001Miss Hall could you please call the role yes ma'am Dr Chase here miss e here miss guy here miss holstead I'm here thank you Miss Healey here miss Irish here Miss Randall here miss Sigman here and Dr Warner here Madame you have a quorum thank you very much could I have an authorization from Miss holstead to participate electron authorization for Miss holstead to participate electronically second okay you please cast your votes H up good I'm trying that motion passes uh six I assume 7 to zero holstead do you vote to allow yourself to participate electronically I agree thank you can I have a motion and a second for theend to approve the agenda second any discussion on the agenda please cast your votes cast your vote M holstead do you approve the agenda yes ma'am
002that motion passes 7 to zero motion to approve the consent agenda second any discussion on the consent agenda yes I'm very upet about looking losing good principles but I'm very proud of the principles I'm losing they're not losing them we're sharing them hey we haven't voted yet please cast your votes on the consent agenda Miss holstead I'm also a yes okay motion passes 7 to zero Dr Smith all right good evening board members tonight on your consent agenda you did approve several new principles that I'd like to take a few moments and introduce tonight uh we do have four principles and we have one new executive director of Transportation so I am going to call them in alphabetical order by last name um and we'll invite them to come to the Podium um and say
003a few words if they would like so the first principal I'd like to introduce is the new principal of our new Elementary School 18 miss Karen Bingham Miss Bingham will launch the creation and brand of Elementary School 18 as the school's founding principal Miss Bingham has been a part of Team Stafford for her entire career as a teacher and assistant principal and currently as the principal at Widewater Elementary School in this position Miss Bingham worked with the central office staff to create the first dual language immersion program for Stafford schools Miss Bingham is eer eager to bring her expertise and instructional leadership Community engagement and school Improvement to this exciting challenge of leading a new Elementary School in Stafford Miss Bingham earned her bachelor degree of Music in music education from JMU and her MERS
004of Arts in music education from George Mason University she received her supervision and administration endorsement from the University of Mary Washington and we are thrilled to have her plan and Lead Elementary School 18 thank you Madame chair members of the board Dr Smith I am beyond excited and humbled by such an incredible opportunity that you are bestowing on me and one of my colleagues this evening we are so excited to I've lived in the area of which I will finally be a principal in the area I suspect it will be zoned for uh for 23 years and to get to bring something like this to the community in which I live is pretty exciting but I can't stand before you tonight and not take a moment to say we tell everyone it takes a village
005to raise a child well it takes a village to raise a principal too and I cannot stand here tonight without telling you about the incredible Educators I have been surrounded by at Rock Hill at Conway at our early childhood programs in my beloved Widewater um I am here because of them and the incredible support I received here at central office and from each of you and my amazing husband in the back and my two children who are graduates of Stafford County and my mom and dad who are all probably streaming tonight so I just thank you so very much for the trust and we are going to give our all to make this just an incredible place for our children here in Stafford County to continue to learn grow and just soar and be their
006very best thank you congratulations all right the next principal I'd like to introduce to you is Miss Christina Herrera the new principal at Kate wal Waller Barrett Elementary School Miss Herrera will join the team at Kate Waller Barrett Elementary School as the school's new principal Miss Herrera joins us from Prince William County Public Schools where she served as a teacher for five years and most recently as an assistant principal in her current school she formed the School attendance team and reduced chronic absenteeism by 9% for the current Academic Year she is focused on using Innovative strategies to elevate student outcomes for all students Miss Herrera earned her bachelor's degree in Psychology and a master of arts and teaching from Christopher Newport University she earned a Masters in Education and educational leadership from George Mason University
007and we'd like to take this opportunity to welcome Miss Herrera to our team thank you so much um I just wanted to say thank you for this incredible opportunity and I'm very excited to actually return to Stafford which is where I started my educational career and journey and so I just want to say thanks for that welcome back thank [Applause] you all right the next principal is not new to you either is Miss Rachel Novak prin principal at Ferry Farm Elementary School Miss novc has worked for the past two years as the principal at Kate Waller Barrett Elementary School and will now join the team at Ferry Farm Elementary School as the new principal she has previously served as an assistant principal at Widewater Elementary Miss Novak is passionate about building a school Community Based
008on trust and transparency to provide all Scholars with the tools they need to be successful both within and Beyond the classroom walls Miss Novak earned her bachelor's degree in Psychology from Robert Morris University and her master's degree in special education from the University of Mary Washington she completed the endorsement Administration and supervision at longward Longwood University congratulations Miss Novak and welcome to Fairy Farm thank you Dr Smith Madam chair and members of the board I am thrilled to have this opportunity to just as my colleague Miss Bingo mentioned work and have an impact on a community in which I also live so I am a Frederickburg resident my husband and I have been there for the past 16 years and I'm going to tell you very quickly my little Fairy Farm Story before I knew
009better as far as an application process and I was trying to get my first teaching job ever I just marched my paper resume in there met with the two lovely ladies in the front office and uh hoped for the best but my journey took me Elsewhere for a while I'm excited to continue this work alongside my amazing colleagues and Stafford thank you all for your continued support as we learn and go grow through this together and I'm really excited for Christina to come to Bear it as well thank [Applause] you all right next opening up our new Elementary School 19 is Mr Jr Jr rold Mr raybold will launch the creation and brand of our new Elementary School 19 as the school's founding principal he's been a part of team staff over 24 years as
010a classroom teacher an assistant principal and currently as the principal at Conway Elementary School in this position Mr rold is established and maintain a positive School culture focused on deep community and family relationships while inspiring the next generation of educational leaders Mr raybold is eager to apply his skills passion and energy to build a new Elementary School Mr rold earned his Bachelor of Science degree from Penn State University and a master of education and educational leadership from George Mason University congratulations Jr Madam chair and members of the school board Dr Smith thanks for the opportunity uh this journey um we now call the one family uh at Conway started 15 years ago uh almost to the to the day when um I was able to be uh named as the Conway principal um my son
011was one Tyler who's now uh a junior at Stafford High School and Tyler and Eric wasn't uh well hadn't even been thought of yet um and as I told our staff today we've been through everything all the highs and lows that of one family could be the U new Love and marriages and divorces and not mine um but thank God the the beautiful lady beside them I I clearly married up everybody in this room know I married up so uh that's Jenna Grafton but um it has been an incredible ride um I would be the only way I'd ever leave that place place is is to do do it again and uh that's what we're going to do uh we're going to build an incredible place for kids in 18 and 19 uh we won't
012let you down sir um and um and to our our Conway people that um just and to my family and to everybody in this room um as Karen said you built us we are who we are um because of every single person in our communities that we've serve and we're honored to be able to do it again so thank you thanks appreciate [Applause] we have one more introduction this evening and that is our new executive director of Transportation Services Mr John wilcots Mr wots could not be with us this evening um but he will join team Stafford as our new division uh executive director of Transportation Services he's currently the executive director of transportation and Fleet Services in Houston Texas uh which is the seventh largest school district in the nation um he served for
013HISD as their training and support manager for seven years prior to his current role and really one of the things that we were looking for that jumped out with Mr wilcott is his his ability to Foster strong relationships with stakeholders uh vendors and customers to ensure Transportation Service delivery within set guidelines and he has a proven track record for managing complex project projects and optimizing workflow processes we're very excited about Mr wilcott joining our team he had completed his Bachelor's in Business Administration and project management at Columbia Southern University and he will be beginning with us on March 3D so congratulations to Mr wilcots and that concludes our appointments for tonight thank you very much uh I would like to introduce the representatives from our citizens budget advisory committee who who making their annual report
014and recog and recommendations thank you guys for being flexible and being here today they were supposed to be here for our meeting that was snowed out or snowed in so thank you very much yep Dr Hunter just let me know what all right well good evening everyone and Schoolboard members and community members my name is Dr Alicia Hunter and I'm the chair of the citizens budget advisory committee tonight I'm presenting the 2025 cabback annual report this presentation is based on the 2025 citizens budget report for Stafford County Public Schools which is Citizens advocacy for public school funding gabs and Sustainable Solutions this full report will be available in board doogs it's about 30 pages long it's a great read for a Sunday afternoon so this will be an abbreviated version of that report but please
015check it out when you get a chance this report represents Collective research from Stafford citizens with expertise in law commercial real estate education military Government Contracting nonprofit leadership and finance tonight we have a clear and Urgent Message Stafford County ranks 117 out of 132 School divisions in Virginia for per pupil spending despite rapid residential growth and increasing student enrollment we're going to present not just a problem but a road map forward this is about accountability collaboration and making education funding a real priority for Stafford County's future next slide oh I can do it all right so CAG serves is a bridge between the community and policy makers advising the school board on resource allocation and financial needs our role is to evaluate funding Trends advocate for necessary Investments and ensure transparency just want to go
016over our accomplishments over the last two years and just a quick summary we've really focused on Research Community engagement and advocacy just in the last year we've partnered with 20 plus PTA and PTO groups engaged with School principles and work with economic development organizations we've developed an advocacy toolkit to educate citizens about school funding and how to participate in local civil Civic engagement we have also prioritized student engagement as well we've partnered with the social studies Department to align learning with Civics education fostering youth involvement and advocacy as well as sought out opportunities for students to receive volunteer hours for local Civ Civic engagement our work has resulted in more support for advocacy that which further supports the shared ver shared vision for investing in our Public Schools Stafford County is one of the best
017places to live in Virginia we're ranked highly for young professionals families and Home Ownership our our population surge is driven by new residential developments a strong job market in our proximity to Washington DC this growth brings opportunity but also increased demand for public services infrastructure and most importantly education Safford County Public Schools must keep Pace with expansion to sustain high quality education and Workforce Readiness as the county continues to thrive according to the Stafford Economic Development Authority Stafford County's economic strategy focuses on four key Industries cyber security data centers Logistics and supply chain and advanced manufacturing to drive business expansion and long-term term economic sustainability we are becoming an ideal hub for data centers and Technology firms very exciting additionally Stafford County Public Schools is experiencing rapid enrollment growth with over 32,2 168 students currently
018enrolled a number that continues to rise due to increasing residential development and population expansion despite Stafford's economic growth and business-friendly policies we lack the capacity to fully fund our schools for years superintendents have warned that school budgets are trimmed to the bare minimum just enough to keep the lights on yet enrollment keeps growing classroom sizes are increasing and Stafford remains ranked 117th in per pupil spending in the state Stafford County faces a 14.2 million gap to fully fund the proposed FY 26 Budget on top of an additional 59 million in unmet unfunded needs this isn't about excess spending it's about meeting the basic educational needs of a rapidly growing student population Stafford County teacher salaries remain uncompetitive driving Educators to NE neighboring districts like Prince William Prince William county is offering roughly 133% increases in
019teacher salary over the next couple of years while Stafford struggles to match competitive pay the Stafford 2040 Vision promotes a public education as an economic driver yet underfunding our schools undermines this goal we cannot expect to attract top industries while Str to provide competitive teacher salaries and modern learning environments if we continue this trajectory Stafford's Competitive Edge will fade businesses families and top educators will choose better funded communities leaving Stafford at a disadvantage our research shows outdated State funding formulas keep Stafford underfunded limited local Revenue investment leave stagger lagging behind its Regional peers over Reliance on residential zoning instead of commercial development strain school funding declining student achievement is a direct result of insufficient school funding let's go a little bit deeper why do we want to highlight outdated State funding formulas we are the
020eighth richest county but the funding models overestimate Stafford's ability to fund schools locally and these formulas limit State funding to pay our teachers competitively and our base State funding on state ratios over actual student needs failing to provide modern highquality education since we have limitations on State funding due to outdated models local funding is key neighboring districts such as Prince William and Lowden counties invest significantly more in education than Stafford Prince William funds 52% of his school budget locally while lden funds 71% of his school budget locally while staffer only funds 36.7% now Lowden is not a typical comparison but I've included Lowden because of the revenue they generate from data centers and Stafford Eda promotes Stafford as a future data center hub we have to acknowledge the Gap in local funding how it directly
021affects teacher pay classroom resources and student achievement Stafford markets itself as a lowcost business location which attracts companies but does not translate into higher school funding Economic Development should not come at the expense of public education low cost to do business at what cost to schools look at the map here look at our residential zoning compared to our commercial zoning green brown and yellow represent Agriculture and residential zones while pink blue and purple indicate commercial zones the overwhelming majority of Stafford's land is residential staffer has prioritized residential expansion over commercial development increasing Demand on schools without the tax base to support them as Citizens we've done the research but now let's take a step back and compare how does Stafford Stack Up regionally and Statewide in education funding and what impact does that have on
022student achievement Virginia school divisions receive less funding than National and Regional averages West Virginia a state with a lower cost of living and fewer economic resources spends more per student on public education than Stafford County this raises a critical question how can we expect to compete regionally when we invest Less in our students than a neighboring state with fewer Financial advantages neighboring districts invest more why not Stafford investment in schools directly correlates with Student Success more funding equals equals higher so Pass rates lower Dropout rates and better college career Readiness let's take a brief look at uh saffr County Public Schools per pupil spending outcomes we spend 13,760 per student during the school during the 23 24 school year our reading Pass rates were 71% across all grades now let's take a look at Fall
023Church City now for the sake of example FSE Church City spends nearly twice as much per student 23,6 73 versus our 13,000 FSE Church Reading task rate is 92% let that sink in 71% versus that 92% the Gap in funding results in lower academic outcomes how much we spend matters our research as Citizens concludes Stafford's current funding model is failing without action student achievement will continue to decline investing in schools is investing in the County's future Stafford must act now to fully fund education we have prepared a nine-point action agenda that offers solutions for sustainable long-term school funding so each board member should have a thre page document that has our full ninepoint action agenda and so I'll just give a brief overview of each action point and then we'll wrap up action one we
024want you to fully fund the superintendent's 49.6 million budget to stabilize School operations protect student services and special programs retain teachers and ensure livable wages for support staff and address deferred maintenance and safety concerns the school board must go beyond proposing a budget they must fight for it through public advocacy negotiation and collaboration with the Board of Supervisors Mrs Patricia hilly has years of underfunding led to the fiscal challenges we face today including declining student achievement and deteriorating buildings action two conduct a comprehensive study and annual stakeholder surveys to identify citizen priorities for school funding guide budget decisions and strengthen funding advocacy with data driven insights the school board must move Beyond informal feedback and Word of Mouth by conducting comprehensive studies and annual stakeholder survey to guide budget priorities Dr Sarah Chase how's the
025school board ensuring school funding decisions are based on real datadriven insights rather than assumptions do we have data that reflects the perspectives of our retirees and taxpayers that don't have children in Stafford County or is it just Word of Mouth action three we want you to invest in community advocacy by allocating resources to a targeted Outreach campaign that educates families commuters taxpayers retire and students on the budget process and highlights public education as a key economic driver for Stafford County Stafford is a communter town with many residents disengaged from local policy a proactive Outreach campaign must educate taxpayers on how school funding works and its long-term impact Mrs Susan Randall can citizens ask for a commitment to educate the public about the budget process and not rely solely on Grassroots advocacy Action Four we want
026you to strengthen the school board and Board of Supervisors joint working group into an action oriented task force that directly addresses Stafford County school funding crisis and delivers Solutions through strategic planning accountability and measurable outcomes The Joint working group must shift from discussion to action delivering measurable outcomes that are publicly tracked quarterly meetings are too slow the urgency of budget shortfalls teacher retention issues and inflation driven cost demand B monthly or monthly meetings to maintain momentum citizens see no clear outcomes from this group public progress reports measurable deliver deliverables and accountability metrics must be established Mrs Patricia Hy what work can this group share with citizens that you are most proud of action five adopt a joint resolution between Stafford County Public Schools and the Board of Supervisors for a multi-year funding strategy that increases
027local educ ation funding including a one-time allocation to address past funding gaps and inflation and establish a fiscal formula based on enrollment inflation and new business Revenue to address long-term Financial stability a formal agreement between the school board and Board of Supervisors ensures consistent predictable education funding instead of reactive year-to-year budgeting Mrs Morin Sigman what previous efforts can be shared with citizens that have led to an increase in local funding for Stafford County Public Schools and how can this joint resolution create a multi-year funding strategy that ensures long long-term Financial stability action six we want you to engage with the staffer Economic Development Department and The Economic Development Authority to establish an agreement with cyber security data centers and logistic businesses for investment in local public schools high growth industries like cyber security data centers
028and Logistics directly compete with education for talent yet Stafford Eda attracts business businesses with low taxes and incentives without requiring investments in schools if strong schools are a part of Stafford's business attraction strategy then businesses must financially reinvest in public education the school board must formalize a partnership with the Stafford Eda and the Stafford Ed to advocate for school funding as part of Economic Development planning Miss Alyssa H said does the board feel Empower to seek a formal funding commitment from the staffer Eda and the Stafford Ed to ensure business invested in Stafford also invest in our Public Schools citizens believe this is achievable how will you make this happen action seven establish a formal partnership between the school board and planning and zoning departments to integrate school capacity and infrastructure needs into land use
029planning ensuring sustainable development that supports Public School infrastructure alongside residential growth Stafford's residential zoning outpaces commercial development increasing student enrollment without adequate TX Revenue to fund schools the school board must work with Planning and Zoning intentionally to ensure school capacity projections are factor into zoning decisions and prevent School overcrowding the three plan must be integrated into Stafford's long-term growth strategy to fund School improvements in alignment with development Trends Mrs Patricia hilly how's the school board collaborating with the planning and zoning department to ensure responsible growth planning and the prevention of school overcrowding and alignment of Capital Improvements are aligned with future enrollment needs two more actions left I promise action eight oh I forgot to click action eight propose an amendment to an existing bill or introduce a new bill to the Virginia general assembly
030for consideration during the first schedule adjoined in 2026 addressing full cost of competing adjustment coka funding for teacher and support staff compensation Stafford's rapid Grove surpasses Manasses and Manasses park yet they receive full cocoa while Stafford is not high paying Industries like cyber security and data centers are increasing competition for teachers without full coca staffer struggles to retain and recruit Educators expanding coca has been done before Stafford should be next this is about fairness not taking funding from other districts Mrs Maya guy what specific lobbying and advocacy efforts have the school board and Board of Supervisors undertaken to secure full coca funding for Stafford County and last but not least action nine unite all planning district 8 koca recipient counties and Nova School Districts as a joint resolution to remove coca caps secure legislative sponsorship
031and make Coca cat removal a state budget priority to address current labor cost and inflation coca caps failed to adjust for inflation making Stafford's teacher salaries uncompetitive the cost of living has skyrocketed in Stafford in Northern Virginia yet coca caps remain outdated preventing Fair teacher compensation a joint resolution with other District a School Division strengthens Stafford's case for full coca funding and makes cap removal a Statewide priority Dr Warren what past actions has the board taken to collaborate with Planning District 8 school divisions to advocate for removing coca caps have any of our state legislators shown interest in sponsoring these efforts CC will continue advocating for sustainable school funding the school board must take action now to address funding gaps this is El year for multiple districts citizens are watching to see how school funding
032is prioritized this budget season we must invest in education or potentially risk losing public trust and long-term economic competitiveness thank you for this opportunity and we welcome your questions and comments thank you very much all of you and Dr Hunter for the presentation um I'm sure we have a lot to say uh I'm going to start with Miss holstead so I don't forget her do you have anything you'd like to say or ask Miss hon um actually I'm just thank you that was probably one of the best and most informative um advisory committee um reports just in terms of really the issues to wrap our minds around as we head into this so I'm going to keep my comment short but thank you so much for all the time and energy and effort you guys
033put in helping us make Stafford better thank you Miss I don't have much to add but uh I do really I think the first page is probably the one that makes your eyes kind of bleed when you see 117th place um I really just that's just so disheartening and disappointing um I would I hope uh of course we had an uh approved budget calendar that would have included a meeting with the board of super visors that didn't happen and um you know we have deadlines that we have to meet for them and we have met them I would hope that we can get this calendar moving in a positive direction with the meeting with them sooner rather than later um it just if we don't have the opportunity to have a conversation soon um like
034I said for both the CIP and the budget um it's just a little disheartening so uh I know every year we put together a strategy I know I'm very lucky that I have a Cooperative supervisor that listens and tries to work with us um and um I hope that we'll be able to continue um to engage in a positive way regarding taking care of our Little Learners so thank you very much for this it's very informative and we have some marching orders thank you thank you Miss Healey thank you I'm I'm just glad we didn't have to pay youall for doing that report because this this is this time this this is seriously this is more comprehensive than contracts that we have issued and spent tens of thousands of dollars on so I really appreciate
035your time your committee's time and I have to say I miss being the Lea on but um we take turns um but thank you for for doing this I think um I think we do have a crisis you know here in the county and it's really going to be up to the the community um supervisors but you know they report to the community um and and we can certainly sing the song and and you know do the the advocacy but it's it's it's going to it's going to be a a tough decision because there are a lot of competing interests here in Stafford but you know when you look at the number of students that we have and and the impact on them and and what's happening I I think you have put it very
036graphically here and this will this will help us to to to make the case you know how how short we are but I I I also think we need to have a little longer term vision and not just pulling up but where where do we want to be because back in the day Stafford was very proud of its place you know in education and and we we know we had you know it was a different time it was a different time and we had new buildings and we had you know seasoned um you know staff and now we're you know we you know we have we have more challenges but I I I think we we have the guidance of a a new superintendent who is you know has a great vision and I think
037with with his vision and working with you know with your advisory committee and with the community we we we should be able to to to make our case so thank you thank you seriously this is an amazing report um and I I mean I I just looked at the slides now so I'm I'm looking forward to reading it I may not even wait till Sunday afternoon thank you thank you Mrs hilly Miss Irish did you have any questions or comments I do not Dr Chase yeah I I'll just Echo what everybody else has said about thank you so much for the work um I do want to make sure you all everybody did hear that that uh um delegate mil did bring coka up and it was voted on and it went down um but
038he worked very hard to get it on there and all of our Representatives did vote in favor of it um it went down by one vote yeah oh just one of our Representatives voted against it which is why it didn't even get out of the committee gotcha okay unfortunately unfortunately yeah um but uh but at the same time I absolutely agree 117th and funding is is not enough but I do given that we had several wonderful principles come up we are extremely lucky and staffer in the staff that we do have and we do have many many wonderful principles and teachers and uh staff who um help make uh 117th not as bad as it could be but we would certainly like it to the funding to improve thank you Dr Warner first of all
039it's such a pleasure to work with you Dr Hunter and I I think that this is one of the most comprehensive road maps that we've ever seen seen in any committee and I think that I love the way you've integrated all the different partners that we have in the community it's not just the Board of Supervisors and the school board it's not just the state government it's the Eda and it's the economic development because education is the driver of Economic Development and it's time that we funded it accordingly so I appreciate the marching orders and I will continue to Advocate and do what I can do thank you thank you Miss guy thank you I think this was a fantastic presentation I guarantee you this will be on my social media I'm probably going to
040clip your presentation and put that on my social media as well and um I'm not going to say any names but the one representative of staffords that did not vote for the Coca I do have a meeting schedule with them next month and I hope to make my case so that if mil brings it back hopefully you know it can make it out of committee this time um I thought this was fantastic and I may have questions but if I can contact you later um just to get more insight because my my brain is thinking now so thank you absolutely thank you uh I love this I've actually gotten probably halfway through the the report I've been and I'm looking forward to reading the full uh action steps as well again um I think my
041question is since this is a you know the property of a citizen budget committee and not the School Division or the school board are you sharing it with the Board of Supervisors with our delegation to Richmond you know essentially with the other people that you've called to action in this so that you know they're aware that this is a public you know ask um and that we can all have conversations having read and heard the same information yes I would like to respond I have actually tried to reach out the committee has tried to reach out and um it has been very responses as far as the willingness to hear the citizens perspective but we're going to continue to maneuver through the bureaucracy and push through but our plan is to extend our advocacy and
042so we are definitely working towards moving towards uh advocacy at the state level and we also want an opportunity to share our perspective as Citizens with the Board of Supervisors and the various groups with Economic Development Authority but um it hasn't been as welcoming with some groups we'll be very honest wow thank you for all of this this is a lot to digest a lot to think about but so much of the know I felt like I was going through and I was screen grabbing like paragraphs because again social for social media for the like the quotes that I want to use later it's so well researched and well thought out but also like easy easily um yes very digestible and kind of into layman's terms because it's kind of the hard part I mean
043Budget is complicated enough as it is but to put it into uh language and you know Graphics that you know anyone can can understand and visualize is super super helpful to me but to to everybody uh in the community as well because you're right it is not just you know currently School connected people um you with all this growth we know that we have families here that are not school connected yet uh that should be aware of kind of the journey we're on here um and then the people who are no longer School connected and remember kind of the good old days um might be a little disheartened to hear the direction that we've been going um and be more eager to help so I am really really looking forward to you know the mile
044this presentation will get for our community thank you very much Madam chair um can I ask if the other members of this committee could stand and be recognized that would be [Applause] great thank you all so much for the work you've put into this and we'll continue to do for the for the rest of the term so we are very glad to have you on our team thank you very much thank you everyone with that this uh special called meeting is adjourned we'll take a brief recess and then we'll reconvene for our work session in the back second any discussion any want all in favor I any opposed hi Alysa motion to approve the agenda hi guys there second any discussion let's do it okay all all in favor of the agenda I okay discussion
045of 2025 2026 uh Bell scheduled hearing and um I know they want to get through the presentation on this and then we can save our questions for the end okay us off yes okay so uh tonight we are here to uh provide you some information on Elementary School Bel Heering option um we as we continue to look at transportation and how we can continually improve uh this is an option that has come forth that we'll share with you tonight that we feel like really gives us some opportunities with some minor adjustments really make some significant improvements to our Transportation uh on time delivery on time pickup and delivery and um you know if we continue to do things the same way we're not going to get the improved results so we do find this as
046a way that we can have some of that improvements really uh appreciative of Mr Greg Maki uh his work in transportation his work with staff to put together some of this plan tonight or this whole plan for tonight and so uh looking forward to sharing it with you tonight and we'll we'll be happy to talk through next steps uh but I think you'll you'll appreciate hearing from this and and how it's going to help us to improve our transportation efforts so Mr Fulmer's here along with Greg Macky to present I'm gonna kick us started but or or get us started but um just thank you Dr Smith for kicking us off and also want to thank Mr Macky for being here this evening him and I are going to tag to this and and cover
047a lot of these slides together so first also with this kind of being our one of our last few meetings uh welcome and uh Mr willcott be starting us but just want to take a minute to thank Greg and Mr Mackey for all the work he's done over the last several months has done a really phenomenal job and you'll kind of see as as him leading that team down there of what we've kind of been able to push out of that department and some of these recommendations for improvements uh so why why should we look at tearing the elementary schools um ultimately as as Dr Miss said Dr Smith mentioned um we need to adjust if we're going to expect to improve so um we know we can't keep our current schedule the way it
048is um if we want to see improvements um we believe that with the tearing of the elementary schools we're going to have more ontime buses with that on time buses we're going to have improved communication the less delays that we have means that our our dispatch department and our transportation staff are not overwhelmed with trying to keep up with them so they're going to be able to stay on top of those Communications notifications it's going to allow us to have more efficient use of our staff um and with that efficient use it's going to provide flexibility for our route coverages and um with all of this we're able to maintain the current order of our schools so we're not having to flip-flop our bell schedule tiers we're just splitting our elementary school tiers all right
049so I'll slide into this uh talk about this slide itself so uh looking over the window as we started pulling this uh data together to look at some the background story um I look at the window between November 1st up through December 19th um and during that time there were 865 absences that's a combination of drivers and also attendance um and when you look at that that the attendance really um with our current uh process if if an attendant's out we need to have two people on every single bus so many times that causes us to take a driver off another route and cover their route in order to to uh provide that extra set of hands um overall that average is out to be just under 29 kids or 29 people every single day
050um with a peak of 38 on December 6th um and that definitely um makes it challenging um it's not just the 865 though um every one of our uh drivers and their uh runs they have at least two different levels if not three so it it kind of uh builds up and so those 865 equated to 2015 bus coverages um and so that's when if you think of dispatch and the workload that they have that's where it's all building up along the way um so uh then you you look further into just the elementary level um that ranged anywhere from 36 to 75 runs being covered on a daily basis just in the elementary level um and we'll explain next on how that kind of why that matters in different areas I want to emphasize
051too this is something we've talked about as a team we want our staff to feel like they can take leave when they need to take leave so it's not about avoiding leave for our staff but we need to be better equipped to handle it when they do take leave and right now we're operating which we'll see in a few minutes too basically at 100% utilization so as soon as one driver is out that triggers us into where we have to have bus coverages and double runs so this next chart is usually the chart that um affects you because you hear about the delays um and um you it all all carried back so the same window of time that U is pretty much being looked at actually this is 11:20 to 1219 but you can
052see where the delays are located and a majority of those delays are located or arrive on the elementary level um and up to 18 delays in a single PM shift and so you can imagine how that stockpiles and if you're delayed on the um the elementary level typically when you look to the right of that you see the middle school you'll find that there are higher delays there too because once you fall behind in that the elementary level it builds up over there as well um so just a little bit of a process and some numbers on how that all plays out it's nothing new um actually before uh the pandemic there was actually a trial with u some tearing that took place between Park rdge and Winding Creek and it was very successful and
053the schools loved it um and found that things were much more on time um but then Co came and we changed around the whole uh teering a couple different times actually during that process and it just kind of went away but it was a very successful pilot whenever this took place at those two schools very similar format so I want to share some data on just our mainstream driver so our gened mainstream driver so this does not include our special needs routes it does not include our early childhood special ucation it doesn't include some Mento students that we transport this is just looking at our mainstream because that's ultimately um where we have to make sure it balances when we look at our elementary school belt hearing so um on the the chart on the
054left just shows we have 171 total drivers for mainstream right now uh and some good news is we've actually added a few more since we created this um five or six that have come out of class and are out on the road uh but um what we show in in the bigger chart on the top right is in that first year which is high school and our Rock Hill Elementary School it's a total of 157 routes well we need 100 or we have 166 drivers plus the substitutes but that equates to we're using 95% of our drivers on those routes but if you look in the far right column we know that we have at Le 15% driver absenteeism each day and so all a sudden that takes us to we're short drivers because of
055those absenteeism and we would need 107% of our drivers that's our kind of new utilization so being at 100% or above in this instance is not a good thing we want that number to be lower so it means we have more drivers available to help coverages Elementary School even before we have a driver absence we're at 99.4% that doesn't include High School runs that are so long that they can't help on the elementary school run so we already have so we're pretty much we are like dead even at 100% so uh we do have some planned double run just because of how short the routes are but ultimately we have a driver for every route if they are all here each day but back to the second column we're at 113% utilization once again not
056great to be over 100 that higher above a 100 we get um the worst shape we're actually in so that's accounting for the absenteeism Middle School we're a little better so um I I've always shared that's our our kind of least volume tier least number of students and and buses required uh so we have about 140 runs there uh we would operate with full efficiency at about 84% but with our absen ISM more about 95 96% um and I do want to also add this does not include if we have attendance absences and then drivers have to cover for bus attendance so trying to look at just drivers and then impact the absenteeism has on that so with that I'm jumping right in a proposed schedule and what the adjustments are so we would split
057our elementary school into two tiers one that we'll call tier 2A one that is tier 2B um tier a would be 8:15 to 245 um take out Rock Hill for a minute all of our current elementary schools that would bump up to tier 2 a it's only a 10 minute difference in what they have right now pretty insignificant uh difference but we are are going to get feedback from parents uh to uh to get some information and let them uh share their thoughts on it uh Rock Hill is currently on our high school tier uh which if you go back to that utilization having Rock Hill on that High School tier is bumping them right up to that threshold where they're exceeding that 100% Mark when you account for absences so we need to shift
058Rockfield back off the high school tier so we're not playing catchup immediately after the high school tier the good news is is I think a lot of the community I think m um hila you can attest to this is we've heard a lot from The Rock Hill Community that they would prefer to bump back a little bit later because of the length of some of those Rock Hill routes we do pick up kids at 6:00 a.m. um for Rock Hill and and so we kind of heard from the community there that they would like to be pushed back so in this case it actually um works on our benefit it's a 45 minute difference for them to shift to the 8:15 tier and then we would have the tier 2B which would start at 8
05945 um so once again we're still going to have high school we'll have tier 2 a 2B that are Elementary School tiers and we would have Middle School at the end before you slide on um you can look up there and see some of those comparisons like Widewater for example was on the tier 2B um and if you look on the tier 2A um you'll be able to find like Hampton Oaks is over there um if you were to look on the right hand side you'll find uh Heartwood under the tier 2 be on the left hand side you're going to find that's where Rocky Run is located there are um I'm calling a sister schools support schools uh strategically looked at so that hey we're on tier 2A and we have a driver that's
060out let's look to see who on tier 2B can support maybe they have a shorter run on tier 2B and and their their routes are closer to the school they could come over and support the tier 2 a side um providing you know hopefully minimal to no delays at all for our kiddos um and so that's how every um school that's up there on the left or the right they're strategically identified to support so other excluding Rock Hill the biggest shift we'll see is our our schools shifting to the tier 2B which will be that 20 minute shift um what that does as as Mr Mackey mentioned is it does provide some drivers now will be able to help on high school both Elementary School tiers and a middle school so um on those shorter
061routes so what does that what does that do for our utilization so the same chart in the top right now in the bottom right you'll see what those impacts are when we're able to split those shifts so we move Rock Hill off of the high school run and that now moves us to 87% if all or almost 88% utilization if all of our drivers are here and even if we account for all of our driver absenteeism um we're right at 100% so we should actually be in pretty good shape at our high school routes except for our really extreme days and some of the flu that we had going around still as I as I hear from uh going around the county but a few weeks ago was really going through some of our bus
062drivers and attendance as well um and you'll see the impact it has on our elementary school two split tiers is now where we were at 99 and 113% we're in that 50 55 and then jumping up to the 65% uh full disclosure we're not going to have all 170 bus drivers running each both tiers of Elementary because some of the routes are too long but what that allows you to do now is by shifting some of those longer routes to tier 2B right now they're trying like we we they can only do one Elementary but we have some elementary schools or some bus drivers that can do both schools now so it frees up and it gives some extra time for those longer runs like a Widewater that the brook point or North Stafford High
063School Bus can finish it now has a longer Bell Gap to get to those students and get them to school on time are we allowed to ask questions okay um not not a whole lot of change on our on our Middle School um with exception of you see the colors change percentage change just slightly and that's because with this consolidation or adjustments we're actually able to consolidate some of those routes so you'll actually see the total number of routes went down a few and also what's not C up caught here is we actually think that it's going to free up 13 drivers which can now be contracted substitute drivers or just help short shorten some of those routes we'll also be able to shift to maybe some of our other tiers or like our early
064childhood special education talk about a couple of the general improvements overall um looking at improved on time runs and if we do have one of those times and we'll have a several people out we will have more options to pull from instead of especially the elementary level where we are already 100% capacity and where do you pull from without creating delays um better staff allocation as Chris mentioned um we looking at it we're able to go from 166 uh assigned drivers and routes to 153 that of course our numbers are always moving in County so that's just a rough number but it's still pretty uh significant um that it can provide that extra uh support um and then the enhanced student and family experience fewer delays um and a better communication which I think is
065a goal for everybody as well special education not in into this consideration as of right now however um the idea is our schools that have kiddos who are riding to one school it's going provide more flexibility where right now they're all showing up at one time where now we can also stagger how they're supporting our school so we will actually have more support um the team is getting ready to actually lay that out to show that but we are confident that it's going to provide more flexibility just having this that tiered effect as well for getting our special wed kidos to school on time and and because we're freeing up some of our um drivers from our mainstream it will help if we need to ship those over to the special needs coverage um so
066again this looking more impact by school freeing up bus staff reducing delays realigning Rock Hills a big plus uh middle schools no schedule changes but if our elementary levels on time then we will have less delays also in the Middle School uh tier and then for the high schools uh no schedule changes but again removing Rock kill that's nine buses that are coming off or that would come off which provides that extra support for the high school level so it will reduce the delays there as well and early childhood the goal is to hopefully be able to allocate um some of the 13 to have less or more buses to be able to support and then maybe get shorter routes for some of those kidos that are pretty long I'd love to be able to
067shift over kind of dedicated contracted substitute over to our early childhood because one of our biggest issues we have is as soon as a driver attendant is out on Early Childhood it's a trickle down so if Northstar is behind or we have a breakdown on the Northstar route then getting to Rising Star creates a significant delay for them so we're working on having a driver basically on call that can jump on we have a bus ready with already that has the specialized seats for our prek early childhood kids um so they can jump on that bus and get right over to Rising Star so even if there is a delay we know it's not going to be an hour delay maybe it's just a 10minute delay um so we we did start to do our
068due diligence and look ahead to what it would look like in 2026 because you know 2026 looks a little bit different than 2025 uh so Greg and the team started mapping out what what will we do with Elementary School 18 and 19 um and right now and so this is all subject to change that we need to see how we districting kind of shapes up and and what that F over districting is because as we mentioned the way we pair our schools depends on the boundaries of so uh we could see some other shifts right now just some high level we would expect 18 to be to fall into the 845 tier 2B Elementary School 19 would fall into the 815 um tier uh a and then the only change we right now foresee as
069far as existing schools that we're putting into place for next year that we would have to potentially shift the following year is Stafford Elementary School would shift from tier a to tier to tier 2B um I I want to mention one of the things we're looking at is for 19 and how having them on tier 2 a how it would align with our bth Point High School arrival and dismissal with the car riders maybe it would be better to have them on the tier 2B so it's something we're looking at right now to explore but we need to see how elementary school or districting going um so this is just uh kind of a visual of what I just explained on on where they would slide into noting that for that following year two years
070from now if if Stafford L falls into that tier 2 a if they have to shift to tier 2B it would be a 30 minute change for them we're trying to minimize as much change as possible and this is just to show that uh this is the routers at work um and it all started with a map you see on that wall over there where they started looking for those supporting schools and where it made sense and then from there looking at every single one of these routes um and really trying to dig into which which combinations make the most efficient um uh use of our staff and our um our buses that we have and um putting those together and then from there they put him into the sandbox and try it out from
071it so um but uh it was a team effort to pull together and I I thought that picture was awesome because it just shows it didn't just happen there was a lot of effort that went into it behind the scenes as well uh so real quick timeline we wanted to introduce this to the school board and then obviously publicly to the community um we also want to get feedback from the community so we'll shoot that out to our PK our prek up until our fourth graders that we looking at you know K through five for next year uh send and Z get some feedback from them you know bu kind of School site let them know like hey here's the projected schedule what it would be for next year um let us know what your
072uh concerns are or or if you're in in favor of it um we also want to send out a survey to our Elementary School staff make sure they're fully aware that goes out about a week later so the principals have a time to talk to their staff about it um so we'll provide this information actually Greg has already kind of provided this presentation with our Elementary School principles uh and they were all 100% in support of it um like everybody hey if it fixes our on time arrivals and or and dismissals um Everybody supports it uh so we'll leave that open for a few weeks and close the survey on March 7th the the parent Community one and then we want to analyze those results and uh kind of finalize we want to share that
073with the school board at the March 18th meeting uh that we definitely want to move forward and then after that we would communicate out to our families um what the start times would be for next year unrelated to our start times is we need to get that done before we start to roll out our opin survey for next year where we want to survey um or a selection I should say of 100% of our elementary school um student or sorry our our K12 students and PRK Early Childhood um so that's going to be open for about three weeks and then we're going to close in close that kind of selection survey form and then we're going to work with our schools and central office to finalize all that so we know we're going to have
074some holes there we want to get to close to 100% uh parent response there we know we're not going to get there but just because they don't respond to that selection form doesn't mean we're going to just not route them we need to work with the principals they know what families always ride the bus what communities always ride the bus we'll fill in the gaps and then we'll give that data back to the schools and then we got to then fill whatever gaps are left and that well we did this um several years ago and we actually called every family to make sure we had every kid accounted for what their selection would be um and so that will go through kind of the month of May uh and then we're going to roll right
075into routing you know Greg's team has already built all of these route packages that's how we know it'll work they've gone through and built it in the system uh and know that the times work so um really it's going to come down to we have to assign students to actual routes uh they know the the system really well now and are kind of ready to rock and roll so as soon as as soon as they can they're kind of antsy ready to start mov forward that's it I was GNA start with Alysa so I don't forget her and then I I did forget yeah Alissa did you have any questions or comments I forgive you for I forgive you for saying them like um I'm I'm a little slow picking things up tonight so I
076apologize for that I'm G to withhold most of my questions just until I can process I actually don't mind any of this I really I really appreciate the effort that everyone put into uh trying to figure this out because wow um but the only question I did have was will we ever do we think we'll ever get to a point where we can bring Middle School to an earlier start time um to get them some relief on that late um dismissal that was the only question I had I think I mean I'll take that I think I've heard from a couple different board members about this and you know we had not planned to look at revising the entire package of of of start times from or the order from um High School Elementary Middle
077School uh for the upcoming year I do think that takes um a lot of community input and and work if we're going to look at uh revising our entire start times um that is not something that I had up was wondering is it in the Middle School start coming a little I'm sorry May understood so can we just move the Middle School up earlier is that what you're asking oh and I would I would say no I not and especially not with this schedule because as we bump our we're we're doing the tearing so um we need to keep as much of a gap between our tier 2B for our elementary schools and our middle schools so we're able to move our middle schools up uh you know 10 minutes I think two years ago
078from that original four 4:00 dismissal so they're currently at the 350 right and so really that's the soonest we can we can kind of bump them until we give overarching thank you Maya um this might not be the appropriate time to talk about it but because you were talking about you're freeing up potentially 13 or however many buses um and I know you guys are always constantly recruiting for bus drivers um does this mean that there will be able to be more buses available for um field trips uh potentially um potentially depending on if we free up more Middle School you know if we have less on the Middle School tier we could do we could start some of our field trips earlier if we don't have as many drivers but right now our field
079trips are really dedicated to be in the middle of the day between our middle school and then our High School dismissal or middle school arrival and High School dismissal uh so it doesn't really change that other than as we have additional flexibility and we have more on time we could free up some of those trip drivers to help with those field trips um at least start them earlier than having to wait until maybe 10 o'cl we could start them a little bit earlier for our high school and Elementary School students Gabby Lillian do you have anything from a student perspective do um I mean not really I have a couple questions but I don't know if they're like the right questions how how do you think this is going to like affect the parents like
080in an emotional statewise like how are they going to react to changing the arrivals and furthermore like creating that difference of minute like I feel like they might create a rise because oh my child's going earlier than eight other schools and why is that and I feel like that's just going to create a lot more answer that as an elementary principle right um our kids can be assigned to runs for buses at any time and uh a 20 minute variance at the worst is minor when it comes down to when they may show up when those buses are picking them up and um it I don't see it to be that major of a change from the parent side because when it shows up everyone wonders hey is that bus showing up for me today
081at 7:45 or is in 8 o' run you don't know um and so that 20 minute Gap it's kind of like a little bit as that that how those the DI are rolling hey I guess I get the 8 o00 versus the 7:45 so for the parent side I don't see it being a huge difference because it's really not a gigantic chunk of time the other point that I might make to that is all of our all of our elementary schools will open at least 20 minutes prior to their start time to allow students in in terms of grow a kiss and ride and so just so when you look at those times I know thinking about what times folks need to get to work and those types of things so even at the 8:45
082time our schools would be open for drop offs at 8:25 when when we had Parkridge and whing Creek on the tier and we switched it back to everybody at the same time the people at parkd wanted to stay where they were and the people wind and creep W to stay where they were so one was early and one was late it didn't really matter they loved where they were so I I think as Mr Macky saying if our buses are going to be more likely to be on time then I would think the parents you know would would adapt and and be grateful they're not you know out there waiting for a bus yeah I think most parents are going to be relieved that there's more consistency when you send the survey out I would
083make sure to put into the the the heading why we're doing this and what we expect the outcome to be because you know that's we're not just you know changing for change but that there's been a you know analysis and that we fully expect that we're going to be able to you know provide better service Beyond Time and and that this is part of it so if they understand why we're doing it and that It ultimately should benefit the families I I think they'll be you know very really um comfortable and and I'm really glad to see Rock Hill I've been asking for that for years and I never believe the answer that it was because it was too much traffic going in that one road because for 20 years we had to much traff
084both schools open all of a sudden it became a traffic problem so thank you for relieving that traffic issue that non-traffic issue well there's still 45 minutes you know they're still half an hour apart it wasn't a traffic problem I do want to thank you Mr matth I know monir's missed you but um I do appreciate all the effort that you put into transportation and trying to resolve some of these issues and I think this is a great idea I've heard great things from principles the only thing I'm a little concerned about is um if I think we should do we really know is it better to put Elementary School 19 and plan for it to be in a specific time slot so we're not changing anything at the start of next year so I
085know there's what we have 45 minutes before from booko start time to um Elementary School 19 is that enough or should we put them start with them in the second tier the two should we so so I'm just because I'd rather not change things well then I also to add on to that it's you know the start of the high school the start of Elementary School 19 but then also the middle school because there is that road new road that they're going to be sharing so I yes yeah I just I I think it would be really nice to be certain of those times if we could I don't know if we can analyze it before we have to make this decision time until we've had some time to think about it was a really
086presumptive or even done correct thinking of what to do with the shifting of those times again way ahead you know we don't I don't make the decision also on redistricting but the idea was it's a longer route of some moreable point you know wondering how that's all decided later on um and so that was the reason to think that direction before but again I'm not making that decision that's yours and trying to figure that out so um but it definitely could be work that direction the most important piece would be you want to have both schools on alternating schedules so that Stafford L would be on the opposite time to to provide that support so that's are not there so that's the that's the biggest premise that I'd go with and I do think I
087mean we I I don't I I agree and I don't recommend that we come out and say this is when Elementary School 19 mean your redistricting is not scheduled to be voted on until May so so we just want you to know we've been thinking about that we have that in mind we are planning ahead but we're not ready to come out and say absolutely be this is going to be the time and we wouldn't plan to share that with the community in the survey because it really doesn't apply to anybody yet right yeah my two concerns would be like I would hate that Stafford L would have to change twice yes um if we could if we could mitigate that I mean I understand that no plan is perfect and if this is the
088cost of the plan I guess but um that is that's stressful that's the for parents finding out that they're their students like did you look through are there other schools that not that you know any one is better than the other but like how we landed on Stafford L versus it was proximity it's just where saffell is located and where the new school is located and but we could have also had the same thing with maybe Rocky Run or Harwood because like Rocky Run and 18 are proximity so did we think about well Rocky Run might switch instead of not that that would be better but like I'm just trying to figure out what the process was and if we looked at other schools that um you know we weighed pros and cons and then
089this would be the best option or is it just for me just thinking I mean until we've done the redistricting I think it's all a lot of this is very spe it can change a lot if you're going to be having I think think those neighborhoods that could move quite a bit so I would just not even I mean I would be clear that that there could be changes that was going to be my like next point is like everything even you know every survey everything we do between now and Final our redistricting needs to be with that asteris caveat italist highlights this is a sander thing um you know this is not even this list is not set in stone after redistricting we might decide you know we might to I wouldn't say we
090might decide we might need to it's not like some winds well we're just looking at this now so this this isn't certainly it's something subject to change based on and I I do want to add you know because of a distric thing we're still another year away from that going into a fact even for our our schools listed here so these These are the tiers and the schools that work for next year before we've added to new schools and before the redistricting so it could be after redistricting some of the other ones might need to shift too maybe to to your point we think um that the biggest change we're going to see is in that Stafford lzone but but before we add Elementary School 19 in order to really make this work most uh
091effectively we need staffordale on that first tier so even we don't want to shift it to the second tier just for one year because we think it's going to work it really you need to have that sister school that it's tied to and it doesn't have that until 19 so we need them on the first tier to start for next year but some of the other ones depending on distric team might need to shift too also keep in mind students are going to be moving schools too so they're going to have maybe potential Chang they would have been a tier one they're going to go to a tier two the survey should show that The Proposal is to either start at 8:15 or 8:45 there's no assignment of schools at this time time but what
092we're looking at is for approximately half the schools to start at 8:15 and the other half to start at 8:45 and then put their end time too even though you would just you know add the time just so that that's do we get any additional buses if we've got buses in the budget this year we do got few there's 12 in in the budget and then we're going to try to supplement with one time money so still a challenge of trying to keep up with our replacement right so the only other I guess concern I had or question was taking 13 drivers off of signed routes and having them be essentially permanent Subs is that going one year until the new when the new schools open I assume we're going to need more buses well
093drivers we need you know the kind of like our some of our teachers we the students generate the need for drivers and teachers so we're not we We'll add a few hundred more students the next year but really what's driving it is the years of adding students so we can open two schools and you have the same amount of buses and still be just as efficient what press we'll we'll look at it there's going to be a shift right so instead of you know right now Stafford Del has nine buses next year they might only need seven or in in two years so two of those buses are going to shift around so are we going to have any driver angst over losing a permanent route like I don't want to lose drivers with this
094plan um so a lot of the routes are staying the same maybe the some of the route pairing is no I mean ders that are no longer assigned to a route and they just kind of show up and will get told what they're driving is that going to be a hardship for could we lose drivers if they're not on a permanent route or are there drivers that are just willing to I'm sure we'll have yeah there's there are some drivers who enjoy that flexibility and so the one thought is drivers would also be brought into this for who's interested in being one of our contracted Subs so that you can have that variety sometimes they don't want to drive that same route so there's survey pieces to go along with that to match up um
095and then also to uh this will help out a lot this year um the the base uh rate for a driver is 6 and a half hours some of our drivers are up to eight hours or more because of picking up all the different runs and and you name it um so the nice part is we'll be able to get this into the system really ASAP to start to put these into traversa um to know exactly how long that they're anticipated to be to then almost go into a bid B based on seniority and and everything else to earn those routes right um and where they want to be and and um I think it's going to help a lot of people because they're going to know very clearly what their routes would look like
096um compared to this year where it's a little bit of I don't know and hey can you help cover um so it it will definitely help out um my other question was and maybe this can't happen when we go into redistricting will we um when we look at our maps and and and tweaks start to come in will we be able to be reminded of like this neighborhood would be in this tier or or I I I don't what I'm saying okay here's what I don't want I don't want anyone to say well you guys changed that and that messed up the tearing or like how do we how would we know or to not have us mess that up so I don't I don't think because our elementary school zones we have a lot
097more of them and so it's some tweaks to the edges it's not like high school where it's five massive zones and we had to turn it into six and so we had some bigger shifts with this it's it's when you have some shifts between schools it's really like on your edges and you're and you're trying to balance them out I don't think it's going to be as much of an impact but 100% you you could take a neighborhood that's in the FMA Zone and we're going to ship them over into the um Fairy Farm Zone and they're going to go from one tier to the other that potentially you know could happen but I don't think we're talking thousands of of students or families Dr Chase yep so um I just wanted to clarify something
098you said which is um we do not have an attendant on every bus right we only have attendance on special ed buses on specialed bus I just just wanted in case people were listening and they're like well there's no attendant on my kids bus it's been proposed but we never no I I would absolutely love for us to be able to do it but that's not happening this year or next year so in in talking about the opt-in schedule um we will have some folks who are new to the community so how is that what's the plan for you know if you have a kindergarten or Rising kindergartener you may not be around and you don't have other children already in the school system um you know or people who mov M into the area
099and haven't had kids we when they're registering we're going to have them you know complete that survey too so we'll do that opin selection form as soon as they're registering or soon thereafter and then we're going to have changes so right now our plan is our routes will be built we're going to have them shared out with families um in like that last week of July but we still have to get through the open house week we're going to have some changes are going to come there we're going to have new students show up so just like always when new students arrive to the division we're still going to obviously give them the opportunity to right to do a selection for and we'll route them we just always say give us a couple of days
100or five to 10 days you know usually it's a quick fix we get them maybe the next day even assigned to a route it just depends on what changes we have to make to those routes well and I mean I was here for the the transportation study that came out with all Co and so I'm I'm very happy to see us actually considering doing some of what was recommended there in terms of this steering I hope it works um and I also so want to say I appreciate um and hope you all will continue in response to the board not allowing us to push you to over promise right like I don't want us to be thinking that middle school could go earlier or this that or the other and then we just have the
101community upset with us because we we promised something that we couldn't deliver on so I hope this works and uh be interested to see what the community has to say when you send out the surveys and things like that can can we get on a separate line um not necessarily on the chart but the longest bus rides you know the current long longest bus rides per school and is are we proposing the longest bus rides are going to be reduced some of the ones that are longer are hard I I will tell you it's it's the marable points it's there are some Heartwood runs I'm just curious do do we expect that there's going to be some not necessarily because of this tearing maybe opening the schools and if your school gets a little bit
102closer really you might cut on a few minutes with es9 being farther down um Courthouse Road than Stafford L but I don't think there's going to be significant impact so so we could we're still in an hour plus for long this runs well at least if the buses are on time I think people will be grateful and what it is I think it's the reliability Factor too we can improve well iist I think that uh you know the reason we get if if kids teachers were late their classrooms you wouldn't hear as much but when it becomes a factor that is affecting the parents that's when you're going to hear something and that's when we have heard stuff is the hardship that is created for the parents and the reliability of you know either their
103child care or their drop off or and you know and talking with the principles that I've been visiting how many more car riders that they didn't anticipate that they've had to deal with and it's not gone down even though the bus that situation has gotten better they're still doing the car riding thing yep so can you remind me um where is Northstar and rising star in the schedule they were on their own they have their own separate buses okay oh oh separate okay dedicated which the federal government pay for some of them not they did they have some of them them perfect tense so they were excluded from this analysis but we want provide additional buses then this will free up some buses hopefully that we can reallocate directly to on we went from 13
104like already planing them but um my other thing is uh Mr Macky you were describing a little bit and I'm I guess a little confused on um the special ed piece of busing to these elementary schools how is that going to be improved as well it's number one is you're able to te right now every bus is still flying to all the locations at the same exact time for the same arrival so um you're able to uh I'm going to look at the Heartwood and Rocky Run piece right now right and so uh let's just uh and I can speak to those I taught I was an assistant principal with those so I can speak a little bit more right so that Heartwood side um has a is the the 845 start and the Rocky
105Run so the Rocky Run can drop off as early as uh 755 for their start so that allows drivers were able to get their kids to Rocky Run and they're able to then at that point still have roughly 50 minutes of travel time from the time they drop off if they're in the early part of that window to be able to get out to Harwood to support and so the same drivers can work in both schools okay um to be able to help out with it just on the mainstream side and our special needs 13 Subs like contracted Subs could help as attendance they could help as more uses for those 13 about the timeline for the optin and closing of the oh yes um I'm a little concerned about and I can understand I
106do but in knowing how uh having our opt in close on May 1 I fear that's a little early I understand that then the schools will kick in and do their part to make sure that 100% parents are included but I I I see it opening in April I just think that with school not closing until the end of May it might be just a little too soon for our parents to all respond but that's just my thought right we may not but we may not have the staff to be making the phone calls after why didn't say wa till the end of the year I mean school's in for most of the 2nd through the 31st anyway actually not super opposed to May 1st like I feel like some of it could be maybe
107concurrent where we're keeping the opin open kind of like those of us who forget to pay our lunch balance like we can I get the reminders but I still go I'm talking about myself um but I still can go in and do it manually I don't have to like report to the front office and bring my checkbook right I can still do it on my own um I definitely think it's our in our best interest to make people opt what way or another before we lose them for the summer and if they have to change over the summer because something happens then we can do that but to have everybody opted in before the end of May um I'd love to get some updates as the month uh between April 8th and May 1st about
108how much we're hearing I'd love to for us to be able to get some Friday updates sure on how that's going I'd like to get the redistricting decision made before we require people to opt in because it may have an impact you know on what school they're assigned to and whether they want to be D driving their kids or whether they want to B I mean there is going to be a another year though oh I thought this was going to start now this is reg oh wow oh then that'll be another opt in yeah do they have to year option every year but still there's going to be some people that are going to be affected if we let fifth graders stay and you know that's when is the redistricting decision in May the
109next week in May when may may what you're meeting in May we're that next it's yeah I know I saw it was sometime in May but is there is there a magic about May 1 really oh this may 1 yeah uh no we just wanted to provide adequate time to close it out because um as someone Miss Sigman alluded to once we approach the end of the summer and we lose our or the end of the school year our 10-mth staff go home uh so we don't have them to help maybe contact families and as you get to those last couple weeks of the school year just you know there's a lot going on with graduations and and field days and yeah and and honestly the the the bulk of our survey responses come the
110first couple of days that we send the survey out and it dies off we send reminders we get a couple hundred more but it really like dies off and I'm hoping that we're going to plaster our schools with like QR codes so that when families are in for that you know kindergarten moving up F day all that stuff that that they can be reminded to scan and opt and because it's going to be harder for us if they opt if they forget to opt in and then they opt in in August it's going to make it a lot harder for you than having maybe have to opt in a little I to say it's a lot harder also for the frankly it's the high schoolers that is just most unclear Elementary I could tell you
111back to m q are exactly which kids are our car riders and which ones are a bus riders right now and I could give you that information in seconds and I I would bet that most of that's going to carry forward it's the middle school high schoolers especially that are much harder to figure out um for it and that's and I think for high schoolers in particular we need to remind families that because I hear a lot well I'm going to sign my kid up because I want them to have the option um if their car breaks down or if we have to swap and they don't remember I guess or realize that if they don't ride for two weeks they're essentially dropped and then you have to get back on it's not like you
112can just wake up one morning and set your kid down to the bus stop but I think that reminder needs to be there's going to be yeah a lot of messaging around this and um I kind of have mapped out a video where we talk about that yeah I just said we need to make a video for optin and if you guys didn't do it I was going to do my own so because we need to make sure people understand that exact point so the high schoolers are going to need to know whether have parking spaces and they won't know that until later in the summer because some of the schools have lotteries to get the parking spaces even though they have to pay for the parking spaces I can't say you know my you
113know my child may have a car and they may be able to drive but if they don't have a parking space they're going to have to opt in so we're going to have to remind them if you opt in and something changes please please please tell us so we don't put you on our schedule this is C when can we decide on the parking spaces can we do that earlier in the year because usually it's in August isn't it would seniors get okay so two-parter I I know this was already answered but I need clarification because I kind of forgot does the bus transportation like with all the busing rearranging is that going to affect parent pickup and car riders not at all I would like to address that because I know specifically for Brook
114Point like with I know that there's a lot of like reconstruction and all that so we kind of have to change our our like Road management and there's like cross guards and whatever but with the busing it makes it really hard for especially parent pickups because I'm a parent pickup and especially in the mornings when the buses are going through and the cross guards do all their thing it'll either be super empty to where like we can get in and get out or I'll be late 5 10 minutes from school when I'm literally in the school grounds but because of the drivers of the bus drivers and all of the cars being packed from that now I'm late and it's my fault well right now think we have the two routes so when the elementary
115school opens I think there's separate car rider and bus Loops oh yeah at high school hopefully that will high school it's a problem but you're also going to have two entrances now it was of the traffic it was just the volume so many people driving and also you're losing kids out of your school yeah I was going to that's actually what I was going to mention is we have that at all of our high schools now actually St High might be the worst and but some of that is as we open up our new schools and we start to like those spread out some of those students it'll take a couple hundred kids out of a high school which means that's now less car riders on the just just to clarify so today really was
116about the elementary tearing we wanted to signal that we we heard what you said about optin we are planning on opting in that's a whole separate inter departmental team that's working on all of the transportation recommendations so we are planning on that we are moving forward really around the tearing um we wanted to present this plan you know honestly when this when this proposal came forth it was something that we know that if we continue to do things the same way we're going to get the same results this is an opportunity for us to get better next year and not wait a whole another year till 2026 um and so want to bring this before you we do want to get community feedback uh we are planning on sharing with families here's what your tier
117would be here's your and get feedback and planning on coming back and sharing with you that with you and and um the operational decision on March 18th we're not asking for really a vote on this it's just a 10 minute and 20 minute shift we feel like we can do that and so we want to get the community feedback come back with you to you at the work session in March share that with you and share with you based on this this is the how we plan to move forward for the upcoming year and you can see kind of communicate with families accordingly Mr Macky I have to give you a big round of applause we really appreciate you and your team because I know this isn't a singular effort but your whole team to
118put something like this together because one of the things like Dr says sometimes these pilot programs are piloted and then all of a sudden it goes away or it's piloted and but we never get the feedback from it so we saw the Parkridge Winding Creek and it was called a pilot but we never got anything after that it just went away well there's that whole Co thing yeah there's that different superintend another new superintendent and here we are and so I just want to thank you for an out of the box Solution that's been piloted and as you said appreciated so I really do want to say stud just a quick question because I don't know and maybe Dr stample knows um if a student gets a parking spot does that mean we do not
119provide bus transportation for them usually they come off the list so if they opt in right in May and they get a parking spot they would be Nam would be for just a question of something that might want to be considered we don't hold the spot for the occasion that they may need to ride the bus right that that that what I'm saying is that we might might want to make clear that when you pay for that parking spot you are giving up right and so that's a a great Point uh and so historically because we didn't know ahead of time we were basically routing 100% of our kids um and it was we were a little late this year I started working with Dr Rice and um and now we're working on it next
120year which is when they sign their agreement for that parking spot it's going to basically say you're losing your spot on a school bus so we're going to take that away from them now if there's a circumstance where they need their car break you know whatever we'll work with them to make sure they have a bus provider but but just ju just to have some clarity there I mean we need to think about and I'm not asking for an answer now but we need to think about the inclement weather if we have snows I mean as a parent I would not want my child my my young driver to be driving you know on potentially dangerous road not that we would intentionally call school but but it's something to think about because we we have
121had a tragedy in Stafford County based on weather and a student driver so it just if we I don't know how we address it but I would like to put that somewhere in the in in the works you know if the parent can't drive the child to school you know that I cuz I always felt that the buses were available you know you know that that the students chose not to take advantage of that ride but if we say if you get a parking space you can't ride the bus then I you know that's something I would like to to think about I don't want to answer now how long has that been the rule um about when you get your parking space you no longer have your seat on the bus it has never
122really been an official rule but typically after a few weeks as they start to like audit those routes they would take students off the buses if they're not riding any they don't want to ride the bus and I'm only asking cuz I had a kid who was driving their two siblings but I know one of my kids was willy-nilly with the bus CU they would argue and they would leave them so I was just curious like my kid never walk was to get on the bus I was just you know is that the same for the two weeks like if you just don't ride for two weeks like how no how long has that been an official rule always it's been a long long time yeah sometimes it hasn't always been followed to a tea
123um but we kind of tried to do all I remember when we we set that policy and it was because we don't want the buses having to make all these stops where there's no students just Wast time for 7 kids on the bus it's kind of soft especially in neighborhoods like the bus isn't going to not stop anymore if there's five kids and you know one of them is and quite frankly I don't know what happens if all of a sudden you show back up and you know that they're not going to especially at the high school level they're not really anymore so they just I don't I don't know like if your ride no longer has a person live in a neighborhood oring out tomorrow right I mean if you're the only kid and
124that's what I mean it's like in these neighborhoods if they're used to picking up you know six kids and all of a sudden it goes to five and then a month later you're back up to six because you're no longer friends with a person typically the drivers away the car privileges yeah a lot of if they've been on the route and they know that know thees usually we're not going to leave a kid on the side of the road we're all right so um moving on to our next topic this is and your team when you get on here let me know I want to come see you sounds great thank you so much this uh agenda item is discussion of proposed changes to policy 1403 DP and propos new regulation 1403 and identification of
125priorities for elementary school redistricting that will take place obviously in August 2026 so there are kind of two goals for this discussion um one and I think we heard a lot of especially me in this past round of redistricting where fam families refer to the policy they see a list in no particular order of about a million things we consider in redistricting but we don't rank those we don't really even specify how or why those are factors to begin with um so this gives us the opportunity to revisit that list and say is this something we even want to list we need to clarify how it's listed do we want to um kind of change any of any of the items on that list or whatever and then also gives us an opportunity to talk
126about which priorities for elementary redistricting we would like staff to focus on particularly when we are before they bring us any scenarios um because in the past the county has brought us scenarios and then we're like oh well this didn't look at this demographic data or this didn't factor in transportation or this didn't factor in travel time or stuff like that and then they go back and they do it again and that's really complicated and stressful for families so we thought that this time we might look at what are have a discussion about what types of things we're looking for consideration on in the proposed scenarios that they bring us at the outset um and having what that conversation is and line is of course here to hear that conversation so he can take that
127feedback back with him on um before we get our first round of scenarios and he can refer back to what our preferences are um so has governance talked about this at all yet I know that not go to governance because it was a school board retreat item and and a request and we've already coming back to the full board in a work session we brought it to the full board and a work so are we starting with 1403 R um I sure we can start with r or the first I had Che I had a yeah so Mr G give us should we right do you prefer that we start does it make sense to start with the proposed amendment start with the policy okay 1403 P there's a lot of a of changes here
128um it puts in a lot of our definitions um I for one thought crowded School percentage should be lower than 105% but we that's line 31 on page one um because I feel like we talk about things in an effort to have a change in place before school hits 105 I don't know what a better percentage would be but I think 105 is5 and I know that my first couple of months when I had to do a redistricting that was a drum I was beating I don't like one five well why can't it be 100% because like 100% of this it's at the lid it's at the top so why are we I mean I don't know maybe that's not it's not educational logic but that's common sense logic 100% is 100% so that would
129be crowded if you're at 100% you're crowded well hypothetically if you're at 100% you're okay if you're above 100% then you're then 100% 01 100% is essentially when start talking about a crowded School versus but if it's a we probably should Define capacity utilization because if I were reading this I would have a question if your a capacity utilization above or below or whatever number what is that I mean I know I know we have a definition for it and I know what it is it's like based on the the the capacity and and that can change and I think that's important that people understand that the capacity ulation of a school can change depending on what the programs are on in there that's I think that's that's not at all three levels though right
130that's just Elementary yeah yeah trying be but uh some of the you know but over half our schools are elemented right some of the r some of the thinking behind 105 or whatever you want it to be is that sometimes you'll have a a large cohort that pushes through and maybe they're in the fifth grade so it could be something that's very temporary and then once it pushes through the numbers pop back down so you know so maybe we need like a step one step two like we have a conversation at 100 um checking in with Lionel to say oh this this is just a cohort a situation versus starting a conversation at 105 so maybe it's maybe we split it and say start the conversation at 100 checking in with staff to see what's
131happening so that we don't get to 105% and all of a sudden you know we're having a November conversation where we need 15 trailers or something you know I mean I agree and I mean just because we're at 100 doesn't mean that we have to do something it just means that we have to recognize that it's there and maybe it's trailer maybe it's a 5% maybe it's a full like you know a real redistricting as it were but but at least a superintendent redistrict yeah but at least at 100% we're having a conversation at5 we're making a decision we're we're defining uncrowded as a school with capacity uation between 80 and 100 so there's a limbo between 100 and 105 that's we've got uncrowded school and then we've got cred I I actually looked up
132crowded in the dictionary because that was because technically maybe it's uncrowded up to 100 then over 100 and Below 105 is crowded and overcrowded is 105 I don't know if that's what you're trying to say because because that's been the the standard approach is once you hit 105 it's almost mandatory that you take some action yeah and and also sorry I didn't me to cut you off but just to give you like some perspective see if a school has a00 seats 5% of a00 is 50 so your 50 kids over the capacity just to give you a frame of reference now it depends yeah so about two classrooms and again it depends on yes you know the where they the distribution right exactly what grade they're in so there are a lot of factors but
133just think of 5% is not necessarily a huge number but starts to tell us there may be a shortage of classrooms but also taking what you give us with this when we look at this number we also have projections from you that show us in the next year the five year the 10 year so that it's a reasonable conversation where we say this isn't going to get prettier right so either let's have a conversation with the superintendent to do something and direct or we bring in the learning cottages trailers or we do like Miss Sigman said a larger redistrict right so I just I think we just need like our thresholds to be I don't like emergencies like I like I don't like surprises yeah like it was a surprise to get that many trailers
134to come at us so at once yeah and another thing just think about that 105 is also the threshold for the administrative boundary change right that's what I was saying directly so you know this no I I didn't think that was threshold I thought they could just the superintendent could just do it up to 5% it doesn't have to be at no it doesn't have to be at 100 but he's just giving numbers yeah I think it's just a definition of crowded school because on the other page next page it saidacity utilization between 80 and 100% not off you know to offset SPAC so I think it's just we got crowded and we got uncrowded I think it's just 5% I we'll take a look at it let us take a look at it see
135if we can't tweak it or clarify the way I read it is 105 is over correct 100 page two just under 105 because it makes sense to me so maybe it shows up somewhere else that I'm not so greater than 100 105 yeah just it got moved it says in the in the thing here that it got basically to I do like page three where they talk about why we take out Mak sense where they kind ofou the different um I do like on the page three where we've kind of grouped and explain the things we consider um particularly that last one stability because we've had so many families saying well we were redistricted in elementary so we shouldn't be redistricted in high school and it doesn't it don't work that way we just try
136to not redistrict I do want to give credit though like when we were doing the high school redistricting and we were brought the scenarios but then we did public hearing and it was at the public hearing not public hearing Town Hall it was at a town hall when I heard a parent say a crowded North is not like a clouded crowded Forge crowded Mountain View so that made me think we needed to think about this differently so hearing you know while we can give everything to you maybe guidance wise those Town Halls served a purpose when the parents started talking about something I hadn't even thought of and so I just I I don't know where to how to state that put that think that but I I do appreciate parent input in maybe driving
137a different scenario and so I don't know how to put that right so the criteria we have here right it's not saying that it's everything because we can't think of everything and that's why okay you know it's saying um here are some of the more popular things that come sure but it's not an exhaustive list of every possible thing that could be ativity yes so Mr R actually one of the things we put on the slide specifically in bold was we want the community to provide feedback on all of the factors which is why like Community feedback isn't specifically a factor yeah we want their feedback on all of the factors and that's what's going to help kind of steer you in a direction okay okay thank you well you got a shell in there
138oh dear the following criteria shall be considered I don't know if you want that should it be a May it's a May yeah Will is May there's May will be considered yeah because I think there does need to be some flexibility we did that just for you miss there's sometimes sometimes when you need to use discretion they tested you this a will not a shall I pass you found so the the bullet that is giving me pause is actually the first one proximity MH um and I think because my experience with PR districting and for your district for my district is that's super hard we are we have not been assigned to schools that are close to student residences we have had to redistrict to schools further away spes um because of we haven't had
139the space in the school closest so I struggle with having that be like a top priority close to wherever and I know that that distance for mine like the fact that I have kids going four miles instead of 2 miles makes the rest of you laugh I get it but for for the people in my district it's important that they have to drive past a school to get to Priority number one just because it's listed number it doesn't say closest I was going to say is reasonably close like do we have to close it just means the you know the location well it just says school that is close to student residences and re the receiving school has adequate space that's just one but miles instead of saying like for me 100% change so I
140I just give a you know don't don't shoot me but why from my perspective from my perspective what I have seen is is we have all these different factors right and if somebody is unhappy with the proposed change and they don't want their kid to go to that school they will pick the factor that we have ignored to make that art yeah so from my perspective I'm pretty happy with I I don't feel any need to prioritize these I mean if you want to you could take a random number generator and make sure you put them in some kind of totally random order so that it's less thinking that this is the order alphabetical order if actually the policy specifically says that they're not listed in order but that doesn't mean that people read it
141um let's put it in bold right seriously yeah yeah would you would you have here the criteria are not presented in priority order any or all may be considered and the board reserves the right to blah blah blah it's it's almost like if you put it in order that it takes the whole conversation away versus if you start with the list with proximity and end with stability with theater in the middle that maybe you know they just are right because you got proximity forecast efficiency contiguous if you put them in alphabetical order then maybe it less like we we you we should probably talk some about neighborhood though I'm not suggesting one or the other but we do have some very large neighborhoods in Stafford County now I mean it used to be it was
142just a quiet harbor back in the day but now we've got other large communities and do we still want to have that as you know a goal because we we really I I think going going around the bend trying to accommodate um I'm not suggesting we not do it but I think it it dep like I personally don't like to split neighborhoods in general I am more likely to split for non- high school because in my experience when you split a neighborhood and they're going to two different high schools you get some kind of Mischief that occurs within the neighborhoods particularly around school competitions people who want to call Leland station neighborhood right you've got got part of Leland station is on one side of of Leland Road and another ofmer house and they do
143not all go to the same elementary school and it's okay and and to claim that they're all in the same neighborhood when you'd have to cross a major road to get to the other get to the other section so again I think there neigh are also so big and have so many students it it's not it's not really practical to how to put them in the same SP I wonder if we're going to get to a point where some of our neighborhoods have too many students for a school right I don't know depending on how many kids we have yeah we could not at Harbor because I don't they're not they used to be yeah har not be in this conversation we're not going students Elementary stud no homes no it's like 25 right so
144I'm giving you my feedback I think we should just leave it and so as far as and maybe alphabetized just so that it takes that thing that we said this don't even put letters next to them right yeah they're just as far as the new regulation I mean we can certainly review this and and specific you say these are presented in alphabetical order right state that people don't say oh you put this first right even though you said they're not in priority order it's new it's a new this a new regulation um as you know regulations are are developed to outline process and so you did ask that we put something together and back to you with this and so um just want to see if this kind of meet you expectation around the regulation
145okay so having these discussion is going to be first Aesthetics will be first um let's have a conversation about what factors we'd like to see presented in round one of scenarios for Elementary 18 and 19 um I think with high school it was the kind of the biggest topics that kept coming up were um the demographic data of the schools which I know is different in an elementary than at a high school because they're smaller but um utilization I think that was trying to maximize the utilization of a school that was more out of the other you know I guess location and transportation um because I think obviously Cardinal forest was like the poster child of the neighborhood that was or Stafford lakes that was bust to the school that was not closest and they
146became kind of the poster child for things we're trying to correct and I think we have several smaller instances in elementary that we might want to look at correcting so I think for me that would be kind of top priority is realigning families back to probably where they should have been 5 ago or whenever they got moved um I I worry about um really um High needs kids who are in a school where the school has really worked to work with those families and then develop relationships and then we're moving them to another school um that can be really hard so and may not be equipped with Personnel to handle correct at that year for that year it might have to be another year before they are right so that's something that I I but
147not that you know on the other hand it may be in terms of we don't want a school to have to be overcrowded because of that or to create Islands because of that but just that it is something that it's more about a resource stability right um I mean like if you have a school that's accustomed to dealing with a lot of elll students and now we're changing it and the elll students are all being moved to a school where there have been no elll students that can be a real challenge not that we shouldn't do it but but to give give it some thought as we go through that was kind of we use wouldn't we move staff as well to accommodate sometimes it happens sometimes it doesn't right like very that's by choice
148isn't that's seniority staff get to pick well not for ell if the school no longer has the population to support elll not we're going to keep it's that's just an example it could be something else we've always had that because certain I was I'm looking down here you're not Mr Mack um you know he knows knows his like he said I can tell you everybody who's a car ride that these principles know their families so maybe what we need is a special plan for the transition between the staff the principal and the staff because the kids that get moved when you're in a school those teachers get together and they decide who's going to be assigned to what class for the next grade level in the elementary and they know the students and they know
149the teachers but if your child gets redistricted right they don't know your child there is a transition plan though for redistrict is but but maybe in the case that Dr Chase is talking about you know it needs to be more attuned family engagement type stuff transition well is that in here too because you just brought up a good point one of the things that and I spoke with Dr Smith about what our principals did with the elementary redistricting they did a fantastic job of not just your family engagement things before school schol that are traditional they did other above and beyond extra so that new families could maybe get to know principles and some staff maybe get to walk around the school right just to for their you know we always know that there's a
150little bit of a fear in a parent and so it takes that down because if you bring down the parent fear you lessen the child's but I just think that maybe as part of this that we find a way to maybe articulate that that will be done something will be done yeah and we've already talked about some it's going be a number of transition events and we've got high school you've already done right we've got Elementary that's coming on uh so there's going to be a lot of that and so um and you're going to have kids coming together from to three new schools just and so we've already talked about the volume of transition and how we do need to plan some of those transition activities and once we have an idea what that's
151going like Elementary we can get our principles around that and I'll just end know that would be ar ulated in this or not so much or you mean in terms of I mean I don't think in terms of the prioritization around around this or the around in a regulation not a policy but a regulation I'm not take a look at I don't I thought think something that triggers that response from the school yes right that it's something that will happen I'm not saying has to but we don't get into the details M Rand but the last bullet in the regulation actually says that superintendent school leadership and administration will facilitate the transition of students to their new schools I think that's the purpose of that was to like incorporate those sort of okay community events
152and the trans transition to the new school okay also doesn't limit them or put them in a box you got to do it this way you know I don't want that but I just still they did because some of the schools did it like Hampton Oaks painted a mural that included monir's bear in with their's mascot as well to show that they were joining together um but I just think that you know every school didn't do that visited every single student from he went to every single student's house gosh that's nice but just like I said just I I I don't say Define it but I was just saying you know some but I think that's this and we have talked about I think mentioned already talked about making sure there is on uniformity since
153we're this isn't a countywide r distric thing we're going to have some kids shifted around do we anticipate there any elementary schools that will be non impacted by any of these I can't imagine no I think everybody's going to be impacted and and the new schools I'm not as concerned about the transition for the new schools because that's that's got to happen they're they're all it's the ones that may be getting a few or you know more and and you know how that how that work right where they're not losing like I think some of our like Corner schools the outlier schools will much like North didn't um like we didn't add to them we took we removed but on the elementary side it's going to be I think the opposite there are going to
154be some schools that may not lose any families and we will just be adding um I'm very careful to have this conversation even with some schools in my district like in high school I feel like everybody is going to have some reduced capacity but in our elementaries that's not going to be the case some of our elementary schools are going to be more crowded post redistricting because of our utilization and that wouldn't even say crowded they will they'll just have a full School whereas like I said you know for me I I've said this early on is I would love to see the outlying schools Fairy Farm uh Rock Hill Garrisonville get a full school because Fairy Farm has been involved in four redistricting as a way of helping out another school and so we
155get a peace meal brought in of communities as opposed to you know a nice redistricting of kids that just are chosen for Fairy Farm so I just think that you know that you're right it's going to fill those schools as they should be right because everything has beened to it it feels you know it's it's certainly something to get used to and that like that is my biggest like my priority is I want to see the schools utilized um I would love to accommodate for future growth if we know we know that ground has been broken you know those tow houses right across the street let's leave a couple spaces in the school that we know that they're going to go to um because we know that those are right there uh maybe not the
15610-year growth plan but at least the the active developments to know so that we're not putting all of our schools to the same percentage like they're not all going to be at 90% And then some of them will stay and some of them will end up at like 120 right but I would say I mean and some of this is a staff question too but um as Miss Randall was noting with North North a full North is very different from a full um Stafford but but I was going to say Heartwood a full Heartwood is going to be a very different experience than a full Conway you know just in terms of and I know we have U you know I know we have this utilization thing and all of that but what I hear
157from principles at the older schools is like there are no closets for them to put any storage you know and that would be the question I think is when we look at all of our schools what's the optimal utilization of a Heartwood and a Fairy Farm and so that we can try to Target so we're leaving space for addition for new students in areas where we have growth but we're not stuffing students into a school that's maybe not going to accommodate all the things they need to and that'll come with the EAP when you had the classroom stuff in the back yes and then the other issue I've been thinking about is I would like to see us try to kind of maintain our Title One proportions like I don't want to end up with
158a redistricting that for for some reason instead of having the six or eight we have we end up with like three but they're at like 80% for in reduced lunch right or that we go down to maybe we've spread out populations that lose the support true but right it might be move it might be yeah and then or to purposefully spread out populations so that we have no title in schools and therefore lose any available support that might exist at the time um so I understand that this might mean that a school that is Title One today based on how population shift that particular School may not be but for those families that have come to rely on the resources um that are needed to support them I don't want I want to make sure
159that you know to your point we have elementary schools that have much stronger PTO because the families are they have more resources and we have schools that struggle because they have a higher portion of free O is a good example hampon Oaks was title clearly title one before the last redist and then and then it switched over to Moncure so but yet Hampton Oak stayed on for the roll back roll back period with CSR yeah yeah I had my iWood did too yeah and and that's I think we're going to have to look very care and then we got a redistricted population that made us title one but we didn't get supports for a year and that was extremely difficult extremely difficult and that's what I'm worried about too you know we we like the
160CSR classes or CRS classes if we have classroom reduction size classes but we redistrict and now suddenly we have a school that doesn't need classroom reduction but we have a school that does and it doesn't have that access to it maybe we ought to build that into our scenario once we we consider assignments then we look at identifying the title one schools for the the year and we we've got another year to can we do that like if we redistrict and we designate at that at the time of redistricting does that help us get the resources in place for when the schools actually open or did the schools have to be open for them to even start it's up to us to identify those schools correct right we identif we still get the same amount
161of P our p in terms of Title One funding is not going to change just how we split it up CSR is different because that's a state program right and it it still does the three threee rolling average we don't have to accept it right if we we have a choice CU I was always asking how much does it cost us because we had schools that were clearly not title one anymore but yet they had smaller classes because we could get more money but it did cost us money to get the money it wasn't free and CSR has a minimal impact on us now because of our staffing caps right now that are class siiz caps that we have on K through three already kind of mirror the CSR with the exception of I think
162K Willard be because their higher percentage has a a lower cap on CSR Mar did too I don't know if it still yeah so it was really like one grade level that Kate Waller Barrett that was impacted by it these past few years that's really the kind of stuff I worry about mostly you know for the kids that are there the kids that are NE that have flourished or benefited under that educational structure and technically they should still have it but because of bureaucracy they don't and I'm you know for the time it takes to re-qualify or recalibrate you know I want to make sure that the kids that need it and the teachers that need it get the resources they need to continue to support those kids we'll have to decide once we know
163what percentage is are then we as a school board say where do we draw the line because it's it's our choice we could have 10 schools inside of one we could have three schools in Title One you know it's it's really in in the past what we've done is look at where where is there a Gap you know in the percentages and if the Gap is like one or two% we would air on the side of keeping them in as title versus keeping them out but it's whatever the board wants to do but it should be part of this process once we finish with the with the decision on who's going to be where and then you get a chance to run all that data and then come back to us and look you know
164what are we going to what are we going to put there okay it's not easy so this will be an ongoing conversation um yeah if I point out one thing just in terms of the timeline if you can more so staff's going to come back to you in March on March 11th with u there's going to be another work session and we talking about these initial uh scenarios that uh the school board will review the plan is to bring you multiple scenarios and you let me know which ones you want my my head is splitting thinking about what 17 schools times multiple scenarios it's 19 schools 19 19 oh my well that's right I haven't I haven't progressed till a year I'm still in the present so so 19 schools with mult mle scenario how
165many scenarios are you talking about yeah I mean I was thinking no no no like I would say three to five that's what I was thinking there's your number three again but but these scenarios are going to be because it is more on the boundaries it's not it's not like we're we're moving way overcrowded high schools and trying to optimize which almost makes it harder it's going to be what you're going to be doing to fill these schools like fil fairy form the reason fairy F has been full is because the kids that would be the natural feed which would be going up the road they want to stay at Grafton they want to stay at Conway yeah but I mean literally kids from Grafton I mean they were because we didn't do you know
166move into Grafton move Grafton into fery Farm we didn't do that you just plop this population and stuck them there but the problem is is that we have populations of students that literally drive by fery Road and go to Grafton so I mean these are not to say that that'll change but I'm just saying that there's some considerations well the last three districting we left Fairy Farm a little lighter because of the construction that was going but we only gained one classroom right I'm just saying yeah no was because because construction was going on yeah yeah and also there was a lot of beep yeah push back but it we'll see we'll see I mean it's good this is I I think this is going to be tougher yep than high school which is why
167you need to start with three CU remember who you work with we going to change stuff so add to it so up for the challenge now are we going to look at it are we going to come in here on March 11th and see it for the first time because I'm it's going to be really hard for me to look at these and and absorb it and have any discussion about it but we won't see it we work we work yeah I mean we still have our yeah we'll have distri meetings and stuff I think we'll mostly receive for information we'll just be rece and ask questions about and then I think we have theity feedback and then we don't work until April 8 on so I was asking because March 18th is a school
168board meeting on my calendar and so I would like the redistricting Community sessions to be when school board members can go oh yeah yeah we'll TW those good catch yes we'll change that and then the 22nd April 22nd I think is a meeting as well okay especially because don't we have to have a to we have the public hearing so that's on that is in there I just want to ask Lono to kind of maybe L can help us just what you heard and so we're all on the same page or I don't know if you want to have consensus around so we I just want to make sure that we're on the same page what we're bringing back what the priorities are so that we're all on the same page so I think I
169mean I'm not gonna ask him to parot it back but you know the fact that we've had the conversation there will be minutes there will be a document he's heard it well I be happy to hear what yeah I already asked L he said I gotta go back and watch the tap said we going to put him in alphabetical order talking I'd like to know because I didn't understand that we had actually given Mr that was for the policy he want us to reorder the policy those changes I feel confident about those changes but as far as if we have priorities as far as L presenting or preparing his first uh redistricting scenarios I think there's maybe some we probably need some more clarity on that unless you think it was all St thought he
170did a great job with high school and then we brought stuff in I mean you got to start some so what we've heard is demographic data what we've heard is transportation and distance particularly realigning those optimization of the schools based on condition space optimization probably the top three and demographics so that we're not demics over um overextending one particular school and special education making sure we're looking at that so that if so we're not we're not because I think and that goes under stability trying to maintain stability especially for special ed stud and it also speaks to utilization too how much space the school has for that well is Special Ed going to be on school they're geographically assigned to or we going back to they were supposed to be closer to their home school
171anyway so I would like to think that we're not disrupting many of those students just one particular section subgroup of identified special so we are taking a deeper dive into into back the base I think one particular subp conversation about that we are we are looking at initially because we think that's kind of the first step it is going to take some additional time for us to look at other programs and whether that's that's best for those kids so and it's not a super large portion of are and there placements a lot of times are I te decisions too so in terms of as we look at that in terms of the programs the part of that might help I mean I sometimes don't know if it's cart or horse because I feel like how
172we redistrict might impact particularly where if we're going to reverse back to base so centralize some of these programs where and how we do that might depend on redistricting or do we have like Mr Mackey or Mr wilcott come in and say if we're going to centralize these programs they should be at these two three schools and therefore we have to redistrict leaving space for them so I'd be curious what the cart situation is yeah yeah I mean I think I would prefer us to look at the kids and look at the needs and then where we have the space and the specialized teachers and where it makes sense so I appreciate the concept of back to base we're not moving so far out of your neighborhood school but we also can't have some of
173those programs in every single school and to have the specialized instruction and support so right um so as we look at that to see where's the best placement for those programs and can we please define capacity utilization because I think that would help people looking at this because I I've heard a couple of times and I get it that North isn't the same as the other high schools because it's older but hypothetically if we have a 100% capacity it should be okay anywhere so maybe our capacity needs to be lower in north in terms of the formula than the other but if we say you know I I just I it baffles me to hear a a capacity 100% capacity at North is not the same as 100% capacity at staff at high school because
174it should be if it's 100% it's 100% and it may be because the the hallways are smaller maybe the capacity should be per classroom or whatever but it's you know it just but you just answered it right there though but it's just like if I have five people in my car it's different than five people in my old minivan right but maybe my but but your car and your minivan should have a different capacity right you know what fits that's what I I just think that would be helpful because we hear this a lot about it's not the same but it it 100% should be the same but it's it's not the same for like Heartwood and for I think it's because we have program capacity at the elementary level but not at the high
175school and middle school level like as a full Drew really a full Drew as being an older school that has some of the same concerns that North does not really I mean a f f should be full for that school but it be Heartwood we we already have a a firm height you know High number and that's from the uh the sewer Capac but if we went on what the original construction was like back in oh right now we're talking beyond that right but I'm just saying like right now we're building a school the school is supposed to be 2000 but 20 years from now if we have reimagined how education is delivered maybe it's going to maybe the number of 2,000 that was set in 20124 is not a realistic number like inflation right
176like we might be able to have more kids in a room because of how education is delivered 30 years from now maybe it's less because of how education is delivered but the 2000 number just because they said it in 2024 doesn't maintain doesn't really reflect how a school can be used all the time right which is why you should fluctuate and if we Define capacity utilization then you know that could change I just think it would we're going to say it's the basis for you know action that we're going to take then we should we should have a definition for it okay I'm sure you got one somewhere oh figure out he can make that up'll make it all right our favorite topic budget that last me your everything on no you still need those
177back papers just give me the staple package I cross over really just date change and there's an extra slide on the back that we added for this work session so even if you keep the old one it's not the end of the world no wrong data in there [Music] picture don't inv and Miss pitch y um all right so uh one of the reasons you just got a new uh printed copy is because we when we Consolidated the two meetings into one we did add a slideer to at the end on compensation because we knew we were going to expand on that on the 18th meeting and that slide deck was from the February 11th meeting that you had in front of you so we just wanted to give you that updated copy uh wanted
178to just talk about our projected Revenue uh but um the governor's budget um ultimately had $4.7 billion in additional spending K12 education only Sol 286 million of that so not great um and so what we were what we were seeing in Stafford was a $10.5 million increase based on the governor's budget for the state that with a uh $5 million increase in our local transfer that was based on the county administrator's fiveyear budget from last fall and then some other local funds um think some impact Aid federal federal dollars ultimately netted out to about $200,000 so we're sitting at a $5.7 million increase now state general assembly is still finalizing their budget uh we should have more information on that hopefully uh pretty pretty soon it's developing I will say that house and the Senate
179both um and I shared this with you a few weeks ago house and the Senate both had additional revenue for the schools um roughly in that 78 million range uh and then additionally they the only difference actually between they both had some relief uh to the support cap full lift of the support cap that we've been dealing with since 2010ish uh and a Great Recession yes and then um some special education add-on money so additional money for our special education students that we already have uh and what they where they both differed a little bit was um and I forget which one is which so I apologize but one of the um either the house or the senate had $1,000 equivalent bonus for S soq positions only um in fy2 one of them had it
180in FY 26 both of them gave us the flexibility that if you didn't have the local match to piece of that or or like every School Division we exceed the sqs in a lot of areas so we have more positions than what are actually funded by the state so um that the money they were giving us for that ,000 bonus did not cover every single position that we had and we have to pay FICA taxes and stuff on it so ultimately um we can reduce what that thousand is so that we um can afford to pay it all without an additional local match that would equate to about $750 that's not an exact amount we'll get to that um if that comes a fruition in the budget the what we're kind of hearing is that
181it's probably going to lean towards the FY 26 budget instead of the fy2 because I know a lot of school divisions will have appropriation issues if if they give us that money in fy2 versus FY 26 um so uh that's high level on the budget we expect some changes uh to that $15.7 million projected increas so what about um I just I mean are members of the general assembly at all concerned about needing more money for the unemployment stuff like is there going to be um you know people needing unemployment benefits and so that's going to pull money from the states or are they thinking at all about needing to hold on for some of that um I have not I've not heard about that I don't know if it's something that Lea has heard
182specifically about just curious y um the house and the Senate budgets both passed and so now it's so we're in correct and they're almost identical yeah so does that mean we're going most likely to receive an additional 7even to8 million from what this budget was based on okay that's good to know in state revenue and and we'll get to it but we had $14 million gap so doesn't quite close the also wouldn't some of that have to be for those bonuses so it's not not included there going to be an FY 26 possibly yeah because I treat that differently because it's not recurring money so it's one time money they would provide us for the bonus it'sing it's also earmarked money that we can't just used for operations so right um guess it's one time
183just here's a little gift because we don't really value enough to give you actual sale right and in full disclosure sorry it's true yeah the $4.7 billion in additional spending some of that was onetime funding so they're they are taking that and then reallocating it to the schools so we thank them for that but you're correct it's not going into additional salaries so it's still just the really the the second year of the 3% so we're allocated from the state which we have to do that minimum of 1.5 but this seven to eight million is monies that we had not anticipated or is not in this number when our budget was put together correct so regardless and that is money that we could use for to meet needs yes ma' any of the needs so
184that's good know we still have a we still have a huge gap I mean with that but it's half the Gap g have the G the Gap is just cut notice from about maybe the ell stuff is not going to be quite as do we know yet we we don't and we won't and I wouldn't and as I recommended the Friday bulletin I wouldn't get ahead of that because the the information we got does not congr with budget language correct yeah the only I mean it's frustrating that we can't count on anything until we get it and but we have to make decision before can't plan on use and we can't plan anything because the rules change and I like even on the local side they prefer to wait and see what Richmond does before
185they decide but it's not like it's not like we have we ever have like extra money the money would go to something else or it would go back to them to decide to reallocate to us anyway should there be a so what's the Gap now between what 15 well we're still at 14.2 and we're waiting on that budget to be finalized from the state so we're not 100% we don't even know we're going to get the five from the county correct that was in the county administrator's fiveyear proposal which was done years ago last just what is what has has the he presented that to the supervisor in the fall oh but year recently in his 5year plan he presented that in October and in the fiveyear plan in year one of the fiveyear plan
186we were getting an additional 5 million but it's not until early March though that's present actual budget for this year I'm not I'm not sure we can count on that five at this point well we can't really count on anything but we have to work with something and I it's like we can't count on the funding formula right because theing seven to eight if if that's a little over 8 million I would count 8 million out of the out of the budget then no I'm just saying that it's not a given it's it's an it's a number that is not it's it's right now it's it's not just based on a past 5e plan it's part of a conversation you had with the County Administrator Dr Smith they were aware that we were presenting and
187that's what we were we were starting at that's his working number for their for their budget I don't know exactly what his number is going to be I know he's been working through changes and some of when he making his presentation March 4th I believe March 4th wow should we be there yes we should March 4th it's your orders March 4th that what color shall we wear green green Green oh okay all right um green bra I mean I look at this budget it's a Rel it's a pretty conservative budget I I I don't I I I don't want to ask for more but I I don't want to ask for less either and then I think we need to see where the county comes in because we still need about another 14 million from
188them $ 14.2 million G State money we'll get down to about 19. yes so we need another 19.2 million so if we don't ask we're never going to get and if we don't ask the public doesn't know and this isn't enough I mean even asking for $19.2 million is not enough because it doesn't fund the teacher salaries it and now we're looking at 133% in Prince William over two years that we can't even begin to compete with and Spotsylvania started to catch up with us because CU they're getting their act together which is why we at least at the start of the scale not later I understand we're probably not going to get it but we but I don't know how we can because also the current economic situ situation is unstable but that's part
189of the reason why we have to like we talk about you know joking not joking that we might lose Federal money what do we do then yeah I mean even if we just lose 10 we lose 2% but we don't have 2% our budget is not in a place where making up 2% is an easy thing to do we don't have anywhere to pull it I just don't think it's responsible to not ask for what we actually need I think that that's disingenuous and it's not it's just not if I'm an educator and I'm working here and you're and we don't say we don't express our needs and then 6 months later we're all looking at each other oh my God we need all this and we need all that I'm going to want to
190be the educator to come here and curse you guys out for not saying what we needed because you never know right we're probably not going to get it but how dare you not ask because I I know they need it yeah salaries and the school side allocation are the two that make me lose sleep we've been trying to do that school side allocation the phase to fall back on the phase the the phase adjustments for the teachers yes and we're already behind in the phase adjustments for the service sector and we've made gar we've made promises to all of our employees so yeah those two things are the two things that are the most important to me and every Supervisor has said that they want more money to go to the classroom and the number
191one way to get money to the classroom is to pay our teachers right um and they do not make that easy for us to do but if we were to make the teacher salary then instead of asking for 19.2 from the county we've got to ask for more like we've got to ask for it's 27 was it s million more to do the phas so eight [Music] I'm eight points out yeah that's that's different but completing phase four is about $7 million each additional step so 16 17 be million 26.2 is what we we ask over the 19 million is what yes so to yeah to get our full phase four is pH for the service scale and and yes well that's already in yeah the 19 that is already in and I in the
19219.2 but to get to the rest of phase four It's s more so do we ask for the 7 million more yes MH all right who's for it Ian we still I mean we we all we sat down at a table together with the Board of Supervisors and they said let's have a five-year plan and we said okay and we came up with a 5year plan and and the 5ar plan is pretty close because when you go back and look at it we needed about 14 and half 15 million to finish to phase four this year that was in the fiveyear budget and they knew that and they knew that I I do want to point out this will kind of set us back a little bit but I I want to be fully transparent
193one of the reasons we've been able to what one of the things that we're not able to do right now when we're doing this phase four is that's assuming that we're keeping that starting teacher pay I 50525 so another Avenue to take to increasing that teacher pay which increases the pay for all of our teachers actually work on getting the base of our teacher scale up higher which makes us more competitive with Frenchburg and Spotsylvania because it it impacts every teacher above there because way do we have more expensive right now like we have to think about how to do all of it right like eventually once we've corrected all the phases we can then work at shifting all of it not to say that we should ignore it but I don't want to give
194back into a compression situation and if we can't even do our phases for the people have been waiting for the phases I'd hate to go back and double down on the ones that have gotten those phased increases and what does scale look like if we just adjust the base and not the scale so and that's where if we increase the base um for every $500 we increase the base it's about a $3 million increase in the overall teacher scale so one of the examples like put up there was what if we wanted to pay 52,000 which is right at that number that Spotsylvania has so it puts us back ahead of them that's 8.7 million verus cost but that's that that's on top of or we we we foras four or an and yes it's
195an or or an and it's either 15 percent 15 million strugg forfeit phase 4 because we've we've done increases does do to help us fix next time we're it's going to what does that do like if we did and this is I'm not advocating for it I'm asking a question if we did this and skipped phase four doesn't that make phase four more expensive to correct in future years when we still have to make up our starting salary as well CU one of the things we where we do win I guess is that if if you stay with us you will end up making more and for some teachers they're not looking to division hop they're not looking to chase the highest Pace you know they live they live here they work here or they
196want a place where you know the progress is going to get them where they want to be um on top of us Jing off them all around it it works both ways so if you increase the base scale the phase four is going to cost more next year if you increase phase four now increasing the teacher the base scale is to cost more in future years as well the reason I brought it up is because we brought up fiveyear plan for our teacher scale it also included bringing up our base scale you know at least a few hundred we actually got off track of that from last year because we couldn't afford to come up a full $250 $500 so we're a little bit behind and so that $7 million isn't incre or you 7
197million to complete phase four isn't increasing That Base teacher scale because we dropped adjusting the base the lower end of the scale last year in order the phas correct it's almost like every subsequent phase like for the next 5year plan should be like correcting also increasing Yeah by not correcting the base and our starting salary we're going to fall further behind we're going to fall further behind and it's more likely that teachers are going to take the offer from the school with the highest starting salary new teachers and move right up and then we're going to be stuck with teachers who maybe didn't get an offer until well and we've already been told that the teachers that we have now are not all coming at zero years right they're coming with years which makes them
198more expensive for us but you know we get them if phase four is not you know but we'll get them with more experience but now they're going to cost us more but there's a cost to training a brand new teacher that someone else incurs and not correct only if we're competitive inale and by increasing I just want to repeat this but increasing the base also has a significant positive impact on 16 17 189 steps because right it's that trickle down it builds on on it so you that's why it costs $8 million for only a $500 incre the base it affects the whole scale but it doesn't adjust it to our phase four if we we just do the phase four we're really just doing that one targeted years between what is what are we
199up to 10 and 15 or 15 we're at 16 yeah in the superintendent's budget we went from 15 to 16 another thing we could do is kind of split the difference and let's say we want to get to phase four to 18 or 19 but let's increase the base of the scale not all the way up to 52,000 but let's get it to 515 what was the what was the 5year plan for the base of the scale I mean I think if we have a plan that we should stick with it unless there reasons deviate so what was the what what did the fiveyear plan say for the base scale were we supposed to be increasing that you know a certain percentage every year yes I mean so that how far off over on oh
200the check yeah I don't know no I'm just I'm I'm trying to look at this in perspective what what is your recommendation I so I mean I I mean what what you what you are you know working through right now a lot of the same things that I had to consider along with their requirements around standards quality and the Staffing trying to looking at what's uh what do we what do we really need to ask for and so that's how I built my budget um that I presented to you based On th those that thinking behind it that we wanted to support staff and do everything we can we also have requirements in terms of SQ positions that we have so that's where I landed um but also knowing you were going to have a
201crack at it too and to see what's going to you to a certain extent I kind of like the idea of increasing the pH because we're still increasing partial phase 4 year 16 which most of our teachers were are that were getting are in the 12E range anyway so the teachers were already getting were already covered by phase four through phase four but now we increase the base and we also give the crack at the starting teacher salaries so that would be 8.7 million so that would be instead of 7 million instead of 7 million so budget budget has us increase just toing 20% of phase four so one of the right so we would still get that to year 16 that's what I said plus we would increase the base which would benefit all
202of the scale Carter Chris does it does it if we if if they did the the base scale um I know with the the phase instructional scale the goal is to get 3% between each right so that's what the goal and that's what steps 15 through 20 for phase four would do if you did the the adjustment to the base does that make the the percentages between each step closer to the 3% it doesn't even touch the it just keeps them at the same differentials we have built in right it doesn't make percentage is it now um so from zero to 16 in this scale it's 3% and then it drops to roughly 1.5% we need to and so the phases were to get that 1.5 up to 3% so there was like a true
2033% differential between each step so that would be if we if we did the step two and phase four through year 16 it's it's 28 million 27.9 million's can I ask a question it's 14.25 and I just want to ask a question and I don't need this answer tonight but when we did our 5-year plan we started a certain presumption and and now the you know we've been mandated by the state to you know add all these positions um and and there's a cost to that so in I'd like to know what is the cost of the mandated positions you know like the additional um esol teachers the um you know all all the ones that we're saying it's not because Fro I'm assuming we should have included growth positions in our calculations when we're
204coming up with a fiveyear plan but these these requirements from the from you know this this legislature were not anticipated so I think that to me you know is is is a difference so if I go in and ask for more money it's not because I've changed my mind or I want to do more it's because we've had additional demands placed on us those but those those soq positions that the state has added that part of the money they're giving us is for their share of those S okay well well then we can you know I'd like to look at it does it balance does that 7 to8 million or 8 million now is that equal to or greater than you know what what we're required to do because I I to me that's that's
205important that I'm not just arbitrary with your yeah just just wanting more right um and so really your question is what is the local cost of those position is that what you're asking or what's the no I'm I'm asking what is the what is what is the cost well what is the cost to us as a school system would be local local and and that would be you know after you they do their their allocations um looking at the growth in s soq i mean surely that the e Esau is is you know that just jumps out at me with 36 additional teachers that's quite a lot of money um that we hadn't counted on but we also have 31 um par professionals level two is that a um was that a legislative change or
206how did that we get to that amount being required looking at Patrick I mean 31 for growth I mean how many that's related to the growth Trend that we have seen among our students identified for level two services for special education based on our locally adopted Staffing standards so are they they're um are they S soq no those locally adoped so that that's our that's our stand our choice right maybe and what in reality it may not be but it's not mandated and what that does is we're not proposing to reduce class sizes reduce Cas based on the growth that's coming into to keep that same level of class size case load same quality that we have now given our growth yeah I'd like to get some more information on that what is the proposed
207growth because 31 is a that's a lot of new positions to to add and I'm not saying we don't need them because I don't have the information but again it's it's a substantial um cost and another one I I I know Dr Chase's question always was when we have when we had a grant what are we going to do when it's over I mean we've got a half was it a half million dollars for for Grant positions that were just rolling over to um operating I see that somewhere where is it I thought it was somewhere in here it's at the beginning the beginning SL two or three adust I thought it was a half million here it is 53 553,000 but grow Grant positions moving to operating so that's a choice not saying we
208I mean when we when we funded these Dr Chase always ask that question what are we going to do when the money's gone I don't know remember what the answer was what was it Dr Chase you borrow from Peter to pay paal yeah well I so wait I'm sorry I'm just maybe slow the grant positions so we're not going to have these humans no we are we are we're pay million we're paying for them out of our local funding all right versus you know the grants but it's it's it's something to keep in mind when when we're doing I mean this half a million here half a million there you know they they're they're adding up there are like Grant positions that W didn't will to operate in in the grant like that there didn't
209get added I guess I'm just trying to understand what your point is because if if I I get what you're saying right you shouldn't you have to do something with it but then do you not take the Grant and you don't create position or so the question is this like you can somebody can say to you hey you know um I'm G to give you uh I'm going to give you a gift gift certificate so that you can go get your hair done okay that's good right here you go right and then next year I'm not around anymore and so you say oh we just need to take we just need to find that for my budget but I didn't used to have it so it was a gift it was a gift one time
210do I keep the gift going and and no no I get that I'm just saying when you look at needing these humans and you get a grant for it you know I mean how in the past because of growth we've been able to like have positions that were previously locally funded are now Grant funded and that allows us to use the money for other priorities and then we make them up like I I love to use the example of the gifted resource teacher that the prior board approved um we used to not have one every at every school building um the state was going to fund us like all but two and two became locally funded and then a couple years later growth was so much that those two are no longer locally funded they
211are state funded because of our capacity so I feel like for some of this it's we're going to use the Grant and then by the time the grant expires our growth is caught I mean hypothetically if it's a grant position it should be discretionary because we we didn't have it unless we took a standard position and covered that with the grant but I'm I'm not I'm not suggesting we not do it but I think we need to be looking this because you know it's it's it's it's a lot of money here that you and I'd be curious if it's somebody who used to be locally funded that is now going to be funded by a grant and therefore it's potentially freeing up funds that we could yes use for something else and then in three
212years when the grant is over that person is reverts back to being locally funded almost treat using their displaced salary expense as almost like onetime funds right like oh well 50 we have $50,000 now this year because half of this position is Grant funded what temporary things can we invest that $50,000 in rather than other Sal well I was going to say you're exactly right in this thing but now there are a number of Grants like for example uh Federal Title One funds you can't do that there's a supplement uh not a plant provision that makes it so that you can't use the funs in that manner um but there are other instances where the accessibility of grant money does enable you to move positions that may have been locally funded into the grant for
213dedicated funds to free up your ability to be able to operate um you know and there are certainly cases where some of these positions uh over time may have started as locally funded moved to grant for fiscal flexibility and now we're having to plan ahead so um that's regular budget management to see those pieces move it' be helpful to know you know when we're looking at this how many current Grant funded positions we have and how many of those um were moved over from operating because maybe it'll maybe it'll balce out I I don't know 124 out of like 5,000 employees are Grant funded is that what I just heard but how many of those were were locally funded before we moved to Mo I think that's what you're saying yeah it won't be clean
214because there's a great deal of positions particularly in early childhood centers that are partially funded by grants and the and say and the percentage may change I'm not trying to over complicate this but they may move from 63% Grant to 69% Grant in the middle of the year so not to over complicate that is and we have special education with title 6B roughly 60 FTE but you can only partially fund them so each of them are half an FTE operating half grant for everybody at home who wants to know how we get these half positions this is how we get your fraction and I will share that we you know I looked at each of these positions and we as Carter mentioned we have several grant funding positions that are not going moving in you
215know I've met with Patrick and looked at each one of these to say all right what are these essential do we really need them what would what would stop that to take place if we didn't um continue with these positions and some of these I mean when we look at our uh some of one of our uh HR position around supporting new teachers our Mentor 360 program I heing time with time again how great that is and help how that helps our new teachers coming in one of these positions supports that supports our new teachers when they come in providing some that support so there's so many things that that I didn't feel like we could live without without putting these in so that's why I recommended these to go in and not some of
216the others I'm I'm say happy to talk make an decision if I have answers the benefits at 28% is that lower than we used to calculate I thought we calculated that higher in years past it always fluctuates a little bit depending on what our vs rate percentage is is but the last few years it's been right at 28% that doesn't include like the health or benefits part so like the we add that on afterwards that's like another eight to n Grand just in he benefits for each employee so so that's not in here no it's in the in our health line of 4 million it's actually baked into that line it's not into this individual line here so I don't know if I can so the 20% doesn't include the health benefits yeah okay that's
217what I'm requ we do a flat dollar amount on top of for health and is it for every employee that participates in the health or is it for every employee we take an average so we apply it to every FTE we add is about 8500 is um but some cost more than that some cost less but what we see on average of our FTE that's what it costs so whether they take it or not that's an average amount so the ones that are taking it are subsidizing the ones that aren't I mean in terms of our local dollars are not the not our current employees no they're not a benefit I mean the health insurance is a benefit MH yeah these are when we show the 28% that's a benefit that's based on a percentage
218of their salary where it's like the retirement and the retirement so what happens if we suddenly give an influx of people add it to our health insurance policy because there's a change in the federal Workforce well we're already seeing significant increases in our health insurance cost if we could see additional if we see add-ons to our employees like um dependents that are added on right change in circumstances allows people to change their health insurance no I know I'm just saying that I think we may seeing um I I had asked so the the slight difference but the the health insurance increases aren't keeping the percentages quite the same as what they were last year so I mean so we didn't want to do a flat percentage um for them because some of them cost more
219than others so our when we looked at where we compared to some other localities and the local government our employee only plan was our cheapest and just doing 5% of that was not a dollar a significant dollar it's like a 7% chance so we did a 7 and a half% and then for our higher amounts we did the 5% so like our family plan you'll see a 5% increase but it was 7 and a half% on our lower um and so are we uh self-insuring for dental also or is that different no so Dental is pretty much 100% funded by the employee we don't really subsidize that at all okay now that just that can go we're talking like tens of maybe 100,000 tops and it can fluctuate but it's designed to be no subsid
220just going from 30 to 31 like a with inflation that just seems really low to me that we can do that by only increasing that $1 from this year to last year and then just doesn't increase and doesn't go up quite as much so it's just not a significant increase the health is what we see the biggest what percentage of our students take students of our employees take the health uh roughly um I think it's about 55 50 do you know off hand I I looked at it before I can we can double check that I know I Hadrian P for me recently we we do pay so much I and I'll call it a subsidy that the other half of the people who don't take it get nothing at all and one of the
221what we see on the county side actually is for their employee that don't participate they actually get a monthly stifen for not participating in he we can't afford them let um I I do want to point out because I know this was a question that came up from board members because we had a pretty big increase in our soq requirements for our elll teachers so wanted to show you what at each level that soq was in FY 26 um also showing you what our projected students were in the current year what our actual students were this year so you can see that we saw an increase just over what we projected in fy2 and then we're factoring in a larger increase or another increase for FY 26 so the FY 26 projected column is what
222we're calculating the FTE required for so for level one we have to have one teacher for every 20 Level One El students well so what was it for FY 24 I mean I'm just saying you're you're basing it on like it could be that that it will actually be a smaller increase next year than it was the previous year right does that make sense like two data points is not like no it was a multi-year data point um Mr Bernett actually worked on that and some pretty level I can let him explain kind of how he projected that okay um but we were well short in the current year uh projection so we were kind of making up for that a little bit and projecting another increase but it was a multi-year was it over
223three I looked at a couple of different models the threee would have actually been a higher increase uh than a one-year uh year-over-year uh increase um it was tailored a little bit by grade level uh as well Ransom sensitivity testing to see which one would have been a more accurate performer for this year and actually a one-year rate uh was the most accurate of the different uh percentages I used but this is an area where there's just a lot of it's very noisy data because the population is inherently very uh is going to shift a lot right okay it's interesting that level two and level four are fair close in the projections to the actual level one of course we don't know exactly who's going to be coming in so I understand why there' be
224a big difference I'm curious about level three um again we don't know who they are either because some of them come in as a level three that's right right well but it be it'd be good to see how our students are progressing you know of the students that are here from 25 to 26 how many moved from one level to another and how many of that total number in the level just came into the school system that's if if we can get that I mean it would it would paint a more full picture for me of you know are our students moving from one level to another that have been with us or you know are they staying and then getting more in you know and getting it more crowded right on that level yeah
225that's information we should that's that's data that we're required to report um for L progression um over time so that's that's M sorry and what percentage of the the new students we're getting are these different levels of the E you know if we get a thousand new students how many are e and how are they broken down by level will we have that we do have those numbers I don't have them in front of yeah and I don't want to now but I'm I'm just yeah we can pull I I think it's significant to to think about future Trends right you know are we some I mean some students might not get out of a certain level they T they tend move faster at levels one and two towards three it's it's harder for them
226to get to four it takes a bit more time but we're doing and the age level at which they enter is has a significant factor as well younger students Advance much faster so because this was a big jump and so many Dynamic to it as far as the state changes and our our projections and and growth wanted to lay it out level by level for you so you can see EX exactly where the FTE requirements are so that far right qu isn't the additional that's the actual FTE were required just to meet the soq and then at the bottom you'll see our current FTS are at 113.5 and so we get to that 36.5 um because we need 150 technically we need 149 but we have one like an itinerant position that serves um kind
227of our special sites like Phoenix and some of the day schools or and private days so how many do we need for this year that we don't have 36 oh for oh sorry in the current year R so of that 36.5 how many of those are are actual growth versus we are under staff right now um yeah so so we have that um and Mr Bernett is gonna pull it up really quickly um for us um he doesn't like that really quickly I know yeah I just said pull it up was fine really quickly but this year was a little bit more complicated because of the state soq changes and we expect there may be additional changes in the state soqs we think it could go well so all the budget language and everything matches
228exactly how we've projected it here what we heard is oh well how you how we actually allocate for the other category which is think of it as a like a monitoring so they kind of pressed out of your level four they're beyond that 4.2 4.3 rating on the weeda test that um they become a status where we still have to monitor them and check in with them very routinely it's just not at the same level as as one through four and um what we heard from the state is maybe that soq ratio is we don't have to treat all of those kids as other we actually don't have to have any teachers for them now I think what what Patrick said in that Friday memo is we still need to monitor those students um and
229so we don't want to go to zero for that line but we need so we need to look at those and play with that but technically the budget language does not say that um so we're trying to get clarification we have not seen any written guidance specifying that that other category soq is going away yeah what has been actually released in official guidance does not align with by Z right by one person join the normally we would just go with what's on the budget to out of transparency we're over complicating it by telling you but just wanted to wanted to be upfront that that we could see a change there based on what we're hearing but right now we can't assume that's happen right right because we know this is a big number and so
230we want anything that we get that suggest hey maybe that number is too big we want to be transparent about it but I right to answer the question of how many uh we will need to have um I'm I'm going to give a lawyer's answer please forgive me it depends um if you go uh it depends on which calculation method the state uses um and the answer would be either 119.5 in which case we would be off by six or 130 now I want to emphasize we are in compliance with the SQ this year because they gave a one-year grace period for school divisions so long as you added enough positions to where you were the year before to make up half of the gap which we did in space we 8% of the position
231we were supposed to so we are in compliance this year but we have to make up that for next year so it's between and 13 correct but we're in compliance because we don't have to meet because for this year only you didn't have to hit that number you needed to make up half the gap between what your fy4 number was under Patrick Patrick give me those numbers again 19 and 130 119 for 130 it's amazing I'm stillw we're at 13 and a and we're at 13 and we're at 1133 so we're missing six because we just weren't able to fill it is that what I'm understanding right because our not because we couldn't fill it um all but one of our sessions are F six or 17 we budgeted based on projections that ended up
232being short of what our actual Esau population was all right okay so we're running under to go back to how much we want to ask for we could just increase our Base by $1,000 which would take $2.9 million out of that 8.7 that would put us at 32 million what does that make the base again 51 it would make it 51 51 515 515 so be close 51 they're at 518 but their health insurance CL 51898 is there this year I don't know scale we don't know when they are going to go up to well they haven't posted their this year's they have not posted scales posted like they posted propos like what their compensation proposal changes are but it wasn't a base scale and in their budget documents I couldn't find a starting teacher
233salary but we're starting to fall behind in the base scale that's what we made yeah yes we already are behind the Masters how do we compare with the master supplement I would say it's pretty even across most I'm just curious because when I looked at those supplement quite you know you could you could really increase your salary quite nicely by you know having supplement educational do do we do we have to increase those supplements by the same percentage as everything else so I supplements we we do 3% because if we don't then their overall pay from year to year doesn't go up that 3% so we have to increase the Ed supplements by whatever we want that minimum pay increase me you do but you don't have to correct you do not thought they were
234the numbers I read they were they were increased % from F and the F you have to if you want to have that minimum 3% like that average teachers already get them if we give them 3% but then we take away the ad supplement are we what are we taking it away you just aren't adding adding supp but it impacts that year-over-year increase so instead of 3% it might be 2.8 or 2.9 and is that a that would be a problem because of the state or is that just no that's just our personal if we're saying we're if we want that average to be three we want that minimum to be three unless you're at the top of the scale but the 3% it's like roughly $100,000 per 1% of the Ed supplements that you
235do it's not a significant number it's not a huge we don't have that many people with Ed supplements we do it's just yeah because you're the Ed supplements couple thousand bucks 4,000 5,000 depending on the level plus I didn't know we gave them for plus 15 so if you have a master's plus 15 or if you have a bachelor's plus 15 you get a supplement then you get a master there was a masters plus 15 you know and then right just so you know when you're looking at that supplement list you don't get the Masters plus 15 on top of the Masters you just get the master I know but but you get more it is a no I'm just trying to find money but what you're saying is that's just budget dust I got
236you it's budget dust I like that only we could get a little more budget dust floting our way side down the revenue side yeah so kind 100,000 after out of 400 20 million is pretty small if you want we can try to in this uh we can try to email you or in the memo bulletin send you some scenarios of what teacher scales would actually look like oh boy we love scenarios I I would like to look at the scales because I'm just worried that we're we're increas we're doing the phase adjustments but by not increasing the base we're still folling behind because now we aren't hiring those firste teachers out of school because they're going to play places where the the base salary is much higher but maybe we're getting somebody up upam cuz
237that number Patrick right has gotten better as our average age it's excuse me it has gotten better I would say that where it has gotten better has been from uh recruitment Fields where our salary is more competitive across the entire scale not necessarily to the counties where scale is not competitive um it doesn't work with Prince William are loud and correct say all otheres there are people we we don't don't maybe not yeah but I'm just I'm just concerned that as our scale starts to fall we become less competitive all the way around even by increasing phases the problem is then we're not following through with our commitments with the plan and we made a commitment well the commitment the plan was for both things to have that well well but but thetically it they
238should be following in line the plan says for 15 is it 16 to 20 or whatever 15 15 to 20 we're choosing to invest in people who are not if we say we're going to we're going to not do the phase because we want to increase the base I've seen this happen before you might get some first year teachers but then your scale gets all un uneven and it it it's just what they're talking about is right what they're talking about is adding it they'll keep the they'll keep the 3% between it's just but it doesn't it's not doing stuff for people 16 17 18 years well that's what I I don't get just and I know it's getting late but the 3% raising the whole line up and not we're going add the same
239but we're not going to add the same amount to each line it'll be a 3% differental so what would happen is one through 14 who've already been hypthetically through this adjustment they would be getting the benefit while the 15 and up would be behind so I'm I I understand what you're saying but I I've just you know I and I've I've seen I've seen given bigger pay raises and increasing class sizes that doesn't work I would not recommend that but I've seen that as a way I'm just say the problem is we need to do both things and and we can't do both things so we have to come up with an or so we have to yeah so it's it's like what what what are we going to ask for that tries to meet
240all of our needs what's our number and I'd like to look at the scales see what the adjustment to base looks like the adjustment to base by adding phase four and then you know where how we fall compared to how much both would cost it's right there you you it's 15.7 milon plus the seven yeah it's it's it's double what it would cost well you could reduce that though you could instead of increasing the base to 52,000 you could just go up a th000 and then it's only 5.8 million this is just it's only 5.8 million that's my couch cushions right honestly yes it is I've seen how You' be trying to live you might have maybe to you Dr Warner so Dr Warner and I think for if there's consensus around which scales you
241we're happy to put together if you want one for adjusting the base up to up to put another th on the base so you want go which would be 5.8 million um increase and then add the phase four to full phase so one adjusting so adjusting the base by $1,000 and then completing pH for is that one scale we can do that if your goal is to be competitive with with spoty you're still4 we still not but we're not falling as far well you're still 400 behind we'll have to win over the rest with charm but it'll beap we offer other things our our mentorship is better there are things that we do that are better for pay for school yeah so there are other things that we do until where that that $500 that
242$400 may not make a difference excuse me does spoty pay them twice a month or once twice twice o they got this on that too okay well yeah but $600 you pull that out of your couch cushion I know they were pursuing mon two years ago but I'm not sure if it made it into the budget so I don't know if they have 600,000 did we say something like that five to 600 it's in the budget is 600 but I'm I'm actually meeting with our payroll staff this week to try to so good at you right know it's 600 yeah that's what we have I remember that's what we well all right we have work okay so I've got one scale you want us to provide you around the adjustment to the base by $1,000
243and phase four so we'll that teacher teacher scale for that yeah it's just in the bottom line numbers what are we looking at and could we increase their cost of health insurance by a little bit more so that we're maybe not picking up as much of that cost again I think we're taking from people who are here to recruit people who aren't and I'm not I'm not super thrilled with that approach I don't know what the right answer is but I I mean I kind of agree we want people to stay you know what I mean I inflation has been quite High I I you're right I just and that inflationary cost for I mean our prices have gone up because we're having to pay doctors and nurses and health insurance adjusters more money and
244so it it's just that the base would would have already been part of the adjustment like we would have increased the base a certain percentage every Year and have the face I think and we're not doing both of those things I think this is a Missy question it might be a Dr Smith question do you know where we are with scheduling uh three on three or um seven on seven well there is a seven on seven already scheduled we don't have the time we do have the date be in is the last year so it's in here already for all the support proposal and my finding request pH pH which goes for step to 10 that's fine I was add they let you know what they are ask them to do it monthly or every
245other month see if we can increase the number of times that we meet with we are trying to also work because if we just go in asking quarterly then they're they're going to not even give us quarterly month tell we want to meet with them once a month that would be something the committee would have to ask I think you going to piss them off by asking I can hear it now who are they they are telling us let's try quarterly and maybe getting more than an hour of meeting time good when set up it was well why don't you suggest or someone whoever suggest three days in times instead of instead of waiting on it this time I'm on it is ala are you here are you awakea left the building here good night
246ala I hope you feel better going officially the back of my throat is starting to get scratched uhoh no did you just throw her was over me I was throwing it over her at Maya