001call tonight's regular Board of Education meeting to order we start with the uh vision statement every school will be a thriving school that prepares every student to grad graduate from high school college career and Community ready and before we begin tonight's meeting we'd like to acknowledge the tragic incident that occurred at Abundant Life Christian School um we're going to read a collective statement with each of us sharing a portion of it first um on behalf of mmsd we'd like to extend our deepest sympathies to student staff and family is at ALCS we are saddened and shaken by the tragic incident that occurred on Monday um which has not only impacted Madison but also Wisconsin and the nation it is hard to find the words to truly Express how sorry we are for all those impacted
002by this unimaginable incident um we are heartbroken for those who have lost their lives um the those who were injured and all who have experienced and are still experienc emotional and phys TR we are grateful to our First Responders this quick their quick response have get students and staff to safety thank you all for your efforts your fast actions help save lives and prevent further tragedy from occurring while many were saved there are others who were lost we honor the memories of student Ruby Patricia Varga a 14-year-old freshman and of teacher Aaron Michelle Wes we send our heartfelt condolences to their families our hearts are with those who were injured and those who are in recovery we know that the emotional impact can take to and encourage those who need support to reach out there
003are resources available to help please don't hesit to do so we hold in our thoughts those injured and still in recovery we encourage all who need support to reach out to community members who need or know someone who needs support to reach out resources are so connection with others is more important than ever please continue to look out for and be kind to each other Madison is a resilient strong and compassionate Community we will get through this horrific event to everyone deserves to feel safe when they go to school student and staff safety is a top priority whether it is here in mmsd or at another school all of us care about our students and want them to feel safe enjoy learning and be active members of their school Community thank you board members Dr
004goth before um I'm going to close this and take a moment for silence is there any other um expression that should be shared or stated I just uh would suggest that if anyone needs support that they can go to the United Way uh has a fund if they want to help out at and that will be on the website to be able to provide support for any of the V thank you all right now uh we're going to ask for a moment of silence uh this evening to acknowledge um the community we expect our schools to be safe places for students and staff to learn teach and work on December 16th 2024 Abundant Life Christian School experienced a horrific school crisis many of us felt anger grief anxiety and sadness ALCS is a strong community
005and we continue to send them healing and comforting thoughts during the ongoing recovery process please join me in participating in a moment of silence thank you um we'll now move into our public input um section of the agenda there um were 44 written statements submitted for this meeting 44 of the statements submitted were in support of the charter renewal for Badger rock middle school we have um a couple of people who have registered online to speak and then we'll move to our in-person speakers thank you our first online speaker is Al we hi can you hear me yes okay my name is Al Weir and I am the English language arts content teacher at Badger rock middle school I'd like to address the district's request that we increase enrollment by 20% and proficiency scores by
00610% to receive a full 5-year renewal this request is at best contradictory to ongoing positive feedback we receive during District walkthroughs and at worst either unknowingly or intentionally unachievable we have four core classes at Badger Rock in the morning Ela math social studies and Science in the afternoon students have a weekly specials rotation and project time which is similar to advisory each of our four core classes is led by a Content teacher and a cc teacher or staff member who work together in a co- teing model to support every special education multilanguage and general education Learner in one inclusive environment for all three of their years at Badger rock with floating support from additional bilingual and special education staff our current enrollment just below 100 allows us to divide students into four cohorts of 23
007to 25 already surpassing the district average a request to enroll 20 more students would push each class size to 30 or Force us to restructure our full inclusion co- teing model effectively disrupting our momentum and the predictability and routines of every returning student to Badger Rock looping with our students in our inclusive Cod teaching model allows for high expectations consistent coaching and continual accountability looping with our students in our inclusive co- teing model allows us to prioritize the safety and support necessary to achieve a culture of learning care and Community this model allows us to prioritize relationship building then continue to cultivate student growth by structuring authentic leadership opportunities for them when they return to our spaces as seventh and eighth graders this model allows our students to feel a sense of belonging and ownership
008over their learning spaces they get to experience increased academic and behavioral expectations in a familiar space with familiar faces we see our students and we meet them as Learners as community members as mentees as family every day every year every chance we get and by teaching them all three years we get many so we play the long game we set our sites on helping them develop their sense of self and their confidence as Learners and they grow we teach them to problem solve and identify the tools they need to succeed and they grow we coach them through the natural ups and downs of the learning process and they grow we help them focus on their next step instead of a benchmark and they grow asking us to restructure how our school is designed while improving
009proficiency scores in three years is absurd it's an impossible request making a 5-year contract contingent upon increasing enrollment and proficiency is negligent of the growth our school has achieved and of the contextual realities in which we live that continue to impact our most disenfranchised Learners at higher rates thank you thank you our final online speaker is David amen can you hear me yes good evening board members thank you for this opportunity I have been on the badger Rock governance Council for the last eight years this uh represents my third Charter renewal and I can say with deep conviction that this renewal has been the best of the three the amount of work that went into providing you the documents that you've have been able to review was enormous the workings behind the scenes that gathered
010the information in a thoughtful manner has I believe shown you the ability of this community school to come together as one I am seeking a fiveyear renewal on the basis of this document secondly and importantly I think that there's been a large amount of miscommunication about the enrollment into this organization and we spoke to it at the last Charter renewal 100 is where we want to land that has been our goal and for some reason the original charter had it at 125 based on the growth of the school footprint in the future with an additional amount of space being added to the building itself this did not come to fruition period so that said the enrollment process has been a very interesting I would say problem that keeps rearing its head and I'm not sure
011why that the board keeps coming back to this 125 number we have stated categorically it should be 100 that's where I hope the board understands that we want to land in the charter period for all future renewals as well additionally I would say in closing that the building is now owned by the district and we should have a very good idea of what the cost to run the school is and I think you'll find it to be a very economically run institution as a result and then finally we finally got the kitchen the culinary arts program will start to run and I think the growth of these students as Miss Weir had pointed out is just going to be phenomenal over the coming period of next five years please vote for a fiveyear renewal thank
012you very much all right we have um 15 registered speakers for inperson tonight um first up is Nan Youngerman and then following will be Ernesto Diego Miranda naxi I think it is um as a just as a reminder there's a three minute clock that will start um on the podium there's also a little black box when you see the yellow light it means you've got about 30 seconds left the red light means you kind of come to to the end if you're still um finishing up a thought feel free to take a few extra seconds and finish up um and welcome to the podium thank you well we're asking for five your renewal and I'm going to focus my remarks on two issues enrollment and the drain of resources if the district's recommendations were adopted
013the current contract was negotiated in February of 2020 before the effects of the pandemic were known the contract calls for Badger Rock to achieve student enrollment of 120 by the end of the 24 25 school year and to have maintained 105 to 120 uh enrollment during the prior years of the contract current enrollment as you know is about 92 and the enrollment for previous years has ranged from 85 to our facility only has four physical classs there was there was ongoing discussion for many years about a phase two construction which would have added a fifth plasting but phase two never happen and there are no current plans that it will happen moreover since the current contract took effect Southside Elementary School was approved by referendum and then constructed on the same site as Badger Rock
014and this has altered the badger Rock space and further complicated the ability to add a fif classroom if still desired revising our contract might have been advisable given the pandemic and the destruction on our site of Southside Elementary however we have faced the challenge of working with five principles and I think at least four superintendent and it's led to constantly Changing Faces and some uncertainty many if not most members of the current reuk I don't think are aware of this or have been in our building during school hours or spoken with teachers students or fames we're looking forward to strong leadership and working relationships with the doyle team this was largely absent for whatever reason during the past several years this is a critical missing seat if enrollment were to increase to 120 students without
015adding a fifth classroom the resulting class sign would be among the highest for All District middle schools our very diverse student population coupled with our physical space limitations make an enrollment of 120 students highly problematic if not unworkable grain of resources the renewal process requires a tremendous commitment of time human resources and energy which frankly could be better spent dedicated to student achievement we went to Great length to document our progress and the thought of repeating this is daunting and perhaps unwarranted so please give us some trust we intend to deliver thank you next up is Ernesto Diego Miranda Miranda I think that's nexie or correct me if I'm wrong and then after that will be Sarah carbon caror I'm so sorry if I mispronounce your names we could do you want to go to
016Sarah do you do you feel like you're ready to come up and then maybe Ernesto you could okay technology is our friend and our enemy me ready for you Sarah all right um I'm Sarah Carlson education director for roded and the depan education manager at badrock where I've worked for the past eight years I want to paint you a picture of what makes this place so special I want to walk you through our November Community thanks forgiving meal a free mail for students families and the community where we thank our supporters and celebrate Native American Heritage Month you're greeted by the smell of 21 student made soups chili pole french onion soup homemade Ramen and more a collaboration with their math class where they practiced multiplying and dividing fractions via scaling recipes students in alumni
017in our youth Employee Program run a Farm Stand to sell produce they grew collar greens turnip greens tomatillos you see three types of hot sauce made in their social entrepreneurship class 15% of the profits support a social cause they chose you see tomato sauce they can honey harvested from our bees herbal Sav made with medicinal plants and Beeswax rendered from our hives and cookbooks featuring dozens of recipes made with rooted staff and guests from the community check your bags um Venezuelan empanadas gumbo wild rice Chinese dumplings and more prices are low snaf and EBT are accepted you can sign up for the food pantry you can also give input into what we grow and what programs we offer at the badgero neighborhood center in the cafeteria you enjoy a meal made by Kip Thomas Red's
018culinary arts manager and our youth employees you taste the wild rice casserole made by Kimberly Crowley who has also taught our students the hooch chunk art of black ash basket making you enjoy a pumpkin dish made by our students with rooted Forest smart highlighting native culture rooted staff share the land acknowledgement created in partnership with hunk President John Green beer we thank the many guests representing hunk oji Onida Chaka and patami tribes who have been featured in our virtual Workshop series and work with our students afterwards you join Alton Sunny smart featured in the recent documentary bad River for dancing and drumming and learn about corn braiding from Dan Cornelius of the United Nations you browse the student Yuba beating project made in social studies you see badrock Middle School staff rooted staff students families
019alumni youth employees and other community members building Community across cultures and ages together what you see are examples of Youth gaining the skills and agency to contribute to food Justice work in their own Community what you see are Pathways for developing youth leadership we never have to recruit for Our Youth Employment Program there more interest than we have funding to support what you hear are current and former students saying this place feels like home this is a place where students are seen heard and supported as whole people where students don't slip through the Craigs our vibrant and diverse student population has a range of needs and the level of support they deserve would not be possible if we're asked to increase class sizes and rooted programs that includes appropriate safety and supervision for students working
020with kitchen and construction tools Badger Middle School more than deserves a full five-year Charter remal thank you M so do you want to come up now or do you still need to charge up you think you're okay all right um so my name is Ernesto dieo Miranda Nashi um my time at B started in a rooted gardening and cooking program the summer before sixth grade um through that I was able to feel more connected to the school um personally before I even started attending I graduated from badok in 2022 and um since then I have been working with the rooted um location there um during my time as a student I really enjoyed being in the building and having a connection with the teachers and staff I felt very safe and comfortable with them um
021The Project based learning that is unique to this school really helped me um find a way to prove that I knew what I was learning and um that I understood fully what was being taught the smaller environment also made it possible for teachers to have a personal connection with students instead of having it just be a name on an attendance sheet and um it's possible for me to have a sort of connection with them um if I needed help outside of academic like um personal support um there are a lot of opportunities that um Badger Rock offered to to the students including the gardening and culinary arts class as a student I learned how to grow organic produce how to maintain a garden and how to use the produce to um cook things in a
022kitchen um dur in this class there would also be many opportunities for guest chefs to present recipy from the culture to the class as a youth employee I can use these skills um to actually use what I learn I'm also able to take on leadership positions in these classes now that I can help out in the class and even be a guest Chef myself to share recipes from my own culture um I know firsthand from the badg community neighborhood where I also live that um food insecurity is a major issue and I think it's very important for students um in this area to be able to learn um how they could um use this like use this program to S learn how to be self-sustainable um without having to depend on or without worrying on
023financial responsibilities um I think badrock is a very um important school for the kids and the location is very important for that um I been granted a lot of opportunities through my rooted work as well I've been able to intern with um state representative Franchesca Hong and I've been admitted into the STEM Academy um doing my Junior and senior years at MATC um I want more youth to have the opportunities that I have been granted to succeed um so please Grant vck a full fiveyear Charter thank you thank you our next two speakers will be Shirley ker and Then followed by Mark Johnson hi I'm shley Kaylor I'm the nurse assistant at bedrock and yes my name got Americanized somewhere along the line so it means charcoal maker um I'm wearing a pin I have
024a new piece of jewelry it's a heart saysi support public I love public I got this at a conference or a meeting this weekend at which some spoke which thank you very much because that meant a lot so everyone here has been talking about class size and number of years and things I've been with the school for 10 years so I've seen lot of people transfer out I've seen a lot of one-year Charters and I've seen the stress of the one-year Charters I've also been part of the five years so I'm just going to say up front I am totally in support of five years renewal and that the school is a beautiful school I see it from a perspective now anybody want to get as to what our number one Health office visit is
025it's muscle skeletal because we've got middle schoolers their bodies are growing so fast they don't realize their size and how fast they're growing so they're a little awkward at times number two is anxiety mental health that's a big part and it's also why a lot of the families choose badge or Rock it's because what we offer I have a great support staff here they are really talented they work hard they love what they do I have no problem ever going to any of these people and talking or sharing about a student I might have a concern about and knowing it's going to be dealt with and we're going to come to a positive outcome that is one reason why I stay at Bader Rock I've had opportunities to go to other schools but I stay
026at bad Rock bad rock is very unique I have worked at other schools in summer school and also helping out when there's been staff shortages there's nothing in comparison so one of the things that the kids asked me you want to take a guess what the one important question that students asked me no how many kids do you have well and I tell each and one of those students just about every day I have 90 plus students and they're all my children so thank you and the last thing I'll say is that we had a sixth grader who was very much in uh frequent flyer mode last year last year at the end of the school year I said are you coming back to bad Rock the student said yes I don't know where else
027I would go hi yes thank you I appreciate the opportunity and I want to thank everybody here from Badger Rock my name is Mark Johnson I'm a teaching faculty in the school of education at W Madison and my own courses and research and policy work have been on National and Global Trends in uh climate change and sustainability education my specific connection to Bader Rock was a service learning course taught last spring in which we placed six or seven students as and as part of Community Based learning and I have to say my understanding of the school it was you know kind of a model of how to do this kind of Environmental Education and project-based learning and the actual experience of the school was a revelation I mean it's an extraordinary place and the combination
028of the dedicated staff the exceptionally Innova teaching model of the co- teing and the integration of the courses um The Project based learning the site itself the use of the building as a living laboratory and also the incredible dedication and talent of rooted and the rooted staff I mean it really is an extraordinary place and I think it entirely deserves to be nurtured and supported I think the argument about the lack of a fifth classroom does call into question the enrollment of projections I think it's working exceptionally well even with a you know very diverse and and interesting student body and I would uh strongly encourage an additional five years I also think there are additional opportunities as part of the city of Madison's Area Redevelopment plans it is a very high priority for the
029city to develop Urban Agriculture and I do think that this can be Badger Rock and the badger Rock Neighborhood Center can be a model for that entire part of the city um if nurtured and supported it could be a model for the district and it could be acknowledged and deserves to be acknowledge Statewide and Nationwide I think there are also additional opportunities for Partnerships and coer operation with the university not just in the school of education But as Sarah mentioned in the office of tribal relations the school of human ecology the College of Agriculture and Life Sciences the horiculture program there are many many units at wuw that would put it would have a lot to learn from cooperation with Badger Rock um I also think there are new opportunities for cooperation with the state
030DPI and the Wisconsin climate education Hub and my impression of the school is that it is really emerging as one of the most extraordinary institutions like this in the state of Wisconsin and potentially in the region I would strongly urge a fiveyear renewal thank thank you uh next up is Lexi Ray and Then followed by Bria Adams or Brea good evening board members my name is Lexi Ray this is my 11th year at Badger Rock and we are in a better place now than we've ever been I'm the instructional coach AVID coordinator and bilingual resource teacher I beyond proud to stand with my colleagues current and former students and families and other community members and partners to present our story and advocate for a full 5-year renewal again this time it is exciting to see
031what we' accompl through all of the personal and Global roller coasters and where we are headed in the next 5 years as you likely know growth must be accomplished first and foremost in the attempt to reach proficiency we don't talk about growth enough and we don't even have a good way to measure growth of success skills in our educational system so we tell stories we engage and we collaborate to better understand ourselves in each other and build a future where every person can Thrive you listen to the stories you will hear growth and setbacks what you might not hear is where it all started how most of our students don't come to us already knowing that they can do math that they can read and engage with a story and that their story is entwined
032with whether or not they think they can and celebrating that growth when they finally believe that they can do hard things and that they are not to be boiled down to a number an intangible goal that will tell them whether or not they will be worth the time and effort putting a proficiency requirement on our Charter renewal does not make sense in our middle schoolers words the math isn't mapping today Miss Ray do you understand what it means for students to grow at an accelerated rate and how sustainable that is or isn't for middle schoolers do you understand that for an average Badger Rock student arriving in sixth grade to go from the average third grade level to eighth grade in three years can seem insurmountable do you understand the pressure that puts on Educators
033families and students to focus on just one number instead of the whole student students can't read if they don't think they can read they can't do math if they've been told they're no good at it they spend their time repeatedly second guessing themselves instead of focusing on the task at hand they need skills bigger than reading or math alone and that takes time to sustain what they would need more than 1.5 years growth every year for three of the hardest most tumultuous years very few can maintain this level of elevated rigor in fact only about 20% of students Nationwide can do it during their middle school years and these students aren't likely to be in the three groups of focused students in our district which make up by the way 75% of our current population
034at Badger rock middle school math is not mathing do we want it to absolutely an everyday staff show up to accelerate that growth for the whole student to put a limited proficiency stipulation on a group of exceptional students is not an avid smart goal at all because it's not the ultimate goal let me put my bilingual resource head on for just a moment and ask did you know that 100% of badgero Scholars last year who took the access for ell's test showed language growth 100% that is a direct result of a team of Educators working together to provide pbl learning opportunities with Avid structures and support built in for every student in the building the question was asked at the work group meeting in November about why we need a charter the answer is simple
035for me a unique instructional model demands it pbl and Avid allow us to go beyond instruction to meet the whole student where they are at know them as individuals and Coach them in growth towards future goals renew us for five full Years thank you hi everyone I'm Bri Adams I'm the school counselor at badar Rock I'm speaking tonight on behalf of our school student support team to very strongly recommend badar Rock for a full fiveyear renewal we wanted to talk more about uh how all staff embed social emotional learning into every project every lesson every interaction or how our student support staff delivers weekly Universal Wellness education but instead we feel compelled to address the school district's recommendations five years ago when I started at Badger Rock during lockdown and a global pandemic my colleagues
036were coming off the charter renewal process this time around it felt like we could finally relax a little and approach this process with some more hope why wouldn't we we're receiving District accolades and praise we've got so many folks who see how special this school is we became Avid certified we have staff presenting to District colleagues and we've got a thriving Lively ecosystem with students who are growing exponentially in ways we both can and cannot measure last year alone out of 28 eth graders we had four students receive full rides to W Madison A Sanchez scholar a man scholar and almost half of our students apply to and get accepted into the AVID program so when the district gave a recommendation of only three years for Renewal with those stipulations they would directly threaten this
037thriving thoughtfully balanced ecosystem we as a staff were floored to be clear the district's recommendations would directly threaten this ecosystem would render much of what you're hearing tonight and will hear tonight imposs possible our team our student support team's role in supporting this ecosystem has been carefully and intentionally carved out over the past several years to the point where we're delivering Universal weekly classroom instruction on wellness and providing preventative social emotional skill building so when students leave Badger Rock they can take on the world if you follow the district's recommendations as a student support team we will not be able to deliver tier one in instruction we would instead be filling the cracks and supporting the strain these recommendations would place on our system particularly the addition of 20 students to the building with our
038current model Wellness education has become a huge outlet for student voice and Leadership and a chance for us to deliver weekly lessons responsive to our students needs um and their interests in our preassessment this year half of our entire student body indicated interest in joining a student wellness committee 42 students so we have students running our weekly trivia trying to improv schoolwide wellness and giving input into our Wellness curriculum this ecosystem thrives because students are seen they can't hide physically because we don't have hallways and the student support staff is always present in the quad and emotionally because the adults here notice when things seem off when there's a slight shift in Behavior or attitude when students finally reach that Milestone that may seem small on the surface but shows that something finally clicked students
039are seen because of our co-taught fulling conclusion Project based model if you've been to Badger rock you know and if you haven't been there you should staff and students feel safe and supported and valued and heard do not force us to change this model trust the voices you hear tonight and renew us for the full five years thank you thank you next up is saffron uh zahor Schultz and Kate mezri I think and then following will be Joseph roses good evening everyone thank you to the badger Rock proponents but we would like to shift Focus to something very important to us as high schoolers we are representatives of West high schools March for our lives Club throughout this school year we have been advocating for proactive measures to mitigate the threat of gun viol vience
040in our school communities as a club we are organizing a campaign for safe storage a powerful mechanism to promote Community safety by inhibiting youth firearm access safe storage describes barriers to youth gun access through lock boxes gun locks gun safes and other strategy in over 75% of school shootings the perpetrator obtained a firearm stored unsafely in their home research demonstrates significant correlations between safe storage interventions and reduced gun violence we have been communicating with West School administration to advance safe storage awareness schoolwide and are seeking further support from the school board to promote a districtwide course of action safe storage efforts have become even more pertinent in the wake of the tragic shooting at Abundant Life earlier this week he recognized the devastating impact of this tragedy on our community and it's important that we
041prioritize time for reflection and healing however we must not lose the political momentum residing in the aftermath of Monday's attack we would like to turn your attention to actions through which we can engage in public Outreach and policy reform to keep our school system safe we would like to work with the district to share information with families regarding Community Based violence prevention including educational materials and Firearm storage methods because Wisconsin currently lacks comprehensive legislation requiring secure gun storage we ask for your assistance in drafting an mmsd resolution for Distributing safe storage information to schools and fam it is critical that students feel like they belong in the classroom and the threat of firearm misuse is an immense barrier to our security we would however like to credit the district ongoing efforts to protect our schools
042we would like to recognize numerous instances during the school year where positive relationships between mmsd Administration staff and students prompted proactive responses to potential threats student and staff safety is clearly a prominent District objective and we are ready to work with you in furthering this goal thank you for your time and consideration school board members and bck Community tonight I want to take a moment to express my heartb gratitude to all the amazing individuals who make Bader Rock School so special and to those who have worked tirelessly on the charter renewal application all 75 Pages the hundreds of hours that have gone into the charter application process do not go unnoticed to our students Thank You for Your Enthusiasm curiosity and resilience you are the heart of badra and your eagerness to learn and grow
043brings energy to our school your unique talents and perspectives enrich our community and we are grateful for your joy and creativity you bring to our school every day a special thank you to our Alum who spoke tonight to the badger Rock staff thank you thank you for your unwavering commitment to our students your passion for teaching and your willingness to go above and beyond truly make a difference in the lives of our students families and Community not only do you provide a rigorous and Innovative learning experience through Aven and Project based learning but you also prioritize the social emotional well-being of all students their compassion and understanding cultivate a school environment where all students feel welcome safe and included you honor and celebrate students history culture and identity you ire our students to reach their
044full potential and prepare them to be College Community and career ready completing the charter renewal process has highlighted your resilience and commitment and love for the badrock for badrock Middle School to the Friends of badrock also known as badok middle school council you chose to give your most precious resource your time to enrich our community thank you for your passion and energy your selfless contributions exemplify the mission and vision of badger rock your support enhances our programming and helps us create a nurturing and caring environment and let's be real we would not be able to to submit our one of the most robust Charter application the state has seen without you and that's a side note from Sarah hacket who is uh director of Wisconsin Resource Center to rooted partnership we are incredibly grateful for
045your continued partnership and your expertise in urban agriculture Food Systems and food Justice your contributions not only enrich our curriculum but also Empower our students to understand the importance of sustainable practices and Equitable access to food together we are cultivating a brigh future for our community to the school board a special thank you for your dedication and hard work in reviewing our application I know was a lot but your mean in your meaningful conversations on November 4th work group that was I appreciate that that was a thoughtful conversation I appreciate it your commitment to bad rock over the years has shown the importance of thoughtful decision- making we appreciate your willingness to listen and encourage you to do what's right to support a full five-year Charter renewal and I'll end we are all Bader Rock
046one Community one school one family thank you next we'll have Carlos I think it's Jos Rodriguez and Then followed by Jamie Olson aim good evening thank you for letting me speak tonight my name is Carlos Rodriguez and I'm a freshman at laal high school I'm here to talk about badrock middle school and why you should renew its Charter to five years I attended badrock for all three years of middle school and it was a wonderful experience everyone there is thoughtful and has great connections with each other this school has caused wonderful things to happen in my life those the community of rooted and many more badrock also teaches you helpful skills that you wouldn't find in your average Middle School from planting and harvesting to cooking and serving it to the community every teacher and
047every scholar I've seen has done great things to themselves and those around them I've seen friends become great people attending at the school badok also gives you Avid skills which can be a huge advantage in high school if you get into the AVID program or not I personally use these skills given to me by aerok every day to be a better academic scholar in conclusion bck middle school should renew its Charter for 5 years because it's an anchor to the community and those around it thank you have a good night feel like mine's G to be kind of a downer um I uh was working for hours on what to say and I just decided to stand in front of you like myself um sincerely without a speech um I'm gonna read what I wrote
048but it's you know it's not like a raw kind of thing um I'm tired and I'm sad and I don't know what to say there's too much to say um I've been at Badger rock this is my 12th school year so over 11 years it seems like no matter what we do we are on trial for some reason or another it seems like we're always accused of either not doing enough or not doing well enough no matter what we do how we perform it's just it feels never good enough and at the point where I don't know what would make the district happy um and that's exhausting and disheartening but I'll tell you this kids come back to badger after they graduate and they thank us they tell us how much they miss learning math
049the way it's structured at Badger Rock The Kids Teach themselves before we learn together as a class in math at bck kids who come back Express disbelief at how quickly their new classmates give up when they're confused about a math topic or how these students who went to the um other middle schools don't know how to help themselves and need a teach teacher right there with them to explain things to them they talk about how helpful their middle school math notebooks still are during the freshman year of high school Carlos is one of those people who came back and said oh my gosh I use this all the time my friends try to use it with me my my friends are asking me for help they want to give up um and we've had multiple
050multiple students back and telling us this um I've watched children go from saying I can't do math to in in saying this resource isn't working for me from saying I'm bad at math to instead saying I'm not in a good place for learning today I'm going to try again tomorrow and they do I see students actively work through their math trauma but it takes time and trust and relationships and more time why is a test score more important than a child's confidence and self-efficacy confidence and efficacy that it takes three years and more to build why is a test score for a math test given on a computer with no room for small calculation errors based solely on memory given one or two days in a school year more important than a child's ability to
051use available resources to Grapple with a challenging problem and come out the other side we say we want to build strong Learners and engaged learner Learners and then we pigeon holder learning based on a measurement that most of us see as flaw in so many ways anyway two years ago a sixth grader now an absolutely incredible eighth grader who I will not name because I did not ask him if I could quote him said to a classmate why are you using a pen you know we're going to make mistakes in this journey and he really like literally said that uh and he's right and that's how they learn so please let them continue learning from their mistakes if you pressure the teachers to cram information down their throats you're actually just pressuring the children and
052that's not how we build resilient lifelong Learners who believe that they can tackle any challenge please allow these beautiful children to have the full undivided attention of their teachers Anders for the next five years thanks for letting me know all right that concludes all of the um folks who registered to speak in person we also have um several who did not wish to speak um Jessica Ortiz uh written statement of being in supportive five-year Charter renewal Kristen rich richels or Rich gels um also in support of five-year renewal Jessica Simmons um in support of fiveyear renewal uh Maya kadakia or kadakia SAR sorry um 5year renewal Unice mckin Charter renewal in support of that and Quinton um Riser also in support of the charter renewal for Badger rock with um a longer letter to the
053board that concludes uh between our speakers online our inperson speakers and those who um sent in written statements that can includes our public input thank you so much all right I'm going to move into the next part of our agenda which is approval of the minutes I move that the Board of Education approve the minutes from the regular meeting dated November 25th 2024 second Nikki Vander all right any questions comments edits to the minutes all right hearing and seeing none Claire your advisory vote and welcome join welcome for joining with us tonight thank you your advisory vote I all those in favor I I all right none opposed passes unanimously all right for board president announcements and reports uh vice president Pearson and I will share these and I'll start with celebrating our students East
054High School school's theater team the easts side players took home several awards at the 2024 Wisconsin inter Scholastic speech and dramatic arts festival more than 1,800 student competitors from high schools across the state participated in this year's competition which took place at the University of Wisconsin Milwaukee in total there were 43 onea performances spread across the festivals 3 days the Eastside players production of playwright Tim Kelly's one-act play country Gothic received the festival's top prize the Critics Choice Award the group also received awards for outstanding Ensemble outstanding technical theater and outstanding directing students Anna mallum Moore and Marcus MCB received outstanding actor recognition congratulations to the Pergo celebrating our community the Board of Education would like to wish the entire a very fun and restful winter break um as a district we've celebrated many accomplishments
055in the first half of the school year and we look forward to all right and to wrap it up um also in tonight's con agenda the board would like to acknowledge and thank all individuals and organizations that have donated to our district one large Grant um on tonight's agenda includes a $50,000 Grant from the advancing a healthier Wisconsin endowment through the Medical College of Wisconsin to support teen parents in mmsd schools so many thanks to our donors and with that I'll pass it over to our superintendent Dr goth thank you president Nichols members of the board staff and Community I appreciate this opportunity so a few things I'll wait for Jesse to get the slides up so that cover picture there is uh pajama day at olon elementary school was able to to read to
056some second graders if you are first graders and I'm giving you next year I apologize but uh we had a great time and always appreciate interacting with especially our youngest children their questions are um always surprising but a lot of fun uh so thank you Olsen Elementary for that opportunity and I should also mention that one of my former Toki students is a student teacher there was in Sea for a long time and is now finishing her teaching degree and to see young people from the community uh stay committed and stay the course and find ways to advance through their District brings a lot of Pride to me and I just wanted to mention that to so Miss Randall over there at Olsson keep up the great work I'm proud of you next slide so
057some community community engagement celebrated all the way back in November which seems like forever ago u m New Year at um at the Alli Energy Center and I have to tell you after celebrating many M New Years in a in a different Community uh one that uh boasts the largest M New Year celebration in the country it was quite amazing to come back to Madison and to see the mon community thriving in ways uh that when I left 11 years ago um wasn't as much uh just to see the pride the celebration the community leaders uh the young people that are now you know the the leaders in the Next Generation it was really an amazing event I can't wait for uh for next years as well also in November volunteered with the downtown rotary
058at the river food pantry and again went into that uh thinking one thing of what I was going to be doing at that food pantry and let me tell you all before the fall break I chopped celery for two straight hours and uh we were preparing homecooked meals and prepping for that and it made me feel so good the next couple days when I saw on the news the line of people who are accessing uh that homecooked meal um and ingredients to to do their own cooking uh really a wonderful feeling food is love and uh definitely a lot of love in uh at River food pantry um over the the fall break and in the holiday the uh annual Centro espano annual celebration was also held at the Centro Hispano building uh wonderful to
059be on site or present for Community awards that were given U many of them to some of our own uh people right here in mmsd the Sanchez Awards uh were were definitely highlighted also Carmen bco longtime Community leader as well uh was given an award and I should also mention that our students were there uh performing music mus as well from lealan East High School and honestly I thought it was coming through the PA like something on Spotify or something and to look over and to see it live and to and to also learn that it was our students was was quite amazing also had some time to stop by a packed and busy Simpson Street prepress Newsroom uh filled with mmsd students and alums as many of you know our alumni come back and
060stay engaged and become kind of the editorial uh leaders of of the organization Jim Kramer has been a long time friend and um just really appreciate the work they're doing at the at the Free Press I had the chance to connect with the entire MCR staff mscr anyone who has heard me talk about my story is such an important part of of of my youth um that I always enjoy spending time with MCR and sharing those connections to their uh important work uh Mary Roth and her team are doing such a great job and looking for ways to continue um evolving with our community as well you know our new spaces that board members I'm so happy that you have supported it opens up opportunities for us to truly serve our community birth to forever
061as I like to refer to it as uh there truly is something there for all of our residents in Madison um and our students as well um also had some wonderful structured visits to Lake View Leopold and Kennedy um and learning a lot about you know it's one thing to go to a school and visit but to to center it around some emerging uh perhaps problems of practice or challenges that the schools are are are facing and trying to focus on those sometimes few sometimes more than a few U problems say given me a new lens on mmsd and when you multiply that at the three schools I mentioned by you know obviously more than that with 52 schools um you can see that we have our work ahead of us and if we don't
062Center it on what those present needs are um I I think it's U It's a Wonderful opportunity for us to truly um engage in that way so we can get into some active not problem solving but support uh to overcome um so excited about uh continuing these visits throughout the district and and learning more along the way and also have many more opportunities for engagement uh scheduled Dr McCrae has my calendar um just about filled I think after break Dr McCrae uh so I I know that we'll be busy engaging with people next slide please Jesse um I'd like to share some mmsd Partnerships now I I'll preface this by saying that a wonderful leader in our community is retiring his name is Dr Jack Daniels and he took over Madison College after I left
063Madison and I and I got to learn about him through yoja or um Hugh and U and online and to see the great work that was happening the Synergy between the community and Madison College and certainly M MSD part of community and uh always said to myself man I wish I could have you know worked with him he really seems to be poised to take these Partnerships to The Next Step well I get to be here now and share this with you and I'm excited about these Partnerships we'll offer three new early college acmis for high school seniors beginning in the 25 26 school year and it's such a great great news because as you know we boasted about 61% of our district seniors graduating with at least one college credit um our goal should
064be 100% And that's for those who choose it doesn't mean that everyone has to uh but let's expand and grow the opportunities for all of our students courses will be offered at Madison College and up to 25 students will be admitted to each new program which includes the Early College biomedical Academy The Early College networking and cyber security Academy and the running start which is the personalized Academy and I'll share just some details about them so you know what I'm talking about for students interested in medical medical lab careers the biomed Academy offers Hands-On learning in the bioh health Fields helping prepare students for high wage in demand Health PR Healthcare careers the networking and cyber security Academy prepares students interested in technology networking and cyber security for careers and it and cyber security did
065you know as a caveat that there are three places in the country right now that are producing the most tech jobs two of them are probably no surprise Seattle and the Bay Area the third is Madison Wisconsin right here so these are high demand careers that might be entry level but they lead to very very um Advanced Career standing and opportunities for students to grow so I'm excited about the exposure we're going to be able to provide with Madison College to these careers the other one is the running start personalized Academy allows students to create their own program of study providing flexibility and the opportunity to explore various career paths they'll work with Madison College advisers to tailor a course schedule that leads to to a technical diploma in a high demand field again providing
066students autonomy choice and agency um this is just wonderful I never would have imagined a personalized Academy like that and to think that we're doing it is is just outstanding we'll continue to offer the Early College Academy early college education Academy of which offers a pathway into teaching students can earn 30 college credits toward a liberal arts transfer education associate degree and it will help take their first step toward towards a degree in education and of course the Early College STEM Academy which is another option available to students it's designed for students who want to explore science technology engineering and Mathematics with a focus on increasing access for underrepresented students and stem Fields this program offers a chance to earn college credits while building a strong foundation for stem careers and again you can find
067more information than this on our mmsd website um this should be something that we're really proud of that your proud of as a board that we're proud of as a community and shows when we come together and we just forget about all the barrias and the reasons why not who can really Center this great work finally Jesse our final slide is our literacy initiative Mt for reading which will launch on National reading day at sside elementary on January 23rd 2025 we'll be sharing more information about the details of this but would like the entire Community uh to be aware of and also um attend and partic ipate if you can we know that literacy is the key to opening doors unlocking the world around us Matt for reading provides an opportunity for us to engage
068entire community on a powerful journey of learning imagine Imaging and growth we're excited to begin the program president Nichols members of the board this concludes my report thank you so much Dr Dr gother um I just want to say I really appreciate hear how much you you are committed to being out in the community not just it does it never sounds like you're just out in the community to like show up you like you are deeply immersed involved like in the celebrations in the volunteer work in the um just really being present and um then also just acknowledging how much our school district needs and is stronger because of the very ious Community Partners in this community that um have a lot of time Talent energy resources to our district so thank you for being
069present with them and um loved hearing about your school visits and um and the excitement we should all have around our early college academies so appreciate your update as always all right we will keep moving um next up is a report on items that proceeded through the instruction work group held on December 9th 2024 and I'll hand that over to chair mro thank you board president Nicholls this past month we focused on culture climate and attendance we had an incredible conversation where we highlighted our entire K through 12 system and heard from three schools a school at the elementary middle school and high school level going into January we will start the year off by getting ready to plan for summer school it's already that time y'all um and and that means we get to
070review all of the excellent opportunities that enhanced our summer school experience in the year 2024 and think through what we want to do in 2025 and this will be um an extensive conversation um in which we get to navigate kind of the moving parts of summer school holistically the second thing we will do in January is focus on the progress made by the superintendent Wellness advisor advisory committee um we'll be hearing a a brief progress update from them thank you chair Nichols thank you for that next we're going to report on items that proceeded through the operations work group um although we did not have a meeting in December I'm going to pass it over to chair Castro to talk about what's coming up thank you we did not hold a operations work group meeting
071in December our next meeting will be January 13th where we will uh look at initial uh Revenue uh projections for our budget talk about our strategy for addressing this year's budget cycle uh we will hear from HR regarding Recruitment and Retention to date this year and the progress we're making um and then finally we will have a facilities update uh and look at two two policies that that will come our way on January 13 it's gon to be a busy meeting all right we did have an item that um proceeded through the instruction work Group which is the Badger Rock Charter renewal um so want to thank again all of the folks that came out to speak tonight and who have also been sending in emails um and also submitted written statements all right we'll
072start with a motion and then um see if we have any discussion I move that the Board of Education renew the charter for Badger rock middle school for a period of three years from July 1 2025 to June 30th 2028 with an automatic two-year extension contingent on Badger rock middle school meeting specific enrollment requirements and academic performance goals as exed wle stated in the badger Rock feedback and recommendations board memo dated December 10th 2024 second Maya all right what discussion do we have all right I see board member simin and then board member malra thank you um there's a lot of special places in mmsd and I believe that brck is one of those places um I've been really impressed with badgero um with their curricul model Project based learning um with their rotating curricular
073focus on air earth and water um with their many deeply meaningful Partnerships and with their accomplishments and not only that but when I visited it felt good um and not just good it was incredibly welcoming and supportive um I met Educators and administrators who are clearly self motivated to innovate to reflect and to adjust their practices in a cycle of thoughtful change I think that as a board we should embrace the unique aspects of Bader Rock's mind I don't want to put stipulations on their next Charter I think that the board the that their program could be expanded but I wouldn't want to diminish their Community by requiring more students without having the ability for them to add another classroom I think that there if there is an ability to expand their space that we
074should support that because their program should be expanded if it could be um I also believe there's many opportunities for learning um for other schools in mmsd based on what badgero is accomplishing now and So based on that I would like to propose an amendment to our action is now the time to do that okay um I'll do it and then you guys do what you want with it um I move that the Board of Education renew the charter for Badger rock middle school for a period of five years from July 1st 20 25 to June 30th 2030 get nck all right we'll take discussion on the amendment all bar member m I greatly appreciate the amendment I was here five years ago when Badger Rock came in front of us and there there's only
075three of the seven of us who were part of the board at that time and I I think what I remember is really wanting Badger Rock to be successful if you go back to February of 2020 none of us knew what was about to hit us right and so I I greatly appreciate folks understanding that those goals were not set with the intention of setting Folks up to fail they were set with an understanding that there are a lot of kids who would greatly benefit from the opportunity of attending Badger Rock we have a lot of middle schoolers who are really struggling and so our Hope was that we would expand and extend the opportunity to more students I still think um that we we want to see Badger Rock grow as a school and
076I do think that there's some real complexity in using the badger Rock model throughout the rest of our district when the vast majority of our dist our our middle schools are serving hundreds of children every single day and so if we say why can't you be more like Badger Rock it feels pretty unobtainable um to embrace the structure you all have um at the scale that most of our middle schools are expected to operate and so I'm really torn right now um about what it means to ensure that more students have this opportunity um that kids are coming off the wait list and and getting into the school and and getting to be part of this vibrant and beautiful community that you all have created and balancing that with what makes the community successful in
077the first place I I I want to talk a little bit about the academic goal that we have um because I I I wholeheartedly agree right like that the test score is not um what defines the capacity of our children intellectually and I think that in looking to next year the group of kids who are going to enter sixth grade our children who miss their kindgarten year and their first grade year so these are our kids that we have watched really struggle with foundational skills in terms of literacy and math um and I have some concerns about what it means to have this really intense expectation specific to that group the other thing I thought about a lot is the message that we send the community in this renewal process so folks are out there
078thinking this might be the right school for me I think that you're thinking about enrolling your kid next year or the year after that you want some assurance that the school is going to be there um when they finish right that my kid is gonna if I get my kid into this school that they're going to get to go in sixth seventh and eighth grade um and so I think balancing that kind of anxiety with what this renewal process looks like is tremendously important I I want to hope that there is a middle ground that we can find a way to have shared goals in terms of the expectations related to enrollment and so is there a middle ground that is getting to 100 or getting to 110 students over the course of the next
079five years um I think that the pandemic created a very specific barrier and my hope is that we don't see uh a barrier like that again but none of us know the future holds and I think it's our our job to rise to the occasion of any given moment and and work together as a community so I I support board member Simpkins Amendment um but I do want to think about what it means to have real expectations of our instrumentalities and one of the defining characteristics of our instrumentalities one of the things that I think makes our instrumentalities exceptionally different in comparison to our 2x Charters is that our instrument mentalities are expected to explain to the community the progress that they're making um and so I think having this conversation having standards and expectations
080and ensuring that they are achievable and realistic um is part of our work in terms of of what the board of education is responsible for in collaboration with you all as an instumental um I I've compared Badger Rock to in the past in terms of kind of the the size and scale although the difference would be that jabaz is a very small school um that serves an additional grade it's four years versus three years and so where where is the pressure to to grow um throughout our system in terms of enrollment especially when uh a school has a unique capacity to serve students differently um I think that's it for for my comments but I want folks to know where thinking about this really intentionally and I'm hoping that within the amendment we can continue
081to hold ourselves to both high expectations and achievable expectations thank you for member m I'll come over to board member Mosner Pam and then follow up with board member nothing like going after board member moo um I also support board members and Kim um motion um for a couple of reasons one is sort of just like in my experience working in secondary schools and I say this to a lot of people it takes three years to make a change or build something and five years to get it right and so for that reason the changes that we want to see at back or Rock um to to imagine like a I think that um PR years is too too little for those changes um [Music] uh the other thing that I wanted to say is
082that uh we just pass this like amazing facilities reference with our eyes on the middle school knowing that we have to make changes to our middle school program um Citywide um and what I what I hope is that we can learn from what Badger is doing um when we're thinking about all of our mle schools and I don't I don't want to be in a um I I want to I'm trying to say that I want to learn from Badger Rock and I support the fiveyear renewal this kind of the basic there member Pon Badger Bader Rock originally as I said at the last meeting I originally had a negative experience that turned into a positive experience and I think that means we need to continue to allow it instrumentality Charter to be just that
083a unique learning experience that doesn't mean they don't have to follow rules or follows things the district it means they do it a different way I've always had a problem with basing anything on test scores in fact I wouldn't be here if the majority thinks were a based on test schools because of high marks what area and considered cognitively disabled other so I would be a hypocrite not to uh I'd be hypocrite to believe that we should base it on the test on the size of school I think that's something we can negotiate but I've seen no reason why there should not be an extension for five years and therefore I'm happy to support this amendment vice president person yeah so I just need clarification about the Amendments um are you saying the five years
084so essentially changing the original motion um from the three years to five years with the same stipulations as set forth in the memo are you just saying scrap the mimo we're just going to give an extension for five years I'm I'm saying without adding those stipulations and I I think part of it is because we when it comes to to their ability to at a classroom that's not fully within their ability at this time to do that um I don't want them to overfill their classes and then have that start to break down their model um and what I think I share what some other folks have talked about as far as test scores it makes me uncomfortable to put that in as a requirement got it thank you thank you for that clarification I
085have a question for um Joe and maybe TJ um or other instruction folks um the set of um recommendations as it relates to instruction um outside of enrollment but instruction not necessarily the ones about the test scores per se um but some of the recommendations um um are these recommendations that I guess we can say are in line with the with our other middle schools um and so kind of asking that question around what um Ali mentioned just about having high expectations um for all of our middle schools but also for RO at the same time as achievable ones so to answer your question yes the um recommendations that we based are based upon our district Improvement plan that all schools are using for the next year so what we have put before you will
086be the same thing that all middle schools will be looking at okay thank you um I have been a part of the badger Rock uh community in many ways as like long before um I was a board member um being a part as a small business owner going to the holiday um or every Saturday like selling wees and having like the markets um I've had my garden there for multiple years I've participated in the community dinners and have definitely built really long lasting relationships with some of the staff there um and so I have to I'm balance I balance that hat right um as well as ensuring that as a school board member hat that we are doing the best to set up our kids our schools um in this case badger badger up for
087Success um I support the the fiveyear renewal but I don't know if I can support it without having some expectations and the reason why I say that is one because in 2020 when running for school board I again this was a really actually really Hot Topic at that time too um with a with a previous principal um and I remember the conversations around enrollment um and enrollment was very important in trying to ensure and yes with the there was a plan of having that second phase and I remember those conversations I don't know if 120 um just because of the constraints of the building um would be setting the school up for success but I do think enrollment and increase in having opportunities for other students to possibly be a part of this amazing community
088that was has been created I think is important um so I don't know if I can support the amendment as is um without some kind of expectation um whether that is an enrollment and a compromise I do like the compromise that were was proposed um I'm not really for the the stipulations around testing because what other board members have mentioned but I do think that um having similar expectations to our other middle schools ensures the some continuity as well um and so as is I can support it um but I don't know what the right um expectation is on the floor um and changing some of those so um I just wanted just to stay that and give my my response um before I to or member Castro and have my own comments I just
089want to clarify even when we vote on the the renewal of the charter there's still a contract right that comes after the vote of the renewal and so some of those details can be worked out in the actual contract is that's correct right okay we we had a similar when we renew Mo Mundo there were certain things that we wanted to do to renew and then some details were going to be kind of worked out in the contract and that the board would then be notified of when the contract was going forward yeah okay thank you for member Castro thank you yeah I think by this point in Badger Rock's assistence through you know the painstaking effort of Staff teachers students partners community members uh Badger Rock has become a foundational Rock no intended to
090the community and unique experiences um however Badger rock is an instrumentality um and so the purpose of instrumentalities is to provide a unique instructional experience that is in part different from our community schools neighborhood schools uh s in the district so I think it's important that like all schools within MMD folks are expected to meet a standard have goals have stipulations for continuous Improvement um so to me it's important that those are stipulated somewhere I don't want it to question whether Badger Rock will be existed existing or not so I would support a fiveyear how those goals are stipulated in our contractual relationship as an instrument instrumentality to me is the question um I would like to see um this opportunity this unique instructional opportunity open to more students in the district how um this
091is a space uh or at least adjacent space next door that just receive very new Renovations of brand new space so I think there's a lot of room to use our imaginations here um so and then when it comes to the academic testing goals I think those can't be the only things we focus on but it is something that we should look at um it shouldn't be the Cornerstone of assessing student achievement uh but it should be a piece so um I'd be interested in learning more about how we can stipulate some of those continuous Improvement goals but um I don't want to be questioned whether this school exists or not thank you um I I will add myself in um first of all I want to just I want to acknowledge all of the
092incredible and obvious hard work that was put into this Charter renewal proposal 275 pages is no joke I want to acknowledge um the rallying from parents I know the board oftentimes um we people don't like it when we don't respond to emails and I'll own that I don't always respond every email but I see the emails and I noted all of the emails that came in from parents of current students parents of former students students who were former students all of the community letters um of support that came in and I also want to acknowledge our mmsd team's um application review committee right because all of this is time and energy um to be in good service of young people getting a great learning opportunity um there's two things I think that stand out for
093me in our um in our administration's recommendation and the two things that stand out to me is that one of them um is making a real emphasis on kind of the minimum enrollment I I saw in the charter renewal application kind of a a strong desire to want to redefine that minimum um instead of what had been agreed upon in a previous contract and I've heard I've heard the public comment tonight about why um adding an additional 20 25 more students given the space and the learn the instructional model would prove challenging um but it seems like the minimum enrollment was one criteria that seemed you know kind of uh as a driver so to speak for the three-year um focus and then also some of the achievement um but when I look at kind
094of the academic performance goals they are they are the same as her school Improvement goals it's these are the same percentages that we um we almost start every instructional work group with when we talk about school and District Improvement so I think where I'm at is I also am in support of the fiveyear because I feel like what our district we may be at a point where we need to go back and re-evaluate our Charter renewal process um I think that we might want to get clear as a district on when we say that there should be a minimum enrollment like what what are the ways in which we help a school or that we guide a school on that um as it continues to operate and is that is enrollment alone kind of like
095the thing or um and how does the enrollment fit with the square footage of a building and the quality of the programming and of course we we have to be committed to student achievement um and I do think when we are saying yes to an instrumentality Charter we are also saying yes to a unique learning experience it doesn't mean that achievement isn't important but we might also hold some other ways in which we see achievement for a young person so I think because we haven't reestablished a new way of considering our our own Charter School renewal process I I think that um you know we I I would be in support of going forward with the fiveyear and then maybe I'm looking at you Dr goth like maybe that's some of the work that we
096start to look forward to like if we're going to continue to renew Andor authorize any instrumentality Charter of the district how do we get clearer about what what are really the drivers for a school maintaining their Charter or not it it for me it doesn't seem like the the timing is right for us to maybe reestablish that right now yes Dr goth president Nichols members of the board if I may respond to that I think this conversation you know the the way that you just framed that is making me think less about instrumentality and more about how do you as a board how do we as a community want to support Innovative schools to me it you know instrumentality right now is seen as a contract it's seen as a renewal it's seen as a
097process and I think if we want to begin looking at our schools our spaces our opportunities as a chance for Innovative learning it could potentially be a different discussion that may very well duvail with I think where we're this conver or where we're leading this conversation right now so I appreciate that and um I think our staff would would agree as well all right um so I want to make sure I restate the motion as you said it Laura your motion was to renew the contract for five years from July 1st 2025 to June 30th 2030 did I capture that correctly okay um is there any further discussion all right um all those in favor I okay those opposed uh all right two all right so that passes and then oh and Claire I'm sorry
098I didn't ask for your advisory vote on that one I okay thank you and now I need to go back to the main motion that we started with which if I can get my computer up okay um we already had the first the initial motion um read and seconded so um that one again was for three years with the stipulation all right uh all those in favor all right thank you sorry y'all all right let me reread the new motion with the amendment it's nice to have people on the left people on the right okay all right I move that the Board of Education renew the charter for Badger rock middle school for a period of 5 years from July 1 2025 to June 30th 2030 all right CL your advisory vote I thank you
099all those in favor all right looks like that passes unanimously and now I'm going to move on to the consent agenda um I guess I'll just take a moment before I go to the consent agenda to say congratulations to Badger Rock Middle School on your Charter renewal are we taking a we okay keep going does anybody want to Res okay all right I'm going to move on to the consent agenda I move that the Board of Education adopt and approve all of the Motions set forth in section 10 of the electronic agenda prepared for the December 19th or 19th 2024 regular school board meeting exactly as said motions are written by voting affirmatively on this motion a board member expresses his her or their affirmative vote on each of the Motions Consolidated hereby subject to
100any Express separations that have been made by any member of the school board thank you board member Castro any separations all right hearing and seeing none Claire your advisory vote I all right all those in favor I all right that will be six Z passes okay moving on to other reports of the board all right starting with the city County Schools collaborative committee Laura and I are on that committee together we attended the meeting on December 11th we had um a short conversation about the topics that we might want to discuss in 2025 and we also discussed whether this committee will remain um at the city of Madison um so more to come forward about this committee our next meeting is proposed to be January 8th all right students on December 4th we had a
101regular student Senate meeting with a board of education report from Megan um and discuss the contents on December 18th we had um a committee meeting where the two committees mental health and academic leadership worked on their projects and then our next meeting is the 8th of January thank you sorry about that all right Madison School and community recreation advisory committee board member mosar f um yeah so um so some MSR updates the district's investment in MCR co-curriculars in middle school is already having an impact on school um through the end of November so through the end of last month 64% of mmsd middle school students have participated in at least one MSD our club or activity nearly matching last year's end of the year total percentage so by the end of November already where we
102were at the of the year last year it's really exciting um and the average number of students attending on a daily basis has also increased 32% compared to last year so we heard Dr goth talk about his experience on as a young person our middle school students are are getting that really exciting um and demand for Community recck programs remain strong uh first day of MS our winter program registration had nearly 11,000 registrations on that first day yeah like wow cool um we're looking forward to providing input on how the referendum 2024 project can be designed to support Community use of our schools um and our next meeting is scheduled for the middle of January I'm sorry that I don't remember the exact right oh we have our citizens ad hoc committee to name Southside
103Elementary evening everyone the ad hoc committee met on December 10th and decided to keep 10 proposals under consideration the committee reconvened on December 17th to rank the top four proposals the top four names in order of ranking are Southside Community ad dear Lori man carry and nine Springs in accordance with board policy two of the names are of individuals who have passed away the next step is for the ad hoc committee to hold a public hearing which is scheduled for Tuesday January 7th at 6: p.m. this hearing will be virtual and live streamed on YouTube it offers is an opportunity for the committee to gather input from both the public comments submitted on the website and the speakers at the meeting afterward the committee will be asked to confirm the four names once the final
104four names are confirmed chairperson Greg Jones along with other committee members will formally present the recommendations to the board during the instructional workg group meeting on February 3rd the final vote on the recommendations will take place at the regular board meeting on February 24th board members will be briefed again in January we would like to express our gratitude to all the committee members who have contributed to this process and a special thank you to Mr Greg Jones for his thoughtful and dedicated leadership as chairperson and thank you to the board for all your support sorry just um online it just has the tabulation where Marlene an Cummings has3 43 so she's part of the four and not Lori man Carrie so I don't oh the TR okay thank you all right next is the policy
105committee is there an update no update okay for governance committee did you want to do an update I'm gonna say we no we don't have an update at this time okay we are now at other business which is the Wisconsin Association of school boards proposed resolutions for the January 2022 2025 delegate assembly meeting um um I will be attending this year's Wisconsin Association of School Board conference to represent our board are you board member maljo it's you are also okay attending so um this motion um directs me to vote um in a particular way so I'm just going to read the motion I move that the Board of Education Direct board representative Nichelle to vote in approval of the Wisconsin Association of school boards 2025 resolutions items 2501 -01 sorry 25-12 at the January 2025
106State education convention delegate assembly meeting second okay can I just um share one thing board members I I have uh board member mald and I have not had an opportunity to talk about these um resolutions uh prior to going to the conference I have read the resolutions as they're stated I think most of them are there wouldn't be anything that we would object to you know there's there's things in here for the most part um there might be something that you are object to board members sing around childhood but hold one moment I'd like to just bring my bring attention to one thing so one of the res resolutions 25 de -08 is accountability and school report card standards and they their recommendation is that the was wasby supports timely revision of the school accountability
107system to calculate school and district report card overall scores based on student achievement only other data may be included for informational purposes but not used in calculating the overall score consistent grade band should be used rather than School building configuration and right now the the this DPI when they publish school and district report cards they're using achievement data growth data Target group outcomes and on track to graduate and then there's also a waiting in their percentage for schools and districts who have higher numbers of economically disadvantaged students so I would need to look more into this with board member malro but right now I wouldn't support their language but I'm I'm happy to learn more talk to Dr Gothard about this because maybe I'm I'm missing something about why we would only want to go
108to student achievement but I I wouldn't I don't know that represents the values that we have yes board member Mal yeah I I want to support you in your interrogation of that specific Amendment and in part I want to ask us to think more expansively about student achievement why is a snapshot or a test so much more relevant than a child's like overall grade or Mastery of skills and the variety of ways that's reflected throughout their educational experience um I think elevating test scorers to the point of being being the only thing that determines the quality of the education of students getting in their schools um is is to the detriment of our students and our Educators so thank you for bringing that up I do want to say I strongly support uh resolution 2511
109which is about funding School Meal debt um and and so I I appreciate the ability to be um critical of these amendments and to also see amendments that I think reflect what's in the best interest of our entire State and and Madison specifically board member module let me go back to board member simin please let me know if there's some another resolution that you think needs attention I'll come back to board member Castro and then go back to board member Mosner F thank you so um I am definitely pulling out 256 for us to to think about which is the resolution that um talks about publicly funding 3K programming um and I have one other resolution but we can go around to the others before we get back to that one um for this resolution
110in particular um I am strongly against it as it is worded um what it is saying is that we are making yet another shift from um being able to have our child care INF INF structure be funded into moving those same limited funds into schools and it is what is happening is the the impact of 4K has been to greatly diminish the amount of child care that exists in our state if we start to publicly fund 3K I can see very easily that will lead to the total collapse of our child care infrastructure within our state um we are about a quarter of the way there right now so there is some language in this that talks about um public private Partnerships but I don't feel comfortable that it is um strong enough language that
111that would not be the cascading result thank you for that um board member s board member cast Jo yeah thank you um yeah I cannot support the report card resolution I think we need broadly we need to investigate the way that school school report cards have been leveraged to punish predominantly poor and black and brown schools not just here but across the country um and especially with test scores a lot of resour research indicating they are directly correlated with economic status um so there's a lot of interrogating and thank you board member Moser F or I'm thinking uh about you the saying when the when the measure becomes the goal like it's not a helpful measure anymore we talk you know student achievement student achievement student achievement but like our goal student learning um and
112the achievement measure is supposed to tell us about student learning and so um so I look forward to more conversation this okay I'm gonna go vice president Pi M yeah um for the resolution 2506 the early childhood education I just wanted just to just respond I think I understand your position lore and I just want to add that there are communities in our state just is just from my own knowledge um Educational Systems in our state but correct me if I'm wrong Community correct me if I'm wrong but from what I understand and what I know is that there are communities in our state who are struggling like school districts and child care facilities and so I wonder if this would allow school districts and um Child Care Facilities to create Partnerships and ways to
113allow um to ensure that both aren't collapsing and so that may be the case in Madison or like larger cities like Madison so I'm thinking of like Milwaukee every or something like that where it could potentially like have very negative impact on um childcare facilities and just Child Care um across the board but um I'm thinking of also like Statewide those smaller kind of community so I would be interested to hear from some of the smaller communities on where they kind of think this kind of Lies um and it's is just from my own knowledge that I know of just how some of the structures in smaller communities are struggling really on both ends um and I don't know if it's necessarily tied to to per say the actual funding for 3K or 4K as
114it is just funding for public education and then also Child Care is within our state so I just wanted just to add that so um I also am totally against the co score card one um so I don't know if we want to vote on that but I'm against that one um and yeah I noticed the yeah oh I did want to just add if we can ask them to add for the educational objectives for 2509 um somewhere Civic engagement being something that is extremely important for our state and for our young people um to kind of focus in on where some of our educational objectives in key curricular areas that we want to see growth so it has like science math language arts social studies foreign language Tech um if we can add Civic
115engagements um and possibly art so just so we know Nikki your mic is not on we can't hear you online oh dear can I start over really quickly sure that was Cindy yes go ahead for member V absolutely sorry about that yes I am very against the report card absolutely that's absolutely an name to put student achievement in that way number two I agree with Laura on the child care my biggest fear on the child care is the way we fund public education on that if we do publicly funded 3K it will be used to weaponize against many schools and it will only raise the cost in my opinion but I am not an expert on this issue therefore I will defer to the person who works in the field La does I do that
116and uh the last one I absolutely agree with via the add civic education because it is absolutely essential thank you board member Mal board member sinen I uh want to really respectfully disagree with you in part because if the public option eliminated the private sector or for-profit option um we we wouldn't have private education Cas through 12 and we live in a community that has a thriving private school Community um and so I guess my question for you is why would 3K be so dangerous um for the the private sector or or the profit you know the the more profit driven sector um be so dangerous it would eliminate or destabilize that entire infrastructure and yet we've had uh tuition-free public education for a very long time um and that has not eliminated uh private
117school I am glad to speak about this so the business model for child care in our country and in our state is very well it's it's not a good business model at all it relies on Early Childhood Educators working at minimum wage or below um for extremely long hours um and so what has happened when when Child Care programs are created they're generally created with a wide range of Ages so you have your infants and you have your all the way up to your four-year-old so that's how you used to have it and you can have one teacher with let's say 12 or 10 fouryear olds but you can have one teacher with four infants parents can't afford the equivalent rate having a room that only has four children and paying a fourth of that
118teacher's salary so what child care programs do is they subsidize the cost of infant and Todd care through the enrollment of preschool AG children threey old old and fouryear olds as 4K has come about throughout the state what happened is that a large number of four-year-olds have come out of those Child Care programs and they've been closing so there are thousands of upon thousands of child care programs that have closed within the last decade maybe 15 years now because of the impact of not having four-year-olds available anymore that then has raised the rate of child care to the point where families can't afford it and then families are moving to unregulated care which can be unsafe um and not healthy for children threey olds are all the child care programs have left because you can
119still put one teacher with 10 three-year-olds if you take the three-year olds out of the system Child Care programs for the most part will not be available to anybody except for those who are V and then we'll have a lot of unregulated child care for in some so that's the system that that we're working with right now I really appreciate you explaining the system in its entirety and I think there are are factors that for for somebody who aligns politically in the way that I do you know the idea of sending your infant to dayare um I have a three-year-old we pay more for her to go to school than our mortgage um but like in a in a country that doesn't have maternity leave right in a country that doesn't guarantee your access to
120child care and subsidizes child care um in ways that don't really um account for the reality of poverty in in our world um I think this is a really complicated conversation I it it the window of opportunity in education is zero to four right these are some of the most important years of any young person's life in terms of establishing their ability to be successful academically and so part of what I worry about is if we're saying we're seeing kids pushed out into you know not certified daycares places that aren't developmentally specializing in that kid or kids are ending up watching a lot of TV at a relative's house while their mom you know pieces together who can watch them because she can't afford daycare 3K seems like a solution it also seems like a
121solution to exploiting the workforce of Early Childhood right because instead of having folks work at you know for minimum wage at latit you can have folks work for a school district um and and be and be Union me union members and have kind of the renewal of the Integrity of the profession I think what we're talking about is is really really complicated and I want to you know I guess caution us on how we have this conversation with the rest of the state while uplifting I think the real complexity that you're bringing to light um and so I think at this time I want to support you in saying this isn't necessarily an amendment we want to see go forward without having a nuanced discussion of what it means but I do think ultimately if
122you're a person who can't afford 3K right now and can't get your kid into the kind of programming that would support their long-term academic success um you can't give your kids the foundation that they need I don't want to Rob anybody of of that opportunity um and so thank you thank you for allowing us to have a a Nuance discussion and encouraging us to do that when we go to this conference yes but that's okay yeah I would be in support of a prenatal 3K resolution um I think that we are are trying to reform a very imperfect system where hopefully uh where um I yeah I I don't want a system where children are viewed as Commodities to sustain a system so everyone gets what they need um I would support but pre PR
123okay all right thank you so can I just say something I know something about this um so there's a lot of research that's been done on this over the last 15 years or so so this isn't a conversation that is unique that we're having um we can certainly pull together resources if we want to dig into this more deeply because it's all there with all the statistics and yes the answer is Public Funding for all children thank you all right thank you all for this what mana and I kind of um discussed is because the motion right now reads that we would that you all would approve me voting in a in support of resolution items 25-01 all the way to 25-12 that's the main motion what I heard was that you all actually would
124not want to approve um automatically 25-06 which is the early childhood education and you would not automatically want us to approve resolution 25-8 accountability and school report card standards so I wonder if we pull those two out and do those as like separate votes and then we can still vote on the rest of the the motion yes would it be appropriate to um adjust a motion to allow um Michelle to vote based off of our discussion um like as see fit like give her the discretion to make a vote based off of like our conversation I mean it might not be as clearcut but that might there might be some nuance is that we learn at the meeting yeah that makes sense um and so what our general councel essentially said is that we can
125choose to do that however then that would just give her leeway to vote how she would like to based off of that or we can just do what she proposed and create the separation I'm just reiterating because the mic was not on and people online cannot hear her so um or do the separation as um Michelle so okay I just was asking just to clarifying if if that's M okay board me zimin I I think I'm came forward with the proposal yeah so there's last year at the meeting by the time they got to the vote things had changed pretty tremendously for a number of them so I think that we have to allow our representatives to then use their judgment in the end because some of the resolutions didn't look anything like they started
126my uh point of clarification is are we allowed to abstain on those two abstain your from voting yes well that's only if she pulls them out if she pulls those two out could we instruct her to abstain from those two that oh for her to abstain yes you to abstain for her to abstain yes I would advise okay thank I didn't think so but I wanted to make sure so let me go back we have a motion that basically right now says that we would be voting an approval of all of the stated resolutions we know that there's two for sure as of tonight what we would not be in support of we don't and what I also hear board member simin saying is and once we get there we may learn some other things
127in the discussion and there may be some additional resolutions that upon further information we may also not be in supportive but we can't necessarily anticipate that tonight so to your point vice president Pearson I don't know if the if the motion using the discretion I don't know if that's the best motion because I think board members want to know that we're representing the Madison School District while we're there but um as of right now there's only two separations that I hear so Mona what would should we proceed as we discussed yes board member Castro it may imperfect but I will introduce an amendment to amend the motion to direct board representative Michelle Nichols to vote in discretion on the wasby resolution I second okay discussion on that all right I see for member Vander M
128and then we'll come for member Malo um I understand things change on the floor but I am not comfortable in this situation as much as I trust my board I just and this sit situation I'm not comfortable so I will vote nay and then if it passes then agree board member malra I appreciate the trust of the board and I appreciate the board president's ability to represent the board um I think that is inherent to the role of board president in so many facets of our work um I think like we we have to be able to make real decisions informed by the long-term relationships as a board have with one another um in real time during this meeting um and I very much appreciate board member simin letting us know that these these amendments
129do change um and change significantly and the implications um are things we need to take into consideration okay so we have an amendment um I can't exactly restate the amendment right now can you restate it B member Castro okay uh I move to amend the a motion to say uh direct board representative Michelle Nichols to vote in discretion of the Wisconson Association of school boards 2025 resolutions seconded okay um oh board member mosar falam okay I'm sorry um can it be to Amendment oh we have to vote that one okay friend oh it would be a friendly amendment I would like to make a friendly amendment I okay I'm gonna ask you board member cestro if you would like to uh modify your Amendment uh to include language um based on our conversation that um
130board president pres should vote with her discretion based on the conversation that we've had at the board approve yes yes based off the wisdom of this conversation let's let's restate the now friendly updated Amendment as submitted by member Castro I move at the Board of Education Direct board representative Michelle Nichols to vote indiscretion comma based off the conversation of the general Board of Education meeting dated December 19th 2024 at the uh Wisconsin board's 2025 resolution I say it's still yep okay all right we've been doing some good work tonight um Claire your advisory vote I all right all those in favor of this amendment six okay those opposed all right thank you Lord member Vander M all right so the amendment um passed now you want me to go back and restate the main motion
131yes yes yes I move that the Board of Education Direct board representative Michelle Nicholls to use her discretion based on the conversation of the of the General Board of Education meeting dated December 19 2024 for the Wisconsin Association of school boards 2025 resolutions at the January 2025 State education convention delegate assembly meeting all right thank you board member malro okay Claire your advisory vote on Matt hi thank you all those in favor all right now we uh have passed that unanimously thank you all right you have no other I business sorry the mscr we have a business item I had another date for the next one next MSR one I got January 22nd all right 202 it the next mscr advisory council meeting in my report I thought it was in January and I didn't
132know the date got it and now now I know the date old business I'm going back to the date is January thank you all right y'all we've made it through 2024 [Music] um I'll entertain a motion to adjourn second Maya all right all those in favor of that any amendments thank you oh Claire I know sorry I forgot to ask your ADV V on that a good thank you bye