001okay good evening I now call this regular meeting I'm sorry I now call this regular meeting of Goose Creek CISD Board of trustee to order the time is now 601 p.m. Mr cesy was a meeting properly posted yes it was and do we have a quorum we do have a quorum okay I will now yield to you Dr price for the opening exercise and recognitions and acknowledgements thank you thank you Madame President superintendent board members guests and staff we'll open our meeting this evening with a Prayer by Mr Howard Samson and then we will follow with the regular opening exercises but everyone please if you got a hat on Take It Off please heavenly father thank you for this another day father thank you for the people we have here today that they made it
002safely father most of all thank you for our students because they are the most important thing to us and to their parents father thank you for the board members and our administrator and most of all our teachers thank you for all of this in thy name amen amen amen at this time opening exercises for the February 17th 2025 Board of Trustees meeting will be provided by Goose Creek Memorial High School the pledge of allegiance to the United States flag will be recited by Trinity Daniels followed by the Texas flag by Elijah limrick to the flag of the United States of America and to the for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all flag toex St and indivisible may be seated a select group of students from our high
003school will perform tonight they will sing the song thank you and wake up everybody arranged by Jay alson our students will be Maxwell Bailey Trinity Daniels Amar Jennings Elijah lri Vivian Martinez reys Ruda Demarcus small cor St John summer Vance Taylor Williams and Arnell Zam the students are under direction of crow directors Mr Douglas horel and and Miss Gabrielle wall principal is Miss Kelly Star take it away my [Music] all [Music] you [Music] you e e e [Applause] excellent do we have any parents in the audience of any of the students would you stand please great job great job everyone and we want to thank you Goose curric Memorial Choir for coming in performing for us this evening as they are exiting we're going to prepare for recognition and acknowledgements of the Houston area Alliance
004of black school Educators teacher recognition Dr romanique would you come up please while Dr romanique is coming up I want to slip in here just for a minute while we're breaking down we have some other special guests I know there's VIPs across the audience but I have a special group here from the University of Houston Clear Lake they're here visiting as a part of their doctoral program can we make pH of Goose Creek welcome will y'all please stand up stand up if you're part of the doctoral program all right y'all dress better than me tonight all right good all right Dr remin back to you Ma'am good evening Board of Trustees and superintendent Dr Randy O'Brien it is my distinct honor to recognize some of our incredible Educators who were were nominated by their campus
005principles for the prestigious hasby teacher Awards and recognition ceremony also known as tar these nominations are a testament to their unwavering dedication to Student Success and their impact on our school communities the hapsy tar Awards celebrates excellence and education by honoring Educators who demonstrate leadership Inspire students and Foster a positive and supportive learning environment for all these distinguished Educators were recognized on January 16th at the George or Brown Convention Center alongside other Regional Education leaders from across the greater metropolitan area this nomination alone is a significant achievement highlighting them as Role Models not only on their campuses but throughout the entire greater educational community tonight we are proud to celebrate their remarkable contributions and we want to thank them for their passion and service at this time I would like the following 2025 tar awardees
006to be recognized from ashbell Smith we have Mary Cruz Rodriguez [Applause] from Crockett Elementary we have Miss Tana [Applause] batist from George Washington Carver Elementary we have Jasmine Nightingale [Applause] the following two are not with us tonight but we certainly want to recognize them from Highlands Elementary we have ebony Edwards her principal is here along with Miss Bianca prosper from pumfrey [Applause] elementary representing days ofala Elementary we have jayen far [Applause] from Travis Elementary we have Tonda long [Applause] Gibson also unable to join us tonight is Kayla Jackson from Cedar Bayou Junior School we want to recognize her as well representing EF green Junior School is Mariam Williams Augustine [Applause] Highlands Junior School is Mr Robert Richard [Applause] you got the most representing Goose Creek Memorial coach Shay [Applause] Montgomery and lastly representing steuart Career
007Tech High School Mr Jesus zapa now thank you [Applause] again Dr Dr all right to the group that we just honored I want to say that um this makes me really proud of this group and honored as you were tonight but as I look at it I look at what a better time uh to take the moment to mark this this event because it's doing Black History Month and from an organization of being honored by your area Houston Area Teachers Association that see oversee this group and and I wanted to that you and guys shape every one of our student lives every day and it just brings me such gratitude and joy to sit here and be able to honor you guys tonight and and it's always a great honor to honor any of our
008teachers and it was so be fitting for the children that the students that sung tonight to you know by encouraging and such an uplifting and and I'm going date myself with the song by how in the Blue Notes that's the one I really like so uh wake up everybody you know it's a new day so if we do that we keep doing what we're doing we're going to nothing but but you you we're going to succeed with our students so keep doing what you're doing and we really appreciate I'm sorry I had to take that time but thank you Dr and thank you Dr O'Brian any of the principles of of those who were recognize would you give us a wave thank you all thank you for your support at this time M President we
009we turn it back over to you thank you Dr Price congratulations to everyone uh citizens participation and we do have one tonight and I'm going to read our little epert to that citizen participation is a time during which the board will hear public concerns or public comments from those who have properly signed up to address the board at regular board meetings the board will allow public comments regardless of whether the item is a topic on the agenda posted with notice of this meeting each speaker is reminded that he or she is limited in his or her presentation to a minimum of three minutes which can be further reduced or limited by the presiding officer please also remember you should respect confidentiality concerns are refrain from attacking the Personnel character of any individual student staff member
010or board member and addressing concerns or comments pursuant to to state law and board policy be legal the board cannot consider or take action on concerns at this meeting unless they pertain to an item on the posted agenda for this meeting any deliberation or discussion on an item that um is not posted for consideration at this meeting shall be limited to the proposal to be placed the subject on agenda for further meetings tonight we're going to call uh annaya Garcia to the podium as our speaker who has signed up our guest and Mr cesy will take your time and he will he's our timekeeper tonight our secretary and it's on you Mr cesy good evening you're limited to three minutes like President Barat Tim said we'll start the time when you begin to talk I'll
011let you know when you have one minute remaining and then I'll stop you at three minutes you can pardon me just a moment we we'll restart your time if you would lower the microphone and speak directly into it so everyone could hear you can you hear me we can hear you now sorry dear members of the school board I am here to express my concerns regarding the potential adoption of the blue bonnet learning curriculum in our schools after carefully reviewing the materials I am deeply troubled by the curriculum's approach one of the most significant issues with the blue bonnet learning curriculum is its Distortion of historical facts for example in the lesson titled the foundations of American democracy taught in 6th grade students are presented with a heavily biased and incomplete view of the nation's
012founding the curriculum downplays critical historical events such as the systemic oppression of indigenous people and the institution of slavery presenting them in a light that fails to adequately address the complexities of our nation's past this selective storytelling misrepresents the truth and undermines students ability to develop a well-rounded understanding of History by omitting essential perspectives and minimizing the impact of these dark chapters in American history we risk perpetuating ignorance and preventing students from engaging with the full scope of their Heritage as a product of GCCISD myself learning history has greatly shaped my worldview and while there are many critics of History who argue that it creates a development of a negative opinion of being American I would argue the opposite when we acknowledge the dark past in our nation we are able to celebrate those who
013fought for Change and move forward together as a society into a brighter tomorrow furthermore the blue bonnet learning curriculum introduces religion in its lessons in a manner that is inappropriate for public education in the moral foundation and values unit taught in fourth grade students are asked to explore Concepts such as the role of religion in shaping Society but the curriculum presents the these ideas from a particular religious perspective often favoring one religion over others for example in discussions about the nation's founding the curriculum asserts that many of the founding fathers were deeply influenced by Christianity without acknowledging the influence of other belief systems and or emphasizing the Constitutional separation of church and state and that freedom of religion is also freedom from one specific religion this could alienate students of different faiths or non-religious backgrounds
014and as someone whose Faith aligns with the religion being favored I am still deeply uncomfortable about teachers being po Ally responsible for introducing students to a crisis of Faith through this curriculum if this curriculum was being implemented for a private school or a homeschooled student it would be their prerogative to choose if it aligns with their views however we are a public school system who is responsible for the education of such a broad and diverse population and implementing this curriculum would be in direct conflict with the district's goal of equity I strongly urge the school board to reconsider adopting the blue bonnet learning curriculum as it risk confusing students limiting their abil ability to critically engage with historical content and violating the principles of religious neutrality in education we must ensure that our students receive
015an education that is accurate inclusive and free from ideological biases how can we teach students to have good morals if we sell their education in the name of extra funding thank you for your attention to this important matter I hope that you will make the decision that is in the best interest of our students and their education thank you thank you Miss Garcia okay we will now uh move to approval of minutes um the minutes for our last regular board meeting February the 3D 2025 was provided to each of our board members do I have a motion so moved do I have a second uh do we uh for do we uh have any discussion there be no further discussion all in favor please raise your hand okay it's approved uh motion carries with uh
016seven no am okay we will move to now to uh discussion items and Dr o BR this is your area for superintendence report so I will turn it over to you sir yes Madam president I'm excited this evening to under super reports we have three phenomenal presentations coming before you starting off with our first one from cni be the middle of the Year update on cni then we'll have our human resources annual update and special education update as well following that so thank you thank you Dr Binger Mr flood thank you good evening president BR Tims Dr o Brian and board members we're going to go through a briefing um and we will not be up here as long as we were last time unless you choose for us to be we won the award
017last time so I have my team here um it's Callahan Miss flushi Dr Martinez and uh Miss Cornelius that we'll go through what you're saying is there will be no overtime sessions for this not unless not unless Mr Clen causes it to happen all right we are here we're going to share about blue b it but first I'm going to turn it over to uh Miss flushi and she's going to talk about the just some imra reminders and then I'll come back on and talk about a process we went through as it relates to good evening thank you for your time so instructional material review approval process is what imra stands for um it was driven by house bill 16605 so House Bill 1605 is a product of a teacher committee where the state of
018Texas brought teachers together to say What are the obstacles what are the barriers to your success or willingness to continue in the profession and so when the teachers were given that platform they made an opportunity to say these are the things that are we feel are are most undermining our ability to be successful in education and so from that came some mandates out of house bill 16005 um and so one of the things that came about was the emmer process so traditionally we adopt instructional materials through what's known as a proclamation you historically have always approved instruction materials that way but as you remember from our previous meetings those are gone and so now that we're moving toward the imra process so with an imra uh the state deems they audit materials with teacher committees
019we did have several teachers from Goose Creek that were participating in those committees and they audit vendors materials and then they come up what they determine are hqm or high quality instructional materials uh for ELA currently there are only uh HQ IMS available for grades K through five but for math are available uh for K12 the state timeline was that they wanted to put out the materials for review in the winter with the goal of districts having the opportunity to adopt and Implement those by fall of 2025 so that's just kind of a quick overview right and I am going to review part of the timeline we've talked about the timeline in September and January so I'm going to kind of just have your eyes kind of rotate over to Spring 2025 and so this
020is where we've done the IM Republic comment window uh we had an opportunity to create the survey and provide links for each grade level kindergarten all the way to fifth grade we sent it out along with the uh parent letter to uh all of the parents in Goose Creek so they had an opportunity to look at a grade level that they were interested in look at the parent letter and then if they uh they had an opportunity to provide comments on any section of the unit so they got the full shebang of the curriculum uh then we had uh committee recommendations so we had a committee come out and we'll talk about that a little bit more on the next slide but we did have the committee come out and they were able to look
021at those comments that we gathered from the community and uh we created a process for that um today we are updating the board on those comments the feedback that we received and then we'll have an opportunity and some of the during the committee work we there were some adjustments uh that were going to be uh put forward for to adjust some of the things in the curriculum uh we are going to talk about the implementation timeline and then the curriculum supports and the professional development uh so by the time we get to Summer 2025 we will roll out if uh all is approved trained staff and then progress Monitor and make adjustments as it relates to Blue Bonet curriculum so on this slide here is kind of walk you through the committee we sent out
022146 invitations the individuals that were invited we had principles TLC's the ilc which is the instructional leadership committee so that means every campus had a could invite a representative uh we had uh sent out invitations to the board members also to Deans and um the T I think at the TLC's so out of all those invitations we had 74 that were accepted to come out and so when they did come out we broke them up into subcommittees and the subcommittees are listed on the slide I won't I won't read through all of them but I will move over to the committee task so we did have a task for the committee to complete so they looked at the uh comments and we had 160 responses so once they looked at those uh we put them
023in table table groups as it relates to the Great level for ELA and for Math and so once we looked at those 160 responses the step the next step for them was to decide that we want to adopt things as it relates to that curriculum that means make no changes to the curriculum like hey yes it's a goal we like everything about that unit or was it adapt do we have anything that we want to revise as it relates to the curriculum advise provide clarity about the curriculum and then abandoned removed from the curriculum so when we move on to the next slide Sarah is going to be able to put those four words were oh I'm sorry you took the mic from oh wow jeez Sarah and then we had some units where the
024parents like oh yes that's that's great so she's going to talk to you uh kind of sort about about that all right if she does but I'm going take the mic from her CU I think equal so uh for language arts there were three overarching concerns that emerged from the feedback from the community and from our staff concern number one was a curriculum appro appropriateness and engagement so just kind of in a nutshell there were concerns that it was perhaps too challenging places other people said they thought it was too simple in places and then some people said they thought it was dull and so from the committee most of their recommendations were to either adapt or to advise so uh for instance um one of the lessons where they said like in particular this
025seem like it was a dry lesson they were like we have Avid strategies we have L Ford strategies we have Kagen strategies like let's embed the good things that we have here into that lesson so that we can make it engaging uh because the curriculum's burden is to tell us what and when to teach it's our pedagogical understanding that kind of overlays that understanding of what engagement looks like what good instructional practice looks like so let's do that um with regard to um advising some of the curriculum said or some of the feedback for the curriculum said uh we really want to advise the community in any change that we're going to make whenever we think that something was too simple or too challenging we want to advise the staff through our PDS maybe create
026FAQ documents so they had a various ways that they want to advise either staff or principles uh teachers uh or Community about the changes they want to see uh for concern number two uh it was about the historical accuracy and diversity uh that was the second most common piece of feedback particularly there was a concern about the super superficial portrayal of historical facts a lack of diversity and representation we saw that um and so one of the uh recommendations that was made is that we adapt the curriculum to make sure that we are having an inclusive curriculum that we we are making sure that all of our students see themselves in the learning and there's nothing from tea that says that we can't make those adjustments we are empowered to adjust based on what we
027think is right and best um to the curriculum and so again we would need to advise um whether it's through written pacing guides what our changes are we want to make through our PDS through those FAQs online um and then one of the other things they they wanted was to make sure that we were acknowledging that while the curriculum does have historical information in it it is not supposed to be a supplement for social studies curriculum the tea has been very clear about that it is a knowledge building curriculum but you still have to have separate social studies instructional time and that would be where the lessons would go into more depth and more detail with the social studies standards it's not really the burden of the ELA um instructional blog and then with concern
028number three the need for a neutral and inclusive curriculum uh there was a concern about the volume and partiality of religious references in rla units and so we didn't see many recommendations for from the committee about abandoning lessons we did not see that but where we did it was around this concern number three and so um there for instance might be a lesson where the students are reading a poem and then for a paired passage because that's a a very challenging te for our students but a paired passage might be to bring in a hymn a specific hym and so the committee would say we would like to maybe uh adapt that lesson to replace that hymn Where as opposed to like another unit might be a larger reference to religious content and they said
029hey for this for this unit lessons one through four are okay but we would like to see you abandon lesson five um and so one of the things that we have to think about on the curricular side is when you you know all curriculums have to be built in a systematic way meaning they move from simple to more complex and sophisticated skills when you remove a Lon lesson what skill gaps are going to be created by abandoning that lesson and that's where we have to sit down and say okay we've abandoned lesson 14 that's where compound sentences were being introduced what are we going to do to adjust that and so that would be part of H cni's work that we would do on the backside with this curriculum so those are the major concerns
030that were brought about from Ela and the major work of the committee anybody have any questions or well I just think uh it's not um appropriate to answer citizens participation during a presentation but coincidentally what you just shared aligns with that and I think if you go back one or two slides Miss Jackson the bottom right hand corner that's what you were just referencing in essence so yes sir if I understand right just to be clear the the state's proposal was to align what we instruct with what they test and through that it's it may have a broad plethora of things and it's each teacher's individual responsibility and through the cni department to identify the most relevant most important lessons to be taught through you utilizing these strategies right here adopt adapt advise and abandon
031yes sir that's correct so that's really going to boil down to the instructions received from this panel uh to everyone who works in cni or in these departments but also it'll be up to the individual teacher like you said to determine the robust nature and using the Avid strategies and those types of things to incorporate to bring these lessons to life not to teach them as a caned teach this teach that I mean it's it's still a teacher's job to identify the most relevant uh teaks if you will that what has to be taught and how it's taught uh so so that it does align with the State Testing am I right yes sir that's absolutely correct and the state it's not part of h605 but part of the star 2.0 redesign was that the
032passages on the test to align to what the content that's being taught in science and social studies so if they're studying Cherokee relocation in fourth grade then we would expect to also be studying Cherokee relocation as part of the reading language arts uh curriculum again not to supplement that social studies curriculum that's separate instructional time where they go into detail there but in order to build background knowledge and build that vocabulary you think about the goal of our Early Learning Centers is to close that that knowledge Gap and that's the goal of this as well um but we would need to be looking at those recommendations from the committee yes ma'am Dr Brian but I know that critics has had some concerns on the bible-based teaching in this particular Blue Bonnet how will we meet
033the separation of church and state and and how is that going to be presented for our teachers to be able to separate that and then we have to look at our students and those students who are who may be non-Christian backgrounds and how how would that other children treat them so I know that's a lot but no that's a really important question so one of the things that we've been looking at is you know what's the volume what's the impact on this curriculum so if every lesson adds up to 100% for instance there are two major portions of the curriculum there's the skills portion and there's the knowledge portion in the skills portion almost none of the feedback came from there we have not found a single lesson in the skills portion that references religion
034in any way it's in the other portion the rla units where you find them and you know it comes down to um there's there's those sort of gray areas that that were're going to have to address because there's there's black and white references to religion in pretty much every curriculum that you encounter A Christmas Carol for instance is taught in most curriculums that you'll find and most people you know they're they're comfortable with that text because it's not being taught from a lens of like indoctrination right it's when it crosses the line um to to a which is a personal preference right based on a person's values that we have to kind of provide that Clarity to our staff so we're finding in the rla units approximately depending on the grade four to eight% of
035those lessons which is the other half so I guess approximately two to six% of what we've found audited so far has religious references so it would be categorized as advise that would definitely it could be advise it could be abandoned depending on the the degree of the if if the entire text is something that the committee felt needed to be reevaluated and that's where we would have to come in and say well we can't abandon the skills that we being taught in there so we're going to instead probably do that adapt where we supplement a different text of some sorts so but we are it's going to have to be in the pacing guides um House Bill 1605 mandates that any adjustments also are made public to our families so we' have to make it
036public to our families so that they know exactly which lessons and units have been adjusted so all of that would have to be probably online through our parent portal is how most people are sorry to ask you so many questions but I think this will apply to the other subject matters as well questions were asking you because you went first I know I sat in the wrong seat anything else though yes so oh go ahead okay so um because these are going to have to be revised on such an individual basis does that does adopting Blue Bonnet then not open the floodgates for teachers who would like to teach that religious material to do so so one of the things that the state has said is look the the tea materials are completely online right
037like the the entire curriculum is available online right now for every parent but the school district gets to decide which adjustments they feel are best and right to their lesson and we do that now right we don't ever adopt no matter what material we bring on board we don't ever teach it as is we make those adjustments based on our data based on student needs based on time um and so we would have to do that locally and then we would have to um make those recommendations to the staff and it wouldn't be recommendations it would be in the pacing guide okay you know lesson 17 has been adjusted in this way Lesson Four has been abandoned move on you know right um but we would have to do that on our side in our
038pacing guides and then make that make those adjustments public to the community as mandated by House Bill 1605 okay thank you and also just I'm sorry go ahead is your world keep going I don't know about that so this is this particular curriculum is going to make a difference in student outcome measures that and in math reading and writing so this is going to totally help us supposedly to bring scores up and is based upon uh um within a learning environment that is Christian based so I want that's what I want to kind of talk about is that we are not given religious instruction you know it's that's not what this is if you think about it um Blue Bonnet is very broad we talk about you know culture it talks about uh topics like
039history it talks about the Arts so and talks about science so they will make religious references and take sampling from our faith so it's not just Christian they have Hinduism is mentioned in there as well so I just don't want people to think that we are it's religious instruction notzing it's not preaching it's simply having those resources as a tool exactly and it just makes some references so we do have that opportunity as Sarah said that you know we can look through and some of those you know that we think may be a little bit too contentious we can remove those uh the other thing I wanted to to say briefly is that you know we've utilized amplify at three of our campuses currently now and three of them are comprehensive campuses so I say
040all that for clarification amplify is the new B it it is it has all of the te so the difference is when amplify came out it came out covid 2019 2020 so it was a you know core what is it called emergency release yeah yeah it was emergency release so now with blue bunnet that means all of the tis that's how it qualifies as HQ because all of the tis for each grade level is in there it is very transparents you already talked about the portal so parents can go in they can look at what we're getting ready to teach unit by unit ahead of time so I was saying that since we've been utilizing amplify at our three comprehensive campuses and we got data back I got data back last week and we also
041have ignite ignite is a one-on-one tutoring program where we looked at those numbers and we compared those students from utilizing ignite in conjunction with title tier one instruction we have kids knocking it out the park which means that on their project writ some of them doubled that is in that's in conjunction with tier one amplify what we're currently using and the supplemental that we're giving them tier two ignite so that's just some of the data that we've collected that uh shows because it blue bunnet is skills it's a lot of skills it's a knowledge based curriculum but it does teach a lot of the skills decoding that our students need in Alliance with assessment I would like to respond to that okay so um as you said that uh the curriculum isn't prizing it's just
042a a reference to but as Miss Sarah said um if for instance we were to have a hymn uh to compare to a poem uh a lot of hymns actually are very explicitly prizing within the hymn itself preaching how you know God is good and Jesus is um you know you know the truth and that the Christian God is the truth and so in the in the um itself it is prizing in a in a certain way and as missah said that uh a lot of these materials can be um absolutely Black or White in terms of if they reference um a religion whatsoever so uh what it then not be appropriate to just remove or or abandon those that do reference any religion and we can and I think you know for me because
043we talked a lot about the religious but there are racial things in there as well that people don't feel comfortable with you know so I think we can and that's what we've done our due diligence is reading through and getting comments from parents to see what what would definitely just send you over the edge and so if there is something that's in there that's too religious or whatever and I don't mean to say too religious because what's too religious to some may not be to the other but we also have to think in mind we all come from a different background so something that I may be like Al though you may be like Oh okay that's that's you know that's great I already disagree with what he's saying I'm good with that but I
044say nothing I'm going stay out of it oh well the point is I think the point is we don't want to be the the religious police if you will and I think the the the four strategies are really what we're going to lean on throughout this entire process in fact it's something we'll evaluate annually so should we get parents that are unhappy with the abandoned throughout the course of the year they wanted that reinstituted we'll get that feedback and we'll consider that for the annual update well in the goal isn't even to wait till the end of the year we have local policy that guides our instructional material review and feedback from families you don't have to wait if the materials are available through your portal you can look at them and then you can
045complete the there's a guidelines on the documents to complete and then we get that and then we make those reviews and adjustments you know that happens all the time and so I know we're talking talking a lot about these things in the lens of blue bonnet learning but as an Ela person for over two decades here in Goose Creek it's every year it's every year and you never can predict it I can go years and not have somebody raise a comment about a text that we've been using and then someone will call and you think gosh it you know the teacher taught it through a lens that I didn't think about that I wouldn't have taught maybe they overemphasized something maybe they read into the text in a way that I didn't or nobody else
046had and so you're constantly sort of pivoting and J and you're you're partnering with the families listening to the their concerns because voice and choice does matter it has always mattered here in Goose Creek if a parent does not want their child to engage with a text we make adjustments I like that's our process adoption is not the end game no adoption is the beginning of an ongoing process like we have local policy and guidelines that drive that I mean you very clear about that when you first preface your words that it's not mandated we can adjust we can adop uh we can change whatever we need to yes my my question is more who is the who who are the Wii you spoke about if we feel it's too much this way or that
047way then we will look at it uh can you elaborate more on who the Wii is that's actually going to look at that and make those adjustments and recommend jackon adapt advise and abandon well we if we can only put it on one person it's a committee we will have a committee we have teachers TLC's and even Community people that are involved in that so the we is a collective group yeah the public comment window was like layer one and that's what tea did they had a public comment window we uh received that feedback and then they will have ongoing uh input from the public throughout the year and make adjustments they'll have another Mr committee meet next summer as well adjusts nobody read it all up until this point and it'll become a something
048once it hits the classroom so the question you know who who is we uh and I just want that to be clear that it's not four people at a table right now we is much bigger than that yeah the imra committee alone was 76 people that attended 146 that were invited we have no desire for this to be like one person's view of what's right and best and we also have no delusion that when we make our adjustments that that will be the end thank you m so we have three more subjects to go through but let's I'm so sorry you're up Mr Samson you're up he forgot excuse me number two historical accuracy yes sir there's no history that we teach in our schools like when I was going to school in this District
049black history Latino history any kind of History so what makes this and and your words are superficial portrayal of historical facts that's right lack of diversity in representation the key is the word diversity and lack of and superficial so why are we trying to go to this program the blue bun I mean what have we been doing that makes it so different than blue bun so with regard to the superficial what are the concerns for I'll give you an example of one um there was a concern about um a unit about World War II and in the in the units and lessons on World War II it doesn't go into the nuances of the atrocities that were World War II and there's a couple of reasons for that um one we do not generally te
050Teach the full depth and breadth of genocide to smaller children um we we do by Nature most curriculums do omit some details for for smaller children um and in addition um I would say that it's it's not the remember it's not the burden of the rla curriculum to teach the social studies to the full depth and breath there are other social studies minutes where those topics are taught explicitly the goal of the rla portion of blue bonnet learning is to build schema like I said much like the Early Learning academies where you have these experiences to build background knowledge so when they're reading texts that are about these really complicated topics um like about weather change and those sorts of things they have background knowledge so that's one of the that's you asked about the
051why uh we don't have a systematic curriculum that aligns to the other content areas and that's where the state is moving the star test if you know you're going to like I said be reading about um weather patterns if you know you're learning that in science that it's possible that's going to be on the ELA it's going to be the reading portion of the ELA test and so this is the the goal to take the curriculum and align it to these other content areas so that they're kind of working together to build that knowledge base for students so how much of the historical parts that I'm talking about will be taught in this can you tell me more when you say that in other words as when I was at Sterling or whatever you know
052they taught black history okay uh you have now is this blue bondit is going to teach more historical packs besides social studies yes yes it does well and and that's typical for a language arts curriculum I mean generally we are studying about other historical EV because every te for language arts almost not every almost every teach for Lang te for language arts has to be taught with a text and those texts are almost always science or social studies based right um they're just not intentionally tied to the exact topics that they would be studying in those grades and so this is more closely aligned um to the topics that are studied in those grades that answers the question I think it's circles yeah if you'd like I can get you a list of the exact
053topics for each I mean we have that we have the list for each unit so that you can see um there are the individuals that you um often think about um whenever you're talking about um Elementary curriculum and historical people we we study about Dr King we study about Harriet Tubman um we study about like I said the Cherokee relocation events um and the only part of it is related to history a lot of it is related to science as well um so but I can get you the list of topics if you'd like that so I think his main question was is this curriculum omissive of particular historical events it's the burden of this curriculum is not to teach every historical event no sir it is there that is some um that such as
054diversity type items well I from what I have seen no I have not seen that um where the concerns have been around diversity is that if it references religion it references predominantly Christian religion so with regard to diversity that's where we were seeing those comments from those 160 public comments it was less about diversity and repres representation of ethnicity and more with regard to religious diversity and so that was why that comment was there so if from a religious standpoint and I'm Jewish yes sir are you going to is that going to be taught about the Holocaust and everything or if I'm Muslim right is that going to be taught in this particular curriculum so it no religion is taught in that in that way with regard to like those historical moments and that religion
055um it may reference it for instance there's this unit on um I think it's in second grade if I remember and it's on the idea that um we we have something we call the Golden Rule right which is technically from oh that's in kindergarten that's right thank you it's technically from a religious text right the Golden Rule but the unit isn't about that it's not about the Golden Rule being from a religious text it's about the idea that hey there are a lot of religions around the world and and many of these religions have their own golden Rule and it describes what those other religions golden rules are and then so it talks about like what does that mean the Golden Rule like to you know to do unto others and to be a good
056good citizen basically and then the rest of the unit is basically about helping your neighbors and helping you know what I mean being following the Golden Rule um so the the burden of that unit isn't to teach religion or or to teach um any one historical event it's to teach a theme around being a good person and it begins with those and again the committee they looked at those individual lessons that the public comment uh we received it on and they they made recommendations on what to do or not to do with those lessons am I misunderstanding your question no I think that covered it really well and in reference to what Randy said about this even with the golden Ru like saying do un you know the Golden Rule there you're not prelighting you're
057just teaching them what this means for this religion or whatever the other golden rules are for the other religions I think important that we remember everyone does have different values that they bring to the table and we have to we do need to respect their values and their voice and their choice with that so it's going to be an important part of our own that particular lesson it might have been emerging themes what are common amongst the golden rules of various religions it might have been I'm not saying it is haven't read it but thank you that was a very good explanation yeah thank you for your time hope Howard got his answers I know what Howard was looking for but I didn't want to say it so I'm going to turn it over to
058miss Cornelius and it's so nice to say that math doesn't have any of these issues so I'm sitting um just one um two statements for claric I'm sorry we got to keep them all so m for math just a little um context for the past three years we've been um piloting Eureka in K2 and this year we're piloting Carnegie in our honors track for six through Algebra 2 I mentioned that to say those are the base products for Blue Bonnet learning in maap so with our committee they've already reviewed compared both products any errors that were in terms of teak alignment any errors in terms of um not applying the Els or a Missin teque or error and just um the content was already addressed in Blue Bonnet so the committee members that I had
059were more focused on implementation and making sure implementation is um goes smoothly and also our teachers receive what they need so for example in K2 um the teachers uh sorry the feedback was about instructional support and adaptation they wanted to ensure how in our instructional minutes are we going to be able to address um intervention and also Spiral Review they also wanted more problem solving opportunities for those K five classes and also to ensure that differentiation in the curriculum and as Sarah say said mentioned before that that differentiation that engagement that comes from our Kagan strategy that's come from our lead forward strategies so it's just helping our teachers and supporting our teachers of how to implement those strategies and now the next point that they had was professional development and teacher guidance making sure
060that our teachers understand the flow of those lessons and the components of those lessons as I mentioned we Pilot We Are pilot in Eureka in K2 our 35 is going to be our new group so they wanted to make sure how is the professional development going to be differentiated between both groups and then they want to make sure that we have a plan for that and last communication and accessibility they wanted to make sure that we had a frequently Asked question document a Livin document so that teachers can anchor to refer to for any clarifi any clarification that they need and also they mentioned the family guides and in the last board presentation there was a question about family guides what blue bana has done this time is Incorporated their family guides within the student
061book so it's right there so if a student takes the book home that family guide is there in that book for the parents to help to support their student and last in terms of K5 just again just resources to help with implementation they just wanted some support with that if a teacher decid that they would not they prefer to do that activity as a pair deck or as a matching activity or put it in some place it in a slide they wanted to make sure that we can support them with that and that assists with their autonomy that they ask for um so those were the recommendation from K slide any questions you just mentioned Carnegie Eureka and blue bonnet all in your conversation ation and we're piloting this and we're piloting that so what
062are we abandoning and what are we what are we keeping what are we abandoning and what are we adopting so Mr Clen um Carnegie is separate and it's what we we did pilot and we didn't abandon anything we just put it in our honors but Eureka is Blue Bonnet they just renamed it likey okay is that confuses a lot of people yeah it it does okay we didn't want we wanted to texize it what so we're we're really already using it we're just going to put label on it correct in math correct in math okay in math um before we move any further could we go back to slide five and I promised I was going to be quiet tonight but I just can't u under the subcommittees is is that representative of what is
063in Blue Bonnet curriculum yes the grades yeah Ela k125 Ela K2 mat 35 MTH eight math and Algebra 1 correct so essentially Blue Bonnet is going [Music] to affect Elementary Ela and Elementary and Junior High math correct it was really not going to move into high school at all Carnegie will for math but okay don't don't don't say other curriculum models to me my question is about blue bonnet well correct Carnegie is going to be the high school is Carnegie part of blue bonnet yes think of it as a pyramid so the front end of my car is a Ford the middle is a Chevrolet and the rear end is a Toyota I think you got it and you have an umbrella and you you have an umbrella called Blue Bon it okay all right
064cool I got it and this is going to make our star scores go out the roof right yes we hope they're they're aligning the test to this curriculum so that's kind who ta I rest my case I'm not going to argue with that either Mr Glenn who said yes about the star I I said that they're aligning the star test to this who said yes is tea when he said it's going to make our scores go out of the roof they're supposed to theoretically but he just he said who said yes well I'm hoping yes strong hope we all are well that's the whole purpose of this right that's why we're doing it um just quickly for six through Algebra 1 um the committee had the same secondary committee had the same type of feedback
065in terms of curriculum pacing and adaptability they wanted to to ensure that teachers have some autonomy in creating the curriculum and pacing of the curriculum and also if there's any supplements that we can provide them in terms for of their diverse students to support them in those res with resources again the professional development came um was presenting as well they wanted to make sure that they had time in the summer to really dive down into the curriculum so that they can plan appropriate for it and that's the same thing with K5 as well with with K2 teachers being self-contained they didn't feel like they had enough time time during the school year to plan for um Blue Bonnet and for their other four content areas so they're asking for more time this summer with training
066and planning and then last but not least the trust and accountability I had uh six administrators that attended um my committee and one of their main questions is how are we going to monitor that teachers are doing um implementing the curriculum with Fidelity and that's one of their main requests how can we support them to make sure it's implemented appropriately and those strategies are going to be created and reviewed by the committee so that we are all in alignment and all in agreement well we'll know when to get the scores back for sure that's true that's true any questions about MK that's the ultimate accountability you're right well we learned this couple years but I was just going to say and I appreciate the part where they added the parents involvement in that so the
067you know the parents can help their children you know I think Randy was helping his son they want to put him in summer school one year is that right Rand sure whatever you say well he's not going to say no just like y ain't GNA say he asked you a question you ain't GNA say no of course not so our next steps um is the this is the administration recommendation um then we have a board review and approval we have the lasso Grant which is the grant that will provide the professional development to support um this implementation and we'll hear that February then we update the implementation plan midm March and of course update you as well you heard the words adapt advise abandon revisions from amra committee recommendations in Spring and then we start
068the PD uh development own boarding systems in Spring of 25 and through the summer so we as a board are not going to be able to see the revisions until after we approve it well we we're going to have to have a group that comes together to look at those revisions just like we would if y'all adopted a a new science curriculum we're not going to take it at face value so we're going to have to have subcommittees that AG group like somebody's looking at first grade somebody's looking at second grade third grade and so we will be going through that all probably I would say and I'll let you speak to that all year we're going to be like one you know probably nine weeks ahead of the next nine weeks so it'll be
069a yearly process so we're going to to adopt it and then ad uh revise the curriculum as we go yes that's so that's what we've been doing the whole time yeah okay so when we get to some of these more um controversial topics they will be revised beforehand correct by the committee yes we don't want any controversial topics either at all but you did you say that they're already available online so if anybody wanted to go look at them and provide feedback we could do that yes just like we invited all of y'all for that that committee meeting you have access to look at every one of them so you know um Mr Martinez if you found something that you felt like wasn't appropriate you could give it to us and let us review it
070okay hey that's why y'all get paid the big books to do that work so Miss Jackson for the people that are tuning in for the first time tonight listening to this presentation where do they go to find this blue bonnet uh program online and how do they voice their concerns to quote unquote the committee so the district has made a web page for blue bondet learning um and so they can go to our website and access the links for the material right now it's already available um I if any of you would like it we can send it to you as well but on the banner is a link that says Blue Bonnet learning and you click it and it takes you to each grade materials and the student additions and uh the the readers
071uh the math books as well family letters that so the public can just go on there and access it at will yes sir that's correct that's right and that was my question and can the parent or the public reach out through there is there a link that will get information to the committee or how do they address their concerns and concerns that come to us as a board how do they uh address that to the committee or is there an Avenue for that so we had a public comment window and that link was available but next up we are revising the local policies um now all of that just happen is happening naturally for the curriculum reviews and so one of the things we were going to put on there is a link on that
072web page that lets parents to take down the public comment window link and now put up uh an ongoing feedback link and to that link will need to be the updated guidelines with the um whenever you have a concern the concern document there's a a like a consistent document that parents use to submit so we need to put that there as well okay thank you so there is an Avenue is there if people will go out and find it and they have to use it as well I'm sorry can you say that one more time said there is an Avenue for them to reach out but they have to go find it number one it's out it will be out there but they have to use it yes well absolutely we want we want to
073hear the feedback from people I mean we don't want to get into the next school year and learn there's something that people felt was problematic U those 160 comments were really great A lot of them were things that we expected people to come on but some were definitely not and so we definitely want people to to take advantage of looking at this material providing their comments so that we can make adjustments ahead of next year right and probably the biggest point being is that our ears are open a th% absolutely with our current curriculum too I mean it it's not just about blue bonnet learning in this District if a parent has a concern about uh the instruction materials we want to hear about it I knew the answer to every one of those questions
074I just wanted to put it out there because most people don't and and and when they hear something on the news they they bad information spreads really quick U but we are listening we are looking at this closely and I know y'all are doing a really good job it's a lot to look at U but I do want to make sure our public knows we are listening to that uh and this isn't a hammer dropping this is what we're doing there there's a lot going into it and we are listening so I wanted to commend you on your presentation this evening but more so for this setting up a website specifically for Parental comment um that you can do so if I'm not mistaken what I'm hearing is is that blue bonnet learning could look
075different in Katie and conro ISD versus Goose Creek CSD based upon parental involvement teacher involvement um your involvement um it can be adapted according to the needs of our community is that right correct one more thing sorry um maybe I shouldn't have said uh controversial because that maybe isn't the right term um unconstitutional might be a better term so the reason that I want to say that is because I as a board member cannot vote for something that is unconstitutional right so a lot of these um problems that the community has brought up about the religious um the religious material in the blue bonnet curriculum um they um so sorry one moment to collect my thoughts um so the reason why I stress the timeline of voting for them and then revising them later is
076because they are unconstitu some might see it as unconstitutional to um to to vote for it in the first place before they have been changed and we already have gotten parental feedback on uh the blue bonnet learning and we already see that there is a lot of parents have a problem with the religious material in them so if we could get those revised before we bring it to the board to vote on it that might clear a lot of um our conscious and uh be able to to vote for it um whether yay or nay but uh vote for it nonetheless I would say that that would probably be impossible to do a whole Year's curriculum we can do do sections and we could bring you um like when we get it adopted then we
077look and say okay here's the nine weeks and bring to the board that the committee's recommendations were these revisions um prior to it being taught right and I and I understand the the magnitude of it so uh I'm not specifically talking about the uh curriculum regarding or or the problems regarding um lack of diversity and representation and things like that those are definitely things that can be um uh voted on now and then revised later um as parents or staff think is is appropriate to do so um but it's just the the legality of voting for the religious because of separation of church and state so it as Miss Sarah said we we can see things that are black and white as this definitely mentions religion that is a black and white statement this mentions
078religion how can we revise it so that people can uh so that board members can vote for so um Mr martinz I think one thing I I I think I heard him say this this potentially controversial or unconstitutional uh represents 6 to 8% of all the curriculum so you're adopting 92 to 94% of this curriculum the only thing under consideration at all is that small percentage point so I think that's what Miss Jackson was trying to say we can't shut down the whole adoption to discover the 1% in the first nine weeks the 2% in the OR 3% in the second nine weeks so I think we've all agreed that's where the abandon comes in that anything that is strictly out there to teach one side we remove and we put in a different story
079a different poem that has nothing to do with religion so I understand that some of that is uh also relegated to the teacher to do one of the four items on a particular area based upon what they post online and the parent can see correct so I mean we could or a particular unit yes but we could abandon something and a parent could see it and say you know I want to teach this at home and they could do that at home even um but we would say at the in the school district we're going to abandon this this reading passage for a different one that teaches that skill that makesense but even if you did section it off and you come back with it we're still going to disagree I mean we're it's not
080not everybody's going to agree I I'm not going to agree with that you know so what I would say to that is we're really we're adopting a program with a policy attached to it on how we handle it and that's probably how we would get to what may be unconstitutional whatever as part of our policy we're looking at that and we're going to make adjustments and make it the Goose Creek Way correct so what this team does is the pacing guide and the pacing guide could be inclusive of that information right correct thank you'all very much yeah uh very comprehensive presentation are you going to get a second trophy is that our objective so I know but this is the good part this is the good part all of this was all part there's only
081three slides I believe hey it was all good so far so um so we talk about ouri toi which is the one thing we went through that uh long board presentation before so what we've done is we've um gone through and said did we perform uh last year Oni and how are we performing right now Apples to Apples in third grade where were we at prediction third grade where are we at prediction so three through five rla you can see that um and I I'm going to start off with um this guy you said something that was really impactful that we are looking at the meat standard and so you can see there's a 10% growth in the meat St standard and at the approaches and we've also seen the Masters grow in 3 through
082five math you see um a slight increase in approaches a 5% increase and the meats and we are about the same on the Masters in the science there's we got a dip there so that's going to be a red flag that we have to look at 66 to 54 and we also um dipped on the meat so that's one of the things we have um we have literally sitting out there to look at overall which is how they get scored um because because of that dip in that science it got us the same overall and um an increase in meets and a slight increase in Masters so if we work on that um science I think we'll see a big dip I mean a big increase and then Junior High you Elementary was there a
083change in teaks for science that's what I thought yes so that probably yeah yes yes thank you for saying that um um never want look like I'm excusing though so Junior High uh we looked at increase in rla 6 through eight uh and a significant increase in the meats and um even a 5% in the masteress that was really nice in the math we saw a slight dip and that was in eighth grade that caused that and then we have um an increase a good increase on the meats and a slot increase in the Masters and in the SS we also saw an increase in the approaches and a significant increase in the meets and a significant increase in the Masters so overall you can see the increases there in the high school we saw
084significant increases in English one and um and in English too for approaches uh same for the meets and the same for the Masters so the English is looking pretty good and then algebra we saw a significant increase there um across the board and so that's really nice to know and in the biology we saw an increase there as well for an overall um nice increase in both the approaches meets and Masters so that's um good information and see it was quick question um so after doing the the middle of the Year assessments last year was it a pretty decent indicator of how our students yes I'm performing I can't remember 9% okay it's a better indicator than the interim assessment very good so what I just heard was we're going to do really good this
085year sure what I heard so any other questions from our board members to this committee thank you all for taking on a very complex presentation I was just okay that presentation took away 15 minutes from our next presentation I'm joking uh what do we have next we have our annual Human Resources update do y'all need a stretch break are we good to jump in okay okay good evening uh School Board good evening Dr O'Brien we're here to provide the uh each year we provide a human resource or HR update and so we'll do that we're going to start with introductions and just to make sure you have a name to a face and so again I'm Matt Binger I'm the assistant superintendent of human resources and we'll just go down the line good evening I'm
086Dr steel I'm the director of secondary campuses good evening Monica Warz director of Elementary good evening I'm Heather alal and I'm the human resources coordinator hello my name is bro docky the associate director for compensation okay and so this is our HR leadership team and so I thought it would be good just to have everyone at the table as we uh present the uh the slides um our uh our presentation is really anchored in two documents uh one document is the taper report so we're going to talk about the HR or the Staffing portion of the taper report and then uh the second piece is really our strategic plan so we're going to talk about our human resources and organizational development uh portion of our strategic plan as it as it fits in line with
087human resources and so we'll hit these topics along the way away we do have a mission statement we developed this about two years ago and the focus is to grow Giants through recruitment retention and development of the district's Workforce utilizing hr's best practices and and really those three things are are uh primarily what we do um our job is to recruit aggressively recruit very strategically in the midst of a teacher shortage and so um we want to make sure that we're doing all we can to recruit high quality candidates to Goose Creek um keeping them here is is the retention piece and so you'll see that we've uh We've implemented some efforts this year to to impact our retention and then also um we we work with our leaders in developing best practices as it
088comes to uh various things such as investigations um hiring documentation that sort of thing and so that that's our our mission statement we feel like really um covers that here here's a list of our primary responsibilities and I'm not going to read through these one by one but I do want to highlight just a few um hiring we have hiring guidelines that our campus principles and our district leaders use when they hire um go through the hiring process on boarding this year we've implemented a a digital onboarding process so that our our newly elected uh staff members can complete a lot of their paperwork at home electronically and so that helps the the onboarding experience and then when they come and meet with us it's it's a little more efficient and hopefully a little bit
089more positive instead of filling out paperwork um we'll talk about recr Recruitment and Retention here in a little bit um also we're uh we're the uh cust in for all service records and Personnel records and that's a pretty big task for our entire department um where we're we're managing service records and Personnel records to make sure that those are up to date and accurate and then also a few other things that we we address is a conflict resolution and so if there's a complaint whether it be an informal complaint or a formal complaint our office usually our department usually takes takes the lead on on addressing that and hopefully deescalate it and so um those are a few of our major responsibilities here's some of the taper report data and so I'm going to go
090through about five or six slides that that hit the taper report and so uh starting off with our class sizes and so as you know through our budget reduction process we've had to make some adjustments with Staffing um for last year this dat is from 23 24 our class sizes are below the state average that's one of the few times where we say that's a good thing is to be below the state average and so um that that's the case uh for last year we're watching this very closely we know we also made some adjustments for this year so when we get that data we want to make sure that our class sizes are in line and not over and if they are we'll have to make further adjustments but that's one one metric that
091we uh track closely this next slide shows uh teacher demographics and so this is another data point that's reported out on the taper report um there's very little difference between 2223 and and last year as far as demographic data we may have slightly more this is just for teachers uh slightly more uh Hispanic teaching population and slightly less white teaching population but those are within one percentage point so uh pretty much the same thing as the year before as far as years of experience we feel like this slide is trending in a positive direction our years of experience for our staff went up from the previous year slightly and you can see that that first year teacher is zero years of experience um two years ago 14% of our teaching staff had had no experience
092and then that number dropped you know almost six percentage points to 8.6 and so that's a that's a positive because we feel like our our principls are looking for more experienced teachers we we want we want a good balance you know it's good to hire new teachers excited and eager but also to have that experience as well um and so we feel like we're we're moving towards that that goal you can see in one to five years that's probably the biggest jump um from from the previous year teacher retention is always a concern and always a challenge and so this is uh I decided to show four years on this just to paint a little bit of a a picture of what happened during Co if you remember many uh many teachers across the state
093and in our district stayed put and so the retention rate was very high uh in 2021 during Co right after Co and then we saw a pretty steep decrease uh following the next few years and so the the drop was almost 10 percentage points um Statewide and also Goose Creek was not immune to that as well this is the first year this past year was the first year in a few years that retention actually went up a little bit B it also went up Statewide and so um we don't like that we're a little bit below the state average here but we are happy that that our retention rate did go up about 1% from the year before and so hopefully that Trend continues and here in a minute you'll hear some some retention strategies
094that we've implemented this year with the committee so we'll we'll we'll share that here in a second all right the last uh or the second to last data piece uh from the taper report shows our uh highest degree held uh for our teachers and so this is just an interesting point um all of our teachers for our except for our industry certification teachers some of our CTE teachers have a bachelor's degree or higher um we have 363 teachers with a master's degree and then 11 teachers with a doctor degree and so again U this just sort of Paints the picture of what our um what what our teachers look like as far as degrees held okay I think I'm going to turn it over now to Brooke Docker and she's going to talk a little
095bit about compensation and tia all righty so you guys can see by this chart that the district actually offers salaries that are above the state average which is something we're incredibly proud of we just so happen to be nestled right in the middle of one of the most highly competitive markets as well so our team does make it a priority to always be looking and strategizing on ways that we can improve our current compensation structure um in order to retain those high quality individuals all across the district and one of the ways that we're able to retain and and uh recruit teachers is through the teacher Inc of allotment so the teacher incent of allotment was designed with just that in mind to reward retain and recruit highly effective classroom teachers so the state provides
096additional funding to those individuals who hit certain marks based on classroom performance student learning outcomes um and a few other things and last year we were able to designate 161 teachers and they received over $1.3 million in bonuses which is huge so we're excited about growing our program out and refining things and and improving that as well so we can continue to um roll in more teachers okay so I'm going to share a little bit about our goals um in our department we surround our work around pre three pretty big goals one being our first one where we really want to develop our um leaders because we know the impact that they make on their campus and with their staff so it's critical that we partner with them to help develop them and train them
097in HR practices um our second goal is to recruit highly qualified staff we're always looking for the best and the brightest around the Houston area we recruit outside of the Houston area and we want our classrooms with the best Educators because we know the impact that it's going to make for those students um and then our last goal is really around retention we want want our employees to love Goose Creek we want it them to love it as much as we do and we want them to be satisfied in their day-to-day activities and that will keep them here with us over a long period of time so that's our three major goals that are tied to the organizational Excellence of our district um so around leadership development I think this is an area where our
098department is really targeting we look at all opportunities to provide leadership development to our not only our principles our directors um our assistant principles but also to our aspiring principles that want to become Future Leaders so we use the portrait of a leader as our anchor our document when we design all of our PD and we focus on those qualities that we want to see in our leaders so we work on them understanding the ethical and legal obligations that they're usted with we want them to be um understanding all the documentation processes and the investigations that are important when they're dealing with issues on their campus we want them to ultimately lead with Integrity so that they're treating our employees fairly and they're they're providing them with that support to be Equitable and to and
099have that fairness when they're looking into issues that they're having to deal with so our second goal in our strategic plan is the recruitment of highquality teachers one of the ways that we do that is through our grow your own clinical internship program so that's where we have University students that come work with some of our best teachers across the district and they're able to learn alongside them for a year as part of their uh bachelor's degree so in the 23 24 school year we had 30 full-time student teacher interns um four of those were PA Professionals in the district before they became intern teachers and 23 of them are now working in the district as teachers so then this school year we've had a total of 35 interns again four were pair of professionals
100before they started their internship from the fall group we hired nine of them and we're hoping to increase that number when we hire for the 2526 school year we also attend University and region job fair so we did nine in the fall and then we'll do nine again this spring at local universities and then with Region 4 and then we have a district job fair that will take place on April 12th so we're hoping to invite a lot of great candidates that our principles can hire from there we've also partnered with two universities and their alternative certification programs so we work with Sam Houston State University and the University of Houston and they alternative certification Pathways to get some of our teachers certified so part of the way that we measure high quality is teacher
101certification status um a really positive celebration is that over 90% of our Goose Creek teachers are certified to teach in their current assignment so with our uncertified staff 85 of them are hired under our district of innovation plan and are currently working towards getting certified and then 54 are adjunct Educators so another celebration in this area is that we hired 171 of these teachers as uncertified through at this point 35 of them are now working on a certification and that number will grow significantly over the next couple of months as they're taking assessments and um meeting the qualifications to be certified all right and goal number three of our strategic plan focuses on increasing teacher retention um and we know that that starts with our mentorship supports um and this these are supports for all
102of our new teachers to Goose Creek we provide all teachers that are brand new to the classroom with a mentor and any teacher new to Goose Creek with one or more years of experience will receive a buddy every campus does have a lead mentor tour that meets with new teachers they also conduct a book study with our new teachers and then we have four retired principles that do monthly check-ins with all of our mentees due to the teacher shortage across the state we understand the importance of teacher retention and so we put together a retention committee this school year we have already met twice during the first semester and we will meet again uh this semester this committee is made up primarily of classroom teachers but we do have district and campus administrators on the
103committee as well this committee has met they have um shared historical uh retention data and then we've also looked at research on the teacher shortage once the committee met they came together to look at uh different ideas and strategies that could help us with our teacher retention on the next slide you will see that we put together a list of current retention strategies that this committee felt was very effective you can look through some of these strategies a couple of them that came up multiple times within the committee is of course the fall break this is definitely something that our teachers uh look forward to and it it really keeps them here in Goose Creek they they love the fall break um they do feel like we do provide them with uh several professional growth
104opportunities that came up multiple times as well as a competitive salary um the part that's listed about effective campus leadership and awareness of teacher concerns at the administrative level we felt that that was great because that connects with our goal number one with developing high quality leaders this next slide is what the committee is recommending as far as retention strategies for consideration so these are strategies that we don't currently have in place but um things that they really felt would be impactful um some of these do have Financial imp implications and so we will look at those when we are preparing for future compensation presentations um so for example the longevity pay that came up multiple times within the committee and this is where they'd get an increase of pay once they hit maybe that
105fiveyear Mark 10 year mark 15E Mark um as well as the typ and increases for advanced degrees okay so that's our presentation and if if you have any questions we'll be glad to answer those at this time would would you tell me again who was on the retention committee so the retention committee was uh 31 people um it was primarily teachers but we did have a couple of District administrators on that committee as well as a couple of Campus principles as well and how was that committee developed I I can answer that what we did was we piggybacked off Dr o'ri superintendent connection committee is the teacher of the years uh teachers of the year and so we uh we asked everyone on that committee if they would be part of a subcommittee and that's
106how we we formed the committee thank you question um just to clarify so on I don't even know the number of the slide but the slide that talks about the certification status um the ones that are district of innovation teachers could those be teachers that are fully certified in a specific area but then maybe they're teaching out of their like maybe they're certified Elementary and if we're teaching sixth grade math and or science and their their principal said they're a rock star so I need them need them in eighth grade and so then they need to get their secondary their middle school certification but yes yes so those teachers do fall under our district fully certified just not what they're teaching correct yes and we give those teachers an addendum to their contract and they
107have a March deadline to get certified in the area that they're teaching perfect okay thank you'all hold on before you leave I just want to say I want to commend you uh the DOI program in particular I've talked to many uh school districts across the board and they leave 100% of the burden on the applicant on the candidate to complete everything and you've done a remarkable job instituting I heard you say it and that reminded me of it deadlines by the March deadline you must have this done and this done so every quarter you're setting up a deadlines for these candidates to complete a portion of of their credentialing and uh I think it's a wonderful thing we didn't do that the first year or two because of Co and what have you so uh
108we've learned from those experiences and I've I'm now sharing your uh work um pattern for other schools so great job thank you all right I believe our next presentation will be from our rockar special education team coming up to bring the annual update for them James I'll let y'all introduce yourselves good evening board president BR Tims Dr O'Brien school board members my name is James husman I'm the director of assessment accountability I'm Holly Ferris senior director of special programs Christina Ritter director of special education and so tonight we will uh we coming before the board just to give an update on special programs um the first slide we want to kind of talk about is our results driven accountability um determination levels um in the past this has been called P pbmas um performance-based um
109monitoring accountability system um and so each year the state has to give us a determination level um on our special programs and we listed here for the Last 5 Years um our our determination levels now I will tell you but that the determination levels are based on a four-point scale zero through four the lower the number the better okay um so you'll see in 2019 we were a three um and during covid that they did not give us a rating um 2021 we were also a three and then 22 23 and 24 we were both um we were a two um um every time we are a two or or higher the state the state requires us to um submit a strategic support plan and um and we're going to discuss that as well so
110if I understand if we attain a zero we will have attained Perfection we would obtain Perfection yes sir so I'm going to talk a little bit about our strategic support plan because we are two that requires us to engage with tea quarterly but it's more than just special education it's the department of testing we also are really working with our social studies so it's our um academic Dean our our um associate director of instruction um Faith Lorio it's also our director of um student services Carrie Smith because the two areas that we're targeting are social studies we were a performance level four we were at 18.9% and our goal for this year is at least to get to 20% or to surpass that um our goal for our indicator 18 is really looking at um
111the total number of disciplinary removals for ISS OSS or da is to be at 50% or lower um and try and get to Performance level two and I'll talk more about that in the presentation so key takeaways we really want to implement targeted interventions for math reading science and social studies for students in special ed we want enhanced teacher training with differentiated instruction and inclusive practices to support our kids in the general led setting we want to increase specialized instructional resources and support programs for students that need that additional support and then really work with our teachers and our teams on strengthening datadriven decision making to identify and address gaps in student performance so some other ways academically we're supporting is we're monitoring our accommodation usage and Edge aoria so one thing we noticed with
112our social studies was that our students were not using their accommodations so we're pulling reports our Specialists are going out having conversations with teachers and talking about those individual students who may not be using their accommodations to ensure that that is taking place um we are meeting with teachers and campus administrators to look at data and so we do that after the screenings after um our beginning of the year and middle of the year um assessments and those types of um things we're also coaching and modeling from our district dyslexia Specialists they're going into our um dyslexia classrooms as well as our sped Ela in doing coaching and modeling so they're supporting our teachers in that way we have PLC training for para professionals on Universal Design for Learning we also um have had our
113our specialist and coordinators helped support our PLC so one of the things that we did to strengthen our team this year was to streamline the information coming from sped sped is a very very large department and so we have um probably the people we see the most would be our assessment staff so we have our diags going back to the campus and relaying that information to their sped team at the campus so that way it's not the teachers are getting this information the assessment team's getting this information and so forth um we also are planning on our resource inclusion and behavior teachers training on our new curriculum um the blue bonnet learning when that comes up so including our special ed teachers in that training as well and then um or whatever uh curriculum that
114may be but and then also our special ed students participating in campus targeted interventions so as we're meeting with principles we're talking about how are you including our special ed kids how are they getting their house bill 146 time what are we doing and so it varies from campus to campus depending on what resources they have if they have extra tutors coming in those people but we're ensuring that our students are getting that assistance as well so with dyslexia you know that that is been the one of the big state mandates that changed and so Goose Creek luckily was ahead of the game so we had already started putting some things in place when we saw that coming so most of our students have already transitioned over to special education we have very few that
115we are still waiting to be tested or that will be tested by the end of the school year um so most of our students have moved over which has increased our sped numbers um you know quite a bit and we'll look at those in just a little bit um with our new state mandates of course you know the new dyslexia handbook came out and there's certain things that we have to follow within that handbook as well so we do use reading by Design curriculum for elementary and so that is the curriculum that most of Region 4 used Region 4 trains on that curriculum we've used it for several years now we did Implement reading Horizons curriculum for our secondary because it was faster paced not quite as basic as our reading by Design and we've
116been seeing success with that as well this year we're monitoring our service our just like say services and our accommodations through accommodations logs and service logs we also are sending out which is mandated by the state progress reports each nine weeks on for our dyslexic students um we have our district level coordinator and our dyslexia specialist also servicing students because even with the influx of um referrals we've had an increase in dyslexia and then moving those students over to special ed our our district Specialists are actually servicing groups as well just based on the need okay for autism and behavior we were awarded the grant it has expired but we do do have with us the star autism curriculum in our structured um classrooms that is the gold standard for curriculum at Elementry and at
117secondary we have the links it's an online secondary curriculum for students we also started this year implementing the solar social skills curriculum that also goes along with star autism it has lots of great video modeling for our students in addition to that we do have one board um certified behavior analyst at bcba on staff to really help conduct those functional behavioral assessments and help the art committees come up with behavior intervention plans for our students um we do have additional campus support provided from retirees who have come back and really helped our teachers um who are novice teachers and brand new to the profession to really help them with their IEP goals and progress monitoring and so forth so next I want want to go back to indicator 18 which really talks about those total
118disciplinary removals and kind of look at the last six years while we are um at pl3 we have had a great growth in that area six years ago we were at 80.5% and last year we ended at 56.2% the outlier in the data is 2021 which we ended the year in 30.1 that was Co the co year so we met required Improvement and received a zero for that rating but our goal is to get to 50% or less we're we're inching towards that what is hindering us from meeting that goal is vaping to be honest with you um with that if we didn't have to worry about vaping we would probably be there so so we attained our behavioral goal while they were home pardon me virtually yes yes yes yes so this next slide
119here is um a slide from EA um it talk um it just displays uh graduation rates of all students versus students with served in special education that also shows um the Dropout rates between um all students and students serve special education we wanted to put that slide in there that showed the the fiveyear uh tendency there and then we wanted to show where we were as a district so as a district um the state Target was an 80% to be at a determination level of zero we were at 82.4 so we were zero in that that area which is a celebration um our sped dropout rate um the state Target was 1.8% we are at 0.7% um our sped year after uh Raa pass rate the state Target was 70% uh we were at a
12076.8% and then our sped year after exit math pass rate um the state Target was 70% we were at 71% so we were zero in all those areas so those highlights are the higher graduation rate than the state Target a lower dropout rate compared to the state Target and then a star strong performance in year after exit assessments so um just to kind of reiterate our increase in numbers so if you notice we have um our student number or student population in sped has increased by about 12 to 1300 in about the last two years and we're continually increasing with many referrals coming in which we talked about a couple of months ago in our department um so some of the highlights we would like to share we've had continuous improvement in our RDA data
121over the last three years we were highlighted at Region 4 for partnering with them on our dyslexia State mandated modules and so they've been coming in during our plc's so that all of our people are trained and I will say we are ahead of the game on that there's many districts that are we just had a regional uh dyslexia meeting and some have not even started and they have to have it done by the time school starts back so way ahead of the game and there's six days of training for that um we've had performance in our Christmas celebrations at the admin building here during um our uh Christmas celebration we had our Lee uh dance life skills class come and do a dance over here we've had secondary students participating in a Valentine's dance
122last Thursday all of our junior high students participated we have Special Olympics partnering in the Sterling star Bazaar booth that selling things that they've made in their class in their classes and then Sterling students performing at our ESC that was something new that we did this year our people absolutely loved it they uh played handbells and drums and it was just a fantastic um celebration and then this year also marks the 50-year celebration of our Tri County Regional Day School uh for the de so in Goose Creek so we're having a celebration in April to um kind of celebrate that 50-year uh March so we're very excited about that other highlights include our 18 plus program and they are working with fueling brains going to the warehouse that's there and putting together those packets together
123for them they also go out to the district warehouse um one of the pictures on the lower leftand corner they're at Target learning to front um items and then you see our apartment where they're learning to Independent Living skills and ultimately to the right we want them to eventually graduate with those post Readiness skills and Workforce skills we also have Texas Workforce Solutions coming in every day to work with our students on self- advocacy and job Readiness skills we feel like that is a huge need and then collaboration with the Houston Food Bank we're doing a service project with them as well and then Special Olympics we've had lots of um competitions recently most recently we had table tennis at Gentry we had 65 athletes from Goose Creek um participate and then we did have
124for the first time cornhole came is new to Special Olympics we had 30 um athletes competing and then for the winter State Games this past weekend it was in bave Texas we had 40 athletes so 40 volleyball teams and one floorball team it's the first year for floorball for Goose Creek most athletes we've ever had taken to State upcoming we have basketball tournament coming with 72 athletes competing and then cycling will be on March 26 with competition on Friday March our April 25th and then we last but not least is soccer as a soccer mom I should highlight this starts March 25th competition do on Saturday April 26th and I would like to share as well volleyball was second in state at the uh Winter Olympic Games this past weekend so we just found that
125out as well and so the last piece of information we have here is just our special ed oh sorry Mr Menon it's right outside of Austin Austin west side of Austin very nice place and then we have our special ed acronym quick reference guide and we did update that so there was one little uh Tapo I think at the bottom and then also um they refer to emotional disturbance and it has changed to emotional disability so we just wanted to be sure so we do have that updated I think on TT didn't update so we found you a good one yes we did with lots of acronyms because we know sped is full of acronyms so any questions talking about dyslexia and reading programs so um our if I can get there I'll ask a
126more intelligent question U the reading by Design so our elementary kids are in in their classroom most the day then they're pulled for this reading by Design yes and their intervention time so intervention okay that's the word I was looking for do they do that daily twice a week most of the time it's four days a week okay so for 45 minutes so with these programs there's Fidelity statements and so you are pretty much tied to you know the Fidelity of the program and they recommend certain amount of minutes or is is there a evaluation of that reading Dev design or do we depend on maps and what have you so we also do maps and all of that but we also do dibles we do a lot of different progress monitoring with our students
127for dyslexia and we track all of that and the progress report mentioned right under that is that specific to dyslexia like here's our progress from yes this nine weeks to next nine weeks in addition to regular classroom progress reports correct and they have mastery checks in the program and so once the Mastery check is done that information is sent home with to the parent as well and then way down still on dyslexia but the the slide that told us how many more we have in special ed we have 17.65% last year U how much of that is because we had to move dyslexia to special ed so some of that but we've also you know um had a huge increase in our Au students and so we've had you know increase in autism and then
128how much of that was because the state of Texas got in trouble for misidentifying sped students and we were just allowed to do our job right yes yes okay so it's it's not that we have more kids we're just able to service them better correct make sure you tell people that because you guys are doing a great job I have a question also so on slide six it talks about that some of the students are being served virtually how how you if they're serve virtually so we do have some kids that are in our Virtual Academy and so we do have if they're dyslexic they're serve virtually through there that makes sense so yes okay not many I want to say we have like four or five yes thank you guys great report and thank
129you wonderful accomplishments okay Dr Ryan we will now move into the agenda item for action item I'm going to ask you to uh Administration to read all the items and then we'll move all right action item 7A consideration of consent agenda the 25 26 budget planning guide as previously presented by Miss Clark number two property foreclosures as presented to the board Administration does um recommend approval of these items okay are there any items that any board member would like to pull for discussion or separate separate consideration no no items pull all right do I have a motion to approve the consent agenda items um 781 and 782 I'll second it okay moved by Mr clim and second by um Mr Martinez how about that I got it okay in favor raise your hand next item
130is 7B it's future board agenda items board training and board meetings uh as previously requested by the board we've gone ahead and itemized the upcoming uh superintendent reports but of course we're at the Leisure of the board to edit or modify but at the next meeting it would be expected we'd have a budget update Fine Arts update superintendent evaluation yeah I'm going to speak a little bit about the superintendent evaluation uh with the staff here um uh with the board members here and what I'm going to do uh Mr Clint with your help I'm going to look at the um superintendent's uh evaluation summary and then I looked on the calendar that was on for the budget review so first we going to have some challenges with dates again and so when I looked at
131the calendar for our budget first budget review we're going to be looking at um let me get my notes I wrote it down we're going to be looking at uh March 24th is our first special meeting for Budget review and so and then we look at March 25th and then you guys we have some folks who going to the governance training so and then spring break so no Amy we're going to have to look at those dates but we also need to be in contact and get a date that coordinate with Dr o' Brian's schedule and our County not County attorney Schoolboard attorney um I can never get that right oh habit with the uh attorney with David Hodes yes and so but I hopefully this week I will send you guys once I speak
132with you Mr Clen for the packet and because I look for it everywhere just couldn't and Tiffany U mentioned that you might be able to assist me with that okay and so we'll look at a spe then we have our second special meeting uh for the budget workshop and that moves into April 1st so we're going to have to look at something in between that time you guys so kind of look at dates and I'll work with Noami and we'll send out some things to request dates if you all don't mind but we need to move forward forward with the superintendent's review Miss BR ens with that said if anybody in the gallery can answer this is the most recent uh update of the Strategic plan what's on the website right now so is is
133100% okay thank you thank you kall okay so as we've done that uh board training governance Camp what mean oh we're going in the close session y'all so hang on let me find one little thing okay okay the board will now recess in the close session pursuant to one one or more of the following sections of the Texas government code section 551.071 072 073 074 075 076 082 083 084 and 087 no action will be taken while the board is in closed session the time is now 8 p.m. thank you the board will now Recon convene into Open Session the time is now 9:34 no action was taken while the board was in closed session at this time Madame President Administration brings before the board for consideration to approve elections and accept resignations and retirements
134as presented I'll move to approve I second okay the motion was moved by Miss guy and second by Mr Martinez any discussion all in favor raise your hand right hand it passes annoying me and we have two administrative elections this evening one is the academic Dean at Stewart Career Tech High School Miss Lisa vria is recommended you I have a motion I move to approve I second okay the motion has been moved by Mr kesi and second by Mr Martinez um there any discussion there be no further discussion is is this person here they were here earlier they came through and shook hands earlier [Laughter] thank you I thought he forgot Mr R for bringing that to our attention we didn't want him forget about that with Mr Samson again right again yeah okay all
135in favor please raise your hand he that's 74 it's U motion carries Administration brings before the board this evening coordinator of Campus Athletics head football coach GCM Mr jond Cleveland I'll move to to approve second second second okay Miss guy moved and uh Mr Mia second uh in discussion yes I just I'm gonna vote for this guy because he's a he's a former robbert El Gander and he's well deserving of this position yeah and I approve all right okay anyone else all in favor raise your hand okay there it is anonymously so we I met him too motion carries I know I saw him here that's anything else Dr W Administration rest thank you we thank everyone for all the great presentations tonight and thank you all uh there be no further business before this
136board this meeting is adjin at 9:36 have a good nighted oh okay it's official they told meam now I'm not doing that anymore because he got