okay with that but they don't know where they're going so you and a lot of students are Contin cycling through like they're pushing through high school with no plan for the after so they even also fall off where they they get really stressed at the end of high school you're not doing as well you're not finishing well because you don't know where you're going after answer that too yeah um I really like what you said about a solid start um I definitely feel like if a lot of students were given some time in the beginning of high school to sit down and create a plan of what they want to pursue and what
049they want to do um that will give them motivation motivation Drive they actually have something they're working towards other than um a diploma and um also giving them multiple different Pathways other than college and being like you have to go to college no there's all these different ways you can do what you want to do do it if you want and that would just you know help students go through high school and actually give them some idea of what they want to do and you know in the end make them successful that's really thank you um so I'm going to go and then I'll go to director top um and then come back to you uh so I um am hearing and also support oh okay great uh support um two goals as opposed to
050three I think um what we're looking for really is to influence change throughout the system that centers on student outcomes and so why would why would we keep the same three things that just feels like let's just keep doing what we're doing um which I know we haven't had an you know it takes five to six years for this kind of systemic change to to happen so I don't expect that in two years we we we should have seen you know a huge leap in progress but um my concern is more about a mindset shift and also about what we heard from our community which to me was so clearly getting kids the support and intervention they need as soon as possible because once you get past second grade I mean I hear from parents
051and students that basically literacy skills are not even taught after second grade so if you didn't get them by second grade too bad like good luck to you and um like and that's and I do not fault Any teacher or school for that I I fault this building and all of us in well it's not fault but the responsibility for shifting that is actually on us here to say everybody out in buildings is working their butts off trying to meet the needs of students with without the structural support and capacity building that they're really desperately asking for um and what we heard from from community members was very reflective of that is is knowing that you know by the time a parent um you know just Child Development and everything by the time a parent
052realizes oh my gosh I should really be concerned about my kids reading it's kind of too late we need staff and teachers to have the the time and ability to say hey I'm noticing that um you know this child it looks like they could be at risk of having dyslexia or some other need that needs to be addressed um because and I say this as a as a parent too of kids with disabilities my one of my kids had a significant language um uh issue when he was really little and I would have we would have noticed eventually but having a professional go huh the development of these different sounds is not he he was an outlier and with that early recognition and support we were able to get him what he needed to to
053be able to to go on accessing education that everyone else was accessing and so I feel like we heard really clearly from Community how important that early and Equitable support is we have as a kind of systemic thing if you if you learn to read great and if you don't well that a bummer for you um and we really need to actually shift so that the kids who are flagged through Dibbles or whatever as as needing more intervention actually get them and that those supports and that capacity in the buildings is driven by this building and bringing that out to people um that's what we really need and so uh I I think we just need to focus on that get you know that the setting up kids early to be successful whatever happens next
054when they're when they're little and then um our community too I think was really strong about the Strong finish part the um yes we want them we want ontime graduation but more than that we want kids to feel like they graduate with a future of their choosing that they're not being tracked or forced into something but that they know and I also I have a 10th grader right now he has never heard of the high school and Beyond plan he has never been talked to about Pathways I have I the president of the school board have no idea if he's enrolled in the right classes to meet graduation requirements no idea um and so we got to get just kind of those structures and support out in the buildings rather than creating a new thing
055that takes a lot of time and energy here and doesn't actually get to students um uh uh director Clark and then I'll go to you director Mahi thank you um so I think I generally agree with my colleagues around um you know working smarter um and focusing on um two goals um and uh really trying to do them well um that being said I have a concern that if we let go of the math goal that it potentially could impact um our overall like graduation life career um Beyond High School Readiness goal um I'm just thinking back to um uh the um assessment results that we got back um from the council for great City schools and the six sixth uh grade math scores in particular um for our students for this from opportunity um
056and black boys um and so I guess one I just wanted to state that two I'm wondering and this is my first time doing this so forgive me if there's a way that we can have two um like goals focused on like one on math one on literacy and have like structurally have like an interim goal interim goals around um kind of the high school and Beyond um so I guess that's a comment and a question thank you uh director Mahi thanks Sarah yeah I turned off my camera I hope folks can hear me okay is that okay yes we can hear you wonderful okay so couple quick thoughts um I also support two go um would love to hear other discussion from the board director around the second grade versus third grade um question
057on the diploma plus I think everyone's making very Salient points about not doubling up on person defending diploma plus because I have my own questions about it but the one defense I will say is that one thing we' also heard a lot about is a lot of the programmatic things within the district like dual language like stem and this is really the only place that that exists in a goal so if we were to move away from diploma plus to a different graduation metric I'd want to understand how those factors could fit into interim goals or guard rails so uh generally supportive of maybe doing something that like not creating a new thing and doing and sticking with something that already exists but want to make sure that we're not leaving out the feedback we
058heard from the community on some of these um beloved programs all right in the spirit of moving forward I feel like I'm hearing consensus around two versus three okay so let's now talk about early literacy and or strong start strong finish if everybody is is ready to move to that part of the discussion okay um so now what we need to consider is um well third grade versus second grade and the and the wording here and then the the um the the last one so Dr sju thank you um so when I I think well first of all for people who are listening and may not be able to have the luxury of seeing um I'm going to do a math problem for the high school students I moved to this District in December of
059of 1985 how many years have I lived here go ahead 39 yeah that's close that's close almost 40 um and that's not performative it is to say that um having lived here that long and not see change is pretty disheartening um I have a 34 a 32 and a 30-year-old um and I'm just shocked that we're still here and so to support what everyone else has said the uh strong start strong finish two goals I think we need to prove that we can actually change the trajectory before we start adding things on because we're continuing to fail the same kids over and over again and we just keep refining our rhetoric to make it sound good and I'm if you're hearing some frustration and sarcasm not so much sarcasm but frustration I'm done with the
060performative we need to get to work we need to see the numbers change that said by the time kids get to third grade we are in intervention mode and I do not think our strategy should be intervention it should be promotion and prevention and then intervention is the last thing the last stop on the train and so if we're waiting until third grade for a lot of kids specifically black boys we're in intervention mode we've completely ignored promotion and prevention and now we're trying to make up that is not logical and so my thinking is we need to be tracking this for second grade and I don't know how we word it I'm not trying to um make that up at this point um but I can say from personal experience my and I'm going
061to tell a very quick story because this is poignant my oldest child had a third grade teacher who requested to have all the black boys in his class this child is 34 y'all can do the math on that third grade eight or nine and the reason why this teacher requested to have all the black boys in his class is because he had watched year after year after year second grade black boys entering third grade leaving third grade not on target every single one of those black boys was reading above grade level by the time they finished third grade that is a targeted strategy I'm going to tell you it pissed a whole bunch of people off because people thought well that means we don't get any black kids in our class I'm like my kids
062are not a Pawn on your chessboard I'm trying to get my kids ready we're trying to get these black boys ready and so this teacher recognized that I hope he's still alive because I would thank him his name is Mr David Wilhelm um he changed the trajectory of those black boys in third grade data showed it they were ready and they're all doing well I'm pleased to say they're all doing well and so why would we wait till third grade to do a intervention strategy when we can actually figure out the kids that need some more prevention or some more promotion promotion prevention that's the order so my hope is that my colleagues will recognize while we have this s is it SBA I I don't even know what that means but we're going to
063pretend like I do the acronyms um why would we wait when we already know we have 40 plus years of data to tell us that waiting till third grade only means we're doing intervention particularly for the kids that we have not been serving historically for at least 39 years if not forever so that's my comment um I see two cards up I have a suggestion for wording on second grade which I can offer now or if you all want to okay so in alignment with what well that's what I'm asking that's what I'm asking um but just to and if we're like nope that's yes we want second grade but not that that's fine um but and I emailed this to everybody earlier today um when we look at the the so esac is required
064by the feds federal government requires states to administer some kind of standardized test to sort of affirm that kids are reading and that they should keep giving us money that's why that back exist um uh and and it's it's I fully anticipate that we would still be interested in the results of that uh in general but in terms of talking about the goals that we're going to use to represent our community's vision and to measure whether or not the district is successful educ successfully educating children um I'm also in favor of of the second grade goal and so I would propose uh instead of the percentage of student students that pass the esbc that we look at the percentage of students in second grade that meet or exceed key grade level standards for foundational literacy
065skills will increase from blank percent in June to blank percent in uh uh 2025 to 2030 and the reason the key key literacy skills you know I would obviously leave open to the people do this but um com align to the state competencies of what a second grader should know know and be able to do is uh phonological awareness word recognition fluency that without those that yes the comprehension the other things that come along of course are important but if you don't have those foundational building block skills you can't you can't get to any of those other things um and uh so yeah that would be my recommendation that um and also I I think uh my concern with the back is that then the uh inadvertently Focus could become on getting kids to pass
066the standardized assessment instead of making sure kids are able to read and so if we're looking at these key indicators which are also indicators of success on the esack um we we we hear from our community like how do we know kids can read and are ready to learn whatever they want to learn in the future um I feel like these indicators would be more leverage than ASC but so I don't know if um now if anybody has something different they want to recommend we could talk about that or if we want to go from what I just read and determine whether or not we want that to be the strong start goal I see I don't know who um I think director Briggs and then director hery oh oh For Heaven's Sake um okay
067I I very much support what you're proposing Liza I'm in agreement with with what Michelle said as well um I think that all makes sense and I'm down I also just wanted time check us it's after 5:30 um the question I have and this might be one that Carol Andor Alicia could answer for us but um I know the first time we made these goals I was not on the board but um they they were wildly unrealistic like it was a growth of 40 percentage points over 5 years or something insane um which obviously unrealistic but is 10% is that the right goal is is that is is I mean and I'm I I actually don't know what is realistic I I want us to push I want to push ourselves to you know really
068um because it's so overdue um but I I I also want to stay within the realm of of what's realistic and 10 10 point going from 40% percentage points to 10 percentage points just makes me wonder if we're under this is under ambitious I I don't know I I'm honestly just asking um because I I have no sense of you know what what is realistic in this case so if if one of our uh coaches has something to add you know guidance on that I'd love to hear it um Alicia do you want to weigh in or I can share I mean that is that's not um that's really a question for your educational experts but it is the appropriate discussion you know what level of um a Target is the right sweet spot that's
069going to require adult Behavior change but is obtainable that that's a conversation worth having but we're not in a position to advise you on that that's really a question of for your experts and you know that's not even anything that we could say we don't know that's a between the board and the administration about um where that sweet spot is but having that discussion is recommended what would it uh would it be appropriate to drill down on the number um when we're at introduction a week from now or is that something we can hash out right now CU we still have guard rails to get to that's um I I think like to talk about that at introduction I mean your call I mean I I that's a timing priority question I I think just
070as long as you make sure that you're comfortable as a board that you've um discussion that you have the right sweet spot I you know I kind of you have to decide when and how in terms of the timing to continue this conversation or set it aside I think you already have the recommendation from staff that includes that think that that's a um that is a bit of a stretch goal and that I think he would prefer that if there needs to be more discussion on that that you do that at introduction so you can try to get through the what you were trying to do tonight uh director seru did you just say 10% over 5 years is a stretch goal that's what's embedded in our in the staff recommendation I want to drill
071down further to see um if that's appropriate or not but just in terms of so again Dr Jones was very clear he didn't want this discussion if it works for the board to be kind of a debate of the recommendation it's there and that was considered so at intro if you want to you know consider refine it that would be great thank you director CL oh sorry um um uh director Clark and then and then director hery yeah I just wanted to say I guess I just feel the opposite that um I mean obviously I want us to hit that right sweet spot between the percentage that is going to change adult behavior and um also have an impact on students um and I I agree that um the last plan was very um I
072think ambitious but maybe not realistic and I would really like us to set a goal that is attainable um and just remind my colleagues that systems change takes time changing adult Behavior doesn't happen overnight um so that with that I'll pass all right Dr hery uh having taught second grade I think that 10% over 5 years especially if you're thinking about the target population and where they are now is both reasonable and a stretch goal right I think that what it's helpful for me is that if you're thinking about you know over five years if we've got 10,000 black boys then that means that 1,000 of them 1,000 more than our right now will be reading on grade level and for a system of our size you know and those numbers are fudged right I
073know that that's not necessarily the case but for a system R size the benefit of that will be astronomical because it compounds if you look at it from a perspective of this is less about the students that we have right now and more so about the students who are about to come into our care and the impact that this will have down the line right both are wildly important but the real benefit is to get a solid foundation for what literacy looks like in our system so that all of the students who are going to be coming after the students that we have right now are going to be the ones that benefit the most from this now that's not to say that and I think that we accomplished both goals by focusing it IR
074ly on second grade right because when a child having taught second grade and knowing what it's like in third the energy is completely different yall have children right like there is a very significant shift that happens in the like General demeanor of a child when they transition from second grade to third grade because the stakes are higher right I think that there's a real opportunity here to look at and this will be for y'all right to look at what are the areas that we are seeing that we are strug Ling the most on the SBA in the third grade and really focusing in on those things in the second grade I think that there are kind of competing concerns of mine the first one is I want to make sure that we're not like extending
075over testing and all of this non not nonsense but all of this stuff to second grade however at some phase when you boil it down there's not a big difference in teaching the the test in teaching a child to read like I think that there is an overreliance in some spaces of like oh like you're teaching to the test or X Y and Z at that age it's teaching a kid to read right I think it's the way that we do it and the in the tools and the resources and the energy that we put into it but the content and the context are largely the same um so my where I'm going with that is I am actually really excited about 2% year-over-year with a goal of 10% because it's more so for me
076about laying the foundation and I also want to make sure that the way in which we get there is continually based in the foundations of reading um I'm trying to think if there's anything else that I wanted on that no I would be really interested at whatever phase we get there I mean I think that like plc's in general and I know that there's some of this going on but specific second one through three plc's um on a regular basis are going to be a critical part of that um trying to think no I'm good but yeah I I like where that goal is I want to make sure that it's focused on second grade and that um yeah the only thing I would add to that would be that if if what we all
077would love to see happen happens and we hit 10% growth grow sooner we can adjust the Top Line goal uh director Serio well of course I'm going to go with the second grade teachers analysis with this one caveat um what if my fear is that we're not even going to reach that and so what if we had this is a what if and I'm not tied to this but I'm going to put it on the table what if it I'm I'm going to throw out a number what if the goal were 15% and we hit 10 I would feel better that if the goal was 50 as opposed to 40 to 70 that was I mean woo wee lesson lesson learned for the adults in the room yeah um I W if we're going to
078say it's 10 it better be 10 yeah that's all I got to say because otherwise we are still doing the same thing with a lower goal it's kind of like this thing of it's better to aim a little bit higher and Miss than aim low and and and hit or not hit like we haven't proven that we can actually meet a goal yeah so that's all I'm saying I'm not going to argue because I trust you you've taught second grade you know better than anybody else in this room by far and I'm I have a lot of um angst that we're not even going to hit the 10 yeah if we just set it at 10 yeah so absolutely I mean there's a lot of ways that you could get at that right like I
079think at the end of the day like we all want to hit 10 um I think like ideally if we hit 10 more quickly that's when you can start talking about working bonuses and stuff like that into the contract there's got to be some incentive there to hit it early right because if we hit if regardless if we set it at 10 or 15 right now that's not going change the effort and energy that a leader regardless of who it is would put into it if we find a way to incentivize the system to hit 10 earlier then that changes the energy I think potentially that gets put into it so it's just like how do we trigger the system and this might not necessarily be a question for us this particular board to wrestle
080with right it might be you know the people who come after us but I think a part of it is also like behavioral economics um there the people are going to do whatever they're going to do regardless of if we as a board set the number for 10 or 15 I would be really interested in thinking about like in hearing for um staff at some point and maybe this isn't and I know this isn't the venue but just putting it on the table I would like to hear from staff is like okay y'all have had a really lofty goal y'all have been working toward it uh for the past several months couple years what incentives and instruments have y'all used to inspire change and growth aside from just mandates and things like that that we
081as a board can attribute resources to potentially um if the legislature helps us out yeah well I think that's the the continuing conversation is also through progress monitoring so as we're monitoring through year one if we see oh wow this is actually turns out this strategy is extremely effective and we're looking to um it looks like that's you know going to make a big impact or we get to the end of year one and say well we did you know a five or 4% gain at one year we always have the option to say well should we should we from here now adjust the the the end point um or should we give it another year or whatever that's always the continuing conversation um so I feel like we could talk about this a lot
082what I think I'm hearing is that we are interested in a second grade literacy goal okay so what we need to decide now is um uh what we want to be measured so I'll read again my proposed wording which is just a take you know take it or leave it um the percentage of students in second grade that meet or exceed key grade level standards for foundational literacy will increase from blank percent in June 2025 to blank percent in June I microphone microphone sorry I um I have no I yes but that that language works for me I think that sounds that sounds great to personally and so the question really for staff then would be you know we say key literacy standards do we want do I don't think we should I don't think
083the seven of us or 10 of us should be in um the business of deciding which key standards those are um I think they're probably what we look for on Dibbles but um but there are also aligned to the state standards and science of reading and all these other things um uh pheic awareness recognition of fluency def my colleagues but it seems like uh the team could probably use time to add introduction get a little bit more specific about what that might mean so what we do need to though not waffle on as a board and well maybe this maybe that is am I am I hearing accurately that there is consensus around a second grade measure looking at uh foundational literacy skills as our early start goal all right done or maybe not uh
084is comprehension included in that no it's just the reading like that gives me pause just [Music] because where do y'all feel like our comprehension education is at in third grade youall feel like it's strong I think doesn't Dibbles have a composition element comprehension or sorry no you're good comprehension can I just offer one cuz we yeah this wasn't in the needs assessment cuz we didn't give them dibles data yeah but we have been looking at it um I'm pretty confident this is accurate so in the 13 literacy skills we looked at the percentage of boy black boys who were at Benchmark in second grade based on dibles MH so no red flags you know um 40% of those students were projected to be proficient on the SBA in third grade okay if they were above
085Benchmark mhm about 2/3 so as long as you recognize that foundational skills from what we've seen in the data and what I think we believe as Educators yeah is part of the developmental story yeah and by as no means gives us a strong indicator that they are going to be at grade level in future years as long as you understand that okay do we do any kind of comprehension work already in second grade like what is the breakdown versus foundational skills and maybe foundational is the issue there's I mean in the in the state standard Matrix there's comprehension and foundational and interpretation breakdown or or different different um competencies yep but it's a progression of learning as we've discussed many times right so kids generally when they learn to read the foundational skills and then
086you build in the comprehension because your you know the way your brain is working is doing the work to decode and once you that's more automatic then the comprehension U becomes more um accessible right yeah and that typically happens in third grade and it's typically measured by the um you know the component of writing on the SBA mhm [Music] mhm I'm going to let this go but there's something like turning in my brain about that um I mean again the we're not going to abandon looking at the esack yeah and just sort of like and I wouldn't expect for anybody to be like I guess we're not going to teach comprehension anymore because the goal is is this other thing um director top you look like you're considering something so and you you sort of
087said this in your presentation but you recommended third grade for a reason can you just reiterate the reason that you recommended third grade be the measure sure so we recommended third grade um because it's sort of the com the culmination and the thinking was to have the topl line measure be third grade because it um SBA measures both the uh underlying skills which are those found skills and then the writing component which is the comprehension understanding that we would you know in this conversation we're not supposed to really talk about the intra measures but the thinking was to have a first grade intra measure and a second grade intra measure that then build to that third grade so that that whole goal really works together as a P3 kind of systems goal we can rethink
088if if the board wants to you know really um have a uh unique focus on second grade I'm totally open to that I'm just sharing with you the rationale as to why we offered that third grade also in compliment uh to Dr Hart's presentation here with his uh thinking around you know scar Bros rope and vocabulary development and all how all that works together I'm not at all going to say that it doesn't matter because this all matters a great deal at the same time we got to pick something we just got to pick something so second grade okay second grade uh meet or exceed key grade level standards for literacy done okay that will be goal one goal two uh I heard a lot of agreement around um understanding what was behind the diploma
089plus recommendation but the concerns about creating a new obstacle or a new system that maybe only some students can access and what we heard from our community was that students graduate having what they need to take whatever step it is they want to take next which to the point of the diploma plus sometimes means beyond what the state pathway is um I will note too that the state is working on their high school and Beyond plan and some life ready pathway stuff that might um uh provide a lot more of the structure that we're talking about creating um and so uh I would lean more towards we should use what we have um and that a way to reflect that might be that the percentage of students who successfully complete a State graduation pathway plus
090any additional requirements to take the next step that they want to take might be a way of getting at that without kind of the I'm also thinking about goals as being communication to our community and adding another adding diploma plus which is just another question mark of what the heck is that um is not as accessible as saying directly what we heard from Community which is that they graduate having a plan and and being prepared to do the next thing so that that again would be my recommendation for the college one that we kind of reord it that successfully complet completing um a State graduation pathway plus additional requirements as shown through their use of the high school and Beyond plan because I think that is a tool that's available and there's also a new
091uh the state's working on a whole new structure of that that I think will be more accessible and user friendly and um uh adjustable for for our needs um that we should not reinvent but use that I'm I'm sorry just really quick I know that this isn't from a a space of advocacy for one you know we'll fully support what wherever Direction you go I just want to make a little bit more clarity around the diploma plus sort of intent and that is remember Dr Hart he sort of talked about this sort of consistent onethird of our students who seem to be low grade level you know all the way looking back at kindergarten Readiness but then our graduation rate is 85% and so we were trying to address the issue do we actually believe
092that all of a sudden we've closed the Gap when they finish around Readiness that was the intent it wasn't to create a a whole new initiative it was how do we solve that problem which I think is that I mean at least my interpretation it this feels like we're all very much aligned that maybe it's just how we how we um descri how we talk about it that's that's let's make sure it's really clear that this is um you know not following in the Seattle tradition of like not only are we going to do this we're going to do it better than everybody in a new and different way and and then we what we actually want is just can can we just can we just do the thing can we just do the thing
093um uh Dr seru um maybe Dr Eric has already answered this but is diploma plus something we're purchasing or something you made up something you made up we tried to be very careful that The Branding and however we would what we call it would something we'd want to take time you know so it was it was the state has a framework I think it's a good framework it gives students different pathway options sounds like we need to do a lot more to educate our students about how that works um but again it is the system is designed in a sense to make sure as many kids finish as possible it's not necessarily guarantee that they will be ready for whatever is next and so we were diploma plus just meant yes we want to make
094sure they get a diploma what would that extra thing be that that we can encourage and support them to do that that was all it was meant to be so no it's not a program it's not something I think I think other that yeah it wasn't even a requirement necessarily I think it would be more meaningful if it was something kids knew about and understood but as you see we we can generate numbers just based on what rules we want to apply even what criteria we want to apply so um so my the the finish of that comment is we've heard from the students who are in the system who have spoken the truth and I would say that that's been a lasting Truth for 39 years and we can't just keep pretending like you
095know rebranding something or renaming something is what is going to get it done what's going to get it done is adults doing what they need to do that is includes not tracking students not making them feel like they only have I see you over there I've been watching you nodding your head I don't know are you in high school okay so we got somebody in the audience who's been nodding the whole time um I I think we need to listen to the experts in the room they're telling us that if counselors actually had the capacity to do their jobs they could actually fulfill what is the the state plan and this this notion that counselors are not able to do their jobs is not a new notion it has been that way for decades and
096that's what we need to focus on we need to focus on listening to students they're telling us what what they want they don't want something new they want to utilize and leverage an an existing resource and to me that's brilliant that we have young people telling the adults let's utilize and leverage the existing resource that we have in our system that is currently not being utilized for the benefit of the student that's where we need to put our our Focus so I don't really care what we call it I I really think we need to focus on what we already have and what we know can work rather than creating something new that then we have to do a whole education campaign and we're we're clearly not doing a good job with not having a
097name for what we're not doing and so let's figure out how to do what we know we can do and what these students have articulated and that's meet with them more than twice right for 10 minutes or not at all that's a family experience I can say zero counselor input for two of the three of my kids so we need to lean into what we have I'm going to say a yes and to that which is the that that utilizing the counselors or or how we get to the goal is not what we want to be focusing on we want to be focusing on what is it that we want to say students need to know and be able to to do based on what we heard from the the community and given that I
098don't I actually don't think that there's misalignment um is that new yes director brag it kind of adds on to both what I would just say with this is it is just the plus factor that adds on we don't need more as students we need it equitably and consistently implemented we need what the state wants from us and what we need to get we need to get to the finish line and know where we're going after and we need that everywhere not anything [Music] more perfect and and to and to have had that conversation and decision-making points before uh second semester senior year probably yeah um director top is that is that a new yeah I think I I don't I let's see if I can actually articulate anything intellig intelligent tonight um I think
099there's two things that I'm trying to that are competing in the school for me um one is that our students are actually educationally prepared for whatever they want to do next and then the second step is or the second part of this is that warm handoff they know what that next step is and I think that those are two very separate things and it's really hard well I I don't I don't necessarily know if either of them are hit in this goal but that those are the two sort of steps that I heard from from Community um and I don't know how to align that with with this yeah um Dr Briggs I yeah I hear that I hear that and um I think they they are two separate things and I guess maybe one
100way we could uh frame it is that in order to be that sort of educational preparedness is a prerequisite for the warm handoff so it's sort of embedded it's like a goal embedded within a a goal kind of like it we can't you cannot be ready for the next thing if you haven't been educationally prepared so so that sort of is implicit in in the goal I guess does that does that resonate so well okay so it sounds yeah we got it we got to button this up so I mean what we want is students who can graduate meet graduation requirements which I think we kind of have have to hope or assume are aligned with basic educ a basic Educational Foundation um so uh percentage of students who um successfully I don't know if
101we want to say do we want to say graduation pathway requirements or just graduation requirements I'm hearing I'm hearing pathway is not students do you I mean just I'm just saying pathway here because the state does have graduation Pathways but maybe what we really want is just that you can you can meet graduation requirements yeah um meet graduation requirements plus any additional this is the wording I'm looking for um the uh how do we describe the second part to prepare for that you know because you can meet graduation requirements and have zero plan for you can get a diploma and then go what I don't know what I'm going to do so um how do we want to describe what that additional piece is to to uh give students what they make sure students know
102and are able to do what they need to take their next step Dr brag I don't have exact suggestions of how we say this but I'm like we don't need to over complicate it it can literally just be like and feel and students feel prepared for their Beyond plan or for their next steps like it super simp just students are prepared for their Beyond planned anybody else have any thoughts on that and and I would also welcome staff to chime in if you have a suggestion on the wording since um yeah what do we how do we want to say that yes meet graduation requirements but that's actually not the bar the bar is that you've graduated and have an idea of what you want to do next and have been prepared to take advantage
103of whatever that might be which could mean additional math classes could mean I mean what basically I think we don't want to have a kid who's like super interested in engineering and doesn't realize until senior year that they needed to take pre-calculus and didn't even if it's not a requirement you know what I mean not a graduation requirement so they could graduate but they didn't get to take Dr sju I'm GNA Echo no I'm going to second the motion that Dr brag director brag doctor you might be a doctor one day it sounds good Dr bra um I just want to second that that it doesn't have to be complicated and what is also true is that I don't feel like any of us are saying that what we expect for example is that at
104the end of this the student will know that they're going to enroll in a computer science program at Yale University most kids don't necessarily know exactly what it is they want to do but they need to be able to explore that with a with guidance of someone who can help them sort of analyze well you're really good at this or you seem interested in that and and help them navigate that and so I don't want us to get locked in on we're saying that the plan is that they enroll somewhere come September 28th you know of their of the fall but that they actually have explored options explored a plan for what they might want to do because once they leave it's it's out of our control and so our work is to ensure that
105we have supported them and helping them think about distill whatever the adjectives or or verbs is that we want to use but that we don't have to be specific but right now it's not happening and how can we word this so that all St so that it is happening for all students it's happening for a select few we know that it is but it's not happening for all students and the fact that if these students ask their classmates you know what is your seat is it I don't remember that acronym yeah and they have no clue what they're talking about is saying that the adults in the system are actually not talking with them because they should have some basic understanding of what that is if adults are doing their part so we how can
106we think about wording this in terms of again what students know and be able and and are able to do on graduation CU I would say even that's with the diploma plus completing the diploma plus pathway doesn't describe to us what students know and are able to do so how can we phrase it that way director brag something along the lines of like students students understand and are educated on their current and future steps for graduation in high school and Beyond something like that like because we can say current and future to because like that builds into the understanding of like where you are because you're going to do some stuff in high school and like the Calculus class like all that there are steps you'll do in high school and it's educating on those
107steps so it can be like we can say current and future and then also High School graduation and high school and Beyond because it's that understanding how you meet that graduation and how you meet that Beyond I don't know exact wording I'm bad at words I'm just trying to figure out how how I mean we're all kind of saying the same thing but in terms of what we want to reflect is upon graduation from Seattle Public Schools students know that they have a basic Education Foundation are able to take their next from my perspective it does sound like the directors and staff have said the same thing I guess I would ask Dr Perkins is there so to get to a Topline gold we need an instrument and a measure and do we have if
108a diploma plus didn't land is exactly the thing is the diploma and Beyond plan or whatever what would the instrument be um to satisfy this requirement I think it's the high school and Beyond plan right so just in brief and thanks to Dr stoski for help so the specific language would be meter exceed the Washington State graduation requirements without the aid of waivers uh and having completed all components of the high school Beyond plan now to be clear that is not raising the bar and what I think if I could fast forward to what is exciting is that eventually it'll lead to a very progress monitoring conversation on what exactly did we learn about some of these lessons that I'm hearing students are not getting access to we have lessons on reflect on your career
109reflect on your interests think about post-secondary institutions I mean on and on and on but yet it's not really a meaningful part of a student's experience which I think is what we're surfacing so how by centering that I think that's what would change it won't make the goal sound any different than current graduation requirements but the reporting will I mean I I'm I I'm so much less concerned with the language or how the goal sounds than what kids are accessing at school and the support they're actually getting in real time so I so I'm fine with that language personally and also you guys we're coming up on two hours now that we've been talking about this and we have not even touched the guard rails and those were what we really needed to do and
110so I'm worried about so wait what was the wording and to be fair like we're we're choosing goals for the next five years so let's just it's kind of important I and that's not to say thank you for keeping us on time it's just if we're g to spend extra time at any meeting I want it to be this one so um a proposal uh could be is all Seattle public school schools uh graduates will meet or exceed Washington State graduation requirements without the aid of waivers as documented as documented um in their high school and Beyond plan to that link which okay maybe I would just have consider the Clause consistent with their personal goals as reflected in their high school and Beyond plan I think that is important because I think that is
111what we heard our community say is that it's about preparing students to take the next step that they want to take and I just wanted to also add that based on our data analysis if kids are graduating without the need for waivers we think I think that clearly checks the box for Readiness that that is a significantly higher bar and so so that would in terms of knowing and being able to do being able to meet graduation requirements without the need of a waiver and knowing what their next step is going to be on their say again say again what combine the two combine what you both said because I think that I think we're there I'll go first and then just chime in right after the with your Brilliance so all Seattle Public Schools
112graduates uh will meet or exceed Washington State graduation requirements without the need of waivers as documented in their high school and Beyond plan with uh graduate without waivers consistent with their personal goals as documented in their High School Beyond plan something like that we got it we got two goals yes and they feel to me to be a good representation of what we heard okay let's take a a p thank you so much um let's take a uh a little stretch break before we get to uh guardrails let's be let's be let's do 7 minutes so that we can get on a you know round let's yeah 620 25 we'll come back [Music] okay [Music] oh [Music] okay [Music] n [Music] oh [Music] all [Music] righty here we go guard rails [Music] oh and I
113would be just clarify really quick when I've said okay done we're actually no board action is being taken we're getting to consensus for what we bring forward for introduction ultimately for a vote in January just so nobody's thinking wait wait they're deciding all of this now um we are getting aligned on um what we're talking about but ultimately no board action is being uh officially or legally taken until we we we vote so just to clarify um all right uh discussion on guard rails for the guard rails the questions that we have are um of the drafts here are these do we do we agree that these five um recommendations from staff align with what we think we heard as the top priorities of our community and then um Are there specific language revisions we
114want to consider um so uh going back to August we developed some drafts and ideas around this things have evolved a great deal since then and we um uh I requested that the the superintendent and staff take a look at um our compilation document on Community Values and kind of take another look and make sure that the guardrail um drafts that we have really do align with what we heard um and so we um we have those that better reflect in align with what we heard from Community um whoops where am I where's page five I'm lost three four I have two page sixes oh there it is there it is okay so again our our job is are these the right five areas and then is there any wording we want to we want
115to um recommend change but we are looking to basically come to consensus or agree upon uh what will'll move forward ultimately for our adoption um so I'm going to pass it over to Julia to present the recommendations which should also be in your email and online y great thank you president Ranken um I am uh Julia Warth director of board relations and strategic initiatives um so the guard rails that are in your packet and that um you'll will be discussing um this evening are a revision to the superintendent's original recommendation so he had proposed recommendations um and potential interims um in response to the board's original draft um and as president Ranken indicated um she asked that um the superintendent revisit the community themes and come up with some um uh additional recommendations on the
116guard rails um and so what you will see tonight is different from what you had um in your previous packet for the October 23rd meeting so just wanted to call out that there's a couple of different versions although we have we have seen these drafts since then yes yes these drafts went out to the board um with the packet last week um and I believe in an email prior to that as well um so uh moving on um the proposed uh guardrails this evening um are uh intended to better align and reflect the themes and the values that were uh represented in the board's Community engagement that you all conducted in the spring um there are five value areas um that the guard rails align with um Equitable access to high quality instru ruction and
117educational opportunities so this includes um themes around rigorous coursework and high standards for all um safe positive learning environment so including themes of social emotional development um empathy physical safety um and ability and opportunity to engage and collaborate with diverse groups uh next is social justice and diversity so this includes themes of um social justice anti-racism and equity in our school as well as um seeing diversity represented in um our curricula uh family and Community engagement and partnership so this includes themes of uh Community connections to schools district transparency and Communications and Family Partnership um and finally uh Equitable resource allocation so uh aligned with themes and the feedback of um students with the greatest need will actually get the greatest resources um other themes in the community engagement are represented in the goals um
118so academic preparation and course subjects um and being prepared for that next step after high school graduation uh so the five uh proposed guard rails um now I've lost my page okay there we go um the first is uh an expanded version of one of the board's original draft guard rails around Geographic Equity um and so uh the top guard rail is the superintendent will not allow a student School assignment family income race or ethnicity need or identity determine access to high standards rigorous programming high quality teaching and supports um this also aligns with the themes uh expressed um about um high standards um and measuring uh educational equity in the feedback um the next uh guardrail would be a new guardrail area aligned with the themes of safe positive learning environments um so this
119would be the superintendent will not allow learning environments that do not promote physical and emotional safety uh the third uh guard rail is an expansion of the board's original ethnic studies guard rail um and it reflects the themes of social justice and diversity um so the superintendent will not allow the use of curricula and material that do not reflect the diversity and anti-racist values of Seattle Public Schools um fourth would be another new guard rail um area that aligns with the themes of family and Community engagement so the superintendent will not allow Community engagement that does not contribute to building trust and partnership with families um and finally another new guardrail area um that aligns with the theme of Equitable resource allocation the superintendent will not allow the allocation of resources to be distributed inequitably
120and with that I will pass it back to you president rinken thank you um so the first question would be uh regardless of wording um do the five themes identified here um does the board uh have thoughts about whether or not these are the do we have agreement or questions about these reflecting the the most important Community Values that that we heard before we get to wording are just are these the right places um Equitable access to everything that the district has to offer um safe learning environments uh social justice and diversity which um well anyway as an area let's just call that as an area although diversity I think is a odd choice of word um and then family community engagement and then again Equitable resource allocation director Briggs I I mean I I
121feel overall these um capture a lot I I think I'm looking for a little specificity um in the what I you know where where I think that needs to be is in the um measurements like the interim measurements or or however we monitor guard rails um do we use interim measure how do we do how do we measure guard what's a little bit different so the the goals have the specific fiveyear Target measures the guardrails are more um uh iterative iterative on behaviors oh yeah Carol that would be great if you want to um yes there are in rooms we um recommend three interim measures that are um basically indicators or um predictive of your honoring the guard rail it is not um It's Not Unusual for the um the guard rail to not be
122achieved at the outset and the interims are basically ways to track improvements toward honoring the guard rails right achieve right where the guard rails might not be um entirely honored at the moment likely they are not because it's tall order um and so the interims are the superintendent's proposed method to demonstrate progress toward adhering to the guard rails okay and the the superintendent proposes the the the guard rail the Topline guard rails don't have measurements they're just saying hey according to what's most important to our community these things are not allowed and then the interims are uh evidence of whether or not um those are being honored and so that uh when the superintendent proposes interims it's based on his his interpretation of the top line and that then is our opportunity to say oh
123waa we think we worded that maybe wrong because that's that's not what we thought we were getting after or to say oh yeah based on like like yep these three things seem like the right things to watch to determine whether or not okay resources are being distributed okay so then maybe my comment is be better um it's more appropriate for at when we're at that point than right now CU I I have thoughts about what where how I'm I'm thinking about number three um will not allow the use of curricula materials that do not reflect the diversity and anti-racist values um I would love to to see uh ethnic studies and access to dual language immersion in as interms for that like I because I I feel like those are things that we heard a
124lot in community that aren't explicitly referenced um anywhere else and so I'm looking for like something specific that that names that um but it it sounds like that's for another time so I'll I'll I'll hold that thought okay uh oh I thought I saw a hand up okay um so do we want to so is there any I guess like high priority value that we think is maybe missing from here that we heard that is missing or is there anything that that is on as as a category that is on here that um feels like it wasn't that important and we should consider something else that would be the first thing to ask Oh I thought I saw your hand okay director Clark um I'm sorry I think I raised my hand again at the
125wrong time I don't want to criticize like I don't think that I think all of these represent at least what I heard um from Community during um our engagements um I just wanted to offer a potential different definition for Equitable resource allocation go for it so whenever it's appropriate for that I can do so I'm I'm not hearing from anybody that um we have discussion to take place around the kind of five categories so hearing nothing there it is entirely appropriate to offer um a suggestion or or wording for one of these so um okay please go ahead sure thank you president Ranken um so I just thought maybe we could be a little bit more specific um so maybe something like um consistently prioritizing and allocating time people and money to align with the
126levels of need and opportunity is that the um uh which one number five Equitable resource allocation thank you [Music] yeah can you say it again as a guard as a guard so so the guard yeah so the current number five is the superintendent will not allow the allocation of resources to be distributed inequitably okay you're yeah sorry go ahead this is uh sorry I'm trying to let's see the superintendent will not allow um people time and money to be allocated or prioritized out of alignment with the levels of student need and opportunity does that I feel like I'm playing a puzzle and I miss well I mean I what what it sounds to me like you're getting at is that you want to see some more specificity in what we mean what we mean by
127resources and what we mean by inequitably yeah exactly I just you know um we use a lot of jargon um this is something like I mean we've been talking about um as a district you know being Equitable and diverse and inclus um inclusive since I like for since I was in kindergarten which was like 30 you know plus years ago and so um I just want to make sure that I think it's important as we're trying to move towards systemic change that we're actually being specific about what we mean and not just you know throwing the same words around um yeah yep that makes sense a qu well a question I would have for our coaches I think is how specific do we want like so as it is right now it leaves it open
128to interpretation which I think is what Sarah is trying to get at is that we want to be more clear um how specific do we want to be or do we want to leave it open interpretation and then kind of say no we don't like those interim measures I I mean I think it it's an either or okay um uh if if you want to get more specific now you'll likely get inter rooms that are um much more aligned to um uh that for sure will be align to what you mean by in equitably okay um on the other hand um I I think actually to director Clark's point we talk in circles about this all the time um and so to some extent um the proof will be in what the interim say and
129whether they resonate with what the board's really trying to accomplish so I I don't I don't I just that's what you're weighing here yeah um do you word Smith if the interims come back and they're not really capturing what you're trying to accomplish or you award Smith now got it Sarah could you ple sorry I'm while I'm writing this down could you please say again you had like three words that you were using to describe resources yeah so resources people time and money um and then you know I guess instead of we can think about Distributing things equitably but more specifically around what the level of need is and what the opportunity gaps are um what about the superintendent will not allow the distribution of uh people time money and other resources CU I don't
130want to I don't want to limit it um to be distributed in a manner that is inconsistent with minated student need oh I love that sweet oh crap what did I just say than you okay thank you much better at that than I am oh yeah we have the transcript okay great the superintendent will not allow the distribution of people time money and other resources to be distributed in a manner inconsistent with demonstrated student need yeah okay president rank president rank can I ask the shift from allocation to distribution is there intent behind that because it seems like board allocate distribution sounds like a mechanical process thing as opposed to allocation but umah Sarah do you have a preference on distribution versus allocation that is a good question um that is a really good question
131distribute um I don't I I hadn't thought about it in that way Dr podesta um I think allocation seems more appropriate okay um for this guard rail yeah we agree there is agreement in the room and I yeah I think I that makes sense too cuz allocation is where is what we would be approving as a board too is like based on Staffing and whatever else okay exactly cool um the first one is one that I um the the geographic assignment that I think is my fault that it kind of focused on that what what I was looking for when we were first developing this was that that we don't say basically we don't say well you can go to a good school or you can go to a bad school it depends on where
132you live um uh and so I don't know um if we think I think what we heard from community and then what I was trying to get out of this when we talked about it back in August in terms of um what students have access to uh is that the right description for that director Briggs so is I think what you're pointing to is that we need consist consistency like you need to be able to walk into any Seattle public school regardless of where it's located in the city and know that there's like a baseline quality that there's quality control basically across the district I mean is that is that what you're getting at with that yeah I mean and and trying to balance that too like so right now we have oh we don't
133do that here right right or oh well because you didn't go to such and such high school sorry we don't have pre-calculus so I guess I guess you don't get to do pre-calculus yes which is not to say every High School like you're exle for a high school example we'd either have to do open enrollment for all high schools or find a way if there's not enough students and there's not a pre-calculus class to provide access to a student through another means maybe it's virtual maybe it's going across the street from Nova to Garfield whatever it may be so you still have access to pre-calculus that basically just like no student should be told oh yeah that's something we do but we don't have it you can't have it because you go here where I
134wonder where that comes into play is different you know that also we don't want to be limiting um because like if you're opting into an optional Pro like if if what you want is dual language and you go to a neighborhood school that doesn't offer dual language um that that was a choice being made and so it your school assignment does does does influence whether or not you have access to dual language because that is something that only exists in some locations so how how do we get at what Evan is talking about which is what we really heard from Community is that kids know and families know like oh our school doesn't have that oh we don't do that and there's a there's a feeling of a hierarchy that's really damaging and negative and
135means that all kids don't have access to what our community would think of as as basic education so um I don't know if um loc yeah what if we just is this is this getting at it if we just changed the wording to the superintendent will not allow inconsistency in um across the district District in access to high standards rigorous programming high quality teaching and supports was the first part you said will not allow inconsistency across the district in Access like in other words there will be consistent across the district access to all of these things no matter where you go and no matter what else might also be yeah anybody else thought Dr brag oh I also just don't know if specifically saying high quality teaching or well not the access to high standards
136Rous program high quality teaching and sports really commun cuz you were communicating there like equity and programs and like stuff I don't know if that direct th those lines directly communicates that um because when I read that my first thought when I read this with I was not at the August the the meeting where these were talked about when I first read that I'm like oh that's standards of teaching versus programs so I yeah I see I think it's both of those things though I I mean that's what we heard from Community it's rigorous academics and access to programs I think it's I think it's that you need both but I don't think that communicates both uh Sarah um what if we changed it a little bit to say that like the super attendant will
137not allow any student to be denied access to high standards rigorous programming high quality teaching and other supports under any circumstances I mean we could add the rest in based on a student School assignment family income race or ethnicity or need or identity but um it might be more clear if we just say that we won't superintendent will not allow students to be denied access to high standards rigorous programming high quality teaching Etc can you guys hear me yeah sorry we're all sorry okay we're all we're all thinking we all have our thinking faces on well here's a question actually that I think we might be um so so these this and five are definitely about Equitable access number five I feel like we have pretty good about how resources are are um deployed throughout
138the district number one I wonder if we want to um it almost feels like I think as Colin was saying there's kind of two things that we could mean which is that like your identity or family situation doesn't predetermine your outcomes and then there's also the kind of placement within the district and programs and do we which one of those are we trying to get at or do we want to find a way to get at both does that make sense like we could have like just the superintendent will not allow disproportionate access or opportunity to any student and leave it open to interpretation and see what the interims are or yeah I but I think that's what we're confusing is we're kind of thinking about student identity and then also student placement within the
139school system which maybe are two different things but maybe are also the same thing uh director hery I just want to remind folks that there is a process in the event that we get down the road and we figure out that hey the wording does not work there is a process for us to address it I think that we can word Smith as much as we want on the guard rails um and I know that this is Rich coming from the discussion that we just had about goals but I think like these particularly are not going to become super clear until we are met with an instance to where they need to be clarified so um I think keep that in mind as we're having the discussion okay Dr BRS I guess I just keep
140coming back to what you know what you were saying initially Liza like that you didn't want there to be inconsistency across School offerings basically like you didn't want kids to go you know have to say oh my school doesn't have that so so if that is the if that is what what is under this guard rail that's sort of like the um what like the underpinning of it then then what then then I think frame it that way you know like so what what is that like drill down to what is is that it it it it sounds to me like it's just about consistency of like yeah access I think it's about consistency of access I think it's also about like the superintendent will not allow students will not allow where students go to
141school to limit it limit their opportunity and access which right now honestly right now we have elementary schools where just because you happen to be in a school with only 175 kids you might not have access to like fourth and fifth grade instrumental music because that's something that M and that is crappy that shouldn't be allowed um if you attend Broadview Thompson K8 in um the middle school that's not a it's not an option school it's an assignment k through eight you do not have access to World Language the same as you would at a comprehensive Middle School we shouldn't allow that we should say Yep this where you have to go nope you don't have I mean if it was an option school that would be different if you know that like I'm choosing
142this for these reasons and we don't have these other things that a comprehensive middle school has that's okay that's the trade-off I want to take but if we're assigning kids to this is your middle school where you go to get this certain basic education and they were like oh but sorry since it's so small you you actually don't get what other middle schoolers get that's that like that shouldn't be we should not allow that the superintendent should not allow that mhm so in the superintendent should not allow inconsistent offerings inconsistent is not the right word it's yeah inconsistent bothering me for some I it's shall not limit student oh sorry help us out keep being the word police but I've you made a shift from equitably from Equity to consistency and they don't mean the
143ex exact same thing I'm just pointing that out um that is cons and certainly one is nested in the other but um you know there may be there may be reasons to provide Equitable Services that we concentrate programs with student assignments so I think the term Equity was used advisably when Dr Jones recommended these you may have dealt with it with the Equitable resource allocation but the conversation has shifted a little bit well but I I think that was the intent um and so I mean neither word is there but but I I think that um Beyond just access that access needs to meet students where they are so that just want to make what about the superintendent will not allow a student's School assignment to limit access to high standard high standards rigorous programming
144high quality teaching and supports what was it again the first part of what you said the superintendent will not allow a student School assignment to limit access to high standards rigorous programming blah blah blah high quality teaching and supports so in other words whatever your school assignment is should never limit what you have access to that it's another way of saying what I think you're trying to say yeah and I'm sorry I'm going back to the themes that you said these were based on that's where the word Equitable was that that that's what the community said Equitable and I believe Dr Jones meant to embed that in the the words okay so yeah and I I felt like that's what we heard a lot was this sort of like painful awareness honestly among some communities
145that if they kid were to live if they were to live in a different part of a NE the of the city their kid would yeah yeah have more stuff that or access to more things that um some people consider to be the basics [Music] um wait the superinten okay somehow that's recorded Sarah okay Sarah did you have something else to pop in with that okay um director CHP I have something on number four we're ready okay hold on one one thing I before we go to so it's not up here and maybe actually we didn't hear this as much specifically from Community was that I don't want the superintendent to allow inequitable outcomes based on student identification that's not actually up there but like basically saying the superintendent won't not address gaps um we
146don't have something hear about disproportionality again yeah we can add yeah we can add it which again and and honestly because of the way that our city is segregated your school assignment is often aligned to some of those characteristics well we can't do anything about that but but it it but I'm going back on what I just said was that actually School assignment unfortunately does does capture some of these other student traits okay okay moving on oh I so sorry director top has something on four I think so this is the communication and engagement one and I I don't think it's strong enough and I'm stealing from borrowing from another district with I I prefer their language the superintendent will not make major decisions or bring major recommendations to the board without first implementing an
147engagement strategy including students parents Educators and community members which is actually much closer to our current guardrail around Community engagement and I agree is stronger than what is up there yeah the superintendent will not make major major decisions or bring major recommendations to the board without first implementing an engagement strategy including students parents Educators and community members anyone else that need need add to that list no I think that's good and and I think what we've struggled with in this iteration was the definition of major which we've got some policy revisions on engagement coming up that could be a place to describe what meets the threshold of major and what what doesn't yeah I I like that one I think that's um thank you Atlanta well and US honestly that's almost like what we have
148right now but we've struggled to yeah we have we have growth we have opportunity to um do practice around guardrails uh better director Sergio I have an uh suggestion for number two the superintendent will not allow the existence of any learning environments that do not promote physical and emotional safety the superintendent will not allow the existence of any learning environments that do not promote physical and emotional safety so I added a couple of words um for specificity because we currently do have learning environments that do not promote physical and emotional safety so by adding will not allow the existence of any gets very specific I so my only Wonder on that is that if I'm wondering about the superintendent's levers of control and that the superintendent will not allow uh threats to student physical emotional
149and social safety to go unaddressed if that gets more at what we expect people to do or or less I don't know well what we know now is we have learning environments that do not promote we have many examples and so I think we need to be specific about our expectations around learning environments and essentially what I'm saying is that there should be no learning environments in SPS that are not promoting physical and and a learning environment can be a variety of things um but I I do feel like it's important that we keep the learning environment because that gets at classrooms it gets at um extra classroom lunchroom sports team right sports teams um a gamut of things anybody else have any thoughts on that one okay cool um so let's see just number
150three h so I have thoughts about this one the superintendent will not allow the use of curricula and materials that do not reflect etc etc um I kind of like something we have in one right now about I mean I agree we don't want to we don't want to allow the use of curriculum materials that don't promote this but I think we also have a lot of things that do promote our values that people are allowed to opt out of so I'm wondering if we want the superintendent will not allow curricula materials um I don't know uh and uh culture Center the diversity representation and anti-racist values of seabo public schools to be optional I'll try to say it again the superintendent will not allow the use of curricula materials and I think I said
151something else else and culture um well I climate climate culture I don't know um uh basically if we have we have we are prioritizing and stating a focus on student representation um Equity you know teaching through an ethic studies lens where all students are represented and and say basically saying that like we these things are a central value to our community and what we expect and it's not optional to participate in these things or do these things [Laughter] help um like if you were the superintendent Dr Bragg Lifeline I can dumb it down right I teach Shakespeare to elementary school kids so I think I might the Su the super uh intendent is uh will not allow any curriculum materials or spaces that do not have the Val that do not represent the values like
152of our school district of like all that uh to be optional the to be optional is the so I think it's just not allowing any of the things that do not represent what we're trying to represent to be an optional part of our school oh and oh sorry go ahead Brandon and then I see Evan's hand yeah I was just going to say so some version of the superintendent will not allow staff to opt out of any anti-racist curriculum or practices I think the yeah the uh transcript might do it but then I'm [Music] done uh Dr Briggs hey can you hear me yep okay um so what what kinds of things are people allowed to opt out of and and what were are you referring to staff I I'm referring to the the fact
153that we have all kinds of of things that are if you feel like it I mean training professional development curriculum are available for use but we don't actually say hey um you know there's there's like PD is required but people get to choose what PD they take and so I don't see how we ever as a whole system say this is what we're doing as a system and this is what we expect for students when adults are allowed to just be like I don't want to do that uhhuh okay okay what about if that comes in conflict with the contract the contract has to be renegotiated well no I know I understand but I'm saying it's like I guess and I'm not saying that we shouldn't do this in terms of like you know it
154unanticipated consequences right but I just want to make sure that we're cognizant that there could be a conflict with the contract and this particular guard rail um that may not necessarily be unilaterally up to the superintendent to navigate well he negotiates I mean he negotiates the contract okay which doesn't mean that that the outcome is always what everybody agrees on but I mean basically I just want us to know yeah I mean like what I I guess what I'm trying to get at is if there's something that we consider a PRI like based on what we've heard from Community a priority for students and we say it's a priority and then we we are agnostic about whether or not it's actually happening um yeah that's the pro yeah no that's it's just we might have
155to navigate it yeah yeah I mean obviously that's yeah I would love to see it testing honestly so that we can highlight an issue um I just want to make sure that like oh can use your microphone sorry sorry like I want to be super clear like I think that we should push forward with that and I'm highlighting it for the purpose that I think that it would be a good thing to be tested and I would be remissed if we were to say there's been a guardrail violation for something that the superintendent can't unilaterally address well here's what I think is important too about guard rails is that there's been this sort of misuse kind of out there of like that's a guardrail violation when really what we're looking for is like ongoing data
156about getting getting closer to these things about how we describe the behavior not like you you know put your toe over the line but that generally if we're like progress monitoring this um maybe I mean I'm just making up maybe there would be like a how like maybe we see an increase in the number of people who participate in professional development around ethics or something like that right yeah cool uh director Briggs um hi just can't stop chiming in um so I I think like I I really get what what you're driving at Liza and I think it's really important and also complicated for the reasons that that Brandon has articulated but that's where I think and you I feel like you were just getting to this that um the interms could really um address
157that in a way like it this one might have we might have to fine-tune and tweak this one over time but I do feel like this is a place where the inter measurements could could do exactly what you just said like number of um staff or percentage of Staff who participate in like X training or whatever like that those would be concrete ways to measure how how are we how adults um changing their behavior to support this guardrail basically yeah and I mean something else too could be you know in the student um student survey uh the number of students that reflect that they feel that their identity is recognized and valued in their curriculum like we would want to see that number increase um wait so okay this is the last one do we
158have a oh oh do we want to change the wording do we have a wording um we not allow um president Rank and there are a couple of different options on the table for this uh guardrail as well as guardrail one um would you like me to read okay um so for guard ra number three the superintendent will not allow the use of curriculum materials and practice that Center the diversity and anti-racist values of Seattle Public Schools to be optional uh the superintendent will not allow any curriculum materials and space that do not represent the diversity and anti-racist values of Seattle Public Schools to be optional um the superintendent will not allow the opting out of any curriculum materials and practices that represent the diversity and anti-racist practices of Seattle Public Schools um and then
159the discussion of interims I okay okay all right and not an official vote just a euphemistic vote yes we're not we're not taking action we're getting to uh yeah yeah and then what did you say we had a couple things still kind of outstanding on number one for number one yes um there's a a few different approaches to the guard rail language for number one um so the first being the superintendent will not allow any consistency in Access across the district to high standards rigorous programming high quality teaching and support um another approach uh was uh that the superintendent will not allow students to be denied access to high standards rigorous programming high quality teaching and supports under any circumstances um and then uh the superintendent will not allow where students go to school to
160limit opportunity and access um to high quality programming the list um and uh finally the superintendent will not allow a student School assignment to limit access to um high quality programming teaching supports standards um and then the second uh piece uh for guard rail one would be um director Bragg's point about um the inclusion of programs so not just services but do programs need to be included here as well um I think there's uh discussion potentially around something like a dual language program or what might be at an option school and how does access to that get addressed um for consistency across schols versus an optional program that students would attend so um Clarity around that as well now of course number two we heard it all but I have to I have to see
161it I may be able to share it if you give me a moment cuz I I think from I think there were there were two different options that some from each made a lot of sense to me um like uh there was the you know can't deny access but I also like um just basically will not allow the superintendent will not allow student access an opportunity to be limited to you know like like just yeah for any student I don't know um the superintendent will not allow any [Music] uh the superintendent will not allow any students access to District resources to be limited educational yeah I don't know will not allow what are we trying to prevent the limitation to go for it yeah so I think for number one what is currently true in
162our system is depending on your ZIP code you have have access to certain things or you don't and so that penalizes MH children who live in a certain zip code yeah about whether they have access to something or not could do attendance area yeah so the goal is that if a student lives in a South End zip code really they should have the same in a Southend zip code that and goes to a school that may have um significantly High free lunch rates yeah they should have access to the same things basic things that somebody in the North End that has very little free lunch numbers has access toh so this gets at a longstanding you know this the system is working right it it works exactly the way it was designed to work if
163you if you if your family can't afford to live in a wealthy neighborhood then you don't get access to certain things that penalizes the child so we're trying to get at that that no matter where they live no matter their race no matter their parents' income no matter any other demographics that should not limit what they have access to how we say that is is obviously harder to get to but that is what we have in our system now yeah director brag is chopping at the bit oh thank you missed when we keep on saying that we keep on saying because I agree with everything you're saying what we're trying to get at but we keep on having the list be determined access to high uh uh access to high standards rigorous programming and uh
164high quality teaching and supports that doesn't to me communicate the access to programs that seems like a standard that seems like we're saying okay they have supports and all their programs and their education is up to this standard versus saying they have access to XY andz so that's my like it was less about the you mentioned the ad programs thing it's less about necessarily that like adding oh and programs it's you don't just add that it's like what this is saying and when I read this it communicates standards and supports not access to programs and access to things like that what what what about the superintendent will not allow oh shoot I just lost it it was so good too um not not allow student um access to Quality education to be predetermined by quality
165education yeah or educational opportunities or something because also what we don't want to get into is like the exact same thing has to be in every location because if while they have a this program from this vendor or something then then we have to have it everywhere and that's not really what we're getting at what we just want is every child to have an opportunity to be in a school play or whatever yeah yeah the superintendent will not allow a student's educational outcomes to be Det determined by their attendance area school or something like that educational outcomes to be negatively impacted by X yeah what about educational opportunities and outcomes I think you get at it with outcomes because if the outcome is the reality of the situation the opportunity yeah I think it's more
166concise with outcomes because that's what we're trying to get that's what we're trying to get at equable outcomes yeah I just wanted to note that uh director Hy's mention of attendance area prompted for me what um Dr Jones's original um recommendation based on the board's original draft the original to the original um was that the superintendent will not allow a student's attendance area to limit access to services and opportunities that create the conditions for a high quality education and SPS so I think we've we've moved beyond that potentially but just wanted to uh put that language out as well yeah so like let's cut the last 10 words of that and just say educational outcomes can you repeat yours brand director yes Brandon is also fine um the superintendent will not allow a student's attendance
167area to negatively impact their educational outcomes can I may I ask a question no I'm joking I'm joking and I know that there was concern about um neighborhoods and attendance areas yeah Dr Jones added family income race or ethnicity advisedly I do believe we have challenges particularly for some students who happen to be in an attendance area for they as a student their identity they have they refer this from educational Justice sure those face the biggest challenges when they're in an attendance area that um otherwise has advantages and you've now taken it back to geography yep and that's fair totally I just pointing that out I I might might have it the superintendent will not allow a student School assignment family income race or ethnicity need or identity to predetermine a student's educational outcome can
168I the superintendent will not allow inequal treatment of students as measured by student academic outcomes say that again the superintendent will not allow inequitable treatment of students as measured by student academic outcomes yeah I treatment is a funky word to me a little bit Yeah so the only thing that I was going to say is like going back to um the C the council's uh presentation to us thinking about what is the real divider of students in like economic is a big part of that I'm wondering if we can like incorporate any of that learning to simplify it and then all of those pieces that Fred mentioned I'm wondering if they can be identified in the interim guard rails in some way I mean it seems like really what we're trying to get out is
169that public education should be the great the great equalizer to access for children right and so how do we make sure that we're not predetermining students outcomes based on their family's income can I lay in for a minute oh yeah Carol please help us help us wrap this up to go back to um what particular Community input this guard rail regarding values this guard rail was trying to um was intended to address and I don't know for sure but I kind of thought it started as um the buildings should have equal um equally rigorous program and extracurriculars and that sort of thing and yeah that's a little bit different than what you're talking about now and it maybe that I'm not right about exactly how which feed you know which category of feedback this um
170guard rail was aligned with but I just would encourage you to make sure you don't lose track of that as discussing this thank you no I I agree I think what we what we heard from the community was the acknowledgement and kind of shameful understanding that the school you attend by chance is hugely variable I mean if it if the thing is it won't have if it's a high school it won't have pre it won't have calculus and it won't have theater or it won't have you know more than one language or if it's an elementary school it will have um won't have meaning uh rigorous art programming or something you know like like one Elementary School does plays and another Elementary School doesn't that sort of thing um that's a different it seems like
171you're wandering into I think you're right um more um macro uh which which may is not there's nothing wrong with it just you know keep try to because there's might be other guard rails that are picking up some of that stuff director hery oh that actually really uh nudged me into thinking something because if we are relating these things specifically to our operations and the outcomes we cannot measure outcomes based on access to Art and things like that right those things are incredibly important and they're critical but what I think we should really be focused on is that like based on where you go to school you should be able to get the same access to fape as any other student and have the same opportunity to do well in your core educational classes as
172any other student which is why I think like really limiting and focusing it into educational outcomes like gives us an opportunity to be like laser focused on like if you are a student in the south in you should have the same access to high quality instruction in reading math literature and all those other things as any other student in the district yes so like really like bringing it in cuz I think where we're at is we're trying to catch all of the like different variables that could exist and that's not the purpose of the guard rail I think you're absolutely right and that's also not what our community said they really did say differences between schools okay so who wants to wrap this up anybody have a way of putting it um well for car
173to for Carol what we're talking about is The Orange Box so if we look at that the Community Values it's Equitable access to high quality instruction and educational opportunities rigorous coursework high standards for all so that I believe is the the impetus for the guard rail number one it it's what fits um out of all the other colored boxes the superintendent will not allow inequitable access inequitable access the superintendent will not allow inequitable access to high quality instruction and educational opportunities for any student it does I think it do I mean I didn't specifically say outcomes but that would be open to interpretation for how the interims would Define the access say it again the superintendent will not allow inequitable access to high quality instruction and educational opportunities for any student okay you guys team
174go team I'll just give a a pause briefly in case I see any hands go up or anybody have anything else to add or ask yeah seeing seeing none we have draft goals and guard rails to consider um uh the there being no further business before the board this meeting stands adjourned at 737 p.m. nice job you guys