001thank you everybody for rejoining us um the time is 5:36 today is February 8th 2025 thank you for the opportunity uh for us to participate and convene our first study session under a new structure um that the board adopted last month um to have a a monthly study session ideally um first I want to welcome everybody for joining us this evening um for the purposes of a Salt Lake City School District Board of Education meeting I also want to make sure that I recognize our classified associations from buildings and grounds we have President Leo compo from Child Nutrition president Tanya Slaughter uh for transportation we have Audrey benali for SLA we have President Mike Haron and vice president Chelsea a Costa and then for sloa they're represented by President Adrien labado um up next we'll
002have the Pledge of Allegiance and I've asked vice president Jensen to lead us in the pledge I pledge alce to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all all right up next in our opening items we have some recognitions we're super excited about this the presidential awards for excellence in Mathematics and Science teaching is our first one superintendent do you want to introduce us or do you have a Cabinet member that I think our award winner Holly McIntosh is going to come up here to introduce our winner of this p8 p e pain P pain actually you can say it that way you can you can and should okay all right thank you board members and
003thank you guests um for the opportunity to recognize our own Todd badre West High math teacher as our PST award recipient the PST award is the presidential award for excellence in Math and Science teaching it's the nation's highest distinction for K12 Math and Science teachers in uh technology engineering mathematics and science this award honors the vital role that American teachers play in shaping the next generation of technical leaders including mathematicians scientists engineers explorers and innovators this award is a very big deal think Oscars think gramys in fact it's true right we're underdressed we should probably have dressed up right in fact yeah yeah Todd's got a jacket on that's that's pretty good um in fact Todd himself described the selection process as like the Olympics for Math teachers and now TD is a gold medalist
004to continue with the metaphor this has been something of a marathon for Todd Todd is the pains awarde for for 2021 secondary mathematics due to delay delays at the federal level in announcing awardees um it didn't follow the typical timeline having no news of the 2021 award waries Todd was nominated again in 2023 and was again selected as Utah's secondary math finalist some of you might have remembered him being presented to the board yep that's why uh these delays certainly kept the suspense up and maybe made the news of the award even a little sweeter in addition to this recognition awardees receive a paid trip to Washington DC to um attend a series of award recognitions um $10,000 from the National Science Foundation a certificate signed by the president and probably the most exciting is
005that the awardees join a national network of active outstanding Educators from across the country that serve as leaders in improving Math Science and stem education if you're looking to make improvements you would want a Todd badre on your team Salt Lake City school district has a long tradition of our Math teachers being selected as state finalists and national award recipients it speaks to the caliber of our Math teachers the level of Cal of collaboration continuous Improvement and commitment to Excellence in our district Todd is an example of these qualities the PST award recognizes those teachers that have both deep content knowledge of the subject they teach and the ability to motivate and enable students to be successful in those areas PST aies contribute excellence in both their classrooms and to their profession as a supervisor
006of mathematics and someone who knows Todd's work I can certainly say this is true of Todd as a national board certified teacher Todd is committed to his students and to bringing them excellent opportunities in mathematics learning in Todd's classroom is engaging challenging and rewarding students access deep learning as they collaborate to build their math ideas and their math identities Todd's a leader who impacts whose impact extends Beyond his own classroom he ensures his students experience math outside the classroom as a coach and an advisor he takes teams and groups to Mar various math events competitions and learning experiences Todd's math counts team often comp often competes at the national level and Todd also teaches courses at the University of Utah please join me in thanking Todd for his excellent work and congratulating him for this
007award piure I just want to thank the members of the Board of Education um eight years ago um I work worked at the State uh Board of Education um I was the assessment director for I was over all of sage mathematics um at the time uh I realized I wanted to get back into the classroom and I had my pick of any District um in the entire State and I want you to know that I actively chose Salt Lake City School District because I had two goals in mind one I wanted to be a national board certified teacher and two I wanted to get this Pam award eight years ago um and because of Salt Lake City School District's commitment to mathematics education not only did I select it out of all of the districts
008quite intentionally and specifically West High School um but I felt support all along the way in getting this and this really does feel kind of like a a Lifetime Achievement Award with how big it actually is so I want to thank all of you um in uh the work that you've done in helping me get there and uh giving me some great students that I can teach along the way so thank [Applause] you hey excuse me Todd we got a a certificate for youor thank can we have you go on this side then it even out a little bit okay everyone looks great okay everyone ready on the count of three ready one two three take one one two three okay perfect thank you [Applause] the good news and recognitions for Salt Lake City School
009District Math teachers just keep coming we truly have some of the finest Math teachers in our district I am so proud to call them mine and yours and ours we're very lucky I'm pleased to recognize La gy a fourth grade teacher at Mountain View Elementary as this year's recipient of the Utah Council of teachers of mathematics Carl Jones award for exemp exemplary elementary mathematics teaching the Carl Jones award is for teachers who encourage student achievement by providing activities which enhance understanding of math concepts for teachers who generate enthusiasm for math among students while providing opportunities to apply and extend mathematics for teachers who serve as role models to other teachers and students by demonstrating interest in acquiring and maintaining skills in mathematics including instructional skills for teachers who demonstrate a willingness to share ideas skills
010and passion with other teachers I've seen all of those qualities in LA's work La is extremely dedicated to teaching and learning all teaching and learning mine yours students colleagues and her own um LA's approach to mathematics instruction is carefully planned to meet diverse learning needs it's Dynamic and Interactive her dedication to students building confidence in mathematics is actually transformative students who enter her class with uncertainty leave with both a love and an understanding of mathematics she uses student data to ensure every student needs are being met La is a leader who collaborates with others at all levels she regularly works with her math coach in her building and teacher teams to ensure student outcomes she authors articles and shares resources her school Community is enriched by these activities Lea is a true or La is
011a true learner herself I see this passion firsthand and I remember when I was watching her in the math endorsement classes that Salt Lake City School District's partners with suu to provide she was so excited to engage in the ideas could not wait to get them back to her students could not wait to come back to class to share how that went um La is also a national board certified teacher a Utah teaching fellow uh member of The Hope Street group recipient of the Excellence in teaching award through UEA and the recipient of the exceptional service and Outreach award from the first lady um Abby Cox please join me in thanking L and recognizing her for this award thank you all um I'm truly honored to receive this recognition um as I stand here today
012I can't help but reflect on my journey when I first applied to teaching District my qualifications including two master's degrees from Utah's University and nine years of teaching abroad weren't enough to even get a call for an interview it wasn't until I raised concerns about Equity that dors started to open I share this not to dwell on the past but to highlight an important truth talent and passion exist in all backgrounds and when we fail to recognize them we risk missing out on Educators who can truly make a difference our students come from the risk backgrounds and they deserve to see themselves reflected in their Educators representation matters not just for students of colors English Nares or newcomers but for all students it builds empathy broadens perspectives and creates richer learning experience I'm so grateful
013to be here making a difference in my students lives but I also wonder how many other passionate qualified Educators never get that chance I hope we continue to work toward a system where every students benefit from the rest talented and inclusive teaching Force thank you so much [Applause] and here is your certificate for today's honor also um you for the other uh award that you earned for the Utah Coalition for educational technology teacher of the year of the district [Applause] not can we squeeze in just a little bit more there's just so many of you guys okay that looks great ready one two three one two [Applause] all right board members don't get too comfy because we are going to transition out to the audience for our next presentation we're really really excited to celebrate
014and honor Black History Month here in Salt Lake City School District and in the city with us this evening we have a very special group we have the Highland High School step team if you don't know about this club or about this team they're on the map you know they've been on the news they do a lot of performances around the community and we're just really really excited that they're here with us tonight to celebrate such an amazing month in our Rich history here in Salt Lake and in this country so we'll head over there and de did you want to introduce anything we've got a senior introduce the group good and I'll just let you know this is laai bakai a senior at Highland High School and member of the Highland High step team
015we're excited to have them all here today and I'll turn it over to latai thank you founded in 2023 the Highland highsteppers emerged from a desire among black students at Highland High to have an extracurricular activity where they felt seen valued and connected with the support of Highland staff members de straight Tiffany rmon the vision gained momentum when Community Advocate Nikki Walker Amplified the call to for leadership answering that call Coach Chris M Henley and Coach Kristen Slade brought the dream to life and transformed it into a thriving reality rooted in the rich tradition of Step the Highland High steppers are more than a team they are a movement they uphold high standards of discipline academic excellence and Leadership while using step as a powerful expression of Heritage and cultureal pride through Rhythm unity and
016precision they continue to expire and concrete create a lasting impact within their school and Community thank you [Applause] I set it's cold in here there must be some steppers in the at Miss I said it's calling here there must be some in the atmosphere I said h i g h l a n e h i g h f a n d h i g h f a n g wo woo what's going on did y see the c p for our science class no why was on it we finally get to join the science fair science fair yeah I think I'm going to do a volcano I cancer I want to explore the space time Contin um guys yeah I'm glad you're excited for this science project but doesn't that mean we have to know
017the scientific method oh don't worry y'all I can help it's super easy it's only six steps observe question hypothesis experiment analysis and conclusion oh that doesn't sound too bad we can work together as a te to get it done faster what's the first step observe what observe what I didn't hear you sit back and Ober you know we set it up you know [Applause] y'all I think we observed a lot but what's the question we're going to try to solve how the a that's a good one what about how the body uses energy to make different sounds wait I got it how much energy do the highers bring to the save yeah that's a good one so what's our hypothesis going to be how about the high high SE brings all the energy to the
018stage from stepping to dancing shaking the stage and energizing the crowd they always put on a show others can try to test this Theory but we always prove them wrong oh we like that so now it's time to experiment with different theories right yep time to go get them Smo wow those are some cool test runs but I don't know if who went first place with it do y'all think have one more experiment than us to try oh of course want [Music] [Music] going on [Music] [Music] w so now that we had some good experiment I think it's time for us to get all the data and analyze the results let's break it down step by step [Applause] you're right the conclusion is my favorite part let's end this project with a bang and show
019them why the high steers bring the energy and every single time what you know about me b g l o n g l e 50,000 new every [Applause] let's have board members on [Music] will you guys take a step this way yeah can I get the whole step team to go this way like a step that's good yes yes is it okay if we move to know we can see her or maybe switch with Ashley is that okay yeah thanks there we go you guys look so good okay everyone smiling come through ready one two three get one more ready I like it okay ready one two three than [Applause] how I step team give it up one more time thank you my alma moer all right now we got everybody back to the board
020table uh we'll move on to our consent agenda uh before I seek a motion I did um board leadership did receive an email from a board member to pull three items from the consent agenda those three items are items 1 a core Technologies items 1 c um KCK up Incorporated and item 1D MGT of America Consulting LLC we will add those to the action agenda and take those up when we get there um is that correct Ashley are the three items okay perfect um with that I will go ahead and seek a motion um to approve the consent agenda minus those three items that will be present on action I'll make the motion to approve the consent agenda agenda minus one a c and d perfect thank you is there a second to the motion
021second you got a motion in a second any discussion all right seeing none we'll start with a roll call Vote with board member Williams Bryce Williams yes Charlotte Charlotte F Jefferson yes a Anderson yes Nate Salazar yes moham deade yes Brian Jensen yes Amanda long yes all right that motion carries and passes excuse me and we will move on to our next item on the agenda which is our request to speak um as you know the board has asked me to read a statement that governs um your public comments um so I'll go and do that now uh the board enjoys the opportunity to hear from the public during the comment portion of its meetings before we begin I would like take a moment to remind you of our board rules governing your comments the
022total time reserved for public comment is not to exceed 15 minutes with all speakers or groups limited to three the board will not allow public comments during board meetings that are slanderous obscene or otherwise violate state or federal law employees and or their representatives may not use the public comment period to address issues that should be raised through formal existing communication channels or establish grievance or negotiations procedures I'd also like to explain that unless the speaker's topic is already on the agenda state law prohibits the board from taking action on items raised during the public comment period however if it seems appropriate to the circumstances I may direct District staff to follow up with a speaker on the topic discussed we have one request to speak this evening doc crane I don't see doc with
023us um all right so being that um they're not here we'll go ahead and move on in our agenda um our first um item in the reports agenda is item number one the draft 2025 26 student fee schedule and annual review fee and fee waiver policy and procedures Alan floor is yours i' like to invite General Council kindall to come forward and she's got a presentation for you great thank you Miss Kendall thank you um so as some of you may know um state law requires that annually you approve the fee schedule but it also requires you to annually review and approve the board policy and the administrative procedures um and so um this report today is to go over um the our District's policy and administrative procedures and then just give you a preview
024of the proposed fee schedules for elementary school middle school school and high school as well as the uhsaa activities um before we put them out for public comment um so that I can get any feedback from the board about any changes you'd like to see before we release it for our two public comments so um in okay well the first slide says school fees and fee waivers General Cil chrisa um and the second slide basically how this presentation is going to go is last year um House Bill 415 made a lot of changes to school fees um especially in terms amended definitions it changed what fees we could charge in a secondary school and but then I can't see what I'm supposed to be saying well this isn't going to be good um well that
025was fun no that's too small um well this is awkward Sam are you pulling it up on your own okay just quietly enjoying the moment I think it's attached to the agenda no the PowerPoint isn't attached to the agenda okay okay now he's going to pull it up on his I get it okay but basically how 415 the school fee amendments bill um amended definitions related to school fees it limited the fees as I said that districts can charge um a secondary student to those that are curricular or co-curricular it prohibited the charging of a general fee um it amended Provisions related to textbook fees and it prohibits charging a student in grade six a fee for a remediation program that's not my presentation um so how it was going was that um state law
026has a definition of a fee and it's I'll read it since it's not on the screen but it's any charge expense deposit rental or other payment and it's basically regardless of how that's paid or like how you term that expense whether it's called a charge and expense a deposit a rental payment anything in which you're um collecting money goods or services in exchange that's going to be considered a fee um as long as it's a condition of a student's full participation in an activity course or a program that's sponsored supported or provided by the school district so what um House Bill 415 did was um fundraising used to be included in the definition of what constituted a fee but um house B 415 removed that definition so on um our fee schedules previously you used
027to see a breakdown between what was fundraising and what was actually charged as a fee we no longer have to do that because they've removed that portion out of the definition of a fee so you can see in the definition I've I've readed lined through money or something of monetary value that was raised by a student or a student's family through fundraising because that's no longer considered um that and obviously Tex textbooks were removed um as well as um materials from the definition of a fee so um next slide please um so the district's process for setting a fee is in November of each year the SEC at each Elementary or secondary school will review the entire list of fees charged at that school and if a school is requesting a new fee or changes
028to the current fees they have to be discussed a minimum of two times in sic and SEC meetings and obviously the goal is always to limit the student expenditures for all School sponsored activities that's one of the things that they're looking at we should also be taking into account the diverse student needs impact on families um fee waiver implications um are always to be discussed and obviously any fee that they're requesting has to be equal to or less than the expense you can't charge a fee a higher Fe than what you're going to pay for an item or a product and you can't use any um any fee to supplement or supplant a different fee that you can't charge so hopefully that makes sense so once um those recommendations come out of the school they're
029signed by the principal the SIC chair and SEC chair and they're submitted to school leadership and performance by January 31st of each year um and then after they're approved through school leadership of performance then they make their way to me to um gather on the fee schedule and um Sam next slide so what role does the board play in fee schedules so obviously as I said pursuant to state law each year the board has to review the fee schedules the policy and administrative procedures and you have to approve the policy fee schedules and administrative procedures on or before April 1st in a regularly scheduled public board meeting you also have to provide a minimum of two opportunities to comment um on the proposed fee scheduled during an open and public board meeting um there is
030a new line in House Bill 415 that you have to authorize each fee individually um hopefully that will not be the longest motion you've ever made in your life considering how long our fee schedules are but um we're going to we've been talking with the State Board to see how how we can do that but that is something new this year so what's required to be in a fee schedule um so a specific amount for each fee um that's supposed to be clear and easy for everyone to understand the total fee for each activity class or program so especially on our um uhsaa fee schedules you'll see them grouped in terms of like baseball and there'll be a number of fees underneath it with a total and those totals would always be the maximum fee
031that a student could be charged um as many of you know who were here previously um they did a Title Nine presentation on Athletics and the amount we're charging for um Student Activities through uhsaa is much less than what's on our fee schedule so those are clearly a maximum that we typically don't even reach on our fee schedule there also has to be an annual maximum aggregate fee for a student so if a student hits that maximum aggregate fee they are not charged any more fees throughout the whole entire year um a maximum fee per student per activity that's also what's um listed either individ jul you're in that grouping a spend plan um for how schools plan to spend that fee on our fee schedules that's listed in the parenthetical um and an easily
032understandable statement informing parents about fee waivers and their appeal rights and so that's always at the um top of um the fee schedules so next slide Sam so what fees can be charged only those on the board approved fees schedule and when I put it in bold like that it means I'm serious as everyone out here who's who's here knows if it's not on the fee schedule we cannot charge it um so next slide um and just as a reminder there are no fees in elementary schools um so no fees are charged for anything um including activities like dress down days I know um other neighboring school districts got in trouble for that but we are not charging any fees for field trips snacks textbooks and there's also specific language that we need to put
033on all our disclosures to families even if elementary schools are just requesting that parents maybe bring supplies um that and bold um it always needs to be told that it's completely voluntary for parents to provide those supplies otherwise they'll be provided by the school so next slide so starting in the 25 26 school year year um which is the upcoming school year and that's the fee schedule you're looking at um for thinking about approving um the district may not charge a secondary student a fee for a curricular or co-curricular activity that is required for the instruction of established core standards and that is not un elective except for the following so we can charge for instructional equipment or supplies driver's education courses open enrollment applications competency remedi programs music instrument rentals and school activity clothing
034so and as um uh business administrator kersley has indicated before in his um prior conversations with the board um although state law does allow us to charge for electives we are choosing to not do that we are getting rid of our all our curricular fees if that's um the intent from the board um next slide Sam so I think you want one too far um so can students be charged for textbooks um the answer is in general no they cannot be charged for any instructional material regardless of the format that material comes in um but they can be charged for concurrent enrollment IB or AP textbooks um obviously those are still subject to a fee waiver um and the district can also charge a fee related tuition college credit or exams related to those courses
035and um House Bill 415 added IB for the upcoming year that previously wasn't part of that so it had had been AP and concurrent but IB is new so next slide thanks um so what fees must be waved um basically it's all fees must be waved for student participation in any class program or activity including extracurricular activities so that includes all our um sports uhsaa activities that are provided sponsored or supported for the benefit of students in grades K through 12 regardless of whether or not the program class or activity is designated as extracurricular or optional mandatory before school or after school those are all going to be wable next slide um so what isn't considered a fee um so regular school supplies are not considered a fee the only exception to that is if
036um a teacher designated a specific type of school supply like you had to have this particular um specific brand style color um or like a special imprint on it um then those would be um considered a fee and those would be wable um insurance is is always optional unless it's required to participate in a class or activity again um sat act GED tests those are not considered fees um college credit yearbook class rings letter jackets spines um for damaging any uh property or for parking violations and um School meals through the school launch program so who can qualify for a fee waiver there are six C atories under which a student is eligible um and can be granted a fee waiver um obviously they're based on income or um receiving SSI supplemental security income um
037Tamp funding um temporary assistance for Dy families if the students in foster care if the students in state custody or obviously if the student is designated as mckin vinto um also just so you're aware even if a student or family doesn't meet any of those um six particular criteria um the principal always has the option of granting a fee waver on a Case by casee basis um so there those can always be granted regard regardless of qualifications under those so the fee waiver process um obviously it's supposed to be confidential 100% um other students can't be part of that process we want to avoid any sort of embarrassment or stigmatism your um administrators are not allowed to keep any verification documentation um they can't ask families or students why fees can't be paid um and
038they have two levels of appeal available to them during any appeal process we will not be assessing we are not allowed to assess any fees um and there can't be separate lines like arrows saying fee W is here um we we need to do it in the most discreet confidential unsatiable methods for collecting school fees but as a result of not paying fees um we can never exclude a student from participating in any class activity or program um we we can't withhold a course grade and we can't deny a current or former student an official transcript or any of their official Student Records so that's just a quick summary of our policies and procedures related to fees and fee waivers um obviously if you look at the administrative procedures um I I think it's 13
039Pages which I barely had that many slides so there's a lot more words in the administrative procedures but if you have any questions I'm perfectly happy to answer any questions about what our process is for setting fees or collecting fees and then we can move on to the fee schedules we have a question from Amanda okay so I won't talk the fee schedules yet if we're going to do that next um I do have a question as to you know you clarified that um the totals are maximum that can be charged and um so schools SL programs can charge less um if you could explain to the public administrators Etc like if they choose to charge less because of the particular population they're trying to serve but the costs do exceed what they're charging what
040are the options to help supplement the the cost even if the fees um are conservatively applied does that make sense I'm not sure I understand your question but what I can I can give you an example if you need it but it's okay I um so what I can say is um schools often have discretionary funds within their budget that they can use discretionary funds to supplement um if there's a shortfall or um obviously the district gives some money to offset fees and fee waivers to schools Additionally the foundation is always available to help um uh fund ra like fund raise or gather money or offset some those costs as well is is that what you're asking me perfectly thank you of course um so the next thing um uh I I wanted to go
041over was the fee schedules and we can start on the um prek elementary and middle school fees um because the fee schedule only requires fees for K12 we have removed all the prek fees from the fee schedule that does not mean that our prek program will not be charging fees they're just not on this fee schedule anymore part of um the thought behind this was that if you had to approve every fee individually this was like an extra 50 but really there isn't a need for them to be on and um some of the feedback from the Utah State Board of Education was um that the fee schedule should really be K12 so we have removed the prek fees from from that um and otherwise um obviously we have um removed um the curricular fees
042from the Middle School schedule um we've removed everything related to field chips um we've left on some um instrumental music rentals um but do you have any questions about the current elementary and middle school fee schedule okay um and just to be clear um under the after school um and Community Education Program on the elementary and middle school fee schedule um we've included the Middle School Musical um Clayton that's where the Clayton play Falls in terms of it being an after school activity um so those fees are are listed there in case there is any question about that so with regard to the high school fee schedule um there is a lot of red because we have endeavored to get rid of um all the fees that are considered curricular or co-curricular we've left on
043um fees where um for school activity clothing a lot of times you'll see like a t-shirt and again I just want to remind everyone that those fees are still fee wable they're still eligible for a fee waver they're just optional um and again if there is travel associated with a particular Club although we can charge a fee for that again that is still fee wable as well so um and obviously with um regard to our um CTE courses um the actual fees that are required to participate in the course have all been removed um so we will be picking up some of those additional fees especially where um there is a component that of of shots or vaccines that are necessary to participate in some of the clinicals that are necessary for those courses um
044but for any of the certificates which I know um uh Laura Das shazo and and everyone here who supports CTE is hoping that everyone will go on to get their certificate because um gaining that certificate is not mandatory for the CTE courses those fees are still on the fee schedule but again they are wable so any questions about the high school fees am May until we get to the uhsaa one uhuh so mine's going to be Unified sports so I don't know if that's a weit or now that's a wait okay yeah I was just going to use the opportunity to ask um Allan if he could clarify many students I assume because students have not come to this meeting they have had their questions about their specific clubs addressed but in addition to clarifying
045the process with the foundation I also know that Allan was working on administrators getting and giving some more consistent information about how Club advisers or athletic coaches could make sure they were using not only their fee but resources from the foundation can you describe any work that's been done on that to date I know James and the foundation uh has have been working James has met at least twice with um facult staff over at West High School uh his department is working on like a one-pager kind of how to access they have a a folder that they've always had that kind of gives the process that they've sent out uh but they're kind of working on even a more concise summaries too um so that all um Club sponsors or activity sponsors know how to
046access the foundation and what they can provide for their activities and then we've heard a lot from students at West but that one pag would be available to administrators also at Highland and East or any other app that is correct okay great thank you and just to be clear um I a student reached out to me and I indicated that the two board meetings in March were when the board is scheduled to hear public comments so they may come speak then as well Mohammed um so if there no question mam hi um so mine is about um uh lunch fees so we all know the cost of living has gone up and even middle class families are feeling it so and I'm just wondering um what would it take for our district to offer free
047lunch across the board I don't have the number in front of me right now but last we looked I think it was about $2 million okay okay so uh um I think this is something we will we owe actually to our children um because there are families out there who even cannot afford it but they will not have you know they just feel the pride that they're not going to uh ask for a fee waiver you know for a free lunch and we need to take that into consideration and I really you know uh uh encourage your superintendent and the staff if there is anything that can be done you know that the board can do so that every kid have food uh in our district and not have to worry about the fees would
048be fantastic because you know food is essential it's just a reality of life thank you thanks Mohamed um I do want to just want to appreciate you stating that letting us know your desire to explore that just want to make sure that um that other board members would agree to that to make sure we have that direction for the superintendent um if that is something that the board would like to explore discover anything like that I would think it's most appropriate if something like that is driven through the finance committee as part of the budget cycle but my followup question would be we're not making the lunch fee with this no no no it's a completely separate thing I would say I certainly support the goal of having free lunch I mean there's multiple bills
049in the session about this Statewide which would be great to advance and I think because that's not on this fee schedule but is certainly a worthy goal the finance committee would be the place that I would suggest personally that I think would be productive to talk about it um just seeing some nods from finance committee members um is that something that we'd like to take up um in our next finance committee meeting yeah we can address it there but I say we stay focused on that particular Topic at hand M does that work for you thanks thank you Miss K of course and one of the things I did want to mention because I I know that um um you have a specific concern about people coming forward and having to ask for fee waivers
050and just that they might not be comfortable doing that um one of the things to know is that of it's part of the online registration that you can apply for a fee waiver and also if you um apply for free and reduced lunch um that automatically qualif qualifies you for fee waivers and we're working on transferring that information so you wouldn't have to double apply and come in and apply for a fee waiver for these fees if you were already eligible for free and reduced lunch um so any other questions on the high school fee schedule before we move to uhsaa helina um so like you were saying about the external fees associated with like clinicals in CTE classes would that have to be through like a partnered provider or something like that a specific
051provider for healthare oh for the for the vacines and yeah in terms of the if if you were getting them through the fee waiver process through our vendor who would come in and do those then they would be they're no longer going to be charged that we would have people come in and provide those vaccines does that make sense yeah okay any other questions okay so for UHS activities I know there's some questions but before those happen I I I did want to um talk a little bit about um this particular fee schedule I um we put on Esports um which was recently approved so there is um a new um piece for Esports um I wanted to talk a little bit I know students have from West have been vocal about um raising the
052travel costs and um the request from West High did come School leadership and performance to raise the travel cost by $600 for each of the sports um Highland High School um asked for a $100 reduction in travel costs um and East High School was um fine with the fees as they currently are for travel so the recommendation coming out of slap was O sorry School leadership and performance no slapping sorry I'll slap myself um um the recommendation coming out of school leadership and performance was to keep the travel fees the same and not increase them um there was a request for um senior Street banners to be added to every sport um and because of timing that wasn't um added to Unified sports but that would be in increased additionally there was a request for
053um the spirit packs to be increased by $100 um uh for each sport um so that is what you're seeing but um I just wanted to be clear that the $600 increase that was requested from West High um the West High Community was not reflected on here although it was considered but based on the input from the other two schools um that request wasn't put on this particular schedule and in terms of Unified sports um that is currently on the uhsaa fee schedule and talking to both Emily southernland as well as Aaron Anderson um previously um Unified sports had been run more as a after school activity or Club it hadn't been run as a full and complete robust um activity or sport through uhsaa and what we're hoping by putting it on this fee
054schedule and there'll be a presentation coming up in which we're um I in which I know they will be asking for some funding for head coaches and whatnot is to actually make Unified sports very robust and provide the same amount of opportunities um services and experiences for students participating in Unified sports as any other uhsaa activity so one of the things is that previously Unified sports the students wore pennies right they didn't have actual uniforms and by having a school having a fee on the fee schedule will be able to purchase actual uniforms provide for transportation district sponsored transportation to the different activities um we're trying to raise it to the level of all other uhsa um activities Additionally the uh the the Unified sports fees are for an entire year so whereas baseball or
055football are those seasonal fees um Unified sports would that one fee would cover participation for all three seasons so if if a student was only participating in one particular season obviously the fee would be a lot less and again this is this is going to be a maximum fee we're anticipating that it'll probably be a lot less but we would like the students to have Spirit packs and actual uniforms and transportation to all the competitions so um in order to make it more robust and um you know get coaching and um all make sure they have similar opportunities um we're asking that it be put on the uhsaa fee schedule with um the smallest fee that we have for these types of activities Amanda thank you for that clarification you answered some of my questions
056I am a little confused about um a statement that you had made earlier where um schools can elect to um charge less than the fee that's um posted but when you were talking about how West High um requested $600 more for traveling but Highland High requested $100 less why um would a school be requesting less if they have the option to charge less so they asked for the $100 increase in Swag Bags and $100 L said on travel but maybe right they wanted so they wanted $100 more on Swag Bags and to take it off $100 in travel so that the fee charged to the student would be the same they just wanted it put in a different line didn't believe that their travel needed to be increased and so in order to not like
057raise the fee overall that students would pay for a particular activity they were willing to take $100 off of travel if they could add it to the spirit packs does that make sense that makes that's makes better sense um and then Unified sports I did email you guys um but uh to go along the lines of what you were saying that you wanted it to be as Robos incomparable to the other uja Sports um what it's missing is a banner option so that would be a request is to get that on there yeah and I I had said that we would put it on oh I missed that sorry it's okay maybe I was thinking and I wasn't listening it's okay I had just I had just said because we had put this the senior
058Spirit banners on the fee schedule at a different time and then we added Unified sports we're going to add that line back on UniFi Sports thank did catch all your words I apologize no worries um and then just extra emphasis on Mark and marketing the waiver exceptions so individuals understand that um and thank you for delineating that if individuals don't participate with the entire year of Unified sports that there is a decrease on the fees and then that does truly uh cover the entire year which helps make it more affordable as well as helps hopefully decrease the potential DeTour for the neurotypical students participation and th negating the UniFi concept so um I'm definitely very helpful for how the the outcomes and the the thoughtfulness for what was put into it so thank you for
059that of course and I will want say that Special Olympics does donate a lot of money so these fees are just sort of a backup plan if if we need it but we do get significant money from Special Olympics for that and I know the foundation is going to offset some of the funding for it as well but it's just we need it on the fee schedule in case we ever have to charge those but again it's just a backup so I guess um what I would be looking for is just any direction if you would like anything changed on the fee schedules before we post them for public comment or input Miss Kendall I keep going back to um ba kerley's um recommendation regarding curricular and non-curricular fees um I can speak for myself
060that I would like to move in that direction um based on his recommendation and I would is that the kind of direction that you're hoping for in this no I just wondered if you had a problem with a specific fee on that you wanted me to change okay thank you great thank you thank you thank you all right our next report this evening is middle level reports superintendent so you got um a copy of the middle level report and Tiffany and D are presenting here they've been the leads on this I want to just call out too you mean online did you not get a copy of I it was online online have online yeah should be yes wait a minute it came with the agenda right am I to have the paper copy oh
061no I printed mine out I was just sorry um sorry about that um what I love about this too just to complement these two and getting started is that um one of the things we're trying to do as a district is get input into important decisions from our stakeholders what Tiffany and all put together around a working group in this middle level question again this was raised last year um I think in a late spring meeting by some Middle School teachers who said we need to be paying attention to Middle Schools we agreed um so we are responding to teacher requests with this but also putting together a group that can spend some time coming up with these ideas together so that we get a lot of input um and so I just want to
062say thanks for putting that group together the middle level group together because it's the it's the process that I want to do more and more as a district and that we have ahead of taking up some big questions and bringing in a lot of voices to the conversation so thanks you guys thanks well you all have heard my voice a lot you know who I am so I'm going to take just a minute and introduce D Miller to you D is an area director in school leadership and performance I first met D when he was working at Northwest and one of the things that I really noticed about him there was his ability to identify procedures and systems and just flat out actions and behaviors that engaged middle school students and really made them excited
063to come and be in the library come and be in school come and do all of those things he since been an elementary administrator and also a middle school principal and he is now over all of the middle schools in the district and a couple of elementary schools and so um he is really the key person who knows what administrators and teachers and students are doing thinking and feeling in our middle schools um the purpose of this committee when the superintendent came to us and asked us to respond to the teachers that came up and uh talked to the board presented to the board about middle schools was really to look at our current middle schools and earlier tonight we talked about the difference with schools and programs and so we were really looking at
064our five middle schools and also nibbly Park which is a school that has and eighth grade in it because what we wanted to do was see what commonalities and differences we had in structures and resources across the district and also to look at the needs um that could be identified across middle schools either individually or as the six of them together um they looked and so um it was really interesting because we pulled together a very large group we we ended up inviting close to 40 people and had a core group of about 25 they're listed in the front of of the report and they included Middle School teachers um Middle School administrators we had some high school administrators that came in every now and then um or all of the time and then we
065had University people who were very involved in this process as well and I think that we didn't we didn't end up where we thought we would in the conversation which is what I thought was so interesting and organic about it um what we discovered wasn't what we expected to find and so that was very interesting but we did have a very highly experienced group of teachers and administrators that contributed to this and really helped us outline some next steps both for us as a district and also requests that we have for you to consider as a board um so at this time I am going to turn it over to Mr Miller who will kind of walk you through our report and some of the highlights and then we'll be open for your questions thank
066you thank you um go to the next slide please thanks all right um You have the report in front of you and we have some very brief slides to cover I'll direct you to the page that I'm reading from I'm not going to read everything I'll just summarize and then we can again take questions at the end um first of all we wanted to highlight a couple areas that we're pulling from the Strategic plan and in three of the areas first one Equitable access and inclusion uh middle schools should prepare all students for advanced High School courses and support the development of their academic identities as scholars in the second piece in academic success um talking about productive academic conversations students should also have appropriate academic support and enrichment and the last section access to
067expanded learning opportunities this includes providing opportunities for students to participate in extended and honors classes to prepare them for more rigorous High School Pathways um moving over to page two of the document we want to talk about uh the similarities and differences in school structures and the first area uh we're going to focus on page two our schedules uh we've got five if you want to call them traditional middle schools in our district and ni Parks we've got we're mostly talking tonight about Brian Clayton glendell Hillside Northwest and nibbly Park which is our K8 school when we refer to nibbly park we're we'll be talking about both the K model and sometimes they seventh and eighth grade um on page two of the top you'll see our current number of students in our our middle
068schools Bryant our smallest right now at 360 to our biggest school at glendell is 680 that it's our biggest because it does have sixth grade in there I do want to highlight that three actually four of our schools our middle schools are smaller than some of our elementary schools right now um just note that and we do have three different models we have 78 a 68 and a K8 in our start and end times and the length of our school days we also vary quite a bit um most of our schools start at 8 we've got one starting at 8:05 at nible Park and Bryant starting at 8:05 and varying end times as well our Northwest Middle School they chose to have have a fewer short days this school year so you'll notice that they
069actually have more instructional hours um4 which is different than most of the other schools next page still talking about our middle level schedules um what we found after studying all of our middle schools is that the their periods vary in almost every building there's something different um if you look at Glendale they're on what we call a 5x5 block so the students they they go to math science and uh language arts every day if they have an ELD class they might go to that every day but then their electives rotate this provides them a 60-minute period which is great but limits other areas of their um academic I'll talk about that in a minute D can I pause you for a minute if the slides are what the public are seeing they're not advancing along
070with where you're at on the slides I'm just reading through the report just summarizing so um three of our schools have a seven period day which is about a 45 minute period and then we have Bryant that has an 8 period day which is about a 35 39 minute period uh nibbly Park they run something times a middle school schedule also an Elementary schedule um they don't have a typical Middle School schedule where they go to Every period or every class every day um nibbly Park talk about them for a minute they don't have full semesters of Health digital literacy social studies in their schedule like other typical middle schools do uh which is a small problem you know state code changed a few years back where students are required to take specific classes in
071Middle School nibbly Park is doing their best to meet those requirements maybe getting that class once a week but it should be daily um so they're not meeting those minimum requirements uh a couple things about the varying periods the seven period day which most of our CL uh schools have uh it is cost efficient but has a shorter period 45 minutes 48 minutes uh you can get almost everything done it is hard to run like a Foods class and get your cooking done by the end of that period however um it is very cost efficient you can hire you uh the teachers you want you can have the right amount of FTE and provide the electives that you want and the kids can choose the electives and get through middle school with the classes they
072want to take the 5x5 schedule you create a space to have more electives however you increase the cost of having more content core teachers you have to hire more language arts Math and Science teachers to run a 5x5 so then you obviously that cost more money to have that many more teachers um having different schedules to start times five different start times and end times and schedules throughout the district is is challenging and less efficient we discovered in our study um if we had all of our schools on the same schedule it would allow schools to share teachers for courses that would have sufficient enrollment for a full-time teacher one school for example um moving over to page five in the in the same section oh actually I want to move over to I'm going
073to take you to while you get to that section may I ask a question sure um you mentioned the five by5 block costs more and I'm seeing that that's only done at Glendale is it able to be done at Glendale because they have the FTE because they have sixth graders or is there some other reason they're able to cover that cost it's a site based decision okay but they would it stands to reason have more money because they have more overall students so their Staffing is higher yes and and as their enrollment shrinks it's harder to fund that yeah it's not not not sustainable um moving over to page nine oh sorry we can we can hold our questions if you want yeah okay okay I can speed up too um over on page nine
074just a real Brief Review on what is required in Middle Schools um students need to take language arts math science a social studies Health Fine Arts a CTE course and digital literacy those are the minimums over on page 10 um we also we would like to provide a World Language Advanced Fine Arts or additional CTE Pathways uh for students the goal is to align our CTE Pathways to what our feeder high schools provide um that's the future the idea for the future and last for this section on course offerings some non-negotiables that we highlighted um this came from just having a conversation with the principls and teachers and other people involved in this group in the middle of the page page page 11 thank you and non-negotiables establishing course non-negotiables and middle schools ensures that
075all students receive a well-rounded education Equitable access to essential learning opportunities and the necessary preparation for high school and Beyond in Salt Lake City School District here at the bottom students should have access to at a minimum courses such as accelerated math Pathways the S and8 the math 7 and8 accelerated class secondary one one to earn High School Credit in Middle School honors courses in course areas at least one world language which could include Spanish DLI if appropriate for the elementary feeder program and at least one Visual Arts track and one performance arts track although more are encouraged the LA uh next point on here we're talking about extracurricular um activities on page 14 uh all of our middle schools do have an afterschool program they look very similar in most buildings the one piece
076that I want to highlight that we felt was very important as we studied uh our after school program is the intramural program the sports program that we have in the after school uh that happens after school um we have four sports that happen throughout the year and we see a high participation rate for students um it has had a positive impact on our students and the community it brings in parents and families throughout the school year each sport brings in different families throughout the year it Fosters a Social Development and helps students build a meaningful relationship with their peers and mentors participation in these activities has been shown to increase School attendance as students feel more connected and engaged Additionally the program offers exposure to experiences that students might not otherwise have to broadening their
077Horizons and building essential life skills we want to continue that program we have found it challenging as the the program is funded on soft money it's funded on grants and we're currently searching to fund that again um to find a way to continue that program and I know that it's been reported on in the past uh we're we're working on uh continuing that sports program and streamlining it making it so you know what requirements students have at Glendale are the same requirements that they have at Hillside and access to those programs is the same at each building the last piece is transitions on page 15 and 16 the the group that came up here in the spring talked about the challenges that middle schoolers have when you get kids that rotate 50% every year you
078it is very hard to build a good relationship with a 12-year-old you get him for the first year you're building that relationship with them it goes well they're gone the next year that was one of the reasons they came up here to talk about you know looking into possibly adding sixth grade having a third year what does that look like um the transition for a 12-year-old to a 13-year-old is challenging research says we've read all uh each you know is it more challenging for a fifth grader to transition as a sixth grader into middle school or a sixth grader from elementary to transition to middle school as a seventh grader those are the things we want to look more into um the other when we're talking about transitions we were looking at the importance of
079our counselors and on page 15 you'll see that our schools have a very different rate of counselors the reason for that is schools can determine how many counselors they want a site based decision if they want to fund additional counselors they can do that um nible park has one counselor for K8 Bryant has one and a half and then a few the others have up to three and we noted that counselors played very different role in elementary school what versus what they do in a middle school and that is noted later on and on page 15 and 16 that the counselors provide uh you know in elementary they provide monthly lessons on how to be a friend whereas a middle school counselor they're starting to talk about Pathways careers um and CCR so it's a
080very different experience and do we want to give those do we want to give our sixth graders that Middle School experience or keep them in the elementary experience so a lot of questions arised the last piece of transitions I want to talk about um talks about our feeder program or not program I'm sorry our feeder pattern and this is highlighted uh back on page five and this is a challenge that we identified near the end of our discussions in November and December and this is based off of the school closures from last year and where where our current sixth graders are so I'll provide an example um if let's take a student at Jackson uh this a fifth grader last year has moved from Jackson as a sixth grader to Newman getting to know their
081new Newman friends um building a new community a new has new teacher and getting to know everybody in mid year they still live in Bryant boundaries but all their new friends that live in the Jackson b or in the Newman boundary are pointed to Northwest so I've got this previously Jackson kid in a Northwest mostly Northwest boundary but is pointed to Bryant so they're kind of in this conundrum of do I want to do a special permit to go to Northwest with my new friends or I'm still living in my Bryant boundary and I go to my Bryant where I'm that's my home school so we've got four you know three or four um schools and groups of students that are in this situation that we've we've got to solve we've got to figure out
082a feeder pattern or address this for students that don't really know you know their Direction so that was something that we identified um not necessarily have an answer for but something that we we should consider moving forward and you could say that about a kid from benan that went to Liberty a kid from Hawthorne that moved to Whittier um or Hawthorne to Indian Hills so there's some there's some areas that we need to address next slide okay last so where we ended as what we need to do as a district and you'll see that in front of you is first discussion select a consistent schedule to be implemented at all middle schools middle level schools place all middle schools on the same start and end time schedule to facilitate collaborative meetings and plc's review course
083offerings for appropriate access at all Middle School levels determine structures that would support elective courses especially if schools impacted by the number of ELD or reading courses needed to support students investigate ways to increase engagement in after school programming and last reconfigure nibbly Park K8 as an elementary school so again that is District next steps last what we'd like the board to consider are two areas first Study middle configurations to determine if creating a 68 School schols is feasible and supportive of student development and learning and second study Middle School boundaries to align students movement from elementary to middle school as much as possible questions sure that will be some I haven't been up here since 2018 so give me a like let me like work into it I don't have a question but I
084have a comment um and I shared this prior to the meeting but I was concerned when I opened the report that West's 7eventh and eth grade was excluded from the review um because in our September meeting we were told that kind of all middle level student experiences were going to be measured and that all programs would be considered and really no indication that a special program would be excluded and so then I was able to hear from Dr Hall that the because this study did not involve a recommend on grade configuration that's why West was excluded but I'm a little bit confused by that because the report does have a lot of discussion of configuration of schools and also as D pointed out the initial ask by slicky Bryant faculty was about some of the
085challenges of that 6 to8 transition and I had originally understood that Brian Connelly was part of the study specifically because it might involve a boundary study which now are being asked to do so my ask would be in order to really effectively study or explore these questions I really do think it's imperative to add some information about West how it works the number of students who go there and really some of the challenges that are present when West is in the mix because there are always courses and experiences that only magnet students can access including but not limited to speech and debate and I think it's worth having that type of outlying information included for us to move forward with all of the information and that when we don't consider the feeder pattern of a
086magnet you know which serves not an insignificant amount of students I think we're missing out on a lot of productive information but with that in mind I think this is very informative and I would also be curious what the recommended timetable would be for the ongoing discussions that we'd have to have oh and I do have one more question uh because my timer dting um I I'm confused about the recommendation regarding nible park because it'd be my understanding that that reconfiguration would have to happen with board approval or direction to study you can just refigure the classroom structure it wouldn't have to be a formal recommendation to study nibbly park that's right great that's right um and on the timeline I'd actually like because sixth grade keeps coming up as an issue do we move
087it do we not um is it good and for what reasons and things um I'd like to get started sooner than later and put together another working group like this to take up that question pull together the research look at the pros and cons bring parents into into that conversation um I think they'll have strong feelings one way or another about moving sixth graders up and make a decision for now about what we do because it'll start to affect what kind of space access we have and things we do have some space challenges if we moved in that direction but for a group to take that up um and bring that back to you as a board with some findings that would help you decide whether or not you want to consider moving sixth grade
088into middle schools it's been done in our neighborhood District at Granite do you know of others that have done this yeah Canyons Canyons Canyons did it as well okay so some here in the valley that have moved in this direction so they've taken this up decided to do it it keeps coming up so I'd like us to kind of roll off this one and roll into a new working group to bring you something in the next 3 to four months do you think that's possible something how long did this one take on the whole to get this all done and written we started in August or September September September yeah so it may be longer than this school year and it would transition into the new school year or something to bring a report back
089to the board but that would be my first suggestion is getting going on that from what I understand the School principles are looking at changing the school schedules together right now they're working together on a plan for that and so getting started on those things yeah thank you while we keep talking can you go back to that slide of asks District or board or district oh the board considerations talking I actually want to see both so but probably the board one is what I mean okay do you have more to ask Ashley or Commander um let me get back to my notes so I I wanted to jump in and kind of emphasize um D and his skills I got the opportunity to get to know him whenever my to older um over at Clayton
090and D was really good about seeing each kid individually versus being too busy to um acknowledge that which is pretty commendable given you're getting into a larger group of students and one of my kids had some stuff and D was really great about navigating that and a way to help them succeed versus um the lot otherwise um so just thank you D for such a great experience over at Clayton I appreciate that um I do want to uh reiterate gratitude for the detail of this report um it's very helpful to be able to make informed decisions and so like kudos to everybody that was involved in the detail on this because it helps me feel feel like I can um feel good about any decisions or recommendations that are being made um I do want
091to point out I've received um about a half a dozen emails about the nibbly conversation obviously it's very early on we don't know what direction we're going to go with it um but I wanted to hit on that um because they did take the time to message me um one was a parent concerned about um their choosing to go to nibble instead of comprehensive Middle School to avoid the bullying um and so that the kids could be seen and heard um um and they did not have a negative transition from nible to high school on that particular parent the student said they were surprised by this discussion um concerned about what will happen of the teachers um a concern for students being broken up with the change um and a teacher uh reached out and
092just said that thata doesn't consider consider the 40% SE of seven to eth graders coming outside the district and boundaries just specifically for nibbly Park's um alternative Middle School approach um and then concerned about only finding out about this at the agenda on Friday so um just some pieces uh to take away on trying to figure out how to um communicate this out to the public um and other things not just specifically this as we're going through these processes of and this will go into a conversation later in tonight's meeting but I wanted to at least get give a voice to those who made the effort to reach out to me thank you for that and um I agree with you in terms of creating time for that voice and for parents to air their
093desires and concerns we would set up a public input process in that with a board meeting even if it's not part of the official G5 yeah and I let them know about that opportunity and stuff so thank you any other questions for all Dr H Char um thank you for all the work you've done on this um I wondered about Glendale um so if they were to go back to a seven periods um schedule would they lose instruction time yes and that is one of our big biggest challenge is because we are because of other powers that be we can't we're really constrained on what kind of schedule we can create with our start and end times so um we've got to be creative in where we can add time to their to the period
094if it's because if it we can only get it to fit in between 8 and 230 where can we make their class periods longer you know we can shorten the transition times we can um extend Fridays as an option like Northwest we can look at a six period day they're looking at all sorts of options um however what we are looking at is what schools are successful with their seven period day and why is it successful what are they offering to their students to close the achievement Gap what what is um what what has Northwest done with their seven period today to show success that glendell could model after so we get we need to pull successful areas of our district and implant those at Glendale if they were to go to a seven period
095model by adding other courses adding some potential intervention classes for students that may need it or extension classes for students that may need it okay um so how long has glendell been in the 5x5 block I would say five to seven years and do you know why they change they moveed to that was it to add instruction time and to to boost it achievement or progress you know both yeah and has it had that effect it I think it did and now we're seeing it go back down they were they've been in atsi for the last three years and recently moved into CSI for low performing student groups for their students with disabilities um can you explain those yeah I don't think you were here for you weren't here for those conversations so so they
096were in the bottom 5% for a couple student groups one of them being students with disabilities okay and for four years they needed to hit a certain Target they were unable to make that Target so this last November they were identified as a a low performing student group for students with disabilities um which means that we've got some oversight uh including me teaching and learning my boss the state and we're looking at different ways to change to increase student achievement and one of those things might be the master schedule so we've got to identify uh through a comprehensive needs assessment what is not working and figure out the root cause of those problems and make changes to their instruction which includes I mean it's everything from instruction to master schedule to curriculum like it's all
097over the place so um and what didn't weren't they they've made progress in the ell yeah right a they they made progress in two of their student groups but not this one group so they were in this atsi for three groups they got out of this uh atsi they were in atsi for three groups they just didn't get out for students with disabilities so it's targeted supportive intervention okay is the category I can go way more into detail for you later yeah I I mean the the the reason to change their schedule would be if it would benefit the students right and boost achievement um so right and the if changing this schedule would actually allow more sections of language arts more sections of math more sections of science to put push in students with
098disabilities into those classrooms at a lower ratio which is what we want right now the ratio between uh students with disabilities and non is too high so having a seven period day would actually benefit students with disabilities which is the group where seeking to close the achievement Gap did I explain that okay yeah you did um I know there was an attendance um issue as well so I mean with the pandemic and post pandemic could that be factoring into some of the low performance issues with our students with disabilities possibly I mean I can't say yes or no to that specific student group but attendance in all of our middle schools is an issue that we're looking at thank you for I mean everywhere na white yeah Brian H yes I have um several questions
099um and I don't know maybe this is suggesting that we need a study session or something on this but um what I got out of the report um were a couple of things first of all we've talked a little bit about nibbly Park and what do we need to do to address the students needs there and to me as I was reading it tell me if I'm wrong are the students are those 70 students getting what they need at nibble park for a middle school education I would say they're getting parts of what they need I think they're getting so they're getting parts but they're not getting the full um middle school education correct okay I I didn't I didn't highlight they don't have access to any honors or extended courses and that that's what
100I was reading that they there's no honors there's a number of things that is just simply not available correct part yeah when when Mr Miller said that they were on the Elementary schedule for um Arts and Music and PE they're participating with the sixth graders on that schedule rather than having a class that might be more advanced or more focused in like some of the other middle schools have that really also then help prepare them to to feed into the high school programs so that's that's another area that's okay so to me that something that we need to look at urgently I mean 7 students right there um another thing to me that was um a concern so you were talking about the theater patterns and all of that so that's tied to boundaries I
101yeah I get that and how we realign the new elementary schools is the way that it's working right now though for a student that finds thems in that predicament the Mary Jackson can they choose either school to go to yeah yeah they do and I when when we started thinking about this like I'm very concerned about students and student centered so I reached out to my counterpart and said hey can you make sure that this group of kids know their options so that you know if they want to go to Northwest that they know how to fill out a special permit or the parents are aware and we get the counselors involved um so they know their options it's but it it's up to me or Tracy the other area director to be ah head
102of the game right we we just don't we want to put systems in place that if if I go away or Tracy goes away that that those are in place okay I appreciate hearing that because to me I guess I'm thinking that Mary Jackson student one of that one of those students may think I want to go with my new friends MH but then there may be another one that says no I want to go back to my old friends or you know maybe they haven't made as many new friends so I just want it to be that they are able to what's going to be best for them because I mean they're transitioning to begin with right but they've also been put in this other predicament with boundary realignments and all of those sorts
103of things right okay and I I we did double check they still there's still a bus right in the Jackson neighborhood to get them to Bryant so okay that was my next one so there's a way for them to get there on buses and stuff yeah okay um and I'm trying to keep track of my time um okay oh in your next steps you talked about every school having like the same core on I mean I don't have that slide in front of me well I think that that's imperative because when we look at some of those like you gave a listing of the courses that were available and okay I just noted like in one high or one Middle School they don't have coding and in all of the others they have coding well
104I think that Middle School needs coding I mean that's an important anyway to me an important area um one of them okay they have Spanish for first year but they don't have Spanish for second year if I'm remembering correctly so there's another one where I mean there's some things that to me suggest more work here or you know we got to address these things um and then another one was band I mean it seemed like in three of them they all had a chance to do band but in another one they don't get banned and to me it's important to support that musical aspect as well um my time's up any other questions for D and Dr Hall okay just to summarize a few things it feels like there's a few things that we need
105to revisit superintendent um you know Amanda had mentioned um you know how do we communicate these types of changes that we're looking at Ashley's asking for um you know what is the board's role in reconfiguration of nibble um and then Brian just noted a few things about how do we kind of manage or close the gap on some of these discrepancies among the offerings at these schools um what are your thoughts on how we address some of these things little forward can I also just add the ask again to include West yes I missed that thanks Ashley thank you um so of those there's some different pieces to that one we're looking at the G5 policy coming up um right now the district in our current policy and in the version of G5 that you
106will see gives to the district the responsibility to look at structure within schools um and so we can move forward with that one that way but what was what there was a question before I lost track of the questions Nate but and the board can discuss that with the G5 policy certainly but um so we had um Brian with your comments about closing the gap on discrepancies of offerings across the middle schools so explain what principles are going to be tackling so school schedules start and end times we want to align for the coming school year what are the other pieces down principles are going to do together and maybe look because course offerings trying to figure this one out the course offerings piece we can discuss that and come up with like a a
107base line of like every school needs to offer these 20 courses we can get to that point but beyond it is very challenging to extend additional courses because it comes down to funding enrollment um especially and then the school is impacted with additional courses they have to offer like ELD and reading that take up F additional funding for of FTE time in the day can't offer what you know Clayton and Hillside don't have as many ELD courses that they have to offer that Glendale and Northwest has to so Clayton and hillsite can offer a lot more electives with a similar allotment of FTE you in here uh glendel offers 20 electives where Clayton offered 38 so I don't know how much the schools can do that work without your help but we can come up
108with the Baseline of musthaves in in each school which I think we're actually getting to way way more this year than we have in the past um and that has included an emphasis on the Arts right trying to get out some similarities around art and Etc offerings art and music and yes and but and what Brian said like coding robotics more of these CTE Pathways we're actually seeing a lot more desire for but hard to staff and sustain I I would okay charlese got one and then re to I I noted that you talked about trying to find an alignment between the CTE Pathways between uh middle schools and high schools but the Arts is they're suffering yeah big time in our district because of that lack of alignment if you don't have a robust
109ban education or orchestra education or choir there's no way that those students will move on correct to high school and these programs just die and yes we can have very culturally relevant Arts programs we just saw one today okay so we can have very modern culturally relevant Arts programs that that keep students engag engaged and keep them creative and keep them um gives them a spark to come to school we're having trouble with with attendance right so it's not just sports or or Tech that that really motivate students it's the Arts and we can't we can't forget that please oh I agree and I it we're a lot of my principles are making a decision do I like I I have to have Eld so I have to cut a 0 Five band or you
110know like they have they're making really hard decisions yeah because there's their enrollments shrinking Title One is down you know we you will you know all the problems I don't have to explain those to you but we're making some really hard decisions yeah uh but I noticed that you said maybe you could have one Arts elective and that's like saying you can only have one sport you want you want teachers to fight each other over that one one visual art one performance art you know so making sure that everybody's got at least but I I hear you I hear you we'd like to there are more performance arts I would no I don't know maybe yeah thanks Charlotte anyway this is coming from somebody who took choir band um you know and drama in school
111so anyway and I took piano lessons as well um I have a question um under this board consideration number one I'm setting the Middle School configurations um determining if six to eight schools is feasible and supportive of student development I know it's a Hot Topic and a hot button issue relative to curriculum in particular and what kind of curriculum offerings um and I guess not offerings but expectations and standards there are especially in the core subjects math science English language Arts um and housing a sixth grade in an elementary school versus a middle school that the opportunity could potentially be better in those course subject areas of course with FTE and the availability of teachers in those curriculum based areas is that kind of what we're getting at what you're wanting us to kind of
112dive into and think about and discuss and then if so what would be your your recommendation or Sweet Spot yeah thank you for for picking up on that that really has been a thing that over the last several years we've seen curriculum and our Utah core standards reflect a K5 612 format and so when you look at those standards for the first several years I guess we've had the new court standards for 12 or 13 years now um you know we thought okay well K5 612 what will that really look like well what it really looks like is all of the Publishers now are putting curriculum out in that way so our teachers when they're collab cting and they're collaborating in their grade but they're also collaborating grade to grade you know fourth fifth sixth
113the sixth grade teachers now have a different Ela curriculum than the fifth grade teachers they have the same Ela curriculum as the seventh and eighth grade teachers science is in the same boat math is in the same boat so you know we're we're really starting to see that shift in terms of collaboration and continuity um kind of now I've got one or two sixth grade teachers at a school that are working on a new curriculum all by themselves so that that's another consideration in terms of continuity and collaboration and focus on that curriculum piece okay and what about the student development piece I know um in some things I've read across the country and here locally that there are concerns from parents and community members about kind of the developmental stages of where a sixth
114grader might be um versus you know a one through fifth grader might be in the same school setting and I'll start with that one and then let let you finish if you if I miss but one of the things that a lot of the research has said is you know a transition is hard no matter when it happens right transition is always a a difficult thing but one of the things that happens um that a lot of our schools around us are doing is pulling those sixth graders together and slowly sort of you know like it's like when you bring a fish home and you put them in a little bag in the aquarium and then you relas them to the whole aquarium you know you kind of pull your sixth graders together but they
115get used to having a multiple period schedule to changing teachers to having lunch out in a commment where you can sit wherever you want instead of you know at a line in a on a table all of those things and then they can make that transition into 7th and eighth grade so there are a lot of transition activities that there's research on that we could really learn from and learn from glendale's example and learn from other examples around us and how they really do build that fifth to six Sixth and then from 6th to 7th transition if that's where we go okay and then I guess just my last question is like what would you want us as a board to be thinking about in particular to that board consideration number one and are there
116resources or research that you could point us to that would help us you know think about that in a very comprehensive way well we we put um a lot of the resources that people suggested or that we read you know at the at the end of this report um I think we would need to get into it to really yeah figure out what those next pieces would be okay I can wait thank you you can't read all of those they're gonna summarize yeah that's what that's what we for imitated bibliography some do a dissertation on this okay so follow so following up sorry Amanda and then Brian sorry Amanda I didn't see you um you touched on part of what I was going to say but mostly I want to just emphasize it part of
117this does play into the G5 part of it may not um but emphasizing that whatever is being proposed whatever we're deciding whether it's the middle school start times realigning them like most of the middle SCH schools it's minor there's only one that's different other than Bryant which is a significant change um and then any of these other changes one of the things I'm pushing for on the G5 is um we make decisions for the upcoming school year and a respectful timeline for the families to be able to adjust to it instead of these this works for us and maybe Administration but it doesn't work for the families so if it gets to the point basically as we're analyzing this stuff this is something that we always need to be thinking about until we get our
118policies outlined to make sure that we're not leaving families in a Lurch of oh cred I've got to do some changes fast especially for people that have young kids that may not be obviously in middle school but they've got younger kids that the whole scheduling is impacted so I just wanted to emphasize that piece that's a huge huge ramification to families no matter what BR okay um I just wanted to speak um to Nate's comment in a way his last comment so the transition part and you were talking Dr Hall about um Publishers and the way that they're presenting the curriculum and all of those sorts of things but as I read through this study you were also saying that Research indicates that academic performance drops in those transition periods so one of the things
119that I'm concerned about and now I'm speaking as a sixth grade teacher um a lot of times sixth graders that's where they really are having success in academic performance I mean I haven't read a whole bunch of reports out there but they're now the top of the school you know they figured out how it works and all of that stuff and that my experience was a lot of children are having real academic success so if we go into this discussion I want it to be that we're looking at weighing okay A Drop in academic performance as opposed to you know what Publishers are providing curriculum wise and you know other reasons for making that move I guess I'm thinking about my students and that bag I think that you were talking about D where or
120not bag a group of kids where you get them together to figure it out so many of my students students they were not ready to know how to do a schedule and all of those things Ashley just to quickly add I brought up West and thank you for writing that down as we get to this part of the conversation I'll bring up something else I brought up in September which is CNA at IGN Elementary which is a program that has Blended grades deliberately in 1 two 3 4 and 56 and this would be another thing that's really impacted so West would be something I wanted to see in the report as it is because it is a middle level program but CNA I would want to make sure we add to any kind of future
121discussion about this as some of our schools will be impacted very differently than others by the the suggestion the sixth grade suggestion you're thinking can I make a comment on what you mentioned Brian we it's fine with me used my time we we did look at all of our sixth grade cohorts and compareed data and didn't find a lot of different in in achievement between a sixth grader at bman versus a sixth grader at Glendale um it was pretty much the same across the district so that was a a data point we look at I thank you and and actually I remember a conversation I don't remember who said it but when we were talking about this with the group somebody said well the only thing that changed is then the fifth graders became the
122big dogs at the school know yeah I I can see that yeah excellent well I don't see any other hands helina do you have anything that you want to add based on your experience it's a lot more fresh than ours um I don't quite know I know that a lot of people um my familiar with went to like the sels academy which also included fifth grade so um I know that that was kind of a harsher transition but I'm not sure about what sixth grade would look like but I don't know it's interesting to look at thank you um so just to summarize again now that we finish the second round there's a a lot of questions there's a lot of things um Brian you mentioned the potential for a study session um is that
123something that the board would like to schedule out while our wonderful team here is pulling together their resources and next presentations um to kind of dive deeper into this and we can also make sure that we manage these other elements of how we coordinate communication and participation parents student voice the the process is that something the board would like to do at Future meeting yes superintendent does that work for you to work for yeah you want a study session on middle level things I'm not quite clear what it would be just answering the questions that were asked which I'm not sure they lead to a study session or if it's a smaller study session sixth grade would be Focus the like yeah it's my understanding the study session would explore the two questions we were
124asked to explore along with all of these elements that were brought up tonight from the questions that so to explore further the idea of pulling together a sixth grade working group or what that would look like the board considerations of okay having the board consider moving to a 68 oh do you know what I'm just thinking of timing and what comes first I'd like to pull together a working group that would spend a few months getting you information reading the research and summarizing it for you um and then with that group bring something to you and maybe that's when we have a study session if we could create that as the timeline for this it sounds like Dr falling down you all need a few months to pull something together as well and does that
125work for the board to get all that I think that's a good suggestion I think that I would like to throw on there kind of along the conversation we've had had about about study sessions is you come up with your general I guess concept you're aiming for reach out to us explain to us what you're going to have them focus on and they give us the opportunity to provide our questions so that as you're doing that uh work it's encompassing the board's um input and concerns as well uh CH question would just on timeline what would with the district next steps would that happen I think we need to bring you information on Sixth Grade okay and get input from stakeholders including parents um and then bring that to you okay and then we could
126have a study session where we talk about the sixth grade Alone um because the boundary question and the feeder patterns we were talking um we don't want to address that one right away if we're going to also address sixth grade because you'd want to only make one transition in feeders and and boundaries and things like that and you'd want to work that around whether or not you were moving sixth grade if we're not going to move sixth grade we can move quickly to boundaries um just alone for to get the feeder patterns a little clearer for people um so I think getting started I mean they already have a starting point for for the sixth grade stuff in terms of the information you've pulled together I think it's expanding the circle that brings particularly parents
127to the table about that one so so for the Public's perspective sorry I'm sorry about that um Middle School changes basically should not be occurring this upcoming school year um and regard to these particular conversations so the public shouldn't be overly nervous about changes because you guys are going to go back a deeper dive which will put us out to potentially split summer um outside of not changes to sixth grade okay so but potential changes to boundaries if that's what the board well boundaries would follow the sixth grade working group's work so no no boundary changes either in the next for fall yeah I would anticipate we probably wouldn't be able to get that done by then um what changes would be made I'd like to bring forward to the board a recommendation well not
128a recommendation but just more conversation about nibi 7 and8 I think the report is pretty clear that we're not serving students sufficiently in the seven and eight pattern um and so would want to set up some public comment sessions and things to inform thinking on that um and and do that as the next step as well so that there could be changes in the fall with you had your hand up last comment on this one so we can move along I appreciate that Dr Grant I guess what I'm thinking is we have two things here we've got the next steps and then we've got the recommendations and for me um like the recommendations are direction from the board on further study and there's those two things so I think we've talked about that but then
129I don't want it to be that those next steps get lost because we're kind of talking about the what we're going to do in the study session because to me some of these other ones really are critical I mean like figuring out well re review course offerings for appropriate access at all mid level you know my coding band you know my example there and maybe we look at a report back an update to the board on where we are with making some of those changes or addressing those or What complications we've run up against and that's where because in the next steps you put in the thing about nibbly I me those are the things that they can't fall off the radar because we're looking at you know what the board wants further studies about
130do you get what I'm saying yeah yeah thank you that's good thanks Brian thanks Bri thank you see attendent I think there's one other um section to this um item here which is the Bryant slickly partnership update yeah thank you Dr Taylor's G come up with that one good evening everyone good evening this is an additional update in regards specifically to slicky Brand I'mma pause for a second presentation yeah the presentation we can go on to the first during the ongoing evaluation of middle schools we thought this would be a good time to provide this update regarding the historical context and the current status for slii brand s brand is a District middle school that is operating in partnership with a district Charter High School slii you see the historical timeline for that there was
131a board report that was brought forward to this board on September the 6th in 2018 a presentation with that secured Board of approval in terms of that was done on December the 4th 2018 and Bryant was renamed by board action to slii Bryant in May of 2019 what you see next is a trend in per people expenditure and enrollment since 2018 for brand for slii brand the enrollment actually peaked really around 2020 to 2021 and since then we've seen about a 28% decline in terms of enrollment at the highest point it was 445 students currently we have 330 students that include self-contained students if I'm moving too fast slow me down there were several core principles that Define the distinctive identity of sxi and sxi brand we hear talk about the model itself these are
132those core principles that I embid that model it had a stem Focus one sics cc the middle school was removed from the Charter High School and placed in the feder program which was slix Bryant team teaching for science math Ela social studies and those teams covered both teachers as well as students no tracking all students would would receive access to a rigorous curriculum and collaboration across sites and across grades there were four main partnership Focus areas and that partnership was with the United Way promise partnership one is teacher leadership and capacity building tier one engagement for we looking at whole school learning powerful student and family engagement and expanded and enriching enriched learning opportunities for college career Pathways what challenges have we encountered when you look at one sic and one sec you see it
133highlighted in red that was because that was not legal in terms of in line with the state law as well as with our written agreement when you look at the parent group one sec That Never Was toally implemented both sites maintain their own SEC so you have a parent group that's said slii Bryant and a parent group that said slii Rose Park which is the high school now I cited the law so you can read it for yourself but I want to make sure what's different about it is that phrase at the end at the school building level notice the words are explicit School building level we might view slix Bryant and SLI Rose Park at one school but they're in two different buildings so it means those buildings have to house those respective committees
134and the next one was the school Improvement Council sic you can refer back to the written agreement section 15.1.2 and you see the same terminology as school School Improvement Council shall be established in each school from The Faculty staff and the administration of that school what other challenges we've heard the mention beforehand about course offerings when you look at comparisons BR slix brand as well as glendell has have the lowest course offerings in terms of number of electives right around 2021 electives in comparison to some of our other middle schools that have upward upwards of 30 electives that they offer and transitions in leadership as we've had new people move in in terms of being leaders on the SLE Brian campus we've had to acclimate them to the model and work with them in accordance
135with the model what are our next steps simple put simply put we want to complete an evaluation of programming and Partnerships and if necessary for changes after getting input from the voices of our stakeholders make recommendations to the board are we making any current recommendations no we're in the midst of looking at our programming building voice getting input in order to determine if any necessary recommendations and changes would come forward we've been hearing a lot about supposed changes that have occurred let me assure the board we have made no official changes except coming in line with state code and our written agreement in regards to the SIC sec's any questions PR uh I have two questions um I initially had three but I think you answered the first one that I have um so the
136two questions that I wrote down um would be um where are you interested seeing this like work in Partnership going and then uh what stakeholder input has or will be gathered to inform any recommendations to the board two well first question in terms of dealing with the partnership we would like to expand Partnerships as much as possible we want those Community buyin from those whether it's business organizations charity organizations foundations I think our kids are worth it we want to expand those experiences so there there's no limitations that we put in place in regards to Partnerships or forming Partnerships the second one input would be taken from stakeholders all stakeholders whether it's students parents teachers we're in the process of developing those procedures in order to do so this is right at the beginning of
137that and it really grew out of questions that came about from Brant's SEC which which one sorry the Bryant so you said Bryant sorry think then uh another part if I may um would be has there been any um initial input from Britney pal the current um principal at sxie Rose Park yeah we've had some ongoing discussions other questions Ashley um so I represent a large portion of Brian's boundary and I've heard from a lot of different people with a lot of varying feedback that I'm trying to balance and I guess my first question for you is why the decision when you realize that the SEC and sic from the original board directive were out of compliance with the written agreement or state statute why wasn't that brought back to the board before rolling out
138the changes and why wasn't the community sort of why wasn't it rolled out in a way where the community found out about it as the discussion was happening well the first section let me address we looked at the intent of the board presentation which was to maintain oversight of the model so there is still a committee in place to maintain oversight of that model that piece wasn't changed what we added was Clarity in terms of making sure that we adhered in alignment to state code as well as the written agreement to have those school-based committees in place so that's why it wasn't brought back to the board the second part could you restate that for me again just Why didn't it get brought back to the board so that also the community knew what changes
139were happening that wasn't Tim me the whole time was it oh no sorry haha I took Bryce's time well well and the second piece in terms of the roll out the roll out was done through communication by the basic by the two sites administrations so we did talk with slii Rose Park as well as sxie Brandon in terms of that communication so when you look at the S because remember from the presentation as well as information that's gathered the sec's were always split what was not split was the SIC which was the teacher employe group and so we did communicate that through those Avenues so one follow-up question I would have is as we think about these changes being ongoing and you said no other changes are being recommended or considered I think the addition
140of honors sections on registration is considered a change by some members of the community especially on the slic high school side and there's also been some changes to the way overnight field trips have been done and other kind of main tenants of what they see the partnership as so I guess I would like to clarify how their current sic at both Bryant and is talking about those changes and what timetable we could expect those things would be brought to the board let me answer that in two sections the first one is I'm not aware of any changes to the overnight field trip process so we have to see Clarity on that one okay uh in addition to any future changes in terms of recommendations we can come forward with a timeline at a future date
141just give us an opportunity to start fleshing out what the process would be and then my last question for you is we see that the enrollment Peaks when the partnership kind of gets going and then the enrollment obviously dips do we have a way to compare that with the same Trends in other boundaries like we know our enrollment is declining overall is this enrollment decline significant in any way if you compared it across our middle schools the percentages would be larger but we can't determine causation because at the same time we had Co so right okay do we say Co or so we don't see enrollment as a significant part of the discussion we're having it's mostly about bringing original board directives into some type of compliance that's correct okay thank you any other questions
142for Dr Taylor Amanda um so in regard to your next steps um that complete the current evaluation programming Partnerships and the recommendations to board what do you estimate the timeline be in that regard we really don't have an estimate at this time we can put one in if you give us an opportunity we come back at the next board meeting or maybe at the direction of the superintendent to share that information in terms of a timeline we don't know what we're going to encounter as we begin this this evaluation it could be minimal changes or it could be a lot depending on what the input from the stakeholders okay and I think it would be good to at some point give a guideline as to the estimated like turn time on this conversation so the
143public isn't um um overly stressed about something that may be um a process of thoughtfulness that may take some time and then these discussions will happen versus a the carpet's pulled out from underneath them overnight type things so having that be clarified I think will be helpful for the public to understand um on timing of all of this these components any other questions sounds like there's um information and questions that need to be answered superintendent what is um your thought on bringing this back to the board kind of time do you need to prepare something like that with your team I'll talk with Dr Taylor and see how long that evaluation looks I think we should try and come back before the end of this school year though okay oh Ashley sorry I missed no
144it's okay I just had one more thing I had meant to say originally which is that you know in preparing for this meeting I went back and I listened to some of those meetings um that where the partnership was originally discussed and I think it does get hard I learned don't approve things from a slide yes don't do that that's a good learn I've been guilty of that as well and I but one thing that was clear in the conversation that wasn't on the slide was that this program would be reevaluated regularly and and the problem is that happened in 2018 and it's 2025 and we've actually never evaluated it which means that anyone on any side of the Myriad debates that happen about these Partnerships or course offerings or you know detracking or honors
145access wherever you land on any of that we have failed to evaluate it now what should have been two times so I think it's important not only that we're putting that on the calendar but that we're putting routine evaluations on the calendars when we say that's what we're going to do and obviously you were not here although I am looking towards you you were not here I was not here right most of us were not here but that's why having a calendar that looks very far ahead and puts things on Alan you are to blame uh but if we look further ahead we would be able to not have issues that then become kind of Rife with miscommunication because we would be doing our part in systematically addressing concerns as they come up thank you
146Ashley um you can blame me too I think I was here for that Alan you and I man all right well thank you superintendent we'll look for an update regarding that thank you Dr Taylor thank you okay um Sam I believe is next with enrollment projections um and demographic study options um that's our last report bran I think you're [Laughter] all right and while Sam gets set up um this is obviously in regards to our demographics um but we also wanted to make sure that we were highlighting board member requests and questions about how often we're updating um these types of demographic reports what's our consistency with that and our routine with that calendaring and so on and then potentially some options um from Sam today about uh where we're at and what we might
147be looking at to to meet those requirements all right good had to come over here so I because I had nobody to drive for me over there I was going to have my junior it assistant this kle come up but I decided to do it on my own so all right we're going to talk about the student enrollment projections this is a process that we run through every year uh at the end of December beginning of January and to talk first we want to just talk about the methodology or the process that we take um we have this conversation with our school administrators every year um just to make sure we're understanding the base of what of the numbers that we're using so these are the these are the terms we're going to discuss average
148daily membership cohort survival projection method District projection versus individual School projections and then how we project special education kindergarten and transition years um so in um our projections we use the average daily membership that's the Baseline number so when we report October 1 we're giving you an exact student count of students that are enrolled on that specific day however what we're looking at here this is from um state board rule r277 419 from pupil accounting um that's one of the uh items that my department takes care of um and it talks about that we are required to report annually our enrollment essentially and we do that three times a year but the ADM really comes off of our July one report that's a that's a accumulation of all of our enrollments over the entire year
149and what that average enrollment is so um ADM is what's used to calculate the weighted pupil unit that's where we receive that funding from so an example of that is where October one is that strict count um but an example of average daily membership is if first student is enrolled 180 days a second student is enrolled 90 days that would be a cumulative ADM of 270 days and the average membership would be 1.5 so on average over the year that school or that grade have 1.5 students in this example um and that that is the found Foundation of what we use because it matches where the funding comes from when we look at um external demographers that come in they tend to use the October one numbers that we give them and not average daily
150membership so that's why you might see some differences in like what I project versus what they project they all give us the trends that we need there are really similar um however you might that's why you would see some variation in that okay the cohort survival projection method this is um a simple method for forecasting what future population will be based upon the survival of the existing population that's that's how we do it we look at the last three years or we look at the last five years we actually do both um three years tends to be um a little more accurate um so what's the probability that a student who is enrolled this year is going to return next year or if we're projecting to the end of the year what's the probability that
151student a who's enrolled today will also be here on the last day of school um so we use that and it really is an average rate of change is what we're looking at over the last three or five years what's that rate of change on average so then we take um this slide is a districtwide projection and we look at it per grade level throughout and this is actually from one of my spreadsheets we have enrollment all the way back to 1975 where we were reporting in that and you can see the numbers in red there that's what I'm projecting for the end of the year and I think that number is if I can read it here 18338 would be our total ADM that's not going to be our cumulative count of students that's
152going to be much higher but based upon their dates that they were actually enrolled 18338 now that could be go up or down so for example last year um at this time I projected that our ADM would be about 18,700 791 is what it was 18791 and then when we finished the year as you can see there the line above the red we finished the year actually with 18852 so about a 60 student difference and that can be due to just that change right we're projecting December 31st for another six months essentially and so enrollments can fluctuate sometimes we're off a little bit um there is a a uh error margin of error in there I put the two this spreadsheet then calculates a three-year cohort history for the district and a five-year and that
153fiveyear number tends to be a little more aggressive but we use that for comparison to see when we're looking at the individual schools how close are we so if we take this model this says our overall enrollment in ADM next year would be 17823 for the three-year and then 17602 for the fiveyear so you can see there is a diff a pretty big difference there um now that just takes those those last three years and then five year takes the five the five years The Last Five Years on each one of those so now we don't hold that that what what I've seen this model do and we're looking at the district level that just kind of helps us look at this big overall number for the district and so in order to get a
154better accurate a more accurate grade level number or School number we we project each School individually so this is an example of what an individual School projection would look like on the left in blue you see the prior year end of year ADM the last three years that's just to for visibility um and then we put a column of what we projected the previous year and then we look at our December 31st count this is actually what students were enrolled on December 31st then our ADM up to so the number um if if we look at this particular um example the count on December 31st was 317 students but the ADM was 319 that's because we had a this this school probably had a lot of Mobility so we had a lot more students who
155um garnered some ADM they just weren't there on the 31st of December okay then the first adjustment is our rate to the end of the school year what's the prob probility that the students on December 31st will remain enrolled at the end and that gives us rate some grow some shrink um and you can see in this case our kindergarten on average at this school grew a little bit for first and second grade were about 98% of the students remain that gives us a projected endof year ADM then we calculate the probability that they're going to return the next year and that's what you see that three-year cohort rate whenever we do boundary changes however um it throws this off it really does because you're looking back historically and for that historical change to be
156accurate you can't have a whole lot of change in what we're doing and so what we did on all of the schools this year is all of the schools that had a boundary change let me clarify that is we took the district rate for that grade okay so if they had a boundary chains we said okay what was the rate of change for all first grade students did this school have a boundary change then yes so we use that rate if the school did not have a boundary change then we just calculated that rate specifically for that school and grade level so that provides a little more accurate you'll see like some of the questions we have are you you know why is it off from year to year last year was um as we
157were considering School closure and what the impact might be um that was one of the variations one of the variables that would affect that projection and so for the next three years we could see a little bit of variation until the in the elementaries until those boundary changes stabilize and we have three years worth of actual change in those schools um okay and then again that projects we use that rate and that'll project um a next year ADM then we look at um special education kindergarten and transition years and you can see in blue that we've got this projection based upon best yes and that and it really is this model helps guide us but if we take kindergarten for example um there's not a really good data source for that that is usable like
158birth rates right when we look at Salt Lake City proper um you can have birth rates but because of the university for example you had a lot you have a lot of Mobility doesn't mean they're going to be here in five years or they're born in Salt Lake a Salt Lake City hospital but they don't live in Salt Lake City boundaries so those are all factors that throw off the birth rate and why we don't use that so what we do is we look back 10 years at those schools and we take an average rate of change again and Project based upon the historical enrollment or ADM for those schools and we say is this reasonable does it look correctly if you if if you look at the bottom segment of that you can see
159how the model projects different rates and sometimes they're higher and sometimes they're lower so if I was to look at for example on the Clayton um projection a three-year rate says they would go up to 284 is that reasonable yes that's that's that's within the tolerance of the projection um but we projected at 273 simply because we can see there's in the middle the two-year was 272 on both of those and then a year one was a 265 so we kind of take a middle ground of that now if we argued and said oh well let's go the higher route we could do that we could do that that within the tolerance but that's how we look at adjusting those transition years we also look at um when we're doing transition years from sixth to
160seventh grade or 8th to 9th grade we look at the area how many students do we know of that live in the boundary of that school and that's a factor right so if I see a if we look at Clayton again 46 grade I look at 276 or I look at the number 280 but I only see 243 students that we're aware of that live in those boundary that would affect how we adjust that okay so based upon all of those that that information we are in a continued decline okay every year for the last few years we've dropped anywhere from 3 to 500 ADM every year this year was a a slightly lower on the closer to 300 um where the model has predicted that we will see declines are in grades K1 2
1613 five and eight and 11 and in our self-contained population with slight increases in grades six seven and nine and grade 12 is pretty much level what we see with grade 12 is um that starts at a high number and then ends at a low number because students start to finish finish early right and they and so they don't complete the entire year for one reason or another um and so that's where we're we're the model is showing right now we've been off from time to time and usually we're off in those transition years a little bit um we haven't really been off significantly in any areas but we we do see it from time to time um all right so our de our other demographics so we run that projection every year and then
162every few years we recommend a demographic company to come in and run a projection just to keep me honest right when I'm running this St just to make sure it's a test for me are the numbers we're running reasonable or are we way off and so every year that we've run this so we had um back in I want to say it's 2015 we had Davis demographics come in and then in 2021 we did we had applied to economics and they both of their projections showed um a decrease but a little more steep decrease than what my projections have have uh predicted not to say that mine's any more or less but it's just a way for us to look from different angles at these numbers to see what our enrollment will probably be so
163last year we um engaged applied economics again they helped us look at the I think last board meeting I talked talked about elementary it was for the um the idea of a fourth high school that's where they were really targeting um and we've asked the reason that we switch from Davis demographics to um uh applied economics was because of their model they more uh closely mirrored the model that I use um than Davis demographics did Davis demographics was very um geocentric geocoding and things like that which is really good to look at um but what I wanted was that model to be able to show me am I on target right and so we have that option we have some responses back from applied economics they recommend if we do go forward again with a
164refresh that we do it this next October that that will give us a better and more accurate prediction for the future and we can look at other providers other providers last year came in um significantly higher than the cost of Applied economics so that's again one reason we with applied economics last year so any questions Charlotte um how how often do you well you look at different schools you have your projections how often are those projections incorrect well maybe that's a hard thing to how how often are they off every year yeah off sorry not incorrect yeah um oh they're off every year but because it's a projection it's a projection right um okay do they tend to do you which way do they tend to be off both both ways both ways both ways
165so sometimes we're High sometimes we're low um the the closest I got I think was a couple of years ago for like October 1 I was like 26% difference and so I was ready to retire because I completed that but Allan wouldn't let me so um then the boundaries then then the boundaries changes and so it's not uncommon to see that fluctuation because again projections are just that they get us in the ballpark they get us looking where we need to and when we're looking at um like the beginning of the year we have processes in place to be able to um have those conversations are we surprised by a larger than expected kindergarten class that happens probably kindergarten happens more often than any because that is based upon best guess where the transition years
166were able to predict a little bit more accurately because we see those students they're here right and we just say okay are they going to go where kindergarten we're like we hope this is the number and then we have some move in or whatever that we didn't know about can I ask another question um oh so you do you base you do these in December and is that what the what the um employees so FTE is based on for the coming year yeah when they do when we do Staffing projections we look at the enrollment projection we is the board ratio of you know K through three is 25 to1 and then 4 through 6 28 to1 high schools are 32 30.2 to one um and those were all numbers that were given by the
167board historically okay any other question Charlotte I just wondered how if it if it is um if you if the projection is an underestimate of the number of students that can really how is that rectified um if there's not enough FTE you want to take that one you want me to take that one I'll take it so we look at October one counts when we get the actuals and if there's um a school that we were significantly off that we would be maybe be married another FTE or so we'll either give them the FTE or maybe because you're too far into the year so uh upsetting the the teaching stuff and maybe they just need more additional resources so we'll allocate the cash value of an FTE um kind we let the school make that
168decision on what they want but if it's the other direction we do not take FTE away because again you don't want to kids are in they have their teachers they're set we don't we want to minime disruption for for the student okay and then one last question what um do you see any trends for Title One schools in projections being either low or high I think the trends right now everywhere are declining um in Prior years we would see some of the title one schools especially the Westside schools increasing in population down that seem to reverse those those are where we started those are the schools we're starting to see the lower number of students right now but even our non-title one schools are showing that a decline as well some some have stabilized a
169little bit where we where we see our um kind of unchanging enrollment are really in The District programs right if they're at a school we project if I have a school that has a general Ed population and a magnet program I will I will project the program separately from the general education because the survival rate for that uh program is much more stable than the general population so we do that just to make a more accurate projection okay any other questions for Sam Ashley I have question um are you asking us to consider whether you should do a refresh or are you saying that you're planning to move forward with a refresh um I think that I could go either way I think if we want to do a full refresh it would be the
170time because the last one was in 2021 so this would be the five year I think every five years is a good measurement for that that's sort of what I thought and if because I'm correct on that I would suggest that we do that um but also I would think that it focusing on secondary is wise given again rebuilds I just want to reiterate our past meeting conversation but also it seems like it's a good opportunity to try to match if what we see or hear about aligns with what the numbers say so like I hear a lot about Middle School attrition to slarts for example right but your report just showed me that there are actually spikes in seventh grade um so it's it would be interesting to figure out if a company that
171does have more access to you know like using ACS data in their modeling can they look at some of this Middle School attrition in a more granular way that we cannot because we're looking at whose data you have and they have a little bit more capacity to look at whose data you don't have y so I think that would be particularly valuable I agree any other questions and does the board also believe um Ashley's suggestion that we should go ahead and start scheduling that refresh um assuming that's a process through the finance committee and procurement process to find a vendor or a outside group to do that yeah we just start the procurement process trying to choose you know what's the most beneficial use a company we've used I mean I think last time Sam
172kind of weighed a couple different vendors and got some estimates from them and then we picked one that we thought was be most uh effective and efficient and did that go through the finance committee or is that District LED through your office okay does the board want to give direction to Allen to start that process head on I think it's wi it's given all the decisions we've got to be making related to numbers exactly um agree Al do you feel like you have clear Direction cool any other questions for Sam anything that you'd like to report on Sam think Charlotte can I just ask a clarification what is a full refresh I thought that would can you explain the difference yeah when I was talking about a full refresh the one we did last year
173really focused on the SEC the high schools when we were trying to answer the question of could we support a fourth high school so this time we were going to say we want a report that looks at K through 12 that's full refresh thank you okay thank you Sam thanks Sam all right um so moving along to our discussion agenda um I've been chatting a little bit with with Brian and the superintendent Allen uh we have actually reached um our 4-Hour time limit that we have committed ourselves to as a board there are a few things that um are time sensitive that we need to get through um Brian I would like to suggest that we um move item number five the B3 administrative procedures and tax increment financing item number seven Board calendar to
174our next meeting um we also believe that the G5 administrative procedures could be a really quick update once we get there um or we could start there um and superintendent what are your thoughts on the district Department reorg if we need to tackle that tonight we could push that to another meeting we can push it but we at each step pushing this out it means we're not making some decisions that would be helpful to make with the team now we don't have approval to hire an assessment and evaluation supervisor um there are people who are reporting to me that should be reporting to other people if we could move forward on that so it delays some work is the challenge by delaying decisions on that okay Bo president saler I would move that we table
175items five six and seven until the next well until someone lifts them from the table at the next business meeting um how does the board feel about that I'm fine seconding that um I don't know if we need a formal vote to we do need a formal vote okay um well let's go ahead and push that to the action agenda since we have a motion in a second or excuse me we'll take it to a discussion um there's a motion and a second on the table um to move items 5 six and seven to the next meeting agenda so we don't need to discuss that because I I'm not in agreement with number six moving we will I'm just stating the we have the the motion and the second to move it to to table
176it basically moving it to action and then table it do we want to table it or just put it on the next one and that a formal than you table is not debatable just take a vote there you go thank you um so since it's been motioned in second and per parliamentary procedure we won't um debate that um and I'll call it for a roll call vote starting with u with Charlotte Charlotte F Jefferson no oh Ashley Anderson yes Nate Salazar yes Mohammad no Brian chenson yes Amanda Longwell no Bryce Williams yes that motion carries um we'll revisit that at the next board meeting um I'm going to go ahead and take some privilege to jump right to number four which is the G5 administrative procedures um we can either take action on that tonight
177um but we also did receive as a board um some suggestions comments recommendations from board member my recommendation based on the that document that you sent to us Amanda would be to push those that document and those recommendations to the policy subcommittee for a response um Brian I felt like since um that policy rests with the board that it wasn't um in the best interest of the board to have that answered or evaluated by a singular individual uh within the district and would like to get that reviewed and recommended through the the policy subcommittee if you're okay with that agreed I'll make a motion to have the policy subcommittee reassessed the policy like or I don't know the proper wording But ultimately you get the point with considerations listed in the memo I shared with
178uh all of you uh board members um which uh let's see which I additionally request um it said mem will be included in this evening's minutes um extra emphasis on ensuring um that the U basically ensuring the timelines are outlined in a way that is considerate to our community um and seeing what else we can expand upon because um as I've said um anyway so I'll make the motion and I don't know if we need a motion I think we could just give direction to the subcommittee to Rie that there your direction okay thank you we'll go ahead and do that and make sure that um your document um that you sent to the board um with ample time is attached to the minutes as well um so we'll move to item number one uh
179property use determining immediate District needs superintendent and ba kley so part of this came out later to the board um the list of items in G5 policy our next step after closing properties is to look at the immediate District need um and so in working with the senior team here in the district we came up with four items that were a need for space and property across the district one is is and these will be attached to the minutes for the public to see as well um the need for professional development space and uh testing center so some space that is um conducive to that that we need in the district the other is an expanded Career and Technical Center um larger than the one that we have right now over at the South um
180the Old South Campus this lixie campus um enhanced programming for students so we wanted to be able to provide some particular programs for students in need um particularly with some behavior problems and such that we could create shortterm placement for students and so we would need some classrooms here to fulfill that need um and the other is that we need some Athletic Field space and Isaac's going to report on some of that about the West High rebuild but just there is always a demand for athletic field so raising those is the four needs that the district has determined we'd like to find space or property for and what's next in the process is that um we would bring to the board hopefully next month a matching of where we think think those needs are best
181fulfilled in the district with some space within the district um so we wanted to just give this to you as a first look at what the immediate District needs are and then we would bring in a recommendation for where we would fulfill those needs to the board asy um it's my understanding that at least one of our buildings is currently being used by a third party provider um and so I'm just wondering if while we're discussing this we could also clear the air on what may be happening with some of those facilities now and if any of those intended purposes are expected to continue so we've got uh Head Start is in benan they were in one of the schools that we closed and they asked they could move to one of our um move
182there and it's a temporary situation is they're building a new building up near the U okay that's really helpful and then um the second thing I would ask is that as we look at um the what's been identified as an immediate District need that we also could look at some of the costs associated with that so in the December board meeting for new board members um the finance committee brought a memo that talked about some of looking at the analysis of Financial trade-offs and we were talking about that in context of something different but I think a lot of the tenants of that memo hold true and thinking about anything that requires new money May trade off with some needs that we have and some growing needs and in Title One in special education and
183I think um one I would like that to be attached so that new members have access to it but also that we are considering not just what the need is but what kind of strategically we're doing related to the costs with some of those needs and that would be great thanks um superintendent I just one I'm glad that it's on the agenda um I know we're not going to dive too deep into the district building needs um at this point but um I think it's a good opportunity that I'd like to just take to dispel some myth that there's all these plans that are being made behind closed doors or plans for housing or Redevelopment or what have you um this is the first conversation the board has had um around this so if anybody
184from the community is listening I know a lot of folks have reached out to me from Community councils from Neighbors who are um who live really close to the schools that we closed um are really worried that these types of things are taking place um they are not and so um please continue to follow us um please continue to reach out with you if you have any questions about our process um but this tonight is really the beginning of our process um that the board is working on collectively um to identify the best um possible uses and student benefit of these properties that we have thanks um did that tackle number one do you want to move on to number two in Isaac's presentation just in case is there any other requests in followup to
185the district needs before we bring that back but I don't think there are I don't think there are either okay than Sor oh please helina I was just wondering for example at West um we're moving apib testing to U Mary Dublin Jackson so our smaller scale things like that like simpler things just not requiring board approval or anything no we're just we're just moving those um kind of temporarily finding space for that testing to happen so that it can happen more uniformally um so we've been doing that for years kind of moving those around what we're trying to decide on is the resolution of those four properties where the schools we closed so we're looking at District needs to say could any of the needs of the district be fulfilled in those buildings and would
186it then mean we wouldn't Surplus those buildings essentially and look at other property uses for them but we'd keep them within the district and use them for district needs thanks Ela Isaac thank you um thank you for your time tonight and I'll try to keep this brief um last year uh I sat in front of all of you well many of you and talked about the needs uh during the project we already knew we had some uh specific needs that were going to happen at Highland faster because of the project um now that we're looking at uh the second High School West High School being rebuilt um there's also some challenges there um step back for a sec uh you know most high schools generally when they build a school they're looking somewhere between 40
187and 50 acres to build a facility um West High School for example we have 30.3 Acres which sounds pretty close until you divide that up between three blocks of third West Second North and fourth West um so we've got quite a few challenges and I just want to kind of talk through I'm sorry we we have um started working with both our Architects and the the contractors now that you guys have approved the cmgc contractors uh from last board meeting um and here that's where a lot of this conversation has started from um West High School as I mentioned it's split up um sorry got it okay uh so West High School split up not only by uh the existing roads but that you can see the yellow lines on the presentation where 200 North
188used to go through our property um those are permanent easements that have uh active utilities being run through those so we've got some challenges as we're looking at this property of how where we're going to place things and how we're going to work through it um with the high school and talking with the contractors um one of the challenges one of the bigger challenges with this cont with this project is that the length of time it's going to take to get this project done uh our goals have always been to to be cost effective uh build a sustainable facility and do it as least impactful on the students as possible um talking with our contractors they've come back and said they're they're some options here that we could uh tighten up the time frame to
189do this but it would require some changes to the the scope um of do more building on the east side I'm sorry the capitol campus side of West High School um which is on the North the east side of thewest trying I'm trying not to say East but it's not working I'm sorry it's all right um it's near the capital side yeah the capital capital campus um so on the capitol campus uh uh there you know the original drawings uh showed that this campus was going to be split between third West um and it still can be uh but a couple other things have come up um from the original drawings our intent was that we were hopefully going to be able to uh purchase some land or trade some land with the LDS church
190there's a parking lot adjacent to the southwest corner of the high school uh we finally gotten confirmation from them that that's not an option at this at this point so we had to go back and say okay what are we going to do to allow the west baseball field to be on the campus because it wasn't on the on the drawings um and these are two iterations that show that um the first one is closer to what was originally presented in the bond um that basically fits the baseball field on there you can see that it's right up against the property line in option one um the baseball field is about 249 ft long uh from home plate down right field um and it would require about a 30 foot retaining wall on that end
191basically the giant green wall from Boston is what we'd be looking at not that fancy but something to represent where the Home Run line is um but that also required us to move the Fieldhouse which then partially puts that over where those utilities are which would require us to uh relocate existing utilities which can be very timec consuming and expensive uh in in most cases um option two is another iteration where we basically move 90% of the uh campus and the academics and uh gym classes to the capital side um this removes that challenge over the 200 North utilities um it does present a couple other benefits in that we could es escalate the or I'm sorry we can do more construction we can do 90% of the construction up front which would save us
192money rather than passing you know doing the the capital side and then rebidding the west side of the campus so there's some about 20 20 to $25 million in savings by doing that that um when you figure a 4% escalation every year um that's where that savings would come in uh there's still many questions that would need to be answered there but those are two iterations that we're presenting to you guys uh for consideration and these are things that we're going to need to get input and some direction on rather quickly unfortunately so we can keep working with the engineers and uh contractors um before I move on from this I do want to say that we've had a lot of difficult conversations over the last few weeks um and I I want to thank
193our partners at the city uh the state legislature and those in this room that have uh found the ways to get through and um come up with a resolution uh for West High School um just previous to this the city council approved a TL forced to continue moving down the road for this so very positive in all regards and I want to thank Jennifer since she's here for all of her hard work and coordination on that I ask a question before he moves on before you move on to Highland you said like you've gone over the pros and cons I've watched a lot of children play baseball but I don't know the best design for a baseball field um how are we including athletic directors and coaches by these impacted Sports in whatever type of
194recommendation you're making because I would defer to the people who coach baseball rather than me right so we we have includ we have discussed with the uh School administration and the athletic directors um we haven't specifically said which one of these do you prefer uh their input was we want to get to a standard baseball field is possible um and that's part of option two is the more standard size baseball field um I'm sorry one other thing I felt to mention is in all of this this will require us to uh have the seminary building moved to another location uh it is our property that we lease from lease to the LDS church um but that would require a relocation of that um most likely to the north why don't they just use their existing
195land I mean the land that they're not it's a great question there were there were there were other properties um that they owned that have been sold to developers adjacent our property that have kind of created this um I'm sorry did did that answer all of your questions yeah I just want to make sure we're were hearing from the people impacted by Sports yeah the the input from the athletic directors is we want to be as standard as possible um I don't mean to just jump into Highland real quick but uh similar uh as we're working with the contractors um part of the plan for Highland is that we're looking at doing ground Source heat pumps uh origin originally the plan was to uh do that on potentially the park property but that's a huge
196investment on something that we don't own and we didn't have confirmation that they were agreeable to that so we went back and and did testing and we found that we have enough Pro enough space and appropriate soil sampling underneath our baseball and softball fields to allow us to do that on our property which would require less trans uh trans mission to the facility uh which again makes it more efficient um but again that creates another conflict in that okay here's two more sports that we don't have that we potentially going to impact for a couple Seasons um I think you guys have all seen the this iteration this is the most recent iteration of the building to the north any questions on that um realistically there's we've got three options uh the one the one
197is to look at impacting all the high schools and consider sharing space um that's very impactful to all the high schools uh there are Davis County recently did this at woodscross during their Remodel and bountiful uh during their remodel uh where they required the schools to share facilities um now this is a bigger imp because we're talking West High School nearly everything but the football field is on the capitol campus which is extremely impactful but that also uh there there's options that we could look at renting facilities but I've not found anything that is realistically the size or has the resources for us to run track and field and baseball and all of the the other sports in a location um and then the third is to utilize some of our current spaces to make
198improvements on existing facilities to uh provide the resources to the schools uh the drawback from that is that it's not at the high schools but at least it is a field that they can call their own and it also provides additional uh resources to the community in that area to utilize those when they're not being used by the sports teams and Isaac just to clarify for the board how long do these options need to be in place for each of the different schools I'm sorry okay so so Highland High School um this the soccer field was four years and that but that doesn't that's taken care of because of rosin Heights softball and baseball we're looking at two seasons um as far as uh West I apologize I had it on the slide oh there
199it is um track I'm sorry so the durations the track we're looking at six years potentially seven depending on when this when we start breaking ground and when we're completed for that potential seventh season that we're going to need a track and field uh tennis baseball softball we're looking at about four years and then the football field would be one to two years um the football field is something that I think is a different conversation because I think it is appropriate that that may be something that we look at sharing one of the other schools because of the infrastructure that's required this this seating and everything else that I think is a fair ask um but the track tennis baseball softball soccer uh and all the other s s field sports uh we're looking at
200four to six years at West High School um the other slides that I have for you are just locations that I think would be good suggest questions um Glendale we have a great track and fill already um previous uh board member Jen Jenny seea spoke about this a lot um it would require a little bit of infrastructure but we could build something like a a locker room that we've done at that we're currently doing at rosin Heights um that would allow rest rooms for the public locker rooms for the teams to be there and that could be used uh for track soccer and Lacrosse um it it it's already a six Lane track um it's large enough to fit a a standard siiz soccer field in there as well as lacrosse um estimate of that
201is approximately $4 million to do that at that facility baseball's a little baseball and softball are a little harder because they can't be played at the same locations and they have different measurements uh currently uh Riley Elementary uh we could fit a baseball field for West High School there um that would require Dugout scoring fencing uh we could potentially use uh Porta poies rather than doing a locker room and bathrooms there or potentially find a way to use the resources inside the school um but that'll take a little bit more collaboration uh estimate on that one this one would requires the playground to be removed and quite a bit of asphalt for the distances to work out um but that's about $25 million Mary Jackson can fit a a softball field but again it's pretty
202tight uh with the current building um we can do it without affecting the building at all but it would require asphalt and some other things moved relocated but that does it's close to the West High School and it also has plenty of parking and resources around it uh Clayton Middle School is another location that uh identified uh for the Highland softball uh Team uh which estimate is about1 A5 million dollars to turn that into the facility that they would need and then uh dillworth we have an existing baseball field there but it's in really bad shape uh we have little leagues that have done lots of work over there to get rid of things um but it would be a prime candidate for baseball with plenty of parking and space um but again that field
203would basically have to be removed and redone which is why it's a little more expensive at $2 and5 million doar question actuallyy it was my understanding that those fields were owned actually by the park there there are land there are land so if a person had a question about like any of these sports or field use that these are all things that are our land that will be impacted at some point by these phases of yes thank you yep and that's it for the presentation questions he said there's some urgency there there is some urgency the the the urgency right now is more on uh what discussions do we need what what information do you guys need to help steer Us in option one or option two on the west high high uh build and
204then uh the other urgency is the goal right now is that we'll have design completed by the end of this fall so we can put out to bid and break ground next spring on West High School and then about two months later break ground for Highland High School um West High School is the bigger time crunch because we'll need about a year to get ready to build facilities if that's the decision uh to have those done in time before we affect those Sports so those are the really time crunches right now the baseball and softball field for Highland can be you know another six to8 months down the road before where we really have Direction but again those are all asked for money that I know we want the money to go towards the students
205obviously the sports affect students but is that really the priority for for the board to fund those things J um I just was curious um why highum Park Elementary wasn't considered for one of the fields I see um Clayton being relevant and that can the Middle School needs um but if there's a potential for competing um needs Middle School and High School it would be better to have it put on another property that's currently being used um I'm I'm sure there's possibility there as well uh Highland Park though is more of a soccer Comm community and those fields are set for that already um it it's a highly uh reserved area that is utilized all summer long for those Sports um but again there there's plenty of other schools that this could be done at
206but these were the ones that I felt were closest in proximity and the least uh cost effective manner for us to build them on existing properties Char yeah have you considered also um renting or using other fields I just know when I played softball at South High School we were busted to Cottonwood um complex I don't know if that's what it's called still but anyway we that's where all our games were I mean we we did we practiced out we didn't have a really great field you know but the so there like I mentioned that the facilities I was trying to find were at least in location in within the district and there aren't really aren't any for those Sports in in our area what about Jordan park with the city would they let you
207use the softball there's a softball field there there there's several Fields out there um that potentially could be utilized um but most of those are Pony size fields which are actually smaller than softball fields a standard softball field so Isaac the question before the board is do we want to spend money creating field space like the different options you've suggested or do we want to find ways to share current space current space or if if there is an appetite Force to send students outside the district to to utilize facilities and one of those spaces with Glendale is a um is the football Ron McBride Ron McBride Ron McBride Foundation group um it it's a great facility and as I mentioned before uh previous member seea she talked about it all the time I've seen it
208highly you used uh the challenge there is we don't have for some funding to help us with that possibly we I mean the issue there is we don't have restrooms for visitors um yeah Alan and it did want to know you know if we decide to go and and kind of update or or build facilities on some of our properties we would look into Partnerships whether with the city or other donors to help uh offset some of those costs and I know I already said something I'm sorry but and the in the cost piece Ashley's always really great about this ask what's the tradeoff you know you're asking 12 to5 million do we have that in our budget are there concerns that it's going to impact something else that we might need yes you can
209ask for those monies you may not get $5 so if we have to come up with the whole 15 mil um is that tangibly doable without compromising something else right so these if we were to go forward with these expenditures they would come out of the capital um projects fund um and what were're in now is a w with the bond it allows us to start building that up so we future rebuilds and extensive projects we have cash to um to pay for them it would just limit the amount of cash we have by the 15 million um or maybe push some projects back a couple of years I mean so it is in the realm of possibilities um but yes there's always going to be trade-offs if you spend your your 10 15 million
210here that means you're not spending it um on another project or you're having to push that project down the road a little bit which makes sense but we've already committed to these builds and personally I like the idea of um improving existing properties that are being utilized um versus um transporting our kids to other districts or putting them on shoddy fields and stuff so they have something quality while the rebuilding is occurring TR um but we want to make sure that what we build isn't just a temporary thing that it's useful for people people in the in the future and will be used you know um is is there a need for a softball field I don't know I mean that's all you're going to be taking that into consideration right yeah we uh similar
211to Rosland Heights these are facilities that are utilized already by different groups and our our department does oversee the uh reservations of those so we have soccer baseball softball Little League football that are always calling asking to use our facilities um so yes uh the intent would be that these would be built to be lasting facilities that can be utilized now and then in the future um and uh hopefully there are facilities that will build a stronger Community as well if that's the option of the board Ashley I think that for both the question about the athletic complex and you know the way we may adapt an invest in field space my answer would be the same which is just that I would rely on the input of the athletic directors and also the specific
212coaches of the impacted teams and I don't know if it's reasonable to bring this um back for us to decide at the next meeting now that we've discussed it because I know I will get a lot of messages from specific Sports and they will say to me when does phase two begin because if my kid has graduated by the time it's phase two I'm not going to B bother you about this because my opinion will not matter so much but if I have a kid who's going to be entering High School in Phase 2 and they are only a softball player you know they're going to have a lot of stronger opinions so how much flexibility do we have with the time and what type of stakeholder feedback could you perhaps get in that time
213because to me that is what would inform my decision personally as I mentioned the the feedback I've gotten is from the the administrators uh of the school and the athletic director from West in Highland uh we've had individual meetings with them about this um and and again really their their input up to this point has been we need to have standard standardized fields and we want a field that's on campus so I think it's important that these obviously have to happen um but uh I mean we we we've included them quite a bit up to this point and that's the input they have uh so are they good with these interim Solutions I I have not presented these locations to them uh I I take that back uh Justin Thompson at West I did talk
214to him there's a track at Rose Park as well and we we evaluated both of those and uh glendell has a much nicer track it's actually six Lanes instead of four which is uh the one at Rose Park and Rose Park is a little bit smaller so we' it' be difficult to fit a full size soccer field there br okay my one question just goes to because there was also the discussion about sharing facilities so going to East or going to one of the others that their field was still available or whatever my understanding is the baseball field at East is problematic are we working on that so there is a project this this spring at East High School okay so are we putting like a urgency so the if we did need to share
215that I mean I think when we say we're going to share facilities you got to have the facility to be able to share it yeah so the baseball field baseball season starts I believe on the 24th of this month or tryouts are on the 24th and then the season starts first of March they end about the middle of May depending on playoffs um our intent was that uh we had to get an engine involved because of the age and challenges there um we've we secured that this winter um they're working on the plan now our our intent was that project would be started right after baseball season this year and be ready for next season okay that's good to hear that doesn't I mean that that's internal irrigation for that field that doesn't deal with
216the 50-year challenge we've had with the storm drains on that field I mean there are some big problems there so you're working to address those y okay charl I just want to make sure nobody else has had a chance to speak Muhammad or Bryce helina do you have any insights just one M yeah so pardon my voice um in regards to sharing Fields with East we got a problem as well with the East uh soccer field um is there any projection to fix in that as well what's happening with that so we've taken care of the irrigation challenges there and we've replanted to take care of those the other issues um we haven't had further discussions of of you know like turning that into a turf field versus a saw field or anything like that
217at this point okay um the sharing the fields it can be tricky um I mean there you've got three we've got schools that have had multiple Sports added over the last few years that we didn't build additional spaces for those so now you've got boys and girls soccer competing with boys and girls lacrosse for field space uh you've got football season where there's you know if we're sharing a field there or sharing Fields all of them that means we have to coordinate to make sure that one team has practice time Fair practice time along with the others um and then game time would be a challenge of coordinating okay you're away this week so we we're going to utilize your field and then swap them back and forth between cross track you got Unified sports
218sharings I mean Highland High School has been struggling with space just on their own site yes let alone trying to squeeze it onto another site my finance degree tells me share Fields but realistically it's near impossible to do that be fair to all the kids um so do we need a motion I think Charlotte had one last burin comment I can't remember I don't remember okay no worries I need to jop my my questions down next time no worries um I think before we seek a motion if that's the will of the board Allan and Isaac is there some wiggle room for us to revisit this next month or does the urgency present itself in such a way that we need to make a call on this tonight I do know I remember um is
219there do you ever um present to local community councils and get their input on what what the community might want or need in those spaces so in the buildings that are not the schools that have been closed that we still own okay so uh I I'm new to the district as well so in the year and a half I've been here a little more than a year and a half um we've done rosin Heights which we did reach out to the community we talked about what would they like to see in it we made some accommodations there um as far as the school themselves we have held off on that because first priority is figure out what the district needs are before we commit to anything else okay um Nate back to your question of
220of urgency the the urgency for waiting on deciding on field space till next month I don't think that's a huge concern we we do need it sooner than later um the bigger urgency is uh talking about option one versus option two of West High School um and uh because that that's going to come down to how do we continue designing and coming up with the plan on both of those um Isaac what you presented here was information about where possible Fields could be placed but not a plan yes for placement I wonder if you want to bring back a plan that the board could approve okay that would include the financial p pieces sort of is that good way Allan to move forward on this yeah just knowing too if we were going to look
221up for Partnerships I mean so we we we could bring an estimated full cost knowing that we will try and um enter into Partnerships um to help offset those costs but we wouldn't have that because we need the plan first and then we can go out and and look for Partnerships yeah because ENT and like personally I would like this broken out a little bit I guess clearer for lack of other words um because we've got like you said the West High um the structure of the fields versus where the building is outlined and uh cost differentiation because I presume there's going to be a cost difference in those um and then that would put for me feed into um the cost for these proposals on where the sports fields are going to be temporarily
222because if we're going to save with one plant versus another that can help that decision but additionally I do like Ashley's uh suggestion that with these locations for the interim Sports um Fields getting that input from the athletic departments on your proposed locations um so that you know the people that are using them are giving concrete feedback versus those of us up here here that do not function in that capacity and if we bring it by the next board meeting that's great if I might suggest I think um the building analysis of where these best fit um perhaps should rest with buildings and grounds in terms of suggesting where they go because it's so determined on the space we have not the convenience of a team moving to that place because these will be longer
223term facilities so we'd want to think about where they're placed in the district what makes the most sense for how this space is used now kind of some of those things that Isaac was bringing up I just think what what will may end up happening is that they will choose space on proximity to the high school which I don't know was our primary concern so much as finding the most cost effective and good space for the district in the long run fully agree with you thank you for that Clarity I would say if there is an option as far as like say by Highland High School if there are two fields that are adequate than them the um Athletics director or team being able to give input on which one they would prefer and then
224if there really is no option then yeah you're probably no need to go that direction I than Amanda that's good the other piece I think you were talking about too was this option one and option two Isaac can you bring to us a more um like side by side comparison of that the costs you had mentioned and what might be saved or not um what the upsides of this are for each of these and the downsides and and then what you and The Architects recommend or yes to so that it's again and if the community over there at West High have the opportunity to give input you know obviously isn't just specific to Athletics that's the whole community at that point if there's an ability to send out a poll to make it easier on
225Isaac or some I don't know but basically getting the community feedback as well while we're analyzing the cost pieces because again it's impacting them it's not impacting me I I would have a hard time making the decision if they haven't had a chance to weigh in and I would presume we could get that fairly efficiently and quickly um I don't know Sam well and some of the trick with feedback is our options are super limited so it's like you know how do you get all this feedback when it's like that's great but based on the site this is the only well I just mean simply put West High option one option two you've got it right here already outlined so do we have 100% saying option one or is it you know 50/50 and then
226we're just looking at money at that point you know what I mean um otherwise we're making a guess based on what we think and it's not necessarily what maybe what's best for that Community it may take longer than it seems to look at Option One versus op to because I think it's hard to look at this picture and know what the implications are of the these drawings um there's a lot that kind of goes into that the placement of the fields the size of the fields the facade and how it's dealt with of West High um you know the but all those points that you're making our reasons we need to get that input you know what I mean I think my ask is is is that the desire and will of the majority of
227the board to take on Amanda's suggestion um or you know rely on the expertise of folks within the district anybody want to weigh in I mean if the urgency is there I just I don't want to put out like a you know kind of a mediocre or like a swift or a fast opportunity for parents to weigh in and the community to weigh in um that's not meaningful I guess is what I'm trying to say and how do we capture that within two and a half weeks between now and our next board meeting I don't know if we can get there or to to capture what it is that you might be looking for might to get some pieces of it um but I just want to make sure that that's the desire of the
228whole board to try yeah and we could maybe yandre could put out on social media the request to re have the community reach out to us board members to provide feedback I mean there's different ways that could be advertised as well without going through a complicated poll and data analysis Ashley I'm just going to put you on the spot and see since you represent both both of you represent that school I just know I will hear more questions about it so I'd like to be able to answer them but if the real answer is we have to choose tonight you've told me you've you've received kind of the definitive asks we want this and this is the space that will accommodate what people already said so there is a problem with delaying two weeks is
229what I'm hearing so that yes that's accurate and and if I can say I I apologize that I'm throwing a lot at you tonight without a lot of data behind it this has been an evolving thing over the last couple weeks since I actually turned in the presentation about the sports I actually met with vcbo and uh the contractor today talked about this and the the reality is there's a 20 to $25 million difference between option one and option two and the budget's tied on this I I can't express that enough um the the idea of um you know how do we decide what we want in the school and not want in the school is those are the conversations we'll we'll be shortly having to you know Whittle this down to what our budget
230is and make sure that the students get what they deserve um which plan is 25 mil more the option one is 25 million more it was um because of the utilities utility relocation and the time because you're you're basically building 40% of the facility four to eight years from now so there's an escalation every year projected projected escalation because we're paying $50 an hour for a plumber now it's going to be 55 next year 58 the next and 65 the year after that got it I I'm just going to ask a question which is if we move this to action can I simply say the item more moving to action and get some more specific language is if you recall saying I move we do what's on the slide is not a good um and
231the way this is labeled if I say I would like to move the the field space for West High rebuild item to action can I do that and then make a more specific motion on action yes I move the field space for West High rebuild um go to action a second I've got a motion so what were what are we approving on field space or are we approving the option one versus option two we're not approving either option we're simply moving the topic to the discuss it there's two topics though and that's why I was hoping someone would um share their preferred language for what it is they feel is most prudent to approve for this option one versus option two thing as well as the second question okay temporary and investing in field use
232for temporary reasons but long-term public gain simplistically it's discussion agenda number two let's move it to the action agenda well we have a motion is in a second so now we have some discussion so um any further discussion to the motion okay seeing n we'll start with a roll call Vote with Ashley Ashley Anderson yes Nate Salazar yes Brian Jensen yes Amanda longell yes Bryce Williams yes Charlotte F Jefferson yes right okay that motion passes we'll revisit this on the action agenda superintendent item number three G5 administrator annual report regarding populations and boundaries I introducing this so um Brian is our G5 administrator and has prepared a summary that I'm going to ask him to work through rather quickly um first every year we are required by the current G5 to give you a population
233update um and school closure update and what we might want to put on the list so um right now we don't have that but to put on the anyway Brian's doing the annual report and then he's also giving a summary of um the impact of school closures and the changes in boundaries taking a look at some of the um consequences of that over the last year so that the board would have a sense of not only what happened at the time but a followup on it uh superintendent Graham would you like me to just do the review of student enrollment today to right now and wait on the other the uh um the other the review of school closure and School boundaries there isn't a timeline I don't believe on the re um the review
234of student enrollment data is a timeline of right now in G5 policy of before the end of February but this review of school closure New School boundaries was something the board had asked for um I can do it all now or if you'd let's see how it goes okay sounds great board thank you for having me here tonight uh we'll get started the first few slides handful of slid slides our review of student enrollment data a little bit different look you've heard a little bit from Sam Quan you'll hear some more from me um and that's a K12 look at student enrollment data then if we continue it will be a focus then after those first uh five or six slides uh then we'll go into the um review of school closure and New School
235boundaries that was for the elementary schools last year so in accordance with our board policy G5 uh the board and superintendent shall review student enrollment data as part of the annual evaluation of the organization and configuration of district schools you see a lot of numbers on this uh slide right here some of the numbers that I'd like to just draw your attention to as you look at this is uh our grand total of our octo October 11th enrollment or October 1st excuse me was 19,176 students um and uh you can see it's broken down by Elementary Middle High School charter schools are two District Charter Schools as well on that page and uh wanted to share that data with you first uh that big picture of where we were on October 1st moving forward with
236the rest of the information I have it is all calculated from our October 1 uh enrollment from this fall so uh you might walk into a school and not see a classroom with 23 in one of them that we said it might be up to 25 or down to 21 but on October 1 that's where we were as we move forward our next slide uh shows our K8 enrollment by grade this uh gives a little bit more of a broken down just as you can see grade level by grade level of uh What uh in M looks like in each of our K through 8 schools we see open classroom at the bottom um in blue it's and I put it in blue because it is a district Charter another question that I often get
237is the column on the far right labeled seie seie is a self-contained special ed uh or special education self-contained students looking at the next slide we have our secondary enrollment again the school highlighted in blue at the bottom is a district Charter uh our saling Center for Science Education but you see here um that our uh enrollments um at each one of those schools are broken out by grade and you can get an idea of taking a look at that of how many students we have in each of those grades this next slide still a District enrollment by grade but I add added this one because I think that there's a a lot of uh data that you can really pull out of this table if you look at the table and as we advance
238it one uh I have uh Red Box around our 9th 10th and 11th and 12th grade uh cohorts for um our elementary middle high schools Charter Schools you see that number down there at the bottom for 9th 10th 11th 12th those cohorts when you look at it what's leaving our schools over the next four years is an average of a little bit better than 1,600 students per grade and if you look at the next one I have circled here's our students come uh first second and third and fourth graders the students that we hope to have for a long time all the way through 12th grade but you'll see that those grades right there are averaging less than 1400 students per grade and I wanted to just share that with you to go hand inand
239with what some of the projections have been what we've been talking about about uh how our numbers have gone down our our projections going forward it would most likely be that those numbers aren't going to start shooting up magically they're going to keep going down a few hundred a year our next slide looks at what our school populations look like in our district often times I think people uh think that every Elementary School is just a k6 element entry but as you can see here even though that is uh the the fourth row down is our k6 um we do have more pre6 schools than we have k6 schools we have many different configurations within the district and our district charter schools are also listed at the bottom um we have a 68 Middle School
24078 middle schools four of those that 712 school is West High it has two approximately 200 7th and eth graders um at West high as well and then uh the other schools you can see there we just have many configurations and uh and it's something good to keep in mind because um because that's something that I don't think we often look at is even though we put prek with this remember prek we love having them in our schools we think that it's a great way to get students introduced to our schools to keep students and they take up space as as well so uh that's a that's a good thing if the school has a space and a good number of them that top row many of those are our Title One schools we'll talk
241more about that later if time permits so that ties up that first part uh do you want me to ask questions or just keep plowing through really quickly thank you for the slide on what do school populations look like that was a really really great graphic on how that breaks out thank you um board what do you want to do we are bound by G5 to have the presentation we just had um but we could wait on the second portion as my understanding what you mentioned earlier Brian is that correct that's yes that's that's just the review of what what's happened over the last year yeah any thoughts on hearing the school closure followup report um at a later time in a report section I think it makes sense to hear as a report given
242that we should ideally approve our G5 process before moving forward although we're finishing this current G5 process so I would be fine proceed oh to proceed I'm fine I'm fine we're here all right great thanks good to be back all right uh our projections for this year um Sam talked some earlier about projections um I do want to start by saying the neighboring District districts um who have been doing boundaries and planning work for many years shared with us a number of times that really stable reliable numbers usually took three or more years to develop we heard as high as five some one said three um but you can see that of our 23 Elementary enrollment projections this the does not include our district Charter open classroom because uh they don't have typ typical Traditional
243School boundaries like our other schools uh but based on our October 1 count 20 of the 23 were within 10% of actual enrollment of the three elementaries not projected within 10% we over projected Newman by 19% Rose Park was over projected by 15% and Whittier was over projected by 14% um and I'll talk a little bit about the why uh some of the some of the reasons we see as why for that of the nine nine uh schools that were between that 5 and 10% Range Five were over projected four were underprojected Sam alluded to that earlier too that sometimes he getes a little bit over sometimes you get a little bit under now projections were um off for various reasons open enrollment of about 30% of our students um was expected and we knew
244that was coming and that's about what we had but where a student was going to enroll and why was a family specific decision also the Open Enrollment window was still open when these initial projections were made um people were still making decisions do I want to open en roll here or there put in an application District programs and where they move affected all this as well uh natural attrition oh sorry not that piece uh a there was um based on on all of this um to have more than half of our schools under 5% of being with uh 14 of our schools changing boundary and 13 of those 14 having significant boundary changes um we thought that um those numbers though off a little bit at about at the other nine um for that 5
245to 10% and three that were more than that we think we're going to keep getting that dialed in more and more as the as the next year or two go by here's what some of the changes look like in our elementary schools that we have now first of all um we look at last year versus now we averaged 379 students in our 27 elementaries again this doesn't include open class room um and last year we had seven schools with more than 400 students we had two with 500 or more this year we have an average of 422 students in our 23 elementaries we'll show you why that's actually a good thing to have a little bit a little bit higher average um we have now 13 schools with more than 400 but still we were
246able to only have we only have two schools still with 500 plus students so it wasn't like our number of 500 plus students in a school shot up astronomically it stayed the same what did go up is the number of schools that had that 4 to 500 range um in some of our slides coming up I'm going to share an example example of why this is a can be a positive outcome for our students and staff now looking at elementary enrollment um in 23 24 more than 800 of our elementary students were part of an unintentional split class or were in a class where their only option was uh in their school in other words it was maybe one fourth grade class in the entire school so whether that fourth grade class had 12 students
247in it or 33 students in it when a new student came or a student left it was always out of that one class um in 2425 we didn't eliminate that um challenge completely but instead of having 800 of our elementary students in that uh potentially compromising situation we now have fewer than 180 students part of an unintentional split and an intentional split as uh board member Anderson brought up earlier is like CNA where they have a k or one two split or a 34 split um sometimes we have only one class per grade level in our programs for example our magnet program only has one class per grade level at those schools but more often than not we try not to do that and uh as you can see from the numbers we've really cut
248those numbers um 21 of our 23 elementaries now have two or more gened classes in every group grade and the only exceptions out of those are insign with CNA and Newman has I think it's just one of their seven grades doesn't have two uh gen classes they with a with a black uh type with a with a black uh type and DLI classes in the blue type uh and I didn't include the Edison eel or Edison magnet on here because those are intentional um one class per grade level for the program itself but when you look at this what you notice right away 2023 to 2024 if you read the headings of each of those tables last year in the Glendale area we had 146 students that were in single grade level classes they were
249the only fourth grade class the only fifth grade class so that we had 146 students this year we have no students in the Glendale area that would um that would have to go with that challenge of boy we really need to look at moving this student to another class we don't have another class we can't do that um so we as we look over here and you see what I've highlighted in the Box the box shows for example last year when we had Riley and Park View in those upper grades it was one class per grade level and you could see what happened to the size of those classes in at least three of those four classes they were well over 30 and uh really went up compared to this year down below not all
250the Riley students moved to Parkview but I'll show you in a few slides that a lot of them did look at those numbers in uh in uh fourth and fifth grade two classes per grade level and 22 to 28 students to per class instead of 33 there's one abnormal there's one on there you go whoa that's a big number if you look at Edison in the bottom table they're kindergarteners you see 3231 that was on October 1st where those counts were I know that they've taken some steps to alleviate those numbers and so those aren't as big now as they were then but um again we didn't this this wasn't a cure all for everything but it did help solve a decent chunk of our problems so back to what I had mentioned earlier more
251than one class in a grade level in other words having about four to 500 students in a school it helps us balance class sizes it helps offer choice to families it creates a healthy mix of students in each class and we have more collaborative adult opportunities and learning going on in schools or the potential for that and moving forward instead of the Standalone fourth grade teacher or Standalone fifth grade teacher here's some additional information about uh again smaller schools like we had last year doesn't mean smaller classes we still our average class sizes have remained low in uh grades K3 and in 46 19 to 21 students per class in those grades I thought this was really interesting last um last year we had 21 classes where we had 28 or more students per class
252this year there's only seven classes like that um and our number that chose not to attend their neighborhoods school maybe they got accepted into magnet maybe they went to DLI maybe they just maybe they had a um a reason to move to another school or want to our number of students uh that went through open enrollment and are not attending their neighborhood school is pretty darn close to last year 30% compared to 28% um I would like to point out on our uh top bullet that gotten a lot of feedback on how our District programs of D and magnet are now more equitably distributed across the city um our DLI programs at Newman Mountain View and nimbley park really show um a concerted effort to have a north to south spread of DLI not um
253Al together and our district magnet programs at Edison Whittier and Indian Hills we still have a class or two at Washington a couple classes at Washington but really shows a west to east spread instead of those um programs being um clumped together as they were last year um also you see the other two bullets on here um we get to also give another thank you to Jennifer Newell who's here right now a lot of these changes we've been working closely with City agencies to improve systems of collaboration with city planners with uh liaison from um the mayor's office in Jennifer Newell I know the super attendant and and uh and uh her Presence at being able to attend and be part of those types of um conversations what happens at ballpark uh yandre and her
254group we've really includ we've really improved our uh communication and systems of collaboration with our city some people um moving on some people were concerned about prek we do have fewer sites than last year but our number numbers are actually up because most of our sites have multiple prek classes so fewer buildings that they're in but actually our number of students is is up here's some of the demographic composition of our elementary schools now um our elementaries um our percentage of low sces has increased at 11 of our schools compared to last year I do want to note that um that 100% that you see on number of those they're reported as such because they are Community eligibility provision schools it doesn't mean that 100% of the um of the community is low sces is
255just they qualify for that and then are are um able to offer free lunch at those schools breakfast and lunch I believe at all of those so we have seen an increase in low sces um at our schools um I do want to point out on the next slide with our multilanguage Learners we have seen a drop actually in percentage of mlls at about half of our schools six had an increase Newman one of our new DLI program schools has had a double digigit gain in multilanguage learners but uh those that are highlighted are the ones that have shown an increase in um percentages of multilanguage Learners in our district our bipo population um has seen um that has shown us that over the years I included one extra column on here notice the very
256first column is 2019 I wanted to take when when you look at just 2023 and 2024 you go yeah not much difference but when you take a look five years before versus now you see that um our most of our elementary schools are becoming more diverse um look at metal AR for example um we see that there the the number of uh black indigenous people of color identified um that number's gone up 19% at wasach elementary that number in the last five years has gone up 15% so um we do see more diversity within our district as well next slide uh wanted to show you where our last year's Hawthorne students went as well as our other three schools that closed the schools that are highlighted in red on these next four slides show us
257where students were pointed due to new boundaries for their Elementary of course open enrollment gives families options to try elsewhere those not enrolled elsewhere in the public State system don't let us know exactly where they went so you see the the bullet at the very bottom um some of those could have gone to private schools some could have gone out of state out of country I do want to add I'm going to be sharing with each of you the mobility rate for 2023 for each of these schools last in 2023 the mobility rate for Hawthorne was 5% and Mobility rate is a student is considered mobile if they have one or more enrollment records with less than 160 days of membership at that school so it's movein move outs things like that it was 5%
258last year at Hawthorne but you can see here most of those um Hawthorne students from last year went either Emerson Indian Hills are Wittier and uh but they went all over I mean we have last last year's hathor students at a number of different places 266 of them did enroll in a Salt Lake City School District school benan um we see Emerson Liberty and wasach particularly Liberty and wasach um because of the boundaries it was those three but particularly Liberty and wasach saw an increase with students that were benan students last year um even though 40 students did not enroll I do want to say that um the mobility rate for 2023 for benan was 41% so um a higher Mobility rate than what we saw at Hawthorne at Jackson new boundaries were divied up
259um or the boundaries were divied up between a little bit to Bachman Newman of course with the DLI program Rose Park and Washington um and uh but we have students that have gone all over their Mobility rate la in 2023 for Mary W Jackson was 31% um and in Riley their Mobility rate also in 2023 was 31% this was just some data I got uh from State website on Mobility rates uh didn't have it written down on here before I submitted it to you but you can see last year's Riley students the overwhelming majority of them are going to park viw good chunk to Mountain View some to Franklin and that's what where they were rebounded to but some have chosen other places as well um our next few slides where are most of the
260current schools with new boundaries focusing their efforts so um for 13 of the 14 Schools I spent one or more sessions meeting with the principal to say tell me what's your hearing what what's going on at the school where are you focusing efforts really have an indepth uh candid disc discussion with the principles I only did it with 13 of the 14 Bruce Simpson that you went got off the hook because his boundary change was really small and he didn't get any new students from that little area so Bruce was probably really happy he didn't have to talk talk with me ad nauseum on this but the other 13 did and they were Troopers and really uh really uh had some great conversations the areas top areas of focus that really we see those schools
261doing um those 13 schools with new boundaries a lot of focus on mtss especially schoolwide expectations and behaviors um integration of new staff uh getting those plc's running even better than ever or sustaining what they already had of course their vision and Mission with new uh staff members and new community members has been an important part and uh four of those schools are implementing a district program new to their school uh Indian Hills Newman and the ones that we talked about earlier uh with the magnet and the DLI programs now um they also shared with me some of the challenges it hasn't hasn't gone um perfect with everything we've had some successes we've had failures um and uh the failures are a good thing to help us learn more and then turn those failures into
262successes so here's um in talking to those 13 princi principles I tried to paraphrase what we spent time talking about and really tried to capture what they said I will say that the four that you see on here were shared three or four times by the 13 principles this wasn't all the principles or even half but it was the ones that we heard that I heard the most um these were shared in one-on-one meetings and um the and the few the principles who spoke had reasons very unique to their schools for for example less District department help that could have looked a lot different at one school than it did at another so it wasn't just a um a piece of that um Dr Grant has that information and and um you know as we
263see these challenges we're addressing needs and some of the information that I'm not getting into specifics on with you all was just Personnel related and the challenges of a lot of changes that have happened at school I wanted to end on a good note of a real positive note of what how they worked successfully to build their new communities I'll say to every one of those 13 principles had a lot to say this wasn't some things I heard two or three times these were things I heard up to eight times things like building a new culture with community events and family nights was been a huge success um students being the adaptable result resilient um so often I heard you know the students get it figured out a whole lot quicker than the adults they
264can make they make friends they make those connections we see that happening over and over again in our schools we see more parents involved at many of our schools with new boundaries getting involved in SEC PTA so it isn't the same person doing 20 different things on the PTA now it's they got they've got some hands to help them out and um this last one I heard over and over is hey we got a new school or we got a new teacher from one of the closed schools and some of their students came to this school and it was just a nice connection for those students to have a familiar face maybe it was uh teachers assistant maybe it was the teacher themselves but I heard that over and over again as well uh and
265there was the the quickest version I could do right there and want to know if you have any questions for me well done yeah for these are the all the numbers from October one not just for theil area thank you okay so just uh one of you had said hey can we see it all and it was easier to show you in a hard copy than to put on a slide okay Brian just a quick question and that was when you were going through the Four elementary schools and where those children ended up going in each one of them you would say down at the bottom 40 didn't enroll in our district 28 or whatever it was um I don't remember what each of them were but to me it added up to probably 120
266or something like that do we know so that number um did add up to I believe it was 155 okay out of those four schools again what makes it really difficult to know exactly is mobility rate at those schools ranged from 5% to 41% so that that I obviously had an effect um who goes to private school vouchers who goes to Charter Schools we don't have we didn't have that information from this data because all the other districts with Charter District Charters haven't reported that to us had or to the state completely yet they're usually about a year behind on that but what we don't know is just how many moved out of out of Utah how many went um we had out of- bounds students um last year that may have said I'm going
267to go back you know we came up here from gr going to go back to M yeah we don't know where exactly they went but we do know that Mobility rates impacted that to some degree as well as people moving I just one followup so my question was or my follow-up question do we have a way that we have kept track of just who those people are so we could follow up with them and see now that you know we've kind of gone through a year and maybe they'll see that oh yeah things are working out out and they could come back or I mean I I just don't want to lose the ones that weren't moving out of the district or sure just a way to um embrace them Sam would know more about
268the specific information on those students but probably layered with the school voucher situation going on too yeah it is yep we see okay so no I don't but we don't have you know here this student um I I think that addresses maybe phone numbers would be an easier way to contact because people tend to keep phone numbers more than addresses um you know if someone was renting a place moving things like that thank you yeah and mine's not a question just more of an emphasis on the positives that you pointed out um for example just how great it is that we have more classrooms or grade levels that have more than one classroom my older children were in a situation they only had one classroom and um it was very frustrating at times and led
269to people wanting to leave the school because there really was no option so it's fabulous that there's such a dominant number of uh grades that have that now um and then just another emphasis on um the schools that received the teachers in the communities from the closed school so my boundary school was hathorn which closed and my youngest is placed at Highland Park Elementary for her situation and Highland Park received two wonderful teachers from Hawthorne um and received the principal from there in the community um and one I'm ecstatic that we got the two teachers we got they were like just wonderful um and the increase in the SEC participation like you talked about we now have a PTO instead of a PTA more participation there it's really been a great um I mean Highland
270Park Community is wonderful in itself but just to reiterate and affirm that what you're stating is actually happening it has really been a great um process to see on the back end as painful as it was thanks for sharing that yeah change is so difficult and we've had community members principes teachers students uh just say yep it happened now how we what are we going to do to make this challenge into a a success for us and a lot of our community members have done that questions for Brian uh one you mentioned that the students made a it was an easier transition for them than the than the adults so what would you hope the adults would would do and and certainly that's a from the principal perspective that it it is the majority of
271students some still struggled as we know but it um it has been um I think I think students uh yeah Embrace that adventure and that newness and that opportunity and feel less threatened by it they've been through fewer changes fewer experiences so in in a lot of ways every year is new to them at least in these younger grades so um they're still given things a chance and I think that's what I really love um to see is that the majority of the students are making that change which means the majority of parents are supporting that at home as well they're going home and having those conversations like I I think that um as tough as this has been this I mean four schools is a lot and it's hard and I wouldn't wish it
272on any District to go through what we went through but I do think we're coming out the other end with more uh looking pretty decent not perfect we still have some things to clean up but the potential just to get better and better with it a lot of a lot of Hope still super anything you want to end just Brian thanks for pulling all this together and doing an kind of after action report that way sure appreciate it sure thank you everyone thank you thank you packed a lot in we'll move on to our action agenda uh we have I guess technically four items there we have um the consent agenda items that um were asked to be pulled and mo to action and then we have options on the fields for West High and
273of course anything associated with that import um Ashley do you mind if I start with you on the consent agenda items no um it's my understanding through our business administrator that the three purchase and accounting reports that I wanted to pull to ask questions are not urgent and so with that lack of urgency in mind I would move to table items 1 A 1 C and 1 D from the posted consent agenda all right is there a second second and since it's a table it's not debatable so we'll go ahead and start with a um with a roll call vote starting with um Brian Brian Jensen yes I'll support the motion I need Clarity afterwards but I'll support it brce Williams yes Charlotte 5 Jefferson yes a yes Salazar no mohamed's out um that motion
274passes uh we'll move on to the second I guess the fourth item um which is the the previous move from the field space for West High rebuild to the action agenda I'll entertain a motion to that move that the board approve option to relocating all athletic fields to the West Campus based on the estimated cost savings presented to auxiliary services by the architect and contractor additionally auxiliary services will provide further input and cost estimates for temporary fields to support High School athletics during the rebuilds I'll second got a motion a second on the table uh let's open it up for discussion before we take a look any discussion to the motion just simply I support that approach I think it's wise any other discussion all right seeing we'll start with a roll call vote uh
275with Amanda Amanda Longwell yes Bryce Williams yes Charlotte F Jefferson yes a Anderson yes Niar yes Brian chenson yes all right that motion passes um that concludes our action agenda we'll move on to superintendent ba and board member reports just a short one that every elementary school has to do testing mid year and what's impressive is that in this last um testing window that um there is a requirement that elementary schools have to have 95% participation in the testing so that it's a fair measurement of the school it's a a big bar to get over um all of our elementary schools tested 95% of their students which is impressive and um that takes a lot of work because these are students who are absent yeah who have other classes that they're running into and out
276of also um five schools had 100% actually Beacon Heights Edison and sign Indian Hills and Newman in some different categories so um kudos to those who are managing the testing in this last round do you have a Baer I'd like to give my book report on War and Peace for the next 45 minutes I have nothing who put you up to that Alan I made it up on myself okay um board member reports uh Charlotte do you have one this evening um just that um we have been involved in a joint The Joint legislative committee and um you know trying to test to like give comment or um to support our our public education and it's been a a real uphill battle and so that hasn't been very fun um I'm I'm disappointed that legislators
277don't listen or or value the expertise of superintendent and business administrators and school board members all over the state they you know um basically ignore and don't consult the experts so I wish they would consult the experts thanks Charlotte Brian do you have a report oh yes just um I talked about the science fairs um last time but I just had to say I went to the high school science fair at Riley Elementary and I have decided that I need some of those students to be my science instructor they are incredible it it was really wonderful to see what those students are doing and then finally I would just say um board president and I are going to be sending out another doodle poll because I really do think that it's important for us to
278work on this training so that we can address um how we work on our questions and I think that we saw how we got some processes started here but we need to have a discussion and it's really helpful to know that Tuesdays off Tuesdays are not an option so I would just ask no one getting out their calendars if we do a doodle poll and we put on some Wednesday are Wednesdays doable are Thursdays doable which during the day Wednesday works for me during the evening both of those days can work for me Wednesdays or Thursdays during the day during the day okay before 3 not in the evening just put a range of options okay we'll put a range of op options great I give like 10 options this time see if we can
279land there Helena do you have thanks Brian I was going to say um there were some focus groups on selecting a new principle and just like the criteria that um people would want at West High and so there were three different sessions one for parents teachers and students and one parent made a very interesting comment of how um every night there were Spanish language interpreters but each night they were turned away because no one was utilizing them um and then also for the student group I think only two other students showed up and we dragged some in from the hallway but um that was interesting to me and then also um at a recent sic meeting it seems that from what I've heard teachers are recepted to District supports for added security positions and looking
280into like an external evaluation of security needs and um what we're doing right and what needs to be addressed as well so that seems good and then for the usbe um student advisory Council we will be going to the um to the state legislature to speak on student mental health firearm safety and devices in classrooms thanks Ashley um yes I have one item of business which is to ask that the two items I referenced earlier be attached to the minutes um and then I have a couple items in the pleasantry Department can you clarify those so one of them was the email you sent with questions on an attached PDF and then the memo that the finance committee sent in December okay um of course and I again had a few pleasantries to share which
281is last week I was able to visit the high school art show at the Springfield Museum of Art where West High had 14 entries which is so many accepted and many of those won additional honors including purchase by the state legislature and our congressional representative and on the tail end of those recognitions were also great theater performers es History Fair judging undergraduate presentations on the tunnel at waset Elementary Book Fairs School Community councils neighborhood councils and I always appreciate the opportunity to be involved but I also want to invite everyone um Thursday is the first playoff game for women's basketball and I don't know if you know Jenny seea knows that West high is undefeated and I really enjoyed going to their senior night game with one of our usbe Representatives Sarah reel and they
282are having an incredible season and you should support them on Thursday at 6 p.m if you can thanks Ashley um I'll be quick um one thing I just want to say I appreciate the opportunity uh to participate in sxie Bryant's History Fair a couple weeks ago um both Ashley and Charlotte were there as well and that was a really cool opportunity um there is a History Fair coming up at Northwest Middle School and they need some judges you should have an email about it um if I were not out of the country I would totally be there so I'm encouraging the other board members to participate and then the second thing really quick um kind of echoing on what Charlotte said as well the um the legislature not trusting the voices of superintendent business administrator
283and school boards I'd also add uh teachers and administrators to that pool as well so thank you thanks Bryce Amanda mine is an acknowledgement and an ask an acknowledgement that we do need to get some training to improve our efficiencies and my ask is that as things are tasked to the board um they are tasked clearly and correctly and concisely from the get-go so that um we can efficiently effectively get to it quickly I personally I want to put quality time to these things um so losing that ability to because I've lost time imps my ability to be effective so just as those are coming through make sure that they're like I said clear concise quality accurate and then I'll do my best to do my job um I've only got one report um which
284is that Brian and I will be um attending a training for board presidents and vice presidents this weekend on Saturday um in at Neo in Spanish Fork so um Brian I will make sure to report back on the experience and what that was like um to the board um that concludes the reports um we did have um some time allotted for a close session but I think we can go ahead and push that to the next meeting so we can go on and get out of here um so with that I'll go ahead and adjourn the meeting thanks everybody thank you for