CorpusRecord 8186

1/14/25 - FCPS CIP Public Hearing

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Fairfax County Public Schools
Date
2025-01-15
Location
Fairfax County, VA
Material
Transcript
Extent
4,296 words · about 24 min
Collected
2026-06-01

Transcript

Verbatim source text

0012025 public hearing on the capital Improvement plan is now called to order Miss Dixit has submitted a written request to attend this evening's public hearing virtually due to medical reasons and she is located in cerville Virginia all those in favor of granting this request please raise your hand opposed extensions okay Miss uh Dixit will be joining us virtually good evening and welcome to the public hearing on the proposed FY 2026 Capital Improvement plan on behalf of the entire school board I would like to thank you for sharing your comments with us this hearing is being broadcast on channel 99 and it's live streamed on YouTube and our website at fcps.edu livestream we have 18 registered speakers who will address the board at this public hearing speakers are allotted two minutes and we ask that you

002stay within that time limit the timer will start when you begin to speak and the timer will sound after 2 minutes please ensure that your remarks are limited to the capital Improvement plan or CIP and that your remarks adhere to the school board's expectations for Community participation if you have not registered to speak but would like to address the board please see the clerk or Deputy clerk to sign up for one of the five extra Reserve speaker slots today the board held a public work session to discuss this Capital Improvement program and we just want to be sure that the community is aware that that can be viewed on the FCPS YouTube channel um and our public TV station and during that time we shared that we are focusing through the CIP on the 8.5

003billion in public infrastructure Assets in Fairfax County for which this board is responsible these of course are the facilities and spaces managed by Fairfax County Public Schools for prek-12 and adult education and the Public's use of these spaces for range of events which last year alone totaled 500,000 our facilities are used 7 days a week from morning until night for essential community services that include public education Athletics Performing Arts academic competitions distribution of Medical Care food and public services polling places to vote Child Care spaces private athletic leagues and events religious services and more critical to recall that this is a voter approved public Bond on the annual November general election ballot that pays for the majority of facilities in FCPS not annual real estate taxes which already provide the annual operating budget of over

004$4 billion this CIP covers the array of critical topics regarding our facilities including Building Maintenance and renovation including safety upgrades and new construction school capacity programming and boundaries and environmental sustainab sustainability planning to name a few with that Madame clerk please call our first registered speaker Jeffrey Longo I'm Jeff Longo co-chair of the Justice High School pyramid workg group consisting of Justice High School staff students parents and surrounding community members uh we were created as a profer of the recently completed school expansion which uh was much appreciated but it ended up leaving the school with only 52 parking spaces for over 1,000 driving age students the lack of parking leads to a number of equity issues at the school School uh including a reduction in permit sales uh inability to host large events the student

005safety and neighborhood issues from students parking in neighborhoods last night our working group approved our final report and so I'm going to try to distill over two years of work into two CIP recommendations in under two minutes let's go profer 6D directed that the north south peace Valley Lane be uh pursued for school use during school hours we learned through a memo from FCPS chief of facilities sensy sorry that uh FCPS considers this option not feasible after discussions with VT and FC dot due to a lack of legislative Authority but our group points to the successful implementation of those student parking restrictions on the east west portion of Peace Valley Lane just south of the school roadway that FCPS recently took ownership of so our recommendation uh is that you direct staff to acquire the

006easternmost half of Northbound Peace Valley Lane from the state and dedicate its use for school parking during school hours with regards to the CIP we recommend that you add Provisions for this Acquisitions during this update cycle finally the previous cips have noted that urbanizing nature of Fairfax County and the need to seek updated designs to meet these needs our Urban peers Alexandria Arlington Falls Church have all prioritized structured parking in their schools enshrine in the CIP that future capital projects should include consultations with Urban urban planners and Consultants during earling planning and determine the need and feasibility of including Urban Transportation Solutions the board will only be listening to public comments tonight not uh responding but we will look forward to receiving your um information thank you Jennifer Falcon John Smith hi I'm Jennifer Falcone

007chair co-chair of the special committee on schools of the great fall citizens Association gfca on behalf of the gfca I appreciate the opportunity to provide comments on the capital Improvement program CIP for over 50 years years the gfca has represented the Great Falls Community on numerous issues impacting County residents we acknowledge the challenges facing the school board and FCPS staff in addressing the Dynamics of planning for County school facilities because of the complexities involved more time for more careful consideration of a CIP is necessary We Believe FCPS has a responsibility to provide a proposed CIP in a more timely fashion additional time for analysis is warranted for example the 2026 2030 CIP became available just one week before the public hearing the following following policy changes last year residents have expressed concerns over inaccuracy of

008enrollment capacity data and the methodology used by FCPS gfca supports the consensus of our community and County residents and agrees that adoption of the CIP should not be rushed we urge the board and the FCPS staff to place stricter e emphasis on acquiring reliable data regarding the number of students we also want to stress the importance of pursuing meaningful stakeholder engagement especially obtaining feedback as it affects communities experiencing high growth and changing demographics we urge that FCPS validate forecasted student enrollment data and methodology to obtain accurate projections before development of revised boundary scenarios we look forward to being able to provide additional input during the review process thank you John Smith in my review of the enrollment projection accuracy I studied the 20133 Virginia Department of Education efficiency review of the school district well generally

009positive it highlighted one Troublesome deficiency substandard projections of long-term enrollment the school district responded that it was developing a more robust system with long-term projection accuracy as an unequivocal necessity for boundary work I chose to confirm that this noted deficiency had in fact been addressed I I reviewed the school district CIP backup worksheets I used AI to scrape FCPS um public web pages for additional data to anal analyze I make comparisons to County city and town forast I met with only personnel and obtained their input I discussed it development constraints and project timing with developers my finding findings further confirmed by this draft CIP is that little has changed the process is flawed severely out of date and fails to adequately consider most new residential development no nor cause and effect of migration and other

010patterns unique to each Community it needs to redesign from the ground up inexcusable for A4 billion do Enterprise is a failure to incorporate modern processes software tools and methodologies the school district needs to fix this deficiency before enacting any action that intimately is intimately linked to long-term enrolling projections I've met with Dr Reed versus Impressions were of a talented leader however the board has dumped a mess on her by pushing through a boundary chains with firster giv her the ability to fix a Le Legacy deficiency with long-term enrolling projections it's time for Dr Reed to push back thank you Scott Jones good evening my name is Scott Jones I'm a parent of the community I have four children enrolled in FCPS schools uh and I am the director of Fairfax matters a nonprofit advocating for

011the welfare of all children in the county I want to talk to you guys about the CIP and some issues of it not taking care of any of our students and US turning a blind eye to it as a community and as the board historically the CIP is said to inform the board on the needs of the community to discuss how the board allocates those billions of dollars you were just talking about Mr Maron and yet fpac is a huge part of that process they inform the CIP the CIP thanks them for their progress right and so that sounds like fpac CIP they go synonymous hand inand the issue comes in when you actually start attending fpac meetings I want to highlight fpac meetings are one of the few that aren't recorded they're not live

012streamed and so the fpac Personnel feel like they can speak pretty openly so much so that they speak about the cue for building uh the board approved a contract and there is currently a contractor that we are paying um a lot of money is the way I'm going to say it uh that we are paying to relook at the renovation queue but fpac members after that contract was awarded joked that it doesn't matter Schoolboard members have made promises so regardless of what that contractor says or recommends the school board is going to continue on approving projects based on the Promises they made if we look at the current construction queue we're not going in order we're going in some strange order we are picking and choosing which projects and which schools get expanded not based

013on the projections from the CIP the information is flawed ultimately what I'm saying is we need to reject the CIP as it is we need to look at how do we get back at providing for the community and how does this board show data transparency to the population that what we are have is Mark D Doner I'm Mark derer Justice working group member science fair volunteer former PTSA park volunteer citizens Association member I'll add to Mr Longo with 12 PS proper planning provide parking protect pedestrians pertinent policy prevent potholes and protect Parks your board policy 81104 says the 5-year CIP is to include rcks and alternatives on capacity of existing buildings proper planning provide parking it plans as far back as fy17 CIP in 2015 to the proposed 261 don't add add Justice's increased enrollment

014on increased parking needs or Solutions tailored for its more urban and higher land use densities are all relevant stakeholder input both school and local community cips speak to smaller things like minor interior facility mods but not to the big ones of Justice parking even 25 CIP page 46 Justice capacity deficit doesn't mention it why fy20 CIP in 2018 recognized we're getting more urbanized less land and impr practic impracticability of traditional designs why not for justice proper planning protect pedestrians it does not seem you're doing safe routes to schools assessments putting results into cips into County and state level like for no sidewalks and poor intersections cips seem to focus on sub substantial capacity but don't address substantial transportation and safety deficits School example no sidewalk on your cafet Tor side of Peace Valley so students

015walk the busy street or the dirt path more on safe routes allad Mansfield roads schoolside sidewalk and rout for hundreds of cmore students was in cleared of snow pertinent policy change Mike burn good evening my name is Mike burn and I'm a proud parent of an F FCPS student well there are many flaws with the draft CIP for 2026 to 2030 I'd like to take the opportunity this evening to highlight two that will lead to poor outcomes for students across the county first the student membership projections in the annual CIP have consistently missed the mark and failed to keep Pace with foreseeable population changes in various parts of the county this is the primary reason why certain schools have become over or undercrowl when and where to conduct School Renovations and expansions one of the

016primary reasons the student membership projections have been continually wrong is that the CIP only accounts for residential development projects that are under construction rather than projects that have been approved and are expected to be completed within the next 5 years this means that FCPS is constantly playing catchup as new residential projects are completed this is a known problem that FCPS leadership and staff are aware of and there's no excuse for allowing it to continue second the program capacity numbers in the draft CIP have been adjusted at numerous schools and some cases significantly without any clear explanation of the underlying factors that justify such adjustments as an example mlan CL High School's program capacity is reduced by 58 students without any apparent explanation for why there are many other examples with sizable adjustments both up and

017down what's notable is that nearly nearly all of the adjustments serve to make certain schools look even more overcrowded or undercrowl evening um today I want to address FCPS comprehensive Improvement plan or CIP which is a vital document that shapes our schools for years to come but there are some areas where the current draft falls short short and I want to highlight those areas today with a focus on data accuracy first let's talk about the student enrollment projections the CIP predicts a decline in student enrollment however it only considers projects that are already under construction as Mike just mentioned this dismisses the full picture take the town of hen's TRG development for example um they predict over 1,000 residential units by 2030 yet since they haven't Broken Ground yet the CIP assigns them a 0%

018chance of being built this skewes the critical data needed to make these important projections the CIP could achieve more accurate projections by considering these already approved projects and applying a probab probabilistic model this would account for the probability of them not being built giving us a more realistic picture of future enrollment inaccurate projections can lead to overcrowded schools and that's something we all want to avoid the renovation queue also raises some questions Centerville is slated for renovation because it's at 109% capacity but mlan is in the same situation and isn't planned for expansion with Tyson's continuing to grow mlan high school should be bumped to the top of the queue this CIP should be an objective document but there are concerns that program capacity calculations are being manipulated to justify moving students around mlan High

019School's program capacity for example again as Mike just said mysteriously dropped by 58 students lack of transparency like this undermines the cred credibility of the entire plan the boundary review advisory committee also needs access to Reliable data to do its job effectively the current projections are not reliable Bill dink Edward Phillips good evening thank you for this opportunity to address the fiveyear CIP I'm Ed Phillips I'm the co-chair of the great fall citizens Association special committee on schools I've had before children go through Fairfax County schools here a very important question was not asked in the comprehensive review process as it relates to the CIP here's the question would you accept your student going to a slightly crowded school if it was a nationally ranked school like Thomas Jefferson or other highly ranked high school

020in Fairfax County and their answer is almost always yes yes and a follow-up question I had to them was would you accept the longer commute time to attend a nationally ranked high school and again the answer is almost always yes here are some bottom lines parents want their children to attend the best possible schools regard regardless if it's slightly overcrowded or if they have a longer commute Point number two we need to get the CIP data right in terms of student enrollment forecast and capacity numbers that needs to precede any boundary change scenarios number three and I acknowledge there's some exceptions to what I'm saying I've listened to a few of these meetings and there are clearly a few schools which need which have issues capacity issues right now and they probably require some board

021action but for for doing a comprehensive countywide boundary change we need to get the data right thank you Abra kesi good evening um I'm Abad kesi a parent with students at FCPS and a member of great fall citizen associations special committee on schools I appreciate this opportunity to provide comments on the proposed Capital Improvement plan as stewards of public education the board carries a responsibility to to every constituent to ensure that all the decisions are made with reliable data sound and explainable insights and full transparency excuse me however the limited timeline for public review of this document spanning over 300 Pages raises some serious concerns we deserve adequate time to fully review and cross check the information in a plan that will significantly impact our students families and communities while the CIP aims to address

022critical capacity and infrastructure challenges several areas lack Clarity and warrant further examination before decisions are finalized number one capacity utilization data the CIP presents capacity utilization figures but does not offer enough transparency on how local Trends such as enrollment shifts or program specific needs are factored into these calculations decisions based on incomplete or unclear data risk to meet the diverse needs of a massive school system like ours number two projected membership decline the document the document acknowledges a decline in student enrollment yet significant Investments remain focused on capacity without a clear rationale linking these Investments to projected needs it is challenging to assess their impact number three decision making framework references to tools like the facilities condition assessment and renovation queue criteria lack sufficient detail about how they will guide prioritization thus requiring the need

023for greater Clarity and transparency given that the public review period Christina Williams Cho good evening thank you for this opportunity tonight I want to highlight one moment we're having a technical issue good evening thank you for this opportunity tonight I want to highlight critical flaws in the current sit projections that will have profound and Lasting consequences for Fairfax County at CPS often emphasizes that a boundary review has not occurred in nearly 40 Years yet during the same 40 40 year time frame FCPS has struggled to produce any accurate student projections a 2013 consultant report noticed that noted that an industry standard for a 5-year projection is a 5% margin of error yet you consistently fail to meet this Benchmark and not just for fiveyear projections but even for one-ear projection this lack of accuracy undermines

024data driven decision making one of the most glaring issues ues is the exclusion of significant new housing developments from your projection this om Omission leads to underestimation of student capacity needs particularly in areas of rapid growth consequently proper contribu contributions as mandated under 2016 legislations which could expand local schools have not been significant have been significantly reduced due to your inaccurate projections this is costing scps millions of dollars a year annually members of the school board we have elected you for the Keepsake of our beloved children and we teach our thing our children one thing attention to detail matters this lesson applies here these decisions will shape Fairfax County's history are you confident enough in these flawed numbers to tie your legacy to this pivotal action thank you Julet Adams good evening my name is

025Juliet Adams I'm a special education teacher US history at Glasgow Middle School as well as the Project Director of the Martin Luther King Jr initiative an initiative that leads a three- Monon celebration focused on promoting equity and inclusion in education given my commitment to fostering an inclusive and Equitable learning environment I have concerns over the overcrowded at Glasgow Middle School which directly impacts our students educational experience with that in mind I would like to address the following question regarding the current capital Improvement program given that Glasgow school is overcrowded why has it not been included in the current capital Improvement program for renovation or capacity enhancement while other schools with similar challenges are being addressed what criteria are used to prioritize schools for the capital project projects in the FY 20263 CIP additionally what is

026the square footage standard for classroom size and why am I required to move mov between four different classrooms including modulars is it maximization of building capacity why does momery County Public Schools appear more efficient in addressing these issues and can FCPS learn from their approach thank you very much Bobby manasella hi I'm Bobby monacella um Mom of two FCPS kids and also here on behalf of mothers outfront a mom- powerered nonprofit focusing on protecting our children from the climate crisis in Northern Virginia we're focused on the transition to Electric school buses electrifying our schools and generating solar energy on our schools my goal today is to encourage the board to ensure that economically effective clean energy remains a critical part of the CIP first I would really like to congratulate FCPS for already committing nine

027schools to Rooftop solar contracts and for the 25 schools that are being organized into project blocks for contract approval in FY 2025 and let me also add a huge thank you for the electric School Bus work that you all have done it is amazing especially the 43 buses that have just been approved um or just been awarded through the clean heavy duty vehicle program um but back to solar with over 200 schools and facilities in the system we encourage the board to take aggressive action to expand School rooftop solar below 250 kilow as we know we know we have to do with Dominion um for the 18 schools left in the renovations queue we recommend that FCPS not just require rooftop improvements to support the expansion of solar in the future but to require the

028Sol solar facilities now with the renovation doing so will minimize disturbances caused by construction and it also um coming from someone who works at a Solar Company it just makes more sense to do it while you're doing the renovation um further for the power purchase agreements already in place we recommend that FCPS review the purchase options in those agreements and analyze whether it's cost- effective to exercise the option and subsequently use the facilities to participate in net metering and sell srex on the energy Market um if you do exercise that option we encourage the board to use the profits from the sales Vanessa Hall ow sorry hi my name is Vanessa Hall I have children and FCPS I've reviewed the draft CIP and there are pretty obvious priorities so some school capacity issues can be

029managed through minor boundary adjustments While others will require renovation and expansion I really wish more people would review the CIP every year if they did then it wouldn't be so surprising that we have to adjust some boundaries as nearly all of the current School boundaries were drawn in a different Century with few of the geographic tools we have today thankfully the boundary policy enables you to be both fiscally responsible while maintaining educational Excellence for fects families I've observed a spirited de debate amongst you about boundary priorities uh so I'm assured you'll Focus the greatest attention on the schools that are most overcapacity while doing so please be sure that title one and the highest needs schools get as much attention as those schools with the loudest and most organized voices in reality there are 180,000

030students and families 25,000 employees and over 200 schools that require require maintenance those needs must be balanced with limited resources and you were elected to make decisions in that tough reality I applaud the neighborhood the efforts of neighborhood groups including my own that have pulled together money time and people to Advocate but we must remember the tens and thousands of families in Fairfax County living paycheck to paycheck who do not have the opportunity language or ability to do the same their voices must not be ignored even if they are not at the table I appreciate that you keep their voices in your heart when you make decisions but please be sure to hear those voices where they live especially those who live in apartment buildings who are underrepresented at all levels of County public input

031and thank you very much Patty Kartchner hello I'm the parent of a twice exceptional autistic student who works in a AAP 4 general education setting at last year's CIP meeting I spoke to you about the need for sensory friendly design in our schools please update our policies to require sensory friendly design and the provision of calm spaces in all schools at all grade levels these spaces should be available to every every student with or without disabilities the is a shared guidance document for creating trauma informed spaces which suggests ways that schools can create inclusive spaces creating these spaces is not required and it's often not a priority the burden of advocating for something like a calm and predictable lunch space falls on families instead of being a thing that's available to any student the availability

032of these spaces should not depend on whether parents have the time and energy to advocate for them you know what would be better choosing to design our school buildings to be inclusive and sensory friendly for everyone FCPS has been working to improve inclusion for students with disabilities but the inclusion is not a matter of just changing student placement the school environment for our students has to be prioritized as we move forward in updating our school infrastructure we need to talk about noise and smells and lighting we need classrooms to be physically larger and less crowded we need every school to have a calm and predictable lunch space for kids who just get overwhelmed in the cafeteria FCPS needs to make trauma informed spaces a requirement please update the policies to require sensory friendly design in

033all School Renovations and new construction thank you [Applause] Jenny white hello I am a parent of a third grade student at West Brier Elementary I'm here this evening to address pedestrian safety at FCPS West Brier Elementary is a large school with over 800 students and many of these students walk or ride their bike on a daily basis parents were notified on November 4th 2024 that school staff are not allowed to act as crossing guards for crosswalks not located on school property since that time no alternative measures have been put in place to ensure the safety of our students for example the intersection of Pine Valley and Westwood Drive is especially congested during school arrival and dismissal times parked cars and vehicles lined up for kiss and ride obscure the visibility of crosswalk additionally cars approach

034the kiss and Rod line from three directions often blocking the crosswalks neighborhood traffic further complicates the situation by weaving around Vehicles waiting to enter the school creating additional hazards the safety of our children walking to and from school should be a top priority I urge the school SCH board to implement and fund an alternative plan to address this issue before someone gets hurt thank you Diana hashimi hello my name is Diana and I'm here to advocate for improved pedestrian safety for students in Fairfax County Schools I commend the board for its attention to this issue but I believe more can be done particularly with the addition of sidewalks and crosswalks these not only protect students but also encourage healthier Lifestyles by enabling safe active transportation to school in the neighborhood of Chesterbrook Gardens in mlan

035many parents are deeply concerned about the safety of their children walking to school Chesterbrook Elementary School and Longfellow Middle School are both within a mile of many homes yet a critical segment of sidewalk is missing this forces students to walk along a narrow two-lane road with heavy traffic often used as a cut through to curvy Road the dangers are evident and while the missing sidewalk is on a project list it is not fully funded I urge the board to explore using Bond money or operating funds to address sidewalk projects near schools like these additionally I encourage board members to collaborate with County Supervisors to prioritize funding for these essential infrastructure improvements ensuring safe routes to school is an investment in the well-being and safety of our students thank you for your time and consideration Sher

036Blackburn Victoria Sneed good evening I'm the parent uh from Justice High School Fairfax County's only title one high school I would like to point out I'm also a member of the working Transportation group The Justice Community Transportation group and I am the director of our food and resource Pantry The wol Shack where I interact with over 400 students a week to provide them with the resources and food that they need on a weekly basis I'm here to talk to you about the transportation issue it's really put a strain on our school so our high school has 52 parking spaces for over a thousand driving age students not every student needs to drive but in a high school like ours a lot do a lot of our students had jobs that contribute significantly to their family

037income they have family responsibilities that go beyond what most high school students really need to deal with the resour the resources at our high school are already crazy thin and never enough and through the poor planning and complete void of student of community and stakeholder engagement FCPS has created a real problem at Justice we don't have what we need to even operate like most comprehensive high schools in in Fairfax County in addition because these students don't have the parking spaces in an around the school it's pushed these students out into the community in very concentrated areas where honestly it's causing a lot of tension in a community that otherwise supportive of the high school so not only have we created problems within the high school we've created problems within the community quite frankly you need

038to use the CIP to write the wrong that was created by FCPS and do something for justice to to just start to bridge the gap right Bill dank Sherry Blackburn Miss Marin that was our last public speaker thank you for sharing your comments this evening the board is scheduled to consider moving forward with approval of the capital Improvement plan CIP at a regular bit meeting on Thursday February 6 2025 if you wish to provide any feedback to the board before this vote please do so by sending your comments to community participation at fcps.edu thank you for your participation and have a nice evening this public hearing on the capital Improvement plan is adjourned as of 6:40 p.m. thanks Ryan

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.