001I love doing that I call this Prem meeting briefing of the Carolton Farmers Branch ISD Board of Trustees to order at 6: pm on December 5th the purpose of this pre-meeting briefing is to conduct a session with administrative staff regarding the posted agenda for the regular board meeting which is scheduled for 7 p.m. tonight for the record board members present are ter habach Kim Brady marjerie Barnes Carolyn Benavides Elana garar roas Cassandra Hatfield and me I'm Randy shackman next item on our agenda is audience for guests we have no one who has signed up there are no one for audience for guests so we will go straight on to number three which is the administrative reports Dr eldrid okay our first is that on okay our first report is from Dr Stout on our purchase
002of iPads and Chromebooks thank you Dr alridge um president chackman and members of the board I'm here to present some additional information for you related to the consent agenda item related to iPads and Chromebooks um this is a slide I I pulled together a couple of slides with additional information for you this slide uh outlines that uh the model of the iPads that we're seeking to replace with the requested 2,660 student devices are for the fifth and sixth generation iPads as you can see they will no longer receive iOS updates um we use our student devices until one of two well one of three things happens one is it gets irreparably damaged and needs to be sent off to where the um old devices go to die uh when or when it will no longer
003receive software updates or when we can no longer purchase parts for those devices and so you'll see that we have a few of the fifth generation iPads that are still floating around um and then mostly this is for our sixth generation iPads that we're seeking to replace and then also um to replace iPads that are damaged and broken throughout the year we're anticipating that that number is going to increase because we used to be able to replace a screen if a screen is broken on a device and in the newer models of iPads we're no longer able to do that the way it's integrated into the rest of the hardware so now when a child breaks a screen we have to issue an entirely new device to them um if you'll notice that we're currently
004those are the fifth and sixth generation iPads the iPad that Apple has out right now is 10th Generation so we use these things until we literally cannot anymore for the Chromebook models um the Chromebook models is more of an issue of parts than it is uh software updates Google will allow software to continue the newer version of chromes to continue being installed on Chromebooks for seven to 10 years um however for these three models you'll notice that um the first two models are uh five and seven years old five and yes five and seven years old um and then the G3 are newer however HP is now up to the model G10 and so they know they stop manufacturing and stop supporting replacement parts for those Chromebooks um if we can't buy replacement parts for
005them then when a child breaks it breaks a key breaks a hinge whatever we can't um get replacement parts for it so we're seeking to request uh Chromebooks to replace those models that we have to phase out as um we can no longer get parts for them and I will be honored to answer or address any questions you may have board members any questions I have a couple and uh first you know and I apologize uh I'm in the process of a move and uh didn't get internet and have access to board book and stuff and all this so is this budgeted from regular funds yes okay yes we will be using our regular annual budget we'll moving moving a few things around but yes it will be our regular budget okay and then um
006Chromebooks versus iPads are we staying the same way that iPads are being used up through a certain level and then we're going to Chromebooks yes we did a stakeholder survey last year and um we asked about their devices and and are they comfortable then also asking the teachers and campuses that they they like the Chromebooks in grade the transition of Chromebooks in grade two um and so students in grades prek through one are an iPads uh we're anticipating also that our break fix rate for the iPads will decrease now that this year we've moved to a cart based model instead of sending iPads home with students below grade three when they're in a cart they're not they're less likely to get damaged in a backpack or you know thrown under the couch great thank you
007very much I know the uh kids get a lot of use out of that and a lot of support for our teaching staff thank you thank you okay um I added item 5 q with Mr Blackburn just to discuss the renovations for the locker room due to the increase in funding and just to talk about the schedule good evening president shakman Dr Eldridge members of the board just a quick review on this item we originally uh the board originally approved the authorization for renovations at standard Stadium involving Sports field lighting Natatorium locker room Renovations and for restroom Renovations on the main Concourse on the home grandstand the reason this is coming back uh for additional authorization is the sports lighting vendor that we originally got pricing from would not honor their pricing that they submitted
008and they came back and wanted an extra $1.2 million so we uh got two additional uh quotes from different firms along with photometric studies showing the lighting levels that the firms would produce with their equipment compared to the original quote we feel like uh the vendor that we selected that's uh part of The Proposal before you tonight provides better photometrics than the original vendor uh for significantly less cost it would be a savings of about $800,000 versus what we would would have had to pay if we had stayed with the original vendor the original vendor was the manufacturer of the the lighting that's there now um the vendor that we're talking to is just going to replace the fixtures on the top of the poles um so happy entertaining questions you may have board members
009any questions mrb yeah just original discussions had been that that lighting and we are talking about the lighting at standards right yes ma' so um are we going to be is it going to be ready by track season it will be tight um the advantage of not putting another difference between uh what we're proposing Now versus what was U what they wanted to charge an extra million for is we're not adding poles we're only replacing fixtures on the existing poles which means it will be much less involved to get the new lighting up and running so the lead times on the fixtures are to where they should be able to get the installation done once they start within a couple of weeks so if they don't quite make it before track season start it should
010be I would expect no later than the end of February based on what they've told me okay um I mean I think it's track season is the priority for that yes ma'am Ray model thanks other questions none Mr B thank you very much this brings us to item four on our agenda the uh board members are there any questions about or discussion for the consent agenda no seeing none we will move rapidly on to H our last agenda item which is adjournment and I will call us adjourned at e e e it's not the most it's not the best of picking up I tend to lean over it but you can hear you this e e e okay now we're going to bang it again would you let me workings are too expensive the bud
011we've seen your Christmas good evening everyone I call the uh regular meeting of the Carolton Farmers Branch ISD Board of Trustees to order at 7 pm. here on December 5th 2024 board members District staff and members of the audience you are free to join me in standing as Pastor Rob lane from the Woodland Baptist Church provides us with a message followed by Leading the pledges Carolyn Benavides leading Us in the pledge to the US flag and Ilana Gara roses leading Us in the pledge to the Texas flag dear gracious Heavenly Father Lord we thank you that you are in our presence right now and that you give wisdom and discernment uh Lord and we also say thank you for sending Jesus Christ the savior of the world Lord tonight there's many decisions that need to
012be made there's going to be great discussion and talk and Lord we pray that in the midst of all of that that it is your glory of being represented uh Lord we pray that in the recognition of the awards that are being given thank you God for that we have so many talented individuals with inside of this school district and God I thank you for allowing all of us to be a part of a school district that wants to glorify you Lord we love you and we thank you that you have us here tonight direct us in Jesus name amen am to the flag of the United States of America and to the republ for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all honor the Texas flag my pledge aliance
013to thee Texas one State under God one and indivisible thank you as a district we dedicate all of our efforts and resources to our goal of high expectations for all the board uses this goal to guide all deliberations decisions and actions you will get to see those deliberations decisions and actions in an open session with the exception of a few items which will be uh according to government code section 551 in Clos session these items typically deal with Personnel matters consultation with our attorneys or real estate for the record tonight uh board members present are Tara Habachi Kim Brady Marjorie Barnes Carolyn benavites Ilana garer roas Cassandra Hatfield and me I'm Randy shackman we constitute a quorum and may conduct business on behalf of the district before moving to the next agenda item I will
014remind you that the board will accept comments from citizens uh in the district and from employees persons wishing to speak uh and audience for guests must have completed an online form for this purpose and submitted it uh with a posting M Lan of 5:00 today when the board addresses item agenda item three audience for guests you will be invited to the uh Podium to speak next item on our agenda is item number two special presentations and recognitions I'm going to turn it over to Karen Rodriguez thank you uh good evening president shakman Dr Eldridge and members of the board um tonight we get to celebrate um a recognition that we didn't get to celebrate last month so I'm excited for this to be my first one through our partnership with Chick-fil-A at Trinity Mills we
015have the opportunity to honor an individual with our CFB Champion award which recognizes teachers employees students or community members for demonstrating Excellence the December CFB Champion award is being presented to Arthur Mendes and the Valley Ranch Baptist Church for their continual support of all seven Westside campuses for the past 6 years they have supported CFB students in need during the holiday season Valley Ranch hosts The Christmas Store where students get to eat shop and experience the season of Joy this year is no different they will be helping make Christmas wishes come true for over 1,000 students please join me in congratulating and thanking our CFB Champion Arthur Mendes and the Valley Ranch Baptist Church for supporting our students now moving on to our student recognitions each fall yel University invites the top mop trial teams
016from around the nation to compete against each other to host the Yale Bulldog Invitational Creek View High School is one of the few remaining public schools that attends the esteemed competition this year the Creek View High School mock trial team racked up some big ones snagging best witness in the nation titles on both the plaintiff and defensive sides of the case and finishing sixth in the nation we are so proud of what y'all have accomplished in this competition I also know that in addition to that after finishing third out of 49 teams these talented students just Advanced to compete in the YMCA mock trial state competition which will happen this spring in Austin please join me in applauding the award-winning Creek viiew High School mock trial team Hannah Anderson Suzanne Bata Casey Brady Kelsey Hayes
017Suman Hong Jackson Hyde and rayy Lewis congratulations and let's give them an another round of applause board members if you could please stand and move toward the center of the Das uh for a group photo parents after our group photo you can please make your way to the lobby to join your student congratulations and good luck all of our board is so proud of these students and uh board member Kim br Brady has extra sense of Pride because that Casey Brady that is on the team is her daughter and we're proud of them all I believe that concludes our recognitions for the evening and uh president's remarks are next on the agenda so for 125 here are my thoughts one of the items on our agenda tonight is the purchase of replacement iPads and Chromebooks
018these important tools support classroom learning in many ways with that being said accidental and unfortunate things happen and I want to strongly encourage all those watching on TV and all those who are here in the audience and encourage your friends and neighbors to do the same consider getting coverage for uh this item it is uh website on our district website and in coverage is inexpensive and it will provide a great deal of Safety and Security and uh kids will be kids so when something happens it's a way to cover that so give some thought to that again look at our website cfbisd and get more information one of our Community Partners five star 4 who is very active in supporting the school district is hosting a holiday blood drive on January 10th critical blood supplies
019always lag during the holidays uh personally my mother's life was saved when I was a boy because she got the blood that she desperately needed from people who had donated it I want to encourage all of us to plan to donate life saving Supply by supporting Sam pac's five-star po Ford on January 10th a great CFB shout out goes to our very own board member Carolyn Benavides and her many community volunteers as they completed another successful Thanksgiving dinner for many of our community members here in the area I understand that this year's program served 3,000 dinners on Thanksgiving uh congratulations Carolyn and to all your volunteers finally tonight I want to formally make an announcement about the completion of our 2024 Carolton Farmers Branch legislative priorities this is a year that the state's banial legislative
020session begins and our legislative priorities will guide our advocacy efforts to encourage members of the Senate and the house to focus on public education we like most of our fellow districts throughout Texas are struggling uh with finances and budget issues and that's an issue that really can only be solved at the State Legislative uh agenda and so I hope that you will all go online and look up our legislative priorities um we have a a great opportunity to all get involved and encourage the state to do what it ought to do and fully fund and support public education thank you and that's a my remarks for this evening next are there any committee updates from any of the board members for tonight here me okay thanks um I just wanted to report on um the
021board subcommittee uh governance subcommittee of uh myself Miss Hatfield and Miss Barnes uh we met on um November 11th uh really for two um purposes one um we had re requ received a policy request and we had uh up review requests and we had committed to meeting within two weeks when we received those requests uh so we did that uh we also went through our long list of items that we had been collecting uh for policy and board operating procedure updates we assigned those amongst each other and that work has started and we're wrapping it up for um admin and legal uh review and then submit for board um approval um as well uh we discussed the approach on the review of our strategic um vision and you know how we're going to move that
022work forward with the intent of um getting our goals and our vision in place for the 2526 school year thank you Mr herbach it sounds like he guys are getting a lot of good work done other board members M roas I have an update on our board subcommittee which is the legislative committee Carolyn benavites uh president shakman and myself met on November 12th and December 4th and we discussed our legislative priorities we also round Ted with raise your hand Texas um and then yesterday we had an opportunity to meet once again just to review our legislative priorities and get all all of our meetings in order I will say you know I'm really appreciative for our subcommittee because this takes this takes a lot of work and it really does take a village to get
023everything together and moving and the planning has been perfect so thank you guys great thank you Miss Ross any other okay then our next item is a district announcements and I'll turn it over to Dr eldrid okay I'm so thankful for our season of giving and thanks to our great community so in thank you Miss Benavides for all the meals you served our community we also had a day of giving at mcorder and Mami we gave away 500 turkeys and meal boxes because we have great Partners in our community in addition um the Daughters of the American Revolution which I'm so proud that my grandmother was in that organization so the state chapter gave our student they adopted 47 students and they delivered all the gifts to rainwater so I think that is just another
024um example of a great partnership um Teasdale Latin foods which is right down not too far from here has donated bikes and toys and Gi for our students and um I think they're all in our communication office right now and um I know that there were some people that were like maybe we should ride the bikes around our um our area to see if we could still ride them but um it just it just shows you the power of our community and great giving um another shout out to Creek View um their High School moving uh ground dance company and Newman Smith U motion dance they were featured throughout um the experienced dance textbooks Nationwide so they came and took pictures of our dance companies and it's amazing to see our students that represented in
025a in a nationwide textbook um you all know that safety is a top priority in our school district it it was so awesome this month our school district is featured in the um Texas safety newsletter we did a um PSA announcement with Carolton um Dallas Farmers brand Irving police departments and within 2 days we had over 4,100 views of our PSA and so now we are in the running for the Statewide um award so we're super excited about that I think that there's just great things happening and um I think there's two more weeks until the holiday break so we are so thankful for our community giving to our students and families thank you Dr alridge and now we're going to have an update from PTA and I believe that's Miss Nunes um Dr Aldridge
026president shackman and the esteem board I'm Dean Nunes and I'm the second VP of membership for the PTA counil board um let's start with our PTA motto to make every child's potential a reality by engaging and Empowering Families and communities to advocate for all children our district membership is growing we currently have have 5,734 members we still need about 723 members to reach our number from last year we encourage you all to join your local PTA and become a CFB ISD PTA Champion that supports multiple ptas across our district right now we currently need two more Champion memberships wink wink if anybody wants to join um to meet our total from last year and increase it um thank you to all those that have joined our champion memberships um to if you need any information
027please go to our CFB pta.org website for more information so I'm going to talk about our coveted Golden Apple award the Golden Apple award is given to ptas who have received 100% of their full-time staff to join their local PTA for Council the award is given to our um for the school board and our superintendent and direct reports if they have joined guess what we have now received our Council PTA golden award Golden Apple award so I'm pretty honored to have you guys all members of our PTA principles don't worry you still have time the submission is due December 15 so talk to your PTA our next big event is our Reflections art contest the theme this year is accepting imperfection and we have received over 150 submissions that are advancing to the council level
028from across the district we look forward to celebrating our winners on January 15th at the Nancy Waton Center our next delegate meeting is also held then a big program that we have this year um that we are promoting is the Paul Patrol stories this is to promote student safety by fostering a positive Community relationship with our First Responders which is a great um deal considering we're up for an award for their PSA this will be a k through eight event on March 1st it will be held at Creek View and it Showtime is at 1 pm this month we conducted a membership challenge for November the November challenge was our Shining Star Award The Shining Star Star Award is for those that have increased their PTA membership to 101% past last year's membership this year
029we had 12 PT that qualified this for this award we chose one Elementary and one secondary out of the 12 our elementary school award goes to mckam [Applause] elementary our Secondary School winner is pulk Middle School um for our December challenge we are going to ask that um PT and local schools submit their best and most creative end ofe events and that's all thank you thank you Miss Nunes and now uh an update from our Educational Foundation I'll turn it over Donna wall and Company and Company good evening thank you D good evening Dr Eldridge and president shackman and esteemed school board members during this season of giving I come before you tonight celebrating our annual tradition of offering gifts from the Education Foundation in 2021 the Ed Foundation committed to a new program a
030new program that was inspiring Innovation cre creativity and novel programs throughout the throughout the school districts classrooms uh and and campuses the Innovative grant program is a deal maker it is a Difference Maker and thanks to you and to you and and to you uh and to you and and also thanks to our innovation academy members we've been able to build on this program it's a big deal since 2021 the innovation academy The Innovation grant program has delivered $130,000 just over directly to the school district uh impacting thousands of students in classrooms and across campuses and numerous departments I think it's worthy to note that the uh Innovation grant program is open to any CFB employee so all CFB employees can apply for the Innovation Grant program uh funding for the Innovative grants is providing
031important Pathways for our community and for our business Community uh to connect with and support the school district I speak on behalf of the Ed foundation on behalf of my directors and share just how grateful we are to be able to play a role in helping build Partnerships so tonight without further Ado we'd like to present you with a check for $ 37,2 se6 to fund new projects I'm going to ask you guys come on forward thank you I I think it's important to note that this is only one of our programs uh so we Fund in a variety of different ways this is but one uh and never one to break a secret or or spoil a surprise rise uh but we'll have more information about the Innovative grants in the weeks to come
032wink wink wink if you know you know as they say um happiest of holidays from your Education Foundation and thank you all for entrusting us and for your continued support so thank you uh we'd like to take a second get everybody in a picture so if I can get Mary and and the Education Foundation directors to come forward St forward with the check um trustee uh Garza roas miss garar roas and miss benovitz if I can have you all join us below the dis um and District senior leaders and uh uh president shakman you all are in perfect place so uh we thank you and again we appreciate your support dance you're right thank you Miss Wald and to the board members from the Education Foundation who joined us tonight and uh thank you for
033on behalf of all of our students and all of those who will receive benefit from such a wonderful wonderful gift and what a great time of year for such a gift thank you the next item on our agenda is item three audience for guests uh we do have a couple of people who have signed up for audience for guests and uh before we begin I will remind audience members of the board procedures for handling audience for guests anyone interested to speak in person during audience for guests must have electronically submitted a form and listed the topic they wish to discuss by the 5:00 pm deadline for the form submission each speaker will be allowed to speak once uh during the audience for guests uh St stakeholders will be allowed a maximum of three minutes and
034speakers designated non-st akeh holders those who live outside the district area will be allowed a maximum of one minute to address the board in compliance with the open meeting act please note that the board uh is not allowed to respond publicly directly and to any any board uh any speaker and they will address any agenda items that deemed necessary when they are listed only on the agenda the timer will begin when shown on the screen in front of you uh when you arrive at the podium and begin to speak again the speaker presentations will be limited to the allotted time we have two speakers in order of submission the first is uh Nicholas orelli I don't actually see see him Mr Mr Onis I don't see him while they're looking for him I'm going to
035go ahead and go to our second uh speaker and that is Mr Mike hennefer well president Jackman and Dr alridge and honorable board my name is Mike hennefer and I'm here because I'm excited that a few weeks ago and actually several weeks ago you nominated Me by open resolution to be a nominee for the uh Dallas County Appraiser District's board of directors and those nominations were collected and a ballot was formed by the chief appraiser that ballot went out and it's now time to vote uh based on the nominees on that ballot so I'm here to thank you for me for nominating me and secondly to um U ask for your vote why do I want to be on the board and why do I think I could do a good job well one of
036the reasons I want to be on the board is I do think that I could do a good job somebody's got to set that thing up or I'll speak the whole night um in 1991 I was I started a company called corporate USA Real Estate Services since then we've managed 30 million square feet of commercial property during that time I did personally handled many uh appraisal valuation protests both formal and informal and even initiated several lawsuits I understand the the appraisal appraisal process a we've hired a lot of property managers in our day and a good property manager finds problems before they get they get big and and kills them that's what I hope I can do on on on the board of directors I'm a big proponent of school districts school districts have too
037many unfunded mandates it's a shame that teachers don't get raises I've knocked on uh over the years maybe over the last 10 years I've probably knocked on I don't know many thousand doors you are the largest employers in the cities and we come across teachers of all times all the time they are dedicated people that teach because they believe in the kids and they deserve uh increase so I I believe in that fully I think vouchers are bad for public schools there's one more problem find problems and fix it this is a big problem and I don't know how to fix it but I'm willing to tackle it the appraisal district is asking for large increases they say they're they don't have enough appraisers they're asking for 20% increases across the board that comes to
038you as a 20% increase but you don't have increasing Revenue so how do you handle a bill from the appraisal district for 20% increase when you don't have them that's a problem and so as a board of director I would hope that I could I don't I don't know how to fix it but I'm I'm not afraid of fixing things that look hard and I uh I want to uh uh try to fix that so I could go on I I really am excited about being on the board I think I can do a job and I would really appreciate your votes thank you very much thank you Mr hener uh Mr orelis appreciate y'all uh giving me another chance when I didn't hear you the first time Miss Nicholas relles address 1117 East Fender
039Drive I'll start with addressing uh agenda item 5S the November official minutes um I noticed that there was no mention of your decision to reduce each speaker's allotted Time by 33% during the audience for guests um while that's innocuous um it's a little puzzling if you compare that to the minutes from October um when there was an oped submitted for the uh for the October official minutes when there's an entire play byplay analysis of the ringer that y'all sent me through that night including how long the exact time that I spent speaking so I just it's a little confusing like the difference um like I said it's not that big of a deal um there was also an explanation as to why I wasn't permitted to speak during the audience for guests um it's stated
040that you had to consult with your lawyer as I mentioned in the last meeting uh it's pretty common um I don't understand why you couldn't have provided me that answer when I inquired 3 weeks prior to those minutes being released it's just simple communication and that seems to be the reoccurring theme with this district and that started back in May when I asked y'all for help and the only information that I was provided as to why you were firing me was because it was best for the district and to this date that's still your answer so um on that note I'm still confused as to how it was best for the district to fire me when we have Joel laum over here our chief of school leadership right who spoke last last board meeting he
041said that I'm needed here that I'm a great teacher um Chad Hunter also said that multiple times throughout the entire year including on April 2nd 2024 he said I could go anywhere I wanted to and then because that's prior to when y'all terminated me right Brian morsh and I had a convers out here on September 5th where he told me he's only heard great things about me he complimented my intelligence he also tried to persuade me to go to another district and how he would advocate for me right why would you want to push me out if that's how you feel so it's just really confusing um why I'm here though is for the external investigation I think that should happen and you can use the investigation that yall voted on for me give it
042to the public I wave my confidentiality be be transparent right show them your decision how you made your decision and you voted to approve it sorry thank you thank you Mr arelis that's all the speakers that I have been given for audience for guests and so that would lead us to our next agenda item which is item number four the non-action item for discussions uh first up is attendance up an enrollment update with Dr Lance Hamlin Dr excuse me Dr Eldridge uh Mr shackman members of the board I appreciate the opportunity to speak with you tonight and to share our enrollment update the first couple of slides that I would like to present it's really about going down memory lane and really how we got here this year uh this is a timeline that we
043used for our registration uh campaign last year and I'm just going to touch on a couple of things because the registration process is a lengthy process it's a process that involves many many departments as well as all of our campuses as you can see the process for this school year it started back last in the fall right so we had the opportunity to have our eighth graders decide what kind of programs they wanted for the programs of the study that happens all the way back in last November you jumped to December we had an opportunity to do our educational uh planning guide updates all this is part of how we really get to that registration process then we do that marketing phase uh in January we had the high school preview nights as well as
044uh in February we had the fifth grade trips to the middle school campuses and all this time we are promoting what we're doing at our campuses for our kids and across the district uh in March we started with the uh Middle School Parent previews that we have every year uh we had the eighth grade visits to the high school campuses and then we had had an incredible collaborative opportunity to create that marketing campaign for registration which was the Fastpass we started pushing that uh in April we opened up that registration window uh for the Fastpass that went from April 1st to uh April 30th and we had that one bonus day in May which was May 19th and then as you know we did several registration events uh throughout the summer we did a couple
045in June we did three in July and then we had the one in uh August and this is just to show that there's so much that goes into uh getting ready and having that registration opportunities for our students now going back to the what I think was an absolutely incredible collaborative opportunity and experience that included many departments as well as all of our campuses and that was the creation of the Fastpass uh when we went and created the Fastpass that included not only student student services but our Communications team it also included departments like Fine Arts student nutrition technology and Athletics because they were all part of this massive incentive process paired with all of our registration events that we had the two in June the three in July and the one in August that
046gave us the opportunity to show you numbers that are just absolutely impressive as you can see early registration we we've had early registration for many many years but we really haven't touted the numbers that we did this year if you look in 2223 we had 2250 students that went through the early registration process that means from April to June 1st they have completed all the documents required to register for the next school year the last year once again we had about 2400 students which is an average about 10% of our enrollment moment a number each year so that's what we've averaged until the Fastpass until the collaborative efforts of all the Departments that came together and really pulled off to what I think was absolutely amazing accomplishment we had 12,000 students that actually registered for
047did the early registration process from April 1st until June 1st almost 50% of the kids that are in our school right now went through that early registration process we typically average 10% each year so this is a it's a pat on the back to the entire District patter them back to every department and every campus that was involved in celebrating and really getting these kids ready for the new school year because when we get these numbers in early that allows us to make decisions regarding Staffing and things that we need to make sure our kids have what they need for that first day of school now it's about the historical snapshot enrollment counts so if you see I kind of shifted my my verbiage we're talking about registration now we're about enrollment because the registration
048process is really about the the documents that parents need to fill out in order for to tell us that hey we plan on our students attending one of your Schools they're now enrolled they're actually in a seat that's when their enrollment kicks in so they're not enrolled until the first day of school starts the state doesn't look at them as being enrolled until they actually show up to school so as you can see on our snapshot date every year in October the last Friday of October is a snapshot date uh this year we had 24,23461 students yes that's a decrease 151 students but I'm going to stand here today and say this is a celebration because we were able to hold on to [Music] 99.38% of our students that attended last year number-wise anyway when
049you look at the districts that neighbor us like Cel they lost uh 1.14% of their enrollment from last year to this year Lewisville 2.7% Irving 3.5% we're looking at 2third of 1% what an incredible accomplishment being able to hold on to our kids uh for this school year yes it's a decrease but it is a time for us to be able to celebrate I want to take a real quick Deep dive into our numbers enrollment numbers across the district by grade level I kind of shared this this chart with us with y'all last year but this is obviously with the new numbers and it's really important to look at not how many first graders we had last year compared to how many first graders we have this year it's about how many students in the
050grade level last year came back to us this year and so I just kind of highlighted a couple of the grade levels as you can see last year first grade uh we had 18895 students this year in first second grade we have a decrease of 82 students we're at 18113 I'll tell you right now that we're looking to find out where these kids went and we're looking for that why we don't have that information for you tonight we won't have it until February because we need to do complete our pee submission that happens in January and we'll be able to know where these kids actually landed you look at our fifth grade numbers fifth grade last year 1819 students this year in sixth grade 1649 we lost 170 students now this is a concern that
051we've had in CFB for the past 10 to 15 years students that are in fifth grade and not coming to our middle school campuses the odd thing if you look once they come into our middle school campuses they don't leave if you look at our sixth grade numbers last year uh 1533 we actually had an increase in those seventh grade numbers this year our seventh grade numbers from last year we had an increase in seventh grade this year we are currently working on reaching out to our families in the elementary level to create we're going to create a service Sur to try to find out exactly what they're looking for in a middle school program in that way we can hopefully mitigate some of that loss in the future and then you look at our
052eighth grade students 1690 uh students last year and then the whopping 2,000 students uh in ninth grade this year and we know that is because we do offer we do promote at a high level the incredible CTE programs we have at our high schools as well as ourmes but this has always been our Trend our kids come back but we need to continue to create a better opportunity for our kids in middle school to where we can mate mitigate that loss this slide here represents our district transfers and as you can see over the past three years the blue bar it represents the transfers into CFB in 2022 23 we had 1274 students that transferred into CFB compared to 12, uh 1245 last year but as as you can see this year we had a
053significant increase we know that we are uh serving 1415 students that do not live in CFB they've transferred from other districts to us now the obviously the elephant in the room is that gigantic Red Bar uh over the past couple years uh the TR those are the kids that transfer out of CFB almost 16 or for uh 4650 students transferred out of CFB in 2223 compared to almost 4,800 students last year this year we do not have those numbers at this time we are waiting for our pee submission in January we'll have those numbers vetted and we'll have all that from tea and I'll be able to provide that in a board memo for you in February I did provide a board packet for you tonight you should have uh that share some information regarding
054the students that have left us for uh Charter Schools do they have that okay uh so yeah you should have that with you uh so we know that those large red bars most of those students they're not leaving for other isds they're not leaving for other or high numbers I should say or high numbers for private schools they're leaving for charter schools and so in your board packet you should have uh exactly what Charter Schools they're attending over the past two years and then once again when we get our numbers back from our pee submission in January we'll be able to share in a board memo in February uh where those kids are this year I do think it's important to state that you know through student services and across our district it is the
055having the mindset of that never stop improving everything that we do every process that we run run when we're finished with that process we do what we call an after action review and we've been doing that throughout uh this year uh not not only through our attendance campaign our enrollment campaign uh but even through our insury tribunals that we're going through now but as you can see here also we are really really working hard to make sure that we are working with our campuses through what we're calling our uh enrollment focused think tanks we've started it last month we met with group of principles will continue to meet with principles monthly on how can we help them increase their enrollment not only at their campus but how they can help us increase the enrollment across
056the district we're also dedicated and really committed to making sure that our registration enrollment and transfer processes are aligned with the new facility study that we've ended our last meeting last night and then once we have the opportunity to kind of get all that information together we will have an effective and efficient process that will be aligned with the information gathered from that facility study we continue to have a very strong relationship with our health services department and making sure that we are offering all the vaccination opportunities for our families that's a huge need I know Miss Sleek works very hard to make sure that happens uh student services also this year has the responsibility and the opportunity to monitor the teacher student ratio across all elementary campuses in every classroom and we've done a
057really really good job making sure that anytime that we get to a point to we see that ratio is in Jeopardy we work with our HR department and the campus Administration to make sure that we provide the necessary resources that campus needs for that specific classroom and then we have a great uh obviously great relationship with our operations Department in transportation and a good example of that is when we had to move a program from one campus to another campus this year working with transportation to make sure our students had that Transportation need taken care of on the very first day when we move that program our goal is always no matter what the the educational environment is Across the Nation across Texas our goal here in CIB is always to increase our enrollment no
058matter what and we know we have a A Hard Road to to uh in the future uh because the enrollment trend's going down we're just making sure that we continue to work hard with our Communications Department with uh our cni department uh with special services and just promoting the programs we that we have at every single level elementary middle and high school and once again I think a big thing that we're going to be doing this year is having that uh response from our parents through our elementary survey on what they're really wanting to see at the middle school level so we can hopefully mitigate the loss that we've been experience experiencing uh at that Middle School level and then once again continue to have those uh enrollment think tanks with our campus leaders this
059is an a tentative timeline for our registration uh in this upcoming year and this extremely tentative because we know everything that's been going on especially with our facility study uh as you can see in February we'll definitely be kicking off with our advertising and our marketing campaign for the registration process open up those application Windows like we do every year example being our steam gifted talented program at Landry the Dual language at program at Thompson and Stark and then really when you move into April and May it's really about making sure that the registration and the transfer processes that we are going to be having during that time is completely aligned with the facility study and so we don't have all that information yet but just know that we're already working on that and seeing
060what that's going to look like based on the information we got from the facility study and then as you know we're going to continue with our registration uh Extravaganza events they've been very successful for the past two years so we will continue to do that looking to have six to eight different nights that we'll be able to uh serve our community and then I always like to finish with takeaways you know I'm I'm proud of the uh 24,23461 going to strive for that uh and then that just leads into also being able to retain 99.38% of our students that were here last year I think it's important that I continue to say it as many times as possible we will have an effective and and efficient registration and transfer process that will be aligned with
061our facility study uh and then that collaborative process that we've created with uh central office all departments and our campus principles to to help us in that process because they are part of the solution and then obviously I always want to just take a a second to say that the central registration Center that we've run through ESC this year has been extremely successful extremely busy from April 1st all the way to the end of September registering kids we we would have a complete packed office uh over at EC uh through that time but even after September end of September we are having families come through every single day registering or having the opportunity as you know with the parent uh education classes that we're running which is also a great way for us to promote
062our district uh we had uh over 190 uh families sign up for the English classes that we just started offering two weeks ago uh we only had room for 70 but we're looking to add additional sessions so that's just another way that we're promoting the incredible things that we are offering here in CFB and that's another way we're going to keep families here because we're not only meeting the needs of our students we're meeting the needs of the entire family any questions yes M hi thank you for your presentation so I assume that those enrollment numbers include our newcomers yes do we have a newcomers number for the for the district Absol well absolutely this year alone we had brought at 9 50 students that have enrolled newcomer wise the past two years we're right
063at 2,000 okay thank you and so what new um events and incentives do you have planned for this coming up school year for registration and enrollment we're we're in the middle of just thinking about what we can do we we would like to follow something like we did this past school year because I think now it's expected because it was so successful uh but we're in the planning PES so okay you get back to us on that one absolutely okay thank you very much it's been yes ma'am I feel like I'm in school you are um yes great report thank you so much um I was thinking about the um Ranch View area I visit over there quite a bit and thinking about instead of reaching children in fifth grade maybe start earlier I mean
064do you have a plan or do y'all do that visit take him to Barbara Bush or bring Barbara Bush to them we we typically do that with fifth grade but we really want to start finding out from our parents because we know that many of our kids actually leave before fifth grade so we really want to be able to look at uh find out what really from third grade on that's the conversations we're having now uh but the only students that we kind of send over right now our fifth grade students but we always encourage our uh elementary kids and give them the opportunity to go see musicals and things like that at the high school uh and get connected to not only the middle school but the high school as well and regarding Barbara
065um during their PTA meetings maybe incorporate the elementary school parents to come over I mean I know they have great programs over there and uh you know parents don't know about that yeah absolutely we can definitely talk with Miss Tilly and uh get some things going because she's doing a great job over there she's really made some great connections with the community thank you board procedure is that she doesn't talk again until all right so I have a I have a question for you regarding the parent survey so I guess my question is what is the purpose of the parent survey and up to bounce off what Miss benav said is it geared towards a certain grade level of parents we're we're in the process of creating that survey now right so as in the
066discussion phase the creation phase and it's typically going to be for our parents at for our kids third grade and up because we want to find out why they're why they're leaving what are they really wanting to see for their student in the Middle School educational experience we we want to to see how we can mitigate them leaving and not even giving us a chance because once again like I showed in the chart if they come in sixth grade they don't leave it's just getting them to come in sixth grade we we had a significant number 170 students that did they chose to go elsewhere and so we want to survey that will help us kind of find out exactly why they're leaving and what we can do uh to keep them here because their
067parent parents voice is extremely important now we also do our parent previews for middle school as well uh and giving the our elementary families to the opportunity to come up and see what's happening on at the Middle School uh but we want to hear what we want to hear from the parents we want to give them an opportunity to speak with their words so we can see if we can keep them here because right now they're speaking that's just with their feet they're walking away okay my other question was you mentioned that there were some English classes provided to about 70 people I know multiple signed up how was that marketed towards our community well we didn't even really honestly get a chance to to advertise uh it was Word of Mouth people heard we
068were about to do this and then before we even sent it out districtwide we already had once again 190 parents that had contacted us uh to say hey we want want to be in in in the class uh and so we had to cut it we didn't even get a chance to to to celebrate and send it out because we had already had the request was far more than what we could actually handle we are we are working right now to see if we can add a few more SE sessions and then if we can get get that done we'll be able to Market it again but we we do it every Tuesday in the morning I believe it's at 8:00 to 9:00 or 9:30 and then we did every uh Tuesday and Thursday morning
069and at night and those sessions are full okay is there a plan to do it a recording of some sort or to provide it in an additional matter I don't know what these classes look like which is why I'm asking well they're English classes the the ones that you we're talking about now uh we have not had any conversations about recording any of the classes uh but we're also looking to add more English classes as well as uh Financial uh literacy classes and wellness classes uh but taking baby steps this is the first time we've done this so once again it's been very successful we're about three weeks in uh and you know we'll we'll see the funding is extremely important so we're trying to secure funding for our additional sessions for the English classes
070first awesome thank you goe thank you Dr Hamlin for your presentation um this evening I heard some things like after action reports connecting with administrators specifically princip and I really appreciate that I think they are an extremely valuable asset and the more that we engage with them um the more they can help us and so I really just want to say thank you for engaging the principles in this work because I think it's critical that their voice be at the table um so that was just a an observation um and then echoing on to what Miss Brady said about the um enrollment it is very good news that we are retaining 99.38% I also see if there are 950 newcomers in that that this chart may not actually show us if we're keeping our students
071versus are the students in the chart the newcomers so I would like to request that we have that chart separated out so that we can actually look Beyond this of is it the newcomers that are keeping our enrollment and it's the dips are only in certain places or are we actually losing students um more students than we actually realize and I'm you have some information on that and we could definitely take a deeper dive into that and provide information at a later datee for sure that would be great um and then my last um note was when is the survey I know you said you're in the planning phases but I'm hopeful that the survey is going to go out sooner rather than later we're thinking May no I'm just kidding we we want to
072get that out hopefully in January early January that's great because that means it can have implications for this year absolutely thank you sir Miss Barnes thank you so much for this um always very interesting um I have a question about um the advertising and marketing that's being done for incoming students um in terms of you know our younger children going into kindergarten or prek what does that look like do you you know go to pre-schools how what is the advertising and marketing that's done is it dependent on people just hitting the website or knowing that they're in the district or are you guys going out well one that's a very good question uh two you know based on having we we have someone that's new to our uh Communications Department so we haven't actually met
073on exactly what that new marketing is going to look like so that's going to be part of our process and so I really can't answer that question with you know as deep as I need to go because we have completely new department and but it's really it's really about just sharing like I said earlier the programs that we have for our our kids because they're viable programs they're successful programs uh but we'll be working with our Communications Department to to have that marketing set and firm and ready to go excellent thank you so much thank you Miss Barnes um thanks for the information I just want you know for um you know priority and and consensus I want to um Echo Miss Hatfield's um comments and Miss Brady just regarding the newcomer data I mean
074I think that's an important anal Anis especially leading into um surveys survey data and what we need to do as far as finding out some of the wise then uh for some of the other comments and and as Dr Hamlin referenced in his presentation um these numbers as far as fifth to sixth grade um is not a surprise um this is a trend that we've seen for many years in cfbisd many things have been tried year to year um to work on this um but but I want to clarify that this is not isolated to a single campus that might or might not be mentioned here tonight this is a a CFB um issue so um I just absolutely I just want to clarify that that's a a CFB issue not specific to a middle
075school campus correct BR no I was just going to comment that those this the grades that you had pointed out where we seem to have trouble keeping our kids or coming back to our kids those are all parents decisions and so if we have somehow can reach out to our parents in a um more communicative way and get them more involved earlier in those decisions because those are all those are when the parents are making decision including prek and k um but certainly in sixth grade going to sixth grade so that's a if we can open our campuses up um even more freely for parents to come up and see that it's not a scary place even though it is Middle School which some people think is scary um it's those are great great great
076schools and same with our high schools but parents are afraid of what they don't know and so if we could just open that up tours as often as possible for our parents to get into those campuses would be super helpful and you're right it's about relationships we want our administrators at the middle school level to have relationships with those elementary students and parents and so it's about being in front of them and it's about starting building that relationship because principles are extremely powerful uh they really are their administrative team and staffs are extremely powerful in the enrollment numbers as well as the retention numbers uh because when when parents really appreciate and respect the principle uh in that administrative team they stay or they want to go you right so you're 100% spot on and
077I think you're exactly right about the relationships and the sooner our younger parents can get involved and understand and meet these people that work at these big scary schools then they'll be less scared to go and and to try it out so just just and I know you all are thinking about it but if we can open it up year around to our parents to feel invited to come to our schools that would be hugely helpful Miss Hatfield um I completely agree with Miss Brady I mean having had multiple board members that either have a middle schooler that are in our schools or have had a middle schooler in our schools our middle schools are not scary there are places where great teachers work and great administrators are doing amazing things and I would say
078you might even consider surveying your students because I I mean I have a middle schooler and I can tell you they talk about their middle school and so they might be able to lend a hand in this how do we keep kids because those fifth graders are talking to their parents they're going and they're they're saying I heard this about this school and then the parents are their wheels are turning and they get nervous so you might think about also engaging the students in this conversation because they probably have some pretty good ideas too absolutely so just an idea Miss barns just building off of what they've said also as the parent of middle schooler high schooler an elementary schooler um I would also encourage that conversation to start much earlier than fifth grade I
079think it needs to start parents are starting to ask questions and look at Schools starting I early as second and third grade they are looking forward um in sixth grade they're looking at the high school and so when you're looking at parent surveys parent education about middle school started a lot earlier than fifth grade because at F by fifth grade parents have kind of already made their choices um and I love the preview nights that or previews that we do with the students um and they're great I think they open our students eyes but like we've you know mentioned and I think you mentioned something like this too we need to open the parents eyes the decisions are from them um so I'm I'm very excited to see how all this Pro proceeds and yeah
080this is great thank plan on doing the survey starting in third grade I don't know if I was clear on that but it's definitely going to be third grade enough okay thank you Dr hlin thank you for your report and yeah um okay I was gonna cut the discussion off on this item and get ready to move along we have a a long agenda left on ourselves so again thank you Dr Hamlin very much I'm going to suggest board that we take a five minute recess stretch your legs and do whatever but I want to keep it to five minutes and uh we have the poor demographers are going are they going to put it off again but uh we're going to take a five minute recess just need to stretch you to just keep
081one of the which one the two we call these our gold snaps not too little and not too big yeah they've been us'll I'm get here on the there are copies of that in here in the finders but they're so little and you got flip to the ring you know so we like this is this is my favorite map I love this it's everybody's favorite map our GIS guys think we're crazy but when I drive the district I need the big map right yes e e e I'm like yelling at him to get the picture there with the lock didn't I haven't seen you you been SI I call this regular meeting of the board uh for Carolton Farmers Branch ISD back in to session at 810 p.m. um our next item on the agenda
082is forb a report from our demographer uh Chris Mr Moore I believe we're gonna turn it over to you thank you Mr shackman trustees Dr Eldridge um work has been underway the past several months on the district's demographic study we have partnered with population and Survey analysts for this year's report and they uh work with fast growth districts uh stabilized districts districts that are in the midst of stabilizing which is always a challenge um slow growth both districts declining all sizes all shapes across the state of Texas um they are well versed in what they do it would be hard pressed to find another group that is as skilled and Adept and uh in tune with the numbers as Pasa is they have been working with us since at least September uh to collect and
083study data sets um they gathered current and past student population analysis um housing projections they've worked with all of the Cities within our district working with the cities uh the the Departments there uh studied e economic Trends real estate Trends and how these numbers impact both CFB as a whole and then within our specific attendance zones and so you all know better than most that uh long-term planning is key our last demographers report was October of 22 and so uh we want and we need the most comprehensive the most recent and the most accurate data um uh in order to to plan longterm and so the October 24 snapshot data was key for this and so we appreciate the leg work they did before G Gathering uh when that came out and then pushing through
084to get this to you tonight um after that snapshot data became available um because the demographics data you'll see here tonight is going to combine with the criteria that's been established by the facilities planning Advisory Group and as we continue uh working through the progressions of of Campus consolidation and we're going to bring you all a comprehensive proposal of all of this in February and this is key uh a key part to that so with that I want to introduce Chris P and Susan Kates from Pasa and I will turn the lecturn over to them okay good evening Mr shakman and board members Dr Eldridge uh that was a great intro so I don't have to say all that much we are from College Station population and Survey analysts and we hope to give you
085a bit of an overview I see you all thumbing through the copy of the report that you have there we we saw your agenda so we do hope to keep this kind of high level and give you a bit of an overview but hopefully this data like you said will be used by your committee moving forward and I expect a a whole lot of back and forth between us and the administration here over the next couple of months but to give you an idea of the process like you said we started in about September we start Gathering and collecting background data some of that may be census data or American Community survey data but one of the thing that's very very important is that we start building an extremely robust GIS map and we've provided
086the district with large copies of that map and I hope you all see it um we provide every district with about 10 copies or so and I got a request just yesterday uh from a district that had just gotten them and they want seven more you know they give them to their police department and they give them to all these departments because they're very detailed and that's very important for us to understand what the lay of the land is in the district itself we have to study economic and housing data are you going to have regeneration are you going to have new homes are they single family multif family and so Susan will be speaking to that a lot we study your past and your current student population we geocoded a couple of sets of
087of student data from you guys you'll see here in a minute the kids up like little dots all over the map but we want that history also because we want to understand what's going on in your existing subdivisions how does kindergarten move to first grade how does K4 become one5 the next year and so that is very important for us we generate the projections under three scenarios a tenure um assessment that we start with but we also sort of have a low and a high and we'll talk a little bit about about that and then we can take that data and the way we have it gathered We Gather it down to a little planning unit level s little puzzle pieces that we'll see in a minute and that way we can do things we
088combine it into your current zones and then we can break it apart into new zones and move things around and and do that long range planning but we'll start with just demographic Trends a few things just to sort of Hit the high points here this is the entire region a fiveyear numerical change now this ended in Fall of 23 because fall of 24 data of course is being turned in but we can't get it probably until about April and so this is the most recent data of available and what this really shows is that the blue areas I know we heard a little bit earlier about surrounding districts that were losing students the blue areas here are the areas that have lost students in the last five years and so we prepared we've prepared this
089mount for almost as long as I've been with a company which is more than two decades and watching that blue spread outward has been quite interesting um there are some districts on here this is still showing some growth in Capel they uh gained $489 students during that fiveyear time period I know there's another couple of these that are showing growth that have begun to lose students and so do you realize that these numbers that blue is likely to keep marching outward from the center of the DFW area this is what your enrollment looks like sort of on a a chart I know this is probably not a surprise to you guys uh it's been steadily downward a little bit the most uh the largest enrollment number that we could find in our data set was
0902011 it was 26,400 and some odd students students we could look out to 2002 relatively easily and the the number that we had for the fall actually was the the lowest number there uh since the 2002 and it's about 2200 students down from that high point but it's not a precipitous drop off like uh some of the the surrounding districts may be seeing now one of the difficult things for us to get at is the kindergarten enrollment how many students are going to walk in the door for kindergarten um because we can't knock on the door and ask how many 3 and four year olds are behind everybody's door they're not going to answer us and so what we can get at is the birth rate by ZIP code of the birth mother and the
091zip codes don't line up with the school district exactly and so we break that using population points and try to get a good estimate of that and so what we then can do is take the burst and compare that to kindergarten five years later and so that's what you see here and you can see they've trended relatively fairly closely together but slightly downward over time and so we can look out that Gray Line is sort of where we are now and so we can look out several years for those 1 2 3 and four year olds there and we can see that it's a little flatter and in a couple of zip codes in your district there was an uptick and so we have built in just the tiniest bit of an uptick in those
092areas that were sort of in the central portion of the district where those zip codes were something to continue to watch if there were to be a little bit of an upte and burst that will mean a little little bit of regeneration there and it's certainly something I think you guys would probably be happy to see but this this is how we try to get at those kindergarten students that are going to be coming in your door starting next fall going on to past and current students I want to stop and explain here just briefly on this map and in basically every table that you'll see in that report the data is gathered at the planning unit level and so knowing that we were going to be doing zoning and and planning and all of
093these things here we very carefully cut the district into what we call planning units and so they may be um uh subdivisions may be a combination of a couple of subdivisions but they do fit inside your current zones and all of the data is gathered to that level and so for the plan actually the data is gathered to the development level it is summed and projected forward based on the planning units and so when we uh we can take the planning units for each one of these planning units we have the number of projected students by grade group for each year of a 10year time frame and so we take them we put them back into your current zones and then we can do the planning based on that now I mentioned the student geocoding
094uh this is is uh sort of how this looks and what this shows is two years laid on top of each other and sometimes these Maps aren't very interesting but sometimes they are and you can see a couple of three different locations where you have yellow dots and what that means is those are students that addresses that did not exist in 2019 and so somewhere in the north you can see sort of the highlands of Carolton and roseme you can see some yellow up in there uh on the Eastern side Brook Haven Hills West and sort of in the central is the asbery Coventry and Kensington there near 635 so this is where you've had some new students new housing uh come in since the fall of 2019 and I don't want to belabor this
095point too much but we also do have to take into account uh how students and classes are moving through the district occasionally you will have a really large second grade class and that means that chances are next year you're going to have a fairly large third grade class so we have to understand all of that as it's working through this just takes your enrollment and it color codes it from K through 8 and from 10 through 12 skips nth grade because nth grade is so often the largest um uh class in the district and it shows the brightest red where there are large numbers in that cohort and so you can see some of these large cohorts work their way through the system and so this is something that also has to be taken into
096account uh on top of you know any new development that's coming in or or any of the attritional retention things that are going on and something very vital for us to understand is how many students uh are um emanating from each one of the single family or the multif family units in the district right now the single family ratio for you all is a 31 and the multif family ratio is a 0.25 now that single family ratio is is very low for most of our clients um most people may assume that how many kids are you going to have in a house you're going to have two well well they're not all enrolled in the school district at that same point in time I've got two kids but they're in college and so if somebody
097were measuring me my house would count as a zero and that zero has to be averaged in with everybody else also anybody that's transferring out anybody that's homeschooling anybody that's Charter schooling counts as a zero and so that ratio is a. 31 now that is the average for the district and we don't actually use that for anything except for the creation of this slide we have it broken down in the report by by subdivision and so you can see that on one end you got nine subdivisions that have fewer than 05 students per home and then on the flip side you've got four that are greater than7 five students you've got greater than three4 of a student in every house and those four I did notice when I was looking this up that the median
098age of all of those was sort of in the 60s and 70s for those that have the highest ratios of students per house now any new developments that are coming in uh we do not just assign a. 31 to any new development that's coming in we try to understand what development looks like whether it's single family or multif family and we assign a ratio based on uh the ratios that we are seeing on the ground and then alternative educational opportunities I know that this is this is what we've started calling uh Charter Schools private schools homeschooling virtualems etc etc um what this map shows is it shows the charter sites that we know of today both inside and outside of the district that are pulling at least some students from the district and so the
099size of the circle there shows the relative number of students that they are pulling from the district the good news is that we are not aware of any other amendments that are planned right now to bring new schools into affect the district we study the Amendments every single summer when they come out but unfortunately a lot of times they're very um General it may say we're going to open a new campus somewhere in the Northwestern portion of Dallas and so that's really difficult for us to get at because so many of the time uh so many of the times when a school opens the most of the student population is from right around it because they don't provide transportation the parents have to be willing to take those students there so the good uh the
100good news there the takeaway is that we're not aware of any others but if and when any uh do come in of course that will impact enrollment we are expecting about 150 additional students could enter Charters it's not because of anything new it's from a little infill from about a half a dozen of the charters that already exist here and the this this uh table is very similar to some of the numbers that uh we were hearing just a minute ago this tries to take a look at where are all of the kids going uh how many of the students that live in the district are attending uh a school here some of this is current data some of it is data that uh is from you know sort of last year's um information that
101was available for tea we're showing about 4,000 Charter uh students moving out or students moving out to Charters some of that is B based on Tea's numbers the largest of those we have contacted again to try to update that as best as we can for the fall um we also contact private schools I'm going to tell you that neither of those are always happy to talk to us because we're working for you guys and somehow that's the enemy and they also don't necessarily know where their kids are coming from private schools don't as much care that they're coming from this District versus that District they care that they walked in their door so these are best estimates that we can get at we also uh see 824 students and other isds virtualy some of our
102districts have very large numbers in virtualy so if I were expecting any sort of an increase maybe it would be there just based on what we see elsewhere and then we've got um based on our counts about 1300 students that are transferring into the district so what that means is about 80% of the residents that are in the district are attending the district right now and with that I'm going to turn it over to Susan to talk about economy and housing thanks Chris good evening um as we jump into uh the information about economy and housing um it's important to understand how this impacts housing in your District um we've come out of a season of very volatile interest rates and that has absolutely impacted the housing market we were down in the the low
103twos with interest rates back in 2122 we jumped up to almost 8% last year um those interest rates are stabilized izing to a new level where the market is regaining some kind of normal activity um with November rates last month about 6.8% and while inflation is is still above the fed's target of 2% um I it is flattening which led the FED to to drop 50 basis points in September and then again uh 25 basis points in November um further reductions coming in 2025 are are in anticipated um but that likely is going to hinge on the labor market which is showing some softening with unemployment numbers Nationwide creeping up this impacts the home buying Market but also commercial construction which in your District means multif family housing has also been impacted uh by this
104interest rate market so um important to kind of keep that economy factors in the back of your mind as we move through this discussion so starting off let's talk about single family residential which honestly um new single family residential is not the story in first ring Suburban cities um that comprise the Carolton Farmers Branch ISD small infield development and Redevelopment are more the story that we are looking for through this 10-year projection period um in addition uh many of the the single family residential projects that will be coming into the district are more in a town home style or zero lot line the type of uh of higher density single family residential that um is is not typically what uh families choose where they you know want the two-car garage in the backyard um so
105Redevelopment is one of the areas that we're looking at um a which is labeled on on the slide a that's Crosby Redevelopment that is the largest single family development that is coming currently that's in uh in process this is a Redevelopment at Crosby and Broadway it's going to be a mix of single family attached DET detached and live work residential um and that is adjacent to the uh Mustang station area so um that's the type of Redevelopment that I think we can expect over the coming uh coming few years also on the map we have highlight ed u the Exxon Mobile campus um I understand that this is a uh of interest to the district because it is the largest single taxpayer in terms of property tax value um in your District um there is
106going to be some Redevelopment that happens we don't have plans or or a lot of information but the City of Irving um in our conversation with them did indicate that they would like to see this include some residential as as part of that re Redevelopment so when the the group that owns that property finds that large corporate tenant they that they're looking to Anchor that Redevelopment um they will be working on a mixed use concept that goes alongside that corporate tenant um and that should include some residential um as well I don't show this on the map but also of interest is a tra of land that the city of Carolton owns sort of at the intersection of uh pgbt and I35 right at Dickerson Parkway um they own some Land There It Is encumbered
107by flood plane but they are currently studying that property they have engaged um with that property and their plan in their future land use is to include some residential there so um that's another area to to be watching so you can see on this slide we've already mentioned the Crosby Redevelopment we've mentioned Exxon Mobile um these are numbers that we would anticipate in the 10year projection period and the numbers are very very small with the largest number being 139 units at that Crosby Redevelopment and it's interesting to note that that of the five listed here all of them are in that kind of Southern Irving Los cenus uh Valley Ranch area of the district this is a heat map that shows the progress ression of of development throughout the 10year projection period um again the
108darkest red areas show the areas that have the highest amount of development through the projection period and you can see by year 10 we're looking again in that um southern area that's Irving and then along the I35 Corridor and that's largely because we're looking at town home style developments that will cluster along major Transit roadways but it's important to note that even those uh darkest maroon colors are still uh the the factor in the legend there is greater than 25 units so it's still a very small number the N the story really is more about multif family in the district and um Carolton farmer branch already has a large number of uh of apartment complexes we're projecting 90% of all of the the new housing within the 10-year period to come from multif family housing
109in on this slide we show where the um units are that are currently leasing up and the ones that are developing I have those marked um with letters on the map but you can see across the district there is a lot of existing apartments and I want to pause here because I there's a a part of the study that I don't typically do for other districts um we just kind of know that older multif family tends to have higher student ratios because it becomes a source of affordable housing for low to moderate income families newer multif family developments are typically targeted toward young professionals and that's what we're seeing in your District these are mixed use developments um anchored with Transit lines Mustang station um Trinity Mills station these are um highly amenitized and quite
110expensive apartment communities that have very very low student ratios so I actually ran an analysis and it's on page 32 in your um in your full study that shows you the trend line and it is a perfect downward line from the from the units that were built in the 60s have the highest student ratios and the ones built in the 2020s have the lowest student ratios and as we begin to talk about Redevelopment it is important to note that when Redevelopment comes in and they tear down an old apartment complex and replace it with a new apartment complex you will lose students because you're going from an affordable housing uh source to one that is um pricing out U the people that are living in those markets so on this map you can see Mercer
111Crossing and Irving continues to add um up scale multif family in that master planned Community again we mentioned Trinity Mill Station and Mustang station are both very popular with young professionals so what to watch I've identified two things that I think that um the district should be kind of watching upcoming over this 10-year projection period the first is Redevelopment on the multif family side we just addressed that on the single family side you probably have the opposite issue what I think we're going to see in this life cycle of young professionals moving into these upscale apartments that are in the pipeline in the district is that they're going to get married and they're going to have children and they will want to stay in those neighborhoods that are familiar to them those are the people
112that are going to go into older neighborhoods and purchase those homes and renovate them and stay in the district it's not going to yield an increase for those neighborhoods but it might be what keeps those neighborhoods from declining in terms of student population so the goal would be that they stay flat so Redevelopment um all of the the municipalities that we talked with all said yes we are starting to see that kind of Redevelopment coming into our communities and then the other one is infrastructure development particularly flood plane management we mentioned that property that the city of Carolton owns and they are already in process working on a study that will allow Redevelopment or development on on that tract of land and the other one is the Exxon Mobile site there is quite a bit
113of drainage issues um associated with that site and in order to fully develop that property over time they will have to M mitigate some drainage issues on that site finally just in summary we're projecting about 6,200 new housing occupancies over the 10year period with 90% of those in the multifam sector um 9% in single family and then about 1% in other types of houses which would be age restricted housing or build to rent communities and with that I'll turn it over to Chris and let her tell you how that translates to students okay and we're going to try to wrap this up I know you guys have a lot to do tonight so we're going to hit just the student projections here this slide shows a little bit of a summary of kind of what
114we've already talked about um how exactly we go ahead and build the projections we've mentioned birth rates being uh relatively flat having been declining couple little places maybe a little bit of an uptick that we're watching how that relates to kindergarten class sizes we do have a little bit of growth in some areas that we're showing in in some kindergartens regeneration Susan has mentioned that cohort size this is kind of similar to the Aging of the current students what do the students that are coming up behind the current kiddos look like alternative educational opportunities of course and then the new housing construction is uh contributing a around a Max of a thousand students per year during that 10 years and so I mentioned earlier I think that we developed three scenarios of growth and so
115we utilize the one that is the middle that's our moderate growth that's our U 10e scenario and that's the dash line there over the over 10 years that shows about a thousand student decrease so it's a fairly similar sort of to what you all saw this year um we also have the The Accelerated one there to the to the top and a reduced one there to the bottom the reduced one would assume that you don't have regeneration that you have uh charter school or two open up that we don't know about the accelerated one actually dips and then comes up if you see that a little bit and so that would assume more of a build in the birth rates and the kindergarten students increasing upward like that and so these are the things to
116watch we hope to kind of bracket in where you might end up being over time now this this is based on attrition retention rates that are occurring now we broke it out by School in some ways we broke it out lots of different ways this was a major part of the study for you guys um and we've also averaged that attrition retention this year um differently than the last couple of years but that's you know kind of data nerdy stuff but at the end of the day this does not um really account for a a market change in marketing impact uh we have heard of of one District I hate to say much about it because they don't have their the raw the actual data in my hand yet but that had been losing a
117lot has done a lot of marketing and they gained students this year so I'll be real interested to get that download from tea in April and see how things look uh for them so it also does not include vouchers though so we have been uh very rapidly trying to gain information on vouchers and how those programs have worked elsewhere but we have not in tried include it anywhere it's going to have to be another layer that's laid on top because we don't know what that program might look like so we're going to have to everybody I think is going to have to be reassessing that sometime in the spring another thing that I want to really emphasize here is resident students versus enrolled students um We Gather students based on where they live but that
118doesn't always mean that's where they actually attend school and so anybody that is transferring out we are accounting for in attrition retention rates that are specific to the area anybody that is transferring in we assume that that transfer rate stays pretty similar and we assign them to the attendance Zone the little planning units to where they're actually attending school right now but then we also have to count for your inter District uh transfers from one school to the next and so we start with those geocoded students and normally when we're doing our work we start with geocoded and that's kind of what we normally deal with but in the maps that you're going to see here and most of the information there we have gone ahead and included the the transfer students on top of
119that because you do have several schools where you're adding or subtracting a couple hundred students and that's important I just a reminder here that data is gathered down to that planning unit level and so that's what you see in all of that there's lengthy spreadsheet and stuff that we've we've got shown in that report and those are our little puzzle pieces and then we put them together into your attendance zones and then we can break them apart to do the planning of course this shows your projected students for the first year the fifth year the 10th year we project for 10 years because it takes a long time to build new facilities if people need them and stuff but we know that those first few years the ones that are the most likely to be
120uh correct these are colorcoded based on the gain or loss that we're expecting and none of these gains or losses are very large a lot of them are 50 students one way or the other and some of them if you look they may go up for a little while and then back down a lot of this is based on you know you can see the some of the red there in the South if you go back and think about the heat map that Susan showed it's maybe only 100 students per year but it was sort of clustered down in that southern portion of the district and then in the northern portion of the district where we're showing some losses um you've got some schools that are have much smaller kindergarten and first grades that will
121be replacing larger fourths and fifths and so that all comes into play of course when we compare to uh the capacity we're showing some pressure of La Alita but nobody no none of the other campuses were expecting to be a problem um with being over capacity and then this shows our utilization level based on those numbers that I've just talked about uh compared to capacity and so the maroon is where you're showing the heaviest utilization of a facility the darker Blues are showing the lighter utilizations of those facilities and if you see the decreases in some of those areas uh it may be like in fno there are presently 38 students in kindergarten geocoded there resident students that live in that zone you've got 61 third graders and 52 fifth graders and so you can
122see how that can work through the system and net some losses over time um there are several others that are are similar to that and then those student populations then of course move up to be middle school students and so you end up seeing similar sorts of things here again these are colored based on uh gains and losses you do see some some gain there at pulk right now for example there are 3 uh 73 students in first grade that live in that pulk zone and you've got 286 sixth graders and so you know we can see some of those things that are likely to work through we do have to account for students that are might leave along the way or or choose to do different things but nonetheless we're we're um seeing a
123little gain here little loss there at the middle school level we're not expecting any of the schools to be over capacity and several of the schools are are quite well utilized you do though toward the end of the projection period have some that are uh have lower levels of utilization there and at a high school level it's kind of a a similar sort of thing all of those factors come into play when we apply the transfers to the high school students all of the high schools end up losing students because they go to the early uh College High School school that doesn't have a zone so we count that as a transfer out to elsewhere they may go to some of the alternative programs and other things uh so these are the the projections here
124uh we are showing a a bigger loss there in Creek View of the north none of them we're expecting to be over capacity and the high schools are I think um better utilized but you do have you know one or two that are a little lower but none of them are expected to be overc capacity by the end so then the next steps the district is going to be using this data studying your existing attendance zones and I think your committee is going to be hard to work they've already you know had a I think from my understanding really good meeting last night and then we'll be doing some work uh with the district to move forward with their long range planning and so with that I'd like to open it your questions great thank
125you board members any questions she's in school again this from the last time um thank you for your report very um deep um but I wanted to ask you quickly um on your single family. 31 and your multif family 0.25 percentages you know since um our pandemic um our Southern areas of Carolton as well as Farmers Branch doubled and tripled up on families living in s single homes as well as families from those areas going have to move out or are homeless and move up north to our Creek View area with families that have big homes so how is that taken into account if at all and I mean what is is there a study we have um other districts where you know multiple families maybe siblings or something living in a large home is
126the norm in in areas and so what that means to to us is a higher number a higher ratio of students it doesn't matter to us if it's single F if it's one family or two families we want understand what's going on today in in that neighborhood um if we see evidence or a reason to think that the situation may change markedly then we could go in and pull some of those those students out but for the most part it takes a lot of movement to when you're talking all of the homes in the district it takes an awful lot of movement to move that number and so for the most part that's a a measurement for us and like I said we never use the3 one except to make that slide um but we
127look at it specifically by by development another question is regarding our newcomers up in the Dallas Northern Dallas Northern far Northern Carolton area um huge huge population of Venezuelans double triple families in an apartment as well as down Trinity Mills before you get to Kelly the apartments and the condos on the southern side another huge uh newcomer we had we several several multif family we talked about this Susan may want to speak to it that had extremely high ratios that we talked about it is very rare to see a multif family that has um a student ratio of 0.91 and um and you actually do have that and and what you're speaking to absolutely confirms that and and just like we said earlier um that those Class B Class C Apartments the ones that were
128built um at through maybe the mid90s do become the affordable housing solution for low to moderate income families and we often see just like you were mentioning on in in single family homes we also see that in apartments and um and so some of those High ratios High student ratios that we're seeing in multif family complexes in this particular District do indicate that we have maybe even multiple families living in apartment units and how does that impct the figure or the numbers it's reflected in the numbers because we geocode the students to their actual physical address so if you have um you know if you have five students living at one address it's still going to to calculate into that student ratio for that subdivision or for that apartment complex and what about the students
129that aren't enrolled is there a measure for that or you have no way okay we don't we don't we can't get at that number anyway we can't get at the homeschoolers very well because tea doesn't track them and if they don't show up especially like a kindergartner that enrolls in some program in Georgia never comes into the the in the door and we can't track them we have no way to track them so in an area that is you know has a lot of homeschooling that ratio is going to be so much lower anybody else go ahead thank you for your presentation it's very detailed um we had um our board had a joint meeting with Farmers Branch um City uh about a couple weeks ago and they mentioned that there is a new um
130school going across from Brook Haven so I just wondered if you got that information um I'd have to look it up um I can find out we have a a lengthy table okay um you know what kind kind of school it is um they said it was called Preston Hall special education okay school but they didn't have any idea how many students it was going to house so I was wondering if you could find out that information for us I know one that is um I it I believe that is one that is going into uh uh it was an office building and it's got yes we do have that one on there and I gave that information to Ben great anyone else else thank you so much wow you've given us a A month's
131worth of good reading here well good I hope I hope it's riveting just thank you very much absolutely okay board the next item on our agenda is item five our consent agenda the consent agenda is a tool that the board uses to approve a number of routines items with a single vote in compliance with the Texas open meetings act the public notice for this meeting includes all consent agenda items the board has been provided ample information about these items in advance prior to any action taken on the consent agenda board members May request uh withdrawal of individual items for clarification or discussion board members are there any yes um I'd like to request the removal of item five U uh consider approval of minutes from the Board of Trustees joint special meeting with the city
132of farmit Branch held November 19th 2024 I'd like to remove that for individual consideration please okay we have item U that we will remove for individual consideration anything else then do I have a motion for the the consent agend Miss Brady I make a motion that we accept the consent agenda with the exception of letter U 5 U to be exact um as presented I have a motion from Miss Brady is there a second Miss Hatfield has seconded the motion any discussion not all in favor please raise your hand we have seven y's there are no nay Miss Canada you see that all right moving on to item six on our agenda items for discussion and or action uh first item is number a or letter a uh items removed from consent it was five
133you missbach would you um I was not able to participate in that meeting so I don't want to participate in any action related to it all okay so do I have a motion Miss I move that we approve item five you the uh minutes of the Board of Trustees joint special meeting with the city of Farmers Branch on November 19th 2024 as presented we have a motion from Miss safield is there a second uh Miss Benavides seconds the motion any discussion all in favor there are six votes for one vote recusing okay excellent uh 6B is next on our agenda and uh this is a water waste man or water management system uh Mr Moore shackman trustees Dr Eldridge um tonight we are um it's really a pretty cool opportunity it's one of a kind
134in the north Texas area and uh it's really exciting for us uh two primary portions first of all CFB was chosen for this um and in large part it's because of the work of these three individuals that are uh they're dressed up nicely tonight they look nice every day I shouldn't say that that's terrible but they are some Sharp Dressed men this evening U Mason drivers our energy manager Bobby Shaw of course our facilities director Dan Lopez um those three have been key in this and then um a second big aspect of why we're excited to see if these is the only School District in the area selected for this specific program um and it's Hydra point they're among the national leaders in um Smart Water Management Solutions uh they've got a lot of product
135lines that uh they they help maximize water savings uh they reduce operating costs and really achain achieve sustainability goals and for us we're going to be able to grow sustainability goals this is an opportunity that we've not really ever had before um and the partnership with hydr point it began um in its infancy if you will I believe around February of 201 before um when um these three and these two gentlemen who I introducing the SEC began talking about a potential pilot program um and um it's um it it uh we were able to venture into that pilot program at Stark Elementary um this summer um it's uh it included asset mapping remote access from any internet-based device and um that remote access is something that we got to experience firsthand not too long ago
136I believe there was a PTA after hours evening movie and uh a work order did not get submitted to shut off the water that evening and um with a couple of phone calls and a click of a button we were able to to remote in and turn off the water and minimize the uh the shower that those in attendance were were experiencing um but the experience at Stark has been successful uh We've enjoyed it and um there's an additional opportunity now that Microsoft is partnering uh with hydropoint and um we found ourselves um and the opportunity toh take part in that through our existing partnership but also because uh we are square in the middle of nor Texas and The elmfork Trinity wated and the growth around us is so exponential and water is becoming
137such an important resource uh that Microsoft and hydropoint are venturing into into this and so tonight what you're going to see is proposal uh that would allow us to extend the agreement um to an additional 20 campuses and receive assistance from hydr point and from Microsoft saw for the next 10 years um and potentially save um what these guys estimate could be upwards of 20 million gallons per year throughout CFB uh through this partnership so with that uh allow me to introduce Ed hodnet and Jeff Welch I told them I would get their presentation up before they got up here and I didn't do it but there we go Ed hodnet and Jeff Welch well thank you for allowing us to speak uh president shakman Dr Eldridge and the steam members of the board we're
138excited to be here tonight representing Hydra Point um our relationship with CFB started in in uh really in 2023 when your energy team in uh were introduced to us and we started a dialogue trying to understand what the needs and goals were for the district uh that as Chris had outlined uh culminated in a in a proof trial to just demonstr R what our Solutions can do both on the eliminating Water waste side of things but also improving operational efficiency if you're dealing with you know limited um Staffing and and just funding there's got to be ways to tighten budgets we're leveraging technology to do that through that relationship and and starting that that process or during that we were introduced to um or we're able to to U strike a partnership with Microsoft and
139Microsoft to just put it bluntly in their data centers aren't really able they use a tremendous amount of water to uh in that process mainly to cool and they're not able to really cut that back so they were looking for a way to partner with public entities to say we will fund your you know implementation of efficiency uh systems uh in trade for allowing us to to sort of help uh take credit for those water offsets and in reducing that Water waste so given our relationship with the team at CFB we were able to introduce this idea and that's where we're at tonight um is to you know present it to you and gain your consent to hopefully move forward because it is truly a once you know it's a tremendous opportunity um so you
140can see where on the slide that's on the the screen right now where the Microsoft data center roughly lies and roughly where CFB lies it all falls in that Watershed and it made this a very very attractive uh program to Microsoft we're also working with them in other areas geographically where they have data centers to find similar Partnerships that we'll be working with and you know uh again as we've talked about we had a prior engagement with CFB uh we were working on that uh just to demonstrate our overall value given your location given the size of this district and the number of schools and your water use um you know this fit that that de or that profile that that we were seeking for Microsoft and that's where it's uh evolved to and so
141you know truly in summary what we're talking about is outfitting those 20 schools at least initially with the correct you know irrigation equipment and shut off devices uh flow sensors so we can monitor what goes out um you know on those campuses the systems will be set up to you know provide for Optimum hydration we're not looking to starve the the campuses for water we want to keep their attractiveness High because you want to keep your your enrollment high but there are countless small ways that we can save water on a daily basis reducing leaks um you know just adjusting that uh those watering or irrigation schedules based on the most accurate weather information that's available adds up to significant savings and so uh again um everything just sort of came together to point at
142this could be a very good partnership should the board decide to go forward with it um other you know items that would need to be considered is you know you will see cost savings not just in water but also in labor and the ability for your teams to be able ble to Monitor and manage things at those individual campuses uh very time efficiently using their existing smart devices and so like you the example at Stark you had an event water came on you know it happens but because of the technology they could could resolve that very very quickly and and not uh destroy that event um and you know one of the things that has come up in some of the dialogue most recently is you know could not just you know saving money and
143water for the the district could this be used for educational opportunities for your students and we would welcome you know the opportunity to participate in you know the continuing technical education or stem programs to try and promote again that sustainability aspect because demographics although they're shifting that was a very interesting presentation we're going to continue to see growth in Texas that's going to put more and more uh stress on the existing aquafers on the existing Delivery Systems so every drop we can squeeze out of existing uh systems using technology will be a benefit and I'm hogging this Jeff y keep going um so that's sort of a general overview of of you know the relationship the district will be the primary beneficiary we will be the technology provider and partner and also provide technical assistance
144training and and OverWatch for these systems to make sure that this program is successful sucess Microsoft is our you know funer and they're the benefactor or the the uh um I guess the the not the benefactor but the the philanthropist that that is offering this opportunity to the district and then we'll be utilizing local contractors to perform the actual installations and um uh conversions of these systems to to make sure we're supporting the local community so the short version of it as this slide comes up what we're looking at doing the simplest way to explain it is we're taking your old irrigation controllers off that control your landscape sprinkler systems putting in a smart controller that's controlled by weather so it's going to be adjusting according to what the weather conditions are and what that
145plant material needs okay then we add in flow sensing devices that just go in line with the irrigation system that's going to detect your leaks unauthorized watering kids get in turn open a valve um starts going they're out there playing in three minutes it's going to shut it off it's going to send these guys an email alert to let somebody know that hey we got water going on it's going to be able to address stuck valves valve that runs all weekend long no one sees it or wasting a ton of water that stops after three minutes so that's kind of the simple version of what we're looking at doing and it's a very simple retrofit to do we're taking an old controller off putting a new controller on we're not doing anything else out in
146the field except for installing that flow device but we're not dealing with heads we're not you know fixing that type of stuff we're not trying to optimize that right now we're putting the brain on there and that's going to control what's going on everything is internet based so wherever they have internet connections a phone an iPad a computer they can be at home that's kind of what happened at Jamie Stark somebody was at home just jumped right on there turn that thing off and they can make any kind of adjustment all stated and then uh you know Jeff is really kind of gone through this we can we can go through this in detail if you'd like but the bottom line our our company has been founded on providing uh solutions to a broad range
147of of uh entities Nationwide we've been in business for over 22 years um in Texas other uh entities that you're familiar with that that employ our Technologies currently include Denton ISD and Dallas ISD um Austin ISD uh mine cville um has a has a pretty large deployment um AT&T Stadium um has our Solutions on the outside they don't water inside the dome but uh you're in good company and we have a a dedicated team myself and Jeff and then other support assets that are here to help your teams get the most out of this and then so the timeline where we're at we have signed our agreement with uh Microsoft we are moving forward in in other geographies um we're at the the point now we're presenting it to the board uh we need your
148approval and then uh to finalize and then uh the contract execution um and then it's really a kickoff in implementing these Solutions between now and irrigation season next next uh spring uh for when this would go into effect that'll give you the maximum benefit going in uh through 2025 so the big question is what's Microsoft thrown into the mix it's about a million dollars that they are putting up for this okay so it's a 10-year contract where we got all the technology going in um all of our controllers have subscription fees tied to them so your internet connections your cellular devices um how it communicates um training all these different aspects feature upgrades that's all included we don't come back to you in two years and say hey got something new you want to try
149this out it's going to cost you more money it's all included in 10 years okay and Microsoft's putting the bill they're excited about the opportunity they've seen our um analytics on how we've figured out you know where we're going to be at with savings we do that all the time for many of our customers and they're very accurate and so they jumped on board so they're actually putting it's roughly a million dollars into your guys' hands there is no repay back there is know if it doesn't succeed and meet the expectations of the water conservation goals it's it's paid for it's done it's over with so it's very very simple clean cut and dried water share programs are very difficult um you guys have probably dealt with Esco companies coming in doing toilet fixtures and
150electrical and oh my gosh that's an interesting experience this is very very simple cut very clean so that's that's a yeah e excellent board members any questions start with Miss Ben thank you um I have a question a neighbor of mine went to an automated thermostat thinking oh it's free free free free but then she receives an email that states we have the opportunity in at Liberty to let you know when you can heit your house instead of 70 to 72 or can't run it at 68 in the summer right what type of control is there Beyond you Microsoft and whomever that might say uh too bad we cannot we're in conservation cannot water your plants this year month whatever that's really not one of the the aspects of this because because the goal of
151the smart technology is to keep your Landscapes you know optimally hydrated but get rid of those that momentary waste I mean most irrigation controllers are about as intelligent as the last human that put their fingers in it and took their best guess at what the next 30 60 90 days might do to you from a water uh demand standpoint so with this the way the the weather track system is set up it will keep your Landscapes optimally irrigated there is no pressure to say okay let's starve them more and if things look a little bit you know funky we'll wait until somebody complains that's really not the goal of it at all um so I don't know if that did that address your question when you talked about weather um what about snow mageddon there
152was no wind and a lot of things went bad how will the weather impact your system's ability to work if there's no electricity no wind Etc well yeah and obviously I was I was here for snowmageddon um in that case we wouldn't be irrigating in in any case um if we hit it freezes it pop and then boom we've got a well the the good news about that is if you do have Frozen uh pipes the flow sensor that will be installed at each one of these schools will be able to detect that so when things thaw out and that water starts flowing if it's not you know given the okay by the controller it's going to alert your team hey we've got a problem out here and so they will be proactively notified thank
153you so every day it is adjusting according to the type of plant material that's in the ground and what's going on with the weather the on the right hand side is kind of what we call ET how we measure um you know the water in the soil and the way that works the simplest way to do it is take a bathtub fill it up with water put it out in the parking lot it's 100 degrees outside and windy you're going to evaporate a lot of water out water level is going to go down in your bathtub once it goes down to a certain point you turn the faucet on to fill it back up that's what we're doing for every individual Zone across your whole Campus based on how we program it it's going to
154fill up that bathtub maybe Zone one but zones three and four no they got plenty of water still they're doing fine because they're a different type of plant material obviously grass uses more water plants use less water so that's how that's adjusted but when we start going into the winter months we will have rain-free sensors um installed their wireless devices and they will be done on um each one of the schools and so if the temperature does drop down to a certain level that immediately will shut off all irrigation we're measuring what's happened in the last 24 hours to what's going to we're going to do today we're not looking into the future so the rain sensor devices and the rain freeze will stop freezing you know irrigation when it's freezing but if enough irrigation
155goes on rainfall starts falling while the sprinklers are running once it hits a certain threshold it then sends a signal down the controller shuts that off we call it a perception device somebody's walking their dog out there and they see the sprinklers going in the rain they don't understand that we have Smart controllers out there that are going to adjust the next day according it rained and we water it's G to shut that off right away bready thank you all very much it's very exciting and I um super appreciate y'all and Microsoft for paying for it so it's even better um I just had out of curiosity what is 20 million dollar 20 million gallons of water save us I mean like as far as financially what are we going to save how much money
156is that worth roughly just that's big exact that's that's a great question uh 20 million gallons divide that by a thousand that would be got a rough idea on that he's a sustainability gu we were all looking at Mason he's going I didn't G different water agencies measure their units differently some are in in cubic meters and other are are thousand gallon units okay um but it's a significant amount of of money for there to be a an Roi where you know Microsoft would be willing to pay for it yeah no that's well we'll figure out the number and get back to you okay M gar I just have one more thing yes ma'am when technology meets this amazing thing it it really does good things Partnerships technology I mean everyone's sometimes scared of this
157but this is really beneficial for all of us so this is wonderful you I know you guys mentioned it's at Stark how many more campuses were you planning on putting it up 19 more okay under this program and and where we had started before the Microsoft introduction was looking at a phase program of changing all the schools ultimately based on the the amount of water they use annually so that was going to be something that that you know uh were we successful in that we'd be coming to you for funding from other sources this just is a Serendipity that that you know sort of materialized out of the blue and because of our groundwork with your team here it was just this is a no-brainer it's right in their backyard thank you very much thank
158you for the app and thank you for turning off those sprinklers when they needed to be turned off Mrs Barnes I just have two quick questions um one of them you mentioned like if the water was left on for three minutes there's a shut off is that something that can be overridden oh absolutely okay I just want clarify and just to clarify how that works so if if you've got a scheduled irrigation event and the first Zone comes on let's say a bus had cut a corner and snapped off the top of that sprinkler well it's going to be putting out quite a bit more water um the system will have learned what that zone should have been putting out and it's going to recognize hey wait a minute this is more it's going to
159give it a couple of minutes to make sure it's just not filling the pipe and then it'll go wait a minute we've got a problem it'll shut that zone down it'll send an alert to your team um so that's that's how that works yeah I'm thinking more in terms of like field day and we're trying to fill up big buckets of water and you were talking about a faucet getting turned on or he was actually referring to how water the depletion modeling Works to to just apply with the plants all right excellent and then my second question is um when you're talking about you know that it will it can detect whether it needs to be watered or not whether the ground needs to be watered can it also detect that it needs that it's
160not getting enough water like in terms of that maybe it's not whatever irrigation is working isn't working well I think I I understand your question so yes the system um it's a depletion calculation so as Jeff was talking about it's sort of like having a a bucket full of water and so um the system will will just start to subtracting the amount of water that's lost to the atmosphere each each time and then when we put water back in it it sort of balances that equation back out if it detects that a zone is not getting the moisture that it should for whatever reason uh it's going to send an alert that says hey we've got high depletion over here at the bed it's dark and maybe it's something that then we check you know
161or they thank you so much ab and one other thing just to throw on there too is also the system includes an electrical diagnostic so one of the other problems that can happen in an irrigation system is just you know and you've got older campuses the wiring to and from can be a problem the actual actuator on the valve itself can start to fail many times that's not seen until you've got damag that you've got a big ugly spot and a principal's calling and saying we've got a problem the system will does an electrical diagnostic every day on every circuit and says hey the solenoid on station five is starting to to go bad and let your team know proactively so they don't have to do an emergency truck roll they can just program that
162in when they're going to be there thank you so much yes ma'am thank you I have one question in terms of implementation uh when you start the construction on these 20 facilities about how long does that take oh you're talking probably two days for campus probably two days because you know we are cutting into pipes so we have the glue pipe so we let that set up but it's it's one of those things where we'll install everything then we'll actually go to another campus start installing and then the next day we'll come back so you we'll actually probably do two maybe three campuses in a day but then you got to kind of wait for the glue to dry and then and then once that happens then we can go through are mapping of where
163all the stations are um where the controller is where the flow sensor is where the water meters are that's all stored in a mobile app and on the computers so anyone that has access if they have one guy on vacation and the other guy's got to take care of his schools he doesn't know where anything is he can pull it right up on his phone and he's walking around there's a little blue dot on Google Maps Okay that's the problem right here and he's right there so efficiency is huge okay so it's it is a relatively quick process just isn't taking six months or okay thank you very much uh board members any other questions this is an item marked for uh possible um uh approval so do we have an amend a motion I'd
164like to make the motion that we um approve the Water Management solution agreement with hydropoint and Microsoft as presented please okay I have a motion from Mrs Brady do I have a second from Mrs Garza rohas have a second board members any discussion all in favor of the motion please raise your hand seven approvals no negative all right thank you gentlemen thank you really app and yes thank you to for being here uh on our agenda uh item C uh consider and approve the board legislative priorities um board we've all seen and worked with the legis lady priorities for some time um I'm not feeling the need for us to read the whole page with all of the information um is there any discussion or questions about that Miss Brady I was G I already
165make a motion so you ready to make a motion okay go ahead and make the motion I'd like to make the motion that we approve the board legislative priorities as presented I have a motion from Mrs Brady do I have a second uh Mrs Barnes on the second is there any discussion seeing none all in favor of the motion please raise your hand seven affirming no opposed all right uh the next item is consider uh an official resolution to vote for the nominee of board of directors for Dallas Central Appraisal District um yours is Denton not Dallas um we did not nominate anyone they were we were slow in getting the information and what we received came in after nomination period so we did not nominate anyone uh the uh gentleman from Garland who has
166been recommended and would have been recommended to us has considerable support and I believe will be elected uh just fine so I'm going to recommend that we skip agenda item D and go to item e which is consider official resolution to vote for a nominee of the board of directors for the Denton Central Appraisal District this item is marked for possible action uh board do we wish to take any action M Brady I'd like to make a motion that we nominate Mike Hefner Hefner um to the board of directors for the dunon Central Appraisal District I have a motion from Mrs Brady is there a second second is Mrs abides uh any discussion seeing none I'll ask for the vote approving that motion from Mrs Brady one I see seven in affirming and no in
167declination okay all right oh I don't know we got to figure you should not I'm gonna raise my not raise my taxes right uh due to various circumstances agenda items 78 uh were removed from the agenda and will not be heard this evening we will continue to agenda item number nine like to point out that uh agenda item number nine included two closed sessions first closed session was level three grievance hearing and the grievant approached the district and requested to dismiss that so there will not be a level three grievance hearing at the request of the grievance and we will then go to the other item on there which is scheduled to be for uh the uh review for uh superintendent and so at this point in time we're going to dismiss and go from
168The Boardroom to to the conference room for deliberations uh on this and uh the time is now 9:20 you all are welcome to stay uh I don't know exactly how long this will take we will be back so at 9:21 e e e all right we're not back that fast but uh uh apparently there is the need for us and I did not do this so I will now do it uh the number the closed session actually has several pieces we were planning to cover them all but uh so pursuant to section 55174 and 55182 Texas government code uh discussing notification to tea uh about contract bment by teacher Sydney poek uh number b letter b pursuant to sections 551 and 55182 government code discussion regarding notification to tea on contract abandonment by teacher Lily
169vicory and then pursuant to section of t uh 55176 of the Texas government code security devices will also hear a security safety update and audit results and then and we will be looking at the superintendent's formative evaluation and then we will be back after we have reviewed inlow session the time is now 9:25 e e e we are back in Open Session and The Time Is Now 11:29 p.m. our next item is to reconvene for possible action Rec regarding uh items discussed in closed meeting 10A is uh consideration and possible action uh regarding notification to the Texas Education Agency or educator certification division of contract abandonment by teacher cydney pek uh Dr Eldridge do you have a recommendation this says you have to read you ready for me it is recommended um Board of Trustees
170that in accordance with Texas Education Code section 21. 210c and 19 Texas administrative code section 249 1.14 the board approv a finding that no good cause exists for Sydney Pac abandonment of her probationary contract of employment abandonment of her position and attempt to resign from Carolton Farmers Branch ISD without consent of the board or designate on November 7th 2024 which was after the 45-day penalty free resignation deadline in less than 30 days before the first day of instruction for the 2425 school year it is recommended that the board submit a written complaint with the information required by 19 Texas administrative code 24914 J to the Texas Education Agency educator certification division state board for educator certification seeking sanctions for Sydney pac's vandament of her employment contract board this item is marked for special action or
171for possible action does the board wish to take action I'd like to make a motion Mrs Benevides I move that the board render a finding in accordance with Texas Education Code section 21. 210 C2 and 19 Texas administrative code 24914 J that no good cause exists for Sydney P's check a teacher on a probationary contract abandonment of her Employment contract abandonment of her position and attempt to resign from Carolton Farmers Branch ISD without consent of the board or design on nove excuse me November 7th 2024 which was after the 45-day penalty free resignation deadline and less than 30 days before the first day of instruction for the 2425 school year I move that the board authorized the board president to submit a written complaint with the information required by 19 Texas administrative code 24914 J
172to the Texas Education Agency educator certification division state board for educator certific ification seeking sanctions against Sydney pek a probationary contract teacher for abandonment of her employment contract with Carolton Farmers Branch ISD I have a motion from Miss benites do I have a second I second the motion I have a m a second from Miss Brady is there any discussion I yes uh Mr President I'd like to make a correction for his Employment contract with Carol defs Branch I said her oh I'm so sorry thank you okay that is done so uh with the correction from the motion uh we'll vote all in favor with the vote of seven in favor and zero opposed the motion to carries for the record let it show that item 10A consider possible action notification to tea certification division
173of contract abandonment by teacher cydney poac has had that was the wrong part you I didn't need to read that part but paragraph is there uh the next item is 10B uh consideration and possible action regarding notification to Texas Education educ certification division the contract abandonment by teacher Lily vicer Dr Eldridge do you have a recommendation um yes Board of Trustees it is recommended that in accordance with Texas Education Code section 2.21 o and 19 Texas administrative code section 24914 J the board approved a finding that no good cause exists for Lily vicary's abandonment of her probationary contract of employment abandonment of her position and attempt attempt to resign from Carolton Farmers Branch ISD without consent of the board or designate on November 22nd 2024 which was after the 45-day penalty free resignation deadline and
174less than 30 days before the first day of instruction for the 2425 school year it is recommended that the board submit a written complaint with the information required by 19 Texas administrative code 24914 J to the Texas Education Agency educator certification division state board for educator certification seeking sanctions for Lily vicary's abandonment of her employment contract thank you board this is an item marked for possible action does the board wish to take action I'd like to make a motion yes Miss Brady I move that the board render a finding in accordance with Texas Education Code section 21210 C2 and 19 Administrative Code 24914 J that no good cause exists for Lily Vicor a on probationary contract abandonment of her Employment contract abandonment of her position an attempt to resign from Carolton Farmers Branch ISD without
175the consent of Bo the board or design on November 22nd 2024 which was after the 45-day penalty free registra resignation deadline and less than 30 days before the first day of instruction for the 2425 school year I move that the board authorized the board president to submit a written complaint with the information required by 19 Texas administrative code 24914 J to the Texas Education Agency educator certification division State Board of educator certification seeking seeking sanctions against Lily vicory a probation at Contract teacher for abandonment of her employment with contract with cfbisd thank you Miss Brady I have a motion from Miss Brady do I have a second I have a second from mcar roas is there any discussion all in favor please raise your hand 70 in favor um next item on our agenda is
176comments from board members regarding posted agenda items so board members are there any comments you'd wish to make after tonight's meeting I would just like to wish everybody happy holidays and have a good time with their families thank you Miss babetes so I be at this point I determine that we have reached the end of our agenda and we are uh adjourned at 11:37