001all right good evening I call this pre meeting briefing of the Carolton Farmers Branch ISD Board of Trustees to order at 6: pm on today January 16th uh the purpose of this pre-meeting briefing is to conduct a session with the administrative staff regarding the posted agenda for the regular board meeting which is scheduled for tonight at 7 pm. board members present are terara habach Kim Brady Marjorie Barnes Carolyn Benavides Ilana garca roas Cassandra hfield and me I'm Randy shakman and we do constitute a quorum and will be conducting business on behalf of the district our second item on the agenda is audience for guests but there are none for this particular meeting so we will continue to move right on to agenda item three Dr elridge are there any reports by the administration and we
002have several reports tonight and first up is Sandra leak item 5G consider and approve the recommendations by the Sha for curriculum regarding topic of child AB abuse Family Violence Dating Violence and human trafficking so Sandra thank you Dr eldrich and Este steem board for the opportunity to address you on the behalf of sha um Senate bill nine of the 87th legislature requires school districts to offer curriculum regarding the prevention of child abuse in elementary and secondary Family Violence in elementary and secondary Dating Violence in secondary and sex trafficking in secondary um it also requires that parents provide consent before receive their students receive instruction on those topics um it also requires that the Sha assists with Senate Bill n curriculum recommendations and then the Sha recommendations are to be made at a public board meeting
003to trustees and votes are to be collected to approve curriculum adoption the following Shack members were appointed to the curriculum Review Committee and they met on October 8th to begin reviewing the materials uh they're listed um there on the slide and these are are the curriculum materials that were received from the CFB counseling department and um the links are there I believe that you've had the opportunity to review those materials so the committee um the curriculum committee um reviewed the materials that were provided by the counseling department and they met on September 26th and October 24th 202 for to discuss the materials and and vote the curriculum committee recommended that Shaq approve the curriculum as presented in the uh previous slide and Shaq has approved this curriculum as seeking board approval their recommendation is that
004the Board of Trustees approve the curriculum as presented is that a regular meeting approval or do you want that approval to take place here it's on the consent agenda right right it's in the consent agenda so we don't need to do anything other than approve it through the consent agenda questions bless okay any questions board Miss Lee thank you very much thank you okay our next item um for pre meeting is item five I with Aurora and it's consider An approved memorandum of understanding for our ghost Center work study student mentorship program with the University of North Texas Aurora yes hi everyone um I don't know if you remember my flyer that I created last time for the ghost Center so I just wanted to review that oh I'm sorry I'm sorry Dr shakman uh
005I mean Dr HRI Randy shakman president of the board um thank you for the opportunity to speak so sorry um today I'm just here seeking the consideration and approval for the memorandum of understanding for the ghost Center work um partnership um with the University of North Texas um we already have a partnership with tww and um we did have a partnership with UTD however they lost their funding with some changes in Dei so we had to seek another partnership um I've been working um for a little bit it's um just been a little lagging but we finally were able to come to a great mutually agree with um uh partnership with un so that they can now support um Ranch viiew High School um and uh Turner High School um ultimately this is just an
006opportunity to um have um you know Collegiate mentors um that come uh every week so that they can help students with college access um events uh College Prep uh test prep um we also um utilize these um uh college students to not just talk about un for example but they also talk about other colleges and help with those applications and essays great board members any questions this is a great program and a great support for the kids thank you for being involved thank you sorry thank you okay next up we have item 5 m and n and they're both with um Mr Blackburn and it's considering approv amendment number two to construction manager at risk contract with B for batty and the other one is Jackson Construction good evening Dr Eldridge Mr shackman members of
007the board it's good to see everyone um I believe the as you know the items before you involved two of the renovation packages for the 2023 Bond work the first one is for the remainder of package nine which uh I'll refer you to the handout you should have in front of you that gives you the context for the whole Bond you can see the various packages how we arrang the work so item m is package nine and that'll take care of everything else in that package uh the work in item nine specifically the summer will take care of some architectural work at Stark and mclin mclin Strickland Blair um and field middle school and then also item 5 n is the second phase of package two and that works work is specifically at Davis and
008Thompson uh you'll see one more piece is coming in package two and that'll be bllac but that's not quite ready yet and that'll be in the coming months any questions word qu Miss held uh one of these had a let me find where it was a refund attached to it or can you explain that a little bit more the way our Construction contracts are structured uh we set up a guaranteed maximum price and if that price is not uh if we don't spend all that money then they return that money to us and so in the earlier phase of the work they didn't spend all the money so they returning that money so we can spend it on the remaining phase in that package any other questions thank you Mr Blackburn appreciate it and it's
009good to see these program progress starting to get going that concludes our administrative reports board is there uh any questions or issues that we're going to pull from the agenda for regarding the consent agenda no see see none will present the yes um are either of the ones related to the calendar for um the actual missed school days I believe it's for the the finance piece of it but um for the actual like are we going to make up the days or not do we have a decision on that okay it is ex okay sorry thank you okay any other questions comments see none I believe we've reached the end of our agenda and so at 609 we're going to close this meeting and we'll see you back at e e e Brian to my
010desk please e e e good evening everyone I call this regular meeting of the Carolton Farmers Branch ISD Board of Trustees to order at 700 p.m. on January 16th 2025 board memb members District staff members and members of the audience you are free to join me in standing as Ivan Deon from the Heartland Church provides a message for us followed by the pledges of Allegiance margerie Barnes will lead us in our us pledge and Elana garar roses pledge to the Texas flag I invite you to stand let us pray Heavenly Father we thank you for this evening we thank you for your presence and your faithfulness Lord we thank you for those that you have called for this time to serve our community we pray for those that are here and those that couldnot be
011here in attendance we ask for a blessing over this body our community our families our children Lord we ask that you would protect them be with them I pray that you you would be present as we speak and prepare for the young lives that we are equipping for the Future Leaders doctors and Community contributors Lord will you just bless this time bless these grounds we pray this in Jesus mighty name and say Amen thank thank you as a district we dedicate all of our efforts and resources to our goal of high expectations for all the board uses this goal to guide all deliberations and actions you will get to see all deliberations decisions and actions of the board in open session with a few exceptions which may be discussed in the closed session and we'll
012describe that later as it would come up for the record board members president are margerie Barnes Carolyn Benavides Kim Brady Ilana Gara roas Cassandra Hatfield Tara herbach and I'm Randy shackman we constitute a quorum and may conduct business on behalf of the district and uh before moving on I would like to remind you that the board will accept citizens comments persons wishing to speak at audience for guest must have completed an online form for this purpose and have submitted it electronically by the deadline of 5:00 pm today when the board addresses agenda item three you will be invited to the podium to speak to the board our next agenda item is number two uh special presentations and recognitions uh first on the recognitions will be Karen Rodriguez good evening president sha shakman Dr Eldridge and
013members of the board through our partnership with Chick-fil-A at Trinity Mills we honor an individual with an A A CFB Champion award which recognizes individuals who demonstrate Excellence the January CFB Champion award is being presented to Janet Lee of DFW We Care a nonprofit organization that helps those in need and bridges communities you want to come up here at the start of the school year this incredible organization donated backpacks filled with all school supply list items for to every Central Elementary School student DFW Weare took its support to the next level by partnering with chairman of ACP foundation and the vendor of qtop USA Inc David Yen to donate 100 pallets of items such as tumblers hair accessories and party sets which not only benefited Central but various campuses and even the community DFW Weare
014continued to go the extra mile donating 12 additional pallets the week before winter break please join me in congratulating and thanking our CFB Champion Janet Le for your contributions selflessness and the impact your organization has made in CFB thank you so as we all know providing a safe and secure learning environment is Paramount in CFB and so every year uh we do give a CFB Sentinel safety award it is presented to one campus that implements Innovative measures dedicated to safety education this year's award recipient is Creek View High School look at that big trophy Creek View's winning projects were planned and sponsored by the student council and included initiatives like team in the driver seat assembly and safety fairs to raise awareness about the dangers of distracted driving four Carter blood care drives that resulted
015in more than 200 donations saving approximately 600 lives and Red Ribbon Week activities and informational booths to promote a drug-free lifestyle and educate about the dangers of alcohol and substance abuse congratulations to Creek View for being a shining example of amplifying student voices and putting Safety First [Applause] and each January we honor our school board members who selflessly serve our community our trustees are elected officials who devote time and energy to help all students and staff succeed these compassionate individuals dedicate themselves to this very important work and I will remind yall this is not a paid gig they're doing this out of the kindness of their heart so for our trustees we have a special presentation in your honor our CFB student ambassadors Calin Collins and Christine Lee from Newman Smith High School would like
016to make some remarks hello the 2025 Schoolboard recognition theme is leadership for tomorrow's Texas and this theme is particularly fitting for the seven individuals who serve on our CFB Board of Trustees we want to thank the school board for your dedication to making CFB ISD a place where we can learn grow and Thrive your commitment to education is inspiring the time and effort you put into listening to our voices and considering our needs does not go unnoticed you make us feel valued and heard and that motivates us to learn and be better citizens thank you for making tough decisions that ensure our schools are safe supportive and well-resourced resourced learning environments we know it's not easy but we see the positive impact in our classrooms and around campus trustees please stand as we announce your
017name so we can recognize you for your service to our FB family Randy shakman Tara her [Applause] herbach Kim Brady marjerie Barnes Carolyn benitz Elana roas and cassander [Applause] Hatfield and thank you once again from all of our CFB family our staff our students our teachers our uh secretaries everybody thanks yall for your work and for your dedication that concludes today's recognitions thank you so much I know all of my colleagues here on the board would share my thought that you are why we do this our staff is uh supportive and helps it make it possible but uh it as Mr R said it is volunteer position and we do it because we love education and students our next item on the recognitions is uh my monthly report and uh three things come to mind
018this month first of all I'd like for us to remember that it is January and as we are moving into January uh it's not very long till May 3rd which is the date for special election for community positions including Schoolboard if you've ever had an interest in running for the Schoolboard uh you must fill out an application to be on the ballot it would be submitted here at the district office and if you would like to talk to me or to ask any questions or probably any other member of the board but I will offer my services uh to talk and discuss with anyone who would like to know more about it I'd also invite you to turn to our cfbisd website where there is more information about elections and about cumulative voting which is
019a beast of a little bit different color that we use here within Carolton Farmers brand uh second thing that comes to mind as we're uh talking this month about a number of different things is that this Saturday the 18th is the annual Martin Luther King Jr uh parade it will start right behind City Hall on Marine waterer Lane work its way around Josie and down Keller Springs ending up at pulk Middle School uh what a wonderful Legacy Dr King has left us we want to be reminded of that wonderful Legacy and the parade starts at 10:00 we hope you will come out the weather's supposed to be pretty good there have been some years that it hasn't been but it is uh supposed to be pretty good and we look forward to a great day
020uh with that in mind I'd also like to give a shout out to H Christ Community Connection uh who is a nonprofit organization here in the area that every year helps to spearhead this project a final thing that comes to mind happened uh to me in the last uh days and weeks in my email box and my uh regular Communications box uh because it's become apparent that uh for some there is a concern that there has been a decision made about closing or cons consolidating local schools and I'd like to report to everyone that decision has not been made absolutely has not been made the board is involved in a study that is looking at how we should best utilize our resources how we should maximize efficiency to provide better high quality education uh for
021all students uh we are Rel line on uh expert demography expert uh space utilization uh Transportation studies all kinds of data and information because we believe every child deserves a good education and we want to make it possible and so uh you can go to our district website cfbisd.edu and there is a proposed timeline looking at how this decision is being made and what it is happening uh as it's being structured through so uh again a reminder to those who are concerned there has been no decision made nothing announced because there's nothing to announce and uh we're going to take care of every child and do our best to take care of uh education on behalf of CFB and uh that really brings me to the con inclusion of uh president's remarks uh we're ready
022for our committee updates uh board members would anyone like to give us an update on a committee meeting that you serve on um good evening um I had to type this out because we've done a lot so I didn't want to forget anything but um this is a report on the governance uh subcommittee um and serving on that with myself is Mrs Hatfield and Mrs Barnes um so since our last board meeting um the subcommittee uh met on December 12th January 2nd we had a meeting with um Brian Rush on January 9th for some additional guidance and we provided an informational briefing to the leadership team this morning January 16th um we've been focusing our work on the ongoing review of our policies our board operating procedures as well as the continued work on the
023review of our community developed CV 2030 uh plan and our goals I've left some uh information uh in the folder um and the your space on the dis uh for you uh the first is a summary of the policy and the operating procedure updates either identified um by the subcommittee or by board member request we're providing the summary so that you're aware of the progress and the status of the items uh you can see that the subcommittee has completed our work on multiple items and those have been submitted to Administration for initial legal review we expect the majority of these items will be included for Action at our February board meeting um and just I want to remind you if you see something in you know our operating procedures in policy if something comes to
024mind that you want us to look into or research um please send to me and we'll add it to that running list list and keep that list of status so everybody knows what's happening uh the second item is the draft of the indicators for strategic Priority One within our original Community developed uh collaborative Vision 2030 document this is to support later discussions on our um future goals um as I mentioned we provided a briefing to the leadership team this morning surrounding the board's intent uh with this review our process and a rough timeline to make them aware that we will need support certain points along the way this support would occur after the board has reviewed the indicators and would include us clarify and that support would include or discussion would include um clarifying any
025of those indicators specifying the data set uh that we're going to use and the actual Baseline and future year targets I do want to make you all aware that in order to push this forward for the 2526 school year we are working through a timeline for each steps of the pro um of the process this includes the board's review and work the work by the governance subcommittee administration review and support as well as collaboration with uh the DIC the district Improvement Committee in order to get all strategic priorities um there's six of them if you remember um through these steps we do anticipate the need for an additional two work studies but we will have that discussion and and determine the best path forward um speaking on half of the sub committee and y'all can
026correct me if I mistake the the sentiment but we're really excited about um all the work but specifically um the outcome and the end result that will support alignment uh from the board down to each of our campuses on what our goals are and how we can ensure the success of our students staff and District um this agenda item was uh update only and does not provide for discussion but if you have any questions um on those items please reach out individually to me and um we'll get that taken care of thank you you guys have been busy yes appreciate it other reports um we have a facilities finance and audit committee report we've met several times with Miss settle and I think Brian Marsh was also there for one of our meetings U discussing
027things like budget and um how we'd like to see budget reporting to the board at board meetings what we'd like her to focus on and just kind of what the board's thoughts are um we have several meetings upcoming for the remainder of the school year already planned and the audit committee met this afternoon before this meeting and she's going to have very happy news to report so I don't want to spoil the fun but I um did very well on the audit again so that's it thank you Mr bretty others M Ross good evening so on behalf of the legislative Committee just wanted to give you guys an update uh legislative committee consists of myself miss miss carollyn benas and Mr Randy shakman today Matthew Hall raise your hand Texas came to speak at our
028team CFB meeting this group consisted of 130 people including principes and department heads of cfbisd uh Matthew Hall provided the group with an overview of the legislative process beginning with a brief recap of the last session and explained how education fits into the overall legislative budget um he shared a timeline of of events leading up to the current session and out outlined actionable ways staff members can advocate for our district throughout his presentation he emphasized that every voice matters um The Hope is that we can do some additional advocacy work sometime in late in April you'll stay tuned for additional updates thank you uh Miss garer Rus you'll be happy to hear that uh during the reception time earlier today I was approached and some one of our staff members said they really enjoyed and
029appreciated learning the process of being a better advocate for public education so um good job thank you about that any other reports uh just to report the district Improvement committee met recently and they were a part of the process and helping to uh tailor and provide input on the calendars and then they also received an update on the district Improvement plan in small groups and the progress towards this year's goals and so um I'm the uh liaison for that and did watch that remotely um and so I just wanted to let you guys know that it looks like the district Improvement plan as District Improvement committee as always which is made up of our community members and a representative from every campus as well as District administration um continues to support the work of the
030district moving forward thank you Miss Hatfield anyone else then I believe the next item for us to take a look at is District announcements and for this I'll turn it over to you Dr idge okay we're all back Happy New Year I don't know when you stopped saying that but um this is our first meeting um in the new year and then we had our snow days and so I just we could not open schools have school schools prepared for all the things that happen when in Winter if it wasn't for our great maintenance and security workers who are you know sent me selfies and pictures and you know uh just showing what the snow look like and making sure our campuses are ready for when everyone comes back so you know it's so nice
031to have a crew that um where we're all in our homes warm they're out there and they're having fun doing it and they appreciate it so I wanted to give a shout out to them um a a great um if you go on one of our social media Pages you'll see a picture of Venita Crouch Venita is the PE teacher at laita and she is the um 2024 World Games athlete of the year she is the flag football quarterback and we need to all vote for her because she's doing a Super Bowl promo and if you cast your vote um you know she will be recognized and and she has done not only so much for our kids but she's also helping us with the effort heard of all our flag football initiative at our
032high school so you all vote for Vanita she's amazing um um Sheffield our Sheffield Elementary um campus was featured in The Time magazine for kids they are the only Texas school that was featured Mrs Pal's class was featured in there for spreading kindness and their service Bingo challenge so that just came out you can find it on timeforkids.com um and you know what would we do without a amazing teachers because at Farmers Branch um just this week on Tuesday one of our fifth graders um was choking at breakfast and she hopped into the the scene and saved our student and so we will be recognize her at one of the board meetings because you know often times you you when you're in a a cafeteria you don't know if kids are yelling or Screaming or
033having fun and the fact that you're you're excited to be in the cafeteria and you see our student and you go into action that is amazing and that's just you know the heartfelt of what all of our teachers do in many different jobs and then you can see this Jinga game over here now we're not going to play a game tonight but I want to give a shout out to miss Canada not only is she our board secretary but um she led the effort of training all of our secretaries in the district along with my Kim back there and um you know she um we call her bossy D but um um anyway uh so she put all these things um I didn't say for the last activity but I thought this was something to
034be shared that our principles and their secretaries sat together and they all filled out one of these Jinga blocks and they set a goal for each other and um I think that you know she put the ones up here this is RL Turners and Sandy and Chad said they want people to leave happier than they arrived isn't that a great goal and so each principal and secretary wrote a goal so if you want to see them um I just thought what a great activity to show that we're all working together because we want our community and our schools to be one big family for sure and make it happen um I want to also thank Stacy um Holman I know she's back there um the PTA Reflections was amazing last night and to see our
035talent among our students um and how she changed the order of the meeting and I know the principles were thankful because we do love honoring our students but we also value our teachers and our our our princip's time and it just ran seamlessly and I can't thank her enough for um her spirit and all there you are oh you do I was looking for you back there cuz we just talked back there but thank you Stacy you're you're amazing and she just told me she was going to do this again next year because I can't do it without you so I wanted to give you a shout out and the last thing is thank you to the board you know we you heard all the committee work that they do and so they have been
036at meetings all day long um and then they go to their job and then they come back and um we've seen each other a lot today but to serve on committees and and to really digest and want to know the work and approve the right work and want to do the right things that's what this board is and so I got a a note from uh Miss Hun's class kindergarten and I'm sorry Randy but she kind of left you out because she said she this is from the kindergarten class and they said we are all pretty but so I don't I don't know if you're pretty or not but you know we are all pretty and nice and they love us so you you know I I can't summ it up any better than uh
037we're all pretty Randy and so um I want to thank the kindergarten class cuz it really means something when our students um you know recognize the work that you all do because several of them asked me what does a Schoolboard is is it a skateboard or a Schoolboard it's a Schoolboard so you're trying to teach you know what we all do but the joys and our kids and our teachers and our staff so um thank you all and welcome back and we'll watch the weather because you never know it looks like snow again but we hope that the streets are clear so um thank you all that concludes the district report inner beauty shines through speeding Miss home and our next item is the report from PTA Stacy thank you and Dr alridge president chman
038and steam board um I'm Stacy hman I'm the president of the CFB Council of ptas this year and as always I want to start with the PTA motto which is is what we're all about to make every child's potential Reality by engaging and Empowering Families and communities to advocate for all children um I know this was announced last month but we officially received the council Golden Apple yesterday for those that don't know that means every member of our school board Dr Eldridge and her staff are all members of PTA in our district so personally on behalf of myself the almost 6,000 PTA members across 38 36 campuses that we have in in our district thank you very much for your support for PTA it is not common across the state I will say we are
039one of the few councils that consistently gets the golden apple and the fact that I get to talk or someone from the board talks here every month is almost unheard of most ptas get one or two addresses a year so thank you very much for your support for what we do for our community um as far as membership we encourage every local PTA to strive for the welcome back award you'll receive that if you re get just 10 new members in the month of January if every campus gets us 10 new members we'll come close to exceeding our membership from last year as a council um I want to thank everyone who came out to our reflection ceremony last night we awarded 105 talented students with um with Awards with 21 of our students being
040their submissions being submitted to Texas to compete at the state level um the theme next year is I belong so get ready start thinking about what you're going to do for the artwork next year and being on the committee because it's a lot of work and I'm really tired um it is election season so we are have our nominating Committee in place at the council level I know a lot of the ptas are also working on getting their boards together we will have Google interest forms out starting next week if you or someone on your campus wants to take a role at a at a level at the council level um we'll have descriptions what's there and please come out and uh if you don't want a chair or a VP or whatever position we
041have a lot of um committees that you can serve on and get involved at a higher level in the district okay our spring training Extravaganza will be at the Waton Center on February 22nd from 9:00 to 12 we will have babysitting available we encourage you all to come out and get training on all the things that we need for the close of the year so elections and nominating committees and financial reconciliations and all the fun stuff we need to do to close out our year um if you have anyone on your local campus that may be interested in being on your local boards or want to understand some of these positions they can come out this is an open event for anybody so they can come out and see what things are about see if
042they might be interested in doing something um we have a big Community event coming up on March 1st it's called Patrol stories it is a promotion of student safety by fostering a positive Community relationship with our First Responders it's geared towards k through eight it's a lot of uh police officers that do this on the side they get in costumes and they hype the kids up and stuff we will have a link to a video on what that event is about it will be hosted at Newman Smith um ticket information is coming soon we have Rally Day coming at the end of February that is when all of the ptas across the state converge on Austin to advocate for public Public Schools uh we are looking at different types of possible Transportation options from us
043from the district but um we will have more information we're setting up meetings with legislators leg legislators that are amongst our CFB community so we can talk to them directly so hopefully some people will feel like getting up really early and driving down to Austin um now it just we are ready for our December awards every month we give Awards to campuses that have met challenges for December we did a winter event award and we are recognizing um for their reindeer run Perry Middle School uh who worked in conjunction with Carolton and Central elementaries they did the event together so if you guys want to come up representatives from those three campuses so Perry Carolton and Central so thank you very much this was a great thing where're Middle School partnered with the two elementary
044schools and put on a really good event for our kids um in February instead of doing a January challenge at the February board meeting we'll be recognizing all the campuses that receive the Golden Apple for their campus which is every staff member being a member of PTA on the campus so that's what we'll do for recognition in February and with that thank you very much thank you Miss hman appreciate it and our final but definitely uh the the old saying least but uh last or whatever uh Donna wall the Education Foundation one of the ESP special things happening thank you good evening Dr yeah now we're on President shakman and esteemed school board members I want to take an opportunity to along with the school district and others um thanks school board members for your
045service during school board recognition month we are so grateful for you all each and every day so thank you very much in December we were excited to report a donation to the school district for a bundle of innovative grants I don't know if you remember A lot's happened since then but we were a little bit reserved kind of buttoned up and a little bit quiet about uh the details of those grants and well here's why yesterday in our annual tradition of surprise campus and classroom Grant reveals we awarded grants to nine different campuses slash centers and locations to 20 different recipients it's a huge big deal we're so grateful uh to be able to uh award these Innovative grants the Innovative Grant reveal day code name will change it for next year code name operation
046Capricorn is our most highly regarded secret event communicated on a need to know basis strictly uh recipients were caught by surprise when the group of revelers started the parade down the hallways with balloons and noise makers and tambourines and lots of shouting and cheering um the band of revelers included members of the Ed Foundation members of the school board our superintendent district senior leaders donors and Community Partners I will say that it is humbling to have the opportunity to recognize and thank our Educators and leaders and know that these projects and these programs will make a difference in the lives of so many CFB students for so many years to come Additionally the day gives us a chance to think about how we can continue to serve and to thank all of our CFB family
047Educators and staff our Educators bring Innovation to our classrooms daily and in our eyes all Grant uh writers all Grant candidates are winners now is a good time for me to plug the Education Foundation Grant and there are three things of course three things to remember one the foundation offers multiple ongoing grants uh number two those grants are available year round and number three the biggest of all they're available to all CFB employees as always we hope you'll stay tuned uh and watch for us on social media we still have some additional January surprises uh that we've got up our sleeves that I'm sworn to secrecy this concludes our report and thank you thank you Mrs Bal there's nothing quite like bouncing Down a Bumpy Carolton Street in an old yellow dog bus and getting
048to give away money so we we had a great day yesterday fun it's the best day ever it was a great day thank you uh if there is anyone that would need to step out and and leave the meeting this would be a good time to do that before we move to our next agenda item the next item posted on our agenda is audience for guests uh persons wishing to speak at audience for guests have filled out an electronic form submitted it online uh prior to the deadline today which is always five o'clock before meetings uh Miss Canada we have three forms that have been submitted uh before we begin I will remind our audience that members of the board are not allowed under Texas open meeting law to respond to public comments Direct ly
049uh they will address any in agenda items uh when they are listed on the agenda so the first person that going to speak uh that is coming up we'll have three minutes which which to speak there's the timer and first speaker is Anna ado [Applause] good evening my name is Anna Ado and I'm proud to represent Rose me Elementary PTA this evening as its board president I'm aware the board cannot comment or respond to any questions that may be posed this is a hard time for many and the emotional tolls already made an impact it's going to get harder still first tonight I'll address District communication and timeline failures regarding fiscal and Facilities concerns it can be better and we beg you to hear our please for more additionally I'll speak to the magic and
050culture of rosem meat Elementary it's unmatched and unmovable it's wide reaching and cannot be replaced this is a hard time the district message of don't worry no campuses have been named has been ineffective and out of touch it's taking too long and your families have been left in the dark until very recently regarding potential closures and plans for what happens next you waited too long and your families are going to Bear the stress of last minute change and emotional conversations with children who will struggle to understand the wise we need you and we need more acknowledge that this is a hard time for all of us communicate more and with more transparency you do not have to have all the answers have a plan how are transfers going to be handled one once the report's
051presented will families have options will we have suggestions how will you comfort our beloved teachers and staff once campuses are announced we implore you to have a plan in place immediately upon release of the report do not wait to communicate with your families until after listening TOS it's too late we need your leadership we need your comfort we need you to acknowledge the concerns face them headon and be better prepared about roseme when reviewing your data driven reports is to the facilties master plan recognize that there is more to a campus than hard data there are staff members at roseme who have welcomed welcome their hearts to students for over 25 years there are families who have worked tirelessly to carry on our tradition of once a Road Runner always a Road Runner for literally
052generations of families please look into your own data as it relates to transfers into roseme over the past three years we've seen our numbers go down and yet we hear from parents who were zoned for that school that even they had to jump through hopes to get their child into prek because roseme was full though class sizes are not maxed roseme Elementary has the highest number of in District transfers of any CFB Elementary School there's a discrepancy here when the data shows declining enrollment but families continue to want to transfer to roseme year after year and are facing roadblocks and being turned away roseme has never been assigned a program of choice though we still maintain transfer numbers higher than those of most elementaries in the district even higher than campuses withies the reputation the
053tenured staff the consistent high performance and that special rosem me magic continue to draw families to our school year after year we're a very proud PTA made up of hundreds of parents ready to help ensure the flame of that roseme magic stays Al light and remains strong our parent involvement in active PTA makes us uniquely prepared to support a large number of transfer students the magic of roseme can't be replicated it cannot be scooped up and easily placed at another campus I humbly request you consider the intangible as you prepare to make some very difficult decisions we ask that you not only look at the data points but consider consider the Community Network and involvement support systems for the district and a high functioning team of parents and teachers that would be dissolved by a
054closure of a campus like roseme instead remember that roseme is full of teachers and parents who make it their Collective mission to not only welcome newcomers but also bring them into our culture introduce our traditions and make sure every family in staff person knows that they have a place and a part in making Rose me a unique place where we all learn and a place where we can all grow thank you thank you [Applause] Mr our next speaker is Arya Dean tonight I speak to the board as a concerned parent Citizen and staff member of CFB carrying the weight of questions concerning and responsibilities not just for my family but for the communities that we all serve we understand that school consolidation is inevitable declining enrollment the rising cost of living the expansion of school
055choice voucher programs in the state's refusal to adequately fund public education have left District like ours with few Alternatives consolidation is more than adequacy and utilization it's about people it's about our students our families our communities and we deserve better than being left in the dark the facility planning Advisory Group was formed in Fall of 24 with three meetings by the third meeting the group came to a consensus on criteria used for recommendations for col consolidation but did not disclose this to the public this was on December 4th on the evening of December 9th Lewisville ISD school school board voted to close five elementary schools on the morning of December 10th a concerned CFB parent started change.org petition regarding a CFB neighborhood schools uncertain future and posted it on social media in the afternoon of
056December 10th the neighborhood school was informed that the superintendent would be filming a super segment at the school on December 12th the super super segment was filmed at the neighborhood school and the superintendent assured staff that their school is not closing on December 18th CFB publicly announced the facility planning Advisory Group on its website on December 19th the super segment was posted on social media this timeline of events could be coincidental or it may be an effect of the district's lack of transparent communication inducing fear distrust rumor spreading and a deep sense of insecurity within the CFB Community the current timeline States the board will vote on March 6th but we should have more information by now our communities need our communities need answers quickly because these decisions impact our futures parents must make choices
057about school transfers um schools and their transfers commutes and teachers must make choices on their careers and no one can plan when critical information is unavailable what will happen to our children's education our careers our cultures our neighborhoods our communities we deserve transparency and swifter timelines the impact of consolidation on our most vulnerable po populations cannot be understated what is the district's plan to ensure students with disabilities are supported throughout this transition the district failed to be transparent during the 24 special education program consolidation families were informed of program changes in school relocation via a letter in the mail after summer had already started disrupting their lives without proper preparation or support during this time what safeguards will the district provide to prevent further harm to these marginalized children and their families the the district
058is not able to avoid consolidation but they are able to openly communicate and transparently communicate regarding this process so this is a moment for CFB for us to lead with Clarity empathy and care to provide the support and resources needed so that our children not only survive this transition but thrive in the future that our district is helping to shape thank you thank you Miss K our last speaker is Annette Reese good evening deadle branch is an offshoot of the Elm Fork Trinity River when I refer to Dudley Branch tonight I will be speaking specifically about the creek that runs behind Creek View High School and next to Timber Creek Park this is a bag of 100 tennis balls these 100 tennis balls are just a part of the 1,21 tennis balls collected from The
059Dudley Branch Creek bed since I started reporting trash picking efforts with the city of Carolton in December of 2021 the over 1,000 tennis balls collected behind Creek View doesn't include the more than 200 tennis balls collected Downstream a few more numbers related to Dudley Branch there have been 17 documented trash picks using 41 volunteers with a total volunteer time of between 65 and 75 hours and collecting 112 bags of trash along with many large items like five white barrels that had chemical warning labels on them Car and Bike Tires large canvas coolers sports bags and even most recently a portapotty door Administration of Creek View High School was contacted by City about the problem in February of 23 and again in February of 24 with this collaboration between the administration at CHS and the city
060the amount of trash behind Creek View High School has subsided somewhat additionally after speaking with Mr sulac recently I feel confident there will be a greater cleanup efforts going forward however based on the two trash picks this month that yielded 15 trash bags and 32 24 tennis balls the problem has not subsided enough and requires more attention and greater efforts so far the cleanup efforts have been reactive to truly address the problem I am here tonight to solicit your help with taking a more proactive approach to the amount of trash invading the deadly Branch ecosystem please consider putting some type of barrier between the mool line and the natural cured bed to prevent trash from getting into the creek this barrier will not only hold back to the trash trash but will make it much
061easier for organizations like the Creek View Community Service club that has an adoptive spot at that area to pick up the trash it would be great to have get the school Community involved in these efforts not only to be more proactive but to help mitigate the cost to do so Eagle Scout projects athletic booster clubs city council woodworking construction biology classes could all provide knowledge time and materials thank you for your time and I look forward to a resolution that addresses the trash problem from a more proactive view that allows greater sustainability for deadly Branch not only behind Creek View but Downstream as [Applause] well miss Reese thank you very much and this concludes our audience for guest portion our next agenda item is item four non-action items for discussion first up is uh Financial
062update we're going to turn things over to uh Miss Carlo s good evening president shakman Dr Eldridge and members of the board I wanted to take this month's Financial update as an opportunity to give a highlevel review of the budget process process as it kicks off this um or rather ramps up this uh semester uh it is intended to be a discussion uh that might Inspire questions that arise for the following meetings and in light of the legislative session commencing on the 14th um I would just like to remind the district we should be cautious on building a budget of on hope that public education might see any of the 24 billion dollar of the State Surplus a key understanding of the cfbisd funding is that the majority of the state funding passes through the
063school Finance formula 95% of the spendable p is controlled by the state funding template in order to create a balanc budget Revenue projections are determined and expenditures have to be adjusted to that pi I want to remind everybody the school funding formula is like a glass of water the state determines the size of that glass and the district does not get any say on how big the glass is needed filling the glass is a shared responsibility between the state and the district if the district overfills the glass with their local property taxes then the district remits those funds back to the state commonly known as recapture another dimension of that piie factors in special student characteristics that make tier one per student VAR in comparison between State and peer districts and at the end of
064the day the only way to increase the p is to increase the number of students frequency of attendance or increasing our local tax rate and of course legislative changes that we hope bull we are are hopeful to see realized in May the last change from Austin that we saw occurred in 2020 but since then the Consumer Price Index has increased an additional 24.6% since 2019 the state's basic formula funding per student has not changed and again just like everything else one of the most critical factors is students just like our goals start with students the pie is driven by enrollment and how often they attend school our most recent demographers projections so show a slow steady decline which as a CFO Who projects but uh Revenue I appreciate uh much like my neighbors uh it's
065much sharper however we are probably in our last year of 24,000 students and I updated this uh Trend in our fund balance based our on our most current audit uh in previous years uh towards the right of the graph you can see at the very bottom we've enjoyed a very healthy fund balance uh some years all the way up to six months however as we continue to adopt budget deficits that does cut away at that heal healthy fund balance and so the time for strategic move is this year maybe so let's move forward with our budget calendar um first of all our budget roles and responsibilities they're driven just like our goals for vision 2020 um everything um is passes from the board's expectations all the way down to the budget managers so Board of
066Trustees you are in the middle of the vision 2020 of 2030 process and as the leadership team we will analyze requests and be strategic that whatever we put in front of you aligns to those priorities uh you know we'll work with all the budget owners this spring uh and at the end of the day my team will make sure that the pi is accurately projected and that we comp compile a budget and hold the line on balancing that budget you've seen this calendar before and I'll probably include it on every Financial update so you can see um I'm a methodical checklist person so I love to see a gray section uh when we've completed that so in January we are in the throws of instructional budget planning um then we progress to our department budget
067meetings and uh as soon as Miss hul adopts a or presents her calendar we can finish our payroll calendar development uh next month we'll start on Staffing and start developing our payroll snapshot which is 80% of our budget uh and then we will review non-payroll with our budget owners we have a lot of other uh projects going going on in the spring but we have a zero focus on presenting a balanced budget at the end of the year so uh just wanted to make sure you heard that commitment um before we uh the finance committee meeting had uh committee update had mentioned that we do have several meetings schedule for this spring where we will be reviewing the components of of what drives a budget development and so after the May Finance committee meeting we
068hope to present uh the preliminary budget draft in June and that is my presentation great thank you Miss subtle board members do you have any questions um I was going to ask about the uh fund balance do we have a minimum requirement for that because I can see the trend downwards yes ma'am um the state through the first report recommends that you keep at least two months of fund balance but the the board policy recommends three thank you and just to clarify on that especially to those who are watching online or whatever A month's worth of fund balance is how much uh I apologize I didn't write that down but you take the entire budget of operating expenditures and you divide it by 12 so depending on the size of your pie that year it
069can vary thank you one trying to put you on the spot no worries other questions board members yes Mr Caron and I know we were in that audit committed Comm meeting earlier today so my question is speaking of the general fund um locally other CFOs other areas I know this is not just an emphasis on CFB their General funds are looking like uh yeah unfortunately we have a lot of neighbors that are living with a one to two months fund balance and uh there are even districts in Dallas County that will be in in crisis mode and borrowing for payroll because that is the state of school F school funding um this year here thank you for that information you're welcome Miss headfield um I just want to add on to that that it is
070been a commitment of this board that we are not to get in that place that is not for our community and will not be acceptable which is another reason why we are making strategic decisions to carry this District forward you can even see in the fund balance we got up towards to six months um because we were cautious and careful and conservative to hold the line to make sure we had extra in there um but we have to take care of our staff and to be able to take care of our staff and have high quality Educators we have to pay them a livable wage to the best of our ability um and so we're going to have we have to make some tough decisions because we can't let our fund balance which like that's
071the district savings account our savings account must stay whole um and so we're we have to make some tough decisions and we have the Dr Eldridge and her team the budget mitigation strategies that they've put in place and shared with the board they've made a very diligent effort to cut expenditures so I want to thank you for that um and then I also just wanted to highlight I really appreciate that we are going to receive the Staffing ratios in the April meeting um I think that's something that's very important for us to see um what the plan is on the student to teacher ratio um we all know that instruction is where the real magic happens and so I appreciate the attention to showing us the Staffing ratios see no other questions thank you Miss
072s we appreciate the information uh next up uh Chris Moore facilities Master Plan update thank you Mr shackman trustees Dr Eldridge um tonight I wanted to review the facilities planning Advisory Group um specifically the criteria how it's being used where we are in the timeline uh in the uh evaluation process and then a high Lev touch on how we're supporting our our parents and our staff um but before we begin I wanted to uh to just the advocacy that we saw before that's greatly appreciated I mean that that part of the process that we're looking at that tells the story it speaks volumes to the individual experiences of of people and families and students and teachers here in the district at their campuses and and that is something that we take great pride in that's
073something that we Embrace and that's something that we are looking to uh not just preserve but to expand and bring to other campuses uh through maximizing our efficiencies um before I get into the specific criteria um I know uh October and November were the last two times um that we we spoke at this board meeting about the facility planning Advisory Group so I kind of wanted to to back up and reset um the um the the planning Advisory Group of course it was it was comprised of um 86 people is where it began we solicited each of our campuses each of our principls for teachers for PTA members for parents for business owners for community members because we wanted them to be part of the process so it could be open so it could be
074transparent so we could get their feedback from the outset uh to have an open door so we could um get that criteria get that feedback that is H the formation of this facilities planning Advisory Group um and the purpose you see there uh it was to set the criteria for us to go in and assess and make our portfolio decisions to uh to set that criteria so we can compare it to our buildings to our campuses so when we're looking at these pieces and really from that yearlong study of the the wer data capacity utilization uh so we could look at take that criteria assess it against our portfolio and bring those recommendations uh to you uh to you as the board We Set four meetings from the outset you see the three check boxes
075on October through December and that is because the committee was very very diligent we got done in three uh we did not need that December 18th meeting um and so um that allowed us an extra two weeks before we got on break to begin looking at that criteria and comparing it to uh what we were were looking at with our facilities and our our demography support and all that information um meetings two and three shifting specifically to the criteria of course meeting one that was October 30th and that was kind of setting the stage the the who what when where why and how of where we got to forming this committee and the year-long study that went into it the 8 n month study rather uh with the with the um uh capacity utilization EDS
076Etc um and then in meeting two or three meeting two and three we focused um on the on the criteria um meeting two analyzing the data uh and beginning that that criteria development um um table work wall charts Gallery walks um that was the Deep data dive meeting it was clear meeting one people were ready to look at things and get into it and meeting to is where we dove into that data uh to really begin looking at the criteria meeting two is where we established those four uh categories you see condition and adequacy cost for Quality location and utilization meeting three uh it was solely focused on gaining consensus on the criteria um the way we did that was focusing within each of those categories and there were really two um two conditions that
077we were looking at we wanted to look at considerations and desired outcomes within each of those four areas condition and adequacy um keeping in mind with the condition and adequacy of the building that's the age that's alignment with current teaching practices a building that was constructed in 1956 does not take into consideration things that are in play today in 20123 uh the cost for Quality the the Staffing levels prioritization of of location program alignment um the location of the facilities themselves um serving all the areas of the neighborhoods that it's around within its feeders and its zones and then the flexibility of the site how the site can be accessed any one-off consideration safety different pieces and then utilization and again that's a districtwide focus not just the individual school so because it's got to
078work in the whole District's premise in order for the for the utilization to to be to be effective and so um what I did for the for for the purpose of tonight meeting I focus solely on the utilization pulled out utilization and this is what we did at that third meeting um we took each again each of those four categories looking at utilization uh we uh worked uh with uh with our uh folks who were there guiding the meetings wper that gather the data they helped guide through these as well uh and when within each of those four categories we looked at a desired outcome and we looked at a consideration some of those four categories had four to five desired outcomes and four to five considerations within them utilization specifically had one desired outcome
079and those three considerations um utilization the target was 85% utilization districtwide amongst all of our all of our facilities um and plan for minimum campus utilization at 75% and a maximum utilization at 90% those were the desired outcomes those were the guideposts if you will uh from the from the Advisory Group for utilization and then some of the specific considerations that they that they wanted to uh add into the uh to the documentation was to ensure within that utilization that the classrooms capacities are adjusted for programmatic needs special ed newcomers this is a district where we have seven seven to to eight nine% of our students are newcomers uh so again a classroom constructed in 1956 uh is not going to take into account everything that we do to teach all of our students Today
080Counseling needs special education needs so just because we're looking at a Target Target capacity of 85% doesn't mean we're just going to force kids into rooms uh that aren't set for that uh that was a consideration balance the enrollment across the district if we're going to Target these utilization numbers there needs to be balanced enrollment um enrollment caps uh rezoning uh which the demographers information that you all received in December is key piece of that uh managing the transfers within that aspect of things in order to balance out the capacity that would was a consideration um and then it was clear that they wanted to that Advisory Group wanted to prioritize maining the maintaining the High School feeder patterns um and so we looked at that again in each of those four categories uh those
081were the desired outcomes and the considerations with the utilization after we as a group discussed those things after The Advisory Group discussed those things it was it was put to a vote uh we established a criteria framework um looking within each of those categories uh and that was the question posed to the to to the uh to The Advisory Group members that night do you support the desired outcome listed for condition and adequacy listed for cost for Quality um in each of those categories and you can see um 97 U 93 93 and 98% no there was no um no support less than 93% within each of those four categories uh by the individuals who were there at uh who were there uh that night to wrap it up and so um we um again
082kudos to that group for for uh getting done in that third meeting because it allowed us two more two more weeks before we went on winter break to begin diving into this folding it into um the facility uh information the capacity utilization Ed specs all of those pieces that we looked at for the a or n months prior um and begin coupling that and folding that into the demographers information because that was an extensive report um and so that was um that was what we were able to do in concluding that uh piece uh one week or or two two uh two weeks early rather and so kind of the next steps where we are currently January we're in that obviously in February we're going to continue putting together um comprehensive is an understatement uh
083the materials development that we're looking at um the combining that with the capacity utilization combining that with the Ed specs the year-long assessment combining that um with the demographers information um remember that that a big portion of this when you're discussing uh consolidations um certainly there would be rezoning around any campus that is Consolidated but we as a district had not rezoned in upwards of 20 years and so the rezone expands Beyond just the um just the Consolidated campuses um and so that's how we We've Ended up with with counts of Elementary that are that have more students than middle schools middle schools that have more counts of students than high schools and so looking at all those pieces is an intricate fold into it um and then combining that into a package that can
084be understood and explained by all in preparation for that February 6th board meeting uh the week of February 6 uh notifying the principles at the campuses uh that were that have been identified for consolidation getting with them one-on-one explaining um the the process the what looks like moving forward hearing their concerns sharing uh the support that they're going to receive um from them one-on-one so they can process it in anticipation of that February 6th board presentation and by the way these are the next steps that that that were shared this morning um at the uh Team CFB so all the principes are aware of this this is a third or fourth time that we've visited with them about it we've tailored it every time these were the next steps we talked about um February 6
085board presentation that is an information only meeting there is no vote at that meeting that is where the materials and all of the package will be shared uh again to to talk through and walk through how we got where we got uh and answer uh the questions in the presentation the morning of Friday February 7th we'll have faculty meetings uh we will split up as a uh superintendent leadership team go to the campuses that are impacted be there before school to visit with them with the principes the teachers and the staff reassure them talk to them hear their concerns reassure them um of of the next steps in the weeks of February 10th and February 17th uh we're going to have campus listening tours at the campuses impacted for the families for the parents uh
086to to hear their concerns um hear their thoughts share the process and explain things to them and then March 6 uh we will take that information that's gathered at those feedback tours and um we'll come back back to you as a board on March 6th um for the uh recommendation uh and that would be a meeting where we would um go for a formal vote um there's what have we done to this point as far as I just wanted to to to revisit what what we shared um we've had communication channels that have gone out from the district um each of the campuses has has posted via their social media uh We've utilized parents quy menley uh We've developed the Standalone website um for um facilities planning for future success uh it's on our website
087linked from our homepage uh that is where uh there's a current active list of FAQs there that is the site that we will update uh as this uh gets underway after the 6th um and so that the dates and the information there um we have um created a standalone email ask CFB um at CFB edu for feedback we've created a hotline for parents to call um because in this day and age we want to communicate as much as we can we also know that there's a lot of mistruths and things that can get out there and so we want this to be the Standalone site if you want the information if you want the details you want the dates you want the timelines you want all of those things it's right there um easily accessible
088um and on from our from our website and through our social media platforms um just one one final note um to just kind of touch on one thing that I do want to make clear is that we we're going to support all of our families and all of our staff that no doubt this is a challenging topic U no doubt we are not alone in any of this um but there is no doubt that we want everyone not to just hear but to believe and to feel and experience the support that we are going to um to give them uh change is change is hard and it can be hard when you're transitioning School communities we want to welcome everyone from a from a from a campus that that may be Consolidated into their new
089into their new campus um we have plans in place for that throughout the spring to open the doors learn the mascot new learn the traditions of the new campuses preserve the traditions and the sanctity of the of the of the former campuses um we're putting together resources to help parents have discussions with their children uh how to talk about and transition through change um explain the process of of what the rezone looks like explain the process of of what registration looks like explain the process of what transferring looks like um and and all of that will be uh will be clear and readily available as part of that uh February 6 presentation um and um you know that's mirrored for Staffing uh had a really good conversation with the principal this afternoon after team CFB
090uh one of the principls who was on the um the Advisory Group and U got some good feedback reaching out from her happy to share and anticipation of the questions that the teachers may ask the staff may ask so we've already engaged with other principles on that committee uh to to ensure that we answer as many questions and and relieve as much angst and and and U concern as possible so um that's again just an overview of where we were with the criteria and kind of the next steps and the processes uh and with that I will answer take any questions you might have thank you Mr Moore challenging but important thank you thank you board members questions Hatfield thank you Mr Moore for the presentation um and the additional information um definitely some needed
091information for parents you mentioned um in your timeline you have the board vote on March 6th but you also mentioned on February 6th we'll have the presentation information only and that you guys are developing materials um at what point will parents see that information about if your campus were to be retired then this will be the process will they get that information after February 6th there will that information go live on March 6th after we present to you all it will be live to parents okay so parents will have that month to start to begin processing and thinking and prepare themselves for that vote okay yes ma'am thank you um what about and you said fact leing staff and this is going to be central office in service of Campus you guys are going and
092will be active in that yes ma'am okay wonderful um I think that's all I have thank you for the information um I think the mental health aspect is critically important so I really appreciate the attention to detail and ensuring that we're thinking ahead and I think that releasing information to parents so that they can begin thinking and processing and preparing for their pathway beginning um after the February presentation is important so I appreciate that thank you Miss safield Board other board M garer roses and just to Echo Miss Hatfield um can we just as a district make sure that we do notify our parents a lot of our parents don't receive some of our parents square or not on social media to stay alert to what's going on so as long as we have an
093effective plan and ensure that communication is presented to our families that would be great thank you yes ma'am we we are in lock step with the Communications Department heavy heavily involved in that thank you thank you very much other questions I see none Mr Mor thank you very much good presentation board members here in my notes is the question do you want to take a break do we want to take a five minute break or do we want to just press through okay let's press through if you are here and you need to or want to choose to leave I'd encourage you to do so at this time okay we will go ahead and proceed with our agenda and we are now at uh item five our consent agenda the consent agenda is a mechanism
094that the board uses to approve a number of routine items together together with a single vote in compliance with Texas open meetings act the public notice for this meeting includes a list of all consent agenda items and the board has been provided information about all of these items in advance prior to any action on the consent agenda board members May request withdrawal of individual items for clarification or discussion uh board members is there any qu any uh interest in removing any item no we're g to proceed with the consent so I'm ready to accept a motion Miss Hatfield I saw to the left eye first I move that we approve the consent agenda as presented you want to Bray a second we have a a motion and a second to approve the consent agenda as
095presented board members are ready to take a vote um so all in favor please raise your hand none opposed so miss Canada you got those numbers for us okay uh item six on our agenda is uh disc discussion items or action items it would start with the re uh dealing with any agenda items removed from the consent agenda there were none so we'll bypass 6A and go to 6B uh consider and approve the district's annual comprehensive Financial package I'm back president shakman and Dr Eldridge members of the board um you know a a financial audit actually starts three years in advance whenever you develop a budget uh and then you kick off the year and um by the time the year is closed and you have another five or six months that you uh complete
096the audit and so for this product and uh that uh Tovar our partner with Whitley pin is going to present I just wanted to take one quick moment uh to recognize some folks who really don't like recognition um but Patty espanosa our director of accounting and our director of budget Carla staty they are an intrical part of the success of the audit every year and so U I just want to publicly thank them right and now I'll turn the mic over to Roger tore good evening Board of Trustees Dr elridge um as Carla mentioned uh my name is Roger Tovar I'm an audit partner with Whitley pen we're a CPA firm um here in the state of Texas we work with uh quite a few school districts across the state um and uh we were
097engaged to perform the audit for your fiscal year 24 um do have a presentation that goes over that audit and those results uh as I'll start off with the uh the purpose of the audit so the purpose of the audit at the end of the day uh is to uh to issue an opinion on your financial statements uh as you can see on the screen there's uh there's a few options there uh that we can issue uh or we can have a disclaimer uh and whenever that whenever that's the case that you know we come in we'll start the audit there's really nothing to corroborate the information at that point that's that's with when the disclaimer kicks in uh qualification qualified opinion is another option um and that's typically when there's a depart a departure
098from Gap or there's a scope limitation of some kind um and at the very bottom there you see the unmodified opinion um that is the the clean opinion the the the highest level of assurance that you can obtain on your financial statements as far as the audit process uh it is a long process for the audit uh so we'll start with the with the planning phase of the audit that includes a risk assessment uh that risk assessment is going to drive uh the audit and it's going to determine what kind of audit procedures we're going to be performing um then we'll look at your internal controls as a whole uh from those internal controls we're going to identify the key controls uh from those key controls we might uh test some controls in detail uh
099we might perform walkthroughs over other key uh key controls uh and then once we perform that testing uh we'll move over to the substantive testing which is uh testing your actual account balances um and so those audit procedures are going to be determined on the prior two steps uh and then we'll that leads over to the final step there which is uh where we are today issuing an opinion on the financial statements as far as those internal controls that I mentioned earlier um based on that risk assessment you can see on the screen here there uh these are the controls that we consider to be significant to the to the district uh so we have other revenues mainly uh the revenue generated in Your Child Nutrition fund uh we also have your non-payroll and then
100um obviously your payroll since that is a significant expenditure for the uh District uh we also look into it uh procurement compliance uh uh federal and state procurement compliance um and then also your federal uh Federal testing uh which is also compliance testing over your major programs as far as the substantive testing or procedures that we perform uh there's several that we can uh that we can perform and that really depends again that goes back to that risk assessment and that's really going to dictate how we're going to uh test some of your account balances so we can perform some analytical procedures we can uh perform some predictive testing some vouching uh in some cases we might confirm uh with third parties such as your financial institutions um and and then for other areas we
101might uh obtain payment reports from tea or any other information such as payment ledgers uh summary of finances uh directly from tea as far as your audit results uh I did mention uh as far as the the different options in in the opinion on your financial statements so we did Issue an unmodified opinion on your financial statement again that is the highest level of assurance that you can obtain uh we don't have any findings related to financial reporting uh and we also have no findings related to compliance so overall it was a clean audit uh one other thing that we are required to perform is what we call a single audit so this is triggered uh whenever an entity receives over $750,000 in federal funding uh the school district obtained uh over 32 million in
102federal funding uh so that trigger what we call a single audit which which requires for us to come in perform again that risk assessment and determine what programs what federal programs we're going to be testing uh this year the major programs were uh Esser your Esser funding uh your title one title two and title three so there were actually four major programs uh for each of those major programs were required to determine uh the compliance requirements and to make sure that the that the school district is compliant and that and that the school district also has controls over those compliance requirements uh uh for those major programs we also issued an unmodified opinion over each major program and we also have no internal control findings or compliance findings uh for each of those major programs
103as far as your financial statements so we have your government-wide financial statements and so this slide and the next one is going to be government-wide which includes um all your funds it's full acrel uh has it includes all your longlived assets uh such as capital assets it also has your uh long-term liabilities such as your bonds um and then has your net net position at the very bottom there so as far as your total assets you do have uh for fiscal year 24 at the end of fiscal year 24 uh there's about 137 billion doll in assets within those assets you have 72.6 million in capital assets uh and then in cash and Investments there's about 6 137.5 million uh your differenter outflows and inflows relate to your pension and OPB uh like ilities and
104then on your liability side you have uh $ 96.5 million within those uh $96 million you have bonds which is the majority of that uh that's 6927 uh and then your pension liability is 123. eight uh and your opip liability is 48.7 uh once you net all that out at the end of the year you have a total net position of on the other side of that of that statement you have your uh statement of activities which uh details your revenues and expenses so for revenues you have uh 43.8 which within that you have 53.6 in program revenues uh your general revenues which includes your state aid and property taxes uh 36.2 million and then on your expenses uh total for the year 43.3 uh your change in that position was an uh was an
105increase of 10 uh $10.4 million and so the next few slides is going to focus only on your general fund uh so your actual revenues for the uh general fund was 288.5a which was under budget uh final budget by $110 million your actual expenditures was $3.1 Million which was under budget by 108. 6 your fund balance in your general fund decreased $9.8 million and then at the end of fiscal year 24 uh that fund balance is sitting at $34.20 million uh that makes up about 80% of your uh revenues in the general fund uh your your next one there will be your state aid which is about $25.4 million for the year uh that makes up about 9% of your revenues um and then you can see the breakdown of the of the other categories
106there for your expenditures in your general fund uh you you can see 62% of that or 85.4 million out of the 301 uh is related to instruction and related Services you then have support support services which is about 14% um and then you can see the breakdown of your other uh expenditures there as far as as far as your uh fund balance in in the general fund uh unassigned fund balance as a percentage of expenditures you can see there for fiscal year 24 uh was 30% your unassigned fund balance is 91.6 for fiscal year 24 uh once you compare that to your operate uh operating expenditures uh you're sitting at 30% which is roughly about 110 days uh you can see that similar calculation for the previous four years uh when district has been around
10730% for the last four years and then as far as required communication as Auditors we are required to communicate a few things to you so uh we uh we do have an engagement letter uh we were engaged to perform the audit uh that was signed back in April um that risk assessment that I mentioned earlier uh incorporates management overit controls as well as Revenue recognition into our audit procedures uh we also review some of your uh accounting policies uh and we consider those to be appro uh in accordance with industry standards uh we did not have any disagreements with management or any difficulties during the audit and we're also as a firm we're independent of District we are not aware of any situations in which management consulted with other accountants on accounting or financial reporting
108matters uh we also uh throughout the audit we discussed the application of accounting principles and auditing standards and our response to those inquiries uh was not a condition to our retention as Auditors uh as far as accounting estimates the only one that we consider to be significant on your financial statements was uh the state aid calculation and I'll take any questions thank you Mr toar any questions it's exciting to once again which is as our tradition runs uh to get a unqualified audit well we thank you for all the hard work that your firm brought to us supporting us in our educational one last opportunity any questions okay Mr toar thank you for bringing this report our next item is the consideration to approve the 2526 academic calendar yes Mr sh did we need to
109I should have taken a motion for that um the financial report but I did thank you I know uh Miss hul I will ask you to wait just a minute and uh we will go ahead uh this an item is coded for uh action and so as such do I have a motion to accept Miss Brady I make the motion to approve the audit report as submitted I have a motion from Miss Brady second missana guards roses second so we have a motion and a second to uh accept the uh report as presented presented the financial report uh board members any other questions no so please indicate your agreement with the motion by raising your hand Miss Canada that's unanimous okay Mr toar now thank you thank you D good evening Mr shackman Dr Eldridge
110and distinguished members of the board um I'm here this evening to present um the academic calendar considerations um for the 2526 calendar school year I'm going to begin with just very briefly overviewing the process that was involved to create the drafts of the calendars um in October we began the calendar timeline and I will go into a little bit more detail since that's a little small to read there in November um we started this year a little differently with doing a staff survey we really wanted to get the internal stakeholder feedback on what they thought about this year's calendar um and then things they wanted us to strongly consider for the 2526 calendar so we did seek that feedback before then creating any of the drafts to ensure that we were meeting the needs of
111our internal stakeholders we then um the district calendar committee met we reviewed the feedback uh as well as important dates throughout the school year that needed to be considered we looked at other um ISD drafts as well as the Dallas College um and then we also set the district parameters for the 2526 school year on what was important for us to uh work around with our drafts that were presented the next thing that happened was then in December of 2024 uh the district Improvement Council met uh they also provided feedback on our calendar um considerations via a survey um following our district Improvement council meeting and then the district calendar committee met um also in December uh created those three drafts that we did wanted to put out for our stakeholders to review and then
112um provide feedback on and then help us to narrow down from three drafts down to two so the last part of the timeline um following that sorry I'm having some clicking issues here okay um the calendar survey went out and the staff then narrowed down to their top two choices so we went from our three drafts down to two and then following that those two final calendars went out for all family staff stakeholders to vote on um from December through um The Return of the break around January the 6th um those choices were then um communicated of course via parent square and many other avenues and Miss Rodriguez will be um reviewing those with us in just a moment moment and that brings us to our last timeline which is tonight which is the board
113approval um the staff survey that we received at the initial onset I thought this was important to share to see what went into planning um what we sought feedback on from our internal stakeholders uh one of the things that was very important was that our first day of school to try to avoid Mondays um they did prefer Tuesday Wednesday or Thursday starts and so we did try hard to provide options that would avoid that um first semester overwhelmingly they would like conclusion of that semester in December so that when we come back in January we are starting spring semester uh that helps with our high school EOC testing as well as other um considerations for um instruction the second semester um also uh they strongly preferred concluding by Memorial Day um professional development days we
114try to restrict until after October the 1st so once we've started school we do try to wait until at least six weeks of instruction have been um under our belt before we then pull for any types of Staff Development so that was something you'll notice on the calendars um also we do have an election day on the calendar this year in November um it was also strongly uh favored for us to have student holidays on those days since many of our schools are testing sites um overwhelmingly uh the most favored vote that we had was to consider a full fall break in October um and so that was a consideration uh this year we also looked at the first day back uh the teachers really overwhelmingly loved the work day this past year uh they
115had time to get uh prepared for instruction get their rooms ready and really be ready for the students um on the first day of school before going into staff development and then the last consideration was um the early release days um that was something that was strongly considered that they would prefer not to have the early release days on the calendars so with that um we then had our district calendar committee meet of course several times all departments within our district were represented by the district leaders um of those departments they sought feedback within their Department as well as then met to review the feedback from our stakeholders um our district Improvement Council also then was a um strong uh part of this process and I want to thank Miss Hatfield for her service on
116that committee with us this year um as well as many other um community members um parents faculty and administrators um that are serving on this year's DIC committee so I'm going to turn the next couple of slides over to Miss Rodriguez and I want to thank her for her overwhelming support this year with increased communication we had the most um votes this year than we have had so I'm thankful for that thank you so for communication due to this being an online survey we wanted to make sure that we were tapping into all of our digital platforms so of course once the survey opened which was Friday December 20th um the day before break we did send a parent Square communication that included um a link to the online news story that we also posted
117which is on the next slide um that actually talked about the process gave you a little bit of background on each option and then the link to the actual survey which was available in English and Spanish um we also posted on social media starting um so that first parent Square uh touchpoint was on December 20th and then we posted throughout the break so that folks had an opportunity if they missed it or if they were just checking it out during the break you know I know people try to turn it off but sometimes what sounds like you know it actually worked uh people were checking online so we did post post a couple of times over the break and um we posted a News Post on the district website that News Post was also on
118all um campus websites and we had it as a main Banner it's a it's called a hero image on our district website and the campus websites so that was up throughout the whole break throughout the whole um uh period that the survey was open we also created an FAQ page once we started seeing some questions come through created that FAQ page and we also created a district email so folks can email if they had any questions now let's pass it back to miss hokom thank you so much um the extra push in communication was extremely beneficial and I think the extended time for parents to be review the calendars over the break was also very um helpful because we had lots of questions and things that we could clear up over the break so that
119was good a couple of reminders about requirements of our calendars um HB 2610 um and the 84th legislature was passed and that amended and basically we don't have a requirement to go a certain number of days which is what we used to have to do but now we have to go a minimum of 75,6 minutes and so the calendars that we adopt to vote must include a minimum of those days um but in addition the the uh change gives us flexibility to be able to then make adjustments if we have a natural disaster we have snow days we have school closures for whatever reason so that gives us an opportunity um to build in time also for staff developments but then also to accommodate if we have to be out for snow days so we
120usually build in a little bit more than the 75,6 minutes so that we can then also ensure that we have time to be flexible to accommodate if we have an unexpected outage um our calendar options also um give us a little bit of those extra minutes then to give us that flexibility uh we are thankful for those minutes this year when we had the inclement weather um and so we are um looking forward to these next calendars also giving us a little bit of a buffer there we will also have a staff development minute waiver this has been done in the district for several years this is a very important waiver because it provides us a maximum exchange of 20 2,100 total waiver minutes if we chose to use that many for professional development um
121both of our calendar options include at least two or three professional development days that we can exchange for uh the instructional minutes um that allows us time to then not only have minutes for instruction but also time for our staff to be prepared for um all of the required trainings that tea requires things that we need to do within the district to continue staff development um and then also time for our teachers to prepare for instruction so the three options were um put out um I'm going to go into the two top two in more detail but from the three that were put out originally the um second and third option were the two that were the highest voted by the internal staff and those two options became our final two that were out as
122options one and two those calendar options um were both very very similar um as far as the overarching if you looked at start and stop times because we did try to hold true to what the um internal stakeholders wanted but there were quite a few differences within the calendar if you really got into it and looked closely uh month by month um one of the um I'm going to give some highlighted differences of course this is a view of English and Spanish that were both presented um there is um 171 instructional days on option one where there's 170 days on option two um both of those calendars provide staff prep preparation time before each grading period um with the exception that option one had um preparation time before the first nine weeks second nine weeks
123and third nine weeks and the option two gave a little bit more preparation time for teachers and so both of these calendars were um giving our teachers a little bit more time in either staff development or Preparation time those were both very very important to our teachers um to feel like they have time to do proper lesson planning look at data and then have time to dive into um the lessons that they're going to be teaching and so that was an increase of what we were able to see on our calendars um if you look at Option One um the start date there was on a Tuesday and um I think both of those calendar options were both starting on Tuesdays um you will see similarities in um the the August and the September months
124um in the October day is going to or October month is going to be the biggest difference um option one required no additional minutes to the calendar it was very similar to the calendar we had this year which was also highly favored um it had a partial break in October with also then teachers coming back midweek for a work day and then also a um professional development day to kind of wind down that second nine weeks and then prepare for the third nine weeks um in November we do have the election day that comes up um and so that day is a preparation or it's a PD day for teachers but it's a student student holiday uh we still built in our two Staff Exchange days which is something that we do every year that
125Falls during our Thanksgiving break um The Christmas break was a two- week uh break on both calendars that was similar um and then of course in March there was a few differences in the option one calendar we do have a preparation day before that third nine weeks of instruction which is different than the fourth the second calendar option um and then in April which is our heavy testing month um you'll notice that there is um a good Friday off around Easter weekend um and um then may was very similar to both we had um the last day of school and then of course a staff work day to wind down the semester at the end of the year so that's option one and then of course here is option two and so I've kind of
126gone through the differences with both of those the other thing to take note of with option two while it does have an additional staff development um or staff work day before each n weeks um there was also a difference in February around the um the president's holiday um and that was on I believe February the 16th and so on this calendar it's a professional development day and on the prior calendar there was also a student holiday so with that those are the two calendars side by side um and both of them do get out before the Memorial Day break and um then we go right into summer school usually in the month of June so the survey results are in um this year we did have like I said the most votes that we've had
127uh we had one did y'all want a drum roll oh well I've already blown it so oh no I haven't really blown it this is actually who voted um so we'll drum roll in a minute um the we had 1,787 votes which I thought was outstanding and again shout out to Karen and her team um we worked um throughout the break to continue to monitor um the comments and feedback that was coming in one of the other things I'm extremely extremely proud of is the fact that on our survey this year we combined um all stakeholders into one survey and so we had students that actually voted we had Parents we had staff members and we also separated out a column of if you were a parent and a staff member and so if you
128look at the percentages there um we were almost 50% staff and parents and that is a shout out to our whole community and our parents for taking the time to to invest in their vote that makes me feel very good about what we're looking at and what the stakeholders voice voice is and what they prefer okay so we can don't have to drum roll but you can see it was overwhelming uh we watched this throughout the break just to make sure everything was working properly um and it really never wavered a whole lot it would came out strong at about 75% for option two around 25% there for option one and so that again was pretty consistent throughout the whole time and so that was what the uh voice of all of our stakeholders um
129was and so this evening we do seek board approval um for the 2526 calendar for option two based on the feedback from all of our stakeholder groups we are very thankful for your continued support um and we are available for any questions that you might have question from Miss Garza roas thank you so much for your all of your hard work and thank you for the engagement over the Christmas break because social media works I mean the algorithm works every time I would open up Facebook Facebook it would have CFB and if I wanted to take the survey I can't take it a lot so just one time is enough but anyways my question is um a lot of community members have asked about the five minutes is it before school is it after school
130uh do we have clarification on that yet that's a great question um and I did probably fail to mention that on that second calendar that was a requirement for that calendar was at plus five minutes um that if that is the vote that is approved this evening um we will then reconvene our District Administrative team team and we will then look at those um options for before or after school um I know we've already visited with Chris Moore and his team operations plays a big part of that uh with our buses and our bus routes and things of that nature um we also looked at this last year um and that was a course overwhelmingly decided to put it at the end of the day because our elementary does go already very early in the
131mornings and so um that is something we will all get together and then look at um so we don't have a hard fast answer on whether it will be for sure in the morning or the afternoon um but we will definitely we will have that answer out very very soon pending tonight's approval okay thank you so much any other comments or questions this item is posted for Action Caroline and thank you for your report um regarding those minutes how do you count minutes how do we count minutes that's a great question so the minutes are based on the instructional school day and so on the second calendar for example um that is a 445 minute school day the option one is 440 which is what we're on currently this year so that calendar has one
132less day than the first calendar so when you take the 170 school days and you multiply it by the 445 you get your base number of instructional minutes of course the tea requires the 75,6 and we're able to then exchange up up to 2100 minutes of our staff development days that start after the first day of school and are before the last day of school so we can't count the staff development days that are before the students are here uh so on that calendar option there were three staff development days so we be we would be able to exchange three of those days for instructional minutes so that would keep us from being right at that bare minimum and we would have some flexibility if there was inclement weather uh both calendar options will Bank
133us around 1.7 1.8 minutes is um depending on which calendar um that has fared well for us of course assuming knock on wood that we don't have an extraordinary winter and we're out multiple days if that were to happen and we use those extra minutes we also have bad weather days built into the calendar which everyone hopes we don't have to use um but those are there if we do need to use those and so the minutes are basically calculated based off of the instructional day without adding those F Well if we added the five minutes to the 170 day student calendar uh that gives us about 800 I think 70 extra minutes that's almost two school days and so that does help give us some flexibility then and meeting um time for proper preparation
134for our teachers as well as not bringing them back too early you know when a August 1 Falls is a really big deal because our teachers are having to come back sometimes in that last part of July um we also try to keep our students from having to come back too early in August and so that start and stop time is also really really critical teachers still have to work the 187 required contracted days and then we still have to get in the 75,6 minutes so you kind of have to you know work the numbers going uh both ways but that extra five minutes is calculated based off of those minutes that were in school any other questions thank you for your presentation I think you know spending all the time that we did on
135the campuses serving hamburgers to our staff the number one thing that they always wanted to talk to the board about was how wonderful it was to have a break and that it was much needed so I think you know looking at what our teachers need um it w it was so supportive you know I know we all worried about it because you worry you know are we feeding kids or you know where who who's going to watch the kids but we did not receive any um email complaints and I think you all experienced all the the positive comments so um I I am hesitant though and to add in the morning when that is so early for our kids already so I know we need to do our due diligence and looking at that yes
136ma'am I would Echo that I heard that most commonly on the campuses in fact it was 84% on that one staff survey question um about the break but it was also interesting we heard from some students out in the field when we were on campuses that they really enjoyed having that kind of mid-fall time to reset especially esally if they were involved in multiple activities and extracurriculars it allowed them time to kind of take a break from school do extracurricular activities and not have to run so hard and fast between September and then waiting until that November break so we did see some positive benefits from our students as well um but our teachers were overwhelmingly um great comments from them as well as our St as our campus administrators um I would like to
137Echo the student comments I was at RL Turner having my hair washed and two of the students were telling me that you know they have to study for exams and then they also have to watch their their you know little brother or sister and they were so excited that they had that mental time to study and and to prepare for their exams and they said the half days are so hard and so that was from our students yes I have another question yes thinking about the five minutes before or after what about or is it considered to take it away from lunch oh so we have to either extend okay either come earlier or stay later so it has to come on one one end or the other thank you yes ma'am okay I see
138no additional questions or comments this item is uh labeled for Action board members is there a uh motion Miss Brady I make the motion to approve the calendar as presented as option two I have a motion from Miss Brady is there a Miss Gara roas as second uh board members is there any additional comments now no I see none all in favor of the motion please raise your hand that is unanimous Miss Canada right uh item d u turn it over to miss hulum guess you're already there yes so I believe item D is an approval for the staff development waiver um and that as mentioned earlier would be something that we would file in our student services department um Miss Katie Bondies will file that for us and so because option two is the
139um approved calendar there would be three PD days that would um be in exchange for instructional minutes that will be submitted um to tea and so that staff development waiver I believe also needs to be approved this evening along with our calendar okay question comment no no again this item is marked for Action so we would need a a motion to go forward do I have a motion I'll make a mo bened I I make a motion that we approve the um the waiver for the 2100 minutes to be used for professional development for the district okay I have a motion from Miss Benevides is there a second is that the right motion 2100 minutes the motion to approve uh 6D as as approved 2100 minutes it will just be the staff development waiver um
140it will not be a total of 2,100 minutes we could go up to that but we will just do the three days as we have planned um for now so I think the approval would just be for the staff development waiver okay um I make a motion that the Board of Trustees approves a submission for and utilization of Staff Development waivers as presented and Miss Hatfield are you and she is seconding that so I have motion and a second uh board any questions comments all in favor please raise your hand okay thank you very much uhuh uh 6E Mr Marsh Dr elridge president shackman and steam members of the board on January the 9th and the 10th CFB experienced emergency closure due to inclement weather that leads to the question do students and staff need
141to make up those days fortunately Miss hok uh referen the bank minutes in her presentation we're very fortunate to have Bank minutes to where students if approved would not have to make up to two days Dr Eldridge has authorized using those minutes so students will not have to make up those two days however Bank minuts do not apply to staff there is a mechanism for staff to be able to have the same Advantage you have flexibility as listed in policy and that vehicle mechanism is a resolution so it is recommended that a board member read the resolution and that the board approved the resolution so that staff will not make up to two days yeah okay board members are other questions discussion okay uh then let's go ahead and get a motion in a second
142and then we'll read the resolution Miss uh um I move to approve the item but you'd like a second first before I read it uh we'll we'll read it here we'll get the second first okay okay so I have a motion and Miss Barnes is seconding this that motion so now prior to voting to approve the motion we will read it in its entirety all right resolution of the Board of Trustees of the Carolton Farmers Branch Independent School District on January 16th 2025 payment of employees during emergency closure whereas the recent inclement weather resulted in the closure of all schools and facilities in the Carolton Farmers Branch Independent School District cfbisd from January 9th 2025 to January 10th 2025 due to inclement weather for the safety of students and staff in the community as a
143whole and whereas through circumstances completely beyond their control cfbisd employees were forced to miss work days due to the closure of schools facilities in operation and whereas board policy DEA local requires the district to continue to pay employees for their regular Duty scheduled during the emergency closure as further provided by this resolution and whereas the board determines that the public school purpose exists for forgiving or excusing the absences of an employee on days when an employee is not able to work due to the closure of school facilities or operations and now therefore be it resolved by the Board of Trustees of cfbisd that all employees will be compensated for their regular Duty schedule during the emergency closure with the exception of any employee who were required to work during the closure and who was absent
144from Duty for a reason and related to the closure number two non-exempt employees who were required to work on school property during the closure shall be paid at the rate of 1 and 1/ half times their regular rate of pay for all hours worked up to 40 hours per week as provided by board policy DEA local and number three the board hereby authorizes the superintendent to take steps deemed necessary and appropriate to fulfill the purposes of this resolution adopted uh by a majority vote of the members um which will be considered now coming right now okay we have a motion it has been seconded and now we've heard them uh reading of the resolution board members any additional questions okay all in favor missing out of that's unanimous okay thank you Mr MCH our next
145item on the agenda is item seven it is closed meeting as authorized under Texas government code uh it is not limited to section 551.071 but it can include various pieces there so the next item is s you're welcome to stay um but we're going to recess into the conference room for the closed meeting [Music] portion e e e turn that on we are back in Open session at at 10:51 p.m. uh board members as a result of our closed session is there anything that we want to do taking action Miss Brady I would like to make the motion that upon successful completion of the superintendent evaluation that the board approve her extension of her contract for another year is there a second second from Miss Benes uh board we have a motion and a second
146all in favor unanimous Miss Canada okay is there anything forther Board of members thank you I'm good now I have I have Chapstick just callor well I think there are no comments left we've all talked it out so at this point in time at 10:52 uh we will adjourn the meeting for tonight again before we leave the jacket and ask that was supposed to