001yes sir we're ready okay I'd like to call this meeting to order and we'd like to begin with invocations and pledges welcome everyone Lord As We Gather here today we appuse to reflect on the responsibility entrusted to us may we approach our work with wisdom and Clarity May our discussions be guided by respect and a shared commitment to the success of our students and the well-being of our Educators May our time together be productive and our actions driven by a sincere desire to uplift and support one another we ask for guidance discernment and unity as we move forward we also pray for those in our community who are feeling a sense of anxiety either from uncertainty for the future or concern about any challenges ahead we acknowledge these emotions with compassion and we ask for
002to be a source of stability and service we ask these name these things in your name we pray amen amen I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all honor the Texas flag I pledge aliance to thee Texas one State under God one and indivisible thank you thank you okay any public comment no sir okay but I would like to ask the board if we could get our food before we start yes let's take a quick break get our plates okay we're going to continue with the meeting yes I'm enjoying my lunch next item is considerable approval of overnight trips there's three of them board member any questions I move that we approve
003the overnight trips I second we have a motion a second hearing no questions all in favor please say I I all oppose motion passes consider approval of a resolution dealing with wage issues for employees involving the emergency School closure yes sir this is due to the fact that we had to close on January 21st uh outside of employees control asking the board to approve Us by resolution per board policy to address pay during the school closure so that nobody has any negative impact towards their pay so the recommendation is the board approve the resolution dealing with wage issues involving the emergency closure for all employees on January 21st 2025 we approve the resolution I second you have a motion second questions for hearing n all in favor please say I I I I'll oppose motion
004pass passes okay now we have a couple of items of information strategic compensation update yep yep so I'm going to present this uh I would like to point out some people on the on this team that we've created for strategic compensation I'll get into what strategic compensation is but every senior staff members on our team that's leading this work also we have Dr mclin in the audience here uh Veronica quink Wilson's part of the team and then Scott Stevens and then uh some of the other EDS from cni are on this team and then some HR folks Adrian armz I believe is the other uh so what is strategic compensation uh let me make sure this works sorry turned it off uh first I want to start off by talking about Texas strategic compensation that
005was focused back in 2017 from House Bill 3 uh it started with the passing of the teacher incentive allotment uh the Tia funds uh we talk about budget each year and we talk about compensation and how compensation looks and we have to realize that uh we are in the people business 80% more than 80% of our budget goes towards compensation or benefits we also often discuss amongst senior staff and also with the board uh about our district goals uh regarding the growth and performance of our students from prek to postsecondary success our ability to achieve these bold goals relies on the teachers who are in front of those children and also the leadership in our schools uh so when we talk about strategic compensation we're going to talk a bit about how we're going to
006start thinking about doing things a little differently different ways to look at compensation uh in the next coming years and to ensure that we are linning our compensation with our outcomes U so that's really what we look at when we're talking about being strategic with our Compensation Plan where are we headed we wanted to first talk about what we mean we say Texas strategic compensation and the terms of looking at it a long-term plan and how this would be rolled out we're going to be on like a like I said a multi-year journey to ensure our compensation system values are the outcomes that we expect from our teachers and our and our principles and our leadership we started this journey with the implementation of the Tia funds the teacher incentive allotment and today I have
007Dr mclen she's going to come up and talk briefly about uh some important updates that we got about our Tia funds and then briefly talk about how that came about thank you good afternoon everyone um senior staff Dr ball uh Board of Trustees so this morning I received an email from tea saying that our data has been deemed valid um so that means that the the allotment that each of our 55 teachers generated this past year for the teacher incentive allotment has been deemed valid our data is good to go and we will be able to give those teachers that have been designated their um generate generated allotments this summer so this is really exciting news not everyone's data is deemed valid but ours um we got a big congratulations from tea today so the
008$673,000 that our teachers generated through the allotment will be paid to the district this summer awesome so that's really good news so I really wanted leslee to to share that with y'all because she's been kind of the leader of our Tia and making sure that all our our data is valid and so sending that in getting that approved by tea and that function really validates what they've been doing and the work that's been put into place so this is kind of like the Strategic compensation goals that the state has come up with obviously uh there it's a like I said it's a journey it's looking at leadership pay on our campuses and then teacher pay uh strategically using that to pay where we have better outcomes we're going to focus on the first block which
009is develop a refined principal evaluation system and look to pay our principles a little bit differently so looking at the theory of action of strategic compensation uh is really straightforward and this is straight from tea to build an evaluation appraisal system that are anchored in objective Effectiveness identify those who are achieving great out comes for us and then compensate them accordingly this will lead to higher retention of effective Educators and leaders we also position Southwest ISD to recruit incredible Talent across the region and state we're not alone uh in this strategic compensation uh Journey uh many of us applied for a grant and we were awarded but there's 11 other districts across the state of Texas actually 12 other districts across the state of Texas that are doing this as well and starting this journey
010uh that being said some of these districts are very large so really one out of every 10 students in the state of Texas is going to be impacted by this type of strategic planning uh and one out of nine teachers across the state of Texas I will say this because we all agreed not to mention in an open public meeting that who these districts were because everybody's still in the early planning of this uh but we do have another District in San Antonio that's going through this planning as well so it's also very important for us to be ahead of this type of change so that we can continue to recruit and and and attract and keep our talent uh so let's look at the road map what does it look like so we're going
011to start I mentioned we're going to start uh looking at our leadership on our campuses specifically our principles uh it is a multi-year process like I mentioned and so this is tiered uh we already are starting our Tia which is that work started last year and that's the teacher incentive allotment then we're going to in the future look at our Educators which are our teachers and then uh obviously the one I've been talking about is our principles so our goal is to start looking at the new principal appraisal system that we would use for this uh to be implemented in the 2526 school year uh which will drive compensation for the 2627 school year so based on the evaluation system that we Implement next year will determine the following year where a principal might land
012on the compensation scale the district uh is committed to not lowering salaries at this time but we will have to discuss over time if a principal who is getting paid wages that are not meeting the criteria of our road map or actually of our appraisal and how we're going about paying principles how long do we hold them harmless with being in affected so those are discussions that we will have to have as a team and build that out uh and then going in the 25 26 school year we will begin starting talking about teacher strategic compensation to be implemented in the 26 27 school year and then uh driving compensation for the 27th 28th at the same time we will continue like lesie mentioned that we will continue to try to get teachers in the
013teacher incentive allotment part of this strategic planning of compensation is to use our and and leverage our Tia funds to do things differently and so we want to ensure that as 27 28 comes around we are generating the maximum amount of TI Tia funds to increase our general compensation pool so what have we been doing uh here's a closer look of the previous months of work and the next six months of work when it comes to our principal appraisal and compensation system you will see we plan to engage directly with our school leaders so on this starting this month we are having a group of principles work with our team to start laying out what a type of evaluation system that would be fair on biased and coordinated so that when we make decisions on
014who is an effective principal we're paying based on that uh and so we will continue to engage over the next few months uh and to hopefully implement this going into next year with the new appraisal system why is the question is why are we looking at this so as the person that has been pretty much promote of bring in the board compensation plans for since 2016 we've always valued experience and sizes of campuses on what we pay our principles on uh and so to look at it a little differently when you take and this is I'm going to say this this is map data just looking at map data this will there will be way more involved in evaluating a principle besides map data but if you look at our map data it is important
015to note that this is a singular data point uh that the map data is showing that as we see principles that are providing growth for our students they're tend to be our lowest paid principles so we have seven principles achieving a campus growth over 50% that are making less than 96,000 where we have four principles that are in between the 32 and 47% that are making between1 and $117,000 even that said we can see that our compensation system is not tightly aligned with our outcomes so that's the difference of thinking instead of thinking about years of EXP and the size of a campus let's talk about outcomes first and then build in those other things so it's not eliminating those other things but it's to really to look at the outcomes first so this is
016driven by the fact if you look at it this this slide shows you that we have valued the size of your campus and your years of experience we recognize that a principal role is different at the varing types of campuses but we are going to move into a system where we reward outcomes first and then adjust for the other responsibilities for the certain campuses rather than the other way around an example would to Envision an effective Elementary principle being compensated at a higher rate than an ineffective high school principle that's just an example uh but at equal levels of Effectiveness and then we takeing the considerations of the size of the campus the different things and the different factors that play into being the different principles questions on that so um then why would you
017want to be a high school principal when you could could just have 800 kids instead of 3,000 so we're not eliminating those other things that cause that factor so I'm saying that we're going to start with a principal High School principal we're not saying they're not going to make what they're making now they can actually make more if they cause growth on their campus we will still take into the consideration the factors that they are in a comprehensive high school with 2,000 students but we're going to reverse it first and look at okay what would we pay them on an outcome base and then build a plan where we honor those other things for those principles does that make sense so really when we're looking at outcomes we're a part of the factor is to
018to look at why are we paying I don't want to say an ineffective principle uh but if you look at data we can consider it ineffective why are we paying them more than an effective princip does that make sense well yeah but I also or maybe I just don't know enough about it yet I I know what say cuz I agree with you I agreee that the running a elementary princip elementary school versus a high school is different there's a lot more to it we're not going to devalue that piece but we're going to find a mechanism that pays principles that have outcomes a lot more so on top of that where they let's say the the starting salary for high school principal here and the starting principal Elementary is here they have an opportunity
019to make a lot more money if they are have effective outcomes on growth for students that's kind of the difference I think that makes sense because sometimes you could have two principles earning the same amount the other way but one can have successful outcomes and the other one may not so yeah you look at it like that it's so based on Merit yeah based on Merit so kind of looking at it like this so this we were able to place the uh the different groups in different cor tiles so the top box represents cti's of pay so CTI 1 is our highest paid people they're making between 104 and 117 and then we separated them to 2 3 4 at the bottom though then we separated not looking at what position they are it's just
020where where was their outcomes where did the student show growth so then we had a a group was in cororo 1 where they had growth between 54 and 58% of their students had showed growth on their campus all the way down to cororo 4 which it was 33 to 40% of their students sold growth now when you take that together and you overlay those cor tiles like if you look at cortile one for student growth versus cortile one for pay uh and you go across you're seeing that the people that are in growth are in the lower percentage of our cor tiles of pay so this is kind of reiterating it I think a better picture of this and really I will say this at the bottom I think it shows that nine of the
02110 lowest paid principles in Southwest ISD achieved the highest growth for us on our map that the next page I think is a little bit gives you a better picture and this is taking out the size of the campus and the years of experience uh years of experience actually would play a role in this it's counterproductive to what I'm saying but principal way at elementary school a had 50% growth 59% of math growth reading is was 50 an overall combined growth of 55% with a test rating their valuation of 3.1 and they're making $92,000 versus is a middle school principal with less experience in the 30s in their both reading and math with a lower evaluation making $103,000 so that's kind of an example of looking at the data differently to create opportunities for that
022person not to say that we're going to pay the principal at Middle School less when they're making right now but lifting up the principle that actually is showing us growth and paying them a little bit more because of their effectiv when you say paying them a little bit more do you mean like a end of year bonus no I'm saying say their salary is this this next page we create a a a salary skill that's not based on years of experience but based on principal Effectiveness and I'll explain kind of what that would include because it's not just map data I'm only using map data to show Effectiveness in the classroom the creating a system and Appraisal that encompasses everything that a principal does and creating an evaluation that compensate them based on Effectiveness overall
023so if you look at this scale we this is just an example so if you score a 50 in your valuation you could be possibly making 100,000 uh and so a lot of our principles that especially the ones that I showed you that were below $100,000 based on their effectiveness could continue to make more money instead of us doing a 2% rise for them and they get a little bit more and they keep chasing it if they are a campus that has great outcomes they're going to get paid more than a campus it does so what if one year I'm a fantastic principal with fantastic growth and I'm going to make $12,000 and then the next year I bomb you going to take money away from me so what we would have to discuss that's
024a great question because the people we visited with that's doing this uh they they they create a timeline so if you're a principle one year you have a great year the next year you don't but then great next year you have a great year so creating a window over 3 years or 5 years depending on how we approach this is determining their effectiveness so like we may hold them Harless for three years you have a great year you're going to get paid this for three more years now you can make more money because you could obviously go up but for this to work financially the idea is the money that we're going to use towards the effective principles is that we aren't paying the ineffective principles more money does that make sense so after time
025if you're not an effective principle you could have your if you're if you're scoring in the 30s then wherever we set that over time we could we put you back to where you are to to motivate you to get back up to the effectiv level we're expecting does a year experience though still do they still get no this would be do they do that do y'all do that now do you right now it's just right now we're paying principles on what job you have if you're a middle school we have a scale that tells it's Middle School Elementary and high school we have three skills for those principles and then it's based on your years of experience all years of experience so if you were teacher for 20 years and you have 5 years admin
026we give you 25 years experience and we pay you on that well why wouldn't we do it like Tia then why wouldn't we do it based on that year Well TI Tia is five years isn't it Leslie so the princip this teachers are getting paid what they're getting paid this year get that for five years whether they whether they have growth or not but that's ti8 oh we we want look at a little differently they get that much every year for five years mhm whether they're effective next year or not Oh I thought it was just one year no it's it's it's for five years right correct so I'm not these these questions we haven't answered we haven't got into these are I know you're asking these but we haven't answered these questions at all
027in our okay so we're going through that so we're still in the planning to discuss those uh but we wanted to get in front of you to kind of give you an idea where we're headed is that where everyone else what everyone else is doing this is what 11 other districts across state of Texas this is what Dallas ISD did to get the outcomes they're getting we have some neighboring districts that are doing performance PID that they're seeing great outcomes uh and we have been uh awarded a a grant from the state to help us actually Dr mcllin is our leader of the group uh and she works hand in hand with a lot of people from the outside to help us plan this out this is a journey this is not like happening to
028next year this would be an appraisal next year and the following year we would have a new skill for principles and then next year we would start with the teachers and then we would have a new appraisal for them to Encompass all the things they do and then bring in the pay so system design so this is an example this is not this this is needs to be worked out with our principles is how do we create an evaluation system that shows principal Effectiveness so we know there's more to being a principal than just map data but that's what we're chasing for outcomes uh accountability wise but we also have other areas of academic grow they do have their test with they have certain criteria that they have to meet for their evaluation we also
029know that they have to have a good culture on our campus so how do we evaluate that so that would be part of the process and then they have to operate the building they have to keep the building safe they have to make sure they're maintaining the building and having good structures on their building so this is the part that we're going to get into with our principles our leadership teams uh and work with principles to design this and they're going to be a part of it so when going into this they're going to know okay these are the areas that I'm going to get graded on so if I Want to Be an Effective principal and make this much money here's where I'm going to have to be so we're this is very high
030level we haven't decided any of these things we haven't decided the pay scale we haven't decided the the evaluation yet but it's a journey that we're on to try to design over the year so that we can start rewarding some of these principles that are highly effective and then the same time turn around and do that to all our teachers because our teachers right now are doing it with Tia but imagine if we can get more teachers and attract more teachers that are come in that are highly performing so that we can pay them uh as much money as we can within our budget but leveraging our resources so that we can make this happen when are we hoping to put this in place so we're going to work this year on creating the plan
031for principles especially the key is to to calibrate our evaluation because we got to have a when it comes to money and evaluations we could see there could probably a lot of questions like so that's the key is to calibrate our evaluation over the next year with principal input implement the evaluation system next year and based on next year's evaluations then pay the following year the principles on a new skill instead of the years of experience skill then starting next year after we finish the evaluation for principles we're going to do the teachers and start that planning for teachers so that the same steps it goes back to this slide here right here so this would be our planning so like right now we're here in you can see we have Tia which is already
032happening this is the planning for the principles and year 2526 this is where we start doing the evaluation and and for those principles and then the pay them out those salaries starting in 26 27 then next year we would start with our teachers creating this plan across the board for all teachers to become create an evaluation that allows us to reward Effectiveness and then evaluate with it and then pay them out starting in 27 28 with basically teacher performance I I guess I mean I'm I'm all for studying it more and y'all figuring out a good plan but I would think um you I think you would have to definitely consider I mean the size has to play a big factor because I'm component if the if we're going to hold uh Elementary School who
033the principal doesn't have to attend evening things they don't have to attend on Saturdays they don't have to you know they're not constantly doing something in the school we're going to have to figure out a way to make that more Equitable and then also if you have I if if the principal is going to be responsible for the growth in the school then maybe they're going to need more autonomy on who they want at their school because if we're going to to say um Roxy you're responsible for the growth at your school but we want you to take these two people because they're not effective anywhere else so that's just going to be a very difficult thing if if if if she's responsible for that high school then she has to have a lot of
034say on what goes in and out of that high school well I I think that great points I think the idea behind it is we may have some people that are I don't want to say they're ineffective because of complacency but maybe they're not feel like they're rewarded enough to to well I'm all for rewarding it I'm just saying we going to and then there has to be like zero subjective evaluation pieces like it and I think that's I mean that's always been the fear when we've always done merit-based pay is the fear is that if the principal likes the teacher they're going to get a few more points on this or if Administration likes doesn't like the principal then they get a few less points on that so it's going to have to be
035very very clear cut with no subjective I think you're doing good I think that our uh the calibration the team has already kind of worked on because our our data wouldn't got validated from the state if we if we weren't doing that right so for for the teachers that are getting the the Tia so I we hear all your points those are the same discussions we had to the to the state of Texas when they brought this to us to te the group that's working with us because those are the same these are the exact same conversations we're having on our on our every meeting exactly where you're you're heading like what what you're saying is exactly what we need to make sure that we have cleaned up so once the plan becomes more concise
036you'll probably have answers to those questions and iron out the details on how you're going to figure it out so this spring is the goal is to work with the team with principal input to create a a evaluation that's coordinated and calibrated so there's fairness and I know you mentioned bias or unbiased but making sure we have a good system in place because yes we don't want like have a bunch of grievances when we get to a point where we're having these decisions about money so creating that is important and then after that creating a scale that is that that's uh I would say fair for the different levels of the campus but also the key component yes is we want you to chase outcomes uh and we understand that you were a high school
037or middle score Elementary and we'll figure out a way to to navigate that but I think for the most part A principal's working really hard and we got some right now working really hard they're showing lots of growth and we're not rewarding them but just based that next year you're going might get a raise based on your years of experience yeah you know 2% or you might make $20,000 next year because you're now moved to a different level on that pay scale based on outcomes and that's I think that could motivate our principles and then in essence the teachers so Brandon currently we're looking at principles and princip principles only we're starting with principles cuz we kind of have Tia happening already with teachers so we're going to start with our principles so that I
038think it's a small group for us to get it right Vice principles included or we're well I think we'll start with principles and as we move into the the teachers we'll be working with those the assistant principles too pretty much bringing everybody else along the next year okay I think we wanted to do principles first so that we could start with the leadership on the on the on the campus work through all of it growing pains and then move to the the bigger group and I'm sure they're involved in the conversation okay anything that just kind of everything that you've so shown me that's how I get paid at work everything's Performance Based paay and Merit paay and it just to do something and you strive more to accomplish affects your payche yeah so it
039it in R about way it it's going to be good but I understand what you're saying well also you you if you if somebody has a bigger way bigger route than you I mean they might make more money than you because they have more opportunity to whatever but yeah absolutely okay any more questions okay discussion of intruder detection audit Mark has a few things before we go into position hi afternoon the top priority of our district is keeping student staff and visitors safe every day ta recently conducted Intruder detection audits at several of our campuses these audits test whether campus is accessible to an unauthorized individual and also helps districts to identify how campuses can improve Safety and Security we acknowledge that parents and community members are likely very interested in the details of the
040audit results however it is in the best interest of students that we do not share this information to the broader public as it could lead to compromise and security information specific details of the Ida Intruder detection audit will be discussed today in executive session and also with the district Safety and Security committee later this month any questions no thank you we'll see a little is this right okay you have something you want to bring up before we go on the close session okay um I'd like to take a few minutes um to thank the board for all attending on Friday I think all of yall were able to attend our pingr program and you saw the amazing performance our students did want to thank uh Dr Hogan I know that Richard is not here but
041hopefully he'll get the message to thank Dr Hogan and Richard for their leadership the countless staff I mean there's so many staff but when you had set high expectations for students they certainly perform and and perform they did so just wanted to thank uh spend a few minutes thanking the staff for that amazing production because it's not something that happens overnight they're already starting to plan for next year so um thank yall for for that so please I sent uh Dr Hogan an email saying what could we come up to with to do to recognize the staff that that works so hard for this so I wanted to to share that um then there's a few items that are happening within our district not one of them not necessarily that we're sponsoring or anything but
042the um cancer boot dance is happening on this Friday from 6:00 to midnight at Country Gold so just want to let yall know about that we have our food food distribution on the 12th um if anybody wants to help out for that lots of games going on tonight we have boys varsity uh baseball versus John Jay at Titan gym and then we have girls softball and Titan um also at Legacy we have girls VAR City uh versus McCullum um at high at Southwest High School soccer games at both complexes so lots of games uh going on tonight anything no okay therefore as permitted by section 551 .001 through 5511 146 of the Texas government code and 551.074 on personel administrator employment and 551.071 through discussion on intruded detection audit report we will now go into
043close session at 1211 like to call reading back into order at23 uh after I close the session there is uh no action needed other than to approve the uh audit report findings I move that we approve the audit report findings a second motion second all in favor please say I I motion passes all I'll get I guess I should say it be technically correct okay motion passes anything else okay just wishing you a happy birthday thank you very much and then we're g to have all your gifts put in a box okay thank you very much okay board members anything none meeting closed 123