001e e e Tom are you ready okay it is 501 I'd like to call this meeting of the teaching learning equity and people Services committee to order first of all I want I apologize for not being um online at the moment my computer does not want to connect to the network so I am working on that I will join as soon as I can get us connected um okay Miss sh can we have roll call please yes uh Megan Miller will be joining us as soon as she can Tom henkins here and Greg Schneider present so all members are present except Megan Miller who will be joining later okay thank you can I have approval of the agenda so moved I will second any discussion all in F favor please say I I I I
002motion carries can I get approval of the minutes the last meeting please so moved any disc I'll second any discussion hearing none all in favor say I I I motion carries that takes us to item 2A dual language immersion and bilingual programming audit good evening um I'm going to be kicking this off to Tony Bosco in just a second he's really been leading a lot of this work um but just wanted to frame things for you a little bit before I do that so our work with our DLI and bilingual programming has been in the district for a long time um and there's some slides that'll give us some um kind of historical reference there and then where we are at currently with populations and needs for service um but this conversation around um the
003quality of programming in our DLI programming in our schools started this time about last year um I remember coming to the board and saying that we'll be uh doing an a an audit of our programming with recommendations uh for winter to begin to inform the following school year so so the intent of tonight is just to give you an update our audit is has been underway uh we started it um in uh early fall and then um we will be coming back to the full board in February the meeting is February 4th uh to give you more of an executive summary and we'll have the researchers with us that we've been working with um that are experts in this area um so Tony is here just to give the committee uh an update where we're
004at in the work so far thank you you bet good evening um board and thank you for having us um this evening to present an update on where we are with our dual language immersion bilingual programming audit um a little additional backstory um to just complement with what Miss morch shared um we've actually wanted to undertake this process um for several years um seeing that our dual language immersion program is 10 years old uh it is a a great opportunity for us to just kind of review and reflect on where the program has come and then um really establish uh a Clear Vision for where we want to go based on an objective review um of our program to date and all the things that we have to offer so um that's really what this
005is about tonight is just kind of giving the board some background on where the audit is who our partners are and what we hope to learn as we move forward again the Dual language program in bloy is um more than 10 years old now we started in 2012 with a relatively small program and it's hard to believe that over the course of a little more than a decade we've grown it to nearly a thousand students enrolled in dual language here in the school is bloy and that's um directly related to the multilingual learner population that we have in beloy but it's not solely reflective of that population um as you can see on the slide our dual language immersion program is open to any students that are interested in learning a second language at a
006very high level so most of our um language Learners our E ESL or multilingual Learners um that's our service delivery model but it's also available to any students that are interested as I said um in becoming highly proficient at a second language namely Spanish here in the school blit by law we are required to offer statutorily um resources educational opportunities for language Learners and that's if you meet certain cell sizes for any school district that has more than 10 students at the K3 or 20 students at the fourth grade and Beyond you're legally obligated to provide bilingual Services um we do that through our dual language program we also do that um through the resources the adult resources that we have with our bers instructional coaches our bilingual teachers bilingual parent Educators um Etc the
007rationale for the audit um again this is a program that we're very proud of of when we look at the school district baloy and where we're located in Rock County there is not another District in Rock County that has a dual language immersing program there are other school districts that offer ESL services or multilingual learner services but none in Rock County offer dual language like we do and best practice shows research shows that dual language immersion is one of the top ways to develop language proficiency for students who are learning a second language in addition to offering students who want to learn um a second language an opportunity to do so at a very high level as we go through this audit process we um did some requests for proposals and we uh contacted several
008agencies that support this kind of audit work and um we ended up landing on cisa 2 who is a local partner that we have worked with over the course of many years um and they do provide these services and and we are uh it's to our benefit to have that collaborative opportunity with agency that'll give us an objective review but then also be here to support us as we move forward in our planning EnV visioning and then lastly anytime you do an audit or a review of this type it is not just about hard quantitative data um we and the schoolers of bloy talk a lot about our ability to connect with our stakeholders in very real ways and you don't do that just by sending them a survey you we have uh interviewed over
0097 five stakeholders throughout this process in just two short months and the idea that we've been able to Garner um on the ground real feedback from families and from students and from administrators teachers everybody involved with the program um that's really going to help round out what this um set of recommendations will look like when we come back uh to you in February project overview these are just some of the essential questions that we're working through that cisa 2 and ourselves kind of partnered on that we thought would give us more of a holistic view of what the program is today um where we've come from and then um of course where we'd like to go over the next uh 5 to 10 years uh project timeline as Teresa alluded to um we did start
010this work with them in October early fall and we meet with them bi-weekly and it's it um sometimes it's a little bit more just depending on if they're getting ready for site visits if there some data collection that they're working on they need some support with um but really when we look at that balance between qualitative and quantitative they do kind of an artifact review so we've sent all kinds of our curricular resources to them for them to um kind of um analyze the alignment between not only our English programming but also our Spanish programming to make sure that it's at a level of rigor that we in the school district expect and then also that it's having the outcomes that we intend for our Learners we show very um productive very good student outcomes
011for our Spanish language as students are coming out of our high school programs approaching the seal up by literacy and we're working to really develop that same kind of rigor and outcome for our English um program and for students who are learning a second language which often takes a little bit longer um when you're you may not have a strong language um native language to to start with as far as your English um other quantitative data we're also looking at Staffing and and other resources that we have in the schoolish BL um bilingual programming bilingual licensing is a hard to fill position and as we look at our resources both material resources our curriculum resources but also human resources and the people that present these programs to our students that that is an overall kind
012of perspective that we're looking to have an objective review of um as we go through this um as we look at what we've done so far H we have had site visits at just about every building in the District so far um there have been stakeholder group interviews both during the school day and in the evenings um with the staff from cisa 2 and they've done a fantastic job working with our B literacy instructional coaches our family advocates to really help aggregate those um stakeholder groups to make sure that we're able to access them and them access us um to provide the feedback that we're looking for to continue to grow this program um we have sent as I said all the curriculum um materials that we have for CA to review just to make
013sure that again it's standards based um that it's high quality and then we work with them to kind of analyze where the assessment um data shows that high quality instructional uh those high quality instructional materials are being leveraged and what opportunities there might be to uh even continue that growth further I just wanted to add with curriculum to um another uh point of Pride for us is that when we landed an American reading company those materials are both in English and Spanish so our students that are in um our classes and are receiving uh that instruction in Spanish have the same highly rated materials which is really important because when you look at dual the Dual language programs over the years sometimes there isn't curriculum that's available and they're oftentimes created inhouse and that leaves
014gaps so we were really pleased that when uh we were looking for reading materials to adopt um this one American reading company as I've mentioned many times before is highly rated on uh Ed reports a thirdparty reviewer this also came in Spanish and so some of those recommendations that were made by the state uh for highly rated materials that are grounded in The Sciences of reading are not available um in Spanish so this was also just a win for us as far as um right time right place for an adoption um because now we have both uh the materials both in Spanish and in English just remember where I'm at here um and there's a list on the on the screen of the different stakeholder group interviews that we have conducted so far um as
015a part of the audit and again we've talked to parents students administrators um teachers and we're really looking forward as we um complete this process to come back to the the board in early February with recommendations from cesa 2 and their deep dive of all of these different qualitative and quantitative uh data points to really help us as I said kind of revision or or vision for another five or 10 years um worth of um dual language immersion programming here in the district and we're really looking at that from a continuous Improvement perspective first we want the program to continue to grow and get better but we're also looking at it from a best practice perspective then also being able to maintain and sustain this program over the Long Haul and I think that's really
016why this is coming at a great time for us um at this point I'll uh entertain any questions if the board would like to ask ask any questions okay um any questions Tom thank you Mr Basco uh two things number one we talk about Spanish being the major there's also other language students in our district how are they being addressed and number two as youve spoken we've had a 10-year history M and we're talking about this year and we don't know anything until February what's our 10-year growth I haven't been on the board but I'm saying every year we we can see a progression of of of better things so you could address those two things sure so um those are great questions um so theow growth in the program as far as dual language
017just enrollment over time as we increase by grade levels to continue to grow and part of that is our elll or our Hispanic population has grown over the years but also our language learner population has grown over the years and so those two two things kind of coincide but from a data perspective we show that English that students in dual language outperform students on forward and other metrics that that are not in dual language and we also have shown at the High School level um we take something called the Apple it's a national assessment and it's the assessment in Spanish that is connected to students qualifying for What's called the Seal of biliteracy which is our Capstone so we hope that as students continue to matriculate through our dual language program when they get to
01811th and 12th grade they'll take that assessment and that will qualify them based on either being intermediate high or Advanced low for the Seal of biliteracy with some other criteria but we compared to national um data on that assessment are outperforming other school districts other students that are taking it nationally so our Spanish language program is creating a a is a rigorous opportunity where students are are developing that Spanish language proficiency and as we can see on our forward exam and some of that other data from a from a programmatic perspective those students are performing well as also does that answer your question Mr henkins yes okay and the other question about the other languages that aren't yes no thank you um we do have it fluctuates between about 14 to 16 languages spoken in
019the school district from Arabic to Russian um just many different languages and as Miss morch talked about we if your cell size for that group that particular language is less than 10 they don't get reported to the state and so we don't see those students by language that but they're included in our elll data they're they have access to our dual language program just like anybody else but the cell sizes are typically very small and in some instances um take Mong for instance we as a district do not have mung language resources in the school district and typically those numbers as I said are less than 10 so we typically will um um contract or consult with another agency to provide some of that language support that we just don't have access to in the
020district and we typically do that with um swits out of Delan and they'll help with conferencing with with educational planning those kinds of things building that relationship with the fam until we can help the students become English proficient which typically especially if they start young um happens fairly quickly that's excellent thank you you bet okay President Johnson um thank you um chairman Schneider Mr Basco I'm wondering in moving forward with this program there have been different thoughts bounced around out there and different concerns you know yeah unfortunately as a as a board member we rarely get people just calling us saying hey this is going great right but sometimes they will call and voice some concerns and and I've heard some concerns regarding our um dual language program in part because of the Staffing issue
021and understanding that this is not particular to school district of bloy but but an issue that um anyone is is trying trying trying to do such a wonderful program is facing have have you guys discussed what might be a good solution um and whether it's um having a standalone building that is dual language or um maybe maybe combining more schools in terms of the DLI program those so um as you said uh bo President Johnson the the we get all kinds ofest suggestions about what might shape the program best going into the future but that's really the point of the audit right we're hoping truly that that will help us kind of land on a place that is objective because I don't want anybody in the district to this is not tle this is really
022an outside third party doing this review for us to be as objective as possible and then what what when we come to the point where we're ready to bring recommendations there might be a recommendation like that that if we condensed into a dual language school or a magnet or something like that that might be best for the program Staffing is an incredible Challenge and we've also looked at where can we and I've been meeting with Miss amandar about how we can recruit you know in a way that's strategic and what things we can do um to recruit teachers to the schools of BL that have that lure or what we can do to recruit teachers that may not have that lure but we have the resource to help them get that licensure so I think
023there are a lot of things that we're that we're in that we've been doing and will continue to do um but that question that you had is really what we're waiting to kind of ascertain from the audit process and the reason I'm asking tonight and I understand the audit process you know that we we'll hear this again in February right but by that time we will have an established referendum question okay and if there are costs um necessary that maybe we might might want to include in sure in a referendum request will we be able to have that consideration prior to yeah January I think that that's I think that that's a great um question when we presented the um state report card data there was some things in there about recommendations so some things
024that we were connecting to was hard to fill positions like um pipelines and how we are doing recruitment efforts right those things take resources and if we're going to build pipelines and pay for people like we sometimes have bilingual par Educators that would make fabulous teachers so how are we supporting them and bridging them and giving them an opportunity to become licensed teachers so those are the types of things that we've been thinking about um I also think it's really important that we that we do do this work and we do it with diligence because we can't this isn't a knee-jerk reaction this isn't a reactive I got a phone call today we're going to you know forget the six schools that have DLI we're all just going to go to one building and the
025reason why is there's a lot of policy that's involved in that and so we have to think about when you realign schools and you move kids into schools that you're not you uh discriminating uh that you're leaving Choice um if you only have a certain number of seats how you're how you're doing that policy so there's all kinds of things to think about um and we want to mitigate the unintended consequences you know that could potentially do more harm than good and so that's why we're working with people that are experts in this they are our thought Partners um and we surfaced all of that right away when you go to interview people you're going to hear about vacancies because we know that's been a concern um so it certainly isn't an approach of ostrich
026in the sand this is an approach of eyes and ears are wide open and we're trying to learn from them and they um conducted 75 interviews with people and stakeholders to really hear about what are the challenges in this program and also what are the assets right this is a beautiful program 50/50 uh dual language immersion is something that's expanded over the state and not a lot of um districts have the seal of biliteracy as a Capstone for our their seniors so there's there's things to celebrate as well um the other piece of that I'll just add is that we do have other uh things on the agenda tonight is we have to remember the the uh Tony Bas was using the word sell it's really in the statute is the threshold when we meet
027the threshold of a population we are by law required to provide services so we have to think about how we're going going to right like you could say we're not doing this but let's just suggesting this let's just say No Deal language we'll just get rid of DLI you still have to service the students by law and so if we're not going to do it through our DLI service model then how are we going to do it and we still have to hire staff and we still have to uh find resources to do that okay so Al okay Dr Garrison thank you so I'll was piggy back on um your your question as it pertains to the referendum um you know some of this could be housed in a a much greater conversation with strategic
028planning down the road um because that that gives us that space and time to kind of plan this out a little bit better um one of the things that we of course like Mrs mortek and Mr Bosco um has has mentioned is that the process that we have to kind of follow so that we can land in a space that is consistent with um I hate to say it but opening and closing a brand new program especially if we were to move to a new building and move staff around um it'll probably feel a little different if that was wrapped into a strategic plan that'll give us time to to plan it out model it out phase it in possibly as well because there's a you know of course time frames in which we could
029actually say um first through third it be the first year second through third through fourth is the third I mean the second year there's different models in which we can kind of use to to so that we can do it so we can build this the right way for the future it's not saying it's not built currently right right now um it's just saying that we need to make sure that we're building this the right way for what booy can handle um for future um conversations especially since we all know that our um largest growing population in the city um is our latinx and Hispanic population so I know we have other things on the agenda but I did want to make sure I Shar that that space and I just want to say um
030you know the DLI program is one that that I've heard from people in other school districts around the state who have asked questions about how is it going and how are we doing this um and what are the results so I'm really looking forward to the results of the the audit um so that we can begin to share some of more information on how well we're doing to other school districts to do that um and one of the things that I've heard in some of the um Community conversations that we've had is is when they talk about someone of the strengths of of the district and it's they usually mention the DLI program as something that's really strong not just for those um who speak their first language is another language but even those whose
031first language is English and how important that is to to their development as a student as they go through the district so um I think it's a great program um I'm looking forward to the results of the audit so thank you thank you takes us to item 2B achievement Gap reduction update uh disconnect disconnect and she'll bring her okay good okay all right just switching here um so this is a um annual occurrence for us we come um in front of the committee to give an update on the achievement Gap reduction the timeline of the state is a little bit off than the schools timeline so sometimes it feels like this time of the year why are we hearing about goals now that sort of sort of thing and it just has always been shifted
032in the in the timeline in which we work with the state um but we we will then provide uh an end of the year summary um either in a Friday update to the board in a memo or um in in a presentation uh mode Kelly uh Dr gud has been uh handling a lot of the data for this work um in her time that she's been in the school district of beloy um and then uh we work together with the schools um and thinking about what are the goals that we'll have um for literacy and math achievement Gap reduction funding is restricted funding that has to be used in our elementary schools uh to support um them in their growth in grades K through three it expands in our uh K5 buildings um but specifically
033that's where that comes from um originally it came from what was called sage funding I'll date myself but it's been around for a while um and I honestly can't remember at the moment what the acronym stands for but at that time it was just strictly for reduced class sizes um and then uh over time they expanded um options for high leverage um evidence-based change so you don't have to just use reduced class sizes um and so Kelly will go through those slides uh just to show where we're at and why we use instructional coaching as our first lover of approach and then that second is to um maintain our reduced class sizes we have an update um on the class sizes for grades K through three I just want to point out often I was
034sitting uh next to board member Schneider last night in our community event and oftentimes we hear about people saying you know we need smaller class sizes and when you see this I mean honestly in our grades K through three we do have small class sizes we've maintained that um and in our four and five are even like when you compare that across the state there's opportunity to talk about you know smaller class sizes in our secondary classrooms um our current policy goes up to 30 but just to kind of put that out there that idea um and you'll see the average class sizes in grades K through three in our district we have done a good job maintaining small class size us thank you yep no problem okay um so uh we're here again to
035do what we call our fall report um as as Miss Mork mentioned the states uh deadlines especially this year are a little bit off cycle for what we tend to think about as fall um but during this report we typically report on where are we now um sort of our spring data from last year so we kind of take a look back and think about where are we coming into the school year and then we talk about where are we going so we think about what are the goals that we set for ourselves at the beginning of the year and where are we headed um I did want to mention that um we're going to be presenting tonight sort of a little differently than what we've done in the past with these AGR presentations because
036we are in between Cycles so we we're this presentation is the end of one one Grant cycle and the beginning of another Grant cycle um so we did finish our our 20 uh 2020 2025 Grant cycle and the goals were really to think about proactively planning um for the needs so doing needs assessment and then also making sure that our resources our curriculum resources were aligned to those needs and aligned to the to the state expectations and standards um we we also through that Grant cycle um focused on um instructional coaching and instructional moves to really move our instruction forward high quality learning and high quality instructional materials um and then we spent a considerable amount of time during these last five years really thinking about how can we maximize the resources that we have
037not just with AGR um but through our title funding as well so we spent some time really aligning the goals of AGR with our Essa gos so that we can uh we could create systems and structures that would allow us to really move learning forward um I was here at the very tail end of the of the previous uh AGR cycle so the one that ended in 2020 and I can tell you that those systems were not very well aligned we've done a much better job over the last 5 years of trying to bring some things into alignment and maximize the resources that we have so um as Miss morch mentioned um AGR funding is based on an old model but it is an updated model that um allows districts to choose from three strateg
038IES um one is reduced class size um the two others are tutoring one toone tutoring for students using licensed certified teachers um or instructional coaching also using um licensed teachers our district receives just under $3 million every year um through through these grants um so um the funding is allocated to schools on a per per pupil basis meaning the the six elementary schools do not receive all of the same amount um but it does bring in quite a bit of money for to support our schools and the work that we do um primarily those funds have been used to support instructional coaching um and also to um where it's possible um hire teachers to reduce class sizes and I say we're possible because in some of our buildings that's that's possible and in some of
039our buildings um through space or just you know the configuration of the building we just can't pack any any more classrooms in um these These funds are are used for um our K5 buildings they're they're designed to support K3 education and closing of achievement gaps um at during this report we always like to show our average class size um for our K3 classrooms so you can see for our youngest Learners our overall class size is about 20 to1 um this year and it ranges at Merill from about 16 to1 um up to converse where it's about 22 to1 so we're we're we stay sort of uh 20 plus or minus a few um for most of our classrooms um the district uh selects instructional coaching as our primary strategy it is not the only strategy
040that we select but it is our primary one the reason why we use instructional coaching as our primary strategy um is because coaching is a research-based practice that has shown to really help districts um Implement high quality Resources with Fidelity um we've shared this slide a few times in the past um I'm not going to go too far into the Into the Depths um but when you're thinking about change and change in schools um there are certain drivers that really can support um positive and uh positive change and growth within schools um some of them are systems and structures kinds of uh things that you put in place some of them have to do with leadership and decision-making and how we approach both Technical and adaptive kinds of um problems um but the third one
041is really about how do we build our people how do we build competency within our schools and so they call those competency drivers and um with those drivers you have to think about what are the materials that we're using how accessible are they to our teachers how how does the training that initial training so that they can access and use those materials going and then what do we do to really help them daytoday in the classroom Implement those materials with Fidelity and that where coaching comes in um DPI recently uh put out a report about coaching and the impact of coaching on the state of Wisconsin and it's it's pretty profound the reasons why coaching tends to work um is because it really leans in on supporting teachers developing credibility with their craft so they
042feel confident and they know what they're trying to do clarifying their their learning objectives and their goals for the day and also it helps because we use both individual and team coaching models it really helps our teams then come together in their plc's in their grade level teams and really think about how can we as a team Drive learning and we need our teachers to believe that they can positively impact learning that's one of the biggest um drivers of um student growth and that's one of the biggest successes of our coaching program so our coaching vision is really to provide our teachers with job embedded professional learning um in the classroom so while they're teaching we have our coaches there to help support them and we've sh again we've shared our coaching Vision in the
043past um but coaching has a strong potential um to address inequities in the classroom um with regard to Student Learning uh effective coaches build that capacity like I just talked about it helps us continuously improve and it really helps us make sure that we're implementing the high quality materials that we've purchased with Fidelity so that our students get the positive outcomes of having those materials um and using those materials in addition our coaches are not just indirect supporters of students um our coaches also provide direct support to students through intervention um and often times through subbing and other kinds of services that they provide to their school so our our coaches become a very important part of the ecosystem of their school um I'll share a little bit about our previous year's AGR goals um
044and then I'm going to show some data from this last year then we'll talk a little bit about our current goals and where we're headed um so last year when we set our goals uh we were really thinking about growing um consistent with that previous cycle of the grant um growing our students both in literacy and math and in literacy we set the goal to increase from 31% to 55% based on some benchmark scores within that eara um the eara is the independent reading of literacy right learning independent reading level assessment oh level I knew the L always gets me independent reading leveled assessment um and it's an assessment that's embedded within our Arc materials our our Core Curriculum materials um in math um we've been working on trying to get our students um to
045perform at least at the 50% threshold on a district of developed standard aligned assessment that we've been using for about 4 years now um and so again we were trying last year's goal was to get half of our students to be able to meet half of those standards that's actually it it doesn't sound like much but this is a this has been a big growth for us in in math um and our emphasis was really on supporting third grade we want to see our third graders be successful so that they can become much more independent in their mathematical skills as they move towards Upper Elementary and Middle School so I'm happy to say um that uh our our data really showed last year that we are move we continue to move in the right direction
046so you can see um that top box shows for each school at each grade level if the grade level met the literacy and the math goals um and if I could go back a couple years in this presentation you would see similar charts like this where we had a lot more red on the screen um we continue to make growth many of our classrooms are meeting um the goals that we set year-over-year and this is also starting to show now as we look at again those goals at the end of our grant cycle and we were looking from Spring to Spring to Spring we can see that each spring in both math and literacy our scores are starting to Trend upward so this is positive news we really put in place some goals that were
047grade level and standard aligned and that's mov moving us in a positive direction anything you want to add before I move no okay um so Reflection from last year um we had three schools that met both their math and literacy goals this was great notice um we have three schools that that didn't meet those goals but only missed um at one grade level in one subject and so um our schools are doing um some really tremendous work some very hard work um to help our students move to those grade level expectations um our grade level data as I said continues to Trend upward overall um again all the goals were set against grade level standards grade level expectations this is a this was our big shift in the the last fiveyear cycle previous to this
048the goals were always written on growth and if our students were performing below grade level that meant some of our goals were below grade level um our state report cards are starting to confirm we're starting to see that come out in both map and forward data data and our instructional coaching continues to to support the implementation of our high quality instructional materials now things that we're paying attention to as we move forward um third grade goals were not met in two of the six schools for literacy so we have a particular focus on again supporting those third graders as they move towards Upper Elementary um we want to maintain a sense of urgency for both math and literacy as we start this new AGR cycle we cannot take our foot off the accelerator because again
049we've moved move towards grade level expectations but we need to raise the bar and you're going to see that in our next level goals um and the acceleration and growth that we've seen typically happens um at its highest rate in the first half of the year and then slows a little bit um in the spring and so that's another thing pattern that we're paying attention to is we want to see the same amount of growth in the fall as we do in the spring okay for our current year I'm going to let Mr Bosco talk about the the literacy goals so as Dr gerud alluded to um with our adoption of Ark several years ago we've really been able to monitor more closely student achievement from a progressive um perspective rather than just looking at
050the forward which happens one time a year or some of those kinds of Assessments and so as we look at our um year-over-year growth goals that grade level Benchmark we're really looking to identify um where students end in the spring of the previous year and where we're looking for them to get the spring of the uh following year we call that an aim statement on the English side but as you can see we're looking to go from 36% um proficient on the grade level Benchmark which would be that eara in third grade at the end of last year to 41% for this year coming up one other interesting thing just to go back for a sec about the um achievement for those two third grade groups that did not meet the district Benchmark um they
051did I believe meet forward benchmarks um for those two grade levels for the 23 24 school year um at Converse in Gaston so we did have school report card um data that was um uh productive and and showed great gains um for that perspective so we're and we are overtime trying to align those systems between the forward exam um and the internal benchmarks that we have here in the school distri Belo yep and then in math for our upcoming cycle again we're we're expecting to see 5% growth per year um but this time in the number of students who are meeting 75% of that Benchmark or more so this is where I said we're raising the bar um because we have students that are performing pretty well on that Benchmark getting about half or a
052little more than half correct um it's time for us to to push a little bit harder um and and press so that so that they can be more successful so um for the upcoming year we're hoping to move from 24% to 30% of students that can um achieve 75% or more of that Benchmark across K3 um and then just we we like to talk a little bit about our Focus um as we wrap up um and so again we're going to continue to um think about that Fidelity and how our coaching can support the high quality instructional materials um making sure that we're standard and uh aligned so that students have grade level expectations um making sure that our professional learning is tightly tied um to the curriculum resources and then again continuing to to
053do the Adaptive kind of instruction individualized instruction where it's needed to support both students in their learning and teachers in their practice in the classroom all right that's it thank you okay any questions Mr henkins yes Mr Brasco if I can go back to DLI sure in the audit okay um and you said C2 doeses your audit for that have they do the do this historically so you can get a year to year to year pression or do you yeah no they'll do they'll do an analysis of growth over time within the audit process but typically you only do audits like as kind of big kind of um dips into the system so to speak um to review we do a lot of internal review of our data year-over-year um but this audit is is
054is a little more holistic as I said during the other presentation so I understand what you're after so you're looking for more year-over-year DLI data how you can see how you're progressing sure yep we have that data absolutely okay and then um going back to what we're just talking about specifically when you had the two grades or two schools that weren't up to bar and what do you what do you do to get them up to the bar what you mean I mean how do you how do you I'm just for Layman how do you get those classes up talk about the learning specifically yeah well I I think this last slide um touches on some of that we're trying to match those high quality instructional materials with best practice on the part of teachers
055and so where does that coaching model support the the Fidelity of the of the implementation of the resource um as it's designed because a lot of these resources that we use have a lot of highlevel research behind them have been vetted nationally and so I think that's one big thing and then we also are building some systems internally so that our building leadership teams instructional leadership teams are going into classrooms and observing practice giving teachers and feedback on that practice and then using that as another um opportunity as Dr Garrison likes to say about continually improving that implementation that Fidelity um approach to uh implementation of those curricular resources the only thing I was going to add thank you Tony is that when you look at um high quality professional Learning and Development some of
056the indicators of that and I and I remember I used it on a different slide deck that we presented at that um we have in place is that embedded professional learning so kind of an Antiquated practice would be what we call episodic per PD a teacher goes to something one time and they sit there for 45 minutes and it's a get and then the application to that is is very minimal right transferring that to the classroom less than 5% that's right so when you have coaching it helps to move that and then even more so now you've gone to a training let's say on American reading company materials you've been doing your training on your act 20 foundational skills through Cox campus this school year now we're scheduling learning walks for literacy that involve the
057coach and the principal the directors myself and we observe classrooms based on indicated uh like walkthrough tools um and then we're reflecting on that and and what we saw and what we didn't see and where we can go from there ultimately we're building capacity with that because what we want is the schools to be running those all on their own independently right and they we want and we're also moving into this year inviting teachers on those learning walks so that the teachers can get inside each other's classrooms which doesn't happen enough in school districts generally and I think I shared this at a different presentation uh that in one of our schools um the teacher had said I have worked in this district for almost like 20 years or 18 years and have never been
058in a walkthr where I visited another teacher's classroom we don't want that right we want teachers learning from each other and so that's the other piece of this work excellent excellent thank you I and as a Layman the quicker that the people know you know where their classes are they can react to it and uh get it situated to the right thing so excellent work thank you okay any other questions President Johnson Dr grood on slide six the one that says why choose coaching where was that information from is that part of that DPI study you had mentioned uh no um these yeah these actually these these come the the table actually comes from um John Hattie's research work so those are the numbers that you're seeing there um through a a resource called visible
059learning the other side actually comes from a resource on implementation science which is about um really implementing resources within schools and and promoting positive change okay awesome could you send that information to the board members as well as the um DPI study that you had referenced and I'm curious then what um what data do we have specific to the school district of booy for our coaching program so um we have some uh data on the um coaching Cycles we want to be careful about the data that we collect through coaching Cycles because coaching is is not an evaluative process and we don't want our teachers feeling evaluated so we do keep a lot of that information confidential we do have some information about which uh teachers have participated in in um in particular I can
060talk speak about math in in coaching in math um and then we do a look year-over-year at at um how their classrooms are doing can I say that there's a um super profound effect like I I I noticed there's a doubling or tripling of outcomes I can't say that but I do know that the teachers who have been participating year-over-year do see incremental growth okay thank you and then oh oh on slide 10 I think it was uh board president I was going to also add you know the idea that we look at um achievement holistically from a district perspective and when we look at um our forward our student achievement data I think that's owned by everybody in the district right the the amount of growth that we have made made um on student
061achievement just over the last 3 4 years is really kind of uh an accumulation of the efforts of many people and cultes are are right at the ground level um working on that so I just wanted to make that point I I I guess I'm just wondering if there is a better way to um have a more specific metric to to understand if this is effective and that's something that we can discuss at a later time it's just something that I think might be useful I I think what the state would say because we have to get this approved by the state is that they're setting aside funds for us to make change in our schools and we have three options to pick from that the state is saying one of those being coaching so
062they're valuing coaching because they know the research and effective coaching we're presenting back to them and over time we've demonstrated that we're meeting the AGR goals that we've set with de pi and so that would be a link where we could say the high leverage or high lever that we've picked for changes coaching um so it's hard to make one direct correlation right is it the materials is it the teacher is it the coaching is it the principal is it the engagement of the students there's all of these nuances so it's hard to make direct correlations but this is pulled from John Hattie's uh meta analysis of effect sizes and so when you look at these at the bottom in research as you know many of you at the bench know anything over a 04
063is considered a larger effect size Collective efficacy has a significant effect size when you look at it that's what a 1.5 is so we're just Gathering kind of all of this this evidence-based research and pulling it together correct I completely understand that and again I'd like to see something specific for the school district of Bel my my next question is on slide 10 looking at the scores for the kindergarteners and the second graders they seem to be outperforming our first and third graders any um Insight on why that may be sure uh I can speak for math I'll let you speak for literacy um I mean I can I can speak very clearly for kindergarten a lot of our our students um when they come to kindergarten are actually well prepared for that first assessment
064um the the standards for kindergarten are are set you know around Counting to 20 um adding and subtracting within 20 they're pretty good at that kind of stuff when they come in it gets harder for them when they start adding and subtracting double- digit numbers and having to regroup and stuff and that's what we start to see in second and third grade I would in you know the kindergarten first grade entering school and learning you know the the language of school and those kinds of things I think that um and then our staff learning getting to know their students and what exactly we need to address in terms of what they're coming to school prepared to do from A literacy perspective um the more we we spend time with students and understand their and and
065M morch alluded to to it how we can dig into their um really minute literacy skill needs based on some of these assessments that we're doing really will help that growth take off over the course of several years and so it's not surprising to see that um in second and third grade be a little different than kindergarten first on the literacy side either uh Dr Garrison so one of the things when we thinking about like growth and growth and over time I I always like to say this you know kids come to us you know four years old and you know then all of a sudden they turn five and we want to see growth happen in that year and then of course they turn six we want to see growth happen in that year
066and so that year-over-year growth is something that we um are are still going to be focused on here in the school district which is a I know I know it wasn't a point that was directly stated but it's something I want to make sure that we are you know mindful of I think sometimes we we also know that even after um school is over our students are still learning right and that's another point that we want to bring into attention of of all you know that that here is this conversation you know the achievement got reduction um you know I always feel like there's a space where we get CAU in a low where there's growth happening then it's like you don't feel like the kids are growing as fast as we want them to
067grow and so we still want to you know see that um accelerate growth over time and and that's something that's really important to me and of course I know it's important to the to the staff as well so thank you all for your report and I'll turn back over to Mr um Steiner uh again thank you for your report and and I like the fact that we're using benchmarks that are separate from what DPI uses so that we have consistant data over over time um where the levels aren't changing at so we can get some accurate growth on it so um good work I keep it up and we'll go forward okay that takes us to item 2 c new course proposals we're going to do this fast okay I'll just speak while we're switching
068over um so this will be our first lap um and in our typical Cadence we'll come back and then ask for that evening to go to the Cent agenda next month um and so we have uh Jeff and Kelly here um with Betsy these are some bla course proposals um bla is on a little bit of a different schedule for selecting courses so these are for term four um however they've done a lot of back work with uh the teacher uh in preparation so they'll do the proposal and then we'll come back again for the recommendation for consent thank you and I know we're running out of time so we're going to do this quickly um we we are here to kind of talk about two courses um and we're going to we're going to
069share the part A's and the part B's the course proposals are Part B part A for this one and Part B for the next one so um uh the two courses uh the first course is electricity and magnetism um this is a course that bla would like to start offering um they've offered a different course in the past that's sort of similar um but this course would actually uh move us to align the curriculum more tightly with what the high school uh down the street bmhs offers as well um and use move to using a highquality instructional resource called open sight ad which is an open educational resource um so the first part of this course the um would would really focus on how can we design reliable uh electrical systems um that communities need
070for their energy needs and so it really takes students um through a process of thinking about energy transfer what are reliable sources how do you scale how do you think about engineering trade-offs and all of those kinds of things and then you can see the variety of standards that are included here include physical science um engineering and tex standards um uh throughout the unit or throughout the this particular course the second part of the course expands um and uses a different part of the open side curriculum from their physics um component to really think about how do we use radiation within our lives um and so it talks a little bit more or it goes into a little bit more some learning about wave behavior um uh wave and Photon models for electromagnetic radiation um
071and then how to really evaluate um em radiation to think about uh the radiation that we have in our lives like 5G right um technology so thinking about uh technology safety for humans and again it touches on physical science um standards at the high school level um and then some um uh some some additional standards as supporting our second course is forensic science this first part of the course is actually already offered um through bla um the forensic science course uses a cons uh computer simulation model where students are actually um taken into a historical crime scene and they're actually trying to solve a Cold Case um so they they get real um sort of evidence and they they have to go through the process of trying to draw conclusion about the evidence that they
072have so in the first part of the the the course they really think about um mapping thinking about um the history and then they do um forensic science around uh uh fingerprinting um blood typing and looking at DNA fragments um and then they they do some research as well and again um tied to the engineering and and Tech standards from from ngss in the second part of the course the part of the course that is being um proposed now um the bla would like to take this course a little bit further to go deeper with some of that analysis and so they'd like to focus on um some measurement um uh practices for students really thinking about physical evidence and and microscopic evidence in a way that they haven't been able to before and thinking
073about patterns which is one of the crosscutting um Concepts in the ngss standards and then they compile all of that evidence um to determine who Prime Suspect would be within this case all right so those are the two courses anything you want to add so again just to clarify um forensic science a is a class we already have so the proposal that we're asking for new is forensic science Part B or part two the electricity and magnetism we're already foreshadowing we're asking for approval for um or recommendation for the electricity magnetism part one part two will be coming down the future for that that's it um any questions Mr henkins what's the participation in these programs let you answer that we always have at least 20 or more students who are interested in these classes
074so F okay Dr Garrison well anytime the students well I say students and staff bring courses to the conversation I think it's very important that you know we recognize the work that that happened behind the scenes and so thank you to the work that happened behind the scenes I know that this is our first time hearing as a as a committee and we'll bring this information back um for a vote at the next conversation and so in between time I always say there may be questions that may pop up in your in your brain over the holiday season and if you have those thoughts um please feel free to share those with um the team members that are here or myself great thank you for the proposals I think they're both exciting I like the
075electricity and magnetism as we look at energy transmission as we start looking at alternative energies it's going to be changed the way that and and a lot of what you're talking about in this course fits directly into that career field um and forensic science is is fun something that it's fun um but very definitely critical thinking skills are very highly needed necessary for that um so thank you for the presentation we look forward to hearing him again next month thank you than you that takes us to item 2D our next meeting date discussion I know in January the the traditional meeting date is the 3 Tuesday but that's also the first date of the uh the State School Board conference um at which point I will I will be at that conference on that date
076are um Mr henen are you planning on attending the conference or yes I was Sir okay um so could we move the meeting up a week I would be very willing to do that okay okay and that I think would work right okay so we will do that so um our next meeting date will then be um a week earlier let me January 14 it be January 14th at 5:00 so our next meeting tentatively will be on January 14th um is there a motion to adjourn so moved I second any discussion all in favor say I I I we are adjourned at 6:03 hey [Applause] can I how are you thank you so Tom yes e good evening every everyone I would like to call to order at 606 the Tuesday December 17th regular board
077meeting M may I get a roll call please yes uh Megan Miller I think she's still is supposed to be joining us Tom henkins here uh Brian Anderson is only to be here this evening Brian Nichols here Amy ly here and Greg Schneider present and tia Johnson here all board members are present then except uh Brian Anderson and Megan Miller will be joining later thank you can I get an approval of the agenda so moved so moved second motion by Brian Nicholls seconded by Tom henkins any discussion hearing none all in favor I I I I any oppose motion carries unanimously tonight we have the privilege of having principal leam lot and assistant principal Benji clet from Converse Elementary to introduce tonight's leaders for the Pledge of Allegiance all right we brought two of the
078nicest fourth graders in all of boo Wisconsin so they are spectacular students and just wonderful human beings we have Elijah and we have Vincent and they are from Converse School Elijah do you want to say what your favorite thing about school is my favorite thing about school is that we get to have all the fun with the teachers okay and Vincent what is your favorite thing about school my favorite thing about school is everything everything all right all right okay and these two young men are going to lead us in the pledge tonight okay go ahead I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all job nice job good job you thank you
079so much [Applause] next agenda item is the board president report thank you everyone for being here tonight during this most wonderful time of year you know it you know it since our last regular board meeting the district has held two referendum listening sessions one on Saturday September December 7th at the Colac Center and another last night at the boo Public Library both were well attended by community members and staff we appreciate the continued discussion and feedback regarding referendum questions the needs of the district and the prioritization of these budgetary items Dr arheart has compiled the evaluation of these sessions and of the first session and it is um in this packet that he has left on your desk blit can be proud of the people that care enough about our schools to take time during
080this busy season to contribute to making this a better district for all in terms of what will be reflective in reflected as our priorities in this referendum thank you everyone we all really appreciate your time and dedication last Wednesday board member Miller reached out to me to to disc discuss a conversation she had with a Community member who is also a member of the ad hoc committee They concluded that presenting the public and staff with a more unified unified vision of the district's direction would be beneficial as we develop referendum messaging and long-term District planning the original draft by Miss Miller was sent to the board 5 days ago on December 12th at at the time of agenda agenda posting I had not received any responses if this is to be a unified Collective statement
081I want to ensure each board member has had ample time to reflect on and contribute to this board resolution please take time over the next couple weeks to do so send your suggestions thoughts and edits to the board secretary Michelle schop by Monday December 30th so she may compile the board's suggestions a Time permitting it may be an action item then for the next regular board meeting yesterday evening board Clerk henkins and I attended the governor governor iver's virtual budget listening session several people across the state attended to voice their concerns and desires for consideration in the next budget many of these were school district and child oriented some requests were to have statewide free breakfasts in public schools improve the daycare and and Early Child Care system and provide n provide an increase to
082cover 90% of special education costs I'd like to give a shout out to our awesome music departments who have been working hard this time of year there have been many and yet a few more wonderful music performances yet this week in our schools our staff and students have been working hard and these efforts are obvious when you attend any of these wonderful music performances we are very appreciative of the staff students and family that make this possible in closing stories of tragedy cut deep in our hearts and tear at the fiber that bonds family and Community one of those stories unfolded in our neighborhood yesterday in Madison at the Abundant Life Christian School at times like this we must remember that there are other stories we must not forget stories of love and faith and
083mercy and goodness remembering and telling these stories help us to heal help us to go to bed with hope and help us to wake tomorrow with promise that concludes the president's report Mr henkins upcoming events and announcements thank you very much board president johnon good evening the Board of Education wants to thank everyone who has attended the past two referendum sessions held on Saturday December 7th and again last night Monday December 16th we appreciate your participation participation and feedback future board meeting dates include tomorrow night Wednesday December 18th at 5:30 p.m. for policy committee Tuesday January 7th will be the business operations and finance as well as our regular board meeting watch for other dates to be announced on board docs as a board will likely be meeting as well on January 9th and 14th
084due to the following week being the State education convention we wish to thank everyone a joyous and happy holiday season we will see all of you back in jry January 2020 2 thank you and this ends tonight's announcements thank you Mr henkins next we have recognition um Dr Garrison and Mr Sten Rus so I'm turn over Mr Sten Rus um um he will be presenting our recognition for today thank you thank Dr garon um yeah I looking at the green L sorry thank you board thank you Dr Garrison um again I'm just and director of Career Tech Ed and alternative education and it gives me great pleasure to introduce um and recognize our Automotive instructor Mr guy olon guy started in the fall of 2022 so just a few years ago after a school year
085where we did not have a teacher in the automotive program save for a couple of courses that Blackhawk Tech helped us out with and that also came the year after covid so we essentially had a program that was little to nothing um guy is building the program up this is his first group level three students um that he's had and he's continually adjusting U monitoring the program looking for improvements um I he asked her a lot of feedback how do we work with this what do I need to do he is the automotive expert I just try to help support him um guy is a uh ASC Master Automotive technician along with several other ASC certifications we currently have one of 12 ASC Certified high school programs in the state of Wisconsin there are only
08612 in the state of Wisconsin guy and I have have worked from the summer through the fall and currently just finishing up our renewal of a 5-year ASC accreditation so we can continue to move forward with that so he has provided um lots of information updated his curriculum um provided some guidance and information about the AC certification process his program is a simulated site-based program which is a DPI recognition when you see our state report card and it talks about work-based learning that qualifies as a work-based learning opportunity because guy runs his shop except for his entry-level classes um as a working shop just last week they worked on my truck they worked in change the oil rotated tires inspected the brakes guy has the students meet the customer take down the information write out
087the service order do the work guy obviously inspects it at least I hope he does um inspects it and then um you know the students take care of the rest of the pieces with it so it truly is run like a shop calling the parts store making sure they order the pieces that are there so he runs it like an operating shop his um goal is about 8020 80% in the shop 20% in the classroom he wants the students doing and if you go up there you will see students doing um guy has also created a number of Partnerships that we didn't have in the past connecting with technical colleges in Illinois and Ohio um connections to the military as he has a military background the parts industry we have uh somebody from Napa who
088sits on our Advisory Board we have an Advisory Board um that we do twice a year with that and also expanding to cre Trucking a diesel program last year we he secured a uh semi day cab that was brought to our program to introduce diesel mechanics into the program so guy is continuing to go ahead and move things forward and perhaps the biggest thing that I knew when I helped sit on the interview with guy I asked him the question Off Script he was at a technical college before why do you want to come from a technical college to a high school program and his answer was profound and simple he says because when I tell a student I want them to go get a Phillips screwdriver and they have to ask me is that
089the Plus or the minus and they don't know we need to get to students earlier I knew guy was a person I wanted for our programs perhaps the strongest piece of evidence and testimony to where guy is at is over the four years prior to our school program I found 14 students or 14 ASC certifications that had been earned over a 4-year period this year alone September October November and December guys had 16 ASC certifications earned and eight nc3 certifications earned so 24 certifications earned to this point he's going to have students take all eight of the ASC certifications that are offered for the high school level that is a very rare thing that happens in any high school program um he may have maybe one of the first that students earn all eight certifications
090in ASC program um certification so that is a testimony to the program that guy has built and developed in a short order and again I'm looking for bigger and better things from him and so um I'm not sure we can get too much better but we can get bigger guy so I want to read this to you certificate of appreciation this certificate is presented to guy Olsen and recognition of his remarkable success as an educator outstanding contributions to the bmhs automotive program dedication dedication in building meaningful relationships with students and his leadership in guiding students to earn increasing numbers of certifications to become career ready guy Olson I'd like to present you with this award of certification our appreciation thank [Applause] you God um when I first met Mr Olsen um I walked into the
091shop and he he said welcome Dr Garrison of course and you know of course the kids were I work already and he doesn't remember this maybe but I do and and and I was just amazed that the kids were doing the jobs that they were set out to do and iy was just able just to have a conversation with me as I knew the kids were doing the job that they set out to do I think at the time they were tearing off a a front bumper or something to that nature um I later had additional conversations with you know the team and guy's not the one for um um I shouldn't say not the one for many words but um he he silently does what he's supposed to do without ask asking for recognition
092and that is a very unique um qualification that I think um goes without saying it so again I just want to say thank you um Mr Olsen for all the work that you've done for the school district of bloy you don't have to say much you don't have to say anything but I just want to make sure you know that from the bottom my heart thank you for taking so many of our students through many ASC certifications I mean that's it's hard enough to get one or two right maybe even three but your students have gone above and beyond what your lead ship there and so again thank you thank you Dr Garrison Mr stenus and thank you so much for what you do for our students we really appreciate everything you're doing Miss sh
093are there any public comments tonight yes I have one email and three public comments here in the room thank you let's get started with the p the ones here in the room okay and while you're getting that ready I will read the norms for public comments during board meetings members of the public are welcome to attend all open meetings of the Board of Education individuals attending board meetings are expected to conduct themselves in a respectful and courteous manner that models appropriate behavior for our students individuals wishing to comment are expected to comply with the Norms found on the back of your comment cards and in board policy 187 public participation at board meetings we ask that each of you contribute to maintaining a respectful and orderly meeting and prevent discussing confidential matters in a public
094form by these by following these norms for public comments during board meetings thank you for your participation and courtesy M our first speaker is Juan good evening Juan Romero parent of a student here in the the district the meeting last night at the library there were some really good ideas that came about and I truly hope that the board will listen and work to implement some of the things that I brought up or the things that got brought up not just by myself of everything that was said there are a few things that struck me out struck out to me as a constant theme as we all know the tragedy at the Abundant Life Christian school yesterday in Madison my prayers go out to all the victims families and communities that were involved it's very
095very it hits hard incidents like these make me as a question parent as a makes me as a parent question if we are really doing enough uh fear is real and it's a real huge barrier in in learning fear from the parents sending their kids to school school can really and will hinder student achievement once a child senses that fear from the parents they also will have the fear of going to school and how can someone learn with fear of personal safety looming over your head and your mind schools are supposed to be the safe place within the first few weeks of this school year here here in booy we had concerning incidents occur my wife and I talked about it and she was she was in contact with the district she brought up the
096question of bringing metal detectors to assist with the safety in schools my wife was informed that the cost was a concern and it was taking too long to to get the kids into classrooms on top of not having sufficient Staffing to man The detectors we need to continue to explore this safety measure possibly applying for Grants to cover a cost is an option at last last night's meeting our group came up with a few other options that would help tighten up security and help promote a Better Learning environment for our kids to learn would would I would implore the board to take all the suggestions from the public and put them on a higher list than they already might currently be to that regard I would also implore to the board to please be very
097cautious of what we do with the SRO program as I feel it is an important part of these issues as well currently if this can happen in Madison and other schools it can happen here too we're not the Exception by not being as proactive as we can be now with trying to find more ways to keep our students safe we are cutting corners and putting our students and teachers at risk please do not sweep this issue under the rug please prioritize the student safety and nothing is more important than that to all of us this is this is a wake up call for everybody this must be a priority we have to start improving now we have to start caring about student safety today I want the board to reexamine more sros metal detectors student
098IDs Etc enforce the rules that require the students to wear their IDs on the lanyard at all times as well as enforcing the current code of conduct yesterday's meeting involving involving public interaction not just the public comments like here today it was a good thing and we really need to have more of them more often and more regularly just remember the public is attending these meetings and the public wants to know that you are Representatives that you care and you're listening please make school safety your top priority thank you thank you Mich next we have pra okay good evening um I'm here to just mention to bring uh um the mention about discipline you know the community has been uh concerned about this for quite some time and and we still are concerned about it
099um especially things that happen like a Madison um so what I would like to mention is that in the classroom you know the discipline starts can it really starts often times in a young age in the elementary school so often times you see certain students that move from grade level to grade level and they're still having problems often times those problems are because it stems from home there's and children when they when they're having discipline issues it's they're usually reaching out so there's signs that that you know that are happening in that classroom and it over time it can often escalate if some of that those issues that that child is having you know isn't addressed so I I'm just here to encourage the board to um to um I'm sorry I didn't hear that
100but oh okay I'm just here to encourage the board to be aware of that um to really keep an eye on that discipline code to encourage the teachers to look out for those childrens that are having discipline issues in their classrooms and see if there isn't something that can be addressed they get some kind of um counseling or support where they can express their reasons why they're they're acting out um it's important for all students not only the child that's having a problem but sometimes those little problems can be solved if if if they're addressed early on or reach out into the community and see if there's uh agencies in the community that could help support that child and give that child some whatever that person needs um it'll make the environment in the classroom
101um more productive it'll make the children that are in that classroom feel safer to come to school because it's very intimidating if you're a child that has not grown up in an a family that has a lot of discipline issues um or a lot of like yelling in in a household and then they're in environment where some of these things are happening in the classroom it's very scary for a child in the elementary level to experience that it doesn't make them feel safe or are comfortable so be aware of that um so I would like the other thing too is I would like the board to be able to communicate to the community a little bit more and what things are being done to help improve the learning environment in the classrooms um I think
102that communication be very very important um you know I often think of a time and experience that I was in court and the bayf would not allow any talking in the courtroom because he said the judge cannot think and so if somebody's um you know causing um any kind of noise not even really disruption but they're asked to not be there so that everybody can hear the judge can think and and a good environment can be there for a proper whatever is going to happen in that room and I I think gee if we could only do that in a classroom to have the children paying attention that teacher could be able to think and not worry about what's going on so I just encourage that and also um remember you've got the phone system
103that you can communicate to your parents and I encourage you to use the phone system more to get those get the messages out to the parents of what's going on in the meetings that are coming up and encourage them to have that communication with you okay thank you so much thank you Michelle next I have Susan I am Susan Adams from beloy I want to make it clear that I'm speaking for myself not for any other group as a higher education administrator with a PhD and higher ed was this on yeah um I have had many leadership experiences tonight I know that you were discussing hiring a board consultant and yet I know the board district has financial difficulties and I know that Dr kimart has been un teering work for free for 2 months
104as a consultant that sounds like a very nice offer but I understand that he is receiving mileage some meals and office space just to name a few so there have been expenses how often has he met with the board I don't see that he's met with the board more than once but I'm not sure I would have thought that in two three months he would have met more often I don't know why that is um in your discussion about hiring a Consultants I hope you will be answering one how much Dr aart has received in benefits so far two what is his role from the list of activities that he's got in his PowerPoint it seems to be much more than coaching which could be very problematic uh three why have you not even met
105with the consultant from Wisconsin Association of school boards which is supposed to be free in actuality please consider these points in your discussion thank you thank you unfortunately the workshop we were planning on having was mis posted so we could not hold that thank you Michel um next I just have the email that was it for the in the room good evening members of the school board superintendent and Community I come before you as a private citizen and member of this community to address a deeply concerning issue regarding the conduct of our elected School Board president during the last board meeting Madame President you used your platform to deliver what was labeled a president's report yet the report itself did not highlight what you have accomplished for the district the community initiatives you've attended or
106any actionable outcomes tied to your leadership role instead you delivered what could only be described as a presidential address specifically targeting a private citizen not only did you misuse your authority to address an individual because you have their personal contact information both cell phone and email this is unacceptable your actions stand in start contradiction to the disclaimer you read at the beginning of the public comment session a disclaimer that explicitly States the school board will not address or engage with public comments during the meeting and yet that is exactly what you did you chose to leverage your elected position and platform to address a private citizen in a public forum in addition to your fellow board member Mrs Levy's use of the word gatekeeping at the table talk by the way you did not give
107the full context of how she used the the word in your presidential report but yet you talk about the private citizen misleading the public what makes this even more troubling is that you attend NAACP meetings on the first Thursday of every month with this private citizen of which both of you are members if you had a personal concern or disagreement why not raise it there within the context of the shared organization and its Community Center Mission you quote Dr M Martin Luther King Jr in your presidential report that would have been the appropriate platform not here in Your Capacity as the president of the school board to make matters worse you identified yourself not only as the school board president in your comments but chose to highlight your racial identity as half black and half
108white this introduction felt irrelevant and performative especially in the context of addressing a social media post you repeatedly claim to have no affiliation with or acknowledge or knowledge of what's truly mind-blowing is the double standard at play here if the former Schoolboard president Sean Levy or the parliamentarian Amy Levy had had used their position and identified themselves as fully black and addressed the public in such a manner the very page you claim no association with would have undoubtedly labeled their conduct as unprofessional and Unbecoming of their positions yet one of the administrators of that same page was present during your comments on December 3rd 2024 and not a single post has called out your conduct Madame President your misuse of power and authority to address an issue you claim you don't even read or affiliate
109with is an abuse of your position as you as an elected official Your Role is to model the behavior you expect from others board members staff students and the superintendent included if your actions are any reflection of what you deem acceptable leadership then I suggest you re-evaluate the standards you hold for the district finally I must ask is your behavior reflective of the privilege afforded to the white side of your identity that you referenced in your comments leadership is not a stage for self serving theatrics it is responsibility to uplift thank you Michelle we're we're at time would you please forward that to me so that I can respond appropriately and correct the misstatements there yep thank you next up we have have our student board report anahi AR Rojo is our student board rep
110and tonight she is going to highlight the current events and news from the high school and District as well as bring forth any student concerns anahi hello um so for my December report I will start off with my perspective um I truly feel that we as a school uh speaking of Belo Memorial have shown a lot of progress since the start of the school year uh from my knowledge uh when I wrote this report um I have not had any students reach out or share a concern they had regarding our school um next I would like to move on to student and staff highlights so um student named Lauren she um a staff member wrote She overcame her nervousness and she introduced the assembly in front of the whole school with confidence and Grace next
111we have the staff highlight which is uh Miss Nicole Carroll uh this staff member wrote she comes in super early and is one of the first people in the building making sure our school is covered students and staff come to her for support all the time she does so much that goes unnoticed so I would like to take a second to recognize her next um I have program highlight which I'm really excited about um there's a program going to be starting called we're here uh which is a peer support group um our previous uh student board uh representative Connie um she this was all her idea and I was very honored to be asked to direct the program which is coming to life and finishing up the last details with Miss pels so so excited
112for that and um can't wait to get it started next month next I have sport Rec recognition so for this month I covered the girls basketball program which I had the honor of speaking to coach Delana Johnson about um so I had asked her five questions and I'll read them off how do you feel about the season so far she says I feel motivated and ready to take care of Unfinished Business uh the next question was what are you most excited about she said I am most excited about having a senior Le team player-led teams find the most success so I'm excited to see my leaders lead this year her hopes and I asked her what her hopes were for the season she said I pray for an injury-free season and for the program to
113get better every day the next question was what motivates you to be a coach she said the youth motivate me to be a coach helping young people reach their goals brings me true peace working for them is one of the greatest careers any human can aspire to have and I asked her if she had any other comments and she said let's go purple kns we are one and last but not least I have um two great opportunities that I would like to highlight that are happening so this Saturday December 21st there will be a HBCU experience in college fair at the boys and girls club from 11: to 3:30 p.m. which I think is a really great opportunity and encourage everyone to attend um next the second opportunity is the tickets for the Martin Luther
114King Jr uh commemorative sorry I know I'm butchering that breakfast um the tickets are now available for that they are $30 each or you can sponsor a table with eight seats for more informations please contact Miss Regina hendris um the breakfast I've attended twice and they have been really amazing so definit encourage the community to get involved with that and that is it for my report thank you an next we have the superintendent report tonight Dr Garrison is providing an update on the BL Memorial Hall of Fame yes and so before I get started with that I want to say first um we know that the tragedy um that happened at the Abundant Life Christian um school um did affect a lot of our our staff members and of course uh families um and I
115would be remiss if we um also didn't um if you wouldn't mind take a moment of silence for those families um um thank you um I would also like to wish everyone a happy holidays um in this season um students families teachers staff Administration board members of members of the community and the purple Knight family throughout the district um happy holiday happy holidays of course during this season I hope everyone has a wonderful break which starts next week not this week yet um on Monday December the 23rd um through January the 6th um for students and staff um we will of course see the students see the staff back on January the 3D um I did have one additional um announcement I wanted to make before I jump into the Hall of Fame the Jazz
116Band um is going to be participating um in our at the WB State Convention um that's a huge honor many districts apply to perform um and they will be performing at our um at the Wisconsin State Convention January the 23rd and so I just want to make sure I brought that recognition to the to the to the community I know that I kind of mentioned it before it's official now because they also have sent us a generous check of of about $500 to support um getting our students there um the wasow did do that and so I want to thank um um the wasow for sending that that that check additionally they have been um asked to open for U wind marcelis I just got this information yesterday open for wh marcelis at the um
117I want to get this right um at the at the sorry guys give me a second Lincoln Lincoln Center Orchestra um at the Overture Center in Madison okay on Wednesday January the 29th January 29th so that just came to me and I wanted to make sure I kind of share that information with the the community at large so I was asked to have a conversation in regards to the Hall of Fame and so I wanted to kind of give a like a brief overview of kind of what that is here in our school district um the FR fren um helped start the Hall of Fame many many years ago the idea of the idea was actually branched out of the Multicultural Committee in 1991 um as a committee they wanted to identify and recognize former
118bort Memorial students who served as models of achievement and have have made a significant have made significant contributions in their career and communities it was decided that they would honor a bmhs graduate each spring with an all School induction assembly with a picture plaque which would um permanently be place in the school's hallway um of fame um the first Hall of Fame and recognition was May back in 1994 and so there of course have been many of these opportunities in the district we did pause this opportunity at at Co okay as I understand it um when I when I was here be honest with you I didn't know about the hall of fame um but that was something that was paused um upon my arrival um so for over six years that that has been
119paused um here in the district I think it stopped in 19 sorry not 19 2019 um and so that's been a couple of um opportunities in which we have not had that here in the school district um the Hall of Fame was established um with the purpose again of identifying graduates oforal high school who have made significant contributions um of course they serve as role models of of achievement for our um current student body and again that plaque recognition was something that was done every um spring nominations had to be put forth in December um with the deadline being December 15th I'm just this is the background information that I I wanted to make sure I went back and kind of did some history around it um that that that information was then shared with
120our alumni um alumni service team we don't have an alumni service team currently in the school district um but they they oversaw um those recognitions in the in into the Hall of Fame um once accepted of course we had the the the we have the um ceremony Ator high school at a selected time in the spring um the candidates must have of course have graduated from the high school be a member of the class that has been be a member of a class that has been graduated um for at least 10 years must have distinguished himself or herself in his uh his or her chosen field in and another area or in in a different area how can I say this let me slow down they must have distinguished him and herself in a chosen
121field and in in an in an in and another area I I'm messed up direct there y'all so in an area in which they of course um choose must reflect honor um to the bmss um through his or her personal or professional activities must show excellence and contribution of time talents and the likely hood of that and the benefit of to our community such as through volunteer work advancement and their profession and advancement in their profession and so with that being said that's just a general snapshot of kind of what the program was we will want to start that back up here in the school district of booy we had had conversations about this um a little bit in November as it was kind of brought to me and then of course this was brought
122up again in the public comment and I thought it both myself and um um Mrs um Johnson thought it' be poate that I of course share this information with you all as a community we do want to bring that back I think it's a wonderful um opportunity for our school district um our goal is to see if we can kind of bring that back here in the next school year not next school year I'm sorry this school year um and we are working to see how we can actually U make that happen um more information will be um shared with the general Community as it pertains to us kind of getting this back started again because I do believe we can and so I want to share that with everyone as a part of my
123report thank you thank you Dr Garrison next we've got Dr art the board consultant report Maybe sh isn't technology wonderful yeah when it works that's right you want me this sorry well I've been in education long enough before all this technology so I can just let her go and I'll I'll certainly start because I know time is always important uh uh good evening board president uh Dr Garrison board uh my name is kimart I am the board consultant and and the first question I'd like to pose in front of you is like well what's a board consultant I know this kind of came out of the blue so I have three goals for this presentation tonight the first the first one again is why a board consultant why should a board have a consultant the
124second goal would be what has the board consultant been doing for the last two months uh it's mentioned before I had volunteered my time for the last two months to do some Discovery in the school district of booy so I'll tell you about what I have been doing and then I think the most important objective to tonight's presentation is what is it that I can do to help the Board of Education and uh the unique challenges that exist here in the school district of a light now I do need the power point okay go to the slide what movie is this please one more okay everybody take a look at this slide here does anyone remember what movie that is anybody storm The Perfect Storm that's the perfect storm so when I I kind of
125think of the challenges and the opportunities that exist here in the school district of BU white and especially for the board I think it's accumulation of the perfect storm so when I first uh was brought on board here uh President Johnson uh eliminated some or directed some reasons for that if we go look at the next slide she said uh we need some help in the following areas these are the perfect storm issues that exist here in bit three failed referendums that resulted in $1 million budget deficit declining enrollments contrasted with increasing enrollments in our neighborhood schools outof district transfers continue to rise concerning student achievement state report card designation of meets FX expectations for consecutive years and uh the lowest state report card score in the state employment and staff retention issues student discipline
126and behavior and um the perception of the Board of Education in the district with the public all of these kinds of issues created The Perfect Storm uh for the district to deal with so what I believe as as a consultant is that the school district of booy perfect storm is a unique Challenge and an opportunity for the board to help lead the district change grow and improve and become this great school district and we do that by making sure that status quo is not an option what I'd like to talk with you again in this presentation is how to move from good to great and I'd like to introduce three words that are part of that thinking process the notion of change how we move to challenge and how we move to opportunity change Challenge
127and opportunity are three words that I'd like all of us to think about so by doing that we have to change the narrative we have to change the narrative we heard all of these kinds of problems that we're facing so how do we change the narrative how do we position our challenges differently next slide so you've probably heard this before Tony says if you do what you've always done you get what you've always got so we certainly need new ideas new Solutions a different approach to solving these interesting problems so for an example that would be the following this is how I would kind of rephrase or re-energize those particular challenges and turn them into opportunities for the board so for example uh work strategically as a district and a community to pass the upcoming
128referendum that's uh coming to us in April of 25 certainty to learn and plan from uh previous mistakes and plan and communicate differently to be successful in the referendum outcome again this is how we would position our thinking and our goals with an opportunity lens second would be to create a sense of urgency in all our schools to raise student achievement performance so that the district improves Five Points and raises the report card score to meets expectations uh this must be everyone's priority and again as we've heard in the previous board meeting that is the goal for the school district of booy number three would be to intensely focus our intervention strategies in each school to reach the target growth of three again that's a metric that's been identified in in our subpopulations our disaggregated
129groups that's the dire and that's the Improvement score that we need to move to make sure that we uh meet that particular report card score goal we want to reduce the number of outof District transfers I just put a number here by 50% uh and we would do that by better uh promoting and communicating uh the positive opportunities for students that are unique for the school district of obloid we also want to ensure that teachers can teach and all students can learn by raising both student and parent expectations for positive conduct and behavior at each school and then finally we want to improve the community perception of the board and school leadership through increased Community engagement through open and honest dialogue and acting on stakeholders ideas thoughts and suggestions so this is how we position
130our verbiage our goals our intent as we move forward and again uh the last two community Community engagement sessions have been perfect examples of of how to do that where I we've had very positive responses from everybody next slide so the strategy is that key words at Key times so the word let's go back to that slide again and let's look at some of the key words that were being emphasized can we put that in the whole so we can see the whole slide it might project better I don't oh okay so some of the key words that I think are important to infuse in in our work is is strategically uh planning and and communicating differently the sense of urgency sense of urgency and I did hear that tonight in earlier in presentation uh
131intensely focus better promote and communicate ensure that all students can learn and then improve the community perception so these are key words at Key times that as we move forward with the change process that would become part of our daily vocabulary and our work and our our talking and our thinking uh as we we do the work of the board so the next slide very good so creating a focus on how we think how we speak and act builds a culture of Excellence so that's part of some of the work that I uh I would suggest and have been thinking about is I've been doing the first two months of my work in terms of Discovery I've been visiting I've been going to all your board meetings all the related kinds of events too so
132as I can kind of understand exactly this current status of the school district of booy next slide so then again as I I think about the role of a board consultant perhaps the most uh significant and the most important role would be to coach coaching uh where I come from the school district of janzel we always had a we always had a board consultant for 20 years there was always a board consultant and I I certainly saw how much the district how much the school board certainly learn from that coach and that opportunity so coaching is uh an important goal of what the consultant would do we all know that education is a very unique animal it has its own complexities and as the Board of Education tries to figure out what all of those
133uh mean uh the role of the coach always in my past experience has been very helpful so coaching is important goal of a consultant the next one is expertise uh again lots of unique things you listen the vocabulary alone could put you over the edge in in terms terms of uh how we think about and how we make decisions and how we have informed practice so uh someone who's had a lot of experience and background and has been through all the different kinds of uh unique challenges that educations that can be helpful to the board and then again all all the experience so experience coaching expertise these are important qualities that a board consultant can give to the board as they uh go forth in their governance functions and Leadership responsibilities and I guess when
134I think of of booy to perhaps another important attribute or quality would be finding a common ground finding a common ground uh beloy has a very very strong Dynamic there's people that are very very interested and citizens very interested in in their school district and their Excellence as well as the board so finding a common ground so that we can all move forward okay the next slide talks about some of the activities that I've been involved in and so you just have a little bit of a progress report at this point I've attended all the board meetings and related functions uh the booy Civics Academy and there's another meeting tomorrow you have lots of meetings here in the school district of beloy so I've had an opportunity to be part of a lot of those
135things I I was able to lead an orientation meeting I only had one scheduled and so I was able to do that and then certainly those people from the board who were not able to be part of that orientation meeting where they met me and kind of listened to some of my experience and backgrounds I then completed individual follow-up meetings with each of those board members who could not attend uh I also was involved with helping the board find a third vendor for the referendum you know I know your new policy requires three and you had two so I got on the phone and called up some of my uh colleagues and we were able to get uh the Hadley Group which is your third person and then uh Hadley group is your preferred vendor
136now for working with the vendor with the referendum so again trying to use my contacts as my experiences to try and help in in areas of need for the board uh I've conducted individual meetings with executive directors and I only have one left to go so uh again learning and hearing and uh again increasing my knowledge base about uh what's working and what are the areas of growth for uh the school district of bloy I was able to attend a cabinet meeting and again an experence and explain what my role and responsibility was there I had the privilege of leading a Tablet Talk community meeting and I developed in an evaluation form and compiled the data from the evaluation into a p published document I've done that before too uh certainly one of the things
137that I think is very important and a recommendation I would would make to the board is that we measure things every time we do an activity we have a measurement of it so that it really helps inform what our future practice is um I have attended again the community engagement meetings and thought they have been very well done and very well received by the public um there's an example in your packet tonight where I customized the form that is just a recommendation for how uh the board might proceed with action items and um the other thing I I teach at the university University of Wisconsin and whitewater I'm teaching courses in education so I'm always on the lookout for potential candidates for B and uh I was able to recommend a couple to the district
138and and also in the area of par professionals so I've given their names to principles and vice versa so as we respond to that Staffing problem so I'm always on the lookout for if there's any way based on a need we have here for the school district of booy how can I help how can I use my experience how can I use what what I know and who I know to help everyone here so the third area that I'd like to talk about tonight then is what can I do for you what can I do for you how can I help again my whole goal behind all of this uh was was just to help the school district aboard I've done some consultation work here in in the district before so I have some familiarity
139with it and as I as I listened to the unique challenges I thought well put my hat into it how can I help I I've had some experience that I thought may have have some value to you so specifically next sorry president uh Johnson said she wants the school district of booy to be a destination School District I think that's a wonderful that's a wonderful vision for the district so so I agree with that too and so what are some ways that we can make the school district of booy a destination school district one of the things that I had a lot of experience in in my time in the school district of of Jamesville was creating and working with this collaboratively this Journey to Excellence and how we completely reshaped the culture of our
140district how the board and the district working together uh recreated uh the culture of the school district of Jamesville and how that was really important and and I know that the steps that we had taken there can be replicated can be replicated here and me skip the slide there okay so um go to the next one please so then also uh it's important and you have you have a recently minted and developed strategic IC plan some of these ideas and suggestions can be used as catalysts and energizers to move the Strategic plan forward and and really all of this happened for us in Jamesville uh with the work of Quint stter and everyone in J in in booy here is aware aware of Quint stoter his investment in the community so as I approached this
141opportunity of working as a consultant here I uh called Quint up and I had several meetings with him he's very interested he's very interested in in sharing his expertise his background his experience and and excellent organizational management to the work that we could do here too so I've enlisted his support and he is ready and willing to go we did have one uh meeting with quent uh board President Johnson uh Mr Garrison was there and Mr chady were there and he gave us some advice and some ideas referendum but uh Mr stter is willing and ready to help all of us uh replicate again some of those things that we did the Journey to Excellence in Jamesville for booy okay how do we do all that so this particular side and you have a copy
142of it right at at your tables there too this is the blueprint this is the blueprint to Excellence this is the curriculum of change this is the pedagogy that we had gone through and we've some of us that looked at some of the books that go along with it but these are really the nine steps and and and just very quickly uh we commit to Excellence we make sure that we measure the important things we build a culture around service we care for everybody uh we develop leaders to develop people we focus on employee engagement there's lots of Staff surveys that go through this process and we learn from each other and we make sure that we're all working c a common Focus a strong sense of accountability what we say we're going to do
143we do and then we measure it make sure that we stay focused we align uh behaviors with goals and values we communicate at all levels and we recognize and reward success when you have Fidelity to these nine steps the kind of progress that we're looking for occurs also along with that within this pedagogy or this whole psychology of change is the notion of the Improvement model mindset and next slide so with that mindset and perhaps again the most important thing it's how we think about our work how we think about uh what we do how we think about how we make decisions how we think about how we help students in the classroom and we're always looking to go from good to great we celebrate actions that are working and then we make sure that
144we can replicate them in other places so if one of the schools is doing real really well with reading Excellence what are they doing that we could replicate elsewhere so that whole look looking for and celebrating uh positive examples uh decisions are are are made based on local data it's not like well I feel this is good or and feelings are important too but we always want to make sure that we can put that with data and that's why the employee satisfaction surveys are good to make sure that the board is making wise decision based on the input that is local we always change um challenges into opportunities we identify ways that uh problems uh can imped impede progress no excuses are allowed when we went with when we worked with Quint he said don't
145tell me an excuse figure out a way to uh take those challenges and make them opportunities for improvement uh then there is again a strong sense of accountability we make sure that we say what we do next slide very good so again the whole system that that I certainly would propose for future work would uh again being close about identifying our purpose our purpose is we've heard over and over again to accelerate student achievement we have worthwhile work we make sure we have the right strategy or approach or formula for sex success and then we make the difference the difference occurs and again some of the other other materials that go along with the staff development that uh works with that is hardwiring excellence and education again this is a whole blueprint to how we
146make sure that we absolutely do what we say we're going to do we make sure that those nine steps become part of everything that we do Fidelity to the process we've heard that word before too uh then there's also always a strong focus on what our goals are you know probably the biggest problem in education or one of them is distractability cuz everybody's asking education in the schools to do everything and and they're all pretty worthy uh requests aren't they but when we say these are the three or four or five goals that we're really putting our attention on this whole sense of focus make sure that by the end of the year we really have achieved some things and then I mentioned accountability uh there's a strong emphasis on leadership and uh in Quint
147stter work with us perhaps the person that was most important or the most important leader in this whole process was building principles building principles uh uh were the the leader that really made things happen so in his whole experience uh uh we're working in healthcare and education getting the building principle to really leverage this model forward uh got the strongest result again then uh the outcome of all of this is to accelerate achievement accelerate performance when you're doing all of these things correctly uh you accelerate the outcomes the whole process moves from good to better to best to great and in particular then what this process will bring in terms of of some summary sorts of statements is I believe that the role of a coach is very important for school boards uh very important
148for uh District leadership uh the adoption of an improvement mindset that whole way of thinking is critical to hardwiring the kinds of goals and success with that we want we're all about accelerating student achievement and growth that becomes the focus and then we get there by using the nine principles so again what I would propose if we move forth with future work is again uh inviting the school district of booy to also go on a Journey to Excellence and what is that achieve so in our in our time with Jamesville from 2008 to 2013 uh we had we were a school of recognition for 5 years in a row and in 2013 there were seven schools of of recognition seven schools of promise and that was the most that uh that year that had ever
149occurred in the the state of Wisconsin other than Milwaukee which has a million different schools so uh so it does get results uh it measures by again your DPI report card score all of those sorts of things so uh if you enter into this journey um it has the potential to bring the kind of results I think that you're looking for thank you any questions thank you for putting up my technology challenges thank you Dr yes I have a question yes go ahead sorry um so I think this you know um the photograph that was up there could you put that photograph back up there Mrs beavers or did you lose it already mean ship no not the ship the last one oh um anyway I think that's that's an incredible uh it's an in
150incredible achievement could you can you share with us where the school district of Jamesville was prior to that and where they were after that uh the school district of of Jamesville was coming in below average and their scores had always kind of been below average and so um then uh By the time of 2013 then we looked at comparables uh the 10th largest school districts in the state of Wisconsin that became our comparison group and we were number one two and three during this time uh after 2014 uh the school district discontinued the program they had a change in superintendent and um everything kind of went in the other direction and right now they're kind of in a rebuilding um position right now because uh their student achievement has has dropped considerably from that point
151so thank you Miss Miller I think Miss leev had her hand up first um I'm I'm recognizing you oh sounds good thank you um thank you so much Dr thank you so much for the presentation it was really helpful um I just had a couple of clarify questions so in your Discovery um on the list of nine principles what were were there any things that you noticed in the work that you've done in the past like 60 or so days that you feel are not reflected and the reason that I ask that is as both a former teacher and a parent and having been on the board I'm not aware of of anything that's on that list that's not currently happening and I think in particular what our district does a great job of um
152that I've seen you know in these updates and things like that that we get from our Administration is our our Reliance on multiple metrics of data uh triangulating data in all of our activities whether it's academics Behavior Etc has been a really key driver in the administration's work um throughout different District leadership um so that was my first question if you could speak to like if you did notice a [Music] gap what this particular blueprint does is that it Accel Ates growth in all of those areas so in my Discovery I I there is nothing that is currently occurring from my um visit and my uh looking at uh the the current status of the school district of Belo that is in contradiction to this but again if you're looking to accelerate growth when you
153look at your student achievement all of this gets it moving faster and it certainly as you look at the opportunity Gap that exists this diminishes it significantly the other part that uh that is perhaps the strongest element is that every with this particular process every school gets behind it and there's complete Fidelity and again those of us in education know that that's always a challenge because everyone has kind of their own version of how they think it should be when when you adopt these pred principles you uh you get more of a uh a common approach to moving forward and that Fidelity to the process is is what happens in terms of getting the kind of results that we look so so bl's completely open to all this I mean the foundation is all ready
154to go from my perspective there's not anything getting in the way uh it's Prime to have have this particular process move forward I appreciate that and I wanted to clarify because you had made a comment during your um presentation about making decisions based on feelings so I just like for the record wanted to clarify for anybody in the room or anybody who might be following along that that's really not a practice that that occurs in the school district de boy and our leadership so I appreciate you clarifying that I guess my only other um I guess just point I wanted to make I heard you talk about a number of things and in reviewing your presentation prior to tonight I noticed these as well you talk about no excuses like that's a huge uh part
155of like Collective efficacy right John Hattie's work uh which I'll say as a former employee of the school district of booy is work that I was acclimated with and trained in as an employee of the school district of booy 15 years ago I heard you talk about um continuous Improvement mindset which what I see that I think of Dr defor um who is the former superintendent of my alma moer Adel Stevenson High School where I was uh I had the privilege as a staff member of bullake Memorial High School to attend a site visit um at Stevenson to get trained in plc's and I have um people who have told me and the other school districts I've worked with that nobody plcs like we do in booy so that's always good to hear so I
156wanted to just like kind of highlight that and I guess uh lastly you talked about um just you know giving students interventions that they needed and one of the other trainings that I was privileged enough to have as an employee of the school district de BL was with Marcia Tate um the author of worksheets don't grow dendrites um which was part of a professional Learning Academy that was offered over the summer where other area school districts sent teachers for professional development so I would say we have more than a foundation I think that what I've seen as a board member what I've experienced as a staff member as a former staff member and as a parent uh tells me that um everything that you presented on which I I think is fantastic stuff uh absolutely
157is alive and thriving and an area of focus and I guess just my last point of clarification and if you'd like to comment is when you talk about Clarity in every building getting behind it we do have a strategic plan it is sunsetting it's it's not terribly new right it's it's sun setting and I'm excited to work with my colleagues here to to re um redo that process we can build on the successes and work on those opportunities as well so all of the buildings um have building Improvement plans um in fact as a as a parent they're in my kids newsletters that I get from their principles every week and they say here's our goal and here's what working in all of those goals and all those building Improvement plans align with that strategic
158plan so I would just say two uh I think we've already got a pretty rich culture of buildings aligning around a clear you know defined goal um and and getting behind it with each other so I guess I just wanted to take this opportunity as you're showcasing the Excellence that you've experienced to just point out that we very much have those practices here in the school district valoy and I really appreciate you taking the time to share those Greg Schneider um just looking at at slide 11 and 19 I hope I numbered them correctly uh slide 11 is a position on problems um as I read through that um um it looks you know to me more like those are a lot of those things are the role of or things that are happening with
159the administration and I know that they're working on those uh since you are hired actually as the board consultant or our board coach I'm assuming that those are all the items that you will work with the board itself to understand and to for the board to help determine ways to move us forward with that um and then also on page on slide 19 um the activi is completed um I know you've done the discovery and I know we had a meeting scheduled and due to a glitch in the in the system we used to post agendas um it didn't get posted correctly um so that will get reposted hopefully we will learn about what you discovered um during those meetings at that time working with the board um but I'm just also a little cautious
160as I look at some of the other activities that you listed which are actually duties that are done by administrators within the district or by staff within the district um and as a consultant for the board you are working directly with the Board of Education not directly with the administration or with the rest of the school district as as such um just so that we we um you know while well I appreciate any help we can get finding staff is is really it's it's hard we have open positions um we do like that but just that that the relationship is working with with you as a as a coach and and the board itself right but I really can't do my work in isolation of the rest of the Enterprise and organization that goes on
161so that's why you interact with with the various components of the organiz but yeah so that I can do the best job of informing and coaching you I don't know if she heard me is she still online Miss Levy are you talking to me yes awesome um I have several questions the first is similar to GRE but but if I could get a little bit more in depth um you mentioned that you attended cabinet meetings and explained Your Role um and I'm hopeful that you understand that the role of the board is to hire and supervise a superintendent to approve an annual budget to set policy and to make expulsion determinations and so I'm curious how comfortable you are with being referred to as a board consultant with you have not met with the board
162but you are meeting with other groups in the district um and and how you kind of resolve that if how are you are a consultant when you have not met with the board I guess I believe that I have had that one session uh with the board again not as much as I'd like but again the mo the biggest uh focus at this time was Discovery so I believe as we if we intend to move forward then I have the the essential background knowledge to do the kind of coaching and the movement forward that I would need to have so uh again I need to discover what the organization's all about and the cabinet meeting was at the invitation of Dr Garrison and just to clarify you mentioned that you led a board of education
163orientation we never had a board of education orientation so I'm wondering are you referring to the meet and greet which that was the label but I I would categorize that as a pitch meeting um so is that what you're referencing as the board orientation the meet and greet that was held correct correct because I introduced some of the same content there so that was a beginning orientation of the stutter work we had a chance to look at the book that was provided and then I had guests that were also part of the process that we had experience experienced in Jamesville to again bring validation to our work so it was a meet and greet and we also got oriented to the potential kind of work uh I was suggesting for the school district of beloy
164and speaking of Mr stoter I just wanted clarification um is his offer to assist the district dependent on us working with you is this a a a package deal um or does that offer stand absent working with you I don't think it's exclusive to me by any means and as I understand that he had made a previous offer before that um apparently there wasn't any uh action taken with that so uh no it would not be exclusively with me but uh I I certainly wanted to check in with him to see uh knowing how important his role uh in the school district of Jamesville for making our transformation wanted to see if he would be available and interested in and he's very much so but it's not exclusive me to me no thank you so
165much for that clarification you also mentioned that you created a form to be used for board meetings to approve action items um and I believe you mentioned that it was attached I am not finding that and I'm wondering why if a form was created to assist the board why that form wasn't shared with the board or am I missing that yeah it's in your it's in your board packet a physical copy that you provided this evening yes it's it's the one that looks at uh uh I think it's from Tia Johnson what's it titled no no yeah I I don't think it's I don't think it's in this so it it's the one that looks at uh continuation of a board consultant you sent that oh yeah that's that's attached to the um but that's
166the um that's a different agenda item yeah yeah but it's it's in it's in the board packet so so I just gave her the outline and and and she used it so to kind of try it out in in terms of um helping you with that decision Tom and then just a final couple questions thank you for your patience um you mentioned that you were looking for potential candidates to fill existing employment vacancies and again as a consultant to the board the board's function in this district is to hire and supervis or superintendent um and we approve additional staff but we are not involved in the recruitment of staff so I'm just wondering how comfortable you are with operating outside of your scope as a a board consultant and and getting into the Affairs of
167the administration I guess as as certainly working with the board as a consultant and hearing you know all the time about the need uh if uh if I understand that there is an employment situ ation and I know of someone that is potentially available I encourage them to apply okay um so yeah that's not something that I'm comfortable with as a board consultant um it it seems as though your your role has expanded to being a at a consultant for the administration and that I would be more comfortable if if the administration selected who they wanted to work with as a consultant so I guess my final question under this agenda item is how many other boards have you worked with um as a consultant uh this is really the first one where I've just
168worked with a board other than I work in China I worked worked for three years in China with with with board over there and um most of my other Consulting work has been uh with with schools working directly with schools it's the first time I have worked with a board other than my work in China thank you when you when you China were you working with the Miss Ley we're moving um thank you um Tom henkins has a question I'd like for all board members to have an opportunity to ask their questions while they were asking questions when actually my hand was the first one raised and you called on several people before me yes you're correct I did I address the members that are here tonight first and then the ones online and in
169interm Tom hins has a question thank you Miss Ley Tom you have the floor point of order asking question I'm being cut off for what reason you're you're being cut off because this is not the agenda item this is questions for his report and that's asking questions about when you were working in China were you working with a school board Dr Gart I just want to say thank you very much it's not so much a question more of a comment and I'm sorry that it is not a question I think that you volunteered to come forward and with with without paying gas mileage and meals and things like that for you to come forward and try to help our district speaks volumes of your character I think for us as a board to not even
170consider it or to dismiss it or to to me it's a Turf War right now that we're uh some board members are looking at several Turf issues you're trying to collaborate our board our admin and our community which someone from outside needs to come in and bring us all together I applaud you for doing that I ran that as a platform when I ran for Council or for the board excuse me um and I applaud you for doing that we do need to say that we don't need help we're crazy because we do need help and to think we can do it on our own we can't goes back to one of your slides to keep doing what we're doing we have seen it look at all of our metrics that we look at and
171enrollment uh people leaving students leaving our DPI report card we need help and to say we don't we're not we're not being very fair to our students and our community so I applaud you and I thank you and I hope that you stay on it and help us get out of this and I really do appreciate it thank you thank you thank you Dr aart our next agenda item is the WIA Sports conference realignment this is Dr Garrison with assistance from Dan Gratz the athletic director the purpose is every two years the WIA reviews and considers conference realignments currently the district is in the Southern Lakes conference after review WIA has decided to leave the football realignment in the Southern Lakes Conference which is proposed for the 26 27 school year additionally all other sports
172would likely follow in the 27 28th school year Dr Garrison yes so I wanted to bring this to the to the board because originally this this was floated around as us possibly leaving the SLC um as a recommendation bond by the wi um Sports commission and um upon further review by the waa they decided to of course um leave us in the um um Southern L conference and um do a different proposal of a different team leaving the southern LS conference um I wanted to bring this to the board for your attention because this is a reoccuring conversations for every two years um with that being stated typically when the football well when the foot when there's a realignment in this case football um the other sports will stay in that same alignment um that's
173just the the process that that the wa has has you know taken upon itself um if we were to if we were the conference that they were asking to leave there was conversations around us possibly going to a a Milwaukee Public School Conference and or as far as racing um a racing um conference as well um both of which would have of course cause us a huge financial burden um naturally we did come from the uh rad Metro I'm sorry the big eight um Big G conference um up in U Madison um that was um changed due to our overall um School of um school um enrollment and so with that being stated I thought it would be important to kind of bring you all this information just so that you are aware that they
174are asking us to remain in the southern L conference the soc um superintendents have met we of course agreed to this um to this to us staying in Souther a conference um please note that um this this this space that we're operating in um and us staying in the southern lace conference uh um it's also predicated that the only other conference that I believe we'll probably express interest in and would be to go back to the one that we were currently in and and that conference is currently full with um its membership and so for us to have to possibly move all the way to again Milwaukee and or to Racine um that would cause us a huge U financial burden and so um with that being stated um I just want to again bring
175this to you all as information and U Mr grass do you have anything you want to add yeah I think just it's important to know that this happens again reiterate it happens every two years we will just based on enrollment changes here as well as the current SLC schools uh very likely be put back in a cycle in in two years from now um so I think being proactive and just trying to plan in the letter that I sent um in conjunction with the rest of our conference we essentially implied we have no interest in in going to the Southeastern Conference which is reing kosha um from a variety of standpoints um you know obviously Financial is is primary but from a misclass time from a uh parent travel and and fan uh you know
176perspective um and then on top of that the the Milwaukee Public Schools conference we were adamantly against as well our our proposal was we remain in the SLC or go back to the big eight which is a possibility in the next cycle in 27 28 so um I think like I said just good to be proactive and thoughtful and watch kind of watching enrollment Trends in the elementary and middle schools not only in beloy but in the schools that we could potentially be partnered with thank you that's that's the informational space any questions for Mr Gratz or Dr Garrison go ahead Miss Miller oh no I just thank you so much for that exp um I can't talk explanation it's really helpful I think for like the community to understand how those decisions are made
177and really appreciate the work that you're doing thank you thank you Mr gretz our next agenda item is the October 24 monthly financials and Bob chady is presenting the purpose is to review and approve the October 20 24 monthly Financial Activity thank you and good evening uh tonight we'll talk a little bit about the financial activity from the month of October uh kind of a lackluster month uh lots of activity but you know really not a whole lot to report on but we'll we'll walk through some of uh the information uh as is typical so we'll start by taking a look um at our monthly summary report uh of revenues and expenses and you can see uh here that we had revenues for the month of just under $800,000 uh the Lion Share of those
178revenues coming in fund 10 and in fund 50 fund 50 actually led the way this month which uh happens um and we'll talk a little bit about why that is uh here in just a couple of moments but more importantly while revenues uh total just under $800,000 in the month of October expenditures were uh just over 5.7 million so keep that in mind $800,000 coming in $5.7 million going out so our outflows um our expenses exceeded our revenues for the month by just uh over $4.9 million and again if you take a look at here uh you could see the top row the general fund uh over 4 million of that uh is in the general fund about 1.2 million of it in special education special education really uh receives the majority of their revenues
179uh in the month of June when we do the the general fund transfer to special ed so really the the 11 months of the year you'll typically see the the outflows there being in the red um and then again in fund 50 our revenues exceeded the expenses by just over $317,000 any questions on the summary before we proceed onward seeing none our cash and Investments let me make this bigger so that people there apologize for that cash and invest Investments uh display the status of our um assets on deposited our various uh financial institutions you can see those and the associated interest rates uh listed there end of the current month uh $13.7 million on deposit looking at the end of the prior month so the end of September here uh we had $19.8 million
180on deposit if you're wondering boy you know what is that significant shortfall keep in mind that you know we had outflows our expenses exceeding our revenues by about $5 million uh in the month of October and you can also take a Peak at the uh previous year end of the current month so taking a look at October of 24 to October of 23 October of 23 we had $ 26.6 million on deposit keep in mind that the district utilized about 14 million um in March of this year uh with regards to debt payments so that that explains that significant draw down more important importantly perhaps some information at the bottom couple of rows uh where we take a look at and we speak to our cash liquidity you can see at the end of September
181that end of the prior month we had 42 days of cash on hand um meaning that the district could operate for 42 days in absence of any additional Revenue coming into the district so that's how much cash we had on hand to to pay those daily expenses so 42 days at the end of September at the end of October 20 days and I'm going to let the cat out of the bag a little bit here and I'm going to talk about the end of November uh not even the current reporting month but just to kind of we had five days of cash liquidity as of the end of November five now thankfully we received a significant state aid payment we knew it was coming on December 2nd um keep in mind with the board we
182put in place that cash flow borrowing opportunity we we did not need to utilize it we're biting the biting the nails a little bit um I'll be entirely honest with you we did hold intentionally uh two accounts payable checks for some of our larger vendors and I contacted them and let them know the why and when their payment would be uh released to them they were totally fine with it understanding appreciative of the call so we did what we needed to do to get through what we knew was going to be a low Point without having to draw on that line of credit and incur that uh interest expense all of our staff got paid more importantly any questions on the cash and investments before I continue on Miss Miller thank you um I know
183you've you've touched on this before but just to help build understanding I know there are different times of the year where we don't worry so much about liquidity because of payments from the state and things like that so I guess twofold question one if you could just clarify that for anybody who might be following along what those times are where we're worried and where we're not worried like typically and then like what would you say based on your prior experience with other districts and just working with your other colleagues around the state um to what extent is that um I guess like a concern like you know 5 days seems pretty razor thin what would you say in those times where it's usually like a dry spell for districts is like a reasonable liquidity goal
184for us you know what I'm saying so obviously like more than 5 days but what just kind of off the cuff if you could help us understand a little bit more about that sure so first and foremost districts uh hit low points of cash typically the third fourth week of November um and then usually that occurs again for districts anywhere from the latter third fourth week of June and then that carries through during the summer uh so we received significant Aid payments from the state in December we received property tax payments pents because you unfortunately everybody just got their property tax bills within the last week or so those payments will be made um those payments that are made here in December we receive from the municipalities in January those payments that are made in
185January we receive from the municipalities in February so in January and February December January and February uh we do have good assets coming in good revenues um and then typically that kind of wanes off then until the end of the the fiscal year in June when we we see more yeah with regards to the liquidity um man that's a really good question as to to what the appropriate number of days is you know I'll be honest with you to my knowledge there's maybe less than a dozen of us business managers that track it by the day basis like that so that's not a common thing but I it's an easy calculation and I think it really just drives home how much money we have sitting around and more importantly in absence of additional revenues coming
186in how long can we operate uh pretty common practice I think in Private Industry I'm not sure why we just didn't apply it to to our sector so I did so yeah well I really appreciate the responsibility that you're exercising and it really helps us understand better and like appreciate your management on that I think that's a good thing for us to kind of keep tabs on to sort of like rate ourselves like how are we doing this year versus last year and things like that that would be kind of a cool thing to see in the future right and I guess you know to be honest with you so if we would have had to draw on that line of credit um then perhaps that number of days could technically be a negative because
187you have a liability um you essentially ran out of your cash assets and now you're using the the loan um so but Tom henkins Mr Excuse me Mr chady to that point the es and flows of the year they should be reflected from the current year so saying that uh if your if your payments come from the state you know you said quarterly or when in December it should have been the same thing last year if we you know look go back to a year before we had 42 days and then 20 down to five um and I understand that you said that you made the big payment but the ABS and flows should be reflected year to year is that correct they of your payments yeah they would be um honestly when you look
188at this report and you look at that far right column the previous year column it's important to keep in mind you know so it shows $17.5 million in assets at the end of October of 23 compared to $6 million here at the end of o October of 24 embedded in that $17.5 Million last year was about $10 million that shouldn't have been in that fund it should have been down in your debt service funds in the middle uh of that or of that chart um the monies were received deposited into the general checking account and then into the IC uh The Sweep account um we left them there probably shouldn't have but you know so debt proceeds Technically when school districts receive debt proceeds those should be those should be segregated out and applied into
189your debt service fund account um and that was not what transpired um back when those proceeds were initially received and I'll just add prior to my arrival in the district okay I'm just year to year to year the your payments that come from the state come pretty consistently right uh they do I know yeah throughout the course of the year yeah so to mean to look at from last year to this year end of the prior month from last year to this year is kind of a a barometer correct yep and so we had 12 29 and now we have six six can you explain that I mean the decrease in six and they were down to 20 days from last year to this year I mean just in a ballpark sense was there a
190big payment that we had to make or we just running that close to the edge now um my apologies Mr henkins I'm not following your your numbers if you okay you're looking at the the very bottom okay correct yep um I think one of the thoughts is one could argue we're receiving less money too from the state from last year to this year um there was a um decrease in state aid um if I'm not correct please correct me Mr AR shady and so when we're dealing with less funds you inevitably have less to to work with from a year-to-year basis also based off of our expenses I know sometimes you look at a month-to Monon things going to be the same in this in this in the month in the school district that's ever
191changing we work with comp insurance is could be different from month to month and I'm also just also trying to allow Mr chady some thought thought process to again correct me if I'm way off yeah no the the state aid actually increased um but we didn't we don't receive state aid uh in the month of October uh so again um yeah Mr henkins you're right at the end of September we had 12 almost $ 12.3 million in operating revenues available and at the end of October uh just over 6 million dollar you know a difference of six 6.2 6.3 million a lot of that is found up here when we go back to the monthly summary report where our general fund fund 10 uh operated at a $4 million deficit so to speak or or
192loss uh in the month of October and then our special education fund uh about a $1.2 million so all of the cash for those um activities comes out of our general fund checking and our IC accounts so that that kind of explains why those values have diminished so much from month to month clear as mud kinda so I in your professional opinion though you don't see anything alarming from this year to last year at this present time no not not really um you know when I look at this and reflected upon this you know it's concerning that a year ago we had 55 days of cash as compared to this year 20 days of cash at the end of October um but I'm also smart enough to realize that we made a significant debt prepayment
193paid offs you know so that draws that down um and then again you know as I look to the next month's report you know we're going from 20 days to five days um of cash which was kind of close but but we were we were we were fine yep and as your forecast to next month with the influx what do you see us at for next month this report uh well next month's going to tell you you know end of November it's going to tell you we had five days of cash you know when we go to the end of December um what a month and a half from now you'll see that number rebound you know what it'll rebound to I couldn't tell you I mean if I had to guesstimate for you today
194um i' probably put that closer into the upper 40s low 50s somebody write that down and we'll uh we'll see how close I am in no I just wanted your professional opinion thank you yep is this P yeah no all right we'll continue on and uh try to expedite things a little bit um and honestly we'll be fine by doing that because there's just not really a whole lot of noted activity in the in the revenues and expenses um you know again kind of a lackluster month if we scroll down you know our fund 10 had $47,552 19,000 in revenues for the same reporting period you know so was an increase of 233,000 um or so and the vast majority of that comes into this uh 971 refund of a prior year expense where we
195receive that $233,000 that is all attributed to um our federal e- rate reimbursement of our contracted IT services as um from the 20324 school year I had to make sure I got those right um looking at fiscal year to date uh revenues in fund 10 10.3 million it was 10.7 Million last year so trailing last year by about $400,000 uh percentage wise we're actually ahead uh value-wise we're a little bit behind not really concerning to me at all to be honest with you scrolling down a little bit more and talking some more uh really the next big item for Revenue comes in fund 50 uh we don't talk about fund 50 revenues a lot but we did receive uh almost 437 ,000 in uh claim reimbursements for providing free uh breakfast and lunches to our
196students and if I remember right this was the month of September um so again 436,000 uh this year in October 420 almost 421,000 last year so you know outpaced last year by about $35,000 uh favorable for us as well and then again looking at total all fund revenues uh just under $800,000 in the month of October of 24 just over $600,000 in October of 23 uh so about $195,000 to the good and when we look at fiscal year to date $1,590 in the current year $1,394 th000 uh last year um so again we're we're trailing a bit there but not really anything that's concerning that was kind of the real quick Lowdown on revenues I'll pause real quick if there's any questions before I jump to expenses any questions go ahead all righty so oops
197too big um expenses again pretty typical uh coming down to page four so we can talk about general fund expenses uh just under 4.4 million here in October of 23 I'm sorry October of 24 compared to just over 5.8 million in October of 23 so our expenses um are you know 1.5 uh to the good and when we look at fiscal year to date uh almost 14.9 million in expenses in the 2425 five school years compared to 17.4 million in 2324 and again the Lion Share of our expenses um are driven by our salaries and that's perhaps most noticeable let's see here 88.4% of October's expenses overall in the general fund uh were attributed to salaries and benefits so just you know our Personnel cost is kind of really what drives um everything here I
198do want to come back and talk about a couple of things in fund 10 one is our purchase Services uh on page two you can see we had almost $419,000 in purchase services in October as compared to 1.6 million uh last year for the same reporting period and of course that's a pretty sizable difference about 1.2 million so you have to ask the question why and I beat you to it because I got some answers for you you know so that that variance is is really uh due to contracted custodial if you come up the page and you look at this row uh 329 cleaning in Environmental Services you'll see that it did not have any activity in October of 24 trust me the activity was there HS did their cleaning the bill just didn't
199come in or didn't get processed through and paid in October um but if you look across the page you'll see $750,000 worth of expense in October of 23 so um so that's a large driving factor and then a couple of rows above that is uh this 327 Construction Services and again we had no construction related expenses um here in October of 24 whereas we had 135,000 in change of such expenses in October of 23 all of that Construction Services work last year was related to the um HVAC eror Improvement project at flit Memorial High School and just an area that we don't often touch about in the general fund and that's our insurances and judgments um on page three uh we had $7 70,3 40 worth of expenses related to our monthly premiums for liability
200uh uh let me rephrase it related to our premiums not always monthly some of the premiums are quarterly some of them are monthly um but anyways that's related to our liability property workers comp and unemployment claims um as listed there really important to point out um if you look at things you know $7,350 in expense this year October as compared to last year under $28,000 and perhaps more importantly looking at the fiscal year to date uh almost $38,000 worth of insurance premium expenses in the current school year and about 28 $86,000 last year you know so 20 $25,000 higher um our premiums this year it is a very tight Insurance Market um and we're paying the price for that despite efforts to find other insurers willing to write our coverage so uh we'll we'll undertake
201similar efforts this year any questions on fund 10 expenses perfect fund 27 um let me just scroll down it you know again not a lot of activity happening here under 1.2 million in expenses in the current year as compared to just uh $1 million $279,000 last year you know so a slight variance there looking at fiscal year to date 2.3 million this year is 2.8 million last year and again speaking about the importance of salaries and benefits and how much of our expenditures are tied up in our compensation and our Personnel costs 89% of October expenses within the special education fund uh were attributed to special Edge Staffing payment of salaries wages and the corresponding benefits any questions there I'm going to skip some of the other stuff that I wrote just for the sake
202of time for everybody um I do want to jump over to [Music] oops our fund balance report um and I've got that displayed on the screen a little bit here for you as well so this top row highlighted in purple um shows some various information so on the far left column our 2425 fiscal year beginning balance so this reflects our balance as of July 1st of 2024 for the current fiscal year 10.4 $493 million and then the next columns uh the next two columns reflect October beginning balance five I'm sorry 9.9 make that bigger for myself 9.9 million and then October ending balance 5.9 million so a decrease of about $4 million go back to that monthly uh Financial activity summary chart the first chart we looked at and go over to the outflows and
203you can kind of see that change um and then you can also see in the next two columns where we were beginning balance for the same point in time last year so October of 23 we began the year at 10.7 we began the Year this year at 9.9 but note this we ended the year October of 23 last year with just over $5 million in general fund and yet we ended the year here in October of 24 uh with 5.9 so we began the month those were month I think I said year we began the month trailing last year we ended the month ahead of last year better than last year so I think that's all uh good and worth noting as well couple of other things um that are in the attachment not necessarily
204uh spoken about in the financial activity report is we do provide the monthly accounts payable uh essentially the check register although lots of our payments are being via a now it's 38 pages long so people that are interested in that just take note before you go printing a whole bunch um and these are attached to um our monthly Financial reports uh going back to when we began reporting on July of 24 so all publicly available to the public and then something that's new uh this month which we had tried to get Incorporated in Prior months and just had a little bit of an issue um is our accounts receivable aging report I don't like the word aging report the report's not quite right because some of the these are all being reflective as um I
205think recent accounts receivable or invoices sent some of them are older so we're still trying to work out some of the Kinks but what you'll what is uh shown here is payments that are due to the school district of Belo from other entities or individuals and then perhaps a little bit as to the why and since I reside in the school district of Fort ainson I'll just use them as an example uh as of the end of October uh the school district of Fort ainson owes us $40 um we share the cost districts share the costs uh with regards to Shared homeless Transportation expenses uh so we had that uh we had $80 incurred uh with regards to a student that was residing in the school district of Fort ainson but returning to the school
206district of booy so we share that $880 expense so they owe us $40 so that invoice is out there but um generally the accounts receivable aging report has a lot of miscellaneous monthly activity that takes place where the board I think will get the most value of it will really be in the months of June July August and maybe into September as we close the fiscal year and we book a lot of accounts receivables um so your fund balance at the end of June May look big but it's not all in cash so it's just important to note we'll talk about that more later I see some puzzled looks so any questions at all go ahead yeah well I was it's funny you brought this up because I had I looked at that and I
207thought what is I I didn't understand what this was so so the ones there's several that homeless Transportation so we're sharing explain that a little yeah so the mckin vento law requires districts to work cooperatively okay to provide for the transportation of students that are experiencing homelessness back to their school of origin okay so they may have been attending school here in the district for whatever reason ex are experiencing homelessness and then they end up in other districts or even State we go south of the state quite a bit too um and you can see that here as well so on a monthly basis then we try to invoice those districts for their portion of the expenses that the school district of blit has incurred in travel to pick up those students to return them
208back to school in the morning and then take them back to their temporary place of residence after school each day it happens a lot it's quite costly yeah and then one other quick question it's just kind of a housekeeping thing the front page of that aging report yes there's a report date of 6:30 2022 yeah and again um I really want to try to generate this report without that front page showing up because it's not really necessary and it's just confusing um we're still trying to figure out how to do that to be honest with you technology technology thing yeah yeah we'll get they're in time you know and likewise uh some of the values that are here um you know there are some liquidated damages resignation fees that I think probably predate the 2425
209school year so really those values should be to the far right under the greater than 90day um column but we don't have the parameters right we're still trying to figure all that out yep thank you thank you Miss Miller thank you yes Skyward can be kind of a bear I think they look lovely um I just wanted to point out because I and I came in earlier um from my daughter's thing we were in the middle of public comment and I know there was a comment made elevating um some of the points that were made at the listening session last night and one of them that I heard across groups was U Transportation costs and so no question just wanted to take this opportunity to like highlight to my colleagues some of whom weren't um
210able to be there yesterday um that that's something that I think we should continue to look at in terms terms of like collaboration and partnership because like you just highlighted there's all kinds of sort of like in the weeds like little rules and things like that and it's not quite as like we're just getting kids from point A to point B in our district right like it's a complex situation I just really appreciate your explanation of that and wanted to take the opportunity to just voice one of those issues that was brought up last night thank you anything else any other questions I would entertain a motion to approve the October 2024 monthly financial statements as presented so moved second motion to approve by Greg Schneider seconded by Brian Nichols any discussion hearing none all
211in favor I I I I I any oppose motion carries unanimously the next item on the agenda is the board consultant discussion this is to discuss additional work with Dr Kim aart and his contract with the board at the October 15th Board of Education agreed to enter into a two-month agreement with Dr aart to provide board with Consultation Services as outlined in a contract agreement between Dr aart and the board on December 20th the current agreement expires the Board needs to decide whether to approve a new contract with Dr G airheart or to discontinue his Services upon completion of this contract the board of education is currently dealing with a number of critical issues that include declining enrollments continued state report card designation of meets few expectations some of the lowest forward exam scores in
212the state three failed referendum questions in the last 20 months Staffing Recruitment and Retention issues parental concerns about student conduct and behavior in the schools perceived Community Trust Issues regarding ing the school board and central office administration and a future budget deficit estimated of about $5 million when the initial contract was offered it was based on the belief that the board and District could benefit from some kind of season experience and successful leadership that Dr aart could provide his extensive training and experience with the with implementing the student hardwiring excellence and education framework would have the potential to positively impact the culture of the school district of booy also his previous experience as a senior consultant with the International Center for leadership education working with struggling school districts with low state report report card scores
213can be an important strategic tool to help give the board expert validation regarding existing Improvement and intervention plans as well as advising the board about making potential changes to ensure that academic achievement in the district is accelerated per the nine principl framework from the stter model finally stuttering the talking points for the potential upcoming referendum could be useful in terms of providing metrics for goals focus on excellence and quality improving the systemwide communication and promoting a universal system of accountability for the district initially Dr arhart donated 60 days of his Professional Services to the district with the district paying for his mileage cost traveling from Jamesville to bloy the new agreement will continue at no salary costs to the district relative to his board Consulting Services upon approval of this agreement the board president will
214seek private funding and potential Community grants to support compensation for Dr Earhart's Services the board will continue to pay for mileage providing office space for the kak education center and a fob to the building more extensive Ser Services could include such as curriculum and instructional audits professional development sessions for the District staff and on-site building coaching could be covered by federal and state Grant titles to F provided to the school district the board could enter enter into a contract extending Dr erhart's current contract and if if desired the board can um make changes to it and upon District Legal Services team again vetting a new contract could approve a new one again this is Dr arheart offering his time just asking for his mileage to be covered um we do not cover the cost of
215meals so if somebody is thinking because he ate breakfast here last Saturday everybody else here that was here last Saturday had the same opportunity to eat that same breakfast um so um whatever how whatever information is getting out there um that's inaccurate the reason I am requesting this I think and appreciate the work that Dr aart has done so far for the board unfortunately because of some uh mispost of meeting and some mishaps on this end he has not been able to do the amount of work that I would have liked for him to visually Accord you know as as was stated earlier in public comment you know what has he been doing because we haven't been seeing him just because we haven't been seeing him doesn't mean he hasn't been doing his job and
216as for um Dr aart suggesting names for um encouraging people to apply to the school district of booy for um employment I've done the same thing and if anybody else is knows somebody that wants to um apply and is qualified please do so I don't care who you are um we we need people we still have vacancies that yet need to be filled furthermore as Dr aart mentioned in his earlier presentation at Jamesville he helped reshape the culture of a school district I am asking Dr aart to do something even more something even greater that would be a small miracle and that is to help reshape the culture not just of the school district but of our community we lack the embracing of Education the way we should and this shows over the past 20
217months of not having our community support us through our referendum we have a strategic plan it's a well it's a strategic plan it it sunsets and we're still last in place our accountability score for the past several years has continued to leave us in the bottom 3% I don't know if anybody here knows or remembers a time when we were above the bottom 10% this is a problem this is something that needs to be addressed Dr aart has proven experience with the school district of blit it doesn't take but a quick Google search of the Jamesville Gazette and you can see the letters people are writing to the Jamesville Gazette with their concerns about the current state of Jamesville maybe had they stuck with the stutter method they wouldn't be so up in arms as
218they are now I appreciate Dr erhart for helping out in those times when we have aired on our behalf for example when the table talks was mispost yeah he went above and beyond and he helped out pull that off because what was originally supposed to be a board meeting he helped pull off so that we could continue to have it knowing we had wide public interest in that meeting he helped us pull that off without us having to cancel or reschedule Mr aart is there anything you would like to add to this discussion are there any board questions Brian Nicholls thank you board president uh Johnson well I don't have any questions I just have a statement to make and I I move approval to extend Dr erhart's board consultant contract through the date of
219June 30th 2025 I'll second point of order could I just get clarification of the the date you stated June 30th 2025 thank you we have a motion to approve extending Dr Art's contract through June 30th 2025 motion by Brian Nichols seconded by Tom henkins any discussion Miss Miller thank you um yeah just a couple pieces so I definitely um thank you so much again Dr ARD for your gracious offer to support the school district um with the expertise that you have um I think that based on the reports that I have seen and I definitely appreciated the presentation at the meet and greet that you provided um I think that while I share the same goal as you just um Express board President Johnson that we reshape and do I think critical critical work in
220our community as well as our district I have a difference in opinion of how we arrive there so um just to speak to that for example this evening um Dr aart did a really nice job talking about the report card please correct me if I'm wrong I think he talked about setting a goal for it was like up three points and things like that so I guess like from and I guess just speaking from my experience as a teacher and as a parent of three kids in our district yes the report card is important but as we've heard two board meetings in a row the way those scores are calculated doesn't necessarily reflect challenging every student and supporting every student to grow and let me explain what I mean by that we get more like
221points or credit on the report card when kids who are struggling increase over a certain line right which is great we definitely want that you can play numbers games with the report card and say we're just going to Target this group of kids because they're like worth more points on the report card than the kids that are just kind of sitting right above that line and a district that would do something like that would like look like they were growing more than a district that didn't so now I'm not trying to say that that's like what people do do or or anything like that but my point is that yes the report card is important but we're going to reflect that growth by focusing on the individual needs of kids and I feel like we
222need to we need to really focus on the students we have to be students first we have a scarcity of resources in our school district and I love the idea of going out and getting like private and additional funding and I think that private additional funding needs to go to our schools to our teachers to support our students so while I find what Dr aart has shared to be extremely valuable and I think very affirming to a lot of the great work that we're already doing and I think absolutely share that Vision like we talked about at the meet and greet it's fantastic stuff I didn't hear a whole lot about students I heard a lot about Optics so it's my opinion as a stakeholder in our schools as a parent and as somebody who
223as as a union member I value professional respect would like to share that professional respect with our Administration who we hire to make these decisions so just like I hire a plumber and I'm not going to tell the plumber what to do because that would that would be a big mess we've hired our administrators to do the important work of our school district I think that if our Administration chose to bring in consultant like Dr aart I think the student Mar is fantastic whatever they choose to do is something I will fully support but at this stage as a board member dealing with unmet student needs and extreme Financial scarcity this isn't something that I can support at this time thank you Greg Schneider board member Levy had her hand raised before me thank you
224I'm um giving the floor to um members present in person and then online well I agree that the district has a long way to go um in ways that we need to continue improving As We are continuing to do that and have for a while um a couple a couple things come to mind with this um number one is it's I think is the responsibility of the board to actually see the contract before they approve it it was very irresponsible of the board to approve a contract and to put it into place that the board had not seen um and not had seen the terms of it while I understand that Dr ight has kindly um donated all of his Consulting Services um there still is a cost of the district for it um and
225so how much or what has been that cost to date um on the contract for the last 60 days Dr art do you know the total of the receipts for your mileage okay okay um um and also the fact that um we do have administrators that we've hired to do this that the the Dr erhart has been hired as a coach and a consultant to the board um and he has stepped over the bounds of of the board's reach um and has stepped into what would be normally an employee of the district which is not the case in this contract um and again is not something that I can support uh especially with um the new policy that's been raised that requires rfps with at least three bids for for um services for the district
226and again the the board is by taking this step in violations of its own policy um as it was the first time that we passed the um the contract Mr chaden so total reimbursements to Dr aart um this is reflect Ive through an invoice number paid looks looks like it's actually going to be deposited Friday of this week just let you know you're getting your money finally uh $566 and10 of that amount $235 and some change was reimbursement um for some books that were purchased uh on behalf of the the district and the board and about $331 in mileage thank you Tom or I'm sorry Mr henkins okay and Mr Nichols any questions or comments yes I do I'm sorry yes I I do I was going to try to find something I think it's
227I think it's in this month's expens reports because somebody alluded to it earlier uh number one um I I wholeheartedly believe everything that board member hanken said earlier tonight um you know this District needs all the help they can get uh yes we're improving but we're still on the bottom so the other districts are improving better than we are so you can play all you want with the numbers but the numbers are the numbers that come off come off the DPI so and I'm sure we're going to see more numbers tomorrow at the library that may even be more unflattering I don't know hopefully they're not but to to to to sit here and say you know we're criticizing for helping that's called networking I got one of my jobs by networking I did I
228didn't interview with the company because of an ad I got it because of a networking so if if we can if and and you've said that you've talked to people so have I you know we need teachers we need pairs if we run into somebody in in Madison who's looking for a job we're we're going to steer him here if they want to come um Dr aart has a a great deal of experience and knowledge that this District can use he's he's exhibited some of that I think as as any good consultant would would do and I've worked with Consultants at at in Corporate America before they do the due diligence before they start working with the employees and that's doing that's exactly what he's been doing so you've got to find out the core
229of what how this how this business and it is a business it's a business of school district teaching our kids and how how it works how it operates and then he can do a better job of Consulting with the board and giving the board Direct ction so um I uh I I 100% believe this is a way to go thank you thank you Miss Levy Miss Levy oh sorry I was wasn't unmuted it's MES thank you so much so I have one question and one comment and hopefully this time I won't be cut off um The Proposal lists that professional development sessions for District staff and onsite building coaches could be covered by federal state Grant title two funds and according to DPI the purpose of title 2 programs are to increase student achievement and
230close achievement gaps by offering professional development opportunities in core academic areas so my question for Dr aart is what experience do you have in increasing student achievement and closing achievement gaps Dr earheart a lot I've done a lot of work in terms of differentiated instruction I've taught courses in classroom management uh for the last seven years I've caught taught a course on closing the opportunity achievement Gap through the University of Wisconsin Whitewater every semester lots of work in that area oh I'm so sorry I didn't mean to cut you off it's a passion of you so much for listing your teaching credentials I'm just wondering what tangible evidence do you have for a school district an increase if any increasing academic achievement and a closing achievement gaps which again is the term I understand opportunity
231gaps but achievement gaps is the phrasing used by Epi with specific connection to title two funds have you done that work in District in the school district of Jamesville that would be correct oh wonderful I I would love at your convenience um to to receive information on specifically on your work of closing achievement gaps and then just my comment is I'm concerned that the extensive Services listed in the proposal are again outside the scope of the board and are clearly in the lane of the administration and therefore in my opinion are not appropriate paths for a board consultant so this is not something that I'll be supporting thank you thank you any other questions or comments Mr Hankins I just want to follow up on what I said earlier in my comments about my support
232and having Dr Ken arur help us and guide us and not only for the board and to bring the board and the admin and the community all together in actuality we all are one and to bring us all sides together to get us forward I think it'll be nothing to nothing but improve bloy as a whole um like I said before we we seem to be a little bit divided between board admin and then the communities out there we need someone to tie us the three of us together in the direction we should all pull together and move this uh District forward thank you Dr ear her yeah if I could make a clarification to Mrs Levy's uh point about uh that that's actually correct if uh there were if the board directed staff development
233in those areas that were identified in your proposal that's part of my wheelhouse I've done a lot of that work too so that's why it was in I want to make sure that that would be uh delineated differently in in the contract so my role is directly uh Consulting with the board but if the board directed those other activities to occur that is in my wheelhouse and I have a lot of capacity in that area too I I believe that was sent to you uh at the first time when we presented at the school board convention for two years and we we looked at all the data and we uh established our record for best practice in the school district of Jamesville thank you um Miss Miller thank you so much uh here let me
234remember to pull my hand down this time oh actually Dr aart I just wanted to well and I don't I don't know if you'll want to follow up or not but I wanted to just revisit um I think you did a really great job at your your presentation that was um it was like publicly not noticed as a meet and greet and I think you did touch on a lot of these points so when we had that meeting one of the really focal parts that you spoke to that really resonated with me was very much you know what Mr henkins is talking about right like bringing all parties together and I just want to acknowledge like I completely understand where my colleagues are coming from and just because board members aren't on the same page
235about the best way to go forward doesn't mean that we don't all agree that this is the vision that we have right so one of the things that you talked about as being really important was your superintendent was like key in this work and that if the super and it was the superintendent that had developed the original Vision right for the the entire Journey that you took it was a journey of Excellence am I getting the right proposition is the right okay so I guess um I want to share something and then I want to just invite um you and Dr Garrison maybe I don't know if we could if we could just kind of talk about like where we are in that process because it feels like this would all be awesome if this
236is what had happened but to Mr Schneider's point this wasn't something this is something in addition to the work our Administration is already doing to help accelerate that growth so it is not in any way way um intended to be disrespectful to anything youve shared I've loved the work that you've shared and I really appreciate you and and your willingness to support our community one thing that I want to bring in though is if we're talking about evidence-based practice there is an evidence-based practice publication about the work of school boards because effective School boards do increase student achievement there are eight of them I won't read all eight but I will read number three so number three says effective school boards are accountability driven spending less time on operational issues and more time focused on
237policies to improve student achievement and so while I share the vision that's been set forth here I feel like it is our role as a board based on that evidence-based practice to really stay in our leane as board members and let the operational work belong to our Administration that's in our employment right so if I don't know if you wanted to jump in or if Dr Garrison would like an opportunity to participate in discussion because it it innately impacts his day-to-day work do you believe this really can be successful if we're brought in by the board as something in addition to and not a central focus of like what their work already is because it seems to me in that meet and GRE discussion there this this doesn't this the way that we're doing doing
238this does not seem in sync with the success that you had in Jamesville because it feels like we're already kind of doing like the same stuff and it's been it's being driven by our current Administration and that this is something like extra and I don't know if Dr Garrison is allowed to have a chance to speak in this conversation so he can give his input as well Dr earheart did you want to respond to that the governance function of the board is absolutely there and again the role of the consultant would be to help uh give suggestions ideas and coaching to the board and how they write and develop uh directives to Cascade through the organization the board then gives you know some of the important direction for the superintendent and the rest of the
239district so absolutely that's that's really what that was all about and in in our experience with Jamesville uh uh Mr St worked directly with the board and then he worked directly with the cabinet group so our our work in in Jamesville then was a collaborative it wasn't just the superintendent we all kind of figured it and and embraced all of it together it was a team effort that's why I brought those two people there the superintendent and a board member so it was a collective efficacy piece that made the difference I appreciate that Dr Garrison is that line up with your vision then for where we're going or what are your thoughts on how you would like us to move forward so one of the things I'll say is you know the work that the
240school district is doing I I stand behind it um I'm not going to you know not say that I think the work that we came in you know two years ago and started to embark on that you know this administrative team and of course my staff teachers um principes you know I thank them for getting behind that work and and moving that work for it um and so I can't um sit and say that I don't believe that the work that we have done um hasn't brought some fruit of achievement to the conversation contrary to you know to to many um I know we have work to still do and I've stated that before and we will get there um but where we had to come from in less than 18 months I'm sorry less
241than two years um is is miraculous with within its own right when I say miraculous I don't mean that in like a spiritual s space but to grow as we have um exponentially over this over this time is something to be noted for the school district of booy again it is not where we want to be and I agree with the board members when they make that statement but we have to follow that statement with we are on the right track we have to follow that statement with we are on the right track we are on the right track now what I mean by that is um from a from a metrics perspective we are moving in the right direction and we as we've talked about in this this conversation once before we do want
242to accelerate that learning we do want to accelerate that growth we do want to accelerate the the conversations across the board because you know we we want all of our schools in the course meets and then of course move on to the next um report card um um standard and so you know when I I made this statement before when I when I first got here we had none no schools in the meats category and then you know the following year we had one school in the me category and this year we got four schools in the me category um no matter how people again want to to to to to divide that conversation these are the metrics in which we have been given to to to make um an informed decision kind of where
243we're going um again I stand behind the work that the school district is doing I believe we are doing this work um and can we be better of course and so that's just my statement the board has a right to determine if they want to use a consultant and I've made that statement when this was bought to my to to the seat back a couple of months ago and so the board has a right to if they want to move forward with a consultant that's that's within you all right but I also want to respect the space that in which we work from in my offices um we are doing the work my staff is doing the work we show up every single day and we will continue to do that work um under my
244leadership with the support of not just the school board but of course with the community teachers parents I mean everybody because we are all in this work I would hope we're all in this work you know moving it Forward together thank you Brian Nichols thank you Dr Garrison thank you I couldn't agree more I mean maybe what I said earlier didn't make sound like that but I know that we have great people in this District I know that we have great uh principles we have great we have great Administration we have great we have a lot of great things going on but if we can get better faster with some help then why would we not take that that's the only thing I'm going to say one other thing though I somebody mentioned it earlier
245about well we have we have we have Consulting available through WB well here's what it cost us in July it cost us $967 for Mr Butler to be here for two hours it's on the it's on the uh thank you Dr thank you Mr chady it's on the accounts payable register so that was that's a lot of money so just just that's just for information purposes but no I just I I I again we got a lot of good things going on you know we we had the auto mechanic or the auto shop man manager in here that's that's that's near and dear to me cuz that's the business I called on so uh my son-in-law did that in California before he retired so um no there's a lot of great things going on if
246we can get if we can get our numbers up and get there quicker then we need it let's do it take advantage of it thank you Dr art I I just want to be clear and characterize the work that I'm proposing this is not a we they kind of proposition this is not a we they proposition again I certainly have recognized the foundation that has occurred here in the school district of booy uh what I am proposing are our ways to again accelerate those achievement and move as you said to more quickly and uh continue that level of a achievement in in ways that I've worked through many years of experience to accelerate the achievement so that's that's the offer that I bring but it's not in any way trying to contradict or create a
247we they situation between my work we're all in this together we have the same uh intention and focus and uh if I can be as some help based on what I've learned and uh through the years to help booy and and the board move forward in in a continued way to accelerate theud student achievement that's what I'm here for thank you thank you um I would love for private funds to come to the school district of booy and I would love for them to come expressly for our staff specifically for our teachers our classroom teachers I would love for that to happen it's not happening um and if there are external funds for Dr aart to do an audit for uh curriculum and instruction audit I would support that I I would like to know
248as not just a board member but as a taxpayer that and I've been living here 20 uh 29 years in January um why sorry 28 why are we last in the place last in the state again and we we make strides little tiny strides great we can Pat ourselves on the back we can give ourselves a rahah I think our community deserves better we can do better our students can do better we can all do better and um I have been inspired by Dr Art's work and I hope I would hope that he would be able to stay on and continue his work uh be it the policies um or a longtime deficit of accountability here in the school district our scores of achievement are slight they're not reflecting the success that I know we
249can have and I think everybody here knows we can have so something is happening that it it hasn't been happening and I think now is the time for we board members to give that opportunity to uh somebody who has had that success just up the road in Jamesville there is a motion on the floor and a second a motion to approve uh a motion to extend Dr Art's board consultant contract through the date of June 30th 2025 show may we have a roll call vote so sorry is there oh did we call the question cuz I didn't recall hear that um we're we're wrapping up um we've we've got um we need to move on oh okay so um Michelle may we please have a roll call Vote Yes Greg Schneider nay Amy Levy nay
250Brian Nichols I Tom henkins I Megan Miller nay and tia Johnson I the motion failed 3 to three thank you our next item is the ad hoc budget committee the purpose of this is to discuss the continuation of an ad hoc budget committee with additional comp with an additional component of referendum this actually is not the continuation it's kind of the continuation kind of a establishment of a new committee because the previous one was at the um finance committee level the committee has completed its work with recommendation for the current budget cycle the board has discussed in previous meetings to continue utilizing ad hoc committee for Budget work if the board or Administration wishes to add additional names to the current committee please have those names available on Tuesday the original committee charge was move
251um that I guess that should be motion to move the charge the ad hoc financial budget committee to come back to the business operation and finance committee based on their research and make recommendations on possible ways to balance the budget which includes impacts on students and the effect on the district we are still looking at a budget deficit and if we don't have a successful referendum in in April um that is going to be even more problematic for the school district some suggestions I would have in terms of thinking about a charge for the ad hoc committee would be to start work on developing a 25 26 school year budget with additional Cuts including perhaps some programming changes explore Revenue new sources and other ideas such as um combining Transportation with other governmental bodies selling
252or closing buildings um a absent a successful referendum another $5 million reduction will be needed for the 2526 Year from that basis a referendum question um we are are uh in the process of developing a referendum question what this adock committee would not be part of developing that question as a committee if any of the individual um members would like to to attend any of our listening sessions they're more than welcome to but we will probably need another referendum later on down the road and longtime planning is needed I would like to see a component of their charge to be more long range planning for the uh financial situation of the school district of bloy are there any board members that would like to add their thoughts to this Miss Miller thank you so much
253um thanks for bringing us up for discussion this evening um I just think that this is a much more appropriate time for us to be initiating an ad hoc committee um given that this is in like now the very beginning of the budget planning cycle and I think that this is going to be a much more um productive uh source of community engagement I feel like some of the feedback we got was that it was a bit frustrating to come in near the end when a lot of the conversations had already been had so I'm excited to see uh maybe different outcomes and a much more positive experience hopefully for all involved since we're commencing it at a time at at the beginning of the budget form cycle uh formulation cycle um I love everything
254you said and if if you don't mind just if I could add um a couple thoughts to that um assistant Su so I think I'm going to mess up his job title but he's like an assistant State superintendent um I think uh Tom McCarthy I was in a breakout session and like a I don't even remember where now I was in some kind of like Zoom meeting and I had sent him a chat many months ago and I was like hey you know would you ever be interested in giving um kind of like a budget 101 to some of our community members in boy CU he he's a really high energy really charismatic speaker and like this is like his whole job at DPI is is dealing with budget and he was I would like
255yeah I would love to come to BL I think it would be really cool to have like Mr McCarthy or somebody like that come and meet with the uh not only just the committee like the ad hoc but anybody else who might be interested um I think that would be a really great I guess opportunity right to build a sense of understanding of like how the budget works just to kind of get like a larger State perspective sometimes we're really constricted by like this is boit this is boo and I know like those of us who maybe have lived or worked outside of the area you know have maybe a different context so I I would love to suggest that part of the charge is to embark on some of that sort of like I
256don't know if you want to call it like professional development but just kind of opportunity like learning opportunities and then to that end um I think this was mentioned When Miss Fox was here presenting last time too um looking at other districts right like investigating districts that are comparable to us and seeing like what is working well in terms of funding priorities in those other districts and like maybe comparing like you know are there barriers that we have that other District stone or vice versa and just helping us learn from not only what are we doing that's working well and what we want to sustain but also like what are other districts doing that's working well that we could possibly learn from right and collaborate with so I guess those are just sort of the
257two things that I think would be helpful to add to the charge that you sort of laid out vice president Nichols you know me thank you you know me I want to get I want to cut I want to get cut right to the chase so I move approval of extending the ad hoc finance budget committee through October 31st 2005 25 with a focus on this is not extending we would be establishing the ad hoc committee okay is the the one that exists right now is from the finance committee so this is a board level committee so we would be establishing okay so so okay so the recommended action is written in error yeah okay got it no you're you're you're right I I'm just um be before you go any further be I think
258this was just taken from the previous um finance committee agenda yeah so if you want to change the word and just because Tech technically we're not extending that one just just a technicality there it's it was the finance committee that established that ad hoc committee so it's not our role as a board to um at at the board level to extend their committee if that makes sense okay because because that's that was the finance committees but now I'm ready go ahead well you guys talk I fixed it it was easy move approval and of an ad hoc finance budget committee through October 31st 2025 with a focus on budget and on referendum including but not limited to referendum 2025 before there's a second may I ask a clarifying question so I understand the intent of
259your motion um vice president Nichols are you um are you open to receiving the feedback that's been shared so far and any other feedback since there are other board members that have their hands raised to weigh to weigh in so did you hear anything contrary to the intent of your motion so far um no no not really and I would I think I mentioned this before when we had this discussion about this in you know couple a month ago is you know this is just a suggestion is that we continue on with as many people that were on the previous ad hoc committee to continue and then anybody that doesn't want to then we fill the that we fill that this is again suggestion we fill that spot and we keep it about the same
260size because I think the size of the group is a good size not too big not too large not too small thank you for that point of discussion I would agree with that and I'm glad we're able to have that discussion I just wanted to make sure that since um board President Johnson laid out some really I think really great suggestions and I added what I what I think are good suggestions to them I just want to make sure I understand the intent of your motion is to Encompass those suggestions is that right absolutely okay perfect thank you for the clarification again back to a previous statement we're all about getting better right agreed good there is a motion for approval of an ad hoc finance budget committee through October 31st 2025 with a focus
261on budget and referendum in including but not limited to referendum 2025 is there a second I'll second um motion by Brian Nichols a second by Tom henkins any discussion Mr henkins yeah just um wondering the end date last last ad hoc went to the end of the year December 31st uh what's the difference why would you want to go to October 31st that takes us through the 25 26 budget the budget has to be done into the d uh DPI by the 31st is that correct Mr chady corre so that's the reason okay I understand that then I I was we're there was a little bit of remiss back when Brian Anderson and I were talking that the charge that we set for last the last ad hoc they couldn't really talk about going into
262the 2526 budget because that wasn't part of their charge it would have made perfect sense for them to pick up the tail end of and move start moving in into the next year uh the last two months have been dormant which to me it would have been a a smooth flow to to know and then start moving going into the next calendar year yes um Mr henkins I understand what you're saying um including the idea of long-term planning that may include some conversation about the 26 27 school year 28 you know um you hopefully a long longterm planning not not just a few years down the road does that um clarify anything for you no I just think it would be it would be nice to be able to at least discuss in that next
263ad hoc committee going forward and not saying that they have to go on past the 31st of December but at least to be able to have the charge to at least look at to hand off to the next team if that's the way we're going to go with it yep and I and I agree with you and I think that's why um I wanted to include the long range planning looking at long ter uh with broad Strokes if next October we feel we need another ad hoc committee for the 26 25 26 budget year then we can um or I'm sorry the next one then then we can continue on there but um I think looking forward broadly with this in particular this group of folks who have um expertise and we can invite new
264members um send your um requests to miss SCH that would be wonderful any uh Miss leevy thank you I just had a recommendation for the work of the the ad hoc committee if they are agreeable to this I think and at the risk of adding additional work for someone other than myself um I think it would be a nice idea again if they are agreeable to do a training with Mr chady about talking points or kind of elevator style pitch because if they're doing all of this great work it is wonderful for them in my opinion to be prepared as they move through the community to kind of dispel myths and point out things that they're working on and these are some suggestions and this is how you can engage and submit your requests and
265information um and I'm just want to make sure that everyone who is interested in doing that part of the work that we give them the tools so that they're comfortable to do that and that we we have a consistent districtwide message any other board members we have a motion to approve the ad hoc finance budget committee through October 31st 2025 with a focus on budget and referendum including but not limited to the 20 the referendum of 2025 Miss sh can we get a roll call please yes Excuse me yes Miller I henkins I Nichols I Ley I Schneider I and Johnson I motion carried unanimously the next item tonight is the resolution authorizing the American deposit management company as an authorized agent for district funds this the purpose of this is to update the employee
266to update the employee authorized with access to the district's American deposit company's account the current the current accesses fall to employees who are no longer with the sdb Mr chady or Dr Garrison so Mr CH to take this over pretty much and and the resolution is attached to the conversation um back when we back when I guess when both of us arrived there was two different people on the um on on the um requisition in order for people to to be able to take money out of the account um those two people are no longer with us um Mark Duff and I believe the other person was Lori McConnell Lori McConnell and now since those two people are no longer with us we needed to update this um as you see to being Mr chady
267and Mrs Mrs Elwood yeah about a week and a half ago um we recognize that we had sufficient assets on hand talking about cash flow um that we were seeking an opportunity to earn a higher yield or interest earnings on those assets so we undertook a process to um seek out some res or some bid proposals from various entities that we do business with one of those being American deposit management company they provided us um a bid proposal for the $6 million that we were looking to invest in the higher yield um earnings however uh American deposit management their bid wasn't really competitive we ended up investing those funds into different capacity but through that process we recognized that we didn't have the current staff members um identified to transact business with them so what
268this is is simply uh designating myself and Miss Elwood uh the opportunity to transact business with American deposit management company in the future if we decide to utilize them the district had accounts with them uh marked off the interim business manager prior to my arrival I don't want to say close those accounts but the accounts are still there but there's no funds in them so all the funds came back to uh Blackhawk Bank at the time so simply uh trying to update uh who's authorized to order deposits withdrawals some monies with American deposit management so that way in the future if they offer competitive opportunities for us we have the ability to pull that trigger and uh continue onward Dr Garrison did you want to add anything no I think we should I'm sorry we
269the the two people that are currently with us are the ones that should be able to have access to this account which will be of course Mr J and Miss Elwood okay Mr henkins Mr J I would assume then that uh with First Mid then that you and Miss Del what are on the signers for that then right the Duff and uh whoever are off of those yeah with First Mid um the the appropriate individuals are on listed on the accounts with First Mid and with regards to the Staffing changes that took place within the business office this summer those individuals have um been deleted or removed from that Authority as well yep the proposed resolution reads resolution authorizing the American deposit management company as an authorized agent for district funds whereas the school district
270of booy the district May deposit funds in one or more Banks as outlined by The District's investment policy and whereas the district desires to designate the American deposit management company am ADM of Pewaukee Wisconsin as authorized agent for district funds and now therefore be it resolved that the school district of beloy board of education for and on behalf of the district authorizes the deposit and withdrawal of monies by the American deposit management company in both noninterest bearing or interest bearing accounts in compliance with the ADM Master service agreement and District investment policy regulations be it further resolved that the following officers employees or their successors are authorized to order the deposit or withdrawal of monies from the American deposit management company until this Authority is revoked by action of the district and written notice of
271such action is received by the American deposit management company received by um Bob shady I would entertain oh I'm going you have a question yeah sorry I I actually was going to make the motion um but I think you missed my hand which is fine but I actually have I do have a clarifying question and then I'm more than happy to make the motion I'm just curious um Dr Garrison since like you know we Mr chady is fairly you know new and has you know obviously has had to pick up the pieces from Mr Duff who is here as an interim are there now currently administrative procedures that exist in like going forward ensuring that when accounts are closed or when funds are removed that there is an update process in place so that we
272don't accidentally find out you know something like this in the future our bank Partners um update us regularly when these types of things do happen unfortunately you know again with the Su of the transition some that happened just recently in the summer um we this was something that we needed to catch and so I believe my the business department has enough checks and balances in place to make sure that when you know people are transition and that we can get this back to the board with different resolutions the bottom line is of course um mark dff no longer works for us and he would not try to take any money from the school district oflo as well as um of course um m m McConnell because that is a checks and balances space within within
273their own institutions that they would need to follow in order for those Monies to be um released back to the set institution which is the school district of booy and so we will no matter what have these checks and balances in place um when this you know of course came to our table we wanted to make sure that everyone know um I never leave these things off the table and so here we are um with the resolution in front of you now no I really appreciate that I'm just you know just so everybody's on the same page you know that's great that we have that process and that happens right when there's turnover and transition so thank you so much for being on top of that um since I don't think anybody else has their
274hand up I'm happy to make the motion as long as I can pull it back up here we go um at that point then I'd like to move approval of the resolution uh authorizing the American deposit management company as an authorized agent for district funds which is what's written in the recommended action is that accurate good okay perfect motion by Megan Miller seed by Brian Nichols any discussion hearing none Miss sh may we have a wall call please Megan Miller I Tom henkins I Brian Nichols I Amy Levy I I'm sorry I couldn't hear you did you respond I thank you Greg Schneider I and tia Johnson I motion carried unanimously thank you Miss shop our next item is the consent agenda typically there is no separate discussion of the items unless a board member
275so requests in which event the item or items will be removed from the general order of business and considered in their normal sequence on the agenda are there any agenda consent agenda items any board members would like removed Miss Miller sorry I just to ask uh just a quick Point um since there is only just the one item is it okay to just give some feedback on the minutes there's just a spell okay sorry um I know it's just a little thing but um I think our public comment speaker's name was not spelled correctly in there and I just I missed that on my first read through so I just wanted out of respect to the speaker I had emailed Miss shop um is everybody okay with us approving the am minute with that just
276with the spelling correction in that case uh I love to move approval of our consent agenda second approval by motion made by Megan Miller seconded by Amy Levy any discussion hearing none all in favor I I I I I abstained I wasn't present for the meeting any objections and one abstention motion approves with one exstension of Greg Schneider our next item is human resources Dr Garrison you said Miss Mrs alerz is available virtually she is as okay wonderful um are there any open session questions on exhibit a or exhibit B or any HR I have a question regarding the um the additional compensation for the principal position to cover the AP position what um what specific duties were covered um that would not have normally had to be covered by the principle because if I
277remember correctly the job description of a principle encompasses every everything that an AP has to do sure so um one of the practices that uh came to be aware of when I first got here is that the um each building that had an AP um that didn't have an AP the practice was that the um Administration would the District administration would pay pay the additional work for the work that the aps I'm sorry the principles would take on with that being stated um um in that Mrs Herford did not have an AP for pretty much the month and a half um I wanted to stay with that past practice of when buildings didn't have APS that were supposed to have APS and principles would cover in those spaces doing all the duties that of two
278that one would have to do um that's why this came back to the board for for your consideration um Mrs alond you want to add anything to that she just must okay so um so I'm wondering how many I how many of those vacancies existed and I've I'm a little bit perplexed because this is the first time I've ever heard of somebody getting compensated to do a position that is below their their status or beneath their status is so um one of the situations that that I can bring note to everyone at the board level is was when um mcil McNeil was um open um there were two um um principles principal and assistant principal there when there was in other buildings there was a principal and two assistant principles in their buildings and so
279the um administrative team there did get an get a stien for the extra work that they was taking on at that at that space now to to further answer your question again this was a past practice that um was in place um prior to my arrival and that this was something that was done to um to compensate The principales Who again were taking on the work of other buildings that would have two people in this in this space that would have only one for Mrs um Herford Okay so back to my original question what duties were performed that were not part of the principal contract so I don't think it was any necessarily duties that was want perform as part of the the principal contract I think it's the additional um time that they have
280to put in when they are having to do it by themselves and so that's the best space that I can um answer that question in and and Mrs um sh I believe you have to unmute um the guests that are you have the access to unmute them unfortunately I can't do it from my computer I'm a little bit concerned about the practice for whatever reasons that it was decided previously to do that because it does not explicitly say in the policy that that is um that that's what we're that that's what the compensation is intended for the um and I guess based on that then we should probably also be giving you an extra 10 um 5 to 15% because we have a vacancy directly under your position that's open the community and marketing position
281so I am a little bit concerned that this is not the intent of this um policy 22 2 22.1 rule 2 where it speaks to this compensation any other board members have any other questions on any of the HR exhibits Miss Levy again Mrs ly thank you so much um one to speak to what you just brought up I think because it's not explicitly laid out in policy I would be apprehensive for us to say that this could not be covered and my actual question seems to be on the other end of the spectrum if Miss Herford was doing the work of two people I'm curious how whoever made this decision landed on 5% and not 15% that seems like a lot of extra work and I'm just trying to understand how we we land
282on a number because policy does give that range of five to 15% great question um Mrs say Le we land on the 5% because that was what was used in previous situations for um principal and so um that's that's why we landing on the 5% um from a precedent U perspective additionally um we have paid um assistant principles for the this this same type of work when principles are out as well they take on additional duties as principal um and there's the um compensation compensation there for um when that happens so we landed on the 5% because that was the past precedent um number that we worked from the last um last time thank you so much for providing that context just of one of seven I would be comfortable with Us increasing that amount
283but again I think it should start with a new school year and we're being consistent across the board and letting people know that but if you're doing the work of two folks um I think 5% when you have the ability to go from five to 15 is a bit low but thank you again for that context and I'm glad we're at least being consistent Tom Tom henkins oh yes and I don't I don't want to cross the line in in the close session but as I remember this specific case at the beginning of the of the school year when the AP resigned that uh it was discussed and uh Dr Garrison I thought related something to the effect that he was going to shift some support into the the principal's position so to help uh
284the principal there with those duties and if those if those actions actually happen then why are we double dipping into that any other questions I just have a procedure question should should we move into Clos session I mean because yeah you bring up a good point and it's not like this is a really good discussion that you're bringing up I just want to check with with you and with our colleagues on the board so far it sounds we're not talking about performance we're talking about um process we're not talking about y totally fine I just just want to do a quick check thank you sorry any other questions or comments Mr henkins well I would just like Dr Garrison to weigh in after my question he was busy can you repeat your question Mr um
285than yes I remember the conversation back in the beginning of the school year when the ap of Merill um resigned and we asked about that and you said you were going to shift some support into help the principal there and if that happened then I don't understand why we're we're paying uh the principal there when she already had support that you I thought you alluded to us that you were going to shift in there to help her we and we did do some shifting in there as much as we possibly could that was not an everyday opportunity though Mr um henkins and so um as we as Mrs Herford um could um take care of the day to-day opportunities that that did happen and when there were some opportunities where she did need some assistance
286um and that's not a performance thing that's just a day-to-day when we down you know bodies and need extra assistance um we would shift the Support over to the building as we would do in any building um ac across the district when it's when that's needed at the principal level and so um that was not something that we were able to do every single day hence the um the um hence the reason in which um she had to take on those extra duties all those times where I wasn't able to bring someone there on their everyday um perspective any other questions are there any Clos session questions for exhibit a or exhibit B or any of the HR exhibits hearing none um I would entertain um I'd like to remove the um additional compensation item
287off of exhibit a and would entertain an approval for um ex exhibit a minus additional compensation and exhibit B so moved second motion by Tom henkins seconded by Brian Nichols any discussion hearing none all in favor I i i i any oppose motion carries unanimously I would entertain a motion for approval of the additional compensation portion of exhibit a so moved second I'll second and when appropriate I'd like a roll call vote please motion by Megan Miller for approval of the additional compensation portion of exhibit a seconded by Greg Schneider any discussion hearing none M may we have a roll call please yes give me 10 seconds okay cig Schneider I Amy Levy I Brian Nichols [Music] I Tom henkins I I Megan Miller I and tia Johnson n motion carried 5 to one thank
288you m our next item executive session a motion may be made and a vote taken to convene the Board of Education into close session pursuant to section 19.85% State statutes for the purpose of reviewing the expulsion orders of the independent hearing officer pursuant to section 12013 parent 1 parent e 4 h of the Wisconsin State statutes the Board of Education shall upon review approve reverse or modify the orders is there a motion so moved Z second second motion by Brian Nichols seconded by Megan Miller any discussion hearing none Miss sh may we have a roll call please yes Megan Miller hi Tom henkins I Brian Nichols hi Amy Levy I Craig Schneider I and tia Johnson I the Board of Education May return from closed session to approve reverse or modify the expulsion orders of
289the independent hearing officer as determined by the Board of Education in closed session thank you I I just have a quick question for President Johnson yes we wouldn't make the expulsion decision public correct so I was just confused by that that last bit of language this is this is how it was posted on the agenda yeah but that doesn't make it correct we wouldn't come back into Open Session to vote on someone's expulsion because we've never done that an open session before in in the past um actually we did and while we go into close session we will um get the advice from the attorney as to whether or not um we should uh do that in open or closed thank you so much sure thing for