CorpusRecord 80458

Clarke County Public Schools School Board Work Session 02/10/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Clarke County Public Schools VA
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Clarke County, VA
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,374 words · about 36 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e m br it didn't seem right for him to be in ax with his roommate it's terrible um good evening I will now call to order the February 10th work session public hearing on the fy2 budget may have a motion um any questions about tonight's agenda may I have a motion please I move to accept the agenda as presented is there a second a second all in favor I I all opposed um Dr balling all right well we'll start by doing is reviewing executive summary one and executive summary one we actually went ahead and the finance office did an absolute wonderful job with this but instead of having three we have four because executive summary one is basically the status quo type of where we're at on the budget but we were able

002to cut a few costs Dr Nell in the office there was able with um some IR ready cost and stuff we were able to get down probably in the neighborhood of a $10,000 reduction it's not much but we have gone through everything again so when you look at executive summary number one you can see the main item probably that everybody would be looking at is under the total general fund tax funding which is the cost to the county the increase to keep everything as is would be 284,807 for working really hard to keep that as minimal as possible um so basically when you don't factor in health insurance salary increases and new positions we're at $284,800 um what beyond that and I will tell you there are some caveats that may make this better as

003far as as time goes on relating to health insurance um for instance when you look at our executive summaries 2 three and four everything is wrapped into those now so those include salary increases new positions and health insurance cost increases we have budgeted as we've done in the past on a health insurance cost increase of 10% that is $3,356 now last year we only came down with a 2% health insurance increase if that happens again that's going to move all these executive summaries down about 250 to $260,000 which would be great news if that happened so I want us to kind of think about things like that this is pretty much as it is but these numbers could come down all right executive summary number two includes the um a 3% salary increase which would

004cost $618,000 and of course it's got the health insurance estimate by the way our health insurance the last information we got is we would have the renewal rate honor before March 2nd so we're getting pretty close but still a while out for that and you can see it includes the $264,400 or 747 for the new positions that we discussed when all that is wrapped in there together the total general fund or cost to the county for a 3% raise is 1.46 million roughly or $1,468 th000 that's the cost of a three % salary increase the next executive summary which is executive summary number three that's the one that has a 4% salary increase which the cost of a 4% salary increase would be $824,000 and that brings the total um increase to the locality to

005$167 million is the anticipated cost there the fin final executive summary is executive summary number four executive summary number four includes a 5% salary increase the cost of a 5% salary increase is a130 th000 bringing the total increase to the locality to $1.88 million now some things that may affect this too and may make this look more positive also Al I neglected to say on that executive summary number one all these include the cost of two buses at $135,000 each um so that's a big part that the fact that we were able to get a second bus the literacy act materials second payment of our world language books in and inre cost in and all come in with a status quo of just 284,000 I think showed some tremendous effort there now some things that

006will factor in to the each of the executive summaries one of them being if our health insurance costs come in anywhere near last year we're going to save a quarter of a million on every executive summary there about at about 250 to $260,000 the other thing that um I included in your um information tonight to look at is the fact that we do not have a cal tool yet for the Senate and the house budget and typically the vdoe and the state don't do c tools for the House and Senate budget individually they wait for a conference budget to become is until that's developed and do one for it now one thing and I've actually been read it in some U media articles is that both the house and Senate budgets are unusually similar this

007year which I think that may lead to a good thing maybe of reaching consensus more quickly they include similar things and actually for operating cost FY 26 they're actually identical for education so what would happen is if you would look it's a document from the Virginia Department of Ed they did a crosswalk um between the governor's budget and the House and Senate since there's not a c tool and said this is the extra funding that localities would get we did include all of it because I wanted you all to see the impact of local Composite Index but this is a file straight from the vooe and if you go over from the Clark County Line you can see when you go about halfway across the page that the things that would be affected by the

008House and Senate budget budget one of them is for food service and breakfast reimbursement and you can see that's $2,222 there the next one is the support cap being completely removed and what that refers to is in 2009 with the Great Recession they cut back on the number of positions that were funded by the state through the standards of quality and that has been slowly chipped away if that is removed and it's in both it would generate $220,100 two for Clark County Public Schools the next one is to um reinstate the local Composite Index cap for early childhood education that will resulting $3 32,4 something6 additional for Clark County and then the last one is just additional special ed funding based on child count and that would give us $ 37,44 so actually when you

009add that up what it adds up to is $292,800 th000 more to the good and they actually have identical budgets for FY 26 for um education so there's no gu guarantee that would happen what will happen now is they'll D they'll draft a conference budget but I think we pretty much can see that we're really close to the conference budget because they're already agreeing on education and then it'll be negotiation between the governor's budget and the conference budget but on two things that could be really positive is if the um house budget were to pass we would be 292,000 to the good there and if our health insurance comes in at a better rate we would be 250,000 to the goodish 250 260 so there you're looking at $550,000 if those two things that could

010happen and that would come off of each of the um executive summaries now and by the way this crosswalk gives an extremely conservative 18 ADM estimate or average daily membership so we're going to likely see more money than this because they dropped everybody's else uh a the membership down dramatically to not get people over optimistic about funding and you can see they have us at 1791 and we're typically around1 1850 so we would actually see more money than that but to kind of get a comparison Dickinson County Public Schools is probably the most similar in size to Clark County but there're else C is dramatically lower they actually have fewer students than us and they're going to get are in the House and Senate budget for um education like I said both of them remove

011and I I think I just showed you all the Senate but for education for FY 26 we also included it as an attachment but for FY 26 the house budget for operating is identical okay the House and Senate budget both remove the support cap give additional funding to education for special ed the differences don't really show up in the operating budget between the two for FY 26 one thing is the house proposed adding 50 million in investment to vrs for Virginia retirement the Senate proposed adding 35 million to vrs but those don't show up in operating cost also the house has added $150 million in extra Construction grants for substantial renovation and Construction in addition to the governor's budget and that's not in the Senate budget but that also would not affect FY 26 operating

012the only other thing is and it's not in FY 26 both the house and the Senate have a bonus payment to Educators based on support staff I mean on standards of quality or so soq and what standards of quality is is the framework of the very very minimum skeletal framework that it takes to operate a school system but both the House and Senate have proposed a $1,000 bonus to Educators the um Senate one is a little bit easier to understand because it's payable by June 1st of this year so that money actually is not any different in FY 26 either because it's going to be back allocated to FY 25 if it happens and we would have to pay that bonus out by June the 1st 2025 now on that bonus it's a no local

013match bonus and does not run through LCI what that means is for every standards of quality position you get exactly $11,000 and the faka for the $11,000 Grant bonus now that is a much more advantageous standpoint to us than sometimes in the past there have been past budgets that run through LCI which would mean you'd only get like 40% of that cost now even though there's no local match though the thing is not every person in our division is standards of quality and nobody's designated as standards of quality or not almost no divisions do that so there is a cost to getting that b bonus access to everyone else but there and it would be they way it was worded it would be that divisions would work really hard to come up with that money

014to give the $1,000 bonus to everybody but if you cannot because it's not budgeted for in this year you could take the total amount of money you got divide it by your employees and give that amount out to everybody now not to get too deep in the weeds the house bonus is the same but it's pay Able by September 1st 2025 which is really kind of odd because that crosses two physical years so we'll have to kind of figure that out if that were to happen other than that I don't think probably too much discussion about the bonus is warranted because it's all hypothetical right now and may or may not happen and that's just something to keep in the back of our mind but it's independent of this uh budget discussion because it's in

015a different physical year here um I think that that is all that there is that has um occurred with the um uh budgeting process since now one thing before I let you all have just any conversations or thought in addition to if the Senate and House budget AV verion of that would pass we would come out much better and our health insurance also I've talked to Mr who is wonderful about really giving back and said that he truly needs two buses next year but that if it makes a difference in getting you know money to our employees and I think it shows a really good effort of taking care of people that he could it' be kind of kicking the can down the road but we could kick it down the road one more year

016and do two buses next year or um if we have any money left over this year how we sometimes request that to be rolled over to Capital we could make it a priority to buy a bus with that money if we have it once we know and that could save you know some cost but that's pretty much all there is so I'll take your all's questions and then let you all discuss I'm open open public hearing on the F 26 budget any comments to speak speak card p no no I will go ahead and discuss question on the uh you mentioned the the uh money that for construction project that's specific for for school infrastructure or is that something that includes other things too it's specific for schools there are no criteria out yet cuz

017it's just in a budget document um the governor has money in his budget for schools construction too that happened last time two years ago because typically other than selling bonds normally the state doesn't get into the business of maintaining and renovating schools it's long time being considered that that was a factor of the um locality to Main maintain and build school buildings I think the history of that is around when road maintenance become a big deal and there was kind of an agreement that the state would handle roads if the locality handled school buildings but two years ago there was a grant program for school um funding but it was prioritized um for divisions that showed that their current buildings were in really bad state of disrepair and inadequate needed to be modernized or brand

018new and um it had to be substantial renovation or complete new construction and it was a competitive Grant and LCI was one factor in whether you got the money or not um not saying that's how it'll be again but there is another round of cons of specific School construction grant funding that's in the governor's budget and it's now in the um house budget to add an additional 150 million over what the governor has if it passes they'll come out with criteria of what it means to be able to access that money and stuff um another criteria last time was it had to be for a building that occupied students for learning during the day like if you had an Athletic Facility it couldn't be used forid or a central office that had to have kids

019for instructional purposes but if it happens what they did last time is Once it's passed they send a to like operations director they sent a Grant application out once it passed and you had to write that narrative to see if you were funded or not um okay going down my list the the uh the monies that would increase the 292 I think thousand stuff pass has that happened before with for us I mean did we get anything extra because of of of bills that were passed that we hadn't expected or counted on um last year it happened I you know it's not a typical we typically at this point in time you're never going to pass a budget based on um knowing what the final Virginia budget is we just have we know what the

020governor's proposed budget is and last year the budget that passed was closer to the House and Senate budget in the end I don't know the additional money that Clark County got but the county I was in got about $270,000 extra after between the governor's budget and the final budget number so last year when we ended up when the budget was finally passed end up being more money than we had thought right but I think so I think when that does happen the county then is decreased it is so just because the state gives us more doesn't mean the count still going to give us what they that was that was my question that's right and that's what typically happens in a lot it just means the cost of the locality goes down sure the only

021way that the cost of the locality certainly wouldn't go down is if the money's earmark for specific things that weren't in the budget before but that's not the case with this money so typically it's a good thing for the county it just reduces the loc count the Cy's cost now there are times if you know Count's in a really good financial situation that if the money comes in better later on that you could go back and request additional funding but that would be something it would be CAU you know you'd ask for an increase in Revenue to your budget if that happened I'd be curious to see what those numbers were the last few years if if um you know whatever was passed at at the state level and what the uh what that allowed

022the county to to back off just just yeah I just think it' be interesting to see can you see if you can do it for the last did you talk about this can you just look to see what the state what the state ended up what their final um what their final dollar amount to us was and then how that impacted whatever we were supposed to get on few years or five years and one thing to remember too I think that they're so close to agreement that we would be okay but even the governor's proposed budgets not not a guarantee at this time because um they have to reach an agreement before June 30th and there have been times unfortunately this is drug out until June before a decision was made um and the other

023thing is we're in the second year of a banian budget so if they can't reach agreement by June 30th which I hope doesn't happen then we're funded based on last year's formula which would decrease money that's why and it is kind of new for me to do budgets this early um now the last District I was was was what I thought was early because we were past them in March because the district before I was in was doing it in April but you know it's important for locality funding but when you're passing a budget this early you're not typically going to know what the state budget looks like exactly um so I know there's only three of us here but well I guess any other additional questions well I just want to be clear also

024on the uh when you're going through the executive summaries all the uh the variance numbers there at the the bottom line that's just compared to what we got uh for last for yeah for for 25 comparable to this year right so that's right to to this year yes and there is one more document in the um attachments if y'all want to look at it it was the um uh slide Mr bubach that you had asked for which is the difference between what we requested and what the locality was able to um pay now what that's it yeah now what I'll say is to me what it shows is that the county has been really good in working with us now if you'll look typically we've not gotten funded at what we initially requested but not

025being here historically there's two explanations to this one of them would be the state budget passed at a better amount which reduce their contribution down or they may not have been able to afford our initial request but like if you look at last year um the school board asked for 6,572 433 the Board of Supervisors actually um approve 5,972 433 which would be less $600,000 but that doesn't necessarily mean that they cut us that that could be close to the increase in the state budget and that's how that kind of works all the way down through there and then the other one the table on the other side is just simply the difference the 6,572 433 that we requested last year from the locality was 1,654 $678 more than we had the previous year and

026the Board of Supervisors actually funded us at $1,232 652 over the pre previous year so you can kind of see there how that works out but I if I was thinking I would think a lot of that has to do with the state budget passing at a more favorable rate so Nancy maybe you can take this document and just add to it with the state information that way it's all together do you mind that would be great if we can work to do that I guess any other questions for me or you all can discuss among yourselves there well the reason I asked for that was just to kind of last year you know we asked for it was a it was a big difference well I mean we had I mean because of the

027LCI right yeah and that's what makes it feel like it was and so that's that's my only I just throw that out there when we're looking our at our variance numbers we're already we're I mean it's it's not you know all your your percentag is here and it it it doesn't seem like okay well that's that's pretty good even even up to the 10% you're like there a lot but you're comparing it to something that we've already that's been bumped up already a lot from the from the previous year from this year yeah and I mean I hear what you're saying at the same time it's so out of our a lot of it was of our control right and just the cost of doing business is going to increase by almost 300,000 right mhm

028yeah one thing when you look at the 4% to be honest that would cost 1.64 million that's right about what we asked for initially last year um so the 4% would put us in line for almost close to an equivalent increase um now like I said if the health insurance comes back better or the state budget this gets to be a lot more favorable and one thing that we can do before we do the final budget is if everybody feels good about it we could cut down to one bus and just try to get it out of capital if we have end ofe funding this year or at very worst knock it down the line one more year um but we would make that a big priority to get that out of capital you know

029if we have excess funding at the end of the year and we request to be able to use that and the Board of Supervisors that would be pending them um agreeing to that the um other things that I did um in looking at some of the um and you all have the comparison that Dr Sil did which is wonderful of our salary scale for teachers at a three four and 5% increase um at a 4% increase teachers would get between a $2,112 raise and a $3,266 raise at a 5% increase they would get between 2,640 and 4,082 um sorry can you say that again I'm sorry on that one that shows the differences I didn't do the three but the four% raise would give teachers according to what step they're on between a $2,112 annual

030raise and $3,266 annual raise okay at a 5% raise it would give us between $2,640 increase up to as much as a $482 increase I only point that out because hopefully our health insurance will come back good and they'll get to take that money home but even if we do that if the health insurance comes back at 10 it may not be a substantial increase in you know living money can you see that 4% range again yeah it's between $2,112 up to $3,266 and then the five is 2640 up to 4,82 um now as far as comparing to other localities we are unique and offer a lot of unique things that make us positive but we do always want to be mindful of that but as far as comparing to other localities it's almost a

031prediction model at this point because we really don't know what everybody's going to do one thing that we do know is if the um Frederick County scale passes as it is was presented in the budget they did mention that the um Step Zero would go to 54,000 um and our Step Zero would be with the 3% raise 54384 so we would remain above them even at a 3% but only at the beginning and by the time you get to the upper salary scales because it mentioned adding a $5,000 on to the upper salary scales we would then be getting behind between 12 and $15,000 so that would be concerning there but at least there at the beginning we would remain competitive but we're only talking at that very first initial step um at the 3%

032Mark the way I calculate it we would probably in all likelihood even on step one fall behind everybody that's around us except for maybe one or two um the 4% would allow us to remain pretty competitive and the 5% would likely keep us really competitive but it's according to what we can afford um so those are just some thoughts there so I will off the bat say I want a 5% increase I know we can't do it so I just saying that right now and I will say even as superintendent that's I want to five I don't think we can physically afford it yeah it's up to whatever you all arrive at though I don't want to lose people I would like to either get a four or four and A2 and I think that

033if maybe if the difference between four and four and A2 is a bus being put into Capital those are my thoughts because I think if we do anything less than four we're not going to remain competitive at all and our buses 13, 5,000 so that's like the point the five% does the state ever do any uh programs for transportation type funding like they do on construction they have done one but not for a typical bus and I don't know that it'll ever get replicated again there was a grant for no cost electric buses to school divisions maybe four or five years ago um the county I was working at at the time time we were supposed to get one but we were one of the very first that got cut when they weren't able to

034fund as much but the county that I'd worked in previously got I think five four or five of them and they were at no cost but that's the only time that that's happened and it was where they were electric and newer technology well I I I don't think I mean I would agree to cutting down to one bus request but I I don't think we should cut it out you mean both buses yeah oh yeah no absolutely no I think we definitely have to leave one in and I think the other one either we need to see if we get money back the end of the year you know that we can do it or to the next year I think we have to leave at least one in and we have to have a

035caveat that we're going to make the bus a priority out of end of year spending if we can this year and the Board of Supervisors lets us move that to Capital and if not moving it in into FY 27 if we can't find it I'd almost even push to leave both of them in there and see what happens yeah because I think I think Mr Cher does a great job and he's not asked he he he wouldn't ask if we need it and and all they're going to do is get more expensive right I was going to say we have to if we're not going to do it then we need to at least add it for this year hopefully I me because to me to me I can that that is something you can

036grab a hold of is a tangible thing that is definitely a need um and and I would rather push for that and support that you know and a same with the positions MH I you know I don't want to I want to see the positions fill I want to see all the what I think are the top needs before I would support bumping up that salary in increased so what are you now whatever money we get we can discuss all right so let's let's let's move a bus till next year and use that money to help maybe bring up a a salary increase I'm just saying what we present to the to the Board of Supervisors I just think we can defend this for for for 26 I think we can defend buses probably more

037than trying to bump up a another percent or even a half percent I just I just got that feeling with with the way things are in the county yeah the only thing would be if we do the buses it' be in a different line item so after it was passed we'd have to stick with that and not you know do salary we can't rearrange um you're not level you're probably not categorical so you might could but it's not that's um it's not ideal well because and the only reason I say that is because um uh I feel like so I don't know if I completely understood everything you were saying outside of we definitely want the two buses but um are you saying let's fight for these two buses let's get these positions let's kind

038of request based on some type of salary increase we'll see what we get and then we can go from there because there's still so many unnown right so I think though for salary increases the county they want they want us they want to know what we're thinking so we can't go in there and be like I agree I agree I'm just saying and and without knowing so much and things being so much up in the air yeah um I'd like I I I think we go and we present to the to the county and and be able to defend wholeheartedly everything that we ask for and then because as far as the county concerns then you know the the the full sum you know they're going to give that to us but I was under

039the impression we could kind of once we get it we could kind of manipulate it a little bit if something changes that's that's what I mean with this with with the with the state something passing you know and oh well we have more we have more coming mhm if the state passes more unless we ask for additional Revenue though it would just cut the locality cost down it wouldn't increase anything to us yeah that's what's done in the past that's that's that's what I want to know I want to know how much the state has been saving the county you know just so we can get a feeling that's all I'm just I'm not I'm not speaking one way or the other I just like to know yeah so that we can whatever it is

040negotiate or say hey we can do this and let pass this off and just try to make it all work out for the you know for the best for on both sides that's all yeah yeah and it's a little bit early in the year to be thinking about like end of year spending what would be left because things could break but what we could do is see if you know Nancy and Brenda M could come up with an estimate of what it's looking like we're at currently at our Fe at their end of the month meeting where we pass the budget to see if it's likely that we could cover the cost of a bus or not what are your thoughts um so I have read like there are concerns about the um $78,000 for

041the English teacher and $78,000 for the math teacher that's not that's so H how do you come up with that number is it like you know kind of looking at maybe like 10 years of experience and then also throwing in um benefits yeah and it doesn't mean that it would come in at that you just have to have a placeholder and I can't remember how far up the salary scale we went and maybe Dr SE or Nancy may remember on that but what we did is we just picked an average Step maybe it's step 10 and said here's the cost was it 10 and it's 10 years of experience with Benefits added in um could come in if you hire somebody at Step Zero and they don't have individual only Insurance then that could come

042down a lot more right so it's not that it do mean they're getting that no right right I think important for people to understand that do you have any thoughts about the salary I think 4% okay so I am definitely at 4% I would love four and a half but um I not interested in going lower than four if we can help it um I know Mr Kennedy feels the same way Michael not sure about um so it's just a matter of what our request is going to be I mean it sounds like we're all in favor of these positions right um yeah I think we're almost done you I mean yeah I think if we do it based on four and we seems like everybody's in favor of the positions so the only other

043question is to leave two buses in or not right because the bonus actually would come out if it happens out of this fiscal year either way and so for some of these positions like um could they be repurposed meaning that like um so we don't need uh maybe an assistant at this building so we're going to move that person to another building because we can move positions with you can move positions and then could it could you potentially save um you know 20,000 to 40,000 by just shuffling we've done that in the past but so this is kind of an overestimate it would be if we had additional people and I don't know you know that yeah their other position wouldn't be needed I don't think that that one's the case but this is an

044overestimate because it's based upon everybody here coming in with 10 years of experience okay so okay okay are you thinking maybe if someone were to resign that maybe we don't necessarily fill that position because we can shuffle a little from here maybe that's where that right Works which which is what we've done in the past we can consider each position that becomes vacated right one by one as that happens yeah we Absol which we've I feel like that's a we do yeah I mean we had the conversation about some IAS right yeah um there were some IAS where we they're vacant right so we're going to kind of keep them that right now I did find out though those are um for our self-contained room and really botle so we've been looking Ono we are

045going to yeah which makes sense um okay Mr runbeck I'd like at least to have a little bit of an idea of where you want to land on salary I I guess I'm going back and forth between the reality of it and the want I mean I'm I I'm I'm at the 4% too I just don't know if that's yeah I don't know if that's responsible well so it's interesting cuz you made the comment about where we can defend a bus we can defend these positions I can defend the salary increase we just it's not tangible like you you know which is is kind of how your mind works and I appreciate that but um so I I kind of feel strongly that I I absolutely think it's defendable um but I'm I think we

046all feel the same way it's it's um it's a lot of money yeah um but we have to take care of our we do our people and you know from a personal standpoint and you know can say it's my ego or not um we have busted our highes trying to get to a um really good place with our salaries in in regards to the neighboring counties we have worked very hard I would hate for us to slide back because it's going to take that much longer to get back ahead especially with how well knowing what we know is coming that's right with the reassessment that's right you know it's it's not going to get better no I mean we're struggling at at 60 or where wherever we're at and I'm stressed we're going to be

047at um it's just going I just it's going to be tough yeah I mean you know everybody's everybody's property taxes when up the reassessment That's Right nailed I mean it's you you'll 50% up and I know there's there's there's ways that that that we're fortunate you know that that the county kind of tried has to soften that but you're talking so this conversation where you're like well look at what we asked for last year it's like we're going to be saying the same exact thing next year well well I know but I'm just saying as far as the tax the average taxpayer you know if the county can cover it it's great and they've done really good without bumping our taxes up it's so frustrating though that like they're that we are this County that

048has Deep Pockets of wealth that I don't like I don't hang out with these people I wish they could you know play you inv but there are there are and there are there are people who have these you know million dooll properties that live here on the weekends and work in DC during the week and they like our lower tax rates and that's not who we hang out out with or I mean I can only speak for myself but you know that's not who my kids have grown up with but that's you know that's that adds to the complexity of you know of the situation and it's and it's really frustrating that we have people who use this beautiful place as a vacation space or a you know an escape to get away from the

049city but they're not going to s their kids to school here and they don't care about the sports here or the band program here or you know the the the wonderful things that that we're able to offer and that and it's really frustrating and it puts our County in a difficult spot but you know it's um there there's a lot of there's a lot of wealth that that like you don't see I think that I don't see and that just I don't know I don't know how you get around that though at the 4% which is the 1,674 n36 if the state budget passes at the House and Senate estimate and health insurance comes in at what we did last year it'll make it like close to 1,124 36 in the requested increase which is

050a little bit less than last year and if we were not to do a bus and do it out of capital in the end it would actually bring the request under a million slightly the increase um but I think I can kind of see maybe putting the four in for the final budget and you all seeing it and voting on it and I can see the position part I guess one thing we'll have to get clarification on is whether to keep two buses is in the budget or to take one out and hope we can fund it at the end of the year or FY 27 so just kind of your all's thoughts on that any chance we can try to see where we might land at the end of the year by the next

051finance committee meeting not this week next week tomorrow no um I'm assuming we are rescheduling right so NE next when yeah and very and just kind of not looking for it down to the penny but you know I think that might give us an idea then if we're looking solid or if we're still kind of yeah so that might give us an idea of whether we go for one two but whatever we submit if the uh if the county says no we'll give you this much MH then we have to go back through and see where we we allocate all that anyway yep that's that's right we do at that point and you got to remember to touch the state money has to be at least three so if it's not that then we're going

052to be making some really hard decisions right so I guess that's so that would lead that would lead me to say let's leave what we everything in there uhhuh I see that's a good point yeah so then we can pull we can pull yeah we'll do the 4% then if it sounds good to every body with the positions and two buses I think that leaves everything answered think so and let's just count on the universe coming in and doing no uh no increase on health insurance be amazing if that number comes in then that's we might not be given you know we might be eaten into people's paychecks more than we're trying to give them so well unfortunately that's the reality I know I know okay so just to recap then so Nancy I'm sorry

053you end up with to-dos but if we can add the state information State funding on this um this one document that way we can have it all on on one sheet and then if we can kind of get some high Lev reasonable idea of where we're going to land at the end of the year and then sounds like we're all for the executive summary is it three yeah executive summary three MH anything else I was really thinking it was going to be a long meeting thank you thank you okay just just a quick question just for discussion purposes or curious our retention over the last however many has has steadily gone up correct can I've not been here that but I've heard that it's good and I'll let Dr SE answer that but I think

054we've only got one or two that have said so far that they're thinking about not being with us next year so it's been very positive are you talking about in general over the past few years oh yeah our attentions it's been pretty high meaning they're staying yeah it's it's remained very favorable you know we have 15 people who are moving shifting cre vacancy that's a high number right now we have one Elementary vacancy for the upcoming year one high school mathematics and then we have the reading specialist vacancy um that was from a retirement now of course it's early and people can put going to stay on their intent to return but I'm not hearing otherwise at this point right and I think you know a lot of it comes down to how you treat

055people and there's other things we can do that are important too one thing that is becoming a reality is you know and I don't think that due to amount of funding they have that we can ever think about you know the Lowden competition piece but when you look at the end of their salary scale which is about 30,000 more roughly for teachers it won't be as long a problem as much long term because hybrid it's more about what you invest in your retirement but our people that are vrs plan one and two in particular plan one um it's a little bit north of 50% of your gross pay is what your vrs is the rest of your life when you retire so when you think about a plan one teacher if they were to go

056to allow and they're probably and they do three years because it's the average of your highest three years they'll be adding about $15,000 a year onto their um salary annually the rest of their life one thing to consider as as the Gap kind of opens with Frederick with us which is going to go could go as much as about 15,000 in the upper steps next year that becomes a relevant thing too because a vrs plan one person could take home about $7,500 more a year by doing three years there um I think that one side is ex exactly how you treat people is very important the other side too you know that business side that as gaps open up there is an an advantage and it with the way vrs works that's a rest of

057your life type deal but I do think that concern will diminish as the years go on cuz hybrid became the only option in 2014 so the people who are not on hybrid are becoming fewer and fewer as time goes on yeah in other words you have to be old to be on plan one or two but I think that there are other like that we've seen especially this year there are some intangible qualities in Clark County that that you maybe don't have in other places and and and I say that because of the number of kids not kids they're adults who've come back here to teach um who were students and graduates of Clark County and that's that's that's remarkable especially um with not not a lot of people wanting to go into the education

058field right now well it's obvious they just want to work for the school board is really what it comes out they you know what it's a coincidence you're here now and all these kids came back play no but on a on a serious note I I think that's something that we need to pay attention to and and I don't know what El is you know in those in the survey and the survey that that gets responded to is is mostly employees uh but where we're at on those others not salary but I mean because it's I mean you can you can have a high salary and not be a very happy employee because of certain you know whatever yeah and and I know the the the the student teacher ratio was on there but I

059would I'd be interested in getting feedback from everyone on on on that and if we we have our retention rate is going up then that's you know are we where does that make any difference well there's a lot of research that actually shows that recognition and feeling valued and having feedback are sometimes as important if not more important than dollars to employees um so there's a lot that shows that so I do think that's a very important component of it um and then the other component which is more on the dollar sign I think that you all done a tremendous job being very competitive with everybody around you currently um except for lden and maybe Frederick in the upper steps so I think it's a combination of both that there's 's been there's the other

060side to it which is getting feedback and filling individual attention but then there's also the side that um would come from us being pretty competitive currently um I know this work session on budget but along um just along the same lines when we're talking about it doesn't necessarily have to be like the dollar amount but we have to vote on our calendar at the end of the month and so as part of that would be those floating holidays right and so if we were to include the three or five floating holidays right that's another that's just another sort of here we appreciate you we know we can't give you all the holidays but you know well again right and that needs to be stressed whether it's in you know whether it's in the paper and

061highlighted but you gold letters red font well because we are up against it with the with our our Composite Index and yes we would love to be able to say we're going to do 5% boom boom boom boom boom right but we can't and so there are other things that we're trying that you know if you could equate a value to you know we could come in and and and instead of just the the 2, 3200 increase for at 4% it may be a whole lot more it may be twice that MH doing beef would' be even more right and actually um two of our policy uh committee things revolve around those so one of the things is if we do pass the calendar as it is it only has it has 190 working days

062for our teachers which would actually give them credit for 10 days that they either can stay at home or they don't know like we're not going to check into that piece but we're giving them 10 days credit for grading and planning so that's an intangible piece of that vots and then to do either three or five floating holidays for our 12month employees those are some things we can do that don't necessarily cost money but are ways that we can take care of people all for it there we go all right anything else nope thank you for being here I'll join the meeting appreciate you thank you for all your work appreciate everything and your ginormous binder yeah e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.