CorpusRecord 78275

NISD Called Board Meeting 2-11-2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / northsideisd
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Bexar County, TX
Material
Transcript
Extent
4,409 words · about 25 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right well let's go we'll say good evening everybody um trusty dur will be should be running a little bit late but she'll be here we'll go ahead and we'll start out with the uh pledges Allegiance and the invocation um trusty s us will lead us in the invocation for Almighty and merciful god we ask your guidance and blessings upon this boards students parents patrons teachers administrators as we are assembled here this evening in the common pursuit of this great nation's wealth our children amen amen amen IED Al to the flag of the United States of America to the repblic for it stands one nation God indivisible liy and justice for all honor the Texas flag I pled Al to be Texas one State under God one indivisible okay good all right thank you trusty

002Sao so once again good evening to everybody and welcome this is a called meeting of the Northside Board of Trustees and before officially call the meeting to order we'll take just a briefly uh a little moment to briefly review someone rules for conducting our meeting so the order business is set off uh in the agenda and the purpose of the meeting is the Kung board business and for that reason it is held in public now it is not a public forum however we do provide the opportunity for audience participation uh if there's anyone here that would like to address the board during an AG agenda item we ask that you uh complete the signup sheet um it's located in the front of the room and indicate uh specifically which agenda item you'd like to address

003and that's important because once again it's a called meeting so this particular meeting we don't have citizens to be heard um so if anybody wants to speak it'll be to a specific agenda item okay so we'll go ahead um is there anybody else that wanted to sign up didn't have the opportunity we have no sign okay good so we have no signups in board okay all right so let's go ahead and we'll have uh Dr craft get us started yes sir under business and finance there are a couple of items pertaining to the May 3rd uh 2025 election so the first item uh for your consideration is the order of election of course this is for single member districts 256 and 7even um the filing deadline uh is uh the 14th Valentine's Day this Friday

004um and so like I say the first item really before you for your consideration um to take action on is the uh election order okay uh trusty Freeman so current ly um there are four seats up for election um three of them have more than one candidate there's one that has one seat that has one candidate and normally when we have only one candidate we don't run the election for that particular seat if we go ahead and approve approve this if that remains one we can pull that out believe that's correct uh Tiffany Monica can yall verify that is that accurate that we can we can amend it after the fact if it is in fact ratified I'd have to check on that I'm not sure yeah I know like I say this is our

005last this is our last meeting uh to meet the election timeline uh for the election order to be approved I think it can be amended if there's not a filing for uh that single member district position remember us running into this before talking about it but I wonder if our motion should um have that in mind and then I mean if for some reason somebody drops out of another race then we would we could pull that too where's our uh presumed it's not official yet but our soon to be hopefully election agent yeah I'm going to have to check with the elections office I'm not sure on that but we can definitely check with them tomorrow to see if we can amend the uh the order but if our motion says that we should be

006okay that would be my guess but I again I'll double check with the elections office tomorrow yeah I guess my suggest let's go ahead and make the motion accordingly as you're indicating that allows us to have that adjustment of flexibility with it yeah so so in essence uh a motion to approve as presented with the uh ability to amend if there's not a filing uh for district I'm sorry which seven but any of them can or withdraw yeah so any if it's a non-contested only one candidate yeah if it's non-contested District a non-contested okay yeah so or the opt yeah exactly that stated or just say any contested position but either way what do you think well I say that if um for some reason I was thinking there was something in the election code

007with even uncont Ed races that their name had to go on the ballot oh yeah think so on I know it saved us money if dollars attached to this and it's a significant amount uh let us Che double check on that Barry what's the what's the timeline I know we were discussing it earlier What's the timing of the approval for this item election order um we're we're running out of time if if we don't make it tonight we will not make the deadline for the February 25th meeting okay because the ballots Clos the applications Clos like you said on the 14th um what are the two questions again well yeah the qu the question is and it's a it's a warranted one it's a valid question um do we have to if we approve this

008election order this evening uh as presented and there are two or one uncontested District um seats um Can the order be amended in order for the individual not to have to um be placed on the ballot and I don't know what the cost savings is I so that that's the issue if they're not on the ballot then that would save us money so I guess and just election in general because we we will still have time we have not signed the official contract with the elections office so we are still waiting for the official contract and that will be after of course the applications close on the 14th so we will have time to check with the elections office tomorrow to see what the cost savings would be if if there was an uncontested race

009yeah if there's a motion that allows us that if election code allows us to make the amendment if it's an uncontested seat um that I think that would cover the question all I know is is I've seen uncontested people on the ballot right right I just did I didn't realize it actually could be a cost saving so that's that's new learning to me I think that's great I'm wondering why like uncontested races are on the ballot if they KN anyway I just there's some we need to double check my question some reason I think that even an uncontested race has to has to has to be on the ballot but we just need to double check I I'll work to get an answer good yeah I know they are for other areas but I don't

010know about Schoolboard Els to be honest but yeah yeah because I'm trying to remember other ones I yeah one of yeah okay all right so is there a motion to come before the board given that discussion trusty Freeman I think I'll take a try at this and um if we need to change the language let me know I move that we approve the um order as stated in the um board agenda for the for the co for the election of Schoolboard candidates with an amendment that states if we have an uncontested race that that uncontested race not be included in the election order that that that covers it if permitted by law not per yeah good is there a second all right so second from trusty Salo any further uh discussion all right it's been

011moved in second uh all those in favor signified by stating I I I any opposed good good thank thank you trusty foren for pointing that out we'll double check and uh probably have an answer here shortly um the second item uh the resolution for election services this is also in your uh board packet um we are um also required uh to bring this forward for your consideration of course this is in the form of a resolution uh to hold a mandatory joint election um odd years with the County city um so uh this is the second item pertaining to the May 3rd trust the election okay any comments questions is there a motion to come before the board Bobby yeah I approve uh I I Mo I make the motion to approve the resolution for

012the May 3rd 2025 election is there a second second all right motion second any further discussion move to second that we approve the resolution for the uh election as presentent all those in favor standy by stating I I any oppose State nay good motion carried all right all right so Dr C we got what resolution supporting next yes sir so the uh final item under business administration is the resolution uh for the school closure on January 21st uh we did experience in South Central Texas a nice event um uh the roads were clear uh obviously as you recall because we were able to conduct business with our Board of trustee uh meeting that later that evening but uh the morning I think would have posed uh some pretty significant challenges uh with the commute just

013based on the number of accident reports uh what have you so um this resolution allows in essence for employees pay to be kept whole um in the event um obviously weather situation Mother Nature that is well outside of their control or our control for that matter um um and so like I say this is an opportunity um for all employees including our hourly employees uh to not be penalized from a a paycheck standpoint uh garnering the garnishing of of wages um um like I say for the 21st um and this this is per policy uh to ensure that as a public entity we're not uh gifting public funds okay any comments questions again this is by a resolution motion to come before the board so move all right have a motion any second second move

014to Second any further discussion move to second that we approve the res resolution supporting employee pay for the district closure as uh presented all those in favor signified by stating I I me oppos a good motion carries good thank you right so that takes us out of business and finance and now we're going to the superintendent area sir um we wanted to just spend a moment um in uh looking at attendance rates uh particularly snapshots and uh Adrian Gutierrez uh who uh really oversees not only attendance throughout the district but really more importantly our public education information management system which is a pretty big uh task uh with the number of students that we we educate um uh and so I'll just point your attention real quickly if you'll pull up that attachment uh looking

015at January of 24 in comparison to January of 25 it it's a little bit confusing as you can imagine the weekends and some of the vacation days and everything from year to year is a little bit off track but you can kind of run a comparison uh looking at 24 25 um from just a time of year but also those that those days that do match up um and we're actually uh a little bit ahead of where we were last year now that being said um we do anticipate based on CDC information that we may start seeing it uptick uh with flu virus I know that we've got um plenty of sniffling and and coughing going around right now but uh outside of uh what we typically anticipate um or would anticipate with cold and

016flu season allergies um um and then of course the executive orders uh pertaining in and around uh immigration uh threats uh we're holding pretty steady with um like I say comparison to last year with our attendance also wanted to just um highlight and bring your attention and of course answer try to answer any questions we went ahead and pulled uh attendance by campus um and you can see that this was the 5-day period uh from January 30th through February 5th um again just to provide a little bit of context as to how we're tracking um during that time period uh just a week ago um because this is usually like I say our our uh lowest uh average daily attendance or attendance rate time of the year so um I said wanted to also provide

017that context um and then try to answer any questions I know that uh Ry myself Adrien has been a real a real resource to us uh to be able to provide how are we looking on attendance um dayto day uh in fact and again um we're also tracking uh the information u based on reported illnesses from our nurses office um this is that time of year that could be a little challenging um especially on mornings like this morning okay any uh comments or [Music] questions I just Su still look just a couple of comments U yeah I think it's um I hadn't realize it makes sense to like alternative schools that that attendance would be lower per se uh pretty consistently um the second chance Academy was interesting to see I know that's lower numbers

018all things considered but it's interesting to see that 100% and then the other one I had noticed and I think I understand why too is Ric I didn't realize our RCT numbers especially that 33% um were that low but I guess because never looked at yeah I think that you obviously you have to kind of think about the student population and the medical fragility and the needs um it it's a little bit of a different education environment obviously BBY I'm sorry trusty harl and then we go there thank you um no um I first wanted to compliment you know when you drive around the district as much as we do it's it we value how hard the the schools are working to improve their attendance and to honor it and celebrate it you know it's

019on mares um it's you know with cups on the fence and all kinds of neat things I know when I had asked for it last week I was concerned just because three of the schools that I work with um the kids have voiced extreme concerns in the families with ice agents coming in and you saw them on TV and at the the city hall the other day expressing their concerns and their real concerns um and so um I know you said we're looking at nurse uh or or you know data from the nurses illnesses thank you sorry it's been a long day um how how would we know if um um these fears that the kids and teachers are sharing with me in in my other day work um are are ones that are impacting

020our kids or um you know are we following up after three days and and are they do they feel comfortable sharing that these are real concerns I I'm just wondering about that I I think so um and I was I just had the opportunity to visit uh Marshall High School uh last week and I asked the principal Mr Holly you know have have you had Parents call about concerns and a handful of parents and either himself uh he himself or a counselor or assister principal have been able to reassure I think couple things um you know we've we've we've we've tried to take a very um int send a very intentional uh unified message um the executive order um was issued on uh January 20th um we started working well before that in anticipation with

021uh principes and directors in particular here are really the four things that we're going to you know focus on and we just need to make sure that you know all of our families and teachers in particular staff are are aware um we went ahead um and pushed that messaging uh out um uh with my weekly update catching up a craft but then again formally to the principls uh the following week and then again to our entire community on the 31st and and really this is it in a in a nutshell um we will of course cooperate with law enforcement entities I mean that that's per policy that's that's in policy that being said um our School Safety and Security um uh department has had a conversation with the Department of Homeland Security and we're not

022going to see ice agents coming into campuses randomly asking for immigration documentation Andor to be able to visit with uh students um the exception is if there is a felony warrant uh outstanding warrant to be issued but that would be the case we would work with in in cooperation with any entity regardless of what the legal matter may be the other piece is is I think that is a reassurance is per policy um we would have to make contact with the parents before we were to release information requested uh and definitely before we were able to allow a uh law enforcement agent uh to have that conversation I.E pulling a student out of a class um and the parent would have the opportunity or Guardian would have the opportunity to be with the student I

023think another Point um that's that's really an important one right now because it is being discussed in many cases is is you know students are still entitled uh to privacy rights uh there is furpa and similar to Hippa in the in the health world I mean there there are rights uh to um U to private information that we are custodians uh of the other piece that I think is important is we don't keep immigration documents we we don't we don't request that documentation and so we don't have that information at at our our um access um we just don't and then finally and most really most important talking point is constitutionally don't forget we are required to educate every student regarding regardless of citizenship nationality um and so that has not changed um and in

024order to change the Constitution uh it will it will take much more than an executive order so so those are our really our four main talking points and like I say we have not knock on wood had that issue arise um since our messaging but even even prior to um unless Ray uh there's been something that has percolated that I'm not aware of and so having that unified uh message but then also procedurally campuses if you do have a a uh inquiry this is is what needs to happen call your ex executive um or assistant superintendent um executive director assistant superintendent and let us be of assistance um which we've got obviously legal counsel uh ready to to help assist but I I just don't foresee that at this point uh being necessary so so

025was it up to the principles to relay that to the families no we did it universally and how how did you do it very I think it was the message was released on the 31st through social media to the families I saw it on social media but I just yeah we pushed it out through our messaging system okay School messenger thank you School messenger thank you appreciate that thanks and I did see it on social media so thank you thank you tresse Freeman yeah thank you Mr blunt my question was along the same lines as um Dr Carles as we look at the attendance anecdotally um thanks to um the NCAA Final 4 read across San Antonio pce I've been in a uh two or three schools recently and not only do we have several

026students that appear to be out but there seems to be teachers out so I I guess um when we look at attendance I would want to know as we look through this as we get perhaps out of the flu season if we see that we have schools um that we have um low attendance because of fear of coming to school you'll let us know about thats watching yes ma'am that that and that's a great question um which I Adrian we we talked about this as well to try to drill into that question because sometimes it is hard to uh decipher is it it's lower attendance a result of what weather is it result of flu or illness is it a result of something else um because we don't always receive the illness reports and so

027one of the things that we uh looked at um were withdrawals um and and just again I don't want to say that that this is uh directly 100% or perfect correlation 1.0 correlation but uh last year uh in comparison to this year uh for the same time period so January 16th to through February 2nd last year uh January 22nd through February 7th this year we're actually tracking uh a 100 less withdrawals this year than we were last year now again is it indicative or causal I don't I hate to try to make that um claim or interpretation um but uh it's not exceeding the withdrawals that we were at this this point last year so um I think it's a I think it's a positive so like I say I mean we're just again not

028to say we're not monitoring and keeping a watchful eye and working with parents that have questions and are you know definitely concerns but um you know we're we're continuing to have school and we'll continue to message uh as we uh need to uh pertaining to to uh this executive order issued on the 20th or any subsequent executive orders which there may be J on a positive note I have gone to uh most of the schools in my area that are have a a lot of newcomers and the principles have all said that things have been going good and there isn't there haven't been hardly any concerns after you put out the the information so I felt good about that yeah I can say it just it hasn't come across my desk and I mean again

029there's been some concerns and rightfully so but it hasn't been an exodus or an attendance drop uh particularly at specific campuses that would have a newcomers program uh for example Colonies North um that was one that wanted to look at very closely and their attendance rate is actually higher mhm um so which means students uh particularly uh Afghan Refugee students are comfortable enough to come to school any other comments or or questions good okay but yeah oh I'm sorry we have any numbers for Super Bowl Monday the number Super Bowl Monday I'm trying to remember what was Super Bowl Monday Adrian do you know supposedly it's the lowest if they were a Philadelphia Eagles fan they came to school uh if they were rooting for the Chiefs they did not so do you know do

030you have to know off top of your head we can we can pull there I'm just curious because some districts were actually closed that Monday so because of that so Wonder yeah maybe if the Dallas Cowboys ever play in the Super Bowl again com be considered you have kind of a holiday on Monday well it was when I was no com it's Dallas Cowboys versus Houston Texans it's definitely going to want to be a student vacation day that's a ath matical impossibility but [Laughter] nevertheless okay any other comments or questions we continue to Monitor and you and you reive in Friday letter the last week Friday letter you receive those attendance rates in your Friday letter as well you need to look at Drilling I think all in all it really is good news all

031they definitely consider I mean even separate from the challenge that we're just talking about now things are still looking good but just even look out outside of that I mean it's it's good to see the the increase so coming back um we just we've got to get through several more weeks of some colder weather and the height of of illnesses okay good ready for the board operating procedure sir so this is a real real quick item um uh as discussed with our joint PTA uh meeting they are uh very willing and actually excited about the uh idea notion of a trustee uh serving really in a non-voting capacity on the PTA Council so uh we wanted to bring it back I included the list um of um those appointments and if you recall uh this

032is an annual uh appointment reappointment um based upon uh the reorganization election Andor reorganization of the Board of Trustees so uh similar to a representative to the nef uh Education Foundation uh board be non- voting um they meet uh monthly um and and visiting with the president Chris Rivas she just has asked if we could have the if the board wants to pursue this um included either as part of just our annual appointments or even embedded into the operating procedure storms which is why that item was included uh just you could take action uh I would let I will notify her let her know and then I likely start the meeting in April uh so they would reorganize their bylaws um notification uh the meeting in March and then could start in April I guess

033so the the first part of discussion is just um is if the board wants us to move forward on having a non-voting member joining the uh the PTA part of it trusty Freeman I was just thinking um so we've need to give them time to amend their bylaws so we we wouldn't be if we appointed somebody today they wouldn't begin until their first meeting which in in April she just had asked if because they won't meet uh before March again so if they can have the meeting in March to organize there end uh then could commence on in April I was going to suggest along those lines since we do re do the board reorganization in May right after oh elections if we just wait and do it um at that time because quite honestly

034if we amend our board operating procedures then um see I is there any reason why would we amend our board operating procedures to included in I don't know if we had the yeah this is not into board operating procedures that's an option but if we do the normal May it's not a board operating procedure issue it's just something we add to our list of members that that was just the point of as I was kind of working through it's it's not included especially the ad hoc positions are not included in how those assignments are made now the reorganization officers is in uh local policy in your local policy is it in board operating procedures that we appoint um like there anyf rep it's not outlined in operating procedures okay Bobby when when would when do

035they meet is it Daytime Nighttime they typically meet um it's daytime 10 around 10:00 a.m. twice a month time may change once a month I believe and they meet here at Knack yes fact they meet in the room right behind us in the morning I'm okay I'm sorry go ahead um I'm okay with appointing tonight but we may give consideration in May again before we do that yes let's make sure we all let's approve it first to add that too okay you know what I'm saying then we can do the yeah I need yeah if we can get a motion everybody's okay we can get a motion to go ahead and wait one more question go ahead did we ask for this or did they ask for it did we ask to be put on

036their board or did they ask ask us to be put on their board I made the request um if it would be considered um and so Crystal went back and talked to the whole Council um and they like they like the idea oh okay yeah it was it was also yeah and it was kicked off also when we had the meeting together too it's just a a natural I'm trying I'm trying to remember exactly how it came up in conversation but I just don't want them to feel like we're trying to tell them what to do how to run no and I think that's why it's important that it remains a nonvoting uh I like NE yeah at hog top position okay okay is there a motion to come before the board on possibly being

037a non- voting member and that we'd add it to our committee board committee Representatives list so moved okay thank you is there a second all right motion second there any further just on that part any further discussion just putting that in place all right not it's been moved a second all those in favor signified by stating I I any oppose great good motion carries so now the discussion on possible appointing somebody to that timing wise go ahead trusty s now that we've approved it there really only three of us who can be on that committee because it's going to be during the day so I think for the next two months April and May it ought to be the president so that he can come back and tell us what you know explain to us

038what goes on and then when after the elections that we have our election then we can elect someone at that time but for two months I would I recommend Bobby it would likely only be the month of April uh because again the election would be May 3rd kind of depends on I don't know that meeting wouldn't be to end of May though right we we don't reorganize until the end of that's true yeah so it would be yeah it would be too I don't know other thoughts I'm in tell truth I'm fine with that I don't mind supporting got trusty Freeman if you're willing to serve on that committee um I I would think that um we need to Define that position as to what it is or how we're going to contribute um to

039their um to their meeting so I would also did you make a motion no I just discussion yeah okay make sure everybody's okay though before we okay yeah if we want to have a motion we can go ahead well let me so let me I don't mean to complicate matters uh but as you recall the officers uh are voted on but then the presiding officer president makes these appointments I don't believe that the other so I.E the representative to the Education Foundation I don't think it's approved as much as it's a it's a an assignment or appointment made by the president at that time oh it's do during our meeting yeah you're right no no no you're right we do it during the meeting and stuff yeah yeah so you're doing a process thing so

040typically we'll do at our Mee meeting is we say who want who ask who may want to serve in that particular position and then we yeah then we do sort of then we make the let me see if I can remember now yeah then we have an overall motion for the whole thing right I don't believe we have do we make a motion and approve the yeah we do slate okay yeah yeah we do because it's a Tas being the other parts to it yeah okay all right okay I think we're okay I think we can do it s this way and then we'll readjust in the May time period that be included the overall list all right somebody want to make a motion I'm not gonna make a motion for myself that don't look

041[Laughter] good Mr blunt I motion that you serve um as a board representative to the um PTA Council for April and May right for April and May then well okay that all right motion and seconds there any further discussion all right move to second that the president um will serve as that representative for the for the April May time period until we get to the uh overall all those in favor signifi by stating I I I okay any oppose and I guess I abstained say is that a five or six0 6 501 you always vote for yourself good point good point I messed [Laughter] up1 I'll let I'll let Crystal know good all right thank you all right so that um that completes um our session yeah this part of the meeting and next we're

042getting ready to go into our Clos meeting part so the Board of Trustees on February 11 2025 uh beginning at 7:40 p.m. I have it right I'm trying to give us five minutes oh oh yeah good point 6:40 p.m. we convene a Clos meeting accordance with the Texas government Co sections that were listed that discussion take place on the items that um were also listed okay so thank you everybody so we'll go ahead back here at um back there correct okay so we'll go in the back room at 6:40 and then we'll come back out for open meeting with any decisions thank you all for joining us so the board at okay 712 we conven back in an open meeting um action can take place on the items that were listed is there a motion

043to come before the uh before the board and there's actually um two items that were that were discussed that the board could choose to move forward on yeah first one is when we're um considering adoption of resolution approving contingency fee for Legal Services contract can I yeah yeah you can do that I move maybe not want separate read for the record the agenda expad you got it oh you gotta be kidding me I'm sorry my bad went the other way I move that we accept Item B Item B item regarding the discussion of social media um hold hold it letter b a letter B consideration oh you got it yeah oh you it's further down the whole thing I move that we accept uh consideration and Adoption of resolution approving contingent fee Legal Services contract

044keep going go ahead and just including findings needed for submission of contingent fee Legal Services agreement and request for expedited review by the Texas Attorney General okay is a motion is there a second second okay motion a second any further discussion it's been moved a second all those in favor signified by stating I I any oppose great motion carries Y and any other item we can go right ahead second item I also move that we accept consideration and Adoption of contingent fee Legal Services agreement with Thompson and Norton LLP uh Eland and bonnan PC and handland dith and Castillo PC is there a second um can I go ahead contingent fee did you say fee and consideration and Adoption of cons contingent fee Legal Services agreement thank you second okay motion second as noted with

045contingent fee all those I'm sorry is there a any further discussion all those in favor CI by stting i i i any oppos mention carries thank y'all well done we were done oh we beat 7:15

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.