001all right thank you everybody for joining us this evening um everybody in person and everybody who's uh joining us online today is January 7th 2025 we are here for the purposes of a school board meeting with the Salt Lake City School District Board of Education um really excited tonight's an exciting evening uh because we have the opportunity to perform the or of offices for four board members two new board members and two board members who won reelection so this is a super exciting day uh for Salt Lake City School School District as uh as we start a new chapter with the board um the first thing that we'll do um is also welcome and recognize our association presidents uh for the classified associations we have buildings and grounds who are represented by President Ayah OKO
002for Child Nutrition we have President Tanya Slaughter for transportation president Chris krogue uh from the Salt Lake Education Association SLA we have President Mike Harmon and vice president chelia Costa um and then from slasa the president is Adrien labado and they are represented by Shane Mansfield um who's with us this evening um up next on our agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance and we have Naim bade who will lead us in the pledge Naim let's get going I pledge alance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation God indivisible with liy and justice for all excellent thank you Naim you got to you know how to project that's really good thank you you're welcome and manners too Muhammad what can I say you know
003um the next thing on our agenda is the administering of the oath of office uh we have a representative from Salt Lake County Nikki vug gopal who's here to lead us in those Oaths um we do have uh vice president Williams who's joining us remotely um so uh Nikki take it away Bryce is on the screen and ready to go you ready Bryce I'm ready okay wonderful um so we have your oath of offices we also have your election certificates that you'll receive today um and we will have you sign two copies of your o of office so that the clerk's office can file one copy and you can retain the other um and vice president Williams we will have you um we'll figure that out on a later date thank you so are you
004ready to take your oath of office I am perfect please raise your right hand and repeat after me I do solemnly swear that my full name is state your name I do Solly affirm that my full name is Bryce Williams I swear to support obey and defend I agree to support obey and defend the Constitution of the United States the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the state of Utah and the constitution of the state of Utah and that I will discharge the duties of my office and I will discharge the duties of my office as Salt Lake City School District Board member for Precinct one as Salt Lake City School Board uh member for Precinct one with Fidelity with Fidelity congratulations thank you congrats Bryce um our next um of office
005um from Precinct to is Charlotte F Jefferson Charlotte would you please uh go to the podium and and uh stand with Nikki we can do it there or do it to the side okay ready MH please raise your right hand and repeat after me I do solemnly swear that my full name is I do solemnly swear that my full name is Charlotte F Jefferson I swear to support obey and defend I swear to obey know obey support and defend the Constitution of the United States the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the state of Utah and the constitution of the state of Utah and that I will discharge the duties of my office and I will discharge the duties of my office as Salt Lake City School distri District Board member for
006Precinct 2 as Salt Lake City School Board member for Precinct 2 with Fidelity with Fidelity congratulations I'll have you sign this thank you told he Charlie if you wanted to take a congratulations a minute just to introduce who's here with you and how excited you are that'd be awesome okay um yeah um my name is oh speaking in the microphone oh okay get used of that and where am I looking um my name is Charlotte f jepperson as I just said um and I am really excited to be here here to do this important work of um improving and and building upon our strengths and our assets um to to improve the educational experiences and outcomes for all of our students um I'm it's I take that job very seriously and and I have so
007much respect for all those who came before me and all those um all of you who have been doing this important work and um so I am leaning on and learning from those who have come before me and um I have much to learn and um I look forward to to doing that and working with you all thank you one more photo okay with the flowers absolutely congratulations thank you all right U moving along um to precinct number five board member Muhammad B yese raise your right hand and repeat after me I do solemnly swear that my full name is state your name I do solemnly swear that my full name is Muhammad B I swear to support obey and defend I swear to support obey and defend the Constitution of the United States the
008Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the state of Utah and the constitution of the state of Utah and that I will discharge the duties of my office and that I will discharge the duties of my office a Salt Lake City School District Board member for Precinct 5 as Salt Lake City School District Board member for Precinct 5 with Fidelity with Fidelity congratulations thank you a very top l okay and here's your certificate thank family oh yeah oh yes absolutely forgot yeah two thank you thank you [Applause] mam there anything that you'd like to say as well there anything you'd like to say the floor is yours yeah I'll say um as you all know uh my name is Muhammad bade and this is my second term and um you know words are
009not enough to express my sincere gratitude to the support of my family because without them you know at a times of stresses I don't know where I would be you know probably I would have left the country by now but with their strength and their love I'm able to be here and I'm here actually for a purpose of making sure the dream of Education will always continue to be the crown above the heads of every kid in our district I came to this country to make a dream come true and I am seeing that happening as I'm looking my two kiddos out there one of them is a senior this year and the other one already graduated and to me there is nothing that we can do in this world and my little one over
010there he just looked at me as I forgot about him um yeah he gets too much attention at home so he's good yes and so he is in the sixth grade and and and words are not enough to express the Gratitude and really looking forward for another term of working together for a purpose of making sure our kids are getting the best education and to the family thank you for [Applause] coming right to our last oath of office precinct number seven Amanda longland raise your right hand and repeat after me I do solemnly swear that my full name is I do solemnly swear that my full name is Amanda MC Longwell I swear to support obey and defend I swear to support obey and defend the con ition of the United States the Constitution of
011the United States and the constitution of the state of Utah and the constitution of the state of Utah and that I will discharge the duties of my office and that I will discharge the duties of my office as Salt Lake City School District Board member for Precinct 7 as Salt Lake City School Board member for Salt Lake for Precinct 7 I was doing really good until doing great with Fidelity with Fidelity congratulations [Applause] pictures blood RSE what do you guys want pictures few pictures the two of you can do it and then more I made it one more for me there you go [Applause] and then what are we saying I guess I can do it in my thinger here yeah we okay I I'll I'll do a you Charlotte how about that I'm fine
012with winging it um I don't know if I can be as eloin a Charlotte there and even though my daughter gives me a lot of bunk for always having too much to say I feel like whenever I'm in these situations I can summarize it really quickly um I'm grateful to be here I am excited to see what the next level of work I can do to try to impact positive change for all of our children um I've been advocating in many different ways over the past eight years um and so this is kind of the next step in that Journey um and trying to make a positive difference in our students lives so I grateful for the community that's rounded rallied around me and supported me I'm grateful for my family who uh and all
013honestly I would not be here today if it weren't for their unconditional support through all these years so um cheers to four years and hopefully many [Applause] more right um Nikki before we go I did want to Circle back to Bryce Bryce I think the virtual meeting element threw me off but if you had anything you wanted to say um as you begin I guess this is technically your third o of office um and a full fouryear term so thank you for sticking it out and going the distance and in running multiple races um yeah much more than I'll be brief um just want to thank um my family my neighbors all my support systems uh quite a few people changed their plans at the last minute to to watch from home and not be
014there uh at the district office but um definitely did not want to share this viral infection with anyone so I hope you all can appreciate that um but just very grateful for the opportunity to um serve another term this time for a full four years not two twoyear terms um but just again thank you I'm excited to get to work and um to continue the work thank you thanks BR and if I may uh president Salazar congratulations to all of you and thank you to each and every one of you on this board for stepping up to be leaders and serving our community so on behalf of the clerk's office thank you very much thank you thank you for being here thank you excellent um the board uh does have a need for a closed
015executive session and I will entertain a motion to to move us into that I can do that thanks Brian I move that the board I move that on January 7th 2020 25 that the board go into closed executive session to discuss the character professional competence or physical or mental health of an individual a second all right we got a motion and a second on the table any discussion all right seeing none uh we will start with a roll call vote uh with board member 5 Jefferson say board board member five person yes Ashley Anderson yes Nate Salazar yes in order moham yes Brian Jensen yes who do I come after you're after me Amanda Longwell yes R Williams yes all right that motion carries we'll go ahead and move into our uh our conference room
016next door thank you all for coming and if you want to stick it out you're more than welcome to thanks thank you [Music] thank you all Li Liz you conratulations [Music] [Applause] [Music] not e [Music] all right thank you everybody for um allowing us the time we're going to reconvene um our school board meeting this evening um if we could please have your all's attention again thank you everybody the Salt Lake City School District Board of Education is reconvening its public meeting host a closed session uh the next item on our agenda is um the election of board leadership positions uh the first um item on the agenda item a is the election of the president of the board for the term of the office of January 25 through January of 2027 I'll entertain a
017motion I'd like to make a motion that we elect uh or Nom yeah no I'd like to nominate Nate Salazar for board president thank you Charlotte I accept the nomination and we'll seek a second I second second all right we have a motion and a second on the table any discussion to the motion all right seeing none we'll start with a roll call Vote with um board member B Mohamed yes Brian Jensen yes we need to have like a prompt up here or something Amanda Longwell no ryce Williams yes Charlotte F Jefferson yes Ashley Anderson no Nate Salazar yes that motion passes the next item on our agenda um Item B is the election of Vice President of the board for the turn of office January 2025 through January 2027 I'll entertain a motion and
018nomination president Salazar um I would like to nominate Brian Jensen as board Vice President we have a motion Brian do you accept the nomination yes I accept the nomination is there a second to the nomination second Ashley is the second any discussion to the nomination and the motion all right seeing none we'll start with a roll call vote Amanda I'm going to make it easy on you long I vote Yes Bryce Williams yes Charlotte F Jefferson yes ashy Anderson yes Nate Salazar yes moham no Brian your vote oh yes I vote for myself all right that motion passes congratulations to myself and Brian Brian if you would like the vice president's seat is yours and I'd appreciate if you moved on over [Applause] grab your stuff here okay oh all right and uh Bryce when
019you're able to join us uh post what you're managing right now with uh with your health um we'll have you assume the position that Brian just left um on the Das here okay all right thank you so much thank you for your service too Bryce um I think that warrants a round of applause from from all of us all right um superintendent looks like we have some recognitions this evening um national board certified teachers turn the time over to you we do and desie Olsen who oversees this program for us is going to come up and introduce our teachers and really um first of all we have a group of amazing teachers here today to celebrate with this and I just have to say um how proud I think we all are to be the
020district that represents the state in this when we're talking about being a flagship district with with excellent teachers this is what we mean and um so I appreciate you as teachers being here uh tonight and for the amazing work you've done in order to get that national board certification and excited about what it means for your students too so thank you desie thank you good evening and thank you to the Salt Lake City School District board members and the Salt Lake Education Foundation for supporting and recognizing our new and renewed National board certified teachers also known as nbct recognizing NBCS is definitely a highlight of the year and we appreciate your recognition of their hard work and dedication to Bringing excellence and Equity to every student every classroom every day for those of you who
021don't know national board certification is the highest teaching certificate a teacher voluntarily pursues it is a process grounded in rights or excuse me in rigorous and extensive Teaching Standards and requires a teacher to demonstrate clear convincing and consistent evidence that their practice meets these Strate standards and has a positive impact on student learning to achieve national board certification teachers complete four components which address a range of practices including content knowledge differentiation of instruction classroom environment assessment literacy and professional learning ncts must renew their certification every five years demonstrating their continued professional growth and how they continue to meet the nbpts standards over 70 teachers have now achieved their national board certification while working in our district though many have retired today we have 46 active NBCS in our district and the largest number in Utah
022we [Applause] currently we currently have 23 national board candidates with nine nbct acting as mentors who play a critical role in supporting candidates as they navigate the Intensive Pro process to achieve certification if I could I'd love to share a quote from an nbct in our um one of our NBCS and they said national board helps me be a more reflective teacher it made me be more intentional about what I do in essence it helped me transform my teaching practice from a skill-based practice knowing how to write assignments and assess students to a professional practice that engages students in learning and elicits deeper thinking from students so this evening I am thrilled to present to you seven new NBCS and five renewed nbct our newest NBCS are Carrie Caldwell from Hillside [Applause] Aubrey Gamble from
023[Applause] Highland Loi LLY got me from Mountain [Applause] View Janette Huffer from Indian Hills Amanda Pasco from Uinta Rebecca Richardson East High School and Jennifer R wasach our renewed NBCS are John author from metalock PA bakerton from Mountain View Anna Christiansen from Clayton Macy cook from uent and Laura Nelson East High [Applause] School and I'd also like to thank all the principles and others who are here to support um all of these amazing teachers oh no it's okay this is show you're good first this is it you're good can everyone move to the left a little bit just a little bit more three more steps taking over okay congratulations all right thank you and congratulations to all of our national board certified teachers uh for all the work that you do um for our students
024and our communities it's it doesn't go overlooked and we appreciate everything that you bring to the table for our kids uh moving along in our agenda uh we have the consent agenda and I'll entertain a motion regarding the consent agenda I'd like to make a motion um to approve the consent agenda with exception of items c um a I mean sorry six A and B um to pull those for discussion because I was not participating in those so I want to be able to abstain so I move those to discussion um and approve everything else on the consent agenda okay thank you for that Amanda and um that means that we'll have to um address um item number six a b and c is that correct um on our action just item oh do I
025have the updated one I don't have the updated whatever's under six that yeah so item six includes item a November 19th 2024 R revised oh yeah B special public I going to do a wrong one yeah so we will revisit those um on the action agenda for your request second we have a motion and a second on the table um any further discussion to the motion Ashley um so I just wanted to point out based on our meeting discussion from December that last year we did miss the boat four times to respond to board member concerns on technology purchasing which is represented here and so I want to be sure we note that this request was made and supported several times in 2024 and was also indicated that was necessary by staff so we should
026honor those requests on the next agenda similarly the reported request exists for the school Financial reports which also appear here and which there was no dissent for placing them as a discussion item on the next meeting but that has not happened so I just want to clarify that I know we would like to move forward as our first meeting of the year with new board members and limited discussion but we we do need to take time to honor those um multiple requests that have been made appropriately Amanda um I do want to uh make a point about the solake city Corporation um request for increase in that contract um I did uh Email Allan and he gave clarification on it and correct if I'm wrong but ultimately with it being such a large increase um
027they're going to be looking into um if this is a long-term increase cost or not so we can decide um how to move forward with that so I just wanted to point out for the community that that is being um discussed and evaluated thank you at least in the future it will appreciate it all right um oh Brian sorry I'm used to like looking over there for you Ashley I appreciate you bringing U those two points up I think uh I was one of the ones that had requested that as well and had a note that we could get um that on the agenda the um report on technology and I think that that's critical and we've also talked about the schools as well thank you thank you superintendent do you feel like you have
028clear Direction on the requests that have been made that um that meting on a future agendas um yes and what I think I'd like to do though is to clarify by email what the topics are to make sure that's right I wrote some down at the last meeting about that request and what you wanted to know but I want to just confirm that that meets the expectation so let's do that over email to confirm what those look like Ashley and Brian does that work for you as the two requesters so that works it was more than us but yes for me okay y thank you for that go ahead and call the the um the motion to a vote um so that again just to clarify the motion Amanda it was to approve the consent
029agenda while pulling item number six a b and c to the action agenda okay thank you for that um we'll start with a roll call Vote with board member Anderson Ashley Anderson yes Nate Salazar yes Mohamed yes Brian Jensen yes is it my turn yep Amanda long well yes Bryce Williams yes Charlotte F Jefferson yes all right that motion passes um our next item is the request to speak um we don't have any signups for this evening so we will go ahead and move on to the reports agenda um the first item on that agenda is the annual comprehensive financial report revised I'll turn the time over to business administrator kley thank you uh here so the Sol city school district has contracted with Squire and Company to conduct our independent uh audit of our
030financial statements and I'd like to invite our Auditors forward from Squire uh we have Dave Brown and Thomas Hazel or Hazel uh please come forward up here um they presented in a a detail report to the board finance committee at the end of November and now they're going going to have a more summarized report of the financials to the complete board and then they'll be open for any questions that you have after their presentation so Auditors go for it thank you appreciate the opportunity to be here tonight spend a little time just discussing uh the results of our audit for the year end of June 30 2024 as prbly been mentioned uh Allan did mention that we met previously with your audit committee um and so that was done in November uh this will be
031more of a summarized overview of things so we'll be quite brief um I believe you do have copies of the financial statements themselves either electronically or in hard copy or both um I probably won't speak directly to those unless tonight unless there are specific questions um but I want to just talk about overall just the things that uh we do and uh the results of that um first and foremost as Alan mentioned our primary responsibility is to audit the financial statements and to issue our opinion on those financial statements um the opinion that we've issued is a unmodified opinion is what we refer to sometimes it's called a clean opinion um but what the actual opinion says is that in our opinion the financial statements are presented fairly in all material respects in accordance with
032generally accepted accounting principles so I always say that's the best grade we can give as Auditors um overall and that's an a grade so I want to talk about two other things um the second the the first of those two would be uh the other audit that we do it's a what we refer to as a federal programs audit or a single audit what we do specifically there is make a selection of specific Federal programs and the expenditures of those programs and then we uh select programs to test that's done kind of on a risk-based approach uh we follow uh uniform guidance um in doing that so Federal Regulations uh they have what they call a compliance supplement we follow that supplement and perform specific audit procedures in various areas specific to that we pull
033transactions we review those transactions and we look at other specific compliance areas uh the the programs that we tested this past year um were the Child Nutrition cluster and also your education stabilization fund money or the co funding that you received um over the last several years I'm happy to report that we're we've issued unmodified opinions on those as it relates to compliance um in addition to the compliance testing that we do we also test controls over compliance and we're happy to report there that there are no findings or question costs that uh we identified and need to be reported so again in a grade specific to Federal compliance and and our testing of federal programs the last item is our state programs audit we do that in accordance with the state Auditor's guide that's
034issued by the state auditor's office um again there we look at specific compliance areas um budgetary areas um a number of different things cash management is another example uh you do a fraud risk assessment each year we look at that and test that um do various things our our process there too is to issue an opinion on compliance with those requirements uh We've issued an UNM modifying opinion on compliance there as well so again an a grade as it relates to State compliance any questions on any of that that we've covered vice president Jensen uh yes so we have the the full yes um report here but I am looking at the one that was online and I haven't had the opportunity to familiarize myself with everything that's in the bound one but at the
035beginning it talks about financial highlights uhhuh and I was pleased to see that um expenses were 22.5 million less than the generated in taxes but the thing that was um pleasing to me as well is it looked like there had been if I'm reading this right expenses were down a lot more than they were in the previous year is that what that's telling me yeah so what he's referring to specifically is in what we call the Management's discussion and Analysis and its highlights I might I would mention here that as we talk about highlights what we're talking about statement wise are the uh government-wide financial statements themselves as opposed to the uh fund financial statements um the government wide captures things such as capital assets for instance and says those we put those on our
036balance sheet it also identifies and recognizes debt so there's differences between the two the the fund financial statements are more on a budget AR basis if you will and it kind of describe describes those there but uh specifically to your point yes if you look on the page 20 of the document itself it does compare two years worth of information there specific to those government-wide financial statements so you can see 2024 as well as 2023 um the revenues in total and the expenses in total and so overall total expenses for the year were 374 million as opposed to 359.06 um and again that's on a government wide perspective um a better flavor maybe for you to say how did we compare to what we plan to do might be to look at the budgetary statements
037okay so that was my next question where do I go okay yeah so if we turn to let me find that as I'm speaking here um if you P turn to page 34 of the document this is the statement of revenues expenditures and changes in fund balances the budget an actual for the general fund um and so you can see it shows a column with original budget final budget then actual and then the variances so specifically total revenues the actual amount was 303 m753 three um for the year um which was we budgeted 307 million and so we were less than what we budgeted in the revenue Side by that 4.1 generally we expect that from the standpoint of when we're talking about Federal expenditures typically we'll budget as if we're going to spend the
038whole thing but timing typically doesn't necessarily work out that way and so a lot of times where you're less in revenues it's it's going to be in the federal and state area due to just the spending of those and the timing of that spending um if you want to look at expenditures specifically that's down just a little lower there final budgeted expenditures were that 317 921,000 and we actually spent 295,000 and so you have 2 22.6 there's a positive variance there compared to what you budgeted so okay so that's where coming from it is okay yep thank you for your work Alan questions this evening yeah I might just mention that yeah this document takes a lot of effort we do our part and say we audit it and we issued our opinion we do
039some assistance in helping and reviewing and doing those things but uh just want to commend everyone that's involved Allen and his staff all that they do to pull this all together and to help us do the job that we do in auditing the the numbers and the financial statements that themselves they they do a great job and we appreciate the help that we get um Ashley since Brian you've already spoken and then come back again the I just wanted to it's not a question um I wanted to clarify for the board members who are new and joining us that when we do our committee assignments which we'll start to talk about later on the agenda this is a report that the finance committee goes over also prior to Squire presenting it to us to make
040sure there are no like big clarifying questions or missing parts and so if any new members had questions and you know Squire goes about their business and they leave this meeting um they that you can ask any member of the past finance committee um for details on things that were not clear to you and Alan's really good at breaking that down if that's something you have questions about whether or not you're placed there thank you Ashley br I just had one other comment and again it was under the Highlight section and it talked about um that we had an actual increase in student enrollment this year it said 74 students I believe um I think that's exciting we're just barely under the 20,000 as I was reading that is that I know you can't predict
041well I'm asking you to predict do you think we're stabilizing a little a I think there's a page of predictions there is on page 25 um in that same mdna we kind of project that out for the next five years but kind of to answer the question I think one year of slightly up is does not a trend [Laughter] make we'll hope so we'll hope so what page was that again page 2 five of the document oh yes thank you excellent thank you are there any other comments or questions for our colleagues from Squire all right thank you so much for joining us it's always a pleasure to see you at our at our table and um I missed meeting with you guys when I was on the finance committee so thank for all that
042you do for us and Al thank you for the work that you do as well I mean I would just like to invite particularly the new board members but any board members because this is a 100-page document and here in a a little presentation talking about government-wide and fun financial statements um happy to meet on an individual or small group basis and really kind of go through the details of this document and help uh you understand what it means and then as we get into the budget cycle which is coming up um hopefully it we can paint the picture so it all you know you get budget you get actual and it all fits together and everything makes sense thanks for saying that Allan and I would definitely encourage not only our new board members
043but all of us to go and spend that time either in small groups or one-on-one with Allan um Alan and I talk about budget from time to time ourselves and and it's been very beneficial um because it's not my strong suit so I'll be scheduling some time with you again Alan and then another thing that I think would be helpful in the back is a statistical section which gives 10year Histories on a lot of these it takes these exhibits and gives a 10e history um if you want to see Trends um spend some time back in that um statistical section thank you Al all right thank you Squire apprciate time appreciate it thank you U moving on to our discussion agenda um the first item there is board training um we have two things to
044go over this evening um as we do traditionally when new board members are sworn in and certainly part of our requirements as a duly elected board um item number one being the open and public meeting act and be annual board member required disclosure so um superintendent I Believe Miss Kindle is joining us for this stream yep thank you I'm not clear who decided to torture board members with first Auditors and then an attorney that sounds not good this is going to be a cure for insomnia so [Laughter] I did it and it didn't do it it it worked what oh look at me um so as board president Salazar indicated um state law requires that you be annually trained on the Utah open and public meetings act and then also we're going to go over
045the new requirement for elected board members to annually complete um an interest disclosure um so if I can the open and public meetings act I know for a lot of you this is just a repeat and a reminder but we do have two board members who are new and might not be as familiar with it so I will go over quickly all the old requirements um things that haven't changed things that you're very familiar with and some of the new things um so the basic rule for open and public meetings are always to make the public aware so that means giving at least 24 hours notice of the agenda date time location um post in the notice of your agenda um and we do that at the district administrative offices um it used to be
046that there was a requirement that we posted it at our main site now it's just the place where the public can walk by and see it and we've chosen to do that at ourain office um and Al also we have to post it on the public notice website and annually you're required to adopt um a meeting schedule um and of course as some of you may know that can change you can add board meetings to it but it is expected that you annually um adopt a schedule with your intended meetings for the entire year so um what's new in the past year is the requirement that all School boards have um public comment in their board meetings um that was not something that all School boards across the state were doing previously um we have
047always had in this District um this board has has always allowed public comment in their business meetings um the carve out in state law is for work sessions um those are what we traditionally call study sessions um and emergency meetings that you don't have to hold public comment there um and the state law also required that we adopt a written policy um regarding allowing the public to not only come and verbally present public comment to you but also to submit written comments um and the board adopted um changes to its B2 administrative procedures for school board meetings there's a whole separate um the administrative procedures are specific to participation in board meetings so it outlines how the public can come and speak as well as um submit written comments for public comment um so what
048is a meeting um and this of course is not new but when a quorum is present for the purposes of reviewing or discussing or receiving comments from the public about an issue that is within the scope of your Authority that you're likely to act on um it's most likely going to be a meeting um so this includes workshops and executive sessions um and we'll talk a little bit later about when four board members are communicating how that might be seen as a meeting um but there was a state law that was passed last uh legislative session that clarified that um you know a chance or social Gathering is obviously not a meeting um when you're convening only for the discussion of administrative or operational matters that is not going to be a meeting because no
049formal actions going to be taken um so for example um you know new board members who came in um if we had a large number of new board members or old board members were meeting with new board members to talk about these are your benefits um this is sort of what we do that's not going to be considered a meaning that would violate the open and public meetings act but um the house bill 36 clarified also that if all of you were to attend say um an event you know that SLE was holding an event this is just a hypothetical to dedicate a track and the members of the public were available and you were all there too that's not going to be considered a meeting that would violate the open and public meetings act
050that doesn't need to be noticed um so as long as the um Gathering is an event that's initiated or hosted by someone other than the public body and um the public is welcome as well and there's no action taken as a public body at that meeting um you are all eligible to go and that will not be a meeting um and um uh and the rest is the same so your should be good so electronic communications um we've talked about this a lot um when do they amount to a meeting um board members need to be very careful when you are communicating electronically through email about matters that are likely to come before the board so you need to be thinking about whether or not you're communicating about official business whether or not this is
051something that a vote is going to be taken on and whether or not you're communicating as a quorum so by that I mean four of you or more or whether or not through a series of rolling Communications like that you keep forwarding and adding people on um that a quorum would be established um typically we aren't trying in any way to dis um dissuade you from sharing information so obviously if you get an A informational item or an article you'd like to share or something that's just informative um you can certainly share it with all the board members we're not trying to discourage that in any way it's just um the communicating and trying to have discussions about something that really should be um held in a public manner because the public part of the
052open and public meetings Act is is to have transparent public discussions and so um the public wants to hear all your deliberations those should not be taken through email that the public cannot hear and that's really the idea behind this so are you is there evidence that you're trying to circumvent the law so um be cautious because it's most likely going to be held to be a meeting if a majority of the board members are participating in the communication um it becomes one of those Ser serial or rolling quorums by your including more people in your Communications um and that you're using some sort of electronic communication method whether it is email texting um instant messaging to express approval or disapproval of a matter that's likely to come before the board so avoid the use
053of reply all copy or forward I know that a lot of times board members just BCC everyone so if there is a reply it only goes to the sender it does not go to the entire board um so BCC is something that you can use Christina what was the last one there no trying oh sorry it's just not trying to discourage sharing information that's what I already said so an emergency meeting so an emergency meeting purum to state law is a meeting that you can hold without complying with the 24-hour notice requirements that is what uh emergency meeting is so if you are able to provide 24 hours notice it's not an emergency meeting so um just to be clear about that so an emergency meeting is when there's it's such an urgent or unforeseen
054circumstance that you can't give that 24-hour notice so some people think oh well this wasn't on our schedule we need to hold a meeting it's an emergency meeting no it's not an emergency meeting unless under the law unless you can't provide that 24-hour notice so the law is very specific um in terms of you have to give as much notice as practical practicable if you're not going to meet that 24-hour requirement you have to attempt to notify all your board members and a majority of the board has to approve holding that meeting so electronic meetings um within the past year there's become a new definition of an electronic meeting um currently the an electronic meeting is defined as any meeting in which one or more board members participates remotely um so as some of you
055may have seen on our board agendas we have an AS that says this this meeting may be an electronic board meeting because um sometimes um certainly not to pick on uh board member Williams but unfor seen things happen and someone has to appear remotely or through electronic means and so um state law would consider that this is an electronic board meeting even though it's just one board member so um also in accordance with state law if we we hold an electronic meeting in which all board members are participating electronically we do not have to provide a physical anchor location um unless there's a written request from the public at least 12 hours before the scheduled meeting so um moving forward what uh those administrative procedures are not online so I know we had an electronic
056meeting recently in which all board members well in which board members were participating electronically we could have not held an anchor location um but we didn't have that process in place and the public wasn't aware of that yet but but this is in the administrative procedures so when they're posted this will be the new requirement that we don't have to hold that anchor location does that make sense yes great um so um as you all may know um we do have to have um public comment and board meetings are open to the public clearly um and we welcome them to attend um but that does not give any member of the public the right to speak or disrupt the proceedings um so in the event that someone was willfully disrupting our meeting to the extent
057that um orderly conduct was severely compromised so for example if the audience breaks out into spontaneous Applause for this presentation that's not going to be a substantial compromise of the the proceedings of this so you know people clapping that's not what we're talking about right you need to have like someone willfully disrupting the meeting and it being seriously compromised um and then we could move into perhaps asking that having that person removed but um that's a fairly High bar um texting during board meetings as I indicated before the purpose of the open and public meetings Act is for the public to hear your discussions so if you are texting during board meeting with other board members about what's being presented or about the vote that's about to happen that is a violation of the open
058and public meetings act um you know obviously if you know you're sending me a text as to my God you're boring um that's not a violation of the open and public meetings act or if you're communicating with your children about an emergency that's not a violation but if you're talking about something that you're about to vote on the requirement would be for you to say that out loud and not text um and I thought oh this is something that I wanted to cover so I went back these slides because I knew I was supposed to say that when you're talking about your emails and text messages for those of you who may not be aware if you're if you're wondering about anything that you're texting as a board member or sending an email as a
059board member whether or not that's going to be considered a public record under Grandma the answer is yes so always always be thinking this is a public record that can be subject to Grandma and for board members who may not be aware we get requests all the time um for board member emails and as part of our process Sam Quant H and his team have the ability to pull those emails for us so we may get uh Grandma requests in which you are not even informed that your emails have been requested and pulled and turned over but you will typically be um informed because a lot of times um they request your text messages as well and we obviously don't have access to those so that is on a um we expect you to comply
060with the law and we ask you to do a due diligence search of your text messages and turn those over um and we have on occasion um been taken to the records committee um when uh the requestor has not believed that board members have turned over the requested text messages um so we just ask that um Jillian Norton would be the one reaching out to you she's in my department to say we've had a request for these text messages do you have anything responsive um you are required to say yes or no so um we would like a response not just well I don't have anything so I'm not going to answer right because we need to be able to say we did our due diligence and that they said they didn't have any and
061and that's what we would respond to the requester is that everybody got that okay um so calling a closed meeting you all just had a closed meeting um in calling a closed meeting you need to call it from an open meeting that's why we always open a public board meeting first and then um a quorum must be present to go into close session um and two-thirds of a vote of board members must approve going into to close session and it must be a proper purpose under Utah code the most common proper purposes that we um use in this district and that you as a board use are to discuss an individuals character competence physical or mental health and the statute is an individual it's not an employee so you might have instances in which you're
062discussing someone else's um character competence physical or mental health that's not an employee but that is allowed by the statute um pending a reasonably imminent litigation um and it doesn't necessarily always have to be litigation in court it includes administrative actions as well um collective bargaining property transactions so the acquisition sale lease or exchange of property deployment of security Personnel devices or systems um and investigative proed proceedings regarding allegations of criminal misconduct those are the most commonly used um there certainly a whole list of other ones that if something came up and we needed to look and see if um you could have a discussion and Clos session for a permissible purpose we could look at but those six are the ones that this board most frequently uses um so violations um if any member
063of the public or any individual felt that they were denied a right under the open and public meetings act because of an alleged violation by this board um they could bring an action in Third District Court um if the violation is found to have occurred and there was any resulting action or vote taken that Vote or action would be undone and overturn and also knowingly or intentionally violating um any closed meeting Provisions is a Class B misdemeanor so um obviously there's the component of knowing or intentionally violating um so an inadvertent violation wouldn't be a Class B misdemeanor but anyone who was knowingly doing that would be okay great um the conflict of interest Financial disclosure previously we have had a conflict of interest disclosure that board members have um sometimes chosen to fill out
064if if um they want to be transparent and they feel that they have um some sort of financial interest or another position that might cause a conflict of interest but it's always been voluntary and there has not been an annual requirement that every board member filled that that out um with the last legislative session there is now a requirement that every board member before January 30th fill out an annual um Financial disclosure um so obviously board members um comply with our board policy P1 which outlines our ethical standards um it also requires compliance with the public officers and employees ethics act um but the disclosure that you were going to be required to well you were now required to fill out um is intended to prevent board members from being placed in a position where
065their interest um as a board member conflicts with any pecuniary interest that they might have or that any member of their family might have and it is to avoid the appearance of a conflict of interest even if no conflict truly exists so House Bill 80 um requires um the conflict of interest for newly elected board members to be um completed between January 1 and January 11th of the year after being appointed or elected and each School Board member has to complete the conflict of interest disclosure within that same period of time um we are going to be sending that to you as soon as this meeting is over you will be receiving it via docu sign it's going to allow you it's fillable so you can just type in all your answers um if you
066failed to complete that disclosure the special filing officer who is your business administrator Alan kersley has 21 days to provide the board member with an electronic notice of deficiency so um within 60 days of your submission uh board member uh sorry business administrator kley I don't know why I was about to say board member kley I'm just I'm whatever okay within 60 days of that deadline uh business administrator kersley will review all those disclosures to make sure that they are complete so when you're filling them out um one of the things that I'm going to recommend is that even if you have a section that you feel like is not applicable to you that you at least put in not applicable so someone knows that you have read it and that you are saying this
067is not applicable and not that it's just left blank right that that you were affirmatively saying there is no disclosure here um because one of the issues that we'll get to is that these disclosures can be challenged for completeness but what you have to disclose um your current and recent Employments as well as that of any spouse or other adult living in your household um any entity in which you are an owner or officer any public employer business entity or person from which you may receive $5,000 or more in compensation You Must List each entity in which you hold any stocks or bonds having a fair market value of $5,000 or more and you have to list any entity in which you currently serve or served in the preceding year and a paid leadership capacity
068or in a paid or unpaid position on a board of directors so any other disclosures that are necessary and that is supposed to be a joke about a shoe size like that they don't ask for your shoe size but you know maybe you have to be much older than all of you are to understand the Sho size but at your option you can provide information regarding real property you own or have an interest in or any other matter you believe May constitute a conflict of interest just as like an example um for the community and for the public while it's never come up but if it were to come up um say Dr Hall needed a specific action taken by the board that impacted the district's work with the say the Salt Lake City Public
069Library my employer I would more or less say I'm going to bow out of the discussion and the voting um to maintain some impartiality um within my two roles and positions with both entities is that that's correct and you'd obviously put Salt Lake City Library on this disclosure right and any other um if you have multiple jobs and and you're going to receive more than $5,000 of compensation you need to list all those so what is done with the form so again this is a new requirement the forms are going to be placed on the district's website and will remain on the website until you leave office Additionally the lieutenant governor will be sent a link to the electronic posting for each of your disclosures and so are penalties associated with these conflict of interest
070disclosures um if you didn't file one or it isn't complete or there has been a complaint made alleging that it isn't complete um business administrator kurley has 5 days to notify you of the failure and request that you complete the deficiency and you will have seven days to correct the problem or explain why it's not an issue if you failed to correct the deficiency you are guilty of a Class B Miss demeanor um and business administrator kley would be required to report the violation to the attorney general um business administrator kersley would also um is required to impose a civil fine of five $100 on you and have that money deposited into the general fund any questions I'm ending on a high note I can just tell okay I have a question sure um and
071I didn't see that it was clear clear in here but for individuals like you're a 401k there's a high likelihood you're going to have more than 5,000 in a particular entity depending on how much you've got invested so um I guess how detailed are we going I my expectation is that um what they're hoping for is more detail more detail than less detail I mean obviously um you know it it talks about stocks or bonds so that would be Pro your 401k and so um it's it's unlikely that that's going to create a conflict of interest but I I would a on the side of a fuller disclosure as opposed to less and that's why it's it's a expandable fillable docu sign form that you can put everything in there that you would like to
072thank you sure business administrator kley do you disagree with that in no but I think on that case you would just put like 401K managed by company X and you wouldn't have to list out how much is in it just say in excess of $5,000 in a 401k managed by this investment firm or Utah Retirement System or whatever be more friendly yeah y any other questions about this yep so just be looking for an email that'll come from DocuSign at at the end of the day and if you have any questions then um the emails Sam worked on the form so if you have any questions or have problems with the form you can contact Sam or the requirements of what needs to be put in the form you could reach out to either Alan
073or I okay thank you moving along to item number two which is the annual board statement of ethics um let me pull that up all right and I'll go ahead and turn the time over to the superintendent and the business administrator so according to the board policy B1 there is a statement of ethics for the Board of Education it's there in the cover sheet on this EX in this exhibit pulling that information from B1 each year the board decided that it wanted to review and re reaffirm I don't know that that needs a vote as much as just a kind affirmation from board members so I'm not sure the best way you want to review this you know um I think the best way is for um you know either myself or the board members
074we can go around the table and kind of read each um bullet point that's here um we've done it a couple of different ways in my experience where we have taken an affirming vote um to to solidify our our acceptance and acknowledgement of the statement of Ethics um and we've also just kind of verbally acknowledged it as well and I would leave it up to the board to help us determine um I think with a new board um kind of where we're at right now I think it would be good personally as the board president that we we do affirm that through a formal vote in action any other thoughts or opinions on that for long one I would be fine with that I would uh just out of clarity are you wanting to go
075around and state that out loud and then follow it up with a formal motion um we could um or we could honestly we could move it to the action agenda and you know either I or Brian or we could go around the room and and and read it out loud but I do think it's valuable that it is read out loud for the Public's sake and for for our continuity moving forward with our ethic statements so would we say it out loud before we move it to action or move we probably move it to action and read it out loud there and I would with that does anybody else have any other preferences so moved okay I will second so I me I think what we're we're doing and just for um kind of a
076training sake in the moment um our board practice the last couple of years has been that um we honor the discussion agenda and the action agenda of each board meeting and so what we would do for this instance is since we have a motion that that you made and Ashley moved it as a second um that we would move this to the action agenda and take it up then when we're done with the discussion point of order I made the motion and am man to seconded EXC thank you sorry for the mixup there um except the point of work appreciate that um but nonetheless um that's kind of the the practice that we've been involved with or engaged with the last couple of years that makes sense okay um any discussion to the motion okay
077and just to clarify this would be to move the annual board statement of Ethics to the action agenda we'll start with a roll call vote seeing um no need for discussion here um we'll start with board member bade mam yes Ryan Jensen yes Amanda yes Charlotte yes Ashley Anderson yes Nate Salazar yes and Bryce I I can't see the screen if you're still with us but uh um but if you've moved on Sam do you know if Bry is still there okay he is there he is GRA you were we off the screen and and off of the the speakers here um we were voting to move the annual board statement of Ethics to the action agenda um do you affirm that with a yes or a no vote Yes okay that motion passes and
078we'll revisit that um on the action agenda um moving along to item number three uh review of board committees again I'll turn this over to superintendent to the VA um what we've provided here is the list of current committees with current member participation there on the um exhibit on the agenda uh the plan was when we did the agenda setting that this would be a first conversation about the Committees and then we would have um that selection believe the board president assigns but you've done things differently as a board you've kind of come to agreement together um so we have that um set up for the next agenda as well to follow up if needed so you could either take action or not tonight um and you'll note that in there um in the memo
079that board member or U business administrator kley dang Allan I think you have a new role you did County back to your s that's right um that there are there were previous board member attendants on the human sexuality education committee the Salt Lake County Recreation Advisory Board the traffic safety and transportation committee and the wellness committee um at this time there are no requirements for board members to attend those and so to simplify your lives we suggested that maybe you wouldn't want to put a board member on but we leave that to the board to decide what to do one those things thank you superintendent I already shared some of my thoughts with the superintendent about this but I wanted to raise a couple of things and the first is about human sexuality so as
080the superintendent pointed out the latest iteration of state board rule no longer requires an Lea board member to sit on the committee but I did want to note from my past participation that we're not seeming to be currently compliant based on rules about parent attendance in the same board Rule and I think it's important if we do opt to dissolve board participation that we ensure measures for the board to determine that compliance which remains our charge I think that board member participation was one way to do it but it should be replaced with another aspect in the annual report and I mention to Dr Hall that I don't raise this because I'm dissatisfied with the meetings led by the staff I think that they are great meetings and they're very productive and I think it's
081very hard in the current moment to get enough modalities to include parent voices and on human sexuality it's just our job to include parent voices so if we need to find new ways to lead those meetings we should do that whether it's us sitting as part of the committee or otherwise um I do think it would be a mistake to leave our role on the wreck board and here's why um I think as a parent of student athletes our relationship with the county is very important especially when it comes to Aquatics and specific types of fields I think the relationship is going to be more important as high schools are rebuilt and we may require support from the county to ensure continuity of Athletics during High School rebuilds so with some of our designations already
082dipping to 4A this year I've heard a lot of growing parent concerns about sports and I don't think we should grow vacate that cons or grow grow that concern by vacating a seat we have at the table I think if the issue is that past members have been disinterested I would be happy to attend that committee um I would also suggest that committees could have more routine updates in our board meetings for instance as RDA designes last year we weren't invited to the city council leaders meetings that were mentioned on the on the spreadsheet until the week of the meeting and that really wasn't a sustainable way to manage our participation um and I also think that the wellness committee I enjoyed sitting in on that because I learned a lot about the USDA smart
083snacks regulations that are really coming up as not being followed in almost any of our schools that I'm part of and so I want to continue talking about maybe it's not the best practice to have a board member sit on the wellness committee but I learned a lot by sitting in so perhaps it's about welcoming board member participation I think as we streamline I want to honor that I've never heard from a single Community member that they want less board member participation in what they're doing I've never heard from Educators they want to hear from board members less or see them less present in committee I actually hear that they want us to be more involved so I think well is this substantially disruptive um I think as as we try to manage that challenge
084it may be that we move to dissolve participation but we reframe what participation looks like rather than just having a seat thank you board member Anderson any other comments or questions I will say Amanda I was just I couldn't remember if I already spoke on this one so I wanted to pause before I inadvertently attempted to dominate I just wanted to say that um Ashley's points were very well put and um I support a lot of what she's saying so I don't really have much to add to it but very poignant and very much should follow up on those aspects of it sure um yeah I I agree with Ashley that it's important to have a connection with the county wreck you know committee um I in fact a long time ago I helped uh
085get the swimming pool built so that West High could I mean I spoke at a board meeting you know in support that I didn't make I didn't build it anyway I am in support of that and as I was a swimmer in high school and softball player um I think that's really important thank you um I would like to note um what the superintendent mentioned in the beginning we've also done this a few different ways um but I would like to note that um Utah code 53g d425 requires that the board president um appoint all committees um which we have like I said done in varing ways but I think in order to streamline this process to be ready and prepared for the next two weeks I would like to take that on on um
086with vice president Jensen and present with you our roster if folks are amable to that I would think it's highly important though to be uh well within the bounds of um Utah cod as we move forward with these committees any objections or concerns about that Amanda so what I'm hearing you say is that you want to assign us um basically would you permit us to submit our um preferences preferences absolutely and then you can take that in consideration yes when would you like that buy as soon as possible when you say that I'm not clear what you mean because none of our participation is outside of code AS code doesn't it tells us what we have to do but it doesn't tell us what we can't do so what would your response be you're saying
087streamline them as written regardless of objection to that no um what I'm suggesting is that UT to Law requires the board president in this case I would move that to board leadership that they appoint all committee members and assignments what but what I'm not clear on and what I would think others might not be clear on is the superintendent has essentially recommended a limited set of committees there's been discussion about whether or not to limit those committees so what would you be recommending that board members fill out or what is your response to the concern about limiting committees or additionally making you know having a discussion about our role on any committee yeah based on the discussion tonight it appears that um the Salt Lake County wreck committee is a strong desired participation that there's
088that there's a desire to have participation from a board member on that committee and so I think because of the number of folks that spoke in favor of that we should do that um but regarding the other elements like the human sexuality um I think those are decisions that we should make at the next meeting um I think Brian and I could certainly prepare a roster but we should definitely make sure that we are prepared to um participate or not participate in the recommendations from the superintendent and the ba in the in the cover letter yeah we can do that some changes yeah we can do that talk about it um so just to review and I don't know if Sam if you could pull this up to show on the screen so the community
089can see what we're talking about um but board member assignments through 20 23 through 24 so this was our last iteration of board committee assignments um I'll wait for to pull that up sorry Sam perfect um I'll just read these out loud um so for the first one that we have here it's an elected position a usba region 5 representative which has been Brian but it is also my understanding that will not be a position available to us Brian do you want to elaborate on that please because we have fallen below the 22,000 or not 22 the 20,000 cap on students uh we will no longer qualify um to be an individual representative on that board so we will not need to be filling that position yeah I think we were probably the founding member
090of that organization thank you Brian for that clarification um one that we should maintain in my opinion is the usba delegate assembly um currently we have Ashley Anderson and Muhammad um both of them play a role in making sure that they attend the delegate assembly when those meetings are there um and also that they vote on the usba priorities we've also um had alternates as you'll see right there and basically it was just everybody on the board um who would be able to attend in the absence of either Ashley or Muhammad um but I do want to thank Ashley for your participation in those you were always there which is really exciting um so that would be one that we would need to keep as well um board committees um the kind of three main
091ones um our board policy committee which consisted this last go around of board member Jensen board member sea vice president Williams at the time um and then their sole purpose and responsibility is to draft update and edit board policy um and work in coordination with Miss Kindle the district's General legal council um to make recommendations to the board for for new policies and of course new administrative procedures along with those new policies or updates to those policies um there's the ad hoc board handbook committee which consisted of board member sweat at the time board member sea and um currently vice president Brian Jensen um and their responsibility was to draft um update and edit the board handbook um also under the supervision of the general legal council Miss kall and there's a recommendation from Christina
092kall to just make the ad hoc committee part of the policy committee the the policy committee itself would be the ad hoc board handbook committee do you want to think that's actually what's in the board handbook now the changes that were made to the board handbook so it's it's not a recommendation that's how it's already so this one we wouldn't designate separate people for that it would be the same people on the policy committee so we'll make a chart that's actually got those together together so that when you appoint people to the policy committee those same people would be on the ad hoc board handbook committee oh and the school choice it functions as the school choice appeals committee as well thank you and um and I think for our next discussion superintendent it would
093be good to outline um both of those elements um okay in the duties and purposes um just so that we're clear about that okay um the next board on our list is the charter school boards um that was conduct it had Bryce Williams and Christy sweat on there and they just represent the board um at those meetings I clarify something on that I mean Spa would obviously be dissolved as Spa is no longer chartered by the district and I want to point out I have a lot I represent the area in which OC is house and OC's chartering documents do not ask a board member to serve so the way this list is created is by the charter the chartering documents and what that charter school has asked for by way of board participation so
094in this case it would only be determining if um Bryce would like to continue a sxie because it's obviously part of his Precinct or if a different board member needed to take that on or was interested thank you Ashley um the other um more significant committee um for the board is the board finance committee um which saler yes general counsel is oh there is there that was only because we were still over spot there is no board member on slicky or OC so that's not a committee that will be necessary um thank you for that clarification and thank you for catching that for me um the next um is the finance committee which consisted last time of Ashley Anderson Christy sweat and uh board member bade um and again that's an internal audit function review
095of annual audit and the annual comprehensive financial report provide recommendations to the board about the form and content of financial information and serve as Legal Financial service advisory committee um to audit reports um under the direction of of Allen and and that collaboration um thank you da kley for doing that yeah there um and then some of the discussions that previous board leadership had is maintaining some continuity on each of these committees particularly the board finance and board policy to make sure that there's at least one of the remaining board members who is on those committees to still be on that um committee so that's something that Brian and I can take on and present to you um after as well as we get your recommendations on where you would like to sit ideally um
096thank you I was waiting for when it was appropriate for to inter check that to me that's uh critise agree I agree um we just talked about the human sexuality education committee um as we know that consisted of um board member Anderson and board member bade um in per our discussion already there is a recommendation to move off of that board but also a request from board member Anderson um that we have a more substantial um annual report or update from the ongoings of that committee is that correct Ashley I mean the request that's is specific to whether or not we're in compliance with the board rule so board rule changed to no longer require a Lea board member to sit on it but board rule also requires a specific number of parents an equal
097number of parents to District employees to serve on the committee and that has not been the case in my participation so the request in other words is about that specific compliance measure rather than the other things that they're required to report on um superintendent what's the best way um through um the you know through your work as a superintendent in collaboration with your cabinate in legal services to determine that compliance um element that Ash is bringing up um it has historically been a hard one because we've got teachers on the committee too and they have certain hours they work those don't often overlap when when parents are available and so we've had difficulty finding time that works for both of those entities on this committee um Dr Hall do you have any recommendations on this
098one or we we do have four parents that have been recommended by their principles um at their schools and that have committed to attend than we do employees and the board did approve that list that had one more the attendance of parents as you said um we it's interesting some years are different than others but we have usually always held this meeting at this same time at four o' and we have had participation in the past but the issue is as you said we also have to have our School nurses or our counseling Representatives or our health teacher representatives and so that becomes the difficult balance um super do you find it reasonable that we could sh up um kind of a a clarification on the compliance elements that we're discussing tonight for our next
099discussion yeah thank you um does that work for you board member Anderson yeah okay thank you um let's see the next thing here um is representatives to the City Council meetings historically that has been um the role of board leadership in the RDA design um and moving along to the second you underneath that is the RDA designes which historically the last couple of years has been board member sweat and board member Anderson um and I think also some continuity with that would be important too Ashley and um that's something that I would advocate for as well um the Salt Lake Education Foundation board has historically been um slotted for board leadership um in order to maintain some kind of continuity with SF and to report back on the ongoings there um because there are a
100lot of initiatives that impact um not only our work but the districts overall work as well in in the as the financial arm of our school district um and so we can we can look at that as well um the Salt Lake County Recreation pointy that was something that I took on I did find it hard to manage both um slef and the recreation board as oftentimes the the meetings for sleth and the rec appointed board um conflicted um so I would I would not want to do that and Ashley thank you for for stepping up and throwing your name out there um to participate in that um the next one is the traffic safety and transportation committee which consisted of board member Jensen board member bade and vice president Williams at the time and
101the real responsibility and purpose there is to work with the city to address traffic issues um near schools and address Transportation concerns um I believe this is a bimonthly U meeting um but it's also one that's being recommended for us to to move away from and just to let you know Isaac AEL is our head of of auxiliary Services attends that meeting with the city yes okay can can we clarify the reason why we're recommending we move away from it I recall it's been stated before but I I'm if I'm a Community member listening to this I think you want to meet less about Transportation concerns but superintendent you've described in the past how there's actually different functions here and why that community no longer serves an intended purpose so could you explain that yes
102if I remember correctly you're help me out Alan thanks yeah let me jump in there there's two Transportation committees and I think there's been confusion in the past there's one that's really that our transportation director Kim Martinez meets with principles to discuss District you know busing and other Transportation issues specifically related to The District there's this city committee that a board member has historically been on that discusses more Citywide Transportation issues and not specifically for the district now those two have gotten confused over the past of thinking they're one and the same and they're not um the committee we're talking about here is a city run committee and the owner of that should be changed from Ken to Isaac on this so we'll put Isaac in there does that make sense okay for B yeah
103so I did attend uh some of those um meetings and frankly uh they were very very useful because the fact that you know I know my schools and I know how they are around and the safety and traffic around them I mean it was really actually essential that I presented my own you know uh uh bias of course as a school board member to make sure that safety is addressed around the school like putting uh those flashing cross signs and yeah that that thing you know and also uh making sure that you know the traffic light it's not taking too long to switch during the during the uh school hours and things like that so I really think personally um stepping away from it is going to be a little bit uh you know it's
104going to be a loss for the board especially for us to be able to pinpoint things as we hear them from our community and so that's uh my take on that for thank you for that I have I just did want to clarify so we would Isaac would still be attending those as so we're not we're not stepping away as a district from the committee we're just saying we're going to have a district employee be the district representation on that versus an actual board member we have Charlotte and then Bryce um I have I was asked to attend um a meeting that came up it's sort of an emergency type of it's not an ongoing meeting right with with Jennifer new um and the at glendell and Mountain View so there were some there's some
105safety issues there with kids um walking to school or being dropped off at school and so I would you know but there are city city officials there there school board there's School District people and I'm happy to continue um attending that um so that was in that case Charlotte you were invited as a community member so yeah not as a board member so that that would be up to all of you we were getting Community input as well as Community Council input so people that Liv in the community and knew the community and Jennifer was that an ad hoc meeting or was that this Transportation committee no it's it's totally it's it's related very different than that so it's a separate thing than that it's a separate thing we now have these this small kind
106of a small team now this is a little bit bigger one at Mountain View that will support schools so we'll go out the city compliance engineer me a couple other people will go to the school and they'll tell us what the issues are and then we'll work with them to support that thank you brce yeah the one uh can you hear me first of all yes no oh we can hear yes yes you can okay sorry um the thing I wanted to say about this uh Transportation committee is I actually think it's a good idea to have Isaac um be that person I've been assigned to this committee for two years and was not invited to a single meeting despite being asked to be invited so if there is going to be board representation that
107um will need to be figured out um just wanted to share that thank you Bryce Amanda um kind of to hit a little bit on what has already um but so the school secs one of the things that they evaluate are safety issues which Transportation can lap into that and then um the light in light of board members not being there but not necessarily knowing exactly what the concerns of are of each school for the community members including sec's how do they get that information up the chain so that it can make it to that City discussion so it can be taken into consideration because you know there's there's layers here so if it's only making it to District it may or may not make it to City to be a well-rounded conversation to address
108those issues in those areas so you know the the default answer to that is usually always send it to the superintendent because then what I will do is send it to Isaac so he has that information from the SEC so SEC chairs at any time can share that kind of information uh and then I can direct it to the appropriate staff that can follow up or share that with the city or something and it's a great suggestion I would just say if it could be communicated um to the district to the SEC players so to speak um yeah the the SEC this the community members Etc just kind of those two those two different is and how to get that that input into making it to the city as well as the district what you
109basically just said um because yeah we if we're sitting here discussing it it doesn't necessarily make it down to those School communities to relay that information up I think that's good in fact you know what I'll do I'll um put that on the agenda we meet with the SEC chairs I meet with them four times a year so we have a meeting somewhere in the next couple of months let me put that on the agenda too thank you thanks Bri so I saw Jennifer n's hand come up and I've been sitting here thinking we have a wonderful resource right here yeah and I know that we have used you in the past with SC sec's I'm thinking specifically of the tragedy that we had at Bonville and how you were able to work with us
110on an SEC level on a district level creating meetings where parents were able to be engaged and um the the resolution that we saw with the flashing lights the speed bumps I mean to me that's a good example of where it was effectively work you so Jennifer I think that you can speak to this you're a valuable resource and Jennifer would you mind speaking into one of the microphones so folks from the community can hear you mind but I have a teacher voice I don't need a mic but the folks at home and online need a mic okay sorry I just wanted to say that my understanding is that Transportation committee at the city level that we're talking about it doesn't just address District issues it's a broad piece so to have District representation is
111fantastic there are a lot of District City things we can work on together and so that's why I kind of I saw the need and started putting some people together so we have been working with schools kind of starting this process where like I said the engineer and the compliance um person will come will go together we'll talk to the school um there's um I think they're going to be somebody appointed from the school district as well to be there just to say let's look at this holistically how we can how can we support these issues I've been in conversations just today with um Adrien kumik at um at wasach about that and we're working with with other schools so there is a process for that and I can share it even more clearly but
112we're I feel like at least as far as I know this is better than it's been in a long time in terms of like seeing how those pieces work together and advocating um and also collaborating um Jennifer one thank you for all that you do for us I have a question for okay I thought you were dismissing Me Maybe it's outside no I'm dismissing you but it might be um outside of the role of this um of this committee but as you know we have um two new high school rebuilds that we'll be planning um here in the next little bit um would this committee also kind of manage some of the needs and requirements that that um we would need to be in concert with the city on for road closures and um making
113sure that all those things or is that a separate entity that would be separate because Isaac is managing the his team will be managing the rebuilds that we talked last time with Jennifer when I meet with the mayor one of our conversations was about this and the request that um we have Isaac working directly with department heads at the city um to coordinate those functions so um yes that's how we want to do it around the build and we have a proposal for that that I was going to after my meeting with Dr Taylor was going to email you about so we have a proposal for that but this was sort of born out of the collaboration that we we had working on when the School boundaries changed and we had kids crossing streets that
114they hadn't crossed before Etc so then we worked directly with our engineer Lynn Jacobs he deserves us a total shout out in our community neighborhoods but he and his team did an overhaul basically checked out all the every single crosswalk in the in the city where school kids cross um kind of did an analysis of them repainted them and so it's Lynn that we've been working really closely with so that's when it kind of moved in towards well here's a crosswalk in front of a school and here's some issues at the school at pick up and drop off time and so just kind of getting smaller committees to be working on things like that right I would just interject as well that you have been really helpful with the crossing guards as well and coordinating
115efforts there and I mean when you're talking about those new traffic patterns with children and I mean the anxiety that was occurring with do we have to and I know that that's a challenging um position but thank you for your help with the crossing cards of course I'm going to continue to beg for more yes and they're in good shape I just um met with Bobby today or and Bobby who's over that he's the crossing guard coordinator they have 75 and they're looking high they have six more ready to be hired oh that's great so they'll be up at 81 and it's it's great we just a great team of people that are also really interested in collaborating with each other and with the district and the yard signs are awesome too pardon me the
116yard signs too oh thank you yeah sorry I I think we're just at a better place than we have been in the past with crossing guards yeah agree thank you all for your support thanks thank you Jennifer for all you do um I'm going to move us along to the next um committee unless there's other things that we feel like we need to talk about um yeah it's just you know would love if we could like get like an update for example uh like just knowing what's happening because it is so fantastic to see so much work happening behind the scenes but it'll be so great like if uh I receive a call from from one of my community people and they are like oh you know the safety in this area it'd be great
117to let them know you know this is happening you know and it's going on because just an update for us would be fantastic uh because after all you know we are responsible for those kiddos and their safety of going to school and back and is that if the board so chooses to move away from this committee yeah okay y absolutely great and what would the frequency of those updates look like for you I mean I look to the board we all decide on that yeah so great um Isaac moving along um Wellness committee which is also being recommended for us to move away from um previously board memb sea and our student board member um participated in that um purpose to enhance learning and develop lifelong Wellness practices for children establish a healthy school environment
118reduce childhood obesity and prevent diet related chronic diseases um that was um kind of chaired or Le the representative supervision from Kelly Orton um part of our Child Nutrition um I guess he's our director over Child Nutrition um and I think superintendent I would also just kind of to similar questions what is the where did the recommendation come from to to kind of move away from this one again in an effort Trying to minimize the impact of board members time uh if there's no requirement then the committee will continue to do its work uh reports back to to the board of of the committee's work uh I think is a on all these committees is uh definitely a good thing whether it's an email report back or a public meeting report back either way I
119think both both methods could be effective um so it's just really trying to free up board members times in areas that maybe it's where it's not required by law sorry um I referenced this committee earlier because I said we don't follow many of the recommend ations that that Wellness committee reproduces um you know not year-over-year but close specifically the USDA smart snacks guidelines those are just routinely not followed in any school that I participated in um there's been robust discussion about whether to relax those standards the committee has agreed they want to keep the standards but we don't Implement them so the thing I think we need to toggle is not whether a board member is sitting on that committee it's how we reckon with the fact that the committee's recommendations and our board policy
120are not being followed um and how we address that report um I think I learned a lot by listening to it and I think there are other committees that exist in our district like our sustainability team has a Seal Team committee they approached board members about joining it we decided not to add it to the list of things I think there needs to be a decision made not about the things we sit on but about all these committees exist that we don't sit on where we miss out on information that we may have an interest in hearing whether we have an interest in attending the full committee every 18 months or bonly or every four years so the question is is not about the committee per se it's about how we address when those practices
121and requirements really are not followed in school I appreciate oh sorry um just on that note I've worked on um other things that ultimately um win the practice of if a committee um implements a um practice of at the end of their discussion if they have something that they would like um an action to occur or a report back by so if they get in this habit of reporting to the board and they're requesting something whether it's a follow-up or information or just providing like kind of creating supporting some kind of creation of these committees putting together a recommendation letter or a um a update letter to the Border who relevant whoever's relevant in that proc process um to get that information communicated back up the chain and actually make those conversations um more relevant
122um versus just talking to each other because that's the worst form is when you're in a meeting and you're just talking at each other with no subsequent outcome thank you board member Longwell I feel like what I'm hearing um as the conversation's gone along um superintendent would you find it reasonable to um as we prepare for the next discussion um obviously working coordination with board leadership to identify positions but also if it is so the will of the board to move away from the recommendations um of the Committees that we you're recommending we move away from to um Identify some timelines or frequencies of what those reports might look like and um a calendaring of when we might receive those reports so that we can consider that in our work moving forward in fact one
123of the things we were working on today actually as a Cabinet is a um annual reporting document for the board so that we could list some things that have to happen every year and mark the month they happen so we have a little more clarity about that as we're making agendas and things and setting them up so we could add this sort of report and some of these reports as Allan said I think it's important to our board meeting time is precious um we can have short meetings or long meetings um some of these reports can come just in the form of emails to the board that then the board if they would like board members can bring them up and ask that they be on the agenda as followup but the original information could
124just go out as an email so that you have the updates that aren't necessarily taking board time during board meetings to do those so if you're amenable to that we could set those up that way as well I think that'd be great to to look at both options okay for each specific um recommendation of these committees that you're recommend we move away from does that work for the the whole board yeah g thank you um is there any other discussion points um to this agenda item of um board committees all right seeing none um we'll move on to our final uh discussion agenda which is options for uh board meeting structure I'm going to pull up my link here one second Sam's pulling that up too this is all we have there superintendent um this
125is from you to the board um would you please um give us your thoughts there's just been board member discussion individually particularly about maybe looking at a different structure of our meetings um currently we have two meetings a month one of those is a business meeting the other one is a study session with a study session we are meant to not take on much business and yet we often have business that needs to be taken up um more than just once a month um and so with there's that issue of having a standing study session uh we also have um struggled to maybe come up with study sessions that fit the board's needs um in those in situations and then also have looked back um people have mentioned that in the past the board has
126had two um business business meetings a month and added study sessions to an earlier time period like at 4 p.m. if needed as as they come up so that's one Arrangement there are other ways to do this I know and I think some of you have some ideas on that but to present to the board the option of changing the structure of monthly meetings to possibly move away from a business meeting and study session into a different kind of arrangement so leave that to you to think about which of those best serve your interests and the from the district point of view it would be useful to have business meetings twice a month because there's so much business that we're often hampered trying to get the agendas right if we have business outstanding so that's
127the district interest in this but certainly the board sets its agend thank you superintendent um before I open for discussion I'd like to just uh take a moment to make a recommendation to the board that since this is um coming from the board itself um I think it would behoove the board to um either have one of our um committees whether that's the policy committee or the finance committee to me it makes more sense for the policy committee to do it or the establishment of an ad hoc Committee of three board members to formalize recommendations and present that to the whole board um being that this is a request from the board unless you have specific recommendations that the district would like to make superintendent no we do not open up for discussion there are
128a lot of good recommendations that just could be made from the outset um I'm really happy this is on the discussion agenda I've been asking you know since my service began that we have this discussion because board meetings you know pre- pandemic were held in a very different way and often they were pretty effective and I think the three main options that we have to consider as a board are first to return to the Past structure alluded to by the superintendent where study sessions preceded business meetings in the afternoon had an ample dinner break and time for Clos session um which would include our current practice of leaving the boardroom sometimes close to midnight um the second option which was suggested by other board members over the past two years was to dedicate one of
129the Bly bi-weekly meetings just to a study session that could be held more informally maybe in a conference room even if it's still open to the public but provides No Illusion businesses conducted um and the third would be to accept that contemporary work schedules are very Myriad and that something like Saturday study sessions or brown bag lunch study sessions via the web may be another way to capture the majority of board members while allowing business to be conducted um but the last comment before leaving it to the body if they care about those three recommendations or have other ideas about how to move it forward is I think that this type of change would have to work in conjunction with changes by leadership I think some of our agenda setting practices and our use of
130parliamentary procedure kind of discourage functional meetings no matter how we set up these agendas so if you take today's agenda as an example if you take just the discussion items if we all use our allotted time excluding student board members remarks and excluding staff presentations our meeting would be already over four hours so while this agenda includes more boilerplate items that might not get to that 4our Mark it's frequently where we're getting and we leave you know later than I would prefer and I think frankly later than the public wants to listen so I think the Norms we use for speaking time and even roll call votes are much less efficient than some of the pre-pandemic procedures and precedent which made board discussions very effective when I originally began my participation as a parent advocate
131so I think I've proposed three potential structures that work one structure that wasn't talked about is across the state many boards opt to meet only once a month for a much longer portion of the day starting in the morning so they're not leaving super late at night but they are able to conduct all their business whatever type of option we consider it has to work in conjunction with change by leaders or we will not capitalize on any potential changes to the calendar thank you Ashley I would also extend that there needs to be a change from the board Collective as well and that we are I also I agree with you but I'm also under the conten mention that often times our meetings run long because we um end up diving too deep into the
132minutia or into the 10 meeting wasters time meeting wasters um as outlined in usba trainings and coming to order the book that we all receive and I think you know focusing our attention and our priority on board goals on the decisions within our roles and boundaries as a board and the decisions that we are legally bind to make um would also streamline the meeting processes as well and um I would encourage us to consider to to practice um the prescribed recommended um provisions and best practices um through usba trainings that we do receive about maintaining um our attention to board goals to policy and to our budget and further and further away from the the detailed day-to-day minute operations of the district Bryce yeah I wanted to um say that the the first three options
133that board member Anderson um suggested suggested I um can get behind I think whether it's a um the policy subcommittee or an ad hoc committee um that's kind of bringing recommendations forward I would suggest that they keep in mind the schedules of people who have um full-time jobs as well one of the concerns I have is making sure that I'm available and giving my all um to everything it means to be a board member but I do have to um pay the bills and be at work for a certain amount of hours each day and just wanted to vocalize that I think other folks are thinking that as well thank you thank you br Amanda no you're fine it's can't see everywhere um I the only point I want to make is I strongly strongly
134strongly would like to see that we do business meeting every single board meeting two times a month and know we look at doing the study sessions however but I think that's been a contributor to um it taking so long for decisions to be made is that it's only only once per month and then if it's delayed then it's a whole other 30 days and where the school is only in session for so many months we're losing so much like critical time for our students and for the district by delaying otherwise so I vinant or adamantly maybe it's a better word um uh request that that um practice be implemented you guys have heard from me from years about well I don't know it's been years but for quite a while saying you turn this into
135each meeting has to be a business meeting even if we don't make decisions allow that opportunity for decisions to be made so we can move more efficiently and quickly so and I personally would like to be on that ad hoc committee sounds like there's a a temperature for potential ad hoc committee um Amanda you you voiced your willingness to participate but I think the board would have to to give the knot for us to move forward with that um in order to provide um more formal recommendations to the board Ashley I follow committee I think there's an interim step that's more efficient which is um I think that forming an ad hoc committee without knowing exactly what Bryce raised which is the difference of people's schedules it's pretty simple to put together a doodle poll
136and look at some of the main options presented and before finding any committee look at if there's actually just consensus based on a poll um and the reason why the second follow up I would have to say is that again looking at this agenda there's nothing on here that's not boiler plate and not not required and if we use the time that we're allowed we would still be here for 4 hours so again to say taking very seriously coupling changes that are very realistic that don't place blame on board members using their available time thank you board member Anderson would you be willing to put together that doodle pole as the inter room first step I don't think that's my job okay I'm happy to do that and get that done um it would be
137helpful to have the options I'm not sure I caught them all Ashley from you of of what you were suggesting it seems like some are not preferred but I'll just restate all four um the first is to return to the pre-pandemic precedent of having study sessions in the afternoon prior to the business meeting that's the one like the four o'l time and then okay the second is having a standalone study session alternating and that means meaning our first meeting of January would be this is our business meeting our next meeting would be a study session in general what we have now on paper but truly a study session and we're no longer doing business the third would be to say that afternoon time is not going to work for concerns that Bryce raised would people
138rather have our traditional business meetings but convene for even more informal study sessions on Saturdays or at lunchtime when we can do reasonably like a webinar and the logic for this is of course to explain to the public why I care about this study sessions are meant to be informal and we can't have have a study session sometimes and raise questions and take the time we need when we're in this format and there's the expectation of all of you that we're going to take action on these items and when the public is listening for us to make really pointed comments that speak to what their concerns that they've already raised to us as their elected representative so the idea of how to make a study session actually studying a topic instead of a faux business
139meeting the fourth option would be to look at what other boards do this is more common in rural boards definitely where people have very long commutes where they meet once a month and they rattle out a lot more business in a day but they do commit to saying you know I'm taking PTO this day I'm finding child care this day whatever it is the same we many of us do at night to um make sure that we get our business done once a month so those would be four main options that I've come up with I don't know if other people have additional options to share thanks for going through those again should we add an like an other category in the P the doodle and then kind of um time uh constraints or concerns
140so that you can kind of get a feel for each person's I guess realities as we're trying to back into what works I think um based on the sentiment of the discussion um I think it would behoove um Brian and I to work in concert with the superintendent to put that doodle poll together if you're so willing Brian to to help out with that cool we'll put that together and send it out um before the next board meeting for sure thanks everybody we'll move on um in our agenda um to the action agenda which we have two items to discuss um the first being um from the motion on the consent agenda from Amanda to pull um item number six a b and c um for further discussion uh being that you're you're new to
141our board and and wanting more information before you make a decision on that or or either way yes or or no just hadn't attended the meetings I think I remember you saying is that right Amanda I would be willing to make a motion on Amanda's behalf because I think I understood what she was saying which is because she's a new board member she doesn't want to approve minutes for a meeting she didn't attend because she can't confidently approve them so I believe it was her intent and her direct comment that she wishes to abstain um but she didn't want to abstain from the remainder of the consent agenda where she was happy to consent to those items so I would move that we accept the remaining consent agenda items as posted second we have a
142motion a second any further discussion all right seeing none uh we'll call for a roll call vote um starting with vice president Jensen Brian Jensen yes Amanda Longville I abstain Bryce Williams yes Charlotte F Jefferson I'll abstain as well Ash Anderson yes Nate Salazar yes Mohamad yes all right that motion passes um we'll move on to our next agenda item which is the statement of Ethics um I'm happy to to read that out loud just thinking about our timing yeah uh this evening and so I'll go ahead and read that out loud and um before we take a formal um before I accept a formal motion um to accept them um so let me just pull up my link here um all right so below is a copy of the statement of Ethics oh let's
143wait for Sam to pull that up as well sorry go Perfect all right this a little bigger on my screen okay below is a copy of the statement of Ethics section from board policy B1 Board of Education legal status responsibilities and ethics in order to comply with the annual review requirements of this policy board members will review and reaffirm these assurances as part of the discussion on January 7th 20125 statement of ethics for Salt Lake City School Board of Education um members of the Salt Lake City School District Board of Education are elected officials obliged to monitor evaluate and work to improve educational opportunities for children and families in the district these responsibilities require that members of the board adhere to the highest standards of ethical conduct key standards are found in the Utah public
144officers and employees ethics act a common law principles defining ethical duties to this end board members subscribe to the following statements and assurances which will be reviewed and agreed to annually in a public meeting I will represent that the board will that the board with dignity excuse start I will represent the board with dignity and integrity I will treat fellow board members District staff and members of the public with respect and consideration through civil discourse exhibiting both honesty and decorum whether we agree or disagree on issues I will keep confidential all issues discussed in executive sessions including legal action negotiations personnel and property I will avoid conflicts of interests or the seeking of inappropriate personal Advantage as a result of serving on the board I will represent the needs of all students in the district
145while balancing the concerns of individual precincts and constituents I will endeavor to attend all board meetings be prepared and listen to others opinions I will guard the public trust by spending School funds to benefit all children I will function as part of a policym body recognizing that Authority rests with the board in Open session not with individual board members of the board I'll entertain a motion you ask for entertaining a motion I will make a motion to approve the annual wait the annual board statement of Ethics second any further discussion to the motion oh one Charlotte um it was talking about executive sessions is that the closed that is meetings okay thank you Charlotte Brian my only thought is I think it was really valuable for you to read through that Nate but what I
146also think is really important is that we are individually reflecting on that I mean it's easy to read through those bullet points but I think if this is going to have impact or effect you're reflecting and you're thinking okay this is what I'm committing to thank you Brian yes any other comments or thoughts okay we'll call it to a vote um starting with uh board member Williams Ry Williams yes Charlotte F Jefferson yes Ashley Anderson yes Nate Salazar yes moham yes Brian chenson yes I'm Manda Longwell yes excellent that motion passes unanimously thank you board uh for reaffirming that um superintendent and general counsel will you please reflect that the board has completed that um annual obligation of these statement of Ethics that'd be great thank you um moving along um being that there's no
147other action agenda items uh superintendent do you have a report for us this evening I do just have one announcement here that I wanted to share um Governor Cox is um it is taking the oath of office tomorrow and the Pledge of Allegiance will be led by metal larts fifth grader Cassandra Reed at that event tomorrow so glad to see that um one of our students is participating there excellent thank you superintendent um Alan do you have any reports this evening I know uh we don't always have you on the agenda but it's good to ask I do not uh board member reports um for Amanda and Charlotte I know you've watched a few of these meetings but if there's anything that you would like to discuss um in these board member reports um we
148try to keep them to District business or your work and influence as a school board member or your participation in committee meetings ideally um or just cool happenings that are going on um that reflect our work be really beneficial so Charlotte if you have anything you want to say that you haven't said already this evening that would be welcome no just that um with the Committees well I just wanted to make sure that you know I'm happy to do whatever um is needed so um but there was also the the JCL um is that jlc oh jlc joint legislative committee is that um something that a that a board members take part in yes that is and I I'll cover that in my report in just a minute okay okay thank you mam no I
149don't have any report either Brian uh yes um first of all I just wanted to I want to thank our music teachers for all of the work that they do and all of the other art teachers um Ashley the work that you do and I looked at a TED Talk that I received um Michelle MCO um I was thinking about the impact that music had with the classes that I taught at Newman Elementary and it was really delightful for me to watch those students um in our December board meeting from Newman um they wouldn't be able to do that without those music teachers and I think that that's a really valuable part of Education um there were a whole bunch of winter holiday celebrations and they would not have been um possible to the level
150that they were without those music teachers and other um art teachers that are helping with that then this will be my final report to you as a usba uh Board of director um to answer your question there is a jlc meeting that will be this week and all of us are invited to participate in that and I think that those are really valuable and I think that it's important for us to to continue to participate in that even though we will no longer have a a vote and that's part of our usba yes it's part of the usba conference so if you will look at your conference packet what it will tell you is that okay the conference is Thursday through Saturday the 9th of January through the 11th at 300 p.m. there will be
151a jlc meeting of the Little America it will be in the Idaho room um all of us are invited to be there um later that evening there and I don't want to go through take time to go through all of the different things that are in that conference you should have received a packet if you have not received a packet on that email me and I'll make sure that you get one um moving on from that just make a note that um on January 27th that will be the usba day on the hill that's another opportunity for us to participate with our legisl as they will be in session okay um Charlotte that is from 7:30 a.m. to 2: PM okay Monday January 27th um there is also a usba policy webinar that is on
152Wednesday February 5th and those are always just a half an hour and you just zoom into the well it's a webinar so you zoom into that and I would encourage you to participate in those they really do um cover really valuable um issues that board members face thank you Brian and thank you for your participation and efforts on our board of directors at usba you're welcome helina um yeah about the usba annual conference I was invited to attend a Q&A with other student board members throughout the state so I'm excited to do that Saturday morning that's so exting really glad do actually um yep I have two updates as mentioned in earlier discussion I've served as a design for redevelopment project area as and Allan and I need to attend a meeting next week for
153an upcoming project area as part of our role and I shared our draft opinion with returning board members and this topic would be a very heavy lift to explain in one quick report so I wanted to tell new board members if you would like to discuss my favorite subject tax increment financing um I will catch you up as the month progresses but when that meeting is done I will provide a more concise report um at our our next uh business meeting and the second update is that I currently serve um a four-year term on on the assessment accountability policy advisory committee for the State Board of Education and I was made aware from a peer at usbe that there is a vacancy for local board members as well as business administrators as well as community
154members and Educators um for the trust lands advisory committee which is also called tlac as our committees are formed and we had that discussion today consider if you have time to do a service to the state board I found um the assessment committee to be a very valued part of my service and I think that the best way you can can find it is applications are on the usbe website and I can also find the link um send it to Allan so it can be included appropriately in the minutes um but anyone who messages me I'm also happy to share the direct link or you can inquire with your usbe representative but I encourage any board member who would like some additional work to do to consider serving on that trustlands advisory committee especially as
155we've talked amply about you know our trust land training and other matters in our meetings thank you Amanda um not particularly a report but I have um I basically want to Express gratitude to the um community members that supported me and um getting me uh put in this position um I've been able to uh Express gratitude directly to um a decent amount that uh kind of gave me the gumption to go for it um and uh big shout out to the state representative that kind of planted that seat in the first place so just um extreme gratitude for the public that rallied around me and um um putting me here to try to do my best to impact positive change for truly all of our students thank you Amanda Bryce the only thing I'll say
156is I'm really trying to focus on getting better so I can join you all at usba uh this weekend thank you thanks Bryce um superintendent did let me know that she had one more update I did I just wanted to mention we have um kind of a fun celebration set up for Saturday it really is remarkable how Salt Lake District has led on so many things and led on having the first woman's School Board member in the state on the Sal Lake City District School Board and that was Genevieve Curtis and um we have celebrated her in the past as a district but have the opportunity there was a plaque that had been in the Curtis Elementary when there was a Curtis Elementary um and we are placing it in the new district office here
157um we'll have a wall for kind of noting a lot of important uh events for the district historically and so on Saturday um Genevie Curtis's granddaughter and other family members including Senator John Curtis who is her grand great grandson uh will be here Saturday to celebrate with us to celebrate her and uh the plaque in the front hall area of our district so just wanted to let people know Saturday at 12:30 if they'd like to attend just a short ceremony that way to recognize her and and note that historically in our district thank you superintendent for bringing that up and um my understanding is that our former board colleague Christy sweat will be there um for those of you that don't know that she really championed um this engagement in this event and um we're
158grateful for her work even post her life as a board member so um thank you for for reminding us about that and um um we hope to be able to attend with all the happenings this week with USB yeah great thank you um there is a need for um the board to re-enter a Clos executive session um and I would entertain a motion to do so right I move that we oh do we have to say the date yeah um on January okay I move that the board return to closed executive session to discuss the Char professional competence or physical or mental health of an individual and pending or reasonably imminent litigation and that the board adjourn immediately thereafter have a motion is there a second I second all right is there any discussion to
159the motion seeing none we'll start with a roll call vote uh with board member Jens vice president Jensen excuse me Brian Jensen yes Amanda Longwell yes Bryce Williams yes Charlotte F Jefferson yes Ashley Anderson yes Nate Salazar yes Mohamad yes that motion passes thank you so much to everybody that joined us this evening congratulations to all of our oath of office um recipients this evening we look forward to working with you in this new year and the next couple thank you yeah like