CorpusRecord 80012

Board Meeting 2/4/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / CSDtv Canyons District
Date
2025-02-05
Location
Salt Lake County, UT
Material
Transcript
Extent
20,636 words · about 115 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001left in this session to do I mean we're telling them we're saying you know this this is the piece that's out we would like you to consider this in funding the other people we've talked to have been our other law enforcement agency and we said they came with a plan y'all come with a plan now one thing a bill dropped this afternoon that could be a game Cher and that is um that uh they is a bill file open now that would change the law enforcement retirement if they go to work in a school um that it would drop their change their retirement so they could come straight back to work for us and not impact their retirement that may be a GameChanger for law enforcement that makes them look at things different if it

002passes um there's also been a suggestion um Made To Us by one of our agencies that uh if they if we the district became the employer and covered um just the insurance piece they may not care as much about pay if we'd cover interest Leon we mentioned that to Leon this last week and it's something we will you know would pursue and talk to them about so Jeff Kirsten have been and EMT have been very careful to say to all the different entities bring us your plans your thoughts your ideas and we'll keep evaluating but we do have a plan to implement if we have to in August and one minor correction I don't want to correct Leon but um the local law enforcement agencies after the trainings now not the county and so they

003will have to coordinate to together and um they three4 of that is we'll be talking and hopefully four quarters whole whole of that we'll be talking on how what that looks like what's the timeline on this um that we have left to continue to discuss or to speak up uh couple three weeks until they can't won't run and change a bill or until these bills pass and they won't do anything so we that that is in everything we're talking to and everyone we're talking to is we don't mind the school guard bill but it's missing the one thing that we needed help on which is this other thing I mean we don't want to quite say it that way but that is basically what we're saying is the biggest piece to all of education is

004not included in the bill and they're like that's because we intend to be implemented as is right now so to your answer to your question Holly I've been thinking about this I think honestly personally as part MERS and myself included is I'm terminating myself I think we need to do a better job of educating constituents about what's coming when I spoke with Senator C about the safety concs he said I get it but how as a legislator do I vote against school safety I think the public needs to understand that this actually is not making anyone more safe in my opinion and actually puts us at greater risk and I I've been thinking about like how can we communicate that more effectively with the public or at least put it out there and say are

005you comfortable with this because if you're not you need to be talking to your legislators because the only way that they're going to vote against the full safety bill is if people widely understand implications of and I don't think the research shows any research that's done on this film has only been done by the manufacturers and Willcox has quoted in an article on the Wall Street Journal saying this doesn't work and yet we're going to spend millions of to do this is that the one he's requesting mute have they ever have they ever donated to his campaign that's what I want to well that's that's it makes you wonder whose buddy is behind um the stuff and even with the Guardians having uh a Guardian Security does not show decrease in uh School violence that's

006right um it's actually actually leads to more arrest because kids are getting arrested for you know sort of teenage behaviors that they weren't necess NE before so the research doesn't back what this bill is trying to push for school safety when you look at the research out there and that's the frustrating part it's like that's great let's put money behind it but let's put it towards actionable things and they talk about access making sure all our exterior exterior doors are locking we have elementary schools that I'm hearing from principales like I have doors that won't lock and they just come and they keep trying to do a Band-Aid fix and it's not fixing the the problem um and you know limiting access to one okay so put bulletproof glass on that one entry that they

007can access the school or something you know but that's the frustrating student ratio start right mental health is a huge piece of it yeah early prevention 350 to 400 per counselor I mean that's impossible and it's sad because it's you know the the Optics is how would you vote against a school safety bill but the real question is are you are you helping our schools be more safe and anyone who's sat in any safety conference or any class at usba or anywhere else the number one predictor is kids that are at risk and making sure we do early intervention so it's so sad we're talking about how to fund School Guardians and you know when I'm thinking about the timeline you know why aren't we you know why why aren't we organizing an effort to

008testify in in these sessions because you know that whole you know the general public no one's aware that it's the manufacturer no one's aware that the film expires after 5 years no one's aware of all these things and I've been saying yeah let's do a Let's do let's do a little investigation you know why why is why is this film all of a sudden becoming such a big Topic in the school safety to begin with so you know I think it this this bill is you know as we know so flawed with so many aspects of it and you know what what can we do to educate the public and and even honestly go and and testify and say we're all about school safety but this bill is so flawed um you know what what

009can we do that way because it's it honestly it's not okay and it doesn't make me feel safer for the kids it makes me feel like this is absolutely less safe and it's not right that it's put on our heads to figure out how to pay someone penis to have a concealed weapon in our schools and that we're being asked to not go through the typical law enforcement which has the background checks and a lot of people who were doing it in the Private Industry are ones that actually had to be removed from law enforcement because they had violations and they were written up with warnings so you know that story needs to be shared I would love this is outlandish but I would love if there was some way that we could bring the

010legislators to a demonstration and see if uh they can clear a room without killing children um so oh jeez the comment of well hire hire former veterans or you know it whoever you know the custodian can do it um it's really hard not to hit other people when you're shooting a Target right because it doesn't stop at that person it keeps going and so I've been trained to clear buildings um and it is incredibly hard and and okay so what would the political Fallout be Susan if we were to go up and Testify the Committee hearing on us so the board like I like for what he says I want to pass out the article from The New York Times to all those people like yeah they need to they need to hear this and

011and also here all of the money that we have spent on school safety on the security vules and all of the other things like like are are we gonna be attacked as a district and say that we're not good players well you're what you're up against is sentive Will Cox brought and our 12 Parkland parents first week introduced the Bill and those parents all testified this is the greatest thing ever if you had done this in Florida you would have saved my kids lives I mean that set the that set the bar was Parkland was because the gate and door work locked well there were a lot of things but he used they used I mean those were the parents that built up when this bill was introduced to get momentum and get people emotionally

012attached to the whole idea and he and he got them to you know right or wrong they all testified that this plan with guardians and all this would have made the difference in at Parkland which may or may not have but that that's the bar that you're it's the how many of those parents actually read the bill I don't how many days they were here not that long only here a couple H keeps representing the bill as something that it's actually not so if he doesn't understand the bill I have a very hard time believe believing that those people fully understand what's in it I I I can totally have empathy and compassion and I feel terrible for what those parents have gone through but it doesn't mean that the nuances of the bill are

013necessarily the right answer especially if we have legislators that are advocating for people with histories that would not pass our own background check carrying a concealed weapon in our not to correct you but they they do have to pass a background check right now these would be our own employees and they do have to pass a background check and in the in the to become a guardian a much more stringent mental health check so there are checks and balances in place for these people it's not like any person can become this with no no background one where I was coming from on that is that we have a legislator who is encouraging us to use private companies where that can sometimes issue we can not use and not hire unless they pass whatever check you

014all decide they need to but definitely our background checks uh they all have to be VCI check they all have to I mean just in the bill they all have to pass mental health screening so just don't focus on that one point in your objections so I'm not trying to soften your objections to the bill but just that's not really a valid I'm GNA direct this question at Communications Department hi is it possible or would it be effective if we as a district or just do it as a board or to write a in my viewpoint article aned no it's not an oped it's a it's a different section and you don't have to document to death at least I've not seen a lot of documentation there you actually say in my view and it's

015your opinion it's an opinion piece would that be effective in get letting more of the general public understand the concerns that we have if we point them out as a public Ed SCH uh school and would that backfire on us I'm just for those folks as elected officials certainly do have that right as a body to be able to decide what type of a message you want to S to your constituents um it does even have to be in my view we have ways to tell that story through District's channels if you now of course putting it in a paper such as the desert news or the suake tribute or ksl.com um it does have that impr of legitimacy because many people go there for differentes of people if that's something the board wanted to

016do by all means we would support you in that provide any type of guidance you would like there so if that's something you would want then we certainly can assist you with that but I would defer to Charlie and Susan on what type if any followup there would be of board members speaking kind of a about currently debated legislation and I would probably back to your question about would it be um keeping in mind that this bill the bill that's running this year is more of a fixed Bill than the bill that you're actually upset about which is the underlying bill um it it would be a little bit hard to testify against the whole testify to this bill you would probably be called on not testifying to the bill that's up in question but

017you could try um but we're just asking that this fix Bill include other fixes right and you potentially could do that yeah you potentially could do that now you know I you're the board you tell us how you want this representative if you want us if you guys want to come up that's totally up to you would there be some collateral damage probably but I would let Char I would rather Charlie be here to weigh in on that or at least to advise on that um but it they have been having committee meetings for three years basically on this bill and while we have spoken to individuals and we've taken all your opinions and addressed our concerns um I I think they would mention that this is the first they've really heard collectively from canyons

018in a collective way that says we hate the underlying bill that passed before it totally up to you that's what you want to do and you want to do it great if you want to get information in if you want to address the bill this year um I think it's been several months that staff-wise we have just said okay well this is the law now we have to go make it happen and we've been dealing with it from that perspective but and we're speaking about you know how to fix the bill and we go jointly and say student safety is Paramount for us as well why is there no portion of the bill that's talking about early warning signs early intervention why are there not being any dollars spent on prevention it's all reactive right

019every single part of this bill is all about what to do in the event there's an active shooter in your building when every single um statistic proves that the very first place you start is prevention and that that is the biggest indicator and way to resolve this so you know does it hurt for us to say please put some funding and help in prevention please help us with you know early warning signs we have some questions about some of these other things like the you know I mean if we're this is a fixed bill you know I guess for me in my mind the rationale of saying well Canyon's board has never come before and and spoken to the legation in this type of manner you know well yeah but this is student safety here

020and this is something that is very important to us and and it's very problematic I mean we're nervous about some of these things I start with um question because I don't remember and wasn't there this last week did jlc take a position on this well not on this one not on this one we didn't discuss it because it was we were waiting for the am amendments to finalize so that we could actually discuss what's really there and not what we're assuming is there and so we didn't so I think you should probably start talking to your own I will tell you there are some districts highly in supportive of this and are fully implemented Alpine being one of them they have great uh participation from their Sheriff and they are pretty far along on this

021um Washington County there are other districts that are pretty supportive so um I would probably start at jlc and ask for a broader discussion there with your further districts and then and then of course you all are welcome to do anything you want and we'll make that happen so are they resolving the school Guardian issue with just having it be a current staff member current faculty member instead of hiring someone from wide range who Washington de volunteers Jordan does plan to go with the um SFO uh from the Salt Lake County um they're planning to do that granite's doing a mix Salt Lake is doing private security and I don't know what Murray's doing at this point thank you that's a good point jlc is the right first mode it will be back it's always

022back I talk to him and see if you can get it on the agenda and actually had the conversation there first and see if not you're standing alone which is fine it's stronger when it's a group okay you all ready for me to move on um there are a few there are several ways what is what is the saying death by because Thousand Cuts or something we've got quite a few bills that are taking money here and money there one of those is roll back tax amendments Leon I believe that one cost us approximately 100,000 give or take it's a want to explain that one when uh so if you have Farmland right if you sell that Farmland right now the Farmland generates very little property tax you know it's benefit since the 70s to

023try to benefit Farmers uh if you sell that farmland or you convert that into development then the county then they you know obviously it goes off what they call Green Belt you can then generate a lot more money off that that does go a portion of that does go into another fund now based on this bill that Susan said would impact cany as much about 100,000 because we don't have any forarms left right but some of these districts that are rural or semi- rural Nebo Weber you know semi- rural they have lots of farmland and so you're looking a million dollar hits to not big to us it's well Jordan still has some too there there but you know us Salt Lake Granite not much but other districts would be hit hard by this that's

024one with the smaller but still a cut um the school fees amendment is out hopefully there people you're studying that fast and furious we'll talk about this next we one of the things that we're asking is just for a year delayed implementation because it's got to line things up and various things so that's one of the things um we're still trying uh minimum basic tax rate amendments this is the one that uh takes the interest right so that would be another what $800,000 cut to canyons and more from public education so we're trying to keep track of all the cuts so that we can present those as a whole not as a little here and a little there but a look at the total um so we're trying to track those um and then there's

025four bills that are well- meaning well-intentioned um that are curriculum bills um that add to mandatorily add to the curriculum every day one is on energy a lesson on energy one is on uh Civics education one is on firearm safety interestingly enough from Kid kindgarten through 12th grade and one is on swimming um and we're just kind of lumping them together and saying uh well I'll tell you what I've been saying in that is you you're kind of asking both ways you want um to say this is a parental right State and parents should be teaching their kids all these things not schools and then you're saying we're going to add all these things to the schools that you're supposed to be teaching so you know which which is it and I don't know if

026we're going to get very far I don't know how those bills are going to do but if they all for passed it would be quite a bit for us to figure that all into a day of curriculum without cutting somewhere else so um we're looking at all of those individually the swimming pool one in particular um there's only like 18 schools Statewide I think is what the state what they showed in J that actually would have theity contract with somebody anyway I think they said the bill was written so that it didn't have to be poolside for yes for certain grades yes kind thing but same with firearm safety it's only a few minutes yet Tom's gonna stand up in the middle of class and he's gonna teach so fall in um that's my rule

027we had you'll notice on today's tracker we had I think four maybe five more that we added The Hot List day that just dropped this afternoon um so uh make sure you read those we have not read them as of yet totally but and then I understand there'll be more coming any specific questions for me hey next on the agenda School fee policy update by lean wiox business administrator just uh that L Emil just keep swimming right say that or Dory Dory says that M it's in context it's it's fine so uh under a state board rule we have to go over our fee policy again this is the policy that we have the governor or fees we have to do that annually it's ironic that we're look we're probably be making some big changes

028to the policy but we're going to go over it as is right now with you uh we'll actually bring the Fe schedule he proposes changes to that uh next week and this is just the poliy again it's not we're g hit on a couple ideas on some fees that we're looking at but again this wouldn't qualify as a reading on the fee schedule that will come at a later next board meeting okay so on board dos you have the policy our policy and you also have the State Board rule that government scor use as well so couple things on the policy I don't think any of these will really change when we if we update when we update the poliy you have to have at least two board meetings where you allow public comment last

029five years or so we've always had three uh three meetings uh we you have to adopt it by April 1 they may tweak the legislation this year based on a bill but we're still going to aim for that date maximum fee for each activity maximum fee for each student has to be based on the cost to provide that activity or that course and you have to have a spend plan for each each course or activity you know we use a an online Fe schedule if you click on the bubbles there you can see what how we plan to you know that would dra as our spent plan there and then you have to have the policy and the schedule on each on our district website as well as each school's website as well uh way

030again if it's a fee it's a fee it's a fee it's a fee it could be wave okay uh that's just really cut and dry there uh we have to make sure no student is denied the opportunity to participate in the class or activity I think our principles have always done that the hats off to them they don't want to see any student deny that opportunity we always designate at least one to me the main waiver administrator at each school but you know more multiple will do it you know just to just ensure coverage and of course you cannot discriminate our principles build that maybe not do that mon you fee wer student as well then you have to proportion out the fees across the district so we do that here kind of check right

031out of our general fund to each School based on the number of fees they have wave so we can calculate that here distribute that out to the school uh donations a donation is a fee if a student or is a a fee if a student is required that donation so it's a if it's a it's not a donation if it's a fee okay what we're trying to say there if it's a fee it's a fee you can't call that a donation schools May solicit donations and accept them but they have to be voluntary where you clearly State they are donations and we try to direct all direct all donations over 500 to the foundation uh we don't want to take donations that would really you know cause inequities throughout the district as well always care

032careful about uh there are some things as Susan hit on Bill HB 344 that is new this session it uh came out last week was signed to a committee today or yesterday that has not been heard in the committee this bill actually is a pretty good livable we call it compromise if you will uh it's not exactly what we want we knew we weren't going to get what we want but it's a livable thing and I think it's easier to understand some highlights there though you cannot starting next year we cannot charge a registration fee okay and you can see the amounts you know was about almost a million dollars 900,000 between our in high schools that's a big hit for them you know for all the things that they pay out of that fee

033uh you can still you can't charge you can't charge for schol equipment uh individual fundraisers are no longer considered fees that's good language there but probably the main thing with this bill is they have gotten away with really subjective language of what is curricular and curricular and just that what is a non-fee course and what is a fee course and so we I do appreciate a representative strong one of ours for help working with others to clean up that Lan which takes away a lot of the ambigu ambiguity that districts had to follow so a non-fee course is really a course subject so your math science Ela and social studies and they also do help you just cannot charge a fee for anything more that's not a big hit to us you know we don't

034charge MBE some chemistry or biology fees but other than that not bad across all our high schools you know was about 100,000 some of that was actually concurrent that you can still charge a fee for but uh your basic math you know you really don't charge a fee for that so that's good language your non I excuse me your fee courses now or your is everything else so you can still charge a fee for the Ceramics class where in the past you could you know the music class drama class your supplies things like that so that's pretty good language there you know that's liveable again we always wish we could keep the registration fee but this other language does clear it up quite a bit there uh and you've always been able to charge extracurriculars

035matter what so that was never really in doubt in any bill they come out uh start but starting not next year but the 26 27 year you actually have to a parent student does not want to pay fees at all you have to design a plan for them to do that now that doesn't mean you have to create any new courses anything like that that means they don't have they may not get what they want but we could you know we've talked of time there are options out there we where we could design a a schedule 9th through 12th where a student have to pay fees again they're not going to get the classes they want but they could there could be options out there I do think this is pretty discriminatory though that's what

036we talked about at jlc last week that you can't you can be done but I think it does some discriminatory elements to that uh policy update again if this bill passes we really want to update the fee policy the issue is we just really wanted to get the legislation correct before we did that going back and doing it a couple times but couple things there this has been out there for a couple years for but and we do follow these even though it's not in policy but you cannot withhold class schedules for unpaid fees uh if you're eligible for uh snap you you're eligible to have your bees waved uh uh there's other things there I won't go through them all again we hit the general fees and the if this bill is passed again

037we want to Define what is a fee course versus a non-fee course uh remove any curricular or curricular definitions put in option that we have to provide or this Clause that we have to provide an option or non pathway through they really they're all middle school and high school then hey Le on real quick so what happens if a student doesn't pay their here goes by parents don't pay it does that follow a collections track or what yeah in our policy we do we do allow those to go to collection yet I've done that for what do we have Dan about we have a couple we have over thousand out there we we do try to work with families and we usually only send the collections when they move or graduate if they're conversing with

038them rather than do that we try to be standing and do what we can we don't that's not our first knee-jerk reaction to send a collection right off obviously we we don't want to get to the point where going to get their cap G for graduation and they have fees paid unpaid fees for the last two years we're always communicating principles and our financial secretaries with families to make sure they're aware know calls and emails and everything of that nature but yeah some of that Commander so a question I get from my constituents a lot I don't know like I don't know how to best address this or if this even like to do it but a lot of my constituents complain about the fact that at the beginning of the year when they register

039and they're fine like paying the fees and understanding what those are up front then over time especially in the high school there's there's like a trickle of like oh by the way there's also and by the way there's also this Fe up by the way so is that all going away or do are they supposed to have things they should not if it's not on the fee scheduled they should not be charging it that's cut and dry okay well so now that being said if it's in track you know you don't have to pay that till some people may want to be on the track team and you know that's a Spring sport not that but they yeah we should not be charging fees that are not on the schedule so what's common practice in

040the high schools is when students register they pay just the registration fee and that's going away and usually wait about three weeks before they charge any class fees because there's so much class changing going on in the first year and so after school starts about two or three weeks then they put on a class fee if their class has a class fee that's the only time they would get a fee and it's just to wait for the dust to settle when semester start is there any way we can communicate that at registration when parents because it's it's legitimately confusing for a lot of because they're like okay I signed my kit up for band I was expecting to pay and I thought I paid some things and now I'm hearing after the fact there's this

041other thing like some of them just say I just want to pay it all at once like I just want to know clearly from the beginning and so maybe we say somewhere in there like when they're actually paying certain fees like you know after the class schedules are settled you will be contacted by teachers if there is a fee right well and right now they usually just added to Skyward there's no like special communication they just see it on Skyward but then sometimes their kids come home and they're like hey so and so like my teacher said that we owe money and the parents are like what are you talking about like it's it's leg I think that's a reasonable feedback and I think that is something we could communicate out better we do it

042the way we do it to avoid paying thousands of dollars in refunds kids transfer out of a class or moving the fee from this class to that class we just wait saves us a lot of work but I think we could do a better job of communicating that that's our practice at our schools Maybe the online registration we should notice there that class fees will be charged but it will be charged because I got that not you know my boy in high school we got the fee notice you know around October but he a certain amount of class well maybe we just I I don't know if there's a parent square that goes out and says okay your child is enrolled in the following classes and please check Skyward to see what their fees are

043I like just most parents aren't thinking a month into school like maybe I ought to look and see if there's some fees that are outstanding you know you probably see those come expecting to pay at all that first week in August open up registration and have them come back okay I can see that I think it's just consistency though too because there's some that I go look for Skyward to pay a fee and it's like no I got to write a check and so there's there's just lots of different communication I think it need to standardize the communication or the process that it's like all fees are put into Skyward um it's the same with AP tests come later too that's another and so that's where I think it does feel like you're getting these

044things at different times and then they start a new class and there's a new fee I think we just need have better communication and one system instead of just like oh you got a letter home and you got to send a check in versus paying on Skyward the only thing required for you to be able to pay in Skyward is for the teacher to to tell the office to put the B on Skyward it's just a matter of ask asking some figured it out on some we can we can I can work on cleaning some that up with with the with the Financial Secret GRS uh any other questions I was more on the policy my question is on number one up here I'm not sure what we're saying a transportation fee of $15 or

045is that less than 50 this is so yeah so uh that was covered the policy okay so this is the next so this is now as I said we're looking to bring the fee proposed fee scheduled for next year next school year probably at meeting the 18th meeting for a first reading okay so these are just some ideas that we have been talked about as as an Administration okay more set in stone just to throw those out to you so you're not surprised on the 18 but just put them out there right now for you okay so these would be propos changes to the fee schedule so number one uh a transportation fee lots of our neighboring districts do charge some type of transportation fee uh for whether it's Athletics for uh SSA or for

046just you know the band or choir going back and forth okay so we're looking at around $15 per student fee so it just be $15 for the whole year so if you're on the football team you pay $15 transportation fee or you're on the b50 uh you know we look at put adding that to the adding that as a participation fee to the fee schedule okay that generates us about $775,000 roughly 5,000 students your in extracurricular activities uh last year we spent about 435,000 just on uhsa at youo that's you know because we do have to go to St you know especially Hill Crest and Jord they go to Ral they go to St George deer they go 4 a that's they have a lot of travel B Brighton play a lot of games they're

047doing a lot of travel and big teams so they usually have three buses same with Alta so there's lots of travel cost there that's just something that we're going to think we're going to propose that yeah that's not been communicated to any of the coaches or stuff because I'm hearing as they're doing their spring coach um parent meetings that they're saying that the transportation has been taken away and that they're going to have to pay possibly up to $400 like Jordan you know what I mean they're saying things that are not correct that the district is doing and it's not it's not based on truth so I'm kind of concerned that the coaches are playing spending or sharing misinformation I mean heavy miss this is for next if they're doing it for this year they

048can't change yeah well anyway I'm just saying I got a phone call so because they just come back from a spring uh training parent meeting what is this thing about buses that we're GNA have to pay all of the costs of the buses coaches went really way overboard and playing a lot of things on the district so I that's new they've never done that before no no I know they never do that that's I was gonna say we expect that but I just wanted that's why I wanted to understand this one because they're overplaying the hand I don't know what they intend to get from it I wasn't either until I got a phone call well Leon just for clarification up to this point we've covered all yeah we covered that 43 and and we're

049saying we're not going to be able to do that but that's not by our choice is it we didn't say hey I just don't think we want to do that anymore being we're being required to red due to legislative requests well and just inflation the cost of fuel I mean alone and the drivers we're still GNA cover 350,000 even if we add5 yeah well I'm just saying that is not the message that's being given to a large number of our parents well so I don't know I don't know that this is widespread I think there's a lot of uncertainty related to fees people been talking about how are we going to recoup some of these fees and they're making up their own narrative but nobody has been given official statement that says this is what's

050going to happen next year it's just a lot of people postulating what could possibly happen they present them as facts yeah which is not okay if you can't don't know anything don't say anything just you don't know anything sh black counts are introverts okay uh another fee we're looking at is Rev track so we use rev track as our third-party processor for the school fees when you sign when you sign up so it's like paying a Visa you know there's always that three and a half percenta that cost us about $200,000 each year to use rev track you know years ago we just added it on as part of the fee that probably in 2018 is but the fees of G up all our costs have gone up we really haven't adjusted the fee schedule

051so do we look at something there do we look at a convenience fee you want to pay a card you know we've all been on mind you got to pay this convenience fee do we want to look at that model or do we want to add something just in here you know part of the participation feed for help cover these these credit card charges okay and just putting that one out there tooand can I just speak to this I think if we charge that percentage you're going to have a lot of parents say I'll just come pay by check and then does that increase the workload of our front office people right I think I think we want people to pay fees we want it to to be as convenient as possible absolutely so I

052don't know maybe wrap that into participation that makes sense sorry so like for traditional fees it's not a huge burden but if you're if you're going on a trip and it's $1,500 pay with the check we get that whole $1500 if you get a credit card and we're paying almost 4% we get we get $1,440 we lose 60 to the reset so that's a big chunk especially when they're trying to pay for that travel and they're to the penny you know this is how much airfare is this is how much Hotel this is food we we don't make up that $60 We Just Lose It how many of the tours are really going through rev track though I mean in my experience as a parent worth kid now in high school like I've never had

053them ask on and they're always asked to bring checks in well is that why Corner Canyon doesn't use as many credit Brighton uses credit cards at the front desk oh so we take just for convenience so we have a lot of people pay with credit cards at that school and we do lose a percentage for being convenient because nobody I don't even hav't a checkbook in 10 years you know so it there is a we either have to pass the cost along or figure out a way to recoup the funds well could we do a combination of this if it's a school fee we've just sort of rolled it in but if it's a extracurricular activity there's a convenience fee if you want to pay via credit card versus pain versus check because the district

054shouldn't have to eat that and you can't just roll that in and some of them are paying the fee and some of them aren't depending on so I think maybe it's a a dual model let us talk about that internally and we're bring something back on the 18 that'd be good uh one this was we uh there used to be there still is a chair safety planic State risk used to do that they're not going to do that anymore we'll need to charge a fee for that to happen uh and then we're looking at increasing the maximum from 5,000 to 6,000 again you got you got set a per student maximum we don't have very many students yet that we only had two or three or four it's where we get into the cosmetology at

055C that's where the stud did it because it's $3,000 for Cosmo now keep in mind you go out to the private world it's 152,000 so it's a bargain right at ctech but then they start hitting that if they do one other activity or go on one trip you know then they're getting to hit that 6,000 Mark so that's where we're looking to raise that a thousand and this would be more of a policy you know this one the travel that we that we always discuss and we'll just we love TR we love discussing travel there I see the real committee members yeah uh uh we're looking to raise that from 1500 to 2,000 plane fairs are just so expensive and and then if you do the every other year 750 to a thousand again it's

056just so expensive with hotels as well Park tickets that's crazy can I can I just throw a grenade into this discussion um so we talked at at nauseum I don't think we need to argue the merits and the benefits or the issues with whether or not it's the right thing to travel or not but one thing that I think as this continues increased in cost think about is remember in the rule that the districts required the subsidize fee waivers and equalize that across the district so and this is just Rick speaking but we cover that cost the schools don't realize any of that burden so for them when it comes to hey let's go to Florida let's go to it doesn't cost them any so I I've thought a lot about this and Tom we

057haven't had a lot of discussion about this but I think thinking about you know really instead of the pressure being on the board or on the committee to decide each time on any you know any trip that comes at you I I mean it's really hard just being completely honest and transparent here once it gets to the board and you're discussing open board meeting at that point how are you going to say no really to any group because every group has a legitimate reason every group has purpose and reason and they're all great but I think including the high school principls more in that process to have more skin in the game when it comes to actually determining is this really worth the effort and the cost of the trip and if we do this

058we are all going to share in that in those dollars in in the amount that is waved because that that I don't know what number we're up to but we last last year we waved about we it was 6 665,000 we waved about 120,000 of that was travel so it is a getting to be a a significant amount so I'm just saying I think as we think about policy if if I'm a high school principal in there and if I know that I have more skin in the game with my high school partners and colleagues that we really need to evaluate like what trips are worth it or not maybe they're all worth it and maybe in the end they decide you know their recommendation to Tom and Leon is hey these are worth it

059to us and we want to share in those costs but right now that burden falls on the district 100% and and so when it comes to determining whether or not this is the right trip or the best opportunity why not because the district's going to cover whatever on the back end is lost and on top of that we send administrators which we should but you're talking usually at least two APS and a lot of times the principal are out for that time to supervise so they're out of the building should be but that's also time that is on us and and I I'm not saying this isn't an argument to against travel I've always supported it because I know those opportunities are rich but the cost of airfare and you know hotels and all that

060goes along with that I I think maybe more of a shared model something we ought to consider so there's my grenade enough enough said I I appreciate you sharing that Rick and I do think there's a lot of Merit to having those High School principles come together and kind of challenge each other go back and a little bit about which things are really going to enhance a kid's education what isn't um my one concern as I'm thinking about this is how do we make sure and I don't know if anyone has ideas in writing a policy that it doesn't pit the bo against a principal like I don't want a situation where the principles have meaningfully had discussions they feel like okay this is not in the best interest of such and such situation and

061then we still have members of the public that come and Circ and come to us and then we undermine a principle and create controversy or division there where it shouldn't be like where we want our principles to know we have their back so um and that we believe in them and you know their process anyway I just I I mean to me I would just like it to not get to the board that it's really they decide way before I I just I watch you guys go through that every time one of those trips comes up and then and we have you know a room full of parents how do we ever say no to that there's just no way speak to this too um so I have yet to know of a scenario where

062a principal has not wanted their student program to travel it's been the exact opposite what it's been is the principal I've had principles calling me stressed out like this team has has fundraised this money they were invited to this prestigious thing we're not sure now it's going to the appeal committee I have yet I have in my now going on fifth year I've never had a principal saying geez you guys are approving this and I didn't want this student group to go so that scenario is not one that we have encountered yet um you know we have encountered you know as as far as um we have encountered hey we need all of our coaches and all of our club uh leaders of the schools to understand the process to get something approved because they

063don't fully understand that process they don't fully understand what they need to do with the appeal committee and we you know we've needed to work on our communication with you know where it is at in process there's been some miscommunication with that so I think you know this is fraught with a lot of things right and and you know but the bottom line is is um you know we need to we need to provide a a pathway it's a good idea to increase the spending amount because of the cost of travel has gone up um you know I think in the policy as it's written right now it is pretty clear um you know what the stipulations are for travel and you know my experience has been that you know sometimes what when there's been

064a recommendation not to approve it it's because you know there wasn't a a clear understanding of the nature of the you know of the event they were going to and the level of competition so you know and that it was helpful for them so anyway um you know this is something I feel pretty strongly about because there as as you all know there's a lot of Collegiate opportunities and a lot of scholarship opport unities and um you know our students being able to participate in some of these competitions at certain levels is where they get exposure to Collegiate programs and scholarships so um just I want us to be mindful of that right we want to make sure that we're not impeding that I'm not debating the merits I'm just saying the cost is residing

065with the district alone and and having skin in the game you're going to be a lot more thoughtful about yes and I think we've got to look across District to make sure it's Equitable just because one team can fundraise and cover the cost there might be another team that has a lot on fee wavers that the district is covering and so we have to be really careful when we look at that creating equity and making sure all kids have the same opportunities regardless of whether they can fundraise or recover those costs themselves that's that's the policy right there right thank you Mr will item C update of final 2023 2024 land trust and tssp reports by Alice Meredith director of Elementary School principles thank you good to see you all this evening um so as

066we do every year I'm required uh to share final reports of the plans that you approved for for our 23 24 school year both our land trust and our tssp PLS and so on Monday I sent you an email with a link to the repository where we keep all of those plans for you um I'm sure you know you may have some questions as you read through those please feel free to reach out and ask me about those um but we're not going to be approving the final reports because they're not plans they're just reporting out the plans the the U actual uh information from the the final reports so we won't be approving anything tonight um so with that I don't know if you've had a chance to look at any of those or

067you have any burning questions that was the first thing I wanted to discuss tonight I are so were they located in the consent agenda documents is that where they when I looked out for it this morning I couldn't see actually they shouldn't they I had just given them um and I apologize they got put on consent consent is for you to approve and you really don't need to approve so so we'll ask when you adopt the agenda we'll ask you to or when you approve the consent we actually you just P item because you don't need to okay and then the other thing I wanted to bring to your attention so that you're aware this year the state has really cracked down on carryover for all the districts as you are aware um each School

068in each district is responsible for spending down to no more than 10% that can't have any more than 10% carryover we had six schools this year that went over that 10% it was less than 11% so it was less than a percent that they went over um the carryover having said that the state is asking us to do some additional training there's video that's required that our principes watch and some of us at the district level um they are not asking they don't want um they don't they don't want us to report anything back to them per se um they're not going to want to stay on top of this they're asking us as a district um to be mindful to hold our school accountable make sure that that carryover is less than 10% so

069in addition to the training video that we'll be showing the principles we've been gr some ideas around um which I think might help our schools they work so hard to get to that 10% and it can really be difficult because so much of the money they spend is on personnel and as we know Personnel um hourly Personnel sometimes they're sick or they have surgery and they're not able to come to work and it makes keeping track of all those hours uh really difficult when you're trying to spin down to a certain amount by May um so one of the things that we talked about doing was for the the purpose of our district helping our principles to focus on staying at 9% or lower so that we can help support them in keeping that below

07010% in place for the state so again they're not asking they're not monitoring this they're just asking us to be aware the only other thing I'll add is that the carryover this year is required to be spent um if an amendment is needed ask us to put amendments in place the low amount of dollars that are in the carryover don't warrant an amendment and I feel confident that they planned on that 10% carryover for this school year year and they have a good plan for spend that 10% carryover in addition to the monies that they have this year well what's the most we're over was it like one% 108% so and and I will be I'll tell you we had I had the opportunity to look at the state as a whole would carry over

071and certainly there's no excuse for carrying over more than 10% but as things go I think our schools did an exceptional job at sticking to that 10% so question is it could we encourage schools to have some sort of a backup because I know sometimes it is personnel and then you're getting down to those last couple weeks you're like oh we're not going to spend it whether it's technology or something suppli something else that they could then just have that they then they don't have to go through the process of an amendment of just having them put that into your plan as a backup if something happens we're going to use it on this yes and we do have backup plans that we are encouraged in their plans when you get this year's you'll see

072there's a whole section if we have more money than we can spend here is our backup plan the challenge we run into Katie is that at the end of the year putting a requisition in for technology I mean we have a deadline to spend money on equipment and other things so that then is taken out of that equation and makes it more difficult to deal with those alternate plans when these unexpected things things come up so uh the spending it's based on when it's actually purchased as opposed to say when you intend to purchase right so for techology you have a lead time on technology yes that makes sense because because my question was going to be how did we get here for example Glacier Hills sec I know reviews the balance every single month

073um and several of these I imagine have pretty active SC um and so they would be monitoring them pretty closely and I believe all of our schools um have a provision that they're going to spend it on XYZ if they have excess um would you say that the reason is they're trying to carry over and they accidentally carried over more or that they're not spending soon enough I'll be honest I don't think it's that they're spend that they're not spending soon enough I think quite honestly it's a fine balance in those last couple of months between having money left over and spending too much so I think it really comes down to crunch time and looking at what our options are in April when we we've already spent the money we said we were going

074to spend on technology in January and now we're you know we're hoping these people are going to be here to work with us as a principal where I struggled with it Andrew was and it's been a while but so so you set your budget and you encumber these expenses especially for personnel which is is the bulk of it right but then as all said they get sick they take unpaid leave days this and that happens then you get time that the money's actually spent and there's additional funds sitting there but over that much time's passed so what do you do right so it's and and we've you know we're always reminding principles that that's soft money when you pay Personnel out of trust lands there that comes ter right but but trying to understand those

075expenditures in real time when all these variables are at play is it's a trick there's also it's also odd how the state Vates carryover right so you would think a school gets on the put it out there $50,000 you would say 5,000 of that you can carry over that's 10% right the trick is the carryover from the previous year does not go into the 10% so there and gets get into a little bit of the math problem so if you have carried over $110,000 previous year and so your balance is $60,000 your carryover is not $6,000 it's 5100 and that gets into the calculation that you know we're going to try to do better on the accounting end before we submit the final reports on that so that that gets that gets tricky for the

076principles because they're kind of carrying two years of budgets there to track so that's I don't I don't think the state should track it that way but that is how they do it and Je Jeff Jeff Murray and Di team added a new program to the dashboard this year that calculates salaries and insurance really accurately we've never had that before so I think them them adding that component to the dashboard really helpful in in the principles hitting their targets because before we used a set formula for benefits when everybody's benefits were different now we can actually see what the benefits are and this is the first year we that that was a really good addition okay thank you next on the agenda is item D graduation schedule by Dr McKay Robinson a super assistant superintendent

077well good evening uh this is simply a followup to our previous conversation as well as the email that I sent to all of you regarding future graduation dates and locations and from receiving feedback from each of you individually not everyone but several of you thought it'd be best reached out to president schill and just said hey is it okay if we come kind of summarize what was shared and then help us to know what to do moving forward and Tom is here just in case there are additional questions but really what it boils down to is for this school year we'd keep it just as is we wouldn't touch it with alone the 2526 school year um we would have it at UVU and the Maverick Center two being at UVU and three being at

078the Maverick Center you have to move that all to the 28th so it' be all the same day and that's just due to the fact that the locations have scheduled different graduations already and then moving forward starting 2627 we would try and do UVU and Maverick Center all on the same day just no no no all the Maverick Center all at the Maverick Center two days yes thank you gonna say lots of options that we out there so hopefully if we're comfortable with that that's how we'll move forward so there's really no changes to this year and next year other than we would just have to be on the 28th all on the same day and then two sites at two sites s and then moving forward we try to be at the same location

079two days preferably to Maverick Center over two days and as close to the end of the school year as possible or the end of the week for lack of way describing right now we'd have to push it up to the Tuesday and the third it might be Tuesday Thursday right if we did it for the 2526 we could get them Maverick Center this spring of 26 if we did we did them on Tuesday Wednesday but the principes were really hesitant to have graduation the day after Memorial Day they want to keep them all on the Wednesday um the other the other thing that you need to be aware of is spring of 26 we typically try to graduate the day before the last day of school and spring of 26 the only place we could

080get all the V is two days for the last day of school so graduation will be Wednesday then we'll have Thursday last official day Friday there's a little bit of a gap in there I have any conc concern call I have one just for the year where they're at two different locations on the same day the difficulty as those of us that are trying to go to multiple how is that going to work that's going to be difficult the assignments that were made last time you're only one would only be at the one regardless if you went to multiple but are you keeping that schedule for the year when it's UVU and Maverick Center that's was my question yeah so for example let's say that you were going to Corner canyons and they're at UVU

081I'm just making something up and then you were also planning on doing altas who's also at UVU so you wouldn't be to leave you're all at the same location other three okay so when the assignments were all made we made sure that you weren't having to cruise from one in the valley to the other would stay the same for that next year okay great you have concerns okay thank you perfect uh that's it for our study sessions we'll meet again for this meeting in about just under 10 minutes e e e welcome to the business meeting of the Canyon's Board of Education today is February 4th 2025 we are meeting at the district office located at 9361 South 300 East in Sandy Utah we'd like to excuse president shill tonight first item is to approve

082the agenda for tonight February 4th 2025 can I have a motion to approve the agenda I'll make a motion to appr approve the agenda for tonight February 4th 2025 do we have a second I'll second that motion okay we have a motion and a second uh is there any discussion all right seeing no discussion we'll go ahead and take a vote all in favor say I I I all opposed motion carries we will now be led in the Pledge of Allegiance from Brookwood Elementary principal Cory Barrett uh after which we will have school highlights by her as well all right will the audience please rise so vast ready begin I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with

083liberty and justice for all at Brookwood Elementary we are deeply committed to fostering an environment where every student can Thrive academically socially and emotionally our dedicated team of Educators and support staff work collaboratively to ensure that each child receives the personalized guidance they need to succeed at Brookwood we prioritize using student data in to inform our teaching practices by closely monitoring progress we can set targeted goals for our students and adapt instruction to meet their unique needs our social worker provides a safe and supportive space for students playing a crucial role in their well being and contributing positively to the teachers as well the social emotional learning support at Brookwood is truly outstanding helping students build resilience and emotional intelligence in addition Brookwood is committed to restorative practices and creating a positive School environment we

084focus on cultiva cultivating life skills in our classrooms helping students develop into successful well-rounded individuals students have ample support to develop problem solving skills with our attentive team guiding them through relational challenges to promote better attendance we have introduced an mtss 8 who works diligently to encourage students and support families this initiative coupled with oural Team ensures that students are motivated and ready to learn every day our teachers and and staff work cohesively as a team fostering a supportive and collaborative environment that benefits both students and Educators our new instructional coach has brought a positive can do attitude alleviating teacher concerns and seamlessly integrating into our community we have made we have many other incredible staff members who do everything they can to help our students and make Brookwood an amazing place to be our

085speech language pathologist screens all kindergarten and second graders every year which ensures that any concerns are identified and addressed early on our reading interventionists are providing enrichment for students who are excelling beyond their grade level during our skills-based instruction time every student is given the chance to grow and Excel we have two remarkable recess AIDS who ensure that our outdoor time is safe enjoyable and well organized our Junior coach's program in partnership with playworks is flourishing with 110 students making a positive impact during recess and their leadership helps F Foster a fun and inclusive playground experience we take pride in our vibrant parent community that leads various extracurricular activities including the bariton choir math olympiads Opera debate chess club Hands-On science and book blits these programs enrich our students learning experiences and provide opportunities for

086growth beyond the classroom as the principal I am deeply attuned to the needs of our teachers and strive to implement meaningful practices that support their work at Brookwood Elementary we are united in our mission to nurture Inspire and educate each student together we are building a brighter future for every student who watch through our doors thank you thank you principal Barrett and please pass the thanks for the board to your entire staff at Brickwood Elementary for the fantastic job that they're doing we appreciate it all right next on the agenda is recognitions and I will turn the time over to Jeff Haney director of communications thank you vice president edel for the the time to recognize those who have gone above and beyond in their drive to be Canyon strong those who are recognized tonight

087will receive a letter of commendation from both the Board of Education and the superintendency we want to stop and thank everybody who we recognize tonight for doing what they can to show the world what Canyons is all about now we started last week as you can see at the state capital it was the Utah School boards association's visit to the legisl session and to start the day Jordan High's Navy National Defense Cadet Corps performed the flag ceremony at the event you can see here that the cadets look sharp in their uniforms be impressed to those who were at the capital including members of their of our board and administration as you can see in the photo there now Jordan High's presentation of the flag was so impressive and we're proud of the students who are

088working hard in this specialized program now our next honores tonight are are the dancers and the coaches of the Hillcrest High drill team on Friday night Hillcrest drill team affectionally called HD repeated as the state champions in the 4A classification at the Utah High School Activities Association state competition at Utah Valley University they scored the highest points of the night in the military military and the show categories and finished second in the dance category to capture the State Tile tile for the second year in a row and the ninth State title in drill in the school's history so congratulations to HD for again capturing the State title in 4 a drill Canyon school district was well represented at the drill finals the corer canyon charell finished in fourth place overall in 6A and the Brighton

089acadians took fifth place in dance in 5A so congratulations to all of the teams the coaches the parents and all of those kids that put in so much work to become state champions now our next honores are the Corner Canyon cheer squad and we're going to start calling them the corner Queens they may be known as the corner Queens from now on that is the title of the documentary style film that is coming out about the nationally known cheer squad this film is being produced by Varsity TV that's the streaming service of the country's Premier Dance and Cheer production company now the trailer for this film can be seen on the Canyons District social media pages and I believe all the board got a sneak peek at that trailer and it is pretty darn amazing

090we encourage everyone in the community to hop on and take a look at the trailer for the film that will feature Corner Canyon cheer now one of the things that coach Whitney LUN says in this is that yes it's a lot of pressure to go up against the state and the nation's best but that pressure is a privilege we love that spirit that competition that drive congratulations also to the Chargers they finished second overall in the 6A competition of all of the cheer squads they finished first in the dance category and they're also preparing for the national competition coming up in just a few weeks so congratulations to the Chargers they're not just L Instagram stars but they'll be stars of the documentary that will be released later this this uh this month I think

091it is if not just in a few weeks and um good luck at the national competition our next honores are our School nurses and head school nurse in particular that's Jen Gerard pictured right there in the middle this is for a project that helped 40 Canyon students get free eyeglasses last week it was called site Fest it's a mobile event that makes it easy for students who qualify to get glasses now thanks to the work of our nurses who do site screenings in schools and have developed a partnership with organizations like Friends for Sight these eyesight issues that can hinder academic progress are diagnosed and corrected at the event it was held in cooperation with the Murray school district and covered by Fox 13 the students went from retinal cameras to the alien looking devices

092used to determine the shape of lens in their new glasses and this obviously would correct the vision issues that they were experienced experiencing the optometrists and other technicians who at the event volunteered their time a big thanks to Jen and our other School nurses and our entire student wellness services department for all they do to support student health and that includes the mental health and academic advisement of our students we want to offer a big thanks and a shout out to all of the Canyon's counselors to mark this week's National School counseling week now this is an event that is sponsored by the American School Counselors Association this week focuses attention on the contributions of school counselors in our schools and throughout the district and how our schools are stronger and better because of what

093our school counselors do National School counseling week highlights the tremendous impact that our school counselors have in help helping students achieve school Success and plan for a career school counselors are certified experienced Educators with master's degrees in School counseling the combination of this training and experience makes them an integral part of a total education program we rely a lot on our counseling centers when our school communities go through tragedies we rely on them lot when we get to the place where students are applying for colleges and universities and for trade programs we appreciate all of the work that our counselors do we also wanted to give a big shout out to some big names in high school football who gave us their thoughts about Sunday's big game you'll see some photograph of the four who

094participated in this week's connect Canyons podcast that's Corner Canyon coach Eric care coach Casey sutera from Brighton High School a bengle graduate and former NFL player Brian Kel they joined Dr Robbins a four-year quarterback at Southern Utah University to discuss the Super Bowl but more than that how extracurriculars play a big role in how students progress become part of a team develop resilience and build friendships and develop mentors that will last a lifetime we encourage everyone to listen to the predictions Dr Robbins who are you predicting the Chiefs the Eagles the Chiefs yes if you listen to the podcast you'll see that the coaches I'll give the prediction on the game we encourage everyone to tune in to this week's connect Canyons for a discussion not just about the Super Bowl but what about Student

095Activities bring to a student's life now one of the things that we've done in a recent recognition is to note to the contributions of our outgoing purchasing director Gary Hansen we welcome to the role of purchasing director Nancy Webb Canyon's District purchasing power continues to be strong with Nancy's appointment which was recently made by the board of education at a board meeting now she is Canyon's District's second ever administrator over our major shopping list and in an organization like ours that task can be daunting from copy paper to toilet paper computers construction materials and everything in between our purchasing department must follow State procurement laws when we buy or enter into contracts for products or Services nany's leadership role in the uare purchasing Cooperative of about 20 school districts has been vital to securing food

096for lunchrooms at just the right price the Utah cooperative for acquiring resources efficiently was created to give school districts greater bargaining power with Food suppliers and is now drawing interest from even more districts so thanks to Nancy for her contribution so far and we wish her well in this new and vital role as Canyon School District's purchasing director now in the coming days we'll see the start of State competitions in swimming boys and girls basketball boys and girls wrestling we've got teams and individuals who are real contenders in all the winter sports and wrestling alone our student athletes are being Tau talked about as possible State title winners and title Defenders now I counted up just the girls wrestlers who've qualified to compete at the state tournament Jordan has nine Brighton has seven Hill Crest

09710 out to Three Corner Canyon 14 that's just in girls wrestling we have girls basketball boys basketball boys wrestling and swimming coming up We wish all of our student athletes coaches and parents so much luck as they start to chase the championship so vice president edel thank you so much the time for the canyon strong recognitions and we turn the time back to you thank you Mr Haney next on the agenda is Patron comments we don't have any Patron comments so we'll move to item 7 the consent agenda can I get a motion to approve the consent agenda please read the items individually uh and remember to remove item e uh I'll make a motion uh to approve the consent agenda uh item a approval of minutes for January 21st 2025 Item B approval of

098higher inter termination reports item C approval of student overnight travel item D approval of purchasing bids item F approval of Cottonwood Heights cdra Second Amendment item G approval of amendment to superintendent contract for July 1st 2024 to July 3rd 30th June 30th 2026 uh and item H approval of East Sandy Elementary Land Trust tspp Amendment all right is there a second I'll second that motion you've had a second is there any discussion to the motion see no discussion uh all in favor say I I I I all opposed motion passes all right next up we have uh item a and new business long range planning update by Leon Wilcox business administrator thank you vice president edel uh moving right along so I got a couple hours to get through this McKay is excited uh want

099to just uh mention our long range planning committee I want to acknowledge the members on the committee so we have uh board member Dolly board member Pon and vice president edel on the long range planning committee again we separated the Innovation Center into one committee long range into another committee uh appreciate that being separated the last six months or so as we met as a long range has pretty much well has all been The Innovation Center so uh so was good to get back and start talking about some other issues districtwide uh that that we're confronting so again thank you to the three board members also on it is uh Dr Robbins Dr Robinson Kirsten Susan and myself so and they'll we'll have others come as needed as we get through other topics uh throughout

100the year uh we hit on a few key things and I want to just go over those with you here the presentations on board dos and uh you know just looking at the long range of the district and where we see it heading uh the first one is just our student enrollment it's been secret we've been losing students about 30 out of the 30 41 school districts have been losing students uh from the last couple years uh and a lot of that you know if you look at probably the two biggest factors at least for Canyons is housing prices just so expensive to own homes here for younger families and the birth rate the birth rate is also challenged Statewide and it getting to be a challenged National nationally wide if you re some of

101the Articles out there uh so here's this chart I'm going to say it's on my left on the screen behind you uh so the burst number of bursts in our ZIP codes for the last 10 years so you can see in 2014 to 2023 so we get the birth the number of births from the health department a year after the year after the following December so we just got 2023 is in December of 202 24s NE this upcoming December we'll get uh the 2024 amounts but you can see the just the drop there in the birth rate uh you know 30 almost 3,300 in 2014 down to just over just under 2500 this past year Well in 2023 uh it if you were to go back a couple years further you would see it started

102with the the Great Recession in 09 10 11 and it's just really never recovered since then Nationwide and Statewide uh so that's roughly an 800 drop in numbers or or a quarter 25% okay and so if you look going over I've taken what the number of births in each year and then looked at five years later the kindergarten enrollments so keep in mind the birth the school year and the birth year does not always line up so you could so then 2019 we had roughly 2319 kindergarteners enroll in our schools keep in mind some of them were born in 2018 you know in October or November right but it kind of balances out a little bit that that way but that's but you have to take that into into consideration there so you can see

103what I'm going to call it our capture rate uh going over so roughly we capture in that 68% range of ver to you know coming as in incoming kindergarteners 5 years later so you can see in 2020 this this school year uh we have 1930 kindergarteners roughly 67% of the bursts from uh uh 2019 again we put estimates going out you know again using that 68% number how that could look again we do see that continuing to drop that way there uh you can also see it graphically just the number of bursts there was a a a blip you know and we had 60 or 70 more in that 20 from 2018 to 2019 but then a then a drop there so again nothing drives our operations and everything everything we do as much as

104our student enrollments so again we just see it it going down I found this interesting article you could want to copied the link and post it into a browser you could uh this was more looking at it from the college perspective of the decline it was decline of number of eight just 18 year olds there are in the country right now uh it's been long predicted as it said it was you know it was written by a on the college front because a few well not a few but several colleges and I'm talking small colleges you know a thousand or 2,000 students have actually shut down throughout the country just because of the number of 18 year olds or the lack thereof so this year next this year and I say the next one or

105two years they expect to hit the peak of 18 year olds in America and then it will start dropping you can see it dropping down there uh so it's really for the college perspective in the fall of 26 or in that class of 26 you can see quite a drop from about 4 and a half million down to 4 million 2032 33 range there's another drop that is when Utah is expected to start hitting that drop as well so Utah will be in that fa next phase down out to you know to see where 240 is so you look at roughly over 6 700,000 you're 18 year olds they're looking at how that impacts the economy you know long term so it's a so it's really a global I mean a national and a global

106issue to read some of the Articles out there on the decline of just a declining birth rate uh going to go back and focus on our enrollments uh here for the last five years so I'm always going to use the October one counts that's where we get our funding from okay we do counts every month but I'll always use October one so you have their last five years including this year on October one and what we projected out the next five years as well I should note that you know we feel pretty good about the 25 26 27 20 eight years but you start getting out four and five years you know it gets less little less reliable you know because more variables comeing to play so we you know I won't probably Focus too

107heavily on those far two columns but know that there will be some you know but we do feel pretty they're probably not going to be as low as we're showing them but they're probably not going to be a whole lot higher either so just to keep that in in mind again this is for our elementaries elementary schools uh few of them I just want to point out here uh you know you look at Brookwood of course we had Corey here Cory's still here she stepped out but uh you can look at where they were 447 5 years ago down to 359 this year again a steady decline there uh I'll bring up Carper viiew another one roughly 390 down to 310 roughly and still dropping there uh a lot of these are in the East

108Sandy kind of bench Area Granite another one you know close to 400 five years ago 314 this year and then a still a decrease ironic Bell Vesta which has been one of our historically been our smallest School actually we're predicting slight increases going forward there in that school uh where my boys went o h you can see they were at six close to 650 at one time now down about 490 you know where I live it's just you know just not a whole lot of young children there and other parts other ones qu Hollow uh Sprucewood wellow Canyon so you can see just the the decline in many of our schools right now we had 10 schools based on the October one count that had under that 370 students there uh so that's a big

109concern going forward with our elementary enrollments and how do we support and sustain these schools again lots of factors factor into home prices interest rates uh now homeschooling gter schools as well as Utah fits Hall scholarships all these have an impact uh middle schools and high school secondary schools it gets it gets better because you know we've found that some parents will choose to you know do homeschooling for a few grades in elementary school then bring their child you know for middle school and high school having a 13y old at home I can see that I don't know why you want a 13 year old on home all day right uh I love you though Zach so just remember that uh but just uh uh and also you know as kids get older families get

110older they usually have a little bit more income and you know maybe look at a home sometimes in our area you know that we do see that a lot but you can see where our middle schools 5 years ago roughly 8,000 down near a little over 7,300 this year we don't see a huge drop for the next few years again that far right column lots of lots in play there but I would caution the biggest drop probably is in the albian area again that's where Granite Brookwood qu Hollow all feed into you know some of those elementaries we talked about uh pretty stable at Butler we do see a decrease at Draper park again hul Hollow feeding into there as we talked about Eastmont we think we've pretty much hit the you see actually we're

111showing some possible increases there we think we're pretty much stable there inding hills pretty stable as well we do expect to get more in mid Vil with as the uh Bluff develops out out there by the Zion Bank processing center and Union Mount Jordan staying fairly stable moving forward as well uh looking at our high schools again we do expect to be more stable there again we get a lot back from Charter Schools most of the charter schools around us are K8 so some will come back for middle school that's a part of the drawback and also high schools we we pick up those eighth graders who live in a lot of them in the Draper area but in other parts again return to us for high school because you know the charter school does

112not have that uh option at least in within the boundaries of the district so uh you can see again we're at a pretty much a peak of high schooler students this year just 11,400 again all they're all full uh even Jordan's up which we like to see and you can see our projections going out pretty stable up most of them increase at Hill Crest mainly again because of the Bluffs being built out there Corner we do see a drop I don't think it will be as bad because they do have a pretty good weight list this does take in these projections take in permits you know kids going in boundary and also permits but it you know we don't quantify a weight list if you will because that's we you know we don't know who

113will take a permit we don't think it will be that bad as it does draw from other districts but again some of the Draper area aging out as well we do see issues there so you can see where those numbers fall out there for our high schools so again uh just you know that's uh this decline in enrollment something that we're going to have to confront in how we want to handle that moving forward uh going to talk now move completely to a different topic we're going to talk about our debt one of the things we talked about is you know we know we have we've done lots of improvements to our secondary schools and some elementaries but we also have elementaries we haven't done improvements to and how do we look at what are

114some of the options we can look at doing improvements there so we look at our current debt structure this is our outstanding debt I'm going to disregard the one on the right we'll come back to that later but this uh on a refunding structure but you can see counting this year in the next four years our debt is about 45 million just a touch over $45 million starting in 2030 it drops down to about 40 million then about 36 in 2031 then even lower there going out in into 2032 and down uh Holly did you have a question Miss SAR yes I'm sorry to interrupt I just had a question because these are two totally different topics can could we possibly address if we have any questions regarding enrollment before before we move into this

115other topic would that be yeah how do we feel about that would that be all right just because I know they're correlated but they're also different enough that my mind is still thinking on some things about the population so um just a couple of questions that and requests um I remember the presentation we had last time regarding that these um predictions and like you talked about the waiting list is not accounted for because we don't really know how to quantify that and I know there has been some difference um actually in some schools I represent elementary middle and high of what was projected versus what was enrolled this year actually every single one of my schools except one um the actual enrollment was more than what was predicted and so I'm wondering if as a

116request that we take a look at that as well when we're looking at predictions because I I think one thing we are finding is that things are a little more unpredictable than they used to be for example like uh Willow Springs that elementary school has a um a lot more high density housing that's gone up um and typically in the past um we had a prediction of what we believed would be true as far as school aged children in high density housing although now that is not really the case we're finding there are more school-aged children in high density housing and with consideration of what we just talked about with what's going on with legislation and property taxes I think that's one message that we need to be clear about um the way that that's

117aggregated with property tax there's an expectation and and anticipation that there aren't going to be school-aged children when in fact there are school-aged children and many times those school-aged children that are coming into our boundaries that weren't predicted that are coming after uh We've already started school also require additional services like they may be multilanguage le Learners or have IEPs or 504s or those types of situations so when we're looking at student enrollment I think it might be good to see in comparison because I kind of and I've talked to Dr Robbins about this too the landscape is changing right we one thing we've learned is it's a little bit more difficult to predict um I think right that's kind of across the board we've had um multiple schools that have ended up with a

118little more than what was anticipated after school started and that's changing because it used to be once enrollment happened there wasn't as much change and there's more CH is that correct I would say in your schools there was yes at areas of the district we had the exact opposite we actually had fewer students than we projected and that's a great Point too so I would love when we're looking at long rrange planning and we're trying to pull together our resources and what we have building wise and planning and providing for the children that are coming I think it'd be uh important to see the difference of what was anticipated this last year and then what was the reality if that could be something we address we could pull what we Pro what we projected and

119what they actual work that would be awesome and maybe something good for the committee to look at as well overall we projected more students than we got districtwide now it varies by school but yes we did project more than we actually got yeah yes overall we did and then there's little pockets you do have the PO yeah and then um so that brings me to another question when we're looking at school enrollments we have a few different things going on right we have some waiting lists for certain schools um maybe based on reputation and different programs offered correct um and then we also need to look at you know why in some circumstances we actually had less enrolled than we thought we would right whether that's due to Alternative some of it's birth rate right

120but is some of it you know when we look at strategic enrollment is some of it parent choice um different uh reimbursements through voucher programs or um charter schools and private schools so um is that something the rest of the board would be interested at looking at when we're looking at um projections and enrollment Miss hes sorry I'm sure this is something that the superintendent would like to probably weigh in on I know when we've talked about this in Long Range planning and Kirsten and Jeff have done a lot of leg work on this trying to get information the difficulty is is that we don't always have access to that data and I think I mean we can ask them to and requests out of them but I think it's very difficult because a lot

121of like if a parent is choosing to utilize the voucher Bill and go to a private school they don't necessarily announce it to the district like there's a lot of reconnaissance and guest work attached to that so I don't know how accurate the numbers would be I don't know maybe um Dr Robbins would want to speak to that yeah I mean we we have some of the raw data cs's already collected so at some level we can you know we can display that and demonstrate you know students coming in and going out but it it's not not totally accurate but it does help kind of paint a picture when we uh the state asked us to do a an enrollment in absentee I think I've told you about this this past fall uh we found

122about 300 Stu the states asked us to send out the survey run to around 300 parents uh to you know ask them questions on why their student wasn't enrolled in a in a public school the state got the results I don't know how many responded you know we we could track 300 parents or students who were enrolled on our schools one year but not and it goes back two years I think even three years who were rolled our schools at one time but not now based on a home affidavit that actually was based on the home affidavits that we got so we sent those out I don't know the response rate because it went the information was clear it was going straight to the state not to us so that you know I don't just

123to comment on that too Leon there's a bill this year that actually makes the affidavit even less less yeah so so so the ability for districts to track that is going to become even more difficult just hard we don't get information on you know I've been asked a couple times how many students were here last year who got a scholarship a UFA we don't know that because no one tells us that information uh so that's the state tracks that and they don't provide that so I yeah so we got all kind yeah it's a little different world as you said uh we'll have uh Miss doy so noticing that we have this these uh elementary schools that are getting pretty small at what level of population do we start to lose an effective School culture

124and environment in these elementary schools because it it's a big deal going from you know going from four classes to three classes isn't as big a shift in a class size when all of a sudden you're going from three to two all of a sudden your class size is balloon and and FTE is short and it It's Tricky I I'm been on the SEC for a number of years at Granite which is one of these schools and and seen those issues I I don't know if there's a magic number I it does get harder class size with smaller schools you would think it may get easier but actually it easier FTE works out easier at bigger schools because then if you have 60 per grade do you 60 second graders do you look at three

125classes of of uh of 20 or two of 30 well we would almost go with three of 30 of 20 fifth grad Reser we probably go with two of 30 and that's where you start getting into this this this FTE issues that we've discussed in other meetings in the past uh so I I can't say what the magic number is I think as a committee we're going to try to look at that and see bringing others McKay I don't know if he would know he's a former principal but so we've talked about this a little bit before but the realities are when those numbers drop to that point then you you know and we've had to do this in some cases is split classrooms that's one way uh to address it uh We've also talked

126about in the past we've absorbed some of the class siiz issue with the cushion um but in the environment we're in that is very thin right so so that then Falls onto the board whether or not to raise taxes to try to maintain that and maintain enrollments where they're at or an unpopular option is to evaluate enrollment after October 1 and look at obligatory transfers you know that late in the school year you can only imagine a family being impacted by a new teacher in you know a couple of months into school some districts do that we've worked really hard not to do that but but you know these realities are becoming more and more difficult yeah and it's it's harder you know with the programs we offer with DLI is a big example you

127have the red class blue class 28 in each one but then you don't have you your neighborhood classes could be larger or smaller we're finding that at several schools right now that's a that's a a Troublesome issue so all these you know and all are no special units that we have in our schools also contribute to the capacity not so much the enrollment but the capacity on how the building's used and what the programs are there so a followup to that what is our cost on average for a year to run an elementary school not not counting in a a teacher salary because kids are going to have teachers but Administration and just the capital cost of running a building yeah so the operation cost we C you know we figure this up and I

128know you were not at at a we brought this to the board oh a year or so ago it was it's close to a million dollars in part of its a chunk of its utilities and a chunk is it maintenance and keeping the building upkeep upkept the other part is just Personnel you know the pr the fixed cost and the Personnel you know I'm using the principal the secretary the custodian uh the achievement coach and some of the some of the uh the AIDS so you get close to a million dollars to a fixed C what we call fixed cost operate a school so that's where you get into this efficiency uh dynamics of operating these smaller schools yeah Miss Oaks okay so to bring um you up to speed um Miss Dolly and um

129also Mr Lewis so there's a bit of history with um declining enrollments with elementary schools and how that stands with local school boards so um I don't know how many years ago it was that the state did an audit of Salt Lake School District and found that some of their lower enrolled elementary schools should have been closed and based off of their audit they felt that their District had wasted funds by keeping them open and that they needed to close them and after that they did taking lesson from that Alpine School District similarly had schools like that on their east side of their District they um proceeded according to what the state had laid out as the process and in doing so there were um parents from those areas that raised Cain for lack of

130a better um term like and contacted their legislators and the IT raised so much craziness that they actually you know even though these board members were operating out of good faith based off a precedent from the state of what they felt they were supposed to do they were actually subpoena to come up and testify in front of the state legislature and were berated so it has the rest of us local Schoolboard members wondering what are we supposed to do it's still not very clear um I am not opposed to the idea of discussing like you know as we move forward understanding what to do whether it's combining School communities or whatnot but I do know whatever we do if if we proceed with that we have to get some clarity I think from our legislators

131and understand that we have to proceed with caution and be above board or we're going to be in the same position as Alpine School District the other thing I just really want to Quick want to address um to miss nar's point about knowing you know where our students are going what their choices are like with strategic enrollment um one of the difficulties we have and and I know that there is discussion at at the legislature about creating some fixes to the voucher bill or the Utah fitall scholarship one of those major fixes that we need to be advocating for is more transparency as I have said and I'm going to say it again for the public to hear the state legislature is putting millions and millions of dollars into a program that none of us

132have access to the information of how it's being spent they have identified a private entity out of the state of Colorado to administer that bill and none of us can even Grandma to understand how it's being spent so we cannot even get information even if we requested it about what is happening and whether or not the students that are receiving that money are the ones that are described in the bill that it is zero transparency so I know that that bothers some of our legislators I know it bothers a lot of citizens and that is something that as Schoolboard members we need to continue advocating for Miss Pon I just want to add to that conversation as we were discussing on the uh committee that I need the public to be aware that none of

133these things that we're beginning to discuss with right now are happening like tomorrow um when we say longterm planning we're we're talking two three four five 10 years out but we want to have a specific Runway that we know what's going to happen and what we need to look at and address each year and now that we've separated The Innovation Center from the long-term planning committees we are going to be working on that in the next little while because all the options are are available but we don't have the criteria established for what step would happen when so at this point no one needs to worry that their school is going to be closed but know that using the data that we have financially that may have to happen we may have to have those

134hard discussions about um possibly closing schools which would probably be our last Choice um but we may have to look at some boundary changes which are never popular um we always look at our program placements and some of the program placements may have to change or be split up or I don't know we we don't know we have not discussed it to the point where we're ready to say this is what will happen but we are looking at that and we're getting that information I think just knowing the trends right right now is enough information I don't think we have to know this school got more and this school got less because overall it boils down to pretty much the same Trend and that when we get down to specific decisions on specific schools then

135we will look at specific information but I think it's premature to ask for information that a we don't have access to and be I don't think it would change any of the decisions that are going to be coming down the line yeah uh to your if I may just to Amanda and to Karen's Point uh because of the Alpine issue that happened uh a couple years back the legislature last session a year ago did pass out a process that you have to follow if you change boundaries or close a school uh there's certain notice requirements that have to go out and when you have to start and you have to be completed by December 31 if you're going to close it for the next fall so you can't part of alpines is they kind of

136let it go till April May and no one told anybody but you have to have it by uh December 31 now that being said they've expressly said that the purview to change boundaries or to close schools solely rest with a local board the legislature has not weighed in on that I don't think they will they might at some point because you know this is kind of a Statewide issue but uh the last last little while they have left that solely they have stayed out of that and made this clearly a local issue moving forward they just set out the process of the the dates you have to meet Miss SAR I really appreciate the questions that Miss doll asked um those are questions we do need to be asking um you know we we sometimes

137we have to make hard decisions I do want that data I do think it's very important it drastically impacts our students and their education we had in one of the elementary schools I represent 64 new students that we were not they weren't accounted for or planned for um we just participated Dr Robbins and I and Miss peton in a listening tour at that elementary school it is no exaggeration to say um they need oxygen and they need it now they're in a very um you know very difficult situation with with um students with additional needs and you know uh my my son in his first grade class his you know his first grade teacher has a staggering enrollment number it's it's it's five more students than she's ever had ever in first grade it's you

138know when you have 34 plus kids in your first grade class it impacts these kids and we have amazing teachers and she's doing a fantastic job but but we do need to look at we do need to understand a little better what's happening with the trending so we can try to prepare um our schools and equip them with enough FTE with the additional supports that they are they need you know when you're looking at an elementary school where the actual percentage of students under the special education umbrella has doubled in the last few years that drastically impa impacts kids and so I think it is important the one thing we may not we we may not know why you know parents are choosing necessarily to to go to different schools but some of these predictions

139as far as um looking at I think looking at what predicting factors we have been using and then looking at what actually has happened I do think that that is important for long range planning to look at uh you know it sure would help our boots on the ground our teachers and our administrators in those schools um you know we have two different situations here we have some schools where we've predicted that they're going to have a certain number and they're having more than and then you know we have some schools you know where the population is 212 children and you know if you look at whole child needs there um when you are in a Grade that possibly only has two teachers and you're just in the same cohort all all the way up

140through the grades you know sometimes that that can be difficult for kids to you know learn some of those important social skills of mingling with um different kids and and being accepting and inclusive and you know there's a lot that plays into that um as well as um M what she pointed out with the expenditures that we spend every year on maintaining um I'm not I'm not I'm not here to advocate for necessarily closing schools um but I do think that we would be remiss to not look at this and say 10 schools under 370 students is something we need to really think about and really look at addressing and I think what we saw happen with Glacier Hills that was pretty amazing we had two communities come together and blend into a elementary school

141and it's been an amazing experience so we you know obviously that was a brand new school and and very exciting but I think if we go back to what is best for kids um we need to we we may need to be making some hard decisions and look at Creative Solutions of helping you know what's going on but I do think it is definitely worth a greater ask and a greater dig for the long range committee to look at and I think you know Echo year some of these are long range and other of these are part of our Strate strategic plan and other committees you know when you look at placement of programs and operating costs so all that roles in as well so so um I'll make a comment then too um I

142think it's important to note that uh we're really emphasizing the long range and the long range planning committee as we're going into it um and I think it's fair to look at our historical margin of error uh when we're looking at our projections I think I think that's fair uh there's lots of things we can't predict but I think the important thing to remember is that this is long range and so as we look at this we're not looking at uh what do schools need next year or the year after we're looking at uh what what does our school situation look like in five years 10 years 15 years and Beyond um we've even discussed some ideas on how to capture that and how to make sure that we're constantly looking at that um but

143as we are refocusing just know that we've had one meeting so far um and we hope to bring back a lot and hopefully will generate some robust discussion um but nothing that this committee brings uh anytime soon should have an immediate impact um it'll have plenty of time for people to weigh in not only other board members but the public at large um having been a parent in the uh Belleview and then Glacier Hills Community uh it hits home to me when we talk about making big changes um and to make sure that we do it correctly um and to make sure that we're transparent about it uh and to make sure that the community understands um what we're thinking and how we're proceeding so continue on um having said that I really appreciate that

144and this is the only committee that really looks at the enrollments and and predictions um and and so it would be great if there's some further um concerns or questions for making sure schools in the next year if if long range can refer it to operations or whatever committee um you know for a future for more shorter term okay any other we'll switch back to a different topic here or again our outstanding bit debt this is our Geo bonds want to just emphasize the red is from our bond election in 2010 or blue is from our bond election in 2017 okay so we have to pass those two bonds uh you can see as I said I'm just going to look at the current one right now come back to the proposed later but the

145current we start it stays constant up through 2029 dips down in 2030 dips down in 2031 and there you can see it layer off till till it goes the idea would be you know we we' build in a plan of how do we want to address this moving forward do we want to you know as far as meeting the needs the capital needss of the district uh there's a couple options here I'm going to come come back to this slide here uh do we look at a a general obligation election uh you know again we passed two Bonds in 2010 barely that was barely that was just over 50% 2017 we passed a bond is about 58% when you you do a go bond election you have to do it with the general election in

146November part of borrowing money though as you borrow or buy a house or something you incur interest cost and that can be a lot of money there so with a bond okay uh the positive things is you can complete things a whole lot quicker you know we in 2010 was a mandate from our community then that we fix some of the schools that Jordan had not you know Jordan was chasing growth out west and not fixing the schools here and there was a mandate that we start fixing the schools here from the community and that's what we did and and when we passed that bomb we started Corner Canyon and Butler and albian and Midville middle I mean Midville Elementary all the same time and got them going all at once uh and same thing

147in 2017 you know Alta hrist and Brighton going all at once uh so that's that's a positive with the a bond but the offset is the interest cost uh should be noted that sjr2 Senate resolution uh uh that's from the legislature says that if they're making a proposal that uh to go to the voters and change the constitution in November of 2026 that a bond election instead of getting 50% now has to get 60% that should be noted that did pass the Senate today on its first reading again how it goes with the Senate the other two readings and then the house the governor I don't know then how it goes with the voters I don't know when I listened to the committee it was interesting most of the comments were against this proposal you

148know they didn't want it put out there but it still P it still went through so again how that looks going forward but that's something to consider if you have to try to pass a bond getting 60% of the vote that that could be a challenge again we haven't done that in the last two but other districts Salt Lake and maray this past November did they did get over 60% in their bond elections another option is do what we call pay as you go you know you you build up income go build the building couple years later build up more income go build the building or do a major remodel or something like that it pay as you go then that's positive because you do not incur all the interest expense the negative with down

149that is you just it just takes longer to build them out you have to have a 10 15E plan there you could also look at a combination of lease revenue bonds and a pay as you go kind of structure that out where you pay off these Bonds in maybe four or five years so you're not going out far and incurring a lot of interest expense that way but gives you a little bit of leeway and getting some more projects going as a committee we looked at maybe a pay as you go with the least Revenue Bond was probably the best our option we just don't know if we're ready for another goo bond election in the next two years or even longer but uh that was our initial thoughts unless Karen or Andrew thought thought

150differently but that was our consideration as well it should be noted that you know we've done a lot of buildings and they're in great shape now but you know in 20 you know another dozen years or so I'm specifically looking at Cor Butler Midville Elementary you know they're going to need some upgrades you know in 10 years as far as the like the roof the H vac parking lots flooring things of that nature so that's something that's also going to be out there as far as maintaining the the the debt so you know our proposal would be to keep it tax neutral to the you know the taxpayers is as this de rise lows off we would increase our Capital debt again keeping it new neutral to the taxpayers or maybe even a little bit

151lower if you will and then use that money for ongoing expenses and every two or three years look at building a building or doing lease revenue bonds and going out there that way that would require you though to build out some plan that's over 10 12 15 years and you know future boards could adjust it as needed but that's that's what we were looking at there so again that's just high level looking at the you know as we still have a few more years of this higher debt but looking at options longer term uh one option that we' like to switch in Gears here is we do have bonds that we issued in 2015 that are now eligible to what we call refunding similar to a home refinance we've done this three different times in

152the past uh in the last couple years those of you have been with us uh it's where you just refund a bond or refinance a bond for lower interest rates what our option would be here is looking at again this possible refunding structure is we would take the last two years off those red lines there in 2032 and 33 and move them forward and pay them in 20 30 and 2031 okay uh the net effect of that is that shortening that time frame saves us about 850,000 in interest cost depending on interest rates we ran the numbers right after the holiday break it was 800,000 couple weeks back it was gone up to 850 so it's going to be what rates are when you hit the market you still have closing costs there but still

153savings you know a decent amount of savings there uh as I said it would complete that 2010 Bond two years earlier uh it does provide you more flexibility in 2032 you can see a bigger drop off there in your debt starting in 2032 with that the con would be you would not have as much drop off in 20 31 and uh excuse me 2030 and 2031 doing this route uh but that all being said it seemed to be the committee I'm gonna correct me if I'm wrong that we do go ahead and look at this proposal this would be if we want to go with this we'd have to bring it back to the board we as you've done in the past whenever we issue bonds usually two readings uh Pro your parameters and we'd

154go to the market we could probably accomplish it by April or May is the the time frame on that so that's there's one thing that we want to put out there as well moving forward uh the next thing again we on our agenda to look at is the whole thing and that is the next thing is building conditions of these main these elementaries that haven't been rebuilt the capacity then the small Capital process the needs of these going forward and what we can do to make sure we keep them going because you know again this is a long-term process we got to keep these buildings going our new ones are in great shape they're good for several years but some of these smaller one these other elementaries got to make sure the parking lots roofs

155HVAC all those issues there and then also we brought it up the process not not see we do it but the process for possible boundary and school consolidations again we'd have to meet at a minimum the state rule but we'd want to go above and beyond that as far as communicating that out so there's where we're at on our again we've only met once appreciate the committee members and uh with that I'll turn it back to you for president vice president Ed for any questions or comments have any questions all right so if it's okay we'll look at bringing back I don't know if it'll be the April 18th or into March the process to going through of refunding these bonds okay and then we' probably want to get on probably more of a rotating

156schedule to bring updates back to the board we' want to look at our predictions and where we're at there and everything like that so thank you Mr Willcox all right next on the agenda we have staff comments I'll turn the time over to superintendent Dr Dr sorry technicar it's okay Dr Robbins thank you vice president edel uh real quick just want to give a shout out to our counselors as Jeff mentioned National counselor's week um and just as we talked earlier in study session you know uh thinking about all of the different issues and parameters with the school safety bills but just keeping a focus on mental health and relationships and the great work that our student services department uh does you know each and every day and I think you know one thing that

157that I'm proud of is the fact that coming out of the pandemic that we really held true to providing Direct Services to students we're not perfect we still have a long way to go but but when you're thinking about you know needs when it comes to mental health or physical health um psychologists and social workers and nurses uh and our counselors just the critical role uh that they play in making sure our students needs are met and when they come to school that you know that that all of those things are in place because you know learning is secondary especially you know if you've got other issues going on as a young person that you're you're trying to work through so just appreciate the board's support and the fact that uh we recognized our counselors

158uh tonight uh is important so I want to give them a shout out and thanks for all they do thank you Mr Wilcox I've talked enough tonight but just want to give a shout out to CTE month as well uh appreciate all our CTE teachers for all they do and you know it's great to see so many kids being able to whether it's our cosmetology program or welding program Home Building program these kids having that pathway upon gradu ation to go get really a livable wage and a livable job it's great to see so big thank you to all our CTE teachers at the tech center and in our high schools uh preparing our students so thank you to all them that's all all right next up we have board comments and tonight we get

159to start with Miss nepper okay um first off I wanted to thank um our teachers and our administrators um as I mentioned before Dr Robbins and miss peton and I were able to participate in uh a listening to her at Willow Springs Elementary and um a lot of things came out of that meeting um and I just I I want to First publicly just any any teachers that are watching this meeting to know that um absolutely that one of one of the comments that was mentioned by a teacher was that they feel that um as a teacher you can um form you can communicate what's going on in your classroom and some concerns but the teacher felt that until parents were notified and then parents talked to others then maybe something is done and and

160you know that was heartbreaking for me to hear uh because absolutely absolutely if if there's issues going on and you you don't feel like you know it's it's being addressed I I absolutely want teachers to feel like um you know that they can reach out to uh you know there's many different resources that the district has available as well as myself and um I think that we have a few things going on right now um in our schools and I think that this will this will this pattern will continue and I think we need to um be really proactive about how we're going to address some of the changing landscape that we're seeing and um and I think that it would be great to have different committees look at that in our committee work another

161thing that was brought to my attention this last week and to some of the rest of us was um some concerns with the registration cards at at the middle school level and um I would really submit that our board be interested in looking at um course offerings and what we can do and which committees it needs to go to but as we're working um to follow through with our strategic plan we need to be careful that in the meantime we aren't having less options for our students and that is is something that that is a that is happening in fact um I'm meeting with some parents um later this week about that so I think we need to make sure like the success criteria under the high quality learning we need to make sure that

162we're providing Pathways and securing Pathways for all Learners to achieve success and to be challenged and to reach you know their potential so I'd be very interested in us requesting that on the agenda to take a really good look at at what's going on um and um another thought that I have is that we I've been thinking a lot about strategic enrollment I really appreciate the work that Kiren and Jeff have done and I'm wondering how we can um better access that information whether they need to join um um you know maybe access an opportunity to do a presentation whether which which committees that we can um take a little deeper dive into into that and you know as as often is the case with our topics lots of times there's um there's kind of

163this area where the topic merges into you know different areas like when we're talking about helping our schools be prepared for what's happening with the population shifts you know that's a that's a operations but that's also an access and opportunity right to ensure that our students are able to participate and have um access and opportunity to programs and so I think I think that goes hand inhand with strategic enrollment I see there's a few different committees that we could really benefit from hearing a little more about the work that you've done there and I I'm very very interested in that just um as a as an aside um clearly you know as Amanda pointed out it's very difficult with the UT fit all scholarship not being able to have the transparency to see exactly what's

164happening there um you know I have been um now you know um in in our private orthodontic practices for 13 years and there for sure certainly um I am seeing a difference in fluctuation as far as you know B we have a lot of adults but mainly this is you know a lot of adolescence and children that are getting braces and and to see the difference of how many students are coming in in uniforms or from private schools or from Charter Schools or a different alternative Choice than the public school and and we can see that trending in in different respects and so I think we just need to be very careful we need to protect the pathways we need to make sure that we're doing a good job of listening to parents as far

165as hey I don't really feel like my students needs are being met with the maybe it's the course offerings we have um back when Wendy da was um uh here and and shairing ing a committee we were really looking at preap classes and um other programs to get kids involved at an earlier level for um some Advanced course offerings and I think that we just it we would really benefit to look at that a little more further so I request that that other board members consider that for a future agenda and um I'm just very grateful for all the great work that's being done um I was I was I heard the Battle of the Bands I was actually at the basketball game at the same time it was happening but I heard it was

166a great success and that was a a special thing at Corner Canyon and then also I have had so many people come up to me and talk about the Lunar New Year celebration I know Miss Oaks um you know actually her daughter was a was such a big part of that orchestration organization but I just had so many great um comments and feedback about that so I just think that's wonderful that that happened and and I also think um what a great opportunity for our kids to learn and grow as they organize events like that so um just very proud of her and and her fellow students who helped her in that effort and for what a great success it was so um at Christmas time my family my some of my children and I

167we went to a little event and it was it was um it was a little there was um like a coat drive and a can drive and a way you could donate and then there were little various activities um there and it was an amazing event the only sad part is there wasn't very many people in attendance sometimes that's the most difficult thing is there's really great plans that have been enacted and I felt so sad because they had all of this food that they you know and there weren't very many people participating so sometimes that's half the battle and congrats to those kids because there was great attendance at that activity that's all I have for tonight thanks thank you Mr Lewis all right uh I had the opportunity to attend canyoning this last

168week at Hillcrest High School uh I uh had the opportunity not just to uh go around uh and talk to everyone at the booths but also I stayed for a couple of classes afterward uh I really really appreciated the uh information that they had on ecigarettes and vaping uh I know that was an issue that was very very prant prevalent when I was in high school um I I have one thought about that other uh it was a great program I'm glad we have it uh maybe updating some of the resources on it uh I from my own experience I'm not a Vaper uh I do know that the predominant use of vaping devices isn't Jewel pods anymore and that's kind of what the the a lot of that presentation was about maybe just a

169little bit more updating on that I also attended the school safety presentation by uh Brian McGill uh which was amazing um um uh just more thoughts on canyoning maybe moving it to the closer to the beginning of the school year I don't know why uh I don't I don't know why I don't know the background of why it's in the middle of the school year I don't know anything about that um and also maybe food trucks I don't know just a thought I have a lot of thoughts about cany earing um we uh we also spent some time on Capitol Hill this last week and met uh with some some of our Representatives had some great conversations about the safety bill uh I worked on Capitol Hill last year so it was uh a great

170opportunity to go back and see some of the folks I used to work with last year like the some of the the older gentlemen who guard the Senate chamber they they stopped me as we were walking by that was a great a great uh a great throwback for me uh and also just wanted to shout out the uh Hillcrest drill team for their state champs that was great great job guys uh always glad to see the Huskies Thrive so that's all I've got thank you Miss Oaks thank you yeah so um one of the highlights for me the last couple of weeks is ala high school ALA High School had an entire Multicultural week which included having um booths that featured different cultural clubs and ethnic backgrounds and and then they finished off the week

171with an assembly on that Friday morning that was phenomenal this is a fairly new um Tradition at ala but an awesome one and it was so great to see everything from Native American presentations Polynesian dances South Asian dancing it was so great and the sense of Pride and community that it created was incredible I I was so happy to be there um I love the USB day on the hill I got to see one of my elementary schools firstwood elementary up there with their fifth graders and um and to attend an innovation Center um meaning it's it's really wonderful to see plans come together for the Innovation Center and those some of those um thoughts and ideas will be coming to the board at large here soon and to Echo what Miss dibra was saying

172the Battle of bands at Corner Canyon was awesome so much fun um some of it like was more crazy than others but it like the kids were having such a good time and I was amazed actually how many adults were there too and the lunar new New Year celebration was indeed a an incredible highlight it's actually I want to thank Kristen um for all of her help with that um even though my daughter did organize that event I literally I had nothing to do with it and I totally turned it over to her and she'd asked me questions and I'd say talk to Kirsten I mean it was and Kiren was a huge support and I would say I mean we had decent advertising but for what we sent out like I cannot believe the

173community response I would say easily we had 14 to 1500 people there I've never never seen the auditorium that full before and the exuberance and joy I wish you guys could have been there we had they had a panel of kids from first grade all the way up to juniors in college that have been through DLI and my daughter asked them what's something you love about learning Chinese and it was so wonderful to hear their perspective and even to the college junior who said I've attended College in Taiwan I'm using this in my career I'm getting a minor in these are all the things I'm doing and and then for all of those kids the high school kids and even like down to little first graders singing the same songs and dancing together it was

174electric and I have had so many parents come to me and say that was such a wonderful Community experience and my younger kids are so excited looking at the older ones saying look this is what I have to look forward to this is awesome like they felt a part of something so I just want to reiterate especially as there's a bill currently being proposed um that would eliminate the protected funding for D and kind of turn it over to a general fund question to the districts and and I think it actually siphons up more money for the charter schools I have a lot of concerns about that because we're handed so many unfunded unfunded mandates including um things like the safety bill and when you don't have protected funding for things like DLI or for

175the Arts um BTS was recently pulled out of that bill but it was on The Chopping Block for a long while we stand to lose a lot um and I would just um submit that we really like if we have the opportunity to talk to our legislators about that and why it means something we need to do that and I this is also to encourage members of the community if anybody hears this please contact your leg your legislators tell them what those programs mean to you and your family I've encouraged my daughter to go up and talk to them in a Committee hearing when it comes up and to also write her legislators and maybe send some pictures of what happened on Thursday night it's pretty palpable example of how powerful some of these programs

176can be for our our kids in our communities and families so anyway thank you so much thank you Miss Dolly first of all I want to start by thanking our teachers our admin our facilities workers our support staff thank you for what you do um some days your job may feel very thankless but what you're doing is critical in the lives of our students and so we just want you to know that we appreciate all the work you're doing each and every day the listening tours have been um excellent to be able to attend I appreciate the teachers that are willing to say something sometimes that can be hard in a big group setting but if we don't know these things we can't fix anything so thank you for speaking up and sharing your concerns

177and so that we can help to to build a better culture and a work environment for uh our teachers here in canyons and make it the best school district to work at the USB on the hill was excellent to be able to meet with some of our legislators um it was very eye- openening to me this my first you know foray and to understanding more of this but just the the difference that we can make and being aware of what is happening I think a lot of times we like to want to just put our head in the sand and hope that everybody's making good decisions on our behalf um but it's good to be aware and talk to your legisl try to follow what is happening a couple um first of all the um

178Jordan high RC I'm grateful we have this program it was awesome for their color guard to come and present the colors that morning and just the RTC program is great I'm a military child I grew up tra living all over the world uh on military bases and so having these programs that teach leadership to our students and also provide uh more experience with the military and a path to going to serve in the military as excellent and so I'm glad that we've started this program at at Jordan high this year um but back to talking about some bills to be aware of um especially we've got the school safety bill that passed last year it's up for amendments this year it's hb40 and to be aware of uh couple of things that it's really pushing

179is bullet resistant film on Windows and the guardian program and and I think a lot of our public is not aware of these things and and the research doesn't back these as school as really preventing school safety we really want to want our safe schools we want our kids to be protected but let's do it by research back methods as superintendent Robins talked to the research shows Pro putting a lot more mental health supports in of supporting these kids it's not these uh you know hardening our schools that are really making the difference and the legislature wants to spend Millions upon millions of dollars on things that then have to be replaced again in 5 years and it's not showing that's actually preventing any uh or making our schools more safe and so be aware

180of that talk to your legislators um let's fund research-backed programs that are going to keep our students more safe thank you Miss Pon okay I represent um our board at the usba um Utah School boards Association and I wanted to share with uh our newer members of the board and to let our board know that in usba we are currently working on a new version of the superintendent's yearly evaluation every year we evaluate we could do ey poops I know we'll just pop in um criteria it's not on the list but they have a yearly and our um Financial administrator does as well but um our school board um board the usba is working on changing that evaluation to be more productive and more a conversational um situation where it's not just a checklist you're

181doing this this this this this but that we would actually we're working on creating a rubric where they know what their expectations are this is what we expect for a highly qualified administrator and then we'd have different scenarios on if you did this much you'd get a four and if you do this much You' get a three and that they would know in ADV Advance sometimes I hate evaluations where you really don't know what they're looking for but then they'll tell you afterwards and now you're going great that's a little little too late so I wanted to let them know that we will have a rubric probably ready for our evaluations this spring Salt Lake City district has been piloting a rubric system and it's has questions and it's so much shorter um normally there's

18229 questions that we have to check um for the evaluation and this one would drop down to like 15 but it has better explanations of what we're really looking for and then the nicest part of all is a superintendent gives ourselves a grade plus there's a space where we can comment on all the positives that we see or any concerns that we can see so I think it's going to facilitate better conversations between the board and our leadership so that we are all working for the same goal and if we're not working completely correctly that we can make those adjustments in a POS positive way so I just want to let them know that that's coming down the road I do have a sample of what um Salt Lake City is using um we're going

183to be meeting this coming Thursday um and that will be further refined by then I'm not on that particular committee but we all give the input so I think that's an exciting thing to see coming up in usba I also wanted to clarify just because I have had a a parent call me about um in parent meetings for our spring Sports they've been complaining about the coaches have been complaining about the reduction of fees and about the fees that they're asking our parents to pay and they're blaming all of it on the district and I just want to make it clear to them that we're not the ones that are trying to slash programs because we don't have the fees to run them it's the legislature and that we simply have laws that are passed

184that cause us to have to make accommodations because there's no funding um for instance we've been covering all the bus trips that all of our special teams coaches cheerleading choirs all of those extracurricular the district has been funding those 100% um to see did I write down the cost yeah half a million dollars every year just for buses and the legislature doesn't want that to happen anymore they want everything in school to be free which is great we would love it if they gave us the money to replace the fees that we've been using to help fund that but no they just said just do it for free and we still have to come up with that cost so there are a few costs that we'll have to as we watch the legislation um it's

185House Bill 344 that is talking about our fee rates some are going to you know some of the things they want cut and some they want eliminated they would love to see and I don't think this is a bad goal the legislators are trying to make a way that you can go to school without ever having to pay a fee however that doesn't that kind of limits what that student would be able to do because most of the fees that they do allow are our extracurricular courses our enrichment courses the ones that make High School fun and that would eliminate those kids if they can't if we aren't allowed to have a fee or give a waiver see if we have no fee then we can't give a waiver because there is none um they

186might not be able to to go to the have some of the choices that they would like to have so I just want it made it made known to our public a lot of these decisions that you think are board decisions or District decisions are directly in ret you know is the legislature is responsible for making those laws that cause us to have to do that so it's really important I know we're harping on legislation but this is the season and we spend a great deal of our time following these bills and looking at where they're um going to be affecting us so I just wanted to point that out because I did get a parent phone call you're going to take away our busing and we're going to have to pay for it ourselves

187that's never been said that's just prediction on a coach's part but please be aware that some of those negative impacts are not in our control we're just simply having to manage what the legislature puts on us um we've also been notified that Senate Bill 102 from Senator Filmore wants to repeal the part of the wpu that helps us pay for our special teachers special ed support all those kinds of things we used to be able to count some of our weighted SPO puple student money be able to help compensate for the costs of those special teachers and they want that got completely eliminated but I don't hear them saying they're going to completely eliminate it and put all of it into the student W wpu we're just concerned that it might get put somewhere else

188so they have interesting ways of taking money away from our students so something to also keep away keep aware of um last on a more positive thing I'm going to call it and I go along with um Katie's conversation I'm going to consider to Valentine to our schools since Valentine's Day is coming up next week and we won't meet again until afterwards that we want our bus drivers our lunch workers our playground AIDS our every employee we have our sweepers our administrators our teachers to know how much we love and support them pull any of those one components out and our schools would not be the great places that they are the safe places they are the clean places that they are the healthy places that they are for our students we love support and

189know that you're there we wish we could brag on you all the time but it's in our hearts so I'm just going to send a a valentine of love and recognition to our entire District support system we are an amazing district and we do amazing things for our students and I want them to understand that we do know and recognize that they are there I see the cutest bus drivers that go by and wave at at at crossing guards and you know everything everything it has to do with with schools um is all for our students and we we we love and appreciate what they do so thank you all right so with the beginning of the year uh and a new board that we have starts new committee work uh so every two years

190There's an opportunity to reshuffle the Committees sometimes there's significant reshuffles sometimes there's not uh but a lot of the board's work happens in committees and uh so that goes largely on in the background but it's exciting to me because it's a time to really get down to work uh and to look at how best can we serve our students how best can we serve our community uh in whatever capacity whatever committee we're ble to serve on so that's a really exciting part of the Year for me at least uh I like the committee meetings I think they're really productive uh and so I'm really excited to continue the work there uh we discussed long range planning tonight that's a going to be a great topic uh and a topic that we'll make sure that we're

191transparent on so that no one's caught off guard with that legislature is a big thing right now we've got our legislative session going on and really the I think the number one issue that we're up against is unfunded mandates uh and it's interesting because the state for many years has complained about unfunded mandates from the federal government um but the state has absolutely no issues sending down unfunded mandates to the school districts um and they do it time and time again the school safety bill has been brought up as a great example of that um I I think every single one of us is absolutely 100% committed to school safety but do we need um bullet resistant film on the outside of the fourth floor windows at Hillcrest High School um that is uh a

192gross waste of resources it's been mentioned before that uh the school safety bill passed last year which is being updated this year with some minor technical changes it doesn't hit the core for school safety and it's it's got a lot of things in it that are good but then it's got a lot of things that are pretty wasteful where they came from I can only speculate um but they're not grounded in science they're not grounded on um information we have on the past uh they're not grounded in reality uh I feel like they're grounded on special interest lobbies and I feel like they're grounded quite honestly in action movies um so if ever you have an opportunity to email your legislator to have a conversation with them if you can't remember anything else if you

193could help us spread the message uh to stop the unfunded mandates uh also I would love for them to stop legislation that should have been a phone call or maybe a conversation with your teacher or principal um that happens all the time not just for Education uh but for a number of things I remember uh it was a fairly recent session uh where they passed a bill that Governor Cox said uh he vetoed it and he said it was should have been a phone call uh I believe it was actually mandating a particular training for state employees that they already took uh and they created a law for it uh when had they just picked up the phone and said hey are you doing this training they would have said yes or if they weren't

194this would be a good idea and poof we can solve problems just like that um without having to create a state law that being said uh we do have some great legislators who uh are fighting for us on the hill and so I want to say how appreciative I am to them to those who are pushing back against the unfunded mandates uh to those who are standing up for common sense uh thank you uh we appreciate it each and every one of us um it was I did go to the usba day on the hill uh with several others and that was a great opportunity to speak with our legislators uh I also had the opportunity to visit the capital today with Mount Jordan Middle School they did a tour and those middle school students

195had really good questions uh they got to speak with two of our representatives and one of our state senators uh and they had a lot of great questions some of them uh pretty pointed pretty relevant to the education uh landscape uh some others equally as important but maybe not as important to education such as does pineapple belong on Pizza which our legislators had some pretty strong opinions on um but special thanks to the PTA who organized that and also special thanks to um uh Charlie Evans Susan Edwards and her team for helping to facilitate that as well as the legislative interns I look forward to continuing our committee work and anyone who has questions about what we're doing about the committee work about how I can help if you just have questions in general don't

196hesitate to reach out uh I had one constituent okay it's my nine-year-old son who had a question on why can't they shovel the black top on the playgrounds and it was a really important issue to him uh he passed that up um I think to the playground Aid who said because it's just policy that we're not allowed to do that and let me tell you I heard an earful about what a dumb District policy that was so from my end I asked the question well why can't we shovel the snow on the black top and the answer is uh because then it creates big piles of ice which become dangerous and they never melt I explained that to him and he thought that that was an absolutely acceptable answer that made total sense and I

197say that because I think there's a lot of questions uh and a lot of things out there that maybe they don't make sense at a glance so ask the question uh we're all here for you uh as elected officials we're responsive we and we've got a really fantastic board right now that wants to hear from you that wants to help get your questions answered because if you hear something that just sounds so crazy well ask about it let's have a conversation so with that uh the work of the board is finished and I adjourn this meeting

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.