CorpusRecord 8174

2/18/25 - FCPS Budget Committee Meeting and Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Fairfax County Public Schools
Date
2025-02-19
Location
Fairfax County, VA
Material
Transcript
Extent
23,005 words · about 128 min
Collected
2026-06-01

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001on the FY 26 budget and before we get started we need to read in Mr frish the February 18 2025 Schoolboard budget committee meeting is called to order at 5:04 p.m. Mr frish has submitted a written request to attend this meeting virtually due to medical reasons and he is located in the Providence District in Fairfax County all those in favor of approving Mr fr's request please raise your hands that is Mr mline Miss um Anderson Mr McDaniel Mr Moon miss lady Miss Marin Miss Dixit and myself that is unanimous for those present I'm going to turn the meeting back over to Mr MCD sorry Mr fr will you please test your mic yes thank you we can hear you I'll turn the meeting back to Mr McDaniel thank you m seore Heiser this morning I

002had the distinct privilege of being an audience member at the Board of Supervisors meeting where the county executive presented his proposed FY 26 budget and uh the high level notes that I'll go into really quick the proposed transfer increase is $118 million uh 7 million an additional 7 million for Capital debt uh with which represents a 51.5 % split in Revenue so that's the high level and with that I'm going to turn things over to Lee and she can give you some more details and we'll kick things off after that uh what Mr McDaniel said is absolutely correct um they have the county funding is at the same percent that it was in the current year which is 51.5% and that results in $18.64 million uh over um the previous year the um basically that

003means that our current budget right now we would have to reduce by about 121 million um and with that I'm assuming that the the house and uh Senate in the general assembly um their budgets that they proposed originally are pretty closely aligned much more so than you normally see normally there's a huge distinction between the two bodies um but they're pretty close this time um so we're comfortable that we think we're going to get about 28.3 million more from the state so the actual difference between the County transfer that we requested and what they've offered is 150 million but we're going to if we get the additional 28 million that the state has proposed um then that would put our Gap at 121 million instead of the 150 so so that's good um you should

004also know that the um that there is not anything included in the county executive budget for the meals tax but he did make some remarks about the MS tax um and I guess what they're considering is a 3 Cent meals tax which for a full year would generate about $96 million but for fiscal 26 it would only be a half a year impact because it wouldn't go into fact until January 1 of 26 so it would end up being about 48 million to the county um his comments seem to suggest that they are going to discuss the meals tax at a later date March April time frame because they want to substitute the meals tax funding um not to provide FCPS with any additional funding but to not include a one and a half cent

005real estate tax rate which is included in the county executive's budget and then reduce that another half cent more so the MS tax at this point would would not have any impact on us at all as as he has suggested in his comments today um the max that you can do on a meals tax is 6 cents and if it was if they if someone proposed a six cent and that passed um that would generate an additional 192 million per year and about half that in the first year because it only wouldn't start until January 1 and as far as the state goes um you know yesterday they were supposed to complete all of their committee work and then once that all of that work is completed then that's communicate well the general assembly has

006until February 20th to put the bills into conference committees with final action on this coming Saturday February 22nd um and then after that's done then the governor May sign amend or veto any Bill presented to him and he has until March 24th to take that action and then General Assembly will return for a reconvene session on Wednesday April 2nd so you know with the county I mean they just introduced today with the state it's early days we have a lot of discussions that have to happen before we'll know our actual funding levels okay thank you um with that we'll open the floor up not everybody jump at once Mr Moon excuse me Mr Moon one thing that I forgot to tell you is they also included in their budget document um pages 37 through 64

007a list of agency reductions uh you may recall that um Mr Hill announced that they were looking at a 10% reduction level well his budget includes reductions that total 3.4% not 10% and of those reductions there's about uh seven of them that would impact Fairfax City Public Schools like crossing guards at the high school no Fairfax County um schools they um like crossing guards apparently none of the other school divisions have crossing guards at the high school level so they've proposed reducing that that's 16 positions um nurses they have apparently 30 vacancies and so they have um proposed reducing those 30 vacancies from nurses middle school after school program um bridge to kindergarten an emergency step program uh and a transition services for FCPS seniors and those reductions that are on the county side on

008our behalf total uh 7.7 million do and Ju Just real real quick a quick comment this is some what unusual timing for us because typically we have this work session while the county is presenting its budget but because of timing we now know the numbers so in addition to more conversation on our budget the numbers that the county executive put out this morning can also help inform our our conversation tonight Mr Moon uh thank you chairman MC uh let me first ask you a question about County budget County side uh is a county executive requesting budget increase for de side I do not know the answer to that but my colleague Matthew Might or Alice wiggington the budget director is online she may know the answer to that but I do not okay if we

009can come back to me uh you know when you have that information with with that said uh with a state fund uh that you said 28 some million dollar you were expecting does there include something I heard about a week and a half ago when I was down in Richmond uh about including just a bonus of $1,000 per instructional staff is that part of that or that's bonuses on top of that or yeah we didn't I'm not including the money for the bonuses in my analysis of the 28 million if you look at the information I provided at the February 4th work session it actually says 48 million because um the house proposed a $1,000 bonus for all s soq positions um for fiscal 26 and the Senate proposed that for fiscal 25 but either

010way it's the same amount of money and um they're one-time costs of which the state will kick in 20.3 million and we it would cost us 36 million to do the bonus in the same way that we did it in fiscal 23 which is ,000 for every full-time position hourly contracted hourly contracted or bus drivers uh and Food Service workers and family Liaisons uh and then we did like $500 for hourly workers and then if you were just a very minimal I think below 10 hours hourly worker than it was $250 so if we did that in fiscal 26 just like we did it in fiscal 23 the cost to us is 36 million of which the state's going to kick in 20 but it's all one-time funds I understand you know my question answer

011again is uh what so that 28. some million does not include that $1,000 bonus for S soq A funded positions it does not and and if I ask you can we fix this what the amount of that $1,000 bonus translate into a dollar could you tell us whether it's a 36.2 36.2 million onetime funding uh other understanding on mind on the ,000 bonus Amendment budget amendment was that matching was not going to be required from local school district is that correct I mean there a no condition that's that's true but implementing what they're proposing is not really doable in the way that they propose it because I think I've explained to you all before and I'm just making these numbers up as an example but I could come up with real examples if we needed

012to let's say that the state says the S soq says that we're required to have one reading specialist um per thousand kids then that means we need 180 and if we have 200 then that means 20 of those people are not included in that bonus because they're not soq positions they're not required could could we could we have could he have detailed know response or information about this proposal so that at least yes I can have a better understanding of what this state legislature is a a including and and one more question related to that is are you suggesting that we reject the money no no I'm suggesting that we fund it because it's onetime funds and we've included bonuses for one-time funds in our budget proposal before to the county and the first thing

013they did was take it out because it's onetime funding right so the 16 million you you'll if we if we I I it would be very surprising to me that we would reject $2.3 million um but if we so if we don't reject it we would have to include 16 million at year end to to bring it up to the level we need okay thank thank you uh yeah um Mr M I can attempt to address your other question earlier on um so the County's total revenue increase is about $255 A5 million um of which 125 million um is is slated for schools it's 118 million for the school operating support and then 6.7 million for Debt Service um and then when you look at what's left after the funding they're providing to schools there's

014$118 million um in additional revenue for the county for that they've also got dispersements related to and then they've got $12 million unallocated um of which they've set aside 6.5 million for tourism and then they have an unallocated balance of about 5.6 million um so their budget you know expenditure wise um they have 118 million that they're kind of increasing their budget so even even though the one of the slides that I saw earlier earlier today you know showed that they are a a county presented they were making certain reductions but at the same time they were overall they were increasing their budget request correct that's correct they do have 59.8 million in reductions that's part of that um overall $118 million increase so without those reductions you know they would presumably have $178 million

015increase okay thank you uh one one last question that I have is with a potential gap of this 121 million County Executives you know recommendation and our superintendent's request for us to request from County Board of Supervisors $121 million if we were to translate all the $121 million to a compensation what's the percentage of uh yeah what's the percentage of compensation increase that we were thinking of doing in under collective bargaining agreement that we would not be able to do each 1% is about 30 million 30 million so that's about 4% exactly okay thank you that's what I have at this point it's very concerning on my part thank you Mr Moon and uh Dr Anderson thank you um I I appreciate the information that was shared today in the news and Mr MCD McDaniel

016for sending that to us as soon as it was presented much appreciated uh Dr Reed I know it's early days I know there's lots of moving Parts but how do you want us to how should we be thinking about this information today when you say this information are you referring to the county the County's proposal yes well I think we should view it in the spirit it's intended it is a proposal and as Miss Burton stated it's early days in our process um we also are not clear about what the state will end up allocating um and we still have several months between now and final budget numbers okay thank you just to kind of help to cement that a little bit Miss Burton can you share in the past few years when the Count's

017come in under what has been the increase generally if any from the proposal to the final well I know that this past year that they originally told us that we would get about 75 million and by the time appropriation came around air increase was 165 million or 90 million more okay so that's encouraging information thank you um can you speak a little bit if you know in terms of in The Proposal that was shared this morning by um Mr Hill the impact on their CBA agreements what what were they able to fully fund that and what did that look like what was that I am not uh familiar with their collective bargaining process um uh it was it was stated this morning that they were uh honoring the collective bargaining agreements the second year that

018they had for for those U as of the ad their advertising and what was that percentage uh it's a combination of a of a of a percentage increase and their their Merit and step increases so um I off the top of my head I don't know the answer to that but I know that their second year was not as substantial as the first year of their collective bargaining agreement okay thank you um and going back to the bonus to the bonus I think that's something that I had asked you during the the presentation what I believe I heard from you it would be impossible for us to tease out because we have gone above the S soqs so it's either we make it up or we don't do it at all I mean a decision

019the I don't believe that the legislation contemplates giving a lesser bonus to hourly employees which that's what we have done you know at the lower level the 500 you know dollars for hourly folks that that work a lot of hours and then 250 for those that work very limited hours um a decision could be made not to do that and then it wouldn't be $36 million for the th000 but if it's an S soq position it's I mean how are you going to we all of the S soq positions pretty much we and all School divisions in Virginia we fund more than actually is required so trying to decide who would get the bonus and who wouldn't is challenging at best yeah so there's actually a three tiers there's not doing it at all doing

020it for everyone like we've done or doing it for the S soq positions because we go beyond that can you get us a list of those positions that would be eligible under the state's regulations yeah thank you um I lost oh thank you the other part of my question uh you you mentioned at the beginning of your statements that we have a 7.7 million um decrease crossing guards nurses can you talk a little bit more in terms of the impact of the nurses where do we not have nurses are these school well this is actually the school impact so we have 30 schools that need to have nurses and don't currently and then those positions are going to be wiped away as per the decision today perh well as per the proposal today well this

021is kind of linky um but it says that they're they're going to redesign the school health model and so I guess they believe that if they redesign that that they will be able to eliminate 30 positions we do think that even if they do that that we will remain in compliance with the S soqs because there's an so soq for nurses and psychologists and social workers that's combined um and so we have enough psychologists and social workers that they could take this reduction in nurses and we still would meet the S soq requirement we'd still be in compliance and why will be in compliance and it's not necessarily providing that medical support to students in our schools who would require it there's not a any level of detail here as to what schools how they

022would implement this it's just that they they say they're going to redesign and we'll need 30 less thank you um and Bridge to kindergarten I think I was a little bit surprised to hear that bridge to kindergarten is funded by the county Dr Reed I thought that was on our list when we were talking about summer programming to be cut yeah Dro do you want to clarify that please so it's a great question and unfortunately it's a complicated answer because our funding is all braided together um so County uh funding and school funding uh for early childhood education programs is funded Together part of the expenditures uh go to support County Community Based programs and part of the expenditures that we get from the state and federal government go to support FCPS programs so I

023think what they're saying with that is that they would reduce the amount of funding that we would get from the county um targeted towards Bridge Decay but I haven't seen any proposals on that so I can't really speak more about that I did see a proposal earlier today or got notification I did not see the full proposal about the nursing situation where they're proposing to replace the public health nurses uh registered nurses uh with licensed practical nurses so it a little bit uh lesser level of accreditation and certification I see thank you um and I'll come back to that but just to sh um ask one more question Miss buron with what you've with what you stated earlier which is last year we said we're going to do a bonus and they remove that the

024county doesn't determine how we spend our funds we determine how we present obviously this is our plan but nothing prevents us from moving things around as we see our needs um emerge correct correct but generally accepted accounting principles say that you should not fund one-time costs with one-time um revenue and so they took it out because it's not an Ask of them of recurring dollars it's a one-time cost that we will have to address okay and um Dr Presidio Rich to kindergarten it's it's its own line item it's not just part of the bucket of ask from FCPS that's why it's kind of targeted in this way well I haven't seen anything on this so I I don't really want to speculate too much but that that's one possibility I think once we get more

025information um obviously we'd be happy to share that with the board but at this point I just I haven't seen any proposal from the county yeah these are items that are in the County's Budget on behalf of FCPS so that particular line item is 150,000 and it's not positions so but it's it's braided together so I don't I don't really know the impact okay thank you I I see there's t 10 seconds left I'll have a go back Miss Mir thank you Mr McDaniel for providing this update and it is great to have it soon after but certainly we haven't digested it so colleagues I would like us to consider identifying our Preferred Future because we are doing the same thing and it is not working and I am not going to go through every

026deduction that the county has proposed my Preferred Future is a unified County budgeting process for All County provided services and Facilities so some of my questions are how would we like the budgeting process to unfold for the remainder of this fiscal Year's process and then in the future what information does our board need to know and what conversations do we need to be part of and when to create a unified County budgeting process how do we as a school board want to be partners with the Board of Supervisors how do we want the school division to be included and considered in crafting an annual budget and long-term Financial Health do we want FCPS to manage instructional related and core Mission related activities including Early Childhood bridge to kindergarten school age child care and any other

027program what does the work look like this is a question for Dr Reed to explore the unbraiding of these funds and services and would FCPS implement this work more efficiently I would love as a Next Step not I would love as a out of this conversation today to be able to show up to the Board of Supervisors next week at our scheduled one hour meeting where all 22 of us are supposed to be there or invited to attend I would like us to show up having gotten consensus on what questions or comments we want to share as a unified voice of the board what I'm thinking a lot about is the superintendent executive limitation reports where she has identified change and growth and efficiencies and savings and while I could ask all those questions of

028the County Board I don't think that that's really productive this is I think my 10th year going through the Fairfax County budget cycle and I started when there was an $80 million proposed deficit back in 2015 I believe that given where we are our local economy is very uncertain we've got people losing jobs left right and Center public education is not on a strong footing politically we have our facilities that we know need a lot of attention I I I think it would best serve us to talk about how do we get to our Preferred Future what does that future look like I think it looks like us sitting at the table with the Board of Supervisors far more often and asking to be included in the work so I hope that you will respond

029to those thoughts I'm eager to hear what you have to say Miss Dixit sorry thank you Mr chair budget chair and um I'm actually just uh I'm reviewing this budget presentation from the Fest County and uh yeah it looks like they have given us 50% 51.5% of the general fund dispersement for 2026 but which is relatively lower from the I guess in the previous year we have been seeing a decline and I think now they're kind of maintaining at that number um even though the cost or request from our uh teacher base uh and the need of U with the collective bargaining is much higher now and there's one slide which says superintendent budget request is is largest in terms of like it's the largest request in terms of dollar in history um I just

030want to say this is also because we have the first time in Fest County there is collective burning agreement in place and the teachers have the right to teachers un need has the right to um you know ask for the raise they're looking for um if we do not do this it's uh lot of County um uh staff uh school school uh staff was going going to leave us this is a a fair you know issue and warning I guess um I did want to ask uh miss buron out of this $268 million we had asked for the increase what how much is was going for the teacher compensation in dollar amount yeah 240 with salaries and benefits 240 million so at at this is I think the only um request from you know from

031all of us and is to meet the request this first time in history of Fairfax County and we have CBA and and and all this Fairfax County staff members are really looking forward to this uh budget to be approved and we we definitely are in a in a crunch right now now so I would just keep advocating that we get the in requests met by our staff um and this is I don't know how this going to happen but um I guess we have to move to that goal um thank you so much thank you Miss Dixit and Mr mline thank you sir thank you Miss Burton so I was um pretty surprised to hear the the news about the meal tax um and that um that would be undertaken with such little inspiration um

032as to uh essentially cut a property tax as opposed to do something positive for our community um those who live through the last meals tax work Melanie was certainly a big part of that Mr Moon um and others will recall that you know we worked closely with the Board of Supervisors at that time um to put forward a proposal that made education the core um of that work and um I just I I found it find it shocking that um all that's been thrown aside uh at this point um so I guess the the question I have is um at this point um and I don't know if you can answer this Miss Burton or or Dr Reid um is there anything that we can do to in inject education back into that conversation or

033has that train left the station well it's not includ there's nothing for the meals tax that is included in the county Executives advertised budget so it would be my thinking that everything it's all up for discussion um because it's not included in any form in the a the county Executives advertised budget so I think there's more conversations that can be had about that okay well that's helpful and I think you know to Melanie's earlier point I think we need to come um Med and ready to to have that discussion when we meet with him um and I think to your other point um I think we just need to have one spokesperson uh because we aren't going to be able to all speak at that meeting so that's my advocacy thank you and I will

034kind of to dovetail real quick off of a point Mr mine brought up I'll send around the link once the video is posted tomorrow so in your free time you can go back and kind of watch the conversation around the meals taxs in particular it was a very interesting and insightful so I'll send that around tomorrow uh Miss Anderson um thanks for the information so I want to say that I I believe strongly that we're at a Tipping Point with property tax in our County um as a continued funding mechanism so I kind of understand where the Board of Supervisors is with this not to say that it's not disappointing to hear um what they came back with but it's also not unexpected based on what we've heard so far so I do want to

035keep that in mind I agree with Miss Marin that we need a new path forward in terms of how we're going to do this moving forward um we have to change our model we have to stop in business as usual which is where we are now and we have to stop allowing ourselves to be pitted against each other based on the way the system is set up and we are loud voices and we can work to change the system and so I would very much like us to go to the Board of Supervisors next week as partners in this that we understand where they're coming from the same way we hope that they understand where we are so I think that that's the only path forward here um Miss Burton I did have a question

036for you in addition to our EFC erfc program which I understand um provides us a different benefit for our staff than other other localities do I've long since guessed that we likely have more staff in our schools than other area other divisions around the state which is why we have more s soq you know more people in those S soq positions and so I guess my question is have we ever done any analysis to determine that as a potential you know we I've talked to a lot of teachers that say well I'm going to go to this other location because I get I'm going to get more money and I said well please make sure that you're looking at the Staffing numbers in the school because all of that comes from somewhere like if we're

037not paying people more money it's likely because there are more people and so um have we ever done any analysis on that we had we we you may have um you may remember that we had ERS do a staffing um study in February of 22 I think and that's online on board docs where they did a comparison of air Staffing standards um the state of course also frequently looks at that and my understanding is all 132 divisions in the Commonwealth exceed the S soq the S soq is considered to be the bare minimum gotcha but you're right if you go work in Prince William you are going to encounter larger class sizes than you would in Fairfax right so we we have a tradeoff and I think that we again if we're looking at all

038of the partners that we're sitting down at the table with I do think we need to be honest about what our options are when we get to the point because we're about to have more difficult conversations in terms of our funding moving forward potentially and so I would very much be interested in figuring out the path forward on those conversations too so that we can H our our primary goal here is is not all I mean obviously our goal is to make sure that our staff are well taken care of and acknowledged for the work that they do with our students but the end goal here is to make sure our students are educated and so we've got to figure out a path forward on that as well so I just I just want us

039to make sure that we aren't going in next week ready for battle I want us to I want us to lock arms instead of being in adversarial position so thank you and miss lady yeah I I uh agree with my colleague Miss Marin and Miss Anderson um having said that I do think it's frustrating sometimes to look at how PowerPoint is laid out and how somebody who's not quite in the know would interpret said PowerPoint um and I'm looking particularly at the county compensation slide that's in their budget uh PowerPoint regarding a cost of living of 2% increase and that's for you know sort of I guess non bargain units but if you look under each of these there's performance Merit and Longevity increases under almost every category um and we have not been doing

040steps um we don't you know we've established the top of our teaching scale is about $50,000 less than the top of the Prince William County teaching scale and my my point in this is we've done across the board I do know the collective bargaining moving forward does increase steps and a lower overall percentage increase but I just want our public to understand that when you look at 70% that's not 7% That's not greedy okay it's not greedy at all in terms of of cost of living it's it's and and the fact that educators are the most educated underpaid profession in in in certainly in this country not in every country a lot of countries that rever this work um but I just want to you know bring that point because we don't have Merit pay

041if we did we wouldn't all collectively be trying to educate all the K the children in the in the building there was a point when there was Merit pay and I think it ended about the time I came in into the system so I think it wased in the late ' 80s and that's because it was competition and you didn't want competition right I don't want to be a best practice person who might be doing something very effectively and not share it with my colleagues because I want more money um I mean we're not in a position to do Merit pay um and I think our you know our communities just need to understand that um and same with performance you know I mean that's the same thing I mean you know just because you

042get exceeds across the board in an evaluation and someone else gets meets that doesn't mean anything monetarily um and and so I just want to bring that up I also think it's um my next question is and this is an assumption that um assuming which based on looking at this that we're not going to get exactly what we need um although I find it interesting that the board of super well the County's increase is 118 million but the increase for us is 125 million but we're incredibly different in size and scope I mean to just to put those two numbers next to each other is just incredulous from my perspective and we do need to work with them but that's an interesting budget point for me where they claim reductions in places but then their

043overall increase to themselves is 118 million compared to us for 125 my question though is assuming we're going to have to cut that goes back to the bargain table correct as to how we would do that so the final budget decisions of course rest with the board uh and if if we're not able based on the transfer from the county to meet our um collective bargaining agreement then that would trigger a reopening um in that agreement if that becomes part of the calculus to achieve the budget so to my colleague's point regarding class sizes hypothetically I mean I would not want to vote to raise class size because the impact it has on a teaching faculty but that could be something that's bargained to maintain the percent raise I don't want to discuss this evening

044what might or might not actually be bargained because that's something reserved for the bargaining table but I do know that there will be likely uh quite a bit of conversation as this process evolves and we'll continue to provide data to support um the conversation as it evolves okay thank you I guess the better point was to just reiterate my colleague's point that our class sizes I think are better than most of our surrounding jurisdictions and we'd like to keep them that way and Miss seis moiser thank you and I know this just came out today the county meeting was just today so there's time to digest and and discuss it um I I wanted I agree with my colleagues that I think we need to figure out a way to work collectively and collaboratively with

045our County Partners I think we all have the same goal to do what's best for our County and for our school system um so I think there's a lot of room there in the process of how we can be collaborative having said that I I also think that we need to balance that with the state in the state constitution the Mandate that the school board runs the schools right and so we just need to find a way where we make sure that the management of the schools the governance of the schools rests with the school board and work collaborating with our County Partners who I also know are strong suppor is of public education but there is a balance and when you sometimes do things when you combine things a lot it may muddy those

046Waters in terms of who's really making the decisions for a system so just things to think about as we pursue this path of maintaining our control as per the state law and also working collaboratively I wanted to put that in the air um I'm wondering and I'm just going to toss this out as an idea as I'm listening where I'm hearing you know we have one hour to meet next week and there's a lot of us to speak and can we speak with more coordinated voice and I haven't even spoken to our budget chair about this but I'm wondering if there's a way that we can put out maybe asking for feedback and having some joint remarks that can be delivered by the budget chair or budget chair and vice chair doesn't mean that others

047can't speak but it would perhaps help at least gather some thoughts that we all want to share that that we don't have to each individually say them so just something to think about if you want to comment on that's fine and we don't have to do it I'm just tossing out an idea to make us a little more coordinate in our remarks towards the county so beyond that I look forward to digging into this um I know this is sort of the beginning of their process as well so there may be changes coming um as far as the meals tax I do hope some of the funding for the meals tax will go to help fund additional Services whether it's for the schools um and I think we could also maybe next week talk a

048little bit about where we have found efficiencies and where we have found um where we also working in partnership with the county to recognize that we can't keep putting pressure on the um real estate taxes and we're also doing our part to find our efficiencies might be part of the conversation next week thank you thank you um I'll take a brief turn then we'll do a two-minute go back round um when I heard this number this morning there there was some concern and and concern not just on the impact to our our public school system because as we all know sitting around this table a deficit of a shortfall a gap whatever you know word we want to phrase of $120 million there's not many levers that we can pull to make that up I

049mean pay class sizes even if we start digging into programmatic reductions it's going to be few and far between that we could actually come up with um but I think my bigger concern or at least a concern of similar size was on slide three of the county executive's presentation um where he talks about the uncertainty regarding the national economy because this budget is based on numbers that were promulgated last fall late last fall but last fall nonetheless and as we almost by the hour see news of of reductions to the Federal Workforce whether it's federal employees or contractors or those Associated Industries um it it's probably going to get worse and that's going to have significant budget ramifications not only in future years but as we go through this process throughout the rest of the

050winter into the spring um so that's something that I'm keeping in the back of my mind which duve Tails into a comment Miss Anderson made the Baseline the the budget right now the county executive is proposing averages a $638 tax increase on the average homeowner which some people will tolerate that we know that some people won't um so I I I try to stay very conscious even though that's not our decision uh we're still elected leaders in the county so I try to keep that in mind as well um and I think you know at the end of the day please call your supervisor and and talk to them I I try to talk to as many of them as I can but please uh help me out and and and pick up the phone

051and call your supervisor um because having being able to have those conversations uh to miss mirin's point it really puts us as partners at the table and that's going to be very important not only this year but going into the future uh so with that we'll do go back and the first uh Dr Anderson oh I'm sorry uh chair frish your hand is up for your first round chish you're muted so we're not hearing you can he hear us we did a mic check we did a mic check all right will'll sidestep Mr fr uh here FR your hand is thank you I appreciate it um I'm partying like it's 2020 with Co over here so I appreciate uh the allowance to speak virtually you're muted so we're not hearing you I'm not muted on

052my end we can hear you I'm here we can hear you can you hear us app okay we're having technical difficulties let's um we'll let it figure this out we'll can you all hear me now yeah yes we're back sorry uh all right um Dr Reed in our previous budget conversation you talked a bit about uh the savings and efficiencies that we found um and that this budget reflects including I I think the county has said that they've found $60 million in efficiencies and maybe you could address the the 50 million on our end and the other work that's being done I think it's important to mention that when we're having this conversation yes sir we have identified um those I think were in the neighborhood of $15 million uh that we do not have

053in this year's budget that was in a previous budget we also have um a chart actually that shows how much money our budget has saved over the last several years um and Miss burden I think will be uh providing that uh shortly we can certainly have it to the board prior to the uh joint meeting with our Board of Supervisors Miss Burton do you happen to have those notes in front of you maybe you can look at those while I'm uh commenting but I do think to your point uh Mr frish we're going to work to make sure we enumerate U those cost cutting measures and we continue to look at efficiencies um within our budget to make sure that we're being um thoughtful stewards of the public monies thank you and as to the

054conversation from my colleagues um uh I would be supportive of coming up with uh something more Collective to share at the meeting um to make the conversation more fruitful thanks thank you and uh lee did you have a follow on I I did um if you look in the approved budget document in the appendix is always a pretty lengthy SE section about all of the reductions that we've made over the past when does it go back to 2009 um so a long time and the total amount that we have cut from our budget since then is over $800 million and we had a pretty significant cut in 23 is my recollection as well so I I think what we haven't done is talked a lot about those cuts and but they um have certainly been

055verified and I think we need to I think several board members have asked for us to uh surface those perhaps and enumerate those more thoughtfully but uh we continue to um try to do more with less so um I know we'll be able to provide those numbers uh Mr McDaniel thank you and uh go back and we'll keep it two minute you're gonna do yeah yeah you're on the list uh the first one was uh Dr Anderson Follow by Mr Moon thank you we'll be super quick as one of board members who've asked for those um numbers in terms of our savings Dr Reed when do you anticipate we will have that information I don't know when our next um budget meeting is or work session well we have the uh macro numbers what we

056are working on is the enumeration um of the specifics like program pieces but we do have the numbers so I would think within the next week we could have that information for you okay thank you um the other thing that I think we should raise in this conversation with the Board of Supervisors and I do lend my support to having a an organized discussion um rather than being in 50,000 different directions because you know the climate is Bleak I I do appreciate you know what's happening in our area we have a lot of federal employees who have lost their jobs so there's a lot at stake here but we also have to also raise in this discussion and I don't know if this is how we're going to get those topics you know the potential

057of the impacts of Our Own federal dollars you know that is going to be something we would have we will have to deal with if that occurs that I hope we can raise in this conversation with the Board of Supervisors I mean granted they might be in a similar position but we still need to instruct our 180 plus th000 students I lost the number here um that's all thank you Mr Moon followed by miss m I guess this goes more to uh you know chairman U Mr McDaniel uh that we'll adopt our budget on Thursday and then we do not make a presentation I mean we have a join meeting with the County Board of Supervisors next week next Tuesday but after that uh we waited are we just basically waiting until we make a

058present oh I take that back we make a presentation to the County Board of Supervisors even though they already know our request on April 22nd and County Board of supervisor make a decision on transfer to us on May the 6 that's their markup day this a markup day I'm hoping that if we if we must to deal with a gap in the magnitude of $121 million that we do schedule for work sessions amongst us and have a discussion about potentially how we going to address the Gap so that by the time Board of Supervisors has to make a decision they will know that what kind of cuts the the school board may have to Institute whether it's going to be program class size compensation I mean we don't have to make those decisions but what

059could be potentially be done I think you probably remember Mr McDaniel because you're working on the county side in those days uh that uh you know Schoolboard routinely had those discussion and present it to the County Supervisors to to let them know that these may be the consequences yeah and on that so yes we have our joint meeting next week the board will advertise the rate which is many people know caps the maximum Revenue uh based on the highest advertise rate uh so I think at that point that would be probably the best timing to have maybe an additional work session once we have a better kind of understanding of what that Max Revenue number is going to look at so I will work with the chair to schedule more um and I'll also work

060with the chair to come up with some uh either a joint statement or some talking points that we can share around for our joint meeting next week thank you uh Miss mirin I thank you colleagues for sharing your thoughts and support for working together I appreciate and would love to have the budget chair and vice chair share remarks but I would like us to get more pointed into what are our asks um not just remarks but asking for specific things so I've kind of outlined two categories of asks one of them is to meet together regularly what does that look like for now until the budget vote is it the budget committees is it the superintendent and the county executive what does that look like the second one is to start creating agendas where we're

061looking at paths to consider to improve the budgeting process slash create more Revenue so that's things like discussing discussing setting an established percentage that's going to annually be transferred so we could stop wasting our time with this discussion of if it's 10% less or not um we can all plan better too when we know what to expect exploring the revenue generation options for our facilities whether that's the bond uh public private partnership all those things that we were going to talk about on May 6th they have the financial knowledge for that what kinds I'd like to know what kinds of financial analysis is happening by agency we do our own we do projections on our student um populations let's share that working together on collective bargaining you know let's let's do that more effectively I

062think we could take visits to our schools and show them what's happening we could also visit some of the county facilities but you know I go to libraries quite a lot um and also what about our plans to get the money from the state because Mr McDaniel you mentioned it's about $600 more per taxpayer I'm recall Mr McKay saying it was over a thousand with that missing jar money I want to say it was 1,200 or 1400 I can't find it so Dr Reed I would love and I'd love again to hear your comment colleagues can we bring to that Board of Supervisors meeting copies of the your executive limitation reports where you have shown those efficiencies I'm particularly thinking of HR of safety things that are common to both of us um and the

063one thing that I will continue to go after though is we are not paying for law enforcement Services we are not going to pay for crossing guards and we will not be you know saddled with that that work that is the County's work to protect adults and children so I do think we can come with uh data uh for that meeting I think we also um maybe can do a synthesis like in a of the El's um although I can also provide those directly it's whatever your preferences are at this point Thank you and uh Miss tickit thank you m Mr McDaniel um I'm just pointing to the comment you made about the third slide from the the uh County budget said the uh the economy National economy our region will get impacted I I

064do understand that um most of our employees um I mean many of our employees are federal workers or working in the Government Contracting space so they're definitely getting impacted however there's a downwards Trend in the housing prices there's already reports on Twitter should not say Twitter but any other channels too but that this downward Trends on the prices of the homes has already started to happen um it may have not reflected in your particular neighborhoods but that's going to decrease the amount of I believe uh amount we pay in taxes uh per year so even that that percentage increase is happening uh it's going to may be actual dollar value it's going to be reduced um that could be the reason the last point I wanted to say is these are we are here for

065the fairfest county children fairfest County um you know employees and people who live here so it's um ultimately these are not uh a separate set of children who come from somewhere else they are all the res son Children of the residents so ultimately we're looking out for them and giving them the best education we can get um they can get in the in the country people move to Fairfax for a reason and and we believe in the v in the uh vision of One Fairfax and I want to say that um at at this time of uncertainty uh with with the what's going on I think we just have to join hands and work together and and just make it a better place for all our students and all our staff members thank you great

066thank you and seeing no others as of 5:59 p.m. the meeting of the budget committee is adjourned part um we are now transitioning from the budget committee meeting to the work session on Middle School start times this February 18th 2025 Schoolboard work session is called to order at 607 p.m. is what I can see with a little light um Mr frish has submitted a written request to attend this meeting virtually from his residents in the Providence District due to medical reasons all those in favor approving Mr fr's request please raise your hand that is Mr Dunn Miss Dixit Miss Maron miss lady Mr Moon Mr McDaniel Miss Anderson Mr M Dr Anderson and myself that is unanimous for those present Mr fris can we please test your mic again Mr Fish if you're trying to

067speak we can't hear you Mr Fish it shows you're muted on our end I'm not sure if it's on your end or but now we can see you but we still can't hear you can we please test your mic again I'm here okay we could we heard you thank you Mr fr I will turn the meeting now over to Dr Reed to for the presentation and then the conversation thank you Miss eore Heiser so this evening um I'm pleased to introduce our chief operating officer Andy muick uh who has been working on this project honestly for over a year and um we're very pleased to provide you a presentation that looks at options uh both the options you looked at in December as well as a new hybrid option that the team has worked hard

068to produce so at this time let me turn the presentation over to Mr muick thanks Dr Reed um just a couple introductions of some uh teammates that are here with me tonight to my left is Dr Tasha prto the uh owner and president of Prismatic uh Services Incorporated our consultant she's been our lead consultant on this project as well to my right I've got uh Paul deandrade our executive director of Transportation uh and have three more teammates in the wings behind you Paul Hatcher our director of administrative services and he that includes Community use in case there's any specific questions there later uh Michelle Phillips uh on the front row over there she's one of our two assistant directors in transportation and she leads the routing team and then Tom Horn on the side over

069here our executive director of Student Activities and Athletics uh in case there's some specific questions I can't answer on that uh with that we'll go to the next slide and I will turn it over Dr Dr PTO for a little bit of background good evening uh I'm just gonna try to put us all on the same page again with some uh bits of background information to make sure that the conversation has some of the same initial facts Uh current situation in the school system just to remind everyone right now middle schools are at 7:30 secondary schools are at 8 high schools are at 8:10 and elementary schools are you know in my notes all over the board from 8:10 to 9:20 uh predominantly from 8:30 uh is to 920 uh the objective that led to

070this project uh just to keep the end in mind uh was to develop an action plan to help the school board attain its goal of starting Middle School at or after 8:00 a.m. while keeping secondaries and high schools at or after 8:00 a.m. and so then um some other things to keep in mind uh we do have evidence that the 20156 Middle School Secondary High School starttime changes resulted in Fairfax High School students getting more sleep but middle school students getting less sleep and we have a couple different um pieces to that uh there was a research study that was published in 2017 drors tempkin and Leen that talked about um sleep uh amount of sleep attained uh looked at different uh eight of the high schools three of the secondary schools and a variety

071of the middle schools uh did some good po pre-post survey work uh one of the things that they found was that fears about sports were not Sports changes were not realized they also found that with the start time change in 20156 your high school students were sleeping for 30 more minutes on average they were going to bed 10 minutes later but they were getting up about 40 minutes uh 40 minutes later in the morning uh at the same time your middle school students were getting less sleep they switched from 8:30 8:00 to 7:30 and they were getting 15 minutes less sleep and during that as part of that study they were reporting more daytime sleepiness and more struggles to stay awake we also had a memo that was provided to Fairfax County in 2018 on

072the overall results of the multitude of studies that were done by various researchers as a result of the 20156 changes and that also found uh middle school students were getting a loss of sleep of about 30 minutes in some cases uh and 15 minutes in other cases depending on which uh whether they were secondary or at a middle school so we have evidence that the changes that were made in the last time around in the case of the high school students moving them to a later start time had its intended effect high school students were getting more sleep uh the unintended effect of the SEC middle school students going to an earlier start time was that they are were getting less sleep then in in order to provide some context and it's it's uh part

073of appendix C that Prismatic submitted uh in the draft report uh we did do an update of the literature uh you know the the report that was provided to The District in 2015 16 2014 for blueprint included a literature uh review and some results of that we sought to update that as well as to look at specific impacts on Middle School students and so we've got a number of pieces in appendix C we just provided to you the the abstract and uh some conclusions from those studies I'm going to run through them really briefly just so we all have some of the same research in mind for athletics uh we've got three different studies in there ranging from let's see 2017 uh down to 2014 that increased sleep duration uh for and increased quality of

074sleep for adolescence makes for better athletes it reduces injuries uh and increases athletic performance uh looking at other physical impacts we included a couple different studies on the role of uh poor sleep for adolescence and later onset use of alcohol um there was a really interesting study that started with middle school students measured them over the course of four years and those with uh poor sleep habits in year one uh increased their odds of drinking by year four uh which was when they're in high school uh we also o have a a couple of studies in there that talk about insufficient sleep among middle schoolers and early adolesence leading to uh more frequent soda consumption and less frequent vegetable consumption as well as uh precursors for obesity couple of studies that looked at that uh

075and in several of those studies they were able to tie it to uh earlier school start times leading to the loss of sleep moving out of physical outcomes uh and into uh school performance outcomes uh there are a couple of studies in there ranging from 2015 to 2022 that talk about less sleep for middle schoolers resulting in lower School attendance higher out of school suspensions uh multiple uh outcomes uh in terms of tardiness uh being correlated to lower lesser sleep and or earlier start times for middle schoolers as well as negative health effects mental health effects uh looking at academic uh there were a number of studies included in there that talk about the impact of Middle School start times on academics uh there was an interest really interesting one done in 2012 which looked

076explicitly at middle school students in Wake County North Carolina and it's interesting because that's also a very large school district and they looked at the variation in academic performance uh with uh day of school start time as the uh variable and they found a 2% gain when middle school started later uh and that was on math scores and so I think that that that was compelling um another one that Associated earlier school start times with less sleep and also lower academic performance that was a 2017 study and then finally you know one study that um I think speaks to some of the concerns that were raised in some of the forums is if we end up changing Elementary School students to earlier start times you know what what is that what is the impact there

077and there was a a 2021 study done by Dr and others uh that really actually looked at that and and looking at a longitudinal study large scale representative uh they looked at elementary school start time shift from 9:00 a.m. to 8:00 a.m. and they found that that had no impact on Elementary School students sleep or daytime sleepiness so that butresses some of the earlier research that we've seen that earlier academic start times for elementary students do not result in lower academic performance and so lots packed into the the one piece of appendix C that is the literature review the other part of appendix C is the case studies and then a couple of other points that um we think that are important to keep in mind nationally 66% of middle schools already start at 8

078A.M or later based on the most recent data that we have and then finally what led us to this point uh we've received substantial uh Community input in from a variety of ways uh one one of the the spring Forum attendance across the multiple iners and the one online Forum had over 700 attendees our surveys in the fall had 5,400 student responses uh 88,200 parent responses and 1400 uh staff responses in addition we did a spring survey of bus drivers in attendance that had 600 responses so we've had substantial input that led us to the development of the options that were provided to you in December and then the subsequent uh additional option option later thanks Dr PTO uh we're on the next slide option summary um I just want to take a minute to

079go through this uh slowly since uh you know we saw it back in December uh we've got a a new option in there C2 and just wanted to take a minute or two to walk through it just to make sure we uh have that uh fresh in our mind for the discussions um so on the left side you can see our current uh School SK start time option or schedule uh option A has Elementary going first uh midd secondary going second Middle School third and then High School fourth it's got a runtime of 90 minutes and that's relative to our current runtime of 110 uh and it could be no cost or zero to 25 buses or0 to $1.8 million uh option b has part of the elementary school the 8:00 start time is going

080first then second and high schools both both at 8:30 uh heading back for middle school at 9 and then the final group of elementary schools fourth uh option C and that and option b also has a 80 minute run time 30 minutes less than what we currently do uh 20 to 30 buses and 1.4 to 2.1 million uh option C is again the 8:00 group of Elementary going first uh secondary and high school sticking together at 8 :30 going back to the elementary school for the 9:00 run and then getting middle schools at 9:30 C2 is an iteration that Dr Reed referred to that we had asked uh Dr PTO and her team to take a look at after December um it has a 90-minute run uh c c has a 90-minute run uh and

081it was you know cost neutral to 1.1 million and potentially 0 to 15 buses uh the reason we' asked for the iteration was uh as I've mentioned once or twice already our current runtime is 110 minutes uh we in transportation were were not as confident in the ability to get down to an 80 minute U run time to shave 30 minutes off of it Dr PTO and her team have a lot of confidence in our routing team which I do as well uh and the new uh Tyler routing system that we're implementing uh right now as we speak but we liked C2 and we just wanted to have a run one time that maybe we we felt more confident in which led to C2 with the elementary going at first at eight the first group

082of them the uh secondary and high school staying second at 8:30 uh back for elementary at 9:10 and then middle schools at 9:40 uh option D as a reminder that was the option that just had uh moving Middle School's 90 minutes uh later to 9:00 uh and option e was a shift of all schools 30 minutes to the right and option D was uh potentially the most expensive uh 6.4 to 17.3 million if we went with that one Kevin next slide please so uh the office of Transportation recommendation we picked option C2 the new iteration change concentrated at the Middle School uh some incremental changes at high school and Elementary School level uh could be cost neutral uh and it was achievable able runtime in our opinion uh we left option e on there as

083well that was what we had uh recommended back in December uh and we still felt that that was a a suitable option as well if we decided to go that route instead and the reasons for that are listed there below uh the next slide I'm going to turn it back to Dr PTO so she can talk about prismatics recommendations from those Alternatives so I'd like to emphasize that all of the options that we provided to you meet RFP criteria and so for that at that level uh prismatics completely agnostic as terms of which option might be the best um we did note that um the much of the language of the RFP that was used to kick this project off uh mirrored that um of what was used in uh developing the 2014 RFP and

084for that reason perhaps uh the the use of secondary at or after 8:30 was not used in the original RFP um but if you were to you know try to marry both the intentions of the school board in the RFP as well as the body of evidence that indicates that secondary should be at 8:30 or later uh Prismatic would fall into the category of saying that options b c and C2 are all U meet both sets of criteria uh they are all similar in terms of cost um they are all similar in terms of the number of elementary schools that will change start times and just to give you some data on that um we looked at uh the number of elementary schools that would change more or Le change more than 30 minutes either

085going more than 30 minutes earlier or going more than 30 minutes later uh BC and C2 are all pretty much equivalent uh 69 that would have that major change 58 and B 58 and C 61 and C2 uh we then looked at how many elementary schools would be at the earlier start time versus the later start time in each one of the options uh they turned out to be exactly the same that wasn't by design it just ended up being that way you would have 67 schools at the earlier start time and 72 schools at the later start time in each one of those options the average start time change for elementary schools is again about the same um on average uh B option b uh elementary schools go about 18 minutes earlier in option

086C they go about 28 minutes earlier and then in option C2 they go about 23 minutes earlier and again those are all averages um so you know not much of a difference in terms of what might be the change impact for the elementary population uh so we really did not have a a favorite within those but we recognized that that C2 is the the point of commonality uh with uh the transportation department and the COO uh the only reasons we do not recommend a DNE or because they do not meet um AAP and other uh body guidelines for St starting secondary at or after 8:30 next slide Kevin thank you um in this slide we were hoping what we were trying to do was show the alignment between uh the transportation team and Prismatic in

087term of our in terms of our recommendations uh you can see there just laid it out again that Prismatic recommended b c and C2 uh and C2 was uh the recommendation of the office of Transportation uh B andc we did not recommend due to you know potential cost uh and the reduced runtime risk again it just cutting that much time off our current runtime uh was a little bit more than uh more risk than we were willing to take and then option e uh again is just listed on there we had that in December and we feel that's a good backup option as well Kevin next slide please uh and this is the last slide before discussion and this is the options of parallel or sequential uh we recommend parallel with the boundary adjustments in

088school year 2627 um you can see a lot of the uh the reasoning why there but key is it allows the projects to better inform each other uh one disruptive period for the for the community and all stakeholders uh it allows us time to uh fully Implement that Tyler routing system that uh that we have going on right now and getting a year of getting used to it uh and time for proper change management you know good Communications plan with us and the boundary team uh in terms of uh trying to look ahead at potential problems getting some Solutions in there working with the community further engagement uh everything you would have in a in a good change management plan to hopefully make it a a very seamless and smooth implementation in 2627 and that

089is the last slide for the presentation and we can shift over to discussion if that works for everybody and Kevin would you mind putting that uh slide three back up there that's probably the best one to have perfect thank you everybody I'm going to go ahead and start with Miss Marin followed by Miss Anderson thank you this continues to be fascinating work um so you know the goal of this is to allow children to arrive at School better ready to learn and succeed as the result of a healthy night's sleep this is the operational analysis and recommendation this would move the children in and out at more optimal time to meet the objective but we also have parameters that influence how well we can achieve that goal and so I'm interested in understanding more about

090the implications of this operational recommendation on the provision of instruction namely how will the instructional schedule Fair along with such an operational change how will Staffing be impacted based on reliable data not generalizations so first I have questions about the principles input uh which is on page 10 and 11 of the report I'd like to know Dr Reed how their input um and recommendation was considered by you and the office of Transportation Services in developing options and selecting the recommendation of C2 and E so thank you Miss Marin um I know that uh Mr muick uh certainly met with the executive boards for our principal associations and um engaged in conversation so perhaps Mr muick could could share how those recommendations influenced um the recommendations um yes well um we we did have conversations going

091throughout with the different principal associations as we were leading into this U but I would say many of their points were already on the table either from other um venues where we got input or from other constituents so a lot of these were being considered uh already in terms of some of the like impacts on after school um Sports different things like that well I'm specifically you know I'm unclear about how the instructional SP experience or daily student schedule was considered so for instance in some of the principal feedback there's a a comment an elementary school concern about the reading block and lunch time being disrupted or a middle school concern about field trips no longer being feasible is this accurate was this considered the the lunch block is not an independent fixed time spot

092in there so the lunch block would shift with the St and uh finish time of the school um as long as it falls between 10 and two which is a federal guidance same with the field trip the field field trip was not a fixed uh independent block from 9 to one it could float however we needed to float throughout the day so any of these changes did not require any changes of instructional blocks so you wouldn't lose language arts in the morning you wouldn't have an impact on reading later uh and had a little discussion during the Middle School principal's association meeting today about that as well well that's the relief to hear uh the comment on it was bullet number six regarding our staff our most important asset the number of staff that may

093need to shift teaching levels Middle School to high school Etc because of family needs when we moved to early start times for Middle School many staff had to leave to go to high school as a result is there quantifiable data to substantiate the quote number of staff that may need to shift teaching Levels by proposed um implementation time of school year 2627 I don't have that data and it seems that be a bit speculative because we haven't to my knowledge surveyed staff of about what those moves might be but perhaps I know you did do some surveys Mr mck was that one of those um no ma'am it was not um but I I did talk with uh I have been talking with HR William Solomon and he's going to try to see what he

094can pull together datawise from like 2014 15 16 to see if that data shares anything but there's not a lot of why in any of that in terms of transferring why people left why they moved if was it a family issue yeah thanks I also agree that it's speculative and it's also based on 10 years ago when life was very different and who can know you know who's going to plan to have a baby or you know do whatever is going to happen in life um similarly with students having jobs before after school it seems speculative and as a side note this raises a question about parking I mean all of that stuff like do we have data on who needs a parking spot to go so that's beside the point I I also wanted

095to mention so that was my first set of questions my second one is about the schedule considerations which were in the chapter 4 of prismatics um work one of them was about bus ridership you know what percentage of our students ride buses by school level and of those assigned a bus service what percentage actually ride the bus round trip or one way you know and those assigned who don't ride what are they doing I mean this is important to know because if we're providing buses to kids who aren't taking them then that's a different challenge um we also talk about safe routes to school so there are these things I don't see where they're intersecting um you know I have other questions about the neighborhood and Community Services is and neighborhood and Community Services is

096that entirely a department of FCPS or is that also partly managed by Fairfax County it is um so we manage Community use the scheduling of our facilities to all the potential Community users the County's team which is neighborhood community services NCS they are the go between between us and all the different athletic Burke basketball Fairfax County athletic community so you kind of have three groups that are being scheduled in our schools our our schools and their related organizations ptas pto's boosters that's number one then number two is NCS which is the county and all those fcac uh athletic programs and then the third is the non NCS Group which would be Boy Scouts Girl Scouts um religious groups HOAs they come directly into us and we schedu them in the remaining spots got it I'm

097always fascinated about Community use so that's another plug for us to work more closely with the county and also I think it's important to know are we talking about school Associated events like PTA sponsored clubs and even our own Athletics programs as opposed to truly outside of FCPS organizations like sports clubs I think that needs to be pulled out yes ma'am thank you m mayor would you like to go on a go back okay next Miss Anderson by Mr frish and then I want to start by saying that um I think all of us understand the importance of having our kids get the Sleep necessary so I don't think any of us here are questioning whether or not this is necessary for our kids um and I believe that I've said that since the beginning

098to any anyone that I've talked to about this um I am extremely concerned about the fact that we have been advertising this as a middle school start time change when it impacts every single time so we have to stop calling it that we have to start calling it start school start time changes because it is disingenuous for us to call it anything else when we have an entire community of people that are not necessarily just in the two sometimes three grades that we're talking about so I would Advocate strongly for US changing that um in terms of the way that we're discussing this the other thing is was any consideration given to surveying All Families you want me to answer that uh we attempted to do that in the fall of 2024 the surveys were

099designed for All Families um was it distributed to All Families the distri distribution was left to the school system and as I understand it perhaps some miscommunications happened and they ended up primarily being only distributed within the Middle School community so I don't think that we can make I I will just say that I don't think we can make decisions until we actually follow through with the survey as designed so that's one aspect of it the aspect of it is where with the surveys that were conducted were they included in all seven languages that we traditionally do the surveys in they were in I don't remember if it was all seven but we definitely provided at least two other three other alternative languages I would have to go back and check okay um 98% of

100the responses came in in English however okay so that is also concerned concerning to me um I want to make sure that we are moving forward with accurate urate information and feedback from the entire Community because this will affect the entire Community um I have a number of questions here and I'm already on the list for a go back but I will I will say that the other aspect of this um that I'm thinking of and this is just because you mentioned Wake County when I went and looked at Wake County they have not made a decision about their High School start times so yes their middle school start times are later but their High School start times are at our Middle School start times so I think it's somewhat disingenuous also to say that

101when we see the report and things like that and it says 67 like 67% of Middle School start times start later than at the 8:30 um how many high schools start at 7:30 so again we're I I don't want to just keep moving this as a way to potentially look like we're solving a problem but not um I think that we need to make sure that we are going forward in a very concise and straightforward way with all members of the community so that we bring them all with us so it doesn't look like we're forcing decisions down um the other thing that I would like to put out there and I know that there's a huge push from from several communities related to getting this done for next year we are in the middle

102of an of a entire Change Model going on across our County the daycare system cannot support the current change related to what's happening with the go back to work that's go or go back to the office that's that's going on within the federal government and we have zero idea what our traffic patterns are going going to do related to that so I cannot say strongly enough that we should follow the recommendation that we at least need to put this until 26 27 so that we can have more opportunity to take those things into account you're already on the GoBack list Miss Anderson Mr frish followed by Dr Anderson Mr frish go ahead thank you um some questions for Mr muick for a second it's it's very light I don't if that's on our end or

103your end but we can barely he you Mr Fish I think it's on our end if you can give a second we're having to fix between online and in person one second okay thank you for the patience no worries Mr fr can you try again yes is this better hello Mr fr it's not can we can we go to Dr Anderson or will that mess up what you're trying to do unfortun I think we kind of need to hear him so we one second please thank you for your patience as we deal with the technical difficulties I would like my two seconds back I'm just kidding can we reset his time please we heard that we heard that one try again Mr frish is this any better yes that is better a little bit all

104right um and I've just created the infinity screen um Mr muick um once the technology on boarding has completed how quickly after that do you think we'll be able to see whether there are you know increased um efficiencies uh that result from that that might pivot our thinking a little bit here Mr frish that's a great question um I may have to ask one of my teammates here just because I haven't implemented a new transportation system at this level before so I don't know how quickly they may see results I don't know Paul or Dr PTO if you have any thoughts on if I'm not mistaken it's August is when they'll be finished with the installation yes sir the implementation started at the uh very end of January and it should be fully implemented in

105uh by the beginning of this coming school year 25 26 and at that point we'll start we should be as long as the pilot on the mobile data tablets is successful over the summer we should be implementing the mobile data tablets as well so yes we should have the the Imp the Tyler routing system up and running at the beginning of the school year I can pause for the other answer Mr and is yes so I think once we have full techn technology upgrades within the routing software and the MDT will'll be able to fully realize um the efficiency of the routes to include how many students are riding once they tap on and off of the buses so I would say at least a semester um six months after that we'll really have some

106good knowledge done be able to adjust from there okay so like by Spring of the following school year that's correct all right um I think that's good information you know as I've talked to my constituents um I think they're where our board is in terms of um wanting movement on Middle School start times and and start times generally that align with um best practices for for student health um I think there are a lot of questions still out there um received an email from SEPTA uh just today with some questions about how this might impact um the ride times for special education students uh Miss Anderson has raised some good questions um you know looking at the options before us um I'd probably be torn between C and C2 I don't want to push and

107my my constituents certainly don't want to push um uh Elementary start times uh to nearly 10 a.m. um but uh you know um it's not as easy as us uh you know we we simply don't have the funding to do a change that would have little impact um uh you know in any kind of negative way on on all students so um I'm eager to hear the rest of the conversation for my colleagues um and to to continue to gather more information um and uh get some more answers here thank you Mr frish Dr Anderson thank you I'm kind of glad to hear the conversation regarding whether or not this needs to happen because I think the science is irrefutable this is what's best for kids and I'd like for us to Center that and

108every conversation that we have I've said this before on other topics and I know sometimes what is best for kids is definitely inconvenient but sometimes that's what we have to do and I I want to add my core my voice of the course of um getting some more data because there's a lot of information that's been shared that I'd like some more information about um particularly um do we have the any numbers to lead us to um be thinking about how many of our high schools high school students who work or watch their younger siblings have we been able to gather any of that information and any of the forums surveys uh so two-part questions so two-part answer um the youth County the Fairfax County Youth survey which is done almost every year it's an

109outside of Prismatic so this is their data um and their most recent data points for the fall of 2022 indicated that 31% of your grade 12 students had some sort of outside uh employment went to work one hours or more per school day that's on page 4-26 of our report uh the interesting piece about that is that the difference in the percentage of students who worked outside of school during the school day uh if you look at the change from 2014 to the 20156 when we had the disruption there with school start time changes for high school students the percentages didn't change uh the same percentage of students were going to some sort of outside work one hour plus per school day um and then uh the question about the students uh providing supervision to

110uh siblings we did ask that question uh we asked it in the parent survey and in the student survey uh the student survey um we asked it of middle schoolers sorry we may not have asked it a yeah we did ask it oh are you currently responsible for taking care of your younger siblings after school on weekdays at least once per week um at the middle SCH School 23% said yes uh at the secondary school uh 22% said yes we asked the same similar question of parents um do you rely on your middle schooler to take uh do you rely on your middle school student to take care of younger siblings after school at least once a week um these are largely uh Middle School parents who may also be parents of other student students

111because of what I said earlier about the distribution of surveys they did we did have representation of parents at elementary middle school and high school but they probably came into the survey as Middle School parents and so 15% of them said yes so my conclusion was at least some middle schoolers think they're responsible for more than they actually are uh but 15% thank you um my community has been parts of Fairfax County that's been very vocal on this and I'm particularly proud of that because I think when I first got on this board it was that we weren't hearing from the Mason District on the things that were important to them so for me that's a huge um shift and that may be primarily driven because we have the three middle schools where it's a

112three-year experience not a 2-year experience and so the timeline has been especially important to this community and so one of the questions that I wanted to raise is the RFP when it was put forward was to help with a 20 was to support a 2425 5 implementation what happened between the RFP which was very clearly articulated to support that that timeline and now we could essentially be speaking about well we're not essentially we're speaking about a 2627 timeline Dr pra do you know what what the delay was answer part of that from what we see um the RFP was issued in January of 2023 um which included you know being done by September of 2023 um it was not actually awarded to Prismatic until uh the end of September end of October 2023 and so

113when I sat down for a a meeting with then the executive director of Transportation you know we had a a conversation but I'm not sure how we're supposed to finish a month before award um but that at that point we adjusted the timeline to fit where we were um we did have a conversation and and Mr Deandra was there about you know do we need to be done in time for a potential 2425 um because that's what the RFP said and at that point um that was October um that was when we found out that the executive director of Transportation was retiring would be retiring at that point wasn't certain as to who would be the executive director and I'm sorry I don't remember if if you had started by then or not I started

114at the end of October y check so there was a leadership transition period there but the the the the procurement process um took from January until octo beginning of October essentially um which made it a little difficult to meet made it impossible to meet there sure Dr V can you speak to that a little bit in terms of the procurement not getting to I guess the vendor until September 202 three yeah our procurement processes are quite thorough um and I can certainly get back to you on what happened in this case the letting of an RFP um the bidding of the RFP the um cyber and data security agreements that need to be maintained so I can certainly get back to you with that I don't have the details but I do know that our

115procurement is a thorough and often lengthy process thank you um can you speak a little bit to how the options could potentially impact Athletics and if you can also compare this to and I don't know if you're able to do that but with the high school change that was done in 2015 because I know the concern around Athletics was very present then as well I can answer you with data from the Fairfax County Youth survey again um Pages 410 and 411 they ask the questions um if you participate in extracurricular activities the exhibit 46 is School School extracurricular activities which would include Athletics as well as other things uh exhibit 47 is extracurricular activities outside of school both of them ask if you're participating with them on a school day and in each case you

116can see that there was no decline in participation from the fall of 2014 to the fall of 2015 and then you look at the fall of 2016 just to see if the trend is going to hold really very little difference in fact the let's see the 12th grade participation from fall of 2014 to fall of 2015 went up by three percentage points probably not statistically significant but it did go up um and what we do see in these data is that you know things are are different postco um but that that is you the schedule change does not seem to have impacted that um we did talk to uh various representatives of um uh external organizations as well as Athletics as part of this project uh and generally you know received assurances that they would

117be able to adjust depending on uh What uh options were selected uh some things may be a little trickier than others but that they would be able to adjust thank you and I also appreciate I let me go back a little bit I really appreciate this report it was very thorough there were a lot of pages to be read and I I definitely appreciate the details um but on one of the pages that I can't recall you talked about um our neighboring schools and their start times now L County full disclosure I work there um their time was Elementary first middle and high school and I can't recall what time the the high schools let out it's after 4 did we have any conversations with cter parts there Mr muick in terms of that impact

118on any Student Activities or all of the things that were all of the variables that we're looking at uh the Lowden County coo didn't have any any to report negative he said hey it all worked out I think their High School I was looking for the time their High School finishes at um gosh I want to say 4:30 but no that's not right not that late but no he did he didn't have anything like hey it was uh a failure we don't like it it's it's been positive okay I I see there's nine seconds left I'd like a go back please I got you down thank you um miss lady followed by Miss St John cunning Mr Maven then Miss Lady thank you um so first of all I want to thank board leadership for

119um bringing this to a work session um uh very very quickly after our last session um and I also want to thank um staff for the ongoing collaboration um with um Dr Pau and um Prismatic um it's great to see that you guys have really taken in um and internalize the the work that came to us previously um and tried to find a a a no cost Solution that's um similar um I think where I stand is similar to what Mr fris conveyed is that um my preference would be option C over C2 slightly um just because it keeps um keeps times more more a little more reasonable um but again I appreciate the the the options there um so building a little bit of on um what Dr Anderson said um and what I

120said at our PR previous session I do think we need to um for the community sake um come to a conclusion as soon as possible ideally tonight um with a consensus on moving forward with this um because otherwise we're just we just continue to spin wheels um without the community having any understanding if we're actually committed as a board to to doing this um so again I'd like those leading the session to um consider um taking consensus to the board that that we're committed to making a change we don't need to know what the change is um but that's what really what set us up for Success um back in 2015 is that um we we took the strong step of making that commitment and that helped Propel us forward to a solution that the

121community appreciated um ultimately I think our job um and our work is to get to yes on this um and if not tonight then then when so um just to a lot of questions have been raised and and colleagues are are are well positioned to raise them um but what I would say uh ultimately is that uh when you make a change like this things adjust things adjusted very well in 2015 Without Really um any substantive Community concerns in the years that followed um your your daycare adjusts your sports adjust um the community moves forward uh with what the board decides um so I I will just leave it at that for now thanks thankk you miss lady uh thank you and uh again thank you to staff uh this is a lot of work

122uh and it's a great report um but I do want to Echo some of the things my colleagues have said this needs to be uh titled moving forward K12 start times because it's impacting K12 um I continue to have um a lot of cognitive dissonance around the fact that we did not survey all levels and I think that's essential and it has to be in the six most spoken languages and I think there needs to be some Outreach to help people complete it um because it is not un we typically get a a very high percentage Almost 100% of our responses are from english- speaking members of our community um I think we also have to keep in mind and some of these questions have been asked but I'm just going to reiterate them the

123Staffing implications of this um it's real because uh people work majority of people who work in fers County do not live here and they have have adjusted to this the start times for their children in a different system um it's also one of the reasons why we work so hard to work with other jurisdictions when we do a calendar every given year regarding what we're going to do for holidays um but I think it's essential and I do have a question I have two um Community School use do we have an moou regarding access like are they guaranteed a per percentage of time because if some of these shifts happen they're going to lose use miss lady there are not guaranteed a specific amount of time the way the scheduling happens is we schedule all

124the school related and school organization um items on there quarter by quarter once we have that locked in then we give to the county the access to the schedule to fill in the open blocks are they aware of this conversation I'm looking at my teammate back there Paul and he's shaking his head yes so yes they are hey Paul if you want to you got to grab a mic right there by you my understanding is this my understanding is Prismatic did interview NCS uh colleagues about this project that's true and so they were then provided that there might be Elementary children not getting out till or middle schools not till 4:45 and 2 hours of after school at the time that we interviewed them we had not developed options we asked them open-ended questions about

125what if it changes by this much what if it changes by two hours you know how to we asked them a lot of open-ended questions because that was done in the spring and and summer we did not have options at the time specific options I think we're going to have to do that it impacts a lot of people a lot of parents spend a lot of money for their kids to play on teams and they need access to fields and gyms um I have a question for Mr horn um I'm sitting here looking at Stonebridge High School's bell schedule and they dis Miss at 418 I think that's an average thing for high schools in Lowden County um and it's it was my understanding at the time that several of them started running practices before

126school is that the case and if in your counterparts in Lowden County was this smooth sailing for them to shift to such a late uh release time for high schools in terms of Athletics yeah thank you for that question um the I think as Mr Mick alluded to um or Mr mavan the Athletics will flow to the times that are available so lden County did see um some experience with individual schools or and and teams based on coaches availability gym availability wanting to access schools for practice before school um it has not been a a massive thing it's not like all freshman basketball teams have moved to the morning um but it becomes an option for flexibility um in addition the 418 start time for them um much like us doesn't necessarily impact their commuting

127um but they do have some of smaller schools which do compete outside of the loud Cy area which do require some early dismissals from school in order to reach again Freshman Basketball times or JV baseball times um you know 5:30 starts those kinds of things um uh A A A Time For Us after 4 p.m. um you know and we have shared in other forums that most of our high school programs can't access buses until 4:45 or 5:00 now uh because high schools are not the last to dismiss um if a schedule was created where high schools were the last school to dismiss that time probably wouldn't need the shift we would still have buses for our kids at 4:45 or 5 o'clock thank you um and I should have said at at the outset

128um I 100% want kids to get more sleep you're talking to someone who is not a morning person at all um and it was awful for me all those years until we shifted for me to even get to work on time so I appreciated the swap with middle schools um and again I think it was more seamless because it was simply a swap I mean so there is repercussion we're back at the table because it's not the appropriate time for middle schools to start so I don't want to say that that went smooth sailing and we haven't heard any repercussions we're sitting here because of the fact it's not smooth sailing um so again I I have consternation over unanswered questions data we don't have properly uh advertising this so that the that that you

129know because again once this went out as a work session my email flooded with people against us doing anything and I hadn't heard that at all I had only heard communic participation at the actual board meeting so I didn't expect that um I'll take a go back thank you Miss Lady Miss St John cunning followed by Miss Dixon so I'm going to be doing some follow-up too because at at our first session I did ask about the survey and who answered it um what the percentages was what the languages were um uh and you noted this on page 22 you said other than middle school students and middle school staff the number of fall of the Fall 202 for survey responses from students parents and staff were less than desired and may not be representative

130of the total population you went on to say well unfortunate Prismatic does not believe these factors substantially weaken the analysis presented herein uh so my question to you is what is the confidence interval that leads you to believe that the analysis is statistically significant with this kind of surveying work confidence intervals would not be advisable because I have no control over who chooses to respond and who does not choose to respond uh we did not do a targeted sampling process like you would do in order to be able to provide statistical significance assurances I think that in terms of of ensuring that we got a broadly representative set of viewpoints we have definitely covered that if you look at the survey results there are people who are adamantly against making any change uh there are

131people who want any change at all and there are people who are very specific in terms of what they want uh it was reassuring to get uh a decent number of parents who again had middle school students but then also had uh Elementary or high school students and were able to respond to those questions that were intended for all Elementary and high school parents uh we did get great results from the middle school students themselves uh and to to be fair we were not seeking to survey elementary students the intent was Middle School and High School only I didn't want anyone to think that we were attempting to survey elementary students we don't feel that that's generally appropriate uh and so you know the the one place where it would have been nice to really

132get um more input would have been from uh Middle School U staff other than Middle School staff um because recognizing that uh with the exception of option D which we did provide to you as a way to make no change except Middle School uh the other options require change at all levels um that is something that could be addressed if they if we decide to do another round of surveying work the instruments are ready to go um and and then we could add those data points in uh so could you tell me what parts of the population are missing from the analysis so Elementary uh staff staff High School staff are not included in this because we did not get res survey responses from them uh and then parents of only Elementary School students would

133be an interesting group to hear from it would be nice to hear from uh those whose uh who chose to answer in a language other than English um I don't know that we could have done anything more than we did providing it in multiple languages already um but maybe some intentional uh additional Outreach efforts by the the school system may get us some more responses there that would be good to hear so I do agree with my colleagues that say that this should be a k through2 um operation not just middle school because it does impact everyone within that range um I'm I'm speaking from um Elementary School uh from an elementary school perspective and having some of those late start times and knowing what it is for staff when school goes out was late

134and waiting for the late bus and having staff members there at five or six I've been one of those so I know what it looks like down on the ground I think that we need to survey everyone because it's going to impact everyone completely on board about changing the Middle School start time completely on board about the importance of sleep for everyone including as one of my colleagues said us adults um so I'm completely on board with that I think we don't have enough voices heard I think that we can get more of this information as a family liaison I know how we can get the these as a previous family Leon I know how we can get these surveys out to our underrepresented population and get those results back and I think that those

135voices are often voices that are not at the table I think that those are the voices that rely on some of their students to take care of their children and also have child care difficulties our responsibility is to not only ensure that our kids are getting rest and are coming to school ready to learn but also be to be responsive to our constituents and so there in lies the problem and how we operationalize this and I think that is the hardest thing and that is what we are all struggling with is we want it to happen but we want to be responsive and have the best impact it this is going to sound strange but the best impact with the least negative impact on certain populations so I I really want to just emphasize that

136that's where I stand um completely support this effort it's just how we operationalize it I do want to note that on page 67 there was a statement saying that there is no Sunday use of school facilities and that's that's not true so I'd like to have that corrected do you need to go back Miss St John cunning okay thank you Miss Sorry Miss Dixit followed by Mr Moon thank you for the presentation um I wanted to actually speak as a parent here as well today one my son was one of the student who was in the first I guess year which it changed to 7:30 uh a.m. Middle School start time and he was in a AAP program so he had to go to further down middle school for because of that um it would

137uh take 40 minutes in the bus almost to get to the school plus um he was going to the bus stop 6: in the morning 6 to 6:15 and dark it was quite far from where you know from the from the house and he would walk alone cross the traffic and and so forth so I'm totally empathizing with every parent who's in the situation and and I just could not understand why are we in this situation where we letting this 12 years old and 13y old going uh so early in the morning and that to uh in dark so I I want to be decisive I I I know sometimes you have to take some decisions and um I would totally support um any recommendation which are um my my colleagues and everybody uh they

138agree with which actually takes some action um it it is you know we can talk about the all the issues in the world and and everything you yeah there are there going to be problems but at some point we have to do to take the right thing and right now I'm by the middle school students I feel for them because they are the the I think that group we are forgetting about them so I think uh I will ask my colleagues to also think about these 12 13 year olds um who are really struggling at the in their school in the start time um I prefer personally option A um but I wanted to ask uh Prismatic team and maybe Andy that how much uh cost it will incur if we change only the Middle

139School start time to 8:30 or 8:00 p.m. and not change any other I know it's going to cost like I just wanted to know what the number would be so option D only moves the middle schools uh and we selected a an option that wasn't you know noon uh or or 10:00 a.m. for middle schools uh if you went to something later than what we have as 9:00 a.m. for middle schools that estimated 75 to 150 buses would obviously go down um and so but we didn't want to you know to to load the the question but option D looked at just moving middle schools and what that would cost moving them to 9: it only says 9:00 a.m. is it a reason uh why 8:30 was not considered uh 8:30 was more expensive oh

140really okay yeah we were trying to pick something that seemed like a reasonable possibility um and obviously I mean I think looking at the options okay option D if we moov to 9:30 for middle schools it's going to go down uh below the 75 bus threshold for sure uh 8:30 gets very expensive you already have about half of your B your elementary schools at 8:30 uh and then you don't have enough time uh between your 8 and your 810 for your high school and your secondary uh to really have many buses available to then serve Middle School okay in in that case I prefer option e um just because it has no cost on it but I definitely U want some changes instead of like another year of having no change to this Middle School

141uh students so thank you thank you um Mr Moon followed by Mr dun I'm hoping that we'll make some decisions tonight uh whatever they may be uh with us let me start with this question first uh when the a RFP was issued back in November 2022 uh was there a Schoolboard goal State Schoolboard goal to have a middle school St time start after 8:00 was it a state goal or was that aspirational goal or was that um the the RFP itself sir indicated that uh the the scope of work was to devel Vel school start times for Middle School at or after 8: a.m. I understand about that RFP but I am looking at your report on page 21 when it's a November 2022 it says FCP has released on Fe requesting a Consulting form

142to develop an action plan to help School Board of a Fest County Public Schools attain its goal of starting Middle School times onward after 8 am so I'm asking because I was not serving on the board at the time whether there was already stady goal of the Dan board some of the board members were serving on the time probably would remember that could somebody answer whether there was a stady go I I'd be happy to answer if I'm recognized at least share some thoughts if you want to seed some of your time to Dr Anderson that's fine go ahead and start the timer I'll be very quick the last board looked at this issue in 2020 2021 we ended up having to pause because we were in the middle of covid but the intention it

143was a goal that we take care of the Middle School times because it was the second part from what your board did with the high school times okay so that's all various stady call and which we do not have to repeat because that's been a stady call unless this poll wants to reverse that goal again I'm not I'm not in any way in favor of reversing the goal but I don't know whether Mr Mr melin was asking for poll's consensus again to restate that goal whether that is necessary if you feel that is necessary I'll I'll be more than happy to support that but if that is already State go of the school board that's a stady go just when and how that's going to happen maybe so with that in mind I am want

144to ask if the board were to wanted to implement this starting from 25 26 career as oppos 26 27 what's the latest the time we have to make a definite decisions Mr Moon you're asking if we were to if we wanted to implement it this coming fall correct when do you have to make a final decisions byy for your department to be able to implement it can I answer that I am just trying to see whether that's feasible all right can I answer that question from two perspectives however perspect how many from perspectives you have please yes sir um you know from a transportation perspective um making that change um they would be able to do it and they could do it with a a a decision that doesn't leave anybody else a lot of

145time the second perspective is everything that we've heard here tonight in terms of that change management the community um you know maybe getting more input that we we didn't get this first go around in some areas that you know surveys after school things like that I think we need and want that time till 2627 to be able to get all that information and really implement it right and our imple our routing system coming on everything if you just looked at us in a vacuum I don't think that would do the whole greater system the jce it needs I understand I understand I only have 21 seconds left so I'm going to be quick uh uh it sounded as if Mr M you want to have a little more time than us forcing our system to

146implement something starting from the next schoal is that fair yes sir okay I will to go back got you down Mr Moon Mr dun followed by Mr McDaniel um can you please explain what you meant when you were talking about your concerned about runtime reductions uh which is the um the third to last uh row on your option summary there yes sir so if you see the current column there where our run time is0 minutes so the morning run of a a bus that has um its run is going to be picking up uh Middle School doing a high school or a secondary run an elementary school run from start to finish for the system for Paul's group is 110 minutes so when you look at some of those other options on there that shave

147it down to 19080 um that's prismatics confidence in our routing team and in what they expect will gain with the new um routing system that we're implementing uh and my our team um as as confident as we are in ourselves that just seems like a big a big risk cut in 30 minutes um we've seen some other districts do um some much smaller things and not have any success with Tyler routing or other other systems and it was just a little bit um I guess we were just being more conservative than Prismatic so does the shorter run times uh mean uh it costs more to run the school buses like if you run the bus more it's more efficient um and to Shorter run times also mean harder to to have enough employees well it

148comes down to having enough drivers and and buses to cover that uh if you throw out what if you throw on to that what's happening now with more federal workers going back to work and the traffic patterns are going to be different um probably more dense more crowded um it just I we're just not sure on on going after that so just just for a lay person who's not in the transportation field shorter bus runs means greater risk because you don't know if the bus will get to the school on time and be able to pick up kids when they're expecting to be picked up is that right yes sir okay um can you explain on slide four um for option two you says uh for C2 it says change is concentrate at the middle

149school level and I see that you know the middle schools move by pretty much two hours but you still have elementary school and high schools moving by about half an hour so um so what does what does that mean changes concentrate at the middle school level um that's kind of what we felt when we were looking at that option that it was it was um that the main focus in there and change was middle school but you're right it probably covers as Miss Anderson pointed out there's no nothing that is just Middle School there's going to be impacts everywhere can you elaborate more there's a recommendation for a pilot can you talk a little bit more about that cuz I haven't there hasn't been any discussion of that and where could that pilot conceivably happen

150have you had any discussions about specific High School pyramids we have not had any discussions about any specific High School pyramids yet um we thought that that might be an option uh to gain some information on whatever option we decided to go with on the change if we could put that into probably one or two pyramids because there is certain um crossover um in terms of Transportation use by adjacent um pyramid so we hadn't looked at which ones made the most sense yet um just because we had it on there as a potential to maybe gain some Intel moving forward um one of my colleagues mentioned you know conversations with potential user of community use has there been change any discussion with the county about potential impacts on the sac program no sir not yet

151okay I think that definitely needs to happen um so looking at the data like just doing the math um it shows on page uh 2-9 75% of middle school students who were surveyed said they want uh to start between 8:00 a.m. and 8:30 a.m. was that considered at all in developing these options yes we're the primary users of the survey data and we use that as input um you know recognizing that we did provide options that included that twice so the 8 A.M um in option e and the 845 and option A comes close to what they were looking for uh I think that um the open-ended responses of the survey data indicated some similar fears that adults also reflected that you know while I would really really like to start school at 9: I'm

152worried about how that changes everything else in my life uh and so we we took that into consideration as well and and I also see on page 2-14 that 60% of Middle School parents who are surveyed and I I agree we need to survey high school and Elementary but 60% of parents want Middle School start times between 7:30 and 8:30 a.m. and so it just seems like some of these options that we're looking at that are 9:00 a.m or well after 9:00 a.m. nearly 10:00 a.m. uh are well outside the the the ballpark for what both students and parents said so was that was that considered in developing these options yes I I think that what we have to balance is what the public would like to have and what is possible recognizing that one

153of the RFP objectives was to be cost minimal uh to cost neutral if possible uh and then reflecting the greater uh body of research uh one of the things that was pretty abundantly clear in with at least a section of the people that we talked to in the forums was that um there was not a clear understanding of the you know the recommendation to start after 8:30 or the the potential negative out outcomes for their students and so we did provide some options with that I think that the bigger learning point in the preferred school start times questions that we looked at was that there is a a substantial tendency to want the status quo uh and so that was something that we recognized that is is going to be would need to be addressed

154in moving start times um you but the middle school students or middle school parents of middle school students if you look at exhibit 2-3 26% of them did choose status quo and 72% chose something that was later um that was in contrast to some of the other ones where we actually had 24% of elementary students wanted something earlier uh than they currently have and so there is a a body of there there is a population that definitely is status quo and there is a a population that is interested in making a change I and and and and line with that um status quo we have the uh the principles of elementary middle and high schools unit uh jointly recommending that we maintain current start times um expressing severe concerns that we're going to have a

155huge Exodus of Staff um uh and that staff themselves are fearful and upset that that that really concerns me um and it may not have been in the RFP so it may have been a flawed RFP but was there any consultation with child care providers or any analysis of child care availability options uh if we do change especially for both staff and for parents caregivers so one of the things that it was required by the RFP was looking at case studies um and we did do case study work with a number of other school systems that had implemented later school start times essentially looking for what are what are the rocks in the road if you do make a change and Anna Rundle is a great example um and and because it's right next door

156and almost similar in size uh they addressed the child care issue headon as part of their change management process uh they will tell you that one of the things they thought was uh a big uh star in what they did was held Child Care uh fairs to help connect parents with options they were very communicative with uh the providers out there they they have a whole Communications package that their communications director has shared with other Maryland school districts for when they make a starttime change and they reported no problems uh and so I I recognized that and this was brought up in December that child care is a burning pressing concern in this school system in this County um it was uh you know was not brought up as part of our work that if

157we don't think there's enough Child Care slots we shouldn't recommend something uh that was not part of the the the process and and finally I'll just say we're at a time of big changes for a lot of our residents who are federal employees it's very dangerous to implement this disruptive of a change at a time when we don't know what the the scenario will look like uh a year from now for many of our residents well timed Mr Dunn Mr McDaniel thank you um I share some of the concerns about the survey methodology and the sample sizes and the lack of the trans some of the translation um I won't beat up on that too much but we got a letter today from SEPTA I think we all got that letter and the concerns that

158they raised that I wanted to make sure got discussed or at least addressed here is about the from their point of view the lack of data regarding special education students and how that how the bus routing surrounding special education services could be impacted by any of the Myriad of options on the table so if if staff could address that I would appreciate it want me to yes sir I'll start I may need uh Paul to jump in there a little bit but um for the special education um support and runs they have their own um set of buses and systems right so they have 320 buses about 350 um runs in the morning in the afternoon it's some midday stuff uh midday runs as well and it it was seemed it's similar to The Lunch

159Period and um the blocks that we would be able to slide that left or right as well um to to keep that consistent Paul you want to jump in there if I'm getting that right and I'll just jump to add um typically our average uh special education bus route is typically around that 40 minute uh time frame for a bus ride for us sped uh student of course when you have uh very specialized programs that you have to transport from one end of the county to another end of the cter you'll have those isolated incidents when you start to creep up closer to an hour so I think regardless of whatever the times are that you have any any of these options you're still going to have those in instances where that happens because a

160lot of it is surrounded by the availability of programs which is outside of the scope I I I I I appreciate that response I'm hearing information that conflicts with the response and I think it really underscores the need to bring the special education Community further into this conversation um as we continue to go down this route I I doubt we're going to have an answer tonight um but they need to have a seat at the table further as we continue to do this [Music] um the question at hand at least from my point of view was whether or not we can change Middle School start times to later in a reasonable way that's somewhat cost neutral or not a unreasonable cost one of the challenges with outlying six options I guess technically seven options is

161we're going to struggle to get consensus around anything at this board much less in the community because you have so many options on the table the only one of those options that actually does what you know the outset was which was to move start times for only Middle School I think is option D right is that fair okay so if it was just option D versus status quo then I can say all right well do I want to spend $6.5 to7 million or do I not the answer to that right now is no not in this budget environment but Dr Reed I will ask this question um as we have discussed one of the goals of the boundary work that we're doing is to reduce Transportation costs um do we see the possibility that in

162reducing Transportation costs option D at 6.4 to and and 6.4 to 17.3 that's a pretty big Delta can is it can someone kind of dig into that costing number a little bit more sure so the 6.4 million is equated to the 75 buses with the me methodology for costing it out that was provided back in December in that packet uh if you were to ask you know which side do we think it will land on it regardless of um attendance boundary adjustments it'll probably be closer to the 75 than the 150 uh for Contex $6.4 million in a $206.9 million Transportation budget is not a a large uh more I forget what the number is um percentage increase and one of the things that we did do as part of our initial work when we

163sat with board members was to ask us to Define what would be a substantial considered a substantial or not a minimal fiscal impact uh the one number that we did get was around 10 million would start to be a problem and but we wanted to point out that D could could cross that barrier um the thing that is not considered in there is what refinements might take place uh with routing software itself um one of the things that is coming out with the tablets will give you the ability to actually know how many students are riding the bus each day with the idea that you would then be able to dynamically route if if you only have 10 kids out of 75 assigned riding a bus regularly that route should be adjusted uh we were

164able to provide load Factor data based on Spring of 2024 rides uh what drivers reported and that those data indicate that there is room to make adjustments like that which is why I say 75 is more likely than 150 okay and did I hear you correctly earlier saying that under option D if you bumped Middle School from 9 to 930 the costs would drop off potentially yes okay my recommendation would be to go back take option D look at 7:30 8 8:30 9 9:30 everything else stays the same and give the costing numbers right there if that's something that can be done because that does in fact answer the question of Middle School start time changes without impacting anything else 7:30 goes against the RFP requirements I mean status quo so status quo so current

165okay yeah to your Baseline and then add the so 7:30 the Baseline 8 8:30 9 9:30 and then see which of those makes most sense and potentially you know my time's up but if the boundary savings could possibly fund that thank you I will take a turn then we'll go to goack um I brought this concern up the previous time and I'm going to bring it back up again but every single option except for e and C2 a little bit less but every single option reduces the runtime every option except for C2 reduces the runtime by 20 to 30 minutes that is a significant change in runtime how confident are you I'm going to ask you Dr Reed that you can deliver this runtime and before you answer I asked this question because the last

166thing I want to do to a community that is undergoing a lot of change and angst is to promise something we can't actually deliver so how confident are you in in any of these options that have a run time that's 20 or 30 minutes faster so I think Mr J muck spoke to this earlier I think there's a concern on the part of our transportation department that we're really going to be able to do that and we have not been able to model it so when you ask how confident I am until we're actually able to model it on the road in traffic I can't say that I am confident I also know that um the tablets being avail able I believe the tablets last time I checked are not going to be available when

167school starts so help me with unless we've been able to negotiate an earlier delivery I thought those were we were looking at December yes ma'am the routing system will be up and running um by the beginning of this coming school year which is August yes ma'am and uh the we're in the procurement process on an amendment right now for the mobile data tablets which the board has not seen yet and approved um which is coming through the process now um and if it then we will be doing a 45-day pilot this summer during summer school to make sure that the mobile data tablets work as advertised as seamlessly as they said and if they do which we feel pretty good that they will deliver then during the school year of 25 26 we'll start um

168rolling those out hopefully by it'll all be fully implemented by spring break maybe sooner like December as you mentioned spring break of 26 yes ma'am okay so I just want to manage expectations that those tablets are not going to be ready likely till second semester next year um so I if you're asking the confidence I would not bet my first born on this um maybe my third but I hope they're not watching I'm T oh no I didn't say that um but uh I just I want to say that I think until we can model it I don't know I'm I don't have complete confidence I mean I think what I'm hearing from my colleagues and what I also believe is we all want to address Middle School start times as Dr Anderson said the

169previous board started looking at that and then Co delayed many things this was one of them I think we all want to address this but I I also don't believe any of my colleagues want to promise something that we don't know if we can deliver and if we have new modeling or new software that can give us much more detailed information on bus runs that might actually be able to save us more time and frankly if we included the special ed buses on there because with all due respect having had a special ed kid who was sent to a school outside the pyramid that wasn't that far away and it was a 50-minute bus ride with all due respect there's a lot of very lengthy bus rides specialed kids spend twice as much time as

170Jen had kids on the bus and to not include them in the report is a real disservice and I'm just going to put that out there bluntly and so I I do think that we need to make sure we're inclusive of our groups when we're looking at shorter bus rides if we have software that is going to get us more detailed information especially as traffic patterns may be changing I think it's a disservice to do this without that data without really knowing the the assumptions of almost all of these even C2 is shorter bus runs without those assumptions being true none of these can be done and it sounds like we don't have confident on whether those assumptions underlying every single option is true and able to be done I mean you can't do this

171the whole thing falls apart so I want to change Middle School start times when my daughter was in Middle School she was actually at a secondary school so the middle school started at the high school start times which was the earlier start time so I have also as a parent lived the 7:20 a.m. start time I understand it as a parent but I also know as a parent I'd be really mad if I was told a bus a pick up my kid at a certain time to get to school a certain time and we consistently couldn't do it because we didn't have the software and information and I don't want to do that to our community so I do think that we can make a commitment to change Middle School start times but I don't

172think we're making commitment to do it next year because it doesn't sound like we have the confidence that we can actually do it and that's the last thing I want to promise our community I just and I appreciate all the hard work but the only one that I could see doing is e because that's the same amount of runtime and there's a lot of issues with how late those elementary school kids get out and without asking the Elementary and high school kids I'm not comfortable doing so that I will pause and take a go back but if anyone wants to comment what I had to say I'd be happy to hear it Dr Reed I think you're correct in your analysis I mean we if our current runtime is 110 I would be confident we

173could maintain that my hope would be that we can continue to improve that um I think Mr McDaniel said with boundaries you know one goal was more efficiency for sure um but we won't be initiating the boundaries this fall um I don't know if the new routing I haven't seen it modeled yet um if the new routing will enable a 20 to 30 minute gain I just I don't know I mean I have to look at the documents but if the team isn't sure then I for sure am not sure um because they're going to have to execute it so e does provide you the security I think we could stand behind the run time for E because it's at 1:0 and C2 maybe within 10 minutes-ish I don't know if we can go much

174further than that I'd have to rely on Mr muick and Mr Andrade for that thank you we'll start with go back start with Miss Anderson then miss Maron um so one thing that I wanted to say is that I agree with my colleague that talked about the fact that I'm not trying to Discount the importance of Middle School in terms but I am not willing Elementary School for most of our schools is the longest amount of time that anyone is in one school so for us to and I live in an area of the District of the county that many of our elementary schools or Elementary School students are on the bus for extended periods of time because of their location so trying to say that we are going to have kindergarteners starting at 6:30

175getting on the bus at 6:30 in the morning or 6:40 in the morning and then having that continue until they're in sixth grade does not seem feasible so I am significantly concerned that we would have that be the solution um I will also tell you anecdotally the only option that I have heard the biggest outcry about is e as an absolutely not so I think that we will have pitchforks if we pick that particular particular option because it's untenable for some parents to to have their kids dropped off at 9:50 in the morning so I will also I will say that um I was this I was the the six years in a secondary school that started at 7:20 so I have I lived that um what I've noticed that we've done with our secondary

176schools is we've given them their own unique start time what I would recommend is if we have strong support from the Mason District at this point because of the fact that they have the only middle schools that have 6 through eight is there any reason that we can't start with them and give them their own unique start times because of the fact that they are their own unique student body if I can answer the first piece the none of the options that we developed had more than a handful of Civil Twilight violations for the first run schools so 6:30 a.m. pickups for elementary school as a de facto result um is not what is included in these Solutions I'm sorry but we're still talking about 5-year-olds walking to the bus stop by themselves understood and

177so the the RFP requirements were um no no ex no Civil Twilight violations we did look at what you currently have already have some Civil Twilight violations happening with middle school students so I didn't want anyone to get the impression that we have excessively early pickups with some of these um the the first tier start times for the elementary schools and one one of the things that that plays into that is that your current runs are optimized for your current set of school start times if you adopt a new set of school start times the runs would be optimized for that new set which would which would change potentially uh a 40-minute runner for an elementary school might have to be broken up into 220s in order not to have Civil Twilight violations and still

178get the kids to school on time that also plays into the runtime window I will say that in in in just to be clear we we vetted these with the transportation department as being possible aggressive yes some of them but what does it mean that we think it is possible that an 80-minute window can happen it means that there is existing space within the 110 minute window to further refine things and that that that's where that comes from uh and so that that's that that piece um is should be considered in this we did not provide solutions that the transportation department said absolutely not it's not possible okay and to the second aspect of my question can you refra remind me of it again I'm sorry oh the the pilot um I I think maybe

179not call it a pilot maybe call it a phase one I do think I'm not asking it for it to be a pilot I'm asking for these three schools to be treated differently the same way the secondary schools are I think that a there there is there are some reasons to want with within a school district to have some commonality for start times however in a district this large uh there's no reason not to start someplace uh with this kind of a change I think that the benefit to doing something like that would is that it would give you plenty of opportunities to understand what the challenges are going to be you would have real world data potentially on how many teachers say no don't want to do that new school start time and ask

180to be transferred somewhere else within the system um you would have real world data on what your new traffic patterns might look at look like uh I I see little downside to it we did take a look um not officially but we were we were wondering what it might look like and looked at several different um High School pyramids uh to see how much overlap there is in bus usage between pyramid a and pyramid B and pyramid C and there are places where there's not a huge amount of overlap uh obviously overlap if you change start times here and from start times here might end up costing you extra buses because I can't now serve both efficiently um and so the fact there wasn't a huge amount of overlap said yeah this is actually possible

181in this school system the other thing that I would just want to put out here is that I understand fully why we need high schools to start at the same time there is absolutely nothing that says that we can't have middle schools start at different times because they they do not have the same programing requirements with sports and things like that at the end of the day thank you you want another go back yes all right Miss Marin these are all really good points and I love to see if we can be flexible for our youngest students who are in middle school so I just want to share a few things one about Community engagement you know we have issues that the board works on because data compels us to and issues that we come

182to our plates because Community advocacy does and sometimes it's a convergence of both and I just would like us to be clear on community engagement because sometimes we hear a criticism that well what are you doing with my engagement it's all just you know lip service but I I'm just reflecting on a few topics I've worked on in my now sixth year on the board covid 50% wanted closed 50% wanted open I could take all the community engagement I wanted it was not going to be any different the calendar finally that became something that was operationalized which this is an operational thing and so I'm wondering who ultimately is deciding on anything is it us or the board because the pattern would be that the superintendent us or the superintendent with the superintendent would be

183deciding recess Middle School recess that came to us from the community but we wholeheartedly supported it but it took us some time to get it done and we still need to make Get Better by providing you know the equipment for them cell phones we're there too and that's come at us all different ways so you know surveys I agree and this has been from the prior board too like what not everyone responds do we want to give people false hope again like I want to look at the data and the data say that it's best for kids to have more sleep so look if this board is committed to making Middle School start times later then we proceed operationalizing what the system can bear what time and funds we have the RFP was designed designed

184with available resources that could be dispersed to this change so we need to have some conversations again with the county one Community use we need to be on the same page about planning two school age child care theou is from the 1980s we must update that and maybe this is that cat you know C whatever you know cat Catalyst thanks Merc to make that happen it's not our responsibility to figure out everyone's child care but we certainly can help so I think we need to just if I could finish what we need to decide what I'm proposing is do we make a commitment to that change as Mr mlan asked for pending that outcome we make a commitment to either the parallel or the staggered proposal and then pending that outcome we decide what the

185next steps are including who makes the decision is it the board or the superintendent and then we got to let the people know we can't leave them hanging and I I hope that we can do that by tonight thank you Miss Maron Dr Henderson okay I'm going to St by answering some of those questions that you raised yes I want to do this and I'd like for us to have that vote that we are going to do this two I am fine with what you proposed Miss Anderson to start with the Mason District to no one's shock ever um so so I am fine with doing that because I also think it's probably one of the densest areas and I'm just guessing by driving around not because I have any you know expertise of that

186and that would make it staggered and that would give us the opportunity to learn and this is I mean we've piloted with other things the security thing we're piloted with six schools this would be three schools so I am all in for that um one of my concerns about the parallel boundary um uh implementation is what if we don't do the boundary what if we are delayed with the boundary adjustments with the boundary changes then does this make this a continu a continuous delay as well cuz potentially that could happen if we're being responsive to our community we have a lot of noise in our ears regarding the boundary but we're forging ahead saying this is what's best for the division this is what's best for our um efficiencies Etc all of the reasons this

187is also what's best for kids so we need to carve that out but I do want an answer to that question yes ma'am um if the something delayed the boundary adjustment review I think it would be a decision for the board and the superintendent obviously to say hey we can continue forward with the middle school with the K through 12 start time changes uh on at 2627 and not delay them further and I appreciate that but given all the conversation we're having right now in terms of why they need to be um coupled what would make that any different a year out which is again continuing delaying what you your child experienced what my child is experiencing and I have to also share this I think I said this before we are also wanting to

188increase ridership we have students at the middle school level who are not on the school bus because it is too early for them they get a whole extra 30 minutes if we drive them my kid is in one of those places because of that additional 30 minutes we can save not to mention all of the safety issues um one of the other questions that I had regarding the elementary how is it decided which ones are 820 and which ones are whatever the other time is 8:30 and 9:20 do you want current or the current okay because I imagine the same application I can answer for the scenarios we developed it's where it fits now we tried to keep them where they currently were as we started um but where it fits and and that that

189could be a potential Improvement on the scenarios is if all of it is off the table in terms of where it fits in terms of the routing time and so how many runs did we need to accommodate for elementary school a versus B versus C and and what we needed to do there was that the original intent yeah that's the same intent is uh the amount of elementary schools cost is more than the middle schools and high schools so we wouldn't be able to deliver to all middle schools at the same time so we have additional tiers to accommodate thank you Dr Anderson do you want to go back yes please all right Miss Lady thank you uh again I want to start with just reiterating that I have complete understanding of the biological needs

190of our kids to to get more sleep um but a couple things that haven't they've been stated but indirectly for the staffing implications we have backed up the time with which our P our current staff can enter transfer window I think the the deadline for them to transfer is April 2nd or 12th when historically they could do it through the end of June we have already backed that up for us to make any DEC ision right now is going to impact that plan um I thank you uh Miss Dixit for highlighting how long a bus ride is for an AAP student um and again overlaying with the boundary work I think we should have AAP in all of our schools and no longer have centers because that'll address our bus problem in a major major

191way um because that bus to be full is going to take longer to get to every single location which is the same issue with special education which I would also uplift that we focused on inclusion and we need Community Schools we need to figure out how to service our students needs in their base school because that Fleet of 320 buses um that probably could be impacted as well and I do believe our staff have the talents um that we can start to look at this from a program perspective because it's going to save us in funding um I think the thing to go to Dr Anderson's point I think what I keep hearing is this Tyler routing software is the game Cher um and we're not fully implemented with it it and so in terms

192of us being able to maybe Implement changes to start times K12 a year from now even if the boundary work isn't ready I think that is a viable option because we will have data from that Tyler routing and from the you know I whatever you're talking about the tablets you're talking about um it also seems to me this is a question if the runtime is shortened does that impact salaries please stop my time no I don't believe because we guarantee our drivers 30 hours so we wouldn't be taking away from the drivers okay I mean I get that but um the other thing I want to say is will we still have four days after school for middle schools if we if they go until 3:45 or 4 you're referring to the late buses uh

193I would assume so Paul I wouldn't assume that that would change um the only thing is that and this all depending on the school what programs they would offer depending on the time and how many parents may say I don't need the programs because school's a little later on so that's a variable that we wouldn't be able to address and I'm going to be out of time but then that might be we shift offering some earlier I don't know but then that's an equable issue because everyone has to get there the last thing I would say is that I think people need to understand this is for faculty listening and parents that one of the benefits when I was at Thomas Jefferson High School was all parent conferences started at 8 a.m. there were no

194After School parent conferences because dismissal was at 350 and it meant that we had 30 minutes and we had to go to class and I just want to uplift that because this looks later but if we moved some of those earlier that would be great thank you Miss Lady Mr Moon followed by Miss St John cunning uh thank you uh it's very intriguing that that you know we can we can start with the three M scools uh Bas District sco member is very willing to you know entertain the idea correct cor I I'll be happy to support that I'll be happy to support starting uh from the far if uh you know it sounds as if that that can be done uh I will support that and and secondly at the same time it sounds

195as if the board members are requesting for additional information additional survey done and additional engagement with the special education community and and also potentially with the uh Advanced academic Community as well so uh doing it you know making a a a division wide systemwide a change from the upcoming year will most likely not be feasible from I mean that's that's that's my assessment of the conversation today so I'm not going to push for a 25 26 systemi change right away but how however at the same time even though it's been it's been a goal stady go of the school board last board I want to have a consensus of this board to bring a change in due time and at the same time we we let you know there will be a a disappointed people

196who wanted to have this change to be done in the fall let them know that let them know that we unfortunately we're not going to be able to do that rather than giving them first hope uh that that's one and and also as far as start time for buity concern I am very reluctant to entertain anything going Beyond 9:00 a.m. that's that's a huge change from a corrent 7:30 to uh I mean that's even 9:00 is 90 minutes that's a lot of change for a lot of families a lot of sta members so uh that will be my bottom line for the change thank you Mr Moon Miss St John conning followed by Miss Dixon um so I want to go back to what we were talking about earlier about Community engagement and data and

197I think that comparing you know engagement with the boundaries versus this is completely different because we had very robust year-long opportunity ities for Community engagement and voices for boundaries and we had a survey and if we look at the numbers and we look at the percentage and we look at the numbers of how many people actually answered this it's a completely it's it's two it's apples and oranges and I think that that's critical because that's how we bring our community along with us I know one member in my community that is a very active parent that wanted to fill out out the survey and the window closed and they never got to fill out the survey because it was a week window they never got to get it it's an English speaker they've pulled their

198son out of middle school in Fairfax County and they're now in private school because of the Middle School start time they weren't able to have their voice heard so I think that the way these surveys were done were not adequate and I feel that we need to have that input so that we can bring our community along with this that's that's the one thing that I wanted to mention the other thing I wanted to mention is please talk to your principles and please talk to your staff members those letters that were sent by principles I had several principles reach out to me and say I did not agree with that letter I then made phone calls to other principles that said I did not agree with that letter so it is incumbent on us to

199find out what people feel in our community including our principes including our staff members so when I got a couple of calls saying I want you to know this letter came out did not agree with that so please I urge all of you to make those phone calls because it sounds like these organizations are all lock step they're not thank you um Miss Dixit followed by Mr Dunn thank you uh this is a really great conversation and um I think we we're going through through somewhere uh brainstorming right now but I think we're heading somewhere I like the idea of uh just doing this pilot for Mason District right now uh and also uh trying the the software and then kind of going from there at this moment but I don't want this to be

200another situation where we wanted to have middle schools in Mason and there's a pilot and then we'll do it all across County and then this also becomes that so we have to stay on task we have to be committed to this um and I as as a parent um I I'll say nothing else U you know worried me by sending my son in dark to that bus stop every morning um and also I'm still still seeing seeing a lot of sleepy middle schooler in the morning I I don't see them bright and chirpy and going to school with with a smile maybe there are some I I Haven I have seen more sleepy more sleepy kids and the sleep on the bus so um actually especially with the long commute time so I I do

201want to support this uh for uh a pilot um and I I want to say that even for high school students um TJ has a great start time I always admired that they had it and they because of the distance of commute I guess but that's exactly um the students need especially kids who are doing a lot of sports um APS and IB programs they have lot of homework um I know students sometimes stay up till 1:00 at night um to you know and then they have school in the morning at starting at 8: so it's it's uh overall pushing the school little bit late is I think is a good thing so I'll just say that and uh I support um the Mason District program right now thanks Mr dun um you're Anis is

202based on current School boundaries is that right so so these costs if we change the boundaries the costs the times the runs will be different right yes sir yes okay so uh that that gives me pause um when we talk about doing a pilot totally supporting my colleague but what which of these options are we talking about doing in the Mason District and what are the costs of that pilot I'd like to know that yes sir before we get too far down the path of changing just three middle schools it would require us to be able to find more drivers and have more buses applied to that because if you the way you build a route with the limited number of drivers and buses we have a bus is going to go and pick up

203a middle school and then an elementary school and then do a high school or secondary you know whatever that whatever that run is and if you change you can't change the times on just one of those in that group right because if you change that Middle School time it impacts how do that how does that bus get to you know the the schools following it or before it you know what I mean they're all Interlink so unless I have a dedicated group of drivers just to go at those three middle schools um we need time to look at it to see if we can do that and how and when you go and look at it will come back to say which of these options are feasible to do just for the Mason District well

204I think when we were talking about a pilot um we were looking at the pilot would be in a full attendance pyramid right so you would have you know South County pyramid and you would have the middle the elementary schools the middle school and the high school in that pilot and they would all be linked because those buses are picking up and doing the middle school the high school and the elementary school so you can link them all together um so if we just said hey change the times for the three Mason District middle schools I don't I don't know yet I'd have to go back and take a look at that and see how that impacts the current resources we have and Paul I don't know if you want to add anything to that

205no I think it's the same methology you'd have to really look at how the whole pyramid interacts with each other so it'll be ill advised to make one just for those three middle schools without making changes to everything else and and for this pilot could the school board direct you to could the school board pick one of any of these options that are up on the screen right now and say we want you to do those School times for the for the Mason District or would you have to come back and tell us which options are feasible for those pyramids I think it's within the board's purview to direct as they wish I think that you know at the system level um those are the costs that are there obviously if you're doing a piece

206of anything other than D um you know there may be additional costs at for for three schools um for three attendance zones that would not be at run rate with all of them because of the attendance boundary issue and buses that cross attendance boundaries I think you can we would have to look specifically at the three uh middle schools in the Mason District but option D gives you the cost for just moving middle schools at the system level um I we'd have to look and see you know is is the answer then 75 divided by number of 26 middle schools 23 plus three secondaries or is it a little bit more than that uh and then 150 divided by the same number well thank you and I think just whatever happens next I think uh

207listening to the voices that have been raised in this report and it is an excellent report by the way very thorough um you know certainly I appreciate my colleagues point about the principes but when the union speaks when a principal's Association speaks I I listen because that's their job to represent um and when the students speak in the survey you know 75% telling you a time frame and 60% of parents speak giving you a time frame I think those should be determining factors um but we also need to gather the data that's been noted by my colleagues as missing thank you Mr Dunn seeing no other Gob backs I have for goo backs but I will did you want to turn otherwise I will take a turn um I understand that the run times were

208suggested thinking they could be done it but when I asked about that in the first work session I was asked if they were driven as opposed to just and the answer I was given was well we just have new software and now what I'm hearing is a new software isn't going to be ready until next year and so as much as I I understand the to do a pilot and I it's a creative solution without even unknowing the software for the runtimes I don't even know how we would do a pilot and if you just do it middle schools I don't know how that would impact the elementary schools they feed to different high schools I think that's an interesting thought to look at but I think it's difficult today to know um that's the

209first thing the second thing I want to mention is that we just had a budget work session where we talked and I know you may may not we talked about collaboration with the Board of Supervisors and partnering with the Board of Supervisors and many of these changes are going to impact Community use it's going to impact sack which some of my colleagues talked about um we've talked about the disruption to our community and they're going to have to make Child Care changes with the community I know in the survey it said 66% of middle schoolers said they did not take care of an elementary school student after which tells you a third of them do that's not a small amount of middle schoolers that are taking care of a elementary school student after school and

210I'm not saying are job is to make sure that they are there to do that but our job is to minimize this disruption whether that's to three middle schools or a lot of middle schools I don't think it's good change management and the goal is to collaborate with our Board of Supervisors and to collaborate with our community I just don't think it's good change management to do this that quickly but a third of our middle schoolers are taking care of someone after school we got to give our families time to figure that out and whether that's three middle schools or not I I just don't think you make that quick of a change like this and especially when we haven't driven the runs and especially with traffic changing so I really think we have to

211be thoughtful on how we do this cuz I don't want to have to undo it and with potential boundary changes and shorter Transportation times there's a risk of either being inefficient with resources down the road or undoing things so my two cents I will go to go go backs um M sorry I just maybe take a second to eliminate a little bit of confusion um we started working with Tyler routing last year year and at the time that we moved into developing Alternatives and and the Prismatic working on that Tyler routing provided a what they call a Sandbox so it was an exact replica of our routing system that Prismatic could use to develop these runs so while we didn't have a somebody in a bus out driving the runs they had the same system

212that our team is going to be using and they were able to go in with the exact stuff we have the exact routes the schools the stops and to manipulate to get to these Alternatives so I just I wanted to make sure that was clear because I I thought that's what we mentioned in December and you had just mentioned that it was unclear so I just wanted to make sure I maybe got some of that confusion out of there and they they were in there C doing the actual runs in there and like run B when it's shaved 30 minutes off the runtime Prismatic feels that we can do that it goes back to the you know the risk willingness of us and some of the situations people said about hey taking that risk and

213kids sitting out there waiting we don't meet it we're we we want to see how you know that goes and if I could just clarify we did not build entirely new runs we use the runs that you already have that you're currently running which is what was input into the new software there are very limited cases where we would break apart runs so we would split a run into two pieces um in order to meet some Civil Twilight potential problems um or to make it so that the new way of stacking Elementary to Middle the high or or vice versa would fit um but we use what you're currently doing uh as the basis right well I'm out of time so I'll respond to that in my go go back but thank you for that

214clarification um M seiser are we doing two minutes or one minute for go go backs oh I believe we were supposed to go till 9: is that correct we're scheduled till 9: for the war8 till 8 oh I apolog I thought it was till 9: um if I know right if I may indulge my colleagues we only have four for go if we can do one minute that will be a quick Round And if I could just ask staff to maybe keep the responses short my if that's okay with you all we'll do an extra 15 minutes okay so one minute sorry one minute yes one minute and I'll suck with Dr an Miss Anderson followed by Dr Anderson just really fast one thing we've said multiple times that we're going to break runs up

215to be 20 minutes instead of 40 minutes sometimes that's not physically possible the kids just live 40 minutes away from the school so I just want to put that out there um second thing is with option e I'm particularly concerned about the high school um dismissal time because of the fact that we have 44 of our our fields that are actually given over to the park Authority or the county for Community use at 5:00 and we're already hearing from our from our teams that do not have time to get the kids out and get practices through in an equitable way for every everybody and so I just want to say that doing anything that disrupts further taking that half an hour away um from that availability is a big deal for some of our teams

216so I just I just want to put that out there that I I think that we have some more discussion about the different options Dr Anderson yes thank you I'll be quick um but one clarification question our high school fields are not turned over they're not utilized for after school because of our own usage correct right can you ask that question again the high school fields and and and we don't have a lot of community use using the fields and the gyms because of our heavy usage of those um Paul you can you jump in on that answer uh I I can speak to the field specifically we currently have anou on the second tur Fields when they exist at our high schools and thatou time uh which is expired and needs to be refreshed

217currently 5:30 uh when Community use turns over but each School works with their Community users to maybe sometimes go to six um but there is room based on start time to work with NCS on when we turn over those second Fields but because the park Authority in the county maintains and replaces those secondary Fields they absolutely expect to have significant use of them uh as far as gymnasium times go um NCS takes over when we are done there is noou there's no specific time when the high school or middle school facilities are turned over to them because those just seem to go on and on and on especially doing volleyball and basketball Seasons um thank you I I will take the rest of my 49 minutes to say this which is okay you wasted four

218of those precious seconds um I will take the rest of my time um to say this you know the conversation that I heard around this table is to be responsive to our community I open up my comments with saying the Mason Community has been very very vocal on this so I would love to work with my colleagues to find a way for staff to review how we can make this happen for the three middle schools because I think going through the whole High School pyramid will be disruptive in terms of sports because you can't have you know Justice High School be on one schedule and then they can't get to activities and to games whatever it is that we need to do with our high schools as well asies I see that being a little

219bit more challenging um and I don't know how it works at the secondary for the secondary schools because I don't have any of those but I would like to see some modeling of what does it look like for those three middle schools you miss Marin yeah look I I requested that we get clear on a few things I don't think we're there um are we committed to making a change that means we don't know what the solution is yet but are we committed I hope that we could I mean maybe we could vote up or down or whatever that would be great are we committed to Peril or staggered can we make that decision maybe we don't need to do that right now but what are the next steps Dr Reed at this point is

220this an operational thing because we are like SE in the weeds and as far as I know the only people who are experts in this stuff are those people sitting at the front of the table so what is our role in this now and in the future do we need to tell you you know tonight or at a formal board meeting and we have got to engage the county further on this community use and Sack are key pieces this is not a simple thing and when I think that this board only got this information in December and we're feeling like we're rushing to do something I'm sorry that's not okay there's lots of questions um we had an RFP then we asked for it to respond to American Academy Pediatrics recommendations now there's a request

221which could be a next step about the Mason District so we are evolving the work what is our plan and when are we making decisions because there's people sitting here and they want to know what's going to happen and so do I thank you m may we do have a next steps document that we can use I'm I'd like the superintend toe resp all right go ahead so I think the history has been that this board wants to make this decision I believe that's what happened the last time so I believe it's the board's decision and we'll Implement whatever the board determines so I think it's a I mean if seven know I guess I'll leave it there because I think back in I guess Mr mline or Mr Moon would have to answer that

222at the last time the start times were adjusted I'm told the board approv those so Bo yeah board made those decisions so so hang on so I'm thinking what I'm going to say is I don't think it's written that the board has to make this decision so we could make a decision to make a commitment to making Middle School start time changes and asking our superintendent to operationalize that that is something that we as a board could do we don't typically take votes at work sessions but if we want to do a formal motion to say the board is committed to making Middle School start time changes and asking our superintendent to operationalize in her best discretion that doesn't have to be this year that's something we could do but is not something we could

223do at a work session because we don't take formal votes at work sessions so I'm going to take my my one minute turn and I'm going to then wrap up the meeting moris Mr fr has his hand oh I apologize Mr fr I didn't see I'll let you take your turn and then I will take a turn Mr frish we can't hear you I didn't know if you heard me or not I will take a turn I apologize excuse me um so yeah I I would generally be opposed to taking any action in the work session I think one of the good things about Mr fr we can't hear you we can hear him can you hear me now yeah there seems to be some kind of delay there's this weird double play I'm hearing

224myself speak back to me can you hear me now we can hear you I apologize um uh as I was saying I really um don't want to take any kind of actions in a work session that doesn't mean a motion can't be brought to a regular board meeting I think one of the good things about a work session next steps in the process that follows is that it gives board members an opportunity to reflect on what everybody has shared um and I think that's the whole point of a work session is to offer some time uh for us to think more deeply about the different points that have been raised so uh happy to entertain a motion at a regular meeting but I wouldn't I wouldn't want that here and as for a pilot I

225I think there's a world of difference between a pilot that is intended to see if it could work in other places and just doing a carve out for three schools um as we heard from staff um you know the preferred pilot would be something that could be replicated and I think I you know I'm if it was the next step I'd consider seeing how I imagine there'd be an expense to uh carving out three middle schools without impacting other um schools uh you know just looking at the other options that we have in the report anything that minimized disturbance at uh two scenar at two Elementary or high school or whatever there's a bigger uh cost associated with that because you need more buses and bus drivers so um you know I'd be open to

226a pilot where we're looking like staff has mentioned at an entire pyramid but um you know I look forward to seeing what everybody brings to the next steps process thank you and I appreciate that I was going to say the same thing I think the work session is for us to talk through there's obviously lots of questions I've heard from colleagues that need to be followed up and um if someone wants to bring a formal vote at a at a meeting absolutely but we don't take votes here at work sessions um a couple things I just wanted to comment back on and you can start my time I just wanted to comment back on what you were saying about the routing I do remember that they had had access to our routes in a sandbox

227right and the point I was making is that until you drive them right kids take different times to get on buses I tell you the number of times I've been that parent when school starts and the bus is supposed to be there at 810 at 8:25 and 8:35 and lo and behold 3 weeks in we've moved the bus time right or the kids are getting it it's just human right you don't the traffic is hard to predict and until we can drive some of it the significant change in routing time gives me pause and it sounds like there's pause as well especially with the change of return to work so I'm just going to leave that there that I I I think if we could have just shaved off 20 to 30 minutes off our

228routing time I think we would have done that already so I just think there's a lot of questions with sack with child care with our staff with I mean I would worry about our special education students and any pilot that isn't replicatable who are going out of their pyramid what the impact is on them if we change Middle School our times I don't I I think that's a big question before we do any pilot of what does this impact the kids that we're not thinking about I'll stop my time is up now we're over our time I thank you for my colleagues for going late there's a next steps document please put in your next steps on the next steps document and if anyone wants to bring a motion at a regular meeting by all

229means you're welcome to do that thank you for your time

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.