001okay this February 11th 2025 regular meeting of the Fairfax County School Board public engagement committee will now come to order um we were going to start with student voice um where Miss Marin was going to give out a report but we'll go ahead and move on to the community advisory uh committee toolkit update uh until Miss Marin comes in and then we'll switch back over to that um the July 18th school board approved a motion oh okay good she's she's here we can wait a few minutes for her to settle in um okay so yeah I'll just say uh we had a Rob robust discussion about how to incorporate the student voice more intentionally with our board work last month Miss Marin and I participated in an informative vsba webinar entitled enhancing student voice in
002school leadership uh Miss Marin will share her thoughts and what we learned um to provide an update um and it was I will have to say it was very informative and very interesting to see what's done in other jurisdictions yes good morning thank you well I welcome your additions to what I'll share so the there was a speaker who was sharing a study that he had done of um Schoolboard you know student reps around the common was it just the Commonwealth I think might just a common Comm no it was also some other pulled in from other parts of the country okay thank you um and so I had asked actually I'd love to know which jurisdictions they had talked about because it would be good to follow up I think one of the local
003school boards though is at Prince William does have two Representatives so I think that would be a good step to ask them how they do it um but um yeah they they had I mean it was I think there was a sample size of seven so there were some really good anecdotes but um I know that we've had some of the conversations about you having one or more two one or two reps or just other ways to involve and we actually shared about our board student leadership program and others were interested in that so it it was quite a lot and I'll um defer to you Miss um St John cunning if you would like to add something else um I think what I found the most interesting was that and I don't remember the
004school board but the student Representatives actually get a vote and that was very interesting um I think that right now what we have to finalize is um if the SE second student and I Mr Moon had brought like geographical you know jurisdictions because our county is so big so having one student represent one geographic area and another a different geographic area because it would just make it Mobility wise for them easier to navigate um the timing of the election and then deciding whether it would be equal representation or it would it be a second or an alternative yes and so I did want to add in addition to the webinar that we attended I did speak with our staff in instructional Services about the process of what is done now to elect a student representative
005and um asked about what it could be to have a second representative and they would really need to think about it and look into it as far as geography I know I I keep a spreadsheet of as many student reps back that I've served with and they've all been pretty much from one part of the county so if geogra geography is a factor in anything I mean we could think about that even for the one student rep we do have um I think in the years I've been on the board we've had a student from the same High School twice which is you know great but you know the process and there was also a larger discussion about how students learn about the Schoolboard application process you know I had a student ask me the
006other day you know what I would suggest to them to be um you know uh an enticing candidate and I said it's out of my hands like it's not the board so I think there's work to do from the board side in both understanding the election process and in advocating for more um accessibility and consistency because I think it's done in different ways in different schools and then also how we onboard that student and you know so this is a little bit of a different thing but you know I'd love to get really strong in how we support our one student before we add on a second um that might sound like a familiar argument for some of you um but um and I know one of our past students Prav he had done work
007to look into student rep voting rights and so there's a movement to do that so there's a lot that could be done I just think that it has to also be feasible for our staff and they really hadn't explored that before so we left it as I was going to report back to you all here and they're going to need more time and like right now is the time that the students are you know applying so they're very busy doing that so I think it'd have to wait until we go through this cycle of Elections and then perhaps with the Fresh Start we can figure out how to find more options or just know what's possible thank you I appreciate that I think you know one of the issues uh you know mentioned you know
008voting rights of students came up before too long ago for some conversation among board members uh at the time some of the things that we needed to consider was accountability because we are all account number to uh voters and then we get voted out we can get voted out I can get can stay on or you can resign however you want to do but is there a similar accountability to a student rap uh who's going to be there for just one year and if a voting rights are given on all issues what issues and and whether whether students will be Pritt to attend close sessions where so those things all came up as a part of discussing a the voting rights of students and you know at the end the the bo you know did
009not entertain giving a a voting rights that was long ago okay so you know we could you know different B could do differently that and what I have noticed over time is that uh you know different student raps do it different ways but uh I for lately I have seen less participation on the part rap to really speak on issues that the the board members or the board is dealing with or are going to be voting on so I I'm hoping that you know as we see more student voices to be reflected uh and the matters directly related to uh them I'm I'm I'm hoping more should voices reflected at least through the student rap meaning that it may be difficult may not be easy for high school students to come to our meetings you
010know many meetings but uh in the past we had regularly seen student rec come to our work sessions even for part of the day even they knew exactly when and what was just scheduled on the agenda and then find a time time to come and stay here for an hour and say what he or she wants to say and then go back to school Etc uh not easy thing for high school kid to do because they got a top schedule but that is having more than one could make it easier they could you know rotate around and see you know com and let us know what students feel about certain issues uh but that's a that's a worth discussing I I agree because we're here for the students and I think that I've participated in
011programming where the students when when they do speak up it's amazing what they have to say and the more that we can get from them the more voice and the more perspective the better we'll be able to do our jobs I agree I think that I've been in support of this since we started talking about it as increasing the number of students that we have for for a division as large as ours I think that it's it's definitely something that we could entertain by having a larger student um group that is able to to give us feedback as to what they're hearing um that could be done in regular report outs from different organizations that are different groups that are already meeting um on a regular basis and so that that is something that we
012could we could further discuss in terms of just making sure that that student voice is represented when we're speaking um I do um agree with Miss Marin that we need to make sure that we have consistency in the way the students are being identified at different schools I do know and even though I I love that our high school brought two of them it's a strong um but I do think that some of that comes from the leadership teachers dedication to ensuring that students know that it's going on and encouraging students to do that um I know that's part of the pathway that happens and we have particularly interested kids um at that at that location um the other thing that I will say is I think that those those pieces can be done in
013tandem so I would love to see consistency in terms of getting information I think we can start that with the student leadership program and ensuring that everybody knows and I think that we've worked on some consistency issues um there already and so I think that those can be replicated when you're talking about the actual student rep that's that's put forward I would love to see us do all of that work in in tandom with figuring out how we would like to get more students that are actually available to come to the meetings in terms of having another rep so I think I don't think that they have to be exclusive to each other I think that we can do some of that work together and so I would love to see maybe working on the
014consistency and then but with an eye towards adding something um the recommendation that I believe that Miss Kareem gave us last year was related to having too many she knew her section of the of the county better just because geographically she could get there um I think that splitting it into at least north south or east west however we want to do it having it be two sections I think that it also it makes the pool a little different so you're getting kids from different locations and so I think that it would be interesting to have kids um kind of split so that they each take a side of the county um I do think that that causes a problem with having one be considered an alternate which is also something that we're going to
015have to tackle and figure out how to move forward with I when I was talking to miss Kem about the options one of the things that she recommended was having it be more of like a either basically each student rep would take one a month one meeting a month and that way we're not we're not exclusively getting the voice from one but they also can work out which one they're able to cover and so it just makes it a little easier for them to manage the workload related to this and there are lots of other meetings that they go to that I don't think that we have full visibility of and so that's the other aspect that I would really like to see how we can make that happen so you know I the this
016came up because um a member worked with our student rep at the time to present the idea of should we have two reps and I think you know we're giving that consideration but I I don't know that yet I'm convinced that that is the solution when I look at the way that students are engaging in the current student leadership program I think that that is an excellent Avenue you know if the goal is to increase student voice being on the board as a rep is not the only way and I've long tried different ways to you know have like a Hunter Mill one one idea was like a 100 Mill student you know group or you know we can also help by so so that's one thing I'm not yet convinced about the two reps
017um and even I think I've spoken with our current rep and there you know she has questions too so I think getting more information about it whether it's from Prince William and how they do it but um and um I think you know the voting item I mean we make fiduciary and legal commitments so I don't know that that that's appropriate for a student rep um to be making those decisions so um I think our carton rep does a great job at presenting things and going to all these other meetings but I did want to share that um at the end of the calendar year just about a month ago our current student rep and I outlined a whole bunch of ways that information could be better shared with especially high school students on all
018the opportunities so whether that's applying for a Governor's School in the summer or um you know the applications to TJ or different types of internships and one of the things was applying to be the student Schoolboard rep because it is different the way that information is is rolled out so I've seen the superintendent does plan for next year to be more consistent in rolling out you know announcements of even coursework selection so we together made a list of all those opportunities that are you know school-based maybe but also FCPS based and even state-based and so I would like to see it more consistent and get the practice so that it's I mean this is a big theme with us right I mean the grading policy it's always how do we get consistency for access to
019these opportunities so I would like to keep working on that angle um so I just wanted to share that update yeah oh Christina so just to we uh one of our Deputy clerks Kevin Jackson is working he's working with the student leadership program on this one of the things I've tasked him with is starting to work on a student rep manual um so that's something that he's going to be starting to work on a couple things that we've seen to the points that have been raised things for the board to consider whether the student rep should be a senior um just because the those who have been Juniors tend to have more responsibilities with their classes it does make it harder for them to come to work sessions and to go do things like School
020visits because their schedule is so packed so that's something to think about is whether it should be just for seniors um they seem to also have more abilities in terms of just Transportation quite frankly because that does seem to be something with our younger students one of the other things that we've seen that has been an issue is we don't usually this year there's been a little bit more consistency but we don't always get informed when even the election is happening so we can't inform SCH school board members to advertise to their communities because we're not informed so having the clerk's office be more informed with things that are happening with the students would be more helpful as well because then we can in include things in chairs notes and other things um because I
021think that's one of the reasons students don't necessarily know about the opportunities is because board members don't advertise them and board members don't advertise them because we don't tell them and we don't tell them because we don't know so just something to consider and if um Kevin is doing the handbook that's something that would be put in the handbook saying that when we're going to have elections you need a notifi the handbook is more designed for things for our student rep for it would help them with training things that we're doing I think one of the things that's come up recently with our current student rep and our former is their questions about uh PD professional development opportunities we don't have that in the budget for them right now um I think there were questions
022as to whether they would go to conferences like with the school board which we said no because they need to be in school now if they found something during spring break that they wanted to attend or something during a fall break maybe that they wanted to attend but we would need to build that into our budget so that's something else that I think the Board needs to consider is what kind of opportunities we want to provide to our student rep as well we they have opportunities through vsba and we've told um Miss Sant our current rep that if she can find things virtually where she doesn't have to go places because that makes it easier in terms of travel and makes it easier with her school that we will help try to find funds for
023those but I think that's something else we need to think about is um what we're doing there and with the student leadership program development leadership program that we have currently we're making um consistent improvements to that as well since this is the first year we've resurrected it in I think four or five years so we're working to to um I know they had a meeting just last night actually where they had Schoolboard members talking to them about how to be better leaders Mr Moon uh in terms of attending giving an opportunity to attend conferences professional development uh I mean I understand a a Christi has concern about students needing to be in class I mean that that goes to a students a a inability to come to work sessions as well uh but you know
024they will they come to work sessions with a permission from their schools and they will carefully take a look at their course work you know when can I actually do this without really sacrificing uh their school workor and they will make that those decisions and that we respect those decisions and you know after all it's a student rep represents close to a 185,000 students uh They're Not Elected by 180,000 but they represent and all that uh attending a conference in Williamsburg where in Richmond even though that may require more time off I think providing that kind of opportunity will help a someone grow as a future leader as well also get to see on a broad scale what the a a entire Commonwealth is dealing with what the nation is dealing with from different school
025districts and Etc so it may not be or three days but it could be a day uh you know accommodating and and it will be up to the stre representa we're not forcing anyone to come and and the stre representative G just like uh if he or she wants to attend the work session and having to take a time up will be the same decision that person would have to make I think providing you know some opportunities for such growth uh will go long way I will say when it comes to time off for school then I think the board need may need to make a directive because schools aren't consistent and whether they give their students the time off and so if we are going to say that it's an excused absence that might
026be something that needs to come from the board so that schools are more consistent because you don't want one student being told that it's unexcused and another school saying it is excused uh Madam clerk do you know whether or not we have a policy specifically regarding the student rep if we do then that then it probably needs to be something that we look at and when the last time that policy was revised and whether or not there's additions that need to be added to the policy to protect those types of absences um because I this while I understand that it's an ex it's an absence from class it's still something related to school that they're going to attend similar to a field trip so I do think that there there are protections that we can
027put in place so that it gives direction to staff on how those absences should be treated so I think right now what we're going to be looking at is then just going out and getting a little bit more definition of where we can getting some more in information to bring back to the committee and we can you know Define that so that we can come back so we can have some better decision making um opportunities um and then if Madam clerk if you could just keep us updated on the student handbook that would be helpful we'll do and we do have a policy it's policy 1802 it was last updated in 2021 it is up for due January 1st 2026 if we follow the five years thank you and I I concur with Miss Anderson
028I think that there's education doesn't just occur within the walls of a school and it would be a great educational opportunity for our student reps um so I think we're ready to move on to community advisory committee toolkit update um which I will hand over to miss Anderson okay so I went ahead and went through the operating manual again just so that I could refresh all the different components that we are going to be um developing in order to to get this rolled out effectively with with our communities so I create cre a um handout that you guys have and is on board docs that will actually outline each of the different components that the that the advisory Comm the operating manual commits to um in addition to a few other things that I've noticed
029related to the changes that were made in the operating manual that will need to be adjusted in practice so if we want to just run through them really fast the toolkit that is a toolkit for board members it's not necessarily A toolkit for advisory committee um participants or um nominees this is related to information that is helpful for for board members um I see this as part of potentially a larger the toolkit is actually related to determining who is going to be your appointee but it doesn't necessarily Encompass everything that could happen around these advisory committees to make it easier for us to find the information that would be accept you know helpful for us so look the um a historical layout of what all the reports have been feedback from staff like just in
030one location so that way it was easy particularly when you took over um the liaison position for an advisory committee you may not have the history and trying to go back and find it all is sometimes difficult and so we can kind of streamline that just a little bit so I actually see this as larger part of a larger project project that wouldn't actually be very difficult to pull together and I think it would be very helpful for all of us so um and I've started creating just a list of the things that I think should be included in the toolkit personally so it would be the standard application which is one of the things here a copy of the operating manual so that everybody has a clear understanding of what we're doing a description
031of each advisory committee along with the current charge for that year and so that way it's one easy place and then contact information for those committees um just so that if you were trying to determine a nominee for one of the Committees that it would be easy to put them in touch with the chair or in touch with the with the committee's email address us and so that's the type of information does anybody else have anything specific to the toolkit that would be helpful to include yes uh you know potential applicants appointees a lot of times you want to know time commitment whether it's uh it's not just attending meeting what sort of prep work uh you know they need to do so uh because that's an important work and if it it's extensive commitment
032you know it may give them a pause and and and I as a board member you know not necessarily know you know how much work is being done by different committees do you think that that's possible that it varies depending on which committee sure but you know could I give an example of last year's perhaps right and then and you know you could we could perhaps get that information from a chairs about from prior years saying that yes for each we meet on a monthly basis uh board our committee meeting generally takes about two hours for the prep work probably additional 3 hours 4 hours 5 hours you know give that that there so that we want to be fair to our appointees that who are volunteering or we are encouraging to serve on the
033committee yeah we might be able to create um some sort of guidance based on the committee and actually use the stly aison as a helpful um person to kind of help us understand where all that's coming in so I think that that's a really good point is that we could almost make an information sheet about you know here's here's the information and I'm seeing this as part of the larger spreadsheet of of contact not not to make the information overwhelming for board members but to have just the information in e One easy location so the idea behind the toolkit eventually or originally was it was meant to make this process easier for people so I think that that's a great Point um as to what what should be included absolutely I I was actually just
034literally responding to get my math resources committee person finalized and I'm sitting here thinking about that and you know my office we developed our own Google form and it would be great to have a standard application form for the school board and you know if members don't want to use it that's their option but I think just having a drop- down menu you could pick your District I think that is a no-brainer um an option could also be to allow entry into a Word document but also we should make it um accessible if someone needs to apply in another format or a video I know even with some of the students I for the leadership program I said if you want to submit a video submit a video so um but I I really appreciate
035this and I was I totally agree about um the standard application I think absolutely describing the language about the commitment I think you know sometimes we put that in the body of the form or we say it but if we look at even the model that staff just used for that bath basil math basil resource appointment that could be you know a model I also is um on the Committee website I know with the re redone website it's Chang the location and I don't think it's as noticeable as it used to be it's kind of buried in a bullet like here are the school board committees and I think that should be way more front and center to find the Committees I also would like to know if this process for the community advisory committees
036could apply for when we do need to appoint constituents to more focused committee such as curriculum review or challenged materials review um because that comes up so can this be brought enough and do we want to include that in here it's not just advisory committees it's these other committees um or can at least maybe the application be used for that in some way and then finally do you picture Miss Anderson that this guide would include a description of the staff liaison role as well as our clerks because that sometimes as a point of confusion for board members the operating manual already has that in there but I do think that it would be important because the other aspect that we haven't talked about is that there is some amount of staff liaison expectation that we
037have that we also should include and so I do think that there is eventually room to I with my training background you know I always go to training first but I do think that it would be an easy like checklist that we could create for safly aison so that they understand what the expectations because there are some changes that have been made in the operating manual related to that they're in charge of minutes and things like that so they can appoint someone on each committee to be the one that takes the minutes but they're responsible for ensuring that the minutes get to the clerk and so understanding what your expectations are I think is always best and so I definitely think that that's something that could be included here um you brought up the standard
038application I did the same thing with my curriculum Review Committee um stuff that I I utilized one I think that what the best bet we can have one Central but the problem is is that then there we're putting more information on the Schoolboard office to maintain I think that it would be awesome to to be able to have a template that we create that you can resave to be yours and then you have control of all the people that come in for you um but it's just an easy way because I did notice based on which committee you're dealing with you do have kind of we will need a standard application but there may be more that you want to put in as a question for your particular Committee Member I understand I was thinking
039about that too here's the thing like when we were doing the student leadership application I would get emails from students who were not my constituents and now I feel responsible for making sure they get to the correct place and if there were a drop down form where with the link I always use the County's my neighborhood link to look up an address that's one thing taken off of us to do and the people get to the right place so I don't know what the right solution is it sounds like a standard application is something we want and maybe we figure out the mechanics absolutely um but yeah so good um and I also think that we should help facilitate for the student moving on to that um help the student rep to actually have because
040there are student liais on or student Representatives appointed to each of the committees as well and I think having the same type of toolkit available for the student rep even though it wouldn't necessarily be be in the same exact format um having those resources available for the student rep is going to be really important to ensure that they can easily pick because they're actually under a tighter timeline than we are because after the student rep gets picked they have to turn pretty fast to try to get all those student representatives in place and I think with the work that you're doing with Dr Reid to ensure consistency of availability of those options and Avail in Opportunities I think that that's going to be a really important thing to happen so um one thing that is
041in the operating manual that we haven't really discussed as a board fully is the bylaws aspect we determined when we were working on all of this we discovered that we have some committees that have bylaws some committees that don't have bylaws and then this year I was made aware that we have some committees that have Charters and the problem is is that's a whole lot of different direction and I think that there should be some consistency between the Committees dictated by us and so I think giving bylaws you know and we can take those committees that already have by laws and create an example of the and it could be a a plug-and-play type of document where we can create that document and then they can just decide on the things that are in there
042um I think creating a standard set of bylaws in terms of expectations and things like that would also be helpful and then they can add their flavor on top of it um so I think that there's lots of things like that but I was wondering what you guys thought about whether or not we when we have folks that have or committees that have Charters how is that different different than a by that a set of bylaws so I have not read those challenge but what which committees do have Charters as far as I know at least fpac has a charter fpac because there was and they'll own created Charter from what I understand which I'm not 100% sure how that is different than the board charge because I really see the charge and the bylaws
043working together but I'm not 100% sure I understand how the charter works with and the bylaws because fpac is something created by the board it not the community and and and then coming to us to help us so uh I don't know how they get to have a charter me neither so that was the question that I had is so I do think that we need to determine whether they are using the charter as their bylaws just naming it a charter as opposed to that's a good question I don't know and that's what my question is is if we are going to give them the language of bylaws that everyone all the different advisory committees are expected to have bylaws if that's the case then we need to help help everybody understand that that's the
044expectation and not necessarily a charter because I do see them as different so just as that heads up the chter uh the fpac charter is actually coming to cpdc this week so this may be a question we need to solve sooner rather than later um because I know that Mr Jackson has let me know that one of the reasons cpdc needs needs to meet as as possible is to deal with the fpac charter that was just approved by fpac I think Madame sh you would have to have a conversation with Mr Done Quick is I guess my question is there a legal difference between a charter and bylaws I mean I mean I would say that Charter Charter is usually a a document that will create something but it was created by the board not
045by itself not the community members gathering together and they will will do this and they will create this and they will help the school book that's not the day there was created and then on on under CH something is created you could have more minute detail included bylaws and Etc but since I haven't seen these charters of fpac I don't know whether it's more like a bylaws and they just they're calling it Charters because they're not creating this right and Madame clerk the bylaws or I mean the charter can be approved by cpdc but it would have to come up to the full board for full approval correct that is my understanding I think it's coming to cpdc for cpdc to approve and then it should be coming but I do need to double check
046with Mr Jackson that that is the intent and I do understand that those two committees work differently one standing committee one advisory committee work differently together but I do think that it's a good point is that if if the all of the advisory committees are board directed then I do think that it is important to make sure that I am fine if there is is language in the charter that would be similar to what would be included in the bylaws and if it's just semantics that we can just call it bylaws and move forward um I do get nervous about whether or not we are going to have some sort of external direction to to the committee that the committee has created itself it kind of changes the dynamic of that the how that committee
047is working and each own work as opposed to what the PO want to do which is problematic because that they they going to consume our staff's time as well yep uh I agree so I do think that we maybe um Can is there a way to uh Christine is there a way to request or figure out which committees have Charters because I was under the impression that that fpac wasn't the only one we're not sure if fleak has one well I have something that I would like to bring up about fleak in just a second but that's a different discussion in just a sec um um but we can check with the staff Liaisons to see I can ask the deputies to check in with their respective committees to see who has a bylaw who
048has bylaws and who has Charters and who has need nothing because that is part of it is that I assume that there are some committees out there that don't have either um and we need to this is an alignment opportunity for all of us to make sure that we're all headed in the right direction as we move forward um can I get just or can can I ask that the chair gets General consensus as to whether or not we want to move towards just having everybody have bylaws right that's what I was going to say I was like I mean part of what this board has been doing is and since I've come on board is trying to get consistency across AC across the board so that everyone is aligned and I appreciate that you
049have seen the seen and pointed out to us that there are some committees that have Charters and some that have bylaws and it shouldn't be both it should be one or the other so yes um if we can get consensus that we want that alignment yes well I I have a a larger question and I'm trying to ground it in then this aspect of how to receive the best value from these advisory committees from these constituents who are trying to inform us and I'm thinking about some committees that the superintendent runs and she is meeting with them on a regular basis like I think it's called The Quad you know meetings where she's in a portion of the county every quarter I'm thinking of the community boundary advisory meeting the student reps meeting um even
050the principles and even before I was elected starting 2020 I had served on an advisory committee and had lots of ideas on how I thought it could be better used and I think we've made some progress in not relying just on that report as it be all and all and we're going to have a focused set of days on that later but I think the benefit of these groups also is hearing from them and engaging with them throughout the year so I attend as many advisory committee meetings as I can for my my committee but I I wonder you know is doing need bylaws for a group that is meant to advise us I don't really know and I'm not ready to give consensus on it I also raises the bigger question of do we
051have topical areas that are best serving us right now I mean we've talked about do we should we have a technology focused advisory committee is it appropriate to have two committees focused well one's an advisory committee on facilities and ones our board committee on facilities is that still necessary given all that's changed including way more data about our um C our Capital programming and the boundary work it's like we're working on it all the time and we have all these other advisories you know I'd really like so one thing at a time I think yes let's do the operating manual but maybe in the next month or two can we start to think about what would it look like to talk with our colleagues and put up a process to say are these the right
052topical areas for this time for this School Division um but I do I would love to see us do something more where it's like I know in the past some members have had a quarterly meeting with all of their advisory committee members now I don't know if that is interesting for everyone because if you're interested in facilities and then you're talking about family life Ed you know but I try to do that you know oneof with a constituent but it's hard to do that and I wonder is there a better way to do this could we have quarterly meetings with you know the board and our committee members I don't know but I just think this approach is kind of I don't want to say stale but it needs some rethinking and I think the
053tool kit is a great step for having us rethink because we're asking people to give up their time away from their families and just one report is not often the biggest return on their investment so what do you all think about that um the only the the thing I wanted to mention was the bylaws are already currently in the operating manual so if we decide that we want them taken out of the operating manual the reason that we ensured that that was still there is because we have many committees that feel strongly that the bylaws that they have created are important to them and what I the reason that I liked the bylaws when I was talking to different groups um when I went in depth with this last year is the idea is is
054that it gives their group members an understanding of their process and it also gives them we gave some latitude in the operating manual to allow for the time timing of speakers the how many public speakers you could have how long they could speak There are rules that are specific to each individual group that as to how they want to deal with it depending on their topic um we have some Community advisory committees that have a ton of outside interest acsd is one of them they have a ton of people that come and talk so they need a place to codify rules that are related to how they operate well I agree but the state sanctioned ones are in a different category like advisory um or acsd but also on that matter I mean even the
055name the advisory committee for students with disability is different than the state's name for it so it gets confusing to some who are in that you know world like Oh you mean that's the state sanctioned committee so there are just these things that you know if it's a state mandated sure then they've got to have definitely the clarity but again even if there are bylaws fine but a bylaw Charter I'm not really sure I'd be open to considering if you know what what they need and what's what's consistent right let's stick with that theme of consistency could we ask whether or not is it okay with you if I ask all of the advisory committees to provide me a copy of what they currently have and that way we can kind of do a deep
056dive to figure out um what's what's being done because I agree the intention behind this was that the board was going to approve bylaws I don't think that's been done up to this point I think that they've just been approved by the Committees themselves which I do think goes outside the realm of what we're looking for I do think that there's some amount of oversight that we need to be able to provide to our committees um I know that the Committees do a ton of work and many of them have served on the on these committees for many many years so I don't want it to be absent of their voice in some of this um but I do want to make sure that we do have the consistency so I think that the next
057step on the bylaws would be to collect what exists and then we can I can bring them back we'll synthesize and bring back and I can look for commonalities in those documents and so that way we can come up with a path forward but I would like to put down that we do have this in the operating manual right now it was considered as part of the decision last year and so that is why I included it here is just to make sure that we we keep on track with that um committee websites is the same we want to make sure that we have a consistent consistent information that is outlined in the operating manual and so what I'm um suggesting for that is that we create a checklist that the chair and the liaison
058would use together to make sure that we had all the information that was appropriate on all of the websites and create kind of a consistency of look so that it's easy to find information when you go from one committee to another um there's a quarterly email update template that we were going to create that gave just a form that the that your liaison could send you about here the things that we're talking about or just general this may not be necessary I have several of my committee appointees that are awesome about keeping me up to date and I have others that I don't hear from very often and so trying to create some consistency that board members can use or not and they can we can give that to both them the other aspect of
059this is how are we going to train all of the committee members as to what this information is and so how can we make sure that they get it across and that's where I defitely want feedback from you guys of what should that look like how are we going to syn this obviously they'll receive a copy of the full operating manual but how do we synthesize it down to be digestible particularly for new members I would very much like to have this done before the new folks come on on August 1st and so that is that's a little bit tighter of a timeline to see what we need to get developed but if you guys have any idea ideas about how we want to might want to do that that would be awesome my inclination
060would be to create kind of like a cheat sheet for the for the document and kind of point out the points that are board facing and then here are the responsibilities of your board member here are your responsibilities here's your staff leaz on responsibilities I this may be a coming down to when the you school board members actually have all their appoin is lined up and have them appointed because sometimes we have difficulties feeling certain positions right and but you know answering your question if there could be before they actually start their work in August or September if there could be a orientation for all the advisor committee meetings and and and someone from school board in know office whether it's a chair or P committee chair you could come and share with them the
061expectations from the board and and also explain them the information that are being given to them as a tools uh that should be looking at and should be using I mean they will they will help them to uh I think the intention was to create kind of a webinar to do it and then record the webinar so that it could be utilized to create a class that was just a quick training that was available for people that came on after the fact is that still that was the direction that the committee had come up with last year is that still something that were that you guys think would work is to kind of so you create that face that time but at the same time uh uh you know giving those committee members if there
062were question to ask question to ask and ask rather than know jump it would be a moderated group so I think that would be a really easy way to do that and then you could use that to create you know we're not going to force everybody attend but if the you know brand new appointees doing the first time might you know benefit from you know such opportunities and I was going to go to you if I may what melan you know said earlier about how we can best to utilize the work of the Committees uh what the committee members they put in a lot of their time as a volunteers to help us is that uh you know correct me if I'm wrong but I still don't see this been a this been a consistent
063challenge over many years so it's not just a this bold or pandemic bold but going back to a mid99s so uh committee members do a lot of work on the charges we give to them and and and at the end of the school year they bring B reports to us and then we we Jam them in two three nights or two three days and then we get a lot of reports and and both members have a tough time being able to digest all of those and then we get you know sometimes in the reports themselves we get steps responses to their recommendations is that they all comment and or or we get those responses subsequently later two months down the road Etc but if the advisory committees are there to advise the school board and
064bringing recommendations School Board School Board got to provide its actions responses to a D recommendation that part has been pretty lacking pretty lacking because I guess we are all busy the board members are busy because that may require in a scheduling additional meetings but I don't think we have given a try uh each response time by the board does not have to be 2 hour long or even an hour long but I think we I think those committee members deserve more respect from us of their work because they're advising us but we're not really saying to them whether we're going to do it or not going to do it or or thank you no thank you or we don't do that other than those pref Peri of time when we have Q&A so we are
065[Music] just very quickly go through the reports ask a few questions and go to next one and then put it aside I mean that's been the consistent way of things handled over the years I think we got to be able to do it better than that um so I'm just going to talk about my past experience when I worked with some advisory boards and also what I'm learning now being on the school board a lot of the recommendations that come forth take time and I'm just going to speak specifically to when we were looking at parently aons and um getting them a contract it took several advisory committees came up with the recommendation that that should happen but it took some time for that to happen because there's the budgetary constraints there's a lot of
066things that go on and so I think I agree with you that we have to have a response um but there are some things that I'm realizing that we can't act on immediately but we can be working on and we can say okay we're working on it help us you know as their charges are going how can we move this forward and I know for the parent for the well now the family Lees on position I think it took a good seven years for it to get to it's it's still not where it should be because not all schools have a full-time family leison but I know when I was working on that and I know that there were several um advisory committees that were recommending this is you know all schools should have a
067full-time family leason but there were budget budgetary constraints there there was a lot of Hoops that had to be overcome that still have not been overcome so I think what's important for us to communicate to the advisory committee reports is that we're working on it and then we're going to take that some we can act on immediately and some it's going to take time I mean I'm just talking from my experience I know melan has a black but you know if I could just respond quickly that could be our response right that could be way it sounds like uh uh uh based up the information we got from the staff that's going to require us to invest another $50 million and which we don't have and they may require 10e approach fiveyear approach we do
068you ask for 100 positions maybe we start with a five positions I know that's it's a small por but or you know I I think there's another issues that I think is more urgent for us to deal with so I will put that you know somewhere you set that aside but we work on these something we need to I think because we are respecting their work but we're not really responding to uh you know their work I I appreciate that point Mr Moon and I and I agree with you and just getting back to the idea of how we more regularly interact like what if the advisory committee like what if in the month of January February each of us goes to the our committee and but the structure of that is like a feedback
069session and a discussion and it could be more than one of us right because we wouldn't need Quorum because we're not voting it could be you know it could be advertised as a public meeting so any of us could go um but it's spreading that out and then we do that again in May or June or we just do it in May or June now the benefit of that is if we're talking in January February that could inform the budget process and then if it's May or June well we've got the budget behind us and now we're looking at the next year I would probably want a richer facilitated dialogue over a report or at least maybe it's a short memo that they're providing but I've seen mixed things like I've seen some committees give
070really outstanding recommendations and yes staff has responded but yeah what does the board do you know there's a lot of information we get that we don't always act on you know I've talked about with the CIP we have 300 pages of recommendations and input from the superintendent that we haven't yet looked at in a year so there's that whole idea of how did the board respond to you know input that we're getting but um again just looking at other models of committees you know I again like if even if I went to all my advisory communes it's just me but I'm writing here now I'm like okay I want to make sure that I update my colleagues on this this and this but then we're back to all of us we need to check in
071together so I appreciate calling it out that it's board Behavior but I do wonder if even for this coming year I know again we have these two Saturday meetings which are a challenge for me personally to attend but could we have you know maybe four of us go to you know the advanced academic committee and five go to the other one because I think what people really want is that FaceTime and to be heard and have a dialogue and maybe it's not us saying we're going to adopt these recommendations but we're going to really be informed by what they've done and I will say that I think that that's part of the intention behind the quarterly update is that the committee would have the ability to create that document um that gives us an update
072and then it would be sent to All board members so at least then that is a step towards the right direction that I think is sustainable at this point where we can build it into something bigger as we move through but at least getting those quarterly Updates this is how it's going this is you know these are the pro the issues that we're determining you know these are the research points like those are the types of things that gives us a way to just have some feedback from them as we're moving forward so if you guys have ideas that's one of the it's one of the smaller portions of what we need to do here so if you have ideas of what should be included in that quarterly email template please let me know and
073so that way when we're creating that document that they could utilize and I intend for that to be like a one-page pretty easy to do kind of thing um but just gives the board a fair amount of EX of information I haven't been a liaison to an actual advisory committee yet because I've been in other things um and so it's very possible like some of us just don't know how they work um and it could be that they don't have any update that they need to provide because if you're talking quarterly and it's in the fall they may not have anything for us yet but it could be that you they let you know what guest speakers they're hoping to do are we having any retreats upcoming events that kind of thing I went to
074The fpac Retreat last year and it was awesome to to hear the guest speaker that they brought in that was talking about um the PPE OPP opportunities that they were utilizing in their division so there's some really cool stuff that we could that we could look at and so I think that that you're you're 100% right getting away to hear those updates as we go it gives people the interest all of these meetings are public so they're already they're already published that way so any of us could go to anything and we just need to to figure out which ones we're really excited about going to see because they're bringing in a guest speaker or they're doing that's the type of stuff that I would love to hear populated more often so we do get
075the staff responses from uh the recommendations we but we usually get those in September October we do post them to board dos one of the things I will say is looking through them sometimes they agree sometimes they don't but we don't necessarily give a board response to the recommendations so that may be something that board members want to think about as well right like the staff's responding but once we get the staff response even if it's the next fall whether you know considering what the staff have to say and then figuring out if the board wants to give a response because I think that is sometimes different one of the other things that was done under the passport is uh Miss omes when she was on the board was working with Miss Tolen to try
076to get things incorporated into the budget because that was some of the concerns that were raised too is that ideas were coming forward they had budgetary implications and the board wasn't really doing anything with them so that's something else to consider so again getting steps to respones one thing but Po's responding is another po could disagree with a staff a poll could disagree with the advisory committees but whether it's half an hour or 1 hour session have that and giving something back could be a one thing could be there could be nothing or there could be tons but that's all depending upon how we want to control our time but I think in as much as we tell our appointed that we appreciate their work by actually putting into an action by letting them know
077how we are reacting to their recommendation I think is hasn't been done for I haven't seen that being done but I think if we this board can do it that will be a huge milestone I concur it's um it's a level of respect and gratitude that is invaluable okay so one of the other things that I asked um Miss Miss St John cunning to put on the agenda for today was related to something that we had discussed previously but I wanted to bring back back up as when I was going through all of these documents again it it again reiterated The Forum topic that I brought up last year related to which advisory committees we have and things like that um I would like to make a motion that the board recommend that the fleak
078advisory committee be converted into a curriculum committee um the same or curriculum Review Committee the same way as every other one um right now the board's this is the only curriculum Review Committee that sits with the board all changes related to fle would still have to come to the board for a vote but I have spoken with the superintendent um and it I have requested and whether or not she would agree to us moving this into a curriculum Review Committee that is the same as every other curriculum Review Committee that we have that gives the committee the space to have the conversation about their curriculum before it would still have our appointees the same way as the the math and social studies are doing now um but it would it would give them the space
079to have the conversation about what needs to be in the curriculum without the the intense public scrutiny particularly for this topic that's going on and I will renew my concern about the fact that we have students that are on this committee and I would like to make sure that they are protected as they are moving forward um that just the nature of having it be an advisory committee forces it in a very public way um rather rather than giving the space and then the board will discuss what the curricul the curriculum recommendations are without the int the focus on our appointees and the students so I am making a motion that I would request that we send a recommendation to the full board that this be transferred into we would maintain all of that everything
080is going to act the same way because this is actually the only committee we have that's in regulation and so it's already being acted on as if it's the the superintendent committee it's just right now it lives under us so I appreciate that is there a second well we got to figure out the exact language but yeah yeah thank you for for doing that and that analysis um I agree it gets um outsized attention and it gets pretty ugly and that's not fair for anyone who's volunteering their time I um so would it meet regularly or would it come together when there are in fact changes like this math basil committee I think that from what I understand I'm not sure that the functionality of the committee would change in any way except for the
081fact that they would have the opportunity to actually examine their work in a way and then bring the full recommendation to the board this again is a different committee than any other that this the only one that is the chair as a staff member um like so with it's already acting as a curriculum Review Committee in the same way that the math or the Bas or the social studies would this just changes the functionality to be in line with the curriculum review and I did determine last year when I was working heavily on the operating uh manual there is no legal requirement for us to have an advisory committee the legal requirement is that we have fle and that we vote on fle when changes are made outside the state requirements and so we would
082still be doing everything and it still is our decision um this just changes the actual way that the committee is working well you had me at consistent so um so are we prepared to take a vote on this uh I'm not going to support that but but but but I'm prepared to vote okay so can we get the exact language I I make a motion that we that the chair of the pet committee takes a recommendation to the full board to convert the Family Life Education advisory committee to being a curriculum Review Committee under the superintendent's office in and I would like to add in line with all other curriculum review committees or and I will send out information to the board that explains the nuances of the fact that it would keep and I
083will talk to the superintendent about how we want to do that but it would it would keep the same structure it would just it's just who whose office it sits under that's not the part of the motion right no that's my explaining why what I'm going to do next okay all those in favor right oh oh okay and this is where I asked you want to speak to your motion can I just a point of word I want to make sure that I understand this correct because we haven't done this type of motion coming out of PEC before is the motion to take it to the full committee or is the motion to actually change the language of the of the governance manual to adopt this change but that's what I I am asking for
084a clarification of just could I the process could I as far as the language is concerned could I suggest that uh for your consideration ation a motion to state that p p is name of the commit right pack recommends to the full board to convert fully C to and the rest of them is well to adjust all well it's it's about adjusting all governing documents to to move Fleek act so it's not it's not it's not chair of the public engagement committee but it is yes moves that the public engagement committee recommends to the full board to convert that's the motion we we are committee is I got you recommended always the lawyers and adjust all governing documents because this is going to need to be changed in the policy the operating manual and the
085I mean this as technical as that is like this is actually what the governance committee is discussing what's the format when we do things for changes and so I would think that you know if we're going to convert something all the things are going to have to be changed so I don't particularly think it needs all the technical like let's list out every place it has to be changed everywhere because then what about training and what about you know like let's we want to recommend to the board that the board direct the superintendent to right because the superintendent's going to have to the super no the the regulation already exists we're nothing with that is going to have to change it's only our documents that would have to change and pec was in charge of
086making all those changes to those documents we did not send that through governance last year so that's why I'm saying that we're going to recommend that we do it that we'll we'll bring the changes with us so um I mean technically we got to adjust the governing do documents you have to communicate it out I mean do we want to list all the steps it's going to take or we're just saying we're going to you know what I'm saying like how micro do we need to get in the list of to-dos well logistically I'm asking how we did it when we when we removed H when we when we removed um atra we actually just changed the go well all the only thing we voted on was changing the actual documents we changed the governance
087manual and we changed the policy right in order to do it so we could do it a few different ways you could do it that you recommend to the full School Board to convert Fleek and so that's why I add it and adjust all governing documents to be line with the change and then that way to miss Marin's point you don't have to list everything that's fine that way it it gets to what we're trying to do which would be the governance manual um and right so you're recommending to the full school board so what we can do there is after you have your motion we can then take work I can work with Miss St John cunning to make sure that we have the documents that need to be so that when you bring
088the motion to the full board um everything is posted on board docs accordingly ab and I'm happy to help you with I with the red line on that so does this motion work Miss Marin you're good secondy okay and do you would you like to speak to your motion okay so we already voted didn't we no okay so all those in favor opposed oh abstained okay so 3 4 1 abstain what is three in favor one abstain the motion carries right the motion passes I'm learning the lingo here and those are all the updates that I have related to the operating manual I'm looking at this very quickly give me one second so just I just wanted to mention on the part of the what we were looking at the structure and framework which Miss
089Anderson was discussing and where um we're talking about the user experience and where the minutes and agendas were all posted um uh we're going to we've started an audit to see how that's all done again going to consistency that we will bring back to tell you where everything is and see how we can have that consistency for each of access to the public in terms of making sure again like we were talking is it you know is it on board doogs is it on the web page how's it done and so we're working on doing that audit audit right now um and as far as um I think that is all that I have today if there's anything else that anybody is interested in bringing up and discussing I know we all want to get
090on the road before the storm yes this was a stormy session so yes this is a sto well this was the Calm before the storm so um the February 11 2025 meeting of the Fairfax County Schoolboard public engagement committee is adjourned at um 11:13 the next meeting of the public engagement committee will be held on March 18th 2025 be safe stay warm you know how we conduct this meeting pack committee is a model for all other committees thank you guys