CorpusRecord 82705

TLE & Pupil Services Committee; Regular Board Meeting - 1/14/2025 (5:00 p.m.)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / School District of Beloit
Date
2025-01-15
Location
Rock County, WI
Material
Transcript
Extent
16,032 words · about 90 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e it is 5:00 so I call this meeting of the teaching learning equity and pupil Services committee to order Mrs shop can we have a roll call please yes yes Megan Miller present tom henkins is UN unable to join us this evening and Greg Schneider I'm present um all members are present except tom henkins can I have an approval of the the agenda so moved and I will second that all in favor say I I I motion carries can I have approval of the minutes of the last meeting so moved and I will second that uh any discussion I did watch the video from the last meeting so I I don't think I was able to be present um for the whole time so I just want to verify that I feel comfortable voting

002I for the minutes great and thank you all right um all in favor I I motion carries that takes us to item 2A um an update from the math department good evening um I am Dr Kelly grude um and I have with me here Meredith fall cavage come a little bit closer and we are here to represent the the math department for the district um and provide a little bit of an update um as we do every year um tonight we're going to really focus on our year 2 implementation of our Eureka math squared core curriculum and the implementation of our imagine math um supplemental curriculum um I always like to start these presentations um by sharing our math vision statement we worked very hard to develop this statement um in collaboration with students and

003teachers and so I think in order to honor that work and to really ground our work I'd like to share that here so our math vision is in our mathematical classrooms we strive to develop mathematically proficient students who project confident math identities and who believe they are capable lifelong math Learners and as I was putting um this vision statement into our slide deck for today um I was remembering an interview uh with a a really great math educator and math education researcher kindall Brown um and in his book he wrote a book with another woman named Pam um in their book uh they really think about mathematical identity ities and the importance of developing mathematical identities in really building student outcomes and so in an interview he talks about the fact that many of us

004think that the only thing that counts as math is what we do in math classrooms we tend to think about math as something that happens in school and we don't see ourselves as math people because we don't recognize all of the different ways that we use math when we're engaging in the real world so we asked the question how do we undo the perception and get people to recognize that the Myriad of ways that we're engaging in mathematical and thinking all the time and so that's really the spirit of our math Vision we want our students to see themselves as mathematically capable during their math classes but also users and Learners of math when they're not in the classroom and when they're out in the world and so we um have really been as you

005know digging in and doing research on what can change mathematical outcomes because we recognize that our math outcomes are not where we want them to be in the district so there is research around um trajectory changing districts what do districts do to really truly change the outcomes and the predictability of outcomes for students and there's sort of three legs um of research uh that districts that really change their outcomes all sort of lean in on one is building belonging one is working towards consistency and the last one is developing coherence so in building belonging we're really thinking about that identity building um space how do students see themselves in that that learning space consistency is really thought of not perfect lessons every day but the accumulation of good lessons over and over and over again

006a lesson does not need to be perfect for students to make gains but we cannot have those be inconsistent we have to make those small gains every day to change outcomes and then in developing coherence districts that really change their outcomes are districts who have a coherence between what students experience in interventions what they experience in their core classroom what they experience when we're trying to stretch and grow them through enrichment and what they experience when they go home and they have experiences around their learning and so we're going to talk a little bit about um some actions that we've been taking over the last year or so and what we're what we're starting to see um in we could talk as you know for days about any of these items so I have highlighted

007a handful that we're going to lean in on today CU I know I don't have that much time um so we're going to really think about how do we help our students support sens making and their identity development what do we do to help accumulate those good lessons over and over through professional learning and the use of the materials and then how are we really trying to build that alignment between our core intervention and extension Pathways for students um so you as you are aware and I put this in here cuz I wasn't sure if there would be people who weren't here when we did our adoption but you are both aware that we did an adoption last year of our core materials um and that we really tried to find some core materials that

008were both highly rated and really good at helping students make sense so I've provided an example problem from third grade where students are being asked to really compare different strategies for solving a problem and determine do all of those strategies work and which one is best and that question of best is really open-ended because when best in one situation is not necessarily best in another and the importance of of really building sens making into math again goes back to that original quote students don't just do math in their classroom so if we only teach them to identify a strategy for a certain type of problem we're not setting them up for Success when they leave our classrooms so we've been um really working with teachers over the last year and a half to help them

009understand the design of those materials and how they can really use them in their classroom and again this goes back to that idea of consistency we really want to see teachers accumulate good lessons every day build their mathematical education or instructional identities and help our students build their mathematical identities this is data from last year we did three rounds of learning walks where we looked at the implementation um of the new math curriculum materials and what we saw is that as the year went on we had more and more teachers move from being aware of the materials to really sort of experimenting and exploring those materials so they were maybe using parts of the lesson correctly and other parts they were deviating from the design a little bit to really starting to use the materials

010as they're designed and even adopt them and make them their own and so we did see an increase over the course of the year um I'm happy to say that we're in the process of doing learning walks again um and what we're seeing is that this shift is continuing 65% % of the classrooms that we've been in this year would be in that implementing bucket so we've had very strong implementation of this core material our teachers are really learning how to use it well and use it with Integrity it's it's quite amazing um yep I just wanted to add to that um sorry Kelly interrupt you uh that we often get asked about the power of coaching and so okay well good so we brought we've talked about this so I just wanted to make

011sure that it was in the air because we've talked about the research that we've brought you know and that the Department of Public Instruction supports instructional coaching as a best practice but this is really a demonstration that if we're looking for more localized data Beyond just our achievement Gap reduction data which is also an example of the value of instructional coaching this is more of a a real immediate because this type of implementation can't uh necessarily be done um in this way to improve practice and to move teachers along the Continuum if there wasn't instructional coaching so again this is a more localized data set to show the impact of coaching awesome I won't have to say as much later we're all on the same wavelength um so it's it's true a lot of what

012we're what we're seeing in our classrooms and we'll talk a little bit more about this is is because we've got training and coaching working hand inand um now I don't want to make this all shiny right there are still challenges for our implementation and one of those is that the Middle School curriculum is very packed there is a lot um with it embedded within that curriculum and so teachers have to learn how to pick and choose with the time that they have the things that are going to be um the most impactful for students and and our teachers are still learning to do that work they have grown tremendously over the last year in doing that work but they are still growing and ping is still a challenge for our Middle School teachers and we'll

013talk a little bit about some of the work that we're doing to try to mitigate that challenge um so as Teresa mentioned um our coaching staff has really been Central to making sure that we have strong implementation without our coaches working as partners alongside the teachers helping them unpack those materials in the moment teaching them things like how to do a unit internalization unit internalization helps our teachers see out ahead of the lesson that they're doing for this day right helping them really start to to build those skills in their plc's and their their professional learning days without our coaches we would not be seeing the the strong implementation that we are um so coaching as we as we mentioned coaching when coupled with training supports the implementation that's that implementation science that I talked

014about during our AGR presentation um for our Middle School teachers in addition to doing this work with coaches we've also built into our professional learning time some time for peer um what we call lesson study and so lesson study is a set of practices where teachers identify a lesson that they're going to be teaching in the near future they really study it deeply and they c-plan they think about what moves are we going to do when we're teaching this lesson and then as each teacher teaches the lesson the other teacher visits their classroom to provide some feedback this is peer-to-peer it does not involve feedback from us sometimes they invite the coaches to participate but it's not required right and so this is really helping them become more comfortable in the kinds of decision-making that

015they have to do as they're doing the implementation and we are seeing our Middle School teachers pick up the pace and use the materials with a lot more Fidelity and also with a lot more confidence okay so that last piece about coherence um we have been working over the last year and a half as we have gotten to know and as our coaches have gotten to know the materials better to make sure that our tier 2 interventions and our extension activities are actually aligned to each unit in the curriculum so we have gone back through and our coaches have really taken the lead on on supporting the the development of some tier 2 um implementation Pathways or intervention Pathways so our coaches have gone back through and they've looked at if a student is going

016to be learning about multiplication in their daily math lessons what are those prerequisite skills that they need to be successful in that classroom can we use our intervention to get out ahead of those skills so when they see that coming up in their classroom they feel equipped to engage at in that grade level learning and so we've really redesigned our imagine uh math Pathways for tier 2 intervention to get out ahead of the core learning and really be aligned coherently to that core learning on the opposite end of the spectrum Meredith and I have been working with our Advanced learning team to develop a set of extension activities that will allow students who are in the classroom and moving ahead quickly through that Core Curriculum to not get bored and lose ground on their growth

017either and so um we've identified threea math tasks different math games and we've included problem-based learning units for every single module that we have grades uh kindergarten through fifth grade in our Core Curriculum that has been a lot of the curriculum writing work that we've been doing this last year so as a teacher um is working with students in the classroom and they have a student that's out ahead of other students they can grab these lessons and use them in that day-to-day classroom to keep the the the students on the highest end of of achievement moving forward as well and then just one more note about why that coherence work is so important we have really um done a good job with imagine math of keeping track of our data and being able to use

018the data because it is such a rich data set to understand the impact of students using imagine math on their actual outcomes and growth and so without going into all of the statistics although I'd be happy to answer some questions about that um when there's time um we know with statistical certainty for our students in our district in their classrooms on their own assessments that imagine math has a direct and positive impact on their outcomes for both map and now for forward we've been able to study it with forward as well and so the charts here the bar charts here are showing the implementation of Imagine math in terms of minutes and the numbers of lessons passed from last year in blue to this year in red our schools as they've learned about the impact

019of Imagine math on student learning are picking up and using that tool more consistently and so the the the goal in terms of minutes is 45 minutes a week we are currently sitting around 60 and the goal for passing lessons a week is two and we are sitting at 3 and so our schools are doing a very good job of finding the tools that work and putting them in for implement ation so again consistency coherence building that belonging and identity those are the ways that we get out of the space that we're in and move to something better but it takes time for us to be able to see that in a meaningful way and so it's going to be a few more years um before we see those outcomes really show up in a

020meaningful way I think on our state tests and and so with that in mind um we are asking um as we move forward because you know this is probably my last update to this committee um that we that the board really consider approving down the line a renewal of Eureka Math when that comes forward in the 26 27 school year and the renewal of our imagin math um supplemental uh tool because those are the things that we know are moving our learning forward and then to continue to support those things that teachers need for their professional learning coaching so that they can get better at their routines um understand the curriculum better really use those intervention and extension materials well and that time during professional learning for that peer-to-peer engagement through lesson study so that's

021all I have anything okay open for questions great thank you so much um any questions okay go ahead thank you um all so much for this update and I I mean I'm I'm already like really excited because even going back to when we adopted this just the process of the the the utilization of student voice and like those groups and just making sure that this was the right fit right for our kids and um you know and our teachers is just so impressive already and so I'm really like not surprised but happy to see that this is yielding such wonderful results and I also really appreciate that you provided that Roi data like just like what are we really you know it sounds and and not that it doesn't matter to say oh kids and

022teachers are enjoying using this because it absolutely does because you have to engage but also like you have the results to you know it just it was just a phenomenal thing that we've seen develop and I I hope we continue to sustain and support it um just to comment too um the pbl the Project based learning piece is just so important I think just helps us be inclusive for our kids especially those who are neurodiverse and like more handson who need that additional relevance and I think too just that peer-to-peer coaching um just want to celebrate the ability of whoever is like working on scheduling I mean I'm sure that's like our largely our principls and counselors and you know teacher input to make that even possible cuz like peer-to-peer feedback is so powerful our

023coaches honestly often times take over classrooms when when teachers are visiting each other's classrooms and yeah and that was actually going to be my question was just if you could just elaborate a little bit um just to give us like a really like clear visual picture of like what is coaching look like in the classroom and like I think like you've done a beautiful job in this presentation saying like hey we've developed this lesson and that lesson here's this whole toolkit we've done this curricul mock for you and all the stuff um maybe just to kind of help build that understanding but yeah that's amazing thank you so much sure so uh our coaches do a variety of different things um sometimes they're working directly with students in an intervention so they might actually take

024a few students from a classroom and do that intervention um often times they're they're visiting classrooms making observations of um what's happening and bringing those observations back either to a teacher directly because they've agreed to do a coaching cycle so that's a teacher that's asking for some support um or learning and they want to get back so the coach goes make some observations they go back they have some conversation they set some goals and then they work for a number of weeks together to try to reach those goals or the coach might make observations and take those observations back to their plc's and talk strategically with the team about what kinds of changes they might want to make and what goals they have our coaches also meet with their admin teams on a weekly basis

025to make sure that the admin teams understand the kind of math learning and where um professional development could support the building um where extra eyes hands might support the building right so they're really they're really kind of the eyes and ears of the building and then they also do as you saw some District level work helping us connect the intervention tools um helping us meet our goals sometimes supporting the district level professional learning so they wear a lot of hats they really do thank you so much I really appreciate that um thank you for all your work the only thing I was going to add is um just to lift this up a little bit um more and I can send it to you or you can just find it uh she referenced it in

026the upper corner opportunity makers so those are the folks tntp that put out opportunity myth I don't know maybe like five years ago was very well known document and so this is the second document that they just put out this year and it's a a national white paper basically about what school districts are doing that are um like ours that are coming out of covid and what some of the characteristics of successful school districts that are moving in the right direction and these are the three buckets those themes that were coming out of those school districts were uh to build belonging to work towards consistency and develop coherence so we did um a pressure test on that to see where we were at in our district and some of the initiatives that are coming out

027of our department and so that's what this chart shows what the descriptions are um in those buckets and then the things that we're doing that demonstrate evidence towards those things because of this National white paper that was put out for districts across the country that are are that are showing growth and doing the right thing so to speak um to to move uh student outcomes I really appreciate that and I guess last thoughts I'm sorry thank you chair Schneider um yeah I mean I think just my biggest takeaway that I sorry I got distracted because I got really excited by the last few things you talked about but just overall like this is all just it's all student centered right like the white you know being timely with the research like thank you so much

028for like you know it's it's part of that continuous improvement process and I mean as a parent I have three kids who love math and I'm like genetically not responsible for that but I mean they must this must really be working um and I mean just like that alone right making it about kids meeting their individual needs and having those systems that can sustain doing that is just it's a huge lift so thank you so much thank you there is an increase a visible increase in student engagement um I've been on the learning walks these last couple of weeks and you're seeing many more students engaged and the other thing I found impressive was um evidence of academic vocabulary and precision tending to Precision of academic vocabulary modeled by both the teachers and then usage

029and application by the students um and so that's critical thank you okay President Johnson do you have any question questions or comments no I don't thank you okay Dr Garrison I like thank the team for the presentation and then as Mrs uh Dr grard mentioned that you know this is will be her last um teaching and learning on Equity committee meeting and thank you for all the work that you've done and of course even in doing this presentation for the board um for the committee um you know math is something that we have to continues to make sure students see it in their everyday lives you know um as you mentioned in the beginning of your conversation I think that's probably one of the most important spaces that we can bring to the math conversation

030is to make sure that our students sees themselves as math people and so um thank you for the presentation and again um this update okay thank you I'm again um just excited about the change that we're seeing in our students as they they continue to develop in math and and this kind of a curriculum now math was my favorite subject in school um so I took every math class I could possibly take and then a few um but the more I hear about what we're doing in this District I wish I was in place when I was in school because I think even I would have benefited from from the development that's there and and it's so great to see the what coaching is doing to help improve those scores to get student and teacher

031engagement and and uh sticking with the curriculum um you know I think both of these have really been a great for the district and as we continue to move forward so we definitely support those things in the future um again thank you so much for uh for the presentation and the up update and Dr Guru good luck in your future um we will miss you here at the meetings um as you've always had a lot of great information for us so good luck thank you okay that takes us to item 3A open enrollment space DET termination I can kick us off as they um bring this presentation up um every year this is the Open Enrollment as I say that it pops on the screen but this is our open enrollment space determination conversation um

032this is something that again comes up yearly at this space and then of course we'll turn it over to uh Mrs beavers and and the team good evening Missy beavers executive director of pupil service I'm here with Eric Eric Weir director special ed in student services and we are here as an annual requirement to present open enrollment space determination to the board in the month of January so I'm just going to go through the basics real quick this is not going to be a long presentation but just a reminder of what open enrollment is um open enrollment is a process to allow parents to apply for there are students to attend a public school in a district H in a um Community other than which they live there are two ways to apply there's a

033regular application period this year the application period is from February 3rd going through April 30th and then there's also an alternative application process um applying for the current school year and that begins July 1st and that is um uh fillable application only cannot do that online um like I said this is an annual requirement by the state to do January space determinations um it's required that the school board designate General and special education spaces available for the next school year so when we're talking to we're talking about the 25 26 school year um because the window opens soon um we must reference the criteria by which we designate space in our enrollment policy which we do we revised policy last year um and then criteria must be applied consistently so that decisions on Space are

034not arbitrary or under unreasonable so um if we wish to if a district wishes to consider space available um for special education or related Services it's got to determine the criteria in which it will um use relative to the space or the staff capacity and Eric's going to go over that shortly it might it must be outlined and followed exactly and consistently for every single student who applies um and I just want to remind everybody on the committee that there are no state or federal special education case load requirements so when we're going through this there is no requirement by the state that says you cap um special education case loads at 20 there's nothing that says that with the exception of Occupational Therapy um physical therapy and speech and language and Eric will probably

035touch on that so I'm going to pass it to him all right uh so this chart here that you see is the criteria that we use uh to determine our special education seat allocations uh we look each building across the district um we have established the case load size based off of Wisconsin's um recommendations they offer not case load determinations but they've embraced a workload model so having districts look at not just number of students but level of need um and kind of balancing out the legal paperwork requirements that come along with supporting a student with special needs as well as just the number of students they're providing specially designed instruction to throughout the course of a week so you can see we have our high school case loads kept at 18 our middle schools

036are at 16 and our elementaries are at 14 like Missy mentioned occupation therapy Physical Therapy speech and language there State Statute that still gives a concrete number so we have that 45 is For Occupational Therapy physical therapy and speech and language 35 uh we then just take the current staff that we have or FTE that we have available for special education teachers or therapists uh assigned to each of those sites and if we multiply the case load Criterion by that person we get the capacity and then we look at projected enrollment and when we're looking at projected enrollment we're looking at our current number of students who will be rolling over into next year but we're also factoring in the average or typical number of students that we have that just move into our district

037annually to determine that projected enrollment um and then when you take capacity and projected enrollment um and do the difference that's where you get how many spaces uh seats we have available so you can see at our secondary level we're actually uh over our capacity uh projected for next year so we would not be opening seats at the high school and middle school level um we had a large influx of students that moved into our district in those grade levels this year which contributed to uh some of that we have open seats at the elementary level and then you can see this year or projected for next year we also have some open seats for students who would require Physical Therapy occupational therapy and speech and language those are Services uh well occupational Physical Therapy

038are services that are provided so a student can't come and just get those Services there has to be a seat available um in one of the numbers up above for them to be able to um receive those and then speech and language it depends if it's a primary disability there would be seat uh opens but if it's just a related service we would have to look then if there's seats available in the grade that they're coming in at so what we are asking tonight is that the committee um move this forward to the full board because like Missy mentioned uh we have to do this annually in January and our proposed motion would be the following that the board approve unlimited general education enrollment seats and the following seat allocations for special education for the

0392025 26 school year and that would be grades 9 through 12 zero seats grade 6 through 8 Z seats grades 4K through 515 seats Physical Therapy 37 seats occup ational therapy 30 seats and speech and language seats okay any any questions any questions or comments M Miller thank you uh thank you both so much for the presentation it's so important for us to see I think this information um thank you for taking the time to put this together and explain everything I actually have a question for Dr Garrison um so you know as we hear more and more about potential budget state budget p pieces um for this next two-year budget is the information that was just shared in this presentation something that we would or could use to make determinations like if there were

040to be an increase in special education reimbursement is that what is this let me make sure I'm asking the right question is the information that was shared this evening about where we're already over capacity based on needs something that we would use to determine like Staffing for example so Staffing is always predicated around the needs of the students naturally and especially in the area of special education we have to have certain staff or certain um students needs so if there is a increase in special education funds from this from the state we will use those funds accordingly um to staff not only the General Ed populations needs but also for our special education needs I hate to say one goes over the other because we have to service all students but in this case we

041definitely need special education teachers um we've always had a you know um some Alles there um they are becoming more and more hard to find um and so having that special education opportunity with extra help from the state we would definitely probably want to lean in and try to support more in special education department because again we just don't have a lot of um well we have the needs but the staffing has been the concern no I really appreciate that and the reason that I asked is this is a fantastic presentation I don't have any other questions for either of you thank you so much I would just love to see this maybe the same presentation maybe come up again when we have a better sense of what our funding will be probably this summer

042we'll hear in July it'll just be good to maybe Factor this into all of our decision- making so thank you so much okay good uh President Johnson no okay um just some comments that as I look at the number um and I know that you mentioned that there's no hard and fast number for the allowable seats um but I really appreciate this the holding the the case load size at a reasonable number um so that it is possible for the staff that we have to actually provide the services that are needed for the students um and the only way that can happen is to is to keep the numbers that they're working with at a much lower level so I greatly appreciate all of that um I have no other questions so I'd like to

043entertain a motion to approve and to recommend to the full board unlimited general education enrollment seats and the following seat allocations for special education enrollment for the 2025 26 school year um grades 9 through 12 zero grades 6 through 8 Z grades 4K through 5 15 Physical Therapy 37 occupational therapy 30 speech and language 28 so moved and I will second that any discussion all in favor say I I I motion carries thank you so much for the presentation and that will then move us to um item 3B new course proposals and this is the second time that we are looking at um these new courses for the boo Learning Academy P right on too is is it yeah I need red and green here okay so I'm not the the technology director director of

044CTE and alternative education um working with my uh my colleague here Kelly grud on science and we've got uh Betsy schroer uh the principal at bla so this is the second presentation of two new courses um for bla and I just want to make sure that in the presentation this slide deck talks about Parts a and parts B two pieces we are only looking at electricity and magnetes ISM part a right now is a new course where foreshadowing Part B would be coming afterwards and then when we look at the frenic science course it has part A and Part B we already have part A we're looking at Part B as an extension so a for one and B for the second one um so these two classes again electricity and magnetism is part one

045this is a course that would um align a little bit better with what we have at BL Memorial High School for this um it would be something that aligns with Kelly what class is it the physical science the physical science class so there's more continuity between the the two high schools um in that matter and then the forensic science class again we have the part A or part one of that class we're looking at part two and extending that and again that one um moves to how do how do we analyze a scene or a crime or some other bits of information they've already done some analysis and in the first stages now we're looking to develop that um a little bit more deeply again measurement looking at uh analyzing the evidence with that trying

046to do some images castings what this uh might haveen try to recreate the scenario for this so again this is an extension of a class that we already have with these two proposals there is no FTE change these are classes that we currently uh we have Staffing for them currently at this point it allows us to expand our bla science Pathways with that and again the one course aligns much more closely with uh Belo Memorial High School and the cost that you see on on the on the oops on the proposal sheets are for parts both A and B so they are not an individual piece um we've looked at those again we want this to be cohesive having two sections to them um and that's kind of where that where that budget piece comes

047from okay anything else and so tonight we're asking the the committee to go ahead and pass this along to the full board for approval we are again on a different timeline than Belo Memorial High School forall we schedule classes because we do a term by term our students turn over a little bit more and so we don't project a whole Year's schedule out for them we do them in a in a little bit different fashion but it's timely because we want these for second semester moving on to uh this for this school year thank you for your presentation any questions or comments thank you so much for this presentation and I'm very excited to support this just like two quick questions um one um so there's forensic science um is sort of like an entry

048way um like elect requirement right at BTC for like a lot of their programs and like especially like for I think like public safety stuff um is there has there been like a partnership explored with um like the technical college for um any like kind of course planning or opportunities on campus we haven't yet with that again those are those are things that are that are out there we would like to yeah so as we fully develop this course into a part A and A Part B and now we have something that we feel has a possibility to align that would be again as we do with BL Memorial bring bla into this is there an opportunity to align this with with Blackhawk Tech something for us to pursue so thank you no absolutely that's

049awesome and also like um so my all mod W Platville also has like a really cool forensic science like that's on your radar like um I've actually like in gajillion years ago took a group of students out there to kind of do the there like a whole crime scene house thing it's really neat so I just wanted to pitch that yeah thank you yeah thank you so much okay uh President Johnson any thoughts or comments Dr Garrison um yes I would like to hear from Mrs um Dr schroer as well um and I think you always you know have some great insights as it pertains to the class and your thoughts around it um just very excited our uh science teacher Hannah mck is always Innovative taking field trips so thank you for those ideas

050um she just recently went to the cave of the Mounds in the planetarium up in Madison so I have no doubt she'll be wanting to go to Platville next um but just excited about our teacher Innovative um ideas and just looking at always providing uh more exciting opportunities for courses so thank you and and a Shameless plug um I think one of the careers that I that they thought I could do when I did that little you know self-questionnaire was crime scene investigator one of them and so um that was a very long time ago um but thank you so much for your presentation I think you know more we get our you know students opportunities to look at things differently even in the area of forensic science is a great opportunity for our students

051thank you great um just one question how many students are currently enrolled in the forensic science part a course that is being offered term three usually between 20 and 25 I haven't looked at the number this week but um always it's very popular we always have over 20 students in that class great uh and the one thing that I really like about both of these course proposals as well as meeting you know the high quality U math standards they both all lead to much higher level thinking skills to develop to be able to go through those and both the electric electricity and magnetism directly relates into into careers into jobs within the bloid area um you know the the part A is definitely aligned to power production and distribution um which is which is a

052large area here in forensic science of course is always around um both of them also begin to relate to the medical field or or the forensic science to the medical field um and so a lot of excitement and and things that are there um a great way to um engage your students in some exciting courses uh to prepare them for the future um just just to piggyback on that um I just wanted to to sort of pin this point the curriculum that's going to be used for the electricity and magnetism course is a uh really highly rated um science curriculum resource now and it is an open educational resource so it's one that they're constantly testing and updating and it's been um really really well received for both high school and middle school science and

053they've just recently um released an elementary one as well yep okay sorry board member Schneider and and board member Miller you both brought up two things that blend my job as alternative education but also Career Tech Ed and College and Career ready or these opportunities they do blend and they're not separated and having you know an Innovative teacher who asks can we do this can we bring this forward and then having you know a science colleague who you know I'm a math major and a science minor and I have some of that but I also rely upon Kelly a lot for some of these pieces and to look at what are those curriculum ones but you're right it does blend into it's not just a class at bla it talks about you know high level

054standards thinking skills career related skills dual credit opportunities that might possibly be out there so these are the these are those stepping of how do we get there and we need to start with the courses to um you know to to be in place first of all but I appreciate the both of you lending in that vision of what's out what's afterwards great well again thank you very much for your presentation and I'd like to entertain a motion to recommend to the full Board of Education the addition of electricity and magnetism part one and forensic science part two courses uh beginning in the spring of 2025 so moved and I will second that and any discussion all in favor I I motion carries thank you so much okay that brings us to item four our

055next meeting date will be Tuesday February 18th at uh 2025 at probably five o'clock at that point um Okay can entertain a motion for adjournment so moveed I will second that all in favor I I we are adjourned thank you e e e good evening it is 601 I would like to call to order the regular board meeting uh for Tuesday January 14th Miss sh may I get a roll call please yes Megan Miller present tom henkins here uh Brian Anderson here Tia J uh let's go to Greg Schneider present Amy Levy here Brian Nichols Here and Now Tia Johnson here all members are present may I get an approval of the agenda um before we second um would it be possible to amend the motion to approve the agenda to remove the legislative update

056um we just got an email this morning and I'm going to that changes it so I'm going to present next time c c um is that okay board vice president Nicholls um okay and since we're doing that um vice president Nichols do you have any objections to if we remove the board president report not at all is there a second for second point of clarification what was the first item the legislative update was the first one and the board president report thank you uh all in favor of approval of the agenda with removal of those two um reports to the board i i i i i any oppose motion carries unanimously tonight for our Pledge of Allegiance we have Dr Betsy schroer from the blit Learning Academy to introduce a student from the bla good

057evening thank you so much for having us uh I am here with our student Alex he is a junior this year on Pace for graduation and joined bla as a freshman of a very talented artist self-taught pianist and just allaround a great student to have at bla so without further Ado here you go Alex I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you so much Alex and thank you Dr schroer next we have upcoming events and announcements and um M Miller is going to read those in um board member henin's absence he's he's with us via phone but not in person all right thank you very much good evening the board

058of education has had several meetings lately including two about the referendum this spring a reminder that there is no school this Friday January 17th for staff professional learning and report card writing day watch for report cards to be sent home on Friday January 24th there is also no school on Monday January 20th in observance of Dr Martin Luther King Jr day there are several celebrations in the community that you can attend to Lear learn more about this great man coffee connections at the blender Cafe resume on Wednesday January 22nd with our teaching learning and Equity Department Staff feel free to step out between or sorry to stop out between 4:30 and 6:30 pm to talk with them ask questions or stop in to say hello board members and administration will be uh sorry attending the

059State education convention next week our Belo Memorial Jazz Orchestra has also been selected to play at this Statewide event on Thursday of next week thank you so much to Mr Barons and to all of our talented students for representing and making us Belo proud wooo our future board meeting dates include our business operations and finance committee at 5:00 p.m. followed by the regular board meeting at 6:00 p.m. on Tuesday February 4th Wednesday February 5th will be a policy meeting beginning at 5:30 p.m. thank you and this ends the announcements for tonight thank you board member Miller next up is public comment Mrs shop are there any public comments we have one here in the room thank you members of the public are welcome to attend all open meetings of the Board of Education individuals attending

060board meetings are expected to conduct themselves in a respectful and courteous manner that models appropriate behavior for our students individuals wishing to comment are expected to comply with the Norms found on the back of your comment cards and in board policy 187 public participation at board meetings we ask that each of you contribute to maintaining a respectful and orderly meeting and prevent discussing confidential matters in a public for by following these norms for public comments during board meetings thank you for your participation and courtesy I have Kelly good evening as you already know I'm in the last few weeks of my employment in the district and I'm here tonight because I have some things I need to say on my heart as I move forward first I'm very proud of the work that I've been

061able to do in this district with my team we've evaluated math and science programs and led the adoption of new curriculum materials and we've LED professional develop for teachers together we've supported our music art PE and health teachers in rebuilding their programs after Co we've expanded their reach for students and tried to build that pipeline in the district office we've made gains to make our systems Tighter and increased communication and Clarity with departments making budgeting more transparent and making sure that we've created inventory systems that are set up to protect the district's Investments and we've expanded opportunities for students and teachers in math and science outside of the classroom importantly probably most importantly I've gotten um to personally know many students and staff in the district that I love very dearly um and that I'm

062going to miss so as I reflect on my time here I know I've done some of my best work and I've um grown tremendously in this District every year I've been here has been a challenge and that's okay schools are messy um they're complex systems with competing needs intentions I started right before covid that was a complicated year for sure and I've worked here through the postco return to school restructuring our schools and many many referendum and budget conversations this year feels different this year I've actually felt under attack and uncertain about my future here beginning on the first day of school intentionally or not the conversations that happened around the budget created some subtle or even not so subtle teacher versus administrator environments the calls for cuts to collac have been perpetual and unfortunately

063I was actually in this room when a representative of the ad hoc committee stated that even though she did not know what administrators do it didn't change her mind about the sweeping recommendation she was making could you imagine if one of our administrators walked into a local business and said I don't know what you do but it's time for you to go the idea is simply absurd there have been consistent public narratives this year about central office staff not supporting or reaching out to support our schools while all the while myself my team and different members of the kak staff have been subbing in various roles across this District including an 8we stent that I did in a frozen classroom it is this level of hubris and ego and assumption that really made me start

064looking for other opportunities but I want to say this very plainly I'm not leaving leaving the district because of the district leadership because of my colleagues in this building because of school leaders because of our teachers because of students or their families I'm leaving because people who do not know what I do and do not know the quality of my work are publicly attacking both this year if you're in the type of role that I'm in right now your future here is very very uncertain I'm also exhausted by how I hear adults talk about students in this community do some of our students have academic and behavioral challenges yes are they illiterate or dangerous absolutely not the vast majority of our students are just kids sometimes they're focused sometimes they're not they want to be

065engaged around their ideas they want to be respected by the adults in their world and they want to be seen and heard by their teachers and peers in schools they are not blind or ignorant though to the adult conversations that happen in this community and they hear the narratives about how poor or their schools are this leads them to believe that what they do all day does not matter if we want to change our outcomes the community leaders and the adults in this community owe our students a lot more positive talk positive energy and continued opportunities to shine so my request is this to the board before you continue to make decisions about the district get to know the district learn from the administrators the students the teachers the staff who are invested in our

066schools every day walk through buildings ask administrators and leaders about the decisions that they're M making and why they're making them build your own understanding of what happens in schools so that you do not act on hearsay and thirdhand information your role in this community is far far too important and the decisions you make today will impact a generation of students tomorrow if you take time to invest in your own learning you will learn how dedicated smart and wholeheartedly invested the people in the central office in our schools are and how curious sensitive and capable our students can be thank you thank you anything else Mrs Shope that's all I have thank you that brings us to reports to the board is our student sent an email and she's not able to make it due

067to a family issue wonderful I mean not wonderful but thank you for letting me know um the policy committee report Mr Schneider I'm sorry I'm sorry wrong wrong wrong chairperson Mr Nichols thank you I knew what you meant thank you board President Johnson um the policy committee met on excuse me THD uh Tuesday just uh January the 7th at 5:30 and we went through some of the policies regarding uh what that are on the that are on the uh consent agenda tonight to two groups and um that's it thank you thank you now Mr Schneider with the tle and pupil Services thank you uh teaching learning equity and pupil Services committee met at 5:00 this evening um we had a great meeting uh we received an update from on the math curriculum and the math

068department here uh as they're continued to digging into ways to changing the math outcomes in our district um with the curriculum Eureka Math and Imagination math um which is working to get students caught up in the skills they need before um they come into the main curriculum and and the great growth that we're seeing in both of those areas um as well as the amount of time and effort that coaches are making to make that curriculum work well and and to build uh extension activities uh for those who have got the skills in order to stretch and continue work on we did go through the Open Enrollment uh seats that are available um especially for special education and that will come to the board uh today um also heard the second time we get some

069more updates on new course proposals for for Belo Learning Academy um the courses are meeting uh science standards at a high level and and developing uh very critical thinking skills um so the courses that you will see on the consent that gener include electricity and magnetism part a um which is being implemented now and looking forward to Part B coming soon um as and that of course aligns with uh parts of the physical science it aligns with power production and distribution aligns with a lot of the medical radi and so on in Parts A and B if that do um so as well as meeting all of those high level science standards um it's also meeting a lot of the career standards that are available in our own Community to help uh our students learn

070the skills that they need to stay in booy and to work here um they're also uh looking at forensic science A Part B course part A is there it's it's a course that's highly sought out um so with 20 to 25 students each term taking that course it's now beginning to stretch that and to add to that as it continues to move forward um so was it was a great meeting um and some of the recommendations will be on the consent agenda later this this this evening thank you Mr Schneider the next item is board referendum discussion Dr Garrison yes so um before I get started um I wanted to just give me one quick second to give the screen situated again this one thank you board President Johnson um what I want to do

071tonight um as we've been you know having this discussion as a team um we wanted to you know again hone in on some of the conversations that we've been having and reference to potential operational referendum question um for the board to vote on um as early as this upcoming Thursday with that being stated um of course last night just to give a quick Rec recap last night we had some additional scenarios to kind of work through um and in those different scenarios we um you know you know kind of work through what those opportunities would possibly look like from the aspect of um number of years to um overall referendum request and then a possibility of what could be in it um from the different um priorities that we've had to discuss what we wanted

072to do tonight was again continue that conversation a little more focused in on where we left off again from last night because each of these conversations of course have been building on each other um with that being stated um I was able to um you know take the feedback from the board um as it stood from last night and come up with some different scenarios again um to consider and in that space um that's also on bardocks will be the um H3 and N conversations that that was added to the most recent snapshot that we had with the top three um options already on the the paper so from yesterday scenario H H1 and H2 came out of our conversations from yesterday at the board level that Mr chady was able to Crunch the numbers

073and bring that that conversation back forward with that being and stated again from the feedback we brought back H3 and N um to the to the table now again um is it as close as we that's the when I say that is it as close as we can get based off of the information that we had this is what we we U were able to bring back to the board for further discussion so with that being stated I would like to open the floor again there was a presentation I'm not going to go over the presentation Again Naturally we all have that um we understand the buckets I'll be able to pull that information up um as needed I said the priorities I'll be able to pull that up as needed um but we are

074working off of the 114 2025 um scenario that's that's on um the screen right now I know we have a lot of these scenario sheets we can still refer back to the other ones as needed I have all of them up here as well um but to keep everybody kind of succinct we're going to start with this one we may jump back to another one but we're going to start with where we left off at which is scenarios that we talked about from a a whip around last night we did land in well the majority of us did land in the H1 space I did not hear back from um while having her back from Mrs um levia as pertains to which one she would have preferred from H H1 and H2 um H2 okay

075so Mrs um Levy has moved into the H2 with Mrs um um Mrs um Johnson for President Johnson and then everybody else was in that H minus Mr henkins was in that H1 space again H3 and N are where we are today based off of the feedback that was given so let's just take a look at H3 I'm going give you a quick snapshot ask Mr chady to chim man if he needs to and then we can you know kind of talk here at the board Senor H3 um gave us the approximate need 7.5 7 7.5 um do mill rate um 5% 4% 4% um was the the breakdown with $ 1.69 million in new and additional stuff that 1.69 million doll dip was to was put in place to kind of bring down the

076um the request from the 1 million um to bring us under the the conversation of $40 million to $39 million but it did bring us down just by playing not playing with but just by looking at that the new additional stuff conversation being a different number than $1.7 million 1.66 n million okay um as you can tell following across you we have a surplus in each year giving us a surplus total of $3.57 million with a$ million conversation that we would have to roll into another referendum in that year four okay that's scenario H3 scenario n as a quick snapshot gave us that 544 number again brought us the supports down to a million dollars as a request but it also brought us closer what brought us down in our mill rate number to $77.34

077reason why this one was brought up is because you know some of the commentary last night was is there if there is anything that we can do to kind of bring that down what would it look like um holding true to where we were with the 544 that's what got us to that 734 now one could argue the 734 is about $3 above what we were going to be paying from that 440 444 number um anyway and so that kind of brought us into that threshold there um to give you all you know that that that space to think about 734 is also in in in I'm sorry 7:15 up to 750 3 was what we were working with from the beginning of a lot lot of our questions and conversations on the other pages

078but 734 is that middle space between the two um and that's kind of how we were you know kind of looking at the numbers to kind of give us a a space in between that 715 number and our high being right now that 753 number from a mill rate perspective um to get us to that 734 number the one last thing that I will say that I need everybody to just remember we do know that in the subsequent years 26 27 and 27 28 that you know the banial budgets even this year hasn't been you know produced and numbers could look different in those M rates so I do want to make sure I bring attention to that it hasn't been a focus of our conversation and I intentionally didn't want it to make it

079a focus of our conversation because our needs are still you know our needs here in the school district and whatever the state does will be in in addition to what we have but it could also off offset that overall mill rate okay um with that being stated that's my snapshot of um H3 and N Mr chaye was there anything you need to add to that no I think he summarized that well um H3 again is essentially a reduction of $500,000 um from H1 or H2 in the new and additional that $500,000 uh was attributed to essentially the extension of transportation to Bullet Memorial High School students um but that's not to say that we can't do that within the 1.69 as well so and then uh scenario n um was crafted this morning essentially that

080734 uh M rate is the midpoint between 715 and 750 so we kind of you know use that to to get us back towards a midpoint again um if there was desire amongst board members for something that was a little bit less was all do any board members have any questions Miss Miller are we looking for questions or feedback I would just want to clarify I'm I'm sorry questions comments feedback I sorry I didn't want to circumvent anything you might have intended okay thank you so much so first of all thank you so much Dr Garrison thank you so much Mr chady you've been so responsive and sort of resilient um with with all of our discussion and that's just really commendable thank you um just two comments one um we received a really great

081email yesterday from um via Michelle show from Rick barter and some other community stakeholders um and I I just I'm not going to like read them but I just wanted to like openly Express like my wholehearted support for what they said which the gist of which is you know inves in kindergarten Readiness laser focus on Student Success um to that we could and I and we should probably talk more about that but the point I wanted to make reacting to the different scenarios is if we're going to make a laser focus on Student Success kindergarten running is all these things work we need the people to do it right the number one differen maker for students are teachers it's teacher self- advocacy right all this kind of stuff we have to make sure our teachers

082feel supported and so just like it's important for in a classroom to be very EXP it I guess my thinking yesterday was okay cool we've got this like 544 we have room to go up I think that at this point we have two real options we're either going to have a 750 well what is the exact number sorry 750 lost my page three or 734 so unless we go with the 734 option I really think the only scenario that makes sense to go with is scenario H2 because that's the one that most explicitly communicates to teachers that we fully support them and see and hear what they need in order to do all of this work that our community stakeholders are are very clearly asking for so I guess my thoughts are gratitude to our

083admin for putting this together um thanks to our community members for for emailing Us in such beautiful um and insightful comments and unless we go with scenario N I strongly feel like we have to go with H2 and commit to that consistent 555 increase for staff thank you Miss Miller uh Brian Anderson yeah so I you know last night I left with kind of supporting that H1 and there was some additional support for the H2 and I just want to point out the kind of the key differences there um obviously the difference is in teacher pays in year two and three um I still contend that we have that option under H1 to do that if the money's there in years two and three um I understand people's wanting the commitment to that in years

084two and three so I I don't want to Discount that the other difference is um you know a positive for H2 is that it does Place additional funding at the state level versus um on the local taxpayer right so where the mill rate doesn't change um you know for an additional 200,000 we're given you know another you know several million dollars in raises to teachers over those years that's great the downside is uh and you can see from the chart that Mr chady put together there that uh the downside is that H2 will provide about a million dollars less to the fund balance over those three years and in addition leaves us with uh let's see what's the difference there about a million four less than a million four let's call a million three um

085in additional shortfall in year four and so where I can get behind the logic behind H2 I think um I I would still put my support behind the H1 option thank you Mrs Levy thank you Mr chady so this is a a crafting the question language um clarification that I would like um and I know we have to be very clear with our messaging um when we educate the Community about the referendum and what our intentionality is around what we're spending but when it comes to the language of the referendum does that specificity need to be and and I get it needs to be brief but what requirements are there that you're aware of of us having to explain in the question what the funds will be spent on for example um with the scenario

086H2 the 1. 669 9 million we could do that for transportation we could do that for additional teacher pay we could do it for a lot of different things um for fund balance for example what are the requirements for how we need to kind of earmark funding in the question yeah so the question um when we draft it will identify the non-recurring referendum amount in a dollar value for each of the three school years so if you think about April of 23 and April of 24 April of 24 the most recent asked for $9 million per year for the 2425 25 26 26 27 school years if I recall correctly this will ask for X number of dollars for 2526 X number of dollars for 2627 and then a different value um for 2728 I

087used x and x x y and z for each of those School so it'll be an increasing amount so the the latter portion the why um is it's a great question and thank you for asking it it's kind of that equilibrium right so you know certainly the public wants the details as to the where and the how and we're not going to be trying to hide that at all but at the same token the question needs to be brief succinct um you know so it may speak to supporting operations compensation of Staff those types of things without getting into you know this dollar value is going to go to that that dollar value is going to go to that so what's actually printed on the ballot is what needs to be approved and totally get

088the idea of laying it all out there um but that's probably not what legal council is going to guide us towards so it sounds like for the question we just need to have the amount for each of the three years and that it's operational operational and it may extend a bit beyond I mean it could be right you know we could say we need these values for each of the next three years for operational purposes period done some districts do that some districts go a little bit further and say for the purposes of um so so what we we've done in the past here is we've we've laid out the question first based off of the request let's say three years whatever the numbers may be and then we lay we also lay out the

089potential of what else it could be used for and in this space we would say based off of what the board talked about last night academics and behavioral supports would be built into this conversation into that language portion of the question got it so the amounts and Broad Strokes we we can we do not leag will not suggest to us that we say six positions and there's two precisions and that they will not say that and you won't see those in any other questions anyway so just BR scow is correct thank you thank you vice president Brian Nichols thank you okay again Mr Shady great great work for something else to look at tonight so let's move down to an as we were discussing earlier so if we I mean I like everything that's here

090but I like in if we if we took years two and three and move the 4% up to 5% and leave the 1 million additional we would back off a half a million for the each of the last two years is that correct non-recurring referendum amount and projected Surplus is that right uh yeah pretty darn close I okay am in the midst of trying to put that all in the model right now just to confirm and um so if we look at n the 2627 projected Surplus deficit let me just go to a different screen here it shows a surplus of 1, 6,257 so if you want to do a scenario o you're looking at scenario n and that uh that 2627 projected Surplus goes from 1. 1423 to 1, 6,257 2728 surplus of 57

0913,000 becomes a $49,400 deficit okay and then the the total at the end would be about a million two give or take uh correct yes so the total projected surplus of scenario o if if we if you guys had it in front of you would be 1,927 42 1,29 uh 1, 19 192 192 okay 742 yep okay that retains the 734 mil rate uh the nonrecurring referendum amounts in 2526 and 26 27 are the same mhm though 27 and 28 we do increase that by $250,000 each year just in 2728 okay okay a couple questions to add to that um I wish Mrs pels were here Dr Garrison do you have any idea how many parking passes we sell at the high school year I don't have that information okay okay well that would be

092handy to know um might be able to get that for us let me get into Skyward Dr Scher is here she can give us an educated guess um not to put you on the spot you can are we going over or under a 100 I don't know sorry good question I maybe Mr chady can help us with that yeah I'll see if I can access the financial history for that account and that'll give us a an approximation uh I just got to figure out which account it is 422 let's start there I encourage you to continue on as I okay okay well I I think that's part of the challenge is we don't really know what it would cost what it would cost to to to bring busing into the high school it's kind of

093a it's kind of a gray area it's it's an educated guess but it could be more it could be more educated maybe right um I guess I guess I'm I'm leaning toward the end with those adjustments that I just suggested because I think that would you know what I I keep thinking we you know we were at we were 27 million a year ago and and now we're talking 40s and 42s where we were and 41s and so um I think that I think that brings him I think I feel like that's more in line with where we probably need to be uh that takes the main the main thing is it takes care of our our teaching professional educator teaching staff for three years in a row so uh going back to Mr what

094Mr Anderson stated um you know when we thinking about some of that fund balance places um scenario and you know if it stays with the 544 without the additional 5% going across the board Mr um Nicholls it still gives us uh you know that $2 million number if it stays what in looks like now with the additional space it will bring down the overall um let's just say fund balance contribution or savings per se um I think what the board has has to understand is the the the 544 that you know you originally came up with in general Mr Nicholls and the five across the board the board can still say you know five four and a half four you know in these spaces if that's what we choose to do we're using the five

095at the high because it gives us that flexibility to say we built this into a possible budget but note that you know naturally this is we're not in negotiations per se in this space and so we we would have to understand that that that that commentary as well so again just to recap the board could say you know 544 as mentioned it could say 555 but the board could also say five4 and a half four you know um based off of whatever you know whatever we we we negotiate in those negotiated spaces the five across the board does give us that number of like this is where we are here's where we want to stay and and it is a solid commitment for our staff but I do want the board to understand that that

096concept as well as Mr Anderson mentioned in his his commentary with the um salary um salary conversations okay that's it that's all I've got thank you Dr Garrison and Mr chady um thank you Greg Schneider as I look at all of the scenarios that we' we've we've gotten over the time um I'm focusing more on what is it that the community has asked us to do and what is it going to take to be able to do that um and and I think personally in order to do that we need to be looking at the the numbers in scenario H2 um as it gives us the greatest support for staff and as an attempt to recruit and retain staff but also gives us funds that we need to be able to put the supports in

097place that the community is asking us to do um to increase the academic achievement and to decrease um any any uh conflicts with the um code of conduct uh so I would recommend that we use the numbers in H2 before I Circle back on board members who have already spoken um board member henkins would you like to weigh in okay I'm not hearing him um Mrs Levy thank you I'll be brief I just wanted to clarify um for the scenarios that have the percentage for staff compensation are those numbers based on that particular increase for all employees uh those percentages are applied universally across all of the objects with the exception of 182 which is Schoolboard salary and compensation not to say that you have to do that 5% but yeah I mean we're just

098applying that across the board right and it's not a commitment that that's how it'll turn out but I just wanted to make sure that that was the allocation yep thank you so much you're welcome yeah can you hear me now yes I can please go ahead Mr henkins oh sorry about that um welcome from the land of cornstock in Nebraska um yeah I just want to take a 500 foot view down on it and I appreciate Mrs Ley on the questionnaire because I am too concerned with uh you know the question and how we how how we if we if if the referendum passes how are we held to to do those things that we are telling the public we are doing with that money I I I I know that it's laborious to have

099say that but as a board and we'll come to an agreement somewhere along the line um what what is the do we have a stick to say okay we said we're going to spend this for that and this for that and uh I my personal view was the last couple referendums and uh you know that it wasn't specific enough to say where we're going to spend this money at and I know we've got very good specificity on where we're going to spend money now but if it's not in the question the public really realize where we are um going to spend that money at in the district and I'll try to be brief anymore with my comments thank you thank you Tom Dr Garrison did you want to respond to that yes um so Mr

100henkins thanks for your question and also by way of Mrs leevy again we in the campaign um we will be very specific with the public in regards to how we want to spend and whatever um additional monies that we want to put towards this opportunity um it will be laid out and it be very specific but for ballot language we will not I'm just being honest with you the legal will probably not suggest to us that we lay out every red scent in the in the on for the ballot language that's just not in my humble opinion what they will suggest to us um and I haven't seen it no and I understand that Dr that's not my point but do we have any do we I'll say the board the hold the stick to

101say okay you we said we're going to spend it there we got to make sure it's going to be there and I'm not saying you wouldn't blah blah blah but um what's the follow back or follow through on that to make sure those dollars that the public says we can spend are going to be spent in the right place where we said we're going to spend it other than being let's say you're not the soup anymore or whatever happens what kind of is there a hold on how we can spend that money legally so the we will spend the money the way that the board have directed the school district to to spend it that's how we have to operate with these numbers especially when we also have policies that say how we need to

102spend money as well and so in this case this is to me uh almost like saying to from our public this is our agreement and this is how we should move and I have no reasons to believe that we would not use the funds in the way in which the board will direct us to use those um and move that conversation forward now I know we've been talking about what we want from the public and what the public will like for us to do um please note that the the million-dollar conversation the $1.16 million conversation um from a bucket perspective it it you know we will have to split it in between the behavior and of course the um academics um that will not give us everything in those buckets based off of the the

103the numbers right now I think our biggest commitment based off of how the board has laid out certain conversations is in the compensation for staff um that's that's how the board has come has come along in this in this space you've all been very clear that you want to you know maintain our staff and and and in in that priority I should say um and it's been very clear that we move from that 3% um to that 5% um throughout all of our conversations and so that those extra funds um that we would have put towards other other um priorities have shifted to how we actually will be compensating um our staff so I just want to make sure that's I was not trying to be disrespectful or admin at all about spending I was

104more like a a question to and letting the general public know that these dollars will be spent the way that they are being talked about right now there's more of space for you to say that yes it will be spent that way thank you uh board member Miller thank you um Mr chady had his hand up too I didn't know if he needed a piggy back oh okay I wasn't sure thank you so much um I'll try to be as concise as possible because I just heard a lot of like really awesome stuff so first of all um to board member Schneider's Point what I keep thinking about and it just sort of crystallized in my mind this way is just this is really a message about like build this to like build this with

105us right we're saying to the community build something with us and we've gone to the community and we've asked for their input and we've got this beautiful presentation last week that actually put dollar signs on the delineation of the feedback we received so like we have begun to to Vision together we're asking people in this referendum build this with us and then I loved what Mr henkins just said too just speaking of that accountability piece we have a strategic plan that we that is is sunsetting in June and so the accountability to the community in addition to what Dr Garrison just shared is also like you have laid out the community has laid out with us now this is what we want to spend our dollars on this is what this is in service of

106and that then can be document mented into the Strategic plan with metric we have already um that data dashboard tool and all kinds we just heard in the tle committee tonight um all kinds of like return on investment type metrics already happening so we can show people qualitatively and quantitatively what their dollars are going to and what results they're yielding right so um the last point I want to make is just coming back to this email that we received one of the um suggestions was like we need more Community Partnerships right like we need to partner and there were great organizations listed uh we need to have I think the terminology was like a bullpen of tutors organizations that are doing good stuff attracts good stuff people want to get on board we're already going

107in the right direction and I think passing a referendum is going to depend on having a question very much to the points that have been raised by my colleagues tonight that can get us to the vision that people want to build if we can deliver right on that vision and asked people to build it together that people have told us that they wanted people are more likely to to roll their sleeves up and say yeah cool I'm excited about this like let's build this together and it's it's dollars and cents here and there but at the end of the day the thing that's going to get us what our community by and large wants is Investments and exactly what we've already talked about investing in the people who are going to make it happen and

108so again that's why I just want to like I really appreciate the comments about trying to find kind of that in between I have to just kind of circle back and wholeheartedly support scenario H2 uh for all of those reasons thank you Mr chady yeah uh real quick got answers to the uh questions about the parking pass and before I answer some accolades to those uh viewers or listeners from home or elsewhere because they lended heard the question and supported some data for us uh going so we've had 82 parking passes sold here in the 2425 school year I believe they're $100 a piece that may be pro-rated based upon semester quarter some distri or some yeah some districts do it differently in 23 24 uh we had receipts of 138 I'm sorry $13,800 for

109parking passes so about 138 is in 2223 it was 15,400 so about 154 and then 18,650 so about 186 so it has been dropping by about 20 or so per year fewer students um could be a factor in that but you know could be other factors too so just sharing the information that uh we obtained thank you yes and thank you to our astute audience member um uh Brian Nichols your hand is up it is thank you so uh this kind of relates to Tom Tom's question so you know I I I agree that you know we can't we can't put everything in the question that that will let the public know what what what we need the money everything that we need the money for so but we've we've heard from the community we've

110heard from the ba uh the Bea we've heard from us that we've got to be spe more specific when we start you know so my question is how soon can we get a somewhat detailed list of our our true wants and needs needs needs mostly needs so that we can we can hit the ground running in April or I mean February we well April to afterwards but let's let's start with with February and uh because you know I think I think that's going to be I think that's the thing that's been missing in in the prior years and that's what the public again I'm not going to be redundant because I've already am so anyway we will put this information together I mean again in our presentation we did lay out like some thoughts and

111some ideas and what it would cost and what we would do and where the money will be spent um the details around that could be also displayed and put out around what it will be done what we do and how will be what will be done how will we do it and what will be spent um based off of and to say we got to put the car before the horse but we we also have to land in where how much we're going to put toward those buckets right um and so I know we've been in the middle between 1.6 69 million um 1 point of course we brought back the 1.69 million conversation and of course we brought back the 7:34 conversation tonight um and so that's that's that having that information helps us

112determine the those next steps um with that being stated I do have to ask Mr henkins um if you're still on and if you're able to um chime in uh of the scenarios uh from yesterday and of course the two additional today um are you leaning towards a specific um scenario sir oh thank you for uh unfortunately Wi-Fi is like uh a corn stock out here I can't get it very often but I tell you the truth I've started before I left and uh listen to Mr Schneider on I think it was hn uh H2 I I knew before I left what they were but um I don't I really don't want without even looking be being able to look at him specifically I think it was H Mr Schneider which one did you weigh

113it on that you were you were in favor of if I may ask you that it was H2 H2 to me just a you know listening audio those that's that's where I will say that I'm at right now um without and again I pr that by saying that I don't invol the facts and figures in front of me but um I I believe that's where I'm at thank you thank you and so um Bor what I'm you know we we did allocate specif specific time for this and I want to make sure you all know that I have reached that time but I also wanted to make sure you all okay will continue in a conversation if we need to yes I I am okay I'd like to um weigh in and I don't want

114to give Mr chady a heart attack so I'm going to preface it with I appreciate your good health so I I did have a question from a constituent this afternoon and so this and it was very good question it was okay Tia so you've got these different Mill rates and you want mill rate stability what does that mean for me and my taxes that I have to pay and I thought well that's a really good question because that's what probably most of our constituents are wondering and so I did a quick little calculation using my own property um and I I was taken back a little bit because it's a it is a considerable jump but then I also remembered wait a minute there is the mill rate and then there's the net mill rate

115and I know you've explained this before so take a deep breath sure say okay I'm a patient person and I'm going to explain this again at at a fifth graders level why have we not been paying the full mill rate and is there any projections as to what the net mill rate will be in the future just trying to write down the talking points so I don't miss any that helps me um so let's begin so the average property if I remember correctly I reached out to Eric Miller uh counterpart with the city of bloy and I believe he told me that the average residential property value was around 157,500 if I recall correctly um but in front of me I I've got the budget model that bases things on $100,000 of value so we're

116just going to use that for simplistic terms so the model I've got open uses 734 as the mill rate so I'm going to speak to that not that it can't be anything else and if needed I can pull up the differences so in the current year the owner of a $100,000 home would be taxed at approximately $192 gross the gross value from the school district however prior to the property tax bills being drafted created by the municipalities the city the townships and then communicated to the property tax owners they net out the school levy Tax Credit Value across all properties so right off the right off the bat it buys down the school levy amount to the municipalities from there then it's distributed amongst the assessed value of the properties so again looking at current

117year the owner of $1,000 home would pay net property taxes of $192 the real I'm sorry that's gross the reality is their net property tax is significantly less than that probably around 100 bucks to be honest with you so if the property tax well well let's let's back up without a referendum it's projected that the mill rate is going to go to $444 so that $192 of gross property taxes paid this current year is going to increase the $444 in Gross taxes next year if we're looking at a scenario scenario n or scenario o which is even on your sheet both revolve around that 734 mil rate so they would grow from 192 to 734 let me do my math whoops let's clean everything out here so it would be about an additional $290 the

118$290 would essentially be the ask amount above what we anticipate property taxes to grow to anyway so it's going to go up to that 444 we would be seeking about an additional $290 worth of expense or an investment from that property owner to support uh education in the school district of booy so we get to that 734 value but as I look at the history on that same $100,000 property back in the 2122 so fall of 21 property tax bills and every year their every year previous to that they were paying over $1,000 in School portion of their property taxes on a gross basis so it's still a $250 $270 reduction from what it was yeah four years ago now it's still the growth from 192 to 444 or seven whatever you know that's going

119to be that can be painful for people um but again you know when we look back at the history they've been paying that for years prior to these last four years where it has fallen thank you so my thought on that and I know we want to get and stabilize a mill rate was there any consideration Dr Garrison for maybe ramping up to that mill rate rather than sticker shock we're here and this is where we're going to stay so and and again it goes back to the the 3% conversation so we were looking at $630 some 34 C I think in some of the scenarios that we had but it goes back to the 3% and the salary um increases and so you know naturally you know hearing from the board and that's why

120we're here to have these conversations and hearing where the direction that we're going in and what we what you all want to prioritize for this referendum um you know things things did shift in some of our conversations which is perfectly fine because our priorities have been very you know clear if you ask me in this in these conversations at the board level so it was it was something that we looked at um our needs are still great here in the school district and and that's something that we all have to you know really come to grips with the other side of that is you know the 26 27 school year you know with the fund balance being what it is and us being able to just do do business here did put us also in

121some dire conversations as we kind of laid out numbers for the district and my my responsibility um in this conversation is to make sure that we have the funding to support our needs um and like I mentioned before in my opening statement that I I cannot we cannot no we can no longer operate School the way we've been Opera it and it's it's it's time for us to you know of course to make these conversations happen um together we can you know make these conversations sound and feel differently but even if we were to even to stop at that 444 we would have had a deficit in in multiple years of cuts and that's why we gave that base scenario because at 444 would have it would still require millions of dollars of cuts year

122to year to year and it wouldn't have wouldn't have gotten us out of the conversation and which a board is considering in a referendum and so that's that's the space that we're still working from thank you and um and I'm sure you understand my personal belief every dollar invested in education is 100% worth its investment as long as we're you know spending our dollars well and wisely um and I believe that the that investment it's not just this year next year it's 10 15 20 years down the line that it's a wise investment were there any last um questions or comments from board members before we move on M Mr henkins did you want to wait say have anything else to add uh no I I appreciate you guys uh working with me on this

123situation just I I think you kind of said it um we talk about 3% 5% and Mr Miller um we you and I've talked and I've talked to a city manager about busing so that's a completely different uh subject so and the EV thing went away so anyways those are different subjects that need to be had and uh no I'm good thank you you for uh putting up with me for being far away thank you bye I mean I'll stay on bye oh no I thank you Mr hkin I appreciate you um joining us from Nebraska Dr Garrison so so where we are now is I need to you from a language perspective kind of lay out um the Thursday's conversation um based off of what I'm hearing from the board um from a um

124I hate to say consensus but from a consensus space um it seems as if H2 is the um most preferred um scenario um knowing that everything that we do it there's been conversations around all of this for everybody um and so um I would like the board to give a one more rip around around that and of course the three-year four-year conversation since we do have Mr hens on I would like to hear him in his space around the three or the foure space and that'll give me what I would need to prepare for a vote on Thursday's conversation um for the board so um Mr um if you don't mind Mr henkins do you prefer a three or four sure do you prefer a three or four year thank you Dr garison I'm uh

125everything's fluid right so I'm I'm all for a threeyear I don't want to extend our Sou much further okay thank you a lot of things could happen in the next uh actually in the next year but uh yes three years rather than four thank you um so overall we are landing in that threeyear space and then um unless there's any other conversations from the scenario perspective um um age2 um one last um with around there any questions about that scenario being what we bring forth and the revenue limit increase to the board for a vote on Thursday oh was that to me I'm sorry uh no I'm good you bring that to a vote I'll be there and uh yes I'm I'm I'll vote Yes I'm I'm I'm good thank you no that that was

126just for the whole board is there anyone that would like I saw know well that was for the whole board anyone and hearing none I'm hearing H2 is where we as a group will land for the revenue conversation it's not something that you know Revenue limit increase and please note that um in the new and additional space we will focus in the behavioral and academics bucket because that was what was decided yesterday as well when we did the rip around amongst everyone um so um I just want to make sure everyone is aware of kind of where we're going Megan Miller thank you yes no totally agree and I just think um I understand Dr Garrison that what you're saying is to prepare us to be able to you know quickly and hopefully unanimously pass

127um you know a question on Thursday also though because I know other people are listening because we're focusing on the question being around the subjects that you discussed does doesn't preclude the district also going forward from doing things like exploring Transportation engaging in early literacy and kindergarten Readiness all these other things aren't off the table I just wanted to clarify for people who might be following along this is a discussion about how to frame the question not like this is all we're going to focus on and throw away other ideas that is correct I mean how we how we get at other community needs is a space that the district operates from be honest with you all the time there's a lot of needs that comes to us from different Community Partners and how we

128work through those as a district may not necessarily need to be in a referendum um so but that's yes that is true um so hearing hearing none I'm hearing that the board is in consensus with H2 being where we are okay Mr Mr Johnson you have any NOP thank you Dr gearon and thank you Mr chady our next item is the consent agenda typically there is no separate discussion of the items unless a board member so requests in which in which event the item or items will be removed from the general order of business and considered in their normal sequence on the agenda are there any board members that would like an item or items remove Mrs Levy thank you um yes I would like item C is in cat f is in Frank and

129G is in Greg remove please CFG any other items I'm sorry any other items removed that see the Open Enrollment space determination F the policy 345 .6 graduation requirements and G policy 345.8 rule 1 specific graduation requirements is everybody in or um can I get a motion for approval of the consent agenda minus cfng G so moved second motion by Megan Miller seconded by Amy Levy any discussion hearing none all in favor I I I I I any oppose motion carries unanimously Mrs Levy item C thank you um so one thank you for including that presentation I just wanted to check and it's the slide that has um The Columns where it has the red and the green um for the project number of OE spaces available for next school year I just want to

130make sure that I'm understanding this graphic so for example at beloy Memorial High School there are negative3 spaces does that mean there's a weight list does that mean there are three children that won't be served it can't mean that help nope so that means next year yep we would not accept any open enrollment applications for high school students okay but it says -3 so I'm assuming you got to that number somehow so what does the ne-3 mean yeah so if you're taking a look at the chart if you start on the far left side y those are our case load size Criterion so I mentioned at the committee meeting we use like a workload model so that's the average number of students that each teacher that provides special education services would have on their case

131load the next column over is our current Staffing Trend so at the high school we have 13 special education FTE so staff we have hired staff 13 hired staff so when you multiply 18 by 13 you get a capacity of 234 students so that's on average the number that we can support with their specially designed instruction in their minutes you just made me feel a lot better so does that mean that and and help me understand because I thought I read that there aren't requirements for case Lo which makes me nervous but that's another conversation for another day yep so we are three above the recommended limit or the preferred spot but all of the children are being served correct and will be next year with these projections correct it's just because that number is

132negative that's why no one is being accepted correct perfect thank you so much yep and that's only new applications so anybody who's currently open enrolled at the high school would St you're going to figure it out even though it's above that ideal case load number yeah they're factored into the projected enrollment already so they would stay got it thank you so much any other questions on item C the Open Enrollment space deter termination can I get an A motion for approval of item C so moved second motion by for approval by Greg Schneider seconded by Megan Miller any discussion just a question do you do you need us to read the whole recommended action for the motion or are we good M okay okay that was my only question thanks okay all in favor I

133I I I I I any oppos motion carries unanimously item F the policy 345.8 graduation requirements Mrs Levy thank you so much um so a few months ago we had a conversation at a policy committee and it talked about potentially reducing the number of required credits so Mrs morek if you could give us the elevator pitch about why the administration is proposing that and like the reasoning behind that because when you did it at the policy committee it made perfect sense to me um and I am concerned that some of us may be equating a higher number of required credits for graduation with like a better quality product with respect to the education that we are giving our children and I if you could help us explain that that correlation is not necessarily the thing

134um I think this is important enough that the full board should hear the explanation and then we can decide if we want to keep things as they are or if we are comfortable moving forward with the administration's original proposal thank you sure so originally um we were looking at our work in theem uh model and Capstone projects and things like that and then it also um so there's that piece there was also a lining to the state um standards uh excuse me graduation credits some of those changes to make sure that the policy had that um and then also in looking across the state um and doing us study of the number of credits that districts um are requiring our graduates and uh the DPI requires in our core classes a certain number of credits

135and then a recommended number of electives and we are um well over the the recommended and even the electives there are districts that go under the the recommended so there's the required and then there's the recommended for electives so when I looked at the um State's largest school districts um I don't have the I'll just read it Milwaukee Madison Green Bay Kenosha and rine are all 24 below um Milwaukee Madison and Green Bay are 22 each kenosha's 23.5 Rines 24 um looked at the top performing districts in the state um which is 23.5 23 uh 24 and 23.75 are those districts that's El Brook moso Norway cedarberg Middleton Cross Plains and then I looked at Rock County um Rock County tends to be a little bit higher um in their ask um I also thought

136about how the last time that this policy was updated was a decade ago in 2014 um and then in in Rock County bloy Turner ederton and Milton are also 24 um and so thinking about um aligning what's the requirement with the state um and making some of those changes along with um opening up opportunities for work-based learning um for our students because they're finishing through those Pathways uh quicker and then that gives them more flexibility um it's a point of pride in our district and then also thinking about um graduation rates and how some of our students um are ready to graduate and to move on college career and ready to the to the next piece um and then you know I think since I have been here that word expectations um is unclear because

137I'm certain that um the largest districts in the state and the highest performing districts of the state do not have one might argue lower expectations um and so a changing of electives uh isn't a lowering of expectations um and lowering the minimum requirements from 26 to 24 doesn't remove access you can still get up to 32 credits as a student um mean in fact when we did that study a lot of our students um on average get 30 um our students that are falling short are are not far um I think jeoff looked at that today was it 2019 credits as often um our students that go into fiveyear six-year graduation rates so those are some of the I think bigger ideas thank you no thank you so much um if other colleagues have questions

138I would definitely yield the floor now thank you any other questions or comments Dr Garrison yes you know when we when we was thinking about this about actually two years ago when we were first kind of starting to look at you know graduation requirements and then of course bringing it to the board for this year you know you know moving from 26 to 24 I just want to make sure I we reiterate that is it's not an academic achievement space um you know we are looking at what gives us access um more for our students as well we know that we have a a large population that that works with us um through um with a ref fresh start as well and also through our BL conversations and so we have a wide variety of

139different needs here in our school district and the the credit conversation from an elective perspective we're not touching the core the core classes that that are required and we will still work through those spaces I think that's very important to note um however again this that's that was part of the you know overall conversation and so um we did bring this forward um and it is um of course now off the consent agenda for discussion and so that's just a space that I wanted to kind of um honor and support of our um District's um recommendation um to Move It from 26 to 24 however again this is the board's conversation at this point and the only thing I would add before that you move on to because I I like what you're saying Dr

140Garrison is that ultimately we want our students to have a high school diploma because that's what's getting them college career and Community ready thank you Greg Schneider the policy committee delayed hearing um or looking at these policies until after it went to the teaching learning equity and pupil Services committee uh um the that committee recommended dropping to uh 24 credits in order to give the students in our district greater opportunities um to prepare for the future um and to be ready to move on to College and Career um when it came to the policy committee um for the portion that I did hear I did not hear the uh policy committee mentioned that uh the teaching learning and Equity committee had had um weighed in on this um but if you take the two committees

141together um and and uh also making sure every person got one vote uh if we took the six people since um Mr hanen is on both committees um so we we would be looking at five so it would have been approved by both committees on a 3 to2 vote um so the again it's not lowering expectations it's providing opportunities for students and give them that opportunity to grow um and to advance in their careers thank you Brian Nichols thank you board President Johnson so uh um Greg you're correct and it did come to the policy committee last week and uh you know we uh as from the very beginning when I actually moved it to the recommended it moved to the to your committee first um I did address this as I did the other

142night um as Mrs mortek just agreed I mentioned too about Rock County tends to be higher well um if you take B boy Turner Clinton ederton Evansville Jamesville mil Milton and Parkview and the Lincoln Academy which is a public charter school in our County we are at 20 they're at 25.5 average and we're at 26 so we're not out of the realm um Evansville for example is at 28 uh at Jamesville is at 26.5 and you know we're at 26 uh and Parkview uh where board member Miller teaches is at 26 so uh it uh I hear what everybody says uh at the but at the end of the day we're talking about getting gra people graduated quicker so they can get on with their career well that extra two credits may be a may

143be the one thing that changes the career the career path that they choose they could take an elective CA course that they may have not had the opportunity to take if they graduated with 24 and they could move on to do something even more beneficial IAL to their their life and and and the and the community and and support the community so um I was um I am you know I uh I believe that that's going backwards not going forwards by going from 26 to 20 it is it is backwards so um that's where I'm coming from thank you Megan Miller thank you so much um I was just going to comment that since um you know we're tasked often with you know we have all these decisions we make and have all these different

144perspectives but really what it comes down to is our job is to advocate for what's best for children and all of what we've heard our Administration present is is centered around the needs of students since um vice president Nicholls just brought up um I love your comments by the way about how like one class can really make a difference in the trajectory of of somebody's life completely resonates with me and I appreciate that very much so in addition to I just want to add perspective to that one of the realities as we talk about like behavior management and classroom management I've experienced in my more than 10 years as a teacher times where you got to check a box and scheduling is a bearer ask anybody who's ever worked in public education scheduling is like

145a four-letter word and sometimes kids get put into classes right because they got to have another class right and so that can be not only problematic for that student because it's it it deteriorates their experience and relationship with the school but it's really problematic for teachers to try to teach a class where you've got a handful of kids who are really passionate about that elective and others who are there because they have to be there it's not ideal and so if we're thinking about not only what's best for the individual needs of our kids but also what's best for our district and its culture and climate and the academic the meaningful academic experiences that they can have I really think that leaning into a structure that is then by Design more purposeful and intentional is

146actually not going backwards or taking anything away it opens up opportunities more for student Choice really to kind of get more at what you're saying um about just like how that one class right can really change your life should really be a student's choice so I I just wanted to weigh in that way and I I for those reasons can't support the the policy as written thank you thank you Mr henkins did you want to weigh in on this oh yes I've been um pretty vocal about this whole thing and I'm not going to change my is my my opinion on it um this morch is quick to note that the top tier do this and do that I wonder what the bottom tier do what which where we are at and what do they

147want and I I I totally agree with not taking our say you know the two the two credits you know if a compromise could be if want to take two credits away from electives then put one credit back into uh Court class class ES uh our student achievement is where it is and we all know it and we need to start supplementing that and not worrying about the other part the high Achievers are high Achievers they're going to do well I uh I just don't see this as being a a positive step in the right direction thank you thank you Mr Anderson did you want way in yeah so I think you know at first I would challenge Mr mork's goal of we want to get these children a diploma that's that's not my goal

148I think I want to have these children life ready whether it's Career College whatever is next for them after high school I think if we've prepared them by default that will come with a diploma because if you've done all the right things you're probably going to get a diploma the reality is I think we have students getting diplomas that can't read and write that have a GPA under one and if that's the measure of success is getting a diploma then let's hand them out the first day of freshman class and then everybody graduates so my point is I don't want to lessen the standards let's let's Instead try to understand that the kids in this District are capable you know what they need is the support and when we're talk talking about tonight referendum and

149and how do we support the students that's what we're talking about we're talking about how do we support the students to succeed in the district um and I think lowering you know credit standards is is absolutely a a backward step so I I would support uh the policy has presented here here thank you um Mr Anderson I I will weigh in on this um gosh almost four years ago when I took a Middle School teaching position here in the district I had the pleasure of being trained by an Exquisite educator unfortunately the training was not long and not long enough at all but this educator inspired the students this educator had enthusiasm and energy and I watch this educator and realize that's the type of teacher I want to be I want all of our

150students to have that opportunity to have that highlevel quality educator in front of them teaching them something they are passionate about with the love and the compassion that this person had and I I I really think that that is what we need to focus on we are performing poorly and it's it's it's an unfortunate reality it's something we are trying to get better at and it's trying something we are trying to hold ourselves accountable for for nobody's attacking anyone it's just the reality of our situation there are some benefits to having fewer credits perhaps we perhaps we need fewer teachers if if there are fewer credits perhaps we um have more time for students to do the um when they go off campus and do their do their work there's even drawbacks to that if

151they're going off campus and doing outside work are you know who's holding them accountable you know I I would hope that they are holding themselves accountable if they're not going off campus and and taking a a job out um outside of the district what are they doing then those two class periods are are they in a study hall are they are they who's who's holding them in accountable it's I agree just because somebody has a diploma does not mean they are college ready nor does it mean that they are career ready that is our goal our district goal we we want to say yes you have a bot Memorial purple night diploma you are A1 you are good to go this is unfortunate the timing of this question I don't I I don't think our

152constituents will say hey that's the right direction we're going at the same time we're asking them money to to recruit and find these highquality Educators and keep them here I I I I think that this is not the right direction unfortunately not now not ever but it's especially not now when we're going to say please we need more money because we want to get better I would rather see students in classes um I I graduated with at the time the requirement was 27 credits that we had to have I and I I you know what it's not difficult you know there take take some classes some electives you know expand your expand your knowledge into areas that you that you don't know I took a sewing class guess what I can't sew I learned something

153about myself there it's okay um I'm not I'm not in favor of this I will Ex I will entertain a motion I move there I move there that we approve rule 3456 uh as as written as shown on the first reading do you mind adding I think it correction I move that we approve item F and item G policy 3456 and 34456 Rule one uh to move forward to the second reading is there a second second can we have a roll call vote please please and before we have the roll call vote so the motion is uh by Brian Nichols seconded by Tom henkins and if I am correct that's the approval of policy five I'm sorry 345.8 and 34.6 Rule one that is correct okay thank you any discussion seeing and hearing none oh

154I'm sorry Mrs Miller no it's okay no thank you um I just wanted to um you made a comment about our performance and I just wanted to to bring to everybody's attention that we outpaced the state and our forward exam growth results and I think that shows that we're going in a great direction thank you thank you Mrs sh Craig Schneider nay Amy Levy nay Brian Nichols I Brian Anderson I Tom henkins I Megan Miller nay and tia Johnson I motion carried 4 to three thank you that brings us to Human Resources oh um are there any open session questions or comments on any of the um Human Resources items um I one of the items we are going to discuss in close session is administrator contracts at this point I am leaning towards a

155one-year extension not a 2-year extension last year the board when we were uncertain about the referendum of last year um the board voted to do extend one year and to my knowledge we did not have any employees resign because their um contract was extended only for one year not two years we don't know the um results of what the referendum will be I think we all have our opinions and and hopes and desires of what it will be but the reality is we don't know and um being more I I think it's more fiscally prudent to go with one year rather than two but that's my opinion I will entertain a motion to um oh a motion may be made and a vote taken to convene the Board of Education into close session pursuant to

156section 19 85 parent1 parency of the Wisconsin State statutes relative to considering specific Personnel recommendations so moved second motion by Megan Miller seconded by Amy Levy any discussion Mrs SCH may we have a roll call please yes and I do want to let the board know there are no close session minutes for this evening to be approved thank you um Megan Miller I Tom henkins are you still with us Mr okay Brian Anderson hi uh Brian Nichols I Amy Levy I and Greg Schneider I and tia Johnson I the Board of Education May reconvene to public session in order to take any action if necessary on items discussed in Clos session thank you thank you e e e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.