001e e e [Music] thee we worried there you go it is Catch e e e two laptop today I have to zoom in to read that line PR good evening I'd like to call to order the special board meeting for Monday January 13th Mich may I get a roll call please yes Megan Miller present tom henkins is unable to join us this evening for personal reasons Brian Anderson here Brian Nichols here Amy Levy here Greg Schneider present and tia Johnson here all members are present except Tom henkins thank you may I get an approval of the agenda so moved second motion by Brian Nichols second in by Greg Schneider any discussion hearing and seeing none all in favor I I I any oppose motion carries unanimously please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge
002ALG to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all tonight we are here to discuss the referendum to share with board members information scenarios and potential action for a 2025 April referendum the background information is that the school district of blit bces budgetary constraints leading into the 2526 school year these budgetary needs have been expressed throughout the 2324 school years leading us to a potential 2025 referendum question Dr Garrison so the board um just thank you all for the conversations that we've had over the past year of course and naturally over um last week um our task today is to really dive right into the conversation as discussed um from last week week one of the things that
003I really wanted to do real quick was just to give us a real quick recap of um Thursday's meeting without going into you know major details before we can just kind of land in the conversation for today um the board has two sheets that um we have um uploaded to board dos um that you all have um um readily available for your um viewing purposes the first sheet um was the scenarios that came from Thursday and in that Thursday's conversation we did hear from the board as it pertains to you know some of your thoughts in in that whole package of different opportunities there I'm not going to go over every scenario in the space but just note that that base scenario um from the last week's conversation is still noted and then of course
004we went through a few other scenarios in that space are there any questions about what we talked about in those base scenarios last week on Thursday I say base scenarios the first set of scenarios okay and so from there um we of course heard from the board took down some notes and we wanted to provide this second sheet that you all have that was um shared in board docs as well as um in in different separate in a separate um email conversations to you all um in reference to for tonight's conversation and just to recap we did hear from the board um that you know a stable meal rate would be pretty important and so what we want to do is try to provide that level of conversation knowing that you know we don't know
005what number is the you know the best necessarily the best number from a midr perspective but we did want to try to provide different scenarios that would provide that level of St stability the second thing that we heard from the board was that we wanted to you know kind of capture the space of should we or should we not um lean into more of the um overall teacher pay space right now in all of our scenarios that you see on um last week's agenda was about a 3% increase and on the one that you all see now today the the scenario opportunities we have various different opportunities with um salary increases for our staff okay so we want to provide that level of detail to you all as well and thirdly we realized that the
006board wanted to fall somewhere in between G and H and if that was a space that we could kind of operate from which again prompted some of the space that you see in the scenarios today okay um again are these all these scenarios perfect like I shared before that's going to going to be something that's going to be missing in anyone's space because it's you know different different levels of opinions around what should be added and what shouldn't however we did want to make sure that we captured um that space based off of your your input from last week's meeting so today um that's that's our charge just to kind of hone in on some thoughts that we you know want to agree on or come to some form of consensus with um I use
007that word very um kindly because I know this is a hard decision this is a hard decision for our board it's a hard decision for um our community naturally but we really want to make sure that we kind of hone in on some of those STS so firstly um I think we need to come to a level of consensus around three years non-recurrent operational referendum fouryear non-recurrent operational referendum and then we can kind of go through the you know one could argue the sandwich of the conversation um throughout I do want to keep the conversation as as close to you know concise so we can kind of move forward through the conversations accordingly but of course the board you know can dictate how how that conversation looks so I'mma turn over to Mrs Johnson just
008to start us off in the conversation first around are where are we at with a non-recurring three or four um as a board and kind of hear from you all where we're Landing with that thank you Mrs Levy thank you my preference is to have a 4-year non- reoccurring referendum and again to provide that stability and I think it's really G to be important with from an accountability perspective I really like the idea of tracking a graduating class so starting with our ninth graders the year the referendum funds are implemented and track them through seni your year and really identify their growth um and and the ways that the referendum benefited that class um and then of course the accounting of exactly what that money was spent on thank you Brian Nichols um I'm I'm
009more in favor of the three-year non-recurring um I don't you know I don't really have any other I just think that's uh that's where we probably need to be for for now Brian Anderson I guess I'd start with uh my preference would be three years based on our uh you know maybe a what we've earned to ask for could I be convinced for years maybe but my I'm definitely would be starting at and in favor of three years thank you Megan Miller thank you um can you all hear me okay perfect so I'm like the opposite of Brian Anderson I'm like I'm convincible for three but I'm leaning toward four for two reasons one I just want to guess reiterate everything that board member Levy just shared I think it just sets us out for
010better accountability and account like this is what we spent the dollars on this is what the results were the second reason that I'm leaving more toward a 4-year is that if you think about the practicality and the stability of running the district if we do a three-year referendum we've got year one year two middle of year two a lot of our administrative kind of like human capital is going to be focusing on preparing the next referendum because that is how school funding Works unless something crazy major changes right at the state level for funding and I would rather have administrative time and resources and expertise spent on producing the results that we hope to gain by passing said referendum so I'm not I I can I'm convincible but I feel like four years is both
011better for accountability and and will'll produce better results thank you thank you Greg Schneider um I'm kind of a toss up between three and four I think for the district four would give us uh more stability over a longer period of time and keep us moving but I also know the concerns of the community uh with possibly going for four um so at the moment as the discussion goes on I'm kind of I'm okay with either one uh you know personally I think I would like to see four um just for stability thank you Greg and Greg to um Echo your sentiment I'm pretty much there with you I can understand and appreciate the desire to do four um but also realistically knowing the Comm community and um first and foremost I want a referendum
012if we're going to do a referendum let's get one that's going to pass um my concerns with a fouryear is although I like what Mrs Levy has proposed in tracking students I haven't seen any plans on what specifically will be tracked who will be doing the tracking the the programming doesn't seem like it's been um well vetted yet or um flushed out yet on on what that would look like so I'm a little bit concerned with saying let's do four and then make it h make make this happen so so that's where I am Dr Garrison okay so you know let me just speak to both of the points of three or four is if it's a fouryear of course we will follow whatever strategic plan that we have in place at the time along
013with whatever board goals that we set that we set and so I just want to make sure that that's a noted space um based off of your statement um our goal is of course to you know bring back that data and that information as we process it um within the spaces of District goals and or of course a strategic plan um just to let you all know we still have to report on how we're doing right from a year-to-year basis um that's that's a part of what we have to do you know on a year-to-year conversation um and so um that's the that's the space that I wanted to share with you all and based off of kind of what I'm hearing you know I'm not sure if we're landing at a consensus around three
014well actually I do believe we're Landing if Mr henin was here I don't know what his sentiments would be um but I'm probably leaning towards him being in that three and we will probably be landing in a three-year non-recurring um space based off of you know just the board's you know deliberation and conversation um with that being stated if that's a space that we need to you know continue the conversation we are more than willing to do that but as it stands based off of kind of what I've you know taken down here it looks like the threeyear non-recurring spaces where we're you know kind of Landing um um and for various reasons um are there any questions about that at all Brian is your hand up for a question or comment no it's oops
015I forgot that take it down okay thank you okay well um as we continue this space um Miss Johnson let me proceed okay so the next space that I would like to kind of consider for us is the scenarios again now I know that the scenarios took us the majority of the last conversation um again the presentation as you see it went through a couple of those presentations from last week I'm going to pull up um the sheet for today um and Mr chady do me a favor and tell me um I want to make sure let me do this real quick I'm going stop sharing and then reshare um so I can pull up that other sheet for today for the public um give me one second present my screen this one oh no
016NOP n this one all right so I think this is the correct one M CH can you look on the screen up there then okay that's the right one okay um so for today's conversation what I wanted to do is kind of walk us through these um not walk us through these scenarios but you all were able to view this over the weekend and I wanted to kind of start the conversation around you know how you feeling what you looking at what's the space that you're operating from and allow that to kind of guide how we start to narrow down what we won't probably be looking at okay now we have to do this y'all so it's one of those spaces where you know we want to kind of go through some of these more
017than once but if there's any questions that we can answer Mr chady is definitely available to help with that my cab will be able to help with that but I'll turn it back over to Mrs um Johnson for you know how do we want to start having these conversations but before I do that Mr chady could you do me a huge favor and just give a overview snapshot of this sheet for the group please yep thank you five minutes tops yep y uh so we'll start at the top the base uh of course that's if no referendum um was provided again we have an approximate $6.2 million deficit for the 25 26 school year the next row down scenario G this is the same scenario G that the board uh looked at and considered on
018Thursday with an approximately $680 mill rate um and then scenario H at the very bottom is also the same scenario that that the board looked at last week Thursday as well with an approximate $7.50 mill rate kind of surmising the discussion amongst the board thereafter um it sounded like the board may have been looking for something kind of towards the middle is probably the best way to put it so Friday morning uh we quickly put together what one two five six scenarios five scenarios uh labeled scenario i j k l and m all of those revolve around the $7.15 mill rate which was kind of the midpoint of that 680 and 750 although all were a little bit different so scenario I uh was essentially scenario G just increasing it to $7.15 as a mill
019rate uh retains the same three % for salary um in wages or Personnel uh compensation scenario J uh takes scenario I and adds in an additional million dollars to support any additional um Staffing Transportation curricular needs Etc scenario K takes scenario J and increases the uh compensation expenses from 3% to 4% and then also retains that additional U million dollars scenario L increases the uh compensation expenses to 5% um and then scenario M was an idea that I floated uh last week Thursday increasing the compensation to 6% in the first year and then 4% in years two and years three so that's uh that's how we kind of packaged these scenarios or came up with these ideas not to say that any of them is what you have to go with um but hopefully we
020can find some resonance around one of those and we can uh perhaps uh get some board alignment on that tonight uh or I can do some more work between now and tomorrow night are there any board questions or comments on any of the scenarios Mr Anderson Mr shady I I guess in general I I mean I do like the idea of a stable mill rate I think that's that's just good for everyone the only question I have of where that would would and should land would also need to include what impact a future Capital referendum would have right so like just looking at these scenarios which thank you for putting them together you know somewhere in that 7 to 7 and a half mil rate makes makes sense to me um but if you tell
021me that a capital referendum is going to move that to 12 now I'm sure it wouldn't I'm just saying because because it's stretched out longer because you know but I'm saying the impact that we are going to have you know our some Capital needs at some point um you know the impact that that would have on it you know if you were to say hey that might raise it because again we we spent a lot of time right at 10 yep and that's a very comfortable level I think so I I'm not opposed to go into 10 but if we're not asking for the capital stuff yet we need to leave room so that when we ask we can still be under that number right and I think we're probably going to be good let
022let me if I can just have a few minut us to talk about the mill rate so we're seeking stability in the mill rate much like the district had for a number of years up until the last four years or so uh which has kind of been the downfall the numbers that we're looking at 680 715 750 are gross numbers and I say that intentionally because when we factor out the revenue limit worksheet you know we come up with that mill rate at the end however that mill rate does not take into any consideration the school levy tax credits that the municipalities apply to property tax bills to essentially buy down that value and unfortunately that buy down uh School ly tax credit amount kind of varies from year to year the other thing that
023I'll point out is that the mill rate um there's really two factors that help calculate the mill rate what the tax levy is and what the total equal equalized value of the district are that's different than the assessed value of the district total equalized value comes from the Department of Revenue that's one of those figures that we receive on October 1st in the budget model we're anticipating a 2% increase in the equalized value which is likely less than what it will be for the number of years back like the last five years um it had average anywhere from like or not average but it had been I think a 12 or 16% increase 7% increase it's likely to come in stronger than 2% that we're using in the budget model always best to air on
024the low side here because when it comes in higher say at 5% um growth and equalized value then your mill rate is going to drop from 715 to like the 680s so it's beneficial to us so when we think about equalized Val or equalized um assessed value from Department of Revenue coming in in stronger and applying the school levy tax credits the net impact to property taxpayers would be less which would provide opportunity then for future Capital referendum um priorities that may be needed to be addressed down the road yes Megan Miller thank you and thank you Mr Katie that was a really helpful explanation um also thank you so much for your work all of these scenarios are really exciting I think they offer um you did a great job like reflecting back the
025conversation from Thursday um so just to kind of like in the interest of consensus forming I I would be happy like in this realm uh I really really like um scenarios M as in Mary and L quite a bit I think budgeting High to retain teachers is key when we spoke on Thursday about what our priorities are there were three of them and two of them are entirely reliant on our staff so I I'm really leaning more towards scenarios M and L but I'm interested to hear what my colleagues have to say as well thank you Mrs leevy thank you um am I looking at this correctly in that scenario H is the only one that would give us the flexibility to bring on new supports um for behavor uh and supported bullet Memorial I
026I would not necessarily um state that well without using the Surplus the resources that are provided you know can certainly be targeted or prioritized to meet certain needs um you know scenario H specifically was a request at 750 for a mill rate and then to support new and additional behavioral support and I can't recall exactly how many positions that was off the top of my head uh and the BL Memorial High School transportation which we're ballparking at $500,000 um but those things could be attended to in any of the scenarios to be honest with you it's about prioritizing your resources so that make you're making sure that you're um striving for your goals that we're looking to uh to hit here so it's my understanding that the scenarios as presented and as you beautifully explained
027in our previous meeting unless it's had that notation that like we could bring in new things or specifically transportation that those things were not earmarked so to speak or we would have to use the Surplus in order to make that happen and I'm not comfortable with using the Surplus for something that's not specifically identified and money set aside for because when we hit that Cliff we're not going to have anything to address it and if we don't pass a subsequent referendum like that feels very Bleak to me so without going into Surplus is scenario H the only one that has those specific items that are listed like new and additional behavioral supports and the transportation and the additional compensation for staff and we have some flexibility how we use that it's scenario h the one
028that covers all of those items without using the projected Surplus or am I not reading these scenarios correctly so can I jump in so Mrs leevy great question scenario H was a package that we put together that did have the the things those two items input into not having to touch the Surplus so you're correct scenario H does provide that level of those two support areas now what we also did was we looked at I'm just going to go back up to the top of the page if you look at scenario J scenario k um we we said the 3% across the board as we've been discussing with $1 million additional something um because we didn't want to you know dictate what the board wanted to lean in on as pertains to the the buckets
029and the priorities so we said like in scenario J it'll be with $1 million additional of something scenario okay same thing 4% though was included in the salaries with $1 million into something um and that's kind of those those are the three areas in which unless me tell you think I'm saying something the wrong scenarios J K thank you SC JK and H provides a level of something that we could do without having to touch the um the Surplus thank you so much for that clarification and the reason that I asked at our last meeting to have that cushion is that my intention and just I'm just speaking for myself I want to be clear about that is for us to have an additional cushion so we can address that Cliff if this referendum passes
030but the next one does not um so and and I appreciate the board's understanding of me needing to be flexible today because I have work commitments um so I might have to jump off in a little bit but I will join you as soon as I can I can't support well I'm very uncomfortable supporting a referendum that does not have those ports that we discussed um because I see that as part of the visioning that we asked our community and staff to come and share with us what they want our district to look like so I am in favor of scenario H I am very uncomfortable with a scenario that does not specifically set aside funding for those additional things that we want that our that community members that participated said that they want thank
031you Miss Lee I'm Sorry Miss Le we can ask you a question um for clarification so with scenarios again that I mentioned J and scenarios K I know it doesn't get us to the five and or the 6% the other board members kind of mentioned as a as a thought process for our staff Jay does provide a level of some Surplus and a million dollars towards something as well as scenario K so would you be amable to and I hate to use the word am meable what would you be amable to the words to scenarios J and K and H because that that opens up a little more no because I think 3% is too low if we are making a ask with intent ality of financially supporting our staff um I for me the
032the floor that I am comfortable with is 5% um So currently scenario H is the only one that I'm comfortable with but but thank you for asking that additional question just to let you know scenario H is a three 3% um increase um to that seven to to stabilize a m rate at 753 751 and 746 scenario um J is the 4% I'm sorry scenario K is the 4% um opportunity for increase in staff pay thank you oh I thank you because I didn't realize it was three and then I'm going to zip it because other people have their hand raised and I want to be respectful of that um if scenario AG only includes the 3% then I can't support that one either thank you so much thank you Mrs Levy um Brian Nichols
033I'll uh give you the floor and then I would like to ask board members if um what their floor is is it um 5% is it 3% or something else I I think uh I'm between four and 5% so I I I'll go for four but I could probably be swayed you had your hand up was there another comment you wanted to make okay thank you Greg Schneider um one I think that the floor as we start looking at Personnel increases I think would for me would would be 5% uh simply because we do need to make up some time that we've lost over the last couple years um and so we also need to be ready for what's coming in the future um with that said I think scenario H if that would incorporate
034the the increase in in Personnel costs um would be my preference um it's it's the one that uh does give us the ability to do what the community has asked us to do to to continue to address increased academic achievement to continue to support to work with behavior issues within the buildings um to support all of our students that are there um and to provide some you know some other supports to enable our our students to be in school um and and to be in the classes um so my preference would be to stay with h but with an increase in the Personnel cost in Megan Miller thank you so much so yeah the reason that I didn't say hro off the bat is because I remember it being the 3% from last time so
035I just want to Echo the comments of the two previous board members um miss or Mrs Ley and Mr Schneider um I'm also I just want to put out there I'm open to I really like um in addition to what was said the scenario M kind of layout of the staff compensation I think Mr Anderson's um email last week also had something like that I like the idea um to to Mr Schneider's point of of putting in kind of a spike right off the bat because we have been so behind um and I think like ideally if we could level out at five that would be awesome I'm open to a leveling out at four but if we I would just I'm curious what it would come out to to see scenario H with sort
036of um like a six% 5% 5 percent just so we could kind of like see it but that's kind of my line of thinking I'm I'm not comfortable throwing out like this is a hard floor I'm still kind of learning from what other people are saying but I'm leaning toward as much staff compensation as we can get um and echoing the idea that we have to deliver on what the community has told us that they wanted Mr Anderson yeah again I I like the idea of you know going as high as even 6% the first year um senario M that goes down to 4% on two and three um I think that gives it doesn't mean it couldn't be five or 6% right it what it means is we we're committing to that amount because
037we're going to spend that from referendum dollars it doesn't mean um if other situations change that we couldn't do just like we make a decision now of what it's going to be anywhere from zero to whatever you know whatever percent we choose so I think I don't think going down to four precludes us from giving five or six in years two and three um but at least it spells out hey this is what's budgeted because we got money from the community so I think um you know as long as I I like the the staff compensation at 644 I'm still okay with a mill rate under scenario M if it were to go above the 715 if it went up to that 7 and a half and Incorporated some other things um that's that's where
038I would land Brian Nichols thank you uh Mr chady let's take M and if we move that from to [Music] 544 if I remember your comments last week that would we would pick up another we would pick up a million dollars as in as we did in J and K is that correct I yeah I believe that would be accurate yes okay so because J&M with the $1 million additional that was to use for the transportation and behavioral is that correct uh the $1 million additional in jnk um I would say was not earmarked okay I just we used the million dollars and okay you know okay we can determine the priority of that after the fact is kind of what I told Dr Garrison okay but if we if we move down to AG
039what amount did you put in there for additional Behavior Support and B B and bmhs transportation bmhs transportation is uh estimated at $500,000 so a half a million for yeah behavioral well probably I think it was more than that quite honestly I it was over a million and I just I can't recall the exact value you I'd have to dig out that estimate or that scenario um and look into that with regard to the BAM HS Transportation so when we talk about Transportation at our Middle School level students need to reside at least two miles away from the Middle School to be eligible for transportation um or reside in a hazardous Transportation Zone if we put a two mile perimeter circle around blit Memorial High School we're getting way out on the fringes of the
040district um I don't know if $500,000 I don't know if it'll cost that much and I think we would need to check to check with those students to see if they would ride so uh lots of things that we have to think about with regards to that but yeah so that that was the number that we used okay yeah I was just trying to back in to something that would maybe be more agreeable to to the board yeah I mean I can certainly I mean it sounds to me like we're in that hm area uh sinking staff compensation to be higher uh perhaps at that 644 544 six five4 whatever right I mean we could do all any and all sorts of things right um and then also provide for some of those additional behavioral
041supports let's just call it some other right I mean you know does transportation get in there not for me to say um behavioral supports you know curricular supports those types of things again not for me to say but let me uh see if I could call up um scenario H and make some revisions to that here Dr Garrison thank you so um one of the things that so Bas Mrs um Mrs Johnson would you mind sharing your floor for um conversation go ahead I need your I was writing down the the numbers oh oh oh so oh oh I'm sry sharing the floor yes you have the floor um I I'm with Brian Anderson I like the 644 as a starting point and my rationale behind that is and that's floor last board meeting I
042remember it was reported out that we had over 50 um in instructor positions open we're doing something wrong in um recruiting and um keeping staff here and I think it's really important that we um pay our staff well um we we we want to keep them here give them the training they need to be high quality good good Educators to our students um and you know just over the state line it's much more competitive um quite quite honestly going a step further I I know in H you've got the bmhs transportation and I know in the Hadley reports from the feedback from our listening sessions transportation did come up but nowhere did I see specifically transportation for high schoolers now personally I love the idea of having transportation for everyone know if I had a
043magic wand I would just have free public transportation period um but I'm a little concerned right now if it was my my decision alone and I had 500,000 to spend for high school transportation or for teacher pay or for addressing Behavior it go to the teacher pay or behaviors be before the high school transportation I don't know was were studies done on the public transportation do we know how many other Urban school districts provide transportations for transportation for their high school students um this is it was kind of a yeah that's that's where I am and great great thoughts there um so just hearing from the board I'm hearing and and if you just look at the snapshot um 5% is where just based off of an average mostly five um% and 6% was the
044the the thoughts and so five actually with to be exact the number was 5 point one 16% if we did an average of of of where we're where we're Landing with teacher pay can the board get behind 5% as a starting point as a as a number I just need to make sure because because I don't I want to kind of land in this space because it's going to help us with other spaces Mr Nicholls um you mentioned your loow would be a 4% would you be okay with the 5.5% yes uh Mr Snider would you be okay with 5% yes Mr Anderson would you be okay with 5% yes um I know Mrs Levy is is Miss Le you can hear us it' be great if you can chime in on the 5% yes
045my answer is yes thank you so much thank you so much um uh Mrs Miller would you be okay with 5% yeah yes okay and um Mrs Johnson okay so we're 5% that's what we'll kind of land at for now um with this scenario and I think that gives Mrs Johnson the question around what the floor would be um so we can you know kind of continue with the conversation is that okay thank you so 5% Mr Shady so we're looking at a 5 perc and then the the the cascading down to 544 is what we're what we're looking at um keep in mind right now the CPI for next year according to our conversations last week was about 3% it's Landing in that area but we we're also want to get get back where
046we kind of left off with being able just to do half over the past you know three years since we've been in the conversation two years two or three years um so 5% is where we're Landing with that now I need to jump us into you know just progress the conversation just a little bit into the package space um so we're going to be okay with the 544 that's that's where we're Landing Mr Snider yes yes I I would Advocate that yes yep Mrs Anderson y Okay cool so 544 Mr shady is kind of what we're looking at with the cascading down conversation the million dooll package um um let me just say this so if and just is piggy back off from Mrs Johnson's conversation um this gets a little hard to be honest
047with y'all um so you know naturally we would like to do everything okay board I think I think we will love to do everything but realistically is at the space where we're are going to land and so what I want to just think about is if you had to forget about the number what would it what would be the thing that you want to see in this conversation and so that's going to help me determine what the number is going to be behind that that Mak sense so forget about the million dollars or the $1.8 million that it would cost for discipline and and the 1 point I'm sorry $1.8 million that would cost for academics the 1 Point $6 million that'll cost for um Behavior and the 1.5 million over three years that'll cost
048for transportation let's just think about what do you really want to see in that other package space and since we probably won't all agree to three give me your top two um if you don't mind so I can kind of you know level set where where we're Landing in that space now the board could always tell me Dr Garrison back up we just want to be able to talk about the million dollars in Surplus conversations later but it'll help if we were concise in this space at this point so um Mrs Johnson I'll turn back over you for to lead that discussion if you don't mind okay just so I am clear you are asking us for our top three priorities or what we want to see specifics what can can you clarify a little
049bit what you're asking so we have we have our buckets of priorities and right now we've definitely landed in that we want to pay our staff so that one is already on on the table in the scenario bucket okay the second thing we need to figure out is is of the other three priorities transportation um behavior and academics um is there a top that you want to see that's going to be included in whatever package we end up building the million dollars the you know $2 million that's going to cost whatever it is because that's something that I have to get at if we're going to get to you know a landing space um tonight so that's that's is that clear okay Mr do you mind going first please yeah I'll jump in I'm Sorry
050Miss Johnson I'll po um so I think you know with the teacher pay thing settled the other two for me would be the the behavioral support whether that what form that takes we can we can talk about but um and then restoring fund balance now I think we can spend the remaining funds on those discipline and behavioral related issues and I think if we adhere to the budget fund balance if we have 56 positions open every year that's 4 million that's budgeted but it's not going to be spent which inherently then if it's budgeted and it's accounted for can return to fund balance each year which I think would help solve some of board member Levy's concern about this Cliff I think we could add to fund balance not that we need to use it
051but what it does is it allows you to to make maybe a smaller ask in year four or um you know or if it for some reason another one wouldn't pass um it's not such a big Cliff Mr siner can I jump to you please I mean the two biggest ones that we're hearing from the community are academic achievement and Behavior Support okay um so those would be my top two um again increasing the fund balance could possibly be done by Cuts in other areas by carefully using what we have I mean that I think is also a critical issue for us um but what the community is saying is academic academic achievement and behavior support thank you Mrs Miller I'm sorry Mr and I'm sorry Mr Nicholls sorry just don't call call me late
052for dinner don't forget um well again I'm going to go back to what I was talking about earlier so if we look at M and we got 544 and we had a million dollars off of this 1% we got there we are correct which areas would you want us to put the money towards oh yeah oh yes academic achievement and and behavior okay thank you y thank you um Mrs Levy do I have you still you do so a couple things um so before I answer your question um when I said 5% is my floor that didn't mean 544 um I am I am comfortable with a consistent Vibe um the other thing that I wanted to address briefly before I answer your question is I know you mentioned um board member hanen previously expressed
053thoughts about it but I I just don't think that's fair to build that in since he's not here and assume that there is consensus so I'm unclear on whether our consensus is threee or foury year um and then to answer your question I don't have a priority because I think all of these things have to be done but we definitely have to address um pay of Staff we have to address academic achievement and we have to address behaviors um and I am hopeful that we can partner with the city to also address Transportation um hopefully in an an amount that will be lower than what is budgeted or projected with the 500,000 thank you Miss Ley so I'm hearing you say academic behavior and also heard you say the consensus space is is a thought
054I'm just trying to get us to a certain package for our conversation really for tomorrow as well but it it allows me to kind of keep working from to eliminate some of our um I hate to say options but to kind of hone Us in towards where we're going but thank you for adding the academic and behavioral piece all of it is important to you what I'm hearing um but maybe we can do something different with the city from a transportation perspective um Mrs Miller but yeah um just because I don't want to repeat anything that's been said I'm really seeing I know that you're asking for specific priorities I haven't heard anything I've disagreed with um I will say that obviously academic and behavior it's it's a reciprocal relationship I think like what Mrs
055Ley was saying between all three right you got to get kids in seats you have to have like safe manageable learning spaces and of course you have to have the investment and academic support so what I will contribute specifically is we need more people and training and I think that the prioritization of academic and behavioral should be like needs based by building so like that's kind of my copout way of saying I really like both and the thing I want to contribute to with Transportation um I think board President Johnson touched on this earlier I'd really be interested in seeing if we're able to invest more in Middle School transportation there are kids with really long bus rides uh because of our shift to the two schools with fren and Aldridge if it's possible to
056allocate some of that million-ish dollars in one of those options if that's where we choose to go to expanding the number of routes I think a compromise between offering busing to the high school and increasing our routes for middle school would be to me like kind of The Sweet Spot for transportation so like yeah like all three but I think like you know academics and behavior have to be our main investment because I do think there are hopefully potential partnership opportunities of Transportation but of course all three thank you um and Mrs joha thank you and thank you everyone for for sharing all all of great comments great ideas um and yeah all of these needs are very very important very relevant very real some of my concerns and I'm thank you for giving us
057the weekend to reflect and listen to constituents and giving everyone time to to weigh in um I know one of the scenarios included like six behavioral specialists and the AP back at the high school um I'm still a little bit hazy on what exactly a behavioral specialist is versus a psych what a psychologist or a counseler or an uh interventionist might do or provide and I'm wondering if our our staffing behavior and academics if if we're trying [Music] to solve a problem with money without addressing where the problem is happening and to what Miss Miller just referred to what what's happening in the classroom would would a million dollars of Behavioral special be better spent as a million dollars of extra par Educators paid at a higher rate in the classrooms where the learning and
058behavior issues start um so so that's a a question con concern of mine um I I think we need to start building back our HR department we're if we're having this the fact that we're Staffing is such a big issue it's and yes the teacher shortage is happening everywhere and part of the reason why we're really in a bind because we you know we're short on money we're short on staff um we we need to do something and I'd like to see a position return to the HR department I'd like to see the AP position restored at the high school um and I would like to have uh behavioral specialist if I felt more comfortable that that was the solution I um I don't know um what the solution is for the behavior you know
059if you look at our code of conduct we seem to have a pretty pretty tight code of conduct but the behaviors continue the the other um issue in terms of behavior and academics that I would like to see addressed is um Early Childhood literacy and Readiness getting the students in um ready to learn when when they come in as kindergarteners or 4K um not that they have to be reading at that level but having the appropriate behaviors and ability you help help me working with Community groups to get our our young young people ready for school is a concern okay thank you Miss Johnson I think I'm definitely hearing you speak to academics as a space as a space and um the behavior as a space as well and what it actually looks like both
060both areas to I did ask Mrs um um beavers to address the Peril space um you're saving around would Peril be better than behavioral specialists um and maybe even you know Venture down the thought around when we think about behavioral specialists again adding another person to support our behaviors in our buildings outside of it just really Landing in a few people's spaces is what we were thinking about and that disposition was something that was already that was already done in our district but I'm let Mrs beavers kind of speak to that pocket of information before we kind of move forward I don't have a lot to say I just my personal opinion is throwing bodies at the problem is not going to solve it and in the spirit of continuous Improvement we have to look
061at the system and so whatever these positions are called my hope would be that they're doing some systems work because we're not going to fix the kids we have to fix our system systems to support the kids as to how they're showing up to us so I guess I would push back a little bit on Paras just because that's a Band-Aid to probably a larger problem okay so if it's the systems then is it Behavior so as I said I'm not certain I know what a behavioral specialist is and you know would is that is would it be better to try to recruit more counselors or psychologists or social workers what's what is your opin your your professional opinion on what would help fix our system yep I personally think that we need to give
062teachers more tools to manage their classrooms how we go about doing that through professional learning through whatever these positions Behavior Specialists you know I'm I'm not I'm not sure that I have the answer right here tonight but I can certainly think about that and get back to you can you explain the different what what is a behavior specialist and and I I heard Dr Garrison say that the district has had them in the past I don't think during any time that I've been on the board that we had behavioral specialist so it's something I'm un personally unfamiliar with I mean I think I think um you could call them behavior interventionists and they'd be the same thing so just like you have an academic interventionist this would be similar to supporting Behavior I don't know
063if that helps okay thank you you know working through the tiered interventions like typically we when a student cannot read we intervene and we give them additional help and we support them through the tiered interventions and behavior we usually just exclude them and we don't teach them the tools they need to be supported in the classroom so really looking at that multi-level systems of support and how we can support them in learning appropriate behavior and giving teachers the tools so to me it would be a 5050 like you're working with students but you're also working with the adults in the building okay just my personal opinion that's what we okay okay thank you thank you Miss Miller thank you so much I just um wanted to just um kind of react to two things you
064said that I thought were awesome one with regards to the early literacy intervention um I used to work in a grant with the library and it still exists and it's fantastic it was a play and read Grant but it's now called ABC play group it's dancer Aly children playgroup the library has done a fabulous job of sustaining the program and the entire purpose of that was a partnership between DPI the arrowhead library system and I just totally say oh and a miracor um to provide early literacy um and kind of kindergarten Readiness to three and four year olds and so this is a program that still exists one of the members of our um uh Finance ad hoc committee was one of our volunteers and um this is a program that used to be in
065our schools and so this is absolutely something that we could um engage in partnership with so I just want to put that out there and just kind of you know contribute to what you said also with um I just wanted to like kind of in addition to what Miss Beaver shared just to kind of help because I know it's like hard when you're not like in the classrooms and stuff so like with behavior um whether it's intervention or specialist that could be something like you need that extra grown up to come and like you've got your case load of kids and maybe you've got a checkin checkout system which you know special education teachers case loads are overflowing just because a child has a behavior issue also doesn't necessarily mean that they have an IEP
066right so they might not be able to get those services so being that person to say here's my case load of kids who have some additional needs and I really want them to be successful keep keep kids in es keep them learning and contributing positively to that learning environment right and so having said that that could be like hey I'm your safe person we built this relationship what are we going to do in class today if we're feeling like you know chucking that pencil at that or you know or whatever it is it could be stuff like that kids who get disregulated we do have a great code of conduct of course there's always stuff we could build on it right but having um that's only one half of the equation right because people do
067impulsive stuff especially teenagers right and so so having a a a person and a place for a child to go to makes teaching spaces right like safer you can you know okay Megan you're having a rough day let's go see Miss Mr Mr soul and soul you get to keep teaching that child gets to get re hopefully regulated get back to class and like learn some things right and so I mean I think like that's just my lived experience as a teacher how I've appreciated my colleagues um doing doing that work how I've I've done that work like that in the past too and it's really powerful so it's something that I just like I really want to support I really am hopeful that in this referendum we can U make that one of our
068priorities because it it just as amazing stuff not only for kids but for the culture of the building as well thank you so much thank you Greg Schneider oh I'm I thought I saw your hand up is it was I took it down because Megan was saying the same thing okay okay thank you so um you know what I'm hearing is again just based off of the the snapshots we definitely want to see some form of Behavioral conversations in there and what that actually looks like we mentioned of course the behavioral supports um as a space as well as you know some of the other spaces um as a way to help with the conversation um we can we can definitely we can definitely do that it doesn't have to be a Allin package what
069I mean by that is from a numbers perspective I know we talked about a three-year total being about $1.8 million which is overall I mean roughly roughly you know divide that by $600,000 a year in a nutshell um 6 128 yeah and so that's what that behavioral package would look like academically um we talked about literacy and math being the space and I know can you project that for us oh sure sure I'm I'm thinking I'm y'all looking at the same thing let me do this real quick um and so um and just for those who follow along with it this is something that's in the um bardocks as well just just just in case um so the academics and behavioral support cost the packages that we have here you know please note that any
070form of these packages we could do um from academic space and from our behavioral space and it may not be like you know the Allin $1.8 million it may not be the Allin $1.6 million but we could actually do something in both um um so that's just a space that I wanted to kind of bring note to um so academics and behavioral is what I'm hearing is something that's very important the transportation we would have to look at you know no one necessarily from a consistence perspective say that this has to be in the conversation but maybe in our and just hear me out in some of the surpluses that we get naturally over time with um some of the natural attrition spaces that we have people retire those conversations that we can look at
071up a bucket of funds to to support that Mrs Mrs um Johnson you also mentioned Early Childhood conversation um that you know zero to three possible space there you know I would love to do everything um I would love for all that to kind of roll into a space however you know these all comes with you know additional cost that was not built into the our necessarily built into the conversation from January the 9th and I want to make sure that I honor you know that thought um but it doesn't mean that we can't still have conversations in it when we have a surplus in these in these buckets of money when we lay out the five for for possibility um with that being stated Mr chady I think from a funding perspective we're looking
072at um a 544 possibly a three-year I say possibly a threeyear based off of the conversations now and until tomorrow and then a package that includes behavior and academics um my goal is again to kind of like I mentioned to kind of get us to a space where we are kind of Landing so that tomorrow or even today we can say you know what let's hone in on what we really mean around academics and or behavior we can do that today as well um but we do need to of course um get to that closer to that space in which we're Landing Mr T can you tell us what that 544 could look like with a not necessarily with a package right now but just with that 544 yeah give me two minutes okay so
073we can actually play um a game no just play just joking not um but that's just full for thought so I'm I'm going to repeat one of my um concerns and that is we are moving in a forward direction we we understand we need more people um do we have the current staff to go out and recruit and find people great question um our current staff will consist of all of our hiring managers so that'll include all of the principles of course HR um naturally all of the directors all of us are involved in trying to recruit in those spaces now realistically putting this out there to the public with a said in with a said salary would could possibly attract people and naturally couldn't as well could people some people that be like I
074really want to get paid more if I'm going to be a behavioral person in the building um we did build in uh like I like Mrs aleris mentioned uh the base of about $50,000 for those positions with with Benny's included in that in in those scenarios in our scenarios here so that's the space that we'll be working from I do think we'll be able to put something out I do think we'll have some people that will jump into the page how many people will jump into the conversation is yet to be determined because natural we haven't put it out yet at some point um and while Bob is doing his calculations at some point I I would like um for the board to receive a report on um are the positions that we are using
075contracted services for like how how many what what positions and how much we are spending for um outside recruiting firms to find find people for us to recap you want in the future a possible report around contractor services and the positions how how much we're spending in the contract Services okay any board members have any questions or comments while we are waiting Mr Anderson um I would just say that I think you know we identify academics and behavior I think like board member Miller said they kind of go hand inand and and I think as we get our arms around behavior in the classroom I think that feeds into additional academic achievement um so it's not necessarily A A duplicative spend in each bucket to achieve the same result because they they will have you
076know one does have effect on the other so I just throw that out thank you Mr chady um put it in the chat I think for the meeting if Dr Garrison thank you so um one of the things that that I like about any of these scenarios is the opportunities for it that we can still grow from from these spaces um I think it's very important to note that the goal of every district is to of course not only just balance this budget to but to have a surplus at the end of each year right and I think again this referendum you know when we move forward um allows us to have these growth conversations from a year-to-year perspective knowing that there's going to be some form of possible Surplus coming back to us that
077we will ha that will naturally happen in our school district along with what you see here on on on the projected estimate estimated values so I just want to make sure we note that too I know again the goal is to try to get everything but you know we have to you know be mindful that that may not be a space a possibility for us um and I'm confident that my district will be able to address you know and our district will be able to address the the spaces around behavioral spaces around Transportation the spaces around um academics um with with the support um that this could provide so what Mr chady um provided for us um and the link will be um shared could you project this Mr chaden by chance okay all right
078let's just do that for everybody can see it at the same time um I did stop sharing so what Mr CH just provided for us was a snapshot of that 544 I'm sorry scenario H with the new stuff everything um and then uh scenario H1 which was a subpart of scenario h that'll gave us the 544 space and then a scenario H2 that gave us a straight five space across the board and what that actually looked like in uh projected savings um when I say savings projected Surplus and so I allow Mr chady to kind of walk us through those numbers and what that what we're actually looking at as a team yeah so uh board member Miller board member Levy uh I put this document linked uh in the chat so if you want
079to um access it if you've got a printer or something nearby otherwise we've got it presented on the screen as well so scenario H at the very top boy can I make that a little bit bigger can't figure out how to do that anyway so scenario H at the top was the same scenario that we looked at previously I did insert in there the 3% uh to reflect the salary wage Personnel cost increases that were being utilized scenario H1 uh approximately that $750 C mill rate it uh it grosses at 753 uh and it uses 5% increase in Personnel costs in the 25 26 school year followed by 4% in 26 27 2728 and then it also has the additional $1,669 th000 uh which was that additional combination of that additional supports for uh behavioral
080support and be at just Transportation I just left the descriptors as to how the money was going to be used off the table because we could prioritize that in any fashion honestly and then just uh to satisfy my own um I did scenario H2 which is the same scenario just it utilizes that 5% adjustment for compensation um Personnel costs in each of the three years so you can see when you're looking at the projected Surplus deficit scenario H1 has a projected Surplus uh just shy of 2.7 million scenario H2 uh has a projected Surplus just uh just over 1.6 million over the course of the three years Dr Garrison thank you so thank you Mr trady for providing that snapshot and overview um you know the 544 you guys see the mill rate being the
081753 what I didn't do is have a general conversation with the floor and ceiling in that space But I do believe um that you know as we you know kind of work through these scenarios that the mill rate if you focus on that it could be definitely lower um in all of those spaces and so Mr Nicholls you mentioned the possibilities of a five I'm sorry of a 644 consensus well I shouldn't say consistence but the numbers of a 544 was presented and also that 555 the savings are you know very clear here um 26 and six uh million so bored um going back to um this space again that 1.66 million of new and additional could be in again in that package conversation going back to some of Mrs Johnson's thoughts of what what
082how much and what we could put towards behavioral and behavioral and academics um so board you have another snapshot at you know something like this if if I can interject real quick I I just discovered uh in scenario H2 H2 okay line out that projected Surplus deficit in the 28 29 school year L out yeah my bad and I'll give you the new number I forgot to update that the new value would be 20 million1 415 20 million 19 195 415 that would be the deficit value in 2829 with scenario H2 my apologies for that thank you Miss Miller thanks I just also uh didn't want to lose the thought thank you so much for this Mr taty that $753 c number is $39 more then the state is going to charge us next year
083for property taxes which would yield nothing which you know keeps keeps us in a bad spot so for $39 more right all this C be so I really like all three scenarios I want to hear from everybody else so before I weigh in on which one thanks Mr Nichols thank you um okay how do we um you lost me when you came back with a1669 th000 I thought we were talking approximately a million so how did we get to 1.66 n uh scenario H always had that 1,669 value built into it okay I didn't realize it was that much I thought it was around a million I thought no no no okay yep okay well um I I personally believe that if we can if we can stay around that 715 mil rate gross I
084think we're close I think we're more likely to get that P be successful with that when you I know that it may not seem a lot but 750 750 753 7 is uh 70% above that 444 if we did nothing next year so that's a that's a huge jump uh for the for the average uh homeowner here in bloy so um I think if we could stay around the 715 number we would be uh better served come election day just my again that's my my feedback any other board members Dr Garrison well that's well that's the difficulty that we're that we're working from you know again if you know the mill rate you know to go from the 715 is number to the um 753 number you know takes us back towards the package in
085which we're trying to to build um for for our for our for our community and of course for the staff um you know when the board when you all you know of course the board wants to give more and the salary compensations that also impacts the the mill rate you know now naturally and that's the hard part about you know kind of what we're doing um and trying to you know get as close to what the board would like to see based off of the conversations here all the while understanding that any change that you make in in these types of conversations will definitely impact our overall mill rate so um that 5% does impact that 753 um you you bet you it does and and so forth the four and the for we we
086built the the district built the 3% because of where we left off in previous conversations okay that's the only reason why we build a 3% as a board and of course internally as a as as a as a as a space to honor here in the school district hearing from you all you we want to do more but understand it's going to impact that mill rate there's nothing we can do around that outside of not doing some of the other things okay and if if that be the case board you know that's how this this this this activity and this conversation becomes much more difficult for us to keep you know trying to hone in on what what that would look like and so um Mr um Nicholls you are correct it does you know
087that 715 was a good space again if we land in that space great if we want to do more for our staffs and at the other packages then we need to be able to go out as a team and naturally support um this this space if that's where we want to land and that's my sentiment um maybe we can bring back another scenario um that allows you know maybe like I said going back to the page even you know we did have in the original document today that 4% space um but that's not what a board is and that kepts us around that 7 15 number again me and Mr Chaya had tons of conversations around what that actually could look like and sound like and come back with um but that 3% is also
088something that we built in to keep us around that 715 number but that's a lower number so um we would love to give the staff what you all are proposing here but that does come with the additional mill rate space unless we take off other themes okay so that's something the board would have to help me decide thank you Brian Nichols thank you just just I want to clarify I'm not I'm not against the wage increase at all the 5% I'm good with 555 or 544 I'm good with either one of those absolutely uh I was just questioning the the extra money was more than I thought we were talking about so my my you know my mistake for assuming that so um anyway but the other part of my conversation I stand on thank
089you Brian Anderson yeah I like the I like the conversation on that mill rate and Mr Shady did a good job earlier of saying you know I think a 750 mill rate can be is not inappropriate um lower means just less Services right but I think that 753 in this scenario H1 as he pointed out is still pretty conservative the way it's the way it's calculated right and so I think I'd rather see that 753 and then be able to say yeah but it likely could come in less than that based on equalized value and how and um you know it's kind of a best guess but I don't want to surprise you the other direction cuz we don't want that two years from now either so I think likely could be lower I think
090a 7 and a half mil rate um puts us in good standing within the rest of the state and still allows room for you know what what may or may not come next again with back to that Capital conversation thank you Greg Schneider I guess I like scenario um I like to go with scenario H2 um but I think that kind of restricts us quite a bit on some of the other things that we can do as an option so I would recommend I would think prefer to go with H1 knowing that we have in the second and third year that 4% there for for personnel costs doesn't mean that we can't increase it at that time but at least we know we have that amount that we can go forward with and again this
091this does allow us to do part of what the community is asking us to do um and I think that should be part of the driving force that we need here we know where we need to go but we have to also meet some of the things that the community is is is asking us to do um I think each1 is going to give us that best opportunity to do that thank you any other board members has a question real quick yeah Mr chady H1 and H um you know H H at the top again gave us two snapshots and behavior and transportation again we can switch that stuff around and it could be looks completely different um what I'm hearing from the board again is we want to pay our staff and so that's
092consistence across the board we all want to pay the staff do you do you think a package of would the board be ad meable to a package of 533 now again I don't want that's not what I I don't think you all want to do but if you want to drive the well if we take away the supports my apologies if we take away the supports and then do 544 let's say we go lower in the support area would that change the mill rate much uh it really won't change the mill rate any um what it will do is it'll change your projected Surplus deficit line items okay so so the 544 let's say we did instead of the 1 .6 we didus 600,000 let's say we just did a million and something would that
093lower the mill rate uh no it it really won't lower the mill rate at all either that that'll just go back to adjusting the projected Surplus and deficit line items thank you with regards to the mill rate I know I I think we're right in trying to focus on that from a stability standpoint for both what the property taxpayers would be asked to pay over the next three years and what those additional revenues that it'll generate to the district are and again that Mill rate's kind of the the top end of the mill rate um I could see it coming in closer to seven plus or minus maybe a dime either way and again a number of factors will determine that when it comes to actually writing the question we can't write the question based
094on a mill rate so we have to write the question based on a dollar value and I just want to point out in scenario H1 and scenario H2 if you look at the non-recurring referendum amounts especially in that 25 26 year it so I kind of rounded up to 9,170 in scenario H2 still ended up at that 753 mil rate um and then you can see the adjustments in years two and years three as well just trying to round the values to a more reasonable number or not as a specific number you know just $1,950,000 um as compared to6 m7974 so just something for us think about uh is the actual you know as much as we're approaching it from a mill rate perspective we need to kind of roll back then to that top
095row the non-recurring referendum amounts and once the board is comfortable where you're at I guess I would seek the flexibility from the board to refine that non-recurring referendum amount a little bit so as to not exceed the mill rate but perhaps to turn that into a easy easier figure two to utilize and explain so so there's a lot of Shifting that we're we're talking about right now and I I need to you know kind of bring us back to where we're where we're trying to go for even yet tomorrow um Mrs Johnson what's your thoughts um I I see Mrs Levy has her hand up thank you and I apologize if this was already covered when I had to step away um if I'm understanding the the compensation allocation correctly are we saying when we're
096talking about percentages like 555 or 544 um that is for compensation increases and potential new positions and then when we talk about money allocated for Behavioral support that could also include new positions are we potentially double dipping or how how has the discussion been when I stepped away about allocations in these two different buckets so we're not we're not double dipping um so the 544 is of course the salary increases and then we decided not decided then we talked about 1.6 million um conversation and a new additional um supports and so when we say new additional supports that's still Landing in the area of academics and behavior and so it wouldn't be the total packages that we presented but a portion of both packages in academics and in Behavior so just so I'm clear the
097the percentage of compensation increases is for current staff increases only and when we talk about behavioral support that would include new positions is that accurate that is accurate um as well as new opportunities and academics yes ma'am thank you no problem and so again I want to get us back to um you know moving towards uh not necessarily just a consensus space but trying to get together with a package so what I'm hearing from the board is we would like to be in between the 7 and the 750 preferably closer to that 7115 well I play preferably but that's the statement that Mr Nichols made um we would like the flexibility to think about the total and the total right now is as we as we're Landing is in that $40 million request okay and
098that $40 million request in either scenarios age1 or ag2 is bringing us at that 753 um the difference in in ag is that that's given us only that 3% increase across the board versus the 544 and that's what the change in the $2 million or so has done okay um so Bard I think I do have enough information right now to kind of bring us to a space um from what I'm hearing is we want something in Behavior behavioral and academics we want to continue with the five and consensus is landing closer to that 544 um minus Mr um henin weighing in um the three or the four year conversation based off of who's in the room right now is still the threeyear as a sentiment non reoccurring and um I think I'm I think
099we're we kind of got to go from there vard any other uh questions or comments Brian Nichols thank you board President Johnson um okay I this is driving me nuts uh so in h at 3% without any addition our second year our second year referend referendum amount went from in age was at 13419 okay so we added 4% which as you said earlier is about a million dollars every time we go up a percent or the million dollars when we go down so that works but then we go down to 5% in H2 and it's almost identically the same as it is in 2728 how does that work I know I know we added the 1.66 million right right yep Brian do you mean if I can ask do you mean in 2728 or do
100you mean in H2 as compared to H1 in yeah in H1 and H2 well I started out at H because of the you know it jumped jumped a million because partly because of the salary uh increased from 3 to four but if you go from H1 to H2 the second year and third years are almost identically the same with a 1% with a with a 1% increase in the salary each year so we have to go back to the basics okay and we're going to go back to the revenue limit okay so the revenue limit is driven by two things I mean that that's essentially what we're trying to solve here is the revenue limit and the limitations there in so the revenue limit is comprised of essentially your local property tax right and your
101Equalization Aid okay Equalization Aid one of the key factors in Equalization Aid is how much you spent in the prior year so your prior year spending so within the formula as we are increasing expenses the equalization Aid is being positively impa imped now that either means we get a little bit more Equalization Aid or it minimizes our loss okay so as that Equalization Aid amount within the within the budget model changes then that provides more flexibility within the property taxes which is driven primarily by trying to hit this mill rate target so on one of the notations um of the original document for today you know and I think we spoke about this last week Thursday that every million dollars in referendum authorities about 34 cents in the mill rate every $100,000 is about 3.4
102cents in the mill rate so again trying to approach trying to maximize our Revenue opportunity through the revenue um the non-recurring referendum amount but yet hit these projected mill rate targets that's where you see that fluctuation or the variance um in the non-recurring referendum amount so you would think that okay so if we're going from 4% in year two to 5% in year two and a 1% change was and I got to remind myself was about $55,000 you would think that you would see $55,000 increase in the non-recurring referendum amount but it doesn't really work that way I had to walk myself through this last week as well so yeah so um okay well but Bob thank you for this putting these together I really do appreciate it make you know makes it easier when
103we're when we're getting updated information as soon as we do so thank you Dr Garrison yeah so I think right now um we want to honor the feedback and I want to do one more Ripple round around just from the board if you all don't mind based off of what has been given to you in the last scenario boxes that you see on the screen I want you to decide if you can H H1 or H2 I just want to kind of hear because that's going to help us develop another possible package again tomorrow um but it also allow us to not do a possible package if we can kind of land somewhere um I know please understand I know we will not be able to do everything um and that was always going to
104be a space that we had to contend with and so that's why I wanted to to to hear from you all around your top Behavior or the top three other opportunities paying the staff was one of them behavioral fun balance and behavioral support academics and so we clearly as heard paying the staff academics and behavioral support has been a space in which we want to honor so we've clearly heard that and so I want to rip around real quick around what you see on this last document where you're kind of Landing more okay and again understanding that the 753 is something that we we can play around with a little bit me and Mr chady but it probably won't move too far off of the off of the off of what you see here but
105we can kind of play around with a little bit okay so um Mr Snider if you want mind me starting with you please uh H1 thank you uh Mr Nichols H1 Mrs Levy I'm driving so I'm GNA be the worst participant in this ever because I can't look at the new information that we received okay so we'll we'll pause um Mrs leevy if that's okay and then we'll come back um Mrs um Mr Mr Anderson H1 Mrs Miller I'm at H1 and um Mrs Levy scenario H2 is the one that's consistently 5% 5% 5% increase for staff um Mrs Johnson H2 okay um Mrs Levy um when you get a chance um just you know shoot me a thought and then um we'll go from there but I'm hearing H1 playing around with that package
106a little bit oh Mr Anderson did I say you yeah he said H1 oh did yeah I'm sorry no problem I like that I miss um Mrs Mrs Levy when you get a chance maybe you can shoot me a thought with the scenarios that we have the most recent scenario box of um H H1 and H2 um the major changes is in H2 is the 5% that you requested and we kind of put that together in a snapshot package for you um and then um that's we can kind of you kind of grow from there Miss T do you think we have enough information to pull up pull together may I interject really quickly um just in case I can't pull the link from the chat could Mr Shady or someone could you email me
107this updated document yeah we'll do I just thank you so much okay perfect so you'll get the updated document um and you can kind of let me know what your thoughts are and we'll we'll kind of grow from there Mr Chay do you think we have enough information right now so I'm here in three year based off of what's in the room I know Mr Snider you mentioned you can go either way Megan you mentioned you can go either way if needed I know Mrs Levy you're still at 4 um and the rest of the room was still at three um we definitely heard academics and behavior is where we want to land and then um paying our staff was the other space and I think that 544 is kind of where we're Landing with
108that space now if we wanted to mess with the milw work just a little bit 533 could do it but that'll be a different space that you all would have probably that we'll probably play around with to show you all what that looks like at a tomorrow's conversation um Mrs um Johnson any thoughts for me or takeaways you want us to go back with last questions or comments from board members thank you cabinet members thank you board members for coming out uh tonight for this special meeting and thank you Dr Garrison for putting this together our next item is next meeting dates we have a meeting uh tomorrow tomorrow night the tle committee meeting meets January Tuesday January 14th at 5:00 p.m. we have our regular board meeting um tomorrow night it's been rescheduled due
109to the State Convention the following week and that starts at 6: p.m. and there is a tentative board meeting to um vote on the referendum Thursday January 16th at 5:00 p.m. can I get a motion for adjournment so moved second motion by Brian Nichols seconded by Greg Schneider any discussion Dr uh Dr Garr sure just want to make sure that the board understands we will not be necessarily voting on this tomorrow but we will be real close to making sure that we're this is where we're going to land for a possible vote on Thursday by by show of hands um who will be able to make that meeting I don't have the doodle in front of me so I just want to make sure that we have consensus there the th meeting yes ma'am um
110Greg I am not available for a meeting on Thursday I thought we would be voting tomorrow we weren't able to vote tomorrow due to the resolution language not being able to be posted within a um 24-hour time frame which that's the space that we had to kind of work from Mrs Levy so I um that's something that we weren't able to do but based off of today's conversation that did get us a lot closer to that res resolution language very close if not right there and then we'll be able to vote on on Thursday so just wanted to make sure everyone was aware of that that that change so Mrs Mrs ly thank you for letting us know that you won't be able to to be at that that conversation um Mr Nichols you said
111yes um Miss Thompson yes Bri yes that meeting will probably need to be virtual due to the fact that a lot of us will no I'm sorry be here it'll be in person we'll we're good on the 16 I keep doing that I'm thinking we ahead uh Mrs Miller I didn't see where you will be available yeah I had my hand up I'm good okay thank you so much so we have um a quum thank you thank you all in favor I I I any oppos motion carries unanimously this meeting is adjourned thank you thanks