001all right um thank you for joining us everybody today is February 18th 2025 uh we are here for the purposes of not only a Salt Lake City School District Board of Education meeting but also a study session under the new format that was adopted by the board um in the previous month um so we are here to discuss magnet programs um we have Dr Hall with us the superintendent um the board um and Charlotte F Jefferson will be joining us here in just a few minutes so Tiffany I I guess the time is yours unless the superintendent needs to set the stage for anything NOP that's great run with it Tiffany and then it'll start the conversation okay thank you um I'm glad to be here I I don't know if this feels more like
002a study session or a responding session but I have had a list of questions that kind of framed where this discussion went um so I'm just going to be very upfront that there is a presentation of data first um that I was asked for and then then after that hopefully then the discussion will be able to grow from there um I also uh just want to make sure that everybody knows that Dr Alex Parsons is out she did have a healthy and beautiful little girl and so we're very happy for her and that she's able to be with her family at this time so if you ask me any really hard questions um the answer might be please check with me in six to eight weeks so off we go um we are going to
003be talking a little bit about class sizes about some enrollment Trends about enrollment and identification and how those things go together and then what our middle level programs look like because they are um really well they're very interesting so we're just going to get there but I'm going to begin with one of the first requests which is where are their special programs now this is not the comprehensive list of special programs but it is the comprehensive list of our gifted and talented programs our magnet program which are our Standalone programs that offer services uh for students in grades 1 through six and of course we know that those are at Edison Indian Hills and Whittier we also have a five and six at Washington that is phasing out so this is the last year of
004its fifth grade next year will be the last year of its sixth grade and a DLI ELP program and that's just always the way that we've referred to it um it is a magnet DLI program and that is now currently at nible Park where a neighborhood DLI program is coming up right behind it so that we will have um a neighborhood DLI program filling that school eventually as that as that comes in so we have kindergarten and first grade there now so those are marked and then our DLI programs at Mountain View Newman and nibble Park are marked and then you'll see that every elementary school has the academic advancement and mentoring program and those are really targeted at students in four five and six but we also do uh reach out work for students
005in grades 1 two and three and and sometimes even kindergarten um to really help identify or move students towards being a part of that amp program and as we've reported previously um that program has really flexed I think our old model was identifying a group of about 15 to 40 students per grade level sort of really depending on the size of the classroom at the school and that group of kids would have pullout services for the entire year in our new model we are looking at students that have high quantitative scores and then doing um a session of four to six weeks around quantitative issues um nonquant scores or our non-verbal scores or our verbal scores so that we have a larger number of students that are able to be um identified in the app
006program and have their academic identity built around that idea of being part of a special program because they're really good in an area so we're going to continue to expand um that identification and invitation process at every one of those middle or elementary schools with this program board member Jensen I'm sorry to interrupt you Dr Hall I just think it would be helpful for the public if you explained aam p and DLI I mean we know those acronyms but I don't know if some of them do if they're listening in okay um again the amp is Advanced academics and mentoring program and again that is really for uh students primarily in grades four five and six in our elementary schools um we we don't continue amp into Middle School in middle school we move into
007either an honors or a magnet and I'll talk some more about what that looks like uh toward the end of this program and then our DLI program and thank you I just kind of they roll off my tongue you know um is our dual language immersion program and in that program students are in a class um for or they're in a a half day of English and half day in a target language and in our district the three programs um for with the DLI program are all in Spanish so we have um students that are having half of their day in English and half of their day in Spanish in the Dual language program thank you thank you um I had several questions about magnet um class sizes and so I just wanted to have
008this information up again we looked at it the last time that we met and it looks at all of our programs including the ones that are in the phase out process and the numbers that are in blue are the smallest in that grade level so for instance in our grade one you'll see that you know Edison we have 16 in Indian Hills we have 18 and then in nibbi park and Whittier we have 15 um we talked the last time we talked about magnet about our combined grade four and five class at Edison we have in the past um split some of the early younger classes I have to go through all my notes to make sure I've answered all the questions we have um mixed some Kinder classes with neighborhood Kinder classes where that
009has been a small class and then um we have also uh looked I also want to just point out in our dual language program in that magnet DLI program we only um enroll students in the first two years because the language development is so intense that if they're not a native or Heritage speaker of the target language it is not possible for them to catch up after those first one or two years have gone by because they have acquired so much Spanish and there is no English at all in the Spanish side of the class and so if they're not converson in the Spanish then they're not able to maintain to into this um when we're looking at the magnet DLI it's phasing out and you're watching the numbers drop down we had that Washington
010pilot and we talked about at what threshold would you recommend something different so like 17 right now is actually much healthier than the previous year's numbers were when the board voted to discontinue the program but I have the same question that I had then which is as these numbers go down to 10 at what point would we recommend that we no longer hold a full classroom per grade level so and that's a great question um one of the things that that we did when schools were closed in the last year is that we you know did promise families and and this will come up in the conversation about where students are at in each of our area models but we had talked about preserving that program so that it would phase itself out um we
011would be able to if we needed to so our neighborhood program at nibbi park is now in kindergarten and first grade and so we would not have for instance a third grade that we would be able to move to so we have some shared teachers or we have some teachers that are teaching two grade levels so maybe a fourth and fifth grade English and a fourth and fifth grade Spanish um different models like that but um you know unless we were able to have students transfer in that had been previous iously in a DLI program or who were native speakers we wouldn't be able to do a lot with that particular grade level so that's that is a concern and I I guess as the board you would need to make a decision and tell
012me what that needed to look like but um that particular grade just ended up smaller across the board one of the things that has been an issue with the Emerson DLI program and now the nibbly DLI program is the number of students that phased out especially in grades five and six and went someplace else and that really breaks up the continuity because just to to talk about the whole program thank you board member Jensen for reminding me that I talk a lot about just the elementary DLI but really the whole point of the DLI program is that it is a 12year program of continuous Spanish instruction and so students will have their half a day in grades 1 through six in Spanish and then in middle school and high school they continue the program with
013classes that not only continue to work on Spanish but also build understanding and knowledge around culture and arts and literature and all of those pieces so that they become a well-rounded student moving into High School taking the first their freshman year DLI class at the end of that taking the AP test and as I'm you know I know many of us have had children that take the AP test and uh with a significant score or a high enough score many universities will award them um college or university credit for that once they pass the AP test they go into what we call a bridge program and that is a joint class that's taught between our teacher and a teacher from the University of Utah and those students earn three units a year of credit so
014a student could graduate from high school having begun in kindergarten or first grade with anywhere from 12 you know 3 to 12 units of University Credit which all of our state universities have signed on and agreed to count as full credit meaning that at most universities students only need one or maybe two additional classes to finish which would be one of their electives to finish in any degree that they wanted with a minor in Spanish and that ability to move into any career field with a bilingual focus and so it's in my mind it's very important to to continue to say this is the first step of a process of building a graduate and our graduates that are um able to speak in another language and to do things with that language as a result
015of the continuous 12-year program that we've provided also on this slide before I go to the next one you know just again we've talked about Edison and and this particular small class in our sixth grade um fifth six split for next year but also drawing your attention to that average District class size that is going to come up in a later slide when we talk about how we are going to look at what a full class means as we as we think about that um just for comparison because that's a great question about that magnet DLI class with 10 um these are some of the numbers in our DLI program and so you can see that um those are a different you know we have a a much higher enrollment especially in those younger classes
016so at Mountain View and nibbi park we've got 23 22 and a half of two classes each so that's that's 46 or 45 kindergarten students in both of those programs um at Newman 22 so those neighborhood programs we really do see a push towards making sure that we have DLI programs in our our district that's something that parents have really asked us for and it's always very pleasant when you you see parents asking for things and the numbers follow the students um some of our smaller classes at Newman are also because they've come from Mary Jackson where we were really getting on the model having a great time expanding that program and we're really looking forward to seeing that program grow okay we have some information about our invitations and enrollment so I have this
017for last year and I also attached to the very end of your PowerPoint um a sheet that had a little bit um more data and I'm going to just kind of talk through um each one of these and so this was what happened for us we test universally in this District at the end of grade uh the end of kindergarten and at the end of grade three so for our Rising first and our Rising fourth now a long time ago and not a long time ago but several years ago we used to start this testing before kindergarten and started ELP in kindergarten we had some concerns with that and you know we've we've brought these to the board before as as we phased kindergarten out of this the first is the coat as an assessment
018or any assessment in general is not very nuanced when it comes to students who are 4 years old second um when we are testing students that are not in our schools and we don't have control over that becomes an issue because it is all opt in it is parents who know even when we um we attempted to go out to schools and hold testing at various schools in the district it's still very hard for us to feel like we had a comprehensive look at all of the students so moving that testing into kindergarten for first grade allowed us to say we were able to to push this testing out more universally to all of our students so we had um again these so in January yes um when my son was invited into what was
019then is now amp um my understanding back then pulling your mic down just a little bit the mic sorry didn't mean to interrupt you it's so casual I forgot about this part um it's to repeat myself when my son uh was invited into um amp which back then was nelp and it's been a while um I believe it was around fourth grade and my understanding back then was that um the amp slnp um program um wasn't offered until about that age so when you're talking about the rising first grade testing is that specifically for the magnet which was previously known ASP but the rising fourth grade um sounds like it could be for amp and the okay for both that's correct thank you yep that is absolutely correct and that is because you know the
020magnet again starting in first grade and then you know we do add students to both programs in Rising fourth grade um we also just for the record also will retest in sixth grade if students are interested in going into a magnet program in seventh grade and they haven't been tested but we do hold the if you have tested into magnet once that's the end you're in magnet forever you know we don't go back and I mean let's imagine that you you aced it as a rising first grader and you had a bad testing day as a rising fourth grader we don't care like once you're in you're in you know that's just the way the way that we roll it's it would be cruel and inhumane to do it any other way so um coming
021in you can see that we invited uh again last year 52 students and had 43 um accept those placements and the piece that I want to kind of go through and on your sheet that was at the very end of this presentation um it has a little bit more information that I just want to explain why there are all of these different uh groups so we tested in the spring and we had some students uh from Spring of 2023 that were accepted deferred their enrollment to start in first grade that was generally students for Edison that was our first school that we discontinued kindergarten in because that with the DLI program as well was kind of complicated so we did have a group of students that tested in 2023 and we had been doing that
022for a couple of years that and we said if your first choice and I'll get back into the choices in the next slide but if your first choice is Emerson because you want to be DLI will hold that deferment you can either open enroll into Edison stay at your home school whatever you choose and then we'll start you in that DLI program that next year um so that that brought 14 of our students in and then in January of 2024 testing those Rising first graders we had another 38 so we had 52 total that were invited and 43 that accepted then we did in March some and so that January test testing is our grade wide testing and our amp teachers help us do that we'll talk about identification later I keep saying that but
023just so that we can move through the the information we do opt-in testing and that opt-in testing is for our families who are outside of the district and so if they you know see on our website we have we have the testing up we have a form they fill out we contact them if they've reached out to us and we provide that opportunity for them to test as well so that happens in March then we had um we have it's not a testing window but we have an invitation window and so in Spring of 2024 especially we reach out to students who had been previously eligible or found eligible but they had declined or deferred or did not respond we reach out to reinvite them just to let them know if you're still out there
024interested in coming in once magnet always magnet it's like being a panther right or yeah once a panther always a panther that's how we roll and so um you know we reach out to them and last year was particularly interesting because we had uh committed to our families that in any school or any program that they could travel with that cohort and so for instance when Hawthorne was closed a lot of the Hawthorne students were uh now now enrolled up in Indian Hills and that's because that is what we said that we would do that we wouldn't break apart that cohort and so in looking at that cohort and thinking about where um they would be we knew that that was going to perhaps give us that bump because they would be out of that
025area model but rather than disband them and send them to all the places when they'd already been to school for a couple of years or several years with that group of students we committed to to them moving over together now I did have some questions about what happens then if a student who perhaps is in the Wittier area model boundary now but is at Indian Hills maybe they have a sibling um because splitting up families we know how difficult that is it's it's very hard and sometimes families do that by choice I have a friend who No Lie drives her kids to three different schools because one wanted this is in another District she takes one to a French Pro program one to a Spanish program and one to another District to be in a
026Chinese program they have worked out quite a carpool but that is that is their choice and they do that what we attempt to do is keep those families together so just like our open enrollment process where if families have a sibling at the school already um they would be those same students are bumped kind of to the top of the list they're given a priority point for having a sibling and so we are mirroring that piece and so does that mean that we may have some students um in the next couple of years that continue through the process of being in one of our schools so that we can keep those families together it does again we committed to those families when we opened the program that it would that we would support them in
027that way yeah um for the Public's purpose um and maybe uh this covered it and I forgot it um but for the families that say they might have those complex scenarios and they feel like their concerns and their needs aren't being heard as they're juggling all those nuances who would they reach out to to help that person better understand the complexity in their family situation to hopefully navigate that a little bit better for them so when they um receive their invitation to apply for the program there is a place on that for that says do you have another student in the program or where are they at or do you have any other circumstances that we need to be aware of and so they can fill that in if they have additional questions about that
028they can reach out to the ELP office um we have Dr Parsons is out but Maggie Nickerson our secretary there is extremely well versed in all the processes and then we have Karen hullman who is our assessment expert she's available and I'm available so we're able to still reach out to that office if you have questions about what that looks like okay continuing on down the road now after we went through our closure process um and looked at all of the different things that might have happened in that spring um we had quite a bit of stuff that we had to do to get that settled and then we moved into some Edison only um identification and that really was in all of the grades we weren't able to start that until March and so
029one of the questions was you know what are we going to do to continue to bump that well one of the things we are doing is starting now like we would like to be able to focus in on that harder and earlier than we were able to last year and one of the things that we do there as we do um with all of our our students is we use what we call the utag which is the universal talented GI and giftedness survey that's another way that we are able to work and identify students at Edison that may come with other skills in addition to a coat or another way again I've got another slide on um identification later then we have one last set of testing or round of testing and that is our
030new to District we do that in August that is for families that move in over the summer and so we'll um test them at any grade level except third we do them in January and so we're able to um look at that so you can see in the uh Rising first we had three newa District they all were invite or three newa District families or students that were invited but then they decided to go elsewhere or they declin that placement um and we have that also in the um Rising forth graders so that was our enrollment trending for last year um we have just finished the January testing so if you look down at all of those numbers the two things that have happened as of this point is we have finished with 100% responses
031the intent to return so every year every student in the magnet program is ask if they intend to return that helps us with the initial number for planning um all of our Rising first and fourth graders have completed this testing and this week their invitations if they are eligible to be invited into the program or if they are on the wait list and they are um uh then either of those scenarios they will get an invitation that will lay out their next steps whether that is here is your form to fill out or here are the the things that will happen if there's movement on this weight list so that will come out sometime this week Dr Hall real quick yeah um a couple of questions I guess on the U tag is that like
032a it's like an entry level type of survey or test and does that you also I know in the past you and Dr Parsons have talked about you know how there's multiple disciplines or elements to ELP that include like art or Civic leadership and is that does the does the U tag help identify students for those particular tracks or disciplines um I wouldn't say necessarily as a track but it is a piece that would look at some different either things that um they have in their lives that would identify that um they have had circumstances that would help us identify them differently or things like leadership or different pieces if you're interested in looking at it we do have it posted on the website you can click through it as if you were a parent
033either a parent or a teacher can suggest that that we use this as well as our amp teachers or administrators we are constantly talking and working with the entire School faculty to make sure that they know if they have a student student that would um possibly that they look at and they say you know maybe they're still acquiring English so some of their academic test scores are not as high as somebody else's but we know that they um you know are able to do a variety of things and so there are several different areas that that that that looks for um when I get to identification I'm also going to say that we use some of our end of the year testing as well you can use that not to exclude but you can use
034it to in include students so um but yes if you're interested in that UST UT tags survey it is posted online it's not a secret survey it's it's um there okay so let's talk a little bit about oh sorry just one question so back on that other slide when you're talking about the opt in and the new to District I know that when you show like the number four and the number three those are the ones that went through the testing and now they get the invit ation I guess I'm just interested do we have a lot of like out of District individ or families that are saying oh we're interested in your program and are they filling out the forms to do that or is it just a small group I'm wondering what the
035interest is um in these programs from families outside the district or are there some that are moving to the district because they like these program s you know I think that there was and I would have to go back up to to pull that data that is a a great question and it really looks at um what I think has happened over time with gifted programs overall um I think we used to have more interest because we were one of the few districts that that maintained kindergarten later than other districts did and so we would maybe have some parents who who would come in for kindergarten but then they might cycle back out to their home districts for first or second or third grade and the fact of the matter is even for kids that
036are maybe really super readers or other things like that the research is really not that great that I mean not that conclusive that being in a gifted program in kindergarten has a long-term beneficial effect so I think that we might have seen more parents 10 years ago than we do now so for instance um probably maybe 25 to 30 families May inquire and and then coming in to test that number goes down and then as you'll see even when they're invited sometimes they make that decision especially with younger kids that maybe my my neighborhood school I mean 90% 95% of parents they they will choose their neighborhood neighorhood school just because that's where their students friends are the people that they know and so it really um is often where they work you know there
037are other reasons that make that really compelling to take a different placement yeah one question on that last slide I had a question about do we know um the ones who did declined where they go instead do we have that data um for the ones out of the district we we don't know we would assume that perhaps they they stayed in their own District um you know I don't think they were District swapping but um for the ones that decline in our district very often they do stay at their neighborhood schools and that's what they decide to do okay all right let's kind of roll through this kind of quickly um because I know I have to end at 5 o' class enrollment past practices so this idea of of a c being sort of
038a new thing is really not a new thing so let's just kind of remember how this went in the past previously we had three magnet locations Hawthorne Whittier and Emerson and what we would do with those three locations is we would test all of the students and they would all be in one bowl and we would ask those students and their families what is your first choice second choice third choice and then we will try to match you it was like going to medical school we'll try to match you with your first choice or your second choice or your third choice and we'll see what happens there and inevitably you know we had the same number of classroom chairs that we have right now um so even if I took let's just say 25 first
039grade chairs I would have 75 first grade chairs because I had three schools but what would happen there is that I had a lot of steps that parents had to go through they had to tell me what their first choice was and then they had to wait to see whether they get their first choice or their second choice or their third choice and sometimes if they couldn't get their first choice or their second choice their third choice wasn't an option because of after school care or Transportation or where did Grandma live we heard all of these things and so that that model created it added both some layers to the process and it also um pushed everything back so our schools didn't know Transportation didn't know we really didn't know it had a lot of
040steps and they were all necessary but we also had that was a lot of work for parents because if they missed a date or they didn't return a document then you know that was always a question too so we had a start date for placement and then after that initial date we would place them as letters came in well that also is a little bit you know if if you're a very busy person um maybe you only check your personal email like I do every third or fourth day um that that is is a disadvantage to parents who maybe are on their email all the time or at dings or whatever um they also had to really you know wait because after school and transportation all of those things had to come after that placement
041the other thing that would happen is that they would accept an invitation but then later decid you know what this is going to be too hard and grandma says she can't drive all the way over here to pick them up and so we're going to remain at our home school and so we had a lot of flux in enrollments placements in transportations sometimes it was a week into the school year before some of those things were settled that created some issues with buses that that creates issues for our teachers so we really wanted to address some of those issues one of the things that we talked about um when we moved to the area model last year is that this means that families will know where their students are going even before they apply they
042know that this is the school that they would be going to so they can think about what that means for them in terms of Transportation or after school care all of those pieces and we also know that a limit is a necessary piece and we've always had one it's just that we were able to spread that Out Among the three schools because if we got to the end and we had five kids we're like well you know these five kids you get your second or third placement and so that wasn't necessarily as Equitable but it did mean that we had the same number of SE of seats and so in going to this area model what we learned last year is that it would be much easier for everyone involved if we just said let's
043have a number that we draw the line because otherwise there will be this constant well but this school has 28 and this school has 27 when we had the three models and we just parsed them out we balanced that way I mean you know you you would put put 25 in each school and then the next person to come in would go to one and the next person would go to two and the next person would go to three and the next so that we could keep those schools relatively uniform didn't always end up that way by the end of the year but that was the placement and so now we're trying to do the same thing it's just that instead of saying that we're going to you know wait and continue to balance as
044kids come in we're just going to say this is how we're going to balance and we did when we talked about this earlier look at using District enrollment but as you saw on a previous slide our district enrollment is actually below what we would call a break even point for being fiscally responsible and so that doesn't mean that you know 25 or 28 students even in a Jed class would be the point where you would split off and make another class but it is kind of that break is is it okay if I say it that way Mr kirley kind of the break even Point like it's more or less a point that we would say this is about how many kids we would expect to have in that class so we're going to say
045that you know 27 students K3 would be our upper and 30 and 46 would be our upper and that's what we're gon to we're going to roll with um can I ask a question about that the practices make sense to me but we are also at a weird bridge between the old way of doing it and the new way of doing it so if I'm a student who is not zoned for instance to Wittier but I have always gone to Whittier and you know School closure was not part of my decision but I have five younger siblings who also want to go to Whittier because that's where their older sibling goes how are we addressing that for families who started in one place right right as I said we're going to Echo the the uh
046open enrollment process we are going to commit to those families that if you have a student already enrolled in those schools and your student qualifies into a magnet program and you say but I have a student already in fifth grade that we will not split your family and that your that student would be placed in Wittier even though it's not their area model we recognize that this is going to take us a few years to work through but we would rather do that than have Stu you know families needing to drive to two different programs do we have a guess of how long that window of time might be of impact we said that we would bus families for three years after closure okay so after that families could make another decision if they wanted
047to um we have been open about that three-year thing so it could be that families may want to make that choice if they have a fifth grader who's only going to be in a program for two years and an incoming first grader they may want to look at a split right because there's transportation to their area model school and they may be driving them to the other school but um you know they they would have they would have some opportunities to Think Through how they wanted to to play that yeah um on the area model concept is there an ability um if there is space available for people to basically open and roll into these area model magnet programs sure so let's say that um I was in I I went to Whittier in second
048grade and and Whittier was full in second grade and so I was on a wait list but I learned that there is an open spot at the Indian Hills second grade I could apply to be on that weight list and then I would be slotted into that weight list depending on my score so it's possible that I could end up in an Indian Hill second grade class or an Edison second grade class depending on on what that looked like I would be then in that class and I would be off the waiting list for my area school um we won't we won't put people kind of in two places because then that's not fair to the other people behind them great question okay let's talk um let's see what what does this do so we
049know that that means that oh I've done that slide already good identification practices so our initial screener is the coat um it's nationally recognized identifier there are limitations the national percentage um and our areas were mapped so that if we identify the top three to six% of students then that should be the right number for us um for magnet assignment and That should be about right having looked at all of our our numbers over the years there some questions let's see I'm going to deal with that on the next slide um so students who were not in the top 3 to 6% but again there might be reasons for that could be second language could be adverse childhood um experiences that um would make that coat less nuanced for them then those students could also
050be evaluated using that holistic Matrix that uags that we just talked about and that we could um use that inv to capture those perceptions we can also look at other academic data all right um and really you know the question is well what happens uh I think you know people have said well what happens if all of the programs become full if all of the programs become full perhaps I come back here and say are we ready for a fourth magnet site I don't know I'm going to wait and see like I I just that would be something that we're always open to as we look at this okay coat identification more so um there were questions about how we are testing students using the Kat and one of the first ones was around that
051kindergarten test Rising first and why we are giving first just the screener so kindergarteners as you all know being on Schoolboard are about 5 years old and the screener is about 30 to 40 minutes long and that is the far outside of what we can do with a kindergartner in one setting but what we do then with the uh kindergarteners is we take that top chunk of scores and this year we did do the Ravens which is a non-verbal test um because that's about another 35 to 45 minute um test Administration but next year uh we've purchased the new licenses to uh give that group of students the full coat so they'll be doing the same thing that our Rising fourth graders do so we'll moving over to that yeah that and how long how
052long of a test is that um that is about another UH 60 to 90 minutes but we won't do it for everybody we'll just take the we'll we'll do the screener across the board and then students in that top percentage of the screener those would be maybe the top 20 to 25% I you know the numbers vary um but they would receive the full coat at that point for that more nuanced um look at their identification um so this year we did about 90 or 100 somewhere in there it's about 30 to 35 students per area that um end up going for that second step in that process um we also had a question about accommodations and what those look like for the coat um as with all tests we have a tam a test
053Administration manual and that Tam helps us to know what is allowed in terms of accomodations for different tests so our coats are all given by our amp teachers and the amp teachers work with our special education department so if a student has an IEP or a 504 that we're able to do these um coat accommodations that are acceptable when working with the Kat we work through them to make sure that they're able to know you know which ones they're able to repeat directions with or add extra time so um we're able to do those things and then as uh a question was asked earlier this is also when we look at um an appeal request anybody can initiate that to use that utag screener or to to look at uh some additional end of level
054testing data and we review those appeals with the rubric to ensure consistency um one of the things that we know is that you know I we all know that the student that we know the best is the most gifted student that we've ever read you you know met and what we found was we wanted to be really um aware of making sure that a teacher or a parent who was really able to lay down some solid you know they like to play with Legos and they talk a lot about death kind of descriptions I don't know that comes up a lot I don't know why um but but that that was not yeah very existential we're all reading Kimu in kindergarten and um but but that that didn't sway a process from a parent perhaps
055that is an engineer and writes three or four sentences and calls it good you know I'm married to one of those three sentences is pretty good so um we're trying to really standardize this process as much as possible so that we don't have those kind of changes or or um floats in a direction and then we have middle uh our Middle School programming so once again once once you're a magnet always you're a magnet um we have three middle school programs Clayton Hillside and West now Clayton and Hillside are magnets within a school so students in those programs they can decide that they want to be in magnet CL classes in social studies in English and maybe in science but if they don't want to be in magnet math they don't have to be in
056magnet math they could be in another math or maybe they love math but they hate Ela they can they can mix and match and they can do all of those things there our third magnet program is at West High School and West High School that's all there is so students who go there know that they are moving into this program the other difference about West High School is that it is the place where they can accelerate because they have more access to high school level classes there so recently and by recently I mean this year some of our state Administrative Code has changed to allow students who earn High School Credit in Middle School to carry that credit forward with them into high school so all of our our magnet programs offer uh 78 uh
057condensed math in seventh grade and an option for students to take um secondary one extended in middle school but at West students who have already I think we have a couple students right now who are in secondary math three while they're in middle school because they've taken classes through the state online education program or they've accelerated and demonstrated you know that that's an area for them that they are good at so they are going to West because they are wanting to accelerate in that way and that's a real difference when you think about a gifted and talented program gifted meaning I'm naturally able to do things talented meaning I'm able to do things with practice and support um maybe better than everybody else you know I was a good I I could catch a ball
058well that's my giftedness but my talent really comes when my coach works with me over time um but an accelerated program really means and I want to move forward fast so um I've provided this and perhaps should have provided it with the middle school program presentation as well but these are the key features of that program at West because it is different um we have 83 7th graders and 111 um eighth graders this year and you can see where they come from we have about 40 out of District so back to Mr Jensen's question board member Jensen's question we have more students that enter from out of District into this program than we do to our elementary program by far um so that is um you know that is where our data is in this
059program they do do because again our Administrative Code says that you can't skip Middle School classes and replace them with high school classes so we do have to make sure that we are teaching the Middle School classes so you can see those seventh and eighth grade classes there but as I said they can accelerate in math and they can also um take as electives a variety of different High School courses so I just you know over the weekend pulled up 25 or 30 different class schedules at West to see what kids in the ELP program in the magnet program sorry old hit diey hard um are taking and it is everything from eighth graders in Chinese and Arabic and French and Spanish to business management to um office Aid to Fine Arts courses some in
060theater some in art some in choir um couple kids intro to debate several kids in the creative writing class I mean there's just and and as they're taking those classes they are taking them with students in grades 9 through 12 and so they're able to do that and that credit will hit their transcript when they move into high school as high school credit and last awareness um just a couple of things about how we continue to promote and um and make sure that parents know about this so first again we're one of the few districts um in Utah and actually even nationally that make sure that we do full grade testing so Kinder and third grade to help identify potential and the students who are identified through that way we do then email those parents
061when they qualify either outright or for subsequent testing so that we can begin that communication process with them about what those scores mean we work constantly with our school administrators and in fact we email on a regular basis principles assistant principles and the secretaries with information asking them to put that in their school newsletter that information also goes out in all of our district Communications we put it on the website um we contact some of our um Charter friends like the open classroom directly to make sure that they know because they are a charter school that is not technically part of our district but we do support them for this um we make sure after testing parents are given um the information about the scores in the parent portal and any next steps they may
062want to take and so that we're able to um really help recognize and find those gifted students and give them this information we also every year um follow up with students who are identified previously um that was we saw that in the in one of the charts about making sure that if they were identified then we follow up every year and say you know we identified you would you like to play ball this year and they can say yes or no um at Edison this year as I said we're really using more time to recruit those families to talk to those families um we're asking and the the teachers the administrators and teachers in the Edison program are reaching out and they're reaching out through our family contacts as well to make sure that um
063all of our families understand what this means our schools also have both walk-in visits and open houses advertised and our middle schools do that as well they will have open houses and they'll review these classes in their registration process to make sure that parents and students recognize that these classes are available and of course the one thing that we also did that has really helped increase recognition is move from the nelp and melp model of naming which was difficult for many people especially those coming from outside of the district to magnet which is a much more um nationally accepted and known name okay thank you for your questions I'm finished with mine please okay so I just want to ask quickly about capping because you talked about that so if we go back and look
064at the numbers um for the class size 20 24 25 um right now at Indian Hills we have in two of those grades fourth and sixth they're above what the cap is so I'm imagining that there's going to be an exception made there if those yeah students continue through okay but what we're also saying is that program is full then so people that are looking to go to Indian Hills like these next couple of years in fourth fifth and sixth grade they're most likely going to be told it's full it would be fifth and sixth grade um because that that's because four is going to yeah so they would they would continue so we would so for instance our Rising fourth graders we currently have 13 in that class right so would' be we'd be
065okay there but those other two okay then the next one and this kind of goes to capping but you were talking about the ELP program at West so when my children were participating in that I mean it was highly competitive I don't know if it still is but um and the list was pretty long okay is that still the case no I I've been informed by the high school that we aren't capping anymore that they're able to take the students that apply to come and so that's nice to know because Middle School we don't have the again the only thing is that they need to have qualified into magnet but we don't wait list in middle schools at all any of oh well that okay that's great because when my children were there you got
066in but then like some of them would get there and they would drop out because it wasn't what they had envisioned or it was hard for a seventh grader to be in a high school setting I mean there were numerous factors so then they would move out of the program but then there were people that were out there waiting going oh my gosh I didn't get in and how do you accommodate that but you don't need to worry about that now no and and that was really very difficult and you know you're you're very correct in saying that sometimes students would get to West and it wouldn't be the right thing it's like students who get into UCLA and then come back and say that was just way too big for me you know and
067it's not it's just what school fits the student and that's that's really what I would say there so um the hard part with that is when they're rolling in in the semester even when they're bringing a grade from another school it takes them some time to grab their feet and to get grades figured out in all of those pieces so yeah it's been it's been a minute I I don't remember us doing a weight list to be honest so it's been at least five or six years okay and then finally on along that line so at the West one the seventh grade it's lower it's like 83 and then the 8th grade it's 111 do you think that part of that is is that there are children that are thinking oh okay I'm old enough
068now that I can go that what do you think that disparity is I mean it's almost like 30 I think it's math oh okay I think it's math we we have students that come because this is the maybe the only one on the wasach front or in Utah where an eighth grader can take secondary two or three yeah I mean most middle schools now have an option for a secondary one in grade 8 but not past that um and it's just not practical for a middle school to do that um but at at West if you needed to accelerate like that you can that's my guess yeah kind of going with that question so are middle schoolers there particularly eligible for the S so program yes they are and that's a fantastic question the state
069online education program is one of the ways that most of them have accelerated up to needing secondary two or three and that's a program where they can take classes online they are teacher-led they are original credit and they will count for credit when they move into high school and is that not available for students at other middle schools it is yeah it is or not it is anybody in the state can and what does that can you repeat that acronym yeah there are a lot of acronyms right here so I'm going to give them all to you so State online education program s o p that is the program um you get into it using a program called seats I don't remember what that one stands for but that's how you register and then within
070the s o there are eight providers that students can choose to take classes from and there's a quite a large variety and middle school students can begin to take High School classes using that program and as of this year that credit all counts towards high school and that's a Statewide thing okay yeah so it really is math in person because a lot of students find when they get to that higher level math being in the classroom does help because they can ask the questions they can hear the yeah oh yeah I think we should just come back to what that the first question I asked which is at what threshold would we consider changes to this format numbers wise because we hear often that this comes from a different budget but all all of our
071money for students comes from the same big bucket so just because we scooped a cup out of the bucket doesn't mean it's different water so it do these District averages show the outliers or do they exclude them like is this the district average for first grade is 18 including elop or excluding magnet classes excluding it excludes it so it's saying that's lower overall yes um it does include our special eding self-contained classes I did not pull out oh so some of those will be below 10 and that brings down the average I guess what I'm saying is when you're if you look at these numbers you think oh these are somewhat uniform but if you're in a neighborhood classroom with 32 and your next door neighbor has 13 or 14 and also we're paying for
072that difference it doesn't really seem fair that we're paying for such small class sizes for one small group so we can talk about how you know beneficial the classes are how we've benefited from them um but what do people think about that like at what threshold would we consider why we operate this in the way that we do um maybe there won't be a finite answer to that right now I would suggest that we revisit this next year because that gives us basically two years from the point that we closed the elementaries have the elementaries more stabilized and then see what the numbers are vetting out to be to then in turn like figure out what the answer to that question might be and one reason I would offer that now it's productive to talk
073about it one we have the study session but we may not do that but two we we did vote as a board to close a program because class sizes were too small but now we're subsidizing a program that has class sizes that are smaller so I think it's you know we've been told over time this takes a while to build up it takes a while to build up up but is there a timing that we would annually talk about that and and just the financial component of it because the academic component of it we understand the practices have become more expansive there are all these benefits to the things we're doing but at the end of the day we have classrooms of 14 or less next to classrooms of you know 29 and above and
074I think that's something worth talking about for the students in the bigger classes I I think you may also want to look at perhaps doing what some other districts on the wasat front are doing and that's beginning magnet programming in 456 oh so you're saying that one reason they're smaller is because of the lower uptake in younger grades it could be I mean I'm just as you look at the data um you know nibbly part magnet is an anomaly there because magnet and DLI should never have been paired together um so we're working through that and that's one of the state assurances that they're not paired because it should be open access but um if you look at our um Indian Hills and Whittier numbers and and you know even our our Washington numbers right
075now the fourth fifth sixth grades are the larger classes what districts do magnet starting and fourth I will need to answer that in four to eight weeks I just know that to eight weeks six to eight weeks yeah Dr Parsons has talked to all of them she meets with the um directors regularly so I I know she told me that but I don't remember where and I won't quote it because I'm I'm not sure yeah that's for the best yeah I've run short on time but we could probably take one more question well I just wanted if we if we did what other some other districts do and start in fourth grade students who need this kind of programming would suffer I guess in a way they their needs wouldn't be met um but but
076you're saying that the class sizes would be better possibly Noor I'm just throwing this is a decision that the board will make um I was just commenting that I know that that's something that some places have done they they've started of that could I um just mention that um gifted in the gifted and talented programs in ELP the magnet is very new to Westside communities and families and so if we could put put some extra focus in um advertising those programs in culturally responsive ways um I think that would help a lot um and if we could advertise them the Edison program one of the real benefits to have students go to Edison is that they will get um an International perspective there their their students will not only get the the gifted education but
077they'll have student uh classmates from all around the world and that is extremely valuable it it just widens a student's world viiew and that should be um championed more I think could be thanks everybody that will conclude our study session and uh please filter additional questions or feedback about the format knowing that this is a brand new thing that we're trying out be super helpful thanks everybody and eat fast