001okay we're going to go ahead and get started for this afternoon morning thank you welcome to everybody we're going to go ahead and start off with the school and traffic's um pedestrian safety assessment project um to start um Miss eisar Heiser has submitted a written request to attend this morning's meeting virtually due to a medical conflict and is attending this morning's meeting from Burke Virginia all those in favor of approving Miss seore heis heis More's request um Mr Moon Mr mline Miss Marin Miss St John cunning miss Mr McDaniel Dr Anderson and myself so that is unanimous for everyone here miss seore Heiser can you please go ahead and check your microphone and [Music] Camera we'll check in with her when she comes back online okay so to kick off this morning we have Mr
002muick our chief operating officer um miss samansky our chief of facilities services and capital programs and Mr Lambert um Chief Safety and Security Officer so you guys can go ahead and take it away thank you Miss Anderson good morning School Board um we're here to talk about the school traffic and pedestrian safety assessment plan as Miss Anderson mentioned again Andy muick coo we got Janice samansky chief of facilities and capital programs Brian Lambert uh chief of Safety and Security and then for the the working group when I call your name in the back if you could just stand up real quick I'll run through the group back there Transportation Paul deandrade executive director Tracy Kubo Carrera assistant director uh John McCracken senior manager uh marari zamani senior manager Derek Gwyn safety specialist uh Isaac Robertson
003uh senior manager and then all the way in the back our previous Chief Tom Vella who helped get us kicking the off um next slide please the agenda um we'll briefly talk about the CIP motion and then more importantly go into what the working group has uh developed uh and where we plan on going from here next slide please so the here's the motion everybody can read it I just want to cover a quick summary highlight um the motion was to develop an annual School traffic and pedestrian safety Assessment program that models the capital Improvement program in approach mitigation strategies and Reporting in a structured response to ongoing concerns across the division so again just modeling the CIP hitting on um a proper approach mitigation um and Reporting next slide please and here's a timeline
004to date we uh we got um started working on this in Earnest in uh January uh of uh this past year at the time the group was focused on how central office Personnel could conduct the uh assessment across all the schools and develop guidance and approach to do it from February through June that's what we worked on the outcome was Lessons Learned From conducting a joint working group assessment um kind of a pilot of the document we put together in February and early March at Fairfax High School to see if it was going to uh that standard operating procedure was going to get the design effect that we wanted um it it helped us gain some lessons learned which caused us to re-evaluate our approach uh and in August through December we spent our efforts
005working on a revised approach to accomplish the annual assessment via a school-based uh initial self assessment process and here we are today talking to you about it next slide please um this is just a list for inventory of the people on the working group for your reference later it's all the people I just in uh introduced next slide please so this is a list of the documents or artifacts that the team has developed over the last 11 months when we first started off looking at doing it as a central office-based approach and then shifting to a school-based self assessment process we have a slide talking about each one of those in a little bit more depth depth so I won't waste a lot of time talking about it here next slide please so the first
006one school traffic and pedestrian safety assessment guidelines this is the document the team put together kind of a standard uh uh an sop that they were going to use going forward when it was central office based staff doing it about a five or six page document so that we would do the assessment the same way every time in a nice consistent repeatable process next slide please that led us to doing the joint working group assessment of uh Fairfax High School um the working group decided to conduct that to better inform their approach on this project uh and it served its Pro purpose we went out there uh in March the week prior to uh spring break and it took several weeks after that and a couple more visits out at Fairfax to fully develop the
007assessment uh and what it really did was it highlighted some lessons learned from us uh just as we hoped it informed us on how we want to approach this process going forward and we'll discuss that on the next slide next slide please so the Lessons Learned what we learned from this was the time to conduct a single School assessment clearly indicated that a small team uh that's sitting behind you back there would not be able to get to all 200 schools in a year uh the formal assessment write up that they put together was very detailed but it took several weeks uh and a couple visits of the school to pull it together um data collection um and um tough to consolidate from these kind of narratives they had some but um just realized that
008it was you it wasn't going to be impossible but it wasn't the most um smooth and efficient way to to gain data and start to see Trends uh limiting resources obviously the personnel and the time to get this done um and then the local nuances uh it's hard to capture those when you're unfamiliar with the surroundings and you're coming into a school and I know that we're all familiar with our 200 schools but there's something about the people that are there uh working and operating out of that school every day that know little nuances that this team wouldn't necessarily pick up on in one or two or three visits uh and then uh lastly uh the lesson learned on figuring out how to get better community and stakeholder input into this process as well next
009slide please so as I said what we learned from that was that approach wasn't necessarily going to be achievable so we had to develop uh a new iteration of it and that was a school-based self- assessment process uh the team created a questionnaire to help guide the school team through an assessment of their school uh they developed an accompanying uh electronic submission form to provide an efficient method to consolidate input from all the assessments to enable us in central office to start seeing Trends either at a school you know across several years or across all schools common issues that we're seeing uh across the division and to to enable us to have a little bit more comprehensive perspective on the situation and the third thing they developed was a mitigation toolkit uh it's a living
010document to help schools um you know address some of their concerns you know it's the old concept of you know give a man a fish feed him for a day teach him how to fish feed him for life so that mitigation toolkit was along those lines next slide please um the school-based self assessment approach or questionnaire if you look the slide behind me has the headings for the sections in that school-based assessment underneath each one of those SE uh qu those headings is a several more additional questions to get into more detail and to help um help highlight some issues or concerns that may be at those schools um this is going to help us it'll provide us more standardized data um about the pedestrian traffic concerns uh along with uh an opportunity for central
011office Personnel now to better see what's going on at all 200 schools next slide please so this is uh the school-based self assessment electronic submission form and just a quick shout out to marari behind you while she took the it was her initiative to kind of pull this thing together and create this document so I just wanted to highlight there everybody back in that row has done a great job but I just wanted to call her out for getting that in here um this electronic submission form accompany accompanies the school-based self assessment process and I'll kind of after the next slide double back to the slide before this number 11 and just kind of walk you through how we envision this process working next slide please the mitigation tool kit um many schools are willing
012and able to attempt to solve some of their own problems and that's the P purpose of this living document um the the team already has a bunch of different links uh tools uh examples of setting up kiss and ride how flow patterns in schools should go better without buses and kiss and ride Crossing each other or interfering with each other at exits and use of cones and signs so this mitigation toolkit as I mentioned a couple times already living do document help those people that have the time and the initiative to be able to address some of their simpler problems at the school without having a tie uh Pullin central office so uh Janet if you go back to slide 11 the way we kind of Envision this going is if you know whenever we
013decide that is going to be let's say the month that the schools do their assessment you have a leadership or admin person who has the questionnaire you know kind of on a clipboard walking around you know for a day or two or three answering the questions that are on there taking the counts the timing that we've listed uh when they're done they come back to their office they sit down they go into this electronic submission form they upload all those answers to those questions because the two match and they also scan in the actual hard copy that they used because we'd want to see that too right that's important the notes they took what they did when they were walking around and now when they hit submit we start to build and have um you
014know uh some kind of repository of information so that we have the beginnings of being able to see some Trends and highlight common issues understand what's going on at each school um and then back to the mitigation toolkit slide number 13 um that is intended to give them some ways to help themselves right um we the whole division is a small team and the more people that uh throw their hands into the mix of the solutions the better we'll be uh next slide slide 14 Janet thanks so where do we go from here path forward our proposal is in the spring that we would conduct a pilot of six schools one from each region just to make sure that what we just told you our vision was actually works out the way we think it
015will um obviously there'll be some things that uh help us shape this even more from that pilot but if everything going the way we think it should and will um post-pilot decision would be yes let's roll this out and move forward uh in school year 25 26 and then in a in a year the way we envision it going is um you know let's say October seems seems like a good month schools have settled out in their routine we give schools that 30 days to do this school-based self assessment and upload their electronic submission and scan their document in in November they can immediately start looking at that mitigation toolkit and they can look at it all year long um and figure out hey what are some things we could do on our own to
016solve some of our problems during that same November early December we at central office are looking at it to to start figuring out okay which of those schools are in most need need of our assistance because we can't get to all of you know if there was 30 High priorities we will do our best to start knocking them out one by one but we'll do our best to prioritize and start attacking those most in need uh and develop um plans to mitigate those biggest concerns and then January through May we would be working with those schools um helping to solve some of those concerns and issues and then in June and there was a a typo in here that that I did not catch before that should have say June 26 instead of January because
017we want to have those five months of work and mitigation to be able to come back to you all and say hey here's the results of this first year here's what we got from the school-based self assessments here's the mitigations we did here's some of the things that we were able to solve and we're now ready to go into year two uh next and last slide Janet next steps this just a little bit uh less uh a little simpler summary of what we just said so spring conduct the pilots um finish these the guides continue to work on the toolkit for mitigation strategies um in May confirm that we think the pilot proved that this is a good way to go um and then in may as well once we have that decision we start
018working on the internal external communication strategies right because there's a lot of communication that goes along with this too to tell uh internal stakeholders external stakeholders what we're doing um there'll be questions on how they can play how they can help how they can assist uh and then school year 2526 uh implement it and see the first report June of 2026 um I know that was uh pretty fast through those 15 slides um everyone here has had them in advance and I figured it was probably more important for the discussion and questions that uh that you may have and you also have a big day ahead of you with the uh the Sip as well so I figured time was of the essence so with that Miss Anderson I think we're open for questions comments
019okay I'm going to go ahead and jump in with the placards I see already Dr did you want to say anything I realized that you weren't here when we first got kicked off uh no other than I think this is really important safety work uh when we think about um especially our carbon goals as well having the number of students able to walk or bike to school or have safer routes to school um I think is healthy for our students and also for our carbon footprint so I think this is important work and I appreciate the board's attention to it this morning okay Dr Anderson go ahead and kick off and then Mr Moon thank you uh I also think this is important work because when we worked on this back in 23 it was
020because we had so many schools having so many issues with having a safe way to get in and out of the buildings um I appreciate this approach that's going to be consistent and form throughout the division and I'm particularly Mindful and grateful that you are cognizant of the nuances that live in each school because it's I was a school principal the things that I see are not the things you would see as somebody who is in the central office um and the mitigation measures that I see here are are also very helpful but what I wonder here a little bit is um the schools do the self assessment then they go through the mitigation list to determine what they can utilize um I see this as kind of another layer for the schools to complete
021I I'm wondering what are we taking off of the plate because we're adding one more thing well first of all um Dr Anderson good question um but not but there are several schools already that are taking their own initiative to do mitigation strategies so what I think we're suggesting isn't something that's going to be foreign to a lot of them if you could go out to I think a bunch of us were at TJ when they were figuring out how to solve their own kiss and ride traffic um uh Fiasco uh and they were able to fix it on their own um um I think can you give me the rest of the question because I kind of lost my thought there um it's okay we'll come back to it because I you kind of
022headed to where I was going um a lot of these again speaking from being a former School administrator a lot of these mitigation measures if you have an issue at your school you're kind of trying everything you're doing everything I'm not necessarily seeing the newness of it I'll give you the example that you just talked about TJ they've been working on it for years they got me involved got you involved went in and had more conversations and did things that are not having the impact that we're hoping for so I just feel like what's the next step because that impact is not being felt I mean the community now they're like we did what we could with the school but I don't know what else to do here I think what it takes off there
023and thank you that reminded me of the other part of the question I think what that takes off their plate is like right now today they just have hundreds of different people coming in and and maybe complaining about different things this doesn't work that doesn't work what about this concern now we put a plan in place and that's part of the communication that says hey we heard you we're putting in a a process to address these give your concerns beginning of the year whenever we say to the principal to the team we'll incorporate it into this process and I think we kind of see that that will take some of that burden off of the schools because right now Community is like if I'm not in your face telling you that there's a you know
024a problem and beating you up all the time it's not necessarily going to get done and I think this is a good step towards us you know kind of getting our effort you know more focused uh getting everybody to the table uh and after a you know it's not going to be immediate but I would say after a certain amount of time whatever that is maybe a year you start to see those improvements across the board and people realize hey I have a method I have an opportunity to give my concerns to the school and it's going to get addressed well it's definitely going to organize it oh yeah and the and that toolkit is there so now they're not trying to think up stuff on their own they have this toolkit of resources where
025they if they have a problem that should save them time as well in terms of having to go look for something or create it they can look and see a school that had a similar issue how they fix it and maybe that speeds it up for them okay thank you very much app appreciate the toolkit because it may provide some ideas that were not yet there and some of these are how to reduce um car traffic vehicle traffic which I think is important but I'd be remiss if I didn't raise the fact that I know particularly at our middle schools where the kids are starting as early as they are that increases the traffic because parents are not comfortable having their 10-year-old who's a sixth grader be at a bus stop at 6:20 in the
026morning and I could can speak about that firsthand because I do that as a parent I'm one of those drivers in that kiss and ride and it's a long kissing ride when you have a school that starts that early so I also think we have to kind of walk handin hand with what we expect with the the infrastructure yes ma'am um can you speak a little bit as to how was it decided that Fairfax High School would be the pilot boy I'm looking at the back room to phone a friend you know I anybody back there remember why we picked Fairfax and you have to if you holler I'll repeat it in the microphone or you can walk to a microphone there's there's a mic right here come on sorry we need you add a
027microphone please sorry Tracy there's a mic here there's a good morning Fairfax High School has a notorious traffic problem that we've been dealing with for years and years and years the buses and the cars are comingled coming into and exiting the school it creates significant delays for buses trying to drop off students and then once they drop them off they can't get out of the schools the school to get to their next run which makes that next run late um it's predominantly a bust school there's very few walkers there's very few bike riders so that's why we selected Fairfax because it's very it's the way it's set up it really needs to be redone with a separate bus entrance exit but that's beyond our control absolutely because they have a different facilities work absolutely the
028six P thank you so much the six schools that you're going to use for the second I guess you had this Pileated now you're going to have a test run how are those schools going to be decided have they been selected they have not been selected we were going to pick one from uh each of the six regions but we hadn't gotten that far down the path yet I would love to hear some of the criteria because I think this was important cuz I if it's having one mode of egress and Ingress for the buses and vehicles I think that says something having um schools that are right on main roads also has a different impact a go back please Mr Moon and then miss Mar thank you Madame Vice chair uh just a couple
029of preliminary questions uh since many of us were not on the board back in February 2023 I think just a four of you were there uh that was there a particular impetus behind this motion uh whether there there were accidents or or or just could somebody explain Miss sers if that's okay I can because this was born out of um two separate motions that end up being merged because there are some issues that Mr frish was experiencing in his area where there were some accidents and I was having a similar issue in the Mason District if you remember the accident with the young girl who um was killed off of Colombia Pike getting her sister on the bus and then something's similar at badier where um the the speed at which cars were traveling um
030caused accidents at a fairly blind road so it was really out of pedestrian safety that came from two different areas of the division and we ended up merging it into a big motion to just evaluate all of the schools because we knew this problem was probably a bit a little bit more wides spread okay with that in mind uh you know looking at the Timeline you know motion study from February 2023 and full report to the board is not expected until June of 26 just a three and a half years is that to deal with something as Grave as what you describe I guess this question goes to Mr Mayor well the the original motion was in February of 23 uh and I know that we were reminded of it in uh I think it
031was was it December 23 or January of uh 24 uh and as as soon as soon as it came back up uh Janice myself and Tom Vell got the working group together right away the only thing I could say for that interim period was just there was a lot of churn going on you had an interim coo you did not have three individual Chiefs yet they were in the process of doing that restructure um Janice got here in July I got here in October Tom became a chief in in December I think there was just a lot of chaos around it um unless but I'm I'm speaking to a time when I wasn't here either so um one of my bosses may have an opinion certainly certainly we've lost about a years worth of time
032but I don't want I don't want I don't I'm not sure that you want to cize that as a chaos but because I don't want to see any chaos in the school system but thank you yes sir Miss Marin and then Mr McDaniel thank you again so much for this work and I'm not sure if you mentioned this but you did uh Dr Reed did share an update of this to the school board in a Friday letter um in August of 24 so that was the first time we saw the initial plans I know I submitted a lot of comments and now we're seeing the report to the full board at this time so this is obviously a great amount of work and it makes sense but FCPS and our individual schools cannot bear the
033full responsibility of all matters related to pedestrian and vehicular safety regarding our schools this is just another example of how we are being saddled with so much more than just instruction now because we're FCPS we're trying to solve this problem we know that our kiddos and our adults I've got adults that have been hitting crosswalks I've got seven years creating um a road diet and crosswalk I I mean the list goes on and on um we always say that student safety is a top priority and it's true but I will continue to push on the boundaries and ask the superintendent to walk a very fine line of what our school staff and on our our central office staff are going to do and what we need other partners to do I think it's reasonable to
034talk about um to be effective and thoughtful about how our students and and adults are engaging on school grounds especially when it comes to buses that's that's our world right how are we getting our buses in and out effectively but um you know this underscores that it's not only government agencies but students families and our local residents who really need to play their role um even just thinking about snow days you know FCPS did its it's due diligence to remove the snow but those public roadways those residential sidewalks were not cleared so I am not comfortable with our schools and our staff bearing the amount of work that is proposed in this um tool so here are my questions um what is the workload for this effort when it comes to how much staff time
035and resources this occupies you know in the context of the portfolio of work that each of your offices are bringing because you all each have huge portfolios and I also would like to hear you know notably there is zero inclusion in this in this work about our Fairfax County Police Department who are responsible for law enforcement or the county and state Departments of Transportation um what was their role if any in developing this work um I don't see from the scope on slide seven the list of public spaces those are those are public managed spaces they're not our spaces I'd like to hear about crossing guards um and I'd like to hear about the experiences that you've had when you do get and our schools do get the call hey we got to change the
036speed limit we got to get a crosswalk we need a speed bump we need W winom matics because that's really for me where my advocacy was born out of I've got residents asking me and I'm asking facilities I'm asking safety so ultimately what I'd like to know is this what what is the role of the county in helping us with this and how do we dial back this approach how do we use students even to create the assessments for them to safely go out and do we have win thematics what's the speed bone I am hardpressed to have instructors and building leaders out logging what the speed loan limit is in front of their schools I'll kind of start a response on this I think that what we want to get out of is the
037cycle of responding to the Urgent so that we can address the important and right now almost exclusively um I would say that it's the complaints and the loudest voices and complaints that get our energy and resources but there's not been what I would characteriz as a comprehensive look at all sites and an objective cue built around what needs to happen first and so I think um when we talk about staff and staff time it's often responding responding responding and what we want to do is get out ahead of responding responding responding so that we can get as I mentioned also be able to use our finances more efficiently in terms of at scale providing adjustments where there need to be made I think Mr Lambert can talk a little about our collaboration with law enforcement
038that Mr Vell began and um many others and he can continue that I think we have many parts of the county where the School Division the county maybe even a city and then V do are all um stakeholders in an intersection or in a part of uh real estate for whatever reason I know the accident Dr Anderson referred to earlier Mr Vell and I went out to the scene that morning and it wasn't really necessarily adjacent or proximal at all to a school it was a one of those separated four-lane highways with a turn lane unfortunately on a horrific um sorrowful morning for sure and it's not something the School Division necessarily like we couldn't have put a stoplight up there or put the lights um but those are the types of places where you
039look at you think this doesn't look safe and clearly wasn't safe that morning and um so I I really applaud the effort that the board had the vision to think about how can we get ahead of the constant reacting um but then I think it's a great segue to our sip conversation this afternoon the the level of resource allocation required to get ahead of it is a commitment that's going to need to be a collaborative commitment because we continue to fall behind in our just keeping up with work orders to our backup projects and you could substitute safe walks safe routes and pedestrian areas for the Sip backlogs right like we continue to try to address backlogs so we're not really having a lot of success getting out ahead of things um so that's just
040a general statement and U Mr Lambert you want to talk about specifically our collaboration with law enforcement please thank you Dr thank you Miss Marin um I think we are very fortunate with our relationship with the Fairfax County Police Department I know Dr Reed um and and the chief of police collaborate and speak often um that said there are parts of this plan um where I am most comfortable that it will move quickly and to Dr Anderson's Point um one of the areas where I want to make sure we include in this pilot our ele schools and the reason being is we know we have great coverage with school resource officers at our high and middle schools which Taps into a lot of resources that are at the administration's fingertips so I want to personally
041be very sensitive to the elementary schools um who may not as easily or readily be able to pull information like accident reports or speed violations or whatnot so that is a factor that we'll consider in in the pilot um and seek to find a way where those school resource officers are really helping because each of those school resource officers even though I'm blessed to have uh an outstanding Captain who sits here and he's the collective glue they do all report to the stations that are in their community so they're they're connected to their Community um as well um ma'am you mentioned the uh crossing guards that is a collaboration between us and the police department um the police department's the the only folks who have the authority to to stop traffic um or their design
042through a crossing guard so there there are a variety of ways that we hear about the need to change those sometimes it could be a a community member um you know School staff what we do is we send out a person from our staff to see first and foremost do we agree with that um if we do agree that hey we should look at this again we work with the Department of um Motor Vehicle Enforcement from the Fairfax County Police Department they also come out and sit down and look at different factors like speeds number of crossers is there an alternative that's minimally invasive and as long as we have concurrence then the police department will look to place a crossing guard there are occasions where demographics may change and they may have assessed this
043in 22 23 school year but now there were a lot of elementary students who were now middle school or whatnot so they'll sometimes come back to it but we do have a good back and forth relationship uh on that on that topic as well and then just getting down at the very micro level and shame on me that I don't share it more but uh Derek and his team that work for for Isaac um they constantly in communication with vot um so that when we have something and I know winka mtic has been you know an issue that we've we've talked about lately it is it is complex within the school system it requires us to assess it Janice's team um because you're you're involving placing electronics and hooking up to um perhaps people's easements
044or property um talking to vot seeing how they're doing with installation but I do want to point out something that's not well known is vot does also reach out to us unsolicited um Team shared with me an example of they were placing a crosswalk that has nothing to do with schools but they reached out to Derek and said hey this isn't proximal to a school but do we need to put the right sign that has students Crossing and so I I do want to provide encouragement that there is a lot of back and forth It's not often raised up to the top levels but it is happening and I would also add and good or good morning everyone I would also add that if I were to put my uh former Elementary principal hat on
045these are activities that I would do with my staff uh at the beginning of each year before students arrived uh I didn't have a full Spate of assistant principles I had one assistant principal and then I had one uh individual who was responsible for buses but we would annually do uh walk around the properties look to see where there were issues work very closely with uh uh Safety and Security at the time uh if there were issues and uh if I were a principal to have these resources it would it would actually help uh ease the load of the work that we were doing and it also create some consistency so that I can could have conversations with colleagues who are having some of the same issues we could work from the same sheet we
046would have the same set of uh resources so I do see this as a a support for principles and I do know that the team has worked very closely with our Ras and EPS to have these conversations to ensure that principles would be comfortable uh taking on some of this work and again I don't see it as additional work because all of our schools are actively engaged in ensuring that uh our students are are getting to and from school safely okay so we have about 20 minutes left and we have five people that still want the first initial time um so I'm going to ask everybody to keep your comments as quick as as quick as possible in order to make sure that everybody has an opportunity to speak so Kyle or Mr McDaniel and
047then miss lady thank you um and if we continue the conversation I think we'll probably set a world record if the number of times wink omatic is mentioned in a single setting um but I can buy into the concept of I think is a good idea I do have some questions on the details of implementation so if each if each of our 19800 schools are being asked to kind of compile this list it's safe to say that this is all self-reporting is that accurate right have we ever had how confident are we in the consistency of the self-reporting that's a big concern that I have and and that's going to be heavily driven by the data collection tool um are we asking qualitative questions are we asking more quantitative questions kind of walk me through
048that actual assessment process questions are a mix of both qualitative and quantitative so you know there's some things that are more focused on yes no numbers and then others that hey what concerns do you have what does what have you heard from the community so it's a mix of both and I think that's partly why we want to do that pilot with six before we roll it out to to kind of far it out some of that okay um and then in terms of expectation setting once we have this list across all of our our our schools is someone going to sit down and go through this list and say okay here's what we can do here's what we can't touch because this is inevitably going to involve as Miss mirin brought up in particular
049V do police outside agencies that we have no control over yes sir I think there's going to be a portion of the data that comes back and in an Ideal World we were talking October would be an Administration November would be an analysis and sitting down I'm actually curious to know what we don't know because just like the pilot told us stuff that we don't know uh I'm also selfishly a little bit excited because it's going to grab some information um to help our safe routes to school program which rests with us um some of the questions that are asked is how many are Walkers how many are bikers that will tell us where we want to put some of that training bicycle training um where people aren't doing it so where we can focus
050different resources because the program has some different parts to it but I think there's a piece of we don't know what we don't know until we hit that that first survey gotta and then at what point again kind of what Miss M's bringing up once we have this list and we know that you know here's our items that we can't touch because it's do or police whatever it may be when does that get sent off to those agencies and kind of what is that relationship because I can I can understand why we would want to take off chunks at a time you know top 10 top 20 top 30 but everything that V do has to fix should go in lump suum over to VT everything that the police have to do should go in
051lump sum over there so I just want to make sure that that would occur yes sir I think that's absolutely valid and this is where I believe we transition from the schools playing a role to the central office playing a role because the relationships with vot for example are our relationships and that's best served um when we go over RIT large and I think an example of where that worked best is recently during this snowstorm um we didn't bombard VT with 10 different emails uh Janice and Andy were compiling hey these are the hotpots that are coming in so that we're giving them as well a product that's simple not confusing and we're talking uh in tandem okay that was all I had thank you Miss Lady and then miss St John cunning so first
052question is has anyone run this by the principles at all or any principles to see what their initial feelings are we uh we did run it by the uh chief of schools and the razes uh and a couple EPs and they were all positive but not directly two principles okay um because I I do agree with this plan of action I do think that schools know better what's actually going on because they're there on a daily basis and they understand other iterations of an accident at this main intersection how does that further congest um I also want to share that uh we were just tackling something similar at Chesterbrook in terms of um that main road and working with Department of Transportation working with vot working with feax County um and I mean the resolution
053is not what the residents want um but what they are going to do is eliminate a lane because they had like a turn lane that people were flying up and not slowing and it was on the side of the school because it that turn lane did go into a retirement home but you have to merge back but people were doing the fly up and cut over um so so while there while there is some resolution to what's going to happen they're going to put some different sidewalks they didn't get the blinking lights right they didn't get some of the things they wanted um but I will say that was a pretty productive uh meeting um as I attended the first one and you know residents were there school was there it was a good it
054was a good dialogue to stand outside and sort of during what was happening with um the start of school um the other thing I want to say is please make sure schools are fully aware of the timeline because it really pains me how often you know and I lived it school-based people feel like what are they doing up there they asked us for this like a year ago okay nothing's being done so please make sure that people understand timelines and so there's not an unfair expectation of turnaround um and then the other question and I'm going to it's rhetorical but I'm going to throw it out there the work order problem that was presented to us in last last spring I believe with technology that was grossly broken um someone I believe it was Miss
055Dix that made the suggestion that we tackle we tap our our TJ students or either anyone in our system who is brilliant when it comes to technology to write a program for Fairfax has anyone followed up on that I will check in on whether anyone has followed up on that I'm guessing not um so I will follow up on that my apologies thank you I just think I think it's a brilliant idea I mean we need if we tap our own kids and it's a great portfolio for them for whatever whether it's work force they're going directly into or whe they're looking to apply to colleges it's a great portfolio and I do believe we have the kids capable of doing it yes ma'am because they certainly can break into our uh technology thank you
056and miss lady just a quick comment you know when we will definitely make sure that they know the timeline and that was why we went to the chief of schools and the razes and the EPS to make sure we hit up our you know central office main point of contact First and the three of us are very reluctant to ever put workload back on schools you know we we talk about it all the time about hey how do we take stuff away from it's only in an extreme situation like this safety Focus first that we would even consider it so and I hope in that communication you'll copy principles I I I'd like to believe that the turnaround conversation happens consistently but everyone's volume is is high and so just if something would directly go
057to principales and their and their staffs about the timeline I think it'd be great thanks yes ma'am Miss St John cunning and then miss exit so so my question and again uh concurring with my colleagues here the people that are there at the school really know what's going on and and thank you for the work providing the toolkit is going to be very helpful but I'm looking at the self assessment form and where you get feedback from students and from the community you're asking you you know what are the primary safety concerns raised by the community or the school staff versus asking them directly and I know that I've been working on several issues in my in my district with several schools where the issues have been brought up by community members and sometimes we
058have extremely Vigilant community members that know a lot I don't want to say they know a lot more but they're on top of it they're out there they're watching I have a constituent that will send me pictures of they're parking here they're parking there uh and so when we're asking the staff members to say what are the concerns that the community has brought you versus going directly to the community I don't know what that would look like so I'm just putting that out there as something that we hear directly from them versus it coming through um that's my one I guess suggestion question something for you guys to look at um and then just the other thing for General um knowledge for the public as another colleague has mentioned all of our Partnerships and working
059on a specific other issue um about what community members want and again winom matics and um working with our partners at a meeting last week you know when it comes down to it it's like how much is this going to cost and that's an issue can we do this and our partners that help fund us are like that's prohibitive you know the community wants it but are we going to invest that money on you know $40,000 for a winom adic on a road that's not a major road so I I think it's incumbent for our community to recognize that there are some things that are outside of our budget that it's difficult to do as much as we want to do it uh and that's where working with our partners is important and that's where
060having our partners understand the needs and prioritize what we can and can't do is important Miss Dixit thank you for the presentation um I wanted to ask you that and I know that you are part of the joint working group and uh leading this but um do you have experience in this kind of work before like questionnaires um assessment any of this listed were uh work here have you had done it before no ma'am it's first time for me so I just wanted to you know understand like why we do all these comprehensive studies and we are hiring Consultants to do the Middle School start time and you know C boundary and everything like that this looks like a you know really important undertaking as well and I think it's going to take a lot
061of time away from our staff so um I just kind of wondered the the decision did the board decide to uh I not not our board previous board decide to go with the staff to do this or it was decision made was the motion as you see it but it doesn't say who is going to actually do the work that's just how it was okay so so Dr Reed I just maybe just ask you this that did you decide this uh based on the there was no budget for it or you didn't think there was a right approach to just go with another uh external consultant I think that what we really wanted to try to do there had been uh previously members of a department tasked for this work so and there were staff
062whose role uh had this work assigned to them so I think what we wanted to try to do first is see if we could do this in-house uh rather than go outside again I think it's really important in these tight budget times as we're talking about budget it's my priority to be as efficient as we possibly can um and not to begin new consultant contracts where it's not absolutely necessary so we do want to try to use um staff to uh many hands make light work so I think that's part of the idea here is partnering with our County um and V do colleagues as well as all of our School principles and school communities to make better choices rather than um going with another uh consultant however I think it we certainly can look
063at that if uh um you know I think we as things are they evolve but at this time we really felt like we could create this plan um inhouse no I agree uh from the work already has been done it's it's kind of the path to go forward but I I feel like then if there is a task where you you know somebody is exper expert in that thatt it would be done more efficiently and in timely manner then we creating a task force uh in without without team which is already busy and have their full-time job day-to-day work and they probably have to now take this project on on its own and and Lead that uh so um I I guess the timeline and everything looks good because we are internally working on this
064but I guess it if we had hired somebody to do it we could have probably hit the timeline a bit earlier so just for the future I would just say that we're taking such initiatives I would like to discuss as a board whether we would like to hire somebody or we like our staff to do all this additional work thank you ma'am okay I'm going to go ahead and take a a opportunity to speak and then we'll go back to um a few Gob backs that we had um I appreciate what you guys have done here because I think that what you've done is create a model for initiatives that are around the division where we can Empower schools to make decisions um for themselves where they're not necessarily just waiting for direction from higher
065up so I do think that that is a model that we can use for lots of other things around the division so I am extremely happy to see things like the mitigation toolkit I do want us to to go and seek out those things that are unique that are being done not just the Norms um but sometimes when you get a new principal they don't know where to buy the the traffic cones and just having that cheat sheet of a place to go to is really important so I'm happy to see all of all of those things I also think that this is an important moment of alignment so asking the question both of the community members and the principles I think is extremely important because then you can figure out whether or not both
066things are rising to the top or whether or not you just have one squeaky wheel because that does sometimes happen um the community doesn't always know what's possible lots of times we're advocating for things that we we've had projects in my community that were funded by by F Dot and they were FC Dot and then they were o they were overruled by V Dot and so we have lots of times that we have overarching state Authority that comes in what I love about the idea of collecting information in one location is that when we pass things forward to V do we can also make sure that the things that we know are possible and that are functional problems that they need to address are able to rise to the top and maybe we can get
067some traction on that and everybody's not dealing with just the squeaky wheel over and over again not to say that the squeaky wheel doesn't have very important things to say but it's just sometimes it's not always as Dr Reed said it's not always the important it's the Urgent um the other thing that I wanted to mention is that the communication strategies to engage with the public is essential here so making sure that um the public understands how to to share problems I think that's going to make it easier for all of us to also know what's going on but also have the opportunity for for community members to feel um empowered with what's with what they need to do as well because there are aspects of this like shoveling sidewalks and things like that that
068are important that it's all a partnership that needs to work together so I am excited about the fact that we may be able to use this information to make our interaction with State partners and and local Partners more effective and the last thing I'll say is regardless of what Avenue we take we are going to need input from the principles because somebody has to feed the assessment and they are the people that have the information so I am hopeful that what we can do is do that as effic ly as possible so I am strongly in favor of having a some a tool that they have a certain window to collect information in and then they have a place to to pass information for the rest of the year so I think that that not
069to say that we'll diminish the importance of those other projects but I think that it's important to kind of Target that in and I think it will ease time in the long run that Dr Anderson for a GoBack thank you you you mentioned a little bit ago about the time it took to take the assessment to complete a report can you say a little bit more there yes ma'am it was about uh I'm looking back there it was probably about three weeks start to finish uh took uh at least if I remember correctly two visits to Fairfax High School and it was just kind of what we've discussed here earlier it's just this was you know along with their other daily jobs so finding that time to get out there and get into the details
070at Fairfax carving that out for us to go as a team just was a little cumbersome so the three weeks included the assessment or just report writing okay and again I do want to raise my concern regarding the additional workload to principles I know their input is key but I'm also concerned that they were not part of this conversation and we always talk about not doing things on to people without them being part of the conversation this was a Mis opportunity it's much easier for us to sit in central office and shift things around but I think we have to really engage with the practitioners hopefully you could have a group of principles review this really quickly before the next update one other oh no go ahead I was just you know just to give
071a little insight we we started the conversation with Chief of schools and raz's and EPS because that's you know who all the principles kind of get their guidance from we started there we weren't by any means done today that's where we wanted to see where this went before we start rolling it out more and that was kind of part of the internal external communication plan we were referred to which is pulling all them in and like Janice had mentioned you know all the principal Association meetings that we go to once a month there's a lot of opportunities for us to roll this out and and make sure that they're we're not just piling stuff on them and Dr uh you brought up a point that I wrote down that I want to reflect in the
072pilot um you see often how long did it take to complete this form I'm very curious in gathering that data as well because I think that's important for us before we roll out countywide thank you um also information about of vehicular traffic um I know that the move is to have more kids on the bus because we can control it and it just decreases traffic do we know at the high schools or do we have a means of collecting how many of our students actually drive to school or how many parking spots are sold at the schools maybe that's more reasonable I was looking at Mr de Andrade back there to see but go ahead Dr Reed sorry well we have actually provided the number of parking slots I believe or we're in the middle
073of uh putting that together I think we had it prior to construction projects and then construction projects have adjusted some of the uh school parking lot Footprints um but that would be for those who park on the school grounds there are a lot of schools uh like many schools across the country right uh that don't have sufficient student parking and in some cases staff parking uh and so we have uh folks parking on side streets and local roads so um we can certainly get that information more definitively for you we know 130,000 roughly of our roughly 183,000 students are on the bus so that roughly leaves 50,000 that are either walking biking flying or uh driving in some way well we're going to have flying cars I think very shortly but um you know skipping
074hopping however they get there but that's about 50,000 left that are either driving or going other than you know motorized Transportation I think reviewing that data would be a good Next Step as well because it informs what are our goals here because we can't just work in darkness around this we kind of have to have a measure for Success um the last thing the next and last thing I want to share is it's really difficult at the school site and you talked you heard about it at TJ when you have parents that are speeding when you have folks making illegal u-turns School staff cannot enforce that and that's the frustration I think you hear from Miss and because we we can't be at this alone but yet we know that's the issue that is contributing
075to the safety issues around those schools so it's just making sure we have someone who could be supportive of this and also just for the rest of the conversation one of the things that we wanted to get out of this when this was brought forward as a follow-on motion a couple of years ago is that we would have a regular look at this information rather than just being responsive or reactive to urg ENT and catastrophic situations I I see this being embedded in el11 as a regular review I see this being part of the regular CIP cycle and it was just to allow us to be really consistent Mrs Anderson one of the things and Dr Anderson in Prior work that I've done we actually had an annual meeting with stakeholders I know we have
076a ski committee here that's um a Cooperative committee between the county and the school division I think having a similar Arrangement that would focus on this topic might allow us to have actually if you will an itemized like we could bring our list of hot areas in the county and other stakeholders and if we brought that to the table and all agreed that these are the 20% that we could address this year I think we could make steady progress Mr mline for his original like for he gets the full 3 minutes that's okay I will be tur uh if possible um so I appreciate this um this approach um but and it's you you've done what you were tasked with so I appreciate that but it is very much an inward-looking approach um and I
077think what we need is um to accompany this an outward-looking approach um and frankly we need a countywide public awareness campaign um you know in my um in my role as a PTA leader uh uh for two years I had worked um with my elementary school to do things like add a win comatic add um speed bumps at um crossing guards at the school uh and um after two years of advocacy work all V do did for us was repaint a crosswalk um it's really appalling um and um to be very honest the supervisors were not very helpful um they um they have all this additional um transportation funding and the excuse they use is that well every school has the same issues so we can't do it for every school um so I think
078the the bottom line is that schools are bringing forward concerns already um and there more concerns will come from this um but the folks outside of FCPS just aren't listening so I think that goes to um what um Dr re just said is that we do need a countywide um uh focus on this whether it's a um committee or something else um and I think we need to do um everything we can uh once we get the results of this to compile all our needs present them to the Board of Supervisors um and begin holding V do to account thanks okay Miss May and we have time for one last GoBack yeah I I continue to say we cannot normalize that schools that education professionals and operational staff are responsible for the assessment management and
079resolution for safe routes to schools I see value in having base level data about status and needs but we need to have the Avenue of raising immediate needs in a in a thoughtful way and that's a CU and I know you all love your cues but um I'd just like to give you a a smattering of the issues I've been dealing with for the Last 5 Years Flint Hill Elementary first had an issue in 2012 with a crossing guard being hit in the crosswalk still to this date nothing of significance has been done there's been some movement most recently because the delegates stepped in floores elementary speeding the county now has the authority to change the speed zone I have asked for it to be changed nothing has happened Sunrise Valley Elementary the county has
080rights over the um roadways the sidewalks are not ADA Compliant it's a dangerous curve I've raised it to the county to the Reston Association nothing Forest Edge Elementary I've asked for a crosswalk to be painted totally in the County's jurisdiction hasn't happened Wolf Trap Elementary took seven years to make bu R be safe and that effort was largely driven by myself and my neighbors as residents getting grants and and seeking accountability so this is the kind of stuff that residents are asking us about um the police you said um Mr Li the police are the only ones with the responsibility the authority to stop traffic and yet the county proposed in January 2024 to cut all the crossing guards in the town of Vienna which I represent in as recently as August 2024 proposed to
081have scps be responsible for managing the crossing guard program across the entire County now I don't know the status of that I believe that's changed but I am concerned that I see efforts by the county to push their responsibility for Road and pedestrian safety onto Fairfax County Public Schools in my view the strategies presented here today are an effort to fill a void left vacant for too long by the county and the state ultimately though I want to know what is the flow of information from FCPS to the county and state for them to get things fixed when we raise them and have accountability for it to be [Music] done Miss Mar you bring up a good point and in my brief time here I have my own frustrations often with where we are with
082a project I think we can do better on that from our end so that we can report out better and I heard some ideas I think from Miss Lady um I was keying in to an idea that she had to provide me with a better tracking mechanism because email is not a sufficient way to follow up on whether you are asking for something or a Community member so I take that as a point of action for me and I think like Dr Reed said I think a real pathway forward is to to more routine and regular sitd Downs with the main stakeholders in this I take that for Action myself and last but not least Miss sear Heiser um for her initial thank you and I'll be quick I've been listening to the conversation and
083I agree with many of the things my colleagues have said and I'm wondering um Dr re you touched on this but I'm wondering after we do our assessment we've had shortterm joint committees with the Board of Supervisors on specific topics um specifically the last one was around um funding for facilities so I'm really wondering if there's a way that we could after we do our assessment once we have the data as we have something to kind of go to the Board of Supervisors with regarding um data around specific issues and needs whether it's possible at that point to propose doing some sort of joint committee or maybe starting those conversations now about a Joint Task Force perhaps to look at this because I mean I appreciate what we're doing I think we can do what
084we can but we are not able to mitigate all the traffic and safety concerns on our own and I know our County Partners want to work with us on getting this done so just a thought maybe those conversations can get started maybe from chair to chair just um some things I want to talk about and also you know I'm hearing from a lot of concerns from different residents in the bradic district about safety and walking routes I think um Mr Lambert you and I work together on assessing some walking with some sidewalks um towards Oak and some of the other schools but I'm wondering how we can sort of proly communicate to our community here's kind of what's under our purview here's um what we can do you know here's sort of a process for
085lifting up concerns you I know many people were surprised during this recent snowstorm right that the sidewalks don't get shoveled that you it's responsibility the homeowner if there isn't a homeowner or renter in certain sidewalks it's you know it's kind of up to the community to do it so I'm just wondering if there's two pieces one conversation about some sort of Joint Task Force with the Board of Supervisors um and two whether there is some sort of sort of proactive Communications plan to help better you know inform our community what we do and what we can do yes ma'am I I think that um both are critical I think we have to have a Joint Task Force joint committee I would hope it's a committee that has the authority to act um because I think
086that this reviewing these hazardous locations and identifying high priority locations and moving on them is critical um honestly that's what we were doing all last week with v do is we were providing lists of uh parts of the county that we were receiving updates on about the uh most concerning roads we were providing it and we were working through that list the team was together um with v do and our staff and I think we can be when we're more strategic we can get things moving more quickly I think the communication around who has what part um would also be a great outcome of such a task force because I think there's not a shared understanding in some cases of who responsibility certain locations are um and then thirdly I think the ability to share
087information across um departments and across entities is very important um I know the team when we talked with v do uh Sunday afternoon actually talked about how important it would be even for them to have our bus routes um so that way they would know which roads specifically bus routing was critical for notwithstanding other routing that uh community members need they already have hospitals and so forth but I just think that the more information we share the common purpose um we're all using the same resources and the more efficient we can be with those resources and clearly we communicate them I think it u minimizes a lot of consternation which leads to conflict well maybe it's a Joint Task Force with v do the for you know the county and us I don't know but
088it feels like there's you know a room to have better processes for information sharing better you know better communication to our community and um you know room to sort of have more collaboration because I think we all we sharing right we all have the same goal we want our kids to be able to get to school safe we want our community and to be safe but how do we better work together on the different pieces and understand kind of where our lanes are and other people's lanes are and you know work together to have the best outcome if it would be helpful I will ask the team to draft a plan for how we might Envision that better working relationship and we can provide that in a Friday letter to the board and have a
089follow-up conversation about who initiates that with who I think from the work uh work side Department side we want to we have a high interest in doing that um I think your point around the chair tochair contact or however uh we go down that road I think we can come back with a plan for your consideration that would be great thank you okay so we are about 10 minutes behind schedule at this point but that's okay um we're going to take a quick five minute recess but really five minutes so we'll be back here at 11:45 to start the CIP conversation okay welcome back we are in our next portion of the work session and let's just check our time here uh we are due to have this discussion until 1: p.m. when we will
090break for a short recess for lunch until 1:30 and then reconvene so we uh let me just uh one second okay so today we are focusing on the $8.5 billion in public infrastructure Assets in Fairfax County for which this board is responsible these of course are the facilities spaces managed by Fairfax County Public Schools for prek-12 and adult instruction and the Public's use of these spaces for a range of events which last year alone in 2024 totaled 500,000 public events our facilities are used 7 days a week from morning until night for essential community services that include public education Athletics Performing Arts academic competitions distribution of Medical Care food and public services private athletic leagues and events religious services and more it's critical to recall that it is the voter approved public Bonds on the
091annual November general election ballot that pay for the majority of facilities in FCPS not the annual real estate taxes which provide the annual operating budget of over 4 billion do this Capital Improvement program or CIP covers the array of critical topics regarding our facilities including Building Maintenance and renovation which includes safety upgrades and new construction school capacity programming and boundaries and environmental sustainability to name a few the board previously during the review of the CIP in 2024 publicly directed the superintendent through two follow-on motions to provide the board information about future strategies that could further economize the public funds used for FCPS facilities this includes exploring new ways to generate Revenue using swing spaces to decrease construction time and alternative delivery methods for projects such as public private part parnerships power purchase agreements construction management
092at risk and design build and reducing leasing expenses while we do have copious information in response to these follow-on motions the scope of today's work session will be on reviewing and improving the CIP document approving the CIP is critical because this sets in motion the bond work that the Board of Supervisors must do on a timeline that runs through spring for completion to place it onto the November general election ballot additional work sessions will be scheduled for us to more meaningfully review the details and possibilities of those follow-on motions as this is ongoing work so with that I will turn it over to our chief of facilities Miss Janice samansky or to our superintendent Dr Michelle Reed thank you Miss Marin and this is a really an epic meeting um it's our annual look at
093our future fiveyear uh plan and our facilities as you mentioned Miss Marin are actually a significant uh part of what we're stewards for um the amount of square footage is uh incredible and the uh projects needs Renovations are significant outlays both of Staff time uh and resources the schools are the center of our communities so it's my pleasure to turn it over to miss samansky um I think that one of the things we really want to stress is that this is about the approval for this 5-year plan there are many other topics that are connected um and we hope to have other uh conversations uh and work sessions perhaps scheduled to address some of the other um nuanced topics that traditionally have not been a part of our uh annual CIP process but anyhow I
094would like to turn over to miss samansky uh to share the presentation thank you thank you Dr Reed and good morning today we are going to cover a summary presentation on the proposed Capital Improvement program for fiscal year 20 26 through through 2030 next slide I'd like to provide an introduction and overview of my Department's offices and responsibilities the department of Capital Improvements and planning is responsible for facility planning Services design and construction and Property Management the work includes the production of the CIP School enrollment projections by grade level and attendance area adjustment recommendations and proposes in conjunction with other offices in the Department bond referenda to fund required Capital Improvements design and construction services is responsible for the design and construction services for new school facilities addition to existing schools renewals or Renovations Capital
095improvement work orders and the purchase installation and relocation of temporary classroom facilities the office of facility management is responsible for the building and grounds maintenance services facility infrastructure repair replacement and sustainability next slide facilities has responsibility for the planning and design and construction and maintenance of 8.7 billion in public infrastructure Assets in Fairfax County I want to emphasize that that is a billion with a B these public assets consist of over 28 million square fet across over 200 buildings in the county for perspective sccps has more than the equivalent of four pentagons of space and if you didn't know the Pentagon is the world's second largest office build building at about 6.5 million square ft next slide facilities goes just beyond education our facilities are also Community assets that serve as most the public meeting
096spaces in the county in many cases spaces in our facilities provided are provided free of charge to organizations such as homeowner associations 4 clubs scouting groups employee organizations and cultural and Civic groups in addition 500,000 events occurred in school facilities beyond the school day instruction annually for some perspective if every facility held the same number of events that's over 2500 events per facility that would be 48 events per week at each School 169 of our schools and centers are also used as polling places for elections 142 schools serve as sites for Fairfax uh sack program and 91 religious and cultural organizations use our facilities for regularly scheduled events next slide we want to highlight the policies and regulations that govern facilities work in the formation of the CIP this full list is included in the
097regulation section of the CIP on pages 15 through 17 we do want to make special note of policy and regulation 8110 that establishes procedures for the 5-year Capital Improvement program planning also important to highlight is policy 8258 this policy dictates a 20 to 25 year renovation cycle and lastly I would like to highlight policy 8542 which is our policy on environmental stewardship and initiatives these policies all govern and guide our work next slide all right so now that we have covered some background on facilities as a whole I'd like to talk about this year's proposed CIP next slide please a capital Improvement program or CIP is a planning and fiscal management tool used to coordinate the location timing and funding of projects over the 5 years the cash flow is submitted to the County for
098incorporation into the larger Fairfax County CIP our CIP includes an annual review of student membership and Facilities data to identify capital projects newly identified needs are included in the estimated schedule of capital projects for the next 5 years and the capital cash flow tracks the funding allocation for these projects please note facilities work reaches just beyond reaches Beyond just the 5-year cash flow of major capital projects well that is what the CIP covers facility also performs projects ranging from reactive and preventative maintenance major maintenance projects such as painting classrooms or replacing flooring and larger infrastructure projects examples of that might be an HVAC uh equipment replacement or replacing a roof next slide please the CIP is a zero to 5year look ahead but it's informed by longer range planning this graphic shows how FCPS collaborates
099with Fairfax County government on the review of countywide residential development and growth within and Beyond the 5 years to identify the impacts on school facilities FCPS monitors new residential developments during the plan Amendment review process for the Fairfax County comprehensive plan and the zoning review process for zoning applications and considers new residential development that is actively under construction in the 5-year student membership projections in the FCPS CIP as they may potentially contribute to student membership growth within the next 5 years an example of this long-range planning initiative with the Fairfax County government is the acquisition of the Silverline Elementary School site the need for a School site was identified by FCPS as part of the comprehensive planned review of land Unit A within the dullas Suburban Center a School site was recommended by FCPS and
100was recently dedicated as part of a zoning application next slide please the CIP includes September certified student membership division-wide and by individual schools the total certified student membership decreased by 422 students from 18,8 6 students in school year 2324 to 18,38 students in school year 2425 the primary factors that contribute to changes in student membership include the birth to kindergarten ratio the migration of students in and out of FCPS and the transfer of students from their base school to their attending schools this data is included at the end of this presentation as reference on pages 27 through 32 in the CIP and on the facility membership dashboards online the CIP includes 5-year student membership projections which show a decrease in student membership for the 5-year period on page 36 the student membership is projected to
101decrease by 2,66 students so that's going from 180,0 384 students in school year 2425 to 177,00 78 students in school year 2930 as best practice FCPS uses the cohort survival ratio methodology as a basis for the student membership projections the cohort survival ratio methodology compares the proportion of students in one grade that progresses to the next grade then historical cohort survival ratios are considered and applied to those ratios to project for students in the next school years as a reminder for the student membership projections only new residential development that is actively under construction are considered as they may potentially contribute to membership growth within the next 5 years and as I shared we do work with Fairfax County government and review planning amendments and Zoning applications for potential new developments in the pipeline and we
102update the student member projections every year to capture any new residential developments that may have become then active can you stay on that past slide please so some of the factors that relate to this projected decline are we are seeing bursts continuing to decrease the 23 Fairfax County demographic report projects a decrease in the school age population so that's ages 5 through 19 in Fairfax County the same report also projects that housing growth will be primarily be multif family housing units which generally yields fewer students compared to single family in town homes and overall we're seeing Elementary uh and middle school student cohorts decreasing every year currently the largest student cohorts in school year 2014 25 are in 11th and 12th grade and again I just would like to stress that with the recent Decline
103and ongoing changes in student membership it is very important to highlight that projections are updated every year in the FCPS CIP to reflect the changing uh conditions continuously next slide please thank you this uh this table shows the accuracy of the 5year student membership projections from previous cips which includes the CIP 2017 through 21 to CIP fiscal year 25 through 29 compared to the actual student membership for school year 2021 to this school year division-wide the columns represent which CIP the student memberships projections are from whereas the rows represent which school year the students membership is coming from each CIP includes fiveyear projected years which is why you will see one to five projection accuracy percentages in each column the projection accuracy is calculated by dividing the projected student membership by the actual student membership
104for each school year a projection accuracy of greater than 100 means the projected student membership was greater than the actual student membership for that school year and a projection accuracy less than 100 means the projected student membership was less than the actual student membership for that school year the one-year projection accuracy for CIP fiscal year 25 through 29 which was last year's CIP the student membership projection for school year 25 425 was 101% so that's off by 1% thank you types of capital and pro uh types of capital projects in the CIP include new school construction repurposing projects capacity enhancements facility Renovations and potential sites and which are defined here on this slide next slide please so next I would like to provide a brief overview of current and completed projects in the CIP next
105slide this includes but is not limited to the renovations of Louise Archer Elementary Wakefield Forest Elementary Oak Hill Elementary and the capacity enhancement at Justice High School FCPS also has many projects in the CIP that are actively under construction this includes but is not limited to the renovations of Falls Church High School Mosaic Elementary Bonnie Bray Elementary and drainville Elementary next all the projects we just saw under construction each have their own project page on our website FCPS is implementing a standard engagement and communication plan for large capital projects lastly I'd like to provide a brief update on one of the unique projects that was improved in a previous CIP a division-wide effort to install security vestibules at schools the project is organized into five rounds totaling 93 locations at a projected cost of over
106$22 million this has not been fully funded round one for 19 schools is in construction will be and will be substantially complete by the end of January round two which is 20 schools and that's in permitting these are anticipated to go out to bid in the spring with the majority of construction commencing over in the summer months round three is in design and rounds four and five are to be determined dependent on funding next I'd like to move on to environmental sustainability highlights of FCPS facilities are shown on this slide and include get to Green energy conservation and solar energy projects we have 149 schools registered with the National Wildlife Federation EOS Schools USA program we are planning over 800 trees between 2024 and 2025 to increase our tree canopies and reduce heat island effect
107since 2013 we have reduced energy expenditures by approximately 97 million and reduced Greenhouse gas emissions by 46% and we now have nine solar power purchase agreements underway on Elementary School roofs going on to Net Zero Energy active design and construction projects maximize Net Zero Energy ready where possible to prepare for future renewable energy installations this might include structural loading on a roof to allow for future stolar to be installed and future projects starting in FY 26 and Beyond include CIP funding for major energy reduction measures to gain possible on-site Net Zero ready such as uh photovoltaics um arrays and ground Source heat pumps for our mechanical system such as geothermal thank you now i' next I'd like to review Capital Project funding so this slide shows an overview of facilities funding and their sources funding
108sources for the capital projects is shown at the very top of the chart and they're the general obligation Bond as voted on by Resident in the biannual school bond referendum the annual limit for General obligation Bond funding has increased over time the most recent increase is a result of a joint CIP committee back in 2021 this increased the annual amount allocated to $230 million per year in fy2 and Beyond it should be noted that the referendum for schools is biannual and we're in the odd years so 23 25 27 Etc as a result of escalation in the construction industry FCPS continues to monitor these costs as they relate to the FCPS capital projects and pipeline additional funds that impact the FCPS uh facilities team are also here on the slide and so that includes our
109operating funds funds from the Fairfax County Board of Supervisors for infrastructure management the capital syncing fund and propers but again just just to stress the majority of it is represented in that Capital Bond project row so this slide summarizes the capital projects identified in the Capital Construction cash flow within the next 5 years these include new construction of dunloring Elementary and Silverline elementary schools with silver line being identified for planning design to begin in the very last year in 2030 capacity enhancement and relocation of three existing modular buildings and the majority of the CIP cash flow includes the renovation of 22 schools including 18 Elementary two middle and two high schools looking within the next 10 years the capital projects included are new construction Andor repurposing of Western High School route one which is also
110known as Pinewood Lakes Early Childhood Center Tyson's Elementary pet Hills and Virginia Hills Renovations include two elementary schools from the existing renovation queue I would also like to note with the countywide boundary review underway and work on going towards a new renovation queue we will want to understand the full effects of those efforts and the relationship to any outy work and we will continue to monitor so this slide is a summary of funding for the current identified projects we just saw on the previous Slide the total 5-year funding requirement is approximately 1.4 billion and projects have been scheduled based on the bond funding limit so the total is the anticipated Bond sales coming to FCPS for the next five and 10 years as it currently stands approximately 384 million is currently funded by bonds and
111approximately 1 billion is unfunded and would be included on future Bond referenda the total 10-year requirement is approximately 2 2.6 billion approximately 429 million is funded by bonds and approximately 2.1 billion is unfunded and would be included on future Bond referenda all right so to this point I have reviewed the proposed CIP and as you can see we are prioritizing based on available resources and we feel like we are doing the best we can with the resources that we have so at this point we would like to change gears a little bit and I would like to share some analysis we've comp uh completed related to Future funding needs so the previous circles shared a total of funding anticipated over the next 10 years scheduled based on current Bond funding limitations this slide however shows
112the total amount broken down by funded and unfunded over the next 10 years if FCPS were to catch up on renovating facilities older than 25 years and having all future work on a 20 year 25y year renovation cycle per Schoolboard policy 8258 the total amount required would be 14.4 billion of which 428 million is currently funded from Bond referendum already approved and um that means 13.9 billion is unfunded that is an additional 1.4 billion dollars needed per year for the next 10 years so miss manky I just want to pause we looked at this slide together and debated whether to put this in the presentation or not and I just I feel like the board and our community really need to understand this is what it would take to actually because of cost escalation and
113deferring and deferring to actually get back on simply a 25e cycle so I just appreciate the time it took to create this slide and it's a significant slide um for many purposes so I know we're going through this I just want to make sure um we both talk about where we are and then what would it actually take to get where we want to be responsibly not even like this isn't particularly aspirational this would simply get us back to where we've traditionally been as a county and School Division is that correct absolutely that's correct this is intended to give you a sense of scale because please note we use CIP estimates in today's dollars which is not even adjusted for inflation so this number could even change depending on the timing of funding future construction
114costs and the commencement of actual work so again the intent is just to demonstrate the investment required to renovate aging schools and bring the current queue down to 25 years in today's dollars next slide please so staying on this topic of funding the data on this chart Compares Capital Construction funding per existing square footage compared to other divisions limited to the DMV where the Costa Regional of construction is most comparable to FCPS market conditions comparing funding per square foot helps understand the size of facility portfolio at a minimum obligated for renovations against available funding we included divisions approximately onethird the size of FCPS are greater as most comparable to FCPS is design and construction program of the eight Public Schools listed above FCPS ranks last with a funding per square foot of $854 the average
115funding per square foot of School Division shown here is $21.80 because FCPS is such a large school system even increasing funding per square foot by an additional $358 to bring FCPS up to the second lowest rank school system on this chart that would mean um an annual bond amount or alternative funding would would be needed to be increased by 97.5 million annually that's an additional $195 million per 2-year referendum cycle next slide so to provide a little bit of an update on the marketplace last year we did see a large increase in projected costs for Capital construction projects to accommodate for Rising inflation fairfax's prev wailing prevailing wage requirements and supply chain challenges you know in response active design and construction projects were budgeted in the CIP using a very design specific cost estimate and
116so with that we are happy to report that all CIP projects that have bid since the last CIP have had good Market competition and have come in on or under budget with the last three bids averaging 12% below estimates so we've been able to build up our construction reserve and value engineering or reducing scope has not been required on projects at the time of bid we are updating our Construction assumption assumptions annually to keep on top of market trends and they are reflected in our budgets so like other Market sectors though projects do still remain more costly than in years past however the updated estimates and practices have allowed for more realistic planning of the capital pipeline while the bond increased to $230 million annually in 2025 though I think it's fair to suisee that
117it's not sufficient enough to cover the cost increases and so not only is the renovation renovation cycle impacted but there are other impacts to the facilities program as well and so that Segways to this slide uh this slide provides a breakdown of the cost of major maintenance and infrastructure replacement requirements and this is done by type of replacement for the next 5 years of the assets currently tracked the backlog stands at deferred maintenance and upgrades if the funding is not increased the backlog will continue to outpace the replacement and so to demonstrate the backlog impacts FCPS we reviewed historic Trends over the last 10 years to determine an estimated average rate of 88.4% growth of backlog annually next slide and so we use this historic data on the previous slide to project over the next
11810 years looking to the Future the estimated backlog should current resources and funding remain constant FCPS projects the rate of growth increasing from 8.4 to 10% with a longer renovation cycle and the cost of construction continuing to rise the result is a projected backlog of over 635 million in the next 10 years and this is for current tracked assets uh next The Joint environmental task force or Jet's mission was to join the political and administrative capabilities of the county and school system to proactively address climate change and environmental sustainability to meet the Jets 50% reduction by the 2040 Milestone we're estimating 1.8 billion worth of facilities projects that improve energy reduction are needed to meet that 2040 date and this I have to copy it is a low-end estimate because it assumes work not covered
119by Renovations and current projects shown in Blue uh they would be done via an energy savings performance contract these contracts typically have a shorter upfront cost and the remainder is funded by financing anticipated Energy savings so examples of that might be HVAC projects LED lighting installations uh building envelope improvements uh and commissioning our HVAC systems and building Automation and system controls uh so without the additional funding we believe this 2040 milstone will not be met all right so with that all being said we' now like to review the next steps for the CIP so this slide shows the timeline of the proposed CIP today is the work Schoolboard work session and public hearing the school board is scheduled to take up action on the proposed CIP on February 6 2025 and once adopted FCPS staff
120will work with the County government staff to incorporate into their CIP for release on February 18th okay and then let lastly we want to close on this we want to acknowledge that in addition to the CIP facilities has many initiatives to present to the school board for discussion in the future and so that's including but not limited to our facility condition assessment the new renovation queue we're building uh work on public private Partnerships reduction of leasing expenses potential new swing space opportunities policy revisions and new procurement options uh athletic Capital replacement cue student membership projections development review of profit and student yield formulas uh new environmental and sustainability initiatives and and even elevators and so moving forward I'd suggest that we work strategically in Partnership to continue the discussion we look forward to working with
121the school board on the best path forward for these important topics and so with that today we appreciate the board's support and advocacy for our work um thank you for your time and attention and I'm available for any questions thank you Miss samki so um we are going to begin round one um May the May the fighting begin so we have um uh three minutes per in initial intervention so I see um Dr Anderson followed by Mr [Music] Dunn that was a lot first of all thank you this is always a huge um component and I appreciate appreciate the level setting that both you and Miss Marin did at the beginning of this session which is to talk about how important this work is this is these are buildings that are used by our entire
122Community pretty much 24 hours a day and so there's a lot of stake here for not just students which we know that's the reason why we're here but we've expanded beyond that which is also what causes me a little bit of a worry we've spent quite a bit of time talking how important this is and on the day that we are offering the CIP to the public we're also having the public hearing that makes it a little bit tight for people to get themselves together to come and speak with us and then we are voting on this at the very next meeting so the timetable causes me some concern um but I do want to spend a little U my first round just talking about funding if you could just talk a little bit um
123cuz I miss what you said in terms of how many more dollars would we need in the bond in order to get the extra $3 per square foot did you say 97 that is correct to add an additional $358 per square foot and again we're 28 million square fet so when you add all that up that's another 97.5 million annually because we go for the bond referendum every two years you double that right and it's $195 5 million per 2-year referendum and again just to clarify that's to bring us up to the second lowest ranked school when we were comparing against other DMV funding I also want to point out another number the current unfunded is 13.9 billion to get us back up to that 25 year renovation cycle um bringing up every school to
12425 years or younger and then projecting out a 25e cycle moving forward sure thank you clearly I I mean I've said this ad a I'm a lot of ways our needs have greatly outpaced our resources and I don't see a Universe where we just look to the Board of Supervisors to help close that Gap can we bring that Circle back up please that seems almost unrealistic Le it's daunting in order to address so I want to start talking about what are the baby steps we can take into chipping away at this so the first piece is increasing the bond ask can you walk us through the process where we can engage with our funders in in order to get to the 425 that you've um recommended in Li of the 230 million that we have
125currently so I believe the last time the bond limit increased uh was the result of a joint CIP discussion between the Fairfax County school board and the Fairfax County Board of Supervisors this was last done in 2021 and the changes we're just now feeling it was for an implementation of an increase to 230 for fiso year 25 and outy year moving forward and so I I see some space for maybe for us to revitalize that committee so we can engage in this discussion um I'm going to skip over the P3 conversation for right now even though this is part of this we have to look at many different ways in order to close this Gap because we're not getting a check for 14.4 billion from any from any entity um what I'd like to talk
126about is when you discussed the backlog um I forget what chart this was and the exponential impact of having the Deferred maintenance onto the system this is slide 30 thank you could should we be considering using a year bond just to handle the 244 million so that we prevent from further expend further losses yeah this question has come up a lot internally amongst staff in fact when we were developing the CIP proposed cash flow we ran a scenario that said what if we only had 80% of the funding and we dedicated Another 20 of it to doing things like this like infrastructure replacements the result was just very very very dramatic for that renovation cycle we're already over almost doubled um where we should be per School Board policy so while that is an option
127we just have to remember there's very big and unintended consequences to doing that I'll take a go back that was my time okay thank you on to Mr Dunn uh thank you um how does our asset portfolio of 200 buildings with value of 8.7 billion compared to our peer School divisions in the DMV uh region and nationally yeah I would probably direct ourselves back up to slide uh 27 please so we did look at the funding other school divisions and the DMV got and we compared it to how big their school sizes were so then you could really see how much money they were receiving compared to how big they were in terms of how much stewardship of square footage they had right so we are definitely by far and large the biggest school system
128in terms of square footage so you can't really actually see the total sizes here it's more about that ratio um I think the next comparable is probably Montgomery County Public Schools they're in the 20 plus million square footage range um DC Prince William and Lowden they're all more in that third to half half range so I can definitely provide more but we are by far and large the largest around here okay what what I was trying to understand is we have 200 school buildings right and is that the right number is that more than our peers or is that on Target and it seems from the very small font total schools at the bottom of each of those columns it looks like we're about where we should be um in your opinion should we be
129looking to consolidate or reduce the number of asset that's you know merge schools together so we have a smaller number of uh buildings that we have to manage well again I I think that's a bit of an apples and oranges comparison we are geographically spread out we have the highest enrollment of all of these uh divisions as well so I think we would need to do further analysis to understand if that's the case um again for example District of Columbia Public Schools their schools are much more closely compacted so if you were to consolidate a school it wouldn't be that much of a geographic impact so again just a point to say I think that would need further exploration before you just stack up these School divisions side by side should FCPS be looking to
130negotiate with developers asset swaps trading existing School sites for perhaps new schools that developers could build at different sites you know so they might we might have schools in attractive Loc loc for new housing or new condo buildings to be built right so is that something that you see in other school divisions and something that we should consider uh not something I've seen personally except for maybe one instance in DC where part of a parcel was split off for uh Workforce housing so I do know there is some instances out there um personally haven't experience that but definitely something I think we would need to come back with more information before being able to sop talk about how that would work at FCPS uh so so there's lots of priorities right um and if nothing's
131a priority then then you don't accomplish anything at the end of the day between maintenance backlog infrastructure backlog and school renovation construction those are three different buckets what from uh you know architect facilities perspective what should be our highest priority I think the biggest Gap is the construction right I mean one it costs the most so it's got the highest barrier to entry and I think when that is also not um properly funded that's where you get the trickle down effect of the maintenance backlog if buildings are being more holistically looked at and renovated and modernized the backlog the energy reduction some of the other things where we shared that funding Gap will start to close up because when you take the time to modernize a full facility you're bringing all that thing back up
132to a certain bar and so when we close that really big daunting red circle the good news is is the other circles and those other charts um you close those gaps as well so School renovation should take priority over maintenance and and infrastructure is that right again if I were to tackle one of those if I could fix one of those things that is what I would fix it's the most costly thing to fix but it will have again positive impacts on other are is so yes uh slide 26 uh the circle uh of 14 billion I don't understand uh this Slide Can you can you explain um how you calculated this uh and how does it compare to slide 27 because you mentioned 97.5 million to get to you said the second lowest school
133system which is Lowden on this chart so um if if if you get $97 million per year on slide 27 does that get us to 25 years no it does not so this slide here shows us to get back to school board policy for a 25-year renovation cycle and this is the cost it would take and then we said hey that's a lot of money let's go see what other schools in the DMV are doing so the next slide if you don't mind flipping over the next slide just does a comparison saying hey are these other school systems around around experiencing the same thing are they receiving the same proportion of funding and we can say the answer is no they are receiving more comparative to how much they have to maintain and take care
134of um so we were just sort of playing out some scenarios to give you a sense of scale to say hey even if we were to meet ourselves up to uh Howard County or Lowden County you know and get us up to where their proportion of funding is compared to their size that is still another $195 million per Bond referendum so again the whole point is just to demonstrate a sense of scale and a sense of um resource needs and not from our compared to our own Schoolboard policy and compared to what other uh School divisions are doing I'm sorry just to clarify 97 million gets us to $263 not all the way to $ 52.75 no it only gets us to the second lowest uh chart on here which is $122 okay okay um
135well that that's the lowest the second you keep saying second lowest but that's loud in at 1263 oh I believe Howard County is $122 but so you mean the lowest not the second lowest well we're the lowest oh okay fair fair fair point okay so uh have you done a comparison of funding sources between these different School divisions and nationally because Maryland it's State Central funded as opposed to we get funded through bonds yeah and so we tried our very very best to do an Apples to Apples comparison for the Virginia schools we use the Wy numbers and that was looking at purely Bond um Geo Bond and pgo bond money not operating and then for the Maryland and DC schools we tried again just to look at their Capital funding so we tried to
136extract out all the operating funds what is unique about Maryland is their Capital funding it's a lot more of it's coming from the state level and a much smaller percentage is funded by the county level but again to be more fair in that comparison we weren't just going to purely look at their County Capital funding we did a a combination of capital uh funding for state and local for the Maryland schools but for at least our Virginia peers uh there could be a comparison looking at are they issuing some type of bond and Lowden and Prince William that we aren't issuing I mean that's that's my question are they making use of some fiscal instruments that we're not making use of or not making use of enough I would need to get back to you
137and and do some of that I had started we started some of that research to talk about each School Division and what their primary funding sources was would be it either bonds or taxes or a bigger proportion of operating fund so let me follow up with you because I think we have some of that preliminary information and and for slide 32 you referred you said that only reflected tracked assets uh what would it look like for untracked assets being included well it's a really good question we don't know what we don't know right and so I did want to caveat in this presentation it's for current tracked assets because that's what we know is out outdated or out aged uh as we embark on the facility condition assessment we are going to learn a lot
138more about our facilities and we'll now know have a whole another list of inventory of assets combined with what we currently know and so I would project that this number will increase after we've done that exercise okay thank you Mr D um we're gonna uh push rajna before Mr Moon um and then Mr Moon because rashna has to leave rajna thank you I really appreciate that and thank you for being flexible um with my schedule I wanted to kind of go back to some of the same slides that Mr Don was just speaking to so if we can go back to slide 27 um that would be great so to kind of pick up on some of the points here obviously the current Bond funding or the the best comparison you can get when I
139look at Montgomery County Schools I think that's a good comparison because their number of schools are slightly higher and their enrollments slightly lower but one of the things I think this really shows is in some ways why we have to do the boundary work we're doing right because we don't have the funds to build our way out of some of our capacity issues and I think that's you know this is a real data driven indicator of some of that work but even with that um I think I heard someone say to me well if the enrollment is going down why do we need funding for renovations and part of that is because you know it's not a oneto one for students in schools right there's a lot of common School spaces that need to be
140renovated regardless of whether the school is at 100% capacity or 90% or 110% and there's also the impact of the community use so Mr manky can you talk a little bit about I don't know if you've been able to kind of quantify the impact of community use fors the student use in the building in terms of wear and tear on the building I mean I think it's great that our schools are Community Resources and I want them to be those S community centers and hubs but I think it's important to sort of quantify the impact that has on our buildings sure and I I think you're right on and that's those actually one of the reasons we wanted to compare ourselves to other school divisions because schools as you know have just thousands and thousands
141of occupants um of all ages and and uses throughout the so the wear and tear on those facilities might be greater than that of an different typology so again that's why we found it very important to compare ourselves to other school divisions because they're dealing with the same maintenance needs the same use and abuse and the same use Around the Clock of their facilities um and so I do think that definitely needs to be considered when we think about the importance of making sure that these Renovations are done at a timely clip and that's why the majority of the CIP that were seen proposed focuses on those Renovations as that key component how much do you think you know I think we've been looking this last year and had some great conversations about unique funding
142sources or looking at being more creative around our Renovations do we look at partial Renovations instead of whole Renovations how much of those different things do you think can really impact when I look at these numbers right I look you know we're a little less than half of what Montgomery County is per square footage um you know and two-thirds of Lowden and significantly less than Prince William do you think there's a lot of space in looking at some of these things to get us from 42 to 25 like is that going to get from 42 to 35 right like how much can that really get to us and you may not have the answer but I'm trying to figure out how do we compensate for the difference in funding here yeah it's a good question
143I mean I definitely subscribe to leave no stone unturn so that's why we are continuously you know looking at ways to maximize our funding I think first it's important to do the best you can with the funding you have and we hope that we've demonstrated that I don't think there's an easy button where we're going to get a windfall and that red circle turns blue tomorrow so we do need to continue working together on addressing it uh for me the first step is sharing this presentation with you guys to hope that you and the public can understand just a sense of scale that you know you're right if we do something small to make a tweak and we get a little bit we don't expect overnight all the problems to go away this is going
144to be a long collaborative effort but I think the first step is understanding what we have and what we need for the future to move forward yeah I think on that note I wanted to S also talk about slide 30 and 31 when we talk about sort of the infrastructure replacement wi so not entire Renovations but major maintenance you know Athletics we've heard a lot about athletic fields Replacements I know I took K to Woodson to look at some of their athletic felds and I really appreciate your team's hard work in addressing the situations but I you know I think we need to point out that the backlog of maintenance is just going to grow coming out of either the I mean my question for you I guess you should ask is when you look
145at current backlog is this funding from Bond funding operation funds both like what are these numbers coming from or this just the total need like how much of this I guess are we paying for out of bond versus operation funds right now currently none so we had to make tough decision to say we only have the $230 million annually coming in we need to divert as much of that as possible into our renovations to keep that cycle down as low as we possibly can or the rate at growth of backlog is going to go way up so right now we are diverting most of that Bond money towards Renovations and all the major capital projects in the CIP I mean in order to renovate you do need good amount of capital up front so that's
146a barrier to entry that's why we need to divert and maintain those funds for those Renovations and then that does leave us in a challenging position where that 244 million has to come from somewhere else so a lot of that's funded from our operating funds um and the you know year end and year end from the county and I just bring that up because some of these numbers are very concerning right HVAC like we have to have functioning HVAC systems to have a comfortable learning environment and if you're saying our current backlog is $9 million that was um and in fiscal year 27 we only have1 19 almost $20 million right if I'm rounding up a little bit that concerns me um and say with athletic Capital asphalt major maintenance I know I hear a
147lot from the community about different maintenance issues at schools is one around cafeteria tables and and so the sharp edges and and how are we able to find some Creative Solutions to these and how I think the bigger question how are we communicating this I really appreciate this slide right but it's a lot of numbers like how are we telling the story of where we're at and where our funding is in comparison to surrounding jurisdictions and what creative things we are doing to address it and the impact on Lower um enrollment Visa what we really still need to do for our buildings and I think that may be my time I can't hear us if my time is up please tell me that is your time thanks rash so thank you and would you mind
148if just Janice has answer that question about the story behind and then I I'll be silent and thank you for letting me go early and just to make sure I answer you correct can you repeat the question I just think we need to and this may Dr Reed put together all of these pieces to kind of answer the community's concerns because I don't think there's a real good understanding and numbers are great but we need a story behind all of this makes sense I think that's something we'll have to continue to look again we just wanted to come and share the data that when we come saying hey sorry these elevators are broken or hey you're frustrated or Community is rightfully frustrated that we're not able to get something done we just want to show
149the true data and what would what we need and what's required to get there so I agree this like to me is like a good starting point and then being able to really articulate that in a meaningful story so people really understand the what's going on and what's going to continue to go on if something doesn't change thank you thank you Miss samansky Miss seore Heiser moiser I think we're also looking at um Miss Marin requested uh some very sort of clear slides for our presentation at the board meeting when we do the CIP uh presentation which will look a little different than this in-depth presentation at a work session so we are planning I think on those if you will storyboard ideas because I think the more people understand we all have a shared
150interest um in making progress on this particular area so thank you for that reminder thanks SE we'll try to get to through two more folks so we have um Mr Moon followed by Miss Lady thank you Mr mavan uh I have a lot of questions but I am limited by my first 3 minutes so uh I'm going to start with uh slide number 24 where we see about a billion dollars of unfunded need for the first 5 years does that mean that within the first five years based upon our proposed CIP we will only need $200 million per year that's correct so this slide shows what we currently have funded and from previous referendum and loaded into our projects and the red is what is currently unfunded but we anticipate getting in those future $230
151million annual um Bond sales so so again because we're going to be making presentation to the County Board of Supervisors uh what if they look at this and say that oh we are giving you $230 million per year and five times five is obviously going to exceed $1 billion of that one funding need for the for the first five years so you don't need any more money unless unless you are asking to be able to do 25e cycle correct where we'll need another $1.4 billion per year to get to that point is that yes is that fair yep you're you're exactly right so this doesn't show the need right it shows what we anticipate getting and we built out a CIP from what is currently approved what we anticipate receiving I think to your point
152that does not include a 25e renovation cycle the circle looks a lot bigger when you include what we actually need for our Schoolboard policy so so let me let's talk about the 20 year cycle I don't recall when that was adopted that 25e cycle as a school of the policy I I did take a quick look at a policy 8258 it seems to be it says notation at the bottom it says they was initially adopted back in 1989 and the last division was 2014 do you think that 25e cycle is a still good industry standard cycle um Let me let me say this because when I first got my car my first car it was a newest car it wasn't a brand new car at that time there was a long ago it was a
153long ago uh you know being able to you know drive a car a more than 100,000 miles was Unthinkable because that was considered to be a a a lot of a Myers on a car you know back then now hey driving for $200,000 is nothing unusual uh so it's a 25e cycle if there was adopted long ago 1980s is that a still good number I am trying to anticipate the questions that may come from supervisors and members in community a who may be concerned about such a huge funding that we are saying that we need yeah it's a great question and we go into a little bit more detail into the CIP and basically I would say I still agree with a generally a 25y year renovation cycle because many of the B major building
154components when you look at a typical HVAC equipment or typical major electrical equipment those manufacturer recommendations are still less than 25 years um even the year uh average lifespan on a roof on windows they're all 25 years are under so I do still feel like the 25 years is appropriate and that's a great time to go in and take um apart those older big pieces of equipment that's that's the whole point of renovating it's not just you know painting here and there it's it's doing a big overhaul on your building systems and and those currently to date are not exceeding 25 years oh that's fair uh since I only have 11 seconds left let me make a request whether you can do this uh because again anticipating potential questions do you have about data showing
155what renovation Cycles other school districts around us are using I I don't have that data and it is difficult we would really have to try to get it as apples apples as possible when I look at other programs such as our neighbors over at Lowden the majority of their school capital projects are like 100% brand new buildings so that might have a different life cycle that we would need to consider when comparing to our standard edpc Renovations I know I'm out of time so could you put me on go back okay added to go back uh gentle lady thank you um and thank you for this um I really appreciate um the slides in the red I think it's very telling right so you know it is it is our hope that we can get
156this story out uh to our communities and uh and taxpayers and folks who just don't seem to fully understand how limited we are in resources um because we often have community members coming and talking at uh board meetings around things that need to be done in certain facilities and so a deeper understanding is great um I have a couple questions um that I think are going to be tough uh one is I know we've never considered multif family units as producing a lot of children obviously I'm drainville where coats is situated and we miss the Mark um so I just I understand it predates you I just I'm just asking is that methodology going to be Revisited uh are there Lessons Learned because as I as a hearnen resident and also in drainville not just
157in Hern in other places the cost of living here is insane and so we're seeing a lot more families with children in apartments in condos in Tiny Town houses or multifamilies than we used to so is that methodology going to be Revisited yeah and I think it's important just to keep on top of that student yield formula when we think about future developments because you're right maybe 30 years ago the super luxury condo is now quite aged and so there's different Ames moving into those same um units right so I definitely think that's something I'd like to keep working again in those kind of next steps uh in partnership with the board to make sure that one you we're educating appropriately and that we're able to demonstrate the things that we're doing to keep on
158top of that okay thank you the other one is and this is slide 23 it's The Five-Year Plan versus the 10-year plan um again as a drainville resident I'm getting lots of questions about the urgency for a done luring versus the urgency for a Tyson's Elementary School um I don't believe we have the property for a Tyson's correct what we have in the CIP and I think I'm want to make sure I'm I'm articulating correct is a Silverline Elementary School and that's out in the coats boundary right I'm going towards Tyson's now oh okay I've moved and I'm looking at dun luring which is in the 5year and Tyson's Elementary School which is in the 10-year and what I'm understanding and what I'm observing it demographically in terms of construction is perhaps a higher need
159for Tyson's overdone luring in terms of timing so do we have the property for Tyson's have we have we purchased do we know where that's going to go I'm going to ask staff to chime in on that one because I don't believe we do the site has been identified and is owned by the Board of Supervisors it's uh off of I think Jones Branch drive it's currently where there's soccer fields yeah but it's not in possession of the school board identified but not possessed by the school board correct correct okay so I guess that's one of my questions because I'm hearing that a lot and and we're adopting a five-year and maybe this is something for me for next steps you know and again I wasn't here um you know I'm coming into my second
160year but it it seems to me that that needs to be looked at I also would like a lot more transparency about Western High School I can remember when I worked at chantilli I thought that was eminent I thought it was I I've been gone from that place now I'm in my 18th year gone and early in my tenure there they were talking about it so we don't have property for that our public needs to understand there is no property nor do we think we have the money to purchase a site is that correct that's correct we do not have a site identified at this time we have pushed that project out it's in the 10year but it's not slated to start any planning until fiscal year 2032 and and how many years has it
161been in the 10year cycle I can't say for certain but I do believe it's it's been in there for quite some time but always in that more 5 to 10 year range and never into the zero to five range with the actual cash flow thank you I just want to be transparent to our public to make sure they understand um the and you know again just to highlight what my colleagues have already highlighted and and you know hopefully we'll get maybe some some press around this story because when you look at slide uh 27 which Compares us to other districts and how much we're spending per square foot it's embarrassing it's embarrassing um and we've got to do something about it thank you perfectly timed it is 1:00 so we will reconvene again in 30
162minutes at 1:30 thank you all few minutes so we will continue our discussion of the proposed CIP for fiscal year 2630 uh we'll continue with our um list of speakers we have Miss Dixit followed by Miss St John cunning thank you so much for this presentation um my question is about uh the community use and I know this topic has come several times before um are we uh getting uh is is it like uh giving us any kind of profit and I believe it is it's a small profit but how can we capitalize on that um if you could give me some you know maybe some ideas and we can discuss that as a board are you talking about the current Community use fees paid by or coming into NCS with the county yes so
163overall uh the revenue I think you we had shared in the past uh that we do have some small amount coming in from that as a profit that's correct we do get a portion of the fees collected by Fairfax County I would recommend as a Next Step I'd like to connect with our chief operating officer whoever sees all the community use of facilities and really I think the first step would be understanding what are the total amount of fees brought in comparative to what fees FCPS specifically is receiving and then that is something that I've been working with him in the background to really understand yes we are receiving fees to pay custodial overtime but as we mentioned there is a big maintenance and long-term impact to this that I don't think previously has been
164Quantified and I think that is something I would also recommend we do next when we try to understand the true cost of you know operating these you know great services to our community and um I think as far as I know there is an insurance requirement from the community with the organization and that kind of hinders lot of organization nonprofits to utilize um FCPS facilities and we like to address that as a board I think few of us are interested to look into that um it will open up obviously more doors to getting additional Revenue uh because I know a lot of organizations are uh can pay a small fee to just uh do a meeting uh at at the school facilities and sometime they need a larger facility like cafeteria and right now they
165need a million doll Insurance to Avail that so that's one of the things we want to look at um the other thing I wanted to ask about the uh in facility maintenance uh piece of it uh we all talked about the large cycle and uh the backlog but uh have you ever done any sort of Outsourcing Contracting to contractors for building maintenance do we do that at FCPS and what's the percentage I would say the percentage is primarily full-time employees at FCPS right now we do contract out the more Specialty Services a great example of that is the snow because it's so unpredictable from year to year and we don't have that level of equipment and all the additional like specialty equipment needed that is something we contract out we contract out other services such
166as elevators again it's such a specific technical trade that we really need to rely on skilled vendors to assist us in that but the primary HVAC electric uh Plumbing structural that is primarily done inous we do have contracts on call when that maybe uh repair what whatnot becomes beyond our means and measures of being able to handle it we might bring it we do have some on call uh contracts to assist us as well uh so that's one thing I want you to address is that in federal government most of the ground maintenance uh is outsourced and um and there is a huge like basically people do the HVAC and plumbing electrical work uh ground maintenance so that's all included in that contract uh given to a certain contractor and it's and then they perform
167the work and I don't know the cost savings which comes to uh to with that that's something I've like to look at it um as uh and and the reason one of the things I've heard in in the last year we were I was in the audit committee was that um there was a lot of uh short like um the turnover or there was open vacant positions also at the some level and um when we saw talk about reactive fixing of things it the any shortage of Manpower can add add to the work workflow because now you have less employees to take care of that uh part so um I'm I'm personally interested in looking into how we can um see Contracting methods can be used to procure some of those services and if this
168was offset any cost thank you great thanks SEMA next we have uh Marcia followed by Kyle so just to follow up on what my colleague just asked in terms of community use in the million dooll insurance policy is there a differentiation in terms of when an HOA ised using say the library or the cafeteria for a meeting versus when there's a big event where there might be you know more risk uh in terms of what the insurance policy requirement would be because that has been brought up several times by community members and how that is creating barriers for smaller nonprofits um just to see if there is a differentiation in terms of why that insurance policy um next I'm going to move to when when we're talking about uh population projections and student projections when
169you're looking at that are you also looking at specific areas of growth like Geographic areas where there might be declines in one area and increases in another because when we're talking capacity and boundaries yes we do we do it by geographic area um we do look at that again starting with that cohort progression but then we look at a variety of other factors as well so one of them does include things like housing sales Census Data etc etc and we work closely with the county and that is done by geographic area because we do onee and fiveyear projections per school and we're looking at it down to the level of every school every grade level okay so then my next question that that I want to ask in terms of square footage and the amount
170of space per student for square footage when we're looking into to that do we also consider the needs of programming in a school for example the amount of students that are receiving IEP services or multilingual Services uh in terms of needing you might what I'm getting at is you may have a lower student population but a higher need population so you're going to need space square footage for pullouts yeah that's absolutely correct and I think that then goes kind of to that that question of overall capacity and utilization of a building and there's the pure design capacity how maybe an architect intended it 50 years ago but we all know schools have evolved and changed and we need to be reflective of the program so if a school has a particular program that might require
171more uh classrooms with smaller class sizes that is going to affect the overall available capacity in that school and that's something we look at very closely can you guys stop my time while it's being answered than I'm sorry no you're fine um and so looking at that true program capacity is something we do annually so we understand the true availability of the school every year given the programs and the needs of that uh School community and are you also looking into projections in terms of capacity for Academy space I do think that does that would influence right the overall um student projections it might influence uh schools in certain Geographic areas so yes we do consider programs and program changes and I would extend that toies as well and I know that we all desire
172and there is potentially a push for having Universal prek if we were to say we're going to have Universal prek what would the capacity be in our schools to handle that I think I would probably need to get more information to give you a sense of that and I also think that there's other uh initiatives happening right now in the county too with the countywide boundary so it will be good to know what is a potential from you know going through that exercise as we think about ways to expand pre opportunities okay and my last question is um because this has been raised in some of my schools where they are older schools and they've had a small addition but the entire School hasn't been renovated and they have articulated to me that because of
173that they they have been dropped down in the queue could you explain that process sure that's a great question it's good to clarify because currently we're at the very tail end of our current renovation queue and that's what is in the CIP that you see today right now we have going on uh we're developing a procurement for a facility condition assessment and part of that will also be as an outcome developing a new renovation queue and so as part of that scope we are looking at all schools it doesn't matter if it had a only a capacity enhancement and not a renovation or a renovation done 20 years ago or 30 years ago doing an overview of that facility condition assessment level sets our facilities so when we come with that new cue that first
174batch of schools we feel like we have all the right data across the board irregardless of what's happened in the past okay and just for and this has been brought up but just for the sake of the listening public our renovation queue has the time has increased and increased can you explain the reason for that sure I mean that is largely in part due to the overall rise of cost of construction and there's a variety of factors for that you know we came out of a global pandemic and we saw a sharp increase in supply chain and and subsequent um subsequent challenges and some of that you know it's never gone back down to pre-pandemic prices uh furthermore prevailing wage requirements were brought on by uh the county and FCPS a couple years ago and
175so there's a big cost implication to that we're still seeing inflation go up so on and so forth so you know with that being said I don't feel like anytime soon we're going to be going down to those lower prices and it's just something that we need to address okay great thanks uh Marcia next Kyle I want to go back to a point that uh miss lady brought up prior to us breaking for lunch um the dunloring project I want to clarify something we do have a School site in Tyson's I know that our name is not on the deed but that site is profer and I'm old enough to remember the Tyson's comp plan discussions and when this was done it was very clear at the time and the Board of Supervisors expectation at
176the time was a School site in Tyson a walkable School s side in Tyson and and in our own document we show it in our inventory list and it's a 7 Acre Site so I want to put that out there for the public we do have a profer land en tyon for an elementary school that was the expectation when this comp plan was done um that being said doveet tailing into dun lauring if correct me if I'm wrong the point of the dunloring project was to absorb capacity as a result of growth in the Tyson's area correct correct so if you look at the four schools that around dun luring right now based on our numbers they're showing a 1,27 seat deficit in the 2930 school year excess yeah excess yeah excess not deficit Surplus
177there you go a 1,27 seat Surplus based on our projections in this document and that will be around the same time that this new school opens which is dumping another 950 seats so simple math shows nearly 2,000 seat Surplus I I'm I'm kind of struggling with this guys I'll be honest because when I look at that but I look at these maps in this document showing capacity issues across the county I'm having a hard time with 86 million doll I I really am um and if the point is to absorb Tyson's capacity why aren't we putting the school in Tyson's why are we putting it 3 miles south and I've driven that road along enough to know 3 miles on that road is a long time so I I'm really struggling with the dling project
178um I I I'm looking forward to some more information hopefully coming back to the board we just got a letter today from the history commission asking it to be deferred or outright denied because of some of the planning struggles that we've had so you know we we need to do some more homework on this before we put our taxpayers on the hook for nearly 90 for $86 million assuming no cost overruns thank you okay next uh Melanie yes thank you um Mr manky thank you for reminding us that it was in 2021 that the two boards the Board of Supervisors and the school board uh together the as a result the bond would increase to 230 do you happen to know what it was Prior I don't think that was a huge jump I want
179to say it was like around 200 or 210 if I remember I might call staff to uh confirm but I believe the recent increases at one point it was 180 and then went to 200 and is now at 230 okay so they've been roughly around that 20 to $30 million jump each time they've increased it okay and I would love to know more of that perhaps in the future of what's been the history of the bond funding um and I'll just put a side note is you know we have no dedicated funding for security upgrades everything that we're doing comes from either Capital operation so we have sced together grants mostly Federal so I I want to say to my colleagues that we as a board have to do something differently we must do the
180policy review when the chief of facilities put up that all of this Pro this whole CIP is based on a 25-year funding cycle that is because a board determined that in 2014 and no board since has really looked at that thank goodness that policy is still on target but we cannot make decisions about $8.5 billion in assets based on policies that haven't been reviewed sometimes in over a decade so as part of the CIP uh approval last year Miss seiser Heiser and I put forth a motion which the board approved it's in the followon motion uh response that we received in April but it's it's still pretty light in response but it has the 27 policies so this was the public motion that some of them are redundant some of them are outdated some of
181them need to go away we must do this work because if we don't we will be right here again in one year having the same conversation because this staff is using this as their road map so we have governance in a week one week from today and I'm really eager to see the agenda posted I know we just did a huge lift doing the grading policy and the boundary policy but also those two policies were out of date we're supposed to be reviewing having completing a review every 5 years okay not like starting it in 5 years but like a new policy updated and if there's no change there's no change to me this is the most important thing because if we don't do this everything else is it's not going to happen so um
182I think it's just the prime example of what happened when a board ignores and abandons its duty to do policy work so um you know just backtracking knowing what it takes to produce the CIP I believe you know you you in the late fall the team the facilities team is really trying to wrap this thing up so that means we've got to get them policies way more in advance so the work starts right now so I hope at um our governance meeting in a week we can discuss with the superintendent what that timeline looks like just like we've done with the grading policy and the boundary policy to back map that and analyze these policies into something better um and we must have discussions together about what we requested from the follow on that we
183all did last year we've gotten volumes from the staff I'm aware that the chair Vice chair and superintendent have discussed scheduling additional work sessions we need multiple work sessions to talk about these huge topics this will be a legacy and our entire Community is counting on us so let's do it great so we're going to move to second round so we'll be doing two minutes each so off uh to the races uh Dr [Music] Anderson thank you may I ask that we we continue with 3 minutes because we still have 2 and 1 half hours on the schedule okay uh after conferring and hearing her telling me this we be continue with three minutes for this thank you um one of the things that I wanted to ask which I spoke with you right before
184the break is how Nimble can we be once decisions are made because I certainly understand that we can only make the decision with the information in front of us but I think Mr uh McDaniel really underscored what we were talking about which is there are future concerns that are surrounding the dunloring project that it's set up to address future concerns but we also have current concerns that are not being addressed what is that cut off where we review the data and maybe pivot to put our resources however limited they are to the places where they're most needed yeah so just taking D luran aside and just thinking more generally about your question I will say it probably depends right um depends on the situation I do think the benefit of our work current work plan
185is that we are updating and adopting a new CIP every year and we are being very good at being proactive of looking and taking in new information from our projections right we do our projections every year so as something that we've kept our finger on the pulse on on a development becomes active then we have the time and the ability to put it in that new updated uh projection set and the new projection set continuously is updated and taking in new data so then from there it's actually put into the CIP and we're making decisions based on all that data that we're collecting and updating it annually so I think moving forward it might just make sense to talk about things that have changed again we kind of spoke briefly about Trends and projections and
186whatnot but if there's a way we could talk more holistically about things that might be changing any sort of update in the CIP I think that's probably worth exploring further um I'm definitely encouraged and I want to have that conversation but similarly to what was shared I find it difficult to explain to the public that we are going to add as was described 900 seats in an area where there's already a surplus I can't explain that to anybody in the Mason District because we're bursting at the seams um getting a a little bit more specific into the student enrollment part of the CIP on table five which I guess begins uh page 53 somewhere there I'm sorry page 51 actually table one that shows coats elementaries numbers um for this year and in the out
187years coats does not have modulars or temporary classrooms coats does have multiple temporary trailers out on their site right now it's not here without it can you just kind of help me understand table one that's on page 51 of the full document sure so right now the first uh set that capacity utilization we're currently sitting at a 137% deficit now that I believe does include Modell but does not include trailers and I'm asking make sure I'm not mist that okay that's correct and with the projected growth in this specific area uh we are seeing by 2029 2030 school year that um overutilization to be at 163% and again just a caveat that does consider modulars we consider them a more permanent type structure with a foundation Etc it does not uh consider temporary um capacity
188trailers are we missing data in the last two which is without modulars I don't think it's applicable in the casee of coats um because coats does currently not have any modulars if it did we would show it an even higher over utilization so it does not have modular correct it it does has trailers it has many trailers it does not have Modells so how does a school qualify to receive a modular I think that's something that my team Works closely with um at the beginning of the year we look at the projections that come through we work closely with ISD and DSs on identifying program needs um and then honestly we look to see what kind of resources we have available with the current modular systems that we have to deploy those to the areas
189of greatest need because when I take a look at the schools that I the schools that I represent which is Park Lawn without the modular they're similar situated as coats so if we were to add modulars at cods and I'm just using this as an example because I'm trying to understand why Park is not also on table one again we were trying to be very flexible and show the data and multiple ways like if you do consider modulars which again we consider modulars a more permanent structure that was the basis of our you know putting it on table one um right now that would be coats only because they don't have any and so we can see that we're at 137% right I see it but I guess I'm disagreeing the premise of and I'd
190like a a review of particularly the schools where those people are looking to me to get the Sea of modular out from where they are right um if you could speak to Renovations you talked about how Renovations have the biggest bang for our buck and I appreciate that are all Renovations do they automatically include an expansion in square footage that's a good question it depends uh depends on the size of the existing building we do try to again be very cost efficient with our building so when you are renovating it does make sense if you're going to expand do it at the time of renovation additionally a lot of times you rely on the expansions because it's a phased occupied renovation so sometimes you would build some of that additional expansion and then the kids
191would go there as you renovate back renovate the area so typically we do try to accommodate for that long-term growth when we are uh renovating and I think it makes a lot of sense especially if you use it in conjunction with boundary to best align um where your capacity is and um yeah is that that doesn't S my qu it does answer my question but it raises this question for me when I look at the future projects that are going to be renovated and potentially expanded one two four of them I believe already are in the Surplus category so I wonder is that the best and the most strategic use of our limited resources to expand schools that in the out years already show that they're in the Surplus right I would agree with you
192and maybe when we say expansion it doesn't mean maxing out to that policy of a th plus kids right it might be just putting in a little bit of growth um and that's something we do look at when we develop the space and program for every renovation school so they're not always the same built out to the same amount I'll take go back please okay thank you Mr Moon followed by Mr Dunn thank you Mr thank you Mr mcin uh probably this question goes along with a questions related to tling uh you know constructing uh I guess changing the building to a in know School building at the downloading site uh if we are projecting all overall enrollment Decline and at the same time we are presenting to the public that we will be building
193two schools two elementary schools uh how do we explain that because there is just overall a a capacity deficit whether it's uh just a pure capacity or program capacity we still need two more school buildings correct I think right now you'll see that when you look at our Maps across the board there's areas that are under utilized and over utilized and while there's an overall short decline there's other that's across the county right so there's other Pockets where we still are experiencing growth in in specific Geographic locations so I would argue that I would also argue there's other factors that relate to utilization of a building and it being over utilized and some of that might be programming if we're adding additional programming we're going to need more space I think prek was brought up
194in the conversation you need you need space if you wanted to expand pre options so there's still a building need um even if there is an overall decline in the county when you look more specifically in the geographic areas and when you consider other factors such as programming geographic location Etc so going back to the downloading Elementary School site that even though there is a capacity Surplus currently existing in the area uh are we then expecting additional programs to be placed to use the excess capacity potentially and I think you need to keep it in the context of countywide right maybe it's not there but it might be somewhere else so we need to consider that that um so I second you know basically what uh Mr U Mr McDaniel suggested earlier that we re
195look at at least we need to find the real good justification uh to be presented to uh uh a county taxpayers a and the governing body asking for more funding uh when you constantly ask for more funding because we are there is a funding deficit that we need to be able to really explain where how we are you know most efficiently using our resources they are giving us understood so with that said I have some minor questions I'm going to go to a page number this is a report CIP it's not part of any presentation wasn't page number 38 uh what caught my attention was I was trying to see the a trend in enrollment projection and I saw please correct me if I am interpreting this wrong in three sets of bar graphs on
196the page number 38 of CIP uh at the very bottom in in green color is a special education and it's broken into high school middle school and Elementary and all seem to be either you know below 10% or hovering around 10% for the special education which is quite different from my understanding of percentage of students our students in special education which is somewhat like a 16% so what am I what am I missing here um I'm actually going to have some staff provide a little bit of context to that because the numbers displayed are correct they're ranging anywhere from that 7 to 11% but I'd like them to be able to provide a little bit more clarity of course um it th those graphs look at the self-contained special ed populations um the ones that
197would be level one maybe in the General Ed classroom um so we're looking at self-contained there the ones that are in a dedicated like enhanced autism classroom or an ID classroom okay uh since my T time is up probably I need to do at least one while go back later uh thank you Mr moon for that self-reflection um next we'll have Mr Dunn um I'd like to thank Mr McDaniel for bringing up the issue about dun luring and the data he shared um what I'll share is uh in my district uh Bucknell Elementary School in around 2017 or so um had 300 seats added on to its capacity its capacity was 600 but that school had had only 250 students for decades so why were 300 seats added back then at significant cost to taxpayers
198I've asked a question to dozens of people and no one's been ever able to explain to me why and uh adding to this and there's another project in my area uh pre Center that I don't think is necessary or could be repurposed for another thing I I I think it would behoove this school board to not assume that everything that's currently in the queue should remain in the Que queue and and I think we should start uh with the superintendent Dr Reed taking a thorough scrub of what's in the queue right now where we have not bid out anything or even if we've bid out only design should we actually go forward with that do the same analysis that Mr McDaniel did and he's a school board member doesn't have the whole facility staff and
199look at the surrounding schools and say is there capacity at those surrounding schools and should this project go forward and and and do it in a fairly ruthless way because we just we don't have have the dollars um to you know we have to make hard choices as it is we should conserve every dollar and spend it in the most efficient way that actually meets uh the demands of the system so we're not as you say we're governing as a school system not a system of schools um I want to ask what expectation you would have that uh right now we're in the midst of a School boundary review that will involve a lot of changes right what effect do you think it will have um so that we are having perhaps a completely different
200conversation next year yeah like I said we do this process every year so this time next year we potentially could have more data right so my guidance would be is we use the current data that we have to date to make the decisions that are best suited with the resources we have in this CIP and then again I agree we would continue the conversation see what has changed I think the boundaries will have some sort of impact to this work and then we're going to make some recommendations on what should change uh as a result of that and given uh scarce dollars um we have facilities condition assessment which really should be the the foundation of determining which schools get renovated and in what order and perhaps at what scale partial full Etc um when
201do you expect that work to be done yes and I had a a background slide if someone could bring that up with a timeline if you can go to slide oh no it's the facility condition assessment in the back 42 thank you because we have so many initiatives we didn't want to build out a full slide for the sake of this presentation but we did include a brief slide in the background information because the facility condition assessment to your point is very very tied to the CIP work so currently we're in phase one right now this is the proposal and procurement facilities uh team has been Drafting and completing that scope of work built out to the budget that we have for this endeavor it's now with procurement services and then we'll move on to
202phase two which which is you know bringing a vendor on board and just as a reminder this is going to be to do the facility condition assessment and have that same V vendor to your point um develop that framework for creating the queue and then as an outcome create the queue itself so it will really depend on when we can bring the vendor on board but our anticipation is at at that 9month period after we bring them on that we'll have a lot of the data collected and then we can then take another or two to about that one year point to actually create that new renovation queue we'll be you know again spending kind of in parallel path assessing the facilities thinking about the ways to weight that factors and and other things to
203consider and then generate it uh my goal is for that to then time up with enough heads up that it could influence not next year's C well not next year's CIP but potentially the following and uh can you talk a little bit about the the benefits financially in terms of construction time frames that could be achieved by implementing um construction management at risk and design build which fpac and cpdc have been looking at And discussing with you over the past year yeah it's a great topic to bring up and it's something that uh we have taken the first steps as staff to um allow ourselves to use this methodology current Schoolboard policy 8240 only limits ourselves to low bid construction methods so the one thing that we've been working on since the last CIP presentation
204is working with our partners at um legal council and procurement teams and our facilities groups and we've redlined 8240 to allow for these two methodologies I will say construction management risk and design build while they are a little bit different they do follow more of that best value model versus just going in under a um blind concealed bid one of the benefits of that is you get your Builder up front earlier on in the construction progress process and while you can't always come up with like a dollar saved just having someone on board earlier in the process with that perspective is very beneficial to school construction work school construction work is on an aggressive timeline it's complicated we have to deal with a lot of logistics um so just really having that Builder to help
205with the constructibility reviews to make sure that the designs are current meeting current budgets it's really invaluable information uh when done right sometimes those Builders can even bring on as a design assist some of the vendors and installers of the equipment and more specialty items so just having the guy that installs the HVAC system be a part of that HVAC design process is great and um so I don't think it's going to make that big red circle blue I do think it's going to help with the overall product here at FCPS especially given the challenging and constraints of uh School construction and I do think it might offer some predictability to the budgets too because you're building to a guaranteed maximum price and you're uh catching all those hey I caught this I caught that
206of making the price go up UPF front and so the cost of the construction is still going to be roughly the cost but I think it might be better for that planning of the budget so bottom line if the school board adopts the redline 8240 do we could adopt these new construction methodologies construction management methodologies which could speed construction and perhaps reduce cost potentially yes um it's not we had a lot of uh conversations with vendors in the DMV when you have a project that's already very far down design you don't get that benefit of having them up front so we want to pick the right projects more in that moving forward versus the projects you might see go out to bid um as early as next month for some renovation projects we have uh
207right now we are slated to have design start at for the current proposed CIP for two renovation schools in fy2 so we're actually writing those rfps and writing the Scopes of work now and we're writing in the scope of work it's anticipated that this could be a construction manager at risk so the architect when they're brought on board know that's a potential uh procurement method so we are trying to Future proof all the schools moving forward to allow for this uh in in terms of uh the um modular trailers in our County we have 900 classrooms and modular and trailers when can we expect to reduce that significantly and get it down to zero that's a that's another it depends kind of answer I one I think there's a lot of initiatives going on to
208address capacity like the countywide boundary work so I will be very interested to see what that does for the ability to remove trailers I also think trailers if we're being quite Frank offer something and so it's a trade-off right you know we have as we mentioned the desire to expand programs and offer more to our students so they need to have some sort of space and so I think moving forward I would like to work with everyone on ways to reduce that but we got to understand what the trade-offs are can you talk about the P3 guidelines that you developed with office of division Council sure for the legal guidelines correct so again I'll just remind everyone policy 8240 only allows for low bid construction so in addition to redlining 8240 to allow for construction
209manager at risk and design build we also wanted to get ahead of things again just letting it be an option to develop uh legal and procurement guidelines for a potential public private partnership should we ever choose to enact one this could be as a writer to that policy to allow for it to take place so we developed a draft and I believe that was part of the follow-on motions and it really just kind of walks through how we would Envision this process going uh we talked about the different ways we could solicit for a P3 vendor or unsolicited uh vendors could bring forth ideas to us and how we would Engage The Board how we would engage the public and how we could um set up the criteria for moving that forward uh H has
210uh FCPS looked at Innovative Construction Technologies such as 3D printing or modular construction not modulars in terms of trailers but modular in terms of assembling buildings like Legos where the Legos are built in the factory yeah it's a good question I think everyone's favorite projects the stadium restrooms is a good example that's actually a pre-fabricated unit and well it was a it was good in that we learned a lot in working with the county I think there was some frustration on the time it took to get to the point where we could get underway with construction and a lot of that was because of the pre-fabricated nature and so that's been good for us on that smaller scale to understand how we would permit it how we would get an architect to sign off on
211it and what we're seeing now is they're in fabrication and we're going to be able to build them at a fairly rapid Pace the only other example I can think of and share it's a project not really discussed much it's not on the CIP is we had our grounds and operations center um burn partially burned down in a fire so we had the insurance money to um rebuild part of the facility uh that's the Woodson complex and so we're actually doing a pre-fabricated model there as well so it's under construction right now it's slated to open this summer and it's been really amazing we built the foundations um and did that last summer and over the fall and you just saw the building kind of pop up overnight so once that building's open I think
212we're going to do kind of a debrief on that one as well just understand because that's a little bit larger of a scale than just the the restroom not a full school but on on a much bigger building type great thank you Mr Dunn um next we have Miss uh Dixit so I'm going to ask a question about one of the um I guess one of the topic we keep discussing about Western High School um are we looking at any ways of acquisition of uh the land we we have talked about it if you could address that a second and I have some follow-up questions on that too sure we've engaged a real estate broker J to help us identify potential fits for a Western High School again without knowing the exact criteria need and
213size it's a little bit kind of like shots in the dark but we are continuously meeting with them to say hey what are potentials it's you know it's very difficult to find that many acres of open land to build upon so we've also asked them to still to consider office space uh facilities as well I think we mentioned that in last week's El there's a lot more of a trend towards uh retrofitting Office Buildings we U I actually went and toward one at Alexandria City public schools where they took an office building and turned it into an elementary school and with great success and now they're building another one across the street so we are having them explore that again I do think the biggest barrier to entry is financial we have some money approved
214in the previous spawn for some site acquisition but just given that dollar per square foot and dollar per acre we don't have the funding So currently it's sitting in an oute um and so as we get more information about the boundaries and other initiatives and other programs going on in the division I do think that could offer some clarity on the program requirements and then as we get closer to implementing and and tell us we in that CIP it should fall too so one of the things uh why you know there is a request for a Western High School obviously it's it's a a geographical need because there is a lot of population growth in the western site of Fairfax but also um there's a whole question about having a uh another science of Technology
215school which is focusing more on uh you know again these things and I feel like ventle being one of the schools which has the academy but it's like overcrowded already and cille high school has its own challenges and going through the permitting right now it's going to take them a long time so we really don't see any anything until 2030 or 35 to even get to a new high school so in the interim um I wanted to just see if we could be a little bit more creative and we have that some funding there and we use some of that funding to um maybe potentially look at other school another High School in western side and make that as a Science and Technology Center Center just adding more programming and maybe adding more um space
216um so uh obviously you you you know you can do that analysis which has the capacity or the acreage but um I was looking at the uh Coville high school has 35 Acres uh Cent Coville High School 36 sorry C Center chantley is 35 Acres space Westfield High School is sitting on 76 Acres Westfield is not on the renovation queue I wanted to know ask why it's not being added ever I I can't speak to the history of where Westfield fell I knew I know the current queue were on was developed in 2008 2009 and it looked at specific School criteria I believe it schools built older than 91 92 so again without really knowing the specifics that was the Nexus of the current queue you see today that Westfield um westfields on and then
217again just to reiterate we're nearing the end of it and I think at this point the direction and the previous approv cips was honoring the current renovation projects and then we're going to as this slide shows do the facility condition assessment so we can get a new queue and I just want to remind everyone we're going to be looking at all the schools so everything is on the table to really understand the condition of their facilities when considering the next pipeline of schools thank you for that answer but I think with the boundary review and also the discussion we just had that we need to look at even the current p q a bit more um I think any school which is not currently in construction um should be looked at again which is not
218currently having active construction still in permitting and designing and things like that because um this question has come up that uh the one school did not need to be constructed or may not be needed there and uh possible location so uh we are doing this 40-year boundary review after and taking so much of time effort to do it it should be used for CIP that's like and I think also this uh facility condition assessment would really help uh to come up with a better queue so having a queue from 2008 may be redundant after we re review all of that so and also I would like to look at adding some funding for uh Science and Technology school at one of the existing High School yeah that D points duly noted and and agreed on
219the boundary and whatnot uh great uh next Miss Lady thank you and I appreciate the continued to conversations around capacity for dun Ling uh versus what's happening with expansion and Tyson uh because I too remain concerned about spending taxpayer money um at that level um uh also I'm a little perplexed to I'm going to I don't want to derail this conversation but I'm going to go back to slide 38 why is it that we only are counting self-contained when we indicate a sped number in here I find that not to be transparent to our public page 38 page 38 of the CIP and we can follow up with more of the rationale but I believe that's because it's directly tied to space that it's a dedicated physical space that has an impact on the program
220capacity and utilization for schools which makes sense to me so can we just add special education self-contained sure because we can make a clarification great um to somebody who's understanding that we're we we we're quoting a different statistic of our special ed population and then this is absolutely we are absolutely y so my other question is I know that part of the boundary View at least I've heard perhaps there might be some conversations later around um wanting to have our elementary schools be K through five and our middle schools to be six through through 8 which might in turn require us to convert some elementary schools to Middle Schools um just hypothetical is that is there is there something that we projectively know about what cost it would take to do that conversion we do
221not and that's one of the big things we're going to be working through in the development of the scenarios in the countywide boundary work and again I just want to reiterate since we are in that phase one we're engaging with the Community right now we have not begun to start on any kind of development and building out what that could look like so you know again in later conversations we might have more to share but we just don't right now okay I appreciate that and perhaps that was some at one of the events I went to maybe that was somebody's on somebody's sheet and it was shared so I just thought I'd ask the question thanks okay U Marcia um so just to follow up again from being in elementary schools and when we're talking
222about self-contained that is dedicated space but we have to consider if a student has an a requirement for speech there has to be a dedicated space where that child can be pulled out to get those services and I don't think that's ever reflected because I'm seeing some of these schools where they where we say they're at 87% capacity in schools that I've worked in and there's not a room where you can pull that kid decide to give him speech therapy so when we're talking about those specialized Services it might not be overall um 24/7 dedicated space but that space would be used to maybe work with the speech therapist it might be used you know differently by sometimes a counselor it might be used differently with working one-on-one with a multilingual learner and I think
223that sometimes the need for spaces not really reflected here in terms of the high need of some of our students which goes to why we need the funding if there were not these extra requirements that our students needed we wouldn't need these set aside spaces and I think sometimes people misunderstand that uh so I want to just put that out there because that was just brought up um but what I want to highlight is the important work that we were doing here I was working at Bucknell when that renovation was made and at that time there were schools around it that were overc capacity and there was supposed to be a re a redistricting there was supposed to be a boundary change and I was told by a sitting School Board member that that was
224not going to happen because it was the third rail and they didn't take up that work then and I was told we will not do this unless we do this overall and what I'm saying is that ball has been pushed down the field too long and I just want to say that I appreciate the work that all of my colleagues are doing here because we're having the courage to touch that third rail because it is what's best for our students had the changes been made then we would have already had some boundary work done kids that can walk to Bucknell are being busted to bellw and that's not right so I just want to thank everybody for taking for Having the courage to do the work that we're doing because that should have been done
225back then and it wasn't okay we're going to go on to third round um and it looks like we're going to keep it at um 3 minutes because there are limited placards so um Dr Anderson thank you can you speak a little bit about because I know I've raised this before and I don't know whether this is a policy that we need to review what the right sizing of our schools what they should be because I think that would impact um how large we build our schools yeah we do have a Schoolboard policy that talks about maximum size of elementary middle and high school I just can't recall the exact numbers off the top of my head are there recommendations from the industry or educationally speaking Dr Reed that you can pull that talks about
226the right size for our schools to function most optimally I think there's been a lot of research around that um and I think it's mixed uh in general there's a sweet spot schools can sometimes feel a little too small when I think of secondary schools the smaller the school sometimes the fewer the elective options are um but then there's also a downsize if it gets too large um then fewer students are able to access uh some activities um because there's so many young people competing for those so I think there's some sweet spots off between 1600 and 2,000 is uh commented on for high schools I think 1,000 to 1500 for middle and um Elementary is 500 to a thousand generally but there are bodies of research that crisscross all of that um and there
227are ways to make very large secondary schools feel smaller by creating um learning communities within the school houses and I know a lot of our schools use those practices um so it's a little mixed I I think it's an opportunity for us to have that research kind of merge with our policy because all of the schools that I've seen that we've renovated at the high school level they've been to be at 2500 2500 and Elementary seem to be all over the place and we do have some elementary schools that are small in this Division I think there's what two or maybe three tops remaining and if we're taking on this whole comprehensive um work that has to be part of the conversation we can't leave what can be a an impactful component out of the
228equation um so perhaps Robin not to put you on the on the spot but just to add that to the governance list of um of policies to review um the other thing that I wanted to talk about is you know we've primarily before the lunch break we had a fairly Doom and Gloom presentation with the CIP it seems as if there's no way out like we're stuck in this space and we're trying to figure it out it just seemed really dark what are the options and I know that we didn't have a slide on options but that's what I'm asking for for the Public Presentation because sitting in the space of oh well we're here we need 14 million dollars and we're just like popping different thoughts here or there it's unorganized I I would
229like to have an organized slide with options things things that we can be sitting with and talking about and wrestling with and things that the public can also be wrestling with rather than the popcorning that we're doing right now is that a possibility Dr Reed so I I mean anything's possible if you ask for it I will make sure we find a way to provide it I would ask for a little more um Direction on options because recalling that the purpose of the presentation is to approve this Five-Year Plan of projects so I think we when we began this we talked about this the purpose of this afternoon was to review The Five-Year Plan and to talk about a variety of other strategies and to talk about sort of how we got here today and
230if we stay on this course we're we we going to end up down the road so are you asking for options for future thinking and planning or options for this five years or it's actually both because the conversation today has gone Beyond those 5 years you know the billion dollars of um resources that we require is beyond that if we're limiting it to the 5 years I think we heard very loudly and clearly like how can we maximize the resources that we have right now with the needs that we have right now I'm going to add again to the chorus of do we have options for done Ling and I know sometimes we already a little bit into the project but is it worth it to perhaps you know lose a couple of million because
231we've had design or to kind of waste 86 million because we don't need the space just whatever it is that our task is in the conversation that we've had here which has been Way Beyond 5 years I'd like to see a way out because otherwise I feel like I always feel in these conversations we kind of sit and we talk and we complain and we say the same things but yet the changes are not as um the changes don't come in the way that I think we would like to okay so you're asking for then options for the five years and options for the future whatever seems to make sense I think we have a priority on the five years so maybe we'll start there just to move this conversation out of the space that
232we're in which is we don't have a way out to make our buildings the learning environments that we want them to be with the capacity that we want them to be so I appreciate that clarification thank you I do think the current CIP proposal in front of you and presentation is essentially our um those are the options we're providing for the five years so I think if if there are different options or options you want us to look at again the fiveyear options are what the presentation today is um and I think we can certainly look at what's possible outside that moving forward but I think the fiveyear current options are the present a today so I just want to make sure that as we go back to work before next week uh that we're
233clear on what options if any you want adjusted for this five years that was my time but I can talk about that and I'll go back um let's just handle it now if you want to address that point yeah let me just take an example of what's here on slide TW um is it 30 on slide 30 where we're talking about the backlog we know how important this is what can we do here what are some options for us to consider to address this is it only going to be year end is it going to be some sying fund ISS what can we do to address this that can be discussed when we have this public conversation it's those kinds of options it's not necessarily uh what we are definitely going to do but we
234can't just talk about the issue but not have a plan to resolve it does that make sense a little bit more yes ma'am okay great um uh Mr Moon uh thank you Mr uh thank you Mr M just a couple of questions let me start with uh something smaller uh the capital sinking fund of $9.5 million how long has the fund been accumulating do we know so it's been three years three years that we've started to receive uh annual year end from the county so it's it's the fluctuation right it's not it's not same it's not guaranteed uh last year a tier point was in that $9 million range and I think we had that shown on a the 9.5 previous slide 9.5 yes you know how much we have had in three years um
235I believe it was somewhere in that $9 million range each year so if I had to estimate I would say somewhere in between that 25 and $30 million total and and and what can we use the money for right now majority of that money is being dedicated to HVAC um replacement work to getting us out of that backlog slide that we just saw this year we did siphon a little bit of it to do that elevator modernization program so in short it is for critical infrastructure needs of the highest priority okay and that is determined by use of them funding is determined by us correct correct not qu of Supervisors correct okay with that with that done uh I'm going to go back to enrollment projection uh with the declining enrollment projected I want to
236see how that is related to overall capacity needs because when we actually figure out determine the capacity needs we look at the program Capac capacity as opposed to just a pure number in number of students correct that's correct so even with the declining over enrollment production do you see that our program capacity needs is growing steady or declining along with enrollment projection decline I would say it's on a definite increase so I've been here two Falls now and fall we've worked closely with our partners at instruction and DSs and we've been identifying many many new program needs that need to be put into schools and find that space um over the last few years so would you be able to because you are looking at the enrollment projection going forward for 5 years until 2019
237or 2030 would you be able to also I mean this is going to be rough estimate mhm about similar numbers relate to program capacity needs sure if I think if I'm understanding you correct I could look at historical Trends on how many additional programs we've had to add per year and maybe come up with that rate of growth because I want to be able to I want to be able to you know share the with the public and supervisors you know if and when someone comes back to us and say that enrollment is declining so program that capacity needs should also decline but our program capacity needs is does not ex is actually going the other direction correct okay and then if it could also provide some explanation as to why that is so okay
238thank you okay uh Mr Dunn followed by Mr McDaniel um just bottom line for my constituents it sounds like we don't have enough money to achieve the Schoolboard policy to ACH to uh renovate schools every 20 25 years is that right that is correct okay and and I also see in here on slide 33 for example that um while we have uh commendable goals to achieve Net Zero uh goals for our future buildings we we also don't have enough money to do that either is that right just to clarify projects per the jet directives projects that are in the CIP starting with design in fy2 and Beyond are being designed with the Net Zero Technologies to make it Net Zero ready where possible um so you will see that number that premium baked into the
239estimates in the cash flow that it's part of the CIP and what does Net Zero ready mean that's different from Net Zero yeah so just to speak about it very broadly Net Zero is when your building consumes of energy but then it's offset by solar production or renewable production so that the net is zero energy we say often Net Zero ready because maybe we design and construct a renovation and it's at a very low energy consumption rate but we haven't put in the Solar or the Renewables yet so I would say it's Net Zero ready so when the solar comes on it's reasonably feasible that we could add the solar to get to that zero status and do we have the esos in place to actually provide $11.35 billion we have the county has an
240Esco contract that we have amended to ride so we have an Avenue to do it and and the the vendors lined up um to to this chart it's an issue of funding it's the barrier to entry uh and but aren't esos normally self-funding through savings and and reduction and utility costs and they the difference that is that is correct it's my understanding here in Fairfax County there is required upfront funding to implement the esos I think it becomes an issue of accounting towards the debt cap so um I do think it's probably a more nuanced conversation but essentially you can get maybe more work for a lower cost amount of money if you Leverage The forthcoming um Energy savings but there is a up there is upfront money required as part of it do you
241know what percentage is required upfront you know I'd probably to get back to you I think I saw a proposal once that was probably in like the 20 to $30 million range worth of work and The Upfront charge would have been in that $8 million range if that gives you a sense of scale and is is that is that just Fairfax County or have you seen that in other jurisdictions as well that that much money is required up front because I've seen I normally see esos with zero dollars up front yeah I believe that's more um for Fairfax great um so first swing spaces uh we we don't tend to use swing spaces so we we have phase construction you know students are still in the building while it's being renovated but that has the
242effect of increasing our construction time frames and increasing our construction cost so can you talk a little bit about what alternatives might exist in uh for students to perhaps not be in the building while it's being renovated and how that could affect our construction time frames and our construction costs yes and um we did provide a followon motion the first followon motion of 2024 for facilities the one that was issued as part of the CIP in February that we answered in April that really started to discuss some of this some of the considerations you need to have um swing spaces you do need to be very very aligned to the academic year because you're moving up picking up a whole school and putting them somewhere else um and so you need to make sure that
243space is up and ready and then when they come back the space needs to be ready but we did uh meet with cost estimators some AR Architects and contractors to kind of get a sense of how much time you could realistically save so again because you have to align it to the Academic Year you're really looking at probably two years right for an a typical Elementary School stay one year I mean construction would take way more than that three years you're already hitting what we're currently doing today so I would recommend that Target be two years for an elementary swing space so then you kind of compare that to what the typical timelines have been running of you know 28 to 30 months and so we started to do some general cost estimating to say
244you have some potential Savings in the general conditions of the contractor maybe a little less time having the architect out there during construction and then not having to bring out trades multiple times a little bit for phase one a little bit for phase two and so we could see some overall costs come down the things you got to consider is the cost to implement the swing option what it whatever it might so if you're building a brand new temporary building you know that might not be worth um or it might cost more to do that we're very interested in looking at some on-site swing options because there it's um could be almost zero for swing space cost so if we have a site where we could keep the existing building up and running while building
245a new facility uh somewhere else if there's enough acreage on the property and then moving them over so in the second followon motion that was was um directed in May and we just recently submitted to the board we did a little bit of an expansion on that so we looked at some of the schools in the current proposed CIP and did a feasibility study on where there might be potentials for that to take place um I do think it's not a it's something else we need to flush out with the county making sure that we can meet um f and floor area ratio requirements make sure we can get everything permitted appropriately but we have started to do some of that preliminary documentation H have you also engaged with the county in any discussions about
246possibly collocating uh facilities um for example the recent Lon Community Center combines a library athletic facilities meeting space nonprofit space with a large kind of playground area um and in the city of Alexandria they just opened a school where the swimming pool for the high school converts to a community pool uh on weekends and evenings is that something that's are there any discussions that are ongoing or been initiated to to discuss those kind of possibilities I believe there's been discussions in the past um with prior boards and I know with um Planning Commission and whatnot but I do think that's something I've had the same thoughts on as reflecting upon this presentation right that we probably need to expand Beyond and have good partnership with the county and see what's possible and so I think
247that's something we could definitely look at to together looking into the future Mr Dunn just a reminder we are going to have more work sessions that dive deeply onto these huge topics like swing spaces and public partner U private Partnerships because we need to all learn more about it and see how we can direct the superintendent thank you great uh Mr McDaniel thank you and um you brought it up and I know it's not strictly limited to CIP but maybe the facility condition assessment it was my understanding correct me if I'm wrong that the idea at least is to assess all buildings not just school buildings it is currently written on our scope that way I think we potentially are looking at just getting an alicart price so we can make sure that it works
248within our budget but the intent is to look at all buildings you're correct okay will that include um Clifton Elementary School I believe it will okay good we're putting buses there and playgrounds and we have utilities turned on and we're paying for security and all that stuff so that going to be the building inside as well yeah the scope the scope of work is pretty straightforward for all buildings so that it's the same and that does include interior assessments okay perfect thank you okay Miss Marin followed by Miss Dixit yeah I've been trying to pull up the policy um class size bardocks isn't loading so well it's not listed as part of the um facilities pieces and I should know it because when I first became a parent in 2015 I helped to Advocate because
249my kids were never in an elementary school class lower than 29 ever and we don't talk about class size at all but we know that the lower the staff to child ratio the better the experience is for everyone again louding County schools has a totally different process if you move in and that school has hit it's class limit for that class you don't go to that school what we do here is so not what's happening other places um in the best interest of kids when it comes to our facilities work I don't know if anyone offand knows that policy about class size but that is one too that we can control that you guys we can say no you know what 31's too much and a middle school with 1,200 kids is too much we
250can make these decisions but we have to have the thoughtful conversations um the bond information you know U Mr Dunn and Miss samansky were talking about that construction management at risk which is something I'm eager to learn more about but you know is it best practices to use the money the way that the Board of Supervisors has organized it in a bond which is to spread the cost out over multiple years I can't seem to find any um support or why that reasoning is still in place but given this time and covid is it better to try and pay as much up front as you can get it done get the swing space get the students and staff in and out but the bond funding controlled by the board of supervisor is still saying it's
251going to be a yearl long you know projection so I'm really eager to learn more about that bond process and just um I'm wondering um I was somewhere PTA last night and parents were asking me you know what's the timeline with the boundary review and what's the timeline with the Middle School start times and then I also got the adjacent coats Elementary boundary review there's a lot going on and I think our community could really benefit from a very straightforward clear calendar of what's happening so we've got the CIP we've got the boundary review process we've got Middle School star times that started separately but now they've kind of careened together and people are wondering like how that's going to you know end up and we're going to talk about that in February and then
252other singular projects of Interest so like the coats review I guess the Glasgow review and then new school construction people asked me when's the new school being built can we have something that makes it clear for folks what's happening with all these facilities because people are paying attention which is great but there's fusion um I also just wanted to share some next steps that I'm thinking of adding to the chart one of them is that the superintendent come prepared to the January 22nd governance meeting with a timeline of how to review the policies identified in the CIP followon motion which was already responded to in April 2024 but I will say it's kind of meager so I think it needs some meat so that the governance committee can dig in on Tuesday and really figure
253out which policies need to be regrouped or Sunset and whatever um I'd also like to ask for a history of the Fairfax County Bond bond amounts and when it's been changed over time so I'll be putting those in thank you great U Miss Dixit Follow by Miss Anderson so um I like to um bring everybody's attention to uh page 10 of the presentation it's a fiveyear membership projections um and uh everybody's pointing it out that we have a decline in uh in the population student population birth continues to downward Trend um hence we are building new schools so I I just even the uh a slide previous to that uh which is on page nine um you know it says propose FCPS CIP fiscal year 26 to 20360 uh to 30 and it talks about
254the primary factor that contribut change membership includes an birth to migration transfer but still we are going back to this 17year old uh of queue of construction renovation and that just not sinking well with me uh because as we are seeing like we are seeing the decline obviously we're seeing some population areas are they have high capacity growth and some are declining and that happens over last 5 to S years I think that's we saw a lot of U Migra migrant population uh in some areas um we have huge migrant population in in Su District too which uh we see in some of our schools and um and yet those um those those this is not reflecting in our our queue so while we have more students in 11th and 12th grade that's what it
255says in the slide we are building elementary schools so I really want to re look at that and would like to request uh Dr Reed to just look at this a little bit more and uh Janice I wanted you to explain to me the slide 11 if you could it is something with maybe I could not understand when you were uh presenting it before sure so um let me just grab my notes here so the columns you know the different school years those represent the CIP membership projections and then the rows represent the year the student membership is from so we continuously update our CIP so each CIP includes five projected years so that's why you'll see one to five projection accuracy in each column so really I guess kind of looking at that um
256oute that last kind of diet diagonal so when we see that 101% that was our accuracy from last year um to how we actually hit for the certified student membership so last year's CIP we said it was going to be a certain amount and then when the September certified membership came in it was 101% off then you go up the diagonal again La two years ago we put in a one one year uh projection and when the certified membership came in it was 100% accurate there was like 100 kids um 3 years ago when we did the projections the next year certified membership came in and it was 99% uh then you kind of hit that covid year that's where you see that na from there on okay understood now uh much better so my
257uh the question was about the inflow of population which we have we're seeing either people are moving into Fairfax County or uh migrating um you know there's refugees and Etc uh is it more than uh the the lowering birth rate of our kindergarten like is it it does it balance off somewhere I do think that the births are on a continuous trend on the decline and that's one of the primary factors and then to your point we do need to still look at net migration so it's people not just coming into the county but leaving the county as well and I think that is not outpacing the birth to the birth rate on the decline we've done some recent um more anecdotal study I I guess we call it Street data a little bit um
258but I think there are certain communities within the county that have more in andout movement than other communities and often I know in Late July I met with a number of students that um it could be an entire multifamily complex that raises rent for example and when that rent hits a certain threshold there are a large number of families particularly with school-aged children who are not longer able to afford to stay there so you see an out migration or you see a migration to another multifamily living unit uh in another school zone that has lower rent rates right and so you see often families moving um and so we may not anticipate a increase and it's honestly up to 100 150 students sometimes that make these moves that a school wouldn't plan for that is
259suddenly much larger and then another school that's suddenly much smaller and when you get back to the Rook cause it came down to the the rent rates right so I think um there are a variety of um topics uh and different zoning in different parts of the county density wise in terms of homes and what can be built and what can't so um there's some variance but I do think we saw some surprising immigration in some schools um in the last couple years that ran counter to the predictions based on birth rate I I would tend to agree again this is an overall County but we're seeing that's not 100% spread out to be true we're seeing still areas where there is growth and I do want to add um to Dr Reed's Point there's
260other factors that go into a population growth or decline that would affect our projections that's why 5year projections are very challenging you know we might have a new program or an AAP Center be built at a school that would that would definitely impact the projections that we did four years ago say or um I think there is an example here in the county where there was a fire to a big multif family uh unit that would have a big impact so there are a lot of factors that you need to consider and keep your finger on the pulse of that influence these um projections and that's why again I just want to reiterate we update them every year as new data becomes available but there's a lot that goes into them thank you so much
261and then my last um comment today would be um I would really like to see the tax Glo dollars going to renovation then you know less building new schools if possible and uh more acmis spread across the county because we have very fewy where students have uh and that's like a a little bit excess issue um and so any of high schools if they all can have their little acmis um you know that would would be ideally what I would like to see and that's where I think our population is Shifting is we have Middle School cohort the biggest and high school cohorts are the biggest in the population as per the slide so thank you great thank you uh Miss Anderson I would like to say first um that I see visions of an
262interactive timeline related to facilities that would be pretty amazing if we could get something like that done um on our website so that people could know what was coming next I know it changes quickly and having it not in print form is probably going to be helpful um page 44 of the CIP is the renovation Q status and I want and we've spent a lot of time talking about particular renovation projects and I had a question um related to this since many of the ones that are in construction or future projects are in my area of the county I did want to talk about this a little bit when you're looking at those schools and it's not one of mine but when if you're looking at those schools that are 63 on the list they
263have waited all the time from number one and so we have to be really careful moving forward to make sure that we are not displacing communities off the renovation timeline that have been in that queue for a very long time and so I do want to to think about that as we move forward because I know our renovation queue is 42 years right now and that we're aiming for 25 but displacing schools off the existing timeline doesn't actually help that happen happen um my concern overall is well I have a couple of questions the first one is is it possible that some of these schools that we consider maybe not as necessary right at this moment uh due to new con like the new construction is there any reason that those new construction spaces couldn't
264become swing spaces for um Renovations in that area and then they would be available to be used by the community after yeah I mean I guess it would depend on the specific circumstance St but I think in theory that would make sense as something possible particularly as we're also looking at potentially figuring out how to move Middle School into ele or out of sixth graders out of Elementary School into Middle School it would also make sense that you could do something like that where you created one that was a swing space that would then be able to be utilized as a full school after so those are that's one thing that I was considering the other one is um I don't think we're there yet but I would very I am very interested to see
265what happens over the next year with our incoming Administration to determine how that's going to impact capacity around the county um based on some changes that have been proposed um just publicly at this point and so I do think that considering whether or not the next Bond could actually be um partially for those improvements that we need to make um based on just basic maintenance I think that that may be an effective use of that time as we determine um what the impact of some of the changes in in and around the area are going to be great uh so we are done with uh third round um we're going to go back to um Dr Anderson followed by Melanie and Dr Reed wants to interject appreciate that Mr meline I just want to go
266back to miss Dixit you had asked and I was sidebarr with Miss Marin you had asked me to review something before you went back to this chart with Miss samansky and I didn't capture it so I want to make sure I capture it I was just uh asking if we could look into all the new constructions U versus the renovation if we can funds can be moved to renovate our school which and somehow uh tackle that 25 you know the 45 year renovation queue and make it lesser than that because if we put more money in the renovation and updating the building our renovation queue uh sorry our uh uh the queue will be um I guess maybe if not 45 years which is right now to like at least 2 40 um it's just
267too many um lot of money is been allocated or kept as a I guess for the new construction and I know only one school is getting constructed right now everything else is just a plan right uh Western High School has $400 million but we don't even have 10 we don't even have a land for it so those numbers are just numbers right now nothing is getting constructed but anywhere we can uh just see if that could be swapped thank you okay onward to Dr Anderson thank you um on page 14 this is the full report not the slide we're talking about that um one of the expectations is that every school PID would have a an um an AP Center and the the anandale pyramid has had one how close are we to achieving this
268goal I think [Music] um it's a great question um I think probably that's going to be inherent in our boundary work honestly uh I um I will have to check in with Dr Presidio on that but I don't know if there was a timeline put in the follow on on that topic what page again just so I can page 14 of the full document it's just one of the expectations and I know that's been an issue okay I think I suspect because there's not a date certain attached to it it's sort of morphed perhaps but I will I will check with Dr presio I would appreciate if there could be because this is one of the things my community has been asking since my first term in 2020 also another question that comes up quite
269a bit um is uh wondering regarding the collaboration between the county and um the schools when projects are are approved that could potentially bring a lot of students and the one that comes to mind that Contin continually comes up in the Mason District is the project on Colombia um Pike near the Acura dealership people are wondering where are these kids going to go to school because we know the closest school Park Lawn we've already discussed is over capacity with 29 outside classrooms combination of modulars and trailers and glasow is already where it is so what is that conversation if there's any there is and and maybe it's more of a next part of those next steps and having us as staff have conversations with the school board on how that works so when we go
270go through like a when a development goes through there's a plan Amendment or a zoning application FCPS Works Clos with um the County's Department of planning and we provide what we think those impacts are going to be we look we review any development that has a residential component because it could potentially impact membership so maybe I would recommend just more information on how that works but is it that we just understand what the impact will be to us or do we actually have input we make recommendations okay so we look at the we review the developments we talk about what we think the membership impact is going to be and we make recommendations and then the county does the profer negotiation and and whatnot but they use our recommendation to to guide those discussions right
271thank you um one of the things that I think I'm struggling with a little bit because we've been at this space where we have paused certain activities because of the pending boundary work I don't see that coming in here either because we still have boundary work that could be impacted where we need to house sixth grade students where we need to place schools yet we're full uh moving ahead Full Steam with what currently exists and I'm struggling with that because I've had the Glasgow boundary adjustment that was in the CIP be paused be killed but yet I'm hearing that if it's in the CIP we have to do it which is it I'm not sure who the question is for I the board voted on the Glasgow piece it wasn't staff well maybe it's something
272I'd like for my colleagues to share because I I I'm struggling to see the consistency of um process here um can you talk a little bit in terms of the least building the buildings that are least but are owned but but that are owned by the county is that part of the data on chart three um on this chart right here oh no no no uh slide three on that report and do we treat that as our property because there's a few yeah for like Gate House for example that we're sitting in we're providing payments but that's owned by FCPS we couldn't incur the debt so they yeah so the county did and then we're doing in payment installment payments to this so in in that number we do consider buildings like Gate House okay
273how do we go about um putting the buildings that are not school sites on the renovation queue yeah that's a that is a great point you rais and so we are as part of the facility condition assessment assessing all facilities right school buildings Administration buildings and in fact Administration buildings weren't on this previous queue the one developed in 2008 2009 it did not consider admin buildings so what we found is a lot of the infrastructure in those facilities are in you know very very past du past manufacturers life cycle uh when you look at some of the biggest energy um consumers per square foot admin centers are right up there so we are going to provide all that information on the facility condition and something as we develop together the Q framework we can consider
274if we want to add the admin Center as part of that next uh next cycle because many of them have pretty good acreage and we already know that they could house a a bill uh a school building because many of them were previously school buildings but being now Ser um centers for adult work and it just makes me wonder with the um availability of office spaces but not the availability of land could we then make a swap where we use those spaces to return back to schools and move those workers into office environments where we can perhaps more easily um procure an office building for that kind of work potentially yes oh that's four seconds left hey thank you uh Melanie I did also want to comment on the renovation queue and I know at
275least on one of the previous two CIP rounds I remember us talking about the renovation queue and should we pause it update it was it this board it was this board um and when I look at this renovation queue and I don't see Luther Jackson Middle School on here it's just really hard to to think that this is really an accurate reflection of needs um you know this renovation queue was done it says you know based on info from 1992 it was approved by the school board in 2009 yet another plug to review our work far more regularly I I don't I mean I understand there are funding implications and the bond monies are tied to certain things but I do think we need to have the ability to be flexible if it's not if
276the renovation queue isn't working and I'm just again hardpressed Jackson is just such a great example and you've got kids from all over coming to that school and um we did talk about last year the opportunity cost of say you know if we have already been in planning and design do we cut those losses for the greater investment of updating the queue so I don't know I mean I'd like some more guidance on it you know um or more of a directive or a statement like what's the actual cost if we interrupt the queue and justes the board need to really take consensus on this is this also maybe the kind of last time we do the CIP this way which is kind of the feeling that it was with the boundaries last year right
277some of us said we're not going to do oneoff boundaries because we're going to do the boundary policy and the boundary review so maybe the CIP is turning that corner too we've got to kind of deal with it the way it is but we're looking to make it far more impactful in a lot of ways so I offer that for consideration I have maybe just a comment to add something I've been thinking about as we develop the new renovation queue because I agree and I just hearing the comments it does seem like a balance right putting something in making a commitment but then not having the flexibility as new uh factors arise over the years right one of the things we've been thinking about is while we might want to do a condition assessment to
278get a snapshot in time of all the facilities so we're starting off on equal footing how what is the end result of the renovation queue I personally don't think it's a list of 200 schools because it will take decades and decades and decades to implement it and so if we are that inflexible on that list you know we might be decades in and we're committed to a certain ordering but there might have been another Global pandemic or there might have just been other regular course of factors that would influence that list so again it's all about striking that balance right so what I think I would recommend um as facilities is we take the data we re review everything we get that snapshot in time and then the new renovation queue it's a little bit
279shorter it's a little bit shorter than 63 schools so that way we can offer the community some sort of stability and planning so they know their number five and they know in a few years they're going to get their renovation and we can keep that commitment but then we're not also so locked in that we can't um pivot and make other best decisions based upon new information so I just want to offer that up to the board as something that we've been internally discussing and we think could be a good potential solution moving forward as we do this new work and and we actually are already moving in that direction because we did approve and now getting implemented the 36 outdoor classrooms in middle and high schools the 14 Stadium bathrooms but again I will
280point us back to the policy and I believe it's 8258 which you know as you pointed out is establishes a 20 25 year renovation cycle so if we're telling the superintendent to renovate entire schools every 20 25 years that's what the superintendent is going to do but if we say things like make sure that all facilities have adequate bathrooms have you know um classrooms wired to go for the future you know this is why that's so important because otherwise they're just going to keep doing this lock step and we're never going to get out of this okay Mr Dunn yes I just wanted to ask Dr um there are uh a lot of cues that are being developed and that's a positive right playgrounds athletic fields and many others and just for it would be
281great to have just one piece of paper two pieces of paper where all the cues are listed or and like I I just don't know all the cues but it seems like every couple weeks there's a new queue of some kind which is not a bad thing it's it's it's a the right direction but it's a burgeoning number and I feel like I'm losing track of them and I PID very close attention to facilities so um so if we can just get like one document listing yeah Q of Q's very well said um it would be great and and if there are dedicated funding sources for those cues like the syncing fund for HVAC or whatever it would be nice to know you know if there are dedicated funds that feed into those particular cues
282um and if not if we if there's a recommendation to develop a dedicated funding source or some percentage of the bond funds every year for particular cues we can establish a queue of cues as well as well as well as backlogs I know there's an infrastructure there's a maintenance if there other backlogs as well that would also be good to include there again just for Simplicity so we don't have to look at a 300 page document every time we're trying to figure it out on our own yes sir I I also think that the caution from Miss Anderson was wise because there are some schools and it's good to show every school so everyone can see where they are but it feels I think I've heard from some school communities that at times as new
283people come and go and so forth the cues shift right and so people lose their spot in the queue and then that they don't feel good about that right because something moves ahead of their project and in some cases feel like they've waited a long time so while it's positive to have cues that are based on objective criteria that we all can see and track they also make a type of commitment I think with our community once we cue them so I I I I meant more just like a simple list like there are 10 cues these are the cues and these are the funding sources but ALS but also having the backup saying these are the schools on the cues that would also be useful yes sir exes it so I wanted to just
284point out that many of the schools which are um like like Miss Anderson said on the list 63 number Virginia on then popular tree Center Ridge uh cabun they're all um they fall under Sully district and I visited most of these schools and they definitely need to be renovated so I'm not I'm just saying not that uh we have to fix change everything we just need to look at it and not topple this upside down or something like that and just create like entirely new list but yes uh we can maybe uh just look at the boundary re and the U other other studies and research we are doing but definitely these schools uh do need renovation I just wanted to make that point because um visited them and U felt the need that they
285have never been touched since they were constructed okay um so we've concluded uh fourth round um uh Dr Anderson do you have anything more okay actually if you could just talk a little bit about because I thought I saw the fpac representative in the room at some point um and I know the language in this document talks about how they have some input they're listed here can you speak to their um cooperation their collaboration or their input into this document just for the community to understand that there are other individuals to go to to help push forward some of their concerns certainly and I guess maybe just to start by clarifying that fpac is an advisory Council to the school board however that being said uh myself and others we make sure as staff that
286we're very engaged with them as part of that process so you know we attend all fpac meetings we come there to share our insight and then even selfishly maybe take some of that space so that as staff I can gain some industry Insight from um the professionals that sit on fpac that you know I might not be seen or sound board things off from there so I do think there is a good working relationship even though um FPC does report to the board and their Charter and whatnot and then uh fpac also produces an annual report to the board we definitely get a copy of that and so um this past year in particular there was the annual report and then a couple specific memorandums provided to the board I mean one of the things
287that we did when we were revising policy 8240 looked at that fpac report on the procurement methods and you know used it again staff guided that work on the policy red lines but you know that was helpful information um and we even looked at it too again when doing our follow on motions because we were also asked to do um alternative methods and find more creative funding mechanisms so you know want like okay well with that um that brings the work session to conclusion uh we have a next steps um document which has been posted and the clerk will make a remark it w it's been sent around for both the traffic safety and the CIP so you uh the board should have received an email already for the next steps as well as your
288calendar invites to remember the deadlines are a little bit different the deadline for inputting is this Friday 5:00 p.m. but because of MLK Day the deadline for showing support is on Thursday correct yeah staff does not move forward until they see that so one more time the next steps are due one more time when was that sorry to input support is Friday at 5:00 p.m. and for board members to show their support for board members have inputed is Thursday generally it would be Wednesday but due to the holiday it pushes it on extra day this is all next week okay this Friday for showing to this Friday for inputting whatever next steps there are and next Thursday for showing your support but we've also sent Cal