001[Music] here we go we recognize that the Hogan administrative Center occupies the land of the hunk people please take a moment to celebrate and honor this ancestral hunk land and the sacred lands of all indigenous peoples will the secretary please call the role Mr Alberts here Mr veski here miss bodol here Dr Garcia absent Dr himz here Mr MAA here Mr new Meister here Dr sprag here miss Sula here the cour of the board of education is present so the regularly scheduled meeting of December 9th 2024 is called to order and we'll now have the Pledge of Allegiance please stand in FA the American flag I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for
002all tonight's agenda has previously been distributed to the board and I'd entertain a motion at this time with a second to approve the agenda as submitted unless there's a motion to amend I make a motion to approve the agenda as written is there a second a second all right moved by Mr booki seconded by Mr new Meister to approve the agenda as presented all those in favor please signify by saying I I all those opposed motion has carried and we will move on to public speakers it is the policy of the board to provide at its public meetings an opportunity for individuals to address the board comments about individual staff or Personnel will not be allowed open meeting law prohibits the board from engaging in discussion or responding to matters not included on the agenda
003agenda all speakers are reminded that the same policy ex limits your time to 5 minutes pardon me this limit will be strictly enforced and if I could ask the superintendent to keep track of the time and to notify the speaker when the time is running out I will do so okay you'll give a 30 seconds y I've got a little sign perfect you're also asked to give your name and the school district where you reside at the beginning of your time for the public record and our first Speaker tonight is Abby Krueger hi everyone thank you my name is Abby Krueger um in school district one I live in Lacrosse I have two kids that go to Longfellow one will be at Central next year I was born and raised in Lacrosse went to Cathedral
004Grade School Lincoln and then graduated from Central in 19 you don't need to know how old I am okay so I moved away for exactly 30 years came back two and a half years ago to care for a family member and to get my kids rooted in a great community in an awesome city with a great educational system um I married somebody in the Air Force we had lots of moves so there's one story I want to share with you quickly an experience we had because I do think it has uh a different perspective um on the issue of metal detectors so at one point we were stationed at Joint Base Andrews in Washington DC and we chose to live off base we lived in kver County Maryland Southern Maryland in a really nice Community
005called uh Sunderland Maryland um upper class lots of government workers military members High clearances um like crime-free Community uh and my kids attended Sunderland Elementary there and we had an unfortunate incident a very clearly mentally ill uh man with an assault assault style weapon uh was walking down the road in the direction of our kids school um he was completely unclothed and it was the middle of winter so fortunately somebody saw him and the sheriff responded very quickly we have awesome Sheriff's Department there and he was apprehended and the crisis was averted but then we quickly realized after that that our kids were not safe in the schools in the elementary schools in that county because they were built in the 1980s and they had an open pod format that was the thing we did
006back then um and there were no doors on the classrooms right so this is an issue um we can't do lockdown drills without doors it's really unheard of now this was 20 15 16 almost 10 years ago today it's unheard of um to not have doors and do lockdown drills it's standard practice we've accepted it as a society we like it we want it parents want that um back then it was kind of weird so it the parents then responded with we want doors on these classrooms um the fear grew with other shootings that happened in the country that year that were very horrible we had Town Hall meetings school board meetings the concern grew turned into anger we need to act we need to do this the only option was really to retrofit all
007these schools with doors which cost Millions um but they decided they were going to divert funds because what happened was enrollment started to drop because the word gets out very quickly Calbert county is a safe place but there's no doors on the classrooms what's the threat today school shootings that's the threat so they happen randomly it's not an inner city problem it's an everywhere problem as we just learned a couple weeks ago at Central High School we had a a scare so they decided to divert funds from a project they were doing it was like a boardwalk with a bike lane and something else and they said this is more important because this is what's bringing taxpaying families responsible Working Families into our community safety so the just coughed it up they paid it millions
008of dollars they did it enrollment began to increase okay came back the pillars of the community still there County still creating all this tax revenue so when we talk about uh metal detectors now do we have them in high schools across the country yes we do are they becoming standard practice they are um do they work yeah are they psychologically damaging to our kids kids no our kids by the time they're in Middle School know that school shootings are happening they know that they happen with increasing frequency today they know that we can't agree on how to fix it they want them we like metal detectors when we go to Sporting Goods or I mean sporting events or the courthouse whatever it is we feel good when we walk through them so do the kids
009they like them they want them there they get used to it in about a week does it require additional Manpower uh yes can those um jobs of you know running the entryway into the school in the morning okay uh can be filled with some volunteer like crossing guard volunteers yes so think about it as a return on our investment metal detectors cost a fraction of what calber county spent they are not a permanent fixture in your building you can pick them up and move them if we build a new school let's do it it's a selling point I'm going to buy a house soon I AB absolutely would pick Central High School District over West Salem if Central put in metal detectors it's a selling point okay think of it as a return on your
010investment very much all right appreciate it thank you everyone have a good night our next item on the agenda is the stem 101 in build your own ukulele kits and I believe we've got Jessica engleson who's going to join us yes so thankful to celebrate one of our great Endeavors in our schools thank you Jessica for being here I brought samples Tim all right so um I thought that I would start well I'll start with my name Jessa enilson I work at Northside Elementary and kie manasu um and what was it two years ago another music person in in the community was like hey I'm making these really cool ukuleles and I wanted to know more I looked up stem 101 and immediately I knew I needed to get on there list because I'm like
011my kids are going to love these um I included their mission statement because it perfectly sums up what the purpose of stem 101 is and what I am trying to incorporate in my classroom and they're a nonprofit they work to advance Economic Development by improving stem literacy skills for all students their approach is designed to improve under repesentative minority and lowincome student growth close achievement gaps decrease increase Dropout rates increase High School graduation rates and improve teacher and principal Effectiveness essentially that part alone of their mission statement had me at hello I was like all right let's we definitely I'm contacting them we're doing this so how do we do this well this is where the Ashley Foundation comes in and the Ronald and Joyce W neck Foundation um these kits that I have been
012using in my classroom the last two years have been at no cost due to both of those organizations the only thing that I had to do this year that was different was write a grant for the Ronald and Joyce Weck Foundation mainly because they're growing this the the people keep hearing about stem 101 they want in on this really great thing and so they're change some of the processes are changing but once again these kits are worth it and I will get more into that later what do the kids have to do well the only things that they're required to do is a pre- and post survey it's 100% Anonymous it literally says like student 1,042 would like to be an engineer one day they think that might take four years usually we don't tell
013the third graders that's not true um but it's questions like that and then as they get go on as fifth graders for me it's interesting seeing how their idea of what they want to be and do when they grow up changes because I'm asking them all these questions in this survey however it also ask them questions in a quiz specific to their kit and I just did one today and it asks questions like what is the purpose of the tuning peg what is the purpose of the body of the ukulele so it's using everything that they learned throughout the project and just doing a nice summary it's eight questions long it took I think one minute for each fifth grader to do it it's 100% worth having a kit covered for free by one of
014these wonderful foundations um and honestly they just want these things to be done so they know the kits are being used it's essentially what it is so what kits are there I thought I'd let you know there's more than just ulele and cuz my fourth graders have been asking me since October when they get to make their speakers yes they make speakers yes they do work are they maybe the most Pleasant for parents to listen to probably not but the kids are proud because they made them they took the white Magnet Wire they wound it themselves learned how to make the inner workings of a speaker pretty cool fourth graders are doing this um there's also an electronic circuits kit where kids get to take um copper tape and Battery and lights and learn how
015all of that works an Arduino kit where they actually program to do I think it's like five or six different things with this one board honestly even for me it's a little complicated so I'm super impressed with them the Hydroponics which for north side kou monor is even more fitting since we just added the greenhouse the kids get to grow a plant but then they also have to learn how much plant food that plant needs at different stages because something I didn't know as a non-plant person is that they don't need the same amount throughout the whole process now you know um there's also a measurement kit and last year the kids used the multimeters to test all of the batteries that teachers were unsure of in their classrooms to see if they were working
016or not so it was all of these kits we found ways to incorporate very thoughtfully and the kids just look forward to doing them um I forgot one on there there's a Building Systems one too they get to build a building out a styrofoam and there's a sensor on the inside they can do humidity tests with it it and then it pops up on their iPad and they can see how their building is doing throughout the day so yeah so I also thought I'd show you what inside the portal looks like so I did one for the ukuleles just so that people people can see what that looks like um so here we see it the kids would log in this is what the kids see pre-unit survey there's three different mentors and they're live
017mentors they're real people that the kids get to hear from so they get to hear how people are actually using these skills in the workforce and there's different content knowledge so that's where they talk about the vibrations in the ukulele what do the strings do what is the purpose of all of this it even gets into um like a little bit of basic level physics of an acoustic instrument then we get to the project instructions breaks it down super simple and then the end is that certification piece that I talked about earlier so what is that content knowledge piece looked like I took a picture so it has a lot of different things it actually talks them through what an assembly line is and why they were created talks about Henry Ford's assembly line um
018so that they can learn how using what you know in slightly different ways can actually make you more efficient and this work they've actually used this in my classroom where one kid realizes I'm really good at using a screwdriver so if you're really good at hot gluing let's use each other's skills and they do and these are things that I don't tell them to do I tell them to try the main activity but then they start to realize oh we could use the assembly line technique and the creative thinking is remarkable here is what it looks like when the kids go through each step so if say I had a sub or someone was gone or I got a call and had to step out they can still do all of this without me because
019it also shows them these nifty videos so it goes through each step so the kids that need to read directions can read them the kids that need to see the directions can see them and they can pause it whenever they need to pause it here I just took a picture of like what one of the questions looked like so we we did talk about dry fitting because we have to do that with part of the ukulele because it literally comes in like this whole thing comes in pieces it's it all fits in a little box and they put all this together this is the most frustrating but funny part for me the students learn how to use a screwdriver and to put the tuning pegs in by the time they're done they are so excited
020to take that screwdriver home and find things to tighten up at home I almost feel like I have to send a disclaimer saying hey your kids have a Philip head screwdriver watch out but things won't be loose anymore so but they they're beyond excited now that they know how to use this tool because what are our kids used to doing tapping mhm tapping screens they forget how to use the dexterity of something as simple as a screwdriver so that's why this is awesome um so why do I love this I love this I've kind of talked about it a little bit but they the kids get really like they get thoughtful and they start tweaking things in their head thinking like oh the glue is too thick here so I need to find a way
021to fix that they used to come up to me and give me this look like you going to you going to fix this Miss ey and now they what they do is they come up to me and say uh so what do you think if I pry that off and scrape some of that glue down and then put some new glue on there just cuz I don't think that's going to work completely different than what they did before or they'll get to the par where they put the strings on and they're like that's not supposed to touch is it nope so then we talk through ways that they could raise different parts of their ukulele without dismantling the whole thing so it's just getting their brains going in a different way that previously they weren't
022doing my unintended benefit some of my rambunctious classes are the most silent um the day that um Nick Maru was in taking pictures the classroom was quiet all you heard were screws being accidentally dropped and then screwdrivers and an occasional because these screws are really tiny so they would drop them but that's all you heard and this was normally a class that was very talkative so and then what did some of the students do some of my students that are underachieving are all of a sudden finishing this first then going around and helping everyone else and that's something they normally wouldn't do so it all of a sudden you're looking around at them like you the same kid and that's what I love about these is I see different parts to my students that I
023honestly without them would have never seen so students they are more than excited to dive in the second the ones that know that these projects exist the second they come in they're like Miss we doing that yet have we started no not yet I don't even have them in the building but they already want to know when they're starting them cuz they're that excited so um what are some other kids excited about I had one kid tell me that her older sibling has a ukulele she's excited to take it home so that they can play together um another one said she was excited cuz her mom couldn't afford to buy her a ukulele but it doesn't matter cuz she made one which is cooler that's quite literally what she told me so um so they're
024and even the kids with the speaker kits there I had one student who was like I'm so excited to take this back to my classroom and rock out all day to it I'll have to forewarn their teachers I think about that one as well um but the cool thing about these kits and why I am hoping at least I'm going to continue doing what I need to do to provide these for my kids as long as I can is because it's helping them to develop critical thinking skills using their hands not just tapping a screen and I'm watching their brains in the way they're thinking and communicating with each other change and it's remarkable quite honestly and it's exciting and what more how cool is it to say that like you made a ukulele at
025in school because this is another one so um I put a couple pictures in so we could see those this is from last year's fifth grade you can see how intently they are focusing screwing in those pegs each design is a little different because I just I give them paint and stain the stain was actually um donated by the Sherwin Williams on the North side so kudos to them couldn't have done that part without them either and then this is this years so as you can see very similar that super you can see the focus and this happens all the way through like even today they're sitting there and when they learned that they could play songs like ho he and Roar by Katie Perry all of a sudden the ukulele became that much cooler
026not even kidding one of these kids on there was like what so so honestly I'm I'm very thrilled that I was able to have this opportunity by STEM 101 I super excited I was able to share what this project is doing in my classroom with all of you and um honestly I could I could keep going but because that's the every piece of these projects is it's done so many wonderful things in our school so thank you and this is all done in music class right um yes the ukuleles and the speakers are yes the other kits are done through Steam lab or kind of to replace some of the hpl time that doesn't happen as hpl time um so and then I have a couple teachers who needed an extension on their science curriculum
027so they asked for like some of the Hydroponics and those kits so I kind of disperse them so questions and comments from the board um as a parent of a a lacrosse student who has whose career is in stem um she's not an architectural engineer I I'm always excited to hear about these programs um couple and so thank you for what you're doing and it's very clear like this Everybody Talks at this table about the generation this generation likes to do and be involved and have their hands involved so I can imagine the excitement that happens in your classroom um so um you mentioned to become an engineer in four years that that happen it it can yes I I was just thinking of my a family member that I had and it's taken taken
028my family member a tad bit longer but yes but you're correct yeah it can so it it can happen is possible yes 100% it is possible um the other point and it's a minor point but I want to clarify because um uh Ron and Joyce were neighbors of uh a family member of mine so it's w n e kic is how it's pronounced okay I just wanted to be clear and give them the recognition I'm sure Ashley's very excited about this because they want to Workforce that does Hands-On things so and and I do know um that Ronald and Joyce are also I cuz I met with Ashley today and she had told the representative had told me they are very very compassionate and giving and very um interested in this program and what it
029brings to schools as well very generous people yes absolutely other questions or comments I think it's on okay hi um I know you mentioned that you talked a little bit about the things that you had to do as a requirement of the grant for followup and that it makes it 100% worth it and at the same time I think you deserve a huge kudos for going through the steps and the effort it takes to submit Grant requests and do the followup and do things like put this presentation together for our board and it's clear that your students are gaining a massive impact from your efforts and I just thank you that's awesome thank you good point Mr new Meister um I'd like to go off that a little bit first off you said the passion
030it's showing I think uh the passion is obviously with the teacher that's giving those out because you can see it in you and you you you obviously take a lot of pride in this and it's it's remarkable that we're able to do this for the kids and so thank you for everything you're doing yeah thank you anything else guess the only question I have for you is could you talk a little bit about any types of Partnerships you have with other teachers within on the North side building and how this project can help benefit those Partnerships yeah yeah so um so our librarian who also runs the steam lab partnered with her and she's remarkable she is like all over the Arduino kits which is fantastic um and she also Incorporated every time the kids
031come in for steam lab or when she does extra activities with the students that are more Hands-On during that Library time she'll bring out some of those kits to work with the students on so like last year they I walked and they were doing a Building Systems one they were learning the circuits she is the one who helped them test the batteries um they're all sectioned off by teacher and so we know that all those work now which is delightful um partnered with the koui monor E2 team um to help enrich and expand their sixth grade curriculum and they I think this year they're using the Arduino kit and hydroponics and measurement kits are the three that they're going to use in their classrooms and then the remaining kits the our um coordinator in our
032building our community coordinator is helping with because she's helping to implement those during inter session for the smaller groups of students that are there that could benefit from a more Hands-On project so she helps to figure out what teacher would be a great fit for a kit that has some extras and um that's not being used by other teachers and she works diligently on getting those out to those kids wonderful so yeah any final thoughts or comments from the board thank you hearing none thank you very very much thank you appreciate it all right the next item on our agenda is the approval of the superintendent's consent agenda so the K excuse me the consent agenda is a mechanism that is used by the board to deal with routine business that comes before the body
033are there any items that the members want to remove from the consent agenda Miss Su um I'd like to remove the um act 143 as well as the um architectural memo okay any others all right so let's proceed and we will move to approve the HR approvals and the Logan High School bleacher project award um is there a motion to that effect I'll make a motion to approve second all right move by Mr new Meister seconded by Mr M to approve the uh HR approvals and the Logan High School bleacher project Award of construction bid any discussion hearing none all those in favor please signify by saying I all those opposed motion is carried let's start with the ACT 143 requirements by the Department of Justice Miss Sula you wanted to break pull those off
034yeah I just think it's important that the public know a little bit more about this would superintendent Engle just be able to give us a little summary of what this is about I we are fortunate to have the subject matter expert here if uh Mr Lina Miss Andress would want to come up and just chat a little bit about this requirement that would be great good evening what can I help with I just was looking for a summary so the public knows what what it is that we're approving this evening what why this document is important for us to improve sure the ACT 143 um basically is um it's the school violence drill um which is um we talked about this uh the hold secure lockdown each school is required to do a hold or
035a standard response protocol which is what this is um every semester in the fall semester and the spring semester and this report or this drill is um the report that goes with that and then I submit that to um to DPI so we're certifying through this process that we've met the requirements of act 143 to conduct the safety drills uh in accordance with the law and I'm thankful for Miss endress for keeping track of all this because it's uh there's a lot of schools and a lot of things going on and making sure we check those boxes as important and give the training our students need to be safe exactly anything else this is a rather routine matter but in light of the recent event I just want the public to be aware of the
036efforts that are being done by the district so I'd make a motion to approve the 143 report is there a second second is that who was that okay thank you move by Muka seconded by Dr spr to approve the ACT 143 requirements by the Department of Justice office of school safety with no other discussion all those in favor please signify by saying I I all those opposed motion is carried and we'll move on to the bray architectural report and I'll turn over missla again you wanted to pull this off the agenda sure uh there's a lengthy discussion at the last meeting about uh getting bids and um again just wanted to provide some more information for the public to follow up on that discussion on what the administration has done absolutely um so we provided
037an updated memo to talk about our process um you know the school district recommends continuing with Bray Architects for architectural services for the elementary school updates um just like any other business or School District once we found a quality affordable service or product we continue with that same chosen resource uh without rebidding for that service or product and the reason are many but we continue with that chosen resource because there's substantial benefits in maintaining continuity and familiarity when we're satisfied with the outcome a great example is with our Skyward student information system software it's an expensive software program that we have to use to manage all of our student information we could bid it out every year and and use a different student information system each year the ramifications for our school district are it
038would be devastating to try and do that on an annual basis you generally find a product that you're satisfied with and you continue to work with that product you know year-over-year um and when you make a change like that it will be the only thing you think about for months or years in some cases and so there's lots of different things on different scales right where we've identified a great partner we've chosen a product typically through a bidding process and we continue to work with that service or product uh continuously into the future other examples are student and staff devices uh varieties of software Legal Services Waste Management cleaning supplies property insurance health insurance restorative justice Services after school programs law enforcement educational materials lots of different things um and of course we always reserve
039the right to go to bid or choose another product or another service if we're unsatisfied uh with um the those services and there's times when we're just not sure that we're getting the value that we need to we go out to bid regularly for auditor Services because we know that there's a large Variety in the the costs for some of those Services over time on occasion we've been unsatisfied with a product or a service in our community and we've gone to bid to see if we can find something else that's better uh and sometimes we're just not certain of rates you know costs inflation we're not sure where things are at and so we go to bid to make sure that we're providing the best value uh for our um Community um so we bid
040out architectural services in 201 12 for the Norths Side Elementary project and we've been working continuously with uh Bray architecture Bray Architects since then on numerous projects and um uh both Joe and I could talk at length about the positive interactions we've had and how they've supported us through numerous projects uh referendum processes uh and been fully satisfied with the quality of the work and continuously with their competitive rates um and you know as we think about you know potentially going to bid on some of these things when we are satisfied when we do know that the rates are good it starts to cause some question we don't know what types of bids we'll get you know if others um think it's a performative process you know like oh they already work with that group
041so why would I even bid um and it could create an unfavorable impression of the school district potentially if people think it it's performative as well or perfunctory um Bray Architects has been instrumental uh in all of the preliminary design work and estimates for this Elementary upgrade as as well as support through the referendum process uh we want to ensure we are still providing the best value and the results of our rate analysis indicate that bra rates continue to remain competitive um in addition to offering competitive pricing that assures the best value is obtained for the district their ongoing successful work and familiarity with the district warrant a continuation of a relationship with BR Architects for this project happy to field any questions around that well we didn't get bids you've gotten some ideas of
042what rates were charged for other um school projects at different times even a half a percent difference is about $270,000 which pays for probably about three staff so even a tiny change like that is a substantial amount of money um the last time we got a bid was 12 years ago um we were told at the last meeting that they were we had a great architect we were working with at the time um I think we had a good relation ship with them um but we went to bid because we had a building project and we got a number of of biders so I think to say that I don't know why the suggestion that it' be performative was thrown out there um I I really wish we would have gone to bid I think
043that's the right thing to do it's the fair thing to do I it's no representation on the work that Bray does any more than a dozen years ago it was a representation of the work that that architect did um I'm I am disappointed that we for project this big for this much money we didn't go and get bids I get why you don't do bids on some other things for the district um but I it's unclear to me why we could do it 12 years ago and now we can't do it other comments on board members I have I too um question it a little bit I I do understand that you're loyal to them and and they're loyal to you but my concern is you You' brought up that they start to question why
044we go out for bids and you know might other Architects may or may not but our taxpayers also question it I would assume so I think we really need to be careful on uh to make sure and I'm not saying you're not and and and I'm sure you're fully aware of where the bids may fall but I think uh I think putting them out for bids is the right thing to do I know the city does it every time they build something and I think uh which you know was brought up if it's a smaller project totally understand it but this this is a big Venture and and I think we owed it to um not only other Architects but also our taxpayers to make sure that we are getting the be not only the
045best value but the best price and and even if it's close and then you choose Bray that that's fine but but at least we're doing our duty to our taxpayers to make sure we're getting the best deal I'd only push it back on the loyal comment loyalty is not an issue here it's about the best service and the best value and that's why we continue to work with them okay and and I wasn't saying that you you're thinking that I could have swore you said that that other was Will question why we're going out for bids that's what exactly that's why I'm saying that's what I meant by the Loyalty part why would they question it the loyalty is still with Bray or whomever but I think going out for bids is just the normal
046thing thing to do for any any uh city government or most companies for that fact and I would say it's not always the case with schools I'd say maybe maybe half but once you've usually picked a partner that's who you work with longterm and in most school districts I've been in if you're satisfied with the services that you've received from a uh a construction management firm from a contractor from a architectural firm the standard practice and my experience has been to continue to work with that same partner because they know history they have all the background knowledge the startup time's a lot lower uh and uh they're able to be that continuing ongoing partner it's like with legal services we could pick a different legal firm every year but then when I call on the
047next thing I've got to start over from scratch it's going to take me 45 minutes to give them the background on a on a human resources issue um that could have taken 10 minutes and now I've cost the taxpayers more money and so these savings that you anticipate they may not come to fruition because we're going to have all this startup cost with a new partner that we're working with uh and so I certainly want to ensure that we're providing the best possible outcome for our our taxpayers but part of that involves continuity with a provider and I would just confer that I think it's good to have a number of bids in front of you so that you can assure the taxpayer that you're doing your due diligence I mean I agree with what
048you said but at the same time having having another company come in in place of bid I don't see that that's harmful matter of fact it would protect our reputation I guess Dr spr I can I can see that concern as well I mean at the last meeting I voiced the same thing that our process calls for you know going going to bid in these kinds of situations I also recognize I think the significant investment that Bray has already made in this particular project that the familiarity they have with it with our needs and our expectations so Aon uh Dr angal excuse me my uh my question for you would be um what what would what would it look like if there were a compelling reason um like if if absent the bidding process how
049do we identify when there is a compelling reason to to choose a different provider of switch services so one would be rates right so our understanding of the rates in the area we're fortunate to have a great network of contacts as superintendents as facility managers and directors uh to talk with our peers and we give phone calls like hey how did things go with your architect how did things go with um your construction management from what were the rates that you got and we share those freely with each other because we're all interested in what's best for kids for our communities and so we know the rates that are out there for projects uh and we have that assessment right up front you know we don't need to go to bid to understand what a
050project of similar size or scope was bid at we know what was bid in our communities um and then it's a matter of the quality of the service that's provided we've had Services provided to the school district in a variety of areas and I hesitate to get into specific names and circumstances because I'm not trying to you know undermine the business of people in our community but when we're not satisfied we choose a different direction and you know Joe Lina can certainly speak to probably half a dozen dozen circumstances where we've gone out to bid to seek something else um uh and it could be anything on this list of things that I've identified that we have either continued with or gone back out to bid over time we've chosen different software we've chosen different
051educational materials we've chosen different Waste Management providers over time all of these contracts and some add up to well over $100,000 while we're working with them or even in a given year as it relates to like a student information system you know so if we're unhappy we absolutely seek something out um if we're satisfied and it's meeting our needs and we know that our rates are competitive we could continue with it because the cost of disruption is substantial and it would be needless to incur that cost on our staff on our schools on our community on our taxpayers other comments when you say substantial what what does that mean cost to be substantial um if we let's say that our project got delayed a month month and a half you know in order to go
052to bid um be questionable you know then whether or not we're able to complete our transfer out of Hogan over to Central in a timely fashion we might not be able to demolish this building you know before winter uh maybe our winter conditions now have increased the cost for that while they have to put in foundations through tarping and heaters and that adds up it's a 10,000 here 40,000 there and next thing you know You' spent an extra $200,000 in costs that would not have to have been occurred if we had uh an efficient process from the start working with a company that we trust and rely on and know provides a good value to our school district Dr so Mr Lina I I had asked in the last meeting when we were talking about
053that 5% versus seven seven and a half% some of those rates do you have some some concrete examples you could give us in comparison just to um we did I think the superintendent sent those out in an email we're reluctant to share them I I will say this and and it's very important to say is that Bray was instrumental in the process of us even going to referendum and so we made no mistake about that during our referendum presentations that we were working with our architect Bray uh the Integrity of the process is really important the other thing I do want to tell you is that um we wouldn't be going out for bid we' doing an RFP a request for proposal there's so much more than just the percentage that we're talking about we're
054talking about bid submitt right we're talking about that process we're talking about bid specifications and how many addendums go out we're talking about change orders a good example would be with Bray at the Northside Elementary School we had five change orders in those five change orders we saved $150,000 okay when we did um the Hamilton uh addition we had zero change orders when we did the office addition at Central we had two change orders mainly because we changed the scope of the work during the process thinking we wanted something a little different and so there's a lot more that goes into the RFP I want to be very careful as we talk about that than the bid process because there's so much more that can cost you money in the process um when you talk
055in terms of even putting out the bid specs and the process proc and then how many addendums do occur between now and when you get the bids in and I all those things are a major part of they cost you money in the long run so it's not just that percentage I think Joe's talking about change orders just to demonstrate that we the design that Bray has provided is the design that we went with and often times we were able to save money they were you know um transparent about their process and met our needs up front so there weren't like hidden costs later on and so we know that we trust them to work through these projects and if that's the case and their rates are competitive it would take a Monumental demonstration of
056quality for us to even consider changing when we have this strong partnership who's already demonstrated success on Project after project after project if you've got a plumber at your house that you use consistently and they you trust them they diagnose things well they they make the changes you need and you've used them for 10 years you might be able to get a cheaper rate with somebody else but are you going to take the risk when you've got the person you trust and the rates are competitive one one of the things we did in 2012 when we did the architect uh RFP uh we had just had not built a building in 20 years so it was the first time we had done any really major we did the addition at State Road school we used
057a different architect firm uh they did a fine job but we thought there were some areas they could Pro in so we did the RFP with that the product was still good but we had some things that in construction management things that could have been better and so we went to that RFP but the main reason we did that is because we hadn't done any major Construction in the district for over 20 years anything else yeah I would just say that um as far as the timeline when we built the Northside School it was approved in November uh we did get bids and the building was done in time so um there wasn't the process of moving like this and quite frankly if Bray did did this project uh moving Central um and the other
058two big pieces of the State Road and the the new building um were done um under bids I think might make some sense um but we got it got it done in time and yeah at home we do things differently than a government entity does we have a lot of different rules than what we use at home so of course that would be a different type of decision absolutely and I would argue that we are complying with our rules we have gone to bid to select this architect and much like many other services in our school district we're continuing we're recommending continuation of that same service as we move forward I think the only thing I would add to this conversation is that I struggle with the conversation as a whole in that I I
059hear the concern regarding going to bid but I also hear in the conversation what seems to be a question about the trust or Integrity of our Administration they are experts they understand the work they've been part of this district for a long time they are definitely here for the students for the community to ensure safety to ensure quality so I also think we need to consider are these questions on Integrity or are they truly questions of curiosity and I think that we as a board and me included needs to re reexamine what is our purpose as board members what is our work what work is within our scope what is the work within the scope of the administration we hold the administration accountable based upon policy and so at this point I just would ask
060the board members to really reconsider what the purpose of the questions are why we are focused so deeply on minutia as opposed to focusing on the policy which is the work that is done at this board level I find it offensive that you are suggesting our question or anything other than we're trying to do due process and do what the public expects us to do in being very open and transparent I appreciate that I also think our Administration finds it offensive with the types of questions we've been asking for the last six months or more so that's why I raise it any other questions or comments um I was one of the folks who was curious about the whole bid thing with an architect last week um I appreciate the table that you sent that
061showed the different districts around our County and what they've seen as rates recently as I recall I think only on Alaska had a very slightly lower rate than what Bray is proposing um I mean I guess I see both sides and I I do feel like it is a genuine just like the maybe you know part of our responsibility as board members to ensure that we're being fiscally responsible and yet at the same time Joe brought up a bit a good point that when we had all of our referendum information sessions that quite a few of them we did acknowledge to folks who are asking that we were intending to use Bray as the architect so I don't know I mean I personally feel comfortable moving forward with Bray um I think the value that
062we gain by going with somebody that we've worked with so many times and have a strong working relationship with and we don't need to catch them up to speed with what our values are um I think that that's a value add enough that it doesn't bother me that on Alaska was 2% lower than ra bid or something like yeah I don't remember what it was exactly but um this is a this is a big deal project and it's great to work with somebody that we trust so I would vote to I would well I I I would agree with you I think I I appreciate the procedural question because it's important to be checking ourselves but I think absent a compelling reason or evidence that we're unsatisfied with their work that we have reason to
063believe a better value is out there and that's why I I know we have we had the percentages in front of us but is there some reason we don't want to share them publicly that's fine um but yeah but if we're if we're reasonably assured that the standard of of service that we we've been receiving is what's going to continue and that it is is competitive on the market I think that the value gained in in continuing that relationship and in moving our projects forward uh satisfies the public concern that we are being fiscally responsible and we would go to bid for the construction part right right absolutely yep there's enough variability when it comes to construction costs and there's so many different ways that those Services can be provided uh that that is an
064area we will definitely be going going to bid uh we still have to evaluate how exactly we want to tackle that but um there's a lot of different people in our community and broader that could provide a lot of these Services I know one of the things we were proud about with Northside or Hamilton was preference for local work try and keep people in our community employed and that's one of the nice things we can approach with a bidding process uh is to seek that out because there are so many quality builders in our area any other comments I would move to approve the bray architectural services continuation memo number two is there a second I'll second move by Miss bodal seconded by Dr spr to approve the bray architectural services continuation membo number two
065all those in favor please signify by saying I I I all those opposed nay motion is carried and we'll move on to the board consent agenda is there a motion on this I move to approve the items on the board consent agenda as presented is there a second second moved by Miss bodal second by Mr Alberts to approve the items on the board consent agenda as presented any discussion hearing none all those in favor please signify by saying I I I all those opposed motion has carried and we'll move on to the matters reserve for board to action the first being operational expectation monitoring report oe4 Personnel Administration and at this point we have already heard this report and so we are just making a motion uh to either uh Mark that we are in
066compliance in compliance with exception to noted or not in compliance is there a motion on oe4 in regard to the monitoring report for policy oe4 Personnel Administration and with respect to the provisions of policy bsr5 superintendent accountability the Board of Education concludes that the superintendent and District are in compliance with exceptions noted I make the motion so stated I forgot the first part of that no you you did great so U moved by Dr spr is there a second a second okay so move by Dr spr second Mr breski to approve um oe4 uh to be in compliance with exceptions noted as Dr sprig stated any discussion on this item yes sir I don't know this Falls in line there but do we have any I don't know I'm going to say Minority Report in
067terms of if it's talking about Staffing how many minorities do we have in the district working for us great question and I think think that's something we cover let me see if I can find it I know that that is an area that the school district has um wanted a representative School District right so as a child when you come into our schools you can see yourself in our staff um one of the challenges that we find with that particular um representation indicator 3 under OE 4.3 racial diversity will continue to increase from a baseline of 5.7 toward its desired redate goal of 10% so our our goal is set at 10% % because that's the percentage of the adult population in our community that is um of color or identifies as of color even
068though our student population is 30% and so we would love you know to have a a representative staff that met that 30% threshold but when we're recruiting against a base of 10 10% you know that's kind of where we're at for right now we'd like to achieve that and we're on our way and we've made some progress let's see it was at 5.76% last year it's at 6.77% this year here um to be clear it is not uniform across staff groups and um I think uh in our support staff group you know the ratio is a little bit higher than our our certified teaching staff group you know so there's areas of disparity even within there but certainly a goal and a focus that we have we're thankful to have continually climbed in that regard
069and we're always seeking new processes and procedures that lower the bar barrier for folks that maybe have been historically excluded from schools and also to actively recruit folks so that um when you're a kid you walk into our building you see yourself here you know so uh something that we're proud of the progress that we're making and we also know that we have a ways to go um years ago in the old days we used to have like I'm I'm going to call a minority coordinator uh a person of color that would come in and sometimes talk to groups of students and so on and I know that there were different times for instance if the student was saying that there was a problem here uh this person would step in and really kind of
070look at both sides and let you know what's going on in in his or her mind so we don't have that position any longer do we um it may maybe a transitioned over the years but we have now our what are called cultural family leaon uh wonderful program that we've had through funded for many years um uh uh Mr Tony Yang has been one of the stalwarts of that program connecting our M Community to our school district and we've had a series of of great um uh folks who identify as Black Or Hispanic serve uh in the other role and right now we have a wonderful teacher and Miss Laura avalara who helps coordinate uh that program as well you know so we have two folks in our school district who have helped support those
071family cultural connections good unaware of that any other conversation hearing none all those in favor please signify by saying I I I all those oppos OS the motion is carried and we'll move on to results monitoring report R2 academic performance and is there a motion in regard to this one whether we are making reasonable progress toward the achieving desired results making reasonable Pro excuse me progress with exceptions noted or failing to make reasonable progress can I try again yes I move that in regard to the monitoring report for policy R2 academic performance with respect to the provisions of policy bsr5 superintendent accountability am I on the wrong one no I am not the Board of Education concludes that the superintendent and District R making reasonable progress with the exceptions noted thank you is there a
072second so we'll go moved by Dr spr seconded by Miss burad doll to uh approve R2 with making reasonable progress with the exceptions noted is there any discussion on this one again right before the meeting started we were having kind of a conversation here and this gives us as a school district it gives School District people some information teacher if they look at it and so on administrator but it says like 20% are Advanced 35% are proficient and I don't know I've been reading more and more and as a building principal I once did this in terms of individualize growth so we talk about growth of each students so we could say if we went along and from what I understand there's 23 States now doing this but they would look at it in terms
073of Hey listen 50% of our kids grew from last year to this year now I know the calculations are pretty difficult sometimes it's hard for I'm going to say this general public to understand all of that but at the same time I think it would really be good to take a look at it I don't know what that all means and I'm not going to be at the computer figuring it out but I just think you know we used to have bar graphs for every kid in the school and we'd give them a reading test and when the first day of school they were here in the second and then at the quarter break we'd give them another assessment did the student grow or not and if the student didn't grow then what are we
074going to do differently and so uh it was really an excellent source uh of knowledge for the teacher the student the parent and so on and so if we could start maybe taking a look at the growth type program to say our students are growing in these areas and we could come back and say 80% of our students grew proficient grew last year yeah and I I would just say to that before I jump in Dr angle um is that yes and I as you well know I always appreciate the conversation of assessment and you know and I mentioned that uh the challenge with the state exams is that we're comparing two different groups of students as opposed to the individual student as you're describing the results the way it's written currently as our indicators
075used the state exam so that's why in this report we are stuck with that but but I hear you that I think you know you're absolutely right I think that's a better measure I think you know looking at individual growth is always going to be better uh and I think you know our faculty are definitely looking at that but that's the only reason that R2 does not necessarily get to that level but I to bring absolutely and it's a great Point say squeeze our data get L squishy I I've definitely heard from Schoolboard members kind of consistent pattern interest in maybe slightly different ways to look at achievement data uh one thing is within your growth of individual students that is something that we do track through a local assessments that we can provide some
076information on another thing I've heard folks mention is um you know the 8th grade assessment tracks you know last year's eighth graders and then Compares it to this year's eighth graders that's not the same cohort as students correct you know it's not seventh graders who are then tested as eighth graders so I've also heard an interest in cohort data it takes us a little while to process that and uh Mr fight and I are in the process of gathering up those analyses and data and we intend to provide kind of an interim R2 report to the school board here in the in the late winter or early winter I don't know next year um that includes different ways to look at that data and if the school board is interested we can then kind of
077reassess our monitoring indicators here and either make them more robust or you know indicate multiple measures will be used or something so we'll have an opportunity here in the next couple of months uh to present more robust data like you're talking about Mr beg neski and like others have mentioned at this board table and even though it takes time you're still way faster than the state coming back with their state with the tests which I it I don't understand this day and age of Technology why it takes so long but yeah we can't even start our analysis until November hon you know it's very frustrating I agree missla thank you I was just going to say I agree with Mr bnavi entirely I think a both and kind of situation here for in terms of
078our reporting would be really helpful I think there's there's usefulness for the district in having the cohort data although for for the public wanting to understand are our kids achieving it's less helpful because the comparison is not a clear one right whereas that that sense of individual growth which doesn't always work well with Benchmark you know settings but indicates that an individual student or hopefully all individual students are are succeeding where we want them to be succeeding and that success is going to look different for many many many of our students I think that would be great to get that picture we also heard an interest in like a cohort other school districts kind of like us and so that'll be some other comparative data that we can bring so that the school board it's
079it's not necessarily fair to compare lacrosse to Bangor right just size scale scope much different they can have much more variability in a year than we can because we're a much larger entity and so comparing us to something like fondel laac Wisconsin Rapids Mana may be of greater value than some of our more Regional comparisons which are a half a quarter or an ather size not to get super into a rabbit hole on how we're analyzing data but one of the within since I started when I first started we were still seeing 2019 data show up in these um results just because of the span of years that we were grabbing but now that fallen off but I at the time found it really helpful to kind of see that preco marker to compare how
080far we've come back from that and is that something you're still looking at we we still do comparison cohort is I mean we can follow a a students all the way all the way through and we've got a a couple systems that are in place to do that um that teachers use that to you know basically inform their instruction so um it's not based on the wison son forward exam it's more based on our Universal um type like I ready um we got am webs coming online here too so um but that's relatively easy data for us to to pull um we want to look at growth we want to look at you name it we can we can generally pull it our challenge as we have progressed through time is the state will change
081the test or we change the test locally and so you know is it still Apples to Apples can be a challenge and now they've just changed the benchmarks at the state level to make them that's right it it's a probably a good change that makes sense on a on a broader scale but it means that we can't compare our data to the past eight years you know so that's frustrating too you know especially as a school board that's looking for that progress and that Improvement you know I think mukla is always wise and looking at the Gap with the state average as like a way to to think about things we can also maybe look at cohorts like our cohort like how are we doing relative to similar school districts you know over time like
082there's a number of ways to tackle that you know but uh they don't make it easy yeah I think and just to jump in one of the other advantages of individual growth is because this is about the student I can convince as student you have to do well this is your marker here versus you're taking this say why do I care what would make the school look good I'm not into the school I'm into me and so that motivation type thing might might help and I I think a good point angle is the point you made regarding that the state has changed benchmarks because I remember previous boards around this table talking about what is reasonable progress and especially during the pandemic times it was hard to create what we talked about which was like
083a three-year average and reviewing that trend line and determining whether that trend line was trending correctly the way we wanted it to or not and so we got deep into the Weeds about the word reasonable so um I think that that is not that is not something the board should shy away from it's talking about what does it mean to be reasonable what does this board determine to be reasonable but I also appreciate um that you and the administrative team will be looking at different ways to present data which will give us a broad picture of the students that we serve and how they are achieving so I appreciate that any other comments on R2 the results monitoring report okay having said that and hearing no other comments then I believe the motion was number
084two that we are uh going to approve this R2 as making reasonable progress with exceptions noted am I correct okay so all those in favor please signify by saying I I all those oppose motion has carried and just a reminder while we are here that starting in January as we review operational expectations um unless it is broken up like usually uh OE 10 or oe1 is broken up um we will be talking about and voting on those policies in the same meeting so we will not have this conversation at one meeting and then voting in another it will all happen the thing that will be different um be at the same is that even though we will vote on the policy in one meeting the next meeting is where we'll talk about the intended changes
085to the policy so just like we're doing now we will have that at a different meeting so that's the only thing that's split and yes ma'am just to clarify the process there so in this last year we've seen a lot of examp of the administration making suggested changes to the policies but if we wanted to what would the process look like for that would we just let you know or is that something we need to talk about it it would be the same that at the time the administration is bringing up changes the board members can also bring up changes so they can bring them in at the same time so the next week correct so like if this was the January what is it January 6th is our next meeting so at the January
0866th meeting if talking about oe7 for example we will hear the presentation we will vote and then at the January 26th 27th meeting we would come back and talk about any intended changes so they would always be on the agenda whether the administration had changes or not just to give us an opportunity to correct in the past there have been times where the administration had no changes it would still on there okay just in case so yes definitely cuz you never know when a board member might bring one sometimes they let me know sometimes they don't so at least we would know that there's a placeholder for the conversation okay thank you I appreciate you're welcome all right moving on to the information uh so this is where we're talking about proposed changes I believe
087other than the general changes that we've been making to all operational expectations there's no others is that correct Dr Engle that is correct I don't think any of the indicators are changing it's just the definitions and the interpretations being removed Etc definitions and interpretations that is correct okay any uh conversation from the board regarding those proposed changes just for oe4 this is for oe4 y any questions or concerns okay hearing none then we'll move on to uh results monitoring report R2 and here we do have not only changes to definitions and the superintendent interpretation but we do have changes to the indicators I believe starting with r2.2 so if I could turn it over to either Dr angle or Mr fimrite to discuss those yeah so um like the other monitoring reports are to we
088took out the interpretations updated the um the uh definitions to more relevance and clearer expectations for students performance there was a few tweaks made of the language in r2.2 indicator 1 through3 and then indicator 2.2 R1 through or sorry indicator 1 through three the language was adjusted to uh consistenly aligned with expectations for all indicators with the board and superintendent accountability and to improve and enhance the readability for the stakeholders so my my understanding of the change is just we removed increase over the prior year to be demonstrate reasonable achievement or growth yeah say more yes I was going to say we're back to reasonable progress which always feels like it like I thought we changed it from reasonable Pro progress to incre because when I okay when the languages demonstrate reasonable progress and I
089I'm looking at the data I am looking for an increase from one year to the next so it could definitely be an indication of reasonable progress and let's say we're going to talk about like multiple measures too right so like let's say there's like four different ways to look at it there's annualized growth there's cohort data and there's academic achievement data what is reasonable progress look like then if it's different with different things um another thing might be it did increase over the last year but our four-year trajectory continues to be upwards and so we're still 10 points over four years ago but maybe there was a spike one year on our state achievement data because a cohort of students who took it was particularly engaged that year you know and so the longer term
090Trend shows progress you might want to say yeah we're we're we're doing we're headed in the right direction you know a onee down doesn't mean we're going down forever when you're up doesn't mean like it's going to go on forever right it just makes it a little bit more up to interpretation so having context it's on us I think and I was I brought mine out to make the point oh totally I think I think as I remember the discussion that uh the demonstrating reasonable achievement or growth gave us the flexibility to determine that and the the intra cohort data I think that that achievement data that you mentioned like we're at a point where when we're if we're if what we're looking for is just percentile growth year-over-year we're going to have a challenge
091with that as our cohort sizes change uh with our demographic Trends the possibility for more significant not sampling error but you're a mathematician you know what I'm saying right and the assessment sometimes changes from year to year too depending exactly right so it just gives you guys more ability to so to to Mr begy's point about the last the last one being able to see student achievement within you know comparing them to themselves year end to the beginning of the year I think that's where for my money I'm going to find reasonable progress being able to look within those you know those reference groups yeah and I think your point is well taken if you have multiple measures right if you have one measure which is what we have currently which is the state assessment
092exam maybe the reasonable thing to do is is our trend line similar to the states and if the state is trending down and we're trending down or we staying similar to the state is that necessarily reasonable growth or not right so just because the trend line is going in the wrong direction quote unquote and the negative direction does not necessarily mean it's not reasonable growth given Trend so I mean it's yeah so it's it it's squishy it is challenging but it's the beauty of assessment and multiple measures that's why it signals at multiple measures is the best way to go Sor indicator one for R 2.3 we indicated that we did not meet reasonable progress largely because we had overcounted things in the past and so when we modified that for the current you know
093when it says we'll increase over the prior year we did not do that but it's because we increased our hurdle for that year we think it'll swing back the next year because we'll it'll be an Apples to Apples comparison again but with a a squishier opportunity then the board could say like it's reasonable achievement we understand that this thing happened and we're willing to overlook that for a year if it doesn't continue next year we would have to you know be more serious about it but when it says increase over prior year we couldn't honestly say that that happened and I think I think that flexibility is important as we you know learned several years ago a once once in A- lifetime pandemic throws a huge wrench in in our statistics and so our ability
094to account for at the board table what's going on in the world that is impacting our students the burden is on us absolutely but I think that's where it belongs right to to make that interpretation and to to provide that oversight I would say I have some the similar concerns that Miss bural has but um I can't remember which report it was but again because of the the way the language was written it was about the increase and it wasn't our fault the staff's fault um and so we had to um say that there were exceptions and that's certainly frustrating for staff for a year I'd be willing to give this a whirl I guess let's see what what what happens in a year and maybe a year from now we're going to be we
095want to go back to we'll be right back here yeah I mean but it's I think it's worth looking and giving it a Year's try but I'm okay with that and I also believe Dr Angel this is the are that you're talking about that we may be looking at some different measures anyway so this one might come back with some changes about what measures we're going to be using so it's not just a state exam yep we're going to bring back an interim monitoring report that has a lot of different ways to cut the achievement data so that you can get a flavor of what's possible and then if there's things that the board is interested in including it'll be an opportunity to change our indicators at that time you know it'll be a couple
096months down the road we'll still have plenty of time to gather the data and analyze it so that won't be in any issue to change those indicators three months from now corre I think that's just a good reminder for the board too is because I mean in the past and all along when we have questions about the results and think maybe the results aren't showing reasonable proess then someone at the board table will surely say well what is reasonable progress yes um to have Folks at the table who are skilled and experienced at data analysis and looking at things differently like Trevor that's one thing I always appreciate about you and others at the board table is that you're more skilled and experienced in that area than I am so just it's no secret I'm
097not running for reelection like for those of you carrying this work forward um I just would encourage everyone to keep looking at more than just the base level what s certain data points are showing us and dig deeper in to the bigger picture of what's going on and to remember that we don't have to always agree with what reasonable progress is like we can it is fairly vague so if yeah that's part of the importance of these discussions at the board table is determining together what we agree is reasonable agreed yeah I think your Point's really important especially for uh measuring an our report the result I think looking at an OE is a different kind of conversation but I I think you're spot on for how we look at the results monitoring any other
098comments yes Mr Alber my question is and maybe this was explained and I missed it in a previous meeting but how is this data being collected is this just an additional like kind of questionnaire that students will have to answer as a part of an in-class reflection or is this a kind of changed um oh curriculum um I probably won't have to deal with this cuz I'll be gone but but you have been yes but my siblings will still have to and what should kind of the students of Lacrosse expect is it going to be a change or is it just going to be a difference in collection so one of the concerns that the board has had over the years is not creating new obligations for teachers and students and so trying to use
099pre-existing opportunities to gather data and um all of the assessments and the results are to are pre-existing assessments that we're obligated to do already so the state tests for uh W um uh Wisconsin forward test that the act the prea you know these are tests that are required by the state that our students have to take you have to take already and so it's not an additional burden it's something that you would see naturally and then we're just taking that data analyzing it and Reporting it to the school board um some of the things that we're talking about like um I don't know if you've taken I ready or you know so that's a an assessment that we use within uh our school district to help inform teachers and how to modify their practice and
100help students learn so that's another assessment that we already use we're required to use something like that for kindergarten through third grade by law as a part of the achievement Gap reduction uh process you know so some of it's already required some of it we continue because we find it provides good feedback to teachers to adjust their instructions so that students continue to learn um on the results policy three the you know the citizenship one there are some Assessments in there that you might find in an eighth grade social studies class or a 10th grade science class what we call curriculum based measures so it's within the curriculum it's a special test written by our teachers that we try and Implement uniformly across their students and so every 10th grader will take this test we'll
101analyze the results see how we did year toe uh and I think we it was I think you might have been here when we had that conversation around like um you know positionality social location you know under how you understand people around you social emotional learning you know those are locally crafted tests not implemented by the state but locally so that we could assess our own internal goals and so those are kind of unique additional requirements that we place upon ourselves uh that students may see but most of our other sources of information are reestablished already existing requirements um by the state or internally to do good work other questions or comments hearing none then we will move on to the next item an information the discussion on the proceeds of the sale of Lincoln
102Middle School so this is something we started last meeting and we are bringing forward again this meeting so um I guess I'll just open up uh either Dr Engle if you want to give some more information or anybody wants to start with the conversation yeah I was super excited by the conversation last meeting just to kind of start the exploration process of these funds uh I I learned a little bit more as I um investigated some options with Patty heard some great ideas by school board members on different ways uh to potentially use these funds uh and what I did find was if the funds are allocated into fund 42 which is like a capital Improvement fund it does not impact our mill rate for the next year so I think that's historically where we've
103kind of lodged These funds so that it wouldn't become an issue with um tax rates in the following slid is a safe place to kind of like store it while decisions are made but once it goes in there it stays in there you know so that's one of those the only challenge with that so some of the other potential uses of these uh these monies you know some decisions would be have to made you know by the sale of the the the the property and then what I did here was just aon's analysis along with our Administration just to kind of think about it in a different way and I I used a process that we I've used in other places for kind of a course of action analysis kind of trying to take a
104complicated thing and assess it and uh just tried to create some up downs some plus minuses some quantification just trying to do an assessment just to help folks think about this in different ways and you can agree or disagree is just errands assessment uh I just wanted to use this as a benchmark to continue the conversation about good ideas about how to to approach this issue so missla Dr Dr is that's okay go ahead go ahead M so um so I just want to be clear what we I understood at the last meeting that this money would reduce our state revenue if we were to receive that and that's why we want to look at how we spend that I think I'm hearing something different tonight I want to be clear what I'm what I'm
105understanding so I was initially concerned that simply receiving it anywhere would be a problem I'm thankful to find out that if it goes into the capital fund 42 it doesn't create that problem so that kind of lowers the temperature a little bit okay but the board doesn't necessarily necessarily want to put it there either so there is a decision that has to be made about where to put it initially you know if you put it into fund 10 you've got a lot more flexibility with the money but if it goes into fund 42 is kind of captured by that fund for the fa seable future so what flexibility do we have to ever move it from fund 42 our expert is not here right now um I it may incur the same like tax liability
106so to speak um if we move it out is my guess that's like the best case scenario the worst case scenario is that there's no flexibility I know like fund 47 is a a fund that was created by the state to give some flexibility but it has to stay for Capital maintenance projects once it goes in there you can't pull it out for other reasons so I need to to verify that and I will certainly do that M but um this it was reassuring to me that maybe there's not as much of a like the temperatures lowered right you know in terms of how to approach things if it goes there so that was my primary concern with bringing that up I guess I was wondering how um this receipt of money was different than
107like if we were to see like referendum money um but so um my I left the conversation last meeting it was kind of exciting and exhilarating to think about how can we spend money cuz we've never had that discussion here and I went home I I've thought about it for about a week and the everything we've heard at this table up until this conversation was we don't have enough money we don't have enough money we don't have enough money we have to consolidate schools because we don't have enough money and we received uh budget projections a year ago from Patty showing and I have copies if anybody I got a copy of the report that she gave us anybody wants to see it um showing that we because of the reduction in uh number of
108students that we will be operating in the next few years in a deficit of $2 to3 million so I'm I'm wondering why are we thinking about how do we want to spend this money knowing we're going to be short2 or3 million that this seems and and we've told the whole public like we have to consolidate schools because it's the only way we can balance our budget and until we have the schools Consolidated we continue with the deficit so I'm it doesn't dve in my mind that is a great question and that is one of the interesting conundrums about like what types of money we have so um the deficit that we had was an ongoing budget deficit we're spending a little bit more each year than we're bringing in um if we continue as we
109were um because um uh the ongoing revenue does not match our ongoing expenses so ongoing needs imp imp perpetuity so like if uh you give a wage increase to somebody you can assume they're going to work here for the next 10 20 30 years that's going to be a continual expense every year into the future and so when we make a change like the consolidation of our schools what we're doing is we're eliminating ongoing money that recurring cost because we're going to end up shrinking our Workforce just a little bit in that process so we're going to cut $2.5 million out of our budget that is recurring costs every single year because of that referendum and that will address that um uh proceed that that that projected deficit that we have so this referendum was
110incredibly huge for balancing our budget consolidating our facilities on occasion though we do get onetime money could be a grant from the federal government you know we got some governor's money a couple years ago that we we ended up giving as a bonus to staff because it was kind of unexpected and kind of a boon and you know we wanted to do something one time with that um you know there's um money that comes in uh kind of unanticipated from like unpaid tax receipts in the prior year and it shows up this year and now all of a sudden we've got an extra $330,000 you know we wouldn't spend that $30,000 on hiring a position or a wage increase because it's only here once and so different types of money this sale of Lincoln you
111know two years ago we were hopeful we would sell it and we're continuing to be hopeful and things things look ripe and um you know you can't really plan for it 3 years ago you kind of got to hope you get to the end and things are looking good and so this is a one-time um uh income a one-time revenue of money and so uh it won't alleviate our ongoing budget deficit it could for a year a year until this build yeah yep um but fortunately the referendum passed and so our kind of continuing budget deficit that's going to be relatively well taken care of as we move forward once the schools are built yeah once the school are built we we've got few years or couple year and a half School absolutely we got
112a couple years to to get there and so when you have onetime money especially of the size as I I think I put in my uh uh my memo like you get a rare opportunity to do something significant that has a long-term impact positive impact on our school district and we could certainly use it to plug the budget deficit and keep our fund balance high but there's also an opportunity to think about it in more creative ways in different ways how do we improve the image of our school district how do we advance the experience that kids and staff have here and so that's what I'm excited to think about it's hard to think about on the heels of talking about deficits just like you're talking about Miss Sula um but they are two different
113things two different types of money that impact your school district in different ways and that difference is important and hard to grasp sometimes times but important to think about so now Dr spr and then Mr sorry now I got a couple couple of things to bring in so if I'm if I'm understanding everything correctly one the onetime infusion of funds from from the sale of Lincoln um if we were to apply it to uh the struct the the budget deficit in one year for example essentially that would just be going into our fund balance to maintain that fund balance at a particular level right that's correct and so because in this planning process that the passage of the referendum gave us the budgeting certainty that we needed to be able to to extend past the
114existing deficits to a brighter and better future right okay would the onetime allocation of the of the funds to fund 42 would it be would it be able to I think missas question at the last discussion was about the cost of moving uh Hogan to to Central and the construction projects and everything would is that where the money would need to be in order to defay those costs it could be in fund 10 or fund 42 either place would allow for Capital maintenance and then the flexibility of fund 10 is where we have these opportunities to think about auditor about public facing facilities about the flexibility of fund 10 would be things like wages um bonuses um programmatic materials if we wanted a bunch of reading materials say the capital maintenance in fund 42 would
115be anything that involves building or repairing things so that would be the opportunity for some of these facilities Investments correct it could just be held there without being spent for periods of time it could be spent slowly on you know a series of projects or it could be spent on a dramatic Improvement a range of things do we know how long it would we could keep it in fun 42 I don't think there's any yeah there's no Sunset there you know it's just a matter the will of the board and prudent use of fiscal resources you know so you know if it's there 6 months 6 years 60 years so I do want to jump Mr bagneski was next well I I want to go back to what I said at the previous meeting that
116is I really would encourage us to use the money in terms of solar or green energy or whatever because we put it into that and then we get money back in terms of savings of energy costs and so that would be a long-term gain and we were talking last time two people mentioned that could we use it for salaries well if we had more money in the budget we could then improve fringe benefits or whatever because we spend less in this other pocket over here um and then to follow up on what you said last time in regard to the um seats at Central High School auditorium and I trust you but at the same time seeing it firsthand some of those seats are kind of ragged I was there last night and there was
117a roll in the carpet about that high that people kept tripping over and I know I'm not a small person but I had to sit like this it's old and built for the size we were in the 1920s yeah I think what I appreciate about this memo is that it does show that we have a few more opportunities for deciding what we're going to do if and when that uh sale is done versus where we thought we were at the last board meeting so um I think that that is a positive and that gives us a little bit more time to decide how we proceed so Mr M I I say we have a lot of interesting ideas how to spend it we we all have board have a different ideas of how to go
118forward with this too um it's we're coming out of a referendum the community supported us spending our money towards it's not a reoccurring fund but to a very expensive project course building schools my question is is there any way that which we can help relieve some of that burden from our taxpayers and just maybe give them a little bit of a break or maybe not fully but partially um maybe we can allocate half of this just to helping with our new building and maybe I'm not understanding this correctly that we cannot put this into that fund but um I I appreciate the effort that we talked about how to improve the schools but I also am kind of curious how can we kind of relieve some of this burden from the referendum yeah we're uh
119fortunate as a school district that we've had prudent fiscal management for many years and our mill rate has actually been declining consistently over time and dropped over 70 cents this year uh as well you know so the the the per capita impact of our school operations has gone down consistently over 30 years for for our taxpayers which is a really nice opportunity that we have and uh you know our our community came out strong in support of us even knowing the mill rate impact at 61% approval you know and it's awesome that we have such great Community Support even when they know it might increase their tax a little bit um and so that is fantastic tax relief is always an option you know you can under Levy if you want to um we have
120had so few resources in our school district for so many years and I know when you go to linkages you hear about the needs that our teachers have and uh you know to to under Levy to not expend the the limited resources we have I'd be nervous about what our school Community would say if that were the case well like great I I appreciate like taking care of our taxpayers who've taken care of us um but I know that their support is strong in our community over multiple referenda and I think systemically as a school board you've done a good job of focusing on the right things keeping our mill rate uh on the right trajectory um uh not using these funds for the benefit kids for the benefit of kids I think that would
121be a hard sell for some in our community I think something to consider as well is that these funds will be used to make changes within the school district if but for these funds we would still be asking the taxpayers to pay for that as well so in in some respects we are reducing the impact to the taxpayer because these funds will be used within the school district and because of that we're not asking the taxpayers for more for those same projects Mr thank you I I agree that the the windfall is exciting because it doesn't happen and and we are in a position where um we are able to do something that probably wouldn't be done it would be for quite some time it'd be a long time from here you know so it
122is but I think we it's a it's also reassuring to know that if we put it in fun 42 or wherever we stick it it does not need to be done within a year or something it's reassuring to me and I I can say something while um we're talking about school auditoriums I've recently been in both uh homman and on Alaska this just Saturday for the Miss um on Alaska page and uh oh boy it's night and day difference between lacrosse and both of those schools it's kind of embarrassing to be honest with you it's it's uh it's that doesn't even compare so I obviously we have a lot of things we could do with it and as long as we just work together and do what we think is best I think that's the
123main thing but I like I said I I'm happy to see that we can stick it in uh fun that doesn't have to be spent like right away yeah I think it gives the board time to like grapple with the question and think of the right thing and explore what needs to be explored um you know I I do know that the board every year when we talk about Open Enrollment you know that's a concern we're losing a few more kids than we're bringing in you know the positive impression of our school district has been on folks Minds over the last year or two you know and and it's not a keeping up with the Joneses but it may be investing in our amazing kids and programs who do great things every single day you
124know whether it's drama or orchestra or show choir FBLA you know who are presenting in these spaces There's an opportunity to show off our school district a little bit because the average Community member does not get into an English classroom and see the amazing instruction going on they show up at a football game they show up at a band concert they show up at a show choir competition uh and you've seen the difference between other places in ours and their impression of our school district is formed by that public facing facility Mr olon um I was actually just going to kind of bring up once again you kind of mentioned it before I was able to but in addition to public facing facilities public facing institutions as well uh we talk a lot about wanting
125to attract um students and wanting to attract the positive attention of the public and I think a great way to do that that's been gaining traction is student initiative and student involvement um and sometimes when we spend a lot of time thinking what do we want to do with this it's best to ask the people who this money would be going to and to give them the opportunity and so I just kind of want to once again put in my two sents that giving I think uh school programs whether it is drama or it is sports or it is something brand new um the opportunity to thrive with kind of like grant money having students write their own grants would be super cool thank you other comments I'm curious to to find out I don't
126know a ton about solar but I'm wondering like how much solar could that amount of money buy us and what cost savings would that result in and would the cost savings be significant enough that it could help us address a remodel of the theater facility sooner than we would you mentioned me the other day was safe so I'll try and give some ballpark estimates and we got an expert in the crowd here Jeff elon's here he is our solar expert um so when we did the Hamilton addition we put on a 100 megawatt system uh or kilowatt and it um produces about $30,000 in savings annually is what our estimate is right now and that 100 uh kilowatt megawatt system is about the largest you can put on right now under regulations and like the
127payback that you get from the the electric companies so that's kind of the size that we're designing and unfortunately it's kind of it's based on like you know ZIP code or address or meter and so doesn't matter if it's on Hamilton or Central that's about the largest we can construct at this time and the only reason we've been able to do solar so far is because of an incredible partnership with solar on Lacrosse schools they have done an amazing job securing grants doing fundraising uh and Jeff has been great working with them on these projects and so we've been able to do north side we've been able to do uh Hamilton um we're doing a uh we're a overhead thing at Summit it'll be a little bit smaller than the 100 uh uh that we're
128talking about we're in the process of doing one on Southern Bluffs just going to out strip me here pretty quickly we have one at Polytechnic how much does it cost for 100 kilowatt and that's why Mr Elson is here hi there everyone um yeah so we we're doing a pergula at Summit Elementary it's an outdoor classroom it's going to have about 50 some panels on it and where you it'll have where it won't the rain won't come through it it'll actually run off and it'll be facing at an angle so um that's hopefully going to be finished up by January and then we're looking at doing Southern Bluffs we got three bids in from um solar connection Olen solar and um um ethos out of Roka so looking at getting those bids in and once
129we what's the typical cost of that size system um like north side I want to say it was like for instance right now at Southern BL we're looking anywhere from 70,000 to 120 you know for the array that would go up there so 100 kilowatt yes but that's just for the array That's not including installation Etc correct it is including inflation yes yeah and we're fortunate there's tax credits which help make it a little bit cheaper we've provided some funds as a school district but most of the funds have been uh fundraised externally through these Partnerships um uh Joe's in the middle of working on a um climate action plan you know with community members that um identifies you know solar as a opportunity as well when we put the addition onto State Road as
130well as when we build um a new Elementary School solar will be a part of those projects as well um the limitation at this point is where we have roofs or certainty that a building's going to be around for 15 years so we need good roofs that can support a plan so we usually want to change out the roofing material before we put in the the solar and we want some certainty that the building's going to be there in 15 years so that we can capture the investment as long as possible there we're about to wrap up our elementary schools frankly and then we'll be looking at middle schools and high schools and so the the total cost of that let's say it averages $100,000 it's about you know $400 $500,000 left in terms of
131projects with a potential savings being around $100,000 $120,000 maybe $150,000 a year you know which is perpetu you know in perpetuity is you know so that that's an advantage as well you know so it wouldn't necessarily need to be the whole 2.1 million I'll also say that it's been a part of our process to continue to work with Souls we have a plan to get there kind of outside of this particular lump sum of money you know so you can be confident that that we will continue to pursue it it would happen a lot faster if we just did it all at once yeah and some people on some of those IES that I serve on are not that happy with the school district because they say we're doing all the work and where is
132their interest in this project and so that's what I hear from some of the spoks people any other questions or comments regarding the proceeds on l Middle School Mr Olson hi again um one interesting thing about solar is it's not necessarily solar that attracts but the environmental consciousness of the action and so one thing that I'd kind of also encourage is is maybe not jumping into solar but utilizing some of our other natural resources to derive whether it's energy heat um or even just investing in kind of outdoor experiences for our students um I don't know cuz solar's tricky one year you can spend quite a bit of money on it and then the next they'll come out with a huge new innovation that could have saved us quite a bit um but yeah I
133do really like solar it's pretty cool but also there's a lot of other amazing options that I think lacrosse has a unique ability to tap into but solar is kind of just the flashiest good point any com my energy I have solar and heat bump and my energy cost per month is around $33 that's wonderful any other comments from the board okay hearing none then we'll move on to announcements and we will turn it over to Mr Olson first for the student Representatives um in the whole week since I kind of last announced uh nothing too exciting has happened which is good things are still happy things are still chugging along and students are still learning wonderful thank you very much Miss Nelson yeah I could say similar things not too much has changed all
134of the concerts that I was talking about were successful I've heard good things um and I guess everybody's just still excited for winter break next week is kind of when we get the holiday stuff going up we got dress up days uh all day or every day for the next week and then there's going to be some holiday music performances like the jazz band in the Commons before school and I think the jazz band and the orchestra and possibly the choir also as well at the winter assembly which is usually a good time games and stuff so yeah just good time until break good thank you very much I know Mr bradesi had mentioned not much to report from season 4 anything you just want to add quickly no the only thing we talked about
135was budget numbers this making it they're self-funding their health insurance company and they're trying to wage whether that was a good way to go or not but I don't know if anybody's interested know I appreciate it Miss bodal just a reminder that the grant award lunch in for the Cross Public Education Foundation is coming up in the blink of an eye January 17th so mark your calendars if you haven't already it would be great to have have a strong representation from our board there it's a super fun time great meal there's always a snowstorm that day keep the tradition alive right yeah all right the only uh announcements I have is a Sunday January 5th for the board members there is a first Sunday Forum coffee hour from 10: to 11: uh at Our Redeemer
136Lutheran Church so anybody who's interested to attend would be uh encouraged to attend and then um Tuesday February 4th from 6:00 to 9: we will be having a Workshop uh regarding policies and uh depending on how long that conversation lasts if it's a shorter one maybe we could delve into linkages and talking about linkages and the um kind of the summary of linkages up to that point we will not have completed all of the linkages but at least we would have a good place to begin the conversation and go from there so that'll be again Tuesday February 4th 6: to 9: um so please make sure to mark that on your calendar uh that will be an important meeting for all of us to attend I'll turn over to Dr Engle winter break is December
1373rd through January 1st um December 24th 25th 31st and January 1st the board offices are closed uh but we will be in and Staffing our district offices the rest of the time um we had kind of the news had just come out last week about um Act 10 being o overturned by a judge in danne County um this is one of those things that could have a SE change in how we operate as a school district and so I just wanted to give a brief update um the brief update is wait and see uh the judge uh still hasn't made a judgment in terms of like so he overturned it on the basis of an entire rationale but he hasn't said what's going to happen like what ought to happen next and once that judgment
138is put forth the legislature has already indicated that they're going to appeal and ask for a stay of that judgment so it is also likely that until it is appealed and gone to probably the Supreme Court in the state that it will likely not be in effect until um it's been ruled upon there's a supreme court election in Spring and so the various parties will be maneuvering to think about are we satisfied with this court or do we want to roll the dice on the next court and so that'll kind of determine the pacing of this whole Endeavor as well um in the very like short term you know there could be some um opportunities but our our legal council has said just wait for the Judgment wait for the inevitable stay and then wait
139for the appeal to go through the process and could be resolved in 60 days to six years you know so stay tuned uh but if we go back to more comprehensive bargaining it will kind of dramatically change the the landscape of how we do business here in the school district of Lacrosse so uh just wanted to give you all an update on that and then the only other thing is we're entering the um bium budget season so the state um uh departments like DPI have produced their budgets and shared those with the governor the governor conducted a budget hearing last week thank you for the attendees uh Mr Alberts was there as well as some prospective board members so that was uh an interesting opportunity to kind of engage in that process Governor iers will
140put together his budget and present that to the legis history uh plays out as it has the legislature will almost surely reject that budget and then start from scratch themselves producing their own uh and then it'll be a negotiation between the the legislature and the governor leading up to July 1st uh in the meantime we will have um a series of budget hearings probably in the March April time frame and um I have testified at those the last couple of Bs um I intend to continue to to encourage folks there and if any Schoolboard member is interested and wants to be a part of that process usually takes a whole day to kind of manage the whole thing but great opportunity for public advocacy to talk to the state legislature to have our voice heard
141uh and uh it's been a valuable process um so that's kind of what we can anticipate with the budget process over the next uh the next um six seven months hopefully it's all wrapped up by July 1 it the the circumstances of our politics right now indicate it may go longer than July 1 as it has in some years when the government is less severely divided when it's a little bit closer it it's harder to come to an agreement you know so um education funding is the third of State funding you know so it's a big part of the line item you know so it'll be an interesting process both between act1 and the bium and I'll keep you updated along the way sounds good we'll move on to board debriefing uh which Falls to
142me this evening so you know I really appreciate whenever we have a School showcase to be able to talk about what are students doing how are they doing it uh the cool things that are going on the the amazing things our faculty and our staff and employee groups are doing so I think that that's really important and uh really valuable uh overall um I do think that we should um consider how we proceed forward in terms of um continuing our conversations I think we have robust conversations I think our conversations at the board table are uh definitely uh good thoughtful questions but again um one of the things to remind the board including myself is that the goal has always been that 50% of the board meeting is spent on student achievement and so I
143I would encourage all of us to think back on our last board meetings and determine whether 50% of each of those board meetings has been about student achievement and if it hasn't how can each one of us help all the board together get to that goal because that's really the most important part of the work that we do is that student achievement so um I think that's all we had for board debriefing yes what I have on here is board debriefing me at at the bottom if you look so but he's on December 9th as well so that was a change but you know Mr manga you could also chime in if you'd like yeah I could try and man I think we have kind of the A on the same points I think we
144have a lot of good discussions about it um I agree about you of student achievement but one thing I always think about is remember that we serve everybody else I think we did really well when We examined our own ideas of how to spend the money from the Lincoln Middle School um we were able to boost a lot of good ideas there another thing I think we could approve upon is be aware that refer did pass we're trying to work through the process how to move forward from here we're going to have some disagreements um the biggest thing that was only really the major concern I had from today's board meeting was about Bray and that we seem to have had a misunderstanding about who we're serving whether it be the the public or Administration
145just I just want to kind of impress upon the board that it's really all a team at the end of the day the public and administration did vote on this referendum we are here to serve them as well so that's just one thing we work together is just make sure keeping all of them informed and all of them at our mind when it comes to how to move forward by making sure that we're going through after this referendum not only keeping our accountability but also keeping that forward reaching but thank you again Mr YZ yeah appreciate it so with that we are adjourned let's take a five minute break and then come back um for our workshop and then if I could speak to the two student representatives in the meantime I appreciate it so
146we'll be back in about 5 minutes [Music] for [Music]