001session um this part that will be moderated by myself and misss diit um very shortly is the goal three report and knowing this is the heart and the meat of our work we are here to this is our rais on debt we are here to speak about how our students are doing academically that's the purpose of this entire organization we do a lot of other things but this is the core and before we turn it over to staff I would like to turn over to Dr Reed for an introduction thank you Dr Anderson members of the board this morning our goal three report um as Dr Anderson mentioned is our core work here in Fairfax County Public Schools indeed it's the core work around our country right now and uh while all uh matters of
002uh topics are swirling it's critical that we stay focused on the education of our uh Young people there's never been a time that education has been more important um in this country and this morning it's uh my pleasure and with great pride that I talk about the team that's going to bring us our goal three report and this team is critical there is no one Department that is responsible for the academic success of all of our students here in Fairfax County it is a collaborative effort Learning Happens best in community and our community needs to remain together as we focus on the needs of each and every one of our students while we're going to look at some data that we're really excited to show gains with there'll be other data this morning that uh
003we're making First Steps in terms of addressing that we look forward to accelerating progress in the coming uh weeks and years but this morning I want to make sure that our community understands that our chief academic officer uh Dr precidio our chief Equity officer Dr King and our chief of schools Dr Pon are working together because all three departments are critical to achieving the goals here of um a world class education here in Fairfax County Public Schools for each and every student and frankly um our future as a nation depends on that so at this point I'd like to turn the presentation over presentation over to miss Neil who has guided the presentation pieces um and then the board we have um all of our chief officers present at the table for questions and a
004discussion so thank you Miss Neil before we get started Miss Neil I have to bring one of our board members in Mr Dunn has submitted a written request to attend this morning's meeting virtually due to a personal conflict as he has a professional obligation as it is and is attending tonight's meeting from I'm sorry this morning's meeting from Mount Vernon Virginia all those in favor of approving Mr Dunn's request that is unanimous thank you Mr Dunn please check your audio and video Mr gun's not on yet we'll let you know so we will check when he comes just kind of a lay of the land folks um this report has three components there is the reading component the math component and the advanced coursework component we will take each of these components separately and ask
005questions after each one we will do one round of questions after each section and at the end depending on the time that we have left then you are free to go back and ask questions regarding all three components we will start each of those first rounds at three minutes and we will make an adjustment at the end depending on the time we have left Miss Neil thank you Dr Anderson Dr Reen good morning members of the board um we're going to go ahead if we can get the slides up please and if we could thank you go ahead and progress to slide two please all right our objectives for today are to provide the board with an update on our progress towards meeting our goal three measures to talk about the work FCPS is doing
006related to goal three and then to talk about the policy budget and strategic considerations for the board moving forward to achieve our goals uh we are today our presentation is focused on goal three which as was stated previously is our academic growth and excellence goal uh there are six measures in goal three and today they are all on the screen and today we're going to be focusing in on measures C D and F and the data for the remaining measures are in the full report that is posted on board docs uh several initial priorities were identified by division leadership to focus the efforts of both our schools and our departments with the understanding that these are key drivers for Success across multiple measures within our strategic plan and during today's presentation we're going as Dr
007Anderson said we're going to be looking at reading by third grade algebra 1 by 8th grade and advanced cour workk in high school and as a reminder to our public our annual goal reports include outcome data from last school year compared to our Baseline data and annual targets that we've set in order to meet our 2030 goals all of the data in these reports were aligned to a consistent student data source and match videoe reporting methodology when it's applicable and this report also Prov provides contextual data and an update on our strategic efforts across the division so for the first section of this presentation we're going to look at our reading by the end of third grade data by the end of third grade our students are moving away from learning to read to reading
008to learn where reading becomes a tool to gain and apply knowledge in a range of subjects reading on grade level is linked to other strategic plan goal measures including persistence in advanced coursework graduating on time and enrolling in college so a sustained focus on reading in third grade should positively impact several other goal measures the national research identifies several factors that contribute to reading on grade level such as division factors related to professional development and systems in place to identify intervene with and monitor students who are at risk classroom level factors including the use of evidence-based literacy instruction and teacher Knowledge and Skills and student and family factors including Reading Readiness such as prek access regular School attendance and ongoing support for learning including reading at home before we review the data I want to
009start with the key takeaways and then we'll further dive into to these we're currently using the so and the VAP data to measure reading by third grade and our report examines last year's so data compared to the Baseline and I do want to remind everyone as Dr Reed said this data represents the outcomes from last year's spring so testing that occurred prior to several significant shifts in practice and FCPS around literacy last year's results showed that third grade so Rate rates were up 1% from the Baseline which was three percentage points below our Target for last year no student group had a pass rate within five percentage points of the division average which indicates a wide disparity in Reading performance among student groups and a need to better serve our students who are not yet
010reading on grade level we are going to look more closely at our VAP insights on a subsequent slide over the past three years FCPS has outperformed Virginia overall with regard to the passing on read the reading in third grade when compared to Northern Virginia wavy districts over the past three years FCPS has shown similar results on the reading the third grade reading so overall Pass rates on grade three reading so increased by one percentage point from the Baseline and the data reflects assessments given prior to the adoption of the basil the adoption of the new Val screener in primary grades implementation of required reading PL and implementation of additional required PD students with 504 plans white asian and multi-racial students had higher than average Pass rates multilingual Learners had the lowest pass rate followed by
011students who were economically disadvantaged and Hispanic students our Hispanic students who were not multilingual Learners however had a pass rate of 61% which reinforces the importance of examining intersectionality data which is available in the full report it's also important to consider that 60% of the students students who did not pass the reading were economically disadvantaged and then finally on this slide in the last row of the chart you can see the targets for last year and in green you can see where FCPS hit the annual targets we've set for ourselves as we've shared in previous reports the annual targets are based on the growth needed each year to remain on track for our 2030 goals and this slide shows the growth lines from the Baseline last year our overall reading scores fell below our annual
012Target meaning we will will need to make more growth this year to remain on track for our 2030 goals this slide looks at our VAP performance on the third grade reading and as a reminder the VAP assessment is given to students instructed with the Adaptive curriculum beginning in grade three last year we had 60 students participate in this assessment and there was an overall decline in scores from the Baseline and the full report does have data by student group for the VAP which in many cases was too small to report because of size as you can see from the growth line we're not currently on track to meet our 2030 goals and we'll need to continue to focus on this metric this slide examines third grade reading performance as it relates to two other strategic
013priorities chronic absenteeism and prek experience students who were not chronically absent had higher Pass rates than students who were chronically absent and students with prek experience had substantially higher Pass rates on the so than students without a prek experience this data reinforces is the interconnectedness between our goals within the Strategic plan and the importance of multiple aspects of student experiences on these outcome measures this slide examines select intersectional intersectionality data with additional data available in the full report students were economically disadvantaged but not multilingual Learners the second bar in the gray second bar from the top in Gray had the highest Pass rates of this group that was examined and students who are multilingual Learners with IEP the final bar in blue had the lowest Pass rates of any groups examined we do see that
014ELP level is closely tied to outcomes on the third grade reading so so our students who are categorized as ELP level four had scores that surpassed the division average by 23 percentage points and our former multilingual Learners had a 98% pass rate on the reading so the highest of any student group examined for this report here we see differences in performance for students with disabilities as a reminder students categorized as level one are those students that receive special education services for less than 50% of their instructional day and level two receive special education services for more than 50% of their instructional day students categorized as level two had a substantially lower pass rate compared to level one and the division average now we're going to transition to talk about the work the division is doing
015focused on improving outcomes for reading by third grade so FCPS is currently focused on a combination of universal and targeted efforts to improve reading outcomes un Universal efforts are happening in all of our elementary schools and include the work that has been done to standardize curriculum and instructional delivery and to align with evidence-based practices targeted work is happening at the school level supporting schools with higher rates of students who are at risk or struggling with raing and at the student level by providing personalized supports for students who have individual challenges with rating on the next few slides we're going to highlight several of the actions within this approach and the full report does have additional details about these strategies as well so we've been working to standardize evidence-based literacy instruction across the division this work
016began as a part of the Equitable access to literacy plan in the division and then merg this year with the requirements of the Virginia literacy act it includes uh it includes the implementation of a common literacy curriculum across our k6 classrooms that's our Benchmark Advance as a part of the division's implementation of a basil and the literacy core teams who monitor their schools implementation of evidence-based literacy instruction and develop actions to improve implementation to support this work ongoing professional learning for teachers and staff continues to be provided to identify students who may need more support the vals risk-based screeners are administered to all primary grade students at various points throughout the year and common assessments are also being used to monitor student progress consistent with previous years all of our schools continue to have a
017reading by third grade goal and Associated action plan in their Sip and finally we continue to utilize Lexia Core 5 which is an evidence-based program that provides students with personalized learning pathway based on their placement test and progress within the program FCPS is providing targeted support resources and monitoring to identified schools where there are larger numbers of students struggling with reading and larger numbers not making weeda progress schools that had low growth in Mastery in grades 1 and two in reading last year are supported through the project momentum early literacy Focus these schools have quarterly meetings to review reading progress and principles are required to provide teachers feedback a minimum of three times per week using walkthrough forms aligned to Benchmark project momentum schools that had less than 50% of students making adequate waeda progress
018also receive support to ensure progress monitoring and the implementation of tier 2 and tier three instruction and finally our Title One schools have the ability to use their Title One School budgets to hire additional staff to support literacy and also have access to centrally funded training opportunities and literacy support for school teams students who are identified as high- risk receive instructional in individualized student reading plans and an additional 2 and a half hours of intervention instruction per week in some schools with larger numbers of students requiring support a walk to intervention model is also utilized where students are grouped across grade level based on need and then walk to their intervention group to receive targeted instruction during this block this model puts additional staff Beyond grade level teachers to work with intervention groups ensuring group
019size stays as small as possible and the intervention for the group of students is specific to their need and then finally last summer additional supports for atris students were provided through summer learning programs our targeted student supports also include a focus on multilingual Learners in the goal one presentation we discuss many of the strategies focused on English language development including the purchase of Benchmark Express as the new Elementary basil resource for English language development which aligns to Benchmark advance and continued training of teachers and project glad strategies which are research-based and strategies and support language acquisition and proficiency and grade level standards FCPS is also focused on targeted supports for students with dis abilities we have a dyslexia specialist who provides support for identifying and serving students with dyslexia and Related Disorders and provides training
020and support to local reading Specialists who serve as dyslexia advisers for their school in addition FCPS is providing evidence-based literacy instruction training for staff who work with students who access an adapted curriculum and then finally our reading by third grade goal Innovation team will continue to identify ways to improve reading outcomes in particular in the areas of concern identified in this report and this will continue to inform future division-wide strategies and at this point I'll turn it back to our meeting managers thank you very much for that very very quick presentation U maybe just slow down just a little um with the next one and we have our first Speaker Mr frish thank you since we are going to do several rounds of Q&A I just have a couple questions um can you talk about
021the evidence that the universal the universal approach and the targeted supports identified on slides 20 through 22 have they they're effective and secondarily related to that we've embarked on a transition to the science of reading something this board is very committed to I'd like to know what the typical Arc of impact is on a transition like that we're certainly the first school division to transition to the science of reading when should we start seeing meaningful results from it well thank you for those questions I'll start and then certainly any of my colleagues please feel free to jump in I think your first question was really around like the efficacy of the strategies that we're using right now and I would say to some extent in relationship to your second question it's a little bit early
022to to really be able to answer that question fully what we do know from the research base is that you particularly as a aains to the science of reading you have to have a comprehensive viable curriculum implemented consistently in every classroom across the School Division so the adoption of Benchmark Advance is is really huge for us as a School Division because we didn't have that Core curriculum for 20 years in the school division so we had a lot of variation from classroom to classroom this obviously is the first year of implementation so we're not going to see results of that um the earliest we would really see results of that would be the end of this year but I think it's going to take more years uh before we see results often times when you
023implement new curriculum what you'll see at least in the evidence base is a implementation dip where scores might actually go down because people are doing things in new ways and they're still developing their own self-efficacy in that and then you'll see a trajectory rise with outcomes what I will say though is we're not just looking at so scores when we're looking at success metrics on some of these things so we have other ways to measure success some of it's qualitative just what we're seeing and hearing from teachers and principles and how they're reacting to the instruction what we're seeing and hearing with our students and and with our families and that's all really positive additionally we have more quantitative measures like our I ready results which are the screening and progress monitoring measure that we've
024used consistently for a number of years at the primary grades K K through three and one of the things that we've seen just even this year in terms of growth is that students at the third grade level on the IR measure are performing uh more students are performing at that Benchmark that would correlate with success on the so so we've established internally benchmarks with like a 95% confidence interval to say if a student achieves this score they're going to pass the so we've seen growth in the number of students that are hitting that Target by around four to 5% at mid year so that's all signaling that things are starting to click and we have other data points as well but the first thing is the curriculum and so we're seeing some impact of that
025right now I think the second thing is the professional development and training to make sure that everybody uh in our classrooms know how to use the materials and are comfortable with them the work that we've done um around professional development I think has has been really strong having that additional time uh for elementary teachers on Mondays to complete not just our professional development but the required professional development from the state has has been very uh well met and well received by folks in our schools so the curriculum the professional development and then the continued progress monitoring and support so again we're looking at a lot of different data points as I describ but it's a little too early I think to see results in the the measures that we have here but we can see
026them in some of the more discreet measures and then the one thing I would say is like if we're thinking about that third grade measure with implementation of our materials this year starting at kindergarten we're still obviously three years out before you know we would really see the full impact of students who have been instructed from the day they walk into FCPS as a kindergartener in science of reading with our new materials our new strategies and our new supports it's going to be three three years before we see the the full impact of some of those changes I think I'd like to see when this comes to the board at the regular meeting is some in the presentation perhaps in the materials perhaps more about these indicators that you all are watching I did write
027down dashboard I wonder if they have a dashboard where they're monitoring things that we're not seeing I had looked in the report for anything on along these lines I already gets passing reference so it'd be good to have two things in the regular meeting discussion one what are the indicators that you're monitoring on a day-to-day basis we've heard a lot from the superintendent about the importance of not just waiting a year to see where we are right and so what are those things and then also how we expect to start seeing the impact here um you know I I don't think anybody was expecting things to turn on a dime but we should be previewing for people when we're presenting this people are not patient right so we need to provide additional information for the
028context um secondarily on slide 16 uh you had 93% for our multilingual Learners who have English proficiency um and I'm curious because they've had as much time with the new uh instructional support and materials as anyone else is that a product of the more specialized and focused attention that they've received as multilingual Learners and if it's not just that what can we learn from this student population to impact other hardto move populations yeah I think that's an excellent question I you know obviously some of the things that we've done to support multilingual Learners I think are showing up in this data set for example when we purchase The Benchmark curriculum we also purchase Benchmark Express which is English language development curriculum that focuses on uh listening speaking reading and writing right all four domains of
029the the literacy domains there what what I think you're seeing on this slide though and why we included it in here is these Trends have been true in previous reports right we know that the more time a student has to develop their language English language proficiency the better they do on these standardized measures and pretty much in any any subject area when a student has exited or is close to exiting uh multilingual language learner support ELD support they're performing at or above the division averages so this is really to say like a lot of students that are at that level one and level two they have not had enough time to develop the academic language Proficiency in English that they're going to need to be successful on some of these standardized tests and we're seeing
030Even in our data a slight shift uh this past year to having about 4% more of our students falling in the level one and level two category and about 4% fewer falling in level three and level four so we've seen even a slight shift at students on that lower end of proficiency and this is just a signal that those are the students that we really have to track we really have to monitor we really have to support with individual plans to make sure that they're making progress so that you know we can continue to see these kinds of success rates but also as much as possible accelerate their academic uh English development so I think in sub ways it's more probably a product of time so well and and I'm not even just comparing level
031one to former or level two to former I'm comparing former to the rest of the student body right 20% plus higher than the the average FCPS student says something and I'm curious and you know we don't have to get into it I only have 30 seconds left I'm curious what we can learn from from that focused attention that they've received as ELP students um or as multilingual Learners um what we can learn for that for impact on other student populations that have been hard to move even with the the new materials thank you very much Mr Moon thank you Dr and thereon I I am going to I start with where Mr chairman was asking some questions on uh SL number 16 that from me no okay uh I am interested in knowing the demographic
032of level four and formal ml whether it is skewed toward certain characteristics and also if he could also share with us uh number of students actual number population the end uh whether we are dealing with a small number or it's you know their performance might be at the top but it could be a small sample small small number overall [Music] and looking at since Mr chairman also raised how uh level four and foral ml could be substantially higher than our average you know passing rate of what we have 71% 70% if we did ex if we did exclude exclude let's say from that our population or of the uh multilingual owners you know students receiving a a special education uh what would that look like whether they would mirror level four or ml whether it's
033it's a similar demographic so and I also want to see for the level one and level two and even level three I want to see the demographic information of those because I I don't have a the percentage with me now but a substantially larger portion of certain group you know receive a a English language they are multilingual Learners and whether they are the ones who may be requiring a lot more support from us uh to improve their language acquisition uh so if you could provide with those demographic information will be helpful for me to ask some followup questions and I am going to go to an earlier slide number 10 which you know comparing our score with ddom Virginia order distri D Virginia for sy23 and 24 our is about a percent below is a
034percent below a substantial amount or is very negligible or if it is okay okay you had quite a bit in there would staff like to respond yeah we'll we'll try to give a quick response to some of them um you asked about on slide 16 about the numbers um the numbers are on the slide so it's about a couple hundred students uh if we can go back in the presentation to slide 16 you can see for each of those years the adjusted Baseline and 23 24 for each level how many students we're talking about so we have a lot of students in level two and three fewer students at level one and level four um so the numbers are there we don't have the demographics I think we're going to have to yeah we can
035pull that up but we'll have to do that offline and and get that to you and board members so we can do that for uh levels one through three and then you had asked about if we had looked at removing certain uh subgroups I guess if you will from the perform reading performance and what would it be if we did that we'd we'd have to do that offline too um one thing I'll say though just in terms of like speculating like what are some of the biggest challenges in terms of moving the division overall rate one of the biggest challenges is our students that are economically disadvantaged right so and when we look at the intersectionality of students that are economically disadvantaged in multilingual Learners those students are really really struggling right or students that
036are economically disadvantaged and have disabilities those students are really struggling so that intersectionality um part of the report I think becomes really important um but we can provide that additional information uh that you requested by trying to remove some of the subgroups Dr Reed yeah thank you Dr Anderson uh one of our key strategies moving forward which we're just launching this year is the ability to look at common assessments across the division to actually be more laser focused on providing supports in real time Dr pidio will you talk about the importance of that initiative please yeah it's incredibly important and I want to thank Dr Pon and his leadership for really encouraging us to look at some of other curriculum based measures we had things like I ready s sols and other measures but having
037that curriculum based measure is really important because that's telling us how are the students responding to the instruction that they're getting in the classroom and what does that look like from classroom to classroom and school to school and that allows us within a school to identify those students using our multiple measures that need the additional support and that's part of our multi-tiered system of support process when we identify students that aren't at the benchmarks that we would like them to be add on those common assessments and other other measures we develop individualized reading plans for students and ensure that they get additional instructional time so miss Neil talked about um a minimum of 30 minutes of additional instructional time for students that are on those reading plans but again those curriculum based assessments those common
038assessments are really helpful to identify students but they're also helpful for us to look at where are maybe students struggling across a particular grade level across the county and that helps us maybe provide more resources and guidance for teachers around the implementation of the new materials or even adjusting um some of our supports to schools that might be struggling across the school so having that additional data is incredibly helpful we have created a data dashboard with that that we can look and monitor school by School in terms of their performance on that measure along with some of the other measures like vals and I ready so I asked Dr Presidio to frame that because it's critical to understand that sometimes in our past not all students had access to these types of Assessments so therefore
039the ability to determine whether they were at grade level in Real Time didn't exist so right now this is a critical piece of strategy that we're launching this year that every child receives instruction at grade level Dr Pon you've had a lot of experience with common assessments just briefly would you share why this is so important for the board and Community to understand the power of this strategy um yes thank you um I know that some of you have been uh listening from uh some principles about a common assessment and how we are being very intentional uh two things that we are trying number one is the uh ontime data where you will be able to modify the lessons and provide the um uh intervention to the child accordingly something else that is is it's
040going to be uh you're going to see how going up the evolution will be the school Improvement plan the school Improvement implementation plan uh a living document and and that's sometimes we have been just been very static just uh having a goal but no necessarily uh modifying accordingly with the strategy that we are doing and so uh that's why uh it's very important uh I'm very pleased how uh principles and the region have been working all together this is the first year I know we have a lot of uh as we move forward you're going to see a very um uh strong uh program testing program where uh we're going to have the data immediately so we can modify we will not be able we will be able to modify on time and not at
041the end of the school year when you already have long time to cover so we are very pleased uh in my past uh work we did it and it was very uh useful for teachers principles and for uh the whole division to make sure that we uh do some changes importantly thank you Dr Pon if I may ask staff I know this is a very important topic for all of us but if I could ask for a little bit more suain in your responses because we have a lot of speakers and two other components to go and I want to be sure we get to all of them um our next speaker is Miss Marin followed by Miss Lady thank you I want to start off by saying that the work of being literate does
042not happen solely inside our school system uh we do not control how children are rri at our schools whether it's at the start of kindergarten or other ways I also want to point out that um dyslexia affects 20% of the population and represents 80 to 90% of all those with learning disabilities that's according to the Yale Center on um dyslexia and creativity so it is the most common of all neurocognitive disorders now the good thing is that our literacy curriculum um it does help all readers because reading is not a natural thing so all readers will benefit from a very strong foundational literacy but those who have a disorder will be identified earlier and get what they need so I keep that in mind as I review these results I wanted to ask more about
043um to the superintendent um she mentioned that the common assessments across FCPS is a valuable uh metric given that our education policies are very at the state and National level are very politicized right now I'm hardpressed to put all of my confidence in the state standards and such um I'm I I do have confidence in the Virginia literacy act and what it's put forth but Dr Reid what metrics do you think are most valuable and have Fidelity so that we can make sure that we are doing the best at teaching our children to read well thank you Miss Marin I it's really important that we understand that the most important work in the school division happens in the classroom right it's that interaction between a teacher support staff the student and the content presented it's
044critical that content at grade level be presented to every child regardless of the content area math right uh reading uh writing science Etc what's then critical is that uh intervention um or enrichment occurs following the grade level instruction so I think that what I think about when I think about assessment is our teachers know the students in their class the best right because they're with them every day um and so classroom based or embedded assessments I think are most critical in the classroom and for us as a school division by region by pyramid it's important for us to be able to look at how our students doing on what we are teaching in the classroom which is why the common assessments are being crafted from our curriculum here in Fairfax County Public Schools and so
045that our students are uh being assessed on what they're being taught right so that there's an alignment between the written taught and tested uh curriculum so these common assessments enable us to do what the board has really been um requesting on a number of topics and that's to move to more of a school system and less of a system of schools if we provide common assessments whether you're um in Franconia uh or in Spring West Springfield or Centerville or whatever part of the county we're able to look in real time to make sure for example that all second graders are uh performing at a reasonable grade level and where they are not we can apply resources strategically in real time um so I think that it's really what's happening in our classrooms that we want
046to stay focused on rather than nape for example which I'll talk about Thursday night which tested fewer than 500 of our Fairfax County Public School students not even 1% of our children well thank you you and you know I'm just sitting here thinking about how complex it is to determine you know what we are teaching is what children need and what is best it's it's hard to kind of just pull this one thread out I will say I agree that the I ready scores are an optimistic signal um anecdotally I hear from students and teachers that students are writing a lot more to the uh not so happiness of some students but um I'm certainly happy seeing books of the um consumables coming home full of writing it's really a a market difference so um
047just a few quick questions what are all the grades in which Lexia is required for use and what additional grades is it offered as an option or tool thank you Miss Marin um we are expecting schools to use this in grades K through 8 um and I'm looking over at my team to make sure that I'm correct um it's used in different ways um but a lot of times during it can happen during the core uh block right the core time during small group instruction while some kids are having small group instruction other kids are on Lexia it can also happen during the intervention block for students who who don't need um uh to be in a small group with the teacher so it is used it is used across uh our elementary and middle
048schools yeah I mean and just from my personal experience I think it's a really great tool for students um I'm don't see it quite as um intentionally used in high school and I wonder about that cuz it's still seems useful so we do have um we do have it in a few of our high schools where we have the greatest need but it is not um it is not a universal tool like it is at our elementary and middle schools got it um is anyone so we were in Richmond last week only it feels like it's been like a year but is anyone able to provide us what at this moment is the status of you know regarding Virginia literacy um act related work I think you know at points some things were slower to
049get to us the screeners and such and the funding is a rein precarious position are things going the way we'd like them to go so we we have some expectations that we'll continue to get guidance about next year um in grades 4 through eight um we aren't 100% sure about the assessment we believe a new assessment screener coming that would replace I ready but we're not sure if it's for all students so so um we know that there's expectations around grades 4 through eight but not everything is quite clear yet but we do continue to get monthly updates from the state um and I think they are trying as hard as they can to get information to us thank you and when I hear that we might have a new screener to replace I I
050mean I is a huge investment it's a lot of money I think we need to understand more about that if it comes to that and finally you mentioned grades 4 to8 what what is happening um well maybe I'll just phrase it this way there are many people who ask me what is happening to help our Learners after third grade especially in middle or high who are not literate so I won't ask for a response but I'm not aware of what the consistent plan is to help those students thank you please go ahead and respond sorry I didn't know if you wanted to response um so we continue to well a couple things have happened the state has changed the standards of learning to be more aligned with the science of reading or evidence-based literacy instruction
051so at the core for tier one there is definitely more expectations that all students are having um a more um having um instruction that includes more U of the word work not just the comprehension work if you will our uh interventions that we continue to offer do um the tools that we're using We Believe are aligned and so we continue to provide support both through gen Ed and special education for students who are showing um signs that they need more support with gaining literacy um our teachers in middle school just like our elementary schools our language arts teachers as well as our content teachers are engaged in state training to learn more about evidence-based literacy instruction which I think is a real game Cher because a lot of our Middle School um and high school
052teachers really didn't learn that in college you know we know that there's some deficit with all of our teachers uh for having evidence-based literacy instruction in college but our middle and high school teachers for sure did not um really receive instruction on how to teach kids to read so there's lots of independent efforts of course there's always room to do more um you know the long-term goal is always that we will have less students needing intervention because of all the work we're doing but we recognize there are students in our middle and high schools now that um need attention it's your turn yes um thank you for this report um first of all I basic prek is key it's obvious from the data um but I have a couple questions related to the um multilanguage
053Learners and our students with disabilities it was my experience erence when I worked in the system that when I had a counselor or even a teacher advocating for um a student to be assessed for special education services who was a multilanguage learner that that was very much deterred um the argument was always made and I was at the high school level that it's the it's the language it's not the it's not the learning so it was very frustrating because those sadly often those were situations where that child didn't have an a parent advocate or a guardian Advocate they just had an internal School advocate and so I just want to make sure that that's not happening um and hopefully Elementary principles Middle and High School principles you know and their staffs are empowered to say
054we need to do a language on this student we need to find out if there's more to what's going on especially in light of the fact that 20% of the population is dyslexic so I just want to put that um out there because I think it's it's of huge importance um the other question I had is when we're talking about uh folks that are working with special education students who are also multi language Learners um are we encouraging uh dually certified teachers um do we have any situations where we have maybe perhaps a self-contained class that is special education and multi language Learners in isolation from other special education students because it seems like there's a little bit of a difference there in terms of instructional strategies to reach that child um so I guess
055that's an actual question so you want okay go ahead oh okay all right well I I'll just give you my perspective and then turn over to Dr Pon I I think your first question I I cannot overemphasize the importance of giving students the multilingual Learners the amount of time that they need to develop language proficiency and we have to be careful about assuming making assumptions about what multilingual Learners are capable of early on in their educational Journey with us we actually over identify multilingual learners for special education compared to State and National averages quite significantly and that's an area that we're looking at we're actually in the process with uh Rich polio uh in our esol office working with the special education instructional team and procedural support team to look at all of the procedures
056and processes that we have in place before a student would go through the eligibility process making sure that we really have done diagnostic uh literacy assessments with those students really to determine what the areas of need and deficits are uh to determine if specially designed instruction outside of English language development instruction would benefit the student or not so we're being very careful and thoughtful about that we're reviewing all of um our procedures right now we're actually um going to be asking our inclusion Consultants that we working with us on our inclusion project to look at all of those procedures um as well because we think it's really important to get that outside lens and view on what we're doing so I just want to kind of clarify that doesn't mean that we wouldn't identify a
057multilingual learner um and certainly we're going to be responsive to what teachers in the classroom are saying what parents are saying but we want to take the whole picture and we don't want to overreact we want to make sure that we're making good instructionally uh sound decisions based on evidence on your second question about how we're educating our students it's important it's incredibly important and we just had a great uh allc count principal meeting with our inclusion Consultants on this topic last Thursday that we really focused on inclusion not just for students with disabilities for but for multilingual Learners and other students as well in the gened setting so that is really the goal is to make sure that all of our students get access to highquality Tier 1 instruction with the accommodations supports modifications
058that they need to be successful I'm getting the cut it off so I'll leave it there for right now I think that you uh said everything uh it's it's very important uh we have been working very uh close with um with nardos and and Sloan uh we called the uh closing the Gap te closing the academic uh closing the academic Gap team um and uh everything is is is been uh discussed uh I agree I I I get frustrated especially that just my passion when I talk about special education and uh multilingual students and how we uh sometimes go by uh sometimes that we don't understand is not the the language but not the content and this is where uh overlap and and thank you and not uh we have been working very close with
059as long and this is something that I can tell you uh the multilingual students here in Fairfax are are doing much much better than so many Across the Nation and so I think that you should be very pleased with with that I know so sometime we can be very uh hard on us but we're doing very well and we are working together with the chart to get more uh certified teachers thanks okay so another question um also is part of an experience and a comment but um and it's I know this is only through third grade but we still have reading problems all the way through 12th grade um so it was my experience as a director of student services that I found to often that middle school counselors were not forceful enough in explaining
060to parents their children needed to take reading um I will tell you what I did I would get all the so scores from eth grade and if they failed I would start with the lowest failures and I would keep a spreadsheet of what elective they had picked that I took them out of and I put them in reading and I think that in my 15 years I only had three parents call me and say I didn't sign up for reading but we got those kids reading my frustration is we have a job to inform parents of where their students are and and I hope that sixth grade going to seventh grade if they need reading they're being put in Reading like we have to do this people because if you're not literate you can't learn
061um and then later in life you're going to be tripped up at every at every turn so that's kind of more of a statement I don't need to ask what's going on but but hopefully people are doing that so directors don't have to spend a day tracking you know and making changes in schedules without calling home um but that's just what I've ethically felt like I needed to do and my last question is Assessments in elementary school I am hearing from con some constituents that they feel like their kids are being over assessed right now so can you talk to me about that yeah I mean I think that's a legitimate concern obviously um we need to be responsive to our uh teachers and and parents and students I think what's really causing that is
062the new state assessment in the primary grades the vows assessment which requires a one-on-one Administration um is taking a lot more time than the computer adaptive I ready assessment did so that is a stressor for for teachers that are trying to cover a lot of content and manage a lot of competing demands uh we are required to use that assessment in the primary grades and as Noel mentioned at some point we're we believe we're going to be required to use that up through grade 8 uh so more to come on that but I I think again that just speaks to the need to make sure the teachers have adequate planning time so that when they're losing time someplace else they at least feel like they're getting the support and conditions that they need to be
063successful thank you Dr Presidio Miss seismo Heiser followed by Mr Dunn thank you I appreciate the car oh sorry I didn't want it was I have a loud mic um I appreciate the conversation and I appreciate all the time that went into the report and the data and I really appreciate the disaggregation of the data you know really teasing out which of our groups which portions of our groups right like the multilingual Learners the ones who complete our program or more advanced multilingual Learners are doing incredibly well and I think that's important to point out that our programs are working if we can give our students the time to go through the programs and I really appreciate you teasing out the level one versus level two with students with disabilities because it goes to something
064I've been saying for a long time because I would imagine if you crosswalk the inclusion data with the reading data and you would see level two students with disabilities are probably included a lot less and their reading scores are at 22% so you know I know people worry about inclusion let's pull them in intensive and pull them out of these classes and pull them separately but the reality is the data shows that hasn't been working we've been putting kids in intensive classes we segregating kids and it doesn't work and there's so much research behind inclusion but there's so many crosswalks you see here so I just wanted to point out that crosswalk that it isn't just sounds good but there's data behind it so I just wanted to point that out that um same with
065I think we need to tell some stories around what's going on here for our funders and our community right we can say students aren't meeting you know we're not quite at our goals yet but our programming is working we're not quite out of goals yet but if the community and our funders would f prek the data is so strong that it would get kids to my colleague's point literate which is important for everything right I think these need to be packaged Dr Reed maybe in some of a way that we can start in our advocacy to our funders saying look here's like we talk we have all these different reports with disate pieces of data we need to connect all of them together into a story that we can explain to our public so I'm
066curious to see what you think about that yes ma'am I agree I just think it's so valuable because there's lots of misinformation out there or or little pieces here and we've got pieces everywhere so I would just recommend we work on that um I was curious what we're doing around family engagement with multilingual and um economically disadvantaged families because we know the data shows so much about engaged families can really help support so I'd be curious to know what we're doing around that for specifically for the groups that have some of the most greatest gaps sorry I know is I like to talk a lot about that uh I think that uh we have been very uh engaged with our families and indeed uh is very important it is imperative that our parents uh somehow
067we engage with them uh things that we have been working working with um Lisa Hall department and the chief of school office is so we have been uh visiting the schools also having some Saturday and Sundays coffee with with the chief of schools where uh we meet with some uh parents in uh some areas that are very I would say UND deserved I don't want to put a label on those uh communities and I will not mention those communities but uh Saturday and Sundays we go and talk and we talk about uh things that they can do while they are at home that they have children and uh some uh sources that we have here in Fairfax that they can utilize it English and Spanish uh little things like hey you can go to the
068website and you can translate into English you just put English through Spanish and everything that is the beginning they have been very optimistic and thinks that we are doing it and I think that um I have been inviting Dr Reed as well we have been visiting some some communities there is one where uh we didn't see one but um coming back at time when they saw us it was like a probably 300 people gathering around us and we have a a lot of uh information for them uh so uh I think it's very important thank you um and on the slide when it talks about slide 22 talks about targeted interventions it talks about dyslexia specialist as kind of new we've had a dyslexia specialist for like 10 years this isn't new so like new
069actions in 20 strategy 8 new actions in school year 2425 tailor based tailored evidence-based literacy dyslexia Specialists like what else is new that's not new so I apologize just to clarify the strategy itself is not new there are some new actions within there we were trying to pull out existing and new actions so I apologize if that was confusing that's okay that's what I was confused by I appreciate that and then um just one last quick question I may need to go back can you tell me more about curriculum based common the common assessments and why we have haven't been doing that before so I'm probably going to have Noel or Diane talk a little bit more about what we're doing currently because in the new curriculum that we adopted there are at the end
070of each unit developed by the publisher common assessments that are easily implemental easily implemented in schools um previously we had tried it at different times but when we had run like internal validity studies on the assessment in terms of correlation to other outcomes we never got good results so it's like it wasn't telling us what we needed it to tell us and we had other measures that we were using um but now given the fact to Dr Reed's earlier point that this is an assessment developed by the publisher completely aligned to what the instruction is and what the students have participated in we think it's a a really valuable tool but in the past we just didn't have that and again we you know had a locally developed curriculum for 20 years so Mr Dunn
071yes it is your turn thank you um so I I I appreciate all the great work that's been done I'm sorry I'm having trouble with my video but um appreciate all the great work that's been done uh but what I it's not clear to me when we're going to get to the point where we have eradicated the achievement Gap and if we have a goal in that regard um because you know this this seems a little bit like process and a little bit less focused on on outcomes and you know there were nape scores that came out recently showing just uh abysmal uh leing scores and every state of the country for black students um in terms of their uh proficiency and we need to we need to do better uh we have so many
072school divisions across the country experimenting with different things over many decades and and so we should have figured out by this point in time in 2025 how to teach a child to read and how to teach uh children to read consistently across different income levels different uh backgrounds Etc so I I'd like to understand um if if there is a year that is in mind and and I'll build on the question of my colleague who asked you know I I understand um um that um Mr P respones were early stages but I'd like to know by what year we we believe that we will have taught all of our children to read proficiently and that there won't be these persistent um achievement gaps across different uh groups no matter how you SCE indise them well
073that is a large and very important question I I don't have an easy answer to that obviously we've been working really hard not just in Fairfax but as a profession in education on closing gaps for a long time we do have evidence on certain things that make a difference in closing those gaps and this report is really trying to reflect what some of those strategies are whether it's a a comprehensive coherent viable curriculum implemented consistently in all schools whether it's the assessment practices that we're using to identify students that are at risk and falling below grade level and getting them additional support before before they fall further behind to get them uh caught up to speed and Ong grade level um whether it's the training and professional development that we're providing to our teachers so
074that they're using the right strategies whether it's the work that we're doing around inclusion which is just beginning um but is going to impact a huge uh number and percentage of our students and getting access to highquality tier one instruction it's all of those things and a lot more um but when we talk about achievement gaps there are also those external factors that I do think we need to continue to remind ourselves of that we can't do this work alone uh the school system needs the community support we need our lawmaker support we need the funding that we need to be able to provide students with the resources that they need um and we're always going to have students in this in society unfortunately that are going to come to us at varying levels of
075Readiness and we need the resources to be able to Target and provide supports to students at where they're at um the research for example is really clear that economically disadvantaged students those external factors that come along with uh Financial issues and considerations whether it's uh housing insecurity food insecurity stressors that exist in their lives all of those things impact a students ability to learn um whether it's the amount of time that students have been exposed when we talk about early literacy uh to language uh really even pre-birth prenatal almost um you know and having strong birth toy programs in in our communities that really support uh students and families and getting the enrichment that they need in the home to be able to perform well in the classroom it really is a community- based effort
076I I really appreciate your question I wish I had a better answer for you in terms of the magic bullet or the exact timeline that we would be on I mean I would go back to just the measure that we're looking at right now with third grade reading um really looking at when those kindergarteners that we have in our classrooms today take the third the third grade so that will be the first cohort of students that have at least gone through our comprehensive redesigned literacy programming at the primary grades and that would be school year 2728 so uh I I've heard many stories as have I think everyone on the board and Dr Reed about the the difficulty of implementation of the new science of reading literacy curriculum um when do you feel that uh
077those challenges will be overcome and this new literacy curriculum will be implemented with great Fidelity with um all teach is fully trained and all students receiving uh consistent uh literacy education regardless of what school uh they attend and where they live to be honest Mr dun it's it's a continuing effort right it's a continuing effort we have hundreds of teachers at every grade level across multiple schools each year with an infusion of new teachers into the profession that um we will continue to support and to develop provide feedback and coach um and will'll continue to work with sta I um you know the the picture that you paint where we're all completely aligned and everything's perfect um I hate to say I'm not sure that arrives I think it's a continuous work and we get
078better and better every year understanding we never get to Perfection as as human beings but um is there a point at which you feel in the next two or three years you will be able to say for the vast majority of teachers you know who are not brand new out of teacher school or for the vast majority of students that there will be consistency I just what I'm not understanding is uh what I'm hearing is from from a Layman's perspective from a constituent perspective we're working on it and we're doing the best we can but that's not what parents want to hear parents want to hear when will it be done right understanding there will always be new people coming in new students new challenges but but when when do we think the year will
079be when we can actually say we have accomplished the full implementation of this lit uh new literacy curriculum thank you Mr dun yeah I I mean I do think that um having been a teacher myself you live through the entire year right the first year everything is new though one of the strengths of Benchmark is is there's a regular Cadence unit by unit so I think as this year's going on teachers are building their own efficacy and their own um understanding and building their their skills and and tools um to implement with Fidelity so I believe that after we get through this year the teachers who have have taught this year will be in a much stronger place next year in year two often we see um you know new teachers really thrive in year
080three right like when they start to not only Implement with Fidelity but they really can be more even responsive to the student needs right in in front of them because they have a deep understanding and comfort level um so it's not a precise answer but I think we'll see um you know a great level of increase of fidelity next year and then then year three is when I would predict that we would really um start to feel like we own this product thank you Miss St John cunning followed by Miss um um so I do want to address um a comment that was just brought up because I have several colleagues that are reading Specialists that have taken the training and are training it and are training other teachers and I think at the beginning
081of the school year it might have been a little bit difficult but I'm in the schools that I'm walking into I'm seeing that teachers are excited about this and that they are embracing this um and I understand that to a late person it may be a little bit difficult I I get that um but when you see that although teachers you know it's an extra thing on their plate but they are happy with what they're doing I think that says a lot when you've got that kind of energy um which makes the buyin and the reaching the proficiency a little bit easier um so I just wanted to give that perspective of what I've seen and what I've heard when I go into school buildings and speak with some of the reading Specialists and then
082talk to some of the teachers that they have trained thank you for the presentation um I'm just going to be very quick and then just a comment for the next round um U from uh when my colleague said about the connecting the data and I wanted to ask um Dr Reed if we have any data dashboard which are public facing to show some of our academics uh CH numbers I believe we have public face in academic achievement data I don't believe it's a live dashboard at this time so we're essentially reporting generally data a year and in some cases two years after when we receive it officially uh from the Commonwealth I think when we started the conversation this morning around common assessments those are internal facing data that staff will see immediately and be
083able to act on immediately and that data is not forward facing at this time okay um that's uh good to know but at the same time I would just say uh say let's just uh put this out there uh if you're improving and even if we are um you know sort of improving in some area some not but it's good to be let the public also know uh what we are doing and uh that would be I think really good to have that data uh dashboard out um as just meeting manager I just want to say we have a lot of pages present presentation left um and we this is a very important topic this is the core of our schools academics um I don't know we going to do justice to all the colleagues
084have questions and so I would just uh wanted to say that next round I think after uh Dr Anderson if uh you could give the entire presentation at least we'll have some 30 minutes left for questions um and if we there is an I would definitely would like another work session if time permits and any in our future to come back to this topic Mr fresh just to the question of another work session there's no room for a work session before we're voting on this at the regular meeting but we do have a regular meeting where there will be opportunities for more conversation okay that's good and I do want before my time gets started I do want to um confirm what Miss Dixon has said this is our bread and butter and maybe next
085time we just give give it a little bit more time and maybe perhaps we'll steal a little time from budget if that's possible just want to put that on the table since we have three and a half hours for that all right you could go ahead and start my time um one of the things that I was very interested in seeing is the information you provided on page 13 of the report where you highlighted how FCPS um performed as compared to other school divisions um you offered seven in the waybe I don't know what slide it is is I'm just looking at the reports when you look at all these eight School divisions where do we fall I I we don't have that specific data we could certainly provide that as a next step for
086the board yes I would be very much interested in that and one of the things and hearing the conversation here this morning I'm going to Veer away from my plans here I'm not as encouraged about the data as I think I I would like to be because looking at what's offered on page 15 across the board there's been very little movement um across all of the categories I think we've gone maybe 2age points in some areas but it's really been very little I'm always looking for where is it that we're having those successes because those are the places that we want to duplicate and and continue with what they're doing so if you could speak too have you had the opportunity do you have access to looking at data with across the groups with similar
087demographic graic like where are we seeing those big pockets of successes in our division I'm gonna turn this over to Diane leig she is our principal and residence for literacy who can potentially answer um your question Dr Anderson we do have an internal dashboard that allows us to look very specifically at how schools with similar demographics are performing in each grade level on each metric and so it does help us to do some deeper analysis to look at where are we seeing po pockets of success that we can then investigate so the go three Innovation team has actually identified a number of schools that we going to be doing empathy interviews to really get a sense for what are the systems and structures in place at various schools that would contribute to um success in
088each of these areas so um it is something we are investigating very closely and we do have a dashboard that allows us to look with that fine grain detail at I would be very interested in seeing that because that's where we can really point to activities that we can replicate because we know there's a lot of disruptions even with the best laid plans we have transiency we have students who have a substitute for a bulk of the year because there's matern leave there are things that happen but if we can duplicate whatever those successes are that is more helpful because I'm not a lay person to this this is my bread and butter so I am looking at this with a very different eye and I want to turn that eye to Common assessments um
089again good conversations about it I would like to know how are we aligning the comment ass the Common Assessment results to the results that we have to be responsible for because at the end of the day with whether we like it or not like it the SOS is where we are what is that alignment and what are we seeing well it's it's too early to really see anything right now but as I mentioned in one of the previous questions we can do basically like a correlation study to show like at what point a student would have to score on the Common Assessment to have passed the so but we can't do that internal validity correlation study until we get the so results back from this year and then it being the first year of adoption
090of the curriculum we'd need to probably do that a couple years in a row but so we haven't had an opportunity to do that yet but we do believe that the Common Assessment because it's aligned to the actual curriculum that was taught and um is going to give us really helpful information to make those instructional adjustments in real time not waiting for the so results to come back a year later but saying based on this past unit what are we seeing what do we maybe need to retach or what do we maybe need to adjust for the next unit of study so more of real time um assessment if you will have we done a similar correlation for I ready which we've had for a number of years in terms of how it's tight how
091it's coupled to so performance yeah so I I was mentioning that a little bit earlier too I was trying to point out that we did do that study and we are seeing um again when you take that cut score that cor on the I ready that a student would need to achieve to correlate with like a 95% confidence interval to passing the so test we're seeing actually an increase of about four percentage points of our students hitting that I ready Benchmark this year so that's a good internal signal for us that we're on the right track thank you I looked at last year's report and I was really digging through the strategies that were part of that report which one of these strategies have we elected that are not having the impact and we have
092to abandon what have we stopped doing from last year is what you're asking for Dr Anderson I think we could give the board a summary for for that section of what we've stopped doing I I think that most of the work as we talked about in the introduction um we were already sort of in progress when the Virginia literacy act came to fruition so much of that work just linked into and I would invite Noel if she has anything to add into that existing work so be prior we were using our our curriculum right our FCPS curriculum so we've completely replaced the curriculum materials that teachers are using we were using I ready with our younger students and now we're using the valves so we've done some Replacements most of it has been driven by
093the Virginia literacy act because that was so Broad and sweeping okay thank you um you mentioned the use of Benchmark Express when did we begin that work with Benchmark Express so Benchmark Express is our English language development curriculum that is aligned to Benchmark advance and that started just this fall okay thank you um excuse me on page 20 of the document the econom economically disadvantaged um intersectionality data all of the groups seem to have increased by a similar percentage points against except for black students what Reflections did you have about that I think there is a need to dig deeper into this data and as a part of what um Miss Li said is our goal innovation team is taking this sort of outcome data the intersectionality data and going out to schools to do
094some further learnings to understand where are we seeing persistent challenges where are we seeing improvements so I think at a cursory level the data is what the data is and we have to get behind the stories of why we're seeing improvements or why we're not seeing improvements in certain areas is that something that will be possible before we have to approve this on date that I don't know think Mr Mr fr is getting the date but I would just say the work that they're doing right now is an ongoing deep investigation and I don't know that we would have a comprehensive answer for you all in two weeks thank you that's February 20th um it just I I think a part of this is missing because we have to get to the why of is
095of why we are in the places that we are because we would we can do this all day and all night but until we get to the root causes it makes it a little bit superficial so I will stop here and then turn turn it back over to you Miss Neil for the second and third Parts I do want to note we are supposed to end at 12:30 it is now 11:45 I am not seeing that we're going to be successful in completing these two parts knowing that we already have um go backs on this first component so I just want to put that out on the table we'll may have to regroup in some way um but please go ahead and start all right well I will attempt to be succinct um so we're
096going to look at Algebra 1 by 8th grade as our next measure um our middle school students who take Algebra 1 by 8th grade do have greater access to higher level Math and Science courses at the high school level and the national research shows that students with strong math skills who take Algebra 1 in Middle School have higher test scores in both math and language arts and better attendance in middle school and are more likely to pursue advanced math and high school and attend college the research has also identified several factors that impact Algebra 1 participation in Middle School including factors such as enrollment practices uh teacher preparation and student level factors such as Readiness persistence and Habits Like checking work for this measure we are specifically looking at students who earn a verified Credit
097in Algebra 1 by the end of 8th grade meaning they both pass the class and the associated so at some point in middle school when we compare this to our Baseline data we did see significant increases in the percentage of students meeting this metric and FCPS surpassed uh the overall division Target for last year we do continue to see significant differences between student groups that we will examine further and when we disc and we'll also discuss in more detail the strategies that have led to these significant gains there is not State data available on the percentage of students who earn a verified Credit in so uh and a verified Credit in algebra one excuse me however we are able to look at differences in the number of students in 8th grade who take and pass
098any high school math um so which includes Algebra 1 Algebra 2 or geometry to see how fcbs Compares against other divisions in the state and as you can see from the slide FCPS has consistently outperformed the state overall on this data point and is also outperforming other Northern Virginia wavy school districts as well so I'm going to go back to our our metric which is looking at the percent of students receiving that verified Credit in Algebra 1 by the end of 8th grade and we did see that increase by eight percentage points from 51% at the Baseline to 59% last school year we did see substantial gains across nearly all of our student groups our students with a 504 plan our multi-racial students and black students all had a 10 percentage point or more increase
099from the Baseline and we also did see disparities in the rates of earning verified credits persistent uh with students who are economically disadvantaged students with disabilities multilingual Learners Black and Hispanic students having rates below the division average and again I do want to point out that our Hispanic students who were not multilingual Learners had a rate of 57% which was just under the division average and again underscores the importance of us looking at our intersectionality data on the bottom line on this slide again you can see uh where we hit our annual growth targets uh last school year in green we did see several student groups exceed their annual growth targets as well as some student groups that fell below those annual targets meaning we will need to make additional growth in subsequent years and
100again on this slide you see that annual growth line from the Baseline that we need to remain on track for our 2030 goal on this slide we're going to take a look at academic performance of those middle school students that finished Algebra 1 last year so you can see overall 95% of students who finished Algebra 1 by 8th grade last year earned at least a c minus in the course while we do see some variation by student group all had rates of successful completion of over 80% and it's important to look at this data because it suggests that the primary driver of students not earning the verified Credit in algebra one by eth grade is more related to enrollment versus underperformance once they are in the course uh returning back to our percentage of students
101who got that verified Credit in Algebra 1 this is looking at intersected student groups we do see that students who were economically disadvantaged and not multilingual Learners had rates that were close to the division average and our multilingual Learners with disabilities had the lowest rates of any intersected group that We examined on this slide we do see Algebra 1 looking at that by ELP level we saw that students categorized as ELP levels three and four had significant gains from the Baseline and the most progress was made by our former multilingual Learners who increased by 13 percentage points from the Baseline overall our students with disability saw a 7 percentage Point increase on this metric 53% of students with disabilities classified as level one received a verified Credit in Algebra 1 by the end of 8th
102grade compared to 8% of students with disabilities classified as level two the rates for both level one and level two have increased from the Baseline with substantial gains for our students categorized as level one there were no differences in student performance on this metric by gender with rates uh and growth similar for boys girls and non-binary student um rate that was too small to report for last year we do have that full data in the report and we know that National research has found that our lgbtqia plus students self-report lower rates of math identity which is their own beliefs about their abilities in math and less interest in enjoyment and the subject and then within this student group the research also indicates certain students may be less likely to take advantage of advanced math in
103high school and these are barriers that can be overcome in environments where there is more support all right all right we're going to now take a look at strategies for Algebra 1 by 8th grade we are currently focused on a set of universal School targeted and student targeted strategies which include a focus on preparing all students for Algebra 1 by 8th grade and encouraging their enrollment in Middle School providing collaborative opportunities for identified schools and providing personalized supports for students who have been historically underrepresented in Algebra 1 in Middle School uh FCPS has made major changes to our our approach to Algebra 1 by 88th grade the k to7 math curriculum is being revised to increase coherence alignment and depth and complexity in order to prepare all students to be successful in Algebra 1 by
1048th grade a multi-year plan that's been developed that Maps out compacting standards the standard mathematics course pathway FCPS is also currently in the progress process of adopting a new basil resource for Math and is continuing to provide professional development to support current and fure future changes uh we have allowed students to enroll in Algebra 1 and 8th grade without prerequisites since 2011 however we know many families may not be fully aware of this option and FCPS is focusing on Outreach and education to students and families about this policy and the benefits of Algebra 1 in middle school and then a math success dashboard that identifies more students who are ready for Algebra 1 as well as a required sip goal focused on Algebra 1 enrollment uh by the end of 8th grade both support these
105efforts uh we have an algebra Access Network Improvement Community or AA neck uh which is focused on increasing the diverse representation of students who participate and are successful in Algebra 1 by the end of 8th grade the participating schools use Improvement science to examine School data and develop strategies to improve outcomes across all the cohorts that have participated in the AA neck um they have seen an increase in the percentage of students enrolled in Algebra 1 by 8th grade from 56% in the 2122 school year to 70% this year so again that's looking at enrolled students um to support students with disabilities we're providing uh a new training for teachers this training uh helps special education teachers with specifically design instruction and supports general education teachers with supporting students who are struggling with certain Concepts
106FCPS is also aiming to increase the number of General Ed and special ed teachers who par participate in the advantage math recovery where teachers use a scripted intervention curriculum to support numeracy instruction in this year FCPS is also piloting a resource for Algebra 1 and instruction and assessment in Spanish at Key Middle School and the impact of that pilot is currently being assessed to determine future implications to support our multilingual Learners in accessing Algebra 1 by 8th grade for students who have not been exposed to certain content when they are accelerating in the math sequence the math team is included support materials that address these gaps FCPS offers math space skills check-in for all of our middle school students and this is a digital learning platform that provides students with customized content and practice and
107we continue to provide professional development on how to leverage our measures in academic progress or map growth assessment to design targeted interventions for our students and then finally our Algebra 1 by eth grade goal Innovation team will continue to identify ways to improve Algebra 1 outcom comes in particular for the things identified in this report so we're going to continue on to our final section uh to look at successful completion of advanced coursework in high school uh here in FCPS we know our students have the opportunity to pursue a wide range of advanced courses while they're in high school which includes college level courses such as advanced placement International baloria dual enrollment and other Advanced courses that carry a 1.08 as well as uh earn CTE CTE course that will help lead to a completer
108status and the research shows that completion of these advanced level courses is linked to higher rates of on-time graduation College enrollment and completion and higher earnings we've also identified several factors within the research that influence rates of advanced coursework uh including divisions covering the costs of AP or IB tests or enrollment in courses with Associated fees uh the availability of courses and the expectations at the school level around student participation in courses and student factors such as family expectations experience with post-secondary preparation and student academic preparation we did see a 1 percentage Point increase in the number of students in the senior cohort completing at least one of these Advanced courses before graduating and fell just 1% below last year's target white students were the only group within five percentage point of the division average
109with all remaining student groups significantly higher or lower than the division average and we'll talk about the strategies that we're focused on on a subsequent slide uh this slide does provide some State and National comparisons we don't always have that oneto one to give you that context but wanted to provide this um and this is based on a 2223 school year which is the most recent year we had the available National Data and during that year FCPS uh students who took an AP test had substantially higher overall Pass rates 73% uh than the state overall which was at 65 % and then the US average which was at 60% so again just to provide some context and during the same year there were just over 4900 CTE completers and FCPS which made up 11% of
110the Shar Statewide uh the vast majority of our students 85% uh who were in last year's senior cohorts successfully completed advanced coursework in high school again that rate is up just slightly from the Baseline uh that was 84% our multilingual learner saw the most growth from the Baseline which was up 7 percentage points uh from 44% to 51% our Asian multi-racial and students with a 504 plan had rates at or above 90% and students who were economically disadvantaged multilingual Learners students with disabilities and Hispanic students had rates that were 10 or more percentage points below the division average um again when we look at that intersectionality data for Hispanic students who are not multilingual Learners we saw a rate of 80% % and then on the final row again in green you can see which
111um groups uh hit the target for last year uh so again overall we fell just one percentage point below our Target for last year meaning we're going to need to make additional growth uh to be on track for our 2030 goals this chart breaks down the measure a little bit more by visualizing um the share of students in that senior cohort who graduated with only that CTE completer status which is shown in red only AP IB or dual enrollment or a 1.0 weighted class which is shown in teal or both which is shown in yellow and again in that dark blue you see the percentage of students who did not do any of those things um the our overall measure doesn't preference the use of a certain course AP versus CTE to meet this criteria
112um which allows students to have the have the flexibility to choose the advanced pathway they prefer um but this Le is useful for us in understanding the role these different courses are playing and their performance on this measure by our student groups so consistent with the other measures in this goal report we saw that students who are economically disadvantaged but not multilingual Learners and students who are economically disadvantaged but not students with disabilities had the highest rates of all the intersected groups we examine which were both within four percentage points of the division average and again our multilingual Learners with disabilities had the lowest rates of all Stu student groups that We examined uh the rates of advanced course workk do increase rapidly as we look by ELP level and we saw the most substantial
113gains since the Baseline for students classified as ELP levels 1 through three uh the rates for our former multilingual Learners were also within 5 percentage points of the division average our students who were categorized as level one had substantially higher rates of completing advanced coursework than those who are categorized as level two girls in the senior cohort were s substantially more likely than boys and non-binary students to complete Advanced cours workk and the national research suggests that our lgbtqia plus high school students tend to take fewer Advanced course um fewer College Prep courses than their peers which is substantially explained by their level of connectedness to teachers and other students um we also show particularly low rates in participation in advanced stem courses and then finally I'm going to um talk about the strategies associated
114with our Advanced course work so we're currently focused on a core set of universal and targeted strategies that aim to increase overall availability and variety of advanced courses and support students in intentionally planning for and enrolling in these classes we see focused efforts in our high schools with lower completion rates and supporting students who have historically been underrepresented in seeking out and completing Advanced coursework prior to graduation we are seeking to provide early and consistent exposure to learning experiences that help students make those connections between their understandings of coursework and future aspirations and to support this ongoing intentional work FCPS does provide resources for all of our schools to support the development of those personalized academic and career plans this year we began a pilot with AEL that allows us to use data on high
115school student cour taking patterns grades and test scores to help principles and their teams identify opportunities to strengthen students post-secondary Readiness and we're going to highlight this more in our goal four reports um and expect that these actions will help strengthen broader academic advisement practices and prepare more students to pursue that advanced coursework in high school all of our high schools do continue to have a required Civ goal that's focused on student participation and advanced cour workk we also have developed an honors framework that articulates the elements of rigorous instruction that should be embedded in all courses as well as how these standards are extended into honors level courses in the middle and high school and this ensures all of our students who wish to take those Advanced courses in high school have that rigorous
116instruction that prepares them for these classes we continue to add dual enrollment options uh in both schools that are have current dual enrollment courses as well as exploring new courses that can be offered in dual enrollment based on student interest uh we're also increasing the flexibility of AP courses that can be used to satisfy certain graduation requirements and expanding that access to begin uh AP in 9th grade and then we continue to expand Avid which as you all know is a national model program designed to support students in completing the most rigorous curriculum last year Avid was operating at seven elementary schools 15 middle schools and 15 high schools and this year access was expanded to 18 additional Title One elementary schools uh a new structure has been incorporated into the AAP screening application that
117provides documentation of support for our young scholars uh in advanced coursework and this information will continue to support access for these students in advanced courses and provide secondary teachers with information to support these students when they are in those Advanced courses uh as we previously shared we have a project team that's focused on our 2E Learners and is currently working to familiarize uh staff with our existing 2E handbook and to develop better tracking of our two e-learners and our student information system with the explicit goal of monitoring access and successful completion of AD Advanced coursework we did see those substantial increases in the inclusion and success of our multilingual Learners in accessing coursework last year in part which was due to adjustments in the Esau programming and course sequencing that have really streamlined a path
118to begin courses required for graduation while focusing on ELD or their English language development and we believe the expansion of advanced course offerings uh will also Contin continue to support our multilingual Learners and finally we have several goal Innovation teams that are working on outcomes that will support these efforts um and these will inform future strategies that we'll bring to the board and with that I will hand that back over to the meeting managers thank you so much being that it is currently 12:04 we're going to set the timer for 90 seconds um so you might just get one question out and we're asking staff to su su Saint so hopefully we'll get to everyone and hopefully we'll have time after the budget to come back to the rest of your questions so without any
119further Ado um Mr frish followed by Miss Marin 90 seconds please staff I don't mind the extra three it's fine okay uh wasting time all right um Dive Right In so I appreciate the information about not only how we're getting more students into algebra by eth grade but also whether or not they're passing I'd love to get data on students who are passing at a B level and a C Level rather than just getting by so it'd be great if we could have that data um and obviously that's going to be impacted by the work on our pipeline Dr Reed can you talk a little bit about the work that we're doing to ensure that we're setting students up for success in algebra by eighth grade and the broader implications for that with your goals
120around math Readiness and increasing our standards around mathematics I say this as many board members are getting ready to appoint members of our community to the math IRC committee thank you Mr frish I think math is critical right now as reading is math limits 40 or 84% of our career choices right now in this country the um proliferation of AI and um other large language models as well as Quantum require a deep understanding of mathematics uh period full stop so we moved up our math curriculum work by a year this year the expectation is to come up with secondary materials and I do mean a book we're not going to be strictly online we need uh math text uh for students uh to work with uh we're going to be looking at elementary next year
121the same expectation for text uh we also need to be really thoughtful about um our sixth grade and the possibility of sixth grade being in Middle scho school because really every elementary school should have a sixth grade section of algebra as well if we don't we can't get to algebra trig and till 8th grade so we're working our math lead here for the division um is here to answer questions um in more detail but given time I think I'll just leave it there there's a significant pipeline body of work happening different pyramids uh who currently don't have some of our strongest numbers are looking at K8 models for adjustment to mathematics uh so it's really a full court press right now on mathematics thank you um the math division average on this for former El
122students is 50% versus 59 for the overall percentage which is way different than our reading score uh you know averages where we were you know 28 points higher among former El's why the discrepancy you know why are are former El's performing so much better than the division average on reading but worse than the division average on math it's especially weird because typically you would talk to experts and they would say math and science transcend language in some regard yeah I mean I think that's true in some regard I mean what we see with the reading measures those students that are former L's have obviously developed complex fluency in multiple languages so they're strong with Reading Writing speaking and listening right this to me when we look at the particular slide that you're referencing is more
123of an opportunity Gap than anything else like having the opportunity for the multilingual Learners at earlier phases to be able to actually access Algebra 1 by 8th grade um whereas I think the other slide is more about students language development progression so I think to me this is again a Target area for us we're working our math team is working really hard to identify students school by school that could be accelerated into Algebra 1 and providing that coaching support to the schools to to close that opportunity Gap thank you final question for Dr Reed on Advanced coursework how are we shifting our approach to Advanced cour work in light of the new accreditation standards we're intentionally looking at the threee instead of the CCC I can go into more detail later and we're working with
124um our a Consulting Group and actually looking at student schedules so they have looked at the last two years of our graduates from from Fairfax County Public Schools and their core schedules to look at the rigor of those schedules and what we can do pipeline wise and um in advising to make sure that those schedules um are more rigorous and we can add more detail to that work but it's very intentional work at this time Miss Marin followed by Miss Isis moiser and then miss lady I really just like being rushed like this um so I'm going to focus on advanced coursework and I'm really glad to see some improvements on Communications and planning around coursework selection to me the biggest thing that we can do is better advertise and explain what Advanced coursework options
125are available to families and to students and so some of that's been happening um I have still some more suggestions but um I think that one of the issues also is the schedule um you know students need to know that they can get around schedule challenges by taking summer course work or online course work that's not universally communicated or clear um the offering of career and Tech work that requires travel that's a problem with scheduling and getting more opportunities in that gets to equity that's related to the equity issues in our boundary review that's part of what that factor of equity to educational options is it's if you have to travel and you're using up your time um I think too if you do your four core academics plus a world language you're really down
126to the minimum and I've seen my own kiddo try and do this and she wants to try these things but she's really hampered to do that and then if you play an instrument or sing I mean forget about it so like what is really these are all great strategies but until we really fix like a lot of mechanical things I don't really think we're going to see much of a difference um just some questions about how courses are selected and this goes back to when we approv some stuff um in the few months ago I just got these questions from a consist constituent how how did the school system determine what schools to offer a course act next how many are currently in a virtual version of it is it possible for teachers to split
127what's the best way to show interest from parents to demonstrate an interest in a course no Universal responses that I know of to any of this so that would be my feedback um did anybody want to respond to miss Marin's comments in the interest of time I think maybe not it the only thing I would say um is if I was following your questions we have a standard set of courses that all schools offer right and then there are the optionals that are more at a school level so um you know you've been you've been a great support like providing us those inconsistencies and I think U we'll just continue to partner moiser um so I would really love to see when we're talking about sixth grade in Middle School I'm going to put a
128plugin again if there's all these benefits of it then I think we need to be care ful of making sure that app it's for all students who are in sixth grade I mean not just some um I am wondering again going back to data points if there's an overlap from the fact that Mr frish mentioned about surprising data that our um English language Learners are less successful in math and the overidentification for special education services when you then also see the level of math completion algebra 8th grade by by our special education students so I think when we need to pull these District data points together to look at why things are happening the way they are um I did have a question about earlier um supports we mentioned young scholars and twice in the
129twice exceptional handbook but these things have been around for a while so what are we doing differently with these programs I'll pause here so uh Dr King could you respond to that I know that's a a topic in terms of closing the opportunity Gap with the young Scholars yeah I I really don't want to waste any more of my time I only get 90 seconds I can I didn't hear the question I can say it again if my time doesn't start one one thing please have her restate the question without the time quickly yeah the young scholars in the twice successional handbook have been around for a long time and we're not seeing these changes so what is being done differently with those two programs now because I don't want to keep listing things we've
130been doing I think we are seeing quite a few changes with young scholars we've got data that shows over the last 3 to four years we've increased the number of young scholars participating in AAP or in advanced courses depending on the grade level between 10 to 30% so we've seen a real increase and I think that's largely attributable to making sure that we had a line item funding for some funds for schools to support young scholars some of the things that we've done to uh code into CIS young scholars um program enrollment some of the things that we've done um to really support our our teachers with understanding the access and the strategies that young scholars need to succeed as well as full-time Advanced academic resource teachers at the middle school so we're seeing a
131lot I think with young scholars the twoe handbook um again continues to be a challenge to make sure that everybody in the system really understands the effective strategies for supporting our twoe students but that's a big piece of our inclusion work and our inclusion model is we change programming and Service delivery that's it's a large area of emphasis two points I'd like to see more stem enrichment in every Elementary School I think if you get kids excited about stem then they're going to want to do math at an earlier age and I haven't heard any conversation about steam actually steam enrichment and and there's so much mix between Arts and Technology that I think you get kids who are into Arts into technology through things are interested in and I think we need to think
132about what gets kids interested and then Infuse technology in that instead of the other way around the twice excep my handbook I haven't heard any plans on implementation oversight who is responsible for the implementation and the oversight to make sure it's being followed and understood and even known that it exists two questions so I can start this is the first year that as part of the required PD we had this um the twoe handbook was part of what teachers needed to look at and do kind of an attestation that they were even aware that it existed so that going from unaware to aware was step one um as far as who is holding it accountable um I think that comes in we have a multi-year plan around 2 e about how we first um one
133of the first things that we've done this year is we've ensured that we have data so we understand who our twoe students are as a county so then we can make sure our teachers know there's now a CIS flag that lets teachers know that they have two e students in their classroom that will hopefully and with the support of um either arts and special ed um people in the schools will help them make the connection I have two e students here's a handbook to help me how and we get this that we get this started I'm sorry I'm talking as fast as I possibly can I know this is not the best work that we are doing right now think we need to be clear as to where we are on these things and not
134just list them because it gives us implication that it's being implemented I know but you were speaking in between so I just want to get to um Miss um lady and then miss um Dix Dixit uh as always thank you for the report uh I would like to see some data if possible in the correlation between grades in in Algebra 1 and so Pass rates I just want to see if our a students and B students are passing I just want to make sure that we're measuring them and evaluating them um especially 100% retake policy um because that should be getting you to a pass rate uh also online campus uh it's robust um but we need to make sure we continue to fund it you know my fear is that and and I've heard
135some conversations from principles that there's been some Communications between online campus and and principles that they're not going to be able to offer all the classes kids are requesting and we can't do that we have to offer them what they're asking for to make sure we have equity and access um the other question is uh Dr Reed I'm very fascinated about the course taking patterns data I would love to see that um and my other question is you know what sort of followup is happening I mean you can probably deduce from that um schools who are not who are under matching kids and or counselors who are undermatching kids to be quite Frank I mean you could be in a school that's got great data except for one particular alphabet um and I just want
136to know what kind of training is going on because I worry that we don't give quality professional development to our school counselors our school counseling office does a fantastic job however I don't think that they're owning to the fact that they need to that they need to thoroughly understand a curriculum and how it maps to postgrad planning if you want to do this trade what do you need to have if you want to do to this particular college for this major what do you need to have so your question is I apologize I was trying to hear the question teasing out the data and if there's any followup or feedback back to director of student services of a program or or around specific counselors and then I mean I'd be fascinated to see it yes
137ma'am we've got um we my directive to uh High School principles as we worked collaboratively on this is that all high schools would be involved in this work within two years so uh we could have Front Runners this year and then everyone else needed to come on board next year and I believe we have 20 uh high schools this year and the remaining will join the work next year and yes we do have the data um by high school for sure for the last two years and principales are really excited and I think this is work our school-based staff have wanted to do and it provides data in real time to make make it actionable for students um and it's one of the I think most um transformational strategies that can occur in real time
138without new resources without um new funding it's just being very intentional in the work that we're expected to do um Dr Pon is familiar with the work I've done the work in our prior State I know Dr King's doing has is part of the team Dr King Dr Pon and Dr Presidio Dr King as a former Regional person when you've talked with some of the principles what are what's their feedback you know I I reflected back to when I was a principal myself when I saw the data and how excited I was to be able to know right away you know how our counselors are pushing our students towards which classes and then how you could double back and have conversations with them as the why right when we see students are capable of taking
139higher level classes and they're not being um celed that way then we need to figure out the why behind that so I think that AEL is going to be trans trans formidable like Dr Reed said so I I just want to put a pin in that and a serious fine point to say that the equity work is not an intellectual exercise on this topic it's simply a matter of looking at the data and making sure each and every student has access to cour taking patterns that benefit them and that's why Dr King Dr Pon and Dr Presidio are working collaboratively on this it's critical thank you love it thank you for this uh very long presentation I know it was a lot um so I wanted to first uh take everybody's attention to page 26
140which is the we have the higher rate of eighth grade passing High School mathematics SOS uh this is why wife FCPS is one of the best school districts in the country in academics we do it well um I do want to say that this increase from 58% to 62% means there is intentional work done and we would I would like to appreciate um the staff and the teachers principals Dr Reed whoever is part of that is uh it's it's great going and we just want to see the skip number going up and up um my question is um do we uh we talked about math success uh D dashboard uh on page 36 on the slide would you be able to tell me what that is hi so um we've been working with our it
141Department to develop a dashboard um formerly known as algebra writing us dashboard trying to broaden the scope um it has several different pages um we have a page that just is about enrollment where schools can look at where their enrollment stands with mass 7 honors and algebra one um in middle school and then we also have other pages that can be used to um Target different student groups so filters that you can use as a school to determine oh um of my students who are passing the so what class are they projected to be enrolled in and what class are they enrolled in right now so we can do some reverse verification to ensure that students who are showing aptitude are enrolling in those more rigorous courses um Elementary is also included in that um
142we have pathway we actually have a very similar diagram to what able has provided high schools it's called a sanki diagram and it shows Pathways of where students are coming from in elementary and where they're enrolling in not only seventh grade but in eth grade so that uh pyramids can do some vertical looking at where our students coming from and are we making sure that all of our students are reaching their Highest Potential thank you for the answer and then quickly and I'm I want to have more questions but I'll come after budget session um how FCPS is doing in advanced course work as compared to neighboring counties I think mtic that that's something we would have to see if we could get that kind of information what we try to at least show is
143some some information to contextualize around AP exam outcomes to provide some contacts that would be helpful the CTE AB uh IB and dual enrollment thank you picking up on the algebra I was very excited to see this as well but it also dot on me most of the school divisions their sixth graders are already in the middle school and it makes me also wonder and they're doing less well than us with that configuration so it makes me wonder as well what is our data that shows how our sixth graders who are in Middle Schools how are they doing in this um Endeavor can that data be provided we can certainly add that to the list of data follow-ups you were about to say something I was I was recently at po middle school and visiting
144with one of the Math teachers there um Mr shidler maybe Alex anyhow amazing math teacher amazing program principal ponudi was showing me around and they are poised at sixth grade next year to have a sixth grade section of algebra at po middle school so I think as they um recognize the opportunities and have the resources we're going to see as significant shift Even in our schools that already have sixth grade at middle okay thank you and this question is mostly to the achievement Gap Group which I believe the the three of you I didn't see any data in the report that shows how we are doing some back of the envelope math on my part and looking at math for um multilingual students going from 11 and the highest performing group was 79 that Gap
145was 68 um and last year was 66 why do we not have that date a little bit more efficiently presented I think if if you're looking Dr Anderson to see is the gap growing or shrinking that's certainly something we could provide some information I think what we see in some of these measures is gaps are growing between highest performing and lowest performing student groups and then we have seen somewh that Gap is shrunk it would be great just to have a for a sheet that actually shows that last piece when it comes on page 36 you're talking about um the data here is the denominator the number of students up to e8th grade or the number of students who took the class but did not get us but may not have passed I'm sorry can
146you tell page 36 not slide 36 I have no idea what it correlates to um this is looking at looking at the percent of students who received the verified credit is out of the class the entire 8th grade cohort so so the eth grade so how do we in how do we incorporate students who may have taken algebra by seventh grade they would count in this data set so you're looking at anybody in that eighth grade C this is everybody who's an eighth grader in Fairfax County last year yes that's correct thank you thank you the last thing that I want to ask with my 13 seconds on page 34 of the report there's an equity statement there it's at the very bottom it says from an equity perspective and it goes on and on
147I help me to understand how this is applicable to us here so I think what this is in the research I'm going to do my best to try and synthesize the research is that using data to show when students are academically ready for Algebra 1 helps reduce some of the disparity so I think back to an earlier question that we're asking about why are we seeing maybe fewer multilingual Learners there may be an opportunity Gap that we're not paying attention to so when we use performance data to objectively encourage all those students who me meet a certain threshold to participate in Algebra 1 the research says you see less disparity in terms of the demographics of students who are participating in Algebra 1 in middle school I definitely have a followup but I have run
148out of time um Miss setlo should we be wrapping up this section as you had previously asked if we may come back to it after budget so we would need to reconvene the work session since the work session and budget are actually two separate meetings we would just you would need to reconvene it so we will just pause for right now because we do think we're going to have time okay so if that's the case then we should recess this portion instead of end it so that you have the ability to reconvene and if it turns out that we don't have time after budget then you would need to come back in really quickly and close this session out okay then we're in recess way to their seats uh that would be great so welcome
149to the first work session on the budget a couple of quick housekeeping items um Mr dun Express say regret but cannot make it today um this is a really good opportunity for us to all have a deep dive into the budget and ask questions um it's also the beginning of a of a community dialogue that I'm looking forward to um there is not a next steps document we did not do this last year the next steps is the budget question process um which uh thank you to Lee and her staff we've really acceler the response time on those so next steps you just submit a budget question and they'll be answered in uh in the queue um after Lee gives her presentation we will do round one three minutes per member and then a Gob
150back round also three minutes per member so with that I'd like to turn things over to the superintendent thank you Mr McDaniel um this afternoon um it's important to note that we're going to be reviewing our proposed budget for fiscal year 2026 and the team has been working hard on putting together the numbers uh which really pulled together an integrate a wide variety of departments School needs topics that must be addressed and in particular it's nice to see the proposed budget um alongside goal three in this work session uh because as we contemplate achieving the outcomes of goal three it's critical that we are resourced to do that uh the first nine slides of the presentation our slides I reviewed um at the uh public meeting our last regular meeting so I won't review those
151in detail this afternoon um but I would like at this point to turn the presentation over to miss Burton who will begin with slide 10 if you're watching at home or listening from home you certainly can review slides 1- n and the presentation provided at the last regularly scheduled board meeting Miss Burton thank you Dr to read um good afternoon and I'm just going to do a real quick summary because you all already heard this on the 23rd when the superintendent proposed her budget but just as a little refresher so high up of course our budget priorities are providing competitive compensation meeting the changing needs of of our students um providing differentiated services and of course continuing multi-year initiatives next slide um the FY 26 proposed budget totals 4 billion which is an increase increase
152of 297.00 25 approved budget um to support these Investments we're requesting an additional 268 million in County transfer funds or about 10.4% um and that transfer request um is is about the same as we asked for last year if you can go to the next slide and of course the first thing is compensation adjustments um and that as a result of the collective bargaining uh agreement um we've included 7% salary increase across the board for all employees um as well as a change to the um food service and transportation salary scals and then of course our health rate changes we also have some small retirement rate changes that total 5.5 million and then we always recognize base savings uh from turnover so that the total of compensation is about 214 million next Slide the Baseline
153adjustments are recurring cost of adjustments that have happened at the quarterly fund reviews um like substitute teacher incentives middle school late buses um Esports stiens workers comp legal fees online campus those kinds of things that are recurring but we've been funding with onetime funds so we we need to really include those in the Baseline um the enrollment cost is about 20 million represents about 208 positions and Matthew Norton assistant budget director will go over that in more detail and then 9.3 million to support um enhanced summer school and 3.6 million to address the backlog of Maintenance projects and those are both routine adjustments that we we have every year um included is um as changes to support that the transfers to other funds and then the contractual rate increases are cost escalations for maintenance contracts
154inflationary increases leases those kinds of things and the Baseline adjustments total 65.2 million multi-year initiatives are at 4 million those are things that you know previous boards or this board have have approved um but that we couldn't do in one year and so we phased it in over multiple years that includes the Inclusive Preschool expansion the uh human Capital Management project find and Performing Art stiens and then certified athletic trainers next up are identified Investments um and that's 14.2 million and that's only two things the Safety and Security and that will fund I don't think it's been decided exactly yet which projects um are the top priority but we know there's a need for exterior security cameras at 44 elementary schools expansion of the rback program uh a panic alert system and security vegetable funding
155and then 4.9 million U for differentiated learning credentials which um will support us offering micr credentials for Universal Design for Learning and multilingual Learners so then if you look at the revenue um again it re requests a County transfer increase of 268 million or about 10% uh and that's primarily to to fund a compensation adjustment state revenue again our budget includes what the governor introduced and those funds um increases total 23.2 million um and that's the state share of a 3% compensation supplement uh increase in English language learner initiatives um and we we're we hoping that the general assembly will allocate additional funding for k12 and to make good on the work of Jar um and they they have a little bit we'll go over that when we do the state update federal aid is
156projected to decrease by a million and that's just current federal awards for Carl Perkins and Ida which are the only two grants that support the operating fund all the other Federal funding is in the grant fund um but that those awards are expected to reduce by a million dollars and then the other Revenue increase is due to increases related to Thomas Jefferson um tuition from other divisions and the city of Fairfax um you should you know it's it's worth reminding you that next slide over the last three years we've had lower and lower rates of County funding compared uh if you compare fiscal 15 to 19 the historical average was 52.7% in fiscal 25 that dropped to 51.5 which was an impact of 64 million to FCPS um so that that's where we stand on
157that and again with the state funding you know we began that conversation months ago um Virginia school divis divisions receive less funding per student than the 50 state average and the regional average and then many of our neighboring states spend more per pupil including West Virginia Kentucky and Maryland but for now Virginia school districts have yet to see any meaningful change as a result of the jayar study jayar estimates that we are underfunded by 5687 million that's not the entire Commonwealth that is just Fairfax County Public Schools um that equates to approximately $3,100 for each of our young people um they also have done some near-term um recommendations um based on their findings focusing on raising on uh elimination or slightly raising the support cap exploring enhanced support for special ed uh and the importance
158of addressing data infrastructure needs however at this point no concrete legislative reforms have been adopted about the jart study um so we continue to wait on that and now I'll turn things over to Matthew Norton who will provide an update on enrollment and student needs next slide uh good afternoon Schoolboard members and thank you Lee uh this portion of the benchmarks chart that is focuses on student enrollment is shown on the chart before you here uh you can see with the exception of special education that we are not projecting substantial enrollment changes uh and we'll go over each of these areas individually uh after I touch on the budget impact uh overall so uh next slide please uh as far as the budget impact goes here you'll see a chart that should look familiar uh
159we've gone over it the last three or four years now and it's also included on our budget documents um but you can see the bottom right of that chart shows with a $20 million increase related to enrollment in student needs and if you look right above that Total Line you can see the sub total for special education is 20.6 million and so basically special education is the factor that's driving um enrollment and student need growth in this budget all of the other items are um basically netting to a fairly negligible amount in comparison or about negative .6 million uh and again we'll go over each of those uh in detail as we progress U next slide please uh we wanted to just start off with a quick uh chart Just sh overall enrollment and how
160things have uh changed since the pandemic you can see uh from this dotted line uh projected enrollment uh over the years since fy21 and then you can see the x's and the Red X represent our actual enrollment in each of those fiscal years with the red being an estimate as we don't yet have final data this year there's a component of our enrollment data that's not measured until after March 31st although it's a very small component so we wouldn't expect things to change very much for that fy2 uh where that is at 18333 um and so that's just uh information for you uh on the overall enrollment now next slide please uh we'll kick things off with uh the component of our staffing formulas that's related to free and reduced price meals um so what
161we did is we kept last year's chart and moved it over to the left and then we've provided this year's chart for the the cost impact on the budget um and again as I said previously special education is the area where we're seeing the most growth so you'll see pretty small dollar amounts on these other slides but for the frm component we have about a.2 million impact um and that's largely because there are the for the number of schools that are increasing in their frm band we have corresponding schools that are decreasing and so we really have kind of a net zero impact over uh the course of the entire School Division uh you can see that we have roughly the same number of schools eligible for needs-based Staffing at 122 it's actually down one
162from from 123 last year and then you can see that instead of a two percentage Point increase we have a kind of negligible um increase this year um again all that kind of leads to that very small dollar amount when it comes to the impact on the budget um if we pop to next slide uh here you'll see a line chart where we're taking uh the solid line is that same information that was provided uh previously for overall enrollment and we're just jux opposing it with um a dotted line that represents free and reduced price meals um and what I'd really like you to hone in here on is the fact that from fy2 to FY 26 that line is relatively flat whereas if you look the last two years it had been increasing pretty
163substantially um now even though that Line's flat we still do expect our overall percentage of students to be eligible for free reduce price meals to pop up to 37% so up 0.1 percentage Point um and that's because our overall enrollment is projected for a slight decline so even though you know the enrollment stank flat we still see a slight rise in the percentage of students eligible uh that's over one in three students eligible for free and reduced price meals in the county um and just for context I think when I started working here it might have been under one in four so it's it's definitely changed quite a bit in my tenure here at FCPS uh if we move on to the next slide we're into the multilingual learner section of uh the changes to
164the budget um this year we have a a shift uh towards lower levels of service needs so towards levels three and four whereas last year the growth that was projected was primarily focused on levels one and two um a lot of the shift is actually based on how students came in this fiscal year um and then we also have a slight decline at 421 fewer students projected to receive Services um those two things alone would actually be a savings to the budget but we are having to um adjust uh to um recognize that the the state had an S soq hold harmless in this current year um that we didn't have to completely meet the requirements set at the state level and so this is going to be the first year where we have to
165meet the full new standards um and so that's offsetting the savings that we have from the slight reduction in cost and resulting in a exact a million dollar um impact to the budget um if we move on to the next slide you can see again we've we've done that same line chart again with overall enrollment in instead of frm this time we're obviously DRX opposing with multilingual learner Services you can see it's a little bit flatter over the time period um and and we actually have like I said that projected decrease from FY 25 to FY 26 um and a slight downtick in the percentage of students who are are expected to be eligible for services um as a percentage of the total population um and then finally we'll move on to the special education
166section of the student needs portion of enrollment um and here's again where you see that $2.6 million cost um and you can see that the numbers this year are very similar to last year we're projecting 1,486 additional students to receive special education services that's very much in line with last year's number um and the one reason the cost is a little bit lower this year or you know $4.6 million lower is that we're actually um opening far fewer uh preschool special education classrooms um because the the influx that we provided last year was enough to kind of meet capacity for even this coming year um is is what the projections are showing um and so there is a a slight savings compared to last year but still a cost of 20.6 million um and again
167uh same line chart that should be familiar with by now except we have special education as the dotted line and then what I would point out there is that that line continues to to increase um whereas the other two were're leveling off or U slight slightly declining and so you can see that uh for the projections for FY 26 uh we're projected to be up to 70 17.2% of students um eligible for special education services and that's up from 16.3% uh projected last year uh finally just to kind of wrap up a summary for you all uh what we've tried to do here is take all the data that's been in this this uh portion of the presentation from the last four years and provide you with the impact of each of those four categories
168um so you can see we show the projected enrollment change in each of the fiscal years culminating with a four-year net of 7,700 fewer students we have the impact that the overall enrollment had on the budget which again was a huge savings in FY 23 uh we had some student increases in 24 and 25 and now we're sort of leveling off but if you look at that four-year net it's a savings of almost 4 $6 million and then you can see that within each of the student need categories um you know we did have a little bit of savings in FY 23 but we've had uh you know tremendous growth in those areas um and so we're investing in providing services to uh our most vulnerable students and and that's resulting in that total budget
169impact that's the four-year net of 43.6 million and about 470 additional positions um I'll turn things back over to Lee for a compensation update yeah so go ahead and go to the next slide yeah um you know then for all of you that just as a reminder air compensation philosophy stems from a 2016 Market study and aspires to maintain a 95 to% of the market at the midpoint that's our goal um as of fiscal 25 we've Fallen just outside that window for the midpoint are even further away at the market Max um and our ranking compared to the other Visions is less than ideal in all three areas men mid and Max you know and you I think you all would agree we have incredible teachers and staff here at FCPS and we want to
170keep them by offering competitive salaries that allow them to live in our County um beginning teacher salaries for the Master's Lane still lag behind other school divisions in the metro area ranking fifth of eight Washington area Board of Education or wavy participants an increase of 7% will prepare Propel our standing to First of eight beginning salaries for those with a master's degree um and if salaries are not at the top of the region we will continue to lose excellent Educators to other divisions it is very valuable for us to be able to go to these job fairs um in the Commonwealth and say we pay the most in the metropolitan area you may or may not know that of the um education programs at universities in Virginia about 2500 people um graduate every year with
171a degree in education and here in Fairfax we could hire them all and we want to um so get them trained up and and turn them into lifelong um employees of Fairfax County Public Schools and the way to do that is to pay the most at least at the beginning salary so that's one of the reasons why we concentrate on that um if you look at the um midpoint or teachers at the middle of their career right now we rank seventh of eight wayy divisions um but this budget will improve our standing to the midpoint um to fifth of eight and then next slide at the maximum we rank seven of eight um and we expect to remain there even with the 7% compensation increase um but the collective bargaining agreement will address this issue
172a little bit because you may recall that the agreement um shows that we will add one step at the top of the scale in fiscal 27 and fiscal 28 um the surrounding counties with us have 30 or more steps on their teacher scale because it takes 30 years to get a full unreduced vrs uh retirement uh and we currently have 25 steps so you know we we have made a con I think we started at 18 the last time they did a salary study for teachers there was only 18 steps on the the teacher salary schedule and we've kind of been whittling away at that so now we're at 25 steps um but we really you know have a goal of trying to get to 30 so that we we we pay more at the
173top for our most tenear teachers and it also is you know enough years to get an un unreduced uh vrs benefit and you know for all that we're comparing fiscal 25 um because certainly at the time the superintendent proposed her budget we don't have a lot of fiscal 26 information um we have a little bit more now um so for fiscal 26 um Alexandria has stepped out with 2. 85% and MSA but their MSA varies uh among different groups so we we don't have they're giving it but as far as a percentage average we weren't able to get that from them Arlington doesn't release their budget until 313 um and they have not shared with us what their salary uh proposal is false churches included 5% uh of course us 7% Lowden has included 65%
174step plus Cola Manassa City releases on February 25th Manasses Park on February 10th and Prince William releases on February 5th but Prince William has already released um information to the media about their agreement with their uh Union and there they have also agreed on 7% in fiscal 26 so we would expect this to say 7% um once their budget comes out I guess that's tomorrow and so this is just a chart of the beginning salary uh the master M's Lane and again we anticipate um the 7% um catapulting us to first in the beginning teacher salary in the region a Improvement at midpoint and Max again are not as favorable um but that's something that you know we're going to work on in the future um the next slide um is about the state and
175federal update we want to provide you the latest information that we have which at least with the federal it's not much but we'll we'll tell you what we have um but first let's talk about the state uh and on Sunday February 2nd just a couple days ago the House and Senate each released their amendments to the governor's introduced budget there are a number of similarities that suggest the reconciliation process could be smoother this year um both CH Chambers maintained the um VPI funding that the governor had reduced um they provide a per pupil add-on for special education um there are a couple of differences the Senate has called for the bonus to be provided in fiscal 25 um prior to June 1st while the house bonus would be in fiscal 26 so next year um
176but both would come with expenditure requirements of course in their respective fiscal years the house provides about 100,000 for Title One enrichment which the Senate does not um and you should know that the final vote on the conference budget is no later than February 22nd of course the governor has a bit of time to line item veto and then the reconvene session will be on April 2nd but we'll of course continue to monitor the state budget and culminating with their inclusion in the approved budget uh assuming there aren't any delays at the um state level and as many of you are aware there's been a flurry of activity with the new federal Administration while exact specifics continue to be elusive it's clear that we may not be able to rely on consistency of federal funding
177as has largely been the case historically um the new ad Administration attempted to freeze Federal funding while reviewing compliance with the president's numerous executive orders um but court challenges result have resulted in a temporary restraining order uh and subsequent withdrawal of the OMB memo um that started all the confusion but of course the executive orders remain it's just the OM memo that was rescinded and that was the implementation piece about the pause and again you all know that K12 the pause targets funding that are in support of initiatives that are out of alignment with the executive orders uh and so for K12 that's Dei initiatives environmental issues and immigrant primarily I mean there's been a couple of executive orders since then um about other things that weren't directly related to grant funding um although make
178no mistake the other executive orders are absolutely contemplate um leveraging this funding to get us in compliance with those two executive orders as well um we have you know over 160 million in federal dollars across our various funds um we don't believe that the majority of these dollars overlap with the executive orders meaning the Dei initiatives the environmental initiatives um and the immigration and it'ses those three things that created the pause um not a a lot of the dollars of the 168 million are in support of those initiatives so that impact if it's as stated um won't be as as significant as it could be um again due to the lack of clarity and the potential for the administration to use funding as leverage um it's prudent to proceed with the utmost caution um you
179know I'm horrified to to report that nobody's still really talking about food service serves um at the federal level I've not heard a lot of uh information about that um and that is particularly concerning because even though all of these funds um in you know that that funds the operating fund is a very small amount of the 4 Bill billion budget that's idea and Perkins um and then of course adult and Community Ed that's Workforce Development that's just a couple of million the grants and self-supporting that's all of the titles Title One title two title three that's about 56.5 million and but the food and nutrition services the meal reimbursement is 58.2 million um as Matthew said about 37% of our kids rely on uh free and reduced meals and for those kids some for
180some of them that is the the best meal they get all day long um and that makes up 60% of Food Services budget so that is much larger impact than any of the other you know Federal funding sources um again you know food nutrition is required to maintain three months fund balance um so of course we can limp along for a few months um but I I'm I just can't imagine that cooler heads are not going to Prevail and that somebody's going to decide that food services should also be exempt as Social Security Medicare um those you know pale grants the direct payments to individuals uh that somebody's going to see the wisdom of that and and exempt that from the pause as well but for now we just have to wait and see and
181now we're going to do uh the Baldridge award update and Marty Smith is going to take care of that okay and good afternoon everyone it's good to be back in the budget seat I haven't been at a board presentation for a little over a year and a half so it's good to be here uh I am going to provide a bit of an update for where we are in the balers process uh and for the community and for the board we are in the process of applying for the Malcolm Baldridge National Quality award and uh for some background it it's an award that was established by con by Congress to improve the quality of American products and services in Education Health Care business and government organizations uh so it's an opportunity for us to find
182uh efficiencies in our organization particularly with our operations the review is broken up into seven specific categories uh I'll read them allowed for uh those who might be following along in the community we have leadership strategy customers measurement analysis and Knowledge Management Workforce operations and results next slide please so the framework includes a series of questions uh to get to the heart of our strategy and our process such as how do we conduct strategic planning how do we listen to our customers there are a lot of how questions that drive this work uh and we'll be uh talking a little bit more about that with the presentation to begin this work we've developed cross functional teams of principles and central office leaders to document our strategy and process in each of the categories I shared
183earlier and this month our senior leadership team will begin the process of analyzing the work of these teams to look for duplication of efforts gaps in our work current efficiencies and inefficiencies I will say that the foundation of this work will be looking at our dollars and FTE by departments uh and offices and also by the tasks of those uh individuals in those departments uh and we're also going to be using uh the program budget uh it's a shout out to Lee's budget team for all the work that they put into the program budget U we'll be using that program budget as the foundation of our work as well at the conclusion of this full review recommendations for streamlining our process will be presented to the superintendent for possible implementation during uh FY 26 quarterly
184budget reviews and certainly for the FY 27 budget process next slide please it's important to note that the project is ahead of schedule uh as you may recall we were presented with the spirit award for our organizational profile submission uh and we're currently gathering information for our 25 page submission uh and that application is about 50% complete so again those seven teams are working across to the division to gather information for that application process and we're about halfway there and as I shared earlier the senior leadership team will assess the information in each of these categories to finalize that application and that same team uh will gather information for our 50-page application uh to include results and this application is due onor before December 1st next slide please and with regard to the timeline uh
185our first 25 page application is due this spring and that feedback will be used for our submission for December 1st uh then in late winter of 2026 we will have Baldridge reviewers here at FCPS uh they will have the ability to engage with uh individual board members uh engage with members of our uh staff members of our community uh to get feedback on our processes to see if the information that we shared with them is actually embedded in the work that we do uh and then the results of that 50-page applic application in any potential award that we will receive uh will be shared in the spring of 2026 now bald has shared with us that it's rare to win an award on the first submiss submission but we are Fairfax County and we're uh
186shooting for that award on the first submission uh and regardless of any award we will receive feedback for all areas of improvement uh on all of our application submissions and I also want to note that we're beginning with a regional process uh so that our national application is well positioned as possible to receive an award so uh these Regional reviewers who are coming out they're highly trained examiners who will provide direct actionable feedback for uh the superintendent and the leadership team and then we will have the ability to apply for that national award uh with our submission in 2027 and with that I will turn it back over to miss Burton y'all are familiar with their budget question process um and we're of course hard at work on the latest questions uh although most have
187been answered to dat right now we have 34 asked 20 were Priority One 14 were priority two of the priority One 19 of the 20 have been answered and the one remaining doesn't have a due date till February 18th uh so I'm confident we'll we'll we'll get that done within the 30-day time limit and the priority two we're they're all in development uh being worked on and then the next slide um we have a public hearing tonight my understanding is the February 5th one has been cancelled um you know you all need to be thinking about if you have budget in amendments because you know we'll need to cost those if you have some um we have another school board work session on February 18th and then the school board will approve the uh 26
188adverti Budget on February 20th and we look forward to your discussion and can answer questions thank you so I saw first uh Miss Anderson without delving too deeply into um all the nuances of what's going on at the federal level um I did have some questions do we have any visibility as to what the Food Services impact would be for Virginia overall is there is there a place to get that information to determine for the state what it would impact is Michael Maloy here's State he's probably yeah down I think he's he's probably enrichment yeah uh no I do not okay and because I would also be very interested in the title one was looking um and I don't mean to use you as Google I just was looking to see whether or not there
189was a listing of how many Title One schools we had in the state of Virginia that that information doesn't seem readily accessible um and I was wondering if you guys were tracking that because I do think that it's important for us to work with our partners across the state to understand that while this is a significant impact for us it could be even more of a significant impact for other divisions across the Commonwealth if we actually aren't all working together to see what we can do to ensure that at least State funding can take over with the federal government decides to to not so I think that it would be a worthwhile Endeavor for us to understand where those partners are located so that we can we can in our capacities go out and see
190if we can round up some help okay thank you and uh Dr Anderson just to pick up on what Miss Anderson said as the legislative liaison I had the opportunity to participate in the federal Elations um committee's work whoops which is um organized by vsba and the food in security and the impact to um food and nutrition programs was the largest part of the conversation with that group yesterday with Senator Cain and so the Coalition is out there I'm here today I'm missing the second part because I had to be here today but everybody who's on that committee is on the hill speaking to their respective um respective um Congress representatives and some of the issues that we all have corales around is the impact of the food um issue so that is definitely out
191there and well inand um just to jump into my questions a little bit and I'm going to work backwards the bdge award um I think I was a little confused I think when the board had put forward in the um budget from a couple of years ago to do the assessment I didn't realize it came with an award I just thought it was an evaluation has that always been the case that's always been the case so it does come with an award so the uh for the operate the profile organizational profile we did win the spirit award which was our first award in this process and uh we're hopeful to win the national award at some point uh first with the region and then move on to the National sure you know as one board
192member because we've been talking about this since I've been on the board it's always talking about the efficiencies making sure we're maximiz izing all of our dollars the recommendations for streamlining processes that you mentioned on slide 44 will those be shared with the board you mentioned it will be shared with the superintendent I guess that's a question so they will eventually through the superintendent be shared with the board one of the things that we're uh that we are also going to do uh just this past Friday we shared an update uh with the board on our Baldridge work and as we move through those processes uh with all of the teams starting with leaders ship going on to strategy and those different category areas we'll be providing the board an update uh from our work
193from those areas thank you and the next question is primarily for Dr Reed um she is not here I'm so I couldn't even see um yeah how about I do that um on one of the slides I can't remember the one that talked about that had the threeyear view in terms of what our increased needs were as per student um um you know student enrollment um no I think it's slide 30 yep just got it are you anticipating is this I I reading this correctly to state that in FY 26 we are needing an additional 207 positions is that what that me oh sorry I was distracted yes that's correct okay that's a lot okay um Dr Reed is here so I'll ask her my question um again we have lots happening in you know
194in the world in the political climate how are we preparing for the potential and I'm not saying it's going to happen but the potentially losing some of our grant funds how will we do we have a plan B that you're working on that will help to address the grant funded positions that we have and this is even outside of nutrition services so I think we're still it's early days on which grants and how they may or may not be affected we know that our major grants are front funded so they're good through um June 30th so as we except for things like our our meals program which are not grants that are frontf funded um so as we think about next year um I think we're going to learn more this spring some of those
195grants require Congressional approval to dismantle so uh I really I don't know that I want to speculate this afternoon but we're looking at a variety of scenarios um should X happen this is how we might respond in a y fashion should Z happen this is you know an H response uh but we're watching and monitoring very closely in between now and may when the final fin budget approval um is required I believe we will have more information then to make more concrete decisions but at this time um we're good except uh for meals and likely other uh non-front funded grants but not position uh grants other than our food and nutrition staff thank you I would appreciate that and I'll Circle back to that in a few weeks um speaking about the scales that are
196shown you've given us data for the master scales but cannot find the data for The Bachelor scales and I know that's not who we're targeting but it's good to have comprehensive information where can that be provided in terms of our um standing yes that can be provided we do um compare a little more favorably at the bachelor's Lane I I know that um but we typically you know try to hire people with the master's degree and so that's you know one of the reasons why we and the other divisions around us all concentrate on that Master's Lane um but we can get you that data that would be very helpful to have thank you and I'll go back please and uh Miss tixon thank you for the presentation um for the budget team it's a
197lot of work and thank you our budget chair and vice chair for all the works gone into it my question is for our slide 15 on Safety and Security needs uh I wanted to uh know what how much is a wraback program cost uh out of this $9.3 million I am not entirely sure I know that uh Mr Smith might be if you've spoken to Mr Malloy more recently it it's currently it's about a half a million dollars uh it's calculated at $1 per employee per month so it's about $12 per employee okay this is one of the thing we uh have been discussing and it's a very important um part of like a request made and it should be definitely be uh funded this program because it just takes anybody who has a criminal
198background applying uh with the prior States applying to FCPS um and it can be uh and if they're uh doing any crime I guess any anywhere it comes back to us as well the reporting is done so I didn't want to just I just wanted to know the dollar value because uh out of 9.3 it doesn't look like it is a big investment uh in that my uh actually the question I wanted to ask is um is there a reason and and I think we have to discuss this more uh with our colleagues On The Board of Supervisors that on slide 17 that there is such a deficit uh of the percentage year by year after year um is it we are collecting less revenue from the county uh from our taxpayers that that's happening
199maybe that number if you could highlight so question is are we collecting L revenue from the counties or we are getting less transfers now well the actual dollar amount is more but it's a less of a percentage share of the county resources that are available and uh there is any um I guess we have to find out why I guess from our side so um lastly I my question and I think May I'll I'll take a go back I haven't formalized all my questions um on this slide on page 20 where we have okay page uh number 28 slide 28 we have, 1486 additional students projected to receive special education service and and then 15 new classroom preschool special education classroom are coming uh we need at at the cost of $20 million uh cost
200um I wanted to are we building these uh classrooms why is it 3 million per classroom um so there may be some facility impact at a school school here or there but it's not I don't think it's widely expected that we would be you know building additions for all 15 classrooms um it's going to depend on the locations that the classrooms end up as to you know how the school can handle the capacity and whether or not they're you know shrinking in a sixth grade class or something like that because we are seeing larger cohorts at the upper grade levels sort of move into middle school and high school um and so I wouldn't say that there is a tremendous facility impact but there's certainly potential for some facility impact so this is um basically
201for it's including the the facility enhancement and uh the Staffing etc etc that's like a cumulative number the the 20.6 is the Staffing cost only Staffing cost only that's correct my question is I think to my colleague and I have 15 seconds and I will come back to that uh just understanding about our Universal learning uh you know we talk about that and then we have investing $20 million in special classroom for preschoolers so maybe you can answer me later and I have my additional time thanks only 3 million is the pre of the 20.6 3 million of it is the pre is preschool and that's um 15 teachers and 15 aids to support those uh 15 new classrooms uh and then the other 17 million is the other special educ education students yeah K12
202I have answer thank you uh miss Robin and then miss Robin yes Miss Rob miss lady and then miss mirin thank you uh just comment slide 27 and slide 29 are identical so one of them has to be the esol or the multi language learner data and one has to be sped so you can check that out later um but then I'm actually going to speak from the um resources that were provided by Dr Reed I believe I'm in the budget at a glance section of the book on page 15 where the breakdown is of the majority of employees are school-based I'm assuming counselors fall under teacher scale yes okay so the other comment I need to make is that while our ratios are good well decent um for high school and middle school that
203um we need to lower the ratio of student to counselor at the elementary level um we are losing Elementary counselors every year to neighboring systems who have a better ratio and these people are in the master schedule which is not what counselor signed up to do um so I think we have a compounded thing here that we need to look at that ratio and add more Elementary counselors um page 19 also of the of the budget report uh I want to talk about average class size and perhaps I'm wrong but I I need average class size to be representative of not specials not not certified teachers in that building and my point is when you talk about some of these ratios they look incredibly low but in practice they're not and my concern is we're
204getting that number but we're including the math specialist the AAP specialist a reading specialist steam specialist and dividing it by our total population instead of saying this is how many fifth grade classes we have third grade classes we have and dividing that by the population I think it's very misleading to our public and I personally have been hearing it from my constituency because they don't understand when they look at that number so I want to do the same thing at middle school and high school is is we can't talk about you know if I trade a teach teacher at the high school level because I need a 504 coordinator that's a certified person but they don't they're not fronting with kids they don't get a classroom of children um so I just want to make
205sure we we correct that math because I don't I think this represents specialists in the building as added on to the number of teachers and then divisible by the number of students in the building and just real quick missley I don't think what document are you looking at I don't think that's in the slide I I see staff furiously shuffling papers to find it this PowerPoint called budgeted glance whatever I was given I think Dr Reed gave us all of these and I put it in a binder is uh sure this is the budget document this was the this was the first page but again I'm talking the first comment I made and I'm losing time slide 27 and 29 of this presentation is identical data 27 so we have 27 it says we have
2061817 1 multilanguage projections and it's down to 18191 and that's the exact same projection for let me just clear that up real special education no no we we repeated the same overall enrollment line that's the solid line on all three CH the dotted Lin different okay thank you that's my my mistake then um so also on the budget at a glance um page 355 um I just feel like I just continue need to elevate this when we have schools of different size and we have one staff member in certain categories per school it's a gross in equity it's just a gross INE Equity when you have one esit at a high school of 2900 and you have one esit at a high school of I don't know 1,700 it's an inequity okay we fixed it
207with tpcs we fixed it with tpcs which is fascinating to me because they're they're not doing the instruction they're doing the hardware but we need support in the instruction but we also have one Finance Tech in a school of 2900 versus an elementary school of 350 I mean we've got to fix this inequity thank you and I'll take go back okay right perfect yep figured um Miss mirin and then Mr Moon okay I first want to say I really appreciated the fact sheets which were provided to the board that really tell the story of our funding and include everything from the you know particular line item to the jlar state funding recommendations and the federal landscape so this is really outstanding I also like that it's capturing in one place information about um compensation changes
208it's providing a history of what the board has done it's really an outstanding document I want to for me to see us be as strategic as possible in how we do our work you know the superintendent provides a wealth of information to the board weekly and then for each meeting and for me in reading these materials over the past few months in particular regarding facilities and budget prep and all sorts of other things I'm seeing a Nexus of connections that's informing my understanding and my questions and my intentions and my hopes for this board so I'm I'm trying to look at things at a big level um because there's tons of interesting stuff at the at these smaller levels but I can't keep on top of that and I don't think it's my job to
209so my biggest takeaway right now is that the school system and the County government must work more strategically and collaborating collaboratively you know maybe it's board to board but I think really it's executive to Executive um usually there's a stance with the budget the Board of Supervisors will increase a little bit and the schools will say it's not enough when really they're both true at the same time um this year and for the foreseeable future we have common challenges and I'll even say threats and efforts you know working against the success of our quality of life here in Fairfax so how do we as a board this is really you know for my colleagues I don't have have questions for staff yet as much but how do we as a board determine where to spend
210our Collective energy what messages and information should we all be committed to and sharing when we're advocating to other elected officials who may have a wider impact in voice and informing our community for instance um I think we need to keep communicating very clearly that we are filling gaps that are not part of our mission to educate students but it's critical to keeping them safe like wraback this is a law enforcement matter that we are now burdened with providing because the governor won't that's half a million dollarss we could use on instruction to do law enforcement work the cost of healthcare page six the cost of the pharmacy plans related to a contract this week that were asked to approve for um an extension for for siga um I tried to look up the profit
211margin for siga and Kaiser didn't get around to it but you know we are beholden to this and the community needs to constantly be reminded that this is out of our control also the increases in International baloria and advanced placement uh college board um I also wanted to do a little bit of learning so on page four and this is where I'll ask my specific question and I'll use a Gob back too but on page four that middle of the fact sheets that the board has there's a story about Staffing numbers and there are changes and some are quite large and some they go up and down and up and down and I'd like to know like what's the story behind that can we learn anything about that decision-making why did we have so much
212fluctuation and how do we avoid that so that's really a question for the superintendent and staff I'll have staff start and then I'll complete so which chart there's like several in the fact sheet that was sent to the board um it's the middle one um middle left so change from prior year the school board I mean it goes from 681 to 324 to minus 321 what page is that on sorry yeah so okay got yeah fact sheet page four the middle of the charts the header is summary of position changes FY 26 2006 to 2026 um and I believe the column that's tagged change from prior year SB and NSB those are our position changes overall so if you recall back to the for instance the present the part of the presentation that I delivered
213related to student enrollment growth we have 207 uh a position change of of plus 207 related to enrollment and student needs for instance that's going to be uh you know um part of that number there right so um we we it's that that all that is is the the the the combination of all the various position changes that are made in any given year but what I would say is that any given year student enrollment is what's driving the bulk of our position changes so does that does that help answer your question can I just finish this topic real quick well can can I just finish this we on this matter instead of waiting like 40 minutes quickly like so okay but like if you look at 14 15 and 16 I mean it's there's
214virtually no change in instruction and there's a change of 600 staff so I understand the tie to membership what I don't understand is is this okay and is this what we want to have happening where we have fluctations of 300 to 600 staff is that where we want to be and that because that seems like it would wreak havoc especially on schools thank you and do you want to go back yes okay put you down for IT staff go ahead so I think you're addressing the in changes is non- school-based correct because they're not tied directly to enrollment in the sense that we have formulas that are applied and that determines the Staffing but for the non-school-based positions um we began to allow permanent conversion of traded positions to author Iz positions back in 2021
215um so I mean most of the Departments have had no increases in central office positions at least since I've been here in the last six years and and it is my understanding long before that but we have been converting positions and when I I talk about conversion it's like okay we have a position that um a department head has been trading for for five or six years in a row and the same person is in that position but every year they're they're renewed for one year only because it's using traded dollars so we allowed them to convert them permanently so there was no dollar cost to the operating fund it was you you're giving up these dollars that you've been trading and we're adding a position so that that person is a a full full-time
216authorized employee moving forward and that's the case um for two or three years that we allowed those conversions and that's largely what makes up the increases that you see in the last six years for non-school-based positions is they're not ads to the I mean some of them are but it's very minimal amount most of them are conversions that was no cost to the operating fund it was just the position authorization thank you and Dr re did you want to jump in on this sure I just I think another piece to remember uh when we think about enrollment versus Staffing increases um and Dr precidio probably can um comment on this as well when and don't within the last six years I think the um special ed Department chairs for example were a new position maybe
217aart positions would be new and when we think about the size of our School Division um the special ed Department shares for elementary Alan would be 141 positions um or an aart I don't know if those were elementary middle and high but those I'll ask do a pridal but sometimes you can have several 100 positions added when enrollment doesn't shift because there's a desire for a certain level of service or a certain um initiative that's requiring that but Dr Presidio do you want to comment on that please yeah just real briefly because I think you covered it the only thing I would add is with the a positions it was largely expanding the elementary aarts to Middle to the Middle School level so that was the big programmatic um from from expansion for Arts but
218those would be not enrollment driven those would be initiative driven so I I do want to note that and maybe we should capture some of those um if your team Dr Presidio could capture a couple of those initiatives perhaps uh where maybe we've had math Specialists or reading Specialists with our new curriculum or however that uh plays out but that may be helpful in explaining the narrative there great thank you and uh Mr Moon uh some of the questions uh relate to what I had raised is at the regular meeting at the last meeting but before I go there let me first go to slide number 29 uh it is a special education enrollment projections uh could uh you know since fi23 has been steadily increasing uh and and we are expecting another 14 more
219than 1400 specializ students next year uh I'm assuming that's a number of students and number of services is also increasing I'm assuming uh could you tell us why the increase of a special education student number of special education students and number of services has been going up significantly higher than other categories so I can offer a few ideas but I I do think there's probably a larger question there for us to consider um so what I'll start out with those I think you know over the year uh yes sorry I speak a little closer um I think over the years there has been um you know better improvements in identification of what student needs are right and so um we certainly saw uh like when there was a lot more awareness about autism we certainly
220saw our autism numbers grow faster than other special education numbers um and so that's one example I'll give for a reason for the increase I I would say another thing that's been going on is that we've seen the number of students receiving preschool special education services increase over the years and those students naturally will transition into being kindergarteners with us assuming they're still here you know as they move through their school age career um so those are two things I I I I can can mention off the top of my head but I think you're probably also getting at a larger question about you know like like um you know what other things are maybe driving identification or over identification or any of those other things that are you know sort of sticky problematic things
221with any school system okay thank you you know when I ask these questions I I I you know try to keep in mind potentially what supervisors may be asking of us looking at this because be looking at the same slides that we do and and we just want to be want to be prepared to respond uh give them give them the information they need as they make a decision to fund us with that in mind uh I'm going to ask you a something that I did ask at the regular meeting is uh you know at times in in the past you know supervisor some supervisors regularly on the regular basis ask us what have you been doing differently what have you decided not to do uh has there been any any cost savings by doing
222something more efficiently we never see those information when you make a bud request to us so I wonder whether it is possible to include the slide or to somewhere when we go to the supervisor to tell them that these are some of the things things that we are not doing so we are saving this much of money by not doing this while we doing differently so we are saving this kind of money however at the same time we need to do these things that's costing us this much money so overall is going to cost us this much more so it's always way will help us in making our case to have those information presented to the supervisors and I would like to have those information for myself as well is it fair well we have
223not done you know a cut drill or reduction process although every year we certainly talk about it but you know 93% of our funding and our employees are school-based and 7% is a very tiny piece of our budget and there nobody wants to touch school-based as far as reductions go um because that means increases in class size that means less support less administrative support at the schools and you know of course they're clamoring for more staff not less um and in addition to that you know we're hampered by being a labor intensive industry and it's very difficult to do much more than compensation in any given year and every School Division CFO that I taught to struggles with the exact same thing with 90% of your budget being salaries and benefits um it's it's very
224hard to do anything except compensation but you know we we have not did not do any new consider any new initiatives this year whereas you know in previous years we would entertain um consideration of of new projects um we do have the the Chiefs are tasked with um when they are reviewing their baselines if there is you know something they're doing that they've decided is no longer a priority but they have something new that is a priority they have the ability to repurpose those funds from one thing to the other but that's largely invisible to to you all to us because they submit their Baseline it's they've made some moves around but we we we don't track what things they have reduced and what they have added that's part of their Baseline exercise and Mr
225pres I'm not going to disagree with you that a vast majority of our a budget going going into paper paying paper and their benefits granted that granted that uh as a a the body a you know making a case to a funding Authority we need to provide even though it could be a a small amount of money complete our overall budget that these are the some of the things that our each department has looked at and decide not to do and include that information well we did include you know we did not There Was You Know 53 million in fiscal 25 that was funded by Esser and those that you know those were items that even though you know we thought they were important because we funded them with Esser we did not include them
226in the operating Fund in the following year or absorb them as again I was not going to use this word but politically speaking it makes a political sense beneficial to us to show them something so that they could be use to talk to their taxpayers thank you and would you like a go back absolutely Mr wet chair all right good Mr fres chair fres just to pick up where Mr Moon left off I think one of the good things about the presentation this year is that it does zero in on many of the things that Mr Moon identified first uh it talks about the Banbridge effort and the efforts around efficiency aligned with being efficacious at the same time right you can be efficient and really make things awful for student performance and for retaining
227staff or you can be efficient with an eye towards being um you know maintaining quality and so that's what Banbridge is hopefully guiding us towards and we'll learn more about that excuse me I keep what is Banbridge is that a furniture store I think it's a furniture store Baldridge thank you Banbridge Baldridge it sounds like some weird law firm uh yeah um the other thing that I would note is in the early slides of the presentation which we glossed over uh in in today's work session is the percent not just the percentage of money going towards staff but the percentage of money ending up in the classroom and the ratio of money going towards central office um one of the things that I think this board has done well for board after board after board
228is keeping the the money going into central office relatively low um and so as a result um our ratios are better than almost every School Division in Northern Virginia when it comes to the split between classroom spending and central office spending so if there's an indication is to if there's waste or not clearly we are doing a better job than most in ensuring that we are investing in classrooms and Student Success I think that's slide seven um and I would also Hammer home the note about Esser the work we were able to do with the Esser money was not just fluff it was essential support for students that we have had to cut because we did not have the resources to continue funding it and this is just one year's worth of cuts right there
229are lots of things that we have no that we've either had to scale back or eliminate entirely in previous years as the money is kind of dried up so we've done quite a bit on this regard um and I think in every conversation we have about this I think we glossed over it today because we just went over this at the regular meeting um two weeks ago um but I think when we do talk about this in the future when we're out in the community when we're talking about it in our newsletters when we're talking to our supervisors when we're going to budget Town Hall meetings with our supervisors this is something that we need to hammer home the beginning of the conversation um and draw people's attention to thank you uh Mr mline uh
230thank you so much um so I would just and I I know this is common sense to everyone but this is the first budget that we've uh done as as this compilation of board members um and part of that brings me a little disappointment in that um you know a lot of the multi-year initiatives in this budget which I which I support um come from a prior board come from a strategic plan that that the new board didn't um have much say in um so that's just to say that um I'm disappointed that we don't have more of a mark on this budget as it stands um one first question I have for you is uh the um In the comparison of top scale of Master's level salaries the thing that really stood out to
231me was Prince William um which has a top salary of $149,000 how in the world do do they make that work um and how could we get to that point I mean I think that's more than our principles make I believe so yeah if you look at the class size um Prince Williams class sizes are larger than everyone else um and they are able to provide higher salar as a result of that fascinating okay that's helpful um next question is that um on um Staffing formulas um I I believe in the past we've been provided with a location where we can look at you know our our formulas for things like psychologists social workers where where can we find those it's in the appendix of the budget document and it includes um our FCPS Staffing
232standard and alongside it the state S soq stand got it what was it okay that's it for now thank you would you like would you like a go back okay all right um SE more Heiser yeah just really briefly first um I really I do appreciate Mr Moon's comments I know the budget Comm the budget chair and vice chair had conversations with you as well about talking about just fiscal responsibility that we that we're already demonstrating right in including also specifics about the differences between the the real needs that we're funding through Esther that we can't fund now so I don't know if you want to comment on that Dr Reed I do miss eore Heiser and it um my apologies for not being clear about that at the outset of this presentation but we
233did uh pair back over 50 million in expenses year-over-year uh because coming out of the pandemic we're still working on uh learning loss for a number of our students um in different grade levels as we emerge from the pandemic so our needs continue uh and the federal dollars that supported those needs do not so we had to stop doing some things to continue doing things that we funded with those dollars uh and saving over 50 million year-over-year is significant for us so I do want to make sure we um have a you know clear talking points on that moving forward yeah if you could get that maybe as a talking point as well in terms of some of the budget commentary that would be really helpful and if there's other things that we can cuz
234I agree I think demonstrating fiscal responsibility I mean there there's just a lot of pressures on our funders and a lot of competing priorities and and I know we're I know we're doing our part to be fiscally responsible but making it clear and and evident what we're already doing is would be really helpful um I know I'm going to sound like a broken record but hear me out I talk about inclusion I've talked about it for 15 years right now we're looking at the greatest increase of our costs in the budget enrollment wise for special education students so I'm just going to read you something in the United States research has indicated that inclusion is 11% or 133% depending on which study you look at cheaper for special education students um for total expenses at
235the federal state and District level for school district only levels inclusive practices may be as high as 37% Cheaper by the way I said this to Dr Garza um research in internationally has found similar evidence in Bangladesh reductions in wage earnings due to exclusive educational practices were estimated to cost the country 54 million per year and inclusive education was estimated to recoup 20% according to the World Bank a similar figure of 20% was found in Nepal and China each year of education for people with disabilities led to a wage increase of 6.4% so if you want to talk about how to save money for the fastest growing need of population it is inclusive education which also research shows is tied to better outcomes both socially and academically and long-term economically so the costs may go
236up in the beginning as we change our practices to be more inclusive but it is clear from 30 years of studies that is not only fiscally responsible but an educational imperative so I just wanted to put that in the public sphere so people know when we keep talking about taking kids away and putting them in these separate classes and all this stuff like intervention blocks and pullouts and things are all so good we still still have a Continuum but both from a fiscal a moral and an educational perspective inclusive education is the way to go to answer my colleague's question the reason that we aren't there yet is because it's going to take time to take what we're doing in Pro this is why I keep talking about program delivery it will save us money
237and it will be better educational outcomes we have to do that from a budget perspective and an education perspective I have more I'll take a go back but I I wanted to put that in the air thank you I'll take a quick turn then we'll go to uh go backs um as always thank you Lee and your staff for this and Dr Reed um there's a lot of work that goes into this behind the scenes and and I know you're staying on top of it um so on slide seven I I really like this slide um I think this is a really important number that kind of tends to maybe get glossed over a little bit because I hear you know newspapers and things like that you got all this administrative blo all this central
238office staffing and all this kind of stuff so I actually asked staff let's look at what the facts tell us and the facts tell us right there that not only we the lowest in the region or the low or the lowest and the second highest is a factor of two so it's not like we're tied neck and neck and it's as a wash it it is a significantly less percentage of our staff is sitting in this building for the most part and I think that that you know it again it it tends to get washed out but that's really important to remember um side 14 and I'm I'm I'm beating the proverbial dead horse here but I'm I'll do it again stem stiens it's not a lot of money I think it's the right thing
239to do for the people that sponsor our stem organizations because in order to get a lot of grant funding we have to have that role fulfilled and we're giving stiens across the board to other positions but we're our stem folks tend to get lost in this so perhaps I'll bring a budget amendment for that but um I just want to throw that out there again um on the Baldridge award I'm really excited about this um do we actually get a medal we we will actually get a crystal award if we uh get through the national okay perfect I I I thank you for all the work you've done on this and I I again something else you read in the newspapers though FCPS has never had an outside audit this is not true not only
240do we have outside audits every year from a financial perspective the annual Financial reviews every year by outside agencies accountants but if I recall correctly and some of those have been on the board for a while I think in 2013 the state mandated an outside review done by a thirdparty entity and if my memory serves correctly they came up with $13 million in savings over an X number of years so um this Baldridge process is another look it'll be the second time in a decade give or take that we've done this um and and it's the right thing to do but it's the claim that well this has never been done before is is not accurate um and last question on slide 34 this is about the Master's number if I remember correctly yeah it's
241says after compensation increases we would go [Music] from I guess seventh and eight help me understand after this increase happens where this number would go up to I wasn't quite clear on that 97420 which I assume is 7% higher than what's listed here okay gotcha I I figured that was the case I wanted that that dollar amount thank you perfect all right um first up Dr Anderson thank you I I do want to kind of plug in uh and support what Mr Moon and then I think other board members reiterated because it's something that I've said myself since I've been on the board and if you recall even Mr frish and the terms that he used which has never left me is we have to show our homework no no no well you've been saying
242this for years ago but Bainbridge is new we have to show our homework and I will push even further for more than talking points it has to be a slide it has to be part of the budget presentation that everyone in our community who's going to pour into it will see that we are being as lean as we we are doing our work to be fiscally responsible um quick question Dr Reed our teacher trainees are they folks with bachelor's degrees or without degrees yet walk me through that a little bit because I didn't recall so Mr Solomon is not here we have several categories of teacher trainees versus provisional um I'm going to have to defer to Mr Smith who oversaw our human resources re most recently so our teacher traines do have bachelor's degrees
243uh it may not be in education and so they're working toward uh certification in particular areas but those trainees do have bachelor's degrees Okay the reason why I wanted to raise this is because we have teacher traines in our classrooms with bachelors and I know we are going to hone in on teachers with master's degrees but we also have to have the opportunity to sell all of the things Fairfax County has and we have to sell the fact that we are highest with the bachelors because we have plenty of people coming out of schools with a bachelor's degree I know I was one looking for a job right away before you take a year or two to get your master's degree we need to make that part of the presentation because when I look at
244page four we are number two just behind false Church city which is Tiny we have got to share that story a little bit boldly and a little bit more forcefully in addition another piece of data that is on page four and this is of the packet the fact sheets is the benefit that we are the the benefit that we provide uniquely compared to any other division in the wayby area our additional 8% from erfc I believe this is the slide here um Miss burden where it says teacher salary with Benefits comparison is is this what is inclusive of the 8% of erfc the additional the additional benefit package yes so if we were to put this out we are and I don't know what scale this is but we're number one and I get it
245it is not all salaries but we are missing an opportunity to advertise the recruitment absolutely uses erfc as much as they can um as as far as when they're talking to to new teachers but I I can tell you it is my understanding after having done this a million years that brand new teachers do not care about pensions they care about the salary and even being a couple of hundred dollars more is enough to get somebody to sign on now tenur it's really more of a retention thing because once you're in erfc and then once you get a little bit older I'm sure that's true of all of us you do start thinking about pension and realize that value of of erfc but brand new new 23 22 23 year old teachers that doesn't appear
246to be a a big motivator um and as far as the bachelor's go another reason that we concentrate on the Masters is because unlike back when when you were in school um these days all the Virginia universities was not too long ago all of all of the universities now offer a five-year Master's for um for teachers um so that they it's it's not like it was you know in the past where she's removing her foot you know where it's four years and then you know after you got a job then you went back to school for your Masters most of them will try to you know wrap that up as as part of their their undergrad experience and I can add after having attended many job fairs uh for those teachers who are veteran teachers
247who might be thinking about coming to Fairfax County Retirement is weighing heavily and and so we certainly have erfc at all of our uh recruitment events all of our job fairs and I have actually had to you know walk several folks over to the arfc table to talk about the value of erfc for those individuals who might be coming to us from Lowden or Prince William and have uh at least five years of teaching left and and very interested about that second retirement system I'll take go back I think that was my time so on the third on the second Gob Back Time permitting um and we'll cut that down to 2 minutes if we have time um Miss Dixit followed by Miss leing thank you so much I'm trying to stay awake also that
248budget session after lunch was not good idea [Laughter] so budget's always a fun thing to yeah oh definitely numbers sorry I'm losing my time now what is it okay I'm going to go straight to the point where can we save money right because all the money is getting tightened and we don't obviously want to save uh lose any instruction of our teachers or so where is the scope and I think the people who are doing the budget probably you you know know a little bit like where is a little bit of flexibility if you could if you look at the budget document in the back of the budget document it provides a listing of all of the reductions that the school system has taken every single year um to reduce the budget um it's an
249exhaustive list going back a decade I think um so sorry just point of clarification is the budget document that is being referred to the fact sheets or something altogether different I I presume it's the fact sheet that you're referring no it's the fiscal 26 superintendent's proposed budget which is online 100 page okay all right I got you thank you yeah so we keep going back and forth between the slideshow the fact sheet so thank you for that the fact sheet is just something that we provide to the board so they have some historical perspective um that it's just mostly for you all to be able to know the history of of the line items but you've got all the reductions by year listed there in in great detail you know you're not going to see
250a lot in recent years because as you recall we got uh full funding for I think five years in a row and so you're not going to see a lot in the recent years but historically um we have reduced the budget by quite a bit every single year but the timing to do that is not typically uh with the introduction of the superintendent's proposed budget as you know the code requires that the superintendent provide a budget based on the needs of the school system in the upcoming year and so we take that very seriously and the budget that we put together it provides the needs that we think is available but however the of course the local governing body is the you know appropriator and decides the level of funding and once they decide that
251if the funding is less than what we needed then we have to go back and reduce the budget and what you see in the appendix of the budget document reveals what we reduced in each year to align with the funding levels that were provided Miss Burton for the interest of I guess our community would would you be able to point out where this document is on the FCPS website just easy access to it uh you can just go to the website and put in the search bar budget documents and there's like four or five years right there and then there's another button if you wanted to look to years previous than that or you can go to board docs um there's a link there uh on the superintendent's presentation on January 23rd that will take
252you straight to the budget document okay thank you so much and I I will include that in my newsletter um for the community to consider um reviewing I also wanted to you know seeing our Mr Gotham seti in the audience I wanted to also maybe check with you or maybe you can U answer this as how could we use AI to improve uh some of the efficiency and productivity while assisting the staff which can lead to budget um Savings in any way is it Poss possible or not possible I think we talked about a little bit about using technology tools to get efficiencies in and that can be Universal Beyond AI itself our goal right now is to get um training for staff so they can understand how to use the tools we also have
253the tools available which is part of our Google infrastructure so there a combination of things coming available but changing your business process and how you use those tools on a regular basis takes a little bit of uh adjustment learning how to use the tools we also had some early conversations with Finance on using data and Reporting analytics tools so lots of opportunities um I don't know if I have a hard number to predict that these tools will lead to this much efficiency but that would certainly be something we're working towards thank you so much and I didn't mean you two have to stand like um so I I think that's a really good way to think in the moving forward is um how we can use um tools and uh AI tools to improve our
254efficiency and uh somehow it affects just like my colleague was saying that uh Universal uh design of learning or inclusive classroom can lead to like 35% 37% of savings we have to see elsewhere where we can use that those those things um last question is about Middle School enrollment I and saw the on the um data sheets which we got from the superintendent that they are and most of the regions have decreased number of uh middle school students um so what is the best way to I guess handle this in terms of allocating right resources to those schools and um maybe maybe there's a potential of moving sixth graders now to middle school as their enrollment is also in and down on the downfall that's for I think Dr Reed for you to consider I
255know we are considering that movement of sixth grade for program purposes primarily and culture purposes right because when you have just seventh and eighth grade half of your student body turns over every year um so I know Miss samansky we've been uh actively looking at that and that's one of the first scenarios we've asked to be uh provided in our boundary work okay uh would that help with some of our budget savings to Dr Reed um I don't know that we haven't done an analysis of that so I'm not entirely sure if it would help us with the budget to do that I think our hope would be it would be budget neutral minimally uh but I I don't know that I can we can take a look at that thank you thank you uh
256miss lady and then miss Miram thank you um slide 29 I just had a question about the based on some my other colleagues comments about the special Leed percentage going up when we identified twice exceptional kids are they in that data for sped so that's also probably a reason is we're we're identifying more 2E kids um then I have another question in the proposed budget pages on page six I'm just curious I was surprised I guess I missed it that the co-pays for Signa were going to go up um and I'm going to assume that's to absorb the fact that we're doing maternity and paternity leave this year and my question is are those projected to go up again next year the co-pays um well of course that was you know subject to agreement by
257the union just so you know that um but we we did have to increase the co-pays and deductibles of air healthcare plan we had not increased co-pays in a number of years but the original rate that was conveyed to us uh by siga um for healthcare was 20.5 uh percent as you know we're self-insured which basically just means premiums pay for claims um our claim experience is is up and the calculation that Signa did for us uh in the October time frame which is typical was that we needed to have a 20.5% increase in healthc care and we bought that down to 15.5% by increasing co-pays and deductibles thank you um so I just have a question when it comes to the budget questions I was just curious because this seemed like a uh I
258don't know didn't didn't compute in my own brain um there was page four of the budget questions there was a question asked by by Miss Anderson related to the cost of steam classrooms in every single Elementary School and if I my notes are correct I believe that it was estimated at $29.4 million um then put that up against another one of her questions which was related to the cost of fles and in order to get fles in every school or no the current cost of fles in the 55 elementary schools is only is only 4.3 million so right now I think there are 49 schools that have some form of steam or CS already established so to get that in 150 more schools why does it cost 39 uh 29.4 million it just seems like
259a weird number compared to what fles is costing us because it's mostly staff I would have to research that I don't I don't have the budget questions um research with me um so we'd have to research that and get back with you okay because I asked that question because I think it's becoming more and more essential that we have steam in our elementary schools um just because of you know as does Dr Reed has emphasized many times that you math you know uh not having high level math prohibits 85% I guess of career path so we we just we need to have that steam experience plus it's also demonstrating to kids how you utilize the things that you're learning miss miss lady Matthew knows the answer to your question that I didn't know yeah so
260with specifically with respect to fles there's actually interplay between how we staff a school for the fles program and how we provide their triple T staffing so the art music and PE at the elementary level and so the reason that you're going to see a lower cost for expanding that is because as part of expanding fles we would actually reduce the amount of art music and PE teachers that an elementary school has whereas when you start to look at the other question there's not an offsetting reduction that we can make in order to provide that like specials time why why would we reduce the number of Art and PE teachers in music is because we had fles that's why so the the way that the current existing Staffing formulas work is that an element school
261that has a fles program receives fewer art music and PE teachers because the students only have so much time in the day to be in those various classrooms right so the specials that you're providing if you have a fles teacher to provide that half hour that's a half hour or less that those students can be somewhere else in the building art music and be all right I'm dumbfounded because the Arts are essential to the development of our youth as well um and maybe that's why certain middle schools can't maintain or sustain certain music programs because you're not teaching it in elementary um and then impacts that high school's enrollment but I I do want to I do want to specify though that this there's still time in the day for students to have art music
262and PE it's just that it's it's it's a less amount of time if they are electing to be part of a fles program as well then why wouldn't steam be absorbed in the same way so we don't ex have an existing Staffing formula for steam so we wouldn't just naturally assume that we would uh level that back out for the schools as part of the Staffing formulas so it's more about the fact that we we have a a tiered system between art music PE and fles right now that we don't we don't even have a model for the steam portion so we wouldn't naturally assume that we would automatically reduce it it it could be part of the conversation if we were to try to develop that but it's not a natural assumption that we
263would make because we don't have an existing model in place all right well and I see I don't know if if Noel or Dr Presidio wants to add anything on that they're looking at me like I'm hopefully I'm not I no I think I think Matthew captured it um one other thing to remember is you the specials time is when when um our classroom teachers have their planning time right so during that specials time we know that all schools have time for art music and PE based on our our standards some schools also have fles some schools have determined to do also do steam but we have never as a division had a steam program that has been formalized or staffed in any way the major the rest or the the remaining time for teacher
264planning is covered as you mentioned by um counselors by espit by all sorts of people so if we were to have the funding to add steam into this formula right then perhaps it would loosen up those people being on the master schedule but with no real additional dollars to do that at this time um you know that's probably not happening if that makes sense it makes sense I find it fascinating that we have 49 schools that have manage to do something so it can be done and I'd like it to be a budget priority in the future just because I think if we're being remiss if we don't have steam in our classrooms at elementary level um and the other comment is another budget question that Mr Dunn asked which is related to the cost
265of AAP at middle schools I love the answer that if we had an AAP Center in all our middle schools we would save money because of the transportation cost so let's make it so let's do it thank you and uh because of the back and forth conversation on the on the what we just had on this funding fles art U the superintendent's going to flesh this out a little bit more in a Friday letter response so thank you um Miss mirin followed by Miss Anderson yeah I think um you know World Language is something we talked about at some point and we had data about what it would take and how it's not really you know offered in many of our schools and um I feel like that's a whole another conversation and unfortunately it's
266not included in this budget but I also want to respond to some of the comments about hey miss lady these very like place-based things like we need a center we need a classroom I would say we should tread very lightly about demanding space for things because first of all we know that we're short on space but second of all there's so much flexibility we have 36 outdoor classrooms and guess what you can do stem outside you could do World Language outside you could do anything you want outside you can also do anything you want in other locations so I I'm not supporting you know creating spaces for programs the whole um one of the big impetus of the boundary work is to figure out how to more equitably have space I had someone ask me
267at a PTA meeting the other night what is Equitable access to programming mean I said well you know that wonderful Edison High School Career Tech program I don't have a single constituent for H 100 Mill that trucks down $495 to go to that location in Springfield that's a problem that's Equitable access so um I'd like to focus on the programs that we want to we want to put forth and I do just want to point out the medical changes are not due to us providing maternity paternity leave they're due to Big they're due to Pharma they're due to increases in Pharmacy benefits and I or benefit costs so that is in those fact sheets that I sent again I just you know I I'm trying to help figure out how do we have the same
268sheet of music here and talk about the same things that are a challenge on any of these topics that we we want to look at I mean I I look at the um the information the superintendent has provided today and I see we've doubled our legal costs now that's not a surprise given the litigiousness of this particular Governor Administration and other things however we need to analyze that we must and I wonder if the board would entertain a motion at the budget vote to have a follow on directing the audit committee to figure out what the board's process is going to be to do this regularly because it has not been done regularly and it's time we figure it out these are the things that I think you know what can only the 12 of
269us do okay the superintendent can do lots of programmatic things I think there's also things we could do in our own communities you know there's spelling bees going on if you're interested in advanced academic mics or literacy you know tout those go to them if you want to you know support robotics you know there's things that we can do individually but there's only a few number of things that we can do all together reviewing our legal costs asking for accountability on programs I'll say you know are we sure that everything in this proposed budget is actually being clearly measured for instance middle school after school program buses I totally support middle school after school programs however in one of the last goal reports from last year and I didn't get to pull it up there
270was really no description of what services were being provided to how many students is it the same 50 kids I mean that's great but like let's do the cost per dollar the same about um how many courses um just with dual enrollment it's mentioned in here well what's the goal for dual enrollment because again we're certainly not advertising it equitably it's a lot of connections here that again only the 12 of us can can do something about so I hope we can focus on that higher level stuff thanks thank you uh Miss Anderson followed by Mr Moon I want to um tread carefully about something and I'm probably not going to say this the best way but I've done a lot of research over the last two years I don't have kiddos within the special
271education World um but I have heard a lot from constituents that have moved here specifically for our services and so I don't I want us to be very careful as we continue to provide special education for much of the area um including from the federal Workforce that comes through with with the military that we are we are an area where folks coming into Fort belor we are identified as an efmp or location that can provide services at the highest level so I want us to be careful that as we're looking at these things that we're also tracking the number of kids that are moving in so that we just don't blame it on over diagnosing kids or overidentifying kids I want to be careful that we're not blaming special education Serv or families as we
272work towards figuring out how to increase the services that we already provide as we know from lots of conversations that we've had as a board we have work to do within special education to ensure inclusion ensure all the things that we're working towards and I particularly don't care whether or not it's a child that we identify here that needs services or whether or not it's someone that moves in as we had conversations previously they are our constituents now and I want us to make sure that we're doing the right thing um as we move forward but I do want to paint the accurate picture of what our division is providing as a as a benefit for many people around the northern Virginia that move here specifically for our special education opportunities for kids because we
273know that more time in these in these inclusive environments give kids better opportunities as they as they progress in life so I just want us to be sure that we're careful how we're talking about some of this so that we don't provide any blame because it can be really easy that as we're looking here we can look at just an increase in special education students as the fault of the reason that we're in the budget situation we are in and that's not true and so I just want us to be careful about how we're saying that thank you Mr Moon and then miss St John con thank you Mr mcer uh the salary comparison that chart really uh CAU my attention especially a I think someone asked about Prince William County with the midpoint for
274the Masters Lane being 6,32 versus ours 91,4 so when you say midpoint how do you define midpoint is that is that years of experience or is that no is the steps or okay how how you define okay it's a very simple calculation that we've used for a million years and other people do too and it is the top of the scale plus the bottom of the scale divided by two top of the scale and bottom of the scale and then div and that that kind of streamlines the fact that you know there's 35 steps at Prince William but only 25 for us and you know 30 at lden and 26 in Arlington that that it accounts for all that if you do Max and me and divide by so is that sort of like a
275average of top and bottom yeah that's the midpoint you are using because okay I don't know whether I would have defined it that way but that's your that's how you define thank you for sharing that because I was trying to find these numbers on scale and there isn't yeah prin County doesn't have 106,000 anywhere in the middle and and ours is 91,000 either so uh unless this is explained somewhere people will go to internet and Google it and then if they Google it they won't find these numbers so you know for example if you go to a Prince William County which has a 30 steps which has 30 Steps step number 16 which is more than half a point on the steps is 98,6 180 and we put 106,000 so people say wow you are
276misstating or misrepresenting to us so that has to be clearly stated somewhere same thing with our own pace scare if you use whether it's e experience or it's number of staffs in the right in the middle it's higher than 91,000 so that has to be explained somewhere yeah this is really the midpoint is really just a Fairfax thing that previous boards have been interested in um it's not something though that's included in the wayy guide in the wayy guide we include the average salary which is a completely different calculation it's total teacher payroll divided by number of teachers then there is a specific step and grade that is identified in the wayy guide as the middle um but none of those account for the fact that they're they're different scales with different numbers of steps
277which is why long ago this is how Fairfax does it and so it's really just for this group I mean I don't even think we refer to midpoint in the budget document anywhere um so it's really just a kind of a Fairfax again my point is to explain somewhere so that people going go and then come back to us and you're not stating the facts and secondly since you mentioned the way wayy guide uh way guide does not give us information on a central administrative cost anywhere anymore it used to long ago but they're not reporting that so uh my question to you is when you talked about we are spending I'm very proud We Are you know most efficient in terms of central Administration where did you get those data from those also came
278from the wayy guide um there is a there's a position list um that everyone adheres to as far as how we count positions um in every division that particip Ates in Wy because that's very important that we're all using the same methodology and so that data also came from the Wy guide because there's a management line item identified and then and then of course total number of staff and that's what was the basis for the chart that shows the 1.1 could I 10 seconds yeah I went to the wavy guide wavy guide doesn't say that wavy guide doesn't provide those information anymore it only provides scool based non based non scool based staff go ahead ahead yeah so we we calculated the percentages using the data on those pages of the way guy that have
279school based and not school based staff but you're correct that you're not going to see that 1.1% figure there but but that is the under the data that's underpinning that action so page 34 what have this conversation offline because I cannot get that number anywhere and also uh it our even our number 1.1% in one time was even lower than that y so we'll we'll show we'll show the homework it's a it's it's yeah it's there anyway uh Miss St John cunning followed by Mr moven so I don't know who direct this question to because I do want to follow up on the Steam and I understand Dr re is going to flush this out for us but for those schools that have a steam program right now in the elementary level they're on the
280rotation how do they work out that how do they work that out with the ratios in terms of the music art and um PE teachers do you know how that's done so what I would say is my impression is it's not done any way that's um consistent different schools figure it out are you taking for time for kids are you talking about Staffing just with Staffing because the the numbers that were given to us were not they used a different model for Flex versus having a steam program because there was no concrete ma way that we're doing steam so then I went for those programs that are doing Steam and I guess what I'm curious is if we were to use the same formula that we use for flax to save we had it in
281Steam if we could get those numbers I know you didn't want to assume that but if we could use like if we were able to do that because it's an extra class I'm I've I've worked in schools that have steam programs and they are in the rotation and I you know and and they love that it's in the rotation because it gives the teachers that extra time for planning so my understanding is that schools sometimes can carve out some of their Triple T staffing to pay for part of it some of them trade funds to fund the staff member and some of them might use Title One um Grant funds to pay for a steam teacher so that's where they get the actual people from and then they use that in their scheduling and yes
282the students as part of their specials time which is basically 60 minutes a day are slotted into that so I think what I'm hearing you saying is could we use the same methodology for fles and apply it to steam correct yes we can definitely we will work with Matthew to relook at that okay I don't know Matthew if you have anything to add no I I I would just say that in that in that fles model that's intertwined with triple t we do still you know hear from schools that it's not the totality of it's not sufficient to meet the needs that they want to meet right so I I don't think it's a silver bullet as I guess all Al say right but we're just but we're trying to figure out what adding that
283class which would be very valuable to each Elementary School would cost but you use different methodologies and and there's two different things with the cost is versus the ratios I mean I guess ideally it would be perfect if we could have flex and you know steam in all our schools I mean that would be the perfect scenario and then the teachers the kids could have the advantage of of all of that one F enrichment and the teachers could have their time but I just like I I don't feel that we're comparing Apples to Apples and I think that's what's difficult for me to wrap my head around yeah the only other thing I would add is you know the triple te time in some schools are divided up between three specials right the art music
284and PE and some it's divided among four specials and these are four very different certifications needed to think about the Triple T time that currently exists and and try and and make it into five certification five different people and it would would be challenging with the existing Staffing yeah yeah I I just want the same formula to be used for adding the steam versus adding flux okay great thank you uh Mr mine well miss St John cunning uh what a wonderful suggestion so you know I've just think about um looking back on the past year the number of times we've had conversations with Dr Reed where we've talked about about the importance of equity and making sure that we have Steam and and fles in every school um you know I think it's clearly time
285that we reform TTT um and uh you know to Miss Lady's point I think you know all of the above should be considered core not just extra you know music art PE language steam um and you know I I don't think that's up for much debate um but my main question is um have we ever considered blowing up or contemplated reforming TTT in any way and what would that look like so answer there there was a period in time where we were moving towards the idea that as we expanded fles we would get every school to that same Staffing formula that's the four specials um and that um I want to say it was around 200 13 2011 um and I were there yeah we've fallen off from that since then um I you know
286I couldn't Hazard a guess as to as to the reasons why I'm sure there's many um but um yeah there was a there was a point in time where it was discussed essentially along something just the budget question is is does that just and this goes back to the previous conversation does that just make it um prohibitively more expensive if we were to handle it separately as opposed to part part of TTT which then you know constricts the other programs yeah I mean certainly you would have a greater cost if you weren't looking at it that way but I'm sure you're asking a different question than that um what I would say is in the conversations that I've had and Noel and I have actually spoken about this numerous times over the years um we
287do run into a lot of implementation challenges with thinking about the amount of time that four different core teachers or five if you introduce um steam to the conversation um at some of our smaller elementary schools you would be talking about a lot of part-time folks and that's a challenge for the smaller schools um so so you just run into a variety of things that certainly none of them are barriers to doing the work but they do bring differing challenges to differing elementary schools got it yeah I mean I think uh you know my daughter has steam once every two weeks ideally we would be having it once every week week uh so I can't imagine that there would be an issue of having you know part-time steam teacher uh in an elementary school but
288uh I appreciate the response and I hope we do uh consider this further thanks great thank you and uh we'll do third we'll do a third round because you guys have gone your second but miss seore Heiser yeah thank you a couple points I want to make is I made this earlier with our um goal three presentation but I'm hearing bits and pieces of talking points and painting the picture that we talked about right the fiscal responsibility we're already demonstrating on slide seven and I think slide 14 where we're showing our our central office staff is 1.1% and significantly lower our class sizes into miss my colleague's point about you know what is going into that class size number is it actual kids in a fifth grade class and a teacher or is it kids
289in fifth grade class and teacher plus reading specialist plus this plus that right I think it'd be good to tease those two things out to get a real picture of how many children do we have in a classroom per adult in the classroom with them full-time I think that would be important to know right the 92.5% um the challenges to our federal government like we need to get school boards across the country or talk to nsba because it's not just a Virginia issue right the the amount of money we're going to lose on our food nutrition services is a national issue and there are students all over the country that count on the food and may be the only meal and what are we doing to talk to nsba and other National Schoolboard associations the
290um superintendent associations so first I think we need to put together locally our sort of funding story and our um fiscal responsibility story and our goal story and the things that we are doing that are both fiscally responsible and best educational practices and put that together and partner with some national on some of the challenges from the federal I do want to put something out there just to clarify um when you have twice exceptional students they don't add to special education students twice we're just starting to recognize now that twice exceptional students are both students who would have already qualified for special education students due to um an area of disability and also have an exceptionality so it's not like extra identification of twice exceptional students adds to the number of students with disabilities it's
291just that we're recognizing that there's also exceptionality that we need to Foster as well I did want to ask the 5% increase in students with disabilities is that students with IEPs or 504s or both just IEPs just IEP so there do we know if there's an increase in students with 504s as well uh it's not something that we track or use to inform the budget so I I I can't I don't know the answer I think that'd be good to find out if if we are also seeing an increase in I in again I don't want to for but I think it's just good to know from from a budget narrative like these are additional needs that we have that we talk about um but I agree with what my colleague said and appreciate it
292that you know we need to educate every student that walks in the door but when we look at you know the additional funding that we would get per pupil if we're funded with Arlington fall search Louden in Alexandria it's you know 150 million if jar was fully funded is $3,100 per student right we are I think being pretty efficient what we what we have but we've also done a lot to reduce what we've had in the in the era of increasing student needs and I'd like to see that some sort of Consolidated with the ways we are being Innovative with what we have with both the Baldridge study to be more fiscally responsible with the Ala by eighth grade the Inclusive Preschool I think we should put that together and say look at the amazing
293things we're doing what are the organization can be as Innovative and as streamlined and funded the way we are so thank you thank you and that ends uh round one of Gob back so we have time um we'll go to a final Gob back and I had first Dr Anderson yes very quickly you talked about average salaries where can we find that in these documents please pause my time that's just a data point that's in the wayy guide on the salary page that shows Bast um Bachelor step one master then average then Max and there's just three or four data points on that page in the wavy guide and it's included there thank you and in the vein of telling our story I'm going to go back to this I think we have to tell
294our story and the unique opportunities that exist with that additional 8% with erfc so on page 32 that slide we can do what we do with CIP you know with and without so there's got to be a place where we're saying there's an additional 8% that is available across all of the scales um and I don't think it's the 65,000 that's on page four it's 8% to wherever you are correct it it's 6.8 not oh 6.8 thank you I don't why can't thank you for for that whatever the number is it's a draw and we have to make sure it's present always it doesn't hurt us to have it in these budget documents it doesn't we don't have to only limit it to recruiting um I'm sorry um Dr Anderson it's 6.61% is the erfc
295rate okay 6.61 thank you whatever it is it's an additional thing that is good um on page 39 you also talked about a $1,000 bonus that is part of the budget conversations can you confirm that that will not require a local match or would it require a local match it does not require a local match but you yeah the amount of funding that they provide is for S soq positions only so it costs us 35 million if we give ,000 if we did do it like we did it back in 23 which was $1,000 to every um FTE employee and hourly contracted which is uh bus drivers Food Services and family Liaisons they're the hourly contracted and then we did like $250 if you worked less than 10 hours as an hourly employee and $500
296if you worked more than 10 hours uh and the cost of that's about $35 million so there there is a cost to us there's not a local match um and you know you could a decision could be made to not allocate to every single employee this bonus um but you can't really do it based on the S soq for example let's say that the soq and I'm I'm making this up just for to illustrate says that we're supposed to have one reading specialist at every school and we have you know so that means we need 200 but we have 220 well it's not like you're not going to give those 20 the, I mean you you know you can't you can't use the S soq to decide who is going to get the bonus you
297could eliminate some groups theoretically um but you can't do it like the general assembly has provided so then what would be the cost to us has that been costed out or is that a budget question that I need to put forward uh it's about 15 million to do it just like we did in 23 which is everybody gets a th000 no to supplement what is being provided so if they are providing it for the one reading specialist per school and we have five reading Specialists per School the cost for us to Inc incorporate the the other four the state is providing 20 million for the S soq it costs us about 35 to do it in the same way we did in 23 so Air cost would be 15 million okay thank thank you um
298I'll come back to that in another Point another um one of my questions is the preschool classes that you talked about I think there were 15 what will be the composition of those classes Dr Reed are you are those just to um capture students with special needs or is there an inclusive factor to those classes so actually we have several models and um I don't know if you want to hear a description of each of those models this afterno just want to know what that those 15 will be okay Dr presidia would you please elaborate on that absolutely so we're right now we have 55 inclusion preschool classrooms as Dr Reed mentioned there's three different models which we can talk about but the data here is representing the number of incoming preschool students with disabilities
299that have been identified for service once we start placing those students in schools if we place them in a school that new classroom that house students if you will if that's placed in a school that already has general education preschool then we can do an inclusion classroom if that's placed at a school that does not have a general education preschool in it for facility reasons like that's the only place we could put the classroom then it will be one of those self-contained special education preschool classrooms we're partnering with Janice really hard to try to make sure that we're citing these classrooms and schools that have general education preschool so that we can increase the number of inclusion classrooms at preschool but it's really facilities driven in terms of ultimately where they're going to be cited
300so those 15 class classes that are on the chart represent 120 kids because of the cap of eight or is it another number um roughly I think that's correct I'd look to Matthew who's costed it out can we put the that slide up I'm not sure which slide it was but I don't remember yeah so we we actually have um yep the one before yes we we have two separate preschool things that are happening in the budget we have the growth that is special education only focused which is what's documented here and those are those are preschool class-based and preschool autism classes that are shown here in these 15 I'm really referring to the 15 new yep the 15 new so those are those are preschool class based and preschool autism classes across the the
301division based on growth in that number of students separately from that there is a investment in the budget to expand Inclusive Preschool and those are 11 classrooms and those are the classrooms that you um would see either we we refer to as either um Early Childhood inclusion program or itinerant inclusion and so there's 11 of those that are that are actually Beyond this 15 that are not part of this cost so if you look in the multi year initiatives part of the presentation that was given last Thursday night or you look in the slides that are today's presentation I believe it's um believe it's like around slide 12 or 13 maybe 14 yeah so within that multi-year initiatives that's actually the expansion of Inclusive Preschool no I appreciate that but my question was the 15
302classes how many kids will we assume yeah so the the two different kinds of classes that are encompassed in that 15 are generally classes that would be eight students a piece or five students a piece and so it's going to be some number between some grouping of that yeah sorry 75 and 12 120 no that's perfect thank you um and the last thing that I do want to share is you know we've been talking about the a um centers since I've got on the since I've been on the board and the savings have been astronomical if this is a focus in the boundary work then let's make it a focus in the boundary rework and save that money and spend it elsewhere I I could not be in Greater support of that happening particularly in
303places where there is no AAP Center and that pyramid at all and those families have to leave their entire pyramid in order to get education which we say that they're requiring so I want to put that on the table and just like a final thing since I have 11 seconds are we saying for the schools that have fles because it's part of the master scheduling that those students have a redu ction and music and PE time cuz I was a little confused as well so what I would say is that we will we provide a fewer number of art music and PE teachers to a school that has a fles program than we would to a that same exact school with that same exact number of kids that doesn't have a FL program I think
304that naturally means that they will have less time but I just want to reiterate that we are still meeting the requirements of the regulation to provide a certain amount of art music and PE you know as as docum as documented in the Schoolboard regulation but but yes there would be a reduced amount of time so maybe I said of three pees per week you have two if two is what we have to meet yeah I think I believe the regulations specify a number of minutes per every two weeks and so what I would say is every school is meeting that minimum number of minutes per the regulation it's just that a school that has a fles program um is is then those students are getting fles whereas a school that doesn't may have those students
305in art music and PE more than that minimum in that regulation or they may have them doing steam or you know whatever else great thank you uh Miss mirin followed by Miss tixon oh I'm sorry uh Mr frish who has not had a go back yet and then we'll go back to miss mirin thank you um so when I was looking at this slide one of the things that I kept thinking to myself is you know I've been to a few of our um Inclusive Preschool preschool classrooms and they've mostly struggled to make them inclusive and so consistent with wanting to continue these Investments I'd like to hear from staff about the work that's being done with the consultant to address the inclusion model that will make this investment more worthwhile to the students it's
306intended to help thank you Mr fr I I would just say when I mentioned the 55 inclusion classrooms we've gone from one inclusion classroom three years ago to 55 right uh we've done that just within our existing staff working with uh our schools and providing you know central office directed professional development to do that um our inclusion Consultants just came on board contractually about eight weeks ago they were out here working with all of our principles last week and we're going to be working with a cohort of schools probably about 12 schools schs U and I'm going to get back to the preschool thing here in just a second uh K12 schools uh we're targeting Schools elementary and secondary schools middle or high in each region as part of an early adopter phase to really
307work with the Consultants they're going to provide professional development to all the schools we're going to provide coaching and support services to the schools to look at a number of different uh programmatic changes the first is supporting uh students with more access to the general education curriculum uh so that's more professional development and training for the general educ teachers about how to meet their needs we're going to be working systematically on our IEP processes and procedures to make sure that uh all students and families understand the opportunities for inclusion that are available to them um and hopefully be able to support more students moving into an inclusion setting and we're going to continue uh to support um schools through this process really over a three-year period of time so we're starting with the smaller cohort
308of schools next year we're going to do the remainder of the half of our schools then the following year we're going to do the remainder of the other half of our schools at the preschool level um our Consultants will be supporting the development of some additional professional uh development and uh that will support the inclusion efforts but largely we're really pretty much in year one if you've gone and visited a classroom where the staff has re basically received a minimal amount of training and support to do this work we're really early in the work uh but the Consultants are going to be with us for a threee period of time to try to help us in in that transition both prek through grade 12 and I assume as part of the goal reporting and El
309reporting we'll receive updates on the progress of the work with the consultant yes sir all right uh my last question for my GoBack relates to the increased cost of different types of students um certain things we don't track when we're looking at charts like that right um it cost us more to educate students who require Advanced academics to have a fulfilling educational experience in our system doesn't isn't that right yes sir and so if we were doing our job in helping these students excel at their best to be their best selves we might have a chart in the future that showed because of our success in bringing more students into advanced academics our educational system is more expensive even though our overall growth has been relatively flat yes sir that's true and so earlier today
310during our goal three report we talked about our success in getting more students into to algebra or higher in Middle School The Logical conclusion is that that will lead to more students taking advanced math in high school which will probably cost us more money yes sir all of this is to say that every time we do something to help enrich the experience of a student in our system so they get the most out of our system we are doing Equity work and so when we think about multilingual Learners and special education Learners and economically disadvantaged students those are the three populations that we talk about all the time but when a teacher differentiates inside the classroom they're doing Equity work yes sir that's true and it costs us more money to differentiate um from the
311materials we provide the instructors to the time the instructors spend with their students and so I just want to be mindful when we look at that chart with the same three populations to miss Anderson's Point some in the community will point at that and say well we know who to blame no to give every student an will shake at life and to give them the best opportunity we can as a school system whether they are on that group or in multiples of those groups they can be multilingual and advanced they can be twoe and special education they they can intersect on all kinds of fronts um I just want us to be mindful that um the differences that make our school system great are the things that drive the cost of our school system thank
312you and now miss mirin followed by Miss Dixon no problem yeah I just want to underscore to I mean we don't want to think about our kids doing you know now it's time for stem and now it's time for advanced academics Ian we've talked about this before that things need to be integrated and this even goes back to the previous board when we did the program audit and we were trying to say okay we have a global classroom Pro we have get to Green we have stem specials I mean stem really could be integrated through any subject area if it's done in a in that way and so you know it's been an inequity that some schools have a steam lab and a steam special special I mean part of this goes back to even
313having Outdoor Learning spaces I mean Cal elementary had a Outdoor Learning special at a time when schools didn't uniformally even have you know we weren't even talking about space for Outdoor Learning so I I just hope my colleagues that you'll not you know think about we got to bifurcate all this different learning when really the goal is to integrate it because like that's what we do in real life we don't be like okay now it's time to do math and then I'm going to set that aside now I'm going to do reading and science um I guess my question you know continues to be and the dialogue I'm seeking is with my colleagues which is where can we start looking for more money because um we are not going we shouldn't expect that more is
314coming our way unless we make it so some thoughts Capital facilities we could look for outright funding through the processes we have and the new ideas to expand funding and we have some of that in the wings um following up from the CIP motions co-sharing responsibilities I mean how can we work with the the County Board and the board of supervisor on shared things like energy goals and Community use and preschool um I just again these bifurcated siloed ways just you know how can we maximize each Fairfax County dollar and not look at look at it as the school dollar and the County government dollar it's a dollar that serves our residents so how do we look at the best way to provide the services and of course get the money with the state I
315mean we have a whole new session that's going to start up before we know it in the fall I don't have much appe to find distinct programs and things to Tinker with I think this is as good as it's going to get I'd love to have World Language I'd love to talk about a whole bunch of things but until we get more money none of that is going to happen so um it's not a mystery would help students succeed great staff we got to pay them so I hope we can do that work together thank you very well said um Miss Dixit followed by Miss St John cunning thank you um so we are having very interesting conversation some of this is really what what we do why we are here is to see how
316we can do the best for our students and provide the uh you know F have the fiscal responsibility as a as a board uh and I think this is uh what we trying to do is where we can save but at the same time not at the cost of uh any program which is good for us but I'm I'm going to ask a basic questions uh about cameras um I know there is a line item under uh the budget for adding some cameras is it for um any cameras inside the school uh if especially in elementary schools so is uh Mr Lambert's getting the microphone I think we're still establishing the Q if you will since we're a a qrich environment uh but we're still looking at the queue for which uh security uh cements
317we're going to be funding and also looking at the viability of some of these uh tools as we've read recently in U news and reports so Mr Lambert yeah thank you Dr Reed um to answer your question yes we would look for the outside cameras at at the schools first and then begin to work inside um we're generally covered on that at the high school and middle school levels there's always you know some room for improvements here or there but the goal would be to bring all of the elementary schools up to scale starting with the outside there's also going to be a a little bit of a Time limitation as the vendors who install this can only go at a at a certain speed so we'll definitely have to work with that as well
318thank you and where are we with our uh weapon uh detection system evolve and things like that I know we were doing a pilot on that sure unfortunately we ran into some roadblocks with some legal language with one of the vendors that we were looking at so we've paused on some of those discussions and re-engaged with a different vendor and hope to have some more information to you shortly um we have some real promise um and think that we can make a purchase in short order okay thank you um again coming back to stem and steam and um AAP um interesting uh topics there too I think a lot of students or families live in FCPS because of also AAP classes or AAP centers um this is something no other County around provides it's a
319r USP to so to speak um I wanted to ask what is is the cost of having a AP class in each school elementary school local level Elementary I should say um instead of doing the the centers is it something we can come up with the rough numbers anybody well I'll certainly be happy to work with Matthew and financial services on that but largely it's just the transportation cost because you're still educating the same number of students who require the same teachers at the same Staffing ratios that were using so it's really largely just going to be Transportation costs in terms of local level four versus AAP centers if go ahead Matthew yeah we do provide transportation um so my last question is of course I think staff wanted to give you some information on
320that yeah um what what I would say is that the the the local level four centers the the way that they staff those local level four classes is through their general education Staffing formulas so it's exactly correct that there's there's really no staff cost related to those um what I what I would add to that and maybe this is just something to to chew on or think about a little bit is that uh we do have a number of AAP centers which there is kind of a separate Staffing formula in our AAP centers um and as we've expanded local level four and gotten uh some of those a centers have dwindled in size a little bit there is an economies a scale that you lose when you start to get fewer and fewer students in
321your AAP centers and so that's just something to kind of chew on or think about as we kind of have this Cadre of various things across the division yeah I think the the Centers do um POS some challenges to some families who are you know either have transportation issue or not able to so obviously we we wanted to look at having a a sort of local Center at each school um but my last question and it is to our overachievers and I know some of us have those too that we do really good with our different classification Center but I think we uh of students but I think we still have a room of improvement when it comes to our student who are achieving all of the bars that they want to do get challenged
322more so um I can you know discuss this offline but I wanted to see we we do have those students and we want to take care of them too great thank you Miss St John cunning so I just wanted to make a couple of comments on this slide because uh my daughter was in preschool special education as a model student and I've spent a lot of time working with preschool education uh special education and in terms of the past couple of years the amount of preschoolers that have been identified as needing this these Services has increased exponentially to where our preschools that are supposed to be at a Max of 10 are far exceeding that so this is why we need this now there is a space issue and as as much as we want
323inclusion and I believe in inclusion if we don't have the similar preschool program there then how are we going to have you a a general Ed program how are we going to do that and I think that when we talk about all of these things we've got to think about what's really happening in our buildings these ideas sound wonderful but I've been in these buildings I've seen the preschools being exploding I've seen entire preschool teams special ed teachers quit not because they didn't love their job but because it was overwhelming and so we've got to look at all of this and say yes we want this but we go back to what our facilities are and what our facilities can handle with all of these programs with AAP with steam if we want steam in
324every in every school are we going to have the facilities for it if we want Flex in every school so I'm saying this to calibrate the public again in a perfect world we would have all of this in a perfect world we'd have the money for all of these programs we don't these decisions are difficult to make and it's not that we don't want them and it's not that we're not trying I just want to tell you that we are limited my first priority is to get these special education preschool special education programs in enough classrooms for all the kids that need it because right now there is the needs of a preschool child are are so much greater and so much more taxing on those teachers and so we need to make sure there's
325enough classrooms for them first I could go on and on but thank you okay uh Miss seiser like thank you so I'm glad you mentioned that because in response the data I read shows inclusion is cheaper and so if we're going to continue doing things how we've already been doing them yes everything that you mentioned is reality but if we look at program delivery and if we look at how we're doing things it's cheaper so it depends on is it business as usual which is why when we've talked about the Inclusive Preschool and we've talked about the models I've pushed back so hard because it's business as usual but the data and the research shows if we do it right it's cheaper so one thing I'd ask Dr Reed as we're opening these new 15
326classrooms right one I love to see the data on preschool teacher retention versus K12 teacher retention because anecdotally I hear what you're saying I'd like to see the data on it to see where we're at um but one of the reasons we're having difficulty in retention of special education students is because our program delivery models are out of date and don't provide the best ways to support the teachers so yes absolutely if we continue how we're doing it and we're just looking at space and it's like that problem solving versus Preferred Future visioning right but if we actually with these new 15 classrooms I think I see them as an opportunity if yes we absolutely have to provide those classrooms because these are for additional students for being identified right but can we use these
327as an opportunity to create start with a better model if we go to the old constraints the old constraints are based around the old program delivery right so I feel like we're looking at this new program delivery but putting all these old constraints into saying this is not going to work because we're looking at old program like we that's how you perpetuate old program delivery models by by putting the same constraints around them so what can we do now with 15 new classrooms that are like a blank slate it's beautiful what can we do so we're not putting the same 30-y old program delivery models and the 30-year-old constraints on a Model that is both fiscally responsible and educational best practices I put that to you well thank you Miss seore Heiser um I do
328know next week uh Dr Dr precidio and I and Miss pilson uh will be walking through preschool classrooms it's a focus for us next week with uh Nancy Pac and Jane pryan who are going to be uh here uh to work with us on our preschool inclusive delivery models and I think um you put it I think really well I think if we have 15 new classrooms one of the things we're going to be contemplating is where how and what those could look like and it looks like Dr precidio has something to add well I I apologize for that Dr Reed I just wanted to reiterate as I I said earlier our goal is to site these new classrooms just as you said in a school location where we can have an inclusion classroom so
329that we can open these programs under the desired new model that we're working towards so I agree with everything that you said that's we're working very hard with facilities to be able to do that with all due as that's not what I said what I said wasn't look at the constraints of the old model in in that we have to have a spe a general education preschool to cite it that's the old model I'm saying that is that is literally the constraint of the old model we can't do inclusion unless the preschool already exists in that building I know I'm past my time I will stop but we've got to stop thinking the old model constraints yes ma'am great thank you and miss lady yeah I just was thinking as I'm also reading things that
330are flowing in my email that this came to mind can we get some data on the um percentage of 504s we have and how that has increased over time uh and I bring that up because there is a cost Associated while there is nothing allocated because it's not an IEP um there is a cost and certainly a Time suck Associated um you know with that process so you know I just would like that data if we could look at it because I do think it impacts our budget like sort of indirectly specifically miss lady which data the 504 okay okay thank you um okay okay well we're going to wrap up a little early as a reminder our public hearing is tonight 6 o'cl and you know just really brief comments for me I think
331what I see when I look at these slides and hearing the conversation around the table is that we're doing everything we can to meet every student by name and need which is not only um the right thing to do I think that the data is also going to show us it's the fiscally smart thing to do um we're focusing every spare Penny we have into the classroom and the data shows that and we're doing everything we can to maintain the Baseline of of services that our County residents have come to expect so those three themes I think are going to be uh you know on my mind at least for the remainder of this budget season and um with that the meeting is adjourned I will see you in about two and a half hours
332right just for folks to I'm not running I'm not running the next one so Dr okay let's target quarter till how about that that's seven minutes just everybody just get their brains recalibrated back to goal three exactly it's like you need you need a transition period I know there were lot of questions that we did not get to ask regarding coursework or the math so um I'm waiting to see some placards of board members who did not get the opportunity to to ask or ran through their questions I know it's going to take a little bit of time to shift into this new conversation and I'm happy to begin if nobody is ready okay we're going to go to three minutes and then we're going to call it um one of the questions that I
333had it's kind of very low-level question I noticed there were changes between not just the adjusted Baseline and the new Baseline but there were adjustments to the targets cuz we had had an extended conversation last year regarding or's recommendation that they be 5 percentage points now they seem to be all over the place and some of them are few and I'm not worried about the ones that are more than five because I think I could rationalize why because we need to catch up a little bit more quickly but the ones that are fewer than um 5 percentage points that had been 5 percentage points in last years can you give some explanation as to why you've made that change sure Dr Anderson well as you said some of those are much more than 5 percentage
334points where we um had initially come to the board with some thoughts about a 5 percentage Point gain and when we actually took the student data un looked by student groups and overall in some cases we saw that the growth needed to be much more significant year-over-year um I think in this report you'll see in some cases we've got students who need to make gains much farther Beyond a 10 percentage Point gain and so what this is tended to reflect is this is what the rate of change needs to be each year for us to stay on track for our 2030 goals and if we exceed those targets it means we may get to those goals faster and if we're below those targets it means we've got to put additional efforts in for those student
335groups or overall data where we're not seeing that we're staying on track of that line I think I'm more concerned with the ones with the with the target goal of less than 5% sure I I what I would say is we're still making change as we get closer to those 90 or 100% those small changes are going to be harder and harder to make for us as a system and I will pull the examples for you because that's not the position of the ones that I'm questioning either because I do realize that you had to maintain but we had some for example that were in the low 80s and the 5% was going to bring them to the higher 80s and then those were changed to be a 2% percentage point target and I just
336wanted to understand but I'll give you the specifics in just a little bit sure I would love to get a better sense on you know particular coming out of budget it's and it's already been here I I I want to get a better sense of the impact of the Young Scholars Program um I understand from earlier Dr precidio said we have more students in a quantify that for me please so I don't have the raw numbers of students in front of me but the percentages that I talked about at the elementary level we now have over 90% of our young scholars who are in advanced academic classes at the middle school and high school level over 80% of our young scholar students taking Advanced cours workor so we could work to get you precise numbers
337on that if you wanted that I would very much like that and also I want to hone in on the practices that have gotten us there because to date it's been they're flagged is that the sole thing no um one of the things that uh we were able to do several fiscal Cycles ago was uh to take some staffing and create a young scholars position it's not the only thing that this person does but somebody who's responsible for going out and working with schools from central office going out and working with schools side by side to talk about best practices uh of supporting Young schol uh in accessing and and achieving success in advanced classes so that's one thing uh We've also continued to have opportunities for Extended Learning enrichment activities in schools for Young
338Scholars at the elementary level um after school we've run a young scholar summer school program uh over the last several years Esser funding helped with that a lot I don't know that we're going to be able to continue that post Esser uh but a number of factors like that have really helped us as well as the full-time aarts at the middle school level I am so sorry we need to pause momentarily for some reason the zoom meeting just stopped on us okay sorry Dr precidio people were so excited about young scholars we just crashed the whole system everybody was logging on to find out what Young Scholars were up to that's a thing could be at least you weren't telling me I'm ancient like Miss burden was well and I will never let her live
339it down oh when we're talk about coming out of school bachelor's degree you know that happened 900 years ago when I was we can resume thank you all right Dr pidio go for it so just brief ly to wrap up what I was saying there's you know a number of factors that I think are supporting young scholar success um additionally what I would mention is uh our Advanced academic resource teachers really receiving guidance and direction from our team central office team to do direct referrals for Young Scholars um so not having to rely on a parent referral or a particular cut score to get the student into the pool to be considered for access to AAP that's been really helpful um and then just the work I think at the middle school level and High
340School level really having somebody to advocate for those students when they're doing course selection and make sure that um they're connecting with the student connecting with the parents and encouraging them to enroll in advanced courses okay thank you um one of the things that I did want to highlight because I did share some disappointment with the reading data I I thought the math algebra data was really a highlight for three groups in particular I mult um even though the the start to where we are right now has been significant for our multilingual students students students with disabilities and Hispanic students and so I I just wanted to make sure that I raised that because the growth is present and and so I wanted to share that can you speak a little bit to um the
341level of data disaggregation that our schools have access to because when we're talking about the intersectionality and you're talk about intervention especially from somebody who was at a school you're trying to identify your bubble kids how much Insight does the School site have with the kids that may be impacting any and all of these areas well that's an excellent question I mean when I think about what school administrators and support staff and teachers have to do today they need a high level of data literacy to understand and interpret all the information that they have access to um so they do have the ability to disaggregate and look at student performance by subgroup by grade levels by classroom by teacher um there's just a number of different functionalities that they have and it really depends on
342the data set that you're talking about but largely any of our large data sets that are part of the Strategic plan measures they have the ability to disaggregate data by we're trying to support our staff with giving them better tools and resources so that they can get the information without having to you know create their own spreadsheets and everything else so for example the data dashboards that we've been doing we talked about the math dashboard a little bit in this presentation um the IT team has helped us develop a number of dashboards um most recently we worked with uh dit to develop an early warning system which is pre-populating a lot of information so taking students that uh might have uh attendance issues or behavioral referrals or performance on SOS or performance on some of
343the screening measures and being able to triangulate that data so that you can look at individual student performance on a number of different data points and then also group students different ways so we're trying to provide our schools with better tools because they are inundated with data uh and we need to really support them in using that data to make good de decisions thank you and lastly we have a lot of things that are outside of our control in terms of what I mentioned earlier you have teacher I mean classrooms where students have um they have a substitute for a long time or they may have a first year teacher versus the teacher that's been there 30 years are you seeing any significance in terms of um student performance when you control for those variables
344yeah that is one of the things that our goal Innovation team is looking at some of the differences in terms of performance that you're raising Dr Anderson okay I would love very much to see that and I'm trying to pick and choose here I think I'll stop here and yield back the 13 seconds to the group um Miss seism moiser thank you and um I just wanted to First say thank you Dr pidia for coming and talk to me afterwards about Inclusive Preschool and understanding that it's not just where the Head Start programs are but really facilities that has space for gened and special ed students that's a good first step so I just wanted to mention that I appreciate it um I wanted I think this came up earlier in our conversation but I
345know what we're looking at is those who earn a c minus or higher in algebra as a success metric and I think that's a good first start but I would just be curious to know for those who earn a c in algebra what is their success rate in subsequent math classes or passing the so because the goal was successful in algebra and to me successful means you learn enough of the concepts to be able to be successful As you move on towards math right because that so I would just be curious maybe for next year to know that if you have an answer there um one of the things I would say is in our work with AEL we're trying to look at some of the Middle School academic um performance uh specifically around math
346and World Language and how that feeds up to Advanced coursework at the high school so I think we'll have some future linkages opportunities to talk about that data great that's perfect I appreciate and I and I there are good there is good news here in the math numbers obvious there's still those gaps that we want to see so the next question and this goes I think to the earlier conversation about increasing steam consistently throughout elementary school but what efforts are we doing to encourage not just math access but math excitement in the elementary school area um and separately from the CT that we're trying to get CT completers like CT exploration in middle school I think to kind of get that interest and excitement and knowledge at an earlier age on that last part you're
347talking about Career and Technical education yes thank you so starting backwards we do have a career investigations course at the middle school now so that's one thing that we do the other thing is our academic and career plan which we really tightened up the expectations uh for that program uh this past school year and developed a new curriculum that is supposed to be deployed in all of our advisory uh learning seminar sessions uh grades 7 through 12 and every one of our schools and students complete a variety of different career exploration activities is part of that uh new curriculum that we're using um and then going backwards on your first set of questions um actually maybe rephrase exactly what you want me to address there um just if I since I'm just rephrasing just on
348um what are we doing at the elementary school maybe Middle School to en encourage my math excitement right like tying it to things that are real for students yeah so you know we are going through a new basil adoption and we're very hopeful that you know our new curriculum will have some of those opportunities to have you know computer science robotics different types of activities hopefully STEM related embedded in the curriculum I don't know if we'll find that or not U but we have in our curriculum this year um that we're using currently I should say over the last several years really tried to embed some of those core stem or computer science type topics into the curriculum starting actually as early as preschool so there are preschool classrooms that you can go to and
349you can see how students are sorting blocks and doing different things to to sequence and that builds its way up in the curriculum um K through 8 so we have embedded computer science topics computational thinking um into our current math curriculum we've also worked really hard with our Title One schools to get math Olympiad um and Dr Pon has done a lot of work on this with his team uh offered consistently in all of our Title One schools um as an extracurricular to build excitement so I mean those are some of the things that we've worked on I think it would be great to even look at Mason Partnerships there's so many tech companies in our area that want to bring enrichment to many of our schools and especially schools that may not have the
350the PTA infrastructure other infrastructures and I think this is a real opportunity to bring really fun competition type things into our schools and um and even using um sort of gamification of math and things that are sort of new so I'd just love to see more of and bringing more math type skills that are tied to like data analysis and things like that that you know that are more tied to things that go across um Industries yeah so I think I would love to see some of that I have a question it says on slide 51 provide personalized and long-term academic and crier counseling to all students how is that different than what we're doing now like what are you looking to do there that's different I'll better look at slide 51 and see what
351that says again so if you could pause my time please thanks what did we say on FL 51 not actually seeing that on slide 51 Under Universal strategies am I looking at the wrong slide deck no I I I think I I think I'm in the same place you know um We are continuing we're continuing to try and um have consistent application of our career in academic planning uh right now we have a tool called Naviance right um that we believe we could have more full use of and really Drive students to making some of those longer term goals and have more um um opportunities for insurance inventories and things like that and we've built a lot of those lessons into our advisory period starting at the middle school level I think that's great I
352think we've talked to some of my colleagues that mentioned you know more counselor training but also more support for our counselors and and so I do think that this is an area that we need to flush out more my experience in navian has been much more self-directed by students and again that that might increase those gaps with the students who might have family members at home that help them use Naviance and others who may not have family MERS as as present so maybe there's some room here also with the family engagement or the Family Support Center Family Resource Center sorry um and trainings on Naviance on how to help students but I I'm pretty sure there's a pretty G big gap there but I think this is something that could be really flushed out even
353at those Upper Elementary School grades I talk about for students with disabilities but I really think for everybody so then when they get to those High School course selection in eth grade they're really understanding the full picture of what they could be looking at um and I think there's some room to talk to families at an earlier age about how careers are changing and how math and technology is embedded across the spectrum of careers I think that's an important piece as well no those are great comments and suggestions the academic and career plan actually is elementary middle and high I was really focusing on what we were doing at middle and high but we do start some of that investigation um just in terms of you know what are your strengths what are your interests
354right really even in the primary grades so it is a elementary through High School sequence um thank you Miss Lady thank you academic career plans curious to know if we're investigating other products besides navian we we are um remember on all these technology tools I don't know that there's a perfect tool and when we sign a contract you know we've obligated funds so we have a expenditure period that we need to make sure that we're completing and being fiscally responsible on the contract but yes we're going to be looking at additional ter what's the current contract go through we're in year one of a 5-year extension so we just paid it again we are in the process of working with it to set up the RFP and we are um very close to actively looking
355for um so to just to clarify when we sign the extension that we can sign that every year for 5 years we haven't committed to five years we committed for another year well we continue to look for other options available on the marketplace so because the other thing I bring you know it's it's been my experience um that when I would invite my middle schools over to talk about acemic advising I wanted all of the counselors to come but they sometimes would only send the eighth grade because they're the ones talking to kids about ninth grade I'm like no you're doing an academic career plan in seventh grade don't you need to know what my curriculum is in the high school so the same CR I have had is that people need to learn our
356curriculum they need to learn about all our opportunities and I don't know where that's being taught like it it's not happening organically um and so there has to be some very specific training about cour taking patterns and how they map to specific outcome goals um and we have to be exposing to kids what those are another question I have is aptitude tests um I know that those are there's a fee that comes with those I know that one of the built-in ones and we've talked about this is the ASVAB I know the ASVAB will the number of students taking an ASVAB will help our accreditation because it's in the new accreditation have we had conversations with our military folks around increasing the number of times we offer that is there a capacity level for them
357around how many kids could take that because taking it gives a student a lot of feedback on their skill set not just their interest because you have to combine the two and I would love to see exponentially more of our students doing this and we engaging in those conversations yet yeah we can get you some more details on that because Jen Glazer's been leading that project but we are going to be expanding access to some of those aptitude tests like the ASVAB for example uh we worked with it to make sure that we could get everything through cyber security so that we could administer the tests on a larger scale so we're in a pretty good place on that we can get you some more details though thank you and hopefully we're going to expand
358it um and and also it what what else might be out there for an aptitude test for a high school kid um that they could self-direct perhaps do I don't know um I don't know if we have the capacity with our TJ students to create an aptitude test and not have to Outsource everything I mean we have some pretty skilled people and with AI I don't know if that's something that we could but anyways I I just think that the there's opportunity there but I think this is where our students fall short you know I I liked a lot of things I wasn't good at as a kid right so I had have eventually had to hone the reality of okay well that's great but you have a reading to ability so good luck being
359an attorney You could argue with people once you know your stuff but you're not going to get there because you're not going to do the reading right so we our kids are going to have to need that feedback and I think it's helpful thank you thank you Miss Dixit so I my question is actually on the same uh P you know discussion my colleagues are talking about uh career planning um Dr Dr SL you have mentioned a few times that there is a a process in middle school high school when when students go over that could you please tell me which school it's getting implemented should be being implemented at all of our middle schools and high schools in The Advisory block some schools will refer to that as learning seminar some have different names
360but every school is required to have built into their schedule a time period where students have the ability to work with one teacher on a comprehensive curriculum that includes executive functioning social emotional skill skill development um academic strategies and habits that we've taken from the Avid curriculum since we don't have Avid in every one of our schools we've taken some of their strategies often referred to some of you you know like the Wicker strategies note taking strategies study strategies and then academic and career planning so those are the three components of the curriculum that we wrote and developed for implementation in all of our schools grade 7 through 12 this year U but it is the first year that schools have used that curriculum so um you know if you have particular questions about your
361school I'd say talk to your students advisory teacher or talk to the counselor talk to the principal but we're working really hard on consistent implementation around that so for the academic and career plan it includes steps that are grade level appropriate um that sequence all the way through their senior year for students where they're investigating different career interests that they might have aptitudes that they might have um thinking about the academic courses that they might want to take to be aligned with uh some of their career interests well in high school and then as we get into college they start thinking more about post-secondary planning employment military obviously College um and how to prepare to be successful through the the next step process of leaving high school and matriculating into next steps thank you for
362the answer um what would the parents see basically in this process well that's a good question because again this gets back to Miss Lady's question about most of these tasks are housed electronically right so um most of the tasks that students are completing for the academic and career plan are going to be in Naviance so parents can log into Naviance through their parent view account and get access to everything that's in there but I understand how I'm getting looks around the table right now I understand that that's confusing uh for parents obviously because there's a lot that you have to know about how to log into the systems how to find the information how to access the information uh but right now it's housed electronically in that system uh thank you um and as I
363just you know as a parent who whose kids have been in system recently um I can tell you this navian was not the best tool to for any of those even College selections and seeing where your SAT scores is as per your it was not the best tool I think we were using and I thought maybe technology is not Advanced so maybe it's happening like this but we we know technology is Advanced and we seen our all it um our it is so Advanced now in FCPS so I think we are we need just find a better program um than than Nan uh so U my other questions was uh based on uh I'll just continue questioning about the a aage school um could you give me an example of Aid school which where you
364know which is which is imple implementing this program I believe is none of in my district well there's 15 middle schools 15 high schools schools uh and now 25 elementary schools Title One elementary schools that are implementing the program so we have quite a few of the programs obviously we have many more schools than that but we do have quite a few Avid programs um you know there are significant costs associated with Avid because there's the program cost that you pay to the company that produces all the materials there's the professional development cost and then there's the teacher cost um and and basically that is a classroom teacher that's supporting students teaching that curriculum and providing um some of the tutoring supports and strategies from Avid so it is relatively expensive which is why we've
365been really targeted um each budget year to try to think about you know where are the schools where the students have the most need for avot um and we've tended to place the well we have placed the Avid programs largely in schools that have a larger percentage of free and reduced lunch students okay all right that's good to know um there are a lot of parents who don't have access to technology so coming back to that navian and how to do this uh logging in if they say they don't do that is there a possibility to do those meetings with like how we have at elementary school I think we miss this this is and I've said this few time is that in mid Middle School and High School parents kind of don't in you
366know participate in the education of the their students like they are more on a um they can help with some sports or events and things like that but really don't don't know much going on in fact I my son went to IB School I'll give you an example I didn't know what IB School was until a friend told me about it and said hey we can apply to this IB School in Robinson and we live in cerville so we we don't have an IB School within our area so but School none of the school my son went to was talking about IB schools so as a parent I did not know about it until a fellow parent told me about it so I think the a general MTH I should say you know of people
367who are working or are busy who don't have so much time to go through FCPS website I think we need to bring parents in the conversation and bring them early and what what is your like what are your thoughts on this I think it's incredibly important I mean with the research is really clear about the role of family engagement in supporting Student Success I I think it is complicated I mean I have two students a senior and a freshman and obviously work in FCPS and there are things that are even confusing to me about what's happening in the school so so I I'm very empathetic to to the challenge um and we're obviously continuing to to strive to do better I think what I would say is one of the projects we're working on right
368now is trying to have a more comprehensive and consistent academic advising uh program if you will in all of our schools Miss Marin's been very uh supportive and advocating for the need to do that and has given us some good recommendations as well as other board members so we've developed kind of a plan uh an outline I guess if you will of a plan to try to standardize that academic advising process over the next two years we took some I think pretty important steps this year in terms of standardizing the information that schools need to have on their websites providing information to schools that they need to send out consistently uh but Dr Pon uh and I are going to be working along with Dr King um to try to standardize that work even more
369in the coming years so creating centralized Communications that schools would deliver that really touch on some of the big areas or big gaps that we've received feedback from community members on in terms of like areas that they'd like to know more about so we're working on it um be happy to share more information offline with any board members who want to um provide more suggestions or have more questions about how to do that but that's a work in progress right now I think I'm out of my time a little bit left okay so um yeah I think the parents without technology uh I think still we have that open questions would you like to say something to that well I think one thing I would say is the tools and resources that we're talking about
370are accessible via smartphone so if a parent has a smartphone um but doesn't have a computer they have access to the information we've been talking about the other thing is if students don't have access they have laptops obviously that they can take home but if they don't have Wi-Fi connectivity in the home Our IT department does have a process by which students can apply and get uh a wireless device so that the student and the family has that that computer access while at home um but unfortunately that does require a student or a family to request that at the school level because we don't have information about who has it and who doesn't have it at home but there are some additional supports that we can provide to families okay the navian I if if
371I it's hard to even navigate on the computer it's not easy going to be as easy on a smartphone that's just um that system is like that um but I think I'm done with my questions for now thanks um I do not see any other placards so this is the last call for those of you who have not and since okay well go ahead okay I was just waiting for other people to like you know chime in with the I just have two very quick questions um I want to know how many of our students have taken Algebra 1 in 7th grade do we have any data on that we do we have about 2,000 students who have taken Algebra 1 in 7eventh grade and then a much smaller number of students who've taken Algebra
3721 in sixth grade or fifth grade I think that's less than 50 students who've taken it at uh the elementary grade levels so these students who have taken Algebra 1 in 7eventh grade is it because they were advised by the school that they can now op opt for you know course or it was more of the parents advocacy so where we currently are theud students who are in seventh grade um Algebra 1 have typically been our students identified for level four services or or participate in advanced math at least in sixth grade and right now we have sort of criteria that they must have taken advanced math in sixth grade scored a certain level on the so and also taken Iowa as we move to um as we move through these next few years where
373we're changing curriculums and where Algebra 1 to e8th grade will be default those things will will change a bit but right now um it's one of the few places in FCPS where it's not open enrollment yeah understand that um there is open enr enrollment for algebra in 8th grade um so is if a student has not done uh advanced math they can still go for it and what if they fall short in understanding the concept they're enrolled are they pulled back or they're giving enforcements so there's a lot of things so in seventh grade students are typically in Mass 7 or mass 7 honors and then in eighth grade some choose to take pre-algebra um but many as you've seen choose to take either Algebra 1 or Algebra 1 honors if students are struggling if
374they're in an honors class they might step back to a standard level if they're struggling in a standard often there are um uh math intervention electives or they can receive help during intervention or after school um and if they choose um they could take a step back um midy year and move back into a pre-algebra class the other thing is um any class taken in middle school any High School Credit bearing class taken in high school parents do have the opportunity to choose to expunge the grade at the end of e8th grade and it disappears off the transcript and the student kind of gets a clean slate and can start over as a nth grader okay thank you so much for that answer um that concludes my questions Miss Anderson okay I wasn't going to
375bring it up but I do have a question how many of our non sixth through 8th grade schools actually have Algebra 1 at the elementary level we'll have to triple check on that I don't believe I I think those students would be accessing it at their neighborhood Middle School not at the elementary school again because or through online campus thank you Noel because we're talking about less than 50 kids so I'm not aware of any elementary school that is teaching a section of algebra but if we are actually going to get to the point where we have kids that are all the way through geometry and into higher level math at the end of 8th grade we're going to have to figure out how to provide higher level math until we can figure out how
376to get those sixth graders into Middle School we're going to have to figure out how to provide more consistently the opportunity to be able to take Algebra 1 in sixth grade correct because we definitely have students that can do it um it's just whether or not we actually have pursued those options for those students if you want the students to complete Algebra 2 before leaving middle school then they would need to start Algebra 1 in grade six right if it's still at an elementary school one of the main um concerns would be teacher certification right okay thank you thank you Miss isah Heiser thank you and Dr re I just wanted to mention just briefly to you as following from my previous conversations it seems like and this is my experience as a parent also
377that naian I understand contracts in this and that is one even someone who's very involved and and it was not easy to navigate and it was it's not really all that helpful as a tool I think for families who aren't as familiar with first generation college students it it's it's not all that useful I think we're talking about some really good things in earlier College and Career counseling and academic path counseling um I think we're talking about maybe some really more interesting ways in getting families engaged in the importance of math and technology and the prevalence in society that it is now and also having sort of technology and math be fun is there like some sort of like working group we can put together within instructional services and maybe there already is one I'm
378not aware of that just has the time and space to say all right how do we really blow all this up and start over again right like how do we really look at in not just fixing what we're doing but like creating new new ways of doing things you know from an early I mean I've talked a lot about transition programing for special ed students but I really think that that same theme is prevalent for all of our students especially as our populations are changing and the needs are changing is there a space to maybe say let's put a group aside to say when should we start what kind of college and C counseling should we be doing I think it's hard to do the work like fly the plane and invent it at the
379same time right or build at the same time it's a better analogy and my poor pilot co- colleague over here is probably laughing at me but um I'm just wondering what do you think of that idea is there space for that well um I of course there is space for that I think that you're not wrong I think sometimes we keep doubling down on remodeling software programs that maybe aren't meeting our needs and maybe starting from scratch makes more sense I don't know I do know Naviance is used in many places around the country and often generates a similar response to what's around the table but it is sort of the product that's out there I don't know but to your point yes we can put together a group to because I think it goes
380to miss Marin's concern also around calendaring and how we calendar both division work and how students and families plan and calendar their work over likely from seventh grade on quite honestly right because if you're not in certain courses uh particularly around mathematics again uh you get on a path and that Arc bends with that path and it's too late sometimes to by nth or 10th grade when you go when you discover your deep passion for mathematics and you haven't had that I mean it it happened with my daughter who was one point I mean who chose not to take for long stories and and some of her friends were in the same I mean she took algebra one I say 114 oh sorry my time was up um but I think when you don't know
381when you're on a certain path it can take you off other paths many years in advance I think that causes problems so I almost feel like we need a a think tank with different topics like an internal think tank with different topics to take the space to say if I could just start over I mean one thing that you know Dr P and I talked about with Inclusive Preschool ideally you would just reconfigure all of the preschool offerings to make it more open to inclus of preschool rather than trying to do what we're doing now which is fixing it right and so it feels like there's a space for like an internal think tank with topics that are given and maybe with community members I don't know to say here are some ideas maybe we
382bring in the families who experiencing this here are some ideas how to fix it we have some brilliantly amazingly talented people in Fairfax County maybe we adopt those ideas maybe we don't but we need some space to work through them because I think we get in this room together and we have great conversations and ideas being pinged about and I think there's some great ideas but what happens to all that who has the space to think down sit down with all those so I think uh Mr sethy uh often talks about tiger teams and we talked about that last year even a small group of people committed to a single topic who are able to move nimbly right so perhaps we can um Center a tiger team on this topic because uh there's obviously a
383high interest and we can improve what we're working on so I'll uh ask our instructional Services team to uh put together such a team I think there's a department already committed to that work so it's really just thinking about what could we do uh differently and ask that we come back with something within six weeks is at least an idea that I can forward in a Friday letter if I may make a request that's an inclusive tiger team because if we're looking at transition and planning we should look at it for all of our students and not Silo the work because I think right now we have Career and Technical Services and career there's just two different departments I would ask for that to be inclusive yes ma'am it'll be an it thank you thank
384you and just I'll take a quick turn before we close out because I think I'm the last one and just to add on to that I raised this to you um Noel not too long ago we had a student who accelerated in math and went she went to high school was then being paused in math because there was nothing else for her to take I'm not asking for you to investigate this in this room but to add to that conversation because we're all of the sudden we were pushing pushing and this child was able to handle it and was interested in it and then the parent is frustrated because now they're told you have to wait a year like well I want more math and we are saying no you cannot have more math that
385just seems counterintuitive but it is happening right now with a student at one of our local high schools and the last thing is we've a lot of the questions that I asked earlier um were kind of bounced to The Innovation team to said you know we're looking into this or we could look into this if we could have if rather if I could have a sense of what is this Innovation team and what is their purpose and what can we expect to have from them so we have several teams that we've identified key priorities based on our reports we've got for this one in particular one that's focusing in on reading by third grade a team that's looking at Algebra 1 by e8th grade and a team that is looking at um as a part
386of our able work which is tangential to some of the things that you all talking about today um each of these teams are representative of uh cross departmental teams we have a principal we have a department lead and we have a region lead who collectively work together with these teams and they go through a process using um the Harvard model our pelp coherence framework um where they are going out and doing some investigations into root causes as to why we're seeing the results we're seeing in some of this data getting closest to where we're seeing some of those challenges so whether or not that is doing empathy interviews with teachers with students with families and they're in that process of doing that investigation and coming back with a set of recommendations to inform our strategies
387for both long-term and Midterm strategies for next year thank you is that Innovation team working with the closing achievement Gap team I i' like to understand better that interplay or is that or the three of you that team uh I'll let Dr team it's a separate team but we definitely have members of all of our departments on each of the Innovation teams so there's members from Equity team that's a part of each of the Innovative teams as well okay so the form is the the work is informing each other you for that um and I think we are finished um the session is over we're we're joury thank