001my Ione it says it's 6:00 and so I'd like to call this Board of Trustees work study meeting Carolton Farmers Branch ISD Board of Trustees uh to order for the record the board members present are Tera Jim Brady margerie Mars Ken Ben Iana gar roas and I'm R sh Sandra Hatfield is on a work assignment in Washington DC tonight I accused her of going back there closed down the Department of Education not she gets in the message say she'll be thinking about it she looks forward to watching the video after we do constitute a for and may conduct business on behalf of the district the first item on our agenda for tonight is audience for guests because this is a work study audience for guests is limited to only items that are on this specific
002agenda and it's my understanding that no one chose wanted to speak as a result of that so we skip pass on yes and directly to our discussion items first is item 3A the multi art we've heard a lot about this toar more um I am going introduce Miss Thomas she is our um person who came in and did our audit for the multilingual program and she has a presentation that she'll be going through this evening all right I hope you don't mind if I stand up I don't present well I sitting down so hi everybody thank you so much for having me I'm really excited to be here in Carolton Farmers Branch and I really enjoy doing this kind of work um you know I just was mentioning how important this type of work is
003to have someone coming from the outside looking in and seeing ways that we can improve um and especially for our emergent vial student population so real quickly I am going to just introduce myself so that you know a little bit more about this random lady standing in front of you so my name is klen Thomas I do go by Carly so if you need to kind of tell me the real deal just be like look Carly okay and I'll know you're like being serious all right uh but a little bit about me um I started my educational career teaching in Beijing China um at a university there and I think it's kind of where my love for second language Learners began um I came back to the States and skittled Dallas Skyline you know what
004I'm presenting in Houston area I get booze during this time but anyways no I'm just kidding uh not really um but yeah you know I came back I was teaching right here in Dallas I you see right around the corner um I was an elementary Ed major but I got out there and I was like yeah older kids okay and so I stuck with that for a long time um but spent time working in in uh the Dallas area before working as an ESL migrant consultant in region tin um and then got really crazy decided to move my family to auson and work at tea um and I was the state's ESL program coordinate coordinator for 5 years building Statewide resources and materials building our program implementation rubrics that we uh use across the state
005um and then just about a little over two years ago is when I launched my business to be able to work directly with school districts and other state agencies and Regional centers to support more directly and say whatever I want to okay uh anyway and so I also get to increase my advocacy I work um on stack with the National Association for bilingual education helping to support their International conferences which is also next week in in Atlanta so if I have bags under my eyes you know that's what I've been preparing for um I'm on the board for the National Association for English earner program administrators uh we do National advocacy working with the office of English language acquisition at the US Department of Education uh to uh really communicate to States what's going on
006at the federal level and um I'm on the leadership team for the national newcomer Network which is a cohort um that it a coalition that has launched a national policy platform to increase supports for recently arrived students and their families um and so bringing it closer to home just want to leave you with one additional thing these are my two kiddos this is my daughter anniah she's in sixth grade and my son Kion who's in third grade now I don't just bring them up because I think they're cute because they're my kids but I also bring them up because it's related to this work that I do um they have both been participating in dual language programs there in Austin ISD since kindergarten my daughter is still continuing in dual language in middle school and
007so watching their P bilingual trajectories has also given me that other perspective um that I'm so you know thankful to have um I think with all of my experiences over the years I've just very thankful for having multiple perspectives you know and being able to see really the education system and our programs for English Learners across a lot of different perspectives so now getting into a little bit what have I been up to well we went through an evaluation process and some of the things that I did was Interview staff okay some of those were virtual about 20 of those interviews were done virtually um interviewing teachers administrators Etc and I'll show you that those details here in a moment um came on site to walk through Stark Elementary pulk Middle School and Newman Smith
008High School School see just kind of walk through and really feel and see uh those programs in implementation and do a few additional uh stack interviews there as well um also I reviewed the multilingual Department's procedures and some of their documentation which they've extensive amounts of documentation and procedure so able to look through those and then of course conducting some data analysis directly from data provided by the district um with star and tell past scores and I'll get into that in here in a minute so really going to talk mostly about the staff interviews and the data before I then get into my overall recommendations so I did as you can see here the majority of the folks that I interviewed were our teachers um and then of course principles El Specialists and District Specialists
009and of course um you know any of those District Specialists and ESL specialist so that's really what you kind of see that breakdown evenly there who I was interviewing really to get that wide pulse of across grade levels across um you know programs to to see how our our uh programs are functioning across schol language bilingual and ESL okay now what was I asking then there was really in three buckets I asked every interview we asked them all the exact same questions and most of those questions were on a quantifiable scale so that I could really be able to pinpoint key data points and and see how they correlate more than just anecdotal data so I looked at the multilingual Department's impact a lot of the reason that I do this is so that when
010I'm interviewing folks they know that the multilingual department is being introspective as well and we're not just trying to scrutinize their work but also the work of the department so it helps to also ease the the worry sometimes of interviewees of why they're being interviewed showing that growth mindset by the department so I'm looking for you know what's the communication like coming from the the multi lingual Department what is the stakeholder involvement and capacity and principal and teacher support as in how do they feel supported by the multilingual Department then the next uh category for my staff interviews was program model implementation this is where I find out from them the communication of the program model design right how are whether it's parents teachers campus administrators what do we know and understand what's being communicated
011about the program model design do we understand it holistically um what is the clear and consistent implementation right what does that look like if you were to describe it do you know what it is if you're teaching in a dual language program do you know how to describe what your model is or an ESO program and what is newcomer support was another key area that I asked about to see how do we feel like um that's going finally the last bucket was on training where I talked about what kind of training opportunities that they feel that they have as well as follow up on the implementation for that training and what kind of targeted training do they receive specifically again regarding newcomers which tends to be um you know a strain point for a lot
012of our teachers across the state let alone across the us of making sure that we are um supporting especially kiddos who at early stages of English proficiency so as you can see these are just over overall the types of questions that I was looking for which helped me to formulate those common trends of what I'm seeing in program implementation and design that feeds then into my evaluation so I want to briefly go through the data and I know I'm talking very fast because I really want to kind of get through this information so I can have time to share with you my recommendations so I apologize if I'm going so quickly uh but I do want to talk through the data analysis a little bit I know this is small but also keep in mind
013at the end I'll share a QR that you can have the full evaluation report to be able to pull up to look at on your own but this these are just the general tpass Trends and of course Tass evaluates listening speaking reading and writing and you can see that by the four colors and across three years I looked at three years of data now as you can see overall our listening and our reading so those are our receptive skills kind of Follow that nice progress expression whereas for our writing and speaking those expressive skills we do see that decline however we also have to keep in mind that writing uh tath changed uh during this time so there's always a dip when that occurs that's natural okay as we get used to a new assessment
014being done online um and of course speaking is always a pain point and I can tell you that's not exclusive I work with lots and lots of districts across Texas and the US and I can tell you speaking is not just an issue for Carolton Farmers Branch okay um now I will just say this as a side note because a lot of people look at the these data and sometimes get a little feeling frustrated and Grim spe specifically about the speaking component right and there's a lot of things that I could tell you about Tel pass I'm sure if we all sat here and talked a little bit about some of our qualms and beef with tath so there's a lot of things um motivation of students motivations of uh the the district I mean
015it's right in during star preparations everybody is doing that um do I even know what I'm taking and why I'm taking it do I want to speak into the microphone do I feel embarrassed so there's a lot of logistical components besides the scoring of the test itself you look up a Texas Tribune article you'll see me quoted talking a little bit about some of those quams with uh Tass itself and we can talk all day about that however I really really encourage districts to pay attention to specifically when it comes to the speaking component yes we can absolutely agree there might be issues with the assessment itself there might be issues with uh the motivations of students taking the test and the logistics of the administration of the exam however it's all of that and
016needing to hold all of our students to high levels of academic discourse I can tell you I am literally in hundreds of class rooms each school year um evaluating teachers and coaching teachers and I can tell you largely we are missing oral language practice right um and this is a huge component not only does it impact emergent bilingual students it impacts all of our students um and so this is a really huge piece as it comes to that instructional design and we'll talk later about content-based language instructional methods to ensure students are increasing in that oral language skill that was my soap box for the day on that all right um now again this is a lot to take in but I want you to be able to see the difference a comparison between students
017in years 1 to three in US schools versus 6 to 12 okay the vast majority of our students across the state and here in Carolton Farmers Branch are identified Emer Bilal students have been in US schools 6 years or more so if we look specifically at students in grades 6 through 12 and that I'm using those grade levels because they could have been in US schools that long we begin the count in grade one right for us School calculation um and so when we look at that the majority of our kiddos um in Texas public schools and specifically here in Carolton Farmers Branch the majority of them are have been in US schools six years or more and I want you just to notice a couple key aspects that cause pause for me now I
018just pulled out this speaking domain okay in the full report it has each domain broken out but I want you just to kind of take this in for a moment the yellow is intermediate level this green is beginning level okay this blue is the advanced High the highest and then this purpley color is Advanced so what we really would hope to see in our our kiddos who've been in US school is six years or more a higher amount of advanced to advance High okay especially as they're progressing into these upper grades and we should see a reduction in that intermediate level but we're still seeing quite a huge gap of students still at an intermediate or even beginning level of speaking proficiency now I can tell you that a lot of this may not really
019reflect their true abilities and levels right and this goes kind of back to things that that we want to consider implementing as it relates to Tass Administration making sure the students know one I'm identified as an emergent ping well what does that mean two what is Tass and why am I taking this right what were my scores last year does that reflect what I actually can do and what might be a goal for this year I have seen districts Implement that kind of uh discussions individual discussions with students and really see some improvements and gains once students actually just know what they're doing so I think it's a lot of that but it is also again like I mentioned earlier especially in the speaking domain needing more oral language practice and recognizing how aacy impacts
020students literacy and it's a huge piece that sometimes gets neglected as we focus on literacy so it's not all Grim okay but there's a need for improvement here now finally I just wanted to mention in the data this tpass and star correl right we have to keep in mind Tel pass and star um this is star reading okay uh and and uh Tel pass reading levels okay and just recognize that they test different things this is apples and oranges right it's not the same but we would expect that as a student progresses in their English proficiency they should also be progressing in their uh performance on the star assessment we would hope to kind of see that clear trajectory Factory okay so as you can see across the left this would be like beginning level
021intermediate Advanced and advanced high this is green is does not meet grade level on star this orange color is approaches the blue is meets grade level and the pink is Masters okay so we we do see a pretty good uh progression but I would hope to see by an advanced level a reduction in just approaching and more of that um you know meets level at a at a minimum right as we're really progressing along that line so seeing where does this correlate and how can we really grow especially when we still have a lot of kiddos at intermediate um you know still at a does not meet level in um in Star we also have to keep in mind currently although this looks like it's going to change thankfully when it comes to uh the
022elps proficiency levels is that we will see an increase in numbers of levels as the elps are um put back out right and under review right now though we only have those four levels and most stages of language acquisition give us six to nine stages of second language acquisition which we're squeezing into four levels so it does take time for students to move across four huge levels like we have this is where we do see a lot of kids plateauing at that intermediate level because that's a huge span to increase a low intermediate and a higher intermediate it's a completely different conversation with a student right but they still fall under that domain okay so this just helps me kind of give a picture of where are we in um seeing our students Pro progress
023in their English uh proficiency so now um and I don't worry I'm trying to leave time for some questions I know you might have a lot of questions breing but what I want to get into is some of the outcomes and my recommendations first I just want to highlight of course some of the strengths that came out um across those staff interviews that I was able to see um absolutely dedicated staff we have staff this is within the multilingual Department this is principales Teachers Specialists we have people who care want to do the right thing who are dedicated um to their students and to their work um and I'll tell you what guys money can't buy that this this is so important okay that that mindset of just being dedicated to the work is is
024huge I saw teachers saying I I want to do the right thing I just I need direction right and so we have people who are willing and ready to do this work we I also saw a lot of Trends about trusting the leadership of the multilingual Department there was even a lot of mention of improved communication as of late and really seeing some of those improvements I've had people talk about oh well in the past it was more like this but I'm I'm noticing some improvement and I'm I'm noticing some strength so um a lot of positivity about that um and just wanting more of it to be honest and that's part of my recommendation um availability for training seeing that there's a lot that's being offered um and of course a commitment to improving
025outcomes for emerging bilinguals um and again those kind of things are things that can't really be taught the mindset of just wanting students to succeed and being willing to do anything that it takes for that to happen that's that's perfect because if we want to make shifts we need people that are going to be on board who care and want to do it and you've got that so you are ready to make positive shifts so I'm going to talk in my full report um there's more recommendations but I want to focus really just on the top four uh my first recommendations the first one is on improving districtwide communication um and so I'm going to actually just kind of get these on the screen so that you can see them along with me I'm not
026going to read them word for word but we do need to really make sure we have some communication protocols in place between the district level staff campuses and all stakeholders related to emergent bilinguals that's including parents it's so important that we have that parental understanding of what program model design is why their students are in emerg bilingual student programs um helping them to really buy into our programs it's really essential especially with the implementation of dual language programs we need parents to feel that they understand and be involved okay um I highly recommend um an update um and a creation of a the district's program manual for all of our programs related to emergent bilinguals so that we have everything that we decide to do moving forward very clearly laid out this goes back to
027that clear defined and communicated clearly defined and communicated and that's really essential to um ensuring success and making sure then that we schedule that regularly um those regular Communications and what those expectations are um how many of you recognize if we don't put it on the calendar it's not going to happen right we may have great plans of ensuring communication but if we don't have that scheduled it's just not going to happen in a timely manner and really the whole point of this is to provide that Clarity and reduce any confusion across our program implementation okay so this one really impacts then the rest of my recommendations number two is ensuring consistent program structures and implementation this is across both our bilingual and ESL programs so one I mentioned this earlier content based language instruction
028practices need to be used in all classrooms that includes all of our bilingual dual language classrooms as well as our English as a second language classrooms um the state has provided in fact uh all the state has all of these wonderful resources for Content based language instruction I kind of wrote those before I left so I think they're pretty good so anyways there's some really good stuff up there um on the txel website so even just that as a foundation we have a lot of material about what is content-based language instruction it's really ensuring that we're making content comprehensible while supporting language development we're making content comprehensible while supporting language development that is what content-based language instruction is not we've got to learn the language first and then engage with rigorous content no it's through
029grade level content that we learn language it's the vehicle for that target language development okay um and then making sure that our campus administrators understand the guidelines of what our program structure should be what it should look like they need to have that elevator pitch to know exactly when someone says what is our ESL model they need to be able to roll that off their tongue okay whether it's to a parent a teacher encouraging them for that Fidelity because it all comes down to monitoring and evaluating our consistent Fidelity of program implementation I will tell you time in again it's not so much what what a district chooses to do with their model it's how they implement it to Fidelity a lot of times districts will want to make changes to a program model before
030evaluating the Fidelity to what they've been doing okay and that's actually key and essential we don't want to make changes to our program model itself based on staff availability or um just based on any you know uh current data that we're seeing and thinking we've got to make a change to that program no we want to look back to really see are we even implementing it to Fidelity this that consistency is the biggest the biggest component and so that actually brings me to oh and I guess there that creates that Equity across all of our programs for all of our students and reduces the variability in experiences for our students so I mentioned earlier kiddos who've been in US schools six years or more right and have still not yet met the reclassification as English
031proficient typically we refer to researchers refer to these students as long-term English Learners now I'm doing it like this in bunny quotes because we don't really like this term it sounds it's a little deficit mindset and it's not that students would ever necessarily see that label next to their name but when we really think about our students we don't want to communicate that deficit mindset over our kiddos um but what's real and true and there's been many studies um that I could even provide for you much of which have been done by of students here in Texas that are deemed long-term English Learners and one of the biggest components to that being the case is that variability in their program experience right whether it's going in and out of inconsistent Bilal to ESL programs whether
032it is highly being you know Mobile going uh across other places that are not having that consistent implementation of the program that is one of the biggest um components that uh impacts a student being a long-term English learner this one right here is one that I think is absolutely essential and very timely um and that is the restructuring of the Dual language immersion program to actually be in compliance with State um regulations so what do I mean by that to be absolutely Frank with you right now our district it has a bit of an identity create okay we're not fully a dual language program and we're not fully a transitional late exit bilingual program we have a bit of an identity crisis we're kind of mixing both of those things and what I recommend is
033that we fully implement the Dual language immersion program not only because research shows us that it is actually the most beneficial for our students in the long run to build bilingualism and biliteracy but also to be honest it's actually easier to implement than a transitional bilingual program because of the availability to use ESL certified teachers to uh Cod teach um with bilingual certified teachers whereas we can't do that in a transitional bilingual program so dollarwise and human resource Wise It's also beneficial okay now what are some components that I'm noticing are needing structured and and uh focus on we have to standardize the language allocation for both our one-way and two-way dual language program across the district we need to make sure that those are consistent what I mean by the language allocation is the
034amount of time and through what content areas is our language of instruction right so our in our Spanish dual language program in the district we want to make sure that there's a clear trajectory from the prek when we are implementing it all the way up through at least the elementary years and how we're implementing each of those languages of instruction okay ensuring that at least 50% of the partner language which in our case is Spanish um of that instruction in the content areas uh through the duration of the program right now we are not currently implementing 50% of instructional time through the duration of the program that's all grade levels up through fifth grade should be receiving if we're fully implementing a dual language program should be receiving at least 50% of their content instruction
035in the partner language in Spanish and putting here the Texas administrative code chapter 89 sub chapter BB with in the sections in which this references the law from there also we this right here I've talked a little bit with the multilingual Department about the criteria for nonb students now there's not a said currently there's not a said additional criteria for non-eb students to participate what I mean by that is we don't want to restrict nonb students by saying they have to have a certain English proficiency or Spanish Proficiency in order to participate in our two-way dual language program there may not be a said practice of that happening currently but really this is something we want to consider as a mindset we want our teachers to understand that just like for our emergent by students
036our non-emergent bilingual students the program is going to work for them too whether they have an IEP whether they have 504 dyslexia any other um components and and uh differences that we might be concerned that they won't be able to perform they actually will be able to so that was more of a mindset shift that we want to make sure we see and this is really important ensuring that training in by literacy instruction which includes bridging and cross linguistic analysis is provided for our dual language teachers to truly understand when and how to provide formalized bridging as well as in instruction to do crosslinguistic analysis instead of concurrent translation I will tell you in ESL classrooms and in bilingual classrooms concurrent translation is one of the biggest components that can be uh make the pro
037PR ineffective and what that basically is is when a teacher like says everything once in English and then says it again in Spanish and back and forth in that manner that's not maintaining the language of instruction right we can allow for our students to trans language but the teacher needs to maintain the language of instruction and focus on particular places within the lesson cycle in which we bridge and have students facilitate cross- linguistic analysis which builds that for them okay I know I'm getting really maybe a little deep because I get excited so I apologize for getting a little excited and nerding out on the linguistic side so excuse me but um overall we want to increase the effectiveness of the Dual language program and the long-term bilingualism and biliteracy tories we have a strong
038Foundation ready in Carolton Farmers Branch we are poised at a good point to be able to do this but we have some changes that need to be made so that we ensure our students actually all come out bilingual and biliterate in the end okay the last one I want to just emphasize is increasing Staffing and having role Clarity and so this is for our multilingual Department I can tell you guys I mean I try not to use specific names in my reports but a lot of our multilingual uh program division was just named consistently with praising their efforts and the things that they're doing to support uh the campuses but just saying but we just need more we need more so really needing especially at the secondary level some more staff to be able to
039spread the love a little bit and get more personal touches with our secondary campuses particularly and making sure we clearly Define those roles and responsibilities of District staff and campus staff so that we understand what you need to do versus what the campus needs to do so it's clearly defined and ensuring we consistently use data to identify campuses with the greatest needs and then allocate our resources accordingly so if we have of campuses with higher percentages of um emergent bilingual students we want to allocate our resources in that manner um ensure that we're meeting all their needs and it's just about increasing the capacity of all of our staff to meet our program goals now um if again you want to see that full report you can jot on this bitly um and of course
040I'm sure miss hulum could share that out um but uh you can you can write that down it is case sensitive capital P capital e capital CT for carlen Thomas um and then of course you could scan that QR uh for the to view the full report as you would like okay and I'll leave that up there a little bit and allow for questions I hope I did okay on my time I know I talked very fast so questions yes ma'am are you gonna share this report with the teachers of the schools that you were at a great question so our department went through about an hour and a half I guess to kind of breakdown of all this data um we've already put a few things in action with our current internal multilingual program
041Department in response there's some other things that are going to require longer term planning and bringing our task force back together to evaluate there's not been any changes made with this program in quite a while so the evaluation was necessary to know where do we need to go um so now that we have that information uh we want to en Force the board to hear the report um and then we will then move forward with more complete communication with each of the campuses as well as all of the um the rest of the department that needs to hear it so yes we will be able to to go through some of this in more detail but the principles also need to go through the training or the um report in detail as well so they
042will be a part of the task force and bringing all of them together so the answer to that is yes is there a need to buy a different curriculum or do we have it we just need to I'll be honest um we we needed carlen because there was a lot of layers of what we need to look at and we want to make sure that we are fiscally responsible with what we need to do and that what we can actually accomplish with the current staff that we have um they are small But Mighty um they've done an amazing job um I do believe there might be a need for us to look at some of the resources that we currently have uh the curriculum that we currently have that we're we're using to implement in
043our um Esau and Elder classes I think we need to look at that deeply um so yes I think there might be some things that we need to kind of shift some things around to get some refresh and some high quality curriculum materials and to back that up a little bit probably to looking at if we're going to ensure because right now um really from uh up through four uh up through third grade we have our kiddos in the Dual language program coded as dual language and the Really fourth and fifth we're coding as transitional bilingual program um a late exit program and by doing so so that may also as we shift to hopefully really fully implementing the Dual language program we need to make sure that we have the materials that are needed
044to ensure that we can provide uh the the content in the language of instruction needed so yes so Kim good point there what is the fiscal impact of this is we move towards it the extra money from the state as a result is there great Point Randy yeah hope you don't mind I'm using first names so I apologize if that's I mean just I like first names but that's fine uh so Randy good point um so first of all good news is when we fully Implement a dual language program there is a bump in funding that came um from sorry my Conta um that came what three legislative sessions ago we began receiving additional funds for students coded in a dual language program and for the first time received additional funding for in our two-way
045programs our kiddos are non EB students who are participating in a two-way dual language program so when we fully implement it to Fidelity because we need those additional resources State's providing additional funds for that so right now the district's actually data they were all they were all Carolton Farmers Branch data only okay so it's all CF all CFB stas gosh I must be I'm pushing oh I was like what am I doing I was oh sorry um I like what am I doing okay thank you and then um on your recommendations and um performing the program either with Fidelity or or and the 50% um split and I'm I'm dating my years but um you know when the program you know was in the early infancy um and I'm talking the Dual language um you
046know I feel like that was a 50% and I might not be maybe it's you I don't know which one but I feel like we were at a 50% at one time what caused our stray and then do you feel like some of those scores is a result of that straight I mean and how far away are we from that 50% that's a great question and actually L comp had some context as well I can say from what I have been able to discover that when Co hit it really did a number on how we were serving kids and trying to help catch them up because they went home and we didn't have you know the way to do our our instruction the way that they were used to so I think that put a
047little bit of a shift on things and in fact in some of our campuses the Dual language program was not able to be sustainable afterwards uh based on the number of kids that were coming back to school um so I think that that's sort of a little bit of a recovery mode if you will um and the other part of that is we were noticing that in our our secondary data we didn't we were seeing that we were having a lot of strong um Spanish speakers um and doing well in some of our Spanish areas but we also didn't have kids coming out that were doing well in English so that whole by literacy piece we could see that shift and to Carl's point that fourth and fifth grade year we to do a true
04850/50 we have to have that day in both languages not doing 80 20 or 60 40 and so with that that requires then a program restruct and making sure that we're on the same page between both dual language programs so with one at one school and one at the other we have to have consistency in the way that we're implementing the program that was another piece that was at play so there's a lot of things that have to be looked at program wise and the structure of what we're doing to meet that need and then to also get us sort of back on track as you were mentioning and I'll add to that oh sorry no that was perfect okay and I would ask that so we think about really most of our one thing
049we have to keep in mind is that the majority of our emergent bilingual students in Texas and specifically here in Carolton Farmers Branch are what we refer to as sequential bilinguals right it's very not it's kind of like old school mentality that we have a lot of sim excuse me yeah sequential bilinguals they're more simultaneous because sequential bilinguals is like I come with high levels of Spanish for instance let's just use Spanish I come with these high levels of Spanish and then we're going to transition ition that to English right that's more of that sequential Bilal trajectory that most of our kidos are not on right most of our kidos are what we call those simultaneous bilinguals who've been exposed to both languages really from infancy in their environments in their homes right and so
050when they come to school it's not like they may necessarily these high high levels of one language or really even a dominant language and what we want most of our current research in dual language is focusing on by literacy from the start in fact there's a book by Dr cath esamia um specifically about doing that by by literacy from the start and this kind of goes back to does this then breed into that success of the program is are we ensuring that our kiddos are not coming into middle school with lacking in their English literacy because if we're not really building in the ELD component the English language development component alongside the Spanish literacy from the start then we're not building that trajectory from the bottom now when we think about what we're going to
051implement what I would pose to you is this as you consider what kind of model are we going to really Implement here there are several Clear Choices some dual language program models begin with high levels of what we refer to as the minority language right and that's for both our two-way and oneway programs where they would begin with 80% or 90% of their day in Spanish that's called content in Spanish okay and then they would slowly e e the programs were first being implemented in the academic presentations that were done with um to parents and um talking about the benefit of that 5050 um instruction and how it like I mean they almost said rewires the brain on learning and how it helps their long-term learning long past when they're out of the program and
052that has stuck with me that it's it's a it's a great program 100% I mean I can go on all day about the you know um brain science behind bilingualism and the benefits um delaying Alzheimer's and I mean like so many benefits that by much of which doesn't really come out until later um a lot of times we're evaluating success of dual language programs I encourage us to be careful when we look at especially like early years like we could look at third grade be like oh my gosh they're all lacking right ah it looks bad um or it looks like it's lower than the monolingual classroom o this isn't working and a lot of districts then pull or change because they see that but we're really not going to see that data really fully
053come to fruition until that longitudinal aspect and when kiddos are fully like through the program right um and again if we're maintaining that Fidelity of e right we're going to get them to that trajectory of bilingualism and biliteracy but you got to stay with us so it's important that parent communication as well yes have a question um so my kids have all gone through that program too so we've had a couple different additions of of it um but um I remember when my oldest was going through it I do feel like there was more about immersive when she was younger and then um and then you know bringing more of the English in later and I when my second one went through it was more of a 50/50 model and which I feel like was
054not helpful with her yes but I do Wonder so I know that that first one was the one that you said was more approved by studies and everything is that also um the most successful for the native Spanish speaking children have still have that high levels of the Spanish bring the English in so because if we're following a biliteracy model it it's important that we recognize they must have that ELD component alongside the Spanish literacy from the beginning that's where sometimes folks leave that out and they need that from that start so that it's not all just Spanish literacy but they're getting those Eld components from the beginning at least in small amounts and to be honest what we also threaten kind of with that uh simultaneous bilinguals of our students um recognizing that you
055know for instance if I'm just instructing this is why content based language instruction across all programs is important for teachers to be trained in because just because it says Spanish on my home language survey whether that's my primary usage language or my home does not mean I have high levels of Spanish right and so our kiddo also when they're receiving that Spanish instruction even if that's their home language actually really need that literacy they may be orally proficient but not having that strong literacy component and to be praying it's just easier to learn to read in Spanish than it is in English and you know we I I'm with you like I mean I've even experienced for my own two kiddos my daughter was at 5050 and Kinder from the beginning versus my son who
056was at 9010 from kinder and massive difference now I always caution us to not Bank everything off of the you know this is this one kid this one kid but that can be that you know um information that we see coming in families yeah I just know we saw I mean just in general as we were were at start so I just remember seeing in general like I know looking back now that my oldest one having that more immersive more Spanish very little English she has been more successful with it and I know her classmates have as well yes and versus that 5050 I feel like was it was a lot harder to get I bilingual Yes actually bilingual actually biling and I will tell you one note here is it's called dual language immersion
057for a reason and there's a difference between immersion and submersion right um submersion is when we're like you know we bring a an English learner stinker swim drop them pick yourself up by your boot shops and figured out that's submersion right that's not helpful but when we think about structured immersion right this is why we have a clear language allocation plan that schedules and you know allocates the language that they're going to need across multiple grade levels and subject areas to get to that bilingual ISM and biliteracy so that they have opportunities for structured immersion right so that they can immerse themselves but with a teacher who fully understands how to support that cross linguistic analysis that's what's so beneficial um about that so I would like to point that out because this the immersion
058we use in a dual language immersion program is not the same thing as just like a sinker swim approach do you feel that their native tongue is a lot of the problem to continue for the teachers to continue their Fidelity in the program what do you mean by that expl so in other words um I was taught for Texas matches mechas Spanish is cidos so my mother-in-law that's from Mexico was like what to both yes so do you mean you're talking about kind of like some of the differences in uh like dialect of this yeah so I think that kind of comes back to that content-based language instruction of ensuring that when we are talking about um certain topics in Spanish for instance that we I always say this to teachers ask first right what
059do you think this is what do you call this right because we're going to get multiple versions of what you know what it is and this might come back you know because maybe our families all come from multiple countries even areas of the same country social economic status can play into some of the language that we use right so I think it all kind of comes back to that training on what does it look like to make you know cross- linguistic connections that are asset-based of students as in recognizing they bring information to the table so I think it really goes back to the instructional design is what does that make sense like our teachers trained to know how to not just say well this is what it is only this one word or are
060we actually you know asking students what else might we call this kind of a thing and I will say kind of to your point as well is recognizing that you know that cross linguistic transfer is so important right what we have we want our parents to understand as well is learning to read is cognitive skills right so let's say a parent does not speak English um and so they're like I don't know how to help my kiddo no read to them in Spanish right read to them in their native language um because the more you do that and ask them questions about what they read you're You're Building cognitive skills inferencing and you know all the comprehension and that is going to transfer as they gain um you know English uh vocabulary right so those
061things will transfer um you know and also that productive struggle of um you know a lot of times we used to kind of refer researchers used to refer to it as negative transfer we don't really use that anymore as in when like things like false cognates for instance might confuse a child right but actually that process of confusion actually supports them growing in the brain development for instance and being able to handle multip multiple intake I'm totally nering out guys and I'm sorry I'm getting excited so let me yes so what is the expected timeline to try to implement this it's a great question um our plan was after the audit was presented we were going to our task force together and our course get communication out um some of the things um I'm kind
062of you know listening to carlen go through this again and I'm thinking back of the history you know after Co with the teacher turnover and then of course recruiting in teachers we had a lot of new Young teachers in the field we also were trying to recruit and make sure that we got in enough teachers that were bilingual and certified so all of this kind of plays into that consistency in depth of training and understanding um so those are things we have got to work on and so I think with um this spring um the number one thing we have to determine is our program model and what is it that we want to roll out and deliver but that needs to come with multiple layers of stakeholder inputs um that have been a part
063of this for a long time there's a lot of great history and a lot of great foundation in CFB around the Dual language program and we want to build on those strings so that's very important there's a lot of success stories of things that have come out of our programs that we want to continue so I want to honor that but also see what we need to do to move forward and get every everybody sort of on the same page and then we can roll out a training plan look at a financial plan of do we need additional resources um Staffing what does that need to look like um so we have a lot of planning that needs to happen and I think you know further conversations will be needed after um we're able to
064process everything so this was for the two-way right this was a full audit form similar for one way I know but right now you said for dual well no it'll be for everything for yes and you can you want to add anything no no I think you spoke to it um just really determining the language model and then from there um determin the basis of the implementation of targeted PPS for not just teachers but principls um and just the department making sure that everything is aligned and uh streamlined into the implementation of the program and when we're talking program we're talking about the Dual language immersion program which includes both oneway and two-way and ensuring that those models are line across all campuses and can I add to um not only for we looking at
065the elementary but what is the impact for secondary because that right there is where we're going to see the longevity of the effectiveness of the program so are you target I I didn't quite get it from the statement or the question on timeline are you targeting 2526 year to have this in place or is this more longer term there going proba be both um there are some short-term things that we will have to determine really soon for 2526 um but there will be some other things that might have to be more longer term planning if it requires you know specifics around Staffing that we can't address immediately um I do believe we'll be able to tackle actually we've already put some things in place already um I will have to give tued a great shout
066out she already um developed the internal I'm going to call it the intranet but it's the internal communication and built at a full platform of all the information for our staff so principes teachers everybody that needs access to the internal piece that communication is now much more robust um there's also a parent newsletter that's been going out um our social media platform has opened back up and so all those communication tools are starting to kind of you know flow out so that's the start um but then the bigger planning needs to come with the team um and so we will have to do some things immediately but I do think there's some other things that we can sort of look at what do we need to do now and then what can we do along
067the way certainly don't want to overwhelm staff um we want to make sure that we have all the right pieces in place um and we want to make sure that we are considered of where kids are within the program carlen will work further with us and continue to help guide us on what do we need to do so we don't have a knee-jerk reaction as kids are already in the you know program models so that we may have to grandfather some things out and then maybe have a new kind of bringing on board with a a different model below them I don't know there's a lot of things we you take a while it could it could but there are do now uh that we are going to have to jump on yes it's like
068stop the bleeding right in in those High need areas right and let's once we figure out exactly how we're going to implement the model holistically then we can kind of figure out what the right roll out of that timeline looks at just like um Kim was talking about making sure that where our kiddos are in the in the directory is a huge we don't want uh we don't want that craziness change for them and also teachers we have to recognize the implementation of a dual language immersion program unlike any other program requires buyin of mindsets right that we are building towards bilingualism and biliteracy we need that mindset for the teachers for the campus administrators for the parents to fully believe in and buy into that and that this works if we implement it to
069Fidelity following that language allocation so but it it's like a yes now we're going to make some changes but it's probably a multi-year out okay thank you so I have a question about your program evaluation you know often times all we use is our state mandated test so is there ongoing like at your time at tea and I know there's discussion concerning all program of evaluation because we get into a program and then we're like wow look what it could or or where we need to adjust and sometimes we just look like you know we waited you know we see our results but we could have ensured um our Fidelity along the way because I know I've been in these classrooms and you've got new Young teachers and they do exactly what you said they
070they want to help the student and instead of going no I can't they'll talk in English and they'll just they'll just start and they know the model but teachers are that's what good I mean I'm not saying good but that's what we do we're like oh we got you don't understand but what can we do that we have ongoing program evaluation that is consistent before we take a state test and then the teachers that have worked so hard and there the passion's there that it didn't do now we're sitting in a meeting going well we should have had more oral language yes right so multiple things there yes we we have to be careful of the Poo mentality right oh let me just help you right and then we water it down right and we
071don't maintain that Fidelity and it's with a good heart right so with a good heart that we're doing that and so one what you just said one really is going to require that consistent training and followup on content-based language instruction and ensuring teachers understand how to implement the biliteracy model and daily content based language instruction on the kind of progress monitoring side um I don't know if you guys already use things like map um data right so really focusing in on making sure they're taking taking those in both English and Spanish um and and tracking that data right having those discussions over that also um do you guys use Summit K12 I know that's another there's others out there but Summit K12 is another um you know program that helps us more English but it's
072it's really to help prepare them for Tass practicing you know using the microphone and those kind of things that's just another one that I hear a lot of districts using and seeing success with on the motivation side and the practice side of those things um you can also use more anecdotal type of data using resources I could share with you free resources from actable is probably one of the only places that you can find language Proficiency rubrics in multiple languages because you know of course we can use the elps plds anecdotally throughout the year you know now that teachers it's nice that teachers don't have to rate tell pass anymore but then we have a whole load of teachers that don't know the proficiency level descriptors so using those periodically over time having them really
073get oh that's what a beginning level looks like like really getting into those proficiency level descriptors and then using something like those Act full rubrics for Spanish to see where how they can anecdotally also measure them in in Spanish proficiency along the way is another thing because sometimes as you know our kiddos get tested out and they just don't want to take the test and so sometimes the data that we get maybe even in a map day was just a bad day and it just looks terrible that that's why some of the use of rubrics along the way for that anecdotal teacher analysis can be really beneficial so on the staffing recommendations especially for secondary um do you have that um model set up because you know we don't want to add more Specialists that
074you know compound our budget that you know is already in a deficit and then they don't understand you know we have all these people like what do they really need so here's what I would suggest one of the most I think beneficial things you can do with current staff you have um before hopefully adding more because that's just it's good down the line but what can we do now right is I would utilize some of your content area Specialists to work in tandem with your ESL specialist right um train those content specialists in content based language instruction have them do co- observation if they're not already have them do co- trainings if they're not already so that because that you guys know it's true right like as a teacher here comes that ESL lady again
075oh je she going to tell me to do this other thing again but then they see their math coach walking out oh great yeah serious here she's going to tell me everything I need to know because it's that trust of like that content area specialist sometimes um and so I think the more that you utilize um the relationship between the content area specialist and your ESL or bilingual specialist really strengthens Your Capacity right there because then they also see that contary specialist elevating that ESL or bilingual specialist and working in Tandem and then you've already got it's like and you're building ambassadors so that you're building their capacity to ensure that emerg bilinguals are at the Forefront of their mind um and that they're trained they are knowledgeable providing them with basic resources like checklist
076and rubrics that even like the simple ones that the state provides so they know the language as they build their capacity so I think in the short term utilizing those relationships can support before you're able to you know hire more staff so I just want to just share on that we actually this year we cross trained our multilingual Department with our current content coaches all the way up Elementary to high school um they are working on that and that was a really great um suggestion par me and I've been in convers for almost a year now um and I'm stealing suggestions and ideas from her so we implemented that this year um and that's been very helpful we have also done um intentional training when we're doing staff development training like on our PE days
077our multilingual Department staff is cross training with our content Department in those PD sessions so everything has that layer of building that second language in all training so it's not like you go to this training and then you go to this training but we are are also doing different differentiated training for the areas that need it if it's just specifically with bridging um or trans languaging and so we are working on some of those pieces um with the current staff that we have and so we've got more work to do um and we need to continue to work on that in that intentionality with the walkthroughs and things of that nature and the partnering with the El teacher so we are still working on a again that's part of our bigger PD plan um but
078I think right now um that has been very helpful and it has yielded some e e team um to help and it is in the content to kind of build the language and the instruction together as simple as if the only place that you know during a training if the only time they ever see um you know language objectives modeled is during a bilingual ESL specialist training and not in a Content area they we're not showing consistency across something basic like insuring students have language objectives alongside content objectives you know it's that it's some of that basic consistency um because our bilingual and ESL programs are general education programs we're serving them through the content right they're specialized but they're part of that basic right for students to access the curriculum other questions I feel
079like I probably took more time but it was good it's good discussion Miss Thomas thank you board is there any other questions we have right now we'll probably have a lot of questions in the next year the only question that I have to wrap this is are there any compliance issues uh relative to the state that we need to be aware of or targeting toward we have a few um Mo mostly it's what was mentioning about the transitional lay exit um and so we need to work on that um it's not we can take care of that one pretty easily and so we will be able to tackle that soon um as far as the overarching big pieces we we've done a good job with the compliance pieces on that end so there's a lot
080of really positive things to be you know thankful for but there are I'm glad that PL was able to come and pull out some things that we might not have known um because of her expertise in that area working with the state she was able to give us some other areas to work on so basically I'm a pe's nerd but I'll tell you the good thing is Randy that one you're being fiscally responsible by not miscoding your students in fourth and fifth grade who are technically not in a dual language program so basically at a at a focused look by grade level you're in compliance with the program because you're explaining the program that they're seated in the thing is are that we want to think about is when we take a step back and
081we look at are we in in compliance with program Dual language program implementation as a whole the answer is no singularly though by student by student are we fiscally being responsible to code them correctly and Ure we're not taking money from the state that we shouldn't you're being compliant in that regard but program dramatically we not in compliance as a whole does that make sense sure it does again thank you for your presentation and we'll go forward put there great thank you guys so much energy and your pass I'm a little bit passionate she's kept us going over the last thank you thank you so much of course Dr hlin up on our next item you ask if you want you want to s thank youate thank you so much thank you for the opportunity
082give you an overview of our proposed attend of changes and you know we wanted to provide you a a one pager today uh but when we started getting into it we saw that that just was not going to be possible so we thought the best way to kind of share this information we be kind of show you through the web page exactly how we find the information exctly what there as you can see you have three options when you look at the uh proposals you see side by side you'll see the uh proposed versus our current and for the elementaries you'll notice that we only have two of our campes that's not would not be impacted by the actual attendance Lo changes yeah close that to make the screen slightly bigger so if you see
083up here you there you go there you very very sensitive you can see morder here that's our current and then you see the proposed morder doesn't change you'll see Kent as well over here per current and then proposed it doesn't those are the only two Elementary campes that would not be impacted in with the attendance excuse me attendance zone changes and then you ask well exactly what does how does it impact the campuses all the other campuses and you scroll down and you'll see divided by Peter pattern you'll see exactly how it impacts the canvases and if you're talking about just the uh for no Elementary for example you can see that for no Elementary stud students they would now be going to either based on their address uh Thompson Elementary or Davis Elementary okay
084when you see here it says rosee Elementary and it says no resident students currently zon for Ros me will change that means the students this year if they're zon for uh rosem meat they're going to go to rosem me next year if there's zone for rosem meat they're going to go to to Ros you see that there so it gives you very descriptive information on exactly why a student would be going to a different campus or the student stay in on their campus same thing for the Smith theater pattern you see Country Place is going to be going to UHC Carolton those students that are impacted by the changes once again every Elementary in that that Peter pattern has the descriptors you see there are several campes that are not impacted once again Water Elementary
085not impacted when you look at the Turner feeder pattern same thing farmer branch not impacted if you look at Blair the students that live at that address the Valwood part subdivision between long me drive and J Lan and alongar I think that's is Drive they're going to attend Farmers Branch so it's very descriptive about which kids are going to be impacted by the change Ranch their campuses and the are listed as well so this here gives you all the information that you need in order for you to be able to share that with our community SCH we also have this for our middle schools and high schools and you can see the middle schools same thing all the campuses uh are impacted other than Bush for Middle School are current and proposed and then down
086below they have the scriptors those fied students uh who live at Dutch Village Oak Brook Town Homes o b States so all of that they're going to be attending Perry so this gives you all the information that that our community would need in order to see exactly how they're going to be impacted you look at the high schools all high schools will be impacted except you can see Ranch Smith you can see changes this a little bit uh creep view you can see this is what it is right now this is what it will be Turner you can see a little bit difference right here straight across here Ranch VI once again is the one that stays completely and the information down below for the students impacted the morning side C Point preview high school
087and turn to another example so it's all right there it's is extremely easy to get to and it's very clear on exactly how they're going to be impacted uh once again they're just High School the olding camp is not impacted is or the is going to be Ranch viw in middle school this is going to be Bush Elementary is B uh and hint and then when you talk about all the attendance zone changes consolidations the question really comes you know what about registration how are we handling registration our registration uh we are going to expect every student in the district to register for their attendance own campus their home campus okay now if they if they're a Consolidated School and they do not want to attend their home campus we do expect them to register
088for their home campus but they do have an opportunity to apply for a transfer okay uh so everybody we're not taking that opportunity to apply for transfer away from anyone uh but obviously we'll be looking at capacity uh enrollment caps things like that uh so that opportunity will still be there for them we've had questions about programs uh what programs uh will have transportation we typically I I look it as a need and a want right uh the programs where our students absolutely need in order to be successful like dual language want that one way dual language they have to have that program so we do provide uh transportation for that program uh we provide trans for leite those are our students obviously that have that are two years or more above grade level they
089need that enrichment they need those type of classrooms so we provide transportation that we provide transportation for our special uh subc contain classes as well we have some camps that that do not do not offer prek so if your home campus does not offer prek we offer transportation to the prek placement tanks so it's very limited on uh who has that transportation opport a question yes ma'am so if I have applied and I now going to Blac and I'm still not in the Blac fer pattern even with the changes do I have to reapply to Blac am I going to get kicked out because I'm not a Blac residential student even though I'm now here as a six grador so could you say it one more time so in the past if you kid register
090is in there accepted a Blac and they not in there attendance Zone didn't have to reapply again you just automatically were lay lacked when you reregister every year but now am I getting kicked out at out of Blac because I'm not a residen Blac because you're not Zone Z thank we we expect everyone to apply for their resident uh their attendant Zone campus and then once if you really are at fill but right now you're going to Blac we're going to expect them to apply register for field and then apply for a transfer even if I've already spent my sixth grade year there yes that's good to know that's yeah I don't know I and and I'm coming from a personal you know perspective when we transferred to Bush you know if this had been
091going on and Jake was kicked not kicked out but there was a change okay there was a change there was a change but he had already made that transition for sixth grade um you know maybe seventh grade and then there was a a change that was District driven um through other necessities and then um reapplying for Bush and for whatever reason didn't get that transfer approved again that's more detrimental I think I I I've got concerns with that that's the scary part is there's worry that maybe won't get reaccept right right that there's concerns I mean I I mean I I know we're rebalancing you know every thing and that the party we've got new you know zones but you know if there's a priority or those those children that already have those transfers you
092know either for a program or for whatever reason already in place um I I think that LE to I thought we discuss grandfathering but we talked about grandfathering at the elementary those fourth graders going into fifth grade uh those students would be grandfathered as long as well as their siblings the siblings would be grandfathered that next year but they would not be grandfathered after that so then they would have to apply for a transfer and we are I know obviously we're we're in we're in development phases right now everything's out on the P so well I would I I'm going to I I want to request just because I have personal I mean a lot of us have transferred our kids but I mean especially in middle school you know Middle School years and going
093in from the higher Elementary if you look at I mean and you're also um to me if you're asking everybody to re-register how are you keeping track that just seems like if we're controlling caps then it is here's the cap already um I I think that needs um that doesn't match up with the transfer process that that was presented I think the key is transfer they've already applied for a transfer to the you know what's the difference between a transfer but you're asking everybody to re-register there's a difference between a trans because if you're if you're already there you you want them to re-register I don't know how you're going to of that that's confusing it's B it's based on the the change in the attendance Zone what we what we've talked about about is
094that if they're an attendance Zone then they they would that's where they would register for and then we would obviously have that transfer so we know exactly these students are there on a transfer you're going to have different numbers I just would we definitely I think we have to really Define that process because I agree with you terara um I think that you know we have people that have already been like if I had a seventh grader and then they now I'm gonna hope that they get to go back um that's not because when we looked at the zoning you're also looking at how many students were we we didn't try to upset the entire Zone we looked at residents versus I think you need to go back to the report because it wasn't intended
095that everybody need to re-register to upset the whole apple cart I don't believe in that so I think that that needs to be highly studied in in the next few days before you put out you want everybody to re-register because I don't know how you're gonna keep track of it I have high concerns about that that's what I want to clear because if you've had a kid already go through that process you wouldn't know to re-register for your home campus and then do a retransfer request so if you already live through that once you wouldn't even wouldn't even dawn on you you have to do so when a child re-registers I mean are you starting from scratch are they starting from scratch or does their information come up well but if we talked about we
096know a lot of people are going to want to be grandmothered in and because that's basically what we're we're talking about and we can't grandfather every grade level in because we're not going to have the space and that's the conversations that we had so we're looking we're looking at each grade level uh and you know once again it's we talked about that fourth grade going into fifth seventh grade going into eth uh and so we've had those conversations and we're still developing it I know I just I just want you to keep that in Minds for those of us who have used the transfer portal and parents that expect it to be there that'll be a great job yeah can I sorry can I ask when does the application and transfer window when do they
097open they open our registration uh online registration will open up April the 1st our uh out of District transfers open up that March 244th and then all other transfers will open up on April div ver as well and we maintain that I mean through any of of changes um I mean obviously inter cfbisd students have first pass and transfer requests before out of District we we have created a transfer 2526 transfer guideline for our community uh we are going through the revision stages now we've had several departments we partnered with our counseling department our CTE Department our technology department uh we just got feedback today from our sped Department uh so once that goes live it'll have all that information in there as well as the priority list as well like you just mentioned all
098that will be there okay and something we've never had before I know there's been discussion in the past about us trans excuse me using transportation for kids that are choosing different ccmr programs around across the district for high school School are we going to have transportation for kids that are choosing Ranch View but they're A Smith kid we we are talking about that right now U really based on the impact it has on our Transportation uh but those are conversations um Perry is in the Smith theater right in the glin Strickland Mig Strickland is in the trer theater um so looking back on plug in their address uh that has not been updated that is so if we use this map and you try to log in or you try to zoom in can you
099see the major intersection no okay so scrolling down to where it list the neighborhoods um so you say that um Oakbrook Town Homes States for Circle Brook Haven Village and Brook Haven will attend Perry um those are uh I know Brook Haven is actually mclin Strickland school and I didn't see that change made um so are they then switching theater patterns look at that okay thank you work in progress it is we uh thank you for your good work and keep up the good work and we want to have we want to be able to make sure all of our families and Community knows that we're going to take care of them and that is our goal that is our goal excellent board any other questions um yeah Dr Hamlin on um the communication methods
100for the enrollment or re enrollment and process I mean What's the timing on um and how will that be delivered is it solely parent Square related or is it messages or I mean you know how I feel I know you're right we have three different methods that we're going to be communicating with our families one is going to be that personalized letter that they're going to be getting letting them know exactly change them they'll be getting a parent message as well and if they are going to be a Consolidated uh going to a new school then they'll get a welcoming message from the principal and our goal is to have all that done prior to spring break right around uh March 14th and um what about families in those specific schools that um aren't impacted
101by any resoning um well and let's just call it on the West side you know our Branch View the The Ranch View and and push um are those parents going to get a hey there's a lot of change that's discussing but you're you don't need to do because I think there's just as much potential for confusion on whether you don't need to do anything do I or do I thank you any other questions Dr Helman thank you very much appreciate all your hard work and your team we love absolutely thank you or do we want to take a short break before we turn things over to Mr let's take a let's take a five minute break stretch and do whatever come back for e e e can I say something before we move to the
102next agenda item I just want to clarify hang on one second I just want to clarify that we will get this Transportation process of how it affects every student because I don't want this to be more confusion in what we ever intended to disrupt anything and so my question is always how does this affect me like what does that look like is it registering is it enrolling is it transferring so we will get those clear guidelines with a chart so everyone knows so that it's not very disruptive like we want to make everything um as seamless and take care of our families that is our number one priority so I just want that clarified because I kind of felt like that was a little confusing that is concerned okay our next item on the agenda
103is uh revised district superintendent goals uh I'd like to stay on this that there was as this came in Mr about gas for we don't typically do close session on work study and yet this was been a close session item on several meetings and the work this committee has done has been like that and I didn't communicate that effectively to miss Canada who did exactly what she should have done so anyway it's a little bit different here and thank you Mr for doing two step and making this work for us uh And to clarify I'm filling in for um Cassandra who is on a work because as you know she usually leads this um discussion my shirt thanks um so this is the continuation of the work that we've been doing on reviewing our Collective
104I me Collective collaborative um Vision um 2030 and um developing you know what we feel the priorities um should be to better set our um goals from top down so that they are aligned from superintendent down to campus and everybody knows what our focus is and what our priority is and so today um we were um working on strategic priority three optimize Community engagement and strategic priority four optimize social and emotional health of all students um as a reminder these were the Strategic priorities um developed by our community um teams on the CD 2030 and so we want to align and um keep with those strategic priorities but we what we are reviewing are the objectives under each of those so as you know in this process we've been looking at the existing objectives and
105identifying them as measurable or not measurable so the first objective under optimized Community engagement is create District districtwide consistency regarding rules policies involving family parent and volunteer engagement so measurable or not measurable now I think it's measurable and I some ways we can measure it okay so you think measurable yes does anybody disagree um not disagree then maybe have a different approach or different thought then everybody I don't know but but maybe I'm wrong because of it's priority rules and policies which would mean we would have something show our community that has been implemented something what do you think so what I when I read that I thought well because I do think it's a and I know that Dr already addressed this that that our teachers and our staff need a training on the
106rules and policies of the district but I also think that that can be measure that they received that training and that time has been uh given to them during staff development week where we go over those rules and policies but then we all that they have to signed that they receive that training and then they understand the rules and policies but that would be one way to know that yes 100% compliance or 90% compliance or what not and I almost want to say that um well it was more about um reporting and volunteers so I personally and I don't know that this is um measurable and of course by saying it's not measurable doesn't mean it's not important and me this is one of our priorities that we've already talked about even to you know
107tonight um on that well um so if we were going to maintain that objective does you know you mentioned um training training with the signature at the end of the um you know at the end of the training but that would verify and it would it would be a policy standard that we would have the training and the signatures collected at the end of from each campus but then I also you know if you're talking about policies involving family and parent volunteer engagement the number of volunteers just ways to measure these if that's what we want to focus on well I think it's an indicator and I think we need to look back at I mean I think we need to take a step back and what is our desired outcome with you know to
108reach you know optimizing Community engagement I mean so we know we want our parents involved right um we know we would like increased engagement from community members maybe community members that might not have students and I'm making an assumption those are my own personal desires I me y' tell me people look different I mean just engagement from the community right right well then I was thinking even though we wanted to measure the engagement with business businesses and community members we could easily do that within level of donations some of our programs sponsored by outside businesses for distri from our kids um so there's lots of ways to do that if that's if we want to focus on that and of course the focus should be an increasement increasing that every year to have more of
109the community engagement more of the businesses and Civic organizations involved in our campuses if that's something that we feel is necessary that we track um there are ways to do so if that's what we want right now things like campus Improvement committee and or moving up to District Improvement and some of the other things like that I also think we have a lot of inconsistencies since we came back from Co some campuses let parents come back in some don't some can eat lunch only on Mondays or Fridays some open them all I mean so we can write any kind of administ of regulations that here's what we require at least everybody you know notifies us so we are consistent um because there's some principles that just open their doors and they're happy that the parents
110come in and there's some that it's still like it may be 50/50 and so but we have the ability to do that we just have to be consistent in what we expect out of our administrators for that is that measurable yeah I don't think that's it goes with the consistent but it's not a measurable um thing but it goes also I think to engagement on our campuses with P you know with parents yeah you can track that through Rapture like increased like just going an arrow going up or yes I guess that's a question for me is it something that we can actually track because what you know Randy says is it going to go up or down and that's the only way we measure it right increased or decreased but like with any goal
111you've got to do your pla which is your present level of performance right so where are we right now and then we do our measurements from that point so if that's something we want to track I'm not saying I'm just giving example of how we can if he wants it yeah and as a reminder these are going to be um you are Mar was like oh my gosh I'm be able to remember and I think in keeping with Dr eldridge's point is that not only are we measuring but perhaps we come up with a Define set these are the numbers these are the pieces of data that we're going to look at it's not to say that there aren't some other things that could be used but I'll just make it a PTA involment that's
112a measurable trackable thing you know that's one of the things we're going to look at fine at least put it out there so if parents coming to eat you know with their child during the week one of the things we changed this year was honoring our campus at our board meetings so because we know our campuses love competition and when principes get to accept award from PTA at the board meeting it has been so meaningful and that's been increasing the memberships um because people want their to be honored and recognize they want to win yeah so um you know we're going to take these no there's no decisions you know or anything to that we the governance subcommittee will take the notes and then we'll do what we have done and kind of put it
113together we'll do why or or what and um get it back out and then we'll go and just so y'all know we're through the first strategic Priority One um that is with Administration right now and we're going to have a meeting um with them to finalize make sure the language is very clear on what our expectations were and what our priorities were set as well as Randy your point review the specific data set that we would be looking at on all those things so it's almost I don't know how many steps are in this five on each priority but that's what it's it's working for okay so um uh did you have something just from a nonmeasurable standpoint sustain intentional relationships with business community and Civic organization so I think this be right back I
114right with the first one right and it might be a com a combination or maybe a I'll shut my mouth measurable or nonmeasurable again I think we can measure if we feel like we need to measure it if we feel like it's important and we want to set a goal I feel like we can measure it and again donations outside business sponsored activities and events mentoring mentoring mentoring something that would be we have we also have our Legacy card that we gave to all of our retired I mean I've given those out so that they would be engaged and we haven't tracked it I mean but we we could come up with a way that because they love coming to our musicals in our games and that has been a game changer they've you know
115I guess it depends on what we're going to track because are we thinking about money are we thinking about meetings invol what and that's just for me I personally it's the engagement for me from businesses organizations families and um community members that might not have kids in the district because I think the more are of those people across all of those that are involved and present in some way in our schools as much as they're able or as little as right whatever it is that exposes our children to so many more backgrounds opportunities you know businesses careers you know anything so just having that interaction I think that's where keeps the community well rounded and informed on what's happening in the schools yes yes what's in in our campuses but you could also meure that
116by the amount of scholarships our seniors were receiv receiving from outside entities because we're getting a lot more of those and we have in the past where there's there's people places C organizations that maybe hadn't heard of before they're giving our kids scholarships too and gr to our schools that's that's a level of Engagement with our kids so I guess maybe we have different engagement ons I was thinking about people and money you're thinking about something different right like money but scholarship form yeah but that's engagement with our children they come to those they come to the ceremonies they sit there they listen they give away their money so that's a way of their engagement so is this would be this like a one day snapshot would this be a yearly we' have to we
117determin that after we figure out some of the the notes again if we feel like it's if we feel like it's important there are ways to measure it that's what we want to do okay well I think we all agree that optimiz Community engagement is important I mean that is something you know we're tracking one day with data to be able to see what it is maybe I mean you would even go as far as like those reading the book Ving machange I mean it's been given by different organization I mean every all the grants all the grants I mean there's so many ways we could we could certainly measure that if we want okay can I move I'm G to move on to Str okay so strategic priority four optimize social and emotional health
118of all students so objective one district will develop and Implement professional learning for all Educators on social and emotional learning measurable or not measurable yes I right professional but it's the Implement part that's that's the hard part so if you're going to measure it you're going to have to have a curriculum you're going to have to have a schedule when that curriculum is being implemented and you have to have some way to to assess it is it working or we using it so I think so like at secondary they get that at during advisory thinking but it's only on certain days yes but it's mandatory so they do get it I don't know are we assessing any part I don't even know so I'm just saying that might be a little more involved we talk
119about the implementation of that versus the training you rece well and so let me take that back step again you know the district will develop and Implement professional learning for all Educators on social and emotional learning and the reason let's talk about why feel that's important or should still be there I mean we want our Educators to be aware of things happening or how to recognize in the classroom right at a high level what's going on to ensure our students you know are therey and safety yeah absolutely recognize you know signs making sure people are secure comfortable right and so that's the signs so I do think it's I think it's measurable from a development but I also think implementing is is that just who's taken it but then what's the result of this training
120yeah the outcome measure the outcome can you measure I mean I mean some of those outcomes I don't want I don't want to measure you know but yeah I I just think you put the Implement part in there which is the important part part I mean well and like we've done on others this could be just a strike and Implement you know maybe it's just that we're maintaining that training you know and that's that's where it is because then the outcome of of teachers in the classroom being aware monitoring watching should come with the training right right but I think you you might have elementaries that are doing a social skills lesson or a social emotional lesson on Mondays at 2 o'clock just I mean we just don't know that that the implementation's actually happening
121on all campuses okay could you measure implementation I mean we have certain things like our our threat assessments that we use when we when kids are you know having some difficulties and I mean I think it's hard to measure because you never um it's not the same thing by night not like it's more like the problem is is the outcome I mean how are you measuring that outcome you can measure anything as far it's implemented check that one check it yeah here's the list it's also so um what's the other thing that Sur it's kind of I mean you we have so many wonderful teachers that'll be like Carolyn you're just are you okay today and then how would you measure that I mean we've trained the teachers to look and our teachers are just
122they they love our kids right and it's their family but what would you how do you measure the differences of maybe they called home or maybe they wrote you a nice note or you know maybe they got you some I don't know how to measure all the things that our teachers do for kids in that degree I mean we do the training we have lots of training we have wonderful counselors um I I don't I guess you have to think about which one you want to look at yeah classic example happened in our family my way and the way uh rou was supported by colleagues who staff and in many different ways and just I think is an example of how this family functions they be very difficult to measure yeah success I mean we
123have so many great organizations that we had somebody yesterday bring us um I think there's over a 100 backpacks in Katrina's office because we're like we always get backpacks at the beginning of the year but you know kids some kids are harder on things than others they may need a new backpack so we get all of that um our faith-based leadership group met today and they ask what our needs are and they they reach out to families and take care of them so I don't know how to measure exactly all the things that we have put in place but it's been developed right just they go the training so that's we want check but as a district too we do a lot of develop an that's yeah we'll take those that and and come up
124so um the second objective number two you're focusing on just on that um the health start this year next year we could also look at um you know one of the things we also have is our um Behavior Specialists that teach teachers how to teach kids to self-regulate and you can pull discipline data for every campus and it has been amazing to see um the discipline of our students that the the behaviors that we used to see you know right when they came back from Co no matter what district you're in it was certain behaviors and now that you know we've got these specialist teaching teachers you or you may be a new teacher and I need to tell you not to yell at kids but um but it has made a difference you know
125because now we can tell you that here's how you handle that you just go to take his pencil away but if you know the the behaviors of students that we are able to get focused has been amazing um but again uh I don't everybody Implement you can have a program but every campus implements it a slightly different so when you're measuring it you're not measuring um the same across the board I mean we can train you but you you you may be a natural at it and you may need a retrain but we we can see the evidence in different ways so if we were determined that this was measurable I mean we know we've got new curriculum I mean you know that's discipline data but is it consistent you know I mean consistent practices
126across so maybe that's the go maybe that's the goal like she was talking about idity across start first grade rning up the RO yeah right I mean so discipline might be an indicator um uh counselor visits might be an indicator I was thinking crisis counselor yeah do to Elementary level regular counselors but you're right but then you have to make sure that it's clear across every campus like here's our referral process and here's how you track that I mean we track the the the how many lessons they do but it would be you'd have to track kids so more paperwork well I and I don't want to add work to add work to track something that we're going to get anyway with implementing a curriculum or something like that I mean the last thing we
127want to do is add to teachers PL I mean no go so so let's just Mark that off I I think our C great job we've got the curriculum let's Shack and let them measure how that's going yeah that's yeah let track let sh track like yes um okay so that's strategic priority um three and four if you think of something that you know as you're thinking through these um just send an individual message to me and I'll get it we I'll add it to our notes with the government subcommittee um like I said strategic Priority One is with Administration reviewing I didn't get any comments on strategic priority two so window is closed it's going to Administration um based on our schedule and then um we've changed it a couple times but I think
128we'll be talking about strategic priority five on um a work study in late March or maybe early April I'll have to look at the calendar again but I'll let y know for what it is okay so there four we're taking out are you going to keep it four part two we already did it I know I'm saying are you keeping are you keep what was the we'll let you know we're going to do our work we'll do our work and then we'll come back with a proposal she she just like we're doing five for next yeah five is next sign all Miss she's okay good thank you committee effort committee effort thank you committee our last item on the agenda is a legislative discussion and as as on day y so I only have uh
129One update right now and that possibly us going to the capital on April 1st um and it would be a just to drive down there get up early in the morning and then drive back the same day um Our intention is just to go as a board hopefully together as a board um and just go down to Austin talk to a couple of Representatives Matthew Hall raise your hand Texas is going to facilitate that meeting for us and uh yesterday we were at team csb and there was a conversation from a principal who came up to me and asked if they could come with us and they asked are we going to open it to principles to come so I mentioned it to Matthew Hall and he said you know it's really interesting because principles
130have they have young staff members in Austin and they have these principles who still see them the kids the staff rece them as authority figures so they really trust them they really respect them and whatever they say it's very important to them and so he's like I If you can I would recommend it there's been a district uh a surrounding District in that area that did that and did the same thing they car pulled and everybody went down to Austin and then they came back so I'm bringing this to you guys to ask your thoughts what do you think we should do you guys let me know I think that's great I think if we can if we could open it to principes that would fantastic I think ultimately want to have a discussion with
131M Marsh and Dr Eldridge to say how many principles if they might we be able toas anyone I'm not sure we want them to all be gone but uh I think it is a good idea and if we can work out some Logistics on that uh to bring that forward for the discussion planning for the April TR okay and transportation yeah I'll and I'll have a like once we get closer to the date we'll have a like an organized daytime hour what are we going to do where are we going who are we going to meet with Matthew's going to get it all ready and he's been such a great asset to us so I really appreciate thank you for bringing Matthew well I think the principales and all the department leaders loved his teaching
132yesterday because often times we don't understand what our legislator is doing and he is a great teacher yes um and that has been some that's been some really good feedback too that a lot of our principles have said I didn't understand that or I didn't know and so thank you for bringing it to light as a committee thank you guys as a district for just showing us because we had no idea 6160 what if you come every day I mean that's some people kind it's the funding it's you know what bills are passing how they pass them I mean just all the basics and he is a very good teacher so so that's all I have on that so we'll come up with the process of you know it's also you want the people to
133go that want to Advocate that really build a passion um and the opportunity and then what Transportation they and then if yall will tell me for rsdp and say who's going to go we did I think a d I hope is that that's April I I I'm unfortunately presenting a 2026 business plan in New York so I'll be there that's that's the pain unfortunately I'll send a strongly worded email that's fair it's April 1st and it's on a some Monday because we have a board meeting on Thursday I'll put it on your calendar send yall all an invite and you can receive I will look and see I have a meeting a doctor's appointment next week uh with a neurosurgeon and there's several things up in the air and so depending upon what and how
134and when I may not be traveling to some place like a we'll just have to see I I supportive and hopefully we'll be the meeting yesterday but we also have a website so anybody can fin don't thing have before we dismiss is an announcement really there's been a group uh Within uh the staff that is working on that time of year already uh planning and prepping for graduations and all the various pieces that go along with that uh one of the things that is being looked at to develop uniformity and consistency is for everyone involved uh to wear a graduation robe and that would include board members who have not in the past tradition Al done that uh they would wear we would wear uh just simple the black robe and then a color band
135that is appropriate to the that's not really a hood but whatever it is that so if it was the Turner graduation it would be blue uh Smith it would be green redr VI and teal for rench View and so that would be there um I throw it out as an idea I kind of like the idea think it might be a nice change to kind of unify some of that and get a little more consistency there would also solve me having to go out and get my suit cleaned but uh I will report back to them may I report back to them that we are willing to try the idea for a year sure yes me me too okay um you just don't want to put that down on but we'll I've never I've never
136been in favor of it but that's that's my personal but if the majority of the board I'm perfectly willing to try it for to do that let's try it this year and see what happens with it J's is for all of the high school and so Justin has said they will provide the appropriate White and the colored uh scarves whatever that's called that will be for that and I will report that back up to change everybody are there any other comments if not what time is it at 809 I'm going to gabble this meeting closed