CorpusRecord 82707

SDB - Special Board Meeting - January 9, 2025 (5:00 p.m.)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / School District of Beloit
Date
2025-01-10
Location
Rock County, WI
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,451 words · about 103 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e okay good evening it is 5:00 I would like to call tonight's special board meeting to order Miss may we get a roll call please yes Greg Schneider present Amy leevy here Brian Nichols here Brian Anderson here Tom henkins here Megan Miller present and tia Johnson here all members are present thank you may I get an approval of the agenda so move second motion of approval of the agenda by Amy Levy seconded by Brian Nichols any discussion hearing none all in favor I I I I any oppose I motion carries unanimously please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance the first item on the agenda tonight is the additional ad hoc budget committee recommendations m show were there any name other names submitted by board members I did not receive any submissions did you receive

002the did uh was the name Juan Romero added to the list last time no okay that was um a suggestion that I'd like to have added okay and I'm sorry could you please repeat the two names I'm sorry it's just one Juan W or Not Sorry W J u a n Romero r o m e r o okay um and um could you refresh my memory on who the board representatives are for that the board um members for that committee last time were um Greg Schneider and Brian Anderson okay do uh Mr Anderson and Mr Schneider do you want to continue as the representatives or would you like um to pass the Baton I'm willing to continue serving in that capacity thank you Mr Anderson um I will pass the Baton thank you thank you

003are there any other board members that would like to volunteer to be the representative for the ad hog budget committee Mr henkins any yeah I would like to my name but I Al want to ask Mrs Fox a question if she's available to answer okay I guess uh we are asked to submit some names but I'm not sure I mean we submitted names before I'm not sure who is on the list from last list or do we have is that public knowledge on who from 24 or 25 last year's ad hoc who may not be and uh attending and before I submit names so we do have a list of names um Mr um henkins I didn't bring that list Down based off of your question right now of course um would you like me

004to go get the list I mean or the names well if tonight's a deadline for adding names I yes I think it'd be prudent thank you I that then I'll go grab that list give me a second I have the sign in sheet from yet last night go ahead Brian Nichols that's perfect Mr sh have did we get responses from any of the other members other than the ones that were there last night no no okay and were two while there's a brief pause if I may May um if the board is extending an invitation to Juan Romero I would suggest that you extend an invitation to all the other Schoolboard candidates as well the reason I'm extending an invitation to him is because he actually contacted me to um let me know that he's

005interested I understand that but I think you're putting yourself in a very precarious position by inviting one and not the others noted [Music] all right with this information thank you I I'm I'm good thank you just let everybody know what I was talking about with Mr henkins um for for the record just because I know that's a question that may come um the list that Mr henin has is provided through an ad hoc committee conversation that we had yesterday that was provided by Mrs Fox and I was just explaining him what that list was thank you okay I will entertain a motion of the approval of the addition of Juan Romero to the ad hoc committee and uh changing Brian Anderson's position and adding Tom henkins is there a motion for approval of these names

006so moved is there a second I'll second motion by Brian Nichols seconded by Brian Anderson any discussion yes go ahead Mr henkins yeah I'm just wondering on the um protocol um Juan is a candidate uh I would like to submit Bill Johnson also if that's what we're going to do I'm not sure how that works out thank you you can make a motion to amend to add his name then I do yes okay may I offer a friendly am Amendment before there's a second um again thank you for your remarks Mr chady I think it would be prudent to at least offer an invitation to all candidates who are not current board members because they had an opportunity to step up and say Yes I want to participate in this so again I I think

007you said his name is Mr Johnson um I if you are willing to accept an amendment to your Amendment um I would like to extend an offer to all non-board candidates to all non-board candidates to all too many mic on to all Schoolboard candidates who are not current board members and the reason is because you asked us and if someone wanted to they could have thrown their name in the hat in the ring yes Mr henkins do you accept that amendment I accept the amendment okay so the amendment accepted by Mr henkins to add all School Board candidates to the list is there a second actually it's noncurrent board members who are candidates non-current board I'll second the motion by Tom hins seconded by Megan Miller any discussion hearing none all in favor I I

008I I I any oppose motion carries unanimously and a mo or um any discussion on the original motion Miss Levy oh no I apologize I didn't take my hand down from before okay so all in favor I oops I I I I any oppos motion carries so our budget ad hoc committee will extend the invitation to all Schoolboard candidates noncurrent members and Greg Schneider and Tom henkins will be our board repes for that next on the agenda is the board referendum 2025 presentation Dr Garrison so um board uh first of all let me just say thank you again for this um opportunity to you know talk again about our referendum one of the things I do not want to do tonight and I'm just going to put it on the table is is to spend

009a lot of time um on these first few slides but I also want to address that the reason why we're here is because we definitely have a referendum um opportunity that we we we we believe as a school district uh we need to approach um with that being stated there's going to be a lot of completing competing opportunities at the at the conversational table here where you know one may believe one should one thing should be there and another should be something else but our hopes is that we can at least have this um um conversation and get um to the uh back end of the conversation where we can have a lot more um um um deep deep discussion and so what you have here in front of you um and I was able

010to share this about to two hours ago um um with you all and I appreciate your patience as we kind of work through um some of the um numbers with this um the agenda is as such we're going to do a overview and purpose background context referendum guiding priorities Community Connection listening opportunities guiding priority cost proposed reference scenarios and of course next steps Community Information and timeline um this agenda we're again going to run through U fairly quickly to get us to the space in which we can all kind of have a a deeper conversation around the actual scenarios and the overall request and I think that that space is very important because again no matter what we may ask for in in any referendum um looking at those scenarios as pertains to the cost

011will inevitably most in most cases drive a lot of the conversations um we already know why we're here um we've been talking about sustaining them and supporting our district um um throughout the course of the past three years and right now we're looking at a three and or four-year non-recurrent operational reference referendum um that's been something that's been discussed here at the board level um for a few months now and I believe it was important that I go ahead and put it on the table that we would be um having this type of conversation for tonight our main goal is to address our our priority operational needs um um by requesting additional funding that will provide for a more stable Financial Outlook we are constrained by some state and local funding um the state imposed

012Revenue limits do do not currently provide the district with sufficient revenues to maintain our current operations why this matter well I believe we all know why this matters at this point um we have to really U come to grips with our financial space in the school district of booy and our depleting um fund balance needs not only that but our overall ability to do the things that we believe is the best things for our students is at question when we don't have these opportunities lined up and so again that's the wide matter of space some of the background context and again you've seen in this slide before once you've if you've been anywhere in any of our conversations over the many years we've shared this slide um most important I think the state knows this

013slot um and I use the analogy of you know gas is not 98 cents anymore I think gas is R around $2 and something now um overall there's been a cost that districts have had to try to keep up with and we just haven't been able to keep up with those costs based off of how School School District revenues per people lag behind the inflation and that's right now as it pertains to about $3,300 since 2009 that's a big gap it's a big gap that we have to try to um you know try to figure out as we go we also have another uh thought that we've been talking about we've we've had some declining enrollment and I don't want to take this off the slide because I think I didn't want to take this

014out of the presentation because I think this still does affect how we actually look at our revenues here here in the school district um our goal is to improve um our uh uh improve our product so that when parents have the opportunities to look at our school district they choose us right we want the students and families in the school district of booy to stay with us but we also want the prospective parents to come to us and the only way we can do that is we improve our product and I know that's some things that we have to work on in order to get that get us there but I do believe this slide is very important because no matter where we are an enrollment Factor there's still needs that we have to address

015there's still needs that every school district has to come to grips with fewer students do generate less State revenues but in that same conversation that doesn't necessarily mean that our needs go away okay um right now we're sitting at around 5,080 students I could be wrong about that number but overall I can tell you we've kind of flatlined or we're flatlining in our enrollment I don't want to use the word flat line um we're we're we're maintaining our enrollment um to a number in which I believe if we stay above we'll be able to sustain things much greater moving down the road we know we have a high need population in the school district of B one of the things that I've been stating for quite some time is that the school district booy has

016some of the greatest needs in the state of Wisconsin um I'm not sure who would argue with that space But we have some of the greatest needs and in the state of in the state of Wisconsin um students and families require more support services which strains the budget further when traditional funding doesn't keep up keep keep Pace um we do have some conversations we've had a lot of conversations around staff rtion and compensation here in our school district but the reduced funding constraints the district's ability to offer continued um competitive wages and professional learning making it harder to attract and keep quality teachers and support staff you know year-over-year conversations around reductions and year-over-year conversations around expenses um being needed to be tightened it's it's a hard space for for us to continue to to

017compete in a very competitive market with teachers and I think that space Alone um has really um hit us over the past two years and we're still trying to figure out the best way to say come to our school district but we still have cuts to make and people see this people know this and and when they have options to choose a school district what you know we will still want them to choose booy but we also want to be real in this space and say well I got another choice I don't have to worry about I'm going to go somewhere else and so that's a space that we have to deal with aging facilities and transportation we know that our our buildings do have some needs there are some immediate needs and according to

018our facility studies that is something that we um have had conversations about um since I've been here one of the things that I did when I first got here was I did want to get that facility studies done so we can kind of know what we what we're working with we have been talking about it um it kind of crossed the um the Finish Line um about two years ago when we were able to get that facility studies completed so we know that we have some agent facilities and some needs there you know transportation is also a concern that we have in our district with high school students not being able to um we don't provide transportation for our high school students some of this information will be repeated just to let you know but

019overall the increasing and undeniable budget pressures are on the horizon um with revenues not keeping Pace with in infl with revenues not keeping Pace with with inflation and and enrollment growth is kind of offsetting some things the school distri lawy has to have to rely on fund balance savings and extreme cost cutting measures just to keep up with some of the conversations this is a very hard thing to do year over-year um this approach is unsustainable long and I've said it before we can't we can't keep doing this we cannot keep having these conversations especially when year over year you're getting closer and closer to not having um a fund balance um and so that this process again is just unsustainable in addition of course we know that we have had some failed referendums here

020so although with the requests being out we know that we're still um you know battling the fact that some of our requests have not been um the voters chose we heard what they had to say and we have had to come come back to the table each year um but at this point without some future support our district will be in some Dire Straits so what we want to do very briefly is just give you a stat shot of of kind of what we were thinking about as pertains to our major operation um referendum guiding priorities um we do want to make sure that people understand that we're not looking for a referendum that well the I don't believe we are looking for referendum that's going to be recurring um for until you know forever

021but I do believe a non-recurring u conversation does need to be had in the conversations that we've been having what we wanted to do was just recognize that we do want our staff compensation and retention to be intact so that we can keep our teachers that we currently have and attract others so you'll see that as a staff conversation and retention conversation we've been having conversations around academics and in the second here I'm going ask Mrs um morte to come to the mic to share some of those stuns but we've had conversations around academics and behavioral support um as well in our district that has been a theme that I've heard since I've been here and I'm not going to shy away from this conversation I know we've had some improvements but also know we

022have opportunities to grow I don't know which one people want to hear more um versus the other but I do know that um we've had these conversations before and we do want to make sure that we you know of course follow our policies and and of course provide additional support as necessary um when possible and again that academic success conversation has also been something that we want uh we've been talking about you know accelerating learning and of course boosting students achievement we've made some changes we've made some um um some some some growth um but we're not where we really want to be um and then of course we talked about another guiding priority was our facilities and transportation and infrastructure upkeep again all of these conversations that you see on these pages will later

023talk about a cost that comes with this but these are some of the guiding priorities and again that fund balance restoration it is something that we will have to look at over time and how we build that bu at in a referendum conversation is also very important so priority number one that staff compensation and retention you know the reason why we chose this and we've heard it loud and clear from our staff members that we have to attract and retain a top tier Educators by offering competitive salaries strengthening recruitment efforts enhancing retention strategies support High performing dedicated Workforce we have to do this we have to do this this is a conversation that every district is having but we have looked at we've had to deal with this differently in the midst of having to

024make some some cuts and some um you know budgetary constraints budgetary um reductions two years ago when the CPI was 8% we gave 4% last year when the CPI was 4% we gave 2% and so we've been able to do something for our staff but that's not necessarily what it's going to necessarily take to to keep all of our staff here and so we also aligned this with our district strategic plan and District goals and so I'm not going to spend a lot of time on that but this thought also captures that that this this page also captures this space another space that we want to have you and we want to make sure we capture some of the feedback along the way this is some of the feed that we that we've heard um

025and and again none of this here is new um we've we've talked about a lot of these spaces over the time and and these things are these themes have been stated to us not just in this past year or just last month but since I've been here since we've been here as a board together and especially as a District administration together moving us into priority number two um our academics and Behavior Support um slides I I'm going ask Mrs mortech to kind of take us through some of these conversations with this emphasis on academics and then I'll jump back in on the behavioral support space But please understand that this goal does strengthen um does um impact our whole Child Development and of course it also speaks to our student achievement opportunity um our district

026strategic plan again it does align accordingly um if we target certain opportunities in our school district we we could I believe we will see some of the growth that I believe everybody wants to um have for our entire School District additionally when you're talking about that behavioral space if students are able to be them best if students are able to be their best selves then I believe that they also show up differently and be able to get those academic um gains that I that I think again once once we're able to prove it to everybody everybody will see and so I'll turn over to Mrs um morte to kind of walk us through some of the highlights around academics that we believe will be important in this referendum um but again some of this is

027is not all encompassing but it does give us a snapshot around what some of the academics look like U Mrs morte sure so um in alignment with our strategic plan um we continue to focus on the whole child uh so that's our academic side and then our um social emotional um side of the house to make a whole child uh and so in understanding literacy um we are looking at the things that we have um in in that are working uh that are showing uh growth and how we sustain that and then what how we'd like to also uh lean in uh to address those additional needs um so some of those pieces up there like Lexia Core 5 um and our School Pace uh data dashboard are been have been showing benefit um and

028have been beneficial um we are this year uh just beginning Pilots for online tutoring this is something that we had looked into in the past um and kind of went back and forth with some things so we decided um sure of our um most uh challenged schools were running pilots in uh hackin and Merill um and just beginning that work so that would be something that we would like to see expanding um potentially and then um the other one is with act 20 um as I've mentioned or a for mentioned many times there was real no real funding that came with it but a lot of mandates so there is an expectation of an additional layer of training for our um anyone that leads literacy so our assistant principles and principles and keeping up with

029that training um will be a cost to the district um and of course we're always building out um you know ways to have stronger instructional leaders in our buildings with our math uh we heard the other night about uh the the work of Imagine math uh so leaning into that continuing um we are seeing as we say in the world of research larger effect sizes that are ranging into um uh significant um is is the verbage to um also looking at our Eureka Math squar that is a three-year um renewal so we have it for 3 years but then coming 26 27 we will have to repurchase uh that adoption and we are seeing a lot of gains already with that math uh program get a lot of positive feedback from the teachers um I

030was just on learning walks today uh for Math and we see high implementation of those materials so really grateful for all of the teachers that have taken on the new learning and just to see the materials out and and people utilizing them with Fidelity um so those are the two pieces for literacy and math so as we um jump back in the conversation as pertains to some of the behavioral um supports we we've heard it that our schools does need support in this area um one of the things that um we believe that we could provide if in the support through a referendum of course will be to bring back some of the behavioral specialists and a couple years ago after doing some of the research we used to have behavioral specialists in our school

031district um again they they it was it was taken away probably due to different constraints that the district had to deal with I don't have the 100% information around why it went away but I can tell you that we used to have these these spaces um in the district and looking to possibly bring back at least six of those positions in our district um the assistant principal position at the high school as you all know we did have to make some reductions in our administrative team and and I have to we've had to you know make some adjustments there the possibility of bringing back that high school um assistant principal is something that we would like to you know explore um from that we also talked about Dean positions you know when we made the

032cuts in the an administrative team we also um had to make the cuts at the middle school level um that doesn't mean that the work that work went away as well so pretty much the work does still need to acquire and the dean of students position is something that we could possibly explore at the the Middle School um with possible support um some of the community feedback again we've we've heard it that people want smaller class sizes we do have some um conversational points about that um but again people want smaller class sizes they definitely want the conversation around English language immersion and dual language immersion support safe spaces you know we want all our classrooms to feel safe these are some of the some of the feedback that we did was able to capture

033in this space um creation of separate spaces for students with behavioral issues that also came up and I didn't want to leave those these thoughts off the table but I also wanted to make sure that people understand that you know our hopes is that we can improve our Behavior with our students so that they can can stay in the classrooms that they're currently um working with especially with their peers um as we continue the conversation we in party go party um section number three we've had conversations around facility and safety um facility safety transportation and infrastructure upkeep um naturally again like I mentioned earlier on in the presentation we do have some um critical maintenance needs in our school district um overall budget for the uh that going to come with a much larger Capital

034conversation and so if I would be so kind to just remind the board that this is this election this conversation this year the board decides to go um is our last opportunity for this year there are no more questions this year that we can bring to the table there are no more opportunities in November um the next opportunity that we would have will be in um April 26 and I know I keep looking to the left and little to the right sometimes too but I I kind of talk with my hands so y'all bear with me I'm also looking at the screen too and I can't figure out where to sit to make my head not be so um over the place um a turn like this for the viewers um I think that's something

035that we we want to you know continue in this conversation as it pertains to our transportation needs our transportation you know our high school students don't currently get you know transportation and I still don't I still I I do understand how we were able to do it with providing some of the city transportation but overall this is something that we would like to see um differently you know moving into the future um here you see some of the things that we need to work on that need some immediate attention in our district and again I'm not going to go through all of these themes a lot of these them you've already seen and heard about um whether it be Roofing hacket playground some of the Fourth Street projects some of the roofing stuff I mean

036overall there's some themes that we have not had a chance to really touch that re really need some immediate attention in our district and here are some of the things that we've highlighted um the school district of does not currently provide transportation as I mentioned um for our regular education high school students District students are able to use B transit system services at a discounted rate um though is limited to current bus routes and so what does that mean that don't mean that the bus is going to come and pick you up on your corner of your neighborhood you may have to walk to a different stop to get on the city bus does not even take you fully to school you know it might get you close to an area and then you have

037to you know walk the rest of the way and so this is something that you know our students at the high school Lev has had to deal with for you know quite some time now um so transportation is a challenge in our in our district for our high school students really across the entire School District um this does align with of course um some of our facilities and and of course we've heard this and and some of the feedback um one of the things that we've stated if you can get kids to school you know attendance will go up and and achievement can follow that's that's also researched um throughout as I move into the fund balance restoration conversation I me thinking about the major priorities remember we said there is four and I know

038I'm moving you know fairly qu fast here because I definitely want to get to the the me of the conversation a lot of the themes we've talked about at the board level and board meetings the fund balance is a real conversation that we need to have here currently our fund balance is not at 18% I mean hasn't been at 18% since I've been administrative here and 100% I cannot tell you when we were ever at 18% over these years with with the many reductions that we've had to deal with um postco I can tell you that in this slide it does fit to talk about fund balance restoration because in the year 2026 the district the fund balance is projected to be depleted you know I think sometimes I Rush past this thought and we've

039kind of been saying this along the way that we we're getting closer and closer to having a fund balance cliff and we're at that point now in the year 2026 2027 our fund balance could be depleted and that will that will painstakingly change the way we do business here in the school district of booy if this happens it's not something that we want to happen but if this happens it will painstakingly do something different for our school district and how we do business here you know we use fund balance throughout the year and and and one of the things that I've stated before we use fun balance throughout the year because we were waiting for checks to come in from different places right from the state and if we're not able to use fund balance

040to to to pay bills or to you know tide us over to the next major um um um Revenue opportunity we run into you know the possibilities of how we're going to pay for people and again running into that depletion space which will be very hard to deal with in the school district things will look drastic Ally different if this is not something we able to to to move into just like I stated before we've been having conversations around this not just last year but the year prior to that when we had a referendum and the year prior to that when we first got here and we had another referendum so these conversations are not new this is just a snapshot that we were able to kind of provide um for for for for the

041community and for the board as well you know overall there's a lot of conversations around communication and Trust in our district there's a lot of conversations around that and what we need to do to improve that I'm and I and I do believe we are moving in the right direction in that space we still got work to do um but that communication and trust is a theme that we've you know we've heard enough and we know that that's something that we want to continue to work on I will say that no matter how we communicate as a school district um there's going to be people that say you need to communicate better we need to do more right and it is our job to still meet those needs of our community members and so I

042don't want to say that's a a negative rebuttal or anything as such there will be people that say do more and again it is our job to figure out how we can reach the needs of all of our constituents and communicate with them effectively around some of the things that they may um be you know bringing to us as a challenge I think there's a question oh I'm sorry Mr henkins uh no it's more of a comment I want to go back to fund balance and the talk of running out of fund balance and I've heard the word uh bankruptcy involved in that and my business knowledge tells me we can only go bankrupt if we spend more money than we're taking in so our fund balance may be depleted but to go bankrupt it

043means that we are overspending and I don't think this board or the admin will overspend what we're getting in I understand that the fund balance has been depleted goes up and down it's at EB and flow but to actually say that we're going to run out of fund balance would be directly the decisions of admin and and this board uh if to say we're going to run out that's that's entirely uh on the decisions that we make Finance make makes and we approve as a board so I understand what you're saying but I don't want to get the misrepresentation out there that we are naturally going to run out of funds we will if we allow ourselves to spend more money than we're taking in thank you thank you for your comments Mr henkins some

044of the guiding priorities do come with a cost and and one of the things that we've been working on in this in this presentation but also working on with the conversations that we've been having is the cost space the cost spaces and so here is where you know I will you know pause and allow some of the conversations not allow of conversations to naturally happen you all can always jump in if you need to um but here's where we will definitely start to kind of spend a little more time around driving in some of the conversations around cost we've built in into that priority bucket number one a 3% um increase in staff compensation yearly and by doing so what you see here is a one two threee um conversation with overall total and so

045I wanted to make sure that was laid out clear so that people can see what it'll cost us if we were able to do this naturally in a in a conversation around referendums um one could argue it could have been 2% what could argue be 1% and one could argue it could been no per that's some of the things that we'll talk about in scenarios But please understand that this is something that is built into the scenar scario conversation that we'll talk about a little later the second is the academic and and um behavioral cost support bucket and priority number two um academic totals if we were to add up some of the things that Mrs Morris Tech was able to mention in literacy and math it'll package us to about $1.6 million um and

046then if we were to add some of the conversations around the behavioral support we will have a three-year total of about $1.8 million and which you see down below um and I'm ask Mrs um um and I apologize um Missy did you have anything you want to add about the U behavioral support at all I'm sorry I know you walked over there to the to the to the table there and I apologize for that thanks I can run it back NOP you're fine all I was going to add was um we did have Behavior spe specialists in the past and they were that FTE was taken and um converted into a APS that's how we got the aps at the elementary schools so but the the the great um opportunity we had there was that

047the behavior Specialists were able to work not only with students but they worked with staff and um the engagement of parents as well so um thinking about whole child and where we want to go with behavior I just think it's important to note that it's not just staff facing but also giving teachers and parents the tools that they need to support the behavior of our students as well thank you so much I saw you walk into to the table and then I saw you walk away and I got to this slide and I apologize for that you know one of the things that um you know from a package perspective that'll be six behavioral support position one assistant principle being added back to the high school and 2D and the students positions and this is

048a replica replica of the previous slide with numbers now okay and so I didn't want to put it all on one slide when we were trying to explain our needs versus to show it all in one one space um Mrs um alander did you have have want to add anything about the the the pricing or not the price and the cost associated with this at all please yes thank you I just want to point out that the values that are expressed on that presentation is inclusive of French benefits so things like HSA contributions our contributions towards unemployment for example health insurance um any of those French benefits are already captured within those values it's not just salaries okay thank you so much R now um in the next um bucket here we not bucket priority

049I'm sorry next priority we have here is uh facility transportation and infrastructure upkeep the facility space is about a $2 million opportunity for us and that's a one-time expense and in some of the scenarios you will see year one look a lot bigger than year two if we added this as a conversational point but that's a one-time expense that we can add in the maintenance space and that'll be about $2 million to take care of some of the themes that we had on the previous slide transportation is a three-year cost of about $1.5 million and that $1.5 million is broken into about $500,000 each year and that's what it will cost us if we were to bring back High School transportation for our students um about $1.5 million um and so with that being stated

050board um I wanted to make sure that we spent the majority of our time laying out some of the other thoughts that you may have as it pertains to our needs some of the things you may have heard from your own constituents and some of the things that you may just brought to the table even for tonight and I'm going to ask Mr Chay to help me through these um through these um conversations and what I'm passing out to you can you pass that down for me please this can you pass that down for me please um what I'm going to ask for you to do is to let us kind of walk through the scenarios and again we will have ample amount of time at at this at this pace to kind of have

051more additional conversations and it's going to be less of um my team and not talking but allowing you all to also kind of weigh in around you know just some general thoughts and so I'll turn it over to Mr tat to kind of walk us through some of the scenarios thank you Mr CH thank you Dr Garrison so Dr Garrison just passed out to the board members um a synopsis of each of the next slides that you're going to see I would encourage you to focus more on the presentation and less so on the handout um the hand what you may want to do is uh make notes on the handout about what you like or dislike or line Out Boy this one's not going to work for me type of thing uh so you

052capture some of your notes on there but we'll begin with the base scenario and essentially the base scenario is taking our current 2425 budget casting it forward with a presumed 3% increase across the board for most expenses uh each of the following slides show the same chart that's listed at the top and it's l also uh captured in the handout that was provided to you so this is at the very top of your handout the base 3 %c uh you may just want to write on the left of that base just to kind of put two and two together each of the charts speak about a non-recurring referendum amount and you can see in the base there is no referendum request so the the uh intent of this slide is to identify what the presumed

053deficit Position will be if each of our assumptions within the model actually holds true so in 2526 with the base we anticipated a $6.2 million deficit those of you that were at the ad hoc committee last evening same value there also listed in the chart is the last row which is a projected mill rate and you can see that impact from year to year to year as well you'll note that 2829 is highlighted in Gray and the intention of that is because the base scenario here we're kind of really focusing on the the first three years so in each not not in all but in most of the following scenarios uh 28 29 will be highlighted in Gray and those values really won't change any uh because we're not really projecting out in and touching

054that fourth year however we do have a scenario that does touch on uh year four as requested by the board as well so scenario B is the $65 million amount per year for three years so essentially this scenario provides sufficient resources to take the deficit amount that we anticipate in the 2526 school year and turn that into a modest Surplus but you'll note then in 26 27 and 2728 that deficit position still remain so while 6 A5 million meets our needs next year it fails to meet our needs in 26 27 and then the 2728 school year if you follow the the projected Surplus deficit row to the far right you'll see that adds up the three years of the referendum and we have a proposed deficit of just under $ 7,250,000 over the three

055years there's lots of ways to address that but just kind of pointing out you know the Gap so to speak that this scenario still presents the other thing I point out is that the projected mill rate has some uh a pretty good amount of instability there where we see a 90% or approximately 90 C annual reduction uh between each of the years Mr chady yes do you want questions at the end or throughout uh I can take them either way Miss leevy Mrs Levy thank you so much just a quick question would we run into any issues so for example under the second scenario with the 6.5 million over 3 years and that would put us if I'm reading this correctly at a deficit in the 26 27 school year so when is that accurate

056uh so let's say the referendum that scenario two passed yep by year two which would be 2627 we would have a 2.4 million deficit for that year correct okay so and then an additional $5.1 million deficit in 2728 not there yet okay okay would we run into to any issues let's say for that first year on just under scenario 2 we it's 6.5 million and then that second year we ask for 8.9 million and then the third so we're asking for the base amount plus the projected deficit for year two and year three can we structure our question to accommodate that certainly and we got a scenario you'll see momentarily that does that perfect and then my last question for now is can you go to referendum while you're under a current referendum yes perfect

057thank you yep Mr Nichols uh thank you uh board President Johnson uh Mr chady let's go back to the base um so I need clarification here because on the the sheet that we were given in at the end of November and and and presented in December the 7th at the workshop here yep on Saturday morning um based on the 3% increases on all expenditures we were going to have a deficit of 3.9 million instead of 6.2 so that's a $2.3 million difference and it continues to go up up to $8 million in 28 29 so help me out here what's what's the difference from from December the 7th so if you recall correctly and reflect back on that December 7th I I think I made a comment that we spent about an hour putting together

058those scenarios yeah so things are going to change okay e even the scenarios and the numbers that you're looking at today aren't going to be the same okay come April 1st no matter if the referendum passes or not yeah okay so I'm just that's quite a that's quite a difference that's that's that's all the only thing I brought it up the reason I brought it up I just want to make sure that there's something I'm not yep so so I've got that uh handout that was displayed um and it also cast forward the same membership so we didn't lose any students from year to year so thus we're able to Ain more revenues MH um as well okay I don't think that's accurate I'm pretty sure we're going to lose about two two and a

059half maybe 3% of students year to year um so that then impacts our revenues okay thank you you bet Mr henkins oh yes I think Mr chady kind of answered what I was going to say but I I'd be remiss if I didn't point out on the same thing that these projections and if I uh go back a year ago and I was a member in the audience and listening to this presentations on projections and at that time we were looking at a $10.8 million uh need for this year and then I believe it went up to 11 something and then 12 something the next and so now as we look at the projection um we're at 6289 116 which is carries another your extra on there I just want to remind everyone these are

060projections and they're based on historical data and it doesn't mean we absolutely are going to be it's just a matter of that's what a carry forward projection is from historical data and uh if we change if the board changed like they or ad admin changed last year's so it it weighs in into that so I I put a lot of respect into what these models project but they are projections it doesn't mean we are going to be it just means this is the way it is if we continue on with the spending pattern that we have today is that not right or am I we off on that um not so you talked a little bit about the deficit projections from a year ago and of course there're are smaller number today because we made

061significant reductions in our 2425 budget um we try to utilize the best information that we have at the time when we're doing the work that information will change you know we anticipate a reduction in membership between now and next year but we really won't know what that is until after the third Friday in September pupil count report um so correct and that's kind of where I'm getting at that these are projections yes we're going venturing into the unknown that we really don't know and I remember sitting in the audience and uh and at the referendum talk of last year and saying well if we need 12 let's just do a$ 36 million referendum and take care of it and then the answer was back that through a question and answer period or a survey said

062well the audience our constituents with only uh I think it was a 50 to whatever it was to say 9 million so we went from 10.8 to n right right is that correct yep okay yep so now speaking of nine yeah okay yeah the next slide if I can thank you yep so the next scenario uh scenario C you may want to write a c next to that third one down on your sheet just to kind of help make the connections here this is essentially the same referendum amount that we asked for in April of 24 it's the same $9 million per year uh interestingly this is the amount that essentially gives us puts us into a break even uh perspective with regards to does that work for us over the course of the three

063years and the answer is it would if the assumptions and the projections used in the model hold out to be true so you'll note there that there's a surplus in the 2526 school year of about $2.7 million come over to the 2728 school year a deficit of 2.6 million so essentially you're utilizing the Surplus from the first year and applying that to the deficit in the third year and if all else holds true you're going to put about $252,000 into fund balance at the end of the three years uh the looking at the mill rate I I think that there's still some instability within the mill rate that perhaps we just need to recognize and think about so again the mill rate here goes from 747 it drops about 90 cents to 655 it drops

064about 90 cents to 569 the following year as well so just you know the interesting thing is here you know I I just I wanted to put in the model what we asked for in April um and it's essentially at our break even spot so what I want to do here is think about all these ones that you see before our our base our 6.5 and our n does not include anything out of the priority list okay what we did hold true to was our 3% increase across the across the board so I want to note that in this slide here so if we bring everything that we had in those other buckets I'm sorry in those other priorities my poies um we will you see what you see what we have now in in

065in a possible request and that's everything that's the you know U the the conversations around academics the conversation around some the behavioral the conversations around some of the uh maintenance conversations around transportation that that that's this is what you see here if we were to bring that forward and an all proposed from the previous um priority list conversation the total ask will be closer to that $39 Million number and we will see a modest um deficit of over the three years deficit over about um $740,000 but again what you see is that instability and that M rate and it goes from you know where we currently are roughly 190 192 um to $926 if this was something that we wanted to hold true to I wanted to make sure we added this scenario because you

066know we do we have heard from the from the public and again there may be some other thoughts that the board would like to discuss in that space But we have heard from the public when these opportunities do come with a cost I think if we were to do everything in those buckets this is what it'll look like and um I want wanted to make sure we took the time to kind of see that in the scenario so the board could also have that um for um discussion um purposes this next scenario scenario e is kind of um a merge or melding of a couple of requests from the board one about can we look at a 4-year referendum and man I've thought a lot about that holds a lot of valid um Merit but

067it also comes with a degree of uncertainty uh in the latter years and then there was also a request last week earlier this week about a I think it was actually Tuesday if I um about can we increase that salary in wage increase from 3% to 5% so what I did is I put all of that into this one scenario um it that can be broken out and trust me I I've been working with the numbers well enough that I can ballpark things pretty close for us tonight if needed so what this does is it it's a four-year referendum includes that 5% salary and wage increase annually take note of the total ask amount to the far right of uh that last column $42 M400 th000 also take note of the row immediately below that

068the projected Surplus and deficit based on this information through the four years we still have a $10.9 million deficit to deal with and then also the significant mill rate um drop from year to year especially the first couple well really all three years right or four years there um and then again with the with the fourth year man there's districts used to do five-year referendums not as often anymore more now they're more four to three uh year referendums I don't have a problem administering a fouryear but I would feel much more comfortable with three just because of the uncertainty you know in that last year just kind of putting it out there but if the board's interested in for and I think through the past month or so there's been some residents amongst the board

069about looking at fouryear options so we put the one scenario together I've got others I could share with you verbally not part of the presentation but just uh to share with that and then likewise there was an email that we received this morning that kind of proposed a uh three-year uh with a decreasing ask amount per year so I quickly modeled that as well uh and that's listed here as well as scenario f um the good thing about scenario f is that the the total non-recurring referendum amount ask over the 3 years is 22 million whereas in comparison in April of 24 it was 27 million but we also still have a nearly $10.5 million deficit uh throughout the three years and again we still have some of that mill rate instability I thought I

070saw a hand raised on the screen so I'm going to pause real quick before we get into the next two and see if do you still have a question I did I didn't want to interject I saw that you were going to the next scenario but um since I get to talk now I will just ask a quick question so I uh I really liked um board member Anderson's email that he sent this morning the one that you were just referencing modeling off of the nine then the seven then the six um I'm also really drawn to if I'm counting is this would be scenario F the one below it approximately the 6.8 mil rate no new maintain is that the one I'm wondering um I want to honor the spirit of um what board

071member Anderson has proposed here um by making the comment that I really like scenario F because it's got that stability of the mill rates I do see that it's more but one thing that I think that gets often lost in conversations is this just authorizes us to up to that we don't need you know what I'm saying so this is so it is possible if we were going to look more to something like scenario F that maintains sort of that mill rate stability which you know I think property taxpayers appreciate some predictability year after year um I'm wondering if we could um I guess where I'm interested in having a discussion is somewhere in between those two I really appreciate um the idea too of of stretching it out for the four years although I

072I understand what you're saying I mean so I just I guess all that just to say um the main reason I raised my hand was just to point out that we could go up further but that doesn't require us right to actually you know we can still be reducing spending as needed and maybe we don't go up to 125 and 27 28 maybe it's you know what I'm saying so there's just a lot of factors there um but I think there's a lot of really great ideas and great um stuff to work with here so just thank you for putting these together Mrs ly thank you I I it's possible I am reading this wrong but scenario F that we've just been discussing that would leave us with an instable mill rate correct correct yes

073think um okay you me G then yep yeah we just G right what's what's on the screen currently yep got it and then I I just need a pulse check why would it be a good idea with with all of your experience to ask for a referendum that still leaves us with a significant deficit um like how is that sustainable are beneficial so if for example we're looking at scenario e or scenario F at the end of the day we're still at a $10 million deficit so what would be the benefit with going with one of those options because I'm missing it well I think the benefit is you're still you are increasing your revenues just not sufficiently to meet the entirety of your needs if you were to do a full plan so the

074absence of that is you still have to make reductions to your current budget and perhaps all of the new stuff that we'd like to do you can't do that so so that's the one extreme right then there's the Other Extreme of hey we need $42 million but I would will the public support that so then someplace in the middle is is where you need to be you know I I don't think it's ever been tried and tested but you know will people give us everything that we need without us giving anything back in return uh probably not likely does the public want us to cut everything so that the school district is that much less of what we are today I don't really think so so someplace in the middle you know make reduction c

075s reprioritize spending be efficient and effective with your spending and we'll give you you know we kind of meet you in the middle and then last question real quick for now have you been in a district where the referendum passed they got most of what they needed but still need to make cuts and that turned into a backlash because if I'm just an average Community member who is not as plugged in if you say hey we need money and I'm like okay I want to support public education and the referendum passes and then you roll out all of these cuts and then all of the things that we brought people in which I think was great to talk about visioning and what do you want to see for the children of bloy oh yeah we're

076not able to do any of that and the you know and the mill rate is going up I just I I am concerned that that would put us in a more vulnerable position because unless public education the funding for that is radically changed we're going to be back at this table again and I don't I think it's going to be even more difficult sell so let me let me let me respond can I thank you and this is we free discussion at this point cu the all these points are very valid I think that's what we tried to do over these past two years as well make some reductions show the public that we're doing the right thing um and then come back with another request do the same thing over and and unfortunately we

077can find ourselves in the cycle that Mrs Levy is talking about but also also understand the and respect to some of our professional spaces around where we yet to still go our hopes though in this conversation is that we we see what we have done people see what we are making improvements in and then you know like high achieving school districts you come back and you keep supporting those things in in every school district every school District we are always looking for ways to save money even in the high achievement school districts you're always looking for ways to say you know what is it that I could do as a district administrator or as a district in general to to bring more money back to um our our opportunities um and revenues um those those

078thingses come in widely different different ways but in our district now um we are at that again critical space where we can't sustain The Continuous constraints and these continuous constraints will lead to more Exodus of our professional staff less likely programs less less programs and it and it kind of keeps putting us in this um had to say Mir go around but it kind of puts us in this space where we can't continue to work effectively and that's that's that's the hardest part about all this like all of our teachers are working all of our staff are working but we also want to work effectively in this space not just kind of get by in that thriving space that doesn't happen and so um Mrs levia I do understand your your sentiment as pertains to

079asking for a certain amount and then still bringing reductions to the conversation and it's like that you know you you kind of playing the Tog of War you're never really moving anywhere cuz you in this space and that space we're not necessarily thriving that's kind of where we've been working from we want to go from here in the school district but let me go to the the slide G I'm sorry that was a I'm sorry goad Megan Miller um I was actually going to comment on scenario G if you want to go ahead if you is it okay for me to jump in after Dr Garrison's thoughts com overall oh oh is that okay okay well okay so Dr Garrison thank you for that and I guess um I want to backtrack a little bit

080and in the earlier in the presentation I just wanted to say I really app appreciate how like the community input pieces are included on the slides and I like how they're included with costs so like Mr chady when you had said earlier like the community wants to see that we're going to give something back me that's what we're giving back so it costs money to do the types of things that we want to do we want to accelerate achievement we want safer spaces we want to be the school district of choice in Rock County so that's you can't do that maintaining status quo which is Dr Garrison the point that he just made is unsustainable able anyway right our status quo isn't working and so we want to get into that thrive space so that's

081more of a general comment and then I did yeah I did just want to clarify um scenario G is the one I was talking about so I am so sorry that I did not follow directions and I didn't I didn't take my pen out and label but I I did now thank you but yeah I really like the stability and the mill rate on scenario G and I do think that there is some give and some in between there right that would maybe bring the overall cost down and again I just want to reiterate this message even if it says it could go up to $9,750 th000 that doesn't mean we're going to go up to that piece and I think just that continued transparency of like this is the price tag on you know

082we have to reup Eureka Math but that's not going to happen every year right and so I mean I think that's a big point of conversation that I don't want to lose as we're making these decisions that we can focus on academic growth and acceler ated academic growth and increased safety and all of the things that our community has told us they've wanted which was beautifully articulated in these bullet points here and we can do that um with the dollars we're asking for which I I think touches too on Miss uh Mrs Levy's Point as well thank you Mr henkins I yes I just want to chime in just a comment uh Dr Garrison thank you to bringing us back to Ground Zero uh you've told me and and I've heard you say it publicly

083we want to pass a referendum and uh how we do that and the number that it is is palatable to our to our constituents who actually vote on this it's not saying that we don't need more money because obviously we do but we need to pass this and so I I agree with you 100% that that number is is the guessing point you know what is the district going what is our constituents going to vote Yes for and then Mr chady if you would just do me a favor on a mill rate 101 my cons my P my knowledge of mill rate only only adheres to our city taxes and our city taxes property taxes only account for how much of your or our uh District funds uh as a percent wise about 8% currently

084so 8% is is we're talking about a mill rate that1 92 per thousand of value yeah which is correct but 8% of a $100 million budget isn't I mean a mill rate gets a lot of attention but it really what are we talking well it's a multiplier effect $8 million on a100 million budget yeah I mean it's not like the priding factor I mean it it helps or diminishes and it could be better but mill rate gets way to me in too much attention because it's only a certain percent of our total budget I mean specialized funding is more important than mill [Music] rate depends on how you look at it yeah so the mill rate will become important when we are communicating with the public uh you know at that point in time we're

085talking about what and how we're going to utilize the money and how was that going to impact people's property taxes and how much they pay and we can talk a little bit about that here in a bit perhaps um a couple of comments were made in this last Q&A time I just want to go back and talk board member Levy uh you spoke a little about about you know the ability to do everything that we kind of promised in the referendum question and then how that impacts the future I mean the reality is once you start down this operating referendum Road we're in this process it's a cycle that's going to repeat itself every however how many years until the taxpayers need some relief and then they vote no at The Ballot Box no better

086example than Orfordville Park fuse School District to our West you know the last three think three three years three election Cycles they had none of those passed you know they had a history of uh operating support and then the taxpayers just kind of said hey wait a minute we need a time out um and it's been a long time out so hopefully they're successful as they're doing the same thing that we are uh here next week as well more importantly we have to be very cautious and intentional about how we word the question and what we tell people we're going to use the money for and how we're going to use it and we need to deliver on that without question even if you have to make reductions elsewhere in the budget you have to

087deliver on what you told people you were going to do with the money because if you don't deliver on that 3 years from now when we're back having the same um discussions about uh future referendums becomes a lot you know a lot more uncertainty there there was also a comment about it doesn't mean that we have to use the full value of the referendum amount I would say that that's true but I would also say that it would be wise for the school district of booy to utilize your full Revenue limit Authority going forward and the district always has so let me talk if you were to under Levy that's what it's called when you have an authority to do you know our Revenue limit says you can uh generate $70 million 60 million is

088going to come from Equalization Aid so you're putting 10 million on the property tax the board doesn't have to put 10 million on the property tax board doesn't put any on the property tax they can just say we're going to use the 60 million and we're going to forego the 10 million and we need to make $10 million in reductions but it would be wise for us to use the full property tax Authority because that then provides you the opportunity to generate Revenue that then you don't use during the budget and you can put back into fund balance we're not taking we're not taking operating fund money and going and buying lottery tickets you know hoping that we win the Powerball and what 240 million or whatever it is um you know so just to

089be cautious about that I've worked in a district that has under levied annually under levied that was a trying District to be in so just uh so those comments I think I see a couple of hands so let's do those before we talk scenario G and H Mrs Ley thank you so much um it's my understanding that even if we don't go to referendum mill rate is going up next year one is that accurate and two do you have an estimate of what the mill rate will be if we do nothing yes and yes perfect and you probably want the number so I'll tell you the number please so based on the current modeling that we're working off of yeah thank you it's coming back here to the base um so that top scenario on

090your handout 2526 $444 So currently the mill rate um was .92 for this current school year so next year doing nothing no changes based upon what we're looking at we anticipate that the mill rate's going to rebound to 444 and then really the question is when we add on any operating support how much more does that cost so that's where I was going great segue thank you so it would be accurate for let's say that we go with scenario H it would be accurate for us to explain that to the community is we're asking for an additional $3.30 give or take so yes the total will be 753 but even if we did nothing we're still going to be sitting at 444 we'll have do you think that's at all misleading not at all and

091we will have to intentionally educate the public about that mill rate of buck 92 it's going up to 444 thereabouts no matter what we do we simply are seeking to go from that level to a higher number to support yep thank you yes so just just great conversations too and um one of the thing I want to add is and so going back to scenario G I haven't had a chance to kind of walk through a ch um but I want to make sure that people see in scenario G this is with no no no additions okay um this is just provides us with additional um opportunities um $7 million 9.7 and again 12.5 and then what the focus is again is on that mill rate stability now with that being stated if we wanted

092to as a district let's say pay for transportation well quick quiz how much was transportation one 500,000 a year that's one that's so one could argue we could pay for transportation with some of the resources that we would gain in the uh $7 million request for year one we could realistically still say hey let's move forward with instead of moving this money into fund balance we can say let's pay for our transation okay we can say in that same conversation you know let's let's let's bring a behavioral support opportunity to the conversation let's add the um um um since the principal for one year now that of course doesn't cover this scenario it wouldn't be able to cover the $2 million of facilities requests now that that wouldn't be in this scenario at all because

093our our our our um Surplus is only 7 166,000 in that first year so it's very important to note that there's some things that we could still do in this scenario um if the board um do so chooses to do that or give us the direction and say you know what Dr Garrison and based off the scenario we do the million flatten out everything on this scenario G we still want to provide transportation that gives us 266 $266,000 of surplus that we can move to fund balance we bring all our B I say babies but we bring all our students um to the high school conversation in scenario H um because Mr leevy did bring that into the conversation I wanted to make sure I snapshot at G but I I see a hand I'll

094turn back over to Mrs U Levy I'm sorry Mrs Mrs Levy thank you so much just really quick this is going to sound harsher than it is meant so I just want to preface that does that at all feel irresponsible to you looking at the projections when we know we have a $15 million deficit like absolutely I want to provide transportation but I don't want to get to a $15 million deficit that I knew was commenting saying oh we don't have anything for that like Mr trady mentioned once you go down the road of referendums these things typically recycle so in year let's say this was the pass hypothetically speaking let's say that the board decide to go with this opportunity realistically we start setting up the conversation around the success of what we asked

095for the the opportunities that we were able to provide we start having referendum conversations right away that third year where you see 28 29 where the $15 million comes into a deficit Mrs Le which you're correct we will be setting up another referendum for that and that's how these things continue to keep moving down the road down the road and down the road so the first three years this does show a surplus Surplus Surplus and let's say that the board decided they want to do anything with the um opportunities that the Surplus gives that's uh 7.6 million I 7 $766,000 savings $849,000 savings $888,000 885,000 SA toing up to a little over um two two plus million that we could just roll it into our fund balance there's a lot of different ways to look

096at it but yes to answer your question very specifically um Mrs Levy that third year we would have to be rolling into another referendum or we would have to make $15 million worth of cuts so just to respond briefly I'm not comfortable with using referendum one to hedge our bets on a future referendum and it sounds like unless I'm misunderstanding that is what you're describing and to Mr jady's I think very wise Point whatever if we get a pass referendum whatever we tell the community that money is going to be used for we absolutely have to do that and for me on the other side of that I'm not use I I'm I am not in support of using that Surplus for something that the community didn't say that they were willing to pay for

097because when we get to the end if that referendum doesn't happen the next one we are absolutely out of luck so again these are the conversations that we have to have because there may be some things that the board really still want to do and they really believe that we should move forward with these are these are the conversations that we definitely would have to have if that's the scenario um that we look at now to move us into scenario H um here's lies some of the different opportunities and packages so not all the things that we use in the scenario buckets but some of the things that we use in the saral buckets um so you see a 7 um $7.50 mill rate um new additional what it be new would be the behavioral

098support and the transportation all right um yeah you see curriculum being left off of there but those are conversations that we could possibly have in the surpluses I say possibly doesn't mean that we will I say possi possibly but in this scenario again it shows you again that's the stable M rate going from 6.8 in the $6.8 million conversation to 7.5 in the $7.5 million conversation with um with a growth over 3 years um that mill rate is stable um there and I didn't not mean to do that so I hope it goes away it did okay great the mill rate is stable um as you can tell um but this allows for that sustainability that we've been talking about we can move those $1 million surplus the $2 million surplus two other two other

099$2 million surplus into fund balance of $5.8 million opportunity those are opportunities that one could have in this scenario again we're talking about scenarios there's a lot of different opportunities that the board could consider we put these few together um with accuracy we got a whiteboard right behind us where we can throw out different numbers and throw out different scenarios Mr chady is prepared to kind of put some things into um into the into the um what we call it projection and see what that possibly look like but I did want to make sure we walk through the scenarios and I'll turn back over to Mrs um Mrs Johnson for further questions any other further questions for Mr chady Miss Mrs Ley thank you so if we go to scenario H is there a reason

100that for the next few years we would be having a deficit at around 2 and A5 million or less per year and then we get to the next year and it's 15 million projected deficit like what do what is the what's the reason for that the reason for that is essentially because the 15 million 15.5 million of referendum Authority in the 2728 school year goes away because it's only a three-year non-recurring amount so as I'm looking at the total column for me that and I'm not saying it's intentional and it could be just me that feels very misleading because if I'm just looking at the total it looks like we would have a $5 million surplus at the end of the three years m we'd actually have a $10 million deficit correct that's why that

10128 29 again all of the scenarios with 2829 in Gray are three-year scenarios um so I applaud you for looking Beyond because you know the reality is that's what we we would be facing uh based on today's information but yeah so the total column to the right only calculates in the years of the referendum in those scenarios so here's my concern and I'm okay help me understand this what do we really need to ask for to get through the next three years with stability and then be okay on year four because it seems like instead of that 38 million we need to be doing 38 + and I'm almost scared to ask what year five would look like this just seems like a hole that there is no way out unless there's some miracle of

102radical financial support for public education right so looking at scenario H yes if you wanted to alleviate the deficit in the 28 29 school year you would essentially add $5 million to the request amount in each of the prior three school years technically it would still give us a $666,000 deficit but that's how you essentially then that higher ask amount for three years will get you through four school districts have done that okay where they have stretched their request amount for an additional year or two before coming back and asking the voters for Operational Support again so one final question for now does it kind of not matter and what I mean by that okay so just go with me this is going to take like 20 seconds promise when I was growing up my

103favorite book was the monster at the end of the book right you might be familiar I feel like even if we did that thing you just described and added in a fiveyear buffer then that next year is going to be the monster at the end of the book is that you're noding yes yeah I mean okay we've probably have heard the term Fiscal Cliff right you know we're we're at that cliff and we're looking off and we're about to jump um and we're going to hit bottom if we don't do anything else you know and then all of a sudden we start walking forward and we go oh no there's another one and that's that's just how funding unfortunately that's how it's set up you know over the last couple of weeks I've heard comments

104about we got to get out of these annual Cuts I I understand that but that's how Public School operates that's how districts just operate you know every year there is no District in the state that has enough money every year that they don't have to make reductions it just doesn't exist even Milton who just passed a ref even Milwaukee who just got what $252 million a year they're still doing cuts and closing schools right thank you back but you will still get the backlash and I think that's the problem with the funding the funding mechanisms in our state and I know this is a much greater conversation especially when we start talking about State funding how we're funded and underfunded and all those conversations but that is that the space and that is why you

105know of the you know 90 plus School District went just last in November and you're going to see another slew of us go possibly in April and then a whole bunch of them go again in 2026 because that's where those questions will line up and people have planned for referendums to come back again in April of 26 that's house districts have been able to survive with so many competing factors Mr uh Katie with the um 3% is do any or all of these also reflect the roow changes for the Bea and Union uh employees well depends upon depends upon how you interpret the 3% so the row advancement for Bea is 2.12% so yes we can ad attend to the row advancement and give them an additional 88% is that sufficient for the board I

106don't know okay preact 10 teacher salary schedules provided for three annual opportunities for a teacher to receive a pay increase they received a pay increase because they stayed an additional year they received a pay increase because over the course of the last year they took some college credits because you take college credits you can take intro to basket weaving you can be the math teacher but you could take intro to basket weaving get your college credits and move to the right into the next column and guess what the next column pays you more and then on top of that then you negotiated your percentage increase so then everybody got the the cola the cost of living adjustment what was it 4.08 3.9 some around four so so the reality is preact 10 with that traditional

107salary schedule which many of our teachers are used to and accustomed to because that's how they Advanced on this you know their pay in any year they could get essentially three increases so that 408 sometimes equated to more like eight or a 10% increase in pay from year to year so you know come forward to today's salary Matrix they want the movement down you know the the go to school and get the additional credits that's kind of off the table um anyway but so now you know it's the movement down and a percentage increase and again if the board does not believe that a 3% value is appropriate currently we can adjust that up we can go to Five we can go to six you know we can run some models that tell us what

108that impact is in fact give me a minute here so every every 1% increase in salary or wage is an approximate $55,000 in additional recurring costs so going from 3 to 5 increases our um our expenses by 1,10,000 that kind of goes back to um the the 5% conversation that we had on I think that was a model scenario um E Yeah scenario e and I also want just to know that's that's kind of what Mr tady is mentioning I also want to note that in the in the scenarios G and H let's ose H specifically I added the behavioral supports and the transportation but we could easily put the academics in this conversation and transportation or we could just put academics in this conversation and it'll change this model completely that make sense to

109the team because I which one that um on H H is like the slide where the board could say you know well we want to put academics in here take the behavior off and transportation as well just that simple and that that change this model completely on Just for age I added two because I wanted to make sure that people um saw that this is what this slide was about and I didn't explain that and very Clarity for for I want to explain that more clearly because you can put any of the um opportunities in this in this snapshot because what I was trying to do was also see um that the Surplus happen so that we can put it back towards um some fund balance which is priority number four okay which is again

110something that we do need to contest with so in this slide again we could put any of the scenarios in this model it'll change of course it'll change based off of how much we put in it the surpluses but that Surplus could be moved to um uh our fund balance I just want to make sure I note that Miss Miller thank you so much um I just wanted to kind of reflect on some of what you were saying Mr chady and also just U come back and touch on something Mr henkins had brought up earlier um with just like this is just like the way we have to operate right and so I've mentioned this before but there was a report that came out I think it was like two years ago now it was

111like a nonpartisan report called K12 on the ballot um it was done by forward analytics um and so there's like an overview sorry an overview and I just there's a paragraph here that just says in 2022 these dollars referring to referendum dollars funded more than 5% of Statewide education SP spending but Reliance was much greater in many districts so that's it's like the overall and it says like in a 100 districts out of you know what 421 referenda approved dollars funded more than 10% of District funding these dollars paid for more than 25% of spending it's like more than a quarter of their budgets right in 14 of those districts and so I think part of our work here as we go into a referendum I I think you touched on something really important Mr

112chady which is that we have to help we have to help bring people into a more accurate mindset of just like how school funding is like the reality and that the the iCal what we would like it to be um because that's not just a bit thing me this is a Statewide report right and so I think that's important to mention um last comment um to that point the way that current school funding is set up across the state not only is the state asking communities to do you know the community share which is you know the property tax part right of the school funding it's really set up that taxpayers sort of have to double dip and that which is what this report says essentially and that's just like not only the way it's

113set up but our mill rate is going to go up anyway even if we don't pass a referendum because it's like a seesaw and like the state's only going to give us so much state aid until they're going to automatically kick it back into the property taxpayers so we have like basically what the community has a choice of a we can take what we visioned in these sessions Drive our prioritization like how we spend our dollars based on the priority the community has shared with us and we can decide to pass a referendum to fund this Vision that we were creating or B we don't fund our local school district and we have to pay more anyway because that's just the way this the state funds are set up and I mean I don't like

114that it's set up that way I don't think it should be set up that way but we don't live in the should we live in the what is and so I just I really want to make sure that wherever we land um ultimately on our referendum question that we do a lot of work because i' I've heard this Mr henin like the whole like oh how important is the mill rate thing brought up many many times you know it it's important in the sense that not only is it affect people's property tax bills it's what the state asks the communities to do as part of upholding public education in our own communities that's why it's important and if we choose not to do that if we just like don't pass a referendum the state's going

115to decide for us to kick more of those dollars on property tax payers anyway and keep us at our current low Revenue limit the difference becomes we can kick in the dollars intentionally raise the revenue limit and then use those extra dollars to fund the vision that people keep demanding from us so I just want to kind of put that out there like I think all the conversation tonight has been fantastic I really like where we're at um and I again really appreciate the work the administration's done to put this together Mrs Levy I think Mr Schneider was first oh okay I I will be brief um Mr tady how adaptable are you in the moment and what I mean by that is I currently um believe I am falling in love with scenario AG

116if we can add a $5 million buffer to those each of those three years and my question is does that put educator increases at 3% over those years or is that at 5% uh scenario H is currently based on a 3% okay so here is my my request um are you able to to give us an estimate on what that mill rate will be with h as it is with two adjustments one going from 3 to 5% each year educator increases and then that $5 million per year cushion so the monster comes in year five and not year four yeah give me a minute absolutely uh so just calculating the mill rate for 2526 scenario H adding yes adding in five million and including the 5% doing this on my calculator without putting it through

117the model but I thank you I think I got the number still pretty tight $966 all right for year one for year one okay so 966 with the 5 million to the I just want to make sure I'm following you too 9 million to the 2025 26 year bringing that that request up to 13 million and it's going to be 966 14,1 169,50 adding in the an additional 2% compensation to bring it to five got it yeah I I can put that through the model it'll take me a little bit longer to do that no that I think I'm pretty close and then going from three to five that's an additional what million per year just over $1 million so the the total request if we do that fiveyear buffer and go from 3 to

1185% would be about 56 million so because we'd have the 38 I round it down a little bit and then adding 15 million and then another 3 million so right at about 56 million all right so let let me just back up a minute and make sure that I've got clear understanding with you so we're taking scenario H yes sir adding in $5 million per year to kind of alleviate that year four yep so that and then the additional 2% increase in salary we're also seeking that additional million dollars for each year if for each okay yeah you we can add 33 cents to that 966 so now we're at aen $10 thank you you're welcome and if that $10 sounds familiar to you you you may recall that the school district of bloy mill

119rate has traditionally been very stable right around that low $10 value for a number of years prior to it dropping to 478 3 years ago 396 2 years ago Buck 92 this year got to thank for numbers sorry Mr Schneider just sorry I turned on the wrong mic um this is is is just kind of more for the people that are actually listening in just kind of a real brief um I guess in my opinion how I look at what how how the the revenue limit works and what that mill rate is with that I mean the state limits how much money every school district can collect to use to pay their bills every year we're told what that limit is we don't get to choose that so we take that limit and then we

120get state and federal aid so we subtract that from that limit and whatever is left gets is what becomes the mill rate to cover expenses in the school district so when we're looking at the referendum this would be adding above that mill rate above the revenue I'm sorry above the revenue limit to give us extra funding um to operate the school district um but to also make it clear like um was it last year that all of a sudden we had an extra $7 million that came into the district a lot of people felt that that was above the revenue Vue limit that was $700 additional money to spend but in reality that 7 million just came off what the taxpayers had to pay the district got zero additional dollars to do that so just

121to again get a easier way to we look at the mill rate and how that functions the other one was is we continue looking at at the fund balance um and and and a way to look at that fund balance and the important is that uh Mr chady how many times a year do we get the majority of our money are our biggest checks twice a year three a year I would say about four times a year we receive significant resources either through State AIDs that come our way or local property taxes that we receive okay yep so let's look at the fund balance um if you're at home and you're on Social Security um the same way this is going to be if we get this four times a year you are going to

122get your Social Security check four times a year your bills are still coming in every month you still have to pay those bills so if you don't have something in your checking account to carry you over from when that last payment came in to your next one you're out of money that is realistically what that fund balance is it is not that we're mismanaging money and we need this extra stuff it's because we only get paid four times a year and we still have payments to make every year um I don't think there's any employee that would now be willing to be paid every three months um I don't think any of our vendors would be willing to wait three months in order to get their their money paid off uh so as we look

123at that fund balance it's not extra money that we can use to spend on anything it's literally to tie us over between when we get the state and federal funds so that we're not short-term borrowing all the time which is what costs us money when we have to borrow um just like anybody at home if you um can't make your payments you find a way to get a loan to cover those costs well you have to pay for that in addition um which is a negative impact on the school district so I just um it needs to be C people need to clearly understand what those terms mean uh you know the fund balance and then the revenue limit and and how that impacts the mill rate um so just I thought to help clear

124that up and make it maybe easier to understand what those mean thank you thank you Mr Schneider Brian Nichols thank you board President Johnson so a couple of things um first of all Mr chady I agree 100% with what what you said that we have to be very specific on what question we put on the ballot and then secondly before I get to the other stuff secondly once we do that and it's out there we need to follow up very quickly with a detailed spreadsheet or email letter to letter to the public whatever in the newspaper here's what we're going to here's what we're going to spend that money just like we do kind of with the with a budget but not you know the the public needs to know where the money's going just

125like you said so that when we come up when we come back around in three years we can you know it'll be more palatable as far as as far as the I like all these proposals I this is this is great having them all in one sheet and we can look at them and compare them um I I guess I'm I'm kind of I'm kind of in in the camp of trying to keep the mill rate as consistent as possible and not not going way up you know like a couple bucks a year or down a couple bucks a year and that's you know per um per mill rate and then um I I like G you know if we we didn't pass it we didn't pass a $27 million budget right um referendum last

126year and the year before I don't remember what the number was but it was it was very close and and so neither one of those pass so I think if we get too far I'm I'm concerned if we get too far off that that number we're going to we're going to maybe shut down some of the public and we don't want to do that um I like G but maybe that we add that extra million each year for the 5% so that makes that makes that a you know whatever um and then you know then in in year three we start we start working the numbers to go to come up the next year I think that's uh you know that to me that would be I think a a more successful opportunity to pass

127a referendum I think I could sell that pretty well too Miss Miller boy it got quiet no that's really no I thank you yeah just just two really quick questions uh love the comments that I just heard that makes a lot of sense I just one thing um one of Mr Anderson's comments in his email was um the idea of doing like a larger bump for for pay and I I you know I had to pull it up I think it was like 6% and then kind of leveling out I was just wondering not to I don't want to burn out your calculator there but if it's possible to calculate that type of maybe kind of Spike and then sort of cascading um staff increase because I think that speaks really really well to that

128first priority of Staff retention um so I'm just I'm wondering if and how it might be possible to sort of account for that type of a of a of a bump and pay for staff um and then another question um looking at the mill rate the projected mill rate for um 28 29 that one and you may have already answered this because I was writing a lot of other stuff down and thinking about other things so I apologize if I'm repeating uh the 2829 base assumption in scenario a is the 191 I mean is that's just sort of keeping it consistent with what it is now because there really isn't a way to project right no the model does project St uh project out the mill rates and it just happens to Sure Be 191

129or is this year it's 192 okay I was just kind of but yeah I was just wondering you know cuz I think Mr Nicholls just brought up a really important point I mean the two the first two priorities in the presentation are really different sides of the same priority because if we're going to like priority to right is academic um and behavior like growth and support those things don't happen without teachers without you know Behavior special the people who are on the front lines with our kids in relationship with growing our children every day right and so if we want priority two to happen we have to really make sure Priority One happens so building off of Mr Nicholls comments and I just wanting to factor in Mr Anderson's comments since he um you know

130had sent us those earlier what what might it look like I guess would it level out um how much we're spending each year in scenario G like I guess how would it impact it to do like a larger increase going into next year if we were to pass the referendum maybe is the easiest way to ask well so scenario G as stands right now provides for a $2.5 million surplus over the three years so so you could spend more money and still have your mill rate be what it is as listed there um you know you've got 2.5 million to play with I guess the goal the question that I would ask is the goal of the board to get through three years and kind of end up at a net zero or is the

131desire of the board to get through the three years and maybe we have $500,000 to put back into fund balance is that enough you know let's talk a little bit about I hear the board speaking about we need to do something with regards to staff so a 2% increase is essentially a million bucks a little bit over but let's just call it a million maybe you want to put $2 million into Staffing that doesn't necessar neily mean that everybody gets a four you know instead of five they get a 7% increase maybe they don't even maybe you don't even want to give them a 5% increase maybe we only end up giving them a 4.6% increase and then the balance of that $2 million can support some of these new positions you know behavioral spe

132oh oh yeah behavioral specialist for a minute there I thought we were talking colak admin but um you know behavioral specialist School positions can help us with recruitment you know and fill some of those vacancies so you know there really the question is how much money do you want to Target towards some of these initiatives because we can we can meld the budget to support that sure and I and I think that's kind of where I'm getting at I'm not necessarily saying we should I mean I'm I'm kind of with board member Ley where I don't want to find Grover earlier than we need to so I want to make sure that we're very deliberate with those dollars is also one of my favorite books anyway um one of my pages was torn cuz I

133was like where did he go anyway so um I guess just again just in the in the spirit of um elevating what Mr Anderson as well said as well if you know kind of his thought was we do a 6% I'm going to make sure I'm representing this correctly like a 6% increase year 1 and then that would give us additional dollars he said an appropriate amount possibly he said up to 1 million and I'm sure he's ballparking right um you know looking at the physical and electronic systems additional sro's addition of Dina students position um he talked about maybe four at bmhs so it's like I guess what type of scenario within maybe scenario G like gives us that wiggle room like is that are we in the ballpark of being able to do

134the things that he had mentioned that Mr Nichols just mentioned in scenario G or we just might as well just jump into scenario H at this point so can I answer that g g i know Mr CH is playing with numbers and stuff so that's okay G allows us again is there's no new no new no new things in this scenario what it did was it gave us a bump in year two of about $2.7 million and then in year three an additional um four four or so million dollar I could be wrong with my numbers there and so that those addition bumps as you increase per year not only gives us a surplus from year to year to year and it possibly provides us with a $2.5 million um fund balance replenishment now like

135Mrs Ley mentioned earlier and and I'm hearing from Mr Nicholls as well we may want to change this scenario all together and add another million to this across Ward that'll increase the 3% to possibly Mr Chas just mentioned to 5% um and it'll change these numbers across across the way no matter how you look at it that'll also change your meal rate remember every million dollars is about 34 C on your mill rate change and I know we were throwing out these numbers but that's what it is when when you play with the model and so our hopes is that people see like although you see no new here if the board again wants us to consider different positions it will only come in the possibilities of either reductions like making reductions to pay for

136extra stuff or using the Surplus that makes sense it does and so go ahead that that's how that would actually work unless we be very specific in in G I'm sorry in h and say what we're going to do it for now I know we highlighted again behavioral support and transportation um and again all three of them had a lot of uh weight in them academics we can change again we can change any of this any of these scenarios to make it be what the board wants us to make it um and and that's something I want to just make sure I Echo but scenario H adds to the conversation but it also as Mrs Levy asked for us to do add to a a possible bigger number or it can just stay kind of

137where it is with the different opport OPP unities these are the opportunities that we need to hear from you today and that's kind of where we here no that's perfect and I guess just uh wanting just to not totally lose his thought he did talk about in his initial email that I think this his thought behind the amounts decreasing year over year right is like we keep what's working we cut what's not so I just thank you Dr Garrison for speaking to that on that same page I think that would be the mentality going into it because in order to make room right for some of those things that were suggested you know we've been doing that anyway like we've gotten all these great presentations saying like Okay like this curriculum's working well this one

138not so much we're going to kick that one over to make room for what what is working or or additional staff that we would need and so like this is something that I believe has been the current practice that's something that is very sustainable right and able for us to continue so thank you Mr henkins uh it's just a comment as my new official duty of timekeeper that we are approaching 7 o' 2 hours in I will entertain a motion to add an extra 30 minutes to the meeting so moved second motion by Brian Nichols second in by Greg Schneider any discussion Miss Levy I just want to thank our clerk I appreciate you being on top of that thank you Mrs Levy by way all in favor I I I I I any opposed

139motion carries the meeting is extended until 7:30 that's known as a backup plan and um Brian Nichols I see you have your hand up I think I forgot to turn it off are there any other uh Brian Anderson yeah thank you so you know I've been listening here and uh I I great conversation thank you to Mr Shady for for putting it together I think a couple of points I would make is it looks like about a you know if we do nothing we're going to a 4.44 mil rate okay so I'm just going to try to list a few facts and somebody Shady please correct me immediately if I get a fact wrong because I'm trying to work off of facts right so um but about a 6 and a half mil rate is

140kind of a hey that gets us through three years without adding to taken away that's up so six and a half is a status quo kind of mill rate um scenario H um intrigues me I love a stable mill rate too right I think I think that's a that's a good Community effort I think uh the whipsaw of up down up down is is detrimental to stability in the district so I I I I fully agree with that um but scenario age I just want to point out that you know part of my Logic for you know the the kind of the email that I sent out and the proposal that's kind of spelled out in I think M must be scenerio app you know is is the reality of passing a referendum too not

141just you know what what we want to see and I but with scenario H static mill rate is 7 a half at $38 million over three years and that is that's $2,500 per pupil right and so really what you're asking the community is hey we understand State funding is broken right we're saying over the next three years we need an additional 22% per student to do these things and I'm okay with that if if the community understands uh how broken State funding is um but that's something that um you know I I think that would be a a a a tough climb um even though I can fully support the use of the funds supporting the the staff the discipline and acade academic achievement right so I think these are all great scenarios at some

142point we need to shift to here's how much we think we need and we want and we deserve and move into a conversation and maybe this is Monday's conversation of what do we think we can pass because I think that's an important conversation along with all the great conversation we've had here today so I would just throw that out for some contemplation um to inject some reality into what has been a great conversation um about that's where the rubber meets a road is at the polls on April 1 so just those are my thoughts thank you Mr Anderson are there any other questions or comments from the board members Mr henkins I I'm in complete agreement with uh Mr Anderson that uh we all this has been thrown on us very recent for everybody and

143uh and I like I said stated earlier the idea is to pass the referendum and uh so as we digest and hear um from our constituents and we have a chance ourselves to Deep dive into it uh I I I totally agree with you uh it does no good to have a go through exercise of a referendum and have it fail thank you Mr henkins anyone else Dr Garrison are any of your cabinet members will U wanting to weigh in and with any other comments or suggestions or thoughts I'm I'm definitely open to everyone come to the mic or share some additional thoughts I know Mrs mortek probably in this and I and I'll mention a couple times in this scenarios we can build a package whatever with any scenario in there academics Behavior Transportation

144all three um I just want to make sure that's that's a noted space so cabinet members you want to share go ahead I I'd just like to Advocate that I I think the latter scenarios G and H that mill rate stability makes a lot of sense it does become a bit harder to educate and to you know explain to the community why the the request amount changes from year to year so significantly and not always aligned um you know it's not always a $2 million increase or whatever there's some variance in there in order to kind of shoot for that mill rate stability um you know the fall of 24 State average mill rate was $79 we're at a buck 92 and I've always kind of looked at it and thought to myself we probably

145ought to be at or just under the state average but to be honest when you look at the mill rate history of the school district of booy for decades boo was higher than the state average for decades and still had some relative stability so you know maybe that at or under the state average is a moot point I I don't know but but I bring that up intentionally because I asked the board you know really what it comes to now is what's the tax tolerance what's the tax tolerance of the public what do you feel is the tax tolerance of the public you know we've got a scenario that's got the mill rate at 680 we got a scenario that's got the mill rate you know around 750 we can do one that's got a

146scenario with the mill rate at 710 you know 675 whatever you we want um I just kind of I don't want to say randomly picked but I just kind of ended up on these 680 and 750 examples so doesn't mean that we're set on those makes my life easy if if you're you're in alignment with one of them but we can adjust some numbers and run other scenarios I've done 25 scenarios so far I can do another 10 pretty easy Mr henkins yes back to my mill rate 101 and I know Greg was waited also so let's say that um and let's base on what the average household iny or house average uh assess value is let's throw a number at 100,000 what are we talking about when we're talking mill rate those numbers just

147make it simple 100,000 yeah give me a minute to clean some stuff off and uh let's do this I plug that up here does that do it for me it does okay do I have that in there right sorry I don't have this on the screen to to share with you but I'll verbally give you these values all right so an average the average property value of a res residents in the school district of blit this comes from the city of blit Eric Miller my counterpart with the city the average property value assessed value in the city for this current year taxes was $57,600 so that individual received a property tax bill last month that charged them $164.4 for property taxes for the school District of beloy $164 at using the 192 mil rate now

148the reality is that 164 is a net value because of the school levy tax credit complicated stuff let's not go there but just keep in mind that that 192 is not really what applied to the property at 444 next year that's same property would be $474 so an increase of 310 bucks at 680 if we were to flow with scenario G as is their property tax becomes $1,200 the following year just under $1,500 the following here uh about $1,800 now if I were to look back four years ago on the same property they were probably paying around $6,700 in property taxes to the school district of booy so again property taxpayers today are paying approximately a tenth of what they did four years ago and if you doubt me I've got your property tax history

149report for your your personal residence properties right here and I'll be happy to hand it to you at the end of the night I I truly believe you because I live it I yeah I just I thank you for putting that context into it because you know again going back to Mill rates and it's uh sometimes it's hard for even you know for for us to think okay what are we talking about in the end that's what people want to know right you know you heard me say it before and we'll say it again this spring and I'll say it in February when we do the Beloit Civics Academy presentation we'll put the mill rate chart up on the screen in fact I did this yesterday at the ad hoc committee for those that were

150there you know we'll Circle these last five or six years because that's when ear in those F last five or six years is when this planning should have begun initially you know permitting that mill rate to drop below 10 maybe you know but there was no plan so we're just riding this roller coaster no matter where it goes thank you yep Dr Garrison yes so you know I want to make sure I I I I lay out you know some of the next thoughts um I see Mrs Ley hand came up do you want to take that question sorry Miss Mrs Ley we may be on the same page I just I think we've had a lot of great information and some clarity and I'm so grateful for that um my question is what do

151we need to accomplish this evening and what can we look forward to on Monday so and that's exactly where we're going um so um one of the things that I want to first thank is the community and and of course the staff and everyone who participated in some of the conversations again we've been having these conversations and your your input is valuable our district do have needs and I think the board has heard that over the course of the three years Mr chady and my administrative staff um Mrs beavers of course M aleris Mrs mortek um I want to thank them um for so much time that they've um invested in into these conversations I know a lot of times we have been talking about our our finances and a lot of conversations have been

152happening with Mr chady um but I want to make sure that I knowe that Mrs beavers and Mrs mortek and Mrs alandis are in these conversations as well and they spend us an enorm amount of time looking at numbers with Mr shady and myself to to to better inform our community of of our needs it goes without saying to the board um you have a huge task ask ahead of you okay and when I say ahead of you it's always been ahead of you you know it's been that's the that's boards across the state of Wisconsin because you are the ones that will have to let us know if we want to increase like Mr Schneider mentioned our Revenue limit to whatever number minus that conversation again we will be back in that space of

153of a base of cuts six six 6.2 one year 9 the next year 11 the following year and 15.6 the fourth year these these conversations are not easy and in our space here in our school district we cannot sustain it I want to make sure that it's very loud and clear moving forward we cannot sustain this Mr henkins you bring up a good point you are right when we're talking about a depleted fund balance I didn't respond at that time for a very specific reason because it's going to get me to this point right now it will be up to us how we decide whether or not we're going to make additional cuts and bring a budget forward but I can tell you our students and our staff will suffer greatly in that space because

154we can't continue to make these types of reductions and still say we have a School District programs will change dramatically dramatically what we've been able to do for these past two years un Bean anyone's thoughts in the community un beyan anyone's feelings has been extremely hard for the board for the for our staff for members of our community driving this conversation has been very very hard as even as a district administrator but I can tell you I will show up and I will continue to do the work but we can't continue this way we cannot and I won't make and I will not make um the mistake and not sharing it this way like I didn't do the previous two years okay um I knew we were coming into the first year I was going

155to have to make some substantial changes in our school district and that was the first 10 or so million dollars I knew it was going have to do that when I came into the school district of BL I already saw where we're where this was coming possibly going from cuz you look on a paper going from 10 to 4 was real it was not a fake space for any of us trying to hold us at that 478 became a very challenging space and we didn't pass that referendum but I knew we were going to have to do some things still and I think we did some of those things that we needed to do as a retains reductions going into the second referendum I knew we was going to have to do the same thing

156if it didn't pass going into this conversation like many have already stated um I will have to lay out if the referendum does not pass what we what we will stand to have to um reduce but I'm but again these are the conversations that we can't continue to have and no matter what you line yourself back up for another N9 plus million do conversation because 2026 is a whole another school year so I got to show not only $6.2 Million worth of cuts but really about $14 million worth of cuts and that cannot sustain itself that can not that cannot sustain itself because I don't know just like um I don't there's no glass ball and again we're not taking any funds to pay the lottery like Mr chady mentioned these are real conversations and

157so I want to make sure that people understand that our next steps as a board and Mrs Levy to answer your question um is to take this information and really process it share different thoughts with different constituents in the community maybe there's some thoughts that you want to bring back to the conversation on Monday or share with us again on Friday because we will be taking in scenarios and playing around with that thought again as well Mr chady jok he said he got about 25 but I can tell you he has actually has more than that you know I'm be honest with you because we we you know we spent hours looking at these um different scenarios and different packages and we just you know these are the ones that we wanted to bring to

158the conversation as a starting point not a starting point but as a some real specifics in this space and so so I do want you all to take this information Mrs Levy and and move it you know to to your constituents have deeper conversations um with us if you need to reach out and just share that information with us um Mr Nichols you're correct I want to bring some thoughts to this when you look at your 6.8 thought and you want to add another million here another million there you know what's what's going to be that tolerance you know who knows you know who knows you know um I know Mrs um Johnson you I know you have some thoughts with this as well and I want to make sure we we we capture that

159I know there's some um feedback that you know that we want to make sure that we we see and I want to recognize that too because it ain't it's not our goal to miss the mark this time it's not I want to get this we got we got to get this done we got to get this done for our students so when you look at the next spaces we have is on Monday we want to bring some scenarios to the conversation again probably we'll probably not have nine of these y'all all right I'm just going to be honest with you all right based off of our feedback and what we heard today don't seem like we're going to fall into do nothing conversation but it's going to be a base there we know what it

160is right um we did the 6.5 doesn't do much for us either but we know what it is right so we'll probably have some less scenarios and some possibilities of what we've kind of heard again to look at um but the question becomes also very important because we got to get to that question space if we want to do this which Mrs ly going back to your thoughts what's next that's that's that is what's next looking at these opportunities and then coming up with the actual question which will be a space that we have to operate from coming out of Monday so I'm not going to spend time on the first 25 or 40 25 or 35 slides because we have this information unless there's different information that's going to be brought to us I'm

161we not going to spend that much time on those slides we're going to hit the ground on Mon on Monday in the conversation with what do you think that's when the board's going to have to really come together and say you know what 680 is the number 790 is the number I'm just giving you you know I'm just you know you know throwing out numbers here and we have to then start to you know formulate what do you want to see in that space cuz we can do it I'm telling y'all we can do this I know that's going be differences of opinions but we can do this y'all we can figure this out because it's going to really impact our students our staff and our families in the baloy school district for not just

162next year because again we don't have another question y'all this is it this is for this year and next year because this is this is the question okay and so I want to make sure that that's very clearly understood come Monday we're going to hit the ground with your ideas we're going to going to come to a uh hopefully a space where we can say you know we can get behind this as a collective and then and then we can actually move that question to Legal you know and I can you know get that vetted and then it's not really hard from that space because then on on Tuesday because that's a part of this conversation um we can we can say this is what the resolution looks like and we can vote on the

163revenue limit increase on those two questions and then move move on with the next steps if we don't come to those spaces the last chance we get for the board to make a decision on whether or not we want to do this is January the 16th that's my that's my hard space that we have to we we really have to you know have it together by January the 16th and only reason why I say that is because you see this slide it's the 7th 2 21st we still technically we supposed to get this stuff to Legal beforehand which we would love to do it if we can do it on the 13th and the 14th right but if we can't then all this come back on the 16th and then we got to do it

164on the 17th to be ready on the 21st and we still got other stuff to take care of right the the school district continues Mr chady so thank you I I understand the timeline that Dr Garrison laid out I would encourage the board to act a little bit more expeditiously uh I I think before you leave tonight you need to kind of resonate around something um and if there's some adjustments or refinements to one of the scenarios that you'd like to see we need to know that today so that I can attend to that tomorrow morning we can get it to you by the end of the day tomorrow so that you have the opportunity to review that prior to Monday's night's meeting because Monday night's meeting I think you really need to Def determine

165of these refined scenarios that come back to you over the weekend which one you you know where you're at and then Monday's Focus needs to be on the language of the question what the purpose is you know what the intention of those resources are because Tuesday morning we need to share that language with legal counsel so that way they can review it massage it change it whatever um they need time to turn that around to get back to us for Thursday of next week so I would just encourage us to you know if there's a scenario that's here that you think is what you're looking at if there's a mill rate dollar value that you want me to try to to um provide a similar scenario for if you want to put more money into

166salaries in wages or into person let's not call it salary and wages but into Personnel right because it may not just always be percentage increase higher percentage increase for our existing staff some of it may be to support new staff too um you know if we want to expand transportation to the high school students kind of need to know that so we can make sure that we're building a budget model that incorporates those anticipated expenses Mrs Levy thank you um it sounds like we're looking for consensus so I will just throw my two cents in um I can't support a scenario that doesn't include any of the visioning that we've brought our community in to help us with um I would love to see a 5% increase for staff instead of the 3% that's built

167in and some significant amount that goes towards a buffer for that Cliff so those are the three things it has to include funding to do some of the visioning work and if we can't get to all of it I it um a 5% increase for I like how you phrased it and then I immediately forgot it um for personnel um which gives us some flexibility and then some type of buffer for that Cliff that we know is coming Miss Miller thank you um I was weighing in for the same reason um I am somewhere between G and H I think um to Brian Anderson's point we want to show that kind of ongoing you know we're going to be fiscally responsible we're going to make cuts to pay for some of these things that we're

168visioning I'm fine with that I think you know I'm definitely between G and H I think keeping it um if we can keep it as close to seven or below for mill rate that would be great and I just want to Echo um Mrs Levy's comments as well about a 5% minimum increase for staff with the understanding too that there is some wiggle room in there if we needed to do kind of stagger it out so also I need to get going so those are my thoughts thank you Mr Nicholls thank you um I would I would actually I would agree with with both uh board member Levy and and board member uh Miller that you know I think especially what board member Miller said I think we need to keep keep below I think

169we need to keep around $7 on the bill right I think if we can I think that's a I think that's a kind of a good consistent area um you know I again I remember when I moved here and it was like sticker shock after we moved in and not not before but after so um and then it you know it did it did get better now it's ridiculous the other way so I think I think I think by by you know sharing that 444 number that it's going to go to next year anyway and and and staying you know two $2.50 you know additional mail rate I think is is sellable and um but I too think we need to listen we need to come make sure that we've got money there for the

170what what the public has said that they want us to have and follow those follow those guidelines uh I like what board member Anderson put in his email today is focus on the three key issues being teacher pay discipline enforcement prevention and student achievement not necessarily in that order I think that's the three key areas that we need to focus on which is part of our goals District goals and um but to be able to have some some funds in there for for high school um transportation um again I don't know what the number is but again if we can keep it there's you know the the the H the H is is more total money but the mill rate's very very very very close to the to item G2 so I think that's that's

171what I'd like to see that's where I'm at thank you Mr Schneider um you know kind of like in the neighborhood what everybody has been saying I like the the scenario H I like the stability in the mill rate so people have a clear understanding this is what it's going to be year after year um instead of okay we're going to jump high but it's going to come down and then it's going to go up but that just makes it very difficult for people to budget and to plan so the the more consistent we can keep at the best that we the better off that we are um you know after we had talked before last time when we started looking at at teach at salaries um you know again I would like to see

172you know that 5% or close to that anyway um because we have given less than what we really wanted to in the last couple years so this would be a chance to be able to to benefit um our staff which also helps do everything else that that the community has said they want us to do um so you know H understanding you know we um you know looking at that mill rate a little bit maybe coming down a little bit I mean if we go halfway between G and H we're at about 7.15 I mean that's splitting the difference between the two um um that might be more likable to the community um I really am hesitant though about not not doing what the community has asked us to do um which is looking at

173it at age at at least um so Mr henkins thank you uh yes I appreciate what Mr chady is getting at and zeroing it and kind of get getting into the uh zeroing in on it at least uh where we're at I will not I I'm not going to marry myself to a letter uh although I am certainly in the realm of what all my colleagues are saying I do want to give myself some time to listen to the public after what they've heard today and those that are listening and paying attention if they do have questions I can take that in but guaranteed I don't see anything that's going to come out of the blue I'll come back on Monday and say wellah blah we should do this I do have one question though

174um and I I don't want to get into things that we talk about in close session but when we talk about the 3% and 5% and in negotiation time when it comes next fall I mean are we laying our hand out I know I know and this is if if the referendum passes okay just if you could just address that without getting into specifics about anything no I mean the district still has to go through the negotiation process before you do I will entertain a motion to extend the meeting another 30 minutes so moved second motion by Greg Schneider seconded by Brian Nichols any discussion hearing none all in favor I I I I any oppose n motion carries 521 go ahead Mr chady yeah I'm sorry I kind of lost help help me reconnect

175Mr henin sorry I was talking about the 3% and basically the 5% and then how we go into next fall into negotiation period right are we showing our hand or not our hand I mean it's all relative anyways right well I mean you're showing your hand in that the Bea um and the Bea secretary support Union will know a value that we are have used the budget for does that mean that you have to give them 5% no because again we're adding five we're adding an additional million doll into Personnel costs that doesn't mean that we're using the full million dollars awarding to current employees there may be some new staff positions that are created or or vacant staff positions that we have to pay more in order to fill so you're you're utilizing those

176additional resources to meet your needs the negotiation process is still there still there and yes and like you've told us and it's a very fluid thing anyway so we're just addressing something to project into the future thank you it I think it does send a good message though you know that we have increased the our anticipated expenses related to Personnel um so long as in either in the question or in the explanation the education we do to the community we identify where where those funds are targeted for thank you Mr Anderson yeah thanks I think you know as we build this consensus a couple thoughts is you know I like to point out the difference between our budget shortfall and an actual shortfall you know for example this year we have a balanced budget um

177and we have 56 open positions as of last week as Mr Nichols loves to ask about right so there's 56 positions love to hire them we'd love to find those key positions and and and they're needed and they're budgeted the reality is there's going to be positions we don't fill and that's just uh again that's the difference between a budgeted shortfall and what the actual shortfall is going to be so I think you know my purpose is I'd love to front load a little bit to play some catch up with staff on on this increase that's why my my my proposal my thought was to to have to commit to a larger increase in year one playing a little bit of catchup and we'll see what happens in year two and year three right we

178we just don't know we don't know what the state's going to do we don't know um what our enrollments going to do um we have a trend of decline in enrollment maybe that levels off maybe it increases right so we you know there's just there's enough unknown things that um you know I don't know that we need to necessarily increase that being said I like I I am a fan of a stable mill rate okay and so as we look at scenario G um you know I I think you know I like the idea of that that gets us pretty close to you know and Asis spending um it doesn't it doesn't add a lot to our fund balance it doesn't put stuff away for future years as board member Levy says she would love

179to see right so there's there's some there's some drawbacks to that plan as well um but I think it also allows some room for for additional right sizing you know I I think it's important we project to the public that um we we say hey we're asking for more money but it doesn't mean we're we're leaving everything status quo that's on the books right now right I think there's uh we're going to make additions there may be subtractions in other areas so I think think um when we come Monday some of my key thoughts are going to be I do like the idea of a stable mill rate um that that would be able to move me from you know having a declining you know annual um request to something stable or maybe even increasing

180but I'd like to see a front loaded increase to staff um rather than a static increase over the entire three years I think we just don't know enough right um and um I would just say thank you to Dr Garrison Mr shady and the staff I think it's this has been um the scenario situations you put forward I think really SP out really well and I want to thank you for that Mr trady just uh reflecting a bit on board member Anderson's comments and then some other comments with regards to maybe striving to invest a 5% increase in our Personnel costs uh want to throw an idea at you just to see where you're at because it's something that I wrote down maybe it's a 6% increase in Personnel costs in the first year in

1814% increase in year two and year three is that something that you would have some interest in okay okay I got a question goad so this is not necessarily a question but a statement I think from a internal perspective from from a staffing perspective I think our staff do want stability um whether the increases are you know anywhere from 3: to 6 I was want to make you all hear this but from 3 to six I think our staff do want stability I also think and I and I I think the board is probably saying the same thing there's going to be a there's going to be a natural attrition thoughts that happens in school district but it that and I know what I'm hearing from staff that can't be the the not just projected

182space of 26 27 and 28 because then it goes right back to am I the one I'm I the one that's going to be possibly reduced or you know talked about as pertains to um attrition their position or reducing their position so you know personally I believe making sure that our staff has some form of stability our current staff has some form of stability over the next three years will be very important um and then naturally we make expenses reductions that necessarily don't impact what our current people are showing up every day has to do so just want to make sure we kind of note that as a statement not as a you know a number thank you Dr Garrison any [Applause] any Mr Schneider was that a hand oh okay okay okay that brings

183us to our next item next meeting dates Monday January 13th 5:00 pm we have a special board meeting Tuesday January 14th 5:00 p.m the tle committee meeting Tuesday January 14th at 6: p.m. the regular board meeting is there a motion to adjourn so moved second motion by Brian Nicholls seconded by Greg Schneider any discussion hearing none all in favor i i i any oppose motion carries unanimously everybody have a good night thank you everyone

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.