001good evening everyone I call this Prem meeting briefing of the Carolton Farmers Branch ISD School Board uh to order at 6 pm on February 6th 2025 the purpose of the pre meeting is to conduct a briefing session with administrative staff regarding the posted agenda for the regular board meeting which is scheduled for 700 p.m. tonight uh for the record board members present are terara her AIC Kim Brady Marjorie Barnes Carolyn Benavides Elana Gara roas Cassandra Hatfield and I'm Randy shackman next item on our agenda is audience for guests we have no one that signed up to participate audience for guests during the pre meeting so we will move right on to the next item uh Dr Eldridge are there any reports by Administration um yes Mr Blackburn has item 5K l m n o n
002p so Mr Blackburn tonight is your night so we're going to talk about our construction manager at risk our athletic facilities and some Bond um approvals campus multicampus um change outs and more Bond round two president shakman members of the board it's good to see everyone tonight I'd like to refer you to some handouts that you should have in front of you um before we get into the agenda items I'm very happy to report that the new lighting at standard stadium is operational it's ready to go so if you see a very bright spot driving down Valwood Parkway you'll know why excited to see that all right for item K this is phase one for uh Kent rainwater and Creek View as we have in U past board meetings we're taking a phased approach to
003try and start the work as quickly as we can uh for that renovation package for item L this is the indoor practice field ventilation and the weight room equipment Renovations item m is is just the design for the track Replacements and overs sprays and the tennis court replacement and or over or refinishing um we wanted to make sure we had the engineering in place before we got final numbers for the tennis courts and the track so that's why that's just a partial for the design work item n is the 2018 Bond funded HVAC replacement that we discussed a couple of months ago so that's the pricing and that's equipment only for item n and I apologize what I did not catch till this afternoon that the right attachment was not included so if you look
004in your handouts you'll see the backup for item n it says item n at the top and it should be in front of you there if you have questions about that and then o you do have the backup there that is the construction management port portion of the 2018 funded uh rtu Replacements and then item P also was missing the backup and it's in front of you as well and that's at the top of um this page so hopefully you all have that in front of you for your reference I apologize for the um that not being attached correctly it got lost somewhere between purchasing and the the board agenda um and then finally in front of you just for some cont text you have a summary of what we have priced to date from
005the 2018 extra projects that we were able to accomplish so um just want to refer your attention to that you can see we did have a couple of variances as usual a few over a few under uh I can speak to a couple of those um the indoor practice ventilation variant um when we initially did the estimate for that we only estimated to replace what was actually broken even though that equipment is 30 to 40 years old and it might be working but it's very old and we felt like the better approach would be to replace the whole system together and keep it uh as a unit we'd felt like we'd get a better value that way so that's why there's that variance as far as the weight rooms the number that we carried initially
006for the estimate was the value of the equipment that we're replacing in the main buildings which the main buildings have a a room that's about a third the size of the rooms in the field houses so that's the reason for the number uh being changed for that line item and then you can see at the bottom um several items that were not yet pricing until we get a little bit further along and the current variance total over there at the bottom corner so any questions hopefully that helps a little bit I know it was a lot any questions board yes ma'am so the estimates were 2.64 and what you've uh what we've authorized and what the variance is now 2486 what about the remaining projects is there funding for that the 2.6 we're not pricing
007yet so we're going in order we're going in the order that uh the board prioritized for us we're trying to do that in order some of the pricing is coming in some of the pricing is taking a little bit longer than some of the other things so what's before you Deni is what we've got pricing for so far the 2.6 that's highlighted in the yellow is things that we are not pricing right now because we want to see how everything else shakes out but your current variance is almost at that number correct yes ma'am so is it mean that we won't have the money to do those other items that means we can we may not be able to depending on how some other things shake out I do expect to save some money in
008a couple of things that are on this list that we haven't priced yet so I'm hopeful we can still do those but we'll have to see how the pricing comes in yeah the on board members any other questions Mr Blackburn thank you very much much Dr Eldridge is that that concludes the administrative reports board is there any question or discussion relative to the consent agenda okay then I think we've reached the end of our agenda and we will call this preting session closed at 6:07 p.m. e e e the it all right here we go good evening everyone it's great to see such a engaged and active crowd here wish you were here every Monday of the first Monday of the month for our regular board meetings we look forward to our board meeting tonight
009I'm going to call this regular meeting of the Carolton Farmers Branch ISD board trustees to order at 700 p.m. and I would invite everyone to join me in standing as Elizabeth vranka from Mary Immaculate Catholic Church provides us with an opening message followed by the pledges led by Carolyn be Benavides to the US flag and Kim Brady to the Texas flag bow your heads please gracious and loving God we come before you today as a community seeking your wisdom and strength as the leaders of the Carolton Farmers Branch school district face difficult decisions especially the possibility of school school closures we ask for your guidance grant them Clarity of Mind compassion of heart and steadfast courage May every choice be made with fairness wisdom and a deep concern for the well-being of our students teachers
010and families let this board be a beacon of unity working toward the good of all in these uncertain times may we trust in your Providence and lean on one another with understanding and Grace bless this meeting bless our students bless our parents bless our administrators and bless our school board Lord and may your peace dwell Among Us amen amen I PL Al to the flag of the United States of America to the repu for it stands one nation God indivisible withy and justice for all honor the Texas flag algi to thee Texas one state God one and indivisible thank you as a district we dedicate all of our efforts all of our resources to our goal of high expectations for all the board uses this goal to guide all deliberations all decisions and all actions
011you will see those deliberations decisions and actions tonight in Open Session the exception would be if we had some closed session which we do not tonight on the agenda uh and that is normally from section 551 of the Texas government code uh the record should show that all board members are present Tara herbach Kim Brady Mar uh Marjorie Barnes Carolyn Benavides Elana Gara roas Cassandra Hatfield and I'm Randy shackman so we are all here we constitute a quorum and we may conduct business on behalf of the district uh before moving to the next agenda item I would like to remind you that the board will accept comments uh during audience for guests persons wish to speak for audience for guests have completed an online form for this purpose and submitted it electronically prior to today's
0125:00 pm deadline and when the board reaches agenda item four audience for guests you will be invited to the podium to be able to speak our next item on the agenda is special presentations and recognitions and uh generally recognitions we're going to turn that over to Karen Rodriguez good evening before I start I I needed to say that Emily Riley left her lights on so if Emily Riley is here good evening president shakman uh Dr Eldridge and Board of Trustees um my name is Karen Rodriguez and I am proud to present our CFB champion of the month through our partnership with Chick-fil-A at Trinity Mills we honor individuals who demonstrate Excellence with the CFB Champion award the February CFB Champion award is being presented to Melissa Clark a fourth grade math ESL teacher at Farmers
013Branch Elementary School Miss Clark is being awarded tonight for saving the life of a fifth grade student [Applause] so just moments after finishing breakfast at school fifth grader Benjamin rooper found himself in a life-threatening situation as he was walking down the hall to class he began choking on a biscuit Miss Clark was nearby quickly recognized the urgency and jumped into action performing the himl maneuver on Benjamin twice saving his life Benjamin's mother Benjamin's mother Miss rooper expressed her sincere gratitude to Mrs Clark for saving her son's life she said we are incredibly grateful for her quick thinking and decisive actions during this frightening moment Miss Clark has been a beloved member of Farmers Branch Elementary for many years and her imp extends beyond my son my sisters and I now in our 30s still fondly
014remember her from our own time at the school Miss Clark we thank you for your heroic heroic actions and the unwavering dedication you have for your students it is an honor to present you with the CFB Champion award [Applause] tonight that concludes tonight's recognitions next item on our agenda will be committee updates and uh so we'll start with our commit board members are there any committee updates yes sir I have two first is the finance and Facilities committee which comprises of myself Iana garer roas and marjerie Barnes um we met with Miss settle and Mr Marsh and we discussed um more efficient uses use of personnel minimum minimum class sizes K through 12 daily schedules of students and teachers and tea policies and then my second one is the bond oversight committee um we met
015uh Mr habach is also on that committee with me we talked about special education improvements at Freeman Landry Ranch viw and Riverchase and how we are actively getting getting those done fast and furiously this summer also um Ranch View robotics Arena and competition space to be completed by this August plans for the Outdoor Learning Center and a Sciences were reviewed and to begin this December it was very exciting but we are waiting on FEMA to get that all that plan started and the facilities planning Advisory Group criteria was shared with us um I'm going to report on the activities of the governance subcommittee and uh that's myself Mrs Hatfield and Miss Barnes uh we met on February 2nd we reviewed the final legal comments on um policies and board operating procedures and made necessary updates
016um I will distribute the draft of our operating procedures uh for your review um at our discussion we ultimately felt the updates were significant enough that you should all have more time to review those thus the policies and the operating procedures have been pushed to the mar March meeting we also completed our subcommittee work on strategic priority two as part of the ongoing work in reviewing and refining our CV 2030 um I'll get that um also out for your review along with the Strategic priority three and four which are the next items if you remember from the previous schedule that we'll review together um as um a board to determine um next steps that's it thank you Mr bachik Miss Benes thank you Mr shackman I'm a reporting on behalf of Shaq we are considering
017backpack weight concerns as well as weather guidelines for When the Children uh rules surrounding when students may have access to outdoor play great great thank you other board members Miss Carls Rosas we don't have a meeting that uh I'm speaking on behalf of the legislative committee which is Caroline benovitz Randy shakman and myself we not have a meeting but we do have an update that on February 11th Matthew Hall will be coming to team CFB to have listening circles to work with our advocacy crew um the intended plan is the hope that the board will come together and go to the state capital on April 1st um however since you guys are all sitting here and in the public I would also ask that you advocate for our kids as well at a state level
018and not just at a local level it is extremely important for us to do so we have priorities as a school board and you guys are welcome to go to our website and find those uh we've worked together collaboratively to get this done so just it's extremely imperative that we do that for our kids yes any other reports we have an active working great bunch of board members and uh Miss garar roas and the work that the advocacy group is doing uh good stuff and we need as she said all of you to get involved with us we look forward to that uh the next item on our agenda is District announcements and I'm going to turn it over to you Dr Eldridge okay several thing great things that have happened in our district um
019principal Nicole Greenleaf hosted rainwater's 30th year anniversary at the campus it was so well attended um there's so much tradition so many great teachers and administrators um great view of all the t-shirts most of the board attended um it was incredible the choir performance and a lively dance club I mean it was just so many amazing uh Traditions that happened at that anniversary also wanted to thank our principal Cara Miller at ranchview high school um she partnered with um undefeated learning and um caterpillar foundation and they um provided our school district with a manufacturer breakout box and it was an immersive learning experience that was we are the first in the nation to get our kids to practice that manufacturing they were actually practicing manufacturing sunglasses it was incredible and that's truly an authentic learning
020experience for them so what a great thing um and it was also featured on Fox 4 news so Clarice Tinsley did a little blip about it um we also um have to thank Carla Hardaway at Creek View um some several of us attended the um for gloro uh competition at the AT&T performance center it was incredible to watch our kids um she's been a part of that organization it's our fourth year in doing so our kids um I think it was field uh finished first in their middle school duet it was incredible to watch our kids dance and so what a great energy and lots of competition across the Metroplex so good things are happening that's all I have there we go and now we would like to get an update from PTA and I'm
021going to turn over to Stacy Alo Dr elridge um president shakman and the esteem board I am Deana Nunes I'm the second VP of um Council under membership um let's start tonight with our PTA model to make every child's potential Reality by engaging and Empowering Families and communities to advocate for all children it is election season and our nominating committee is looking for you we have a Google intros form available for job descriptions on our Council PTA website you can fill out and find out the jobs that are available our spring training Extravaganza will be at the ncy Waton Center on February 22nd from 9: to 12 babysitting will be available and anyone in the community is welcome to attend it's a great way to learn about the roles of PTA if anyone is interested
022in becoming more involved in your local ptas please fill out a Google form on our website to RSVP we do have a big Community program this year Patrol stories is coming soon it is promoted for student safety by fostering a positive Community relationship with our First Responders it will be a k through eight event on March 1st at Newman Smith the showtime is at 1 p.m. and ticket information is coming soon this month we are recognizing all of our golden apple schools we want to honor those principles who have supported PTA by getting their staff to join golden apple is received only when you have 100% of your staff members as PTA members um principales when we call your name you're going to come and receive a banner this year is a banner with a
023golden apple hopefully we'll get all schools with a banner next year you'll get an Apple sticker for that year to continue so our first school is Rainwater Elementary Blair Elementary Country Place Elementary Kent Elementary Farmers Branch Elementary Thompson Elementary Lalita Elementary mlin Strickland Elementary Rose Meat [Applause] Elementary bleac Middle School DT Perry middle school pulk middle school and Newman Smith high school thank you principals for your support of PTA as always thank you community for supporting PTA okay you guys can turn turn around now too one more big all right so an excellent example that shows how much our campus Administration believes in the power of PTA and uh we are grateful for all the work that PTA does and if you are uh interested in becoming a member of PTA would encourage you to
024do that the next item that's up on our agenda is uh number three our uh non-action items and uh first on the list is our annual report and the hb3 goals the taper report Miss Keane good evening Dr Aldridge president shakman and members of the board thank you for the opportunity to share the cfbisd annual report information on student performance in our district for the 2023 24 school year please know that the data we will be reviewing tonight was released by the Texas Education Agency on December 15th and while the information on STAR testing is from the 2324 school year our financial rating graduation rate and the college career and Military readiness factors are from the 2021 22 school year so I'll refer to that as a lagging indicator Texas Education Code requires the Board
025of Trustees to publish an annual District performance report and hold a public hearing on information provided within the Texas Academic performance report or also known as taper this year Carolton Farmers Branch held our public hearing earlier tonight prior to the board meeting tonight we will share the information um with the board and those in attendance um all information related to the 2023 2024 taper which is an overview um will also include an overview of our financial Integrity rating system um the district accreditation status how to access the campus performance objectives also a report on campus incidents and a look at the house bill three goals which are reflected in the taper additionally I'll provide an update to the state's accountability rating process as a reminder to those in attendance the mission of cfbisd uh as
026a diverse community of global Learners um is to empower Scholars to acquire lifelong knowledge skills and values that prepare them to compete in the world marketplace while contributing to their Community we have high expectations for all students as we look at our student performance data tonight this is a good reminder that we know that our students are valued and are more than just the assessment numbers that you'll find on the public State sites as we preview the 2023 24 taper please know that this data is reflected from our pe's submissions and student assessment data this report is compiled and distributed by tea and the published taper PDF which will be located on our district website includes a wide range of student information um regarding our performance which is also disaggregated into student subpopulations and it
027provides extensive information on staff in our in our programs this is a great way to see our data compared to the region and at the state level um all within that report typically um each school year districts are assigned a district rating that is calculated by the culmination of all of their campus ratings they are also provided a special education determination status this slide shows a picture of the first page of the taper now the once again anticipated ratings have not been released due to two one the initial lawsuit between other school districts and tea around the timeliness of releasing the final 2023 accountability manual and now an additional lawsuit lawsuit between other school districts and tea regarding questions of assessment validity for the 2024 accountability ratings so these lawsuits have resulted in a delay
028of our annual campus and District ratings however tea was able to release our special education determination status through um results driven accountability or what we call RDA and cfbisd received our status of meets requirement for the 2324 school year and we're continuing to make improvements in our processes and supports for our students each year cfbisd has earned the highest rating of superior achievement which is a rating of an A and a numerical score of a 100 on the Texas first which that's the acronym for financial Integrity rating system of Texas um for the 2324 school year we have received the highest rating every year since the system's Inception this is another rating that is required in the annual report the first rating which the Texas Education Agency um issued to public schools and has issued
029since 1999 measures the quality of school district's financial management and Reporting the report ensures that Texas public schools are held accountable for the quality of their financial management practices and that they improve those practices the system is designed to encourage Texas public schools to better manage their financial resources to provide the maximum allocation possible for direct instructional purposes the rating is based on 20 indicators that include results of the annual external audit debt management fund balance and administrative cost ratio among other Financial indicators the recent designation is based on financial information from the 2223s fiscal year before we begin looking at our academic performance let's look first at the profile of our district and then the students and staff in CFB from last year our district serves students from Age 3 to 21 across 35
030campuses and three education centers in 2023 and 24 we enrolled over 24,000 students and employed nearly 3,700 Personnel of which 67% were professional staff our average teacher salary which is 63,9 $45 and CFB is almost $1,500 above the state's average as you're well aware this helps keep CFB competitive in regards to recruiting and retention of other teachers in our area taper also provides a view of our staff profile our full-time teachers accounted for 51.4% of our full-time Staff last year looking at the pie chart the majority of our teachers had had over or excuse me had over 5 years of classroom experience of the 1,893 teachers 45.4% of our teaching staff had zero to five years of teaching experience uh experience that's about 10% higher uh than the state for this past school year remembering
031that these are our students from last year you can see that our CFB student population profile is listed here our CFB student population has remained relatively unchanged Over The Last 5 Years the district saw the largest increase in our um Hispanic population um and so that is just information for us to know regarding student enrollment by program type we saw a slight decrease in our economically disadvantaged students from 66 a. half% in 2023 to 65.9% in 2024 again all of this information is reflected in the taper our special service population is also continuing to rise as we see here it went from 15.4% to 17.1% which is another increase um over the the year previous to that so in 2022 um emergent bilingual our third program type has experienced significant growth in our district we
032see an increase from 38.8% up to 42.7% last year you can see the increase in our gifted and talented numbers as well by almost a full percent from 11 .3 to 12.2 in this past school year this positive increase is attributed to our enhancements and adjustments to our identification processes and additional screening tools used last year due to the stall and the release of our ratings for 2023 and 2024 the district accreditation statuses for the 2324 school year have not been issued so each District's annual report must instead include the 2022 23 accredit ation status which was a b meaning that we are an accredited school district our campus performance objectives which is another piece that is required within the annual report um they can be found in our campus Improvement plans so if you
033go to our district website and our campus websites you'll be able to find those specific uh campus Improvement plans which house our campus performance project uh objectives we initially shared the locally calculated accountability subset scores from 2024 during the September school board meeting as released in taper we see the confirmation of those accountability subset data for those results included uh all students testing during the Spring administration of star 3 through eight tests as well as the end of course exams the scores shown here from the recently released taper include all versions of STAR testing so that's grades 3 through eight and EOC including those who tested during the summer and the December of 2023 as well as our star alternate scores additionally these scores only include students who were enrolled in CFB on Snapshot date
034which was that last Friday in October of 2023 taper does include two consecutive years of star data and so for comparison purposes we've included those here looking at all subjects com combined for approaches grade level and above uh 74% of students were at or above the passing standards gains have been made in comparison to 2023 most notably the all subjects for um in the all subjects area as well as in reading and in social studies and that is at the meets grade level or above as well as gains in our master's performance level and again for the all subjects for reading and for social studies here's an additional view of that exact same data which um shows more years to consider and to see how we performed compared to pre-co and pre-star redesign um and
035so what you see here is 2019 and then you see that bar representing covid so there are no data points available because we did not test that spring and then it moved into the 2021 school year we had testing again in 2022 then the star our redesign occurred so across all assessments that were given the test looked slightly different with new question types um including writing samples drag and drop and multi- select type questions and so we can see that our meets grade level percentage is above where we were in 2019 while our masters and approaches grade level um and above is nearly there we previously shared all of these next slides um at our board meeting in September um take paper does confirm the accountability subset data and so I'll briefly go through these
036with you all again again the the purpose of the annual report is to provide information from the taper and so that's what we are doing here you'll see that the state and region percentage for each grade level um in elementary mathematics and a well to um in addition to the district performance across third fourth and fifth grade here we re we revisit the elementary Reading percentage for each grade level these are percentages for approaches grade level and above and are reflected in our district taper here's our Middle School mathematics slides um again we'd like to remind the the board and our audience that Middle School mathematics is an area that we see off-grade level testing we where we have our Advanced seventh grade math students taking the eighth grade math assessment and the advanced eighth
037grade mathematics students taking the algebra end of course or EOC exams here's a view of our Middle School reading scores and again like I mentioned we've previously shared these scores in September um but what we are including here um are is just the confirmation of what we see in the taper here's a look at our fifth eth and our Biology EOC um these are the only three grade levels that are tested in the area of Science and so CFB was above the state and region in fifth grade science just below the state and 8th grade science and we were equivalent to the state and region in biology as as we wrap up our review of the student achievement performance we see our uh EOC tested courses which include algebra English one and English 2 the
038state region and District are trending similarly in student performance in algebra and English one um and if the board or Community was interested in looking into campus level data please know that each campus has their own taper report available um on the tea website as well as your campus websites um here in CFB and then here is just a quick view looking at the last two eoc's um which are US history and Biology another requirement of the district's annual report um is showing our progress towards our house bill three board goals again this information was shared at the September board meeting and the graph here shows a green line which indicates um the 60 by 30 which is the initiative of tea to hit 60% of third grade students at the meets grade level or
039Above Performance indicator so you can see here that we surpassed the House Bill 3 board goal with 51% of our third grade uh students earning a meets grade level or above on Star here is another view I've again provided that green line to indicate the 60 by 30 um which means by 2030 we will have 60% of our third graders um third grade mathematics students at meets grade level or above we had a 4% goal increase from 2023 to 2024 and we were able to meet that goal of 49% which puts us on track with our house bill 3 board goal for our third grade students we had a rigorous goal here and we met it here you'll see that our class of 2023 which shows the 61% um is reflected in taper um these
040are one of our lagging indicators that we'll look at that are found within taper and this um this is one of those so 61% is a 1% increase from the class of 2022 and this is included in the 2024 accountability um again that's on hold uh but then based on our preliminary indicators the class of 2024 has a projected overall ccmr percentage of around 86% um you'll see that I added a blue line here um which highlights Tea's score of 88% which would scale our District to an A and ccmr for accountability ratings we have surpassed that 60% goal of Tea's 60 by3 and we are maintaining a rigorous goal as we continue to strive for that a rating in ccmr this class of 2024 data so students who graduated this past spring um will
041not be seen until the 2025 accountability rating um if when and if those do come out um but now for more expanded look at college career and Military Readiness found within taper ccmr includes more than College ready factors uh which does include test scores on TSI accuplacer sat or act so again remembering we're looking at the class of 2023 here um we'll see the coursework taken by graduating seniors while they are enrolled in high school such as dual credit advanced placement on-ramps and College Prep as well as industry-based certifications earned through CTE classes um a note of change this year within taper is that they did move the calculation of our students who received um what's called a sped Advanced diploma um under College ready um it was previously listed under career and Military Readiness
042and so as a result this is the first year of um where the data has been moved and so um we aren't able to compare the percentages to last year because they made that change it changes our overall percentage um of that 5050 and a half% that are that are deemed College ready that's found within within the taper here we'll turn our attention to graduation rates again another lagging indicator is this is the class of 2023 you can see here the 10-year um trend line CFB continues to have a four-year grad a four-year graduation rate above 90% the four-year grad rate for the class of 2023 and C FB was 94.1% which is above the state average which was 90.3 and the region which was 88 and a half% for the class of 2023 so
043this is a moment of Celebration um as it is a significant increase over the previous two years and the work of our campus counselors and teachers the grad team efforts and the administrators is clear and evident here as we want to ensure that as many of our students um graduate from Carolton Farmers Branch their senior year safety is a top priority in CFB last year the number of mandatory expulsions in our district accounted for an overall incident rate of less than 1% and so we can remember that through our Department of Safety and Security all campuses were equipped with a secured safe entrance that includes a video Bell intercom system additionally our security directors have worked to increase the required staff at all campuses across the district and train Personnel on safety systems through Raptor
044alerts thank you Texas Education Code 5143 e requires postsecondary institutions in Texas to report student performance during the first year of enrollment After High School graduation to the high school from which the students graduated and then districts must include this information in their annual report and so the Texas Higher Education College Board publishes a report listing this information for each of our high schools in Texas um they are sorted by county and district and it's available on the website so if you need any easy reading over the weekend um you can find that there this first page um does explain the first page within that report does explain the purpose um of the report and some very in-depth data calculation methods so again that easy reading would be great prayer of the weekend um so
045these last two slides are just the um the data that has come from the Texas Higher Education board to let us know the percentage of our students and the count of our students who have gone on to uh to college this report does include the GPA earned during that first year in post-secondary education um if they're enrolled in a public higher education um campus in Texas so our key takeaway key takeaways tonight include these four points um our ratings are on hold for 2023 still and now 2024 um we did receive that Superior Financial rating it's the highest rating reflecting finan uh fiscal responsibility our academic performance um there are areas of increase and we are excited about that we're thankful to our teachers who work so hard with our students to make that happen
046and then our graduation rate it's increased from the previous years um and that is no small task and so I've said this before each time I present but I don't ever want to miss an opportunity to extend a much-deserved thank you to the work of our many many teachers our staff our campus administrators for just the level of intentionality that we see in our students education we have a big push for knowing our students by name and need um and they make that evident um so that we can have an incredible community of Learners and so thank you to the families who ensure that our students are at school and that they're there for learning it has an incredibly important impact on who um who they're going to be come to our community in the
047future this does uh conclude our presentation on student performance and the required components of the annual report and taper as a reminder um we did hold our public hearing earlier tonight and you will be able to access this report um in the coming weeks on our District's website thank you for your time this evening are there any questions that I can answer at this time thank you Miss Keane we appreciate your report uh the annual taper shows us some great things are happening in CFB we still got work to do but we have uh Superior staff and resources that are making the high expectations for our students a reality thank you board members are there any questions mrbk thank you um so a question on the postsecondary performance data and information yall know I have
048an interest in this but um so this is just GPA for first year following graduation does this continue to track a second year third year or does it stop after the first year at public un I understand it's public universities the report that is provided is just that first year following yes ma'am okay okay thank you yes ma'am thank you Miss Kean you did a wonderful job as always um I was looking at the college career and Military Readiness slide when students are indicated as College ready um under like dual credit and AP is that a certain number of classes that they have to pass or receive a certain rating on like or is it that they take a class um for example under dual credit they've received they've received credit okay great thank you
049so much yes ma'am yes M thank you for the presentation as well I just have for clarification for the community what is a taper report and who does it go to oh absolutely a taper report is a great read um every single School District across the state of Texas has a report where it it provides you a lot of information regarding your school profile so you can look at it from a district level to see overall how the district is performing and then you can see it at every single campus so you can look at information regarding um class size you can look at how many teachers are brand new how many teachers are veteran you can look at salary averages you can look at just a lot of disaggregated information um it'll have a
050breakdown of grade level performance in terms of percentages which is why we made sure to include those here tonight um it holds a lot of information and you can look up any campus across the whole state of Texas so if you have a a family member down in Houston and you're just very curious on a Saturday night you can pull up their taper report and just check in on how that school is performing thank you so much for the clarification abolutely any other board members Miss Keem thank you again appreciate all your hard work thank you the next item on our agend agenda I suspect is one that has brought most of us here uh it is the facilities Master Plan update and we're going to start with uh some information from Dr eldrid and
051tonight's facility master plan agenda item has been a 15mon long methodical and challenging process for all of us involved as your superintendent I would like to reassure you that this process involveed data collection feedback on-site facility walks conversations and Community input this has been an open process for all of us it's been transparent and it's been very inclusive there is no way around the difficult conversation that we have to have tonight but the real conversation that we're facing is that for the last two years in 2023 and 2024 we have adopted deficit budgets 24 of our 34 schools are only utilized at 75% capacity or less some of our buildings are outdated and they do not Foster the safe and dynamic learning spaces that we need today and in the future this painstaking work has
052led to the criteria that was developed for tonight the criteria was created by our facility planning Advisory Group and they helped guide us even with the guidance and the data that's been provided it does not account for all of the emotion and memories that have been made at all of your campuses before we present I would like to play a video that we shared with our facility planning Advisory Group that summarizes the state of our schools not just in our school district but across the state and after the video plays Mr Blackburn will present his presentation so watch the video talking to you schols mayed to know anes en do not some finan changes what we would see is that def appr these students atals searching I believe we're searching for answer where there is
053no good evening Dr Aldridge president shakman esteemed members of the board it's good to see you tonight tonight I'll be presenting the facilities planning recommendations for the board Bo to consider as we begin I want to say that discussions like this are never easy when I first became acquainted with CFB over 20 years ago it was evident that there was a strong sense of family here since I came on board I have come to believe that the sense of family here is even stronger now as every family knows sometimes hard conversations are needed and this is one of those times that said I firmly believe that our family will come out stronger on the other side how did we get here after adopting a deficit budget in August of 2023 we recognized the need to
054take a close look at things including commissioning a capacity study and a facilities master plan the last thing we wanted to do was to spend money as planned prior to the deficit budget and then realize afterwards we should have made a few course Corrections the capacity study and Facilities master plan were presented to the board in June of 2024 and included recommendations for consolidation of three elementaries and one Middle School the board requested input from the community before taking any action we wanted our community staff and board to have the best information possible so that they could make the best decisions our demographic information was not up to datee so we commissioned a demographic study using fall 2024 snapshot data a second consecutive deficit budget was adopted in August of 2024 reinforcing the need for
055Change and the facility planning Advisory Group met three times in the fall of 2024 and the fall 2024 demographics report was presented at the December 2024 board meeting our guiding principles throughout have been and continue to be student achievement teacher support and fiscal responsibility the capacity study completed at the end of last year using 2023 2024 data documented a large number of empty seats across the district to two points I want to make regarding capacity utilization low campus utilization does not mean that a particular campus will be recommended for consolidation the goal is to improve utilization across the district and more students per school does not mean more students per class it does mean we can better afford the staff space and resources needed for optimal student achievement you might ask why is having extra
056capacity an issue in a word it's expensive the two schools here are both less than 25 years old built only six years apart and have similar floor plans we spend 30% more per student on the campus with lower utilization our goal is to maximize our investment for every student to do that we need to address this kind of imbalance here are the recommendations presented to the board in June of 2024 being considered now consolidate three elementary schools add one new prek and consolidate one middle school just to rec AP the charter of the facility planning Advisory Group was clear setting criteria for CFB to make Master planning criteria to make Master planning recommendations to the board and the goal was for CFB to be among the most competitive districts via efficient use of District funds
057and Facilities as we shared with the facility planning advisory committee thanks to conservative fiscal management by the trustees and our staff we currently have a healthy fund balance if we do not act now that will change quickly this slide shows what will happen with no raises and no changes it would not be long before the fund balance is gone here you can see the results criteria developed in four categories condition in adequacy cost for Quality location and utilization were all approved by over 90% at the same time that the facility planning advisory committee was doing their work our demographer paa was analyzing our current demographic data their report was presented to the board in December of 2024 there are a couple of things we want to highlight from posa's report looking back five years we
058can see that while our enrollment has declined most of our immediate neighbors are seeing steeper declines looking forward for the next 10 years we can see that posa is projecting a continue decline of roughly a thousand students declining enrollment of course means declining Revenue the last thing to highlight from the demographics report is areas where student numbers are expected to increase as you can see most of the growth is projected to occur west of I35 now we would like to briefly look at where things stand right now regarding existing utilization and adequacy this shows the elementary schools in the Creek View feeder the blue circles depict a one mile radius from a campus in other words half of our transportation radius as you can see there is an area in this feeder pattern where you
059are less than one mile from five of our current elementary campuses overall utilization is currently 71% for elementaries in this feeder pattern this shows elementaries in the Smith feeder again the blue circles depict a one M radius from a campus in other words half of our transportation radius this feeder pattern has an area where you are less than one mile from four of our current elementary campuses and overall utilization is currently 77% for elementaries in this feeder pattern for the Turner feeder it's the same song but a different verse this feeder pattern has a large area where you are less than one mile from four of our current elementary campuses overall utilization is 65% for elementaries in this feeder pattern this shows elementaries in the Ranch View feeder again the blue circles depict a one
060mile radius this feeder has the least overlap of them all and overall utilization is currently 75% for this feeder pattern this shows middle schools districtwide red circles depict the 2 mile radius from a campus middle schools have an area where you are less than 2 miles from four of our current campuses overall utilization is 67% for Middle School tools now that we have discussed how we got here and gotten some context about the existing landscape it is time to look at the specific recommendations the reasons for these recommendations are fiscal responsibility efficiency student achievement competitive position and Equity across the district the benefits we expect are reduction of more than 2,300 empty seats firste Savings of up to 9 million Programs located near the majority of students served and improved Transportation efficiency for the Creek
061View feeder pattern the recommendation is to consolidate for no Elementary this is projected to improve Elementary utilization in this feeder pattern to 8 2% this is the oldest Elementary facility in the feeder pattern at 55 years it has small classrooms that are difficult to secure presenting Safety and Security concerns as we saw on the maps earlier this feeder has the highest density of elementaries and we believe that we will be able to maintain a neighborhood field despite consolidation and it will allow us to invest more in every student for the Smith feeder the recommendation is to consolidate McCoy Elementry the recommendation is only regarding the facility at McCoy the LEAP program will continue intact and is proposed to be located at Landry going forward this is projected to improve efficiency excuse me utilization in this
062feeder pattern to 86% this is the oldest Elementary facility in the feeder pattern without a major renovation at 48 years small classrooms that are difficult to secure present Safety and Security concerns here and as we saw on the maps earlier this feeder has a very high density of elementaries and we believe we will be able to maintain a neighborhood feel despite consolidation for the Turner feeder pattern the recommendation is to consolidate Central Elementary this is projected to improve Elementary utilization in the feeder pattern to 81 excuse me 81% this is the oldest Elementary facility in the feeder pattern at 61 years as we saw on the maps earlier this feeder has a very high density of elementaries and we believe we will be able to maintain a neighborhood feel despite consolidation this will also allow
063for long-term improvements at Turner High School for middle schools the recommendation is to consolidate long this is projected to improve utilization in this feeder pattern to in across middle schools to 79% this is the oldest Middle School without a m major renovation at 46 years and it will allow us to invest more in every student you might be wondering what is the plan for the Consolidated campuses for the fno Elementary School location the planned alternative use is a possible future pre center for the McCoy Elementary School location the planned alternative use is a possible sale for the central Elementary School campus the planned alternative use is temporary classrooms for campuses under construction and for the Long Middle School the planned alternative use is temporary classrooms for campuses under construction new attendance Zone recommendations a few
064things to remember consolidate recommendations require us to consider new attendance zones we want to balance our utilization so we can balance our investment in every student new attendance zones have not been considered for over 20 years and our neighborhoods have changed a great deal in that time and we want to optimize our transportation here are the proposed Elementary attendance zones a few highlights Forno students would attend Thompson or Davis McCoy students would attend good Blandon or Carolton as noted previously the LEAP program will continue intact and is proposed to be located at Landry going forward this will allow the majority of students in the program to be closer to home Central students would attend Carolton or M Lin Strickland the boundaries of the surrounding attendance zones will need to be pushed and pulled somewhat as
065well to accommodate the changes and again the goal is to balance utilization so we can balance our investment in every student all but two attendance zones Kent and mcarter have proposed changes here are the proposed Middle School attendance zones Long Middle School students would attend bleac or pulk and again the boundaries of the surrounding attendance zones will need to be pushed and pulled somewhat as well to accommodate the changes and here are the proposed changes at the high school level Creek View Zone got just a bit bigger and Smith's Zone would include a small area south of belt line now I'll turn it over to our assistant superintendent of Human Resources good evening superintendent Eldridge president shakman and members of the board in the very short period of time that I've been here in less
066than approximately 5 months I can see the comp passion and the emotion that this is bringing to everybody and I just want to stand here on behalf of the human resources department to reassure you and all the staff impacted by this consolidation that they will have a position in CFB I also want to take a few moments to go over a very brief overview of the relocation process after this evening PR presenting the recommendations tomorrow morning we are going to start early and visiting our camp CES impacted by the consolidations to share information about the reassignment process after the March 7th board meeting when you all make the final decision the HR team will issue a survey to to the impacted employees to gather their input and preferences on some of the preferred colleagues and
067teammates that they would want to stick stay with interest in specific positions as well as some top campuses their top three choices of where they would like to be uh sent HR will review the survey results and prioritize Staffing relocating with programs or designated student groups we will work hard to keep as many teachers as we can together with teammates and with groups of our students assignments will also consider staff preferences alongside programs being moved certification requirements rezoning needs and District priorities ultimately our goal is is to ensure by May 1st all staff will be notified of their new assignments we are committed to transparency and ensuring a smooth transition for all staff impacted by this change and with that I'd like to turn it over to Dr Lance Hamlin Dr Eldridge Mr shackman members
068of the board I would like to thank you for the opportunity to assure our community that the registration and transfer processes and procedures will be more efficient than ever during this process as you can see it is our goal to notify every family that will be impacted by the attendance zone changes by three different ways you will receive a personalized letter a parent Square message as as well as a welcoming message from the principal from the newly assigned campus on March 24th two things will happen we will have our program application window open like it does every year these programs apply to our prek programs our two-way dual language program and our steam GT Academy we will also open our campus transfer Windows as well as what we're really excited about again is our early
069registration window that will open on April the 1st and as you remember last year we had our most successful early registration window in the history of CFB we had over 12,000 students register before summer we encourage you we encourage you to register early start on April the 1st please we wouldd also like to inform you of our uh Community I'm sorry inform our community about our family information sessions that are scheduled uh here next week you can see these uh information sessions are geared towards these following communities The Long Middle School Community you'll have an opportunity on February the 10th from 6:00 to 7: P.M to have your session at Creekview High School in the auditorium the McCoy Elementary Community will have an opportunity on February 13th from 6:00 to 7:00 p.m. at Newman Smith
070High School in the auditorium the Central Elementary Community will have an opportunity on February the 18th 6 to 7 p.m. at Turner High School auditorium and then our Forno Elementary Community will be able to have their opportunity on February the uh 20th 6:00 to 7: p.m at the Creek View High School auditorium at this time I would like to hand the presentation over to Dr Eldridge for closing tonight these recommendations have been presented the official board vote will be on March 6th I know this is a tough decision for our school board but I have no doubt that they will make the best decision for our students in their future I want to thank everyone that has been involved in this process we would not be able to get through this difficult and challenging time
071without the strength passion love and support of our CFB family challenges are very hard this has been very hard and challenging for all of us but it also will bring New Beginnings for all of our students so I thank you all for the presentation tonight Mr shakman I would add my thanks as well and my thanks to uh the district Partners Passa and walport and those who have provided excellent professional C to us to consider in this process uh as a a McCoy alumni parent it's a hard decision but these all are decisions that are to benefit our students going forward we want the best for all board members are there any questions that you have regarding the presentation yeah um I would like to start by clarifying um for the taper report the academic
072rate is better increased performance all campuses have met uh Safety and Security and trained Personnel saying that every one of these campuses that are listed for consolidation have met those requirements yeah and it's mentioned that was not that was not a primary factor in this evaluation space utilization cost a whole number and they pointed out all the different factors that were involved in that and uh then these are the recommendations they are simply at this point recommendations and they uh have been given to us as a board to study uh with extensive background material and we will be studying it over the next month uh prior to the vote to to approve or to move forward with this process at the next meeting um no doubt we could probably make an argument for every campus
073that's out there but the district will be underwater and bankrupt in in years forward unless we do something this year and uh as a board member I don't want to leave my legacy at CFB failure so can I ask another question or would you not you don't want to discuss it well um it's for discussion yes what well I know that uh the proposed savings is $9 million but the campuses are all going to be utilized for something else and we're keeping all of our staff so I want to better understand the savings now I know that y'all it has been mentioned that it will be used for overflow and for construction purposes and I'm sure those are all Bond construction items y so is there income from the bond to utilize our facilities since
074they are going to possibly be closed um Miss benavites I think Mr Blackburn can address that as far as um you utilizing our campuses for construction for example at RL Turner do you want to address that Mr Blackburn about Portables and and swing space yes I can speak to that for example at RL Turner if we were not to use um a facility that we're repurposing we would have to spend the money on Portables and our alternator in in uh particular that would be between $2 and a half to $3 million we would have to build a new fire lane a permanent fire lane we'd have to move a fire hydrant and the parking situation at RL Turner is already requiring a waiver from the city and and if there's ever an event it's really
075a challenge so that should enable us to save uh to basically to invest more of our bond dollars towards uh building the building that will benefit the students instead of having to pay for temporary Portables so that's the savings uh as far as not having to use Portables so then bond funds would be used to rent these facilities so that we don't have that expense because if we're trying to cut cost using them still in creates cost or expense for us we would not be um renting there are some campuses where we'll end up having to get Portables but this lowers the number of campuses where we'll have to spend the money on Portables but uh it's just an expense that's sometimes unavoidable but in this case it appears that we might be able to
076avoid spending that money in a couple of campuses other board members questions it's a hard decision something we've got to positively approach and make the best J as we go forward because it's about our kids thank you Mr Blackman Dr smas Dr who else L hand Dr Hamlin for your presentation we appreciate it I'm going to recommend that we take a five minute recess and break there may be some that wish to use this opportunity to uh leave the meeting that's fine uh but uh we'll be back in five minutes and start on our audience for guests e e e look I'm going to call us back into session okay we are back in session at p.m. the next item on our agenda for tonight is audience for guests uh let me go over a
077few of the uh board operating procedures for audience for guests I will remind everyone if you're interested in speaking you've already signed up for doing that and submitted a form each speaker will be allowed to speak once during audience for guests speakers uh designated or stakeholders will be allowed a maximum of 3 minutes to speak uh to the board according to board policy policy bed local because the board wants to hear from as many of you as possible while keeping the meeting running efficiently groups of five or more people who wish to pre uh present a particular viewpoints should appoint one person to speak on behalf of their group uh please remember that the board is not by state law allowed to respond uh sometimes that gets confusing but it is the rules not of
078our doing but rules we must live by that we are not allowed to respond to individuals and audience for guests please keep your comments or criticisms civil or courus I know you will uh we ask that uh no one make personal attacks and that you uh not discuss students that are not your own child um in the event that uh the presiding officer that's me constitutes that there is a complaint or a charge against an employee or an officer during this time I will ask that you stop and we will direct you to the appropriate grievance process for that in compliance with the opens meeting act please note again uh in the uh we will not respond publicly to items that are not on this agenda the timer will uh show up on the screen
079and when you start to speak uh the three minutes will begin uh F our first Speaker tonight is I hope I'm pronouncing this night uh uh proud ver Med good evening committee members my name is chish and I am a third grader at McCoy I love my school before the sun even Rises it's a dark and cold outside but I wake up excited to go there my sister who is in high school now also went there and I was so happy when my chance came I love my classmates I've known them for a good part of my life after my house this is where I've spent most of my life learning growing and making friends who feel like family we play games together at recess and I feel happy because everyone is included and there
080are no bullies here I feel safe my teachers make learning so much fun they inspire me to do things like Reflections art contests and World Cup challenges I also ran for student council this year since McCoy is small I know all the teachers not just those in my grade this gives me something to look forward to as I move up each year one time I painted a picture of a rocket ship and my my teacher said it was out of this world that made me feel really proud I love McCoy and especially leap as it's my favorite part because it's a place where I can be myself and explore new things and dream big thank you for listening and for helping us keep McCoy the magical place it is thank you very much our next
081speaker is uh Diana Ferrar thank you I'd like to give you my appreciation for the for the moment to speak superintendent and the board I came tonight to advocate for the school I've called home for more than 35 years rosem meat Elementary I am grateful that I don't have to give this whole long I had it down to exactly three minutes speech but roseme like so many of the other schools in our district is so special it's the dedicated staff working with caring parents that make it all make make it what it is and I want to thank you such deep appreciation for the long arduous process painful process that you have all gone through so far and that you will continue in the next month um I know moving forward our focus should be
082on the state and let's all talk to our reps and our Senators and our governor but I know in the meantime that that dedicated rosem staff will Embrace any and all students that come through its doors and I do thank you for being such wonderful custodians for our community this is a very difficult process and I appreciate it thank you very much aara amand good evening and thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak on behalf of the leap parents at McCoy I'm a resident of the neighborhood zoned for McCoy as well as the mother of two beautiful McCoy Cowboys Mera who's an eighth grader and Leo in his fifth grade year at McCoy that makes this my ninth year as a mcoy parent I'm here representing three generations of leap families spanning over
08350 years grandparents who are leap teachers as well as former leapers who now have children of their own in the program Among Us are those who purchased homes just to be closer to the leap campus and those who wish to send their kids one day we have recent graduates that go on to attend top institutions in the Ivy Leagues and young professionals who have launched their careers in fields like science and engineering we would like to underscore that we are the living and breathing human data that demonstrate the power and promise of the LEAP program and I think you know we represent cfbd well with that said we would also offer as parents of leapers as well as gened students what your data may not be able to convey We Believe M McCoy is uniquely
084capable of blending our leap kids and our gened kids in a way that I don't think could work on another campus we are all one school and segregation truly is minimal you may be able to move our program but can you assure us that our kids will be able to learn and grow from each other anywhere else while we value the education they are receiving from our outstanding teachers their friendships and interactions with kids from diverse backgrounds and abilities are also our utmost concern as you know many districts including LISD mckin ISD Capel ISD and others our diverting are diverting resources to entice outof District transfers to make up for low enrollment without the unique environment provided at McCoy where the top 1% of CFB ISD Learners attend elementary school many Elite parents have already
085expressed that they are considering other closer campuses for many of us it truly is this special program at this special campus or nothing we will explore options including other school districts the elap parent group chat has already expressed major concerns over land Landry's taper scores teacher turnover rate and several have already stated they will not be continuing with leap if it is at Landry the concerns are multifaceted and Grave for the program Landry is too far south for many programs and you are abandoning many students to other isds you are sending kids from a 9 out of 10 school to a five out of 10 school which is unacceptable to the leap parents I could go on because there are many concerns but the overall message from the most involved highest performing group of elementary
086kids in this District is that this is unacceptable and we know our choices are many thank you thank you I would ask that we try to keep the process moving forward and uh with all the cheering and clapping I understand the emotion but if if we could slow that down just a bit it will make this process go a little more efficiently uh Brady Barnett is the next speaker thank you board president chman uh as a parent of a first grade student at McCoy Elementary uh and a property owner deeply committed to the well-being of our community the primary reason we bought here was mcoy elementary it is the number one draw protecting our property value safeguarding the high ranking in performing schools within our district is crucial for the growth and prosperity of our
087community and local economy we must prioritize the top rid schools the inventory of single family homes in DFW area is at highest level in years if enrollment numbers are a concern then this is an opportunity for our district to differentiate differentiate itself and attract young families to the area when considering purchasing a home the quality of Local Schools is a draw in Insurance on investment leading to increased property values enrollment and positive impact on the neighborhood's desirability however the consolidation and closure of highly rated schools can have substantial effects on residential property values resulting in a decline in property values and changes in the overall appeal of the neighborhood decreased home buyer demand School quality is a major factor in home purchases uh families will look elsewhere when highly rated schools close families reconsider moving
088into the area families in the area will move out of the area uh lower property value students show homes in uh studies show that homes in top rated districts command higher prices some 10 to 20% uh anyone that's had their hand uh their home on the market recently knows this in DFW it's a tough market right now and it's going to kill the property values neighborhood stability and appeal will and appeal will take uh a strong negative effect it will force homeowners to relocate okay my family being one of them uh we are zoned for McCoy we're proud uh to be zoned for McCoy this will force us out uh there will be a strong shift in socioeconomic demographics tax revenue and public services uh I believe the walper data is lazy misleading inaccurate without
089actionable future The Advisory Board is by designed to disassociate walart from the controversial decision the uh reason to engage walper needs to be reviewed and investigate it uh the final takeaway here review the data from walart and look into what the public sees on Zillow on every real estate app out there data from grade schools and from Niche McCoy is a top three in the district you must mitigate the impact or postpone the consolidation plan until proper uh evaluations by reputable uh consultants in a transparent manner uh the proposed plan fails to do this please protect McCoy Elementary thank you thank you Mr Bernett our next speaker is ARA Dean good evening you know last month I spoke to the board as a concerned parent Citizen and staff member of CFB and I am still
090concerned though that is not why I'm here today and I want it to be known to everyone that this speech that I'm about to make was a speech that I was going to make regardless of the outcome of the schools that were named for consolidation I was at the point in in my grief state of acceptance that if my school was closing my school was closing this is what we have to do um and so you know I'm here right now and i' I've had strangers already tell me like are you okay CU I'm crying you know and I'm crying because I'm feeling everybody's feels here right now this is not fun you guys aren't having fun we're not having fun none of us are enjoying this experience right and so I'm here to share
091my support to all of our school communi and to remind all of us here in this room that none of our schools deserve to be shuttered not a single one and our district was forced to make this decision and we must trust that this decision was made in our best interest and in our children's best interest so yeah we need to be angry all all of us need to be angry but we don't need to be angry at the board we don't need to be angry at the district but we need to be angry and upset about what brought us here today and we need to take that anger and we need to put it to use and the place for us to put it is what brought us here and that is our states
092refusal to adequately fund education and public education for all of us and for all of our children and so this is time for us every single one of our communities to come together to be one big family am I right I'm right and I'm sorry I hate hate hate the idea of anybody's school closing it is not fair is not fair to any one of us that this is happening but even though it's happening the one thing that we can control is how we love each other and so I am here for Forno I'm here for McCoy I'm here for Central I'm here for long I'm here for everyone and I hope that the rest of you join me and being one big family for all thank you thank you [Applause] m Miss Kim Crosley
093hi there as a resident of Carolton I find myself facing the real possibility that the actions of the Board of Trustees is causon Carolton to lose our high earning residents to provide more details to the beautiful geography lesson we got earlier today many of the elementary schools in Carolton are located in wellestablished neighborhoods it's the heavily involved in higher earning taxpayers that are at risk of leaving the district for better education opportunities I believe it is the placement of schools in neighborhoods that has been key to attracting outstanding citizens I want to acknowledge our trustees and the challenges you presented to us today and I would like the trustees to recognize the challenges they place on taxpayers for example we recently voted on a bond for $700 million and a portion of the funds was
094dedicated to the special ed program for roseme elementary while the district removed the sped program from roseme it is these kinds of actions that have people questioning the planning the budgeting of the trustees and which group of children children will be relocated next I hear the trustees when they say there is a deficient and one of the reasons is low student enrollment but after implementing the consolidation what are the trustees doing to retain and attract new students to get the budget you need I don't think closing schools is sending the correct message thank you thank you and our final speaker is Leighton [Applause] gamble president chackman Dr Eldridge and members of the board my name is Leon gamble y'all know me this is my son Noah gamble he's a fifth grader at McCoy Brock gamble
095you scoot up he's a first grader at McCoy this is my husband Nick Gamble and we have the teachers if y'all could stand in staff [Applause] um when thinking about the right words to say to you to describe what makes McCoy different than the other schools being considered for closure everything kept coming up Jeff shagu Jeff shagu has been a constent McCoy Elementary since 2009 that's 15 years he alone brought peace to my frazzled mind as the art for my son brought nothing but fear and anxiety the simple words of all things considered Mrs gamble this is just third grade Noah is a great kid and he is going to be just fine was exactly what my mom heart needed to hear in that moment and has brought peace that has resonated with resonated with
096me ever since throughout that year Jeff sh grew intill the love of not only learning but statistics problem solving and Star Wars in Noah Our Lives had been forever changed by him but here is where the magic lies he is not the only one that has been constant Mina shagu and Tiffany Joel both at koi Elementary 20 years Mrs Green 13 years Miss Talbot 9 years Miss John's and Miss kwood 17 years Mrs Canon 10 years Mrs aenor 23 years Mrs Petri 50 year 15 years Miss Wheatley 21 years coach sharp 20 years that is at least one teacher from each grade and specials representing tenure but it doesn't end there Mrs Walker 19 years and Mrs Hatcher 38 years these are teachers that spent their careers at Coy and have chosen to spend their
097retirement subbing for our students on a regular basis both in positions of long-term Subs this year but it doesn't end there Mrs Chamberlain 18 years Mrs kid 18 years Mrs Harrison 16 years Mr Williams 21 years it was Mr Williams silent service during Co that lit a fire in my heart for the appreciation of every unseen sacrifice that the staff standing and sitting before me makes there are a million more things that I could say that make these teacher special but their continued commitment to our school stands Above the Rest families change students leave but these teachers and staff remain you cannot recreate this magic anywhere else and that is why McCoy deserves to stay so that the future of this community can experience the magic of being a McCoy Cowboy thank you and yeaw
098[Applause] [Music] [Applause] thank you Miss gim this board faces challenging decisions we appreciate the input from those of you from our community and from various schools the next item on our agenda is our consent agenda and uh we will proceed to that uh the consent agenda is a mechanism that the board uses to approve a number of routine items uh with a single vote in compliance with the Texas open meeting ACT public notice for this meeting includes the list of all consent agenda items and the board has been provided ample information about these items in advance prior to any action taken on the consent agenda the board May request withdrawal of items for clarification or discussion board members is there anything that you wish to remove from the consent agenda prior to a vote we'll
099give them just a minute for a folks to get out of the way again thank you to parents and all for your attendance tonight again we'll go back to our consent agenda item uh is there anything that any of the board members any items that you wish to remove I see none is there a recommendation on a motion Miss Hatfield I move that we approve the consent agenda as presented I have a motion from Miss Hatfield is there a second second from Miss Brady any discussion board members hearing none and seeing none I will ask for a vote all in favor raise your hand opposed be did okay all right so did you get that M all right so we have approved and passed the consent agenda uh item six on our agenda is uh
100items for discussion or action there were no items removed from the consent agenda so we'll skip past 6A and we'll go to 6B uh it is regarding the upcoming general election and the adoption of an order for the election this item is marked for um approval for uh discussion and we will go forward is there a motion for this item Miss happel I move that we approve the matters related to the May 3rd 2025 General trustee election including the adoption of an election order thank you is is there a second uh yes arery thank you we have a board members is there any discussion if not see none all in favor raise your hand seven in favor no opposed let the record show that item 6B has been adopted a general election order number seven
101on our agenda is are there any comments from board members regarding posted agenda for tonight no okay uh it's been an interesting evening and I suspect next month's meeting will also be interesting when the vote is taking place uh thank you for your presence and your attendance and we have reached the end of our agenda and I am calling our meeting concluded at 8:43 p.m.