CorpusRecord 82704

SDB - Special Board Meeting - January 16, 2025 (5:00 p.m.)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / School District of Beloit
Date
2025-01-17
Location
Rock County, WI
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,149 words · about 74 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e is e e e good evening it is 501 I would like to go call to order the special board meeting for Thursday January 16th Mrs shop can we get a roll call please yes Megan Miller present tom henkins here Brian Anderson here Greg Schneider present Amy Levy Amy Levy Brian Nichols here and tia Johnson present and I'll call one more time for Amy ly I see her on the screen but we're not getting a response so all members are present um with the exception of Amy Lei Amy Levy until she uh indicates she's present thank you may I get an approval of the agenda so moved second motion by Brian Nicholls seconded by Tom henkins any discussion hearing and seeing none all in favor I I I I I any oppose motion

002passes unanimously please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance [Music] thank you Mrs Shope are there any public comments tonight I do not have any in the room and I have one um that has come in via email okay would you do you mind reading it and know who it's from okay uh the email is from Bill Williams um the booy public schools can't even teach reading writing and basic math skills adequately anymore and they want another 40 million no not until they actually show that they have the ability to teach these very basic and very necessary subjects to our young people please vote no on spending Millions while more scores are so abysmal in this school district thank you bill um there is a PS um the school the blit schools have been so poorly

003operated and the results so abysmal that we we would like a full refund for our last 10 years the School portion of our property taxes thank you Mrs schop are there any other public comments thank you our next agenda item is the resolution authorizing the School District budget to exceed the revenue limit um Mrs Levy do you have a question or comment I have a question thank you so much um is there a reason that there is an A and A B because my assumption and please correct me if I'm wrong is that b is the proposed question as it would appear on the ballot so I'm just wondering is there a legal reason why we have to approve or or deal with approve or uh decline On A and B and then my second

004question for b um in Dr Garrison I guess this is for you because my assumption is that you had the contact with legal to get this vetted do we have any leeway to streamline that language in the opening um just so it's easier for the public to read on the ballot um or is more straightforward so those are my two questions do we need both A and B um and if no do we have any leeway to streamline B so it's more reader friendly thank you so to answer your question about a um a this is the way legal told me to of course post post the information and so I just use what legal um directed me to do um this is also the process that they share with me from from last year

005as well so I don't have any legal reasons so why we have a and b outside of this is the way legal asks me to present it Mr chady may be able to share um more details about it I just took from what legal and then I answer your I'll answer B after Mr chady is able to respond yeah so resolution uh 3A the resolution actually adopts the language that the board would like to place on the ballot 3B is the resolution to actually put forward that question onto the election ballot so it's a two it's a two-step process um you both have to adopt a question and then actually physically place it on the ballot and with regards to the brevity um if there's any brevity that can be done to the proposed question

006it would be after the dollar values in the years when we get into the purposes not prior to that that's pretty standard language that's used throughout the state thank you so I think Mr chady answered your b as well so um that concludes my questions from Mrs leevy for now just joking thank you thank you so the purpose of tonight's discussion is to gain approval of the resolution for exceeding the REM Revenue limit for 3 years for a spring referendum the background information is the school district of booy faces budgetary constraints leading into the 2526 school year these budgetary needs have been expressed throughout the 2324 school years leading us to a potential 2025 referendum question Dr Garrison yes ma'am and so um first of all thank you Bo for your your time and and

007dedication in this space over the past year and and more of course um my hopes is that tonight we'll um answer any additional questions that you may have and possibility of a vote um one of the things that we have tried to do over the course of these past you know few months is you know gather information and naturally move from information to um um action and then here here we are in this space um tonight you know when we dated back I just want to give you a quick snapshot when we dated back looking at a timeline we we knew that we were working up against you know pretty tight timeline but what we also knew is that our District's finances and some of those conversations have been consistent over many years and our

008needs have been expressed in many different platforms uh my hopes tonight is that we again are able to kind of you know walk through any questions that you may have and then of course we will you know let the board kind of go from there um tonight we also wanted to make sure that everyone is aware you know from last week to this week of course some things changed and so when when you have those moving targets naturally scenarios changed and when scenarios changed the dollar the dollar values changed um even from Monday to Tuesday they changed um and so here we are tonight with a scenario snapshot of what it could cost based off of scenario 2 I'm sorry H2 which was the uh consensus in the room on on Tuesday um when we

009had this discussion and so what I wanted to do was provide additional details um based off of you know some questions that that came to me from the aspect of how the money will be spent um the good thing about it is in all of our presentations we've had the the the priorities broke down as it pertains to cost and once we kind of landed in this H2 space we were able to kind of pull that information back to this document to give more specifics around how much things will will cost now please know these are estimated priority cost um naturally we always use that word estimated there is because that's the natural conversation that we have knowing that sometimes we estimate um right right to the number and sometimes it's much lower based off

010of if we're able to get you know certain you know people people in um on this first slide here from a compensation perspective we did go back and add that 5% across all salary schedules to give you that snapshot of year one year two year three and the totals in which it will cost over a threeyear time frame in that space please note that you have the the 3% increases that we also built into our uh uh um budget model um that we use for benefits and just that annual cost of things um possibly going up so you will see here the totals that will be for all all employee groups now with that being said of course this is not a negotiated space so naturally the board could say you know we want to

011do 5% for the teachers 4% for you know administrative staff just giv you an example or we can do 5% for all teachers and you know year one and year two you can say you want to do 4% for everybody that 5% was the top number that we use for this model based off of what the board was given us as as it pertains to feedback um that's a space that I just want to make sure we share we've shared that before that file was just with the numbers that we used to build out our scenarios um before I move forward I want to make sure I capture any questions just from this snapshot here do any board members have questions on the staff compensation and retention cost uh Dr Garrison or Mr chady um

012does that include benefits or is that just the wage increase that includes benefits okay okay any other questions go ahead Dr Garrison thank you so um that gives us the the snapshot for the 5% across um H2 scenario now what I could have did was pull up the H2 scenario but we've got those scenario sheets out I can kind of tell across the board here and um um if you want me to pull up that scenario too for you know for everyone's viewing purposes I'll be able to close it off and show everybody um but we that's that's scenario for for H2 scenario and the next two buckets well next bucket we well next priority we have is our academic bucket and our behavioral cost um estimated breakdown and what we did was we used

013the presentation that we currently had we rolled those conversations over and you see the cost of what things will will be for literacy um integrated technology reading intervention American reading company um ebooks replenishment act 20 um professional learning training and Virtual Reading tutors um that's the reading literacy bucket followed by our math bucket I apologize I couldn't squeeze this all on one slide um but the math booket also came to the Eureka Math and the imagin math totaling um this three-year total here which is um 1.68 million um that's the threeyear total the next I'm sorry is there any questions of with well let me let me finish this whole bucket and I'll take questions after that Mr thank you um the next bucket we have is our behavioral support bucket now uh what we

014wanted to go back and do since we knew that behavioral was a space that we've you know we've heard from um in different spaces um and we wanted to make sure we captured that and and one of the things that we did was we of course we kept the six behavioral support positions there those are pretty much like teacher positions um added to the behavioral conversation and of course we wanted to look at the assistant principal being brought back at the high school that's a three-year total please understand that 351,000 is not for one year for an assistant principal um the two um the two the two dean of students position is um again a three-year total 375 and and then we added the conversation with the six PA professional support positions and we believe

015that that six PA professional support positions could be used in in tandem with the behavioral support person along with the par par person working closely with student and teacher behaviors teacher learning opportunities if you look at that priority bucket it'll cost us over the threeyear time frame of $ 2.84 million um um which if you add up the 2.84 one million plus the 1.68 million you get the four um 4 and a half million dollar conversation now to those of you that look at the look that's looking at our H2 scenario you'll see that $1.66 n Million number of new stuff do you mind if I kind of cheat off here I'm sorry I don't have M sped up um oh perfect thank you thank you um if you pull up the if you look

016at if you anyone's following along on the H2 scenario you'll see that 1.69 million of new additional stuff that's $1.66 n million conversation is year one year two year three you know you multiply that times three you got $5 million $557,000 to be exact and then you subtract the $451 and that's where you will get all remaining funds could be utilized for addressing District Maintenance and or deposited into fund balance okay and so I tried to make it so that people understood exactly where the money would be spent and of course these have been the conversations that we've been having um you know and we wanted to be as clear as we needed to be in that in that space so that gives us a snapshot very clean snapshot I believe around how the money

017could be spent in the parity buckets um one and parity buckets um two and I will turn it over for any questions that the board may have do board members have any questions U Megan Miller thank you so much um I know you've discussed this already and we we've covered this at several meetings but just for the sake of kind of synthesizing all this information together um the last statement on the last slide that that you have up here that talks about how all remaining funds could be utilized for addressing either District Maintenance needs and or deposited into fund balance I think there has been some I think there is a space to build some understanding with the community here around what that means and I know like we have just recently talked about maintenance

018costs but does somebody want to give us just kind of a gist or kind of a snapshot of like what we're looking at over the next couple of years so people understand that that's a reasonably sized number so to be to be honest it's about $400 to so ,000 has left over in that in this threeyear bucket conversation in this in that $1.66 n million conversation so um that's you know will that carry Us in fund balance one could argue no um but when you look at the scenario H2 you see that in each year in our projected Surplus and deficit conversation um you got $91,000 in year one about a little over a million in year two and a little over 200,000 in year three um then that that um very um small amount

019could be rolled into the fund balance conversation to kind of bring that $ 1.69 million total to about and one could argue if we use all the $400,000 could be a little close to about $2 million that we could possibly save over these course of these three years we do know that minus a referendum at all we are about a six $6.2 million um deficit um that's for year one um and then in year 2 26 27 the district would run into you know the possibilities of not being able to fund ourselves and that's the conversation that we had last week around um not having fund balance and in that case one could argue we're getting real close to bankruptcy um that's that's the the reason why fund balance is very important and and again

020from year 1 to year 2 that's 6 million I think and I think to be exact year two deficit is a little over 8 million and so we're looking at minus a referendum not just a 66 million deficit we're really looking at plus eight because January of next year we still got to have $8 million of reductions so that's $14 million that we'll be talking about having to reduce again and so in that space again you know we're looking at some drastic measures that the school district cannot keep affording to to to work itself through um as a matter of fact as it pertains to any of our goals we wouldn't be able to possibly reach any of those because now you're talking about again cutting multiple staff in many different areas that includes teachers

021while retention could possibly necessarily go away because we won't be able to retain people um when the year-over-year cuts are still still is the it would have to be a focus um I would just hope that when you see that you know that the the 400 or so thousand that we'll able to move into fund balance or possibly use for maintenance needs um it's it's not a large amount but it is putting back something to kind of help us in that area of the projected Surplus and or deficit may I ask a brief clarifying question thank you so much Dr garron that was a fabulous kind of overview um that helps I think us understand fund balance and why that's on there because I know that people have reacted sort of negatively in the past

022of the idea that we would use money toward fund balance so I appreciate the explanation um I just want to clarify my question because I don't think I asked it very clearly I was just wondering um if you could just remind us about like the gist of around the total of Maintenance needs that we might see over the next three to five years it's it's it's a lot right yeah I mean our maintenance needs will have to come in in a much greater Capital conversation because right now this is not in any of the buckets I know we have some you know pressing needs but the board has really identified retention and paying our staff has been a very top priority based off of the scenarios that we've been able to to present um the

023buckets that we I mean the priorities that we were able to produce that was over in a $2 million number with just some things that we needed to take care of just right now um that conversation will need to be brought back and again in a much greater Capital conversation in which we will tackle some of those things that was in our presentation along with some other of our um you know 5 to 10 year plan opportunities that our district has and so Mrs U Miller that it it wouldn't touch many things at all I appreciate you clarifying that because I just I just don't want people to to have the the misunderstanding that asking for more than we need and so I really appreciate you adding that context of the importance not only of

024mitigating any Cliff that we might encounter at the end of the length of the referendum as well as just keeping a reasonable sense of wiggle room or margin of wiggle room to deal with facilities I know we've made a lot of important like safety infrastructure Investments over the last several years I mean when we talk about student safety part of that is like Building Maintenance safety as well and so I just really appreciate appreciate you sharing that and I think you've helped clarify the point I was hoping to make thank you can I just I want to just add because I don't want to leave this out Mrs joh Johnson you know the district year one we we did go to referendum and you know we weren't able to you know get that one pass

025that would have it wasn't going to give us everything that we needed in that referendum it would have got us to keep a mill rated around 478 and use some extra dollars to put back towards our fund balance um year two we didn't ask for what we needed as well we did the cuts and the $9 million conversation and and here we are again right and so in this snapshot this is the first time since I've been here where we kind of have asked what we what we need to to to maintain and survive um and our what we're currently doing my hopes is that you know people see even in the Surplus area not 91,000 that's a modest modest Surplus in year one and the million dollar is a modest Surplus definitely a great

026Surplus in year two year three um you know a little over $200,000 but you know we have a District budget that's floating between you know we've went from 100 let's say 110 million and down to almost you know under 90 million um over the years and so we've had is Major just you know you know reductions over the years and so this this is our first time coming to the public with a real with a request that we've heard from different pockets of people as a retains of what they would possibly support and still gives up some just a little wiggle room in each year based off of scenario H2 and where the board kind of has landed and and and so I just want to make sure I note that too that you know

027last year we did not ask for what we needed okay we asked for what we thought would pass and we still had to do those reductions um even with a past rep there have been deductions and so it was a little more drastic because we didn't get the referendum right and so that's that's the space that we had to you know of course work from just want to make sure I note that thank you Mr henkins yes thank you very much um Dr Garrison and maybe deei obviously um hiring is a very competitive market right now and just because we allocate monies for hiring all these different positions you know does it make it so and they're going to they're going to pop up onto our screen and be filled my question is and I

028know we have positions that are open right now I'm wondering what happens to those dollars that were allocated but we can't find someone a you know a um a prospect that would fill that need where does that money go Mrs Al sorry um so that money really is budgeted and simply not used um another benefit of the referendum and trying to increase Recruitment and Retention it would allow us um to potentially consider um how our increase in wages can impact people's decisions to come to our district versus next door or over the state line so it is a benefit that money would just remain in that um in that pool okay just it won't get transferred to the general fund balance or it stays in within your or the employee um as a benefit to

029employees only I mean we talked just I'm I'm not trying to make a big deal about it but Dr Garrison just talked about if there's a 400,000 I think it was that could could go into maintenance if we don't spend it my not a concern it's a question if all these different positions that are we are going to uh get money for if you can't fill them does that stay in a fund somewhere and so go ahead so great question so the question that you're answering is based off of attrition and of course um attraction is what I like to call it can we get the people here if we're and every year there's positions that are unfortunately left open here in our school district and that money is used in many different ways one

030of the ways it's used is to help us with our budget um because that money is rolled back over into our negative that we that we run into on a regular basis because of our funding here in the school district being what it is so if we don't hire for the position that savings does come back to us it doesn't go away no it doesn't go away because that's what was allocated that's what the money was allocated for now uh from a year-to-year perspective and I know Mr chady can probably answer this a little bit better than me but from a year perspective we sometimes have to rely on those funds being there at the end of the year based off of the time of the year so let's just say we get to March

031and we still don't have ex teer now that March turns into April chances are we probably won't hire that position that that money comes in for us in the form of a savings because we got through the year you know that's not the what we wanted but we got through the year with a savings of let's just say set teacher $68,000 with Benefits um and that money comes in the form of a savings to us because we don't have a large fund balance you know sitting there from you know year to year and then we we use that money to you know move towards our fund balance and so I hope that answers your question well it does and I think that's what uh my my point was that if we can't hire people that

032this money that is being allocated to those positions will go back and not be allocated to because we can't find a competent person to hire that money also will go back into the fund balance I would like to add if possible we also have to look at the full picture of when we don't hire a position there are other teachers for example that may be giving up their prep time and so those are costs that are associated with not filling a position so it's not like we save a full $68,000 because we didn't hire at um there are others that are helping to cover whether it's students being moved to other classrooms Etc there's overages there's overload pay there um blue sheets there are different ways of compensating whenever they give up a prep time

033or extend their classroom okay thank you but you know I guess the answer would be you know we got look at the slide that's up there if we don't hire these people CU you can't or for whatever reason there's not a a person who applies for it that's a lot of dollars that could go does it stay in in our budget for that year and then the next year you try again and the next year you try again right it's not like it rolls over um into um it's not like HR has a surplus of x amount of money to use the following year so it does get allocated as needed and so that's something that the board I mean Mr chady would keep us surprised of because I know that Dr Garrison I don't

034think I'm saying you've already said it you know that these vacancies that we have currently uh I think you said till March I know you use a baseball analogy when baseball season starts if you haven't hired by then then that money goes back into the fund balance we have allocated for that and with that in mind are we doing the same thing with these referendum dollars if we can't hire someone for that sorry that's a great question that you ask um you know so looking at the slide it talks about six behavioral uh support positions we'll just use as an example very valid point right are we going to be able to find six quality individuals that we can bring on board to help reduce our behavioral and academic needs great question yes the resources

035could go to fund balance but before they do that so so we're going to budget for those positions and hope that we have them hired and filled for the start of the school year but maybe not right I mean that's that's your concern maybe they get filled in the fall maybe they're still open after the first of the year maybe they're still open even at the end of the school year if they are then those resources yeah could flow to the fund balance and help replenish that but even before doing that and maybe even earlier in the process I would say we're directing these resources to meet these academic and behavioral support needs let's not handcuff oursel to filling positions maybe we need to reallocate or prioritize those resources to meet academic and behavioral support

036needs in other Fashions would would that shift if it happened would that be brought to the board would you alert us that we're going to shift this money I would think I'm not trying to handcuff you I just want to know I I would think that that would route through the appropriate committee yes okay thank you yep Brian Nichols yes thank you um another clarifying question uh Mr Shady on uh on that slide does that also include benefits for all those positions yes I'm sorry yes those positions are included with just like on the previous um on our main um presentation we had that added um and this is the same thing okay is that it Brian for now okay this um any other board questions or comments one of my concerns with this um

037I'm I'm all for looking at um improving our behaviors and absolutely our academics um we we want our students to do the best they possibly can and be the best students they possibly can um a concern of mine is we we did used to have behavioral behavioral specialists in the district and those positions I believe became assistant principal positions where the assistant principal was to um address more of the behaviors and the principles were supposed to address more of the academics um you know so that Arrangement it sounds like is insufficient to address our behavioral needs at this time if if we are not um consistently using the code of conduct um as appropriate throughout the district um how how is having more behavioral support in the buildings going to change ultimately moving us towards

038the goal we'd like to see and and then my next question is with the par par of professionals and believe me I strongly support par of professionals and having more but if we can't get the pair of professionals now putting more money towards more positions are we just going to have more open positions um I'm I suggest did last time um perhaps hiring a recruiting Specialist or something I know our HR department took a big hit I know our business um and finance Services Department took a big hit this this last um budget cycle I'm so I'm a little concerned that we're not looking at putting a little bit more support back in those departments and and or maybe trying to balance out a little bit of the um the cuts the reductions that were

039made in Colac so that department wise and we're we are now in effect missing a complete Department with our Communications um Department no one no one in there right now so those are my questions and concerns you can I you know you make some valid you know valid points you know people NE necessarily doesn't mean the problem will be fixed and I I'll be the first to tell you that um I can tell you that without people in in spaces where there could possibly be help it just it magnifies the problem even more um I think right now there's going to be conversations um that we have to continue to have internally in regards to not just behaviors but also looking at the structures and more conversations around that um our hopes is that with

040these positions we not hopes I believe that these positions you know with new guidance can be beneficial for our students and behavioral conversations because again one thing we do know is the behav the behaviors aren't going away um you know we do know that there's a Code of Conduct that we will still need to enforce um and that's going to continue um we we we are working through our code of conduct we we we do have referrals we do have suspensions we do have you know those levels of different you know disciplinary actions but again you know I'll be the first to tell you that well yeah we would love to know that adding more people could help us but you know it's going to take much more than just you know people there going

041to have to be some structural changes in this conversation and I believe that with additional support with with some of our teachers and classrooms um that this could be a very you know great opportunity for us to show that our community that we are working with the whole child conversation our PA of professional support in the classroom could be a benefit to some of those classrooms that may have more um challenging students because sometimes it just balances out differently in different spaces um that behavioral support position is true it did shift to assistant principles but that's just one person right now all of the discipline really falls into a few laps in the buildings right principal assistant principal and sometimes I say sometimes our student services team if they're available they don't always go straight

042to the student services teams I.E counselors and or psychologists they pretty much Falls or lands with the the uh administrators um and so these additional support opportunities in buildings that may need additional support provides another layer of you know what if the assistant principal is dealing with one major situation we got a behavioral support specialist that can go and help along with a pair of professional that could be added to that classroom to provide additional support um again these are opportunities that we have in in these spaces and we know right now in our middle schools we currently have one principal and one assistant principal and when they used to have of course two and it has been you know challenging um this year working through our Middle School conversations and so the two Dean

043opportunities is a space and which we believe could be beneficial as well based off of some of the conversations that even came from um from the public and so that's that's a position there now let's just do this since you know that's a statement Mrs um Johnson you know we can you can minus 375,000 right we can take that off we could take off the six pair of professional positions that's another million it'll change the behavioral support package I'm just giving you an example um it'll lower this bottom number of 41,000 right it would um but we will still probably have some behavioral concerns yeah and I understand that we can change that I my personal opinion is no I would absolutely keep those Dean positions at the middle school because I know they are

044um um desperately needed with the reduction that um of staff that we've had there um I do know that we also lost um cut some of the uh secretarial positions at the middle school and their strain and extra work burden there as as well um ultimately I guess my my question or my point is there are if if if I have a factory and the goal of my Factory is to make widgets I don't know if adding more cogs in the system is going to make better widgets um what the the system we have to look at what we're doing what is going to change what are you as the district administrator going to do to get this system to be more effective and align with the direction this we we want to see the

045district going and that's a great question um you know some of my response here is is going to be very open-ended um right now minus any support in a referendum it's going to be drastically hard to do anything because we won't have we won't be able to pay for what we currently got and so I just want to make sure that's the the first space Miss Miss B you come to mik please um that's that's the first space So currently what we're doing is we're trying our hardest to maintain what we currently have to to with the staff we currently have to get the job done we want to be able to provide more professional learning around behavioral and behavioral support in our buildings we want to provide that we of course had to back

046away from certain contracts and certain things based off of our needs you know and so we we haven't been able to do that um which is hard because again you take away the the the funding for it and then you still got the need and then it's you you struggle another thing that we would love to do is still work with our family and Family Services in our community um there's Outreach that still needs to be done there um I'll be honest with you um there's there's work that I need to do better in that space because I believe that our community at large possibly do want to help us in different spaces we extended some of those conversations we have but maybe there's more that could be done there um in especially in the

047in the behavioral opportunities that one could one could argue the third thing that I think we could do better and especially in the behavioral let's just speak from behavioral perspec perspective right now is how how we talk about our students is very important um we have to communicate some of we I have to do a better job at communicating the great things that are happening in our day day-to-day basis in our school district we used to do you know three positive messages a day maybe that's not enough because some people believe that we are having major issues every single day of the week you know and maybe I'm sorry every single day and maybe that's true but we have 5,000 plus students and if let's just say 15 of them have a rough day that's

04815 of the 5,000 and I think we missed that the let's just say we missed the four 4,000 h 885 students that's having a great day and maybe we need to do a better job at communicating some of th those excellent opportunities that that that are happening daily in our district and I can ask Mrs Bieber to share additional things that we are currently doing to support this conversation okay so I'm I'm I'm feeling like there's two different conversations being had because Administration and student services um are responsive to the behaviors when somebody violates the code of contct conduct these positions I think should be looked at as building and supporting skills so that there is not a violation of the code of conduct so think about like the emls system and the multi-tiered system

049of supports in in regards to academics right we have these coaches and these interventionists that are sitting in meetings and disaggregating data and then being responsive to that data and working with teachers and students to build the skills in Reading in literacy and math right that's how I would see these positions really working we talk about behavior in these meetings but we don't have assigned individuals to go in and work directly with students or with teachers in regards to the data that they're analyzing I don't know if that does that help a little bit yes yeah that does okay you then another question I had Dr Garrison going back to the um slide with the um support what that um the priority to academics and behavioral support costs we've got Virtual Reading tutors um $180,000

050assigned there um what does $180,000 buy us in terms of Virtual Reading tutors um explain to me why a virtual reading tutor is better than a an in-person tutor well we we of course would say I believe an inperson tutor would be great to have um and I can't say that one I I can't say that one would be better over the other but I would personally prefer iners tutor if I was in this space and this package with the Virtual Reading opportunity um I know Mrs mortek is currently over at um doing the spelling be right now but the Virtual Reading Twitter is as I understand it is a space that's that's picking up in the world of being able for a lot of students to access tutors um because we may not have

051them readily available here you know and and and and it's a hard space for me to you know try to explain better than that um we we would love to have tutors everywhere you know in in our city but unfortunately in the virtual space I can be a tutor on the weekend if I wanted to you could be a tutor on the weekend and I log in I sign on and I'm working with whoever is on the other side of the of the screen um it just opens up access differently and so the Virtual Reading space um that's the that's the package that that was brought to us I do support it again I would love to have in-person tutors as well thank you uh brand Nichols I'm well excuse me I'm I'm Greg I

052apologize I know you I just want a quick question on that subject so what data do we have to support the success of virtual tutors what data do we have to support successful tutors she's covering for you Mrs Shope thank you I don't have any data right now to support this the the statement around virtual tutors are the the route to go for ref for forever I don't have that data but thank you for acent I can provide additional data um as needed Mr Schneider well my comments go back to the beginning of the discussion that we had on the behavior supports um and I guess I look at it this way if we have a child that's in the school system in in third grade is not reading at grade level we don't just

053punish that child we provide the supports to teach them the skills that they need with behaviors I mean yes they have to deal with the code of conduct so there there is a consequence for the behaviors but just to assume that because we give them a consequence they're going to learn the appropriate behaviors would be like expecting somebody in third grade who can't read to to on their own develop all of those skills that they need to move forward we need that support to teach those skills so that they know the correct behaviors the correct way to handle situations and and again you know begin to identify some of those other social and emotional concerns that exist um and if we don't have somebody who's trained in that it's not really going to happen well

054and so the advantage of putting those behavior supports is it's just like the coaches that we use in math and in reading that we've heard at at the teaching learning equity and pupil Services committee how great that the advantage is and how much good is coming from those coaches to coach both the students and the teachers and and that's really where these positions are it's somebody who's trained and how to deal with those concerns and to teach them the skills they need so we don't have those behaviors again in the future I think another good point you make Mr um Snider and Mr Nichols as well when it comes to the research around this even from the I'm sorry even from a reading perspective um we are responsible for a lot already and how students

055show up on a daily basis it may be in academics it may be I need help emotionally it may be it's a lot of Mayes that comes with the conversation I just believe that our reporting also matters and so you know the board could ask us for let's we want to report on how our behavioral specialists are working how our behavioral specialists are doing in our district those reports can be brought you know based off of request and naturally the board president and myself working together to get that on an agenda at an appropriate time that data also is very important because sometimes you know from a research perspective is it's one space but how is it actually working in your own system can be brought through data with your own research internally from a

056from a special place based off of what the request is and so I believe we'll be able to bring to you all reports around how this is being impactful and if it's not that's a conversation that we need to have as well that's a space that we would have to operate from I would want these positions to be very successful and that would be my goal to make sure that these positions are successful for our students families students teachers everyone um and we bring that information back to the board and letting everyone know hey there it's working and and maybe maybe it's not and so that's a space that we can also work from from a research perspective before I Circle back around to other board members um Brian Anderson or Mrs Levy did either

057of you have anything you'd like to ask not at this time thank you thank you Mr Anderson not at the time either okay thank you Megan Miller thank you so much um this has been a fantastic conversation and I feel really in alignment with kind of like where we are in here so this this feels good um because I think it's really important for us to be unified as we move forward however we move forward tonight um a couple things um that I want to react to and respond to one I think the conversation we just had was such a perfect way to characterize and sort of like this entire this entire effort right so like we want to be specific because we want to make make sure all of our dollars are in alignment

058with our vision and goals we also want to be needs driven and I I love the question that you asked about like what does this look like because I think that's what we should be defining not just tonight but like as we move these conversations forward we have to have that Clear Vision for like what what really will change like how will this really truly make a difference I love that we went there um and I also want to make sure people like we want to be as specific as possible we also have to be flexible based on the kids right because this has to be about the kids and meeting their specific needs so I just I wanted to just state that point I've heard that point a lot but I wanted to just

059sort of like label this part of the conversation and clarify that that's awesome um the other two things I want to I want to point out briefly one um John Winkleman used to always say like relationships relationships relationships so when we talk about like what's the difference going to be bringing more people who want to work with our kids who have something to offer them and who have a heart for working with children is automatically going to improve things for kids now that's a really fluffy thing I just said I realized that and I don't think we can stop there I mean we do need to clearly Define more of this Vision but I am so wholeheartedly in support of getting more caring adults with our kids and I think we have to go into

060this with a plan for that but also with just that like let's reflect and assess kind like you know plan do study act like figure out what's working what do we need to change so there's got to be that flexibility built in so I just want to make sure I really hit that point of relationships and it's got to be needs driven the last thing I just want to build off of um uh sorry Mr Schneider's comment about the behavior piece so I'm a reading teacher I I work with in in in both proactive reading intervention and also helping kids who are who have fallen behind and who need support right and so just like that you know in the behavior example that that Greg gave um Mary studman uh when she first trained us

061in our reading program back in 2011 and she like why I want to be a reading teacher little pug Mary students amazing YY Mary um the story she told us was how when she was teaching kindergarten she had this routine every day of saying you know A is for apple a a apple and they would go through you know different letters I don't know if it was the week or whatever and you know all the kids are yeah yeah okay cool and she got to M and you know M is for whatever and all of a sudden this little boy just goes oh so oh that oh the letter matches the sound and she was like why right we've been doing this for how many weeks and so I just want to make the point

062that as much as we can be clear and redirecting our kids and some kids all of our bodies are different we all learn differently we all have different needs and so classroom teachers are competent amazing human beings right but they're not actually magic and so in order for us to really meet the needs of all of our kids you have to have the people whose job it is to like make sure we can help those kids who really need that extra hear it in a different way experience it in a different way to be proactive about those behaviors because we do not want the behaviors to happen period right and so I just wanted to share that um that's the way I understand our Behavior specialist piece but I also agree it has to be

063flexible and continue to be data driven and I just I love where this conversation has been overall so thank you any other board member questions or comments on either of these priorities okay then I will finish with a question that I have so on Tuesday we heard that um one of our district administrators was assigned to teach in a classroom for I I don't remember if it was six or eight weeks um which wonderful opportunity for our students to have such a highlevel high quality High performing educator in the front of the classroom room but that's a very expensive substitute what are we doing to change and to recruit substitute teachers I understand that it's very hard to get substitutes postco but um I don't know that and and I love having administrators in the

064building so that they are seeing and feeling what teachers are have to experience what are we doing to address the the issue of um classroom coverage when our teachers can't be there so I'll be honest with you we're doing the best we can um you know my my hopes is that we are able [Music] to hire and retain what we qualify staff for positions that when these positions do come open for various reasons during the school year we can keep those people but when these positions do happen it does become a Scramble for us teachers have to teachers have to sub classrooms administrators have to go in classrooms Executives have to go in the classrooms coaches have to go in the classrooms and we we've had to we've we've had to do this a lot

065in our school district because of our shortages that we do um that we do have for various reasons um we had talked about increasing the sub pay we talked about about that too um we that's a space right and then we talked about splitting classrooms and paying teachers more when that happens that's a space as well we've tackled this many different ways um we've tapped into our you know Bel retired Education Association to have ask for help even in that space as well we we do a lot of different things to make sure the classrooms are covered daily um and I don't have a perfect answer for that you know we just have to continue to to look at ways in which we can hire and retain our current staff number one U I'm sorry

066retain our current staff number one but we also have to be able to recruit um better and and when I say better that's also meaning that maybe we need to you know stretch further than you know Wisconsin and start looking you know more Midwestern spaces to see if we can get more qualifi people here which we do a little bit but I just don't I don't have a perfect answer for that one Mr Johnson you you bring up a great question but right now we're doing everything we can to make sure that there's a qualified person standing in front of students so that we can reach our academic goals Mrs Alam manderas is there anything you want to share with that just coincidentally um today we were able to review some of the upcoming Career

067Fairs um here in Wisconsin we have the first one slated for February 4th and they will include not only um full-time regular positions but also help with recruiting for a lot of other positions we have open it includes W Platville um Purdue University university of Wisconson River Fall so there are quite a few that we just signed up for in addition we're also utilizing the services of ste.org it's an organization that focuses primarily on substitutes and so through that service we are identifying opportunities that we can perhaps stretch our reach and getting substitutes into our district thank you Dr Garrison um did you want to discuss the the priority the facility safety Transportation facil um priority so we we of course aren't able to you know and in every referendum you would love to have

068everything in it and and unfortunately we will not be able to you know roll in the conversation the um transportation space currently um based off of some of the feedback that we did get from you know not only from the board but our priorities now of course paying our staff um retention um behavioral and of course academics the the cost that it will cost to roll over that $500,000 for our for our for our students and transportation is something that is not going to go away from my brain as you all know I kind of hold on to certain things and try to figure it out um we will still try to work with our city in this space um that's something that will not be included into this um referendum um that doesn't mean

069that I won't again be you know trying to figure out how we can get busing based off of possible some of our surpluses that we have but that is a space in which we um are having happen to still work um from um currently and and as pertains to our facilities as as mentioned that's something that we won't also be able to really J out delve into based off of the cost in this referendum however that maintenance piece based off of what small you know increments that we have could address some very minor things like you know siding or lights or something very small because again the savings that we have is only about $400 or so thousand are there any board members that have questions or comments for priority 3 facility safety transportation and

070infrastructure upkeep costs um so um on the PowerPoint from I guess Tuesday slide 31 the priority um three the facilities onetime expense we had $2 million and the transportation we had um 1.5 million um and don't get me wrong transportation is important to me and I it's I went to graduated from Parkview Orfordville I spent an hour and a half on the bus every day and um so I understand Transportation but I also remember there were days when I rode my bike to school and some days we even walked when when it was the the elementary school but um this one did come as a surprise regarding the high school transportation um I know when my dad graduated and lived on Alice they walk to school um and it was just an an expectation now

071I understand things are different than 50 years ago but um it's or even more um I'm more concerned about trans personally more concerned about transportation in terms of Elementary and specifically Middle School and Middle School um I I know we have sports and after school activities I want to make certain that our students that want to be involved in those things have that opportunity um so that's just a personal concern of mine and then in terms of facilities I I am concerned about the lack of green space at hackit um I I would you know love to see that and I understand that this you know we although this is a large referendum we also don't want to go you know tooo far overboard it's it's hard to find that perfect sweet spot of what

072what to request um I know some of the lighting in in around the high school could use some improvement what um what are your priorities right now in terms of facilities hacket Green Space um not the not that I had a response real fast there sorry um but hacker green spice is something that is one of my top priorities I I have to do something different there um you know just like the unfortunately the the you know with putting the ballots down we figured out how to get that done and took me took me two years to save up the money to to do those ballots in front of the high school but we did remove those you know concrete Center blocks that's been there for years um the hack of Green Space would be

073something that I think from a community project could be something that I want to explore I've already started to have conversations with you know people around can we start looking at donations for some things like this um because I do want to I number one hacker deserves it um and um I that's how that's the best way I can say it hacker deserves it we want to do right by that that green space there so it is one of my top priorities in this space our Roofing needs are very important to me as well because you know our roofs protect our building with they start to deteriorate we don't have class right that's that's how it is if your roof start to deteriorate you don't have a home and so that's that's why the roof

074the roofs are very important to our school district and it's something that we need to take care of but if I had to put this into a uh priority perspective it'll be the hacket playground in Green Space it just needs to be redone it's it's unacceptable in every every every area um we have been talking about doing some upgrad to other spaces but that hacket playground would be something that I would like to even tackle through possible community support and donations you know um in a campaign even this summer I mean I have some ideas um cuz I'm always thinking about it but the hack of green space thank you thank you any other questions on priority and transportation I'm sorry and transportation for at least the ninth and for at least the incoming nth

075graders I know it's 550,000 for everybody but maybe we can just kind of build it and so it's a little less money you know we do 9th grade and then we probably do 9th and 10th grade but it's 550,000 for all to to make it happen but maybe it could be a slow roll conversation so that's another thing that I believe should be happening for our our student population thank you thank you before we move on to priority for any last questions or comments on um the priority three transportation and um facilities facility safety transportation and infrastructure upkeep and are board members online do you guys have any questions sounds like there's none not at this time but thank you so much for checking thank you Mrs Levy um the last thanks for checking in

076I do not wonderful the last priority is priority four fund balance restoration Dr Garrison so fund balance restoration is something that again we've had to be real creative with doing over the past few years unfortunately we are set to you know not be able to pay our bills and again this been stated multiple times 26 27 school year so that's something that we know that we have to address somehow fund balance is not just used you know on a daily perspective but it's used as bills come in as well and so one of the things that I tell people you know we only get paid a couple times during the school year from the city and or from the state and what happens in between time is we use fund balance to pay bills and

077to pay staff payroll whatever it may may be needed for we use that um to to do so um we've been lucky not to have to short-term borrow only because we've been depleting our fund balance over the years due to Rising costs and inflation and and so we've I shouldn't even say lucky because right now again we're we're in this position that we're in so fund balance restoration is something that we've taken a very close look at um I can tell you based off of what you all have in the H2 scenario the the cplus deficit space um we would love to you know possibly use those funds in in that area and and help to kind of replenish our fund balance and to move us closer towards our excuse me our 18% policy um

078Miss TR that correct uh 18% thank you 18% policy that we have on on on that's supposed to be guiding us we're not there um at 18% you know we that's going to take some time to replenish even going at it the way we're going at it now um I can tell you 2728 that of course there is going to be a deficit that we have to work from and that deficit as it stands could be you know around that $20 million number so line up another referendum like like we stated is going to be very important and in that space if we can make it to that space barring a referendum being passed we will be able to possibly R address more fund balance replenishment after people see and of course our academic is

079getting better our behavior is getting better over time based off of DPI report card things have been um progressing in that in that in that in that space it gives us better credit with our public right and that that helps to support that next big conversation that could happen 3 to five years down the road which could move us closer to that 18% that we are looking for so with that being stated we will not be able to get to 18% based off of this referendum um that's not the possibilities that's that's laid out in H2 scenario thank you are there any board questions regarding the fund balance priority for seeing and hearing none I will open the floor for last questions or discussions before we move on to a motion Mr henkins thank you

080very much I just want to say a comment that uh I think it's proper that we are going to referendum and the voters will decide whether we are going to raise this tax levy or not it's a imperative that the the decision makers are not this board so much but it's the the people who have to pay the bill I know everyone's try to do a good job of educating on why we need it but as I said before it's it's in the hands of the voters and uh I think that's where it properly should be and uh I just think it's a great exercise of referendums you know actually done by the voters thank you um Brian Nichols thank you board President Johnson if the board will indulge me I have some I have

081a I have some uh historical information to to share and and and personal information kind of and uh I'd appreciate your indulg and uh hopefully you'll see where I'm going with this so um two years ago I made a personal commitment to run for the school board at that time I made a promise to the people of booy who voted for me that I would represent them I listen to them I'm a good listener and I have endeavored to keep my promise to the the best of my ability as we Face the question of presenting another request for a referendum I am torn on the board this last year it has been an enormous emotional and difficult task for all of us to to cut close to $1 million from the School District budget it's

082plain to see that we need the money personally I would love to see our teachers get the raise they deserve most of all on the other hand I promise to represent the voters I hear from all over booy not all but most people consistently share very negative views about another referendum I most concerned that I seem to hear the same thing over and over number one they don't feel heard by the board of the superintendent they still have questions about what the money is needed for specifically although we've answered a lot of those questions tonight they don't trust the board and District to spend the millions of dollars they are asking for and they are not happy with how the monies from the last referendum were spent one example that keeps coming up even even

083almost 2 years later is the money spent on The Mod remodel of Cunningham turning it into a new Middle School only to scrap that expensive project uh leaving no Middle School on the west side of booy that decision alone begs for answers some of the questions are how expensive is it to bus children across the river every day to one of the two middle schools on the east side of baloy did the B did the districts consider the inconvenience to East Side families that the B that the school district consider the effect of property values on the east side of blit that no longer offers a neighborhood middle school did the school district think that the west side of blit would just forget about their questions and concerns were basically ignored well we got the

084answer to that last April when 100% of the precincts on the west on the east side on the West Side voted no for the referendum as I continue to struggle with these questions myself and because it is my opinion that asking for a referendum and spending the money for advertising for that ask before we are assured we have have a fighting chance to get the positive answer we need will not just be a wasted expense we can ill afford psychologically it's even more costly every time a person says no they are much more likely to say no the next time we had have we have had three resounding NOS to our request for a referendum and each time the referendum has failed the nose is stronger than the time before perhaps we need to work

085a little longer answering questions providing explanations for past actions and giving me more details about where the requested monies are most needed and will be spent I have I have been I've been contacted by probably three or four people today and um all good conversations all from the heart and I was listening a lot and um unfortunately as we said here tonight with this information I can no longer support the amount of money that this District wants from the from the voters and the taxpayers based on what I'm hearing outside now one of the things that somebody mentioned today and I think it I think it warrants a discussion and some serious thought is why don't we do a one-year referendum to prove to the city and the voters that we can improve this District

086over the next year the next school year and put another referendum on the ballot next spring uh based on improved academic achievement behavioral retaining of teachers and to do that I would Advocate that we look at the former k scenar IO which has a 4% increase plus a million do additional that's $850,000 gives us a a surplus at the end of the year of 8 $810 $811,000 it could be more if we don't use all the the $1 million um and that that runs at a mill rate of 7.15 which you know reduces tax burden a little bit um someone told me uh in this one of these conversations that the average home average house home income is $56,000 I don't know if I haven't had a chance to check that information and see if

087that's valid but if that is valid then obviously they're I think there are a lot of a lot of community members that would struggle with you know a 7.53 referendum I mean a mill rate so um scenario K scenario K again goes to 4% for the for the uh for the teaching staff B including Pairs and then I would also suggest that we use a little bit of oped money to give the PE teachers a bonus to make up the other 1% because we've all been looking at 5% so um I think that made a lot of sense to me I'm not saying that that's um um anyway uh that's it that's my suggestions thank you Mr Nichols um Megan Miller your hand is up thank you so much um I really appreciate your comments

088and you're thinking I mean that's going to the voters to ask for a referendum is a huge deal uh we've spent a lot of time obviously here but outside of these meetings right I mean yeah it's no one can doubt it's it's a huge undertaking um I have a lot of empathy for what you shared particularly when we think about you know the grand scheme of how how difficult just like everyday life is right now when I ran for school board the first time I ran to represent the community and specifically the community's opinion and needs and vision for what we do for our children so we're never going to find an overwhelming Community consensus on such a huge topic because there's so much nuance and so at the end of the day while I

089don't doubt that you had really good conversations with people whose whose perspectives deserve our respect we've also heard from people who have shown up here who have reached out to to others of us offline as well who have given us a clear directive that's been delineated in all of these slides it's not an easy decision uh the the Westside School closure is something that I still feel a lot about some times there's just two you're between a rock and a hard place right and that's why we have elected people like us and others are willing to step in and just try to problem solve through th those adversity situations ultimately we're here to do what's best for our students and the community has given us a very clear vision for what they'd like to see

090for our kids it's not to say that if somebody doesn't vote in support of the referendum that they don't care about our kids like you just described beautifully there are it's it's so nuanced and there's such a range of situations and perspectives that go into in into these decisions right so I don't want to Discount anything you said but all of us chose to run for this office to represent the community with a focus on what is best for children here the dollars invested in our kids today is is the literal future of our community I would if we hadn't heard so clearly and definitively and consistently from people over these last several years exactly what they want and need I might feel a little more uncertain as well but I feel very firm and

091very confident stepping forward to say that what our Administration has worked with us to propose is solidly what voters who are interested in supporting a referendum want so again I just want to be really clear all of these feelings and thoughts are totally valid it's so important that we have that perspective because like Dr Garrison said earlier there's still so much more networking work to be done with the community I would love to shave off that $180,000 make some connections get some volunteer caring grown-ups working with their kids on reading there is so much potential in this District and we have an amazing Community an amazing community and I will never lose Faith or hope in our community despite of how these elections turn out but we owe it to the people who have voiced

092their support for a referendum and have been so clear and so consistent in painting the vision for what they want to see for all of our children in our district we owe it to them to follow through thank you thank you Miss Miller any other board members wanting to wait Mr henkins yes and uh this is very heartful uh fruitful discussion and what Mr Nichols brought up is just another option I know it's late in the game but I think Brian brings up a very valid point and so does Mrs Miller um Dr Garrison has told me from day one when I stepped into his office after I got on board you know that about referendums we don't want to go to referendum to lose we want to go to referendum to win and why

093go through all this exercise if we have a feeling that it's not going to pass Brian brings up some very good points and yes there's a lot of yes voters but there's also a lot of no voters I don't know who's what's going to happen but I do think um I think it's very fruitful that we are discussing what an option different option I know like I said that it's late in the game but if if our biggest goal is to pass a referendum I think we have to listen to everybody and I think what Megan that we what we all say here means a lot the voters will choose in the end but if we um I'm going to start rambling a little bit but I just think that those are very valid points

094the yes voters but remember there's a lot of no voters and we have to appease them too and maybe by doing some of the things that brought just brought up and I know it's late in the game I don't know if it makes it more palatable or not um I don't know we don't know we do not know uh we hear things but we don't we got to be in The Ballot Box when when everyone votes and again it's who votes and what they say and that's why I'm very happy or I'm very satisfied that this is a referendum that the voters choose it isn't a directive from the board it's it's a something put out there by in the board and uh they say yes or no so it's the voters who choose um

095I just want to give Credence to what Mr Knuckles said what we all say you know but again in the end of the day if we're trying to pass a referendum we need to talk about these um different scenarios and at least discuss them I think I don't want anybody to get uh the wrong idea that we're nitpicking or I just think that the idea in the end is to pass a referendum that's what I've heard since day one so I think this very valid points are being made and with that I'll pass thank you thank you Mr hins Mr Schneider okay um like Mr Nicholls said I've also heard from people some who who um have said Point Blank they will never support a referendum um but I've also heard from a lot of

096others that continually say this is what we need to do in this District we're not going to be able to cut our way to the top I mean at some point after we've already cut actually it's not 11 million it's actually 21 million in the last couple years out of the budget um you know to have to cut anymore is going to is definitely going to impact what we're trying to do we're not going to be able to do everything that that everybody is saying we need to do if we don't have uh the ability in order to do that um the budget that we've talked about and the requests that are here are are addressing everything that the community has said they want us to do in the district um you know and while

097I agree that maybe they they may like a shorter referendum uh period but it we didn't get to the position we're in overnight it took years it's not going to get out of where we are in one year either we have made continual gains over the last couple years we need to continue that um but we're not going to be where everybody wants at the end of next year but we need to continue making those steps and progress to move forward to get us to where we're going to be in the future and mean we've got great um leadership you the district and moving us forward to achieve what we need to achieve uh we need to get behind them and support them and give them the tools that they need to get the district

098to where everybody wants it and we're in that progress to do it now this referendum that we're looking at is putting into the referendum into the all will allow us to do what the community has asked us to do um I think going back and starting looking at something much different maybe have some options but it's it's also taking away with the community has asked us that we need to accomplish thank you any other questions or comments I do but I want to give other board members a chance okay I just um I'm going to just throw this out out there because um uh it was a good good point the median median household income in $ 2023 between 2019 and 2023 for the city of booy was $59,995 um Miss Miller thank you that's

099really helpful and thank you for sharing that that's helpful um I guess just two points one um as I'm thinking more about um vice president Nichols comments when we had our input sessions I I was at the one here that one Saturday and then the one at the library um I sat with people both times who in the past or just sat with in the Monday one but spoke with people at the Monday one who who did not vote in previous referendums to support but who showed up to share their thoughts so to say that we didn't receive feedback though from like the no voters isn't entirely accurate now certainly not every single person and that doesn't take it all away from what was just shared but I did just want to note it's not

100like we had two rooms packed full of people who were already just in support so I I did want to bring that point in um while it would be awesome if we had like the magic wand to make everything totally palatable to everybody the first commitment that we have is to our kids and these are important pieces of information to consider um regardless of what we do and how much elasticity we have to try to accommodate as much as we can there absolutely will be people who vote no it's it is impossible statistically and and probably impossible to put something on an April ballot and have everybody who shows up to vote vote Yes so I want us to also stay grounded just like I'm hearing like we need to be realistic about our ask

101right that's another part of that realism that I just I want us to stay grounded in because you stretch I'll quote Fiddler on the Roof if you stretch so far you'll break right you can only stretch so far um lastly I don't know if anybody feels like clicking around but I I went back to a previous board meeting I think it's the November 19th one I already like lost the date but when we got our state report card presentation it's on slide 13 um I'm happy to share it out um when people are talking about seeing results we've now seen three years of year-over-year growth and I want to just be really clear because I know there's some conversation about you know not being able to compare you know a couple years to this this

102previous year like this 2324 school year in comparison to other schools in the same year in the same year we outpaced the entire state of Wisconsin in academic growth so our rate of growth our rate of progress was higher than most school districts in the state of Wisconsin just in that one year just want to be clear I'm not comparing year to year because I know there were some changes so I mean that in addition to the year-over-year growth for three years is evidence of of improvement we also heard at that meeting that because of the orientation of our schools and how it used to just be the K through three that has been a hindrance to how those scores are calculated and next year we're anticipating a bump anyway because now we'll have enough

103years of that k35 68 model that work better right with like how the math maths out for that uh lastly I just want to point out on that same PowerPoint which I'm happy to share with the board and if Folks at home let me just make sure what what meeting this is oh sorry yeah it's so November 19th board meeting it's item uh here item 6A is where I found the PowerPoint uh slide 15 it talks about our state assessment forward for ELA uh for third grade went up 9.8 I mean it's just like slide after slide of growth now does that erase the work we have to do does that does that say there's oh no everything's hunky dory of course not but we have to speak truthfully about the repair that needs to

104occur and the great stuff that's happening and if we don't speak like some hope and some pride into our kids and into our community like what are we even doing here so again we had a mix of people with different opinions different perspectives different household incomes reach out to us show up in person for weeks and months and year-over-year to tell us what they want and what they need they've asked us to show growth and we've shown growth the work's not done we got a whole lot more growth to do whole lot and it's going to take the resources and the funds to do continue to grow into the vision that we all want to see so thank you Miss um Miller you know one of the things I want to just add you know

105thank you for adding those points you know as we continue to build trust you know there's value added that we you know of course we still are trying to get to on on all of our state report CS as you aware um the goal of course in every school district is to continue to move in the right direction and although we have not met the Matrix that we want to see internally yet as well as externally on state test our goal is still to keep moving in that direction and that's something that from a public perspective I would want people really to understand because when we start really talking about growth and we start talking about value added it gets it gets lost you know people don't really may not understand all of how that

106how we get to that point but we do know we want to get better and and our metrics internally you typically see increase internally before you see it happen on the state test I also don't like to put a whole lot of weight on everything that comes from just the state test because it's like there's other days in which our students are learning and doing great um but we are you know we are held accountable to this one test that happens on a day and sometime in March and everything is weighted that way and so I just want to make sure that the public understands that we still want to move in the right direction we know that we are not meeting the growth that we want to see across the board um and then

107we know there's value added that we haven't met as well but I do believe you know with continued support from everybody and that's including the board the community staff students working their working their butts off like they always do um we will start to see that growth that we you know have started to see over over time and again like I've always stated we're not there yet um we still have a ways to go um our metrics do show that you know we do have some opportunities for growth and that's just where we are right now and so um I do appreciate your thoughts Miss Mrs Miller but I also don't want people to get you know like I said when we start talking about growth they may not understand all of the the intricacies

108to that and and then it's then it becomes a a matter a matter of Are We being transparent again or do we even do we believe what we're saying um and so I just want to let people know that we do have a a ways to still yet to go we still want to keep that that Improvement um moving in this direction and with again with the support and of the community we will be able to to you know to do so um I do want to I I do need to you know speak to Mr Nicholls um statement um Mr Nichols thank you for sharing you know your perspective uh on scenario k um you know scenario K that you're referring to I might need to you know just for viewing purposes pull it

109up um so that everyone can see it um give me a second oh maybe not sorry scario K that you referring to gave us the 75 mil rate about 4% for the four years um um with a million doll of additional opportunities each year um you mentioned a year oneyear opportunity um that brought in that $800,000 giving us a little over $810,000 in Surplus for that one year um you know please note that a a scenario in one year puts us right back in that same conversation the following year with deficit it's not in built into this scenario but if we only had a oneyear refere renom the following year again we will be right back in this same conversation having to still save or make reductions because we got to we got to get

110to the following year um and in that space we right back in that 8 possible $ 8.9 million conversation because that's if we did nothing on that base part at the top of that page you're looking at we're right back at 8.9 million plus dollars of reductions that we have to have that's starting in January because the the $8 million that you send for one year gets us through this year because we have a deficit but starting in January we have to come back and line ourselves up for 2627 which is another $9 million worth of Productions we can't sustain the the the up down because again that's going to drop us back down again that instability of the mill rate and and I understand you know the thought process with with the oneyear we

111here the first time we came to this conversation we tried for the oneyear space I mean for the oneyear space just let you all know that the first time in this conversation we tried a one-year space then we did a two-year and both both opportunities fail okay and so I understand that and I know you made a statement which is accurate as it pertains to the West Side not voting voting no east side also voted a lot of NOS this past referendum so just to just to be very transparent again it's not just east side just not West Side East versus West but the reality is this past referendum they also voted no Esau did as well I don't have the precincts in front of me to give you that that accurate data there but

112I can tell you I know the majority of the East Side um precincts also voted no and so this is this is hard Bor I understand this is hard this is like I mentioned all along from the beginning this was going to be hard but I think along the way we were Landing in the space some of which you know you brought to the table Mr Nicholls um the some of the scenarios that we spoke about were scenarios that we you know that we wanted to bring back based off of some of your input you know um H1 was based based off of your input H2 was based off of kind of the board's input um and we we did that because we we heard from the boards and so that's the space that I

113wanted to also just address and again I wanted to make sure that everyone was aware that both east and west side unfortunately in the precin perspective it was a lot of nose in that space and we did try for that one year the board decided to do a two-year in year one it also was a no and the first year that we that we went to referendum two years ago not to confuse anybody but what was on the paper when we first started from the ad hoc committee was a one-year and then we we the board decided to move it to a two-year same request but for two years and and then and of course it it barely you know wasn't successful um and then of course last year here we are now thank you

114Dr garon Brian Anderson yeah thank you so I think um you know just to give feedback on board member Nicholls comments I think you know we look back at you know the first referendum our second Year's referendum and I I agree you know I I supported Oney year referendums under the aaces of let's let's ask for the minimum amount prove it out and earn the right to ask for more and and unfortunately we didn't get a chance to do that because we didn't try for the one year like Dr Garrison just said so um I can fly support the the the logic of that and and and could still support you know some this time around that said hey we're going to ask maybe we're asking for less than what we want what we need

115what we've heard to you know you know because we're not supporting the full wish list um maybe it's maybe it's still three years maybe it's not um but there's a danger in going too low as well and I think uh not so much with dollar Mount by but by timeline so I think where I could get on board with a lower dollar Mount um the the time frame I wouldn't want to shrink up I think um some stability there would or lack of stability if you go less than three years at this point I supported one year each of the last two times um I think at this point it just it probably should be longer um so I would just say I think as we've worked through this process I I can get on

116board with what you're saying um but on the 16th of January we also have to come to a consensus um so I just I wanty to make sure we're moving this process forward versus eternally coming up with well what if because we could we could what what if ourselves passed January 21st and not have a question on the ballot at all so those are just my thoughts thank you Brian Anderson Brian Nichols your hand is raised just want to clarify a couple things number one uh my comments do not preclude me from working my you know what off talking knocking on doors uh talking to people at Walmart Menards uh wherever that you know we need we need help you know the district needs help and Now's the Time so uh I just I just

117want to share that with with everybody um you know but again I you know I take I take the duties that I signed up for seriously and I take the people that I res represent seriously to and they have serious they have serious comments and serious concerns and that's that's what I brought to you so thank you for listening thank you for the the extra time and uh I appreciate all you guys I really do so thank you thank you Brian Nichols any other board questions or comments um so I attended last night's um ad hoc committee meeting and the my takeaway message from that meeting last night all of us in this room and the cabinet members that are not in this room we've got our work cut out ahead of us we all

118know the dire Financial need of the district we're asking a lot of our constituents of our families and it's you know it's an unfortunate situation that we are in now we would all love to not be here but we all need to be the strong leaders that we are that we have within ourselves to be our students deserve it our staff deserve it we need to have consistency from the top down throughout the entire system we have to have respect for one another we have to support one another I think I've made these comments last May when I took this seat and I'm saying them again now because there are over 5,000 reasons we should be voting for this referendum 5,000 plus the 800 employees that we have as well um I hear their stress

119their burden and it's really unfortunate then when we in this room are not reflecting what we want to see in our very own District we have 2 and 1 half months to go out there and earn the trust and the respect of our constituents I look at this referendum when I'm wearing my board hat and yeah hey we need this we have to do this but I also am a realist and I've got bills I'm not making a whole hill of beans sitting up here as a board member none of us are regardless of what the public may think we we aren't this is a lot of hours we are putting forth this is the fourth night in a row I am at a meeting in this building it's we still can do better and

120we have to do better my suggestion my personal suggestion is between now and April 1 the administration think about what more can and we do I know it feels like we've done everything we can like we have given all the Blood Sweat and Tears we possibly can but I know that there is more we can do what other reductions can be made it's say I will say it's very hurtful as a board member when we are disrespected by the cabinet publicly that needs to stop we appreciate our cabinet members we don't attack our cabinet members we ask questions because we are curious because we care we need to work together better so all seven of us all four or five of you guys I'm tasking you I am asking you I am pleading let's all

121do better together because our students deserve it let's show our public we are putting our students and our teachers first with that I will entertain a motion for the approval of the resolution authorizing the School District budget to exceed revenue limit by 9,170 th000 for the 2025 2026 school year by 14,1 120,000 for the 2026 27 school year and by $1,950,000 for the 2728 school year for non-recurring purposes consisting of operational and maintenance expenses including teacher and staff compensation and academic and behavioral resources so moved so move second motion by Greg Schneider seconded by Amy ly any discussion Miss Miller yeah I just want to kind of honor the space and I just want to just offer some gratitude to everybody you know in the room virtually everybody who's put the work into this um

122as we've just experienced very much in real time tonight this is really hard emotionally mentally Psy logically for everybody um and that's not like a oh woe is us I just this this is a huge thing and I'm just very grateful to everybody involved thank you thank you Miss Miller anyone else say this real quick oh Dr Garrison sure I would like to appre I appreciate the school board for their you know cander and of course their um space in this work like I said this is hard work um I take full responsibility for any um actions that you know comes from you know my team um to the board um I also take full responsibility I hate to interrupt but just point of order since we are in the discussion for the motion the

123discussion should really stay on the motion that's on the floor not that these other things shouldn't be addressed I just don't think this is the moment sure and I what I was going to say to that Mrs Levy was that this work is hard um whatever the motion um is is in this space I appreciate the work of of the team um the cabinet and of course the board working through this this this this space and thank you for correcting me as well thank you Dr Garrison thank you Mrs Levy any other discussion on the resolution if a roll call is not re if it's not required I'm requesting one please thank you it's requir yeah it is required um anyone else anyone online I seeing none M sh a roll call please certainly Greg

124Schneider I Amy Levy I Brian Nichols n Brian Anderson hi Tom henkins I Megan Miller I and tia Johnson I motion carried 6 to one the next item on the agenda is the resolution providing a referendum election on the question of approval of a resolution authorizing the School District budget to exceed revenue limit by 9,170 th000 for the 2526 school year and by 14,1 120,000 for the 2627 school year and by $6,950 for the 2728 school year for nonrecurring purposes um for um procedure purposes um Miss Miller do you know do I read the resolution before the motion or after I'm going to defer to miss CH or our parliamentarian Miss leevy I would assume before the the policy says that you really only have to read the title of the moot of the resolution

125which is what you have read um and then the part that goes on with the consisting of operation and maintenance Etc is just part of the motion to make it clear for everybody okay so the policy I'm looking at is 183 rule one and um number three it says in the interest of administrate of efficiency the reading of resolutions verbatim into the record as required by Robert's Rules of Order may be waved by a majority vote of the board and such resolutions May then be read into to the record by title only so we would need um a um motion um it's it's a two and a half page resolution if if board members want me to read it I will if somebody wants to make a motion that either way I'm good I move

126that we wave the reading of the entire resolution and and just go with the the title second we have a motion to wave the reading of the full resolution and just the title by Greg Schneider seced by Amy Levy all in favor I I I any oppose hearing none motion carries unanimously and my my AP iies I forgot to ask for a discussion um okay so with that then may I get an A motion for approval of the resolution so moved second motion for approval of the resolution as is by Greg Schneider seconded by Amy Levy any discussion hearing none may we please have a roll call Vote Yes may I clarify did you want the extended information with the operation and maintenance expenses or did you want it cut off at just the title

127for the actual motion um oh oh oh the meaning you're looking at the recommended action mhm um yes because we will need all of that because that is that is the am I looking at the same thing here yes yeah we need all of it in there okay that's I mean that's the way it comes up for me on board dos but I wanted to make sure that you were all aware that all of that would be in there so Mr Schneider for clarification then so your res your motion then is everything that I had read earlier plus where it continues for non-recurring purposes consisting of operational and maintenance expenses including teacher and staff compensation and academic and student behavioral resources that is correct thank you okay thank you um Megan Miller I Tom henkins

128I Brian Anderson I Brian Nichols n Amy Levy I and Greg Schneider I and tia Johnson I motion carried 6 to one thank you Miss chop I will entertain a motion for adjournment so moved second motion by Megan Miller seconded by Brian Nichols any discussion Dr Dr Anderson I mean Dr Garrison sure um about at the adjournment place since the there was a possible meeting that was posted for tomorrow do do need to announce that that that will be counseled at this point okay thank you Dr Garrison so there will not be a meeting tomorrow we've all in favor I I I any oppos motion carries unanimously thank you everyone for coming out tonight have a good evening

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.