001that 20 to 25% of the cost of a new home is government regulation they put that in there um they they released their objectives so yeah so they're the government yeah and so they are contributing 20 to 25% of the cost of a of a new home and they still going to this Tiff these Tiff bills to address the issue me it doesn't make any sense they are the government they know speaker said in that meeting that that was 20 to 25% the cost of a new home with government regulation and yet this is their solution I don't want to say it's their only solution but I haven't seen any bills reducing the amount of government regulation in the building of a new Hall so anyway we did start today went very smoothly um those
002bills I just described I think it's Senate Bill 23 and 26 yes both passed out of the Senate today and are on their way over to the house um hope we if you saw them yet Leon but we need to look at them quickly because it sounds like they're griefed just like they did vouchers couple years ago and usually when they start moving bills like this the beginning of the session is because they don't want to be very closely scrutinized which means obviously we need to scrutinize them very carefully and else want talk about the Committees MH just I mean is just a followup now that you've actually seen the tracker it came out today and you you got a preemptive one like a pre session one on Friday is it working for you do
003you understand it any followup questions for us on that okay follow got got six billing committee tomorrow afternoon there a lot on the tracker already it's almost somebody asked me today one of the lobbyist and the lobbyist Lounge said um I never print out a track it's why I don't do a Tracker because I you know it just it takes a lot of work and I said how many bills do you track and he said we usually track five six and I said we track over 200 and he's like got it so you know that it's already a lot but it's okay um one thing I would point out to you um the Committees especially we've never seen a um a house education committee like the one we have this legislature um everyone on that
004committee if you talk to them would say and sincerely mean that they are very much Pro public education so I hesitate to classify them as anti-public education but quite a few people on that committee see public education quite a bit differently people in this room do I'll just leave it at that and some of them radically so um especially some who will be serving in their first term I don't know if you guys remember when Susan pulser was first elected to the legislature they wouldn't add her to the public education committee because you know that's one of their most important committees and usually you have to serve in the legislature for a couple terms before you can get on that committe one of these people that was serving their uh was just appointed this committee
005has never even been elected to the legislature and has now been appointed this committee so um you know things are changing at our legislature pretty fundamental way um we've always had at least in the house and usually in the Senate we've always had a house committee where we had a Fighting Chance um and it's becoming less and less so I yes put it as diplomatic very diplomatic as I can is there any anything else or question any questions you guys have any questions for us yeah well just thank you for your work pleasure thank you that's that's all thanks guys few questions you guys have ever had just make one comment um I think recently through a Mutual contact I reached out to the auditor the auditor's office got a question regarding the Utah fits
006Al scholarship and um because my question was in talking to some of the new legislators I asked them do you know what the D is know how that the money is being spent I've heard different things across you know some of the chatter on the internet about you know grand pianos being purchased or purchased with the money or other things that are inappropriate use of the money and the answer that came back from the auditor's office is that it is I knew it was a private entity out of Colorado that's been administering it but because it's a private entity we are not able to Grandma that information so this whole thing was subject to an audit nor they well they audit technically but they get the reports that are given to the leg ISL and
007the only thing is how much money was spent and very Loosely how it was used so they are under a veil of secrecy I would say and I think that it's pretty deliberate and that you know because they're the legislature and they've made this legal it's legal so I think as board members when we talk to our legislators I mean to me it's maddening because of the kind of um transparency we are required as a public entity to have with the public tax dollars and the fact that this money has literally zero transparency I think is important and they knew it when they put it in the details of that bill and refused to allow legislators to read it over a weekend to ascertain them zero transparency and zero accountability right y okay well thank
008you that was very quick and shortest one you ever do so thank you both six bills in committee that tomorrow afternoon so okay and if we are hitting the ground running and if you read any and you say why is that not on The Hot List just text us and we'll look at it and examine it and probably put it on hot lot list yeah but just let us know if you see any that you think should be there that we've missed okay thank you both and the next item on the agenda is the height cdra amendments first reading and Leon Wilcox business administrator will lead us in this thank you president CH let me just start off by introducing this is Mike Johnson he is the uh community development director for p height City
009and next to him is uh Chris MCAS he is a former uh city councilman here Sandy City when the district was split some a few minutes ago so uh uh what we want to do what they brought to us for your review and a and if so eventual approval is a Amendment to the cdra that we have with cwood Heights city let me just do a quick 32 overview of what a cdra tiff tax increment financing I'll probably use that word about is is about okay uh we'll throw that out quite a bit mebe we ought to have a study session get PE some people cut up on this at a future meeting but for property taxes everybody under the state's Constitution everybody has to pay property taxes nobody's free of that Duty so any
010you own PR it's taxed now where the tax dollars go can be subject to certain types of agreements so you know everybody we all pro you know most of us in this room own a house and the city where where we live in the we live in the school district where we reside collects property taxes that goes to that respective entity okay sometimes they what they can do is they can create what we call a tiff agreement and usually that's going out and blocking off a section of property for some type of Redevelopment and then what happens is you go out and you calculate what that base year or when that property you're going to start developing what that value is worth and then you go on along a period of time and they build
011up or redevelop that area and during this time this Blue Area the property taxes are still generated you know people are still paying profit taxes but they go to the to pay help pay for the development of that area but they don't go to the school district they go to the city who then pays off bonds or other things related to that related to that development then after the project ends in the period of time whether it's 10 years 15 years 20 years whatever is negotiated then the property value is again up higher it's gone and been been developed and increased then all the money all the future property taxes go back to the know the county the school district the city that does that make sense just a quick 30 flip notes version here
012so what happen what's gone on is back in 2012 so I don't know none of you were even here at the time never mind never mind the board entered into a cdra what we call the cut Canyon center canyon Center cdra City so the our Agreements are only with the city city has a subgroup cdra Redevelopment qua entity and that's who we that's who the agreement is with so we agreed to this back in 2012 in 2018 Amber would have been here at that time we made an amendment to the to uh cdra at that time uh just so again the property that's being redeveloped here is the old ret book bracket ball Club area back there on so just to give you an idea Union going east west waset right there this would be
013the mouth of Big funwood Canyon right here this road going up the canyon and just off to the side is the Redevelopment area here there's a here right Porcupine restaurant right there so if you get the the idea where this is at so we agreed to this development so they started it and part of the agreement was in 2018 was they would start doing what they called the trigger date in 2021 which occurred then so the value's gone up quite a bit since then since we started the whole thing way back in 2012 was it 3.8 million G up to 56 million which is what we expect to happen you know it expects to generate property tax that way you know 1,300 plus per. based on the value of 2024 and also in between here
014we've been negotiated as the value goes up they get 70% of what we call the increment or the that increase in value of the property taxes and the school district it's 30% okay so it's shared that way so they don't get it all in thisa we get technically 30% of that and so then this is one of those agreements that goes out of ways it goes out to 2047 so just to give you an idea what we've already agreed to in previous reports of that okay so one of the things that they've brought to us to look at is what they call a land use requirement on what we agreed to and then make a change to that back in here they have various phases of what they would do so they want to build
015a hotel which is the Courtyard hotel right they have a couple restaurants the e sers restaurant which I had on the previous slide and thata restaurant they had a large parking structure used for parking to get as a pickup for up and down during the ski season and then one of the things they brought to us back in 2018 was put on single value single family homes now we really don't like single value home single family homes in these areas because one they bring in kids and we're not getting the property taxes which we want the kids but we're not getting the property taxes to educate the kids so that's why we don't in our policy we say no single family homes but so what we agreed to at that time is they would pull
016these there 17 17 homes out of that and we would this District would get the full property taxes for those 17 homes okay uh and then they were supposed to build a office building about 83,000 Square ft and then they show uh apartment complex is going to be built on that as well what they are proposing is you know we all know what the commercial commercial building Market has done over the last several years everybody working from home have to build a a commercial building so what they are proposing is to pull out substitute the commercial building with cond now again condos may bring us kids they may not we'll see but but part of it is they would pull that out as well so we would collect the full property taxes on the condos
017that would not be part of the Tiff agreement so uh back in 2018 when we came the office building came and we came we agreed to this they thought the office building would be worth about 17 million I again over prices this is 2018 prices have all gone up skyrocketed since then they're estimating the value of these condol will be about 21 million take when they're built out keep in mind as condos as with your own individual house only 55% of that value is taxed the other 45% is exempt from property tax okay so that's instead of being maybe 35 36 million that's why it's 21 million there uh they' hopefully be complet ated 2829 along with that department bill so then on uh so what the what they're looking for approval is the amendment
018to the plan which there's been two amendments there Second Amendment and a third amendment they're all all out on board dos with the red line there what they're looking to change and then what we had agreed to is the interlocal agreement which references those two amendments again that are on board bu the Ila is also on board bu where you see that's the long and short of it so long and short we're looking to replace the office building with 36 condos we're looking at it as pretty much a net even break even thing the office building 20 million the condo is worth about 20 million which collects same amount of property tax on both so that's we fell okay with it the other cities wanted to bring something to us that had housing probably make
019the same requirement of them that they got to pull those H individual houses out because again they probably bring students if we want the property taxes T any questions for me or Mike Chris so just a better understand so we're swapping but we will that gets pulled out and we'll SK get the full tax on that instead of the office building we had agreed to delay office building we get 70% we'd get 30% so we actually come out faster long term probably very even yeah any other questions Mrs single family homes is staying the same they're not increasing there those single family homes have been built they were built six eight years ago they were like the first thing done yeah they've been up there for quite some time so they will still be the
020same we'll still collect the property taxes off of and no consideration to convert the office building space to single family homes instead of oh the office building is going be the condos I know so just there it's on top of the parking structure it's a Podium so it'll be there's no questions we could look to bring this back he could almost go on and could send agenda if you want we don't to beside that right here right now but uh the four meeting or not is everyone okay to bring this back on consent yes thank you thank you so the next item is the 2025 board of education graduation assignments and Dr McKay Robinson superintendent will present so earlier I was joking about not having a suit cat on the real reason to be honest
021now it's because I know how passionate we about this and I'm appreciate all arm wrestling so I don't know if you had a chance to pick one of these up or if it's in your folder I do have it's in our folder really this just comes down to we have as much information we can possibly gather for um tonight the only one that we are unaware of at this time is the life skills academy in regards to their theme but other than that we know who speaking as well as the location the date and then the approximate number of graduates you will notice that on the locations that we have um down at UVU instead of the University of Utah as those of you that have been on the board the last few years have
022known that it's been very difficult to work with the University of Utah um in that particular area with graduations not in other areas but um that's why we've made that switch we have also been talking with the Maverick Center in hopes that we could possibly did it all at the same location for all of our schools maybe in two days have to be two different days and so I just wanted to kind of throw that out there for you to be thinking about we do have it scheduled on the end of the 2026 year is the last meaning graduations taking place in the last week and we would just want to look at if we're willing to have it on two different days what two schools would be on one of the days what three
023schools would be on the other and we could make those arrangements but we would want to start making those arrangements with I Center pretty quickly that makes sense um but they've been willing to do it but as for this year this is where we will be and on the dates and the times for each school so really I just need you to let me know where you would like me to place your names in regards to who will be attending which one and who will be the speaker at that particular let's just go down the list M and then also just board I just want to remind you that only one board member speaks and they've asked us to be as short as possible I will tell you that I got the most compliments when
024my talk was like one minute so they really don't like I promise they don't care I mean I know they don't care they don't know who we are they just want us to be done so shorter is better just keep that in mind no 15 minute speeches please and just remember we're the guest of the school the school plans this um so we go along with their schedule and their perfect should we start with Alta who wants who wants whose turn is it to speak I'll be attending but I have a daughter graduating from Corner Canyon this year so I speak a corner so Amanda who wants to speak then I can okay okay anyone else will attending altas no no let's get them settled first and then okay how about Brighton I would like
025to speak to Brighton any wants to speak I will attend I'd say it's TR I did I've got one graduating too remind me d a h l e can you say it Dolly you guys I'm just gonna you there's a lot of different ways to say I'm just saying and I did ask her so I have Amanda down is speaking at corner at least made that request we're good there is anyone else planning on attending okay and then that takes us to Hillcrest I would like to speak my sister's graduating I would like to attend then HR in a long time and I love I'll also attend Ela Karen and I yeah for the future was awesome I'd love to speak at Hillcrest someday but before you said what you said I also thought you
026should speak just because it was extra cool but now you've got like double the reason we had the queen of Ghana last year and we got Jackson standard awesome whoever follows you Jackson I do not so we have Jackson speaking president Shi and Andrew also attending yes Jordan High School I always like Jordan we always fight over Jordan so whose turn is it to speak we both spoke we will spoke last time I guess rock paper against the rule because we had I'm just kiding last year too we had some cabinet speakers not speak that's why we had to okay so who's speaking Andrew then but who does I so can we do that can we make that agreement sure it's okay with me I will have a who's gonna gradate not this year next
027year next year may be two years takes a minute to get through high SCH I bet I bet Andrew work with you even he does he does work with me in fact that when the very first time he was supposed to speak he got sick so I was given the opport to give his tuck so I was I stepped in yeah it worked it was great great so Andrew and Karen anyone else want to attend or Andrew will speak I'll be there perfect diamond ridge one diamond ridge was that the that's my school I don't care what day it is because it doesn't matter we just don't have a time on it no it doesn't matter oh yeah is it usually at night it's at night it's usually diamond ridge and inada I like doing
028those I like doing them diamond and can I would like to go to one of them um can I go to Diamond is that okay you go ahead and speak I'll speak it's really short they don't pay any attention to what you're saying um I may be out of they they they're funny the one that listens to you the very least is life skills I'll just tell you that have entertaining didn't have a board speaker they um they may not that's that's why I said both because Entrada it's fine don't worry about it I did I mean yeah I can do a followup do you want Karen and then let you know if they're Diamond R in okay anyone else planning on attending in with Karen I know I may be out of town too
029so I it's June 12th I should be able to do it there's a potential I might be out of town but we'll kind of put you and I would like to attend Jordan Valley I've never been able to I want to attend Jordan Valley I didn't necessarily have to speak Mont did the speaking is awesome never everybody wants to go nobody's speaking so I don't know I don't think no don't know it yeah Nate Nate's been the only one that has I was gonna say it's one of those where you're going Karen Holly you're usually talking about like four or five graduates at them most three yeah oh is that how many oh yeah so I mean it it's not very long just like tiny okay we none we won't speak it's fine four of
030you though right I just never been able I know I haven't never been able to because you for some reason something happens it's nice that it's before and it's on a Friday can you send us calendar invites did you do that you mind all have Speak life skills okay the life skills people sometime well say and I both came have have taken a speech but it's really short yeah Karen spoke last year I did speak last year and I'll do it again if you'd like I don't mind they're I'll attend that they fun to play with had it in the auditorium and Katie Ken will you speak sure let's do something short I it's really oh they don't sometimes they don't want us and sometimes they say no and then go okay all we do
031is pass out their their things but but I don't have a major school so next year you know what I mean a big school Comprehensive High School Comprehensive High School the Ala one with h if you need you guys are always you're always welcome to replace administration too like we done this millions of years so like if you want to speak speak at one of those high schools Karen and replace me you're welcome to I'll think about it um I will say Karen to your point when you we were talking about life skills academy I felt like that one was pretty powerful for the parents it that makes sense so it's nice for them just really short but it's it's it's a good one that's one where the parents I think it's really fun um
032sweet kids so I think we have an accompanyment Ollie the only one at altaa oh Amanda Katie were you also yeah I can I can go or I cannot go it doesn't I don't know K you me I'm just saying I'll just I'll let go last week is crazy it's crazy or I just I don't think you should do to if you really want that time but you're just gonna be busy two different spots yeah because if you're going to be at the Maverick and the other on down there oh yeah you don't want to do that you don't want to part but if you really do I'm not gonna in your way well then Amanda and Holly are both down there anyway yeah is it okay if I just go through them again really
033quickly just to make sure I've got them all that's great so at Alta we have um Amanda and Holly with Holly speaking at Brighton we have Katie and president chill attending with Katie speaking uh Corner Canyon Amanda and Holly with Amanda speaking at Hillcrest I have Jackson president shill and Andrew with Jackson speaking Jordan I have Andrew and Karen with Andrew speaking diamond ridge I have Karen and president shill with Karen speaking and trada Karen and possibly Amanda yeah I'm attending yeah or let's see in trada gonna I'll find out for you if they're speaking or not I just come prepared just and what is that the one that does thought is really fun diamond ridge is the one that doesn't have the time yeah and I'll make sure I get that figured out as
034well for you all and then Jordan Valley we will be pleased to have President shill Holly Karen and Jackson and then life skills academy I have Karen speaking and Katie attending I will get the Google doc updated and then I'd be more than happy to send you all invites that's great thank oh just let us know as well did I tell Tom to the next year at ubu what do you gonna say SP on to two different days because that you can't do you can only do three only do three in mon two and three I love the Maverick Center I do two I don't think any kids are G to be sad to graduate a day earlier they'll be jealous of whoever about a day later do you like we'll just have to rotate
035it why don't we just figure out a rot maybe it was okay but it's not like amazing all have to drive down huh paring a nightmare there yeah I think that is the strength of the Maverick Center you don't have to worry about honor the day of doing graduation at the school I love that part of the reason why they went away from it is that ala had a graduation outside right and a lightning lightning struck right didn't hit the student but it hit the ground between the photographer and the student I asked that because I didn't know that last year it would have been bad because it was yeah and you can't ever tell what the weather is gonna be like is the weather is a problem and I know it was in the
036paper it was a big deal I know and then we didn't but then when Co hit we did the driveth through right then the year after Co we actually did do a cool Jordan did one outside after Canyon did too and the feedback from the community was if the weather it's hard because of weather but it is amazing because that's where all theing is not as good fun stadiums would you guys be okay too at both sides if we just had a small hospitality room with just some Waters and I just I mean by the pleas yes through I don't know exhausting I just thought we had a room that maybe had some light snacks and some water that'd be great just because we have a lot of staff there too right that were there
037every been a lot of people in this room are there pretty much the whole day I that's great neither neither venue ever provides that and I noticed that last year yeah I just like man it's so hard even to get a bottle of water if you then if you want to leave you got to walk to those restaurants and then in it so anyway okay we'll set that up it's great sorry to Hound but am I asking Tom to pursue that purs it I think so possible I do think he looked into it this year he told me he did but it was already booked that's why we couldn't do it that's why we had to do UV so I think our community would prefer to be closer to home is that closer I think
038it's six the vi maybe maybe for for corner it's I think I think closer yeah Maverick's close 20 minutes I think it's probably about six reel I think it's a question of the the venue honestly I mean I've been in the very first gradu uation I spoke at for Corner Canyon was in it's not as nice as Maverick Center I think if you're looking at so nice to work with as well hey I'll just have him kind of pursue that and then we'll okay thank you and we will start business at 7 thank you for keeping this meeting on time too more we had important things e e e welcome to the meeting of is January 2 202 ande the distri office first item on the agenda is to approve the agenda for tonight do
039I have ation I move that we approve the agenda for January 21st 2025 okay thank you is there a second to that motion I second I pledge allegiance to the flag of United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all good evening board members thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak about my amazing School Brighton height it's a privilege to share just a glimpse of what makes our school such a special place first and foremost I have to highlight the incredible teachers and staff at Brighton their dedication is unmatched from our custodians who come in on Sundays to ensure our sidewalks are clear of snow and ice to our secretaries who greet every student with a warm smile to
040our teachers who spend countless hours of their own time helping students succeed Brighton High is filled with people who genuinely care about every student who walks through our doors Brighton continues to excel academically by the end of last year we had given 756 AP tests and we achieved 100% pass rate in several rigorous subjects including literature research seminar physics 2 and US government and in other Advanced courses we maintained or we maintained remarkable Pass rates of over 90% in biology calculus AB Calculus BC chemistry and US History these accomplishments reflect the talent and hard work of both our students and the Educators who support them of course it's not just just about academics at Brighton we shine in every area at the end of last year our baseball team made it to the state finals
041our boys lacrosse team were the 5A state champions and this year our football team had an incredible season making it all the way to the state playoffs at the University of Utah our Arts are outstanding as well the theater department has had a year to remember I'll never forget the energy and fun of Matilda and and my favorite scene Miss trench marching around the stage singing the fizzed song but there was success before this our theater program was recognized at the Shakespeare Festival as well Brighton students earned second overall Ensemble scene first place in the tech Olympics for props fourth overall in the tech tech Olympics for sound additionally one of our Juniors brought home the Larry El lot acting award the festival's highest honor her portrayal of cor coriolanus for her portrayal of um
042coriolanus this is the second consecutive year that a Brighton student has won this prestigious award an incredible achievement Brighton High is more than a school it's a community of Learners and Achievers whether on stage on the field or in the classroom our Bengals consistently rise to the occasion making all of us proud to call brighten our home thank you for supporting our students and teachers and for celebrating these achievements with us go Bengal okay thank you Marielle um I love to hear about Brighton and I feel super pass about it so I know it's a great school and I really appreciate all you do and all your staff does um I loved it when I was um shadowing a student that day and just talking to the different teachers and even the hall monitors they
043they had been there like 10 a long time like how long six years I don't know but they loved it and they just loved talking to the kids and helping them so I really appreciate you so the next item on the agenda is um the canyon strong recognitions and de Haney director and K associate director of communications will present that thank you president shill for this time granted to US during board meeting to honor those who are truly Canyon strong and it's been a fantastic start to the year we excited about the possibilities of 2025 now the first images you'll see here during tonight's recognitions are of current and former students who spent Monday January 20th honoring what is good and great about America that's the peaceful transfer of Presidential Power and our country's guarantee
044of civil rights for all of our Citizens First you'll see here a group of students from Brighton High School they represented Canyon School District at the Salt Lake chapter of the naacp's 41st annual Memorial luncheon to honor the landmark contributions of Martin Luther King Jr and Rosa Parks Canyon's District sponsors a table so our students can participate in this event and have this Educational Opportunity on a day reserved for remembering our principles of equality and respect and love for our fellow man and next we want to point out this shot that was forwarded to us today it is of Jordan High graduate midshipman Thomas Johnson who is part of the beat Digger Naval Cadet Corps program when he was at Jordan High School as you can see there midshipman Johnson was part of the military
045choir that performed at the presidential inauguration on Monday and what a fantastic memory for midshipman Johnson a proud beat Digger to have the canyon strong start to the year for students is great and it's also great for our employees we kick off our recognitions tonight by emphasizing an honor that was announced nationally last week Canyon's district is the proud home of the national girls tennis coach of the year so Brighton High's longtime tennis coach Natalie Meyer was announced last Monday as one of the top 24 prep coaches in the entire country this was announced by the national Federation of State High School associations now coach Meyer who is actually a Bengal herself and a former University of Utah tennis player is the only coach from a Utah school to be selected as a national coach
046of the year so congratulations to coach Meyers now good for us she tells us that she has no plans to retire soon even though she's been an educator for 35 years now she tells tells us that she loves teaching she loves coaching and that interaction with uh students and student athletes keeps her young and uh raring to go for another tennis season now winners are chosen after a nomination process and an application window and as we all may know the bright and high tennis program is one of the most successful in Utah for both boys and girls tennis Aces have brought home do pres of team and individual state titles underneath Meyer so congratulations to Natalie once again the national girls tennis coach of the year and we also want to spend a few moments
047honoring the contribution of Gary Hansen Canyon's District's purchasing director he's retiring at the end of this month and Gary was one of the very first employees hired in Canyon school district in the fall of 20 2008 he was part of the startup team that helped launch the district even from its first days he was part of that small group of employees Leon was there I was there a few other were there we huddled up around electric heaters in that first winter in our first headquarters which was the old Cottonwood Heights Elementary School which has since been torn down Gary was one of the group of people who was hired to start this district and we're very grateful for his contributions since that time in 2008 from computers to crayons Gary has ordered it all his
048number one priority is to make sure schools have what they need when they need it now we know that can be quite a task but more than 40 years of experience buying everything from toilet paper to toothpicks he has definitely been up to the challenge now like I said later this month Gary is retiring and taking with him those years that years of experience and he's also taking with him a lot of great memories his reward has been seeing students sitting in new chairs and knowing that his department has made it happen if Canyon's district has it Gary's department has probably bought it he has filtered requests from lawnmowers to leaf blowers to snow blowers to pencils and everything else Under the Sun that help our schools and our departments run and he does it
049all by following government requirements for using public funds and always in the back of his mind Gary who we know was the 2019 Apex Award winner for district administrator of the year he considers how to make every dollar count no matter what the request he's also always willing to chip in when needed you'll see him with his shirt sleeves rolled up and he's often carrying tables and chairs at all of our events so thank you Gary because of his contributions Canyons has succeeded in so many ways and that's why we want to mention Gary Hansen as a canyon strong employee please join me and all of us in Wishing Gary well and also so much thanks for his contributions to the success of Canyon school district now what would we do without our fixers especially
050in plumbing and power now when we don't have water and we don't have power we find out really quick how much we need them our Canyon District facility fixers you know those are the employees who rush to fix the broken water lines here at the district office and also to address the power outage of a Jordan High School that forced the early release of school for the day these are the work workers who are the epitome of Canyon strong these guys responded so quickly and worked so professionally on the Jordan power outage those are Casey Hart and Jordan Ms and electrical and Dan Hughes and Zack lingren and HVAC the facilities fixers who were hard to get a broken waterline to the district office last week are Cody scheme and boow Waters their work was
051truly Canyon strong and we truly appreciate them now next up we want want to wish good luck to our cheer squads who are competing at the state competition competitive cheer season culminates this week with the state competitions and we wish the Bengals and the Chargers much luck in the 6A and the 5A competitions Corner Canyon has won this competition since it became the sanctions board by the Utah High School Activities Association two years running and we're cheering for both the Chargers and the Bengals to bring home the State title Hardware so consider us the biggest cheerleaders of our cheerleaders tune in to the Canyons connect podcast tomorrow we sat down with Coach Whitney Lunt from Corner Canyon High School and three of her senior captains to talk about cheer competitive cheer and how these student
052athletes have to go into the weight room to lift like offensive lineman have to have stamina like wrestlers have to Tumble like o Olympic G gymnasts and basically know how to dance like even the best choreographers who are up on the stage with pop stars like Lady Gaga and Britney Spears they are ultimate athletic competitors through and through and we wish them much luck so president shill thank you so much for this time for the canyon strong recognitions we turn the time back to you okay thank you Mr Haney appreciate that so tonight we do not have any Pat comments so we'll go on to the next item on the agenda which is the consent agenda and I will now take a motion to approve the consent agenda and please list all the items under
053there I make a motion to approve the consent agenda for tonight January 21st a approval of minutes for January 7th B approval of higher inter termination reports C approval of student overnight travel D approval of purchasing bids e approval of December Finance reports F approval of laa specific licenses and endorsements G approval of administrative appointments and H approval of Brighton High School early out on April 24th 2025 okay thank you we have a motion is there a second to that motion I'll second okay thank you we have a motion and a second is there any discussion to the motion okay seeing none I'll call for a vote all in favor say I I I any opposed okay that motion passes unanimously okay the next item on the agenda is new business and it's the Canyon
054school district 2023 2024 employee survey results and Dr Laura Tuesday heathfield program evaluator will be presenting this thank you very much and good evening um I was asked to present these results they some some of you on the board have already heard them um as part of the human centered supports um committee but I'll go through um pretty briefly about um the survey results from last year so those of you that are new to the board welcome um we send out a uh satisfaction survey to our employees each year we've been doing it with our licensed Educators since uh 20156 school year excuse me Laura can you move the microphone just closer likeor I do have a mask on so it's a little hurt yeah thank you um we send it out to our licensed
055Educators which we've been doing for the past um 10 years nine years with our administrators and our education support professionals we've been doing it this is our second year of um sending a similar survey the items align with the survey that we've been sending to licensed Educators um the surveys are sent via um District email with about a two we week window to respond and reminders are sent in that window um they are lyer related items on each of the surveys for each of the types of employees they vary a little bit in terms of number depending on whether the a particular item applies to them or not for example um there's 25 items for contracted esps but only 24 because there's no there's no uh benefits question for hourly esps they cover the general
056area as of General satisfaction expectations professional growth value and a sense of belonging and well-being and these somewhat mirror um the types of items that are sent out yearly or pretty regularly I don't know about yearly but regularly by the Gallop poll that demonstrates that if your employees are happy they're going to stay with you there are also two open response items that we include um one what do you enjoy most about working in canyons and then what single change would you like to have um would have the most positive effect on your overall satisfaction so any questions before I jump in okay so I'm going to start with the educator satisfaction survey um It's always important to look at our reliability and response rate to make sure that we're getting um a good uh
057representation of our employees overall reliabil was excellent at 93% and we got a good response rate of 47% of our licensed Educators so a little over a thousand um this is our the one question they asked about overall satisfaction across years and for those of you on the board you'll recall that we were concerned about this dip that we had in the 20121 and 2122 school year the good news is we've seen a 10% gain across the last two years so we're getting back up to approaching our high point back in 201920 um and that's reflected in this little U bar graph at at the top so overall we saw a slight increase in overall satisfaction from last year we're also celebrating the 2-year upward Trend in overall satisfaction additionally we saw um an increase
058in satisfaction on 22 of the remaining 28 items but we do have six items that had less than 50% of our respondents responding positively so what I plan to do is go through each of those areas and just highlight a few things um celebrations as well as areas of concern so in the area of General satisfaction um we did see gains in recommending a teaching job at Canyons or recommending a teaching job to a friend but we did see a decrease in um satisfaction with the benefits pack package as well as salary and salary and recommending a teaching job are two of the ones that fell below 60% and just to remind you that the percentages represent um the proportion of respondents that responded agree or strongly agree to that item in the area of
059expectation s uh celebration is we had a a pretty substantial increase in the percentage of licensed Educators who feel physically safe in their school or Department it was already high but it is even higher this year um we did see um a low rating which is not um a surprise because it's been this low for a long time that the expectations of teachers in canyons are realistic similarly a very low percentage extremely low percentage thought the expectations of teachers na Nationwide were realistic and I guess the good news about that is we're above the what they feel is happening Nationwide kind of over on the left I I've indicated in the past the board has asked have are there differences between Elementary and secondary Educators and there were two items in this section that had
060a significant difference um the being physically safe uh more Elementary Educators felt physically safe at their school or Department than secondary but both were very high um and then at the bottom in terms of Nationwide uh expectations secondary teachers um had a little bit higher rate than elementary teachers but both were quite low in the area of professional growth we saw a substantial increase in receiving training to know how to respond to an emergency and a slight increase in I have received adequate training to be able to manage behaviors and I know that's been a focus of concern over the last couple years um similarly um there is a below 60% um satisfaction rate with receiving adequate training and support in managing behaviors again over on the left there are several items that had a
061significant difference and when I say it's significant difference it was statistically significant but not by many um percentage points so I don't know if it's clinically significant but it is statistically significant and three of those the elementary respondents were higher than the secondary and the third one the secondary was higher than Elementary um in terms of feeling valued um there were several items that were below 50% uh satisfaction rate um speaking with a district administrator and this potentially is low because there was a large percentage of respondents who um had no opinion it was about a third of respondents so my guess is they never had the op they never had a need to contact anybody at the central office um receiving recognition continues to be um a concern because it's below 50% but it
062did increase slightly this year compared to last year and similarly um being valued by the Canyon's Board of Education by you all is low but there is a slight increase from last year and then um another good celebration is that in the sense of feeling that they belong in their schoolers department or their overall well-being was all rated very high and even higher than it was last year so these are the open-ended questions what do you enjoy most about working in canyons and what single change would have the most positive impact what we did is looked for most prominent themes as you can imagine with over a thousand respondents it's a little overwhelming to read every single one but the three um most prominent themes in terms of enjoying working at Canyons included having a
063positive work environment or relationships with their colleagues the impact that they are having on students and professional learning opportunities that are available to them um in terms of uh changes that would have an impact the first one was student behavior and discipline uh second is pay Anor benefits and the third is reducing workload or expectations any questions before we move on to the next group comments are there any questions right now we want to wait till the end to discuss okay okay go ahead thank you the second survey is the administrator satisfaction survey and as I mentioned last year the year before last year was the first year we sent that one out again excellent overall reliability and a good response rate of 63% um slight increase again from last year in terms of overall
064satisfaction um a large majority of our administrators are satisfied with their employment more than half of the lered items were posit positively endorsed by over 80% of our responding administrators but we did have three items that had less than 50% of positive response um General satisfaction we saw increase in recommending an administrative job at Canyons but that was already very high um and a slight decrease in salary satisfaction with salary and an even uh Stronger decrease in benefits satisfaction expectations similar to um our licensed Educators administrators believe that the expectations in canyons are not necessarily realistic and even more so nationally um the great news I think is the other three items in that they feel supported by their um supervisors they feel safe in their um current position and they know what's expected of
065them um in terms of professional growth the strength um again similar to um um Educators they believe that they've received ad training and support to be able to fulfill the functions of their position and then there was a slight decrease in receiving encouragement for professional growth and having sufficient opportunities for professional development in terms of value there was a a pretty substantial increase in feeling valued by their Community um but a decrease in receiving adequate Tech recognition for their work and again feeling valued by the Board of Education and then again similar to our Educators there is a strong um satisfaction with um their sense of belonging and well-being but it is decreased from last year in all four items um and then the two open-ended uh questions administrators enjoy most about working in Canyons
066is the supportive work environment that district has systems and processes in place and that they have positive relationships with their colleagues um in terms of single change that would impact their um overall satisfaction workload paying benefits and support from District leadership and I should add in the um final reports that you received they I did give some examples of what they meant by the those those themes to help you understand their concerns um in terms of esps we have two surveys that we send out one to contracted esps and one to hourly both had overall reliability that was excellent we had a 40 40% response rate with our contracted esps but only 30% of our hourly so caveat is we should probably consider the hourly ESP survey results with a bit of caution because that
067is a pretty low response rate not horribly low but it's it's low in comparison to our other um employee groups um similarly their overall satisfaction increased slightly from last year and both are high so a large majority of them are satisfied with their employment and I mentioned the interpreting survey results with some caution because of that low response rate for hourly ESP so what I've done is kind of put the contracted um ESP responses next to the hourly so that you can kind of they're fairly similar but there are some differences um I think on the positive side both had Fairly High satisfaction with recommending a job to a friend or relative in Canyons um and then the concern obviously is that they are not very satisfied with the salary and that decreased for hourly
068but increased for contract employees um in terms of expectations all of these were fairly high and all of these increased um from last year so that's a a good sign as well um professional growth I think um both had a substantial increase in um the item receiving adequate training to know how to respond in an emergency um and then they both had a below 60% uh satisfaction rate with receiving encouragement for professional growth and then in terms of feeling valued um on the positive end they was very high and had a pretty substantial increase from last year in terms of having opportunities Pro to provide their opinion within their school or department and then again Lower items were receiving adequate recognition for their work particularly among contract employees and then um feeling valued by the
069Board of Education and then similar to our other two employee groups um High rates of satisfaction with belonging and well-being and some pretty substantial increases from last year and then there open-ended responses what they enjoy most is interacting and impacting our students um having supportive collegial relationships and having a flexible work schedule um the single change that would impact their overall satisfaction included increased pay professional growth opportunities and receiving recognition or appreciation for their work um and just for a summary we had um adequate to good response rates across um employee groups except for hourly esps overall satisfaction increased slightly from last year across all three employee groups um satisfaction level increased from last year on the majority of survey items for both licensed Educators and esps and then from those lered items um there
070were some differences in terms of primary areas of dis dissatisfaction for licensed Educators it was um too high of expectations not enough recognition and low salary for administrators was similar in terms of expectations and recognition and not enough uh professional learning opportunities for esps it was salaries um being encouraged to um grow professionally and then for contracted it was recognition and for hourly it was professional learning opportunities so I just offered some considerations um looking at those areas of high satisfaction can they be capitalized on to address some of the areas of dissatisfaction what are some action steps would that would be essentially more most bang for your buck and then How can any strategies that are implemented be communicated broadly so that employees do know that their concerns are being addressed I think I
071mentioned before that some of the responses say things like like I don't think anybody ever reads these I don't know why I fill it out so knowing that their voices are heard I think is important and then lastly we might want to think about how we can get uh better participation among our hourly esps since that was the lowest response rate so questions comments okay thank you Laura um Bard are there any questions that you have for her um Mrs peton button I don't know if this is a specific question as much as I'm asking you an opinion um obviously the board is not reaching the needs of all of our employee groups is it of your opinion that because of the distance between those groups and ourselves and our interactions with them that that
072would be a factor that contributes to the lower response that we aren't meeting their needs I think that I think that contributes to it certainly um I but some of the comments indicated that for example that they feel like there's certain groups the louder groups get attention than those that don't scream the loudest um so there's some I think there's some other factors too that play into it yep I appreciate that okay any other questions board um because I oh go ahead just a quick Katie just a quick question was this a fivepoint lyer scale fivepoint ler scale strongly agree agree no opinion disagree strongly disagree good question thank you okay if there's no other questions then um I think the board I think we wanted to have a discussion so okay I don't know
073if you need to stand there but if we have further questions we can have you come back up okay so great so board our um our strategic Plan Focus Group human Center support we um reviewed this data and then that's why we brought it back to the full board but we did have a few ideas in our committee which I kind of want to pass on to the board um before we start having a discussion for your consideration so the first one um Paula Logan had and she wondered if we should recognize like an ESP group every month that was her idea recognize them at board meeting and I do think didn't we just recognize some people tonight the fixers um so I don't know if we're already implementing that plan but um that was
074her idea and then also when I was talking to Mr Haney about this he had an idea so I'm wondering I don't know if you can come up again Jeff sorry with your crutch um yeah if you could come up and just tell the board your idea also for us to consider thank you so as We examined the results of the student the employee satisfaction survey we looked at ways that we could connect with the employees who either didn't respond to the survey or gave us the responses how they really felt and we want to directly address some of these issues by providing information to them about the ways that the Board of Education in particular is discussing issues that they bring up either through the superintendent's listening tour or they provide us in an
075email or feedback in any other way so plans are being made to create and send a postcard monthly to all the employee groups licensed in ESP to provide insight about the decisions and discussions of the Board of Education and this directly affects them meaning the decisions you all make affect their workplace environment and sometimes water doesn't get to the end of the row because a significant group of our employees have jobs that take them away from laptops so they're not at their laptops every single day and seeing what comes across in their email we have a large group of employees who don't check their email often so they may not be receiving the information we're providing to them so we want to do a hard copy Direct Mail campaign monthly that would provide information to
076to our employees about the decisions and the actions of the Board of Education that directly address their concerns you can see here a draft of one of the postcards that we would put together on behalf of the board here we would identify the items of what the board of education is doing to work for the employees you can see there's some of the dummy text but it really does reflect items that they may need to know as in employees of the Canyon school district we would propose on this card to also feature employees so you'll see here that we have put on the draft version of the postcard a spotlight on Natalie Meyer who we announced tonight is the national girls tennis coach of the year that's a feather in the cap of Canyon school
077district to have that quality of a coach and an educator for Canyon school district but then we also very easily could have profiled our fixers our plumbers our HVAC technicians and our electricians who work so hard on the waterline brakes and the power outage at Jordan High School we also can provide information to them about how they can remain connected this could touch um all parts of an employees workplace and get information to the people who don't necessarily look at their emails every day we would start this direct mail this month also we would continue with the email updates for our employees who do remain connected to information about their workplace here by looking at information that's provided to them through our email system and also we have indicated to the board that we'll start
078working in more information about board members their representation of employees and their constituents and how their discussions and decisions here during board meeting and in the course of your duties how that is affecting how the district is running things like the extra planning time that was a board decision we want to make sure our employees know the board helped facilitate that there are many other things that have come out of all of our feedback forums that we've created such as the superintendent listening tour that the administ ation is then brought to the board the board's then made the decision and it's directly benefited the employees we want to make sure that our employees are aware of the work that you've done for them so those are the three things that we've put together as possibilities
079to get information to our employees about the board's good work okay thank you Jeff are there any questions about his presentation oh yes Karen um not necessarily to you I'm want to compliment you on moving forward on some suggestions that were made right after our human centered support conversation and you are I passed to the board a list of some of my concerns and possible solutions and that was you did a better version of it because you're a Communications person but anyway um Communications would better identify specific decisions made by the board board versus administration because sometimes I think they mix the in fact I know know they mix the two if Administration doesn't want to take the Heat or they're not really sure where it came from they always say it's the Board of
080Education whether we made that decision or not it doesn't matter we're the scapegoats and that's fine but I don't know that it's accurate so thank you I appreciate what you have done this is this is great um I also have some other items I want to discuss along this topic but it's not a question okay okay is there anything else for Jeff because we won't make him stand there with his leg okay and if you have any feedback on the draft now keep in mind it's just a concept it was very quickly put together but if you have any like offline please send me just your feedback and of course it will be refined as we go but please send that feedback to me on the draft and suggestions on how we can streamline this
081information to our employees it's great awesome thank you that's great thank Youk you yeah I I personally love the idea because I do think there's there's just so much distance between the board and our employees and they don't know sometimes what we're doing so just more information I think will be better okay um I think Mrs Oaks has something then Karen again so yeah I want to reiterate kind of what Karen said I over the last six years that I've been doing this I've lost count how many times I've had faculty members or sometimes even um School admin come to me and say why did you make this decision and I'm like I I have no idea what you're even talking about like where you know they've been told that the board has made a
082certain call on something and literally it's it's completely new to me so I don't know how to effectively address that other than you know some of what Jeff was suggesting but I do think that that's kind of a common issue so okay thank you anyone else or should we um Mrs Nar and then we'll go back to Karen okay I super appreciate what Jeff presented I think that's great um I H I know Karen has a probably a few things yes so um I have a few things that I I wanted to highlight so first just looking at our part right how people feel supported it was very awesome and I'd like to celebrate the fact that our teachers we grew plus 2% that they're feeling valued and supported by us um I I noticed
083that the esps it's minus 7% um and looking at last year's negotiations with pay and salary it'd be really interesting to do a follow-up question because people feel valued in two different ways how they're compensated and pay and then how we communicate to them of how appreciative we are of their value right and and it's different for for different people and I think it's very important for us to understand you know where is this coming from because it was minus 7 and the administrators was minus three but teachers was plus two the one thing I do know is in the last four years we have raised teachers salaries it it seems to be directly linked to compensation so I think it'd be really good to have follow-up questions how are you feeling valued or not
084valued and have some open-ended response because I would really like to know how so we can better address that um some of those things we have more latitude that way than others right um the other thing that I wanted to just celebrate for a moment as a board is I really loved the growth of being valued by their Community plus 8% that's pretty awesome and that is a that is a thank you to our wonderful Community right that that appreciates and supports um I also wanted just to highlight that the teachers said plus 7% when they're feeling overwhelmed that administrators are helping them so hats off to our administrators that's an amazing growth and I think having sat on the EMT committee the last few years uh the fact that we had a plus 7%
085that teachers and faculty to Jeff I know he's the director of that committee I was like yes like plus 7% that they understand how to respond in a state of emergency that is a huge jump and that is something that we addressed as a committee does everyone in the building understand and know what the plan is so that's pretty awesome um the supervisor support plus 12% that's amazing plus 12% with your your local supervisor so I just wanted to celebrate that um a few things that I feel like um need more of direct detention was also um the administrators are saying that there are not realistic expectations for them that's that's minus 7% and I think that's something that as a board we've talked about before in different study sessions and maybe committee work but
086I think what's required of our administrators today is considerably growing especially with the level of communic ation between parents and themselves and how much they're inundated with needing to respond and and that they're you know their list of to-dos is so long um I know meeting with my administrators another thing that has been mentioned is how many times we're pulling them out of their building for different meetings and some of the meetings of course are so crucial and so vital but making a cognizant effort to to think about how many times we're pulling them out of their building I think we need to do a deeper dive on why the administrator what what can we do on our end right so that with those expectations so that's a takeaway that I would love to discuss
087as a board and then the other thing that I really noticed was professional development went down by 6% with us providing opportunity so I feel like I don't know the best way how to but I feel like some of these really big glaring ones I feel like we need to be discussing as a board obviously it's going to be in human centered supports and then hopefully brought back to us is that the plan with some of these bigger ones because I I would love to have human- centered supports come back to us with those okay thank you Mrs Dolly thank you and thank you for doing this because this is very Vital Information um it would definitely be nice to get some more specific feedback on items and how get some suggest questions uh from
088our our community our staff as to how to improve in some of these areas because certainly there's there's some uh start call outs for the board um that we've got some work to do and just to help people feel involved and so maybe a suggestion even is uh ways that figure out a way that there's a board specific recognition program that we're in the schools recognizing teacher staff um along those lines and then I noticed also that that PD and and some of these things I think our communication issues you know communicating to our esps about what PD opportunities they have and and talking to our different contract groups um even our administrators here's opportunities you have conferences stuff in house stuff in state and and compiling that all into one place might be helpful
089for uh them Mrs Peterson okay I passed out this paper because after our human Center supports meeting I called Amber and I was really upset and not that that I didn't think that the board the our teachers and our administrators understood us but I think that we could do a better job and so I knew that we needed to talk about doing making some making sure our culture is correct and that we're doing the right kinds of things when it comes to making decisions that affect our employees um the one that concerned me the very most was and that's what I gave you a copy of is the district leadership comments and um they kind of tie in together it says I need the board and superintendent to trust administrators to make decisions that are
090best for our schools this has not been true for a few years the Board of Education continues to micromanage all man all aspects of our district which has eroded trust efficiency and Effectiveness admin are undermined and demoralized on a routine basis as their knowledge and expertise are blatantly dis regarded by the Board of Education better relationships with the Board of Education a filling of care and respect for the work the administrators do every day there is no feeling of support or trust that comes from the board of Administrators those three kind of tie in together let me go with the last two the Board of Education needs to listen to teachers and administrators as much as they listen to parents I feel that often the loudest and most privileged parent voices get heard often to
091the detriment of other students and staff feeling supported by our school board and not having to worry about public blindsided attacks when they don't agree with the recom recommendations of Educators those are very specific and I really feel very strongly that we need to create an atmosphere of trust I'm going to use that word a lot this year this is kind of my key word you know how you pick a word for the year that's my year my word trust I honestly think we have the best Educators and best administrators in the district and sometimes when they come up and they'll present from their committees or share even from their well not so much from their schools but when they present from their committees we ask a million and a half detailed questions which would
092be great but I I don't know that they are the people that we need to ask sometimes we need to ask each other we're on the board on those committees maybe we could talk about that I think we do micromanage I will just say that and when we talk about well my constituent said this and my constituent said that we represent this the employees as well so I think we need to balance our point of view from what we're hearing from our community and parents particularly with what we hear as we're talking to our Educators and our principles they need to know that we're really there I I guarantee all our principles don't feel this strongly I guarantee it um because usually you do get the ones that feel the strong EST and often it's
093in a negative way but an example of micromanaging is when we almost had the principles when we were doing the uh extra planning time for elementary teachers is when we asked that we needed to see every school's plan okay that's micromanaging that's way overstepping I know they'll work it out for their school and if they don't we'll hear about it and then we can address it but I really feel strongly that um um we need to be careful that what we're asking them to provide for us isn't just interesting information for you but that it really truly makes addition uh a difference in our decision if it's a detail that you'd like to know more about maybe you could make a Comm a a a meeting with that particular leg you principal or administrator and
094have them explain it to you but I don't know that we need to mandate it from the board I think that's part of the problem is that they feel like we're always asking them to do one more thing that what they've brought to us and you've seen the detail that our presentations have in it miles and miles and hours and hours and hours of information that they've compiled for us to see and then we ask one more thing I think that's pushing it over pushing it over does that mean we never ask questions not at all but I think we're not always asking them in the right time in the right place we see those presentations before they present them if you see something maybe you should we could it's been said go to the
095person that's presenting and ask let's take advantage of that um I love what Communications has proposed um we'll have to look and see which is the most effective I think you want to probably try all three and then see what your response is or we can get see what anyway somehow we'll find out what the response is I don't know that you'd want to do all three all the time but it could be a one one week one another one another week or rotating because too much information becomes no information because they stop looking but I really like the the things that you're looking at and I would like us maybe as a board we were writing little notes to to our teachers about things that we recognize that they were doing extra I think
096we should also include the achievements and positive changes that the principles have made to change their schools we have amazing cultures in in a lot of our buildings and we know that because we go into those buildings we need to let our community know more of what our schools are doing I mean just brag we need to blow that horn for them they are so busy and we're in there and we represent them as much as we represent our community it's it's it's the whole process and I just thought it was funny I put crankshaft at the top because I thought that's kind of how it works out and for those that don't have my paper I'll read it it says here's how we'll deal with the school bus driver shortage first the school board
097will explore options soliciting suggestions to help remedy things then they'll form a committee to consider the suggestions and then the parents can hear the committee's recommendations and then the board can meet to consider the parents feedback on their recommendations and by that time school year will be over I think we put too many layers some of that pressure that they're feeling so I I I I will take ownership I think it comes from the board I think some of it we're putting a little more emphasis on the details when we need to look at the intent so I know that there's more things that you want to say and I'm not trying to criticize but I do want us to be aware that I don't know that we've always looked out at what we're saying
098and the effect that what we do is affecting our employees and our principles yeah by the way all your positive stuff was awesome okay hly you know what Mr edel was next so sorry if mine was negative Holly's was positive mine's a little more negative and it was I know that we're doing so well in those other areas I think principles are the concern that I have the most of so that's why I brought this forward for us to talk about so I'm not really trying to judge us as much as bring up things I think we need to be aware of yeah we can always get better um okay Mr Ed so I feel like this conversation's neither positive nor negative it's it's a look at you know ourselves and our communication uh which
099Speaking of that I did have um some really good feedback that came from um one of our Educators and some things that were said made me realize too that my choice of words matter um so constituent for example uh in the past I've used for every single person who communicates with me but it might be seen differently right some people might think of that as parent whereas it could be an educator it could be a Community member um uh because in my mind mind everyone matters and I'm accountable to to everyone um so anyway some of the feedback uh that I got was instead of flooding the same message 10 different ways was to um vary it so for example uh celebrate 10 different groups or people or board relationships um in 10 different ways
100of communicating rather than one celebration in 10 different forms of communication and then as I thought about this uh I think one of the hard things for me is when I go visit with teachers or staff or really anyone it's hard for me to capture that or to tell that story because it feels really self- serving um but I guess if the story is never told it never happened uh and so I a lot of my things that I'll publish are more likely to be students because I feel less bad about um sharing those stories and the students are always really excited every time they're mentioned um but when I go and visit with teachers or um a cafeteria workers or uh I mean I like to wander around and and talk to people in
101the district offices a lot too I like to talk to people um and I guess for me it's hard because one I don't know a good way to capture that and then two I think capturing that is outside of my comfort zone and so got to work through that as well okay thank you Andrew um Holly I I just wanted to um as a followup with what that was really good thank you Mr edel um I think as a followup when I'm looking at really a lot of the larger negative percentage it is in the administrator section um the professional development that's not from the teachers that's the administrators the minus 6% expectations realistic minus 7% That's in the administrator section it's not in the teacher or the ESP um valued by the Board of
102Education was minus 3% um rely on colleagues for support in my building minus 6% um know what is expected of me minus 6% and the benefits packaged minus 7% so um their overall General satisfaction is pretty high um you know looking at that it was 80 85% so that's pretty high but it's just those specifics where we're because you know if you just glance through this document quickly and you're saying wait we're not providing professional development but those plc's but this is for administrators that are saying that they're not receiving the professional development that they would like so I think it would be really great just to get some more followup with the administrative group specifically and then um esps it looks like it's minus 5% in professional development for them and minus 7% invalu
103um by the Board of Education so maybe some followup there but I I see those as two specific groups teachers the only two negative percentages with salary and benefits and they're less of a negative than you know they're like two and three% but anyways I think um I'm excited to see what the human centered supports comes back with I would love as that um I don't know if other board members would but I would love and Katie echoed it I would really love to get a little more specific information and followup questions about this okay so thank you let me ask the superintendent at this point because I do feel like some of the some of the things need to be addressed well most of the things need to be addressed by the administration but
104is that the right committee to look at these things or I don't I don't know so I just kind of want to get your input on if you have any ideas and just what the next step should yeah thank you president shill just a couple of thoughts first off um you know I I I look at all the great things that the board has done over the last few years in the decisions rather rather that's in compensation or leave or prep time or daycare um you know there's so many things that that um I think we forget frankly and and we just move on and we you know probably could spend more time reflecting but I just thinking about kind of the spectrum and the Paradigm that the board's in and really any leadership roll
105and this comes down to kind of the governance piece and administration right so if you lay that over a spectrum from one end you really have this place of compliance and efficiency like you are ultimately responsible for the district and the budget and meeting and meeting the needs of constituents employees parents all the above right but then on the other side of that Spectrum you have uh true efficacy or the the empowering people to do their job and that's more on a servant model right and in the center piece to that is where the sweet spot is and that's relationships so you know how you balance that you're constantly in a push pull between those targets right and and I think you know one thing that we probably could do better across the board including
106myself is recognizing that we're we all move back and forth in that Spectrum you know on different decisions sometimes I see administrators including myself really pushing the boundaries on governance right like things like policy then other times board members can go the other direction on more administrative responsibilities when it comes to this servant model and maybe that's in curriculum or human resources or whatever Falls more on the administration side but at least I I think us having ongoing conversations just about in our committee work about recognizing where those are at so that you know we have a kind of a cognizance that where does that lie um because many times you know with all the issues that we deal with they're very emotionally charged right so we come at it with all the emotions and
107everything that's in our backpack and our history uh to the table and frankly you think about public educ ation most people you know in the world have background in public education most people in the world have don't have a background in law or in medicine or in whatever but we're all experts in public education and that and that comes to play right that bears out whether it's the legislature or our own feelings about you know policy or whatever it is that we're working on so I think more than anything just recognizing that and continuing to develop that and then just you know focusing on relationships it really is one person at a time and one administrator at a time one teacher at a time and I see you all out you know whether it's listening
108tour or visiting schools it is hard to capture that but but those are you know that's the that's the bank of trust right and then when you have to pull credit from that to make a hard decision that may affect people most of the time you are going to make people unhappy no matter what the decision is it's kind of like calling a snow day when Leon and I and Jeff and McKay are up at 4:00 a.m. I know we're going to be dead wrong no matter what I'm going to get emails at about 7: a.m. why did you call this the day or why did you keep us in school right so recognizing that you got to give yourself some Grace too that you're the further you get away you know from the classroom
109and that's just how our system of democracy works and you know I think there's a lot of Beauty in that too about just the the wills turn that way um and so I think that's important too anyway those are just some comments okay thank you superintendent so I think um should we ask human centered support since they already did review the data to maybe like come up with a few suggestions or recommendations oh yeah Dr Mill is here perfect thank you for staying um okay let's let's move forward with that and I think we all like the communications idea because I do think Communications is a part of it so that will help so thank you Jeff and then thank you Laura again for being here and so Laura did send us in December I
110think she sent the full board all the comments right so I don't know if you two no new board members want do you want her to send you all the new all the comments okay could you do that to those two so they have all the information okay um thank you board U Mrs nyar one thought how does the board feel about just sending a letter of thank you to our administrators for that plus 7% like teachers are saying from this year to last year it's a plus s% that their administrators are helping them when they're feeling overwhelmed I would love to do a little celebration for the administrators have a letter and have as the Board of Education send something as a thank you and congratulations because I think that's something to celebrate okay
111is everyone's nodding so I believe we're all good with that okay thank you there is administrat when is administrator's month is that coming up or not for a while you guys it's October I think okay well let's do the letter right now then yeah yeah and will you send a draft to the board yeah that' be great that'd be awesome okay thank you thanks for that idea that's great okay so the next item on the agenda is just staff comments so superintendent do you have any report not tonight thank you okay Mr will Cox just uh quickly uh as we talk about our strategic plan the focus groups uh last week the legislative auditor general that's the ones who represent the legislature are putting together a best practices handbook for school districts and other and
112Charter Schools uh they called me we spent about an hour on a zoom call going over how we developed our strategic plan and how we're conducting the focus groups ongoing they were very impressed with that I want to include that somewhat as an example for other leas moving forward so uh it did get their has gotten their attention we've commented that on other when other districts have had gone through their audit process with them so I just wanted to bring that out that uh that was going to be part of their best practices is moving forward with the developing the plan getting the focus groups who help develop the plan and then keep the plan of living document as we've tried to do that's all I have thank you thank you Mr wi Cox and
113we will start with Mrs peton tonight for board comments um I was excited to have the opportunity that we have each year to go to the Utah School boards Association conference they many people may not know but school boards also have professional development and that is provided in our association and they train us from everything from law to current top issues and it's fun to rub shoulders with Educators leaders of Educators all the school boards from all over the state I did get to attend um one of my um workshops or one of the courses that I attend was presented by Alpine district superintendent I didn't write down his name sorry but he had a a topic called live and Lead better and it was it ties right into what we've been talking about because
114his presentation is how superintendent and um support the school board and Leadership and then I mean how we work together as a group and there his emphasis was on if you want to improve a school then if if you want School Improvement then you put your emphasis on people because teachers directly affect student learning school leaders indirectly affect student learning and principls affect teacher efficiency and District leaders directly affect School leaders so the chain we all affect one another and it boil down to what their district is doing to try and build relationships which is what Rick was just talking about with their principles and then the principles have been doing have been sharing that information with their teachers um I thought one of the funnest activities um they're basing this on a book by
115Eric poterat learned excellence and what he was saying is that we need to build on the strengths of our leaders and not always look at their deficits I mean it's so much easier Human Nature always looks at the Negative Zone that we're trying to build on the strengths and he was trying to figure out how can we bring more joy to the job for everyone so they were trying to be more proactive and I thought one of the cool things they do and they meet um once a month but they actually had um their principles give three references as if they were going to get a job that but could tell that would write them a letter about what they do well and they had at least three sometimes more people they sent them out
116they actually sent that request to their references and brought them back and then shared them at a principal's meeting with the principles we always are telling them what else they need to do to get better and what was really fun about this is that they had heard what are the strengths that other people see in them now we've I've done this with my kids in class but do we do it with the adults and uh then they gave them a vend diagram and they listed all the qualities that they say about themselves and they had them fill that in first before they read the letter and then they had them fill in what they had said that they didn't say and then what they had in common so they did a little Vin diagram and
117then they were asked to choose something that they're good at that they wanted to get even better at that when they were choosing professional development and when they were meeting with their principles for goals it wasn't on a weakness it was on a strength what would you like to be even better at what would you like to be the Prof you know the expert at and that just the attitude changed a lot of the perception of the principles and then it filtered down to their teachers so um his his comment was is that we don't rise to our goals we settle to our systems and so I thought it was really interesting that um their process was to instill hope and joy in their principles and I thought exactly what Dr Robbins had said we
118need to really work on those relationships with our with our principles and so that was a fun you know I really enjoyed what I was able to take out of that class and then I went to another one that was called teacher believed in me and uh that was talking about how we can avoid suicide it was interesting how many had different relationship basis they were a lot of positivity about what we can do to bring out the good because the world is so good at telling us about the negative so I've really enjoyed that I'm looking forward to um it's that season again I get to I have tickets already to go see albian Singing in the Rain albian middle is putting that on this weekend and then um Hillcrest is doing a dual
119cast one night they're doing boys uh all boy cast doing um lord of the r Lord of the Flies no rings flies Lord to the Flies and then they're doing an all girl cast and then the contrast between the two which is really kind of amazing so I'm going to the all girl cast performance and I think it'll be really fun so I appreciate the opportunities that our schools provide for us and our community to be exposed to Great literature and then to offer opportunities to learn from it so I'm looking forward to that I appreciate it okay thank you Mrs Dolly thank you and I I appre appreciate the um survey results uh there's a quote that my daughter shared with me my college AG daughter says feedback is just feedback it's neither good
120nor bad it's an opportunity to improve and uh talking about Karen's the same presentation they said that did the degree to which a person can grow is directly proportional to the amount of Truth they can accept about themselves without running away so we appreciate the feedback and uh using it for an opportunity improve that we can better support our c Community um I'm thankful for our superintendent and going out with the listening to her the opportunity to meet with our faculty and staff in the district and to learn from them and and please you know share us all the feedback you have because we're looking for opportunities to improve and a happy birthday to our our superintendent this week okay thank you Mrs Oaks okay so thank you so much I Echo what Karen said
121about usba that I it was a great opportunity to learn some more um I want to congratulate all the teachers and students for as of today officially starting the second half of the school year we're now on the downhill slide everyone so my kids were kind of excited about that um I also enjoyed the superintendent listening tours I got to go to Sunrise elementaries and alter Altera elementaries I really love that um superintendent Robins has been doing that I think it's a wonderful opportunity for our teachers to be able to give us very specific feedback and um share their concerns in in a very comfortable Forum um the student advisory Council last week was a awesome I really shared how open and candid the kids were with us about um subjects relating to um Project
122based learning and Hands-On learning as well as um safety whe whether or not they feel safe and and why not um what areas we could improve I also um enjoyed being able to have a town hall meeting last week at Indian Hills Middle School and had a number of parents from that Community come and share concerns with me and questions um specifically um the most Salient of which was regarding um Chinese immersion in the Lone Peak and Indian Hills and Ela feeder systems and um we can discuss some of that more later but um that was something that was of note I'd like to um um a couple requests that I just wanted to make while we're here as a group and I don't know if we want to kind of um Sion these off
123to various committees but um one of the feedback pieces that we got on the listening tour and it and I've heard this from multiple BTS teachers the Beverly Taylor Sorenson teachers that we promis them um in the fall a survey about how things are going with the new Elementary schedule and they wondering what's happening with that and so I would like to formally request that that happens I don't know if that goes through high quality learning or I don't know probably high quality learning just a comment on that Amanda um I I shared that with Amber and Alice and Sally and they email me back and they're working on that right now great so that's awesome okay and then the other thing I've just been thinking tonight um in light of so many of the
124the changes that have happened and what things are making a positive difference what aren't I'm interested in knowing um and maybe getting a report on the success thus far of the early out schedule that we have with the high schools and those iplcs um do we see that making a difference like what what has helped what hasn't like where do we is the needle moving or if if not what do we need to do to change that so that's those are two of the Salient thoughts I have um this evening and I also just want to throw a shout out um this coming Friday is the battle of the bands at Corner Canyon High School and they have for they're normally happy if they get five or six they have 11 so they're starting at
1255 o'clock in the afternoon but they have a lot of really eager and excited kids and I don't know if any of you guys have ever gone to any of the Battle of the Bands it's usually run by the PTSA they are a kick in the pants there's so much fun so the kids I'll have to each band has to do one cover and they have to come up with one original number and then the kids go on to Regions and then there's a state competition and it's a big deal and they talk about it for years after it's really fun and then um next or on January 30th um for the first time ever our district will have a lunar New York New Year celebration it's happening at Corner Canyon at 6 PM there's
126going to be performances from all of our Chinese imersion elementary schools um actually I don't think Ridge Crust Elementary is performing but they are coming and we have um representation from Indian Hills Middle School Draper Park Middle um I think from some kids from Brighton High School and definitely from Corner Canyon um selfishly I just full disclosure my daughter decided to do this she started the Chinese Club at Corner Canyon this this last year and realized that um all of the different school districts around us including Provo Jordan School District Alpine School District a number of different school districts they have these huge Lunar New Year celebrations and we've never had one so she started small and it just snowballed from there Kirsten is over there smiling because she's been really helpful and we have
127representation from some of our um various Partners around the state that are going to come and share um opportunities that these kids can um enjoy as a result of their language proficiency so I would encourage anyone who's associated with the program or not just come and celebrate the new year it'll be a lot of fun and the kids get really excited they're adorable when they get up there some of them are doing Kung Fu and others are singing it's really cute so anyway okay thank you Mr edel uh so my highlights were that I got to visit with the AL ofie Elementary student council um and you have not seen true excitement until you've heard that it's about time to start penny wars uh so uh yeah they they were they were pretty thrilled with
128that uh they were doing a a really fun activity to uh help recognize the teachers and some of the great things that they do and it was fun to meet with them um I also met uh with the Jordan High School student body officers and uh that was definitely the highlight of some of the visits I've had and as soon as we got past that you know wall of ice that they had at the beginning where they don't want to say anything uh the floodgates opened and uh we had a great discussion uh and I still need to uh continue to go through some of my notes that I took from that um but I did promise that I would bring forward one of their items um which is that they said that they would
129really love to have the Friday schedule every day uh they made some good points to to argue for that too um but uh anyway I appreciate uh our students for talking to me I appreciate uh the Educators that we have over that over those programs um and the time that they were able to carve out for that uh it is it's nice for me to be able to meet with the students and then it's also nice for me to have some opportunities to um meet with some of our uh School staff before and after those happen as well um I I enjoy being out in our schools and uh will continue to do so and that's all I've got for tonight okay thank you Mr leis all right uh so it's been I've been in
130this office for about two weeks which is a little bit weird to think about it's gone by super fast um so my highlights over the last couple weeks obviously going to usba that was super informative super awesome uh meeting with a state uh meeting with Schoolboard members from across the state and even state school board members that was super cool uh this morning I got to I was invited to tour Mid Valley Elementary School I learned about their food and nutrition rules which is which is you can't bring food into the school and it apparently it's really helped with the culture there it's really been productive and keeping uh peanut out and just keeping keeping an inclusive uh healthy environment that's something I got to learn about today as well as uh the amazing dual
131language immersion program at Mid Valley I got to sit in on one of their Spanish speaking classrooms and it was it was incredible I I I was even joking to uh the person who's walking me around I need to sit in on more of these Classics because I do not know how to speak Spanish so that's something I might be doing um I also got to sit in on the student advisory committee that was incredible I loved it uh uh it's there's been many notes been made about how young I am uh obviously that's the truth uh I like I I I talk about often I like to bring student perspective to the board I can only do that if I can remain connected to the student body because the more further I go from
132being a graduate the less of a student I am so I really appreciated that opportunity um that's all I've got okay thank you Mrs nbar well first off I wanted to say thank you to Dr Robbins um in our study session as we were kind of going back in time he was talking about 2020 and he was brought to the district about six months before I was sworn in for the first time and and thinking about how far we've come and the direction he has helped lead us has been incredible so thank you for your service to this district and for doing such a great job and I also wanted to just say thank you to our administrators funny enough that actually was my comments before I saw the survey uh I was able to
133sit down with two of my administrators just this past week and you know you sit down with with these amazing for me it was two women the you know separately but these amazing women and as we sit and delve into the specc specifics of their school and what they're facing and they challenges and how they're rising to the occasion I'm just in total awe not of not only of what they do but how they do it um it's incredible and for those you know half hour or so I feel like I'm I I'm living in their shoes and I'm just in awe at all that they accomplished during their day I think as a board member whenever we filled phone calls of concerned parents you know we get that little flavor that little taste of
134what our ad administrators are going through through every day right but they hear from so many and so I'm very grateful to them and for their dedication to our schools it was fun um driving up to Willow Springs they have the flags of all the different countries strung along their fence it's also inside their building um Willow Springs is one of those elementary schools that has definitely had a lot of changes in the last few years as far as um multilanguage Learners moving into the area and being part of the school community and it's really neat to see how they are embracing that um they had a little diversity Bingo talking about different cultures that the kids participated in um in December that was super cool and it's neat to see all the different ways
135they're they're integrating everyone so super neat about that um also we have a little problem um which I think a lot of our schools do with drop off right the traffic can kind of get all jammed up and parents like to kind of stop right where it's easiest for their kid to run out of the car and maybe cause a little bit of that jam-pack situation in the parking lot so Willis Springs has this new parking lot safety plan and um I was hearing about it and and you know the principal was saying yeah it's going to be great Willie the Wild Cat's going to be out there directing traffic we're also going to have parents and of course an alltime cold spell right um Monday morning yesterday morning and and I'm seeing these amazing
136dedicated parents of our community in gloves and hats and scarves directing traffic so how how awesome is our community for doing that um in uh 2003 I walked into a little converted frat house uh that was converted into a church building in Cleveland Ohio and I walked in and there was this little woman very tiny little woman her name was Robbie Penman she was 102 years old she welcomed me to the area and then she started telling me a little about a little bit about her story and her story was that she would send her sons with Martin Luther King Jr out to doorsteps with pamphlets about love and unity and that she would then have him over for dinner afterwards with her sons and uh really amazing little lady really amazing to hear firsthand
137experiences she had with him I wanted to share a few quotes from Martin Luther King Jr uh probably one of my very favorites is out of the Mountain of Despair a stone of Hope love is the only Force capable of transforming an enemy into a friend um in our student advisory committee this week this last week uh one thing that was brought up is these Rogue Instagram accounts that are are created by students and how it really drags down the the morale of the student body and that kids are made fun of and and what started out to be humorous you know um maybe in good fun it kind of goes over to this other area that's really inappropriate and not okay um I know that all of our high schools suffer from this problem
138and you know I know uh the high school I represent also has had some really and very tragic and and sad things in that account and it's very difficult for administrators to find out which kids are running it and then what happens is it's shut down and then it's reopened with a new name with new kids running it um there's a quote by Martin Luther King that says in the end we will remember not the words of our enemies but the Silence of our friends and I hope hope that we can teach our our sons and our daughters and the kids and students in our community that it just takes a little bit of moral courage if you see that going on to go ahead and report it and to not participate because it can
139really be damaging to your peers um I'm super grateful for the opportunity we have to go and support all these kids and all the different programs they have I really enjoyed at Christmas um going into Willow Springs and seeing their cute little Christmas concert uh it's pretty amazing uh our cute music leader said can you believe it I've only met with some of these kids twice in December and they knew those songs and their actions and and it was it was probably one of the highlights for me of December uh we have so much opportunity to do so much good and I look forward to helping our our kids and our community see what a difference they can make in in friendship and kindness and thank you that's it okay thank you um Bor there's
140a couple things I wanted to um ask you about and first of all is um do we want to still continue to do thank you notes so Jackson and Katie we have been doing thank you notes um that we get and there A lot of times they're the people we recognize during board meeting during Canyon strong um but I'm just wondering do we want to continue that board yes yes okay okay we do so um we will continue to work on that I just wanted to make sure we wanted to do that um also I was just able to attend a couple of listening tours at Bella Vista and albian and I just really appreciate the superintendant continuing to do those and they are really informative to kind of get a feel on the ground
141of concerns our teachers have so I would just recommend board members if there's any way that you can go to them it's it's really good and informative and I just want to thank the board for our discussions tonight I think it's been a great meeting and it is before n um I will call this meeting to a close thank you