CorpusRecord 76942

December 16, 2024 – Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Goose Creek CISD
Date
2024-12-17
Location
Harris County, TX
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,273 words · about 69 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I will now call the special meeting of Goose Creek CISD Board of Trustees to order on December 16 2024 at 6: p.m. Mr cesy uh was a meeting L posted yes it was and do we have a quorum we have a quorum would you please stand and join us for The Prayer by Miss guy and the pledges by Mr cesy Lord thank you for our many blessings thank you forting everyone here safely tonight guide USIS decision makion stud I ask in Jesus name amen amen if you would join me in the Pledge of Allegiance followed by The Pledge uh the Texas state foot I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all honor the

002Texas flag I pledge allegiance to the Texas under God one and indivisible thank you both and everyone else uh we will move to number two on our agenda and that is I have to get my little speech up please give me a second that is our uh citizens participation information citizen participation is a time that the board will hear public concerns or public comments from those who have properly signed up to address the board uh the board shall permit uh public comments regardless of whether the topic is an agenda item um posted um with notice of the meeting um at all other board member meetings public comments shall be limited to open session items on the agenda posted with notice of the meeting each speaker is reminded that he or she is limited in his

003or her presentation to the maximum of three minutes and our Mr cesy will be our timekeeper and that he or she respect confidentiality concerns and refrain from attacking the personal character of any individual student staff member or board member in addressing the concerns or comments pursuant to state law and board policy be legal the board uh cannot consider or take action on concerns at this meeting unless they pertain to an item on the posted agenda for this meeting any deliberation or decisions on on an item that is not posted for consideration at this meeting shall be limited to a proposal to be placed for on the plac the subject on the agenda of future meetings okay we will start with our first Speaker tonight is um Ginder McKay Community member and resident Miss McKay you

004may begin when you're ready the clock will start when you begin I will let you know when you have one minute remaining and stop you at three minutes good evening board members and Dr O'Brien I would expect that most of you would not know that I am a Lamar lion but I am not a Lamar lion in the same way as the others who have spoken last week who are may be speaking today I was selected to be the campus principal in 1995 for Lamar Elementary uh by the outgoing principal Barbara Wilson who was being moved to Steven of Austin at the time to lead the rebuilding of that school I was given the great honor to be the leader of the rebuilding of Lamar Elementary School that opened in 1996 meeting with the Architects

005picking out paint colors facilitating relationships with the contractors watching the many many large oak trees being bulldozed down were just a few of the things and in fact I went to look it up I still have my worksheet that I saved on my computer that has every single piece of of equipment and Furniture chosen for each room and every area of that building and when printed out covered the entire wall in my office at at one point the budget was even a little bit over and we were told that we were not going to get to have Landscaping so the Landscaping was going to get cut but what is a school without trees and Shrubbery so we punted and we came back with a fundraising event where people were allowed to donate funds towards a

006tree or shrub so every tree and shrub on that campus was donated by someone in this community that was connected to Lamar Elementary which stretches back to 1930 the other piece of the rebuilding was the difficult side with the community just as individuals have voiced their concern last week in 1995 the Lamar alumni which were 65 years strong and they were not thrilled about the rebuild it was close to home for me though because every time I went home my husband would ask me about why we were rebuilding it because he was an original Lamar cowboy because that's what they were at the time and he shared his opposition a lot it made me think I even tried to get the front of the school the old school to have the contractor save it to

007try to have it embedded into the new building but that got kicked because of the way the building had to be replaced and we weren't going to be able to take it on so my point is this being a Lamar Cowboy or even a Lamar Lion in any capacity runs very deeply through our veins however just in 1995 change is constant while we want to keep things the same we love it when we can make them stay the same it unfortunately comes anyway our present is not what it was in 1930 it's not what it was in 1996 when we opened the new building and it's not what it's been for the last 25 years so with that being said the decision rests with you about how to plan for the present and the Beyond

008you have an important role as a part of this board sometimes the decisions are easy and sometimes they're extremely difficult this is one of those difficult times as a board please deliberate all the options and make a decision that will continue a promising path that moves us forward and through the progress of change thank you thank you please note that Mr Ria has joined our meeting at 607 oh oh okay thank you um originally I'm the TL reading TLC at Lamar and originally I had prepared a speech but um I had a parent that was wanted wanted to be here tonight but she had to work so she asked me to tell me tell her son's story why was it um I've been at Lamar for 20 years and 11 of the years I was

009a dyslexia specialist and her son was one one my students so I'm going to read you directly what she wrote these are her words not mine um tell them she said please share Z's story and you can tell them I said forid to do so tell them Lamar saved my son in one day since kindergarten I have been pleading every year with each new teacher to help me help my son in Reading ex reading explaining that he really really struggles with it and every year instead of reports on him how they trying to help him I only got reports of him having episodes of pure frustration that they had made my son hate school because this 5 to nine-year-old little boy was desperately telling his teachers that he didn't understand anything only to be called

010a liar and told he wasn't trying hard enough that he just needed to actually try so he'd have anxiety attacks and leave the classroom having rage fits and crying episodes every morning begging me not to take him to school and then we walked into Lamar and they looked at his be Behavior reports and they said hm let's try something and they immediately stuck him in a GT class setting setting to see him see how he' react to it then at the end of this very first day his first day he asked they asked me if they could test him for dyslexia which no other school had ever mentioned and I had no clue what it was but I agreed anything that could potentially help him I was 100,000 1,000% behind and results came back showing

011my son was not a bad kid as in past schs had said but he has just a little kid who didn't know how to properly Express the enormous emotions he was experiencing he was found to be severely dyslexic he's now a uh his scores have skyrocketed he's a as he's a freshman at Lee High School he plays football he has a job and has great friends his teachers do nothing but praise him and tell me how good a job I did raising him when in reality it wasn't for if it wasn't for Lamar I don't know where Z would be I will say too I I want you to consider that um when you're thinking about this decision we all obviously know what the position the district's in financially these are my words but I

012want you to think about the Z of the world and maybe Z going to Lamar where there's lower capacity and there is lower class sizes that maybe that was the difference that made Z successful and not all decisions can be made when we were looking at these kids in Lamar's population we need to look at the whole picture not just one part of it thank you our next speaker is Katrina miracle that's good evening I would like you to reflect for a moment about the most important financial decisions you have made in your life for me that would be buying my home how long did it take you to make that decision weeks months buying a home involves a lot of factors such as location cost interest rates all of which require research not to

013mention the financing process and many more factors that for the sake of time we will not go into now let's discuss how long it took GC 2035 to reach a consensus that Lamar Elementary be be recommended for campus repurposing according to Miss Douglas a GC 2035 Committee Member 6 hours that's right six hours to come to a consensus to close an elementary school personally it takes me longer than 6 hours to make a purchase in excess of $100 much less May such an immense financial decision like closing or repurposing a school that impacts so many GCC ISD core value number four creating a culture of mutual respect dignity and transparency to build trust with each other and those we serve transparency where was the transparency with the staff and the parents of Lamar Lamar staff

014had to receive the news from outside sources how does that create a culture of mutual respect I know there were notifications sent in Giant news and news of the week but not in one place on any of those announcements did it State the repurposing consolidating or the closure of a school it stated the long range facilities plan is a type of planning that ensures our facilities can accommodate growth changing legal specifications or evolving Technologies over time once the Lamar staff began asking questions minut then there was a meeting scheduled to inform the staff 14 days after the consensus was made this is transparency now to discuss the future of Lamar Educators Human Resources offered options for Lamar teachers they can either choose to move to ashell Smith or Carver both of which are F schools

015the irony is striking we are rewarding high performance teachers and students from Lamar by transition iing them to schools with lower performance ratings the third option presented to get is to get on the transfer list which requires an interview process in this scenario a principal chooses not to hire the teacher HR will place them wherever they choose this process does not seem very respectable considering the hard work and dedication of Lamar teachers in closing I ask that you take all this information into consideration before making your decision considering the long range facilities plan is a 10-year plan perhaps more time should be spent analyzing all of the data before making the decision to close a school undoubtedly more than six hours thank you thank you I will try my best not to butcher this name

016I'm sorry and arala janaza am I close would you say no say it for me though please huh aelia eaga okay I was close it's okay I get it a lot good morning members of the Board of Trustees and Dr O'Brien we are not here to try to change your decision it's clear that that decision was made months ago and stated by the administration I want to begin by acknowledging that our emotions ran high during um last Monday's meeting that was not Our intention however I would ask you how you would feel if your family and home we're being attacked and because Lamar is our home and our family unfortunately this is how we feel we do not feel supported or hurt this is truly a great sense of loss for Lamar what saddens us

017the most is that Lamar is now being perceived as rude and disrespectful for our emotions that night that is not us and most is not Lamar Lamar Elementary embodies a culture and climate that is safe respect for and caring a place where family staff and students take pride in being part of the Lamar family I assure you I assure you that in no time did we mean to come across as disrespectful to any of you however what about the emotions that was shown by the committee a committee that stated leaving out their emotions and having empathy for Lamar but when the vote was in their favor committee members were seen dancing and laughing floating where was his empathy and respect for lar then the Board of Trustees made it a point to acknowledge the committee

018by patting their bags for their hard work and the countless hours as we all should thank them and we do but I would like to take this time to acknowledge the staff of Lamar for the countless years and hours they have given to the district for all the hours work beyond the contracted hours for always and I mean always going above and beond to make Lamar a place of Excellence so I say to you to the Lamar family and as we always say to our students every morning in case that no one has told you we here Lamar we love you very much and we appreciate you as you prepare to vote on the plane tonight I plead with you to reflect on whether it truly serves the best interest of our students while I

019understand that districts needs to address budgetary concerns this proposal centered in logistics fails to prioritize our students educational and emotional needs it overlooks the legacy of excellence in community that Lamar has has built over the years repurposing Lam more is not in the best interest of our district especially for our students under this plan 500s will be reassigned to Asheville Smith and Carver these schools while thriving for improvement face face they face academic challenges and remain focused campuses adding more students will only add to those challenges this is not a strategy that ensures the success of our children neither those who currently attend L more nor those at the receiving schools our respect your role as decision makers elections elected to serve in the best interest of our students our staff and our families in

020closing it has been stated that this plan will save at the district $2.5 million but tonight I simply asked this question what price do you put on Integrity loyalty commitment dedication and our students overall well-being thank you thank you our next speaker will be Mr Robert B Martin Jr good evening board it's an honor to be speaking before you tonight on such a uh bad topic my name is Robert B Martin J I went to lar that day I currently reside less away from Lamar my investment properties are all located within walking District of Lamar Mr Martin please speak into your microphone I I did not receive any notice whatsoever as an entrepreneur as a businessman or as a resident that Lamar was being repurposed now I I know you guys are all very smart

021but there's one thing I think you guys have overlooked that's the property value whenever you take away an elementary school the zoning goes down that means people don't want to buy your house that means people don't want to rent your rentals especially if it's families that's a problem and I think it's something that you guys never really considered because the community was never asked nobody came and knocked on my door why you guys are are supposed to be taking care of the community that's what you have pledged to do so I'm urging you guys to vote no or at least table this until you giving Mr rentoria the ability to go and speak to the business owners speak to the people that actually live there like myself and you hear our concerns it is not

022fair and it is not right you're messing with my personal Investments now in addition it is a proven fact and there's been plenty of surveys that when you take a school away the community becomes unsafe so what you've unintentionally done is said to community members like myself we don't care about your safety now I know that's not your intention I know that is not what you meant to to do but that exactly is how it comes off to me and to the other members of the community that I've spoken to again we were given no notice so for a fact a neighborhood Elementary School makes the community safer period now I'm asking you again to vote no or to table this but for sake of time I'm going to bring up this last Point Lamar's

023been around for decades decades I'm old I know this is never come up before the only time it's come up is because if there's a new Charter School two blocks away Bob Hope how many students were pilfered from Lamar that are now going to Bob Hope has that question been answered because all you got to do is ask the registar and they'll tell you how many trans trips they've sent over there is that the reason why that the student count is low this school does not need to be repurposed it needs to stay as Lamar Elementary the greatest little Elementary School in the world period it not purpose so I beg you please vote no or table it and speak to the community to give us the proper time because that's what you're there to

024do right thank you very much for your time appreciate thank you thank you [Applause] sir our next speaker is um lucer Guzman Miss Gman advises she's going to speak in Spanish and she's giving us an English copy of it Miss Guzman you can proceed [Music] Lu [Music] for [Music] for e time has expired thank you thank you our next speaker for this evening is ala Suarez good afternoon thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak once again today we understand the the need to make changes but there are several unused buildings in the area that could serve as a better fit for the repurposing rather than disrupting an elementary school that has been a heart of this community for over 60 years by exploring these alternative buildings me we could preserve the stability of

025the school and the sense of security that it provides to our younger students and their families we are not asking you to Halt the changes but we do request more time and more transparency in this process we believe that with more time and collaboration we can find a way to meet the district's need without sacrificing the stability of this school for our children and teachers we want to work together to find the best solution and that requires open dialogue and Community input many parents of this community rely on the school to provide not only education but also a safe environment for their children while they work long hours if the school is repurposed and the changes are not well thought out it could force families to find other schooling options potentially impacting their children's education

026and their family stability for many this school is irreplaceable our neighborhood has been centered around families with with young children if older high school students are brought into the school this could change the dynamic of the entire area parents may become concerned about their children being exposed to behaviors they aren't ready for and there may be perceptions that the area is less safe or familyfriendly I urge the board to consider a more gradual approach to these changes and seek more input from the families and teachers who will be directly impacted perhaps we can explore alternative Solutions such as creating separate programs for high school students or finding ways to support pregnant teens in different settings this will allow us to keep the Integrity of our elementary school intact while still meeting the needs of our

027community in conclusion repurposing the school has been has potential to create a necessary disruption for our teachers students and the entire Community we need to protect the stability of the school especially for families who rely on it every day I ask the board to Recon these changes and to prioritize the needs of the children the teachers and families who have trusted the school as a Cornerstone of our community our goal is to ensure that any changes to our school are made with careful consideration of all factors involved especially the impact of the students the teachers and the families who rely on us we ask the board to reconsider the timeline provide more opportunities for the parents and teacher involvement and and explore other alternatives to repurposing the school such as utilizing other buildings in the

028area I know that together we can find a solution that will benefit everyone thank you our next speaker tonight is uh Gonzalo Espinosa all righty last week I came here and I spoke up as a coach right so last week I spoke about the lack of transparency and communic Communications regarding the closures since then I was informed the district has started sending physical letters and notices to the staff why wasn't this done from the start why did it take for the public backlash for the district to communicate properly this is not leadership in my opinion what this is is damage control but the damage has already been done teachers and parents as you can see they feel lied to and deceived and while they are the ones that are affected right now this is a

029warning for everybody in the district teachers and parents of other campuses that given the district's history of lack of transparency and consideration one day this might be you you might be sitting here asking the board for the same things hopefully you have more than five minutes to ask questions as that's how long the Lamar staff had to ask the superintendent questions when he paid them a visit to discuss the matter also since last week multiple members of the district communties reached out to me and clarified that they never recommended a closure instead they were given a binder by Administration that provided data solely to support that consolidation find it fit in the narrative but were never given other options to explore like Standalone rezoning whenever one of the members asked if rezoning alone could Sol

030solve the issue the comment was dismissed and reated that consolidation was the top priority because the district had data to back it up but if rezoning is happening anyways with or without disclosure why wasn't this considered to avoid the closure from the first place right why why do we have to shut down a school now committee members also revealed that they were given plenty of data but not critical details that matter in a huge decision like this like the fact that the district has no long-term Financial strategy to sustain these changes as they made it also known in the last board meeting for the lady that presented their their case however how can you make a decision this far reaching Financial financially with implications without knowing where the money will come from I mean I

031can't even pass buy a piece of shoe some shoes right now without cons Consulting my wife how can you do that one member told me the closure voter passed by a slight margin and with full information including the lack of funds the outcome could have been different it is clear the district's agenda is driving this decision not the but not the best interest of the students families or teachers I ask the I ask the board this if even one of this committee committee members feels misled how can the public here trust this process how can you believe this is the right decision when the process has been rushed biased and lacking transparency thank you also I have here from the gccd website a portrait of a leader how ironic is this their five uh top

032points are leads with Integrity makes strategic decisions builds relational relationship capacity and collaborates with others and communicates effectively how ironic straight from the district's website thank you have a good night thank [Applause] you our next speaker is Terry Martino good evening and very with me I have a couple of questions to ask the board would you be okay sending your child to a focused School known by tea as an F School R campus would you be okay if you were if you were a teacher being forced to go to a focus campus known as an fady campus where tea Region 4 and District admin were on your campus in out of your classrooms wouldn't it make more sense to move one of the other schools to better help those teachers who have or might be

033struggling we have been told by many visitors that Lamar is one of the best schools they have ever wor been to we worked highly to improve our students academics look at our latest ratings have you looked at those did you know Lamar had a low turnover rate compared to ashell who thought they were going to be repurposed last year have you considered that Lamar should have two or three more years to give teachers and students ample time to decide what the next step would be not slapped in the face after other people knowing before us of the 2035 plan I have a parent who worked very hard to get $2500 deposit so she could be close enough for her children to walk to and from school this just happened last month had she known this

034you think she would have moved there no she wouldn't have was Lamar St blindsided to L more family and staff we were my last question to the board is one minute I better get my glasses on please vote no to repurpose of the highest rated school on the south side and that we are thank you thank you our next speakers are Christine McDow and our Ario mdow hi my name is Chrissy and I'm a a Lamar lion I want to say how much we love this school and how much they all have helped and protected my daughter because they all love her and she loves them I don't understand how you're going to close an AB school and leave open an F school and you want to send our children there they will not be

035getting the same education attention that they obviously deserve and that is not fair to these children you cannot convince me that anyone from Ashville Smith would be here to fight for their closing of their school it's a failing school and has been for a long time it is definitely it definitely isn't getting any better especially if you add more students in fact if Ash parents even knew that this was going on they may they may be up here fighting right beside us so that their children can have a chance at a better education than the one they're getting right now they certainly cannot keep staff and it's a revolving door and that in itself is sad something needs to be done with that school and it isn't keeping it open all I heard last at

036the last meeting was Lamar was picked due to being the best money maker and that is wrong I feel people are putting themselves in their paychecks before our children and their well-being I hope you can find it in your hearts to make the right decision that's best for our children and what we Lamar lion parents and staff are begging continue to do this is the best school and experience I've had as a parent as I have older children that are 28 and 27 who also went here the whole time and they went to San Joo we are Lamar lions and always will be thank you thank [Applause] you hi my name is Aria and I am a Lal lion I'm here today for one minute to fight for my school I don't want it to

037close I love it there and I feel safe there please don't take away the people and school I love make the white choice tonight thank you thank you on behalf of the board we'd like to acknowledge and thank every member of the public that came out and gave input tonight and um thank you for taking the time out of your busy schedule to come and speak with us we really appreciate each of you thank you uh now once the board as we move now Dr O'Brien we will move to uh number three on our agenda discussion items and at this point it will be designated staff who will be speaking and let's move forward as you may thank you madam president number three a superintendent report we have the board recommendation or recommendation to the

038board to repurpose Lamar Elementary it will be presented by facilities and Community engagement it's on good evening president TS BR Tims board members Dr O'Brien um we are here today to discuss the recommendation to the board to consider consolidation repurpose of Lamar Elementary um I have with me I'm kendel David uh executive director of community engagement I'm Brenda Garcia the director of facilities planning and construction and Matt Binger assistant superintendent of HR so let's talk about why we as a district have considered consolidation to begin with we know that this is a very difficult process um that that falls on our community on our district on our students so why are we considering a consolidation of an elementary school in our district uh the first is declining student population this was directly highlighted by the

0392024 demographic study um it highlights underu underutilization of facilities on the south side of Goose Creek we have also been called um to to be very efficient with tax dollars so whenever um we talk about maximizing District resources a campus consolidation at the levels that many of our elementary schools are sitting at capacity wise on the South Side um it is not maximizing per pup spending um and ultimately a school consolidation would generate an annual cost Savings of two almost $2.5 million in addition to that we are undergoing a district a district comprehensive resoning plan um ultimately we um will be looking at about four to 5,000 students that are impacted by rezoning um as as a whole that's about 18% of our student population ultimately the goal of resoning is we have campuses on

040the north side of our district that are sitting at over capacity um and again campuses on the south side of our district that are sitting under capacity so it directly aligns with the rezoning efforts that are forthcoming uh this school year in addition to that we do have the opportunity uh to expand Services uh that Peter E Highland offers as well as child care services in our district and also um it is imperative that we move point out of the old sanino that building is um very inefficient and very costly to maintain and keep students um in that facility and then last um just looking at State challenges it's no secret that lack of funding has really forced a Statewide trend of leveraging all different types of budget reduction measures uh School consolidation is being

041considered by many districts which we'll talk about here in a minute um as a budget reduction strategy so let's talk about um Elementary campus capacities this is a very short glimpse of uh campuses across the district if you notice campuses in red are overc capacity and will continue to increase um over capacity over the next 10 years campuses the campuses in red for the most part are campuses on the north side of the district campuses in yellow are uh typically your central uh campuses those are sitting anywhere between 80 and 90% um and and are almost at capacity if you look many of these campuses increase uh drastically over the next 10 years I'd like to point out Victoria Walker Ben Whos um a consistent increase of capacity at those schools on the North side

042on the contrary you also have schools on the South Side specifically ashell Smith and Lamar Elementary that are currently sitting at 58 and 60% capacity um those uh capacity numbers remain stagnant over the next 10 years uh indicating that we will do not uh plan on seeing much growth in those areas okay I want to talk just on the on the Staffing side and the budget reduction side um so at the close of last year the district anticipated $12 million deficit uh for this school year 2425 school year um Miss Clark and her her business team will of course leads that initiative and uh they'll do that again this early spring uh since an additional expenses have Arisen including um increased Insurance costs um also lower tax rate so those those are just two pieces

043that U have have increased the uh the deficit this year's budget reduction will be significant we know that and we have already implemented numerous Cuts over the past two years you've been involved in those cuts um particularly in Staffing and so uh the consolidation of Lamar Elementary or any any Elementary for that matter um is expected to save the district approximately $24 million um and we'll talk about other other districts in the state of Texas who are facing similar challenges but this gives a breakdown uh because the question was asked you know where are those uh cost savings and it's really two two pieces one one is Staffing and then the second piece is um taking the old s jno offline and so you can see it itemized um for Sano on on the maintenance

044repairs and the utility cost and and Miss Garcia can talk in depth if you have questions on that um for Staffing I think it's important to say that if we consolidate any Elementary um individuals are not losing their job they will have a job um what consolidation does because we have several elementaries at 60% as you just saw in the slide before um is if there are duplicate positions we will find another position at another another Elementary School for those positions for example a principal um a counselor a receptionist um positions that that that are not needed for for duplicate roles and so we would find vacancies and we'll get into the transition process here in a minute but uh but we have identified over 40 positions for an Elementry School including Lamar that would

045uh save 1.7 million that's the projected cost and then you can see the um the following savings with taking the old sing just offline and so the the uh total cost is 2.4 million you go to the next slide um also it's important to note um that many districts across Texas are facing several challenges including uh declining enrollment in certain areas of town increased operational costs and also U the need to maximize resources due to reduced funding we know that Statewide that uh that that funding has been a huge challenge we haven't received an increase since before covid um inflation has has contributed to that um also there's been an increase in funded mandates and so many districts including Goose Creek we're not immune to it are are having to make very difficult decisions that

046we do not want to make um and this is one of those decisions you can see that almost 20 districts over the last two years have Consolidated one or more campuses right now um I believe El Paso announced they're consolidating 10 campuses um Lewisville is consolidating five right now Gus Creek is looking at one um and and that may change in the future but I know that um again this is a this is a tough decision that that many districts are are in the same boat um addressing this concern okay so let's talk about the campus consolidation and repurpose timeline in March of last year we had a budget reduction Workshop where we uh considered as a tier 2 budget reduction strategy a consolidation of one of our campuses um at that time um we

047felt like we didn't have enough information and we wanted to make sure that we were doing our due diligence in making that decision and so a demographic study was completed by June of 2024 and presented to the board and Community um from the de findings of the demographic study it was very clear that there was a need to rezone and there was definitely an option um capacity wise to consolidate a campus on the south side of Goose Creek GC 2035 was formed in August and proceeded to have um five meetings regarding um um facilities and long range facility planning as well as going into rezoning in the coming months um on October 29th GC 2035 reached consensus that Lamar would be repurposed now I will say um that the district brought forth the option of

048consolidation the committee was simply to consider both facilities that were being um presented and uh charged with determining what would fit best for for the repurposing in addition um in at the November board meeting immediately following the October 29th meeting uh we provided an update to the board and the next day to the Lamar Community to inform them of the GC 2035 uh recommendation that would occur in December uh last Monday the GC 2035 committee presented uh the long range facility plan and of course it did include the repurposing of Lamar Elementary before you move on uh m David um I think it's important the demographic study you had it on the first slide with a 10year snapshot so most people would pick up that that's a 10e picture of it correct who conducted the

049demographic study and what what basis did they have to conduct the study absolutely so um it is a firm called paa and they are um used by the majority of the districts districts in the state um the report is available online it is a comprehensive report of 250 300 pages and it really analyzes um planning units um upcoming planning units birth rates uh School Trends um it's a very large study and I will say that um we have had a Passa study done in 2019 and just in looking at their projections they are very accurate um over the last five years what they projected five years ago uh where our campuses would be standing currently at this moment so let's talk about GC 2035 uh Miss Garcia is going to walk um you guys through

050the data that was presented to this committee but ultimately um just as a as a reminder this committee was formed um it was a community- based committee it consist of 117 original members from all over um our community parents uh alumni uh community business owners uh teachers students administrators um and again they were tasked to choose between two campuses uh to consider for repurposing so miss Garcia is going to walk us through um the intricacies of how that decision was made sure so when the committee uh compared the Lamar and the Smith campuses they reviewed several factors um some of the factors they reviewed were things like the facility condition assessments that we had done on various campuses that includes the deficiencies um that are at these um campuses that were assessed they also reviewed

051things like the site the acreage uh the traffic flow and the different entrances at each campus they also reviewed campus accessibility and classroom use and then um the demographic uh study information that Ken mentioned as well when looking at Lamar um the major thing that um that stood out was that there was a lot more outdoor space um 2.8 Acres of outdoor usable outdoor space at Ashville Smith in comparison to about 1.5 Acres at Lamar Elementary um Additionally the amount of deficiencies um the cost estimation to do uh that work was um quite a bit higher higher by um over $5 million at the Lamar campus versus the Ashville Smith campus um including um a um a need to review or to renovate the um internal stairwell at Smith that would be uh very comprehensive

052um additionally there were more priority ones at the Lamar campus um I mentioned this because we really wanted to focus on if there was going to be an ele Elementary campus that would serve um 800 students we wanted it to be the campus that was in the best shape um additionally um just the layout of the Lamar campus with uh minimal modifications that would be needed at the entrances in particular to accessible restrooms for for um the program that could become the child care facility and those restrooms already being available on the for first floor with easy access for drop off for those parents as well um so ultimately the decision was made um based on um the facility that that was viewed as the best suited to be able to support the district's repurposing

053needs okay in in the event that this decision is approved by the the board we do want to present a uh a tentative transition plan um if if resoning is approved which which I think that's coming down here here in a here in about two months um the majority of Lamar students would be reson to to Carver Elementary and a smaller portion would be reson to Ashville Smith and so we want to make sure that the transition plan U it's a very stressful process and so we want it to be as organized and as clear as as possible I know over the last two years we've had to um reduce positions and so there there's been opportunities to um um have to reassign or have to go through a process to make sure that we're

054reducing positions and several individuals um have moved from one campus to another um we don't like doing that but but of course if that's needed then we want to make sure that U we have a clear process in place and so pending board approval uh the plan is to send out a survey to to the teachers of Lamar beginning on January 6 where they can State their preferences uh whether it be a certain School such as Carver or Smith or if they prefer to be on the transfer uh transfer list and then that survey will be open for about uh 3 weeks and then after that administrative guidelines will be followed um in the reassigning process teachers uh will not interview for Carver or Ashville Smith um if they choose the transfer list then principales

055will have the opportunity to to select them our plan is to create a a a special list for the school that's Consolidated and provide that to principals ahead of the transfer list so they would have priority um so principls would have that list to u to to fill their vacancies at that time uh we typically do Staffing in March every year we do Staffing in March we do elementary and then secondary and so um so right after spring break our plan is to start the reassignment process as soon as possible once we have those numbers of course this is also pending on the resoning approval so we know where um where where staff positions are allocated and so um so our plan is to notify as soon as possible so that staff will know what

056their with a reassignment will be our transfer window every year opens April 1st so I wanted to put that on here districtwide and then um then if if Lamar teachers uh prefer the transfer list and if they happen not to be selected then uh we would make sure that we uh we would we would find a reassignment and we'd work with that teacher in 101 to see what vacancies are available to try to meet their needs um while also meeting the needs of the staff um it's important this bolded piece right here all staff members will retain a job and that's really what we're pushing for or um we are concerned down the road about financial excy and we want to make sure that we are making good decisions now that will sustain the district

057long term and so um so this is the transition plan that we would put in place okay so in summary um I hope today we've communicated that ultimately this is a very difficult decision it's a difficult process for us as administrators to go through Dr O'Brien the GC 2035 committee um we are our not in a position where this is favorable we know that this is going to be very very difficult for the community should it be approved but ultimately um I I we want you as a board to know that GC 2035 carefully evaluated campuses um they they were looking at this from a lens of what is the best suited campus for repurposing um ultimately we tried to create an environment where it was an unbiased approach to assess facilities and their alignment

058with the district needs for repurpose again this is a Statewide challenge go Goose Creek is not alone uh many other districts are have already made the decision to consolidate schools um many other districts are um going to see school consolidations come up on their board agendas in the future as a budget reduction strategy uh we want to make sure we say that uh job security for staff is is very important to us and that no staff members will lose their job um in this process and HR is committed to ensuring that teachers of the Consolidated campus are um are met in a situation where their skills are best utilized to support our kids ultimately this is a strategic budget reduction item repurposing Lamar is a cost-saving measure that that we have been looking at since

059uh budget Workshop of last year um and operating schools at 60% is is not efficient um is not efficient way to spend tax dollars and at this uh current time as we go through a comprehensive resoning plan this effort ultimately is part of a a very broad rezoning initiative in our district um and so this is not something that just Lamar will go through when it comes to transferring uh students to different campuses this is something that will will come up for many many um of our families are there any questions I have some questions so I just just want to and not really I don't know anyway I just want clarification I guess so I heard you say that other students in the district will will need to transfer campuses which also means other

060teachers in the district will need to transfer campuses um also I've seen that there's talk about um students who are moving to different campuses maybe fitting into the the teachers classrooms that are already there so my in my head my thought is that if we're moving teachers also to these new campuses we shouldn't expect these huge class sizes so their students should still be getting the attention that they're they're currently receiving at their current school yeah our staffing ratio will not change so it'll be the same it'll be the same district wide that on on the same of District y with teacher student ratio that was what I'm looking at the numbers cuz some of our North Side have a little bit larger classes so we don't want that Trend to happen if we're going

061to merge something we want to look at our ratio and being beneficial to our students and our teachers as well so we I'm with Tiffany on that one it wasn't real clear for me I'll tell you I'll tell you um that that one of the main reasons that we are looking at resoning is because we do have campuses that are over capacity and so it's very challenging um when we have campuses that continue to that area continues to grow and we have more students enroll in those schools um we're at a point where we're we're maxed at a lot of our campuses and that's ultimately why we are looking at a comprehensive rezone for all of our schools to to create that um Equity across the district and I'll say that we are staffed at

062the same ratio districtwide so if for example pumfrey is is you know at high capacity that they will get an additional teacher if they if they cross that that formula to add another teacher um but as far as space goes um that that's the challenge yeah so I got a question how much is it going to cost to modify Lamar if it passes we were never toally given any numbers we're still reviewing um based on your decision those programs that will be put into the campus and so um um just in in researching it um minimal modifications would have to be done um we don't have an estimate for you today but um we'll plan on but that would that would reduce the number of savings and cost that you the 2.4 million that you

063were uh that is correct please keep in mind that that 2 point um 2.4 2.4 is per year over at least the next five years and so there's no way that it would be anywhere close to that a couple of questions one is if we do move students from Lamar to Smith and Carver instead of them sitting at 60% about where will they lie capacity wise let me pull that for you they will uh be sitting depending on which rezoning option is selected um they will be sitting anywhere between about 87 and 93% at those campuses so if we move 88 kids from Smith I mean from Lamar to Smith we're going to move for teachers too with the ratio yes it the whenever we do Staffing uh once we know where the students are

064seated basically or assigned uh projected then that'll tell us how many teachers we need um each each school and how many peer professionals and so on since you since you have the m my my last question for now is you mentioned administrative guidelines will be followed when reassigning can you elaborate on that just a tiny bit are we talking Staffing ratios or what else yes so so what I meant by that was on the administrative guidelines it's it's based off seniority per grade level and so we'd still follow that process but we'd also look at that survey result to see um what teachers prefer and we'll try to as best as we can honor that request okay and so I think it's going to be very much of a customiz um reassignment uh a little

065bit different than what we've done in the past where once we have a vacancy we move that teacher immediately our our hope I don't know if we can I don't think we'll be able to meet everyone's needs um or their get their first preference but our goal is to to do to maximize that as much as possible thank you but excuse me so for example there's 38 teachers at Lamar there's 300 vacancies annually across the district so with the number of vacancies we will have due to retirement and people who move and things of that nature um 10% of what we're talking about a 10% move into 100% vacancy uh going forward with those that opt not to go to Lamar I mean opt not to go to Carver or ashel but there is the

066chance that all teachers don't have to go to the Ashville uh they can go if they see a position somewhere else they can go there so in the uh preference survey right um they can they can pick a reassignment to Carver or to Ashville Smith as their first and second choice or they can select uh being on the transfer list and then there's also going to be a place where they can add comments so if they wanted to drill a little bit deeper they can do that as well so if I'm a teacher who selects the transfer list right then I'm saying that I'm going to be put out there and then uh then we'll create a special list just for Lamar teachers and provide that to principls so if I'm over at Harlem Elementary

067and I have a fifth grade vacancy I can see um the teachers are eligible for that from that Lamar list and and talk to those teachers how many for example Mr Samson if a a teacher teaches fourth grade ELR and they only want to teach fourth grade and Carver and um ashal do not have that vacancy that's when they would opt for the transfer to another campus across our district that might have a fourth English spot open how many what is the possibility of the kids from The Mark going to Ashville whatever School Carver that they can possibly get the same teacher that they have or had at Lamar if they moved to to that school that way they have you know that so the the students would not be moving in the the same

068uh instructional year so they would be uh starting their next grade level with a new teacher regardless so this will take place at you know the the next calendar or instructional year okay yeah and so that they get a new teacher regardless um so it's not one for one right well I mean if I go from third grade to fourth grade I'm G to have a new teacher that next year but maybe the question is will I have an Lamar you know a Lamar teacher um as as my teacher and I don't know how how complicated that would be um that's something we can look at yeah I will tell you one thing to note again with the comprehensive rezone and looking at the best rezone options uh again to improve efficiency across the district

069many of the Lamar um students will be zoned or could be zoned to Carver um in addition to that many students from Carver who may be closer to Travis Elementary San jino Elementary could be rezoned outside of Carver into one of those campuses so it is it is very complex when you're looking at a comprehensive rezone and a shift um we have not done a comprehensive rezone of our district um in over 10 years um so we have a lot of pocket zones we have a lot of zones that uh transportation is traveling uh quite some distance to transport students that aren't as efficient because that's the zoning that uh made sense at the time and so much of the district will will experience a change in their student population in keep resoning be in

070keeping with that Kendall do you think that we'll lose some of our kids to Bob Hope school and how many have we lost that brought our percentages down I never got any numbers on that either I can't predict that um I can tell you um in the demographic study it was presented um that we have lost students to Bob Hope currently they are only servicing up into third grade I can get you the ex exact number um that was uh presented by the demographer Dr Binger my question is for you uh how many teachers currently are at Lamar that would have to go on the transfer list or go to other options I can't answer that yet because once we do rezoning um then we'll do Staffing and what let me let me rephrase it

071how many teachers at Lamar currently will be moving moved one way or another how many current teachers do we have at Lamar if we consolidate no current currently right now how many teachers will be affected tomorrow 38 38 but it it depends on um what the projected enrollment is for next year if if they if they lose one or two teachers then we would reassign those teachers or they would get on the transfer list so we haven't we don't receive those projections yet until we reone right but but currently tonight as we said here we have 38 teachers that would be affected by this projecting just ballpark projecting of those 38 how many will we be moving over to Carver and Smith okay best guess yeah so so my best guess would be the M

072the vast majority of them would end up at Carver Ashville Smith because that's where the students are going um there there may be a chance where there may be one or two teachers um that end up at a different school but based off if all the students are are moving to just one of two schools then the staff will most likely follow um the numbers may not fall exactly right so there may be one or two teachers who who elect to be on the transfer list and end up elsewhere but I would say the vast majority would fall into one of those two schools but we could expect tonight that the majority of those teachers could be expect to go follow their students to those schools and bring their culture to ashbell and to um

073Carver Carver yes sir all right outside of an exception where a teacher wants to stay in the same grad level and that's not available at one of those two campuses then they could get on the right and that's understood uh I'm I'm looking more at the availability portion of it um I want to change it over to just a little bit and pardon my congestion I I I got this here at the board and I'm going to keep it here uh Dr Binger we talk all the time about our teachers and our staff I want to use the word employees instead and I want to I want to hear directly from you and I want our community here that we are referring to employees when we say no one will lose their job if we

074uh consolidate the school and it being in the best interest of our district and to me that means retaining every employee that's U committed to serving our district in one way or another where there be a bus driver custodian receptionist uh all the way up to the principal uh I want to use the word employee are we retaining all of our employees yes uh and what I'd like to say is over the last two years we've reduced over 200 positions and and we use the attrition model um so so what that means is that we we have vacancies in the district and then we we allow certain staff members to to get placed into that vacancy so that someone does not lose their job um our our main concern and I I feel like a

075lot of districts are talking about this is what we don't want to do is get into a situation where we have to have a reduction in force where where individuals do lose their jobs and so um by making some of these tough decisions we're hoping over the last two years at least that um that we're able to continue to use the attrition mall to make sure everyone stays gamefully employed um a lot of those reassignments are are either welcomed or they're not too dramatic uh but I I'm not going to lie to you some of them are you know depending on you know a certain certain secretary in this building was moved to a campus um because she was last and first out and so that happened a year later a vacancy opened up here

076at admin and she was able to move back so so there is some transition but the key is that we want to try to retain employment and we've done that successfully over the last two years and the followup to that is it would be at comparable pay they would not be moved to a lower paying position correct correct thank you for clarifying for the for for the most part unless there's these n uh Niche or Niche positions that are that are difficult to fill and so they may but they they keep their pay for the year and then we make adjustments now that's not true for any contracted employee um that they they they are placed into uh the same the same pay position um when we're talking about teachers for the vast majority were

077able to find that same or similar position because there's many of them thank you for clarifying so um if the uh repurpose were to um pass uh Lamar would still remain an education facility um what is the likelihood of some of are current employees at Lamar staying at Lamar at the new education facility is that possibility I don't think we've gotten that far down the road the the example that I'm thinking of is like let's say the custodial staff or the cafeteria workers um there's going to be a need there um but if for example Peter E Highland moves over they also have custodians they also have uh cafeteria workers so I think we're going to have to to iron that out on what that would look like I will say that just in talking

078about this the concerns that you're bringing up we've also had those concerns and so I've asked the question how many vacancies do we have in the custodial department and you know nutrition services and there's absolutely vacancies there are consistently they are consistently filling in those roles and if we're talking about adding a large population of students at any campus you're probably going to need more custodial staff and more food service staff on the campus right we have a ratio that we staff at for that uh the issue is that our ratio is pretty Broad and so even with our smaller campuses we've just kept the ratio the same um and so so there will be an adjustment to that but it'll be us utilizing that staff more efficiently at at at that campus and then

079back to your question um just in thinking about it I mean we we'll resort to administrative guidelines so it'll be based off seniority on on who gets who gets that position and who doesn't uh if they want to go to you know to another facility my next question uh Miss Garcia is for you um looking at it constrict con I promise I'm not on anything from a con construction standpoint construction standpoint I am definitely under the weather looking at it solely from the construction standpoint and you don't have numbers and I understand that you are you probably know our buildings more than anyone in the district uh I've toured many of them with you do you feel that this is the best repurposing use of this building and that we would get years of use

080out of it given the direction that Administration wants to take this and I know it's kind of putting you in the hot seat but this board's going to kind of come to you down the road and say well you you thought this would be a good we could do it for so much money um I just kind of want to know from you because you're you're the expert in this field that this is the right direction to repurpose that school or should we look at repurposing it into something different the short answer is yes I'm very comfortable with this plan and um truly we did a lot of work um ahead of time um in presenting the information to the committee um you know internally a review a facility and look at all of the

081different options and because of the programs that need to be moved to that are suggested to be moved to this particular facility um the the most important thing was really having two points of access for injury um to to separate the two groups and um in reality it's uh two groups that are already currently at one campus and so they would be relocating to a different one and the facility would function very much in the same manner as having uh separate points of entrance of of an entrance um again we talked a little bit about the repairs there really would be minimal at this campus it truly is the best suited for repurposing okay and along those lines um that would take Point going to the old Peter Highland building is that correct correct that

082is correct let's talk a little bit a little bit about Peter Highland that and the same question and um I'll go ahead and ask Merced Mr rri's question too how much remodeling will that take to put point in there um probably also very minimal because the spaces um that are needed by that campus are already there um if anything some minor painting um they already have secured entrances secured fencing all of those things are already in place for that type of Campus um the um and as a matter of fact they'd have a little bit more um Elbow Room at that campus including something that they really appreciate being at the old Santo facility is cafeteria space eating space without being on top of each other as y'all are aware their old campus was very

083crowded their eating um cafeteria was a portable so now they'll have a little bit more breathing space and that's really been one of the reasons why they've want wanted to remain at the old Sano uh additionally it has a gym that uh was that space was not available at their old facility and so um it it's ready to serve day one for them and we would get years of useful life for point at that facility yes absolutely for both campuses correct okay thank you you know in keeping with this question when you say minimal 200,000 500,000 um probably probably closer for for a Lamar repurpose but um point is is uh I'm sorry Peter Highland facility it's moving ready it's already functioning um no I'm talking about Lamar itself are you saying how much give

084me a number just saying minimal that tell would you be looking at as partition um Pathways to section off the the one side of the campus from the other side of the campus for example and I'm glad you brought this up Mr Martinez to go back to you could a current employee at Lamar St at Lamar under the repurposed plan and the answer to that is yes under several circumstances custodian cafeteria worker other hourly employees possibly but there is a shot just so everyone will understand what the repurpose is of of A Faculty a teaching faculty member to because the repurpose is going to be 9th through 10th grade I mean sorry 9th through 12th grade in addition to 0o through three years old so if there was a prek or a kindergarten teacher that

085wanted to go to a0o through three teaching position that's a possibility I'm not that's not a promise from the from up here I'm just saying there are considerations that are academic teacher um pertaining to the needs there if a fifth grade teacher was very confident in uh their their language skills to teach a ninth grade class that would be a possibility to for them to they may already be certified secondary so those are chances that a person who was really determined to stay on the campus could for academic reasons beyond the uh hourly employees okay Randy thank you for interrupting me but I need a number back back to your question I it it is very difficult to provide you with a number um we need to review um ways that we can renovate the

086facility in a flexible manner um flexible could be uh the use of partition spaces um uh a roll down gate those are different different than making permanent changes to a facility and so um those things need to be reviewed scoped out also need to speak with the campuses and the programs that need to move in and make sure that we um design that space that's suitable to work for them and don't you think that before we make a big decision like this those things should have been hashed out already so we would know the numbers I I do I do want to answer I do want to answer that question um when we design facilities um a first step that we always take is is doing a feasibility study is it possible will it work

087and that's what was done for this facility yeah well I'm just saying you know we're we're projecting 2.4 million savings but we're not projecting how much we're going to spend to modify that school so it's not going to be the way we're we're projecting that it's going to be the numbers are going to be different and it's very expensive be very close I'd also like to point out that that's a projected 2.5 million yearly so yes we may have to make some some very minor modifications to that campus but that is a one-time cost you know I semantics I I just don't you know I'm a construction guy myself and in hearing y'all say it's minor it's minimal you know that's not true I can tell you that's not true anytime you go build or

088I can give you an example of something that I'm I'm referencing when I'm saying minor um for example there are toilet fixtures that are suited for um an elementary school student and so that would need to be changed um we do a replacement of um Plumbing fixtures uh frequently within our district that's considered a minor repair so those are things that I'm trying to with those things because we would look at our own construction department for many of those things as well that we could do or would have to bring in a contractor for most of it um we can review that um together with our maintenance department as well to see if that's a possibility um it would also depend on their Workforce availability but but um we could look at purchasing that internally

089as well so there's a lot of avenues that we can take and I I promise we will be um as Frugal as possible with this renovation I mean I get it and I understand what you're saying but I mean that's talk but when you actually get down to work and you know remodify the school and doing all this work they're charging all kinds of money to do work these days so I don't I just don't buy that minimal stuff and I know that there's going to be give you a laundry list of ticket items what things cost like the pull down gate we could give you a cost that's what I'm saying Randy we should have had that already a portable building is $100,000 to move it set it up put an awning on it

090uh hook it up with electrical and water so I mean um you could itemize every single expense but we haven't gotten that far in the process as far as knowing whether it's going to be a a large expense or a small expense so we're using the term minimal to reflect that and that's my point we didn't get no data to make a real good decision with what we're going to do tonight that we just didn't get the numbers we didn't get the information well you got the number on the side of closing the old saneso yeah and the cost Associated issue that was you know an issue that we've had for what two three years now maybe longer since the new s open correct yeah so you know me personally I think we should should

091just sell the San CA the way it is and let somebody else do what they got to do with it and make some more money off of that but that's that my we thank you for your comments I think just in response to that comment um you know a lot of the families here tonight have talked about uh you know home value and educational facilities and I think just I I would like to note when it comes to Sano that that Community has expressed um that that building should not be turned into just anything and so that's why it's being considered for a demolition and and us having um you know a a say for that community and what it turns into the same as Lamar should it be repurposed will continue to be an

092education you're talking about apples and oranges because we have a new sanino that old Sano is no longer a part going to be a part of our school district they have something to compensate for now these students are going to be dispersed throughout the school district that's a real B different thing I have a question Kendall or for you to kind of s like repurposing the buildings or properties for other um District use but also being mindful that our Partnerships and with the communities could you kind of expressed that when you shared with me and as I had asked that question about uh the property and public use meaning we could sell it to someone and they could put what they want there which not would not would may be an eyesore for the community

093so could you kind of elaborate on that a little bit if you I'm sorry to take this little time absolutely but I want you to hear this too absolutely so when we first started looking at the demolition of old sjo one of the biggest concerns from that Community because it lies in the middle of a neighborhood um was that if that facility was sold to say a storage building now you're going to have a completely different landscape and use of a fa of a facility in the middle of a neighborhood and so just like Lamar continuing to be an educational facility we'd want to be very careful with how we uh utilize old SOS and who you know what control we have over that uh building simply because it is again in the middle of

094um a neighborhood that's my neighborhood and you you know in we we have refineries all through our neighborhood there you know I'm just saying that we can't control things that happen after we sell it we're trying to control what we have right now and we can't do that so you know my my whole deal is in response to you know Madame president's question is you know hey we're selling it to make the money to to offer more to our students not to control what's put in the neighborhood so we we you know that's not even a to me that's not even an argument there I got another question is Lamar Elementary an A&B school or not I want to clear the air with that because I've heard some discussion you know that it is I've

095heard some some comments tonight that it is but I've heard other comments that it's not and I want to answer that maybe Randy can answer that I can answer it for you um you know we have not had a through F accountability since 2021 is that correct Miss Jackson so to to use that term the a through F uh that that has not been released for any uh scores over the past three instructional years I will say I pulled data for because I was curious myself that it is something that has come up across the community I've pulled third through fifth reading scores at ashell Carver and Lamar and third through fifth Mass score at ashell Carver and Lamar and they are relatively performing at relatively simil similar levels ashel Smith uh performed 62 approaches

096um last uh instructional year Carver at 66 and Lamar at 63 in approaches uh that was for reading for math Asheville uh 46% approaches Carver 53% approach approaches Lamar 58% approaches so they are performing at relatively similar levels um all three of those campuses and something that hadn't come up tonight is the all three campuses are within one mile of one another which was not uncommon 30 years ago today and that was because 80% of the population of Baytown was south of itin or even further south south of central what we call Central Baytown now and today 80% of the population is north of that centrus line so um the demographic study that was repres um referred to this evening is is reflective of that uh I don't think anyone architect or otherwise would have

097recommended building three campuses within a mile of one another that would have have that house that many students even with highly dense uh housing U there's it just wouldn't have been done that closely together that's correct Randy but here's a question well if if there's that many in the North why can't we rezone and move them down some just that is that is absolutely what we are proposing and and you'll you'll see those zoning options I agree I I I get it but I'm saying without repurposing Lamar just rezone and everybody move and Mr I'm glad you asked because you know we are again doing a very um extensive rezoning I have to ask kle this is my district and you see the crowd back here they're really concerned about I complet I completely agree

098and I and I'm glad you asked and and let me say this um again we you're going to see um in in the coming weeks that yes it should the Lamar repurposing be approved um then we can release some of the rezoning options that we would uh propose to our community to provide feedback on and again they will push many students down towards uh the south side of the district but what I will also say is there is a threshold when it comes to transporting students you cannot take students it is not recommended to take students past a certain point to trans to transport to school who recommended it um transportation at some point it becomes more costly to transport students it's going to cost them money they and they have less money to move

099around this is a poverty stricking area we're talking about Transportation people some people don't even have cars in our District transportation will be provided to students to go to schools okay and I think the point is uh just for transportation if you're transporting them over long distances students are going to be sitting on that bus for over an hour one way and we also don't want that to happen too so there so when there's boundaries as far as how far you transport them I think that's a that's also consider I happen to talk to the director of transportation and asked that very question what is our current route average and it ranges between 25 minutes to 40 minutes is our current route so the proposal to bring students from north of it 10 to South

100uh could leave them on the bus for an hour and a half each way every day so that's just me checking and asking a question that's not research I just wanted to know what our current routes are and what they would be if we were to to route or rezone students that would fill up these campuses without moving anybody else have Co guy have more I I think another piece of the puzzle that we need to look at is point they're over in a building that we promised the community that we would no longer utilize uh when they passed a bond and we got pushed into a corner because of uh we hate to say it unfunded State mandates um with this vaping issue and we had to increase capacity that was the only option

101at the time but I think we need to talk a little bit about how we're on borrowed time over there whether we need to build a new building to house that program or pump a ton of money into sustaining a building we promised we wouldn't keep um and I think that's a piece of this puzzle we really need to look at as well and this kind of alleviates that at least for the foreseeable future am I seeing that correctly yes any savings that may be realized by this proposal would be lost in the uh complete restoration of the old San jinto in order to be able to allow point to stay there with this move is allowing them to move into a more updated facility at the current Peter H campus and option b would

102we would be we have to go out and build a new building to House Point correct that we currently do not have a building that would house them that's correct so it's um we are we are solving more than one issue here it's a very complex issue and I was the board member that spoke up on tier two six nine months ago that said no we're not going to do this as a knee-jerk reaction uh I I was the one that you know really spoke loudly to that so we have been talking about this for a while um but I think it's it's very comprehensive U and it it it's there's more going on behind the scenes that are really looking at the district as a whole um than what many of us realize I'm

103a I'm a don't close the school kind of guy uh but but I'm also a bigger don't lay off an employee that would be the absolute last thing I would do as a trustee um but given the circumstances that we're in uh I think we're looking at a lot of different options that are sustaining the district and that is going to allow us to provide quality education um I want to speak too also about our best assets and resources are what's in the building not the building uh I want to speak a little bit about our teachers that are at Lamar they are great people um we we have not forgot y'all we talk about y'all all the time but we also have a commitment to the community as a whole and if it means

104we have to go through a little tough time and reallocate our resources to keep you here at Goose Creek that's my best option rather than even look at a reduction of force down the road uh I just wanted to share that with y'all but uh I I think we need to look at the other piece of the puzzle and that's old Sano we we have a commitment to our community and I haven't forgot it I sat on that Bond committee and Miss Garcia I said we're going to back this but sano's got to go that's the agreement uh but we had to borrow that on time but that time's ticking um that was more of a comment than the question is David I had questions for you as well sure uh but I sent those

105earlier and you did address in the slideshow so thank you for that thank you before you move on though I don't think the solution is to to house the Peter Highland students and point students over our students that are growing up and barely learning they didn't make any of those decisions that those students did and they shouldn't be being affected by it now that's just that's not a solution to me that's a travesty and I just don't agree with it and you know I want to talk talk about the committee for a sec if I can what schools did y'all give to them to choose from for repurposing now let me ask you this just has was Austin or Crockett Elementary thrown in that proposal by chance no it we were uh we gave the

106committee ashel Smith and uh Lamar Elementary so only those two yes because they were saying you could roll to that slide and indicate why it was those were the top two right there because they're sitting at 58 and 60 I I get it but rezoning can take care of that that's not the issue to me rezoning we reone and move some of the students from maybe Asheville and caror south I mean I think it would accomplish the same thing we're are we're where we're putting a priority on is point and and uh Peter Highland and that to me is an injustice to our students that haven't you know are learning and growing and especially our neighborhoods legitimate um legitimate concerns Mr I agree with you 100% one of the things that Peter Highland campus does

107and for one I want to make clear those students aren't there because they're in trouble they're not trouble kids necessarily they have chosen a path other than the traditional campus pathway but what having more space for them will do it will capture potentially the 70 or 75 students that disappear within Goose Creek if they have an alternative pathway than the traditional campus and and as most people in the room know Peter Highland is an alternative campus that allows for expeditious uh achieving of their academic goals meaning a kid could graduate in three years even two and a half years a student could graduate from that campus because they have either a remedial path or an accelerated path we have both students at that campus what we're what it will do with more capacity than the

108current campus has for it it will allow us to possibly pick up some of those 50 to 70 students that are disappearing between 9th and 12th grade if they knew they had an option like Peter Highland that had the space to take them because Peter Highland is currently operating at 100% capacity there's no space for us to take some of the students that are disappearing on us so it is to Mr C's point it's multiple purposes uh not just one we're looking at all three but you you make a very valid point well I would put those people in mobile homes or wherever they some temporary setup since they made their choices the rest of the students they need a fair chance that's what I would do and uh that's another solution there's a many

109ways to skin a cat and that would just be me they deserve to have a proper education and you've heard some of the the the teachers saying that you know it's going to be it's going to disrupt all of their lives well I just just to counter just a little is that this is tonight's presentation is all about facilities we could have had an academic report tonight from our cni department and I just think that most uh administrators who prepared this presentation would believe that the students at Lamar even moving will get a highquality education wherever they land exactly if I could speak to that point um so I was born in Baytown and I actually attended four different elementary schools in Baytown um just because you know single mother we lived on housing we

110were able to move every year and we did so I got to attend four different elementary schools one of which was sanino one of which was Alamo and one of which was pump Frey you know these are all schools that have moved um so the the the education quality in our district I think is is something that I should speak to I think that kids can can go to any school in our district and get a very good education um this is you know I I personally um I hate to see schools close because I have witnessed three of the schools that I've been to close and it's a very hard decision of course and so to say that they're not getting proper education because they're going to a different School in our district I

111think is not the the whole picture there thank you well nobody said they weren't getting a proper education we just said that their education was being disrupted you did say they are not going to get a proper education no I said that the we're prioritizing High Point and Peter Highland over on our students that's what I said there are students at those schools who are in very are going through a lot and that that's not their fault it's not something that they chose necessarily yeah okay we're going to I would like first say board members should have we've had ample opportunity to discuss but we are repeating ourselves on some things and thank you Jesse for for presenters for presting much thank you Madame President that does bring us to our next uh item yes

112which would be uh agenda 4 a consideration of approval of the repurposing of Lamar Elementary as outlined within the GC 2035 committee report and as was presented to to you this evening okay the chair will entertain a motion on this item I move to approve the repurpose of Lamar Elementary as presented tonight I'll second okay I have a motion from Mr clim and a second from uh Miss guy to approve the item to repurpose Lamar Elementary do we have any discussion yes I will be voting against this it's in my district I didn't you know this is the reasons I will be voting against it I didn't believe in administration's numbers that they gave the 2.4 million we're going to be spending money when we modify Lamar they didn't give us no datb on the

113cost we're making decisions that we don't know we're going into blindly doing these things uh I know that if it was a school like Crockett or Austin we wouldn't be here today uh I also believe that the committee was guided and it's not the committee's fault they did they did their due diligence and their work but they were only given certain choices and presented the information that they were wanting to give them uh you know I I agree with uh you know or I believe that rezoning would would accomplish the same goal you know and uh lastly but not least is I think we're rushing this decision decision we heard one of the teachers say that it took six hours to come to this conclusion of course there was nothing else to decide but you

114know we don't make those kind of decisions and we shouldn't make those kind of decisions in a rush I think this me personally I think this should have been tabled and gone back to the drawing board but I will be voting against it and it's do we have any other discussion Mr Samson I think that we are looking at a situation that if it have been Ashville Smith someone would a group would be here if it would have been Carver a group would be here I think that what we have to do is look at the whole picture is that we are trying to repurpose in order to develop our school district a little bit more to help all kids elementary kids are resilient they can be at any class or go anywhere we're looking

115at trying to have a situation and I'm I'm you know been up and down about this situation because uh back in the day when they took Harlem out of my community McNair and moved it to the freeway I was disappointed about that and Y A lot of y'all too young to remember that so uh but I think we have to look at it from the big picture and Mr R uh I understand where you're coming from uh I don't think that one way of the other we have to make a general uh decision about the district and the kids we have in here and the kids that we are trying to put in the school because you got to remember all of them are our kids whether they Elementary or high school or trying to

116recover their credits to be someone in this community and as as Mr uh clim and the others have stated you know we here for the kids and that doesn't mean the little kid that doesn't mean the high school kids we talking about all kids and that's the purpose I serve on the board not to be you know partial one way or the other and thank you Mr Samson that's the way thank you and my last thing would be I if we do vote on this I recommend that the next Elementary if it comes up be called Lamar Elementary I I had my light up for disc or discussion we we did not discuss that if this board votes to consolidate what we would do with the name would we take that into a secrate separate

117action or would the motion and the second want to address that at this point or do we want to look at that separately yes let's look at that separately if it passes there a recommendation for the next an agenda item okay okay yes okay there being no further discussion all in favor please raise your hand one two three four five four I'm sorry Jesse you okay one two three four five 6 four um any oppose one oppose and C for um 54 one oppose 64 one oppose against uh the motion carries okay Dr Brian we're moving to action item 4 B 4 B okay we will now um instructions for our board uh the board will now recess in the Clos session pursuant to the following section of the tensas open meeting act um tensas

118government code section 551.071 551 551.074 551 .075 55108 3 084 4 and 087 no action will be taken while the board is in closed session it is now 7:45 no action was taken while the board was enclosed session Madam president Administration brings before the board for consideration of personnel this evening action item four D recommend that you accept the resignations and retirements and elections as presented okay do I have a motion uh for approval for the uh consent agenda items present it I'll move to approve the elections and resignations and retirements as president second okay was motion by Miss gu second by Mr clim all in favor raise your hand seven unanimous vote and one administrative Personnel the administration brings before the board Katherine Ward as educational technology specialist uh recommending approval uh do I

119have a motion for approval so Move Motion by Mr Clem and second by Miss guy all in favor please raise your hand animous seven votes for and that's it okay okay that was the best nice okay there will be no further business before this board this meeting is now joined at 8:09 good night thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.