CorpusRecord 8189

1/13/25 - FCPS Audit Committee Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Fairfax County Public Schools
Date
2025-01-14
Location
Fairfax County, VA
Material
Transcript
Extent
3,492 words · about 20 min
Collected
2026-06-01

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay well we have quum and thank you to everyone for being so timely today so this uh January 13 2025 regular meeting of the faest County Schoolboard audit committee will now come to order uh we will now vote to approve the minutes the November 18 2024 meeting of the audit committee all those in favor pass than you so with that we just have a couple of items before we go into close meeting today uh first of is the fy4 office of a annual report so I will it thank you chairman so um good afternoon everyone so today I am really happy to uh share the fiscal year 24 ogag office of auditor general annual report with you all and um first of all I would like to thanks the author the main author of this

002report who is Danelle here uh Danelle is our Deputy auditor general uh General Moore Deputy General Mo and we also have Nora here um Nora is our newest member uh who is our auditor one and Norah is also a fresh graduate from George Mason University so we are very happy to have her here so um I also want to thanks all my team members too who are here with us because we have all worked very uh hard together to get the audits the fraudway and abuse inquiries and training programs completed so thank you um it is indeed a big very big team effort to accomplish all the tasks that the school board and the audit committee has delegated to us um So within the annual report um we first talks about the structure of um

003office of auditor general uh whom we report directly uh under the school board and the audit committee and this is very important because Independence is uh very critical for the success for a uh internal audit function So within the uh annual report if we can go to page four um it talks a little bit more about the measurement of our value so we included indicators there um where we compare us against the Council of great City Schools so um the latest information inform that we received from the council was back in 2022 so I apologize here that the comparison is a little bit aged but um we know that that the Council of great City Schools is actually in the process of collecting data from the internal audit office because I'm one of their um

004interviewees so to speak so they're in the process of collecting data so I'm sure that in the next reporting phase we can compare to more upto-date uh data but with that comparison as you can see uh for the various datas or factors that we can include ogag is operating more effectively and efficiently than the other school districts um and then also on the next page uh which is uh page five you can see that that ogag has always been administering the after audit the post audit surveys with our users um we try to keep the questions very objective because sometimes it can be difficult right you are asking your audities to give feedback on the auditor so we try to keep all these eight questions very objective so whether we deliver a um timely audit

005management letter did we have the entrance and exit meeting was there any surprises from the audit Accentra so as you can see we got 100% of all the ratings so we are very proud of that and also the continuous collaboration with our stakeholders and then with that then I would like to to go to the four pillars of the ogag work um so the first pillar is about risk assessment um and the audit plan which is on page six exactly thank you clerk um so we identified all the audit topics through an extensive process which we called as risk assessment and including independent review of all the Hot Topics in the industry we analyzed financial and operational factors and passed audits Schoolboard and audit Med interest last year process document is included as a link

006um if the cler can scroll down a little bit further on that page yes so there will link that you can uh go back to the um documents itself or the presentation to find out more and uh we also listed out all the fiscal year 25 audit plan topics here on page six uh which is the 1 to 10 thank you um and we are processing all the audits on time and um next month we are very excited that we're in the Final Phase of wrapping up item five which is the critical process review for hiring we are also wrapping up item seven which is the procurement process audit uh which we plan to present to the audit Committee in the February meeting and then um with that I would like to move on to

007talk about internal audit um so again this is the core bread and butter for what we do within oag and I would like to defer to the details to Danelle who will walk us through um towards the end of this presentation then next on page eight is the fraud ways and abuse um hotline that we maintained so um last year we have received a total of 79 cases um all the themes of what kind of like the types of situations that we received is listed on um on this page so um as you can see the number have increased and the questions that I got many times is that is it that we have received like the situation at FCPS may not be go as well that's why we have more concerns um my um

008interpretation on that is not is more about the awareness of the hotline that people are using it that really see something say something so we receive a lot more situation so that we can prevent a concern from being a concern so which is a very good story to tell so I encourage that our audit committee to continue to Advocate about this um means to report to our community members or to our staff members so that they can continue to report in a situation and so with that we can move forward to our last pillar of our work which is Outreach and education as listed on page nine here uh we have done a lot in this area um but just to highlight a few major accomplish lishments um the first one is about the auditus

009and I hope that all of you here have um signed up to receive this audit bus and uh of course I'm not going to audit who have and who did not but um the subscription numbers have um been going up uh we are now um over 4,800 subscriptions and we try to summarize our audit results in a short and sweet version that the stakeholders could easily understand um we can also Pro promote our fraudway and abuse hotline and other education opportunities within the bus as well and the next we have done a lot of training and education so first of all I would like to thank our office of controller our controller is here with us um for the P2P conference they always include ogag to be part of the presenters and I know that

010there are a lot of topics that they can present and I really appreciate that they always save a space for us and then also at the leadership kickoff want to thank our um Chief of Staff M Mr Marty Smith and also our superintendent often time they willing to give me some time to be able to have that uh opportunity to speak to all the school-based administrators um uh in in that meeting so that to set the tone uh for the upcoming year um the importance of audits and in the past um presentation if I may just talk about that is because if you recall it was during the Olympics time frame so we were able to link um the Paris p a r i s with audits if you wonder how the linkage work you

011can look at page 10 of this report um and another fun fact that I found at the time was that the Olympics also has an audit Committee just like us to promote transparency and compliance the audit committee meets every month to talk about all matters related to risk assessment and also risk management and financial accounting methods so sure enough at FCPS we have met the global standard and then uh the last item I want to highlight is that oag continue to serve as the certified National Association of state boards of accountancy CPE provider sorry about the long name but essentially what it is that it is a National Organization that provide a certified CPE continued um professional uh education and we uh are certified to do that and I just checked today on the board

012they have over 2,000 sponsor and the only K12 organization that I can find there is FCPS so we are very proud that that ogag can provide training to all our employees who may be certified public accountants Etc at no cost because if those credits you have to pay outside it can be expensive so with that the last thing and then I'm going to pass the mic over to that now is about the reconfirming about the quality of ogag work um that we have a peer review program um that every three years we will receive external review to check ogag work and confirm if we are following the government auditing standard or not so um the last peer review that we obtained was back in 2023 and we got a pass with no management comments that

013is the highest level of results that we can get and the last thing I want to touch upon is also the certification at ogag we have um uh different uh alphabet certification uh including certified public accountants certify internal Auditors certify fraud examiners certifi information system Auditors so it is another assurance that uh we process our Audits and also the fraud ways and abuse cases um according to the industry stand it so with that I would like to pass the time to Danelle to briefly walk us through the audits that we completed thank you Esther okay so um I'm going to refer to the audits that we completed on page 11 you see our beautiful Matrix that we have here um we completed eight performance Audits and nine business process audits um for FY 24 and

014I'll just go over at a high level um what those audits were so our first audit was food and nutrition services um during this audit we we found found two moderate one low risk and two observations so two moderate findings one lowrisk findings and two observations and so those findings were related to internal control weaknesses um uh such as inadequate segregation of Duties lack of Integrated Systems and monitoring by operation Specialists we also um had a finding as it relates to the use of benchmarking and key performance indicators um and Facilities I mean excuse me in food and nutrition services um and another that we had was relating to uh needing to update the food and nutritional Services regulation for our second audit which was facilities maintenance um we identified one highrisk finding for modded

015refindings and one observation um one of the findings was related to noted internal control deficiencies related to workflow workflow approvals um and work order documentation that is maintained in Teamworks which is facilities um maintenance management system we also identified um finding related to utilizing benchmarking and key performance indicators to measure their work um as well as um not having a comprehensive process to ensure compliance with federal state and other regulations other requirements our third audit is related to Grants um for the grants audit we identified one moderate responding and one observation um the moderate risk finding was related to um the grants that are issued at the school level um not complying with the FCPS Grant process and Grant requirements and the one observation we noted was as it relates to needing to update the

016regulation and the grants manual our fourth audit which is our it systems access audit is exempt from disclosure so I'm going to skip that one here our fifth audit is our local school activities fund audit this is the audit that we do every year and this is related to June 30th 2024 we did not identify any findings as it relates to this audit but we did have an observation related to compliance with applicable policies and regulations and so this is related to those processes like cash receipts cash dispersements and accounting procedures um and in in this audit we noted that out of the 202 sites um exceptions for non-compliance were noted at 92 schools 92 sites excuse me our six audit is our continuous monitoring audit and we do this for appropriated and non-appropriated funding

017um this is performed on a quarterly basis and for the non-appropriated funding we use this as a sample for our local school activity funds audit so the results of this um particular audit will roll up into our local school activities funds audit for those non-appropriated fundings and then for appropriated we'll kind of measure and assess to see if a business process audit is needed if we're having issues that that were noted as it relates to appropriated funding so for this particular one um continuous monitoring that we did for each quarter um out of 204 sites um 112 sites had no exceptions noted 49 sites exceptions noted in three or fewer areas and one site had exceptions noted in four areas and we had one site that had exceptions noted in six areas and out of

018our we did this on a sampl basis and we had 41 sites that did not have any transactions appear in our sample okay for our seventh audit um our seventh and our eighth audit these were some some continuous monitoring programs that we um use as a pilot for FY 24 um we use uh uh analytical software to review and test controls as related to my time and online travel so for my time the scope of the audit included time and attendance data reported in the my time system and for online travel we the scope of the audit focused on non-local trans uh travel expenses for the first quarter of FY 24 and during these two reviews we did not identify any areas of concern okay so those are our eight business process audits um we

019had nine I'm Excuse me eight performance audits excuse me um going forward we have nine business process audits um which were conducted at one office and eight schools um in total there were three moderate risk findings and 19 lowrisk findings that were identified those findings were related to timeliness of reconciliation sufficient documentation accounting procedures related to bank reconciliations Personnel payments and outstanding deposits so those were the performance Audits and business process audits that's at a high level those were the results of those Audits and with these audits will conduct audit followup and so for our performance audits we'll conduct followup on any High moderate or low findings for our business process audits we'll conduct audit followup on those moderate and high findings not the low findings so as it relates to um AO recommendation followup

020for fy4 at the beginning of FY y24 there were SE seven recommendations from prior audits um that were outstanding during the year ogag clo was able to make 21 new recommendations as a result of the audit work performed and closed 14 recommendations so as of um July 31st which is our most recent reporting period and in a minute we'll hear from Ona and she'll kind of walk us through our next reporting period as of October 31st there were 14 outstanding recommendations that remained but with that I would like to turn the time that Wonder wonderful thank you Deputy General um any questions or comments on this yes Mr thank you for the report I have a just a couple of questions to have a better understanding of some parts of your presentation let me find

021the page where you have your goal was to have a 90% of yeses in all you are able to obtain 100% so when he says number five commun what does yes IND were effective in Communications and and and findings were easily understandable we yeah so Mr we are trying to find the exact question so that we can share with you maybe you can go ahead with the other question to one more so a number seven is well a proposed fible or the recommendations whether the question was it's a feasibility or is that to were recommendations okay to answer your first question okay number five so the question is did the ogag team share preliminary findings and or observations related to this audit on a regular basis during field work okay that's 100% yes yes okay

022what about number seven proposed Fe number seven number seven yes ma'am do you believe that the proposed audit recommendations can be feasibly implemented it's a feasibility that okay got it okay and then the next one has to do with what's on page number eight and I understood what the auditor general said about number going up from 47 to 79 you gave a pretty good positive spend in increasing number so uh is the higher the number always the better then or will there be a a a certain point after which you will start having concerns so great question uh Mr Moon so um we actually um organize a DMV auditor group we try to understand what is the right number of fraud ways and abuse right um we need to get some benchmarking in the industry

023unfortunately what I found is that each internal audit kind of structured differently um sometimes actually sometimes this fraud ways and abuse hotline is not managed under internal audit they may be managed by the legal division Council Office and then cover cover more contents than just fraud ways and abuse so it's all in comparison it's always apple and orange when we try to find out what is the re able number and when I make the comment about the increase from 40 some to 80 some 47 to 79 thank you thank you to 79 is when I looked at the nature of the claims that were reported to us is is something for example I just did a training for example with the school based administrators that always trigger more calls so I can actually see link

024the what we have done over in training and then we get more calls so I as a member of a committee as a school with a member what I need to know what I need to hear from you as an expert is when should I start getting worried I think right now we don't need to worry so when should I start getting worried that's the a what I want to hear from you so that when I see that number I should ask you more proving questions I think we shouldn't just be worried or Not by a number alone right we have to look into the nature of the situations that were brought forth to us and some of them may require more attention from the audit committee which I will be sharing with you all

025either in a public setting or in a Clos meeting setting based upon the nature of what they are when I get that but at the same time I as as someone who needs to hold you accountable for your work need to have some sort of a standard by which I should hold you accountable if you do not come back to report to us because I cannot just wait until you tell us to worry about so great question I mean accountability is always a big a major thing for a for the success for the audit office right so I see this Mr Moon as a comprehensive program like fraud Wass and abuse is only one piece of it you will also hold us accountable for the audits that we completed right do we complete the audits

026approved by the school board in a timely manner and also according to the objective that we agree to do so that's that and then the fraudway and abuse to me is one piece of like the different like job responsibility that we do um how to hold us accountable again I mean is what we set up in the beginning for our plan and fraud waste and abuse is one piece that is very difficult to speculate I cannot see the crystal ball how many cases will come in can we do better of course I mean but what is the right number unfortunately I could not share with you a number or when you will get you you like on an alert but I think it's a comprehensive program based upon the audit based upon the fraudway and

027abuse based upon the trainings that we have done then you can make a comprehensive assessment on whether oag is doing meeting the goals for the school board or if we are not I'll take this conversation offline thank you can I add something I I think that just looking at that number as an audit Committee Member I look at an increased number of reported cases as actually being a good thing because it indicates that the employees are more aware of fraud waste and abuse and things that they should be reporting and bringing to the the oag office and like Esther said I think really what we need to focus on more is the individual cases and what it is that they're what they're finding in those reports and if there are you know patterns C like

028you know we might want to be really concerned if there are things in use of assets that go way up or something like that but just looking at the number itself I'm not sure like I said I kind of think with what's been going on an increas in cases is actually a positive rather than negative just my opinion I was bringing the question of because you are reporting numbers right so what are the significances of you br to our attention if numbers don't mean anything sure maybe we can um we can think more in the future right when we report upon um how we're doing it maybe in a different format and bring some other indicators to go with the trend and thank you Mr moon for that advice thank you Mr lady I just

029want to add that I appreciate the fact that you met with administrators I ever meeting with you as an administrator um because I do think unfortunately in any company as big as ours there definitely situations that need to be reported um but I was not aware of a confidential way to do that when I work for the system so I do think that that training has created an uptick but we do want our people to know they can trust to come forward when they think something is not right um and then again as the auditor general has shared I think that depending on the findings of those that would later determine maybe a height sense of worry if you will but right now I'm just see the way that the net just this is more

030awareness okay thank you for that and we're gonna move on to the second item for discussion which is good afternoon everyone I'll be presenting the audit recommendation followup status as of October 31st of 2024 as you can see we currently have six audits with OP recommendation the first item go to the next SL the first item is related to the employee evaluation process AUD One open recommendation that has been closed now this recommendation is related to the employee monitoring process um during our followup we verified that quality control checks have begun at the on the operation employee employee evaluation on a random sample basis next we have food and nutrition services there are two recommendations that are outstanding and are currently in process the first recommendation is Rel to benchmarking and key performance indicators or

031kpis per management FNS will leverage its new software system to generate kpis reports which will allow them to provide data driven assessments this action was originally scheduled to be implemented by full 2024 now per management we have a new implementation date of January 31st of 2025 next recommendation is related to FNS regulation updates according to management FNS has begun updating the regulation and expect to be completed by March 2025 item number three is related to facilitate maintenance process audit we were able to close Six recommendation by verifying that ofm had developed standard operating procedures conducted customer surveys and drafted a request for proposal or RFP to address the facili condition the facilities condition assessment recommendation we were also verifi we were also able to verify that key performance indicators or kpi have been established with

032results shares with leadership additionally we have noted that there are four outstanding recommendation related to preventive maintenance and the existing software um we noted that management have taken steps to address it however these actions are resource dependent and would like to bring it to the audit committee for discussion after this presentation next we have the grants audit we verified and closed two recommendation related to the grants application principle approval and educate grants requirements we verify the office of rers created a grants reference guide that clarifies the pre-approval process and requirements for Grants from all grantors also there is one recommendation to Grant application training which includes developing a process for schools to report all local school activity fund grants or lsaf grants this recommendation is currently in process as final Services fast team has created

033an electronic lsaf grants reporing web form and phase two testing is near completion for our last followup audit we have do our business process audit we have homes Middle School there is one outstanding recommendation uh related to nonbank reconciliation which is now closed we verified during our followup by reviewing three months of financial management reports or fmr and procurement card reconciliation and they were signed reconciled and approved in a timely manner for Holland Middle elementary school there are two recommendation related to monitoring of donation and payment to FCPS Personnel these recommendations are not due as of October 31st of 2024 so we will continue our followup on an on a courtly basis on open items or outstanding recommendations our next followup will be as of January 31st and to be presented at the mar audit

034committee meeting any question thank you so much any questions or comments on this okay seeing none we will move to adjourn this meeting and we will move to go close um so theard will make a motion to go into Clos meeting on December 19 2024 to discuss Personnel matters pursuant to the section 2.2 3711 A1 of the code of Virginia and two consult with legal counsel require regarding specific matters requiring the provision of legal advice okay okay sorry uh January 13th not December 19th to discuss personal matters pursuing to section 2.2 37111 of of Virginia and to consult with legal counsel regarding specific matters requiring the provision of legal advice pursuant to section 2.2 371 A7 A8 of Cota Virginia specifically personel matters all those moved moved by Mr Moon second by miss lady all

035those in favor it is unanimous by audit committee members so we are now en close meeting thank you than

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.