001and I believe that we are now recording all right it is two o'clock I know we still have some people coming in but we have a large group of folks with us today so we are going to go ahead and get started welcome to the first of a series of Texas EP support webinars in this webinar today we're going to be talking about legislation related to the classroom teacher pedagogy standards we'll look at some of the key shifts in the standards themselves and we will hear from a great partnership between an EP and an Lea my name is Beth and I am very happy to have you all with us so welcome to all of the educator preparation programs who are joining us today we're so happy to have you here we're just really excited
002to share this work some of you have been involved in this work for a while now and some of you this is going to be pretty new so welcome to everyone we're just very happy you're here couple things about our meeting Norms we are recording uh usually I put that sign there and that's exactly when I remember to start recording but today I'm a little more on it we have already started recording um please ensure because of that that you are on mute we are close to capacity today so we've got almost 300 people registered for this webinar today uh so it's really exciting but because of that it's going to be important that you remain on mute and then our chat question and answer feature is going to look a little bit different than
003uh a usual webinar we've turned off the meeting chat uh and instead we are going to be using the Q&A feature this will allow us to see the questions that you submit which will be helpful when we get to the EP Lea partnership uh we'll be able to Marco and I will be able to answer the questions that come in um and then respond to them because we have such a large group we're going to take a lot of your questions and add them to an FAQ document that will be shared with you uh after the webinar additionally the record ing of this webinar will be posted for you to rewatch uh and send to your friends so without further Ado let me introduce our team here we are the educator standards and testing team
004so anything related to educator standards and test Administration is covered by our team there's me in the corner uh my name is Beth I've been at the TA about six years before that I was a middle school math teacher and also worked in an educator preparation program so just very excited to be continuing this work with you you will also hear from DeMarco Petri uh the director of educate educator standards and test development today and then some of the other team members may be joining us as well here's what we're going to cover today we will look at the legislative requirements that drove the revision of the classroom teacher pedagogy standards these standards are still going through ESC rulle making uh so they just passed through proposal in December and they're going back to the
005board in February for an adoption vote uh these standards are also currently available for public comment I will have the link for those at the end of this webinar today we'll also look at some of the key shifts in the structure and the content of the standard so these will look different than what you currently see in chap 235 will outline some of the key shifts and what those will mean for uh teacher candidates right now or once the standards go into effect if they do we'll also hear from a strong partnership between Richardson ISD and Dallas college and they're going to give us a lot of great information on how these kinds of Partnerships can support implementation of legislative requirements that you'll see in these standards couple things to look forward to and what
006we won't be talking about today but we will soon uh we will have a webinar about the implications of these standards for certification exams or the implementation of this legislation or the implications of legislation on the thir exams additionally what are the implications of these pieces of legislation on your continuing approval review and as the standards go further into Ru making we will start to have more deep dives into the standards themselves we will also commit to working with programs throughout this process on webinars on integrating these standards or the legislation into your curriculum and your coursework quick overview of our agenda we're right on time we just did the agenda and objectives it's 205 uh we are next going to go into an overview of the legislation that drove this change to the standards
007I will go over the key shifts in the standards themselves we will turn over the bulk of the time to the strong EP Partnerships between Dallas college and Richardson ISD we will have some time for Q&A and then we will have closing and next steps with that I'm going to turn it over to DeMarco who's going to lead us through the legislation overview good afternoon everyone I'm excited to be with you this afternoon I'm DeMarco Petri and I work on Beth's team as the Director of educator standards and test development um before actually diving into legislative implications on the design of these standards I want us to take about 30 seconds to pause and reflect on the question that you see on the screen um so how has your EP built or leveraged Partnerships with
008districts to to implement legislative requirements just think about that for just a couple seconds while you're thinking I am hoping uh that many of you are considering the work that your program has done uh to actually Implement Str Str um that's one example that comes to mind when I'm thinking about how EPS leveraged Partnerships with districts to implement legislative requirements um so really the intention here is to call out that our programs in the state um really engage in partnering with their districts to ensure that they're implementing legislative requirements um and so the same will be true or can be true for what we will see with implementation uh potential implementation of our updated teacher pedagogy standards I think I'm ready for the next slide Beth So speaking of those legislative requirements legislation um as
009Beth shared really serves as the Catalyst for redesigning our updated classroom teacher pedagogy standards um so as it relates to the standards the espc has worked to implement the pieces of legislation that you see on the screen recognizing that hb65 HB 159 and SB 226 serve as the foundation for the draft standards that the espc in the field has reviewed and discussed over the last year or so hb65 is what requires HB uh requires EPS to train candidates on understanding and uh components of Oar HB 159 requires training requirements that would enable all Educators to more effectively serve all students and sb22 uh 22 six excuse me requires training that would ensure candidates receive instruction in digital literacy best practices so again these the the kind of implementation of these stand of these legislative requirements
010our espc uh essentially creates The Perfect Storm for us to think about how to incorporate all of these different requirements into our chapter 235 teacher pedagogy standards and the next [Music] slide for additional context there are two sets of standards that I think we're all aware of so there are two sets of educator standards that work together and ultimately provide the foundation for teaching in the state the chapter 235 standards which fall under the aspects Authority um inform EP curriculum and training certification exams and requirements and observation requirements for our teacher candidates on the other side of the kind of proverbial aisle um we have our chapter 149 standards which fall under the commissioner's Authority these standards inform ongoing support teacher evaluations teacher coaching and the teacher incentive allotment so we like to think about
011these standards um as our standards in practice out in the field EPS however utilize both sets of Standards to inform the training of novice teachers really as recognizing as both sets of Standards serve as a Continuum of aligned preparation support and evaluation for educ a the legislation that I discussed in the previous slide uh provides an opportunity again to align both sets of Standards uh which will allow for the continuity between preparation and the field however um as we're aware today we are focusing on the updates made to the tap to 235 standards on the next slide I could not um really move forward in speaking about anything standards related without bringing attention to the committee and the work that they've done over the last year uh to make this work possible so following discussion
012of legislative requirements at the July 2023 espect meeting uh the board gave staff the directive to convene three educator standards advisory subcommittees um which would work to review edit and revise standards according to those three pieces of legislation that I just discussed at the September 2023 meeting um tea staff shared that we had received 168 applications for 45 Committee Member positions y'all um and these positions existed within the three subcommittees that you see on the slide the selected committee members represent at least 15 different regions in the state a range of leas um and Charter Schools um iich acps es nonprofits and also teacher organizations so a very divers set of committee members on the next slide I do we do have listed out the organizations that our committee members belong to in some of
013the schools and districts that they serve under and I just want to give you all a second to review the list just so you can see um how diverse this group of uh professionals really was and special shout out to any of the committee members who are currently on this call I can't see all of you um but I can feel the energy I know y'all are there but just really appreciate the work that this committee has done um to ensure that this is a solid draft of work on the next slide um as I shared you know the draft standards represent truly uh you know a collaborative effort um an iterative process iterative process on the front of e staff uh our espc and committee members um these standards are informed by research and
014evidence-based practices for Universal and specific content uh educating all students and the skilled use of hqm which includes open education resource materials ultimately excuse me on the next Slide the intent behind these standards is to ensure that new teachers are ready for day one in their respective District districts uh that they are prepared to effectively utilize District selected highquality instructional materials apply knowledge of cognitive science to customize materials to meet students needs and prepare and Implement evidence-based instructional practices to educate all students with that y'all context has been set um I will hand everything over to Beth who will provide a deep dive into the key shifts in the teacher pedagogy standards thanks so much DeMarco all right uh we won't go into the individual standards themselves but I'm happy to share with you some
015of the big shifts that were made to this group of Standards so first of all when you look at the standards you'll notice that there was a sha a change in the structure of the standards currently in rule there are six standards uh instructional planning and delivery knowledge of students and student learning content knowledge and expertise learning environment data-driven practices and professional practices and responsibilities in this revised group of Standards instructional preparation is its own Standalone standard and it's really built out into greater detail we'll go into that in just a little bit instructional delivery and data- driven practices are combined into one group of Standards uh because of this connection between in instructional practice and instructional delivery and assessment so those are combined under one group content pedagogy Knowledge and Skills is still a
016standalone but it does include uh content specific standards both for Math and for language arts and reading learning environment remains a its own group of standards and professional practices and responsibilities does as well so you might be wondering what happened to knowledge of students and student learning uh while the committee was working on the revisions to this they recognized that knowing who your students are and knowing how they learn is part of everything that you do as a teacher and so you'll see in this group of standards that knowledge of students knowledge of student learning is actually embedded throughout the five standards rather than being a separate part of it a separate standard on its own in terms of the content we're going to point out and talk about four key shifts to the standards
017and we'll go into more detail on each of these so don't feel like you need to memorize all of this at once uh key shift number one and this is directly related to house bill 16005 is that these standards explicitly integrate the knowledge and use of open education resource instructional materials uh you'll see that specifically in the first group of Standards around instructional preparation the standards also differentiate lesson design from internalization and lesson delivery so those are seen as separate skills and they're built out into separate Knowledge and Skills in the standards it also significantly upgrades these expectations for teachers to know the cognitive science evidence that impacts teaching and learning so you'll see a lot of information here about how students learn um how memory works and how teachers can use planning and instruction
018and assessment to take advantage of that and then finally related to legisl this reinforces the Knowledge and Skills for educating all students so you'll see those practices embedded throughout the standards as well uh first we can go into the use of open education resource materials when you see these um particular in that first group of standards in instructional preparation the intent with them is to increase the understanding for teachers to know highquality instructional materials and how to use them so NV teachers are going to understand how to identify the materials what makes instructional materials high quality how do I evaluate materials for Quality so what does good look like uh this gives teachers an increased focus on students and student learning because they can recognize their materials they can evaluate the materials then they can
019make these changes if they need to to meet the needs of their students they're also going to use internalization practices to help prepare for their instruction and then relate that instruction and the content to their unique group of students this also helps them identify gaps in their own knowledge as well as possible gaps in their students knowledge there was also an additional call for clarifying the district's role in selecting the instructional materials so you'll see call outs to that in this group of standards as well the next key shift uh and this one will spend a little bit more time on because I can say that this is where most of the discussion has taken place these standards have been by the way in front of the espc three times for discussion uh where we've
020heard a lot of input from stakeholders so really wanting to get it right our conversation has focused largely on this key shift this shift differentiates lesson design from lesson internalization and delivery so these are separate skills that fall under instructional preparation and it reinforces this need for lesson internalization and Delivery for novice teachers a little bit of context on this shift um this comes from the same place where House Bill 16005 really originated and that is how you teachers are using their time and recognizing that they don't have a lot of time so studies show that teachers are spending seven hours a week at least I would say developing their own instructional materials but teachers really only have just under four hours for planning and built into their master schedule so as we know many
021teachers are working after hours weekends evenings to work on their lesson plans despite all this hard work that teachers are putting in and despite all this extra time students are not receiving consistent grade level content so teachers are working really hard but students aren't consistently exposed to to challenging and grade level materials this is where this focus on using highquality instructional materials come from the way that we've been looking at instructional preparation initial lesson design and the use of curriculum is that initial lesson design so teachers making lessons from scratch is one of several pieces of instructional preparation it's part of preparation but it's not all of it uh it's also time consuming those of us who have done it probably everybody on this call knows that it does take a lot of time and
022it's also challenging I think it's challenging for all teachers especially novice teachers and to get it right consistently is really hard to do so we think of instructional preparation as this umbrella skill under which teachers need to one know how students learn and then they need to know their learning processes and they need to know their content so that understanding is critical to being able to understand how to plan for instruction then we get down to their instructional materials so teachers need to know how to evaluate their materials select the right kinds of materials and customize them also if they are in a district or a subject area or grade level that's not using a high quality instructional material the teachers need to know how to design initial lesson plans so that is is an
023important skill in here and then finally whatever materials you're working from lesson internalization and rehearsal is this essential piece of instructional preparation the implications that we see for novice teachers here is that a teacher's time how a teacher spends their time is really captured in these standards because instructional planning is a complex skill it requires knowledge and skill Beyond writing your lesson plans and then lesson planning lesson design is a component of instructional preparation but it's not all of instructional preparation this also allows teachers and programs to act emphasize these activities that are directly related to teaching and learning so teachers are able to focus more of their time and attention looking at things like who are my students how do they learn what is this content this essential content that I need to get
024to them and how do I best do it so again thinking about how people learn there are explicit call outs to the cognitive science evidence related to teaching and learning in these standards and this is something we're we're pretty excited about um existing in these standards so what you'll see in here are instructional practices planning practices assessment and learning environment practices that support memory encoding and recall so how do your students take in information how do they retain it how do they recall it in the long term how do you use this evidence um to elicit and sustain student attention and motivation so that your students are accessing the most important content that they need to learn how are you helping students integrate their new learning with their prior knowledge and finally we have these
025three examples of essential practices based in cognitive science of what to do there's also a call out to avoiding misconceptions about how memory and learning work so there are standards about avoiding practices that are ineffective and potentially um harmful to students the implications here is that by increasing teachers knowledge of how students learn you're increasing teachers autonomy to plan deliver and assess this effective instruction so if you understand how your students learn you're able to customize your materials to meet those needs of your students you can plan instructional strategies that support memory encoding and recall you're able to use assessment student work analysis to gauge your students understanding and respond to their progress you're also able to use that knowledge to think think about what the outcomes and possible misconceptions are going to be from
026your students you can also use these practices to design a learning environment that will support student motivation sustain student attention and make your instruction more accessible to all of your students finally um a change that we're really excited about is this reinforcing Knowledge and Skills for educating all students including students with disabilities so you'll see some really specific practices called out in the standards that are not currently in the standards right now this is going to require that all teachers so any general education teacher uh General pedagogy needs to know the skills to fully support the unique needs of their students teachers will need to know the disability categories under idea and 504 and their implications for student learning they're also going to require that uh candidates are prepared in assessing background knowledge linguistic differences
027and student learning needs and there will be clear expectations outlined in the standards for how to implement an IEP the standards also get more specific around the knowledge and skills related to educating all students Beyond a a blanket term of differentiated instruction so the standards break down differentiated instruction into specific skills uh things like scaffolding acceleration linguistic supports interventions and finally we recognize you know we're nobody has all the answers so there are standards that call out an expectation to collaborate with professionals to ensure your students meet academic and non-academic goals so it's knowing who to reach out to how to ask when you need that assistance um from other Professionals in the field where we are right now so this work began in Earnest uh November 2023 and we've been going through the rulemaking
028process and again hearing as much as we can from stakeholders to make sure that these standards are setting out are doing what we set out to do um they have one more chance at espc um for an adoption vote in February and then they will go to the sboe uh this spring from then on if the standards are adopted EPS will begin the work of updating curriculum to align with the pedagogy standards with as much support as we can give you uh if these go into effect we we are happy to to help with all the resources we can here um the first time you will see these standards on an assessment will likely be in 2027 so there'll be a long runway for that um to implement the standards so this is what our
029timeline looks like so far and I want to pose just one question maybe you're already thinking about this probably um and we'll come back to this question after we hear from Richardson ISD and Dallas college and the question is this so preparation of candidates in the use of Oar and the strategies to educate all students is required by this legislation so thinking about these requirements and the standards spell out the specifics of the requirements what can EPS be thinking about now and doing now to start preparing for this and I'm sure you have a few ideas going through right now possibly to help you with generating more of these ideas I'm really excited to introduce our friends from Richardson ISD and from Dallas College uh so Richards and ISD if you're not familiar they're the
030fifth most diverse School District in the state they serve a Vibrant Community of students represent a wide range of cultures languages backgrounds and they've been partnering with Dallas College uh they're fostering Innovative Pathways for educator certification they're looking looking to address the unique needs of their diverse student population the collaboration here highlights the shared dedication of both of these institutions to creating Equitable opportunities for aspiring Educators and ensuring a high quality of education for all of their students so I am excited to turn the mic over to them and I will be back at the end of this meeting to close us out good afternoon everybody uh my name is Chris Goodson I'm the assistant superintendent of human resources for Richardson ISD and I'm here with friends from Dallas College we have Sarah deleno and
031Shannon Watson I believe is also with us um and we just want to take a little bit of time to kind of talk through first of all the evolution of the partnership between Richardson istd and Dallas college and then we'll shift gears and get uh into more detail about how Dallas college has had to make adjustments along the way to get prepared for these standards coming into place uh if I can I'll apologize because I I see there's a couple of items on the slide that we sent and it's my fault I should have updated it but you know we had a couple of snow days last week and you know things can happen so um but again we are um proud to be um a district that serves 37,000 students on behalf of Tabitha
032brandom our superintendent and our Board of Trustees uh we love we love this District I'm a current parent in the district and so part of of what we get to celebrate is that we have about 50 campuses now across Richardson Dallas in Garland We Are um uh have a 57% economically disadvantaged population we serve bilingual students we serve we have 76 different languages um and we are again the fifth most diverse District in the state of Texas and back when we first did this slide we actually had a 10th a 10th pick in the NBA our one of our former students is playing for the Oklahoma City Thunder right now so um doesn't exactly impact y'all's programming but you know we get to we get to shout out a little bit um we actually started
033our partnership with Dallas College really um we we've had a partnership with them as it related to not only dual credit but a lot of our students going to Dallas College to to pursue their their careers in education um their their postsecondary Readiness if you will but over time our partnership evolved into much more than that as you can see Dallas College uh is a community college with um that serves the same same students that we have they are our neighbor are literally two two miles from the administration building here and so you can see uh the different um programs that are offered there more than 80% of the residents are multilingual aspiring educators of color and first generation College goers um the reason we have those comparisons on there is because we want you
034to again see that the while you'll have Partnerships with all types of leas and as a school district we have Partnerships with other uh providers as well um it's important to be sure that you have have that relationship with the provider um so that you can see the common good the the purpose if you will you have a shared purpose you're serving the same students and ultimately serving the same employees that you'll have um as we got started back back in the day and Sarah can can chime in when we first started our conversations it was a little bit before covid and Dallas College was able to um they they had an opportunity uh to to work with the Department of Labor to work on on paid residencies and really we were able to connect
035and start building a a program from the ground up and what I really appreciated about that we as the district appreciated is that it wasn't a matter of what could Richardson ISD do to implement Dallas colleges program it was Dallas College Representatives representatives from RISD including HR teaching and learning the budget Office Professional learning having multiple meetings throughout the course of several months to really talk about what is our philosophy for prepping uh for preparing our Educators what is our philosophy behind what our students deserve and what they should receive in terms of quality instructional practices in education and as we took those months to build that together by the time we got to the implementation we were lock step we knew what Dallas College would provide and support Dallas College knew what RISD would
036provide and support as it related to the candidates and that groundwork really is what led us to this conversation today I I know again we and I see other partners for Richardson ISD on the call we are we very much value any partnership we can have and and as you I know as many of you have worked with school districts you're you're valuable to them too uh this is really just an opportunity to show how through those several meetings uh several of virtual because Co hit right in the middle of that and uh as we started looking at teacher shortages started looking at okay what can we do to continue finding uh I guess redefining the pipeline at the time we had because that's what we had to do the traditional pipeline was not meeting
037our needs we had to create our own and so through different Partnerships we did that um through this one in particular with Dallas College um and so what that really did is it laid a groundwork not only for the initi um programming and opportunities with Dallas College it also set the stage for additional opportunities which is kind of leading us to today as different uh things change I guess in terms of the trajectory the landscape across tea the landscape across uh legislation coming forward what I know I can always depend on is Sarah and her team to go hey uh Chris do you want to talk to you about something we we know this is on the horizon uh we just wanted to see what your thoughts were uh if we were to make some
038adjustments to our programming how would that work with Richardson ISD that that's really the game changer for us as it is for for y'all as well and so then it it went to not just what changes are happening but what that would look like in our district and how that would look in our district how that would work for the um future Educators who want to work in Richardson ISD and ultimately knowing that we have this solid foundation and relationship to to live off of uh that's really what brought us to where we are today so I'm going to go ahead and turn it over to uh Sarah deleno and Shannon Watson they'll talk in more detail about some of the adjustments that they had to make from a programming perspective great thank you so
039much Dr Goodson um it is wonderful to see all of you this afternoon um it has been such a pleasure partnering with Richardson ISD in our program and I just um as you heard from Dr Goodson um when we were first starting our partnership I think the first thing that I want to talk to all of you about is the initial conversations we had where we were aligning around which teacher preparation competencies we should prioritize in our program um and these were during these design meetings that we had with Richardson ISD in 2021 and one thing I'll say is um Dallas college is a new program and so we were just launching our upper level bachelor's coursework as we were launching our Partnerships with isds and so what we did is we came to the
040table with our thinking around which teacher preparation competencies we should prioritize and then we asked for feedback from our school system Partners one of the teacher preparation competencies that we were considering was this competency around curriculum literacy and what we knew as we were launching our program is that in Texas many school systems were in the midst of a paradigm shift whereby instead of um having teachers individually design lessons many school systems across the state were adopting open resource instructional materials and then supporting teachers to know how to implement those materials effectively with their own students and so I remember one of the very first conversations we had with Richardson was this conversation around to what extent is this happening in Richardson and if we were to rethink the way we are preparing teachers here
041and not focus on novel lesson planning throughout all of our coursework but instead Focus on curriculum literacy would that meet the needs of your school system and I know at that time Dr Goodson you all um were really piloting those open resource materials and had given us feedback that that would be incredibly helpful and since that point in time Richardson as is the case with many other school systems um are now utilizing open resource materials especially um in elar in math across most most of their Elementary campuses and so with this sort of charge from Richardson to say yes we really need teachers to do something different and we need them to know about the instructional materials that they're going to be asked to use and really know how to deeply understand those materials we
042embarked on a really significant redesign of our coursework that had just been approved by the Texas educ ation agency so we had it and then realized that it wasn't going to meet the needs of our school system Partners so we went about redesigning it um in just a moment I'm going to turn it over um to my colleague Shannon and she's going to walk through some of the specific cours work shifts that we made but before I do that um I just want to share a little bit of of my perspective as a Dean at an ed prep program and some of the action that we needed to take to support this work just as it was new for teachers um to say hey we know since forever um Your Role has been to design
043lessons from scratch and now we want we are asking you to do something different and there are many um philosophical conversations and sort of um heated debates about this that exact same Dynamic was at play at Dallas College um and so the approach that we took was really to engage in this dialogue with our faculty members headon and multiple times and so the way that we started with this was just to talk about why is this shift even happening what are the results that we're seeing with students that is leading um there to be this push for high quality instructional materials so to really go through what's the why behind this and then also to clearly connect this shift to high quality instructional materials with research-based best practices and I think that this is absolutely
044critical because the truth of the matter is these highquality instructional materials are not new they are grounded in decades of research about how students learn and what is new is this research has been packaged together in a way where teachers can use these tools with their students in a way that is not going to require them to spend hours and hours on the internet trying to figure out how best to support a student and so I think that's one thing that as we started to have conversations with our faculty members and say look this is the research that under GS these highquality instructional materials that was really beneficial um and so we first talked about why they matter what's the research behind them and then we went through a process of actually updating our coursework
045to incorporate high quality instructional materials really throughout our program and so what um I'm going to do now is I'm going to turn it over to my colleague Shannon Watson um she's the associate Dean for our school of education and really LED this work and she's going to walk you through concrete examples of what our coursework looked like before this shift and what it looks like now thank you Sarah um Beth do you have the slides Rel the slides we sent you yes can you go to the next slide thank you good afternoon everybody um I'm really glad to be here excited to share some of the work that we did um to update our uh coursework I'm going to share two examples one is elar language literacy acquisition course and one will be a
046map example um because we started in two different places but you'll be able to kind of see some similarities um I actually didn't lead the work for the language literacy acquisition redesign my colleague Janette s Su sua did and she's on the call so I just want to uh name that and give her credit for this so I'm just talking about it today um so the one of the first things that we had to do in this course to redesign it was actually identify a textbook that aligned with the science of teaching reading and so the way we went about that is we actually went to our partner districts and you know invited their input onto a tech into a textbook that aligned with the science of teaching reading um once we got that input
047then we took it to our faculty and you know did some work with them for them to review it and actually um make the decision to adopt um that text so you can see that there additionally what we did was identified that our districts were starting to adopt amplify as an open resource um high quality instructional material that they were using and so we um explicitly named that that was going to be required in our course um in the language literacy acquisition and even in a later course as well and so we wrote that into the syllabus um and provide access to our students for that next slide um this shows some a summary of the assignments that were in this course before the redesign and then after and so you can see before the
048redesign there's a lot of focus on you know discussion on quizzes on writing a paper you know traditional assignments that you might find in a college course um you can also see the final assignment there is a lesson plan and demonstration you know not a bad assignment because that is something we want teachers to be able to do right um but you can see after like one the assignments are paired down um there's much more focus on on the literacy skill implementation videos and so what this is is students are actually learning about specific strategies to support students in literacy they're learning how to um prepare to teach those lessons or those strategies they're actually going out into the field and implementing those strategies and they're video recording themselves doing that um and then they
049bring that back and there are opportunities for them to reflect on their implementation to share with peers and get feedback from both peers and uh from their instructor in addition we still have that final project which is an amplify lesson video but instead of students creating um their own lesson plan from uh scratch um they're actually using the high quality instructional materials that amplify materials um to do that work um so you can see here that there has really been a shift from maybe more knowledge-based assignments to more focus on practice and implementation like what does this look like in practice um and I will say the focus on practice like our instructors you know support students with the planning and preparation as well um and so this connects to what B the question be
050Beth asked earlier about you know use of Open Source materials and strategies to educate and that's what we're really focusing on here next Shannon I want to name just one other thing about the evolution of this before you go on to the next slide so we had our students in paid year-long residencies with a number of school system Partners when we were implementing the coursework before it had been sort of fully redesigned and our faculty members were out in schools observing students and we were receiving feedback from our school system Partners like Richardson overwhelmingly our school system Partners our faculty members were saying that our students in their residencies were not demonstrating the ability to teach kids to read this was incredibly alarming to us and as we looked into this number one we saw
051that we didn't have the right textbook that was really focused on the science of reading and then number two we came to understand that we were not providing our students nearly enough practice in how to actually effectively deliver literacy lessons so they didn't know how to do this and so in addition to having significantly more practice that's tied to assignment ments our faculty members are also modeling effective literacy instruction in the coursework as well in a way that had not been a focus previously thank you Sarah for that context next slide um so this is just a little bit of more detail about the assignments um again I think the biggest takeaway here is just the focus um you know before was more on designing original lessons um where you know our candidates go out
052and find their own materials um and then they put that together in a way um that makes sense for them um next slide um and then the after is more focused on using the actual open source materials um to Think Through the materials how they're laid out the strategies that are being used um the strategies that are in uded for you know differentiation Etc um and then what that looks like to actually put that into practice um I do want to say that once this course was redesigned um this was like Sarah kind of said like this was vastly different for our faculty they were not used to teaching um towards assignments that required students to actually Implement strategies um and video record themselves and so my colleague and did a lot of work with
053faculty to look at you know the modules as we put them together um collaborate around what would this look like in a classroom to support um our candidates our students in actually being successful on these things and then they got opportunities to you know kind of practice model for this uh model what this would look like for students Etc and so that that faculty support um was a really big piece of putting these changes into place so that they would be effective next slide um so we also kind of Applied the same thinking to our math courses and this one actually um happened before our literacy course design um this one the course we actually identified the open- source material before um any students ever started taking the course and so this is something we
054were kind of thinking about because it was a course that was offered later in our sequence of courses and so we identified that our district our partner districts were starting to use Eureka um it was open source so we were able to give our students access to it and we went ahead and put it into our syllabus um from the very beginning and so we were starting to introduce them to these materials and how to use these mat materials um you'll see um before uh these assigns assignments before and after don't look vastly different but there are some differences so um in the before there is a research study um investigation and presentation there are module quizzes um Etc so there are some traditional assignments that were kind of um embedded in there because that's
055how you know our courses kind of historically or traditionally had looked at Dallas College after the redesign um after engaging faculty in a lot of the why behind the shift you know when they were ready to make more of a shift from those traditional assignments you can see um that there's much more focus on high quality instructional material so we have some modules where we teach students you know what are high quality instructional materials what um is the rationale for using using them what are the research-based practices that undergird those materials Etc um and so we have those modules in there we also have a teaching experiences portfolio it was in there from the beginning because we knew we wanted to focus on the practices of teaching um but it looks a little bit different
056in the after um version um we also have a lesson plan analysis so again shifting from CRE creting a lesson plan to actually taking a lesson plan that has already been created through um you know the the curriculum materials and like looking at specific aspects of that and really that's focused on can I take a lesson plan and internalize it do I know why the the strategies that are in there why they're in there do I know how to use the strategies that are in that lesson plan do I know how to make modifications to them based on the needs of my students do I know what's um high priority in that lesson plan and do I know if I'm running out of time like what I can afford to or what I can you
057know kind of get rid of because it's not as high priority so things like that next slide um again this is just more detail on the assignments um so before you can see we had weekly lab time reaction papers and this is where students were going out they might be observing in the field and so they were writing about their observations um module quizzes like I said we did away with that in the after research study and investigation um we did away with that we still have the teaching experiences portfolio next um and this is after so just paired down and really focusing on using high quality instructional materials and and focusing on what does it look like to implement those in practice I will say before I turn it back over to you Beth
058I will say even in the math course like faculty support was important even though that course kind of evolved a little bit differently um and I I I did um where my colleague Janette kind of focused on literacy I focused on math and so I continued to support faculty um in understanding like what what do these things look like to support students in learning the practices of teaching rather than just focusing on the knowledge um and I I feel like that that faculty support is ultra important thank you all so much um that was just very helpful we have until 3:30 today and we are actually right on time uh to start our Q&A section uh so if you have questions for Richardson ISD or Dallas College add them to the Q&A and I can
059ask them um to answer live here so Beth I wonder that's one that's um Beth actually best actually addressed I think uh Dr Goodson I would love to know kind of well one I would name that the sboe um has developed a set of approved rubrics to evaluate high quality instructional material um and so that's the process uh that's formally posted that folks can take further look at but I wonder Dr Goodson from your perspective uh working with Educators who are uh using and implementing high quality instructional materials just wondering um you know perspectives you've heard from folks how they're able to still you know customize materials for their own instructional context while ensuring they've got that appropriate level of riger yes thank you I and U I think the the emphasis goes back to
060teachers knowing their students uh understanding what the challenges are that they face and what they need um from a district level perspective we provide as much support and structure to the teacher through professional learning uh knowing that it's at select campuses even when it comes to for example a districtwide day where we're providing professional learning uh teachers who are using hqm hqm and and these materials have a completely separate professional learning session that they attend it is usually coordinated through our different departments our math and elar department they have become experts on the the Dual curricula that we're using uh and and it's a way to customize the kind of learning that the teacher has while letting them know this is the way to embed the autonomy that you need this is how to take
061the structure of the trainings or the modules that are required uh in incorporate that into here is how Richardson ISD expects this to be delivered and then the next part is here's how you take all of that and then you look at your students you look at their data you look at how this small group can work you look at where they are on their trajectory of learning and that's how that's how they still feel like there's ownership from them as the teacher uh yes there are structured aspects of the curriculum that they have to follow but it is not uh open to page 10 and read from here to here does that make sense it it's it's um it's it's a juggling act yes but because we provide them with the professional learning and
062the support we we help them figure out how that works we actually have Specialists within each of the Departments that are assigned to these campuses so that they stay focused on okay if I'm working at this particular campus using uh Eureka then here's what that can look like that that's just one way that we approach it that's super helpful Dr Goodson uh Sarah I wonder from the um educative preparation program if there's also ways that um you kind of continue to reinforce that you know it's interesting I think that um if our faculty members were here they would say something very similar as what Dr Goodson communicated about the way they talk about this to our students right and the big piece of this is understanding that highquality instructional materials are a critical tool for
063you in your tool belt you know one of the analogies that we use is like if you're a carpenter you don't first have to make your hammer and nails and then use them your hammer and nails are provided to you and then you build the house right and so in the same way even if you have high quality instructional materials there is so much that you have to do to understand the individual circumstances of your students and know how to reach them and that's really such you know one of the most critical aspects of teaching and that aspect is there and I I think it it gives teachers even more time to spend there all right thank you so much um we have another question for Dallas College uh are all Dallas College teacher candidates
064required to complete these activities or only those seeking certification in core EC 6 48 elar uh and math 48 and 712 if not what materials and resources do you have for other candidates to use in their implementation videos yes so we're um we are certifying right now in EC to 6 and then bilingual in sped so all of our students do go through um do have to complete these assignments right thank you looking for other questions for Dallas College any other questions to add I'm seeing uh questions specifically to accessing Blue Bonnet materials we're happy to help you with that following the webinar um but any other specific questions related to Dallas College Richardson ISD the work of this partnership uh in implementing these changes Beth I'm GNA take a privilege of um got the
065tea background so I figure I can come off you I I'm just curious uh Dr Goodson after uh there your colleagues at Dallas College they've made these updates to their curriculum I'm curious to hear from your perspective when you see these teacher candidates in the classrooms or as they've been prepared and some of them might now be teachers within your school district um what what differences have you seen um in terms of their preparation that's a great question thank you I I think ultimately um going back to the importance of the partnership and knowing knowing what your other partners doing U not just what what needs to happen when comes to an educator prep program but how that happens with Dallas College Dallas College knows how we do things in richardon ISD what we found
066is um these candidates are ready on day one because there is confidence in what they've experienced not just through the content but the way that Dallas college has prepared them uh part of our partnership is making sure that there's a quality um internship residency student teaching opportunity Dallas College knows the teachers that we select as the mentor teacher the master teacher to work with those candidates that person is ready to go right that person truly is showing this is what quality instruction looks like this is what quality instructional planning looks like and here's how it looks in real life uh whether it is shadowing or teen teaching or having a day of subbing in the classroom uh so that you can put what they're learning into practice it provides a stronger foundation for that candidate
067and so that's why for for all of the candidates that we got to see not only through the residency but through these other opportunities we're looking at a 90% higher rate for candidates who have gone through Dallas college and it's because they they know what they're getting from Dallas college but they also know what they're getting from Richardson ISD and so part of the importance of the partner ship is just knowing here's what to expect here's the consistency um in how I get support and guidance from Dallas College here's the consistency that I get from training and support uh from Richardson istd that that really is ultimately the probably the most important aspect of any kind of partnership again we have lots of partners with other providers and we love them to death too we
068couldn't do what we do without them um but you know the the partnership that we started to really cultivate with Dallas College over the last several years has really paid off for us there's uh thank you there's another question uh similar related in the chat here uh does and this is for Dallas college so does Dallas College have multiple District Partners if so how do they make sure that they are embedding voice from the multiple partners into the curricula or a single course yes so we do have multiple partners and this is evolving because we're growing and and so what we used to do is we would have individual monthly meetings with each school system partner and so that's what we've been doing um over the last I guess three three and a half years
069and we are now switching this for for the very first time so Dr Goodson you'll get an invite I think tomorrow um where we're actually going to do quarterly in-person meetings with all of our school system partners and what's really exciting is we now have um graduates so we now have data to know where our students being hired how are they doing and so we're stting going to start to um incorporate that into our um quarterly partnership meetings with our school systems right now we have um six Partnerships um with school systems that are offering paid residencies and then we have about seven Partnerships with school systems that are doing paraprofessional um to teer pipelines thank you um and then this is a question I think Richardson ISD or Dallas College could answer uh is
070Richardson ISD involved in the course updates each year what does that communication look like how often is Dallas College communicating with Richardson ISD yeah S as s was saying I mean anytime there are up to any kind of programming um we're we're having conversations about it you know she gives us a heads up uh it's it's basically it's an automatic to be perfectly honest and I it just go it goes back to you know the relationship that was formed and so when we start to see things whether it's you know upcoming legislative sessions or or changes to rules um a lot of our partners will reach out and so I can always expect to see an email or a phone call get a phone call and then we'll set up a time to to talk
071and see what that communication needs to look like I don't know if Sarah wanted to add anything yeah the only the only thing I would add is again just this shift um now that um you know we are more established we are move we are going to move to this place of having um this quarterly inperson meeting to dig into the data um so I'm really excited because now we have like our observation data from our Mentor teachers and our faculty member so we're starting we'll be able to dig into that and then otherwise we have a partnership lead who also communicates I think you know almost daily in some instances if there are um sort of challenges or things coming up um with student placements yeah I'm I'm so glad sir you mentioned the
072partnership lead uh one of the questions I was wondering is what would you recommend are the essential things that uh districts or that EPS would need to start on this work with a partnership to implement some of these larger changes so I'll tell you something we didn't do and I wish we would have at the very beginning um and that is I really wish at the very beginning we had done a learning visit for our faculty members to observe teachers and our partner school systems working with high quality instructional materials and have a chance to talk to them about the difference it's making or you know just to get their thoughts there we didn't do that at the beginning and I think we could have really accelerated our work if we had begun there um
073I'll offer two other things and then I would love to hear from Shannon um and Dr Goodson um so I think one thing that we did do which I think mattered a lot is we took the time to have an honest and open dialogue about what are highquality instructional materials what are faculty members concerns about them because those concerns are real and something that we needed to address and how do we do that this this took time we had many meetings with our faculty members we had one faculty member who's absolutely amazing and she was very honest with us and said look I'm I'm facilitating learning for my students I don't know what these materials are and I don't know how to help my students use them I need a lot more information and so
074we actually did um trainings for our faculty members um we had um TW day what was a Shannon two or three day trainings um with um about amplify and Eureka that our faculty members um became a lot more familiar with them and so that dialogue around the why and then having the Deep training so that faculty members can understand what the what they really are and how they can help our students um I think was really beneficial um yeah I I would Echo that Sarah um I think once our uh some of our faculty actually got out in the field observing residents and seeing um their Mentor teachers use the materials like there was much more Buy in as to the shifts that needed to happen um in our coursework I also want to say
075that um something to think about when we think about having to update our courses if the materials change I that doesn't like I don't think that's going to be a heavy lift because the the way we have the materials um embedded in our courses it's not about the specific materials necessarily it's about the approach to using the materials and that approach can be used for any highquality instructional curriculum um that is in place we recognize that many of our districts aren't using Eureka and amplify and one of the things that our faculty um members do as they supporting residents is help them think through like what do these things look like in the curriculum that they're using and how do they take that curriculum and apply what they've learned um to effectively deliver that curriculum
076so it's not really about the specific curriculum it's more about how do you take a curriculum how do you approach it so that you're taking out of it what you need to take out of it you make the decisions that you need to make based on your students needs um and you implement um the curriculum you know effectively for your students thank you I I appreciate that answer too and I I think we could say the same with the the standards themselves that it's not about a particular curriculum but it's knowing how to use curriculum well um there is another question in here well there's a let me grab it it disappeared on me sorry so so what are the major challenges that have Arisen with the implementation of this revision for your new teachers
077and how did you CH uh how did you handle them to make them successful um I I think it's a good question it it's a mindset shift I think in a lot of ways because what they were accustomed to with traditional programming um this changes all of that right when when you have something with more structure or the the this um an identified structure like this with specific materials being referenced um when the wording is changing in terms of some of the earlier slides that you showed uh Beth you know it it's important to communicate you are still expected and going to be supported in becoming a highquality teacher going back to Shannon's Point regardless of the specific materials there is an approach to instruction and pedagogy that that expectation is not changing I think
078making sure that we as a district dedicated the resources whether that is through a department or Specialist asside or professional learning or even adjusting a walkthrough form to accurately reflect and align with okay if these are the instructional materials and this is the structured approach to delivering that then what kind of feedback from my supervisor the principal or or instructional coach what kind of feedback can I get that directly aligns with what I'm being trained to do when there's a disconnect that is typically when we hear the most concern from our teachers and so yes there are still some growing pains because it's not at every campus but by selecting specific campuses by making sure that any Prof profal learning opportunity they get is focused and it's not necessarily trying to cover all aspects of
079test for example uh and every domain and every Dimension it's focused on those particular Dimensions that directly connect with what they're seeing in these instructional materials what they're learning from their training so that it just starts to make better sense from someone who's about to step into the classroom and have a you know 20 some odd faces looking at them for the very first time that's that's just that's how I would approach it yeah and I can speak to one challenge that we've had in terms of supporting students as well like our our own students then I'd love to hear Shannon if there I'm sure there are other challenges that I don't know about but I'd like to hear your perspective too I think that one of sort of the shifts that we've needed to
080support our students and faculty members with is this shift around spending time not on developing an in like developing a lesson or looking for a resource online and then that time actually needs to be spent to prepare to effectively deliver instruction and that sort of I know folks kind of call this that internalization process number one that takes a long time to internalize a lesson because our students for a math lesson are going through all of the math problems that their students are going to do during the lesson identifying where might a student have a misconception and laying out how am I going to address that that takes a lot of time it's valuable time it is also something that I don't think in teacher prep we have explicitly taught and said it's going to
081take you a lot of time to do this and so one of the shifts that we made is it's different for our faculty members too when they're going out um to understand how well did my student really prepare for this lesson and so in our observation tool now we are asking faculty members to look for evidence of did a student really internalize this lesson do we have evidence of that do we know that they're prepared and just emphasizing that it's that preparation that can make or break student learning and that piece matters a great deal and I think in the past it was perhaps masked in a way because we didn't talk enough about how much that matters yeah Sarah I was thinking exactly what you were thinking um you know Beth talked earlier about
082how teachers spend their time like we want students to understand when they are in entering this profession like what is expected of me and how I spend my time and what we found is many of our students um even ones who have worked as paraprofessionals in schools maybe never even took the time to read a math lesson and it can be very overwhelming when you start to read a math lesson and really start to analyze it and internalize it and so we've had to support our student um in doing that um because that like Sarah said takes time and it's um you know a lot of brain power that they have to put into it in order to make sense of a math lesson if they've never even looked at a curriculum before thank you
083all so much um so we have a few more things to share uh so that will be our last question but if your question didn't get answered we will follow up and make sure that that we do provide answers for your questions um now that you have heard from these fine folks uh maybe this answer changes um maybe you can think a little bit differently about what your program can do to prepare for implementing these legislative requirements and to help you get started we have another webinar alert coming your way uh this one's coming up next week already um so this is an introduction to the research-based instructional strategies and you'll learn purpose and construction of we call them the RBS and I giggle every time I say it because I think about roast beef
084sandwiches um but we call them the arbs the research-based instructional strategies you will get into specifics of these practices and their alignment with the high quality instructional materials and then you'll identify ways that maybe you're already integrating this work in your programs and ways that you can further integrate uh the RBS into your program so we will this link is in our EP newsletter we can also add it to the Q&A section so you have access to it Beth just to stamp one thing I know Sarah had named early that in training and her faculty uh and building kind of Buy in and awareness around high quality instructional materials Sarah I think I recalled you saying that one of the things that was the most powerful was about grounding in the research-based instructional strategies that
085kind of undergird high quality instructional materials and that's what we'll begin to dive into in this understanding the research-based instructional strategies specifically for reading and math so really highly encourage folks um to join this webinar because this will really serve as um some of the foundational content that could really help start to springboard um some of these uh conversations internally internally with your faculty and staff and you'll also see these research-based instructional strategies represented in the standards both in the general pedagogy as well as the content pedagogy practices so some steps that uh we would recommend for getting started so thinking about who your District partners are and and begin to connect with them about their instructional priorities so really having these honest Communications and honest conversations touch points with your District Partners uh I
086will add the link to the standards I saw some requests for those the standards latest version are out for public comment so please do take a chance to read them we're we're looking forward to hearing from you on those and then yes attend this RB's webinar uh it's it's going to be a good one finally just again thank you for giving uh some of your time today we do appreciate you being here we were excited to engage you in this work and help answer some questions I have a survey um where you can ask more questions um help us plan for the next set of webinars and I will add all of these links to the Q&A shortly I'm not able to do two things at once but I will do that right away so
087thank you all so much for being here big thanks to um Richardson ISD and Dallas college for being here we so appreciate all of your Insight today and we will see you soon okay I'm gonna get St thanks Melissa e