CorpusRecord 8193

12/10/24 - Public Engagement Committee Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Fairfax County Public Schools
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Fairfax County, VA
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,016 words · about 51 min
Collected
2026-06-01

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e e e e I'm sorry so we're so cozy here that I didn't think I would need the microphone um so part of this process in this work was to for me to try to organize a framework um and I know that there was a lot of work done last year to go and change things but if you look at the top part of what we're going to be looking at the priorities uh the Strategic and tactical the top part is what is the board charge what we have to complete and then the bottom part the gold Golden Rod is for us to look at and start thinking about um I know that there are some time restrictions for people today and so what I really wanted to do is for us to

002have a discussion about this and then to think about it as you know we we look into this and think about it and come back and review some of this but if this all looks like if it's something you want to do so if we start with our strategic uh priorities um that we have to complete by June 27 is to review the standing Community advisory committees with an eye to the Future and the Strategic division needs um so I'd like to open that conversation now to see what your feedback would be on that I know we have have discussed some of that a little bit but would like to get some feedback from what you think that looks like hi good morning yeah I I'm very interested in doing this work I would love

003to see us have time during a meeting to perhaps come with ideas for what um committees we might want to put in what committees we might we might want to Sunset and also how we might want to gather input from our colleagues from current um advisory committees or whomever to determine that so maybe a bit of a plan and um I think we could do it by the you know by the spring um we all have talked about it before so I think we'd have a good start so I'm really interested in that work thank you I I think we've kind of talked about this but having it in a framework I like the idea of maybe talking to some of our advisory committees because some of them may feel that they may have gotten

004too big and would like to Splinter to two committees or I know we've discuss some other committees in terms of how you know there are somewh thinking of sunsetting and what that would look like um and also talk to our colleagues about some of them have mentioned some ideas of what committees they'd like to see some new committees as as our world is changing I do think it's a good idea for us to survey folks um I it worked very very well to survey the committee leads last year like the who the chairs of each committee and I think that we could probably um create the same type of survey that we could use with board members too just to find out um we do want to make sure that we frame the questions carefully

005because some of our committees are required to be as large as they are and so um the other aspect that we haven't really talked about yet this this time around is that we we did require or we did ask the the Committees work on bylaws and so it could be that they create their own internal structure related to the in their bylaws that actually show how they break up but things like acsd and sha are are state are laws that we are we're meeting so we want to make sure that those we don't go too far down a path where we're asking those to split because they're set the way they're set on purpose thank you um so the other does anybody else have comments on yeah I do think it's also relevant to think

006about the name this um note here about does it reflect the community's oversight role I know um just comes to mind is our advisory committee for students with disabilities that's technically called something different at the state level and so then when we get into cross division conversations I know that that's an issue or for people you know we're talking about Statewide stuff so that might be just like one of those things that exemplify that we might want to especially when they're required by law think about how to um how to do that so yeah thanks and that's what I was going to move down to next and also oh I'm sorry Mr M just a question um looking at a committee name and then there's a question does it reflect the committee's oversight role are

007we assuming that committees do have oversight roles the the overall the the name of the public engagement the the the name of our name as well our name as well um I'll be honest when I said that I wanted to be in this committee I thought it was something different uh and that probably comes from my lens of what I used to do and how I would I know I I look at public engagement is actually going to the meetings and you know trying to generate more public engagement not necessarily just through advisory committees so when I first heard about PEC my perception was something different than us being the oversight Committee of the advisory committees I actually don't think that we're intended to be the oversight Committee of the advisory committees in any other

008role except their governing documents so we are not meant to the board liaison is the one who actually works with the individual committees I don't think that this committee this commit that was discussed quite a bit when we were working on the handbook um this was really about the fact that we are the organizing function so we're the ones that are making sure things are getting done um but we're not necessarily in charge of the other committees if that makes any sense so we are just the administrative function of ensuring that their documents are are like the the guide book is created and things like that but it's not necessarily that we're in charge of the other committees that was very clearly designated by so the school board as a whole is the is the

009group that's in charge of all of the Committees so we would just the same way as we would have to make any of these decisions as a whole so I just wanted to make sure that we we talk about that a little bit so that it doesn't it doesn't come across incorrectly right so so then we're pretty much like the organizing role we're we're so so that's even if it's that rule I I'm just saying like the public hearing public engagement committee and maybe it's just my lens from where I come from but in terms of it being the organizing committee for the other advisory committees it was something that for me just I felt the name didn't reflect what that we are the public maybe engagement organizing committee or something like that I mean

010not that we want to change it's just something to think about that that's just a suggestion and I don't know what your thoughts are um I mean I mean I mean I mean I I'm agnostic about the name itself but when I just saw these first two questions seeing these questions for the first time just a few minutes ago under strategic priorities and then look at complete June 27 board charge review standing advisory committees with an i to Future strategic division needs I thought that that charge was reviewing what our advisory committees were doing and then you had these two questions below and that is why I I ask whether you know other committee has I got I I got these questions completely understood completely wrong okay so yeah so the first part is what

011we're pulling through from 23 24 the orange part is proposals for 2425 think so we kind of divided it that way so it visually you could see the the teal is what we're working on now and then propos of stuff that we start to work on now for 2425 and that's something as a committee we have to agree on and that's just my perception obviously doesn't mean it's some somebody else's perception um just something to think about okay I'm just going back again name of our committee p uh is I don't really particularly have any inclination toward any direction uh and I I also do appreciate um Miss Marin's suggestion about the names of other committees too I mean maybe something our standing committees that I mean like our committee but the thought the thought

012that was brought up was also another thing for us to maybe start thinking about to add as well I mean mean our standing committee yes correct okay I don't know whether that is within our perview to look at standing committees more like there a governance issue uh uh and okay that is being referred okay and I'm still looking at going back to what is in that if you call that green is that green color all right we were we were trying to use the FC as colored okay completing June 27 Bard charge reviewing standing of are we done with that the only reason that we're not done and I'm sorry I the only reason that we're not done yet is because we haven't actually talked to our colleagues about which committees like we' we've generally

013had conversations about other committees that we think but we haven't had like a actual committee or actual discussion about which committees people we've we've had the admin committee floated where it kind of talks about the administrative I'm talking about advis committees in the green well but okay so there are two aspects right is that standing commit these standing committees are different than advisory I'm I'm so I'm just looking at this what's in what's in the green and what's happening is is that we're conflating the two because we said standing Community advisory committees and so we did do much of that right we did that when we so standing committees we have referred to as the board's standing committees which is this one right and so it's it's just confusing to write standing Community advisory committees

014because so let's just take standing out of it so what I think I understand I want to check my own understanding is one of the things we're trying to do right now is to review our community advisory committees to see are they still the most relevant and most pressing and there's work then to figure that out and then we also might you know adjust the name that's like a very secondary thing but you know getting to that point right so that's so that's underway right now this St John cutting right like by having this discussion but we need to really flesh out what the work plan is is to do that work of reviewing our our advisory committee structure right is that cor correct perfect yeah correct and I think that we had talked about

015one that's been floated up quite a bit is having some sort of like technology Committee just because it would be a way that we could pull in Industry industry professionals that could give us guidance related to certain topics that were kind of bubbling up to the top so okay so that's one piece of work the Tactical stuff you know I love tactical so um yeah this the second student representative so that was to refresh our memory our previous student board rep brought that and then we brought it um so we would want to do that we need to find out when the election is happening and I forget when in the spring because we would want to have that in place and work with staff so that all gets so so that's a complete task

016I guess I'm just trying to task out you know like what what the big chunks of work are right that and then the fleak structure reporting that could really be part of the first task right the understanding you know just reviewing our advisory committee Universe right and then um the training for staff leaon is a whole other piece but it seems like I mean reviewing our community advisory committees is will be a sizable piece of and we get to get to the things like is PEC really getting at the things so we could map that out with an expected due date but then we just um let me try and pull up while I'm listening the uh when the student rep election was last year to get a sense of when that Happ was March

017so that's yeah so we'd have to figure that out pretty soon okay but that was part of the question is whether or not we were going to use the same functionality to choose the second rep so that is a decision point that we were going to have to make cuz I think that the recommendation was from not having it come from sa for both and so that would be something but I don't know what other functionality we would have um in order to pick pick one and I definitely believe that it should be the kids that are picking who who they bring forward right and I think that another question had Arisen from some other board members about since we've now started the new student leadership and we each have so is that going to

018have an impact like would that have an impact or or would would it not and you know so now that we have 12 student leaders student leaders and maybe now that we do have 10 student leaders maybe that's where we select the second ref from so because that there's just a couple of things that happened since then I mean I I would you know I would not necessarily support a second St representative come from those two student leaders because student represent supposed to be representing students basic you know supposedly elected by schools Representatives coming to the meeting and electing them as opposed to school board members picking one for them to represent them so uh the one thing we may want to considered is I'm I'm okay with uh having a second Prion live uh

019with you know our count is so large and you know High School juniors and seniors they have a busy schedule so if it can if they can divide up their their work between two of them they will be great to one thing we may want to consider is whether whether we'll consider them to be of two equal status or one to be the representative and the other one to be a maybe a little bit of a supporting role as opposed to a equal role because somebody ultimately somebody going to have to make a decision if there is a conflict between two of them and I don't want to come in and become an arer between two of them right no I don't think any of us want that um I think that part of what

020was happening is there was some discussion as to one whether or not one was going to be an alternate or whether or not they were both going to be equal reps on the board um and then they could kind of work together to split up so that they don't have to feel like they're at the entire you know the entirety of all events they do have quite a few events that they go to and participate inre and they are tapped a lot when it's related to um just also for but a little more go ahead a little more visibility the you know the position could bring to those students two of them if they two is actually being able to sit at the de at the regular meeting if if they are of uh whether

021they can give an equal opportunity to be able I'm saying alternate rather than somebody always at the Das and have an opportunity to speak on topics versus you know doing the work behind the scene there those are two different things I think that that's what I had in mind is that having two two that were equal that they would pick and choose as to who was going to be on the day I you and I both understand that we're at at a limited number of amount of space and so we I don't think we can add on the and I don't think that that's what our goal is but I do think that having having one you know they can alternate or one a month or however they want to do it um as a

022way to split up the task so so so so my suggestion at this point is uh there'll be two and and two of them have equal chance of actually coming to a regular school with the meeting and become part of the board's discussion and debate at the Das and between two of them one to be uh St represent the other to be alternate so that at least there's a when if and they when there is any any disagreement between them somebody could make a decision somebody could make a decision about our expectation is for them to work with each other divide up the work and and so that is the approach I would like our board to take and and give that to a student counsel for them to consider whether there would be something

023from the students perspective uh would be acceptable and and supported by if they are not going to be equal Representatives on the board um which I believe is what you're saying if I'm understanding correctly then I would support having them both come from SA just because then you're not creating a hierarchy of which one is more important um from which group they're coming from and so I do think that that is something to consider if we're going to have one be an alternate and one be the primary then I I actually think that creates more conflict in the long run for the maybe the alternate not feeling like they're as as full a member and so that's why I was hoping that we could have two that were equal um if they came from different

024groups then it wouldn't be that one was more important than the other it would just be that they were both working together um I love the idea of splitting up the county we have six right now we have six um regions and having you know one one set of regions and then the other because that was something that we heard from our previous our last year's rep is that rtha talked to us a lot about the fact that she she knew her area really well but she didn't know other parts of the County as well and so just being able to split it up that way might be helpful for them too so that was something else I mean I mean I mean that's a good idea you know who you know he one could

025have come from Southern world Norther eastern or western or or read you know 1 through three versus 4 56 you know however you want to do it that is the just the only thing that H I'm hoping to avoid is you know two Str representative having different ideas of how to want to do certain things and and if that is way I I'm I'm trying to give one person a little more Authority than the other where I think that part of the reason this came up was in terms of as you mentioned the time commitment and they're really busy and I know from sitting next to the student rep um as you know as well Mr moon sometimes depending on what's going on in their lives like in terms of tasks in terms of you

026know and they're they're very faithful they come but they could split up that task of sitting at the dis or being out in the community and whether whether it's regions um I think think the consideration was the time commitment that was brought up because and also the knowledge uh based about the different regions and different areas um I understand what you're saying in terms of if they have conflict but I also think that's part of leadership skills learning to resolve things and learning to come together and learning to compromise um I think that's where we try to model that for them um but I think all of these are good ideas that we will take into consideration and that then um we would ask I know Rita was very interested in helping with this and

027we can ask Megan and they can kind of I would love to hear their ideas and have them flesh it out because because they're the ones doing it you know absolutely absolutely I think you know you know whatever the ideas you may have you want to give that to Megan to take back to students and then hear from students if they can come up with the recommendations how they should be done I think that it's a probably a better approach than we dictating you got to you know do this way and otherwise we're not gonna go and one thing that I just came to my mind was you know in the past that we had student Representatives who were able to find time even during the day to come to schoolb work session it might

028not have been a whole day could have come in for a couple of hours depending upon topics and voice student opinions on certain issues in a grading policy could be one right affecting them student discipline could be another right so so but for the I guess last seven eight years I had seen that so that was just something that wow because we do we long ago we got to really value when student representative spoke up and certain issues directly affecting I mean everything affects them but more so on their daily life and then we really got to listen to them and that part was if he could find a way to encourage for them to be able to do that uh is probably will be a benefit to all of us at a school system

029I completely agree I think our students are the wisest um advisors that we have and some of the things I've heard them say are just like drop the mic you know it's like we learn from them so much so then I think oh yeah something I wanted to share is at some point during my first term I looked into understanding more about the student board Representative election process because it's very separate like so staff run the election and what I understood at the time is that every school determined their student um representatives in their Student Government whatever way they did and then whoever got onto the the student advisory Council and then the staff would run that election but like sometimes the board wouldn't know when the election was or we'd be invited to observe

030but to my knowledge there wasn't a time when we were actually talking about like what the school board does and so the previous student rep might have shared their experience which is should totally be part of it but um I found in working with the student reps after that sometimes you know they're like oh I didn't realize I could do this or I don't I could do that so I think there's also like I see like a broader piece of work around it definitely it's the student engagement but if we're just going to focus on the student rep piece figuring I had a better align with that election process um and then onboard them and like transition them over you know do we do something like we did for the new student leadership where it's

031all of us and we get to meet the student rep and and that kind of thing and I also wanted to share that vsba the Virginia Schoolboard Association is actually having a webinar maybe this week I got to dig it up but they um have some findings around how to best engage student voice and it's going to include student board reps on this webinar so that could be a good resource um as well one other thing I I wonder too is like if we think three years out to the end of you know this board's term so what if this year we hash out you know how to get this second board student rep started but then I always wonder about what about like middle middle school students or even Elementary School like we default

032a high school because they're likely generally more articulate and they've been through the system now but there's also space certainly for middle schoolers and doesn't mean we have to have all these different board reps but it could be even a toolkit for board members to say this these are ways to engage students you know you could have your round taes you could have your student like that could be helpful too so I just share that but um I did just before I finish this little turn I went through and looked at all of the items on the the pretty colorful page and really what we've talked about so far are two of six tasks that are before us us and the first two are pretty meaty right we've got the reviewing the community advisory committee

033which also includes that piece about ensuring that our FCPS staff who are assigned to support that committee again like they're clear what they're doing the board memb clear what to expect so that's like a subset of this whole let's review our advisory committees with the public which feels very public engagement committee like Focus like that seems like and then we've got this the second board rep but really it's about student and engagement if we really want to even elevate it it's student engagement student voice then we've got um the community participation standards for the general public reviewing and streamline the proclamation process if that's even us that that should do that the magisterial district piece for reviewing how when proclamations overlap into many um Fairfax magisterial districts and then how to make sure our minutes

034which the public relies on are you know set and how they're stored so these are a lot of important things and looking at our schedule you know I'd love to map out you know does someone want to be a lead do we want to work together because um yeah we're going to have to figure out how to collect all this input so Y and and part of this exercise at looking at this is also you know is this something that everyone is on board with or or like you should say well really I don't think we should have we should look at this or you didn't think about this why why isn't this here so part of this exercise was to look at this and see and definitely start mapping out but do is this

035the work that on the yellow part is this what we want to do is this where I mean the the green part is our is our charge the the yellow part is reflective of 2425 and is this some of what we want to do is um I mean I think you brought up some really good points thoughts I do think that the the onboarding I'm hoping that the onboarding related to student reps is going to be helped by the handbook that they're working on and so I do think that it might be helpful for us to give that group of people that are working on that a date when we're hoping to have it back so maybe by the May meeting I think we have two meetings in May so the May the like the

036later May meeting it may be a great time because that would be around the time that we would have to have it ready um to give forward and it's far enough in advance that we probably could get that H to happen um so if we could have that done by that last meeting in May then that would be a really easy way for us to say yay nay and then I I guess that Melanie would that that would require a board vote to pull that in to create it as a handbook for the student representative I think so I just am not 100% sure I don't know I mean I think these are it's it's fun and interesting to talk about these ideas and questions and then some of them I think are part of

037the work right that's maybe that's one of those things um I would think it would because we voted on the handbook related to advisory committee so it would make sense to me that it would be um but that also means that we need to make sure that we change the governance manual to to state that it's there so that people that are going to look for it can can know what they're looking for I mean I think it it depends and this is where working with the I think it's instructional services staff and the equity team that they run the student um elections like I wonder if it's part of their stuff in which it's not really a board thing like that's a whole another conversation like what needs to be voted on by the

038board right because it's really a student so like that could be part of that process I guess yeah I I would definitely want our board to have a say in what's included because they're our representative even though there the elections are conducted by another group I do think that it's it makes sure it would be important for the handbook itself to kind of at least be discussed by the board to make sure that we're all on track with what it's suggesting as the requirements for students I can see that yeah I don't know about an actual vote but okay but I could see that yeah thanks um otherwise I do I know up to this point that the proclamation process has has been dealt with in PEC before and so I think that that was

039the reason that it was discussed as bringing it back here um I do see that there are several buckets of work here that people could kind of take on part of it um and then come back I think that that would be a faster way for us to get things done but um and in minutes in the process in storage I believe that that's with the clerk's office I know that we can we can discuss with the clerk where we stand I know that the the chair and I have been working with with her um to see where we standing to ensure that those minutes are are up to date and everything's legally um are we talking about advisory committee minutes though there I I was talking about P minutes like minutes for the standing

040yeah that's what I was talking about I don't know if you feel I mean that's a question that has been raised now and what your thoughts are on that I know that up to this point we have had meeting minutes in some way shape or form related to advisory committees I do think that that in my opinion is a best practice moving forward for those folks that can't attend those meetings um and so I do think that it's important particularly as they're voting on things because it does give us a record of what's happened in each of those committee meetings it's just making sure where those get published because they're in a different location so that also requires the oversight related to what's getting put on the website so there are some components here because

041those meeting minutes are actually published on the individual committee page not necessarily in board docs where all of our me meeting minutes are am I wrong about that okay so this is a question more for Sandy Anderson as Vice chair okay I I would be more inclined to have everything done the same way so if we have our public meeting minutes for regular meetings then they should live with the meet they get approved say at a one meeting and then they get back placed into the past meeting I think that for standing committees you are correct I think for advisory committee meetings because they're not noticed on they're not an agenda okay but I thought we were talking about PC just now U Miss Brown right but wasn't Marc you talking about PC but I

042I was was but then when she brought that up I said I was talking about P okay well just one question real quick can we take binding votes though can like these standing committees of the board take binding votes like governance if we vote to or this committee right if we vote to change the governance manual is that like a vote the way that the board it's a record of our action to the board okay so does so then I would say ours minutes should live on board docs where for the standing committees for the standing board committees I agree with you okay for advisory committees yes for the community advisory committees well I would love to have a standard and regular you know updated I also think that there current ly the way that

043the refresh website is as nice as it is I think it's hard to find these advisory committees it used to be much easier they're a little buried yeah Miss Brown um what we're doing now is we have it on the events page if you look on the events page it has the advisory committees and then once they have pass the minutes we are posting them to board docs within five days oh excellent where is the events p is the events page on the FCPS website on board docs if you look under the section all the way to the right where it says like general or library and then you click on the carrot and then C you know that sounds really complicated I don't I like it in both locations so I'm I'm perfect I

044I personally would say if I'm going to find it having more paths to success isn't necessarily a bad thing and so I like the idea of it being linked on their advisory committee website as well so that way it could be linked to board dos in the direct link to the and so that way they could get to it both ways depending on where they were coming from yeah but when it gets to it board dos having it I mean I think it should be it should follow follow the way that we have all of our meetings which is you click on the agenda for agendas passed and then you see the meeting minutes it's not on events Library like it's a meeting it's a public meeting so the minute should live where the public

045meeting agenda is the if if I'm understanding correctly the the agenda for the advisory committees I well no no and we're so we're we're crossing paths here so standing committees are 100% you're right that's where they live she's what Miss Brown was talking about was the advisory committee minut yes so it's the other bucket not not standing sorry I've never looked at an events page on board doc so I would say save your time and you know yeah have you have to probably legally required because they are a so that seems like as part of the review of the advisory committee work is to is to look at how are we best communicating about our committees I agree okay right because I would not think to look at events like if there was a tab

046there that said I clear I don't think I have ever go to that event page uh and and for advisory advisory committee meeting minutes as long as that is on the advisory committee site I think for the general public right that's where oh there's this committee AAPAC is discussing on this particular issue and that's really I have a lot of interest I want to see what they're doing and then they should be able to go and then be able to take a look and then they will go our website and advisory committee they'll put ADV AAPAC and then go there and then that's where they should go the benefit of having it duplicated on on boarddocs is that it's searchable and so that is a benefit of having it in two locations I don't I

047don't disagree with you but I think having two paths to success here would be a good thing as long as is there for the general public to go come to our website and be able to find it Well I think this is if this is a new feature we board members should be informed about it and told about it like and make sure we really know about it and put it in our newsletters and you could even go in a toolkit I mean you know it could be something that is even in the FCPS wide I mean there's a lot here with the advisory committees that you know there could be just a piece about Communications in all the ways you know for the Committee Member for the public the board member so um what

048I again like just to summarize I mean I hear great interest in US wanting to really like I If We Had to label this task it's Community advisory committee overview right Community advisory committee review and then the other one that we've talked a lot about is I would say it's called elevating student voice right because it's bigger than just that student board rep piece and it could include you know what are we learning about the student leadership program and and all of that but definitely you know how would we go about incorporating a second board rep but um so those seem to be the two big ones and then we've got the reviewing the community participation standards I'm not sure what's involved with that maybe someone who's more familiar could share that and then the

049proclamation process which is like a never- ending uh gift and then the magisterial district boundaries I know some of our board members had particular interest in them so maybe now that you've had this analysis done it's just a matter of someone being the person to share it around and get the feedback and we bring it to decision so okay I I think that sounds good I think um I know it's a lot and it's getting down in the weeds but I think these are things we have to work out and and I'm coming from a point of view like the events page as someone that is going to go look like even when I think we have to look like when we're communicating with the public we have to be accurate when I look at

050an event I don't think a committee meeting I think of a a different kind of event you know and so if we could change that tab to say advisory committee minutes or so I mean just be as transparent as possible I don't know we can do something like that I'm GNA ask our Deputy clerk to put that on post chairs for this week so that we can discuss it because what thank you just going to what Mr moon was saying if somebody in the community says oh I'm interested in this they may not know what they're interested in but if there's a bucket where you go see they may not even know there's an advisory committee you know and I worked my work has been with people that it's hard for them to access this

051stuff they may not even know it exists but if we make it easy then they'll go and realize what committees do exist to understand where their interest might lie because we're making making assumptions that they know they even exist and that they're going to look into the minutes and say this is a topic I'm interested in and my whole thing is let's if if you say these are the advisory committee committees that the community can engage in it's not an event it's actually where you can participate in this committee so that I what you're saying is what I want people to do but I I want to make it more accessible easier to get to and not make assumptions that the public even knows that advisory committee exist can I volunteers as tribute to work

052on um the community advisory committee stuff I'm happy to help like lay out what the framework is of what I think needs to happen um moving forward and then start to put some St in condemn motion and then melie as long as it's not I somewhere and then Melanie because you've done so much work with the the election stuff up to this point would you would you be interested in continuing to work I'm not trying to like take over I'm just asking that really helps because I'm learning how to be a committee chair just send me an access to the link I'm just joking yeah I um no I'm I'm happy to take point on this on task two I'm calling it the Elevate student voice and I could certainly talk with Mr mine about

053that as well and um I'm even talking to our student board rep this evening so the other I do want to add though I would like to be I I'm eager to give to share input about the community advisory committee review because Marcia what you mentioned about people understanding that the Committees exist I've had a question about you know can the public just come and watch because we've had instances in the past where we've made it kind of like a work session where the non you know seated members can watch but they can't participate and so like is that really of interest to people to come or like and also just how we as board members engage with our appointees like we have some board members that have quarterly I think meetings where all of

054their members come we have others like I've tried to do quarterly phone calls like again I think the idea of some kind of toolkit for all parties involved like of you know what could be and what maybe needs to be you know it could be you know again the staff liaison right that goes back to you know our community our um Chief engagement officer and like how are they ensuring you know not only that they're Staffing the committee and the board member but that they are communicating to the chief engagement office officer about what's happening um and there's always been a rub that our our community our committee members you know I know we're going to try something different this year with having these Summits where we hear from them but like a lot of

055times like I would love to think of them as very real time um advisers so it's not like okay we're going to wait until May and then hear what you have to think but um you know I think that if we can figure out a way to do that and it's going to take board member effort as well but but again saying like ideally or to optimize your committee advisory person here are things you can do and like and I also think we could have report outs at our regular work at our regular meetings or our work sessions or if it's a work session that's topically related we could be like hey liaison for this advisory committee like we're going to expect you to come and share some input you know we could really do

056a lot more um so I think it's a really cool place to expand because it's also harder than ever I think to have to get people to commit to being volunteers so if if they're going to actually commit I think we should really make it worth their while and get all the good stuff out of them you know that we can so can we talk about magisterial districts because we might be able to knock that one out mind if we no yeah because this did come up at our board meeting and um at our last board meeting when we were talking about proclamations and so you have a couple of ideas there in terms of when we were talking about the definition and um you know I I know what I think about this but

057I would like to hear your feedback can you just rephrase what the the matter is at hand so we were talking on the board about when we did proclamations pertaining to schools or pertaining to certain things and then we were talking about what was it at a work session or a board meeting I can't remember I think it was at a board meeting and then we started talking about well is is it a magisterial district is it some and we know that sometimes something sits physically in a magisterial district but maybe the percentage of the population is from somewhere else so who's going to bring that proclamation to honor that school you know it's their 75th anniversary and obviously we work together to like if we have 50/50 or whatever one brings it one seconds

058it but that became a discussion and I'm like I think if we Define it it would be easier um and then we put for consideration that at larges don't have magisterial districts but there are a lot of schools that you know like TJ and Bryant did that serve everyone so maybe that would be the place where uh at largest could participate bringing that Proclamation so that we can share the um the honor but if you look at you know the different options what would you look at I mean I know where I sit I would like to get your feedback without me influencing so I do do have a chart that it's a little dated now and I was hoping it would be updated with the membership numbers but I know another board member does

059this as well and it seems like this is one of those things where if 12 of us want to do it we could each 12 do it where in reality we could probably ask the superintendent to just give us the master list and then we take what we need but that number changes every year and I don't know that it's drastically changed in some of mine but um like that is one thing I think then just needs to be current is is that we have to make sure that the membership numbers are current and that's got to come from the superintendent you know and so that usually membership closes September 30 we used to get an update soon after but then I think there's another update in January I'm not sure again if it's a

060few students here and there I mean the numbers um so I just want to mention that too that there is a data component to option one I'm in I'm in favor of leaving it that the magisterial district is where the school resides um and then use have the board member cuz I I am one of the people that have several that are in my school that I am not the not the largest magist like not the largest member in terms of coverage um I don't have a problem sharing with my at large colleagues for these types of things so if I have a school where I've got 20% but it literally it sits in Springfield I I mean I don't feel the need to be involved in every single one of them I do like

061I do significantly encourage us to consider schools that are serving the entire County should be considered all of our schools regardless of where they reside because technically the Burke School sits in my in my district but I don't I don't claim that as just my school and so particularly when we're talking about schools like TJ and Mountain View and Bryant I I do think it's a good idea to have all of those schools be and I love the idea of making sure that they are specifically for the atlarge members um and if it just changes the percept perception of how we're talking about magisterial so I am in favor of option two and the for consideration that would be what I would vote yeah M here again I think we've been spending way too much

062time on Proclamation and and who's going to do well and how that's going to be done and and then spending I've never seen any poor spending in so much time and word smithing every every Proclamation and go through a Google doc and trying to find the consensus and then wait until the last minute and we need one more vote on this I okay come on this is all 99% of them are ceremonial uh just trust each other uh and and just option or option to as an energe member but really really doesn't concern me but I would prefer where the a a school is physically located so that we know we know at least for the proclamation it's not going to change depending of on in number of students which could fluctuate from year to

063year when it becomes very close 49% and 51% it could have flip every year and but on the other hand does it really matter who brings the proclamation right and and also since I'm an a large member I consider all schools as my schools I'm just giving deference to The magicial District board members if they want to bring their Proclamation I don't need to fight over that right so just I let them but if I really car about certain school for example if we talk about my kids school then I may go to that District board members say by the way this is blah blah and then if F so that's how I will approach but this is it's not really worth spending so much time on great then I think we can move on

064it sounds like uh option uh two and the for consideration so how do we move that forward yeah and actually that was my preference so I'm glad so can we all vot so now it goes to the board for or we're just going to make it so or I would I can talk to the chair as well I think that this makes the most sense to bring forward I don't necessarily think that it needs a I don't know if it needs a vote I can I can check with um the chair but I also think that it could just be when you report out for the next meeting um for p so thank you yeah and I agree with a lot of what you said I think that the whole thing with proclamations so many

065of them are boilerplate but I also know that sometimes it's hard to find them and so I think that's what we have seen with some proclamations is um like I think there are boilerplate ones that we know that are the ones that we do all the time and I think if they're just sitting there we know this month that is this and if anyone wants to update to add like I know when we do a boiler plate Proclamation I like I like to personally this is my personal um preference is that say that say we're doing the Hispanic heritage but if I can highlight people from Fairfax County and students then I think that's where the to me personally the value of the Proclamation is Raising some of our own community members so if there

066are boilerplate ones that we can access and that we can see and have them you know their boilerplate they're there we know and if somebody says in someone in someone's District just did something and they fit the bill and they want to add that then it can be done but I agree with you I think there's a lot of time spent on them and for one word or another um you you you know Mercia at a good point since you used the Hispanic heritage celebration Proclamation if you were picked or you volunteer to do it you want to do it I'm going to trust you unless I see something that really objectionable then I will approach you personally right to would you consider this that's what I meant to say to trust our colleagues while

067working on Proclamation rather than spending unnecessary amount of time that can be better used to somewhere else I did want to offer a clarification um because it was a little confusing for some of us that had just come on the board the first year that these proclamations were done since they were determined in PEC that was why we were given options to to provide input the last few have been repetitive they're the just the ones that are the yearly and so we did not receive an option to provide comment so there is a moment that we eventually probably doesn't need to happen anytime soon but we probably should at least make sure that when we're looking at the at the scope of all of the proclamations that they're somewhat equivalent so that we don't have

068some that have had your touch of adding extra things related to the county and others that don't have that because it may it may come across incorrectly um one of the things that we haven't talked about yet that I do and I know you're tired of talking about proclamations but I'm going to bring up one more thing um if we can continue along the path of making of having every school anniversary at every meeting I agree with you that it's going to it's going to add to even more we've worked really hard in our short time on the board to make sure that those proclamations were kind of rained in just a little bit because they were taking an extensive amount of time um I I am promoting that we do this very similarly to

069the way we do vhsl is that and we could actually do this in January for the coming year since it's actually a physical year that that a school turns is that that first meeting back or sometime in January we do uh here all of our anniversaries for the year kind of thing and that way if people wanted and we could read them off and invite everyone to come and have pictures and that way it's it's more like what we do with vhsl for all of our different winners um and so that way it's doesn't take as much of our board meeting time throughout the year so that would be my advocacy to kind of to to do it with the calendar year and also I have found I'm just going to add I have found

070that it really means a lot to a school uh I know one of my schools had an anniversary but I actually went to the school and they had their their meeting and did the proclamation there for them and that's that's what means something too cuz all the staff can't come in an evening but to have the proclamation there and to let them know and to you know um so maybe that's another thing we can look at and maybe there would be some board members that if I say hey this is you know I'm going to go to school and I want if any of you want to join me if they can go fine if not but if it's your school and you're recognizing them and you want to recognize the community then being at

071the place it's like having the birthday party at their place versus asking them to come and so few people can come at that time and Miss seiser Heiser and I did that last year when Robinson couldn't participate because they were having they had a band concert we actually took the took the certificate related to their achievement for vhsl and took it to the school and presented it to the class and so I do think that there's a way that we can still do those things and where but it just streamlines streamlines the process for our side of it so and you know and I don't think I've talked about proclamations in a year and a half because I also think that in the past an enor amount of time has been spent but just to

072share that it was because for some of our board member it is it is a very important opportunity to highlight certain topics and people and celebrations and advocacy points and so it has now been at least a full year that we've used this newer process which I've received feedback from the community that they love it way way much more it's much quicker I think this could also be maybe an opportunity to report at one of our regular meetings and say and share some of this Miss John cunning and say you know just to remind the public like the point of these proclamations is to highlight particular topics people matters that the board wants to call our attention to and you know we are very you know thoughtful about this I also think that there is

073some tweaking that could be done there's some um duplication I love the idea of doing all of the things you know the the school um anniversaries and such the only thing is that I just you know we made the move to do all the photos together which was great cuz we saved time from the board going up to the risers and back however when we have something where we've got like one or two people who are there and we read their Proclamation and then we have like a slew of other people and they're all waiting like we I want to figure out how to maybe let people not sit so long it kind of like takes away their excitement it's like we honor them and now you're going to sit for 10 minutes while everyone

074takes photos so just some kind of balance and maybe it's a meeting by meeting basis but um you know for particularly when we do our purple star our schools or our national um uh certified teachers nctp right uh we know when we do big groups of people maybe considering having just that one for the night maybe that's the way to go um this way everyone's there for the big celebration and I totally agree with going to schools again but Schoolboard members may want maybe people aren't aware of that like that's an option you could take it to the school I mean I would like to go rather than asking people to schle to you know the Central Center of fair ex and during rush hour so for consideration if you want to you know update

075our board members or just refresh them about these options and things in the public thank you I I know I think I think we'll get there with proclamations and we'll refine it um I do know that it means a lot to some of our community members and they get really excited and they and they love that so and um it's the one way that we can honor it but streamlining it is important um for everyone and and it it's a far slap for some of our community members to come to gate house not Gate House to uh Luther Jackson we need we need a bigger more steps so that we could take that more risers so we can take have more pictures more people on the risers so are we doing anything further exactly with

076proclamations then or we voted on the magisterial was kind of part of that it sounds like Vice chair you're going to take some stuff back about process so are we knocking out tasks that's like three that's like half of the list I think that uh I'm going to look back in the governance manual for proclamations and see um we made some changes this year already just to kind of clean up some of the language but I'm going to one I we do not have in there right now our process for VHS C or any of those larger nights and so I do think that it would be worth it to get the process put in the governance manual so that it's clear as this board transitions to the next board and things like that that

077there's no question um so I do think that maybe I love the idea of only doing like vhsl night only doing vhsl Pro like that because it's such a large amount of time that maybe people understand what they're getting into a little bit better um and so and then having more having the other having the other meeting that month unless there was something hugely time sensitive like I know that in the past we've tried to get Veterans Day as close to Veterans Day as possible but I think that maybe we can put that qualifying language that unless there's a Time bound um Proclamation that we we would reserve it for a different night so I do want to say that I mean we talk about updating the governance manual but this to me is a

078very procedural thing like this to me is more of like a Schoolboard office operational thing I I think because it's as long as we authorize it in the governance manual that it will be held that the the procedure will be held with the Schoolboard office I worry about because we've got so much procedure in the governance manual related to proclamations that that's fair I mean I'd love to when I think of you know the next three years one of the things would be like a real wholesale you know updating which I attempted to do in the first term and we've made good updates but now at this point I think it needs a real clean scrub so that's TBD not on this list the only other thing that it seems we haven't really talked about

079is the community participation standards for the general public so for things like the regular school board meetings work sessions forums and public hearings so this I know that this concern came up in terms of what the expectations are in even though we read what the decorum is like what the enforcement is in terms of um while respecting The public's ability and interest to express what they feel but to what extent does if it starts to interfere with the process of our business to what extent when does Action get taken I know that those were concerns that were brought up and I am not sure where there's that line of where things become extremely disruptive if we take a what what the procedure is to either take a recess um uh to remove some members of

080they're behaving extremely unruly like that that was kind of where where this came from there's a legal question here as well um we need to to talk to division Council about whether or not we actually can physically move remove someone or if they just have to be given another alternative location to be able to watch the meeting I think that that um there was some question about a in a training that we did earlier this year there was a question about whether or not that was what the requirements were related to that in the foil law so um I I we all support having the public at our meetings we want their participation and you know discussion um we just need to make sure that it's done in such a way that it doesn't impede

081the ability for us to to get stuff done which I think has only happened um once since we've been on the board so um I know that as we move into more and more contentious topics that this is going to be more of a problem moving forward and so from one thing that I did want to say is we talk about decorum but we don't talk about necessarily the decorum of the audience as much as we do for Community participation and so that is something that I've wondered whether or not there's some sort of agreement when you walk in that posted that this is this is the expectation for your behavior could they could he ask a division councel to uh could you schedule a close session for our committee and and and have a

082conversation with the division Council of about uh what clarify right legal recourses may be available to the school board uh when there is a a behaviors which is disrupting the business of the meetings okay you know I want to share when the previous board was uh reviewing our public engagement for the process for the public comments we looked at a number of models both the Fairfax County Board of Supervisors and other Schoolboard members and there are models and there's even research that talks about how you know it is a decision to not have the board respond after each public comment so that could be a point do we want to have time to respond I mean you know so you figure someone comments the board responds comments the board responds or do we only respond

083in some ways or you know it could be anything from a constituent talking publicly and they want a response and it could just be even the superintendent saying we're going to have a staff member follow up you the the board chair says it or if a member of the public says something that is um in opposition to you know data that we have and we could clarify and say well this data is here you can go look so I'm just saying like that is an option in a practice it does have a Time component which when we reviewed these public comment processes last in the last board we were focused on um you know keeping it a balance of time for the public to talk and time for the business of the board maybe that's

084up for reconsideration but I'm not sure that other board members know that it it could be a practice to do or maybe at the end of the block of comments but we have to figure out how do we synthesize what do we do so um anyway just for consideration um that that's a great Point I've really never thought of that I was just thinking more of um the one meeting where it was I believe Maybe the first or the second meeting for our student representative um and she was visibly very frightened on I was sitting next to her and I was strategizing how I would protect her um because of some of the behavior of the audience um so I was thinking more in terms of the public uh not necessarily the people that are

085speaking but when there were people in the public getting up and moving down the aisle um and shouting and uh that that's kind of what I was thinking of and I guess that protective maternal Instinct kicked in and at that time I know that not only I but other people that are new to the board were thinking where's the line of again like you say legally where people have a right to voice their opinion um but if there is perceived danger which I felt sitting next to the student was visible then that's where my thinking went to that we need to go to council and figure out okay yeah let's have that conversation with uh division counsel okay but I do think it's it's a safety issue and I do think that is appropriate to

086share publicly that as school board members we feel at times in and our students can and even members of our audience in the public who are waiting to speak or there to observe the public process have voice that they feel scared so um you know we do have security there and we have security briefings so if that's a matter that we need to review more regularly and it's certainly with the student voice piece you know when we onboard our student reps do they know all the exits and and all of those things but um you know it's uh I've seen it Go different ways I've seen the board take a recess and it only gets more heated I've seen board take take a recess and it doesn't so I I think it's important to know

087our legal rights but I also think as we continue to try and you know um convey Civility and model it we have to ask the public to do that as well so thanks for bringing it up I think on this you know we our our followup is to to talk to division Council so thank you so I think we've kind of covered everything if there's anything here and try the gift of time I think we've been very efficient um I'm going to write up notes and do some follow-ups of where where we're going to move forward I'm really excited to move forward with this work um I don't know if anybody else has any comments I wish you all happy holidays in the gift of time is the best that we can get at this

088during this time of the year so okay thank you you're welcome thank you for your input for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.