001Bond related so we'll hold call for other comments okay is there any public comment that is not related to an agenda item and I'm looking on Zoom as well any public comment not related to any agenda item I don't see any do you Stephen already okay I'll ask again is there any public comment for any agenda item not sorry any item not on our agenda excuse me okay well then the first item on our agenda is approval of the consent agenda and I had one question about it so sorry and I forgot to ask about it for the item that is actually resolution 12 1236 it lists this current calendar year in the resolution is that is that true yes that is true it covers this year and um we can be submitting it any
002time during this year so yes thank you for that clarification question uh with that uh I will take a motion I move the consent agenda be approved as presented second all those in favor say I I I I I any oppos there the next item on our agenda is establishment of the regular agenda are there any changes uh yes there were two changes to the agenda um since it's been posted publicly the first is the topic that was previously listed as 2025 Bond discussion was updated today to say 2025 school bond and April Levy discussion um there is um you know options for possible action for the board on this topic and a presentation with additional reference materials were also uh uploaded as links to the public agenda and the second item that was added
003was uh about the structure of schools discussion uh for the board to discuss with possible action okay well we will move on then to the first item on our agenda which is Works in progress great thank you um I'll be brief because a lot of the comments that I would have are also related to topics on the agenda itself um so last week uh we had several weather issues so I always want to make sure that we talk about that um and then there's always more in the works and so we were navigating those issues and just again a huge appreciation for our team members out there doing the hard work of assessing our school buildings and making them ready for staff and students to be on site for learning um there was an impact
004on our schedule and so I want to make sure that we are talking openly about those calendar adjustments and as of now seniors will have two Saturday schools and then we're slated to go to June 25th and we will be submitting a waiver request we have received questions about that that is a process that which we go by um and OPI reviews that and there are some technical things that they um have in their waiver request process and we will um be trying our best um and then questions have come up around uh flipping to online learning as Seattle public schools had done and so of those um an important thing that does happen for flipping to online learning while a school might be closed for in-person learning it does require uh sort of pre-planning
005well in advance and also uh negotiation and conversations with our labor Partners so that is um something that we um don't currently have in our in our you know agreements but we um certainly will consider that for the future because we saw that that was one of the things that were um recently adjusted although I do know that you know two days in a row of remote learning they'd become more reminiscent for people of the time when there was full-time remote learning and maybe not as enjoyable at the time so um that is an update there um on the Strategic plan last uh this week we met with the strategy leads of the Strategic plan and spent time doing a midyear um and as well as mid three-year assessment uh and reflection not only uh
006to sort of take stock of where we are to see where they're having celebrations to make connections across the different strategies for where um the work can intersect and be reinforced and Amplified um and what new opportunities might be coming forward but also um preparation for a reflection time with the board at the board retreat in March and that was very helpful um I've talked a little bit about our Tech deep Dives and so this week Martin turny and Marcel Houser and I had a great meeting uh with Microsoft to discuss what possible opportunities exist for school districts to plug in uh more closely with product development uh to understand best um and highest use of products that we currently we have not only to enhance the teaching and learning process and Learning Journey for
007our students but to make sure that we are staying on the Forefront with our um you know backyard neighbor so to speak um as well as think about ways we could also add organizational capacity um to ensure that we're doing um the best things uh that humans can do by leveraging tools that accelerate both Effectiveness and efficiency so that was very helpful we met with a principal group product manager in Microsoft education as well as a senior director um of strategic accounts who who does uh oversee medical centers and higher ed but um has adjacent um expertise in the education space for for K12 um the legislative session is in um full swing and so we've had several members of our team testifying for a range of topics that um are very numerous so I'm
008not going to list them out but I appreciate Martin turny Jason Morris Laura carmichel and Aaron mcke Who provided testimony on a range of topics with the legislature and then finally I'll close with um a a new uh item that I added to my my Cadence and work calendar but also was a great opportunity just get to be in the space with colleagues here at the district office um I had an open open Office hours time this week for folks in the district office and we had over 45 people come through in that hour and the format was unstructured it was meant to say you can come and go you don't have to stay here for the full hour uh you can come for a bit you can have a snack we did offer some
009snacks and that's always a good thing but um colleagues really shared what was top of mind for them uh some top themes that did come out um were questions about the bond and what happens next and this was actually on Wednesday so after uh the Tuesday February 11th election day and there was enormous amount of pride and gratitude for the district that was expressed many staff members are parents are married to uh parents uh are a lum of the district and so um there was a lot of just opportunity for people to share and and that appreciation and gratitude for the kind of um unique and amazing educational opportunities that this school district does provide that's it for me can you just provide greater Clarity for our community about the waiver is it uh is
010there a minimum or maximum number of days and uh how would that look like just in the sense of obviously we don't winter is no not over but we know we're already up to five so yeah so there there's actually probably several technical things that are come into play here but um you know the school districts do have to have a minimum of 180 days um that that we are teaching students and so and we have to also provide uh a number of instructional hours as well and that does vary by level so uh schools can um request a waiver and they have to meet a series of thresholds such as the number of hours that's uh on average of requirement across the levels um as well as have had an opportunity to make up
011three school days already uh for for closures that have happened and that there's a line there that says per incident which is uh one that we will be um testing out um there's making sure that we have made reasonable effort to make up those instructional hours as well as to um ensure that we are um using the days potentially that were scheduled vacation days or foreseen School closure makeup days on the calendar so there's a a variety of factors but um we've certainly had um enough days that weren't us making an attempt to get this waiver thank you we appreciate it other questions at all no perfect uh thank you for that the next item on our agenda is 2025 school bond and Levy discussion I think I would rather us not start with the
012motion that seems a bit premature so I think is there a district presentation we have a short District yeah about five minutes and I I'd like to welcome up Mark Sherwood and Martin tney to just share a recap of the 2025 February Bond um that was just is still in progress for some validation and vote counting but um yeah we'll pass it over to mark thank you superintendent and board members good evening I'll be brief as requested um the numbers that are we can go to the next slide if you could yeah just providing the results there actually was some uh recent results that just came on just before the meeting uh there wasn't a significant movement uh basically uh it's down to 46% approved and 53% rejected and right now the uh it appears
013it'll be a validated vote but uh they've only counted to date uh 23,000 votes votes at the this point so we're still at roughly about 31% in terms of the validation but it appears that it will be validated next slide um these are just two I just wanted to make sure that we capture these are two articles of interest that c captures a bit of a timeline and also activities based on the super majority a requirement of a bond um uh some of our students were involved uh members of our of our of our team and uh just there just some good opportunities to kind of get a snapshot and a timeline of of some things that have happened over time leading up to this Bond next slide these are campaign metrics I I won't
014go into great detail I just wanted to make sure at least we had a good closing out on it in terms of uh using and leveraging our own channels uh did have some great success in terms of the reach in terms of the open rates the click-through rates they're all above industry benchmarks which are are wonderful uh a lot of people are viewing our videos um if you looked at the video uh metrics on the screen right here you'll notice our students are very high so at the end of the day students win on on the video contest if uh you want to look at it from that perspective um events we had our school board uh Town Hall Financial Forum uh board members and superintendent and uh Chief uh attorney participated in some PTSA
015uh um Council and local meetings and the Chamber state of the city next slide these these are some top themes and sentiments of of supporters and one of the things obviously in a very quick turnaround um I didn't have a chance to look at every single element out there but I went went and looked at all the different platforms from redddit to next door to Facebook try to bring in as many of those themes what they were most mentioned and then rank them Bas based on the number I've mentioned and I really for me it was also out to see if our messaging was in line with what people were speaking and talking about so as you can see from the top uh overcrowding uh no increase to the tax rate and upgrades to safety
016those are the top three themes of our messaging and that's what people were at in terms of the supporters were were carrying on on social media and again this is more of a snapshot I don't want to say this was a comprehensive of looking at every uh platform and also talking to other members uh in different areas of the community who may not be online so it's not a full comprehensive type survey I think you just went to the wrong slide we go back to slide down yep and again these are just the top themes of the of the supporters that they were repeating and in terms of messaging on the online platforms um and again oversight and transparency and long-term planning and then also many people talking about a good schools do contribute to
017a strong communities and help maintain or increased property values let's go to the next Slide the these were the themes of of the opponents um trust issues uh this is what resonated most online from people in terms of their posts um not listening to constines and uh and trying to uh educate instead of uh you know voters into an agreement and leading to a loss of trust um concerns of financial management I think there was some Mis information or some some discussion about who was actually in charge of finances years ago versus today but again those are things that are carried out on social media that may not necessarily um have an opportunity people like to just say things as as they will as they feel and so I think um that was one area
018was was financial management repeated Bond proposals that that rose up quite a bit and concerns over how we do our enrollment projections I think there was uh a lot of discussion about uh the use of the uh the documents we do from the city and the state level and then also doing our projections and I think the community is looking for a little more clarity on how we do our our enrollment projections um kind of a disregard for voter sentiment and then lack of broad support while there were some key groups as far as our some of our labor Partners um there was some uh some comments about how there wasn't a collective broad support by uh business partners um by um other organizations it just seemed to be a little bit fragmented and they
019recognized there was support but just it wasn't broad enough next slide and I'm going to turn it over to Chief turny right now he's going to give a little bit about the historical Bond uh in the past thank you Mark um starting here as we shift into um kind of a change of conversation toward a levy um this was just a snapshot of the history bonds and levies since 2016 just to give you an idea of what those percentages of yes votes have been next slide please uh and then just some reminders really about um an April Levy um potential here um obviously you approved resolution on January 16th to put this on the ballot with the um direction that we hold um at that time uh so it has not been filed with King
020County as of yet and that deadline is February 21st so just from reminders on what that April Levy would look like uh the tax rate um would be going from 309 to 330 if approved uh the total amount would be 138.74503 sixe Levy we are currently at a disadvantage because the current law does not allow us to issue debt upfront and then pay it off with those levies so that's one thing that uh is currently not something we can take advantage of and if we were able to do that though uh interest on that debt is uh needed to be paid out of the general fund so it's important to know that even though if we were able to do that and there are a couple bills right now in the legislature that would allow
021us to do that uh we would still have uh interest payments that would need to be covered by the general fund and then waiting um over six years obviously has a cost escalation risk um as things do escalate over time next slide uh and then some other key considerations things that are kind of top of mine right now um possible legislative outcomes I just mentioned um the possibility for us to be allowed to use lgo debt for front funding construction uh skipped over the possible you know if we don't know what's going to happen if the possibility the state says okay we want to increase the state's um version of the school tax it could mean a an adjustment up for our local taxpayers here but that's not our local piece so that could be
022an increase in taxes for uh folks in this community and we don't necessarily see those funds return to us um in terms of uh funding so and then potentially a lift of the local Levy lid that is being discussed right now so we'll see if that happens and then um locally what that means for us in terms of what we potentially go out for in the future um replacement levies so again a reminder that um we're approaching the end of the four-year cycle where we typically would go out for our education programs and operations Levy technology critical repairs and transportation um and just thinking ahead I went back to the last um the last February time frame if we ran in February and we would typically start committee work on that um sometime in late
023spring or maybe as late as early fall uh just to have the timing correct for um for that other un unknowns things to think about um obviously at the federal level right now there's a lot of talk about what's going to happen with Federal funding and grants um also construction costs tariffs unknown impact to what that could do to projects um and then any local you know state and local jurisdictions uh putting other things on as proposals that would impact local property taxes so just some things to consider possible impacts and that's the last slide for this presentation thank you for that can you just go back to slide number six so I think what I would just say and again I wish pres raldo was here but uh was we transition this conversation to
024getting ready to take a motion language and hear it you know I think one of the things that I would want to highlight is in at least in my line of work the first kind of is is Do no harm and so I think for me when I see it says trust issues concerns over financial management we can talk through those and I think we have and I think there's a lot of misinformation there repeated Bond proposals concern over enrollment projections I think also talk through those uh but the perceived disregard for voter sment and lack of broad support I think that uh we want to show that we hear you loud and clear and I think that that's what will lead us to transition to the next part of this conversation and so at
025this point I would love to entertain a motion I move the board adopt resolution 1237 repealing resolution 1235 that called for a special election in April 2025 for capital projects levies second perfect and before I go to public input I did want to give an opportunity for president moraldo if there's anything else that she wanted to say or um sentiment to convey no actually Harland I think you said it spoke um eloquently to say that it's really those last two pieces um that we need to consider and so um that's why at the last minute we did kind of take a look at um the response from the public and uh wanted to move forward with evaluating whether the right thing was to continue to press for a levy in April cor uh with that
026I have people uh that are signed up uh in the room to provide input onto this topic and if for some reason I call you and this wasn't a topic you wanted to please please just wave me off and then if there's people online that were wanting to provide input if you would start raising your hand so we can uh take care that for this topic only so first one when you would come up if you would introduce yourself in your feeder pattern attendance area you will have two minutes and we will ask you respectfully to wrap up when you hear the Bell thank you uh toam Mars good evening my name is tolm arts and I'm a 22-year resident of isqua uh both of my children spent 13 years in the isqua school system
027isqua Valley Elementary isqua Middle isqua High I'm a proud member of the isqua schools foundation and I'm a former officer of volunteers for isqua schools I'm also a 16-year member of the isqua city council though here tonight I speak only as one of seven on that body I come as a friend and fierce advocate for both public education in general and this District in particular I ask you to take a pause on the road to potentially authorizing a new Levy losing a second consecutive Bond This Time by a levy proof margin is a clear message from the voters that at this moment there is a disconnect between them and the people in this room the magnitude of the loss precludes it being about any particular single item such as the location of a new high
028school please I beg of you as a friend take a pause talk to voters talk to other leaders in the community and the region talk to the folks who forged 20 years of successful bonds and levies in this community confirm to the voters that you have heard them and will bring something substantially new to the table before asking more of them you have friends the city of isqua has supported the district time and time again as recently as last month as one of seven I will say that I think that if you were to reach out during a pause you would find ample enthusiasm for conversations about such things as for example other possible locations for a comprehensive High School closer to where projected growth is likely to occur please take a pause respect what
029the voters have told us use that time to out to your friends and supporters thank you thank you next Michael Boer good evening uh board members uh superintendent and Madam president on the screen uh my name is Michael Boer I've been a resident of samamish for 30 years uh my kids went through Sunny Hills Creekside um U Pine Lake Middle School so we're really familiar with the system um I support resolution uh 1237 to repeal 1235 uh if this means that you're going to think about high school number four differently and redirect your energies uh to funding other better academic um Alternatives and with that I really applaud applaud your leadership on this issue um it's apparent to me that after hearing all the sides of this argument and considering the recent public vote that
030other alteres May service our community better uh one of the concerns raised during the vote was this clear tax fatigue that we're feeling um to me a deeper message though and I think your data shows it here is that the community wants something better and a smarter use of our resources I don't know what path you're going to take after this I think that's what you're going to talk about um but with the 120 million that you have in reserves maybe you could take those funds and it would go a long way in um providing more distributed smaller more focused and effective Solutions I don't know if the money can be moved like that um but having a focus in that manner might serve us better um if so having multiple more locally embedded highly
031flexible and adaptive facilities and it might even promote more non-traditional means of Education that would be a welcome site for us so I I see all this as a grand opportunity for all of us uh to to teach our youth about critical thinking problem solving and developing a modern educational model that fits our AC academic needs now and for years in the future oh thank you for your time and I I applaud your efforts everyone thank you uh I apologize in advance because I'm trying to read this the best I can Wesley either most thank you okay that's the next one it just it says bonds so fair enough Albert serz good evening again I was here after the last failure of the bond issue and most of what was presented here I understand I've
032delved into it myself one of the things that I personally didn't like is the way I need to dig into Data to find something a quarter of a billion dollars over a quarter of a billion dollars for a new high school seems extravagant I don't know what it's for Does it include an auditorium Does it include a gym Does it include a stadium you know it's just a new high school I was a teacher 50 years ago I contacted one of my former students who's on a school board in Louisiana and she was at one point um assistant superintendent of education for the state they just opened the new high school for $18 million dollar now I realize that's Louisiana cost of living and all that you know it's like comparing Gayla apples with Red
033Delicious apples it's not apples and oranges okay so you need to do something and do something different and today I was digging through stuff and found out the superintendent of schools here makes more money than the governor she makes more money than a fourstar general the United States Army you have 13 or 15 people in the administrative staff who make more money than the governor I don't see that money being well spent if after two tries you get a worse result thank you thank you1 dard I have a suggestion to offer which is would you start with your introduction and Fe please thank you absolutely so my name is Chan dander uh I have kids in uh middle school and Elementary looking forward to attending high school and I'm keenly aware of the overcrowding in
034various high schools right and um I wish we had a magic wand to create the new High School uh but I think our current strategy is not working right as as uh earlier speakers said we have repeated failures on bonds so my request is to be transparent about what is the backup plan there is a lot of speculation about what might happen if the new high school is not built um and I think uh that doesn't help our case at all and my so my just my request is put out a a fallback plan like if you don't let's say for next two years if you're not able to get capital projects Bond passed what is your backup plan to elevate crowding in high schools thank you thank you is there any more public input
035in the room on this topic uh is there any public input on zoom in this topic and uh just to directly answer the next topic of our conversation will be on that and and then secondly is if we were in Louisiana the bomb would have passed in November and we would have broke ground but we don't live in Louisiana so I see no public input on this topic on Zoom am I missing any Stephen okay so wanted to open up to board discussion on this resolution oh sure president moraldo do you want to kick us off on public discussion oh I'm sorry I was having a coughing fit um uh I can certainly start us off uh one of the reasons I felt those was important was exactly what one of the uh speakers said
036is that we got a worse result this time than last time when we tried to be more specific about the the needs um and um you know this included a quarter of uh was not this was not all high school so a quarter of this was going to be uh to do security and an addition at Liberty High School as well so it is unfortunate that um that that's not going to happen but I think we do really need to look at what are our options we do have money that we have currently and is there a way that we can address some of our needs by utilizing what we do have and so I think that is to me I'm interested in that conversation and as public knows the board does not have secret
037meetings where we discuss everything before we come before the public we do all of our our our uh our work in front of the public so you are now at our public meeting um and so I have no idea what the rest of the board feels with regards to the results how that impacts their thoughts about the future and so that's why I felt this was really important for us to to talk about and to really hear uh what plans are I just I'm concerned we uh that I don't want to erode trust from the community when we go out for levies um you know I I'm really concerned about that that eroding trust uh we've heard often from the public you keep asking us for money which that's how funding is done uh director
038Mings and I did a wonderful video that you can go watch uh talking about that's how funding is done in Washington so we will always be coming back for our education and operations and programming dollar so we we will still need to do that a year from now and that is critical that's 10 to 15% I think the superintendent can correct me of our overall budget that's non-negotiable for us and um I don't want to erode trust now that says next February I'm not going to give you your EPO dollars which I think would be um uh detrimental to the district thank you J Coen I I uh appreciate we're having this conversation and um appreciate director M Aldo's comments as well and I I think um I want to talk about a few things
039I want to have I want to acknowledge some thank yous to because there were so many people who came out and and uh put a lot of effort into this um this Bond and so I will just say right now for myself the feeling is sad um not supporting education is sad so I want to just throw that out there but um going back to this specific topic um and really thinking through over the last couple of days how important the brand of this Aqua school district is to me as a resident of this community for 20 years the brand is important and I think we diminish it if we don't pause um and we think through other options and have further conversations with the community I mean obviously elections have consequences and I think
040that our our voters told us that they'd like us to pause um and and again have more conversations share more data come together around a go forward plan that would obviously to get the support it needs before I end I just wanted to acknowledge some thank you because we worked hard um over the last uh several weeks on this and there wasn't a lot of time obviously but between the November election and the election we had on Tuesday and I want to thank the district for their incredible work um it it was just absolutely incredible I know folks say gosh I couldn't find information on the bond I will it was there um I will just say you know that I I think one of the things that I've learned and would just recommend to
041the community is people need to look search out the data if you're only on one Forum if you're only on one social media platform really encourage you to look broadly and know too that hey if I want information about the district the district has a lot of it search it out on the district website um I want to specifically thank our superintendent I want to thank uh Martin turny our um our CFO I want to thank Mark and the and the communications team I mean my gosh all of the work that you did in terms of putting information out there was amazing I want to thank our volunteers we on volunteers for squas schools V for the work they did I want to thank our parents who engaged members of the Comm on social media
042um particularly those who really thought creatively around how we get information out so posting on social media platforms to reach you know the different very culturally diverse groups across our district those who put signs up in front of their their houses in support of the bond those who talk to neighbors um I also want to just as I reflect on this so there was a group of us that spent the last five weekends uh D Belling knocking on doors across our district and in this political environment you don't normally find this we were door Belling side by side Democrats Republicans all in support of public education and it was absolutely incredible and I want people to pause on that because this is not a partisan issue um it brings people together when we support education
043and so I want to thank folks for that and then I want to I Really also want to pause and thank my board colleagues as well for their amazing work I can look at each and every one of you and think about the amazing work that you did from the podcast to conversations to presentations and I am just so proud to be up here with this group and I'm sorry for going on and on about thank yous but it's been it's been a journey that we've been on and just like so many of our volunteers the five of us have been out there working to advocate for Education funding I know we hear from folks saying gosh we didn't know that was the function of the board well that is the function of board members
044and that's those are the board members that I want on my board in a squa was why I ran for this position a year ago was to support and to advocate for schools and so I want to end with that as just saying thank you um to to my board colleagues um so I'll in there yes Dr Taylor thank you um so yes I mean I think it's very clear that based off of the results on Tuesday that this is not the political environment for us to move forward with the ly uh that seems more than obvious to me and I'm feel fairly certain that we would not be successful in April if we did choose that course and um to director moralo's point I too am very concerned about further damage to the district's
045credibility particularly when it comes to our enrichment levies that we are so dependent on right now particularly with State funding continually to decrease so I don't want to put any of that in danger and and worry about that then I want to just say for my board colleagues since we are having the discussion um I really do not want to rush the next step at this point to me there are too many uncertainties that um I think I need time to consider uh I think we need to honestly relook at the viab viability of the site uh I would like to have time to see the developments out of Olympia and that I do think there are some very optimistic things a foot down there um we've talked about but almost hypothetically I would really
046like to look at the development of that site if we were to sell it or what that would look like with some hard numbers or projections because I still don't know what that would entail um and then perhaps even a new analysis of other land options which might lead us right back to the same conclusion that there's only one site but I would like to reconfirm that I think that would have some also some legs with the community as well um that we're doing that work so I I do think we've reached the point where we need to use the word we've heard pause and reset and to take a very measured approach as to what we're going to do next um I also do want to say that I think our advocacy folks with
047volunteers for call schools are exhausted and spent and are not in a position right now um to take on another campaign and and I think that we should afford that organization an opportunity to reset as well um as we consider our next steps um and I mean yes we do have a duty and we are definitely going to be talking about contingency planning but I also want that to be a very measured process where we take into consideration you know as many different options as we can and run those things to ground so it's a lot for us to take on for sure I think we are going to have to come to the conclusion that these permits are going to expire that does create some sadness for me as well because I am still
048very convinced we're going to have a new High School in this community uh it's now going to cost a lot more money for our taxpayers and that is extremely unfortunate but that is kind of where we are at this point so we'll have to keep solutioning um you know the best we can last thing I want to say is I think more than anything we need to get to a point where as a community we can acknowledge a key problem because there's been this skepticism I'm not even sure where it's coming from about the data showing the populations of our high schools and the directions that that growth is going to take over the next few years we've got to get to Point as a community that at least we can start with identifying the
049problem which is our high schools are grossly overcrowded that is the problem that needs to be solved um willing and we'll continue to you know uh work on the issue but we're going to need some time to do it and that's my point of view Dr mol sure thank you um so obviously this question at least is about whether we pause on April and so as I work out how I get there I guess I'll go through a couple steps I think I think uh as we look at the feedback and I love that we put it all out there I think we've done a good job of putting our feedback out there positive or negative the whole time um but I think we have to acknowledge that there's some interesting a differences in that
050feedback right when you look across our population I think the tax sensitivity is a clear piece of feedback across all constituents beyond that we really just have a lot of conflicting feedback and I know as people here it it's like well the board isn't listening I think what we've been trying to do is listen through a number of different kind of concerns and figure out the path so you know great example is you know there's people who have um a lot of different sorts of concerns and it's hard to to triage through that right so I think for me um the challenge is the first time through what we heard was I didn't even know you were running a bond and then we heard from people I'm hearing too much from you about this Bond
051you're it's oversaturated right so that we have this jux toos of feedback back all the time um I think you know we could pick any topic and people have an opinion on it I think there's other places you could have a school I you know I don't I don't know where that comes from like it's fascinating but I think that's those are interesting so I think um we've been trying our best to listen to the signals that were the clearest in people's feedback and adjust that make the make the bond more targeted deal with the tax sensitivity the reality is there's ways to do it with less tax sensitivity so I think we've actually heard quite a bit of the feedback I think we I think where the struggle is is where we don't react
052to people's exact feedback that that causes stress and I I get that for me I don't feel sad about it I'm a sports parent I've rais sports kids you take a loss you go on to what's what's next um I'm also not much of a pause person so I think my belief is and I will stand by this is now that we have people's attention we should be really really clear on what the um what possibly has to happen next I think we've started that conversation we have published what some of those contingency plans are we're going to talk next about what some other ones could be um but for me I think it's just what's the right uh solution that fits the resources we have and the direction that we have to educate kids
053so um I worry that without having this next resolution without moving forward we lose attention and later people say oh well but they just stopped it must not have been important they didn't continue to fight for what was important for my kids they didn't continue to work on what overcrowding is in my schools and just based on how the last six months have gone we will get that feedback thank you for listening you didn't listen we'll we'll both come out so I do worry about how we properly use the moment to make sure um that we lay out the facts although some will say we're trying to over educate them and not listen that came out in the feedback so I don't know how to resolve that how to give information without I guess lecturing
054um but I I think for me that's the case I do I am as I sit here I am not convinced we should take the the um item off for April I get the facts that we had less support um but I don't know I don't think from a change management perspective that that is the right choice um now I have I have a lot more to say in the next topic which is what do I think we can do with other options on the table I think we've got a l lot of great options um on the table with the resources we have but in this case um I actually think it's a really good time to keep the attention on what is a really important topic and uh to at least make sure
055that before we have to do something dramatically different and disruptive everybody understands exactly where we're going I don't want to get to next school year and we do something big and it's like well did you even try did you try hard enough did you try more than once um and so that's where I sit with it uh so I'll do storytelling I guess before I get to to where I feel you know I grew up in Pierce County and I grew up at in what was a considered a smaller inferior District uh when I was a kid and graduated from Summoner High School in 1994 uh we were always overshadowed by the peup school district and at that time even the school I think Dr coin went to was a 1012 high school and that
056was a a common model back 30 years ago many high schools in our state were that way and uh at some point P up had a crisis and then after they built their third Comprehensive High School that was 1012 uh they went through this decades long process where they were unable to pass bonds and over those two decades suer School District uh transitioned to a 912 system uh their property values have now exceeded PPS as evidenced by the fact that that is now the cutline where teachers in the suar school district get the full Regional and P doesn't kind of ironically and uh suar passed a732 million bond in November to do further Investments and there's a school Community that's half of our size uh so I think I've lived and grown and watched what
057the longterm play impact is to a community over the course of sustained dein of public education and I've seen it and then how it impacts community and schools and happily schools did pass an $800 million bond this week uh on I how ran many try I don't know I give up uh but so so good for them but they are now decades behind in school investment they're decades behind in property value and that has had real th impact in what their teachers are paid and so I don't want us to go down that journey and if it takes a pause in this moment and yet I would agree with you short if I'm going to pause it needs to be short and focused and uh really not pausing and we're not GNA stop having conversations
058about it and dialogue but what is the path forward that we go for that we can all collectively get behind because the problem is still there and it hasn't magically Gone Away by a vote in November which again in 42 States would have been us breaking ground on a new High School uh and then what we heard this week so with that uh I am uh supportive of this move with the understanding of the next topic I have much more strong opinions about uh and we're gonna kind of have to nest in sort of where we where we see opportunity because it's kind of bubbled up but I think we need a focused conversation that we're gonna kind of added into the next uh agenda topic to talk a little bit about structure schools and
059sort of we we we could potentially go forward because I don't see another place in it and don't want to wait till the future agenda topics at the end because people are here and listening now so looks like there's a you you raising your hand oh yes I was um so I would actually ask that we hold this this decision until after the next conversation so I'm assuming that's a motion to table which I would second okay um I hadn't made the motion yet I was just expressing a desire I will make a motion as soon as I hear Naomi's insightful input hi everyone um I'm seeing I saw little bit closer hello all right um I saw that there was I think over a 100 participants on Zoom currently um when we normally have
060like maybe 10 there's also several listeners in the boardroom right now and I want to thank everyone for coming um for those who are new I want to introduce myself and the other student reps here um my name is naiu I'm a senior at isaa high school and there are several students here with me that are a representative of our high schools um all four high schools including Gibson e um there are two for every high school and I'm one of the representatives from isqua um I think when we're talking about a pause on uh bringing um sending out another Levy and uh asking more from our community I think what we really want to do is not necessarily take a physical pause but simply redirect our efforts and energies into rebuilding our trust and
061EST in communication with our community we would not be fully halting any operations or planning or preparation for building a new high school for funding our schools would simply be trying to um increase the probability that those efforts will pass in the future because we do need um from the votes and from uh the results of past bonds it seems clear to me and I'm sure some of the other students here that we do need to uh create a stronger connection with our community um we have several speakers here today that came that I think says some things that were very wise um we have supporters and also um people who did not support the bond that are calling for um a pause for us to reestablish a connection to help them learn and understand
062what we are trying to do and to be more transparent I think it's very wise to listen to those voices um and also to the I think somewhat division among the board right now um president moraldo uh director Ming and director gallinger you've all been on the board for quite a while I think uh director coin and director Taylor bring a fresh voice to this community to this board um as newer members of the board they share a a fresher perspective they bring um a greater understanding of what it is to be a regular citizen coming into a board meeting who are who may be more unfamiliar with board language and policy um and how School fing funding works I think it's very wise to listen to these fresh and newer voices because they represent
063um a great population of our community that are not as engaged with our district and what our district is doing um on a constant basis thank you hello okay cool um I just wanted to piggy back off of what Naomi was saying um I'm AA I'm also the other student rep fir from isqua um and I just wanted to talk about how we have kind of seen this mistrust in our community and when we look at pivoting the way that we're giving out information so that it feels less So like um kind of a forced education and more so like we're having a dialogue with our community um I would really urge the consideration of utilizing students more in that manner I think that there's less doubt um when students are speaking in terms of
064what our experiences are because obviously when you have something that's coming from the student saying we like need this this is what we're experiencing um there's less of that communication gap and I think that was shown in the um success of the video that we had in terms of the day in the life videos across all three high schools um and then beyond that I would say that when we look at taking a pause and re-evaluating I think that making it so that students are able to kind of address some of those more specific concerns and make more like Bond directed information um or potential change directed information uh that that could be beneficial and also provide A New Perspective um I think um naami and Ava put up some points really elegantly I would
065also just like to comment you expect expect us as student representatives to represent our schools and not just our own opinions which are vastly more informed than those of our fellow students and we are student School Board representatives and it's your duty to represent your community and not act like trustees or an educated liaison and if your community isn't agreeing with you then that's communication gap and if you're making decisions that don't represent the community that's communication gap and you're not representing the community and I think it's important to reach out because it's taken me a year to be able to understand what's going on here and the gift of that is is I get to go and I get to talk to students and I get to explain what an OE is and what
066the school board does and what it's like in admin and that's important for students to understand it's more important for the community to understand because they're the ones where that they're they're where we get our funding and I think it's really important that if they're not understanding then the Board needs to respectfully educate them not just about the bond but about Administration and about how that works and about the struggles that we're facing and I looked at the bond website after the first Bond failed and it was not clear it there was a lot of information and it needs to be accessible we have a lot of different demographics in our district and it needs to be as accessible as possible um I would also say like we had a lot of proactivity from students
067um Naomi did some really cool work trying to reach out and that was so cool and we would be happy if you would use us as much as possible to give us directives to help spread word and and encourage people to learn more and and to even share what we know because we are we're even more educated about what's going on than some parents and community members so please use us that's kind of what we're here um so perfect yep I move we table this vote second oh Pardon Me Oh Chris you wanted to say something you can talk oh okay um I know we just highlighted a lot of the bad things but I kind of want to highlight one positive uh especially from just in the past few months especially from November I
068think communication has got a lot better I mean there's still a big gap and there's still a need to like you know fulfill that but it's definitely gone a lot better definitely in the ways like day of the life I feel like that gave a great insight to people to podcast more and more stuff like that um the thing is though my concern and like fellow people at Liberty's concern is that like obviously these issues aren't going away anytime soon and clearly they've just gten worse and worse over time so I just want to make it a little bit clear that by taking a break it's not putting the issue like on the back burner like this only going to progressively going to get worse and I feel like looking back a couple months ago
069maybe get if we knew where we would be today we'd like make a couple different decisions but I mean this is as best as we're going to have it we can't go back and I feel like waiting on it is just going to keep on multiplying but definitely communication has G better and there's a lot of it's a lot of Ro of improvement where I definitely think a lot of my other Representatives here mentioned like using students and so that that's all I want to say but I just want to highlight a couple positives thanks so we have a motion to table this any discussion see no discussion all those in favor of table I I I all any opposed Okay so we've Ted this agenda item and we will move to the next agenda
070gen item structure of schools discussion yeah yep I move the board adapt a change to the structure of schools to take effect in the 2026 27 school year second second sorry okay uh motion has been made and seconded and uh at this point I think we will hear from discussion uh with public input and the first item of public input is Wesley most good evening my name is Wesley Mo I have children at isqua high in Cougar Mountain Middle School I realize now you have to solve the problem of overcrowding I realize that there's going to be limited options that you can do however I've heard a variety of different things such as you know some redistricting that could potentially you know shift the overcrowding possibility I would say after hearing all this information about
071pause and reset and listening and all this I would say be mindful about what you're about to do figure out can you use existing facili ities to potentially solve this problem you know if we have a location for a new high school why not use that as a potential Ninth Grade Campus it'll cost a lot less money than a full high school and won't it need to be as big I also think frankly that we have no real understanding of how much you know overcrowding will stay or reduce so let's try to make sure we're doing legitimate items that will restructured out gentlemen I don't know your name but you said about the possibility of doing 10 through 12 and uh and whether that's better than 9 through 12 I don't know but again if
072we're talking about giving the more information out to the community let's make sure we do this right because this is the option we have to do we have to be pragmatic we have to solve this in this way and let's make sure that this information comes out properly versus just make a decision because I don't think doing something like I heard of redistricting CER Mountain to go to Liberty solves the problem I think it just basically shifts the overcrowding position I would say take the pause figure out how to do this pragmatically and do it right thank you is there any other public input on zoom on this topic of structure of schools or in the room if you would just come up and introduce yourself with your attendance area and again I think to
073to follow up with what director Mullin has said this now that we have everyone that have joined us tonight this is not a it's the first time we're talking about this topic we've been talking about how we're going address this problem and potential adjustments to our facilities and our structure of schools for well over a year so this is not a new topic it might be new to some people tonight but it's not a new topic go now okay um my name is Jennifer Harrington and I'm a parent to a current 10th grader at isqua and a seventh grader at Cougar Mountain Middle um I like many others are disappointed that the school bond did not pass but I'm here today because I fear that the board will make knee-jerk reactions that will harm our
074students far more than the overcrowding that they have very unfortunately grown accustomed to regarding the proposal that Cougar Mountain attend Liberty High School you've probably already realized this by now but Liberty does not have room to accommodate such a move assuming you started moving nth graders next year alone within four years Liberty would be at 50% capacity trying to equalize the population of all the schools when they have wildly different cap cap capacities is not Equitable there's no question that our high schools are overcrowded but since none of the four Solutions proposed back in November seem palatable to anyone I would like to propose two more options the first proposal would be to find a cheaper way to build this high school maybe we can expand existing facilities alternately maybe we have enough money if
075we redesign it maybe we can sell off a portion of the land and make it more compact maybe we can get corporate Partners to help fund the school maybe the high school can be built in phases or it doesn't have to have a stadium to begin with second proposal which somebody else touched on is that the district start looking closely at its School boundaries and adjust them if necessary to send some of the students in samamish and Lakemont back to bellw school district while the district will surely lose tax revenue as a result if overcrowding is such a crisis surely the board would agree that sending some of our students to a district that's closing schools because they're far enrollment might be prudent regardless I ask the board to take no action at this time
076without asking parents and students what they want I think you'll find that most of us would rather stay put over shifting boundaries time shifting or sending our kids backwards by keeping them in elementary and middle school longer thank you thank you uh on Zoom so you can turn your video on and unmute Jennifer sasi and then ad hello uh my name is Jennifer sarasi and I'm going to try to turn my video on uh oh there we go oh I'm sorry it says the host has stopped it but can you hear me we can absolutely hear you and hopefully you can try and turn your video on as we uh oh I'll try again oh sorry it won't let me um oh there it will fantastic no okay hello hello it's nice to see you
077all um thank you for letting me speak for just one minute I have two things to say one is that um I think director mullen's made a motion to adopt this thing in the 2026 2027 school year but the advanced notice that's up on the website says the 2027 2028 school year um and I just I just want to be clear about when this is um I am a teacher at isqua high school I teach English and um I recognize that you as a school board and the administration of the district is in a really difficult situation our schools are overcrowded we need more funding I wish the bond had passed I would also um I just want to note that we as teachers and I feel confident in speaking for a number of my
078colleagues want so much to work with the leaders of this District to make things work um and I know that you've talked about this in board meetings before restructuring the schools but for voting on anything that might require a lot of action I would really love for to feel a little more partnership with maybe some Outreach and discussions with um the staff that are going to be working to make these changes um so I respect your time and I really appreciate your work thank you very much thank you yeah I think that the board agenda unfortunately because I was a late add-on got uh added on with a typo of the years it was different time frame than what I had talked with with President raldo as we were getting ready to open this up
079for this addition the next yes so that what was stated was was what we wanted the next uh is danana and while she's coming on can you make sure that the others that are in line can have the ability to turn on their video so then that part's ready perfect hi good evening I'm uh d Ole I am a Isa Education Association president and uh parent of a student that is in the ISA High School feeder pattern that goes to Cougar Mountain Middle um and I'm just here uh to just kind of reiterate a little bit of what um the other speakers shared I'm concerned that a lot of the conversations have been through the board meeting and haven't been with um our uh labor partners and there's a lot of questions that I feel
080like they are still unknown uh do we have room in the schools uh to be able to do this um how would that look with teachers moving with endorsements um and so for me with a lot of other questions I do think could there be data collection conversations with community members conversations with our labor Partners to see if this is even a feasible option and I'm not sure that really has occurred with our our labor Partners so I ask that instead of moving forward with a direct decision that there's a decision to start collecting that information and seeing and making the decision based on actual data and and um facts thank you next is Leah whitacker apologize in advance I mispronounce your name I think you are still mute um on can you unmute on
081your end she said no not from our end we'll let you troubleshoot and we will try and circle back with you so uh next then is Sarah Cen good turn on your camera when you introduce yourself please all right it says I cannot okay first of all so happy to be here those students spoke so wisely it's just so impressive I just have to say from teaching in this district for 12 years that is H just so beautiful so well done you guys um I do I do want to reiterate what we've heard um we all have different lenses that we've been navigating in and and it's not to devalue those um so I just wanted to kind of share the perspective of moving that as a sixth grade teacher and I like sixth grade
082is just such a fundamental Year you guys it's just such a cool opportunity to see that growth in these students that grow that go from fifth to sixth like they become such different humans um it it would be such uh from from the perspective that we have a a sad disappointment to not give them that opportunity of growth not saying that it's the right call but going back to what a lot of these students were saying and community members were saying of just discussion and ideas that that we all are coming with um to move from a seventh to ninth grade and miss out on the opportunity that these when they go from fifth to six so beautiful is that it yes sorry it went back um so yeah I just I that was something
083I just wanted to share again nobody knows the exact right call but um I did want to share what like it's my favorite year to teach because of the growth that they make and I I do think it's it's something just to be a be aware of um to take that opportunity away so thank you uh next is Natalie shean again if you would come off mute and uh turn on your video as you introduce yourself hi I'm Natalie Sheen I uh teach social studies at isqua high school Naomi is actually my student so it's nice to hear her um uh I just wanted to reiterate what Jen saroli and Dona said um is that in discussions about restructuring which I understand May totally be necessary and certainly we've been feeling the effect of overcrowding
084at IHS for quite a while now um I really urge you to take into consideration the voices of teachers uh and get feedback from us and not only get feedback but also you know act on that feedback as well um I think it's a really crucial voice that's been missing from this discussion about what's how this is going to affect us and our students uh because we're the ones on the ground every day that's all thank you for your time We Are you able to come off mute okay so then I think you're gonna probably need to try and call in with a different device or reconnect to the meeting but if you can't come off mute then I'm sorry we can't take your public input I've been clicking the ask to unmute button yeah
085so it's on your end that you have to then say we encourage you to submit submit it in writing so uh next is write again since I only see a single name if you introduce yourself with your full name as well as attendance pattern thank you thank you I'm right and N my kids all graduated from Liberty High School all five of them uh and as you guys know I uh was very active in the campaign um front row seat in many of the discussions with people uh that had differing views than myself I was very active in promoting and trying to get the bond passed uh and I would encourage you to hit pause for a minute I I think there's value in just letting the dust settle before you make a decision on
086rebounding and other significant things that impact people one of the messages that kept coming as we interacted with people is they decide what they're going to do do and then they just do it um and so I think I know you guys have been talking about this it looks knee-jerk if you decide two days after the vote what you're going to do even if you've been talking about it I think perception's important and so I would encourage you to just hit pause for a minute um unless there's some urgent need to make a decision today about redistri redist ring so thank you for the efforts you guys thank you for all your work I appreciate it thanks thanks Maya again introduce yourself by your full name as well as you feater pattern as you come
087off mute hi my name is Maya Rari I have a student in isako high school and PCMS um and again um I'm kind of new to this uh but one thing that you know that has been discussed multiple times is kind of the issues like the trust issues and like hey board is not listening I'm just curious have the board thought or is it a possibility to do a poll instead of a yes or no for a bond Levy just a yes or no questions this is the list of things that we have considered and people can put a poll and then put like one two three this is my preference and then you can display it like you know of course the poll with the education in the same time what is going to
088be done and what is the impact for each of the different options and then people can put a for of like this is my favorite one two three and four as opposed to just a yes or no and then show that you know hey instead of just people who come to the board meeting but you know kind of GA just like you know um election polling and whatnot um to show that the district listen not just in terms of kind a binary resolution but um um what is kind of the majority uh from everybody again you know there are a couple option that has been discussed right the changing of the structure 9 to 12 uh moving to bellew school district or like moving some of the cmms into uh Liberty I don't know what
089are the other options but you know if all of the things that you have worked through like hard work if you can put it out there um and let people show their opinion thank you thank you we last track we're rooting for you okay flashback but um thank you for um persevering with me um I uh definitely Echo the sentiments of um students but also my colleagues of please uh let us work in conjunction with you for determining how we can try to solve the problem that now we have that we can't solve with a bond which boy we really were rooting for it um I'm uh a music teacher in the district I teach a isqua high and also Skyline and I teach the only dist all district program for music for and it's
090the Evergreen philarmonic and I would like as you look at problem solving to make sure that we don't leave the Arts behind um I think it was Carrie Dean was talking about that critical year of sixth grade and what a special time that is for them to launch um and the impact that moving sixth grade where they start instruments would have on them and what kind of problems that would logistically cause for Staffing and just for those programs in general and we actually draw students to our district people have moved here from across the country when they're looking around they move here because we have programs like at Evergreen Phil harmonic or it's not just sports that draw people we have great academics so I ask that we please please please don't leave behind the
091impact that possibly and I understand that thing something's going to have to happen we understand this but just looking at how to problem solve to not decimate the music programs in the process to the the students really um have high value there we have like a quarter of the population involved performing out of time thank you thank you uh Cammy Crest hi thank you my name is Cammy Crest I live and teach in the Sunset Elementary boundary um I want to Echo my support for what people have said about asking for there to be a a moment of pause and not make any hasty decisions um the effects of changing grade levels in the school system would be very impactful as I know you're all aware and I think um partnering with Educators and talking
092through what that potential change would look like and the timeline um would be really beneficial to getting people to help support such a transition I also wanted to voice support for the idea of seeing if there's still a way to build the high school with lower costs and also um if we can pursue trying to get more funding from the state uh I know that education is not funded from the state as highly as we would like so whether that would be legislatively um you know supporting legislative action for more funding just want to voice my support for that idea also thank you okay this will be the last hand we take because again this is a business meeting that we do want to have people be able to get home at a reasonable time
093including ourselves so what it says biswell be if you would introduce yourself with your full name hi my name is Betty biswell I actually teach at um Beaver Lake Middle School I teach sixth grade biology or scence life science and the eighth grade high school biology for um the the advanced students and I I just want to say a few things about uh the notice I I got today about the possibilities for Shifting the schools around the kids around um first of all the one thing I I one of the questions I have because I do teach the sixth grade students at a middle school level um uh that expectation for teachers to teach at an elementary school that are currently teaching sixth grade how does that look for certification process because I hold a
094secondary Ed um certification so I'm just throwing that idea I'll to keep it in mind about um the certification processes that go with that um the other thing is I want to reiterate what some of the other teachers have said about the growth that I've seen in sixth grade students so this is my third year teaching um sixth grade I usually teach high school so it's been an interesting experience um personally I I think I'm saying this correctly is that um some of the expect that they come into in middle school they don't really know what their expectation is as a sixth grade student so as a middle school teacher and a high school teacher I felt like we have more um control as to um how to set higher expectations for those students so
095looking at some of the test scores that our school has kind of um had in the last year two years we've seen um considerable amount of growth in our students reading ability from coming into a Middle School St school and being um setting those expectations of um being able to read at a higher level and being able to um function and change you know because they're trying to do more class schedules and there there is a lot of grow WRA up so I I would just like to think about that more thank you very much for letting me speak and thank you very much for holding the Open session today so first off of all as I frame this discussion I want to extend gratitude to all of our uh teachers and uh staff across
096the district and when you speak about the importance of transition of what it means for sixth graders and for 9th graders like for us you're preaching to the choir literally like we know and understand uh with very intricate detail that however the community has spoken very clearly that they want us to fix our overcrowding problem within our existing structure that we have and the budget that we have so I want to bifurcate this conversation into two because I do want to fit sort of high school property and sort of our thoughts on that in a secondary part of this but I would like tonight to walk away away with as this is framing the timeline the timeline and the uh compon components of what we would want the administration to come back with us for
097a recommendation I do not see this as a moment that we're voting on changing the structure of schools tonight just to be clear to everyone that's listening that's watching but this is for us to establish what is the time frame for that change as well as what are the what are the components that we would need to have so for an example for me as for kicking it off and I think that director mull is going to go over like the the topics that we talked about I don't want us to to necessarily select from that menu that would be the administration's role but for me I would want like these are the criteria that it must meet and so an example for me would be whatever plan for the structure of schools it must
098meet the implementation year of the 206 27 school year for me it must have our high schools be at 95% of their permanent capacity and the reason why is that way we don't have to make a change once and then as our schools grow over the next couple years to have to like redo it again so we want that's why the state and everywhere uh in in the state uses that as the number so those would be just an example so what I would like for us to walk away from this conversation with is what are the criteria and then what time frame would we want an expectation for the administration to come back with a a plan and and obviously we would want to partner with our uh educational um bargaining units and yet
099we are supposed to enact and reflect the will of the community and that's what we are going to do starting tonight so and it's not starting tonight we've been doing this for ever in a day but uh this conversation starting tonight J M um can we start superintendent with just a review of the Alternatives as they've been previously discussed so far so there were Alternatives uh as part of contingency planning as part of the discussion at the December 12th board meeting so I believe uh Stephen can pull up the archived agenda for the December 12th 2024 board meeting right and here it is on the screen okay so maybe we're thank you for that appreciate it so I think um to the point that we've started this conversation of what could potentially happen I'll just
100reiterate my my points at this particular meeting which is this is the list we had so far right these were the starting the starting list of Alternatives I do not believe they're our only list and that's I think hopefully what we can get to tonight because to your point I think the opportunity we have is um and certainly before I get more comfortable with the discussion I I help table is what do what do we need to know about these Andor other options um so that we can get to a decision so that we can understand who do we have to not I have to but who are we going to talk to what's the order of operations on conversations Etc so but just to give a sense so people understand what we've talked about
101in previous discussions was one is there a reconfiguration option that might mean and many have certainly brought this up in the last uh set of bond conversations is do we go back to a freshman campus um that we had in the past just to be super clear on that so everybody understands we have too many freshmen today to be housed in any one of our middle school buildings so that is actually not an option in an existing Middle School building I know that's one that people hearken back to as wonderful times we had significantly less freshmen so now we have too many freshmen to put in any one of our middle school buildings we also don't have enough capacity one of to move all those middle schoolers out of one of the buildings to put
102in another building so so um would we do that for the nth grader so we've already asked and answered that question that is actually a no we don't have room the next one is would we reconfigure as uh director gallinger mentioned to a K5 from K5 to k6 we've certainly gotten some feedback tonight on that um 6 to8 and then 9 to 12 no I'm doing that wrong sorry going from 6 to8 to 7 to9 and then 10 to 12 so I think that one is still um one to be discussed we also have many of our middle schools that are in capacity so it would be where is that possible redrawing of boundaries that came up tonight we talked about that before at this meeting we did have at this December meeting spirited conversation
103I was very spirited about it I know I get that way um but one of the things we talked about um was what is the potential of Cougar Mountain Middle School going to Liberty we after that meeting went through the actual data and that's the data you saw in many of our Communications post that conversation that indicated that no Liberty's already over capacity so so that is another item that was on the board um and then double shifting at high school which would mean something to the effect of some kids go to school something like 6:00 a.m. I don't know where it would end one in the afternoon and other kids would go from like 2:00 in the afternoon to 6:00 in the evening or whatever how we get to the math to get to
104the right number of hours in a day I think I have heard stories of someone who was here when we had to double shift before and their kid went till p.m if I understand that correctly but it would be like two shifts of schools so those are conversations we have had and um to date and I think our opportunity tonight is are there others well I would say I would take off the the table I don't see us doing any uh short or longterm like swapping of a whole corner of our district to another school district I would say sending kids to and B high schools are actually overc capacity as well there's only one of their high schools that is even allowing any students uh so that's really not something that is a table
105option and something you'd want to go year toe for right so if sorry if I can build on that again I don't I feel like people don't like the lectures but um the school no one is talking about closing high schools there's no one anywhere talking about closing high schools so that's why the Belleview option is probably not is not an option either so for me why that urgency is is that I think our community and our parents and our students deserve an answer as as quickly as possible and this is again not a new topic maybe new to some people tonight but not a new topic and so I would like us to have a announcement made no later than the end of the May of this year for what a plan is but
106I want to open that up for like I think I'd like us to choose like when we think we need to make the announcement by and then what the parameters are that it must meet uh director Mull and direct Point okay so I would like to table a couple of additional options uh first one is building a new Ninth Grade Campus using the existing thing I think that came up tonight so I was excited to hear that one but I think is that possible do we use the property we have and on that site build a new Ninth Grade Campus that would house the number of freshmen that we have so I think that's one I'd like to put on the board and then the second one which I'd say I'm much more spirited about
107is um I I don't think this has to be a moment of auster I worry that out of our reaction to this result that we treat this as a moment of austerity I treat it as a moment of opportunity and if I look at the the the vast majority of conversations we've had around high school and what we hope for our high schoolers and what additional um opportunities we can put in the system we have had a number of conversations and what was in the initial bond from November was how do we expand once we could build a new high school then could expand in each of our high school buildings additional learning opportunities um to allow our students to pursue uh practical certifications and other career exploration in their buildings so in that November
108conversation it was a two-step process um I still think that's an amazing plan but it was not the will of the voter so I respect that but I think what we do have as an opportunity is to still get to that outcome which is my second proposal would be to build a career center on that location in the spot that's currently designated for what would have been Elementary 17 17 is that the right number leaving room for the high school for further development um but that would both give us the career options and training and it would help get some of the um volume as our 11th and 12th graders go to pursue that type of coursework on that site think that's part of the bifurcation part I'd rather us talk about what that site
109development could look like after this but I but I so I don't want any of those answers I think they're all terrible so I am positing my new answer we know they're all terrible and yet we've been tasked by the community to do them so I don't know that we have if we have a better answer that we can afford I don't know that we have to get there my I I know we'll get there okay I'm sorry you're in charge I have uh yes I want us to have a conversation about the property after this like I promise we're going to have it because I have lots of ideas and thoughts myself so I don't disagree with you but I want to talk about first of all the problem we're trying to solve is
110overcrowding and we've been asked by the community to solve it with an existing means and existing buildings and it's been very clear feedback about that there is not a belief that we are overcrowded there's not a belief that we need another building in this district and they there is a request to change Andress how we use our space given theity in some of our elementary schools so I just want to recenter us back on that conversation all right well I'm just gonna actually say director mulling now you're actually talking like so like something I'm excited about because again that list I just want to be clear I don't like anything on it nothing to the point I don't even want to have a conversation on it so I'm just going to be really clear Junior
111High model no way Ninth Grade Campus moving any anyone structuring you know in an existing Middle School no um the idea of altering and double shifting students no I mean the idea and maybe you know yes I I know this is the second portion of the conversation and maybe we just need to speed ourselves to it but I think how we rework that location or we think more creatively that's what gets me excited I think that this idea of and I'm going to take us back to just offer some personal perspective on it I mean before coming to the board I spent years on the isqua schools Foundation board and this isqua school district brand is very important to me we promoted I fundraised for on behalf of this district for years we were the
112cheerleaders of the district and we have an expectation in this community that we provide excellence in our schools and this idea of going back in time I can't sit up here and support that at all um so I want us to think about how we can use what we currently have and be creative with that and do something that moves us forward I think some of the feedback that we got even though as a board we talk about this and again I'm so glad that this boardroom is filled with people and we have a hundred people supposed toly on Zoom I can't tell but we as a board talk about CTE we talk about options even though there's a lot of feedback saying oh this board doesn't do that we do that's what gets us
113excited we want to talk about the kids in the middle we want to talk about the kids who need options and that is why I think as we think creatively about what we can do with existing Resources with existing funds that's what gets exciting that's what moves us forward this idea of what was on that that slide doesn't get me excited and I don't and I think I would also ask to I'm not sure that the community has actually tasked us with solving for overcrowding so I'm not sure I'd be comfortable with even a May date and coming out with something I talk to so many people people over the last couple of months around this Bond who told me I didn't realize our schools were overcrowded in our community we know they are and
114I know that there's you know you could debate hey those people maybe are not in touch with this but I don't know if we've necessarily been tasked with that we need to solve for it but I don't know if we've been tasked with it to solve it for next year so all in there it's not for next year we're solving it for a year and a half from now so but didn't the but but I thought it said 26 27 that would have been two and a half years from now okay I see what you mean because 25 26 so it's the one okay and this that would be like in four years that we've been talking about it so at this point we've got to move from talking about it so again I would
115ask that we have the eat our vegetables part of the conversation first before we get to to dessert I promise we will have the dessert conversation but I do believe we need to have this conversation as painful and unpalatable as it might be I think I'm ready there's a lot suddenly floating around in the room okay I want to talk first about the timing of a decision um we can talk about may but um I have a lot of concern about any perception that we are rushing to a decision even though that is two or three months away when we first had this discussion in December I heard outrage from the community and it might have been that my directorship area was particularly in arms about the move to Liberty but what I heard was
116people saying this is being sprung on us the board's not taking its time you're not considering input and I think we also just learned through the bond campaign that we were getting the same message so I would encourage us to First have the discussion what needs to happen between now and to the point that we're going to make a decision with the public in the community and how we're going to engage them and then plan backwards from that that would be my opinion as to how to go about it and if that ends up being in May great but I want to be absolutely sure sure that we have given the public ample voice in whatever decision we're making and I know we bemoan the fact often that we have town halls and people do
117not show up and there are you know we try all these different mechanisms but I think we're going to have to try all those different mechanisms and more and we probably have to put our heads together and think about other ways we can engage the community on this because there's going to be a firestorm one way or another to director coin's points I don't like those ideas either but we got to have some plan we have to dis and if they're not great decision okay but there are certain facts about all of those potential models that I need to know and I think this is the question you asked first which is I would like to know costs associated costs with each one of those potential plans um do we have to remodel facilities is
118there Transportation cost that will be you know incurred that kind of thing impact on teachers and on the public comment we just heard I honestly do not fully understand the impact on certifications for teachers in our various buildings would like to have that information so I know how staff is going to be impacted by whichever path forward we go on and then lastly I need to better understanding on the impact for each of these models on the educational experience I don't know where that exists but is there data that shows that a 7 through n 10 through 12 model is detrimental to our kids in particular ways if we can get to that I want to see it that's my point of view director moral or president moral uh yes so um first of all
119so I've been waiting uh a bit here before speaking um first of all uh there was not an error on the agenda uh after my discussion with director gallinger and then my discussion with uh superintendent Tek I was the one that proposed the 2728 because I think that this is a huge decision and I whatever that result is is going to S take some time to actually have it Implement and I think rushing it having some type of decision by May so that we have a quote unquote year to try to figure out all of the logistics around it I don't think is sufficient so I'm already out with a 26 27 um evaluation of what that is the community spoke really clearly saying let's take a pause let's figure out what is the best
120solution I do want to say though that um I mentioned this to the superintendent I lived through this making a a significant change at the time it was a significant change to one school in which there was of all the results there was only one that was possible so what I really want to avoid is rushing looking at at you know a closed set of options and then making and then making it look like we're engaging the community when we know only one is possible it is not possible for us to have students starting at school if they would have to go from 6:00 a.m. till 1:30 which is just means you're picking kids up at 5:00 in the morning that's so it's it's already there it's a full stop that's not going to happen
121so we can go forward and have that as you know do you like this option do you like this option it reminds me of asking people would you like us to end school early start school later or not have um winter break second winter break and you get the community is a mixed and you don't really get a decision made by them I don't don't want to do what we did with liberty and the six period schedule where in the previous administration they put together a big group they came together for like six months and then it was all fixed from the beginning like the only answer they could have come up with was the one that was intended so I don't want to go through a big huge long process if we find that
122there are there isn't um anything more amendable I mean anything more possible than looking at where do we have room in schools we have room in elementary so if we're going to push to do the 26 27 school year then we already know what our answer is going to be unless we start looking at building but if we're going to make any changes to reduce um capacity at the high schools by the 26 27 school year only one of the options that are presented to us is the one that's possible and none of them are likable but that's the one that's possible I just don't know logistically how you can make that happen within a year because you're talking about figuring out which which schools would then go which which sets of sixth graders would
123go to which elementaries and then you know look at boundaries and which elementary schools have full capacity and then you have Ive that I don't think does so you can't be sending kids there so I I just systems wise I don't know that saying we're going to come up with a solution for the 26 27 school year makes sense to me so if that's what the board feels and that can be a board consensus move but I think that even if we want to say we have to set some parameters of time frame otherwise it's not going to get done so if people don't feel comfortable with May then throw out a time frame like throughout December of 2025 but I mean that that takes us 10 months away and this is an important work
124to get done that I don't believe is going to be 10 months and I think that we we need to have realistic time frames and expectations so that we know and so families can start planning for that and that's why so I'm not beholding the may but I I do believe that we need to have some time frames and the whole point of us talking about criteria is because if it is no going to school what I'm hearing like not school does not start before its current start time would be a potential criteria like we we need to set some broad boundaries so what's generated by the administration isn't one that we would say go fish and that that's why this is important for us to have so here's here's my suggestion um because we
125don't we February March April May so here's what I would suggest is that um by May in maybe similar format to the budget the board's budgetary guidelines that we commit to by may we will come up with guidelines for what um like what are our boundaries around how we can look at re reallocating students around the district to get to that to get to that point in May what I what I think what would be great is if we set some interim pieces one is if we flush out all of the options we've heard and we've um assumed into an actual readable document right so we've talked about n9th Grade Campus is that feasible or not we've talked about redistricting the other school districts other ones that we sort of talk about in rule out
126we should do a good documentation of which ones aren't even possible to go to a um a deeper review and on the ones that still have some level of viability for those then we can get into some what are the key considerations like what would have to be true in order to implement them start times of the day Transportation considerations um capacity by building at all levels right where are we for across every school um and then uh I think that would be a fair amount of input to get to by May which is what are what are some principles around restructuring that we can talk through and agree to and then I think um to director Taylor's Point while we're doing that we can figure out what is the timeline for a successful engagement
127approach um I think we did a lot of Engagement over the past few months I think um very impressed with the Improvement in comms we have an opportunity to do that over a Runway to what we think would be a good and successful plan so we can lay out what is a plan that would include engaging with multiple constituents over time creating feedback we've done we did thought exchanges this time we did town Halls this time we asked for submissions of questions through podcasts I think we we did a lot of creative ones but I think we could lay out that time frame and then to your point I would say why don't we we could set another window of once we look at what we think a successful engagement plan would look like to
128get to all the people and all the places to set an actual decision date post that um I'm willing to say we don't know what a success successful engagement timeline is at this point I would pick six months but that would be completely arbitrary right based on what we know but we can also ask people that question right who who do you want to hear from how do you want to hear it what formats are needed and then create an actual plan so I would go with a May for um any initial principles we have once we have some data about the options that are on the table that we can go through in detail and then maybe in may we look at what would a planning timeline for engagement look like to set a
129decision timeline I I just want to make sure that this is something that we understand that there is going to be a decision made and this isn't just perfunctory going through this exercise for no decision like also for me one criteria is like change is H change has to happen and I worry that by prolonging this people will get a sense of we just have to win this war through attrition I think I have heard all of us say a change has to happen I I I'm not as worried about that I guess I or how else can I say that I I I support your goal director Galler I I do think we understand that we're at a place where we will like we likely need to make a change so but I do
130like director Ming's staged approach I think that makes sense and I also think I would just add on that when when we get to a point we create a plan that we share that obviously with the public in ways that can be consumed much like the bond information on a bond website what have you so all that you know can be consumed by the public I would like to ask for the superintendent's opinion as as you're sitting here chewing on this as to what the burden is on your staff and whether this is doable the time frames are throwing out here now or is it not oh there I mean this is a we're talking about a fundamental overhaul of our entire system so let's just say that um that is the change and magnitude
131of change which is probably pretty unprecedented to do in a very you know in any given time frame right in general so uh I think this will take an enormous amount of lift um on all all people's parts right that are involved in the system um I know that one thing that the the board really wants is intentional engagement so how it gets phase in different phases is is one thing having a decision about this by a certain time frame by May makes me feel uncomfortable for lots of reasons um because I don't think there's enough time to do that kind of surfacing of the conversation and it will feel rush and we also have to Everyday run schools and and do great things in in partnership with our families and our kids and and
132with you all so um for me this this uh complexity and the order of magnitude of change is Weighing on me um so speed I think is when I when I hear when I feel that sort of in my gut this lexity and magnitude of order of change is so so voluminous I say let's just really make sure that we are intentional and being thoughtful um I always like to say to myself you know make sleep on it right before you make a final decision on something especially if it is something in my gut telling me um that is going to be very challenging or hard um I mean to for for comparison you know the seventh how do how do you manage a seventh day period shift right that was the most analogous sort
133of recent example um and that took a year of of conversation and Eng agement I know that that conversation did start earlier so I want to be clear that it wasn't the conversation kind of happened and there was only a year worth of Engagement and the board had been talking about that for some time and there was a lot of things but then even uh the amount of time one that formally did kick off was a full year so the magnitude of change for this I think outpaces and is greatly outsized compared to a seventh period day change for a high school schedule um so there's lots of things I mean so I also am hearing new ideas so what will also happen during any process is new ideas will be coming forward right and
134I don't I think I hear also willingness to entertain what those ideas are so that we're not limited to the three bad ideas that were on the December board meeting um and I want to honor that I think many people in our community during the bond the two bond election Cycles we're we're we're surfacing actually some of those bad ideas because we haven't been able to be in a space of generating opportunity and insight around what really is going to take us not only to a place where we have improvements on the student experience but we're also um not using structure right to then dampen that in some way we want to make sure that we pull out what those trade-offs or risks might be some things off the um and I and I know
135that I mean just hearing all of our team members that did come and share public comment on zoom and in the room that there's a lot out there in terms of where we can generate partnership to just hear what people are saying and also what might inform parameters right they might have their own um input on that so based on the various ideas and options you know I think we we would want to then also have a thorough riew and audit of all those implications so director Taylor did ask about cost implication certification Staffing uh all of that does take a significant level of understanding of the Ripple effects in a way that our system hasn't had to take that full audit before so it would take a lot of Staff time to be able
136to figure okay well if we make this change here then what's the implication to our serving students with special services in some of the programs that exist how are we going to square that with their efforts to increase access to learning with peers how are we going to think about Merlin Science Tech te dual language um all of the CTE Pathways what about what happens to Gibson e because that currently is a 912 would that be exempt would that be part of this um operations considerations are you know how do you run High School classes in a middle school middle school classes and an elementary school so we have kids in elementary school remaining in one classroom I taught in a middle school where my middle school kids did not rotate classes and teachers did
137and there are implications for the experience for both staff as well as students when you are shuffling as a teacher between classrooms to teacher students uh because of finite space so there are you know those are that's one example um operations considerations are certainly around gosh how are we going to uh do the food service requirements so there are all different legislation uh ideas come up around having kids sit right after after lunch for 20 minutes and so how does that play into all the different requirements that we do have for food service um as well so there's Transportation implications um do we have the right space properly um in a um Middle School to Run High School courses um there's a bunch of different considerations for as teachers were sharing on public comment around
138um what does it mean for my certification to be 912 right and but I have to then push into a um a different model which is which is 79 that's it just changes the way our certification matching and it'll adjust our admin ratios so how do we think about evaluations for our assistant principles and our principles there's supervision requirements as well when we look at U maybe adding sixth grade to a an elementary school um so these are just a several of the things that are on my mind as I've been it's been recing right through through hearing people but also um as as I've been thinking about this very deeply as well and ultimately you know there's are there are questions around what this do to elective activities to Choice um so these are
139Big this is a big change and I want people that are listening to know that this is just a sample of all the kind of considerations that we will need to be able to thoughtfully review surface concerns on Surface tradeoffs and be able to say at the end of the day what is best for kids and uh superintendent tell I appreciate those comments you know I I guess where I'm struggling and I'm I'm fine with the timeline but I'm struggling with having our district look at the ideas from that slide because those are specific items that we spoke against in both the November and the and the February Bond measures we talked about the reason why the Freshman Campus was not a good option we talked about why the junior high model was not you
140know the the superior direction to go we talked why about why dual scheduling would not work so I'm struggling with why we would go back and have the District put resources to researching you know to to to pricing that out or researching it and we know that it's it's those are inferior options I think that the community has told us at least this is my interpretation that to pause and to come back with new ideas so I I know I keep trying to move us to this personal conversation but that's I think where we need to go I don't think the community is coming back and saying research these other items we during both of those campaigns said those items are not going to work and here's why and so I struggle with asking the
141district to research things that we have said repeatedly would not be good for students particularly the junior high model um I really want the district I want us to think about new ideas to use existing resources to use existing funds and see how we can come up with a solution that's good for students so Dr coin I I agree with your sentiment however we have other elected officials like multiple SM city council folks who have said you should do the fix by k6 79 1012 and as long as that continues to be voiced loudly from their dis we are being forced into this decision of costing out the implications and I think the cost that you talked about that I think is is the most underestimated is the cost to students and you know I
142think this board and this Administration has really narrowed the focus to the student experience and there is no question that none of these options are going to elevate the student experience so uh d molens i i maybe disagree with you director coin I think we've we have discussed why we feel that those models will not be successful we have not documented the truth of that in a way that someone can consume that on their own so um no I don't necessarily think that will change someone's opinion I think there are those who just want to use one of those answers because they're available but I I do think there's a there is an opportunity I'm not saying people have to do dissertations on this stuff but we should say hey there are multiple things that
143have been considered and are no longer in consideration for the following reasons so I don't I don't think it has to be you know I think obviously the deeper research should go to the most viable options but I do think we we owe a greater outline like for example I think we verbalized that there's more freshmen now than we're on the nth Grade Campus but that's not documented anywhere that's not written down as like an alternative considered and answered so I do think um especially in a case like this because again I want people to understand we looked at all the options we took all the opportuni ities that's what I'm going to keep coming back to and I think we have the opportunity to be a more crisp you know when people are like
144well I could go to Belle well Belle's got full high schools we we those are things that can be better documented Milo has had her hand raised Milo hi um for those of you who don't know me I'm a student rep from Gibson hi I'm Milo I see some of my old Middle School teachers in here so that's really great I'm excited that everybody is tuning in to listen um one thing I would say is in that December meeting when you were all as let me make sure that my mic you can actually hear me uh in that December meeting when everybody was going through like the options of either a split timing like starting really early or just any of those other options I know at least I was and after I talked to
145that meeting uh to my friends about it they were all like oh these ideas suck I know you know that they're not the greatest ideas um but I I just want to be here to really urge you guys to look into other ideas I'm a gibon x student so I personally am not on campus for 5 days a week week I'm off campus for two at an internship where I get to build wonderful skills I get to teach monor um I was intern with the district and I was off- campus but I was still doing a lot of learning and so I think this can really be a good opportunity to look into Innovative learning and different ways that you guys can um kind of up our learning and I I think if what you
146say is that you guys are a truly student focused student experience-based which I know from like talking to each one of you that you really are that if that is super super important to you then you'll want to talk to students you'll want to talk to teachers but most importantly you'll want to try to find a different option even if it's it's hard and I mean the best things are always the harder option and they won't come easy and they might not be easy to implement but I I would like to see some Innovation or some new thing we have a really great Innovation team capital projects we've got all this experience from our Gibson High School our principal and special assignment jul abamba there are tons of people you can talk to um but
147either finding a different way to utilize the space that we have or doing those internships I don't know I just I would like to see us looking at different op options and opportunities so like like what director coin and said thank you uh yeah thank you so much so there's a lot that has been thrown out today and I just kind of wanted to synthesize it from a bit of a student perspective and offer some new takes as well so I think first of all today and within the past few weeks especially surrounding um putting forward the bond the second time um I've been discussing the potential changes that could be made in terms of easing overcrowding with a lot of students at Isco high school and the overwhelming consensus and I think this is
148something that was echoed by uh mrol earlier in public comment as well is that there's the potential for a lot of these options to be more damaging than the overcrowding that we're dealing with right now at least from a student perspective um if I look at uh times in terms of changing double shifting I know that that brings up a lot of transportation and extracurricular issues and things like that um when it comes to shifting where students are in terms of the Middle School and High School Elementary grades that for me and the people that I've talked to at least brings up a lot of questions in terms of um how can we adjust classb how does that change what our applications look like how does that change the way um our GPA get calculated
149when it comes to things that get stried um and I would honestly feel that that overcrowding is something that I feel every day and it's definitely an inconvenience to me but I don't think that it has hindered my learning to the degree that um a change in the opportunities that I get in terms of classes or things like that would be um for percent overcrowding um and or excuse me for Shifting the percentage of students from isqua and Skyline to Liberty I honestly saw this as a viable option for a long time um I recently just looked at the statistics on the istd website in terms of what overcrowding looks like and I've always heard that Liberty is a smaller school but is school as um overcrowding is 10% which doesn't feel like a lot
150but it is um and Liberties is 15% in terms of uh like scaling those so I don't uh really see that and my whole point with this is that um trust in the community comes from trust within our schools as well and I feel that while we are moving quickly I think there's a lot of action towards um incorporating those things and I One really hope that we um value our student and teacher opinions and takes on the ground um two like Milo and director Mings were saying looking at more creative options um especially expanding R CTE I think this is a great opportunity um and three I understand that action must be taken and change has to happen but I fear that doing so in this way might just be changing something for the
151sake of saying okay we've alleviated this problem without um taking into consideration all the possible drawbacks for students um I really appreciate what AA said I'd also like to say like I don't know if what the community is saying is that overcrowding is the most important issue I would like to say that the only signs that were up were about overcrowding but that was not the only issue on the bond so the things that the community is hearing is about overc overcutting is an issue but it's the only thing we're hearing about so it's the only thing that people are talking about I think it's important to go and talk to people um you have a lot of really cool smart people educated people in this building who have lots of ideas and they're really
152cool you have a lot of really talented cool Educators who are in your buildings every single day who have a lot of cool ideas you have a lot of really cool kids who are getting educated in those buildings and they have a lot of ideas and this might need to be something that does take time it doesn't feel good to say like we're going to push this out but maybe this isn't what it was but as somebody who doesn't know what you're talk you've guys have been talking about like when you brought up these three options in the meeting after the bond um failed it did it did feel like a kn- jerk reaction it did feel like a fear response it didn't feel like something that was being approached with cool heads and that's
153not comforting to the community and what is comforting is when you say these are the ideas that we had what do you guys think are these really bad ideas and maybe they'll say yeah what other ideas are there and people have ideas everybody has a different perspective and then taking that and processing that and listening listening to understand and not speaking to convince and that's where trust comes from and there was no trust built by moving at top speed there was no trust built by that and I can I see that in the students that I talk to who were like wait there's a bond what even is this Bond like does it matter should I listen to the people who are saying no I know from the adults in my life who I've been
154talking to and who voted gu the first time at least and Trust doesn't happen when we move quickly it happens when we take a second to breathe and to listen and that's my perspective as as a student in the district and as somebody who's spent a lot of time in these meetings so um Yumm me yeah I'm sorry I'm really impressed by our student reps and my these friends here today um just adding on to aa's point about school overcrowding we've stressed it a lot during these meetings um as well as just our Outreach to our community um I mentioned at the last school War meeting that I sent out a survey on um was high school just asking if students felt that schools were overcrowded if our school was overcrowded I have the numbers
155here today um my survey uh got responses from 638 students out of a total of around 2,48 84 I think um and I have the numbers so the first question that I asked was do you think ISO High School is overcrowded 61% said yes for a clear number that's 388 28% said no that's 181 students or respondents and then 11% said unsure and that's 71% and my next question was would you be interested in being interviewed about the subject majority of students as you might expect said no uh but I did get 133% that said yes and that is 84 students and following this survey I sent out emails to these students that said that yes they were interested in being interviewed and I interviewed a small number of them I think around 10 um
156and I did get a mix of students who thought ISO high school was overcrowded isak high school was not overcrowded and mix students thought when I asked is ISO High School overcrowded they said that's a tough question and I think that just kind of points Us in the direction of taking some time to figure out what our students want what our staff want because as we've said in previous meetings our students a majority of them even if our school is overcrowded it doesn't feel like it is because it is what we have always known and while that is a sad fact because we could be getting better better education we could be having a better experience in schools I think a majority of students uh in our schools today think they're schools are pretty great
157and we're very appreciative of our teachers and our school staff for managing us and teaching us and uh doing such a great job uh handling such large classrooms um but just echoing what ala said this is all we've known um and while it is kind of inconvenient to not be able to find a parking space to um bump into people in the Halls it's okay it's not great but it's okay we can manage right now and when we're talking about building a new school about new options and redistricting and how to solve overcrowding um we need to look at the effects of what our students are feeling right now and are are students like very unhappy because to me it doesn't look that way it looks to me like we have some time to take
158a breath and reach out to to our community and find the best possible answer without rushing to build trust and to do it in the best possible way for our community our students and our staff because and what I'm saying right now might be upsetting to some teachers because they're the ones having to teach 30 students in a single classroom and move around classrooms in the Halls during passing period with a cart and not have their own rooms which is tough um but that is what the students are facing right now and that is what I as a student representative believe um a majority of our students at is high school are experiencing so just on the topic of planning and having ideas on how to address overcrowding please do take a breath and ask
159us what's wrong what's going on in our lives and what are our thoughts on this issue and just one small point do we need change at this moment right now or can we wait a bit thank you um I want to start off by saying that all my fellow Representatives have kind of read my mind um uh one thing I do want to it like strongly you make a point on is that there seems to be really really strong teacher support and I know there's even stronger student support and um this is not a change that like needs to be made just in this like small circle and this like Community I feel like obviously we've gone over the three options which I collectively I think we all think are bad so being open to
160potentially new options or but even by you know talking to students or teachers or so on so forth would be a great idea as far as mayze seems for me at least mentally I don't think it's like close to enough time to even think about making a change of this like caliber especially because as superintendent said it's a fundamental change in the way the district operates and that just trying to understand um the student perspective not even going to the district perspective it's just it's hard for me to understand um other thing is that a lot of these uh Solutions per se seem to create a lot new problems I know overcrowding is a big issue um but kind of like my other representative representative said it's sad that this has become the norm but
161by alleviating over crowding we're creating potentially creating so many more issues and it's just this big like cycle of like all right now we fixed overcrowding and now we got to fix like the potential classes offered so on so forth um one last thing is I do know Liberty is the least overcrowded and it is easy to you know to say to Let's shift students to the school or like let's shift students here redo boundaries but it's important to realize that the more Liberty already is it's pretty packed I bumped in a couple people myself today but um adding you know potentially hundreds more students just especially in the smaller premise it's going to be a challenge um overall what I want to say though is that I feel like what I've at least heard
162from today is that taking like some sweet time with this and really trying to think through um what we might potentially do in the future I don't think it's something that can be made quickly and really trying to determine like is this something that we can address now because it's clear that overcutting has been an issue for a while but like we're still here we're still doing all the great things we are so I just want to add that thank you so we spent an hour admiring the problem and this is what I worry about if we don't actually take steps forward we'll still be here six months nine months 12 months admiring the problem and the point of tonight is to kick start a convers ation to work towards a solution and a destination
163and otherwise we're just like the state legislature with admiring the problem of school funding and they can talk about and take days and days of public testimony on how short funded our schools are but at the end of the day they don't do anything and that's not what we want because ultimately if there is something that requires all of our students to be in a building that's catastrophic on campus I want that to happen and if that tradeoff is kids being in a middle school instead of a high school I'll I'll choose that over the alternative and that's what's super important to me so cost has uh many implications uh director Molin yeah so I'll go back to my proposal so um so I think we need to do some level of Investigation of the
164items at hand I don't think I mean tonight what I wanted to talk about was are there something else we should add to the list um on this list which is reconfiguring existing footprint I I don't have any new items to add to that discussion that to be evaluated but I think we should document the ones that we sort of talked about and ruled ruled out or and confirmed this should be ruled out um and get that into uh straight order but I think the ones we've discussed unless someone else has another option they want on the T put on the table tonight to be investigated then I think we need to at least just go through those documentum and then we can come back and evaluate what we want to do about those in
165particular um I would like to do that in uh I would like to do that in May so in May and that's all the ideas we've heard to date put them down in piece paper better are about configurating within the building structure we have and then in May I would also like a proposal for what the engagement process is to review those options with the community and I will even pick a decision date um a first opportunity for decision and maybe we treat it as we treat all policy which is as a first read second read maybe that's the way to help uh not set the expectation that whenever we get to a decision Point it'll be a knee-jerk but we can absolutely do it in a first read second read and then final approval
166in a third uh conversation and I so I would say we can go with first read um September okay so what I'm hearing is uh sourcing choices and elevating them by May to work towards an engagement and then getting towards decision making by Fall is that what I heard you say I did yeah okay uh president moraldo yeah I'll just go back to I think that it's going to be really hard for us to even if we have a decision by September to make that happen within this that next school year to begin on in 26 um I think that whatever changes we're going to be looking at will be radical and systemwide and um I just really hesitate in stating that whatever change needs to be done and in place by the 26 27
167school year that hear you I I I would second that too I would struggle I I guess I'm going to reiterate what I said earlier I would struggle with putting a timeline on this right now and I mean we can put a motion on the table i' not to vote for it uh but I would struggle with the timeline and I would struggle with asking the district to spend much more time with those options I know maybe there's more information we can provide but we were pretty clear again through both of these campaigns why those would not work and I guess we can spend more time throwing data at it and um I just am not supportive of that I want I want us to spend time listening to the community I I I I
168looking at that election from Tuesday and trying to read what the voters are telling us I don't think that they're telling us that there's urgency around overcrowding or they would that percentage would have been higher than 50% I think we're not on the rights we see it but I think our community the community that came out and voted didn't see it that way so I think we need to spend more time and I don't I don't feel comfortable putting a timeline on that I'm not sure how long it's going to take for us to to lean into the community and figure what out what it is I fully still support that we need to figure out some sort of a solution for overcrowding in our high schools um but I'm not comfortable putting a timeline
169on when we'll we'll put together a a potential recommendation and I definitely don't think I'd be comfortable with the you know two years school years out I mean this um we need more time we need to spend more time listening Amy I just want to Echo D president maralto director coin and some of uh the student reps earlier points um first off um do we need to decide on a deadline at this moment and and I ask this because having a deadline as just an ordinary Community member as just a regular teacher as a staff member having a deadline set for deadline during this school year is very stressful and that kind of stress uh inspires dis distrust and fear as we've seen with pre previous uh board action and District action on things like
170el12 uh those changes and those uh proposals were made uh fairly rushed um with limited input from our community and those decisions sparked a lot of outrage and fear and distrust in our just even our school community so I would highly highly highly encourage us to wait to listen and to take things slow we don't have to to stop and take a full physical Halt and pause we can redirect our efforts to communicating and trusting and building trust with our community um and even if we do want to set a deadline um in the next few meetings I would suggest uh speaking with our teachers and our uh on the ground School staff first because these decisions will impact them at the foremost um students will feel the impact too but is it is teachers
171and our principles and counselors that will also be feeling that stress most directly because that is their jobs um so I would highly encourage uh you the board and the District administration to reach out to them and to get their opinion and hear their voice on things before setting a deadline and making plans for changes if you decide to do any thank you Dr mol okay so what I'm trying to get to is forward progress um and so what I'm trying to get to I hear the suggestions about hearing from people but we also need to plan to do that so I'm all for feedback and communication but we have to make a plan and I know for other people that may not feel great but if we so then what we should say and
172I hear what you're saying director Quinn but then please give me an I would love to hear an alternative to put together a plan to do the listening you would like to to hear but like to leave it open-ended we will leave this room and nothing will happen and people will not have been engaged so if making if the stressor is getting to a decision Point okay what is the what is the what is the proposal for for putting together the plan to get to communication so we can direct the district and put Motion in place that's what I'm not comfortable leaving with is without some forward motion of how we when we and I'll give you the example we when we did our listening sessions we sat at this dis and we said okay
173we're going to do listening sessions Town Halls podcast we made all those decisions and I'm I'm happy to agree to do all of that again I hear the feedback that people don't want to get to a decision too quickly what I need to hear is a proposal of what does it mean to listen and put together a plan to do that can I just quickly respond um I I guess I'm saying I would be comfortable leaving tonight without one and maybe that is feels uncomfortable to to some folks but I think what I have learned is maybe and and this was my own mistake in this potentially maybe we've moved too quickly on some of these things I I mean I frankly would be okay walking away from this saying hey we need to pause
174we need to listen to the community and leave it at that tonight I don't think we have to come up with a timeline I I yes I agree I think there needs to be a prob there needs to be a timeline eventually I this just feels it's still too raw like why can't we take some time and think about what it is I just I don't want us to run out and put another timeline on this I mean I think we've done that a lot and it hasn't really worked for us in our favor so and I would be okay if the majority of the board wants that I just that isn't where I'm at tonight dror Taylor then president raldo um okay I I think there's Middle Ground here I completely agree I think
175we need a plan I think it is time to let's run these options to ground let's get the information in front of us so we can evaluate it make a decision our gut reaction tells us right now that are not very good decisions but let's run it to ground go through the process come to that point at the same time uh to the superintendent's Point undoubtedly or hopefully new ideas will come up and we'll go through the same process to run those things to ground as well and for the ultimate time frame I agree with you director coin maybe now's not the time to say this is for the 28 school year or 29 what have you but I do agree with director mulling I think we got to move forward this is what's in
176front of us now let's deal with it we're going to be moving forward on other fronts too I mean we're certainly not done with um the discussion around financing for a new high school that's going to be a whole another you know strategic plan that we're going to have to come up with so I think we have to keep moving forward on all of them and this is the path forward as far as is President ralo yes so I do want to be clear that I um I I want to make a decision that we would start moving forward um I just don't think that having something ready by the 26 27 school year is is um reachable um without basically saying we're going to listen to the community but we're not going to listen
177to the community that's my fear that's what happened in a previous mind you I'll go back you know practically 13 years but I don't want the community to feel like we're asking for their input but we really don't want it if we really want the community's input I think it's going to take more time um you know much to what the students were saying I think there's some great ideas out there that might not be things that we've thought of yet um and that having those conversations will weed that out I just don't see an implementation by 2026 as reasonable so so I that's fine I understand that I still fear that by not providing any boundaries to the possibilities we're wasting Community time and staff time and what of the non-negotiables is We're not
178gonna have school start before 8 am like that should be elevated early on in the same way we have budget development guidelines I think that's that's my worry like for me if it doesn't address our overcrowding it's not a a a reasonable option uh if it's uh something other ones that I've heard heard about the um cost or some people maybe like don't adjust the boundaries or some people maybe like the boundaries must be adjusted so I I think that's my my concern is by leaving it so wide open then it's disingenuous about saying like oh here everything's fair game and then but it's not like so for instance if we don't if we leave it on the table like in District transfer to another District so I just want to be careful about it
179being so wide open so I would still recommend that we go for a narrowed set of options by sometime this late spring and I'm fine if the decision making is by December of next of of the start of the next school year and then for a 27 28 implementation that part is fine but none about nothing about that feels rushed but to me by walking out of tonight without some sort of pathway forward seems uh like again to me like we're not listening we didn't hear I think I heard at least my opinion is do something different director mulling and then back to presid ralo yeah so the here's where I hear the anxiety in this conversation I hear there's anxiety around the implementation year we should separate that out in the discussion there's anxiety
180about making a decision about what the change will be I'm actually not talking about either of those all I'm trying to do is plan for how we will how we will close out on things we've suggested and how we will do an engagement process and I just want to bring up we are the hardest people to schedule on earth like I'm being super practical it's impossible to schedule us so if we don't actually say here's what we want to do to hear people to meet with them and be them and put a plan together to do that it will literally not happen for the next year and so all I'm trying to get to is one is all the suggestions that have been made Let's just write down what they are and then we're still
181gonna still have to have the conversation about the other side of this which is I think there's still options we haven't talked about yet but on this one I so I'm not trying to I'm not trying to rush to an answer I'm trying to be practical about the use of time right if I just look at my travel schedule over the next three months we can narrow that down to me being any conversation to minimal days so I'm just trying to be practical about if we're saying we want to engage and listen then we actually need to have a plan to engage and listen anytime in the next six months so that we can do that I would separate from that the anxiety if uh I I'm not trying to put a finite end date
182on um making the decision I'm trying to get to are we taking some practical action between now and then to do the things we're all saying we want to do very practically president R um I I think I would wholly wholeheartedly agree that I want to get us started when are we going to get things done for me though I'm speaking to the motion the motion is about the structure of schools will change by this date you want to so that's why I'm uneasy about it if we were to so if we weren't to pass this we can still say that by you know you can tell your board president Hey by the May the first meeting in may we would like to work on guidelines for the restructuring of schools and I bet that
183would get on the agenda because I think she's pretty reasonable to that because I agree uh being able to put that forward I'm just speaking to the motion as it has been so would we like to should we would someone since I made the first one would someone like to put forward something else do you want to amend it I would amend it to be I move the board adopt and change the structure of schools to take effect in the 27 28 school year second any discussion on the amendment see no discussion and moving us forward all those in favor of the amendment say I I any opposed oos is is it I haven't done it an opposition V is it I you just say name name okay it gives it gives some we always
184agree so okay the amendment pass don't interest at least since I've been oh no that the one two two away is we don't always agree okay so the am the amended motion is to move for the the board adopt a change in the structure of schools to take effect for the 27 28 school year and what I heard through consensus is we will have a a menu of options by the first meeting in May and I heard that we will do some deep and wide listening uh over the course of some fall time period I do believe if we're going to hit our Target we still must have an answer to the community by the middle of next school year even to give a year and a half out so that's why I worry even
185if for that I think that the longer we wait the harder it is for the system because I still I think a year and a half is not a lot of time for what this potentially could be required my assumption is that depending on what the options are that would then inform the conversation on a timeline uh for for when to make a decision by um uh this is a this is a big moment because I the board has not taken action like this before to make a decision for something so far in advance without hearing the recommendation first so this is really unprecedented to you know to show your will here um so we uh have all good intent to be thoughtful and supporting a very intentional um engagement process and I think that
186it'll be very important for people to show up and to share their ideas and to make sure that they are sharing all of the ways that they can um we can consider what both the trade-offs might be but also the benefits because I really want to make sure that whatever happened that we are centering our teachers and our students and our staff at the core um and that we're not jeopardizing the really good work that we also do know that we have you know as a foundation couldn't agree more any more discussion all those in favor of the amended motion I don't see president raldo on the screen so can I see her we're not no that's been table no yeah we're just doing this this motion right here and then we're moving into the
187desert conversation I promise we approved the amendment correct you getos correct and now we need to approve the amended motion so all those in favor of the amended motion say I I I I those oppos n hey motion carries okay so now the second part of this conversation is really well all those options sound really unpalatable uh at least to me $160 million seems like a lot of money and so I think we engage our friends uh with the city of isqua and uh we have an upcoming uh dinner date with them in just a few weeks actually so I I I suspect this will be the topic of conversation of I think we will with the permit exper we're gonna have to completely start over and do a site revision but use that as
188an opportunity to dream what is it that we can build within our budget uh and maybe it is a phasing element where it's built such that the central core I.E the cafeteria and all the entrance areas and a classroom Wing is built to support you know 800 students to address overcrowding and it could start as a specialty focused High School whether it's Health Sciences or technology but designed in a way that uh if that's the way we go another Wing could be added that would could also be another specialy school or it could change into a comprehensive High School my understanding that Skyline opened supposedly as a specialty based School small was not intended to half Athletics and for those of you that go to Skyline it'd be hard to imagine Skyline without Athletics and
189yet like things change but I think we could ask for the design to include that sort of phasing capacity because uh I think that would allow us to reach towards goals of let's Infuse what we believe is best for students which is choice and career focused learning uh it doesn't have to have a stadium it doesn't have to have Auditorium and hopefully we could negotiate with the city to not have a parking garage or a smaller campus which would save a lot of funding so uh I I like the ideas about however engaging with a real because again that's their job to let's do a site selection let's let's look at there like there is no harm in that and I think that that's an important thing to do having been part of that discussion
190for a decade I I will be impressed if they can find anything within the urban growth boundary uh that would meet the needs of of a high school of our size but there's no there's no harm in doing that look again there's no harm in engaging with corporate partners and sponsors and I don't know maybe building a Ninth Grade Campus is not off the table uh as sort of a phase one of the project to then work on you know but if it's designed and cited in such a way that it could over time you know continue to serve students I I don't think it's a bad thing so I think that this is an opportunity for us to look at we should be able to do a lot of things for students for 160
191million doll and if that like yes we're G have to go through permitting and redesign but since we're have to go through it I think I would love to sort of this is the the second part of the conversation which is we have to go through the painful part of should nothing go forward and should the the we get denied and permit and because we won't know that for a couple years given how long like having sat on this part it getting the initial permit took more than two years from the time of application so this is not a short process so we we can't like keep K kicking the can down the road in my opinion because we've done that now and we're on year nine of that so uh but I think we
192should be able to really think about and I encourage us think about we should ask uh not just for the redesign part but to look at as a stage design and focus on Career Focus learning because since we're building new space this is the time to build it versus retrofitting space at isqua or Skyline we know is going to be expensive uh and we don't have the for that so opening up for the desert conversation respond I don't know if I have much more to say I agree with everything you just said I mean that's what gets me excited I mean I I I don't know how detailed we want that conversation to be tonight I mean I think you covered all of the the high level ideas that I that are consistent with what
193I've been thinking about um it gives us the opportunity maybe to start smaller and then grow out of that I mean a space you know maybe it's a nth Grade Campus maybe it's a nth Grade Campus with a CTE space I mean maybe there's more magnet programs that could potentially be there I I don't know what that could look like but those are the things that I think are exciting and I that's where I would like to explore further and I think engaging the the community around that I think engaging the Providence Point Community around that I think we want we need to have more conversation with them as well and I'm you know definitely willing to do that too so those are the things that those Concepts get me excited yeah I I'm not
194sure we like Ninth Grade Campus because it would have to be so big it would be almost the size of our high school so like it would be 12200 students so I don't think we have the funding for a 1,200 student building well or but if we think differently about that ninth I don't know we could think it maybe it's not ninth graders all from Skyline and from isqua there could be a re in there could be a different way to think about that I don't know some creative ways that help with overcrowding but don't take us back in time still move us forward in a way that helps us to meet our longer term goals as a district those are the conversations I want to be having and again that's where I struggle though
195because those are those are going to be long lengthy conversations I'm not sure or maybe some of them will move quicker than we think that's why right now I'm not comfortable with committing to a timeline like I I mentioned earlier but yeah I'm those are the things to get me excited oh don't worry that won't be our timeline okay Dr Taylor uh yes completely agree you know my my wife actually to two or three weeks ago said something along the lines of why don't you build a modular High School meaning some module some portion of it now uh which was you know got me thinking along these very lines too so yes uh I'm going to say the same thing we just same conversation we just had which is I fully support it let's come
196up with the plan what are the steps in order to do that it's creative thinking obviously um so what do we need to do to push this this stream work stream I guess I would say you know forward because it's it is all of those things about um you know starting to engage with the experts and start to really get some firm ideas as to what that might look like so yes I'm just basically yes president RDA yeah um this is really an exciting piece of you know I think I had said in testimony before that the city council in isqua that there was that the the permit was this ticking clock in the back of my head um but now that that's set to expire and um I don't know that we're going to
197have any other means to build the current plan and that's not a bad thing at this point so it's like how can we then rethink the structure of that entire plot of land is there a way of being able to parcel it out so that some of that can become uh revenue for the for the school district to be able to build what it is we need to build on what's left of that uh it allows us to maybe meet the uh the floor area ratio that um we always had to get an exception to because we have such a large plot of land and a small-sized building on it so we would be closer to the far that the uh city of isaa would like so I think there's a lot of opportunities um
198and I think that we have an opportunity to really focus in on our career uh Tech Career Training that we've talked about so it might not be um obviously at this point we don't have the finances to build something at each of the high schools but if we built a facility that students could come to and then they we be drawing them out of their high schools to go and attend um a skill center that might have a multiple a variety of different things and we can add the a tech we can add the uh the medical um and um and health that we want to look at we might be able to do um aona iCal um or construction so what are the capabilities once we scrap the plan that's currently there knowing that
199it's going to take at least two years probably a year to design something two years to get it permitted and then two years to construct it I do my biggest concern is going to be the cost um of things and just the explosion of costs over the next several years and I I wish that more community members would have understood that um during the election but you know the the County of LA is going to have to rebuild seven schools Portland is trying to build a comprehensive High School there's other large cities on the west coast trying to build schools and they're ex extremely expensive so cost of material is going to be astronomically High um because it's going to be in short demand for a lot of people going after that and so those
200things concern me um but I do think we need to start planning ahead what can we do with the money that we already have to ease the crowding that that we're concerned about so one of the things that's amazing is in the first version of the bond and all of the work that's been done over the last year maybe more on secondary Innovation um is that we have a plan for what we wanted to add on to each school I think we have large agreement of what programs we would run um what the structure of that would look at I think what what would be different and what I'd like to explore is putting that all Under One Roof and putting it cited at that property um I personally just to get super specific would
201love to see it cited where the elementary was and preserve the entire rest of it for a comprehensive High School in the future I say that all because just to make sure people know exactly what I want to see in the plan when we get it but I think we actually are quite close to that design today um of all of the components we said we would want to build at each of the existing Comprehensive High Schools um and that is an offering that I think will stand the test of time and be complementary to a comprehensive High School in the future I think preserving that entire property is a great value in future Revenue source to the district so if in the future we decided to segment off what remains after that um uh
202career center and sell some for develop real estate again I don't want to sell any of the property I actually want to be the developer um I'm not I'm have no interest in selling a parcel um I think working along with the city of VIs qu and there needs to grow housing um is another way we serve the entire Community if we get there um but that is what I would like to see is if we were to pull together the plans we have for each um each High School to grow on their career center and I think corporate Partnerships are great in each of those cases to help us outfit that if you add that in plus the money we have I think we have a lovely high functioning um career uh Development Center
203that will also help alleviate overcrowding by having 11th and 12th graders as already designed take advantage of those programs um so I think that is a way we can satisfy all of the same needs um while preserving the rest of that property for what may be a future growth of a full Comprehensive High School so sounds like we're hearing board consensus for moving forward with the redesign we don't have board consensus on what that redesign would look like other than to to serve students and focus on careers I think that's the consus redesign serve students focused on careers what parts of the property and what how it would look like different just a titch okay thank you uh this might be the time to re bring back a item but looks like President RDO has
204a I I just wanted to add that one of my criteria is that um now I've lost it but that in the time if I think of it I'll I'll let you know I'm sorry I'm sick um totally oh I know what it is that whatever we do that we start to do something more immediately on that property I think that's the other criteria oh yeah I think we're I think we're all on board there at least I am do I have to do something to untable it that's a president raldo question coming back to the previous agenda item I think yes so we would want to untable the motion the previous motion um I think you just bring back the tabled motion um I'd like to bring back the tabled motion on resolution second
205discussion I'm bringing back that motion see no discussion all those favors of bringing back that motion say I I I I any opposed none opposed okay so the motion before us is uh to reiterate I can you want me to reread it or you gonna do uh move that the board adopt resolution 1237 repealing resolution 1235 that called for a special election in the April 2025 for capital projects levies Is there further discussion and did we address whatever you were wanting to discuss in sequencing prior to voting on this I think we're close so I think what I wanted to understand before before voting on this one is one what would be our approach for I I wanted to make sure we weren't tabling it and not having some sort of tangible action we would
206take to engage the community to move forward in some way so I think we've addressed that and saying we will um in our previous conversation that we'll look at the Alternatives that were on the table we will detail out information about them so that's more clear and then we'll go into a formal listening process so I think that's good I think second what I wanted to make sure that we got to a discussion of is the last one we had which is we have a lot of money and we have property to develop and I would like to move forward with that um and if we are largely in agreement which I believe that last conversation indicated um then I am fine with pulling this off knowing that we can move forward with the dollars
207in hand and the property we have I would like to hear more discussion if folks agree with the way I just summed up the last conversation before for that vote I'll just say I agree I I'm not sure I have anything else to say yeah I fully agree with that me too is that why we paused this one I'm just uh no I just wanted to have it first and you guys always do the agenda in order I don't like so I wanted to talk about that one I dropped in my lap just for just just for the record can I add one just one additional thing we were having the conversation and I just for my my b colleagues so snow a tech center so I actually I went through I graduated from the
208ever public schools and I remember during my time there there is a CTE Center there it's actually I believe now it's within the mleo school district but I would love us to check that out I remember when I was in school that there was interest in it um it was quite popular and looking at it now it's quite comprehensive in terms of the different offerings and so that model again is is uh it's out there and I think we can explore it yes if you haven't visited uh like Wasington Tech where most of the wanic programs I encourage you guys to do that if you haven't gone to the skill center and Highline School District we've hosted meeting there uh intentionally so you could see it so I'd encourage you to do that as well
209uh so there are lots of skill centers across the state uh I would be hesitant to build it as a desney and skill center because those are even less funded from a Capital standpoint than what we are building locally so but the intent I think about serving kids through career Focus doesn't have to be exactly but that concept and for folks maybe that are listening and we're having the conversation those might be things to look at we want the 100 plus people potentially or maybe I don't know hopefully they're still on Zoom with us if they stick with us it's long it's late but those are the people I want you I want everybody in the community to check these things out and let us know what you think we want to hear from you
210we listen the feedback it's important any more discussion okay all those in favor of the motion in front of us say I any oppose next item on our agenda is high school graduation requirements for the class of 2029 which is for our newest board members this is probably the most highly contested board votes historically uh in the whole time that I've been here uh there's there's rarely uh consensus is that a challenge there might it's late there might be [Laughter] consens all right well we have um uh Char Cox here to talk about the high school graduation requirements and so we are going to move forward we'll uh talk about what uh is different but also specifically consider um a lot of the work on online learning and so that's an important thing to lift
211up during this conversation so but that I pass it over to Sher Cox great um good evening I guess it's still evening um Sher Cox executive director of secondary education and I'm here to just run very quickly through the high school graduation requirements for the class of 2029 and these are identical to the state of Washington graduation requirements um so the purpose is to get the board approval and then I do want to give a few online learning updates um to the board about some work that's currently happening and then some work that is uh in the planning um I don't have a clicker Stephen um so uh as as before we have four things in the state of Washington that our students um must do to graduate and that is earn 24 credits complete
212the high school and Beyond plan um complete a pathway as well as complete the Washington State History and for the most part the Washington State History is completed in um our middle schools um these are the credit requirements um they are in perfect alignment um for the most part with the state of Washington um just calling out a couple of things that um our strategic plan has guided us to do and that is provide a aligned course guide that will uh will be launched for the first time to all three of our Comprehensive High Schools will have a very similarl looking um course guide there will be some differences because a school with 1500 kids uh versus a school with 2500 kids cannot offer the same level of courses but for the most part um
213course alignment thanks to Julia Bamba and that team um is well underway uh and will launch in our new um course request process um and just reminder that that third year of Math and Science is based on student interest in their high school and Beyond plan um the high school and Beyond plan uh again this is part of our strategic plan workk that um uh director um neighbors has been working on and so the addition now is that it starts in sixth grade last year when I stood in this very spot it was for seventh grade through 12th grade and now uh it has pushed down into sixth grade with lessons being presented um throughout grades 6 through 12 um I did want to also call out that by the spring of 2027 we will
214have to transition to a new platform called School links and that is a decision that was made by the state of Washington to align all schools currently we use Z in the next slide um graduation Pathways uh the only and it's not a change last year it was um a brand new pathway but it is fully developed now this combination uh or I'm sorry the performance-based pathway where um students uh essentially present a portfolio that is um showing their math as well as their Ela competencies and that is um uh graded by our staff um at the high schools and then our uh Gibson X students um this is their graduation requirements um they uh have a very different um life uh than our comprehensive um students do as far as how they earn the
215um graduation requirements and they are outlined here and I just want to pause there because that is um the part that you are approving tonight is just the graduation requirements and um so I want to just pause and acknowledge that and then the next part of this um is just to talk a little bit about some of the work that has been ongoing that uh is happen happening with our online learning program um as you maybe know but this program is growing exponentially um last fall we had 306 courses taken and this fall we had um I'm sorry 306 and this fall we have um 453 completed courses our spring of 2024 enrollment was 441 courses this spring we have 5 125 courses so we it every single semester summer last year was much higher
216than summer the year before um so it's working for some kids who need this type of a learning environment and so um and the evidence is not just in the number of courses but we actually had a 95.6% pass rate of all of our online um programming um we did this year uh launch something new and we're calling it our re-engagement project um where our students who have not been attending schools and are very far along in the court process uh backup petitions we have created our own programming for them um with the help of uh Stephanie Grayson and Stacy Cho uh to re-engage these students and families and this past um semester fall semester we had 11 students in this program and it's doesn't sound like a lot but it's 11 kids that we
217recaptured that they were no longer on our books um except in the court system and um some huge success seven of these 11 kids passed the three course two or three courses that they signed up for they earned uh high school credits which some of them have almost no High School course uh credits um two of them uh have decided to move on to rent and Tech to earn their GED as well as start working on a um post High School plan um and all 11 of the students passed at least one of the courses so small number of students but big lift um and that was done um in partnership with the PTSA and with ISF this group of students has access to as many of the things as possible that our students in
218the comprehensive high schools have there's food being donated there's clothing there's monthly celebrations with families um it's just it's really heartwarming to actually see the work that's happening and these students actually report to this building some of them have decided to come multiple times for up to three hours a day on their own um I me we are providing transportation for students who need it but we're not requiring that much of their time here they just have found success and it's really because of the great um staff that are working one-on-one with with these students um and I I believe this has been highlighted for you but uh a goal is that by fall of 2026 that we would in the ISD have our own online learning school with its own entity um we are
219currently losing over 300 students to Choice transfers um and other on online programming as well as homebased learning and I'm super hopeful through the work that Stephanie is leading that we can bring up to 200 students in grades 9 through 12 back into our system um and one of the things that I think makes our online learning system better than all of the rest is that the students actually have connections with mentors and certificated teachers and if they start to slip we call them in here to this building and they meet with their mentors or they meet with the certificated teachers to provide support the other thing that we do a little differently is that if they're doing the course to earn um a grade we bring them into this building for the testing so
220that there's some rigor um and high expectations for the students taking our online classes which I would not say about some of the other um online programs across the state so with that I'm happy to answer any questions if you have any I'll start uh first of all for the online learning uh do you know is there plans to expand offerings such as health so my eth grader takes Health Online because that's how she can fit it in for Middle School my high schooler still hasn't fitted into her schedule and it's not offered uh online currently so I was a bit surprised by that and I guess I would then want to know as a like at our level like what other sort of graduation requirements are not offered online or which ones are offered
221online that would be helpful for us to have a sense it's a great question I don't know the level of detail of our course catalog for the Apex is the server we use but it's certainly something that I can look into and see um if it's something that they don't offer or that we're not choosing to access perfect and just when we get that answer if we would also know out of the our graduation requirements like which ones are offered online or not would be a helpful thing just to know yeah yeah Dr Quin just quick question on the online learning uh environments my my wife actually currently teaches in an online um environment here in the state of Washington and I know she's been keenly aware of several districts that have gone this route
222to create their own online environment and they haven't worked and that the success rate hasn't been great are we I guess what would set us apart because I I I like it I love the idea and I think that it adds some structure and I think you could attract more students to it but are we certain that it's different from what other districts have done that have not worked um I I get I want to ask good question is it that the it's not been successful because the students haven't found success or that the program is just collapsed it's just collapsed okay yeah that's a um great question and one of the things that Stephanie Grayson is working on now is um the research about what is out there what is working what isn't working
223I feel that I can say with some confidence just based purely on the number of um students that continue to access the course that we do have available um I I believe that we can find success with it and because I would love for it to eventually become a 612 um school but starting with 912 to see like test it because you know I don't want to go big and then have it sure fall down um and yeah I mean I guess for me I would just like to understand maybe what hasn't worked with those other programs I think there's been interest and districts doing more of this post pandemic and it's it it just sounds great but then it doesn't have long longevity with it yeah so I I love the idea I just
224would want to understand what is what how does ours look different from those that have not been successful so thank you yeah she's going to a conference next week so she may very well learn more about that great perfect other questions Dr Mo sure so if we can go back I guess to the first the first part on the graduation Pathways um couple questions so one one of the things that's always stood out to me about the graduation Pathways is that they they don't clearly State and maybe that's what the new tool does the new school LS when when someone picks a college pathway it doesn't clearly State the what is the additional requirements like of the Washington State College acceptance minimums um and so just having gone through this process with a high schooler
225I understand that schools all around the country have lots of different requirements but Washington does have minimum requirements so um is that does that become apparent to the student in School links if they choose a college pathway like for example three years of language arts as an example would show up on the college pathway class links will not or at least at this time does not give that information to students now you asked us that very question last year about to put it on our website and guess what we did we put it on our website so students in our district have access to that that information it's just such an odd it's a small thing but it's like if there's a difference and we can alert people to that as they're making their plan
226I think that's really important and then the um uh School links sorry oh 2027 so we're still Zell so Z you you said we're going to start with sixth grade now so like is that this current school year next school year or with school our current sixth graders no our current everybody in our system right now is using Zelo yes and by 2027 the entire system has to switch over to school leags yes I'm sorry I thought you made a point about but our sixth graders are now currently doing Zell lessons Okay so this year our sixth graders are already in zel okay that's what I was I just want to make sure that was this year or was that coming later and then my last one is this is where I Miss Suzanne um
227there was previously a difference between our graduation requirements and the state's grad requirements and that was around social studies I believed and the Civics point so are we losing that 0. five additional that we had previously in social studies this was going to be my question so I'll ask it no differently if you go to this the slide four so I think that the challenge is is when we aligned the credits to match the state please correct me if I'm wrong but my understanding is is a move to a senior level class for all of our high schools because it was offered in different configurations prior but the world history requirement is a semester yet they get a full year of it in their freshman year and don't get a choice and so I me
228I mean don't get a choice and that I mean I guess you could in theory separate a bit of skyline it's all blocked together so they're getting 3.5 at a minimum just by virtue of truly the schedule works and I think we still have't cracked that net and I think that's that's my that was a question I had is like it says that our our our requirements are three but they're really 3.5 structurally by how students have to schedule themselves at least a Skyline it's 3.5 and I don't know if what I just said makes sense no what you said made sense but I don't um ninth grade World study it will be next year is a one year of a nth grade course and then the US history is a one-year course I'm looking
229for an head yes and then there's two semester courses which is so that's three credits total whereas before our 10th graders also took a full year of world history a world was it world had to be us no 11 gr us so yeah but that's so that's my question though is but at schools like Skyline where it's blocked together you there Des not a choice for them to take just a semester in their 10th grade and then something else so fundamentally it's 3.5 yes there is a choice though next year well it's a it Skyline is now offering blocked or unblocked options for both students who choose the honors track as well as the non honors track so is the is the difference then from the last time we reviewed this that the third line
230where it says semester contemporary world history geography and problems that that used to be a full year is that is that the Practical change I'm gonna have to tag a friend yes I'm good with that it is also officially 15 minutes past my bedtime so so friend help me out so so um the skyline next year will start offering a one semester option that sophomore year to take just the Contemporary world problems course which we will be calling Global Studies it's getting late no Global Studies and so yes that will that will give an option for all students to be able to fill just the three credits if that's all they want to do yeah and in the prior it was linked as a full year course and that is changing so so for students
231who graduate before this is 2029 before 2029 they will still have 3.5 am I hearing that correctly yes right I still have 3.5 think so I'm looking actually to our experts but I believe that is the case that they would have the 3.5 um almost all of our kids take an elective in this social studies realm as well so um I would have to go back and pull the data to confirm that for sure I guess guess maybe the question I'm asking is how do I ask this question in a world so in the same building now next year we will have freshmen that will go be under this three credit requirement in the building and have an option in their sophomore year did you say sophomore year is when this global the new Global
232thing happen the Global Studies happens but the sophomores will also be in the school so when they take do they still have to take a full year to meet their 3.5 or can they take the half no next year next year sophomores will be offered a my this is my understanding of the the work we've done with the course guide is that they will offer a one semester option to just do the global studies which means the required course of contemporary World issues and they will not have to take they will not have to take a companion course with it so if they just next year sophomores class of 2028 yeah will have the option to just take Global Studies their sophomore year if they wish and what and I just don't have it open
233but 2028 grad requirements in this category says three or 3.5 three credits okay yeah okay but they were linked in such way that it was no I get that I just want to make sure that they don't get caught out with still having a 3.5 requirement but take the half so as long as like my kid so my kid would be 2028 I have to go back and look at his yeah graduation requirements he will have a three in his and then the option to take the half okay I just want to make sure we don't yes get in a position where they're still required to get to three and a half but now they've taken the the three credit route and it's like uh oh I'm a senior and I've got this extra half
234credit okay that was my question thank you for the work you're doing to align across all of our high schools I think that's the fundamental work of el12 and what we're looking for with that alignment so students have the same opportunity across campuses I think that uh this breaking up of block and being able to have just semester credits gives the board more space to talk about what a finance course requirement would be for a semester long class because before we just didn't in reality have that capacity in schedule so I think that part is exciting because I think we would do our servants a better service students a better service by having them have a financed course before graduation and I absolutely agree with that and I think too just the idea of more
235space in the schedule which is that you know the unblocking and and I know we've talked about this before and I I I want to make sure for our community too like that is that's a plus for our students to give those it offers more options so I'm excited about that super prend it I will say so moving forward we won't have this 3 3.5 discussion again because I think we have yes completed the course of that conversation and discrepancy so and I appreciate um your leadership Sher Cox I also know many others but I also want to acknowledge that uh Stephanie Grayson has been doing a phenomenal job with our online learning and it's a really important opportunity to think about our enrollment and also the ways in which students um maybe best perform
236right um in terms of learning and academics so thank you uh Dr Mull and then president raldo do you have any comments first uh just because we can't see you so if you were raising your hand I would be apologizing no I'm fine I'm uh thankful for the for the um clarifications um so I just want to make sure on Gibson um because again I just don't have up the old one is this is unchanged or is is did you point out anything in this that there was a a difference um I I have notes from last year that are slightly different but um I believe that uh I don't know if it was an error um the previous years but the um 36 competencies um is is the actual number of competencies that our
237students need um as well and then the 32 writing submissions um used to be 36 uh and it's not that they've T it's just that their kids are building on the it's like a revisionary process so they're still doing the same amount of writing it's just that they're building on the the um submissions to make them even stronger um The Learning plans uh they do one big one per year and then they revise it four times um to just again really enance it and they have increased the number of exhibitions um per year up to four sorry the so four exhibitions per year is up from the previous it used to be three and so why why did we increase it um go ahead Hava let's have the expert answer we were in trimesters and
238we switched to to quarters for ease of college applications so now we still actually have the same three exhibitions that we did last time but we've added a um personal Vision Exhibition at the beginning of the year so this is the first year we've done that awesome can I just log a piece of information for that may conversation that has nothing to do with this I just want to log um which is I would like in that conversation to see demand for Gibson I think we throw out quite a bit shouldn't we do another one I'm not sure I see demand for that model in the system um at least in our conversation so I would like to log that as a piece of information thank you yes you're over you're generally everyone on the
239way list gets offered a spot generally thank you and I I think that's a good point too when we think about alleviating overcrowding and that being an option I think um it's a good question so thanks for bringing it up okay did we need off with a motion on this one that'd be my mistake so I apologize for that so uh I will now take a motion I'm sorry right [Music] um I move the board adopt the graduation requirements for the class of 2029 at Gibson e isqua Liberty and Skyline high schools and Echo Glenn as presented second is there any comment in the room or on Zoom for this agenda item okay any more board discussion or student input okay hearing none all those in favor of this motion say I I I I
240any opposed there you go and as director Taylor predicted there was consensus on that which is an odd odd one so next item is a lengthy one so I would like to propose that we take a uh five minute break and we will resume at uh actually 8 minute break 9:35 e e e okay so we are resuming after this uh for this really exciting part so we are all here tonight for this report this is about uh the academic excellence that is Manifest across our district from prek through grade 12 and we are excited that this gets to be showcased so I will start with a motion I move the board accept the monitoring report results to academics and Foundations as presented second second superintendent great well this is um one of my favorite
241results because it does give us a moment to pause reflect and really lift up um all the amazing work that does happen in our system and give us good dialogue and conversation around um whether or not we are on our on making reasonable progress towards um achieving very ambitious and lofty goals which is what I would expect for the squa school district um but I think we're going to start off with our students first um to share their report and input um for you all so I can invite you to come up to the podium and following that we'll have um Dr Bailey and and Rich melish join us questions hello um we're the remaining student reps to the Schoolboard um and uh we're here to present our report we collected qualitative data via one-on-one
242or advisory interviews um on this topic um a few of the questions uh it was very brief um the first one was how have your classes helped to prepare you for your post High School path higher education or specialized Career Training and are there any other programs that you feel have helped to prepare you how has what you've learned prepared you to interact with your to and contribute to your community and for Gibson how has the Gibson model helped you helped to prepare you to contribute to your community how have your classes or in Gibson neck's case the design thinking method helped you to learn how to creatively solve problems and what do you think is missing from the courses and programs at your school what would have helped you to feel more prepared um
243we all used these questions and we're able to gather insights um specific to our schools um so for Gibson uh we had a lot of great um feedback and one key Insight that I'd like to highlight is that um a lot of students Feel Like the Model H helps students to think more about what impact is and what problems need to be solved our model helps push us to um contribute to our community and get involved through our interests and through our education um from Liberty we did this a little bit differently but we conducted like focus groups and uh like extensive one-on-one and so um a lot of the conversation uh with students from Liberty were that there was like they felt uh overall pretty well supported at their high schools but there were
244concerns with transitioning either from middle middle to high school or grade level to grade level um a lot of students mentioned that they understood the graduation requirements but found difficulties navigating the course guide or just understanding and what classes bring what credits so on so forth um additionally a lot of students felt the current course offering was sufficient but wanted more art uh elective credits and more language like Manor and Chinese classes as well and one big thing that was prominent throughout all was uh students wanted more career preparing classes like the expansion of future ready in like Financial classes that was mentioned earlier yeah so um I'm AA I'm gonna be talking about isqua a little bit in terms of how we conducted interviews isqua they were again more similar to the skyline model
245and that they were one-on-one and a little bit more extensive overall we had really positive feedback especially in regards to the clubs at IHS um students felt like that really helped them connect with specific groups who share their interests and also explore those interests more deeply um when it comes to specific feedback though students felt like they needed more Hands-On opportunities within their classes rather than more worksheets and lectures um but even within that there were mixed opinions about whether or not group projects and discussions were the place to build those skills or if those skills should be afforded um more outside of the classroom time uh so not a whole not a very direct consensus on that but there's just definitely differing opinion and none of our Skyline students are here but I think
246it's important to have their insights um on record so I'm going to present them from a document with their insights um so this is just a few of them but uh students found that IB and rigorous courses help with time management and want more creative freedom in assignments uh CTE opportunities exist but Humanity's classes feel unequal in quality um and uh some of the cours workk in their classes are repetitive and many feel assignments don't enhance understanding and some classes focus more on delivering content rather than actively teaching uh and this can make heavy course work difficult for students um to engage in community activities and or maintain a free time outside of school thank you thank you superintendent um well I'd like to welcome up Dr Bailey and Rich melish to um prepare an
247overview share more of an overview here but I again I just want to re reiterate that there's so many bright spots that we have in our district um as it relates to um how our students are doing academically and we also um have organized you know a lot of our ends reports our our results reports now with what we're acknowledging our areas where we can also continue to make further progress and I will sure that we we are constantly seeking to um increase a more positive productive experience for all of our students and so we look at all the data very deeply and look at where we're not making progress as well uh so this is where we are able to surface some of the opportunities that exist as a result to where we see
248we can continue to further uh enhance um our work and again really um proud of all of our students and our staff who do amazing things every single day and that is the joy of teaching and learning um as well so I will pass it over to Dr Bailey and rich melish thank you school board and students before you dash out the door and get safely home and our superintendent for the opportunity to share and invite feedback on our progress towards a goal of results to that upon graduation students will be academically prepared and confident to pursue higher education and specialized Career Training the team and I Incorporated the previous feedback of wanting to see more summative results or Pinnacle data Regional District comparisons and as often as possible to compare our results against the
249state average internally we will continue to triangulate data watch progress throughout the year and scrutinize information about students whom we know aren't yet succeeding in our system we will persist in adding tools to the adult toolkit being responsive to feedback from the students and work to build a system where everyone experiences a warm and welcoming um environment to learn this this report is organized with key indicator data celebrations and highlights and challenges or areas of this work we know aren't yet meeting the needs of each and every student getting to strong graduation graduation results at the end of our 13 years starts at the very beginning or in the entrance to our school system honoring the work of every team in every school at each grade level and in each subject including when students don't
250love the class they required to take as the students just shared they don't always love taking the classes they're required to take we totally get it and we're cheering them on at the preschool and early learning years our celebrations include expanded opportunities for our youngest Learners including full day um ecap inclusive transition kindergarten and the ever expansion inclusive practices in kindergarten primary grades invested in found foundational literacy helps illuminate the reading struggles early so that primary Break by primary meet primary grades first second third um teams can quickly support students and respond to their needs everyone in the primary grades is working towards that third grade ontime reading goal and our achievements here are that nearly 3ars of our students meet this goal and 41% of elementary students are achieving high growth which is important
251to us because it's more than a Year's growth in a year time although the percent of students in foundational and high-risk areas of achievement is static or flat the percentage of students in this measure stayed the same while the district experienced high growth in students receiving lwi income supports growing from just under 10% to almost 15% in one year and the percentage of students served in special education grew by a percent each year for three years challenge in this area persist and that our students served in special services and students from the bipac focus group continue to have disproportionate outcomes on this measure the use of additional instruction time during success blocks and the new tools from the newly adopted literacy um program support closing this Gap math achievement is high on everyone's radar and
252should be as our state has seen significant drops in math achievement SBA achievement shows that our district is Comm measure with our regional peers and the new middle school math path allows for students to strive for acceleration with a safety note built right in so that students and caregivers can see how their desired math and goal can be built upon in the years that started um a challenge in the math pathway Is the participation and achievement for students in the students served in special services in the bipac focus group is disproportionate and another challenge is the stacking and cumulative nature of mathematics and the teachers and teams are still finding unfinished learning from covid or post you know early postco time and they need to make sure that those mying missing math foundations don't go
253unnoticed um High graduation rates continue and simply put we're crushing it in both achievement and persistence to graduation high schools offer a wide range of options for students who need to recover credits from initial struggles and success in in nth grade is a strong indicator of success at graduation and the disproportionality at ninth grade success is actually wider than the disproportionality at graduation which shows that the high school teams are working diligently to support students to get across that finished the high school and Beyond process which you heard a little bit about earlier has a role in helping students explore choice and Define a personal path this is both a promising indicator and a place more where more work can be done leveraging the full impact of planning throughout the middle school and high school
254years so that students can focus their time their energy and their talents on their own personal goals While most of our graduates report that their plan is to seek a 4-year degree and most achieve this goal in four years not all popcorn pops at the same time and we strive to create a system where each of these paths and personal timeline is valued and celebrated we'll present more on tenacity and resilience in a future result and um because we know that getting to the graduation is one mark but being successful in the next step after is another and to be truly prepared and eager to accept we need to be watching both of those measures we are also keenly aware that if you present uh right before a lunch break in a conference that's not
255this desired spot and if you present right before going home that's also not maybe the desired spot but we are here to answer your questions and we welcome the feedback great uh thank you for that introduction Stephen can you make sure that you can put this up now that uh Dr Bailey's done so wanted to open up for board Reflections uh for the community we've had two work studies before our two previous board meetings uh about this agenda item and had an opportunity to go uh really deep on different parts of it and we've appreciated our superintendent and her team to be available and um enjoyed that rich dialogue we had together so there may be less visible dialogue here not because we don't care about this most important one it's because we spend so
256much time on this one Dr Mo yeah um just building on that comment I think it's great to see some of the items we talked about being reflected differently or additionally in this are are very good so for example having the um peer comparisons of districts as well as having the um Statewide comparisons I think those are just very helpful to have it all in one place and get a sense of of how are we how are we doing against those peer groups I think that some of the breakdowns that are in here as you go through different sections on the specific gaps by population are helpful I think maybe in the past we've had those a little more munged together and so I think um looking at if that's a word we've had them
257grouped together but um I think looking at them separately like where are their gaps in different areas that are affecting different parts of our population to me seems like the more successful way to actually make progress so I really appreciate having them in that um having the data displayed in that way um I think what jumped out at me I'd say the thing that I was really kind of floored by was looking at I mean obviously we have High graduation rates we have a significant amount of our population that goes on to some two or four year uh Institution for college but I was actually really um surprised by the percentage of those students who are graduating college within four years like those are Stellar numbers um crushing it like like and so for me
258that's just an amazing indication of preparedness by the time um students leave us it's not just that they got finished but that level of success in in four years and just again having gone through a college search last year they you know the graduation rate from colleges all up is in the 30s 40s if you look at the national averages so to see that we have our students who go choose to go to college finish in four years in the 60s and 70 ranges is it was just really a stellar attribute that I don't know that I've maybe I haven't seen the data in that way or absorbed it in that way so so that's the one that jumped off the page of me that's actually a a new data tool the national student Clearing
259House that superintendent tyak invited us to explore which does two things it gives us much more descriptive data but also gives it to us quicker so that's last year's graduates and then four years ago so we're excited to see it as well yeah I think it shows that our Focus remains on the right things contrary you know I think we just spent a couple painful hours earlier in the meeting but that is very small part about what we do and this is what the bulk of what we focus on is how our students doing in what supports do we need to provide to make sure that they can reach these high levels of achievement and uh I think that shows that it's those things are happening J coin U it's funny uh director Mings you
260went exactly to where I was on page nine I well fix it I was I mean that's where I'm at with a senior right now and I went to my school to Skyline and to see that with 76% of the graduates from 2018 gr not only did they graduate I mean graduate with a degree in four years like that is extremely impressive I think it's also interesting too because I think in our district sometimes there's Mis this misnomer that a lot of kids go out of state for school which is great but there's a lot that stay in state and there's a good concentration so it's just interesting to see the data again having a senior Skyline and I think that's a little bit of a misnomer people think hey out of state that's where
261everybody goes if they go to a for University and that's not necessarily the case most are actually staying in state so yeah we have a lot to celebrate for sure Dr Taylor a few comments given the hour but yeah I think um just just for the public you know the results here in many areas are just so encouraging and that I hope people are our community realize this how above State levels across the board we really are and I think we have a you know we have a tendency here in the school board to dive into the problems and the issues and uh sometimes we don't we don't take enough time to you know really celebrate how well the the district is doing so you know I'll use the word of the night which is
262pause let's take a pause and and celebrate those those results um the other thing I just mentioned this is something that I was very fond of is the companion dashboard that goes along with the results and the data and how we can now kind of sort visualize the data I just really really love and appreciate uh and the fact that that that dashboard also has District comparisons now built into it um really really helpful but uh and then the last thing I will say is I I also did appreciate what I felt was real cander in the report is to say hey there are areas there's work to be done and um I thought this report did a good job of of recognizing that and offering what we hope are the solutions moving forward so
263that's president raldo since I can't see if you are ready to provide any comments wanted to offer this moment yeah I um I really appreciated the thoroughness um in the report uh the way the data was shown to us um I'm just a little curious about some of the consistencies between sharing whether whether or not how what percentage of students got B minuses and above C minuses and above and then one where there's a table of all the different ones so I think just some maybe some consistency around that would be great but I think the data reflects some really good work that's going on um I think that this is the first time where I really feel like I can find how you're using the multi-tiered systems of support within the document and to
264be able to say okay that's where that comes in that's that's a tiered support report that's going to happen with students and we're seeing results and I think that is really important as we continue to talk about how we're serving students with Universal Design for Learning and multi-tiered systems of support how those are are working together so I did appreciate that uh within there and then I appreciated the fact that there was identification of here are the challenges we still have and actions that we're taking and I think that um is an important way and I appreciate the structure of the report to be able to share that I I agree I mean this report has come so far from when I first started and there was these things like seventh grade social studies Common
265Assessment I'm like why do I care about that uh so my question is is now that you have Middle School grades in here which I think is really cool first time I've seen this and then you've highlight how in ninth grade and so I'm on page five people are wondering in ninth grade that core courses of world history and biology are among the most failed courses in nth grade has has this data and now see in the middle school where you see like gosh the students who are below B minus because you've sort of pled the flag like B minus is where we see is you know that's our Target B minus and higher so you now can identify in Middle School in eth grade if they are below that level is there a connection
266between those students and the ones who ultimately go on to to not pass one one or both of those classes in nth grade I don't expect you'd be able to answer that tonight but has there been any any thought to like being able to look and see a potential connection and then therefore if the case if the answer is yes then how are the interventions can they be driven towards like that group yeah quite a bit of discuss has gone into the the question about nth grade biology and world history and one of the one of the things the anecdotal observations that teachers in the conversation point out is that those are two courses that have really high vocabulary and complex reading levels and they so when we think about the scientific language of biology
267or the world history ancient you know the the language in world history is quite complex so one of the things we've really looked at are those reading interventions throughout the uh Middle School um actually that even even even was used in thinking about our elementary literacy adoption is heavily informational text oriented and vocabulary and background knowledge developing with the idea of the better students are at having strategies for attacking complex words um close reading informational text and building those skills from kindergarten all the way up through 8th grade the more likely they are to be successful when they hit that really complex lit uh uh informational text that is in those courses so that's been a big part of it and then the other big part of it has just been the the work that
268we tried to highlight around schools really looking at data and really monitoring students closely so really getting as quick information as possible so that we begin to identify when when grades start to slip early and then jump in there and find out why is that happening is it is it reading support is it engagement support is it you know what's what's going on so those are the two things that have popped out the most when it comes to biology and for me I think at least being three years into being a High School parent every teacher of every class that my student has had believes that they they are teaching a really important class and I don't disagree with them but I think that from kindergarten all the way up through 8th grade our students
269are wired to focus on reading and math so I think it doesn't surprise me that by the time they to nth grade where a high school teacher saying like you know every High School teacher saying this class is important that then they run into this oh wait science and social studies are also super important and now maybe a a level of seriousness in the subject matter that I wasn't quite prepared for so my wondering is is also in addition to those interventions you said as early as like literacy Parts in elementary also I think the importance of Scaffolding in Middle School of that preparation because having an eighth grader where who's now becoming an eighth grader is like uh adolescence it's an interesting impact on um the concept of learning but I I I wonder
270that if we could do more scaffolding and seventh and eighth grade for what what high school is going to be like it's not like you can't I want them to live in the moment of middle school but to make sure that they like for instance words or language or concepts are more embedded within as we move to these new adoptions it would be I think helpful and um an opportune moment Jos Mings I think what I'm about to say is connected to what you just said I I am I am curious about I I see noted a couple times throughout the um the material a call out to Executive functioning and that call out though is is coupled with um the support class the guided studies class and I my question or maybe it's my
271experience but I do wonder if part of that scaffolding is is really taking a focus maybe in a seminar sort of way for all students on Executive functioning on how to study like to me now watching a new College freshman a new High School freshman operate it it isn't necessarily the complexity of the language it's the complexity of multiple requirements and multiple different subjects and the time management of that and how do I practically fit all of that in a day and so it's watching them gravitate toward the subjects that um doing well on those subjects that they like better because they're willing to spend the time on that so I I just wonder having seen the call out here for executive functioning in guided studies having kids who are not in guided studies probably
272still need as they progress to these different levels of intensity a bit more help on how do you manage at this next level and I know we I think it was a previous board retreat we talked about you know how do we start to do some learning for students that doesn't have the increment of a semester that might be more seminar or shorter shorter course so I just for me um I think that part is great that we're doing it in a guided study session but I do wonder if if executive functioning seminar wouldn't help all students deal with their increasing level of complexity yeah I'm I'm glad you brought that up we actually couldn't agree with you more and in the mtss structure we would very much like to continue to build towards this
273shared dream of having guaranteed curriculum on Executive function that is available to and experienc by everyone in sixth grade and I know you're working on a ninth grade piece as well yeah yeah I I think we're you're we are all speaking that language these days about looking at how can we get a better tier one universal instruction on Executive functioning um we have we have some work to do on that definitely um one of the places we've started to unpack it a little bit is executive function is one of the one of three major strands in uh Universal Design for Learning so when you're trying to identify barriers or you're trying to build strength and student uh ability to control their own learning it's about executive functioning and so we're starting in that UD udl
274training with staff to to really kind of draw teachers attention to that and say how are you supporting executive functioning in every single class that a student is in we're beginning that Journey we are not deeply into it at this point in time but it is definitely something we're all very interested in in growing more in in in coming years for page 22 it would be helpful for me to know what percent do three years of language just because two is a graduation requirement unless they choose a different pathway uh and while two is part of cater it's recommended for many colleges that it's actually three so it'd be really helpful for me to know because I can't toggle from the the the table above which shows the three three plus or four but to
275translate into a percentage would be just helpful to know because I think that would be more reflective of our four-year College Bound cohort and just to know that sort of trend over time just like you know all the all the courses held pretty steady except like French second and third year for this past year very different than it's previous years versus all the rest of them all looked similar so I didn't know if you guys happened to know did we like lose a teacher in a building or something that that so then that wasn't offered I don't know just not expecting an answer but just curiosity yeah I I I don't have an immediate answer to that one but I will note the three-year request on there and then I just wanted to highlight just
276for the community because I appreciate that we also have't here specifically about Fine Arts and our focus on that and Performing Arts and just the high levels of participation that is across our middle and high schools and that it's in here as a subet of policy for the board because it is something that we uh believe is so important and and consistent across all schools for the most part that's what's cool when I looked at that across middle schools on on the three High School any other board uh comments or thoughts then my last question for oh president raldo sorry I just really quickly would like to hear a little bit more about the Aerospace manufacturing course at uh Liberty next year I wonder why that's of interest to you president raldo but um I
277think we would love to share a bit more because it's really a highlight um for us to start to offer that and so if we can welcome up um Lisa neighbors director of Career Technical education to talk more about this uh this is a real win for us to continue to make the steps tracks for certification thank you so much um so we have um it will appear on the course catalog this year the Aerospace manufacturing course at Liberty High School um the students it's it will be a skill center course through the wanx skills center so what that means is 85% of the seats will be held by ISD students we have to hold 15% of the seats for One e they graduate um like what does it set them up that it adds
278another piece so I've been talking to written Technical College um and our goal is to match hour for hour so it's a 540 hour course total um the dean of advanced manufacturing at Ren Technical College would like to match us hour for hour with um college courses that lead to a I want to say it's like a basic manufacturing certification um and she has told me that that will allow the students to go to Boeing and get an entry-level Machining job um or alternatively um blue origin is also increasing their manufacturing Force um and potentially a student could get an entry-level job there as well thank you president RDA did that answer your questions in the preview that you were wanting to hear about um I I got most of it the the the thing
279lagged out um but any additional questions I will ask uh director neighbors okay any other board I was I was going to draw your attention to page 117 where I I joking of course page report I mean that sounds like 10 years ago okay uh with no further questions or discussion and anymore on it I do want to point out that um Dr Bailey mentioned some of our demographic shifts you know over the past uh series of years and I think it's important to note that we uh we are trying to and and I think seeing some um good indicators of being able to meet the needs of our growing uh diverse population and it's growing diverse in many different ways but I think it's um important to note that we're balancing that adjustment um
280with also maintaining high performance but also making sure we're focusing on where we can go and and get better so I want to acknowledge that you said that earlier and that's an important part to lift up agreed no further discussion all those in favor of this motion say I hi any opposed thank you we know that this is uh the culminating project of sorts for you and your team that is ongoing and never ending and uh just one moment of snapshot for us to be able to highlight the amazing work that it our students are doing through our teachers and our building leaders all the way up through the leaders in this building so thank you uh next item on our agenda is legislative matters again I recognize that it's late but this is my
281moment to shine so uh I do want to just uh run down a few things because that there's a lot going on in Olympia right now for sure um special education Bills remain the f e e e engage um on the legislative matters it's a fast and furious session already and I I feel like every day we're getting a new request to to join for some sort of testimony and and the point is you have to keep coming back they they reset with every committ hearing so you actually do need to keep coming back to every single time a new version of the bill is proposed or the next stage so um that is an important note okay next item on our agenda is announcements of Correspondence next item is calendar and future agenda oh
282we don't know so there's a lot listed there I am here by the way you guys were the ones that dropped off oh yeah we should talk about the day of Hill that's a mess so it is amongst the topics of possible action to be taken yeah that's why I'm I don't know any more about this that's so the uh the efforts to reach out to legislators um about um doing Dan The Hill in the original um time that was identified by the board was not um they're all they're on the floor all day so if you want to share more director teror about your guidance on that one and and what you also might have heard that would be great yeah I mean just very simply none of the uh legislators are available except
283for I believe Victoria hunt for 15 minutes at 7:45 in the morning I believe so something like that so uh that's not going to be a good experience for our students obviously so we are kind of faced with the decision now of trying to find another date pushing back further into the session or finding some of their alternative um I did wonder well I mean I guess I leave it there with the board first if what is the feelings about I guess probably having to try to find a date in April um it would depend on availability and if we want to do that the dates are listed on the oh I'm sorry what March 14th 17 yes yeah there's all those yes exactly so the four 14th 17th 18th 20th of March well they're
284alled um but of course now yeah we would have to we have to go through the same exercise right which is to pick a date and then try to Circle back with our legislators and see if they're available I do know again as I mentioned Tuesdays for Senator Ramos are no good so I'm not sure which of those states are Tuesday 18 and I'm actually not available on the 24th you have days you need to rule out I mean I guess people can start however you want to start this the 17th could work for me would work it could I could make that work Marney yeah do March 17 work at all for you that would work for me yeah I can do it as well so um so you get another one while we're
285doing this for Emily yeah good advice next week's not very good forby so not the we can't do the well we shouldn't do the 31st we have our meeting with city council that night you said no Tuesdays right so APR well you know I mean April 1 is a Tuesday we just might not get Senator R the 20th are you already passed the 20th March uh I can do the 20th as well I don't um the 20th is hard for me okay 25th 26th 28th I can't do Friday Friday that might not be might be did you just say no to the 28th I can do the 28th I can't do you guys har said no you guys do it well you guys could do the 20th and just not have me I think it's
286getting tough I do think that later we become less effective in what we're doing because there's more bills that have either died in committee or yeah very true cut off has already passed by so then the 20th what does the 20th look like then so I heard the 17th and then the 20th would the 20th work for you I can make it happen mney yeah I can make it happen yeah preference for the 17th though we here okay yeah you you're in control of that preference for the 17th fall back to the 20th okay do you want the mo an actual motion yes because we have to amend okay I I move to amend the motion that was passed on Thursday January 16 2025 to move the day on the Hill from March 10 2025
287to either March 17 2025 or March 20th 2025 second any discussion very no discussion all those in favor say I I any opposed and then for information the senior exit interviews are listed there so I think you would coordinate that through Emily uh if you want to participate I hear that they are a rewarding opportunity I highly recommend the opportunity to get to talk to um seniors and get their Reflections I think gives unique insight into actually the results um and we would just want to know if there was more than three at one time that we can then notice appropriately for a board it's great and how many students participate is that oneon-one with students or is it it's all it's all the students okay yeah it's a grad requirement it's like they have
288to fill the surveys that's why we have 100% participation for the uh senior exit survey skylines coming we just don't have that would be the one I won't do but I will do Isa or Liberty yeah okay well that you follow up uh anything else for anything else president raldo before we can say goodbye yeah I'm very much done with this meeting because I'm and