001e e e is now 9 o'clock I will call the meeting of the wache Independent School District Board of Trustees to order let the record show we have six trustees and attendance this meeting has been duly called and notice this meeting has been duly posted for time and man required by law at this time the board will convene in a close session according to section 5511 at SEC the Texas government code it is now 9 a.m. e e e okay it is now 9:37 we're going to reconvene back into Open session at this time our next item on agend will be our open Forum don't believe we have anyone signed up to speak this morning so we'll move into our action items with action item a consideration of possible action to approve an agreement with
002Geotech engineering to provide the material testing services for w chat Creek High School project at the appropriate cost of approximate cost of $79536 Mr cin thank you sir good morning board and Dr AIT um have a couple of items for you today generally related to uh the construction project over at walks Edge Creek first one uh is the materials testing and engineering uh services on that project um geotex is the firm that we have used at Hancock Finley and Howard uh we uh we're pleased with the service that we've received from them uh and so it's a recommendation to proceed uh to use Geotech engineering uh for the materials testing at wety Creek right now the the best guest we have is is just shy of $800,000 uh on that project um we will get
003a better idea kind of as we go through it and we may have to come back and for a little more authorization uh if there's additional testing than what is currently uh planned to happen on that site questions from Mr Colin okay I entertain a motion motion to approve action item a as presented motion by Mr Timberman second second by Mr mccut any other discussion all in favor say I I oppos say nay motion carries 70 and moving on Item B consider consideration of possible action to approve easement to Encore Howard Jor High thanks sir Bo this is actually an item that uh is a little bit out of order so uh this item relates to the relocation of the main power line over at Howard Junior High you know that we've already relocated the
004main power line at Howard Junior High uh because of where the construction is going so uh it's kind of a little after the fact that we're asking for an easement uh so that Encore will have access to where the power line is and they can service that line uh going forward over at Howard Junior High questions comments okay I entertain a motion to approve action item b as presented so moved motion by Mrs creal second by Mr Scholfield any other discussion all in favor say I I say nay let carry 70 all right moving on to action out of C consideration with possible action to approve Renovations at the Ellis County Appraisal District Bo we recently received an email from Kathy rhodri over at the appraisal district um I learned something new when I got
005the email apparently when they have funds in their budget to do a renovation project they still have to ask for approval to do the renovation project from the taxing entities within the county okay learned something new um so M rodrig advises that they have funds in their in their budget to turn uh a couple of larger spaces into smaller uh more conference style spaces more conference room style spaces uh and she says that that will benefit the taxpayers of Ellis County because there'll be more spaces uh for the appeals hearings uh to happen over there this is all within their budget they're not asking for any funds uh from any of the taxing entities they're just asking for approval uh of that project to move forward in accordance with the uh with Texas law questions
006comments on action item C okay I cons consider a motion for approval s motion by Mrs kgal second second by Mrs Timberman any other discussion all in favor say I iOS say nay motion carry 70 action item D consideration possible action to approve the purchase of HVAC units for walki Creek High School from Texas air systems at the price not to exceed $5 million Bard we did an RFP for the hbac units over at walket Creek High School um we know these are going to be a significant number and a significant purchase we don't need them immediately uh but what we are seeking is to go ahead and get the order in and get them purchased uh in 2024 pricing and not have to purchase them uh with anticipated price increases next year in 25
007uh as part of our solicitation we asked for the respondents uh to get give us information or to actually give us a a uh all-inclusive price including storage uh and future delivery of these units at walki Creek when it was time in the construction project for those uh deliveries to happen uh so we did get two respondents we got one from Texas air systems and one from carrier um in looking at the information that was responded to or the responses from both uh parties uh we did feel that the Texas air systems uh was more in line with the the uh scope that we put out as part of the RFP and so it is the recommendation to you today uh for Texas air systems I did increase the price a little bit from what
008their response had uh to give us a little bit of flexibility uh in case uh as we work through the project there's anything else that that may have been missed or we decided to size up a unit uh as we go through the project so the original response from Texas air was 4 million and change where is it 4,929 52 uh so I did increase it about $70,000 uh just to give ourselves a little bit of a cushion uh asking for the $5 million uh that's been our experience um in addition to reading their response in the documents uh we've been using Texas air systems at a good number of campuses now uh we've had really good uh quality of unit and really good response from them if we have any issues so uh that's
009it's one of the main reasons we were looking to to continue that relationship I was just going to um ask even with the additional cost of um storing them by purchasing them early is still a big cost saving than what's projected yes sir so one of the things that we're really concerned about is a change in the freon standards going forward and so the freon that's required starting in in calendar year 25 Ford is more flammable uh and so we'd rather not get into that boat any sooner than we have to so we'd really like to use uh some current uh model standards that we already have we're familiar with them we know how to service them uh and then that that uh more flamable Freon or cooling product uh is really not an area
010that we wanted to get into when we have the opportunity to go ahead and and do something we're more familiar with now you help set up my question um with those changes in the manufacturing requirements for the AC units are we anticipating there being any code changes the city that would require us to have those newer units there's nothing that I'm aware of right now okay U I didn't want us to go buy all these units and then the city say well I'm going to go off our our past working relationships with the city uh when we were building Max Simpson and proposing to build max Simpson city was very upfront and telling us that there's a Code change coming code change coming uh so I would assume uh they know our timeline they know
011that we're we're pushing to to get this project uh fully approved and ready to go uh all permits by April so I would assume that they would have kind of given us a heads up hey this is coming down down the pipe we anticipate this be a change I'm not aware of any U conversations with the city about that at this point thank you that's my understanding that carrier's bid was actually cheaper but they were deficient in several of the areas that we were requesting specs on correct yes sir so carrier was about a million three uh lower than the Texas air systems but as we started looking through and matching it back to the scope we noticed some significant variances one of which uh the carer response did not appear to include the storage
012and future delivery of the equipment uh which just on the surface of of uh you know our thoughts as we're going through this would have made up a significant portion of that difference uh but we did go through and it's in your uh information that you have boarded believe it's page 20 uh there were about seven or eight variances from the publish scope uh that we noticed in carrier's response some of them not deal breakers uh if we're really honest with each other one set of filters verse two is not a deal breaker uh but some of the other things we thought were rather significant including not including modulated reheat uh within the scope and I will be really honest with you I learned what that meant at the time uh Mr kiss uh was
013educating me on exactly what that meant and it really sounded uh like it was an efficiency gain to have the modulated reheat on the units as we requested uh which Texas air systems did include so that was just one of the big components that we looked at and um those variances in scope really uh at the end of the day for us outweighed the savings that we could have uh realized with that lower cost any other questions okay at this time I entertain a motion to approve action item d as presented motion by Mr McCutchen second by Mr schoolfield other discussion all in favor say I I post say n motion carry 70 and our last action item will be consideration of possible action to approve the second early package for the boah Hatchy Creek
014High School project from po construction at a price not to exceed 20, 250,00 ,000 thanks sir uh board actually have an update on that pricing number it's uh not to exceed $18 million 29,7 so at the time that we were publishing the agenda uh we needed a placeholder as we still as po still work through reviewing the scope of the responses and and making sure that they were comfortable with uh the proposed uh vendor responses so that is a a decrease um of almost $2 million from the original placeholder amount but the the amount that's being requested today for approval is 8,259 72 uh the second package includes structural steel on the site and it also includes the Electrical uh switch gear you may remember back when we did the interviews for contractor we heard
015nothing but switch gear switch gear switch gear uh Mr M tells me that uh the the pressure on switch gear has eased a little bit we're not looking at 52 plus weeks we are still looking at roughly 4 something weeks uh at this point going ahead and getting the switch gear in the queue uh is something that that we would like because it will accelerate that delivery but it's not critical at this point we're not looking at paying extra to in program or to accelerate that delivery on switch gear um as far as the structural steel uh board we had provided you with um some plans some site plans and some floor plans uh as were requested so I hope that you've had a chance to to kind of look those over uh we do
016have uh the structural steel will allow us to go ahead and get in line for that we don't we can't just go to Home Depot and pick structural steel up off the shelf would be lovely if we could um so that would go ahead and get us in the uh in the queue to start having our steel uh manufactured and then we'll start getting it delivered on site in time for the construction uh project itself any questions okay at this time I'll entertain a motion to approve action out item e with the noted change of price being 8,259 072 072 so Move Motion by Mrs Timberman second second by Mrs Kel any other discussion all in favor say I I post say nay motion carries 70 and I need a motion to adjourn Mo by
017Mr pits second my Mr Cooper all in favor say I I say n car 70 thank you guys very much and I hope everyone has a very merry Christmas thank you