001e [Music] h e e e uh the time is 7:08 p.m. and this January 16 2025 comprehensive planning and development committee meeting of the Fairfax County School Board will now come to order uh Mr McDaniel has submitted a written request to participate in the meeting well first of all do we have uh C McDaniel on he's he's on uh Mr McDaniel has submitted a written request to participate in the meeting virtually due to a personal conflict and is attending from his residence in the Hunter Mill District all those in favor of approving Mr McDaniel's request unanimous uh so it is uh approved all right yeah can can you test your mic uh Mr McDaniel you unmute yourself just say hello can you uh can you hear us Kyle no okay great uh okay uh the
002minutes of the October 17th 2024 cpdc meeting are before the committee for approval um has everyone had a chance to review or do you need a minute okay uh do I have uh a motion to approve the minutes can you say I move to approve the minutes I approved to move the minutes approve the minutes second I have a second all those in favor right that's unanimous all all foreign attendants uh okay agenda item uh 1.03 uh updates from the chair uh I think uh we have all been in attendance except for Miss Herman at the recent work session where we've received uh productive updates from uh Miss samansky and uh and we also have all uh received and reflect on board docs uh are the following motion reports um the there are certain parts
003of the Fallen motions report that were redacted um specifically the part relating to potential reductions and leasing expenses but the public private Partnerships report um which includes the uh proposed guidelines developed by facilities in combination with office of division Council uh were posted to board docs for everyone to review um so with that um I'd like to turn to agenda item 1.04 uh updates from the facilities planning advisory Council Miss Herman so the main update did did you did you put in your mic hi everyone thank you again Katie Herman chair of uh fpac um just general updates obviously I hope to or I look forward to the next agenda item to discuss or an agenda item tonight to discuss the fpac charter but in addition to that um in December we encouraged fpac members
004to attend uh some Community engagement meetings regarding School boundaries so that was a successful Endeavor for most of our members and we just held our January meeting um on Tuesday evening where we received an update and briefing from um FCPS staff on some of the organization and Mission that they have as well as a discussion on some CIP items so we appreciated staff's time and efforts and updates and that is my brief update great so uh thank you for that uh with that uh let me turn to agenda item 1.06 uh the revisions to the facilities planning uh advisory Council Charter um I believe this is the first um revision to the Charter since fpac was established is that correct I think there was an update in 2015 but I was not a part of
005it pack at the time but I believe that's the date of our current version of our Charter so it has been since 2015 in which there has been any revisions to my knowledge uh and I'll I'll provide brief comments on kind of what I see is the major thrust of these revisions but then I'd like to come back to you Miss Herman to kind of provide larger context um I think in in looking at the charter uh at at a time when we are undertak a comprehensive School boundary review uh there was identified the necessity to update the charter because uh the charter in its current form uh refers to fpac uh convening Community meetings and in its current form fpac does not play any role in convening community meetings um that is instead a
006role undertaken by um other parts of FCPS uh but e fpac uh in its current Incarnation and I think as we desire it to continue to be uh provides a critical link between the community industry and FCPS uh and and providing critical expert in independent expert input to the uh school board and so we wanted to uh revise uh or fpac wanted to revise this Charter to emphasize the fact that fpac and this is emphasized in the uh criteria for appointment to fpac that they have special uh you know backgrounds uh credentials that are sought after in order to be appointed which distinguishes it from other uh advisory committees to the board um is really uh a set of Industry experts and you know uh not limited to the construction industry but also you know
007management or Architects or you know uh lawyers involved in real estate um so you know the speaking from a very broad brush uh people involved in construction renovation uh maintenance infrastructure you know from a variety of perspectives because it's a very multifaceted um field of experts that we have on fpac and we benefit from um but it it's not intended to be a a convening uh organ ization bringing together the public with FCPS because again whatever the original intent of uh F packet it's outset that's not uh functions that performs today and then we also wanted to um update the charter because there were extensive references to fpac essentially being primarily responsible for you know revising School boundaries and um while it it certainly has uh some some role to play or input to be
008provided um that's not its primary function um and as we saw in the work session on Tuesday there's you know a raft of challenges that we face um as a school system where our needs um vastly exceed our uh our resources and and so providing greater specificity on areas uh that F you know FCPS and fpac will be working on in the next few years was viewed as as desirable so those are from a very high level kind of the general uh you know objectives of trying to uh revise this um Charter um and Miss Herman if I can turn over you to provide more specific uh comments I actually think your summary was very well put and included all the main aspects that fpac members considered when we had our conversation um again just
009to mention you there we did try to condense some of the background information which can be found in section three we wanted to um break apart and kind of reorganize some of the um matters so to speak that would be included as fp's mission of activities and research so we took a stab at that and then again just say um in the last section or so to clean up a little bit more of um what the functionality and and products are for for fpac moving forward thank you and I I I just want to emphasize two things that I didn't mention before one is there was some historical background information that uh while educational is not necessary for inclusion and in a charter of this type so that was uh as Miss Herman said condensed
010and then uh finally uh historically fpac had operated uh on a schedule of providing a mid-year report and an endof year report in practice that midyear report was not being delivered I believe in recent years and the end ofe report um was of somewhat questionable utility because early in my uh tenure as cpdc chair I learned that you know before miss samansky this does not apply to Mr manky but before that the people who are in charge of facilities were not reading the year-end reports and so um even though it's an you know advisory committee to the school board um you know facil the head of facilities should be reviewing this important committee uh year- end report and so you know working with Miss Herman and and miss hosek the the deputy chair Vice chair
011of fpac we determined that a more productive um uh method of communication or or reporting to the uh School Board is on an ad hoc basis there'll still be a year-end report but uh we identified the need as as we are undertaking um uh a a real focus on addressing the the longterm infrastructure maintenance renovation construction issues facing our our school system we need something more than an annual report and so having memos delivered throughout the course of the year that are timely targeted uh and informative to the school board and to facilities um providing that critical link between industry and the school system so that uh we are not acting in isolation but instead being informed continuously by people who are connected not just as independent experts but through their own networks have access
012to a vast range of information and expertise um those memos serve a critical uh function that was previously missing and so that is also a function of these revisions um as and and will provide critical ongoing support to the school board as it considers different issues within the facilities domain did you have any further comments on that M Herman no the your point about transitioning away from one annual report that's delivered in May or June to a process where every couple months the hope and expectation is is that memos would be provided on a particular topic to the school board is um an accurate reflection of fpac attempt to be nimble on particular topics as well and more responsive to the school board's requests thank you well I I appreciate uh the opportunity to partner
013with you and Miss and and the uh committee members many of whom are new this year which is exciting uh reflecting a broad degree of expertise um are there questions from uh Miss Dixit or Dr Anderson or Mr McDaniel about the revisions that are proposed in this red line oh Mr McDaniel thank you um I'm gener fine with this everything looked you know looked good and I appreciate the explanation um just a couple of I guess technical questions um I think P went through a rather lengthy process a few months ago earlier last year to kind of update Advisory Board handbook was this update a result of that done in conjunction with that or did we did you know was that a part of that process where does in conjunction I was just kind of
014curious about the the impetus for the update uh uh if I I'll just offer one word and then I'll turn over to miss fman I believe it was um uh that was that was one impetus for it but it was also um when I became cpdc chair and and talking with Miss Herman and fpac members um it was clear from the early months that in recent years both with the head of facilities again not miss samansky but previous heads of facilities not reading fpac reports the members of fpac Express and Miss Herman can elaborate that uh fpac was not being utilized uh as it should be by the Schoolboard and there was a sense of Disconnect um between um fpac the school board and Facilities um and you know people questioning whether they should continue
015their involvement and at a time when we're facing all these uh facilities related challenges a desire to transform fpac to become uh more useful and and more engaged with the school board and at the same time the school board seeking more input from fbac so these changes respond more to that rather than to uh the PEC uh uh changes to that uh manual but I I'll I'll also ask for Miss Herman to respond yes sure and that's a great question and again I think member Dunn did a really nice job summarizing what the thought process has been over the past year or so we did um fpac has done some soul searching some conversations and um strategic thinking about the focus of fpac moving forward hence some of the other changes in the proposed Charter
016but again Additionally the hope is is changing the work product which is an important change here in this proposed Charter edit would allow fpac to work more quickly um to be more responsive to the school board we felt like we were honestly getting to a point where the Schoolboard only hearing from fpac in a written format once a year with actual substantive recommendations maybe was a little too long of a term to wait for feedback and recommendations from from this group so we wanted to try to change up the format so we could try to be a little bit more um quicker with our response and recommendations so that the school board could hopefully um be armed with the information they're requesting and and I'll just add um I I think fundamentally this is an
017organization fpac that is has incredible expertise connections resources available at their fingertips um but had not it had not been structured appropriately to provide maximum utility and benefits to the school board and I'll say also the relationship with um with facilities I in in my view my opinion only had deteriorated over time uh and uh and I think under Miss Samy's leadership uh previously the head of facilities did not always attend fpac meetings but Mr mansy made a personal commitment to attend every fpac meeting and I believe uh that has transformed the relationship between fpac and Facilities even though fpac is a Schoolboard advisory committee I believe that um it can act essentially as a source of continuous expertise uh to Mr mansky as well do you have any comments on that Mr mansky nope
018no comments that's correct in my view as well uh thank you for the question any other questions Mel just a couple of others real quick they they'll be rid they'll be yes or NOS for the most part um and I assume that fpac did you guys vote to approve these changes well so we have taken a couple meetings to go through some Redline discussions um points that we felt like would be available to be up for change um emailed versions went back and forth between fpac members and the folks who are working on the redline edits um in which you know member Dunn and others you know I I came to cpdc in October October and presented a previous draft as well so there's been quite a bit of opportunity since September for comment and
019feedback again in in fp's view this Charter is the school boards Charter for fpac so these are fpac recommendations for the school board to consider on this document if the school board decides to make changes to the document that is within your Authority and right in my in our opinion we are here for you and this is this is your document we did not take a final vote on this version at our meeting on Tuesday because again this could um have additional edits further down the line um through this process that we're undertaking this year um if a vote is needed by fpac to pass a a draft along we can do that at our February meeting um that's no problem but again these are just considerations for the school board this is you know
020this is fp's you know marching orders from the board so right no I I appreciate that what I what I want to make sure is that if you know we do move forward and the board approves it you know we're not going to have fpac members coming and saying well wait a minute we didn't vote on this so I want sure that you I don't I don't sure you guys with your fpac internal process um you've done what you need to do to get your members on board with these changes that's kind of what I'm asking whether that's a vote or consensus or whatever it may be M Herman do do you feel that this uh red line and clean version reflect a consensus of of fpac I mean I I do I will say
021that I only received written comments from one fpac member everyone else seemed to provide an an okay even either verbal during a meeting or by not submitting written comments I I have to assume that that this is moving forward but this was discussed at the most recent fpac meeting last week correct well yeah I mean versions have been sent out for sure right yes so um it and again we are free to have the ability to review and edit and members can can bring up topics as they feel we have member time during each of our meetings so those conversations were um possible okay uh and kind of a similar question have is staff are you okay with these changes have you reviewed them from the staff perspective we are good with these changes but
022again we'll defer to the school board sure um and a a comment there was there was a lot of redlining in the background section I don't it doesn't really matter to me I don't want to get this granular but I would kind of suggest the background section maybe just eliminated because it's history it's not necessary and just to kind of keep a clean document of how fpac operates um but again I I if if this is what fpac is kind of okay with then that's fine with me um and last question and this isn't specifically the charter but because membership is mentioned in the charter is it worth putting in there that members of fpac are subject to you know certain disclosures and making it pretty clear that they cannot accept I think they can't
023accept contracts or they can't be involved with the Contracting process is it kind of worth putting some verbiage in there to that effect and maybe that's a question for staff but that was one thing that did jump out to me I believe that when uh people submit their application to fpac and and and Kevin if you have input to provide I I know that before you get formally appointed you have to um sign certain documents that uh conflict of interest yeah you know I don't know how it's termed a statement or commitment and I think that's also part of the application process isn't that right right so as part of the application process um applicants sign a disclosure um it's also included in the policy um that the Schoolboard revised at fpac members are subject
024to certain um disclosure requirements as well as the conflict of interest provision so my only concern about putting it in the charter is if uh School Board evolves its conflict of interest rules uh and policy then it may create a mismatch at some point in time so having it where it is right now you know and what do you know what the Schoolboard policy is that governs the conflict of interest refback let me look it up real quick yeah maybe just putting something in there I mean I again I don't want to like Wordsmith things but that because if the public is looking up this Charter and they go to membership it might be beneficial to have a line that says members of fpac are subject to nonis to not to conflict of interest in
025the school board's conflict of interest policy and then insert the policy number which references back to the policy that would really be my only suggestion from a substantive perspective so again because I was writing it down sorry in the membership section something to the effect that all members of fpac are subject to the school board's conflict of interest policy and then insert that policy title and number just so it's really clear and it kind of calls attention to that fact okay um could could you make a motion to that effect or do you want me to I would move to amend the membership section of the draft to sort a a reference to the fact that all members of fpac are subject to the school board's uh conflict of interest policy um that's yeah I
026think that that's a sufficient motion and I'll leave staff to kind of Wordsmith that okay uh if if I can I make oh you still there okay can are you bringing it up well no I think it's just one sentence he he already stay what the words are I just so we can then make a motion to forward it to the school board for approval um I think you have to scroll up uh it's section five Roman numeral five right there so uh It should read all members of fpac are a subject to the school board conflict of interest policy com yeah the school boards and then just in you can insert the title and the the num the numerical reference whatever that is I don't have it in front of me um and that
027I think that will be F that's fine okay yeah so conflict of interest policy comma policy 17 so to clarify the school board has its own conflict of interest policy there's also a conflict of interest section in policy in 1710 do you want which whichever one applies to fpac members okay yeah whichever one or two both yeah yeah because and I think it's important in this one in particular because we are rightfully so we're engaging industry experts and you know when you engage industry experts with these conversations and you also have obviously a very healthy uh capital budget I think we we should kind of go a little bit of above and beyond just to call out the fact that you know there's there's nothing everything is above board there's nothing going on here can
028just just say policy 1710 and close parenthesis you don't have to cite the specific section you make interest is capitalized put a space between membership and in the title of section five uh okay uh Mr McDaniel uh can you can you repeat your motion and just propose the specific I'll I I'll read this in so I move to amend section five to add the sent s all members of fpac are subject to the school board's conflict of interest policy for Community Advisory board members policy 1710 is there a second okay uh all in favor uh sorry the second was uh uh dict it uh sure discussion Dr Anderson no okay any comments no okay all in favor are we doing just for this motion right I I still have question on the yeah just just
029just adding the sense okay it's unanimous okay uh further discussion Miss Dixit yes I have some questions about this too um so I wanted to ask about um how this uh this document came about like was it the entire fpac team discussing and then doing it a subcommittee uh between in some members of fpac so for this iteration of the edits yes we had um myself as chair and the vice chair we collaborated on some potential changes we also solicited early feedback from Member Dunn who again is um the school board liaison Schoolboard member Le on Two fpac And um an initial draft was put together with red lines that was emailed to all of the fpac members I don't remember when sometime in September October we talked about those changes during our fpac meeting
030I believe in October also November it was on the agenda um and then a couple iterations were emailed out to the entire fpac membership so we didn't have a subcommittee so to speak but all members were emailed the ver the draft versions along the way and you know could have could have responded in email with comments or brought it up at our meetings okay uh the reason I ask is because on on the page two it says the below matters are within the preview of fbac as determined by the school board and include and there eight uh items under that um did you get the direction from school board to add these as a list no uh the this list again is a draft of what fpac members believe could be our kind of mission
031for activities so if there are comments and um feedback on this list of eight items um we're more than happy to you know take that into consideration and re reroute a draft or um have a separate conversation about it um yeah the only reason I ask is uh number seven construction financing and procurement um how is fpac being advisory committee and um not part of uh any of the staff who reviews the construction plans um is it something you have like fpac has uh access to all the contracts and financing and procurement we do not have access to all of that there are certain components of school facility construction financing that we've looked at in the past um per request or direction from school board members or because of um a topic that touched on
032that that the school board had asked us to look into um you know an example would be the request we had last year to look at different types of Contracting mechanisms and provide our feedback via a memo which was included in our annual report last year so we don't have access to everything but we do um have research and Industry experience in which we draw on and um certainly bounce questions off of Staff when appropriate um but again if this is a topic that the school board um would like fpac to research or provide feedback on in the future including this item number seven allows fpac to essentially do that great um yeah that's that's good to know and that's what I was thinking about like um maybe it's like a more of a broader
033uh procurement process and that is uh uh the removal of CIP uh from the list is was done to keep it comprehensive like keep it like General cuz I know cips one of our main focus and and and be are any fiveyear plan so is that one of the things were like redlined on that um maybe you could just you know yeah yeah yeah so the reason why we struck out the specific term or phrase of capital Improvement plan is because um you know for one thing referring to another document that may EB and evolve and may not be become be called a CIP at some point in the future maybe called something else we want to be cognizant of that plus we think that items pretty much all of the items went through seven
034are included in some way shape or form in the CIP so we felt like from an activity standpoint you know we've never it's been years probably more than S years since we've actually been asked to look at something specifically related to the CIP a CIP a portion of that document moreas is it's been um a request to look at a component of the CIP that folds into um the Improvement plan that that FCPS has if I can also mention number five that's in the red line um references long-term planning prioritization and visioning of construction Renovations and Investments I think that's the as as you said m the broader category Beyond just the one document okay um I think my last question is about the membership um and length of terms uh in the prior version
035we had more spe specific uh information about their 13 members and one from each district is it uh removed for a reason or it was uh just to keep it concise uh number five is membership and length of terms I'm sorry I don't see that the the text you're the the only changes I see in in uh Article 5 is uh eliminating the reference to Chairman uh with chair and then uh replacing the reference to Department of facilities and transportation services staff with Office of the chief of facility services and capital programs those are only Redline changes I see the oh from the original I apologize me on that okay well and I will also add that fpac has a bylaws document that talks about the number of appointments we have um an initial term
036um how the appointments how long the the the length of each term term and how that that's determined by school board members and such so you know we have another more procedur document that which is our bylaws document but yeah I agree but it should still say that the member of uh you know committee members are there in just in general it does says it shall include chair of the comprehensive Planning Development Committee and scho uh and the and the staff um of school and they both are non-voting advisory members something like that but it doesn't say anything about all the people part of it would you like to make a motion to restore the first paragraph from the current version of the charter I I would just say we could just say the fbac
037uh should have uh C you know advisory members along if if you like you like um Dr Anderson was saying that we have it in the advisory committee handbook um the more detailed version uh okay well I I mean I I will uh I'd like to make a motion uh for the current approved version of the charter dated February 19th 2015 that we insert in section five the first paragraph of the current Charter which states the fpac shall consist of 13 members one from each of the nine Fairfax County magisterial districts three at large representatives and one representative from the city of Fairfax each shall be appointed for three-year terms using the process defined in the current version of policy 1710 uh do I have a second yes okay or is that a question a
038second I'm seconding but I also have questions on that go ahead yeah go ahead I'm done oh no I just want to have a question M uh Mr McDaniel do you have your hand up well yeah I had a question I didn't know if Dr Anderson was I don't think her mic was on I didn't know if she was talking or not no it wasn't no it wasn't sorry my apology so I um oh I did have a question on the table that they're looking for yeah oh okay so my turn Dr I was just hoping to get a sense of what policy 17 because we're making a reference to it or its most current version and it feels a little bit in the dark so I'd like to have that but I also want
039to have my general turn about some other questions that I had okay I had a specific question on the motion because I'm I'm I'm I'm a little I'm kind of little confused here so my understanding was the redline version was an exact copy of the February 15 of the version dated February 19 2015 and then that was redlined which that would be the definition of Redline version however if you go to the February 19th 15 version the membership section in that version versus this red line versus the Baseline on the red line is completely different so I'm it's not a red line version that's exactly the point this I I'm a little confus and I'm not assigning any I'm just that that's so now I'm kind of thinking well wait a minute if we've recreated
040the if this Redline version is a recreation of the February 19 2015 version do I now need to give this more scrutiny and read it line by line because what else is different Miss Herman can you address that I think it's just an editorial error on that's a pretty significant editorial error I I I that's pretty significant that's not like you know a capital letter or a comma that's that's pretty significant and I I I I'm I'm I'm not not comfortable with that I'll just be very honest and I just I it just it just jumped out on me because I kind of took it at face value that it was a red line um but that's a pretty significant difference and I'm not comfortable with that so can I I I want to allow
041Dr Anderson to ask your questions but that was that was all that that was all I'll just mention um perhaps Dr Anon can ask her questions and then we can uh table this uh for uh the next meeting of cpdc uh maybe fpac can take a vote on it in in between um and when it comes back it can be the original existing version of of the charter with a red line and I mean there's a lot that look Sim similar um or the same but it does look like there are pieces that are different and I'm not quite sure where out off but anyhow that can be figured out for the next meeting but Dr Anderson Yes actually you covered one of the points that I wanted to share um one section five I
042think and again this is a tiny thing I'm just going to go in order where we talked about chair man being changed to chair it just seems to be inconsistent because on the following page we've made references to both the chairman of the Fairfax County School Board and city of Fairfax School Board it may be that I don't have all the right terminology since I'm not an FCPS employee so I'll maybe just keeping everything as chair seems to make sense so that's one um the second point I wanted to make is I do think we need to just take this back and you just mentioned it to the group for vote even if it was cursory even if we agreed with everything here because it resolves a lot of issues um you know once people
043put their hand up or however it is that you vote it just really affirms their um position rather than assuming their positions we want it to be explicit and avoid any future thing down the line um question that I had regarding the reference section um give a little bit more detail if you have it because I know this was already the reference section was already there as to the utility of that section because I'm just kind of thinking back to the Charter or bylaws well maybe it's because this is not bylaws this is your Charter I may be answering my own question but I do want to hear your thoughts with the need for the reference references section it was a carryover from the 2015 version and I I think we just felt like it
044was worth keeping um just to make sure that it's clear What policies or other related documents on our procedures um still apply sure absolutely that makes sense um the other thing that I wanted to ask on the red line section this is on page one under background number one the need for increased public awareness does that show up anywhere else like that um sentiment of increasing public awareness because I was in terms of I mean that that is included as part of the historical reference as to part of the reason why um cpdc uh was you know created I believe with a connection to fpac there um so it just and then there are some references to um making sure that public input is is collected but we do that through you know our our
045website feedback through our public meetings the fact that fpac meetings are open to the public um that you know our email addresses are available for um sending comments from the public obviously we're not holding our own meetings on these topics aside from our fpac monthly meetings I I just wonder um because these advisory committees all of them are to advise the board but it's also an opportunity well not an opportunity its purpose also is to be essentially like Watchdog organization on the system because especially fpac where we have collected such expertise um it becomes even more important just like we do with some other committees um there's no one on acsd that wasn't dissatisfied with something that was happening in the system and they've come in to kind of be the eyes and ears of
046the community to inform the school board that there's more happening beyond what we can see and understand in our scope um so I find the need to really stress that there because it gives the public a place to to reach out to in addition to the school board um and just looking through this on I don't know what page number it is sorry but in section six um item number e it says you know this is in the context of fpac may be asked to fpac members may be asked to interact Comm and communicate with the school board and community in public venues such as work sessions community and focus group meetings sure but if we could somewhere in the mission which is essentially for me a mission SLP purpose includes some language on that
047I I think that would be very helpful um I I think there is some space to when you go back to the original document um and to make sure that the red line is full I think for us and our work before just you know placing this in front of the school board to vote that one we have the fpac members vote on this then it comes back to cpdc maybe um Mr dun that we pars out conversations for the four of us or the five of us no it's just m Dr pites that's the other member right it's just the four of us in Fairfax County on this committee right so it's it's it's the four of us it is with Caroline pitches that's why and Mr McDaniel on the so then the four
048of us could have some conversations with our colleagues in advance to bring their feedback into this discussion because we're not going to have a work session on this but we want to make sure people are comfortable and not having a space where we're returning this yet again but that's a future activity once we have what is going to be happening with fpac come back to us um and I think that's it for me right now I think that's an excellent suggestion Dr Anderson and perhaps um uh M Herman if if you can provide the red line against the original at your early convenience with the two changes that we discussed today that first paragraph from the original charter with the correct citation to whatever if it is 1710 and and you can Mr Jackson should
049be able to tell you so we haven't voted on that second motion yet oh no I'm just well we're not on the point where we're going to vote on this today because we have to table it does that make sense yeah but you would still have to withdraw the motion before moving on to I I withdraw my motion then may I say one more thing yes um and my haste to just get through my comments I do want to say thank you to miss Herman for all of your work and trying to get us streamlined I think we kind of missed that part of the conversation when we first started because we know it's not easy to get this work started knowing P knowing that you did not you were not working with a full
050compliment of FC of fpac members so so thank you for taking this and for your work uh yes I'd like to Echo that thank you Miss Herman um uh for that and with that uh we will send this back to fpac for uh revisions vote and if uh we can receive a a red line that addresses Miss dixit's comments and and Mr McDaniel's comments uh the two two of Miss Dixit and Mr McDaniel uh discussed uh to have that get a vote by fpac would be great um and if you don't mind circulating that by email and we can share that with our colleagues and have some discussions um and we can work that out maybe after the meeting uh Dr Anderson um okay I'd like to move on to the next agenda item um
0511.07 public private Partnerships report um which was post on board Docs um uh Miss samansky Could you um uh you know along with the staff response could you uh walk through the report and the staff response to so we have a better understanding of this uh important uh report thank you Mr dun and if it's all right with you I think it would be best to just start with an overall timeline of work done to date with staff because this work launched with FCPS staff back in February 20 24 as a part of the initial followon Motion in the CIP from fiscal year 2529 I believe the school board had directed staff to look at Cost efficiencies and part of that include public private Partnerships we then took Information Gain from Prince George's County Public
052Schools and their P3 program staff also interviewed developers with this experience as well as interviewing um construction management project management consulting firms with this experience the result was a report delivered to the board in April 2024 and it really spoke at that high level on what a P3 is um some of the considerations uh the County's use of p3s we walked through uh the Prince George's program sort of as that uh precedent model we shared how the solicitation was done and some of that beginning framework that they used and then we also kind of gave some highlights from their phase one package on how big it was the annual uh costs for them and the terms and from there also provided a few other research documents that we collected along the way as an appendix
053from there in April 2024 or I'm sorry in May 2024 the school board as part of a budget followon motion directed staff to conduct further investigation in the P3 work and include a cost benefit analysis so that was recently presented to the board and um I believe you all have a copy of that report given the cost benefit analysis piece it's quite technical so we actually decided to as staff build a framework uh for guiding a consultant to do the cost benefit analysis itself we wanted to make sure we had uh a team that had done this before and had that technical expertise however we did want to make sure that that was guided and aligned with FCPS um needs for the division so we started that by creating a a little bit of a
054framework and summary we took a look at what we think we could use as a model to do the cost benefit analysis and as you know we have a lot of initiatives going on at FCPS we have a new renovation queue uh other strategic initiatives but we wanted to give some kind of real data and real uh schools for the consultant to do the benefit analysis on so we decided to take the remaining schools in the current renovation queue we didn't do the first two because we figured design is loading in fy2 those will be well underway on our current program but we said Hey what if we skipped out a couple schools and then did the remainder from there and it just so happens that was about six schools and then we took the
055uh Silver Line Elementary again we wanted to do a model where it was maybe a new program and that's the one school in the CIP that had dedicated land that a consultant could benefit do the benefit analysis and have a little bit more data to do that work and it's kind of nice the result was uh a group of seven schools and with Prince George's County they had uh their first phase be six schools and their second be phase be eight schools so we figured this was a really good place to start as FCPS on a scope of work kind of in the middle of the precedent that we see uh in this area and it's all schools that we know to be true needing future work as it pertains to the current CIP so
056from there we gave that to our consultant they provided a benefit analysis they did two different ways of looking at the P3 package a design build Finance model uh that's where they would be the financer and and we would pay over a term and then they would in turn design and build the the school projects the other option they did was a design build finance and operations so that one is the same as the design build Finance but it also included additional work to be performed on those seven facilities over the course of 30 years now there's many ways you can slice and dice it we wanted to kind of go in that middle of the road I believe the initial followon motion said no reduction in staff should be considered in the benefit analysis
057so we kind of descoped a lot of that routine maintenance but we added in the typical infrastructure repairs that you would typically Al do under those 30 years after you build the building per manufacturers recommendations for things like HVAC Roofing electrical equipment so on and so forth uh the other big thing that we considered when doing this was swing space now it wasn't explicitly said in the followon motion but we really wanted that to be considered when doing this work well one it creates a lot more scope if you're doing a benefit analysis on just seven schools or seven schools and building seven swing sites along with them you know it could change the size of the package and two regardless of whether we pursue the work knowing more about those sites in our queue
058and what the potential could be for swing we thought beneficial so we did some of that and as a result for both the design build uh Finance framework and the design build Finance light operations they developed kind of three different options so one of the options looked more at your traditional uh phased occupied renovation which FCPS is historically done one of the options looks at those same seven schools but more of them are new construction and opportunities as part of that swing space analysis where they figured we could do an on-site swing where there was enough acreage reasonably to uh put a new school up while the existing school's in operation and then go back and Dem demolish the old building once the new one's up and running and then they did advise be from
059their Market sounding they wanted to look at a package that was a little bit smaller they saw a lot of benefit in those schools with the on-site swing they got a lot of great Market feedback that developers were very interested in and doing those types of projects so they said hey let's do a third option that kind of takes out some of the schools where that's not possible and just focus on four of those schools where we could do the on-site swing just to make it more advantageous to the marketplace so those are the three options and again we did them for a design build Finance model and a design build Finance SL operations model uh from there we submitted the report so u high H have access to that uh we did provide a
060staff response so again we thought there were definite strengths to the work the consultant did you know it was nice to get that market Insight they did a lot of Market sounding and research reached out to a lot of developers and folks that have done this they did take a look at our Ed specs and our sustainability goals and they made sure that was all incorporated into the bis of assumptions for their work you know things that we saw where we might want to continue the work further the two models that they provided they did different leasing terms so one was like a shorter term and one was a longer term we understand why they did that they wanted to provide us some variety but if you really want to Stack the two up when
061you're making that decision we might recommend doing if we're more interested in a longer term we might want to match the other model with that longer term as well um you know overall we thought between options one and two because they both looked at seven the seven same schools they both would result in seven schools that meet edpc so we would recommend having that said option two was more cost effective than option one so if again we were to narrow down some of that work we would recommend looking at option two over option one because it's less expensive and a greater portion of the funding is going directly into the cost of the building of doing work and less into doing on-site trailers uh we still think option three could be considered as well because
062it's a little bit different in scope it's that four schools and so you know we recommend if we were to pursue continuing to look at option two and option three option two completes a much larger scope of needed work but it's more expensive so understanding Financial availability will be important for moving that forward and then just some things that we felt that are specific to FCPS that the consultant as as a as a outside perspective we wanted to bring the light just what we know about FCPS to say a P3 could be beneficial for just the financial need so we know all about that big red circle and the current backlog that we have so we know that the funding is often like the biggest thing preventing us from doing more work so just having
063this type of program that gives us a little bit more financial flexibility could be a potential benefit uh for our work while we would still be able to use the referendum money that we receive as part of bond sales to keep our typical Capital Improvement programming and this could supplement it um you know we see a lot of uh benefit to that not just for our renovation cycle but I think as I mentioned in that Tuesday work session that a lot of the maintenance backlog and jet go work it's all tied together so because of our major backlog need this could also be a potentially a good solution whether we go the design build Finance or the design build light operations because it's all it's all tied together and again with that that's a pretty
064high level overview but I'm available to answer any questions and as we get deeper into the work I'm happy to bring staff at Future meetings or maybe the consultant just if there's specific questions just um let me know where the board word is is falling on this and I'm happy to bring them to the table Mr D before we get started may I ask a quick question because I want to get a sense of what is our goal for this discussion this evening as per these documents if you could set the stage a little bit that would be helpful that's actually what I was going to do so uh great mind think Alik um so thank you so much Miss samansky um I I would like to um solicit the um feedback from uh cpdc
065members uh about where we should go based on this document um I want to be sensitive to um bandwidth of staff so we'll definitely uh be seeking input from Miss samansky um as she said we have a lot of um strategic initiatives big changes going on School boundaries and so forth um but I believe uh what the work session Illustrated uh in a very holistic way is that uh the needs of our system far exceed our resources and uh this report is um excellent uh and the staff uh response um the way I read it it sounds enthusiastic is that a fair characterization sure we think it's worth definitely more exploring given the unique position that FCPS is in okay thank you I appreciate the clarification um and so to build on Miss saman's comments
066uh the question is um uh how how do we go about exploring this I think um in the work session miss Marin stated correctly that um this this is something that will require multiple work sessions and so the initial framing question I would like to propose to my colleagues is um uh I would like to uh get consensus not immediately but after we have some discussion about you know which you know if if we are to make a request coming out of CP cpdc to the chair and and vice chair of the school board for a work session or two or three work sessions what are the topics that we would um request for each work session and um and so that is if you could please have that in mind as as we're engaging
067in questions um I might uh propose uh one approach could be uh I think swing spaces based on this report is is a and and what's a what's on board docs is actually uh a shorter version than the full Fen motions report that was provided by facilities to the board so if you haven't reviewed the entire uh document please do so um but the swing spaces discussion I found highly Illuminating and the swing spaces has relevance not just to public private Partnerships but how we do construction and renovation generally with different options being you know trailer Farms on site number one number two building a brand new building adjacent to the existing in building and then at the end of Once the new building is completed demoing the existing building um and number three having
068an off-site location where you uh you know basically tell move move a stun population to that temporary site for couple years while construction is ongoing there are complexities to all of these questions and I'm sure Mr McDaniel is highly attuned to some of these in terms of um you know how many uh people on site right so there's a permitting issue that would have to be worked out with the county right density of development but that density of development issue would be shortterm in nature nature temporary and I think could likely be worked out uh in a collaborative environment um and and likely we wouldn't have to be the first ones to run that Gauntlet we could look at how has that been addressed in other jurisdictions Nationwide um so one work session I believe
069should focus on swing spaces because right now a major cause of higher construction costs and longer construction time frames is the phased construction approach we use where students remain in the building while we're renovating it it increases cost increases time frames uh we need to address that and move away from phased construction um in my belief a second work session and I I'm not proposing these in a particular order but just conceptually a second work session I believe should focus on public private Partnerships and I don't think it will be all resolved in one work session but I believe uh there needs to be greater education provided to the board about public private Partnerships and a presentation on the different options that were examined in the study and the staff response to it um for
070me the the most noteworthy piece of information in this report is table one which is um on page uh 3 three of the report and table one shows that uh for the seven schools that were considered um you know with six elementary schools and one Middle School um package two um the the uh design and construction costs are virtually the same with our existing approach which is design bid build um and the and the public private partnership a difference of 6399 million versus 64.9 million so a difference of only $1 million and you know around $640 million total cost and the swings the swing costs is lower with the public private partnership 60.1 million compared to 71.6 million with our existing approach that we're using right now for all of our construction projects now there
071are additional costs such as financing but um and and and how you do a public private partnership is it just financing is it light operational is it maintenance and then over what duration um I believe that uh the staff response properly highlights that they prefer a 30-year time frame for paying off uh the private financing cost which is what most people use with their home mortgage as opposed to the four-year um time frame that was suggested in this report and I can say I have experience with public private Partnerships and I've never seen a 4-year payback period because it it negates most of the benefits of actually going to the private sector for financing so um so you know I believe this study is useful there are uh issues that would need to be addressed
072and those are highlight in the in the um staff response but having a work session at least an initial work session on public private Partnerships perhaps we could also build in some consideration of the guidelines that facilities and legal work together to prepare um and I believe is desired to have those uh uh appended to an existing Schoolboard policy 8240 um would be useful um and it will likely take multiple public private partnership work sessions over a significant amount of time to get the board comfortable to authorize this to be done but at least it would provide direction for um for uh this you know facilities to understand the consensus of the school board as to next steps and and finally a third uh work session I I I think uh may be worth um
073exploring is uh looking at construction management at risk and uh design build as alternative uh construction management procurement uh approaches because uh facilities has provided to um to uh Dr Reed and has Dr Reed now provided to the chair of governance committee I'll have to check with Dr Reed on where she is and working with governance but staff have provided a redlined policy 8240 that now allows for construction manager risk and design build construction methods thank you um so those are two new approaches that um have that are common in the construction industry correct Mr manky yes especially for K12 work in this DMB area Okay so those are common for this area but uh uh ftps continues to rely on what I understand to be an outdated approach to construction management and procurement which
074is called design bid build not to be conf confused with design build um so uh you know those are that red line policy 8240 uh will be considered by governance and and um but without having a work session on these approaches I'm not sure that we will gain the confidence of our Schoolboard colleagues uh to to adopt these new methodologies which should in my understanding reduce costs reduce construction time frames and build a more unified approach rather than sequential approach to to construction but again I want to open the floor that was a long answer to your question Dr Anderson but I I do have and oh I may a fourth work session it may not be an entire work session is uh least office space I Believe Miss Dixit and others during the work
075session on Tuesday talked about are there opportunities to uh convert off commercial office space uh to New School sites and um while the report only really focused on reducing existing leasing expenses for existing least space there are commercial office opportunities that may be worth exploring and and getting further research so those are four work sessions that could be held and they don't all have to be held at once but and and sequencing I think is open to discussion but those are my thoughts and so I'll open the floor to to questions uh who'd like to go first oh oh sorry that's so formal Dr Anderson the best why she brought up um thank you so much for this first of all I do want to say there is a lot here I I've never highlighted
076and tabed and put notes as much as I have with these reports and I'm very excited by them I think there's a lot of opportunity the reason why I asked what is our purpose here this evening is because I didn't want to get into things that this is not the right Forum to get into which is potentially most of my questions um one of the things that I want to be mindful of you know having sat in the seat of the chair is the time I know this is an important thing it is a very vital thing I just think given that we are already in our work mode um it would be potentially very challenging to carve out four separate work sessions um I do feel however that we do need to chunk this
077work because this is a lot not only do we want to build understanding with the school board we also want to build build understanding with the community but and we have to make sure that we are well versed in this so that we can go out into the community and have those conversations because there will be a lot of questions um if we proceed on this route because this is new and people want to feel as if one we're getting the best possible bang for our buck and that we're being fiscally responsible and so I do think we need to take the approach of um really going deep into building understanding rather than just having a cursory review of this information across the board um I don't have any issue with the components that you
078have that you've outlined but I'm wondering in terms of timing if we could include oops outside of maybe an overall um introduction at our typical work sessions that we have here but I wonder if we could consider the same approach that we have considered for um the Strategic plan updates um where we have conversation at the public meetings where more of the public is actually watching where we could chunk these small pieces and have uh I don't know whatever how whatever you want to call it you know some update some status some opportunity to learn small chunks at a time in a manageable way that it gives us enough time in between to be reflective to be thoughtful and most importantly to gather the questions from the community because we are Representatives I'm not here
079just to talk about ricard's thoughts I'm here to talk about the thoughts of all of the Mason District and there's not a single person who I can think of in my community that's going to read these heavy documents and be able to without thoughtful um engagement and walking us through all of this information to be able to give me feedback on what they feel you know I we need to consider as a board so I I definitely would like to um put forward uh a request for chunking the work and with time in between for us to be able to engage with community and come back with thoughtful questions that they may have because we don't come up with all of this on our own um some of us have more expertise in some areas
080than others you know the two of you are who I considered to be the the procurement experts I I said this before you know in a meeting and I've learned quite a bit from what you have asked on those matters um and but I also will want to go back and ask other people what does this make sense um because I can't trust my own thinking on this because it's so outside of my willhouse but I do want to engage of the you know in this work in a thoughtful way um and I also want to be mindful of the timetable that's even outlined on this even if we were to move on this tomorrow we are years away and I want to be mindful to not overly extend that period but to take advantage
081of what we do have available uh I think we're a little bit in a Groove and I've said this before and this is not your responsibility um that the Strategic updates that we get at the board meetings they're not as relevant as they were a year or Soo this or do they have to be at every meeting or every other meeting I can't I can't call the Cadence U recall the Cadence at this point uh but maybe once a month or once every two months we come with a small chunk of this for the foreseeable you know next few months because I do know that time is tight on the calendar of work sessions and again I'm not against having at work sessions if we could get it great my only worry about that it's
082not as visible to people who come into our meetings um on Thursdays so I'll stop there for right now uh Miss Dixon Mr McDaniel uh I I don't know if Cena raise her hand first but if if she wants to go I can go whomever you can go first that's all right okay thank you I I mean what Dr Anderson said pretty much sums up my my thought it's a lot I printed off all the pages and it's it's a very heavy B that's starting to hurt my back I'm carrying it around so much um of all this stuff and I'm slowly making my way through it um I'm a pretty big and Dr an just kind of alluded to this I'm a pretty big fan of let's grab the low hanging fruit that we
083can get now and the rest of this we can kind of start working our way through um and of the topics that were thrown out there are two that I would suggest we should move quickly on or at least as quick as possible on um and that was the design build component I've talked to my fpac appointe about this I think it's smart it makes sense uh in my understanding there's there's already some draft language out there for us to pass a updated policy to at least let us look into it so I I'm fine with design build I don't need to have I don't need to have a work session on it but it may be a good idea if it's going to come to a board vote to at least put that on
084and and have that conversation but I'm fine a big I'm a big proponent of design build um the second one that I think we should just we should have a discussion about and perhaps at a work session with design build is the utilization of office space to relieve some pressure um you know we've been talking about Western High School for a long time um is there opportunity to kind of take advantage of these vacant buildings that are sitting in the Dallas Corridor whether it's for a uh you know a high school a traditional high school or a magnet school that could then be used to take capacity put it into the magnet school and relieve pressure um through other parts of the County so I think that's a really important thing that you know you
085can execute an office leases pretty quick building a building takes a long time a decade I think and staff can correct me if I'm wrong but generally a decade to build a high school so um I would recommend doing a work session on design build and office space combine that into one getting board approval and buy in and moving forward um P3 I have some questions on P3 um but that's for a later conversation and and you know Dr Anderson kind of alluded to it even if we approve P3 tomorrow reasonably I'm thinking you know 7 to 10 years before we would see a potential benefit and that's really an eternity um if if for no other reason than the economy just going to be changing uh constantly uh swing space I have some concerns
086on swing space and Mr are done you kind of alluded to them I don't know how willing the county is going to be to play ball with respect to adding more uh floor area ratio to an existing site and allowing us to temporarily use that in a perfect world this isn't an issue but um the Fairfax way might make this an issue so I think the P3 and the swing space conversations my suggestion would be maybe put those onto a back burner but go full steam ahead on design build an office space that's how I would kind of uh structure this conversation M tix so yeah this is a lot to take in um and uh one of my question is that this is excellent time for our fback uh committee to dive into it
087I feel like they are the experts in the from the industry and if we can get the recommendation to the board um and it could be I think they'll understand it more than all of us uh like uh so I think we should just that's what the expertise I guess matter for us is now um if fback and look at and give us some advice and uh I know we got it from the staff already um so the second thing I want to say is this uh the competition on this or procurement method is it going to be the similar way we are doing a procurement right now for construction project or is it going to change are you referring to the construction manager at risk and design build methods yes it will be different
088currently uh in a traditional design bid build method you do an RFP to hire an architect so you set up a technical panel and you select the the one most qualified and then you negotiate the price they then design the drawings they get them very to a very complete Manner and then we uh issue that to the marketplace for a concealed bid and then the vendor that comes in the lowest is selected and that's how we get our Builder on on board construction manager at risk and design build are more of a best model where you would hire the Builder also as an RFP so in a construction manager at risk you're still doing the architect separate you hire them at the beginning and then ideally during early design you issue an RFP for a
089construction manager a builder and you can review the proposals you can base it on the qual qualifications they have in their resume of their staff so you're not stuck with the lowest spitter you're actually selecting them based on a certain set of criteria in that panel from then they advise on the design they provide constructibility reviews they can help with the phasing Etc and as part of the RFP we will issue a guaranteed maximum price so we'll say hey this renovation needs to be um a no more than $40 million or whatever it might be and so at a certain point the drawings will be at a at a more developed stage and we will we will dictate this maybe they're at the permit level and then the construction manager will go out to the
090marketplace they'll start getting their pricing from their subcontractors and at that point we negotiate and finalize the guaranteed maximum price so you try to stick under that that um number that you issue in your RFP although again if you during the design process you want to add more scope so it usually ends up falling somewhere there and then they'll the architect may continue to design so again it's not it's not always has to be a complete set it's more about the scope of work that they need to guarantee a cap on and then yeah you move into construction and and go from there design build follows a similar best value model except the architect is directly underneath the Builder so that you're hiring just one team so you'll hire the Builder and as a subc
091consultant they'll have the architect so you're kind of um you might consider the architect they choose as part of the selection criteria you you'll look at their qualifications as well and so that means they're from day one on board and then they have control over that architect to ensure that guaranteed maximum price is met so again similar in that you get to select your vendor based on qualifications similar that you do a guaranteed maximum price for that best value model so um Jenise why are we not doing that right now well I think the first thing is right now now Schoolboard policy doesn't allow for that right now Schoolboard policy 8240 only allows for low bid construction so right now I have we have no choice and so our first step is getting that redlined
092copy uh in front of the board to adopt it I think that there could be a lot of benefit that because you don't have to necessarily pick and go forward and and only do design build or construction manager at risk it just gives you the option to right um because I I personally think there's a there's a right procurement meth per project depends on how many inherent risks how complex it is if it's a really straightforward project you might want to do low bid right um but having for this more um nuanced construction the more complex especially with the phase occupied just having someone on board earlier that builds buildings to advise on that I think is very beneficial in addition to the cost component and that's how federal government does it right it's not
093the lowest bidder um because what happens with the lowest bidder is they come in they go with get in and now they have the project and they just keep asking for more funding and then 40 million becomes $80 million uh and they have no choice like basically you have to get the project finished so um I thought we were School Board takes the policy from the Virginia um you know so we are kind of dependent on that and Virginia state has the low bid uh procurement policy so I think it has to change in at the state level before we can change it that's my understanding yeah it it's a good point and I'm going to hopefully stay within my wheelhouse the vppa has low bid as the preferred method they do carve out Provisions
094for these other types of methods such as construction manager risk and design build but they stipulate that the local governing body will have to adopt and allow for that to happen uh so part of that in in 8240 revisions you'll see that uh in order for me to issue an RFP I'm going to have to come to the school board and the school board will have to approve and deem it uh permissible to use that method I believe that's that's required for uh per vppa oh good to know that I I thought there was no option but thank you for uh so I do I'm also uh going again the you know just like Mr Don um the federal government the operation maintenance also comes in to player we like to uh we're seeing the
095increasing cost of maintaining these buildings and if we can you know contract is out uh I'm sure we'll see savings and that's that's good in some of these uh analysis that it says uh design Bill Finance uh operate maintain operation maintain is that the part of the P3 uh private part is on page 36 of the report I believe it's pages 37 and 38 that look specifically at the design build finance and then that light operations and yeah 36 only tells a little bit about their uh definition that's that's correct uh tables tables are on 37 uh yeah right T on 35 and 36 those two tables are for just the design build Finance only okay on pages 37 and 38 that explores further the design build find fin with light operations and maintenance um
096this is through P P3 or is it directly with dbf omom does it both of these are P3 types one just adds on that operations and maintenance component the other one does not we just wanted to provide some options I mean I would love to go down this path at some point uh I know today it's not possible tomorrow is not possible but I think as a board we need to do look into to this um because we are not going to get funding as we can continue to see the money is getting tied um and we do have to get creative and um this is a good option um um and other thing lastly I would I wanted to ask about uh I think I think I covered my question but um I just
097want to understand that the the how fast can we build these uh buildings if we are we go with the construction uh management process I do think you get a running start when you do this so not to get too in the weeds but one of the benefits of doing a guaranteed maximum price is at some point you got to negotiate the whole contract and Shake Hands on the 40 million but what we could do is do what we would call maybe an early start agreement and maybe say hey I'm going to award let's negotiate the first 5 million let's negotiate some foundation work so we can get started on just this while we're still figuring out the rest of the design and once the design is more developed you can shake hands on the
098remaining 35 to get you to that full 40 but it does open up the possibility of getting a vendor out there early to perform early work and you can kind of get ahead of schedule while you're waiting on the designs to be fully developed again I do think it's more specific to the design so you got to have a situation where you can do that I also want to caveat we got to make sure we can get um separated permits with the count so there'll be some things that we need to work out to do that but you can't do that with design bid build you have to wait for the drawings to all be done and issued out to the marketplace yeah I understand and I'm a big believer of this uh ceiling pricing
099uh firm fix price basically you know you can't come back and ask me for more money you just got to do the project in this funding so if we move towards that I think overall we'll see saving even though if we don't change anything else but just move to this procurement approach I agree there there's always opportunities for change orders for things that are completely unexpected so I do want to C I understand I do understand I I've done those requests to government myself and as a contractor yeah yeah but you're right because drawings are never 100% perfect just you know guaranteeing that the Ed specs will be completed for that say $40 million or whatever we decide does kind of give you more of that insurance for things like that okay thank you so
100much um I I'll just speak a little bit um and I appreciate the all the comments of my colleagues um uh I I think based on Mr McDaniel uh Mr McDaniel's comments and and Miss dixit's comments and Dr anon's comments um I'd like to suggest that we could consolidate the four possible work sessions down to two um with perhaps the the most urgent one the one that cpdc could recommend to the chair to occur first to be one focused on uh the two new construction management approaches uh design build and construction management at risk combined with opportunities for commercial office space facilities being converted to schools um and uh a second work session to focus on uh public private Partnerships um I I I appreciate uh Mr McD's comment that it might be seven to
10110 years in the future but I I do want to just share um from conversations at fpac and presentations we've received um for my personal conversations with members of the school board in Prince George's County to understand how long it took for them to implement this approach uh it was two to three years uh not not 7 to 10 and um this this uh public private Partnerships are very well established around the world um UK Australia Canada do them all the time Fairfax County does them all the time is Mr McDaniel knows for Fairfax County Government Center and many other things um and we can build on the work of others without having to you know build you know we we should uh borrow B deal best practices from other jurisdictions and we already have
102a head start because although it's not posted on board docs included with the fen motions report was a legal framework developed by the office of division council with facilities to serve as a uh to to put together a framework by which the school board would actually consider and approve uh proposals from outside vendors for public private Partnerships and that's consistent with Virginia uh legislation so and and given the um very dire Outlook fiscally we have compared to the the need needs uh the maintenance backlog infrastructure backlog and the continuing uh increases in the time frame for construction renovation I I I don't think P3 can wait 7 to 10 years I think it's something we should start exploring now so we can have that option doesn't mean we have to do them but at least
103have that option that tool in our toolbox uh to consider um so with that um Dr Anderson you you asked for a go back yes I didn't speak about this explicitly because I was more speaking about the logistics um but I do want to say I think it's really important for us to explore the P3 options because what um PG County was able to do we cannot do that here and we are not going to have anybody hand us 14 million 14 billion dollars in order to modernize all of our buildings and to get the ones that are needed um we have been talking about Office Buildings for a number of years I remember back in 22 um supervisor walkinshaw talked about how there were so many Office Buildings that were vacant in Fairfax County
104I said well you have a lot of off Office Buildings we need space for schools where's the conversation to marry th those two and so I think that's a really uh a relevant conversation to have no matter what the the structure of the pending School may be um because we've seen what happened at Bailey's and from what I understand that was a very very fast um construction or renovation how whatever it is that's called um whenever we have this conversation I would love for that for information regarding the construction of Bailey's upper to be brought forward uh in terms of scope in terms of time in terms of cost and how that compares with your traditional um School building so that's one additionally I understand from um folks that were around that when glasow Middle
105School was built it was um it mirrored one the options that's in the documents because they built the School on the ground um and pretty much just across the way and then they demolished the old building and that became Fields so they were on premise when that occurred so we already have a president of that in Fairfax County and again I'm asking you to bring the information the cost the F all of the things that um accompany that kind of project um if you could bring that to the conversation because I think it will be quite informative because we've already had that occur um the third thing that I wanted to raise you know working in Len County for many years um and Len county has built many many schools in the past 15 20
106years the year that this school was opened which I had the opportunity to open three schools were open in one year it was the elementary school the middle school and the high school and they're building them fast and furious and one of the things that also I think saves some of the cost and again this is for you to explore and get some more information rather than my anecdotal um recollection um particularly with the elementary schools they were not all designed differently it was the same design they just changed a color scheme so right away you're saving a lot of money granted when you're starting from scratch it's a different conversation than when you're trying to offset you know how can we add to this building which has a lot of um drawbacks you know
107you have floors that are taller on one side and you have the weird you know step down inside of the building not being able to elevate you know ceilings of the cafeteria the way that we have it at for f Church High School um it prevents some of that when you can begin a new which is kind of my um support for doing it on site if at all possible I know some of the schools it is um because it allows you to perhaps use the same plan over and over again and you could save all of those design costs um so I wanted to share that um again oh and the last thing that I wanted to share that I didn't hear in the conversation of planning for what to look at FCPS also
108owns properties right now that we haven't really had an we haven't had an in-depth convers ation in terms of what their future can look like some of those properties are being used for administrative purposes and some not as much Graham Center Graham Road um the former Graham Road Elementary School comes to mind um we've T that building at nauseum it's really underutilized what can we do there and there are others like it that we haven't really elevated to a full board conversation so I think having that kind of data would be very helpful because we have to have a really strong sense of all of the assets and what we can um maximize with maybe a minor renovation or you know just tear down and start a new in order to realize where we are
109it needs to be comprehensive but it still needs to be chunked but those are the pieces that I really want to move to the Forefront of this discussion Mr McDaniel well Dr Anderson said the magic word uh and and Janice mik uh know what I'm talking about which is tear down um we we do have a site sitting out in Southwestern Fairfax County that uh when it was closed back in June of 2010 the board promised to look at options for and no board has looked at options for and it's something that I know myself and and Miss Anderson are pushing it's clion Elementary um you know we have security risk there going on and we're we're exploring options of what to do with that so if that could be packaged and as part of
110this broader conversation of what to do with these buildings and sites that have just kind of been allowed to go so to speak um I'd be very supportive of that um I I I also I I forgot to say two things um one is uh Miss Dixit brought up you know we might want to refer certain issues to fpac and I think that's an excellent idea uh and so we might want to discuss what issues we refer to fpac for for consideration um and second I just wanted to bring up uh what was mentioned by Dr Anders and that we can't do what uh PG County did what they did was build six schools in two years and uh PG County uh officials I've spoken with and I've come to fback said that would have
111taken them 12 years and what this report that's on board do shows is that uh for the same money we could build schools in half the time three years instead of six years and what they they say we can build uh second option of six elementary schools and one Middle School they could build they could renovate three and build three brand new elementary schools and one brand new middle school and still have it cost less in half the time which is extraordinary to to consider as a as a possibility for our County even though we have an excellent um facilities team that's that's not our current pace of operations and so accelerating um the pace of construction so it's not 42 years but coming down to closer to 2025 as required by Schoolboard policy would
112be uh excellent so um I would like to um at least initially um uh I'd like to be able to have cpdc make a request to the chair for two work sessions and so I'll propose a motion um and open to discussion uh I'd like to move that cpdc request that the school board chair and vice chair schedule a board work session on uh design build and construction management at risk combined with opportunities for commercial office space conversions and a second work session on actually can you bring up a so we can type this up so we can all be looking at it okay so uh I would like to move uh request that the Schoolboard chair and vice chair schedule a board work session on design build and construction management at risk methodologies along
113with opportunities for commercial office space conversion comma comma and a second board work and a second board work session on public private Partnerships do I have a second Miss Dixit uh discussion Mr Dixit I just wanted to see if we could add the um what uh Dr Anderson and U Mr McDaniel were talking about the the existing facility FCPS um and I don't know how what how you want to add that in our discussion perhaps that's should that be part of the first one a little bit uh should that be part of the commercial office space conversions yes there okay okay so can can before the comma and uh utilization of existing FCPS assets maybe maybe for uh utilization but uh optimizing uh discussion Mr diit I think we just remove utilization right if you're
114using optimizing well some of them some of them are being used as administrative centers um I maybe Clifton Elementary is not being used at all but some of them are being used but I think it's we're talking about could they be repurposed to something where we're getting better use out of it from a systemic perspective but I'm open to deleting it if if you prefer I mean because optimizing alone if you're saying optimizing assets it sounds like you're improving the assets but really what we're talking about is efficient utilization Kev okay yeah you can do that optimizing slash utilization okay and then yeah okay uh Mr McDaniel do you have any comments on on the motion no no I'm fine with that yeah that's fine okay uh Dr andon do you have any comments just
115want to be sure that we're not leaving any of the components that I thought I heard earlier out we're leaving swing spaces out and and so uh what what I would propose with swing spaces is either we could refer it to F pack for study um or we could make a separate separate motion I'll ask Mr Man we could also make a separate motion asking facilities to come back to consult with the county maybe to study what happened at Glasgow and then to come back with um some research or but Mr mansky go ahead would would you allow me to make make a suggestion on this because we've been thinking a lot about this internally I don't want to just we can maybe kill two birds with one stone in this uh instance where we
116have two projects that are coming online with design in fiscal year 25 per our current cash flow that's Cub Run Elementary School and Franklin our team did some Prem uh preliminary studies and we feel that the Cub Run site has the potential to do one of those onsite swings so right now we're developing that scope of work to do an RFP to hire an architect so they can can get started in design next year and so the thought that staff had was we could write in the scope of work where an architect typically at the end of their conceptual design might present three options and then we pick the one advantageous we might send it out to the design Review Committee or have a community meeting we could ask them to make sure one of
117the options shows us what it would look like to do an on-site swing and another option shows us what it looks like to do the traditional um phase occupied renovation so then we can see it and time because I do think swing space is very nuanced it's very sight specific like that it might be a great solution it might not be the right solution for Cub Run but for another school but you don't know until you really get to that analysis and we're already going to be doing it as part of the Cub Run renovation so that's just something we'd like to potentially float out there and once we get to those conceptual designs the architect as part of their due course and practice will highlight any like zoning risks and they're already going to
118be engaging with the county as part of the permitting process we just feel like why not take the process we already have and use this as a as a good opportunity but don't we already have some existing information if that's what occurred at glasow middle that's really encouraging like if it's been done before all the more reason in this CU run RFP to ask them specifically to look at it because we think it couldn't be a possibility here I I think we do need to embed the swing space conversation somewhere because it is is such a huge component to potential savings even though there's some other costs because of the expedited timetable um I would not want for that to be lost which is why I wanted to raise that I thought there were some
119pieces that we were still missing and do you see Janice that there's one of these two and again these are just this is just a recommendation but do you see that one of these two um work sessions makes more sense to embed the swing space conversation should that be with the P3 because I I I'm not I I'm not really seeing the need at this point to refer the swing space discussion back to fpac because there's quite a bit of data here regarding that and we just need to unpack it why we do this do it with the second work session because the first one is very full and to give Justice to that and because swing space is addressed as part of the P3 report uh maybe it makes more more sense there but
120I I I appreciate what Missy is saying but perhaps we could also do some historical research at what happened at Glasgow and see if there are any other examples in FCPS uh uh history and that could be brought to the work session to to talk about that that background sure uh I think maybe we can just continue the conversation to make sure we come prepared on top of the um analysis that we've done as part of this okay uh doc uh would uh if if uh we amended the language to say on public prate Partnerships and swing spaces that works okay um so can I amend my motion K because it hasn't been was it seconded it was seconded you seconded no miss di seconded I think we both uh all right yes uh so
121can I make uh all all in uh okay can you yeah and swing spaces um all right all in favor of the motion I and uh Mr McDaniel so it's unanimous um okay so that will be conveyed um in terms of fpac I I feel we should provide some direction to fbac on on what we would like them to to study and work on because uh U Miss Herman can you convey what memos you currently have on your agenda to prepare yes let me see if I can pull that up really quick um we definitely have one related to procurement um see here sorry oh man oh no sorry maybe while you're looking for that um can I move on to an an uh agenda item 1.08 and just ask for a quick update on
122the facilities condition assess ment update uh no change since the work session on Tuesday where we provided the overall timeline uh staff at facilities and uh office of procurement services are continuing to develop the scope in the RFP for solicitation do you have a sense of when that will go out the door I do not that's in procurement hands I'd like them to be able to provide an update is that Miss Burton who does that that's correct okay all right M Herman I found the the topics sorry for the delay uh one item is considerations for procurement policies so it was our our thought process was that is you know seeing what staff and the school board had thought based on all the work that's been done over the past 6 n months and to
123do some follow-up research on p through is CM um based on again the changes and also where things are headed with the policy 8240 so um that is a piece and if that um memo and the research and feedback needs to be more focused on on these things now that we're all seeing this report that's fine we also you know have two other topics um but this but we did kind of identify the procurement next steps based on feedback and discussion as something we could look at perhaps we could um uh refer the P3 report and the staff response to fpac for fpac to prepare its own response to the two documents would that be something that uh uh so can I make a motion to I I move that uh cpdc refer the p
124P3 report and the staff response to fpac for fpac to prepare an analysis and and recommendation or or uh response to the school board uh second um any discussion uh all in Mr McDaniel good um I I actually had a question so I'm following the motion um but I do after we vote can we go back to the facility condition assestment yes of course thanks so I I'm I that's fine I I just wanted to know if this uh fback recommendation could be in sync with our work session mhm okay that that's an excellent idea uh and okay so uh did you do you mind respons respons school board and if you could just add on at the end uh to uh to be delivered in advance of the relevant work sessions thank you uh
125okay uh all in favor I okay it's unanimous um uh second is Dr Anderson um okay um uh Mr McDaniel you had a question about the facilities condition assessment yeah so it's it's kind more of a comment um I I am going to request that the chair and vice chair because of the r the sensitivity of the responses to the RFI that we put out um I am going to request of the chair and the vice chair schedule a close session conversation so the B the full board um can ask questions about this and there there's really kind of two reasons for that one because of the sensitive nature of it um you know they're obviously confidential responses but number two we've never done this process before and it is to inform a new renovation
126queue hypothetically um I do think we need to give the full board the opportunity to kind of see what industry said in those responses and let the board ask questions about that um so the board has a full understanding of of what is contained in those responses I've read them U individually there's a lot of good information in there and the only vehicle that we have to bring that before the full board is a close session conversation so I am going to ask the chair and the vice chair to schedule that that was my only comment would would you like to make a motion in that regard um sure I would move that CPD request the board chair and vice chair schedule a Clos session conversation to discuss the res the responses to the RFI
127of for the FCA and if I can squeeze any more acronyms in there I will try to why technically the cpdc requests the the chair and vice chair schedu a close session uh discussion agenda item whatever uh on the RFI responses to the uh FCA RFI on the responses to the FC arfi that's probably the best way of phrasing it RFI uh okay all in favor uh okay uh I'll all right second uh Miss Dixit yeah sorry we're we're it's such a good motion um okay uh all in favor uh it's unanimous um I would also like to make a similar motion um that cpdc requests the superintendent uh to share the responses to the FCA RFI with with fpac uh consistent with uh any legal restrictions and [Music] redactions comma so fpac may provide
128expert input on the development of the new renovation queue just as background um I I understand you know I think Miss Miss Dixit and I both have a lot of experience with Federal procurement and my experience with RFI responses is that they are uh virtually never uh attorney client privilege certainly not that and and usually not confidential either they're you more typically published because uh you know sometimes anonymize sometimes not but the whole idea is that all potential biders benefit from from seeing the um and and and the organization that's doing the procurement benefit from seeing the information that is shared by by all respondents um and it just makes better bids it makes better bid selection um and so I think there just needs to be um a formal request to enable uh a
129a uh an a legal analysis if one is required um because we have this group of experts and uh they've been requesting it for a while um and it seems to have stalled maybe inlegal but um I I think making it a little bit more formal just will allow us to have an answer can it be shared and maybe it's not in the Raw but maybe it can be redacted to some extent to remove any procurement sensitive items but again if it's procurement sensitive it probably wasn't submitted in response to an RFI because I don't think there was I reviewed the RFI and there was and I do not recall any provisions guaranteeing confidentiality of information submitted um do I have a second before because that's necessary before a motion can be discussed I have
130a question because you kind of went off the rails there a little bit and talked about it before it was seconded could this not be a result of the first where we're going to have the discussion in close I feel a little bit in the dark in terms of being able to make a determination here because if we're going to talk about it in close because there's some questions that can't be asked or is it because we can't disclose some of the information contained therein then that would be counter to that approach because once we disclose it to fpac we've disclosed it right right and that's why I say Le consistent with any legal restrictions and redactions right I mean you can if I have an attorney client privileged document right there are certain information
131that you can redact then makes it public similar to a classified document if you make certain redactions right then it can be publicly disclosed uh so redactions are just a common feature of you know the public disclosure process and that would allow it to be and and again I I just want to cast out that any reduction are are uh necessary at all but I'm not the judge but that that would allow that process uh a request would require office of division Council kind of say which parts of this if any right because I'm not making assumptions that any of it can be shared but I believe at least part of it could be shared with fpac so they can advise the board sure and I'm all about that uh but I just feel like
132this motion is pred predicated on the first motion if we don't have that meeting then we can't accomplish the second one I feel as if that's a motion we should be embedded in that at that meeting I mean it could still be I don't know if it could still be a cpdc request it just seems to it doesn't seem to stand alone to me but I don't know um so I kind of want to First Look at the RFI response ourselves as a board and then decide and and knowing how thei responses if there's any propriety information there is any pricing involved U then I would be hesitant to share that publicly and and uh maybe we can summarize the part of it and then share that with our with uh fpac without telling who
133responded what that's a that's a way government issues the responses to the industry they don't say this company responded this way and that way so I would say let's just do that and then we can decide whether we can do this motion I I appreciate I withdraw the motion uh with that um I uh I propose that we um uh postpone the rest of the agenda we we've basically already covered most of the rest of the agenda but uh hearnen es renovation and different renovation cues we can discuss at the next uh school board meeting because I want to be respectful of everyone's time um before we adjourn can we go back up through some of these uh motions so I'm clear on staff expectations so if if you don't mind course so I'm reading
134this the first uh work session that staff were to present would be on design build construction management risk methodologies along with opportunities for commercial real estate office space conversion and optimizing utilization of existing assets okay so for the first component it it's my understanding staff have provided a followon motion back in February that discussed discusses this at length so we would come with that um report that we have already done I do want to point out for the second piece I don't believe there has been a a specific directive to do um an commercial office space conversion uh report or very specifically an optimization and utilization of existing FCPS assets that is a little bit different from the follow on motion from May that we were directed to do on lease consolidation so that would
135be uh my opinion like a new directive uh the first piece I feel like we've already addressed and it would become more just a sharing and and we can present that I I do have concerns with the second piece because that has not been part of the follow-on Motions to date so uh I I guess to my colleagues uh perhaps we could uh put together a motion um uh for a Schoolboard meeting to have a study done of commercial office based conversion and optimizing utilization of existing FCPS assets I welcome your feedback Miss Dixit I my understanding was that as a board we can discuss to do we need a presentation from uh Janice at this point for this particular discussion because I think a lot of us have like Dr Anderson was sharing her
136information I did not know until today you did not know some of the information she was sharing and same with uh Mr McDaniel I think even the board can discuss this even if we don't direct um the school the staff that's a good point Dron yes I do agree with that and I think it would be important um when it comes to existing FCPS assets what I would Envision is what do we have what exists because the Clifton site you know this site and some of the other information it's I don't think it's as you know challenging it's like oh Glasgow did this and this is what happened these should be existing things that we could just share to Spur the conversation and um I also think I asked a question regarding the baile construction
137which would tie into the office space conversion it's just having some things for us to to Spur the discussion with the board to determine you know what's possible from what has already occurred I don't think it's a whole new body of work for you at this time I just wanted to manage expectations especially since many of these um work sessions are uh a part of a big robust document we did I just wanted to point out those particular items were not part of follow on and again I just want to manage the expectations for the work session um and and your discussion yeah and and and perhaps in building out the agenda we can continue to work uh I don't think the work session will have happen next month so perhaps at the next cpdc
138meeting we can have further discussion and drill down a little bit um looking at going through the CIP because the back of it has a lot of useful information we can kind of talk through some of those assets by the way I thought Clifton was on uh the terms escaping me it's not on public sewer right uh I I thought isn't that right Mr McDaniel it's not on public sewer it's on a is mostly well I have I think only Gunston and Clifton were on what's that what's that word where you don't have public sewer well and you well and what do you call it yes septic well and septic the septic yeah septic syst so it's on a septic system I believe that's the limitation of that site um okay so okay so uh
139are there other aspects of the other motions that you'd like to discuss Miss samansky uh no and again we can continue the conversation I just want to make sure we were meeting the board's expectations it's my understanding we've already provided two follow-on motions that discuss the public private Partnerships uh both motions also address swing SPAC and we wanted a preliminary preliminarily and then the other one specific to the scope of work of the P3 so it's our understanding we'd be presenting that for a discussion that's fine great all right uh any further issues that anyone would like to raise yes we're oh okay uh with that uh uh we are adjourned thank [Applause] you thank you thank you so much very exciting stuff I was reading it I was just so oh my God I
140I was so giddy and it's like oh it's just