001I'd like to call to order the January 13th 20125 annual organizational meeting special meeting of the York County School Board good evening everyone and welcome to the first meeting of the New Year I hope everyone had an opportunity to connect with family and friends over the break a new year is a time to set fresh goals reflect on our priorities and gain A Renewed perspective going forward into 2025 as a board we remain committed to providing excellent learning opportunities for our students as a reminder I will read our ycsd mission statement the mission of the York County School Division is to ensure every student is valued supported and challenged through learning experiences which prepare them for a successful future as we go into our organizational business and our annual elections I will now turn to
002Dr shander to lead us in the election award chair thank you Miss good Madam chair I have a point of information I have a letter from uh the Attorney General's office uh one of the attorneys and if you can take one of these the board members Dr shandor and um attorney Melanie Barry um that's one to each one of these um local attorney and also our um one of our delegates Chad green had sent a letter to uh the Attorney General's asking for a response about this and uh this is the response from uh Manda Maguire uh opinions councel out of the Attorney General's office on his letterhead I'm responding to your request for an opinion the Supreme Court of Virginia recognizes that construction of the Constitution and statutes of the Commonwealth by the Attorney
003General under section 2.250 of the code of Virginia is of the most persuade of character and is entitled to Due consideration the same status and weight however are not afforded inal opinions and advice rendering but rendered by any other attorneys in the office the views Express herein do not constitute an opinion of the Attorney General under prision provisions of section 22-55 rather this response to your inquiry represents only the individual views of one of the councils to the attorney general the issue presented you ask whether a school board upon majority of vote uh majority vote excuse me may remove a Schoolboard chairman or vice chairman from their respective chair positions prior to the expiration of the one-year term set forth in code section 22.1 76 applicable Law And discussion the constitution of Virginia provides the
004uh quote the supervision of schools in each School Division shall be vested in a school board to be composed of members selected in the manner for the term possessing the qualifications into the number provided by law school boards are public quasi corporations that exercise limited powers and functions of a public nature granted to them expressly or by NE necessary implication a school board May exercise only the power granted it by the general assembly school boards are thus subject to a coral of the Dylan rule whereby they quote have only those powers that are expressly granted those necessarily or fairly implied from expressly granted powers and those that are essential and indispensable unquote as enacted by the general assembly Provisions contained in chapter five of title 22.1 of the code of Virginia establish the manner of
005selection qualifications and salaries of Schoolboard members and Provisions in chapter 7 set forth school board's General powers and duties the statute about which you inquire code section 22.17 addresses board Leadership School boards hold annual organizational meetings either in January or July of each year code section 22.17 six directs that at such meeting quote each School Board shall elect one of its members as chairman and on recommendation of the division superintendent shall appoint a clerk of the school board unquote in addition quote the school board may also elect one of its members as Vice chairman and may appoint a deputy clerk who shall be empowered to act in all matters in case of the absence or inability to act of the chairman or clerk respectively unquote section 22.1-cu that quote the term of the chairman Clerk
006and any Vice chairman and Deputy clerk shall be one year unquote when a statute is expressed in plain and unambiguous terms whether general or limited it is a assume that the general assembly means what it plainly has expressed and no room is left for construction the plain language of section 22.1 76 makes clear that once a year every year each School Board in Virginia must elect one of its members as chairman and appoint a clerk of the school board and also May select a vice chairman and Deputy clerk indeed the word shell in a statute typically is construed as mandatory absent any manifestation of contrary intent by the legislature the use of the word shall in establishing the terms of office under Section 22-7 six demonstrates that the general assembly intended that the provision designating
007a one-year term be mandatory rather than permissive or directive I find no indication of contrary intent neither this statute nor any other confers any Authority upon any school board to modify that term or to make interim Replacements swas fonte section 22.1 76 thus expressly fixes the term of the chairman Clerk and any Vice chairman and Deputy clerk firmly at one year with Replacements to be chosen at the next annual meeting I therefore conclude that a school board does not have the power to remove its chairman from that position prior to the expiration of the one-year term established under Section 22.17 6 conclusion accordingly it is my view that a school board does not have the authority to remove its chairman or vice chairman from that position prior to the expiration of the one-year term required
008by the relevant statute with kind regards I am very truly yours Amanda uh Maguire opinions counsel and your point is Miss Fairman with this long that you illegally removed me in May from being the chair and the board also illegally remove removed you from being Vice chair is against code under this lady's opinion not the attorney general just one person it's from it's from the office it's not from the attorney general it's not not directly yet we have two issues here first of all this letter was written supposedly on December 13th and today I did not receive it until a days it was a few days ago it was before the weekend right and you know what the process is for getting items on the agenda if you wanted something on the agenda to discuss
009you were to give that to me so that I could get it on the agenda to discuss you did not I believe this needed to be in front of the board as a whole for transparency to the public part of the reason while the whole change and process took place was because you do your own thing when you want to do your own thing rules apply to us and we're supposed to follow rules but when it's about you they don't okay now this we're we're leading away from what's going on here this is actually with all due respect the law with all due respect and in the interest of these other people here who have things to do we're moving on we can revisit this at a later date but we're going to move on
010with the meeting continue as such you've you've given your statement you've read the letter and we can confer with our attorney to uh go further but we're going to move on here if you have you know since according to this and according to the statute that your term was illegal there isn't uh possible problem that anything that you have signed is invalid well okay we'll we'll take that we'll leave that to the legal professionals to handle okay we got to move on Dr shander yes good evening board members I now I'm going to open the floor to nominations for the board chairman yes Mr schaer I'd like to nominate uh Mrs Goodman District 3 to a full term as chairman I'd second that are there any more nominations okay hearing none I will um turn
011it over to Miss Howard so miss Goodwin has been nominated as chair and by Mr schaer and a second was made by Mr Richardson Miss Howard if you'll pull the board please motion was made by Mr schaer and seconded by Mr Richardson to nominate Mrs Kimberly Goodwin as chair board chair Mr schaer yes Mrs Fairman no m Mr Richardson yes Mr kich yes Mrs Goodwin yes the motion is passed for to one Mrs Goodwin has been elected board chair congratulations good well first I want to say thank you thank you for having trust and confidence me and confidence in me to leave the board um it means a lot and I'm happy to do it uh for another term and with that said um just a reminder that um as far as getting items on
012the agenda you know we have the rules and protocols that we established when we went to retreat um so we're just going to go forward using those same things until such time as we convene to change them okay all right okay uh see I open the floor to nominations now for board Vice chair Mr sh I'd like to nominate Mr Richardson okay like to see him complete a full term as Vice chair as well right I'll second that nomination any do we have any other nominations for vice chair I'd like to nominate Mr pich for Vice sure okay can I have a second so I need to say that sorry okay all right so Nicole can you take a poll yes a motion was made by Mr Schaefer and seconded by Mrs Goodwin to nominate
013Mr Richardson as board Vice chair Mr Richardson yes Mr pich yes Mrs Fairman no Mr schaer yes Mrs Goodwin yes motion passed 4 to one Mr Richardson is our is our board Vice chair [Applause] congratulations all right um our next res resolution or I'm sorry our next organizational item is resolution 251 approving the school board organizational business for calendar year 20125 um so I know board members you've had the opportunity to review these documents ahead of time but are there any questions or comments related to the resolution or any of the attachments can I have one please uh over on the last page three um section number Roman Roman numeral five uh it looks like this was copied and pasted from the issue from last January that was discussed and we had to change where
014it says um at the Bottom's see going about after the $100,000 for a single transaction provided set procurement has been funded in either the operating budget or the Capital Improvements budget for fiscal year 25 and to execute change orders to contracts which shall not exceed the greater of $50,000 or 25% of the contract price we voted last year to change that because 25% of a contract price if you've got a $4 million contract 25% is $1 million um that would give the division superintendent according to section five The Authority without going to the board to spend that money and that was that was a discussion last year I think it's an issue again I know Mr pich spotted it halfway way through the year on one of the uh the other budget issues but I
015think it's um a problem where it was cut and pasted without the correction that was made last year it it should be I don't believe it was cut and pasted first of all it was actually because the $100,000 number changed as well so it's actually five is actually new so it wasn't cut and pasted no that it's the last statement there that which shall not exceed the greater of $50,000 or 25% of the contract price come from County policy purchasing the 100,000 has come from County Purchasing County Purchasing right so that's why I was referring to that number five is actually a new section Miss Barry or Mr bone would you like to comment related to the 50,000 or 25% of the contract price refresh my memory on that actually in Friday notes there was
016an email from me that explains all this uh if yall had a chance to read that County ordinance changed and so these numbers have been updated and Additionally the County Purchasing policy is now an ordinance so it's now county law that that was dealing though with the hundred thousand do and I don't have a problem with that knowing that it's the new um the new the new ordinance from the whole policy is lawed out but the problem is the fact that the wording it says which shall not exceed the greater of $50,000 or 25% of the contract price again if we have a contract of $4 million that gives the authority to the superintendent to make a purchase of $1 million without coming before the board and the school board's responsibility deals with the fiscal
017side of all of this that I believe anything over and above the 50,000 or you know like I said the the 100,000 since that's stated in here that still needs to come before the board as I stated this is now the County ordinance is not just a policy and this is the County Administrator has the ability to approve change orders up to a million dollars if that's what's 25% just like the superintendent however as Mr Bowen can explain those uh CIP items do come to the board it's just that this is County ordinance this is now an ordinance and they are a Fiscal Agent and we're obligated to abide by County ordinances and if we want to have our own fiscal agency we can certainly pull out of that and they can change the ordinances
018to pull us out but as we are under the the purchasing department as far as our fiscal accountability goes we need to comply with what the county has put into order right and I understand that and I read your reasoning you know with the ordinance that it was increased because of inflation and things to the 100,000 it's just this particular line that particular line is in the ordinance that is what the ordinance says it's the greater of so to change that we we'd have we would be out we'd have to go back to the Board of Supervisors and say we would it change so if I can if I can say something um the the county ordinances as Miss Barry stated we uh we fall under the County's policy and ordinance under the purchasing what
019the county did share with us is that they would prefer not having two sets of rules um and the and the reason being is that now they have to not only follow their rules but they would have to follow any other rules that we would deviate from their their policy and so it creates a little hardship on their side um if the concern is about transparency or or oversight from the um when Mr shart has a request for to increase a contract um we typically bring 100% of those changes regardless of the dollar amount that's here because because of the expenses are so high um when we we talk about uh CIP we want the board to see those expenses however if we missed one um not on purpose but if we just happen to
020miss one and because of the timing we talked about this last year where we see this problem is during the summer when the board doesn't meet and when the majority of our CIP occurs so if we have something that needs to be done during that time period then we won't have to call a special meeting of the board to have that contract approved or that change order approved it doesn't mean that we can't bring that back to the board and share that with them at at a later date but the the way that that language would read that we would have to call I mean have to call a special meeting of the board if we reach that the lesser of not the greater of so um but just to kind of add on to
021that um we we have a a review process in place that when Mr shearhart um submits a change order to a contract in the finance system it goes through the review of his supervisor which is Dr Carol which then all of those changes come to me as a review Once I approve those reviews they go to the county and County Purchasing reviews them so there is oversight if you would say not only from internal uh management but also from from the county side to review those contract change orders and also you know when you're dealing with this with this this this is a team and it's a trust issue too it's an issue of you got to trust the person that you put in place to lead just like that person trusts you to do
022your job and to do your job and to do your job until such time as you somehow show that you can't do that and then that becomes an issue I have not seen where it has been an issue up to this point I mean even though it is a policy and it's an ordinance that we need to follow I think the bigger uh issue here is it's a trust I'm trusting that we put a superintendent in place who can lead effectively and I trust him to make the right decision and if that backfires well then we come back and say okay I can remember times in the past on being on the board where Dr shandor would pop an email send us or make a phone call and say hey we've got this and it's
023going to cost us a little bit more money but you know we don't have much of an option here and he would brief us on those those things I mean I haven't so I feel like we're arguing over something that's I think we ought to do like Miss Barry said and just follow the County ordinance yeah I mean I don't see any reason why we need to not follow the ordinance it's like I said I'm just backing it up with the fact that I have not seen any gross negligence here in the use of funds in any way I I just know things you know you have to have a parameter of some kind on this and if Mrs Barry is saying that this particular phrase is specifically in that ordinance I met we met
024last week and we discussed it and she made me aware that that had changed I mean as soon as they got word I was no I knew the 100,000 had changed the whole the whole ordinance had changed was we like we get a financial report every time like know I think we discuss it for all the purchases over what is it $5,000 $10,000 $10,000 that we get reports all those yes so that's reported every every major expenditure and that's our level for reporting that to the board it's attached to board docks so you can see those expenditures um and and some good detail except unless it's coming from a PE card um you it's a limited data that's provided on the PE card we know that um but um items that run through our finance
025system you can see those details and then these are more contract latest so I can watch M Mr Bowman's words like you know that I've been reviewing every single financial statement comes in from the last year that we started and uh all of our uh expenditures they do make on report okay regarding since you brought that up with with the PE cards is there a way to monitor that a little bit closer so um how the PE cards work p cards are purchasing purchasing cards just so each PE card user has a supervisor that is responsible for their approvals and that that Supervisor was responsible for reviewing the detail at the end of the month a summary report comes to me and I and I review that summary report and I look at anything that
026looks out of the ordinary ordinary um or then I will question and I will ask staff to provide me with as much detail that we have um as part of that record and that's on top of limits on the card that's on top of limits there's a there's a $2,500 limit on the card itself so the single uh purchasing transaction is 2500 is there is there an example from last from the previous year I mean you've all been on the board for a year is there an example that we need to look closer to the PE cards that you can share with us no just and looking through the list and I know it was discussed at one of the the school board meetings the question was asked if there seemed to be an awful
027lot of these for a high amount and adding up you know that's it just didn't give specific like Amazon you know those bud I believe it was Mr pich Amazon was pretty standard use for the supplies and uh once when you go through the notes you can get some some kind yeah you get an idea of what it is for the or supplies or whatever I mean they amount to a lot of it but it's single but it's all it somewhat item totally yeah yeah some of the description material itself on the P card is limited it's limited based the number of characters and so we try to um enter that the details as much as we can into our financial system which is also limited by a number of characters for description Mr Bondo
028if the board member had a specific concern about a particular line item they could always reach out they can always reach out to me pull that documentation correct all right with that said the next document is the organizational calendar I'm sure that you've all had a chance to look at that you can see when the the meetings are yeah I'm sorry still in packet um the organizational meeting obviously is today you can see the schedule of work sessions through the spring as well as the regular meeting dates [Applause] what I would share um what we would like to try to accomplish potentially in June um at our June work session is to meet with the board and um potentially set a calendar for the next year for um um excuse me for work sessions and
029regular meetings right so um sometimes we're uh we're doing that early in the fall or late in the summer and if we can do that in June that'd be really helpful I think for for everybody involved yeah it shouldn't be hard to do yeah and then the next one was the school board policy manual you can see that we have um those items for when you see particular policies there's some um red red lining on there for dates from staff and who responsible for those and I believe the last section would be the committee assignments if there were any changes or thoughts on the committee [Applause] assments is everybody still good with their current committee I as [Applause] well all right so now I need a motion to approve resolution number 25-0 1 Madam chair
030I move to approve resolution 25-01 second all right we have a motion in a second Miss Howard motion was made by Mr Richardson and seconded by Mr Schaefer to approve resolution 2501 approving County School Board organizational business calendar for year 2025 Mrs fa did I second Mrs fman yes Mr schaer yes Mr it yes Mr Richardson yes Mrs Goodwin yes motion passes 5 to zero all right we will now discuss our capital projects um we have presentations Dr shander would you like to comment yes uh thank you board members we have seven uh presentations this evening and discussion topic um leading off Mr shearhart unfortunately can't be with us tonight he is ill so sitting in or pinch hitting for him is Dr Carol our um chief of operations and he will be presenting on
031the capital projects I'll turn over to Dr Carol thank you Dr shandor this is good one members of the board here is your projects report uh so we'll uh we did do some work over the winter break so that's what we want you to be aware of so uh brutin high school that we continued working on the roof repair and the cating the sighting has been completed around the instructional Wing now the siding for one end of the auditorium remains and the gutters and down spouts for me final coating which is the the last piece is uh dependent on weather and uh can only be above I think it's 60 degrees so this is probably going to push into a while be a while so it can push into the spring uh we the contractor
032had hoped to get it done in December but now that the winter weather's here it's going to delay us to the spring but I'd remind you that the due date wasn't until the end of summer so we're fully confident that that'll happen and so here are some pictures uh of the working on the siding um on the instructional Wing so this is over on the U you the left side of the school as you're facing it and then making their way around that corner and so that gray section to the right of the picture what was uh still needed to be done at that point and then here's your completed instruction link so nice facelift on that building okay then we'll look on to York High School and York Middle School we had finished the
033locker rooms but there was some team room work that still needed to be done and some gates that needed to be installed so it was functional but it wasn't finished and so we've done that with the boys and girls locker room and the team room lockers for Yorktown Middle School were being uh assembled today and if they weren't finished today they're going to come by tomorrow and finish it up so it should be in good shape there and there'll be not much difference in here's the boys room and there's the girls room could be the same picture I'm not sure it's not we we changed the angle a little bit uh so then uh we wanted to get you caught up on the Secondary School auditorium upgrades as we start to work on that no
034work's been done yet but we are still planning the stage curtains and the seating have been ordered that's the biggest thing that we needed to get the uh those items ordered because they had the longest lead time we're finalizing the lighting and sound system prices right now we're as we're waiting for uh last prices to come in and we are working on selecting carpet and paint colors right now so all the fun stuff that you get to do in your interior decorating and then the last item I think is the astur field installation at tab High uh We've removed the existing grass and we are ex Excavating the soil there uh we're installing AstroTurf uh infrastructure and the turf will be next and uh that work started in December atab and we plan to install
035the LED lighting next spring and so the picture is kind of tough because you're winter uh conditions here so uh look kind of looks like dormant grass but if you look over at the yellow uh excavator uh mid right to the picture you can see a ledge there and that's about 8 to 10 inches where they're taking the top sell off and that's the work that's being done right now and then U just a little bit of a preview on the tab High School editions of Renovations so right now uh geothermal well field design is done except for a factoring in the results of the test SPS the three test SPS have been done they'll be in different uh parts of the property now that those are done now they'll need to there's some testing
036that they do of the soil to see how the heat transfers within the soil and that dictates whether they they'll need to add Wells or take away Wells and we're hoping they'll have to take away well and uh so that should be done in the next week or two also the interior LED lighting uh replacement is uh being designed and we've also put out the RFP for the additions and Renovations for the A&E on that those came in last week and we are actually starting to uh vet those tomorrow so we will have uh be in position to uh award that well to bring the uh agencies in for a second interview and then to award the uh architectural work soon so we'll be able to get moving but the work that's going to happen
037this summer is the geothermal Wells and the LED lighting and those are already in motion and here's an exciting picture of drilling test boards for so the sky looks beautiful though oh yeah beautiful and that concludes my report and I'm happy to take any questions that you have any questions for Dr Carol thank you Dr Carol all right next we uh have a finance update who is our presenter yes that will be our Chief Financial Officer Mr Bowen he's going to share some information related to the governor's proposed budget for fy2 and FY 26 as well as um update on the superintendent's proposed Capital Improvement program forly 26 Mr bowan thank you Dr shandor chair members of the board Dr shandor um first let me begin with an apology uh this evening I have brought
038with you brought uh with me and presented to you the fy2 budget book um that came back from the printer in mid mid-september and um I was out of out of the office at that time um long-term medical and um when I returned I didn't realize that those hadn't been distributed to you so I apologize for that what I wanted to focus on tonight though is the uh first of all is the school board uh budget resource book and this is this uh binder here that I provided you you know last December December in 2023 um when the three new members were elected we provided you with a lot of information budget wise and it's it was a lot of information it's a lot to digest um and we had several Mr pich we met
039several times just to talk about the budget itself not to really dive into the data so we wanted to try and put something together that would be a quick resource for you um that would provide some historical information but also provide some data that tends to be significant budget drivers for school divisions and so what I want to do is just quickly run through the the book itself um if you look at tab one this is our revenue and expenses and I don't have that on the screen um but I did did post this budget book in booc so the community has access to this information as well this is just some historical information on our Revenue expenditures uh for state revenue State Federal local and also for all of our funds so we have
040workers compensation um capital projects fund health and dental and and such so you can see the history there with those funds in tab number two we have the uh jayar study uh we've talked a little bit about this this was released in July of 2023 this has a lot of good information and it talks about the deficiencies in state funding um if you saw that the the governor provideed his state of the Commonwealth address he referred to the fact that um the State funding formula needs to be corrected there is a legislative committee to uh to study this and to come back with recommendations and changes hopefully in the next budget cycle so we're hopeful that some things are going to change because of this report already been assigned or I believe it's already been
041assigned yes uh tab number three is our Pro people call we've seen this information in in a previous presentation but it's good information just to um refer to knowing that in our region U we are the lowest uh besides picosen and then on the state side you can see they're highlighted our regional comparators but also you know we often refer to ourselves as being third in the state our other two comparators that are number one and number two are Arlington and Fs church at the top left you can see that FSE church has $10,000 more dollars per pupil so uh we're talking millions of dollars of difference in funding um and we're doing a fantastic job here with the funding that we receive tab uh four is our local composite yes I have a question
042on online section three I'm looking for Mr pich has one that's it's like highlighted a listing is that I don't have that in tab three tab three looking right behind you maybe maybe it's tab toang let me [Applause] look now mine starts with page what page is that that should be page 22 page 22 yeah see tab three page 22 you can have but thank you I have I have extra I don't know why it's Miss I'm going to set mine here at the end just in case we can figure out why then thank you very much there it is uh Tab four is our local Composite Index uh this is the rate that's assigned to each uh locality and it determines the wealth of the community um you can see back in 2010 or
043back in 20124 our LCI shot up significantly and this was a result of the Great Recession and what happened is that the Great Recession was first felt in Northern Virginia so we saw a huge shift in the funding where um the state gave gave more money to Northern Virginia during the recession and then we ended up paying more for the cost of Education that has since flipped back and now we are at the lowest we've been since prior to 2010 m b can you explain just to the people out that they don't know is it better to have it lower or higher it's better to have it lower the the lower the the LCI then it means that the state pays for more of the cost of Education when we see that shift and and
044just a small shift a tenth of a percent can mean hundreds of thousands of dollars um in in additional cost to the school division thank you vrs rates this is tab uh five this is another significant budget driver and if you look at the top 2009 through 2017 um you see some uh percentages in red what happened there this is really a function of the Great Recession also the vrs board um certifies rates and the general assembly approves rates and so you can see the general assembly was approving rates much lower than the vrs Board of Trustees was recommending in order to maintain the value in that fund but this is how the state balanced its budget they were balancing on the backs of the the the teachers vrs and so uh we didn't have
045any choice in that that's that's just the way it happened but we've can you can see that we've been paying relatively higher rates um since 200 uh 20134 to make up for that shortfall from 2010 and 2012 so in um tab six we have enrollment we'll talk a little bit about enrollment tonight in the next presentation um this this particular snapshot here that we're looking at was done in November we have an update for this I wasn't able to get this in this book because we just got this printed and had it reviewed today so um we're going to talk a little bit more about that but the other thing we need to look at is also our sub subgroup enrollment because we've seen some changes in that and I'll talk a little bit more
046about that but you can see just for economic disadvantage since 2017 we've seen a 66 66% increase in our uh disadvantage population we've seen a 16.5% uh increase in our students with disabilities and then on the next page English learn we've seen a 55.9% increase in our English learner population and with our children's services act and we've talked a lot about this we've seen a 236 per increase since 2017 in our CSA program the next and uh tab number eight is our um New Horizon's annual report now this is really good data we make a significant investment to New Horizon it's about $4 million a year for our CTE program for governor school and for our students with disabilities um this provides a lot of information about our enrollment in each one of those programs
047and provides subgroup data as well the tab number nine is our standards of learning um just our results from FY 24 and then tab number 10 it's um our teacher salary comparison now this comes from last year's presentation in January Dr Wes is going to update this this evening and provide us with some new information and then last is the legislative priorities this is what the Virginia Association of school superintendents has adopted as their um legislative priorities and it's just good information to to refer back to okay so now for the 2526 budget Outlook so as you know the governor released his Budget on December 18th uh it was just last week that we received uh the calculation tool which is the Excel file that shows us all the details now there's two there's two
048documents that are released as part of the the governor's budget or any calculation tool there's the Excel file and there's an accompanying Word document that explains all the changes state has not release that accompanying Word document so I'm going to just provide you with some high level changes at the state level for k12 and then talk a little bit about some details for your county so I'll start off with this um the state's in the best financial position in my 36 years in in in state and local Finance there's set 4.7 billion available in this Bia meaning $4.7 billion available for 25 and for 26 um however what we've seen from the governor's proposed budget is only $286 million dedicated to K12 now that's a little frustrating however this is just step one um the
049governor releases the budget and then it goes to the general assembly the general assembly has convened and now they get they're kind of shot or crack at their budget amendments and then because there's so much money out there I I feel optimistic that there's a lot of room for compromise and so I think that these numbers could change for us at the end of the pro at the end of the state process so I'm not disillusion by what I see here yet um but I think will there'll be some additional funding when the state completes this process Mr B I have a quick question because I keep hearing about Virginia having a budget surplus yes so if we have a budget surplus you're saying that we there's not enough money that needs to come well
050it's it's all about priorities so um there's Transportation priorities uh there's tax credit car tax credit priorities a billion dollars is just set aside by the governor for tax credits uh I mean for the car tax credit there's um there's significant investments in water quality improvement in other other areas there's a number of state agencies that um have to be addressed there's so you're saying that we have this budget surplus but basically everybody has meat and yes that Surplus yes needs to be divided Ross a lot of people ask me about that well but we supposed to have all this money and the Surplus and where is it in the lottery and I've never seen this kind of surplus in in in a given year so this is this is significant I mean we had
051a a budget surplus a couple years ago at the end of the year was a $5 billion and so we did receive some of that money um we we received another $3 million um in September of 2024 as a result of that so there have been some windfalls for K12 throughout this process just that when we get to this year we don't see as much but I think there's going to be some change so Dr shandor and I attended a virtual conference last week and we had senior members from the house and the Senate and so they were T they were from the Democrat side so they were talking about the governor's priorities and while they saw a lot of good in there there were some differences of course there's going to be differences um
052there's uh I'll talk a little bit about this the lab schools that was one specifically that they didn't think that there was a lot of um momentum in general assembly to pass lab school so there's there might be some things in the governor's proposals that they may not find favor in and they may want to reallocate that money there's 230 I think it's $234 million that's dedicated for a voluntary um transfer to the uh Reserve fund now the reserve fund is at an all-time high so they don't have to make that deposit so the general assembly could redirect that to other programs and specifically K12 so just real quickly just looking at some of the highlights um updates to English language uh learner learner um those ratios have changed and we will have to make
053a change to our staffing as a result of that it's updating sales tax revenue so when sales tax revenue goes up basic Aid goes down but what we're seeing here is the net of that of that change Statewide there's an a update to average daily membership um the governor has mentioned that uh more people are moving into Virginia than leaving Virginia and so when they built the budget last year it was based on a certain number of students what they had projected well that numbers those numbers are wrong there more students are coming are in K12 schools in Virginia so there's additional money that's required for the state to fund and we're seeing that in our school um system as well I'm sorry I have a question do we know um from the the governor's
054overview of that do we know which there are certain sections of Virginia that they're coming to or they're not coming to or is this just in general that the state has that information because what they do is they look at um they look at Trends and history but they also look at the fall membership every School Division has to report what their enrollment is as of September 30 and so that data is is part of the calculation and updates to to the ADM are we in the area that the the whole area getting more students I haven't looked at the whole area I've only looked for York County and the numbers are quite surprising I'll talk to you in just a minute okay thank you there's um implementing a new state assessment contract um provide
055opportunity scholarships now the opportunity scholarships they aren't really for K12 but they're coming from the direct Aid funding these are um uh scholarships or vouchers for 10,000 needy of the neediest students in Virginia to go to private school 5,000 each 5,000 each yes and then establish new lab schools and then of course with the increases there on the general fund side there's also some decreases um Lottery proceeds have gone up so what they do is they just move money out of General funds and replace it with Lottery funds and what we're seeing here is a reduction on the general fund side we're not seeing the lottery funds but there is an corresponding increase on the lottery side update to lottery funded programs there's a number of lottery funded programs that are dependent upon participation and
056so when they update the numbers for participation at this time of year then there's some reductions to uh in funding and um we're seeing some of that update to incentive programs this is a small amount but our compensation that we're providing from the state is dependent upon in order to receive the full funding you have to provide the the percentage rate that they're funding you on so if it's 3% then we need to give a 3% and I have to certify that at the end of the year but not all School divisions have the funding of the local government to provide them with the required match to provide that 3% so those School divisions that couldn't provide the full uh amount those funds are taken away and then they're um reprogrammed and then there's update
057to program participation remedial summer school this is again based on participation and if this if the students are didn't participate then funds are reduced so this is um the project projected State revenues for FY 25 and 26 and that's what's in green but I will have you look just at the bottom we show um from fy19 to FY 26 but you can see the difference between years so in fy20 we had a 3.2% uh $3.2 million increase in 21 we had a 5.4 million doll increase where I want us focus on what's happened the last few years um in FY 23 we saw almost $7.4 million in state funding 24 we saw uh almost $1 million and this current year it was $8.4 Million so we've seen significant investments from the state um and what
058we're expecting based on the the enrollment change for 2025 is we're expecting another $500,000 for this year and then when we look to 26 you can see not not as much of an investment from the state because we're only seeing $4.2 million so quite quite a shift um I will say because of that number it will it will be a tight budget year because what we understand from the county side is there's not a lot of funding on the county side to support um what they've been providing us for the past couple of years so this is interesting so this is um a lot of the new money that we're seeing in fy2 and in FY 26 is um related to the average daily membership the projections for average daily membership so there in green
059is what we're currently budgeted at at 12966 what the state now is saying is that we should we should be at 13142 we're not seeing that Trend right now um that's 176 students uh we're seeing it about 13080 so we uh need to go back and verify these numbers um so the 500,000 that I showed as an addition may not be 500,000 it may be much less and then for next year they're showing is as a four four 401 additional students from our current budget that is the single largest increase from budget to budget um in in recent years so um what we see here in 2020 when we had that significant loss in 2021 we lost 670 students that first year we gained back to 176 the next year in 20 23 we gained
060back 435 now the difference between this that what happened then and what's happening now is that when Co hit we never reduced our budget we had the Staffing and the budget in place for staff we didn't have positions filled but we didn't cut positions so it wasn't a budgetary impact this is going to be a budgetary impact because with 401 additional students we're talking at least 16 teachers is that just based on what the state thinks as far as the number of students that are going to just come in they have their own calculation tool they just that's a lot they do they update it with that that fall membership but it's a little bit more than just the most recent fall membership so that is something that we're working to confirm with them okay
061so in addition to the increase in enrollment is the challenges with what subgroups those those students fall in um one are they falling all in kindergarten or are they falling across all levels but two is it are we going to see an increase with e students um with economic disadvantaged students with CSA students all those subgroups bring some additional challenges um because when we talk about uh say students with disabilities it's not just teachers it's support staff you might need pairs you might need otpt speech and there other related services so that's that's what makes it challenge is we don't see that level of detail we won't see that level of detail until we start registration um but this is where it looks like we're trending and then just finally just a reminder of our
062budget calendar um the general assembly has convened in February the superintendent is going to present a budget and and then the general assembly have will have crossover and that'll be our first snapshot of what's happening with the priorities at the general assembly and then um in March the board will approve and then hopefully in may we will have a final budget that we can bring to the board for their approval uh we haven't had a final budget in May um in the past four years so U it's highly unlikely but we'll remain optimist can help you can always dream that's right so that's the um that's a budget update um any questions about that okay so board members last month uh we presented the superintendent proposed CIP and in that presentation I mentioned that um
063there was an environmental concern with the Grafton uh turf field um we thought we would have this resolve by now but we don't I said there's no final decision on the Graf and turfield um so what we're going to bring to the board in January at the business meeting is we're going to bring the superintendent's proposed um CIP that was presented in December and if there are changes that occur after that approval then we will bring that back to the board for the board to consider those changes so what's the latest with that t like we still with the new news Water Works yeah so we have we have information from from them what they want us to do um we didn't there wasn't a lot of action over the break uh so it's just
064that we have to decide they want us to do a study they want us to pay for half of the study um we don't if we pay for the study it doesn't mean that the that that that the turf field is going to Project's going to move forward so we just have to decide if it's worth the expenditure um to have the study done we still look in different locations within the that would be a fallback but we're not optimistic that there that's going to Avail itself for us that need see you know what it is it's fomo ever since brutin got it you know all right and that concludes the finding up thank you all right next presentation is a license staff compensation and that would yes yes Dr rights our chief human resource
065officer is going to share some information related to the licensed staff compensation which is our pay scales Etc so I will turn it over to Dr RS good evening Miss Goodwin Dr shandor and members of the board this evening I will be presenting to you our annual compensation update and you're going to see many numbers just as you saw with Mr B um this evening and I'm going to focus on our starting salaries or ending salaries and how we rank as compared to our region and our Peninsula divisions our compensation package is a combination of salaries and various benefits and is an area F within our strategic plan of um highly effective Talent priority you just heard from Mr Bowen about uh presenting our annual operating budget and my presentation this evening is going to
066expound upon the licensed staff portion of compensation while all employees are critical to the success of ycsd licensed staff make up over 60% of the workforce historically salary and is a driving force for recruiting and retention of these positions however we are seeing that working conditions and support of culture are currently just as prominent VOE categorizes ycsd into Region 2 for State reporting region two includes Virginia Beach Norfolk suffk Al of white Newport News Chesapeake Hampton Portsmouth wjcc and picosen our Peninsula region is comprised of Hampton report news wjcc Williamsburg bosen and Gloucester which is where the majority of our lateral moves come from here we see lateral moves from surrounding divisions for the FY 25 school year some highlights from this slide are 7639 of our new hires were from our regional divisions with
067an average of 7.13 years of experience if we look at our regional employment shift by division we received licensed employees two from Chesapeake seven from Gloucester seven from Hampton 25 from Newport News two from picosen one from suffk three from Virginia Beach and eight from Williamsburg some of our tactics to help retain our new hires and allow for all staff to have a voice are we are doing our monthly pulse surveys and those results are shared with our administrators and our supervisors to help Target any concerns staff might have we have new higher focus groups we have our let's talk Forum we have the implementation of a new higher touch Point survey we have professional growth opportunities tuition reimbursement our lead cohort and we have firste mentors this slide shows the divisions in our region
068including the number of students served in the State ranking for size of school system or division YC SD's fall membership as of September 30th was 13,300 13,22 which ranks us 22nd out of 132 divisions in other words we're among the largest 20% of school divisions in the state here is how the division ranks per pupil expenditures the total amount of money spent on education is divided by the number of students this formula includes state and local and federal funding and as you can see we are ranked 10th out of 11 and also want to refer to you from the budget resource book Mr billan just handed out to you about how that per pupil funding formula [Music] works this slide shows the divisions in our Peninsula which you will see the same numbers and it
069shows how we rank in our K12 membership however through why the ycsd does not rank high with per people expenditures within the region our utilization of those funds continue to rank us positively with the niche ratings as we are still number one in the region for best teachers and number three in the state here comes a lot of numbers um as I was talking to you about earlier and I'm going to keep up as we go through these slides but this is for a bachelor's degree here are the divisions on the peninsula with the starting pay for steps 0 through 30 for licensed staff on our bachelor's degree the blue indicates the top three divisions for each step next is we have here are the divisions on the peninsula and this is our largest percentage
070of our staff with the starting pay for step 0 through 30 for licensed staff with a master's degre degree and the areas highlighted in blue rank in the top three Dr right yes uh you're saying like average experience of our incoming teacher is about 7.13 uh where does that fall in steps do that comes to be so it it's difficult to um compare steps to years of experience um we're going to talk about that a little bit later um because years of experience did not automatically equal with the step but whenever someone does come in as a recruiting strategy that we have we a lot of times years of experience is placed on that step so if you have seven years experience um it's around the seventh step as you're coming in okay so we
071still not highest paid in that R ranking so if you're in the seven years as you're going we're still in the top three three yes out of three we on the lower that's next is um the divisions on the peninsula with the starting pay for step 0 through 30 for our licensed staff for a master's um plus 30 degree um we are 100% in uh the top three and 96% of Staff in the top three and next is the doctorate um starting salary for steps 0 through 30 for license staff with a doctor degree and we are 100% in the top three steps and 100% of our staff in the top three this chart shows um a summary of our licensed staff compensation history of the past six years and shows how ycsd is committed
072to ensuring fair and Equitable compensation practices and maintaining competitive salaries not only does this show how we continue to re remain or retain our employees um but also attract our viable candidates this shows our next steps on how and what we're doing with this information we are going to continue to track applicants lateral moves and years of experience do an ongoing Regional Peninsula comparator review continuous opportunities for staff inut input which is very important and that's through focus groups exit interviews surveys and teacher Council and then our non-licensed salary riew cycle and benefits and this is again A lot of times I do a plug for um February 1st uh we are going to do a job fair and that's our our our large job fair and that's a Saturday so we' like you guys
073to come out if you could and that's at 8:30 at Grafton Middle School February 1 Saturday and that concludes my presentation on our licensed staff compensation for this evening do you have any questions can just a comment to be our per pupil expenses to be what they are and to be ranked so well that is a direct function of stewarding our resources you have to be doing a good job doing that to achieve those numbers it takes a lot of ingredients to get to where we are and it is our teachers it's our administrators it's everything put together um to get us to where we are right now absolutely and I'm glad to see that we address the starting pay uh what was it last year or the year before it was last year last
074year and that makes it so that we are on even footing with everyone else as far as attracting new teachers absolutely any other questions comments all right thank yous all right next we will discuss the Strategic plan academic assessments we'll have a presentation Dr Sher yes this is why everyone's tuning in tonight [Laughter] the just a joke Dr Skinner um Dr candy Skinner is our chief academic officer she is going to share information related to the PSAT Dr Skinner thank you Dr shandor for that wonderful introduction Madam chair members of the board tonight I'm going to share some information about our students performance on the fy2 preliminary Scholastic aptitude test or I'll refer to that as PSAT and how we use information to support our students academic success so student performance on the SAT is
075one of our future ready graduate key performance indicators as it helps us measure our students progress towards preparedness for the rigor of cour workk in college before I share our specific information about the PSAT I want to share some background information about the PSAT and the SAT assessments which will help as we interpret some of this data so there are four um assessments included in the SAT Suite the first and you see the blue boxes there those are the PSAT assessments the first one is PSAT 89 and I'm going to use the word and emphasize the word Baseline that is a baseline assessment for students it's the first PSAT that they offer is part of that suite and it's a baseline for college readiness for our students the PSAT T10 is often given as it
076indicates in 10th Grade and then the PSAT National Merit Scholarship qualifying test and that is a mouthful nmsqt um that is an assessment that um is given typically in 11th grade and students can use that test to qualify for the um an msqt scholarship okay so in the fall we give the PSAT 89 to our ninth grade students to all students we give the nmsqt to all of our students in 11th grade um and then if a student's parent wants to um have their child take that and they're not in one of those two grades they can pay that fee to do so um and then we'll allow them to jump into that assessment while give it to the other students so the PSAT does provide Baseline data for our students to prepare them for
077the SAT and it also giv gives um students information on their potential for advanced placement courses so that's another benefit of taking the test and as I shared before the nmsqt is a way that students can be selected for National Merit semifinalist and therefore they can compete for the National Merit Scholarship and that's that 11th grade assessment and then we also use this information so students get a lot from it we also as a division use the information to help us look for potential AP courses that we should be offering as well as any changes that we might need to think about in the rigor of our curriculum um in the alignment of our of our instruction okay so when you look at the um the scores I want to show you how to interpret
078this because I'll be throwing as Dr Rice did I'm going to be throwing a lot of numbers at you tonight and so I want to share how to interpret this information so the PSAT has two sections the excuse me the SAT PSATs have two sections and um the first is the evidence-based reading and writing I'm going to refer to that as erw and then there's the math and as you go across they the scores get progressively more rigorous so to meet The Benchmark and I'm going to kind of go just use erw to an example when our students in nth grade take this um The Benchmark is 410 and so if a student scores 410 or higher they've met essentially The Benchmark for that it gets progressively more challenging on the nmsqt that Benchmark goes
079to 460 and that's the the point is like students should be kind of tracking and looking to see how they're progressing to eventually The Benchmark on the SAT for erw is 480 and they can use the information they get from these assessments to continue to improve towards that goal when you think about the SAT which is what is reported to colleges um you really want to look at that 480 and and we've defined that there for you but a student who reaches the 480 basically what that data is saying is that student has a 75% chance of earning a c at least a c and their first semester college credit bearing course and these are typically and they're listed there more of like the humanities so it's a prediction so to speak the same is
080for math if a student scores at least a 530 they have that same 75% chance of scoring at least a c in their first semester College course and those math courses that are listed there and then when we think about about the combined score um for a student a student is considered College and Career ready by the college board if they've met both of those benchmarks not just one but they have to reach both of those so that's ultimately the goal for a student who's considering College okay so there is also a little bit more background information I want to share with you before we get into looking at some of the data and how we use it so back at for um the PSAT in October of 2023 college board made changes to the
081administration of the PSAT and then just this past year in March of 2024 they made changes to the SAT so you have to use this um when you're interpreting longitudinal data on these assessments because the College Board recommends you don't go back only so far because you're really not looking at the same assessment some of the assessments that were um some of the changes first they moved to an Adaptive and shortened so and it's an Adaptive assessment now so when you take your F you answer a question it's going to get uh possibly more rigorous or the questions may move down and when that happens the test actually becomes shorter so it's a shorter test um than it used to be and when they did that of course they had to move from paper pencil
082to um digital Administration and the last change that they made is they did remove the non-calculator section and they now require students to use the Desmos calculator Desmos is a brand of a calculator like TI but the state uses Desmos we use Desmos with our students um it's just kind of so our students are prepared we're prepared for that change but the only reason I'm sharing all this is really College Board does say to interpret longitudinal data you have to take that with caution because of the change in the administration I have a question regarding the Adaptive assessments how how do you compare a student so if you have have a student who Mrs one and so subsequent questions are easier am I interpreting that correctly you'll adjust the the rigor of the questions as
083you go so that you can get to a final score in a shorter amount of time than like the typical paper pencil that might have taken several hours to get through okay so does that automatically then move a student further down and away from that Benchmark I don't believe so our our current so tests are also computer adaptive assessments and so they adjust as well it's really um and and Lisa Beasley may be able to provide greater um a better answer than I can on this but I don't believe it changes anything they've equated all of this over the years and so they feel pretty confident that a score that you receive is Equitable to the score someone else has received even though their questions May there okay did I leave anything out there NOP
084you did great thank you okay all right so so any other questions before I move into all right so I want to talk a little bit about why we give this assessment to our students and how we leverage this for their academic success so there's really three primary reasons why we want our students to take these assessments and we give them the opportunity it helps them guide towards college andc readiness which I shared I'll talk a little bit more in a minute we also Identify some Advanced coursework opportunities for students and then it also provides career insights so this is an actual example of college boards this is Parker pupil this is a sample they provide but this is what our students receive it's multi-pages but um they'll receive this every time they take one
085of the assessments and it's pretty valuable information so the first thing that it does if you look on here this is like from the top of Parker score report it gives them their total score but it also shows them what percentile they're in so for this um total score of 1120 this shows that Parker scored in the 70 75th percentile and when you think about that that's across the globe or the nation of all the students who took this assessment um so that's valuable information it also gives a window for his particular score and then it breaks it out into the two sections I year before this is the erw so Parker scored a 620 and he is in the 60th percentile he scored a 500 on math placing him in the 70th percentile of
086his um comparator peers across the globe all right all right so the next thing that it does is it provides students with um knowledge and skill information and so on the left part here there's four sections to the erw and you'll see those four sections there the math also has four sections so when Parker gets his report you can see there's information ideas craft and structure expression and then Standard English conventions and so that information shows him like at the top under information and ideas 26% of that test is that section but look how well Parker did did really really well in that area where Parker can work a little bit more if you look is under Standard English conventions and so it will also lead him to some practice and things of that nature
087that he can use this information to um continue to work in that area and it does the exact same for math so this is just a sample I read another question sure the the slide before this one where it showed that one and individual was 70th percentile then the other individual score was a 60th percentile but added together it was a 75th percentile um no I don't believe they're added together um no not well because if his scores are reading and writing he's in the 60th math he's in the 70th and yet the total Al together puts it in the 75th okay because it's it's not combined at the bottom it's then comparing every everybody's total scores total scores okay what's interesting is if you look his his erw score is actually higher than his
088math but he's in the 60th percent off for erw and 70th for Math and that really remember their separate scores right okay okay so um every student also gets a report that talks about AP potential and the AP potential tells the student what type of coursework they may um benefit in taking it's kind of a recommendation to the student it also tells us as a division and it tells their counselors this is a student who should be thinking about this AP course so when the counselors pull the students in they can open this up they can talk to the student and the family about we let's talk about this AP course we think this might be a good fit for you let's get you enrolled into that class um it also tells us what AP
089courses we should be offering so that's very helpful the AP seminar is a good example though when we're offering this year college board recommended to us that we offer that class to our students because we had a lot of students who showed potential for it and we added it and it's in um we're offering it this year do parents get this report as well yes they can log into college board and get all of this information and we talk about it when they come in for their conferences with the counselors as well and I'll tell you something else we're doing in a minute could you describe AP seminar I've had some people ask me about that Karen do you want to talk about that so AP seminar is a course where they do it's it's
090more re it's very research based we've combined it with Advanced English 10 and the students um they are engaged in um a more rigorous type of instruction than what you might see in and just the grade level English um 10 class so and they do they do a lot of reading and a lot of writing and it really prepares them for college um to starts to prepare them for college and if you remember back in November um when I presented the program of studies part one um we are proposing AP research next year as a combination as something a student could further take that rigorous um reading and writing course work and AP research so it kind of prepares them for the research class and if they do if they receive a my understanding if
091they receive a three or greater on both of those assessments they can earn a certification um it's the AP Capstone certification certific and then if they receive a three on both of those assessments and I think it's four AP courses that they receive a three or greater there's an opportunity for them to Learn to Earn an AP um diploma no CST diploma that we're working we're researching into that kind of like the IB diploma so this will be a great opportunity for our it's a great opportunity for our students who want that advanced cours work to prepare them for a college now does that translate then to coursework in college that they don't you know if they make the three score or better it really depends on the college every college is different and what
092they accept and how many AP credits they will accept okay yeah okay and then the last thing that um the student will receive well there's a lot more but what I want highlight tonight is career insights this is really important for our students especially if you're in ninth grade and you receive this report because it can help you with your planning of your courses so every student is going to receive something like this and it's actually for their state that they reside in so Virginia so Parker wisom Virginia it's going to tell Parker based on his interest and his performance these are some career examples he might want to think about and here is the median yearly income in the state of Virginia for those here is the number of projected jobs in the next
093five years here's the growth index and here's what type of educational level you might want to think about so as he as Parker's going in to meet with his counselor this information can be very helpful as you're trying to decide if you want to take New Horizons courses or something of that nature all right so now we're going to turn and we're going to actually look at some sat PSAT data and so um want to mention um we'll look at this year's and then we'll look at twoyear data as well okay so this is our students who took the PSAT our students take this in October so this is this year's data our students in n9th grade who took the PS1 1889 you can see that um 67% of those students met the Benchmark 46%
094met the ma math benchmark that I shared with you earlier 44% met both you can see similar results as you go across and looking at the msqt um what you do notice I want to mention is the discrepancy between the erw and the math the percent of students Meeting those benchmarks that's that's important for for us to talk about for just a second so when you think about English and when students take English courses whether you're taking uh General grade level English Advanced or AP English all students receive exposure to the same standards of learning doesn't matter how what Advance if you're an advanced course or not everyone will get 10th grade um so English instruction you might get more than that in an advanced course but everyone's going to get that Baseline that's where
095you see that when you get into math it's very different what you're exposed to really depends on the math course which you're enrolled in and so that's where you see the differences the root cause for those differences um and so I'll share with you this example which I think will help explain it a little bit more what I was going to say geometry versus algebra so the top um pie chart up there is the actual assessment uh with the focus of the PSAT 89 so this isn't the nth grade test you can see on that PSAT 42. and a half% is algebra based questions that moves to 20% for advanced math 25% problem solving data analysis 12.5 geometry and trigonometry on the left what I've highlighted for you is the typical um math selection of
096courses for our ninth graders and so now we have some anomalies we have some students that might be a little more advanced than that but that's not the norm for our students and so you can see the courses that they're enrolled in algebra geometry Algebra 2 trig the bottom right is the percent of our students enrolled in those courses so oh I apologize that's a little off but um that should actually be further down um but 23% of our students who took the PSAT this fall actually completed geometry and algebra at the time of this assessment so that's important for you if you look at the percent of what's on that test compared to the exposure that those students have had to the math that helps explain a little bit more about why we see
097those differences between the English and the math okay all right so this chart shows the outcome for this year's PSAT test and last year's sat I wanted you to see um how our students kind of progress as we go through I don't have this year's sat data because we still have students taking that on Saturdays we won't get that till towards the end of summer but you can see that we do see some improvements in our students um meeting the benchmarks so as a division 88% of our our seniors last year this is a cohort um data met the um Benchmark for erw 62% of those students met it for Math and 61% of our students who took the SAT were considered college and crew ready so um and then you can see how we
098compared to the state and that same year as below right so now we're going to look at some longitudinal data and remember I shared with you earlier I can only give you two years of data because of the way this assessment changed um but we can see here if you look at the top that's PSAT 89 that's our ninth grade data and you can see um below is the our msqt are 11th graders and when you look across the last two years you can see that um our students performance improved in both areas by four percentage points for erw we see increases for math as well seven percentage points for um in the m nmsqt and then we see increases for both areas uh for students who met both benchmarks right so the last part
099of the data we're going to look at is we're going to break this out by demographic group and so the chart um this chart shows um demographic performance of our students for uh the PSAT 89 and on the left is our erw assessment and on the right is the math the green bar is fy4 the purple bar represents fy2 so you can see on the left all of our student groups maintained or showed Improvement in their performance on the right all students showed impr um improvements in their performance all student groups so now we're going to look at the same data for nmsqt and I'll remind you these are our 11th graders who took this assessment on the leftand side you can see all student groups with the exception of black students showed improvements and
100on the right hand side you can see that hispanic white and multiple race um student groups showed Improvement while Asian and black students showed a decline in their performance and when you look at these charts you can see that there are performance gaps between the reporting groups there are also differences in the percent of students meeting the erw and as compared to the math benchmark our division's PSAT results show similar similar Trends to the college board's National Data with gaps in performance between different student groups and between subject areas these gaps highlight the need to focus on giving all students the support they need to succeed and we're committed to using this data and partnering with college board to provide resources as well as opportunities so that every student can achieve their fullest potential so
101the next slide is I'm going to talk a little bit about some of the things that we're doing and our next steps um that we're planning has there been any analysis of why there was a drop for black students in both um the English side and the math side and then with the Asian students with the math side has there been any analysis yet of what caused that we've looked at our data there's no particular um um calls that I can tell you specifically what I do what I can tell you is we've as I shared our data is similar to the college board's National Data Trends they see the same Trends and so we partner with college board Libby Brown we we speak frequently with Libby to talk about the things that we can
102do to support and improve improve the Gap and decrease that Gap um liby's also come in and met with our school counselors and provided training one of the things that um we talked about several years ago was adding more opportunities for students to receive feedback on how they're performing so that they can use this to improve and get better and so that's why you see two years ago we brought on the 89 assessment then they can take that again in 11th grade and therefore they um should be prepared when they get to the SAT but I'm going to share a few things now that might answer that question a little bit more for you thanks yeah okay so um first of all college board has said one of the best ways to help students prepare
103for college coursework is to give them an opportunity to take Advanced coursework so we have added additional AP courses we've added AP seminar um we're adding AP African-American history and I think there's another AP pre-calculus I think we've added to our program of studies and AP research AP research thank you and so we're um and we've also added additional dual enrollment because not everything is AP so um dual enrollment is also something that our students can choose to take as an advanced course workk um and so that is one of the the strongest indicators for helping all of our students get better and more prepared for colleges to have the experience in high school of taking that cours workk so we're working to do that um we're also looking at um and and what I
104will say is our counselors use this information and so as I shared Libby came in and provided to our counselors we'll continue to partner with her on that but our counselors when they meet with their families and they do that academic planning sessions which I'm sure you've been you've had been a part of those with your own students um they will use that information to help guide those and so they'll seek out students they're having conversations about how a student performed did they try their best what type of math classes should we be considering for for um their student we're also working with families who may have a student who be a firsttime college student there's a lot of work that can go into helping that student prepare for applications if you think about when
105we when our students take dual enrollment there's an application process that goes with that with BCC there's a lot of things behind the scenes that our counselors are so wonderful and they help prepare our students for we're also looking at our sequencing of math one of the things VOE has said to us it across the state is that they would like to see more students taking advanced math courses um the pass r rates for s sols in Middle School are very very very high and so there may be opportunities for more students to participate in advanced math so by bringing on our map assessment data and we've talked about that before that's another data point we are using to triangulate whether students can take Advanced coursework we're also giving that math assessment earlier in the
106fall so if it's a transfer student like a military we have lots of military students um we can use that data to make adjustments in their course scheduling as soon as possible if we've not placed them in the correct math um regarding military students uh along that line if they come in after the testing window say they're they're just transferring in and it's not during the normal transfer time are they then given that opportunity to take that assessment to have that background to know what's going on with their course choices the map assessment can only be given at certain times because it is a nationally normed assessment okay but we have other assessments we're working to develop some other things that may be more that are comparable yes the best thing we do though is
107we call the school and we speak to where they're I mean our students come from all over we really want to make sure that as best we can we want to place them initially in that best placement first so we don't have to move them the front right that's what I was concerned at just coming from that background and moving with our son when he was younger yes knowing that sometimes when you come in after school's already started and they've already gone through everything can be a little tricky yeah we don't want that extra challenge for that so we look at their records from their previous school we reach out if we need to our school counselors do because we do want to place them in the rights great right math class thank you couple
108other things I'm just going to highlight very quickly for us we also make sure that our students um have some input into their their course offerings we're in the middle of doing our academic nights right now I think your Tri just had theirs last week I think it was um and so students can actually go in and give input through a QR code what courses they want to take things that they're interested and we try to provide those as much as we can um we also involve our students in college career planning as early as possible believe it or not we start in seventh grade our students start their academic planning in seventh grade and we use um the school links which this board approved we use School links to do surveys with our students
109in sixth grade we use that survey data to help plan for when they come in to meet with a counselor we see you have an interest in this we should think about taking this course we're trying to get as much data as can to help them with that process um we also give opportunities for our students to explore options post high school and this is another Mrs Fairman you asked this is another strategy College Board is very um supportive of is making sure that our kids have opportunity so our career coaches that we you that we have they will um use survey data from the school link surveys they look to see what are the interests of the students like get Graft in high school what class what are what jobs are they interested in
110and so they willing bring guest speakers in based on that data that they've received invite students in they'll also take students out for like to Advance Technical Institute we take students over there we'll run a field trip over there which is post High School um opportunities for students to learn about trades so we do all of those types of things with students giving them some experiences outside in post High School um last a couple other things we do facilitate student connections Dr shandor and and Mrs H um Sedler have talked about how we monitor students being involved in academics college board says it's really important and so things outside of academics clubs um um Athletics Athletics thank you those types of things we monitor that monthly quarterly basis because if you're connected to school more
111than likely you're you're you're going to academically you're going to do better so that's another thing that we do we actually have a um a grant that we applied for and received Yorktown Middle School in Queen Lake where they are um offering um like summer program summer enrichment where they'll take students to college they can see colleges some opportunities that might be available to them and then we also offer um resources for families and you asked me about this a few minutes ago um we're we of course do those career plannings with our families but we're also going to be offering a PSAT parent University for our families that we're going to be um scheduling where they can get on and we're going to go over these reports with them spend a little more time
112on that with our families and we offer SE SAT prep courses we had 86 students attend this past summer it's a free on the summer activity that they can do our we offer courses for um SAT prep in our high schools and then we're getting ready to launch a self-paced campus course for our students to use as well this sat Academy for parents is that something that's going to be like conference we'll probably do it virtually we'll probably do it virtually showing them how to log in making sure that they know where that information is how to use that report what opportunities are available for their students offered by the school division to um you know what we offer in the summer we have this they can do we're gonna we're going to launch that
113canvas course self-paced canvas course that that evening with our families so lots of opportunities for them to so will that class be recorded kind of being able to use as resource for later on date or the parent University we haven't talked that far yet into it but we may it's a possibility that we can do if not we will at least put those resources okay online for sure yeah um and then last but not least we do offer um I've talked about thinking based classrooms this is something we started two years ago and this is where we're um finding and building in more opportunities for students to think critically and um problem solving and so we're building that into our curriculums and by doing that this aligns to those those practices that we want to
114see for students on our SAT all right well that concludes my presentation I told you a lot of information do you have any questions for me answer many of those we great presentation especially for our families out there so thank you it was it was very detailed and covered it so uh that was wonderful thank you we'll send out more information soon about the others thank you thank you Dr Skinner all right am I turning this over to that next we got our um program of study oh me did I skip one yeah oh I did I skipped right over Dr Sherlock I'm sorry that's becom a habit so sorry we don't we don't skip even though I skipped him at our one o00 meeting today before so he sended the skip twice today yes
115so Dr Dr Sherlock is gonna share his 19th update I'm just kidding I think it's his sixth update related to the m Middle School schedule Dr Sherlock thank you Dr shandor you're welcome sorry good good evening Madam chair members of the board and Dr shander tonight I'll provide an update on the middle school schedule as this will be the seventh update uh of the to the board about our Middle School schedule um in the past within the past two years I thought it was important to revisit and kind of lay this the the lay lay of the land and kind of revisit our journey that we've taken up until this point after that I'll provide some new information so when we started exploring the middle school schedule our guiding purpose was clear and it's on
116the screen for you here to develop a recommendation for a middle school Bill schedule that best meets the needs of students in ycsd now our journey started as I said in uh 2022 when a small group when a small team which included Middle School principles started looking into and wanted to look into uh the potential of uh a different bell schedule uh from October of 2022 to March of 2023 that team uh reviewed a numerous number of B schedules uh but they realized that one they needed additional St stakeholder input and two they realized that the work really required a larger committee and so in May and June of 2023 a focus group meetings took place with students teachers and parents where uh where input was provided as far as um feedback on our current
117Middle School schedule and ideas that they thought would be good in a different schedule uh in August of 2023 that middle school committee uh was was formed and that was composed of Middle School principes teachers counselors uh parents and Schoolboard office staff nearly 30 people were on this committee uh and from September all the way through the end of November the committee met a number of times and they discussed a number of things but really they they they looked at that data or the the the the um information from the focus groups they reviewed um and they analyzed data from a survey that was sent out to all Middle School parents and to staff and they looked at a uh a very large number of schedules right and iterations of those different schedules as they
118really wanted to get an idea about what was out there in our surrounding divisions in addition they created criteria and priorities that was going to be used for a schedule evaluation in January and February of 2024 the committee uh reviewed and or uh for ranked those uh four schedules and ultimately made a recommendation or I made a recommendation their recommendation to the board in March of 2024 since that March board meeting a smaller team of principles and staff continued to investigate the implications and considerations of that recommendation in in addition to looking at necessary steps needed to implement that um potentially Implement that recommendation and of course today we have our board meeting now I do want to talk a little bit about that criteria that was used for the committee as again it's been
119quite a few different um committee or quite a few different um board updates and the criteria really is the critical piece of this decision on the screen you see the top three uh criteria of the 11 that we used the the criteria was to optimize the ability to build student interventions into the schedules uh to provide students the opportunity for daily for daily math class and to provide students an opportunity for a daily English class now I want to focus on that one on the right that the provide students with the opportunity for daily English class that was the utmost really the priority of our committee um moving to daily English was important to that committee uh they recognized the need for more English time to address the more rigorous 2024 standards and they were
120also much more complex as well in addition providing additional time would would give teachers uh more time to for um writing instruction in the classroom in addition the committee felt by modeling grade level English after our current model of grade level math which you see in the middle there students would have more success in reading and writing uh essentially especially sense we do see a reduction of of scores when students move from the sixth to the seventh grade level now remember our current English model for sixth grade is every day is daily English and when they move from 600 to 7 they go from to every other day English so again the committee felt that if the the data reduced from 6 or seven that a daily English class could be uh worthwhile finally the
121committee uh felt that us or that building student interventions within the bell schedule within that class period was essential and the daily English class really dis pair nicely with that uh in the end the committee felt it was that the committee felt that the daily English was a crital cral aspect of any schedule that was recommended now let's go through to the process of that recommendation the schedule recommendation uh was the the committee re reviewed the schedule recommendation through a decision analysis where they took that criteria I mentioned earlier there was 11 total criteria and they looked at four different schedules right they looked at a daily um seven period day they looked at a schedule with skinny shorter and longer blocks they looked at our current ycsd high school schedule and our current ycsd
122Middle School schedule and after they work through the decision analysis uh process along with the potential problem analysis they made the recommendation they see on the right hand side to maintain our current uh Middle School bell schedule but with the addition of daily grade level English for grade seven and for grade eight they did want to make it clear and they made it clear that that did the recommendation did not include did not include uh daily English for advanced English s or8 uh they also wanted a gradual ation where they wanted to hold for one year with the recommended with with the recommendation to implement in 2526 so this upcoming schoolar now this final slide shows the work completed since that last board meeting in March where that where that recommendation was made and this
123includes both considerations and implications for that daily English class this work was used to develop the following proposal to Executive cabinet for the 2025 school year to change English 7 the grade level English 7 to a daily class there would be no changes to grade level English 8 or to the advanc seven or advanc eight classes so they stay on the Block so it's every other exactly so what basically so we would move just our our um uh grade level English 7 to the Daily well the proposal was to move them to a daily English English 8 would stay the same in every other AB BLX schedule along with our Advance s and Advance eight they would stay on that same AB BLX schedule so no changes the only change would be to the grade
124level English seven classes sure you talk about the considerations as to why without doubt so and you'll see why that why that came about and you know but however we we still based on those considerations the consideration for an English a class could still be in the works but in future years right not for the upcoming school year the considerations um that we looked at were two um we looked at you know we anticipate the need for approximately six to eight additional staff uh when we move to daily English and we recognize the fact that any change to a middle school or any schedule is really budget dependent the second um consider consideration is our state accountability system our new state accountability system which I know you've heard a lot about and uh as you
125know there are substantial changes to that accountability system and however some of those changes are not yet finalized one of those changes not yet finalized is Advanced cours workk for middle school students now that would particularly affect or you know more more likely affect our grade eight students and so until that is finalized we didn't feel comfortable making a recommendation for that gr english8 and of course the staff medications also was a reason for not making that recommendation for English eight just English or grade level English 7 and that concludes my update of the Middle School uh bell schedule I would love to have any questions or any comments at this time question comments very thorough thank you for your seventh update I might give an eighth one in we move into the changes to
126the program of studies and this will be by Dr kle yeah Dr Kel brought you the program of study presentation a month or two ago November and so now there's just a few updates Dr K just a few updates because as you recall Dr Evans and I presented almost as long as Dr presentation um we shared with you proposed changes for next school year these are just a few additional ones that have come about since then as I told you back in November we would have some changes because of the new state accountability framework New Horizons Chang to their cour work as well as any changes to our own programs that may happen um that we need to be prepared for next year so I'm I'm I'm glad to share those with you tonight there
127are only a few um before I start I want to give you a little bit of background information this the the change I'm going to share on the next slide um is a result of a house bill that passed in um April of 20 um 24 and House Bill 98 allows you as a school board to um allow students who take jrc to count that as a fisical education requirement in high school so in a jroc I I like to refer to it as jrc but that stands for junior Reserve Officers Training Corp and I think most people know jrc but just in case so um this is our our courses that we have that um help our students um become involved in the military training and and that type of thing so they can
128be considered um a requirement uh they can beet the fulfill the requirement for a physical education course to those students who are interested so currently what York County does in our program of studies jc1 we allow that to be um a fulfillment of health and pe9 so that was a local decision made several years ago because before this house bill local school boards had the um autonomy to make those types of decisions but this provides a little more clarification for us and a little more Guidance the booe has also come up with guidance because because the health component of the requirement still needs to be met um the house bill only allows us to use the um jrc as a physical education requirement so so we knew we needed to get a group of people
129together to address this and so we as a um School Division pulled together some of our high School principles our high school school counselors Roc teachers instructional coordinators and central office staff and um we did two troed um decision making models so that we could decide how we're going to move forward with this a house bill and as you see on the left that's what we currently have that I just mentioned currently enrollment in this course fulfills the health and pe9 requirement for our RTC students so what this committee um is proposing is that moving forward with House Bill 98 is that jrc continues to fulfill the um pe9 requirement and jrc now to now will fulfill the pe10 requirement so we're we're proposing to add that pe10 but now we need to decide what
130to do with health right so what are we going to do with the health component and per this Virginia Department of Education we need to account for that so what we're proposing is that for our students who take JROTC one and two is that we will offer a health n semester course and a health 10 drivers's Ed course because as in York County we do provide drivers's education to our 10th grade students School divisions don't have to do that but if you do you need to do it in a separate class and not um JROTC does that make sense so we're we're proposing to offer the semester course for those Jr jrc students who are T who were um using jrc to meet the PE requirement okay now with the house bill it made it's
131going to impact two of our other classes that we are currently um the local school board had made the decision to count as PE so I want to share those two classes with you as well and these are our dance classes so previously when the school the Arts was established they um allowed students to either select um Dance Arts to meet a fine arts elective or a fiscal education elective the students had the choice but with the guidance from Virginia Department of Education and with the house bill now it will just be a fine art elective and students will take their health and PE 9 and health and pe10 through the regular health and PE 9 and 10 classes okay and then the last change we have is with New Horizons they did approve their
132coursework for next year the only change that they've notified us that they're making is the patient care technician class they're removing that from their course list it was a brand new class this year we didn't have any students enrolling it this year I think they had low enrollment numbers for it so they are and there were some other fur as well that they're removing that from their offerings next year so we wanted to provide that information to you tonight as well so all of this will um come to you um in the consent agenda later this month and this pretty much concludes what I have to share with you tonight and I'm more than willing to take any questions you may have when you um when we had to switch to offering health and um
133the driver's EDS separate um did that did you have to get separate teachers now to teach just the health part of it or do your PE te still they're going to we're going to have to have teachers that are endorsed and with the health and PE endorsement to teach that class and so we've looked at our numbers it will be a small number of students um they will take the health class and their H school we right now um we have students that travel to two of our schools for JROTC but they'll take the health classes in their own school so it won't be um it won't be the two J the two schools that house jro TC that they won't go there for health and Driver said so it won't be as much of
134a burden for those schools and we'll be able to work those into the numbers thanks I have a question regarding driver's ed any student can take driver ed in your County schools in 10th Grade it is part of our curriculum for health um for health and pe10 and the the course that they take here that satisfies their driver's ed or do they then have to continue and take it as you know with private behind the wheel it satisfies thetis but they have to take on the road so they'll get their card from us which then they can sign up for on the road they don't until they get that I think it's they have to get it's a green card I a green card but part of that too and and what was legislation I
135believe it was last year was that um the parent university has to be attended by the parent as well like a parent training coures as well and that's a requirement um so our parents also are responsible for being a part of the student getting that um green card to move forward with their driver's education okay so then uh in order to get their their permit their their driver's permit they not only they get the classroom here but then they have to get the actual on the road from a private you remember years ago we used to do on the road and I think if you go to tab you can still see like how it was more D you did that in Florida you just was that a budget reason that was long before me
136I do not know and I might be the oldest person in the room so well take that back you're not the oldest person in the room you're the longest wife yes because I've had some questions about that of you know why why isn't it available and would it ever be considered to be put back in for those students who can't to do that road portion privately so School divisions do not have to offer D the driver said portion that we offer it's not a requirement of us to do that we but we do do that part of it and so again to add that piece would be a you know there would be a lot of budgeting and everything else implications yeah okay yeah yeah I don't know if I want to be the person
137that space I think a lot of it has to do with liability and insurance because I remember taking it um when I'm going way back get taking it in in high school and we had quite a few accidents I can imagine not me not me but we did have accid so I think that that's probably why it eventually got scrapped yeah yeah any other questions for Dr C thank you Dr C Dr Kel we have H one final presentation and it's on the school calendar so we have um we good Dr Aaron Butler and are we good guys are you sure y I'm sure we arguing that you're going to start teaching kids how to drive so me to do that Dr Aaron Butler our director of student services and our coordinator of testing and
138accountability Lisa Beasley our going to share a draft of our 2526 student calendar um they work with the regional team they also have a team of folks here that they work with and I certainly want to get some feedback from the board related to next steps so Dr Butler I'll turn over to you madam chair members of the board and Dr shandor this evening Mrs Beasley and I will present the 2025 26 draft school calendar options as well as begin discussion on the 2026 27 school calendar per Virginia code School divisions are required to develop school calendars that have a minimum of 180 instructional days or 990 instructional hours in addition within the 990 instructional hours 140 instructional hours per course at the high school level must be included as well as 560 instructional hours
139in the four core classes at the middle school level and finally 680 instructional hours in the four academic disciplines at the elementary school level additionally back in 2019 the general assembly amended the code of Virginia to allow School divisions who have previously not been granted a waiver to start the school year 14 calendar days before Labor Day with the contingency that the Friday prior to label day must be a non-instructional day the calendar proposal we will PR present this afternoon align with all state requirements to give a historical perspective back in the 20 uh pre pandemic back in 2018 2019 um the division had develop 180 day calendar and you can see there was 11 early release days and then of course we had to make some changes due to co and make some shift
140to the calendar however we switched to if you can look and see you can see that we did start switching to a pre-labor day calendar and the good thing about that is when we took that shift Labor Day fell late to minimize the impact on summer schedules with the reduction of early release days is a direct result of our staff and family feedback particularly for the impact on instruction and child care arrangements for our families some of the benefits of switching uh to a pre-labor day calendar as well as reduction of the early release days was that we gained between 12 and 15 hours of instruction at each level which equated to two or more instructional days and even when we had the Year back in 2023 24 where we had less than 180 days
141uh students still had more class time than they did back in 2018 2019 is that how we handle snow days yes so whenever yes so we always try to aim to have a 180 day calendar but if for some reason we can't then it goes to hours and the hours and so we just calculate to make sure ma'am great thank you yes ma'am for every calendar that we develop the division uses a driving principle and that is how can we develop a school calendar which best supports student academic success while meeting state requirements U for us to develop the calendar we have a two-part process so the first process is that there is a regional calendar Committee of our surrounding divisions U Mrs beastley serves on that committee and they work together to make sure
142we're trying to have alignment within our region but then locally at our division we also have a local committee and you can see it was made up with several stakeholders it included our some teachers from all three levels families we had student Representatives this year who participated as well as building administrators school counselors and several members from our school board staff now Mrs Beasley will share more information concerning the two draft calendars that were developed by the committee so here on the screen um is a um sense of key dates uh for the two calendars that were recommended by our committee committee um in your folder this evening you have a full calendar um for each of these drafts one is on blue paper and one is on green paper just for ease and they've
143also been posted on board dos for a community so if you look at draft one which is that top row uh we would start school Monday August 25th which is 4 days before Labor Day um that is similar to the schedule that we did uh for this current school year and our last day of school would be Wednesday June 10th uh that would be 180 day calendar um and that matches uh to this the current calendar we have for this school year where our last day is also on Wednesday draft two uh has students starting on Thursday August 21st so instead of four days before Labor Day uh it is now 6 days before Labor Day uh this would allow us to make our last day of school potentially Friday June 5th uh this calendar
144would have 179 days so as Dr Butler shared we would IM immediately start counting instructional hours if that's the calendar uh we elected to go with instead of meeting the 108 um 80-day requirement the committee's rationale for actually starting two additional days prior to labor day was actually to avoid that abbreviated schedule at the end of the year by ending on a Friday you have that Mo that consistency of going to school a full week um and that's likely to reduce cases of absenteeism those last couple of days um this would also provide our students who are taking AP and IB coursework two additional days of instruction prior to their exams so our our AP exam schedule and our IB exam schedule um begins in early May um and we don't have control over those
145testing calendars uh the uh college board and IB provide us those testing calendars so by moving up to additional days that would get our students two more additional days of instruction for both both draft calendars you can see that the Thanksgiving holiday is the same winter break would remain consistent with two full weeks and three weekends which has been um an important component that our stakeholders have been sharing with us and spring break would would would remain the first full week of April as we've done with our spring break pretty consistently so we do have a uh division calendar committee scheduled for next week uh to work through any additional recommendations that the board might have for us so at this time we'd like some input or feedback that you might have for our calendar
146committee regarding these draft calendars right off the bat the one I think about and I'm just thinking in terms of families traveling in the summer is number uh one allows families to have another full week of vacation a lot of families do take like a late August vacation whereas if you start on Thursday August 21st first that kind of would cut into that that's just an initial observation I would see some people I out of the experience would say you know because I know a lot of families do take like a late August vacation conversely for those that take the early vacations they do better on on number two right then you get the flute side of that is if they like to go in June you know that's true too did the committee have
147a a recommendation between the two or was it kind of a split split decision I think the the K the committee actually worked through three draft calendars um and the third draft calendar was not um not highly uh preferable from the committee um so we narrowed it down to these two drafts and for every Pro they could figure out a con and and vice versa um I think you know knowing that we could get two additional days of instruction in for AP and IB students um knowing that that draft 2 um in some instances aligns better with like virtual Virginia we always work with virtual Virginia so their kids aren't behind but it but it does align with one of their cohorts better that was going to be my next question what does one of
148these over the other align better with the um the other programs that we do the governor schools so um our our regional committee is um a little mixed right now in regards to where they are in the process uh we've had several School divisions that are in our regional group uh that have already approved their 25 26 calendars they've done they're done they've made the decision several of those School divisions are actually they work in a two-year process which is where we' like to go next and that's why we'd like to start to look at 26 27 um those School divisions who have set their calendars for next year are starting August 25th um there are several School divisions uh similar to us that are starting the conversation either this month or next month um
149and so it's hard to know where where those School divisions Will Made decision for 25th which who has made the decision um so Hampton does a two-year calendar so when they did their calendar for last year they put out a draft 2526 that they'll go to their board with um here in the next month or so um wjcc has already approved their calendar they do their calendar in October uh for the the next school year they're actually going to start working on 26 27 here in the next couple weeks um and then um Gloucester has approved their calendar for 25 26 because we TI on New Horizons we're tied up new news in the governor school yeah so typically New Horizon says when they're uh when they're working through the schedules and they're they're looking
150at inconsistencies they basically look at the three biggest school divisions so they look at Hampton Newport News and York County because we're the three largest school divisions with enrollment and they say if Hampton and Newport News for example are off that particular day their students are going to be off but if only one of those School divisions is off then the expectation is going to be that students come to school that day so you said Hampton Williamsburg James City County and Gloucester are 25th the 25th yes ma'am which would be our draft one do we have indication on Newport News what they were thinking about or um so she is uh she actually does her calendar the latest of the regional uh group um so she won't take uh the the person who leads that
151project um in their division won't actually go to her board until late February or or March um but she is leaning towards August 25th they are leaning the same sched right yes this year for this current school year we all started school on the same day uh we are not all ending school on the same day that Aries um anywhere from that Friday bosen's last day is that Friday um and then some of the schools are going all the way through Thursday and that that varies because of um early the early dismissal soosan has a significant number of early dismissals in their schedule that they do on Wednesdays um whereas other school divisions similar to us have have reduced their early dismissals down pretty significantly any feedack that's all is there any other feedback you'd
152like us to take back to the committee or you know any other ways of getting additional feedback or any questions that you would have to help you when we bring this before you to make a decision I think You' answer my questions I think I know where I'm leaning so yeah like option number one just kind of end of the start two weeks and then weekend and then four days of school and then holidays that's kind of where I'm at yeah so option one the the recommendation for starting four days before Labor Day that that's where I was and since it's coordinating also with the other ones it seems just like we don't know about Newport News yet but if if our other learning communities follow the majority it would be a whole lot easier
153you know if those three are already along those lines for the start okay that's where my guts leaving right leading right now okay until I get people calling me saying no no no so as I mentioned we would like to start having conversations about the 2027 uh calendar um it's been a goal of ours for a number of years to get to a place where we're going to have a 2-year calendar um so that our families our stakeholders our community um can can really plan forward and plan out um and so we would like to begin those conversations this evening in regards to 26 27 I think that's a wonderful idea because I so many times I have parents ask me do you know what the Calendar's going you know what it's going to be
154question it's nice if we have it pre-planned out for two years for them because people make a lot of plans way ahead of time so that's U I think it's a great idea we have a number of outside organizations that contact us about summer camps and when they're going to start going to end and all those types so I think this would help everybody pleas for that not to mention graduation and all the people coming in for graduation right yes let's do that so as we previously shared as Dr Butler previously shared in the 2020 2021 school year uh the division uh first made that decision to move to that pre- Labor Day start to those four days before Labor Day um at that particular time it was shared with the board that eventually our
155goal was to get to a place where we were 14 days uh before Labor Day which is the maximum as Allowed by the code um this particular school year the 2026 2027 school year um is an ideal year to make the change because Labor Day in the 2026 2027 school year is September 7th late very uh late compared to um say this school year or next school year so additionally as I just mentioned by working with a 2-year calendar uh we can allow uh families to adequately plan uh we can uh plan for construction projects we can plan for Summer Academy um as well as any other summer events that we might need to lead so with that we have two drafts that we would like to bring to the board uh for further uh
156discussion um and uh considerations and recommendations so these are key dates as you'll notice there are um portions of these particular drafts that have not yet been worked out with the calendar committee um and that will be part of the work that we work on next week based off of your recommendations so draft one begins school on Monday August 31st that's four days before Labor Day um and again as I mentioned Labor day is September 7th um and the last day of school would likely be Wednesday June 16th because of that late Labor Day start um and that would be a calendar that would have uh 180 days planned draft 2 begins school on Monday August 24th which is 14 days before Labor Day and the last day of school would likely be Wednesday June
1579th um again that would be 180-day calendar again in both drafts Thanksgiving break would remain consistent winter break would remain two full weeks and three weekends and spring break would be a uh full week and would remain the first full week of April so at this time we'd like to identify potential next steps as we consider these key dates um this might include additional work being conducted by our division calendar committee as I recommended some of those key dates or TBD uh we could get input from the community through a stakeholder survey and then bring those results back to you during our February work session um and then we'd also like to get input or feedback from you uh regarding these key dates for 2627 how's option one I like option two is this for
1582627 2627 I don't want to throw a whole big wrench into this but but I'm going to so the state years ago um gave us the latitude of going 15 days early 14 I'm sorry 14 days earlier so my point many years ago as we talked about this was there used to be a map that you could see the west side of the State versus the east side of the state all about weather and the King's Dominion law right so for example um there are schools in the in the western part of the state that their first student day is August 12th oh yeah okay so oh let me finish so their first day is August 12th but they're out their last day of school is May 29th so you know my goal when I
159first got here was to try to push the envelope because I always felt like in Virginia the um holiday break really penalizes where we started sort of penalized our kids because they would have to come back from the break have you know another three four five six weeks and then have to take finals way back win remember and you know the division that I came from in another state we started school and we ended school at Christmas break for the semester and then everyone could actually enjoy their three weekend and then when you came back you started for second semester the way the the way the code has been written we can't uh the Eastern districts on on on well let me say the Eastern districts in the state of Virginia you have to meet
160x amount of qualifications for snow days and days Miss to get to that point that's why the Western districts can so my um advocacy was but our kids still have to take IB test that we you just heard us talk about test we have no control over of when they are so is it fair that um Dr Van hookim in Winchester his kids get get three more weeks of instruction for AP IB all those assessments than our students do so that was my argument years ago now they've put these 15 days in there but they've also put some um little their school is it school days versus calendar days calendar days versus school days so if it was school days obviously you can come back earlier and potentially fit that in before the break but
161it's calendar day so why we're counting Saturdays and Sundays for for school I think that may have been a political decision potentially um so my my question would be to the board just not to make that you're not making that decision tonight but really is to think about when we did this and went early before Labor Day we were the first division that did it and all the other districts got in line sort of with what we did so think about that in your decision- making yes it would be difficult for one summer everyone would leave school June 12th or whatever and then they would say ah we got to go back early you're right but if there was a way that we can get out of school before Memorial Day that would be wonderful
162too so then you would sort of reset that so just again just something to something to think about I'd just like to comment I know when this first changed and we got the the provision to be able to start 14 days earlier um that was kind of the the desire the board was actually looking at um that's why we moved it a week now do we want to go that extra wheek now to incorporate those extra days to get out early um and I'm okay either way I'd like to see what our stakeholders have to say and um you know cuz they're the ones that really are going to it's going to affect them more than me right now yeah you know our staff that's where your come in so you I I can go
163either way I'd like to see a start early but I don't want to make a decision without hearing more from them and their recommendations I'm looking at number one the problem is is that you're going to school past halfway through June yeah yeah yeah yeah long time yeah and that's why if you're going to make a change if you're going to make a shift this is the year to do it because the you feel the impact less because of that late Labor Day you actually feel the impact on the the back end right when everybody's used to it when everybody's used to it because of the fact that that Labor Day is later I will tell you we had a um School Division on the South Side who made the jump this year um they
164were the only School Division to make the jump um and they started a week ahead of everyone else um and they got some push back from their Community about it but they they did a series of stakeholder surveys and and got feedback on that type of stuff um and as school divisions are starting to plan for 25 26 two more school divisions in that area have now announced that they're going to they're going to go ahead and make the jump um and and go ahead and and make that alignment it may be inevitable for us in 2 three years if we don't you know but yes so the question is what would 14 days earlier be before Labor Day on on during that year you said it was AUST which is not that bad really
165at that mag so this year actually I believe we are or the next school year the start date is August 24th 25th so that date is a familiar date to our families because of the start time and to your point of the longer or how the impact is um in this that summer between the 25 26 school year and the 26 27 school year summer would actually if we do not make that change the summer break would be close to 12 weeks approximately making that change would actually leave the break the same amount of time that our families are used to currently right so I want to make that clear when we're doing the survey that's to help the math because it's hard when you think about oh you're shortening summer break in essence we're
166keeping the exact same summer break you're used to but also being able to get you out before late coming in point of June so those are some of the points we want to make and for clarity sake if we're doing a survey um would you only want now to do the 26 27 or since we are doing it would you want some feedback on the two options for the 25 26 just this one okay just wanted to be clear because I don't want to confuse that's the big change fantastic that makes everything clear for me thank you very much I also to just as a comment from a student perspective I don't know I think like once June 1 hits to you know you're done you're done and you want to adding that extra week
167in that first BL like oh no or two weeks I mean really so that just because I mean that's me June 1st was like okay school's done well and I think it's it's about that Memorial Day just like Dr shander was saying right and by starting that August 24th we do then get that additional week for our students in regards to AP and IB exams where we don't have the flexibility to change those testing schedules one question I do always get is well what about the so testing schedule right like how does that get changed well we as a division actually develop our s testing schedule so we have the the flexibility to adjust that schedule how however we want um and we work every year uh Dr Skinner myself Dr Kel uh Christina head
168and Dr Sherlock really work to get that schedule as late in the school year as possible knowing that we still have to do makeups and expedited retakes um so that our students get as much instructional time as possible for before they have to take those assessments right any other questions so I just want to uh kind of summarize what what we're hearing from the board this evening so in regard ards to the 2526 calendar uh we're hearing from the board the recommendation would be uh option one uh with the start of school on uh Monday August 25th and then finishing school on that Wednesday and then for the 26 27 uh year we'd like to do a stakeholder uh survey and get some feedback from our stakeholders regarding those two drafts even that timing wise
169because I do do not want to confuse our community I would probably recommend we complete the work of the 2526 calendar have that approved by the board then initiate survey in the next one otherwise people may think that they're surveying on next year's calendar right but we can still try to have that to you by the February March meeting because we are talking a year out we could put some distance between the two we can bring the recommendation for 2526 to you at the January uh regular session uh on the consent calendar and then we can put the stakeholder uh survey out after that date and get that feedback and then bring that feedback to you in a February or March work session that'll work okay thank you that concludes our presentations for the evening
170so now we're on to a discussion item policy K and I believe that's yes yeah policy K uh School community relations it's going to be I think a tag team effort U Miss Barry are you starting discussion no I'm happy to Simply share um this is the quadal review of policy section K which is coming to the board for discussion this evening uh potential first reading at the next regular meeting and then of course second reading based on that um what you received and what has been posted on board docs are the redline versions of every policy as along with a summary of um um the revisions and so what we have are mostly minor revisions which where we might have added legal references or cross reference to further supported individual policies in some cases
171we have t taken terms that might have been general or potentially misleading or just said his or her design so we just made sure it was clear what role had that design so superintendent designate or parent Guardian replacing General um terms there we've added the copyright to the BBA if it was appropriate because it aligned we you know relied heavily on that um policy we did have some subst substantive revisions um that would primarily be policy KD dbdh the public participation at board meetings this added language um regarding the procedures for signing up added we added accommodation information which had never been included in our policy there so accommod ations for um if you needed assistance with the speaking or sign language anything like that any type of accommodation delineated purposes of the public comment
172periods and then included um expectations and the time limitations and other comments there we still have some meetings scheduled to continue to review and analyze this where we wanted the board's feedback so that we can analyze any of that before the first reading and then there are um two additional policies so what we had done was because policy KDA BD DH is rather lengthy when you explain at all of what's going on there is a second component that is the public participation at Schoolboard public advisory meetings so that is the previously right now currently our policy includes the public forum public hearing processes within the general comments so we recommended separating those out to two different po policies because there is a difference between the general public comment period and you're speaking to a specific
173public forum or public hearing so that is a separation of those two policies and then um we included a new policy K&B which is reports of missing children which was a recommendation from the BBA policy manual so those are summary again the sheet that explains each individual policy those changes are in um available and of course the redline versions but we're happy to take questions or receive feedback on the revisions I have one question when I was reading it uh this afternoon the reduction of time speaking time for Citizens reducing from 3 down to 2 minutes was there a particular reason for other than time you know what was the I think that was just a general that as individuals had walk we had listened to some board members comments over um the course of
174the last year looking at those so it was just placed in there and also that delineation between two ensuring two different public comment periods so ultimately and they can speak at both now so an individual could sign up to speak specific to the agenda budget hearing or to two minutes budget hearing whichever and then at the end of the meeting again they could speak for two more minutes so ultimately they could before I thought they could speak to the current policy states that an individual may only speak once during a board meeting ah okay during the whole board meeting okay yes so this this does expand actually some opportunities for IND but then it reduces their time to two minutes instead if we go that route of allowing them to speak at both components it
175seemed The Logical otherwise you minutes they're just doing one you're saying if we have two public speing speaking comments General comments from citizens and one on Capital Improvements is that what you're saying so currently the way the policy is written is that there is a specified public comment period at the beginning M and then there is the anyone who did not sign up to speak may speak at the end of the meeting right okay so that along with the public forum and public hearing the way the policy is worded is if you speak during the public forum on a night that we have it the policy indicates you should not be allowed to speak either at the public the general comments or the end of the meeting right so they they get three minutes total
176even if they want to speak to both the policy or the public forum and general comments of matters before the board so this would allow an individual now to say well I have comments specific to the budget I have comments specific to the um agenda item and or I have non-agenda items and I can speak two minutes at each I mean I thought it was fine the way it was where they could speak on General comments for 3 minutes and then if we had a a budget for them they could speak again in for 3 minutes I was I was good with that problem they couldn't do that but they should be well I allowed them when I was chair and they should be because it's two separate things yeah I think this is why
177we also that's also why we would like to remove it from the policy because it was not um we were not necessarily adhering to the because it didn't make sense because they were two different issues but to have them speak after for the meeting to go on and on and on they've had their opportunity to speak I mean we're listening to them they they they can s emails they can call us whatever so part of um I didn't mean to interrupt s I'm sorry part of the delineation and with the two separate ones was um to ensure that the time spent at the beginning of the meeting is truly on the matters the board will be discussing or voting on that night and if it is a matter that is just passionate I just I
178want to make you aware of this I need to speak to the board it allows the board and those there for the business of the meeting complete that component of the board meeting first and then another topic can come to the board if it's not before the board to vote on that night that was that was the rationale and we're fine to change that if the board is it's not the board's I just don't think we had that big of an issue with people coming and unless it was a passionate issue of whatever came up um I mean I think we've had we've had that in the past absolutely uh but it's it's not been that big of a deal to give the the citizens their three minutes and then give them another 3 minutes
179for the if there's a separate hearing I was good with that but to continue it at the end of the meeting and go on and on me you could be there till midnight um I I I just think it was fine the way it was just allow him to speak both times I'm good with that both times being if we have two if we have two public session but if they speak at the beginning of the evening would they be able to speak at the end you want to go back to what the policy currently states which is if you you can only speak at the end if you did not previously speak right right if you didn't previously sign up somebody came in late or something like that which happens on occasion I'm okay
180with that but to allow everybody to do that we can we can go forever absolutely can make those revisions prior to the I mean that's that is the will of theard that's the way I'm looking at it but that's up to the rest of the board so yeah I agree I think at the the end of the meeting it was just those people who either didn't get there in time to sign up um or realized as they were hearing other people speak that they wanted to say something that was at the end of the meeting but I think what what I'm understanding is that previous policy and I don't remember that when I was looking at it kind of just said that you there was the speaking time for a particular item like budget you
181know for the citizen input and then speaking at the board meeting was separate from that and and you're saying that no it actually wasn't it was one or the other well it did delineate public forum public hearing the the fact that the board would hold those they fall within the board meeting and agenda and the policy states that in the agenda they may only speak once so when the it was an interpretation at the time it's an interpretation because we hold the hearing within the board meeting okay so we that is what we need to correct we could actually do what Mr Richardson was saying is that delineate okay there's speaking for such a thing as you know the board the citizen comments to a particular topic and then you can speak to the board
182of whatever you choose or on the budget if we have a budget hearing or if we have a so you would have identified a particular topic that's separate from just coming to tell the board your thoughts about something right right well that's if we're holding a public comment on that correct right right that could be nothing within this policy prohibits an individual from speaking during a designated public forum or public hearing held by the board on the same night that that and we still gonna go with two different color cards right that would delate yeah have two different cards yeah makes we do that currently we do that currently so that'll be part of it so we will take that feedback review how that impacts the other compon and if there is anyone that comes
183lat or whatever we'll still give them an opportunity to speak at the end yes correct so we can we can make those adjustments on that policy are there any other policies that there's questions on or feedback on thanks so um quick question I know because the previous policy had St stated that you know it was up to the board chair of what was going so has that been removed I'm not looking directly at it okay yes all right this was a lot of pages so to go through it yes make comments the first time seeing it absolutely that's that's why there is the three step process so that if there's more that you catch between now and the first reading we can still adjustments prior to the second reading thank you for your feedback thank
184you all right we have one more little business item we need to take care of Dr Shand yeah I had a question yeah I had a question for Miss Barry um this document that was shared at the beginning of the meeting um my question was that I know we're Bound by 2.2 3707 item G to make sure that all materials furnished to members shall be made available for public inspection at the same time such documents are furnished I know we do that our goal is typically on Wednesdays we'll post at least the agenda and then when presentations are out there with the board season the Community season at the same time how shall we proceed related to the item that was presented at the beginning of the meeting I do not have a digital copy
185the item should have been posted when it was handed out to the board members and as we were in the meeting we're unable to do that so so my question that's a foal violation correct correct okay so do we need a self-report to Foya or how should we do that any member of the public could file a petition with the court um for fo violation if a screenshot is taken of it and posted before midnight tonight does that satisfy since it's when within that day no we still need to do that when it was handed to the board that's too late yeah so yeah it's too late contemporaneously is that the term that's in the code um and but we will of course post it tomorrow when we're back at work um so the the
186public can't see it but it is a violation okay thank you moving forward um I'm for future so we don't end up in this situation again if it's not brought up for inclusion on the agenda it's not going to be addressed because we can't have another situation of way of violation um ample opportunity is given everybody knows the dates of the meetings you know the policy when things have to be given to myself or if you want to uh give them to Miss Howard for inclusion in our organizational meeting or business meeting you even email us and let us know I I I've been I yeah as courtesy I've tried to do that as well so there really is no reason why we can't include those ahead of time so from going forward um we're
187not going to do this random oh I have something to throw in at the last minute because it's it's not a it's a violation and two it's not fair I mean it's not transparent and that's what we're aiming to be is transparent this is not transparent the public can't see what we've been looking at what you read to us so anyway I just want to put out out there that we're I'm not going to I gave Grace tonight but I'm not doing that again okay any other you ready yeah I'm ready uh well let me close out with well first of all whoever's left thank you for presenting this evening yeah thank you uh I do look forward to a successful and collaborative 2025 um we have to have a closed session at this time
188so uh I need a board member to take us into close session got it I move the York County School Board convenience close the session person went to Virginia code section 22- 3711 A1 of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act to discuss the performance of a specific individual as the matters addressed in close session are confidential no minutes or recordings are permitted thank you second gotta Miss Howard a motion was made by Mr schaer and seconded by Mr pich to convene in close session as stated Mr schaer yes Mr Richardson yes Mr pivot yes Mrs Fairman yes Mrs goodin yes motion passes 5 to Zer you're now in close session our next regular meeting is January 27th here at yourk call thank you are we staying here while we moving