001[Music] C e e e [Music] last time Tuesday Pres um just if you don't do I'm understand pleas the city should this middle Independent School District Board of Trustees meeting is duy open for the transaction of business or any matters which may be prbly presented uh agenda item two everybody the only person missing is Sarah verification that compliance with uh open meeting law this is certified that the pro provisions of section 55101 of the Texas government code have been met in connection with public notice of this meeting before we do public forum I wanted to introduce Mike leer is zoomed in with us or Google one of the he is the attorney for the school district thank you Mike for joining us I appreciate it we changed this kind of last minute wanted to let
002y'all know we were originally go in do public form in an ex session we're not going to do that because this meeting was me is meant to talk about the real estate holdings that M has so because of the past things that have gone on we want to make sure that we're fully transparent so we're not going into executive session at all because there's no transaction of business and no transaction so I appreciate everybody showing up today being here the district has a presentation for the board members to go through and look at the different Parcels of land that we have so I wanted to say that before we got a public for on this so anyhow without any further Ado we'll go to agenda item number three public for and the first person and
003if y'all would just go to the front Podium with a little desk up there and speak there that would be wonderful and the first speaker will be Amanda Archer I believe I hope I have the last thank good afternoon schard Dr Howard PES um and all the members of the community that showed up today appreciate you're showing up for our community um I am here to speak to you on behalf of one of our consol School teachers that is unable to be here due to um their teaching oblations today um so I would like to read their statement to you um on their behalf first and foremost any decisions about the land deals or property must be made with one priority the best interest of our students in our community personal agendas should never take
004precedence over the need of our children when decisions are made behind closed doors without collaboration we lose sight of that responsibility thank you to the board for listening to the community at the this past um board meeting however I'm disappointed that the Midland High location was even raised again after being resolved in March this issue was put to rest and it should stay that way many ofs are deeply disturbed by the board president's actions at the last meeting his condescending treatment of the women on that stage was unacceptable these actions damaged the board's morale and erode the community's trust in the board and we expect better to the board president please allow your fellow members to collaborate with you this is not a dictatorship we need open dialogue we need respect and we need cooperative
005decisionmaking for the sake sake of our students in our community lastly the community is watching we are deeply invested in our children's education and we will continue to show up we will continue to raise our voices and we will continue to hold you and this board accountable for acting with transparency and integrity thank you next speaker is Katie Jer thank you for having me again um first and foremost I want to say thank you thank you to the board I have actually been in your position when something really big and controversial and Powerful starts to happen and it's difficult it's a difficult seat to F in um but I do agree that we didn't even have to go through that we had had that difficult conversation back in March we had looked at so many
006different versions of how this Bond could be laid out um and I think the thing that was upsetting and the reason that you saw the response that you did is because people want to know that the bond and the vote that they placed uh in November of 2023 is going to be honored in every aspect of the bond so please know that this was one issue associated with it but that many people spent countless hours being on the committee creating the proposal getting input from Business Leaders teachers athletic directors everyone you can imagine we wanted all that input so we could put the best proposal together possible everyone had an opportunity to be a part of that and I'm not here to throw stones you know and say you should have been there but you
007had an opportunity to be a part of that conversation that conversation is now finished it's been voted on and the public expects you guys now as our leaders to carry that across the finish line and to include every single piece that was proposed in the bond package and promised and my hope is that by doing so you will be able to authentically and genuinely regain the trust of the community because we're delivering on what was promised so again thank you for your quick and Swift response we appreciate the clarity on this issue I hope next time going forward we don't have to have these fights no one wants to do this um we feel like all of this discussion surround what should or shouldn't be in the bond was done so thank you we appreciate
008you please keep serving us to best the abilities thank you next speak speaker is Savannah Davis hi there I also want to thank each of you for making the right decision yesterday I also want to thank those that responded to my emails your responses were candid and warm and I could feel your honesty and loyalty through those emails for those that didn't respond sometimes but not always Avance is a byproduct of guilt moving forward I would like to remind each of you and urge you to keep what I say with you it is never too late to do the right thing it is never too late to get off the Crooked path and get back on the straight and narrow I to empower those of you that might have strayed to see the light do
009not for one second compromise your values or the promises you made to the City of Midland in order to get elected politics are hard complicated and often thanless I'm sure at times it feels like you are Stretch Armstrong being pulled in four directions at once but I'll say this being sneaky taking meetings behind closed doors trying to change and or manipulate the will of the people is Devious dishonest cowardly malicious irresponsible and disloyal I know there is goodness in each and every one of you that sit around this table so you need to ask yourself with every decision moving forward if your opinions are those of your own or were you passively forced into or were they passively forced on to you I would like to remind you that the use of position and power
010is a coer of act I implore you all to continue to make the right choice for our children be a leader and do the right thing because it is always the right thing to do thank you thank you next speaker is Brian hore I apologize I did get these out of order when I follow so you might not be in the order sorry thank you thank you thank you I want to thank the board uh for listening to the community thank you guys for folling through with a ranch l location for Midland High School uh I also want to thank you guys for looking at the benefits really of the students in the community here um I also want to thank you guys for following the legal obligations of the vote and the the will
011of the citizens I do believe that there's a huge benefit for the new high school it will allow us to retain uh highly paid professionals not just in the oil and gas industry but across all Industries here um I I believe it should be done as efficiently as quickly as possible uh to the benefit of our students and I look forward into doing anything I can to help MISD or the board or the city in general than next speaker Jared Sparks right good afternoon thank you again for your time in ISD board and Dr Howard mean two times in one week um I just wanted to share that I also truly appreciate the note for support um of the bond and the vote that came out yesterday by you all and um hopefully perhaps it
012can assist in putting to rest the pending litigation and get this moving forward I understand that this discussion today possibly uh will involve other tracks of land within the district I would share just few comments that I'm sure you all are aware of but just to verbally pass along anyway if it is existing own land think outside the box as to what other potential uses could the land be used for either permanently or temporarily you are in the middle of executing a bond could you necessitate a staging area or additional storage as an example could the land be used by a company for drilling to help access minerals underneath the city I mean just look at what Midland College is having to go through I know sometimes There are rules and discussion and what can
013and can't be shared with the public but please utilize constituents to bounce ideas off when necessary thank you again for your time and service thank you next speaker is Kevin Williams hello Dr Howard president hes School Board I appreciate the time U sitting here listening to this and I I just can't help but think this is a sad time it really is Midland ought to be better than this uh there there shouldn't be anything that that dictates that in order to grow and prosper that that means that something's going to be taken away from the community that is heavily utilized I hear people all the time talking about the Green Space the quality of life bringing in recruiting people to to to move here and stay here I've lived here 63 years and in all
014that time I have never met anyone that was traveling that was living here that happened to be traveling through Midland Odessa and said you know it's just such a Charming Community with so much to do that we decided to move here this is Oil and Gas Town it always has been it always will be right now it's just a larger version of what it always has been I don't think we ought to try to make this Dallas report work we ought to embrace what we have right now and make the best of what we have right now um it it's just you know the leading indicator for me is what's happened in the past I don't hear this was just a bad decision uh all the way back to the transaction in my opinion the
015leading indicator for that for me is we're the public outcry and protest over the over the property where legacy's being built has anybody heard it I haven't heard it so you know there's something that differentiates this location from that location and it would have been nice to have all things equal um I've heard several times to honor what was in the proposition I've had back and forth with some people hopefully it's been respectful I've tried to keep it that way to me I don't understand why the verage wasn't included in the proposition that people voted for that's where the rubber meets the road that's where the vote is counted uh if it had simply said by voting yes you're going to get these high schools but it will also mean removal and destruction of ranch
016and Hills then that takes all this all this away there's no basis for for anything to be discussed it was it was fully transparent it was fully know so uh just my two cents worth I feel bad for the retirees that have lived here and supported the community all their life I feel sorry for the kids that I've seen out there at the golf course that are not going to have a place to go I feel bad for the Charities that raised over $1.5 million there I've spoken to several of them and it's also causing problems in the surrounding communities those people have their their facilities that they want to use for their taxpayers and they're being overrun with people from Netherland obesa so just my two cents worth I appreciate your service it's a
017hard job and and sometimes there's a no one scenario thank you next speaker is James Henry James R Henry that's because my son James well I know but I use my middle initial and when people don't use it I get frustrated I apologize think must be important know who I thank you all name is James R Henry and I'm here to speak on a missed opportunity this is not about schools bonds golf courses it's about riding a wrong the wrong that's got us all here today the wrong that brought us here put us against each other fighting Nick and knacking everything going on and that wrong was the purchase of the ranin Hills Golf Course by MISD that should have never happened it should never even be a topic could not happen we wouldn't even
018be here today we' all be you know happy and have what we all want the St was surrounded by red flags everywhere there were flag regarding the whole deal between the owners and MD whether the school district chose to just ignore those or not pay attention we really may never know but there are two red flags in particular first the ordinance that was written specifically by citizens of Midland who felt the need to do this to protect their property to present it to the city council and have it agreed and talked about and passed as a legitimate city ordinance because they knew it was the right thing to do to protect that piece of property and what it was originally designated to be the second red flag even more is the fact that it could
019be involved in an illegal sale in regards to violations of federal law in particular the deceptive trades and Practices Act which is a law if you don't know about it protects consumers which also protects members and protects those who pay memberships pay dues pay initiation fees and pay Monies to protect their interest from illegal and bad sales whether or not Midland ISD do about that I think there's some some documentation out there that shows and whether they just chose to ignore it or just move on without consideration of it uh is an issue they should have walked away from that deal immediately and apparently did once because it failed in the board on a boote and then was tied subsequently through some more negotiations that the whol sale should have never been happened we can
020have both we can have we could write a wrong we can write that wrong that was done that's got us all against each other now we can have a new high school and we can have ranin Hills Golf Club what everybody wants and anybody who's not against or who's against having all three is not part of the solution you are the problem and that's why we're here and what we need to focus on not all this other rhetoric that's been going on but what got us here in the first place I implore the board to write the wrong please and it ain't over till thank you mallerie Maru good afternoon thank you first I would like to say I did I am from Dallas and I did come here seven years ago and I thought
021thought Midland was quite Shing and that's why we were here today um but that's not really what I'm here to talk about um I am here today to plead with the board to not hire Tim Davis of Jackson Walker LLP as your legal council Mr H you told us at the board meeting on Tuesday that you are not trying to do some type of takeover you also said you do not have any brand loyalty to Mr Davis or Jackson Walker and you're willing to come up with a compromise and look for someone else that people are more comfortable with despite what you said at the meeting I'm not a conspiracy theorist with too much time on my hands I actually have very little time on my hands a Friend R shout to me and said
022oh my gosh this better not be the attorney trying to destroy my kids school district Keller ISD he is a snake and he has no history of education law Tim Davis is in fact that attorney I agree with Miss Burleson that the board of seven should interview and vote among M multiple candidates thank next speaker is Stanley Smith Stanley sorry actually I go back St Smith I look I look out this crowd there's very few of you e coose I've never even been in this situation but I can tell you right now that I work in the oilfield for 30 there 35 40 years and most of you young couples out here you hav't seen what a downturn in the oil business does to this town $1.4 billion dolls whenever all goes south let me
023tell you what happens you're going to find geologist sitting their house with their desk when I moved here in 1989 there was houses there was a house houses were being bought by the Banks because they could not sell them you $118,000 house you could get it for 72,000 so enjoy this price of oil and enjoy this Revenue that's going on right now because when all you people go back to Dallas Fort Worth wherever you're from if your parents accept you in your house but I have two kids that graduated from M Lee and I'm glad they did it a long time ago I got I got grandkids here I got two in Middle High I got one in Middle classical I've got one in compass I got a couple in love but the thing that
024gets me when I when this all happened I did a for year report I got 693 pages of information on this what happened okay and if you had read those 693 pages I suggest you ought to go ahead and get copies of them because it's emails it's Tex it's the sales contract it's the lease contract it's everything that went on between MISD and this is I'm talking R reer whatever his name was I got I got all that information I read all 693 pages of it and what's been out in this public has not been totally true I can sit here and I can talk about this all day long but the thing is is the appraisals $3.4 million for ran and that based on continued operations medin paid $9.5 million to tear it up
025the other thing is I appreciate the lady that talk about how hard the committee worked on getting this proposal together they studied it they did it all but now what do we got we got two high schools planned to be in the same district you got middle and high and Le District you got Midland Le legacy's District okay so they did their homework and they got them in the right place why would they do that that's the question that needs to be asked why would you put those schools where you put them stick Legacy out in the middle of a pasture let's take over a golf course I don't care if that Golf Course turns into a dog walking or a senior Park but it don't need to be destroyed so you you can smirk
026at me you can do whatever you want but I don't care I I've been here since 1989 and I'm not from Fort Worth I'm not from Dallas and I'm glad you're here but you know this this city is not built I've been here since 1982 yes three minutes up Austin Dr members of board appreciate the opportunity to come speak with you again today um you know long time can't help but I mean longtime West Texas person I grew up in a small town seag Graves and actually spent six years in Midland growing up and um very invested in this community love this community want to see it continue to thrive I think we're doing a lot toward that I appreciate all the people that have come out um you know really spoken on key issues
027and and uh you know I want to tell you as a board I appreciate you hearing us on Tuesday and I appreciate uh you know what was put forward and the commitment to see through the bond is somebody who worked on the bond planning committee uh a spokesman for the bond sits on the bond advisory committee uh it's near and dear to my heart to see it through and uh see it completion as it was laid out and I appreciate the commitment that you all made in that statement to doing that so so thank you for that I really want to encourage you to continue to listen to the community and continue to listen to the feedback that we provide you uh also want to encourage you to continue to listen to one another and
028partner and collaborate toward uh bettering this community bettering this school district and uh I I firmly believe if you continue to do that we're going to see great things and continue toh to thrive as a community I just want to let you know that I'm going to continue to be here to help um please don't hesitate to reach out if there's ways that I can do that I want to continue to offer that and uh just both as a as a parent of MD kids as a as a as a citizen who cares about this community and through my role in the bond advisory committee in all of those capacities I want to offer whatever support that I can and I really just look forward to great things for MISD I ask that you maintain
029that commitment that you made and see through the bond and the in the whole process and uh thank you for your time thank you for your service I appreciate what you do I know it's a tough job I know it's probably been a tough week and uh thanks again Mr Matt gindo good afternoon um my name's m I've I've been in Midland since 1988 uh here I was born and so I welcome everybody from Dallas and everybody else that that comes to this community and has uh made this community feel great um you know I'm up here one um just to talk about the the election that we had you know there was an understanding that we were going to use that golf course and that purchase happened and whether the purchase happened how you
030you know if you agree with that purchase or not um I think that whoever sold that is the folks that you need to talk to and and have those dealings why take it up with the school district who purchase it when when the dealing was already done so um that the other thing too um we're here we're going to continue to push MD for we're going to push our babies to get the best education that they can uh and we want to be able to work together as a community with this board with everybody else to to Really push things uh forward um oh we have time the behavior of this board um is one that's very concerning and I made that statement um at the uh at the last meeting when you all went
031into to Executive session um and I know it wasn't the time to do it but I stand by what I said to say that the behavior of this board is an absolute embarrassment um to see the bickering and the back and forth that goes on is embarrassing to Midland and into MISD uh it's disrespectful and um it's disrespectful to the 29,000 babies that were serving why continue to act that way what what um example are we putting to those students who were trying to teach conflict resolution what example are we putting towards our um staff who are creating policy on how they should or should not conduct themselves in a professional setting and so I really challenge of you all and that's not just m Mr Hodes but it's everybody else too and to be
032very clear one of the reasons why I am so hard on Mr hajes is because when you were elected you and I had a conversation you said hold you hold you accountable and hold you to a standard and I know beep down inside you care because you wouldn't be here and you wouldn't do the things that you've done we've had those conversations but the way that we go about it is not okay the disrespect that happens is not a a reflection of who Midland is um the other thing too is when we're talking about this attorney that we want to get all of the board members should be involved in it it shouldn't just be somebody that someone picks it's representation for each one of you you want to be able to get the right
033person so work together figure out ways to do this but most importantly do it in a way that brings Pride to Midland to MISD some of us are crazy enough to to still be involved and still uh try to help and do everything that we can we're going to do that you're in charge of our tax dollars and and the education of our babies so when you have our babies and our money we're going to hold you to a high standard thank you can you hear can you hear us y I got you I'm gonna get some heartburn real quick but I'm talked to Dr Howard I know we're in the time front so I'm gonna take two minutes just trust me plus you're a lawyer you can fix this if it doesn't work so
034I want to Sor I don't want to be my back here when I talk to Y pH that's kind of funky so my name's Brandon hes I've been here my whole life I went to S I went through MD schools my nephews my brother sister long time my mom worked here I was elected to the school board because I believe in academics and I'm not happy with academics and discipline going with our schools I'm not trying to take over the schools not trying to pit one school against another not going against private school I appreciate what you said Matt so first off I wanted to apologize to everybody out there for miscommunication when I got elected as school board President we had new school board members on there it has been my experience Katie is
035probably might not agree with me on this but knows that it's like trying to drink a whole lot of information out of a fire hose at one time I do not think this is I will stand by this still to this day even with all the arrows that have come the new school board members came on the board and they felt like they wanted more information on things that they are responsible to to their constituents for that money and we got all that information to them we know that the board did their due diligence prior to but we still made that accessible to them that has been determined we made a statement yesterday the ranch I don't even like calling it ranchin but the address that's there on wobbly where midd and high was going
036to be presented is that is continuity as is no delays now I want to take full responsibility I did talk to Dr Howard and I said hey there's a conversation going on about some trees I don't even want to bring up why that was because I'm not going to throw any other taxing enies under the bus but we had to stop and halt trees on a Friday so we we didn't move trees for three days so if that's the thing that ruins the school that's on me too I don't believe that that'll be the case but it is Full Speed Ahead Dr Howard everybody's back on the trees that's my fault but I want to take responsibility for allowing the new school board members to have the information that's on me so I apologize for
037that but that is a leadership decision that I made I think they are totally entitled they have rights and privileges as elected officials to that information to the board that has been here Tommy I do not want us to argue I think M Lind makees some great points we will do better in communicating but a lot of people it's there's no vast conspiracy lots of people are in involved in the meetings and all these decisions right so the things that we hear on the Internet is some right all the people that called me personally there a lot of people that spoke today that personally called me and I got to have a conversation with them I cannot tell you how appreciative I am that yall found my phone number or already had my phone number
038and called me personally to talk and through to understand it most of the people that I had a conversation with yesterday were like thank you very much this makes more sense so it's not now the situation with Tim Davis and Jackson Walker we are not going to even interview like I called them yesterday morning I told Ally who was the junior attorney I said we're not going to put our community through this we're no longer even going to consider yall I know this is probably out of the standard process I know yall you I will do better but don't blame it on the the new board merse right because I I I allowed some leeway to have some some questions answered right that's on me as a leader and I stand by that but thank
039you for y's time for reason we going to have we open this up we're just going through none of this information today has anything to do with with the ranks the this has to do with looking at Capital assets that are under underutilized or unutilized and an opportunity at a future in the market to possibly look at at at liquidating those to help alleviate a 41 and a half million Current financial crisis that we're in right now going forward so again thank y'all for being here my apologies we will do better and we will do better as a board and we'll have better leadership on the board thank you all for time sorry sorry sorry can you ask the attorney if it's legal to cut public comment short in my experience on the board we
040never not once even though we might have wanted to cut it off I think there were other people correct there wasn't any more oh I'm sorry I apologize I thought there were m i mean you're I didn't mean some people signed up after the I don't have the to speak I'm sorry anybody's in dou did anyone get skipped anyone get skipped that's in the room I'm good say it again you're good on public comment thank you for making sure that we did not I do really apprciate thank you thank you so moving on to J I know we're not going into close session we're going to skip that so we do this Mike we just want to talk about yeah and open Forum sir right and you're welcome to do that um of open forum
041is the default or or Open session is the default you close session only if there's an exception uh so you're welcome to discuss property and the the presentation and you're welcome to do it in public in part of your open session so there's really nothing to do other than just say hey we're going to do this in public instead of closed start okay okay so I'll kick us off Courtney and the team have worked on this a little bit of background around this and on some this as far as properties that we have owned um properties we've soed in the last couple of years and um you're going to see some recommendations on here and those recommendations some of them I believe are very solid recommendations and and I'll absolutely make that recommendation others I
042think it's somewhat contingent on what the board decides related to finance so at the um end of the year we anticipate having about 41 and a half million left to be assigned fund balance for coming off a formula transition Grant um having had some conversation um there may not be an appetite for using that and um um being asked to get to a balanced budget so with that being said the recommendations could certainly change because some of these properties we would almost have to sell in order to balance a budget so um that's why you're going to see some recommendations on here I will as courney goes through the properties I will talk about the ones that I would recommend regardless of what's going on and then of course we need your feedback these are
043not action items so we're not going to take any action on them today but we do want to have some conversation and get some feedback around the various properties so courney I'll turn it over to you thank you Dr good afternoon president Hodes MERS of the board um appreciate youall having us today Tucker we're going to run through a slideback like Dr Howard said address several properties um for you like like she mentioned you know we're in a pretty big deficit so we we pinpointed some properties have some recommendations hopefully mediate some of that some of that pressure on our on our current budget situation not interrupt you I think the board I think we just save our questions for the end I mean if yall are good with that we just kind of J
044down if you have any questions for the Public's time we ask all the questions watch a little bit are we in a time and I don't mean this read I'm serious is anybody on a time crunch trying to get back to work because if they are we can email our questions just get the presentation and email them later for anyone who's trying to get back to the office no I'm good you're good you good okay let's keep that we need to keep that okay um so in in speaking of the the property sales we have over the last couple years worked to to already you know pinpoint some properties and have sold some um you can see those listed here here for you um to the tune of almost $2 and a half million dollars
045of property that we've already already unloaded and sold and put back into the budget um the first piece specifically is a piece of property south of Travis Elementary uh it's about almost 40 acres work the property Valu at about $1.6 million um we have a recommend they are some pipelines on that property the four pylons there um that's um so you about sorry we had originally on this piece of property discussed um a satellite Transportation location for um transportation have basically a satellite Bus Barn if you will to alleviate all the back and across town uh we do believe that we have a another site for that we aren't ready to make that recommendation yet but we do believe we have another site for that that um will actually be less expensive to do and
046so with that you know in mind this is a piece of property that I don't see a a use for in the future uh there could be a concern about if we were to sell it what comes in right behind one of our schools um there are some restrictions to that so yes well I would like to Dr how I just I'm somebody who really wants to look at the substation to cut down on on travel times so if this is one of them but we have a plan B we've got a plan B we're moving to plan a I still don't I would like to put this one in a holding pattern until we have finalized whatever we're going to do with building that kind of transit station because I think that there is
047a lot of appetite on the board in the community to reduce the travel time so if this is we don't want to put this out for bidden this the first one that is sold and the other one not work out so I just want to note that absolutely yes sir anybody else have any questions comments I kind of would like to do these one at a time is that okay yeah sorry I just want to throw that one out because that's an important piece I'm sorry to break the decorum that's fine and to that point I think once you see the other piece of property we do believe it is a better option there is already a place for an office and so forth there uh we do think it'd be a cheaper option and
048a viable option so and we can bring that recommendation and yes ma'am um also would if we did a bus barn when we need the whole thing okay so I think we should look at that and even as opposed to five maximize efficiency a little bit better Logistics I know there's a lot of busing so right I would really like to look at you know I don't know how close is to your other let's at least consider we'll bring a recommendation in February for the um to use Capital project funds for the um transportation Annex if you want to call it we'll put those side by side and you know we'll make a recommendation that we think is best but I think I mean our traffic in 2025 is much different than it has been
049in decades past so we really got to be agile and dynamic anyone about leing that property well the addons I have to that Mr Smith I guess is what type of pipelines is one and then you know selling the land and knowing that we have an opportunity for the city of having other inci come star schools and Bill schools will and then bu right next to the schools that and then always had my mind got years don't grow so we start S land and come up in a few years and need some of these mentioned properties we're out spending or four times of what we're asking to sell for then we're in another I mean I'm not say we don't have any asset but when I look at at those 40 acres of land kind
050on what Dr thre I mentioned on some other things we can be used that for versus maybe having two so because the city's continuing to grow and we're moving out east of town west of town south of to not places to to use for hubs I just me personally on this side of the property that value for the district I think that I think that's I can only speak for myself I think I'm more interested in the properties that we feel that like this one right here looks like an odd shape like we don't know if we'd ever be able to build a school on it or whatever for me it's more like properties that we know that would probably never fit the scope of something we would need you know I mean if it's
051something we could potentially use I mean yeah me keep it we can't grow land but me I think it's more L not being utilized I think first school board meeting we signed a a piece of property all sold six months ago we had a sign a something for that like that was a 10 track the middle of a residential neighborhood Stu like that's kind of what I'm looking at and you're going to see as we go through each property there are some we don't recommend at all even you know and because we do have a future plan for that whether that happens you you never know but it does have the the size the shape all of the the things yes and I appreciate Mr Smith and Mr Glen Mr Bish everybody's concerns on it
052and I think it's important that we have an overall long-term plan to look at our Capital Holdings but at the same time uh we're when Tucker can speak to this as well when you look at the finances we're about four years a little less than four years if we continue on the bird rate with the you know with the differentials between our expenses and our total revenues not factoring in other economic factors of going down or what have you um that we could be essentially in solving in less than four years if we continue with the burn rate so unfortunately there's going to be some tough decisions that have to be made and even though we might want and it would be nice for us to be able to hold on to some of our
053Capital assets as they appreciate so we can look for Prime Times to sell them that might be better um we just cannot continue to put pressure um on on the school district and expect it to perform I think that we need to bring down and it's very important to focus on our finite resources which are our economic dollars and really be fine-tuned on getting a rate of return for educational value that goes directly into the classrooms and that is going to be a strategic directive of me as my presidential leadership and it's probably going to get uncomfortable on discussing this I just wanted to say we need to be cognizant of what we want to hold out long term be strategic about it and but we're also going to have to wait with the economic
054pressures that we're currently under we're going to we're going to be in a big big big problem in you know in a very short time with being able to even turn the lights on so anyway with that noted go ahead let's go ahead and after this can we wait I I want to go back to Mr gwin still for time sake let's take notes and send the questions or we'll be here for hours on this Mr Durham would you speak to the financial impact other than sales PR us yes ma'am so um as you all know unfortunately we are a Rec capturable School District so unfortunately the way that that um really um adds up is whenever there's additional value um specifically on our M property taxes um then that unfortunately means more recapture goes
055back into State and so um the the net benefit that the district will receive if we were able to sell this property for 1.6 million on the general fund would be $18.59 on an annual basis um ins we do receive the entire um 100% of the collections that we get to keep so that would be roughly $3,400 and so the total estimated annual benefit to the district would be right at $3,400 What's the total percentage that we would keep then out of it out of the total sales price I I do not have that percentage but extremely small keep all that would keep basis having someone else own this property would do [Music] that send you an email and this will be that ize the Financial impact will be on every slide for piece of
056property to answer your question Mr Bishop Centurion has three uh pipelines on this on this particular property and Energy Partners has one transmission line so one getting high pressure over four the next piece um of property is a small piece of property located just west of a bunch Elementary it's about right at 22 Acres uh this was if yall recall before put out for vid um we had two pieces of property here actually this one is right in this area um the other one was down here a little further south it sold um was included on the slide presented previously our recommendation would be to go ahead and put this piece of property out for bid um and speaking with our real estate broker uh they believe market value is listed there for you but
057we could put it out for bid at approximately $220,000 as a minimum bid and then again you can see the estimated Financial impact they're below the Tucker just um the next next pie we just say what the purpose was sometimes um we acquire property because they don't pay their taxes and it comes back to us um do we know when we acquired that I not have that information no no I mean there's probably history at some point that isn't a piece of land I would expect we would have ever bought I bet it came back to us being that small um the next two slides will have to do with our apartment complexes the first three in Town and Country um apartment just located just west of mid it's about block Northwest MK and cord
058intersection on Bedford Avenue 24 units at this property it's currently fully occupied um we paid $1.8 million for this property and we put another approximately 1.1 into it uh to renovate it we are currently paying taxes on the these two apartment complexes we paid 56 ,000 in taxes in 2024 on this particular complex it cost us almost $111,000 in insurance cost um in discussions that we've had we can put this our recommendation would be pending board approval and y's recommendation of course to put this property out for bid or sell now um we do have to give the current tenants in both these proper both these properties 60 days notice um however all of their leases are up at the end of June um they start over at the each the beginning of each fiscal
059year i' would like to say right here you know I've been in multiple districts and every one of them I've been in got my housing business not necessarily because they wanted to but because they had to at some point so you know it wasn't here when these were purchased but I know when they were purchased it was because it wasn't a matter of the teachers afford housing they couldn't find housing at one time we were putting them in Midland uh campus um in hospital room because they they have nowhere to live and so I see why you know the district would have made the purchase at the time um you know we certainly can run apartment complexes it does take away from signs that could go other places but I do want Tucker to talk
060specifically about plal impact because there are some caveats to this because it is in a housing fund yes so um the housing fund is um not associated with the general fund um and so none of this necessarily has a net impact on fund other than the actual sale of the property which would then be put into the sales account um so long story short um this these two properties um the stico and Town and Country um we do have to pay taxes on um because they are not um directly related with instructional facilities um and so that's the reasoning for that um the only other properties or things that we pay property tax on um are oil and gas royalties um along with the current ranchin Hills um site and so um as I mentioned
061there's no necessarily benefit um to the general fund other than the sell of the property what does it cost do we take anything out of the general fund to move over to pay any of the expenses of the apartments is there a cost for owners ownership of this uh so other than the um initial purchase of the properties along with the Capital Improvements um there has not been anything else from the general fund Associates so how would we pay maintain the maintenance on uh that is all um maintained with the overall Revenue that we are getting back from the resident so that's housing fund under the housing fund so that's generating a profitable revenue of say 30% I I don't know if it's that much whenever you net everything out but the the overall Revenue
062that we are receiving from rent is going back to paying all of our um require utilities um the management the property taxes because the last I just I'm confused a little bit so if you could it seems like uh it seems like we're saying that we don't want to get rid of this property because there's not any net benefit no I'm just I'm saying let me let me finish so I'm trying to explain so help me understand because the finances I've seen prior to this thing we've been in the red year over-ear on it and I think we finally got to a breef even on it so I'm just wonder ing I'm confused on somebody who wants to understand the p&l part of it is if it's coming out of a housing fund and it's
063in an asset that's that's essentially serving a good purpose for the school district right how do we explain that when it's been in the red year overy year and we're barely at break even and then we're not are we going to have maintenance in the Years coming up like it seems like and I also believe too that wasn't that originally purchased for teachers I'm not 100% sure maybe you can speak to that because I think that was originally purchased for teachers that a little bit it's my understanding that it was communicated as bu teachers a place to live Mr Bishop can speak to that because I wasn't here at that time um 67% of our tenants are teachers uh we certainly can you know we they they live there we can certainly limit it to
064procures if that's the you know what the board propers to do this housing fund I think it's important to for us to just all understand how this impacts the 19 199 budget which is where we're trying to shore up the deficit and so we are planning if we don't sell the property we are prop we've already planned to increase uh rent we would review that annually because we need to be closer to Market um and it does need to break even it doesn't need to be one of those um projects where we're losing money so I just believe this is a property that we should that we should that it will be a priority of mine to get get us out of the housing market I it'll be the will of the board next I
065think I'm still on Town and Country sorry any other feedback on that on both of these properties we do have the Praises order to get a get those get those figures and we actually started yesterday so we should is a little different because we currently have Encore Academy housed at syo so I let cordney explain that property and and what we believe we will be able to do sell sure so um sympatico like like Dr Howard said made up of 25 units in full um currently um we purchased it for $1.3 million and put another 1.3 into it to to renovated it uh Capital Improvement wise paying $8,000 in Insurance costs and then $1,000 in taxes on that piece of property last year again the appraisal was on order Encore is currently at that property
066we have a meeting tomorrow and I've met with the special ed department is not a requirement that that they stay there they've technically outgrown that space anyway so we're looking to move them to a different to a different location um they can be in Portables they can be uh within a school building so again um our our team and the special ed team are meeting um tomorrow morning to find off location for that in case the board does decide to move forward with the spell of of this property so that should not limit us I guess in our decision um since that program's there there'll be limited cost to move it we can take all the furniture out of there our team can do all that inhouse um and then move them into another local
067it would be my recommendation to get on court Academy out of this department complex anyway yes sir uh we just the city just the community just passed a 1.4 billion Bond so we can have facilities that's safe we've heard a million times that portable buildings are unsafe and we have our special needs kids at an apartment complex agreed in our long range sorry Dr We inherited that that was already there we do have a plan uh when Legacy High School moves to their new site uh the soccer and softball Fieldhouse it's about 20 years old right there about softball fields that can be renovated with Bond money to be an encore Academy because right now we have Encore Academy and then we have some other programs at different places we would like to ultimately get
068that all in one location and be renovated for that purpose and not having to to be yeah we've had this conversation bit already you know just you know I feel like th those kids are they the same as everybody else sure so that is absolutely hear that we have special needs kids wasw you guys to fix that problem for pretty Qui we can fix it temporarily as soon as next year um to fix it permanently will be when we get Legacy moved to their new site um so be able to start around August of 2028 on renovation of that facility Tu I actually have a question that I hope I don't put you on the spot because I haven't asked you this before um so if we sold these two properties the revenue from the
069sales goes into one n that is correct if there's any remaining funds in the housing fund what happens to that is can that be transferred that can be because at the end of the day Mr Hodes Point 199 funds were utilized um I would assume in order to purchase this along with any improvements and then to address your other question the Deferred maintenance let's say something goes out if there's not sufficient funds in that fund um then we would have to make it up in in another way thank you for explaining that and so I I do recommend that I know this isn't for approval so unless you all look at me and say I don't think that's a good recommendation I do recommend we put these on the market to sell uh provide the
070notice to our tenants and um of course we would have within the ulations that we could not sell until we had our ten maybe that would be good to bring four in the February meeting as an yeah I don't want to answer that yet that's collectively let's we'll wait to answer that but sure on that and Mike can you clarify for that um so we do it right I mean I know we need board approval when we sell the property but to put it on the market yeah put it on the market I think you need board approval also okay because what you'll do is selling properties well selling properties you have to jump through several more Hoops than you do to buy property believe it or not and so selling you'll initiate the process
071with a resolution thank you to Mr Gwen's point on the Encore we have plans and drawings to Dr Howard's Point too of where she was just talking about the move on course so when that time comes we've got pricing and so very preliminary for pricing and plans for the academ getting close to the two o00 Booker so let's move on we got 60 like he's got I know where he works got a ask no let's wait let's move on to the next so the next uh item is is the Audrey Gill Sports Complex actually broken up into two two separate areas Boneyard being the first one um you can see the the acreage there and the apprais value back in November of 23 is $10.7 million um our recommendation would be once the new high
072school opens would be to put that property out out out for so um and a little bit of history on this property because I remember being in the community when this property was purchased um this property was originally purchased for a School site and then um that just has not worked out over the years so um yes it's Audrey Gale Sports Complex so it's the Boneyard as well as uh the property that weers well I've only known as the bone yard I think it's called theard so this is a property where again we can't put the what you're calling the Boneyard and what we even call the Boneyard there that part we can't put on the market until we have middle and high bill because that's where we have soccer and softball for mland high
073school U the part of the property that is what we are referring to here is the Golf Complex this is a piece of land that the district leases to First for a dollar a year and that is 25.91 Acres I think the question that we even had was you know if you break these up and sell them separately does it bring as much as if you sell them all together so we are in a lease with first T through three years in 15 year three years in year lease um but uh we have talked to the attorney and if we give the leasey 60 days notice of the intent to sell um we can sell that property so that's you know we're going to need some direction on that and then I believe um we
074would work with first T because they have the opportunity There's an opportunity for that um lease to transfer to the seller s could to our hands it's just need to work with firstc if that's something that they want to have happen or and the buyer to the potential investor um we have not had that conversation with first te but it would have to occur should we decide to sell this property one other thing to mention on the first te side is that's currently used every day um by our sub Varsity golf teams um so that would there def be some conversation um take place with Athletics and so forth and and the the local golf course just to see if they could accommodate our our our JB golfers and sometimes also with for our bars
075go so just something to keep in mind so um before we get into the long range sites on down the road um we did want to kind of sum this up for you on the left side if we sold all those properties that we just mentioned we're looking at just shy $20 million um revenue for the general fund and then um we just totaled up all of um Tucker's annual Financial impacts that sold over there on the right side for you for the ins fund the general fund um and and the total benefits District hous so it's a it would definitely be a onetime help on the left side on the right side it doesn't do a lot year after year yes ma' one time one time chunks through what hell one other thing too
076that I mention is on the revenue from the sale of the properties um these are um very contingent and depends on actual sales of the properties based on the appraisals um and the bids that's a great Point what we're going to go into now our properties our team's been working ever since the bond passed on not only the bond but on properties that will be U um available after the bond and really trying to look at um really trying to look at I think Mr Sparks actually spoke to that but trying to look at do we have any properties that are going to be freed up that have a use for the district rather than what they're being used for now so as we start to go through these next pieces um some of these
077are pretty final um not time to do it but u based on all the work that our team has done and everything that we've looked at so what we're shifting into now really has no impact on this year or next year this is going to be when all of the the bond is complete and those properties become available so yes ma'am the first being the Legacy freshman High School site sits on just a little shot 20 acres we had it a praise back in May praise for $ 6.45 million it is one of the the next two slides actually the two highest facilities on our facility condition index scale um the higher the number the the worse shape those facilities are in and it's it's cheaper to either sell to knock them down and and
078and rebuild them then it is to renovate them so that's part of the recommendation here but our recommendation will be like Dr Howard said after the completion of the bond when all the schools are are complete just put this property out for bid 2028 what we can do here too there is a a requirement that if we yes ma'am s the property with the school on it we have to allow we have to advertise that to Charter School that's correct yes ma'am um we don't have to take their offer if it's not the best value for that land but we do have to go through that step before we can put it out so um I think we have some options there we won look at you know do we get more for the land
079if the building is there um do we get more for the land if we've already demolished that building uh and and so there's going to be some options there we'll work to make sure we're getting the best value for that uh one thing that we know that it's you know I've seen this in other places when you sell the property it becomes someone else's but everybody still calls us when it doesn't look good around them right they still think it's ours because it was for a long time and so um that's one of the things that we want to be a little cautious of because you know other districts have seen that they fill a school somebody owns that school they store stuff in it and people are you know calling the school district to
080fix that because everybody still thinks the school district owns it think if we don't have a purpose for it we need to make would like to make a decision on it we don't want to keep paying Property Insurance on maintain in the facility we don't have anything to use use for the facility and being mham high school again very high on our facility condition index um the the recommendation here is again in 20128 uh to sell the parking lot uh in the Northwest um Northwest and West part of section of the campus along with the F courts the ROTC building um across the street um also also sell that particular piece of the building demolished some of the um older part of Midland High School and no decision yet yet made but options open um
081for the newer parts of M if you will no appraisals have been ordered on this piece of property yet this new as the fact that if we do it now we're just have to do it again in a few years Clos we get to making a decision selling or not one of the ideas that has um surfaced you know gosh year year and a half ago now um about the auditorium is uh the opportunity to have a private nonprofit fundraiser partnership to be able to put that into a Performing Art Center for the District of course downtown downtown revitalization the bandall that you see back behind the auditorium that was built during the last secondary Bond so it is about 20 years old so if we were hosting contest um for Band Fire Orchestra you
082have a stage you also have site reading room with the band tall back behind it um again that would be you know one of those things it's not necessarily money in the fond do that work so it would need to be more of a private nonprofit type thing um and we have been engaged in conversations with the local vendors that that seem to be interested we're not to the point where we're ready to start raising that money if you will um that part that's 86,000 square feet uh that um is again the about 20 years old so there's some opportunities there the team's not ready to make a recommendation on that uh what we do know as we sit in what is not really a boardroom but is being used as a boardroom there could
083be some opportunity to maybe convert some space in either one of those areas into a true boardroom um they could also be used for our mon trial teams our debate teams team Court things like that trying to think about what kind of spaces could serve more than you know a meeting once or twice a month U but with team for different things even General meetings could be in there district meetings Dr Howard's SP yall are very familiar with the SPO process we just formed another committee strategic planning oversight committe they not strategic planning oversight committee we have formed the same type of committee to look at these very things specific two facilities um five 10 years down the road so that that committee would begin meeting next week one and then the last piece here
084is a piece of property that was purchased um back in January of 2023 uh for 4.9 million for a for a future School site possibly just did want to bring this to the board's attention uh it's just south of I20 there in County Road 1256 this is Liberty oil field services just for for reference here and then the loves travel stop right there south of the recommendation of the 65 acres it's actually two pieces of property this yellow shaded piece here's just a little over 27 acres and then the red piece about 35 we bought both at the same time totaling 65.5 One Acres the recommendation is just to hang on to that piece of property for the time being um again for long range plan we don't know what's going to happen down the
085road by not land this purchase was made when I was coming into the district one of the things I was asked to do is try to find some Land South part south of the significant number of students in this is more Southwest the challenge with that was trying to find a that had utilities and this has utilities and so when we found this land we made that recommendation and we purchase this property so we don't have plans for a future School in the next you know five or so years we have a bond that we're trying to get through we want to balance out our elementary schools we never want to overbuild because having too many schools and then eventually having to close some down is not a good thing to do um but we
086do believe that because it has been so difficult to find land in this part of town um there even was discussion during the long range planning or I should say the bond planning committee you know should we put this in the bond and we did not put it in the bond we bought it out of one and with that tuer and I be glad to ask questions you have additionally or you go ahead um so I think you know given our 415 million doll budget crisis that we're in I this is a crisis that we've inherited I think it would be really helpful to you know make public to the to everyone how much we're losing or making on these apartments every year for the past few years I think that would be good transparent
087governance of this board and the school district um and you know I don't see that on here I think we should make that public especially when we're considering selling these also I think we should also include in that number how much you know we we have management fees but it also obviously consumes some of your time probably some Dr Howard's time so we can somehow and any other staff we can somehow quantify how much of that time is spent in you know per year and use that in these calculations so I I just think we should we should be very transparent we bought these things not only will you know would it you know help help the public maybe understand that we have to do this because of the de we're in but also kind
088of show going forward you know may future School Board are considering this approach um it may have long-term you know ramifications on your budgets down line especially if they're losing money I I don't have this number in front of me and I think that's a big part of the decision and and whether we keep or sell these things is how much are a year I would like a really good accurate I like absolutely um with this bringing it back to the board uh we'll bring the Lisa Road Transportation complex as one item next February or next next month um the resolution for Bunch Elementary project of land as a separate the Town and Country and senao and that's where we can get into that gr near level of detail that I think would be helpful
089and then um then I guess my next question is do we have a temporary location that's we're meeting about that very thing tomorrow okay like the brainstorm and try to figure out some options we could present even in the the presentation about selling property what that what we would do with our so in other words everything involved with those two apartment complexes selling them we can you know bring forward a presentation in February talking about the sell of the property I think it's important to know all the other I think regardless sell it or not can bring the uh the temporary side as well as made plans for the long permanent side um next on the sports complex I I think I mean I guess this is all public but um make sure that the
090county and the city aware you know these spes we cannot afford we're run 41 halfon we cannot afford to lease this for a dollar year an no matter how good are and you know first I think raises a lot of money so um I would hope that somebody could at least keep this going it's a huge asset for our especially the golf team the golf the golf teams need facilities also and we're build we're spending at least 40 million for our football teams golf teams also need facility so that this is being used for that right now for our golf kids so I would really hope that we could maybe you know present this K to the county or city or some maybe philan philanthropic organization that could maybe take over this and um I
091would really like us to consider I mean you know if you get a little bit less from one of these entities with a with a agreement to keep the first key I don't know what the law is on this um would we have to take the highest bidder I guess I should ask Mike can you you're mut I apologize I'm trying because I've been coughing I don't want to cough in y'all's ear um you have to take the best the highest best offer doesn't necessarily mean the best bidder okay so there you've got a little bit of leeway there there's some wiggle room not much somebody that in your face could po you know we could sell it maybe with some agreement in there that this this uh whoever we sold it to would would
092allow our golf teams to play on this is that would that be possible yes okay all things are possible when it comes to that I would I would given the l space go sorry given this is just kind of a plead to the board and the community given our lack of space for golf um you know I would really hope that we really emphasize making a deal with someone to buy this that keeps the including in part of that deal for for home for golf teams so is it accurate that um first team does not currently charge our golf is that accurate correct I know there was consideres W was able to are you finished i' would also like to say um that this is very this organization it's been my experience that they are
093they kind of are very open to the community and allowing Community use first you know not necessarily just anyone so that's it's a park but you know I don't the school subsidizing park when we're running a41 a half million doll deficit just it's hard to justify so we can't have education to do that but I would really like hope that somebody can step up and recognize the value this this for the community and try to we best agreement Mike I have another question if you don't want to if you shouldn't answer this and don't know the answer I'm kind of being careful as you can tell so yes um so is with maybe Courtney can work with you to see if there's an opportunity to re renegotiate that lease yes ma'am that might be of
094interest to the board to renegotiate it to get a a better value for that lease I think we could look at all those options and and then way which is the best for district yes ma'am uh Courtney and I have already discussed it a couple or once at least and talked about it so that yeah all those options are very very much on the table I say it's very important that the public knows that this today was for informational purposes it's not saying we are selling all this land aren't selling this land this is just for informational purposes so please before you call for our heads on Facebook it's information item it's just information I particularly requested a lot of this information just because I wanted to know um what we have don't have what
095we can utilize not utilize is doesn't mean we're going to go in here just because it has a recommendation to do something doesn't necessarily mean or aren't to do that so it's today was just informational purposes glad we move that to open session so everybody can get the same information as we got well I appreciate that I think that's smart you know for the board to look at that that's something we've been looking at I think a lot of the recommendations that we will make on on these properties is going to be conent on um the willingness of the board to utilize about 40 million in fund balance that's been set aside to come off if we're told we cannot do that then we're going to have to get much more aggressive with selling properties
096whether we think we need to keep them or a combination of both are you Mr Bishop okay on M uh I know talking about happen with legy freshman also fresman campuses but said to that have a a committee put together to decide what was going to be happening over in mid we ever get a committee together we have committees for both of those campuses they don't decide what will happen we run ideas through them to make sure we're not missing something each committee on two separate occasions and so um you know there might be some things that we're not thinking about from a tradition or historical standpoint and so we utilize that committee to let them know what we're looking at thinking about and and see if we're missing anything that might be a big
097interest up both been very productive feedback Prov well I I would just like to bolt on with Mr Bishop comments on that Dr how thank you for that explanation but these committees I think they're and I mean this with all I don't know how say this it's not to be mean or whatever but the Board needs to know what's going on and when these committees are meeting and all this kind of stuff's going on and people are talking we don't we're end of the day this we're the bosses yes sir by State Statute so we've got to know what's going on with a multi billion doll education system in Newland Texas first and foremost because other people out in the community you KN and stuff or what have you that that can't happen we've got
098to have we've got to get together and have a better communication plan as a board with the administration and make sure we're on the same page so everybody has the same information that way we can avoid the problems that we've had for the last three years right that accumulated to an explosive environment in the last three days that cannot happen again and I'm charging the administration to help us do that and when we have Mr Bishop a sitting board member being told yes we have the Committees but he doesn't even know anything about it and this is a pretty important subject matter correct he needs to he needs to know first we need to know first going forward so but I mean that with all due respect don't know tone I'm Hope was message correctly
099thank you are you anything else Mr Booker no it is but a discussion not and it's pres to have the information as well too right not to make there is no action that's why we brought it to open session Mr Hernandez huh good you need to hold me accountable for not getting my hearing yeah any anyone else I got some more okay get them first cple so I think this is really I appreciate time out real quick Booker you can leave and we can like I know I know Booker like I know what he's up to on this we might should two minutes ask I'm sorry I appreciate you opening this up so everybody knows what we're talking about so that we don't have all these questions that I appreciate that this is this is
100the room where things are discussed now so um uh so this this Legacy freshman did did we just install this tur field here is that okay so we we knew so we we install it before we knew we might not correct and then mid High you know we have not even discussed are like some other parking I don't think we're ready to make on that we've tried to prioritize I mean we can't do anything until 20 August of down I think it's good to draw attention to the community so that they can I mean people have ideas brainstorm give them to us [Music] right just make sure it's not don't tell everyone else just tell me anyway the are there any pipelines in the Southeast area of the county land or is that is all
101clear um Dr Frieza I can't answer that off hand I don't believe so when we purchased that property there were no high pressure lines there and they're not listed on that map but I'll get you that answer short of all right and also I was wondering if this has been considered for a temporary bus barn or something that area we haven't considered the area we're considering already has a structure that could be used for clocking in and out things like that so we're trying to find the best location or the best value you know structure that all right that's it moved in second to adjourn the meeting all those in favor raise your right hand sorry raise your right hand unanimous meeting is 128 january3