CorpusRecord 80132

February 18, 2025 Board of Education Study Session Live Stream

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Granite Schools
Date
2025-02-19
Location
Salt Lake County, UT
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,483 words · about 109 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001um welcome everyone to our our Board of Education study session it is February 18th 2025 5 PM we're GNA Begin by indicating who's here we're GNA start with Julie because she is online Connie Burgess Kim Chandler Chris win Karen W Clark Nelson Ben Nicole mcder and Todd Harbor will be here any minute I'm sure all right um first item as far as I know we don't have any patr participation signups is that correctly okay we have some consent items um we've had these for a few days to be able to ask any questions if there's no questions I will entertain a motion I move we accept the consent agenda I'll second we have a motion and a second to approve the consent agenda is there any any further discussion all in favor please say I

002I I Julie did you say it okay all right just want to make sure any post all right motion carries we're going to move on to our action item we have administrative appointments um and if there are no questions here I will also entertain a motion for us I move the we accept the admitt ministrative appointments I'll second we have a motion a second to accept the can I make a comment before you call for a vote yeah thanks so this list that I was sent yesterday I got to it and uh in kind of another situation where two weeks ago we lost Tyler how and I was really sad and then I looked at the list and about lost to my heart I'm looking at two of my favorite principles over here who are

003going to be appointed in just a minute and I realized I did the math that that's 23% of my precinct I'm losing my principles and so for my Gorly people and my far Ro people just know I'm still fighting for you and while I wish these principles well and I'm so excited to have you and your new upcoming positions where you can really embrace our new vision a direction take all of that back to our schools and help not only one school but a lot of schools and like I said truly go my mic truly um get behind the new direction we're trying to take our district and get behind Ben as superintendent and get behind the board so I'm really excited no I'm sad but I'm really excited to see you guys in your

004new position and holding our principles accountable and also helping them helping them catch the vision that we're trying to get others to catch so I just want to send my love and fars with and gorley and my Lancers same thing um so we're I'm not forgetting about you um even with this little bit of turnover and the admin fer has had this will be four principles in seven years um that's tough on any community so but we're we're fighting for you and we'll do our best to take care of you thanks Ken all right any further discussion all right all in favor please say I any opposed right motion carries I'm G to turn the time over to Ben all be before I turn the time over to Dr how to make introductions I just

005want to Echo uh Karen sentiments and I appreciate she said that so so kindly and nicely is a little bit different than the Emojis I was getting over the weekend um but uh I can appreciate her consternation and concern that's a big gap out of uh some of our most needy communities and these are Stellar individuals and um I gave a charge to Dr how and the folks on his hiring committee uh to find the best instructional leaders in the district to help us uh set our focus on instru instructional Improvement and and improving student outcomes and uh we had a stellar group of individuals apply for these positions I I could not have been more pleased to see the best and the brightest and so truly um it it came down to fit in

006some regards and uh we're very grateful for these appointments tonight and I'm going to turn the time now over to Dr how to introduce these phenomenal individuals thank you superintendent and good evening to the board and to our executive leadership team um I'm new to this but I want to Echo what I just heard our superintendent say um I've been very privileged over many years to do lots and lots and lots of interviewing and I do not feel I've ever been in the kind of experience I was this last week of the caliber of Administrators that we have in our school district and their dedication and their work um was one of the hardest processes that I've ever been a part of um and I I celebrate each of those individuals who are part of

007the process and I'm excited to get to celebrate those who are are newly appointed and get to do some introductions but um it was a privilege and a burden to be a part of and I'm I'm excited to get to be here for that um I'm going to say some names and have these individuals stand up and then we'll get a chance to be get to know not just them a little bit more but their family members if we could our first person we want to recognize is Wes Cutler Wes if you could stand up for us Wes is being appointed a secondary school leadership and Improvement director just to give you a little background on Wes Wes has been a social studies teacher at Evergreen Junior High School he was an assistant principal at

008Granger Elementary and Olympus High School and is currently the principal at Evergreen no that's incorrect at Eisenhower Junior High School caught a typo here Wes will be a secondary school leadership and Improvement director as stated previously Wes can you do introductions this is my wife next we want to recognize Amber Clayton Amber if you could stand up Round of Applause for Amber Amber is being appointed a elementary school leadership and Improvement director she has been assistant principal in Salt Lake and Davis School District she's been principal at GR Elementary mil Creek Elementary and Woodstock Elementary she's currently an associate director of K12 literacy and curriculum and instruction congratulations Amber can you re uh introduce anybody who came with you or my H had a procedure wonderful we're going to make her present later and that's

009what happens when you don't bring other people with you next we want to recognize Wendy level Wendy if you could stand up Wendy is also being appointed as Elementary School leadership and Improvement director Wendy has been a third grade teacher at Crestview Elementary she was an intern assistant principal at benan Junior High Academy Park Elementary and Farnsworth Elementary she was principal at Western Hills Elementary and is currently the principal at Farnsworth Elementary School Wendy can you do introductions [Music] some with red hair we identified there congratulations and finally we want to recognize Brier matui Brier also being recognized as a um Elementary School leadership and Improvement director Brier is taught at West Kern's Taylorville Elk Run and Armstrong um Academy Brier was a title one instructor instructional coach at jackling Elementary uh she was an

010administrative intern at diamond ridge gorley element and gorle elementary schools um so congratulations to Brier she's being um appointed to be an elementary leadership and Improvement director can you introduce your family today Bri thank you round of applause for you it would be great um a big thank you from me to this group I'm excited to get to talk to you a lot more um we get to start a journey together but I'm excited about this I'm excited about all you've accomplished in the past and your desire to keep building Granite School District in every way you possibly can thank you thank you Dr how and please say hello to your families while you can cuz you're not going to see them very much anymore we're going to be working really hard just kidding we're

011so glad and excited to have you be part of our instructional leadership team you're amazing and we so appreciate support of your families here tonight we are thrilled to have you guys on board we're sad to see those leave who are leading but we are so excited for these new ones so thank you you're welcome to stay it's a thrilling meeting where you can go all right we're GNA go ahead and move on we have an information item excuse me Dr Converse is g to come up and we're gonna present on curriculum adoption thank you thank you you board President mcdermit and Vice President WN board members um as you're becoming more aware we have this new instructional adoption process that requires a couple um interactions with the curriculum that um you are looking at

012to re as recommended for adoption so this is the first of those two so I'll just quickly go over slides that you've all seen before um and and you can ask any questions you might have um so the objective for these is to Pro provide a summary of the acquisition of the curricular instructional materials and then to introduce the first reading of the request for proposal um after our instructional um materials adoption committee has already gone through the RFP and are making the formal ad uh adoption recommendation so um there's three pieces of legislation and policy that apply here one is the the Senate Bill 55 which actually um transformed what we used to do with a single adoption to a TW meeting adoption and then with the public review in the middle and then

013that's based on our Utah code and then we have um built our our Granite board policy to support that existing legislation just for a quick review of definitions um in the legislation the existing code learning materials are U materials or any resource used to deliver or support a student's learning instructional materials are materials that a local board adopts and approves for use with the Lea and then there are supplemental materials and those are materials that are adopted at the school level or at the individual teacher level and they um are not approved or adopted by the board formally um but they by all legislation and code that exists um and they uh are they adhere to our curriculum topics guide so we have two kinds of instructional material core instructional materials um which are large

014scale adoptions like the one we're talking about tonight uh which is a secondary Ela um adoption and um that accompanies a RFP or a request for proposal and and um applies to all of our accounting and purchasing uh rules as well and policies and then there are also ancillary instructional materials those are materials like assessments or other um ancillary tools that we might also centrally adopt so just to know the difference between those two two pieces but they also go through an RFP process so according to s sp55 on the local board is uh must make instructional materials that the school district use as readily accessible and available for parent review right now we have all of these materials um up on the website it went out through Blackboard um we have uh um also

015have them on posted on social media and um and you received a copy of those materials so they're all able for View and we're collecting those parent comments as we speak those will be available for the next board meeting that we review the materials and then the the other part of this is to establish an open process involving Educators parents and students enrolled in the Lea to review and recommend the instructional materials for the board and that's what um our instructional materials adoption committee has been uh involved in recommending so as as the last slide said this is a little repetitive but um we post the recommended Learning Materials online to allow for review and then before adopting the recommended instructional materials to public meetings so this will be the first our second is hoped

016to be the March 4th uh date and um and this is to allow for adequate time for the public to review the materials to ask questions to have questions answered um and to provide any opinions they might have about the materials before formal adoption um and then finally we uh the board formally adopts or approves the instructional materials in an open board meeting and you've already received the links to these materials but they're still actively available to all of our patrons and um and those individuals who want to come in can also schedule an appointment to come in and review the materials questions just some clarification items you because I think I heard two different things this is the first meeting March board meeting with the second and final meeting right okay I thought I

017heard there would be a first reading and then a second reading so just confirming and then there's another um sexed curriculum as well that's being reviewed by the public right now is that just going to be approved so so the sexed materials are out for public review it's a bit of a different process they still have to follow we still have to follow the two board meeting rule but we have a different policy that preceded this legislation that actually um requires them to be out for 30 days in public review so they're out for public review we'll introduce those materials in the next board meeting and then those would not be formally recommended for approval until the April meeting okay thank you any other questions okay right thank you okay next up invite Ambert up

018get to learn about science of reading literacy I apologize I've got a spinning wheel of death is this the one that's later on in the presentation uh it is okay it'll probably just take a second there we go there we go don't look at my password okay so there they are the tab well I am finally ready and so excited to be with you today we get to talk a little bit about the science of reading and how it is impacting our state and our district and what's happening in our classrooms here in Granite so it's it's exciting to be here with you that one two fingers you can SC okay two fingers there we go so so we're going to talk about three things this afternoon we're going to talk about just a quick

019overview of Science of reading um and then we're going to talk about the implications of SB 127 on literacy instruction in Utah and then we'll talk about current trends that are happening in the school district so here we go so the science of reading is um it's a frustrating term to me because I think we see it capitalized in the literature as science of reading as if it's a defined like it's concrete that it's going to last forever that this is this is the end all in be all but really what it is it should be science of reading lowercase in that it is what we know about best practice at this current time based on the research and so it is going to evolve all our time so you're going to see lots of

020capitalization but I want you to think wider than that it's about using the very best that we know from science and applying it to the way we help um students learn learn how to read so according to the reading League the science of reading is a vast interdisciplinary body of scientist scientifically based research about reading and issues related to reading and writing we're going to watch a really short video now I challenge to Utah we need our own video this one's from West Virginia but in three minutes it really very quickly summarizes some of the key components reading is not a program and is not a couple of research studies that say this or that it's the body of scientific research over the last several decades that def proves how the brain to become a

021proficient reader and writer so when we something align science we me that it's that research what does the research say it some things you probably already know there are five awareness vocabulary and comprehension but the science also points to some things that are not common knowledge yet first written language is a contrived system the brain images show that reading and writing don't come naturally which is why high quality instruction is so important secondly B needs to be taught excit systematically with a scopen sequence but without is unusual term for something probably everywhere you may have heard it strateg sound Ms or problem that's not we ESS called ma that allows our to our F we can recognize picture of a the brain is hardwired sight and speech but the connections in our brains that possible

022don't get built we're using pictures or other cl to gu instead next highy need to be taught selling patterns as much as possible rather than ask students to [Music] memorize which me that students are a lot more eny aren't able to connect their sound spelling patterns to other similar words another is how comprehension works it isled science that the single biggest driver of reading comprehension is background knowledge of words in the world so we must intentionally build knowled and vocabulary about a variety of social studies and science topics from the moment students we can't wait as old go students are able learn the best way to build that text for comprehension instu Anda access to those test that requ sh away from the common practices EAS level T for struggling students because research students dur

023compreh finally the science points to the necessity of frequent shared and independent wri not just to inform others but as an essential learning tool to help students practic and Sye and communicate their understanding of topics so that's on the sence of reading on the look for more ofing videos deeper into there we go I think you can see in three minutes we covered a lot of territory one of the things that has really happened is that the especially in K2 the way we teach reading is much more scientific and structured and the great thing about that is it makes sure that all students develop the skills they need to be able to reader to be readers lost my you oh there we go there we go get on it they're frozen there there we go

024so we've got a lot of variety of areas of science that impacted the science of reading so cognitive psychology communication science developmental psychology education special education implementation science Linguistics neuroscience and school psychology so for somebody that's been teaching for 30 years the way we're teaching especially early early literacy has become much more detailed and Technical um and you know we're going to we're going to see the outcomes of that and more of our students being able to read earlier and not playing so much catchup down down the road oh my goodness this is not my computer I apologize just two fingers that way there we go what's really important um there's a lot of talk of the reading Wars and that some folks have tried to politicize what's happening I would stay away from science

025of reading considering it an ideology or ideology or philosophy because it's coming from science and the research it's not a bat it's not a trend it's not even really a new idea um it's not a political agenda even though for us it was sb127 that brought it to the state it it's really not a political agenda we just want all kids to be literate and to be able to read it's not a one-size fits-all program um it's not a program of instruction so sometimes folks will say we're teaching the science of reading we are not teaching the science of reading we're using science of reading strategies to help kids access our curriculum and to teach the standards um it's not a single specific component of instruction such as phonic it's much um bigger than that

026one of the things that we need to remember is that reading is not a a natural process I want you to think in your memory all of us have in our background a child a grandchild a neighbor a sibling who really struggle to learn how to read um reading is not a natural process speaking to a child typically ensures that they will learn to talk but not necessarily to read and while a uh important alone it will not yield fluent readers instead reading really requires explicit systemic and cumulative instruction and there's a uh real strategies for doing that in a way that make sure that we don't lose any students along the way this instruction builds connections between certain areas of the brain and these connections are really vital to reading in fact when you

027look at the brain Sciences probably some of the most interesting part of this where they've taken um readers along the Continuum and really studied their brains to see which areas of the brain are triggered and how over time for both reading and writing they're building connections between the different loaves of the brain so drors an Cunningham and David Rose note that beginning readers show more activity in the prial temporal region while more experienced readers become increasingly active in the aspal temporal um region and so they've even studied adults who can't read and areas of the brain just don't light up because that that information those connections aren't there so we really using the best of science to help more of our students learn to read so one of the basic comp uh concepts of the

028S of um the science of reading is the simple view of reading and it really says that if you want to get to reading comprehension you have to have two parts the first is word recognition and the second is language comprehension but you'll notice in between those two it's not an addition sign it's a multiplication sign so over 150 scientific Studies have empirically validated the simple view of reading it showed us shows us that reading comprehension is not the sum but the products of two components word recognition and language comprehension if either one of those is weak reading comprehension is diminished I I know that I came as a young teacher from the era of um of whole language and you know really maybe in my early career had some resistance to phonics what we've

029really found is it's not one or the other students really need both the science shows that we need strategic word study and word recognition skills but then we also need really enriching experiences with literature and non-fiction text in order for students to build all the background knowledge that they need to be able to apply those skills reading words in isolation doesn't help you comprehend but having somebody read something to you that you can't read for yourself in the end you've got to have both pieces in order for our students to access what they need to be able to access and do well in our schools here's another concept that's really important to the science of reading is Scar's reading R um and what this says is between that language comprehension domain and that word recognition

030there's some really important skills that need to happen so under language comprehension it's really critical that we're building background knowledge um that we're using academic vocabulary building vocabulary for students um that we're teaching the structure of the English language that we're helping develop their verbal re reasoning skills and that we are um teaching literacy literacy knowledge which is things like print concepts and genres and then on the word recognition size it recognition side it's phonological awareness decoding and sight recognition you can see both of those blend together to develop skilled readers it's not a one or the other from the very beginning in early literacy and I see Nan in the back um even down to preschool we want to catch them very early and to begin to develop these skills you can tell I'm

031just a little bit passionate about them just a little um this is really an important thing to share with you Louisa Moz who's very um a well-respected scientist in this field says that teaching reading is rocket science and and what I would say is you cannot passively teach early literacy K5 you really can't do it at the at the junior high and high school level either it really takes intentional practice and craft on the part of the teacher um and our investment in in our teachers especially with um coaching and professional learning is absolutely critical for them to be able to implement this science in a way that leads to more readers and stronger readers um so the way we break this down in Granite School District this is actually colorcoded for our new series

032hmh we we're trying to make the science accessible to our teachers so there are five pillars of literacy femic awareness fonic fluency vocabulary comprehension and writing um and this is actually the color codes of How It's found in their hmh materials so this system the purchase that we made I wasn't part part of the adoption but I'm really glad we purchased this particular product because it has been organized around the science of reading and makes it very easy for our teachers to find it in fact the the most biggest concern is it's almost too much but you saw how broad the science is so helping our teachers hone in on exactly what their students need that's what we're working for for professional learning and with coaching two fingers I will get it so for me

033we really simplify it and we have skills that fall under teaching kids to read so learning to read and those we Track by Acadian Alo um and that breaks down whether kids have pH basic pheic awareness skills phonic skills and fluency skills you're used to looking at those scores over time um that tell us how proficient our students are at reading what we really need if we're going to move Bry scores which I know is a is a big priority for the board is a lot of focus also on reading to learn and that's vocab comprehension and writing you you can't um divorce the two both are absolutely critical um for our students to be able to thrive all right so you can see that the learning to ride is all that bottom word recognition

034part of the scaros Rope so this is how the science is embedded here and the reading to learn part is that upper part that language comprehension so we're using the best of science um to make sure that we've got complete structures compl complete literacy blocks and in fact you'll see this is um the work of Becky Monson and collaborating with the state office my predecessor we've really worked this year on creating enough time enough time is defined by the the research of how much time students need in each of these components across the grade levels so there is a 120 minute literacy block is our Target and you can see it's organized around the simple V reading and Scar rolls rope and it's all laid out for teachers what should happen in each of those

035blocks now those blocks don't necessarily happen in 120 Minutes in one block they can be divided across the day but essentially we're hoping um and supporting our teachers in making sure that we don't leave anything out that they need to help kids to be able to read we got it I am really excited I want to show you we've been keeping what we're calling game film we've been out reporting teachers in Granite and watching the progress and the great things they're doing um this is Mrs Reba from stanbury elementary with her second grade as you watch I think she's really close to 90% mls in this particular class um but watch watch what they can do it's pretty exciting know watch you [Music] [Applause] all right I am completely biased because Miss Reba was a

036student teacher for me at Granger Elementary um and it was a joy to go in I actually got to visit her more more recent L where she was doing writing with the kids what you have to remember is how many of those students are Spanish speakers there is no long I in the Spanish language so they really need all kids need it but especially our MLS need really strategic specific explicit instruction in how English works so that they can internalize those things so that they can apply it when they're reading um it is a lot of repetition but this is about a 20 minute block for them that will later go on to writing and dictation they go through a whole set of skills in that time um but you could see the kids are

037really on one of the things that we found early on is our teachers really appreciate and value seeing their peers in Granite schools teaching they feel like those classrooms look like their classrooms um it's great to celebrate things that are going on you'll see people then reach out to Folks at other schools um to can I come see your classroom will you talk to me about that and so we're trying to build this whole network of teachers that are talking to an another and learning from one another we believe the talent is here in Granite and what we want to do is magnify um magnify that work all right now what am I doing the there we [Music] go clearly I am not Apple proficient here we go um one of the things I want

038you to know and this is this is really essential and it's something that we have to talk about all the time we are still teaching Utah language art standards they are what Drive our instruction and our Prof proficiency based learning um but we want to make sure always that we're teaching those standards in ways that have are evidence-based and with materials that are aligned to the science of reading um and that we're measuring progress over time to make sure that we're not losing um any of our students in the process that all kids are making good gains in this particular video we focused on those learning to read skills we also uh videos of the reading to learn that deep practice exposure to literature is so critical reading words in isolation or small passages does

039not make lifelong readers those are essential skills they need but equally as important as what we're doing with high quality literature and helping kids access that and talk about it um and write about it and celebrate it so um no we have film there and I would be happy to take anyone on a tour if you want to go see um but there are great things happening on both sides of our instruction here we go so sv27 is what uh brought the science of reading in a very strategic way from the state office from from the legislature to the state office to Utah um and they set a very ambitious goal that by the end of 2027 that 70% or more of Utah's thirdd graders would be reading on grade level that's that's a very

040very lofty goal this year's first graders the class of 2036 is that group so we're tracking them through to third grade um it's important to note that what does reading on grade level mean some of you may remember we got used to get very excited when kids got to green or blue on Dibbles the target score for reading on grade level is actually in the Blue Zone it's a 405 composite score for third grade it's a very ambitious goal what they found over time in research is that in order to feel really confident that kids are going to continue to have the literacy skills they need as the curriculum the rigor of the curriculum increases they need to be out of 405 um by the end of third grade and so you've over the course

041of time we're switching our language to not just settling for kids hitting the green but that we're really trying to push kids to that blue what I love about this is that sometimes we haven't pushed our kids who already have good early literacy skills as far as they need to go we have kind of said oh they're at Green they're good but really now we're all focused on helping all kids maximize their reading skills as early as possible so that they'll have what they need throughout their education there we go so s sp27 that's where the need to progress monitor kids come from so we give benchmarks testing three times a year and then our students that are struggling we continue to progress monitor them to make sure that our interventions are having impact that

042they're continuing increase and that we're not you know if something's not working with three data points then it's time to look at what else we need to do for that student whether it's more intensity or a different version of the program like we're constantly working to make sure that kids are not falling behind so if we think about what we know about the brain and how much easier it is when they're young to build those connections in the brain we have this precious time before third grade to get a lot of these things in place it gets much harder after that time so that's the way that's the way we track that um you remember that a few years back that all of our teachers went through letters training all K through3 teachers and special

043education teachers letters is merely a program that um encapsulates the science of reading so they've taken taken the body of work and given them a strategic pathway for learning that our te K through3 teachers and sped teachers um took two years to go through that um and so we're putting all these pieces together we have the assessments de see what's happening we have um the teacher training and we're continuing to teach on my team we have five letters trainers inh house in Granite school district and they are continuing to offer um letters trainings for teachers who may not have been around when the first round of letters came so we'll continue to offer that as well the last piece for us and maybe the most important piece is we've we've kind of built this science

044of reading structure in Granite um it it's it you know the pieces haven't necessar neily been in order but this year we got the the Lynch pin piece is to have materials that are actually aligned to the science of reading with hmh into reading and I know that that R RFP group just as with the secondary has spent a lot of time making sure we're getting um the most rigorous high quality instructional materials um that teachers can use in the classroom to help support support literacy the intervention Play Pieces um we've had sips in 95% for the last couple of years and we're seeing great outcomes from those but really we don't want more students in intervention we want we want our tier one instruction to be proficient so that we're getting 70 to 80%

045of kids on grade level in their grade level without having to go to intervention here we go all right so one of the other initiatives that we've had um over the last two years is trying to Target that group who has to be you know where the target is 70% by the end of third grade so we have introduced what we're calling Milestones some goals for um last year was just K and this year for K and one one of the things that we have to do is a mindset of what kids can actually do I'll give you an example under wonders it took almost the entire year for our kindergarteners to be introduced to the letters of the alphabet it was like one letter a week it took the whole year we don't have

046that much time we know that many kids come in with those skills and we know others can learn them much more rapidly so that we can actually get into the way um words work and blending words and so we set some goals that we started tracking the number of students in our district who knew letter names and Sounds by November one in kindergarten and we have a Target to have um we're tracking how many kids can read 10 whole words by the end of kindergarten because when they walk in the door for first grade they already have to read words in order to get to Green on a Cadian so we need to make sure that our teachers are moving to BL funding um much earlier and that we're we're helping students progress at a

047faster rate and we've seen some phenomenal data of even our most impacted title ones where you're getting 70% of kindergarteners who by mid year knew their letters names and sounds it's it's fabulous the work that's happening many of you may have been out for literacy nights or the literacy kits that we've worked with parent the parent engagement team on all those things are about galvanizing the entire Community around helping our young readers develop the skills they need to be successful and then this year we added milestones for first grade a target of 15 whole words read by November one um and then uh correct words per minute by mid year they are already being assessed on their fluency with reading connected text and so we set some goals there next year we'll be setting a

048goal for second grade so just continuing to develop our skills and rigor if you take a look at this data I'm really super proud if you look at kindergarten last year at boy gardeners came in at 41% proficient and at mid year moved to 50% this year our kids came in lower they came in at 34% but look at that at mid year we were already at 53% proficient so look at that gain that they've made same thing historically with first grade we've gone backwards at mid year because it's the first time the fluency is assessed so we went from last year was 43 at beginning of the year and 40 at mid year this year we went from 43 to 44 so for the first time we've moved in the opposite direction um where

049more more students were reaching those targets um you can see we've got some work to do second grade I've already told you that's our big goal for next year is to carry that up but already even with hmh and the focus on um really good comprehension um and more exposure we're starting to see those numbers shift and we're really exciting to see see what happens by the end of year so that's Benchmark um we're seeing similar things um with pop so last year at mid year pop pop is um the percent of kids that grew how we expected them to grow yeah I going make sure I said that correctly um so in kindergarten last year at mid year we had 53% that hit their pop Target this year we had 59% I mean those

050are significant shifts um and first grade went from 47% last year to 53 I really feel like we're in a Renaissance in Gran at school district finally having the training um the materials having all these things mind where we are going to continue to really change the trajectory of what happens and it's going to be exciting to see for this generation of students what happens for them across the course of their career all right can I ask a question about that data before we move always yeah just curious as to the reasoning for so you can see the kindergarten end of year 63% there on the previous slide 65% and then they roll over to first grade and it's down to 43% for that same cohort of students it measures different skills and the biggest

051one is that midyear first grade is the first time they're reading a passage so before that it's prerequisite skills so that's a big thing being able to read words in isolation to be able to read connected text um so that's a huge huge jump um the shift as in the early grades the shift for discret skills is um really specific it's that whole progression of how kids learn from sounds to words to Connected text um in the upper grades it really is then about the increase in the rigor of the text the sophistication of the words um but again this is why first grade you often see that drop and we're really happy this year that we we have um stemmed that tie that means more of our kids were ready to read connected text

052all right so our academic priorities oh my goodness you I'm just a little nervous I am so sorry you're a great so we we need to have you come more out there you go okay I will no I'm not volunteering y'all are lovely but here we go so we're looking over time at scores things have been pretty stagnant they've been pretty stagnant you know you you see a dip from um the time of covid and then you see some slight increas but I what I really love and have appreciated um sitting on the elementary guiding Coalition and sitting on salt is just this real desire and the time and space we're in in Granite School District where we were really rolling up our sleeves and saying we can do better we really can do better

053and I want to give you the confidence that on the literacy side of things especially in elementary and then extending to secondary is we also have the science um behind it the strategies behind it and the tools behind it that we need to change this trajectory and really start moving it's going to show up first in those learning to read skills under aadience um but as those students build their skills it's going to take off also on the higher order literacy skills those comprehension skills those writing skills will begin to show up as well we um I was in a class today with hmh on writing and we had one of the parts was Kindergarten they were asking teachers what they have enjoyed so far with hmh around writing and one of the kindergarteners had

054put on there that they have students that are writing two sentences already there was a time in Granite School District where um we weren't really weren't writing in kindergarten but we know that kids can do more and to give them voice and the ability to express themselves um and to learn to write with with intention and purpose all of these things really um help improve their passion for Education um and get us going in the right direction all right that's what I have for you I'm happy to answer any questions that I can I'm glad I don't have to move the slides anymore so now you're Prof now I'm almost Mac proficient so I'll be ready to take the assessment does anyone have any questions or anything I can answer for you I have a

055quick question sure maybe it's quick I and maybe this is even a Todd question the the funding for um from usbe correct for the for the letters training does that have a Sunset date are we taking that on are we continuing to pay for letters training our teachers pay for their own letters training how was that yeah this year we um we have an early literacy grant money and we have paid for our teachers to take letters I think it's really super important Ben that's actually done superintendent horley has actually come by several times um to just thank that group for their investment in their um in their learning and their knowledge base for their classrooms and it's been great to see um and we will continue to have cohorts as long as they needed

056I saw some data today the state um the state knows they didn't capture everyone and so they are strategizing around how to get more teachers but for us we have the ability to do it yeah we so we have five individuals here and together the literacy the district literacy coaches and District literacy Specialists deliver those classes to teachers I would just add uh agreed um the this is a huge investment and probably one of the most important things that we do and I I think our data is not reflective of the challenges that we're faced with because if think and consider that over the course of the last decade our multilanguage learner population has grown exponentially um the fact that we don't have people at home that can simply read with their child in English

057uh for 20 minutes which is what we would expect from a typical middle class um population and ask for their support in that way um our schools are taking the brunt of having to to teach these these basic English literacy skills and so these coaches and this program is pretty phenomenal and pretty important and considering the data points um if we were some other um I don't know normal District uh not awesome amazing like Granite District um then I I think we'd see different outcomes but given what we are I think our outcomes are pretty pretty darn good and I'm I'm particularly proud of this I've actually had the opportunity to go out and Shadow a couple of our coaches actually more than a few of them and seen the work that they're doing and

058uh they've let me uh come in and teach uh some of their tier 2 um interventions and do that I would encourage you all to get with Amber and some of her amazing coaches and go out and have that experience with these kids and teach them some of these basic skills it's a lot of fun and you'll see where the need is and uh how important the work that they're doing is I I couldn't agree more and I think it's it's really exciting to be in classrooms right now the vibrancy of you you saw all those little those second graders sitting in front of her 100% engaged I'm so proud to show what they know that's not a single classroom we're seeing that widely across the district so it is it is a Renaissance for

059early literacy in Granite and it's it's been a privilege to be part of it Connie has something and then Julie do you have something to why don't you go after Connie I have been on the board a long time and my goal when I started was that we become examples for the world why can't we do that we have the best and I appreciate greatly for the commitment that Granite has made also I would love to be able to ask that parents somehow are taught so that they can work with their own child it's not that they don't want to it's how what do I do so I'm hoping that there's some little help for parents also Connie and I worked together she was my board member for eight years while as at Grand I

060love her so so let me just say I think what's really exciting is curriculum and instruction has been working side by side with family engagement and we started with those kindergarten kits that are in both English and Spanish everything has been recorded for parents um we' have seen an explosion of literacy events for parents in our elementary schools it's amazing um schools are getting really creative and doing them at drop off and pick off pickup even when you know you've got this captive audience of parents coming through the parking lot um and we're seeing a lot of traction from that there is no doubt that you are spoton it is going to take the work of all of us um to continue to move this to make sure that all of our kids have access

061to high quality instruction and I just want to do a shout out for um uh family and Community engagement yes uh they've been great Partners in in our um goal to establish really discret milestones at the K level and then up through the first grade level and then to get it out into the hands of our parents um through these kits and so JD's done a lovely job of getting us funding to build those kits and then get them out there but I also want to um speak to what superintendent horley was saying in terms of um having to rely so heavily on us in the schools we are now with um the help of of the our family engagement Department um building QR codes that literally train Spanish speaking parents and English-speaking parents in

062the best ways to do letters and sounds to play the games that are actually um supporting the science of reading and we're even dipping down with Nan um into preschool now and getting out into the community into the daycares so that's our next event we have an event tomorrow night where we're going to start introducing some very very foundational or primer skills um at those kinds of events so that it's there before um the kids even get to us I'm Noel's being modest Noel with the family and Community engagement director and the family community engagement Department are going out to schools if you look at their calendar if if anyone calls them they're there they'll be there on the the family literacy night and they'll take up most of the lift too they'll copy materials

063they have everything prepped they'll come and train side by side with your teachers they have the experts on this so principles I'm going to give you a little shout out you call these people because they're here and ready to help I want to add one more thing we were out at Walker um in this this parent Center that Tony Pho helped and one of the things we heard out there is that our parents really do want to learn side by side with their students which is really incredibly powerful they want to help their students at home um and they've been excited to learn the same skills so they're getting the knowledge of how English works as well compared to Spanish and so it's it's been exciting to see just a a move in some new

064directions thank you Julie go ahead for for for yep I totally agree Julie I also have really seen our principal step up to be the literacy leaders in their buildings this year um really connecting their CIP plans and their efforts their strategic plans to focus on you know we we all know that kids have to be able to read if we're going to get them to graduation we all we all know that intuitively um but we've seen every every part of the system really step up and really Embrace this so it's exciting to be able to share with the board what's H been happening around the district can you um give some your best guess I guess as to how much of this science of learning methodology is reliant on edtech for its delivery in

065our district and especially with ML Learners and right as we get to the higher grades yeah I think so a couple things I think especially can it be done without yes um but we also you know that that visual component and making sure that everybody can see what the teacher is doing and talking about um really helps and assists all students our special ed students our MLS All students need to see it for themselves um you could do it with a small post post or you could do it you know old school um but this the technology enhances that part I think where things shift is when you're working on comprehension that is that what we all remember interacting with our teacher around text um talking about it getting engaged in it and then writing

066about it sharing ideas with one another so I think different parts are enhanced more from technology um but I think you know technology is a help I think Noel has wants to add to that yeah Technologies definitely enhances it but it's the teacher and and it's it's the skill of the of the teacher um that makes it if our if our students were just to use the technology they wouldn't data shows they're not learning anything the teacher has to be highly skilled highly trained and so that ongoing professional learning uh like Julie was referencing is crucial to our teachers because these are highly complex skills to learn and to teach and so the what what the technology really does is it it creates um kind of a uh a standard for us so that we

067don't Veer off and it allows for kind of a a place to reinforce for the teacher some of the different um aspects and the the different strategies so it's an enhancement it is not um something that can take take over the actual work of what a teacher needs to do we need highly skilled teachers and highly trained teachers to be able to do this kind of work well and it's the teacher who's deciding what is on that presentation slide right and that is based on what they know about their students and what they know about the science and what they know about their standards so you you cannot take a high quality teacher out of that equation that's that's the most important element and then you know I'm referring I appreciate your responses and I

068know you're talking about like this slide she had up as she's having the kids engage with her I'm I'm guess I'm asking more specifically about how much time do they spend in front of their Chromebooks interacting with the curriculum like how much of that is going on and I would imagine with our ml students it's more um but I just don't know I actually think you know I I think it's less I don't know if you all have seen but um with this purchase we bought what's called a my book so rather than a hard cover book every kid every child has their own soft color book that has got in color and high quality Graphics the text and then places to annotate highlight and write so if anything I think what we're seeing is

069um much more student engagement with the actual texts more discussion more writing that's the way this program has been designed so it's not passive sit and get it's very active and intentional in the way um we're introducing students to to text and then helping them work through it thank you so I think you know it would be I don't know why we would consider it progress to render our teachers obsolete so that's definitely a big concern in my mind and just want to make sure we're we're stick staying away from screens as much as we can right I think if anything the pandemic taught us that too much screen time is too much screen time and um what we're really seeing now is is quite a Renaissance in terms of um teachers trying to figure

070out ways to really pull off the screen time um we're really limiting that independent time to situations where um we're working with one small group while kids are rotating through those but we know based on the data that we've seen that that is not how our students are learning so our goal is really that that active 100% engagement all of the time and working on the strategies that get there but that interaction between te teacher and and student and student and student is key um that that's our focus and instruction right now even the programs um so like I or Mera um or Lexia they all have guidelines of how much time students should spend on those programs and it's actually really small it's really targeted specific strategic instruction at their level it has never

071been intended for hours of long practice um it's never intended to be a babysitter and so that's why we use it typically in small group as a center where kids can get some differentiated practice but I couldn't agree with you more I just want to say thank you for your presentation super helpful and it was really interesting like that science behind um reading is is fantastic and I just want to give a shout out I've had so many great principles in my precinct invite me to their literacy nights and the engagement level is high and it's so great um I have a couple schools that they've just they turn in the Halloween theme or they take the theme and they they make it fun for those kids to take home some reading activities to do

072with their families and um I think that has helped our engagement in our community so much and so I appreciate your support to to help our principls be able to do things like that in our community so thank you thank you all did you thank you I I my one I do have one real quick question um I I go help with the ml Learners at the high school has have they ever approached them with the science of reading like using that in the secondary schools because I just I can't help but think that maybe some of this I don't know maybe it wouldn't help maybe is there a different way that they've proven that it's better to do it the other way yeah so so at the secondary level we've also um really started

073to double down in terms of reading intervention so the secondary Ela specialists um in in the curriculum and instruction Department H actually teach a reading endorsement program they partner with the U ofu and we started doing that about well we started doing that during the pandemic when we had the SR funding and so we were able to do that startup but we've for years seen the deficit that you're describing where kids who didn't acquire the skills um need to to you know address the deficits and so we have more and more teachers every year that are in the reading endo ment uh program and we have more reading classes than we've ever had before so it's actually becoming a part of the master calendaring discussion at the junior high level and the high school level

074of how we fit in the reading the targeted reading intervention class not just a reading class where anybody goes who needs extra help and you kind of make do but but a a skilled teacher who's been trained in in science of reading so they actually go through the the foundation letters components and then what we add to that is adolescent motivation so there's a lot about adolescent literacy that has very much to do with relevance and motivation and what feels um what feels like it works for kids who have faced a lot of heartache and um and and not too much success over the years and how to get them very very motivated to continue to build those skills so that's that's how we're addressing it at the secondary level thank you I wondered if

075that translated anywhere in there I appreciate that and I I really I I mean I looking at those it's true you look at that and say well why are we so low in Granite but at the same time knowing that we have how many ml Learners that we have in our district I think it is um commendable that we are working on this and that we're using the science of reading and really hitting that hard so thank you thank you for all that you guys have done with our our teachers and our your your team so we appreciate that thank you and like Karen I'm really mad that I'm losing Amber but I will use her just as much over in the school leadership and Improvement but I love hearing this because this is I

076I'm hoping this will translate now she can have this direct impact too as she goes out to these schools so right thank you that is the plan we want to see great numbers thank you everybody abely thanks for the warm welcome okay we're going to switch and inv is with Amber but just so you know everything you adopted last month with the preschool curriculum part of our RFP process and our criter it was all around science and reading so everything that we adopted is a perfect match and we've been training um our leadership team in letters in it's called EC letters so early childhood letters this year um and so so preschool will do we're in an exact match we've taken those November one kindergarten targets and we've taken those down to the preschool level

077so those are the targets we've been using this year so it's a scar Bros rope has as much to do with preschool and early literacy on that end as it has to do with k23 so that's my passion too I love ly to so um and Amber's wonderful and I too am sad because we've done a lot with Amber but she'll be awesome in slid so thank you thank you for your time um tonight I came tonight by invitation of superintendent horley that asked me to come and just give you an update on preschool funding and the financial outlook for the 2526 school year so just briefly oh we're not on a scroll anymore now we're on a click all right so actually I need to come back one I whoa there there we go

078we don't have to scroll on this one perfect there we go so just as a quick overview preschool in general we have kind of two sets of students that we serve we have our general education students and our special education students so our general ed students are our Title One eligible children and then our tuition pain children and then our special ed students are the ones that are in our inclusion classroom so that's the majority of our classrooms um those classrooms have usually um about five kids with disabilities in that classroom and then we have our special classes that are our hired needs specialed kids um that have by their IEPs the needs and that classroom so those are kind of our two populations right now in preschool as of today we have 18897 preschoolers

079enrolled um and of those kids we have 215 additional kids on weight list so we have a high demand for preschool um and lots of kids enrolled so as the question about how do we do funding in preschool so we use a braided funding model you can see on that graphic we have General Ed monies and we have specialed monies um our special ed monies come from idea Federal funding both on the preschool there's a preschool line and there's a school age line and then State special education monies on the General Ed side we have tuitions um registration fees donations Title One and tssa money that we use so we use a braided funding model to truly try to utilize as much as we can some of these streams have really strict guidelines as to

080ways we can use them percentages that we can use things um so so we use a braided funding model because of we have limits on some of them to be able to really benefit and utilize the most we can and be as fiscally as responsible as we can with the different funds that we have so looking at next year um even with the braided funding model we're still seeing some challenges that are coming up so over the past couple years we've seen some consistent annual reductions in multiple our funding streams um idea money has gone down fed um I mean you guys know Title One money definitely hasn't increased um and has decreased sometimes our tuition revenues are decreasing also so with that the other big piece so there's a grant in the state that's

081called the high qu well it's now called called the high quality School Readiness H qsr preschool grant that has not been adequately funded by the legislature so we've had grant funding in the past um we didn't have it last year we wrote for for the grant last year and we scored second highest in our application but we weren't funded between the people that applied and scored high quality and the money that was available there was a $12 million gap so there's a huge need for preschool funding in the state um but there's definitely a shortfall we've written for the grant again this year it's turned in it's in process of being looked at um this year is actually a multi-year grant so if we're funded this year we're actually funded for 3 years we don't

082have to reapply again that was a change they made this year superintendent horley has been very active in working with legislators and really trying to Advocate and help them understand this need for preschool money right now there's an RFA a $5 million RFA that's been presented to the legislature to ask for additional funding for the hqs um Grant we have been told we won't know anything until mid April to late April um on the grant so that's kind of where we're sitting there so with that and no could I speak to that real quick just as a matter of update yeah go ahead with respect to that so in addition to that we've also looked at um uh getting state board rule modified to allow for tssa funds that might be allowed for this purchase

083but there's also a bill that would eliminate tssa altogether and new funding yes it would be held flat um to that to that extent so there are some some ch challenges on that front and we continue to to look for some potential Solutions but the the data is pretty clear our students who participate especially our high poverty families um when they come and participate in our pre our highquality preschool programming those kids are much more ready for our kindergarten and you're going to show us what that looks like so yeah they definitely are um so as we're looking to this and knowing the value that this plays in our schools um knowing what we experienced last year with not being funded because of the grant for shortfall we're really trying to look forward and be

084proactive in any way that we can this year so in looking at kind of our two sides of the stream of that we of the streams that we have obviously special ed money is fixed there's nothing we can do to like go and get some more special ed money those are fixed streams so where we have the opportunity to make an impact is on the general education side um so we've really been trying to explore some ideas of how could we add some Revenue how can we expand our current efforts looking at at through a lens of how can we maintain as much enrollment as we can in that inclusion ratio and really maximize the impact that we have so obviously the best of the best would be the legislative funding comes through and there's

085enough for everybody that wants funding and everybody that scores high quality um without that again we've been trying to really brainstorm and generate some ideas so these next five um that we've identified are solutions that we actually have some control scoll over so the first one is registration fees um we we don't sit in the K12 registration fee structure and so um we're allowed to charge registration fees in preschool so we're looking to raise that registration fee by $5 this year for our tuition based students um the next thing we're looking at is monthly tuition so right now in Title One schools we do not charge any tuition but because of the shortfalls we're having to look next year at charging some tuition and having to have everyone contribute at least a little we want

086to make you aware of that because it is different than something we've ever done in the past we've also W worked with Dr Aaron Wilson to make sure we've checked in at all things at state level to make sure of any Title One regulations requirements um that we make sure we're following those and in some of that research we we've actually found that other school districts charge tuition in Title One schools so we have never ever ever done that here um but we're looking at needing to do that next year to try to generate a little bit more Revenue it will be nominal um it won't be full tuition by any means um again trying to really make sure that we get our highest need kids into those seats so that we um can do

087everything that Amber's been talking about and really be a value add on that end can you just give us an idea of what we're looking regular tuition yep so right now regular tuition is $200 a month for fouryear olds and 150 for threeyear olds on the title one end we're looking at doing $40 for for four year olds and $20 for twoy olds so keeping it as minimum as we can we have some history with um an early reading first grant we had back in started in 2005 um I was an instructional coach at that point but that Grant didn't require us to charge parents anything but we charged a nominal fee and we saw better parent participation when they were paint just just a little bit so we have a little bit of history

088that we're coming from on that and thinking um hopefully that would help with a little Buy in to permits special permits um we have always allowed special permits at Title One schools um but we're looking again to limit that to only kids that attend in those title one schools knowing that if we have to close classrooms we again want to do everything we can do to maximize that our highest need kids get into those seats so we would stop doing those special permits at Title One schools unless there was a parent I mean excuse me a principal request if there was a principal request for a special exception we would do that but then we would charge some tuition with that too um because those aren't kids that are living in the boundaries so scholarships

089um in the past we've been able to do full subsidies for some families um that's something we're looking at not being able to do full subsidies again next year um or for next year and again requiring some sort of a tuition we're looking more like a half tuition there um to be able to still provide some opportunity for families but to generate um some Revenue also donations um we just met with Sean and JD last week we're really trying to expand our work with the Education Foundation we have um some additional grants that we're working on different proposals that we're putting out to companies we've really been trying um I've got an incredible person that works in our department that she's really kind of scoured the websites and the fun the founding and fundings to

090try to see who might have an interest in early childhood and maybe who could we push forward some proposals to um that might have some interest so those are solutions that we've identified that we're starting to work on and planning like I say to move forward on um kind of to summarize what we're seeing um you can see this this chart kind of gives The Good the Bad and everything in between so obviously the farle um if we received the hqs our grant again we could go on as as is this year with no concerns no classrooms would need to be closed we wouldn't need any reduction in teaching Force we would still have the same amount of gen Ed and sped students far right is the ugly um if we don't have the ability

091to bring in any Revenue um we would be looking at closing 10.5 preschool classrooms next year reducing our classroom teaching Force by 21 and we would have an additional 357 kids that wouldn't have have preschool spots um obviously you can see that special ed line it stays the same because by law we're required to serve our special ed students so that's that's not changing we will obviously still continue to serve those then those two in the middle um working to the left from no additional Revenue implementing initiative so those are the five that I just talked about if we Implement those five things like we're looking to do you can see it makes it a little bit better um not we don't have to close and lose quite as many and then that second from

092the right next to the H qsr that initiatives and District support that would be as close to what we've been doing this year um so you all know there was a million dollar set aside from the board it was set aside I think actually two years ago but then we didn't need to use it because we were so horribly staffed for about two almost three years that we saved a ton of money because we didn't have staff so the leadership team and myself and my assistant director are out teaching a lot um so so we saved some money there so this year we have been um spending down all of our reserves that we had build up and then the million dollars is what we've been using so that that second column over would be

093kind of what it would look like next year our best pro projections obviously not aning colas or anything like that um that would kind of be our best projection with that next year so superintendent anything else you wanted me to add there just wanted a really good summary as I kept sharing these things with him he's like H let's share it with everybody so that's kind of where we're sitting right now questions I can answer I have a question go ahead Julie no we're asking for it's like 1.99 is what we're asking for with granite the gap between everyone in the state that applied both private preschools and leas the Gap in funding was 12 million so there was basically 12 for the whole state not for us no we our our ask that we

094just put in for this grant is 1.99 basically I mean best best projections for right now yes so this you've hit on something that's a little bit touchy for me personally so I apologize if I get a little snoody here but the fact that uh this program funding was looped over to Department of Workforce Services and part of traditional daycare is appalling to me because our preschool programming is not daycare and so having to go and ask uh on bended knee uh for additional funding so we can qualify for a grant that we should just automatically get because of the the program and its successes is just it's it's it doesn't take into consideration the tremendous amount of data that shows the effectiveness of highquality preschool programming and especially with impoverished or limited English profic

095uh proficiency populations you just saw this amazing program uh and some of the successes we're seeing on our science of reading the challenges just become exacerbated when you have students coming into kindergarten who can't not who have no ability because not because they're not willing or not because they're not smart their families don't speak English and so it it's really hard for a family who doesn't speak any English to teach their kids basic sounds and identification of letters um in the English language and that's what we're we're hope a traditional English-speaking middle class family comes into a kindergarten classroom speaking over 2500 words and most of our impoverished families are 600 and if your limited English Proficiency in a home you're probably coming in with very little identification of those letters so the fact that

096our our best and most needy populations and the PO the way this grant is being funded is is through a day a daycare programming Grant through Department of work force services clearly I I don't I don't know how to fix that because our legislators should be listening but they're not hey Ben so what is this new oh sorry Julie I was just wondering so is this grant this grant was redone this coming is this reconstituted several years toed kind of year after year after year and it started in with usbe having more control and it is a grant that serves both private child carees and leas so it kind of services everybody but now it's just recently with some again changes last year it's now house within the Department of Workforce Services usbe and there's

097a School Readiness team is what they're calling now it has representation from both um but it is funded I mean in 6 million of the there's 12 million allotted to the grant every year six million of that is coming from ccdf funds so that is child care like federal child care money so we have 6 million that's coming for laas okay we have a lot of so it's sort of morphed into that it's like it's gradually Chang's been a million iterations over the years yeah but the some of the requirements of the grant are really intended to address private daycare based requirements and we're like we're not a daycare but we're being categorized as one so I'm a little bit embarrassed that's not your fault trying to stay off my soap box I'm trying to

098yeah you're doing a good job I'll I'll get on mine thanks Ben sh for for thanks Julie clerk you mentioned that you try to provide priority to certain families that are at most in need perhaps how do you assess that as part of your regular apprach that has actually been something that's been part of the grant for years and so when preschool families register they actually fill out a kind of a risk factor form those risk factors come from the Asus study um and so they do that and so when when we have had grant funding we're actually required to look at those factors and to prioritize kids based on those factors so we have between that and financial the grant also sets aside English language Learners or MLS and um any kids in foster

099care that type of thing to have priority so we have never gone away from that because this is the soap box I'll stay off it was actually Granite District that helped form this entire Grant so the high quality markers that are part of legislation that you're that you're um that you have to write on the application to these were actually things that were formed from that early reading first Grant from 2005 um to about 2012 we had no early learning standards in the state we had nothing like saying what high quality preschool was it was actually our program Grant at District that provided all the foundational data that got all of that legislation written so it's a little frustrating we're not in it uh Julie did you have something else whatever the board feels inclined

100to uh help support I mean this is this is this is budget questions so that's why we're bringing this here and wanted to have conversation about what the Outlook looks like on this particular program our top our top priority is to get the grant funded and uh look for other potential ways to provide that funding potentially through tssa but with that uh funding not increasing the chances of that being um helpful is is that window is closed to some degree um we need some growth in the funding in that program to be able to to subsidize this piece so I'm not hopeful on that front that yeah that would definitely fall under the initiatives Julie either one of those scenarios um is where that would fall and again that's it's just so variable that we

101don't we don't know when and how much and all that kind of thing but yeah it would fall under the initiative so either one of those absolutely correct okay I just remind me if you're like on a an IEP or 504 and you have a preschool that needs it are we do we charge the same tuition is that tuition free because of the I yep yep it's tuition free so none of our special education students pay tuition yeah that's all provided and that's hence the reason that line is the zeros but I and I knew we had to serve them but I couldn't remember the financial aspect of that no tuition yep no tuition charge to those kids and obviously those special education funds that are on the fixed funds those are the funds that

102are funding those kids yeah so my question is um the scholarships part that was up I think the slide before this when it says no full subsidies do we stand to lose like do you have any idea at all would we lose families if they did not have full scholarship are there families that can't afford a $20 or I think the answer would be I mean yes possibly um I mean we've tried to be really careful on that because we don't want to lose families because the families most likely we would lose would be our highest need families so I mean I don't think we can guarantee that but I definitely think you know we're going to try to do everything we can not to lose them um but I mean I do think there

103could be a possibility that we could lose some yes is there anybody that we can call for the grant just kidding it goes through don't call anybody on education because it doesn't go through education because it sits in DWS it goes through the economic I just yes yes and then it's so it's been it's been brought through that committee now so now it's on an Appropriations list so I mean really I mean I think it would be those that sit on the Appropriations Committee at this point what was the committee prior to Appropriations thank you so it's just general Appropriations yeah it's not education money it's just general Appropriations yeah that's the hard part okay Julie did you have something else for I'll just add in Julie I mean it's one of our goals in

104preschool to absolutely give that family the most successful start and we know that often times we have families that our parents are coming back to the school and they may not have had a great A great experience themselves so that truly is one of our key things that we focus on with families is giving them a positive experience getting them connected to the elementary school I mean we currently we're in enough elementary schools that there's only a handful that we're not in and so that's I mean that is you're absolutely right that's one of our main goals of the family is to get them connected so that they are in the school they know the school they know the people in the school and then we can just keep them heading right into kindergarten yeah

105and we have preschools currently Julie at all of our Title One schools we have a preschool in every Title One school yeah so they're coming to their home school So when you say wpu do you mean at the district level or at the state level so at the district level the wpu does come in as unrestricted funds and could be used and essentially is what we are using right now to backfill the the grant that we don't have at the state level the state funds on K12 not prek uh but again it doesn't restrict the use for prek it's just not in the funding formula but it's still we would have to decide where we would take that from because we're not we're not rolling yeah we'd have to reallocate for do do you actually

106have data on how many kids that have attended our preschool matriculate all the way to say junior high or High School uh I'm sure I'll let you answer that question we we have some we've actually had some um external longitudinal data studies done by a professor from BYU um sociology Professor um that actually have shown like effect size on especially with our more atrisk populations our Hispanic population on um attendance and on C scores too so there is yeah the data that Julie's referencing is what I showed some legislators this this last fall to get the RFA going because what it showed was actual students over here at one of our neighborhood schools and um identification it was three class lists for three kindergarten classes and it was uh first year this was like the

107second week or third week of school and so is that that testing that gets done to see where kids are at and uh sights and sounds and of both uh lowercase and uppercase letters and then and identification and you could see the kids that were involved in our preschool program you're like oh that one was this one was and it was literally about 80% of the kids who had even remote identification of letters and sounds um had been been in our program and so the the impact I mean if you're a kindergart teacher and you're looking at all that data only a handful of those kids have participated and so you're starting from from scratch literally showing the letter a sounding it out um and these other kids had already were way ahead by virtue

108of being in that program exactly let alone the school skills that go like they know what a classroom is they know what a teacher is they know there's some rules they need to follow and there's the structure doesn't throw them off you know we deal with that on the preschool end we take the crying as they start in preschool but that again that's one of our biggest goals is like get them into this school so they know what this is and then give them all these pre-literacy and pre-math skills so that when they hit Kinder that Gap that Julie's talking about is either closed or much closer to being closed and and they their little brains are learning so much in that 3 to four age range for our MLS like the strategies that we

109use for all preschoolers support our ml Learners I mean you know so they come in not knowing a word of English and they go out being able to speak and express themselves with some skills already that they're headed with so that's another big thing is like if we can get them in the door and have them for that time makes a huge difference in in their confidence level and their ability to just function within a classroom I would just say I believe our system exists to support families and parents with uh quality outcomes and one of the primary jobs that we have just based on the last presentation is to help kids learn how to read and uh this is such an essential function to support those families who do not have the ability to

110teach they don't know English and that's not because they're bad people they just don't know English and so it's really hard to again um teach your kid to learn in English by reading with them 20 minutes today which is our expectation of of families if if they don't have that ability to do so and I think that other piece that Amber and Noel both alluded to is that those prek kits now looking to get funding for those so that we can start to support families in even a more strategic way of getting them to understand how is it that I do this with my child at home in the preschool world and how do I start that so I think that's another really I'm excited I'll get it out about that piece so and I

111would add too that one of the benefits just seeing because I have some friends who teach the early the K you know K3 having them in preschool helps us identify if there are some issues that we need to work with them on because it's super hard to do that but I mean kindergarten you know that's but first grade second grade third grade and you're trying to qualify them for the services that they need and the sooner you can get them there the better it's it's a it really is it's a huge child find piece for kids that land in preschool that we kind of go whoa we we need something more than just a preschool classroom here and it is it's a huge piece of child find that we use to be able to get

112those kids the services they need even sooner in that early intervention piece and it gets them that much fur absolutely Julie look like you have more yeah that I think it's a high likelihood for especially for our higher risk kids yeah our our families that are middle to Upper income probably not so much but for sure our high-risk kids no we have a way we have a weight list right now of 215 and that has decreased some over the year because families just like they drop they don't think they're going to get in so yeah I mean we currently as of today we have a weight list of 215 students it's both both yep go ahead Kim I think I seen data um around so talking about any learning advantage that students have if they've

113been to preschool versus if they haven't that that um difference or that Advantage disappears by is it around fifth or sixth grade it there's different studies out there there was a longitudinal Head Start study that showed that some of the effect size went away um I'm trying to think if there's other longitudinal preschool studies um there was one out of Tennessee that it was showing that to start with but then it was kind of brought back it was a few years ago I would have to refresh myself on it was kind of brought back as to that wasn't exactly what the data was saying so yes but there have been some longitudinal studies out there that have shown that the effect size can wear off as it gets like into the lot later grades yes

114but again I think it's how you look at the data too and especially when we're talking about this gap of like actual skills do we know exactly where they were and are they headed to kinder with an actual skill set that we can quantify that then feeds into all this stuff we're talking about with learning to read and that type of thing to feed into really the third grade reading being able to read on on level at third grade thank you I'm I'll be maybe just the tenth man here I um I think little kids in preschool age it's most important for them to be spending time with family um I'm not personally in favor of bringing kids into public education younger and younger and more and more kids and so I personally don't I'm

115not trying to take away from a value proposition necessarily I just don't see it as essential to our mission and goal I think like perhaps we need more research on this subject but I think since research does show that over time that Gap disappears anyway I don't know that there's a whole lot of you know need to push right more and more kids into that preschool setting personally I think there are also other options out there like my kids never came to um a granite preschool but I just send them to a neighborhood friend who helped to to do that I I don't think we're the only end all be all option um so when we're talking about funding I'm giving this background just because if we're talking about funding we have a lot of

116competing priorities this year as we all know and and again I'm just being the 10th man I I I have maybe a different opinion than the rest of you on this topic so I I would prioritize other things probably higher than than moving money toward preschool so just to be frank on that point and I appreciate I appreciate your point of view um and you're absolutely right there are other options out there um I had I had a kid who was who was a specialed student for a while and then once he progressed past that we just finished out the year as a regular student he paid the tuition um but I can also tell you we we sent him to a different preschool the following year and the difference between them was huge and

117I I appreciate that there's a lot of options out there um but I think when we look at the fact that 70% of our moms if they could stay home and Mom was reading to them I think that's great but more and more we're seeing these kids not at home with Mom reading to them we're seeing them at home with Mom working and them on a screen and I would rather have them in a classroom with quality instruction than sitting with a a screen in front of them because that's not quality instruction either and that's creating not just a gap in their reading but also in um a lot of other things that that that I mean you've talked about how screens are not great for kids and we're seeing that so so much with

118the kids as they come in so um I guess just offering my perspective as well that that I see that that those kids come in not just with that deficit in reading but in a lot of other skills and I'd rather see that I'd rather see them here than sitting at home with a screen in front of them with an iPad doing watching shows watching YouTube or you know something like that so anyway but I I can app what you're saying as well J go ahead for e and I think that's that's key Julie is to make sure that we're comparing apples to app too on that data um you know what they were doing in the programs type of a thing too I just want to say thank you um preschool for for the

119families that want it and need it is very important to give these students all around just you know the etiquette in preschool and they have I mean all of it is very important and thank you for the high quality that that you're determined to have here in Granite I appreciate that we love those threes and fours thank you so much thank you I'm gonna suggest that we take a a five minute break while I'm assuming it's done the setting up right are you are you going up are you it Todd Todd and okay I'll be your white if you want kind of make sure youin the problem e e e sorry Senate bill 37's before the house tomorrow and they're looking for talking points to uh do a call Action that's that's important you step

120out go for it all right take care of it in good time we're we're going to go ahead and continue on this is our last item um and we had asked to just have you guys review with us what is happening with the our current real estate and the what we're doing the rele proper process perfect hopefully the the slight presentation we've put together will get you through an answer to that question because it ends up being complicated I feel like Doug sometimes it depends it's a it's a legal answer but uh we we'll go through the slides please ask questions as we go because it it uh is a fun topic but challenging at the same time these are the areas that we' like to cover tonight in the time allotted talk about the

121real estate committee's role uh how we start to look at retention or use of properties the uh some of the challenges we face when we close schools what what obligations do we have and responsibilities do we have for the property as well as the the legal and financial environment that we operate in and then talk a little bit at the end about long-term view what is the perspective that the committee uses as we look at properties uh that come to our attention so the first is uh it's it's great to have guidelines and for the most part the district has history to rely upon and not necessarily written guidelines so it's probably a great opportunity for us to put those in writing not by policy per se but something that we can lean on so

122that when questions come up we can give a pretty uniform standard answer when this happens these are the things you could expect as possible outcomes or if this happens this is how we react and we respond to those situations uh so we want to make sure that we have that opportunity as we move forward to develop those guidelines right now we're using our best practices of the past as we look at properties some definitions as we go along there are some technical words and there are some less technical words Surplus property is actually a statutory Concept in in statute if the board determines that it no longer needs a piece of property it declares it Surplus and that then triggers a a section of that we'll talk to a little bit later as to how

123that uh property then leaves the possession of the school board and moves into some other possession uh closed schools uh we have facilities and in some cases if we decide to demolish the building we have a property or a vacant lot sometimes described what is that uh and then that's the last one the vacant site so this does not have a school facility or structure on it and the district does have in its inventory properties that have no structures on them but they were acquired in anticipation of future needs whether it was enrollment growth or facility needs the district needs for its operations so there are uh that uh category of properties as well these are your illustrious committee members you have myself and Don uh Chief of Staff general counsel then we have our

124risk manager our architect engineer director and planning and bounding director so we have a quite a broad spectrum of views and and understandings and Technical or technical expertise that we bring to the committee uh as we look at all of the the opportunities that that come to us when we look at properties we have some basic buckets are different categories in which we look first is if we have a property we can have to make a determination should we retain it is there some internal use uh that we could use that property for so for example we had the foundation that needed better space and uh we made a school available to them so that was an internal use it didn't go out to bid didn't go out to lease or anything like that we

125we kept it inhouse and took our own internal program uh we could also sell a property again through that Surplus designation the property could be sold and we'd go through a regular sales process uh to uh dispose of the property and we also have the the opportunity to lease a property so this is building or land uh that we could make available on a short-term basis or a long-term basis for someone to lease the revenues and uh thereby generate revenue for the district we have a number of criteria that we go through to determine which of those three buckets we might put a property into uh we do need to take a look at the age and condition of the site itself uh we have some schools that are old enough and have different hazardous

126materials in them that that we have to make some real determinations as to whether it's appropriate to uh lease that property use it for future internal use uh or estimate what the cost would be to mitigate that if we needed to demolish the building itself and retain the property so those are uh items that we go through we also look at the financial viability of the space some properties have really good Market values for different purposes in the valley and others don't and so we would take that into consideration as well uh we look at the legal environment that we're in uh do we have responsibilities for tenants and improvements and other contracts if we get into any of the leasing scenarios uh we also uh take a look into the future to say this

127property isn't needed today but in 20 years 30 years 50 years from now will that neighborhood regenerate and we will have students that we need to accommodate and if we divest ourselves of that property we've just made our challenge 20 30 40 years out all the more difficult because there won't be a piece of property to build the school on or to have the students come back and be housed uh so we do take that into consideration as well as what are the the fin the revenues or the finances of that property and can we find the best use for that property given the the constraints that we see within the committee is that my cover am I good so I'm going to turn the time over here from several slides and let Don talk

128about some of the challenges we have as we look at closing schools yeah the the most important thing that we we want to make sure that we provide for at a closed school is that we're not creating a neighborhood isore an attractive nuisance Etc um so so we we staff a custodian one custodian roves between every three of our buildings right now at the elementary site at um you know projecting forward at a close Cyprus that school will need its own associate custodian roving and so they'll probably be under the purview of of the custodian at um at Brock Bank we're continually doing inspections for mold for leaks damages Etc that's something that we have to keep on top of because it will ruin our facilities uh and and that's never good it's always more

129expensive to have a facility in disrepair uh we're always checking for again Pest Management those infestations and health hazards um nip them in the butt right just got to get on it it's the ugly side of our life but it's something that we do uh regularly we're always trying to to make sure that we're a visible presence and that uh if we see vandalism we promptly remove it um and then we Patrol Granite uh PD patrols we're always trying to make sure that people understand even even though the building's closed it's it's not vacated by us we're there and we're omnipresent so those are the important things that we have to do uh when a school is closed and we traditionally plan to have two or three years worth of coverage budgeted out and and

130Staffing arranged to do this after a Clos School sometimes it just takes time to to get it into our system to determine what the real estate disposition is going to be to budget for disposal demolition whatever it is I just didn't want to leave buildings closed and struggle we learned a lot of lessons off of um off of the old Granite High School uh so those were lessons learned that as I as I came on board I saw that that building had been neglected and it caused a lot of problems and so we just we we've determined a system to not uh to not struggle with that yes ma'am I just caught something you said you when we so I have a problem with the real estate committee and how slow is molasses we move

131I think I've been very open about that so I don't think that's going to surprise anybody you just said that when a school is closed we plan two to three years of personnel so as a board member I hear that and I'm like so if I vote to close another school we're not doing anything to reach out to communities for three years no I think that's misinterpreted even when you engage with communities some of them are taking a while to get uh their decisions made and and operationalize what they want taking a long time or are we because I don't think it's just them I think it's us no it it'll be both sides uh we're in several lease conversations that have been in place for as long as I've been here and it's it's

132working with the legal councils and putting that language together there are others that are definitely us that there's a interest in putting uh some of our property to use as teacher housing and we don't have any constructs we have no policy we have no standards by which to venture into that opportunity and so those pieces need to be put in place and they have not happened quickly and so so it depends on what scenario we're working our way through I think what I need to understand as a board member is as we continue on the steady March of looking at school consolidations that these kinds of decisions the real estate committee and how long they're taking to make these decisions will factor into how I communicate to the communities about us really being in good

133faith saying we're taking care of their school so we can take care of their school as far as you're staying with having a custodian there or whatever but that's not what they want they want to know what is their building going to be used for and so for me to close a school and then wait for 2 to 3 years to be able to answer that part of the question after my board action vote has already been done I'm I'm trying to reconcile that in my mind because how do I vote in good faith to close one more school here if I can't really promise that community in good faith that we're moving quickly to ensure that some good replacement something or another is going into that Community cuz that's something we hear a lot

134as board members is what happens to the property what happens to the community what happens to our community center is it going to be a park is it somebody else going are you going to sell the property all these questions 3 years is kind of a long time to have to wait to be able as a board member to meet to be able to give them a legitimate factual answer so these are the struggles I'm trying to reconcile is how do I in faith go and vote another school closed if I know it's going to be such a l whoops that's my microphone sorry y'all um yeah if it's such a lengthy process before we can give a true answer to that and and I can just I just want to I appreciate that Karen

135because I'm hearing a lot of it right now about Cypress high and you're saying you learned a lot from Granite High having a building that was empty for so long and I think my community looks at that also and going please don't let that be Cyprus um and I know you have thought about that that it would you know we don't want an empty building there for years and years and years so but maintaining it 3 plus years is also probably not in the best interest of the community either so how would we have conversations with our community about that I think that's that's very interesting because it's the challenge again when we talk about what we learned from Granite High South Salt Lake and and superintendent you you went through this as well so

136check check my memory South Salt Lake went through periods of Interest where we want to be there we want to use it as a Community Center they entered into a lease agreement and said well let us just lease it until I can go to my community for a general obligation bond to turn it into the community center we want and so we did and their their go Bond failed they came back to us and said wait wait wait we're going to try it again can we continue to be there and at that point in time the lease had maintenance obligation ation on their side and one day Heats off pipes froze boards warped we had a problem and so we had a very damaged building that's what I'm trying to prevent is turning what used

137to be a usable facility into something that now when you rehabilitate it the cost are substantially higher for any next user and so they went through and had a second Geo bond election fail and these were very close the community tried very hard and it was a hand literally a handful of votes separated success from failure and so again it's not it's not necessarily how quickly we're acting and reacting but even if it becomes available what's the local jurisdiction's ability to fund for acquisition for repurpose for whatever they want I just experienced at Granite the Long Haul and and so I just said well we we should not do that and we saw the degradation of the building the degradation of the community uh folks trying to come in and steal copper and successfully steal

138copper throughout the building we we just can't do that again and so again I I'm just saying I'm prepared to do it from the get-go and conversations with t on a budget for three years because I don't know what I don't know and that that's why I I mention that is granite was really hard and and I just I don't want to have one of our facilities be the attractive nuisance ever again so I say I plan that because I don't know what our reciprocating Partners capabilities are what what does that make sense that makes more sense and that's a better explanation of why we would do something like that but it's such a big facility with a I mean I think 72 door entrances and stuff so I'm just I'm I'm concerned about that

139and my community is concerned about that we keep yeah for we we'll keep the security systems active all of what we can do I'm just saying B based upon lessons learned from Granite High the minimum we should budget for and think about is this whe whether whether we get something off the books in two months four months whatever I just don't want to be left holding the bag that I didn't think about how to protect the asset in that area of town and I think high schools are its own animal for lack of a better term so when I'm speaking I'm speaking more just to be clear I'm speaking and I appreciate Chris bringing up Cyprus obviously that's your area you're probably hearing a ton of questions on that but um I'm talking more these

140Elementary closures that's my specific concern of reconciling this timing issue of promising the world to the community when we go and close the close their school but and it's years and years down the road before we actually do anything for example Westbrook Taylorville told us 5 years years ago they were interested in Westbrook well we've also known the exact year that Westlake was going to move out of Westbrook and and yet here it sits so it's just a few things like that that raises my rais my eyebrows and makes me think are we moving as fast as we can and I appreciate all the legal like everything you said Todd totally you know totally agree but it's like I said I'm I'm struggling with the concept of close now figure out later that's what I'm

141struggling with yeah and I think we feel that same struggle because we are somewhat flat-footed because we don't know what the board's decision will be till it's made and then we start reacting which is probably not helpful either yeah and so so is do we have guidance that that the board would give us that say hey we're engaging the community the the Community Partners who most likely could use the space in a conversation exact problem with reconcile cuz you know you you're not acting till we vote but when we vote it's a delay of I don't know I just I'm struggling with that overall thank you I I think we're all struggling with that same timeline but back to the r back at the ranch you this one uh yeah so these um I got

142remember what I was going to say here so so as we look at the um potential uses of facilities uh these are the the areas that we start looking at is there a short-term occupancy so so is there a community partner out there that's interested and has come forward or do we need to be on the front foot and go chase them down and say hey this opportunity is coming do we need to uh turn this into something that can be used on a short-term basis uh how ready is the the building for that we're finding that some of our buildings have hazardous material conditions and the question then becomes well is it whose responsibility will it be under a lease or some other short-term arrangement to clean that up do we need to get

143it into a certain State and then it's now ready for use or can we pass that along or what how do we manage the the Readiness for repurposing and if I could the the comments here are typically surrounded through asbest the batement so this is asbestos that's trapped in place that if it's not moving and we're we're not touching the walls or disturbing anything it's perfectly fine but those that want to reuse the facility want to remodel in some way shape or form and so again they're they're perfectly safe for occupancy unless you start to remodel and disturb material and that and that's one of the challenges that our partners always have is they come on board hey we're interested oh let's get somebody to to concept caliz our reuse and then we have to

144react to that conceptualized reuse and understand what materials may or may not be disturbed and so that that's even when you're proactively engaged with a user they put their thinking cap on and then we have to react to okay then that means X Y and Z and so that that I just wanted to say they're ready for repurposing the building's fine the day we we close it but when they want to demolish something or modify that's where we we encounter some challenges then we had mentioned that there are some legal requirements if we're going to Surplus we go through a process there and there are timelines established in statute as to how that happens that we have to let other jurisdictions in that area know that we are intending to Surplus the property then they

145have up to 45 days to respond as to whether or not they have an interest in acquiring that property or not and then if they say no it can then go out onto the open market for sale um I think you've already talked about the the timelines and compliance of of repurposing uh and then again that that public or private cell uh we we just go through the statutory process to accomplish that go ahead I I just wanted to highlight what what we believe so as we're moving forward on a couple of these projects now uh just theous abatement and demolition cost just throw it out there for for for when we're looking to roll this into capital and not adversely impact uh other school needs an elementary school is going to take $750 $850,000

146to to Abate and remove and my best high level guess right now at a Cypress High School type facility is is over $2 million and so you know when we talk about expediency I'm not talking small money when I get nervous about how I make sure I'm rolling out things to to our existing facilities taking a portion of that free money and remember Todd in our in our I think January you talked about some budgetary things said hey you really have about $9 million a year worth of capital rolling out now that's not pre- encumbered so to Me 2 million of I'm planning it out and I'm making sure that I can I can accommodate those things when when I think about some of those budgetary so in that budgetary impact I'm using a little

147bit of long-term thinking here to make sure that we're not adversely impacting an existing school too much when we take down um a closed school did we just go backward no no there we go oh I see where we at uh so so Todd talked about temporary uses uh and and some Community expectations so we we do look at what some of those short-term leasing uh revenues are uh Granite High used to be used as a film set for countless uh films uh filmed in Utah it had a historic junqua about it that that these uh site directors wanted and so we saw a lot of that um we've so we've even used some of the buildings that we have for storage so when we were constructing Cypress and and Skyline uh we use them

148to store materials that we would acquire through the contractor three plus years in advance because it was a lot cheaper to do it now than wait for inflation and so it saved us a lot of money by storing light fixtures flooring ceiling tiles uh ceramic tiles so so there's some internal reuse that makes sense and then there's a concept of using it for a Lifeboat on a rebuild or a remodel ochre Hills was used as South K's Elementary during its rebuild really important and so we're looking at how that fits into our Capital Remodel and rebuild with some of our other facilities as well it's it's so much easier to take students off campus on some of our schools than it is to keep them on campus and rebuilt sometimes our sites are plenty large

149that we can operate and construct safely there are other times where it probably is not in our best interest and if there's a Lifeboat School in the vicinity we can we can grab that population and and bus it uh you know for a year whatever uh Canyons does this regularly with one of their middle schools I think it's Crescent middle has been used for oh the better part of a decade in all of their remodels they would take an elementary school and move it there they've moved I think Union junor there temporarily they've they they've used the Lifeboat model successfully uh and a lot of districts do so that's another consideration that as we look at the long-term construction cycle sometimes we we may say oh that's going to be a great Lifeboat for Project

150X if it's in the reasonable reasonably near future so these are some of the long-term considerations that that we look into as a committee so we have a operating timeline of a long period of time when we build schools are for 40 50 plus years of duration and so we're looking that far into the future to make sure that we have our our student populations covered and taken care of uh we have our population projections this is this is an interesting area because we have a hard enough time figuring out who's coming next year let alone in 30 40 or 50 years uh there is a data that comes out of the keny gardener Institute they do their long-term population projections and they look out into 2060 and uh their latest analysis that uh was

151updated about 2 years ago uh shows the dip that we're experiencing right now so through the 20s and the 2030 there's a decline in enrollment that's just not granted that's a a Statewide experience but when we get to the tail end of 2030 it's going to come back and not only come back it'll surpass where we are where we were just a couple of years ago so it's so it's a dip down and then a huge climb up and so those are things that we want to take into account as well as yes today we don't have the students but not far in the future as far as long-term planning uh we could need those uh facilities back and online again for the students that will come back into the population uh so we we

152take that into account because it would be easy just to say oh we close the school we're just going to sell it and and and move on but if in 40 years we come back and say oh all those students have come back where are we going to build the school there isn't new land land doesn't get produced it's there right now um we also have vacant land uh that is in our inventory we we often have interest in those properties as well and so we want to make sure we have our long-term planning in place for that as well as will we get to the point at some time where we need to look at Future expansion it's not today but as we look into that projection and say well if it's going to

153be higher than it was previously are we in a situation where we need to be thinking about land banking for those Futures as well I think we've talked about the legal environment um so this is yeah let's go back let's go back one there there's a there's a little Nuance that in in state law if the district is acting to construct a an educational institution we don't have a lot of we're our own jurisdiction and can take care of our own planning building inspections Etc when that use transitions out of an educational use to anything else we actually have to comply with local jurisdiction zoning building codes Etc so just understand if there's an a use other than a school um it there there's some operational challenges of who regulates um and then just thinking

154as we go to sell these properties Granite was a was a a prime example the community sets their future land use not the district we're kind of like a farmer selling a field but it doesn't feel like that every member of the community says no we want you to sell it only for x or y or Z and so that's just you know the experience of the past we don't we don't control schools when they transition into different non-educational uses so there's some regulatory uh and permitting processes that that that come with all of this is it possible I mean I would I would assume this is a no but I'm just asking is it possible to when if we did sell a parcel of land to say you can it can only be used

155for this this if we sell it to you oh yeah you can do deed restriction certainly it it affects the value of the property depending on what you're restricting the use to okay I just so those are considerations you can one of the things we've noticed is that over the past probably decade a lot of communities used to keep the underlying zoning of the property so if it happened to be a school that was bought in the middle of a subdivision and it had a quarter acre lot designation most of the communities seem to have have have kept that they've now developed uh these uh public park public use zones uh and then rezoned it um and there's a dimunition of value associated with that because the the uses are so small so we'd almost

156always see someone whoever the buyer is offer contingent upon receiving a zone that they can then develop yeah just I going back to Gran yep yes you you can do all of those things should you desire yeah so this is the decision-making process that we're in right now so we conduct an analysis of the the property we evaluate the financial strategic and legal criteria and purposes of the property uh we do present a recommendation uh so you've had opportunities where we've talked about sales and purchases of property so we make those recommendations uh to leadership and then uh from there it comes to the full board for Action so that's the process that we're in uh right now today and uh this is a great time to review the process and we're hearing it's not

157fast enough so th those are things that we probably should look into uh not probably we will look into uh to see if we can make that more streamlined and more efficient uh for our communities to understand the future use or at least the district's intended ideas around closed School properties with that I'll I'll open up to any further questions could I just point out um appreciative of the real EST estate committee report that Todd forwarded out to this group you'll see that uh monthly after those meetings um just hearing some of the questions concerns we got from the board I appreciate them being responsive on that and hopefully that will help I did indicate that some of those Communications are sensitive and uh involve some transactions so please don't put that on Instagram I

158know none of you would ever do that but just putting it out there um so with respect to that I appreciate the update and uh I think one thing we really want to emphasize here is that we did learn a lot from our process involving the the sell of of granite uh High property and we definitely don't want to go down that road again so although sometimes it can be a little bit frustrating we certainly want to make sure that um we make good choices moving forward and if I could we had a simultaneous transaction with Canyon Rim Elementary uh as a charter school that leased it for at least a handful of years uh and then and then acquired it so we learned a lot from them as what you want to do as

159a landlord and who you you you want to sell it to your competition or not and so I think uh those are some challenges that we always face as well a question I think Julie has something so you mention cut let's let Kim go first sorry sorry Julie um so you mentioned some reasons why we may not want to sell property um can you talk a little bit more about the leasing option and what some of the challenges there might be pros and cons um if you already covered that I'm sorry if I missed it no you're good I'll take a stab at it and I heard Doug making comment already in the sideline so the one of the prospects that we look at is that 100-year timeline so if we're not in a position

160to sell like we we believe that that property will have a use in that time frame will consider a long-term lease so we have a ground lease in which someone can develop on top of the property and then uh when we then need to recall the property we can and reuse it for a school purpose so that's one one Avenue of leases is this ground or a long-term lease some of the the challenges are if someone's going to De develop on it they want it forever they don't want it just for 30 years or 40 years they want to be able to use it in perpetuity so those are some of the challenges that will come into is well how long will this term be uh often we will look at those uh leases and

161also say we'd like a reversion clause in other words if we need it even sooner than the 30 years that we're willing to commit to but we might need it in 15 or 20 what are the conditions around a reversion so so if you've improved the property do we have to buy it back at you do we buy it back from you at Book value or current market values or what have you so those then get caught up in legal discussions as to okay yes we'll do a long-term lease and we have all these other considerations that that need to be put in place you can have short-term leases which is you know maybe someone wants to use it for a community center or they want to use it for a charter school or something

162else then we get into questions of okay you're not just looking for the the land you want the building so we're looking at a building lease and now we have to talk about okay what's the condition of the building and what will they what condition will they maintain the building in uh will you be providing the custodial and maintenance services or will the district still be responsible for those and if so how what will those terms look like in a contract and those are the the conversations that happen on those short term is well who's responsible to keep the building in good shape and and are you willing to pay for it some of the challenges that we run into with uh some of our municipalities is they see that this is a public asset

163already the public has either paid for it with a bond or they've paid for it through some other taxation process uh so it should be available to any public purpose just because you stopped using it for a school doesn't mean the community can't have it for a park or some other uh purpose and they'll ask for that at no cost they'll just say just let us use it the challenge we run into is well we actually bonded or we taxed for the purpose of a school so those assets actually belong to a school purpose within the community Arena and if you want to use it for something other than a school the community should uh be on the hook then to to pay for whatever that new purpose is so those are some of the

164challenges we'll run into is hey it's already a public asset let us use it thank you thank you very much is that they've covered com kind of high level but those does that help a little bit yes it does thank you ahead Julie for PR for for no I do and I'm happy that your schools over there have been taken care of and and that's good Twin Peaks was like a no-brainer I I don't think there's any of us on the board that wouldn't that would ever take back you know moving the foundation over there that has been such a huge blessing to them but also a huge blessing to us as a district and to every single teacher and every single student in the classroom we have so so that makes me happy I

165do think that all I'm saying is I think that I don't want to rush a decision so I agree with you on that Julie but I do think that there can be a little bit more engine behind little push um I've got Sandberg in my area it's been closed for four years and it's there so there's just a few things out there you know Westbrook is not my area but I've kept my eye closed on that cuz when I was in board leadership Taylorville had numerous conversations with us about Westbrook every time we' visit for our yearly check-in so I'm I'm happy you've you know you've experienced that and I'm not saying I want to rush through and get the wrong decision I just think that there are maybe some practices that we can put

166in place that just move it along a little bit for for I have a comment so I wrote down a question I'm like do we have a larger number of empty buildings than historically in the past right now like currently is this unusual for us that we have this many school and I think that's where maybe part of this convers it's frustrating for us is this hasn't happened before where we've had a large amount of empty schools and so maybe that's where a lot of this is coming from with our communities also yeah I I think the the the pace of closures has been a little more rapid than we've seen historically um and then again oh Doug says by a long way um and then of course some of our these odd externalities of

167uh using a couple of them for storage for the two High School builds you know this these were hundreds upon hundreds of thousands of dollars of savings to use Sandberg and and others to store materials and so it was a an economic decision yes it's a delay uh of of what's happening but you know it it saved a lot of money just taking that Storage off of what a contractor was going to charge us to rent a warehouse our ability to just keep ordering materials so so I get that there's some frustration and rightfully so I mean there are a lot of details that go into why some schools it's that and not I would say that the other challenges that in years of closure you had pretty good sizable swats of vacant land that

168you could go reacquire for the next growth cycle um I'm I'm not seeing that this is an intensification of urbanization in our community that we've not gone through before and I think that's also part of the scary part of we don't know what we don't know on on student yield into the future I I Salt Lake is getting very very intens developed and it has and it has brought different interests into a closed school property versus are we going to make a community center out of it will someone come forward and operate that please versus there is no available land you just close to school you're not going to use it for that purpose we would like to develop it now so it's changed who's knocking on the door and now only increase as the

169housing crisis continues to promate and we we know that the legislature is not been shy about uh exerting their thoughts and opinions on how we do things in in public education so I I think the big scary fear is that if if we if we don't strategically hold on to pieces of property we'll be forced to do a land acquisition which is a Shopping Center yeah and that could be a derel shopping center or not and it will be tens of millions of dollars for that acquisition demolition on top of a construction cycle of of a school so those are I mean that's that's when Todd talked about what's that strategic Outlook you're certainly not going to go into a neighborhood and buy 40 homes to get a School site yeah and and I appreciate

170this um these slides because I think it helps our public understand some of the challenges that we face when we do close schools it's not just that easy to turn around into something else or to something viable which we have done with some of our schools but I think it's good for them to know that saved us money with storage facilities like that like that cost there is there is some benefit to that cost even though that school is now going to be empty again so you know just I think if we can just keep our public in the know of what what our plans are that we can share I think is helpful so thank you go ahead J for well I I am I feel like um that if we have the land

171and we can build a a larger school and and have the land that is already available even as the um growth if it increases at any time then we can build another school down the road if we like you I would worry about I don't want a highrise in my neighborhood and that's what it would be most likely in today's market I think the you know the one thing that we're not getting more of is land so you know it's just land is we've got the land that we have and and so um for me to support selling you know one of our properties I would have to have a really good case for it you know very very outlined because I think right now you can't grow more land and we've got to hold

172on to the land we have um you know that being said I'm not against looking at lease options and repurposing the land through leases because that still allows us to own the land if needed in the future keep our options open I think is what Connie is saying um to have that land to to you know potentially rebuild if needs to be you talked earlier the demographic swinging back up you know we're kind of in this little Valley I also know it never regenerates neighborhoods don't regenerate over 60% of their original population that's kind of a demographic rule by and large is that right projections I that that's the part that I alluded to that we don't know what we don't know with this higher intensity of UR urbanization you're absolutely right back in the

173day you you'd build a new subdivision and it would come in a 100 110% of what you think that population would be and then the families move in and out and it's coming back at 60-ish 65% exactly I don't know what it means to have all of this infill coming in yet and and other so so back in my younger days as a consultant we were a consulting firm for for school districts in Southern California and they faced this that their urbanization was coming and they had Asset Management challenges like we do and they were waiting to understand as intense development came in how many kiddos did it bring and I can't point to a rule of thumb in all of the communities in LA county Ventura County Orange County Etc Riverside where we work

174that could lead me to say oh I understand exactly what's going to happen in that City because each city was different where boy we would see some crazy population swings in one community and the other just kind of held steady so it's I don't know what I don't know and I think that's exactly what both Connie and Julie are getting at though is if we don't know what's coming we got to be protective of the asset we have right and so like I said earlier I you know I just I would have to have a really good case study um for me to support a sale of any property I know this would have to be very oh sorry Julie can I um I don't I in my area is that what you're asking no

175most I think mostly because weslake has been in there until this year I mean they they're still I think correct me if I'm wrong I don't know if the building is entirely recovered from what like occupying it it's getting there it's getting there you know they had to remove they they had to remove other so I think that's the only property that they see in front of them as far as like presence of mind so I that's so the Westbrook campus is the only one that I'm thinking that they would they would even I that's at least from my let me let me take a shot on that one Julie could I take a shot on that the one thing we did with the sale of the property of granite high was about 10 or1

176million and we put turf fields in all of our high schools and then now we're replacing all those turf fields right so this onetime infusion of a small amount of money comparatively speaking to the cost of a new building think about and I'm looking at Don he's going to nod his head $200 million at least for a new high school probably 80 to100 million for a junior high what did we end up on West Lake 65 65 okay not as bad but that was then yeah what does that look like and that's what I'm thinking and probably close to for a new elementary school yet most of these properties are still especially a small elementary site 5 to 7 acres is not going to fetch but a few million dollars and so it is a

177scratching the surface we'd have to sell a lot of real estate to even build one school and the value of that property long term has so much more uh value to us um in a long-term cost benefit perspective um even if we do long-term lease or some of these other uh just making sure we have access to some some of these pieces and Parcels longterm is there's some wisdom in that and and just a consideration as as you debate this do we sell do we keep do we lease long-term short-term the district isn't built around the idea of long-term Leasing or short-term leasing we don't we don't have a we don't have a landlord expert on staff so as we venture into that Arena we'll need to pull some expertise inhouse how do you manage

178a lease how if you're in those responsibilities in the leases we've been doing the best we can to get out of responsibilities because we don't have a lease person on staff so we try to push it off onto our Lessie but it doesn't always work and so there's just a dimension as as we move forward if if leasing is the direction we will need to manage ourselves in a way to do that efficiently and effectively I can tell you we can attempt to they don't always accept as we go through negotiations so it's a challenge and and here's a an example that that I like to illustrate if if we're we prefer that the the less e takes on the maintenance of the building why because if they take on the maintenance of the building

179the operational maintenance staff that's at the district gets to pay more attention to our open schools and I think that there's an intrinsic value in paying attention to our schools that have students than servicing a less e but that's that's sometimes we get some inexperienced buyers that don't have capability that don't they don't know how to go out and find uh someone that can provide those maintenance services and so that's also part part of the learning curve as these lesies approach us oh well there's there's a servicer out there that could do this tenant management for you you should have a conversation with them and they oh okay go have the conversation learn and understand build their capacity and then return to us in the conversation again I if you if you don't if you

180want us to continue the maintenance we can we just thought that that was a disservice to our students well I think the the big part and I'll summarize what I think Todd and Don just said that I think really important here is that treating our our especially our Municipal Partners fairly and the same and consistently trying to swing a good deal for friends and family on these long-term leases but at the same time making sure that our costs are in fact covered and to some degree um those Partners don't have the resources to do that which is why they're trying to access this property at a significant discount um so even when we are providing as much as we can um to to benefit uh both parties as it were sometimes the costs are still

181uh denigrating to to that partner I I mean I can I can speak to the the from the point of view of I I live vicariously through my family with the whole granted High School thing and it's I mean we can suggest to sell it but that is a huge part of community and so important so Central to that neighborhood and who they are and the thought of selling I mean Connie was here when when they went through that I don't think Ken was here when they sold sold Granite but um just you know that that's why I asked you know because I know they wanted to put a Walmart on that corner and the community was just no they you can't have a Walmart on a road that is you know two lanes it's

182it just you know it it is such a hard hard cell I guess if you want to say for a community and it's much better I think not just for the community but for us as well that in our relation with the community to say we will do everything that we possibly can to maintain this and keep this is a green space for your community I think that's what the community at Westbrook um you know this is a valuable Green Space for our community can we please keep this open for our kids to come play and for our dogs to come and run around and and you know things like that I think that's the as long as they're picking up after themselves yes that's what I said to them um well school's not in

183session but I think that's also it's not just that we can't gain property but it's also it's a value for our communities and it's something that they want us to continue to maintain as we are looking at that so I I I hear you saying this with Cyprus that your community is worried about what's going to happen with that I understand because we went through that as well so so to that end we do have a mailer going out and ad with an update on the Cypress High construction project uh an announcement of Tim as the new principal at Brock Bank Stam and a reminder of what happens with the property once those the schools no longer there and that the district intends to maintain the property currently but to this end I I think

184we can't had I known what I know now and we talk about a long time Granite High closed in the spring of 20 9 that property was not the final disposition on that property took almost 5 years and so it it was it was on the board when that actually went through yeah and and if I knew now if I knew then what I know now we never should have gone down that road I don't think it was worth the $1 million I don't think it uh endeared us to that particular Community to there was a feeling of cutting bait and run and then allowing for development to happen in treasured and uh open space in a place where that didn't have very much open space at all and so we're kind of in a

185and I apologize this is a family meeting but damned if you do and damned if you don't um on a lot of those types of decisions and frankly we should air on the side of caution thanks man agre I I'm just throwing this out there you know spaget against the walls some the sticks I don't even know if we would entertain it but we talked about how property is very rare and we do have our GTI classes would we ever consider using some of that property as I mean rezoning it some of this and having them build the houses on some of that property or is that we we've actually had some of those very discussions have you um and again that the two the two challenges to overcome are proximity to the GTI it

186makes Transportation so so easy when we're buying lots for them to build here they're currently on some West Valley stuff because we couldn't find anything around the GTI so maybe they'll they'll get over that and then the second is what did the community Zone the property so we might have to go to Baton in a community that zoned at open space and again in the right opportunity we should do it it it may not endear us to certain communities when we go in and build homes on what used to be playground or or but it absolutely makes sense and we talk about it quite often uh with with um uh James and others involved with CTE it's it's a very common and it's in the it's front of our mind again that's a repurpose that

187we think what's good for our kiddos we kept some of the Granite High School lots and built on those as long as we could and it's out there yeah yeah and and so it'll come up more pointedly probably in a year or two because we have enough inventory in stock right now to support the GTI program for the next four years is and so it's going to come up right any other questions okay thank you we missed some basketball games tonight so uh check in with your local scores we had a bunch of girls first round basketball games tonight I think Taylorville is beating Hunter right now Olympus is winning those are the only two I've heard reports back on move to adjourn second motion second toour all in favor please say hi all right

188thanks bye

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.