001right we're live awesome all right I'm gonna call our special dation meeting in Open Session Workshop to order and first we have some minutes to approve um so I move to approve the minutes from the special meeting in Open Session dated February 26 2024 second thank you um did you that Jesse board member Pearson all right all those in favor all right for member Castro okay great that passes 60 thank you next I have move to approve the minutes from the special meeting and open sessions dated May 6 2024 someone passed candy wait was that second in by board member Pearson all right all those in favor all right thank you that passes 60 and next I move to approve the minutes from the special meeting in Open Session dated May 20th 2024 second Maya
002all right second by board member Pearson all those in favor all right thank you that passes 60 all right for tonight we have two topics and also just to state in our open workshops we do not include public common and we don't seem to have anyone here um tonight and we won't be recognizing anybody online we have two topics the first being a review of policy and then we'll move into a discussion of the forward career and College Academy charter proposal that we will be voting on at our regular Board of Education meeting on Monday February 24th all right so with that I will pass it on over to our policy committee um board colleagues hey thank you um I apologize in advance for my voice so hopefully those that can um online can hear
003me um so we are going to start today with um a policy that we review the um policy 3031 for school closing Implement weather be the first one that we will review we took a first review of that in our operations work group um January 155 and so this is our second review um for our board policy 1301 um in which dep pending on how shakes out tonight may end up on our regular board on the 24th um to vote to either go ahead and adopt it or um not to adopt it um and so you have with you um board members each of the policies um you have um the 3031 with the updated changes based on our conversation you also have here with you um the proposed um PL version of the policies
004um for your review and then once we are done with that we will move on to um four other policies um regarding finance and at that time once we are done R this first one um we will move to talk about in each one individually which for those for you have um the preliminary Red Line um and this will constitute as our first review um and we'll come back at a later date depending on um how much information we need to update or change um and that will be discussed later with the policy Committee just need to correct the record on one thing um board didn't the policy committee didn't get through all four of the new Financial policies I'm not objecting to that at this time because I already have discussed it but I
005do believe record needs to be to be clear State we did not discuss bid bid policy okay and and I think that just needs to be clarified for the okay if that's the case I would also like to further clarify um that our policy committee gave um our legal council that is um assigned to our policy committee um we agreed to um go ahead and kind of go around the policy um committee um agreements that we all came up with of how we will work through policy recommendations and threat lining to bring that those things forward to the board um we gave the power to Petra to be able to work back with Bob to get those red lines because it was time sensitive and unfortunately we didn't have another meeting prior to this one
006to be able to discuss in depth um that initial red line so I just wanted to also further clear that up um so that everyone understands that however Pedra did talk with um our our head legal council Mona to um go through and make sure that everything is legally sound and so the icies those other four for finance um they have confirmed that they are sound and so we can still have that discussion and we'll be considered per 1301 as the first staff um for the board to review okay so moving on to the first policy to review 331 um school closing and Clement weather um I think have Scott maybe believe so you or you want to like State like some of the changes and updates go ahead yeah so I mean there is
007one change in 3031 we have in section five A and B removed references to applicable collective bargaining agreement and replace that with employee handbook this is just reflecting a change you know have the collective bargaining agreements and it's reflecting that the requirements that are set forth here can be found in the employee handbook so it's pretty straightforward and there was no necessarily sub substantial changes the our last evening think folks were good with that y so open into discussion yes the only um yeah the the changes seem um in accordance with what I remember before um the only thing that is standing out to me this time so sorry if I didn't catch this before is in in line uh item three of the policy it does say that the superintendent will contact the president
008of the board as though that is a kind of a process in the queue before determining and I I would say I don't know if that's a consistent practice nor do I nor do I know if it needs to be I do think the board generally should be notified but I don't know if it's specifically the president of the board president Nichols I've operated by informing the board just to avoid calling you at phone in the morning yeah um to have the conversation around the decisions I could live either way just I want the policy to practices right so I think my recommendation would be the superintendent will contact and unless there's an objection to it has to be the president and then the president therefore is then having to use some kind of communication
009mode to get the word out these are weather sorry school closing inclement weather in weather there are other times where we might be Consulting around other school closures be any number of things that would happen as well that might be different so for in Clement weather I would agree our team is work many times around the clock right and be calling to inform you that we're watching it so kind of alert you or just the decision we made on the information that's available is there any objection to that or any thoughts I don't have objection I do have when we're just updating that language I think it does need to be clear that the board isn't making the decision to close school I agree but that it's just because we don't want to make that
010decision or I don't want to no it just will contact right but the way that it what you're talking about the progression in this paragraph yeah say informing the board of the decision might be clearer um distin for you know who's who's making that decision yeah point point agree yeah but just to be clear the proposed revision would be the superintendent will inform the board yeah yeah I think that that sounds right and this is our second read on this policy and so per board policy 1301 I wouldn't consider these additional revisions substantive so if everyone's comfortable you could proceed and move forward with a vote at the regular meeting on this one with the language we've just discussed the red line will of course be everyone to see if folks are comfortable with that
011so yeah we can kind of like take some consensus conversation so it's sounding like for the most part most of us are in favor Blair I know that you stepped out a little bit um there's a part that the the superintendent will contact the president of the board know uh Michelle made the point that um maybe it should just be the board um and Jill somewhat agreed yeah personally I'm fine getting the email when the school like I don't I don't know the board doesn't make the decision I'm not monitoring the weather right I don't know why I would need to know in any special way right um and Laura made the the comment of like it sounds like based off of the progression that maybe clarifying some language around um that makes it more
012clear that we are not the decision makers number four says the decision to close schools as made by the superintendent yeah yeah oh yeah okay so I think you were going to change it the word yeah so the proposed revision for that sentence it would read the superintendent will inform the board right great okay we're good any other comments about that do people feel good about that thumbs up yeah hey I'm pretty much consensus thank y'all we are done with that one it will come back on the 24th for final approval okay moving along doing great um bring my Bo do now we are moving on to District fund balance um policy 6071 um I know that this has been a topic that we have discussed a lot in the past in very many different
013ways um and so Bob is going to um let folks know why we are making some of the changes that we are making um and the recommendations go ahead Bob all right thank you um so the to start off I'll just kind of summarize what the current policy says current policy has AR ranged 10 to 15% current policy says you fall below the minimum or go above the maximum for plan to do to either get you back into the board policy at minimum or have a plan on how to spend the fund then um and and the proposal that I put in here was to get rid of a range and just go with 177% that's based on a couple of things first uh primarily independent a audit fir when they presented to you on
014the 23 24 audit they recommended our fund balance policy be change 17% is a recommendation don't have to change this policy at all keep 1015 but that was their recommendation I did a little um searching on the state's publicly available information in terms of um fund balance policies they really um have policies in terms of actual fund bounds um for the last available year which would have been 2223 Statewide fund balance is about 22% of all the 421 school districts right but 22% is what people have or what people's policies say it's what they have it's what the numbers are as reported for the unassigned okay then the other changes really um is reflective of going from a range to a number so you don't have to have a conversation on what you're going to
015do um necessarily if you're below it um um I've removed the minimum and maximum just to talk about one and then there were some other changes in terms of really updating the language um since the policy was there different terminology was use in terms of classification of fund balance and so um working with the team we we updated terminology and of fund balance categories um our fund balance like like everyone else talks about an unassigned um fund balance and so there's there's really five current categories which is why the language has been updated to be more reflective of what the definitions that Epi has established for discussions of fund balance one's nonspendable one's restricted one's committed one's assigned and then the unassign which is what the fund balance policy really is um All About so
016those those were the changes in terms of overall than thank you Bob any questions about um the fund balance proposal and just to remind everyone we'll we'll have a second stab this with updates um at a later time Michelle oh um Bob can you explain and I'm trying to go back to the whipley report but can you explain from your understanding why it would be beneficial to go with the 17% or a fixed minimum versus the range that we've had the the recommendation of 17% rly talked about that we're in a time of Uncertain Financial conditions both at the state level and at the federal level and so they their processes looking at all their clients and looking at the current res search their recommendation is is to increase that um I'll also add um
017our budget for 2425 has about a 177% um on signed fund balance so that's what we are currently budgeted to be at um at the end of this fiscal um and so um if we want to talk about changing that 177% up or down right there's a there's impl the only consequence is you'll have have more money set aside not allocated out not appropriated to spend if you go above 17 less will free up additional funds um yeah that's that okay Ali she's online y thank you board vice president Pearson um I've said before I'm not interested in voting in a s 1% I think like it's a real risk to have the bare minimum without any flexibility to spend fund balance at this point especially given some of the unknowns related to our budget
018I am interested in increasing our fund balance policy to between 12 and 24% um and I think that having some level of flexibility as we navigate a series of significant unknowns related to our budget uh makes sense to me but I'm not going to vote in favor of a 17% minimum um I don't I don't think it gives us the flexibility to leverage our fund balance um and I I I worry that it ties the board's hands at a pretty inopportune moment I also think the 177% that we have or I think if I go back to our audit conversation was actually 18% um I think that that changes as the the um as the referendum increases in terms of our base and so achieving that and staying at exactly 177% seems unlikely in part
019because we've been outside of our current policy significantly um because we've had more resources so I I do think we we want to have a policy um that you know if if the the reason we're saving resources is because our our schools are not staffed then I think it's important that our policy dictates that we reinvest that savings into the classroom um strategically rather rather than uh kind of sit on on resources that could really help support an underst staff school that's it for me thank you Ali the other comments I see Nikki and then I agree with uh i' like to raise up the comments of um my colleague Ali mro I don't think at this time of un certainty the 177% is a good idea I could understand the 12 to 24 in
020the future but I would need one a lot more discussion two a meeting with all the stakeholders Union nonunion in general and I want to hear from our staff and what they think on our fund balance I know it affects them as much even though we're the ones making the decision it almost feels and this is probably me and I'm probably misreading it but it almost feels like the money is at ours completely and because of that I think I need to hear from everybody involved that's just me and it's for that reason not because of Bob or anything else but for that reason that I couldn't vote for this at this time so Nikki let me just ask just quick question I clarify are you then saying that leave it at the 10% 15%
021range okay yeah thanks for the clarification that really helped okay um I guess so okay the first third strikeout um does not include carryover funds utilized and that's um that's your proposing we strike that as like part of like making sure the def definitions are clear yes okay wait where are you BL uh it's just in the first paragraph under procedure where it says Define signed general fund balance each year and then the stuff that's struck oh okay I was just asking like just trying to get my head around that and I think I do have that um I I will confess I don't understand why we wouldn't have a range like I don't don't understand what would be good about that like and I would love to hear what you think would be good
022about having a number instead of a okay um sure um I I I don't want to make any generalizations but I've looked at a lot of fun balance policies over my career and I would say more than not have a single Target right instead of a range I if the board's comfortable with range like I said there there's nothing wrong with the range we have a range so I think it's more standard to have one number Wily recommended the 177% go from a range right if they're saying 15 to 1 we could do 12 to 17 right or up two percentage points on the bottom or leave it um it's really the board's discretion got okay that's helpful yeah um and then I guess the my other question is uh one two three four paragraphs
023in the bottom the district shall classify related action form of um adding those words like what is my assumption is that that gives the board greater ability to um to commit funds without having like a specific budget number is that or like a or um to to me that reads like adding that means we can pass a resolution that says we want to be allocating kind of way without getting really specific about it is that what that's saying there what that language really means to say is the board action is it would have to be a resolution right goes back to the definitions of what committed is U some of the definition require an actual board resolution and then something would have to pass another resolution to say we want to change that said so
024it CL it clarifies the what taking action means okay um thank you uh thank you that's all my questions and also I want to say congratulations and thank you to the policy team and everyone else who's been um working to get this meeting on the books for a long time um Jesse included uh yeah Jesse she never gets enough thought on this one so I just I wanted to put put that out in the room nice work thank you Laura go ahead thanks um I have two questions for Bob um one is um can you talk about the implications for the district's credit rating as related to the recommended change in the policy yeah so um two things I'll talk about the credit rating um the credit ver I'll say Masson has one of the
025highest credit RS District can get Masson um with a few other that are as highly rated as we are one of the characteristics factors the rating agency look at is does the board have a fund balance policy and if you do are you following so that's the main thing if you have a fund balance policy you really need to follow What bond that we in terms of the 17% and riple it's um it's conservative budgeting to keep more money in your unassigned balance handle any unexpected changes in state revenues or federal revenue right to be able to make the fiscal de so um increasing that is really what that's about um that answer questions it does I was also I guess I'm also wondering about the implications for borrowing is related to credit score when
026you maintain a high credit rating people are more interested there's more competition for the bonds that we put out for sale so the higher the credit rating the better the lower risk one has that we're going to be good on it we have a good fund balance we're following the policy and so what we have to pay in interest to the folks that buy those bonds generally goes down so if you get a lower Bond rating or more of a risk there have to pay people more to buy your bonds okay so if we compare our current policy with the recommended policy would you anticipate that would impact our credit rating and therefore the rate of interest for borrowing um answer it this way the credit rating agencies like the fact that we're above our
027stated policy because that shows we're being very conservative in our funding in terms of what we're allocating for and we're keeping our birs good so um but I would say in terms of ultimately the biggest thing is and again this doesn't mean if we don't hit our fund Bal policy we're g to be down right it's it's it's a it's a process there's a lot of questions a lot of factors but generally you wanna want to maintain want to meet FS 177% then I mean to me the it's it's a decision point it's a consequence um so if we if we have a policy that's higher than 177% or lower than 17% then that's not money available to say U add something to a program staff right because that money won't be available spend okay
028so then my my next question is I'm wondering if you could respond to the points that board member mro brought forward yeah um the only the only response that I would add is just like put numbers to the numbers right because I did a little table um so um right now as I said I compared it to what we have budgeted for 2425 and what our budget is saying will be about 17 um we're going to get into more changes that budgeted number at the March operation work but so if we go to a highend of4 % our fund balance goes from 86.3 to 12.1 which would mean 35.8 million more in fund Bal the high end on the low end 12% would be 61 million which is 25.2 million less than we currently have
029budget in terms of the range again current policies 1015 it's really a board discussion on what range you're comfortable I'm G to follow up with one more question then pass it along so we may be entering a very turbulent time regarding funding that traditionally we've been able to count on what are the implications and I'm I'm talking about um board member's comments about flexibility and being able to access funding is if we were to have a situation where suddenly we didn't have the same um money coming in that we were expecting are we able to access this money in case of an emergency if we have uh the the policy set as described um as a 177% the money would always be there right um but if we would have to access it and go
030below the fund balance policy we we would want to be explaining why we went below the fund balance policy I I would I would talk about how we don't want to do that we figure out some other options um but the money is always right it's in our fund balance it's our Mone and it's there it's just we would need to take say we're at 86.3 million now we need to take 20 million and be dropped down um with and we're still within our range right 10 to 15% okay um 10% by the way is 50 million or 35 million 35.4 less than what we're at in terms of the lower range I think it's important consideration right um we've talked about this right now in our budget 2425 we have budgeted $37 million in
031federal revenues we've sought reimburse a little over 7 million so if the fed's all a sudden said the money that's been appropriated by Congress the money that's been approved to spend by DPI and Department of Education we're not going to give it to you right um that would create a literal $30 million hole budget so you either cut expenditures by 30 million which is next to impossible to do in the middle this you'd have to go to your fund balance to cover which I'm pretty sure the rating agencies would say that's a legitimate reason who because the money's been appropriate but I'm not a ring agency thank you go okay savan I saw your hand earlier do you still want to comment um I'm still getting the um the the the the question if you
032could come back to me yeah absolutely absolutely yes thank you I think one of the things I'm trying to balance is technically the way I've always understood our fund balance is it's the savings I'm I'm putting it in my own Lanes terms it's it's the account that you are holding like a savings account your rainy day fund for so that you always have some something in reserve for the unexpected and with that orientation I could see how especially given the climate that we are in and the uncertainty it would seem smart to say let's make sure we're holding some money in this rainy day f because we don't know what to expect um and so when I see that the whipley folks are saying at minimum you should have two months of General operating funds
033to cover any of your expenditures in case something were to happen and that tends to be around 177% I can see why you might move in this direction so I I understand that and I also I know that we've always had the range and the range has allowed us to kind of draw down out of the the rainy day fund to make some critical Investments when we felt it was necessary I don't think I'll speak for myself I don't think that's a a a long-term practice of always using the fund balance to like kind of make up your annual operating budget um but I think we've been in a fortunate position over the last few years that we've been above at a time um of our own policy and it's allowed us to make some
034critical budget moves um so it seems like one of the advantages of of maximizing the minimum is it kind of forces us to really kind of save and use the fund balance for unforeseen circumstances the disadvantage going to a single number and kind of raising the bar on that minimum is um it seems like we don't have as much flexibility so do you have a um I guess what I'm wondering Bob is if we could be closer to where the recommendations are but still using a range do you have like a range that you think would keep us um closer to the recommendations but also honor the the need for maybe some flexibility that we can't foresee right now um I talk sorry to put you on the spot yeah you don't I I talked
035to my keep about that right we're 10:15 is the range right now right Wily saying really be 17 so one could look at it they want us to increase at 15 to 17 which means then the range would go 12 so we keep the same five point range but we go 12 that's a possibility and we talked about it but as I've shared with the board before my preference is to have one target now right um another benefit of us being projected at 177% instead of 15% right which is the difference between 15 and 17 is about10 million and so the last few years we've had to borrow about 60 million a little over 60 or a little over 60 million short-term borrowing to make our bills because of the state aid delay this year
036we only are paying for 50 million right and we had that opportunity because we have more money in as you said president Nichol in our savings account right we had additional funds available no reason to borrow $60 million and pay the interest on that 60 million when we can aieve what we need to achieve by just 50 right we couldn't have done that if we would have B fund balance % budget right had the funds available okay so that's a that's another bener right of not having to borrow as short term you know the onee notes um but the consequences you have to you have to have that money there right fund it yeah exactly okay I don't have a a better um suggestion on a red line but I appreciate the context yeah thank
037you go ahead Mickey I just I think that this we look reactionary that we're doing it expecting there's going to be a problem and I understand the need to have reserves do not get me wrong but I think it part of the reason you have reserves is also to have that flexibility and I don't think by trading the the false sense of security we're really becoming more secure in fact I think we're giving both of both flexibility and security at the same time and that's what I'm really really concerned about but that's my last comment on the subject savan go ahead thank you yeah um yeah one comment that I'm kind of noticing in the conversation is that uh or kind of tension in the conversation is there's um kind of two buckets for what
038the fund balance is four kind of schools of thought one is like a rainy day fund and then one is is a it's a tool to help uh smooth out the cash flow things for the district to function throughout the year and so while I'm chewing on this whether it be a maybe uh increasing the range or settling on a target number Bob I'm wondering you know kind of narrative wise for the past few years we have engaged in either deficit spending or using onetime funds to cover ongoing expenses through the uh Federal relief funds and stuff so and it's been a goal of ours to stop doing that so I'm wondering how this policy fits into meeting that goal yeah good question um that that Target of what we budgeted at 177% right um
039we we we we'd been higher on that but because of the expenditures that the board approved we need $23 million from our fund balance to cover that so um now we're gonna we're going to work on getting that number updated at the March operations work group but um if if we would have been if our expenditures would have been matching our annual revenues we we would have had a $23 million more in our fund Bal but we need we needed that $23 million because we need a balanced budget so we approved higher expenditures and annual revenues and we need 23 million of that savings account our our unassigned balance to balance this year right uh again I've shared I think we're GNA we're we're on our track to be better than that that is we're
040not going to need a full 23 million I don't believe to end this year positive it's going to be something less than that and we're working on those to present in March does that that answer it yeah yeah um and yeah there's just some observations in that like any point throughout the year our fund balance percentage can be anywhere in that range just because of the nature of how we use it to cover expenses throughout the year so trying to weigh these things and you know when when is the date that what's the date that matters for what the fund balance has to be at if that makes sense so um those are some things that June 30th and that's why it's a little dangerous to think of our fund balance as a savings account
041because we do not we do not have $86 million sitting in a savings account right fact we'd be negative right now if we wouldn't have our 50 million short-term loan right so it it's a point in time it's snapshot calculated on June 30th and then it is is just a calculation right it's an important calculation but it is it does have some cash but it's not it's not a constant number right it's a calculation at the end of the issue okay thank you and as we continue to discuss this I hope that helps conceptualize what this is so thank you sorry thank you saan go ahead Nikki sorry my brain comes up with weird ideas but what I'm worried about and my big thing is that this the future this lack of flexibility and the
042tying of the board's hands away will be used as a way to say well we don't have the full Revenue picture so we can't do Cola because we can't provide it or we can't fund black Excellence because we can't provide it how do we prevent that from happening where are you directing that uh anyone who wants to take it well I think anytime the budget is priorities so we have to you know the board sets the priorities the administration makes recommendations to fulfill those priorities and we have to work together to do that if we were ever in a position and this has happened where we have a fund balance number that's set and if we have to go below that I've had to wave a fund balance policy before to um to have a
043budget pass for that year I would hope that we would never be in that situation that we're making other strategic moves so we can avoid ever having to do that but there would be ways to uh to make sure that we can both comply with the priorities and U use our budget policies to to close our budget iately I just don't want to what my fear is is that we're not going to be able to at the to have the Nimble this to do so and then with the uncertain funding that'd go oh we can't do our priority actions which this board has prioritized those are the kind of things I worry maybe it's just me I'm a worrier by nature but those are things I need spelled out that it's not going to be
044used that way because I don't think that that's what taxpayers necessarily want but I could be wrong I'd love to hear from go ahead Laur okay so I've really appreciated hearing everybody's perspectives I feel like I'm I'm prepared to support the changes as as suggested in the redline version um and part of that is um I'm thinking about listening to the news about other school districts in the state and how fortunate we are in not having had to cut major programs Staffing and be looking at closing schools and I think we are fortunate one because our community has been incredibly supportive and two because we have been fiscally conservative um consistently for a really long time and that has served us really well and puts us in a position to not be in a in
045a state of emergency with budget right now um and I feel like we're at a good moment to say let's make sure we try to stay that way and I feel like that's when I'm reading this and when I'm I'm thinking about the implications of just making sure we've got a little bit more put aside for when we need it because I suspect that we probably will have an emergency or two over the next few years um I appreciate that we could be thinking in advance and be prepared for that um I also just want to say when I read the wording should hold a minimum of 177% even though I'm hearing Bob talk about this as a target number I'm thinking of that as a range because it's 17 and up so it's not
046exactly a target number it's it's a range that starts at 17 te so there is some flexibility in that in perspective thank you so much thank you more colleagues is there any final thoughts before I just ask the question okay um that we weren't voting on no I'm just asking a question oh okay just oh oh I misunder I thought called the question and I got no I sorry about that yeah I appreciate like all the convers and it has me thinking about in a perfect world what do we consider as like frequency that we should be coming back kind of looking at this because what I'm also thinking about is that we can plan you know for next year and maybe the next four years um based off of how things are going um
047and it's still a policy that we get to control so then like what is the recommendation like if we decide right now be very conservative go forward with this what is the recommendation of like coming back and maybe like reassessing where we're at and maybe changing the proposal or doing the range or we find out that you know this isn't going to be the best and so just in a perfect world or not a perfect world just what's the recommendation of what you've seen or or thoughts about that don't think there would be anything uh vice president Pearson I don't think there would be anything to prevent the policy work group to take this up however they see fit if the situation would arise or if there is some sort of unforeseen condition where we'd
048say wait a minute we just didn't predict this we know what the last five years is like but I think that it's important that we get a policy written so that Bob and his team can begin to plan this to me it it touches the entire organization yeah and and and from my perspective if if you want it to impact the 2526 budget right we we start having a preliminary budget in May and we would be voting in June on the final preliminary budget so if you want it to impact those discussions then obviously that would be a timeline doesn't have to impact that right it can go conversation go as long as you want to but okay thank you for um answering that um so it sounds like we're in a place where folks
049are Mar on the conversation um I think um Petra has been Tak exensive notes um to be able to come back with Bob and um update and a new red line um and pardon did I clarify something yes um I know um it was stated we gave legal permission I don't give legal permission legal permission to do what for anyone to Advocate outside of the board president on my behalf you stated earlier in the meeting that we gave legal the permission to advocate for us and to speak for us I am resending it so let me clarify what I said I said that you and I and Petra we had a conversation together and we agreed together as a poli committee to allow Pedra to work with Bob to get the red lining together so
050that we can be prepared for tonight's meeting and so that's what I said and it's not necessarily that Petra is advocating we have this time to discuss which we have we have another I meant in the future outside this meeting I thought it was permanent that's what I was checking no we didn't change any kind of like process we just allowed I wanted to make sure to be able to do it and we'll discuss again the process that's what I needed to make sure because if the case and I that's the way I but I respect meeting you've done it I appreciate that Nikki and we've had the conversation earlier and we will discuss the process together as a committee so I just want the public to be clear oh absolutely that there are not
051side decisions that are being had that we are having conversations together um as a committee okay so um Pedro will work back with Bob to update this based off of our conversation to bring it back to us again we'll try to work on a dat to bring it back depending on how much time it takes to update that and we'll let the board know um when we are able to get it scheduled again for the second review of the second red line can I so what I heard in the conversation though is there's some board perspective on I'm okay with the single Target number because it is minimum means there is a range it's just not stated what the maximum of the range is right and then other board members are saying I I still
052want a range but I don't we haven't given specifically I mean a board member may have given a low and a high but there's still some sentiment around a range feeling still important yeah so I I think for the policy committee do you feel like you have enough to work with to even do a second headline given that we aren't necessarily in census on are we going with a range or are we going with a target number if we were going with a range what would be the minimum what would be the maximum like I kind of feel like we're still all digesting and thinking out loud but do you feel like you have what you would need to move forward I don't okay H well and and and just to be clear my role
053especially with something like fund balance I'm not an expert in this um Bob is I'm really supporting him in revisions and yes I have been taking notes and that's so that you know when it comes time to to do revisions on this and I don't I don't have a sense that we're in a place for that but I would defer to Bob but then we have a a record of like where everyone has landed so yeah I don't know um I don't I don't have a sense of where the board really wants to go on the next one I would see if I would take all the comments I'd say should have a range if if whipley said go 17 and we're currently at 15 and that's our new Max and I would say the
054range from 10 to 15 12 to 17 covers the Spectrum but I I'm just kind of surmising but but clearly I I have no direct okay go ahead what do you like further conversation in another policy meeting is what would get us to more information um something that would be helpful for me be um like a a little bit like a where where I could go for like a little bit more information about how other districts think about this or um you know we pleas as one thing and that's helpful um what else do people say who are they that would be helpful for me yeah that would be just to to like deepen my own understanding I could put a table together on a slide of this is what 12 to 17 means this
055is what 12 to 24 means in terms of if our our budet B and it is what what what would that mean definitely don't want to overburden but if that feels like something you can do straight ahead like for the expert and you know this and can make that clear for me that would be helpful yeah I mean sure like I said what what's publicly available is 22 23 because you know both boards municipalities have now to clear that all up so DPI won't put 23 24 updates for later this spring after lest um probably summer but but you know late spring early summer but I can take a look at that boards really range there there are boards that have fund balances 100% 110% of what they spend at re W there also boards
056that have no funds right so it it is a big range and I can maybe pull some of that summary statistics Statewide larger districts that kind of thing that would be cool um I I'll just say this this feels very arbitrary at this point you you threw out a potential range of 12 to 17 um Bob as one scenario and I think in my mind I was thinking if we went with a 15 to 20 22 it's still a five percentage Point range it takes our last maximum and kind of makes it the new minimum which is close to the 177% but still a little lower and then it gives us some but again it feels very arbitrary without um besides just using 5 percentage points in a rate I don't so yes I I
057think some additional information would be helpful and hopefully we can help narrow down yeah for the policy committee because I I I think it would be hard for you all to move forward based on this conversation yeah and again um we can talk about this policy as many times as we want um if we are I mean of course I don't want to talk about a hundred times but if we need to talk about it as many times to get to where we are all feeling like this is a good policy and we can move forward um we will continue to have that conversation um and our process right now for the policy committee um is something that we are still working through and this is like the first policy special meeting that I've ever
058had while I'm being on a board right in my four years so um I think we can definitely take back um some of the feedback um like providing maybe some extra information maybe trying to figure out how we can add that in the process as we deliberate and get information back to the board so that they have um and we'll discuss more of like where that might live whether it's like in our operations work group bringing it Forward there just as like information to help folks kind of like digest it more to ask questions and that's just a recommendation um but we can talk further um as a policy Committee of how that might come back up not necessarily for the second you but can I just clarify Bob made a comment earlier that if
059we wanted the fund balance policy to impact or be utilized in our 2025 26 budgeting process what would be the timeline for our fund Bal our fund balance policy to be officially approved in order for that to happen um ideally we'd have it taken care of before we started May because May's kind of one to do the operation support group about this is kind of the last conversation we're gonna have before we put that preliminary budget for you to vote on okay remember if you increase the fund balance policy that has that has consequences because you're taking revenue and it's not going to be available to appropriate for some other purpose as to as to stay here right okay okay balance yeah so or we just go with to 10 to 15 do 2526 budget
060that way won't come into play again until my 627 got it all right thank you okay um Bob do you feel like you have a sense maybe and maybe what we can do now is just um get the update um and just kind of go from there as far as like what and have a conversation with the policy Committee of like what how we want presented to the board options um and discuss further maybe how we're going to bring it back to y'all to to discuss so any other questions right now on this policy right now okay thank you um moving on to policy 6242 the bid practices for supplies and equipment um and guys's going to go ahead and us to start the conversation changes Bob can also yeah the 6242 is the only
061change we're talking about is the purchasing procurement team has been moved to the my team and is no longer in administrative services so it's just merely specifying our contract manager as the entity that's responsible to that's all that changes G me folks just a time to kind of look at it adjust it am I correct WR that's the only Red Line in yeah make 100% sure seconds any questions after kind of just a quick glance at it with that one change straight forward okay so none um we'll move move forward actually actually I did think of one just this so the depart the administrative Services doesn't have a problem with the switch over do they absolutely not then cool that was my only question we did it before Scott hired so perfect problem then cool
062okay thank you that's that's a good question okay move into policy 6244 the procurement there's only one related Red Line This is a consideration to contract amount that's required to yeah so and I've done my research and I know this has been the issue the has interested it was seven years ago yeah um so the the the work I did with my staff was we picked 50,000 um we tried to do a little survey of districts around us and large urban districts are in terms of their policy Milwaukee is at 50,000 now Green Bay Sun Prairie and Verona are at [Music] 250,000 contract has to 250,000 before it goes to the board um in between that range of 50 to 250 is wosa is at 84,000 Shaban are are at 75,000 or above kosha also
063has 50,000 Middleton has a 100,000 while aossa has 84,000 kind of give you a sense of the it's all so I went with the Lan number knowing this has been an issue where the board doesn't like to go too high on this so I want with 50,000 talk to the staff saying well Milwaukee's doing 50,000 Kos is doing 50,000 let's go 50,000 we think it should be raised obviously um but I didn't think you'd go for the 250 red lines yeah that's I entertain putting it down at 250 I didn't think pressure would let me get away yeah okay I see um Ali's hand Nikki's hand then Blair's hand Bob what is manona Grove at in terms of their consent agenda I do not know I can I'll I can get I'll look into that
064it's it's a surprisingly not an easy number to always get down by just doing online searches so but we I'll definitely check that I I'm deeply curious and I guess I I wonder if there's anything to be gained in terms of caution related to uh the board's ability to oversee cash flow management and you know uh I I think there's some nervousness around you know if we I I agree with you I think over 50,000 is reasonable just given the size of our budget and the amount of work it generates to bring everything over $50,000 to this board um and and still I think that there is some real consequences for a board letting their budget get away from them thank you Ali for go ahead Nikki I think to no surprise I I am
065against this I think this will further weaken the board because contracts won't people vote for their elected official they don't vote for their administrators they very very simply the board is in charge of making budget decision we hire the superintendent we have a limited role in certain areas I respect that I understand that but when the contract doesn't even go to the board yet the board is held responsible for the actions of that contract that they may not that they may have absolutely nothing to do with let's take the mascot for example that we will have nothing to do with yet the number of emails and things that board members have been asked regarding that when we have absolutely no say in it whatsoever is other than for example with the large contract portion I
066I really think that 50,000 is too high the 35,000 anything under 35,000 would be too low I'm sorry I don't think business could be done and I think 35,000 to the most I could see is 40 because I think that the taxpayers have a right to know how their money is being used and I think that part of that is the give and take between the board and administration and I think that needs to be done in a manner when I first came on the board seven years ago sorry this long share but when I first came on the board seven years ago it we had too many oh God I'm sorry I'm sorry I did I'm um we didn't we we had too many things of board involvement I'm agreeing with that 100% because
067you couldn't do the normal course of business I think we finally struck a balance where people could understand it at 35,000 to raise it to 50 especially after a referendum where people are like I trusted you with the money I trusted you with this I'm showing you this and I get that I think we followed absolutely all our obligations and are doing it well what I'm afraid of is people aren't going to understand and people are going to see the words 50,000 and say see they're just using it for their own gain I don't know how we could explain it but I think that would be a serious problem presswise and publicly that's why I'm against thank you Nikki so are you then proposing to at the 35 35 at most raised to 40 if
068I absolutely had thank you um Blair and then sh um if I understand like inflation would time this was get about 40 just just with inflation um I think 50 sound reasonable and I support that change thank you then morea yes I was going to say I also support raising the minimum to 50,000 I I literally as we were here talking just went back to our January board meeting I opened up all of our consent items and of all of the items that we approve as a board there were from what I can tell only two items that would have been under 50,000 um um one was uh ordering paper for printing that was under 50,000 but it but it still hit the threshold that needed to come to us and then one was um
069our partnership with 100 black men of Madison that was under 50,000 but over the 35,000 so it did come to us and in though in and just I know we fluctuate month-to month but in last month's board meeting we didn't pull any of those items we we approved them um so I think the the only thing um if we go to 50,000 is for the smaller um for the amounts that are less than the 50,000 that we would no longer see what is the is there some other way that the board would have a sense of like let's just say like the 100 black men partnership like where how would we know that those things have continued um because I think sometimes our Partnerships with community-based organizations sometimes not always sometimes those may be at
070a slightly lower amount um and and so just curious how the board would know about any of those ongoing Partnerships or contracts um um just in case we were contacted at a later point so I my recommendation would be that we're even going to be doing an update on Partnerships okay for the most part most of the time we focus on high intensity but the ship would just be to provide an update on all the Partnerships that we have within the district so the board would know the Partnerships that were loing along with the the approved contracts correct okay like we we could just provide you with the information so you know what what uh what Partnerships are ongoing with your team well under board policy the the board is supposed to be approving medium
071and high-intensity partnership right low intensity doesn't require that so that would just you just add L but and get to a Cadence of doing it like on a yearly basis from the beginning so you would kind of know like what those Partnerships were from the very beginning versus py okay how would the this policy impact would it would it impact the donations or is that a separate policy because I do see that in our consent agendas we often are approving um donation amounts per policy 6177 different policy so we would still those would still come forward to us corre okay unless you shifted that policy to address okay got it okay I see um Laura's hand and savan okay so Claire and Nichelle you basically answered both of my questions which was kind of crazy
072um but I am curious about I was thinking about the rate of inflation for the original policy in 1998 what was that question yeah right like I'm I'm wondering if we have not at all actually kept up with the pace of inflation so it's a curiosity I guess I don't need to know but I'm glad to know that we are seeing that this is even below the rate of inflation from the last update um and I was also wondering about the percentage of consent items this start taxs was there any actual analysis information this is slightly above 50 is slightly above what the inflation would have been between 2020 and now okay um I was responding to board member Vander mulan's 40,000 number okay um it's I just used the calculator but it looked to
073me like if inflation between 2020 and now is 22% yeah it would be like 40 like almost 43 thank you for sorry for the the interruption I just wanted to make that point of clarification no that that's that's helpful um so and then I am wondering I know it's a big lift to put together the consent item memos um and so I I appreciate that this would take a little bit of that administrative burden off um but I am wondering you know like how much of a burden does this actually relieve yeah um and so I don't know if any any analysis was done to look at other than in last January or last month like I can pull those numbers I don't you know what don't don't worry I'm gonna agree with it's fine
074actually I'd like to see Nikki excuse me I'm sorry what' you say I said I'd like to see it if it's not too much trouble it's too much trouble don't do it if it's a minute like a five minute thing then do it if it's more than five minutes please don't do it because your time is much more valuable than that can we does that make sense can we clarify like what you're asking then I just I just wanted to see what the abouts work okay okay I mean I'm happy to do that I but if it takes a lot of time I'm not trying to ca a lot of time I just I'll talk to it's curiosity more than anything contract in M I'll see what we can pull together I'll get a report
075I'll get you I appreciate I don't take more than five minutes but pull the numbers okay D go ahead thank you hey Bob yeah I appreciate the figures you gave for surrounding districts and Milwaukee um just as a percentage of the budget um that we do approve and vote on and um formulate um where already at the very very lower bound and even if we increase it by 15,000 it seems like we'd be at the lower Bound for other districts with smaller budgets but higher thresholds um God I sorry um I had my comment and then it just escaped me it's all right davan if you say go higher you were gonna say go higher wer no I was not gonna say oh no okay no I just wanted to to to to to to
076clarify that the contracts going through for purchase um that amount was already approved by us no through the formal budget process like which number do you be referring to uh either way like if it goes through the consent process that dollar amount has already been like you know the board approves a certain amount of expenditures per year through the budget process and so that gets allocated to dep departments and so they have that discretionary money to execute you know the vision so that money has already been allocated to them no correct correct that's correct yeah okay so this is like a second level of of approval then when you think about it that way um so even if we do increase it by 15 um the board still has levers to course correct um through
077the overall budget process if something below that threshold um indicated that we were drifting away or violated our values or something like that so thank you thank you so what I'm hearing just a recap is that majority of folks are kind of like around the okay with the 50,000 we're looking for per curiosity some of the inflationary numbers in the past um and so it's like that's where we're at right now any other questions about this policy let's move on to the last on policy 85 or sorry 8351 travel reimbursements pet talk about this I'm just kidding so there's a lot of red line but I'll just quickly explain all the red line is going on we have a policy that talks about travel reimbursement that we have not let me say we have an
078alternative proced procedure that we've been using um to reimburse employees for travel it's been going on for few years and what we're doing now is pretty much summarized in the language under two that we add so this really is a board policy um that we're updating to the steps and processes that have already been adopted by the district um and so that's why you see um the red line through all the other stuff because we just do it based on um fedal reimbursement or mile set on on for this one for travel it's the Pedro IRS amount that we use and I am like change and this is is actually also a topic we're talking in handbook an improvement I consider an improvement of policy is we would like employees um to submit for for
079reimbursement um within a month after the month the travel has happened so if they travel in the month of December they have until the end of January to submit that reimbursement to their supervisor the supervisor will then have a to approve that and we think that's we think that's beneficial to employees and to supervisors to be real clear on we want you to get your reimbursement for your travel get it done we think it's reasonable a whole month after the month get your travel reimbursement in and then specifying supervisors we got a month to take care of it I think that's really what this is well I would just add just one quick thing to what Bob had said which is um striking the L language about um the required minimums for insurance carried by
080a driver of a vehicle the reason that was struck is because the language is duplicative if you look at policy 8350 which is in regards to liability insurance slash alternative method of providing transportation for students that policy sets forth all these requirements and one initiative that the policy Comm is wanting to undertake and this is at the advice of Legal Services is to make sure that we're not being duplicative across policies because that makes the administration and revision of policy time more burdensome so if for whatever reason the state passed something and that need to change be having to look across policies versus one so that's the reason for that language being struck thank you for that um that added um explanation BL be the name of the policy that 83 thanks yeah um other
081otherwise the changes make perfect sense yes in this policy um you have embedded a process which is the submission on a monthly basis and that the supervisor gets an additional mon to me that's internal processes um and since the board itself is not really position to Monitor and or enforce the internal processes of employees I guess I guess I'm wondering that should be in here or that's something that is like more like guidance from the budget planning and accounting department out to employees um because I I think what I think about is what if there was an employee who did not submit their mind Mage reimbursement on a monthly basis they let it accumulate for several months because they're just too busy to get mileage for men and just what if budget planning and accounting
082then decided Well per for board policy you're out of compliance and we're going to deny your reimbursement and then now all of a sudden you have an employee filing a grievance because they act did the travel you know I mean so I I think what I'm trying to think about is like should that language actually be in the policy or not did you guys think about or discuss that we didn't discuss it there is a provision in the handbook that's very similar to this policy that we're also making we're discussing with MPI and about having the same language that appears and really the the way the handbook reach now it says should be submitted within two months the reimbursement right and so wanted to specify in the handbook we're asking to specify what is the
083employees responsibility and what is supervisor's responsibility still maintaining that TW Monon window of requested the answer is for president if you don't submit it time you under the current so that's why we're trying to specify we're still maintaining a two-month window but we're specifying employees you have a month to submit then end of the month that you travel supervisors you have one month to approve it be and the office to process the payment within two months of the month of Trav I see it's and it's specified this way in the H so can I just so we we looked at a policy Red Line earlier this evening that just said shall be in accordance with the employee handbook would we would we use language that could be similar to that or is there are you
084seeing that this is something that really needs to be more delineated in policy to make it more effective I think that's a good point you're raising for pres I think it's a good point okay okay Blair and the I appreciate that too um uh okay staff member assigned to more than one school can be compensated for travel but I'm wondering about like what about people who are assigned to one school but because of the nature of their work at that school are often traveling like um for example special education teachers in transition programs who are going sight to site but are still you know attached to one school um or like uh people who supervise students and youth apprenticeships who were making visits to the students job sites wouldn't fall into this policy and I
085just wonder about if if that came up or have you thought about that right because there because they're assigned to a school but they're they uh they travel in the course of performing their duties something a very good point because I didn't yeah my answer but would been someone would asked me to get to be reimbursed for the trail you just grabed that would said of course you do just same right like you have to go what do all this stuff but it's not it wouldn't fall under the policy so something up for the committee under this policy or this policy it wouldn't fit right because it because it says a staff member assigned to more than one school shall be con unless it's separate right like like the second part would say the district
086shall reimburse employees in such and such a way um to each employee required by the district to drive their personal vehicle during the of so the I guess is it both so the second part would would cover someone who's for example going to visits for youth apprenticeships or adult transition but the first I don't know I don't I don't personally feel like I need to do the do that part but just popping up to me okay I'm not following I see the item you're talking about item number one wasn't redlined um and I had Miss yes thank you yes that's what I'm talking about uh Ali oh sorry go ahead Nikki and then ali um just uh briefly um I happen to agree with the shell we could just say this is a handbook issue
087the also my other problem that I have with this is that I feel it will burn our HR department because it's not just staff I worry about but everything must be processed within one month I think right now that might overburden our HR at the same time and I think there could be an absolute hardship on them because it says that people won't get reimbursed if it's not it well they may have done it if HR didn't is is swamped and doesn't get to it this is going to cause a lot of issues yeah it's an it's an online form can be submitted by the employees TR when it's submitted it's my team that okay okay that that makes more sense because I was assuming supervisor I was thinking the HR department end up going
088do we really want to burn that and that's what my fear was so thank you for clarifying that that's really much more helpful Ali thanks Maya um I curious about how you factor State Statute into this in terms of our reimbursement related to private school transportation and so I very much appreciate that we're talking about employees and that we're talking about um you know something that aligns with our current handbook I think that makes this an easy policy to vote in favor of um I really appreciate the Nuance of the conversation but my understanding is that state statute dictates that we reimburse people whose children attend private school for their mileage relating to transporting their own students and that people have until the end of the year to collect that reimbursement from us if their
089student is supposed to attend our district is that correct so there's a separate poliy I Ali I think that that it's two policies that we're talking about the policy that we're talking about right now is just the policies for how staff are reimbursed when they drive down their cars or when they're out going outside for traveling that's a totally different separate policy I guess I am asking about that policy because I'm wondering why like we have that standard as it if if I'm correct in my description of that policy I'm wondering why we have that standard as it relates to state to Statute in which people um can accumulate that cost over the course of the school year and then submit a a reimbursement um for the to for the total amount at the end
090of the year I guess I'm curious is there a reason why we couldn't Echo that process as it relates to staff so if if you know to Michelle's point if someone's traveling really consistently and they're keeping track of it and it's easier to to do it all at once or to do it every semester um is there a reason we'd want to stay away from that kind of flexibility as it relates to this mileage reimbursement versus per state statute is there a difference in terms of how we're handling reimbursement related to um transportation for private school I'm wondering if I we could take your question as an admin team because I think we need to be better suited to answer that question by reviewing the process of of that particular policy that you're talking about
091against this one so we can have another answer so my recommendation is that we bring that back at the next time when we review this particular policy Dr McCrae I greatly appreciate that and I think I do I do understand that these are are different realities and we get to hold our staff to a different standard but I think if we already are equipped to take on the accumulative cost of Transportation or mileage reimbursement for some populations I'm just curious about what it looks like to apply that um to our faculty and staff and and so I I greatly appreciate your willingness to look into it and you know hopefully it doesn't create too much work for anyone I I but I I my initial gut is telling me just the amount of doing it
092that way where it's open-ended just what that capacity of workload be for our finance department that is it is a great team but it is a small and Nimble team um and so I and just the amount of employees that we do have with malet compared you know it's it's very different but I rather us like pull the data so we can really have that conversation but initially that's what my gut is telling me like our huge thing is going to be the amount of individuals that's working to do these processes because it's still some of it is a manual piece of it so I would just rather us have that conversation to review thank you so much I appreciate it and I do understand that like we have to take into consideration and Factor
093capacity um to fulfill this work in a timely matter and the limitations of our capacity related to this particular body of work so thank you for um being willing to to review kind of the the relevant data and bring it back to us great question not Le thank you um any other comments about this policy go ahead Nikki that's I Ali's uh questions actually spur uh question in me because I'm worried that um the Optics of the situation and we will pay for private schools you have until the end of the year but if you are a teacher who or a custodian who working certain number of shifts and or teacher or staff not necessarily custodian who's working a certain number of shifts and doesn't get it in at time they're held to a character
094standard seems almost punitive but maybe I'm wrong and maybe I'm missing something and I could take it as I'm probably missing something but any suggestions would because I just don't want it to seem like we're punishing our staff that's my only well yeah maybe as board members we can each um go back and just even look at what's currently in the employee handbook um because I I know when Bob was saying this would cross reference employee handbook um you know if our employees are looking at the handbook as a way to um navigate through the district um for a variety of ways it might be good for us look at currently stated in our handbook and then come back to this um policy and um yeah and does the do you all as the poliy
095committee feel like you have enough reaction yes on for not I think so yes think we're thank you off yeah next okay that that is the last policy for this policy review meeting um give you guys a round of applause thank you to the policy committee for all of your work to get us these set of policies and I will also I know um Blair said this earlier but I just wanna congratulate the policy committee and congratulate us as a board for trying out a new structure which is we agreed working 2025 we would kind of designate quarterly meeting to um try to accelerate us getting through more policies at one time so thank you for giving us such a successful first run yeah absolutely thank you um well we'll we'll figure out what the
096nexts are for all of these and and with that you have to say something oh I'll hand it over to board president Nichols thank you all right the second item tonight is a discussion of the forward career and College Academy charter proposal as a reminder um this item tonight is is not to indicate how a board member tends to vote uh we will actually take that action on Monday night this is really a discussion item grounded in The Proposal that we received the feedback um about the proposal um and any follow-up questions um that we may have wanted to raise um tonight so with that I I will turn it over to uh Dr goth and Dr mccraine thank you very much president Nichols members of the board um we are going to just simply
097give a bit of a recap on the process and what we have done to this date uh to get you are to prepare you to prepare all for Monday night's deliberation and eventual vote so ask Dr McCrae just outline briefly the the process the documents perhaps that you have in front of you tonight a new one I want to definitely give you some context on CTE overviews that we provided TJ if you could take it from there um good evening so this evening um we are here just to allow the board to engage in a conversation around the current Charter School application that we have in front of us the organization has submitted the proposal via our board policy that we have and met all the timelines that we have already outline um each board
098members have that uh actual proposal in addition to that we provided them with some feedback that is also in front of you that includes a workbook mockup for what this school could look like in addition to that you will see that they did provide some feedback to the feedback and so you have that in front of you too um so if you want to engage in those things that you're having in this conversation this evening finally um as Dr gotha highlighted um we did prepare a document that um um really looks at what CTE looks like um for us as a district and where we are and what we're doing in our CTE world and so we wanted our board members to also be able to have that information um as we're beginning to engage
099in this conversation um and then finally just board Nicholls um stated board president Nicholls stated um the vote part of our procedure will happen at our February General board meeting where the board will take action on so tonight it's just allow you to conversation well point of order question yes will the will the uh as these public documents now will they uh public be able to see them on board docks or how does that work in in a workshop I'm gonna have to get back to steeve because I need because I don't I don't want it I understand that's where I'll follow that's fine I'll turn it over to the board to engage in the conversation okay um so let's see here we know that we received a proposal um there was feedback that the
100administration provided based on a rubric um that is used to kind of score and look at different components of the proposal and that was done not by an individual but a a Comm of folks correct okay and then that um information was shared with the proposing organization back to Ford career and college academy career and College Academy okay and then um they didn't have to but they also took the opportunity to respond to the feedback that they received correct okay so that um you have and that document is dated from February 13 and and there provide some additional um responses to the um administration's kind of analysis on the proposal the sample School allocation is um an attempt to look at what we would require if the school were to be an instrumentality based on
101what the forward career in college um Academy said on the 150 ninth graders year one year one and I just want to think like there are other roles that we might not see so you gotta think like custodian you need to think of like food service like so there are some things that are not showing up on this one um but there are some additional responsibilties and roles that we will also need to fold into the school in order for it to be just just want to put that in your mind too yeah and then the Career and Technical education um flyer or document that you all put together provides board members with more insight on kind of what we do have going on with Career and Technical education and I'm assuming in some ways
102we're getting this um which is helpful because some in The Proposal I think there was a kind of a strong assertion that we weren't doing anything and there were kind of references to something at the state level that said we had like zero um percent of I don't I don't remember if it was work-based some industry credentials industry credentials okay so this this gives us a little bit more perspective on what we do have happening and and just as a reminder of it is that the we tried to correct that issue with DPI however because the issue was it's an older issue we're unable to go back and correct it once to reported to it so we try to be um to update that and we've been doing a lot of internal work to make
103sure that our reporting structures are set up properly by meeting and just making sure our data is clean but we were unable to correct that so I just want to make sure we know that that is incorrect but we are unable to corrected with right so I guess I'll open it up to see if there are comments or questions um about any of the documents presented yes I really I really appreciate that um that information about the the the error um in the state provided data um I'm really proud of the way that our CTE programs with an University High School are growing um I know that students who are attending our comprehensive high schools have access to work-based learning that is getting better every year um and I and I think that there's a
104like with the state data that information is not always out there um and and so so for me when I when I hear community support for a charter school that would offer work-based learning and internships I understand it um um and I would say to people who say hey this sounds great like this does sound great and we have it right now in MSD schools go talk to your school counselor because they know how to get you hooked up um and I think that I think that really matters um the other thing that I think has been coming up for me through this process is is twofold one is like without discounting the the the applicants desire to see Innovative things happening I think that there's a misconception about what goes into running a a
105high school for hundreds of students um in and I think the um this the the sample allocation here sort of like elucidates that like there's so much that goes into making it possible for an adolescent no I think this is it right like it's easy to do it for one right for one student for two students for 10 students sure right like you can kind of like Homebrew um something that functions to serve those students but we don't have 10 right we have thousands hundreds and thousands like not hundreds of thousands we have hundreds and then thousands and like the the um the what we provide in comprehensive high schools in a in um a full in a full District that has so many supports I think can't be can't be understood and it's not
106always seen um partly because it's not always everybody's business right like the the amount of work that school social workers do to support a student who who's struggling to get to school like you don't talk about it right like they're not supposed to talk about it's not anybody's business um but when you when when people who whose experience of school is being a student or having a kid in school um you're you're missing that context of like what really goes into it and I think that's important and then the other thing I think that's coming up for me is like an understanding of what's getting in the way and when I look at this application a lot of the rhetoric is about like kids just need to believe they need to be shown that they
107can do it there's opportunities and while I believe and like live my life working in schools like building students up to that there are also barriers that are significantly beyond what a student thinks is possible um again I'm going to bring up Transportation housing and stability all of these things that get in the way of a student's ability to take advantage of an internship um that that to me especially right now especially as our um broader political situation is like consistently undercutting the supports that people need to get what they to just like live dignified lives I think it's important that people not be discounting those and then I guess the last thing the last thing that's on my mind about it is like uh no no I I I'll leave it there so that
108those are the kinds of things that are on my mind as I'm reading through this application and thinking about the the existing programs in mmsd that we've been investing in that have been growing that have been successful um that I I mean like more Partnerships are always welcome but I don't to me I don't see here I don't see the Innovation and I don't see the expanding access which for me are the the main the main things so that's that's kind of where I'm at with that thank you Blair other board members have any responses questions or comments from the documents that we have Benny meren so far yes for member malra thank you board president Nichols I um I'm really sorry I can't be there in person tonight I'm incredibly sick um but I
109think that this is one of the most important conversations we're gonna get to have is really teasing about this proposal um I have to admit that I was really disappointed by the final proposal because I felt like questions I asked really early on in the process were not addressed in terms of the size of the school where these students are coming from um and the implications of where this school will be located right if this is a school that's going to serve the entire city um I think working in partnership with our district to discuss what it means to have a centrally located High School is is a relevant Factor so I guess I want to ask our Administration how responsive um the the team putting together this proposal was to questions board members raised
110early on and why that information is not included in the final proposal and obviously I I know that you didn't write the proposal so I just I don't it's not on you I'm just I'm just curious if there's an explanation I don't I I think it's hard to answer that question on why the questions were not answering in the final proposal because we really did not engage in conversations about um The Proposal um after we get provid them with the feedback so I think it's also critical to just remember that we provided the feedback thinking about some of the things that the board voiced at the meeting and we shared that feedback for them prior to them creating the final proposal um and so all we can do is just provide the feedback to them
111and hope that they incorporate it and that's the standard process that we've done with all of our Charters we did the same thing with Vader Rock we did the same thing with no shundo by giving them opportunity to submit it when it was in draft form provide them feedback and then provide it again and then give them the fal yeah so I will say like the location and number of students is one of the more concerning components of this proposal and I didn't feel like I gained a lot of clarity um around those those aspects of The Proposal I also want to lift what board member Moser felm said which is these these opportunities exist within our district and so it feels like we would be creating duplicative opportunities um and I think that there's
112some real missed opportunity and expanding access to Opportunities or strengthening opportunities um that that maybe the district has n already um developed programming around and so I I really I find this proposal hard to um support at this point because I feel that it's missing some really foundational information um in terms of how this would work I also want to say that we've seen 2x 2x Charters really struggle um at the high school level at the secondary level and you know uh we saw we've seen multiple 2x Charters shut down their High School programming um and so I I agree completely with my my board colleague who said you know this is a a tremendous undertaking and you know it it's something that has to be done with a great deal of Integrity um in
113order for it to work well otherwise it destabilizes students who are really really looking for a solution to to being successful at school Bob I have some curiosity about um what this will cost the district we're a 2X Charter with 600 students um you know to pull a significant number of that 600 students from our district going into the 2025 2026 school year that's a that's a difficult question to answer because of the lack of specificity where the schools going to be located um first so I'll talk about rues work in the state funding formulas um and in order to get a really clear picture on that we really need to know if they're going to start with 100 how many students they have whether the students are currently enop if they're currently enrolled in
114massan school district we get zero new revenues and it becomes an issue of whatever is going to cost the school is all cost right no additional revenues generated just new costs um so we'd have to come up with where you gonna cost right if all 150 students are new never been enrolled in Madison School District and and move into the district the way Revenue limits work is we would get revenues per child of about 14,400 this year but it would only be onethird of that Revenue because Revenue limits threee average so you'd have full-time costs a first year and only onethird of the revenue cover those costs the costs are or above that um if they're coming from other districts under open enrollment we get about $99,000 spendable Revenue um but that would be the
115only new Revenue we would generate and so that's kind of how the high level numbers for I greatly appreciate that that explanation and I do hope that we can really refine um some level of protection around projection around uh the financial implications of this school becoming either an instrumentality or a 2X Charter um I think that's a major factor in how this board moves forward in discussing this proposal the last thing I want to acknowledge is that we heard a lot of support for this school in public comment comment recently um and the racial demographics of folks we heard that support from were were folks who uh for for the majority part identified as as African-American and black and so I do think there's a need to acknowledge that our our district has to strengthen
116our approach to working with students of color to particularly serving our our our black students and at the same time I I want to recognize that there is a predatory Dynamic of coming into a district like ours and uh saying that you are going to resolve something as deepr rooted as racialized inequity um through a a school that pairs young people with professional opportunities I think there's a lot of complexity in the conversation about how this Pro proposal is leveraging the race dynamics of our community and I am curious if our Administration um wants to acknowledge that Dynamic and speak to the work that we're doing to ensure that all students but specifically students who have been historically underserved by our district um are getting their needs met and you know I I think I
117have a great deal of compassion for families who are coming forward to us and saying what you all are doing isn't working for my kid and I need something else and and I want people to know that we hear that and um we we are willing to work together and work with them to address it so board member Alro thank you for the question I'll um start with a response can you hear me okay okay perfect it's Cindy by the way in case you can't see um uh so I think there are um a couple of responses that I would provide to that um first is um the CTE kind of quick facts or uh fact sheets that we provided um does provide a breakdown in terms of who we currently are serving across all
118of our schools as it relates to these opportunities and there is definitely proportionate uh ratios in terms of of students uh specifically black as well as other student groups compared to our overall um District demographic data so I think we are doing a good job in terms of getting students the opportunities that they deserve in addition to that I mean we can always you know do better and improve we are also ensuring that these opportunities exist beyond our for comprehensive high school and so that is an important factor so Capital High if everyone recalls has a culinary uh CTE program has a health science CTE program and also we have a strong partnership with Madison College for other areas that they cannot do on their campuses uh Capital High happens to serve about uh 80
119to 90% of students of color so they're getting a great opportunity there shabaz also has um these opportunities and then iae uh which is our Innovative alternative education programs we have really worked on that in the last two years to en sure again regardless of what school or program our students are in that they are receiving these opportunities so the internships um this is where our partners come in and are really important because uh iae doesn't have the facilities on their site but they are working in collaboration and then we've also been able to do um though more minimal um at our Metro we have four that we serve and we've done a lot of career exploration and been able to bring in some exposure there so I think we're trying to ensure across all
120um eight of our high school spaces that students are receiving these opportunities I do think as a system there are um infrastructure barriers and other barriers for the access that we have to continue to work through but I think the team and myself are really proud of the work over the last five years that has grown and just again some of the you know quick data points here show that we are continuing to do it and I'll remind the board of the um presentation we did in October which really showed both cost-saving measures that we've been able to provide to students and families as well as kind of a highlight about what happens in the summer when students have much more free time and the number of paid internships we've been able to provide and
121that's really in collaboration with our cbos Our Community Partners and the city so just another um mention of where we think this work has really grown okay I see um her heart response um Savon or board member Castro I believe I saw your hand up a little while ago did you still wanna make a comment or ask a question yeah um I guess two broad comments and maybe a question um I just wanted to well I guess three yeah I wanted to thank everyone involved in this progress I think or process I think at the end of the day um we can all agree we want to um have an education system that meets the needs of every child and uh improves access and opportuni so I value that base value from all of us
122um having said that just about the application in general I have been concerned by the kind of seemingly evolving leadership um from the folks submitting the application um some of the backgrounds of some members of the leadership team uh do not necessarily uh fit with the philosophy of education that that we have so I wanted to get that off the bat and I think fundamentally um there was just a misalignment here um that doesn't mean that this has to be the final missed opportunity but I do think that there is a fundamental misalignment in terms of how the school would fit into our um more broad District plans and misunderstanding of services that we already provide especially boosted up services from the passage of the past two referenda um and um spaces in our high
123school to provide more CTE um and also when I think about some of our more successful Partnerships um they have kind of started small and then we scaled up further um for example when it comes to or when it comes to enrollment um meeting their enrollment goals I was kind of suspicious on how they would meet that um especially if some of the students came disproportionately from one from what high school what that would mean to the viability for that one high school um kind of uncertainty about um the in structional design and Staffing as well um whether that would be additive or duplicative it just seems like there is more opportunity to figure out where the holes are um and the services that that that we provide um so yeah that's my general first
124thoughts thank you thank you member c um Bo member simin you don't have to do you have have anything you want to share tonight or ask okay great y I can speak um I don't really have any questions I'll I'll just share a little bit about my my impression of The Proposal um when I was reading it it left me with a lot of a lot of questions that I'm not going to ask right now because they're questions of the group that submitted the proposal um and a lot of them fell into the category of how are the students academic social and emotional needs going to be met within this framework um looking at the proposed curriculum I couldn't see a justification for how those curriculums were chosen um I also was and am very
125unclear on on the the idea that the first year in ninth grade that students would be moved up to grade level academic work and then go on from there I I would have loved to know how that that was anticipated that that would be taking place um since that's something thing that is a district and I'd say as a country that we're struggling with and so there wasn't detail to describe how that was going to happen um there there wasn't really anything in the proposal about students with different learning needs and so students who either had IEPs or were um identified as advanced Learners were not acknowledged throughout the proposal and we have a large number of students that fit into those categories and so I would assume there'd be within pool that would fit
126into those categories and it didn't talk about meetings as far as curriculum or um support of adults within um within the program and and then that led me to wonder there wasn't a budget attached to it and so it it my impression of The Proposal is that it's very ambitious and that it would take significant funding structure to be able to meet all of the students needs academically socially emotionally um that it would be a high intensity um Staffing situation but we did work provided with that information um so I was left with a lot of curiosity about that um um that's my feedback thank you well I will also say a few things um work with me for a minute as I share this this reading this proposal and being presented with the opportunity
127to think about um whether or not we're um wanting to to move into a charter school uh another Charter School it made me think about the two Charter renewals that this current board has recently engaged in we recently renewed Badger Rock and we recently renewed no Mundo that's all been within the last year and of course renewing a charter school is very different than approving a startup charter school which led me oddly down um down the road of thinking about huh I wonder what it looked like Char um the wal Mundo first began that charter school is an instrumentality of ours and is like 20 years old but 20 years ago they would have been coming to the district right with a proposal and I went back on their website um went back and found
128older articles and there were some things that were distinctly unique um when nestro Mundo decided to form and propose a charter school what I found in some of the archives is that the community of Madison had changed very dramatically in the late 1990s we had a huge migration um from Mexico Central and South America and guess what but that meant our Madison School District was not well equipped or staff to actually serve our Spanish-speaking Children and Families very well the families then decided to start and and probably staff of mmsd um started meeting about what would be a better way to address this need because we're probably going to see more families moving to Madison and at that time they they went beyond just looking at like English as a second language they looked at
129dual language immersion it was a practice that at the time mmsd did not have and they spent a couple of years actually forming their nonprofit a couple of years in the community meeting with parents about this potential new school and would would they even send their children into a dual language immersion school they were meeting with Community leaders they were fundraising like you can see the work they did from about 2000 to 2004 they worked with board members they worked with existing school they they actually were working with lafalot high school staff because they wanted the school to be located in that attendance area and wanted to have some sense of what it would look like for for students to move up into that to their feeder high school so I was like looking at
130all of the ground Community work and when they came forward to the school district at uh the school district and the school board at that time their proposal was to start with a Kindergarten class I don't remember the size of the class it might have been 90 students 75 I don't remember but it was to start with a initial class and they would grow each year adding a grade level right and they were a school in a school they were actually housed in Frank Alice Elementary School and their first Charter School contract with the district had them in one of our schools as an instrumentality um and then upon the second Charter renewal some five years later they were starting to burst at the seams um because of really great enrollment and Frank Alice was
131also bursting at the seams and said like we could kind of use some of that space back and that's when new westro Mundo ended up moving to a leas space in manona growth at uh I think it's Nicholls at Nicholls school but anyway and then it's odd that they're back in the Frank Alice building now um kind of in the building to themselves so I I share that to say reading this Charter proposal kind of put me back in the mindset of like what does it look like when an organization has an idea for an unmet need in our district um and that could bring something forward and Innovative that we maybe we haven't tried yet so I opened up this proposal actually looking for a vision that um I could I could see um
132on paper and I appreciate all of the work that has gone in to writing the proposal I I don't think it's an easy thing to write a proposal and to spend a lot of time um envisioning every aspect of what a school needs to have and for me um and I used our our own District rubric it it was there were just components within the proposal that didn't give me enough detail um and it it was not in one or two areas it was in um several of the areas and it did leave me asking way more questions about what what's the curricular model what is the the kind of the Master's schedule for students um I I kind of got a good sense of the the curriculum but there were there were just some
133things overall that I was left with more questions about out and I think to your point board member simin because there wasn't a budget which I could imagine if you're not inside the district it might be hard to come up with a budget you know I mean for an instrumentality school but because I I didn't I couldn't see a budget it was also hard to imagine how the Staffing um that was in The Proposal would work within our larger system I I think for me as a as a board remember um you know one of the things that we also for me there's one of the things is considering is like is there an area that our current system our current programming does not provide um and is a charter an instrumentality Charter an opportunity
134to try something so I tried to read it in that spirit and I think I was still left with way more questions than uh potential answers about how that could work I also think um in a system that's as large as ours um you know when you're looking at the the strategies for recruitment the strategies for enrollment um in The Proposal that didn't end up feeling as clear to me either about where the students were coming from uh would we be if we were to implement this as an instrumentality are we taking students from our four five six schools and trying to get them into this new offering are they yeah it was just a it was a little harder to imagine exactly um how it would fit in our larger system so I it
135but I do want to just say I appreciate the time that went into writing the proposal I appreciated the um public comment uh you know one of the things that I have noticed is that I kind of have been checking my emails even since the public comment looking to see if there has been more student or family demand um kind of going back to what I I had seen and what newro Mundo had when they first started and I I haven't seen that um in my in my inbox so I don't have a I don't have a sense that um there's a lot of folks asking for this um but that's not to negate the the power of the the public comment um a while ago and I and I will just conclude by saying
136I do also appreciate the administration like your time reading providing Fe back um and also being able to come up with like some facts about what we are providing and what we're not um and where there's opportunities to continue to um strengthen our own District I I will say recently you know just kind of looking at the educational landscape I think there is a lot of conversation not unique to this Charter proposal or mmsd I just think in the educational landscape there's a lot of language about our Public Schools being places that prepare our students to go directly into the workforce um I think lots of districts have been investing more in Career and Technical education but I I'm hearing more and more of like may be a prioritization of dollars um at the federal
137level towards this idea of students being able to go from high school graduation directly into potentially High earning um jobs and or um filling gaps in the workforce that currently exist around kind of these skilled trades so I guess given that like given that that might be where the educational landscape is going um I can understand why maybe this proposal is is coming forward because it it's I think there's um there's more of that kind of talk around the importance of our Public Schools serving that purpose as as well um and you know again I'll just say that I guess as I read The Proposal used our own rubric um to think critically about about what was being proposed I still I just was left with more questions but I I do think that whether
138regardless of how the board votes on Monday night I think that we have got to as a district be thinking about there are lots of students in our in our district that like it's not that they're not capable of going to college that's just not the thing they want to do and there are students who want to be able to get out there and make money um and to feel like they they've got a kind of a natural progression um right into what could be a a decent paying job right after school um that doesn't require a degree and I think the more that we can bolster those opportunities in our district and I think it is critical because I think more and more students there are more and more more numbers of students who
139want those opportunities not just a pathway to a two or four year college yes I appreciate your thoughtfulness so much um and I want to say a couple couple of things not necessarily specifically in response to this proposal but in response to some of the ideas that you brought up as were thinking about the the future direction of schools um you it like your your little History tour was so helpful um and it made me think about how like the way Charters function has also changed significantly over that time yes and like if you think about the intention of a school district being able to Charter a school 30 years ago um that is no longer the only thing that shutters are being used to and like I said I'm not talking necessarily about this
140proposal right I'm not casting accusations about this group necessarily but I am saying that we are we're in a context where the existence of public high schools public schools not just high schools but Public Schools generally is being challenged um with a lot of money behind it and a lot of political sophistication behind it using ideas like um choice or parents rights that are actually masked for dis manling public education again not talking about this proposal but I do think that we should not naively assume that like that's never present um around us so I wanted to offer that um for anybody who's listening like I was like my my like first full-time teaching job was at a charter school in Oakland like I loved that school I loved my students I think I I
141was a new teacher so I sure I made a lot of mistakes um but I did good work for my students we learned together we grew together um so I I understand why people are seeking other other things but I but I do think that um sometimes that desire can be uh that can can lack the full analysis which I think I appreciate us bringing here so that's one thing the other thing I wanted to talk about is like going directly from high school into the workforce which I which I support for any student who wants to do that and I want to be a district that can prepare any student for that if that's what they want um that said being prepared to go out into the workforce After High School is totally different
142than like spending the majority of our high school experience working um and I bring that up because there's a there's just a difference between preparation for work and work and like we have child labor laws because poor children historically have been forced to work and not get their education and so as we're thinking about moving toward Ward being able to say yeah you can graduate from NC High School ready to work and ready to get paid when you graduate which makes it all the more important that in high school you have robust access to Arts to music to social emotional learning to to community building with your neighbors um not like not less of that right like they have to go together so I wanted to bring that up and then the last thing I
143wanted to bring up that I'm thinking about as your as your days on this History tour is gone from my from my brain so I talked I talked about like the way the the what happens around a charter proposal is different now than it used to be very much so oh I I remember right so I was looking back at our board norms and like a norm I think that we all share which is taking students under leadership students at the center and I think that sometimes when we're talking about choices it can be tempting to be like well we know there's a group of students in mmsd in this city right now who meet and therefore responding to that need right now X is the student centered choice but I also think about how
144much effort we put into an energy and thinking we put into um what makes what what our sustainability goals are and I think that we can extrapolate from our environmental sustainability goals to like what makes a school district sustainable in this political climate right now and like taking student centered leadership and making Student Center choices doesn't just mean these 25 or 26,000 students it also means the 25 or 26,000 students who are going to mmsd schools 10 years 20 years 30 years from now just like we need to make sure that they have the facilities that can support that we need to make sure that they have the public in public education infrastructure to support them and that is the last thing I wanted to say I remembered it thank you thank you player I
145want to just say um thank you for highlighting that the chartering process is much different than even the example I gave from the wro Mundo coming to the district some 20 years ago right um and yeah we we are in a different environment alog together and I also want to just say my comments about their my guess that there are young people in our district right now that would like some additional opport unities to be able to kind of graduate and get right into a a good paying um industry or sector um I I want to clarify that I think even on this fact sheet the work the fact that we are providing as many industry certifications as we are is a great start I mean we've done really good work and all I was
146saying is we should we should also just be mindful that we probably do have more students that really want these opportunities and so we need to think about how we increase access and opportunity to them um let me just say this without belaboring the night but I want to say this because I know this is on um our mmsd Board of Education YouTube um so we have Cindy you're gonna have to help me up what is the as certified tech that's for Autos that's in order to get the full certification for industry for autom okay so we have an auto certified tech certification Pro uh program is it considered yes it is a Autos program and we have autos at all four of our high schools now through our rough 2020 and continuing to work
147through so that they're all a you have to go through a certification process like from the outside organization to get cleared so we're working on making sure that happens so that every student in one of those schools that wants to take it can get the the ASC certification beautiful we have the Cort software development or its yep so for information technology it's a credentialing for information technology for the infrastructure side of it more of like the coding the hardware side great we offer nursing assistant yep CNA yep CNA we offer an nccer construction so that's construction so back to uh some of the conversations around the trades that's an opportunity for students uh through our construction labs to earn a credential in the area of construction so The Woodworking uh beginning stages of uh future
148construction we have a photomy lab tech yes industry C that's in our health sciences that one's got fewer students I wonder why because that the FLOTUS they draw the blood don't they because it's Rel so we only just got it started last year so it's relatively new and and maybe people might not be interested in BL all right Project Lead the Way sure so this is in our uh biotch stuff so for students that are interested in going into biotech or bioh health it's a project lead the way it's also a college credit bearing course so you both earn both your industry certification as well as college credit okay Serve Safe food handler and Serve Safe food manager sure so these are in our culinary program so we have culinary one two and then we
149go into proart and these our certifications that are in culinary progr okay very nice and then we also get to see the courses that are being offered um across and these are across all of the high schools correct or just the four comprehensives so it depends like barbering right now is not offered across all of our high schools mostly at East it came through our I remember that yeah so through our Esser funds um and we are continuing to work on growing that so students have access to the internship uh so that one is not off across the board and and can you say anything about the current state of our youth apprenticeship just we're talking about what we do provide yeah so youth apprenticeship is all the way at the kind of like end
150of what we think about about in terms of work-based experience for students so it starts with like job shadowing opportunities guest speakers internships and then youth apprenticeship is all the way at the end for students that uh really want to experience the full hands-on experience in a particular career field so their senior year they spend 450 hours of their school time working in that career area on the job like job site uh working and training and then at the end of that youth apprenticeship they're earning an apprenticeship opportunity so they could go straight into a registered apprenticeship right afterwards or launch right into that career currently we have about 60 students that are in youth apprenticeship across all of our high schools and that's uh more than doubled in the last few years I don't
151know if you uh recall but maybe we were at around 25 we're continuing to grow okay um you know there's there's many reasons why students might never make it to that full end of the work-based learning experience but yeah we have about 60 students um career Fields uh we've got the fleet um through uh the city of Madison we've got some in the health science we've got one student doing physical therapy that is interested over at wuw um students uh a wide range of opportunities for our students okay it's interesting I was on the thorf site recently um and I noticed they had a youth Apprentice to ship little button on their website and I I I I wasn't sure if it was like oh is that in connection with our district exclusively or just
152generally it started through it started through the ref 2020 and we had said we also want to make sure that you uh uh get uh females and students of color so there's uh you know a growing need for females in the construction area and so uh Jim yly who's you know the head of findor really made that commitment so we hired three youth Apprentice that uh have been working and I don't know the number we have this year but that all um was another amazing opportunity that came through ref 2020 I know uh board member uh Mosner belam you talk about that a lot in terms of the experiences that students can also learn from the construction of our stuff so that was one of those really cool opportunities that we started yeah well thank
153you so much um for making sure that we can speak more um poignantly about what we are providing thanks to my colleagues tonight for um engaging in just some thoughtful discussion not only about policies but about the charter proposal and um look forward to to taking action on this on Monday night um I'm assuming we're are we okay for tonight in terms of conducting our business business all right I'll take a motion to adjourn thank you board member Moser fum and M seconded all those in favor of German I all right thank you Ali hope you feel better meeting a journ