CorpusRecord 82702

SDB - Policy Committee Meeting - February 5, 2025 (5:30 p.m.)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / School District of Beloit
Date
2025-02-06
Location
Rock County, WI
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,792 words · about 55 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e good evening this is the call the order for the Wednesday February the 5th policy committee committee meeting uh Mrs shop can we have a roll call please yes Tom henkins here Amy Levy here and Brian Nichols all members all members are present and could I get an approval of the agenda so moved second is there a second I'll second any discussion all those in favor say I I'm sorry my hand is raised yes board member leevy thank you um so I just wanted to point out I'm concerned that this evening's agenda includes a review of policy 8811 District booster clubs when there is an active policy already using this number um the current active policy 8811 is family is relations with family school organizations um and if we reviewed policy in number groupings

002we could avoid this for example the current active 8811 titles could have been adjusted to read relations with family school organizations and booster clubs and the content from the proposed policy tonight could have been listed as policy 8811 rule 2 which is available because the content under that policy number has been renumbered 883 um so I'm just concerned that our current process is keeping us from being comprehensive and reducing our effectiveness thank you board member Levy um actually that is noted on the um that is that is actually noted on the uh on the agenda page for the policy for the discussion tonight because of that issue it's it's described in the uh public content per section on 8811 so we're going to address that when we get to that policy so can I get

003an approval of the agenda you just neede oh all those in favor say I I [Music] I you you need to ask if there's any Nays or obst is there any Nays n okay motion carried two to one and could I get an approval of the minutes so moved second um any discussion all those in favor say I oh my hand is raised um just wanted to note according to policy that I'm abstaining because I didn't attend that meeting so I'm not able to Y I was particip I was going to ask for that thank you say all those in favor say I I I any abstentions I abstain okay motion Carri two Z with one exstension okay the first item up is uh policy 881 um one District Bo booster clubs and um when

004uh when this was brought forward by the uh by the by The District administration um it was noted in the um in the policy that it's 881 is actually being used for our relations with fam School organizations PTO PTA if we want to go by the WB policy guide 8811 should be the booster club club policy and the relations with family school organizations should be 8812 there's also an 8 8811 rule one that would need to be renumbered to 8812 rule one these polic policies were just revised less than a year ago in July of 23 so um so I I I think what we need we need we need a motion to um well we can we can discuss this policy but it's going to need to be renumbered and uh so open for

005discussion board member Levy thank you so much um so a couple concerns one since the other policy that would be impacted is not listed on the agenda we can't take action on that tonight because it's not noticed and that was my point in the discussion with the agenda if we looked at number groupings and we don't have to spend a ton of time on each one but all of them are available to be edited so we can handle all of these things at once um that aside I do have other concerns with the policy so I don't know how you want to handle discussion do you want to get into the content of the discussion or do you want to handle naming and then the content I think we should handle the naming and then

006the context so would you like to uh do you have further discussion on that well I just want to reiterate since the current policy is not on the agenda we can't address that this evening and again that's the point for looking at policies and number groupings so we could name this as it's listed but it then we would be sending it to the full board and the other part of the puzzle would remain unaddressed board president uh Johnson um thank you I'm I'm I'm sorry I'm a little bit behind um in in following the meeting so I'm a little bit confused this policy was adopted previously and there's already a policy in existence may I or and and and I I see that for this one Dan Grant the athletic director the um person presenting

007but but I don't see him here tonight well that's part of my content issues which it seems like our chair wants to separate which is totally fine so the proposed policy is brand new but it's using a number that already exist for another policy and that's fine if we I don't think we need to follow wb's numbering so carefully that ours is identical I think it just needs to be in the correct category and if we have a little variance I think that's completely okay however I yield to the will of the committee if the committee wants to stick with policy 8811 for the new booster club that's perfectly fine but there's already a 8811 relations with family school organizations which is a active policy and since that policy is not noticed under that number

008on the agenda we can't Swap all the numbers to get it how we want it in one meeting and that's my concern board President Johnson um may I ask the board secretary a question absolutely Mrs sh do you do you know um um did Dan Grant submit this to you or why this was chosen as this num number what the what the rationale was behind it you usually you usually have a good backstory so Dan Gratz submitted the proposed policy he asked um he and uh Emily pels the president asked for some sample policies I check reached out to my colleagues to see if they had sample policies um not a lot of the districts have sample policies a lot of them just have like guidelines or websites that have guidelines and um um bylaws

009um some had policies so I was able to pull some of that together um I helped him do a little bit of modification to kind of get it into more of a policy format because it wasn't totally like that and then he had no idea what number to give it and so I was kind of going through the our policies to see where it would fit best and when I looked up in the WB policy guide they actually have a number for booster clubs which is the 8811 which is why I put in the um content area of the board report that if that's the number that you would like to make it we would just simply have to rumber the other policy and the accompanying rule to the number that I suggested because that's

010where they technically should belong in that policy guide if that's what you want to follow which we kind of had that conversation at the last policy meeting about whether the board and the policy committee wants to follow that or not so that's why I kind of left it that way and when we were getting ready to post the agenda um chair Nichols and I kind of had that conversation so he would understand why that was written in the board report the way it was so I'm not saying you have to follow that I'm just saying that's where it would fit in and so that was the number it was assigned temporarily as a placeholder to get it on the agenda so I don't know if if the committee would be comfortable making the motion to

011if you decide to approve the policy to move it forward making the motion to give it that number and to bring for those other two policies to the full board to change their number accordingly that's up to you guys cuz those policies were just reviewed less than a year ago I board M hankin oh I'm sorry I I'm just looking for resolution um is there a way the way it's posted can we change that number from 81.1 discussion and get give it another one so we're not having to change can we give it another number here and still move forward or do we have to still go change it and then come back well I will I will give you my opinion but it doesn't necessarily mean that that's right but my opinion is that

012we should be able I I would think that we should be able to to make that make this with motions and re renumber reum the other couple of policies and then and then move on uh board member Levy thank you so much so just a couple things one I I don't believe it's appropriate to take up policies that are not noticed on the agenda um so that's not something I would be able to participate in if it's okay can I get to my content concerns because that may make this a moot point um so I'll start with policy 151 board policy development States in formulating policies which this is new um the board shall willever appropriate consult individuals and groups affected by the policies um it's my understanding that that one Mr Gratz isn't here

013to present this which is concerning to me and two the current leadership of our multiple booster clubs have not had an opportunity to read and provide feedback and they are the ones that would be governed by this policy so I think it's premature for this committee to address it and we don't have feedback from the people who would be governed by it um and and I this may not be an exhaustive list but just so everyone's on the same page I am aware that we have multiple booster clubs so there's the grid iron which handles football there's bot girls basketball there's band there's swim there's hockey and then there's the bmhs booster club which handles multiple Sports um just to let you know um chair that deian Evans who is the president of that booster

014club is in the audience if you want to lean on her for information but that's totally at your discretion so one I don't think we should be reviewing this because they haven't reviewed it and provided feedback because the ad is not here and because the other policies that are impacted by this name change I would like to do that all at once the other concerns I have is this policy could go into effect as soon as March 4th um and his and my question which I'm not sure who I'm asking it to is has any thought been given to the timeline if any that booster club will have to be compliant if they're not already compliant with everything that's listed in a policy that it's my understanding they haven't had an opportunity to read um

015and has any thought been given to when this policy should go into effect now most times new policies go into effect as as soon as they have that second reading from the board but we are in the middle of the school year and we have booster clubs I'm assuming currently active and so if they are not compliant with this new policy once it's approved it's my understanding they would no longer be acknowledged by the district and I don't think that's no problem problem problem I don't think that's fair to spring it on a booster club like midyear midseason um and then my other concern is um the state of Wisconsin booster club guidelines are referenced in the policy I was not able to easily identify that document and normally if we reference a document we

016have it cross-listed at the bottom so people can go there and check it and make sure that they're being compliant so my other question is does anyone have that document readily accessible and we definitely need to include that in any new policy that we would propose thank you okay well now now it feels like we are way way go let me finish my spot and then I'll you can I think I think we're I think we're way ahead of where we need to be on this that's my uh thank you for all your clarification board member Leia I really appreciate it um and Mrs Shope thank you for for sharing about the information so uh board me board President Johnson um just my what I would would suggest is maybe um delaying this until the

017next policy committee meeting and that that way we can get the things in order and um make certain that Mr Gratz is available um to be here thank you that's pretty much where I was going to go but anyway board member uh pankins you have a comment yes well to be clear Mr Gratz should have been here if he proposed this uh number two I was wondering what the protocol is I we have one here why weren't the other ones here and whose job was it to inform them that this might be affecting their booster clubs was it Gratz or us or edmin or when did this get posted um I'm hearing that it was kind of a it might have been not notice not not saying correctly timely but um was Mr grat supposed

018to do this leg work but and I don't know K ask him he's not here which really disappoints me but uh I agree but I just want to know the protocol if we're uh not to blame any anybody but if we have one here why aren't the other ones represented can I jump in on this goe carison and I apologize for my um absence the district's booster club's conversation has been an ongoing conversation for quite some time since I've arrived what we wanted to do was bring this policy to the board for a discussion policy committee for a discussion hear your feedback of course naturally I would have liked Mr grat to be here he is not however we can still take your feedback and bring that back forward not all policy conversations are supposed

019to be captured done wrapped up into a bowl in one session each time as well some of these things do take time and I feel like that's also a space that we also need to recognize so if your questions were and I wasn't here for the beginning part of the conversation but if your questions was captured we can get those questions answered and we can bring back even polish more polish conversations for the next time that's what policy is sometimes I think we we may get you know misconstrued around what is supposed to happen and when it's supposed to happen how it's supposed to happen but in the absence of um um one of my um one of my direct reports not direct reports one of my employees not being here we can still capture

020what questions you may have and bring those questions back get those questions answered send the those responses to the board to the policy committee to have a more fruitful conversation next time I don't think we should have to you know always have in this space Maybe um a automa this is it let's move it straight to the board and we're done with it because this this may be one of those that take a little time to make yourself that we work its way through so I apologize for Mr grass's absence I'm not going to assume what was stated beforehand but if we were able to capture those questions Mr CH we can get those questions answered and we can move um accordingly with the other policy where we do have um you know participation thank

021you Dr thank you Dr Kon well the policy was brought forward you know it showed up when when the draft was sent to me this was already on there and all the uh all the comments under the public comment or the purpose name and title and purpose and it's it's showed as an action item not a discussion item so just FYI but um I I believe that I agree with board member board President Johnson that was where I was going to go but I wanted to let her talk first so I think we need to I think we need to table this for this evening and move and uh and bring it bring it forward to the uh to the March um whatever the date is March 4th I think uh meeting for for review

022and and hopefully Mr Gat can be here um for that I mean was and again just because it says AC on a on opportunity if the board is not really ready to make an action we can always like you just mentioned TBL it Y and we can keep moving forward um and that's that's a space that the board has the option to do sure um and and again I I will take a look at the questions that was proposed in my absence and we will be able to move um accordingly okay board member H uh yes just to bring Dr Carrison a little bit up to speed the conversation was part of it um this affects a lot of different booster clubs and only one is represented and we as a policy committee wanted more

023input from the booster clubs so we can sit here and take do go through this uh exercise but at the end of the day this committee wants to hear more input from the people will be most directly affected and Mr Gratz isn't here and there's only one booster club president here which is disappointing so I think in all fairness to everybody it's a it's a good idea to table it until we can get more bodies here to talk about it thank you thank you board member Henkin board President Johnson thank you um Mrs Levy had listed uh several booster clubs can we for the next discussion have a list of the booster clubs and what they represent so that we're all aware of them and um will um Dr Garrison will you talk to um

024athletic director Gratz and have him get input from the various booster clubs sure if if that's okay with you chair chairman Nichols thank you board member Levy thank you so much the only thing that I would add is I think as one thing to get input but it's another thing to make sure that the leadership of each of the booster clubs has this policy in their hand so that they can read it for themselves they can determine if they are compliant if they are not currently compliant what needs to happen so that they can be compliant and then if you don't mind Dr Garrison just really quickly what my concerns were and hopefully this will save you from going back and after the watch the tape um is it this policy if it pass forward

025tonight could have went into effect as early as March 4th now it could go into effect as early as sometime in April after a second reading from the full board so my question is has any thought been given to a timeline um if any where booster clubs would have to be compliant and my concern is if we don't make a special accommodation for this policy for example it will take effect at the beginning of the 2526 school year we could have booster clubs that are in the middle of seasons in the middle of the school year that are operating and then all of a sudden if we're following this policy they're no longer recognized by the district and that's going to negatively impact our kids ultimately so that's a concern um also the state of

026Wisconsin booster club guidelines are referenced in the policy but I couldn't readily find that document so if someone has that if they could provide it because I think that would be helpful for us to be familiar with and then also cross reference that at the bottom of the policy thank you thank you board member Levy okay um could I get a motion to move these move this policy to the uh March 4th uh meeting so moved a actually I would like to offer an amendment if we could also make sure that on that March agenda is the current um policy 881 or 8811 relations with family school organizations so if we choose to renum we can handle that all at once okay so is that accepted is that acceptable okay thank you so much I'd

027like to second okay any further discussion no the amend the amended motion i i i motion carried three okay NE next up is uh next next up is policy uh or 2B item policy 183 voting method with a proposed name change to board member voting and participation in meetings so I will open it up for discussion remember Ley thank you um so a few things [Music] um so in the middle of the green portion um when it's talking about a member who is not present may not vote by proxy uh that totally makes sense um and may not in their absence have their opinions or concerns on a matter shared by others during the board meeting I guess my initial question is um what is the point of adding that um and I think we

028have a couple recent examples um I don't think he would mind me sharing but Brian Anderson was not able to attend a meeting recently and he sent us kind of some notes of his thought and I thought that was really helpful and it made the conversation more robust I wasn't able to attend a recent policy meeting but I did go through the agenda and provide my notes and I hope those were helpful so unless I'm missing something I don't see what the harm is if a board member wants to take the time and prepare and review and submit their thoughts um clearly understanding that they're not able to vote because they're not present so if I could just get clarification why that was added and then I have a couple other things that would be

029helpful thank you board President Johnson I'll I'll answer all these at the same time oh oh thank you um well I don't necessarily have a question but just um I know sometimes during meetings it's people have said what is so and so's opinion on this or and if we if it to me my my personal opinion if we have it in writing then from that person emailed by that person that would make sense but to hear it through somebody else's mouth saying oh I talk to this person I'm not so comfortable with that okay thank you P member henkins yeah I'll be a little bit more technical than that um again the the whole our whole job is to be here in person and live and I know there's uh cases when you can't but

030to have your comments read by other people people for you number one there's the security involved and you can say it came from their email account those sometimes can be stolen they can be produced by somebody else um in this day and age hacking is huge and it's a slippery slope I know during the co time there was lots of reasons not to gather but that is certainly not in the nature anymore I think attendance is mandatory uh recently I was only able to attend by phone and I certainly agree with the expressions of uh concern that I was sitting in my car on my cell phone and although everybody knew it was me but nobody knew who was around me and that is certainly correct um I think it's a slippery slope we start

031doing this we do start doing everything virtually or by emails we're missing the point of being here and I I just think it's a slippery slope I like this tidying up of it I don't think it takes the hard stance of we will never consider that but I think it's time we address it and get some proper order in to before we ALS I could start you know the uh the two times that Mrs Levy is talking about I sat here and went oh wait their their viewpoints are getting read and they're getting more Credence to the guy sitting here and yes I could have uh stood up and said something but uh I heard admin reading emails from board members and I'm like that's not their job um it really Disturbed me I wasn't

032the author of this change but I certainly agree with it and not because of the examples but it's I think it's a slippery slope that we should at least discuss and uh get an accurate policy on this right or wrong thank you thank you board member henkins board member Levy thank you um I appreciate your perspective uh I I don't agree but I appreciate you sharing that I would be in favor of um and May in their absence have their opinions um have their written opinions or written notes on the matter shared by either the president or the chair um I I don't think there's rampant hacking of our accounts and I think it's proper and appropriate that if I for some reason am not able to be physically present for a meeting or virtually

033if I sent the board president my notes or if I sent the chair of whatever committee my notes um I think that is a way to make the the conversation more Rob bust because we so often have different perspectives um I don't see the harm in doing that I agree with that board member Levy but that's not the case what happened uh I heard admin reading uh let's be concise back to you and I heard I didn't hear Brian Nichols the the chair or he may have weighed in but I heard uh admin reading your emails which to me was totally out of line unless given permission by the board chair or the board president thank you so if we could just tidy that up I would be more than happy with that sure good

034thank you so much so would you be opposed to us structuring it so that in a board member's absence they can send their notes to either the board president or the committee chair to have them in included at when that item is is discussed by the full board absolutely okay um thank you so um I would be in favor of and May in their absence have their notes on matters shared by either the board president or committee chair during the board meeting could you clar could you clarify where what do you want your yeah absolutely and Miss schop let me know if you need me to read so I'm in that green section it's like the third line down that it starts with proxy and if we adjusted it to say and May in their

035absence have their notes shared by either the board president or committee chair during the board meeting committee or we could just say during the meeting and then if we say board president or committee chair I think people would understand whoever is presiding would read okay Dr Garrison that's want to make sure that we know that that I'm okay with both both spaces um as the district administrator um and that you all do work with with me secondly I want to say that the the goal in in this space to me is about collaboration you know the board members are supposed to be collaborating with each other and your opinions and thoughts should be shared um how it gets there based off of what we just shared amongst each other I'm fine with sending it to

036the board president or chair for communication is perfectly fine but again the goal to me is collaboration amongst the boards board members and of course the district administrator because um you know I'm here to help and assist that is part of my goal um as a district administrator so I kindly disagree with you Mr um henkins that I can't read something from a from a chair or from a board member because things are sent to me communication is happen and so whether it stays that way or not or superintendent I'm fine with but the goal is collaboration that's all I'm that's my statement thank you Dr Garrison board President Johnson um Dr Garrison it's it's um things do get sent to you but um for these meetings you're not the presiding officer sure so um

037I agree with uh board member Le 's um statement that it should be the presiding officer if if board members want to copy you on the email that's that's that's fine um if if not I quite truly that's fine too because when somebody's expressing their opinion we all come to this to this board and you we don't know what every everyone's going to say you know we have surprises so um that's I it's important that it is the presiding officer thank you board President Johnson well now I'm going to I'm going to put my two cents worth in as the policy chair so um I I I would agree with what board members hanin said that you know it's our job to be here that's what the public expects the the constituents the people that

038that uh voted us into this position expect us to be here in be looking out for the the school district from their standpoint um that's part of that's part of this whole thing um uh I uh board member Le I you know I I'm I'm good with sending a a note I think it should only be to the policy chair or the president uh without anybody else um because I think that's where we get into you know that's just where we get into things things things getting out of out of hand uh so to speak and so uh I'm I'm you know I'm good with that that change um is there any other discussion on the any other part of the uh of the policy that needs that there's any concerns board member henkins M's

039just a comment that uh these our committees in our board our board driven uh admin is here for research sourcing advising creating U but these committees admin and and what I felt was we it's a slippery slope and uh if they're shared to everybody uh somebody might start picking and choosing and interpolating what a comment email said and to anyways just to clear it up I just think the policy the way it's stated with the amendment graciously made by board member leevy which I totally agree with uh should go forward thank you thank you board member henkins board member Levy thank you um and I I want to be clear before I make my next statement please let's all be conscious that we don't share anything from closed session all right with that being said

040um I just had two other concerns uh it it says in the propose that board members will not have the option to participate virtually in closed session and so and and I get if that is coming from a secure location perspective but if we are potentially giving legal councel the option to participate in closed session why would we not extend that to board members and then my other concern was um let me just read it to make sure I'm doing right um legal councel in closed session meetings shall be at the discretion of the board president um I think it should be at the discretion of the board and one reason why I think that would be a good idea if we can have legal council participating virtually is that that could be a potential

041cost savings we don't have this person physically in the room and then our meeting runs late and they're just waiting and the the clock is kind of running on what we're paying or if we don't need them they're not here and then find out we didn't need them we can have them on standby which hopefully is cheaper than having them here physically um so again one I just want clarification if legal council has the option to participate in Clos session um why would board members not have the same ability and I totally understand if we want to be clear on how you confirm that you are in a secure location again without sharing details and then I think it should be at the discretion of the board so those are my two other um concerns

042for this policy thank you board member Levy any any other discussion I do I um Dr garison sure thank you um the the so the Clos session space um whether it's in person or virtual um as long and again if it's secure then the not allowing piece again if the goal is collaboration I don't sure why it would be not allowed I mean so that's that's that's the space that I mean in in today's world that we live in naturally let's just say we have another pandemic right which could possibly be um and we have to go remote you know we can come in of course suspend policy right but in those spaces I believe we probably would have to be closed virtually um and so I I just think that if it's a secure

043space then that's a possibility now um as it pertains to the rest of the policy I'm not sure if we're going to go into discussion around that or not but I'm just I have some other thoughts about some of the other spaces um outside of the green space that's highlighted thank you Dr Garrison board member ly thank you so much and Dr Garrison thank you for those comments because it made me think of something else um has legal looked at this because I'm not sure if we have the authority to exclude a board member from participating virtually especially and I get the goal is for us to be together but if we allow virtual participation in Open Session I don't know if we can exclude a board member from having that same ability to participate

044in closed so I would just want to R have that run by legal um and the reason I ask I I'll leave it at that um I don't know if we have the authority to exclude thank you board member board President Johnson um thank you um Dr Garrison how do we determine if if a space is secure and how do we know that that space is secured during the um entirety of the meeting um and this um board member Levy this is from uh WB meeting on open meetings laws I attended on November 12th where WB took the stance where they strongly advised against um remote participation in executive session did they give a a reason why they and I get it's better it's easier it's the Nuance but did they give a legal rationale

045for why that wouldn't happen um for the um issue of confidentiality Integrity of the information being discussed in the meeting um there if if I if things haven't changed since November there weren't any laws prohibiting board members from partaking um virtually but it was WSB St that it it should it's a bad practice quote I mean that that's in my notes it is a bad practice and I'm I think we've had some different hiccups with um some of those issues um concerns with the Integrity of our closed session meetings um in in in the the one time when whatever electronic device was in there that was I just I'm I'm interrupting because I don't want us to go into what happened in closed session and Open Session okay but just that there are many different

046um things that can happen and concerns that um this would help us avoid that board member henkins did you yeah just commenting um again I agree with board President Johnson secured space who knows you know I'm not calling on anybody but I do know we go into closed session the doors are shut they're maintained shut I've even seen Dr Garrison go out to make sure the hallway is cleared and then we go remote and we don't know if there's anybody else in the room where the a remote person is I'm not calling on anything but I'm just saying it's because that person chooses not to be here they're given more latitude than a person who has showed up and is in that room and is insecure place so I think this has a very credible

047policy change we're in charge of policy change and this is a policy so I think it's very good that we're looking at it and talking about it thank you board member henkins um as a reference as reference to the um uh this the part about the U with legal counsil well first of all legal council is attorney client privilege so um you know if they're not if they're not uh follow if they're not following their law you know their own ethics uh then we got a lot of problems more than more than this so uh I I think um again I believe that we need to be here and if we if that closed session uh needs to be done in person um because that's the only way that we can totally make sure that

048it's a secure situation so um could we get a motion to move this policy forward for to the board for board for first reading with uh the first amended that uh Mrs Levy Michelle did you did you get that by the way you've got that right so could you read that again please so the sentence would read a member who is not present may not vote by proxy and May in their absence have their notes hang on I rewrote it down at the bottom and May in their absence have their notes shared by either the board president or committee chair during the meeting okay thank you so could I get a motion uh excuse me I think we had the motion and on first is that correct Amy no no but you may want to

049say just as amend it because we made other changes like the title and all right thank you and I well yeah that's correct that that includes the title change so moved it's on the it's on the policy okay a motion to uh to change the title of policy 183 to board member voting of participation in meetings and the amended plus the amended uh information that Mrs Shope just read some moved can I get a second I'll second any more discussion board member Ley thank you so much um I'm not able to vote in favor of this because I think it's appropriate for us to see if we have the author and I'm not saying I disagree with anything that was said about security of Clos session and the importance of us being here um but

050I think it's appropriate for us to have this cleared by legal to see if we have the authority to exclude board members from closed sessions because we may find that yes you can do it although it is not preferred but these are the guidelines you have to follow you have to confirm you're in a secure location by doing X um so that's why I'm not able to support it thank you board member Ley all those in favor say I I have a question and discussion part Dr Garrison thank you um the the second the next sentence there says members may vote on a topic if they have participated in the meeting and discussion for that topic so that that M Dr Garrison that's from the original policy so that's not that's not been changed correct

051I that may be true but I just want to make sure I get my thoughts out here if they have participated in the meeting and discussion for that topic who who did I mean how do we determine if they have participated in the meeting I just I I know it's written back in 19 revised in 22 but P member leaving thank you so much so hopefully this will provide some clarity let's say that you all are on agenda item uh A1 and I come in right at the time of the vote what this is saying is it's not appropriate for me to participate in the vote because I haven't consumed the discussion I haven't heard all of the perspectives so I am not as informed as the rest of my colleagues now you can disagree

052with that um but that's what that language in the policy is stating is that in order to vote on something you need to be present for the discussion of that topic can I respond to that sure so but what if what if I came informed you know what if I read the notes what if I you know I you know I looked over the discussion and I thought about what was supposed to be discuss like you like you prepare to come to a meeting and you know I mean that's a space too um Mrs Lev that I think some of our mean I think all board members probably have the right to from that space so I just I just don't know just want to make sure I put that out there too thank thank

053you Dr Garrison board board President Johnson thank you um Dr Garrison you can we're a board of seven or Committees of three and you can do all of your research you can you can be you you might have a PhD in the item we're discussing but the idea is to come here and hear our colleagues and then make that decision thank you board President Johnson okay moving on you going to take a vote on that yes all those in favor say I I I any Nays nay motion is moved to the uh full board for the first reading and pass 2 to one okay next item is uh item D 185.5 Human Resources committee was 185 I'm sorry 185 y I'm sorry I got got ahead of myself so um as as you can see

054there's been some some changes made because of of um you know we've we changed our Cadence our meetings and all that sort of thing so these are the changes that have been made uh to 185 so I will open that up for discussion hearing none can I get a motion to move this forward to the full board for approval so move second any discussion all those in favor say I I I I motion carried 3 Z so next item is 1851 I mean 855 jeez and and we are basically well this is to cancel the policy because we no longer are meeting uh as a committee um because we've absorbed it into the uh the general agenda and and then if we have a closed session item we go to uh so is there for

055discussion and board member leevy you're up first I just had one um question on policy 185.5 the status is listed as proposed which that's usually refer or reserved for brand new policies so I'm wondering why the status isn't um like to be retired um because it seems like unless I'm missing something that that is what the administration is recommending um that we retire policy 185.5 so I just wanted to confirm that that's accurate correct we're going to retire right that's correct it's being proposed to be retired so got it that's why it says post cuz if I actually said retired it would go into the retired section so I can't say that yet so just just a quick thing so like in 185 the status says up for revision do you have the option to

056put up for retirement um I can look into that I mean which is H deal take that but and I don't want a curtail discussion but unless there's something um I move thank you I move that re retire policy 185.5 Human Resources committee some right she moved second sorry any more discussion hearing none all those in favor say I I I I motion motion carried this policy's retired three three well it still needs to go onto the full board for yeah yeah right needs to go to full board for for uh first reading yeah to be retired okay next policy is uh 2231 2E tuition continuing education reimbursement um this this came to the to the policy committee to U determine if we want to suspend or retire this policy due to the um do

057the issues with you know from the for the budget that we've already discussed earlier in the year so uh I will open it for discussion and and then we'll go from there board member ly thank you so just a few questions um the first is are teachers eligible for continuing education credit reimbursement or is it just administ rators just administrator just administrator okay thank you for that clarification um so just the notes that I have on this is that I would actually recommend um one that we keep it and two that we combine policy and the reason behind yes I think we should keep it um is because I appreciate that let me find the correct language that every February we get a report on budget impact um and oh where are my notes what

058is it called the the administrative forecast of continuing educating education credit reimbursement procedures and for me I think this is a benefit that benefits not just our administrators but also our students um and since we are in my opinion being responsible with that forecast that comes in February we have an idea of how it will impact the budget and then we can decide if that's something that amount that we can approve and it's my understanding someone jump in if I'm wrong in order for an administrator to be able to use this benefit they have to have had gone have to have gone through the administrative forecasting process um so that's why I'm in favor for it and then just my notes is I think it would be appropriate to combine policies 2 23.1 and 223.000

059Rule one um and adjust the title to read administrator continuing education credit reimbursement um just because the information on 223.000 one that last sentence um that says in accordance with provisions of current employee agreements um unless I'm missing something if we could just keep our language consistent and say current administrator contracts because I'm assuming that this benefit is listed in the contract um and then instead of and establish procedures just to keep our language consistent I would propose um and administrative forecast of continuing education credit procedures so it's very precise what needs to be followed in order to take advantage of this on and then I have a few questions but it's on the current information that's in rule one so I'll pause in case my other colleagues have questions on just the current policy

060may I yes my thought was that this was being brought to the policy committee because as part of our budget reductions we proposed that we were eliminating this moving for forward and so this is part we couldn't take it out of our contracts because it's policy so we're trying to bring it to policy to retire it because we shared with the community that this benefit this um um process was going to be eliminated as part of our budget cuts let me let me add from my understanding in this space I I don't disagree with you Mrs um alander but I thought we're pausing it we're pausing this benefit due to our budgetary constraints so that's where I that's where I was Landing in that in that in that space and Mr chady you I saw

061you move over so yeah you know I was it paused eliminated I I don't recall um there's three key pieces to this issue there's budget there's board policy and there's administrative contracts currently there's a policy says that we do this thing there's administrative contracts that the board just approved last month that provides this benefit however in the budget we do not have an allocation in that line item however in absence of the budget the district still has board policy that says if an administrator was to come forward and go through the process that perhap perhaps it would be reimbursed um so you know again just trying to get alignment of these three issues budget policy and administrative contracts so that there's more certainty to it all okay but did we not suspend tuition reimbursement um

062we eliminated it in the budget process yes but your policy still exists and it and you just approved administrative contracts that provides this benefit as well okay board member leing oh thank you so Mr Shady don't go too far I think I may have a solution and I think the solution is found in policy 2 23.1 rule one number four so that states for those who don't have it in front of them every February a forecast of current administrators intention to use continuing education credit reimbursement during the next budget year will be performed to anticipate budgetary impacts so I totally get there's not a current line item in the budget but it does still exist the potentiality for this in policy and in their contracts so and this is for next year so are we

063not on track to receive that report of who would like to use this for next year because I think what might be helpful is even though it's not a line item in the budget and I don't like to do this but I'm willing to make an exception if we are able to cover it by shifting something else and we know how much that amount will be then I am fine with moving forward and what might happen in that February report is we get all of the request and we say we can honor this amount so for example if three people want to take six credits the board may say each of you can take one class and then we approve that and then we find the money for that specific thing so that still honors

064the contract it honors the policy but that number for gives us the flexibility to limit it if we need to because we can't identify the money for next year and I would love to hear feedback from my colleagues board member henkins thank you uh yes until Dee got up there I was going to absolutely say that my recollection was this was to retire it because we couldn't afford it and uh I don't I didn't know why we were proceeding forward with it so thank you my second question goes into um in the contracts uh and let's just say it stayed the way it is and is there anything in the contract okay so an administrator furthers education is there any handle we have on them can they get their education from us on a and

065we reimburse them and then they go somewhere else which uh I'm totally against but there is stipulation about how long they have to work for us prior to being eligible and after and that standard in every administrator's contract um I don't want to speak off the top of my head I think that that's more covered and it doesn't go if I recall correctly it's not detailed in the cont contract itself that provision is part of um policies and procedures oh no problem it's number 14 on the the rule one of this policy okay I'd like to go back to um item four so the impact will be submitted to the board in February for approval so that wasn't submitted last night so is it so right so that therein is a challenge yeah um a

066suggestion that I would have is that the with regards to number four that first every February be changed to January that way the process of reaching out to the administrators occurs in January thus providing us the ability to bring the information to the board in February either at that first regular meeting or the second regular meeting um and does it come to the board or does it flow through the finance committee it's entirely up to the board to decide on that right well yes that's true but e either way it's going to it's going to go to to the general board that same night right it goes the finance committee right but just keeping in mind that the finance committee occurs on the first Tuesday of the month so you know trying to bring you

067something for February doing the survey in February yeah it's just too too much what your say well it's a no more than seven days right so yeah okay and one last thing we do not have any to submit in February because administrators were communicated that this was um not happening uh so there is no list to present to you okay that's what I thought uh board President Johnson um thank you should this um come to the board before the contracts are signed um and and you'll have to forgive me I'm a little bit confused because if this is already in their contracts and I know they've I've signed several contracts all of them um and we're are you know I I guess I'm wondering what is Our obligation if it's in their contracts and if

068it comes to us in February but the signing of the contracts takes place in January shouldn't it happen before the contract is signed I think board policy and the contract language provides the board great flexibility to be honest with you I mean you can make a decision in between the contract language Andor the policy you're not obligated to doing it so I I'm not sure that a timing thing really matters per se but I would suggest that perhaps as we go forward into the future when it comes to administrative contracts two years from now next year with new people whatever that perhaps you we just need to look at that a good point in the current policy on number eight it says administrators must complete two contract years of administrative service before the administrator will

069be allowed to participate the contract itself says one year now again the board has the ability to you know adjust make changes I'm not quite sure that it's worth the paper that it's written on but you know so okay well I need I just have to ask a question so the administration brought this to the policy committee for recommending suspension of retirement so that's why we're that's why it's here and and you've so eloquently pointed out that there are no requests because we've already told the administration that we weren't going to do it so I guess and before I hear from board member Lei and Dr Garrison I just want to say where I said I'm leading toward we need to suspend it and things change after the referendum and then going forward then we

070can pull it back out of suspension and go Michelle is that the is that the way it works okay thank you okay that's my two sents board member Levy thank you so I have a couple concerns one I I don't think it's ethical to tell someone that they can't use a benefit that is in their signed contract and I think that leaves us legally vulnerable so that is a concern um the the next thing is number four says every February a forecast of current administrators attentions comes to the board that does not mean that that information is compiled in February that can be compiled in September or any time before but the report comes to the board in February um I am in favor of keeping this benefit because it is in the signed contract

071that our administrators have I'm a little concerned that the contract language says they need to be with us for one year if you continue reading number eight that you mentioned the last Clause says unless otherwise provided for the individual's contract so my additional question is do and and you don't have to give me exact numbers but do we have many contracts that differ from the standard contracts where people have negotiated specific benefits that was changed at some point in one but theard may want to change it back to at some point consistent that it has read one year of service since I've been here okay so here's my recommendation I think one we need to let administrators know this benefit is in your contract and if you want to potentially take advantage of it let

072us know immediately and then I think that forecast needs to come to the board even if it's not in February if you can't compile it that compile it that quickly then maybe we do it in March um and then the board will be looking at a number not a guess a number and then we can decide if we are willing to commit to that so that's how I think we should move forward but again this is a committee decision Dr Garrison yes um you I I'll always thought that we put a pause on this based off our financial um constraints and so I remain in that space cuz that's what that's what we discussed we we need to deposit because of our financials and then and right now to be honest with you with with

073the deficit and the impact of just having a deficit we probably wouldn't be bringing more money to spend with not knowing where we will be in in in April unfortunately so that's I just want to make sure I shared that I also agree with Mrs Levy um um because this is one of those benefits that I think is beneficial to um um not just the staff but it's also something that's been written um and so pausing it I hate to say suspending It Whatever terminology we want to use um Stills allow allows us to you know figure out how we can move this forward later or not you know and it's not like it's taken away um from our administrative um Team or their contracts board President Johnson well I'm so old and that's where

074you guys go how old are you um I I remember when the district used to provide uh compensation or reimbursement for teachers as well to take classes um so I I am disappointed that this is limited to just administrators because I think uh continuing education as an educator is imperative Beyond just professional development um I tend to side with um board member Levy in leaving this um knowing that there is nobody this year um applying for it I'm comfortable with us leaving it as is and perhaps having the policy committee revisit it after we know the results of the um uh referendum board member henkins do you yes uh I'm in agreement with board President Johnson but I I would like not to leave it to suspend it with the caveat that board it comes

075back to the policy for revision or look at again in uh the fall or whatever you want to do in the future and I would like to address what Bo President Johnson said and revisit the teacher language also for continuing education I think it would be a uh you know if if if we do get healthy that uh it's it's a a uh hiring tool to say we do offer this so I'm all for suspending but definitely revisiting thank you board member henkins board member Levy thank you I'm just and it's possible that I miss this so if I did forgive me why did this remain in the contract if it was simultaneously I'm assuming it was simultaneously being taken out as like a deficit measure then why would we keep it in the contract

076and I just want to reiterate one I'm concerned that we have communicated to employees that you are not allowed to use a benefit that is in or we are not going to honor a benefit that is in your contract without it going through the for forecasting process and then the board saying no we can't afford it because I think that leaves us legally liable and to since the policy is still active I think we need I I am in favor of telling people if you want to utilize this benefit in your contract then then this is the window to make that request I just don't think it's fair to have it both ways so I'll try to address a portion of um your question or your statement there the initial part about why it's still

077in I can't speak to that that's outside of my scope and responsibilities I do happen to have my administrator contract here before me and I'll just read to you um the education expense section after one year of employment the board agrees to reimburse the administrator for tuition expenses associated with college or university coursework that has been pre-approved by the board in accordance with board policy no issue up to that point really um other than you know in the budget or I'm sorry out of the budget currently board policies still exists the next sentence is key though however the administrator agrees that the board retains the discretion to modify or cancel this reimbursement program during the term of the contract so again the board has provided much latitude there to make changes to say hey we

078can't fully fund at the amount that we um had intended but we can cover 10 cents on your dollar or or none um so you know much like the policy speaks to if we can we can the contract also speaks to if we can we can you know why the policy says two years the contract says one year the policy does have that unless otherwise specified in the contract but if all the contracts specify one year why not just have the one year in in the policy Miss leave does that answer your question I knew that that was a part of the the the contract language that there's an out unfortun I hate to say it like that but there's a there's a clause that prevents you know the board from having to commit to

079something that unfortunately when these types of things happen we can't we can't afford um thank you for following up it does however briefly I I think it's one thing for us to suspend it or to say no we can't do it for this reason but I'm not comfortable if this is what happened with employees being told they can't use a benefit that's in their contract without following the process that's laid out in the contract and in in policy that just that makes me uncomfortable the the contract gives us that levity though of like Mr T just read that that that Clause there so regardless of for me I'm just going to speak for me in this space as a district administrator I believe again the contract allows us that Liev to protect the board from

080obligations that due to finan concern constraints we couldn't commit to the policy though I mean I hear what people are saying about the one year versus twoe it's been the same way since I've been here so but the policy gives us that that space as well a lot of times you'll see policy does protect the district you know and so that's I believe that that's how this was probably written um for the protection for the from the school district's perspective so um you know I just want to make sure that again that language and the cont contct does protects the board and the district from overc committing to something that we can't financially approve board M henkins yeah I think to Mrs Levy's point I think and I I know where she's coming from I

081think it would and we don't know what the language was to the administration administrators on the saying they couldn't use this um you know if it was prefaced by saying as in your contract language we you know are not just saying uh you cannot do this I you know I think that would help us and I agree with you Mrs Levy that how it was communicated not just yank in their chain and saying nope you can't do it and that's an Administration thing how that was communed back to administrators so Dr Garrison can we get a clarification was it communicated to the administrators and how was it communicated and when was it communicated CU I think it really has a bearing on this um what what we're going to what are we going to do

082with this so so it was communicated that we were you know of course this was something was going to pause in during the the during the reductions conversation the second part of the conversation Mrs aleris U mentioned um how that was communicated I'm not 100% sure of but I know what we have always been talking about was that this was something that we couldn't commit to however in the contracts again it still gives us that space and the policy hadn't been changed yet so we were trying to follow both what what we're stuck in financially what the policy states and we still have protections across the board so if the board would be amable to of course um you know keeping things the way they are I'll be fine with with the understanding again if

083something was to come to us we probably wouldn't be able to commit to it just based off of our financial financials currently and we will be will be okay um as things stand now the board could also decide to suspend it uh which is a space as well um until you know you know further notice um thank you Dr Kon I just I I believe I believe that what my suggestion is that we sus we we suspend it temporarily suspended uh until further notice that you know after after further analysis financial analysis you know Etc then then we can we can bring it back to the board and un unsuspend it and make any adjustments that we need to then board member Levy thank you I just have one remaining question since these forecasts are

084supposed to come every February for the following budget year do we have any requests from last year that we approved and we are currently honoring or were those I hopefully the answer is no approved last year and then we said no we're not doing this this year uh so yes I happen to have the forecast um that was undertaken in January reported to the board in February of 2024 there were two administrators uh that responded at that time both requesting support of their educational advancement opportunities to the tuna six credits one of the challenges with regards to the time frame is our reimbursement um ties to the tuition rate for the University of Wisconsin system but you don't know what that is in February for the fall you know the upcoming semesters I mean we

085can approximate it but of the two individuals and their total requested 12 credits six credits each um we estimated the potential expenses in the 2425 school year at 9,620 neither of those two individuals have received any reimbursement after the board acted to remove it from the budget so one of them received reimbursements in February of 2024 for work that they had done prior to that and one received reimbursement I think it was June or July of 2024 prior to the board uh eliminating that line item in the budget so just for clarification we approved those 12 credits a year ago and we have not honored that approval because of timing and when this benefit has been pulled is that accurate the line item in the budget has been eliminated but your policy still exists you

086know so it's just that mixed messaging yeah no no no no so my question is last year when we approved these 12 credits um it sounds like we have not honored the full 12 credits and and so I'm just wondering before we honored Our obligation did the pulling of this benefit happened and if yes I'm assuming those employees were communicated to and said because people plan their budgets around things that have been approved so I'm just want how we tied up our approvals from last year well I don't think that the board necess necessarily approved the 12 credits it's about making the board aware we'd have to go back and read the policy and what the policy says right um but it's more about I think how much to budget for it and then the

087board subsequently eliminated lined out that budget item so I think both of the these individuals you know if you are making an effort to seek the educational attainment that uh that you are that an individual is you're undertaking that effort no matter if the district's going to pay for it or not right I mean I I want to get my doctorate degree so I can be a superintendent um I mean it's great if my current employer helps reimburse me for that and most do uh but there's also that repayment schedule if you you know when you leave um but even if the district doesn't I still want to get my doctorate so I can be a superintendent so I'll I'll cover that expense well I think that's an assumption that we I don't see the

088benefit in us making that assumption and it does say in the policy following board approval so if I'm understanding correctly the board committed to employees last February and said we would cover your 12 credit because I'm assuming we follow policy because we're all on board with that so the board approved it and now I'm just wondering did we honor that approval before we pulled the benefit and then I'll I'll stop because that that I want to know that because I hope that we did but it it doesn't change my support for this so I won't belabor the point uh not reflected on here and maybe a change going forward would be that that we ought to include the semester fall spring uh I believe that these courses were reflective of the fall of 24 and

089spring of so thinking back in that time frame the student is enrolling in class and right about that same time frame I think we were making the determination as to can we afford this or is that something that should go as part of the budgetary reductions neither of the individuals have sought to my knowledge reimbursement for any of those credits and honestly Dr Garrison may know I don't know if either of those individuals have attained their degree if they're still the they're both I think relatively close to graduation that's correct so um I don't I don't know if it's legal for to name names um shouldn't be no no should yeah so um we don't we don't have to yeah so the individuals that I'm aware of both are still in school processing their degrees

090and then the one other person um has received um a license and so at the time of this request there were funds to to help in that in that space and so I I I think I I'm Mr cha I want to go back and I can just ask the the people did they submit anything and we can kind of go from there but I I I believe some reimbursement was given to um an individual and an individual yeah you're right so they would summer 24 what was my my last recollection I don't know about the fall of 24 um yeah board President Johnson thank uh thank you vice president Nicholls I am really um caught off guard here and um really disappointed if this body approved something last January and then we said no

091we're not going to follow through with that I'm disappointed in us and um I would my personal um opinion is we should try to do everything we can to make this right because we have a reputation with our community that we are trying to rebuild and that includes trust and if we tell somebody we're going to do something and then don't that's not very trustworthy and Trust building um I'm so I'm um this feels like we're going the opposite direction um and you know I understand administrators you know make make decent money you know I don't know which which administrators these are I don't know if they're at the top level or the bottom level it doesn't matter we said we're going to do something let's follow through with it um you we Dr Garrison

092would let um perhaps have a conversation and um see if we can get some resolution to this and that's all I have to say thank [Music] you board member henkins yeah well and I totally agree with Tia on that point but I think we have two U things here we have suspect spending of this but also the other side of that coin is is dealing with the two that were have have done and they in the process of taking those credits and uh but that's I think that's a side issue I think we I think we suspend this thing so we don't find oursel in this position again but I think Dr Garrison and our board President we can figure out a way to reimburse these people once they have uh attained what they're going

093to do and honor their contract what we said we do and but I do think it's two separate things and two separate issues is there any other discussion okay um I need a motion just either either way I I move that we suspend this policy until further notice and if we want I would love to put a date in there to revisit uh whether it be July August September whatever but also in that caveat we looked at the uh teacher compensation also that's my motion is there a second I'm not providing a second because I don't support it but you may want to include um the policy and the rule yes board member henkins can you re uh board President Johnson um before he does can I suggest that you put a hard date or

094month in there um the hard date would be then a policy first meeting in in August for a revisit and uh I'm not sure if I could have Michelle re reread it U what you may want to say is that you oh yeah the yes yeah you moveed to suspend policy 2231 and Rule one of that policy until the first policy meeting in August thank you whatever she just said I agree with okay is there a second I'll second any more discussion typically um and I'm just I know August was mentioned of course I have to wait for a discussion naturally um would there be any thought to this being July because typically teachers and well I'm sorry administrators definitely have to enroll in school sessions start and fall knowing if that's going to happen

095would be a better beneficial space so just you know would prefer it to be Revisited technically in June because you register with school July and go back to school in August kind of thing so I would prefer June to be a space and if it's there great if it's not then we can always keep you know possibly extending that June or July I prefer June um but you know the new year starts July for board purposes type of thing but June for for this space makes more sense because you're ending School technically in May to start possibly even a summer session in June that makes sense M so in colleges they we they in they end in may not not like we do so you know yeah yeah so that's just a little different time

096and also with that we'll be looking for teachers absolutely so it'd be a good bonus if we could add that into it so yes I'd like to amend the motion I don't know the proper procedure on that and include that Mrs SCH also to change it to June first our meeting in June policy meeting in June hang on I'm going to look up the date that would be June 4th 2025 okay um I'm going to amend amend the motion to um revisit the suspension in on June 4th 2025 at the J the June policy committee meeting um could I get a second a second okay um all those in favor say I I I any Nays nay okay may want to re open for discussion yep so we uh so that passed two to one

097so now we need to um go back to the original motion which I you you uh board member hkin you used August and I seconded um so so sorry to interrupt that's already been remedied because the amendment passed so when you go back to the main motion it's the amended main motion now now oh okay so we're voting on The Amit y the amended main motion voting voting because we've already Yes I I any Nays nay okay both may have passed two to one the next meeting date is Wednesday March 5th at 5:30 p.m. um could I get a motion to adjourn so moved second any discussion hearing all those in favor say I I I I motion meeting adjourned at 710 thank you everybody

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.