CorpusRecord 82703

Business, Operations and Finance Comm. and Regular Board of Ed. Meeting - 2/4/2025 (5:00 p.m.)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / School District of Beloit
Date
2025-02-05
Location
Rock County, WI
Material
Transcript
Extent
27,841 words · about 155 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e all right it's 5 o'clock we'll call the Tuesday February 4th 2025 business operations and finance committee meeting to order uh M can I have a roll call please yes Brian Nichols here Greg Schneider present I'm Brian Anderson here thank you all members are present all right IEM one see approval of the agenda I'd entertain a motion to approve the agenda so moved second we have a first and a second any discussion all in favor signify by saying I I I I and opposed that carries unanimously item 1D approval of minutes any have any so move all right second all right we got a first and a second any discussion commentary here in none all in favor signify by saying I I I I and opposed that carries we're going to move on

002to item 2A monthly financials and I'm going to let Mr JD lead this one thank you and good evening to the committee members uh this evening we got a lot to talk about here over the next hour so we'll try to move expeditiously through uh beginning with our financial statements for the month ending December 31st of 2024 um materials were posted in bardocks publicly available and as typical we'll kind of walk through the the big picture highlight so to speak uh we'll Begin by looking at the monthly summary report I'll just make this a little bit bigger see if I can even go bigger yet for those viewing online there we go so monthly summary report hey December was a great month um December is one of those few months where our revenues significantly exceed

003our expenses uh and you can see that as reflected here on the summary report with revenues of 22 uh plus million dollar and expenses of just over $7 million uh so again we have inflows exceeding outflows in the month of December by 15 million dollar and again that typically happens about four times a year um so we just we have have to wait until December when we receive um a large portion of our state aid and we'll see that here in just a little bit so top row uh fund 10 our general fund that's where we see the driver of revenues 20.8 million we'll get into those details momentarily uh pretty typical just over $5 million in expenses in the general funds so inflows there exceeding outflows by 15.8 million uh which is um a

004pretty awesome thing row 27 are special education fund uh expenditures typically exceed the revenues and that's the case again this month as well $858,000 uh keep in mind that the Lion Share of the revenues in our special education fund come as part of our year end inter fund transfer from the general fund to fund 27 the special education fund that occurs in the month of June so uh typically throughout the other 11 months of the year uh the special education outflows exceed revenues we'll talk uh briefly about fund 50 our food service fund um right about the middle of the page $539,000 in income Revenue coming in 468 almost 469,000 in expenses going out inflows exceeding by just under $70,500 and then the last one that we'll talk about um is fund 73 our employee

005benefit trust fund revenues uh just over 19,000 expenses just over 55,000 but I use the term expenses rather Loosely there uh we'll talk about what that is momentarily uh but the outflows in fund 73 that employee benefit trust fund um were nearly $36,000 for the month but overall 22 plus million in 7 plus million out1 155 plus million is a benefit before I go on I'll just pause and see if there's any questions about the monthly summary report I don't see any everybody joins in the celebration of of a good month that's yeah uh cash and investment report uh so this reflects or should reflect uh where are finan where our assets are as of the end of the month my apologies there are two rows that are missing on here and I didn't catch

006it until today uh after stuff was posted um to bardocks and everything and I'll talk about that here momentarily so um you could see total cash and Investments reflect 17.7 million uh the reality is there's $6 million missing out of that value so it should be 23.7 million those $6 million uh we did two sets of 91 days CDs back in mid December uh totaling $6 million so 4.5 million were entered into on December 13th I believe 12th about that time frame and an additional 1.5 million was entered into a week later um I just didn't even dawn on me when I was putting this together to add those two new rows in I do have it in for January of 2025 already um but because stuff was already posted I just uh didn't have

007the ability to go back in and add that in and get that all updated so just a note to everybody uh we can include an additional $6 million in that total cash and investment value and so if we did that you know 23.7 is compared to the 32 million of a year ago and again reflecting back last year um we had an about an additional $1 million in assets that was used as uh a payoff on our debt service funds to help explain that significant difference and again drawing the attention to the very bottom of the page the approximate number of days of liquidity if you recall back in November we were down to the margin with 5 days of cash uh to operate and now we're up to 35 so we see how that

008number kind of changes um as our cash uh or as our revenues and expenses impact our fund balance essentially I'll pause and ask if there's any questions on that Mr Nichols so that that change did not have any uh any effect on the bottom line the $6 million in CDs that yeah uh okay yeah it would increase that total cash and investment number just in the current month because that was not um entered into until mid December so it would not appear in the end of the prior month or in the previous year comparison and it would not impact the cash liquidity values at the bottom um while I guess technically perhaps it could but because it's a CD and we're locked into a 91-day maturity I really don't consider that as current cash availability

009thank you yep any other questions therein all right let me open up the revenue reports and I'll continue to follow along in the financial activity the uh the narrative report um so general fund fund 10 whoops had total revenues uh again 20, 820,000 in change uh in the month of December and if we look up the page a little bit right in the middle is our state Equalization Aid Source 621 and you can see a state Equalization Aid payment of just under1 18 million 17.94% month of December bringing our total Aid to date from the state 27.2 million and in comparison it was 14.3 million for the same month last year 24.4 million for the same fiscal year to date a year ago uh note that the percentages for both are 40% uh based upon

010the state's formula how they um pay out or disperse the equalization Aid it calls for 40% to be dispersed um by that payment date in December so they honored that commitment down a couple of rows uh Source 730 you'll see Federal special project aid from the DPI uh receipts of 2,434 th000 and some change uh that was the final Grant claim reimbursement for our eser3 grant uh totaling just under 2.1 million and then the balance is made up of the arpa summer school um reimbursements essentially a kind of a component sr3 uh grant funding that finally reimbursed us for our summer school costs um that were eligible from Summer of 24 so that's what totals that and then just up above the uh Equalization Aid there's a bilingual bicultural 618 um 300 almost $326,000 receded

011it's important to note that a lot of these smaller AIDS like the bilingual bicultural Aid is that's actually computed and distributed based on how much money we spent on bilingual bicultural programming from a year ago in the 23 24 school year and then on top of that because the state allocation is not sufficient enough to fully fund that then the DPI has to take the state allocation and prate that against um school districts that submit those eligible costs uh in reality I think we end up getting like 79% of our um expenses reimbursed so it's not not significant but it's helpful so any questions on fund 10 seeing Don we'll kind of jump down a little bit uh a quick comment about fund 27 our special education fund uh state aid State education state aid

012Source 611 payment is $30,988 we receive that I believe five times a year if memory serves me correctly um and you can see uh fiscal year to date 1.2 million so that must be payment number two uh of five 27% this year compared to about 30% last year but otherwise pretty much right on track there was a little bit of miscellaneous um income in uh 780 I didn't even highlight it but you'll note it there $16,814.23 staff to students and then submitted for reimbursement and then finally we'll scroll down and talk about fund 50 uh just a quick comment there um Source 7117 which is our federal Food Service Aid reimbursements uh receipts $517,000 um that was for reimbursement of meal served during the month of October um so we're trailing a little bit you

013know there's kind of a timing and a delay play of how fast the district can get our claim reimbursements into the DPI and then quite honestly how fast they can then process everything and get it paid back to the district so um I would expect that we'll see some catch up over the next couple of months hopefully to kind of close that Gap if you look at fiscal year to dat we're just over a million dollars in the current year last year we're about 1.5 million so we're kind of trailing a month of reimbursements by about a month um is all so hopefully we'll we'll see that closed up here in the next couple of uh reports overall Food Service fund 539,000 last year same month 546,000 so again month-to-month basis pretty much on track

014um but that fiscal year today 1.1 to 1.5 million uh just trailing final big picture look at revenues uh totals again for the month 22 just over 22 million uh 16 million same month reporting last year uh December of 23 fiscal year to date just over 35 million in the current school year it was just over 31.6 Million last year so favorable there by about four percentage points questions on revenues hey hey we'll try to move through some of the expenditures with the same degree of efficiency hopefully and if I'm not being efficient just tell tell me uh fund 10 so we'll go to page four to look at the big picture initially in the uh current month activity uh $516,000 worth of expense looking at December of 23 it was 5.5 almost $5.6 million

015of expense or 500 almost $600,000 uh to the better and then looking at fiscal year to date 24.6 million uh this year last year it was 28.1 Million so again um that's a little bit better to the date for us as well when we come back up to the top and take a look at um salaries and benefits our salaries and benefits total 76.7% of all expenses in the general fund in the month of December um so that's uh that that's pretty typical as what we'd expect it to be our total salaries for the month here we go 2.6 almost $2.7 million compared to 3,1 125,000 for the same period last year and you can see fiscal year to date 12.1 to 13.5 um so both of those are favorable given our current Financial situations

016uh employee benefits 1.1 almost 1.2 million in December 1.2 million uh last year so about $100,000 shy of where we were last year 5.3 million ion in the current year 6.1 million for the same fiscal year to date a year ago some of these differences between current and a year ago because that's probably a question that uh you have going in your mind is why are we so much below very likely related to Staffing you know we have some vacant positions perhaps that aren't uh being filled and thus not incurring that expense and then along those lines in some instances we have contracted out for certain staff levels they would not show up in the 10000 series 100 salaries and benefits I'm sorry salaries and wages 200 in benefits that expense would show up in

017the 300 series as a purchase service so and I think when we talk about that you'll see some increases in purchase Services especially when we get into the special education fund so just kind of trying to connect those dots for you because I'd ask that question continuing down purchase Services uh in the the general fund uh just over a million just under 1.1 million this year last year 981 th000 so again about a $100,000 variance looking at fiscal year to date 6.2 compared to 6.7 million um some of the difference in the why were about $600,000 different there is going to be found let me scroll back up where is that 327 Construction Services uh so in the current fiscal year we have almost 1.4 million at this point in time last year it was

018almost 1.1 million so about a $300,000 difference there um that was all related to that construction the um HVAC project work at Beloit Memorial High School that project's been completed and we'll kind of see that work itself out of the equation over the next year any questions on fund 10 expenses hearing none fund 27 um again if we look at the total expenses on page six I think it is oops I went past it there we go 1.5 million in the month of December of 24 it was one just over 1.3 million December of 23 fiscal year to date just under 5.5 last year it was just over 5.5 but if if we come back up we'll see um salaries just over $700,000 to uh pay for our special education staff in the month of

019December was $815,000 last year so obviously $15 or so thousand difference there when we look at benefits 340,000 this year 366,000 last year so a $26,000 difference you know uh so now we're talking about about about $140,000 but when we get down to purchase Services you can see our purchase services in the month of December 463,000 as compared to 160,000 last year you can go up a couple of rows and you'll see this 370 Educational Services payments $117,000 there whereas there was none last year uh and then if we scroll up a little bit more uh pupil travel is that also a big driver in special education Fund $248,000 in expenses paid during the month of December um some of those expenses may cross more than one month um but that was only 123,000 for

020the same reporting month of a year ago so just kind of commenting on some Oddities some observations on my end but I'll again I'll pause and see if there's any questions for clarification Mr Anderson yeah is it is it B piece of that the students that we send over to the Richardson School that would be a component of it yes so any students that are placed outside of the school district for their educational programming are reported in that purchase Services category um and that would be recorded as a 370 object code so that would be part of that $117,000 this year and again if looking at that we have $46,000 in um expens expens is there in the current year and last year it was just over 95 so do you think is are those

021students receiving Services there because of the level of need or because so even if we were fully staffed in that department it's still a need that we wouldn't typically be able to serve or if we were fully staffed would that come in those students come back in and we would not have to purchase those Services you're asking the wrong person I think I can answer the question and um I think because of the needs of those students is what's driving that external placement if our staffing were better aligned to what our needs were might there be the possibility for some of those students to be returned question mark but I doubt it yeah I think she's got a comment yeah I'm sure she does I'm smart enough to stand out of the way we yep

022nope they would not come back their their level of need is so high that we I don't allow anybody to have that conversation until we exhaust all of our resources here and they've got to definitely proof that they've exhausted all of their resources here first and the expense here becomes so great because sometimes it's a two staff to one student ratio and it and um the time and effort that we're putting in it it makes more sense to go there um there were four students there last year there are four students there this year so I'm not sure if that explains that yeah that that would be a portion of it um and again the other thing that's kind of reported in that category would be contracted Specialists like OT PT speech and language psychologist

023thank you yeah um are also included in in that 370 um payment line any other questions special ed Mr henkins yeaha could you just without names just give me a or us an example of the type of student that would be at Richardson that we couldn't accommodate what I I know he mentioned PT and uh but give me an example of a student that would be there that we couldn't accommodate please I feel like this is kind of reaching confidentiality a little bit but this that's kind the the question makes me a little bit uncomfortable because I feel like I'm breaching a little bit of confidentiality because there's only four students however um every single student needs an adult with them at all times um these students elope the building and Richardson has locked doors

024so um they cannot leave um there are students who are nonverbal um there are students who are there's bodily fluids being I I don't feel very comfortable answering some of these questions without I mean it's it's very very significant thank you uh real quick on expense I think the oh that's I was going to say the last item but it's not quite um Food Service fund total expenses 468,000 uh 800 for for the month 447,000 of that was remittance to Chartwells for providing Services uh in the month of November if I recall correctly um so that's that and again you can see comparison last year it was 433,000 December of 23 uh fiscal year today 1.1 as compared to 1.6 and I do want to comment a little bit about fund 73 our employee benefit

025trust fund we don't talk about this often however there was activity in the month of December that's noteworthy and while it shows up as an expense uh you can see this expense $ 53,8 22 in a penny it's not really an expense what it is it's an unrealized loss on investments um and you can see that reflected there in Source 998 so because the market value as of December 31st 2024 was actually down whatever was happening in the market and the Investments um of our assets we took a loss of almost $54,000 um in the month so that's reflected there I pointed out there are losses that and gains that happen every month um typically not as large but because it is what it is I I just wanted to kind of point that out

026to the committee um that that that was occurring so when we look at total expenditures again just over $7 million in December of uh 24 just under 7.4 in December of 23 fiscal year to date 32.2 this year 36.5 last year so I think all things there appear to be uh fairly appropriate any questions on the expenses I want to talk about fund balance real quick before we jump to our next agenda item I do have just I had I had noted this this afternoon and I I apologize that we didn't have time to send you a note but so how often does that happen that we have a a loss like that and I guess the next question would be let's say in the course of the from September to now how would how

027would we compare from where we started then you know school year till the end of December in that in that account I guess my question where I'm leading to is would we be better off to move that to the if you've got the crystal ball yeah I know yeah I know I know it's an investment if you don't invest what right I mean a good way to look at that fund 73 um assets so half of those half of that value is placed in a money market account at the bank drawing 4ish percent interest the other half of it is invested in some of these Securities and again the best way to think about that would be any personal retirement savings that individuals have you know at the end of the day sometimes you make

028a little bit and sometimes you lose a little bit sometimes you make more and sometimes you lose more it's just it's a reflection of a snapshot on that date um but every month there are either unrealized gains that show up on the revenues and quite honestly because they're just so small we don't talk about them um and sometimes we have months where unfortunately at theend end of the month the market wasn't doing so well and then that loss is just a little bit larger yeah in the grand scheme of things you know I I sit here and I wonder to myself all the liabilities are gone in fund 73 so now we just have assets you know the assets sitting in the money market account at the bank that's fine these that are in the

029market should they be still should should we move them out of the market into a more cash stable investment that way we don't lose our principal or our current asset value um but at the same token if we do that and the market continues to grow then we also lose out on that investment opportunity so H Walmart doesn't have the crystal ball maybe I should check Amazon huh so just commentary on that yeah no I appreciate that I you know I I understand that and you know from you know my personal stuff and just just was just curious and I wanted to see what the yeah yeah yep total totally right there with you because you know the same things have been crossing my mind too you know should we pull it out and put

030it in something a little more stable but then if it grows you know got it yeah thank you you bet any other questions on the monthly financials hearing none I think there's a motion that was included in the doc in board docs for your consideration yeah we don't have if there's no questions I would entertain a motion to move this to the full board I do have a question you were you going to touch on the fund balance oh my bad yeah thank you totally was and I forgot to yeah so uh here's our fund balance project or um so at the beginning of this current fiscal year back to July 1st we had a fund balance of 10.49 3 million at the beginning of December our fund balance was down to just under 2.3

031million and then we got that large State Equalization Aid we had all those revenues the inflows coming in exceeding our outflows so our fund balance at the end of December grows to just under 18.1 million and again the two columns to the right there um present the same snapshot Pointon times from 2324 so December open 2.3 million this year December opened last year at 2.7 December closed at just under 18.1 million this year December closed at just under or just over 11.9 Million last year so again December is just one of those months because of the amount of state aid that we receive um that that's the one month one of the few months that we end up on the positive side thank you for the reminder on that apologies for missing that any other

032questions on the financials I entertain a motion to move that to the full board so moved second I have a first and a second any discussion all in favor signify by saying I I I I that carries all right thank you Mr chady we'll move on to item 3A outstanding checks yeah just a uh verbal mention um if nothing else so as the business office has been uh adjusting to our new Staffing arrangements and some revised assignments we've had the opportunity to kind of look at things a little bit differently and as part of that looking at things a little bit differently we've identified that we have a some outstanding checks that are rather old um so we're going to begin efforts to try to work through some of that issues and just to kind

033of call it out we've got 119 outstanding checks that were dated between August 13 2014 through December 27th 2023 in the check amounts vary from 50 cents not mistyped it's in there appropriately 50 cents somebody wrot a check for 5050 to $2,000 2,000 was the largest we happen to know who the $2,000 check is for quite honestly I was expecting to see the individual today haven't yet but maybe will yet today um so the total value of those 119 checks is uh just under $7,500 so um we've noticed it the auditor we've spoken with our Auditors a little bit about it as well they've provided us with some guidance uh of course one of the guidances Mr Anderson you're probably familiar with this is the unclaimed property process through the Wisconsin Department of Revenue it's

034rather prescriptive um however we can only remit outstanding or stale items that are five years old or more to the state so anything uh newer than five years we have to continue efforts and that's really important is that the DPI still requires the current holder of those funds in this case the school District to make efforts to reunite the monies with the people that it is due to um so that's the part quite honestly that has not been occurring in the district Beloit is not alone in this issue we had similar issues when I was in Marshall and we put a process in place to try to reach out and contact the uh rightful owners of the outstanding property and in that Communications in Marshall what we did is we provided the Don or the

035donor the individual with three options one reissue the payment to them they just had to give us a current mailing address or Bank information so we could AC direct deposit it you do that you don't have outstanding checks to begin with two we gave them the opportunity to direct the amount owed to another student within the district to support another student Food Service uh school fees whatever but the owner had to identify the name of the student that it went to so maybe a neighbor moved away you know we owe him 13 bucks and they're like does Johnny Smith still go to school in belloy yeah we just get give Johnny the $13 so we had in Marshall we had some people do that and in Marshall it may not work quite as well in

036booy because our uh meals are served free in Marshall they were not but um owners of outstanding checks had the ability to donate to an angel or a gift fund to help offset uh breakfast and lunch costs for students that needed that financial support but again here in bloy it's not really applicable because all of our students are eligible for free meals to begin with so we'll be making similar efforts to reach out to these 119 or so individuals just trying to clean up the books so to speak so just an odity just to point it out Mr Anderson yeah so obviously you got to follow DPA rules and try to contact him that's fine but I think if it helps you you might want to consider you know just stopping those and go ahead

037and clearing your books you can still have a you know from a ledger standpoint know that you owe them and make contacts because let's see if you call someone and you go to the they say oh yeah I still I've got it it's been sitting in this at my desk for a year or for 10 years for one of them right if they present that to the bank it's quite likely the bank's not going to honor it you would expect however I would also say that so many of the deposits today aren't physically presented they're done electronically and and it could be returned like a lot you take a picture with your phone right yeah it if someone presents a 10-year-old check that bank I'm say they would but it's it's possible and then you've

038got an unpleasant experience right so I mean I would say my recommendation would be to to stop those items you still want to follow the dpi's rules get it to the rifle owner when you identify it and they do want to check you're going to a new check anyway yep just a recommendation yeah a thought worth Merit um the district incurs a stop payment fee on certain dispersements by the bank so you know if we're going to be charged a 20 or $25 stop payment fee and a $8 check so things that we have to think through um been down the road before and we'll we'll figure it out we'll yeah we'll try to start getting some of this cleared up I that we'll have it cleared up by the end of June but we

039will certainly make efforts to get the 10 what was it 119 117 whatever it is you know perhaps down in the 60s you know so yeah I think we got one more Mr henkins yes Mr J I I know you there's several outstanding I see staff reductions but then I hear students so most of these checks I know there's a myriad of checks that are out there are a lot of the checks to students or uh from teachers that haven't I know I know there's plenty but if you put a number on it I would think that the majority of the checks would be to adults and or vendors and very few to actual students okay but that doesn't mean that they're not there I've we haven't really dug into the who that 117 or

04019 you know who those people are some of them just screening through the list were easily recognizable to me some of them are vent ERS couple of them are individuals some of them are actually District employees um but again going to direct deposit helps alleviate this issue right yeah the the big one when was that issued date wise um I don't have it in front of me the $2,000 one I would say within the past four to six years I believe okay um but again it's one check to one individual $2,000 and I know that individual so can sign it over kind of figure that maybe I see that person today and I just haven't bumped into them yet but okay yeah we we'll address that one and get that one taken care of quickly

041okay anything else to add on outstanding checks any other questions anything all right that's just information only so we'll we'll move on to item uh 3B real property items Mr J yeah so there's really uh three items to discuss with the committee today um board policy gives the this body um the authority to speak about and to make decisions with regards to selling Andor purchasing or acquiring District land uh want to go back to mcneel and Wright um I I believe and you can correct me if I'm incorrect but I believe believe we're at the place where it is likely in the district's best interest to Market those properties for sale that does should not be interpreted as we are willing to sell um if the price isn't right right I mean it it would

042provide us the opportunity for interested parties to Tender an offer to The District in the school board for consideration and then for the board to look at it and say h I'm not quite so sure you know personally I think we're probably good with um selling and uh mcneel right myself I would tend to think that we might be in the best interest to hold that property for a little bit yet um but again there's no harm in listing it you know we can get it listed we can get a for sale sign up in front of it and then offers will either come or they won't come and during that period of time we can consider what other potential uses best uses uh there are for those properties so along those lines um our

043operations facility which is just a couple of Doors Down Here on Fourth Street uh is a property that I think it would be ideal or wise for the district to market for lease not for sale I think it makes sense for the district to retain that property uh with regards to any potential long range vision of the Fourth Street Corridor here however we have very few staff that work in that building in there's plenty of space available in other facilities to move those individuals too so if we can find somebody that is interested in leasing that for a shortterm medium-term um time frame and thus generate income on that I think that's in the district's best interest as well there is one other piece of District owned property uh further down four street that we'll

044talk about with number three um with regards to what we may choose to do with that but so currently the recommendation is that we strive to lease mcneel and write for sale and that we uh Market the operations facility for lease ideally I'd like to see if there's a way that we can bring Caldwell Banker and Century 21 both to the table with regards to those facilities uh I'm not sure how that works out co- broke or brokering a property but um I think there's validity in having both parties trying to help us so we'll try to explore that with them and see where we go my intention will be so long as the committee uh says go forth would be to reach out to the realate Brokers tomorrow to arrange an opportunity to meet

045with them to discuss the desires the interests for them to submit proposals and then to bring those proposals back to this committee on March 4th if not for uh you know I I think it's probably in the district's best interest to get signs up in front of those properties sooner than later so yes sir Mr Nichols well I would I would wholeheartedly agree I just have a couple questions so what is the footprint of the operations facility the lot and then the building itself you know that by chance don't Tommy or Acres Acres acre half acre quarter acre and then what's what's the square footage of the building I can pull that up for you yeah I I should know that my no Mr Nichols I think that's 1.29 Acres yeah total Total Property there

046for the on Fourth Street yeah I've got Acres rounded at one square footage of the building 2,623 approximate yearbuilt question mark uh condition report from eua fendorf rated it at a 3.23 on a fivepoint scale I do recall that rof uh was an issue at Ops um because it's not student focused it was low priority for the district but uh if we were to go about leasing it then that may require us to do some Roofing improvements there in order to protect the leasy L or whatever it is yeah 2,6 23 23 I think is what I found in one of my sheets yeah and did you say was it one acre uh just over one acre yeah although as I'm looking at this map I think that is that 1.29 is that the that's

047the Burger King facility and then ours is on ours is on the other side other side of Ling green Creek correct. 56 Acres okay so round it up to one yeah yeah any other comments or anything I I would just say I agree I think there's no harm in in listing for sale I'd say good luck if you can get two brokers to do the work for one commission if you can do that yep that' be awesome um and I think finding uh you know that's how you're going to find the value something's worth what someone's willing to pay right so right um I mean we've got the appraisals uh so we may need to come back before the committee or the full board with regards to the asking price to establish for sale um

048I don't I don't know that that's a my decision as much as it's a your decision to be honest with you so uh but that you know again we'll try to work through this over the next four or six weeks the sooner we can get those signs up the better um selling those properties for the Public's benefit selling those properties doesn't solve our financial situations you know if and when we sell those properties there's really two options um that you can do with the funds one you can bring those funds into your general fund and they can help provide revenues in that fiscal year Alone um or two you can deposit those funds into a capital Improvement trust fund to help maintain assets other facility improvements down the road you know thaning parking lot improvements

049roof improvements Etc uh with our other schools that seems to make the most sense to me but again that won't be I'll give you my guidance but it won't be my decision to make so sure Mr henkins yes thanks for that work and I I also I'm know I'm not on the committee I really think that's a wonderful idea I agree with Brian that and you Mr chady it's it does not hurt to ask couple other comments along with selling real property another real good benefit is uh you know not so much the the take the getting price which is nice but we're going to stop the expense of maintaining those buildings and I know from discussions with you and Mr bicko you know correct whatever it is 50 60,000 you know it's it's still

050a savings so there's Stills right we still have utility expenses uh for those we still have maintenance of mowing the grass clearing snow I'm not sure benefit if we just the benefit to unload it and I would just like to make a comment on the operations center and I've had discussions with Tommy and you probably Mr chady but you know go back 6 months and uh ago when uh the settling was CCI and uh on the other property and the burn property and the and the uh need came up about um parking and I know that's it's part of what you're talking about the Operation Center as it sits could be parking you know like for a football game for disabled people and I know there's a big sign there you can't and it we'll

051tell you away but there's nobody in that parking lot as it sits now and as a temporary you know stop Gap to open that up and let people park there now not not overnight but you know yeah no good good thought um that parking lot is not in good shape would not meet ADA requirements from a handicap accessibility and would pose more challenges than it would Solutions however you know that too is a potential solution you know we could raise the Operation Center and expand parking there put in a new parking lot and that would even situate you know for handicap accessibility for Jacobson field better yes exactly where was going but you know first we got to figure out how much is if somebody's going to lease it or buy it so right on

052good thought thank you yep so I think we have a consensus does that have give you what you need to I I believe so it sounds like carry on that we're marching in the right direction and it doesn't hurt for us to do that and it just positions the district and the board in a better position um as we await offers and when the offers come then you got to decide is that worth it to sell it at that value so perfect okay good deal number two um we received a letter uh from the Wisconsin Department of Transportation with regards to a parcel of surplus land that the dot owns um over by i39 it's on Ki Road the letter was included in the packet perhaps more importantly was uh this map um that I

053grabbed off of map quest I think and kind of highlighted that parcel so it's barded to the west and North by Ki Road uh to the East and the South by I 3990 uh composes just under six acres relatively flat not much elevation change uh I've driven out there I haven't I didn't walk it um but I drove past it and looked at it and paused and I I just don't really see much immediate need uh for it from The District's perspect perspective um so again I I would think that it would be an offer that we would just let pass Us by but again not really my decision to make it's the committee's decision to make so I got one question for you so again not that I want the school district to get

054into speculative real estate um and owning properties but um maybe do you know what price we would get that at I I don't yeah that that's the great question right you know um so I think the letter says something about if you have interests we got to write them back and let them know and we have to kind of share with them you know what our intended use of it might be um it doesn't really say or doesn't speak to you know could we get it for 10 bucks you know I don't know maybe I I don't know or you know might there be an appraisal on it and it's at whatever value and so maybe if you're making phone calls tomorrow with calwell and Century 21 ask them what they think now the only

055reason I say it or even entertain it is it's a stone throw now from the casino right and and I is I don't think there's any value to the district but if there's value there I it wouldn't hurt us at the right price to buy and hold it if we could for a year and a half right right if we could so recently we had to do a notice of federal interest at blit Memorial High School and that that basically said because we spent more than a million dollars in facility improvements using federal funds there the federal government now has an interest in that facility so that if the district were ever to say we want to sell the high school the federal government would essentially say that's fine but we'll take our million dollars

056back so my guess would be that you know and we can inquire with the do about this could we buy it for bucks and then in five years sell it for $155,000 because there's retail development out there and somebody wants they like that location you know dot May sure may say fine but we win our $100 back and in this case we'd say gladly you know here you go yeah we can I can make a phone call and have that uh discussion with them just to see how that process actually works out and you know if we don't end up using it per se and it's just y okay can do Mr henkins um Mr chady I know that they as I read that and just perused it did the city get the same offer

057is the city interested do we know that are we the city yeah I believe all municipalities in the area would have received that probably including the school dist uh the Clinton Community School District right uh they likely received it the town of booy likely received it the city likely Rock County probably as well okay yeah I you know how far they cast that net I I don't know yeah and there's no way to know if they have interest or not so you know we're no way we're going to get in a bidding war of something we're probably not going to do anyways right but it's worth the phone call yep we can do that Mr um chaye just due to time um the next conversation with the um buring space yep um let me just

058jump in real quick and just share that that's something that we ventured into looking into um there's some conversations that we are yet to still have with um the company I don't think right now um BK is interested in our um possibilities there due to the fact that they're a little further down down the road um that doesn't mean that we can't think about the um south end well I want to say the wrong direction here no you got it right the south end yeah at the south end of um right Crossman Taco John of us looking at the possibilities of us selling that that piece of land as well um maybe in this package of opportunities with cwell banker and um said real estate agents um we could look into the possibility of that

059also being something that we could look into possibly selling now um now that is very close to our high school um initially with Mr chady and and when we discussed all of this I was in the middle around should we list that space I can tell you um we don't currently use it for anything um but it is still our land it wouldn't hurt for us to see you know what interest we possibly will have in that space um down the road currently we do still cut the grass and you know of course obviously cut the grass and motor line but it's the same thing um we still of course um upkeep that area so that is what we were thinking with that there's no need for additional discussions with BK at the current time

060but we will look into possibilities of having a conversation with um our bankers and I do want to spend a little bit more time in the next conversation and we do have about seven minutes to do so all right if you're in agreement then we'll move on to item 3C the January P count thank you so um the January P count um one of the things that we wanted to just make sure that everyone was aware of is we we are currently always looking into this conversation and I want to thank the entire team who had a lot to do with this I don't want want to you know of course we've shared this information with you all for your review um I want to just touch on just a few of the opportunities in

061the in the P count report one um our overall head count we always say people who are in The District um we are down about eight students from last year September to where we are currently um that is something that we you know not necessarily are proud about but it is something that we can just definitely say that from last year September third Friday count to where we are now we're just down eight students overall though um from a overall resident count we're down 49 students um from um September to where we are um currently now the resident students from a district perspective those students we have to of course identify where they are where they're not if they go to if they go to a different school but the bottom line is they're not

062with us and so that is a different um space that we would need to you know keep looking into as as this year goes on um it is real hard though to you know I just want to be honest with you there's a lot of transient families here in the school distri there's a lot of people that move around a lot and so sometimes when our students come to us or move away from us we don't always get that ready on time information and so we are you know of course looking to you know Rectify that as quickly as we possibly can because we do want to be able to count all of our students who are either with us or want to come back to us or are no longer with us I know

063it's a uh a tongue tie there all this money does impact revenues as Mr chady will probably um indicate um but again people who are currently in our district we are currently eight students um down from September to now um overall resident students again students who reside in our district can can possibly come to our school we're down 49 students again those are two of the major snapshots in this and I'll turn it back over to Mr chady I just wanted to make sure I just touch that before our time gets a little close yeah thank you and I'll I'll try to move uh quickly through this as well so the pupil count process happens twice a year is required by the DPI on the third Friday of September and then again on the second

064Friday of January um here's the steps of the process step one two 3 four five we'll walk through those we'll also take a look at the comparison um to the September pupil count data and actually you'll see that throughout each to the um slides and then lastly well actually not lastly there's the reconciling student changes that be uh that occurred between the count dates and we'll talk about that I missed a bullet on here and that's the lastly component um and that's where we actually calculate the membership the FTE membership um but that gets a little bit more complicated so step one of the process is the headcount of eligible students and you can see a column here that says physically present so those were students that that were in class um on January 10th

065of 2025 the absent column reflects students that were absent on January 10th however they attended prior to and or after the count date and thus are eligible to be counted so th those are absent but countable students is what that is so the DPI has a number of different categories over here on the left there's preschool special education so those are basically students Less Than 3 years of age that or 3 years or younger uh that are receiving specialized Services um then we operate this four-year-old kindergarten at 5245 hours so the values are reflected there 5-year-old kindergarten full five days values are reflected in that row so we T we talk about those three and then the DPI just kind of lumps everybody else together in one big pot and says okay now just tell

066us about all your grades 1 through 12 students so it's not by grade it's just all grades uh so you can see that reflected there as well over here on the right hand side you see the comparison so on the left is January's pupil count on the right is the September pupil count so you'll note that preschool special education had an increase of 22 students from 26 in September to 48 in uh January that type of growth during this school year is pretty typical to be honest with you um four-year-old kindergarten a reduction of one from 293 to 292 a gain of 2 uh 5-year-old kindergarten from 359 to 361 and then a loss of 31 students in grades 1 through 12 uh was 4276 in September 4245 here in January so overall loss of

067eight students in our head count step two then is to identify and deduct out to remove those students that are open enrolled into the school district of booy the Wisconsin um DPI opal system assists Us in doing that and we had 108 students open enrolled into the district uh so essentially non-resident students attending along with one individual paying tuition to uh take part in I think one maybe two courses at blit Memorial High School this individual is an Illinois resident that's paying us tuition um to take part in some of our programming that they have interest in so in total we deduct out 109 students from the head count because they're not our resident students and again a comparison to last year was 110 I'm sorry comparison to September it was 110 step three uh

068very seldom does this occur in districts but DPI um had has us record if we have any Resident students that are um attending a part-time homeschool program and then participating in our programming or part-time private school program at the grades 1 through 12 level and participating or were outside of the age eligibility uh none of which we had in September and again none of which we had in January in step four is where we identify School District oblit resident students that are attending through the Open Enrollment program so they are attending a public school system elsewhere in Wisconsin and through open enrollment we identified 873 students uh with two students doing a tuition waiver so a total of 875 students in January were actively open enrolled into another school district in September that value was

069917 so a difference of 42 the great question would be where did those kids go we don't know because they weren't attending the school district of bit to begin with so they were you know their bit residents that may have been open enrolled to Jamesville as an example or Clinton or wherever but they are no longer actively participating in that open enroll districts programming nor are they open enrolled to another Public School District in the state of Wisconsin could they have moved yes could have and we just don't know um could they just be truant and no longer attending that could be a possibility too we just we don't know but just kind of pointing out um that you know while you'll see a large value reduction here in a couple of slides maybe even

070the next Slide the Lion Share that happens to be in that open enrollment out category so summarizing the data then we take our starting count 4946 we have to subtract out the open enrolled in students of 109 subtract out uh resident reductions a zero add in the 875 students are actively open and rolled out and we end up with 5,712 resident students within the district and you can see a comparison to the September pupil count here's the January column 5712 September column 5761 so a decrease of 49 but again what was that number number 42 of those whoops 42 of those 49 are were in that open and rolled out category and then a couple of last comments uh M or Dr Garrison talked a lot about the student movement that occurs uh during the

071count dates and you know people are just blind because you don't see it you don't know or expect it to happen but between September 20th and January 10th the district had over 430 different students moved moving into or out of the district so that's a lot of turnover and flow as families come into the district or as families depart the district um and included in that were those 42 students that you know were previously open enrolled out of the district and we just are uncertain as to where they they don't appear to be attending uh Public Schools uh within the state of Wisconsin currently the only other component that I missed on this was you know so of we talk about enrollment which is the number of students we have enrolled in the district and

072are educating in our schools we have the pupil count which helps identify how many students reside in the district and then we take that pupil count and we put it through a couple of formulas and we end up with our FTE membership and that the membership factors are our early childhood special ed students we can count at 0.5 our 4K students we can count at 6 and every body else we count at 1.0 FTE um thought about that last night I was I was crawling into bed and again it already posted I wasn't going to go back and change the presentation but just uh orally uh speak to it lot of information any questions sorry for running long this evening any questions from committee members real quick so do you know what the current membership

073is I I sorry no I did not calculate the membership okay um I I'll try to do that here during the meeting thanks sure all right any other questions all right thank you Mr chady we'll we appreciate that we'll hear those numbers again updated um at the end of the year I think and we'll move on our next meeting date for this committee is Tuesday March 7th at 5:00 pm um I think that's the fourth Tuesday March 4th is that Tuesday's the 4th I I think I'll Trust your calendaring I'll go with Tuesday March 4th um okay let's go over the fourth um and I would look for a motion to adjourn so moved second got a motion to Second any discussion hearing none all in favor I I I and opposed we are adjourned

074we'll give a quick five minute recess so we'll the full business meeting will start approximately 6:10 e e e we'll get started in 1 minute e good evening it is 610 I would like to call tonight's meeting to order Mrs hope may we get a roll call please yes Megan Miller present tom henkins here Brian Anderson here Brian Nichols here Amy Levy here Greg Schneider present and tia Johnson here all members are present thank you for tonight's Pledge of Allegiance we have CM Berling the assistant principal here with us and a student from Aldridge middle school if they would come up and introduce your student oh okay that's that's fine iuce mine who used to be an student currently a senior at Memorial oh okay meline would you repeat would you turn the microphone on

075and repeat your name so so that I can get that written down for us thank you so much um my name is meline Lannon um and I am a senior at BL Memorial okay and before we move on Dr Garrison just reminded me I forgot an approval of the agenda so can I get an approval of the agenda I moved to approve the agenda minus item 7D to my understanding those minutes were adjusted today to give board members a chance to review those and also item 9 c um there are no closed minutes attached for us to approve is there a second [Music] second any discussion hearing none all in favor I I I I I any oppose motion carries unanimously Mrs sh did you get that motion I did thank you okay mine please

076proceed I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic with which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for [Applause] all mine I would just like to say thank you so much I appreciate your your courage and your uh will willingness to represent not just Aldridge but BMS bmhs and the school district of booy we are really proud of that kind of energy and [Applause] enthusiasm next up is the board president's report thank you everyone for joining us tonight board members uh cabinet members staff members community members and everyone online on Tuesday January 28th I attended the Wisconsin public education Network virtual session for Schoolboard candidate connections this session provided information on how to be connected to the Statewide Community Education Community to learn

077more about the Wisconsin public school funding and how Schoolboard members can advocate for policies that support students on January 201 9th I attended the bit Civic Academy at the bit Public Library Brad B the Turner School District Director of Business gave the presentation he gave an overview of funding since Act 10 and the disparity in current actual dollars funded in relation to the real cost of considering inflation also discussed was the impact of open enrollment and student demographics on some District's ability to maintain Financial stability later that day I attended our ad hoc committee meeting followed by the Wisconsin public education Network legislative action briefing assessments accountability and AD adequacy were discussed board members and I attended the 2025 Ed Wisconsin education convention in January we will hear more about this later this evening however

078I do want to go into a bit of detail pertaining to the first session I attended at the convention mastering publicly reported data for Schoolboard members in this session the presenters discussed some of the changes in the DPI report card how to use the data from the report card to highlight the district's successes and to address areas of concern the session included a brief tutorial on how to navigate dpi's wise dpublic portal this session was well attended and while it was very informative it was obvious many participants had a general sense of frustration regarding the usability of this year's report card data this presentation piqu my curiosity because there were some data points in our report card for which I had questions and concerns some of my specific questions were answered by presenters for others

079they did not have an explanation for further clarification last week I spoke to the DPI Office of Education accountability some scores on the report card have been adjusted to better represent accuracy for us to use reliably and others are not usable the achievement scores are one example where the DPI oea the office of Ed uh education accountability con consultant suggested I looked for other data to use what caught my attention was the same number for two consecutive years for the ELA achievement and the target group outcomes achievement scores which were also the same as the previous year the odds of that happening are phenomenal the oea consultant explained that with the changes the higher number of the two years 2023 and 202 2 and 23 and 23 24 the higher of the two numbers was

080used he further explained that we cannot interpret this to indicate a regression in this area merely just the adjustments to the forward tests and the redistribution of achievement scores could not provide year-to-year comparisons what we can state with confidence is that the school district of bloy over has had an overall improvement in our growth score this is commendable to all staff students and families who have made the effort to make this a success story to be shared however we cannot rest on our growth in growth score alone the district must take action to have significant improvement in our achievement scores recently the national assessment for of educational progress na released its annual report unfortunately Wisconsin is not fairing well as we once did in the area of education for example only 31% of Wisconsin's students

081are proficient in Reading in an article in MKE education News and Views titled nap results reveal Stark reality for Milwaukee students author coulston Morgan Jr States James Baldwin's wisdom once again fits not everything that is faced can be changed but nothing can be changed until it is faced the Statewide results are sobering and the results in Milwaukee are a five alarm fire that we must face headon this statement must be taken with all du importance objectivity and care for our students and the future of our community although the author is talking about Milwaukee Public Schools they outperformed the school district of G in most a achievement areas which those current School scores can be compared District to district with reliability to simplify the situation in terms of not use being able to use our achievement

082scores year after year I'd like to use a medical analogy say for example I have had high blood pressure for many years the blood pressure that is is what is being measured and scored and tracked it can be tracked and compared year after year it represents a factor in my overall health and if not treated could cause greater damage to my overall health let's say this year my doctor for whatever reason changed how my blood pressure was measured and what scores indicated low normal or high blood pressure if my blood pressure were actually worse this year than last year I would want to know this so we could start looking at diagnosing the systems causes and potential treatments if my doctor were to say well I want to use a the higher of the two

083scores because we've made these recalibrations I would consider that a lapse of judgment and potentially harmful to not know the true status of my health the board and administrators have to know the true health of our district in order to remove the obstacles and barriers presenting us from moving out of the bottom 3% in the state we have to make sound decisions based on reliable information friends colleagues in closing I encourage you to look at other data sources that were not changed such as the ACT scores and please remember that we all care deeply about our schools and want every student and staff member to succeed these next couple of months may be emotionally charged for some please board members staff students be truthful be kind be respectful be open to hearing opinions different from

084your own and choose your actions and words as if our students are watching and listening this concludes my report thank [Applause] you next up we have upcoming events and announcements board clerk Tom henkins thank you board President Johnson good evening the announcement for Tuesday February 4th include a Martin Luther King Jr black history celebration at Converse beginning at 1:30 p.m. on Friday February 7th Monday February 10th there will be no school due to a staff professional learning day High School parent teacher conferences are being held on Thursday February 13th from 5: to 7: if you're looking for some music entertainment Aldridge is having a winter van concert on Monday February 17th from 7:00 to 8: p.m. and fren band concert is the following night Tuesday February 18th beginning at 7 p.m as well our future

085board meeting dates include policy committee meeting tomorrow night February 5th at 5:30 here churching te excuse me teaching learning equity and pupil Services committee meeting at 5:00 P p.m. followed by the regular board board meeting at 6 pm on Tuesday February 18th thank you and this ends the announcements for tonight thank you Mr henkins and if I'm not mistaken is there a an ad hoc committee meeting on Wednesday okay and that is at 5:00 p.m for anyone who's interested for that yeah next up we have recognitions I'm so sorry Bard President Johnson my hand is raised I'm sorry I did not see that no no no no problem at all are we meeting on Thursday and I know that there was a doodle poll but I wasn't yes so we we are beating on Thursday

086that agenda will be posted tomorrow um the doodle poll did indicate that we would have a quorum and that's Thursday 5 to 6 That's Thursday 5 to well 5: to 6:30 thank you yes yes thank you thank you board member Levy um board president Nichols do you have a question no I just saw your microphone's on oh turn my off okay so I am really excited tonight um our first recognition is Raul Sanchez Martinez and we have Christy Champion here the advanced learner specialist to help us with this recognition and we even have some visual aids tonight while they come to the Podium I'll give a little background information on rul and why we are giving this participation for his um efforts in the South Lakes Lakes Anthology artwork competition bloy had nine entries in

087this year's Anthology publication crusen had five entries Aldridge and hacket had two entries each in order to be published on the front or back cover of the Anthology a student has to receive a perfect score on the rub rubric and be recommended for cover art by the judges 37 participating districts voted and for the second year in a role rul Sanchez Martinez received the most votes to have his artwork published on the front cover of the Anthology one of his other entries received the second most votes so he will also have his artwork on the back cover of the anthology very impressive Mrs champion thank you um so we had Raul bring his cover from last year's Anthology so this is the first time in the 17 years I've been in the district that we've

088ever had a student on the front cover um and he said when I presented in the classroom that he was going to end up on the front cover again I didn't think it was going to happen when they made the announcement they said not only is the artist from last year on the front cover again um with his piece the planets um he also was selected for the back cover and he had one other piece um that was also selected for publication so congratulations [Applause] Raul there you go a picture for thank you thank you R I would just like to say I am so impressed with your artwork being a science and art uh major myself I love that you are blending scientific ideas with your art that is so impressive I'm looking forward

089to seeing what you do in the future and congratulations on your job that you've your succcess now thank you let me just say this so I was actually in school on Friday and we was walking the hallways and was walking I was actually about to leave out of Frozen and Mrs Champion walked up to me and mentioned that you know we had a student that has some wonderful artwork and I was like of course we do right and I'm thinking all of our kids are just great with everything they do and then she went on to share with me of course the wonderful conversation around your artwork and so then that just that just captured me right and so I told Mr Champion I was like be careful when you say something to the superintendent

090because then I'mma put a you put a task to it right and so right away I was like we got to get this you know we got to get this you know conversation in front of everybody so again congratulations on your artwork and I'm an art fan as well um as Mrs Johnson and probably many people on the board as well I love your art it's beautiful and then again um to all great artists of course there's parents that help Usher that conversation right and so um thank you um for the for the wonderful Arts that your son created so thank you our next recognition is of Grant recipients many grants are received in the district at this meeting we will recognize the recipients of the community enrichment grants we want to thank them for

091all the hard work that it takes to write for Grants these grants are for our students and help support the district where other funding does not and tonight our grants received include and um I understand not everyone could be here tonight but I'm going to read everyone's name and um the award $2,000 to the school district of baloy choir collaboration Kristen Valentin valent from Memorial High School $3,750 to fifth grade ukulele program Tiffany k kenser um at Merill Elementary $490 to the wellness room and calming space for students Abby baxer at Gaston $500 addressing sens in needs for all Chen Woodward at hacket $310 for social emotional learning superhero student project Amy Langer at Converse and $600 special education outdoor field trip learning Explorations Regina mallister at Merill nice job and thank you everyone you

092next on the agenda is the public com comment Mrs sh do we have any public comments for tonight I do not have any public comments in the room nor did I have any emails okay thank you reports to the board the superintendent report Dr Garrison sure so good evening um School District BL and booy um Board of Education and ab of course BR Community I want to start off with a student story in relationship to a double header game that I attended at elorn um last Friday it was a boys and girls double header game basketball game a parent came up to me and stated um I want you to know um you all have wonderful students and I appreciate how this place is packed okay um additionally she stated um that a student of

093ours who is in our band asked the pep band director could she play with the pep band okay and of course the the pep band director stated to her of course yes you can play with our with our band so the student went on out grabbed her instrument came inside and played with a pep band at elorn now I know she wasn't torn who she was rooting for but she wanted to play and came and played and they allowed that to happen but what's bigger to me is just that story about our students okay that's that's a story about our students I've never heard a story like that before personally maybe you have I know when I was in the band I played the saxophone as well and this young lady was a saxophonist as

094well and at half time I wanted to still play in the marching band cuz I'm from the south and my coaches used to tell me that you couldn't do that until one time I asked him I said well if I'm not if we're not really talking about anything in the locker room why can't I just go outside and go ahead and play and he sat back and he said go ahead go ahead and do that I was sharing that story because my my voice of me asking could I do that was heard and this was the same conversation for this young lady her voice of asking and that that took some you know I want to say that took some pride and her ability to say you know I want to play for I want

095to play my instrument and I don't care where I'm at I just want to play my instrument that was a wonderful story and I thought I would share that with you all now I know you all probably thinking what was her name who was she and I was just so caught up in the story that I did not C capture the young lady's name I know I can find her if I really wanted to but I just wanted to share that that that story with you all um because these are about our students you know speaking about our students I know there's been conversations around our enrollment count and of course naturally at the last meeting we we had some conversations about that we are down about eight students from last year from September 8th

096to where we are January um of third accountant so I just want to make sure everyone is aware of that overall from a district perspective we're down 49 resident students overall as well um another snapshot um as we kind of think about our students not I'm sorry as we kind of think about our students we are still in our attendance matters campaign so parents and Guardians please remember that daily School attendance is vital and if you need assistance please contact your school your school students Services team or the building principles we definitely want all of our students in our buildings every single day because not just on third Friday when we have to do the count this is about learning um every single day and we definitely want our students in school um regularly and

097like Mrs um Johnson mentioned uh as it pertains to the Wisconsin State Convention I would like to thank each board member who was able to attend the Wisconsin State Convention in 2025 um these opportunities for learning are essential for boards and administrators as it allows us to connect on many different topics that we often times don't get to discuss here in the district as we are learning um we we learn together that's that's the goal of the Wisconsin State Convention and and have that opportunity amongst all of us is very important I must highlight that on Thursday the feature of presentation before the guest speaker was our very own jazz band so our jazz band got to perform in front of pretty much thousands of people I can say that they're not they're used to

098that because of their um heighten um um skill set that they do have but I want to say thank you to the jazz band who came out and traveled of course and and was able to give us um a three three three band set for that Thursday um this is always a wonderful opportunity for our students and again I want to thank them for for that opportunity um naturally they go against other people who make submissions right and our jazz band was selected and so I just want to make sure that's something that we bring note of um the referendum 2025 um we are underway with our communications platform for the 2025 5 and Thursday February 6 our website will be live with um information for all we will be sharing opportunities with information um

099based off of where we will be in the communities we will look forward to answering questions about how this referend will support our students staff and of course community at large this of course concludes my announcements and thank you Mr Johnson thank you Dr Garrison Mrs Levy thank you just one quick question Dr Garrison I know that you said correct me if wrong our residential count of students is down from September do we know if those are students that have moved out of the district or given our current climate with respect to immigration do do we understand if that's individuals being fearful of sending their students to school so our District's resident count is down 49 students I wouldn't know if that that's the case as it pertains to um the environment um I do

100know that 42 of those students we were unable to account for based off of we don't know where they are um the other remaining students were due to open enrollment um but there's about 40 or so students that we weren't able to account for for our overall District's residents um attendance thank you so much I said attendance M Sor count any other questions for Dr Garrison okay hearing none we will move on and lost my agenda there we go next up the legislative update board member Miller good evening um because we have a lengthy agenda I'm not going to do a full update I will just quickly since it was brought up say that there are um 94 referendum questions this April ballot across the state coming from 86 different districts um and also just

101that the state is projected to have a budget ending at um $4.3 billion this June 30th 2025 so if you are interested in advocating for increased State funding for public schools across Wisconsin so that we don't have to continue to go to referendum for operational purposes please do contact your lawmakers thank you thank you Mrs Miller next up we have the State Convention report and this is to share with the board member staff and Community Information obtained at the State education convention in January tonight um myself Dr Garrison board member Mrs Levy and board member Mr Schneider will all um have the opportunity to share thoughts on the convention Dr Garrison sure um as I mentioned in my report I just think the state convention is awesome opportunity for us all to kind of learn

102together of course there was some conversations that I was able to sit in as it pertains to the learning naturally when we thinking about enrollment some things around metrics is around um attendance um we had two of our own um present at the um Wisconsin State Convention um this year as well um Miss Miss beavers around attendance and Mr uh Mr Eric wear around the complexities of being a um a special education director um when you're having to do dual roles and so um for me it's the opportunity also to connect with other superintendents as well as um other um colleagues of mine um naturally with the board we of course have opportunity just to connect and and I I always think it's funny because seeing each other outside of like work um it's it's

103an amazing opportunity so thank you for the laughs that we were able to share um and I appreciate that thank you Dr Garrison Miss Board member Mrs Levy thank you um thank you to the district for affording me the opportunity to attend another state of Wisconsin education convention um I encourage everyone who is interested to download the Wisconsin education convention app for 2025 um several presenters have uploaded their presentation slides and name and District information is provided for all presenters to make it easy to reach out with to those presenters if you have um any questions or looking for clarification uh for any of those slides that are uploaded I also want to thank Roseanne Han um for inviting me to serve on the state policy and resolution uh committee I learned a lot and

104enjoying representing Region 13 and the school district of booy I value the opportunity um to connect with school board colleagues from across the street state in our meetings throughout the year um and thank you to Dr Garrison for inviting the board um to a beautiful dinner uh that was great to kind of see each other outside of the boardroom and enjoy a meal uh and a great time even Rob stopped by so that was that was lovely so again thank you to the district um for allowing this opportunity for me very grateful thank you board member Mr Schneider good evening um again I just want to appreciate being able to go to the State Convention um there are so many different sectionals that opportunities I've me every section or every time frame that there was

105I I think there were at least a dozen different options that you could go to um so there's no way you could attend all of them um I attended a lot of different ones looked at referendum they looked at at um connecting with the community and and engaging in community support um and so and a few others that were there leadership and so on to do that um um I did attend the the pre-conference that uh president um Johnson attended when we were trained by Deep people trained by DPI to look at the state report card and what really surprised me is there was really nothing in that report card you can take at face value while they may look at if you look at the score it may be a score from Zer to

106100 that is not percent that is not percentile it's taking the scores and fitting it into a range of zero to 100 where instead of getting into the middle or the average they take the total and then they start taking points off for different things so you can't use that data and just report out that that's what it is which is where wise Dash is really important to look at because that's the raw data that you can see there and that's really the data that you can use um and it's so unfortunate that that the state is so into looking at that state report card and taking it at face value um and you really can't do that which is which is unfortunate for the state um the report card looks the way it is

107because that is what the legislature has said that it's going to look like so this is not the way the DPI would do it or any educator would create a report card of this kind um but this is determined by the legislature um um great conference uh great opportunity it was great listening to the Jazz Band it was great meeting and talking with people from other school districts um and and just talking at what they're going through and what is happening uh so again it was great conference I look forward to going next year hopefully thank you board member Schneider I too attended and a couple of the um sessions I attended uh one was tell your story and measure success with a strategic dashboard I decided to attend this one as after the first

108one I attended about the report card I know that there are other ways to show our successes and um perhaps building our own dashboard may be the way to do that um another one I attended was your your community as a classroom engaging students and building public trust I think something that the district is uh wanting to work on in not just engaging students but in other regards as well I attended calling all board presidents this one was put done by the Milton board president and it was very nice and interesting um and a bit of a relief to realize that there are other districts dissimilar to ours experiencing many of the same problems we're having I'm not trying to say misery loves company but um uh Thursday night rather than attending the dinner um

109with Dr Garrison I did attend the buo veter session um they had um four presentations one on um updates on um Title 9 o another on open meetings law another um looking at some of the executive um orders and um another one on finances it was it was very very informative I'm I'm sorry I missed the dinner with Dr Garrison but I'm I'm really glad that I went to that I attended the WB legislative update and um learn more about the um state budget and legislation that's um potential legislation affecting public K12 schools the another one public education funding in Wisconsin is it adequate is it Equitable and this one looked at the disparities again between Public Funding and how it does not keep up with the cost of inflation uh U Madison Professor Chris

110Sal was the presenter and has some very interesting um um charts that he said that he would share share with us um I did attend the um session with Sam Glenn the General Session he was an artist and I'm sorry that Raul has already left but this one was a fun event to attend and he was comical and humorous I'm I'm not but um and he he made art while he was giving his presentation and it it was really worth um looking into this this gentleman and his story so again thank you for this opportunity for us board members for we board members to learn grow develop and make connections Tom do you have a question oh okay okay there okay next on the agenda we've got the Dual language program review so this is

111um the purpose of this is to provide the Board of Education with a summary of the findings from cisa 2's dual language immersion DLI program review during the fall of 2024 CA 2 assessed the structure outcomes audience reach Staffing alignment and academic rigor within the school districts of beloy DLI program Dr Garrison actually you read exactly what I was going to State um but that's perfectly fine we we want to make sure that we thank our partners for um the work that they were able to conduct in our district Iran ID program the report of course is duly noted in the agenda as well as what we have posted um um a full report for the public to review I'll turn over to Mrs mortek and she'll introduce our speakers and of course um lay

112out the conversation for today thank you for tonight thank you good evening um so as promised we're here uh mid mid year to um share the findings of the DLI review uh we started this work with our Partners um Audrey and Fran they're from the language and culture center of excellence from cisa um and so in the presentation they have the timeline that they've been following the goal of tonight is for them to go over and and share the findings uh and then uh we will take that back we'll debrief uh with staff as well uh with the idea of coming back um for some potential decision making uh that could happen at the board level for what we want to do in the future for programming some of the other findings in there we

113can um take care of internally like professional learning um or thinking about curriculum and materials and things like that uh but there are some recommendations in there about the actual DLI program um so as we come back and debrief uh we will come to you with some ideas about a phased in approach uh so here are Audrey and Fran um I just want to lift up how much I've enjoyed working uh with them as researchers truly experts in the field of uh dual language imersion um and they have been uh wonderful thought Partners um and so Tony Bosco also under his leadership um we've really enjoyed just working with them and uh here they are to present thank you you thank you so good evening um I really appreciate Fran and I both really appreciate

114the opportunity to be here today and to be able to share with you we're super excited when people want to hear and see what we spend our time doing so it's just really important to us so I'm going to sort of start us off um briefly just to give you some context of what we put together and what we looked at and then Fran's going to sort of break down the specific recommendations that we have for you and then we'll follow up with some final details so let me see if I can press these all in right way oh did I no I did oops nope let's try again yes okay so we were um we were approached this summer and specifically this fall to do a program review specific for the DLI program so

115we had sort of a lot of questions about that and sort of what it would look like in terms of you know were we going to what are we going to look at we're going to look at assessment the structure the audience what did the intended purpose of the program so we really want to sort of get into what is the scope of the research that we're doing the next step of the process is collecting the data and I'll go into a little bit about what we were doing as part of that data collection process as we go through and then we sort of um we wanted to kind of highlight and leverage key findings for you and what's um just to kind of highlight some of the unique things is that your du language

116program efforts are on par with your District as a whole and sort of consistent or even a little better than some of the state is for some of um for du language program in general so pretty consistent so I sort of really wanted to highlight that and then I also wanted to make sure we highlight that your students when it comes to Spanish proficiency you have a high number of students on the assessments that you have that demonstrated Proficiency in Spanish so um we'll go into a little bit more detail about that um so what did we look at we specifically looked at the structure of the program what does a dual language program look like what is your allocation of your Staffing your time your schools what's that structure then we take a look

117and we look at the curriculum does the curriculum align is there parity between your dual language program and the parity of the um and your other programming in your school district um we also look at what are your instructional approaches um you know what kind of approach do you take um where is the balance between the language is they bridging across languages what are the assessments that are using specific for dual language do they make sense for that is there formative assessments Summit of Assessments that are being done um are you examining um what are the achievement results for that as well we look at Staffing uh both in terms of Recruitment and how we recruit and then um also what is the um qualifications of the Staffing and their abil your your your Staffing

118potential actually I want to say and what does your what is your structure in place that um you're for things to integrate across language arts and other curriculum within that context so both languages are validated so there's a way to create a smooth transition um that's one way to do it uh another way to there's other ways to do it that you would basically um just regrow the program up and create other incentive ideas within the school clubs and other activities to build or support language development in places where that language is not happening you can add more yeah and that would be another potential opportunity for biliteracy coaches as those students are coming out of kindergarten first second to then work with those third fourth and fifth grade teachers where while you may not

119have a true 5050 dual language those teachers that had those clusters of DLI students could do some bridging cross- linguistic connections just with the assistance of the coaches um in that particular building so I think again we're trying to keep the spirit of that language development going even though it may we may not have capacity at those other grades to have 50/50 until we can recruit retain and then as Audrey said over time maybe build into second build into third once we get the Staffing solidified that's a big issue so that might be one way to address that Miss leing thank you y board member henkins yes it's kind of piggy backing off Mrs Ley on that vertical are you suggesting and I know you're far you know you're taking these recommendations going to work

120with them did I am I sensing that you would uh because of Staffing and stuff you would get a couple schools on the west side east side whatever and then if they wanted to go into DLI have them open and roll to that school and Al Al also the F uh fren sure Al is that how you s it's we generally that is the process we if we went down to two elementary schools it might create a waiting list right because you've got sections in three elementary schools right now so that if you said all of the elementary schools were going to have the program we're going to do something different at the middle school maybe we would move those Middle School DLI teachers down to fill out our elementary Staffing solidify that and then

121as I said do something a little different with the language programming at the middle level while it might not be a true 50/50 dual language program at that level could we try to expand the World Language Spanish opportunities and do some more of that work with the coaches the Spanish teachers maybe the ELA teacher the social studies teacher to try to make some of those cross linguistic connections um so it it would be different but I think we have a lot of infrastructure in place that wherever the stakeholder groups kind of send us with our next steps uh we'll be able to adapt but would you could you see a a scenario where Gaston is a DLI school for and uh another school and so if if you wanted DLI you would send your your

122kid to yes it's it's almost like that now with Converse hacket in Robinson if a parent is a Gaston right attendant they could say I'd like my student to go to and they just have to get them there right so we kind of do that now okay thank you yep no problem board Miller thank you uh thank you for this wonderful presentation the report too is just awesome to read um so I'm a parent of three children who are in the DLI program one at seventh grade one in fourth grade and one in first grade and so um a couple of things I just wanted to react to I loved in your presentation just now how you talked about expanding sort of our the elasticity right of like our understanding of communication I just think

123that's really on par with like what I've experienced as a parent and as a teacher um I really loved when you talked too about targeted supports and so then I actually had a question for for our uh District staff would you say that like our DLI progress monitoring and intervention and targeted support systems are they sort of like in sync with the rest of our like Equitable multi-level systems of support or is there capacity that we need to build there that's a that's a fantastic question board member Miller um one of the things that is a a blessing and and a challenge sometimes with dual languages we we are not as language develops we do not want to Heap on Intervention early but we are looking at the data early right we understand that it

124will take students who are learning Spanish as a second language or English as a second language six years or so to develop that proficiency but we also have to make sure um when we look at that data is there do they have one language strength and then that second language is coming up if we see um a lot of growth opportunity in both languages that will raise some flags for us and that would be an opportunity for us to understand that there may need to be some intervention or additional support there on the Spanish side our Equitable conferencing kind of construct applies in Spanish as it does in English so as we see students need to work on particular Silas or whatever it might be we are looking at that data and then in the

125Equitable conferences trying to adjust it address it just in time so that that emss process is there but we give a little bit more grace to the development of the language just because of that trajectory of B literacy no thank you so much because actually my follow-up question then is if we were to keep the three element you know like keep the programs horizontal right um because there are kids for a variety of reasons who develop language you know at a different pace if you have children who are enthusiastic about continuing to be dual language um you know to become biliterate who are more slowly developing in one language or the other is there I guess capacity at the middle level in the mtss kind of stuff we have right now to offer some ongoing

126support in that transition yeah that would we'd have to explore that a little bit because the the challenge with say we were to move those DLI folks down to the elementary to fill that out that our only language resource at those two middle schools is a Spanish teacher and right now again because of Staffing we're filling one FTE of Spanish at one of our middle schools with a DLI teacher because we lost the Spanish teacher late so I it's it's again Staffing Staffing Staffing highly qualified language teachers is what we need so can I can I add something sure um one of our recommendations is to put a really heavy significantly more heavy and emphasis either through your training of your teachers and your coaches around meta linguistic meta- awareness it's essential component to a

127program The Catch about that is the more we do that or the earlier they do that they do that the more we build the capacity of the students to do their cross linguistic transfer so so if you were to reduce some of that language acquisition later in a um if you maintain a horizontal program your emphasis is to say we're going to give the kids the skills to be able to make those connections and we're going to teach more of we have lovely fancy terminology like trans languaging to basically create opportunities for increased learning at a level level so your program has done very has followed a more traditional model significant research shows that there's ways to make connections that you're really kind of in a place that you can develop that's awesome now I

128really appreciate that and just because this is a long report I wanted to point out on the topic of Staffing my favorite paragraph out of the whole thing on page 28 was um despite facing significant challenges the staff within the Dual language immersion program demonstrate remarkable commitment and dedication to their students and the goals of bilingual education teachers consistently work to provide quality instruction even in the face of Staffing shortages high workloads and limited resources I really appreciated that you took the time to point that out and I really that is something we could say about all of our District staff um and I think that is just a huge strength of our program so thank you so much any other board questions or thoughts comments just one final call thank you again to the

129team who of course worked so feverously over the past few months to get this report done it was something that Mrs mortech and I discussed when I when I arrived actually um but due to you know different times and things that we needed to take care of we just weren't able to get it going right away um Mr Bosco you're leadership thank you for this conversation as well I'd like to also thank our teachers as Mrs U Miller has mentioned it is very important to note that you know our bilingual um teachers and a lot of our um um students in this conversation as well they have a skill set that skill set is great um and we need to you know of course recognize and honor that and as much as I would like

130to say that you know we are doing the the absolute best in this space I know there's opportunities for us to grow um it is hard knowing that we have Staffing um limitations and of course some staffing conversations in general um due to our budget but again I know that our staff is resilient and like I said before somehow we just you know we just keep getting it done so thank you so much um to the team who help put this together um over these past few months thank you thank you thank you thank you next on the agenda is Staff survey climate results the purpose is to review the results of the staff climate survey Miss Mrs alerz good evening board I'm very pleased to have school perceptions present the findings of our 2024

131fall climate survey um we are very excited about the turnout um the percentage of participants and we're hoping that moving forward we'll continue to grow the number of participants so that we can have um excuse me a better understanding of where our staff are with regards to their employment with the district uh Rob Muse has been instrumental in ensuring that uh this climate survey was rolled out successfully and he will be presenting those findings Rob sounds good thank you so uh like d just said um my goal for you tonight is to take you through your staff survey report um there's about 30 questions in here or so that we'll review um but then we'll spend some time at the end kind of putting a bow on it and putting it all together and giving

132you some summary slides for you to think about um over the next few weeks months and maybe even years so like you heard Dei said what we have for you tonight is a district level staff survey report um this was sent over to the district um about three weeks ago or so just before I believe your your previous board meeting so we got to dat it as soon as we could on your agenda tonight um there are four different colors of slides we will have very few background slides we'll just briefly reintroduce myself um we'll talk about who took your survey where do they work um uh you know how long they've been with the district and so on those are yellow slides overwhelming majority of our time will be spent on green that's your

133results and Analysis and then I'll leave some time for wrap up the questions at the end um hopefully you recognize our name a little bit we've worked with you just had the screen up I think it was maybe 20 2015 is the first time we did belit staff and parent surveys we've done a couple of referendum and planning surveys for you in between uh mostly with me so hopefully um we don't look too unfamiliar to you but um we've been in business since 02 and our mission has never once changed we want to help you as educational leaders gather organize and use data to make strategic decisions um we've done over or collected over three million of these and we've helped more than 1,000 districts I think it's about 1300 on the dot uh 1300

134school districts across the country navigate the strategic planning referendum planning and engagement process for your staff survey um it was primarily a December window um so kind of between Thanksgiving and Christmas um you ended up with 394 respondents for a 54% participation rate so over half of your staff responded uh now for context here in any given School District um especially in Wisconsin the average response rate is about 60 to 75% however it usually goes down for the biggest of the big districts and you're one of the biggest districts in Wisconsin so I'm actually really happy with this for the number of employees that you have um it wouldn't have been uncommon to have you get in the in the 40 to 50% range so as you heard DD say you had an outstanding response

135rate um you know when we're working with the very very small districts those that have two 300 kids um it's not too hard to get them to 60 70 80% so for you to be able to get the 54% response with all of your staff members um that's definitely a win here and you have a lot of strong data to be able to stand on to to be able to ascertain um how your staff are feeling in various areas couple of pieces of demographic information and I know DD's been doing a lot of work slicing and dicing this data across different schools and really digging into some of the spreadsheets we sent along um here again we're going to focus on the district level data but just to give you some taste of your responses

136uh we did ask at which location do you spend the most time um one in five of your survey respondents work at Memorial um followed by Aldrich and then so on down the line um all the way to multiple buildings at 2% um and zero folks chose other and zero folks identified themselves as working at the F maintenance or facility building second to last demograph or uh yeah second to last demographic slide we asked what best describes your position this is pretty typical most of your staff are going to be classroom teachers in fact one half of your survey respondents are classroom teachers um educational Specialists those are folks that need a certification and a license but they're not classroom teachers so in that case um think your school psychologists your school social workers your

137Librarians your interventionists and so on those are educational Specialists U par professionals some districts call them AIDS some call them instructional AIDS um all all similar names for the same group um support staff those will be folks like your bus drivers your custodians um your food service workers um your administrative assistants Administration makes up 6% and then you can um get into your substitute staff as well 1% of your survey respondents are are your substitute uh teachers and other fill in staff members this though is pretty much what i' what I'd see no matter size or location of the district and then finally uh final demographic question including this year how many years have you worked for the district um you got about well a little over onethird of your survey respondents that are in

138the one to five um Range um one and five are in the six to 10 um but the majority of your survey respondent well plurality of your majority respondents um have worked at the school district of blit for more than 10 years um just under 40% just under 4 and 10 in that very 10e group we always um also allow staff to say I don't want to answer this um here the good news is that very few folks decided to not tell you where they worked or how long they've been with the district and so on very very few um it's not surprising especially if we work in a district that is lacking in some trust that can be you know eight nine 10 some sometimes in the up uh mid to uper teenss so

139fortunately here that does not seem to be an issue um folks don't have an issue um identifying you know some of their demographics and where they work and so on so that's that's that's good we're going to start broad we're going to go down and then we're going to come back up broad so we're going to begin with 30,000 foot analysis your indexes indexes are designed to provide you as educational Leaders with a snapshot of your results so these are indexes specifically designed for staff these scores here particularly the middle two columns they're in a range of one to five in fact unless I call out differently um about 98% of the questions in your survey are on a one to five scale um so in the back of your mind I'm just bear that

140in mind um the worst possible score a district can get is 1.0 and the best possible score a district can get is 5.00 now the middle of that scale then obviously is 3.00 so when I'm eyeballing this data for the first time I'm looking to see where are you above or where are you below three if you're above three you're on the right side of the fs you are on the side where people are agreeing with each of the statements and that's where you want to be none of your items are reverse coded in other words you don't want people to disagree you don't want to have a score of one you always want that score to be higher and minimally you want that score to be above 3.00 there are five indexes um and

141there are key questions throughout the survey that feed these indexes so not only does this give you a little snapshot of where you are it's a good way for folks across the district or in the community that are a little less comfortable with data and statistics to kind understand where you're at um and other districts also use these to build out quantifiable measures of their strategic plan um readymade quantifiable pillars so that that's how districts use these more specifically these indexes are as follows academics we are effective in teaching and supporting our students second engagement I like working at this school because I'm valued heard and can contribute support I have the support I need to help our our students to help educate our students and work as a team and then the benefit of

142staff is they have kind of a dual lens here they can tell you how they're doing and they can tell you their perception of how the kiddos in their room are doing student experience students are accepted respected and supported at school and then likewise for staff are they accepted respected and supported that school your um format of the data here is going to be very similar to how much of the slides moving forward are going to look as well so where were you before where are you now what do that percent change and then among a comparison set of school districts that look like us what is their score and how do we stack up so my eyes here are going to these the the second and third from the right columns where are you

143now and how is that different um some of these are down very negligable negligibly um so you maintained a very steady score down 3 hundredths of a point a decline of about 1% and we are effective in teaching and supporting our students a pretty small decline a decline um but this is also the only index that falls below three all the rest of these are above 3.00 um the next one you're well above three I like working at the school because I'm valued heard and can contribute again pretty steady data down by 100th of a point I have the support I need to help educate our students and work as a team down by approximately 2% down by about 2 and a half% students are accepted respected and supported at school and then a slight

144increase up by 100th of a point how are staff doing are they accepted respected and supported at school um there you're at a score of 3.47 so in summary um four went down one went up four of them are above three and one of them remains below three um and and to varying degrees away from the comparison so your nearest your comparison among your student oops among your student experience students are accepted respected and supported at school the one that's least like your comparison group is the academics bit we are effective in teaching and support our students so we begin from the top then however we're going to go into the item analysis so what about these questions that feed these indexes what's going on with them same scale one to five can't get better

145than a five can't get worse than a one middle of the scale is three these slides are sorted by the survey section and they're uh sorted by this this column second from the right the percent change so the items that went up the most are at the top items that went down the most are at the bottom respectively for each section and then we'll bring this data together and show you went where you went up and down the most across the entire survey at the end um some areas where you went up and actually here you broke four so you're starting to get into the area of the strongly agree range um which is a strong win our staff does a good job of educating our students up by over 3% and approaching your comparison

146group there 4.23 two other items that went up um and another one where you're getting very close to your comparison pool I feel supported by my supervisor or administrator when I make a decision up by 1.3% and just about a tenth of a point away from your comparison average another up by 1% the amount of work I asked to do is reasonable or manageable VAR slate decrease about two10 a of a point away from your comparison I feel comfortable sharing input and concerns with my supervisor or administrator Trader down by just under 1% um 3 hundreds of a point difference rounding out the workday section few declines here um and three that fell below that magic number of 3.00 first one though down by just a little bit once again pretty steady data here most

147days I look forward to going to work down by 4 hundreds of a point and about three t0 of a point away from where your comparison group sits down by just under 2% our school's student discipline practices and policies are effective down by 2% on the dot the district seeks input from a broad group of Staff members down by approximately 2 and a half% information important to my work is shared with me in a timely and effective Manner and down by about two and a half% our staff handle student discipline in a consistent manner the environment section here up by a little over 4% you folks in this room the school board is doing it takes to make our district successful you went from 2.17 to 2.26 So Below three certainly but absolutely going in

148the right direction that was the highest um the item with the most growth year-over-year from this particular survey section staff also feel better recognized I am recognized when I do a good job you remained above three went from 325 to 335 up by a little over 3% and approaching your comparison group just under two tens point away from your other districts down but pretty steady data in the last year I received useful feedback to help improve my work 349 to 346 and then down by 1% on the dot I feel safe at work 399 to 3.95 rounding out the environment section by the way there's three sections total this is the section the second of the three main sections here we do see some slightly bigger declines but beginning at the top both down by

149about 3.6 3.7% respectively I have training and support to work with students from different backgrounds and all students in our school are respected for their values and beliefs down by 4% on the nose I have opportunities for training or PD to help improve my work down by about 7% and these final two items by the way are the only two from this section that fell below 3.00 the district is heading in the right direction and District administration is doing what it takes to make our district successful down by 7.2% and 88.9% respectively the final main survey section was support here large increase the district's pay practices are fair um 2.2 to 2.33 a few other increases here um all of these on these uh on this page here went up um half a percentage Point

150increase both for our school has a process to ensure every student has a connection with at least one adult in school and I have healthy working relationships with my co-workers another one where you're well above the median of 3.00 kind of getting into that strongly agree range once again and then up by 100th of a point I have access to the Technology support that I need and nipping at the heels of your comparison group there as well turning the page in this section to some of the decreases down by 1.6% but remaining above your median staff input is valued at a score of 3.13 down by just under 2% I have the technology I need to do my job well similar decline about 2.2% but a still fairly high score just under four our school

151supports students from diverse backgrounds and then finally a decline of 3.5% I have the materials and supplies I need to do my job well down by a little over 6% but remaining above three all students in our school are given equal opportunities to learn and experience success and then the two biggest declines in this particular particular section the social emotional needs of all students are being met down by about 99.3% and our parents and Community Support the school district um was the item with the most decline across the survey at a decline of 12% on the notes this was part of the support section just a slightly different question so we call it a little bit differently still same scale one to five um but the this particular question focused on the student subgroups that

152may be in my room so the question read our our school supports equal opportunities for students of or with these five groups different economic backgrounds you remained above four so kind of getting into that agree strongly agree range just a slight decline different economic groups basically the same score as where you were last year 4.0 five to 4.04 so very strong there and also by gender 4.15 to 4.13 uh you know in this case it's kind of the the difficulty of getting a versus maintaining an A in comparison these are quite high scores and you can tell that you're just about like everybody else here in terms of how you're performing by gender um and just nipping again once again at the heels of your comparison group for different economic backgrounds outperforming your comparisons uh

153the extent to which the school district of boo is supporting students from different cultural backgrounds also outperforming your comparisons how you support students from different racial backgrounds and then the one student subgroup that went down the most down by about 2.8% um students with special needs went from 3.59 to 3.49 so I recognize that that can be some fire hose drinking that is a lot of numbers you might still be thinking about a number that was four slides ago I I I completely recognize that and I know that this is where de is stepping in and looking at school-based data and all kinds of things and all kinds of spreadsheets that we in and dated her with but from a district level I want to put this back together and I just want to isolate

154what is going best what are the five highest scoring items for the school district of valoy Staff couple notes about these but first what are they the highest scoring item I have healthy working relationships with my co-workers second highest scoring item our staff does a good job of educating our students third was related to technology access fourth I feel safe at work and then the fifth highest scoring item our school supports students from diverse backgrounds now a note about this what I'm really happy about seeing here some of the things that you have to have in place you have in place for instance if I don't get along with my co-workers if I don't feel effectual in my job if I don't feel safe at work and if I don't feel like I'm supporting the

155kiddos in my room it's really difficult to make progress on anything else especially safe at work if I go to school in the morning and I don't feel safe there how could you possibly make progress on anything else in this survey fortunately that's not you some of the places that you have to have some of those hurdles that you have to clear in order to make progress in other areas you have here so it's good that's all items in our survey are created equal just that some are more equal than others things like getting along with each other feeling effectual in your job and feeling safe at work again not to sound like a broken record but you got to have those if you want to make progress in any other area those have to

156be in place so it's good that these are part of your top five scoring items on the other side of that coin what are some of these items that are overall leaning towards disagreement some of those items that fall below 3.00 as you go on the list here fifth from the bottom our parents and Community Support the school district district Administration is doing what it takes to make our district successful pay practices are fair the school board is doing what it takes to make our district successful and then the bottom scoring item the district is heading in the right direction adding some Nuance to that though where did you go up the most relative from last year when you did this survey in fall in fact just as I score just as I scroll between

157these two slides here some of these while they may be lower scoring you are going in the right direction so for instance the district's pay practices are fair I just told you that was third from the bottom I don't want to negate that point however it's also the item that you're making the most progress to so I don't want to you know again negate the point that it's towards the bottom but I do want to celebrate the fact that you're making some pretty outstanding progress on the fact that payer the perception of the pay practice as being fair is a big step forward by the way I tend to celebrate anything that's you know on the four to five to six per growth um it's very very uncommon for us to ever type A a

158double digit here but especially for a district your size I mean to make that amount of change over that many employees and end up at a score of 5.9% that really is a w there I mean you you can make some pretty quick percentage growth when you're one of those districts especially in Far Northern Wisconsin that employ 25 FTE it doesn't take too many to move it a score by quite a bit when you have 5.9% across multiple hundreds of employees that's quite a few that that's quite a bit of growth there otherwise you would never get to 5.9% similarly the school board is doing what it takes to make our district successful yes that is second from the bottom but you're also moving in a direction that is positive and again I don't want

159to negate that um staff does a good job of educating our students one of the top items and getting better Staff feel better recognized and they feel more supported by their superviser or administrator when they make a decision more so than they did last year second La second to last slide where did you go down the most a decline of 6.3% all students in School are given equal opportunities to learn and experience success about 7% the district is heading in the right direction about 9% The District administration is doing what it takes to make our district successful down by about 9% the social and emotional needs of all students are being met and then down by 12% our parents and Community Support the school district the final overall satisfaction number on a scale of 0

160to 10 How likely are you to recommend the district as a place of employment you're seeing a bit of a bell curve here um quite a few neutral in the middle um that's actually I think where your score is going down a little bit um that's longer than it typically is you know your Your Greens your Reds um I wouldn't say those are are vastly different but there's quite a few more folks in this middle range than what I would normally expect to see now I don't know if that's good I don't know if that's bad I don't know if that's indifferent but what that tells me is there's quite a few folks in the middle here who are ready to make up their mind they they they are ripe to make it decision and

161now they're going to go up or they're going to go down so I'm very curious to see where you move um forward in the future because those five people will they tend to sort themselves up either up or down as you move on but altogether you were at 5.19 last year you still remain um on the good side of the neutral there at 5 5.01 your percent change is down by about three and a half percent among your comparison score you're looking at a 7.08 so again I recognize that's a lot that's from the district level um so we kind of started at the indexes overall how were we doing delt into some of those items and then finished up with what's going the best what's going the worst and where have you made the

162most progress or what are some items that decline so I'm gonna take a quick sip of water but by all means let me know what questions you have what didn't make sense what you'd like to revisit from the report thank you Mr Deus are there any board member questions or comments Tom henkins Miss Board member henkins yes Rob um just going back to the beginning how many how many actual uh respondents were we better than last year we were doing this comparison yeah it went down a little bit you were at 448 respondents last year okay and how many possible responses are there in the district for this survey oh let's see if I could do my math whatever 54% of AIS 3 if I could do that live I would uh let me tell

163you without doing the math um you must have sent it out to you know ballpark a little under 800 okay um uh the exact number 724 with the denominator okay so what going back to the first three or four slides and I haven't done that but on the percentages you're talking about the percentages of the responses responses response ease excuse me that's yes sir that's correct yep okay thank you yeah y you back thank you board member Miller thanks um so I really appreciated um Mr deo's your comments about I guess just the matter of perspective so I think some things that jumped out to me were I I had sort of the same takeaway that you that you were articulated when I was looking at the you know what did we what are we

164doing best in like those are some pretty key um I guess like pillars of being able to function as a district so that that that made me feel good when I looked at that I do think though we have to be responsive to the actual commentary from the teachers and from the the people who we surveyed that don't feel like we're going in the right direction despite seeing that slide that that makes me from where I'm sitting in my perspective feel like we kind of are and so um I have some thoughts but I'm kind of curious about your expertise on the matter um the things that jumped mind for me are you know increasing communication internally as a district and making sure we're all C at on like what what we need to look

165at and then I guess the only other things I wanted more information on were um the what is it the um I'm sorry I just like lost my place in my notes but I found it okay sorry with the discipline piece with the policies and practices did you happen in the interest of calibrating communication do you have any more information on whether that's more policy heavy which is like a board thing or more practices heavy and if not that's okay I'm just kind of curious for our purpose is here um yeah a couple things so your first question I'm going to do my best to remember these um oh you said something very smart uh your first question take me back there what was that no yeah it's okay no I didn't mean to just

166like segue really quick into that I just didn't want to forget my other thing um so my first the first thing I was pointing out is like I agree with your kind of takeaway like my initial takeaway When I Was preparing for the meeting was like Hey wow those are important pieces to have in place feels like we're going in the right Direction and then I like went to the next slide and I'm like o people don't feel like we're going the right direction like where you know so I was just curious in your expertise of you know in practice you do this all the time right um one thing they came to mind for me is increasing internal communication calibrating what else do districts do when they see results like that yes sorry H

167thank you so I I what I'm saying this is this is funny in a not funny way but we worked with the district who did some staff and parent surveys and they really got knocked on their communication and I think I just about gave the superintendent an aneurism and he was like oh my God I I write so many like I'm how can that possibly be and he was right actually they did so much communication what we found out is everything in there people didn't care like it wasn't what I wanted to read about like you were talking to me all the time it just wasn't interesting it wasn't relevant to me it came a little too late like it was everything in the communication not how I was getting the communication so when we

168did that survey the next year we said okay we'll still ask you how you want it most app want emails but there you know there's some I think when we get inundated with too much technology I I pay more attention to something that's on my counter these days than I do in my inbox because I'm my inbox presses me out we're seeing a big move towards something that's tangible in my hand which this District was doing too but then they added a question that said okay when we talk to you what is it you want to know about do you want to know about our financial plans do you want to know about you know staff achievements do you want to know about student achievements do you want to know how facility work is going

169so they they teered those and then their score went up and it had nothing to do with timeliness it had nothing to to do with when it went out it had nothing to do with how it was all about what was in there so they they that was I hadn't thought much about that but that was so I guess I'm curious in your case is it a is it a how or a what um for your second question about discipline um what actually pleased me quite a bit um so when I go to the lowest scoring items um if this pleased me in a good way I can't tell you the last time I gave a report and didn't have discipline be one of the in the bottom I mean it doesn't matter which one

170of the 14,200 some districts are in the United States we work Nationwide and I can't tell you the last time especially following right around March 14th 2020 that that was not at the bottom so it's good for you that you're not there um so whatever the secret is there's a lot of people that want to know what what Boyd's doing but I think more direct answer to your question um the two discipline questions are here they were in the workday section so one second here and one's at the bottom what this is telling me is staff to staff we more consistent like I'm doing what the next teachers doing which is which is good that's a good place to be however what we're applying consistently doesn't work for what I needed to do so it's

171not what you know not that the policies can't be improved but if everybody's doing the same thing but that's an ineffectual thing it's not going to make me go up very much so that's one thing the other part I would say though one of the items that declin the most and this is like I mean the the correlation coefficient here is like 1.0 um where did that go right here the social emotional needs of all students are being met that and the two discipline questions they will go hand inand when students feel more supported social emotionally everything else goes up along with it so couple of points there it's not so much I guess the consistency it's the policies and it has everything to do with how you can support social and emotional students but

172once again I don't know if this makes you feel better but you're I don't know if you're a good company but you're in large company with that being towards the bot something that's going on here thank you so much I really appreciate it you board member Ley thank you um do school perceptions provide recommendations with some record of success related to survey data for boards that want to set District goals or to incorporate this into strategic plans like this is amazing data do you have recommendations for how we improve the experience for our students in staff based on the data that's been collected we do yeah so my role tonight is to give you the data but let you digest it a little bit and then my colleague Derek gotle um he actually we just

173poached him away from being an education Professor that's kind of his world like okay you got this data now we'll work with you to figure out what it is you want to prioritize or an understanding like you know in this area you're going to get the most bang for your buck and also here are some things you can do here are some resources and also I think one of the biggest things we've taken a step forward with in the last couple of years years is you know we're kind of a mile wide and an inch deep and so we see some districts that are really rocking it and we're like great you know on to the next what we can do better and what we've tried to do better over the last year is saying

174you know you know who's really doing this well Glendale River Hills or Medford or you know whatever go talk to them and and because we're all under the same funding structure everybody you know much like I heard the discussion before everybody's you know under the under the realm of operational referendum there's a lot to be learned here from districts that are doing really well what's their secret how how come their communication is so good why is their discipline so good so long story short my colleague Derrick will do that he'll work with you to figure out what it is you want to prioritize what those resources can be from both an academic and practitioner perspective and then third what are some other districts in Wisconsin in our region that are really rocking it that you

175can beg borrow and steal from thank you so much and I don't know if this is on your radar or not but I would love to attend a school perceptions Workshop maybe at the next wasby conference um and and learn some of this like what are the trends across the state and what are some things we can all be doing better thank you so much yeah bet could pick this year so I'll put you down as a reference and maybe that'll help next year any other board member questions or comments thank you Mr deuse Dr gar sir so thank thank you Mr deuse thank you Mr Didi for the U presentation uh one of the things things that I want to let you let you all know is naturally this is the you know first

176step just like an audit Auto as it pertains to what we um share with the board the next steps will be of course I'll meet with the paa we'll have some conversations around this um as well from there of course we'll look at some opportunities in which we can kind of grow um naturally there are some things in the presentation that we want to see um better in um we'll probably bring that back to the administrative team there's an administrative meeting that as an example even next week the goal is of course is to keep getting better in this space and um hopefully that these scores will continue to uh reflect what we all want to see here in our school district so I just want to make sure I noted that those are some

177of the immediate next steps that we will see in this conversation thank you thank you Dr Garrison Mrs alander and Mr deuse for this information um before we move on to the next item we are approaching the 8:00 hour um so we don't have to interrupt our next um session our next presenters um can I get a motion to extend the meeting by 30 minutes to 8:30 please so moved motion by Brian Nicholls is there a second second second by Greg Schneider any discussion hearing none all in favor I I I I I any oppose motion carries unanimously thank you our next item is the district self-insured insurance plan uh Mrs alander is presenting this with Seth frisbee the employee benefit specialist from TriCore insurance and the purpose of this item is for information only

178thank you and so thank you so much Mrs Johnson I just want to make sure I jumped in real quick um this has been a conversation that's been for about 2 years with us uh here in the school district of as it pertains to our health plan uh one of the things that we want to make sure is to have these conversation as it pertains to the difference between self-insured versus fully insured looking at our numbers um this was a conversation that also came up not just in internal conversations but also at the ad hoc level as well as the board I'm having conversations around our insurance plans we know that we did make some changes to our insurance plans and so we wanted to make sure that we captured some of this conversation as

179we are moving forward into the next school year and then now I'll turn over to Mrs mad I just want to give that General overview thank you very much and I would like to call up uh Miss Cindy mckillips who is a member of my team that is very instrumental and administering and managing all things benefits um she's the person who quietly does everything and we don't even know she's there sometimes but um I want to acknowledge and thank her for all the work that she does and without further Ado Mr Seth Frisby thank you thank you so much for having me this evening and for extending our time out so I'll try not to take up the full 30 minutes um wanted to get together today 20 minutes so uh wanted to get together

180today really the uh overview that we have put together we reviewed with Dr Garrison a couple weeks ago and it was really to illustrate the key differences between a fully insured Health Plan and a self-insured plan that the district has had now for decades um this is something that myself my team and the team behind me here with the district look at on an annual basis and re-evaluate along with every aspect of the health plan so with the presentation uh we really wanted to get into uh the weeds a little bit with where the district ran from benchmarking data with other districts in the state of Wisconsin um look at the fully insured environments updates that can be made due to being fully insured as a possibility the self-insured environment will currently operate in options

181that are available from there and then the trends that we're seeing with the current plan year and something that we'll continue to evaluate as we kind of work up until the 91 renewal cycle and going out to Market so okay so the first slide that we'll touch on is just the Benchmark data um and just really to summarize uh the data here the district overall is falling right in the middle of uh a lot of districts in the state of Wisconsin uh the bracketed on top represents the single plan data that is submitted to the Wisconsin Department of administration uh the bracket on the bottom represents the family plan data that's submitted um started a few years ago where districts self-report this data and it's collected and searchable on a public website um we carve

182the data into a couple different data sets uh the self-funded um on the very top for 2024's plan year for all the districts that choose to self fund uh the fully insured districts just under that and then we did break into South Central Wisconsin some of the smaller midsize districts in our area and then uh a more comparable large District sorry am I getting too close to the so um were you talking to me no no there's just feedback so uh along with a comparable large District in our immediate area that uh a few years ago made the decision to move from a self-insured environment to a fully insured environment okay and then we have our school district of bloy uh references down for the 2024 plan year at the very bottom of each section

183and the current plan year of 2025 down there below so just some obs obervations here if you look at the total monthly premium and again premium is a little bit of a differentiation between um what it's representing when you're fully insured and self-insured when you're fully insured it is truly the premium that you're paying on a monthly basis into a carrier when you're self-insured like the district is we have an independent actuary that puts that information together and it's more considered what's called a funding rate the funding rate is what's used to work with the payroll deductions um and evaluate what is going to be the basis of the payroll deductions for what the employees are going to pay what the district's going to fund from a month-to-month basis it into the claims pool okay

184so really when you look at the data to the Statewide data in the top two categories uh the district from a premium standpoint Falls right in the middle of both the self-insured outperforming those from a cost standpoint um slight above the fully insured districts um if you go over to the right right in the middle of the employer contribution percentage you'll notice one item that the district uh outperforms everyone I guess in a positive way from an employee standpoint is the overall contribution level that the employees are currently paying towards their monthly premium is far less than most districts in the state of Wisconsin that are now sitting at the you know 88% maximum 12% contribution rate R um our plan that we have with the district is a HSA High deductible plan and like

185many districts that have that we do make contributions to that HSA account two years ago we did update that to minimize that and save on some fixed cost um we also lowered the deductible to accommodate for that uh you'll see again just that the district as far as the contributions of $500 for an individual and $1,000 for a family is right in line of being more competitive when you compare that to other self-insured uh organizations and uh Falls slightly short when you're looking at fully insured now the reason for that lies in the plan design details to the right uh you'll see our deductible is far lower for a single individual and for family along with the max amount of pocket is far lower than what you see with our fully insured organizations in around

186the state uh self-insured has taken a very similar path um that we have at the district here of having a deductible that really is sitting at what the uh lowest deductible allowed under IRS rule would allow which would be the current plan year of, 1600 for an individual 3,200 for a family in a non-embedded deductible environment any questions there all right so we'll get into uh fully insured and again fully insured is something we look at continuously on an annual basis uh so again just to paint a picture of exactly what a fully insured environment it is is really you're purchasing health insurance right you're purchasing a contract a carrier is agreeing to take on the medical risk of your employee population for the 12-month period you're going to pay a premium to them to

187do that right so with fully insured there's advantages and drawbacks as with each plan set up uh really the advantages of the fully insured environment is fixed cost premium so premium that is build on a monthly basis based on the membership for that month uh simplified invoicing reduced Administration effort there's just less to manage and more of a kind of set it and forget it mentality so once you go through renewal you go through open enrollment the rates are Set uh really don't touch it until the renewal cycle starts again the following year some of the drawbacks with fully insured is just overall lack of control again uh you're paying a carrier for their services uh they don't give you much control back uh reduced ability to really proactively address high cost areas showing in

188the data for the health plan um if there is profitability with the plan meaning that the claims came in lower than the funding rate was set up for and things like prescription rebates come into play those are all going back to the carrier's profit those aren't coming coming back to the district as they would today okay um and then HMO carriers that are pretty prevalent in our area represent just a smaller overall Network options than a lot of our self-insured plans would offer um tighter Windows less providers overall so last year's data we included in the presentation uh so when we looked at fully insured plans for the district it really boiled down to not surprising three of our regional HMO carriers uh Dean Health Plan Mercy Care as well as Court's health insurance um

189the two that were the predominant ones that uh we were strongly considering was a dual option offering as a lot of districts do with both Dean Health Plan and Mercy Care um allowing each employee to choose which option they would like to move forward with usually BAS based on price and availability of in network providers so Dean Health Plan was going to be the core of that uh had agreed to be a dual option with Mercy Care uh their HMO Network in our local area includes Bloyd health and SSM facilities in general uh you will see there is a second category of uh cost laid out there for the PO Network so obviously we do have District employees that live outside of the HMO Network area they would be offered a PP Network or a

190national network that would give them providers in network closer to where they live because these carriers do not control that Network and have to rent that Network it's usually a third party uh you'll see the premium are higher for individuals that have to elect that plan or be offered that plan okay the next was Mercy Care Health insurance so again this was going to be offered in conjunction as an option with Dean Health Plan uh Mercy would must be their HMO Network and for all intents and purposes Mercy's network is Mercy Care um is Mercy Health um there is not a p option needed um but you'll see the annual premium uh slightly elevated vers where we were at with Dean Health Plan and then the third option that did come to the table was

191courts health insurance uh courts was in the mix from a pricing perspective when you compare it to Mercy Health it's plan with Mercy Care however courts is uh currently unwilling to be a dual option candidate uh meaning that they were unable to work with Mercy uh they wanted the district as a whole um courts has a very large Network that includes UW both in the Rockford Market Madison Market Bloyd Health System here their issue with their Network right now which will be resolved in the next year is that they don't have a provider in network in the city of Jamesville so any District employees that live north of blit in and around jville area would not have a a network provider in their City they'd have to travel either south or north to Madison to

192render services so um this was the reason we chose not to move forward with Courts for further consideration any questions there board member henkins yes thank you very much for this um I would imagine our history generates a the premium I mean it goes into any insurance rate goes by history and our our history of using insurance or needing insurance and you know you go back to workman's comp and we got dropped and um that all plays into our premium rate what is what is the number that just explain is what I'm saying kind of true is that true uh in a fully insured environment yes uh rarely does a fully insured health plan have a negative renewal right so it is this ever increasing insurance policy as the medical risk continues to grow over

193time a cost increase over time in medical Trend which is you know in in a vacuum the minimum increase that's going to be seen for the same level of claims from a year prior to a year now roughly is about 9% on a year-to-year basis is the blit School District in a higher bracket comparatively when you look around uh again every employer group is a little bit different presents its own medical risk um so you know if you had a high cost cancer claim it or therapy claim it that another group doesn't have it's not always like an apple stapples comparison because every underwriting risk is going to be different from a group to group standpoint okay thank you board member Levy thank you um two questions the first is it's my understanding that one

194of the benefits of using a self-funded insurance plan is a positive impact on cash flow um so if you could briefly explain like how that is realized and two has that been the experience in our district and then I have one other question sure do you mind if I jump down a couple slides uh we have data just to get to do you want the other question then I can just hold the first one okay perfect um what is the timeline in in the kind of the timeline and the length of time it would take for our district I if down the road we thought this would be a better fit to transition from self-funded to fully funded is that you you can just adjust to the next open enrollment cycle or is that something

195that takes longer yep uh thank you a common question so uh the transition to fully insured uh can be immediate uh there's a tail that occurs to kind of close out the self-insured plan we'll touch on that with some of the data later as well uh the common question is well can we go back to self-insured if we miss it and the answer is yes you can flip back um however what happens is one of the advantage of a self-insured program is all the Cost Containment strategies that go into it and additional programs that yield savings those take usually two to three years to really get up and running so you kind of lose that momentum there's a great reset there and then you're kind of starting from Ground Zero again and building that over

196time so thank you you're welcome so getting into the self-insured environment a very different mentality overall um I always label this as you're purchasing health care at this point right so no longer are you paying an insurance company to assume your risk for the next 12 months you as a district assume the risk and pay the claims as they're adjudicated or as they occur throughout the year so currently uh there's three main Partners uh that we uh have selected to run and assist the district with running their self-insured program uh the most important is your TPA or the third party administrator uh so that's historically been PR States Enterprises for about the past 13 years um they worked with the district in a little different capacity that I know Cindy would remember uh where they

197were just dealing with high climats before that um but TP uh they've been the TPA partner for a number of years and really the TPA partner for all intents of purposes is the insurance company they're the one that the members are going to call if they have questions they adjudicate the claims they produce the explanation of benefits um they do all the medical management side of things so they're kind of the Hub of your plan uh next would be the pharmacy benefit administrator or Pharmacy benefit manager uh this again is the pharmacy side of the benefit they go out uh negotiate all the pricing and rebates with your drug manufacture facturers put together what's called a formulary which is basically a list of covered medications for your plan and how they're going to be covered

198underneath the plan and then your medical Network which our medical Network historically has been the alliance Trilogy Network again another uh powerful value add to our our current plan is just the availability of in network providers the alliance Trilogy regionally based out of Madison and Milwaukee really matches blue crosses Network in our area very inclusive really between Rockford over to Madison and then over to Milwaukee in that zone okay this next slide really illustrates the key difference to uh Mrs Levy's question between the fully insured environment and the self-insured environment so on the left is our fully insured environment um and really 100% of your cost are premium right you are paying a carrier for their service right and their Assumption of risk on the right you'll see you still have some premium with our

199current plan and that would be the stoploss insurance we'll touch on that in a minute uh you see a very small amount of costs going towards your fixed cost to pay for the TPA your network your PBM services and then in green the majority of your cost come as far as the claims cost okay so with the majority of the cost coming in for the form of claims cost again you are not paying that expense unless it's a expense for the district unless someone walks into a physician's office and renders that service right so to Mrs Levy's question on cash flow the money stays in the district's pocket longer and potentially forever if that money is not spent okay so some of the advantages of a self-insured plan really again are the Opposites of what

200we touched on with fully insured uh increased control and flexibility ability to offset cost with other Bolton programs using the data that's provided to you to react to that and not necessarily have to wait till renewal to do that uh rebates are coming to you from the prescription program um some of the drawbacks are just active management it does take a lot more work on the administration team to manage this program throughout the year um we get together at least quarterly to do claim review meetings we're constantly talking having conversations on other programs and how we can further Implement these programs to cost contain the current claims that are rendering through the plan I mentioned stop loss Insurance a little bit earlier so even though the district is self-insured you do purchase what's called a

201fully insured stoploss coverage over top which works decapitate the overall risk so there is three layers that we currently have in place just to give you a little insight into the reinsurance uh the first is our specific stoploss so this is the most utilized area of stop loss it is a value that's placed over each member that is on the health plan so that member cannot supersede in our case $275,000 worth of claims in a given plan year okay the next is an aging specific deductible so once members or if members start to accumulate claims that go over that $275,000 Mark the overages go to satisfy the separate group deductible of$ 115,000 000 the reason why um this has been in place for a number of years a lot of our groups have elected to

202add this to their contract it is optional is it's a dollar Ford dooll trade-off with premium so if we took this out of the current stop-loss contract the premium and the fixed cost that the district would pay for their stoploss contract would increase by $15,000 so we always cherish the ability to keep the dollar in our client's pocket the longest just in case it doesn't get spent right instead of paying for it on the front end so that's where the AG guar specific comes in and then the overall uh aggregate stop loss is your ultimate protection essentially in a very very high claim year where you have a lot of high claim it's a lot of people hitting that spec deductible this capitates the overall risk of the plan now it this is done in

203two ways so the aggregate stop loss uh is factored in on the claims that they expect and then where the plan will fully reimburse the district back for claims up and above that amount so for the current year uh when they issued the renewal September 1st the carrier estimated that claims would be roughly about 2 12.8 million um they set the maximum claim Threshold at 16 million and the way they get to that number is called a corridor they basically take your expected claims added an additional 25% to that and that's what that threshold is okay so looking at the data of really where we've been with our current plan we always need with a self-funded plan to look at kind of a rolling five-year Trend because there's higher peaks in valys to Mrs Levy's

204question on cash flow throughout the year so with this if we look back dating back to nine or September of 2020 um through the August 21 plan year we have our claims that were paid out um medical and Pharmacy are fixed cost TPA fees Network fees and stop-loss premium and then we do have reimbursements right so we get reimbursements back from that stoploss contract throughout the year so the credits that you see stop- loss reimbursements there along with your prescription rebates that have been realized each year so on the far right in green your total cost is the true net cost that the district has had for the health plan over the course of the past 5 years so dating back to 2020 you'll see that's 12.4 million uh the next year it was up

20512 1.5% uh the following year we went backwards 13 1.5% so a net 1 and a half% increase there um last year was a uh higher claim year overall so we were up 24.9% uh however this year through the first four months of the plan Year we're trending down 177% um now I called DD today we did get the numbers in for January and this morning um January for was a very low claim month for paid claims as well so if you factored in the January claims the actual Trend year-over-year through five full months is actually 39% lower than we were at last year so again that cash flow that's roughly $1 1.9 million which not has not been spent on the plan that was spent on the plan last year at the same time

206frame okay so our average increase with the plan over that 5year period is roughly 2.6% okay which is far lower than General Medical Trend would support so if we bring the two sides together and this is what we do on an annual basis during renewal we're really looking at uh if we move fully insured what's that future going to look like compared to if we stay self-insured um not knowing exactly how the enrollment would sift out during open enrollment we modeled out both and mercy with 100% of enrollment in each um the first year um and again M Levy's question on the runout that occurs um with the self-funded plan you'll see on that first year we have 2394 million that is the average run out that would have occurred over the past five years

207along with the TPA fees that the district would have to pay the TPA for staying around for the first six months of that plan year to adjudicate those runout claims okay so in yellow that's really your transition year um again if you look solely at Dean there's some savings on the table there if you look at Mercy Care it would actually be more expensive that first year of transition to transition to a fully insured plan because of those runout fees okay second year uh both plan options provide some level of savings if you merge the two together though um under a million okay however by year 2 three and four you'll see that starts to dissipate and again solely looking at Dean alone there may be savings on the table through year four but by

208year five that plan would exponentially be more expensive um dual optioning with Mercy Care you can see Mercy Care essentially with their rates from last year would have offered about a year worth of savings before those plans would have been higher than our Trend would have been now the increases that are built into this performa uh is 10% for the first two years for fully insured we had a 2-year rate cap not to exceed um offered by both carriers so they would uh cap the district's renewal the first two renewal Cycles at 10% um from there uh trying to be as conservative as possible year 345 we estimated that at 12% um we that's a very conservative increase uh if you remember the benchmarking Data before the District of size recently just had an 18%

209increase for one carrier and a 21% increase for the other carrier um over on the self-insured side uh the first two years we labeled that a 3% Trend to match our current Trend and then increased that to 5% for year three four five again just trying to be as conservative with our estimates as possible Cost Containment programs that we do have in place that are slowly taking in effect as the plan year goes on uh we've got two really running now uh an alternate prescription sourcing program and then a program that works with some of the highest claimants on the plan obviously if you're a high claimant dealing with a lot of medical issues you're paying a lot out of pocket so they look for alternate options for you to uh receive your coverage through

210charitable orations or other sources um the great thing is we do have one participant that is uh taken advant anage of that um the cost backs to the district at the bottom there you see is 120,000 uh that claim it produced $480,000 worth of claims last year so our net savings for the plan is 360,000 for the upcoming year um in addition to that up above the Prescription Savings Program uh we are expecting another $215,000 worth of savings to that we altered the plan design last year to help enhance that so our net additional savings for these Cost Containment programs that we can put into a self-insured environment uh we're expecting another 575,000 which again is leading into that Trend that we're seeing with the claims th far for the year okay so I know

211that was a lot and I went over I apologize so um any questions overall any board member questions Mrs Le or board member Levy thank you um just a quick one do you see districts that are self-insured um couple that decision with some sort sort of like Healthy Living incentives um my memory with the district is long enough when I was an employee here you could connect to a program with your Fitbit or your Apple watch or whatever and you could earn money or gift cards or things for individual challenges or group challenges um and have you seen those that coupling of that program um have a positive impact financially for districts that do that uh we still have our program in place today uh Wellness programs are great option to enhance employees experience with

212Wellness as a personal goal um their interaction with the health plan itself unfortunately because cost of extreme care has gotten so high cancers medication Wellness programs effect on cost has been minimized over time and so again it's a great option to have it really helps support people that have those healthy habits or to get back to healthy habits um it just does and create that total cost mitigation that we used to see long ago so thank you you're welcome board member Anderson yeah so thank you Mr Frisbee I think I had a bunch of things written down and as you went through you kind of answered a lot of them so I don't have to ask them so good job um so I guess I'll get to I think what I'm hearing is you know

213insurance at its core is made to spread risk right and so I think a district this size um that gives us the ability to spread that risk enough to justify the self funding and it sounds like you have the ability to do to pull a lot more levers under a self funed plan to help us keep our costs down than you would had we if we choose a a fully insured plan is that accurate correct yeah and again it's all medical risk right so as long as the medical risk stays manageable but to your point the levers are there The Cost Containment programs are there when you move to a fully insured environment you lose that a little bit right so you get your two or three year not to exceed rate caps once those

214comes off you're kind of on a roller coaster ride of whatever your claims experience is for that carrier um so again when you see District seeing 18 to 21% increases there's really nothing you can do about that there's no other programs you could in place because you're working in the ecosystem of that carrier okay thanks yes any other board member questions or comments Mr board member henkins yes thank you Mr Frisbee um this is new to me but the stop loss I mean I'm what I I think I'm hearing that like in a catastrophic thing and I know there's a cap on it but the district pays it and then we get reimbursed back correct correct okay I just want to share a comment real quick um Mr Frisbee was talking a little bit about

215what we're running 25 is% below last year's claims so in our budget model going back to the referendum in the budget forecast we're using a 10% increase in claims there so if that holds true throughout the remainder of the year you know that 10% can likely become less and provide some Financial relief to the district reduce the budget deficit Etc so just kind of mental note there for you as well thank you Bob thank you Seth unless there are any other questions from the board thank you so much for coming out tonight and providing this invaluable information I appreciate all you do thank you all thank you Mr pisy thank you Mrs alander it is 829 so I will entertain another extension of the meeting to go to 9:00 so move second motion by Megan

216Miller seconded by Brian Nichols any discussion seeing and hearing none all in favor I I I I I I any oppos motion our next item is the board pay discussion the purpose of this is to uh discuss the change in board compensation the background on this is the Board of Education policy committee and Board of Education discussed revisions to its compensation and expenses expenses policy policy number 164 in December of 2018 at that time the current policy indicated a rate of $187.50 per meeting with compens ation not to exceed $375 additionally board members received another $1100 per month for travel and general expenses the revisions to the policy at that time included raising the compensation per meeting to $225 per meeting for a total not to exceed the amount of $450 and removing the extra

217$0000 per month for travel and general purposes there were also other revisions proposed these revisions were sent to the full board in January 2019 and the motion to approve failed on March 26 2019 the final approval stated that board members are compensated $450 per month for board service and general purpose and general expenses total no longer two separate amounts to the best of the current administration's knowledge the administration at that time did not share this policy change information with the then payroll coordinator in order to make the change to the Skyward system some further background information prior to this change in the board compensation in 2019 all board members received $475 per month it appears there was a lapse in communication between the then superintendent and the administrator who would have executed that change the

218policy that was adopted is the current policy 164 which reads Board of Education members are compensated $450 per month for board service and general expenses board members may also request reimbursement for loss wages incurred while performing board duties reimbursement will be limit limited to actual lost wages or $200 per day whichever is less the maximum number of days for which a member could seek reimbursement at any one time is kept at 3 days per month board member attendance at meetings is one of the most important duties a board member of a board member and is critical to the success of the board each board member is expected to attend meetings board members will have occasional situations that prohibit meeting attendance and in such cases shall notify the board president and superintendent that they are unable

219to attend a meeting accommodations will be made for electronic participation in a meeting if requested by a board member roll call will be taken at each meeting a member participating electronically will be counted as present board member attendance will be documented by the board secretary and available to the public on board docs and under Board of Education on the district's website board attendance will be included in the annual board self- evaluation compensation increases a associated with this policy shall take effect in April following the approval of that policy revision a board member may elect to wave their compensation in whole or in part so that's the current policy that was changed back in 2019 on December 23rd Mr chady sent us board members an email email detailing this oversight and it states given that there

220are four months remaining January to April in the current board members term I intend to have payroll adjust future board member compensation payments to $400 a month $1600 remaining divided by four months yet to pay for the previously noted months making the above mentioned adjustments for the remaining four months of the current Schoolboard term will ensure that no school board member would be compensated more than the permitted more than permitted by policy on an annual basis school board member compensation will then be adjusted to $450 a month beginning May 2025 to align with current board policy I did not receive a phone call regarding this error or the email being sent on December 23rd I did not actually see the communication until after the holiday when I read it I immediately called Dr Garrison to

221inform him this was not in accordance with actual current policy 164 which makes no reference to the board's annual payments only monthly payments Dr Garrison informed me that it was too late to make changes as dictated by policy for the month of January we agreed the change would would follow board polic we agreed the change would follow board policy would take place as soon as possible and that the matter on how to proceed would be decided by the board since the posting to tonight's agenda I have received some phone calls from constituents regarding this matter one concern is that board members should have seen this error I would like to explain to the public that we board members do do not receive a paper or an electronic pay statement pay check statement or pay stub

222this would have to be accessed through Skyward to my knowledge board members have not received instruction on how to access the Skyward account as for receiving information on 1099 yes board members do receive an annual 1099 statement however many people use an accountant to use or a tax processor to file their taxes my point is it was not just this current set of board members who did not notice this error it has been quite a few years of various board members not noticing this overpayment the board does not administer the policies the board sets the policy it is only with board action that any policy can be changed for this reason it is on tonight's agenda as a discussion action item for this situation the board should decide how to correct the administrative errors regarding

223policy 164 it is my hope that we can come to a decision on how we want to make any corrective actions in as Fair a manner as possible and for us to work in unity rectifying the situation at this point I will um open the um floor for board questions or comments Mrs Levy uh thank you board President Johnson I think you beautifully laid out the situation here is my concern I think it's wholly appropriate for the administration to point out discrepancies I think it is wholly inappropriate for the administration to decide how the discrepancy should be remedied um and and I a fan of fairness and consistency and so when I look at us my position on it is how would I handle this if this was a district employee and what I would

224do is once the oversight has come to our um to our notice then you correct it from that point moving forward um but to adjust pay to kind kind of offset with the remaining 4 months um would not be my way to go once you acknowledge it you set it to the 450 moving forward but again if we're just going and final point if there is a discrepancy between policy and practice then the board decides what changes is it the policy or is it the practice because if we're just identifying where we are outside of policy and just making those adjustments without that going through the board then somebody should make a deposit to the fund balance to get us at 14% of our budget because that's in policy um so we need to be

225consistent in how we handle things and I I am concerned that the decision was made before the board had an opportunity to have this conversation so I'm glad it's on the agenda thank you thank you Mrs Levy any other board members have qu uh board member henkins I'm kind of confused because you know that we did get the email and I I thought we'd all talk about it but I did notice when I you know call I called the bank the tele Bank thing and my my pay was considerably less than normal and it was like it was already enacted I'm just wondering where that authorization came from if we're now talking about it to do it so something was done already so you're referring to your January pay that is correct yes yes and

226as I had mentioned um when I read the email I contacted Dr Garrison by that time that late date in December it the changes to the January payments had already been made and it was too late to unchange them so again who made those changes without board approval I answer that question so when we found out this was a concern you know two things happened one we when we found out so let me just put it on the table whenever whenever there's errors in our funding I've always tried to of course bring that to the to the board and have that discussion okay and so I do note that this is this is a concern from the board from both Mrs Levy and now of course um well I'm hearing you um have that same

227concern U Mr hankin sorry um one of the things that I want to note is that an absence when we have to follow policy and so what what I was attempting to do and Mr Tay was was to follow policy and not run into the conversation around overpayments and knowing that we was going to have to bring this back to the board for discussion um of course that was my discussion with um Mrs um Mrs um Johnson in general and and that and hopes that we can have this discussion now again I know from the board perspective that you know you all believe that we probably should have came here but again the policy states what the policy states and I was trying to alleviate the administration and not following policy um and that's something

228that um where that's kind of where we made that decision now of course Mr chady did have this conversation uh with me after um I wanted to make sure that we had the the right information so I did want to do some digging around what happened and so that's why you see both the background information and of course a lot of the information that Mrs Johnson was able to share as well so I wanted to make sure we went back and looked at kind of where this where did this start where did this happen how did this happened how how long it's been going on and once I realized it's been going on for almost 7 years say 2018 19 six years um that was also very concerning because it's been quite some time that

229this has been an error in our offices un Bean both Mr chady and myself until we found out uh uh vice president Nichols thank you uh well board board President Johnson you did a beautiful job of setting the stage and and board member Le you I you you did a great job of of uh expressing your opinions and and facts and and I you know this is I mean this is just you know I don't again I don't know how it happened but we can't change it can't change the past it happened um but as far as I'm concerned um we were paid money that we didn't deserve everybody all the way back to whenever it started we were paid money that we didn't we weren't we weren't um wasn't it wasn't for us so

230I'm of the opinion that we should uh repay the money all the way this current board should pay the money all the way all the way back to the started their of their terms and as far as beyond that I think that's a whole another legal issue that we would have to get probably legal involved but um I think in the interest of transparency for the public we need to we need to show them that we're you know we're we're taking everything seriously so and uh that's my opinion thank you vice president Nicholls um board member Megan Miller thanks um yeah I'm I'm curious still to hear the thoughts of my colleagues and I'll probably just yield to the will of the board I mean I guess I just wanted to take the opportunity to

231point out that this is why stability of leadership is important and if you you know board President Johnson did a nice job setting all this up for us I just want to go back to the posting background and it talks about how all of this occurred during one of many term superintendent terms um in the 1819 school year and I just while this is like a Thor anything that we're working through I just like I really appreciate that our Administration is like trying to get on top of this I appreciate that we're collaborating as a board and an Administration to resolve this and I just think that the stability of leadership and Clarity of communication um that's currently happening going forward is just key so things like this don't happen so we can be more

232transparent inent and more responsible Etc so curious to hear more thoughts thanks thank you board member Miller board member Anderson yeah thanks so I guess when I when I saw the email I'm like okay that's seems like a minor thing I love the common sense approach by Bob to say well let's just if we do this we can kind of make it right so I I I understand the approach but board member Levy makes a great point that we need that repetitive process of following policy and let's do it the right way um and to board member Nicholls point I think you know I think we can control and and Claw back the current board going back to when the seven of us started which is only going back to last April right and then

233the rest of it could be a legal thing because you know not everybody was on the board going back past the last term so like from a policy standpoint we could say let's adjust the amounts for February March and April to whatever amount would make it right for the this fiscal you know from from this not term because it's a three-year term but for this last year and then the rest um you know we decide how you know you could make a make an ask to everybody but I think um you know if you did that for this year I'd be I would support you know the kind of approach that that Bob was trying to get to of making it right for for this year going back to last April thank you board member

234henkins oh yes I agree wholeheartedly with the the comments of the seven board members that's the only ones we can control and I think uh absolutely repaying the district the money that we are overpaid is makes it's the right thing to do um so I'm all I'm all in favor of something that we set up through payroll that you know and I I go I agree let's go back to April when I was elected and uh Tia was elected also and start there and just control these seven I mean the other thing is a wild animal and I don't you know again you talk about legal I think it's going to get ugly but uh you know we're talking some bigger dollars that uh you know it's nobody's fault I'm not I don't think this

235is a blame game thing it's just how do we make it right so I appreciate the off I think my nod is to readjust our pay from now until uh April when our term expires or this this board ends and try to get give that money back thank you thank you board member henkins um board board member uh Greg Schneider you're the only board member who has not weighed in do you have any thoughts that you'd like to share I mean I have no concerns about going back to April and making it correct for this time um I just think you know in business if the company makes a mistake and overpays they don't always go back after the employee and say okay pay back everything that you received um especially if we weren't aware

236of what that difference was so I mean to go back Beyond earlier than that just doesn't make sense um since most things on the board go from from election time to election time you know from May to the end of April um it would make sense to go back and do the compensation from that point thank you you board member Schneider any other questions Mr henkins or board member henkins yeah just to go with what Mr Schneider said that we're in a different situation we're not the private sector we're we're dealing with taxpayer dollars it's uh it's their money and uh it's not a company's money so it really it reinforces the idea of making it right thank you and thank thank you for all board members for sharing your oh miss uh board member

237Levy thank you um just to reiterate I don't have a problem with making the adjustment for this year so it is what it should be what my problem is is that Authority does not lie with the administration so my problem is not what happened but the way it happened and Dr Garrison you responded but the question wasn't answered like why did the administration feel that you had the authority to make that decision instead of having this conversation with the board and again if if we're just strictly following policy which I'm a fan of who's making the deposit to the fund balance because we're out of compliance with policy with that percentage thank you board member Levy I appreciate all of us uh board members weighing in on this um it's as as I mentioned it's

238not so much the dollar amount because $25 a month I don't think is going to make or break any board member it's um um the process and um the the need for transparency um you know I I am disappointed as board president how this was handled we we do have a policy that um is an absence of policy where um the superintendent does have some authority to take action um however that those actions need to be in consultation with the board president again I received the same email um everybody else here did um so what I would like to see here tonight again all of us working in unity and um trying to um support our superintendent our cabinet in making this right and figuring out okay we have found a mistake an error in

239our system how can we all work together to make this better so that we don't have these types of mistakes again it is very unfortunate that this is occurring or this has occurred at this moment moment when we are also asking our taxpayers for more money um and when I think about I sat down I calculated out about how much I would have to to pay back it's not a lot but to a teacher that extra few hundred would mean a lot if that could go to classroom supplies it it it you know so we are at the point in our uh financial crisis every penny counts so even though it's 25 isn't a lot to us it is a lot to some people Dr Garrison you know I I agree with what the board

240is saying um you know the board's responsibility is to you know work through policymaking and it is our job as administrators to administer the policy as well um my to answer Mrs ley's question that is the direction that I took um and if wasn't to you know you know put us in a in a space where we weren't going to be in agreement but it was in a space where I believe that we had to you know of course follow policy um and administer that policy now with that being stated I know there's thoughts about going back and doing back pay and I'm I'm as a administrator I got to be honest with you all I kind of side with Mr Mr Schnider um it was not you all's fault this board's fault and and

241even previous board's fault you know this was an Administration thing that happened back in 2018 and I don't think anyone on sitting on this board was here then at that time and so that's that's so long I hate to say so long ago that that is you know six years ago where something happened and here we are in 2025 you know trying to figure out what is the best next steps again I don't don't think it's anyone on this board's fault and so I'm not sure if I 100% agree that you all should go back to when you all got on the board and start thinking about back paying um it it could look different because now that's that's just this board and again I know there's previous boards involved in this as well and

242like you said that's a legal matter there as well my goal has always to been is to be transparent and that's you know why I'm bringing this conversation forward because if I did then it'll come back somehow differently so here we are again and this is not the first time I brought you know transparent Financial you know mistakes um that you know previous administrations had to kind of work through to the board um how we moved in this space um was based off of administering the policy um it wasn't to again you know negate the conversation and or the action of the board the board could right now say we want to keep everything the same as an action it could the board could say right now move us back to what we were the

243board could say that and as an action or the board could say you know what we've already put for put forth to you all which is there's a way to that we can Rectify this year and you all still will get paid what the policy states and then we can bring this back at a policy conversation to possibly even change it or not you know those are different options that this board could take and so I wanted to make sure I did answer Mrs Le's question again it may not be the um the response that anyone on this board is looking for but it was the direction that I believe that we were just trying to administer the policy that the board has set forth well in this case previous board set forth that we

244didn't change thank you uh board member Miller thanks um so wherever we land here um a little I'm going to take something that's a little off topic and weave it in we've talked in the past about um reestablishing the foundation that exists on paper but not in practice and I know that there are a number of community members that are interested in in doing that depending on where we land with the decision on how to deal with this I think a really great option for board members current or or past that might want to make right you know any overpayment that was done might be to um help create kind of some seed money for that Foundation which could be a nice way to jump start that whole concept but I just wanted to throw

245that out out there thanks thank you board member Anderson yeah so I I think in in the interest of time I don't think we should meet out a new policy here tonight it can certainly go through policy committee and we can decide we get paid zero a month to a 10,000 a month that's that's you know it's a discussion and I think we can have that um but for the purposes you don't want to have that for the purposes of making things right is there an appetite to say look for February pay us $225 onetime adjustment that way current policy stays in place because 225 would capture the $25 extra for the nine months that we've been overpaid by $25 that way current policy stays in place and it's a one-time adjustment for February and

246then we can make whatever policy we want going forward in due time uh thank you board member Anderson did you include the 50 from January in your calculation I did not okay and then the other question I have is um well I don't think we should change board policy tonight we can suspend policy for a month or two or three um and direct the administration how how we want to do that if I may certainly it's sounds like the efforts of everybody is to correct the wrong I believe the decision that was made in December does that already by reducing the board memb pay to $400 a month there is no repayment necessary by anybody you get paid the full value 450 time so did I overstep my bones I don't know I guess that's

247for you to decide as the board I see it as administration's job to administer the policy the board's job is to set the policy not necessarily to administer the policy if you're going to administer the policy you don't need the administrators to do that many in the public would be very thankful for you for that step so I just you know there's talk about the need to repay that adjustment has already been Incorporated and that was communicated in that December email thank you Mr chady um and yes you are right the the board sets the policy the policy does not State anything about the annual board payment it's a monthly board payment that's where um I think there was an error on behalf of of this Administration and I see that board member Greg Schneider

248has his hand up um I guess the question I have is just in consideration as we look forward to this um is that since I have waved my board stien for the year um as was suggested earlier um just how would I then I would need to work out a different arrangement to to pay back or to correct the compensation for that since I won't have any paychecks for them to deduct from thank you board member Schneider it is 9 o' I will entertain a motion to extend the meeting until 9:30 so moved is it was that Brian Nichols it was Brian okay is there a second second second by Megan Miller any discussion hearing none all in favor I I I I any oppos I motion carries unanimously board member Levy thank you and

249I'll be brief I just want us to note that the type for this agenda item is discussion um now as I mentioned in the past we could eliminate that all together and just reiterate to the public that any item on the agenda the board may take action on however because we listed discussion I don't think it's appropriate for us to take action thank you board memb leevy um actually it is listed under discussion um board category board action SL discussion items according to um legal advice we can take action on this then just a quick question for clarification when you click on the item is there a reason the type is just discussion because I think that could be misleading to the public so I'm try just I an oversight I don't may I respond

250yes yes okay um uh but but item six says board action discussion items so okay mine says mine says both it's I I we're not outside of the um legal um parameters to take action on on this thank you any other board um comments or thoughts Dr Garrison your um yes um just just a final thought from Administration um the the work that that the team has put into this conversation I want to say thank you to me it was a worth discussion um it does do help you know to know what direction we want to go in I would hope that like Mr chady had mentioned what we did was we in the 12 months this year if we keep everything the same everybody's fine and again that was that's always my heart is

251try our hearts be honest with you try to you know level set with policy and make this correction and everybody's fine now if we want to do more from there that was that was my part of the whole discussion tonight um just want to make sure you know I put that back in the air again thank you Dr Garrison so from the sounds of the board members it sounds like we are all comfortable with um going out to April at the $400 a month so that this year will'll all be set with the exception of uh board member Greg Schneider who has chosen so graciously to wave the remainder of his um uh board stiens would anyone like to make a motion suspending the policy 164 until April so that the board members can receive

252the payment of 400 400 a month so moved I'll second motion by Brian Nichols seconded by Brian Anderson board member Levy so just a question um and and again I appreciate what you outlined from legal um and it is under the header of discussion SL action but when you click on that item up until a few minutes ago it said discussion so I'm wondering who made the change to action comma discussion um when when I printed out my agenda this morning it says board action SL discussion items so I don't know why and I and I printed it out from board docs so I don't know why some of us are seeing just discussion no and I think that the discrepancy and I'll be brief six absolutely says board action SL discussion items but when

253you click on 6D until a few moments ago it said discussion and so thank you Miss sh mystery solved it was changed I am voting nay for two reasons one I don't appreciate the way this was handled I think it was inappropriate not that I have a problem with the content of what was done and two if we are going to include those headers under the IND individual items I for me that's a transparency issue because if I was a Community member looking at this they're not going to take action because it says discussion so for us to change that in the middle of the meeting I I don't support thank you may I clarify certainly so when you said that you might take action on the backside where I take minutes in order for

254me to be able to take the motion in the minutes I had to add action so that the motion box would pop up for me not realizing it was going to change on the front side too for everybody else to see so I lesson learned there but it's the only way I can get a motion box to pop up for me to be able to take the motion on the back side so in the future we'll just make sure that we Mark things for both information and action whether you need to take action or not I guess thank you Mrs schop and um you know maybe this is a discussion to have with board docs because the um agenda item detail that I printed out this morning clearly states board action discussion item so I

255why why there are these differences in how how it's presented some places versus others I I think so that we get to label things ourselves and then you have to choose some of those labels it that's what makes it difficult and we we'll we'll talk about this later yeah thank you okay so we have a motion and a second on the on the floor any other discussion board member henkins um I think it's Mr T I don't know if he answer this is this is there enough time now to to readjust one way or the other the payroll for February so as currently um intended to be administered February March and April board members will receive $400 right so so it wasn't changed after December when we had the telephone conversation and I said wait

256a minute this is out this is breaking board policy it needs to get set back until the board discusses it January was when we made the change um to the 400 that's not what you said in December in December um our discussion was well I'm being honest which I don't remember all that discussion since December um but I can tell you that when this was brought to me I did have a conversation with Mr chady around what happened I did want to go back and look at the policy and from there we had already made the changes in our system for January to to occur so that's that's where I'm at that's where I've always been is not to misinform anyone about any decisions that was made here we've been very clear that this was

257to to rectify the board's pay back to what it was supposed to be based off of the policy and the $400 allowed us to do no for you all not to have to do any changes to your to your checks and it will keep everybody one could argue clean for this year without having an overpayment oh EXC Bob I'm just wondering I'm not going back or rehashing what that was the comment my comment was when do you have to make the adjustment to payroll let's say we didn't want to do the 400 does there time to change that for payroll for February I believe the answer to that would be yes if I recall correctly board members are paid on the last payroll of the month so there would be time to make that adjustment

258if you want to go if you want to go to the 450 and write the district a check we can do that no that wasn't what I I was just getting at what what's the time frame of of doing I know it has to go in the whatever you know through payroll blah blah blah y but there's a time constraint if there was going to be a change to it so it's set okay thank you board board member Anderson and then I see board member Schneider also has his hand up and just a clarify because the motion mentions until April and I just want to make sure Mr J's okay with that because he mentions it through April until April does it start in may I just want to make sure that the motion as

259motioned it will solve your problem yes okay April's fine beginning May 1st we'll revert back to the perfect just want to be clear board member Schneider okay I am going to abstain from this vote um because again 6D specifically States board pay discussion which therefore by open meeting laws should State discussion only even though it is under the category of action SL discussion uh so to be clear with open meeting laws I will abstain since I think any motion would be in violation of that thank you board member Schneider any other discussions before we take a vote oh Brian Nichols well I you know I don't want to I don't want to get I don't want to make this thing go longer than it really has to go but I you know I just I

260would I would you know I would just ask all of us every one of us to think about what we've done because um you know we got we got a lot of things on the fire and we got a lot lot of responsibilities coming in the in the near future and you know quite frankly we received something we should not have received and um I I I I just I mean at the end of the day I'm not comfortable with I'm just not as as for me me personally I'm not comfortable not paying it back because it wasn't do me just like just like when I pay my taxes if I underpay I'm in trouble if I overpay they send me the money back end of story thank you thank you vice president Nichols Michelle

261can we get a roll call on this please absolutely Megan Miller I Tom henkins I Brian Anderson I Brian Nichols nay Amy Levy nay Greg Schneider I obain Tia Johnson I motion carried 4 to2 to one thank you the next item on the agenda is the consent agenda and Mrs Levy would you refresh my memory which ones did we already remove during the approval of the agenda all now you're making me work we removed um I believe it was item uh it was D um the minutes from the January 14th meeting um but since my mic is on I would also like to remove items G and H please okay thank you she also mentioned item N9 C right right I'm I'm just I'm just looking at consent agenda right now okay so I will

262entertain a motion for the approval of the consent agenda with the removal of item D approval of minute meeting minutes and uh removing G and H for discussion so moved second motion by Megan Miller seconded by Greg Schneider any discussion hearing and seeing none all in favor I I I I I any I any oppose motion carries unanimously policy that brings us to item G policy 3 45.6 graduation requirements um Mrs Levy I believe you're the one that removed this so you have first go at the discussion yeah and if you don't mind I have the same concern with G and H so in the interest of efficiency um I just requested that both of these items be removed because um I support the administration's recommendation to reduce the number of required graduation credits from

26326 to 24 so I just won't be voting um to support those two policies as is thank you board member Miller thank you so much I'm ditto and I have a child who has a need so I'm gonna is it okay if I just jump on virtually for the rest of our absolutely absolutely thanks everybody appreciate it board member Schneider again um I I agree with the administration's recommendation to increase the opportunities for students um by reducing the graduation requirements um and I noticed that it it states here under purpose it's to align with the changes made in the state level um uh the state level is not weigh in at all on this recommendation one way or the other so it is not adapting it to meet state requirements um but because um I

264agree with the administrators administration's recommendations I cannot support these thank you any other discussion on 7 G or h I will entertain a motion for approval of item G and H if if so moved I'll second motion by Brian Nicholls seconded by Brian Anderson any other discussion Mrs sh can we get a roll call please could I also get clarification was that for both the policy and the rule I can't yes it was green I couldn't Tom Megan Miller mic sorry nay uh Tom henkins I Brian Anderson I Brian Nichols I Amy Levy nay Craig Schneider nay Tia Johnson I motion carried four to three thank you our next item is human resources do any board members have any open session questions regarding the HR committee report employment recommendations exhibit a I'm sorry did you

265did you say open or closed open oh I go ahead Mrs Levy thank you so much so just two questions um there is a district level substitute that was scheduled to start on November 1st um so I'm just wondering why the board is reviewing this 3 months later and my second question is the schal education PA professional uh at Robinson had an effective date of last week so I'm just wondering is there a reason that one month of service is listed so with substitutes it takes sometimes to determine if that individual is actually committed to starting to provide those services to our district so it is not unusual for someone someone to after being board approved either move out of the area or otherwise advise that they're no longer going to consider providing substitute services

266for our district so it seems that the the note says that they never started so for the last three and and the only reason I ask is because I know we had a separate conversation about purging substitute list when they weren't inactive so I'm just wondering what is that time frame of inactivity um where this would come before the board and say no this person is no longer eligible to sub um the biggest difference is that this person never wants substituted for the district and has um since advice of their lack of interest to provide substitute it wasn't the a perch we don't do that routinely but in this particular situation knowing their intent or lack thereof it did not make sense to continue carrying them okay and then my second question do we do

267this in month increments and that's why a person who was supposed to start last week is listed as a month of service you're referring to the um support resignation with a one month cor service um I that would that month of service would have to do with when they started working for us which I don't know well the effective date says 1 128 2025 which would be last week correct but I so is the effective date different than the start date well these are resignations so that's the last day that they physically worked for us was 128 okay um thank you board member Anderson and just another one that looks like probably clerical but we have the teacher uh resignation the art teacher um with an effective date of 111 1900 I'm guess oh that

268is definitely a typo um I would hope that was not the case um we can definitely um if you don't mind updating that in the motion I would greatly appr appreciate it sure sorry for the oversight any other Open Session questions on exhibit a are there any closed session questions for exhibit a hearing none I will entertain a motion regarding exhibit a I move approval of exhibit a as amended second thank you we've got a motion by Greg Schneider seconded by Brian Nichols of approval of exhibit a as amended all in favor I I I I I any oppose hearing none motion carries unanimously our next item is executive session a motion may be made and a vote taken to convene the Board of Education into Clos session pursuant to section 19.85% to section 12.13

269par 1 par e4h of the Wisconsin State statutes the Board of Education shall upon review approve reverse or modify the orders the the board um of Education May return from close session to approve reverse or modify the expulsion orders of the independent hearing officer as determined by the Board of Education inclosed session thank you everyone for your oh I'm sorry um we need a roll call on this m Mrs shop he I I need a motion in a second first I'll move to go into executive session second motion by Brian Anderson second by Brian Nichols thank you for your patience and your assistance um any discussion Mrs Levy oh thank you just to clarify we wouldn't return to open session to disc discuss any decisions made about the expulsion hearing so just wanted to we'll

270be adjourning from Clos I'm I'm reading what's on the agenda and um I think that that will be made in close session if there is some reason that the Board needs to come out for some um unique action regarding something I'm just making that statement Mrs sh Schneider I Amy ly I Brian Nichols I Brian Anderson hi Tom henkins Hi Megan Miller hi Tia Johnson I motion carried unanimously thank you we will convene in executive session thank you everyone for coming out tonight and your patience and contributions to making the school district of blit better for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.