CorpusRecord 80461

Clarke County Public Schools School Board Meeting 12/16/2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Clarke County Public Schools VA
Date
2024-12-17
Location
Clarke County, VA
Material
Transcript
Extent
17,444 words · about 97 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e anybody I move that we um approve the consent agenda as presented there second second all in favor I all opposed before we get started with all our fun stuff I just wanted to introduce Dr bowling this is his first official meeting here so um we're very excited to have you so welcome to all the fun in Clark County um um do you I guess I'll do it um so we're going to start off with um the jawz band from Johnson Middle School Johnson Williams Middle School yeah you guys are first all right all right that's awesome Y is that Mr [Music] Clark great there are a lot of you who have no idea who I am most you probably had m in middle school or new I am Mr Clark I the

002middle school band recor it's nice to meet you football te right cross country excuse me I'm sorry I great we have some fun pieces selected for you this evening we're playing some of the things we put at our concert last Friday K great looking forward to sharing let's do it [Applause] [Music] [Applause] a [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] la [Music] every [Music] [Applause] [Music] great that was Jazzy Merry Christmas this second is called Deacon Jack go Shack we have three solos for even one from Charlotte Queen please ra [Music] your pleas raise yourt our last are done playing it is customary to CL them uh these people are 11 and 12 years old and they are doing something impress it's called improvising they're totally making up something based on what the

003music were playing it's really hard they're really young might be weird don't worry about it great here you 43 sorry oh [Music] [Applause] a [Music] [Applause] [Music] a [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] h [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] la [Music] [Applause] [Music] our last one for you is a classic I'm not even going to tell you what it is figure out immediately I'd like to recognize three individuals this evening Sam bar Jackson sping and you please stand up not would you please give these individuals a round of applause here how cool Middle School band is okay they're playing seventh grade jazz band uh one of our people couldn't beet tonight I email Sam and say hey awesome so today both Rory andson were staying after school and they like play like so the US

004just decided to pick up an instrument and just join us their rehearsal with us was what like 30 minutes like three hours ago so this is pretty impressive for what we're able to do thank you so much for coming in really okay great here's our last [Music] la [Music] [Applause] la [Music] [Applause] [Music] n [Music] a [Music] fig out what was it good job yes great is there is there anything else you'd like me to come and would love um for all the stud students to introduce themselves and tell us what grade they're in come up front um there is fine I okay come up front kids my is embarrassing come so funny swear [Music] God and Mr Clark they can actually stand over there so everybody can see them that would be great hey

005Scott oh it's great I could paint tomorrow Jackson go ahead painted tomorrow and uh while we're waiting on uh you all to start one thing I did want to say is we're I think when we get talented young teachers we always need to recognize them for what they do what they Mr Clark um your band concert on Friday evening last week was exemplary you and the kids did a fantastic job so I was highly impressed it would have been highly impressive for any year teacher but what you accomplished in one semester certainly commendable and the most I thought it was really theatrical the instrument that you created and that and the way you kind of core graph that piece it was a really nice night slay right yes thank you so much I really agree

006what what he's referencing one of my we played slay ride who knows that song you [Music] know one of my eighth graders built a slapstick and and made it themselves and then like two days with the con like you want to like run through the audience and do it she like yeah my so that half of half of my job is making it fun for them and also embarrassing them like they're about to do right now Jackson please up first yes and what do you play I play yeah let's give Jackson a round of applause Rory you want to repeat that so they can actually hear you this time do St loud [Applause] guber and I'm and I play and [Applause] I'm charlot Queen and ium and Mr Clark if you want to wait till

007all the athletes are recognized if you have time you might have more room to pack up at that point okay we can we can do that that was such a wonderful idea to have them introduce themselves thank you so much for that you're welome seriously no can we get one more round of applause that's efficient and and brave work for young people to want to go out there and do this thing and do that for a bunch of people seriously thank you so much for being with a nice [Applause] AUD um Miss Williams I'm sorry you have to go after them but would you love to give us an update on the Clark County Education Foundation yes I would love to Dr bowling as much as I wish I could tell you this is normal

008for these meetings it's not this is such a fun night so thank you for welcoming us here at the Education Foundation um I'm joined Tonight by John Ericson my board president and Dr Cameron FY uh she's a board member No Label but both of these people are Clark County high school graduates and I'm joined um every day by a board of volunteers of 15 people who are members of Clark County um some of them are Clark County graduates some of them aren't and we work to fundraise to support the public schools as best we can so our office is here in the Schoolboard office we work with Dr bowling very closely um and we're proud of the work we do and today we're going to share a little bit of of it with you but

009we're going to start by recognizing some kids um La this past month we invited all Clark County Public School students to participate in an art contest and we'd like to recognize the winners of them that contest first so we're going to call up the winners first so if you look on the screen I have them I have them big and we're going to start with Johnson Williams Middle School Miss yakan Ariana Vargas from seventh grade yakan are you here tonight okay I think they're in order she's not here but congratulations and then we're going to move to DG coie there we go DG coie Elementary School Miss Masha Kina come on up Masha make sure it's her name I think it is Masha come on up congratulations congratulations conat Beau picture congratul and we're going

010to take your picture real quick so look this right here Mas congratulations and we've put all of their artwork up here it will be up for several months um to enjoy for everyone next up Miss V sour from second grade DG kie elementary school thank you congratulations congratul ulations stay right here V take your picture real quick okay right here in the middle your art you want to show your art open it up oh it's not the picture there so I will interject each of these students is winning $50 today and they're all being featured in our holiday art um holiday card from the foundation that's going out to our supporters so next up we have have Miss Caroline White from Boyce Elementary fourth grade conat congratulations great we'll take one picture with you okay

011next up Mr George Skinner from Boyce Elementary from first grade I sh your which one this one can we take your picture you stand right here and we'll take your picture Okay congratulations George and our overall winner this year is From Clark County High School Miss Camry Ferrari Camry how do I say it f Cambry Fay congratulations thank you congrats can we take your picture real quick I hope the mic didn't pick that up congratulations to all of our students so we at the foundation are an independent public charity um our job is to promote expand and augment educational opportunities for the students and staff in Clark County Public Schools so we do that by fundraising um by private support and um by involvement to enhance these publicly maintained services so that's a lot of

012words and we've been talking as a board about possibly changing that but um really our mission is to support you guys you guys have a budget and you do what you can and then our job is to fill in on top of that budget to make more exciting opportunities for our teachers and staff and I feel like we do that I'm really proud of what we do here um we have 15 local board members who are all volunteer and then I'm one part-time employee um since 1991 we have Ed over $3.5 million to support Clark County Public Schools so I listed our board members here and everyone I'm not going to read them um the two that are here I introduced but we have a great group right now and like I said these are

013all volunteers who volunteer their time every single month to try and make our schools better and so I can't thank these people enough they work really hard to help um this organization and this school system just a few of the things that we do I'm just highlighting a few each year for the past 10 years we've helped with the Clark Innovation conference by sponsoring um we award teacher grants and scholarships each year and tonight we're going to award a few teacher scholarships we have continued the story walk over at Chet Hobert Park um we've given over $40,000 in student scholarships the past year alone over $500,000 total um to graduating seniors at Clark County High School each year and we host fundraisers each year including a golf tournament a Gayla auction the than of teacher

014campaign and the employee giving campaign these are the students that we um offered scholarships to the past year and I'm sorry those are really small pictures but if you come to my office I would invite all of you to come visit me I have it really big on the wall um you can also see that on our website all the students we recognize this past year with scholarships so like I said one of the ways we give back is by offering scholarships and we're really proud of that and tonight we'd like to recognize um a true pillar of our community Mr Mo Murphy you've probably seen at almost well he just told me he hasn't missed a football game in 10 years um he's been around for over 20 years taking pictures of Clark County

015high school athletes um he took pictures of me he remembers when I was an athlete here and um he's just been a huge supporter of Clark County and he not only is a huge supporter by offering his services but he now is also starting a a scholarship with us the the mo Murphy journalism scholarship and this is going to be given to a student who's contributed to the high school yearbook or is in um the journalism class and so we would like to recognize him today and just offer him a certificate of appreciation thank you you so can we take your picture real quick my good thank you thank you would you like to say anything well it's just been a pleasure being around a kids all these years they're like my own I understand

016a few of the teams are going to be uh honored here shortly and I'm looking forward to that and anybody interested in journalism get on the scholarship it will help you out a little bit so thanks a lot Merry Christmas okay and then we'd like to recognize some teachers tonight and unfortunately some of them couldn't be with us um we offer two different scholarships for our teachers um the Kenneth and Barbara Thomas Memorial endowment scholarship which is a given in memory of Kenneth and Kenneth and Barbara Thomas um this year is going to miss Kate bevens and she couldn't be here tonight because she has a student or a a kid with a broken arm maybe she has a cast at home so she couldn't come tonight which is understandable and then we're also going

017to recognize two other teachers who are receiving the 2024 Virginia Lloyd superintendent scholarship re Awards each of these teachers are receiving $1,000 to help them further their education tonight we'd like to recognize Miss Rachel Crawford and Miss Christina [Applause] Collings congratulations thank you thank you so much yeah open it up thank you congratulations okay and the last thing I'd like to say is thank you to everyone who supports this organization almost every single person in this room has supported us one way or another our major fundraiser is coming up on March 14th it's a Gaya theme I mean it's a mar gr theme this year it's at historic Rosemont right down the street um we would love for you all to come whether you're in BEC as a student or in band as a student

018um or as in baseball as a student we have a lot of students there helping us out but adults in the room we would we're inviting all of you um this is our major fundraiser of the year and it's a lot of fun it's really a a night to support public education and celebrate our awesome schools here so we invite you all tickets are on sale January 1st sponsorships are on sale now um and if anyone is interested in receiving a set of our Student Art cards so all of those six pieces of art on a um 5x7 note card um anyone who donates $100 or more this holiday season to the foundation will get a set for free mail to them so um thank you all and I think my last slide just says

019happy holidays maybe it's the inside of our it's the inside of our Christmas card so on the front of it will be um Camry's cow which is I love and then all the other kids art is on the inside cover on the top and it says sending warm wishes to you and your loved ones for a joyous holiday season thank you for choosing to support us this year from all of us at the Clark County Education Foundation so thank you um so Beth yes so um you've been with us has it been four years now seven SE um so Mrs Williams has been here clearly seven and I just don't think you pat yourself enough on the back and I just appreciate your relationship with us you have done so much for us and for

020the foundation so um if we can just do a huge shout out to you I would really that would be great so thank you thank you thank you she makes my life and the rest of the board very easy good okay student recognition Dr bowling all right good evening um it's always a pleasure to get to recognize students for the accomplishments that they make um and the board tonight will recognize Clark County High School students for their groundbreaking and historic performances during the fall Sports programs our teams won a record setting combined 11 so 11 vhsl Bull Run district and region 2B titles all participating students are commended for their efforts in addition to the team rosters the following students earned additional recognition so that's something to be really proud of 11 titles and these

021range from theater to you know um traditional Sports programs and we'll start by recognizing our theater group and they finished as the runner up in the district competition so if the uh students and coach would please come forward face whatever we are uh very proud of them and Miss Kristen Brewer is our coach so I'd like for her to take a moment to introduce herself say a couple words and then either have her team introduce themselves or she can introduce them so hello everyone Christine Brewer and I coach the theater team theater is a vhsl event under the academics um category we compete by uh producing a one-act play that is judged against other schools from our district and then region and then States and as they mentioned we finished runner up in our district

022this year with a play called bomb art it was kind of an absurdest comedy had a wonderful cast and crew and I have a few of them here today unfortunately a lot of them could not make it but I will um go ahead and I'll just introduce him I guess on the end there we have uh Rory Murphy Maggie Lair Logan McDonald who by the way was accepted to NYU School of the Arts Tish so for musical theater Grace Holman and Kayla Calder so unfortunately the rest of them couldn't be here with us but uh this is a dedicated group of um of theater students and we have a lot going on we are getting ready to have auditions for our spring musical which is Chicago teen Edition going on in April so hopefully all

023of you will come out and support us in that and my theater classes will be performing their Christmas play on Friday for the school and anybody who wants to drop in at 8:30 and check it out and Miss Brew correct me if I'm wrong but uh Caroline and Maggie both did all district performance honors right yes actually uh Caroline Maggie and Logan right Logan also got recognized Logan um Caroline and Maggie were recognized at the regional level and uh Logan and Maggie were at the district level right so yeah well congratulations thank you thank you next we'd like to ask for our golf team and Coach to come forward our golf team won the Regional Championship which is the first time in school history and qualified for States as a team so at this point

024we'll have uh coach Phil fa Meer uh introduce himself and members of the team so um I'm Philip facemire I'm the coach for the golf team been doing this for about four years and uh each year they just keep exceeding my expectations um we uh started off like the in the very beginning like you know I'd have only maybe 10 people at trying out and I could hold about 10 or 12 students and then every year more students would try out and then I got these individuals at VAR various different years and uh each one of them came to play um that it's a it's an interesting sport because there's no golf in the school system until you hit high school so there's no like Elementary or Middle School feeder program or anything like that

025so I'm seeing all of these kids for the very first time in high school and I don't know what their background is but they come in and they tell me they can play and then they show me they can play and they did one hell of a job so um starting with uh Jonah zurer um two years and I still he doesn't show me any emot whether or not he's he how you doing I'm playing fine that's a 85 or winning the regional tournament overall either way no emotion I've got Dylan who's come in here and he's uh he he also is very consistent I have Caleb who uh I stole from baseball a little bit and I'm not even sorry um I have Camry who came in as a freshman and I put her

026in a tournament I said let's see how you can play and boy could she play and I have Grace who come in here and this is her second year and she's she's far out out exceeded anything that I could expect so I have a wonderful team here and uh I'm so glad that we had this opportunity to um uh really show them how much uh the community supports them thank you and as he's being seated too we'd like to recognize Jona for region individual Champion so so congratulations that's probably the first time ever right all right at this time we' asked the volleyball team and their coaches to come forward the coaches of the volleyball team were skyar Leighton and bl Lambert so I'd like for them to introduce themselves and their team volleyball this

027fall won the Bull Run District the Bull Run District Tournament region 2B Championship which is the first time in school history they also are advancing to the state semifinals for the first time in history um so if the coaches would introduce themselves and the team all right all right um I'm Skyler Leon uh head coach I got my co-pilot here fly Lambert um this season this season was definitely one for the history books we've been talking ever since we started coaching together about how that Regional spot up on the wall was was blank and we knew starting in August that this team had potential to do wonderful things um winning that District Tournament um District championship and then for the first time ever finally getting a 2024 under that Regional Title um that was absolutely

028incredible and not only did did we do that but then we made it to State semifinals where we got to host and we went to five sets and ultimately did not make it to that state championship game but we came very close and next year we plan on getting there um these ladies here um were a huge part in that um there's two girls who um couldn't make it tonight that I'd like to recognize uh Grace jensky and Gracie Brown they received second Team all district um Marley backover also received second Team all district um Brun fransen received First Team all district first team All Region second Team all state Isabelle Al Vito received First Team all district first team All Region and First Team all state and Ali Lynch received First Team all district

029first team All Region First Team all state as well as The Bull Run District's volleyball player of the year nice um all all five of these ladies have been with us since either sophomore or freshman year um and they are huge parts of the reason why we did what we did this year so thank you to them and thank you to all of you for your support one more thing recognize coach L she was the Bull Run District Coach of the Year Regional coach of the year and she will be the Winchester coach star coach of the year don't say nothing yet and we would recognize them for their individual accomplishments there but uh coach Leon did such a wonderful job uh telling us about those so thank you for that at this time we'd

030like to ask Mr Casey Childs and the football team to come forward football completed a perfect 10 undefeated season for the 10th time in school history while winning winning the district championship for the 23rd time nine players were recognized in All Region and 17 at the district level so uh coach Charles if you would introduce yourself and your uh team members you have with you Casey Charles I hit football coach I'm also the athletic director of the high school um so first speaking on the athletic director side of it it's unbelievable fall um extremely busy as you can imagine um historic you know grounds were made um with the titles and so forth and on top of it it was great support from the community uh from the administration and the coaches uh tremendous job

031from top to bottom with every and every one of our teams extremely proud of everybody um and they know that as well so it was it was a great fall football-wise today uh well between boys and girls basketball playing uh tonight and swimming's practicing and then we've got um wrestling practice and then also we've got a few of our kids that are playing in All-Star game this Saturday so they had their practice tonight so that's where those kids are at they're at shanora right now practicing so we're missing a lot of our guys but these guys did show up Zack Hagerty um Forest U starting out here too Aon paalo is what we call him but it's Aon Mina Hammerman Drake Barton Conor Dennison Evan Dyer otherwise known as gron uh and then we've got

032that's always the best nickname ever um I'm having I'm having a complete meltdown I call and then of course we've got Joseph stem here uh he was playing he was also a lot of our guys guys got uh Awards he was also one of our guys that got a lot of postseason Awards um as well and then yeah wide order my gosh wide order the starting center for us um and these guys did a tremendous job overall team in a nutshell uh tremendous tremendous season uh just a shame that everybody kind of got a little broke up and sick the last week uh going into the playoffs um so you like kind of go out on you know all cylinders that didn't happen for us but tremendous year couldn't be more proud of the kids

033and while I've got a second too I also want to say happy birthday to Mo Murphy uh today the man the myth the legend Mo with a birthday so I want to make sure I said that to you but thank you guys very much for having us really appreciate it and thank you guys up here for your continued support uh it's greatly appreciated and uh Mr Childs as I introduce these if you'd help me c um the first team region linebacker was Carson is that correct yes Carson chin yes uhhuh and then your first team all purpose and defensive back was Tanner Tanner sight okay and the first team All Region on offensive and defensive line and also Defensive Player of the Year sa to I probably said that wrong but that's what I've always

034said I'm sticking with it so yeah actually and Sir to be quite honest I always I think it's so important to get people's names said correctly that's why I put it on YouTube well for some reason I forgot why a minute ago so I don't even know what to tell you on that one but yeah but yeah those those guys uh they were all in the All State meeting is uh this coming week so I'm hoping that we have some representation in that as well um so I won't know that until probably till after Christmas all right thank you thank you guys very much all right and our final team for recognition Mr Dr hey Mr coach child before you guys head out I I'm going to try to like not cry which is always

035like impossible for me but um and I'm not even going to look at you all but as your season went on and you know there was like one Victory after another um like your your team experienced an abnormal number of losses personally and you lost you almost lost one of your own and um I think that that um definitely played into uh the experience uh the or the success that you guys had um because of the unity um and um I mean the the losses like I would after like every game say to my family like think about what this group of kids have been through and then also you coach child um losing your brother this season and I remember being at a JV game and it was the week that your brother had

036died and you know you had all of these teenagers just surrounding you and it was just a really beautiful thing to see um how special and H like just what a unique season it was um but you know I was reading the article about Saia from the Winchester Star and he lost his mom when he when he was two years old Carson chin lost both grandparents during the the four years that he played football for your team um Tanner cye lost his aunt due to cancer um and and please forgive me if I forget somebody um Wyatt Palmer lost his cousin who was a former student of ours Connor you lost your brother and we almost lost you so it's just um you know and we lost coach Emer um so it was awesome to

037see the way you guys came together and I know that that there are probably a lot of things that I don't even know about that you all have experienced just personally without sharing um but you've taught us how to come together as a team and most importantly to support each other um through those losses and I just can't believe that that didn't play an impact in your success I think that you had some angels with you this season for sure no I I appreciate that and and I just on my personal level and Ian these guys were there but obviously all not all of our guys are here tonight but um at my brother's funeral you know I left um our walkthrough practice on that Thursday and you know I live with my family I

038turn around and the whole football team came in with their jerseys on uh and that was probably one of the most touching things ever I've ever gone through in my 50 years um but you know and things just got rolling on a really good so it was a lot of like I think you're right a lot of stuff came together but this group of kids I've been doing this now for 28 years and and uh this is going to hold a really special place in my heart they do anyway every group does but when you turn around and you see all of them coming in on the uh well the family night and it was it was very special very touching to me my myself and my family uh a total so yeah it's it's

039it's really a special special group of guys for Serv and I appreciate that thank you thanks and our final group for student recognition a wonderful sport our cross country boys and girls if they would come forward um along with their coaches is Jeff Webster and Amy Smith and um if you all would maybe start by introducing the cross country girls you have with you um at this point and introduce yourselves as well sure actually what um what I'd like to do since there's a whole her of them um maybe we'll just let let the individuals introduce themselves if you don't mind for that for me please can we just that would be great you guys and GS together yeah just let them go one after each other it's fine for it okay I'm Emma Houston

040and I'm a sophomore I'm Mia tber and I'm a sophomore I'm Meena and I'm a junior I'm T stle and I'm a senior I'm abof and I'm a senior I'm I'm a senior I'm jais and I'm a senior I'm J I'm I'm Lon Horton and I'm a sophomore I'm Carter Starley and I'm a sophomore I'm Ellis and I'm a sophomore I'm Matt L and I'm a sophore I'm Warren and I'm a Jun all right coaches do you have anything you'd like to share sure um so I think after hearing uh coach Char and and about the football I think we all have to remember that behind every successful athlete is a very supportive and engaged group of of parents um I can certainly attest to that our parent group certainly keeps me on my toes

041um and you know next to me um are two very um awesome coaches Amy Smith and then a volunteer Jamie Starley who um on days would I text at 3:20 and say I'm coming in hot I'll meet you at the park Loop for warm-ups they're they're very quick to say sounds good gotcha so um you know this year was a year where you know everybody was pulling in the same direction um but I think it's important to note that what makes these guys really special is sort of their their qualities that lie far outside of the athletic Arena um they're good kids they're great students I knew several of them were in the you know top five or so in their class rank um our seniors are just putting down some big numbers for SATs

042and have gotten into some pretty pretty fantastic schools so they're going to go on to do really great things um the fact that they're good Runners quite frankly is is really just a bonus um and when I when I say great Runners I I have to give you some context because cross country is a different difficult sport to sort of dissect and when you think about the Virginia League you know there's between six and 700 Runners of each gender in 2A so when you boil that all down and you take the top seven or or 10 that are varsity and then those top top seven or 10 have to go through the district and region pathway just to get to the state meet and then when you get to the state meet after 105 days

043of running and racing you have to be your best on that day so these guys you know if you're James Casey getting third or TAA getting fifth or Molly Sixth and Jackson Sixth and you know we had I think seven Runners across both genders get top 15 All State it's hard to wrap your head around how these guys they're not number three out of a 100 they're number three out of 700 right they're the top 1% of the runners in 2A right and you know you you've heard a few of the seniors introduce themselves and there's quite a few right and we're going to miss them as quality Runners but I I think more importantly for me I'm going to the the quality of people that they are um so you know when you look

044at this group I I I have to point out and and this just a hard thing to say because this was such a great year for all sports so I don't want this at all to sound uh anything against the success of the other programs but I want to give you a little context that for this group here of the last four years right of the last eight combined Seasons only in one of those seasons did either team finish lower than second in the state right so that's the world that they know so what happens we lose these seniors right we get the Juniors we get the sophomores freshman next year is freshman what happens so they step up and they you know they they pick up the mantle of that challenge and they drive

045the culture they drive the philosophy that you know they set goals they work extremely well together ultimately there's winning right but what's really interesting about what these guys do is they enliven the culture where all of those things are the expectation and not the exception and and that's what makes them so special right so it's my privilege to to be a part of that I'm thrilled to be a part of all the successes that the schools had this year it's just a Great era for Clark County Athletics um and and obviously you know we're just thrilled to do our part um so thank you for the recognition thank you thank you thank you all and can I just say something coach Webster so um I I don't know all of the stories behind all of

046your athletes but I know that um a number of you have dealt with injuries that that have not or that have um held you back from doing your best and then Having the courage and the the willpower and the fortitude to fight through the season and not give up um and then and come out on top is is tremendous but then also to miss out on two seasons um and still stick with your team is is phenomenal um and I know that again there's I wish that I knew your students better um but the stories that I do know are are exceptional and um I know what it's like to have a have an athlete who's you know held back from doing what they love and it's it's tough and it's tremendous to see you

047all come out on the other side of it and it's a great lesson for life um because we certainly do experience those setbacks and um push through um but the success of your team is just tremendous and it's it's become like the expectation that that our cross country teams are are the best um and I loved seeing you guys on the uh the fire trucks in in the Christmas parade that was so awesome um but I'm thankful that you guys came tonight and so many of you all came tonight and I think that um I'm biased of course but this is the best sport to take with you for the rest of your life and you know no matter what day you're H what kind of day you're having a good run makes it all

048better so you could do my job no no not even close thank you guys thanks um just quickly Casey don't go anywhere just quickly um you know everybody talks about how this was a groundbreaking season historical historic um performances um and you know Casey was here highlighting all his student athletes but I think there's something to be said about that and you um your leadership you're at the Helm of this um people love you when you win we talk about this all the time people love you when they win they don't like you that much when we lose um you tend to be the punching bag for parents coaches however it goes so um and to Katie's point you went through a lot personally this um this season so we appreciate you showing up every

049single day um and the way that you support our athletes it's just amazing so thank you thank you very kind work thank you and hold on one more thing Ally before you leave um I didn't get to say this about volleyball I had notes written about volleyball and golf and I didn't get to say them so I'm going to say it before you guys scoot out but um in volleyball I still remember coach Styer when you guys were seventh graders talking about how amazing you were going to be by the time you seniors and she was right and um our community is really really going to miss this tremendous group of of seniors um but uh she was spoton when she was talking about how amazing you guys were going to be um when she

050hit high school so thank you for [Applause] coming oh Miss Bennett it's always like this for you every time I'm so sorry don't am I good you are good thank you us to go to okay Miss ven Bennett will um report on the finance committee meeting the finance committee met and um reviewed fy2 operating expenditures um we do do this we try to do this at least uh every other meeting if not every meeting we're looking through them but we did have discussions regarding the operating year-to dat expenditure report uh that was presented in the consent agenda and um looking at expenditures to make sure they look like they are in line for this type time of year um and with u the expectations of what we should be seeing and also to look forward

051to know that uh is if there is available budget you know what what it can be utilized for and those those types of things so the committee did didn't have any uh there are no red flags or anything that was noted that would be um need discussion or or warranted any further investigation so um the operating expenditure review um presented in the consent agenda looks looks like it's in good shape um the next item was the fy2 capital projects expenditure review and discuss discussion and as I've put in my finance committee report um several staff members leading up to that meeting there were several staff members and Dr bowling that met ahead of time we reviewed all of the capital projects reports with um transportation operations uh maintenance and so we were all able to

052have um a meeting together to have uh important input regarding the status of the projects and any needs going forward um several of the projects uh was noted several of the projects have been completed um things like the Boyce Elementary School loading dock coie Elementary School bleachers uh several of the HVAC product projects were already completed as well um Safety and Security projects I know Mr taner has had several meetings and identified those uh those needs and and working through those list of items to to uh purchase and get those project going with the grant funds that were received from the um Department of Education and then it was also one of the nice things getting together as the group where everybody can kind of collaborate together it was noted that we'll probably be able

053to to fund quite a lot of the furniture requests that came in with the FY 26 request we'll be able to use the fy2 funding and go ahead and get those those requests taken care of so that was that was definitely a bonus for the meetings any questions about Capital so far um there is a supplemental appropriation request item number three this is fiscal 25 supplemental preparation request for school security Grant there was additional funding of $1,200 from the Virginia Department of Education it is for school security Grant uh equipment and we're requesting the supplemental Appropriations to the capital projects fund so that it can purchase um battery backups for the security equipment for Johnson Williams middle school so that's an appropriation um request and I think the action comes later in the agenda so

054the last item that was discussed at the the meeting was uh for the FY 26 budget items there's a several things that are listed here and um several of the factors and I'll go through a couple of them and I think Dr bowy probably wanted address a couple as well um the composite index does remain at um 6032 that's the same um rate that was included with the fiscal 25 the current year we're in so that will not change um stiens we did have a small discussion about that I know there was an increase last year that's expected to at least remain flat health insurance estimate normally this is a um an item that we don't know until further into the budget it's actually close to the end of February before we really know what

055those numbers will be so there's usually a placeholder for that Dr bowling will include that in his budget presentation um vrs Virginia Retirement System rate changes there won't be any of those for fiscal 26 those remain they're set for two years so this is the second of the two years so that will uh those will stay St stable and then um you know we're in the finance world so we're waiting on that Virginia Department of Education Cal file which would be really nice to see it later this week or really early next week but um it you know it could be as late as the first of the year before it really comes out to us so but there's some other items that um I think the ADM estimate and and scales and things like

056that that I think you wanted to speak to uh yes correct um one thing uh going into it and I think we may get an answer to that C file or at least the budget potentially there are some thoughts that the governor's budget could be released this Wednesday the 18th and the calf could follow shortly thereafter so hopefully maybe later this week or early next week we'll get that I'm hopeful but it could be the beginning of next year one thing the budget right now the Surplus in Virginia stands at estimated between $2.3 and3 billion so um it's been a very good year for the Commonwealth financially and there's a large Surplus but there is concern that the future years may not be as promising so what we're starting to hear initially is more one-time

057Investments instead of ongoing cost some examples may be like additional investments in Virginia retirement system and capital Improvement project grants for school construction and substantial renovation currently we have about 1,847 seven students in Clark County Public Schools my ADM um estimate for next year was based upon moving the kids up grade wise in a formula but then instead of going with the three-year average on kindergarten I went with the 5year average that landed us at1 1850 as an ADM estimate for next fall of course ADM or average daily membership does not include our our prek preschool students so they're not included in that uh an independent company of the University of Virginia uh told me that their ADM estimate or average daily membership would have been 1875 I'm still leaning toward going closer to 1850

058you're staying at 1850 because I would rather get good news than have to make up in the end so what I proposed as our ADM um measure is an average daily membership next fall of 1,850 students one of my biggest points and I'll bring this up over and over in our budget I think anytime we can do it our greatest asset is our people so I would always say that whenever we can investing in our people's I think the most important thing to do so that's all I have unless there's anything else you'd like to ask no I don't have anything else I think just as we start these budget conversations um Katie and I were had had that finance committee meeting so we have talked about some of this stuff so I'll call each

059one of you and then we can kind of start getting ready for the next few months conversation and so when you um shared with us the update um with the Surplus in Virginia it made me feel really optimistic and hopeful and then you know you reminded reminded me quickly of um the the grants that could potentially be available for for capital projects but um because of our LCI that really limits the the grants that we're able to apply for typically yes that would be correct and you can normally they'll allow you to apply for about anything but a lot of times things are competitive based upon current condition showing what you need and then ability of the locality to pay and Virginia typically uses LCI as that measure the last time they did competitive School

060Improvement Grants and not saying it would be the same again but Virginia hasn't done a whole lot as far as providing funding for school construction because typically historically that's been looked at as a locality um responsibility but within the last 5 years there's been quite a few grand opportunities for substantial renovation and construction to schools and those that we we've had so far have been based on deteriorating condition and need of the facility or enrollment increases and another criteria that's weighed on the committee on selection is LCI which is the higher the LCI the less likely you are to receive funding and what Miss Bennett said is uh correct that our LCI will remain at 6032 for this uh current budget year for next year and roughly for anybody who may not be as been

061you know work with LCI on a daily basis or local Composite Index being what that stands for it's basically a percent that the locality has to pick up the overall cost of Education now you still have some federal money but it's not all that significant but if your LCI is 6032 think of that being close to 60% so the locality is going to have to pick up 60% of the cost of the Vision which means the state would only pick up roughly uh 40% of the cost and the highest in LCI can go in the Commonwealth of Virginia's 080 meaning the locality would be paying 80 and the um state would be paying 20 when LCI was developed in 1974 it had a bottom threshold to of 020 meaning that the um least a a

062locality would have to pick up was 20% in the last few years that's changed in code so now there's actually I believe four districts where the state's picking up more than 80% of the cost of education so that number is a big big piece and in a preliminary budget it won't really affect us this coming year but there were concerns that in some localities in the Commonwealth assessments were going up like 40 to 60% and one of the biggest variables in the local Composite index formula is the value of property not necessarily the amount of tax is brought off of it but the value of property um impacts LCI significantly so they said there were some concerns throughout the Commonwealth of how that would impact LCI not in this two-year cycle because it's always a

063two-year cycle but in the next two any other questions NOP okay thank you thank you um I'm going to make a joke but I feel like all the Clapping we've done maybe we should clap for you but I'll go ahead and just clap for you thank you well I think Miss Bennett's wonderful every day in such a tremendous help to us and asset so I think we should clap for her anytime um okay Dr Bing your first superintendent update all right the um what my update for this meeting um it's been a pleasure to get started here about between two and three weeks in something that I was able to go watch um was actually two of our uh winter concerts I was able to watch the high school band Winter concert and the concert

064at Johnson Williams middle school and both of those uh schools their band leadership did a tremendous job and they Des deserve all kinds of praise for what they've done actually the one at the high school it felt like you could have paid a price for a ticket to go see a concert of that caliber and Mr Clark's concert was just really on point and did not it was as polished that it could have been easily a high school concert for Mr Clark to do that I was highly impressed with those one thing that I got to do today that's not on there yet is I got to go read a um holiday book to our grade students down at kie and that was a true pleasure so I was thankful for that opportunity and one

065of our teachers does that invites people in and they unwrap a book to read during this week a couple times a day one thing I'm really excited about is this Friday December the 20th will be the Clark County Citizens Academy education day Chris boy does a great job with that and I think it's very Innovative to have a leadership program that focuses on what's available in the community and we're really excited to have um Clark County Public Schools featured on this Friday so we'll be touring all the schools and doing a presentation with roughly about 24 citizens in regard to the availability of programs in Clark County we've been doing the budget proceedings and where we're at so far as I've been able to meet with each School principal and all the Departments right now

066we're at the point of just kind of collect ing request so the hard work lies ahead but the governor's budget could be released as early as this Wednesday which will give us on the 18th our first kind of view of what might happen in the Commonwealth and really although we may have a little indication until it's released we really don't know so we might get some really good promising news on Wednesday we'll see what comes out if it's released uh some things I think that are very important um these are dates in December but December 2nd was National special education day that day con uh commemorates the 49th anniversary of the nation's first first education law for special education which was the individuals with disability Education Act or idea that was signed into law on

067December 2nd 1975 and I just want to say that really thankful for all of our special Educators and our par professionals that work with students students our parents our students it takes everybody working together so I think that that needs to be noted for their tremendous effort based on our staff the parents and our students so really proud of that another day that I think is important to remember is December 7th was Pearl Harbor Remembrance Day and on December 7th each year we honor and remember the 2,43 service members and civilians who were killed at Pearl Harbor further we remember the 1,178 persons who were injured and I think it's always important for us to remember our armed services and what they do for us and the sacrifices that they make in the past and

068daily so thank you thank you any questions for Dr bowling no okay uh audience comments audience comments are limited to three minutes per person those wishing to speak should F out a speaker's card with Miss Weir Miss we none for this none okay um and then we have public comments on the FY 26 budget as part of the budget development process each year Clark County School Board accepts comments from interested individuals regarding priorities for the upcoming fiscal year please blah blah blah blah blah the okay there'll be a public hearing um a formal public hearing um in regards to the budget on February 10th 2025 anybody yes ma'am Rachel Thompson okay good evening members of the board Dr bowling and Dr seal my name is Rachel Thompson and I'm the Clark County Education Association president

069I would like to thank you for the opportunity to address priorities for the fiscal year 2026 budget tonight I stand here not only as the ccea president but as an advocate for the future of both our students and our staff when looking at the budget I want you to remember that it isn't just numbers on a spreadsheet but a list of our division's commitment to education our values and our priorities the decisions that are made regarding the fiscal year 2026 budget will have an extensive impact on our Schools staff and students educators are the fundamental element in a flourishing School District not only do they teach the curriculum but they also Mentor counsel innovate and Advocate tirelessly for their students they do all of this without a blink of an eye because they care and

070want students to succeed they do all that they can for their students even when they are stretched thin due to increased demands in Li mited resources when discussing the fiscal year 2026 budget please keep in mind the following critical needs competitive salaries we want to retain the phenomenal hardworking staff that we currently have as well as attract new talented staff professional development opportunities we want to ensure that our educators are able to keep up with the evolution of teaching practices the last one is smaller class sizes this is vital in order to ensure that our students are receiving the individualized support that they need as well as reducing teacher burnout when we invest in our staff we also invest in all the students that they encourage Inspire and Empower each student deserves to have access

071to a quality education the fiscal year 2026 budget should also provide Equity such as allocating funds for schools with increased needs in order to ensure that all students have the tools they need to be successful as well as enhanced support services such as intervention Specialists special educ a programs and mental health supports Equity is not just a goal that we as a school system should work towards but it is our responsibility as Educators the fiscal year 2026 budget shouldn't be about just meeting the minimum requirements it should be about exceeding the expectations it's about showing staff students and families that they are a valued priority in Clark County let's work together to build a future for our schools that we can be proud of thank you thank you thank you anybody else no okay um

072consideration of organizational meeting so every year at the beginning of the year we have to have our oh just kidding consider oh do we have to tell talk about cell phone um okay uh I got excited consideration of cell phone policy Dr bowling you want to start off the conversation yes I I'll be glad to um and where this stems from and I'll do just a brief overview on July 9th 2024 Governor yunan issued executive order 33 and that establishes a cell phone pre-education for the Commonwealth of Virginia and in that um executive order it was noted that all public school divisions in the Commonwealth of Virginia must uh submit a policy and pass a policy by January 1st 2 some of the definitions that were important in that um executive order which was Bell

073to Bell which meant that no cell phone use or any other electronic communication device used between the first Bell of the school day and the very end of the dismissal Bell the um cell phone free education Pol U executive order and the guidance for a policy What followed and I believe this was in August of 2024 was a draft one of the or and it may have been Late July but it's either Late July or August an initial draft of Rec of how you would guidance of how you would make your policy and then on December 16th 2024 final guidance on how to create this policy came forward it differentiated schools at at three levels and gave you criteria that if you weren't exactly the same configuration as met that within it that you would

074how you would proceed for instance if you don't have middle schools and you had Ka that told you which level that would go with the one thing that this was almost tailor made for Clark County being that the first category is elementary schools K5 which um clearly meets our model and it says that in K5 elementary schools cell phones will not be used by elementary students anytime on school grounds is the minimum guidance there if they're brought to school they must be turned off and stored away there are several options for being stored away that just can't be on the person some options include lockers book bags shoe pouches over the door there's some vendors that make lockers for putting away cell phones now you know some other things of that nature in GR 628

075Middle School it is um exactly basically the same thing is Elementary the only difference is there's some consideration to sports and school after school activities when you hit Middle School in high school the minimum guidance is the cell phone will be off and powered away and stored from the first Bell of the day to the dismissal Bell is the minimum guidance but it does say that uh cell phones at the high school level under the guidance were suggested to be able to be used until the first Bell Rings there on campus and after the dismissal Bell like during sporting events and stuff of that nature uh there were um exemptions allowed to the cell phone free education policy if you um were to request an accommodation it was approved those could come through individualized education

076plans 504 plans or healthc care plans and those would have to be done on a one by one individualized basis so that would be like most things in these type of special needs um education Arenas will be determined by the individualized education plan the team has to make the decision so it's a team decision and we would have to have approval of our director of special education and student services it was recommended that if you can come up with an alternative as opposed to using a cell phone for a modification you should do that for instance if a kid could use a school-based iPad as opposed to a cell phone that could do the same function if it was something along those lines those are the um guidelines as issued by the final guidance we

077do have to turn our policy into the state before we leave for break so that's something we're going to have to do I was able to draft two policies up one of them completely complies with the executive order and the other does not it is lacking in one area if you look at version one it complies with the Executive Order final guidance except for high school lunch and transition time version one only prohibits cell phones and other electronic devices during instructional time at the high school level yet all other parts of version one comply with the final guidance and we do have this kind of throughout the Commonwealth and we don't know how many districts are in each category as of yet but there are a number of districts who have fully complied with the

078guidance and some actually even made rules that were more harsh than the final guidance and seeing that this has being something we need to tackle there are very few schools districts that have allowed cell phone use during transition times at levels below high school and there's a few of those um probably the most two prevalent types of this policy currently are the ones that fully comply and the ones that fully comply except for high school lunch and transition time now I do think the goals of this policy were commendable and are commendable the governor um both thinks that we need to focus on educational priorities and learning while we're in school but there's also concern that cell phones may be doing in extensive screen time and use may be doing some mental harm to people

079long term in comparison of seeing social media all day and comparisons to other people and not having true face-to-face social Communications I would say I do see that as being accurate and I have concerns along that line but I also have concerns along that line for adults too and I think that we need to be good role models and not be you know hypocritical in it as well so I think that it's important for us to try to think that we need to not be communic connected so much every day and looking at a screen as well I don't think that this just applies to our youth so I think this is all with the best of intentions and actually I can see both sides of this argument the only thing that concerns me is

080we're at the middle of a year and changing in the middle of a year I don't think is drastically is the ideal time and you know I think that we could look at the one that allows transition at high school lunch by making sure we get it down pat at the elementary and middle levels which is pretty much what we're already doing but just making it part of our policy and I think that would allow our high schools to get it down pack during instructional time and I think it's always good to be transparent and honest too that in that policy and I think it's important and always try to be aware and cognizant of it it but it mentions that adults that work for us will not use cell phones texting or calling unless

081it's an emergency anytime they supervise students or or in front of a classroom so I think that gives us a lot to get in good shape as an initial step is my thought and also we've got a whole lot going on in the Commonwealth of Virginia right now with the Virginia literacy act new math and reading standards a new accountability framework and I always believe that you look at implementation and listen to the leadership in your buildings um although I think this has the greatest of intentions sometimes writing something to do is one thing but having to implement it is quite another so I really leaned on our Administration to see which one they supported and I believe that we have more support for um version one at this point I can see both sides

082of this so I'll be transparent say the reason that I would recommend version one is because it seems to be consensus of the our leadership team and who would be implementing it having said that I have heard other districts mentioned that they have passed a policy close to version one and said they were going to see how it went this semester and reconsider for next year if it didn't have the effect that they wanted so if we were to go with version one there's nothing to say that we couldn't go with version two or somewhere between or somewhere even more strict or develop our own policy thereafter but to be quite honest too we could go with version two which is the fully complied and back down if it didn't work or give us the

083results it could go either way but this is a policy that can be amended you know if we find that we want to go a different direction once again I think that this is one of those that I can see both sides of it I think that either one of them would be a step in the right direction I just think that whatever we do we need to implement with Fidelity because if we don't do that it's not going to matter the words have to have meaning behind them and that I'll let you all discuss it and if you have any questions of me I'll try to answer those um Mr bubeck can start with you um the version one policy if I understand is what the current policy is now with for the most

084part for the most part in the high school um I guess um I hear the the concerns about implementation uh trying to think about what the actual goal of of this directive from the from the state or even just amongst us what uh this as a board is to do what's what's best for the students and um it's a it's a split issue Bas based on what I've heard from from my constituents and people I've reached out to it's it's about 50/50 um but I will I will not quote but I'll say what one person said to me and a parent was was talking about I guess what she wanted was probably the the the more laxed version the version one for communications with her kids but if she really thought about what's best for

085the student it would be the the uh version to the the adoption of what the governor's saying the Bell to Bell in high school um I mean I have a a lot of reasons I think we should go that way um the implementation is is is tough but I do think there's a problem and I I think the DAT is out there that supports that without cell phones the educational environment is better and kids will perform um and I I I recognize that there's going to be a a pretty steep learning curve and some frustration and uh but I think that will settle down after a little bit so I'm not finished talking I can't keep going on forever but we'll see what the rest of the board says but that I I'm leaning more

086toward a more strict policy um the Bell yeah I I I know there were some people that some of the major concerns that I received were uh in an emergency situation being able to talk to your kid uh my my thought on that is that is even more of a reason to not have a phone because if there is an emergency situation how do you not want any student to be messing around with the phone I want them to be listening to that teacher or that SRO officer and and doing what they should be doing and um you know you could have a whole class adhere to that but one phone going off uh making noise or somebody not following instructions because they're on the phone trying to to answer something or or or call

087something I I think that's a serious ious concern and uh um uh that that's my response to emergency situations I know there's communication that parents want to have um if we implement the version one policy kids aren't supposed to have their phones during instruction time and so probably the fastest way for a parent to get in touch with their student is to call the office and make that uh uh the administration can interrupt class and say hey uh so and so has a has an issue they they're they're leading their parents are on their way to pick them up so when you think about the the practicality of it all I I I think version two actually lend lends itself to pretty much a a good thing in in all Fields other than it's going

088to make our secretary work pretty dagam hard initially with with phone calls but any just of my thoughts and I reserve the right to bring up some more uh Mr Wilson Madam shair uh I tend to mostly agree with uh the arguments that Mr brumbach has presented uh this the problem seems to come with two there three aspects one is enforcement which is a school uh this is not a democracy the students don't get a vote that's simple that's simple uh particularly it's a state mandate which may be we may have to go to version two whether we like it or not down the road anyway uh as far as emergencies the last thing these kids need to be doing is get on a phone to call Mommy and Daddy are having mommy and daddy

089calling them they need to be as Mr brumbach pointed out listening to the safety officers and to their teachers uh the other thing is well as a change in plans most of these changes of plans should have been implemented at home the night before at breakfast before they left for school and the fact that an appointment has been changed or something is not justification to alter a policy uh and we do have the school uh Personnel who can advise anybody if it's a serious business you know somebody's been in an accident or something like that yeah that's fine but we can get word to them they don't need have a cell phone and I think part of then now we'll get to the personal part of it I am tired of seeing family sitting there

090in a restaurant and everybody's got one of these damn things in his or her hand they're not talking to one another they're not making contact with one another and I'm starting to see it with some of the kids and their parents you talk to somebody and you if you go into an uh HR person to get a job and you're sitting there like like this wan to be on your telephone you're not going to get the job that simple or to get that University slot we need to start interfacing I guess that's the word with one another once again and we are not doing it by uh AB betting the problem and the other the other last thing that comes to me I wouldn't mind we call these things cell phones but they're not uh

091telephone is something on which you have to speak you do not have to speak speak on these things and this is part of the problem the kids are sitting there in class doing this under the desk and they are not learning because they're more focused on something else on top of this just a an extra issue and it's getting into a whole different field is this whole business of cyber bullying uh without these things certainly in school they can't be bullied in school and I don't know and nobody seems to be willing to tell the parents look your kid doesn't have to have the fanciest phone in school if you have one of these flip phones they could call you you could call them they could dial 911 and they could talk to their friends

092uh they couldn't they wouldn't be bullied there's no social uh social pages on there that's my feeling so as you may have deduced by now I am in favor of option two thank you thank you Mr Kennedy I definitely see all the the um the concerns on both sides I do um I have obviously a vested interest with a 15-year-old and I understand your concerns everyone's concerns with people you know sitting at the dinner table whatever um our jobs here are to manage the schools not the the home life you know we can tell parents that all day long but um you know some of that starts at home I look at the the policy it starts with basically the introduction of the cell phone into the schools isn't until the high school level um

093based on the policy itself and I feel like that part of that too is our secondary education is to prepare them for college and they're going to have that tool there at all times with them as well um so there's something a different side of the ins you know of the thing ining into that as we prepare them to the to to go on to universities or trade schools or work or whatever um I understand that they're you know they need to be talking to people and uh having that interface and everything else that goes along with it but um I do feel like it's it will be challenging for administration to Marshal the cell phone usage at any level and know what I know from talking to students and everything else um Administration would

094have a similar struggle with managing and marshalling the teachers or to your point Dr Bowen the volunteers that come in tutors that come in that are used to being in the outside world and now they're standing in front of a classroom and so they put up the you know the lesson for the day and then they go get on their device whatever that may be whether it's a cell phone or or an iPad or or whatever um so there's going to be a sense or or concern for hypocrisy in in that instance as well so um that's that's my opinion on it we've all grew up in a time when when parents would we we would we'd get everything scheduled for the day and if there was an issue that came out that happened during

095the day our parents called the SE secretary got us a note sent to class whatever the case may be but it is um challenging with our limited staff for sure so I'm I'm think in in my opinion I want to support the um the administrators of the school they I think they feel similarly that that's going to be a challenge for them and so I I'm supporting version one so excuse me question Mr Kennedy it's a valid argument but it's you're going to have no less of a problem if the state mandates this which it very well may right now we've got an option we got version one or version two they may decide to come down with version two and then the school better be thinking and as I'm sure they are already of

096how they're going to implement this rule so uh the idea that well whatever they feel like and any teacher who's sitting there fiddling with a his uh iPhone when he suppos were paying him $50,000 plus a year to teach I'm sorry I have an issue with that too so uh and I realize the world is what the world is but we can do what we can to change it and make it better M hbert oh sorry okay M so I agree with what Dr bowling was saying that um I see the value in in both versions um and you know read through all of the comments that we've received throughout the community which um we had a lot of input and I really appreciate that um because sometimes we don't hear anything until we make

097a decision and then you know everyone's alarmed and upset um you know the the two themes that I came away with in in favor of students being able to have their phones are for convenience and and for emergencies and really I don't even want to say this out loud but um there aren't many emergency situations that that the children of Clark County have been in um you know in terms of school shootings and that kind of thing um so we're you know that doesn't happen often emergencies um the convenience factor I just read a couple Snippets from um the book that kind of initiated all of this um uh the anxious generation and one of the the points made is that you know parents don't want their children to lose their phones because of the

098convenience that it provides to the adult and not it does provide convenience to the student but it does help the parent out quite a bit um and then we heard a lot from from staff members regarding cheating um and you know the impact that the negative impact that phones are having in the classroom um and so really I am in favor of version two but I don't think right now is the time to to move with that um because of it being January and I just think about how how do you how do you imp like and and for those of you who are in favor of version two how do you f are we going to follow students around in the hallways and and say you've got your phone out you've got your phone

099out like so you know our staff is already struggling with vaping in bathrooms and and other issues that are far greater than cell phones and I I I don't know what the answer is in terms of implementation and having a good relationship a good rapport with students if you're if you're constantly following them around like put put your phone away put your phone away especially in between classes and at lunch and then it's you know it's kind of similar to hats like for and I don't know what the policy is on hats in in schools but I remember being a teacher like take your hat off okay and they smile and Nod and they do and then they slip it right back on so I think that it it's just difficult to rester a ship

100halfway through the year I'm in favor of working towards version two to start August 2025 um and the state may reject us us saying version one they may reject version one anyway but I also expect that if we do version one that it's understood that phones are not out during class and I've listened to podcasts and and other things about about this issue and you know people can't even like last 5 minutes in line in the grocery store without picking up your phone and like what's going on like it's like we don't know how to be bored anymore and that's seems to be like the go-to in classes just based on conversations with students um that I've had that okay you're finished all your work that's fine you can get on your phone and we're

101really they're really not supposed to be on their phon anyway so I think that we do need to bump it up in terms of like this it is expected that the phones are away during class time and I don't know that that's that's happening right now so I don't if and do you all have any thoughts on like you know chasing kids around in the hallways with their phones I like you know and when you're on duty as a teacher in between classes and you're making sure that kids aren't fighting or you know whatever getting into Mischief um like that's going to add an element I also though question like I mean I I really can totally see both sides I've also thought to myself well if you get your phone out for the first

102time in between classes and it's four minutes are are the tardy rates going to increase because you've got my phone and I I just want to finish this one text I don't know I I I don't have an answer and I'm not going to implement it like I'm not going to be the one like who's on Deck yeah yeah so I'm kind of the mindset if you're going to go go you need to go whole hog and that means no phones well I don't know how to implement that but that takes care of it I if there were no phones it would be the that'd be the easiest thing for for staff cuz then if you see one at all then you take it it goes the office and it and it's done you don't

103have any more issue with the day the allowing allowing usage during transition time exactly your point if is it's it's four minutes between class I mean really what's the point and that's part of the part of the issue there's you know some of the some of those comments received or from what I've heard you know uh some of the kids that aren't behaving too well are are videoing during that time or in the bathroom doing things and it it's just you know we we've created this problem because we've allowed it in in the schools to begin with and I know people will say well that's the new normal I can't stand that phrase just because it's normal doesn't mean it's it's good or or is beneficial to to whatever it is and it's nobody can

104nobody can say that they have never looked at their child or or or or athlete if they're coaching and and didn't say hey put the phone away it it it just happens and it and sometimes I think whether it's an adults or kids that you you're going to have to be forced to deal with with something and and it's going to be tough no matter what I mean the implementation the question is What's um what's the easiest or what's uh how's it going to affect staff I mean if we've already got this policy in place but we're going to actually put teeth to it because I've heard that even though we've had this policy it's not really executed like what we're saying it should be so either policy is going to have to have some

105growing pains and and and and staff is going to have to administer it regardless of what what we decide on if the governor okay or the state okay is our version one policy if that's what we passed or the version two policy we still got to implement it there's no getting away from it right I don't know what to what's easier that's why it's almost and one thing that I that I forgot to say when I was talking um are you finished sorry interrupt you um so I I did send Dr bowling a number of questions from the the VOE um guidance that we received like early September and so there are a lot of um safety things that are brought up in that in the guidance packet and so some of them are like

106um you know having paper copies um in case of an emergency to like for um our principles to or whoever administrators like if if the kids have to go leave campus Because of shooting or whatever um that those emergency materials are are ready to go and so there were a number of questions that I had for Dr bowling and they're all supposed all of these things are supposed to be addressed or should be addressed in our emergency plan and what I question is I think we approved our emergency plan like in August or early September and then this guidance comes out after August early September and so now I'm like well do we have this do we have this do we have this and so I think again version one buys us like six months

107or however much time to make sure that these emergency things are in place and that so that that was another thought of mine because it is important the emergency piece of this because it's a it's a it's a concern that that we never had as children in high school school shootings and there was one that happened today in is in Wisconsin it's a valid concern that our kids feel scared or have it in the back of their heads that that could happen and so we owe it to them to make sure that our emergency plans are as tight as they possibly can be and so I like that this guidance P this packet that we received has a lot of information or has a lot of points that we need to consider in our emergency

108plan and that may already be a thing that you all receive every year from from the state but this seemed more detailed than what I've ever seen we don't um it's more detailed and how that got included if you look at the initial draft of policy guidance it didn't include that a few of the districts throughout the Commonwealth one of the main concerns was about emergency situations so what the booe did was said well in your crisis plans that each school board has to approve before the start of each school year all these things should be addressed and these are things that are in there um and I was able to answer those questions and went with more clarification um from Rand and Randy was able to get us all that information so we certainly

109have all those pieces in place um but those are things that you would approve before each school year starts is where those crisis plans went it was kind of more like an appendix not part of the cell phone policy but saying that these things would go in your annual crisis plans um normally they're approved right at the beginning of August like right before the school year starts because you have to have them in place um for the beginning of the school year just a few things you all brought up and then I'll kind of um let you all continue leading that one of the things about emergency situations and actually everybody that's giving any guidance on this for an emergency says actually you're better off not to have them in the rooms at that time

110because typically if you have 25 cell phones in 20 rooms jamming up lines during a crisis situation it's actually going to make the situation more wor I think what you get with cell phones is comfort and I'm never going to downplay that as being a parent myself cuz I think heaven forbid a tragic situation every parent's going to want Comfort but as far as actually being productive and getting out correct information instead of misinformation and not jamming up the phones when emergency responders are coming actually having them in the rooms on on a lot of kids would do more harm uh there was an article that was written related to Ron Oak City Public Schools policy and theirs that they passed fully didn't didn't fully comply but what was asked was um someone reached out

111to the Virginia Department Ed and said what will happen if your policy not in compliance by January 1st this will be the first time related to an executive border that that we're going to get individual guidance on everybody's policy and the response from the VOE is the majority of Virginia Public School divisions have implemented bell-to-bell policies and we look forward to the remaining divisions continuing to move in this direction and that was by Todd Reed who's one of the senior administrators there at the bdoe that was his response on what would come to follow one thing we are going on in Uncharted Territory is once we submit this we're going to get guidance back and then we'll have to proceed at that point um the one version is almost identical to what we've done some

112of the differences are it includes some guidelines for staff in our schools and adults posting on social media during the day and it puts the consequences in writing which had not been those are the new parts one thing that I had thought about um our elementary and middle um front office administrative assistance receptionist who do tremendous work are accustomed to this but high schools are incredibly busy places so it would with a lot of practice and stuff move a lot of work off and you know initially it would be an uptick in the amount of messages to our front office administrative assistance um one thing I think that we're everybody I think that it does c has a potential to cause anxiety and you compare yourself to others if you glance down and you see

113something that's happened traumatic then it can really alter the course of your day and thinking too something that someone brought up brought something to mind of me is if one of your parents were in an accident or something during the day you know the administrative assistant and the principal could get that to you if potentially and we live in a community Nationwide or worldwide where everybody wants to put everything instantly on social media there is always the risk that somebody's going to post something that's happened traumatic to your family and you may see it that way which is concerning one of the things I think though that all this misses is that we need longterm to be educating our kids and our adults and everybody employees on when to use cell phones when it's appropriate

114and to have this conversation in general it's yet another thing though that would get added on to schools but the appropriate use of cell phones I think is something that anyway we need to talk about with our kids as we prepare them for the work world and the real world and regardless of whatever policy model that we go on I think all of our adults myself included need to be go good Role Models I think for myself not pulling a cell phone out in front of a kid or anybody 10 15 years ago I would have been so on edge to do it because we had a board that was one ful but was retired administrators at the time and they weren't as relevant that if a cell phone got seen in the hands of

115a principal or assistant principal or teacher in the high school 10 15 years ago you certainly heard about it now I think even myself I don't use them much but if I'm in a panic you know it happens and I think that we all need to be aware and be good role models in doing this that including myself if I go in a building in front of kids I need to be mindful that no matter what comes on that I need to wait till I exit and them away from kids to be a good role model for it um the one thing though that I do think we absolutely have to keep in the policy and it's in either one is to allow them to be carried on the person of Staff just so they're

116on silent because um in case there is an emergency and they're outside I would want staff to have that on them um I just want to just say a couple things so we are talking specifically about cell phones but this policy says all other personal electronic devices including but not limited to headphones earbuds SmartWatches and other bluetooth enabled devices good batter or IND different whether it's a big deal or not I mean smart watches right and we know a lot of kids wear that too so what we're also saying again whether it's a big deal or not we're also saying potentially they can't they can't wear those either right so that I wanted to highlight um the other thing I wanted to say is I agree with everything about version two I agree with everything

117everybody has said so I won't go into it again um I do feel like if we do go to version two I just I feel like there needs to be more thought put into the implementation I do think it's I do think it will be difficult um but I understand and can appreciate what you both are saying about it um so um and when you think about the attendance stuff we have to keep track of I mean these counselors they're constantly calling parents where are you where are your kids they haven't been here for three days right we've got um Virginia literacy act we have this accountability program there is a lot going on while that not is not meant to be an excuse It's reality right and this whole cell phone smart smart watches

118whatever it is will be Mr Kennedy mentioned the word Marshall but we'll we're going to there's going to be an expectation that our Administration is going to sort of be on top of this I just feel like we're not and I think Miss kobert said it about you know we're starting I don't know who said it January 1 we're already halfway into the year right I just feel like if we go with version one we're kind of already doing it I think we can be a little more strict about it the states going to come back they might say nope we need you to go to version two we'll go to version two and we can Implement for 25 26 um I just I think it's a lot right now um and and the one

119other thing I Al want to say is um you mentioned how this is convenience for the parent when we implemented this a few years ago um maybe four years ago where we were already doing this about cell phones not being um not being allowed right they had to be in the backpack more parents complained about it than the kids again I appreciate you saying we have to do what's best for kids I think social media is you know you know isn't good for any of us but um more parents complained about that than kids so when I speak to version one I'm just out loud saying is it going to be a lot for administration yes is it going to be huge for parents absolutely will kids get used to it sure right all all

120to say though I don't think we're ready for version two I think we could start off with version version one and then um EAS into to version two um I do not want to put Mis wearing on the spot but I sort of do sorry I care for you so much um do you have anything I mean I know we know how you all feel about it but do you want to add anything else I absolutely agree that instruction needs to be cell phone headphone free um I do believe that kids need some downtime at lunch um they do have conversation at lunch um but you are correct a lot of it comes from parents who want to communicate with their children and that is where the the conversations will come and we will follow

121whatever the ums yeah I think that'll be a bigger rub than than um the kids being upset about so that's just so I'm obviously leaning towards version one um as well um but if we have to go to version two I'm also you know again at the beginning of the school year I'm also one thing and and this is just the culture and I I almost view this as as is making a stand but I bet if you talk to every employer school system uh included the the biggest hit and detriment to Workforce productivity is the cell phone whether that's an employees spouse calling because because they have the ability to contact them right then and there and I see that the same thing is with with with kids at school and I and I

122understand parents wanting to update with a change in plan but it's so readily available it it it really has to be a different mindset and it's not going to be a different mindset unless you take that away yeah and I don't know and you know I think we're all on the same page we all see the see what's happening but but trying to actually do it is is the is the challenge and I don't know is there a difference really putting it in place now putting it in place in the fall we're going to have the same issues par the parents that don't like it or that are having you know issue with it are going to have an issue then it's going to be a a huge change for those kids and and the

123same arguments so when are we going to do it are we just going to keep cooking the can down the road or do you make a stand and and make a big change too that's the other thing this policy is already in effect and if we're after which I think we all want an improvement in education whatever that comes from better resources better uh you know smaller ratio to class sizes more focus and attention from the student on the instructor we and and and that's really what where we're at here right this this shouldn't be coming from a state mandate this should be coming from everybody that cares about students you know let's let's let's get your focus on what it should be focused on right and at some point that's we're going to it

124needs to happen and I and I and I you know so when when are we going to do it these kids that are graduating right now that are going on into the workforce I mean if you get you uh good balles and I'll say good bosses and tough they're they're going to run up against it when they pull out their phone and and and the boss says hey one more time and you're out of here it's a tough lesson but I'd rather learn it in high school than when they got a job it's just something to think about and and I guess I totally get the implementation and all the stuff but where are we at what what's it look like the implementation of of our version one which we're already doing or or or

125two how's how is that different and where is the benefit as far as the the load on the staff I I don't know that and I know that's it we need to think that through and that that leads to your hey can we push it off I don't know what if we can't what if the state as no you have to be in compliant so to me it seems like well we better figure it out anyway regardless but at least so to miss kober's point though it does give us some time right so here's the thing if we go with version two and we try to implement and we fail who who do you think who's going to be upset at who the we're probably going to put it on the high school and say

126we put this policy in place and it's not being followed right and again I think I am not disagreeing with you I agree with everything you've said I just think we need time to think about what this looks like and to your point the state might come back and say um the state might come back and say nope we're going to reject this you need to go do you need to go to version two which is fine I still don't think we're going to implement till 25 26 right because we might not hear from them until marchish right oh that's that's I guess that's my next question what really is the timeline for the State uh and you can see based on Dr bowling's um uh notes about when someone asked the question and how

127that whoever responded I'm sorry I don't remember was pretty vague I mean that's kind of what's hen they're not even they put through they put this executive order in place but they're still pretty vague when people are asking very specific questions it was a ready shoot aim mentality I feel like it's a what a ready shoot aim mentality no you're exactly right um you know and my my deal Clay is um a a midyear roll out is going to be challenging anyway I think I and and the summer provides a break a clean break to say okay when you come back this is it so and that's that's my thought on it but I just think if we're going to do version two I'd rather be closer to succeeding on how we're going to implement

128than not and I hear what you're saying about well implementation what does that look like you're right I don't know we don't know and then that's something miss wearing is going to have to figure out right Dr bowling and so now we're saying this is going into effect theoretically January 1 everybody's going on holiday right so again I mean I I I agree with two I think you know to some I think it's the right thing to do I just think that if we're going to do it we got to do we we need to do it well and um I'm just worried we're not prepared just yet for that I'm not saying it it's not doable I'm just saying we just need to give more time maybe we ought to try to implement it

129for the next semester and then when it is implemented if it's a total failure there'll only be a a month or two a month of school left but I I I I I'm just I'm saying we're kicking it we're kicking the can down the road yeah and and and the other thing is too the the and we say this our number one our number one concern is the safety of our students and staff and if there is an emergency that something going on shooter situation and those kids have the phone not one of you can tell me that those phones aren't going to be pulled out and they're going to uh record or they're going to call whatever and that can't happen that cannot happen because that's uh the students have got to be paying

130attention to what their teacher says it's a it's a huge risk yeah and and so the emergency emergency situation I think does nothing but but uh Lyn support for version two if I as a as a parent I am definitely not going to be uh calling my kid because I want them to be paying attention and do it exactly what the instructor said or I want them to be quiet if they're in a situation but a majority of the come on Clay majority of the parents are not going to be helping that right they to on the flip side one second Mr if I can just finish on the flip side we're saying okay kids need to be paying attention in class 100% when something like this happens 100% we also know parents are already

131going to be freaking out right calling their kids if they have phones if they don't have phones they will I was going to use a wrong word for this um thing but they will be calling sure they will right and so e either way you're looking at this right and I'm not again it's kind of hard I'm looking you know it's both sides sort of double-edged Sword right that we can say okay at least kids will be paying attention but I just feel like the the fear and the um you know all the I guess the fear right from the parents side that will just exponentially um sort of be crazy I don't want to say crazier but become probably a little more to handle and we already know that that's going to that would

132be something that would be really difficult right again double- edged swords well I mean yeah but if if there our policies for what we do in in emergency situations things are going to be released they'll be released and and um all the more reason for the kids not to have a phone period I I I hear you sorry Mr Wilson yeah we're talking about what is convenient what is compliant with regulations and what is compliant with Norms just to give you a sense of perspective when I went to high school 75% of of this nation smoked and you are no more influenced by ads for High-Tech today than we were for uh cigarettes and most of the family smoked how many people in this room have ashtrays out out of tables in their homes every

133home in America just about had an asay out even if you didn't smoke yourself your guest would come and do it and part of a a write a passage to adulthood was starting to smoke now we're down to what 25% as a nation now and going down all the time because somebody decided to do what was right instead of what was expedient and uh not not say well everybody does it well everybody did it but it was bad and people were dying more and more people were dying from cigarette related uh uh problems then they went to the smokeless tobacco about 40 years ago until the kids Jaws started rotting away you know with uh oral cancer sometimes you just have you should do what's right and that's what this board is for we're not

134uh making this thing work that's their job our job is to make sure that we set a standard of behavior what is best for these kids not what is convenient for the parents want to change uh somebody's tea time changed or somebody's hairdressing appointment changed and the kids got to know no it's about what what is really right what these kids need and as Mr brumbach said you going a job today people don't want you it's a safety hazard be fooling with these things and the time to learn this why we we don't just send kids to school to learn math in uh Virginia standards of learning and all this and literacy act we sent them there to learn how to among other things how to be good useful citizens and I think this is

135something maybe we should do just based on that I'll end it there thank you very much did you want to say something um I I I still stick to the fact that I don't I I think version two's the way direction we should be heading I think a midyear roll out's a bad idea that's a midyear roll out's a bad idea so that's just m one second did you have any okay go ahead clay um well however the vote is whatever whatever version like I said we still have implementation to put in and if it's if it's just a continuation of our our current policy which is version one then we better really enforce it yeah no agree and I think that's tough I think that's going to be a burden on the on the

136teachers but I would also like to say that I I think we should try the best we can to come up with an imple implementation strategy for version two and and get it out there as soon as possible I I I everybody everybody I would think maybe not everybody but if you really just focus on what's best for the kids what's easier for the teachers is no cell phones period I mean if if the people are really honest and and the convenience factor is I I get it but that's just going to take a little bit of time of of figuring that out and I would think in the end it's probably a good thing for everybody parents adults we've lost that and that's the ability to communicate the ability to to to um set

137a plan and rely on that plan we our society is so fast and and we and we change things so often because we can because we can communicate everybody and sometimes that's tougher than than you think instant gratification it is it's instant gratification if we you know we have a meeting and we I can fit this in I'll just let everybody know we'll reschedule well that's a nightmare getting a hold of everybody but we've fallen into that trap mhm and these kids are learning that so anyway I whatever however the vote turns out we we've got to have teeth with with either one which is going to require effort from staff and and and teachers and it's it's going to be tough regardless um if we need time to figure out exactly how best to

138implement a more strict policy then okay I'm still going to I'm still going to vote for version two right now but I would I would really push that we get that get plans and and maybe try to roll it out and for the mere fact yeah if it doesn't work and there's only a month left to school then it's only a month but maybe they get a taste and of what it's going to be like when they're or what it should be like when they're at a job and they and they they have they can't just answer this phone call from their buddy to talk and how well or how badly either one of these versions uh is not accepted is not the word I want is implemented is going to depend on the attitude

139with which it's presented if we say G kid we really feel your pain we don't like it either it's it's an inconvenience you know but look we kind of got to do this so let's play along with it no this is a rule it is for the benefit of you to make you better students and better citizens down the road and there going to be a lot of rules out there you drive drunk you lose your license uh you speed a couple times you lose your license uh this is life that's the way it is you beat your girlfriend up you go to jail you know this There are rules and usually the rules are not put in there to aggravate people they're put it in there as a necessity so that we can have

140a functioning Society so that's the way they should be preser it um just a few things y'all mentioned I think as far as what will happen in as far as months and stuff I think that would be important to your consideration one thing that Mr Wilson said that I thought was really insightful and is really important to me and I remember this message being conveyed one time about what real leadership is and leaders don't say I'm doing this because the state told me I had to or you don't lead a building and say I'm doing this because the school board and superintendent said it you should buy into stuff and do it because it's what's right for kids and I think that is ultimately very important to the successful implementation of anything you do is

141to take ownership in it and sometimes you take ownership in it even when you don't agree with it 100% like when you look at the new accountability framework there's I I agree with it overall as far as being good goals for us for kids but there's a few things in it I don't agree with but I have to take ownership of doing overall what's best for students as far as the win piece um and if we don't get this we cross it and we get there but what's in there is every District must have a policy ready to enforce by January 1st of 2025 so we have to turn whatever policy in that we pass before we leave for winter break and then it has to be implemented the first day of next semester so

142basically we're going to have this whatever's passed from January 1st until if there were a revision now what's going to happen is the way that it was presented to me was after we the Boe gets back from break they're going to comb through all these policies and it may take a couple two three months but there in February or March um individual divisions would be emailed back feedback on what they need to do with their policy which is kind of similar to how they did the Virginia literacy plans and then you would probably have to go through a first read second read again so that's kind of that timeline there I've certainly done a whole lot of things that you know are not perfect one thing I will say though is um I'm proud to

143say I've never texted my kids during the school day because I've always tried to be a person of integrity and think if we're going to do this I think we all need to take an inward journey and say am I doing what's right and modeling it correctly and I remember having this conversation recently with a group of principles and they were all good people and but they come from different viewpoints and the high school principal said to some of our other principl said to two or three other principles in the room said well you all would be the ones that would have the hardest time with this CU I can't get you all to quit texting your kids during the day and they were principles of other buildings and uh so I think that I

144said whatever we do we have to take ownership of and do it right um and um and to support that but um I think this has all been very productive discussion and whatever you all decide to pass I know that myself and Leadership will enforce it to the best of our ability now if you pass one and you don't like it in March either way all remember any board member can ask for something to be put on a board agenda to be brought back up so if you think that whatever way this passes that you can bring it back up to consider another policy and you can even consider something above those policies or request that I write something different but I do think it does take courage to kind of change things I think

145those are commendable points and something Mr Wilson brought up that I had not thought about is the ashtrays argument so I sitting here thinking about that and I think that's very correct you know that smoking has definitely taken a big downturn in the United States and I think that was out of good information and I'm certainly of the age I can remember going to any adult's house as a kid and they all had them whether they did it or not and some of them even had invested in furniture that were like decorative ones on stand so I don't think you could buy those anymore so change does happen kids can't make asteres and art class anymore for Christmas presents for their parents Kitty you were going to say something I feel like it's irrelevant but

146um I remember right before I left teaching um Lowden County had implemented a a policy of bring your own technology to the classroom and so we had fourth graders because that was the age group that I worked with bringing a cell phone laptop tablet whatever so it's just it's drastically different than than what it was I don't know 10 years ago I'm not sure how long ago it was that that I left but um so I think that that to Mr W Wilson's point we are seeing some course correction um and it needs to happen especially coming out of um covid and maybe this is time too for more um teachers and and people involved in the school system to read the anxious generation and to really do some insightful you know kind of soul

147searching on you know some of the points that Dr bowling was making that um what do I need to change as a parent and again I'm going to break this up but I I know it's a little nitpicky but just an example of of how of implem a is I mentioned that we're talking about smart watches too these kids are going to be wearing those smart watches you can I'm you can't see mine on my sleeve you can't see Katie's right so now are we asking our principles and teachers right one kid's going to be like oh I saw soand so at a smartwatch and they were texting so now we're saying okay these teachers better be looking on all these kids' wrists right that's kind of a little dramatic but if we're saying we

148want to implement this that's what I mean either one is going to be uh it's going to require effort that's that's version one that you're right that's version one that's sort of what's the easiest to impl no you're right I yes you're right you know yeah it would it's it would be a it would be a a pill to swallow but the easiest is wipe it all out leave it in the car figure out some locker and it then it's not an issue you're all right that the smart watches is actually a lot harder piece of this earbuds and cell phones are easier than the watches because technically to implement the model guid lines we should be W looking at every kid's wrist when they come in and if it's a smart watch thring it

149away it's crazy and not the others and that's a massive task that's why they're kind of written the policies are written to be unless it becomes apparent that they're texting with it calling or video and that we wouldn't treat it because a lot of watches that are not smart watches now that are just like digital time pieces look just like a smartwatch and you really can't tell the difference so actually the SmartWatches is the hardest part of this whole thing and I sat here defending it thinking it was version two but you're right it's version one too yeah you're right yeah yeah that's what I mean either way it's going to be a burden and I have a smartwatch I have a a Garmin for running it's not an Apple Watch I can't text on

150it but it's a smartwatch like I can I could receive so like are you gonna I mean fight with students about you can't wear a Garmin Runner I don't know it's just it's it's interesting it's I will say I I do support version two in the same vein I will say I am incredibly um nervous that we won't be able to implement it properly especially with the time given which we are basically saying a week right and for parents to to get the memo right and students um so that's that's why I want version one I agree with version two but I just feel like we I I think we I if we're going to do this we need to implement it right and I think we need to give um Administration time to to

151figure that out and what how you know what it looks like so how much time you want to give them if everybody's if I'm hearing it how much time so I'm saying I'm saying let's hear so my personal opinion is we see what the state does if the state's going to kick it back to us I still don't think we should implement it until 25 26 so I mean that's kind of where I'm landing um August you mean are we vote new school year sorry we have to vote this season yeah we have to I mean we can kick this but also um this we haven't discussed this but um with iep's 504 plans and and medical plans it also provides time to uh really look at how to change an I like what to

152change in the in the IEP what to change in the education plan for the student with the disability and good do we like what does it look like how often does the student um use whatever piece of assist of Technology it is and then um work towards moving away from you know using an iPhone to using an iPad or tablet or um whatever it may be and changing the plan because they have to be change you know the meetings have to have to happen with a certain number of people and the plans have to be signed and you know there's a lot of um it's not just a okay check we'll we'll switch this um so there there are I that include cell phon well they'll need to students use their device to access certain

153websites things like that that is are conducive to their to their IE so either way that has to be that has to beemp Exempted yeah and not to belor or continue with you know too much on this piece but like if it's something like something they watch or something that could probably be done on an iPad and that would just be switching that over in that language but like a lot of it's Health monitoring like if a kid has diabetes and they use their phone to monitor glucose level s there might be programs that would allow it on iPads but those would be think those would probably be the harder ones to change would be the medical based ones and they have this in the same point like the diabetics they'll they have it where

154it's connected to their parents cell phone children there's multiple people monitoring it we're trying to make the exceptions the rule here though no I don't think we're trying to make exceptions we're just bringing up points that that haven't been necessarily been thought through on the roll out on again a midyear roll out right um I don't think yeah so they're not exceptions they're not excuses but to Casey's point right like these are things that need to be considered and Katie made a great point trying to get all these IEPs together and she's right you have to have certain people there and trying to get schedules together I mean again if we're going to do this and sorry for my language I don't think we should do it half ass right so that so that's my

155thing so I think we all know where everybody stands so the motion is to I move to approve version blank so who wants to make the motion for version one and if version one goes through fine if you either one of you would like to make the motion for version two I'll do it okay I move to approve version one of the cell phone po policy for first and second reading and adoption all in favor we have to second oh second okay second all in favor I I all opposed no no okay oh W okay did you get that so Brash I know it was really little scary um I was just a little close sorry um you can do individual oh so she not unanimous three it's three to two three three um eyes

156two nose um this was really good discussion board this was really really great um okay uh consideration of organ organizational meeting so obviously we need to have our reorg meeting at the beginning of the year does January 2nd work for everybody or is there an alternative date we have to have our reorg we have to have our reorg meeting at the beginning of the year so we have it listed as January 2nd at 6:30 it's literally a six- minute meeting already have the train right so is the second good for everybody yep yep Casey yes yeah okay may I have a motion to approve January 2nd I move to approve Thursday January 2nd 2025 at 6:30 p.m. as the date and time for our organizational meeting is there a second second all in favor I

157I all opposed um okay so this next one is the um um the uh capital projects supplemental appropriation that Miss Bennett was talking about may I have a motion please I move that fy2 school Capital fund budgeted expenditure and appropriation be increased $1,200 and that Revenue budget and appropriation be increased by the same amount for the purpose of receiving additional state revenue from the Virginia Department of Education for a school security equipment Grant is there a second second all in favor I I all opposed Schoolboard member comments Mr brombeck um at our governor School uh committee meeting that uh applications for any student that wants to uh uh apply for governor schools March 20th I think okay so any school board member that uh anybody of your constituents that field ask you a question about

158Governor school they need to be getting on the ball uh right after uh break to get their application in we do have I don't how many slots we have seven or we have seven total three open yeah but three how many open yeah for this year or next year two two okay anyway um that and then uh was also approached by uh uh Community member that would like to get on the agenda for next meeting concerning the uh uh the presentation that was done about softball lights and baseball lights uh they would like to come in and give us a an update on that and they may be coming into the uh office to schedule that or get with you Renee and I think meet you Dr bowling anyway I I did tell him I

159would bring that up Mr Wilson uh no I'll SL now Mr Kennedy um I think the only couple things I had uh back to Capital expenditures Capital assessments and stuff like that there has been noted that um DG upper is freezing in the hallways um so might look into that uh classrooms seem to be comfortable I have personally haven't been up there but just in talking to parents and and teachers so take a look at that I know there were in the assessment I don't have it in front of me that um Randy Joey they when they did the assessment there was um a note about the heat I think a whether it was a u an electronic card or something on one of the units so uh the other thing I probably will be

160reaching out to you or Dr null talk about um just our literacy program and in in the specifically in the elementary schools uh what I see personally um from my son is that there's some concerns with the the benchmark grades being they're being um I guess assessed on items at a Mastery level that they haven't necessarily been been uh taught so there their grades are affected by it while the grade will can continue up initially it Trends down until they get to that level so how do you balance that with their grades things like that and what's um you what type of collaboration efforts are we doing you know I don't know that if there's discrepancies between Boyce and kolie or you know and and our teachers having those sessions to talk about what's working

161for them what's not working for them them and I think that's important um and we talked about that you know during your interview process as well but just some concerns on that that I'm seeing firsthand that uh challenges and and again these are the these fourth and fifth graders are these students that um were dealt with covid at one of the most pivotal points of their especially their reading Foundation uh preschool and and kindergarten and everything else and now we as you know our educators are trying to come up with solutions to catch them back up so I'm just personally I'm interested in that and and personally vetted so that's all I have okay ktie um I don't have a lot but I felt badly that I didn't say anything about the theater group before

162they left as well as golf so with theater um and I'll email Miss Brewer but um I did go to see their onea play when they competed for districts and they were phenomenal and um they've got a quite a core group of seniors that are really really going to be missed next year um but I think it sounds like a lot of them are going on to um use their skills that they've learned through the theater program in the future and so um there those groups of that group of seniors are really going to be missed and then golf has just completely taken off um since like you know it first started here like my brother played and and they weren't very good and now to have to cut kids from the team is just

163it's tremendous so um and I think that the success of the theater program as well as our Athletic program says a lot about our community and the time that parents and these programs that we have H have really shaped our kids um and you were part of you know you were part of that with with soccer and I know Mr Broach was too with you know football basketball softball like so it's just it's it's cool to see it come to fruition and then lastly doc welcome to Dr bowling and I hope everybody has a great break and many snow days in [Laughter] 2025 um I'll just quickly say um I think I started this open holiday open house maybe five or six years ago just you know I love warm and fuzzy and so um

164I should have said this at the very beginning but you know we talk about cell phone policy we talk about all this other stuff we have to do but just seeing these kids and um and their accomplishments um and seeing the good things is always just really brings me some Joy um I also want to say I know Miss uh Katie brought up the parents um but I also want to say the all the accomplishments and successes are also a testament to our principles in our Administration there um every meeting I say this so thank you for being here tonight especially you are I know you're counting down the days for holiday break so I get hope you um get some well-deserved rest um and may I have a motion for close session please I'm

165going to jump in you had your turn no because I don't want to I don't want to leave our wonderful discussion and I just and I'm not going to do a an official motion but I do am going to request that that this board bring up the cell phone policy uh sooner than later and not wait for the state to come back and uh and tell us that that's not good enough or even if they tell us it's good enough based on what I think our discussion is we all were kind of in agreeance that there needs to be some some boundaries big a whole lot more boundaries than what is already am I reading that right yes I and I don't disagree I mean we have a meeting every month but let's get it

166back on the agenda we had a something we a mandate that we had to meet tonight um and I think all that's understandable and we and and that's easy but I I don't want to kick the can down the road well so can we do like let's just remember maybe um February or March I know we've got budget I know we got budget so maybe March we can do a pulse check get just like a progress progress update yeah yeah so maybe we'll put that down for the March meeting I lose any momentum or whatever ideas that we have and get people thinking about it cuz it's it was good discussion and and it is in my mind the right thing to do uh course correction anyway that's all okay I just want to do

167that in public thank you and I'll say Merry Christmas before I make the motion to go in green session and before I tried you all had your time to talk trying to I'm trying to get the principles out of here I'm sorry I I your no I was getting ready to so we can go a close session oh okay is that good that's I move to convene a closed session to discuss Personnel matters including appointments and retirement pursuant to code Virginia 2.2 3711 A1 the estimated time required for the Clos session is a 15minute and action is expected we have a second all all in favor I posted e e e I move to reconvene an open session I second it hi hi hi hi hi I I have a motion for Action to approve

168the status second

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.