001e e [Applause] good evening everyone this is a call of the order for the policy committee meeting for Wednesday January the 8th at 5:30 p.m M Mr sh could we have a roll call please yes Tom henkins here Amy Levy is unable to make this evening and Brian Nichols here all members are present accept Amy Ley wait a minut thank you um could I get an approval of the agenda so moved and I will second in Amy's absence any discussion all those in favor say I I I agenda could I get an approval of the minutes for November the 6th so moved I second any discussion hearing known all those in favor say I I I minutes approved first item on the agenda is policy 3456 graduation requirements and Mrs mortech thank you for being
002here and your team it's all yours okay thank you um so we have a mini set of uh policies and then we'll be coming back uh to finish the complete set um in in the coming months uh with the end of the school year coming uh I'm going to show you the presentation that we had planned um back in October when we first came uh to the policy committee to go through that um we did also go back to the T committee uh two out of three of those committee members supported our changes uh in completion uh Mr henkins uh has remained consistent with uh concerns with the change in 26 to 24 credit um there are other changes though in the policy that I would like to get to this evening so um hope
003hopefully our conversation won't just rest in the CR number of credits uh required because there are uh changes that were made at the state level so in order for us to be in alignment we updated the policy uh which informs the master scheduling process going forward for students uh so I will show the uh presentation okay so why the changes uh we had to be in alignment uh with the updates made in state requirements to be more in alignment with high performing school districts AC across the state we looked at top performing school districts to see what their number of uh required credits were and then um the last part was to continue to offer well-rounded education to students and allow um opportunities to earn beyond the minimum requirements that the state has and opportunities
004to be recognized for academic Excellence so um we looked at schools uh the largest school districts in the state we looked at our highest performing districts um in the state and then we looked at districts um around Rock County to look at the number of credits um that they were requiring so um currently we are requiring 26 so our recommendation based off of all of these other school districts was to move to 24 then what we did when you go into the policy a little bit deeper um we wanted our students in alignment with our Academy structure to be recognized for academic Excellence so um currently with the recommendation again of a minimum of 24 or if we stay at 26 they would be a graduate um at the end um as seniors or they
005could graduate with honors if they have those additional requirements or we would recognize a graduate with honors distinction should they have those additional um accomplishments uh during the ceremony and then some other considerations that we were looking at is um just with those minimum requirements that changing the uh minimum requirements does not prevent students from seeking the maximum credits which is 32 credits uh the change does not change the core requirements from the state it's only our number of electives that we are uh requiring students uh to do changing from the 26 down to the 24 will allow more students to participate participate in work-based learning opportunities uh which is definitely a point of pride in our district we outpace the state um still approximately 3 to one um and that's a lot of the
006work that we're doing uh as our initiative and focus has been in building academies for um earned credit and uh college career and Community ready and then also um improving our four-year graduation rate um is another one we are really working towards changing our system of uh getting out of the mindset of credit recovery being a fallback and really pressing on students to take courses and pass them the first time in in their class you know classes and so that's another piece of that that um we've been talking about um as the as an administrative group we have some of our administrators here today that have worked um in collaboration on this policy so those are that's the presentation um and then the meat of the changes are obviously in the edits um that are
007found um in the uploads are there any questions uh board member henkins oh yeah a few um and correct me if I'm wrong but I think what I heard you say was I'm concerned obviously I'm concerned about lowering it the uh I think you're trying to on the I think that a student has more flexibility in taking different varying classes other than core classes but I thought I also heard you say that this does not affect core classes going from 26 to 24 they still have to maintain is that true yeah what we're what we're removing is the number of required elected courses I'm sorry if I misspoke there no I'm just so they're still required to take the core amount that the state requires we right now require students to take more electives so
008the reduction from 24 to 26 is reducing the the required amount of electives which is beyond what the state suggests okay then I thought I heard you say that that would give them more flexibility in taking these elective classes it well it gives them flexibility because they can stay all the way up to 32 credits so it's this change doesn't change the opportunity to take 32 credits no no what it does is it gives them more flexibility to have work-based learning opportunities or it gives students the opportunity if they're ready to graduate and move on to to not have to stick around and take additional electives explain that that they what do you mean stick around if they have completed you mean they have to take two more electives is that what you're talking about
009currently yeah with someone else in the group maybe one of the administrators could you explain the difference in the electives and and what is the core class requirement uh as as units sure so if you look at the um policy the way it's written in the draft it has what the requirements are by the state so it's four credits of English three credits of social studies three credits of science three credits of math a05 of uh phys personal finance and 1.5 of fiad equals half of Health half of Health thank you equals how many total is that 15 15 thank you so 15 and they're required to have at this point 26 credits to graduate right correct correct so they're already getting okay um when you say to get us more in alignment with the
010state what does that mean sure so um in the presentation there was a link where it talked about some of the changes that have been happening so for example um in the future we may be able to substitute a CTE course for a math credit um and there are some other changes like that that were suggested um the way in which we were doing and recognizing math credits those types of things there's also can I just please yeah so it also the guidance from DPI says um the state superintendent encourages school boards to require an additional eight and a half credits in combination for vocational Ed World languages arts and other courses so that's the electives they're recommending eight and a half credits and currently we require more than that okay but she's that's she's
011not saying we wouldn't mind if you have more than that okay that's sorry okay um would you like to go first do you have some oh I've got a question okay no board member president please president please please carry on so 32 is the maximum possible that's just during the regular two semester year they could get all if they took a class every single class period they would have 32 yes yeah okay I I know sometimes there's in the past there were students that would take classes during summer school to get the extra credits um to try to graduate early and I didn't know if that was something that students still do or not thanks we don't have a early graduation um opport well technically students could graduate early we technically students car here early
012let me let me correct myself correct um when I when I'm thinking about like the you said 32 it's 32 over four years of course yeah yeah up to 32 over over the course of four years I just want to make sure I note that yeah or in L of having to take it during the regular school year and we only offer it in the summer when we have a licensed person to do it so we haven't offered it every summer that I've been here and on average students in the distri burn which begs a question why change it okay well now it's my turn um so I let's let's go to the spreadsheet that you presented I guess that's page what two or three three um and I appreciate the data that you put
013together on the on on this on the uh do you want to put that back up on the screen Mrs morac okay thank you that one thank you okay um so you know I I appreciate the largest public schools and the highest performing Public Schools um but I'm I guess I'm more focused on bit in Rock County so um you're you um if you did not include the Lincoln Academy which is a part of our part of our Network you know in this in this County it's Public Charter School right um yeah I could have put that on there I I was thinking about public school systems I wasn't thinking about one charter school in our city okay well I'm I'm not F on that it's just one okay so um so they're at 26
014so the average in Rock County is 25.5 hours and we're at 26 so I would um I would tend to agree with board member henkins is you know why would we change it um if if you know if we've got a lot of students that are getting 30 credits and all that um and it gives them the opportunity to be to take more elective classes um you know they might find some that that elective class that they could take instead of in those extra two credits could be a career decision for them ultimately is that correct is that possible yeah I mean with all due respect I've brought this policy and we've gone around and around about this I've taken it to another committee uh those two out of three board members supported the change
015and I'm back here again so I started this conversation tonight to say that I didn't want to get hung up on this because there are other edits in this so if you and Mr henkins are still concrete that you want to keep it 26 uh Miss Levy shared her thoughts that she is in support of the change if it will not get out of the policy because the two of you are solid on 26 I'm okay with that because there are other changes in these other policies that I need to get to because they are we are not in alignment to the state okay okay good well I I am I'm I'm I personally am firm as a member of the policy committee I'm firm on 26 also I think uh I I just I
016think I think it feels like we're going backwards and and we don't there's you know that's that's the and I can tell you I would be almost sure if we share you know share this with the community we're going to get we're going to get the same same I respectfully and professionally disagree but that's another way for you to look at it and I think we should just move forward on the other changes because we will have another board at another time sounds good thank you thank you so want to go through the other changes yes okay absolutely so so in in 3456 is there any other changes so we're going to leave 20 we're going to leave that at um I think that would I I believe that would change would that not change
017the uh the second paragraph to except we would not change that so for number one having pass grades and all that are required we would keep that at 26 Michelle schope yes and then we would um add at the bottom recommendation beginning with the class of 2526 so if we're going to keep it at 24 we can strike beginning with the class of 25 26 because there's no need to make that change that's okay very good yep bullet point two is okay correct bullet three is correct with with the change correct yes okay we are just using um the they e they correct correct and then uh um the next paragraph uh we are striking that out okay you you still want to strike that correct okay all right next paragraph's fine um what about
018the last par the next to the last paragraph yep those are my recommendations so I'm good as they stand okay I will note that um Miss Levy suggested that we collapse all three of the policies rule one rule two rule three um and run them all together which I am open to that change um if you are uh chair Nickles um we would just have to change those edits uh with Miss schop I would I'm I'm a I'm a I'm I'm the I'm Different I I I believe we should keep him separate as rule one rule two rule three yeah because okay in for me in looking up policies it's easier to look up you know because it's it's titled different than than the the the one the one bigy set I it it it
019doesn't make a big difference to me personally okay and then the last the last sentence um refers to rule two should we should do we need to strike that um no we added that in green yeah I know so we wanted to keep that because okay they have to get that in in time to apply for completion okay Mr shoper you did you get all that okay thank you question Mr um Nicholls yes sir when we think about the and and I needed the discussion to happen because uh the recommendations that are coming to the board are you know number one vetted through my office and of course we move those conversations forward um accordingly the 26 to the 24 I know you asked us to go to the um teaching learning and Equity committee
020they they said they're fine or to the policy committee we're not with that with the 26 24 so what what was the rationale of going back to the to the to the teaching learning Equity committee it as I stated at that time it seemed like that's where it should have started in the first place so that that hasn't changed so I don't know that there's really any reason to to go over that again so so I disagree because if it went there and if it went there was is it the charge of the policy committee for it to stay there and then it moved to the full board that wasn't the charge I didn't think that was the charge that's why we had to come back here and so that's that's what the disconnect is
021because if we go to another committee and the committee there is fine with it do we do we do we then is it a policy that we say then it goes back to the full board because coming back here it didn't stopped you you see what I'm saying so' I did email the board about that for clarifying um how we were going to go forward because for example the policy committee has handled Finance policy here like they are tonight but those were not asked to start in the finance committee so there's an inconsistency of practice and I did email and ask for clarification which I did not receive okay my apologies for that no worries so um this this is this is kind of a wholesale change of the program to me program I mean
022we're changing you know we're changing graduation requirements so that's that's that's a big deal and uh uh you know I mean we're talking about the area that we need to really improve in which is academic achievement so um I uh I can't put words in board member hanken mouth and I won't I refuse used to do that but in my mind um I think we need to give our our children the opportunity to get more exposure than less in high school and and again I don't disagree with that I think sometimes we keep we associate credits with with achievement and that's where the disconnect comes in at often times in this in this conversation um I just wanted to make sure from a Clarity perspective that you know as as as we move these conversations
023through different committees that we're that we want to be consistent and we also want to do with the the board is asking me you know I got to follow those procedures as well um but it it passed there came back here it didn't pass here well based off of where we are we haven't voted on it yet um we still got to do that part um and it it seems as if when we sent it there those two those voices there maybe and I think maybe like a policy as such for clarity perspective maybe we should have brought it maybe I should have brought it to the full board but then again that's why we have the policy committee so it's is one of those things where we have to make sure we work out
024so that the clarity is there so that we won't I don't want to disrespecting another Committee in their work and then bring it back here then that you know there that space as well so I just wanted to make sure I brought that as a note um um because that's something that may come up as we continue to review more and more policies um if it goes to a committee if we ask if the policy committee ask to go to a committee and that committee votes it up then maybe we should bring that up to the full board and then the board can take it off the consent AG vote on it as a hole and then move on like we would normally do anyway as a suggestion uh because again for to go come
025back go yes come back no it's like the other board other committee I should say um we're not recognizing that well we're not recognizing that space um that that took place last month so I just want to make sure I note that as as as as the district administ I would also note that the inconsistency has set us back four months I intentionally brought this to the board in October because I knew that we were starting the master scheduling in the high school and because I've sat here now four times for a first reading it has pushed us into January and the high school has already started their Master scheduling so I ask out of respect of the time and the work of the staff because this is now another night that our administrators are
026sitting here to discuss this policy that we have more consistency and practice in valuing people's time and work okay let's go back to 3456 so we uh could I get a motion to move uh the recommendations to the full board with the addition with the changes that we have made that Mrs Shope has made so you are suggesting May yep yeah we're going to do well we're going to do one policy at a time okay so 3456 was the first and the one we just went through correct that correct right so we're going to you know requ I'm I need a motion to move this the changes to the board of education for policy 3456 so 3456 um with the changes of the um this committee 20 of the 26 credits remaining yes and striking
027the beginning with the class of and then all of the other changes remaining correct Mr hins uh so move I know we're going to probably discuss then the other changes thank you I second any discussion hearing none all those in favor say I um I thought we might have a discussion first I I that's okay okay yes okay uh for this Layman um the other changes and I know we struck this and added this in the verbiage what maybe M morch you could explain what now remains in place place that we are changing for uh on a thumb thumbnail sketch for me please are are we still with the first policy are we on the next one I'm sorry I'm lost we're on 3456 okay so we haven't moved that forward yet we that's what
028we're voting on to Mo I'm sorry I so we're we're we're on 26 to 24 we're still on what we just went over okay right okay but not any other changes just that is correct 26 24 okay I'm ready to vote all those in favor say I pass I'm not sure I meaning you change or not change if I so the just a clarification I'm sorry so so if if I understanding where we are you guys the motion right now is for the um 345.8 the this this one um leaving the credits at I I motion carried two Z okay now we're moving on to 34 56 rule one thank you that's correct okay so we're going to make the change on a to TW back to back back to 26 and Mrs mortech what
029are the changes sure so then in green where it says beginning with the class of 25 26 we'll strike that St that yeah okay we will leave credits earned shall be in accordance with State and policy statute okay and then moving on to the different content areas anything in green we've added anything with a line through it we've struck out okay all righty just want to make sure I want to I don't want to I don't want to miss anything correct and then uh thank you good catch Miss gud so on the back of the of it this where it says College and Career Readiness and elective courses yes we will need to change that from back to 10 instead of 8.5 that was where the reduction was coming from right so we need to
030move it back to requiring kids 10 electives to graduate instead of 8.5 10 and a half excuse me 10.5 10.5 instead of 8.5 okay that's where we picked up the 10 the two that is what I was trying to explain that's correct okay okay uh aside from from that everything else but are there any other changes that yeah we need to adjust the last part D okay so Michelle show in part D where we have the 24 minimum requirements earned it'll have to all change the 24s back to 26s right sure so College in Readiness courses is going back to the 10 10.5 10.5 want the verbage in the Box to change because it says students must and change to 10 correct okay so in the first box where it says 8.5 you're going to
031change that to 10.5 and then when we break it down it stays the 0.5 College and Career ready course and then that eight is the 10 thank you for your clarification that's correct but the half stays there right yes sir correct the 10 plus the5 is the 10.5 right yep and did you get the items in D Mrs sh yes okay I did have a clarifying question with my colleague um Tony Bosco on threee will we have the examination to meet the requirements for a particular course we wanted to strike out that the principal should be the sole determiner of the credits but do we want to put back in the examination okay I'll explain it to you reason why so Michelle where it says examination to meet requirements for a particular course we want
032to keep that in the verbiage um we're on the second page A3 3E 3E is the reason why is because we're looking at in our dual language um a proficiency assessment that students could take that would allow them then to like skip a language course at the high school level um in the statute you have to identify that and and build out a process but we don't want to strike it totally out of the policy yet until we build out the PO the process because otherwise we have to come back to the board and it was written in here before but nothing was really done with it it was just sort of sitting there and so um in our deeper conversations about uh students proficiencies in like Spanish for example how they could earn credit
033then with an examination okay so that's why we're leaving it okay and that also applies to some AP tests also oh yes and some AP tests that's right I have a quick question on in C is that okay the 60 60 students who have an i or excuse me students must correctly answer at least 65 questions is that still correct that's correct okay yes just wanted to verify thank you for asking yes okay that takes care of it right yes sir okay okay uh could I get a could I get a uh is there a motion to move the uh 3456 rule one to the full board for first reading with the changes that we have uh Mrs Shope has notated noted so moved I'll second is is there any discussion hearing none all those
034in favor say I I I motion carried okay 34 3456 rule 2 do you want to keep do you want to change graduation to completion or do you want to leave it at graduation yeah um it's a little bit of word smithing but it helps to you clarify that students can complete early but they are not fully graduated until the day of the ceremony and then they're a graduate so it just is more accurate in its wording and that's why the word completion is found throughout this policy in lie of the word graduation okay Mr um right can I ask a question yes Dr gears and this is what I was referring to I don't I know when I said earlier that we don't have a early graduation we don't we don't have early graduation
035so I don't want I don't want people to think I was just crazy by stating that because I wasn't um um we cuz I never seen one since I've been here I think that's just something I just want to mention we we have early completers and they do finish it's just that then the full fledged graduation is at the ceremony correct we do not have early graduation you are correct correct thank you s June Saturday in June right okay um uh items 1 C is that still okay to to do you need to to leave it at 7 um we will be striking that okay this was that this was we're going to leave it I mean we're going to strike C period one C yes yes okay did you get that Mrs sh yes
036okay uh items 2 a strike okay and completion what what about uh 2D do you want to move that back to principal or you are you going to leave we're striking principal and going with school administrator okay uh early completers completers class rank um so it will be class rank will be determined upon graduation and we're striking all of the other stuff okay Mr sh did you get that yes okay I hope you don't mind me continue to ask I just think I might be easier if we get the back and go all the way back so okay so that is 3456 rule two uh could I get a motion to move this back to the full board move it to the four board um with additions and deletions as noted by Mrs sh so
037moved second any discussion hearing none all those in favor say I I I motion carried okay moving on to 2D um rule three which is 3456 rule 3 rule three excuse me um so what what do how do we need to change sure so um it will in that first paragraph M it will now read a student who meets all of the following requirements we've added will be exempt from the point five Credit in physical education for the purposes of high school graduation in accordance with the state statute so we are now in in alignment with the state statute so and that as as as suggested at it the same okay all right just want to double check sure okay and then bullet point number three Asis Asis okay uh bullet point four Asis okay
038and the next paragraph yeah that that's not necessary that's not necessary okay and um there wasn't there is a note down there that we need to um remove his her okay got that okay and the assistant principal for athletics and activities leave that we're crossing offices in principal Athletics because we just simply have an athletic director right okay yeah it's a title change I think at some point okay all right that's good Michelle Michelle you good on that okay all right um so we get a motion on 345 rules. 6 rule 3 to move to the full board with the changes that we've uh discussed so moved I second any discussion hearing none all those in favor say I I I motion carried okay 34561 uh you recommend no changes yeah I did want to
039add in if you don't mind just crossing off that last sentence there shall be no formal graduation exercises Miss Levy had asked for clarification I don't disagree cuz she said you know sometimes people want to do like a 4K bridge and an eighth grade bridge so maybe we just get rid of that whole last sentence and then it just if people want to do their informal things in those buildings and this just sticks to what a formal graduation ceremony is in that top part okay I just felt like it simplified it okay any discussion on that U board member henkins yes so Mr morch you're just suggesting we eliminate that last line yeah okay I think it just makes things more confusing than trying to be clear which is what I think their original intent
040was I I would agree okay okay so could I get a motion to move 345 about 61 to the full board for approval with the uh that one change some moved I'll second any discussion hearing none all those in favor say I I I motion carried to Z and as you so happily noted 3 34562 and. 63 have never been used to represent policy in the last 26 years so I think I don't know what to say I wasn't here me either I don't think anybody in this room was here then okay okay 35 345 64 Miss Levy did suggest that we change the number on that then to be in alignment of the policies in order because those other two are like mute do it so I don't know I'm fine with that oh
041cuz then it's more in order yeah that's a good point it's not a question of like where are the other two okay does that make sense to you mot it does and if I could have 30 seconds to catch up I would appreciate it absolutely we're moving too quickly now so I'm gonna let them yes President John Nichols so then 345 64 will become what number 3456 do 62 okay yeah [Applause] and just to clarify am I correct that the only revision to the pous diplomas is the number change is the number correct okay we we did have a recommendation I'm sorry uh Mr Nicholls it was a Miss on our H our behalf so do you see that bullet where it says the student must be enrolled in Belo Memorial High School or boo
042Learning Academy we have we have students that are enrolled in virtual school and other programs so do we just say that the student must be enrolled within the school district of booy at the time of death and then they would get that diploma well they wouldn't get a diploma if they were in the sixth grade right right but would they get a diploma if they're a freshman because according to your policy they do now right that's the idea yeah sure so yeah sure I think in a lot of um in these situations we just really want to honor um the families that that's going through this bement and since I've been in schools even here in in booy there has been untimely um passing of a student and I've been thinking about this this this
043specific it's like we have Challenge Academy students Fresh Start students and and it doesn't say that in this policy so I think but for me when I read it the student must be enrolled in B Mo or B Learning Academy if they are part of our virtual program they are inbl I mean I mean that that it is under the umbrella of the bla Academy that is true yes that's a good point Dr Garrison so I didn't I wasn't trying to I thought it was fine the way it is that's the thought you just brought in the room but I I don't I want to honor your space too but I think we should leave it because in because our understanding is in booy Academy we have a lot of programming underneath that umbrella so
044all of those are programs that I listed so a student would a family would receive them because they are a part of the blit Learning Academy that's correct they are not okay that makes now that we've talked that through does that sound good to you Mr Sten yeah and also addressed your point board member Nichols of somebody in sixth grade if they're in Memorial High School or belake Learning Academy they are a high school student I just want to make sure missing students in those other programs looking at BL only physical building so thank you you're welcome thank you well um and also uh board member Levy made a suggestion that we change the first sentence uh to read upon the request of a student's parent which we have slash Guardian the relative if the
045student is accompanied unaccompanied a high school diploma may be awarded possibly so I think that's a good addition agreed do you agree yes so Michelle did you get board member Levy's email I I didn't but it was forwarded to me okay okay Michelle are you ready Mrs chop are you ready okay so I I need a okay yes for M Hankins yeah just clarification I think this covers it when it says may be awarded um so it leaves some wiggle room you know I mean the worst worst case scenario of someone had to die on campus for some you know extenuating reasons why smell feance of their own it's a maybe so you suggesting we change a May to a shell are we leav it says maybe so I think that leaves that wiggle room
046I'm just thinking oh you would like the wiggle room yeah yeah I I do okay that it says we have to you know I'm just thinking the the 99.9999% is good but and I just want to jump back uh chairman Nichols and I don't know if you're doing this on his his motion do we need to go back when we did we eliminate the two Mrs Mork and do we need to say that the ones that haven't been used for 25 or six shouldn't that be a motion to eliminate those no but if we're pushing everything up they just go into the hyperspace those numbers I defer to the expert I defer to the expert on policy numbering those numbers were actually never used and quite often this committee has asked well where's the policy
047that was represented by those numbers so I looked back as far as 25 years and couldn't find where those two numbers were ever used and so like we in the past have used the WB guideline for numbering policies and so if their guidelines said to number graduation exercises as the0 61 and then posist diplomas as the 64 those two other numbers could have some other policy represented by them but we've never had a policy for them so that's why there's no need to delete them because we haven't had a policy thank you and excuse me for does that make sense yes very much so so are we good to move forward okay uh I need a motion to move policy 34562 the new number forward uh to the full board with the noted uh changes
048so moved I second any discussion hearing none all those in favor say I I I pass today um first of all thank you all I I I do appreciate the time that you guys spent and I'm sorry that we drug you out and I apologize for last month I twice in I mean two two weeks and anyway personal health jumped in my way so thank you appreciate what you do good night okay now we're on to the 600 policies 672 policies so 672 no no no changes Mr chady uh correct yeah no changes to 672 um we've read through that we feel that that's appropriate as it is today so okay yep good thank you Michelle I have a question on that for you we just do a review date that's you would just review
049today date do we need to do we need to do a motion on that and no I didn't think so okay so you you will just change the last review date to January 8 whoa hello okay okay 6722 the only thing you changed was the um to to delete human resources and operations from how on second second sentence correct uh 6 72.2 local purchasing yes the old the old policy had however the on second sentence however the Executive Director of Business comma Human Resource as okay yeah I'm sorry what's posted in board dos doesn't reflect that change but I do recall that yeah trying to think back to the work that we did for November yep just updating that title was all okay yep and that's considered a minor change that I'm was given permission
050to do by the committee so that's why it wasn't highlighted or anything right so we don't need to vote on it okay I have a question though okay when I'm looking at the policies and I see last reviewed and I know we had had conversations about this um does is there is there a policy Michelle because I I just need to not this for myself there's a is there a policy that speaks to how often we're will to review policies is it too yes um there's a policy that says that we're supposed to totally review every policy and I believe it's every 3 years I can do and that's like according to the master policy you know with the master policy log or whatever and that's in the 100 I think for the policy committee
051not that good function that's what practices in their policy but when they fall into but I don't know that we've ever made it through every policy in three years I know and I think we've tried really hard starting when Dan keer was here and we've started going through in chunks but we haven't made it in 3 years and the reason why I'm bringing it up is because I know there something that my Administration not currently able to I'm putting it out there accomplish I'm not I can't go we can't go through 900 policies and correct correct so I I just want to make sure that everyone's aware at the policy committee that I am thinking about that I know we are not able to you know meet that that that threshold uh so we'll do
052the we'll continue to do the best we can but I want you all to know that cuz I'm I may I would just say we are we are in the last 3 to four years reviewing policy at a much better rate than it was being reviewed 10 years ago sure so thank you okay it's good to hear we'll try to keep it going here sorry for the delays okay um so uh 6724 vendor relations and 6724 Rule one vendor relation guidelines no changes um either one of those correct I I see no changes uh for either um I did read Committee Member Levy's suggestion about combining the two oh um I would encourage you to pause on that yeah instead of doing so I'm accustomed in other districts where you have approved policies Schoolboard policies
053and then you have Associated administrative rules that govern how the policy is adopted or implemented internally okay you know can they be all the same I suppose they could but I've always been coached that less is more when it comes to policy instead of more is more so your policies you try to be succinct and to the point yeah um without getting into this you know the administrative rule component but you're you're the policy committee and the board so so you're recommending that we keep them separate I I I would encourage the policy committee to reach out to to the Wisconsin Association of school board and speak to their policy team yeah about what the difference is between policies and rules um and get guidance from them and I know that the district has collapsed
054administ collapsed rules into the associated policy in the past not saying it's right or wrong but okay you know context to that too um go ahead go ahead Dr kison so so little little bit of context that that is true um typically there's admin guidelines that are associated with policies um in our district however we have we have these rules and then when I had a conversation with M mop years ago when I first got here like what are these rules we typically we see admen guidelines and then of course policies like Mr Chay is talking about but here we have rule one rule two rule three which has kind of folded almost sounded like our admin guidelines um and so I hear what Mr chady is stating I understand what Mrs Lev is where
055Mr Lev's point is and also understand where um um your your your space in this as well Mr Nicholls I think that's the Dilemma How We Do policies in in boo because again we have rule one rule two world three a lot of times those rules sound and feel like admin guidelines versus policies now the question that I had you know in my you know as I spent spent numerous hours on policies here um do we roll all of the rules into an admin guideline conversation now you have admin guidelines instead of rules but you know again that'll take a whole another conversation with hundreds of different policies and I think there's a bigger conversation that we probably need to have just as an agenda item here um we're talking about the Neola policy set
056and having having um more people come to talk to talk to us about policy and policy layout because we do do our policies different here in booy that's not negative that's not like you know a shot at anything or you know any one or anything like that just that from a consistency perspective it's kind of hard to keep up with the many different changes that we are making and like I said collapsing versus not collapsing rules versus adman guidelines I just want to make sure that if we were to do this thing full-fledged across all of the conversations then we probably need to have a greater conversation around policies policy layouts as a just an agenda item not even thinking about looking at policies because right now we're just we're just you know we're humming
057through all of them so just full for thought well I I appreciate that um I I I took your advice Bob I wrote down the BB policy and I'll I'll check with them but I back like this the this one that that we just talked about 6724 and 4 rule one is part of the 672 so if you put it in 672 and I I don't even well let's say 6721 is let's say we well that's no that that's not a good this but this then it would be a challenge finding if you had a question about vendor relations I think maybe yeah you know I'm not saying what's right or wrong there I I just you know most districts have the policies that are generally briefer and then they have Associated rules sometimes those
058rules are board approved sometimes they're administratively crafted that then speak to how that policy is administered you know and provides the guidance can it all be in one sure um you know earlier in your agenda I think your postumus diploma you're you're change that policy number understand that and that's wbb's got a policy Matrix with numbering MH you know so the number that you're changing it to 3 [Music] 45.6251 not that we have to follow wb's numbering system yeah but a lot of districts do you know so when comparative purposes and just alignment just some something to think about is all but okay yeah I mean what what the again what the your decision right not mine so what the committee and what the board decides to do it's up to you we we'll administer
059it the best we can however if if you want just a Heir more background absolutely when I first started working with policy eons ago um dick Peterson was our assistant superintendent of finance and he took the entire 600 series and said okay what is the WB Bible okay of numbering say right and we went through and we renumbered all the policies in the 600 series to get them to align to that guidance book because the numbers were all like all over the place like people were just throwing numbers on them and so we got it to align and follow that and make sense and so since then with me in the seat I have done what I can to follow that but as Mr chady just pointed out some policies have been in existence for
060a long time and so they don't follow that schedule but if somebody says to me hey we've created a new policy and this is what it inv involves what number do we give it that's where I go and look up a number to give it and so I've done my best to try to keep it in that numbering system now in relation to what's policy and what's the rule or admin rule I believe that all of our rules are technically admin rules but again not my call but if you look at 6 72.4 the vendor relations basically what's the policy is what you as board members are saying we need to do and in that policy where it says vendor relation guidelines in policy 6724 rule one what that would say instead is vendor relation
061guidelines in administrative Rule 6724 and then there'd be an administrative rule on board docs which we have set up that numbering we just aren't really using it yet so then the 6 72.4 rule one would actually be administrative regulation 6 72.4 so you know it goes with that because basically what the rule is saying is so here's how it works with the vendor here's what employees need to know here's the responsibilities of central office or Colac here's the responsibilities of the building principal and here's the responsibilities of the teacher so it's not necessarily what the board is saying it needs to do it's more the guideline for everybody else in the district which is why they're usually administrative RS now that might not be the case for every single rule but that one would definitely
062fall into an administrative rag in what I've been taught about policy but again like Mr chatty said it's it's not up to us that's got to be a big board decision yeah okay so wow so Mr Chay I guess a question for you and and and your group if you will and specifically talking about Finance stuff is the is does this create challenges and or real hardships along the way or is it you know you you've been here a couple years or and you're well Stephanie's not been here that long but she's been here over a year now right I mean is it for me you seem like you have a really good grasp on the policy so does does this is it bring any challenges to I I don't think it brings challenges with
063regards to collapsing the rules into the policy I mean the language doesn't change right um your policies have a tendency to then become more detailed sometimes it's nice to have some flexibility when it comes to reading the policy okay and when you have more then perhaps the flexibility becomes less so you want some gray areas sometimes it makes sense yes okay well I I just uh what was I thinking about um you know again either way okay uh and I just I've recognized over the past couple of years efforts to merge rules into policies and you maybe there just needs to be a little bit broader reflection on that before it's done is all I'm saying but you know well looking honestly looking at this one from for me again this is me personally vendor
064relations and vendor relations guidelines I don't even see why there was ever a rule one I would have thought that would have been vendor relations and you could add and guidelines and you've got you've got the policy that you didn't even need the rule one I don't know when the rule one was developed back in the 90s yes I'm just just to point out the very last sentence in the policy says the administration shall establish guidelines for implementing this policy these guidelines shall specify areas of responsibility for the central office the building principal and teachers so that's basically telling you that's the rule and that the administration is going to establish those guidelines which kind of tells you it should be an administrative regag okay as opposed to a board policy a board policy okay
065I mean that's at least in my opinion the way I'm reading that that's what it's saying to me but again not my choice not my decision and that's why I go that's why I go back to say like these they rolled in rules instead of admin guidelines and in which this was something that was practiced long before all of us right and so here and lies the the concern because now we're reading these as policies when these actually supposed to be admin rigs based off of what this policy stated that we should be going back and doing making it a little bit confusing at times well 6724 and and 6724 Rule one so yeah and you know often times resources that I often go to look at are other school districts you know what policies
066do they have and I just I happen to pull up bloy Turner they don't even have a policy on 6 72.4 you know not to say that we have to follow anyone because I'm sure I could go to Evansville or Jamesville or ston you know all the districts that I typically do and I I can find some um sometimes you find districts that policy language aligns and that often is the case when Neola is providing vendor assistance to you with policy development and administration because they've got their base framework um that they work from um but WB can also provide examples you know as well and so but again if if the desire is to merge it we can merge no harm no foul but but your recommendation is to leave it there the way
067it is for now I I would encourage the policy committee to look into the rule structure and is that board approved rules or is that administrative guidelines and rules and if it's administrative guidelines and rules should it be reflected differently yeah in board dos perhaps okay yeah okay I guess that's that's that is a recommendation from Mr chady I support that recommendation from Mr chady I just need the board to understand I think a a greater conversation needs to happen right because if we look at Neola policies and see how they're doing them if we are we going to start shifting rules into admin gu lines so that the board necessarily shouldn't have to you know be involved in necessarily that cuz we have to follow the policy that's what policies policies give um leverage
068to give leverage to Adent guidelines so we can't be out of the policy how we do it internally is up to us um but right now it's all in to one big package and that's what's making it a little bit confusing I still I still encourage the board to to for us to have a greater discussion to determine that direction all right um and in the meantime okay we can keep these separate or put them together okay so I did share with the committee members and uh board President Johnson wb's policy coding manual that has the listing and I just I did a quick control left find on the word rule so WB has policy number 253 .1 development of administrative rules and then I quickly went and looked in board dos at our policies
069and of course we have no 253 policy that Associates with that so development of what was it administrative rules administrative rules okay okay okay so we're just going to review so review we don't need to vote on right these These are reviews so that's a that's another question I have I know it's going so while you're while you're here you're the expert again so we've got some policies that says last revised and last reviewed and some don't have last reviewed it's like it yeah they all should right yes we think they would all be reviewed what well I mean if we're if we're supposed to do them every 3 years give or take then we should review them and no either make no changes and then if we revise them they're revised right but so
070correct but if a policy okay so say a policy's developed and approved that's your adopted right date but if that policy comes up for revision and hasn't been reviewed it's not going to have a reviewed date no it's just going to have a revised date okay so that's why a policy may never have a reviewed date because reviewing is just looking at it and determining it doesn't need to be revised right and sometimes that's a Board review and sometimes that's an administrative review well this is this is an example 6724 was propos adopted November 25th 1980 when I was a kid and almost anyway last Revis March 26 2013 prior Revis dates 1991 there's this will be the first review so yes this would be the first time it was reviewed okay because it was
071developed in 80 and adopted okay and then it re was the next time it was looked at revised was 1991 yeah okay now there was a reprint in 2000 which is a whole different ball game which means a title change typos were found okay something like that something minor but we don't use reprints anymore okay okay let's move on 6725 protections and guarantees for construction Renovations uh um I I looked at the I looked at the changes and they looked odd good to me uh okay I should yeah so so the changes in the dollar values probably look Odd as to where did Administration come up with these these weird ranges yeah 16 right those ranges currently reflect the ranges that are found in the Department of Workforce development's um Administrative Code so it ties
072back to state regulations which at one point in time probably were uh the same values that we are editing and changing and in fact later in this policy um under item number four contracts exceeding 100 now sought at 148,000 I struck the as amended from time to time because I'm not sure that that's necessary and then the the following um initial part of that last paragraph the forgoing dollar limitations Etc um also struck as well okay it it appeared to me that the administrative regs at one point in time were tied to um tied to Amendment but but it doesn't look like that happens anymore so it it appeared to me that they changed almost on an annual basis like an inflationary increase and then that practice seemed to have stopped so in any case
073the the dollar values that look a bit odd why 148,000 and why not just 150,000 because the 148 actually ties to the value that's in the administrative code with the DWD currently [Applause] okay okay any discussion Mrs um Levy noted some different numbers um and I just for points um she said for number one contracts less than 10,000 for number two um 10,000 to70 um uh 75,000 so she just balanced the numbers if that makes any sense 74,000 75,000 and C to 15,000 and then for um contracts holding $150,000 ,000 or greater and so she just rolled the pretty much she rolled it down to go up and then started up to stay at a at a balance number right but Committee Member Levy didn't didn't have the knowledge or the logic of the connection
074back to the administrative code and why the numbers were presented as they were right yeah that's what I was going to say so okay um I get a a motion to rec recommend to the board recommend to the board uh policy 672 for first reading uh within changes that are made so move I'll second any discussion hearing none all those in favor say I I I motion carried two Z 672 6726 there's no recommendations so we'll just correct or did you well actually um in reading through Committee Member Levy's uh comments uh she noted kind of an oddity and I tend to agree and as I reread it I think I have a better um proposal so she notes that uh really at the end of the first sentence it reads you know the purchase
075of custodial and operational supplies to ensure the efficient operation of school plants MH well I understood what they meant by that yeah many people probably did uh Committee Member Levy suggests School sites which seems to be a little bit clearer but I think maybe we even go another step and replace School plants with District facilities because not all of our facilities are schools right so operation operation of facilities yeah I think you know just if we replace School plants with District facilities I think that that meets Committee Member Levy's desires and perhaps is a little bit even more encompassing then Mr chady is there any non-district owned facilities that this would apply to purchasing custodial non District owned facilities I I guess technically perhaps so um the district is responsible for custodial supplies at least
076during the spring when we utilize telur Park the baseball field um I don't know if that applies to hockey and the use of the Edwards ice arena or not and that's that I was getting at you know it says District right facilities yep okay um could I get a motion to move policy 6726 purchasing custodial supplies to the full board for um first reading with the change uh noted by Mr chady and and uh Mrs shop you got that right okay so moved house second any discussion hearing none all those in favor say I I I motion passed two next item 673 payment procedures um so when I read through that policy I wasn't confident that our current practice met the policy intention so I struck a couple of sections there that perhaps bring us
077more in line with our current practice in the past when I started my career in school business 12 plus years ago a good number of districts prior to the payment of checks or the issuance of checks would bring a check register listing before the board that the board would have to approve then the invoices were processed and paid and then the checks remitted that was done with paper checks because there wasn't a lot of people doing ACS at the time and it also posed challenges about various due dates of you know some invoices came with a 30-day uh due date some were less than that so just some challenges with that you know in my almost two years now in the school district of beloy the board gets notified of the expenditures but they're all
078after the fact right and I think quite honestly that's pretty much the norm throughout the state so my strikes there um were just trying to remove that question I guess uh from it we'll continue to provide you know each month we'll continue to provide the expenditure report to the board currently we're including that in the board's monthly Financial right uh report makes sense to me but I do know that some members of the public didn't know where to look for that um it's been listed in a different portion of board dos in the past that they were referenc you know so what do we want our practice to be going forward is another question uh as far as how to make that information publicly available as well well board member uh levia addressed that she
079said make sure the monthly full report you know you read it right and and it is available on FR you know on Friday and thereafter on on your your agenda item for the finance committee Andor the the full board so I think we're I think we're covered aren't we well I think we're covered I think some members of the public and former school board members are used to finding similar information in the board Library portion of board docs gotcha you know so but there's nothing there um but yet I think we're being over more transparent to be honest right in in the business finance and operations committee agenda item I agree than what had been in the past so okay yeah okay any uh any discussion additional discussion uh board member henkins or board President
080Johnson do you have any comments on that okay could I I'm good okay sorry oh you're good okay so uh I need a motion to move 673 payment procedures to the full board for first reading with the uh not changes that approved changes that um the business operations finan office have uh have put forth so moved I second any discussion hearing none all those in favor say I I I motion Carri to z Oh I sorry I hit the button uh anyway policy 674 emergency procurement and expenditure Authority um there are some changes that uh have been made on the amounts and uh a few wording changes um I'll open it up for discussion um board member henkins do you have any do you have any comments on the noted changes um i' just like
081to hear from Mr chady an explanation of the changes that would probably clarify everything for me sure so again this policy deals with emergency procurement um and expenses and really this policy is going to come into play there's probably two unique circumstances that come to my mind when this policy is going to come into play one might be a tornado a significant tornado weather event that comes through the schol school district and perhaps impacts a building two or three or if we have a fire uh significant fire at a building in either of those two instances the emergency Operation Center for the district is going to be activated and we're going to gather a team of people that are going to need to have the authority to do what they need to do to protect
082what remaining asset there is um physical property and life of staff and students so first and foremost the policy language as it states today says that it only authorizes the superintendent to be able to have this Authority I strongly suggest that we add some designes to that as well uh because the superintendent may not be available may not be reachable for whatever reason you know and then you're you're kind of hand handcuffed the also advocating that we increase the amount from 50 to $350,000 and I know that that's a $200,000 jump but I think it's really important that in the event that any of these types of situations occur that the team that you have assembled has the authority to spend up to that amount um to to mitigate continued loss uh and to protect
083the assets that we have and you know certainly we can sit here and talk about okay so we have a tornado that comes through and it's over $150,000 efforts ought to be made to reach out to the board certainly but a tornado of that size is going to impact many of the board members as well and your availability may be constrained as well we may not be able to reach you we may not be able to get the board together so you know my my logic was that $150,000 um came into being apparently in 2002 maybe even in 2013 I don't know that just seems a little bit low you know if the board's more com I I think it ought to be greater than 150 if the board's more comfortable with 250 you know
084but more importantly I I think that we have to in the event that such a situation occurs we want to control but yet we also need to trust the team that's there to do what they need to do to shore up roofing uh you know address whatever the issue is Mr Shady what's on our building what's our deductible I'm not sure what our deductible is off the top of my head great question but keep in mind so you know certainly you immediately go to insurance right yep insurance doesn't write you the check the night of the incident right and I'm following that logic right you know that they reimburse you yeah weeks and months later spend it but yet when these in instances occur we need to be able to respond to again limit our
085loss at the then and there but just as a ballpark what what are deductibles at now in buildings of that size like boy Memorial just a ballpark uh I know this doesn't have to do with if I recall correctly I think it's $75,000 per incident have you ever had to deal with FEMA and and they're kind of the same way they come through and might Grant you a loan that you got to repay or you got to go through you know in catastrophic thing like that have you ever had to deal with FEMA I I know I'm getting off track but yeah no I I did actually look at FEMA funny I this came up uh in a discussion among School business officials today um I did look at that for an issue that occurred
086in a prior district and I have had colleagues in other districts work through FEMA for such instances as well um challenging can provide some reimbursements but again those reimbursements come no months and years after the event yeah okay that's just for my own general knowledge yep thank you m Mr chady I I know uh board member Levy um put in her notes she she thinks it should remain at at 150 um I I think I would be more comfortable if we were at 250 as you alluded to I think I just I think that's kind of I'm fine with that as well okay you know uh I understand you know it's that fine balance right of to what Authority do you provide the superintendent or the designate to respond to such situations to mitigate that
087loss to start remedying it in the short term yeah you know insurance will come into play for these instances but that insurance and the reimbursement you know oh yeah a roof's gone on an Aldrich as an example because of a tornado our insurance company doesn't show up and put a new roof on the next night you know we got to somehow so yeah I know well yeah I use I use California today for an example of what yeah there's school's gone you a heartbeat snap of a finger right yep nothing's going to happen yep for a while so um I I think I'm I'm good with everything else except I think we should change it to 3 250 from 150 to 250 I on this want to defer to Mr sh um if if he's
088okay with 250 I am two 250 is better than 150 350 is better than 250 but you know more importantly I think the 150 is just a little too tight God forbid we ever have to use this policy to begin with but if we do I think we need to make sure that the individuals that are involved in attending to that situation at at that time have the authority to do what they need to do um before we have to start chasing down the board with regards to you know permission to exceed and scheduling an emergency meeting and a two-hour window and you know so okay board President Johnson do you have any comments or no okay well um I move that we um that we move this we move this policy to the full
089board for approval with the with with the only change being to uh change 350 to 250 and then I would and I would say the same thing in the next paragraph not to exceed the $250,000 amount but I'm good with all the designes and everything else does that make sense Mrs sh yes okay just a question the design is that specified somewhere I I will assign the destiny in most cases in these situations I will just say Mr chady you the Destiny for this situation if it's something else that's I would say blank is the next Destiny you wouldn't put me on that list I yes I would put you on that list Mr henkins cuz you're a part of the board well you are pretty you are pretty close you could be here soon
090off the list cuz you're on the board yes I got you will be on that list way down way down no not way now the the the other thought to that and I I didn't say anything during the conversation because also agree with the changes and I I was going to be fine with with the number there as well the in event of an emergency the board does need to understand the superintendent will act in what's the best interest of the students and the families absolutely and you know that's that's what he or she will do now we're talking about a catastrophic event but there could be other events that happened um that you know that probably won't come up to $250,000 that the superintendent typically will act in what's in best interest of the
091families and the students and then we'll come back and have those conversations at the board level I haven't seen the superintendent get in too much trouble by doing what's right for for students and families in certain um emergency situations and so um duly noted we will always try to work through a board president in the board and kind of let people know what's happening but um just want to make sure you all know that that that that will will we will continue in case of something like this does happen because we are in the district yeah so so just to share with you the the district does drill on these types of events annually this past summer was my first time being trained and able to participate in that during the drill even before we
092knew what the issue was my having knowledge of this policy we reached out to the superintendent who it wasn't Dr Garrison in the drill was somebody else for authority to exercise this policy to have that $150,000 um Authority and available to us right away not even knowing what the issue was but just being proactive and as I think it through and corre if I'm wrong Mr chady if something were to happen like this and and you are a design or you know if Dr Garrison isn't available would a let's say this happened and you need to get some work done very soon would a a contractor kind of ask do you have permission to not to say give you a check for $250 but they would want to know that you have the authority to
093okay this on the spot likely so some contractors will require a purchase order or some some sort of written commitment to them some may require a credit card number to hold um yeah it's just to have in your back pocket yep and also keep in mind you know we'll go back to the tornado situation because perhaps that's the most likely but hopefully again it never happens you know the district's wide and Broad right could could impact one two three of our facilities and perhaps some of our board members and our fam's homes if I'm at home in Fort ainson and I need to make my way to booy to help respond to something I may have issues in trying to get here myself you know perhaps Tommy bricko our director of facilities who lives nearby
094um but it may impact him too so while the design may be myself may be it may end up being somebody else too for a period of time which leads me to another question let's say it is a tornado and it wipes out three or four of our buildings does a 250 time three then or two does that not it's not to exceed 200 but a one it's a one one one Event Y just one I I would interpret it as the for that event for that event thank you one event yeah thank you suggestion just as a suggestion do you have a or an no I have a question and then do you have a list in order of who you you would so that's a great question do we have a list I
095typically look at situations a little different based off of the emergency in most of these situations i' have to work through you know the business operations and finance committee right um but as it pertains to my immediate design which is my number two which be Teresa mortech but in that case I would tell Teresa mortech to tell CH to authorize blank regardless these conversations have to start or come at some point come through the superintendent um Mr chady is not going to just arbitrarily ride away a $250,000 check without telling Dr Garrison he's going to ride away $250,000 so um it just depends on the situation now a suggestion there might be that the superintendent may want to provide that authority to the finance and administration position on the emergency Operation Center these positions change
096by Personnel daily based upon who's in District and who's out of District District in case we have to implement the EOC but so long as that position is the design yeah then whoever's in the room always has that Authority good good okay okay well I uh I need a motion to move this policy to the full board with did I already do that point of order you made the motion I made the motion and I thought Tom seconded it yeah did you did you uh did you um did I second I'm not sure did I okay I okay I any discussion hearing none all those in favor say I I I Carri two Z okay the one we've been looking for the last one uh policy 683 inventories um I I see the 10,000 is
097because of the federal guidance right yeah the feds literally probably within the last six to eight months or so increased um the value that they require um for inventory purposes from 5,000 to 10 ,000 so timing is what timing is and it since they recently increased and we're going through uh technically if you look at the uh policy number 683 it's not part of the 670 series but because we were bringing all these other Finance policies I don't want to say We snuck it in but we included it because of that change no I I I noticed that but I thought well I think it's a good it's a good idea to to to do this one right and then you know please take note of the last paragraph under the direction of the Executive
098Director of Business Services or design a complete physical inventory of all district property will be undertaken at least once every three years I've stricken that um that seems to be kind of honorous and uh there are vendors that we can contract with to come in and do that but that would be expensive too so so an inventory is never been done at bloy at the school district of bloy facilities well I can only speak to the last 20 or so months okay not in my time okay Mrs Shope do you have any history of that there there's never been one no no there's there's been inventories done okay we've had we we've had people come in and they would um in the old building they would there was a tag on the door and then
099they would come in and they'd start tag you know clicking on all the tags on all of like our computers and stuff worth value yeah I haven't done an inventory over the entire District since I've been here and again this is my second year right I think this is a very um big task for our school district how I do believe we should be doing it I know it's tricking through um I guess I guess Mr chady you know I we talked about you know this being a real hard thing to accomplish and then very costly as well M and and I'm like I said I'm dealing with a lot of different costs in general um I didn't ask you what would be a cost for something like this for the School District of Beloit
100based upon my past experiences is uh to do all of our facilities it's probably in the six figures I would say it's probably $100,000 or more and that that you know when I talk about Big Ticket big Ticket stuff because that's what I look at a lot trying to figure out where we're going to save money um some of our policies we just you know we want to do these things but we got to have the money to do them and then if I'm going to take $100,000 to count stuff versus put it in the classroom I'm I'm going choose putting in the classroom that's what I'm going to choose but then I'm out of compliance with the policy so I go back and forth on this one U Mr Nicholls you have a tough
101decision to make I I'm just not sure what the benefit of it is yeah I mean other other than theft say things a value of over 10,000 and I'm not sure how much we have that's over 10,000 well we probably have a lot of stuff over 10,000 but when we talking about 10 buildings but it it it doesn't apply to over 10,000 it applies to all distri property correct so you're talking about how many chairs are in every classroom what style of chair you know and again I go back to what is the benefit of doing it you know versus what the cost is you know the only benefit is are we losing stuff you know are assets walking out the door through theft or some other means um or from insurance purposes but our
102insurance carrier is not asking us to do this correct so from a cost I want to make sure that's brought into this conversation Mr chades thinks that it could be in easily in the six figures I don't I didn't know that cost that's why I'm asking the question now that's uh something that we need to discuss here well I I guess my my my question is well there's an inventory tag right there so um I bear with me we're talking apples and oranges but I managed a facility in California that produce millions of gallons of oil a year from big tanks to you little bottles and we inventoried once a month and we double counted it once a month and then Auditors would check it would come through once a year and do an audit
103on it so I guess the question back that M reminded me Bob does does have our Auditors never mentioned or requested inventory records uh the Auditors look at our fixed assets which are items that were originally purchased at either the five or now would be the $10,000 threshold and above okay so those items are are tracked okay um but again coming back to the policy it says all physical property all district property all so it's not tied to any dollar value in that paragraph the prior paragraph just says that an inventory shall be taken at least every two years on property purchase with federal funds with a unit value of $10,000 or more right and through our fixed asset process um with our audit firm they we track all purchases of $10,000 or more for
104goods y okay um then we got to update it when goods are removed from service and new things are brought into service yeah it's a challenge but we get through it well I'm not sure I have I have a I have a firm answer right now I just you know I again in my my career there was inventories were done all the time and uh I know it's different different business but um you know yeah I think you mentioned the word Mr shady and I you know that's you know you hate to say it things get lost and things get misplaced and things get sometimes inadvertently picked up and sometimes they're they're purposely picked up but um I would think that we would want to know you know I I'm not so sure that you
105know you want to go through and you know do every blind in the windows and some of that sort of thing but what I read is District owned Furniture equipment and materials so um you know uh I don't I don't know I Mr Mr henkins do you have thoughts yeah just a couple thoughts um you know when you talk about insurance and its replacement value is I I is what I hear in in my personal when I had insurance on my business and properties um and it was a it was a very simple thing and it's gotten easier today to go around and do videos uh and insurance companies accept that you know it's time dated it it shows you know a guy walking through a camera and and it I don't think it has
106to be as as taskful as it was at one time for the guy with a calculator walking around how many desks are in a room um so I just want to offer that in I'm not saying that it has to be done every three years but I'm I'm wondering at what of course Auditors or insurance company uh I mean I'm told by my insurance carriers if you want to get your protect yourself at your you're even in your own home you better know what's in there cuz you can't raise a flag after it burns and we were talking about catastrophic experiences today and uh so there is that the other part I want to bring up and this isn't part of this but it is um I've been a proponent of getting inventory of our
107unused or not using stuff and I know we have several buildings with a lot of equipment uh trucks food trucks what high ticket value tables and chairs all that stuff that we keep moving around and we have moved and I know I've talked to Mr chady and I've talked to Tommy and I've talked to Dr Garrison about it you know sooner or later we're going to have to downsize and get rid of that but that's a different area and I know that but I just wanted to throw that in there as long as we're talking about inventory um because it's all in the realm we need to know I think the district need you know it's good it's good knowledge yes it's expensive um but you know I if we did have this tornado or
108fire and we had to replace everything you know who's going to put the value on it I just you know I'm just throwing that out there I'm not trying to stand up and jump up and down about it but I think they're it's all good good conversation thank you yeah that's that's good point board member henkins yeah if there's you if there's an incident then I would think that the insurance compan is going to want to know numbers um for replacing replacement and replacement value Ard board President Johnson you have comments I'm wondering um Mi Mr jady how would you feel about um changing the parameters of this if so maybe instead of once every 3 years um once every 5 years for equipment or or uh supplies whatever above X dollar amounts that that
109way it would satisfy Mr henin's concern of if something does happen with the insurance then we've got a record so while you were speaking I my note right here check with Keith at trior regarding the replacement value of contents in inventory so let's check with our insurance broker if an incident occurs how do we justify you know is the insurance company going to request something first and foremost going from three to five sure but I'm not really sure that it makes sense um because especially if the intent is to identify loss of assets you don't identify it for another two years you know um you know we can we can adopt the policy without that stricken for now we can always come back to the policy Committee in the future I mean that gives us
110time to look at other districts look at WB sample policy language and see what they say you know reach out to the insurance broker um to get guidance from them talk to the Auditors even about guidance from them um and then it can come back at some point in time in the future as well but just you know putting it out there the all district property I'm pretty sure it's going to be a pretty significant expense and as the policy language is currently written we'd have to undergo that process within the next 14 months so I'm okay with leaving it but going back to review I think it's excellent that Mr K brought up that we go to those resources and see what uh WB say but more primarily what does trior say and how
111often would they want to be you know if if they're asking for not a perfect world but uh is 5 years you know I just think we need more information before we strike it but we could always bring it back and strike it so I'd like to defer on the side of caution a little bit here yeah Dr gears yes I I think a good recommendation would be that we hold this policy over until we are able to get some more um questions answered I I would suggest that we don't hold it because I think we still want to adop adopt the $10,000 increase um instead of the five but the bottom portion is still right the bottom portion I think we just leave as is leave it in the policy for now but then
112it'll have to come back if something changes and that's want that's okay okay you know and again it's about bringing policies forward to the policy committee that are timely and need you know there's a lot of logic in reviewing policies and mass you know look at all your 670s all your purchasing policies but we may be looking at all the 670s and purchasing or focusing on the finance policy but it might make perfect sense to revise a board of education policy because committees don't start at 5:30 anymore now they start at 5: but the policy says they start at 5:30 or even 6 so I just want to make sure Sor I just want to make sure that the full Bard is aware of that this may be a seesaw no you yeah I understand
113but I I think I think uh the recommendation to leave leave it leave the last paragraph on there uh and leave the 10,000 change the 5 to 10,000 and uh bring it back when you yeah find find yeah find more information out see what we what we can do or not do and what's required Michelle did you understand all that well we got to vote on it but so we're going to make the change on the 10 from 5 to 10,000 but the the last paragraph we're going to leave in okay y assum assuming that the committee votes that way okay okay so can I get a motion to move this policy um 683 to the full board uh for first reading uh with the changes noted so moved I second any discussion hearing none
114all those in favor say I I I motion carried to Z okay next meeting date will be Wednesday February the 5th at 5:30 p.m. and got I get a motion to adjourn I just want to make a brief comment I just want to thank uh Mr chady and and Dr Garrison I think uh it's very timely that you brought up WB and the number of different resources we can look to and it's very timely because we are going to stay convention in a couple weeks that maybe Brian you and I could I'm not going to be there oh uh maybe I I'll just go myself I'm just kidding uh but anyways get I can research or look somebody up to get and I'll get with Mr chady prior to and maybe get some uh Knowledge
115from them and what you know firsthand Knowledge from talking to a person there but I do appre appreciate guiding us to to use the resources at hand that we do have we don't have to reinvent the wheel all the time so I just want to say thank you to both of you good point I agree we do we do have more a lot of resources sometimes we we just don't think about so so anyway uh could I get a motion to adjourn so moved I second any discussion hearing none all those in favor say I I I we adjourned at 7:30 thank you everybody toour limit